There seemed to be quite a lot of discussion generated yesterday around the comment I made about the apparent move by the MOE to introduce critical maths into our education system.
For me, education is one of those things that should transcend politics, and we should all be working together to ensure our children get the best possible education to set them up for life.
Just some further thoughts on the critical maths aspect.
Firstly, I think it is important to distinguish between critical maths and applied maths.
Applied maths deals with how maths can be applied to various practical problems in a wide variety of settings. So, in framing maths scenarios (rather than "problems") I don't see any problem using a wide variety of cultural settings for these scenarios. It doesn't change the underlying maths, and if it helps children relate better to learning maths, then I am all for that.
The difference with critical maths is that it appears, according to the Wiki article, to try and shape the view children have of the world, and how they fit into it. In that way, it appears to go beyond the objective of teaching children how to do maths.
Many of us who are parents or have young grandchildren are concerned about the state taking control of the education of our children and perhaps instilling them with values we don't agree with.
An example that will likely resonate here is the current discussion around women's rights in the context of transgenderism. I am sure many here would not approve of schools instilling the belief in children that they may not be the right gender and they should do something about it, for example.
It seems to me that there is at least grounds for suspicion that the MOE may be attempting to politicise maths in this way. If that is the case, then it should be put under the scrutiny of public debate so kiwis have input into how their children are taught.
The other concern I have is whether critical maths approach will actually be effective in teaching maths, The reason is that, according the the Wiki article, critical maths teaching does not rely on a set curriculum.
Because critical mathematics pedagogy is designed to be responsive to the lives of the students in a given classroom and their local context, there is no set curriculum.
The problem I have with this approach is that growing in learning maths requires understanding prior principles. If teachers are going to pick and choose what they teach, then there could be a lot of students who never grasp those prior principles, and hence struggle with learning new ones.
In the MoE video on their critical maths policy project I did get the impression of a hostage situation out of some participants. There was apparently 'robust' disagreement within the group, leading up to its teaching guidelines. I was also informed language can shape our reality and got the impression that the strong language of one participant might have shaped the reality of the project.
"… growing in learning maths requires understanding prior principles"? Isn't all learning laddered on prior learning, mental and physical?
Concerned about the state taking control of the education of our children and perhaps instilling them with values we don't agree with? Values are being learned through everything done in school, it is simply an environment, some of the learning is planned, some is incidental, some is accidental, but it will happen.
Natural clashes may happen when the values a child has been exposed to since birth and lived minute by minute for years meet something totally new in their very limited time at school. Like finding the kid with the brown face is normal. And nice. And bright.
The only way to be sure of avoiding the risk of offspring being instilled at school with values we don't agree with, is to keep them away from school.
"… growing in learning maths requires understanding prior principles"? Isn't all learning laddered on prior learning, mental and physical?
To a degree, yes. But, with maths I think it is especially so.
Values are being learned through everything done in school, it is simply an environment, some of the learning is planned, some is incidental, some is accidental, but it will happen.
Agreed. But it is a bit different if there is a state agenda to instill values without that information being conveyed clearly to parents.
The only way to be sure of avoiding the risk of offspring being instilled at school with values we don't agree with, is to keep them away from school.
Or to send children to a school that isn't subject to that sort of influence as much. But that is where huge inequities can start to arise.
If rich parents believe their children will get a crap education in the state system due to also sorts of extraneous woolly factors, they will likely pay to have their kids go to a private school where the education sandards are much higher.
However, parents who can't afford to do that, may have no choice but to leave their children in the state school environment.
Personally, I believe all children should be entitled to a high standard of education where the focus is strongly on gaining the necessary skills to succeed in life. So, to me, it is vitally important that our state system meets those standards.
"Personally, I believe all children should be entitled to a high standard of education where the focus is strongly on gaining the necessary skills to succeed in life. So, to me, it is vitally important that our state system meets those standards."
Agree. Delivering quality education should be focused on how to achieve competence in learners not (assumed) comfort for learners.
An understanding of prior principals building on each other is an overly simplistic way of looking at the topic. A lot of the university courses are covering subjects already fully covered by secondary school. The difference at university is that the topic is dealt with in excruciating detail. A second year calculus course begins with limit series needed to construct calculus, where secondary school would likely make do with a bit of a hand wave over what makes calculus work. A third year group theory course is really a more general description of basic arithmetic.
Also with any subject you will find many students who didn't get the earlier material and a range of proficiencies. For any subject it gets repeated multiple times year on year as thats more or less the nature of teaching it.
