About David Parker’s and Labour’s debate about taxation
Written By:
- Date published:
10:58 am, August 31st, 2024 - 69 comments
Categories: david parker, Deep stuff, labour, tax, uncategorized -
Tags:
Gerard Otto recently posted on his Facebook page an account of a Labour Party meeting, held on Waiheke, in which David Parker discussed taxation and ways in which Labour might address growing income inequality in New Zealand. That post has been taken up subsequently in the media, with an emphasis on the taxation debates in Labour.
I doubt if anyone is surprised by this coverage. The tax issue was front and centre before the election and remains so today. It is a major issue – perhaps the major issue – in rank-and-file member discussions in the Party, Growing inequality, coupled with the work on who pays what tax undertaken when Labour led the government, suggests that this is an issue that will not go away, Indeed, some, like me, believe that tax reform must be undertaken if Social Democracy is to survive in a post-Keynesian, increasingly unstable world.
The Party has already begun the process of policy determination. The Party’s Policy Council, replete with expertise, is actively involved with the tax issue. Policy Council has substantial power within the Party apparatus. In this and next year, Labour holds conferences able to determine future policy, that is, if members so choose, a mandate on the Parliamentary Party may be imposed. This fifteen-month window for action is important. If the membership does not lay down an unequivocal mandate on taxation in this period, policy setting will drift into the campaign process, notorious for its contingent thinking.
This also speaks to the operation of the Party. My support for the Policy Platform was grounded in a strong belief that a democratic party should allow members to determine policy, except in exceptional circumstances (for example, unheralded and urgent circumstances when in power). The membership of the Party values that role.
There is another current in play, unsurprisingly. It owes more to elite theory than participatory democracy, positing the existence of a parliamentary elite which, based on its experience and knowledge, should be entrusted with policy decisions. The Labour tradition has always shaded pragmatically into this way of thinking, especially when in power, but the constitutional framework of the Party, and members’ thinking, reject its principles.
One might say that taxation has lifted the lid on many things. One is the best way of protecting New Zealand, especially working people, from the travails of international political and economic insecurity. A second is the renewal of a sustainable Social Democracy in New Zealand. Third, it speaks to the role of Labour in New Zealand’s political system. Fourth, it highlights the democratic process within Labour. Perhaps the worst and the best of times.
Nigel Haworth
69 comments on “About David Parker’s and Labour’s debate about taxation ”
Leave a Comment
CommentsOpinions
Recent Comments
FeedsPartyGovtMedia
- My Substack erm… Summer
Hi all,Apparently it’s the end of Summer, hope you enjoyed it. 🙂The rather Northern Hemisphere centric folks over at Substack have sent this out, I’m not sure what time period it covers, I guess the last three months. In any case you might like to give it a go yourself ...11 hours ago - Pricing Road Usage
Congestion pricing is easier said than done.The first seminar I attended in Britain – around sixty years ago – explained a scheme for road usage pricing which would eliminate traffic congestion and direct roading investment. It was impressive and elegant (as many such seminar propositions are) but proved impractical and ...11 hours ago - Tory Whanau may have to sell Wellington mayoralty to make ends meet
Tory Whanau has revealed that she’s struggling so much financially that she may have to part with her beloved mayoralty, that of New Zealand’s capital city, if she’s to fund her ever-diminishing lifestyle. Whanau was elected to lead Wellington in 2022, winning an overwhelming victory against the incumbent mayor: the ...12 hours ago - And round we go again…
One of Labour's few achievements last term was to finally move on RMA reform. Following an independent review and a select committee review of an exposure draft, both aimed at ironing out bugs and producing a compromise most people could live with, Labour passed the Natural and Built Environments Act ...13 hours ago - The Supreme Court stands up for fairness
National is planning to breach te Tiriti o Waitangi by amending the Marine and Coastal Area Act to effectively make it impossible for the courts to recognise Māori rights over the foreshore and seabed. But its also been playing dirty in other ways. Earlier in the year it announced changes ...14 hours ago
- Today’s 10 Politics Headlines: Luxon flails and Simeon Drives
1/ Jobseeker numbers are going the opposite way of Luxon’s KPIs. Against a target of minus 50,000 by 2030, the new forecast shows the Government is looking at an increase of 24,000 jobseekers in its first term.In Thomas Coughlin’s report, Upton responds by blaming Labour: “We inherited an economy in ...19 hours ago - Kaka project: What could a revamped Entrust do with/for/to Vector?
Long story short, I interviewed transport and energy activist Patrick Reynolds this week about the bid to run Entrust by a new campaign group he’s part of called More for you; better for Auckland. There’s a lot more detail in this GreaterAuckland post and on ‘Better’s’ website.They’re campaigning to win ...19 hours ago - Missing the Feckin’ Targets
And although my eyes were openThey might just as well have been closedAnd so it was laterWhen the miller told this taleHe said that her face at first just ghostlyAnd then turned a whiter shade of paleSongwriters: Keith Reid / Gary BrookerI want to talk about two things today, subjects ...20 hours ago - Deadly floods and streams of non-solutions
Long stories short, here’s the top six news items of note in climate news for Aotearoa-NZ this week, and a discussion above between Bernard Hickey and The Kākā’s climate correspondent Cathrine Dyer:Central Europe is reeling from the devastating effects of Storm Boris, which has so far caused 21 deaths and ...21 hours ago
- Weekly Roundup 20-September-2024
Welcome to the end of the week, as we head towards the spring equinox. Let us brighten your week with links to stories about how to make our city a little greater. This roundup is brought to you by a largely volunteer crew. If you’d like to support our work ...21 hours ago - Three years of recession deeper than GFC
Kia ora. Long stories short, here’s my top six things to note in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty on Friday, September 20:New Zealand’s total GDP contracted less than expected in the June quarter, but per-capita GDP extended its three-year-long slump at a rate that is faster than ...21 hours ago - That’s Gangsta!
The gang patch legislation finally passed in the House after a long period of fanfare from National. Gangs won’t be allowed to publicly display gang insignia on the body or in vehicles, and if they’re very naughty i.e. caught thrice, police will be able to enter private homes to search.How ...22 hours ago - The Hoon around the week to Sept 20
The podcast above of the weekly ‘Hoon’ webinar for paying subscribers on Thursday night features co-host talking about the week’s news with:The Kākā’s climate correspondent on the latest climate news, including media coverage of extreme events and how big tech is gobbling up so much renewable power growth; ...23 hours ago
- A very healthy distrust of how this Government is handling health across the board is needed…
And alongside that, is the ultimate question for the public, and indeed Opposition Parties trying to appeal for enough of the public to support a change from this heinous direction of travel being imposed on us: how much of the damage here can even be stopped in time? Let us ...1 day ago - Hang up on him David, just stop
There is a story I want to tell, but I'm not going to begin with it because it would be too abrupt. I'll start by telling you that I'm a big fan of the way Nicola Toki conveys her message. And Nicola Toki is a big fan of the way Jane ...2 days ago - Tax the rich!
We already know that the rich people aren't paying their fair share. But it turns out its worse than that: we're a tax-haven! Our rich people pay lower taxes here than in any comparable country: Well-off New Zealanders are paying less tax than their peers in nine similar OECD ...2 days ago
- Worse and worse
Cancer Minister Casey Costello is in trouble again over her secret, magically appearing tobacco policy document. The Ombudsman has already found that she acted contrary to law in refusing requests for it; now she has been referred to the Chief Archivist over a possible breach of the Public Records Act ...2 days ago
- NZ’s lack of a capital gains tax means the richest here pay vastly less than elsewhere
The lack of a capital gains tax means the richest Kiwis are sitting pretty compared to taxpayers overseas. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāKia ora. Long stories short, here’s my top six things to note in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty on Thursday, September 19:New Zealand’s richest ...2 days ago - Verrall to Levy: “Health NZ NDAs are North Korean – Get rid of it.”
Open article. Note the video of the Health Select Committee excerpts starts at 1:22 In watching the Health Select Committee yesterday, it became clear to me why Margie Apa remains Health NZ CEO.During Levy’s testimony, Apa sat like a rock next to her boss. She nodded supportively, scribbled notes to ...2 days ago
- The Show Must Go On
Empty spaces, what are we living for?Abandoned places, I guess we know the score, on and onDoes anybody know what we are looking for?Another hero, another mindless crimeBehind the curtain, in the pantomimeHold the lineDoes anybody want to take it anymore?The show must go onSongwriters: Brian May / Freddie Mercury ...2 days ago - Managing on-street parking for local benefit
This guest post by Malcolm McCracken originally appeared on his blog Better Things Are Possible, and is republished here by kind permission. The case for Parking Benefit Districts: managing on-street parking for local benefit Parking is often the centre of debate in our cities; particularly on-street car parks, who gets ...2 days ago
- Doubling down?
This is a re-post from And Then There's Physics I wrote a post a little while ago commenting on a Sabine Hossenfelder video suggesting that she was now worried about climate change because the Equilibrium Climate Sensitivity (ECS) could be much higher than most estimates have suggested. I wasn’t too taken with Sabine’s arguments, and there were others ...2 days ago - Too much haste & waste in Simeon Brown’s need for speed
Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāLong story short, the Government’s myopia of only choosing transport policies that reduce travel times means we’re missing out on the health benefits of more cycling and walking, along with the health cost savings from fewer accidents, less pollution and mentally healthier ways of getting ...2 days ago
- What seemed so simple is now so complex
The Health NZ rescue that seemed so simple back in July was presented to a Select Committee yesterday as a complex challenge that could take some years to sort out. In July, Prime Minister Christopher Luxon said Health NZ was on track to record a deficit of $1.4 billion for ...2 days ago
- The utterances of Shane Jones
Let us consider the utterances of Shane Jones.Let us consider the derogatory terms of abuseNow is not the time for Green Wombles, it's black and white decision making.We will stand with the energy industry and ensure they are not monstered by Green Termites nibbling away at our economic capital.The Green ...3 days ago - Ukrainian militia receives defective shipment of pagers that just send and receive messages
There’s been a major setback for one Ukrainian-backed militia on the Russian border, after the group ordered a large shipment of pagers to use as improvised explosive devices. The plan was to litter the pagers throughout abandoned homes and buildings in hopes of wounding Russian soldiers. But upon arrival of ...3 days ago - A constitutional shitshow
Last month, we learned that the government was half-arsing its anti-gang legislation, adding a significant, pre-planned, BORA-abusing amendment at the committee stage, avoiding all the usual scrutiny processes. But it gets worse. Because having done it once, they're now planning to recall the bill in order to add another such ...3 days ago
- Political Round Up
Note: An earlier version of this article noted Levy was a “party time Health NZ commissioner” - this has been updated - forgive my Freudian slip.Dr Lester Levy is charging $320,000 a year to be a part time Health NZ commissioner. Rachel Thomas reports that Levy is still teaching 2 ...3 days ago - Postcard from Sydney: Southwest and City Metro extension
This is a guest post from Sydney reader Nik Clement After 2 years in Auckland I moved back to Sydney just over a year ago. While in Auckland, I went to the opening of Puhinui station and used it a fair bit, living in Manukau Central and being able ...3 days ago
- Tolling revolt brewing in National heartland
Kia ora. Long stories short, here’s my top six things to note in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty on Wednesday, September 18:Locals gathered in Woodville last night to protest at the National-ACT-NZ First Government’s decision to toll the new road linking the Manawatu and Hawkes Bay, saying ...3 days ago - The doom spiral
This is a re-post from The Climate Brink by Andrew Dessler In his last post, Zeke discussed incredible warmth of 2023 and 2024 and its implications for future warming. A few readers looked at it and freaked out: This is terrifying and This update really put me in a ...3 days ago
- Government directs Te Puni Kōkiri to conduct Māori Language Week in English
The coalition government has issued a directive to Te Puni Kōkiri, the Ministry of Māori Development, instructing them that – in the interests of clear communication – they are to conduct this year’s Māori Language Week primarily or exclusively in English. The directive is in line with the Government’s policy ...3 days ago - Government celebrates fact that New Zealand’s healthcare is so good people are queuing up for it a...
