Civl unions and the legal recognition of de-facto relationships.
Stayed out of the ‘Coalition of the willing’
Resisted the calls for tax cuts that were based purely on the existence of temporary surpluses. had those calls been heeded the economy wouldn’t have weathered the current storms half as well.
Civil unions were a cop out from the decidedly socially conservative Labour party – they were too afraid to go for gay marriage. The ideal though should be to get the state out of the marriage business altogether. An argument for replacing marriage with civil unions is worthy though.
But what about the cynical lack of marriage or even civil unions for multiples? What about gay adoption? Abortion on demand?
Labour achieved very little in nine years on social issues. Prostitution legalisation was one of the only major gains from the otherwise deeply conservative Labour party. Look at what happened to BZP and NOS thanks to Labour’s partner Anderton.
What about the erosion of our civil liberites and Labour’s sickening law and order auction?
I can’t look back nine whole years of Labour and say that there was much positive progress.
I agree with all of that. But I don’t make the perfect the enemy of the good. Progress is progress q, it is not an end state but a journey etc.
These might sound to you like apologies for failure, or prettified conservatism or what have you, but to me it’s about the best one can expect barring revolution. Leaders must lead, but they only do so effectively when they go at a pace the people are willing to follow at. That makes progress more durable.
I want progress not revolution, but I just don’t see it from Labour. It’s just absurd to say that that’s the best we can expect.
On many issues Labour actually took us backwards – drug prohibition, law and order, civil liberties, immigration.
I’m ashamed to have ever voted for Labour.
Ministry of Justice – Labour increased prison sentences, toughened up bail laws and parole. They for me were steps backwards. Here is some stuff on immigration at NRT Immigration Act Review index On civil liberties there’s such like the anti-terrorism laws, draconian laws against boy racers various new police powers, etc.
Any increase in state power is a step backwards in my eyes.
I have had a comment on our previous Prime Minister stalled waiting for moderation since 11 am. I wonder why?
This was it –
Helen Clark was good but should not be canonised and criticism of her performance is as relevant as for other politicians. Don’t be paranoid, the Nats nicknamed her Helengrad which was unfair and unreasonable but leader worship should not get in the way of reasonable analysis.
Why should the above trigger moderation – are there some terrible key words?
[lprent: I’ve been offline for a few days. Not sure – I’ve have a look at it. ]
That’s nice dear. A few more days of non-committal vague posturing and veiled insults and I’m sure you’ll have drummed up enough interest for the big launch. Yawn.
It’s the Open Mike section, I gather you can say pretty much whatever you want (subject to the whims of the moderators), so go wild.
Care to explain why you think all of the achievements listed to be bad?
I’m pretty happy with all of items listed as positives, even though most of them don’t affect me directly. And I acknowledge QtR’s points that Labour (a) did some bad stuff and (b) could have gone further – I look forward to them going further at their next opportunity.
I would add
Interest free student loans
Increased RUCs
Legalised prostitution
Cheaper doctor’s visits, and
a lot of the updated Local Government Act and Building Act were a step forward, too.
Meanwhile National have us in reverse with the clutch up, accelerator pushed hard down and someone with no vision holding the steering wheel. I can’t wait for the election next year.
I prefer to discuss topics one at a time for clarity. Oh well… lets see what happens.
Why I consider the achievements to be bad…
Minimum wage – Government interference in contracts.
4 weeks holiday – Government interference in contracts.
Working for Families – Generosity with other people’s money.
Kiwisaver – Not the Governments business.
Cullen Fund – Not the Governments business.
Civil unions – Not the Governments business (i.e. giving moral sanctions). I could support QTR’s idea “to get the state out of the marriage business”.
Defacto relationships – Government interference in contracts.
Prostitution legalisation – Decriminalisation of prostitution is not bad in itself but it is bad while there are anti-discrimination laws. It amounts to a government moral sanction.
Interest free student loans – Generosity with other people’s money.
Cheaper doctors visits – Generosity with other people’s money and Government interference in contracts.
Minimum wage – there is always a minimum wage. Without legislation it just defaults to zero. There’s a word for minimum wage = zero, slavery, and there are reasons why it is illegal.
4 weeks holiday – Well it’s government interference whether it is three weeks or four. Got anything to argue about three weeks versus four?
Working for Families Generosity with other people’s money. More like returning money to people that paid tax. Y’know, like Ragnar Danneskjold did with Hank Reardon, just before he told us how bad Robin Hood was. I expect you will find that most people who receive WFF are net taxpayers, and those that aren’t have creative accountants.
Kiwisaver and Cullen Fund Not the Governments business. Much better to be left to one of those wonderful private investment funds, eh?
Civil unions and Defacto relationships I could support QTR’s suggestion about keeping the government out of the marriage business too, but let’s not equivocate. Before the legislation came in the government interfered more than it does under the current legislation. Is your argument that because the government didn’t go all the way, the steps they took was worse than doing nothing? I disagree.
Prostitution legalisation It amounts to a government moral sanction. Whereas previously the government made a moral judgement that it was wrong to offer to have sex for money. Now it has stopped enforcing that judgement. What is wrong with that?
Interest free student loans Generosity with other people’s money. It’s peanuts compared to the subsidy paid in terms of the course fees. Would you prefer a society where, to obtain a tertiary education, one had to pay the full cost? Why stop there, though, why don’t you object to children earning their primary and secondary education by paying for it themselves? It is just another type of intergenerational equity transfer.
Cheaper doctors visits Universal and affordable healthcare is one of the bases of a civilised society. I don’t give a shit that you think it is interfering in contracts and generosity with other people’s money – it is better than the alternative.
BTW I am not affected directly by any of these things, I’m not on the minimum wage, being self employed I take as much or as little leave as I want, I don’t benefit from WFF (I haven’t even checked my eligibilty), I don’t use the Cullen Fund or Kiwisaver, I’m not in a civil union or defacto relationship, I don’t know any prostitutes or anyone who acknowledges having used a prostitute, I don’t have a student loan (because I paid mine back years ago, before they were interest free) and I don’t benefit from the changes around healthcare.
Best of luck with your blog. Be sure to post a link.
The thing that is so striking is the belief that the government has no place interfering with agreements between individuals which would lead me to believe we are dealing with a “free marketeer” here. Would have thought they would have learnt their lesson after the failure of their goals in the past few years? Or was that all brought about because there was too much government interference in Wall Sts profiteering? 😛
Minimum wage there is always a minimum wage. Without legislation it just defaults to zero. There’s a word for minimum wage = zero, slavery, and there are reasons why it is illegal.
There are no minimum wage laws in countires like Sweden and Denmark. The UK didn’t have any minimum wage laws until 1999 and I don’t think they had slavery then. I just do not think there is actually a strong argument either way on the minimum wage that is for the negative economic consequences (inflation, unemployment, etc) or the positive effects of it. A greater influence on wages comes from a lack of unionisation and unemplyment reducing workers bargaining power. It’s interesting to look back at some of the writings of socialists and communists in the US opposed to the introduction of minimum wage laws. Their thinking was that employers would stick to the floor with wages – and that may well be the case.
My personal opinion is that it should in time be removed, but we need reforms to free the market first. Here is a different view: On crutches and crowbars: toward a labor radical case against the minimum wage
Zorr – Maybe you should look into the role of central bank policies and fractional reserve banking in creating credit driven bubbles before jumping on the anti-free market bandwagon.
Cheers QTR, I always enjoy reading your perspective even though I don’t always agree with it. This time I reckon a minimum wage is necessary, though if an effective non-legislative mechanism is used that’s fine by me. Happy New Year.
Self admitted Frankenstein’s monster honoured under Nats
For services to lock-outs
Arise, Arise, sir monster
Like Dr Frankenstein’s monster which was assembled from various body parts, Infratil founder Lloyd Morrison says he is made up of various parts: part, Right wing capitalist, part socialist, and with an egalitarian heart.
Like the fabled monster which also had a soft heart but which struggled with its other components, Morrison was obviously out of control when he locked out the low paid bus-workers in an unprovoked rampage last year.
“…tbh there are a lot of dubious people being given the ONZ this year and a lot of them are Business Roundtablers funny that…”
As Idiot/Savant points out “ACT – they demanded a position on the Honours and Appointments Committee as part of their Confidence and Supply Agreement…” So it’s pretty clear ACT is ensuring those that bankroll get to be called ‘sir” (but not by me).
A brace of linkies from Eric Martin at Obsidian Wings:
Please to be ignoring the neocon tubthumping re: Iran and the current situation there. As he says, sepak softly and don’t buy anyone a stick. Active foreign support for revolutionaries when the regime’s propaganda is about painting the revolutionaries as foreign puppets; trends toward fail.
If we define winning in Afghanistan as having a govt seen as legitimate by her people, and that doesn’t co operate with AQ, then that government might not be the sort of thing we like. The chances of getting a govt we like however are near to nil, so if that is the goal we shouldn’t be there in any case.
American civil liberties were gutted last week, and the media failed to take note of it.
The development? If the president or one of his subordinates declares someone to be an “enemy combatant’ (the 21st century version of “enemy of the state’) he is denied any protection of the law. So any trouble-maker (which means anyone) can be whisked away, incarcerated, tortured, “disappeared,’ you name it.
A colleague in the US sent me through the news on this when I was moaning about a petty issue we have back here in NZ – I still find it hard to believe that the US would openly continue down this path…. very depressing.
That DTB is a drip ……. looking back through the comments on this blog I don’t think one could dispute that, same old tired capitalist = bad crap ad nauseam.
Earlier this week the Fire Service said more than 25 percent of all fire calls in the past financial year were false alarms and cost taxpayers up to $25 million.
The Auckland Firefighters Union told NewstalkZB the figures released by the Fire Service were paving the way to reduce the response to central city buildings with fire protection systems.
President Jeff McCulloch said the only additional cost for attending a fire was the diesel used by the fire trucks.
He said fire fighters were being paid regardless of what they were doing.
More than 20,000 Contact Energy customers in North Canterbury will face price rises next month.
The company said it was passing on costs it had incurred from MainPower, along with higher internal costs associated with operating and building power stations.
Christchurch-based energy analyst John Noble said Contact should have absorbed the increase from MainPower, given Contact’s profit last year.
Raising prices because of internal cost increases was “rubbish” and made a mockery of Energy Minister Gerry Brownlee’s plan to get power companies to reduce prices.
Contact made an operating profit of $445.3 million last financial year and is forecasting a profit of $485m this year.
From .” Ministry of Justice” the first 3 words sum it up and there’s no need to read any further. …” I can’t think….” – Just another right wing dullard.
Quoth the Raven similar… ” I can’t see…”, ” I can’t look back…” ” I just don’t see..”
Rodel – Speaking of dullards why don’t you expand on your argument a little more because I just can’t see your point. Or how about this why don’t you actually respond to Ministry of Justice or respond to my points. Or you can just continue to leave snarky substanceless comments on other’s style of prose.
Jenny, Thanks for your regards but here (now in Athens) I have met no-one who speaks conversational English. If I ask anyone for help they always kindly give it and in English but i have not heard anyone, and there are hoards of tourists, discussing anything in English. I must accept that here at least English speaking is very unimportant. Actually global warming might be of interest as the mid winter here so far has been daily 18-20 degrees C so you can’t argue with the weather but the climate might be a different story. Cheers.
Armchair Critic –
Minimum wage… There’s a word for minimum wage = zero, slavery, and there are reasons why it is illegal.
When I was at the Fair Trade shop they had a “help wanted” sign up so I asked if the wages were fair, the lady told me that there was no pay. I laughed and told that didn’t sound very fair and she told me that only the boss gets paid.
So I say that not only is a zero wage legal it’s even compatible with “Fair Trade”.
Because there’s no objective difference between “volunteering one’s free time to a cause one finds worthy” and “being forced to take work at zero or near-zero remuneration in the hopes of future income because there is no protection for workers and the “free market” doesn’t give a hoot if you starve to death”.
I’ll keep in mind that you don’t know the difference between being a volunteer and being a slave when I reed this blog of yours.
I get that you don’t think there should be a minimum wage. The original point was that Labour under Clark raised the minimum wage and tis was one of the good achievements of the Clark governments. Do you just think this was not a good achievement because you believe the “minimum wage = bad” mantra, or have you thought about it further? Got any arguments that show that the actual increases the minimum wage caused more harm than good?
There is nothing within Labour (Or any others) that quantifies the value of a livable wage (H1 would not answer this when I posed it to her) then how min wage, soc welfare benefits and other assistance eg WFF dove tails into this base level. I have had this idea that a livable wage is higher than what any envisage. How can we have the likes of Kiwsaver when I believe many are excluded from this indirectly as they cannot afford to contribute, yet they are contributing to subsidise the cost of running this as any tax payer does. Lab should IMO have made Kiwisaver compo with a min fixed $ value being contributed by the govt (Read tax payer) to all tax payers (Beneficiaries pay tax as I believe).
