web analytics
The Standard
Advertising

Key: Vietnam War was “right thing to do”

Written By: - Date published: 11:12 am, May 29th, 2008 - 113 comments
Categories: election 2008, john key - Tags: ,

Yesterday, the leaders of the parliamentary parties apologised to the veterans of the Vietnam War for the treatment they received both while fighting and on their return home. It was not these soldiers’ fault that their government deployed them in a disastrous and unjust war.

Except, now John Key is saying the war and New Zealand’s involvement weren’t wrong either. Incredibly, Key has said that the Vietnam War was justified and New Zealand’s involvement in it was “the right thing to do“.

This was a war in which over two million of the poorest people on Earth died as a superpower attempted to defend a succession of corrupt military governments.

This war remains America’s greatest military shame. A war that should never have been fought. And they have the wall in DC to remind them, name by name, of the cost.

This was a war that all the Western allies, except Australia and New Zealand, rightly refused to follow the US into. It was a war that New Zealand only, reluctantly, joined after years of US pressure in return for better trade and security assistance.

Vietnam was a mistake. We should never have sent soldiers there and they deserve the apology they received for what they went through because of it. Key has displayed a breath-taking, scary ignorance in defending this indefensible war.

Key wanted us in Iraq (he complained we were ‘missing in action’), he is happy he were in Vietnam. Now, there is the possibility (advocated by Senator McCain ) of the US attacking Iran. Would Key lead us into that war too, given the chance?

113 comments on “Key: Vietnam War was “right thing to do””

  1. Steve – how about a bit of context, rather than Key-bashing. I’ve followed the link to Newstalk ZB, and this is the relevant paragraph:

    “Miss Clark, who was a young anti-Vietnam War protester at the time of the war, stands by her vehement opposition to it, but the National Party’s leader says he was too young to take a serious view. John Key says the National Government at the time determined that being involved in the war was the right thing to do.”

    You are drawing a very long bow here with your headline, rather like the Dom-Post sub-editor I have just blogged about:

    http://keepingstock.blogspot.com/2008/05/misleading-headline.html

  2. gobsmacked 2

    Inventory2, you missed out the following line:

    “He says the conflict came at a time when New Zealand had a strong attachment to the ANZUS alliance, so given the circumstances it was probably the appropriate thing to do.”

  3. gobsmacked: At the very least, this demonstrates Key either hasn’t thought about the great moral issues NZ has faced in the recent past, or he doesn’t want to commit publicly to a view. Either way, voters have a right to know whether or not Key and National would whore the lives of loyal Kiwi soldiers for a better trade deal. This isn’t a trivial issue at all. The current government has had to face it more than once over the past few years.

    We already know beyond doubt that National front benchers, Simon Power and Wayne Mapp, would send Kiwis to die for an FTA with the US. They made that clear in 2003 when they criticised Labour for not joining the invasion of Iraq because of the effect it would have on a possible FTA.

  4. Inv2. My headline says what Key is reported to have said. Key thought Vietnam was a war worth fighting, my posts says so.

    Hardly a long bow

  5. gobsmacked 5

    Steve W, I agree. It’s his indifference to history that is the running theme in his views on international affairs. His line that “the past” is not worth discussing is truly scary from a possible PM.

  6. Inventory, Not quite so long a bow. The next sentence in the original story, which you omit, quotes Key some more:

    “He says the conflict came at a time when New Zealand had a strong attachment to the ANZUS alliance, so given the circumstances it was probably the appropriate thing to do. Mr Key says he does not think it is helpful to relitigate events which took place a long time ago.”

    In context, I think that Key does mean that involvement was the right thing to do.

    Of course he’s wrong. Subsequenetly, records of the time have shown that the main motivation for involvement was the then Governemnt’s desire to keep in the US’s good books, so as not to jeopardise our trade. To be fair, Holyoake kept NZ’s involvement to the minimum, unlike our gung-ho neighbours.

    No wonder Key doesn’t want to relitigate this.

    Weird captcha Dautieng flying

  7. Lew 7

    This is a point of differentiation and a dog whistle. By this statement Key is making the following three points:

    1. He is of a different generation than Clark, Goff, etc.

    2. He disagrees with them on this significant issue of moral and national identity.

    3. He is not afraid to speak out against the current orthodoxy.

    The subtext of all of this is `Key supports the veterans’. This places him in direct opposition to Clark-led Labour, who disbanded the RNZAF strike wing and refused to commit troops to Iraq, and persists in supporting peacekeeping and police operations such as those in Afghanistan, Timor Leste and RAMSI in the Solomons. The dog whistle could potentially lead into debate about closer defence ties with Australia, whose realist IR posture and views more closely align with National’s.

    L

  8. gobsmacked 8

    You’re giving him far too much credit, Lew. He doesn’t think that deeply.

    Key-think: “Vietnam war … Hmm, never thought about it … a National government at the time … better not criticise”.

    That’s the depth of his understanding. He doesn’t read history books. He said so himself. Seriously.

  9. rjs131 9

    Whats wrong with at the time, fighting the spread of communism? Are you saying that things were great for all those communist citizens at the time, or is there something i dont know about life under mao in china, life under kim il-sung, life in the soviet union and eastern europe during the 50s and 60s which meant we should have led the peace loving communists come to power. I think the american military leaders at the time were quite justified in wanting to prevent the spread of communism

  10. higherstandard 10

    Lew

    Thankyou for a considered and rational response.

    Clinton get off your soap box for five minutes – what really matters is that the veterans of this conflict have finally been given the recognition they deserve if you’d bother to listen to the various speeches in parliament you might have noticed that some of the leaders spoke very well (Clark and Key) while others used it as a political soapbox to expouse their own views

  11. rjs131. Are you saying the Vietnam war was worth fighting? 2 million Vietnamese, 50,000 Americans, 37 kiwis, dead, three countries devastated, and all to not achieve the objective NZ and the US fought for, and objective that was always unachievable. you’re saying that was worthwhile?

  12. gobsmacked 12

    RJS131

    They did it (in the famous phrase) “in the wrong way, in the wrong place, at the wrong time”. But at least you have bothered to form a view on the Vietnam war, which puts you above John Key in my estimation.

  13. Matthew Pilott 13

    Lew – I’d read that as political opportunism – he genuinely doesn’t give a flying toss about issues such as Vietman and the Aparthied era, so he’s figuring out how he can make political mileage from his apathy and ignorance.

    I’m also somewhat unsure of your theorised subtext, “Key supports the veterans”. Would a Vietnam vet feel negatively towards someone who opposed the war? I doubt many had a good time over there, but that is of course over-simplifying it.

    Still, I don’t think it’s as clear-cut as you say. Someone could equally think “Vietnam was a disaster, Key doesn’t respect vets because he’d do it all over again”. Given the Agent Orange factor I’d think that’s more likely, but I wasn’t there so I can’t assume so…

  14. HS. I’m not talking about the apology, I acknowldege it’s good. What I’m worried about it the possiblity of the deployment of our military being in the hands of a man who wanted us in Iraq and is happy we were in Vietnam.

    Doesn’t that worry you? because it scares the sh*t out of me.

  15. mike 15

    Steve, your selective quoting in the post heading is inflammatory,

    “Mr Key says he does not think it is helpful to relitigate events which took place a long time ago.”

    Couldn’t agree more – apology given – good – move on

  16. gobsmacked 16

    That “pingback” (Inquiring Mind) is hilarious – John Key was too young, so naturally he has no opinion!

    Hitler may have been a bloody good bloke, I don’t know, I wasn’t born.

  17. Lew 17

    gobsmacked: I’m not sure this is Key’s own deeply-held opinion; in fact, he has steadfastly refused to give a personal statement on the matter. This is his position on the matter as National leader. He doesn’t necessarily hold it himself (though I tend to give people the benefit of the doubt and think that he does).

    rjs131: The entire premise of the Viet Nam War was flawed, we realise that now. I think what you’re saying is that they couldn’t see it then. However this ignores the fact that the premise behind the war was a very far cry indeed from the actuality of what happened – from the Gulf of Tonkin Incident to My Lai to Kissinger’s secret carpet-bombing campaign in Laos and Cambodia, it was a bad war with phenomenally bad consequences.

    This is not to cast any aspersions on those who fought it. Just those who led it, though in some cases the Nuremberg Defence remains as hollow as ever.

    L

  18. Billy 18

    “probably the appropriate thing to do” in the context of ANZUS is hardly the blood thirsty boots and all support you are painting it to be, Steve.

  19. higherstandard 19

    SP

    No Steve it doesn’t worry me one bit I am quite comfortable with either National or Labour being in charge of deploying our military …… as I suspect is our military, what would scare the bejesus out of me is the Greens in charge of where to deploy them.

    And in response to your video on McCain try this one

    http://youtube.com/watch?v=F2zx3-0zOPs&feature=related

    I’ll call the US election for you now – McCain will win and he’ll be damn good President.

  20. Lew 20

    Matthew: “I’d read that as political opportunism – he genuinely doesn’t give a flying toss about issues such as Vietman and the Aparthied era, so he’s figuring out how he can make political mileage from his apathy and ignorance.”

    Yes, I agree.

    “Would a Vietnam vet feel negatively towards someone who opposed the war?”

    Viet Nam vets are not the voting bloc Key is targeting here – it’s those who think `supporting the vets’==`supporting military operations’. That is, people who think the Clark government is soft on defence.

    “Still, I don’t think it’s as clear-cut as you say.”

    Fair enough, it’s a complicated business.

    L

  21. gobsmacked 21

    “The premise behind the war was a very far cry indeed from the actuality of what happened – from the Gulf of Tonkin Incident to My Lai to Kissinger’s secret carpet-bombing campaign in Laos and Cambodia, it was a bad war with phenomenally bad consequences.”

    Amen to that, Lew.

    Lunch now, but when I return I will be very disappointed if I don’t see a Santayana quote somewhere in the thread. It’s obligatory in these discussions, folks … ;)

  22. Steve Pierson said “What I’m worried about it the possiblity of the deployment of our military being in the hands of a man who wanted us in Iraq and is happy we were in Vietnam.”

    You’ve got a source for the comment “and is happy we were in Vietnam”? Please oblige!

    [he said is was "appropriate", that means he was happy with the decision. I suggest you get something better to argue with than semantics. SP]

  23. Matthew Pilott 23

    Ok Lew – I guess that means the subtext isn’t specifically “Key supports the veterans”, more like “Key supports the military”.

    On that topic, I feel Clark has been a good leader WRT NZ’s armed forces. The only real gripes are funding – an armed services is the single greatest black hole for funding though (show me an army that’s happy with the level of funding it gets and I’ll show you a country spending 30% of GDP on defence) – and the Air Strike wing. The A-4Ks were operationally worthless and the F-16s may have been a good replacement in their own right, but I think NZ could far better spend such a sum on other areas. Project Protector, for example.

    What I’m getting at here is that I don’t think Key projecting a pro-military sentiment will have a lot of legs.

    I would tend to look upon this with a favourable bias though.

  24. higherstandard 24

    Mat

    I’m pretty certain the largest back hole for funding in NZ is Health, however, I’d be happy to be proven wrong.

  25. TomS 25

    Lew – If National wants to fight an election on Labour’s record on foreign relations, all I can say is bring it on! I don’t know a single person of any political persuasion who think we should have had a bar of the Iraq war, or who still believe in the domino theory, or don’t think Australia is closer to the United States than we would be comfortable with.

    Don’t confuse a woolly warm and fuzzy “support the troops” feeling with a lessening of the overt anti-Americanism and support for internationalism amongst New Zealanders.

  26. Pascal's bookie 26

    There would have been some interesting political problems with the f-16′s as well.

    We got offerred them because of the coup in Pakistan. Pakistan had bought some f-16′s that had not been delivered, and the coup meant the Americans rightly backed out of the deal. They offerred them to us.

    Cue Sept 11 2001 and the Military dictatorship in Pakistan becomes Washington’s BFF with military deals back on the table. Who knows where this would have left us. It’s not open and shut.

  27. Hey guys – don’t really have an opinion on the Vietnam war (but I did watch Rambo 4 the other day – surprisingly good!). I’m just linkwhoring to my latest post (at least I’m honest about it – unlike your mate Bryan):

    http://newzblog.wordpress.com/2008/05/29/stupid-or-crooked/

  28. Lew 28

    Matthew: “I guess that means the subtext isn’t specifically “Key supports the veterans’, more like “Key supports the military’.”

    Yeah, in this context I think the two are intended to mean the same thing.

    “I feel Clark has been a good leader WRT NZ’s armed forces.”

    Yes, I wrote a paper on this at skool the other year, defending her 2000 statement that we exist in an `incredibly benign strategic environment’, and essentially arguing from a liberal internationalist perspective that peacekeeping, police actions and regional security, stability and democracy-building work in the Pacific are what NZ needs to be doing.

    TomS: “I don’t know a single person of any political persuasion who think we should have had a bar of the Iraq war, or who still believe in the domino theory, or don’t think Australia is closer to the United States than we would be comfortable with.”

    The Clark statement above is still widely ridiculed, though, and a lot of people want a stronger (read: more realist) defence posture than Clark has advocated. National is appealing to these sentiments more than those you list above. I think if Goff succeeds her, he will try to claw back some of that ground for Labour.

    L

  29. higherstandard 29

    Tom

    I can’t say there is a lot of overt anti Americanism in my neck of the woods.

    Certainly derision about the current President but not Anti USA

  30. Matthew Pilott 30

    HS – I was talking in worldwide terms (and I’d have you there, global arms expenditure is HUGE), but the frames of reference are a bit loose – you could theoretically pour untold billions into both and not see the water-line.

    Globally defence would have it, but domestically i’d give it to health.

    Pascal’s bookie – hadn’t though of that, but from memory we were offered them in ’96? might have been a done deal by then. And now we’d have a modern(ish) air strike wing. And for what?

  31. Felix 31

    gob, thanks for pointing to that pingback.

    They refer to Mr Key as a “21st Century politician”, supposedly in contrast to the current government.
    I suppose in a sense he is very much a 21st Century person as he has no thoughts, memories or opinions about anything that happened in the 20th.

    captcha: at troops

  32. Pascal's bookie 32

    “And now we’d have a modern(ish) air strike wing. And for what?”

