Open mike 04/05/2025

Written By: - Date published: 6:00 am, May 4th, 2025 - 10 comments
Categories: open mike - Tags:


Open mike is your post.

For announcements, general discussion, whatever you choose.

The usual rules of good behaviour apply (see the Policy).

Step up to the mike …

10 comments on “Open mike 04/05/2025 ”

  1. Bearded Git 1

    After being soundly beaten by the far Right Reform UK party in the local elections and for mayoral roles and in a by-election this week does Starmer grow some cohones and stick to his supposedly Labour Party principles?

    Of course not-he shifts Labour even further to the Right.

    https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2025/may/03/labour-targets-international-students-claiming-asylum-after-losses-to-reform-in-local-elections

    • weka 1.1

      crushing fly tippers cars.

      Tbf, when you're that wedded to neoliberalism, there's not a lot of room to move.

  2. OliverBinto 2

    With the new defense spending is there an argument against it being paid for using a wealth tax? Arguably, defense spending benefits those with assets to loose far more than it benefits salary and wage earners.

    https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/political/559866/defence-force-maritime-helicopters-to-be-replaced-at-cost-of-over-2-billion

    • Muttonbird 2.1

      The language coming from these clowns is less about what NZ needs, and more about what other countries say NZ needs:

      “Global tensions are increasing rapidly but our current defence spending is simply too low and we have to rebuild the defence force,” Collins said from Whenuapai airbase.

      “It’s very clear New Zealand is not immune to the increasing tensions being felt throughout the world … distance no longer provides New Zealand the protection it once did.”

      – Collins

      We have not been pulling our weight so today’s announcement is a start, but it is only a start…You can be assured that through those reviews, we will be pushing hard to get defence spending up to two percent much sooner. That is our commitment to you today.

      – Peters

      https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/politics/watch-government-set-to-make-defence-announcement-ahead-of-budget-2025/IBWYVQMWVVFZTMGW64Y7QTYRDY/

      Did we ask for the commitment to get defence spending up to 2%? It's more that Australia and Trump are demanding that.

      $2B on five helicopters: YES!

      $3B on two mega ferries: NO!

      Anyone done the operational cost/benefit on the above?

      • Scud 2.1.1

        The RNZN Helicopters are due for replacement anytime soon as serviceability of the 8 Seasprites has fallen below 5 Operational Seasprites ie spares along with consumables are being used at a faster rate with an ageing airframe as Karman is getting out of the Helicopter business.

        Also note that this Navy Helicopter replacement project was knocked by Robbo when Andrew Little was the Defence Minister along with the Littoral Support Ship which the Navy had 3-6yrs designing when Ron Mark was Defence Minister & finally the all important Southern Ocean Patrol Ship was also knocked back by Robbo when Henare was defence minister.

        If you want the NZDF to do Peacekeeping/ Peace Enforcement Stabilisation Missions under the UN Peacekeeping Charter & uphold the UN Charter especially Article 51 the right to self defence?

        Then defence funding has to been around the 2% GDP & sometimes rising to 2.5-3% GDP as required ie Operational requirement & capability replacement & or Asset replacement.

        • Muttonbird 2.1.1.1

          Accept they need replacing at some point but "global tensions" as a reason to bring this forward while the health system is on its knees, and a resilient Cook Straight connection is in jeopardy, and public services are being slashed, and govt KiwiSaver contributions and winter energy payments are on the block, and social housing is being hocked off, and emergency housing is shut down, and while increasing numbers of vulnerable families are on the breadline, visiting food banks, and without prenatal care…

          We just received a squadron of P-8s and a squadron of C-130Js. It doesn't seem the right time to do this $2B chopper spend of questionable operational value. It feels like a sop to regional and global hawks for party specific political gain rather than for the benefit of NZ.

          Also, I didn't realise the UN had specific defence spend to GDP ratio recommendations to fulfil peacekeeping and self defence functions. Will try to find.

    • Barfly 2.2

      I'd like a wealth tax to pay for free dental it would likely have great appeal.

      • Muttonbird 2.2.1

        "Free" dental is a no brainer, but I'm concerned about the use of the word "free" in conversations about government policy. It's not free because we have already paid for it.

        There's been a few headlines recently about the $512 government contribution to KiwiSaver being cut by that incompetent harridan, Nicola Willis. Common to these headline is that the $512 is "free". It's not free, it's just tax money returned to our own retirement plan because we can't rely on sufficient Superannuation (which we have also paid for).

    • weka 2.3

      Arguably, defense spending benefits those with assets to loose far more than it benefits salary and wage earners.

      How so?

  3. Muttonbird 3

    Farrar watch:

    There's been a long running series of guest posts on Kiwiblog by Israeli supremacist lawyer Lucy Rodgers.

    Dangerous territory for Farrar to freely promote islamophobic themes given his blog site's behaviour before the 2019 terror attacks in Christchurch. Behaviour which required Kiwiblog to introduce strict moderation.

Leave a Comment