web analytics
The Standard
Advertising

It’s not just about cyber-culture, Judith

Written By: - Date published: 7:59 pm, November 4th, 2013 - 310 comments
Categories: accountability, crime, john key, Judith Collins, labour, law and "order", leadership, national, police, sexism - Tags: ,

The news reports about the Roast Busters are chilling.  Watching 3 News tonight was very upsetting.  There has much been said online that is relevant.

The most important immediate question is – how hard have the police and authorities worked to support the woman who are living with the damage done to them by the rapes?  And why wasn’t more being done to protect other women from having the same trials?

I’m with Carol Beaumont is correct in saying that there is a problem with our culture, as does the spokesperson fro Rape Crisis:

Meanwhile, Rape Prevention Education executive director Dr Kim McGregor said that if media reports about the Roast Busters were correct, what they were doing was “absolutely rape”.

“Some of the girls are children, they’re only aged 13 so that’s rape. Even if you’re over 16 and having sex with people who cannot give consent because they’re stupefied by a drug, that’s rape.”

The attitudes of the men involved were a “huge concern” and unfortunately widespread, she said.

“They have been saying it makes them feel like a man, and talking about women not as humans but as boasts – dehumanising them. I hope men’s groups are stepping up to address this.”

rape_culture

However, I am appalled with the latest NZ Herald report with the attitudes shown by the quotes from John key and Judith Collins.  The article does report some good points made by Carole Beaumont:

Ms Beaumont said the case raised broader questions around the way rape victims were treated and questioned what was being done to change the culture that meant teenage boys thought such behaviour was acceptable.

But, as this article reports it, Key and Collins seem to be saying the problem has a lot to do with cyber-bullying:

Prime Minister John Key said today the “disturbing and disgusting” behaviour of the group will be unlawful under a bill about to be introduced to Parliament.

“As a parent I find the issue very disturbing and abhorrent,” he said at his post cabinet press conference this afternoon.

[...]

He said that their practice of naming a particular young woman would be unlawful under a law the Government is about to introduce, the Harmful Digital Communications Bill.

“But it is actually a bigger issue and it is just extremely disturbing and disgusting behaviour and these young guys should grow up,” he said.

He said it was very difficult to progress the issues if the victim was not willing to make a formal complaint.

So John Key is just going to sit back and say, “too difficult”?  This just looks like a bit of opportunism by Judith and John, with a main focus on cyber-bullying, over-shadowing considerations to deal with the real, physical brutality of the crimes committed by the men – and they weren’t committed digitally:

Justice Minister Judith Collins foreshadowed the bill in April as a way to address cyber bullies.

Then the article goes into details of the cyber-bullying Bill.  I’m sure that the government is looking for ways to be able to have more control over online behaviour.  But surely as Justice Minister, Collins should have more to say on this issue? However, Collins is someone who enjoys perpetuating a bullying style of behaviour – also a problem in the masculine legacy that still dominates politics.

But there are urgent questions that need answering.  Such as why the police seem unable to apprehended the rapists quickly, when they are very quick to arrest people for other suspected crimes?

NB:  I will moderate this thread quite strongly. Comments that support rape culture will be deleted.

[Update] Scuba Nurse – positive steps to make a difference [h/t Pascal's bookie]

Scuba Nurse has posted suggestions over at The Hand Mirror,

for how you can be brave, and carry your torch out into the community and really make a difference.

It’s a must read post.  The ideas are explained under the following headings:

Be the light at the end of the tunnel.
Be the voice of reality.
Be the person brave enough to discuss “consent”.
Be the person who knows the facts.
Be the killjoy.
Be the support person.
Be the person advocating body autonomy for the children and young people around you.
Be the person supporting those on the front line.

310 comments on “It’s not just about cyber-culture, Judith”

  1. RedBaronCV 1

    I am so angry. I don’t know how to say how dreadful this is.

    The justice system is for women and children too.

    On one hand we have police who seem to be totally unable to charge males bragging about raping under age women because they don’t have a complaint. WTF. When I last looked child abuse is a crime and it doesn’t require a complaint from the victim. Murder is investigated without a complaint.

    And on the other hand we have a prime minister whose response is to say “the boys need to grow up”. So it’s okay for a teen to rape but not someone over say 21? People who make those sorts of excuses aren’t facilitators they are co-abusers.

    • Chooky 1.1

      RedBaronCV +100….there is something dreadfully wrong with Auckland

    • weka 1.2

      “When I last looked child abuse is a crime and it doesn’t require a complaint from the victim.”

      +1

      • David H 1.2.1

        @Weka Then that makes it “what is a child” in the police eyes. Personally I put a child as anyone under the age of 16. And anyway having sex with an underage girl is also a crime, so why are the police dragging their heels on this? And now I see that if the police don’t do anything it seems that there is a group ready to hand out some ‘street’ justice..

        • you_fool 1.2.1.1

          I haven’t read today’s “news” stories on this, but yesterday I got the impression that the police do not have anything more than some teenage boys bragging about having sex, which is what all teenage boys do. This bragging seems to be much much worse than “normal” bragging, but if the police can’t actually find evidence then they do have their hands tied.

          The question should then be how hard have they looked?

        • SpaceMonkey 1.2.1.2

          A child is defined under the Child, Young Persons, and Families Act 1989 as being under 14 years of age.

          http://www.legislation.govt.nz/act/public/1989/0024/latest/whole.html

        • weka 1.2.1.3

          David, there is a pretty good explanation of what the law says on the Public Address thread from yesterday. It’s in the comments, and mentioned a few times. Look for the one about the difference between statuatory rape and unlawful sexual connection with a minor. There are two different age brackets I think.

    • Zorr 1.3

      “Boys will be boys” should never be a legal defense…

    • Ant 1.4

      I think you have to keep in mind that a lot of the evidence that the media is reporting on is being lifted from social media – A lot of it is obvious trolling/teenagers giving each other shit.

      There is a massive scummy side to it but there is also the scummy manipulation of outrage.

  2. ann kerr 2

    Great article Karol.

    I also wondered were CYFs alerted given the age of these girls? Can’t charges be pressed then. If a child is sexually abused by a relative, surely the child doesn’t have to make a complaint for the perpetrator to be charged?

    Did the police make any attempt to stake out and follow these young men and catch them about to commit these despicable acts? I am not an expert on the law, but could they not have pressed charges if they catch someone about to commit a crime like this?

    It is a very disturbing case and even more to hear that one of the perpetrators father is in the police.

    • karol 2.1

      Thanks, ann. I actually feel inadequate in commenting on this case and the surrounding comments & issues. It’s all too disturbing. But it also needs to be addressed urgently.

      Good point about CYFs.

    • Tim 2.2

      Indeed ! Great article Karol. It’s also obvious that not only should there be concern over Collins’ et al ‘kulcha’, but ALSO that of the NZ Police – it doesn’t appear to have changed that much and is backed up by their own worst enemy – a dinosaur called Greg.
      Watching that TV3 item, the detective appeared to be saying that they couldn’t act UNLESS there was a compainant – never mind that its clear that rape has taken place. Admittedly since then, there’s been some real backpeddling and the efforts are based on gathering evidence to obtain a conviction, but equally evident is that efforts to date haven’t exactly been that strenuous.

    • David H 2.3

      Sorry Ann, but as someone who has dealt with CYFS (we kill your children quicker) is that they are great talkers they will talk and talk and yes talk, but do anything ? That a completely different matter. In the 2 years I dealt with them (over a troubled teen) the levels of disinterest and incompetence, were amazing. And to get them to even call you back is a mission. This is one govt dept that NEEDS an overhaul.

      http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=10842434
      http://www.nzherald.co.nz/hawkes-bay-today/news/article.cfm?c_id=1503462&objectid=11103254

      And it’s not hard to find more.

  3. Lanthanide 3

    Can someone give examples of the people who would fall into the “facilitators” group?

    Also, are the police faciliators in this particular case?

    • RedBaronCV 3.1

      Essentially yes. They know what is going on, they have identified the alleged perpetrators, know who they have targeted and have done nothing effective (or nothing at all about it).
      In the vernacular, facilitators are those who knowingly, do others dirty work for them or aid and assist in same.

      • Lanthanide 3.1.1

        “In the vernacular, facilitators are those who knowingly, do others dirty work for them or aid and assist in same.”

        Yeah, but what I’m wanting here are some examples of who a facilitator might be when it comes to rape, vs say a bystander. Maybe a parent of a rapist who discovers it is happening and doesn’t do anything about it is a facilitator? Bystanders would be those, like John Key, who don’t/can’t/won’t acknowledge the gravity of the situation?

        • karol 3.1.1.1

          Some explanations on that slide are here:

          A slide by Dr. David Lisak used to explain how Rape Culture, bystanders, and facilitators help camouflage sex offenders in our community.

          And here:

          Facilitators perpetuate an environment that allows core sex offenders to assault

          * Reinforce negative behavior

          Bystanders have knowledge of incidents & dangerous environments, but fail to act

          I would include police as both facilitators and bystanders.

          I think quite a lot of our celebrity culture facilitates core sex offences – see for example some of the antics amongst male rugby players. So it is perhaps not a coincidence that 2 of the alleged offenders have a celebrity & a police parent.

          • Lanthanide 3.1.1.1.1

            Thanks, both very helpful. I find the “good person” defense particularly compelling.

          • Chris 3.1.1.1.2

            IMO I would say Facebook is a facilitator along with Police. Police have known of this Facebook page since 2011 after a victim made an “informal” complaint. Why they would continue to allow this page to exist for 2 years to “gather” information is beyond belief. And in fact Police had no intention of getting this page shut down, that came after TV3 made it public last night.

            Police behaviour and attitude is abhorrent as is Key and Collins.

            • Lanthanide 3.1.1.1.2.1

              True enough I suppose. But on a medium like the internet, it’s not really feasible to monitor and police everything. To attempt to do so would greatly diminish freedom of expression.

              • Chris

                L it became feasible from the very first information Police had back in 2011. At which time they could have worked with Facebook.

                • Lanthanide

                  To say Facebook is a facilitator because they didn’t shut down the page in 2011 implies they need to be policing and monitoring all pages on their site on a continuous basis.

                  The fact is, once Facebook were alerted to the situation, they shut the page down. Doesn’t seem like they fit the role of facilitator to me.

                  • Chris

                    I doubt very much that Facebook wasn’t aware back in 2011

                  • weka

                    “To say Facebook is a facilitator because they didn’t shut down the page in 2011 implies they need to be policing and monitoring all pages on their site on a continuous basis.”

                    If I continuously provided a house for teens and children to party in without supervision, and I actively promote this house in a way that makes it desirable to teens, am I a facilitator if bad shit happens even if weren’t there at the time? I think so.

                    If FB were a responible organisation it would have set up processes to minimise rape culture. Reddit is worse I think. There is fuck all social responsibility from these companies.

                    Every person who saw what was happening on this particular FB page and didn’t report it to FB, they’re facilitators too.

                    • Lanthanide

                      It still is very tricky though. There’s a limit to what automated tools can do to detect undesirable content, particularly if slang terms are used.

                      Even having a simple system where the names of newly created groups were eyeballed by humans may not have caught this one.

                    • Chris

                      “Every person who saw what was happening on this particular FB page and didn’t report it to FB, they’re facilitators too.”

                      exactly, Facebook would have had hundreds if not thousands of reports in regard to the roast page over the last 2 years.

                    • Lanthanide

                      @ Chris: if it was a private group (no idea if it was?) then it’s by invite-only, in which case the chance of abuse reports would be greatly lowered.

                    • weka

                      “It still is very tricky though. There’s a limit to what automated tools can do to detect undesirable content, particularly if slang terms are used.

                      Even having a simple system where the names of newly created groups were eyeballed by humans may not have caught this one.”

                      Ah, the old ‘it can’t be technically done’ defense. Ironically, I see Russell Brown coming out today and saying this case does support the Harmful Digital Communications Bill. I seem to remember for him being an early apologist for internet porn on the grounds that you can’t control the internet.

                      What FB could do is have staff in NZ, who facilitate both education and supervision of FB culture here. Given that part of FB’s core business is youth culture, I can’t see how this would be impossible. They could use both tech and human solutions. They could have built such social responsibility into their system in the same way that they built in advertising or controlling data. We only think these things are impossible because we believe that FB has the right to act like a profit-driven business ahead of social responsibility. Am pretty sure if social responsibility were a given, solutions would be found.

                    • Lanthanide

                      Fundamentally we’re talking about censoring content. In order to (fairly) censor content, you must first review it.

                      You can foster culture as much as you want, but when push comes to shove, someone still has to click the “block” button.

                    • QoT

                      Lanthanide, I think this has already been said on the thread, but it should be repeated: Facebook is frequently alerted, by people pressing the “report” button, to content which targets individuals for harassment, publishes people’s photos without their consent, and advocates violence and rape.

                      They do precisely sweet fuck-all until a mainstream media channel starts asking questions. I have a dozen or so “Sorry, this content doesn’t breach our Ts and Cs” emails from them in my inbox to prove it, and I know many other people do too.

                  • idlegus

                    russell brown (i think) said on public address he was aware of a complaint to facebook months ago, it wasnt until the tv3 story facebook shut it down.

                • weka

                  I agree. That the NZ Police allowed the FB page/s to continue because they needed FB to continue their investigation, and that they did this for two years, is one of the most appalling things I’ve read today. That alone bears investigation and at the very least a detailed explanation from the police. Because as it stands, what it looks like to me is that they had someone using the FB page as a means of identifying serious criminals, who were commiting crimes over time, and the police didn’t put resources into extra investigation to bring that to an end. If the victims had been say 9 or 10 years old, and the perpetrators say 19 or 20, would the police have still acted in the same way?

        • QoT 3.1.1.2

          Just about everyone involved in the Steubenville case would count. Coaches and parents who cover up evidence, police officers who refuse to investigate, district attorneys who refuse to press charges.

        • RedBaronCV 3.1.1.3

          In my mind John Key isn’t in the bystander category because he occupies the office of Prime Minister. He has the power at least at some level to direct what should be done.

          Instead he has minimised the offence, “the boys need to grow up”, denied the real problem ” we are going to have rules on cyber bullying”, we already have rules on rape, John, which he seems to have missed and attempted to shift the blame “teenage drinking?”

          You and I Lanth are now “bystanders” at some remove. We know about this and have information to form at least a partial view as to whether or not we condone this, I don’t.

          Well, that’s my take on it. Over to others.

          P.S JKey doesn’t seem to see this as an issue. I think it’s an issue that’s going to be many many times larger than say “Rena” which they ignored at the start.

          • Lanthanide 3.1.1.3.1

            Right, I was wondering how far the ‘bystander’ term would reach, and also whether there’s any purpose reaching out as far as myself and you. Your definition makes it sound like if you become aware of something, you’re a ‘bystander’ to it.

            • RedBaronCV 3.1.1.3.1.1

              I’m not a professional in this Lanth and this is a personal take on the slides.

              I know we were not in the vicinity at the time but even as a far flung ripple in the pond, I would at this point, find it hard to restrain myself from giving the nearest politician or policeman my unvarnished opinion. Heat in the kitchen does matter.

              • Zorr

                RedBaron – you aren’t a bystander in this instance because you don’t have specific knowledge that would allow you to act immediately to prevent these rapes from occurring or to bring the perpetrators to justice.

                If your attitude were different however, like JKeys, then you would be a facilitator.

                The point is that this kind of activity by anyone should be abhorrent to all members of our society/culture (in much the way that murder is) as it is such an incredibly destructive act. There need be no pussy footing around here – from what I’ve read on this so far, it is as bad a situation as has ever been discovered in NZ. Would be willing already to rate this up there with the Beast himself.

                • Lanthanide

                  Ok, I thought Key would be a bystander rather than a facilitator, and someone you describe who had the ability to stop the rapes but didn’t would be a facilitator not a bystander.

                  • Zorr

                    Fair enough – it seems I have gotten the terms the wrong way around in my reading of the comments. It’s such a long way to scroll back to the image… :P

            • weka 3.1.1.3.1.2

              I don’t consider myself a bystander, because I address rape culture as and where I can. Were I to go and look at the FB pages out of curiousity and then do nothing, then I would be a bystander.

              Bystander isn’t becoming aware of the abuse, it’s what you do once you become aware that defines whether you are a bystander or something else.

              From one of karol’s links in her comment above

              “Bystanders have knowledge of incidents & dangerous environments, but fail to act”

              • Lanthanide

                Ok, so in what way should I be acting to avoid being labelled a bystander?

                • weka

                  Do you want to not be a bystander, or do you just want to avoid being labelled one? Because those are two different things.

                  • Lanthanide

                    I’m just trying to explore these labels and how they’re applied. You seem to be tying the labels to actions that should be taken but aren’t, and the severity of the failure to act determines the label you get.

                    • weka

                      Not really. I’m not sitting here thinking Oh Lanth, he’s x, y, z in terms of the diagram. The diagram is a tool for raising awareness and prompting discussion and self-reflection. I think you asking questions in this thread about that has been useful.

                      The severity of the failure to act might determine where on the scale of things you fit in. When you started talking about being ‘labelled’ I thought that was less useful. Where do YOU think you fit in, and why (in any situation like this that you’ve been in), would be more interesting to me.

                    • karol

                      Yes. Actually, weka. I came across the diagram when I was looking for a suitable image for the front page. I was finding any specific image on its own with people in it, tended to be skewed one way or another to support current cultural values – or at least could be without some accompanying explanation.

                      The diagram seemed to be more suitable than any other image I came across.

                    • Lanthanide

                      I don’t consider myself a bystander since all I’ve done is been a recipient of the mass-market news. I don’t see there’s any need for me to act in any particular way in response to that news, so it seems to me that my non-action shouldn’t be used against me.

                      Now were I much closer to the situation, and ethical standards and morals compelled me to act in a way that I didn’t act, I think I could be fairly classed a bystander and/or facilitator.

                      I do consider Key a bystander because his comments were well shy of the mark of the message he should be conveying as someone of his official standing.

                    • weka

                      “I don’t see there’s any need for me to act in any particular way in response to that news, so it seems to me that my non-action shouldn’t be used against me.”

                      It’s not actually about you.

                    • Lanthanide

                      ???

                      I’m trying to explore the use of these terms, who they apply to and when, which naturally raises the question of whether the terms apply to myself, and if so, why.

              • RedBaronCV

                See what you mean Weka “but fail to act”. At this distance there are not many actions we can take except voice our grave concerns.

                • weka

                  Most people with a FB or twitter account can do things pretty easily today. Anyone with the time and skills could be writing letters to the NZ Police, or the govt, or Key or his MPs etc. Donate money to Rape Crisis.

                  It’s tempting to think that the rape happened only in the spaces where the young women were. But all of us here partake of the internet and this abuse has moved into our sphere. To say that we are very far removed from it is akin to being in a pub with men who are now drinking in the pub at the other end of the room and bragging about rapes they have committed, and saying that because the rape happened in another part of town it’s nothing to do with us and we can’t do anything. It’s just not true. If we accept that the situation we are hearing about today has come about because of rape culture, then we also have to accept our part in that. Rape culture isn’t something over there. It’s right here.

    • weka 3.2

      Facebook are facilitators in this situation.

      I’ve not seen much of the FB content, but am willing to bet there are FBers who weren’t the actual rapists but were facilitators too. Taking part in the online humiliation of the women, supporting the men, making jokes etc.

      • Zorr 3.2.1

        The people on FB who didn’t report this despite having specific knowledge were bystanders.

        FB themselves were facilitators (as long as they didn’t have specific knowledge) by providing the environment for this behavior to breed

        • Lanthanide 3.2.1.1

          Right, but I think if you’re saying Facebook are facilitators for the duration of time in which they didn’t have specific knowledge, then the only 100% foolproof way for them to not be facilitators would be to drastically step up the amount of monitoring and policing they do of user content. Realistically given their size this would require them to limit what people could do on their site, or put all content into a queue to be reviewed – either would ultimately destroy Facebook.

          Are you really suggesting that open forums like FB shouldn’t exist because a tiny number of people might use them inappropriately?

          • Zorr 3.2.1.1.1

            Do you realize just how difficult it is to put up an image of breastfeeding a child with a bare breast? They *were* taking them down almost immediately.

            Why couldn’t they respond to this as effectively?

            And yes, if they can’t provide a business that is capable of monitoring against such crimes as rape and murder in their own confines, then may I suggest that their business needs to rethink their stance VERY quickly.