    Fly overs and airshows I suspect. (sorry, couldn’t resist)

    The problem with the strike wing is that it cost a lot of money and saw very little use. If we had of needed it to defend invasion, (highly unlikely given that the only country with enough force projection to invade us is the US), it couldn’t help.

    In any other theatre that NZ forces are likely to be in need of air strike capability we will be there as part of an alliance.

    How often has Australia used their fancy jets outside of airshows?

  33. Matt – I’m pretty sure those f-16s were we offered were ex-National Guard F16As, already 15 years old, they’ld be 25 years old now. So, not even modern, let alone useful.

  34. rjs131 34

    Any war is crap………..i personally think that fighting the spread of communism was a noble objective. If their aim was to deprive the Vietnamese of the living conditions that other communist people suffered at the time then i think that is worthwhile.

    While the devastation reaped on the people and the countryside was horrific, it must be remember (rightly or wrongly) that this was an intervention in a civil war. Tens of thousands died before and after the americans intervened. To liable every death in that country at the foot of america is a little inaccurate

  35. higherstandard 35

    mp

    Worldwide agreed no contest.

  36. yeah, well, they deprived 2 million people of living conditions pretty conclusively.

    captcha: ‘of servicemen’ this thing is incredible

  37. Lew 37

    RJS131: “To liable every death in that country at the foot of america is a little inaccurate”

    This statement is strictly true, but its implication (that the US weren’t directly to blame for the majority of evil in Viet Nam) is utter bullshit.

    L

  38. Matthew Pilott 38

    Felix – good call…

    Everyone – I brought up the F-16s as an example of the discontent people may feel towards Clark and her policy viz-a-viz defence. All good points, but I can guarantee there are people out there who are bitter about it.

    I never said it was rational!

  39. TomS 39

    I am sick and tired of the A-4′s being continually raised as an issue by right wing half-wits. By constantly mentioning the A-4′s all they show is they are blockheads incapable of following a rational argument.

    The A-4 force consumed a disproportionate amount of the defence budget in fuel, parts, wages and maintenance. Even with the money spent on them the airframe was basically obsolete, with OK 1980′s era avionics. No one in the defence establishment could come up with any sort of realistic scenario in which the A-4 force might be used. Any “hot war” mission involving our allies in a place like Afghanistan could be done better with more modern equipment by the United States, and the RNZAF’s A-4′s would frankly simply provide an easier target than the jets of the USAF. In peacekeeping and disaster relief the strike wing was a complete waste of money. The F-16′s were unaffordable from an operating costs point of view and were of a model (F-16A Block 15) that had avionics no better than those of the Kahu Skyhawks. The reality of the RNZAF strike wing was it was retained as our contribution to an Empire Air Training Scheme in the event of WW III and was a classic example of having armed forces ready to re-fight the last war. Further, practically nothing was spent on upgrading the military from the time of the first oil shock in 1973 until Labour came to power in 1999 – a quarter of a century. Labour on coming to power in 1999 had an underpaid and run down military facing block obsolescence, huge calls on the public purse after a near decade of incompetent management of infrastructure by a do nothing National administration and a public with no appetitive for massive increases in defence spending when no one could produce a realistic threat scenario. So Labour looked at who did what in the military and drew the obvious conclusion – the army followed by the Navy followed by the airlift component did all the useful work that helped meet our foreign policy objectives and international obligations. Under Labour, the army has received new soft vehicles (Pinzgauers), new armoured vehicles (LAV’s), new anti-armour (Javelin) and anti-aircraft (Mistral) missiles and the defence force has had significant pay rises. Defence spending has risen in real terms, and the money has been spent wisely and realistically.

    So to all you right wingers who bang on about the strike wing, just fuck off and die, you ignorant pricks.

  40. erikter 40

    Yes, it was the right thing to do.

    Fighting against communism is always a good cause, regardless of the prevalent anti-American bias and selective quoting of some bloggers around here.

  41. F E Smith 41

    I’ve always thought that the Spanish-American war was America’s greatest military shame. Far less justification for that than Vietnam ever had..

    Or probably worse, if you are willing to include it, was the military support and then legitimisation of the coup d’etat in Hawaii in 1893.

  42. Nicaragua anyone?

  43. Pascal's bookie 43

    “Fighting against communism is always a good cause”

    Objectively pro-Hitler!

  44. Tane 44

    The backing of the fascist coup in Chile, while not technically an invasion, was hardly the United States’ finest hour.

  45. TomS. Great informative comment. Not sure about the ending.

    F E Smith, ‘sod. That looks like it could be quite a long game. I would contend that, at least, Vietnam is the war Americans are most ashamed of.

    erikter. 2 million lives and they didn’t stop Vietnam going communist.

  46. erikter 46

    “The problem with the strike wing is that it cost a lot of money and saw very little use.”

    Impeccably said, Pascal’s. Or are you a reincarnation of Neville Chamberlain?

    Why do you bother with any sort of insurance then?

  47. Tim 47

    Rjs131 and Erikter – Are you saying millions of people should die because you’re afraid of communism?

    Franco and Hitler fought against communism. Does that make them nice guys or make their wars justified? What about the CIA’s support of repressive right wing regimes in South America like Pinochet in Chile? What about McCarthyism which led to the persecution of thousands of law-abiding citizens because of the spectre of “communism”?

    The fact is the Soviet Union, China and North Korea were and are not communist (or socialist) countries. They are actually countries ruled by an elite cabal with no interest in the working class whatsoever. This is certainly not Marxism and it betrays your ignorance of what Marxism and communism is.

    I guess with your worldview anything (including supporting corrupt anti-communist regimes or killing innocent people) is justifiable if it’s done to fight communism. Never mind that some people might actually choose a communist political system instead of being exploited by imperialism.

  48. higherstandard 48

    Rather a lot of Anti US sentiment on this thread

  49. Matthew Pilott 49

    erikter, have you got insurance against The Rapture, or Alien Abduction. Both exist you know, I can probably point you in the right direction if need be.

    I can only conclude from your argument that New Zealand should get nukes, anthrax and VX as well – I mean if you’re going to look at defence with all the context a three year-old could throw at it, then that’s the stupid result you get.

    Really, HS? I didn’t think so, being critical of US history doesn’t necessarily translate. It could easily be much worse, I’ll say that…

  50. Tane 50

    Rather a lot of Anti US sentiment on this thread

    More anti-invading-countries-and-killing-people sentiment to be fair HS. I’ve no gripe with the American people.

  51. erikter 51

    Tim, you may be an unabashed communist, but do not expect the rest of us to follow suit.

    Marx was wrong in his analysis of the way people can organise to successfully create value. To Marx, ownership of the means of production was the main fixture in a society’s ability to produce wealth and justice.

    The right to all property in a Marxist society was to rest with the state, in trust for the people.

    Marx also argued for the collectivisation of the division of labour. All working together for a common goal would be far more productive than markets collating the disparate choices of individuals.

    Do human beings optimise their potential in a collectivised society? Does it work as proposed?

    The final arbiter is reality.

    Marx’s economic model in practice, the USSR and elsewhere, COULD NOT produce wealth or justice. The rationale for collective ownership failed.

  52. erikter. Should I buy flood insurance if I live on a hill?

  53. TomS 53

    Steve Pierson:

    I’m sorry, but you get this strike wing argument all the time, you tell these dunderheads, they look at you, blink, you can see the cogs turning, and then they just repeat the same bumper sticker. I suppose arguing with a right winger is like dealing with Auckland’s traffic – if you let it get to you you just end up with road rage, but every now and again you have to vent!!!!

  54. higherstandard 54

    MP and Tane

    That the US fought a cold and sometimes hot war against communism in all its various guises is something I for one am very thankful for.

    If people like Tim want to live under a communist system they’re welcome to it but I’ll take the US despite all its bad points over the alternatives of the Soviet Union and Mao’s China any day.

  55. Pascal's bookie 55

    “The final arbiter is reality.”

    So Vietnam was a fnckup then?

  56. Tane 56

    I’ll take the US despite all its bad points over the alternatives of the Soviet Union and Mao’s China any day.

    HS, I’d suggest you do a bit of research. Have a read about the death squads in Chile and the systematic raping of nuns and murder of priests in Central America. You might get a bit more perspective.

    It’s not a case of whether you get to live in the US or in the Soviet Union – that’s an obvious choice. It’s about whether you get bombed and your family killed because some guy at the top in the US thinks your country’s a little red for his liking.

  57. erikter 57

    “It’s about whether you get bombed and your family killed because some guy at the top in the US thinks your country’s a little red for his liking.”

    What about the counter-argument, Tane?

    It’s about whether your country get invaded and you and your family killed because some guys at the top in the USSR Politburo think your country’s a little liberal for their liking.

    People in Poland, Hungary, Latvia, Estonia, Lithuania, Ukrania, Afghanistan, Finland, amongst others experienced just that.

  58. Tane 58

    erikter, why do you assume I support Soviet imperialism any more than I support American imperialism?

  59. Draco TB 59

    The history of the US is filled with shameful military interventionism. The land of the free doesn’t like other countries choosing a different path to them and that don’t do as they’re told.

    This thread seems to have wandered off topic.

  60. gobsmacked 60

    Well, I’m strongly pro-American myself.

    The essential requirement for wars like Iraq and Vietnam is that the American people are lied to. Eventually the truth comes out (not least because of the American constitution and the determination of free citizens to challenge its government) and the people learn the truth. Then they oppose the war, as they do now, by a huge margin. The protestors are the patriots.

    As for NZ, Helen Clark has led the country for the entire length of the Bush Administration, not Key/Brash/English etc. That’s something to be very, very thankful for. (Compare: Howard, Blair, many other client states at war, and their angry populations. They envy us).

  61. TomS 61

    erikter – perhaps you ought to study a little history. Whether we like or not, the USSR was given a free hand in Eastern Europe as a result of the November 1943 conference in Tehran. Its setting up of puppet regimes in the territories it over-ran in 1944-45 was done so with the tacit agreement of the USA and UK. Apart from that, Finland’s winter war in 1939-40 and the invasion of Afghanistan in 1979 are the ONLY two occassion where the USSR actually invaded another sovereign nation. Whatever your views of the Soviet Union, it always adhered to a vague legalism and the USSR never embarked on the sort of reckless global adventurism the United States has indulged in. Just off the top of my head, Grenada, Panama, Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan, Cambodia and Laos are all countries that the United States has invaded (Korea was a U.N. action).

  62. Tim 62

    I support peoples’ rights to choose which political system they want. If they want to be socialist, they should be able to do so without being invaded by the US Government. This has nothing to with an anti-US posture. The Vietnam War destroyed the lives of plenty of Americans conscripted to fight and die in a war they didn’t want or believe in which was waged by fools in the White House.

    If a country decides it wants to be socialist, it shouldn’t be invaded because of that. The whole “war was justified because it stopped communism” argument is bogus.

    The whole “USSR and China are communist = bad” argument is also bogus, look at the legions of failed capitalist states in the world today eg. Niger, Chad etc. It’s a simplistic and unjustified comparison in my view. Of course I don’t want to live in the USSR and China, but they’re not really socialist or communist states in the true sense of the word.

  63. Billy 63

    “The whole “USSR and China are communist = bad’ argument is also bogus”

    How so? Isn’t the murder of tens of millions of innocent people usually regarded as a bad thing?

    Yup. I’ve thought about it and I’m going with bad.

  64. Lew 64

    Tim: “If they want to be socialist”

    Very naive. The problem is typically that people want it in theory, but they end up not wanting it in practice. And there’s the secondary issue that socialist nations have had expansionistic tendencies. The domino effect is seen as mostly bogus now, but in the context of the Cold War it wasn’t so clear.

    “The whole “USSR and China are communist = bad’ argument is also bogus”

    I’ve got one question for you, Tim: have you read The Gulag Archipelago?

    I don’t consider people qualified to comment on communism (or any form of socialism) unless they’ve read The Gulag Archipelago. If you’re going defend something, know what it is you’re defending.

    L

    PS: I’m not interested in hearing the `communism doesn’t necessarily require totalitarianism’ line. It does, temporarily, and so far in history proto-communist states have singularly failed to progress beyond that stage. They are run by people, after all.

    Captcha: `suffering Shirley’. Don’t call me Shirley, tovarisch.

  65. Katipunan 65

    Rather than apologising to Vietnam veterans on behalf of the nation, Helen Clark should apologise personally to the vets, the people of Vietnam, and the people of Cambodia for her prominent involvement in the so-called “peace’ movement, a treasonous hate group founded, funded and directed from Moscow.

    North Vietnamese General Giap has extensively described in post-war memoirs and interviews the step-by-step defeat of US forces, not on the battlefield, but in the streets of America and its allies.

    A relative handful of dedicated Communists mobilised thousands of those whom Lenin once termed “useful idiots’ (like many of you pinkos posting on this thread) to influence public opinion against the US, thus aiding and abetting North Vietnamese Communism’s quest to crush South Vietnam’s independence.

    After the US pulled out in 1975, the Vietcong murdered millions of South Vietnamese. Hundreds of thousands of others made a perilous journey to freedom in small boats.

    Pol Pot’s Communist Khmer Rouge regime came to power in Cambodia and was responsible for almost two million deaths (or one third of the country’s population) through execution, starvation and forced labour.

    Clark and her radical lefist student mates throwing bags of human excrement, spitting, and screaming “baby killer’ at returning Vietnam soldiers owe everyone an apology: for being on the wrong side of history.

  66. Tim 66

    Billy: You clearly haven’t actually read what I’m saying so I won’t bother to respond. Read my posts again including the one at 1.28pm.

    Lew: Yep, I’m very familiar with Solzhenitsyn, although I prefer One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich.

    I don’t see how Stalinist atrocities have any relevance to a pro-socialist argument. Marx never said you needed to enslave and kill, his philosophy was the opposite and conceived as an alternative to the exploitation of capitalism.

    Why shouldn’t people be able to determine their own future without interference from imperialism? There is a history of the US and the CIA backing coups to overthrow democratically elected leaders who might be “communist” (eg Jacobo Arbenz in Guatemala in 1954). Sorry, who’s “expansionist”?