At yesterday’s post-cabinet press conference, Prime Minister Christopher Luxon, flanked by his Health Minister Shane Reti and someone we can’t independently verify was a real sign language interpreter, announced that he had some positive news for the country. “Alright team, I’m just going to hand over to uh, Dr. Shane, ...3 days ago - Heartwarming: Thoughtful driver uses indicator to tell you what they’ve just done
It’s 4:10pm in the morning, and you’re in the middle lane heading north on the great southern motorway of our nation’s capital, Auckland. There are no cars directly in front of you, but quite a few in the lane to your left. Suddenly, without warning, a black ute enters your ...3 days ago - NPC teams will now be allowed to actually use the Ranfurly Shield in play
Following decades of controversy, the governing body of New Zealand rugby, New Zealand Rugby, has ruled that the team currently holding the Ranfurly Shield may once again use it in play during the National Provincial Championship (NPC). The ruling restores the utility of a prize that for many years was ...4 days ago - Climbing out of the hamster wheel
I arrived home with a head full of fresh ideas about mindfulness and curbing impulsive aspects in my character.On the second night home I grabbed a piece of ginger and began swiftly slicing it on our industrial strength mandolin, the one I have learned through painful experience to treat with ...4 days ago - More Notes From Stinky Town
Good morning, folks. Another wee note from a chilly Rotorua morning that looks much clearer than yesterday. As I write, the pink glow in the east is slowly growing, and soon, the palest of blue skies should become a bit more royal.A couple of people mentioned yesterday that I should ...4 days ago - Make it make sense: why axe valuable local projects?
Last week, Matt looked at how the government wants to pour a huge chunk of civic infrastructure funding for a generation into one mega-road up North, at huge cost and huge opportunity cost. A smaller but no less important feature of the National Land Transport Plan devised by Minister of Transport ...4 days ago
- Driving blind at higher speeds
An open letter by experts about plans to raise speed limits warns the “tragic consequence will be more New Zealanders losing their lives or suffering severe injury, along with a substantial burden on the nation's healthcare and rehabilitation services”. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāKia ora. Long stories short, here’s ...4 days ago - 2024’s unusually persistent warmth
This is a re-post from The Climate Brink My inaugural post on The Climate Brink 18 months ago looked at the year 2024, and found that it was likely to be the warmest year on record on the back of a (than forecast) El Nino event. I suggested “there is a real chance ...4 days ago
- National plan for 2000 more Kiwis a year in prison
Open for allYesterday, Luxon congratulated his government on a job well done with emergency housing numbers, but advocates have been saying it‘s likely many are on the streets and sleeping in cars.Q&A featured some of the folks this weekend - homeless and in cars. Yes.The government’s also confirmed they stopped ...4 days ago
- I Found a Note in a Tree
Hi,On most days I try to go on a walk through nature to clear my head from the horrors of life. Because as much as I like people, I also think it’s incredibly important to get very far away from them. To be reminded that there are also birds, lizards, ...4 days ago - Jacqui Van Der Kaay: Politicians need to lift their game
Declining trust in New Zealand politicians should be a warning to them to lift their game. Results from the New Zealand Election Study for the 2023 election show that the level of trust in politicians has once again declined. Perhaps it is not surprising that the results, shared as part ...4 days ago - Police say they won’t respond to bomb threats anymore as ‘it’s never anything’
Police Commissioner Andrew Coster says that New Zealand’s police force will no longer respond to bomb threats, in an attempt to cut costs and redirect police resources to less boring activities. Coster said that threat response and bomb disposal was a “fairly obvious” area for downsizing, as bomb threats are ...4 days ago - A dysfunctional watchdog
The reality of any right depends on how well it is enforced. But as The Post points out this morning, our right to official information isn't being enforced very well at all: More than a quarter of complaints about access to official information languish for more than a year, ...5 days ago
- Climate Change: The threat of a good example
Since taking office, the climate-denier National government has gutted agricultural emissions pricing, ended the clean car discount, repealed water quality standards which would have reduced agricultural emissions, gutted the clean car standard, killed the GIDI scheme, and reversed efforts to reduce pollution subsidies in the ETS - basically every significant ...5 days ago
- Vegas Baby
Good morning, lovely people. Don’t worry. This isn’t really a newsletter, just a quick note. I’m sitting in our lounge, looking out over a gloomy sky. Although being Rotorua, the view is periodically interrupted by steam bursting from pipes and dispersing—like an Eastern European industrial hellscape during the Cold War.Drinking ...5 days ago - Why Entrust Needs New Leadership
I am part of a new team running in the Entrust election in October. Entrust is a community electricity trust representing a significant part of Auckland, set up to serve the community. It is governed by five trustees are elected every three years in an election the trust itself oversees. ...5 days ago
- London Bridge is falling down
In the UK, London is the latest of council groups to signal potential bankruptcy.That’s after Birmingham, Britain’s second largest city, went bankrupt in June, resulting in reduced sanitation services, libraries cut, and dimmed streetlights.Some in the city described things as “Dickens” like.Please, Sir, Can I have some more?For families with ...5 days ago - Govt may kick elderly out of hospitals
The Government is considering how to shunt elderly people out of hospitals, and also how to cut their access to other support. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāKia ora. Long stories short, here’s my top six things to note in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty on Monday, ...5 days ago - Getting the nephs off the couch
The so-called “Prince of the Provinces”, Shane Jones, went home last Friday. Perhaps not quite literally home, more like 20 kilometres down the road from his house on the outskirts of Kerikeri. With its airport, its rapidly growing (mostly retired) population, and a commercial centre with all the big retail ...5 days ago
- De moralibus orcorum: Sargon of Akkad, Rings of Power, Evil, and George R.R. Martin
I have noted before that The Rings of Power has attracted its unfortunate share of culture war obsessives. Essentially, for a certain type of individual, railing on about the Wokery of Modern Media is a means of making themselves a online livelihood. Clicks and views and advertising revenue, and all ...5 days ago - 2024 SkS Weekly Climate Change & Global Warming News Roundup #37
A listing of 31 news and opinion articles we found interesting and shared on social media during the past week: Sun, September 8, 2024 thru Sat, September 14, 2024. Story of the week From time to time we like to make our Story of the Week all about us— and ...5 days ago
- Salvation For Us All
Yesterday, I ruminated about the effects of being a political follower.And, within politics, David Seymour was smart enough on Friday to divert attention from “race blind” policies [what about gender blind I thought - thinking of maternity wards] and cutting school lunches by throwing meat to the media. Teachers were ...6 days ago - A warm embrace
Far, far away from here lives our King. Some of his subjects can be quite the forelock tuggers, but plenty of us are not like that, and why don't I wheel out my favourite old story once more about Kiwi soldiers in the North African desert?Field Marshal Montgomery takes offence ...6 days ago - Literal clowns are running the place, we must put a timeout on this stupidity… right Aotearoa?
These people are inept on every level. They’re inept to the detriment of our internal politics, cohesion and increasingly our international reputation. And they are reveling in the fact they are getting away with it. We cannot even have “respectful debate” with a government that clearly rejects the very ...6 days ago - Fact brief – Does manmade CO2 have any detectable fingerprint?
Skeptical Science is partnering with Gigafact to produce fact briefs — bite-sized fact checks of trending claims. This fact brief was written by Sue Bin Park from the Gigafact team in collaboration with John Mason. You can submit claims you think need checking via the tipline. Does manmade CO2 have any ...6 days ago
- Judge Not.
7 days ago - Managed Democracy: Letting The People Decide, But Only When They Can Be Relied Upon To Give the Righ...
Uh-uh! Not So Fast, Citizens! The power to initiate systemic change remains where it has always been in New Zealand’s representative democracy – in Parliament. To order a binding referendum, the House of Representatives must first to be persuaded that, on the question proposed, sharing its decision-making power with the people ...7 days ago
- Looking For Labour’s Vital Signs.
Flatlining: With no evidence of a genuine policy disruptor at work in Labour’s ranks, New Zealand’s wealthiest citizens can sleep easy.PRESIDENT JOE BIDEN has walked a picket-line. Presidential candidate Kamala Harris has threatened “price-gauging” grocery retailers with price control. The Democratic Party’s 2024 platform situates it well to the left of Sir ...7 days ago
- Forty Years Of Remembering To Forget.
The Beginning of the End: Rogernomics became the short-hand descriptor for all the radical changes that swept away New Zealand’s social-democratic economy and society between 1984 and 1990. In the bitterest of ironies, those changes were introduced by the very same party which had entrenched New Zealand social-democracy 50 years earlier. ...7 days ago
- Kōrero Mai – Speak to Me.