            • weka 3.2.1.1.1.1

              +1000

              Lanth, what makes you think this is “a tiny number of people might use them inappropriately” issue?

              • Lanthanide

                I simply don’t think it is up to organisations like FB to be spending the resources to police their users in the way that is being suggested here.

                It is also an inherently difficult point to decide who should be doing how much policing. FB has 1.2b users. What about twitter? What about MySpace? What about AIM instant messaging? What about SnapChat? Are all communication mediums required to put in equal levels of content policing? Or just the most popular ones of the day, helping to ensure they become less popular because they’re a hassle to use and be replaced by some other service?

                • weka

                  They all support rape culture, so they can share the responsibility. Are you really saying that FB’s shareholders are more important than protecting people from harm?

                  “I simply don’t think it is up to organisations like FB to be spending the resources to police their users in the way that is being suggested here.”

                  I haven’t seen anyone suggesting that FB ‘police’ their users in the way you seem to be suggesting.

                  • Lanthanide

                    “Are you really saying that FB’s shareholders are more important than protecting people from harm?”

                    Actually I’m saying the vast majority of uses of FB and other communication mediums shouldn’t be unnecessarily burdened because of the actions of a very minute few.

                    “I haven’t seen anyone suggesting that FB ‘police’ their users in the way you seem to be suggesting.”

                    People here seem to be suggesting that such content should not be allowed on facebook and that facebook shouldn’t require 3rd party notification in order for it to be removed.

            • Lanthanide 3.2.1.1.1.2

              I haven’t really looked at any TV/website/newspaper articles on this so don’t know if they’ve shown any pictures. My primary source has been radio.

              Is it the case that the pictures, taken out of context (because that’s exactly why the breastfeeding pictures are taken down), are not inherently objectionable?

              • Zorr

                How is a picture of breastfeeding inherently objectionable? If I take a topless photo right now (as a guy) and post it on FB, that is fine. But a woman choosing to post her own topless photo is not? Even when mostly covered up by baby head? This is puritanical thinking at it’s finest because the moment you can see a female breast it is objectionable.

                This kind of material is something that Youtube is capable of monitoring and policing but Facebook is incapable of apparently. I wouldn’t expect that FB could catch everyone and that it would still be possible to utilize their service for such things even with stringent policing *but* they don’t have to make themselves an easy breeding ground for such practice.

                If you can’t get away with it in a physical store/meeting place, you shouldn’t be able to get away with it in a virtual one where it is even easier to potentially police such activity.

                • Lanthanide

                  Sorry, bad choice of words. “Against FB’s terms and conditions”. They might have a fucked up definition where booby = bad, but that’s what they decided to define it as.

                  I am reminded of a US judge who failed to come up with a definition of exactly what was and what wasn’t pornorgraphy and resorted to “I know it when I see it”. One person’s art is another person’s blasphemy. At least the standard of “is there a visible female breast in the picture” is by and large objective.

                  “If you can’t get away with it in a physical store/meeting place”

                  Because the police inspect all buildings on a regular basis? As long as a physical store/meeting place was purely invite-only and highly secretive, I’d say it’d be quite easy to get away with murder.

                  • Zorr

                    It’s not about the police at that point Lanth – it’s about the business owner making sure that their business isn’t being used for illegal purposes if it is within their means to do so.

                    If they are capable of monitoring criminal activity, then they should report it.
                    If they are incapable of monitoring, they should develop the capabilities to monitor in order to prevent criminal activity.
                    If they are incapable of monitoring and choose to do nothing about it then they shouldn’t be allowed to operate.

                    Willful ignorance is no excuse.

  4. toad 4

    Key is clueless on this (once again).

    Cyberbullying is threatening adverse consequences IN cyberspace.

    What these guys are doing is threatening adverse consequences in cyberspace only if the victim complains.

    Surely they can be charged with conspiracy and/or incitement to rape, even if no victim comes forward.

    As usual, the NZ Police fail to score on this issue. I wonder how much that has to do with the rape culture identified within the Police.

    • weka 4.1

      “What these guys are doing is threatening adverse consequences in cyberspace only if the victim complains.”

      I haven’t seen much of the media coverage yet, what were the threats?

  5. BM 5

    The elephant in the room is black gangsta culture that encourages this sort of bull shit behavior, but no ones has the cajones to point that out because they’re scared of being seen as the slave owner telling dem darkies how to behave.

    • karol 5.1

      It is part of a much wider culture than a specific youth subculture or music style.

      • BM 5.1.1

        I disagree, it’s black gangsta culture, the same shit all the Maori, Polly boys are into.
        Women = meat, Some play thing to do what ever you want with, use and abuse.

        [karol: I've said I will moderate this thread strongly. The issue is far more widespread than any one subculture. The problem is all throughout our culture. Blaming the least powerful culture is a way of denying we are all in the midst of the problem culture. It's scapegoating and blame shifting..

        Rape is about power, and usually about men asserting or making themselves feel more powerful by abusing others. White policemen and sports players, for instance, have been guilty of rape and pack rape.

        Any more attempts to blame a particular subculture or ethnic group will be deleted. It's a diversion from finding real and successful ways to deal with the problem behaviour and prevent further brutality.]

        • weka 5.1.1.1

          I wonder who they learnt that from.

        • North 5.1.1.2

          You’re an obscene old bastard BM.

        • thatguynz 5.1.1.3

          What a generalising piece of shit you are. True colours shown. Fuck off back to WO’s pond of like minded scum.

          • amirite 5.1.1.3.1

            BM you fuckin’ idiot. If you can blame any culture it is the one where your parents are in high position which helps you to get away with murder and makes you think you’re above the law. This is the culture that is interested only in an individual’s own selfish interests, well-being and enjoyment, no matter how it may effect others.
            Sounds familiar? That is the ideology that leads this government.

    • Murray Olsen 5.2

      Bullshit. Plenty of young white boys act in just the same way. Or are they under the influence of the evil blacks? Pffft.

      • framu 5.2.1

        yeah ive seen plenty of well heeled white boys you dont fit “gangsta culture” that behave like misyonginist (sp?) litte scum bags

        you could equally blame rugby culture, or any other entrenched macho posturing

    • Tim 5.3

      That’d be a bit like a rellie of mine (one of dem ‘spooks’) telling me once that they couldn’t do shit because the (then current) regime of political correctness limited them to some very specific tasks.
      (That nanny state Helun Kluk was in control then)
      Well – we all know what bullshit that limitation turned out to be.
      WHY are you suggesting it has anything to do with a kulcha that’s related to race?
      You do know there are ‘whities’ (dem honkies) all doing their very best to emulate what they perceive as ‘black’, but is in fact not related to race or ethnicity in ANY way.
      All that nasty rap crap I suspect you’re referring to (dem bitches etc), may well have been popularised
      (Commoditised – using a word you should understand and be the devil’s disciple of), but it is actually racially non-specific!.
      Were that not the case, we’d not have dem bloody honkies talking like dem fukn murries.
      Wotcha rekon – we should get Pulla Bent onto the case aye!

      • Tim 5.3.1

        I bet you think that ‘gangs’ are specifically race related too. As in that’s where they originated from.
        You should probably look more closely into the seedier side of your own fukn heritage and you’ll discover that they were peculiarly ‘WHITE’ and honky.

        btw – what does ‘BM’ stand for? I don’t necessarily mean that q interms of a name, more your moronic belief system.

        I dunno why TS actually tolerates some of your trolling dressed up as mature argument, but then I’m just an interloper here, and it’s one of the few outlets there is to contest your fukn bigotry that there is these days.

        Oh…. btw. I have a rule: I don’t believe that pushing SHIT UPHILL is really that productive – so don’t be surprised if I don;t reply to any offering you’ll be tempted to follow with

    • North 5.4

      Strange BM…….one of those “meat-lovers” on the tele’ looked unquestionably whitearse to me. That’s right……the mouthy one.

      Elephant in the room you reckon ? There’s none. Only the one up your ignorant arse you old fool. It’s making you squeal all sorts of crazy wicked shit.

  6. Martin 6

    If this were about underage males the police would have laid charges long before now.

  7. Murray Olsen 7

    I wonder how much the police reluctance to make any arrests has to do with the problem some of them would have with seeing anything wrong with this behaviour. They certainly act quickly and without a formal complaint in other cases. That NAct chooses this as a further excuse to crack down on the internet rather than addressing the (alleged) offences is just one more example of their moral bankruptcy.

    • Martin 7.1

      ” They certainly act quickly and without a formal complaint in other cases.”
      my point exactly!

      • Mike S 7.1.1

        The police can’t prosecute someone for rape unless the victim lays a formal complaint. It’s not perfect but how else could they possibly prosecute? What evidence could they use in court if there is no victim statement affirming that she has been raped?

        • weka 7.1.1.1

          I don’t think that applies to victims under the age of 16 Mike. In that case they need evidence but not a complaint.

        • McFlock 7.1.1.2

          Didn’t they just convict someone of kidnapping when the victim was adamant she hadn’t been kidnapped but the evidence was overwhelming?

          Same thing. Cameras, FB, interviewing their acquaintances, getting a facilitator twho feels bad to confess against the others, etc. The point is that we’re not hearing “no comment while matter is under ongoing investigation” from the cops so much as “our hands are tied it’s all so sad but we’ve told the lads to stop”.

  8. AmaKiwi 8

    Crusher Collins made headlines cracking down on boy racers but ignores a gang of rapists for 2 years!

    Down with this government!

    They have ignored the fundamental responsibility of every government: to protect their citizens from harm.

    Colonial Viper, say it in a few short words, because I am so incensed I am in danger of blabbing on for pages.

    • Tim 8.1

      Well – you know ….. apparently it’s easier to measure ‘loss of traction’ and speeding than it is to measure whether a certain demographic (complete with registered birth certificate) is ‘legal for sex’ or not.
      Of course in our Polis’ minds, there are extenuating circun …errr cicumcis …. no wait! stances! Stances, that’s what I mean. A 13 or 14 yo slut dressed up in leopard skin with that fukn skirt circulating round her cnut: Well – she wuz js ASKING for it aye!
      Let alone the fek she moighta been on facebook, let alone (as is normal with the pubescent), she may just have begun thinking about guy’s diks – most guys of which are anxious to tell us how fukn enormous their’s is!.

      Where have some of these rockhoppers come from ffs!!!!!!!? Apparently they have children just like the rest of us.
      Apparently they’re Norman Normals (at least the MSM is very anxious to portray them as such, as is Greg – chief apologist)

      Can’t diss that Polis Kulcha aye! It’s treacherous to do so – besides which there’s a true slut (maybe on account of her not getting anything were she to be otherwise) that heads up ‘Truth, Justice and the NuZill way’. Where’s she at presently? How many cars has she actually crushed?
      Has her disciple (Pulla) gotten with her learnings?
      I’m sure she has to get thru’ half a dozen more before there’s an agenda she can be totally convinced of winning.
      …btw Jude – my neighbour (the varicous vein/botox/etc spessshlist – you know – that one that deals in TOTAL confidence) has ordered up the latest.
      schedule your leave now – be in to win (you gorgeous beauty)

    • Tat Loo (CV) 8.2

      Colonial Viper, say it in a few short words, because I am so incensed I am in danger of blabbing on for pages.

      As far as I can tell, this is an accurate summary of Judith Collins and John Key’s attitude –

      “The young guys from the Facebook Rape, Shame and Gloat Gang need a tough lesson via our new cyberbullying laws: if you are going to manipulate, stupefy, abuse and rape vulnerable underage girls, please be considerate enough not to put it on the interwebs.”

      • miravox 8.2.1

        yes, Tat, that’s how I read it too.

        Brett Dale needs to go tell police and politicians how to say, in six short sentences, what they should have said.

        Just a niggly point, though. It was rape also for the girls of legal age.

  9. They were underage, so its rape.
    They were stupefied so its rape.
    They filmed their victims, so its child pornography.
    They put pictures up on social media sites, so its distribution of child pornography.
    They not only admitted to all this, they wore what they did as a badge of honor.

    They should be in jail right now and be listed as a child sex offender.

    • weka 9.1

      crikey Brett, that would have to be one of the most cogent comments I’ve ever seen from you.

    • karol 9.2

      For once I tend to agree with you, Brett.

      • Brett Dale 9.2.1

        Karol:

        I hope most people in NZ would agree with those statements I wrote, Ive been on twitter all
        day and it would seem people are on the same mindset.

    • toad 9.3

      FFS, Brett. I have never seen you make so much sense here before.

      I welcome your epiphany.

      Long may it continue.

    • Naturesong 9.4

      Yup, this is one of the few times I agree with you.

      John Key says: “But it is actually a bigger issue and it is just extremely disturbing and disgusting behaviour and these young guys should grow up,”

      Actually, no.

      It’s rape. It’s a crime.

      “He said that their practice of naming a particular young woman would be unlawful under a law the Government is about to introduce, the Harmful Digital Communications Bill.”

      No John, It’s rape.

      If you can legally add to their sentence because they published their crimes thats great.

      Its rape John. The publishing of the crime is insult added to injury.

      These young men need to be in court before a judge.

    • Zorr 9.5

      I think your comment here proves how far removed the Police now are from serving the interests of all New Zealander’s – where the opinion from across the political spectrum is so negatively against the actions of the Police that it is now apparent they are a law unto themselves and need to be dealt with

    • framu 9.6

      at the very least thats enough to get a warrant to search their laptops and cell phones – if they are posting online, and obviously smart enough to be selective about what they post then i will bet dollars for donuts that theres incriminating evidence on their personal devices

      these kind of low lifes cant help bragging on camera

  10. vto 10

    Why on earth do the Police need a complaint from the victim and how do the Police then lay charges in cases of murder?

    • weka 10.1

      While on the face of what I have seen so far I believe the NZ Police have been extremely negligent here, I suspect what has happened is that they’ve not been able to get a statement from one of the women under 16, esp one much younger than the perpetrators. Not having a complaint seems irrelevant, but not having statements would make a prosecution very hard because they would be relying on the FB pages alone. I also suspect that the MSM are being their usual sloppy selves and not thinking these things through and asking the right questions. It’s all random reporting and fuck all journalism.

      • vto 10.1.1

        I aint going anywhere near the FB page, but I understand there are admissions of crimes committed on it.

        That is evidence sufficient for a conviction in most all cases.

        • weka 10.1.1.1

          I don’t think it is vto. If I say right now that I am sitting here smoking a big fat joint, and then I get busted on the basis of that, I can just say I lied online. It’s not a crime to lie like that. Without supporting evidence, saying shit online is not enough to prosecute someone.

          afaik the FB page is down now.

          • Pascal's bookie 10.1.1.1.1

            It would, especially if you were doing a lot of drug talk on vairious social media, be probable gorunds for getting the police all up in your phones though.

            if you were talking about how much drugs you were selling and how good they were and all the rest, would the police be in your phones? I’d say good chance of ‘yes’. maybe the police did get warrants and track these guys. We don’t know.

            • weka 10.1.1.1.1.1

              Yes. I think there is a lot we don’t know about what the police have actually done. I appreciate they need some degree of privacy to be effective in their job, but this situation is sufficiently damaging to young people and the community that the police need to front up now and explain what the fuck they have been doing.

              • felix

                I think they already have. And the answer is “nothing”.

                • tinfoilhat

                  You really do talk a lot of rubbish some times Felix.

                  • felix

                    Then please enlighten me. What have the police said they have done?

                    • weka

                      Apparently, they’ve had a team working on this for two years. You might think that that means they’ve sat in their offices doing nothing. I don’t. I want to know exactly what’s been done and by whom, because it will make it obvious to people that trust the police a lot what the problem is. Saying that the police have done nothing is a misleading, too easy copout.

                      (apologies for the pun).

                    • felix

                      Well weka, in two years of knowing about these rapists they have either:

                      (a) prosecuted them, or

                      (b) done something else

                      Thing is, I don’t give a fuck about (b).

                    • weka

                      For me, I want to a better analysis of the situation than “the police are crap”.

                • Murray Olsen

                  They would have opened a file.

        • Mike S 10.1.1.2

          “That is evidence sufficient for a conviction in most all cases.”

          Ummm, no.

          A formal statement given to police admitting a crime is sufficient evidence. Posts on facebook aren’t.

  11. vto 11

    Haven’t read all the comments above and the issues seem to have been canvassed all over the media. But if a few quick 2c could be added…

    – This issue has very long legs and high potential to blow up in the faces of both the police and this government. Big time.

    – The attitudes expressed by the arseholes concerned will be familiar to many males (and many females I’m sure). It is one of humankind’s most abhorrent features. It is most common in gangs. Ugly. The worldwide communication today has merely exposed it (like so many other issues).

    – Betcha we see the arseholes concerned in the news in the future – knee-capped or hung drawn and quartered. Would not like to be them at the moment – there will be some bad eggs hunting them down.

    – NZ culture has transformed at many points over the last 200 years, usually for the better. This event will hasten improvement in this area too.

  12. vto 12

    John Key is again exhibiting his woefully inadequate and shallow nature in how he has attended to this.

    inadequate

    shallow

    woeful

  13. North 13

    Lanthanide, you @ 1 in the Plutocrat v Populist post: I responded rather too dismissively I’m sorry. Having seen the subject of Karol’s post and read it (it’s now at lead as stipulated by you), you are completely right.

    I see this as a reflection of how spiritually and morally corrupt our society has become. Young men, good looking “now” dudes. They are powerful in the context and are thus persuaded of their “entitletment” to plunder the weak.

    Certainly according to many the right of the powerful to plunder is the new morality. It is the very foundation upon which rests neoliberalism and ShonKey Python’s cargo-cult. Even those of its practitioners who once believed that it was for the common good have been disabused in numbers. So for an excess of “self” they define their plunder as glamorous, reflective of their elevation to “more than equal”.

    Wonder if those guys who self-videod understand that they’re probably looking square in the eyes of an eight year starting point right now ? The fact of videoing and the whole Facebook thing is distinctly aggravating of course.

    Does make you wonder about the Police’s two year “hobby” investigation.

    • Lanthanide 13.1

      You don’t need to apologise. No one should ever feel the need to apologise to me for anything they say on here.

    • Naturesong 13.2

      North,

      This is not something new. Though the publishing of it on FB may be.

      When I was at school in the 80’s there were boys at my school who did this, and bragged about it. The girls who suffered were branded as sluts and had to change schools.
      There were much publicised pack rapes by gangs at that time.

      More recently (in the last 5 years), there have been a pack of boys around Pt Chev. doing this as well.

      The acceptance of this behaviour, or at least the feeling that nothing can be done about it, I’ve known all my life.

      I’m 45.

      • vto 13.2.1

        Yes, it will be familiar to many people, as mentioned above. It is as old as humanity. Like murder, infanticide, on it goes …… one of humanity’s very ugly sides

        The reaction is due to its super-wide publicity.

        The super-wide publicity may bring about change for the better too though….. like the dangerous intersection that doesn’t get fixed until someone gets killed.

      • weka 13.2.2

        I’m a similar age Naturesong. I had a friend in my mid-teens who was pack raped at a party while very drunk. It was years before we talked about it in terms of rape.

        “There were much publicised pack rapes by gangs at that time.”

        Yeah, but betting that they were proper gangs, hated by society. And that no-one was talking publicly about the school boys doing it. In my friend’s case the boys were all ‘normal’ middle-NZ guys.

        Rape is what Other people do, people who are distinctly different from us, not our brothers or mates or sons.

        • Naturesong 13.2.2.1

          “Yeah, but betting that they were proper gangs, hated by society”

          Correct.

          Though they were happening at similar times, mid 80’s.

          One caused outrage, the other shamed the victems.

  14. weka 14

    Idiot Savant, in reply to Rageaholic, About 8 hours ago

    “I genuinely don’t understand why no charges can be laid unless a victim makes a complaint.”

    Well, it makes it very difficult to bring a successful prosecution in a rape case (and its difficult enough when the victim is willing to testify, because rapists love to put their victims on trial). But given what’s been said publicly, they should be able to start with conspiracy to commit rape (7 year sentence) and move on from there.

    http://publicaddress.net/system/cafe/hard-news-narcissists-and-bullies/?p=299996#post299996

  15. sarah54 15

    This truly is an appalling case. Which is why we start changing our laws to make a serious effort to stamp out rape and rape culture once and for all: If a woman or girl says she has been raped, we accept her word for it and do not entertain any argument that the sex was consensual, as I’ve posted elsewhere.