  67. Billy 67

    Well, I suppose we should have guessed you’d come back with a “they weren’t real communists” argument. Got an example of one of these “real” communist states in the real world, Timmy?

  68. Katipunan 68

    Tim says: “Of course I don’t want to live in the USSR and China, but they’re not really socialist or communist states in the true sense of the word.”

    Communism everywhere it has been tried has a record of failure so dismal that only an idiot or an academic could continue to deny it.

    Oh, I get it, Communism led to almost a century of state-sponsored mass murder and economic misery because of the perversion of a noble ideal, and because the right people have never been in charge.

    Wasn’t it Marx who said: “The bourgeousie as a class must be made impossible”? Lenin who said: “We’ll ask the man where he stands on the question of revolution. If he’s against it we’ll stand him up against a wall”? Stalin who said “A single death is a tragedy. A million deaths is a statistic”?

    Communists regard certain social classes as “diseased.” Some can be cured with a “tenner” in a labour camp discovering the virtue of labouring without reward for the benefit of others, but the vast majority are too wedded to private property rights, individual freedom, the rule of law, freedom of speech etc.

    These must be exterminated lest they infect others and retard the emergence of “the New Soviet Man” or whatever you want to call him.

    “The Idea” is dead, long live “The Idea” eh Tim?

    Unregenerate commies like you are an emetic!!!

  69. Tim 69

    Get real Katipunan – the peace movement was comprised of Americans sick of seeing their brothers sent to die for no good reason. Agreed an apology to veterans is in order, but people got sick of seeing young working class and black men being sent to die in someone else’s war.

    Oh, and another thing is that North Vietnam and Pol Pot’s regime were actually at war, but don’t let that little detail get in the way of your tirade. It was Hanoi that actually overthrew Pol Pot capturing Phnom Penh in 1979, the USA just dropped more bomb tonnage than in WWII on Cambodia, mostly on civilians.

    What, and capitalism works? Millions of people are starving while others are throwing out food. Great system.

  70. Katipunan 70

    Tim said: “Why shouldn’t people be able to determine their own future without interference from imperialism??

    The actual “imperialism” was all that of Sino-Soviet Communism who saw their role as winning a world for Communism.

    The so-called “peace” movement, throughout the Western world, was always a treasonous hate group founded, funded and directed from Moscow.

    As Dimitri Manuilsky stated in a lecture to the Lenin School on Political Warfare in Moscow 1931:

    “Today, of course, we are not strong enough to attack … To win we shall need the element of surprise. The bourgeoisie will have to be put to sleep. So we shall begin by launching the most spectacular peace movement on record. There will be electrifying overtures and unheard of concessions. The capitalist countries, stupid and decadent, will rejoice to cooperate in their own destruction. They will jump at another chance to be friends. As soon as their guard is down, we shall smash them with our clenched fist.’

    Communists are expert at creating “Popular Fronts’ whose apparent purpose attracts the support of the gullible and well meaning, while covertly advancing the Communist agenda.

    This enables a relative handful of Communists to multiply their effectiveness many times, while sitting back and laughing while those whom Lenin once referred to as “useful idiots’ do their dirty work for them.

    The essential goal of a Communist Front is always hidden behind an ostensible purpose of wide popular appeal. Its Communist puppeteers are well aware of the true agenda, while most of the Front members see only the smokescreen.

    A permanent Communist objective was always to tilt the balance of world military power in favor of Communist military strength. Wherever possible, they created a dialectical conflict between “warmongers’ and “peaceniks’ to achieve this purpose.

    However, to loudly proclaim the real objective of weakening militarily all those countries opposed to Communism would recruit few supporters in those countries. The “peace” movement therefore needed an announced objective that would accomplish the same purpose, but present itself in a totally different guise.

    The ostensible purpose of the “peace’ movement therefore became the preservation of peace in the face of the possible horrors of a nuclear war. Its Communist directors described the demands for disarmament which were to be made to Communist and non-Communist countries alike.

    They failed to point out that these demands would have no effect in the Communist Bloc because there was no public opinion there that they could influence: the people of the Communist countries couldn’t even find out about these demands unless the Communist Party decided to tell them.

    The hidden purpose of the “peace’ movement was to influence public opinion in free countries whose governments were elected and controlled by the people. The “useful idiots,’ satisfied when these demands are nominally extended to all countries, were sold on this magnificent idea and enlisted in the cause.

    The ultimate goal of those directing the “peace’ movement was always to leave the Soviet Union as the world’s only nuclear power. After all, if one side has all the nukes, they can simply go to the other side with the proposition: “Surrender or die!’

    To apply a local example, all talk of the Pacific Ocean being a “US Nuclear Lake’ failed to point out that the Soviet Union maintained at Cam Ranh Bay, North Vietnam, a far larger flotilla of nuclear powered and nuclear armed ships than the US Sixth Fleet ever was.

    The “anti-nuclear policy’ that removed NZ from ANZUS was actually a massive triumph for militant Marxist-Leninism, and for our local embedded Commies with the Liarbour Party.

  71. Tane 71

    Christ, every time communism’s mentioned we get another verbose nutter from the right. You’re not Michele Cabiling are you Katipunan?

  72. Lew 72

    Tim: “I prefer One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich.”

    Ivan Denisovich is to Archipelago as MASH is to Apocalypse Now. That’s perhaps a bit frivolous, but a novella just doesn’t have the same impact as that three-volume behemoth. It’s heartening that you’ve read it, but it’s disheartening that despite having read it you still think communism can work.

    “Marx never said you needed to enslave and kill”

    No, indeed he didn’t. He advocated the temporary concentration of power in a few individuals. That’s what caused the dictatorships: it wasn’t temporary. People with power don’t like to give it up. I shouldn’t have to provide examples.

    “Sorry, who’s “expansionist’?”

    The Soviet Union explicitly was at the time. China was particularly so toward Viet Nam.

    The US was aggressively anti-communist, but that doesn’t nullify my point.

    L

  73. Oh yeah – that’s michelle all right. How’s the self-improvement going M?

  74. Katipunan 74

    Tane wrote: “Christ, every time communism’s mentioned we get another verbose nutter from the right.”

    Repeat after me: “A label is not an argument … a label is not an argument … a label is not an argument …”

    If you can’t engage on an intellectual level why not shut the hell up?

  75. It’s heartening that you’ve read it, but it’s disheartening that despite having read it you still think communism can work.

    Could you be any more of a condescending co*ksu*ker, lew?

  76. Katipunan 76

    How’s the stroking yourself in a very small corner going, Robinsodomite?

    [Tane: One more homophobic outburst and you're banned for four months.]

  77. Lew 77

    I might not like communism, but I’m sure as hell not buying this PNAC bullshit either.

    L

  78. If you can’t engage on an intellectual level why not shut the hell up?

    Right back at you ‘chelle. Are you still pedaling that 19th century faux-Darwinist tripe?

  79. Lew 79

    Robinsod: Yeah, I think I could have been.

    As I said earlier, I’m sure the condescended masses are glad to have you as their knight in shining armour.

    L

  80. Pretty damn good michelle – how’s that lonely, lonely life of misguided belief in your own superiority going? Actually, come to think of it, you and Lew might get on quite well…

  81. Lew – I’m no knight baby. I just got a dislike of your pomposity and some time on my hands. If you’re gonna be all full of yourself at least do it with some flair…

  82. Katipunan 82

    Robinsodomite wrote:

    “Could you be any more of a condescending co*ksu*ker, lew?”

    You couldn’t have summed yourself up better in a single sentence, could you?

    [Tane: And that's Michele banned for four months. That was quick. See you in September Michele.]

    [lprent: Fast, efficent, and not here.... I was just coming in to see what the fuss was.]

  83. Katipunan 83

    Also, your avatar, if it purports to describe you, shows the wrong end of the horse.

  84. Tim 84

    Whoa, whoa, whoa. Let’s get back to the point. I was originally responding to an earlier post trying to say the Vietnam War was justified because it was anti-communist. I don’t think it was, nor do I think any war in purported opposition to communism is justified as a corollary.

    As for John Key, he doesn’t really seem to know where he stood on any important social issue, being the Vietnam War, the Springbok Tour or a nuclear-free Pacific. I’m glad some others did know where they stood and took a stand.

  85. erikter 85

    “Could you be any more of a condescending co*ksu*ker, lew?”

    Tane, you’re trigger-happy banning others

    [T: Not usually, I've just had experience with Michele. She was banned for exactly this last time - she's abusive, verbose and destroys threads. I choose not to have her here]

    , but how can you justify that level of abuse on Robinsond’s part?

    [T: I don't agree with the Sod's behaviour, but his saving grace is he actually adds to the conversation and he's got a sense of humour. He does need to stop having a go at Lew though - that's becoming disruptive]

    One thing is the right to argue the point and come to a civil disagreement (even a heated one), but surely his sentence above is beyond the acceptable norm.

    [T: Again, I don't think you saw her behaviour last time. Go back and have a search under "Michele Cabiling". We ended up giving her four months off after a lot of warnings, and she showed back up here and started exhibiting exactly the same behaviour patterns. I'm in no mood to give her the benefit of the doubt]

    Micky Porton is a disgrace to this blog.

    [lprent: Michele is far more unique than the 'sod. For a starter he doesn't paste copied rants. Robinsod merely pushes the line, so gets tolerated. Michele on the other hand just pisses me off, especially her refusal to learn how to link. Tane only just beat me to it]

  86. Also, your avatar, if it purports to describe you, shows the wrong end of the horse.

    No michelle – if you were the clever bugger you think you are you would recognise my avatar and get the joke. But alas you are not quite the great mind you consider yourself to be.

    Tane – Please don’t ban michele. She may be as mad as a cut snake but at least she has some fire in her belly and some opinions (albeit crazy ones) – otherwise I’ve got nobody but Lew-the-bore to tease.

    eriktar – good to see you are concerned about the level of debate on this blog. I suggest if you really want to improve it you take your bigoted bumper-sticker arguments back to the bog where they belong.

  87. Lew 87

    Tim: Yeah, drifted away a bit, there.

    erikter: FWIW I don’t take such things personally, particularly not from Sod, who seems to have launched a somewhat endearing crusade against my vapid pomposity.

    L

  88. Damn! you banned her. Well michele – if you want a good old bit of biffo you are more than welcome at newzblog.

    Lew – at least you can laugh at yourself. If you find self deprecation too tiring then let me know and we can laugh at you in shifts for a while…

    [Tane: It'll probably double your readership Sod. By the way, lay off Lew okay? Critique the ideas, not the person]

  89. Do mean my readership at http://www.newzblog.wordpress.com (the best site on the web!)?

    I haven’t check the stats for http://www.newzblog.wordpress.com lately but I would imagine that plenty of people visit http://www.newzblog.wordpress.com for its witty and concise take on the modern world.

    In fact Tane – you would be more than welcome to drop in at http://www.newzblog.wordpress.com some time.

    Oh and I’ll lay off lew because I don’t need to get banned again but if he ever feels like a robust chat he just needs to visit http://www.newzblog.wordpress.com

    [lprent: I could just make some URL's to go straight into moderation. Or possibly write some code to automatically make certain URI's auto link to the wikipedia article on link whoring. I was wondering what to do on Monday morning. I've been meaning to try out the filters in wordpress]

  90. higherstandard 90

    Sod

    I just had a look at your site – it is marginally better than

    http://capitalismbad.blogspot.com/

  91. r0b 91

    “Link whoring” always was an unpleasant phrase. It has now been rendered totally inadequate as well.

    So what was that – a link blitzkrieg? Link warfare? A linkademic? Linkbotting?

    Whatever, I think I’ll go visit ‘Sod’s site at http://www.newzblog.wordpress.com

  92. RedLogix 92

    I’ve no problem with banning Michele, but if you are not reasonably even-handed about it, you’ll fall into the trap that Farrar set for himself. His banning policy is openly and cheerfully biased against left-wing posters, but this has only encouraged the rwnj sub-culture/scum that flourishes under his blog’s refrigerator.

    ‘Sod dearest… are you trying to see how many warnings you can accumulate before they add up to a red card?

    [Tane: Red, I am aware of that and I genuinely don't want to ban anyone. My concern is with behaviour that disrupts the threads, leads to flamewars or is overly racist, sexist or homophobic. Michele has a history of doing this - it's why she was banned last time. Her dreadful homophobia is present in nearly every comment she writes. She had a second chance, I warned her to stop the homophobic remarks, she did it again, I banned her.]

  93. QoT 93

    I’m one smeg of a lot younger than John Key, and I sure as hell have strong opinions on things that happened before I was born, even.

    Still, a population ignorant of history has to be a heck of a lot easier to sell outdated illogical National and ACT policy to.

  94. The tragedy of Vietnam is that ALL powers used it as a proxy war, there was significant Soviet and Chinese involvement in Vietnam too, but I don’t believe their embassies had people protesting outside saying “get out of Vietnam”. Nevertheless, the US made a huge strategic error in not siding with the anti-colonial Ho Chi Minh, which drove him into the hands of Moscow. Vietnam suffered from war, but also the communists – nobody can pretend that it was liberated, or that the end result was good at all (or the “choice of the Vietnamese people”). The communist north twice promised free democratic elections (as did the south) and it never happened – by no measure was the north better than the south.

    It threw hundreds of thousands into prison camps after the war, 2 million fled the country of whom hundreds of thousands died on the way (boat people) and there were peasant revolts against so called “land reform” that were suppressed brutally. Vietnam still throws people in prison for political activities, there is no free press or right to protest.

    The war in Vietnam was wrong in many ways, but its objective of stopping the whole country going communist was right. Tragically the lot in the south were next to useless, corrupt and cruel. However, nobody should pretend those in the north were or are noble.

    The Lon Nol puppet regime in Cambodia, after all, was corrupt and cruel, but nothing compared to the Khmer Rouge – but by the time that war was being fought the West was withdrawing, tragically. Defending the Lon Nol regime would have been moral, but few paid attention to the horror stories of the Cambodian hinterland in places where the Khmer Rouge were running things.