Good morning all you lovely people. 🙂I woke up this morning, and it felt a bit like the last day of school. You might recall from earlier in the week that I’m heading home to Rotorua to see an old friend who doesn’t have much time. A sad journey, but ...7 days ago - Winning ways
7 days ago - 48 seconds on a plan that would reverberate for a million years
Despite fears that Trump presidency would be disastrous for progress on climate change, the topic barely rated a mention in the Presidential debate. Photo: Getty ImagesLong stories short, here’s the top six news items of note in climate news for Aotearoa-NZ this week, and a discussion above between Bernard Hickey ...7 days ago
- Using blunt instruments and magical thinking to ignore evidence of harm
The abrupt cancellations and suspensions of Government spending also caused private sector hiring, spending, and investment to freeze up for the first six months of the year. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāThis week we learned:The new National/ACT/NZ First Coalition Government ignored advice from Treasury that it didn’t have to ...7 days ago - Is This A Dagger Which I See Before Me: A Review and Analysis of The Rings of Power Episode 5 (Seaso...
Another week of The Rings of Power, season two, and another confirmation that things are definitely coming together for the show. The fifth Episode of season one represented the nadir of the series. Now? Amid the firmer footing of 2024, Episode Five represents further a further step towards excellent Tolkien ...1 week ago - In Open Seas; A Book
The background to In Open Seas: How the New Zealand Labour Government Went Wrong:2017-2023Not in Narrow Seas: The Economic History of Aotearoa New Zealand, published in 2020, proved more successful than either I or the publisher (VUP, now Te Herenga Waka University Press) expected. I had expected that it would ...1 week ago - The Hoon around the week to Sept 13
The podcast above of the weekly ‘Hoon’ webinar for paying subscribers on Thursday night features co-hosts and talking about the week’s news with:The Kākā’s climate correspondent on the latest climate science on rising temperatures and the climate implications of the US Presidential elections; and special guests Janet ...1 week ago
- Do or do not. There is no try
1. Upon receiving evidence that school lunches were doing a marvellous job of improving outcomes for students, David Seymour did what?a. Declared we need much more of this sort of good news and poured extra resources and funding into them b. Emailed Atlas network to ask what to do next c. Cut ...1 week ago - Dangerous ground
The Waitangi Tribunal has reported back on National's proposed changes to gut the Marine and Coastal Area Act and steal the foreshore and seabed for its greedy fishing-industry donors, and declared it to be another huge violation of ti Tiriti: The Waitangi Tribunal has found government changes to the ...1 week ago
- Climate Change: National wants to cheat on Paris
In 2016, the then-National government signed the Paris Agreement, committing Aotearoa to a 30 (later 50) percent reduction in emissions by 2030. When questioned about how they intended to meet that target with their complete absence of effective climate policy, they made a lot of noise about how it was ...1 week ago
- Treasury warned Govt lower debt limits meant less ‘productivity-enhancing investment’
1 week ago - Is the Media Complicit?
This is a long read. Open to all.SYNOPSIS: Traditional media is at a cross roads. There is a need for those in the media landscape, as it stands, to earn enough to stay afloat, but also come across as balanced and neutral to keep its audiences.In America, NYT’s liberal leaning ...1 week ago - Black Friday
It's Black Friday, the end of the weekYou take my hand and hold it gently up against your cheekIt's all in my head, it's all in my mindI see the darkness where you see the lightSong by Tom OdellFriday the 13th, don’t be afraid.No, really, don’t. Everything has felt a ...1 week ago - Weekly Roundup 13-September-2024
Ooh, Friday the thirteenth. Spooky! Is that why certain zombie ideas have been stalking the landscape this week, like the Mayor’s brainwave for a motorway bridge from Kauri Point to Point Chev? Read on and find out. This roundup, like all our coverage, is brought to you by the Greater ...1 week ago
- Release: Coalition cooking up costly RMA replacement
National continues to dismantle environmental protections in the interests of rushing through unsustainable development that will ultimately cost communities. ...15 hours ago - Release: National red-faced as benefit numbers skyrocket
The economy has stagnated and the National Government is having to face the consequences of its atrocious lawmaking, as beneficiary numbers skyrocket past even Treasury’s predictions. ...20 hours ago
- Release: National allocating police officers not hired yet
There are 104 fewer police officers now than there were when National came into Government. ...20 hours ago
- Economic decline further cause for tax transformation
Today’s GDP figures combined with the injustice of our tax system will mean more pain for our lowest-income households while those at the top remain relatively unscathed. ...2 days ago - Release: No growth under National, just cuts
The National Government’s decisions have hindered, not helped the economy. ...2 days ago
- Govt must act to avoid the worst of NIWA’s climate projections
New climate projections from NIWA underscore how urgently climate action is needed. ...3 days ago
- Release: More job losses as Government fails on manufacturing
The Government is failing the manufacturing sector with no plan for its future. ...3 days ago
- Tāmaki-Makaurau MP Urges Immediate Support for Families Impacted by Mill Closure
Te Pāti Māori Member of Parliament for Tāmaki Makaurau is urging a full wraparound of services to intervene quickly with families affected by today's announced closure of the Penrose Mill. Seventy-five people are set to lose their jobs right on the eve of Christmas. "I want to extend my thoughts ...3 days ago
- Release: Sentencing package misses the mark by a mile
Sentencing policy announced by Minister Paul Goldsmith today is anything but new, merely window dressing to make up for backwards violent crime statistics under the National Government. ...4 days ago
- Release: Seymour’s Ministry of Double Standards
David Seymour doesn’t stick to his own standards of good regulation despite having a multimillion-dollar vanity ministry set up to do so. ...4 days ago
- Release: Labour Leader to travel to UK
Labour Leader Chris Hipkins will travel to the United Kingdom this week to attend the annual UK Labour Party conference in Liverpool and meet with members of the new Labour Government. ...4 days ago
- Govt Warned – Increasing Snapper Quota Breaches Fisheries Settlement
An imminent decision to increase the total allowable commercial catch (TACC) for snapper would be a direct violation of the first-ever Treaty Settlement and inevitably breach Te Tiriti o Waitangi, says Te Pāti Māori. Te Ohu Kaimoana has sought a High Court declaration to prevent the Minister of Oceans and ...5 days ago
- Govt attacks workers’ rights once again
Today’s announcement from the Minister of Workplace Relations emphasises how deep in the pocket of big business this Government really is. ...5 days ago
- Release: Māori business not a priority for this Govt
Scrapping the Progressive Procurement programme designed to support and grow Māori businesses is a missed opportunity. ...6 days ago
- Release: March 15 inquiry grants cut by Government
Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith has cut grants helping overseas family of victims to attend the next phase of the Coronial Inquiry into the 15 March 2019 Christchurch Masjidain Attack. ...6 days ago
- Minister of Injustice seeks to Entrench largest land confiscation in History
The Waitangi Tribunal has released an Urgent Report on the Government’s proposed amendments to the Takutai Moana Act 2011. The report calls out Paul Goldsmith’s proposal for what it is: a “gross breach of the Treaty” and an “illegitimate exercise of kāwanatanga”. The Tribunal is recommending the Crown step down ...1 week ago
- Takutai Moana changes another assault on Te Tiriti
The Government must abandon its Marine and Coastal Area (Takutai Moana) Act interventions after the Waitangi Tribunal found it was committing gross breaches of the Treaty. ...1 week ago
- Greens call on Govt to leave Te Reo in schools alone
As Te Wiki o te Reo Māori approaches, the Government is considering deprioritising teaching Te Reo Māori in our schools. ...1 week ago
- Govt cannot ignore racism
The Government’s directive to the public service to ignore race is nothing more than a dog whistle and distraction from the structural racism we need to address. ...1 week ago
- Release: Lemauga Lydia Sosene to take medical leave
Labour’s Mangere MP Lemauga Lydia Sosene has been diagnosed with breast cancer and will shortly take medical leave. ...1 week ago
- Potential intelligence sharing with Israel must be investigated
Concerns have been raised that our spy arrangements may mean that intelligence is being shared between Aotearoa and Israel. An urgent inquiry must be launched in response to this. ...1 week ago
- Release: Charter schools undermine our education system
The Government is taking a wrecking ball to our public education system by reinstating charter schools. ...1 week ago
- Youngest MP to travel to Canada to accept Politician of the Year Award
Aotearoa’s Youngest Member of Parliament, and Te Pāti Māori MP, Hana-Rawhiti Maipi-Clarke, will travel to Montreal to accept the One Young World Politician of the Year Award next week. The One Young World Politician of the Year Award was created in 2018 to recognise the most promising young politicians between ...1 week ago
- Greens celebrate huge step forward for ADHD community
The Greens welcome today’s long-coming announcement by Pharmac of consultation to remove the special authority renewal criteria for methylphenidate, dexamfetamine and modafinil and to fund lisdexamfetamine. ...1 week ago
- Release: Millions to be spent dividing NZ for no reason
The National Party is wasting millions of dollars allowing David Seymour’s Treaty Principals Bill to be drafted and go to Select Committee. ...1 week ago
- Release: New Zealanders departing our shores at a record rate
The Migration figures released by Stats NZ today show National is continuing to drive Kiwis away from New Zealand in record numbers. ...1 week ago
- Te Tai Tokerau MP Slams Govt Overreach in Scrapping Māori Wards
Mema Paremata for Te Tai Tokerau, Mariameno Kapa-Kingi, has reflected on the decisions made by the councils of the North amidst the government’s push to remove Māori Wards and weaken mana whenua representation. “Actions taken by the Kaipara District Council to remove Māori Wards are the embodiment of the eradication ...1 week ago
- Govt already seeking advice on Treaty referendum
On one hand, the Prime Minister has assured Aotearoa that his party will not support the Treaty Principles Bill beyond first reading, but on the other, his Government has already sought advice on holding a referendum on our founding document. ...1 week ago
- Release: Aged care will be worse off if redesign rushed
New Zealanders needing aged care support and the people who care for them will be worse off if the Government pushes through a flawed and rushed redesign of dementia and aged care. ...1 week ago
- Release: Govt fails hundreds of workers as mills close
Labour is devastated at news hundreds of workers are set to lose their jobs following the closure of Winstone Pulp mills. ...1 week ago
- Job losses from mill closures consequence of Govt inaction
Hundreds of jobs lost as a result of pulp mill closures in the Ruapehu District are a consequence of government inaction in addressing the shortfalls of our electricity network. ...1 week ago
- Ngarewa-Packer devastated for Ruapehu following WPI closure
Te Pāti Māori Co-Leader and MP for Te Tai Hauāuru is devastated for the Ruapehu community following today’s decision to close two Winstone Pulp mills. “My heart goes out to all the workers, their whānau, and the wider Ruapehu community affected by the closure of Winstone Pulp International,” said Ngarewa-Packer. ...2 weeks ago
- Release: Cabinet should stop the Treaty Principles Bill
National Party Ministers have a majority in Cabinet and can stop David Seymour’s Treaty Principles Bill, which even the Prime Minister has described as “divisive and unhelpful.” ...2 weeks ago
