We, in the left, have some great writers and opinion shapers.
Obviously the easy clicks are pointing out how poor our current coalition government is. There is lots of low hanging fruit to pick.
But… we need a vision of an alternative. Where a government is there to serve the people first. To set policy that improves our infrastructure and resilience.
Ideas that can unify a splintered left. Where we can ignore essentially petty differences and aim for a bigger prize.
I am neither a great writer, nor an opinion shaper, but I do have some firm and decided ideas on what a left-wing coalition government should be pushing.
Take one idea as an example:
ALL utilities upon which human’s depend MUST be publicly owned.
This means our health system, our water supplies, our energy requirements, our transport systems, our education establishments, our food distribution outlets – all owned and run in the interests of the public.
That leaves plenty of things for the private sector, just not essential things.
It is true that food is a human necessity but I don't think it is a good idea for the state to be in charge of food distribution. The private sector is more efficient.
I have a long association with Cuba where the state heavily subsidises staple food products.
Everyone has a ration book (La Libreta) and hours are spent queueing for items that often run out. I once spent 4 hours in a queue for charcoal for cooking only to just miss out and be told to try again in 2 days.
In a food crisis the state would obviously be involved but outside of that private enterprise works better for food distribution.
We grow our own veges mostly and bake sourdough bread and eat little meat so our food bill is low. Fish is free so we eat lots of that.
I was visiting family in Dunedin a few months ago and at the railway farmers market was told that the reason farmers markets are more expensive than supermarkets is the industrial scale at which supermarkets operate.
There was an online supermarket that we bought some items from but they couldn't compete with Pak n Save.
Farmers markets are often expensive due to bourgeois boutique producers pretensions. At our local Far North Kaitaia market, fresh produce is good value, often cheaper than Pak n Slave from small organic and other growers.
Agree about food, we are being reamed as they are across the ditch by a duopoly. Busting it up benefits everyone with the political will required to do so nowhere to be seen.
Power, water keep public as everyone benefits from that.
More public housing is desperately needed, didnt stop them cancelling 40% of this years so easy to see the coalition priorities once you factor in charter schools corrosive impact.
Aussie may have more choice of suppermarket than we do but that means nothing when there is no choice when you enter the doors. In Melbourne this past week, 37.0 degrees, beer might be good, an IPA or a Hazy, nope only Furphys or Carlton and that at $56 a dozen.
Well, so far the 'State' has shown minimal ability to learn from any source in education. I have zero confidence that they will do so. More importantly, those parents who have kids who are falling through the cracks have zero confidence in state education.
When we have a previous Minister of Education, turning down an integrated school proposal – specifically directed at neurodiverse learners – because "there are available supports for all learners in existing state schools". It's very clear that the MoE and the education bureaucracy in general are severely out of touch with the on-the-ground reality.
I agree with you on this. However I can only speak from my personal experience with the state system. Going from the state school to private/alternative schools opened the doors for me, I’m afraid it’s a bit difficult to explain, but I do remember I would have been 7/8, this wonderful older woman sitting next to me and treating me as a normal person and feeling valued. My reading age went from practically zero to 13 in a few months. So personally I’m all in favour of these different schools
The one area that they have mandated is phonics-based reading – and all of the international research is with them, there. They've also set minimum standards for the amount of 'basics (reading, writing, maths) which should be going on daily/weekly. At the level they've set, every school should be easily complying. If they're not – you have to wonder what they're doing instead.
Can you point to even one state school which is significantly outstripping the expected-at-decile level? I can point to half-a-dozen integrated schools, which regularly do so (have a look at McAuley – delivering results better than state schools two or three deciles higher)
The state system does the same thing at every school – they regard this as a feature, not a bug. And, based on the evidence of the last two decades – across multiple governments, by-and-large does it increasingly badly.
The exceptions are Decile 10 schools like Auckland Grammar – which effectively operate as post-code limited private schools. And are rich enough and well-enough connected to tell the MoE to take a hike.
Well. I went from not reading to over 14 reading level in less than a year. This was with reading recovery in a State school in the 60's. It was using phonics, by the way. Because good teachers have always changed their approach to suit the individual learner.
A successful program which is now being defunded to buy "one size fits all" "structered literacy" materials from some overseas corporate. I wonder which Coalition of Cockups MP's have an interest in that. And what is going to happen to those who the magic one size fits all solution fails. "Sorry, we have no funding for that".
It is obvious the Coalition of cockups is setting up State schools to fail by putting them in an underfunded strait jacket, while giving private schools more freedom and funding to meet students needs.
By the way, Auckland grammer like the charter schools, and private health shoves their failures back on the State system to make their results look better. Whangarei schools are well aware of the kids they have let down.
The goal remains the same. Destroy the State system to make privatisation look better. Force a narrow one size fits all on State schools, while private schools are giving the freedom to teach to best practice, and the funds, State school teachers can only dream about.
Private schooling in the USA, like privatised health, is an abject failure. Only right wing fantacists and those with their eyes on billions of taxes going to private school profits, and "useful idiots" truly believe that private schools are the answer. Decades of evidence worldwide shows much better results if the funding is directed to State schools.
It hasn't changed. Fuck up State provision, so a few people can make billions from privatisation. W've already seen how it works with rail, power, health (GP is apparent at present) , State housing, aged care, child care.
Why the hell would we want a repeat with education.
The Reading Recovery programme in NZ has been anything but successful over the last 2 decades. Just witness the long tail of children who are reaching secondary school as functionally illiterate. Most of which have failed to learn in the classroom, and then failed to learn in the RR programme.
The MoE has remained firmly wedded to the concept of 'balanced literacy', regardless of decades of international research showing that it has poorer educational outcomes than phonics-based strategies for learning to read.
Schools which have gone against the tide in NZ – specifically disregarding MoE directives, and using discretionary funding to support a phonics based learning to read programme – have reported very significant improvements.
Most parents are not willing to put philosophy ahead of the welfare of their children.
Just witness the long tail of children who are reaching secondary school as functionally illiterate
Yes. Just note the long tail reaching secondary school illiterate.
Who were at primary during the last National Governments "unfortunate experiment" in education. Forcing Teachers into a strait jacket after they canned the Clark Governments evidence based and widely consulted "New NZ curriculum" ( which allowed Teachers flexibility) for a top down imposition of NACT standards.
Again we are seeing top down impositions. Just the thing you complain about.
Of course, widespread effects of housing shortages and poverty which the Coalition of cockups are exerbating, has an even greater effect than anything Teachers can do. The "tail" are known to consist mostly of children whose families are below the poverty line!
Yes. Just note the long tail reaching secondary school illiterate.
Who were at primary during the last National Governments "unfortunate experiment" in education. Forcing Teachers into a strait jacket after they canned the Clark Governments evidence based and widely consulted "New NZ curriculum" ( which allowed Teachers flexibility) for a top down imposition of NACT standards.
I realise that maths may not be your strong point. But we have just had 6 years of a left government. Any kid reaching high-school at this point in time, had had their primary/intermediate years almost entirely under a Labour led government.
I have commented on this topic extensively, before. From my reading, in both the UK and Australia, a big shift to for-profit schooling by the Torys and the Liberals has sucked a huge amount of government money away from state education. The end redult is a 2-tier education system, with a breaking/broken state sector.
Just who do you support, BD? Your red herrings on name suppression took up column space on MTui's Yago post, which was about ACT's strategic obsfucation's, not Yago's crimes.
And today, BD, you are coming out behind Seymour's destructive charter school policy, which has been extensively debunked in a previous iteration in NZ.
Don't bleat about consumer choice and failures in our state school system. Put up the case for the for-profit model from, for example, your 'Isle of Perfection', the UK academies.
If you struggle with differing viewpoints, then you are likely to find a political blog a … challenging … place.
I've been commenting on the need for phonics-based reading education in NZ on TS, for quite some time. Based on the overwhelming international research on its effectiveness. This is hardly new territory for me. Nor is the fact that the state schooling system in NZ has continued to fail children. It's an unpalatable truth for those wedded to state-is-best – that children at state-integrated schools, regularly out-perform their decile peers at state schools.
The current charter schools (just opened this week, so a little too soon to comment on their effectiveness) appear to be very largely run by trusts or zero-profit organizations – and specifically targeted at kids whose needs are demonstrably *not* being met through the current state system. This is hardly privatization of education.
Nor, have I advocated for a 'for profit' model for education. Or claimed that the UK is an 'isle of perfection'. This comes entirely from your disordered imagination.
that children at state-integrated schools, regularly out-perform their decile peers at state schools.
The results, in reality, are rather mixed.
But once you add family income as a variable. No! State integrated schools and charter schools in NZ do not perform better than State schools.
When you have much more funding and the capability to pick and choose your pupils it is easy to, outwardly, show better results. An example is Auckland Grammers zoning. I could do that too, if I could pick my students.
I taught for a while at a very low decile school. Their results, as far as "value added" student achievement from a disadvantaged base, far exceeded those of the more prestigious, but hidebound, school down the road. The local charter school startup, which was supposedly set up for disadvantaged Māori kids at great expense, booted any kids that were "difficult" back to us. To the disappointment of the kids, and their families, being promised much and then shoved around. I suppose it made their "results" look better, though.
Lastly. State schools would perform a lot better, if we could teach as we are taught to teach, with evidence based pedagogy and with regard to learners needs. Instead of having to follow particularly National Governments”one size fits all” nostalgia for rote learning and rigid counterproductive summative testing.
The rigidity you complain about in State schools comes from, mostly, National, Governments, not teachers!
Lastly. State schools would perform a lot better, if we could teach as we are taught to teach, with evidence based pedagogy and with regard to learners needs. Instead of having to follow particularly National Governments”one size fits all” nostalgia for rote learning and rigid counterproductive summative testing.
State schools have just had 6 years of a left government which was highly supportive of the teacher unions – and their 'teacher knows best' mentality. Learning standards continued to fall. Teachers, led by the MoE demonstrably did not learn from international best practice (cf phonics-based reading and open-plan classrooms). Continuing to do what has been happening over the last two decades – under a range of different governments – is clearly failing.
State-integrated schools rarely 'pick ad choose' pupils. They have strict selection criteria to prevent that happening. And even more rarely select based on academic ability (there is an argument that sporting ability 'counts' – but the result is that the sport-selected kid is getting a better education than they would in the state system – so pretty moot, from a parent's perspective. Note: this notoriously happens at high decile state schools, as well)
Any exclusions will be around behaviour, rather than learning ability. If a pupil chooses to deal drugs to other kids, or be violent to kids or staff, then they will be excluded. I'd argue they should be excluded from State schools as well – but that rarely seems to happen (the 'right' to education for that specific kid outweights the 'right' to education for all the rest of their classmates)
But once you add family income as a variable. No! State integrated schools and charter schools in NZ do not perform better than State schools.
Can you link to any evidence for this?
It doesn't seem to be borne out by the MoE data in the EQI (replacing deciles), which is intended to take this specific factor (along with a whole lot of others) into account.
I invite you to compare the NCEA results for One Tree Hill College (which has a lower, i.e better) EQI (470) than McAuley (487)
Cuba is a bad example to use because food is an internationally grown commodity and trade with Cuba is restricted e.g. US suppliers are prohibited from selling food to the Cuban government. Given the success of their education and health areas to everyone it is hard to make a case that food distribution would necessarily be inefficient in a free trade situation.
We're about to find out how efficient international food distribution is with trade tariffs.
Hi DOS US suppliers are not prohibited from selling food to the Cuban government. At the moment all of the frozen chickens in the system are from the US along with many other items.
Cuba can order whatever food it wants from the US and would order a lot more if it had the money to pay for it.
I had understood they can only sell to private enterprise in Cuba – capitalism vs communism.
Indeed this seems to say the same.
In a surprising development given Cuba’s worsening economy, exports of food and other goods from the United States were up last year thanks to an explosion of trade involving private small and medium enterprises on the island.
According to trade data gathered by the New York-based U.S. Cuba-Trade and Economic Council, an organization that tracks business with Cuba, U.S. companies, many based in Miami and Hialeah, exported food and agricultural products worth $342.6 million. That’s a 12.4% increase from 2021, when private enterprises, known in Cuba as pymes, were first authorized, and exports to Cuba reached $304.7 million.
Exports in December also jumped 58% from November, to $45.2 million from $28.6 million.
The export data for 2023 “is remarkable not only by the U.S. dollar value, but the substantial increase in the number of companies, primarily located in South Florida, who are exporting products from the United States to Cuba specifically in support of the re-emerging private sector in Cuba,” said John Kavulich, the council’s president. “This data legitimizes these are real businesses, that there is commercial activity, and it is expanding.”
Cuba has been under a U.S. trade and financial embargo since the early 1960s, but there are several exceptions that allow for the export of food, agricultural products, medical supplies, humanitarian donations, and several other categories of goods if they are to be used by the private sector and not the government.
DOS there maybe an embargo on US goods still. I don't know. What I do know is that the Cuban government is corrupt and desperate.
Yesterday- for the first time ever – they went begging to the UN World Food Program. Castro would Never have done that.
The young have had the internet for a few years now and are all looking at Amazon who deliver whatever you order. Not that anyone has any money except party officers and their families. Three years ago one USD cost 50 Cuban Peso. Today one USD costs 325 Pesos.
Cuba used to export food. Now agriculture has collapsed. Old tractors and farm machinery sits rusting on previously productive farms.
As I mentioned I could not believe all of the chickens are now imported from the US. Last year there were riots in at least three cities over food supply.
The power infrastructure urgently needs replacing and Cuba's major source of funding (exporting doctors) will come to an end if they can't find the money to upgrade the medical equipment that the doctors need to train on.
Diaz- Canal the President schedules endless speeches which no one listens to and no one believes blaming American Imperialism for all of Cubas woes and asking for more sacrifice.
Well a good step is: stop talking about the government and the state. Start talking about New Zealand. The right talks only of markets, property owners, and customers. That's how to start unifying.
I often think about what the perfect society would look like. And what part I play and what part the state. Obviously individuals can't provide hospitals, police, roads etc.
What if everyone was housed and had their nutritional needs met. And there was free healthcare, education and public transport.
To get there we would need a powerful capitalism to generate the necessary wealth.
Some socialism to spread the wealth
And the constitutional power of liberalism to keep us in order.
Norman Kirk: “Basically there are four things that matter to people: they have to have somewhere to live, they have to have food to eat, they have to have clothing to wear, and they have to have something to hope for.”
It's a coherent statement of principles. It stakes a claim for Norman Kirk's Labour Party as champion of humane and decent values; a stark contrast to the "vision" put forward by Bill Clinton and his malevolent campaign manager James Carville in the 1990s.
Maybe you've heard of some of the things Kirk's government did: 1) opposing French nuclear testing in the South Pacific—he sent a ship with a cabinet minister (Fraser Colman) on board to actually stop them; 2) standing in solidarity with the South African liberation struggle—Kirk stopped the Springbok tour in 1973; 3) establishing alternative lifestyle communes (the Ohu movement); 4) pulling New Zealand troops out of the U.S. assault on Vietnam; 5) established the Waitangi Tribunal; 6) abolished Compulsory Military Training; 7) established the DPB; 8) established the Disability Allowance; …
Your memory of New Zealand history is a little different to mine.