    We have great wisdom of hindsight nowadays on all these events, the ongoing litany of mistakes, the cruelty of the Western side (though we’ll never know half of the north Vietnamese side’s cruelty) and say what should and shouldn’t have been done – it was the Cold War, and the fight against global Marxism-Leninism was moral. Sadly the concentration on this didn’t mean, in some cases, fighting for freedom and liberal democracy – it meant backing the enemy of our enemies, and in far too many cases they weren’t much better than the enemy.

  95. Luke C 95

    Anyone else hear Key on bfm this morning? Saying again that the Nats supported the right of the ‘Coalition of the Willing’ to go to Iraq.

    He also said that he still believed Bush and Blair thought that Iraq had WMD’s and supported terrorism. This shows how amazingly naive Key is in terms of foreign policy. All evidence coming out suggests Bush deliberately mislead the public. The more people that hear Keys comments the better.

  96. Lew 96

    Luke C: “the Nats supported the right of the ‘Coalition of the Willing’ to go to Iraq.”

    This isn’t as extreme a position as you make out; after all, international affairs is a normative field, and the primary actors in this case (US and UK) are the two pre-eminent norm-leaders in that field. If anyone believes they had no right to take the action under international law and convention, their recourse is to NGOs including the International Court of Justice. Until someone does so, then in strict legal terms they did not act illegally – even if there is a prima facie case to answer under international law, as there seems to be here.

    If Key had supported the moral authority of the Coalition to take that action, that would have been a less defensible statement, since `moral authority’ is a more malleable concept than `right’. I think it’s clear that the US and UK lacked moral authority to invade Iraq, and like others before them, they’ll be judged on this by history.

    L

  97. Luke – Iraq did have WMDs, it used them on several occasions. It didn’t allow full inspections as required by umpteen UN Security Council resolutions. The fact that the Hussein thugocracy destroyed/dismantled it is another point, but nobody can pretend Iraq didn’t have WMDs. That’s a fact. It’s a fact it supported terrorism, it cheered on 9/11. It wasn’t allied to Al Qaeda, that was a complete fabrication, but it has long been allied to other terrorist groups.

    You can oppose the overthrow of the Hussein regime, fine, but let’s not pretend Iraq was some innocent peaceful party. This thread isn’t about Iraq, but there is a legitimate debate about whether invading Iraq was the right thing to do – but you can’t pretend it wasn’t run by a dangerous megalomaniac mass murderer. Though I fully expect someone will divert this onto “Bush is the same” hyperbole, which is as tiresome as it is intellectually vapid.

  98. Lew 98

    Drifting off-topic again here, ah well.

    libertyscott: The question is whether those rationales (previous atrocities, previous possession of WMDs, failure to comply, supporting terrorism, and cheering on 9/11) justify invasion led by the USA.

    You can argue that they justified invasion by someone but I think the US and UK would be very far down that list; certainly the customary test for intervention under international law (UNSC resolution) was not met.

    L

  99. RedLogix 99

    Iraq did have WMDs, it used them on several occasions. It didn?t allow full inspections as required by umpteen UN Security Council resolutions.

    Iraq had a PROGRAM to consider ways to make nuclear WMD’s. At no time did they ever actual possess or even so much as test one. Nor did they ever possess any effective delivery system against a properly defended power.

    The chemical WMD systems always were a much lessor threat. They were basically only of limited use against undefended civilians.

    ANY evidence whatsoever that Hussein cheered on 911? Like what this guy said?

    but you can?t pretend it wasn?t run by a dangerous megalomaniac mass murderer.

    Well in historic terms Hussein was pretty much your run of the mill Middle Eastern strongman. For the average Iraqi, life under the socialist Baath Party rule was reasonably ok. Iraq had an excellent education system, more doctors per head of capita than most other countries, working infrastructure in most cities and a decent economy. Hussein was actually quite popular with many average Iraqi’s for this reasons.

    And yes Hussein also maintained political stability by murdering his opponents. Dangerous, yes. Meglomaniac, maybe… but for actual numbers of deaths he was very amateur mass murderer compared to the 100′s of thousands, possibly millions of Iraqi’s who have died either directly or indirectly as a result of Western intervention in that nation’s affairs.

  100. Dean 100

    “he said is was “appropriate”, that means he was happy with the decision. I suggest you get something better to argue with than semantics. SP”

    Well, Steve, I guess that about wraps it up for any chace of you being considered objective or brimming with facts when you make your analysis.

    You’re like some sort of self professed left wing mirror image of whale oil.

  101. gobsmacked: I wonder if Key could be described as uncurious? I don’t know. It’s a genuine question. If so, it would be very Bush-like (according to Scott McClellan and others)

    We can see clearly enough where that leads to. NZ doesn’t need to go there.

  102. libertyscott: Why fudge on the timing? The timing of Iraq’s “WMD” is relevant to the case for war. Iraq had not ad any WMD since 1998. Until Bush decided to invade the place, the only serious discussions through 2000 and into early 2002 in relation to Iraq were WHEN to lift sanctions….not IF. Bush fabricated the pretext of WMD like he fabricated the rest of his case for war. Remember, to be legal, the threat needed to be serious and imminent. No such threat existed and it was obvious at the time that it did not exist in so far as there was no credible proof of any imminent threat.

    The legal argument hangs, in part, on the UN Charter being a fully ratified treaty by the US Senate. Under the US Constitution it is therefore law and cannot cannot be overridden by any state. It is a part of the United States’ law.

  103. Chemical WMDs were used against Iran, the US didn’t turn a blind eye to this, but it was supporting Iraq (as was the USSR) against Iran at the time.

    RedLogix – All you said about Hussein could be said about Pinochet too. The ends do not justify the means. He murdered hundreds of thousands of his own people, imprisoned and terrorised many more, and killed thousands in neighbouring states due to his own adventurism in Iran and Kuwait. The “oh but some things were good” argument is like saying “Hitler was popular, he made the trains run on time and built the autobahns”. Don’t forget Hussein’s “amateurish” murders were deliberate – he bombed civilians to terrorise them. Western intervention has been to kick him out of Kuwait, stop him using air power against the Kurds and Shi’a Arabs in the south, and boot him out of power – it wasn’t to engage in genocide as he did. However, play the moral equivalency game if you like, pretend the Iraqi insurgency seeking to (and has already in some places) impose an Islamist totalitarian state, which targets civilians is the same as US forces. The war in Iraq has been waged badly, but defending Hussein, a genocidal maniac is a non-starter.

    Steve – Nobody could verify that there were no WMDs in Iraq in 1998, but if you choose to believe a megalomaniac dictator then fine. North Korea has proven the trustworthiness of that. Iran will do so again. The argument about the legality of war is dependent on respecting state sovereignty – if you believe the genocidal Hussein dictatorship deserves such respect then good for you. I don’t. I believe it lost any such right to such protection in waging two aggressive wars, in repeatedly engaging in genocide and operating a brutal totalitarian nepotistic dictatorship. That doesn’t mean there is an obligation to go around and overthrow such regimes – but the regime had no moral rights whatsoever. Reasons to overthrow Saddam include all of that, the unwillingness to allow inspections of WMD facilities on a transparent and open basis, and the malignant nature of his regime which continued to seek the destruction of Israel.

    There is an argument that the West should have sat back and let the regime continue, let it profit from high oil prices today, breach sanctions and build up WMDs again (who honestly thinks he wouldn’t have tried). Yes in hindsight the regime should have been crushed in 1991, but there was a genuine US effort to maintain a wide ranging coalition then that would have been broken up had that happened. About the only cogent argument against overthrowing Saddam is the financial cost, and the risking of soldiers’ lives in doing so (the planning and tactics are a whole other point after you’ve decided to do the job).

  104. r0b 104

    libertyscott: It didn’t allow full inspections as required by umpteen UN Security Council resolutions.

    Iraq allowed full UN inspections from November 2002. The UN reports stated clearly that no WMDs were found.

    http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article5878.htm

    On March 7, 2003, just a week prior to the U.S. and British led invasion of Iraq, the U.N. Security Council received testimony from the heads of the nuclear, chemical and biological weapons inspectors concerning any weapons of mass destruction possessed by Iraq. Their testimony represented the unanimous conclusion of over 100 U.N. weapons inspectors who were on site in Iraq for four months just prior to the invasion beginning in November, 2002. Unlike the Bush and Blair administrations, these inspectors, who were from all over the world, had had no vested interest in invading Iraq. They publicly refuted every charge that Secretary of State, Colin Powell, made about chemical and biological weapons could not be substantiated.

    The timeline of all this is explained in detail here:
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iraq_and_weapons_of_mass_destruction

  105. Dean 105

    oh r0b.

    From your own linked wikipedia page:

    “On October 3, 2003, the world digests David Kay’s Iraq Survey Group report that finds no stockpiles of WMD in Iraq, although it states the government intended to develop more weapons with additional capabilities. Weapons inspectors in Iraq do find some “biological laboratories” and a collection of “reference strains”, including a strain of botulinum bacteria, “ought to have been declared to the UN.” Kay testifies that Iraq had not fully complied with UN inspections. In some cases, equipment and materials subject to UN monitoring had been kept hidden from UN inspectors. “So there was a WMD program. It was going ahead. It was rudimentary in many areas”, Kay would say in a later interview.[81] In other cases, Iraq had simply lied to the UN in its weapons programs.[82] The US-sponsored search for WMD had at this point cost $300 million and was projected to cost around $600 million more.”

    Lied to the UN about their programs!

    Equipment kept hidden from inspectors!

    I expect your character asassination of Kay presently.

  106. deemac 106

    can you PLEASE put a word limit on comments!! some of these mad right wing rants take ages to scroll thru. I sure as hell don’t waste my time reading them – they are intended to get us to divert resources from discussing the posts to answering their insane views which is pointless as they don’t take any notice when their positions are comprehensively demolished. The point of blogs like this is debate, not being sidelined into their nutty world views.

    [lprent: Michele (the worst offender today) managed to get banned in almost record time. I'll keep a closer eye on it. It'd be easy enough to impose a limit - I'll write one if there isn't anything available, just to keep it in reserve. Another filter job for monday.]

  107. r0b 107

    Oh Dean

    There was a UN inspections program.

    They didn’t find WMDs.

  108. Paul 108

    Someone pointed out way up at the start that John Key was too young for Vietnam – but he’s the same age as me and I spent my entire teenage years scared of the draft ballot (we were all eligible at 18) – while at the time one had to volunteer to go to Vietnam we all expected that that would/could change any day – it’s a shadow over my teenage years that leaves me unable to join in with the modern ANZAC day fetish – it still reminds me of the RSA who at the time were the first in line wanting to send me off as cannon fodder (good for those young ‘uns character building)

    Honestly Key’s either telling porkies or was entirely disconnected from the world as a youth

    Remember – many years later we found out the only reason Holyoake went into Vietnam was because the US threatened to cut off all trade with NZ if we didn’t – and the Nats folded under the pressure – to keep the farm prices up and kiwis died as a result

  109. Oh brilliant,

    If Key gets elected he will be just in time to lead this country into the next illegal war of aggression. Hi ho,hi ho, it’s of to Iran we go.

    For that new and exiting trade deal with the US. Oh oops thanks to him and his greedy banking mates at the Federal reserve in New York there will be no more USA.

  110. Phil 110

    You seem to be assuming a McCain victory Eve…?

    I cannot help but paraphrase a “West Wing” quote;

    War in Iran? No way. We’re from the National party – we’re stupid, but we’re not THAT stupid.

  111. roger nome 111

    Vietnam was the outcome of erroneous geo-strategic thinking, and as with the Iraq war, faulty intelligence that was elevated to the status of truth by politicians in order to get into a war that was pre-determined by people in the white house.

    Hennery Kissinger (arguably the US’s foremost foreign-policy maker of the cold-war period) concedes the former part now when he admits “we misunderstood the nature of the communist nation state, thinking it was akin to the spread of Hitler’s fascism”. What Kissinger is saying is that the communist block was far less united than Hitler’s fascist block. i.e. China was, in many aspects, in competition with Russia, and many of the soviet satellite states were able to exercise a large degree of autonomy. So the “free world” wasn’t facing a “united communist enemy” as most of the politicians claimed, but was involved in a global system of states with varying degrees of affiliation to the US or Soviet Russia.

    Communism can now be seen as part of a nationalistic “development phase” of the 20th century, which was often a starting place for capital accumulation and infrastructural development, but ultimately unsustainable as a political system because of the desire for higher living standards and political freedom. Communism per see, wasn’t a threat to the US, but the Soviet communist state was. The US’s Vietnam was therefore founded on the erroneous assumption that, “not fighting them there would mean fighting them later at home” (similarities to the “war on terrorism” rhetoric can be found here). Or if we don’t fight them now and stop the spread of communism we’ll end up with a unified enemy that will attempt to defeat us.

    As to the aspect of faulty intelligence being used to justify the pre-determined war: declassified documents show this to be the case.

    As much as anything else, it was an awareness that President Johnson would brook no uncertainty that could undermine his position. Faced with this attitude, Ray Cline was quoted as saying “… we knew it was bum dope that we were getting from Seventh Fleet, but we were told only to give facts with no elaboration on the nature of the evidence. Everyone know how volatile LBJ was. He did not like to deal with uncertainties.

    Page 213:

    http://www.fas.org/irp/nsa/spartans/index.html

  112. roger nome 112

    so in Key was wrong on both Vietnam and Iraq – both wars were based on deception through faulty intelligence, and both were strategic blunders.

