Robinsod is no longer here to do the book reviews of Wishart‘s latest insights into the world of the paranoid. As he said before pronouncing his severe disappointment with Wishart in his last book..
I had high hopes for Absolute Power, I really did. If Faulkner taught us anything with The Sound and the Fury it was that a tale told by an idiot could be a masterpiece, if Nabokov’s Pale Fire offers us any lesson it’s that an exposition of paranoia and madness can make for damn fine reading.
However Gareth Renowden at Hot-topic has stepped up to review Air Con, Wishart’s latest foray into exposing his mind in the post “Somethin’ stupid“. Gareth has a lot of fun tearing the ‘science’ in Wishart’s opus to bits. As he points out, Wishart doesn’t actually understand the fundamentals of any of the science. It would involve learning and thinking, something that Wishart appears to consider is below his dignity.
Gareth finally realises the point of the book
Having disposed of the science, he moves on to consider why this great propaganda coup has been undertaken. Turns out it’s all the fault of an evil cabal of child-eating greens, supported by mega-rich capitalists (George Soros gets a chapter to himself) who are intent on imposing socialism on the world through the UN. So all the world’s climate scientists, save a brave few supported by the downtrodden fossil fuel companies of the world, are complicit in a global conspiracy to impose socialism and world government. With this penetrating analysis, Wishart ultimately undermines his own work. If his cavalier attitude to climate science and the facts of climate change weren’t enough to destroy any credibility he might possess, then his portrayal of a great global conspiracy manipulating the world condemns his opus to the lunatic fringe.
Like Robinsod, he is ultimately disappointed
Not having read any Wishart before, I was expecting something racy, pacey and persuasive. Air Con is none of these things. It’s a crude mishmash of crank propaganda, wild and intemperate accusations against the people the author defines as the enemy, and displays a marked lack of any ‘investigation’ worth the name. It’s not even well written. They say you shouldn’t judge a book by its cover, but Air Con, with its back cover cover blurb by potty peer Christopher Monckton and IPCC proof-reader Vincent Gray makes a compelling case for so doing. It’s certainly not worth the money, time or trouble to read.
Gareth Renowden’s post is worth reading however.
Talking about Gareths, Gareth Morgan is on The Big Warm on Sunday tonight on TV1 at 7:30pm. The blurb says
Gareth Morgan, shocked by what he has seen on his motorbike travels, just wants to know the truth. He has spent considerable amounts of his personal fortune to find out who’s right about climate change…
I have a soft spot for Gareth Morgan even when I disagree with his conclusions. He is disturbingly right in most of the things that he produces data on, from polls to economic trends. He is someone worth listening to. However he should be aware that he is probably now classed with George Soros as a enemy of mankind by Wishart, which if you are defined by the class of your enemies, puts Gareth Morgan amongst the exceptionally sane.
Update:The Sunday program is available online. Gareth Morgan is already promoting his book Poles Apart – it is available on most local online bookshops. The blog on film about Takuu is here. All are far more interesting and use better science than the trash from Wishart. Unlike Wishart, the latter two didn’t just rely on warmed over reports off the internet. They went out and had a look at what was happening, and talked to working scientists.