    While I understand that it won’t directly solve this case, what it will do is make victims of cases such as this much more willing to come forward, because all they will have the confidence to know that if they do come forward, their word will be taken as fact by the justice system. They won’t be further slut-shamed by the justice system and the only legal avenue for the perpetrators to prove that they are not guilty will be to show that they were mistakenly identified (obviously this cannot happen in this case since the perpetrators have pretty much identified themselves).

    So that’s my proposal. If a woman says she was raped by a man, then she was raped by that man. That is all we need to know. A simple solution with absolutely no drawbacks, since false allegations are so rare they are pretty much non-existent, and all are discovered before they go to trial.

    I hope this idea gains support here an elsewhere, and if so maybe we will gain momentum to have the law changed. And for those of you who say this is treating rapists as “guilty until proven innocent”, I say rubbish – this is simple accepting a woman’s word as proof of guilt.

    • Not Another Sheep 15.1

      And if a man or a boy says he was raped by/sexually abused/ assaulted by a man or a woman, boy or girl; then “he was” too ?

      Big police SAT team hui in Wellington already this year. They are well onto it !

    • Lanthanide 15.2

      No. What you’re suggesting offends the basic principles of justice. There are no other crimes where an accusation is as good as a conviction, which is what you’re proposing.

      You definitely would be overhauling the existing rape culture, but you’d be replacing it with another where an accusation of rape is used as a weapon, rather than the current culture where rape itself is used as a weapon.

      Sure, at the moment there are very few false allegations, but in the system you’re proposing, there definitely will be because the only defense you’re allowing the accused is mistaken identity.

      The current system definitely needs to be overhauled and made much fairer and safer for the victims, but what you’re suggesting is not justice either.

      There is a bit of a weird ethical situation here, because I don’t doubt for a second that your proposed regime would actually see significantly less aggregate harm done on society than what we currently have, so in that sense it should be welcomed. But fundamentally what you’re suggesting isn’t justice.

      • KJT 15.2.1

        No question that, on the face of it, those boys should get jail time for what they did.

        But. Abrogating laws of evidence, repressing free speech, people should be allowed to condemn themselves out of their own mouth, and assuming that witnesses identification or statements are always correct is not the answer.
        Havn’t we just had an accused rapist freed because DNA evidence showed it could not possibly have been him.

        Bringing attitudes out into the open and changing young peoples perception and care for each other is!

    • emergency mike 15.3

      “A simple solution with absolutely no drawbacks, since false allegations are so rare they are pretty much non-existent, and all are discovered before they go to trial.”

      While it’s obviously very difficult to get any meaningful statistics on false accusations of rape, that doesn’t mean that the are ‘so rare they are pretty much non-existent, and all are discovered before they go to trial.’

      http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_accusation_of_rape

      No drawbacks? You want a society where any woman has the power to destroy any man’s life any time she wants? Sorry sarah, but female psychopaths do exist. There are documented cases of women who falsely accuse men of rape on a serial basis. (There’s this thing called google.) Do you think there would be more if we did as you say? Mmm I think yeah, probably.

      As others have said, this goes against our concept of justice, innocent until proven guilty is there for a reason. Because even if it means that sometimes the guilty get off, that’s better than innocent people having their lives destroyed without proof. One person making an accusation is not proof, not even if it’s a woman.

      I agree that this case shows that something is flawed in our justice/police system, but this is not the solution.

      • Chooky 15.3.1

        +1…guilt must be proven in a court of law

      • weka 15.3.2

        Mike, while I agree with you generally (but no absolutely), I have to take issue with this

        “You want a society where any woman has the power to destroy any man’s life any time she wants?”

        As opposed to the current situation where any man has the power to destroy any woman’s life any time he wants? Why would reversing that be so bad?

        I think sarah is wrong, although I appreciate her comments because they make the issues starkly visible. But your argument is not the right one to comabt it because you are essentially saying that men’s safety is more important than women’s. We already knew that.

        I think Lanth’s last paragraph on ethics is most astute.

        Sarah,

        “If a woman says she was raped by a man, then she was raped by that man. That is all we need to know. A simple solution with absolutely no drawbacks, since false allegations are so rare they are pretty much non-existent, and all are discovered before they go to trial.”

        The problem here is that not all women know which man raped them, and sometimes women make mistakes ie the rape allegation isn’t false, but the identity of the rapist is wrong.

        There used to be a prominent NZ QC who suggested that rape trials be the one situation where the defendent wasn’t presumed innocent until proven guilty, that a different approach was used. I’d like to see discussion about how to change how law is tried so that the process is more equitable for victims and society. Rape seems a singularly distinct crime, from all others, and it’s worth looking at why. I think there are connections between how our justice system was set up and why rape is so hard to try ie if women had set up the justice system we would have different kinds of rape trials. I think this is a better path to explore than using the current system but just making women’s testimony absolute.

        • emergency mike 15.3.2.1

          “Mike, while I agree with you generally (but no absolutely), I have to take issue with this

          “You want a society where any woman has the power to destroy any man’s life any time she wants?””

          You take issue with that? So you do want a society where any woman has the power to destroy any man’s life any time she wants? Each to their own I guess.

          “As opposed to the current situation where any man has the power to destroy any woman’s life any time he wants?”

          Wait what? Did we legalize rape? Anyone has the power to destroy anyone’s life – stab someone in the chest, poison their coffee, etc. However those things are illegal, there are consequences if you do it. Like rape is illegal, and like falsely accusing someone of rape is illegal, if you get caught there are consequences.

          But Sarah is talking about giving women the right to make their accusation of rape unquestionable and consequence free legal evidence of rape, whether it’s true or not. One could falsely accuse someone of rape, send them to jail, have have them be a ‘rapist’ for the rest of their life, no questions asked. That’s ridiculous.

          “Why would reversing that be so bad?”

          My comment was specifically to Sarah’s suggestion, you seem to be talking about the wider issue of how we currently deal with rape. I absolutely agree that the current situation is badly flawed. Would I like to see a system that better protects the victims put it place? Yes. Is Sarah’s suggestion the way to do it? No.

          I’m not sure what you mean exactly by ‘reversing that’ since you said you disagree with Sarah, so I fail to see how you can accuse me of doubting the merits of ‘reversing that’.

          “you are essentially saying that men’s safety is more important than women’s”

          No, I’m saying that ‘innocent until proven guilty’ is the cornerstone of our justice system for good reasons and we should keep it.

          • weka 15.3.2.1.1

            Don’t be a reactive dick. You appear to be saying that the current state of affairs is preferable to changing it so that men are disadvantaged but women aren’t. Read Lanth’s comment above and then come back and talk about what’s fair.

            “As opposed to the current situation where any man has the power to destroy any woman’s life any time he wants?”

            Wait what? Did we legalize rape? Anyone has the power to destroy anyone’s life – stab someone in the chest, poison their coffee, etc. However those things are illegal, there are consequences if you do it. Like rape is illegal, and like falsely accusing someone of rape is illegal, if you get caught there are consequences.

            You really have no idea what you are talking about if you think how rape gets dealt with has any comparison with other crimes, esp murder. By far the majority of rape goes unpunished and unnoticed expect by the victim and those closest. Most rapists don’t face consequences. Please educate yourself before you start making such frankly stupid comparisons in conversations about rape and rape culture.

            “you are essentially saying that men’s safety is more important than women’s”

            No, I’m saying that ‘innocent until proven guilty’ is the cornerstone of our justice system for good reasons and we should keep it.

            Yep, and I don’t particularly disagree in general, but feel free to respond to my points about rape being a different kind of crime (whilst I didn’t agree with sarah). If you hold ‘innocent until proven guilty’ as the most important thing here, then you are saying that men are more important than women (because that’s how that principle of justice plays out in the real world).

            • emergency mike 15.3.2.1.1.1

              “Don’t be a reactive dick.”

              I’m reactive but you’re the one calling me names? Irony much?

              “You appear to be saying that the current state of affairs is preferable to changing it so that men are disadvantaged but women aren’t.”

              Nope, I’m saying that Sarah’s suggestion is not the remedy for the current state of affairs. I’m not sure how much clearer I can make this for you. I’ve said more than once now that I’d like to see a system which fairer for and better protects the victims. But I’m not claiming to have a good idea about what that would look like. As you said, some discussion would be good.

              My comments were in the context of arguing against Sarah’s suggestion. You took them out of that context, made up some weird strawman about how I think rape is treated compared to other crimes, and then called me more names. Good fun. Let me reassure you: I didn’t mean to imply anything at all about the conviction rates for rape compared to other crimes. Here I’ll rephrase that if you really want:

              “However those things are illegal, there are consequences if you get convicted. Like rape is illegal, and like falsely accusing someone of rape is illegal, if you get convicted there are consequences”

              All better?

              “If you hold ‘innocent until proven guilty’ as the most important thing here, then you are saying that men are more important than women (because that’s how that principle of justice plays out in the real world).”

              I don’t think so. I think the problem is that the police/justice system does not have a good way of dealing with rape cases that is fair to both the victim and the accused. Due to the psychological trauma involved for the victim, we should give a better way of proceeding in rape cases. Yes, differently to other kinds of crime. But the principle of ‘innocent until proven guilty’ isn’t the culprit and doesn’t have to be sacrificed. And I for one would like to see neither men nor women disadvantaged.

              • weka

                You do realise that I largely agreed with your original comment, with the exception of one sentence that I thought bore analysis?

                “All better?”

                No. It’s not valid to compare rape with other crimes, because rape doesn’t get treated like other crimes irrespective of what you discuss in the abstract.

                Making some changes to how rape trials are conducted would be good for sure, but I can’t see how you can do that without changing the advantage given to men via the ‘innocent’ principle. If you can see a way, please post it. This doesn’t mean throwing the principle out completely, but the value of what sarah wrote was that it points out how extreme this situation is for women and how completely lame society is at dealing with it. Again, I point to Lanth’s comment, and that yes if sarah’s idea were adopted (for rape cases) it would be unfair on men, but fairer on women, and on balance less damage would be done. You argue no to that, hence my view that you think that men are more valuable than women. I’m sure you don’t WANT it to be that way, but that’s the way it is under what you argue.

                • emergency mike

                  I do realise that we are largely in agreement about the main points weka – the current system is not working and is unfair to women, but innocent until proven guilty can’t be abandoned. I just think that given that problems seem to be based around a hugely dated patrichial view about how to respond to this crime, there must be a solution which is fair, or at least fairer, to both victim and accused.

                  I don’t have the answers and I haven’t claimed to.

                  I feel like you think there is some kind of men/women ‘fairness’ scale, I think that’s a false dichotomy, this is a problem for the whole community. And if there is anything good to this roastbusters thing, it’s that people are talking about exactly this. That the status quo is crazy, something has to change if we really want to call ourselves a civilized society. (Oh that’s right, John Key’s gonna sort it with his cyberbullying law. Great.)

                  As for Lanth’s comment, I don’t think it would be ‘unfair’ on men, I think it would be an obscene injustice if someone could point the finger and say “He raped me.” and with no further evidence a man goes to jail for years and is a ‘rapist’ for life. Also ‘on balance less damage would be done’ is an blithe opinion unbacked by any argument. What would the social ramifications of sarah’s law be? Because I don’t agree with Lanth that means I think ‘men are more valuable’? Really? Or maybe I just think there must be a better way?

                  But back to our slavishly pedantic and largely pointless argument about ‘comparisons’. I said that rape, like murder, is illegal, and if convicted there are consequences. That’s not a comparison, that’s a statement of fact. I was making a point, you took it out of context, and tried to make it about something it wasn’t.

                  • weka

                    Ok, thanks for clarifying.

                    I don’t think it’s just the justice system that is the problem here, it’s the rape culture so deeply embedded in all sectors of society.

                    “As for Lanth’s comment, I don’t think it would be ‘unfair’ on men, I think it would be an obscene injustice if someone could point the finger and say “He raped me.” and with no further evidence a man goes to jail for years and is a ‘rapist’ for life.”

                    I agree, it would be an obscene injustice. But that is what happens to many women all the time. Their lives get destroyed in that way, and sweet fuck all is being done about it. So, just making some figures up here, let’s say with sarah’s idea we might have ten men per year wrongly imprisoned for rape. Compared to say 1,000 women raped with no chance of justice under the current system. Do you get it yet? Why are those ten men more important than those 1,000 women?

                    It’s not a false dichotomy. This is a VERY gendered issue, and the reason the above example exists is because our whole society, including our legal and justice systems, is structured so that the ten men are more important than the 1,000 women.

                    So to go back to your sentence ““You want a society where any woman has the power to destroy any man’s life any time she wants?” Do you see now why I reversed it? Because the situation that you find so obscene for men already exists for women. I want to know why it would be so terrible to reverse it.

                    • emergency mike

                      “I don’t think it’s just the justice system that is the problem here, it’s the rape culture so deeply embedded in all sectors of society.”

                      I totally agree, the way we currently deal with rape cases is sadly influenced by said culture.

                      weka, I’m not saying that the many women who are raped and let down by a justice system that is stacked against them are not the victims of a gross injustice. But sarah’s law is madness. Without even the appearance of justice, you’re heading for societal breakdown, forget civilized society.

                      Your made up figures are the same kind of Ethics 101 dilemma as ‘would you murder one man to save two? five? ten?’ Some of us don’t see easy answers to such questions. You want to talk about things that you can’t compare I think your 10 men vs 1000 women is one such.

                      “I want to know why it would be so terrible to reverse it.”

                      Again I’m a bit confused here. You’ve said you don’t agree with sarah’s law, but you want me to tell you why we shouldn’t ‘reverse it’. If you want me to argue against it then I have to ask what ‘reverse it’ entails exactly if not sarah’s law. The two situations you want to ‘swap’ are apples and oranges.

                      If you want me to imagine that men are the rape victims and women are the rapists and the system is skewed in their favour in just the same way, then sure, they are morally equivalent. Otherwise I’m not sure what you want.

          • QoT 15.3.2.1.2

            So you do want a society where any woman has the power to destroy any man’s life any time she wants?

            It has been a fucking long day full of fucking rape proponents (at this stage I’m canning the word “apologist” as too moderate) so all I can say is: yeah, mike. That’s exactly it. Enjoy living in our fucking world.

            • emergency mike 15.3.2.1.2.1

              I’m sorry you’ve had a busy day ‘n all QoT, but I’m not sure what your point is exactly.

    • Mike S 15.4

      “since false allegations are so rare they are pretty much non-existent”

      Ummm, no.

  16. Tracey 16

    Lanth

    a facilitator would be a parent bring uo children in an environment where women are under valued and seen as less-than men. Where boys learn women are weak and useless and most of their bad behaviour is boys being boys… and even applauded.

    I was appalled to see the police officer on tv saying in the end the girls have to give evidence and it wont be nice. He should just have been encouraging them to talk to the police and take it from there. I woukdnt have pressed charges based on what he said.

    bm

    sorry but what shit. Women and girls have been raped and gang raped long before gangsta stuff.

    my own sexual violation at age 11 was by a white man aged about 60 who was a granddad figure to us.

    my friend was raped from the age of 5 to 11 by her older brother. White and children of a school dp and teacher. That was also in the 70s.

    this incident is horrific. Most if not all victims of rape and sexual assault feel ashamed and that it was their fault. Hence they keep quiet. By publicising it the young men have raped them twice. I hope all the victims are on suicide watch.

    I also dont understand why the police didnt follow the ring leaders to get evidence.

    IF the actual raping is not recorded that cld be why the police cant act. Young men can claim what they like but its not evidence if in court they retract.

    I am appalled by the pm and collins equating it to their cyber bullying campaign. The young men dont need to grow up they need serious re-programming and the beginning of learning to face consequences. And some pressure put on their parents wouldn’t hurt.

    • felix 16.1

      “I was appalled to see the police officer on tv saying in the end the girls have to give evidence and it wont be nice. He should just have been encouraging them to talk to the police and take it from there. I woukdnt have pressed charges based on what he said.”

      Of course not, what he did was a deliberate threat. Live on tv. He should be charged with intimidating witnesses and obstruction of justice.

  17. Ad 17

    NZHerald reports one of the males was fired from his job as a result.

    That’s a nice blunt instrument for business to use to show its disapproval, other than criminal section.

    Hopefully they all lose their jobs.

    Another step would be for the Minister of Social Development to issue a directive that anyone caught doing this on Facebook (Twitter, Vine etc) will have their benefits stopped.

  18. RedBaronCV 18

    And the Herald managed to ignore and minimise the main issue – how could somebody possibly write this story and for it then to go through all the various edit layers- and then be printed – and nobody there noticed and said anything. What sort of culture does the place have?

  19. Tracey 19

    Some things bear repeating

    They were underage, so its rape.They were stupefied so its rape.They filmed their victims, so its child pornography.They put pictures up on social media sites, so its distribution of child pornography.They not only admitted to all this, they wore what they did as a badge of honor.They should be in jail right now and be listed as a child sex offender.

    brett please send this to the pm and the justice minister

  20. Pascal's bookie 20

    Posted this in open mike too, but please read these thoughts about what to do with your justified anger around this:

    http://thehandmirror.blogspot.co.nz/2013/11/the-baying-mob-or-how-i-carry-torch.html

    It’s not just one case. Forming a mob and hounding this case until it’s over one way or another won’t fix anything. these guys are not victims by any stretch, but they aren’t the whole problem.

    • karol 20.1

      Thanks, pb. I’ll add a link to it in my post.

      • weka 20.1.1

        Karol, any chance that Hand Mirror post can go up as a guest post? Very important post and it would be good if it got wide exposure. Not sure who manages the guest posts at ts, I’ll try emailing Lynn later too.

        • karol 20.1.1.1

          weka, I have never had anything to do with organising guest posts. emailing Lynn is probably seems a good way to go about it.

  21. anarcho 21

    Sure it is the system of rape culture in action…. but…

    I forwarded this tragedy to ‘anon’ hackers with a plea that they put their very effective spotlight on these boys – if the systems ‘justice’ fails then the community needs to act.

    Baying mobs achieve.

    • grumpy 21.1

      Dunno about “rape culture” but is sure appears that some “cultures” (such as gang culture) have rape as part of their “culture”.

      • weka 21.1.1

        You obviously haven’t been paying attention grumpy. Yes gangs have rape as part of their culture, so do white boy rugby clubs and boarding schools. Rape is (predominantly) something that men do to people they have power over. The common denominator is gender and power relations, not ethnicity (although the ways that rape culture plays out varies from culture to culture).

  22. Win 22

    Didn’t they get Teina Pora on his word alone? I guess it just depends who you are.

    • grumpy 22.1

      No, it just depends if you make a confession. Hardly incomprehensible that if you confess to a crime you become a suspect? FFS

      • thatguynz 22.1.1

        No-one ever gets coerced into making a confession do they? ffs..

        • idlegus 22.1.1.1

          bragging about stupefying young girls & giving other boys advice on how to ‘spit roast’ (first one guy starts, then the other sneaks in!) isnt some kind of confession? i see one guy lost his job, now with employers doing quick google searches on ppl before the employ then then these lads futures are stuffed. im amazed at how stupid they are online, the drug pics, the bragging, … you gotta be so careful about how much you share on the web.

  23. Tracey 23

    Pascals b

    I for one need no convincing this is not the story but rather the attitudes still held toward women and girls. Men have been raping women for millenia.

    people like bm shows how far we have yet to come… he thinks women have achieved full equality and then their are the people and parents who say derogatory things about wonen in front of their children say its just a joke… but children are more literal than that.

    • grumpy 23.1

      Hey, if you generalise as much as possible it all just becomes some great political bullshit fest – eh?

      • Pascal's bookie 23.1.1

        Instead of mindlessly slagging people off, why don’t you say what you are hinting at Grumps?

        • grumpy 23.1.1.1

          Thought it was clear. At the start of this thread the discussion was pretty straight to the point, the further it goes, the more generalised it gets until it just becomes a political wankfest and the original issue gets diluted to irrelevance.
          These women deserve better.

          • Pascal's bookie 23.1.1.1.1

            People are discussing why these things happen. They don’t happen becuase of isolated events. They are not isolated events. They are manifestations of really prevalent parts of society.

            it is a social problem. That’s worthy of discussion.

            • pollywog 23.1.1.1.1.1

              Ah yes, so in the wider context of culture and evolution…

              Has rape culture always existed or has it evolved ?

              • Rogue Trooper

                latent

              • Tat Loo

                Has rape culture always existed or has it evolved ?