  113. Hi roger. I do miss you over at kiwiblog deary.
    Kind regards
    d4j
    xx

Links to post

Important links

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

  • Some thoughts on the mass abuse of children in England
    We're all roughly familiar with the the horrible story of persistent mass abuse of vulnerable teenage girls and the shameful failure by the police and social services to help the victims of the notorious 'street grooming' gangs that have been...
    Left hand palm | 30-08
  • John Key’s Top 69 Lies: Today no. 21 – I trust Judith Collins t...
     PM Questioned About Judith Collins  PM Faces More Q's About Collins  Corruption Allegations Fly in Parliament  Judith Collins resigns, says she's a victim ...
    Arch Rival | 30-08
  • Thus, I give up the spear!
    It's a pretty safe bet that when a certain blogger whom we don't name came up with his "trophy wall" of individuals that he had "harpooned" through his work, he didn't ever think that the biggest head mounted on it...
    Pundit | 30-08
  • Are Mental Health Services Failing Cameron Slater
    Firstly, I don’t want to make excuses for the Scumbag Cameron Slater, in fact I am amazed the Police have not yet arrested him for collusion to commit blackmail, or for several other crimes he has appeared to have committed. ...
    An average kiwi | 30-08
  • Corrupt Collins resigns
    Today, the corrupt and arrogant Judith Collins was forced to resign. Clearly her position had already become untenable because of her involvement in the Oravida debacle and a smear campaign against a public servant. Because of Collins and attack blogger...
    The Jackal | 30-08
  • Whose Resignation?
    Judith Collins’ resignation has, it is suggested in some quarters, allowed a line to be drawn under the whole dirty politics saga. We can, it seems, get on with the “real issues” of the election. Such optimism, however, seems entirely...
    Bryan Gould | 30-08
  • Winston Peters finally allowed on TV3 set after standing next to it for 78 ...
    Some political reporters believe that Peters doesn’t have a home, and sleeps in television studios in hopes of being asked about current events. New Zealand First leader Winston Peters was finally allowed on the set of TV3’s The Nation this...
    The Civilian | 30-08
  • Prime Minister issues Judith Collins with last, definitively final, absolut...
    Key insists that this is Collins’ “very last” penultimate warning. Prime Minister John Key cancelled a campaign event in Wellington early this afternoon in order to publicly issue Justice Minister Judith Collins with a “definitively final penultimate warning” over her...
    The Civilian | 30-08
  • A Tale of Two Tracks. Part II – Something new under the sun.
    [This is the second part of a two-part post. In the first post I argued that our modern world is susceptible to 'two tracks' arising in all areas. In this post I argue that it is wrong to claim that...
    Political Scientist | 30-08
  • A Tale of Two Tracks. Part II – Something new under the sun.
    [This is the second part of a two-part post. In the first post I argued that our modern world is susceptible to 'two tracks' arising in all areas. In this post I argue that it is wrong to claim that...
    The Political Scientist | 30-08
  • A Tale of Two Tracks. Part I – A two track world
    There’s plenty of interesting side-tracks to travel down in Nicky Hager’s book ‘Dirty Politics‘. But the main track needs to be kept visible. That track is actually two tracks. And those tracks amount to a highly networked web of relationships between a loose...
    Political Scientist | 30-08
  • A Tale of Two Tracks. Part I – A two track world
    There’s plenty of interesting side-tracks to travel down in Nicky Hager’s book ‘Dirty Politics‘. But the main track needs to be kept visible. That track is actually two tracks. And those tracks amount to a highly networked web of relationships between a loose...
    The Political Scientist | 30-08
  • Serious questions for Jared Savage & the NZ Herald
    So, further to the Cameron Slater email that felled Judith Collins, there’s a particular line in the email that’s rather troubling: I am maintaining daily communications with Jared Savage at the Herald and he is passing information directly to me that...
    Occasionally erudite | 30-08
  • Photo of the day: Urban Charity
    Yesterday was Daffodil Day and in two different locations people put a lot of effort into creating neat displays that enhanced the urban environment and made people stop and look. The first one I saw was on Durham Lane where Daffodils...
    Transport Blog | 30-08
  • Collins’ resignation
    I've just been watching the Prime Minister announcing the resignation of Judith Collins. I'm glad to see her go. A Minister using a sewer-blogger to undermine their own chief executive is absolutely toxic. But rather than resigning, she should have...
    No Right Turn | 30-08
  • Judith Collins resigns
    Oravida and the mysterious Chinese border control official, the Simon Pleasants leak, Bronwyn Pullar’s Privacy Commission complaint, plotting to roll John Key after the election – the allegations just kept coming. Now there’s the allegation that she conspired with Cameron Slater and...
    Occasionally erudite | 30-08
  • Andrew Williams lawyers up
    Andrew Williams is somewhat annoyed about being dumped completely from the NZ First party list. As such, he’s following in his leader’s footsteps and is lawyering up, seeking a judicial review of the party’s decision. My immediate response, on hearing...
    Occasionally erudite | 29-08
  • DIRT ALERT! – Are The Greens And Labour About To Become The Targets O...
    Deja Vu All Over Again? Are we about to see a repeat of the 2005 negative advertising campaign  launched in secret against the Greens and Labour? WE’VE SEEN IT ALL BEFORE. In 2005 pamphlets began appearing all over New Zealand attacking Labour...
    Bowalley Road | 29-08
  • Call for Aaron Bhatnagar’s resignation from govt body
    .   . One of the many sordid “bit”-players in Nicky Hager’s book, “Dirty Politics“, and one of Cameron Slater’s inner-cabal, is businessman, National Party card-carrying cadre,  and former city councillor, Aaron Bhatnagar; . . In 2008, Bhatnagar was caught...
    Frankly Speaking | 29-08
  • Call for Aaron Bhatnagar’s resignation from govt body
    .   . One of the many sordid “bit”-players in Nicky Hager’s book, “Dirty Politics“, and one of Cameron Slater’s inner-cabal, is businessman, National Party card-carrying cadre,  and former city councillor, Aaron Bhatnagar; . . In 2008, Bhatnagar was caught...
    Frankly Speaking | 29-08
  • Wynyard Cycling Complaints
    The new Waterfront Promenade linking the Harbour Bridge to Wynyard Quarter will be fantastic when finished later this year however its completion will leave a gap in the network through Wynyard Quarter itself. Auckland Transport and Waterfront Auckland are going to be...
    Transport Blog | 29-08
  • Something to do today
    From the FaceBook page: NATIONAL: NOT OUR FUTUREMARCHES ACROSS NEW ZEALANDAUCKLAND RALLY SATURDAY 30th AUGUST. AOTEA SQUARE, 1PMThree weeks before the election, action is being taken across the country voicing a rejection of the National Government's track record and direction....
    The Jackal | 29-08
  • Slater packs a sad
    H/T Porcupine FarmWe all know that Cameron Slater AKA Whale Oil is a bit of a dick at the best of times. His stupidity and vindictive nature is clearly evident throughout the book Dirty Politics and on his discredited blog...
    The Jackal | 29-08
  • Key weak on Collins coup attempt
    Politics is a strange old chestnut with the motivations of those playing the game not always apparent to the rest of us. However, more often than not the politicians invariably only have their own vested interests at heart with little...
    The Jackal | 29-08
  • Koretake II
    The Crown is to appeal against the son of Kingi Tuheitia not being convicted - in a case where the other offenders were all let off without convictions without any name suppression - and the Crown is not to appeal...
    Tumeke | 29-08
  • Another meteorite
    In 2003, the Court of Appeal delivered a bombshell ruling in Ngati Apa v Attorney-General: the crown had not generally extinguished Maori customary rights over the foreshore and seabed, and ownership of particular areas of the foreshore and seabed was...
    No Right Turn | 29-08
  • Who says organisation, says oligarchy
    So Andrew Williams has decided to do a Winston Peters and go off to Court to try and stop "his" party from excluding him as a candidate....
    Pundit | 29-08
  • John Key’s Top 69 Lies: Today no. 22 -What Cunliffe said about Lochin...
     Key says Cunliffe's Lochinver sale stance weakening Prime Minister John Key said "A couple of weeks ago (David Cunliffe) was screaming at New Zealanders that he would stop the sale (of Lochinver station); last night he was essentially saying, 'I'm going...
    Arch Rival | 29-08
  • Oxfam: saving the tava’e (and the world)
    This guest post is by Oxfam NZ‘s (relatively) new director, Rachael Le Mesurier. She’s off to the UN conference on Small Island Developing States in Apia next week, and here provides an interesting overview of the climate, sea level and...
    Hot Topic | 29-08
  • Robin Hood tax and other clever ways to help our kids
    MEDIA RELEASE: 28th AUGUST 2014 “Robin Hood tax and other clever ways to help our kids” It’s time to talk about tax. Not just income tax but other kinds of tax too. It’s time to talk about Capital Gains Tax,...
    Closing the Gap | 29-08
  • Government to save $400 million by doing ice bucket challenge on behalf of ...
    Turkmenistan’s challenge to New Zealand comes just one week after Pope Francis apparently died attempting to avoid his own $100 donation. The National Government this afternoon announced plans to save New Zealand in excess of $400 million by performing an...
    The Civilian | 29-08
  • Green Election Policy Highly Sophisticated.
    As each new election policy is released by the Greens I am impressed by the depth of thinking, costing and multiple benefits that come with them. We have made a convincing impression this election that we are ready to govern...
    Local Bodies | 29-08
  • Stuart’s 100 #17: A Greater Auckland?
    17: A Greater Auckland? What if we felt like we lived in an Auckland that was greater than the sum of its parts? This is perhaps one of the reoccurring themes in my 100 days project. It reflects the public...
    Transport Blog | 29-08
  • Green Party companion leaders’ debate
    The Greens take an inclusive approach to being excluded. So when we were shut out of the TVNZ leaders’ debate (despite being New Zealand’s third largest party, and despite the two-handed Key-Cunliffe format feeling more like a throwback to First...
    frogblog | 29-08
  • Shouldn’t this farmer be prosecuted for bribery?
    The Waikato Regional Council, in reporting on the fine handed down to a polluting farmer, also has some disturbing news:During the course of the Waikato Regional Council inspections that led to the prosecution, Bilkar Singh, a director of B &...
    No Right Turn | 29-08
  • Whatever happened to liberty?
    Yesterday, the Independent Police Conduct Authority released a report finding that police routinely exceeded their powers in shutting down "out of control" parties, invading people's homes, assaulting people, using excessive force (in some cases causing significant injury), and shutting down...
    No Right Turn | 29-08
  • Viewers judge TV3 to be winner in TV One leaders’ debate
    Key says the poll shows that Labour is 4% worse than gouging your eyes out, while National is only 2% worse. A snap political poll taken after last night’s leader’s debate on TV One has revealed that most New Zealanders...
    The Civilian | 29-08
  • Kiwis care about inequality
    Inequality has emerged as the key issue in the election campaign:The gap between rich and poor is by far the biggest issue facing New Zealand three weeks before election day, a new poll has found. The Roy Morgan Research poll...
    No Right Turn | 29-08
  • Something to do on Saturday
    There will be a series of anti-government marches in Auckland, Wellington, Christchurch and Dunedin on Saturday:The Auckland rally starts at Aotea Square, Wellington at Te Papa marching to Parliament, Dunedin held at the Octagon and the Christchurch rally at Haley...
    No Right Turn | 29-08
  • Speaker: Rocking in the Public Good: Hager and Shihad
    Seldom has New Zealand seen such super-harmonies in the traditionally separate spheres of music  and investigative journalism. The release of New Zealand prog-rocker Nicky Hager’s latest album Dirty Politics coincided with the well known citizen journalist group Shihad’s book FVEY,...
    Public Address | 29-08
  • The cost of irrigation
    At the moment, the government is pushing irrigation and water storage as a way of increasing milk production and boosting the economy. Critics have argued that the result will be dirty, polluted rivers unfit for recreational use. And we've just...
    No Right Turn | 29-08
  • An empty void at the heart of the election
    Its election time. The blog should be humming. Its not. Why? Because there's not enough policy to comment on. Note that this is not a complaint about Dirty Politics. How power is exercised and the ethics displayed in doing so...
    No Right Turn | 29-08
  • Making money out of fanatics
    Click on image to enlarge This looks like a Xcd cartoon. I picked it up from a new Facebook page The Girl Against Fluoride Lies. Good to see more and more Facebook pages like this. Speaking of fluoride – the cartoon sort...
    Open Parachute | 29-08
  • Debate 1
    As you know, there was a debate last night, and the consensus appears to be that David Cunliffe won. (The strongest clue that National also thinks Cunliffe won is that Kiwiblog has seven posts up this morning to change the...
    Polity | 29-08
  • Britomart precinct quick wins
    It has now been three months since Janette Sadik-Khan visited Auckland and showed us how easy it was to create a more liveable city by making things better for people to walk and cycle around, and best of all we...
    Transport Blog | 29-08
  • Poll of Polls update – 29 August 2014
    The polls are coming thick and fast. There must be an election on… Yesterday, we had the release of the latest Herald Digipoll, while this morning it’s the Fairfax Ipsos poll. In the Digipoll, National are up 0.7% to 50.7%,...
    Occasionally erudite | 28-08
  • World News Brief, Friday August 29
    Top of the AgendaUkraine Accuses Russia of Invasion...
    Pundit | 28-08
  • Hard News: Friday Music: Tramadol Rock
    I saw Samuel Flynn Scott a couple of times last year at the time he was suffering through a back injury in a haze of painkillers. It made for a fairly spaced out Phoenix Foundation show at the Powerstation --...
    Public Address | 28-08
  • Vale Brad Fletcher, MUNZ Lyttelton Branch President
    The Maritime Union is greatly saddened by the death of Maritime Union Lyttelton Branch President Brad Fletcher in a workplace accident on Thursday 28 August 2014. Maritime Union National Secretary Joe Fleetwood says the death of Brad Fletcher, a full-time...
    MUNZ | 28-08
  • Matthew Hooton (Fanatical National Supporter) Says Key is “Dishonest”
    This morning on Radio Live, Matthew Hooton has said what John Key is saying about about not being told of the SIS Official Information Request release to Scumbag Adulterous Blogger Cameron Slater, is “unbelievable”....
    An average kiwi | 28-08
  • Labour’s plan to end homelessness