Perhaps a large number receiving WFF are well above this livable wage and we are paying welfare to those that do not require assistance.
There is nothing within Labour (Or any others) that quantifies the value of a livable wage…
This is something that’s been bugging me for the last couple of years. What is the minimum cost of living? And, yes, I believe it’s far higher than what many, especially those in government and business, are willing to admit.
WfF is an admission, of sorts, that wages aren’t high enough to cover living.
I think you would get no one disagreeing with you on that. Yet there are a few points, what is a livable wage, can NZ “afford” this. And how can we progress to a stage whereby those on min wage can more than just survive, and when I use min wage I refer to the tax, WFF,etc allow the individual/family to approach this livable wage level. Until there is some effort into calc this wage and “we” accept that this is calc is appropiate otherwise we are just shooting in the dark with no real target we are attempting to achieve.
WFF is I believe an acknowledgment that the simple tax system of set percentages for all on PAYE and with GST has unfair consequences on people with extra costs and responsibilities that society needs to be concerned with ie parents, carers etc.
So the people who most need a tax system that recognises their importance as parents and the costs involved, receive some of their tax back – then having the odium thrown at them that they are receiving handouts. They shouldn’t be charged so much in the first place – the amount of tax charged is a large cause of financial difficulty for families.
“I simply think it is wrong for the Government to interfere in contracts.”
No offense intended, but when I see simple and pure principles like this put forward, where they so plainly contradict how liberal western democratic governments have acted, I’m always left in a bit of a bind.
I want to assume that there are some obvious qualifications to the asserted principle that are being left unsaid. What those qualifications are, is precisely where the real debate is hiding.
There are many such broad principles one can put forward, that most people agree with up to a point. Where that point is the debate, so an absolute stating of the generally held principle doesn’t tell me where about your ‘point’ is . So I’m left in the position of not really knowing what your position is. Which considering that you clearly disagree with me, leaves me unable to respond.
The most obvious unstated qualification to the above principle:
“I simply think it is wrong for the Government to interfere in contracts.”
is one that would prohibit contract killings and assaults, slavery, child prostitution etc. (But how much would you put in to the etc?)
So assuming your principle means something like:
I simply think it is wrong for the Government to interfere in contracts between consenting adults, where such a contract wouldn’t breach whatever basic human rights legislation the nation has in place.
Assuming this allows a government to counter Murder Inc type activities, it still leaves an enormous amount of things that are currently proscribed, for long established reasons, fair game.
What, other than labour laws, does your principle condemn? Anti-cartel and anti-monopoly laws? Legislative consumer guarantees? Securities legislation (insider trading etc)? The Companies Act? Environmental laws? Town planning? Public Works? OSH?
What are the qualifications, if any, to your principle here?
Armchair critic asked if I had any “arguments that show that the actual increases [to] the minimum wage caused more harm than good” to which I responded “I simply think it is wrong for the Government to interfere in contracts”.
Let me clarify… if it is unjust for the Government to interfere in contracts then it is unjust irrespective of the consequences (i.e. even if it causes more good than harm).
If you think there are exceptions to the principle as applied to the minimum wage situation then you should say what they are.
Consider the following statements…
1. Legislation that prevents people from being employed at a low wage is a good thing.
2. Legislation that prevents people from being employed to perform sex acts is a good thing.
Either both statements are true, or both are false, or there is some principled difference between “being employed to perform sex acts” and “being employed at a low wage”.
If you agree with 1 and disagree with 2 can you identify why?
I think that principles should promote good over harm. If there are applications of a general principle that would cause more harm than good, I think we should make an exception to it.
As you seem to be saying that you do not hold any exceptions to your principle, can I take it that you think Murder Inc is ok, and that monopolies and cartels should be allowed, and that all those other things I listed in my second to last para should also be done away with?
All of these things are breaches of your principle. That’s fine, but it is an incredibly fringe position.
“If you agree with 1 and disagree with 2 can you identify why?”
Because 2. relates to the nature of the task undertaken, whereas 1. relates to payment for the task undertaken, i.e. they are fundamentally different issues and relate to different principles.
“I simply think it is wrong for the Government to interfere in contracts”
As a general principle, yes.
In the instance of a minimum wage, and in the absence of an effective non-legislative mechanism, I think the government is obliged to act. Because, in general, people who accept offers of minimum wage jobs are under a sort of economic duress, in that they have no other practical alternative than to accept the offer. Unless, of course, you believe that going/staying on the benefit is a practical alternative. But based on your previous comments, I expect you believe that going on the benefit couldn’t be a practical alternative.
Setting a minimum wage is one way of obviating the economic duress, to some extent. Raising the minimum wage reduces the degree of economic duress.
For the record – I know it doesn’t meet the legal definition of economic duress.
There are fools on both sides of the ‘class war’ …. the unions and workers endlessly demanding more money for less endeavour and the employers trying to get more work for less money. The intelligent person on both sides, and there are a few around, knows that both sides must be happy for the joint enterprise to be successful in the long term. So they talk to each other and reach a mutually satisfactory compromise..
But it’s not a ‘joint exercise’ is it jcuknz? It’s a relationship predicated on exploitation. A joint exercise would entail an end to the vertical divisions of labour wouldn’t it? Do you think there are any bosses intelligent enough to use their position of power to similtaneously empower the workers beneath them and delegitimise their own position in order that ‘joint exercises’ can be brought about smoothly and without friction?
New cyber-monitoring measures have been quietly introduced giving police and Security Intelligence Service officers the power to monitor all aspects of someone’s online life.
The measures are the largest expansion of police and SIS surveillance capabilities for decades, and mean that all mobile calls and texts, email, internet surfing and online shopping, chatting and social networking can be monitored anywhere in New Zealand.
In preparation, technicians have been installing specialist spying devices and software inside all telephone exchanges, internet companies and even fibre-optic data networks between cities and towns, providing police and spy agencies with the capability to monitor almost all communications.
Looks like the debate has been lost and the authoritarians won.
It seems that in spite of ‘everything’ inspirational people persist.
“…Hedy Epstein, the 85-year-old Holocaust survivor, who initiated a hunger strike in Cairo for the opening of the borders of Gaza to the outside world.”
The expensive fireworks set off merely to register a change of date and year should be saved to honour such great acts of kindness and humanity. That she is a holocaust survivor and 85 and really little at 4’10” makes her a towering beacon of hope to a disillusioned world. And maybe she will bring much needed relief to the ghetto of the Palestinians.
Very sad about new security surveillance having so few checks and balances. When it comes to the USA the National Party seem to fall down like a stack of cards. All our politicians have the English disease, the common language that is jokingly supposed to divide us, but we understand threats in it very well.
Im afraid a mininum wage is a must until a better way is found to stop employer exploitation of workers . What is badly needed is a control on the higher wage bracket.. Some of the wages /packages and bonus’ paid to some of these high profilers are insulting to the average working person.. Its the wealth gap that is the top priority not this stupid obsession on the wage difference between and and Australia/ .
Minimum wage Government interference in contracts.
Prostitution legalisation Decriminalisation of prostitution is not bad in itself but it is bad while there are anti-discrimination laws. It amounts to a government moral sanction”
Can you see the massive contradiction between these points? Are you really concerned with such principals, or are they just just convenient liberal-ish arguments you use to justify your pre-existing baseless prejudice to avoid confronting that such prejudice has no place in law?
We are the Awaleq
Born of bitterness
We are the nails that go into the rock
We are the sparks of hell
He who defies us will be burned
And if that’s not enough…throw in Somalis aiding any fight … “Yemen has said it will not tolerate foreign fighters on its soil, following a pledge by Somalia’s al-Shabab group that it would send fighters to help an al-Qaeda affiliate in the country.”
and then oh, what the hell, lets throw a curve ball at Iran….and whatd’youknow?
I am sure that Bush lead the American people the wrong way after 9/11 and although appeasement did nothing for the world in 1938 there must be something intelligent people can do to rein in America’s foolishness. All power to Hedy Epstein, not that I think it will do any good for the Palestinian problem … might is wrong. Which way do we take the Yemen statement? Which foreign soldiers are bad and who are good? Somali or Anglo/American?
Excuse me if I sound depressed and don’t wish everybody a happy new year at the beginning of the last year of the decennial from hell. I sound depressed because I am.
When the story of the underpants hijacker began to emerge I predicted X-ray scanning machines ate every airport within three months. It turned out that most countries western countries decided to install them within three days of the failed attempt to blow up an airplane over Detroit.
Now only that, Mr. “Change” Obama immediately swore to find the people who helped a disturbed Nigerian son of a rich banker to smuggle a lump of explosives hidden under his genitals onto a plane.
It turns out that we were wrong about Osama bin Laden and that the real spiritual leader from the 9/11 hijackers down to the sorry young man from Nigeria was someone who goes by the name of Anwar al Awlaki and surprise surprise lives in Yemen. Well we know what happened with Afghanistan when we, apparently mistaken, thought that a Saudi hiding in a cave over there was the spiritual leader of the 911 hijackers.
Anybody else out there saying, “Oh puleese, enough with the scaremongering and propaganda already.”
It turns out you see that while the MSM has already spoon fed us the story of the crazed religious nut who wanted to be pure and in order to do so tried to blow up a plane that some of the people who were on the plane have conflicting and disturbing accounts of what really transpired on the flight and once again we should have an open and independent investigation into what happened instead of once again using it to invade another oil rich, strategic important country but it is my humble opinion that this will not happen and that the sheeple will allow themselves to be let to slaughter by the worlds elites.
The UK and US embassies have been closed already. Will John Key follow his masters as he did when they walked out of Ahmadinajad’s speech at the UN?
If the news that our cyber boys are now allowed more and more snooping into our privacy sneaked into law is anything to go by I don’t hold much hope.
I’m sure New Zealanders will get X-rayed soon at our airports.
Anti spam: DISAPPEAR. Who knows, that might be next.
May the force be with everyone who tries to fight for freedom and justice in the years to come.
Tests by scientists in the team at Qinetiq (….), showed the millimetre-wave scanners picked up shrapnel and heavy wax and metal, but plastic, chemicals and liquids were missed.
Solution.
“…We must now start to ask if national security demands the use of profiling.”
I’d have thought the obvious solution to all this fear of aeroplanes being blown up is to simply ground the whole damned lot of them.
Permanently.
Peak oil…CO2 emissions… the parlous financial state of a number of airlines. Add the fact that jobs are needed (unless we advocate a jobless ‘recovery’) and all that public transport infrastructure that will be required to replace air transport…
But that’s not all!
Consider the benefits of a slower paced life….no flying up and down the country to meetings and conferences of questionable worth…have a three day paid work/life balance travel holiday instead!
But wait. There’s more!
Never again will you need fear the underpants of the gentleman next to you.
And all for one lump sum of meaningful stimulus package!
BLiP …. the link doesn’t work for me but rather than grounding the planes a simpler solution, or at least an alternative, is for every passenger to strip. I remember when the restrictions/ inspections first started one woman vowed she would be happy to if it meant a safe flight.
This re run of a Kung fu monkey post from some years back pretty much sums it up for me.
Read the whole thing, but here’s the gist
I am just not going to wet my pants every time some guys get arrested in a terror plot. I will do my best to stay informed. I will support the necessary law enforcement agencies. I will take whatever reasonable precautions seem, um, reasonable. But I will not be terrorized. I assume that the terror-ists would like me to be terror-ized, as that is what is says on their nametag, rather than, say, wanting me to surrender to ennui or negative body image, and they’re just coming the long way around.
Osama Bin Laden got everything on his Christmas list after 9/11 — US out of Saudi Arabia; the greatest military in the world over-extended, pinned down and distracted; the greatest proponent of democracy suddenly alienated from its allies; a US culture verily eager to destroy freedoms that little scumfuck could never even dream to touch himself — I would like to deny him the last little check on the clipboard, i.e. constant terror. I panic, they win. To coin a phrase, Osama Bin Laden can suck my insouciance.
If fourth gen warriors can get us to implement millions of dollars of costs and cause millions of hours of delays and have every traveler reminded of their cause every time someone goes to an airport; that’s a pretty fckn good return from having one recruit captured.
There is a strangely panicky wee piece in The Independent about a proposal to ‘parade along the high street (Wootton Bassett in England ) with empty coffins symbolising the ( Afghanistan) conflict’s Muslim victims.’
Wootton Basett it seems is the town where the coffins of dead soldiers are driven in hearses through streets lined with onlookers. (An RAF base is nearby)
As expected the Press Association piece slams the organisers of the proposed parade branding them as Muslim extremists (they may be). Brown and Cameron condemn the idea. Civic leaders oppose the idea, and so on.
Anyway. To get the other side of the story I googled the organisers and…. surprise, surprise error 403 on every page directly related to them.
Assuming this is not a coincidence ( I don’t understand the reasons behind error messages.)