                Records of war rape and the usual conduct of armies of raping, pillaging and burning as they go have been around for a very very long time, back to the days of Homer and before.

              • Rogue Trooper

                as the schematic illustrates, prevailing social conditions excite, or inhibit, the penetration expressed.

              • weka

                “Has rape culture always existed or has it evolved ?”

                Some people believe that rape at the levels we see it now is a manifestation of the patriarchy (so around 5,000 years). This is based on the idea that rape is about power and control (which is why rape is so common during war). It makes sense to me that the more egalitarian a culture is, the less rape there is, and I don’t have a problem believing that rape is a relatively recent thing in terms of human evolution. I’m sure there has always been isolated instances of rape, but I don’t see the evidence that rape is a common phenomena across all cultures and all time.

                • Chooky

                  +100….”a manifestation of the patriarchy” ….good points weka….

                • Robert M

                  Bullshit. The military have always fought with their cocks as well as guns. The only difference between the SS and the German Army were the SS were selected as to be sufficiently good looking that ethnically and racially (sic) desirable women would remove their clothes and voluntarily have sex with them as soon as they arrived as conquerors. The strategy seemed to work in France, Holland, Roumania and the Baltic States. In France 8 million French citizens are now German possibly advancing European unity and peace more than the EEC. In reality many seemed to be attracted by the SS, elements of the NZ Maori army were apparently keen to sign up with the SS as long as they had the use of the SS Brothels.
                  Invasions have usually had an evolutionary effect, as did the British arrival in Tahiti and NZ.
                  There seems little difference between the roasters and any British rock group arriving in Australasia or the US in the 1960s or 1970s. Apparently hundreds of 14/15 years old girls were directed into the arms of Jagger, Wyman and Jones in Sydney and Melbourne hotels in 1964/5 and they were even out on the trawl in Invercargill
                  It would seem to me that most young men are highly sexed particularly if they are intelligent and the sexual activity comes out one way or another. In many of the good and second line , UK public schools most of the 13/14 yrs were raped by staff and the older boys ( eg nb Peter Cook bio- re Repton Public School and reflect on the general darkness at schools like Eton and Loretto were these activities peaked in the late 1940s. The introduction of women into public schools and the RN was to give the boys something softer to rape than their fellows. Actually although these things were probably only common in NZ at Kings, Christs and various Maori, Catholic and SW institutions. The propensity of rock stars, racing drivers and actors to have sex with 30/40 partners a night seems not unusual and has probably been typical since Roman and Greek Times. Apparently when Ronald Reagan was an advance man for GE in the states in 1950s the average female industrial worker was inclined to strip the moment he walked into the factory.
                  So I just think its exraordinary hypocrisy, crap from the feminists, anti men and headmasters. The idea that girls should not have sex before their 16 seems ludicrous and one would suggest male health declines if they don’t have sex by 17.

                  [karol: your first sentence was on the right track, but your comment was all downhill from there. Rape and consensual sex are two totally different things, which you are confusing. You seem keener to accept rape happens when it is males that are the victims. If you are incapable of learning the facts of rape and rape culture, any more comments like this will be deleted from this thread.

                  The hypocrisy is all yours]

  24. Tracey 24

    Win

    two young men have gone to the cops. If they confess in a formal interview like teina paul charges will be laid… I suspect the parents of some will be pressing for reduce charge for evidence against others.

    one girl has already attempted suicide…

    now turn your minds to the rape and sexual assaults committed everyday in nz with no reporting or charges.

    lets focus on how as a society we can change our talk and our actions so no victim feels they cant come forward. Vengeance may make some fathers feel better but it does nothing for victims.its about predominantly male power and violence those baying for blood are on the same spectrum as the rapist… just at the other end…

    it is not about how WE feel its about the victims

    • grumpy 24.1

      This is more about the evolving of an abhorrent culture, mainly in Auckland. There are specific issues here, some to “sensitive” for some to stomach. I find the lack of action by police very disturbing but also the attempts by some to deflect the responsibility and underlying causitive factors.

      [karol: it is you who are attempting to deflect away from the underlying causative factors - the wider rape culture. You are on a warning]

  25. uke 25

    So it emerges that one of the ringleaders is the son of a police officer:

    http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=11151474

    Wonder if he bragged about this to his victims to stop them complaining to police? Another reason why none of the girls have been “brave enough” to lay formal charges…

  26. grumpy 26

    This is crazy. How can this be tolerated for so long in a decent society? I can understand the vigilante threats as it seems to only way these women will recieve any form of justice.

    However, from a lot of the comments on this thread, it appears many are only interested in this topic for political reasons. Their concern runs shallow and hopes of a constructive discussion doomed to failure.

    • Pascal's bookie 26.1

      Discuss away.

      here’s something to start with:

      https://medium.com/ladybits-on-medium/4c854eb591a5

      Lots of food for thought there about culture, and who needs to fix it.

      • grumpy 26.1.1

        Thanks for proving my point.

        • Pascal's bookie 26.1.1.1

          What point?

          Are you not being political Grumps? What is this sensitive issue that you think needs to remain unspoken.

          make your fucking point already.

          • grumpy 26.1.1.1.1

            Yeah, look how some commenters turned on poor old BM a bit further up for having the audacity to make the startlingly obvious comment that maybe, just maybe, the growing Auckland “Gangsta” culture might, just might, have something to do with this.
            Whine away if you like but to pretend otherwise just exposes those as politically motivated fuckwits just using these women’s plight to push a political philosophy and hide “inconvenient truths”.

            [karol: you are on a warning. It is you who are avoiding the politically inconvenient truth that you seem unwilling to face - rape culture is everywhere. Gangsta culture is a sub-set set of the wider rape culture. And your line is one that is an attempt to stifle that "inconvenient truth". The evidence is everywhere. Any more along that line and such comments will be deleted from this thread.

            You have no idea of the way rape culture, along with the explicit examples and threats of rape, work to intimidate and silence women. Sometimes it's time to stand up and say ENOUGH!.

            Here's a clue, grumpy - maybe you could try listening/reading and taking notice of what many women say, like the one Pb linked to, instead of pushing your own, hands-over-ears, political agenda.]

            • fender 26.1.1.1.1.1

              Yeah poor BM, how unfair he gets a tune-up for being a racist prick.

            • Pascal's bookie 26.1.1.1.1.2

              Well he didn;t say ‘might just might’ or ‘maybe’ or anything like it. he said that gangsta culture was all it is about. That there is nothing to see here but black people.

              Why is that generalisation ok, but other generalisations not, Grumpy?

              • grumpy

                Yep fender and PB. I just looked through the Roast Busters facebook pages and one thing does jump out. There’s a lot of poor bastards that can’t write, have their baseball caps on backwards and cover their bodies with scribbles.
                There also seems to be quite a few blaming the victims.
                Not all of them are male either.

                • Pascal's bookie

                  Clearly it’s all about hats and grammar then.

                  As you were.

                • fender

                  Remember the good old days before rap music when rape never occurred…Tui time Grumps.
                  Shock-horror but some rapists wear suits and listen to jazz or opera…

                  • grumpy

                    Agree completely. Some are also police officers…….

                    • framu

                      so why are you going on about gangsta culture? shit mate you cant even describe it!

                      So far you seem to think its poor grammer, badly worn hats and tattoos

                      fucks sake man

                • Tat Loo

                  I thought I heard on National Radio that FB had taken those pages down, grumpy.

                  • ropata

                    I think the original page is gone but there are several hate pages seeking revenge on the little rapists, and a tasteless one that attempts to be funny. Excuse me while i go wash my hands…

              • BM

                I may have been guilty of not quite covering all bases and should have mentioned young guys of all races are part of this gangsta culture.

                My apologies.

                • One Anonymous Knucklehead

                  You may have been guilty of not quite using any critical faculties and should have realised by now that rape culture is ubiquitous, and not confined to people who listen to music you don’t like.

                • framu

                  clint rickards – would you describe him as belonging to this black gangsta culture BM?

                • felix

                  Hi BM, let’s just revisit your original comment so everyone can see how it wasn’t really racist at all and how you just forgot to include a couple of races.

                  I disagree, it’s black gangsta culture, the same shit all the Maori, Polly boys are into.

                  • BM

                    How about we swap “all” with “a majority”, would that be acceptable.

                    Unfortunately I can’t really contribute to any further conversation because I’ve got to go change out the engine mounts on the car.

            • felix 26.1.1.1.1.3

              grumpy, your last sentence is a strikingly accurate description of what BM was trying to do.

              • grumpy

                If you want to hold the police, Key and Collins to account for their inaction, then I’m your man. But………………..

            • grumpy 26.1.1.1.1.4

              Well, Karol, I just guess that having daughters and grandaughters must give me a little bit more focus on the immediate problem at hand. I accept that you have a more global perspective but my sympathies are with the abused girls and certainly with anyone who would seriously address the poor response from police and politicians.

              • miravox

                “I just guess that having daughters and grandaughters must give me a little bit more focus …. Gangsta culture might, just might, have something to do with this”

                Maybe if you were a granddaughter or a daughter you’d know that it’s only gangsta culture because that’s the culture these girls came across. If you were in a private school it would be private school culture that created these rapists, it you were in an IT environment it would be geek culture, if you’re mates were car mechanics it would be a boy racer culture that had no respect for girls.. the list goes on and on and on and on….

              • karol

                my sympathies are with the abused girls and certainly with anyone who would seriously address the poor response from police and politicians.

                I agree with you on this.

            • framu 26.1.1.1.1.5

              its not a black culture thing and its not an auckland culture thing – thats why BM got pounced on. He was being staggeringly thick and engaging in a gross generalisation.

              The exact thing your on here bitching about!

              Theres isnt a growing auckland gangsta culture you dick – young boys be acting all tuff and shit everywhere for ages

            • Ennui 26.1.1.1.1.6

              K, you might as well tell me to take a flying hike as I find your statement “avoiding the politically inconvenient truth that you seem unwilling to face – rape culture is everywhere.” at total odds with my view of the human condition. I just cringe at materialist logic producing nice tidy models and labeling neatly all those considered within as defined players. This line of thinking leads inevitably to sanctioned acceptance of defined groups. They can then be “dealt with” inhumanly and with impunity by the labeling committee, dehumanised and sent to the camps. It mirrors the thinking of the perpetrators, the rapists, the power structures that rely upon violence for adherence.

              We are all individuals, we are not part of your model. It is how we as individuals interact with others and how we address being human that counts. having self awareness to be able to decide what is good, to treat others as you would be treated yourself.

              • Rogue Trooper

                as an aside, Simon Moore suggesting on Midday Report that the online statements of offenders (such as these pack-rapists) may be as, or more, admissible as statements given to Police.

              • McFlock

                Actually, I don’t mind sending rapists to a camp. We can surround it with walls and barbed wire and call it a “prison”.

              • karol

                Ennui, I do not agree that we are such islands on individualism, unaffected by the culture we live in. Yes we do need to take responsibility for our actions and the impact they have on others. But the route to understanding our own actions in the wider context can be a complicated one, as indicated by Scuba Nurse’s post.

                The case currently under the magnifying glass is, among other things, the example of a group action. And there’s a lot of research that shows how people get drawn into doing things in groups that they would not necessarily do on their on. These are social acts, in a social context with many contributing factors. It requires education and self awareness, based in research, to understand how such actions have become so prevalent in our society.

                I do not agree that these are isolated examples. And i do not agree that they exist in a bubble outside of the dominant culture.

                • Ennui

                  Karol, I think you might read me again: at no point did I say we are unaffected by the broad and undefinable “culture” we live in, I agree we are. And yes the issue at hand is a group action specifically because we are affected by our culture (which rather proves the former point). And I agree these are not isolated incidents. You have missed the whole point: I don’t find your model and the labeling in the slightest bit useful. In fact I see inherent danger in it as I pointed out.

                  It is at this point I will concede that the bloggers all seem to be trying to address the evil that is rape: McFlock wants rapists incarcerated behind barbed wire. I want restorative justice where the perpetrator has to recognise the damage and to demonstrate empathy for the victim, to take responsibility. How else do we rebuild broken lives of victim and perpetrator? To change the “culture” with its basic building blocks : individual people.

                  • karol

                    I’ve re-read it, Ennui.

                    Then I do not understand how you get from this:

                    I don’t find your model and the labeling in the slightest bit useful. In fact I see inherent danger in it as I pointed out.

                    To this:

                    I just cringe at materialist logic producing nice tidy models and labeling neatly all those considered within as defined players. This line of thinking leads inevitably to sanctioned acceptance of defined groups. They can then be “dealt with” inhumanly and with impunity by the labeling committee, dehumanised and sent to the camps. It mirrors the thinking of the perpetrators, the rapists, the power structures that rely upon violence for adherence.

                    In fact, from what you’ve written, I don’t understand what you mean by my model and labelling.

                    PS: Especially as my comments that you have quoted and bolded in your comment, refer to the general culture and not the labeling of individuals or groups within that culture.

                  • McFlock

                    McFlock wants rapists incarcerated behind barbed wire. I want restorative justice where the perpetrator has to recognise the damage and to demonstrate empathy for the victim, to take responsibility

                    The two are not mutually exclusive.

                    • Chooky

                      +1….I think they deserve to be incarcerated if found guilty( barbed wire wouldnt trouble me at all)

                      ….and then they must make an extended public apology to their victims and families on Facebook, or wherever the victims deem fit online.

    • TheContrarian 26.2

      Well said Grumpy. Making it political detracts from the real issue

    • QoT 26.3

      How can this be tolerated for so long in a decent society?

      Because we don’t live in a decent fucking society for the majority of people, grumpy. You might call that statement “political” but I call it “acknowledging fucking reality”.

  27. Varity 27

    i am no fan of shonkey and am guilty of saying any old thing to have a wee dig at him …

    but i really don’t see where he’s said or done anything wrong in relation to this particularly highly emotive and sensitive story. i believe he would be as shocked and appalled as the rest of the nation about the actions of these young hoods and if he babbled a pile of twaddle when put on the spot and questioned about it then that just makes him as human as the rest of us.

    collins on the other hand (i have no link), i’ve heard implied and seemingly condoned, the “hoods”, being raped themselves in jail. as i said, i only heard it but wouldn’t be in the least surprised if something like that came from that rabid troll.

    sadly on social media – many of our countrymen are making similar comments re the hoods getting raped in jail or worse. they can’t see it makes them as bad as the offenders.

  28. Bob 28

    I am sorry Karol but do you support the GCSB bill which would allow the police to issue a warrant to invade these boys privacy to collect evidence? Otherwise this is not a case of rape until a victim comes forward and lays a complaint.
    The government and police hands are tied until there is a victim, and saying otherwise is simply politicising the issue as much as I just have which us unhelpful to the whole situation.

    This is a failure of our judicial system which puts rape victims in particular under such scrutiny that (according to stats that have been thrown around over the past 24 hours) 9/10 rape victims don’t come forward as the stress and fear of having to face their attacker in court, and having to re-live the attack is often seen as worse than just dealing with it privately and trying to move on, THIS is what is abhorrent. There needs to be a way of helping rape victims through the judicial system in a more sensitive manner. Why can’t we make exceptions for rape cases whereby the victims do not have to sit face-to-face with their attackers, where they have counsellors available to them throughout the process and both the victim and the attacker have name suppression right up until the release of the attacker from prison (at which point he goes on to a publically available sexual deviant list)?
    Maybe it is time for an advertising campaign similar to the John Kirwin depression campaign that reinforces the fact it is okay to come forward if you are a victim.
    This whole situation makes me so angry, and blatant politicising of it like you are Karol just helps to detract from the fundamental issues that need to be addressed.

    • Pascal's bookie 28.1

      The police can do a phone tap without the gcsb.

      • Tat Loo 28.1.1

        They can also do a search and seizure of hard drives without the gcsb.

        Mind you with all this fuss, I’m sure the boys have long deleted all the files they had.

        • idlegus 28.1.1.1

          i dunno, these boys seem some kinda specially stupid, i would imagine they have left an online trail, the photos i saw of them online taking drugs & all that kinda thing will be still about somewhere, with their names & all that . (one idiot was bragging about how much morphine he shot up & there was his profile pic, him & i assume his small child! i mean how dumb is that.)

          & if the police really search those computers, they can still find things. but yes, the police should have done something a little while ago. so the police can raid news paper & media offices to search for some teapot tapes, but are not able do a search & seizure of these guys computers. big story, & been really good in some ways with ppl taking about ‘rape culture’, this could be a turning point. all we need is a leader to lead….

          • weka 28.1.1.1.1

            “big story, & been really good in some ways with ppl taking about ‘rape culture’, this could be a turning point.”

            I’ve been thinking that all day too.

        • NickS 28.1.1.2

          Nothing you upload to facebook is lost right away, even if you delete it and all easily available to the cops with the appropriate court order…

          • weka 28.1.1.2.1

            Do you know if when FB close a page like they did with the rape club page, does the owner of the page lose access to all content? Or is it just hidden from view to the public and other FB users?

    • karol 28.2

      Bob, I agree there is a failure of our justice system.

      This whole situation makes me so angry, and blatant politicising of it like you are Karol just helps to detract from the fundamental issues that need to be addressed.

      There is so much contradiction in this statement I don’t know where to start. If something needs to be done, then how is it not political.

      The GCSB was fundamentally set up to protect the country and it’s people from threats outside NZ. It is (or should have) no relevance to cases of rape in NZ. What is your point in dragging this into the argument?

      This is a failure of our judicial system which puts rape victims in particular under such scrutiny that (according to stats that have been thrown around over the past 24 hours) 9/10 rape victims don’t come forward as the stress and fear of having to face their attacker in court, and having to re-live the attack is often seen as worse than just dealing with it privately and trying to move on, THIS is what is abhorrent.

      And a failure in our judicial system is NOT a political issue? And one that shouldn’t be addressed urgently by the government of the day?

      You do make some suggestions for improving the situation that are worth looking at, Bob. Your suggestion for an advertising campaign suggests the problem is wider than a broken justice system, but a deep-seated set of cultural attitudes. An advertising campaign would only scratch the surface. There needs to be a wider cultural change starting in the education system.

      • Varity 28.2.1

        i doubt very much he’s saying it shouldn’t be addressed by politicians but this is an unprecedented event so to blame a government or expect them to have answers on tap is unreasonable.

        • karol 28.2.1.1

          It’s not that unprecedented. I’ve read reports in recent years about how there’s been increasing evidence of young men deliberately getting women drunk in order to rape them. Politicians should already have been addressing the issue. Instead, our current government has been under-funding rape crisis centres, and not implementing Task Force recommendations.

          Even if the Roast Busters was unprecedented, rather than being the most extreme example or most visible evidence of such practices, I expect better answers than the ones we’ve seen from relevant ministers on the news so far.

          • Varity 28.2.1.1.1

            i’ve got like 5 minutes to get to work so no time to put this tactfully, but …

            that’s a bit like blaming George Bush for 911 unless you believe all the conspiracy theories.

            • Pascal's bookie 28.2.1.1.1.1

              I don’t think Karol was saying the government was underfunding rape centres as part of a conspiracy.

              They underfund it because they see higher priorities. If we want to fix the problem, we need to prioritise it.

              That will mean some money, but more importantly serious thought, from men, about how we talk to each other and how we bring up our boys.

              • weka

                They also underfund it because rape culture gives them privileges they wouldn’t have otherwise. I wouldn’t go so far as to say conspiracy (although I have no doubt at all that there are individual men in govt who actively support the withdrawal of funding from places like RC), but I do think that rape is still used as a collective tool of oppression of women, not just an individual tool.

          • Tat Loo 28.2.1.1.2

            In addition. No addressing of this issue will be complete or sufficiently effective unless there is also a thorough examination and phasing out of the massively harmful binge drinking culture that NZ society has hung on to for decades. Which includes the fact that parents need to take their share of responsibility if their 12, 13, 14 and 15 year olds are seriously abusing alcohol.

            Why so few people have remarked on this so far actually astounds me.

            • miravox 28.2.1.1.2.1

              Binge drinking culture is awful, harmful and an loosens social constraints. Agreed it needs to be challenged. But just like posting on Facebook, it’s something that is associated with rape. It doesn’t cause it.

              If booze wasn’t there people (?) would still form gangs and rape, they’d still spread the shame around the schools and other places where the victims go.

              • Tat Loo

                But just like posting on Facebook, it’s something that is associated with rape. It doesn’t cause it.

