web analytics

Polity: Labour’s fiscal plan: B+

Written By: - Date published: 2:30 pm, June 25th, 2014 - 20 comments
Categories: Economy, election 2014, labour, tax - Tags:

polity_square_for_lynnReposted from Polity.

I’m a glass half-full kind of a guy, so I want to start by emphasising the parts of  Labour’s just-released fiscal plan that I like.

First, the commitment to paying off government debt during economic good times is laudable. In the past, some of our parties have been too quick to demand that any surplus be hocked off immediately in tax cuts or spending binges. Michael Cullen knew the value of paying off debt, and so does David Parker.

The other “fiscal prudence” commitments are also pragmatic and helpful, capping the size of the new spending allowance, and saving again for the future fiscal timebomb with resumed NZ Super Fund contributions.

Second, the tax rate changes are welcome. Everyone knows Labour’s commitment to a CGT which not only makes the tax system fairer, but more importantly it provides an incentive for investors to put their money into productive sectors of the economy, rather than just speculating on capital values of fixed assets. And it is good to see a new tax rate for top income earners, matched to the trust rate to limit opportunities for avoidance. (More on this below…)

Third, targeting tax avoidance by large multinationals is the right thing to do. I have heard some shrug-happy commentators decree that a global race-to-the-bottom on tax rates is inevitable, and that we just have to accept countries like Ireland pulling in tax revenue that should stay in New Zealand. I don’t agree, and I am really pleased to see Labour gearing up for this fight.

So what did I not like? Two main elements here:

First, the top tax rate is still too low. In Australia the top rate (including medicare levy) is 46.5%. In Canada it is around 50% (depending on the Province). In Ireland it is 41%. UK is 45%. USA is around 50-55% (again depending on the State). Ours is 36% + ACC levy, for around 37%.

I think there is room to increase it further, without risking the apocalyptic consequences predicted by the chicken-littles at the Taxpayers Union and other right-wing fronts. Here’s an example for a top-earner. Consider a person who earns USD300,000 (this is the standard KPMG comparison for top earners). In NZD that is around $350,000. How much tax do they pay overall in various countries? Here’s the answer:

CountryOverall tax rate at USD300k income
Ireland44.1%
UK42.3%
Canada40.8%
Australia37.7%
New Zealand (with Labour’s changes)32.6%
New Zealand (2014 rates)30.9%
USA30.5%

As you can see, top earners pay a lot more in most other comparable countries, before and after Labour’s changes.

Second, I am not convinced about the need to signal second term tax cuts. there is a lot of water to go under the bridge until that point, and I think building up expectations this early could be an error. There may also be competing priorities for the money, especially in the education sector.

Overall I would give this package a B+. The big positives are that it is moving in the right direction and is prudent. Smaller negatives is that there are some half measures and some needless populism.

This sets the stage now for a fascinating election campaign where both large parties have well signalled tax-and-spending plans, with pubic costings for people to pore over. That is a whole lot more productive than watching guys in suits excitedly scream “show me the money” at one another.

20 comments on “Polity: Labour’s fiscal plan: B+”

  1. Tom Gould 1

    Top marks to David Parker and his team. Now, where’s National’s fiscal plan?

  2. Ad 2

    Just great to see Labour in front of a policy story finally.
    And no, I would not change a thing.

    Some will quibble that the top tax rate, trusts rate and company rate should all be equalised. Fortunately Labour are not dumb enough to fall for making companies less competitive here.

    In fact it sends the right signal: it’s more tax efficient to start up your own company, and go out into the world and make something fresh happen.

    And as for there being lower taxes for the top rate than in other countries, well, welcome back you successful New Zealanders. Door is open, and bring all your savings with you.

  3. bad12 3

    Marvelous, simply marvelous, according to Labour it is the ”time-bomb” of aging in our country that sees it having to invoke raising the age of entitlement to superannuation,

    Is this Post correct, Labour have signaled tax cuts for the middle class in a second term of Government???

    The two go hand in glove, raising the age of entitlement to superannuation pays for tax cuts, its a pretty simply piece of riffmatic,

    i really enjoyed David Parker’s setting aside of a financial pile with which to directly attack child poverty, you know the stuff, the child poverty that Labour have waved about endlessly during the current Parliament, including in posts here at the Standard,

    Oh right, there is no such monies being budgeted for…

    • tinfoilhat 3.1

      @bad12….yes quite true I sometimes wonder why labour and national don’t give up the pretence and just have done with it and merge.