    Labour has a comprehensive approach to end homelessness starting with the provision of emergency housing for 1000 people each year and putting an end to slum conditions in boarding houses, Labour Leader David Cunliffe says. “Labour believes that homelessness is not...
    Labour | 30-08
  • Labour: A smarter approach to justice
    A Labour Government will improve the justice system to ensure it achieves real public safety, provides equal access to justice and protects human rights, Labour’s Justice spokesperson Andrew Little says. “Our approach is about tackling the root causes of crime, recognising...
    Labour | 29-08
  • Labour to foster Kiwi love of sport and the great outdoors
    A Labour Government will promote physical activity, back our top athletes and help foster Kiwis’ love of the great outdoors by upgrading tramping and camping facilities. Trevor Mallard today released Labour’s sports and recreation policy which will bring back a...
    Labour | 29-08
  • Pacific languages recognised under Labour
    Labour will act to recognise the five main Pacific languages in New Zealand including through the education system, said Pacific Affairs spokesperson Su’a William Sio. Announcing Labour’s Pacific Island policy he said that there must be a strong commitment to...
    Labour | 29-08
  • No healthy economy without a healthy environment
    Labour recognises that we cannot have a healthy economy without a healthy environment, says Environment spokesperson Moana Mackey announcing Labour’s environment policy. “New Zealand’s economy has been built on the back of the enormous environmental wealth we collectively enjoy as...
    Labour | 28-08
  • Better protection, fairer deal for Kiwi consumers
    Tackling excessive prices, ensuring consumers have enough information to make ethical choices and giving the Commerce Commission more teeth are highlights of Labour’s Consumer Rights policy. “The rising cost of living is a concern for thousands of Kiwi families. A...
    Labour | 28-08
  • Media Advisory – MANA Movement Candidate for Waiariki Annette Sykes, Waia...
    Media are advised that this coming weekend, the MANA Movement Candidate for Waiariki, Annette Sykes, will be on the Internet MANA Road Trip within the electorate of Waiariki. Speakers confirmed are Annette Sykes, Hone Harawira, John Minto, Laila Harre and Kim...
    Mana | 27-08
  • Internet MANA – Waiariki Road Trip: 29, 30, 31 Aug 2014
    The Internet MANA Road Trip hits Waiariki this weekend. It would be great if all MANA members in Waiariki could especially attend the public meetings and show their support for our Waiariki candidate Annette Sykes. Confirmed speakers Hone Harawira (except Taupo), Annette...
    Mana | 27-08
  • First home buyers $200 a week better off with Labour
    A couple earning around $75,000 a year would be $200 a week better off buying a two bedroom terraced Labour KiwiBuild home instead of an equivalent new build under National’s housing policy, says Labour Leader David Cunliffe.  “National’s policy to...
    Labour | 26-08
  • Another Day – Another big power profit
    The latest profit announcement from Genesis Energy shows that the power company was sold for a song to the detriment of the country’s power consumers, says Labour’s Energy spokesperson David Shearer. “A net profit of $ 49.2 million follows hard...
    Labour | 26-08
  • Labour embraces the rainbow
    Labour will work hard to ensure all New Zealanders enjoy the freedom to grow up and live their lives in dignity and security. Labour’s Rainbow policy, released tonight in Wellington, focuses on International Relations, Human Rights and Education....
    Labour | 26-08
  • National gets fast and loose with the facts
    In their desperation to make it look as though they are doing something about the housing crisis, National is playing fast and loose with the facts, says Labour’s housing spokesperson Phil Twyford....
    Labour | 26-08
  • Labour will drop power prices for Kiwi families
    New Zealanders will get cheaper power prices under NZ Power, says Labour Leader David Cunliffe. “The electricity market is clearly broken. With falling demand for electricity, prices should be going down. Instead prices are going up and companies are extracting...
    Labour | 26-08
  • Labour: Promoting sustainable tourism
    Ensuring New Zealand’s clean, green status continues to be an international tourism benchmark and reviewing MBIE’s oversight of the tourism sector will be on the radar under a Labour Government. Releasing Labour’s Tourism policy today, spokesperson Darien Fenton said tourism...
    Labour | 26-08
  • Skills shortage a result of National’s complacency
    The fact that there is still a severe shortage of skilled tradespeople, despite a growth in the number of apprentices, is a result of National’s failure to plan and develop the workforce, Grant Robertson, Labour Employment, Skills and TrainingSpokesperson says."The...
    Labour | 26-08
  • How much tax does John Key pay compared to a minimum wage worker?? – Mint...
    MANA Movement Economic Justice spokesperson John Minto is calling for a radical overhaul of New Zealand’s taxation system with calculations showing that a minimum wage worker pays a ten times higher tax rate than the Prime Minister. o Minimum wage...
    Mana | 25-08
  • Labour’s culture of science and innovation
    Labour will create a culture of science and innovation in New Zealand that will be the envy of the world, says Labour’s Innovation, Research and Development spokesperson Megan Woods. “Labour believes that good science lies at the heart of a...
    Labour | 25-08
  • Improving life for our new New Zealanders
    New Zealand’s international standing as a community that encourages and fosters all cultures will be bolstered under a Labour Government with an upgrade of the present Office of Ethnic Affairs to a Ministry. Releasing Labour’s Ethnic Affairs policy, spokesperson Phil...
    Labour | 25-08
  • South Auckland housing crisis
    National’s HomeStart package is nothing more than a political stunt designed to beguile South Auckland voters, said Labour’s Pacific Affairs spokesperson Su’a William Sio. “Few working Pasifika and Maori workers in South Auckland will be able to buy their own...
    Labour | 25-08
  • Home buyer subsidy discredited in Oz
    Treasury advised against National’s policy of ramping up home buyer subsidies after it was discredited in Australia because it pushed house prices even higher, Labour’s Housing spokesperson Phil Twyford says. “Documents released under the OIA (attached) show Treasury advised the...
    Labour | 25-08
  • Nursing hours explain turnover and high-stress culture
    A staff survey supports concerns nursing staff at Dunedin Hospital are under increasing pressure and that the emergency department is in a critical state, says Labour’s Associate Health Spokesperson David Clark.  “An ED nursing survey at Dunedin found that 80...
    Labour | 24-08
  • Underhand tactics prove case for axing donations
    Revelations that schools are using underhand tactics to coerce donations from cash-strapped parents further highlights the need for Labour's plan to increase funding so they aren't dependent on contributions from parents, Labour's Education spokesperson Chris Hipkins says. “By law New...
    Labour | 24-08
  • National applies band-aid to housing crisis
    The Government’s flagship housing announcement is a band-aid approach that will push up prices rather than solve the housing crisis, says Labour Leader David Cunliffe. “House sales to first home buyers have collapsed as a direct result of the Government’s...
    Labour | 24-08
  • Climate change focus on the now for the future
    A Labour Governmentwill put in place a comprehensive climate change strategy focusing on bothmitigation and adaptation, establish an independent Climate Commission andimplement carbon budgeting, says Labour Climate Change spokesperson MoanaMackey."This is about future-proofing our economy. Making the transition to alow-carbon...
    Labour | 24-08
  • Labour’s 21st century transport pledge
    The next Labour-led Government will create a 21st century transport system for New Zealand that promotes the most efficient and sustainable combination of transport options, says Labour’s Transport spokesperson Phil Twyford. “Labour will rebalance the Government's transport spending away from...
    Labour | 23-08
  • Housing under National: the facts
    1.       House prices in Auckland Council valuations indicate Auckland house prices have gone up by one-third over the last three years. (Auckland Council) The average Auckland house price has gone up by nearly $225,000 since 2008, up over $75,000 in...
    Labour | 23-08
  • Labour irons out low income tax issue
    The increasing casualisation of work has led to many New Zealand families being disadvantaged through the tax they pay, Labour Leader David Cunliffe says. "Many low paid workers are having to work two or three jobs to make ends meet...
    Labour | 22-08
  • Cornered Government comes out swinging
    The National Government is so desperate to keep its dead-in-the-water expert teachers policy alive, it has refused to rule out forcing schools to participate through legislation, Labour’s Education spokesperson Chris Hipkins says. “John Key today attacked the Educational Institute for...
    Labour | 22-08
  • Pacific people continue to go backwards under National
    A report from Victoria University highlights the fact that Pacific people are continuing to go backwards under a National Government, said Labour’s Pacific Affairs spokesperson Su’a William Sio.  “The report shows the largest inequality increases were in smoking, obesity, tertiary...
    Labour | 22-08
  • Wellington transport plan needs to keep moving
    The failure of the Transport Agency to properly look at alternatives to the Basin Reserve flyover is not a good reason for further delays to improving transport in Wellington, Labour MPs Grant Robertson and Annette King say. “The Board of...
    Labour | 22-08
  • Labour’s focus on inequality, kids and better job prospects
    Tackling child poverty and removing barriers to people working part time to enhance their prospects of moving into a fulltime job are highlights of Labour’s Social Development policy. Releasing the policy today, spokesperson Sue Moroney said while part-time work was...
    Labour | 21-08
  • Political staff should give answers under oath
    The Inspector General of Security and Intelligence should use her full statutory powers to question witnesses under oath about the leak of SIS information, says Labour MP Phil Goff. “Leakage of confidential information from the SIS for political purposes is...
    Labour | 21-08
  • High dollar, hands-off Govt sends workers to dole queue
    The loss of up to 100 jobs at Croxley stationery in Auckland is devastating news for their families and the local Avondale community, Labour’s Employment, Skills and Training spokesperson Grant Robertson says. “The company’s inability to compete in international markets...
    Labour | 21-08
  • National’s flagship education policy dead in the water
    National’s plan to create executive principals and expert teachers is effectively dead in the water with news that 93 percent of primary teachers have no confidence in the scheme, Labour’s Education spokesperson Chris Hipkins says. “The fact that teachers are...
    Labour | 21-08
  • Dunedin will be a knowledge and innovation centre under Labour
    Dunedin will become a knowledge and innovation centre under a Labour Government that will back local businesses, support technology initiatives and fund dynamic regional projects, Labour Leader David Cunliffe says. “Nowhere has the National Government’s short-sightedness been more apparently than...
    Labour | 21-08
  • Inquiry into SIS disclosures the right decision
    Labour MP Phil Goff says the Inspector-General of Intelligence and Security has done the right thing by launching an inquiry into the disclosure of SIS documents about a meeting between himself and the agency’s former director-general. “This inquiry is necessary...
    Labour | 20-08
  • Labour – supporting and valuing carers and the cared for
    Placing real value on our elderly and the people who care for them will be a priority for a Labour Government, Labour Leader David Cunliffe says. Releasing Labour’s Senior Citizens policy today David Cunliffe promised that a Labour Government would...
    Labour | 20-08
  • By Hoki! It’s Labour’s fisheries policy
    A Labour Government will protect the iconic Kiwi tradition of fishing by improving access to the coast, protecting the rights of recreational fishers and reviewing snapper restrictions, Labour’s Fisheries spokesperson Damien O’Connor says. “Catching a fish from the rocks, beach...
    Labour | 20-08
  • Mighty River – Mighty Profits – Mighty hard to swallow
    Mighty River Power’s profit increase of 84 per cent is simply outrageous, says Labour’s Energy spokesperson David Shearer. “Demand for electricity is flat or declining yet the company has made enormous profits. It is the latest power company to celebrate...
    Labour | 19-08
  • Collins’ actions were wrong, not unwise
    John Key’s moral compass remains off-kilter as he cannot bring himself to declare Judith Collins’ actions outright wrong, not simply ‘unwise’, said Labour MP Grant Robertson. “Under pressure John Key is finally shifting his stance but his failure to condemn...
    Labour | 19-08
  • Public servants behaving with more integrity than their masters
    The State Services Commission's new report on the integrity of our state services reflects the yawning gap between the behaviour of public servants and that of their political masters, Labour's State Services spokesperson Maryan Street says. “This report, which surveyed...
    Labour | 19-08
  • Phil Twyford Speech to NZCID
    "Labour's plan to build more and build better: how new approaches to housing, transport and urban development will deliver cities that work" Phil Twyford, Labour Party spokesperson on housing, transport, Auckland issues, and cities.  ...
    Labour | 19-08
  • Labour commits to independent Foreign Affairs and Trade
    “Labour is committed to New Zealand’s Foreign Affairs and Trade policy being independent and proactive, Labour’s Foreign Affairs spokesperson David Shearer says. “We are a small but respected country. Our voice and actions count in international affairs. Labour will take a...
    Labour | 19-08
  • Key must sack Collins over abhorrent actions
    The latest revelations that Judith Collins sent the contact details of a public servant to WhaleOil in a desperate attempt to divert media attention from a bad story is abhorrent, Labour MP Grant Robertson says. “John Key and Judith Collins...
    Labour | 19-08
  • It’s downhill from here under National
    The forecast drop in exports and predicted halving of growth shows that it’s downhill from here with National, Labour’s Finance spokesperson David Parker says. “Growth under this Government peaked in June and halves to two per cent in coming years....
    Labour | 19-08
  • John Key loses moral compass over Collins
    John Key has lost his moral compass over Judith Collins’ involvement with Cameron Slater and lost touch with New Zealanders’ sense of right and wrong, Labour MP Grant Robertson says. “Whoever is Prime Minister there are expectations they will not...
    Labour | 18-08
  • Mana Movement General Election 2014 List confirmed
    The MANA List is now confirmed with all the candidates as below (the numbers are the respective Internet MANA rankings). Candidate, Electorate, Internet MANA List Position Hone Harawira, Te Tai Tokerau (1) Annette Sykes, Waiariki (3) John Minto, Mt Roskill (4) Te Hamua Nikora, Ikaroa-Rawhiti...