After adjusting for socio-economic factors, private schools and states schools have similar outcomes. You don't get a better education at a private school, you get a more advantaged network.
I had a quick browse through the docs. I don't think they are using critical, for maths, in the way that is being implied here. They mean critical as in "vital" – skills that are vital for living as an active citizen. They do talk about using maths in other areas as a way of providing evidence. I take all that to mean understanding percents, interest rates, proportional representation calculations, what makes a good survey, experiment or trial, being able to estimate things as a check to see if something makes sense.
The document seems to be about lifting the tail. The only talk about giftedness is bracketed with learning difficulties. I can see quite a bit of push-back coming from that area.
If rich parents believe their children will get a crap education in the state system due to also sorts of extraneous woolly factors, they will likely pay to have their kids go to a private school where the education standards are much higher.
Many of those schools teach you that god exists so I hardly think standards are higher. I'd argue the standards are pretty awful.
And from my experience this is much more accurate than your statement.
If rich white parents believe their children will go to school with too many non-white children in the state system they will likely pay to have their kids go to another state or a private school where the white proportions are much higher.
Algebra with its basis in simple arithmetic loses me and is akin to me watching someone do a magic spell that I don't have the recipe for.
Whereas I got the magic of algebra at an early age – well before high school but found trigonometry boring as anything. Like magic and much more exciting algebra and elegantly designed algorithms.
As one who missed out on basic arithmetic at primary school by the absence of our noted arithmetic teacher and the hopelessness of the reliever in the olden days I agree with the continued discussion on this point.
It was much later when an adult that I learned about maths people such as Fibonacci. (who is one of my 'heroes' now along with William Morris) I was taught tricks to help me with addition by my parents.
I loved trig and geometry. I was able to do these to 6th form level. This I put down to other influences reinforcing what was taught eg Brownies/Guides, time telling, compass work that focussed on the circle or sphere.
Algebra with its basis in simple arithmetic loses me and is akin to me watching someone do a magic spell that I don't have the recipe for.
So primary school maths needs to be basic and the teaching of it reinforced across all teachers, including relievers. It should not be possible for children in a primary school class to just lose maths ability because their teacher was sick for a month or so. We had remedial reading but no remedial maths.
As one who missed out on basic arithmetic at primary school by the absence of our noted arithmetic teacher and the hopelessness of the reliever in the olden days I agree with the continued discussion on this point.
I was similar. But I missed out in one of my high school years due to having a teacher with absolutely no class control. We called him "baldy King". The sole object of maths classes with him was for students to wind him up until he threw a wobbly and grabbed someone out of the class to cane them.
It became macarbe entertainment. He was probably brilliant at maths, but IMO should never have been a teacher.
I picked it up again at Uni where I did a couple of maths papers that caught me up with what I had missed out on.
I really love maths. Not because I am really good at it. But I admire greatly those who have a gift in that area.
I really love maths. Not because I am really good at it. But I admire greatly those who have a gift in that area.
I do too. I especially came to love it when I knew of its value/history in observation of the natural world and in basic design principles such as the golden ratio/perspective that we seem to know instinctively. In art I learned about these 'rules' so I could competently break them, to make people think and that was how I first researched Fibonnaci.
In art playing with perspective is fun and thought provoking. I have looked for, but cannot locate yet, a link that had very young children learning to add geometrical perpsective to their drawings. Including the concept of infinity and roads and lines leading to where we cannot exactly see.
While we love the house with the windows, door and perhaps a chimney that we get from our children, children themselves are not convinced apparently that it represents the real world they are trying to convey. Because they can see that the house has a side as well as a front.
Teaching children about perspective, which is a difficult concept for many to put down on paper, or think about was accepted by children in the study as a much appreciated way to represent the world.
If the concepts are taught young they can be built in/on later in formal maths teaching.
How about some reality! The NZ Government or “ the State,” has ALWAYS controlled NZ Education. The Department of Education as specifically set up to do just that. Then and now! Politicians are the problem, they can’t keep their stick fingers off Education!
I was involved in teacher education in mathematics for 10 years. My Masters thesis examined the barriers and affordances that teachers faced when teaching mathematics for social justice or critical maths. The case study had teachers present data that looked at inequity in wages, unemployment, housing, life expectancy as well as whether you could live on the minimum wage.
Student engagement was high and the students from Pacific nations over the period of the study moved from blaming themselves for inequity to realizing that the inequity was a result of systemic racism.
The mathematics learning was incredible but so was the integration with social science and that the students were talking about their learning at home with Aiga.