                Which is actually fine, because when we are talking about alcohol abuse we never talk about it “causing” adverse consequences, we always talk about it being “associated” with adverse consequences, or being a “risk factor contributing to” adverse consequences. A road fatality isn’t usually said to be “caused” by alcohol, it is usually said that “alcohol was a factor involved.”

                Also I don’t think your Facebook example is quite appropriate. I’ve never seen usage of social media being identified in evidence as having an increased association with rape or sexual abuse.

                • weka

                  It would be interesting to see what the rape stats are in countries without binge drinking.

                  My main problem Tat is that we are very bad at seeing things and dealing with them in isolation. I’m sure it could be done well, but until the mainstream actively acknowledges rape culture and builds prevention into its structures, the most likely thing we would see is young women being educated to keep themselves safe.

                • McFlock

                  @TL: What’s this “we”?

                  There are significant semantic differences between “associated with”, “contributed to and “caused” – the first has no known causal link, the last is necessary and sufficient. Driver error might have caused the crash, and alcohol contributed to that error, but if the tyres weren’t bald and if the road weren’t soaked and if the camber hadn’t been at the wrong angle for the curve…

                  Binge drinking doesn’t cause rape.
                  There is an association with rape, but I’ve not seen any study that adequately addressed other factors for which “drinking” might be a confounding factor for other causal associations (such as being in the vicinity of rapists). For example, ISTR a college study that found a higher proportion of sexual assaults were committed at student dwelling parties where all the residents were male.

                  Like gangsta culture, I think drinking is a red herring that some folk latch on to because it fits their preconceptions. To me, the issue is rape and how we as a society minimise it and accept it as a problem, rather than addressing it front-on.

                  • Colonial Viper

                    Binge drinking doesn’t cause rape.
                    There is an association with rape, but I’ve not seen any study that adequately addressed other factors for which “drinking” might be a confounding factor for other causal associations (such as being in the vicinity of rapists).

                    You sound like the National Government saying “more research is needed before concluding that alcohol is a true contributing factor to societal harms.”

                    The facts are clear and well established – there is a high degree of association and correlation between levels of intoxication and acts of violence or physical harm occurring, whether in the home or outside it, whether between strangers or between people who know each other.

                    The research which demonstrates this has been replicated over and over again across continents. It’s very easy to find. I hope it fits your “preconceptions.”

                    Dealing with alcohol abuse effectively is not going to stop all sexual violence. But it’s a bloody good start and should be part of any serious programme.

                    • McFlock

                      Oh, I’m sorry, I thought we were talking about rape.

                      I think you will find a significant different between how significantly the offender is affected by alcohol in rapists vs other crime. I’m not calling them all sober by any stretch of the imagination, but if you’re near-paralytic you can still throw a punch. Maintaining an erection, on the other hand, is not so certain.

                      Funnily enough, I’ve not found too many studies that managed to get info on how drunk the woman was, how drunk the offender was, and what other confounding factors there might have been. But the one common factor in all of those situations would be exposure to at least one rapist. And being drunk is no excuse or explanation for being a rapist.

                    • Colonial Viper

                      You can make all the assumptions about the research that you like McFlock, but its there, and there is a vast body of it. The higher the levels of intoxication the more likely and worse the physical harm and violence that people experience.

                      As for “excuses” and “explanations” that is not what the research is centred on; it merely states association and correlation.

                    • McFlock

                      and yet you presented none of it to support your point, but you say it so it must be true.

                      For example, A. Abbey(J. Stud. Alcohol, Supplement No. 14: 118-128, 2002) reviewed some literature about sexual assault and alcohol, and mentioned that “At least half of these sexual assaults involve alcohol consumption by the perpetrator, the victim or both.” The study went into descriptions about why this might be, but never mentioned the basic issue: is it associated with alcohol simply because that’s how college students socialise? Greater socialising means greater intermingling between social groups, and greater probabilities that a person will encounter a rapist.

                      But of course, if we can just blame alcohol, or gangs, or the parents, then we can ignore any responsibility that we might have ourselves.

                • miravox

                  ” I’ve never seen usage of social media being identified in evidence as having an increased association with rape or sexual abuse.”

                  The Facebook page indicates that the thought processes that lead to the rapes are not spur of the moment, caused by booze, thoughts.

                  The Facebook pages may also be associated with normalising, within their own social network, what these guys are doing. In other cases that normalisation could occur through watching hardcore porn, reading lads mags, having friends who are rapists… all sorts of input.

                  Focusing on booze is not going to bring about a change in how some people think it’s ok to rape other people.

                  Having said that, I do agree we have an enormously destructive drinking culture and that needs attention too.

            • greywarbler 28.2.1.1.2.2

              I have put up two posts and had no one comment on them. My long posts often are trying to put things in context not just vent emotion. Perhaps that is why they get
              by-passed.
              I was thinking of the strength of the alcohol lobby and the way that government assists it. And went back to Hogarth as a parallel to where we are getting today with it degrading many people’s lives.
              Gin for Sale. Drunk for a penny. Dead drunk for tuppence. Straw (bedding) free.
              http://thestandard.org.nz/open-mike-04112013/#comment-721712

              And on the parents role. There has been some critical comment as usual about parents not doing their job. So I’ve mentioned that social scientists say that parents may have a very small voice these days when competing with the loud media messages to the young, and its sexualisation from an early age. (Little children can’t run around naked on the beach these days because we are at once puritanical and over-sexualised and frightened of the warped in our midst.)
              http://thestandard.org.nz/open-mike-04112013/ #comment-721693

              And boys parents – what do they say to them about behaviour to others? Is it enough to have them do well at school and force their way into the rugby team, head butting, eye gouging, and spear tackling, and perhaps grabbing an opponents privates in a ruck? Anything goes and can be excused if it helps you win.

              What standards of behaviour and respect do the boys have for just anybody – the vulnerable, the animal, do they club the seals and sit in Court arguing they had a right for this blood lust, this bloody deed, and the child, the woman, the guy tottering towards them with a walking stick, do they kick it out from under him for a joke? And what concept do they have of their inner being, their good self, their life force, their mauri? What’s right, what’s fair, and what makes a strong, good man so that they feel respect for the self they have created

              • Colonial Viper

                I have read your comments mate, and they are good.

                If parents, immediate family, and extended family are not going to be around to teach youths “what concept do they have of their inner being, their good self, their life force, their mauri? What’s right, what’s fair, and what makes a strong, good man so that they feel respect for the self they have created…” then the young lads are pretty much stuffed from the start, right.

                • karol

                  Ah, CV and gw, you have reminded me of when I used to teach young children a couple of decades back. I have seen boys of 5 and 6 years old, behaving in ways that can only be a copy of adult male behaviour they have witnessed, and thought was in some way cool. for instance picking up a little school milk bottle and starting to drink from it with hand on hip just like a guy drinking from a beer bottle.

                  And some of the same 5 & 6 year old boys sexually harassing girls – aggressively putting their hands up the girls skirts. Something that happened too often. Maybe not as often as the “kiss – chase” game, but enough for it to be clearly a modelling of adult male behaviour.

                  • Colonial Viper

                    Yep…parental units can be the best of role models…and the worst.

                    • karol

                      Actually it is not just a child’s parents that provide poor models. The milk bottle incident I described above also involved putting an arm around another boy’s shoulders and chanting. Most likely copying behaviour of a group of adult males.

                • greywarbler

                  Hey CV
                  Your back, visiting. Where’s that Tat Loo who said he was your twin or something?

                  @karol
                  That mimicking of adults is a problem. My grandchild can pick up a phrase and the inflection just like a parrot. I have to tidy up my language. By the time she is 5 or 6?

              • Chooky

                +!00 greywarbler…your comments/musings are always well thought through!…so much so that there is really very little that one can often add….but here is my attempt

                ….to bring up a boy or girl…. takes a society …and the more caring and better that society is at respecting and supporting children /teenagers and parents …the better the chances are that they the teenagers will turn out well because they will be imbued with the values of that society ( one could ask questions about Auckland and the values of this present Nact government )

                …as a parent all I can say is that teenagers can be damned difficult !!!….Nigel Latta’s book “Before Your Teenager Drives You Crazy ” was a life saver for me….his thesis is emphatically that… physiologically as well as psychologically teenagers ain’t the full biscuit….brain development does not reach maturity until about 25 years old

                ….so parents ( even with the best will in the world and with all their best attention) cant be blamed for everything….add to this …(.reincarnationally speaking or not ) …..some kids are born wise… and some kids are born stupid….. and some kids are born for trouble ( this goes for the parents as well )

                …outside parental control… teenagers are all about raging hormones, see-sawing emotions, peer group pressure in school and out , alcohol, social experimenting, and media modelling( unsavoury ..or savoury if you are lucky)…music/ DVDs/computer games / interactive social media sites /fortran/facebook/commercial radio …..all have huge impacts …which often parents can only guess at.

                • greywarbler

                  Chooky
                  +1
                  My feeling is I’m all for parents getting respect in society and from government, and being given advice to help and advise what they need as far as rules and guidelines (up to a point). Expecting parents of boys to do a better job and ensuring that boys do get a message of self-management and self-respect should be mandatory. Self respect that doesn’t rely on doing well at sport, that stands on its own legs so to speak which includes respect and understanding of others and oneself.

                  • Chooky

                    greywarbler ….agree….I dont think that boys get enough encouragement to be nurturing as opposed to being destructive….i think pets and animals are a great way to encourage care in boys

                    …incidentally my son at age eight found an injured young hawk( a common Australasian falcon, that you often see dead on the side of the road)…one leg was damaged but could have been saved with antibiotics and plasters) and we cared for it over a weekend using long leather gloves and feeding it mince and got very fond of it….we took it to a city bird vet on the Monday to get its leg seen to and the woman at the desk……. young and officious , who told us her father used to shoot them….virtually whipped it out of my son’s arms citing DOC regulations….she said we couldnt have it back and even if it was cured we would not be allowed to keep it…it would be released somewhere else….I was furious but didnt have the wits to grab it back and make run for it…i complained to Doc and they gave all sorts of spurious reasons why we were not fit to look after it ( years ago New Zealanders would not have had to have permission from such bureaucracy)

                    Several years later when a young boy at Arthurs Pass threw rocks at Keas and came in for social approbrium from Doc on the front page of the Christchurch Press ….I thought how ironic this was …on the one hand they would not allow a young boy to look after a wild animal…and on the other hand, another young boy trying to make some sort of contact with wild animals ( albeit in the wrong way) was publically humiliated

                    I guess my point is that we need to treat young boys with respect and sensitivity and encourage them to be caring

                    • Chooky

                      …teaching boys ( if they will let you) …and/or allowing them to cook their own meals and yours ( if you are lucky) is another good scheme ….because at a later stage they will know how to woo a girl by cooking/feeding her a lovely meal ( ha ha) …..of course this applies to girls as well ….( cooking for boys) …instead of just……

                      …and then we get down to the issue of drinking…..why is it that the French seem so refined when it comes to drinking?……for them eating and drinking are an art form to be shared with the opposite sex….an important part of socialising and intimacy and conversation

                      …it often seems in NZ that the young just drink to get out of control and/or blotto

                  • KJT

                    What some schools are doing, in teaching relationships, is a step in the right direction.

                    Teenagers almost by definition are brainless and impulsive, male and female, and it can be very difficult as a parent to do anything about behaviors. Our influence is often minimal, compared with their peer group.

                    • BM

                      From what I’ve heard it’s not until around 24 -26 that the human brain completes all the necessary wiring.

                      Goes along way toward explaining the appalling decision making of young people.

                    • felix

                      Doesn’t explain the shit that pours non-stop out of your supposedly fully wired brain though, BM.

                    • BM

                      Ha ha, I was waiting for a reply like that.

                    • greywarbler

                      BM We aim to please. But your point falls down. It’s not only 24-26 or around that, that make appalling decisions.

      • greywarbler 28.2.2

        Gee Bob
        I am sorry that you feel sorry that you can’t see any way that anything should be done by the police until the apple falls into their hands. And by the way – everything that we do is related to politics. As soon as we live in groups we make political decisions on how the group should act.

        The free dictionary – The art or science of government or governing, especially the governing of a political entity, such as a nation, and the administration and control of its internal and external affairs.
        Wikipedia – Politics (from Greek: politikos, meaning “of, for, or relating to citizens”) is the practice and theory of influencing other people on a civic or individual level. More narrowly, it refers to achieving and exercising positions of governance — organized control over a human community, particularly a state.

        Years ago in Canada at La Paz I think, a Canadian Indian woman was hussled into a car by some likely lads of the neighborhood and raped and ended up dead. The whole small town knew about it but no-one liked to come forward and inform on everybody else’s knowledge. The police did very little to press for evidence. They put an advertisement in the paper asking for anyone with possible information to come forward. It took a crusading journalist to break the guilty official silence. The unofficial silence had been broken by some of the perpetrators weighed down by guilt and talking about it. I think they often were listened to by people of the town who would let them talk, and then pass on to everyday matters, archiving the information under not to be released. It was a conspiracy against this poor woman and her family and racism came into it also. Being not one of us, being from out of town, being a Canadian Indian. There were numerous aspects as to why people shouldn’t admit guilt and face the consequences.

        • greywarbler 28.2.2.1

          If anyone is interested in reading about this Le Pas (logging town) rape and murder case, that is announced as one of the most notorious in Canada – here are more links. Have a look at the fun trivia one and consider whether this shock method of getting information into the general public’s mind is one that works.

          Helen Betty Osborne in The Pas, Manitoba, died November 13 1971?
          (a strange way of getting information across- effective?)
          http://www.funtrivia.com/en/subtopics/Conspiracy-of-Silence—Murder-in-The-Pas-157915.html
          and
          http://www.ajic.mb.ca/volumell/chapter4.html
          and
          http://business.highbeam.com/435424/article-1G1-54169504/osborne-murder-case-closed-again
          Aboriginal family’s quest for truth dies as Manitoba’s Justice Department and RCMP decline to lay new charges in one of Canada’s most controversial and long-investigated killings

          She began the week speaking of closure and healing, but yesterday Cecelia Osborne found herself back at the beginning of her family seemingly endless ordeal, wondering whether she and Manitoba’s aboriginal community would ever see justice done.

          Ms. Osborne, sister of Helen Betty Osborne – the victim in one of Canada’s most controversial and long-investigated murders choked back tears as she denounced a decision by RCMP and Manitoba Justice Department officials to close the case. Their decision came after the latest renew of the 28-year-old murder, which took a fresh look at blood spatters, wiretap evidence, and photographs of the crime scene.

          But for the Osborne family, it was not enough.
          “I feet frustrated, very disappointed,” Ms. Osborne told reporters in Winnipeg, after receiving the news. “Put it this way: We’ll fight it for the next 28 years if we have to.”

          Thus begins yet another chapter in the slaying of Helen Betty Osborne, a 19-year-old aboriginal woman who was abducted, sexually assaulted, then stabbed 56 times with a screwdriver in November 1971 by four white, male attackers.
          Four suspects were eventually implicated in the case. But from the beginning, the investigation was hamstrung by unco-operative witnesses in The Pas, the northern logging town of 6,000 near where the murder occurred. While the identity of Ms. …
          and
          Pleading against parole. (residents of a northern Manitoba reserve …
          business.highbeam.com › … › Education magazines › Maclean’s‎
          Jan 29, 1996 – (residents of a northern Manitoba reserve beg board not to grant parole to … The murder is one of the most notorious in Canadian history-and last week it got more … Dwayne Archie Johnston, the convicted killer of Helen Betty Osborne from …

        • greywarbler 28.2.2.2

          And I think it wasn’t a crusading journalist that brought the Canadian woman’s murderers to the fore so they could be confronted and tried. I think it was a policeman who still had soul and guts. And he needed them.

    • One Anonymous Knucklehead 28.3

      The police can already get a warrant to monitor people’s communications without recourse to the GCSB.

      Facilities for remote witnesses are already available.

      Karol didn’t politicise this issue. It’s already politicised. In any case this is a political forum.

  29. felix 29

    What’s with the blurred-out guy in the back seat?

    • One Anonymous Knucklehead 29.1

      He’s innocent until proven guilty?

    • karol 29.2

      Interesting. Maybe because the 2 in the front have been cooperating with the police and agreed to have the video shown on TV – the person in the back may not be cooperating and not have admitted guilt? May have not agreed to being shown on TV?

      • TheContrarian 29.2.1

        May be a witness or someone the police are talking to (or who approached the police themselves) and they don’t want the viewer to think they are part of group?

    • fender 29.3

      Maybe his dad is a cop, or like TC he just wants to stay out of it, or is just too out of it…

      • idlegus 29.3.1

        i thought it was because he doesn’t talk, so doesn’t incriminate himself. i think in some ways the media are being very responsible with this story. (so far)

  30. greywarbler 30

    This morning on radio – The police spokesman says that police don’t want to victimise anyone (involved in the sexual porn case).

  31. vto 31

    So the police can’t lay a charge until the victim makes a complaint.

    How do police lay charges in murder cases then?

    (apologies for repeat of question above but curious if anyone knows…)

    • miravox 31.1

      “How do police lay charges in murder cases then?”

      Because they don’t dis-believe the victim?

    • karol 31.2

      I think that with a murder, they have a body or some other hard evidence to show a murder took place. With rape, the only usual evidence is from the people who were present – the victims word against that of the alleged perp. The forensic evidence most often does not provide irrefutable evidence a rape has taken place.

      • vto 31.2.1

        Not with Olivia Hope and Ben Smart – no body, no hard evidence, just a crooked copper in Rob Pope

        • Varity 31.2.1.1

          yes this is what the story should be about. the police – not the government.

          they can make a case against watson with no bodies and only manufactured evidence but they can’t make a case against these hoods with videoed confessions?

  32. Tracey 32

    Grump when your daughters or grand daughters were raped or sexually assaulted how did you react.

    how dare you accuse anyone trying to get to tge root of this behaviour to try and stop it in the future. It is you being shallow and frankly ignorant if you think this is about caps on backwards and rap music..

    in some ways we are lucky to have the internet to reveal these attitudes to women because everyday girls are being sexually abused by people who dont wear caps backwards or listen to rap music. Until that is addressed the young women you claim to champion, the one being raped as I write this or sexually assaulted while you type your reply will continue to have no voice.

    its not about YOUR reaction to one incident tgat eithat natters or will make any difference.

    no one other than me has asked about the boys parents.where were they when these young men were doing this? Where is their internet oversight… havnt they ever noticed their offsprings attitude to females or was it just their boys being boys.

    • karol 32.1

      Tracey, the point about the boy’s parents is a good one. How could they not have known about the facebook stuff? Why did they seem to do nothing about it?

      The main thing we know so far about their parents is that one parent is a police officer, and one some sort of celebrity.

      People have questioned the role of those two parents.

      I’m not a parent, and know it can be a difficult but important job. I’d like to know more about the roles of parents who have sons who rape, and pack rape. And about how parents can bring up boys to be non-rapists, to counter rape culture, and to be more empathetic and respectful of women.

      • KJT 32.1.1

        Unfortunately teenagers are often able to pull the wool over their parents eyes.

        And whatever you have taught them it tends to be overruled by their peer group.

        You just have to hope that some of the things you told them when they were younger, stick.

        Unlike toddlers, you cannot watch and look after them 24 hours a day.

    • greywarbler 32.2

      Tracey I referred to the boys parents too.
      http://thestandard.org.nz/open-mike-04112013/ #comment-721693

  33. Sable 33

    Keys and his masters in the US want to control the internet because its the only information medium that is open and free from the lies and half truths that keep these clowns in office.

    Actual abuse of people is of little interest to these people as it does not serve their interests.

    To be balanced and fair however if the police do not have enough evidence to move forward with a prosecution then that’s reality as well. If people wont confess to crimes “bending the law” to meet the demands of politicians and interest groups is also very wrong as it creates a dangerous precedent that is open to further abuse.

  34. Tracey 34

    “unprecedented event ”

    first known and publicised.

    girls are raoed and abused regularly by single and multiple perpetrator.

    Girls massively under report

    about 5% charged are convicted.

    of course its political and social.

    those of you hang wringing about this one awful example while haranging those wishing to highlight the iceberg below the tip are part of why it will happen again…. and is happening to a girl or woman right now.

    Labelling a desire to get a solution to all rape and abuse of children political, as a negative thing, is worse than shortsighted.