    Mana | 18-08
  • PREFU likely to confirm dropping exports
    National’s economic management will be put under the spotlight in tomorrow’s PREFU given clear signs the so-called rock star economy has fallen off the stage, with plummeting prices for raw commodity exports, Labour’s Finance spokesperson David Parker says. “Under National,...
    Labour | 18-08
  • Record profits while Kiwis face a cold winter
    The record profits by two of New Zealand’s largest electricity companies will be a bitter pill for New Zealand households who are paying record amounts for their power, says Labour’s Energy spokesperson David Shearer. “No doubt the Key government will...
    Labour | 18-08
  • Time for John Key to answer yes or no questions
    John Key’s train-wreck interview on Morning Report shows he is no longer capable of a simple yes or no answer and has lost touch with what’s right and wrong, Labour MP Grant Robertson says. “John Key has become so media...
    Labour | 18-08
  • Review: Hairspray
      Oh Hairspray! What fun! Somehow I managed to miss the movie when it came out, I had no idea really what it was about though I felt it had a vague relation to High School Musical. In retrospect, that...
    The Daily Blog | 30-08
  • Mounting global pressure against Timor-Leste’s ‘death sentence’ media...
    East Timor’s José Belo … courageous fight against ‘unconstitutional’ media law.Image: © Ted McDonnell 2014 CAFÉ PACIFIC and the Pacific Media Centre Online posted challenges to the controversial ‘press law’ nine months ago when it emerged how dangerous this draft...
    The Daily Blog | 30-08
  • GUEST BLOG: Curwen Rolinson – Spies, Lies and When Campaigns Are Fried
    Like most of the rest of the nation’s political classes, I was eagerly affixed to TV One from 12:30 on Saturday afternoon to witness the downfall of Judith Collins.Whenever we witness the crumbling of a titan of the political landscape...
    The Daily Blog | 30-08
  • BREAKING: Whaleoil crushes Crusher
    Judith ends up shooting herself A new email has been released suggesting that Collins was attempting to undermine the head of Serious Fraud Office with the help of far right hate speech merchant Cameron Slater. Unbelievable!   She has been forced...
    The Daily Blog | 30-08
  • BREAKING: Rumours Judith Collins gone at lunchtime
    Brook Sabin first of the mark with rumours Judith Collins is about to resign – PM announcing a statement at 12.30pm… …Paddy follows… …Vance confirms..   …if Collins is gone by lunchtime, it will be because the PM understands the...
    The Daily Blog | 29-08
  • BREAKING: UPDATE on DIRT ALERT!
    Thanks to the information passed to Chris Trotter by “Idiot/Savant” from No Right Turn it is now possible to identify at least some of the persons involved in this latest example of attack politics. What follows is Chris’s response to Idiot/Savant’s timely assistance: Well done...
    The Daily Blog | 29-08
  • Comparing burning puppets, hip hop lyrics and drunk student chants to black...
    Watching the mainstream media try and obscure Cunliffe’s surprise win in the leaders debate  is a reminder the Press Gallery is in depressed shock. The current spin line from the Wellington bubble media in the wake of Dirty Politics is that...
    The Daily Blog | 29-08
  • Why has it all gone quiet on Charter Schools?
    They’re one of ACT’s flagship policies and the National Party have been gung ho in supporting them. So how come we’re not hearing Hekia Parata, Jamie Whyte, Catherine Isaac, et al singing from the rafters about what a resounding success charter...
    The Daily Blog | 29-08
  • Moment of Truth – September 15th – Auckland Town Hall
    Moment of Truth – September 15th – Auckland Town Hall...
    The Daily Blog | 29-08
  • EXCLUSIVE: Dirt Alert! Are the Greens and Labour about to become the target...
    WE’VE SEEN IT ALL BEFORE. In 2005 pamphlets began appearing all over New Zealand attacking Labour and the Greens. For a couple of days both the parties targeted and the news media were flummoxed. Who was behind such an obviously...
    The Daily Blog | 29-08
  • The Donghua Liu Affair: the Press Council’s decision
    . . 1. Prologue . The Donghua Liu Affair hit  the headlines on 18 June, with allegations that David Cunliffe wrote a letter in 2003,  on  behalf of  business migrant, Donghua Liu. Four days later, on Sunday 22 June, the...
    The Daily Blog | 29-08
  • The difference between Cunliffe & Key in the debate
    It was with much interest that I watched the leaders debate on Thursday night.  I watched with an open mind, always happy to have my opinion changed.  Maybe John Key is all the wonderful things that many say about him,...
    The Daily Blog | 29-08
  • GUEST BLOG: Denis Tegg – When Did We Agree To Our Data Being Shared with ...
    New shocking evidence has emerged from Edward Snowden’s trove of documents about a program called ICREACH under which data collected by the GCSB is shared with 23 US spy agencies. Under new sharing agreements which appear to have commenced immediately after...
    The Daily Blog | 28-08
  • Why Internet MANA are the best political friends the Greens could ever get
    Metiria at last nights #GreenRoomNZ: standing on the shoulders and camera cases of giants  NZers, regardless of political spectrum or apathy level, have a wonderful beach cricket egalitarianism about us. If we can objectively conclude a winner, then that person...
    The Daily Blog | 28-08
  • Sick of the Sleaze? Protest against National’s dirty politics THIS SATURD...
    Sick of the Sleaze? Protest now dammit! Three weeks before the election, action is being taken across the country voicing a rejection of the National Government’s track record and direction. Rallies are being held in Auckland, Wellington, Christchurch and Dunedin...
    The Daily Blog | 28-08
  • GUEST BLOG: Sir Edmund Thomas – Address at Nicky Hager public meeting
    I regard it as privilege to chair this public meeting. I have long had the greatest admiration for Nicky Hager’s work, and nothing I have read or heard in the media over the past week or so has caused me...
    The Daily Blog | 28-08
  • Labour and New Zealand Superannuation
    The kerfuffle in the wake of Nicky Hager’s Dirty Politics has had a detrimental impact on our discussion of economic policies. Signs are that the main beneficiaries of the dirty politics revelations will be Winston Peters and Colin Craig; certainly National suffered...
    The Daily Blog | 28-08
  • Coalition for Better Broadcasting – Mike Hosking and the Leader’s Debat...
    A few weeks ago I blogged that Mike Hosking was a terrible choice as moderator for the TV One Party Leader’s Debate, because he is so embarrassingly biased in favour of John Key. So I watched the show with curiosity,...
    The Daily Blog | 28-08
  • Democracy and Cancer: A critical analysis of Dirty Politics
    Twenty years ago, England’s renowned television playwright Denis Potter died of pancreatic cancer.  Readers may recall his two masterpieces ‘Pennies from Heaven’ and ‘The Singing Detective’.  During a final television interview with Melvyn Bragg, Potter declared that he had named...
    The Daily Blog | 28-08
  • Cunliffe beats Key in First Leaders debate
    I watched the First Leaders debate at the Green Party #GreenRoomNZ, they were very kind to include me and the atmosphere was great. The debate was a resounding victory to Cunliffe. He won Round 1, Round 2, Round 3 and...
    The Daily Blog | 28-08
  • LIVE STREAM: The Green Room Leader’s Debate from 6:30pm
    The Green Room will be hosted by media commentator Russel Brown, and will feature Green Co-leaders Metiria Turei and Russel Norman responding to the debate live, along with comment from thought leaders and commentators. ‘The Green Room’ 6pm – 8.30pm...
    The Daily Blog | 28-08
  • How many taxpayer funded staff does John Key need to prepare for a Leaders ...
    John Key is currently at the Auckland Stamford Plaza with 40 staff, 4 undercover police cars and an entire floor booked out in preparation for tonights Leader’s debate. Isn’t 40 staff including coms, flown up to Auckland for a debate...
    The Daily Blog | 28-08
  • A brief word on National Party Rodney MP, Mark Mitchell
    MP considers legal action against Nicky HagerThe National MP says he is considering taking a defamation case after the September 20 election.“Someone needs to be held accountable,” he said. Oh really champ? Brothers and sisters, there is a long way...
    The Daily Blog | 28-08
  • Greens advertise on Whaleoil – but not on The Daily Blog?
    PaknSave have shown ethical compass and blocked adverts on Whaleoil, yet the Greens are advertising on Whaleoil, and not The Daily Blog? I would imagine there are far more potential Green voters on The Daily Blog then ever are on...
    The Daily Blog | 28-08
  • It’s about the stupid economy stupid
    In focus group meetings, the sleepy hobbits of NZ by a staggering amount all believe that National are better economic stewards of the country than Labour, that’s why, instead of answering questions about blackmailing MPs, trawling brothels for dirt on...
    The Daily Blog | 28-08
  • Labour Policy vs National Policy
    John Key’s favourite defence spin at the moment is people want to talk about policy and not hear answers on the ethics of trawling brothels, why Slater was given SIS information, blackmailing MPs into standing down, rigging candidate elections and hacking...
    The Daily Blog | 28-08
  • The Green Room live streamed on TDB 6.30pm tonight for First Leaders debate
    The ‘Green Room’ will stream 6.pm tonight on The Daily Blog during the TV One leaders’ debate.Use #GreenRoomNZ to join in. The Green Room will be hosted by media commentator Russel Brown, and will feature Green Co-leaders Metiria Turei and Russel Norman responding...
    The Daily Blog | 27-08
  • Manukau East – the next Coalition in action
    A couple of weeks ago I had the pleasure of opening Voice Up – a youth forum run by young people in Otara. I had been asked as Chair of the Local Board to set the scene, encouraging young people...
    The Daily Blog | 27-08
  • GUEST BLOG: Kelly Ellis – The Big Bang Theory
    It’s a shame that it took a brain injury for me to start seeing things with such startling clarity. The realisation that lawyering, fishing, parenting, selling cars and racing yachts had common themes was stunning. Not perhaps as stunning as...
    The Daily Blog | 27-08
  • Jeremy Wells’ Mike Hosking rant on Radio Hauraki: Today, how much Key aro...
    Jeremy Wells’ Mike Hosking on Radio Hauraki...
    The Daily Blog | 27-08
  • 5AA Australia – New Zealand’s Dirty Politics Aftermath and Polls
    MIL OSI – Source: Selwyn Manning – Analysis Headline: 5AA Australia – New Zealand’s Dirty Politics Aftermath and Polls 5AA Australia: On this week’s Across the Ditch bulletin on 5AA Australia, host Peter Godfery and Selwyn Manning discuss the aftermath...
    The Daily Blog | 27-08
  • La’o Hamutuk calls for inquiry into Timor GAP ‘mismanagement’ of oil ...
    The Suai project on the South Coast … “liberated” land but confused communities.Photo: La’o Hamutuk David Robie also blogs at Café Pacific. AN INDEPENDENT Timor-Leste development and social justice agency has called for an inquiry into the Timor GAP corporation...
    The Daily Blog | 27-08
  • What Is Nicky Hager?
    WHAT WILL HISTORY MAKE of Nicky Hager? That slight, perpetually boyish, journalist who descends periodically, like the admonishing angel in a medieval mystery play, to trouble our consciences and wreak merry havoc with the orderly conduct of our political affairs....
    The Daily Blog | 27-08
  • Can anyone in msm explain how after Dirty Politics that they all got played...
    Would you not think, that after reading Dirty Politics, that our mainstream media wouldn’t allow themselves to get tricked and played again by the VERY SAME discredited pundits? The best new feature on Radio NZ is their ‘Blog Watch’ and their...
    The Daily Blog | 27-08
  • Crusher Collins caught out lying about Privacy Commissioner – is this her...
    Crusher angry. Crusher smash own career. Crusher more angry. You would think that after getting outed as such a nasty, vicious piece of work in Dirty Politics, that Crusher would be scrambling to dial back the lies and manipulations. Apparently...
    The Daily Blog | 27-08
  • Cunliffe vs Key – first leaders debate
    This is your election ‘moderator’ – just one more reason an incoming Government need to sack everyone at TVNZ and reform it into an actual public broadcaster. The first leaders debate happens this Thursday, 7pm on TV One. I have...
    The Daily Blog | 26-08
  • GUEST BLOG: Kate Davis – An Old and Honourable Profession
      When Dirty Politics started to reference an ex-prostitute I began to get antsy. My first response was “come on Nicky, we decriminalised in 2003. Its sex worker.” My second response was “Ah oh. Who was it and did they...
    The Daily Blog | 26-08
  • Bought and paid for: the dirty politics of climate denial
    Has climate denial in New Zealand been bought and paid for by corporate interests? We already know that the ACT Party’s routine denial is closely linked to the financial support the party receives from wealthy free market fundamentalist Alan Gibbs,...
    The Daily Blog | 26-08
  • If the msm read The Daily Blog, THIS wouldn’t be a surprise – explainin...
    Yawn. How embarrassing for Hamish Rutherford and Andrea Vance, their breathless article today suggests that the idea of Labour and NZ First cutting a  deal over the buy back of assets  is some how new news. Silly mainstream media  journalists. If...
    The Daily Blog | 26-08
  • How much tax does John Key pay compared to a minimum wage worker??
    Yesterday I did some calculations to find out what tax John Key pays compared to a worker on the minimum wage. And I put out this media release for the Mana Movement: MANA Movement Economic Justice spokesperson John Minto is...
    The Daily Blog | 26-08
  • Hip hop death threats – the selective outrage of our media
    PM death threat in hip hop songAn Auckland hip-hop crew slammed for releasing a song with lyrics that apparently include a threat to kill Prime Minister John Key are urging young people to enrol to vote. Kill The PM, by...
    The Daily Blog | 26-08
  • Watch Slater turn into Key right before your eyes
    Watch Slater turn into Key right before your eyes...
    The Daily Blog | 26-08
  • I don’t always agree with Patrick Gower – but he didn’t deserve this!
    I don’t always agree with Patrick Gower – but he didn’t deserve this weird spear tackle from behind by his own company. I was listening to this interview at the time, and the awkwardness of it must be the worst...
    The Daily Blog | 26-08
  • Is it weird Radio NZ ban me yet still have….
    Is it weird Radio NZ ban me for life because I criticised the Prime Minister yet still have Matthew Hooton, David Farrar and Jordan Williams, 3 of the main protagonists revealed in Dirty Politics as part of their ongoing political...
    The Daily Blog | 25-08
  • Christchurch GCSB meeting – why mass surveillance matters in 2014
    This is the video for last weeks GCSB meeting in Christchurch. Don’t forget Nicky Hager’s public meeting Wednesday night in Auckland, TDB will live stream the event in the interests of our democracy. Broadcast starts 7.30pm here on TDB....
    The Daily Blog | 25-08
  • Assange, Greenwald to appear at Town Hall meeting? + KDC is not the hacker ...
    Wikileaks founder and the engineer of revealing some of the largest abuses of power in the modern era, Julian Assange, is rumoured to be appearing at the September 15th Town Hall meeting. Assange would join award winning investigative journalist Glen...