The teachers in the study also grew and when students made statements like Pacific people do not get high paying jobs because they do not do well at school, they were able to flip this to do Pacific talavou not do well at school or do schools not do well at teaching Pacific students?
I have done similar research in high decile schools and had similar results. Improved learning in mathematics as well as critical analysis of inequity. Done well it is a win win. Paulo Freire was an outstanding educator and if New Zealand schools were to introduce his pedagogy our society would be a far more equitable place than it currently is.
Well there are other things hapening and it's killing the site.
I guess that it ultimately depends on whether or not you want the comments section to be your personal platform to flog your hobby horse to death to an ever diminishing audience.
Still, if your ears are painted on and you don't want to listen then go for the doctor.
Well there are other things hapening and it's killing the site.
someone always ways that, every single time there is a hot topic that gets a lot of comments. Usually someone who doesn't like the topic. I empathise, there are plenty of conversations here that I'm sick of too. Imagine what it's like being a moderator. You at least can scroll on by. Better yet, put up some content to get people engaged in the things you want to talk about.
And it is that simple. We had a process that worked for the few who needed to transtion and that could have been tweeaked,
Instead we had the No Debate and 'men are women when we want to be' mindset rammed down our throats. This was followed by a baying crowd a beating or two to keep us in our place. I find the women-hate mind boggling, not to mention a little frightening.
When parts of the state seem to be part of this movement such as the Police non presence on 25/3 and the signing by the Human Rights Commissioner, Paul Hunt, who I assumed was non biased in appearance and fact to the Yogyakarta prinicples that have never been accepted by the UN.
You would think that bwaghorn, its not as if its tricky. Why the obfuscation and deflection on something so self evident ( to me anyway) is bewildering.
I guess that it ultimately depends on whether or not you want the comments section to be your personal platform to flog your hobby horse to death to an ever diminishing audience.
Do you say the same about the people who usually have threads on Russia/Ukraine?
Hmmmmm I didn't think so….only threads relating to 'women's stuff'
One is a clear political wedge issue, certainly here on TS, which is what we’re talking about, and the other is not. For example, did shit hit the fan when Zelenskyy spoke before NZ Parliament?
I can see your point. I sort of stopped reading Open Mike, because of the "trans debate". Every now and then I scroll through to find the bits I'm interested in, which hardly exist nowadays.
I suggest to split those "small culture war discussions", that's where I place trans debate (how many trans people are in the general population? More than 1%?), into a separate post. Or even better, people should fight it out on Facebook or Twitter etc.
It is not killing it. It is polarising it and wedging it into two sides on one site.
Trying to create a safe space were some commenters can talk safely amongst themselves is or should not be an issue – whether it is genuine debate is debatable. However, when this space is so tightly controlled & defended and others are not welcome unless they know the secret handshake and sing from the exact same and only sheet, then it runs contra to the kaupapa of this site, which is robust debate that is inclusive.
For my two pennies worth, the reason I don't comment much on Kiwiblog these days is that the comments section seems to have become infested with anti-vaxxers and climate change deniers, and commentors there seem quite boorish, and don't really enter into reasoned debate.
I haven't picked up the same vibe here yet with respect to women's rights etc. Probably the key difference is that people are at least prepared to discuss ideas politely.
if during the election campaign there is this level of sustained debate, I will probably start putting up some dedicated posts and asking people to comment there. Like we have done for the 2016 US election, or the parliament grounds occupation. But I am waiting to see if it settles down post KJK, and because I don't have time atm.
Looking at the number of posts, the site is doing well, but perhaps it would be better if topics with a large number of posts are reacted to by starting a new "thread", without needing much more than a paragraph outlining the topic and any obvious limits on the discussion. So for example a separate thread for trans debate may have been useful a week ago; it may have run for three or four days, and enabled Open Mike to cover a large number of other topics. Yes there is overlap and it gets a bit messy, but it would make it easier to track comments on a particular issue – and if the topic is kept ''alive'' by sufficient reasonable posts, it could be re-opened in a new thread every so often.
A separate issue is that I value the posts that are written by individuals to start a thread. The "right" have no similar equivalent – Kiwiblog remains a dog-whistle sewer, but the right do have a lot of blatant propaganda sites covering a wide range of extremism with a common link of being anti-government, and anti-this government in particular. I am not criticising those like MickySavage, MikeSmith, Weka and GuestPost that have written material that make good conversation starters and give good information; I just think that the left needs more people helping by bringing different views and covering other topics – refuting some of the bizarre assertions from the right, but also celebrating success and explaining difficulties rather than blaming. With an election coming up, there is a greater need than ever to counter mis-information through advertising facts about past performance and policies to help those supporting the left make informed choices and be able to counter lies from elsewhere.
the only reason I haven't set up a dedicated gender/sex post is that it's a fair amount of work to do and run and I've been busy. I've definitely been thinking about it. Too much of my time on TS has been taken up with moderating for things done by regulars who should know better.