Of course, the msm will be reporting on this block…this denial of freedom of expression and democracy as they do when it is initiated by China or Iran. Right?
The day the government starts trying to separate peaceful protests as being ‘good’ or ‘bad’ or ‘extremist’ or ‘terrorists’ by distinguishing on their backgrounds and motivations is the day I take up arms.
With historical perspective, the ‘extremists’ are frequently where everyone else is in 100 years. Think of such things as woman being able to vote.
Umm are you a complete numpty – comparing this jerks behaviour with giving women the vote is laughable especially as he’d likely seek to remove that right from them.
Have a look at the tosspots Wiki profile he is clearly a complete cunt.
You mean that as a negative connotation don’t you?
This mean you as sexist as you are racist?
Just digging, just ’cause you’re walking right on in and asking for it…don’t bother responding. Just reflect and remember Hone and his motherfucker comment and your condemnation….or, oops!…did you miss the sexism and focus on the non-existent racism? You go figure you.
Meanwhile, I notice you offer no response to my comment below. Suprised? No I’m not.
Um what … are you drunk, illiterate or just retarded ?
Feel free to continue to side step the reality that this cunt (slang = a contemptible person) is a cunt (slang = a contemptible person) and is undoubtedly a sexist and racist to boot…. and I can’t be fucked responding to you bullshit below.
And calling my comment racist and sexist ……. perhaps a frontal lobotomy might improve your comprehension.
In my opinion, you’d have probably said exactly the same thing in the late 19th about the suffragettes. Or unions. Or CO’s. Or anyone else who had an opinion you objected to.
However that isn’t the point. Democracies run by having open public dissent. Trying to suppress it just leads to having nasty internal conflicts. If they step over the legitimate legal line which is assaults or property damage, then society acts appropriately. However in this case that seems unlikely – it isn’t exactly a covert action. The counter-protests are where you’re most likely to see the violence and property damage coming from.
Or are you trying to say that these people you’re disparaging for exercising their peaceful rights (and taking a reasonable amount of risk to do so) should instead go and make bombs to kill UK civilians because you’d be less offended (and it would probably fit your prejudices better)? It must be hard being such a sensitive soul about a symbolic protest…
Incidentally, have you figured out what they’re protesting about yet? It sounds like a valid point to me bearing in mind that the UK has troops in Iraq and Afghanistan – who are inevitably killing the civilian bystanders as well as their targets. Civil insurrections are an armies worst duty.
Are you completely fucked in the head Lynn – I am not saying these turds don’t have a right to protest……. I was pointing out in response to Bill (aka Jerkwad cockhole) that the protesters were indeed extremists, which then had the two of you rushing in to defend those same extremists and portraying them as upstanding citizens.
I think these pieces of smega in the UK have as much right to protest as that bottom belch Minto and his friends in Auckland – as long as they don’t disturb the peace or break the law let them do what they want.
Fuck with friends like you two the vast bulk of muslims in the UK don’t need enemies……. or perhaps you agree with Anjem that the British soldiers are murderers, rapists and baby killers and that sharia law should be installed in the UK, the pope should be killed, that the terrorist attacks in the USA and UK are OK etc etc…yep I sure that’s just the message that the vast rump of british muslims want out there and associated with their religion.
Oh dear. When I said ‘take the biscuit’, I wasn’t expecting you to take the whole sugar coated packet!
I was also unaware of your apparent diabetes.
I guess the invective comes on down in line with the sugar levels?
Anyway. Extremism and upstanding citizenry really are quite subjective labels and are entirely beside the point in this instance.
The message is a valid one. The messenger is irrelevant. But in an attempt to invalidate the message, AP maligned the messenger. The message gets affected by this. The subtext becomes something along the lines of ‘ If you think this thought, or propagate this thought, you are really no better than Islam 4UK ( ‘official’ designation) scum. And that is what any utterance of such thoughts will be associated with in the ( manipulated) public mind and also who any person, who utters such opinions, will be associated with in the (manipulated) public mind.’
The thought then becomes ‘inexpressible’ and a very pernicious form of censorship moves on to quash the next valid expression that governments or others would rather did not gain currency.
gitmo: Your orginonal comment gave me the distinct impression that you thought they shouldn’t be able to protest because it was offensive. In much the same way that I found DPF and CJS’s disgusting billboards in 2007 extremely offensive over the EFA.
I’m not a ‘friend’ of any extremist from any angle, religious, political, ecological etc. I am also not a friend of anyone who does more than protest about peaceful protests. My comment was something like that removing the ability to protest in a democratic society was when I’d start looking for arms – it means that full blown repression of all groups isn’t too far behind.
Linking to the telegraph as a definitive source for anything is a tad suspect. But anyway. So they hold what appear to us as extreme religious views. So what? So does the pope.
The question surely ought to be whether the proposed parade is expressing a legitimate concern. I’d have thought that bringing the public’s attention to the numbers of civilian deaths in Afghanistan was legitimate.
I’d also have thought it a sad day when a legitimate message is so easily and casually killed off by the self same media who should be reporting that very message themselves.
Anyway.
His open letter as printed in the telegraph is linked below. When the religious clap trap is put aside, the political argument and analysis that is left is more coherent than the official version of the why’s and wherefore’s of Afghanistan. So, can we call the official version extreme, insofar as it appears so removed from any intelligent interpretation of reality, or is that label reserved for official enemies only.
Hope everybody is enjoying the NZ summer that here in Wellington has decided to arrive in full force, ableit belatedly. Splendid.
I stopped to read a few blogs, the one that really hit home was Trotters latest in Bowalley. Regardless of how you rate Trotter his contextual powers of observation are worth taking note of.
The premise of the latest is that the same bludgers who created the mess we are currently in last year were bailed out by us, the public…and now we are expected to not only pay for their mess but to allow them to carry on blithely repeating the same nonsense at our expense.
Methinks he is onto it, welcome to a new year and the same old story.
In 1962, as part of the Model Penal Code, the institute created the modern framework for the death penalty, one the Supreme Court largely adopted when it reinstituted capital punishment in Gregg v. Georgia in 1976. Several justices cited the standards the institute had developed as a model to be emulated by the states.
has given up:
Instead, the institute voted in October to disavow the structure it had created “in light of the current intractable institutional and structural obstacles to ensuring a minimally adequate system for administering capital punishment.
Legal prof points out that:
“The death penalty was an abstract issue of little interest to me or my fellow students,’ Professor Gross said. But he remembered being impressed by the institute’s work, saying, “I thought in passing that smarter people than I had done a sensible job of figuring out this tricky problem.’
Things will look different come September, Professor Gross said.
“Law students who take first-year criminal law from 2010 on,’ he said, “will learn that this same group of smart lawyers and judges — the ones whose work they read every day — has said that the death penalty in the United States is a moral and practical failure.’
If people cannot change their minds in light of fresh evidence then it is a sad state of affairs and shows a serious lack of intelligence to criticise them for doing so.
The earth ‘was’ flat, the sun went around the earth ……….
I wasn’t actually criticisng them per se jc. It’s a major and welcome sea change, one that’s well overdue. The evidence has been there for a while. Any criticism implied was about that delay. Perhaps the US might start moving to a legal framework more in line with the liberal western values they claim to represent on the world stage.
To not criticise the US on it’s failings in these areas is to not stick up for those values. That’s ok if you don’t hold them I suppose.
NYT today “Two Indian tribes successfully argued that a wind-power project would impede their ritual greeting of the sunrise” What I tried to say is a spam word on this siteso wwhat can I say to express my disgust and amazement?
Again NYT “Yemeni officials said two militants were killed in a firefight as France, Germany and Japan joined the U.S. and Britain in closing their embassies. ” I’m reminded of a song from my WWII childhood ” Run Rabbit Run, Run Run RUN”
Then it continued ‘get the Hun on the run’ today AQ seem to be rather effective …. sadly.
This is a difficult blog to read –
With 100+ comments I have to skim read the whole thread to find the few new posts since I last read it.
Other blog software allows me to subscribe to a thread (and receive new comments by email) or have new posts highlighted. Is there some way of achieving that functionality here?
The Prime Minister says he's really comfortable with us not knowing the reoffending rate for his boot camp programme.They asked him for it at yesterday’s press conference, and he said, nah, not telling, have to respect people's privacy.Okay I'll bite. Let's say they release this information to us:The rate of ...
Warning 1: There is a Nazi theme at the end of this article related to the disabled community. Warning 2: This article could be boring!One day, last year, I excitedly opened up a Substack post that was about how to fight back, and the answer at the end was disappointing ...
This may be rhetorical but here goes: did any of you invest in the $Libra memecoin endorsed and backed by Argentine president and darling of the global Right Javier Milei (who admitted to being paid a fee for his promotion of the token)? You know, the one that soared above ...
Last week various of the great and good of New Zealand economics and public policy trooped off to Hamilton (of all places) for the annual Waikato Economics Forum, one of the successful marketing drives of university’s Vice-Chancellor. My interest was in the speeches delivered by the Minister of Finance and ...
The Prime Minister says the Government would be open to sending peacekeepers to Ukraine if a ceasefire was reached. The government has announced a $30 million spend on tourism infrastructure and biodiversity projects, including $11m spent to improve popular visitor sites and further $19m towards biodiversity efforts. A New Zealand-born ...
This is a re-post from The Climate Brink by Andrew Dessler “But what about when the sun doesn't shine?!” Ah yes, the energy debate’s equivalent of “The Earth is flat!” Every time someone mentions solar or wind power, some self-proclaimed energy expert emerges from the woodwork to drop this supposedly devastating truth bomb: ...
This post by Nicolas Reid was originally published on Linked in. It is republished here with permission.In this article I look into data on how well the rail network serve New Zealanders, and how many people might be able to travel by train… if we ran more than a ...
Hi,Before we get into Hayden Donnell’s new column about how yes, Donald Trump is definitely the Antichrist, I wanted to touch on something feral that happened in New Zealand last week.Members of Destiny Church pushed and punched their way into an Auckland library, apparently angry it was part of Pride ...
Despite delays, logjams and overcrowding in our emergency departments, funding constraints are limiting the numbers of nurses and doctors being trained. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāLong stories short, the top six things in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty on Tuesday, February 18 are:A NZ Herald investigation ...
Now that the US has ripped up the Atlantic alliance, Europe is more vulnerable now than at any time since the mid-1930s. Apparently, Europe and Ukraine itself will not have a seat at the table in the talks between US President Donald Trump and Russian leader Vladimir Putin that will ...
Olivia and Noah and Hana are going to the library!It is fun to go to the library. It has books and songs and mat time and people who smile at you and say, Hello Olivia, what have you been doing this morning?The library is more fun than the mall. At ...
New World Orders: The challenge facing Christopher Luxon and Chris Hipkins is how to keep their small and vulnerable nation safe and stable in a world whose economic and political climate the forty-seventh American president is changing so profoundly.IT IS, SURELY, the ultimate Millennial revenge fantasy. Calling senior Baby-Boomer and Gen-X ...
“This might surprise you, Laurie, but I reckon Trump’s putting on a bloody impressive performance.”“GOODNESS ME, HANNAH, just look at all those Valentine’s Day cards!”“Occupational hazard, Laurie, the more beer I serve, the more my customers declare their undying love!”“Crikey! I had no idea business was so good.” Laurie squinted ...
In 2005, Labour repealed the long-standing principle of birthright citizenship in Aotearoa. Why? As with everything else Labour does, it all came down to austerity: "foreign mothers" were supposedly "coming to this country to give birth", and this was "put[ting] pressure on hospitals". Then-Immigration Minister George Hawkins explicitly gave this ...
And I just hope that you can forgive usBut everything must goAnd if you need an explanation, nationThen everything must goSongwriters: James Dean Bradfield / Sean Anthony Moore / Nicholas Allen Jones.Today, I’d like to talk about a couple of things that happened over the weekend:Brian Tamaki’s Library Invasion and ...
New reporting highlights how Brooke van Velden refuses to meet with the CTU but is happy to meet with fringe Australian-based unions. Van Velden is pursuing reckless changes to undermine the personal grievance system against the advice of her own officials. Engineering New Zealand are saying that hundreds of engineers ...
The NZCTU strongly supports the Employment Relations (Employee Remuneration Disclosure) Amendment Bill. This Bill represents a positive step towards addressing serious issues around unlawful disparities in pay by protecting workers’ rights to discuss their pay and conditions. This Bill also provides welcome support for helping tackle the prevalent gender and ...
Years of hard work finally paid off last week as the country’s biggest and most important transport project, the City Rail Link reached a major milestone with the first test train making its way slowly though the tunnels for the first time. This is a fantastic achievement and it is ...
Engineers are pleading for the Government to free up funds to restart stalled projects. File Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāLong stories short, the top six things in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty on Monday, February 17 are:Engineering New Zealand CEO Richard Templer said yesterday hundreds of ...