    The Daily Blog | 25-08
  • Why Paula Bennett will be the next leader and Hooton throws the Prime Minis...
    I don’t think the public have any idea of the behind the scenes meltdown now occurring within National. There are plenty of decent right wingers who all have ethical standards who have looked at what their leaders have been doing and...
    The Daily Blog | 25-08
  • GUEST BLOG: Curwen Rolinson – That Awkward Feeling When Your Campaign Goe...
    Urgh. It’s a thankless and nearly impossible task politically firefighting some days. Somebody (who isn’t you, but who’s in your care, or whom you’ve got a close professional relationship with) does or says something stupid; somebody from the Media’s there...
    The Daily Blog | 25-08
  • GUEST BLOG: Joe Trinder – Dirty politics goes viral
    Join the latest social networking craze this election that every Dog Cat and Jabba is putting on their facebook pages.     Joe Trinder – Ngāti Awa Born and born in Ōtepoti Ōtākou, Ex RNZN he is an Information Technology...
    The Daily Blog | 25-08
  • Blogwatch: An open letter to David Farrar: Please, be that guy
    Dear David, In light of  Nicky Hager’s book Dirty Politics, you wrote a blog entitled ‘Some changes on Kiwiblog’ and you suggested it was time to tighten up ship on your website, saying “I want to improve trust in myself,...
    The Daily Blog | 25-08
  • New Zealand’s biggest problems are Economic Issues
    New Zealand’s biggest problems are Economic Issues (41%) while the World’s most important problems are War & Terrorism (35%) just three weeks before NZ Election...
    Scoop politics | 29-08
  • NZ 2014 Leaders Index – week ending 29 August
    Below is iSentia’s first weekly Leaders’ Index, showing the relative amount of coverage of nine Party Leaders in the lead up to the National Election across news media and social media. We will produce these reports for the next three...
    Scoop politics | 29-08
  • Judgment in Paki v Attorney General
    Tamaiti Cairns said that today’s Supreme Court decision is complicated, but, in essence opens the door for Maori people to go forward with their essential claims to water. Further work is required and Pouakani Trust will continue to pursue its...
    Scoop politics | 29-08
  • Supreme Court Decision on Maori Water Rights
    “ … the Supreme Court refused to give Pouakani people what they asked for, but may have given them something much, much better instead. The Appellants had argued that the Crown’s ownership of the River was as a fiduciary for...
    Scoop politics | 29-08
  • Leaders Dinner with Campbell Live, Dessert with RadioLIVE
    John Campbell is hosting Colin Craig, Winston Peters, Laila Harre, Metiria Turei, Peter Dunne, Jamie Whyte and Te Ururoa Flavell LIVE from Auckland’s Grand Harbour Restaurant on Wednesday 3 September at 7pm....
    Scoop politics | 29-08
  • Credit unions in the political spotlight
    Dirty politics was put aside last night as senior politicians outlined their universal support for growing the cooperatively owned credit union and mutual building society sector in New Zealand....
    Scoop politics | 29-08
  • Maryan Street on issues of importance to older people
    Liam Butler interviews Hon Maryan Street MP on issues of importance to older New Zealanders...
    Scoop politics | 29-08
  • John Hanita Paki and others v The Attorney-General
    JOHN HANITA PAKI, TORIWAI ROTARANGI, TAUHOPA TE WANO HEPI, MATIU MAMAE PITIROI AND GEORGE MONGAMONGA RAWHITI v THE ATTORNEY-GENERAL OF NEW ZEALAND FOR AND ON BEHALF OF THE CROWN (“THE CROWN”) (SC 7/2010)...
    Scoop politics | 29-08
  • Last Nights Leaders Debate Drives The #nzpol Wordcloud
    Following last nights leaders debate on TV One between John Key and David Cunliffe, the data insight organisation Qrious collected all tweets that used the hashtag #nzpol from approximately the last 24 hours to produce this wordcloud....
    Scoop politics | 29-08
  • Campaign suggests reason behind suicide gender statistics
    An online campaign about meaning and belonging has revealed an interesting connection with the difference in suicide rates between men and women....
    Scoop politics | 29-08
  • Act Policy Vindicated by Sensible Sentencing Data
    ACT Leader Dr Jamie Whyte says the Sensible Sentencing Trust's just released analysis of 3 Strikes legislation "proves ACT was right to promote the policy and that it has made New Zealand a much safer country. The figures show beyond...
    Scoop politics | 29-08
  • “Robin Hood tax and other clever ways to help our kids”
    It’s time to talk about tax. Not just income tax but other kinds of tax too....
    Scoop politics | 29-08
  • Cannabis Laws Breach Treaty – ALCP
    Cannabis prohibition is neo-colonial oppression resulting in the disproportionate imprisonment of Maori, the Aotearoa Legalise Cannabis Party says....
    Scoop politics | 29-08
  • 2014 Variation Broadcasting Allocation Decision Released
    The Electoral Commission has released a variation decision on the amount of time and money allocated to political parties for the broadcasting of election programmes for the 2014 General Election....
    Scoop politics | 29-08
  • New Zealand Shoppers- Demand Blue Tick Accredited Products
    Following ongoing concerns surrounding the issue of animal welfare in farming, particularly in the layer and broiler chicken sectors, the RNZSPCA is now asking consumers to purchase only eggs, pork, turkey and chicken that have been Accredited by the Blue...
    Scoop politics | 29-08
  • EDS welcomes Labour’s Environment Policy
    The Environmental Defence Society has welcomed Labour’s Environment Policy which recognises that New Zealand cannot have a healthy economy without a healthy environment....
    Scoop politics | 29-08
  • Candidate calls for an end to institutional racism
    29 AUGUST 2014 Tāmaki Makaurau candidate, Rangi McLean has spoken up in support of Irie Te Wehi-Takerei who was wrongfully accused of shoplifting at a Warehouse store in Manukau. "Over the last month, two different supermarkets have been...
    Scoop politics | 29-08
  • Making tertiary education more accessible to Māori
    29 August 2014 The Māori Party launched its tertiary education policy today at Te Huinga Tauira o Te Mana Ākonga, the national hui for the Māori Teritary Students Association in Palmerston North. Te Tai Hauāuru candidate Chris McKenzie says the...
    Scoop politics | 29-08
  • NZ Sign Language programmes receives $11 million boost
    Deaf Aotearoa are thrilled with Education minister Hekia Parata’s announcement this week that $11 million in funding will go towards a range of New Zealand Sign Language initiatives, including First Signs – a programme that involves sign language...
    Scoop politics | 29-08
  • Abortion violates the Human Rights of Fathers
    Fathers1Right to Life is concerned at the glaring imbalance that exists in law, in regard to the rights of men to defend the lives of the children they have fathered. Fatherhood commences at conception. Children in the womb, just like...
    Scoop politics | 29-08
  • Hundreds to join march against male violence in Auckland CBD
    Hundreds of supporters are expected to join the 'Take Back the Night' march through central Auckland streets tomorrow night in solidarity with making the streets safe for women and the rainbow community to walk without fear of male violence....
    Scoop politics | 29-08
  • Classic example of need for Conservative policy
    The Conservative Party Justice Spokesman, Garth McVicar believes the sentencing of killer Aaron McDonald is a classic example of why an overhaul of the parole and sentencing system is required.”...
    Scoop politics | 29-08
  • Greens & Labour Politicising Bullying in Schools
    Family First NZ says that both the Greens and Labour are wanting to politicise and sexualise school children under the guise of bullying programmes rather than deal with the school bullying issue as it should be dealt with....
    Scoop politics | 29-08
  • Wellington National Is Not Our Future Rally 30/8/14
    Thousands of people will march and rally at National is not our Future events on Saturday. Auckland is the main rally centre with supportive actions in Wellington, Dunedin, Christchurch and Hamilton. In Wellington, marchers will assemble at Te Papa...
    Scoop politics | 29-08
  • EPA grants marine consent for OMV exploration well
    The Environmental Protection Authority has granted a marine consent to OMV New Zealand Ltd for its Whio-1 exploration well in the Taranaki Basin....
    Scoop politics | 29-08
  • First anniversary of the horrific chemical attacks on Syria
    Members of the Syrian Community and friends are commemorating the first anniversary of the horrific chemical attacks on Syria, in Aotea Square on Saturday 30 August 2014, between 11-3 pm. The Assad regimes chemical attacks on al Ghouta were responsible...
    Scoop politics | 28-08
  • Anniversary of the NZ Occupation of German Samoa
    Today, 29th August 2014, marks the 100 years centenary of the occupation of Samoa by New Zealand forces at the request of the British empire, ending the German rule of Samoa. It is also the starting point for the special...
    Scoop politics | 28-08
  • Submissions sought on mosquito repellent
    The Environmental Protection Authority is calling for submissions on a portable mosquito repellent for use outdoors. The repellent consists of a strip impregnated with metofluthrin, a substance from the pyrethroid family....
    Scoop politics | 28-08
  • Spot the difference – the leaders debate
    I watched the Leaders' debate last night and was struck by the fact that John Key accepted all of David Cunliffe's basic assumptions. For example, he did not say that the government should not tell farmers who they could sell...
    Scoop politics | 28-08
  • Colin Craig’s tax figures do not add up and are dishonest
    “Colin Craig’s tax plan is to have two rates of income tax: 0% up to $20,000 and 25% above that. This will leave a $6.4 billion hole in the budget even before the new spending proposed by the Conservatives. The...
    Scoop politics | 28-08
  • Dirty Politics Impacts National Party Support
    Media Release – For Immediate Release Dirty Politics Impacts National Party Support Support for National has dropped by 4.3% to 50.8%, the latest stuff.co.nz / Ipsos political poll shows....
    Scoop politics | 28-08
  • Labour’s environment policy welcomed
    The independent conservation organisation Forest & Bird says that overall the Labour Party’s newly released environment policy would go a long way towards protecting New Zealand’s natural heritage....
    Scoop politics | 28-08
  • National: Not our Future Marches across New Zealand
    Three weeks before the election, action is being taken across the country voicing a rejection of the National Government's track record and direction. Rallies are being held in Auckland, Wellington, Christchurch and Dunedin to oppose National's...
    Scoop politics | 28-08
  • Tune in to tonight’s debate from 7pm
    The countdown is on! You can watch the first leader’s debate for 2014 tonight, 7pm, on TV One ....
    Scoop politics | 28-08
  • Gamblefree Day 1 September
    It's Gamblefree Day this Monday 1 September, the national awareness day for problem gambling in New Zealand. While traditionally celebrated on the first day of September, many events and activities are held both before and after this day to raise...
    Scoop politics | 28-08
  • Success through captioning should be a given as a Right
    Success through captioning should be a given as a Right per the Convention on the Rights of People with Disabilities...
    Scoop politics | 28-08
  • Alcohol Marketing Committee Questions Government’s Motives
    An Independent Expert Committee on Alcohol Advertising and Sponsorship (IECAAS) has been formed out of concern amongst alcohol and public health researchers about the government’s Ministerial Forum on Alcohol Advertising and Sponsorship (MFAAS)....
    Scoop politics | 28-08
  • How Much Higher Can Auckland Prices Go?
    National's plan to liberalise the use of Kiwisaver funds and its proposal to raise ts cheap "Welcome Home" loan thresholds to help buyers purchase a new home has been welcomed by home building companies but attacked as a "welfare scheme...
    Scoop politics | 28-08
  • OPC submission period extended
    We have extended the submission period for the modified reassessment of a bee control affecting five organophosphate and carbamate insecticides (APP202142)....
    Scoop politics | 28-08
  • Vinay Deobhakta struck off roll of barristers and solicitors
    The New Zealand Lawyers and Conveyancers Disciplinary Tribunal has ordered former Tauranga lawyer Vinay Deobhakta to be struck off the roll of barristers and solicitors....
    Scoop politics | 28-08
  • Major parties to front up for Climate Voter election debate
    New Zealand’s main political parties will take part in ‘The Great Climate Voter Debate’ on September 3....
    Scoop politics | 28-08
  • Family violence… too big to be ignored
    As Annah Stretton gears up for her New Zealand Fashion Week show on Thursday she is utilizing her spotlight to help change the face of family violence in this country saying “the problem is far too big to ignore”....
    Scoop politics | 28-08
  • Candidate’s SOS to northern Maori voters: Save our seats!
    (Extract from address by Rev Te Hira Paenga to Kura Hourua Maori Political Leaders hui, in Whangarei this evening)....
    Scoop politics | 28-08
  • Mary O’Neill to Stand for the Alliance in Napier
    The Alliance Party has confirmed Mary O’Neill as the Alliance candidate in the Napier Electorate for the 2014 election....
    Scoop politics | 28-08
  • TONIGHT [28/8/14]: The Great Political Comedy Debate
    It's a night for debating. You could stay home frowning at tonight's Leaders debate, or laugh it up with us at BATS!...
    Scoop politics | 28-08
  • Cunliffe against personal responsibility over billboards
    The accusation by David Cunliffe that the Conservative Party is subscribing to a surveillance society by protecting its billboards via the use of motion sensor cameras reveals an anti-personal responsibility position by the about-to-be-retired Leader...
    Scoop politics | 27-08
  • Groundbreaking health and climate conference
    The World Health Organization (WHO) is holding its first conference on climate change and health at its headquarters in Geneva this week, with New Zealand health experts in attendance....
    Scoop politics | 27-08
  • Te Tai Tokerau Party
    Last night at the Leadership Academy of Company A debate Clinton Dearlove announced the creation of a new political party supported by Whanau and Hapu....
    Scoop politics | 27-08
  • Significant fallout from Dirty Politics allegations
    Dirty politics ... costing National up to 3.8% of its pre-publication support Large numbers of New Zealanders are aware of and talking about the issues raised as a result of the publication of Nicky Hager’s book, Dirty Politics, according to...
    Scoop politics | 27-08
  • Colin Craig is “deluded and dangerous” – Act
    “Colin Craig is proposing a radical transformation of our constitution. The Conservatives are proposing to overthrow of one hundred and fifty odd years of parliamentary democracy and replace it with binding referenda” said ACT Leader Dr Jamie Whyte....
    Scoop politics | 27-08
Images of the election
Public service advertisements by The Standard
x
Unusual punctuation in comments is automatically going into spam. It is a bug. Your message will be extracted manually.