Tale four – the Death of Philip McHardy. Killed 31 August 2011 – struck by a tree

Written By: - Date published: 7:35 pm, July 25th, 2013 - 7 comments
Categories: health and safety, workers' rights - Tags:

I have collected up the available documentation on the men killed in the forest since 2008. I am going to try, using the documents I have, to tell their story – one at a time. I haven’t been able to contact all the families of these men and hope if any of them read them, they are not surprised or upset to see the details set out like this.   You can find the first three blogs here and here and here.

Philip McHardy was killed while working in a pine plantation block in Overton Forest Winton on 31 August 2011.  He worked for Don Contracting and was working in a Southern Forest NZ Ltd managed forest.  Don Contracting employed 5 employees at the time.    Philip has worked for 18 months for the company.

The crew started work at 7.15am.  Philip was felling trees while the rest of the crew were doing other work.  Just after 1pm, a tree blew over on top of him and killed him.  He had 20 years experience.  It is unclear if Philip had taken any breaks that day.

Workers working on that day gave various accounts of the wind when they started work.  One said that at the time he started there was already a “reasonable breeze” blowing.  Others said that by 10.20am the wind started to pick up.  The investigation report by the DOL references the MetService reports for the day.  They recorded winds of between 20-35 km/h in the area with a cold front on the way.    After lunch one worker had actually started down to talk to Philip about the weather getting worse but had got called away to another task.  A truck driver arrived on the site and witnessed the tree falling on Philip – it was the last tree in the stand and he was about to fell it but it fell before being cut.

The regulations for forestry were changed in December 2012.  The previous regulations applied when this accident happened.  Listed under Employers general duties it said:

“The employer or person in charge shall suspend all operations when adverse weather creates significant hazards that cannot be satisfactorily controlled”.

In the new regulations this duty has been removed from employers and shifted to the  employees !

The provisions now say:

Hazard management

 2.8.1 All employees must identify and regularly review hazards in the place of work (existing, new and potential) to determine whether

they are “significant hazards” and require further action.

 2.8.2 Operations that are affected by adverse weather or other events shall be suspended if hazardous conditions cannot be satisfactorily controlled.

The new code was written by the forestry employers and signed off by the  Minister.  On weather conditions, it is significantly inferior to the Australian standards and it is unclear why the duties have now been shifted to the worker.  This is likely inconsistent with the Act.

The tree that killed Philip was the last tree in the stand.  These are known to be dangerous as they have often grown protected by other trees so have small root balls and are less stable.  They are also  very exposed to the wind when standing alone making them more dangerous.  The investigation report notes that there is no guidance on the risks of the last tree standing in the old ACOP.  This has not changed in the new regulations despite this accident – there is no recognition that the response to weather conditions might very depending on the risks at hand.

The investigation report notes that hazards were regularly discussed and a Pre Operation Physical Hazard Identification was conducted for this work but wind was not on the list.  No investigation into hours of work, employment standards or production requirements is recorded neither is any description of the system in place in this worksite to recognize and manage hazards.  It is unclear what the process was if people had concerns or to identify emerging  risks.

The employer insisted that the wind was not out of the ordinary that day and if it had been Philip would not have been working.  Employee interviews record that employees felt able to stop if they thought the weather was bad – no inquiry was made into  if they would be paid for stopping or in fact if they had ever stopped on their own accord.  This “worker control” approach seems inconsistent with the regulations and with the revelations that one worker at least was going to talk to Philip about the weather before he diverted and the fact a tree blew over.  The inspector found no breach of the Health and Safety Act.

The Coroner held an inquiry into this death.  The truck driver who witnessed the accident gave evidence of seeing that tree swinging and bending over at the top with the wind.  “I would estimate that it was bent over by five-six meters at the top.  It was still held at the bottom”  He then saw  the tree get pulled out of the ground by the wind and fall.

The Coroner found that on the 31 August 2011 at Overton Forest, weather conditions were poor and the wind was increasing.  He noted that all the witnesses at the hearing made mention of the fact of strong winds but because they thought the area Phillip was working in was sheltered they did not suspend operations.  This was despite the fact they had seen other trees falling down on the skyline.  The Coroner on a slight margin accepted the employer did not have a duty to call the operation off in the circumstances of the day because Philip was autonomous in this aspect of his work.  He found he “was a hard worker, wanting to please and because of his work ethic, has continued with the tree felling in adverse conditions, wanting to get the job finished”.