It’s one of New Zealand’s great sustaining myths: the spirit of ANZAC, our mates across the ditch, the spirit of Earl’s Court, Antipodeans united against the world. It is also a myth; it is not reality. That much was clear from a series of speakers, including a former Australian Prime ...
Many people have been unsatisfied for years that things have not improved for them, some as individuals, many more however because their families are clearly putting in more work, for less money – and certainly far less purchase on society. This general discontent has grown exponentially since the GFC. ...
A listing of 34 news and opinion articles we found interesting and shared on social media during the past week: Sun, February 9, 2025 thru Sat, February 15, 2025. This week's roundup is again published soleley by category. We are still interested in feedback to hone the categorization, so if ...
The Salvation Army’s State of the Nation report shows worsening food poverty and housing shortages mean more than 400,000 people now need welfare support, the highest level since the 1990s. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāLong stories short, the top six things in our political economy around housing, climate and ...
You're just too too obscure for meOh you don't really get through to meAnd there's no need for you to talk that wayIs there any less pessimistic things to say?Songwriters: Graeme DownesToday, I thought we’d take a look at some of the most cringe-inducing moments from last week, but don’t ...
Please note: I’ve delayed my “What can we do?” article for this video.The video above shows Destiny Church members assaulting staff and librarians as they pushed through to a room of terrified parents and young children.It was posted to social media last night.But if you read Sinead Boucher’s Stuff, you ...
Skeptical Science is partnering with Gigafact to produce fact briefs — bite-sized fact checks of trending claims. You can submit claims you think need checking via the tipline. Is sea level rise exaggerated? Sea levels are rising at an accelerating rate, not stagnating or decreasing. Warming global temperatures cause land ice ...
Here is a scenario, but first a historical parallel. Hitler and the Nazis could well have accomplished everything that they wanted to do within German borders, including exterminating Jews, so long as they confined their ambitious to Germany itself. After all, the world pretty much sat and watched as the ...
I’ve spent the last couple of days in Hamilton covering Waikato University’s annual NZ Economics Forum, where (arguably) three of the most influential people in our political economy right now laid out their thinking in major speeches about the size and role of Government, their views on for spending, tax ...
Simeon Brown’s Ideology BentSimeon Brown once told Kiwis he tries to represent his deep sense of faith by interacting “with integrity”.“It’s important that there’s Christians in Parliament…and from my perspective, it’s great to be a Christian in Parliament and to bring that perspective to [laws, conversations and policies].”And with ...
Severe geological and financial earthquakes are inevitable. We just don’t know how soon and how they will play out. Are we putting the right effort into preparing for them?Every decade or so the international economy has a major financial crisis. We cannot predict exactly when or exactly how it will ...
Questions1. How did Old Mate Grabaseat describe his soon-to-be-Deputy-PM’s letter to police advocating for Philip Polkinghorne?a.Ill-advisedb.A perfect letterc.A letter that will live in infamyd.He had me at hello2. What did Seymour say in response?a.What’s ill-advised is commenting when you don’t know all the facts and ...
NZCTU Te Kauae Kaimahi President Richard Wagstaff has called on OJI Fibre Solutions to work with the government, unions, and the community before closing the Kinleith Paper Mill. “OJI has today announced 230 job losses in what will be a devastating blow for the community. OJI needs to work with ...
NZCTU Te Kauae Kaimahi President Richard Wagstaff is sounding the alarm about the latest attack on workers from Minister of Workplace Relations and Safety Brooke van Velden, who is ignoring her own officials to pursue reckless changes that would completely undermine the personal grievance system. “Brooke van Velden’s changes will ...
Hi,When I started writing Webworm in 2020, I wrote a lot about the conspiracy theories that were suddenly invading our Twitter timelines and Facebook feeds. Four years ago a reader, John, left this feedback under one of my essays:It’s a never ending labyrinth of lunacy which, as you have pointed ...
And if you said this life ain't good enoughI would give my world to lift you upI could change my life to better suit your moodBecause you're so smoothAnd it's just like the ocean under the moonOh, it's the same as the emotion that I get from youYou got the ...
Aotearoa remains the minority’s birthright, New Zealand the majority’s possession. WAITANGI DAY commentary see-saws manically between the warmly positive and the coldly negative. Many New Zealanders consider this a good thing. They point to the unexamined patriotism of July Fourth and Bastille Day celebrations, and applaud the fact that the ...
The podcast above of the weekly ‘Hoon’ webinar for paying subscribers on Thursday night features co-hosts & talking about the week’s news with regular and special guests, including: and on the week in geopolitics, including the latest from Donald Trump’s administration over Gaza and Ukraine; on the ...
Up until now, the prevailing coalition view of public servants was that there were simply too many of them. But yesterday the new Public Service Commissioner, handpicked by the Luxon Government, said it was not so much numbers but what they did and the value they produced that mattered. Sir ...
In a moment we explore the question: What is Andrew Bayly wanting to tell ACC, and will it involve enjoying a small wine tasting and then telling someone to fuck off? But first, for context, a broader one: What do we look for in a government?Imagine for a moment, you ...
As expected, Donald Trump just threw Ukraine under the bus, demanding that it accept Russia's illegal theft of land, while ruling out any future membership of NATO. Its a colossal betrayal, which effectively legitimises Russia's invasion, while laying the groundwork for the next one. But Trump is apparently fine with ...
A ballot for a single member's bill was held today, and the following bill was drawn: Employment Relations (Collective Agreements in Triangular Relationships) Amendment Bill (Adrian Rurawhe) The bill would extend union rights to employees in triangular relationships, where they are (nominally) employed by one party, but ...
This is a guest post by George Weeks, reviewing a book called ‘How to Fly a Horse’ by Kevin AshtonBook review: ‘How to Fly a Horse’ by Kevin Ashton (2015) – and what it means for Auckland. The title of this article might unnerve any Greater Auckland ...
This story was originally published by Capital & Main and is part of Covering Climate Now, a global journalism collaboration strengthening coverage of the climate story. Within just a week, the sheer devastation of the Los Angeles wildfires has pushed to the fore fundamental questions about the impact of the climate crisis that have been ...
In this world, it's just usYou know it's not the same as it wasSongwriters: Harry Edward Styles / Thomas Edward Percy Hull / Tyler Sam JohnsonYesterday, I received a lovely message from Caty, a reader of Nick’s Kōrero, that got me thinking. So I thought I’d share it with you, ...
In past times a person was considered “unserious” or “not a serious” person if they failed to grasp, behave and speak according to the solemnity of the context in which they were located. For example a serious person does not audibly pass gas at Church, or yell “gun” at a ...
Long stories short, the top six things in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty on Thursday, February 13 are:The coalition Government’s early 2024 ‘fiscal emergency’ freeze on funding, planning and building houses, schools, local roads and hospitals helped extend and deepen the economic and jobs recession through calendar ...
For obvious reasons, people feel uneasy when the right to be a citizen is sold off to wealthy foreigners. Even selling the right to residency seems a bit dubious, when so many migrants who are not millionaires get turned away or are made to jump through innumerable hoops – simply ...
A new season of White Lotus is nearly upon us: more murder mystery, more sumptuous surroundings, more rich people behaving badly.Once more we get to identify with the experience of the pampered tourist or perhaps the poorly paid help; there's something in White Lotus for all New Zealanders.And unlike the ...
In 2016, Aotearoa shockingly plunged to fourth place in the Transparency International Corruption Perceptions Index. Nine years later, and we're back there again: New Zealand has seen a further slip in its global ranking in the latest Corruption Perceptions Index (CPI). [...] In the latest CPI New Zealand's score ...
1. You’ve started ranking your politicians on how much they respect the rule of law2. You’ve stopped paying attention to those news publications3. You’ve developed a sudden interest in a particular period of history4. More and more people are sounding like your racist, conspiracist uncle.5. Someone just pulled a Nazi ...
Transforming New Zealand: Brian EastonBrian Easton will discuss the above topic at 2/57 Willis Street, Wellington at 5:30pm on Tuesday 26 February at 2/57 Willis Street, WellingtonThe sub-title to the above is "Why is the Left failing?" Brian Easton's analysis is based on his view that while the ...
Salvation Army’s State of the Nation 2025 report highlights falling living standards, the highest unemployment rates since the 1990s and half of all Pacific children going without food. There are reports of hundreds if not thousands of people are applying for the same jobs in the wake of last year’s ...
Mountain Tui is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.Correction: On the article The Condundrum of David Seymour, Luke Malpass conducted joint reviews with Bryce Wilkinson, the architect of the Regulatory Standards Bill - not Bryce Edwards. The article ...
Tomorrow the council’s Transport, Resilience and Infrastructure Committee meet and agenda has a few interesting papers. Council’s Letter of Expectation to Auckland Transport Every year the council provide a Letter of Expectation to Auckland Transport which is part of the process for informing AT of the council’s priorities and ...
All around in my home townThey're trying to track me down, yeahThey say they want to bring me in guiltyFor the killing of a deputyFor the life of a deputySongwriter: Robert Nesta Marley.Support Nick’s Kōrero today with a 20% discount on a paid subscription to receive all my newsletters directly ...
Hi,I think all of us have probably experienced the power of music — that strange, transformative thing that gets under our skin and helps us experience this whole life thing with some kind of sanity.Listening and experiencing music has always been such a huge part of my life, and has ...
Business frustration over the stalled economy is growing, and only 34% of voters are confidentNicola Willis can deliver. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāLong stories short, the top six things in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty on Wednesday, February 12 are:Business frustration is growing about a ...
I have now lived long enough to see a cabinet minister go both barrels on their Prime Minister and not get sacked.It used to be that the PM would have a drawer full of resignations signed by ministers on the day of their appointment, ready for such an occasion. But ...
This session will feature Simon McCallum, Senior Lecturer in Engineering and Computer Science (VUW) and recent Labour Party candidate in the Southland Electorate talking about some of the issues around AI and how this should inform Labour Party policy. Simon is an excellent speaker with a comprehensive command of AI ...
The proposed Waimate garbage incinerator is dead: The company behind a highly-controversial proposal to build a waste-to-energy plant in the Waimate District no longer has the land. [...] However, SIRRL director Paul Taylor said the sales and purchase agreement to purchase land from Murphy Farms, near Glenavy, lapsed at ...
The US Foreign Corrupt Practices Act has been a vital tool in combatting international corruption. It forbids US companies and citizens from bribing foreign public officials anywhere in the world. And its actually enforced: some of the world's biggest companies - Siemens, Hewlett Packard, and Bristol Myers Squibb - have ...
December 2024 photo - with UK Tory Boris Johnson (Source: Facebook)Those PollsFor hours, political poll results have resounded across political hallways and commentary.According to the 1News Verizon poll, 50% of the country believe we are heading in the “wrong direction”, while 39% believe we are “on the right track”.The left ...
A Tai Rāwhiti mill that ran for 30 years before it was shut down in late 2023 is set to re-open in the coming months, which will eventually see nearly 300 new jobs in the region. A new report from Massey University shows that pensioners are struggling with rising costs. ...
As support continues to fall, Luxon also now faces his biggest internal ructions within the coalition since the election, with David Seymour reacting badly to being criticised by the PM. File photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāLong stories short, the top six things in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate ...
Not since 1988 when Richard Prebble openly criticised David Lange have we seen such a challenge to a Prime Minister as that of David Seymour to Christopher Luxon last night. Prebble suggested Lange had mental health issues during a TV interview and was almost immediately fired. Seymour hasn’t gone quite ...
Three weeks in, and the 24/7 news cycle is not helping anyone feel calm and informed about the second Trump presidency. One day, the US is threatening 25% trade tariffs on its friends and neighbours. The reasons offered by the White House are absurd, such as stopping fentanyl coming in ...
This video includes personal musings and conclusions of the creator climate scientist Dr. Adam Levy. It is presented to our readers as an informed perspective. Please see video description for references (if any). Wherever you look, you'll hear headlines claiming we've passed 1.5 degrees of global warming. And while 2024 saw ...
“The ACT Party can’t be bothered putting an MP on one of the Justice subcommittees hearing submissions on their own Treaty Principles Bill,” Labour Justice Spokesperson Duncan Webb said. ...
The Government’s newly announced funding for biodiversity and tourism of $30-million over three years is a small fraction of what is required for conservation in this country. ...
The Government's sudden cancellation of the tertiary education funding increase is a reckless move that risks widespread job losses and service reductions across New Zealand's universities. ...
National’s cuts to disability support funding and freezing of new residential placements has resulted in significant mental health decline for intellectually disabled people. ...
The hundreds of jobs lost needlessly as a result of the Kinleith Mill paper production closure will have a devastating impact on the Tokoroa community - something that could have easily been avoided. ...
Today Te Pāti Māori MP for Te Tai Tokerau, Mariameno Kapa-Kingi, released her members bill that will see the return of tamariki and mokopuna Māori from state care back to te iwi Māori. This bill will establish an independent authority that asserts and protects the rights promised in He Whakaputanga ...
