India and Free Trade – finally someone turned the lights on

Written By: - Date published: 12:26 pm, December 19th, 2022 - 16 comments
Categories: exports, Free Trade, tourism, trade - Tags:

In this guest posts, Paul Chalmers reacts to some changes of approach for the free trade agreements with India.

After nearly 20 years of frustrating ‘Free Trade’ talks between India and New Zealand, the chair of the India New Zealand Business Council (INZBC), Earl Rattray, has acknowledged that “a different approach to the traditional Free Trade Agreements which have served us well in many markets will be needed for India.” Whew. About time.

Earl was talking at the recent INZBC forum, where the lights have finally been turned on in a relationship that has seen six failed negotiating rounds for the FTA, and regular trade visits to India by a variety of Ministers. I have been on three.

In the meantime, the Australian Parliament has set a date of 29 December 2022 for the formal establishment of their India-Australia Economic Cooperation and Trade Agreement (AI-ECTA). This is not a ‘free’ Trade Agreement as we would know it; dairy and other some other agricultural products are excluded. India has effectively protected its dairy industry, building it to be the world’s largest, and commentators are not expecting these barriers to come down any time soon. However, wine, sheep meat and wool and the crucial services sector have had their tariffs removed and other products, including a range of seafood items, will see most tariffs eliminated over 7 years. A number of side letters establish working parties to progress other areas of trade not included specifically in the current deal. Up to $14.8 billion worth of Australian merchandise was traded into India in 2022. Removal of tariffs will likely increase this significantly. A 40% increase is expected for 2023.

Yet New Zealand has struggled to get any Trade Agreement across the line, partly because India sees our dairy industry as a threat and partly because, in the words of veteran commentator, Venkat Raman, ‘we have drifted apart’. Back at the INZBC Forum, our Minister of Foreign Affairs, Nanaia Mahuta, noted that India “is a priority relationship for New Zealand.” Excellent news.

But what of the sector that was, prior to Covid, by far the largest export revenue earner with over $4b of exports to India: International Education.

On a trade visit to India in 2012 led by the Hon Steven Joyce, the Indian Minister for Human Resource Development, Shri Kapil Sibal, had expressly asked New Zealand for assistance with enabling students to Study, Work and Settle. Our Minister was sympathetic, but the high numbers of students suggested by Kapil Sibal were more than our tertiary education system could handle. On the recent (2020) Trade Mission to India, Education Sector reps did not even manage to get a seat, until the sharp eyed Minister, Hon David Parker, noted the absence and insisted to New Zealand Trade and Enterprise that an International Education rep needed to be included in the party.

Private providers have been to the fore in trying to build successful partnerships in India for over 20 years. We have aimed at building viable and profitable export education businesses which then supply job-ready graduates with the vocational skills listed on the Job Shortage List. Information Technology programmes and Business/Management programmes, both providing qualifications on the Job Shortage List, made up the bulk of the student enrolments.

Students who come to Study, Work and Settle make ideal migrants. They bring skills from their own country, contribute significantly to the economy through their fees and general spending, work in part time jobs while they are studying and coming to grips with the Kiwi way of life, and then find employment in NZ in our skills shortage areas.

However, the concept of Study, Work and Settle became a contentious battleground in our country’s immigration debate, especially when Immigration New Zealand (INZ) consistently refused visas to students who mentioned they intended to get jobs in New Zealand. It took over ten years for INZ to finally admit that Study, Work and Settle was a viable pathway and perhaps encouraging students to follow this might assist with New Zealand’s skill shortage.

When the Helen Clark government introduced post-study work rights in the mid 2000’s, the International Education industry took off. Students were then able to work for up to two years following their graduation and, hopefully, find work on the Shortage List. Many did. It was estimated by the industry that around 50 – 60% of students studying between 2000 and 2020 managed to complete their study, find jobs and gain a residence visa.

From being the only training provider in 2000 enrolling Indian students, our business suddenly found ourselves surrounded by new and interesting competitors, many of whom quickly realised that NZQA quality oversight of their operation was close to zero. A small number of these moved to exploit the weaknesses in the system. It was a case of ‘no traffic cops and some ingenious speedsters.’ We struggled for over 10 years with dodgy competitors who evaded the monitors with ease and, in a number of cases, exploited the students, took their money and abandoned them.