The evidence at the Coroners hearing also concluded:

  • that the trees being felled had small root balls and were easy to push over with diggers – this appears not to have been considered a hazard.
  • the ground was soft after several days of rain making the soil weaker; and
  •  the ground on which Philip was working  was water logged from water run off following the construction of an access track that pushed water over the area – again not noted as a hazard.

There was no evidence of any drug use.

The coroner found the accident occurred with the bringing together of a number of contributing factors including the wind and those factors noted above.  He  also felt that Philip working alone was part of the scenario leading to his death (had someone been nearby he may have had a caution given).

At 10.43am that morning, Philip had sent a text to his wife saying the area was getting windy – by lunch time he was dead.

At 3pm that day one of his children received a text from someone,  who heard it on the grapevine, that his dad had been killed.  He was the first in the family to know – the police notified his widow at 6.30 that evening.

 

 

 

7 comments on “Tale four – the Death of Philip McHardy. Killed 31 August 2011 – struck by a tree ”

  1. jim 1

    Lady lets hope your comment does not go by like the wind that the coroner described.Blown away without any overseeing care.

  2. Arfamo 2

    It’s a tragedy Helen. I can see how the laxer regs and operating method and poor risk management all operated against this worker.

  3. tricledrown 3

    Rural workers in this country are being exploited by greedy employers because they are isolated and easily manipulated by these employers!
    Long hours, poor conditions,, abuse, pay delays, no pay!

  4. CnrJoe 4

    good grief. the worker is responsible for hazard management? and if the boss says otherwise?- what? theres no pressure?
    Excellent work by the ctu.

    • Chris 4.1

      just because you work for a contractor & you have a ticket does not make the contractor or the company hiring the contractor any less liable than the worker. if you have a look at my comment below, ive stated some facts from the health & safety employment act that anybody who hires has a legal obligation, regardless of any contract that may have been signed, to take all practical steps to ensure the health & safety of staff on site. its a pity that workers don’t know their rights a little bit better. contractors & management have been brainwashing workers on their legal rights as an employer since adam was in nappies.

  5. Chris 5

    hi this is a sad fact about our industry forest owners’ & contractors can not be trusted to make these decisions to pull guys out of the felling zone or breaker outs off the extraction line. you see if they done this then the contractor would be eligible 4 compensation 4 loss of production so they eliminate cost & liability by giving the guys tickets & there lies the responsibility on the worker 2 pull the pin ….this is a rarity it is not encouraged by management or contractors & it is a mental obligation on the worker to keep the crew going. you see they have tickets to protect management & contractors but no ticket 4 the workers 2 gauge wind & rain ………another classic example of company & contractor skipping liability they will give the fellers felling tickets but no over head hazard ticket ….also they have time to audit your stumps yet no time to educate or train the fellers THIS IS WHY WE AS WORKERS NEED AN INDEPENDENT AUTHORITY TO OVER RULE THIS BLATANT NEGLICT OF WORKERS under the h/s employment act 1992 it states that an employer which is anyone who employs; hires or rewards and in relation to any employee which means an employer of the employee..and includes; in relation to any person employed by the chief executive or other employee of a crown organisation…….as I understand the owners & contractors are just as liable as the worker …….it also states the employer [contractor…forest owners ] must take ALL PRACTIAL STEPS TO ENSURE THE HEALTH & SAFETY OF THE EMPLOYEE this is section 2a 1 & 2a2 of the code … and also section 6 a,b;c;d;e TAPS (take all practical steps)…….so legally how do they slip through the net surely they’re accountable 4 neglect!
    The pathetic thing about this situation is there’s no need for people to die while felling in heavy winds. this is the second case ive known of in the past 4-5 years. I guess there will be more. if there was compensation for the contractor & worker there wouldn’t be any deaths relating to bad weather. once again profit before people. this is why we need independent regulation. people for the people

