National use opening of Christchurch Justice Precinct for political purposes

Written By: - Date published: 7:43 am, September 13th, 2017 - 21 comments
Categories: bill english, election 2017, national, Politics, same old national, spin, the praiseworthy and the pitiful - Tags: ,

In the insanity that is this current election campaign the media has missed a rather large story, Bill English breaching the Cabinet Manual’s requirement that the resources of the State not be used for political purposes.  Yesterday there was a grand opening of Christchurch’s Justice Precinct.

And it was done a month before the Christchurch Justice Precinct, a rather large project was ready to be opened.  Clearly rules and understandings to not apply to National.

From Stuff:

Christchurch’s justice and emergency services precinct has officially opened – but the project is not yet complete.

As Prime Minister Bill English and Justice and Courts Minister Amy Adams opened the $300 million yet-to-be finished precinct on Tuam St, construction workers huddled out of sight.

The Ministry of Justice was expected to start operating from the building about mid-October. Agencies would start fitting out their offices after a public open day on Sunday, Adams said.

The area, which has been repeatedly delayed, will house the ministry, police, Department of Corrections, Fire and Emergency New Zealand, St John and Civil Defence.

Stuff reporter at the opening said the part of the building where the launch was held looked finished, but 100 metres down the path the parking building and some of the emergency services building was incomplete.

See the problem?  National is getting political brownie points for the opening of a building that we all paid for.  Business as usual is somehow virtuous.

And the pointy head constitutionalists have thought about this.  The Cabinet Manual says this:

6.9 In the period immediately before a general election, the government is not bound by the caretaker convention unless the election has resulted from the government losing the confidence of the House (see paragraphs 6.21 – 6.40 for information about the caretaker convention). Successive governments, however, have chosen to restrict their actions to some extent during this time, in recognition of the fact that an election, and therefore potentially a change of government, is imminent.

6.11 In practice, restraints have tended to be applied from about three months before the general election is due or from the announcement of the election (if the period between the
announcement of the election and polling day is less than three months).

6.15 The State Services Commission publishes guidance on the pre-election period for those agencies in the state services that are subject to the Commissioner’s mandate. The guidance is available on the State Services Commission website, and sets out good practice that may also be useful for other agencies in the state sector. For guidance on the pre-election period, the State Services Commission is available to provide advice on the obligations of agencies and their employees, and the Secretary of the Cabinet is available to provide advice on decision-making.

And this is from the SSC guidance on treatment of the pre election period:

Programme launches and events

Key points

  • Agencies should continue to support Ministers with ‘business as usual’ initiatives during an election period.
  • Particular care is needed around ceremonial events to avoid perceptions of being associated with any political aspects of such events.

There is no blanket restriction on Ministers wishing to launch programmes or initiatives in the lead up to the election. In general, the business of government should continue and State servants should support Ministers with ‘business as usual’ initiatives. However, the nature and timing of high profile ceremonial events (e.g. building openings or award ceremonies) must be carefully considered.

During an election period, there is a risk that public launches and events may take on a ‘party political’ character that would not be evident at other times. This is particularly so when Ministers and/or MPs are involved in the event. In general, State servants should support Ministers as usual, but must be vigilant in avoiding association with any political aspects of such events. Particular care must also be taken with the preparation of supporting material. All agency material must remain strictly impartial and factual to avoid any perceptions of being associated with any party political messages (see ‘advertising campaigns’ directly below).

National know about this rule.  They did their best to open the Waterview Tunnel on June 18, just outside the three month election period.  So what happened?  Why did the Public Service agree to a highly politicised event two weeks from the election?

And we are talking about a $300 million precinct in the middle of a marginal seat.  It seems there was too much for National to refuse.  And so finished or not finished a publicity event had to occur at our expense.


21 comments on “National use opening of Christchurch Justice Precinct for political purposes”

  1. Nick 1

    They are gifted at deceit.

  2. Don't worry. Be happy 2

    It will be ok. They will forget they did it soon…..

  3. cleangreen 3

    Dirty subjugated politics is well and alive, so we hope the MSM is happy they have subjected our Democracy now since they have not even battered an eyelid.

    ‘Carry on nothing to see here.’

    Nothing has changed.

    Vote national out!

  4. Pat 4

    did anyone expect any different?…..however National have frequently misjudged the mood in ChCh (although this will be playing to a wider audience) and is unlikely to move any voter intentions….a non event, albeit one that highlights their lack of ethics.

  5. Just imagine the howls of outrage we’d hear from National if Labour had done this.

  6. alwyn 6

    I find it difficult to see, in the quotes you provided that show anything that English shouldn’t have done.

    Your quotes seem to be aimed at any Public Servants involved rather than any politicians.
    “In general, State servants should support Ministers as usual, but must be vigilant in avoiding association with any political aspects of such events. Particular care must also be taken with the preparation of supporting material. All agency material must remain strictly impartial and factual to avoid any perceptions of being associated with any party political messages “.