      • bad12 3.1.1

        Although the Post identifies Parker as having signaled ”second term tax cuts” i have yet to see confirmation of this,

        Having said that, IF true and ”second term tax cuts” are the agenda then we all are being gamed by Labour, especially so when we care to consider the elongated cries of 280,000 children living in poverty from the likes of Jacinda and (in a post here at the Standard), Phill Twyford,

        What happened in the Governments books last time we faced this so called financial crisis of an aging population time-bomb and resulting raising of the age of entitlement to superannuation, TAX CUTS, the first in the form of Working For Families, the second in National’s Tax Switch,

        i have been in Taiho mode in my comments opposing the raising of the age of entitlement for a while,(since it was pointed out that population expectations pointed to there being less workers in the economy, despite my pointing out that based on historic data GDP will double in dollar terms in the next 30 years),

        But, IF it is true,(and at present i only have this Post to base my comments upon), and Labour are now proposing ”second term tax cuts” then my opinion says we are being ”Gamed” by Labour, not only over its ”concerns” surrounding child poverty but also its ”claims” of unaffordable superannuation in the future,

        The alternative budget from David Parker to me smacks of something Sir(spit) Roger Douglas would have proudly proposed…

    • Colonial Viper 3.2

      bad12 you curmudgeon stop pointing out these inconvenient facts

    • Bearded Git 3.3

      More policy to be released on this bad12; give them a chance.

      • bad12 3.3.1

        The vows of silence are only dished out by the Mods thanks Bearded Git, if David Parker chooses to release economic policy which has no apparent component which directly attacks child poverty then He is asking for criticism…

      • lurgee 3.3.2

        “More policy to be released on this bad12; give them a chance.”

        Give ’em six more months, you mean?

  4. ianmac 4

    Great points for discussion thanks Polity. (But excluding your ” …..with pubic costings for people to pore over. “

  5. Ennui 5

    The devil is in the detail. Two bits I really like:

    1. Targeting to get unemployment down to 4%. Really good BUT full employment is a better goal, plus adding making wages livable.
    2. The Kiwi power plan. great to see a recognition that power is made artificially expensive by the current “market”. As it works as a cartel and avoids any “price discovery” it might as well be regulated.
  6. Colonial Viper 6

    First, the commitment to paying off government debt during economic good times is laudable.

    So…where exactly are these “good economic times” to be found for the bottom 80% of this country

    • Colonial Viper 6.1

      So as 300,000 Kiwi kids live in poverty day to day, and the retirement age just HAS to go up, we’re going to set aside money to pay back the Goldman Sachs and JP Morgans of the world.

      Shit its a hard compromise.

    • Lanthanide 6.2

      Looking at the detail, it’s a bit of a hollow promise.

      They are saying they will get to 3% net crown debt, including the superannuation fund, by 2020-2021. This compares to National’s 2014 budget which puts them at 3.7% net crown debt on the same basis in that time-frame. In otherwords Labour are barely doing anything different than National.

      Of course National has racked up such a massive debt the only way to combat it would be to massively cut down on tax fraud (apparently $7b per year) as well as restructure the tax system radically, the latter of which is politically unpalatable and the former of which they have very modest aims for ($200m per year by 2020).

  7. dave 7

    i also really like crack down on tax avoidance and since the farmers don’t pay any tax but use all the services the rest of us pay for its about bloody time they paid there share

  8. Herodotus 8

    Michael Cullen knew the value of paying off debt,- really citation required, as data below shows that debt levels slightly increased
    http://www.stats.govt.nz/browse_for_stats/snapshots-of-nz/Measuring-NZ-progress-sustainable-dev-%20approach/sustainable-development/economic-resilience.aspx
    http://www.rbnz.govt.nz/statistics/discontinued/
    1999 NZ Govt Debt $17.384b
    2008 Dec $18.86b. It marginally Increased !!!!
    “but more importantly it provides an incentive for investors to put their money into productive sectors of the economy, rather than just speculating on capital values of fixed assets” So if I had the available funds and invested into a business I pay …. 28% tax on the profits and if I invest into property I pay …. 15% CTG so how can being on a lower tax rate motivate me into changing any investment decisions. Especially given that should property inflation cause the RB to consider increasing interest rates I will be instead subsidised with rates NOT increasing but Kiwisaver rates being increased instead – “Instead of paying more interest on your mortgage, a similar amount of extra savings would go into your KiwiSaver,” Parker told an Auckland breakfast.
    http://www.nbr.co.nz/article/labour-use-kiwisaver-instead-interest-rates-drop-dollar-bd-155356
    perhaps a B- would be a more appropriate grade.