You say "opposing French nuclear testing in the South Pacific—he sent a ship with a cabinet minister (Fraser Colman) on board to actually stop them". Are you really suggested that the testing stopped? Remember that the frigate was sent in 1973.
In reality French nuclear tests continued at Mururoa until 1996. Twenty three years is an awfully slow stop, isn't it?
It succeeded in stopping atmospheric testing, which ceased only a year later. Underground testing was of course still utterly reprehensible, but the effects were by comparison much more confined, and not at all susceptible to the vagaries of weather.
Not only did that Labour Government stop France carrying out nuclear tests, it later prosecuted France at the World Court. The Lange government continued this policy of principled opposition to nuclear testing, culminating in the ban on nuclear ships entering our waters,
Sadly, such principled and courageous politics was entirely absent when the National Party was in power—of course, the most abject moment was Don Brash's pathetic "gone by lunchtime" pledge.
Given that Lange was only Prime Minister from 1984 until 1988, and the French nuclear tests continued until 1996 just how did he " stop France carrying out nuclear tests"?
You then claim that " entirely absent when the National Party was in power—of course, the most abject moment was Don Brash's pathetic "gone by lunchtime" pledge. "
Well the National Party were never in power while Don Brash was an MP. He was there from 2002 until 2007 so how does anything he is claimed to have said have to do with when the National Party was in power?
I was also tempted to comment on your comment about NZ in the Vietnam war. All the New Zealand combat troops were withdrawn a year or so before Kirk became PM.He withdrew some people who were helping train the Vietnamese forces. He left other military personnel there of course. He had been dead for a year or so before the final troops were withdrawn.
It's a tetrad. I'd up-grade it to incorporate fun as 5th essential since all culture emanates from it! To do a reality check, ask around friends & family to ascertain the viability of life with no fun. Big Norm clearly had a tacit acceptance of there being no fun in Labour.
Privatisation of mass surveillance has happened and mass lethargy remains the norm. She'll be right – but Bomber dissents anyway. "What, me worry?" thinks Alfred E Neuman https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alfred_E._Neuman
Panama's president vowed Sunday to end a key development deal with China after meeting with Secretary of State Marco Rubio and after complaints from President Donald Trump that the Latin American country had ceded control over its critical shipping canal to Beijing. José Raúl Mulino, Panama's president, said his nation's sovereignty over the 51-mile waterway, which connects the Pacific Ocean and the Caribbean Sea, will remain unchanged. But he said he would not renew a 2017 memorandum of understanding to join China’s Belt and Road global development initiative and that Panama would instead look to work more closely with the U.S.
"I think this visit opens the door to build new relations … and try to increase as much as possible U.S. investments in Panama," Mulino told reporters after meeting with Rubio on his first international trip since being confirmed.
This has been confirmed by Rubio, yet apart from Reuters all our main sources remain reluctant to acknowledge the win!
U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio on Monday welcomed Panama's decision to let its participation in China's global infrastructure plan expire, calling the move "a great step forward" for its ties with the United States.
The “TrumpFather”–a lot of people seem to let him get away with his mobster affectations.
But that's ok for me to say…there are hundreds if not thousands in some genuine fear of their lives in the US following his return. If John Bolton and others of that ilk are on his revenge list who would be safe?
That list includes “gender, transgender, pregnant person, pregnant people, LGBT, transsexual, non-binary, nonbinary, assigned male at birth, assigned female at birth, biologically male, biologically female,” Inside Medicine, citing the email, reported.
Back to binary, folks! No tertiary category will be used officially. Real people will be allocated official categories on the basis of biology. Identitarians will prevail?
Back to reality folks. Real people have real categories based on the binary reality of human sex. And nobody is "assigned" anything at birth except a collection of sexist stereotypes tied up in a pink or blue ribbon.
If the terms assigned male at birth, assigned female at birth are not used, how will they discuss such cases (those not of the biological sex) in research?
Maybe the term classified. We use this term, from observation of certain characteristics. The word assigned suggests something random, or how the drill sergeant would assign a new recruit to potato peeling duties
Sure, some term would be required. Usually the "classification" would be for social reasons as the child would not have the same genitalia as others – but then comes puberty (and the issue returns of difference returns in the outward appearance).
do you mean research on trans people? It would depend on the research.
Obviously medical research would need to know if the person was female or male.
If it was social research, then use the term trans man or trans woman (and define that in the research brief and paper).
The problem we have at the moment isn't lack of language, it's ideological enforcement. The liberals enforced one set, they can 't really complain when the conservatives do the same. This is a superb example of the principle that you have to bring society with you, and that forcing people to think like you doesn't work.
Fortunately, left wing gender critical feminists, and others who are both gc and progressive, had been discussion these issues for a long time and have solutions. At some point the left should stop ostracising us and engage in an open manner and see if we can't find a better way than the left and right identitarians.
There are additional issues. Trans people with marked gender dysphoria have a need to not be reminded of their biological sex, and to have their chosen gender identity affirmed. This seems reasonable, and it's also reasonable that society places limits on that. eg people should be registered with their GP as their biological sex (and additionally their gender id if they choose). It also matters when it comes to women's spaces and similar issues.
There also appear to be trans women whose identity is around being affirmed as a woman because of their sexual fetish eg autogynephilia. They were formerly known as cross dressing men. They are particularly problematic for women, and we should be having an open public discussion about where the boundaries are. But at the moment, thanks to liberals, people with AGP are allowed to self identify as trans and into women's spaces. They tend to have a particular sense of male entitlement similar to other men, disrespectful of women.
Research has been done on AGP, someone could look up what terms were used.
I agree. Trump doesn't seem to have factored in Differences of Sex Development. He doesn't seem to care.
The term "assigned female/male at birth" was initially used for people with DSDs, whose sex was incorrectly identified and recorded at birth. These are largely males with atypical genetalia and the conditions are mostly identified at birth or puberty, especially in wealthier communities & countries.
The gender ID movement appropriated the term, which many DSD people and organisations are not happy about.
Trump has also made these EOs in a way that seems to make transgender IDed people a target. But, I don't think he really cares about people with DSDs, people whose bodies have had some of their sex characteristics altered medically and/or surgically, or about females.
I think giving primacy to biological sex over gender identity, is good, but the way Trump is going about enforcing those definitions is not good at all.
Back to binary, folks! No tertiary category will be used officially. Real people will be allocated official categories on the basis of biology. Identitarians will prevail?
you really are missing the politics here Dennis. There are whole swathes of people who now support Trump, who didn't before, because of this issue. Stop and think about why that is.
Biology matters. Try reading Jane Clare Jones who spells out the connection between denial of material reality and the ecological crisis.
There are whole swathes of people who now support Trump, who didn't before, because of this issue.
… Try reading Jane Clare Jones who spells out the connection between denial of material reality and the ecological crisis.
Weka, when you say "whole swathes of people who now support Trump" "because of this issue" [that sex in humans is binary?], what might "whole swathes of people" mean as a number or percentage of US voters?
And do you believe a similar proportion of Kiwis might have been swayed to cast their votes for conservative political parties based on "this issue"?
And would it be unreasonable to suggest that a majority of Trunp supporters are in denial about the polycrisis? If the Trump administration can "erase terms including gender, transgender, pregnant person, LGBT, transsexual and nonbinary", then maybe the polycrisis is similarly erasable – just imagine what a strongman like Trump can do with whole swathes of people supporting him.
I used the term support, not vote, but few organisations are counting this issue well, so my guess is that there is almost no reliable data on voting choices in the US or NZ.
But here's the crunch: it's very difficult to do such research when it might cost you your career. No Debate means we have no debate and that included no data. Not just voter patterns, but attitudes or societal shifts. We don't have good data on transition and detransition for the same reason.
What I do know is that I've spent 7 years watching this dynamic unfold. Women being radicalised because liberals said women can't have our own rape crisis or toilets any more and if we want them we are bigots. That includes women in the UK and the US, and women in NZ, including on TS.
There are women like myself who are left in our bones and who understood that women's rights couldn't be attained by moving rightwards. But we are in the minority. The liberal left have ostracised us, so the great work being done on these issues by left wing GCFs is not well known.
'Last year just 8 per cent of Britons said they paid a lot of attention to trans issues and as many said that trans people face significant prejudice as said the same of disabled people. And those paying the greatest attention to media coverage of trans rights are people who are more supportive of them than opposed'.
And the UK is a hot-spot for anti-trans/culture wars electioneering. There was that senior Tory official who claimed the 'trans debate would win the election' for them. Ha.
There have been some polls that show that last year both Democrat and Republican voters became more opposed to trans IDed males in sport (a big issue in the US), in bathrooms, etc.
YouGov on bathrooms: the Independent vote is significant because it may have shifted enough swing voters to make a difference.
"Of the 1,025 people who identified as Democrats or leaning Democrat, 67% said transgender athletes should not be allowed to compete with women."
I think this is a conservative Christian group – Concerned Women for America (CWA) exit poll:
"found 70% of voters indicated transgender issues were an important factor in deciding their vote."
"Hispanic men carried the largest demographic of voters who found the issue important in their voting choice (84%). In 10 key states, Hispanic men and women were Trump’s largest voter gain."
Quite right – happy to change “US voters” to ‘US supporters’ [of Trump] in para 1, and “cast their votes for ” to ‘support’ [for NZ conservative parties] in para 2.
The liberal left have ostracised us, so the great work being done on these issues by left wing GCFs is not well known.
So how might "ostracised" (left andright-wing) gender critical feminists and activists get more publicity for their great work?
Women being radicalised because liberals said women can't have our own rape crisis or toilets any more…
Have liberal lefties really been saying that – for seven years? Not this lefty, but if so, then for all the debates – culture wars even – such comments stir up, there seems little appetite for implementation in NZ.
Just like Williamson’s carefully chosen words, the words in Peters’ tweet are carefully chosen. Among the “‘atta boy, common sense, I remember when men were men and women were women” framing is a signal that amplifies a fringe concern. It sanctions that concern and all the division it causes on a platform where it will get enough unregulated airtime to satiate and encourage those who want it to be a mainstream concern. If people are looking for cues to dress up their prejudice against an already marginalised group of people as socially acceptable behaviour, there they are, sanctioned by no less than the deputy prime minister of our country.
…
The debate is frequently given oxygen on social media and is a direct import of tactics deployed by politicians in the fanning of culture war flames around the world.
…
I think it’s perfectly fine for people to be asking questions about gender and our evolving understanding of it. It’s fine to be confused. It’s fine not to have all the answers and to not know the right thing to say. The toilet bill and the toilet debate, happening as it is on the worst possible platform for encouraging thoughtful conversation, is not a genuine exercise in advancing our collective knowledge and understanding, it’s a Trojan horse for people’s prejudice. It is a tail flicking at us from interests that don’t represent the majority and we, in the absence of leadership, are a dog being wagged.
there's no such thing as a RW GCF in the way you imply. Kellie Jay Keen is not a feminist. There are centre right GCFs I guess, Helen Joyce being the most notable. Economically conservative, socially liberal, GC, feminist.
I generally use the term GCF to refer to the left and centre left feminists who believe that biological sex is binary and that this matters, and that gender stereotypes harm women. I also think feminists like Joyce are important voices.
In the UK, those feminists have fought a long, hard grass roots campaign, and eventually shifted the MSM on the issue. They also made policy gains in legislation and won legal cases. There are people other than feminists doing this work too.
In NZ, the situation is different. Much smaller population, we don't have the kind of pre-existing grass roots feminist movement that the UK has (what happened to that btw?), and we are more liberal than the UK. Liberal NZ is firmly in the women's spaces are transphobic camp. Hence your Spinoff link.
But, my guess is that if NZ women were asked, the majority would say they want women's spaces. If you look at the yougov polling in the UK, once you shift the question from 'do you support trans rights' to 'do you support trans identified males who haven't surgically transitioned', people's positions become more aligned with GCFs ie supportive of trans rights but not at the expense of women.
But No Debate was incredibly successful, and it hasn't really been broken in NZ. The GC feminists I know here are mostly laying low, or just working steadily on the issues. We still can't have an open, robust debate. Even on TS, one of the few places online where debate has been held, is now in a kind of stasis.
One consequence of No Debate in NZ is this:
1. GC policy is being advanced by conservatives
2. GCF voices aren't being heard, so there is a dearth of progressive GC voices*
3. Liberals like Rawhiti-Connel are free to distort the debate in similar ways as Peters and co.
4. Women will increasingly say fuck off, as they come to realise what it means
*I'm generalising, WRP and SUFW in particular continue to do good work.
Have liberal lefties really been saying that – for seven years? Not this lefty, but if so, then for all the debates – culture wars even – such comments stir up, there seems little appetite for implementation in NZ.
Sure, and not this liberal lefty either. I was talking policy and positioning. If. you doubt what I say, stand up and talk about women's spaces in any progressive space in NZ and see what happens (seriously though, don't do that).
And I was referencing other countries. I've been following the UK GCFs for that long, I watched liberals (including NZ ones) allow rape and violence memes against terfs online in that time, I saw women lose jobs, careers, get arrested for tweets.
There are places in the UK now where there are no Rape Crisis centres that provide women only services. What do you think NZ women would do if they knew that was happening here? Why don’t they know?
Sure, and not this liberal lefty either. I was talking policy and positioning. If. you doubt what I say, stand up and talk about women's spaces in any progressive space in NZ and see what happens (seriously though, don't do that).
I regard TS as a progressive 'space' in NZ. My current view on the need for (maintaining) women-only (safe) spaces in NZ has been informed by what I read here, and I don't remember anyone challenging me when I stated my view, except perhaps a few Standandistas who thought I wasn't articulating that view correctly or strongly enough.
There are places in the UK now where there are no Rape Crisis centres that provide women only services.
I was unaware of that. How have UK women / women's groups responded to this (new?) lack of women-only services in (some) Rape Crisis centres?
Support all that Weka has said. There are women who voted right last year, other who voted left but who were absolutely over the moon when Trump made his pronouncement.
As important & ground breaking as a changed vote from left to right for womens rights is/would be, the shattering aspect for me is the number of people who won't or can't make the move to vote right and whose decision is to not vote at all.
This may have a flow on to local body elections when we see aspiring national (small 'n') politicans being inspected for anti women sentiment eg Katrina Biggs has kept followers on X up to date with the moves to allow men into women's dressing rooms in Christchurch espoused by Phil Mauger's council. Mauger is centre-right so it's a fair old mix up .
We/the women may just slide away……will we ever hear from them again?
And would it be unreasonable to suggest that a majority of Trunp supporters are in denial about the polycrisis? If the Trump administration can "erase terms including gender, transgender, pregnant person, LGBT, transsexual and nonbinary", then maybe the polycrisis is similarly erasable – just imagine what a strongman like Trump can do with whole swathes of people supporting him.
Of course. This is such an obviousness, I'm not sure what your point is. Would you mind stating it directly?
This is such an obviousness, I'm not sure what your point is. Would you mind stating it directly?
Not sure I have a point – just musing on the human ability to pick and choose which 'realities' to believe, be it the polycrisis (very important) or self-ID (important to some individuals; not very important in the greater scheme of things – just my opinion), and how we enable stromgmen to erase and/or ignore complex and challenging 'realities' – Keep It Simple Stupid!