    This is all for the guidance of Public Servants, not the Politicians.

    • TootingPopularFront 6.1

      Are you suggesting MPs are not public servants? I believe we taxpayers pay their salaries, expenses, accommodation supplements (although some have to pay those back due to breaking the law)…

      • In Vino 6.1.1

        Exactly. I clearly remember that in 1970 (my first year of work) Sir Leslie Munroe stood before us, and as an MP proclaimed how proud he was to be a public servant. He was trying to belittle our protests at the poor working conditions his Govt was imposing on us public servants. Get it right, Alwyn.

        • alwyn

          I’m afraid you seem equally confused then Vino.
          When you write something like ” his Govt was imposing on us public servants” you are clearly NOT regarding him as a public servant. The term “public servant” is clearly only intended for “us” not him.
          What is the word these days? It used to be “Civil Servants” but not many are “Civil” and they don’t “Serve” us very well.

          • In Vino

            He was imposing the term, not I, and it embraced us all. He definitely said public, not civil. I was young, and took a while to see him as the puffed up hypocrite that he was. You appear to be of his ilk.

  7. NZJester 7

    National is all about illusion.
    It’s a lot like his visits to those pack houses full of staff. Only there was no one there but the management as the season was not underway yet and there were no real workers there for him to address.

  8. It won’t worry their Mate Peter Hughes who is the State Services Commissioner…. Why else do you think they might have appointed him to the job… Old boys club going well LOL

  9. mpledger 9

    I was kinda surprised when I heard it was “opening” and then the police said they weren’t moving in till next Feb. A strange kind of opening.

    I was also kinda surprised it was all in one pricinct. What if there is another earthquake and this is the site of most damage – everything will get wiped out.

    • Jimmy 9.1

      It is a highly resilient building with backup generators, potable water storage, fire supply storage, wastewater holding tanks, base isolation etc. It can go off-grid when all else fails around it.

  10. tc 10

    Radio off limits this election is it ? Points for consistency in disregarding electoral guidelines, if nothing national are predictable.

  11. Wayne 11

    Shock, horror, the election is mentioned during an election campaign.

    • Stuart Munro 11.1

      it’s quite understandable Wayne – we know you Gnats are scurrilous and absolutely desperate. As any party that treats its citizens this badly in a democracy is wont to be.

      Principles are for other people eh.

  12. Tanz 12

    Who cares. They arn’t trying to write certain electoral rorts into law.

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

  • Have your say: Country of Origin Food Labelling
    People want and deserve to know where their food comes from. That is the intention behind my member’s bill (originally Steffan Browning’s) the Consumers’ Right to Know (Country of Origin of Food) Bill which has re-opened for submissions. There is ...
    GreensBy Gareth Hughes
    4 days ago
  • Government announces the panel to recruit new Human Rights Commissioners
    Justice Minister Andrew Little today announced the process for the appointment of a new Chief Human Rights Commissioner, Race Relations Commissioner and Equal Employment Opportunities Commissioner. ...
    1 week ago
  • Police initiatives across Auckland
    Two new policing initiatives are being launched in Auckland with the objective of preventing crime, improving community safety, and reducing reoffending. Police Minister Stuart Nash will today launch an iwi community justice panel, Te Pae Oranga, at Hoani Waititi Marae ...
    1 week ago
  • Māui dolphins deserve better
    Like many of us, I feel a deep connection to our oceans. The rich marine life that surrounds our shores is what makes our place in the world so special and why we’re so passionate about protecting it. There are ...
    GreensBy Eugenie Sage
    2 weeks ago
  • Fixing our broken justice system: first steps
    Justice Minister Andrew Little has revealed the first steps in fixing our broken criminal justice system, so we can make communities safer. ...
    2 weeks ago
  • Guide to making a submission on the Election Access Fund Bill
    Our democracy should be accessible for everyone. One of the fundamental things about civil society is that it’s supposed to be by the people, for the people. Currently, it’s harder than it should be for some people to take part. ...
    GreensBy Chlöe Swarbrick
    2 weeks ago
  • Ngati Tamaoho Treaty settlement third reading
    Minister for Treaty of Waitangi Negotiations Andrew Little acknowledges and welcomes the rangatira of Ngāti Tamaoho who came to Parliament for the significant third reading of their Treaty settlement legislation. ...
    3 weeks ago
  • Unacceptable culture and conduct
    Justice Minister Andrew Little and Under-Secretary Jan Logie have received the independent review into allegations of sexual misconduct, harassment and bullying at leading law firm Russell McVeagh. ...
    3 weeks ago
  • Eighty new Police recruits begin training
    Police recruitment is taking another significant step forward with the arrival of eighty new recruits who begin training today at the Royal New Zealand Police College. Police Minister Stuart Nash has extended a welcome to the recruits of Wing 319 ...
    3 weeks ago