Where were you Granny?

23 comments on “Where were you Granny? ”

• Comments are now closed

1. Draco T Bastard 1

   1 February 2013 at 10:57 am

   According to Corrections Minister Anne Tolley, the work will give prisoners “a structured day, help with behaviour and [mean] you’re not institutionalising them too much before they go back out into the community”.

   Contradictory much?

   That cutting means, inevitably, that in some cases prisoners are taking the jobs of people in the community.

   And that will have someone bringing up the Lump of Labour Fallacy fallacy.
   • CV - Real Labour 1.1

     1 February 2013 at 11:05 am

     Wisconsin Republican Governor Scott Walker already has prisoners replacing unionised workers. This is where its going. (cancel the annoying pop up thing)

     http://thinkprogress.org/politics/2011/07/06/261319/scott-walker-prison-labor/?mobile=nc
     • aerobubble 1.1.1

       1 February 2013 at 12:21 pm

       Its necessary, the evil unwashed need to be tied to their work stations less they up and overthrow the wealth owners, being chained to the work place is nothing new. First they target the weakest, the most powerless, and once they’ve iron out the processes they move up the social ladder.

       The left, rightly, has made the argument that governments have a obligation to provide access to meaningful living wage work to all citizens. The conservative right is silent having been over run by the extreme revolutionary conservatism that believes any government must be onerous and draconian otherwise they won’t be able to do away with regulation that harms their rent seeking owners. Slavery takes differing forms at differing strata of society, those who support the revolutionary conservative (oxymoron) actively believe they are free and acting to keep us all free.
       Ignorant fools. Key is a slave.
       • Andre 1.1.1.1

         1 February 2013 at 12:37 pm

         Me thinks this is a plot…… Mr brownlee is going to only incarcerate Trades people.. Canterbury solved.
       • Dr Terry 1.1.1.2

         1 February 2013 at 1:18 pm

         All one has to do is take note of who the Minister is – none other than that “marvel” Tolley! The poor prisoners will have no future, certainly not a scrap of what we derisively must call “rehabilitation”. Punishment is the order of the day (and this scheme could rightly be described as “slave labour” where the prisoners have no options and incredibly no remuneration!
   • David H 1.2

     1 February 2013 at 10:45 pm

     And did you read some of the comments FFS, bring out the whips and chains mob.
2. Andre 2

   1 February 2013 at 11:05 am

   We spend around $250 a day on offenders . Maybe we could spend some of that in good work for them before they offend. Just an idea
3. tracey 3

   1 February 2013 at 11:12 am

   And so it begins… the play for the dopey and misguided law and order vote… but it works which is why they are doing it… and it costs us SO much financially and socially to follow this kind of flawed thinking.
4. quartz 4

   1 February 2013 at 11:24 am

   I’m not sure attacking a media outlet for writing an editorial you agree with is a particularly productive a strategy, Anthony.
   • Galeandra 4.1

     1 February 2013 at 11:38 am

     FIFY:I’m not sure attacking a media outlet for failure to write editorials that critically evaluate cynical government policies is a particularly productive enough strategy to convince concern trolls like me, Anthony.
   • r0b 4.2

     1 February 2013 at 11:45 am

     I would call it an exasperated venting of frustration, rather than an “attack”, quartz, but to each their own.

     The Herald could be serving the traditional role of media – holding government to account – in the way that this editorial does. But most of the time they abdicate that role for infotainment and a supine posture as the Nats’ chief apologist. It’s worth being frustrated about…
5. shorts 5

   1 February 2013 at 12:33 pm

   Whilst the editorial might agree with many peoples thoughts here it doesn’t go far enough… wish the writer had read No Right Turn’s take on this scheme

   http://norightturn.blogspot.co.nz/2013/01/nationals-economic-plan-prison-slave.html

   There are huge concerns this policy/scheme raises and the editorial neatly skips the most important imo
6. Tiresias 6

   1 February 2013 at 12:55 pm

   “So – here’s my question. Where were you for the last 5 years Granny?” Anthony R0bins.