I'm confident I'm not missing the dimensional drivers of the trend. Realism has two sides: binary people cling to their tradition while trans people know they don't belong in the binary. Denial of trans reality is silly and cannot prevail socially. The principle of biodiversity applies. Yet it's also true that nature features dyads, and male/female is the dyad of reproduction. That's realistic.
So we must transcend the binary by allowing trans to be realised as an evolutionary option (despite the dead-end it becomes for some who adopt it), and acknowledge that the binary is real for most of us. Both/and logic applies!
Re JCJ, I found this:
Those committed to the belief in innate gender identity – while simultaneously denying that it is a belief, and hence that other people are entitled not to share it – will only interpret ideological non-compliance on this issue as “hatred of trans people,” and feel fully justified in punishing all detractors for their wickedness
It nicely illustrates how people create barriers to sharing reality, which effectively isolate a social group from another, and fixate on the dichotomy instead of anchoring on common ground.
"I have no doubt Jesse Thorn is a decent man who wants to do the best for his child. But while transactivists lauded him for trying to hold Webb to account, what I heard was an act of ideological coercion, and a signature example of how mandating belief in gender identity is destroying public discourse."
This is akin to weka mentioning No Debate. Tis still alive and well.
I'm confident I'm not missing the dimensional drivers of the trend. Realism has two sides: binary people cling to their tradition while trans people know they don't belong in the binary. Denial of trans reality is silly and cannot prevail socially. The principle of biodiversity applies. Yet it's also true that nature features dyads, and male/female is the dyad of reproduction. That's realistic.
Um, material reality exists whether humans do or not, and whether humans think about shit or not. Material reality doesn't have two sides, it just is. All humans are one of two sexes.
If you are talking about philosophy, then there are more than two sides on the issue of binaryness, this is my point.
There are the people who believe that the binary nature of sex matters and should be enforced via gender stereotypes (fundamental conservatives).
There are people who believe that the binary nature of sex matters because material reality matters, but gender stereotypes suck (gender critical feminists and other progressive gender critical people)
There are people who believe that biological sex is a construct, that it can be changed, and that gender identity trumps biological sex.
There's more than that, but you get my point. My comment above was about the numbers of women for whom being female matters a great deal and who will side with that over liberal left politics. Understanding why is crucial to the left making gains. To frame the dynamic as two sides missed the point.
So we must transcend the binary by allowing trans to be realised as an evolutionary option (despite the dead-end it becomes for some who adopt it), and acknowledge that the binary is real for most of us. Both/and logic applies!
maybe. There's a pretty strong feminist argument that gender identity (as we currently do it) is harmful. Some people say they have no gender identity.
I have commented here in the past a few times in support of the feminist position. I don't claim any competence around gender since I grew up back when it was used as a simile for sex and haven't encountered any explanation of difference that stuck in my mind (I do recall reading one of yours once that I thought at the time clarified it nicely – but retain no memory of the details due to being ancient!)
This is a twitter thread by a US human evolution biologist, Carole Hooven. She would not agree with you. The thread is a copy of the email responses she sent to The Guardian journalist who asked her views on Trump’s sex/gender EO.
"TLDR: I provided her with plenty of scientific evidence/argument/detailed commentary in answer to her questions about Trump's executive order (YES it is scientifically sound) and the idea that everyone starts out female (UNsound). All of that was ignored, which is not unusual."
What is the "biodiverse" reality that you refer to re transgender IDed people?
There are only 2 sexes. Within each sex there is a great deal of diversity. However, all but an infinitesimal amount of people have a male or a female reproductive system, which is full integrated within the whole anatomy. This creates important differences between males and females that need to be acknowledged.
Transgender IDed people include a vast range of different people, including differences between male & female sex differences. Some trans people take opposite sex hormones and have surgeries that modify their bodies. Others ID as transmen or transwomen without any medical or surgical intervention.
Whereas evolution works via mutation & selection (theory), male & female are the norms that enable reproduction. Those who are attracted to same sex don't reproduce unless they are also bisexual & do the normal thing.
That makes 3 obvious categories: male/female/whatever. Trans has become the culturally-endorsed category for whatever but there are various sub-categories that have become popular in recent years/decades. Nature makes all, but there's a cultural warping also evident with some folk. I here use the word warp in a technical non-condemnatory sense. So nature provides biodiversity within humans as a spectrum, which is our collective reality.
Traditionalists & conservatives go instead with the paradigm that socially conditioned them when young: male/female. It's their reality.
I'm having difficulty following your argument. Many lesbians and some gay men have children, eg through reproductive technologies these days. But, also many lesbian follow social pressures when young, get into heterosexual relationships, even though they are not attracted to men. Furthermore, many heterosexual humans choose not to have children – and the numbers seem to be growing in younger generations these days.
But what does that have to do with trans identified people, who indeed are strongly influenced by various cultural, and sexual experiences in the way they come to ID as trans? Each individual's story is a bit different thought there are some common themes.
Male and female aren't norms. They are sexes, which are reproductive systems and all but an infinitesimal amount of humans have either a male or female reproductive system. The results are a cluster of differences between human males and females. There is no spectrum with gradations between being male and female; it is not like some genetic rainbow spectrum where one colour gradually fades into the next.
Yes, culture has a role in how each human understands him/herself, and sex-based, culturally-constructed stereotypes have a lot of influence how we view ourselves. Many of us call that 'gender' ( a term derived from linguistics, not biological reality).
Many trans IDed people have mothered or fathered children, so I'm not sure where your connection with childless lesbians and gays relates to them.
And this is a review of Scott Newgent's biography, about how lesbian mother, Kellie King, transitioned medically and surgically to transman, Scott Newgent. Now Scott puts that drive down to homophobia, and now still sees herself as female and a lesbian, but continues to the external appearance of being like a man. Plus she had early childhood trauma, and was raped as a teenager.
Both Debbie and Scott don't really care about what pronouns people use for them, and both are not concerned about being 'dead-named'.
These are not in some "whatever" category that is neither male nor female. Sex (male or female) is not the same as socially constructed 'gender'.
My view encompasses all that you describe so well. Perhaps my framing seems too simplistic: one's personal framings are aesthetic choices, and I prioritise communicating complex topics is simply as possible to optimise comprehension. Doesn't mean anyone else necessarily gets my intended meaning, just that it ups the odds of success.
In essence, use metaphysics to discern the metapattern. The spectrum runs from 0 to 1. Sex is the two natural numbers 0 & 1 used as symbols to represent male & female. All fractions in between them are available to users to represent their self-identity in the sex category.
If it helps, take heed of how this metapattern is used in quantum computing, where the functional design of the tech system selects a value between 0 & 1 (false & true) as answer to a binary question into what's real.
In my view this is the same mental process that our minds use when making a decision of what to do. Shakespeare made Hamlet say to be or not to be but we are no longer limited to that binary. Trans folk live accordingly.
$21 billion was returned to victims of financial fraud and abuse. Of course the billionaires want it gone.
//
President Donald Trump on Monday appointed Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent as the acting director of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, a powerful watchdog agency whose operations Bessent immediately halted pending a review.
In an email to agency staff sent from the “acting director,” Bessent ordered the bureau to cease all work to craft regulations, enforce its rules, conduct investigations or provide “public communications of any type,” citing a need to “promote consistency” with the goals of the new administration, according to a copy obtained by The Washington Post.
Those nice billionaires will acquire debt at cents in the dollar.
/
A government-wide hiring freeze has led the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. to yank job offers to more than 200 new examiners, the front-line employees who closely monitor banks to ensure they operate safely and adhere to an extensive rule book.
The FDIC is already facing a staffing challenge, particularly with a lack of examiners, undermining its ability to reduce the risk of bank failures. A chronic shortage of examiners contributed to the failure of Signature Bank, one of three large banks to collapse in 2023, the agency has said.
Though the FDIC historically operates independently of the White House, it is complying with the freeze, which President Donald Trump announced through an executive order last week. The move demonstrates the extent to which financial policy is increasingly set by the party in control of the White House.
Wrote a thing warning people to expect a "Twitter Files" redux, of "The Government Files" in which Elon's dumbest fans will make a bunch of blatantly false conspiracy theory claims, he'll find some credulous "reporter" to repeat them, and people will believe it: http://www.techdirt.com/2025/02/03/t...
Remember the Twitter Files? That carefully orchestrated “exposé” where incredibly gullible hand-picked journalists were given selective access to internal documents to manufacture misleading outrage about Twitter’s content moderation?
Get ready for the government edition.
[…]
So, consider this a blaring warning: we’re going to see a bunch of false and misleading nonsense pushed by Elon and his crew, claiming all sorts of waste, fraud, and abuse. Most of it won’t actually be any of those things. Much of it will actually be important (sometimes life-saving) programs. They may stumble upon actual problems — those always exist. But they’re going to destroy hugely consequential elements of US infrastructure to get there.
And then we’re going to be lied to about it all by dimwit reporters for years on end.
The Twitter Files were just the dress rehearsal. The real performance is about to begin, and this time, the damage won’t be limited to content moderation decisions at one social media platform — it threatens to undermine crucial government functions from international aid to public health infrastructure.
His first reel, "How dumb are Aussies?" skewered the decisions of successive governments that he said allowed corporations to "rip off" Australia over its natural resources.
It compared Australia's comparatively tiny tax revenue on oil and gas in the 2022-23 financial year ($2.6 billion) to that of Qatar's expectations that year ($76b) and Norway's take ($133.8b) in the year to December 2023, despite Australia being among the world's biggest natural gas exporters.
In less than 12 months he has amassed about 330,000 followers on Instagram, set up a website and a podcast that has been joined by several politicians, and has "patrons" backing him financially.
He has also raised more than $80,000 to erect billboards across the country ahead of the federal election – a move that is sure to cause a few headaches for all sides of government – as he continues to highlight Australia's comparatively small gas royalties… University of Adelaide media lecturer Caitlin Adams said satire was an "effective vehicle" for social and political commentary… "The Onion, for example, was first an offline satire newspaper before it gained popularity online," Ms Adams said.
Guerilla politics was invented by the yippies circa 1971 when Jerry Rubin's Do It hit the bookshops (bought brand new by me). Nike, much later, recycled that slogan. Street theatre was the style of the times. Online peer pressure is the current form.
Friendly Jordies rips into Gena Rhinehardt, the richest woman in Australia and doyen of the mining industry, talking to the poor mining industry late last year. The industry been hit by taxation enforcement and pressure to unionise by the current Labor state and federal governments.
Start from 20 mins, Jordie is both funny and informative:
When Gena advocates for an Oz DOGE department: "Elon musk's ideology seems to be centered entirely around reading Ayn Rand when he was 15, so… it's the same thing that all those like libertarian types in the US have of 'yes yes I will counter Das Capital with Fountain Head'…it's a fantasy book, it's like saying here's my view of the world have you read Harry Potter 4 yeah I'm going to base my political leanings off of… fighting evil with magic'."
The points in this about the rip-off by the Oz industry, with PROFITS of $250 bi last year, and probably around 10% of that contributed in tax.
‘The JP Morgan Chase chief economist.. said: “This weekend’s actions challenge our underlying view that the Trump administration will strive to limit disruptive policies as it balances its desire to reduce engagement with the world with a commitment to support US businesses.
“In short, the risk is that the policy mix is tilting (perhaps unintentionally) into a business-unfriendly stance.”
Interislander replacement: Government begins global hunt for ferry builder
Rail Minister Winston Peters has this morning announced it has started a worldwide search for two medium-sized ships, and will engage with international ship builders that can deliver the ferries by 2029.
Worldwide. I wonder if that includes a certain ship builder in…Korea?Would be so fkn Ironic if they were the solution ? Also of course so very unlikely as…Willis and Co could not ever admit their screw up.
"This will narrow the list of potential ship builders to those able to strike a deal, ensuring no time is wasted when we issue the ship specifications later this year," he said.
People are following government advice and fleeing Santorini in Greece, after an increasing swarm of quakes, and . More than 30 > 4 magnitude tremors in the past 3 days. Santorini itself is the rim of a huge caldera, and the site of the cataclysmic earthquake that destroyed the Minoans.
Government to sell 1000 – 2000 state houses – John Key
And revisiting the past. Same old Nat modus….nothing changes.
Labour leader Andrew Little says the Government's plan for social housing is about looking after National's "private developer mates" rather than fixing the country's housing problem.
Proven
Little said boosting subsidies for state house tenants to move into the private rental market would push up prices, affecting all renters.
Housing Action Christchurch has been set up to oppose the sell off.
Its spokesperson, Sheena Dickson, said the type of civil disobedience seen in response to the demolition of state homes in Glen Innes could also be seen in Christchurch.
"We hope it doesn't come to that obviously, but yes we will take the action we need to take just to move things forward
Did the state tenants take action? Would they now?
"So you know, we'll be drumming up the state tenants to do the same thing if they feel so passionate about it as we do, watch this space."
The alarm bell ringing in that poll is NZ First scraping just above 5%. Soon Winston will be off the leash (no longer deputy PM, no longer sitting alongside Luxon in the House and playing loyal sidekick).
Then he and Shane Jones will turn the rabble-rousing up to 11. Luxon won't be able to cope. He's already a feeble apologist for his Minister's bigotry, how much worse will it get?
Chewie at BHN (from 1h20) has noticed that the algorithms in FB and even google have changed his feeds in the last week of so to push more rw anti-woke material, and that finding certain stuff is harder, or you have to be more careful to not be shadow-banned for innocuous statements. Meta looks to be pivot to a more partisan pro-Trump approach.
Time to change to bluesky and nsearch engines like duckduckgogo.
An effect of Meta's removal of fact-checking and switch to a community notes model for policing objectional material is to shift the algorithm. This article backgrounds how Meta's political bias setting has changed over the years.
‘But then last year, Meta started to change its tune, with Zuckerberg penning a letter to Congress in which he expressed regret over his company’s decision to censor COVID vaccine misinformation, at the behest of Biden administration officials, and the mistaken blocking of a New York Post story about Hunter Biden’s laptop.
At that stage, Trump looked to be gaining in the polls, on the way to his subsequent re-election. That could be coincidental timing, but it did seem like Zuckerberg may have been setting the table for last week’s switch-up based on the poll projections.
Also of note, Trump had threatened to jail Zuckerberg for life if he was ever re-elected, due to what he viewed as political overreach by Facebook in suspending his account.’
Not quite a "get out of jail free card" , but free carbon credits for..these polluters?!
Climate Change Commission backs 'reviewing' free carbon credits for big polluters
The Climate Change Commission has given support to a campaign to end free carbon credits for big polluters such as Methanex, Rio Tinto and NZ Steel.
In a letter released overnight, the independent body pointed to serious problems with the subsidy scheme, after MPs asked it to comment on a 6000-signature petition before Parliament.
The 'Don't Subsidise Pollution' petition seeks an end to hundreds of millions of dollars in free carbon credits given each year to manufacturer/exporters under the Emissions Trading Scheme.
Greens claim they can better NZ's emissions reductions five-fold and improve the economy
Party co-leader Chlöe Swarbrick said acting in the best interest of both the environment and the economy was possible.
"Our plan outlines an economy that supports people and the planet, instead of exploiting and exhausting both.