- Release: Staff gagged to keep fast track list secret
The National Government is so determined to hide the list of potential projects that will avoid environmental scrutiny it has gagged Ministry for the Environment staff from talking about it. ...2 weeks ago
- Release: Labour challenges Te Whatu Ora gag orders
Labour has complained to the Te Kawa Mataaho Public Service Commission about the high number of non-disclosure agreements that have effectively gagged staff at Te Whatu Ora Health NZ from talking about anything relating to their work. ...2 weeks ago
- Greens call on Treaty Principles Bill to be abandoned after letter from Christian leaders
The Green Party is once again urging the Prime Minister to abandon the Treaty Principles Bill as a letter from more than 400 Christian leaders calls for the proposed legislation to be dropped. ...2 weeks ago
- Sign the petition: Keep military-style firearms off our streets
Help us tell the Government that reintroducing military-style firearms should not be up for debate. ...2 weeks ago
- Vast majority of councils support Māori wards
Councils across the country have now decided where they stand regarding Māori wards, with a resounding majority in favour of keeping them in what is a significant setback for the Government. ...2 weeks ago
- Release: Government on the wrong side of Māori wards
The National-led government has been given a clear message from the local government sector, as almost all councils reject the Government’s bid to treat Māori wards different to other wards. ...2 weeks ago
- Release: Labour congratulates Kuīni Ngā Wai hono i te po Paki
The Labour Party congratulates Kuīni Ngā Wai hono i te po Paki on being crowned as the eighth Te Ariki Nui – head of Te Kiingitanga. ...2 weeks ago
- Tourism on the table for Pacific Ministers’ meet-up
Tourism and Hospitality Minister Matt Doocey will meet with Trade and Tourism Minister of Australia Don Farrell and Fiji Deputy Prime Minister Manoa Kamikamica in Rotorua this weekend for a trilateral tourism discussion. “Like in New Zealand, tourism plays a significant role in Australia and Fiji’s economy, contributing massively to ...13 hours ago - Young people report on family and sexual violence
The Te Puna Aonui Expert Advisory Group for Children and Young People has presented its report today on improving family and sexual violence outcomes for young people, to the Minister for the Prevention of Family and Sexual Violence, Karen Chhour. The presentation at the Auckland event was an opportunity for ...13 hours ago
- $18 million being invested in the victims of crime
The Government is putting more than $18 million towards improving the experience of the criminal justice system for victims, Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith and Minister for Children Karen Chhour say. “No one should experience crime, but for those who through no fault of their own become victims, they need to ...14 hours ago
- Landmark phonics check in te reo Māori
For the first time, schools can use a purpose-built tool to check how a child is progressing in reading through te reo Māori. “Around 45 schools are trialling a New Zealand first te reo Māori phonics check, known as Hihira Weteoro. It will help kaiako (teachers) focus on what ākonga ...15 hours ago
- New sea walls safeguard Ōpōtiki’s transformation
Two new breakwater walls at Pākihikura (Ōpōtiki) Harbour will provide boats with safe harbour access to support the continued growth of aquaculture in Bay of Plenty, Deputy Prime Minister Winston Peters and Regional Development Minister Shane Jones say. The Ministers and leaders from Tē Tāwharau o Te Whakatōhea and other ...17 hours ago
- Kitmap to improve access to science infrastructure
Science, Innovation and Technology Minister Judith Collins today announced an online platform to optimise the use of New Zealand’s science and technology research infrastructure and to link the public and private sector. “This country is home to world-class science, technology, and engineering expertise. Kitmap is set to empower Kiwi innovators, ...17 hours ago
- Driving the uptake of low emission heavy vehicles
The Government has launched the Low Emissions Heavy Vehicle Fund (LEHVF) to promote innovation and offset the cost of hundreds of heavy vehicles powered by clean technologies, Energy Minister Simeon Brown and Climate Change Minister Simon Watts say. “Boosting economic growth and productivity is a key part of the Government’s plan ...17 hours ago
- Speech on replacing the Resource Management Act
Replacing the RMA Hon Chris Bishop: Good morning, it is great to be with you. Can I first acknowledge the Resource Management Law Association for hosting us here today. Can I also acknowledge my Parliamentary Under-Secretary, Simon Court, who is on stage with me. He has assisted me in establishing the ...18 hours ago
- Replacement for the Resource Management Act takes shape
Two new laws will be developed to replace the Resource Management Act (RMA), with the enjoyment of property rights as their guiding principle, RMA Reform Minister Chris Bishop and Parliamentary Under-Secretary Simon Court say. “The RMA was passed with good intentions in 1991 but has proved a failure in practice. ...19 hours ago
- Tough laws pass to make gang life uncomfortable
Legislation passed through Parliament today will provide police and the courts with additional tools to crack down on gangs that peddle misery and intimidation throughout New Zealand, Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith says. “From November 21, gang insignia will be banned in all public places, courts will be able to issue non-consorting orders, and ...2 days ago
- New levy rates set to ensure continued funding of FENZ
Minister of Internal Affairs Brooke van Velden says the Government has agreed to the rates for the redesigned levy that will fund Fire and Emergency New Zealand (FENZ) from July 2026. “Earlier this year FENZ consulted publicly on a 5.2 percent increase to the levy. I was not convinced that ...2 days ago
- Police allocate Officers to Beat and Gang Units
The Coalition Government welcomes Police’s announcement today to deploy more police on the beat and staff to Gang Disruption Units. An additional 70 officers will be allocated to Community Beat Teams across towns and regional centres. This builds on the deployment of beat officers in Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch CBDs ...2 days ago
- Consultation begins on significant updates to the biosecurity system
Proposals to strengthen the country’s vital biosecurity system, including higher fines for passengers bringing in undeclared high-risk goods, greater flexibility around importing requirements, and fairer cost sharing for biosecurity responses have been released today for public consultation. Biosecurity Minister Andrew Hoggard says “The future is about resilience and the 30-year-old ...2 days ago
- Wānaka community to benefit from new overnight health service
Health Minister Dr Shane Reti says an Overnight Acute Care Service opening in October will provide people in Wānaka and the surrounding area with the assurance of quality overnight care closer to home. “When I was in Wānaka earlier this year, I announced funding for an overnight health service – ...2 days ago
- Preventing potholes with data-driven technology
The Government is rolling out data collection vans across the country to better understand the condition of our road network to prevent potholes from forming in the first place, Transport Minister Simeon Brown says. “Increasing productivity to help rebuild our economy is a key priority for the Government and increasing ...2 days ago
- GDP data shows effect of high interest rates
Gross Domestic Product (GDP) data for the quarter to June 2024 reinforces how an extended period of high interest rates has meant tough times for families, businesses, and communities, but recent indications show the economy is starting to bounce back, Finance Minister Nicola Willis says. Stats NZ data released today ...2 days ago
- NZ to host first Fiji, Australia trilateral trade Ministers’ meeting in Rotorua
Trade Minister Todd McClay will host Fijian Deputy Prime Minister Manoa Kamikamica and Australian Trade Minister Don Farrell for trilateral trade talks in Rotorua this weekend. “Fiji is one of the largest economies in the Pacific and is a respected partner for Australia and New Zealand,” Mr McClay says. Australia and New Zealand ...2 days ago
- NZ hosts Annual CER Trade Ministers’ meeting in Rotorua
Trade Minister Todd McClay will meet with Australian Trade Minister Don Farrell for the annual Closer Economic Relations (CER) Trade Ministers’ meeting in Rotorua this weekend. “CER is our most comprehensive agreement covering trade, labour mobility, harmonisation of standards and political cooperation. It underpins an important trading relationship worth $32 ...2 days ago
- Government proposing changes to jury trials
The Government is seeking the public’s feedback on two major changes to jury trials in order to improve court timeliness, Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith says. “The first proposal would increase the offence threshold at which a defendant can decide to have their case heard by a jury. “The second is ...2 days ago
- Business key to regional economic dialogue
Local businesses and industries need to be front and centre in conversations about how regions plan to grow their economies, Regional Development Shane Jones says. The nationwide series of summits aims to facilitate conversations about regional economic growth and opportunities to drive productivity, prosperity and resilience through the Coalition Government’s Regional ...2 days ago
- More funding for Growing Up in New Zealand study
The Government is investing $16.8 million over the next four years to extend the Growing Up in New Zealand (GUiNZ) Longitudinal Study. GUiNZ is New Zealand’s largest longitudinal study of child health and wellbeing and has followed the lives of more than 6000 children born in 2009 and 2010, and ...2 days ago
- Tough targets for charter schools will raise achievement
Associate Education Minister David Seymour says that Charter Schools will face a combination of minimum performance thresholds and stretch targets for achievement, attendance and financial sustainability. “Charter schools will be given greater freedom to respond to diverse student needs in innovative ways, but they will be held to a much ...2 days ago
- NZ votes for Middle East resolution at UN
New Zealand has voted for a United Nations resolution on Israel’s presence in occupied Palestinian Territory with some caveats, Foreign Minister Winston Peters says. “New Zealand’s yes vote is fundamentally a signal of our strong support for international law and the need for a two-state solution,” Mr Peters says. “The Israel-Palestine ...2 days ago
- Honouring the legacy of New Zealand’s suffragists
Suffrage Day is an opportunity to reaffirm New Zealand’s commitment to ensuring we continue to be a world leader in gender equality, Minister for Women Nicola Grigg says. “On 19 September, 131 years ago, New Zealand became the first nation in the world where women gained the right to vote. ...2 days ago
- Foreign Minister to travel to New York, French Polynesia
Foreign Minister Winston Peters is travelling to New York next week to attend the 79th session of the United Nations General Assembly, followed by a visit to French Polynesia. “In the context of the myriad regional and global crises, our engagements in New York will demonstrate New Zealand’s strong support for ...3 days ago
- Thanking social workers on their national day
“Today, on Aotearoa New Zealand Social Workers’ Day, I would like to recognise the tremendous effort social workers make not just today, but every day,” Children’s Minister and Minister for the Prevention of Family and Sexual Violence Karen Chhour says. “I thank all those working on the front line for ...3 days ago
- Minister of State for Trade heads to Laos for ASEAN meetings
Minister of State for Trade Nicola Grigg will travel to Laos this week to attend the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) Economic Ministers’ Meetings in Vientiane. “The Government is committed to strengthening our relationship with ASEAN,” Ms Grigg says. “With next year marking 50 years since New Zealand became ...3 days ago
- Members appointed to retail crime MAG