    • Rhinocrates 34.1

      The etymology of the word itself reveals that it is political. It’s original meaning is to seize or plunder (hence the birds called raptors – because they seize prey in their claws) – ie., to treat women as property to be taken.

      In a lot of classical and renaissance artworks with “rape” in the title, what is depicted is usually an abduction or even an elopement, again treating the victims as property. That ingrained view of women as objects or dependents extends to Bob Jones’ recent columns and that’s just another facet of the iceberg.

      Rape is intended to humiliate and destroy the victim. The boasting on Facebook is not a record of an assault, but the continuation of the assault. The police facilitated those rapes by allowing those pages to remain up for “tactical and operational reasons”. The had absolutely no cognisance of those girls continued suffering.

      The reflexes of the vigilantes is… er, “understandable”… but it’s sadly telling that they’re offering their bounty for footage of the perpetrators being beaten rather than setting up a fund to help in the victims’ counselling. Revenge will give power to the “white knights” but will notably not help the girls, instead it keeps them as passive objects to be fought over.

      • Chooky 34.1.1

        +1 Rhinocrates…also dont agree with the physical whipping, although can understand how parents would feel

        …..personally, i would like to see all those males found guilty put away for a time to think about what they have done , receive counselling themselves ….and then maybe videos of them in prison making abject apologies to the girls and their families…. for their crimes of misogyny, humiliation , and sexual and psychological violence ……these could be put up online….maybe on the same Facebook pages used to humiliate their victims.

    • Sable 34.2

      Quick break out the pitch forks and the flaming torches, chuck the law and reason out the window and lets have on old fashioned style lynching.

      Whilst rape is abhorrent giving in to hysteria and hate is equally repellent and dangerous.

      • weka 34.2.1

        I think the point is that the law and reason have not been applied hence some people wanting to take justice into their own hands.

        Giving into hysteria (very interesting choice of marginalising, gendered language btw) is NOT equally repellant and dangerous as rape by a long stretch.

        I don’t support vigilantes in general, because (a) they often aren’t listening to what the victims need and (b) they up the ante and/or reinforce domination as a valid mode of behaviour. I think in some cases they prevent offending, and in others they just perpetuate it.

  35. Rogue Trooper 35

    as uke linked Above , one of the offenders is the son of a police officer.
    Furthermore, violence begat and all that, people are offering to pay for footage of the offenders getting desserts (beaten, not whipped).

    • Ennui 35.1

      “Justice is mine, says the Lord, I will repay”…..”Let he who is without sin…..”

    • greywarbler 35.2

      “Whilst we acknowledge it was upsetting for the victims, it was being monitored for information or evidence that would assist our investigation.”
      Police comment from report on TV3.
      The whole sentence could have been expressed like this, ‘it was being monitored for information or evidence (and some of our officers found it quite exciting but would never admit this outside our circle).

      Police managers should realise how this would look even if they are innocent. And there must be doubts about that, there have been too many scandals that have shaken faith in the cops. You can’t be innocent and cope with police work, true, but you do have to hold onto your basic standards not slide and get dirty minded and hardened by the times of unpleasantness, with some filthy stuff too, that is part of the job. Otherwise what are yah eh? Just another street sh.t.

  36. captain hook 36

    post modernistic bullshit.
    nobody wants to do anything in case they get their hands dirty.
    it all turns to custard and nobody gives a fuck.
    too busy salivating over the salacaious details of how LB knew exactly what to do with me.
    keep it up and some geek will make a programme out of it or a short story for Radio New Zealand.

  37. Tigger 37

    ‘Grow up’? So Mr Key, rape is something you do if you’re not ‘grown up’? There’s the rape culture right there. It’s men saying ‘this is a younger guy thing, this is guys sowing their wild oats’ blah blah blah.

    How about saying to men, as a man, stop raping. Just stop. Stop! It’s unacceptable. It’s sick. It’s wrong.

    • emergency mike 37.1

      +1 Our PM saying effectively “Some boys get rapey and form rape clubs when they are young and stupid, but at least we have some new cyberbullying laws on the way so they won’t be able to brag about their raping so much,” just isn’t good enough.

      For an intelligent guy this further evidence that Key’s emotional intelligence is seriously retarded.

      • Rhinocrates 37.1.1

        Key is not an intelligent guy. He’s proof of Arthur Conan Doyle’s maxim that mediocrity knows nothing higher than itself. He’s mediocre on every level (that is, one, since he has no other dimensions) and is simply possessed of an excess of smarm.

        • emergency mike 37.1.1.1

          You’re right Rhino. I think he is intelligent in certain narrow areas, like as a politician, a debater, and a money maker (for himself). Others have commented that he is easy to underestimate, and it’s a mistake that the opposition have made time and time again, (I think they are catching on now).

          But to call him an ‘intelligent guy’ is not at all accurate since in other, more meaningful areas, he’s mediocre at best. In some ways, as I said, quite retarded.

          • Rhinocrates 37.1.1.1.1

            Yes, in terms of empathy, he’s definitely not even mediocre, but deficient. Like Bob Jones, he has precisely one skill: making himself somewhat rich and that’s all.

  38. Tracey 38

    Yup. Men telling men to stop raping… to stop “jokingly” denigrating women… they wont do the latter cos they consider its “pc gone wrong” …

  39. captain hook 39

    hey this is what ultra fast broadband is for.
    [deleted]
    groovy.

    [karol: yep. Not funny.]

  40. Tracey 40

    My comment about parentsv is in relation to now they know what their sons are involved in.

    • weka 41.1

      Thanks Brett. It probably pays to remember that Willie Jackson thinks Clint Rickard is innocent. Jackson is a rape enabler. What interests me is that the Herald article is basically condemning Jackson and Henare, and uses a headline that names victim blaming. That’s a good sign.

  41. Treetop 42

    Where is the funding minister?

  42. SPC 43

    The government’s cyber bullying bill only covers named people

    “He said that their practice of naming a particular young woman would be unlawful under a law the Government is about to introduce, the Harmful Digital Communications Bill.”

    The legislation needs to be extended to criminalise boasting in any public media (such as on-line) where this would be an offense against the victims of the said crime. This boasting can occur without naming the victims, such legislation would allow police to prosecute on this charge at least without even knowing who the victims were.

  43. Tracey 44

    The cyber bullying law is the red herring. The behaviour has been brought to the nations consciousness, we can thank the internet for that. Believing that this law will prevent rape or punish rapists will allow the nation to sigh and think “phew thats taken care of that”