"That means a Green Jobs Guarantee, planting native trees instead of pine, efficient public transport, sustainable food production, restoring our wetlands, designing our cities better, distributed and resilient renewable energy, real just transition plans led by local communities, and so much more.
"He Ara Anamata not only reduces the cost of living, but increases quality of life. A better world is possible, and this is how we build it."
Tomorrow afternoon, if things go really really badly, I may find myself down to one eye. People who used to sneer at me on Twitter will no doubt say So what's changed? Nothing, that's what, you one-eyed lefty.I don’t mean to be dramatic, it’s just a routine bit of cataract ...
A few weeks ago an invitation dropped into my email inbox to attend a joint Treasury/Motu seminar on recent, rather major, changes that had apparently been made to the discount rates used by The Treasury to evaluate proposals from government agencies. It was all news to me, but when ...
All your life is Time magazineI read it tooWhat does it mean?PressureI'm sure you'll have some cosmic rationaleBut here you are with your faithAnd your Peter Pan adviceYou have no scars on your faceAnd you cannot handle pressureSongwriter: Billy Joel.Christopher Luxon is under pressure from all sides. The reviews are ...
After seeing yet-more-months of political debate and policy decisions to ‘go for growth’ by pulling the same old cheap migration and cheap tourism levers without nearly-enough infrastructure, or any attempt to address the same old lack of globally conventional tax incentives for investment, I thought it would be worth issuing ...
The plans for the buildings that will replace the downtown carpark have been publicly notified giving us the first detailed glance at what is proposed for one of the biggest and best development sites in the city centre. The council agreed to sell the site to Precinct Properties for $122 ...
With the Reserve Bank expected today to return the Official Cash Rate to where it was in mid-2022 comes a measure of how much of a psychological impact the rate has. Federated Farmers has published its latest six-monthly farm confidence survey, which shows that profit expectations have fallen and risen ...
Kiwis Disallowed From Waiting Lists Based on Arbitrary MeasuresWellington hospital are now rejecting patients from specialist waiting lists due to BMI (body mass index).This article from Rachel Thomas for The Post says it all (emphasis mine):A group of Porirua GPs are sounding alarm bells after patients with body mass indexes ...
The Prime Minister says he's really comfortable with us not knowing the reoffending rate for his boot camp programme.They asked him for it at yesterday’s press conference, and he said, nah, not telling, have to respect people's privacy.Okay I'll bite. Let's say they release this information to us:The rate of ...
Warning 1: There is a Nazi theme at the end of this article related to the disabled community. Warning 2: This article could be boring!One day, last year, I excitedly opened up a Substack post that was about how to fight back, and the answer at the end was disappointing ...
This may be rhetorical but here goes: did any of you invest in the $Libra memecoin endorsed and backed by Argentine president and darling of the global Right Javier Milei (who admitted to being paid a fee for his promotion of the token)? You know, the one that soared above ...
Last week various of the great and good of New Zealand economics and public policy trooped off to Hamilton (of all places) for the annual Waikato Economics Forum, one of the successful marketing drives of university’s Vice-Chancellor. My interest was in the speeches delivered by the Minister of Finance and ...
The Prime Minister says the Government would be open to sending peacekeepers to Ukraine if a ceasefire was reached. The government has announced a $30 million spend on tourism infrastructure and biodiversity projects, including $11m spent to improve popular visitor sites and further $19m towards biodiversity efforts. A New Zealand-born ...
This is a re-post from The Climate Brink by Andrew Dessler “But what about when the sun doesn't shine?!” Ah yes, the energy debate’s equivalent of “The Earth is flat!” Every time someone mentions solar or wind power, some self-proclaimed energy expert emerges from the woodwork to drop this supposedly devastating truth bomb: ...
This post by Nicolas Reid was originally published on Linked in. It is republished here with permission.In this article I look into data on how well the rail network serve New Zealanders, and how many people might be able to travel by train… if we ran more than a ...
Hi,Before we get into Hayden Donnell’s new column about how yes, Donald Trump is definitely the Antichrist, I wanted to touch on something feral that happened in New Zealand last week.Members of Destiny Church pushed and punched their way into an Auckland library, apparently angry it was part of Pride ...
Despite delays, logjams and overcrowding in our emergency departments, funding constraints are limiting the numbers of nurses and doctors being trained. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāLong stories short, the top six things in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty on Tuesday, February 18 are:A NZ Herald investigation ...
Now that the US has ripped up the Atlantic alliance, Europe is more vulnerable now than at any time since the mid-1930s. Apparently, Europe and Ukraine itself will not have a seat at the table in the talks between US President Donald Trump and Russian leader Vladimir Putin that will ...
Olivia and Noah and Hana are going to the library!It is fun to go to the library. It has books and songs and mat time and people who smile at you and say, Hello Olivia, what have you been doing this morning?The library is more fun than the mall. At ...
New World Orders: The challenge facing Christopher Luxon and Chris Hipkins is how to keep their small and vulnerable nation safe and stable in a world whose economic and political climate the forty-seventh American president is changing so profoundly.IT IS, SURELY, the ultimate Millennial revenge fantasy. Calling senior Baby-Boomer and Gen-X ...
“This might surprise you, Laurie, but I reckon Trump’s putting on a bloody impressive performance.”“GOODNESS ME, HANNAH, just look at all those Valentine’s Day cards!”“Occupational hazard, Laurie, the more beer I serve, the more my customers declare their undying love!”“Crikey! I had no idea business was so good.” Laurie squinted ...
In 2005, Labour repealed the long-standing principle of birthright citizenship in Aotearoa. Why? As with everything else Labour does, it all came down to austerity: "foreign mothers" were supposedly "coming to this country to give birth", and this was "put[ting] pressure on hospitals". Then-Immigration Minister George Hawkins explicitly gave this ...
And I just hope that you can forgive usBut everything must goAnd if you need an explanation, nationThen everything must goSongwriters: James Dean Bradfield / Sean Anthony Moore / Nicholas Allen Jones.Today, I’d like to talk about a couple of things that happened over the weekend:Brian Tamaki’s Library Invasion and ...
New reporting highlights how Brooke van Velden refuses to meet with the CTU but is happy to meet with fringe Australian-based unions. Van Velden is pursuing reckless changes to undermine the personal grievance system against the advice of her own officials. Engineering New Zealand are saying that hundreds of engineers ...
The NZCTU strongly supports the Employment Relations (Employee Remuneration Disclosure) Amendment Bill. This Bill represents a positive step towards addressing serious issues around unlawful disparities in pay by protecting workers’ rights to discuss their pay and conditions. This Bill also provides welcome support for helping tackle the prevalent gender and ...
Years of hard work finally paid off last week as the country’s biggest and most important transport project, the City Rail Link reached a major milestone with the first test train making its way slowly though the tunnels for the first time. This is a fantastic achievement and it is ...
Engineers are pleading for the Government to free up funds to restart stalled projects. File Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāLong stories short, the top six things in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty on Monday, February 17 are:Engineering New Zealand CEO Richard Templer said yesterday hundreds of ...
It’s one of New Zealand’s great sustaining myths: the spirit of ANZAC, our mates across the ditch, the spirit of Earl’s Court, Antipodeans united against the world. It is also a myth; it is not reality. That much was clear from a series of speakers, including a former Australian Prime ...
Many people have been unsatisfied for years that things have not improved for them, some as individuals, many more however because their families are clearly putting in more work, for less money – and certainly far less purchase on society. This general discontent has grown exponentially since the GFC. ...
A listing of 34 news and opinion articles we found interesting and shared on social media during the past week: Sun, February 9, 2025 thru Sat, February 15, 2025. This week's roundup is again published soleley by category. We are still interested in feedback to hone the categorization, so if ...
The Salvation Army’s State of the Nation report shows worsening food poverty and housing shortages mean more than 400,000 people now need welfare support, the highest level since the 1990s. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāLong stories short, the top six things in our political economy around housing, climate and ...
You're just too too obscure for meOh you don't really get through to meAnd there's no need for you to talk that wayIs there any less pessimistic things to say?Songwriters: Graeme DownesToday, I thought we’d take a look at some of the most cringe-inducing moments from last week, but don’t ...
Please note: I’ve delayed my “What can we do?” article for this video.The video above shows Destiny Church members assaulting staff and librarians as they pushed through to a room of terrified parents and young children.It was posted to social media last night.But if you read Sinead Boucher’s Stuff, you ...
Skeptical Science is partnering with Gigafact to produce fact briefs — bite-sized fact checks of trending claims. You can submit claims you think need checking via the tipline. Is sea level rise exaggerated? Sea levels are rising at an accelerating rate, not stagnating or decreasing. Warming global temperatures cause land ice ...
Here is a scenario, but first a historical parallel. Hitler and the Nazis could well have accomplished everything that they wanted to do within German borders, including exterminating Jews, so long as they confined their ambitious to Germany itself. After all, the world pretty much sat and watched as the ...
I’ve spent the last couple of days in Hamilton covering Waikato University’s annual NZ Economics Forum, where (arguably) three of the most influential people in our political economy right now laid out their thinking in major speeches about the size and role of Government, their views on for spending, tax ...
Simeon Brown’s Ideology BentSimeon Brown once told Kiwis he tries to represent his deep sense of faith by interacting “with integrity”.“It’s important that there’s Christians in Parliament…and from my perspective, it’s great to be a Christian in Parliament and to bring that perspective to [laws, conversations and policies].”And with ...
Severe geological and financial earthquakes are inevitable. We just don’t know how soon and how they will play out. Are we putting the right effort into preparing for them?Every decade or so the international economy has a major financial crisis. We cannot predict exactly when or exactly how it will ...
Questions1. How did Old Mate Grabaseat describe his soon-to-be-Deputy-PM’s letter to police advocating for Philip Polkinghorne?a.Ill-advisedb.A perfect letterc.A letter that will live in infamyd.He had me at hello2. What did Seymour say in response?a.What’s ill-advised is commenting when you don’t know all the facts and ...
NZCTU Te Kauae Kaimahi President Richard Wagstaff has called on OJI Fibre Solutions to work with the government, unions, and the community before closing the Kinleith Paper Mill. “OJI has today announced 230 job losses in what will be a devastating blow for the community. OJI needs to work with ...
NZCTU Te Kauae Kaimahi President Richard Wagstaff is sounding the alarm about the latest attack on workers from Minister of Workplace Relations and Safety Brooke van Velden, who is ignoring her own officials to pursue reckless changes that would completely undermine the personal grievance system. “Brooke van Velden’s changes will ...
Hi,When I started writing Webworm in 2020, I wrote a lot about the conspiracy theories that were suddenly invading our Twitter timelines and Facebook feeds. Four years ago a reader, John, left this feedback under one of my essays:It’s a never ending labyrinth of lunacy which, as you have pointed ...
And if you said this life ain't good enoughI would give my world to lift you upI could change my life to better suit your moodBecause you're so smoothAnd it's just like the ocean under the moonOh, it's the same as the emotion that I get from youYou got the ...
Aotearoa remains the minority’s birthright, New Zealand the majority’s possession. WAITANGI DAY commentary see-saws manically between the warmly positive and the coldly negative. Many New Zealanders consider this a good thing. They point to the unexamined patriotism of July Fourth and Bastille Day celebrations, and applaud the fact that the ...
The podcast above of the weekly ‘Hoon’ webinar for paying subscribers on Thursday night features co-hosts & talking about the week’s news with regular and special guests, including: and on the week in geopolitics, including the latest from Donald Trump’s administration over Gaza and Ukraine; on the ...
Up until now, the prevailing coalition view of public servants was that there were simply too many of them. But yesterday the new Public Service Commissioner, handpicked by the Luxon Government, said it was not so much numbers but what they did and the value they produced that mattered. Sir ...
Photo by Mauricio Fanfa on UnsplashKia oraCome and join us for our weekly ‘Hoon’ webinar with paying subscribers to The Kākā for an hour at 5 pm today.Jump on this link on YouTube Livestream for our chat about the week’s news with myself , plus regular guests and ...
In a moment we explore the question: What is Andrew Bayly wanting to tell ACC, and will it involve enjoying a small wine tasting and then telling someone to fuck off? But first, for context, a broader one: What do we look for in a government?Imagine for a moment, you ...
As expected, Donald Trump just threw Ukraine under the bus, demanding that it accept Russia's illegal theft of land, while ruling out any future membership of NATO. Its a colossal betrayal, which effectively legitimises Russia's invasion, while laying the groundwork for the next one. But Trump is apparently fine with ...
A ballot for a single member's bill was held today, and the following bill was drawn: Employment Relations (Collective Agreements in Triangular Relationships) Amendment Bill (Adrian Rurawhe) The bill would extend union rights to employees in triangular relationships, where they are (nominally) employed by one party, but ...
This is a guest post by George Weeks, reviewing a book called ‘How to Fly a Horse’ by Kevin AshtonBook review: ‘How to Fly a Horse’ by Kevin Ashton (2015) – and what it means for Auckland. The title of this article might unnerve any Greater Auckland ...
This story was originally published by Capital & Main and is part of Covering Climate Now, a global journalism collaboration strengthening coverage of the climate story. Within just a week, the sheer devastation of the Los Angeles wildfires has pushed to the fore fundamental questions about the impact of the climate crisis that have been ...
In this world, it's just usYou know it's not the same as it wasSongwriters: Harry Edward Styles / Thomas Edward Percy Hull / Tyler Sam JohnsonYesterday, I received a lovely message from Caty, a reader of Nick’s Kōrero, that got me thinking. So I thought I’d share it with you, ...
In past times a person was considered “unserious” or “not a serious” person if they failed to grasp, behave and speak according to the solemnity of the context in which they were located. For example a serious person does not audibly pass gas at Church, or yell “gun” at a ...
Long stories short, the top six things in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty on Thursday, February 13 are:The coalition Government’s early 2024 ‘fiscal emergency’ freeze on funding, planning and building houses, schools, local roads and hospitals helped extend and deepen the economic and jobs recession through calendar ...
For obvious reasons, people feel uneasy when the right to be a citizen is sold off to wealthy foreigners. Even selling the right to residency seems a bit dubious, when so many migrants who are not millionaires get turned away or are made to jump through innumerable hoops – simply ...
A new season of White Lotus is nearly upon us: more murder mystery, more sumptuous surroundings, more rich people behaving badly.Once more we get to identify with the experience of the pampered tourist or perhaps the poorly paid help; there's something in White Lotus for all New Zealanders.And unlike the ...
In 2016, Aotearoa shockingly plunged to fourth place in the Transparency International Corruption Perceptions Index. Nine years later, and we're back there again: New Zealand has seen a further slip in its global ranking in the latest Corruption Perceptions Index (CPI). [...] In the latest CPI New Zealand's score ...
1. You’ve started ranking your politicians on how much they respect the rule of law2. You’ve stopped paying attention to those news publications3. You’ve developed a sudden interest in a particular period of history4. More and more people are sounding like your racist, conspiracist uncle.5. Someone just pulled a Nazi ...
Transforming New Zealand: Brian EastonBrian Easton will discuss the above topic at 2/57 Willis Street, Wellington at 5:30pm on Tuesday 26 February at 2/57 Willis Street, WellingtonThe sub-title to the above is "Why is the Left failing?" Brian Easton's analysis is based on his view that while the ...