   That is the question. What is the answer?

   I never see the Herald, even hanging in the loo, wrapped around fish-and-chips or on-line, so I have no idea what its normal stance is. Does it even pretend to be a Serious Newspaper, or is it just a middle-brow Tid-bits like the Daily Mail in the UK? Is there any reason to look for a Left-Wing commentary from it? Or a Right-Wing one?

   And why should it apparently break whatever mould it’s adopted now? Does it sense a shift in its target audience away from uncritical acceptance of National dogma or is it actually saying that trying to a) help prisoners pass the time of their incarceration with something to do and b) equip them with a trade and disciplines to keep them in line after release, is soft and mollycoddling? Or is this just a subject sufficiently simple that even its particular readership might be capable of forming an opinion in their guts about it?
7. aerobubble 7

   1 February 2013 at 1:03 pm

   High Dollar makes us feel richer, a false economy. China is awash in US printed money and is buying up anything anyone is selling, unlike many countries that have shut their legs, NZ has kept selling itself like a cheap whore. The imbalance in the dollar is a National crisis.

   http://gordoncampbell.scoop.co.nz/2013/01/31/gordon-campbell-on-jonathan-colemans-defence-debacle/
   A former military man, now Mayor, says that there are too many officers and the different arms of the military need to be merged. This typifies the problem of debate in NZ, why we have policies, how does changing the policy without revisiting the reasons for a large officer contingent?
   We need to hold on to expertize, and have the capacity to expand the militry when the needs arise, so its essential to keep a larger number of officers and shrink the bulk of the military, hold on to traditions hard won from war time. But no, find some stupid right winger who has some experience of the issue but has never shown any capacity to see more than one view point.

   We have too many of that type, who just won’t consider that maybe, for example that Bain is innocent, less they come across and moderate liberal minded.
   • aerobubble 7.1

     1 February 2013 at 1:07 pm

     So some manager flies off the cuff and sacks
     someone, for good reason, but cost their
     shareholders as the correct procedure was not
     followed, but the manager keeps their job.
     No questions of a nudge and a wink between
     firer and firee, just a lot of hot air about
     how wrong the payout was, as if managers had
     no responsibilities. MSM supports their mates.

     Now the military spending, and cost savings are gutting
     the military, and still the same managers who gave us
     Novopay, who hired the now disgraced Binnie, who
     still can’t get a grip on the economy as it exports
     its people, its wealth centers, hell we are now exporting
     our dairy herds on a massive ship!!! Why won’t
     National voters realize, that China is awash in US
     printed money.
8. tc 8

   1 February 2013 at 1:24 pm

   the upper class telling the middle class it’s the lower classes fault.

   Granny serves it’s masters not joe public, that’s why the nat’s have hobbled TVNZ, freeview, RNZ and boosted Sky’s monopoly even further.
9. Tom Gould 9

   1 February 2013 at 2:33 pm

   Where was Granny? Why she was out by the still brewing up a new batch of John Key’s snake oil and splashing it all over the front page. How else to you explain National’s consistent high polling despite consistently screwing up? The public only know what their government is up to through the MSM. And the pack has largely decided Key is their man and his snake oil cures all that’s ailing ya. Simple, really.
   • Tim 9.1

     1 February 2013 at 4:11 pm

     I think you’ve just put your finger on what the political “battle” in NZ is all about. An MSM that the “sleepy Hobbits” (as a Bomber Bradly would describe them as) still rely on, and one that’s been hijacked by a media ruling elite who’re comforable and lazy (never really that bright or intelligent to begin with either). Watch them bleat like sheep on the way to the slaughterhouse though, or squealing pigs though when more of them begin losing their yobs.

     IT would be good to be able to get NZers to consider their position were they to have to ‘cash-up” tomorrow – perhaps having just lost their jobs a la Oamaru – or something similar.

     In many ways, I sometimes find it hard to feel sympathy – especially when I see Morgan polling (absolutely as unreliable and meaningless, and unscientific as it actually is).