The issues were exacerbated in 2014 when the Hon Steven Joyce facilitated the Rule 18 change to English language requirements. This allowed students to provide their own ‘proof’ of English proficiency and was controversial. Industry reps alerted NZQA to the potential problems, but nothing was done and some students entered with poor quality English. It wasn’t until 2015 that a new NZQA Deputy Chief Executive, Quality Assurance, Grant Klinkum, introduced more effective quality control mechanisms. These have weeded out many of the poorer operators. Grant is now CEO of NZQA.

However, the public image of the industry was significantly affected by a minority of shonky operators and comments in the media began to note that students seemed to be using their education programmes as a backdoor to residency and citizenship.

I should make it quite clear. The business we established in 2000 was a front door designed to bring Indian students to NZ specifically for the purposes of studying, working and settling. The front door was a pathway that conformed to both NZQA and Immigration NZ requirements, and
constituted a government supported and promoted pathway to residence. Promoting the idea that legitimate, potential migrants are actually deviously rorting the system via a backdoor, is not a healthy or fair approach to ensuring we have effective and safe migrant pathways. Students were especially vulnerable to exploitation in other spheres of their stay in the country, particularly in the labour market. Such exploitation is being addressed by the current government in the Worker Protection Bill which Hon Priyanca Radhakrishnan is shepherding through Parliament and the significant increases in numbers of Labour Inspectors.

Following Covid, the government has taken the opportunity for a reset to our approach to International Education and all in the industry have accepted and supported the need for a review. The ‘new’ approach is to develop a ‘high value’ international education offering. Unfortunately there is no clear definition of what high value means. It can be interpreted in a variety of ways, but the government’s initial strategy is to target degree level students who indicate they are returning to their home country. This is despite the fact that we now have a burgeoning skill
shortage in the areas that were on the earlier skill shortage lists i.e. IT and business skills.

Recent announcements by Australia that they are changing their visa and residency status for New Zealanders will encourage more Kiwis in key skill areas to move to Oz and will put significant additional pressure on these sectors; especially IT. Because of the belief that students were coming in “through the backdoor”, the government has restricted the numbers of students eligible for post-study work rights, a key component of the Study, Work, Settle equation. Unlike our main competitors, Australia and Canada, post-study work rights have been removed for these students. Few will come and recent data has shown that international students are flocking to our competitors. One might have expected that a reset might include a strengthening of the Study, Work and Settle approach – given we are now experiencing skill shortages to such a degree that many businesses are working shorter hours or closing for specific periods.

Recently the Indian External Minister, Dr. Subrahmanyam Jaishankar, criticised New Zealand for not being fair and sympathetic on its immigration policy because Indian students who have partially completed studies in New Zealand are being refused return visas. This comment may have been unfair in itself, given that the reluctance to reinstate visas applies to all international students, not just Indians. The Minister of Foreign Affairs Nanaia Mahuta has ‘said she had noted Mr Jaishankar’s concerns and would be passing them on to the Minister of Immigration Michael Wood.’

So our relationship with India is not as warm as one would hope it to be, especially in the International Education sector. As skill shortages increase, we await Minister Wood’s announcements in February 2023 with some confidence, given he has quickly moved to amend the Green List settings. Hopefully the next reset will address the need to welcome International students to Study, Work and Settle and our relationship with India can start warming.

Paul Chalmers
Board Member – Independent Tertiary Education NZ (ITENZ)
Founder – Africa New Zealand Business Council

16 comments on “India and Free Trade – finally someone turned the lights on ”

  1. Tiger Mountain 1

    Mr Chalmers industry wants bums on seats again, but…the infrastructure is surely not there in terms of housing in particular.

    Director of Universities New Zealand, Chris Whelan admitted in 2021 that the virtual halving of foreign Student numbers then would have a financial impact on various institutions.

    Well perhaps education should be a bloody social service rather than another neo lib for profit “service provider”. The Government does not want to leap into mass student accomodation, and neither does the private sector it seems, so something has to give until this is properly addressed.