The Government has appointed four members to the Ministerial Advisory Group for victims of retail crime, Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith and Associate Justice Minister Nicole McKee say. “I am delighted to appoint Michael Hill’s national retail manager Michael Bell to the group, as well as Waikato community advocate and business ...3 days ago
- Speech to the New Zealand Nurses Organisation AGM and Conference 2024
It’s my pleasure to be here to join the opening of the NZNO AGM and Conference for 2024. First, I’d like to thank NZNO Kaiwhakahaere Kerri Nuku, NZNO President, Anne Daniels, and Chief Execuitve Paul Gaulter for inviting me to speak today. Thank you also to all the NZNO members ...3 days ago
- Improvements for New Zealand authors
Minister of Internal Affairs Brooke van Velden says changes to the Public Lending Right [PLR] scheme will help benefit both the National Library and authors who have books available in New Zealand libraries. “I am amending the regulations so that eligible authors will no longer have to reapply every year ...4 days ago
- Minister commends Police for gang operation
Police Minister Mark Mitchell congratulates Police for the outstanding result of their most recent operation, targeting the Comancheros. “That Police have been able to round up the majority of the Comancheros leadership, and many of their patched members and prospects, shows not only the capability of Police, but also shows ...4 days ago
- New appointments to the EPA board
Environment Minister Penny Simmonds has announced a major refresh of the Environmental Protection Authority (EPA) board with four new appointments and one reappointment. The new board members are Barry O’Neil, Jennifer Scoular, Alison Stewart and Nancy Tuaine, who have been appointed for a three-year term ending in August 2027. “I would ...4 days ago
- Enabling rural recovery works in Hawke’s Bay
Cabinet has approved an Order in Council to enable severe weather recovery works to continue in the Hawke’s Bay, Environment Minister Penny Simmonds and Minister for Emergency Management and Recovery Mark Mitchell say. “Cyclone Gabrielle and the other severe weather events in early 2023 caused significant loss and damage to ...4 days ago
- FamilyBoost childcare payment registrations open
From today, low-to-middle-income families with young children can register for the new FamilyBoost payment, to help them meet early childhood education (ECE) costs. The scheme was introduced as part of the Government’s tax relief plan to help Kiwis who are doing it tough. “FamilyBoost is one of the ways we ...4 days ago
- Prioritising victims with tougher sentences
The Government has today agreed to introduce sentencing reforms to Parliament this week that will ensure criminals face real consequences for crime and victims are prioritised, Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith says. "In recent years, there has been a concerning trend where the courts have imposed fewer and shorter prison sentences ...5 days ago
- Targets data confirms rise in violent crime
The first quarterly report on progress against the nine public service targets show promising results in some areas and the scale of the challenge in others, Prime Minister Christopher Luxon says. “Our Government reinstated targets to focus our public sector on driving better results for New Zealanders in health, education, ...5 days ago
- Asia Foundation Board appointments announced
Foreign Minister Winston Peters has announced the appointments of Hone McGregor, Professor David Capie, and John Boswell to the Board of the Asia New Zealand Foundation. Bede Corry, Secretary of Foreign Affairs and Trade, has also been appointed as an ex-officio member. The new trustees join Dame Fran Wilde (Chair), ...5 days ago
- Endeavour Fund projects for economic growth
New Zealand’s largest contestable science fund is investing in 72 new projects to address challenges, develop new technology and support communities, Science, Innovation and Technology Minister Judith Collins says. “This Endeavour Fund round being funded is focused on economic growth and commercial outputs,” Ms Collins says. “It involves funding of more ...5 days ago
- Social Services Providers Whakamanawa National Conference 16 September 2024
Thank you for the introduction and the invitation to speak to you here today. I am honoured to be here in my capacity as Minister for the Prevention of Family and Sexual Violence, and Minister for Children. Thank you for creating a space where we can all listen and learn, ...5 days ago
- Parihaka infrastructure upgrades funded
The Government will provide a $5.8 million grant to improve water infrastructure at Parihaka in Taranaki, Regional Development Minister Shane Jones and Māori Development Minister Tama Potaka say. “This grant from the Regional Infrastructure Fund will have a multitude of benefits for this hugely significant cultural site, including keeping local ...5 days ago
- Gentrification isn’t inevitable − it can hinge on how residents view their neighborhood
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Elizabeth Korver-Glenn, Assistant Professor of Sociology, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill Families on bikes at a July Fourth parade in Houston’s Northside neighborhood. Jimmy Castillo, CC BY-ND Gentrification has become a familiar story in cities across the United States. The ...4 hours ago - Discrimination faced by indigenous Papuans ‘isn’t something new’, says disturbing new rights r...
By Caleb Fotheringham, RNZ Pacific journalist Racism, torture and arbitrary arrests are some examples of discrimination indigenous Papuans have dealt with over the last 60 years from Indonesia, according to a new report by Human Rights Watch. The report, If It’s Not Racism, What Is It? Discrimination and other abuses ...7 hours ago
- Wā Pātai: Māori language week at Parliament
The House - Parliament was buzzing with te reo this week - but how common is this, really? ...7 hours ago - Otago land and water plan to continue, despite government’s ‘strong preference’ it...
Regional councillors have voted to continue work on the plan, despite ministers suggesting they hold off until the government confirms its policy direction. ...9 hours ago
- Many people in the Pacific lack access to adequate toilets – and climate change makes things worse
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Benny Zuse Rousso, Research Fellow, International Water Centre, Griffith University Pvince73/Shutterstock The Pacific Islands may evoke images of sprawling coastlines and picturesque scenery. But while this part of the world might look like paradise, many local residents are grappling with a ...10 hours ago
- New Law To Ban Gang Patches A Dangerous Move For New Zealand
Censorship can be a natural impulse to things we don’t like, but it’s better to know when hateful or offensive ideas exist. Otherwise, they’re buried underground to fester and can crop up unexpectedly. We see this legislation no differently. ...10 hours ago - Government urged to intervene in Cook Strait ferry woes
There are fears lives could be lost if the government doesn't step in to bring the country's ailing Cook Strait ferry services up to scratch. ...10 hours ago
- Is life getting better for China’s tech billionaires?
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Wenting He, PhD candidate of International Relations, Australian National University The skyline in Shenzhen, the city that is home to many of China’s largest tech companies. asharkyu/Shutterstock According to the latest Bloomberg Billionaires Index, Pony Ma, co-founder of Tencent Holdings, is once ...11 hours ago
- Fiji 2000 coup leader George Speight granted presidential pardon
RNZ Pacific The man behind the 2000 coup in Fiji, George Speight, and the head of the mutineers, former soldier Shane Stevens, have been granted presidential pardons. In a statement yesterday, the Fiji Correction Service said the pair were among seven prisoners who has been granted pardons by the President, ...12 hours ago
- Supreme Court orders government to pay in advance for Māori coastline appeal
In a rare decision, the country's top court has told the Crown it must give advance financial support to a group of hapū challenging it. ...12 hours ago
- Darleen Tana fails High Court bid against Green Party investigation
Green co-leader Chloe Swarbrick says the party welcomes the ruling and will now consider its next steps. ...13 hours ago
- Resource Management Act to be replaced by two new laws
They'll ditch rules that "invite every Tom, Dick, and Harry to vexatiously object to peaceful use and development", the government says. ...13 hours ago
- Are sports stars who are caught using illegal drugs unfairly vilified?
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Jack Wilson, Postdoctoral Research Fellow at the Matilda Centre for Research in Mental Health and Substance Use, University of Sydney JFontan/Shutterstock With the Paris Olympics and Paralympics wrapped up, and leading Australian sports codes coming to an end of their 2024 ...13 hours ago
- Flood gates could reopen for Māori claimants after landmark ruling
The Courts have ruled the Crown must cover the costs of customary marine title claims, but where will the money come from? A landmark Supreme Court ruling could once again ensure Māori have adequate resourcing to pursue customary marine title claims, despite the government’s recent drastic raising of the threshold ...13 hours ago - RNZ’s online surge could start to worry private media
Public broadcaster RNZ might be struggling to stem its falls in radio listenership, but the audience for its website rnz.co.nz is soaring.In the latest Nielsen online audience figures for August, RNZ hit 1.56 million unique readers for the month, up from under a million a year ago and less than ...13 hours ago - Referendum on four-year political terms may come by next election – Luxon
Prime Minister Christopher Luxon says he may bring four-year political terms to a national vote at the next election. ...14 hours ago
- Afghan women have been robbed of health care, education and now their voices. But they won’t remai...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Susan Hutchinson, PhD Candidate, International Relations, Australian National University Last month, the Taliban passed a new “vice and virtue” law, making it illegal for women to speak in public. Under the law, women can also be punished if they are heard singing ...14 hours ago
- What is ‘dynamic pricing’ for concert tickets? It can cost you hundreds of dollars while you que...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Ben Green, Research Fellow, Centre for Social and Cultural Research, Griffith University When tickets for Green Day’s 2025 Australian tour went on sale, fans joined a queue – a ritual that has been practised for decades on footpaths, on phones, and now ...14 hours ago
- Week in Politics: ‘Crime wave’ puts government’s target in doubt
Analysis - Crime throws the government's reduction target into doubt and Labour's Chris Hipkins has to deal with a bad poll. ...15 hours ago
- India is in the midst of an electric vehicle revolution – and Australia should tap in
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By David T. Hill, Emeritus Professor of Southeast Asian Studies, Indo-Pacific Research Centre, Murdoch University David T. Hill You don’t have to be in India long to appreciate just how dramatic its electric vehicle revolution is. Whether it’s electric two-wheelers or trucks, ...15 hours ago
- Supreme Court orders Govt to pay in advance for Māori coastline appeal
In a rare decision, heavy with judicial and political implications, the country’s top court has told the Crown it must give advance financial support to a group of hapū challenging it over the Marine and Coastal Areas Act.The Supreme Court’s intervention, ahead of seven appeals scheduled before it in November ...15 hours ago
- The Friday Poem: ‘???’ by Freya Daly Sadgrove
A new poem by Freya Daly Sadgrove. ??? where you wake is black and very far back behind your eyes back past your whipping branches and backer far backer than bone and blood ...15 hours ago
- The Unity Books bestseller chart for the week ending September 20
The only published and available best-selling indie book chart in New Zealand is the top 10 sales list recorded every week at Unity Books’ stores in High St, Auckland, and Willis St, Wellington. AUCKLAND 1 Greene Lyon by Alan Goodwin (Quentin Wilson Publishing, $38) An intriguing new local release. Here’s ...15 hours ago
- Why is pain so exhausting?