The Whangarei District Council being forced to fluoridate their local water supply is facing a despotic Soviet-era disgrace. This is not a matter of being pro-fluoride or anti-fluoride. It is a matter of what New Zealanders see and value as democracy in our country. Individual democratically elected Councillors are not ...
Nicola Willis’ latest supermarket announcement is painfully weak with no new ideas, no real plan, and no relief for Kiwis struggling with rising grocery costs. ...
Half of Pacific children sometimes going without food is just one of many heartbreaking lowlights in the Salvation Army’s annual State of the Nation report. ...
The Salvation Army’s State of the Nation report is a bleak indictment on the failure of Government to take steps to end poverty, with those on benefits, including their children, hit hardest. ...
New Zealand First has today introduced a Member’s Bill which would restore decision-making power to local communities regarding the fluoridation of drinking water. The ‘Fluoridation (Referendum) Legislation Bill’ seeks to repeal the Health (Fluoridation of Drinking Water) Amendment Act 2021 that granted centralised authority to the Direct General of Health ...
New Zealand First has introduced a Member’s Bill aimed at preventing banks from refusing their services to businesses because of the current “Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) Framework”. “This Bill ensures fairness and prevents ESG standards from perpetuating woke ideology in the banking sector being driven by unelected, globalist, climate ...
Erica Stanford has reached peak shortsightedness if today’s announcement is anything to go by, picking apart immigration settings piece by piece to the detriment of the New Zealand economy. ...
Our originating document, theTreaty of Waitangi, was signed on February 6, 1840. An agreement between Māori and the British Crown. Initially inked by Ngā Puhi in Waitangi, further signatures were added as it travelled south. The intention was to establish a colony with the cession of sovereignty to the Crown, ...
Te Whatu Ora Chief Executive Margie Apa leaving her job four months early is another symptom of this government’s failure to deliver healthcare for New Zealanders. ...
The Green Party is calling for the Prime Minister to show leadership and be unequivocal about Aotearoa New Zealand’s opposition to a proposal by the US President to remove Palestinians from Gaza. ...
The latest unemployment figures reveal that job losses are hitting Māori and Pacific people especially hard, with Māori unemployment reaching a staggering 9.7% for the December 2024 quarter and Pasifika unemployment reaching 10.5%. ...
Waitangi 2025: Waitangi Day must be community and not politically driven - Shane Jones Our originating document, theTreaty of Waitangi, was signed on February 6, 1840. An agreement between Māori and the British Crown. Initially inked by Ngā Puhi in Waitangi, further signatures were added as it travelled south. ...
Despite being confronted every day with people in genuine need being stopped from accessing emergency housing – National still won’t commit to building more public houses. ...
The Green Party says the Government is giving up on growing the country’s public housing stock, despite overwhelming evidence that we need more affordable houses to solve the housing crisis. ...
Before any thoughts of the New Year and what lies ahead could even be contemplated, New Zealand reeled with the tragedy of Senior Sergeant Lyn Fleming losing her life. For over 38 years she had faithfully served as a front-line Police officer. Working alongside her was Senior Sergeant Adam Ramsay ...
Green Party co-leader Marama Davidson will return to politics at Waitangi on Monday the 3rd of February where she will hold a stand up with fellow co-leader Chlöe Swarbrick. ...
Te Pāti Māori is appalled by the government's blatant mishandling of the school lunch programme. David Seymour’s ‘cost-saving’ measures have left tamariki across Aotearoa with unidentifiable meals, causing distress and outrage among parents and communities alike. “What’s the difference between providing inedible food, and providing no food at all?” Said ...
The Government is doubling down on outdated and volatile fossil fuels, showing how shortsighted and destructive their policies are for working New Zealanders. ...
Green Party MP Steve Abel this morning joined Coromandel locals in Waihi to condemn new mining plans announced by Shane Jones in the pit of the town’s Australian-owned Gold mine. ...
The Green Party is calling on the Government to strengthen its just-announced 2030-2035 Nationally Determined Contribution (NDC) under the Paris Agreement and address its woeful lack of commitment to climate security. ...
The Government’s commitment to get New Zealand’s roads back on track is delivering strong results, with around 98 per cent of potholes on state highways repaired within 24 hours of identification every month since targets were introduced, Transport Minister Chris Bishop says. “Increasing productivity to help rebuild our economy is ...
The former Cadbury factory will be the site of the Inpatient Building for the new Dunedin Hospital and Health Minister Simeon Brown says actions have been taken to get the cost overruns under control. “Today I am giving the people of Dunedin certainty that we will build the new Dunedin ...
From today, Plunket in Whāngarei will be offering childhood immunisations – the first of up to 27 sites nationwide, Health Minister Simeon Brown says. The investment of $1 million into the pilot, announced in October 2024, was made possible due to the Government’s record $16.68 billion investment in health. It ...
New Zealand’s strong commitment to the rights of disabled people has continued with the response to an important United Nations report, Disability Issues Minister Louise Upston has announced. Of the 63 concluding observations of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (UNCRPD), 47 will be progressed ...
Resources Minister Shane Jones has launched New Zealand’s national Minerals Strategy and Critical Minerals List, documents that lay a strategic and enduring path for the mineral sector, with the aim of doubling exports to $3 billion by 2035. Mr Jones released the documents, which present the Coalition Government’s transformative vision ...
Firstly I want to thank OceanaGold for hosting our event today. Your operation at Waihi is impressive. I want to acknowledge local MP Scott Simpson, local government dignitaries, community stakeholders and all of you who have gathered here today. It’s a privilege to welcome you to the launch of the ...
Racing Minister, Winston Peters has announced the Government is preparing public consultation on GST policy proposals which would make the New Zealand racing industry more competitive. “The racing industry makes an important economic contribution. New Zealand thoroughbreds are in demand overseas as racehorses and for breeding. The domestic thoroughbred industry ...
Business confidence remains very high and shows the economy is on track to improve, Economic Growth Minister Nicola Willis says. “The latest ANZ Business Outlook survey, released yesterday, shows business confidence and expected own activity are ‘still both very high’.” The survey reports business confidence fell eight points to +54 ...
Enabling works have begun this week on an expanded radiology unit at Hawke’s Bay Fallen Soldiers’ Memorial Hospital which will double CT scanning capacity in Hawke’s Bay to ensure more locals can benefit from access to timely, quality healthcare, Health Minister Simeon Brown says. This investment of $29.3m in the ...
The Government has today announced New Zealand’s second international climate target under the Paris Agreement, Climate Change Minister Simon Watts says. New Zealand will reduce emissions by 51 to 55 per cent compared to 2005 levels, by 2035. “We have worked hard to set a target that is both ambitious ...
Nine years of negotiations between the Crown and iwi of Taranaki have concluded following Te Pire Whakatupua mō Te Kāhui Tupua/the Taranaki Maunga Collective Redress Bill passing its third reading in Parliament today, Treaty Negotiations Minister Paul Goldsmith says. “This Bill addresses the historical grievances endured by the eight iwi ...
As schools start back for 2025, there will be a relentless focus on teaching the basics brilliantly so all Kiwi kids grow up with the knowledge, skills and competencies needed to grow the New Zealand of the future, Education Minister Erica Stanford says. “A world-leading education system is a key ...
Housing Minister Chris Bishop and Associate Agriculture Minister Mark Patterson have welcomed Kāinga Ora’s decision to re-open its tender for carpets to allow wool carpet suppliers to bid. “In 2024 Kāinga Ora issued requests for tender (RFTs) seeking bids from suppliers to carpet their properties,” Mr Bishop says. “As part ...
Associate Education Minister David Seymour has today visited Otahuhu College where the new school lunch programme has served up healthy lunches to students in the first days of the school year. “As schools open in 2025, the programme will deliver nutritious meals to around 242,000 students, every school day. On ...
Minister for Children Karen Chhour has intervened in Oranga Tamariki’s review of social service provider contracts to ensure Barnardos can continue to deliver its 0800 What’s Up hotline. “When I found out about the potential impact to this service, I asked Oranga Tamariki for an explanation. Based on the information ...
A bill to make revenue collection on imported and exported goods fairer and more effective had its first reading in Parliament, Customs Minister Casey Costello said today. “The Customs (Levies and Other Matters) Amendment Bill modernises the way in which Customs can recover the costs of services that are needed ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By John Blaxland, Professor, Strategic and Defence Studies Centre, Australian National University Last week in Europe, the United States sent some very strong messages it is prepared to upend the established global order. US Vice President JD Vance warned a stunned Munich ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra The Reserve Bank has delivered the expected modest rate cut of a quarter of a percentage point, and we’re set for the predictable frenzy of speculation about an April election. The cut is unlikely to ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By John Hawkins, Senior Lecturer, Canberra School of Politics, Economics and Society, University of Canberra The Reserve Bank cut official interest rates on Tuesday, the first decrease in four years, saying inflationary pressures are easing “a little more quickly than expected”. However, the ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra The Reserve Bank has delivered the expected modest rate cut of a quarter of a percentage point, and we’re set for the predictable frenzy of speculation about an April election. The cut is unlikely to ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Allan Fels, Professor Allan Fels, Professor of Law, Economics and Business at the University of Melbourne and Monash University., The University of Melbourne Australia is creeping towards adding a divestiture power to its Competition and Consumer Act. Under such a law, ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Arjen Vaartjes, PhD Student, Quantum Physics, UNSW Sydney Dmitriy Rybin / Shutterstock What makes something quantum? This question has kept a small but dedicated fraction of the world’s population – most of them quantum physicists – up at night for decades. ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Mary Anne Kenny, Associate Professor, School of Law, Murdoch University Australia’s minister for home affairs announced on Sunday that the federal government has struck a deal with Nauru to “resettle” three non-citizens from what’s come to be known as the “NZYQ cohort”. ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Matt Fitzpatrick, Professor in International History, Flinders University (From left to right): Neville Chamberlain, Édouard Daladier, Adolf Hitler, Benito Mussolini, and Italian Foreign Minister Galeazzo Ciano before signing the Munich Agreement, which gave the Sudetenland to Germany.German Federal Archives/Wikimedia Commons Ukraine ...
The purpose was to establish the facts and provide an independent assessment of government agency activity in relation to allegations that personal data may have been misused during the 2023 General Election. ...
Privacy Commissioner Michael Webster said he is carefully reviewing the referrals raised in the two reports. That work will be done in the context the Privacy Act and the need to ensure individuals’ rights to privacy is protected and respected. ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Bhavna Middha, ARC DECRA Senior Research Fellow, Centre for Urban Research, RMIT University The average Australian household size has decreased from 4.5 people per household in 1911 to 2.5 people in 2024. At the same time, the average house size has increased, ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Catherine Page Jeffery, Lecturer in Media and Communications, University of Sydney suriyachan/Shutterstock When the Australian government passed legislation in November last year banning young people under 16 from social media, it included exemptions for platforms “that are primarily for the purposes ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Leslie Roberson, Postdoctoral research fellow, Centre for Biodiversity and Conservation Science, The University of Queensland If you’ve ever been stopped by quarantine officers at the airport, you might think Australia’s international border is locked down like a fortress. But when it comes ...
Duncan Sarkies’ latest novel, Star Gazers, is about the collapse of democracy in a society of alpaca breeders. Here are some things his intensive research revealed. 1 How greed works, psychologicallyYes, I guess I already understood greed, but I could never understand why people who already have everything they ...
The proposed cuts would see only two full time Telehealth data and digital roles, and one Planning, Funding and Outcomes (PFO) role remain, reduced from 17 Telehealth support roles (including vacant roles). Roles proposed to be cut include Telehealth ...
The Taxpayers’ Union is calling for Ministers to end funding for Te Kurahuna programmes and workshop grifters that have received millions in taxpayer funding, despite the Government’s supposed focus on cutting costs. ...
By Caleb Fotheringham, RNZ Pacific journalist, in Avarua, Rarotonga More than 400 people have taken to the streets to protest against Cook Islands Prime Minister Mark Brown’s recent decisions, which have led to a diplomatic spat with New Zealand. The protest, led by Opposition MP and Cook Islands United Party ...
In the second episode, Brynley Stent and Kura Forrester unearth some truths about dating on a dance floor in South Canterbury. Bryn & Ku’s Singles Club is a brand new documentary series for The Spinoff following award-winning comedians and friends Brynley Stent and Kura Forrester as they embark ...
The first half of a billion-dollar pipe that will drastically reduce wastewater overflows in the Auckland isthmus is now in operation. As I biked south, I thought about all the poo sloshing beneath my wheels. Tubes of it disgorging from U-bends, into wastewater pipes laid under our streets that become ...