     There’s a media ‘feed’ tho- one that pumps populism, stardom, be happy, don’t worry, a mUddle class in denial and fawning over what they think is the ‘self-made man’ – Slippery [one day I’ll be loik him].
     He’s a self-made man whose foundations rely on a firm foundation of solid bullshit – a backgorund that a lazy MSM has never really gone into (Remember for example all that crap about how ‘hard’ things were for him and his mum – not really that dissimilar to most others at the time – in fact a lot better off even THEN, than most)

     Re this MSM though – I mean ffs – look at the promotional shite ONE is currently pumping – trying to convince us what good blokes Greg Boyed and Ali are. BOTH probably are – in fact the former is – its just that he has a mortgage to pay, pathetic Andy Pandy egotistical bosses, kids, a family, commitments, and all the rest of it.

     NZers are not unintelligent, but it seems that an escapist attitude is better than recognising reality, and who wants to be in a position of being associated with a negative attitude. (Oima glass harfull koinda goiee aye!).

     It would be an interesting poll if NZers were asked ” what IF you lost your job(s) tomorrow – WHAT WOULD YOU DO, where would you be?”.
     Most….well pretty obviously really – up Shit Creek without a paddle. While they have a job though, easier to occupy regular haunts, pretend you’re OK (and better off than dole bludgers and people “that just don’t WANT to work”), and all those other images of what romantic notions of Kiwidom are.

     I witnessed the spiel of an Oamaru Mayor on various media outlets today. Reluctant as hell to admit to the bleeding obvious – if only because his ‘heartland’ was extremely too close for comfort to a NAct utopia.

     Oh well….we’ll see what we see but NZers actually only have themselves to blame for the current predicament.
     A philistine of a used-car salesman with an ego the size of a bus, masquerading as a Proim Minster, over-ambitiously desperate to be seen with those he thinks are the world’s movers and shakers that Kiwis think is actually “charistmatic” ffs!
     One day he’ll realise just how much of a joke those movers and shakers think he is.

     We’ll see next election JUST how smart Kiwis actually are, but we wonder why so many are crossing the ditch.
10. Rogue Trooper 10

    1 February 2013 at 2:58 pm

    “This is a Pole”

    -Vince (Martyrn)
11. North 11

    1 February 2013 at 5:45 pm

    What pray tell will the “work” be ?

    Polishing pebbles with a rag perhaps ?

    Corrections Department security measures have seen me sent back to the main gate of a medium security New Zealand prison because inadvertently I’d not removed a plastic cashlow card from my shirt pocket.

    Of course “work” has nothing to do with it. It’s all about inciting hatred for the advantage of our Effigy of Wall Street PM, the henchmen in his cabinet and the backwoodsmen who sit behind them.
12. Rogue Trooper 12

    1 February 2013 at 6:48 pm

    arbeit macht frei
    http://news.nationalpost.com/2013/01/31/human-rights-dont-assert-themselves-germany-marks-80th-anniversary-of-hitlers-rise-to-power-with-warning-from-merkel/?utm_source=dlvr.it&utm_medium=twitter

    and a couple of leavenings omitted from the hard copy (divestment of national MSM portfolios coming? )
    http://www.nzherald.co.nz/world/news/article.cfm?c_id=2&objectid=10862762

    http://www.nzherald.co.nz/world/news/article.cfm?c_id=2&objectid=10862769

    http://www.nzherald.co.nz/world/news/article.cfm?c_id=2&objectid=10862761

    From Mri (you know you’re standing in it when cowpats are termed “little lucifers”)
13. Don't worry be happy 13

    2 February 2013 at 10:27 am

    “Where were you Granny?’…where the B^%$&* hell were Labour?
    • tc 13.1

      2 February 2013 at 2:51 pm

      Same place they’ll be in 2014 if the mallarfia stays in control.

• Comments are now closed

• Log in
• Donate
• Contribute post

• Articles RSS