Links to post

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

  • Anzac Commemorative Address – NZ National Service, Chunuk Bair
    Distinguished guests -   It is an honour to return once again to this site which, as the resting place for so many of our war-dead, has become a sacred place for generations of New Zealanders.   Our presence here and at the other special spaces of Gallipoli is made ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 hours ago
  • Anzac Commemorative Address – Dawn Service, Gallipoli, Türkiye
    Mai ia tawhiti pamamao, te moana nui a Kiwa, kua tae whakaiti mai matou, ki to koutou papa whenua. No koutou te tapuwae, no matou te tapuwae, kua honoa pumautia.   Ko nga toa kua hinga nei, o te Waipounamu, o te Ika a Maui, he okioki tahi me o ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    10 hours ago
  • PM announces changes to portfolios
    Paul Goldsmith will take on responsibility for the Media and Communications portfolio, while Louise Upston will pick up the Disability Issues portfolio, Prime Minister Christopher Luxon announced today. “Our Government is relentlessly focused on getting New Zealand back on track. As issues change in prominence, I plan to adjust Ministerial ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • New catch limits for unique fishery areas
    Recreational catch limits will be reduced in areas of Fiordland and the Chatham Islands to help keep those fisheries healthy and sustainable, Oceans and Fisheries Minister Shane Jones says. The lower recreational daily catch limits for a range of finfish and shellfish species caught in the Fiordland Marine Area and ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • Minister welcomes hydrogen milestone
    Energy Minister Simeon Brown has welcomed an important milestone in New Zealand’s hydrogen future, with the opening of the country’s first network of hydrogen refuelling stations in Wiri. “I want to congratulate the team at Hiringa Energy and its partners K one W one (K1W1), Mitsui & Co New Zealand ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • Urgent changes to system through first RMA Amendment Bill
    The coalition Government is delivering on its commitment to improve resource management laws and give greater certainty to consent applicants, with a Bill to amend the Resource Management Act (RMA) expected to be introduced to Parliament next month. RMA Reform Minister Chris Bishop has today outlined the first RMA Amendment ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Overseas decommissioning models considered
    Overseas models for regulating the oil and gas sector, including their decommissioning regimes, are being carefully scrutinised as a potential template for New Zealand’s own sector, Resources Minister Shane Jones says. The Coalition Government is focused on rebuilding investor confidence in New Zealand’s energy sector as it looks to strengthen ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Release of North Island Severe Weather Event Inquiry
    Emergency Management and Recovery Minister Mark Mitchell has today released the Report of the Government Inquiry into the response to the North Island Severe Weather Events. “The report shows that New Zealand’s emergency management system is not fit-for-purpose and there are some significant gaps we need to address,” Mr Mitchell ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Justice Minister to attend Human Rights Council
    Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith is today travelling to Europe where he’ll update the United Nations Human Rights Council on the Government’s work to restore law and order.  “Attending the Universal Periodic Review in Geneva provides us with an opportunity to present New Zealand’s human rights progress, priorities, and challenges, while ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Patterson reopens world’s largest wool scouring facility
    Associate Agriculture Minister, Mark Patterson, formally reopened the world’s largest wool processing facility today in Awatoto, Napier, following a $50 million rebuild and refurbishment project. “The reopening of this facility will significantly lift the economic opportunities available to New Zealand’s wool sector, which already accounts for 20 per cent of ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Speech to the Southland Otago Regional Engineering Collective Summit, 18 April 2024
    Hon Andrew Bayly, Minister for Small Business and Manufacturing  At the Southland Otago Regional Engineering Collective (SOREC) Summit, 18 April, Dunedin    Ngā mihi nui, Ko Andrew Bayly aho, Ko Whanganui aho    Good Afternoon and thank you for inviting me to open your summit today.    I am delighted ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Government to introduce revised Three Strikes law
    The Government is delivering on its commitment to bring back the Three Strikes legislation, Associate Justice Minister Nicole McKee announced today. “Our Government is committed to restoring law and order and enforcing appropriate consequences on criminals. We are making it clear that repeat serious violent or sexual offending is not ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • New diplomatic appointments
    Foreign Minister Winston Peters has today announced four new diplomatic appointments for New Zealand’s overseas missions.   “Our diplomats have a vital role in maintaining and protecting New Zealand’s interests around the world,” Mr Peters says.    “I am pleased to announce the appointment of these senior diplomats from the ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Humanitarian support for Ethiopia and Somalia