    • Lanthanide 8.1

      “Michael Cullen knew the value of paying off debt,- really citation required, as data below shows that debt levels slightly increased”

      The point is, Cullen used a lot of the ‘surplusses’ to pay back crown debt, instead of spending it or giving tax cuts, as he was hounded by National and latterly the media to do.

      If he hadn’t, we would have been up shit creek during the GFC and of course the Canterbury earthquakes.

      That’s all the proof you need – that he spent a significant portion of each budget ‘surplus’ on debt reduction.

  9. Jepenseque 9

    Hi, The proposed capital gains tax is projected to be earning $1.035B by fy20/21. What assumptions for asset price inflation is used to reach these numbers? That implies circa 6.9b in realised taxable cap gains in that year. Particularly interested in what this implies for house price inflation.

    Labours release says modelled by berl but cant find it anywhere. Cheers

  10. Sable 10

    Would be nice to see something emphatic from Labour on the TPPA and dismantling the spy laws/apparatus. Fiscal plan is a little bland but could be worse….

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

  • NZ fisheries depend on the environment – they should protect it
    The attitude of the fishing industry and the National Government to our oceans, and the life within it, still amazes me. Like many New Zealanders, I find it perplexing that an industry which depends entirely on the long-term health of ...
    GreensBy Eugenie Sage
    41 mins ago
  • Bigger is not always better with local government reform
    I have written previously about the overwhelming opposition expressed by local councils and community members to the latest Local Government reforms.  The Select Committee heard more submissions this week, specifically about some of the unintended consequences that may arise from ...
    GreensBy Jan Logie
    1 hour ago
  • Labour calls for state of emergency on homelessness
    Labour’s housing spokesperson Phil Twyford is calling on the Government to declare a state of emergency over the nation’s homelessness crisis. “There are 42,000 people homeless and living in severe housing stress while the National Government behaves like a possum ...
    1 day ago
  • Labour calls for state of emergency on homelessness
    Labour’s housing spokesperson Phil Twyford is calling on the Government to declare a state of emergency over the nation’s homelessness crisis. “There are 42,000 people homeless and living in severe housing stress while the National Government behaves like a possum ...
    1 day ago
  • Government must review state sector retirement investment
    The State Sector Retirement Savings Scheme has no business investing in companies which manufacture cluster bombs, anti-personnel mines and nuclear weapons, Labour MP and Parliamentarians for Global Action executive member Su’a William Sio says. “I endorse the call made by the ...
    2 days ago
  • Councils shouldn’t rush into Easter Trading
    City and district councils must ensure they don’t rush into trading on Easter Sunday ahead of local body elections next month, Labour’s Pacific Islands Affairs spokesperson Su’a William Sio says. “This decision must be taken seriously and only after extensive ...
    2 days ago
  • Minister can’t wash hands of illegal KiwiSaver investments
    The Minister responsible for appointing default KiwiSaver providers should take responsibility for ensuring they act legally, Labour’s Finance spokesperson Grant Robertson says. “The National Government has now had confirmed what they were told more than a week ago – that ...
    2 days ago
  • Fixing our broken economy
    Globally, the “neo-liberal” consensus is rapidly vanishing (I use quotation marks because there are some in Aotearoa who deny such a thing as neo-liberalism exists). Regardless of the debate around its meaning, neo-liberal is a useful descriptor for the general ...
    GreensBy Julie Anne Genter
    3 days ago
  • Fixing our broken economy
    Globally, the “neo-liberal” consensus is rapidly vanishing (I use quotation marks because there are some in Aotearoa who deny such a thing as neo-liberalism exists). Regardless of the debate around its meaning, neo-liberal is a useful descriptor for the general ...
    GreensBy Julie Anne Genter
    3 days ago
  • Government railroading Maori Land Bill through
    Maori Development Minister Te Ururoa Flavell seems determined to railroad his Te Ture Whenua Maori Bill through despite the large number of submitters in opposition to the bill, says MP Meka Whaitiri, whose Ikaroa-Rāwhiti electorate contains nearly 30 per cent ...