Salvation Army’s State of the Nation 2025 report highlights falling living standards, the highest unemployment rates since the 1990s and half of all Pacific children going without food. There are reports of hundreds if not thousands of people are applying for the same jobs in the wake of last year’s ...
Mountain Tui is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.Correction: On the article The Condundrum of David Seymour, Luke Malpass conducted joint reviews with Bryce Wilkinson, the architect of the Regulatory Standards Bill - not Bryce Edwards. The article ...
Tomorrow the council’s Transport, Resilience and Infrastructure Committee meet and agenda has a few interesting papers. Council’s Letter of Expectation to Auckland Transport Every year the council provide a Letter of Expectation to Auckland Transport which is part of the process for informing AT of the council’s priorities and ...
All around in my home townThey're trying to track me down, yeahThey say they want to bring me in guiltyFor the killing of a deputyFor the life of a deputySongwriter: Robert Nesta Marley.Support Nick’s Kōrero today with a 20% discount on a paid subscription to receive all my newsletters directly ...
Hi,I think all of us have probably experienced the power of music — that strange, transformative thing that gets under our skin and helps us experience this whole life thing with some kind of sanity.Listening and experiencing music has always been such a huge part of my life, and has ...
Business frustration over the stalled economy is growing, and only 34% of voters are confidentNicola Willis can deliver. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāLong stories short, the top six things in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty on Wednesday, February 12 are:Business frustration is growing about a ...
I have now lived long enough to see a cabinet minister go both barrels on their Prime Minister and not get sacked.It used to be that the PM would have a drawer full of resignations signed by ministers on the day of their appointment, ready for such an occasion. But ...
“The ACT Party can’t be bothered putting an MP on one of the Justice subcommittees hearing submissions on their own Treaty Principles Bill,” Labour Justice Spokesperson Duncan Webb said. ...
The Government’s newly announced funding for biodiversity and tourism of $30-million over three years is a small fraction of what is required for conservation in this country. ...
The Government's sudden cancellation of the tertiary education funding increase is a reckless move that risks widespread job losses and service reductions across New Zealand's universities. ...
National’s cuts to disability support funding and freezing of new residential placements has resulted in significant mental health decline for intellectually disabled people. ...
The hundreds of jobs lost needlessly as a result of the Kinleith Mill paper production closure will have a devastating impact on the Tokoroa community - something that could have easily been avoided. ...
Today Te Pāti Māori MP for Te Tai Tokerau, Mariameno Kapa-Kingi, released her members bill that will see the return of tamariki and mokopuna Māori from state care back to te iwi Māori. This bill will establish an independent authority that asserts and protects the rights promised in He Whakaputanga ...
The Whangarei District Council being forced to fluoridate their local water supply is facing a despotic Soviet-era disgrace. This is not a matter of being pro-fluoride or anti-fluoride. It is a matter of what New Zealanders see and value as democracy in our country. Individual democratically elected Councillors are not ...
Nicola Willis’ latest supermarket announcement is painfully weak with no new ideas, no real plan, and no relief for Kiwis struggling with rising grocery costs. ...
Half of Pacific children sometimes going without food is just one of many heartbreaking lowlights in the Salvation Army’s annual State of the Nation report. ...
The Salvation Army’s State of the Nation report is a bleak indictment on the failure of Government to take steps to end poverty, with those on benefits, including their children, hit hardest. ...
New Zealand First has today introduced a Member’s Bill which would restore decision-making power to local communities regarding the fluoridation of drinking water. The ‘Fluoridation (Referendum) Legislation Bill’ seeks to repeal the Health (Fluoridation of Drinking Water) Amendment Act 2021 that granted centralised authority to the Direct General of Health ...
New Zealand First has introduced a Member’s Bill aimed at preventing banks from refusing their services to businesses because of the current “Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) Framework”. “This Bill ensures fairness and prevents ESG standards from perpetuating woke ideology in the banking sector being driven by unelected, globalist, climate ...
Erica Stanford has reached peak shortsightedness if today’s announcement is anything to go by, picking apart immigration settings piece by piece to the detriment of the New Zealand economy. ...
Our originating document, theTreaty of Waitangi, was signed on February 6, 1840. An agreement between Māori and the British Crown. Initially inked by Ngā Puhi in Waitangi, further signatures were added as it travelled south. The intention was to establish a colony with the cession of sovereignty to the Crown, ...
Te Whatu Ora Chief Executive Margie Apa leaving her job four months early is another symptom of this government’s failure to deliver healthcare for New Zealanders. ...
The Green Party is calling for the Prime Minister to show leadership and be unequivocal about Aotearoa New Zealand’s opposition to a proposal by the US President to remove Palestinians from Gaza. ...
The latest unemployment figures reveal that job losses are hitting Māori and Pacific people especially hard, with Māori unemployment reaching a staggering 9.7% for the December 2024 quarter and Pasifika unemployment reaching 10.5%. ...
Waitangi 2025: Waitangi Day must be community and not politically driven - Shane Jones Our originating document, theTreaty of Waitangi, was signed on February 6, 1840. An agreement between Māori and the British Crown. Initially inked by Ngā Puhi in Waitangi, further signatures were added as it travelled south. ...
Despite being confronted every day with people in genuine need being stopped from accessing emergency housing – National still won’t commit to building more public houses. ...
The Green Party says the Government is giving up on growing the country’s public housing stock, despite overwhelming evidence that we need more affordable houses to solve the housing crisis. ...
Before any thoughts of the New Year and what lies ahead could even be contemplated, New Zealand reeled with the tragedy of Senior Sergeant Lyn Fleming losing her life. For over 38 years she had faithfully served as a front-line Police officer. Working alongside her was Senior Sergeant Adam Ramsay ...
Green Party co-leader Marama Davidson will return to politics at Waitangi on Monday the 3rd of February where she will hold a stand up with fellow co-leader Chlöe Swarbrick. ...
Te Pāti Māori is appalled by the government's blatant mishandling of the school lunch programme. David Seymour’s ‘cost-saving’ measures have left tamariki across Aotearoa with unidentifiable meals, causing distress and outrage among parents and communities alike. “What’s the difference between providing inedible food, and providing no food at all?” Said ...
The Government is doubling down on outdated and volatile fossil fuels, showing how shortsighted and destructive their policies are for working New Zealanders. ...
The Government’s commitment to get New Zealand’s roads back on track is delivering strong results, with around 98 per cent of potholes on state highways repaired within 24 hours of identification every month since targets were introduced, Transport Minister Chris Bishop says. “Increasing productivity to help rebuild our economy is ...
The former Cadbury factory will be the site of the Inpatient Building for the new Dunedin Hospital and Health Minister Simeon Brown says actions have been taken to get the cost overruns under control. “Today I am giving the people of Dunedin certainty that we will build the new Dunedin ...
From today, Plunket in Whāngarei will be offering childhood immunisations – the first of up to 27 sites nationwide, Health Minister Simeon Brown says. The investment of $1 million into the pilot, announced in October 2024, was made possible due to the Government’s record $16.68 billion investment in health. It ...
New Zealand’s strong commitment to the rights of disabled people has continued with the response to an important United Nations report, Disability Issues Minister Louise Upston has announced. Of the 63 concluding observations of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (UNCRPD), 47 will be progressed ...
Resources Minister Shane Jones has launched New Zealand’s national Minerals Strategy and Critical Minerals List, documents that lay a strategic and enduring path for the mineral sector, with the aim of doubling exports to $3 billion by 2035. Mr Jones released the documents, which present the Coalition Government’s transformative vision ...
Firstly I want to thank OceanaGold for hosting our event today. Your operation at Waihi is impressive. I want to acknowledge local MP Scott Simpson, local government dignitaries, community stakeholders and all of you who have gathered here today. It’s a privilege to welcome you to the launch of the ...
Racing Minister, Winston Peters has announced the Government is preparing public consultation on GST policy proposals which would make the New Zealand racing industry more competitive. “The racing industry makes an important economic contribution. New Zealand thoroughbreds are in demand overseas as racehorses and for breeding. The domestic thoroughbred industry ...
Business confidence remains very high and shows the economy is on track to improve, Economic Growth Minister Nicola Willis says. “The latest ANZ Business Outlook survey, released yesterday, shows business confidence and expected own activity are ‘still both very high’.” The survey reports business confidence fell eight points to +54 ...
Enabling works have begun this week on an expanded radiology unit at Hawke’s Bay Fallen Soldiers’ Memorial Hospital which will double CT scanning capacity in Hawke’s Bay to ensure more locals can benefit from access to timely, quality healthcare, Health Minister Simeon Brown says. This investment of $29.3m in the ...
The Government has today announced New Zealand’s second international climate target under the Paris Agreement, Climate Change Minister Simon Watts says. New Zealand will reduce emissions by 51 to 55 per cent compared to 2005 levels, by 2035. “We have worked hard to set a target that is both ambitious ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Alexander Korolev, Senior Lecturer in Politics and International Relations, UNSW Sydney The United States and Russia agreed to work on a plan to end the war in Ukraine at high-level talks in Saudi Arabia this week. Ukrainian and European representatives were pointedly ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Karleen Gribble, Adjunct Professor, School of Nursing and Midwifery, Western Sydney University BaLL LunLa/Shutterstock Sleep is the holy grail for new parents. So no wonder many tired parents are looking for something to help their babies sleep. A TikTok trend claims ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Ranjana Gupta, Senior Lecturer, Accounting Department, Auckland University of Technology Jirsak/Shutterstock The profit made on every breakfast bowl of weet-bix is tax exempt, giving Sanitarium Health Food Company, owned by the Seventh-day Adventist Church, an advantage over other breakfast food companies. ...
A closer look at some of the homegrown talent currently commanding television screens around the globe. The new season of The White Lotus hit our screens this week, and with it a familiar face in New Zealand actor Morgana O’Reilly. To secure a role in one of the world’s most ...
"This is a crisis of the Government’s own making and the unit is another sign of desperation," said PSA acting national secretary Fleur Fitzsimons. ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Francesca Perugia, Senior Lecturer, School of Design and the Built Environment, Curtin University Australia’s housing crisis has created a push for fast-tracked construction. Federal, state and territory governments have set a target of 1.2 million new homes over five years. Increasing housing ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Ash Watson, Scientia Fellow and Senior Lecturer, UNSW Sydney Shutterstock When we’re uncomfortable we say the “vibe is off”. When we’re having a good time we’re “vibing”. To assess the mood we do a “vibe check”. And when the atmosphere in ...
What’s up with the man from Epsom? The leader of the Act Party has been in plenty of headlines in the last two weeks, ranging from a controversial letter to police on behalf of constituent Philip Polkinghorne (written before David Seymour was a minister) to an attempt to drive ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Elise Stephenson, Deputy Director, Global Institute for Women’s Leadership, Australian National University Newly published research has found clear evidence that openly lesbian, gay, bisexual, trans, intersex, and queer+ (LGBTIQ+) Australian politicians were disproportionately targeted with personal abuse on social media at the ...
Gilmore Girls, Schitt’s Creek, even The Vampire Diaries – they’re all set in tight-knit neighbourhoods where everyone knows everyone. So what is it like to actually know your neighbours? My favourite television shows are set in tight-knit neighbourhoods where everyone knows everyone. Characters attend town meetings where they debate local ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Yanyan Hong, PhD Candidate in Communication and Media Studies, University of Adelaide IMDB On the surface, Ne Zha 2: The Sea’s Fury (2025), the sequel to the 2019 Chinese blockbuster Nezha: Birth of the Demon Child, is a high-octane, action-packed and ...
Wellington travellers say their buses are so hot they’re often forced to get off early and walk. Shanti Mathias explores the impact of non-functioning air conditioning on public transport. When Bella, a young professional living in Wellington, thinks about taking the bus, her first thought is “Ugh”. The bus might ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Annette Kroen, Research Fellow Planning and Transport, RMIT University The cleanup is underway in northern Queensland following the latest flooding catastrophe to hit the state. More than 7,000 insurance claims have already been lodged, most of them for inundated homes and other ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Subha Parida, Lecturer in Property, University of South Australia Carl Oberg/Shutterstock Houses and fire do not mix. The firestorm which hit Los Angeles in January destroyed nearly 2,000 buildings and forced 130,000 people to evacuate. The 2019–20 Australian megafires destroyed ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By David Bowman, Professor of Pyrogeography and Fire Science, University of Tasmania Tasmania has been burning for more than two weeks, with no end in sight. Almost 100,000 hectares of bushland in the northwest has burned to date. This includes the Tarkine rainforest ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Martin Loosemore, Professor of Construction Management, University of Technology Sydney This week, the Productivity Commission released its much-awaited report into productivity growth in Australia’s housing construction sector. It wasn’t a glowing appraisal. The commission found physical productivity – the total number ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Pascale Lubbe, Postdoctoral Research Fellow in Molecular Ecology, University of Otago Royal spoonbills are among several new species that have crossed the Tasman and naturalised in New Zealand. JJ Harrison/Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA When people arrived on the shores of Aotearoa ...
Stats NZ’s head is stepping down over the agency’s failure to safeguard census data, and more officials may soon be in the firing line, writes Catherine McGregor in today’s extract from The Bulletin. To receive The Bulletin in full each weekday, sign up here. An ‘absolutely unacceptable’ failure Stats NZ chief ...
Health NZ is under greater government scrutiny, with the new health minister setting up a unit he says will "drive greater accountability and performance". ...
Manurewa Marae acknowledges should have done better at handling completed census forms, following an inquiry into steps government agencies took to protect data. ...
Police failed to protect people from protesters at a high-profile rally and made unlawful arrests at another, the Independent Police Conduct Authority says. ...
Comment: Crypto exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are making it easier for people to invest in cryptocurrencies such as Bitcoin and Ethereum without having to handle digital wallets or private keys. These allow investors to buy and sell cryptocurrency through their regular brokerage accounts.This has opened the door for billions of dollars ...
Two long-awaited reports into alleged personal data misuse, centred on census collection and Covid-19 vaccination efforts at Manurewa Marae, were released yesterday. Here’s what you need to know.“Very sobering reading” was how public service commissioner Sir Brian Roche described his organisation’s long-awaited report into the alleged misuse of census ...
Backbench MPs reached new levels of patsy questions in an extraordinarily dull question time on Tuesday. Echo Chamber is The Spinoff’s dispatch from the press gallery, recapping sessions in the House. Columns are written by politics reporter Lyric Waiwiri-Smith and Wellington editor Joel MacManus. “MPs ask questions to explore key issues ...
The New Zealand Government says the Cook Islands must share more information about the deals it has signed with China, following the release of an ‘action plan’ in the face of protests in the Pacific nation’s capital.The Cook Islands government has also revealed plans to spend $3 million on a ...
I have a plea, a hope, a wish.
We, in the left, have some great writers and opinion shapers.
Obviously the easy clicks are pointing out how poor our current coalition government is. There is lots of low hanging fruit to pick.
But… we need a vision of an alternative. Where a government is there to serve the people first. To set policy that improves our infrastructure and resilience.
Ideas that can unify a splintered left. Where we can ignore essentially petty differences and aim for a bigger prize.
I am neither a great writer, nor an opinion shaper, but I do have some firm and decided ideas on what a left-wing coalition government should be pushing.