I agree we need more peopel writing. I've been toying with the idea of a Debate of the Day post, where we post a topic and people can go discuss it here. I like the idea of using comments from regulars as Dotd, because lots of people bring good intros to the table.
Some Posts or topics do well in terms of numbers because people are emotionally (and/or ideologically) invested in them. Identity Politics ranks right up there [no pun intended]. Posts or topics with heavy intellectual [for want of a better word] investment are not so common because they require much more effort on behalf of the Author. They also require more mental work from commenters (and readers!). Don’t forget TS is competing with MSM and SM, among others, for time & attention of people. TS does not have anything to gain or lose in terms of advertisers on the site!!
I had thought of some subjects being used say once a week – examples could be Water, or Climate Change, or Celebrating success (of government), or Transport – they may concentrate discussion for that day, but also make it easier to track issues on Open Mike if there are a reduced number of concurrent threads. I appreciate the work done by the moderators; I was not wanting to make that work harder!
"I have a suggestion – can we have a ban on trans debate until after the election?"
Going too far but I second the sentiment. It is clearly putting commenters off this site. You only have to look at the OM posts to see that is happening. Perhaps the one trick ponies could be discouraged from hogging the posts and let other commenters introduce other arguably more urgent issues which beset the nation and elsewhere.
The Letting Women Speak post had the highest comments TS has seen in while. It got 4,800 views, most posts get under 1,000. My casual observation is that OM views and comments are high atm too (for a range of reasons).
Perhaps the people with antipathy towards women's sex based rights debate could start talking about the things they want to talk about instead of telling women to shut up. Anyone can post in OM. How about you put up a topic for discussion today Anne.
Perhaps the people with antipathy towards women's sex based rights debate could start talking about the things they want to talk about instead of telling women to shut up. Anyone can post in OM. How about you put up a topic for discussion today Anne.
Unreal Weka. We shut up so 'others' can debate 'other' things that 'others' have deemed more worthy.
If someone wants to read different topics then put up some different topics to discuss.
Go back on the boards and find a topic you would like to explore further and comment on that. It will show in the index of posts and people may find here is a topic I'd like to comment on/read.
Or is this related to serious techno things like in the olden days our dial ups couldn't cope with massive amounts of data coming in? If it is seriously related to constraints on data then perhaps there is a point. If it is constrained then how can we get more is it band width? I could put some $$$ forward.
I'm in agreement with Weka and Shanreagh here. A while ago, someone suggested that those who want to learn more could do a bit more listening, rather than blurting their 2c all the time.
I've been doing that (as in reading, rather than 'listening'), and have been well rewarded by the quality of argument.
Please don't ban this discussion, just because someone's 'tired' of it.
Yup, it takes up bandwidth & oxygen here, but some seem to regard this as good & desirable, apparently.
If the wishes of one group interfere with the quality of experience (aka enjoyment) of another group and start to become detrimental to the general good I think we have a problem. But not everybody sees it this way or wants to see it this way and if there’s no problem or the problem is downplayed there’s no need to change anything, is there?
I agree to an extent, this election is going to be won and lost on the economy, cost of living and housing. Everything else is window dressing.
The public are hurting, badly and they expect our politicians to be dedicating ALL of their time to the cost of living and housing crises, instead what a furious public see is left wing politicians and activists obsessing over skin colour, gender and sexuality and fighting amongst themselves and the public get angrier.
None of it puts food on tables or gets people in houses and that's all poll after poll tells us the public care about…. So yes I agree the left in general should stfu about identity politics till after the election
Buuuut at the same time, certain debates need to be had, the amount of rampant homophobia and misogyny coming from mainstream lefty's is scary to a lot of people.
When I was growing up it was the right and religious who didn't like gays, now it's the left, media, academia and "queer " organizations that hate gay men and women and call us genital fetishists, bigots, say we chose to be gay and reduce our sexuality to a preference that can be cured by being more open minded and we're not allowed to disagree or we could lose our jobs and be ostracized
And as for women, if they speak out about any concerns on sex based rights they get called a nazi and lose their jobs and risk getting punched over and having the left celebrate it.