🚐 The vulnerability continues as the pair head to the Hunt Ball in South Canterbury in search of a rich farmer, before getting some sage relationship advice from Brynley’s Dad and Oma. ❣️ Bryn & Ku’s Singles Club follows comedians Brynley Stent and Kura Forrester as they head out on ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Joel Garrett, Lecturer in Exercise Science and Physiology, Griffith University Australia’s love affair with the major football codes – the Australian Football League (AFL) and National Rugby League (NRL) – is well documented. However, one aspect that stands out to many observers, ...
The White Lotus is back for season three. Here’s what we made of episode one. The third White Lotus season rinses and repeats – and thank God for that. Turns out there is enough comedic and dramatic juice in resort-set ensemble satires on privilege in the modern world, ...
Founder, journalist and author Tim Burrowes joins Duncan Greive to discuss a torrid decade in Australian media and whether there are reasons to be optimistic amid the carnage. Tim Burrowes is the author of a book and a Substack called Unmade, which are truly essential guides to media in ...
The self-appointed apostle says he could be to Christopher Luxon what Elon Musk is to Donald Trump, and his track record speaks for itself.Who is New Zealand’s answer to Elon Musk? The Herald’s tech insider, Chris Keall, put the question to his LinkedIn acolytes the other day. “If Luxon ...
The last good thing at the supermarket is gone. Mad Chapman mourns the Cadbury mini egg cartons. When life is overwhelming and it feels like every story around you is a bad news story, there are a few things that can be relied upon to instil a sense of calm, ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Stephen Parker, Honorary Professorial Fellow, Melbourne CSHE, The University of Melbourne Shutterstock Judges in Australian courtrooms have a lot of power. They can decide on someone’s guilt and the punishment for it, including lengthy prison time. But what if they get ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Louise Birrell, Researcher, Matilda Centre for Research in Mental Health and Substance Use, University of Sydney Pixel-Shot/Shutterstock Australians are waiting an average of 12 years to seek treatment for mental health and substance use disorders, our new research shows. While ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Justine Bell-James, Professor, TC Beirne School of Law, The University of Queensland Almost 200 nations have signed an ambitious agreement to halt and reverse biodiversity loss but none is on track to meet the crucial goal, our new research reveals. The agreement, ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Philippa Collin, Professor, Institute for Culture and Society, Western Sydney University Australian school students’ civics knowledge is the lowest it has been since testing began 20 years ago, according to new national data. Results have fallen since the last assessment in 2019 ...
Does this make me the first to welcome a new year? Greetings to all anyway.
Happy new year to you ianmac. How are things in Abu Dhabi?
Do the people there, believe that global warming is the threat we have all been told?
I can’t think of anything good that came out of Helen Clark’s government.
I’m genuinely curious to know what lefties think Helen Clark did to deserve her ONZ honour.
Just a list of bullet points of her top achievements will suffice.
Happy new year!
Here are a few that I like:
– minimum wage raised to $12
– 4 weeks holiday
– Cullen Fund
– Working for Families
– Kiwisaver
I am sure people can add in a lot more
Consistent independent foreign policy that kept us out of Iraq (other than UN sanctioned presence). That’s not bad for starters.
Civl unions and the legal recognition of de-facto relationships.
Stayed out of the ‘Coalition of the willing’
Resisted the calls for tax cuts that were based purely on the existence of temporary surpluses. had those calls been heeded the economy wouldn’t have weathered the current storms half as well.
Edit: logie: snap
Civil unions were a cop out from the decidedly socially conservative Labour party – they were too afraid to go for gay marriage. The ideal though should be to get the state out of the marriage business altogether. An argument for replacing marriage with civil unions is worthy though.
But what about the cynical lack of marriage or even civil unions for multiples? What about gay adoption? Abortion on demand?
Labour achieved very little in nine years on social issues. Prostitution legalisation was one of the only major gains from the otherwise deeply conservative Labour party. Look at what happened to BZP and NOS thanks to Labour’s partner Anderton.
What about the erosion of our civil liberites and Labour’s sickening law and order auction?
I can’t look back nine whole years of Labour and say that there was much positive progress.
I agree with all of that. But I don’t make the perfect the enemy of the good. Progress is progress q, it is not an end state but a journey etc.
These might sound to you like apologies for failure, or prettified conservatism or what have you, but to me it’s about the best one can expect barring revolution. Leaders must lead, but they only do so effectively when they go at a pace the people are willing to follow at. That makes progress more durable.
I want progress not revolution, but I just don’t see it from Labour. It’s just absurd to say that that’s the best we can expect.
On many issues Labour actually took us backwards – drug prohibition, law and order, civil liberties, immigration.
I’m ashamed to have ever voted for Labour.
What do you consider were the backward steps WRT law and order, civil liberties and immigration?
Ministry of Justice – Labour increased prison sentences, toughened up bail laws and parole. They for me were steps backwards. Here is some stuff on immigration at NRT Immigration Act Review index On civil liberties there’s such like the anti-terrorism laws, draconian laws against boy racers various new police powers, etc.
Any increase in state power is a step backwards in my eyes.
I have had a comment on our previous Prime Minister stalled waiting for moderation since 11 am. I wonder why?
This was it –
Helen Clark was good but should not be canonised and criticism of her performance is as relevant as for other politicians. Don’t be paranoid, the Nats nicknamed her Helengrad which was unfair and unreasonable but leader worship should not get in the way of reasonable analysis.
Why should the above trigger moderation – are there some terrible key words?
[lprent: I’ve been offline for a few days. Not sure – I’ve have a look at it. ]
@prism: I imagine the issue was “Helengr@d” and the number of people who use it un-ironically.
Thanks all for answering my question – I consider all of those achievements bad.
It’s a shame I can’t start discussions here – there’s lots I’d like to discuss one topic at a time.
I guess I’ll have to watch and wait for the topics that interest me to be brought up by someone else.
Or you could start a blog.
I’d visit to read about your ideas for a lower minimum wage, militarily subservient, less tolerant NZ with no money in the bank.
Sounds awesome.
Felix –
I am starting my own blog (almost ready to kick off) but if I posted there I wouldn’t get your insights.
That’s nice dear. A few more days of non-committal vague posturing and veiled insults and I’m sure you’ll have drummed up enough interest for the big launch. Yawn.
Yep, thought so, somebody who believes that the poor majority should be thankful for being ripped off by the rich and powerful and do as they’re told.
Mr Bastard –
You’ve got me figured out.
It’s the Open Mike section, I gather you can say pretty much whatever you want (subject to the whims of the moderators), so go wild.
Care to explain why you think all of the achievements listed to be bad?
I’m pretty happy with all of items listed as positives, even though most of them don’t affect me directly. And I acknowledge QtR’s points that Labour (a) did some bad stuff and (b) could have gone further – I look forward to them going further at their next opportunity.
I would add
Interest free student loans
Increased RUCs
Legalised prostitution
Cheaper doctor’s visits, and
a lot of the updated Local Government Act and Building Act were a step forward, too.
Meanwhile National have us in reverse with the clutch up, accelerator pushed hard down and someone with no vision holding the steering wheel. I can’t wait for the election next year.
I prefer to discuss topics one at a time for clarity. Oh well… lets see what happens.
Why I consider the achievements to be bad…
Minimum wage – Government interference in contracts.
4 weeks holiday – Government interference in contracts.
Working for Families – Generosity with other people’s money.
Kiwisaver – Not the Governments business.
Cullen Fund – Not the Governments business.
Civil unions – Not the Governments business (i.e. giving moral sanctions). I could support QTR’s idea “to get the state out of the marriage business”.
Defacto relationships – Government interference in contracts.
Prostitution legalisation – Decriminalisation of prostitution is not bad in itself but it is bad while there are anti-discrimination laws. It amounts to a government moral sanction.
Interest free student loans – Generosity with other people’s money.
Cheaper doctors visits – Generosity with other people’s money and Government interference in contracts.
Minimum wage – there is always a minimum wage. Without legislation it just defaults to zero. There’s a word for minimum wage = zero, slavery, and there are reasons why it is illegal.
4 weeks holiday – Well it’s government interference whether it is three weeks or four. Got anything to argue about three weeks versus four?
Working for Families Generosity with other people’s money. More like returning money to people that paid tax. Y’know, like Ragnar Danneskjold did with Hank Reardon, just before he told us how bad Robin Hood was. I expect you will find that most people who receive WFF are net taxpayers, and those that aren’t have creative accountants.
Kiwisaver and Cullen Fund Not the Governments business. Much better to be left to one of those wonderful private investment funds, eh?
Civil unions and Defacto relationships I could support QTR’s suggestion about keeping the government out of the marriage business too, but let’s not equivocate. Before the legislation came in the government interfered more than it does under the current legislation. Is your argument that because the government didn’t go all the way, the steps they took was worse than doing nothing? I disagree.
Prostitution legalisation It amounts to a government moral sanction. Whereas previously the government made a moral judgement that it was wrong to offer to have sex for money. Now it has stopped enforcing that judgement. What is wrong with that?
Interest free student loans Generosity with other people’s money. It’s peanuts compared to the subsidy paid in terms of the course fees. Would you prefer a society where, to obtain a tertiary education, one had to pay the full cost? Why stop there, though, why don’t you object to children earning their primary and secondary education by paying for it themselves? It is just another type of intergenerational equity transfer.
Cheaper doctors visits Universal and affordable healthcare is one of the bases of a civilised society. I don’t give a shit that you think it is interfering in contracts and generosity with other people’s money – it is better than the alternative.
BTW I am not affected directly by any of these things, I’m not on the minimum wage, being self employed I take as much or as little leave as I want, I don’t benefit from WFF (I haven’t even checked my eligibilty), I don’t use the Cullen Fund or Kiwisaver, I’m not in a civil union or defacto relationship, I don’t know any prostitutes or anyone who acknowledges having used a prostitute, I don’t have a student loan (because I paid mine back years ago, before they were interest free) and I don’t benefit from the changes around healthcare.
Best of luck with your blog. Be sure to post a link.
Thanks for that response for me Armchair.
The thing that is so striking is the belief that the government has no place interfering with agreements between individuals which would lead me to believe we are dealing with a “free marketeer” here. Would have thought they would have learnt their lesson after the failure of their goals in the past few years? Or was that all brought about because there was too much government interference in Wall Sts profiteering? 😛
There are no minimum wage laws in countires like Sweden and Denmark. The UK didn’t have any minimum wage laws until 1999 and I don’t think they had slavery then. I just do not think there is actually a strong argument either way on the minimum wage that is for the negative economic consequences (inflation, unemployment, etc) or the positive effects of it. A greater influence on wages comes from a lack of unionisation and unemplyment reducing workers bargaining power. It’s interesting to look back at some of the writings of socialists and communists in the US opposed to the introduction of minimum wage laws. Their thinking was that employers would stick to the floor with wages – and that may well be the case.
My personal opinion is that it should in time be removed, but we need reforms to free the market first. Here is a different view: On crutches and crowbars: toward a labor radical case against the minimum wage
Zorr – Maybe you should look into the role of central bank policies and fractional reserve banking in creating credit driven bubbles before jumping on the anti-free market bandwagon.
Cheers QTR, I always enjoy reading your perspective even though I don’t always agree with it. This time I reckon a minimum wage is necessary, though if an effective non-legislative mechanism is used that’s fine by me. Happy New Year.
Self admitted Frankenstein’s monster honoured under Nats
For services to lock-outs
Arise, Arise, sir monster
Like Dr Frankenstein’s monster which was assembled from various body parts, Infratil founder Lloyd Morrison says he is made up of various parts: part, Right wing capitalist, part socialist, and with an egalitarian heart.
http://www.stuff.co.nz/business/industries/3199920/Infratil-founder-believes-in-giving-to-community
Like the fabled monster which also had a soft heart but which struggled with its other components, Morrison was obviously out of control when he locked out the low paid bus-workers in an unprovoked rampage last year.
Still no matter, he gives to charity.
(well at least enough to buy a new years honour)
What a hateful little troll you are.
Troll isn’t the word I would use.
tbh there are a lot of dubious people being given the ONZ this year and a lot of them are Business Roundtablers… funny that
Yeah, it’s funny how Key’s ‘war on P’ seems to mean that dealers of other drugs get battle honours.
“…tbh there are a lot of dubious people being given the ONZ this year and a lot of them are Business Roundtablers funny that…”
As Idiot/Savant points out “ACT – they demanded a position on the Honours and Appointments Committee as part of their Confidence and Supply Agreement…” So it’s pretty clear ACT is ensuring those that bankroll get to be called ‘sir” (but not by me).
ACT – the party of, and for, corrupt crooks.
Anybody doubt that the market is on taxpayer life support?
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB126195515647306765.html?mod=WSJ_hp_mostpop_read#articleTabs%3Darticle
It has been for the last 500 years.
A brace of linkies from Eric Martin at Obsidian Wings:
Please to be ignoring the neocon tubthumping re: Iran and the current situation there. As he says, sepak softly and don’t buy anyone a stick. Active foreign support for revolutionaries when the regime’s propaganda is about painting the revolutionaries as foreign puppets; trends toward fail.