Take one idea as an example:
ALL utilities upon which human’s depend MUST be publicly owned.
This means our health system, our water supplies, our energy requirements, our transport systems, our education establishments, our food distribution outlets – all owned and run in the interests of the public.
That leaves plenty of things for the private sector, just not essential things.
It is true that food is a human necessity but I don't think it is a good idea for the state to be in charge of food distribution. The private sector is more efficient.
I have a long association with Cuba where the state heavily subsidises staple food products.
Everyone has a ration book (La Libreta) and hours are spent queueing for items that often run out. I once spent 4 hours in a queue for charcoal for cooking only to just miss out and be told to try again in 2 days.
You have a point about Cuba.
However, you use the term efficient in relation to the private sector. Is that a euphemism for obscene profits as witnessed by the supermarkets?
Excuse the term but we must find a third way for food distribution.
In a food crisis the state would obviously be involved but outside of that private enterprise works better for food distribution.
We grow our own veges mostly and bake sourdough bread and eat little meat so our food bill is low. Fish is free so we eat lots of that.
I was visiting family in Dunedin a few months ago and at the railway farmers market was told that the reason farmers markets are more expensive than supermarkets is the industrial scale at which supermarkets operate.
There was an online supermarket that we bought some items from but they couldn't compete with Pak n Save.
Farmers markets are often expensive due to bourgeois boutique producers pretensions. At our local Far North Kaitaia market, fresh produce is good value, often cheaper than Pak n Slave from small organic and other growers.
That's another way supermarkets continue their evil corporate ways.
Suppliers often sign contracts that forbid the sale of produce locally.
& they pay a pittance to those suppliers.
Our local vege market, just round the corner from a New World, is almost always cheaper, and with prices that mostly are below Pak n Save.
What they don't tend to do is offer North American stone fruit in the middle of winter – we've got to get back to the idea that our fruit is seasonal.
Agree about food, we are being reamed as they are across the ditch by a duopoly. Busting it up benefits everyone with the political will required to do so nowhere to be seen.
Power, water keep public as everyone benefits from that.
More public housing is desperately needed, didnt stop them cancelling 40% of this years so easy to see the coalition priorities once you factor in charter schools corrosive impact.
Australia has a lot more supermarket choice than NZ with Aldi and Metcash along with the big Woolworths and Coles.
Martyn Bradbury suggests setting up a competitor to the NZ duopoly to be jointly owned by the State and Iwi.
This new business would pay staff more and treat suppliers better by paying them more. It would also have cheaper prices than the current duopoly.
I don't agree that we need more public housing. We need more people owning houses.
Aussie may have more choice of suppermarket than we do but that means nothing when there is no choice when you enter the doors. In Melbourne this past week, 37.0 degrees, beer might be good, an IPA or a Hazy, nope only Furphys or Carlton and that at $56 a dozen.
Looking at the list of charter schools opening this year – it's difficult to see the 'corrosive impact'
https://www.stuff.co.nz/nz-news/360568057/what-are-seven-new-charter-schools-opening-week-and-what-are-they-offering
Unless you don't support immersive language, or schools specifically targeting kids who are being failed by the current schooling provisions.
One-size-fits-all just doesn't work for all kids.
Doesn't mean the state can't learn from that and apply itself to those youth.
Surely there is a part of you that is uncomfortable with a profit motive in education?
Well, so far the 'State' has shown minimal ability to learn from any source in education. I have zero confidence that they will do so. More importantly, those parents who have kids who are falling through the cracks have zero confidence in state education.
When we have a previous Minister of Education, turning down an integrated school proposal – specifically directed at neurodiverse learners – because "there are available supports for all learners in existing state schools". It's very clear that the MoE and the education bureaucracy in general are severely out of touch with the on-the-ground reality.
https://thespinoff.co.nz/politics/23-07-2021/chris-hipkins-needs-a-reality-check-on-kids-with-special-learning-needs?amp=
We already have a 'profit-motive in education'. It's called private schooling.
It seems as though the majority of the already-announced charter schools are in a not-for-profit or minimal profit management structure.
I agree with you on this. However I can only speak from my personal experience with the state system. Going from the state school to private/alternative schools opened the doors for me, I’m afraid it’s a bit difficult to explain, but I do remember I would have been 7/8, this wonderful older woman sitting next to me and treating me as a normal person and feeling valued. My reading age went from practically zero to 13 in a few months. So personally I’m all in favour of these different schools
But that is precisely what Erica is imposing on teachers in state schools – a one size fit all approach.
Any teacher of any degree of competence, knows this does not work!
Not sure where this is coming from….
The one area that they have mandated is phonics-based reading – and all of the international research is with them, there. They've also set minimum standards for the amount of 'basics (reading, writing, maths) which should be going on daily/weekly. At the level they've set, every school should be easily complying. If they're not – you have to wonder what they're doing instead.
Can you point to even one state school which is significantly outstripping the expected-at-decile level? I can point to half-a-dozen integrated schools, which regularly do so (have a look at McAuley – delivering results better than state schools two or three deciles higher)
The state system does the same thing at every school – they regard this as a feature, not a bug. And, based on the evidence of the last two decades – across multiple governments, by-and-large does it increasingly badly.
The exceptions are Decile 10 schools like Auckland Grammar – which effectively operate as post-code limited private schools. And are rich enough and well-enough connected to tell the MoE to take a hike.
Well. I went from not reading to over 14 reading level in less than a year. This was with reading recovery in a State school in the 60's. It was using phonics, by the way. Because good teachers have always changed their approach to suit the individual learner.
A successful program which is now being defunded to buy "one size fits all" "structered literacy" materials from some overseas corporate. I wonder which Coalition of Cockups MP's have an interest in that. And what is going to happen to those who the magic one size fits all solution fails. "Sorry, we have no funding for that".
It is obvious the Coalition of cockups is setting up State schools to fail by putting them in an underfunded strait jacket, while giving private schools more freedom and funding to meet students needs.
By the way, Auckland grammer like the charter schools, and private health shoves their failures back on the State system to make their results look better. Whangarei schools are well aware of the kids they have let down.
The goal remains the same. Destroy the State system to make privatisation look better. Force a narrow one size fits all on State schools, while private schools are giving the freedom to teach to best practice, and the funds, State school teachers can only dream about.
Private schooling in the USA, like privatised health, is an abject failure. Only right wing fantacists and those with their eyes on billions of taxes going to private school profits, and "useful idiots" truly believe that private schools are the answer. Decades of evidence worldwide shows much better results if the funding is directed to State schools.
It hasn't changed. Fuck up State provision, so a few people can make billions from privatisation. W've already seen how it works with rail, power, health (GP is apparent at present) , State housing, aged care, child care.
Why the hell would we want a repeat with education.
The Reading Recovery programme in NZ has been anything but successful over the last 2 decades. Just witness the long tail of children who are reaching secondary school as functionally illiterate. Most of which have failed to learn in the classroom, and then failed to learn in the RR programme.
The MoE has remained firmly wedded to the concept of 'balanced literacy', regardless of decades of international research showing that it has poorer educational outcomes than phonics-based strategies for learning to read.
Schools which have gone against the tide in NZ – specifically disregarding MoE directives, and using discretionary funding to support a phonics based learning to read programme – have reported very significant improvements.
Most parents are not willing to put philosophy ahead of the welfare of their children.
Yes. Just note the long tail reaching secondary school illiterate.
Who were at primary during the last National Governments "unfortunate experiment" in education. Forcing Teachers into a strait jacket after they canned the Clark Governments evidence based and widely consulted "New NZ curriculum" ( which allowed Teachers flexibility) for a top down imposition of NACT standards.
Again we are seeing top down impositions. Just the thing you complain about.
Of course, widespread effects of housing shortages and poverty which the Coalition of cockups are exerbating, has an even greater effect than anything Teachers can do. The "tail" are known to consist mostly of children whose families are below the poverty line!
I realise that maths may not be your strong point. But we have just had 6 years of a left government. Any kid reaching high-school at this point in time, had had their primary/intermediate years almost entirely under a Labour led government.
You may have noted that NACT standards, curriculum, NCEA and other carryovers from the Key Government, continued under Labour.
Unfortunately!
I have commented on this topic extensively, before. From my reading, in both the UK and Australia, a big shift to for-profit schooling by the Torys and the Liberals has sucked a huge amount of government money away from state education. The end redult is a 2-tier education system, with a breaking/broken state sector.
Just who do you support, BD? Your red herrings on name suppression took up column space on MTui's Yago post, which was about ACT's strategic obsfucation's, not Yago's crimes.
And today, BD, you are coming out behind Seymour's destructive charter school policy, which has been extensively debunked in a previous iteration in NZ.
Don't bleat about consumer choice and failures in our state school system. Put up the case for the for-profit model from, for example, your 'Isle of Perfection', the UK academies.
If you struggle with differing viewpoints, then you are likely to find a political blog a … challenging … place.
I've been commenting on the need for phonics-based reading education in NZ on TS, for quite some time. Based on the overwhelming international research on its effectiveness. This is hardly new territory for me. Nor is the fact that the state schooling system in NZ has continued to fail children. It's an unpalatable truth for those wedded to state-is-best – that children at state-integrated schools, regularly out-perform their decile peers at state schools.
The current charter schools (just opened this week, so a little too soon to comment on their effectiveness) appear to be very largely run by trusts or zero-profit organizations – and specifically targeted at kids whose needs are demonstrably *not* being met through the current state system. This is hardly privatization of education.
Nor, have I advocated for a 'for profit' model for education. Or claimed that the UK is an 'isle of perfection'. This comes entirely from your disordered imagination.
The results, in reality, are rather mixed.
But once you add family income as a variable. No! State integrated schools and charter schools in NZ do not perform better than State schools.
When you have much more funding and the capability to pick and choose your pupils it is easy to, outwardly, show better results. An example is Auckland Grammers zoning. I could do that too, if I could pick my students.
I taught for a while at a very low decile school. Their results, as far as "value added" student achievement from a disadvantaged base, far exceeded those of the more prestigious, but hidebound, school down the road. The local charter school startup, which was supposedly set up for disadvantaged Māori kids at great expense, booted any kids that were "difficult" back to us. To the disappointment of the kids, and their families, being promised much and then shoved around. I suppose it made their "results" look better, though.
Lastly. State schools would perform a lot better, if we could teach as we are taught to teach, with evidence based pedagogy and with regard to learners needs. Instead of having to follow particularly National Governments”one size fits all” nostalgia for rote learning and rigid counterproductive summative testing.
The rigidity you complain about in State schools comes from, mostly, National, Governments, not teachers!
State schools have just had 6 years of a left government which was highly supportive of the teacher unions – and their 'teacher knows best' mentality. Learning standards continued to fall. Teachers, led by the MoE demonstrably did not learn from international best practice (cf phonics-based reading and open-plan classrooms). Continuing to do what has been happening over the last two decades – under a range of different governments – is clearly failing.
State-integrated schools rarely 'pick ad choose' pupils. They have strict selection criteria to prevent that happening. And even more rarely select based on academic ability (there is an argument that sporting ability 'counts' – but the result is that the sport-selected kid is getting a better education than they would in the state system – so pretty moot, from a parent's perspective. Note: this notoriously happens at high decile state schools, as well)
Any exclusions will be around behaviour, rather than learning ability. If a pupil chooses to deal drugs to other kids, or be violent to kids or staff, then they will be excluded. I'd argue they should be excluded from State schools as well – but that rarely seems to happen (the 'right' to education for that specific kid outweights the 'right' to education for all the rest of their classmates)
What planet are you on?
Can you link to any evidence for this?
It doesn't seem to be borne out by the MoE data in the EQI (replacing deciles), which is intended to take this specific factor (along with a whole lot of others) into account.
I invite you to compare the NCEA results for One Tree Hill College (which has a lower, i.e better) EQI (470) than McAuley (487)
https://www.educationcounts.govt.nz/find-school/school/qualifications/ue-standard?district=®ion=&school=85
https://www.educationcounts.govt.nz/find-school/school/qualifications/ue-standard?district=®ion=&school=90
Cuba is a bad example to use because food is an internationally grown commodity and trade with Cuba is restricted e.g. US suppliers are prohibited from selling food to the Cuban government. Given the success of their education and health areas to everyone it is hard to make a case that food distribution would necessarily be inefficient in a free trade situation.
We're about to find out how efficient international food distribution is with trade tariffs.
Hi DOS US suppliers are not prohibited from selling food to the Cuban government. At the moment all of the frozen chickens in the system are from the US along with many other items.
Cuba can order whatever food it wants from the US and would order a lot more if it had the money to pay for it.
I had understood they can only sell to private enterprise in Cuba – capitalism vs communism.
Indeed this seems to say the same.
In a surprising development given Cuba’s worsening economy, exports of food and other goods from the United States were up last year thanks to an explosion of trade involving private small and medium enterprises on the island.
According to trade data gathered by the New York-based U.S. Cuba-Trade and Economic Council, an organization that tracks business with Cuba, U.S. companies, many based in Miami and Hialeah, exported food and agricultural products worth $342.6 million. That’s a 12.4% increase from 2021, when private enterprises, known in Cuba as pymes, were first authorized, and exports to Cuba reached $304.7 million.
Exports in December also jumped 58% from November, to $45.2 million from $28.6 million.
The export data for 2023 “is remarkable not only by the U.S. dollar value, but the substantial increase in the number of companies, primarily located in South Florida, who are exporting products from the United States to Cuba specifically in support of the re-emerging private sector in Cuba,” said John Kavulich, the council’s president. “This data legitimizes these are real businesses, that there is commercial activity, and it is expanding.”
Cuba has been under a U.S. trade and financial embargo since the early 1960s, but there are several exceptions that allow for the export of food, agricultural products, medical supplies, humanitarian donations, and several other categories of goods if they are to be used by the private sector and not the government.
https://www.cpapracticeadvisor.com/2024/02/14/u-s-exports-to-cuba-increased-in-2023/101676/
DOS there maybe an embargo on US goods still. I don't know. What I do know is that the Cuban government is corrupt and desperate.
Yesterday- for the first time ever – they went begging to the UN World Food Program. Castro would Never have done that.
The young have had the internet for a few years now and are all looking at Amazon who deliver whatever you order. Not that anyone has any money except party officers and their families. Three years ago one USD cost 50 Cuban Peso. Today one USD costs 325 Pesos.
Cuba used to export food. Now agriculture has collapsed. Old tractors and farm machinery sits rusting on previously productive farms.
As I mentioned I could not believe all of the chickens are now imported from the US. Last year there were riots in at least three cities over food supply.
The power infrastructure urgently needs replacing and Cuba's major source of funding (exporting doctors) will come to an end if they can't find the money to upgrade the medical equipment that the doctors need to train on.
Diaz- Canal the President schedules endless speeches which no one listens to and no one believes blaming American Imperialism for all of Cubas woes and asking for more sacrifice.
Don't sell yrself short.
I understand that there are way more readers than commenters here. Lurkers?
What you propose will influence others.
While including the TS commenteriat, I was thinking of writers the likes Trotter, Rockel, MT, Slack etc.
Well a good step is: stop talking about the government and the state. Start talking about New Zealand. The right talks only of markets, property owners, and customers. That's how to start unifying.