    New Zealand is contributing NZ$7 million to support communities affected by severe food insecurity and other urgent humanitarian needs in Ethiopia and Somalia, Foreign Minister Rt Hon Winston Peters announced today.   “Over 21 million people are in need of humanitarian assistance across Ethiopia, with a further 6.9 million people ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Arts Minister congratulates Mataaho Collective
    Minister for Arts, Culture and Heritage Paul Goldsmith is congratulating Mataaho Collective for winning the Golden Lion for best participant in the main exhibition at the Venice Biennale. "Congratulations to the Mataaho Collective for winning one of the world's most prestigious art prizes at the Venice Biennale.  “It is good ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Supporting better financial outcomes for Kiwis
    The Government is reforming financial services to improve access to home loans and other lending, and strengthen customer protections, Commerce and Consumer Affairs Minister Andrew Bayly and Housing Minister Chris Bishop announced today. “Our coalition Government is committed to rebuilding the economy and making life simpler by cutting red tape. We are ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Trade relationship with China remains strong
    “China remains a strong commercial opportunity for Kiwi exporters as Chinese businesses and consumers continue to value our high-quality safe produce,” Trade and Agriculture Minister Todd McClay says.   Mr McClay has returned to New Zealand following visits to Beijing, Harbin and Shanghai where he met ministers, governors and mayors and engaged in trade and agricultural events with the New ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • PM’s South East Asia mission does the business
    Prime Minister Christopher Luxon has completed a successful trip to Singapore, Thailand and the Philippines, deepening relationships and capitalising on opportunities. Mr Luxon was accompanied by a business delegation and says the choice of countries represents the priority the New Zealand Government places on South East Asia, and our relationships in ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • $41m to support clean energy in South East Asia
    New Zealand is demonstrating its commitment to reducing global greenhouse emissions, and supporting clean energy transition in South East Asia, through a contribution of NZ$41 million (US$25 million) in climate finance to the Asian Development Bank (ADB)-led Energy Transition Mechanism (ETM). Prime Minister Christopher Luxon and Climate Change Minister Simon Watts announced ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Minister releases Fast-track stakeholder list
    The Government is today releasing a list of organisations who received letters about the Fast-track applications process, says RMA Reform Minister Chris Bishop. “Recently Ministers and agencies have received a series of OIA requests for a list of organisations to whom I wrote with information on applying to have a ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Judicial appointments announced
    Attorney-General Judith Collins today announced the appointment of Wellington Barrister David Jonathan Boldt as a Judge of the High Court, and the Honourable Justice Matthew Palmer as a Judge of the Court of Appeal. Justice Boldt graduated with an LLB from Victoria University of Wellington in 1990, and also holds ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Education Minister heads to major teaching summit in Singapore
    Education Minister Erica Stanford will lead the New Zealand delegation at the 2024 International Summit on the Teaching Profession (ISTP) held in Singapore. The delegation includes representatives from the Post Primary Teachers’ Association (PPTA) Te Wehengarua and the New Zealand Educational Institute (NZEI) Te Riu Roa.  The summit is co-hosted ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • Value of stopbank project proven during cyclone
    A stopbank upgrade project in Tairawhiti partly funded by the Government has increased flood resilience for around 7000ha of residential and horticultural land so far, Regional Development Minister Shane Jones says. Mr Jones today attended a dawn service in Gisborne to mark the end of the first stage of the ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • Anzac commemorations, Türkiye relationship focus of visit
    Foreign Affairs Minister Winston Peters will represent the Government at Anzac Day commemorations on the Gallipoli Peninsula next week and engage with senior representatives of the Turkish government in Istanbul.    “The Gallipoli campaign is a defining event in our history. It will be a privilege to share the occasion ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • Minister to Europe for OECD meeting, Anzac Day
    Science, Innovation and Technology and Defence Minister Judith Collins will next week attend the OECD Science and Technology Ministerial conference in Paris and Anzac Day commemorations in Belgium. “Science, innovation and technology have a major role to play in rebuilding our economy and achieving better health, environmental and social outcomes ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • Comprehensive Partnership the goal for NZ and the Philippines
    Prime Minister Christopher Luxon held a bilateral meeting today with the President of the Philippines, Ferdinand Marcos Jr.  The Prime Minister was accompanied by MP Paulo Garcia, the first Filipino to be elected to a legislature outside the Philippines. During today’s meeting, Prime Minister Luxon and President Marcos Jr discussed opportunities to ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Government commits $20m to Westport flood protection
    The Government has announced that $20 million in funding will be made available to Westport to fund much needed flood protection around the town. This measure will significantly improve the resilience of the community, says Local Government Minister Simeon Brown. “The Westport community has already been allocated almost $3 million ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Taupō takes pole position