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Michael Henry, Physiotherapist and PhD candidate, Body in Mind Research Group, University of South Australia simona pilolla 2/Shutterstock One of the most common feelings associated with persisting pain is fatigue and this fatigue can become overwhelming. People with chronic pain can ...16 hours ago
- OpenAI’s data hunger raises privacy concerns
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Uri Gal, Professor in Business Information Systems, University of Sydney Last month, OpenAI came out against a yet-to-be enacted Californian law that aims to set basic safety standards for developers of large artificial intelligence (AI) models. This was a change of posture ...16 hours ago
- Ads from Hell: how a pizza brand’s marketing reveals NZ’s shifting religious attitudes
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Dan Fastnedge, Lecturer in Advertising and Brand Creativity, Auckland University of Technology Getty Images Controversial advertising holds a mirror up to society. It can unite us in laughter or outrage, spark debates that shape our beliefs – and sometimes expose our ...17 hours ago
- Breaking update: More NZX CEOs are called Mark than are bogans
There are more Marks than women leading NZX companies, RNZ reported this morning. The Spinoff can now reveal that there are way more Marks than bogans. It’s not exactly breaking news that women are underrepresented in business leadership, but RNZ found a funny and inventive way of demonstrating that this ...17 hours ago
- From cauldrons to cardigans – the lurking prejudices behind the name ‘Granny’
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Kate Burridge, Professor of Linguistics, Monash University Shutterstock “Honestly, I can’t wait to have grandkids and spoil them — but I don’t want to be called ‘Granny’” (overheard on the No. 96 tram in Melbourne) “I love it. It’s not ...17 hours ago
- Where do Wellington’s top chefs eat on their day off?
The capital’s best chefs and restaurateurs share their favourite local eateries and hidden gems. I have always been fascinated by chefs and restaurateurs. Perhaps it is because of how altruistic they are, existing in a space that seeks to provide pleasure to others regardless of how it impacts on their ...17 hours ago
- Council ‘got it wrong’ with Links Ave closure, meeting told
It's the most controversial road in Mt Maunganui and a newly elected councillor is asking why it was allowed to happen. ...17 hours ago
- Murdoch to Musk: how global media power has shifted from the moguls to the big tech bros
ANALYSIS: By Matthew Ricketson, Deakin University and Andrew Dodd, The University of Melbourne Until recently, Elon Musk was just a wildly successful electric car tycoon and space pioneer. Sure, he was erratic and outspoken, but his global influence was contained and seemingly under control. But add the ownership of just ...18 hours ago
- Defence Force offered zero pay increase start industrial action
Civilian staff employed NZDF have started industrial action, unhappy not to be offered any increase in pay. ...19 hours ago
- ‘There isn’t any acting here’: What it was like recording The Bone People audiobook
Ruby Solly on reading Keri Hulme’s Booker Prize-winning novel The Bone People for the audiobook, released this week. Initially, there is only one way to describe this work; an honour and a privilege. I say this every time I get to spend time with the words of our kaumātua, but ...19 hours ago
- Pacific profiles: Mr Tiria, the English teacher showcasing Pacific literature in Naenae
The Pacific profiles series shines a light on Pacific people in Aotearoa doing interesting and important work in their communities, as nominated by members of the public. Today, Tiria Tiria. All photos by Geoffery Matautia. On a Saturday afternoon at Lower Hutt’s Naenae College, I sat with Mr Tiria as ...19 hours ago
- More than half of people who use party drugs take ADHD medicines without a prescription, new researc...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Rachel Sutherland, Research Fellow, National Drug and Alcohol Research Centre, UNSW Sydney Alex Green/Pexels Each year, the National Drug and Alcohol Research Centre at UNSW Sydney surveys hundreds of people who regularly use drugs in Australia to understand trends in substance ...19 hours ago
- Scientists reviewed 7,000 studies on microplastics. Their alarming conclusion puts humanity on notic...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Karen Raubenheimer, Senior Lecturer, University of Wollongong Shutterstock It’s been 20 years since a paper in the journal Science showed the environmental accumulation of tiny plastic fragments and fibres. It named the particles “microplastics”. The paper opened an entire research field. ...19 hours ago
- Endure – or peter out? Here’s what Northern Rivers organisers and Stop Adani can teach us about...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Amanda Tattersall, Associate Professor in Urban Geography and Host of ChangeMakers Podcast, University of Sydney mantisdesign/Shutterstock Over the last decade, several groups in Australia have successfully mobilised against fossil fuel interests. But which ones have gone the distance? The urgent ...19 hours ago
- Treaty Principles Bill Politically Clumsy And Unproductive
The Treaty Principles Bill is unproductive for New Zealand, says Te Rūnanga o Ngāi Tahu Kaiwhakahaere Justin Tipa. “David Seymour and ACT are misconstruing history. You can’t have a reasonable debate with a person or party who distorts the truth,” ...20 hours ago
- ‘I don’t believe I would have gotten into university’: how early entry schemes help Year 12 st...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Sally Patfield, Lecturer, Teachers and Teaching Research Centre, School of Education, University of Newcastle Matej Kastelic/Shutterstock During September, many Australian universities start making early offers to Year 12 students for a place next year. This is ahead of the main rounds ...20 hours ago
- The most miserable and fucked-up children’s authors, rated
You don’t have to live a haunting life of unparalleled grief and sorrow to be a great children’s author, but it helps. Content warning: This article mentions suicide and abuse. It’s always been a cliche of children’s literature, that many of the greatest writers for children dislike children. Even those ...20 hours ago
So good Nigel can pop in to comment on Labour, Social Democracy and taxation from his winter base in the French Riviera.
If you want it, come back and fight for it.
Did you post this from your second home on the shores of Lake Wānaka?
🔥
Long way from the blackball hotel aswell!
Now, now, Ad, I live on a beach in the Far North–may I comment?
There are various levels and arenas of political struggle and inner party is one of the most fraught. NZ Labour has a major policy shift required and it is nice to see Nigel uttering that which for years shall not be named…Social Democracy.
also, we have the internet, it's not like people can't participate in participatory democracy from various place.
I am outed as a Francophile, who, in retirement spends a month or so in Europe every year, where we can see two of our Europe-resident children and their partners, whilst chewing the fat (and the croissant) with our local Communist mayor in a tiny Cantal hamlet. We will do something together on the political economy of regional dairy farming next year. Less exotically, this post was written in Auckland, where our other two children reside. I love Wanaka, too, where my brother lives, and gives the likes of Peter Theil a run for their money.
is that supposed to a argument in favour of a CGT? if so, I'm sold. lets do it
What snarky comments Ad and Muttonbird. Nigel is a great thinker and has contributed years to the Labour movement even before his involvement as LP Prez. I welcome the debate and his contribution.
I was pointing out Ad's hypocrisy.
Way back in the late 80s Nigel as an academic gave some good advice and support for a bunch of us South Auckland workers involved in a lengthy strike, including meetings at Auckland Uni and attending final mediation. His heart is with working class people.
I remember it well. Fresh off the 'plane and made very welcome by local unions.
It’s been pleasant to read Mountain Tui’s work also. There must be many sincere and strong voices with different experiences of the left within Labour and with a loyalty to Labour.
It’s been good to see some of these return to The Standard or perhaps rightly some newer voices come through- though I always enjoy MickeySavages work! It’s just alarming that he’s still the ‘sensible’ one on this site. Though he must be much younger than Biden or Trump…or at the very least somewhat!
this is an encouraging post.
Do any Labourites want to have a crack at explaining how members determine policy?
Labour also has a Policy Council elected after an election and policy committees selected from people who put their CVs forward (at the same time as Policy Council) – the terms of both run to the next election.
The policy committees work on policy remits based on subject area – item 4 above is the domain of these committees.
Policy Council puts together the manifesto based on the last manifesto, their own work, spokespeople's work and annual conference voting.
Members can also start a dialogue with MPs and spokespeople directly and participate in policy workshops as they happen.
What Craig H said.
Also, ask the leadership questions. We have Jill Day coming to our LEC at our next meeting.
Great Post, so let me address it instead of taking lazy potshots at its Author.
On the one hand, professionalisation and corporatisation of politics have increased to a point at which it has become the domain of (and for?) the so-called Professional Managerial Class (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Professional%E2%80%93managerial_class). Sadly, this is not affecting only parties of the Right.
On the other hand, guiding principles of deliberative democracy suggest that anybody can tackle even the most complex issues.
I think that Labour leadership and membership need to work together more closely and in unison instead of adhering to corporate dogma that ‘management knows best’.
When a serious point or two is raised on our blog, it bad enough when "so called lefties" take pot shots, and so much worse when a real lefty does.
I think Labour lost its way last election, as a faction felt threatened by David Parker's indepth look at Taxation, and who paid and at what level. It was a huge talking point, and handled with more grassroots feedback, we may have had cut through.
Hipkin's Captain's call cut the conversation dead.
I stopped contributing in that week, wrote and said I would not contribute any more money, 'till I saw a more grassroots version of social democracy.
So what Nigel has to say resonates with me. I think we need Social democracy discussions from the Grassroots up, not Top Down.
See Incognito’s thoughtful post.
Na it's symptomatic of the left wing problem, there is few that appear to rub shoulders with us out here, shit I've been in spitting distance of 3 nat mps in the last year, I did refrain btw.
I don't always agree with what you say Patricia, but I always listen to what you say. I'm a lifetime left voter, usually left of Labour. I vote tactically but this year I was so pissed off with Hipkins with his "captain's call" and the Greens generally, I voted party vote TPM, because I liked their focus, and electorate vote Greens, because it doesn't matter under MMP and it's the nearest thing I have to a party whanau.
Since the election I've rejoined the Greens as in "do you want to have any party/political influence or not" and Hipkins is doing a good job as "Leader of the Opposition" along with the stellar Chloe Swarbrick.
Personally I believe the role of Leader of the Opposition should be up for debate rather than going by default to the leader of the biggest party, so Swarbrick should be leading not Hipkins, or at the very least they should be a tag team.
My fear is that Labour are irredeemable, centrist neoliberals rather than even social democrats. David Parker seems to have integrity, but Hipkins not so much.