Go for it.
Good point.
I often think about what the perfect society would look like. And what part I play and what part the state. Obviously individuals can't provide hospitals, police, roads etc.
What if everyone was housed and had their nutritional needs met. And there was free healthcare, education and public transport.
To get there we would need a powerful capitalism to generate the necessary wealth.
Some socialism to spread the wealth
And the constitutional power of liberalism to keep us in order.
Norman Kirk: “Basically there are four things that matter to people: they have to have somewhere to live, they have to have food to eat, they have to have clothing to wear, and they have to have something to hope for.”
That's a sticker not a programme.
It's a coherent statement of principles. It stakes a claim for Norman Kirk's Labour Party as champion of humane and decent values; a stark contrast to the "vision" put forward by Bill Clinton and his malevolent campaign manager James Carville in the 1990s.
so just post the programme that Kirk did after he made that statement of principles.
Maybe you've heard of some of the things Kirk's government did: 1) opposing French nuclear testing in the South Pacific—he sent a ship with a cabinet minister (Fraser Colman) on board to actually stop them; 2) standing in solidarity with the South African liberation struggle—Kirk stopped the Springbok tour in 1973; 3) establishing alternative lifestyle communes (the Ohu movement); 4) pulling New Zealand troops out of the U.S. assault on Vietnam; 5) established the Waitangi Tribunal; 6) abolished Compulsory Military Training; 7) established the DPB; 8) established the Disability Allowance; …
perfect. That's what Ad meant about a programme rather than a statement.
The statement is all well and good. The programme is the meat that voters will be interested in.
Your memory of New Zealand history is a little different to mine.
You say "opposing French nuclear testing in the South Pacific—he sent a ship with a cabinet minister (Fraser Colman) on board to actually stop them". Are you really suggested that the testing stopped? Remember that the frigate was sent in 1973.
In reality French nuclear tests continued at Mururoa until 1996. Twenty three years is an awfully slow stop, isn't it?
It succeeded in stopping atmospheric testing, which ceased only a year later. Underground testing was of course still utterly reprehensible, but the effects were by comparison much more confined, and not at all susceptible to the vagaries of weather.
Not only did that Labour Government stop France carrying out nuclear tests, it later prosecuted France at the World Court. The Lange government continued this policy of principled opposition to nuclear testing, culminating in the ban on nuclear ships entering our waters,
Sadly, such principled and courageous politics was entirely absent when the National Party was in power—of course, the most abject moment was Don Brash's pathetic "gone by lunchtime" pledge.
Given that Lange was only Prime Minister from 1984 until 1988, and the French nuclear tests continued until 1996 just how did he " stop France carrying out nuclear tests"?
You then claim that " entirely absent when the National Party was in power—of course, the most abject moment was Don Brash's pathetic "gone by lunchtime" pledge. "
Well the National Party were never in power while Don Brash was an MP. He was there from 2002 until 2007 so how does anything he is claimed to have said have to do with when the National Party was in power?
I was also tempted to comment on your comment about NZ in the Vietnam war. All the New Zealand combat troops were withdrawn a year or so before Kirk became PM.He withdrew some people who were helping train the Vietnamese forces. He left other military personnel there of course. He had been dead for a year or so before the final troops were withdrawn.
It's a tetrad. I'd up-grade it to incorporate fun as 5th essential since all culture emanates from it! To do a reality check, ask around friends & family to ascertain the viability of life with no fun. Big Norm clearly had a tacit acceptance of there being no fun in Labour.
Panopticon alert: https://thedailyblog.co.nz/2025/02/03/mass-surveillance-fascist-nz-corporation-demands-more-mass-surveillance-powers-with-zero-accountability/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panopticon
Privatisation of mass surveillance has happened and mass lethargy remains the norm. She'll be right – but Bomber dissents anyway. "What, me worry?" thinks Alfred E Neuman https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alfred_E._Neuman
Trump chalks up another win: https://www.foxnews.com/world/panama-pledges-end-key-canal-deal-china-work-us-after-rubio-visit
This has been confirmed by Rubio, yet apart from Reuters all our main sources remain reluctant to acknowledge the win!
"You've got a nice canal here. It would be a shame if something happened to it"
fify
The “TrumpFather”–a lot of people seem to let him get away with his mobster affectations.
But that's ok for me to say…there are hundreds if not thousands in some genuine fear of their lives in the US following his return. If John Bolton and others of that ilk are on his revenge list who would be safe?
SNL began the Sean Spicer/Trump press spokesperson impersonations.
Mexicans will pay for the wall, the USA will get the canal back if the charges for the USA are not lower.
US govt censors bad words:
Back to binary, folks! No tertiary category will be used officially. Real people will be allocated official categories on the basis of biology. Identitarians will prevail?
Back to reality folks. Real people have real categories based on the binary reality of human sex. And nobody is "assigned" anything at birth except a collection of sexist stereotypes tied up in a pink or blue ribbon.
If the terms assigned male at birth, assigned female at birth are not used, how will they discuss such cases (those not of the biological sex) in research?
Maybe the term classified. We use this term, from observation of certain characteristics. The word assigned suggests something random, or how the drill sergeant would assign a new recruit to potato peeling duties
Sure, some term would be required. Usually the "classification" would be for social reasons as the child would not have the same genitalia as others – but then comes puberty (and the issue returns of difference returns in the outward appearance).
do you mean research on trans people? It would depend on the research.
Obviously medical research would need to know if the person was female or male.
If it was social research, then use the term trans man or trans woman (and define that in the research brief and paper).
The problem we have at the moment isn't lack of language, it's ideological enforcement. The liberals enforced one set, they can 't really complain when the conservatives do the same. This is a superb example of the principle that you have to bring society with you, and that forcing people to think like you doesn't work.
Fortunately, left wing gender critical feminists, and others who are both gc and progressive, had been discussion these issues for a long time and have solutions. At some point the left should stop ostracising us and engage in an open manner and see if we can't find a better way than the left and right identitarians.
There are additional issues. Trans people with marked gender dysphoria have a need to not be reminded of their biological sex, and to have their chosen gender identity affirmed. This seems reasonable, and it's also reasonable that society places limits on that. eg people should be registered with their GP as their biological sex (and additionally their gender id if they choose). It also matters when it comes to women's spaces and similar issues.
There also appear to be trans women whose identity is around being affirmed as a woman because of their sexual fetish eg autogynephilia. They were formerly known as cross dressing men. They are particularly problematic for women, and we should be having an open public discussion about where the boundaries are. But at the moment, thanks to liberals, people with AGP are allowed to self identify as trans and into women's spaces. They tend to have a particular sense of male entitlement similar to other men, disrespectful of women.
Research has been done on AGP, someone could look up what terms were used.
I agree. Trump doesn't seem to have factored in Differences of Sex Development. He doesn't seem to care.
The term "assigned female/male at birth" was initially used for people with DSDs, whose sex was incorrectly identified and recorded at birth. These are largely males with atypical genetalia and the conditions are mostly identified at birth or puberty, especially in wealthier communities & countries.
The gender ID movement appropriated the term, which many DSD people and organisations are not happy about.
Trump has also made these EOs in a way that seems to make transgender IDed people a target. But, I don't think he really cares about people with DSDs, people whose bodies have had some of their sex characteristics altered medically and/or surgically, or about females.
I think giving primacy to biological sex over gender identity, is good, but the way Trump is going about enforcing those definitions is not good at all.
you really are missing the politics here Dennis. There are whole swathes of people who now support Trump, who didn't before, because of this issue. Stop and think about why that is.
Biology matters. Try reading Jane Clare Jones who spells out the connection between denial of material reality and the ecological crisis.
Weka, when you say "whole swathes of people who now support Trump" "because of this issue" [that sex in humans is binary?], what might "whole swathes of people" mean as a number or percentage of US voters?
And do you believe a similar proportion of Kiwis might have been swayed to cast their votes for conservative political parties based on "this issue"?
And would it be unreasonable to suggest that a majority of Trunp supporters are in denial about the polycrisis? If the Trump administration can "erase terms including gender, transgender, pregnant person, LGBT, transsexual and nonbinary", then maybe the polycrisis is similarly erasable – just imagine what a strongman like Trump can do with whole swathes of people supporting him.
I used the term support, not vote, but few organisations are counting this issue well, so my guess is that there is almost no reliable data on voting choices in the US or NZ.
But here's the crunch: it's very difficult to do such research when it might cost you your career. No Debate means we have no debate and that included no data. Not just voter patterns, but attitudes or societal shifts. We don't have good data on transition and detransition for the same reason.
What I do know is that I've spent 7 years watching this dynamic unfold. Women being radicalised because liberals said women can't have our own rape crisis or toilets any more and if we want them we are bigots. That includes women in the UK and the US, and women in NZ, including on TS.
There are women like myself who are left in our bones and who understood that women's rights couldn't be attained by moving rightwards. But we are in the minority. The liberal left have ostracised us, so the great work being done on these issues by left wing GCFs is not well known.
This 2024 polling shows
1.clear Dem-GOP divide
2.a trend 2017-2024
What it does not show is polling of any difference between male and female voters.
https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2024/06/06/gender-identity-sexual-orientation-and-the-2024-election/
I didn't say anything about voting sex demographics.
You asked for reliable data on voting choices in the US as related to opinion on gender ID.
This does that by showing the clear difference between Dem and GOP voters on that issue. And a trend in the overall position over 7 years.
But what it does not sample is female and male difference on the gender issue.
which bit in your link talks about women changing their support for Trump over the gender/sex war?
But what it does not sample is female and male difference on the gender issue.
What it does show is an overall trend towards a strongly held GOP position on the issue since 2017.
ah, ok. Yes. But what we don't know is how many people would have voted differently if women's voices were being listened to by the Dems.
Here's a data-filled analysis on the issue un the UK's 2024 election.
'Last year just 8 per cent of Britons said they paid a lot of attention to trans issues and as many said that trans people face significant prejudice as said the same of disabled people. And those paying the greatest attention to media coverage of trans rights are people who are more supportive of them than opposed'.
And the UK is a hot-spot for anti-trans/culture wars electioneering. There was that senior Tory official who claimed the 'trans debate would win the election' for them. Ha.
I would guess that the US was not much different.
There have been some polls that show that last year both Democrat and Republican voters became more opposed to trans IDed males in sport (a big issue in the US), in bathrooms, etc.
YouGov on bathrooms: the Independent vote is significant because it may have shifted enough swing voters to make a difference.
"NYT poll finds majority of Democrats oppose transgender athletes in women’s sports"
I think this is a conservative Christian group – Concerned Women for America (CWA) exit poll:
Quite right – happy to change “US voters” to ‘US supporters’ [of Trump] in para 1, and “cast their votes for ” to ‘support’ [for NZ conservative parties] in para 2.
So how might "ostracised" (left and right-wing) gender critical feminists and activists get more publicity for their great work?
The Women's Rights Party may have broad support, but fewer than 1 in 1000 Kiwi voters gave it their party vote in the 2023 general election.
Have liberal lefties really been saying that – for seven years? Not this lefty, but if so, then for all the debates – culture wars even – such comments stir up, there seems little appetite for implementation in NZ.
there's no such thing as a RW GCF in the way you imply. Kellie Jay Keen is not a feminist. There are centre right GCFs I guess, Helen Joyce being the most notable. Economically conservative, socially liberal, GC, feminist.
I generally use the term GCF to refer to the left and centre left feminists who believe that biological sex is binary and that this matters, and that gender stereotypes harm women. I also think feminists like Joyce are important voices.
In the UK, those feminists have fought a long, hard grass roots campaign, and eventually shifted the MSM on the issue. They also made policy gains in legislation and won legal cases. There are people other than feminists doing this work too.
In NZ, the situation is different. Much smaller population, we don't have the kind of pre-existing grass roots feminist movement that the UK has (what happened to that btw?), and we are more liberal than the UK. Liberal NZ is firmly in the women's spaces are transphobic camp. Hence your Spinoff link.
But, my guess is that if NZ women were asked, the majority would say they want women's spaces. If you look at the yougov polling in the UK, once you shift the question from 'do you support trans rights' to 'do you support trans identified males who haven't surgically transitioned', people's positions become more aligned with GCFs ie supportive of trans rights but not at the expense of women.
But No Debate was incredibly successful, and it hasn't really been broken in NZ. The GC feminists I know here are mostly laying low, or just working steadily on the issues. We still can't have an open, robust debate. Even on TS, one of the few places online where debate has been held, is now in a kind of stasis.
One consequence of No Debate in NZ is this:
1. GC policy is being advanced by conservatives
2. GCF voices aren't being heard, so there is a dearth of progressive GC voices*
3. Liberals like Rawhiti-Connel are free to distort the debate in similar ways as Peters and co.
4. Women will increasingly say fuck off, as they come to realise what it means
*I'm generalising, WRP and SUFW in particular continue to do good work.
Sure, and not this liberal lefty either. I was talking policy and positioning. If. you doubt what I say, stand up and talk about women's spaces in any progressive space in NZ and see what happens (seriously though, don't do that).
And I was referencing other countries. I've been following the UK GCFs for that long, I watched liberals (including NZ ones) allow rape and violence memes against terfs online in that time, I saw women lose jobs, careers, get arrested for tweets.
There are places in the UK now where there are no Rape Crisis centres that provide women only services. What do you think NZ women would do if they knew that was happening here? Why don’t they know?
I regard TS as a progressive 'space' in NZ. My current view on the need for (maintaining) women-only (safe) spaces in NZ has been informed by what I read here, and I don't remember anyone challenging me when I stated my view, except perhaps a few Standandistas who thought I wasn't articulating that view correctly or strongly enough.
I was unaware of that. How have UK women / women's groups responded to this (new?) lack of women-only services in (some) Rape Crisis centres?
https://rapecrisis.org.uk/about-us/women-only-spaces/
Is it happening here, in NZ?
Support all that Weka has said. There are women who voted right last year, other who voted left but who were absolutely over the moon when Trump made his pronouncement.
As important & ground breaking as a changed vote from left to right for womens rights is/would be, the shattering aspect for me is the number of people who won't or can't make the move to vote right and whose decision is to not vote at all.
This may have a flow on to local body elections when we see aspiring national (small 'n') politicans being inspected for anti women sentiment eg Katrina Biggs has kept followers on X up to date with the moves to allow men into women's dressing rooms in Christchurch espoused by Phil Mauger's council. Mauger is centre-right so it's a fair old mix up .
We/the women may just slide away……will we ever hear from them again?
Of course. This is such an obviousness, I'm not sure what your point is. Would you mind stating it directly?
Not sure I have a point – just musing on the human ability to pick and choose which 'realities' to believe, be it the polycrisis (very important) or self-ID (important to some individuals; not very important in the greater scheme of things – just my opinion), and how we enable stromgmen to erase and/or ignore complex and challenging 'realities' – Keep It Simple Stupid!
I'll go to my grave still struggling with 'they/them' – much to my shame.
https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/climate/trump-environment-rollbacks-list.html
https://earth.org/trump-2-0-actions-we-are-likely-to-see-against-climate-nature-and-wildlife/
I'm confident I'm not missing the dimensional drivers of the trend. Realism has two sides: binary people cling to their tradition while trans people know they don't belong in the binary. Denial of trans reality is silly and cannot prevail socially. The principle of biodiversity applies. Yet it's also true that nature features dyads, and male/female is the dyad of reproduction. That's realistic.