If we define winning in Afghanistan as having a govt seen as legitimate by her people, and that doesn’t co operate with AQ, then that government might not be the sort of thing we like. The chances of getting a govt we like however are near to nil, so if that is the goal we shouldn’t be there in any case.
That sick tyrant Obama is gutting American’s civil liberites. This time by gutting due process protection.
A colleague in the US sent me through the news on this when I was moaning about a petty issue we have back here in NZ – I still find it hard to believe that the US would openly continue down this path…. very depressing.
Why?
The capitalists tried for a fascist coup in the US back in the 1930s. It failed but that doesn’t mean that they stopped trying.
Don’t be a drip.
Matter of historical record, no?
That DTB is a drip ……. looking back through the comments on this blog I don’t think one could dispute that, same old tired capitalist = bad crap ad nauseam.
Hiding from reality again there gitmo?
They didn’t need to. With the New Deal FDR effectively handed over their economy to big corporates. Mussolini said:
See the New Deal and corporatism.
Earlier this week the Fire Service said more than 25 percent of all fire calls in the past financial year were false alarms and cost taxpayers up to $25 million.
The Auckland Firefighters Union told NewstalkZB the figures released by the Fire Service were paving the way to reduce the response to central city buildings with fire protection systems.
President Jeff McCulloch said the only additional cost for attending a fire was the diesel used by the fire trucks.
He said fire fighters were being paid regardless of what they were doing.
http://www.stuff.co.nz/national/3201200/Firefighters-union-hits-back
More than 20,000 Contact Energy customers in North Canterbury will face price rises next month.
The company said it was passing on costs it had incurred from MainPower, along with higher internal costs associated with operating and building power stations.
Christchurch-based energy analyst John Noble said Contact should have absorbed the increase from MainPower, given Contact’s profit last year.
Raising prices because of internal cost increases was “rubbish” and made a mockery of Energy Minister Gerry Brownlee’s plan to get power companies to reduce prices.
Contact made an operating profit of $445.3 million last financial year and is forecasting a profit of $485m this year.
http://www.stuff.co.nz/business/industries/3201447/Contact-price-rise-in-North-Canterbury
From .” Ministry of Justice” the first 3 words sum it up and there’s no need to read any further. …” I can’t think….” – Just another right wing dullard.
Quoth the Raven similar… ” I can’t see…”, ” I can’t look back…” ” I just don’t see..”
Why would you want to read any further anyway?
Rodel – Speaking of dullards why don’t you expand on your argument a little more because I just can’t see your point. Or how about this why don’t you actually respond to Ministry of Justice or respond to my points. Or you can just continue to leave snarky substanceless comments on other’s style of prose.
Jenny, Thanks for your regards but here (now in Athens) I have met no-one who speaks conversational English. If I ask anyone for help they always kindly give it and in English but i have not heard anyone, and there are hoards of tourists, discussing anything in English. I must accept that here at least English speaking is very unimportant. Actually global warming might be of interest as the mid winter here so far has been daily 18-20 degrees C so you can’t argue with the weather but the climate might be a different story. Cheers.
well nobody here speaks conversational english either.
its all gimme gimme gimme and much obliged.
Armchair Critic –
Minimum wage…
There’s a word for minimum wage = zero, slavery, and there are reasons why it is illegal.
When I was at the Fair Trade shop they had a “help wanted” sign up so I asked if the wages were fair, the lady told me that there was no pay. I laughed and told that didn’t sound very fair and she told me that only the boss gets paid.
So I say that not only is a zero wage legal it’s even compatible with “Fair Trade”.
Because there’s no objective difference between “volunteering one’s free time to a cause one finds worthy” and “being forced to take work at zero or near-zero remuneration in the hopes of future income because there is no protection for workers and the “free market” doesn’t give a hoot if you starve to death”.
I’ll keep in mind that you don’t know the difference between being a volunteer and being a slave when I reed this blog of yours.
I get that you don’t think there should be a minimum wage. The original point was that Labour under Clark raised the minimum wage and tis was one of the good achievements of the Clark governments. Do you just think this was not a good achievement because you believe the “minimum wage = bad” mantra, or have you thought about it further? Got any arguments that show that the actual increases the minimum wage caused more harm than good?
There is nothing within Labour (Or any others) that quantifies the value of a livable wage (H1 would not answer this when I posed it to her) then how min wage, soc welfare benefits and other assistance eg WFF dove tails into this base level. I have had this idea that a livable wage is higher than what any envisage. How can we have the likes of Kiwsaver when I believe many are excluded from this indirectly as they cannot afford to contribute, yet they are contributing to subsidise the cost of running this as any tax payer does. Lab should IMO have made Kiwisaver compo with a min fixed $ value being contributed by the govt (Read tax payer) to all tax payers (Beneficiaries pay tax as I believe).
Perhaps a large number receiving WFF are well above this livable wage and we are paying welfare to those that do not require assistance.
This is something that’s been bugging me for the last couple of years. What is the minimum cost of living? And, yes, I believe it’s far higher than what many, especially those in government and business, are willing to admit.
WfF is an admission, of sorts, that wages aren’t high enough to cover living.
I think you would get no one disagreeing with you on that. Yet there are a few points, what is a livable wage, can NZ “afford” this. And how can we progress to a stage whereby those on min wage can more than just survive, and when I use min wage I refer to the tax, WFF,etc allow the individual/family to approach this livable wage level. Until there is some effort into calc this wage and “we” accept that this is calc is appropiate otherwise we are just shooting in the dark with no real target we are attempting to achieve.
NZ, on it’s own productivity, can afford to have everyone in a style of living that most people don’t get ATM.
That’s the million $$$ question – quite literally. Obviously, it’s not by continuing with the way we have been over the last 3 decades.
WFF is I believe an acknowledgment that the simple tax system of set percentages for all on PAYE and with GST has unfair consequences on people with extra costs and responsibilities that society needs to be concerned with ie parents, carers etc.
So the people who most need a tax system that recognises their importance as parents and the costs involved, receive some of their tax back – then having the odium thrown at them that they are receiving handouts. They shouldn’t be charged so much in the first place – the amount of tax charged is a large cause of financial difficulty for families.
I simply think it is wrong for the Government to interfere in contracts.
What’s worse is in this case they caused changes to existing contracts.
“I simply think it is wrong for the Government to interfere in contracts.”
No offense intended, but when I see simple and pure principles like this put forward, where they so plainly contradict how liberal western democratic governments have acted, I’m always left in a bit of a bind.
I want to assume that there are some obvious qualifications to the asserted principle that are being left unsaid. What those qualifications are, is precisely where the real debate is hiding.
There are many such broad principles one can put forward, that most people agree with up to a point. Where that point is the debate, so an absolute stating of the generally held principle doesn’t tell me where about your ‘point’ is . So I’m left in the position of not really knowing what your position is. Which considering that you clearly disagree with me, leaves me unable to respond.
The most obvious unstated qualification to the above principle:
“I simply think it is wrong for the Government to interfere in contracts.”
is one that would prohibit contract killings and assaults, slavery, child prostitution etc. (But how much would you put in to the etc?)
So assuming your principle means something like:
I simply think it is wrong for the Government to interfere in contracts between consenting adults, where such a contract wouldn’t breach whatever basic human rights legislation the nation has in place.
Assuming this allows a government to counter Murder Inc type activities, it still leaves an enormous amount of things that are currently proscribed, for long established reasons, fair game.
What, other than labour laws, does your principle condemn? Anti-cartel and anti-monopoly laws? Legislative consumer guarantees? Securities legislation (insider trading etc)? The Companies Act? Environmental laws? Town planning? Public Works? OSH?
What are the qualifications, if any, to your principle here?
Armchair critic asked if I had any “arguments that show that the actual increases [to] the minimum wage caused more harm than good” to which I responded “I simply think it is wrong for the Government to interfere in contracts”.
Let me clarify… if it is unjust for the Government to interfere in contracts then it is unjust irrespective of the consequences (i.e. even if it causes more good than harm).
If you think there are exceptions to the principle as applied to the minimum wage situation then you should say what they are.
Consider the following statements…
1. Legislation that prevents people from being employed at a low wage is a good thing.
2. Legislation that prevents people from being employed to perform sex acts is a good thing.
Either both statements are true, or both are false, or there is some principled difference between “being employed to perform sex acts” and “being employed at a low wage”.
If you agree with 1 and disagree with 2 can you identify why?
I think that principles should promote good over harm. If there are applications of a general principle that would cause more harm than good, I think we should make an exception to it.
As you seem to be saying that you do not hold any exceptions to your principle, can I take it that you think Murder Inc is ok, and that monopolies and cartels should be allowed, and that all those other things I listed in my second to last para should also be done away with?
All of these things are breaches of your principle. That’s fine, but it is an incredibly fringe position.
“If you agree with 1 and disagree with 2 can you identify why?”
Because 2. relates to the nature of the task undertaken, whereas 1. relates to payment for the task undertaken, i.e. they are fundamentally different issues and relate to different principles.
“I simply think it is wrong for the Government to interfere in contracts”
As a general principle, yes.
In the instance of a minimum wage, and in the absence of an effective non-legislative mechanism, I think the government is obliged to act. Because, in general, people who accept offers of minimum wage jobs are under a sort of economic duress, in that they have no other practical alternative than to accept the offer. Unless, of course, you believe that going/staying on the benefit is a practical alternative. But based on your previous comments, I expect you believe that going on the benefit couldn’t be a practical alternative.
Setting a minimum wage is one way of obviating the economic duress, to some extent. Raising the minimum wage reduces the degree of economic duress.
For the record – I know it doesn’t meet the legal definition of economic duress.
Do you have a gas driven dildo in that chair ?
There are fools on both sides of the ‘class war’ …. the unions and workers endlessly demanding more money for less endeavour and the employers trying to get more work for less money. The intelligent person on both sides, and there are a few around, knows that both sides must be happy for the joint enterprise to be successful in the long term. So they talk to each other and reach a mutually satisfactory compromise..
But it’s not a ‘joint exercise’ is it jcuknz? It’s a relationship predicated on exploitation. A joint exercise would entail an end to the vertical divisions of labour wouldn’t it? Do you think there are any bosses intelligent enough to use their position of power to similtaneously empower the workers beneath them and delegitimise their own position in order that ‘joint exercises’ can be brought about smoothly and without friction?
Still in moderation?
[Be patient with us Bill – there’s no one much about at the moment. I’m in transit myself… — r0b]
The end of privacy
Looks like the debate has been lost and the authoritarians won.
That’s step one.
And bearing in mind that where America goes (some of) the world follows.
Here’s step two. Coming to your street soon.
http://www.truthdig.com/report/item/one_day_well_all_be_terrorists_20091228/
heh
johnny Banks now in third place in polling for Supercitymayor
(Granny’s spin amusing)
It seems that in spite of ‘everything’ inspirational people persist.
“…Hedy Epstein, the 85-year-old Holocaust survivor, who initiated a hunger strike in Cairo for the opening of the borders of Gaza to the outside world.”
What a wonderful story about Hedy Epstein.
The expensive fireworks set off merely to register a change of date and year should be saved to honour such great acts of kindness and humanity. That she is a holocaust survivor and 85 and really little at 4’10” makes her a towering beacon of hope to a disillusioned world. And maybe she will bring much needed relief to the ghetto of the Palestinians.
Very sad about new security surveillance having so few checks and balances. When it comes to the USA the National Party seem to fall down like a stack of cards. All our politicians have the English disease, the common language that is jokingly supposed to divide us, but we understand threats in it very well.
Im afraid a mininum wage is a must until a better way is found to stop employer exploitation of workers . What is badly needed is a control on the higher wage bracket.. Some of the wages /packages and bonus’ paid to some of these high profilers are insulting to the average working person.. Its the wealth gap that is the top priority not this stupid obsession on the wage difference between and and Australia/ .
“Ministry of Justice
Minimum wage Government interference in contracts.
Prostitution legalisation Decriminalisation of prostitution is not bad in itself but it is bad while there are anti-discrimination laws. It amounts to a government moral sanction”
Can you see the massive contradiction between these points? Are you really concerned with such principals, or are they just just convenient liberal-ish arguments you use to justify your pre-existing baseless prejudice to avoid confronting that such prejudice has no place in law?
Oh dear.
“Britain and the US are to jointly fund a counter-terrorism unit in Yemen, it has been revealed.
Downing Street said Gordon Brown and President Barack Obama agreed the move as part of the response to the failed Detroit airliner plot.”
Oops!.
We are the Awaleq
Born of bitterness
We are the nails that go into the rock
We are the sparks of hell
He who defies us will be burned
And if that’s not enough…throw in Somalis aiding any fight … “Yemen has said it will not tolerate foreign fighters on its soil, following a pledge by Somalia’s al-Shabab group that it would send fighters to help an al-Qaeda affiliate in the country.”
and then oh, what the hell, lets throw a curve ball at Iran….and whatd’youknow?