Important links

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

  • When do we reach ‘peak cow’?
    How much is enough? Or even too much? It's a fundamental question for any business or economy when you're dealing with supply and demand. And it's a crucial question when it comes to New Zealand's dependence on the dairy industry. So...
    Pundit | 25-10
  • ‘Progressives’ who side with imperialism
    Although the Alliance for Workers Liberty has no co-group in New Zealand and is a minor player on the British far-left, we’re running the article below because the AWL ideas being critiqued in it are certainly relevant here (and probably...
    Redline | 24-10
  • ‘Progressives’ who side with imperialism
    Although the Alliance for Workers Liberty has no co-group in New Zealand and is a minor player on the British far-left, we’re running the article below because the AWL ideas being critiqued in it are certainly relevant here (and probably...
    Redline | 24-10
  • The Songs of Yesteryear – Or, What I Was Listening To 40 Years Ago
     Sonnet to the Fall: Penned by the group, Dulcimer's, founder, Peter Hodge, the song also features the English actor, Richard Todd, reading Hodge's poetry. Dulcimer's first album, And I Turned As I Had Turned As A Boy was released on the...
    Bowalley Road | 24-10
  • Beach Rd Cycleway stage 2 design
    The new Beach Rd cycleway is fantastic addition to the city however at the moment it’s a little short only extending from Churchill St to Mahuhu Cres. That’s set to change next year as the second stage gets underway which...
    Transport Blog | 24-10
  • Taylor Swift NOT entertaining misogyny, even for laughs
    I saw this on Graham Norton’s show last night and was impressed with Taylor Swift’s deft ‘warning’ to comedian John Cleese … to not engage in comic misogyny – not even as a joke. Good on her. Here’s a short...
    The Paepae | 24-10
  • Tory Austerity mythology exposed ( from The Guardian & Social Europe Jo...
    The same neo-liberal mythology which declares  National as the best manager of New Zealand's economy is used in the UK to boost the credibility of the Conservative Party with disaster-ous consequences.This article from The Guardian and reproduced in Social Europe...
    the Irascible Curmudgeon | 24-10
  • Neo-Liberal Economics and the danger to nations’ sovereignty. From So...
    The TPPA debate has echoes in Europe as Neo-Liberal economists conspire to remove national sovereignty through the Juncker Commission.Will The Juncker Commission Continue To Entrench Neoliberal Policies?Lukas OberndorferA few days ago, the designated European Commission finally showed its true colours:...
    the Irascible Curmudgeon | 24-10
  • Saturday playlist: new beginnings
    Every Saturday we’re going to post a couple of music videos, probably on a particular theme, unless we run out of ideas and it just turns into Stephanie spamming us with professional wrestling soundtracks and Nicki Minaj. This week’s theme, fittingly: new beginnings....
    On the Left | 24-10
  • Save us from Ebola, Muslims but not guns!
    For some reason, Americans are terrified about the threat of Ebola, the dangers of Muslim terrorists, but not gunzzzzzzzzzzz.Meanwhile:At least three people have been hospitalised after a student reportedly carried out a shooting at a high school north of Seattle...
    Left hand palm | 24-10
  • Because they wanted a better life for me
    (For our opening week, we asked all our contributors to think about why they’re On The Left, and what the next three years holds for the left, the government, and New Zealand.) The first time I saw snow I came...
    On the Left | 24-10
  • Letter to the editor – Key paints a dirty, great, big bullseye on our cou...
    . . from: Frank Macskasy <fmacskasy@gmail.com> to: Dominion Post <letters@dompost.co.nz> date: Thu, Oct 23, 2014 subject: Letter to the editor . The editor Dominion Post . On Radio NZ, on 23 October, I was gobsmacked to hear this from  our...
    Frankly Speaking | 24-10
  • 2014 SkS Weekly News Roundup #43A
    Amazon deforestation picking up pace, satellite data reveals An in-depth look at the oceans, climate change and the hiatus Citing rising seas, Florida officials vote to cut state in half Climate records are breaking so often now, we’ve stopped paying...
    Skeptical Science | 24-10
  • The state of the working class in New Zealand today
    Redline’s readership has, since we began, grown consistently and substantially. At the same time, it can be quite daunting going to a website for the first time and reading a few things on the home-page and then wondering what to...
    Redline | 24-10
  • The state of the working class in New Zealand today
    Redline’s readership has, since we began, grown consistently and substantially. At the same time, it can be quite daunting going to a website for the first time and reading a few things on the home-page and then wondering what to...
    Redline | 24-10
  • Lisa Owen interviews Fonterra CEO Theo Spierings
    Press Release – The Nation Fonterra boss worried about the spread of Ebola in West Africa and potential big consequences for the company, saying it doesnt feel to me like that it is under control at the momentLisa Owen interviews...
    Its our future | 24-10
  • We can be heroes
    (Trigger warnings apply on this post for assault, misogyny, domestic violence, and bitter sarcasm/flippancy about male perpetrators of violence against women.) This is written for cis-gendered straight guys. I have nothing to say to women on the subject of male...
    On the Left | 24-10
  • Stuart’s 100 #47: Water in Public Spaces
    47: Water in Public Spaces What if we made more of water in our public spaces? Sometimes it is the simple things. People flock to water in public spaces. We need more of it in this city. And in more...
    Transport Blog | 24-10
  • Freedom of information: A good idea from India
    One of the better ideas for freedom of information implemented overseas is disclosure logs - agencies posting requests and responses publicly, allowing performance to be monitored and reducing repeat requests. This is widespread in Australia and the UK, but poorly...
    No Right Turn | 24-10
  • The Age of Cupidity
    I've been trying to publish a post for the past couple of weeks.  Although I have several in draft form, when I try to finish them I find myself overwhelmed by a deep lassitude - an uncharacteristic gloom which is only relieved...
    Te Whare Whero | 24-10
  • De-industrialisation and the prospects for socialism
    Is the world really de-industrialising? by Michael Roberts Last week I spoke on a panel that debated De-industrialisation and socialism.  The panel was organised by Spring, a Manchester-based group in England that has become a forum for the discussion of...
    Redline | 24-10
  • De-industrialisation and the prospects for socialism
    Is the world really de-industrialising? by Michael Roberts Last week I spoke on a panel that debated De-industrialisation and socialism.  The panel was organised by Spring, a Manchester-based group in England that has become a forum for the discussion of...
    Redline | 24-10
  • Looking back with pride – Maryan Street
    Maryan Street joined the Labour Party in 1984, was President from 1995-1997 and became an MP in 2005. She talked to Labour Voices about her Labour journey and the people, events and achievements she recalls with the greatest pride....
    Labour campaign | 24-10
  • Strong and comprehensive
    DEVELOPING “a very strong and comprehensive” Women’s Affairs policy going into the 2014 election is one of the achievements Carol Beaumont is most proud of. And being unable to implement it one of her regrets....
    Labour campaign | 24-10
  • Christchurch’s rebuild should be decided by Christchurch, not Welling...
    Radio New Zealand has an appalling story this morning about the government's interference in the Christchurch rebuild over the new District Plan. Normally district plans are decided by elected local councils accountable to the voters who will live under them....
    No Right Turn | 24-10
  • Turning a blind eye to corruption
    As we are constantly reminded, New Zealand consistently leads the Transparency International Corruption Perceptions Index as the "least corrupt country in the world". And as we are increasingly becoming aware, that reputation may be undeserved. Today there's another nail in...
    No Right Turn | 23-10
  • Police Association off target with call to arm Police
    Arming our Police will lead to more crime, more violence, and more killings – by criminals, and potentially even by police. The Police Commissioner is correct in pointing out that the Police Association’s recent call to arm all officers is...
    frogblog | 23-10
  • Political interference at Maori Television
    A government-owned television channel arranges an interview with a former opposition MP, but the government-appointed CEO spikes it. Something from Russia or Cuba maybe? No - according to Hone Harawira its happening right here in New Zealand:“[Maori TV CEO Paora]...
    No Right Turn | 23-10
  • September 14 Patronage
    Auckland’s Transport’s patronage results for September are now out and they show that the city is experiencing spectacular PT growth, growth which is also setting a number of records. The big news was earlier in the week was that when it was announced...
    Transport Blog | 23-10
  • Maiden speech – Jenny Salesa
    Jenny Salesa, Labour MP for Manukau East, has given her Maiden Speech in Parliament....
    Labour campaign | 23-10
  • Maiden speech – Adrian Rurawhe
    Adrian Rurawhe, Labour MP for Te Tai Hauāuru, has given his Maiden Speech in Parliament....
    Labour campaign | 23-10
  • Roastbusters, one year on (almost)
    March in Wellington against rape culture, from Stuff.co.nz Content warning: contains discussion of rape and sexual assault You can literally get away with rape in this country. You can be a serial rapist, with photographic and video evidence you willingly...
    On the Left | 23-10
  • Labour Needs To Stop Saying What People DON”T want to hear.
    A Freight Train called Key: On election night 1975 Bill Rowling said Muldoon's landslide victory felt like being hit by a bus. Oh what David Cunliffe would have given for that bus on 20 September 2014!THE ANGUISH of Labour supporters...
    Bowalley Road | 23-10
  • And if you have to carry a gun to keep your fragile seat at number one R...
    What happened at Canada's war memorial and parliamentary buildings is a pretty bad thing. It should, however, be kept in some sort of perspective. ...
    Pundit | 23-10
  • Beware the sucker ploy.
    A few years back I wrote about the strategic utility of terrorism. One thing I did not mention in that post was the use of a tried and true guerrilla tactic as part of the terrorist arsenal: the sucker ploy....
    Kiwipolitico | 23-10
  • Hard News: Friday Music: An accompanied korero
    I'm chairing the LATE at the Museum event next month, under the title The Age of Slacktivism. We've picked a strong lineup -- Nicky Hager, Matthew Hooton, Marianne Elliot, Laura O'Connell Rapira -- and it should be a rousing hour's...
    Public Address | 23-10
  • 6 amazing renewable energy projects that we love
    Here's a few renewable energy projects from around the world -- ones that we totally love.1. Germany has invested big in solar and wind. And in the first six months of 2012, the amount of electricity produced using renewables jumped from...
    Greenpeace NZ blog | 23-10
  • China’s coal use actually falling now (for the first time this centur...
    Coal use in China is falling this year - according to official data reported in the Chinese press.It is the first time this century that China has seen year on year quarterly falls in coal use. The Chinese economy continues to grow...
    Greenpeace NZ blog | 23-10
  • Can new roads pay for themselves?
    It’s common to hear people say that because roads are paid for by their users (fn 1), we should build more roads. After all, the new roads will fund themselves! At first glance, this seems convincing. But a closer look...
    Transport Blog | 23-10
  • As a nation drowned in the PM’s lies, sons & daughters were sent to d...
      As a nation drowned in the PM’s lies Sons & daughters were sent to die Meanwhile at home democracy cried But his government crowed Everything’s fine.   Other peoples’ children signed up for his war While at home in comfort...
    Politically Corrected | 23-10
  • Why I am on the left
    (For our opening week, we asked all our contributors to think about why they’re On The Left, and what the next three years holds for the left, the government, and New Zealand.) Post by Jem I am left first and...
    On the Left | 23-10
  • Minister to attend TPP Ministers’ Meeting
    Press Release – New Zealand Government Trade Minister Tim Groser will depart today for Sydney to join Ministers from countries participating in the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) for the next round of negotiations.Hon Tim Groser Minister of Trade 24 October 2014...
    Its our future | 23-10
  • On The Nation this weekend
    Press Release – The Nation This weekend on The Nation with dairy prices falling, China growing its agriculture sector, and the environmental costs piling up, we ask the Fonterra chief executive Theo Spierings if New Zealand is too dependent on...
    Its our future | 23-10
  • Agri-Food Producers Call for Strong Outcomes through the TPP
    Press Release – Federated Farmers International Agricultural and Agri-Food Producers Call for Strong Outcomes through the TPP At the round of Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) negotiations taking place this week in Australia, agri-food producer and processor groups from Canada, Australia …International...
    Its our future | 23-10
  • Grant Robertson is not as much like Joseph Stalin as some would have you th...
    It’s not often you see a New Zealand political figure compared favourably to Stalin, but this is what Chris Trotter has done to that decidedly non-genocidal non-lunatic Grant Robertson.  ...
    Pundit | 23-10
  • Food, Fossil Fuels and Filthy Finance
    It is depressingly apparent that powerful forces in the global economy are set to carry on with the exploration for and use of fossil fuels ass a primary source of energy for decades to come. Oxfam has produced a report...
    Hot Topic | 23-10
  • 2014 Arctic sea ice extent – 6th lowest in millennia
    The National Snow and Ice Data Center has reported that this year we saw the 6th-lowest minimum Arctic sea ice extent on record. Research has shown that most of the long-term decline in sea ice, or the “death spiral” as...
    Skeptical Science | 23-10
  • How low can you go? Mining the depths
    Today I made my oral submission to the Environmental Protection Authority on Chatham Rock Phosphate’s application to mine phosphate from the seabed approximately halfway between the mainland and the Chatham Island. In a nutshell this application is for the deepest...
    frogblog | 23-10
  • Surrounded sex offender still won’t come down from roof
    While they would still appreciate him coming down, police say they’re confident the man has “nowhere to hide.” After an agonising 54-year wait, it is beginning to appear as though a notorious sex offender dressed as Santa may not, in...
    The Civilian | 23-10
  • Stuart’s 100 #46 On the Way or Already There?
    46: On the Way or Already There? What if we dropped the pseudo-word “roading” from Auckland’s vernacular? Roads are on the way somewhere; streets are already somewhere. This simple difference in understanding and perspective between movement and place often results...
    Transport Blog | 23-10
  • National’s failed commodities export strategy exposed
    National's strategy to rely on commodities such as milk powder and logs has been exposed in the September trade figures released today, the Green Party said."National's strategy to hang all economic hope on exporting ever-increasing volumes of milk powder and...
    Greens | 23-10
  • Caution needed on calls to arm police
    There is no justification for routinely arming our police and doing so would change forever the way officers interact with their communities, Labour’s Associate Police spokesperson Kelvin Davis says. “As one of the few organisations distinguished by its unarmed status,...
    Labour | 23-10
  • Govt strains to get tea break law through
    The Government has been left with egg on its face - failing to get its much-vaunted, but hugely unpopular, meal break law passed in the first week of its new term, Labour spokesperson on Labour Issues Andrew Little says.“National desperately...
    Labour | 23-10
  • How low can you go? Mining the depths
    The company says there will be economic benefits, which the EEZ Act says the EPA must consider, but even these benefits are in doubt. The royalties while not set will be tiny, the profits will flow offshore, and whatever phosphate...
    Greens | 23-10
  • Fed Farmers defend GE Agriculture
    Federated Farmers, which represents a minority of farmers, appears to be captured by a pro-GE clique hell bent on increasing unsustainable technologies for the benefit of the herbicide and patent controlling seed companies. That there are better more sustainable farming...
    Greens | 23-10
  • Government loses the affordable housing race
    Nick Smith is dreaming if he thinks he can deliver affordable housing to Cantabrians on his current figures, says Labour’s Associate Housing spokesperson Poto Williams. “The Minister’s announcement that the Government will build 237 new homes, most of which will...
    Labour | 23-10
  • Labour’s thoughts with Canadians
    Labour has offered its sympathies to the family and friends of the Canadian soldier who died in what appears to be a premeditated and unprovoked attack while standing at guard at the Ottawa National War Memorial. “Our thoughts are also...
    Labour | 23-10
  • What next for TVNZ? Outsourcing the news?
    Television New Zealand’s decision to outsource Māori and Pacific programming is a real blow to the notion that our state broadcaster is a public broadcaster, says Labour. “CEO Kevin Kenrick has said today that TVNZ has ‘a very long and...
    Labour | 22-10
  • Green Party expresses sympathy for Canadian shooting victims
    The Green Party expressed its solidarity with Canadians and the Canadian Parliament today, offering its sympathy for family and friends of the soldier killed in the attack. "Our thoughts are with all those caught up in the shooting in Canada...
    Greens | 22-10
  • Prime Minister must honour his promise
    It’s time for John Key to honour his promise to the Pike River families, says Labour MP Damien O’Connor.  “International mine experts have confirmed the view of WorkSafe New Zealand and many miners on the West Coast that it is...
    Labour | 22-10
  • Kevin Hague questions the Minister of Health about Katherine Rich’s c...
    KEVIN HAGUE to the Minister of Health : Is he satisfied that there is no conflict of interest in the head of the Food and Grocery Council, Katherine Rich, being a board member of the Health Promotion Agency; if so,...
    Greens | 22-10
  • Kennedy Graham to the Prime Minister on the Deployment of New Zealand Speci...
    Dr KENNEDY GRAHAM to the Prime Minister: Does he stand by his statement that the risks to New Zealand from any commitment of military assistance to counter Islamic State militants in Iraq would be "no greater than I think the...
    Greens | 22-10
  • EPA finds Shell Oil illegally drilled two wells
    The Environmental Protection Authority (EPA) has concluded that Shell Todd Oil Services (STOS) broke the law by drilling two wells without a marine consent off the coast of Taranaki, the Green Party said today. The EPA conducted an inspection of...
    Greens | 22-10
  • Soaring rail use in Auckland shows need for rail link now
    News that Aucklanders overtook Wellingtonians as the biggest train users is further evidence the Government needs to start work on the Auckland City Rail Link now, the Green Party said today.Auckland Transport said today that in the year to September,...
    Greens | 22-10
  • Tea breaks gone by lunch time
    Labour is calling for an eleventh hour reprieve to employment law changes which could see thousands of Kiwi workers not covered by collective agreements lose their smoko breaks, its spokesperson on Labour Issues Andrew Little says.“How cynical that on the...
    Labour | 21-10
  • Metiria Turei to lead fight on feeding hungry children
    Green Party Co-leader Metiria Turei is urging all political parties to support the Feed the Kids Bill which she inherited today from Mana leader Hone Harawira.Mrs Turei, who leads the Green Party's work on child poverty, will pick up Mr...
    Greens | 21-10
  • Otago dairy farms fail basics
    I’m really privileged to take on the responsibility of the water portfolio. Eugenie Sage has done excellent work in this area in the last term of parliament and provided a great platform for further work. Last Parliament my bill to...
    Greens | 21-10
  • A mighty totara has fallen across the Tasman
    The New Zealand Labour Party expresses deep sadness at the death of former Australian prime minister Gough Whitlam, aged 98. “Today a great totara has fallen across the Tasman,” Labour’s Acting Deputy Leader Annette King says....
    Labour | 21-10
  • Note to National: Must deliver on child poverty
    John Key and his Government will be held to its promise to make child poverty a priority, Labour’s Acting Deputy Leader Annette King says. “In its priority-setting speech today the Government stated child poverty would be a major focus for...
    Labour | 21-10
  • New Analysis show Government cut tertiary education funding
    New analysis done by the Green Party today shows the Government has made cuts to funding of tertiary education since 2008.Figures compiled by the Parliamentary Library show that between 2009 and 2015 Government funding to Tertiary Institutions dropped by 4...
    Greens | 21-10
  • Students doing it tough as fees rise again
    The Government is making it increasingly difficult for Kiwis to gain tertiary education as fees continue to rise and access to student support becomes even more restricted, Labour’s Tertiary Education spokesperson Chris Hipkins says. “Steven Joyce is shutting a generation...
    Labour | 20-10
  • Key misled New Zealand on Iraq deployment
      John Key was misleading New Zealanders prior to the election when he ruled out New Zealand special forces being deployed to Iraq, says Labour Defence Spokesperson Phil Goff.  “Post-election he has cynically disregarded that by saying that deployment of...
    Labour | 20-10
  • Swearing about swearing the oath
    Yesterday, I was swearing. Swearing the Parliamentary oath, that is. But, under my breath, I was also quietly swearing about the archaic, colonial form of that oath and its inappropriateness for today’s Aotearoa New Zealand. To be permitted to speak...
    Greens | 20-10
  • Kevin Hague speaks in the 2014 Address and Reply debate
    Thank you very much, Mr Deputy Speaker, and, like others, can I begin my contribution by congratulating you and the others in the Speaker's team: the Rt Hon David Carter, Lindsay Tisch, and the Hon Trevor Mallard. I also want...
    Greens | 20-10
  • Damning report on Ruataniwha dam numbers
    When I presented my submission to the Board of Inquiry on the Tukituki Catchment Proposal I compared the proposed 83 metre high Ruataniwha dam with the Clyde Dam and noted the risk of cost blowouts in the construction process.  The...
    Greens | 20-10
  • Church congratulated on child poverty stand
    The efforts by the bishops of the Anglican Church to ensure that the issue of child poverty is not forgotten is a call to all New Zealanders to take action, says Labour’s Interfaith-Dialogue Spokesperson, Su’a William Sio.   “I think...
    Labour | 19-10
  • Labour names Review Team
    Labour’s New Zealand Council has appointed Bryan Gould as Convenor of its post-General Election Review.  He will be joined on the Review Team by Hon Margaret Wilson, Stacey Morrison and Brian Corban (see further biographical details here). The Review Team...
    Labour | 19-10
  • Labour backs urban development plans
    Auckland Council’s plan to set up an urban development agency is to be applauded and central government should get behind it to make it a success, Labour’s Auckland Issues spokesperson Phil Twyford says. Auckland Council CEO Stephen Town has indicated plans...
    Labour | 18-10
  • New Zealand can be rightly proud of seat on Security Council
    Gaining a seat on the United Nation’s Security Council shows the sort of standing that New Zealand has in the world and the quality of the long campaign that we ran over nearly a decade, says Foreign Affairs spokesperson David...
    Labour | 16-10
  • NZ has opportunity on UN Security Council
    New Zealand has an opportunity to make a major contribution to the strengthening of international law and institutional capacity through its upcoming two-year tenure on the United Nations Security Council, Green Party spokesperson on global affairs, Dr Kennedy Graham said...
    Greens | 16-10
  • MPI still dragging the chain over causes of food bug
    The Ministry of Primary Industries’ release of Environmental Science and Research’s initial reports regarding the sources of a nasty stomach bug will be little comfort to the 127 people affected by it, Labour’s Food Safety spokesperson Damien O’Connor says. “This...
    Labour | 16-10
  • Treasury officials should try working without food
    The Green Party is challenging Treasury officials to work for a week without eating properly, in light of their advice to Government that a food in schools programme is not needed."Treasury's advice was that providing food for children in schools...
    Greens | 15-10
  • Councils need to better protect our drinking water
    Environment Canterbury (ECan) is proposing several variations to its regional land and water plan that will allow for increased nutrient and other pollution from irrigation and intensive agriculture on the Canterbury Plains. Commissioners are hearing submissions on Variation 1 to...
    Greens | 15-10
  • National needs to commit to making NZ workers safe
    The National Government must do more to help make New Zealand workplaces a safer place to work in, Green Party industrial relations spokesperson Denise Roche said today.Data released by Statistics New Zealand today showed that workers in the fishing and...
    Greens | 15-10
  • Key commits to deployment before consultation or analysis
    John Key’s offer to consult Opposition parties on whether to deploy New Zealand forces against ISIS looks increasingly like a PR exercise only, says Labour’s Defence spokesperson, Phil Goff. “The presence of New Zealand’s Chief of Defence Force at a...
    Labour | 15-10
  • National must end ideological opposition to raising income
    If John Key is serious about tackling child poverty he must approach it with an open mind, and overcome his ideological block to raising incomes as a solution, the Green Party said today.Papers released to Radio New Zealand today show...
    Greens | 14-10
  • Pentagon links climate change and terrorism
    Yesterday the Pentagon launched a plan to deal with a threat that “poses immediate risks to national security”; one that “will affect the Department of Defense’s ability to defend the nation”. It wasn’t referring to Ebola or ISIS. It was...
    Greens | 14-10
  • Four Nominees for Labour’s Leadership
    As at 5pm today four valid nominations had been received for the position of Labour Leader, as follows: Andrew Little(nominated by Poto Williams and Iain Lees-Galloway) Nanaia Mahuta(nominated by Louisa Wall and Su’a William Sio) David Parker(nominated by Damien O’Connor...
    Labour | 14-10
  • Green Party calls for consultation over terrorism law changes
    The Green Party has today written to the Prime Minister asking him to engage in wider consultation prior to changing any laws as a result of the recently announced terrorism law reviews, said the Green Party today. In a letter...
    Greens | 14-10
  • MPI must name product and supermarket chain
    The Ministry of Primary Industries must name the product responsible for severe gastroenteritis affecting people around the country, and the supermarket chain distributing it, Labour’s Food Safety spokesperson Damien O’Connor says. “The Ministry seems to be more concerned about protecting...
    Labour | 13-10
  • John Key dishonest about reasons for wanting to change terrorism law
    John Key is misleading the public to push through terrorism law changes under urgency, the Green Party said today. On Sunday, John Key stated that it is not illegal for someone to fight overseas for a terrorist group, such as...
    Greens | 12-10
  • Law changes shaping up to be worse than first thought
    The Prime Minister needs to be up front about exactly what changes he is planning to make to the Employment Relations  Amendment Bill, Labour's spokesperson on Labour Issues Andrew Little says.Interviewed on Q&A yesterday John Key said he did not...
    Labour | 12-10
  • Rapists, not Tinder, the threat to women
    Blame for rape and sexual assault should only ever be laid at the door of the perpetrator, not dating services or the actions of women themselves, Labour’s Associate Police spokesperson Kelvin Davis says. “Tinder is not the problem and women...
    Labour | 09-10
  • Safer Journeys For People Who Cycle
    You have a rare opportunity to tell the people who are making the decisions on cycling how to make it better. The Cycling Safety Panel is seeking feedback on their draft recommendations for improving the safety of cycling in New...
    Greens | 08-10
  • Subsidising more pollution will undermine water clean-up plan at Te Waihora...
    In 2010, NIWA found Canterbury’s Te Waihora/Lake Ellesmere had the worst nutrient status of 140 lakes around New Zealand that it measured. In 2011, the National Government committed to spending $15 million across the country through the Fresh Start for...
    Greens | 08-10
  • Adding value not herbicides
    The HT swedes, and other brassicas, might seem like a good idea to farmers struggling against weeds but like the GE road, is this the path we want our agriculture to be treading? The Federated Farmers President, Dr William Rolleston...
    Greens | 07-10
  • ‘Blame the Planner’ bizarre approach to child poverty
    The National Government is stooping to a bizarre new low in blaming "planning processes" for poverty and inequality, after spending six years doing nothing about either the housing market or child poverty, the Green Party said today. Finance Minister Bill...
    Greens | 07-10
  • Media Advisory