    3 days ago
  • A national day to commemorate NZ land wars
    It’s fantastic that the government has agreed to a hold a national day commemorating the New Zealand land wars. Announced at Kingi Tūheitia’s 10th koroneihana celebrations, alongside the return of Rangiriri Pā to the Kingitanga, the news marked a significant ...
    GreensBy Marama Davidson
    3 days ago
  • A national day to commemorate NZ land wars
    It’s fantastic that the government has agreed to a hold a national day commemorating the New Zealand land wars. Announced at Kingi Tūheitia’s 10th koroneihana celebrations, alongside the return of Rangiriri Pā to the Kingitanga, the news marked a significant ...
    GreensBy Marama Davidson
    3 days ago
  • Government turns a blind eye to struggling sole parents
    Social Development Minister Anne Tolley’s claims that her Government’s work with sole parents is her biggest success are in tatters after a major increase in homelessness amongst that group, says Labour’s Social Development spokesperson Carmel Sepuloni. “Anne Tolley is seriously ...
    3 days ago
  • Time has come for state apology on abuse
    Labour is today calling on the Government to issue an apology for historic abuse in state institutions. Speaking after the launch of Elizabeth Stanley’s book “The Road to Hell; state violence against Children in Post-war New Zealand”, Labour’s Justice spokesperson ...
    3 days ago
  • It’s OK to have a few slaves, just not too many? Minimum wage loophole hasn’t gone away
    New Zealand still needs legislation to ensure adult New Zealanders are not exploited by being taken on as contractors for less than the equivalent of the minimum wage, says Labour list MP David Parker.  “My Minimum Wage (Contractor Remuneration) Amendment ...
    3 days ago
  • Lessons from the Future of Work Commission: Building Wealth from the Ground Up
    Good morning, and thank you for attending today’s Future of Work Seminar here in Wellington. I want to particularly acknowledge Beth Houston who has spent many hours pulling together the programme for today’s event, and to Olivier and the staff ...
    3 days ago
  • Cooking 4 Change at the Auckland City Mission
    On Tuesday evening I participated in the launch of the ‘Cooking 4 Change’ recipe book, which Metiria and I both contributed our favourite recipes to. Along with Dick Frizzell, Trelise Cooper, Tiki Taane, Erin Simpson, Jono & Ben, Colin Mathura-Jeffree, a couple ...
    GreensBy James Shaw
    4 days ago
  • Cooking 4 Change at the Auckland City Mission
    On Tuesday evening I participated in the launch of the ‘Cooking 4 Change’ recipe book, which Metiria and I both contributed our favourite recipes to. Along with Dick Frizzell, Trelise Cooper, Tiki Taane, Erin Simpson, Jono & Ben, Colin Mathura-Jeffree, a couple ...
    GreensBy James Shaw
    4 days ago
  • Backbencher Matt’s Bill is a Doocey
    The latest National Member’s Bill pulled from the ballot is yet another waste of Parliament’s time and shows the Government’s contempt for the House and the public with much more important issues needing debate, says Labour’s Shadow Leader of the ...
    4 days ago
  • Gun laws creaking under the strain
     Questions have to be asked  after surprising revelations at the Law and Order Select Committee about the police and their ability to manage the gun problem in New Zealand, says Labour’s Police spokesperson Stuart Nash.  “The lack of resources is ...
    4 days ago
  • Most homeless are working poor – Otago Uni
    The finding by Otago University researcher Dr Kate Amore that most homeless people are in work or study is one of the most shocking aspects of the housing crisis, says Labour’s Housing spokesperson Phil Twyford. “Social service agencies report many ...
    4 days ago
  • Māori seats entrenched by Tirikatene Bill
    National and the Māori Party need to support my member’s Bill which is designed to entrench the Māori electorate seats in Parliament, Labour’s Te Tai Tonga MP Rino Tirikatene says. “Under the Electoral Act the provisions establishing the general electorates ...
    4 days ago
  • Trade dumping bill could hurt NZ industries
    The Commerce Select Committee is currently hearing submissions on the Trade (Anti-dumping and Countervailing Duties) Amendment Bill. This bill worries me. I flagged some major concerns during its first reading.   I am now reading submissions from NZ Steel, ...
    GreensBy Mojo Mathers
    5 days ago