Fantastic stuff Patricia.
Patricia : Labour had a CGT in its policy for 2011 and 2014 – we lost both elections. It was pulled by Jacinda after 2017 when she couldn't get NZ First to vote for it. Chippy's Captain's Call was, I think, an attempt to neutralise National et al's attacks on tax increases in the election debate – while they were promising "tax relief":. I didn't agree with it and it was probably misguided, but nor did it stop my contribution and determination to keep the CoC out. Voltaire said "don't let perfection be the enemy of the good." Look what we have now.
Surely any decent leftie knows we need to tax the rich.
Even the middle class are losing ground as the rich buy up all the assets.
However, what I don't know, is what is the most effective type of tax? One that really addresses inequality. Inheritance? Capital gains? Wealth? Financial transaction?
Or land tax?
it would be great if Labour could go back to the work it was doing on the various options and present them to the public as points of debate. Now is the perfect time. Not because NZ should necessarily do what Labour suggest, but because as the biggest progressive party, we need to hear their ideas and for them to lead not by telling us what should be but by naming the issues and ideas and solutions and engaging the public on that.
Engaging members first is what is needed. That is happening right now with discussion going on all over the motu.
that's great to hear, thanks!
Yes and because that grassroots appears to have begun I am contributing again. Jacinda used to reach out and ask what we thought was needed. (Or her team did) That stopped when Chris Hipkins took over. Now I believe he is a good man, who had big shoes to fill. When you are 83 you can not be sure you will even see the next election!! So like many I over reacted in despair. I remember saying what austerity would do, and Belladonna saying have a lie down and a cup of tea. For a while I disengaged. Incognito Darien and Nick Rockell and Otto gave me heart again. When I watched Chris Luxon in the house, crouching snarling sending waves of hate across at Jacinda, I recognised he was signalling to those angry people outside the house, to all who hated the control of the lockdowns and the medical calls that were made. He would use every trick to gain power, and he was an Atlas follower. So Ad's comments reminded me the Left need to remain resolute. So for what it is worth I am back on board again.
Some ideas
1.Progressive taxation on companies – as per the USA. Larger companies pay a higher rate – 33 cents instead of 28 cents.
Reduce some other companies to 25 cents tax.
2.A 10% surcharge (3.3%) on banks and supermarkets.
Use the money to develop business finance (development) and loan insurance (cheaper loans) and support competition in the market.
3.A 5% stamp duty on houses over $2M.
4.A wealth tax (and restoration of the bright-line test), while a CGT and estate tax is developed. With the wealth tax paid credited to the estate tax liability. The purpose to realise revenues more quickly.
5.A 1% mortgage surcharge on landlords.
I'm inclined to think we should scrap GST and make income tax more steeply progressive. This in effect would be a return to what we had prior to the 4th Labour Government.
The point of the change was to encourage savings, rather than spending – but instead of savings for productive investment, we got speculation in property (no CGT, and the removal of the estate tax).
That and the decline in wages relative to business profit (ECA and decline of unions with globalisation) has diminished home ownership.
The consequences include the under-funding of government – the decline in public services and infrastructure followed.
The neo-liberal right of private health insurance and private schools (or gated community school zones) cares naught about this – they retain citizenship because of the taxation regime we have, their children live abroad and yet will do the same. They are our rentier class, and their settler vs indigenous Maori divide and conquer game is their form of the Trumpian red MAGA Cap populism.
It's really a reprise of a combination of Massey's colonial "supremacism", Hannan's assimilation and a pro American policy of Cold War era, all to distract us from the class order of rule being imposed across government.
Luxon, being of a prosperity gospel religion sees it as the natural order of rule of the landlord class (of the time when property ownership was required to vote).
We are now falling below 60% property ownership and trends are for it to be below 50% by 2050.
The default answer of the Left appears to be to increase taxes. However, on its own, this does little to nothing to lift productivity that grows the overall tax base.
So, in addition to progressive taxes and increased tax breaks & credits for low-income people, Labour could introduce tax incentives for R&D, tax exemptions & credits for green investments (e.g. insulation of homes in areas that are economically deprived), and tax deductions for training, educating, and up-skilling of low-income workers. When designed and targeted well, these initiatives could boost job opportunities for low-income workers.
I'd look at a boost to the roll out of solar power to homes (capability and funding).
Maybe the 1% mortgage surcharge funding it for both landlord and other properties.
Allowing people to intern/work for training while on benefits.
https://www.rsm.global/insights/2024-guide-rd-tax-incentives-across-australia-and-new-zealand-key-considerations
The problem with NZ is that we don't have any significiant taxes on property capital gains, at least compared to any other nations in the OECD.
This gives considerable advantage to financial and unproductive economic parasites. Which is what we see.
If someone can show me how economic productivity increases without those kinds of taxes to limit capital growth and rentier economic attitudes in our or any economy, then I will support swinging inheritance taxes, capital gains taxes, and wealth taxes, land taxes. In fact any taxes that drive economic rentier parasites away from NZ as far as I am concerned.
About the only capital taxes I don't like are those that are based on innovation and company growth. They pay company tax. Shareholders pay PIR. I think that the IRD has enough computer power to deal with them.
Actually the problem is that NZ doesnt have any significant taxes on property….the gains have already been made
Rates are a property tax so it is good to see them rising now. But rates are nowhere near enough. Either a Wealth Tax or a Land Tax is needed. Capital Gains Tax is complicated and often raises. little revenue….the proceeds are highly variable.
The problem is that rates rising is dealing with a problem left by previous generations who haven't paid their part in repairs, refurbishment, and replacements. Mostly because they have effectively taken the profit from drops in capital values from depreciation of infrastructure in the form of reduced rates and taxes.
The problem with NZ is that we don't have any significiant taxes on property capital gains, at least compared to any other nations in the OECD.
This gives considerable advantage to financial and unproductive economic parasites. Which is what we see.
Not really. The seller's capital gain is, in effect, paid for by the buyer, who pays for it from his own tax paid income.
"Rentier income" is actually non productive income such as rent, interest and, probably, excessive salaries, all of which get built into production costs and push up prices thereby. Capital gain is an effect of rising prices rather than a cause. Rentier income is actually taxed, but that doesn’t change the price effects.
This is not to imply that rentier income is not justified: I suppose nobody would wish to lend money or property to another without receiving a return for doing so. However a (social credit) government may well decide to lend out fiat money for productive purposes.
You're describing the residential housing?
Problem is of course that the purchaser isn't paying for the capital gain from their income.
They are paying for it and the interest payments from their future income. The majority of the payment is made from funds from a bank, typically using capital from offshore. Something like 80% of that offshore capital has never paid any taxes in NZ.
Offshore capital are unlikely to pay much more taxes and rates, because the banks and finance institutions are adept at pushing in costs from offshore to reduce local profits that they have to pay tax on. They usually wind up paying little for local deposits, so probably most of the capital in NZ is held offshore for better returns.
Anyway on the sale, there is no capital gain tax being paid up or has been paid up front. Certainly not while the brightline test has been dialled back to 2 years – a time period designed to maximise short-term capital gains and reduce any capital going into something productive like building property.
The seller takes whatever market rise there has been, and pays no tax on the income that they made off the property. If they are dealer or an investor, they buy another property. If they were a householder then do one of two things typically.
They buy a house that costs more – ie upsize. Or they downsize, the latter typically heading into empty nest and retirement. May pay some tax interest earned, but this steadily reduces as they enter retirement and have a reduced income over time.
As an example, I'm currently paying PIR of 17% and probably less on income tax on super that I got in June. Last year I averaged income tax of 30.5% on my gross income for the year. Then the PIR was at 28%.
Or spend a lot on overseas holidays in a way that doesn't return too much tax here. I am avoiding that, having done way too much local and international travel for work since I was 20.
BTW: The seller is also dumping the ALL of the current and future infrastructural costs including wear and tear on things like roads, schools, demographic change, etc on to the next buyer. In theory this should be pre-paid for over the 60+ years of most infrastructural assets. In practice it never is.
Wastewater pipes and their inevitable rate rises to fix and replace them are dumped on the suckers who haven't worn them out. It is dropped on a narrow generation who pay for the infrastructure of future generations. Look at why we have a few hundred billion in infrastructure to build in the next couple of decades.
Anyway the capital gain is likely to have limited tax paid on that income ever again. The costs of capital gains (as you say) are going to be dumped on suckers who are paying student debt, sky-high rates, and paying for the ever increasing hospital bills and superannuation of the people who are often sitting in multi million dollar homes or on piles of capital gains, and have no income to pay taxes on.
People ask why they don't have grand-kids around?
That is because their kids can't afford to have kids, they can't afford to buy house here because the wages are low compared to housing prices, and they and any grand kids leave NZ for places that have more rational tax policies.
This is what 40 years of a housing price spiral and a capital gains bonanza have left us with. An unproductive economy that like Shane Jones trumpet export revenues rather than export profits. A country that has a massive infrastructural deficit that makes it hard to develop profitable industries because most capital is unproductively driving a largely untaxed property price spiral.
They are paying for it and the interest payments from their future income. The majority of the payment is made from funds from a bank, typically using capital from offshore. Something like 80% of that offshore capital has never paid any taxes in NZ.
Whether future or present makes no difference. A lot of borrowers making repayments in a piecemeal fashion over a number of years is likely to be equivalent to one borrower making one lumpsum payment in the present. And the payments are still being made from the borrower's income, even if the bank's finance is coming from overseas.
Anyway on the sale, there is no capital gain tax being paid up or has been paid up front.
Why would that be desirable given that the borrower is not receiving a tax deduction in respect of the capital gain that he is paying for ?
The seller takes whatever market rise there has been, and pays no tax on the income that they made off the property.
The seller pays tax on the income he receives from the property: i.e the rental income. Capital gain is not income (except where the property has been purchased with the purpose of resale).
BTW: The seller is also dumping the ALL of the current and future infrastructural costs including wear and tear on things like roads, schools, demographic change, etc on to the next buyer. In theory this should be pre-paid for over the 60+ years of most infrastructural assets. In practice it never is.
These costs should be met by the tenant since it is the tenant who benefits from the infrastructure etc.. A landlord will usually pass these costs (where they appear as rates) on to the tenant as part of the rent.
This is what 40 years of a housing price spiral and a capital gains bonanza have left us with. An unproductive economy that like Shane Jones trumpet export revenues rather than export profits. A country that has a massive infrastructural deficit that makes it hard to develop profitable industries because most capital is unproductively driving a largely untaxed property price spiral.