    MANA Leader, Hone Harawira will not be available to speak with media today regarding his release “Recount Just One Step To restoring Credibility”. He is however available for media comment tomorrow, Tuesday the 8th of October, all media arrangements are...
    Mana | 07-10
  • RECOUNT JUST ONE STEP TO RESTORING CREDIBILITY
    “I have applied for a judicial recount of the votes in the Tai Tokerau election because it is one step in trying to restore credibility to the electoral process in the north, and, I suspect, in all other Maori electorates...
    Mana | 07-10
  • MANA SEEKS TAI TOKERAU RECOUNT
    The MANA Movement is supporting Leader Hone Harawira’s application for a judicial re-count in the Te Tai Tokerau electorate for the 2014 general election. President Lisa McNab says there are a number of serious issues of concern regarding the ability...
    Mana | 07-10
  • Ideological Blitzkrieg – Privatization of state housing, more charter sch...
    Pundits in pundit land will tell you that this Government is boring, that Key is the great pragmatist and that it is his ability to create elegant solutions that keeps him the firm favourite in many Kiwi eyes. This ability...
    The Daily Blog | 24-10
  • Hegemony rules but resistance is fertile
    The Prime Minister is a puppet. Not just our current Prime Minister, but given the forces of multinational globalisation, the role of any head of state, is less as independent actor, and more as a puppet of international trends and...
    The Daily Blog | 24-10
  • An open Letter to Sir Bob Jones: demanding a ‘liveable wage’ is not “...
    How out of touch with reality is Sir Bob Jones? You know, that white dude who invested in privatised SOEs after the selling off of our assets in the eighties and made a ludicrous and disgusting amount of money and is...
    The Daily Blog | 24-10
  • My insecurity about the Security Council
    As I write this (on 24 October) it is international UN Day. Of course, you all knew that already, right? Well, the day celebrates the entry into force of the UN Charter in 1945. With the ratification of this founding...
    The Daily Blog | 24-10
  • GUEST BLOG: Catherine Delahunty – Back in That House
    Parliament opened this week and I still find it a very odd place. Most of the people are reasonably courteous and friendly, but the rituals are archaic and the rules around issues like the swearing in oath are oppressive and...
    The Daily Blog | 23-10
  • Marae Investigates No More
    TVNZ yesterday announced the closure of their Māori and Pacific programmes department. That means they’ve chosen to stop making Fresh, Tagata Pasifika, Waka Huia and Marae Investigates to let independent producers get their hands on these lucrative contracts. This is...
    The Daily Blog | 23-10
  • BLOGWATCH: An Un-Civil War in Labour, eh?
    Earlier today, my attention was directed to an entry that’s just recently appeared on the Slightly Left of Centre blog. It purports to contain the ‘inside word’ from a highly placed NZF source – which is funny, because I’m pretty sure...
    The Daily Blog | 23-10
  • Santanomics 101
    Santanomics could mean a number of things. It could be the study and practice of giving. Or it could mean the study and practice of rampant end-of-year commercialism. However, for me today it is the economics of erectingAuckland’s giant Santa...
    The Daily Blog | 23-10
  • SkyCity boss misleads public over workers lost shifts
    SkyCity CEO Nigel Morrison has defended the employment practices at his company in an “Opinion” piece entitled “Human Capital key to corporate success” in the NZ Herald on Thursday. A number of his claims are misleading, contain only partial truths...
    The Daily Blog | 23-10
  • Review: Perfect Place
    I went to a Perfect Place on Tuesday night, and what a delight it was. The marshmallows sweetly (and forcefully) handed out pre-show, set the tone for the next hour. Walking up the stairs at The Basement was a complete...
    The Daily Blog | 23-10
  • 5AA Australia – NZ on UN Security Council + Dirty Politics Lingers On
    5AA Australia: Selwyn Manning and Peter Godfrey deliver their weekly bulletin Across The Ditch. General round up of over night talkback issues: Thongs, Jandals and flip-flops… ISSUE 1: New Zealand has been successful in its campaign to become a non...
    The Daily Blog | 22-10
  • When I mean me, I mean my office & when I call whaleoil I mean not as m...
    This. Is. Ludicrous. Green Party co-leader Russel Norman put the first of what are likely to be many questions about Mr Key’s relationship with Slater, asking him how many times he had phoned or texted the blogger since 2008. “None...
    The Daily Blog | 22-10
  • A brief word on describing the Government as ‘boring and bland’
    The narrative being sown is that this Government will be a boring and bland third term. Boring and bland. Since the election, Key has announced he is privatising 30% of state houses without reinvesting any of that money back into housing society’s most...
    The Daily Blog | 22-10
  • More Latté Than Lager: Reflections on Grant Robertson’s Campaign Launch.
    BIKERS? SERIOUSLY! Had Grant Robertson’s campaign launch been organised by Phil Goff? Was this a pitch for the votes of what few Waitakere Men remain in the Labour Party? Was I even at the right place? Well, yes, I was....
    The Daily Blog | 22-10
  • About Curwen Ares Rolinson
    Curwen Ares Rolinson – Curwen Ares Rolinson is a firebrand young nationalist presently engaged in acts of political resistance deep behind enemy lines amidst the leafy boughs of Epsom. He is affiliated with the New Zealand First Party; although his...
    The Daily Blog | 21-10
  • About Kelly Ellis
    Kelly Ellis.Kelly Ellis – As a child, Kelly Ellis didn’t so much fall into the cracks, but willfully wriggled her way into them. Ejected from Onslow College – a big job in the 70s – Kelly worked in car factories,...
    The Daily Blog | 21-10
  • About Kate Davis
    Kate Davis.Kate Davis – Having completed her BA in English and Politics, Kate is now starting her MA. Kate works as a volunteer advocate at Auckland Action Against Poverty and previously worked for the New Zealand Prostitutes Collective. Kate writes...
    The Daily Blog | 21-10
  • Parker does a Shearer – oh for a Labour Leader who can challenge msm fals...
    Sigh. It seems David Parker has done a Shearer… Like a cult and too red – Parker on LabourLabour leadership contender David Parker says Labour borders on feeling like “a cult” and must look at its branding – including its...
    The Daily Blog | 21-10
  • A brief word on the hundreds of millions NZ is spending on the secret intel...
    The enormity of the mass surveillance state NZ Government’s have built carries a huge price tag… Kiwis pay $103m ‘membership fee’ for spyingThe $103 million taxpayer funding of New Zealand’s intelligence agencies is effectively a membership fee for joining the...
    The Daily Blog | 21-10
  • Where. Is. Jason. Ede?
    Where. Is. Jason. Ede?...
    The Daily Blog | 21-10
  • Labour’s Din of Inequity
    Watching Labour’s leadership candidates on Q+A on Sunday, I noticed the ongoing use of terms like “opportunity” and “aspiration”, and “party of the workers”. What do these mean? We glean much from Labour, and from the media about Labour, but not...
    The Daily Blog | 21-10
  • “Blue-Greenwash” fails the test when it comes to endangered dolphins
    National’s pre-election promises saw some wins for the environment – perhaps as the party sought to appease its “Blue-Green” voters and broaden its popular appeal. Some of the ecological gains were a long time in the making, overdue even– such...
    The Daily Blog | 21-10
  • Reasons not to be cheerful, Part #272b
    Why don’t you get back into bed? The next few years — the rest of this century — are not going to be pretty. There is an obvious disconnect between any remaining political ambition to fix climate change and the...
    The Daily Blog | 21-10
  • OIA protocols and official advice ignored to hide Child Poverty
    It might not seem so now, but child poverty was a major election issue. What a pity we did not have the full debate. In that debate it would have been very helpful to have seen the Ministry of Social...
    The Daily Blog | 20-10
  • Previewing the 4 candidates for Leader of the Labour Party
    The extraordinary outbursts by Shearer last week highlights just how toxic that Caucus is. Shearer was on every major media platform as the ABC attack dog tearing into Cunliffe in the hope of diminishing Cunliffe’s support of Little by tearing...
    The Daily Blog | 19-10
  • GUEST BLOG: Kate Davis – the sudden explosion of ‘left’ blogs
    Time to Teach or more people will suffer from P.A.I.D. Political And Intellectual Dysmorphia.I was on the Twitter and a guy followed me so of course I did the polite thing and followed him back. He wrote a blog so...
    The Daily Blog | 19-10
  • Ego vs Eco
    Ego vs Eco...
    The Daily Blog | 19-10
  • We can’t let the Roastbuster case slip away
    Those of us (like me) left with hope that the police would aggressively follow through on the large amount of evidence on offer to them (let’s not forget they forgot they even had some at one point) in the Roastbusters...
    The Daily Blog | 19-10
  • Food, shelter and medicine instead of bombs and bullets
    The on-going conflict across the Middle East – due in large part to the US-led invasions of Afghanistan and Iraq – has created another humanitarian crisis of biblical proportion. The essentials of life are desperately needed in Iraq and Syria...
    The Daily Blog | 19-10
  • The politics of electorate accommodations
    National’s electorate accommodations with ACT and United Future were a big factor in it winning re-election. Interestingly, there is another electorate accommodation scenario whereby the centre-left could have come out on top, even with the same distribution of party votes....
    The Daily Blog | 19-10
  • Why you should join the TPPA Action on 8 November
    On 8 November 2014, thousands of Kiwis will take part in the International Day of Action to protest the Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement (TPPA). The rally cry for us is TPPA – Corporate Trap, Kiwis Fight Back. Why should you join...
    The Daily Blog | 19-10
  • GUEST BLOG – Patrick O’Dea: no new coal mines
    Green Party and Mana Party policy is “NO NEW COAL MINES!” Auckland Coal Action is trying to put this policy into action on the ground. ACA after a hard fought two year campaign waged alongside local residents and Iwi, in...
    The Daily Blog | 19-10
  • Comparing Police action – Hager raid vs Roast Buster case
    This satire had the NZ Police contact TDB and threaten us with 6months in prison for using their logo.   The plight of Nicky Hager and the draconian Police actions against him has generated over  $53 000 in donations so...
    The Daily Blog | 18-10
  • Malala Yousafzai, White Saviour Complexes and Local Resistance
    Last week, Malala Yousafzai was the co-recipient of the Nobel Peace Prize. Since her exposure to the worldwide spotlight, her spirit, wisdom and strength have touched the hearts of people everywhere. However, there have been cynics who have argued that...
    The Daily Blog | 18-10
  • Jason Ede is back – but no media can interview him?
    Well, well, well. Jason Ede, the main figure connected to John Key’s office and the Dirty Politics black ops is back with a company with deep ties to the National Party. One thing you can say about the right –...
    The Daily Blog | 18-10
  • GUEST BLOG: Curwen Rolinson – Leadership Transitions In Other Parties: A ...
    As cannot have escaped anyone’s attention by now, the country is presently in the grips of an election and campaign that will help determine the fate of the nation for years to come. It’s gripping stuff – with clear divides...
    The Daily Blog | 17-10
  • SkyCity worker says she faces losing her house
    SkyCity worker Carolyn Alpine told the company annual shareholder’s meeting today that she faced the prospect of losing her house because the company had cut her shifts from two a week to one without consultation. The solo mother, has worked...
    The Daily Blog | 17-10
  • Greg O’Connor’s latest push to arm cops & 5 reasons not to
    I was wondering at what point within a 3rd term of National that Police Cheerleader Greg O’Connor would start trying to demand cops be armed. O’Connor must have thought to himself, ‘if bloody Key can get us and the GCSB vast new...
    The Daily Blog | 16-10
  • You can’t have crisis without ISIS
    So the new scary bogeyman ISIS might have chemical weapons that the US secretly found in Iraq, but America didn’t want to expose this find because the WMDs were actually built and made by the US and Europe, the two powers...
    The Daily Blog | 16-10
  • NZ WINS UN SPIN THE BOTTLE! Privately sucking up to America for a decade me...
    Oh, we are loved! Little old NZ, the 53rd state of America after Israel and Australia, gets to sit at the adults table for the special dinner party that is the UN Security Council. How delightful, a decade of privately...
    The Daily Blog | 16-10
  • MEDIA BLOG – Myles Thomas – A World Without Advertising
    Non-commercial broadcasting and media. It’s a solution for all manner of problems ailing our tender nation… voter engagement, unaccountable governance, apathy, stupefaction, public education, science in schools, arts appreciation, cultural cringe… But no-one could’ve guessed that non-commercial media might solve...
    The Daily Blog | 16-10
  • March against war – 2pm Saturday 25th October
    March against war – 2pm Saturday 25th October...
    The Daily Blog | 16-10
  • Whack a mole as US govt foreign policy
    Whack-A-Mole was a popular arcade game from my youth.  It consisted of a waist high cabinet with holes in the top. Plastic moles seemingly randomly pop out of these holes. The purpose of the game was to hit as many...
    The Daily Blog | 16-10
  • In Paean of Debt
    This week is ‘Money Week’. It’s an opportunity to promote to the middle classes, and anyone else who will listen, the virtues of wise ‘investment’. The aims are to promote the mystical (and indeed mythical) virtues of saving for the...
    The Daily Blog | 16-10
  • The last 48 hours – Poverty denial, war denial and unapologetic abuse of ...
    The bewildering speed of events that simply end in Key shrugging and proclaiming he doesn’t really give a shit is coming think and fast as the Government suddenly appreciate the full spectrum dominance they now enjoy. Here is Radio NZ...
    The Daily Blog | 16-10
  • GUEST BLOG: Pat O’Dea – Mana 2.0 Rebooted
    Internationally the news is that Evo Morales of Bolivia won big with Left Wing policies But what are the chances that the Left will make a resurgence in this country? As the internecine struggles between the Left and the Right...
    The Daily Blog | 15-10
  • The Blomfield IPCA letter – Has Dirty Politics leaked into the NZ Police ...
    It’s difficult to know what to make of the IPCA letter to Matthew Blomfield over Slater’s continued insistence that the hard drive taken from Matthew wasn’t stolen.  Slater has selectively cherry picked the Police referring back to his claim that Blomfeild perjured...
    The Daily Blog | 15-10
  • ​Media release: Rail and Maritime Transport Union – Auckland move for K...
    The Rail and Maritime Transport Union is questioning a KiwiRail proposal to progressively relocate its Zero Harm personnel from Wellington to Auckland. “The purpose of the Zero Harm team is to drive KiwiRail’s performance in health and safety.  Rail is a...
    The Daily Blog | 15-10
  • Amnesty International – Friend request from an IS militant
    There’s always that one person, that one Facebook friend, usually a musician or event promoter, who, when you so foolishly accept their friend request, will completely inundate your news feed with copious event invitations and promotions. The person who, despite...
    The Daily Blog | 15-10
  • NZ should follow the UK and recognize the Palestinian state
    Over the past two weeks, the United Kingdom and Sweden have made headlines through their decisions to recognize the state of Palestine. They are hardly the first nations to do so. Indeed, 134 countries have, in various ways, given formal...
    The Daily Blog | 15-10
  • Pike River Families Group Press Release
    The Families can now but hope that Solid Energy will consider closely the response of the Families’ expert mining advisers, Bob Stevenson and Dave Creedy, and the independent legal advice by Hugh Rennie QC as to why re-entry to the...
    Scoop politics | 24-10
  • On The Nation this weekend
    This weekend on The Nation… with dairy prices falling, China growing its agriculture sector, and the environmental costs piling up, we ask the Fonterra chief executive Theo Spierings if New Zealand is too dependent on milk powder and if we’ve...
    Scoop politics | 24-10
  • NZ Government Urged to Do More to Fight Ebola
    As Ebola continues to tear through West Africa, Save the Children NZ is urging the government to do more in the fight against the deadly virus....
    Scoop politics | 24-10
  • Korero Mai Ki Ahau – Saturday 25 & Sunday 26 October 2014
    Broadcast on Waatea 603AM Saturday 12.00 - 12.30pm Sunday 12.00 - 12.30pm Both shows repeated 5.00pm – 6.00pm On Sunday...
    Scoop politics | 24-10
  • Putting whānau foremost in Family Dispute Resolution
    Dispute resolution company, FairWay Resolution, has developed a uniquely New Zealand approach to family dispute resolution (FDR) that is underpinned by the cultural needs and values of the parties to a family dispute. In support of its role as a...
    Scoop politics | 24-10
  • Anglican Family Care staff to rally industrial action rises
    Public Service Association (PSA) members working at Anglican Family Care (AFC) in Dunedin will hold two rallies in Dunedin next week as they seek a fair pay offer, following a week of low-key industrial action....
    Scoop politics | 23-10
  • Flying Visit for Adventuring Kiwi Socialpreneur
    12 Months on, this former Alexandra barista is changing lives in Buenos Aires Slums with free lunches, music, art, drama and toothbrushes...
    Scoop politics | 23-10
  • March in Solidarity with Kurdistan Against ISIS Attacks
    The New Zealand Kurdish Community will march in solidarity with Kurdistan in light of the heinous genocidal attacks in Kobanê by ISIS. We will begin with silent demonstrations then commence marching. We will start from Britomart, Queen Street (outside Dick...
    Scoop politics | 23-10
  • No Problem for Henare & Jones, But “No Way” for Harawira
    “Just before the election I broke the story about the gutting of Maori Television’s News and Current Affairs department by MTS’ new CEO Paora Maxwell. I pointed out that Carol Hirschfeld and Julian Wilcox, two of the country’s most experienced...
    Scoop politics | 23-10
  • Corruption: Positive developments for NZ but more to be done
    Global anti-corruption group Transparency International today released a report on OECD Anti-Bribery Convention enforcement and called for New Zealand to implement draft legislation to ratify the United Nations Convention against Corruption....
    Scoop politics | 23-10
  • Government to Blame as Much as Council for Marryatt Payout
    The Taxpayers' Union is calling on the Government to fix the employment law regime that has forced Christchurch ratepayers to fork out $800,000 to former Council boss Tony Marryatt....
    Scoop politics | 23-10
  • Unanimously Call for Commissioner to Arm Police Full Time
    In the wake of a series of recent armed offender incidents, delegates to the Police Association Annual Conference today called unanimously on the Commissioner to arm Police full time....
    Scoop politics | 23-10
  • Bank gets behind NZ wildlife icon with sizable donation
    It will be easier than ever this summer for holiday-markers to dip into their pockets to support the yellow-eyed penguin....
    Scoop politics | 23-10
  • WorkSafe report raises concerns about asbestos
    The union representing construction workers in the Canterbury rebuild is surprised at WorkSafe’s conclusion that no action needs to be taken against EQC and Fletcher EQR over asbestos exposure in Canterbury homes. “This report was an opportunity...
    Scoop politics | 23-10
  • Union accuses SkyCity CEO of misleading public
    Unite Union has accused SkyCity CEO Nigel Morrison of misleading the public over the cut in hours for a staff member who raised the issue at the company's AGM....
    Scoop politics | 23-10
  • Last Hurrah on the Taxpayer
    Responding to the NZ Herald report that Hone Harawira spent up $54,000 on the taxpayer in his last three months as an MP, Taxpayers’ Union Executive Director Jordan Williams says: “It is absolutely disgraceful that an MP managed to rack...
    Scoop politics | 23-10
  • Press statement in relation to search of Nicky Hager’s home
    On 2 October 2014, Nicky Hager's home in Wellington was searched by police. Mr Hager asserted that documents kept at his house were protected by privilege, including because they contained information that might identify confidential sources....
    Scoop politics | 22-10
  • The Sam Simon arrives into Auckland for new campaign
    This morning Sea Shepherd ship, the Sam Simon, arrived into Auckland harbour after its journey from Melbourne. The ship and its 25 crew from around the globe have come to New Zealand to source supplies and prepare for the upcoming...
    Scoop politics | 22-10
  • Low inflation – time for meaningful wage increases
    With inflation low, now is a good time for workers to negotiate for pay increases that outstrip price rises and deliver real increases in wages and salaries. “For too many people, real pay increases have been missing for several years...
    Scoop politics | 22-10
  • Auckland Rates Rises Out of Control
    Responding to the NZ Herald report that Auckland ratepayers will face an average of a 29 percent rates increase, Taxpayers’ Union Executive Director Jordan Williams says: “These rate rises show that Len Brown's spending is out of control.”...
    Scoop politics | 22-10
  • Protest at New Plymouth Oil and Gas Expo
    About 30 protesters from Climate Justice Taranaki, Frack-free Kapiti, Te Uru Pounamu Action Group, Oil Free Wellington, Frack-free Manawatu and the east coast protested yesterday outside New Plymouth's biennial Oil and Gas Expo at the TSB Stadium....
    Scoop politics | 22-10
  • FMA warns consumers about cold-calling investment offers
    The Financial Markets Authority (FMA) is warning New Zealand consumers and investors to be wary of cold-calls asking them to buy shares or put their money into offshore firms....
    Scoop politics | 22-10
  • Comprehensive plan needed to end child poverty
    Child Poverty Action Group says it is vital the newly re-elected National government takes a planned and comprehensive approach to reducing child poverty in New Zealand....
    Scoop politics | 22-10
  • Metiria Gets Feed the Kids
    Yesterday the Speaker of the House advised that he had accepted my request to transfer my Feed the Kids (Education (Breakfast and Lunch Programmes in Schools) Amendment) Bill to Metiria Turei of the Green Party....
    Scoop politics | 22-10
  • DIA undercover investigation leads to jailing
    An undercover Internal Affairs investigation has led to a Hastings man being jailed for three and half years....
    Scoop politics | 22-10
  • Call on Minister McCully to pursue the case of Balibo Five
    Media Information: Call on Minister McCully to pursue the case of journalist Gary Cunningham and the Balibo Five...
    Scoop politics | 22-10
  • Australia and NZ actions on press freedoms alarming
    Global support for investigative journalism in Australia and New Zealand is a welcome response to law changes and a police raid, says the Pacific Freedom Forum...
    Scoop politics | 22-10
  • Call for release of French journalists in West Papua
    West Papua Action Auckland, the EPMU Print and Media Council and the NZ Media Freedom Network call on the Minister of Foreign Affairs to speak out in support of the two French TV journalists whose trial has just begun in...
    Scoop politics | 21-10
  • Court of Appeal: Dotcom v 20th Century Fox Film Corporation
    A The appeal is dismissed. B The 20 August 2014 order of the High Court dealing with confidentiality and the 29 August 2014 order of this Court dealing with confidentiality are set aside. C The confidentiality orders set out in...
    Scoop politics | 21-10
  • Glassons Blasted For Glamourising Animal Cruelty
    Clothing brand Glassons have found themselves embroiled in another controversy after launching a new advert featuring a girl riding a bull. Animal advocacy organisation SAFE have asked them to remove the ad immediately as it glamourises animal cruelty....
    Scoop politics | 21-10
  • Smuggling honey into New Zealand isn’t sweet
    Smuggling honey into New Zealand isn’t sweet Federated Farmers Bee Industry Group applauds the tough line taken by Ministry for Primary Industries (MPI) Border Staff at Auckland Airport. In deporting the couple found trying to smuggle bee products...
    Scoop politics | 21-10
  • Taxpayers’ Union Responds to Joyce on Corporate Welfare
    Responding to Economic Development Minister Steven Joyce’s defence of corporate welfare , Jim Rose, the author of Monopoly Money , a Taxpayers Union report on corporate welfare since 2008, says:...
    Scoop politics | 21-10
  • Speech from the Throne brings welcome focus on children
    Today’s speech from the Throne confirms the Government’s focus on children, youth and their families in the areas of health, education, youth employment, poverty alleviation and Whānau Ora; now the challenge is to ensure every child in New Zealand...
    Scoop politics | 21-10
  • John’s Job Fairs no fix for unemployment and poverty
    “John Key has clearly been looking to the US for his latest bright idea on dealing with employment issues,” says Auckland Action Against Poverty coordinator Sue Bradford. “Job fairs where the desperately unemployed queue in their corporate best to compete...
    Scoop politics | 21-10
  • Speech From the Throne Foreshadows More Corporate Welfare
    Responding to the Governor General’s Speech from the Throne, which outlined that the Government’s intentions for the next Parliamentary term would include further Business Growth Agenda initiatives, Taxpayers’ Union Executive Director Jordan...
    Scoop politics | 21-10
  • Green MP to speak at panel on Rainbow Mental Health
    Hamilton, New Zealand: Recently re-elected Green Party MP Jan Logie will be a guest speaker at a panel on the mental health of Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual, Trangender, Takataapui and Intersex people taking place on November 1st as part of the...
    Scoop politics | 20-10
  • Evidence Supports GE Moratorium
    Federated Farmers spokesman Graham Smith's call for a 'rethink' on release of GeneticallyEngineered organisms is misguided, and instead it is time for a formal moratorium on GMOs in the environment.(1)...
    Scoop politics | 20-10
  • Chatham Rise mining could have impact on whales and dolphins
    Wellington, 21 October 2014--Mining phosphate on the Chatham Rise, off the east coast of New Zealand’s south island, could potentially have many impacts on marine mammals like whales and dolphins, the Environmental Protection Agency was told today....
    Scoop politics | 20-10
  • Council endorses Nanaia Mahuta as the next Labour leader
    Te Kaunihera Māori, the Māori Council of the New Zealand Labour Party, have passed a resolution to endorse the Hon Nanaia Mahuta as the next leader of the Labour Party...
    Scoop politics | 20-10
  • Kaumatua to organise petition to end Maori seats
    Ngapuhi kaumatua David Rankin has announced that he will be organising a nationwide petition to seek support from Maori voters to end the Maori seats. “These seats are patronising”, he says. “They imply we need a special status, and that...
    Scoop politics | 20-10
  • Announcing a New Voice for The Left
    Josh Forman is pleased to announce the creation of a new force on the Left of politics in New Zealand....
    Scoop politics | 20-10
  • Public services held back by poor workplace culture
    A new report by Victoria University’s Centre for Labour, Employment and Work shows that public servants are working significant unpaid overtime to ensure the public services New Zealanders value are able to continue....
    Scoop politics | 20-10
  • iPredict New Zealand Weekly Economic & Political Update
    Andrew Little’s probability of being the next leader of the Labour Party has reached 70% and Jacinda Ardern is favourite to become his deputy, according to the combined wisdom of the 8000+ registered traders on New Zealand’s predictions market, iPredict....
    Scoop politics | 20-10
  • Prison Drug Treatment Unit marks a milestone
    Christchurch Men’s Prison’s Drug Treatment Unit (DTU) celebrated the completion of its 50th six month Drug and Alcohol Programme today, with the graduation of a further twelve offenders....
    Scoop politics | 20-10
  • Security Council seat a chance for NZ to empower women
    The UN Women National Committee Aotearoa New Zealand (UN Women NCANZ) welcomes New Zealand winning a seat on the United Nations Security Council and is calling on New Zealand to use its position to proactively promote effective implementation of the...
    Scoop politics | 20-10
  • Waipareira and ACC sign Partnership
    Waipareira and The Accident Compensation Corporation (ACC) have signed a Memorandum of Understanding at Whanau Centre, Henderson – marking a special day for the West Auckland Urban Maori organisation....
    Scoop politics | 20-10
  • Humanitarian aid desperately needed in Iraq and Syria
    Global Peace and Justice Auckland is calling on the government to provide humanitarian funding for non-aligned NGOs (non-governmental organisations) in the Middle East rather than give any support whatever for the US-led military campaign in the area....
    Scoop politics | 19-10
  • Court Judicial Decision: Dotcom v The USA: 17 October 2014
    The United States of America is seeking the extradition of Messrs Dotcom, Batato, Ortmann and Van Der Kolk. The matter has been before the Courts on numerous occasions, and no further recitation of the facts is needed....
    Scoop politics | 19-10
  • Marshall Island poet speaks at UN climate summit
    “The fossil fuel industry is the biggest threat to our very existence as Pacific Islanders. We stand to lose our homes, our communities and our culture. But we are fighting back. This coming Friday thirty Pacific Climate Warriors, joined by...
    Scoop politics | 19-10
  • Many tourist car accidents preventable
    Simple steps could dramatically reduce the number of accidents involving tourists, says the car review website dogandlemon.com ....
    Scoop politics | 19-10
Public service advertisements by The Standard

Current CO2 level in the atmosphere