  • Just 8 per cent of work visas for skills shortages
    Just 16,000 – or 8 per cent – of the 209,000 work visas issued last year were for occupations for which there is an identified skills shortage, says Labour Immigration spokesperson Iain Lees-Galloway. “The overwhelming majority of the record number ...
    5 days ago
  • Hard won agreement shouldn’t be thrown away
    The Government should ignore talk across the Tasman about doing away with the labelling of GM free products, says Labour’s Health spokesperson Annette King. “Labelling of genetically modified products was a hard won agreement in 2001 by Australian and the ...
    5 days ago
  • National’s privatisation Trojan horse
     The National government is using the need to modernise the school system as a Trojan horse for privatisation and an end to free public education as we know it, Labour’s Education spokesperson Chris Hipkins says.  “There is no doubt that ...
    5 days ago
  • Shameless land-banking ads show need for crackdown
    The fact that more than 300 sections are shamelessly being advertised on Trade Me as land-banking opportunities during a housing crisis shows the need for a crackdown on property speculators, Leader of the Opposition Andrew Little says. “Of the 328 ...
    5 days ago
  • Standard and Poor’s warning of housing crisis impact on banks
    The National Government’s failure to address the housing crisis is leading to dire warnings from ratings agency Standard and Poor’s about the impact on the strength of the economy and New Zealand banks, says Labour’s Finance spokesperson Grant Robertson. “Standard ...
    5 days ago
  • Ihumatao needs action not sympathy
    The Petition of Save Our Unique Landscape (SOUL) calling on Parliament to revoke Special Housing Area 62 in order to protect the Ihumatao Peninsula and Stonefields, has fallen on deaf ears, says the Labour MP for Mangere Su’a William Sio.  ...
    5 days ago
  • Another delay to justice system reform for victims of sexual violence
    I believe most, if not all, New Zealanders would expect our court system to uphold the dignity of complainants, hold perpetrators to account for crimes including sexual and domestic violence and uphold the crucial right to a fair trial. Yet ...
    GreensBy Jan Logie
    5 days ago
  • Another delay to justice system reform for victims of sexual violence
    I believe most, if not all, New Zealanders would expect our court system to uphold the dignity of complainants, hold perpetrators to account for crimes including sexual and domestic violence and uphold the crucial right to a fair trial. Yet ...
    GreensBy Jan Logie
    5 days ago
  • Student visa fraud & exploitation must stop
    The Government must act immediately to end fraud and exploitation of international students that threatens to damage New Zealand’s reputation, Leader of the Opposition Andrew Little says. ...
    6 days ago
  • Government needs to show leadership in reviewing monetary policy
    The Reserve Bank’s struggles to meet its inflation target, the rising exchange rate and the continued housing crisis shows current monetary policy needs to be reviewed - with amendments to the policy targets agreement a bare minimum, says Labour’s Finance ...
    6 days ago
  • Local democracy under threat
    The National Government is in the process of gutting our local democracy through it’s Local Government Act 2002 Amendment Bill (No 2). We’ve been hearing submissions from councils, and a few community members, all around the country who are deeply ...
    GreensBy Jan Logie
    6 days ago
  • Local democracy under threat
    The National Government is in the process of gutting our local democracy through it’s Local Government Act 2002 Amendment Bill (No 2). We’ve been hearing submissions from councils, and a few community members, all around the country who are deeply ...
    GreensBy Jan Logie
    6 days ago
  • Slash and burn of special education support
    Slashing the support for school age children with special needs is no way to fund earlier intervention, Labour’s Education Spokesperson Chris Hipkins says.  “National’s latest plan to slash funding for children with special needs over the age of 7 in ...
    1 week ago
  • National’s Pasifika MPs must have free vote
      Pacific people will not take kindly to the Government whipping their Pacific MPs to vote in favour of a  Bill that will allow Sunday trading  at Easter, says Labour’s Pacific Island Affairs spokesperson Su’a William Sio.  “We are seeing ...
    1 week ago
  • Maritime Crimes Bill – balancing security and free speech