  2. RedLogix 2

    Maybe we should be ensuring New Zealanders got a world class education before selling it to others.

    • Proof that our offerings are inferior?

      • Gaynor Chapman 2.1.1

        Hi Patricia,anecdotally I know of students from Asia,who fail to attain entrances to their own universities but come here and achieve honour passes. To some NZ is seen as a soft option.

        However the NZ Initiative have produced a free pdf "The NZ Education Delusion", by Briar Lipson which clearly shows the horrible standards of even high achieving students in our schools, and the rapid decline this century. Students are not going to become better on arrival at tertiary institutions.

        I agree with RedLogix's astute comment above.

  3. Roy Cartland 3

    Went to a kiwibank forum a few years ago; the speaker foresaw a growing Indian population and economy, eclipsing China in importance to us.

    India has a more similar understanding of the rule of law, a broadly English-speaking outlook and the benefits that come with being a democracy.

    Of course, climate change was absent from the talk, so all the norms could be upended… But it's always nice to have an alternative.

    • India also has a caste system where people "are not equal"

      scams are prevalent and scam calls from India a problem.

      So saying we are alike in our understanding of "Rule of Law" is moot . imo

      In trade we need to consider many things… semi slavery, child labour, fair trade etc.

      This is a huge market and could balance China, if we get it right.

      It could send good signals to locals who have Indian connections.

  4. Ad 4

    Get it right Labour.

    India is our likely viable export market alternative to China and we are going need it.

    Plus you have a lot of angry Indian voters here who need a positive signal.

    We need more tertiary qualified Indians here.

    • RedLogix 4.1

      OT but you will be interested by this.

      Foreign Minister Penny Wong will take a historic step in resetting Australia’s relationship with China this week.

      Senator Wong will travel to Beijing for a bilateral meeting with her Chinese counterpart – the first government minister to be invited to do so in three years – to mark 50 years of diplomatic relations.

  5. SPC 5

    Normal trade is via a WTO based framework. But some nations oppose free trade in agriculture – EU and India.

    The EU and USA seek to input access to ownership of domestic assets (utilities) for global corporates in trade (whether WTO or bilateral deals).

    Bilateral deals can also involve the risk of selling out of sovereignty – access to water, investment rights, access to study and access to residency (China and India) (offshore finance for local property purchase).

    There will be those who profit from such arrangements – whether access to their market or profiting from migration.

    As John Key says there will always be money to made by connection to the Chinese market (even if only for those appointed to directorships here). But opening up, as we did our financial markets, led to us being embarrassed as a place to launder money.

  6. Mike the Lefty 6

    During the last National government it was an open secret that there were perhaps dozens of dodgy schools run by Indian nationals in NZ where the education was just a cover and the real intent was to provide an easy path to work and residency. Of course John Key's government turned a blind eye to Indian people being ripped off and lied to because it suited their aims to keep wages lower by importing thousands of foreign workers working at the minimum wage.

    I wonder if we will see the return of this kind of rort. I would hope that Labour has got more principles on this than National had but I wonder if there is a FT deal just what terms and conditions the Indian government will want in this regard.

  7. pat 7

    If we are going to sell residency can we at least make sure it is the public purse that is the recipient?

    Ideally we stop selling residency, but I suspect that is unlikely to occur.

  8. Sanctuary 8

    I would be opposed to any free trade deal that opened us up to yet another round of mass immigration from a developing country. The cultural, economic and social impacts on our country of such mass movements of people no one living here is ever democratically consulted on first – migration and free trade being seen as an entirely business perogative. Personally, I think we should hold referendums on free trade deals with far reaching consequences like the “free movement” of people.

    I am tired of my country and the people in it being treated in an entirely transactional way by businesses keen to exploit third world labour.

  9. KJT 9

    Some people can't wait for the return of the very profitable, “selling residency by pretending to be an education provider, scam”!

    Combined with the equally pernicious supply of cheap labour on student visa’s.

    Time our businesses, including education, weaned themselves off scamming and exploiting people, as a business model.

  10. Stuart Munro 10

    The cynical exploitation of impoverished Indian students by language mills is a stain that will take generations to wash clean. They are no different to the liquor store wage thieves, and should be treated accordingly.