So we must transcend the binary by allowing trans to be realised as an evolutionary option (despite the dead-end it becomes for some who adopt it), and acknowledge that the binary is real for most of us. Both/and logic applies!
Re JCJ, I found this:
It nicely illustrates how people create barriers to sharing reality, which effectively isolate a social group from another, and fixate on the dichotomy instead of anchoring on common ground.
please post the link for the quote.
Sorry
https://thecritic.co.uk/owen-jones-vs-robert-webb/
thanks.
Good read thanks Dennis.
From yr link:
"I have no doubt Jesse Thorn is a decent man who wants to do the best for his child. But while transactivists lauded him for trying to hold Webb to account, what I heard was an act of ideological coercion, and a signature example of how mandating belief in gender identity is destroying public discourse."
This is akin to weka mentioning No Debate. Tis still alive and well.
Um, material reality exists whether humans do or not, and whether humans think about shit or not. Material reality doesn't have two sides, it just is. All humans are one of two sexes.
If you are talking about philosophy, then there are more than two sides on the issue of binaryness, this is my point.
There are the people who believe that the binary nature of sex matters and should be enforced via gender stereotypes (fundamental conservatives).
There are people who believe that the binary nature of sex matters because material reality matters, but gender stereotypes suck (gender critical feminists and other progressive gender critical people)
There are people who believe that biological sex is a construct, that it can be changed, and that gender identity trumps biological sex.
There's more than that, but you get my point. My comment above was about the numbers of women for whom being female matters a great deal and who will side with that over liberal left politics. Understanding why is crucial to the left making gains. To frame the dynamic as two sides missed the point.
you are conflating biology and social identity
conflating biology and social identity
Not equating them, framing them as an inevitable complementarity. Some people have their identity anchored in biology. Others self-define it.
maybe. There's a pretty strong feminist argument that gender identity (as we currently do it) is harmful. Some people say they have no gender identity.
I have commented here in the past a few times in support of the feminist position. I don't claim any competence around gender since I grew up back when it was used as a simile for sex and haven't encountered any explanation of difference that stuck in my mind (I do recall reading one of yours once that I thought at the time clarified it nicely – but retain no memory of the details due to being ancient!)
"Not equating them, framing them as an inevitable complementarity. "
Re your very strange comment on JCJ's views. She sees biology and social processes as interacting in some quite complex ways.
What do you mean by an "evolutionary option"?
This is a twitter thread by a US human evolution biologist, Carole Hooven. She would not agree with you. The thread is a copy of the email responses she sent to The Guardian journalist who asked her views on Trump’s sex/gender EO.
What is the "biodiverse" reality that you refer to re transgender IDed people?
There are only 2 sexes. Within each sex there is a great deal of diversity. However, all but an infinitesimal amount of people have a male or a female reproductive system, which is full integrated within the whole anatomy. This creates important differences between males and females that need to be acknowledged.
Transgender IDed people include a vast range of different people, including differences between male & female sex differences. Some trans people take opposite sex hormones and have surgeries that modify their bodies. Others ID as transmen or transwomen without any medical or surgical intervention.
Whereas evolution works via mutation & selection (theory), male & female are the norms that enable reproduction. Those who are attracted to same sex don't reproduce unless they are also bisexual & do the normal thing.
That makes 3 obvious categories: male/female/whatever. Trans has become the culturally-endorsed category for whatever but there are various sub-categories that have become popular in recent years/decades. Nature makes all, but there's a cultural warping also evident with some folk. I here use the word warp in a technical non-condemnatory sense. So nature provides biodiversity within humans as a spectrum, which is our collective reality.
Traditionalists & conservatives go instead with the paradigm that socially conditioned them when young: male/female. It's their reality.
I'm having difficulty following your argument. Many lesbians and some gay men have children, eg through reproductive technologies these days. But, also many lesbian follow social pressures when young, get into heterosexual relationships, even though they are not attracted to men. Furthermore, many heterosexual humans choose not to have children – and the numbers seem to be growing in younger generations these days.
But what does that have to do with trans identified people, who indeed are strongly influenced by various cultural, and sexual experiences in the way they come to ID as trans? Each individual's story is a bit different thought there are some common themes.
Male and female aren't norms. They are sexes, which are reproductive systems and all but an infinitesimal amount of humans have either a male or female reproductive system. The results are a cluster of differences between human males and females. There is no spectrum with gradations between being male and female; it is not like some genetic rainbow spectrum where one colour gradually fades into the next.
Yes, culture has a role in how each human understands him/herself, and sex-based, culturally-constructed stereotypes have a lot of influence how we view ourselves. Many of us call that 'gender' ( a term derived from linguistics, not biological reality).
Many trans IDed people have mothered or fathered children, so I'm not sure where your connection with childless lesbians and gays relates to them.
There's Debbie Hayton, born male, medically and surgically transitioned, has a wife and daughter. Here Debbie talks about the need for single sex hospital wards, and, if necessary trans people should be put in single rooms. And here Debbie talks about the desire to be a woman was his (hetero)sexuality.
And this is a review of Scott Newgent's biography, about how lesbian mother, Kellie King, transitioned medically and surgically to transman, Scott Newgent. Now Scott puts that drive down to homophobia, and now still sees herself as female and a lesbian, but continues to the external appearance of being like a man. Plus she had early childhood trauma, and was raped as a teenager.
Both Debbie and Scott don't really care about what pronouns people use for them, and both are not concerned about being 'dead-named'.
These are not in some "whatever" category that is neither male nor female. Sex (male or female) is not the same as socially constructed 'gender'.
My view encompasses all that you describe so well. Perhaps my framing seems too simplistic: one's personal framings are aesthetic choices, and I prioritise communicating complex topics is simply as possible to optimise comprehension. Doesn't mean anyone else necessarily gets my intended meaning, just that it ups the odds of success.
In essence, use metaphysics to discern the metapattern. The spectrum runs from 0 to 1. Sex is the two natural numbers 0 & 1 used as symbols to represent male & female. All fractions in between them are available to users to represent their self-identity in the sex category.
If it helps, take heed of how this metapattern is used in quantum computing, where the functional design of the tech system selects a value between 0 & 1 (false & true) as answer to a binary question into what's real.
In my view this is the same mental process that our minds use when making a decision of what to do. Shakespeare made Hamlet say to be or not to be but we are no longer limited to that binary. Trans folk live accordingly.
$21 billion was returned to victims of financial fraud and abuse. Of course the billionaires want it gone.
//
President Donald Trump on Monday appointed Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent as the acting director of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, a powerful watchdog agency whose operations Bessent immediately halted pending a review.
In an email to agency staff sent from the “acting director,” Bessent ordered the bureau to cease all work to craft regulations, enforce its rules, conduct investigations or provide “public communications of any type,” citing a need to “promote consistency” with the goals of the new administration, according to a copy obtained by The Washington Post.
https://archive.li/xcPvf
Those nice billionaires will acquire debt at cents in the dollar.
/
A government-wide hiring freeze has led the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. to yank job offers to more than 200 new examiners, the front-line employees who closely monitor banks to ensure they operate safely and adhere to an extensive rule book.
The FDIC is already facing a staffing challenge, particularly with a lack of examiners, undermining its ability to reduce the risk of bank failures. A chronic shortage of examiners contributed to the failure of Signature Bank, one of three large banks to collapse in 2023, the agency has said.
Though the FDIC historically operates independently of the White House, it is complying with the freeze, which President Donald Trump announced through an executive order last week. The move demonstrates the extent to which financial policy is increasingly set by the party in control of the White House.
https://archive.li/2u0el (wapo)
ffs
.
@mmasnick.bsky.social
·
3h
Wrote a thing warning people to expect a "Twitter Files" redux, of "The Government Files" in which Elon's dumbest fans will make a bunch of blatantly false conspiracy theory claims, he'll find some credulous "reporter" to repeat them, and people will believe it: http://www.techdirt.com/2025/02/03/t...
https://bsky.app/profile/mmasnick.bsky.social/post/3lhc4zyc7nc2s
Remember the Twitter Files? That carefully orchestrated “exposé” where incredibly gullible hand-picked journalists were given selective access to internal documents to manufacture misleading outrage about Twitter’s content moderation?
Get ready for the government edition.
[…]
So, consider this a blaring warning: we’re going to see a bunch of false and misleading nonsense pushed by Elon and his crew, claiming all sorts of waste, fraud, and abuse. Most of it won’t actually be any of those things. Much of it will actually be important (sometimes life-saving) programs. They may stumble upon actual problems — those always exist. But they’re going to destroy hugely consequential elements of US infrastructure to get there.
And then we’re going to be lied to about it all by dimwit reporters for years on end.
The Twitter Files were just the dress rehearsal. The real performance is about to begin, and this time, the damage won’t be limited to content moderation decisions at one social media platform — it threatens to undermine crucial government functions from international aid to public health infrastructure.
https://www.techdirt.com/2025/02/03/the-twitter-files-playbook-comes-for-the-us-government/
Konrad the Kool does exemplary enterprise: https://www.abc.net.au/news/2025-02-04/engaging-young-australians-punters-politics/104878384
Guerilla politics was invented by the yippies circa 1971 when Jerry Rubin's Do It hit the bookshops (bought brand new by me). Nike, much later, recycled that slogan. Street theatre was the style of the times. Online peer pressure is the current form.
Friendly Jordies rips into Gena Rhinehardt, the richest woman in Australia and doyen of the mining industry, talking to the poor mining industry late last year. The industry been hit by taxation enforcement and pressure to unionise by the current Labor state and federal governments.
Start from 20 mins, Jordie is both funny and informative:
When Gena advocates for an Oz DOGE department: "Elon musk's ideology seems to be centered entirely around reading Ayn Rand when he was 15, so… it's the same thing that all those like libertarian types in the US have of 'yes yes I will counter Das Capital with Fountain Head'…it's a fantasy book, it's like saying here's my view of the world have you read Harry Potter 4 yeah I'm going to base my political leanings off of… fighting evil with magic'."
The points in this about the rip-off by the Oz industry, with PROFITS of $250 bi last year, and probably around 10% of that contributed in tax.
Trump's first Truss-onomics moment: Global stock markets come under pressure amid ‘Trump tariff tantrum’, And the DeepSeek imbroglio hits those investment vehicles heavily exposed to Nvidia et al, europena car comapnies and international crypto investments.
‘The JP Morgan Chase chief economist.. said: “This weekend’s actions challenge our underlying view that the Trump administration will strive to limit disruptive policies as it balances its desire to reduce engagement with the world with a commitment to support US businesses.
“In short, the risk is that the policy mix is tilting (perhaps unintentionally) into a business-unfriendly stance.”
Perhaps unintentionally?
Worldwide. I wonder if that includes a certain ship builder in…Korea?Would be so fkn Ironic if they were the solution ? Also of course so very unlikely as…Willis and Co could not ever admit their screw up.
People are following government advice and fleeing Santorini in Greece, after an increasing swarm of quakes, and . More than 30 > 4 magnitude tremors in the past 3 days. Santorini itself is the rim of a huge caldera, and the site of the cataclysmic earthquake that destroyed the Minoans.
Bishflap hand on "heart" states…(for what thats worth : (
I see Simon Moutter was also yakking. I had a looksee what he would know about Social Housing. SFA as far as I could see…Maybe thats part of the Plan.
Si's a change agent. A glib, smarmy pos who fucks up peoples lives and does it with a smile.
Yup also likes to buddy up to the workers to discover things he can use against them from his management perch.
He fooled a few at spark who weren't paying enough attention to what he actually represented and they found out the hard way.
He was a good culture fit at akl airport.
Yup, that's what he did.
Always good to hear from those who have had some interaction with these types.
in my long working life, your description would IMO, fit the majority of so called managers.
Most with very little, if any, practical or business ability, common sense etc;
How do they get to become manager? Stabbing and bullshitting their way upwards…..
Just doing what Key did – getting rid of all the state housing in posh areas.
On that….
And revisiting the past. Same old Nat modus….nothing changes.
Proven
From ChCh some years back….
Did the state tenants take action? Would they now?
https://www.stuff.co.nz/nz-news/360569356/new-poll-has-centre-left-enough-support-govern
Spin this luxon
The alarm bell ringing in that poll is NZ First scraping just above 5%. Soon Winston will be off the leash (no longer deputy PM, no longer sitting alongside Luxon in the House and playing loyal sidekick).
Then he and Shane Jones will turn the rabble-rousing up to 11. Luxon won't be able to cope. He's already a feeble apologist for his Minister's bigotry, how much worse will it get?
Chewie at BHN (from 1h20) has noticed that the algorithms in FB and even google have changed his feeds in the last week of so to push more rw anti-woke material, and that finding certain stuff is harder, or you have to be more careful to not be shadow-banned for innocuous statements. Meta looks to be pivot to a more partisan pro-Trump approach.
Time to change to bluesky and nsearch engines like duckduckgogo.
An effect of Meta's removal of fact-checking and switch to a community notes model for policing objectional material is to shift the algorithm. This article backgrounds how Meta's political bias setting has changed over the years.
‘But then last year, Meta started to change its tune, with Zuckerberg penning a letter to Congress in which he expressed regret over his company’s decision to censor COVID vaccine misinformation, at the behest of Biden administration officials, and the mistaken blocking of a New York Post story about Hunter Biden’s laptop.
At that stage, Trump looked to be gaining in the polls, on the way to his subsequent re-election. That could be coincidental timing, but it did seem like Zuckerberg may have been setting the table for last week’s switch-up based on the poll projections.
Also of note, Trump had threatened to jail Zuckerberg for life if he was ever re-elected, due to what he viewed as political overreach by Facebook in suspending his account.’
Not quite a "get out of jail free card" , but free carbon credits for..these polluters?!
Signed, and was proud too !
And….Green party looks to our Future.
Onya Chloe : )
It has been decades since a National government increased public housing stock and there will be no change.
It was about 1979-1981
https://teara.govt.nz/en/graph/32421/total-state-housing-stock
There will be less social and or public housing than in 2023.
https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/politics/housing-minister-chris-bishop-to-speak-to-media-about-kainga-ora/EMWE3MFNGRBIROMJ6CIQ7UUDII/
Rubio appoints Jan 6'er to head of USAID.
https://bsky.app/profile/sifill.bsky.social/post/3lhcx4jgzuc26
Meet Rubio’s new Under Secretary for Public Diplomacy and Public Affairs.
https://edition.cnn.com/2025/02/03/politics/kfile-darren-beattie-state-department-controversial-tweets-white-nationalist-conference/index.html
"Competent white men" looking rather rare at present.
Certainly in the USA, they are having trouble finding any.
I'm getting a sneaky feeling this Luxon lot are our first 1-term government since 1972.
There's now nothing they can deliver that will turn their tide.
He's delivering, recession, high unemployment, and dog food to our school children,
Yes to 17 and 17.1
It would have to be a hungry dog.
Or a labrador
Even the dog food isn't arriving on time….listen to RadioNZ Checkpoint.
They've got to see the full term through first. Plenty of potential for tears before bed time.