    Parliament is currently considering the Maritime Crimes Amendment Bill, which would bring New Zealand up to date with current international rules about maritime security. The debate around the Bill reflects two valid issues: legitimate counter-terrorism measures and the right to ...
    GreensBy Kennedy Graham
    1 week ago
  • Rio Olympics captioning – setting the record straight
    In the House on Thursday, my colleague, Labour Party spokesperson on Disability Issues, Poto Williams asked a great question. After which the Minister, Nicky Wagner, stood up and finally publicly acknowledged the National Foundation for the Deaf for funding the ...
    GreensBy Mojo Mathers
    1 week ago
  • Rio Olympics captioning – setting the record straight
    In the House on Thursday, my colleague, Labour Party spokesperson on Disability Issues, Poto Williams asked a great question. After which the Minister, Nicky Wagner, stood up and finally publicly acknowledged the National Foundation for the Deaf for funding the ...
    GreensBy Mojo Mathers
    1 week ago
  • Teachers’ low wages at the centre of shortages
      Figures that show teachers’ wages have grown the slowest of all occupations is at the heart of the current teacher shortage, says Labour’s Education Spokesperson Chris Hipkins.  In the latest Labour Cost Index, education professionals saw their wages grow ...
    1 week ago
  • Government’s Tax Law undermines common law principles
    A tax amendment being snuck in under the radar allows changes to tax issues to be driven through by the Government without Parliamentary scrutiny, says Labour’s Revenue spokesman Stuart Nash. “The amendment allows any part of the Tax Administration Act ...
    1 week ago
  • Government slippery about caption funding
      The Government has refused to apologise for taking the credit for funding Olympic Games captioning when the National Foundation for the Deaf  was responsible, says Labour’s spokesperson on Disability Issues Poto Williams.  “This shameful act of grandstanding by Ministers ...
    2 weeks ago
  • Default KiwiSaver investments should be reviewed
    The investments of the default KiwiSaver providers should be reviewed to make sure they are in line with New Zealanders’ values and expectations, says Labour’s Finance spokesperson Grant Robertson. “Most New Zealanders would be appalled that their KiwiSaver funds are ...
    2 weeks ago
  • New ministry should look after all children
    The Government has today shunned well founded pleas by experts not to call its new agency the Ministry for Vulnerable Children, Labour’s Spokesperson for Children Jacinda Ardern says.  “Well respected organisations and individuals such as Children's Commissioner Judge Andrew Becroft ...
    2 weeks ago
  • Triclosan – nasty chemical will be reassessed
    Last week my campaign for this chemical to be reassessed by the Environmental Protection Authority (EPA) took another step forward. After many months of waiting, the EPA have agreed that triclosan needs to be reassessed. Triclosan is an ingredient in many ...
    GreensBy Catherine Delahunty
    2 weeks ago
  • Triclosan – nasty chemical will be reassessed
    Last week my campaign for this chemical to be reassessed by the Environmental Protection Authority (EPA) took another step forward. After many months of waiting, the EPA have agreed that triclosan needs to be reassessed. Triclosan is an ingredient in many ...
    GreensBy Catherine Delahunty
    2 weeks ago
  • Ratification okay but we need action
    Today’s decision to ratify the Paris agreement on Climate Change by the end of the year is all well and good but where is the plan, says Labour’s Climate Change spokesperson Megan Woods.  “The Government’s failure to plan is planning ...
    2 weeks ago
  • Stats changes can’t hide unemployment reality
    Today’s minor drop in unemployment numbers is nothing to celebrate given the changes made to the official numbers that cut thousands of people looking for work out of the jobless rate, says Labour’s Employment spokesperson Grant Robertson. “Making any comparisons ...
    2 weeks ago
  • Stats changes can’t hide unemployment reality
    Today’s minor drop in unemployment numbers is nothing to celebrate given the changes made to the official numbers that cut thousands of people looking for work out of the jobless rate, says Labour’s Employment spokesperson Grant Robertson. “Making any comparisons ...
    2 weeks ago

Public service advertisements by The Standard

Current CO2 level in the atmosphere