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

  • Government invests further in Central Hawke’s Bay resilience
    The Government has today confirmed $2.5 million to fund a replace and upgrade a stopbank to protect the Waipawa Drinking Water Treatment Plant. “As a result of Cyclone Gabrielle, the original stopbank protecting the Waipawa Drinking Water Treatment Plant was destroyed. The plant was operational within 6 weeks of the ...
    16 hours ago
  • Govt boost for Hawke’s Bay cyclone waste clean-up
    Another $2.1 million to boost capacity to deal with waste left in Cyclone Gabrielle’s wake. Funds for Hastings District Council, Phoenix Contracting and Hog Fuel NZ to increase local waste-processing infrastructure. The Government is beefing up Hawke’s Bay’s Cyclone Gabrielle clean-up capacity with more support dealing with the massive amount ...
    17 hours ago
  • Taupō Supercars revs up with Government support
    The future of Supercars events in New Zealand has been secured with new Government support. The Government is getting engines started through the Major Events Fund, a special fund to support high profile events in New Zealand that provide long-term economic, social and cultural benefits. “The Repco Supercars Championship is ...
    18 hours ago
  • There is no recession in NZ, economy grows nearly 1 percent in June quarter
    The economy has turned a corner with confirmation today New Zealand never was in recession and stronger than expected growth in the June quarter, Finance Minister Grant Robertson said. “The New Zealand economy is doing better than expected,” Grant Robertson said. “It’s continuing to grow, with the latest figures showing ...
    19 hours ago
  • Highest legal protection for New Zealand’s largest freshwater springs
    The Government has accepted the Environment Court’s recommendation to give special legal protection to New Zealand’s largest freshwater springs, Te Waikoropupū Springs (also known as Pupū Springs), Environment Minister David Parker announced today.   “Te Waikoropupū Springs, near Takaka in Golden Bay, have the second clearest water in New Zealand after ...
    21 hours ago
  • More support for victims of migrant exploitation
    Temporary package of funding for accommodation and essential living support for victims of migrant exploitation Exploited migrant workers able to apply for a further Migrant Exploitation Protection Visa (MEPV), giving people more time to find a job Free job search assistance to get people back into work Use of 90-day ...
    2 days ago
  • Strong export boost as NZ economy turns corner
    An export boost is supporting New Zealand’s economy to grow, adding to signs that the economy has turned a corner and is on a stronger footing as we rebuild from Cyclone Gabrielle and lock in the benefits of multiple new trade deals, Finance Minister Grant Robertson says. “The economy is ...
    2 days ago
  • Funding approved for flood resilience work in Te Karaka
    The Government has approved $15 million to raise about 200 homes at risk of future flooding. More than half of this is expected to be spent in the Tairāwhiti settlement of Te Karaka, lifting about 100 homes there. “Te Karaka was badly hit during Cyclone Gabrielle when the Waipāoa River ...
    2 days ago
  • Further business support for cyclone-affected regions
    The Government is helping businesses recover from Cyclone Gabrielle and attract more people back into their regions. “Cyclone Gabrielle has caused considerable damage across North Island regions with impacts continuing to be felt by businesses and communities,” Economic Development Minister Barbara Edmonds said. “Building on our earlier business support, this ...
    2 days ago
  • New maintenance facility at Burnham Military Camp underway
    Defence Minister Andrew Little has turned the first sod to start construction of a new Maintenance Support Facility (MSF) at Burnham Military Camp today. “This new state-of-art facility replaces Second World War-era buildings and will enable our Defence Force to better maintain and repair equipment,” Andrew Little said. “This Government ...
    2 days ago
  • Foreign Minister to attend United Nations General Assembly
    Foreign Minister Nanaia Mahuta will represent New Zealand at the 78th Session of the United Nations General Assembly (UNGA) in New York this week, before visiting Washington DC for further Pacific focussed meetings. Nanaia Mahuta will be in New York from Wednesday 20 September, and will participate in UNGA leaders ...
    3 days ago
  • Midwives’ pay equity offer reached