    The Government is proud to support the first ever Repco Supercars Championship event in Taupō as up to 70,000 motorsport fans attend the Taupō International Motorsport Park this weekend, says Economic Development Minister Melissa Lee. “Anticipation for the ITM Taupō Super400 is huge, with tickets and accommodation selling out weeks ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Cost of living support for low-income homeowners
    Local Government Minister Simeon Brown has announced an increase to the Rates Rebate Scheme, putting money back into the pockets of low-income homeowners.  “The coalition Government is committed to bringing down the cost of living for New Zealanders. That includes targeted support for those Kiwis who are doing things tough, such ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Government backing mussel spat project
    The Coalition Government is investing in a project to boost survival rates of New Zealand mussels and grow the industry, Oceans and Fisheries Minister Shane Jones has announced. “This project seeks to increase the resilience of our mussels and significantly boost the sector’s productivity,” Mr Jones says. “The project - ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Government focused on getting people into work
    Benefit figures released today underscore the importance of the Government’s plan to rebuild the economy and have 50,000 fewer people on Jobseeker Support, Social Development and Employment Minister Louise Upston says. “Benefit numbers are still significantly higher than when National was last in government, when there was about 70,000 fewer ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Clean energy key driver to reducing emissions
    The Government’s commitment to doubling New Zealand’s renewable energy capacity is backed by new data showing that clean energy has helped the country reach its lowest annual gross emissions since 1999, Climate Change Minister Simon Watts says. New Zealand’s latest Greenhouse Gas Inventory (1990-2022) published today, shows gross emissions fell ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Earthquake-prone buildings review brought forward
    The Government is bringing the earthquake-prone building review forward, with work to start immediately, and extending the deadline for remediations by four years, Building and Construction Minister Chris Penk says. “Our Government is focused on rebuilding the economy. A key part of our plan is to cut red tape that ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Thailand and NZ to agree to Strategic Partnership
    Prime Minister Christopher Luxon and his Thai counterpart, Prime Minister Srettha Thavisin, have today agreed that New Zealand and the Kingdom of Thailand will upgrade the bilateral relationship to a Strategic Partnership by 2026. “New Zealand and Thailand have a lot to offer each other. We have a strong mutual desire to build ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Government consults on extending coastal permits for ports
    RMA Reform Minister Chris Bishop and Transport Minister Simeon Brown have today announced the Coalition Government’s intention to extend port coastal permits for a further 20 years, providing port operators with certainty to continue their operations. “The introduction of the Resource Management Act in 1991 required ports to obtain coastal ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Inflation coming down, but more work to do
    Today’s announcement that inflation is down to 4 per cent is encouraging news for Kiwis, but there is more work to be done - underlining the importance of the Government’s plan to get the economy back on track, acting Finance Minister Chris Bishop says. “Inflation is now at 4 per ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • School attendance restored as a priority in health advice
    Refreshed health guidance released today will help parents and schools make informed decisions about whether their child needs to be in school, addressing one of the key issues affecting school attendance, says Associate Education Minister David Seymour. In recent years, consistently across all school terms, short-term illness or medical reasons ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Unnecessary bureaucracy cut in oceans sector
    Oceans and Fisheries Minister Shane Jones is streamlining high-level oceans management while maintaining a focus on supporting the sector’s role in the export-led recovery of the economy. “I am working to realise the untapped potential of our fishing and aquaculture sector. To achieve that we need to be smarter with ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Patterson promoting NZ’s wool sector at International Congress
    Associate Agriculture Minister Mark Patterson is speaking at the International Wool Textile Organisation Congress in Adelaide, promoting New Zealand wool, and outlining the coalition Government’s support for the revitalisation the sector.    "New Zealand’s wool exports reached $400 million in the year to 30 June 2023, and the coalition Government ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Removing red tape to help early learners thrive
    The Government is making legislative changes to make it easier for new early learning services to be established, and for existing services to operate, Associate Education Minister David Seymour says. The changes involve repealing the network approval provisions that apply when someone wants to establish a new early learning service, ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago

Page generated in The Standard by Wordpress at 2024-04-25T12:49:32+00:00