BOOM!
antispam – assured
I am sure that Bush lead the American people the wrong way after 9/11 and although appeasement did nothing for the world in 1938 there must be something intelligent people can do to rein in America’s foolishness. All power to Hedy Epstein, not that I think it will do any good for the Palestinian problem … might is wrong. Which way do we take the Yemen statement? Which foreign soldiers are bad and who are good? Somali or Anglo/American?
Excuse me if I sound depressed and don’t wish everybody a happy new year at the beginning of the last year of the decennial from hell. I sound depressed because I am.
When the story of the underpants hijacker began to emerge I predicted X-ray scanning machines ate every airport within three months. It turned out that most countries western countries decided to install them within three days of the failed attempt to blow up an airplane over Detroit.
Now only that, Mr. “Change” Obama immediately swore to find the people who helped a disturbed Nigerian son of a rich banker to smuggle a lump of explosives hidden under his genitals onto a plane.
It turns out that we were wrong about Osama bin Laden and that the real spiritual leader from the 9/11 hijackers down to the sorry young man from Nigeria was someone who goes by the name of Anwar al Awlaki and surprise surprise lives in Yemen. Well we know what happened with Afghanistan when we, apparently mistaken, thought that a Saudi hiding in a cave over there was the spiritual leader of the 911 hijackers.
Anybody else out there saying, “Oh puleese, enough with the scaremongering and propaganda already.”
It turns out you see that while the MSM has already spoon fed us the story of the crazed religious nut who wanted to be pure and in order to do so tried to blow up a plane that some of the people who were on the plane have conflicting and disturbing accounts of what really transpired on the flight and once again we should have an open and independent investigation into what happened instead of once again using it to invade another oil rich, strategic important country but it is my humble opinion that this will not happen and that the sheeple will allow themselves to be let to slaughter by the worlds elites.
The UK and US embassies have been closed already. Will John Key follow his masters as he did when they walked out of Ahmadinajad’s speech at the UN?
If the news that our cyber boys are now allowed more and more snooping into our privacy sneaked into law is anything to go by I don’t hold much hope.
I’m sure New Zealanders will get X-rayed soon at our airports.
Anti spam: DISAPPEAR. Who knows, that might be next.
May the force be with everyone who tries to fight for freedom and justice in the years to come.
You had me at … ‘X-ray scanning machines ate every airport within three months.”
magnificent satire
Airport Scanners
Problem.
Tests by scientists in the team at Qinetiq (….), showed the millimetre-wave scanners picked up shrapnel and heavy wax and metal, but plastic, chemicals and liquids were missed.
Solution.
“…We must now start to ask if national security demands the use of profiling.”
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/are-planned-airport-scanners-just-a-scam-1856175.html
Meanwhile.
I’d have thought the obvious solution to all this fear of aeroplanes being blown up is to simply ground the whole damned lot of them.
Permanently.
Peak oil…CO2 emissions… the parlous financial state of a number of airlines. Add the fact that jobs are needed (unless we advocate a jobless ‘recovery’) and all that public transport infrastructure that will be required to replace air transport…
But that’s not all!
Consider the benefits of a slower paced life….no flying up and down the country to meetings and conferences of questionable worth…have a three day paid work/life balance travel holiday instead!
But wait. There’s more!
Never again will you need fear the underpants of the gentleman next to you.
And all for one lump sum of meaningful stimulus package!
LOL. My defence is that I usually check when I post it and this time it got placed in purgatory. But it is funny.
help, purgatory
[lprent: I have released you from the wee vase, and you can now proceed down the nine circles. (just been reading Dantes insane vision again). ]
Looks like US homeland security are really on to something this time.
BLiP …. the link doesn’t work for me but rather than grounding the planes a simpler solution, or at least an alternative, is for every passenger to strip. I remember when the restrictions/ inspections first started one woman vowed she would be happy to if it meant a safe flight.
This re run of a Kung fu monkey post from some years back pretty much sums it up for me.
Read the whole thing, but here’s the gist
If fourth gen warriors can get us to implement millions of dollars of costs and cause millions of hours of delays and have every traveler reminded of their cause every time someone goes to an airport; that’s a pretty fckn good return from having one recruit captured.
It is sad that America is its worst enemy and Bush was theiur best recruiting agent
Ooops – not sure what happened there. This link might be better.
There is a strangely panicky wee piece in The Independent about a proposal to ‘parade along the high street (Wootton Bassett in England ) with empty coffins symbolising the ( Afghanistan) conflict’s Muslim victims.’
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/political-leaders-condemn-islamic-protest-march-1857088.html
Wootton Basett it seems is the town where the coffins of dead soldiers are driven in hearses through streets lined with onlookers. (An RAF base is nearby)
As expected the Press Association piece slams the organisers of the proposed parade branding them as Muslim extremists (they may be). Brown and Cameron condemn the idea. Civic leaders oppose the idea, and so on.
Anyway. To get the other side of the story I googled the organisers and…. surprise, surprise error 403 on every page directly related to them.
Assuming this is not a coincidence ( I don’t understand the reasons behind error messages.)
Of course, the msm will be reporting on this block…this denial of freedom of expression and democracy as they do when it is initiated by China or Iran. Right?
“As expected the Press Association piece slams the organisers of the proposed parade branding them as Muslim extremists (they may be).”
They most definitely are extremists.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/politics/defence/6931212/What-is-Islam4UK.html
So what?
The day the government starts trying to separate peaceful protests as being ‘good’ or ‘bad’ or ‘extremist’ or ‘terrorists’ by distinguishing on their backgrounds and motivations is the day I take up arms.
With historical perspective, the ‘extremists’ are frequently where everyone else is in 100 years. Think of such things as woman being able to vote.
Umm are you a complete numpty – comparing this jerks behaviour with giving women the vote is laughable especially as he’d likely seek to remove that right from them.
Have a look at the tosspots Wiki profile he is clearly a complete cunt.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anjem_Choudary
A complete cunt you say?
You mean that as a negative connotation don’t you?
This mean you as sexist as you are racist?
Just digging, just ’cause you’re walking right on in and asking for it…don’t bother responding. Just reflect and remember Hone and his motherfucker comment and your condemnation….or, oops!…did you miss the sexism and focus on the non-existent racism? You go figure you.
Meanwhile, I notice you offer no response to my comment below. Suprised? No I’m not.
Um what … are you drunk, illiterate or just retarded ?
Feel free to continue to side step the reality that this cunt (slang = a contemptible person) is a cunt (slang = a contemptible person) and is undoubtedly a sexist and racist to boot…. and I can’t be fucked responding to you bullshit below.
And calling my comment racist and sexist ……. perhaps a frontal lobotomy might improve your comprehension.
Cunts, numpties, retards, illiterates, drunks, racists and misogynists all within the space of three comments?
That’s class debate that is.
The biscuit’s all yours son.
edit Almost missed the wanker slight…go, gitmo!
And I’d strongly prefer it if both of you tone it down.
In my opinion, you’d have probably said exactly the same thing in the late 19th about the suffragettes. Or unions. Or CO’s. Or anyone else who had an opinion you objected to.
However that isn’t the point. Democracies run by having open public dissent. Trying to suppress it just leads to having nasty internal conflicts. If they step over the legitimate legal line which is assaults or property damage, then society acts appropriately. However in this case that seems unlikely – it isn’t exactly a covert action. The counter-protests are where you’re most likely to see the violence and property damage coming from.
Or are you trying to say that these people you’re disparaging for exercising their peaceful rights (and taking a reasonable amount of risk to do so) should instead go and make bombs to kill UK civilians because you’d be less offended (and it would probably fit your prejudices better)? It must be hard being such a sensitive soul about a symbolic protest…
Incidentally, have you figured out what they’re protesting about yet? It sounds like a valid point to me bearing in mind that the UK has troops in Iraq and Afghanistan – who are inevitably killing the civilian bystanders as well as their targets. Civil insurrections are an armies worst duty.
Are you completely fucked in the head Lynn – I am not saying these turds don’t have a right to protest……. I was pointing out in response to Bill (aka Jerkwad cockhole) that the protesters were indeed extremists, which then had the two of you rushing in to defend those same extremists and portraying them as upstanding citizens.
I think these pieces of smega in the UK have as much right to protest as that bottom belch Minto and his friends in Auckland – as long as they don’t disturb the peace or break the law let them do what they want.
Fuck with friends like you two the vast bulk of muslims in the UK don’t need enemies……. or perhaps you agree with Anjem that the British soldiers are murderers, rapists and baby killers and that sharia law should be installed in the UK, the pope should be killed, that the terrorist attacks in the USA and UK are OK etc etc…yep I sure that’s just the message that the vast rump of british muslims want out there and associated with their religion.
Oh dear. When I said ‘take the biscuit’, I wasn’t expecting you to take the whole sugar coated packet!
I was also unaware of your apparent diabetes.
I guess the invective comes on down in line with the sugar levels?
Anyway. Extremism and upstanding citizenry really are quite subjective labels and are entirely beside the point in this instance.
The message is a valid one. The messenger is irrelevant. But in an attempt to invalidate the message, AP maligned the messenger. The message gets affected by this. The subtext becomes something along the lines of ‘ If you think this thought, or propagate this thought, you are really no better than Islam 4UK ( ‘official’ designation) scum. And that is what any utterance of such thoughts will be associated with in the ( manipulated) public mind and also who any person, who utters such opinions, will be associated with in the (manipulated) public mind.’
The thought then becomes ‘inexpressible’ and a very pernicious form of censorship moves on to quash the next valid expression that governments or others would rather did not gain currency.
gitmo: Your orginonal comment gave me the distinct impression that you thought they shouldn’t be able to protest because it was offensive. In much the same way that I found DPF and CJS’s disgusting billboards in 2007 extremely offensive over the EFA.
I’m not a ‘friend’ of any extremist from any angle, religious, political, ecological etc. I am also not a friend of anyone who does more than protest about peaceful protests. My comment was something like that removing the ability to protest in a democratic society was when I’d start looking for arms – it means that full blown repression of all groups isn’t too far behind.
Linking to the telegraph as a definitive source for anything is a tad suspect. But anyway. So they hold what appear to us as extreme religious views. So what? So does the pope.
The question surely ought to be whether the proposed parade is expressing a legitimate concern. I’d have thought that bringing the public’s attention to the numbers of civilian deaths in Afghanistan was legitimate.
I’d also have thought it a sad day when a legitimate message is so easily and casually killed off by the self same media who should be reporting that very message themselves.
Anyway.
His open letter as printed in the telegraph is linked below. When the religious clap trap is put aside, the political argument and analysis that is left is more coherent than the official version of the why’s and wherefore’s of Afghanistan. So, can we call the official version extreme, insofar as it appears so removed from any intelligent interpretation of reality, or is that label reserved for official enemies only.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/onthefrontline/6930015/Anjem-Choudary-an-open-letter-to-families-of-British-soldiers-in-Afghanistan.html
Hope everybody is enjoying the NZ summer that here in Wellington has decided to arrive in full force, ableit belatedly. Splendid.
I stopped to read a few blogs, the one that really hit home was Trotters latest in Bowalley. Regardless of how you rate Trotter his contextual powers of observation are worth taking note of.
The premise of the latest is that the same bludgers who created the mess we are currently in last year were bailed out by us, the public…and now we are expected to not only pay for their mess but to allow them to carry on blithely repeating the same nonsense at our expense.
Methinks he is onto it, welcome to a new year and the same old story.
The legal brains trust in the US that did this:
has given up:
Legal prof points out that:
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/05/us/05bar.html?partner=rss&emc=rss
If people cannot change their minds in light of fresh evidence then it is a sad state of affairs and shows a serious lack of intelligence to criticise them for doing so.
The earth ‘was’ flat, the sun went around the earth ……….
I wasn’t actually criticisng them per se jc. It’s a major and welcome sea change, one that’s well overdue. The evidence has been there for a while. Any criticism implied was about that delay. Perhaps the US might start moving to a legal framework more in line with the liberal western values they claim to represent on the world stage.
To not criticise the US on it’s failings in these areas is to not stick up for those values. That’s ok if you don’t hold them I suppose.
NYT today “Two Indian tribes successfully argued that a wind-power project would impede their ritual greeting of the sunrise” What I tried to say is a spam word on this siteso wwhat can I say to express my disgust and amazement?
Again NYT “Yemeni officials said two militants were killed in a firefight as France, Germany and Japan joined the U.S. and Britain in closing their embassies. ” I’m reminded of a song from my WWII childhood ” Run Rabbit Run, Run Run RUN”
Then it continued ‘get the Hun on the run’ today AQ seem to be rather effective …. sadly.
This is a difficult blog to read –
With 100+ comments I have to skim read the whole thread to find the few new posts since I last read it.
Other blog software allows me to subscribe to a thread (and receive new comments by email) or have new posts highlighted. Is there some way of achieving that functionality here?