    Around 1,700 Te Whatu Ora employed midwives and maternity care assistants will soon vote on a proposed pay equity settlement agreed by Te Whatu Ora, the Midwifery Employee Representation and Advisory Service (MERAS) and New Zealand Nurses Association (NZNO), Minister of Health Dr Ayesha Verrall announced today. “Addressing historical pay ...
    7 days ago
  • New Zealand provides support to Morocco
    Aotearoa New Zealand will provide humanitarian support to those affected by last week’s earthquake in Morocco, Foreign Minister Nanaia Mahuta announced today. “We are making a contribution of $1 million to the International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies (IFRC) to help meet humanitarian needs,” Nanaia Mahuta said. ...
    1 week ago
  • Government invests in West Coast’s roading resilience
    The Government is investing over $22 million across 18 projects to improve the resilience of roads in the West Coast that have been affected by recent extreme weather, Prime Minister Chris Hipkins confirmed today.  A dedicated Transport Resilience Fund has been established for early preventative works to protect the state ...
    1 week ago
  • Government invests in Greymouth’s future
    The Government has today confirmed a $2 million grant towards the regeneration of Greymouth’s CBD with construction of a new two-level commercial and public facility. “It will include a visitor facility centred around a new library. Additionally, it will include retail outlets on the ground floor, and both outdoor and ...
    1 week ago
  • Nanaia Mahuta to attend PIF Foreign Ministers’ Meeting
    Foreign Minister Nanaia Mahuta will attend the Pacific Islands Forum (PIF) Foreign Ministers’ Meeting, in Suva, Fiji alongside New Zealand’s regional counterparts. “Aotearoa New Zealand is deeply committed to working with our pacific whanau to strengthen our cooperation, and share ways to combat the challenges facing the Blue Pacific Continent,” ...
    1 week ago
  • PREFU shows no recession, growing economy, more jobs and wages ahead of inflation
    Economy to grow 2.6 percent on average over forecast period Treasury not forecasting a recession Inflation to return to the 1-3 percent target band next year Wages set to grow 4.8 percent a year over forecast period Unemployment to peak below the long-term average Fiscal Rules met - Net debt ...
    1 week ago
  • New cancer centre opens in Christchurch
    Prime Minister Chris Hipkins and Minister of Health Dr Ayesha Verrall proudly opened the Canterbury Cancer Centre in Christchurch today. The new facility is the first of its kind and was built with $6.5 million of funding from the Government’s Infrastructure Reference Group scheme for shovel-ready projects allocated in 2020. ...
    1 week ago
  • Government invests in top of the south’s roading resilience
    $12 million to improve the resilience of roads in the Nelson, Marlborough and Tasman regions Hope Bypass earmarked in draft Government Policy Statement on land transport $127 million invested in the top of the south’s roads since flooding in 2021 and 2022 The Government is investing over $12 million to ...
    2 weeks ago
  • New Zealanders continue to support the revitalisation of te reo as we celebrate Te Wiki o te Reo Mā...
    Ko tēnei te wiki e whakanui ana i tō tātou reo rangatira. Ko te wā tuku reo Māori, e whakanuia tahitia ai te reo ahakoa kei hea ake tēnā me tēnā o tātou, ka tū ā te Rātū te 14 o Mahuru, ā te 12 o ngā hāora i te ahiahi. ...
    2 weeks ago
  • New Wildlife Act to better protect native species
    The 70-year-old Wildlife Act will be replaced with modern, fit-for-purpose legislation to better protect native species and improve biodiversity, Minister of Conservation Willow-Jean Prime has announced.   “New species legislation is urgently needed to address New Zealand’s biodiversity crisis,” Willow-Jean Prime said.   “More than 4,000 of our native species are currently ...
    2 weeks ago
  • Further safety initiatives for Auckland City Centre
    Central and Local Government are today announcing a range of new measures to tackle low-level crime and anti-social behaviour in the Auckland CBD to complement Police scaling up their presence in the area. “Police have an important role to play in preventing and responding to crime, but there is more ...
    2 weeks ago
  • Govt confirms additional support for Enabling Good Lives
    The Government has confirmed $73.7 million over the next four years and a further $40.5m in outyears to continue to transform the disability support system, Minister for Disability Issues Priyanca Radhakrishnan has announced. “The Enabling Good Lives (EGL) approach is a framework which guides positive change for disabled people, ...