Capital gains are an effect of rising property values, not a cause. One needs to look at the underlying economic factors to ascertain the causes of rising property values: e.g. shortage of properties, excessive lending by the banks, perhaps too many landlords. These factors may be encouraging investers to overinvest in property rather than in productive economic activity, but one is "putting the cart before the horse" if one blames capital gain
Bullshit. Only if they make a profit, which most landlords usually do not from income. (I must dig out the OIAs that show this clearly). The key to not doing that is to have costs that roughly match the income. Rates, insurance and financing costs being some of the major costs, the latter mostly.
It is routine for landlords, especially the ones with a number of properties to not make a profit because they leverage the property to not make one. Using the one or more properties to leverage ownership of others.
Residential property investors are typically mainly constrained on their incomes by the ability of tenants to pay. Something that has been increasingly apparent to be constrained when you look at the rate of house prices increases against a much slower rate of growth in rents over decades.
Effectively investors are increasingly becoming bludgers on the state and people who actually pay taxes providing tax income support in the form of housing benefits and working for families. They farm tenants for as much as they can extract while making capital gains.
Yes, and also expending considerable effort in trying to keep the rates that they pay down as it reduces their ability to realise capital gains profits. Which is leads directly to infrastructural debts.
Actually no. That is just the excuse used by people who don't clearly understand basic investment strategies, or more probably do only two well.
Landlords and property investors are not passive in political and economic decisions about property, they are usually heavily involved in making them for their own benefit. You only have to look at the published donations to political parties and lobby groups to understand that.
At least a third of all large donations to the parties of the current government are from property owners with large housing investments. If the visibility on smaller donations were visible, it would probably rise to closer to 50%.
Capital gains are the direct cause of rising property values. The reason is obvious when you look at the investment risk vs returns in NZ – ie the basis for all investment decisions. Why would anyone invest in building new or redeveloping properties, with the higher associated risk levels, when you can make more money from spiralling property values, at virtually no risk to original capital? Which is exactly what has been happening.
The rate of growth in housing has been falling behind population for many decades. This is especially the case since the landlord lobbies managed to stop the state building or assisting to build significiant amounts of affordable housing back in the early 90s, as well as getting the government agencies to sell off their stocks of housing – mostly to property investors and landlords.
Consequently the rate of growth in property values in NZ has been far greater than any other safe financial investment for the 45 years I have observed it. So the capital available from local and offshore sources has poured into buying existing properties and not into more productive but riskier investments in building housing or even building businesses.
In effect property prices have starved the NZ economy to the point now that a housing speculative bubble is making the whole economy highly unprofitable. All for the benefit of a relatively small number of politically connected donors of the parties in our current government.
That is why this government has once again cut building affordable housing actually being built, and why our housing construction sector is once again going into a major slump. It competes directly with the 'right' of landlords to induce artificial housing scarcity for their own profit.
Bullshit. Only if they make a profit, which most landlords usually do not from income. (I must dig out the OIAs that show this clearly). The key to not doing that is to have costs that roughly match the income. Rates, insurance and financing costs being some of the major costs, the latter mostly.
These landlords are purchasing with the intention of reselling and should, therefor, be caught by brightline tests. If they lie to IRD about their intentions then they are committing fraud and, while that fraud may be difficult to detect, I don't think honest landlords should taxed just for the sake of catching the fraudsters.
Actually no. That is just the excuse used by people who don't clearly understand basic investment strategies, or more probably do only two well.
Whether or not a tax is applicable should be based on the facts of each situation, not on whether or not the taxpayer "understands investment strategies". If a landlord is not earning any rental income then he should not be paying any tax, unless of course he would be subject to the brightline test. The latter situation will only arise however if he has purchased with the intention of reselling.
Also the fact that the brightline test has been reduced to two years is irrelevant. If a landlord/landowner purchases with the intention of reselling he will be liable for the tax regardless of the period of tenure, providing of course that he is honest in his disclosures to the tax department.
PS: I think "intention" is not a particularly useful way of determining tax liabilities anyway. A better idea where a landlord is making no rental income would be to impute to him a risk-free-rate-of-return and tax that, as advocated by Gareth Morgan in his book The Big Kahuna, and which later pushed as Opportunies Party policdy when he led that party.
Problem with the brightline test is that they have now dropped it back to 2 years. Which makes it pointless.
I don't think that 'intention' is useful. It just leads to ambiguity and expensive legal issues.
Personally for the revenue, economic and simplicity reasons I'd just levy a straight percentage of land sales value on all land title transfers before there are any title transfers from the seller. The seller pays it as part of the settlement process. This is pretty much what happens for all title changes anywhere when finance is involved.
Probably do it on the land values, not improvements, because ultimately the crown still has ultimate ownership and responsibility for all land. Call it a land transfer tax. Let it be handled by LINZ who maintains the land information database.
If any social redress is required, then treat it as recoverable taxable rebate against income or company taxes of the seller. Much the same as working for families does.
Then fiddling capital gains and even complexity doesn't come into it.
It would better if the government brought in legislation that allowed only the government to buy and sell land. Of course once a government has acquired land in this way, it would not need to resell it; itcould, instead, lease it out. Any would-be landlord would then have to lease the land from the government, in which case any capital gain would accrue to the crown. I would assume virtually all capital gain is in the land.
I realise this would be something of a long shot.
Howzabout rather than increase taxes, bringing untaxed activities under the tax umbrella? By that I mean Financial Transaction Tax.
Lots of untaxed goings on plus is essentially unimpactful on the have-nots.
Labour should not necessarily settle for the usual (orthodox & ideological) tools but do some lateral creative thinking about options that might actually work. Take a bunch of ideas to the members and then flesh out the best ones to take to all New Zealanders. Initiate genuine conversations, with clear & honest communication, and bring the people alongside.
Seems to hang a lot on a definition of productivity, right? I mean Jeff Bezos apparently found it highly productive for employees to pee in bottles while on shift, but this mostly seemed to benefit Amazon.
Heh! Good point.
What’s the correct terminology, in your view, is it output?
Dont think output is even a viable measure of productivity, problem being comparing across products/sectors. If anything I would target productivity to mean hourly wages earned, but that is already a statistic.
The problem is across the neo-liberal era productivity (sales per hour worked) has run streets ahead of hourly wages anyway. I dont think that will be addressed with fiscal policy, and also dont see why supporting that trend would be a good Labour economic policy.
Interesting to see the term post-Keynesian applied in the post. Maybe the various meanings of this should be unpacked. In economics there are two schools taking names after Keynes, these being the new-Keynesian (Krugman, Samuelson, Summers) and post-Keynesian (Keen, Davidson, Mitchell). One of the principal disagreements is if John Hicks correctly summarised the general theory in his work, connecting Keynes to the IS-LM theory and implying that monetary policy can be the only tool needed to administer economic policy (with fiscal policy relegated to balancing taxation and spending at least longer term). Or as post-Keynesians argue that the general theory actually claims a potential general short fall of fiscal policy is possible and economic outcomes may be improved with increased public spending.
I get the impression post-Keynesian in this post means the end of a period where the available tax take was seen as sufficient to balance sufficient public spending, with the future likely to require significant more tax collection to make such a balance work.
On the other hand however with UK Labour taking office and immediately announcing austerity in favour of unpopular tax increases, maybe actual alternatives to behaving as Tory light should be considered. The very real benefits of expanded public spending should also be considered on their own terms.
Post Keynesian here refers to the replacement of the 1930s-1970s Accommodation, in which Keynesian thinking played a crucial role. It makes no reference to contemporary “schools” of post-Keynesian thinking in Economics, about which I hesitate to comment in brief.
There are many issues with wealth taxation, in particular they can harm the investment necessary to achieve growth required to fund social spending, if some in the business community decide to take their lot and leave.
For this reasons, I far prefer a residential land tax, on all residential property, including the family home. Every real person (over 18) is allocated a residential real estate portfolio, based on what they own (or actually control personally), and are allowed a $1.5m tax free threshold. In this instance, married couples would be able to divide their $3m property (or even $3m property portfolio). Any amount exceeding this, would be subject to a 0.7% annual tax.
E.g.
Couple control $5m property portfolio
Each person deducts their $1.5m tax free allowance
$3m remains.
This $3m is taxed at 0.7% = $21,000
Trusts (trustees) and companies (shareholders) owning residential real estate would be obliged to disclose their real person ownership allocation. Rates of land tax would vary for special cases (e.g. iwi land, rural/working land), whose primary purpose is not housing people.
Land taxes cannot be avoided through creative accounting. A further benefit of this is mass disinvestment by property barons. Hopefully even saving money as well on the accommodation supplement.
This is based on the title prices, based on the last council valuation, or historic purchase price, whichever is most recent, and not the freehold value (i.e. less any mortgage outstanding).
The business community are still going to get upset with a land tax because most indulge in amateur landlordism as a side hustle as a way to build mini fiefdoms.
Whenever a charity collector comes to my door I politely thank them, and send them on their way, ears ringing with a short, gentle diatribe on how the progressive tax system should be doing their job.
NZ has a very poor philanthropic culture, perhaps because it has historically been an egalitarian welfare state, and I don't want to see philanthropy have to increasingly fill the widening voids in the social system, but what if a wealth tax were coupled with tax credits for contributions to social support or infrastructure projects.
Probably a dumb idea, too expensive, and the rich pricks would inevitably find a way around it.
Right now, wealth creators use plenty of social and infrastructure resources but the beneficiaries are largely restricted to immediate family.
They will be still upset, but they can't exactly take their land away in the same way that they could take their capital away (as in a real business, that we want to encourage).
They could only sell, and in an environment fostering cheaper house prices, they would be forced to either take the hit in sale price, or obliged to hang on to it and pay the tax.
How would it work in a multiple owner model? Maori land?
It's more than 30 years since we drafted the FTT proposal into Green economic policy and still nobody has ever hit the media with a credible reason not to use it.
Labour's timidity seems to have become congenital in the interim, sadly. However tax policy no longer provides the semblance of social equity that it did when I was a kid in the '50s – from a design perspective limiting income would work better.
If a patrician like Plato, operating in the heart of the Athens establishment, can advocate a 4:1 ratio between highest & lowest earners, I see no excuse being available for Labour. The ratio in corporations topped 300:1 earlier this century so anyone serious about solving the inequality problem needs to grasp that capitalism maximises the return to owners and share-holders by design – so we must shift away from that prescription.
Would an FTT apply to mortgages ?
Agree +100%