    2 weeks ago
  • New Zealand gets AAA credit rating from S&P
    Standard and Poor’s is the latest independent credit rating agency to endorse the Government’s economic management in the face of a deteriorating global economy. S&P affirmed New Zealand’s long term local currency rating at AAA and foreign currency rating at AA+ with a stable outlook. It follows Fitch affirming New ...
    2 weeks ago
  • Appointment of Environment Court Judge
    Christchurch barrister Kelvin Reid has been appointed as a Judge of the Environment Court and the District Court, Attorney-General David Parker announced today. Mr Reid has extensive experience in Resource Management Act issues, including water quality throughout the South Island. He was appointed to the Technical Advisory Group advising the ...
    2 weeks ago
  • NZ’s biggest ever emissions reduction project hits milestone
    New Zealand is on track to have greener steel as soon as 2026 with New Zealand Steel’s electric arc furnace project reaching a major milestone today.   The Government announced a conditional partnership with New Zealand Steel in May to deliver the country’s largest emissions reduction project to date. Half of ...
    2 weeks ago
  • Poroporoaki: Paki Leslie Māngai Nikora
    Pokia ana te tihi Taiarahia e Hine-Pūkohu-rangi Hotu kau ana te manawa! Horahia ana te whārua o Ruātoki e te kapua pouri Tikaro rawahia ko te whatumanawa! Rere whakamuri kau ana te awa o Hinemataroa Ki te kawe i te rongo ki te mātāpuna i nga pōngaihu Maungapōhatu, tuohu ...
    2 weeks ago
  • 50,000 charges laid in crack down on gangs
    Police Minister Ginny Andersen has today congratulated Police in their efforts to crack down on gangs, after laying 50,000 charges against gang members and their associates through the hugely successful Operation Cobalt. As at 31 August, Police have: Laid 50,396 criminal charges against gang members and their associates Issued 64,524 ...
    2 weeks ago
  • Farmers and cyclone-affected properties supported with tax rule changes
    The Government has confirmed details of the tax changes to the bright-line test for cyclone-damaged properties, with the release of the required legislative amendments. Revenue Minister Barbara Edmonds has released a Supplementary Order Paper (SOP) to be considered by the Finance and Expenditure Committee in the next Parliament, as it ...
    2 weeks ago
  • New Zealand wins CPTPP dispute against Canada
    Minister for Trade and Export Growth Damien O’Connor has welcomed the CPTPP Panel’s ruling in favour of New Zealand in our dispute against Canada, a significant win for our primary sector exporters. The Panel found that Canada’s dairy quota administration is inconsistent with its obligations under the Comprehensive and Progressive ...
    2 weeks ago
  • New intensive turnaround programme launched to break the cycle of offending
     The next phase of the Government’s response to youth crime is underway, with an intensive programme for the country’s most prolific young offenders launched today in Auckland, Minister for Children Kelvin Davis said. The programme, announced by Prime Minister Chris Hipkins in July, will see up to 60 recidivist young ...
    2 weeks ago
  • Government extends report date for COVID inquiry
    The Government has agreed to a request from the Royal Commission of Inquiry into COVID-19 for extra three months to deliver its final report. The Royal Commission was established in 2022 to strengthen New Zealand’s preparedness for any future pandemics. It was originally due to conclude mid-2024. “The Commission has ...
    2 weeks ago
  • Wainuiomata school property upgrade making great progress
    The Wainuiomata High School redevelopment is making great progress, with two more classroom blocks set to be complete by the end of the month, Prime Minister Chris Hipkins announced today. The Prime Minister visited today to see first-hand the progress of the redevelopment which is continuing at pace and is ...
    2 weeks ago
  • Language week focuses on sustaining Lea Faka-Tonga
    New Zealand’s Tongan community are coming together to promote language sustainability this week, as Uike Lea Faka-Tonga – Tongan Language Week begins.  “For our Pacific communities, language is more than just a means of communication. It’s an important way to link generations and maintain connections to our ancestral roots,” Barbara ...
    3 weeks ago

Page generated in The Standard by Wordpress at 2023-09-21T18:52:01+00:00