And that loses us voters too.. not to mention, this is probably the only left wing place in NZ or indeed the internet that won't outright ban users for wanting to have cordial debate about concerns about gender ideology, so it not here, where?
And while I'd love for the election to be about the issues that matter, this is labour and the Greens we're talking about, they have no intention of campaigning or addressing cost of living and housing beyond band aid tweaks.
Labour and the Greens have shown zero ability to debate populist soc dem economic policy, their caucuses have almost zero first hand experience with poverty and they can't bring themselves to say the word poverty without the word child being in front of it.
Without identity politics the NZ has nothing! A few tweaks. A few payment increases.
So why can lesbians gays and women air their concerns about gender ideology? It's not like the left have anything resembling social democratic economic policies to debate.
Sanctuary – have to agree with your comments above. When one topic is constantly discussed day after day other important and interesting topics get lost or little opportunity for comment.
best way to remedy that is to go comment on posts that aren't about women's rights rather than expecting OM to be limited. Generate some discussion on other topics.
Come on weka. For some time now when people have tried to introduce another subject, their comments are often cancelled out by a sudden rush of trans and related subjects which leaves the unfortunate commenter's comment alone and unloved.
Nah. The GC debates generate energy which is why people are in them. There are non GC comments today and yet here you are talking about this instead of other topics. Can’t blame the GC debate for that.
Two weeks ago following the Posie P debacle it was noticeable – not so much now. Soon after some comments appeared on another topic, there was a GC pile-on following it so that it got lost in the melee. I doubt I was the only one who picked it up. It may have been a case where one person made an effort to start off the debate again and that pulled in the rest of them.
It is not good for this site's previous reputation for wide ranging and mostly informed conversations about topical issues both in NZ and overseas. That I am sure is what pulled in the lurkers who largely never comment but like to read the posts and some may even read the comments.
I suspect there are those who entered the GC debate on the basis of misinformation being promulgated (not by all commenters of course) and they felt compelled to say something.
totally agree anne. Im so over it, this is the first time for over a week that Ive looked in to TS. the topic seems to have overwhelmed the site. on behalf of the VAST majority who dont give a phuck about sexuality., can TS have a seperate page for the sex obsessed.
The issue is if intact males are able to enter female safe spaces as per new rules for magically turning a male to a female.
The more the actual issue is minimised the more it becomes of concern.
As Queen Victoria is alleged to have said I don't care what they do 'as long as it does not frighten the horses'. But that is NOT the issue.
I do not believe women should have to give up their safe spaces to cater for males.
How about we get men thinking about how to keep non conforming males safe in their spaces or if that is a bridge too far, then we get our best architects/ policy analysts on the job to design/plan for by alocation of $$$, the best spaces that allow for trans people while keeping women safe.
I find if difficult to understand why there is still this myth that women are concerned about what other people do sexually. For most/many/all of us who have commented here it has never been about this.
The reason why intact or minimally transitioned men will be able to enter women's spaces is because of the changes to the BDM Act allowing men to ostensibly change sex from male to female. And the reason this was a 'shoo in' was becasue of the 'No Debate' self ID that has whipped around the world.
Hopefully I have explained it clearly enough so that all who think it is about what people do privately can see this is not the issue/point.
There are calls to stop talking about the issue. With the lack of knowledge about what the issue is for women it seems many have remained stuck in their own one track of what they think the issue is.
Bwaghorn succinctly summed up the issues here
bwaghorn2.1.1.2.1
11 April 2023 at 10:15 am
I know he/she used the wrong word, but the rest of the comment is true. "The vast majority who don't give a phuck…"
It has been taken to a level beyond that which is appropriate. By all means lobby the government vociferously for whatever changes in the legislation you think would solve the problem.
Trans people also have safety fears if this opinion piece is any guide:
Look I am willing to take a break from the Gender critical stuff for a week or so, just to give everyone a breather.
However I don't like the idea of banning a topic, any topic that is.
The Standard is one of the few places that issue of gender ideology is debated and gender critical people such as myself get a chance to be heard.
If the msm were doing a balanced job then probably the Standard would not have been the place where the issue got brought up so much. And the recent events around Posie Parker of course escabated that. Women again were silenced, this time by an angry violent mob.
So look, I'll hold back from GC for a week (I still intend to comment on other issues).
I am not suggesting this for anyone else. Up to them.
If I can think of a way that debate could me more constructive about the issue then I will.
Please don't take a break Anker. I don't comment much but I am an avid reader of this topic – its like this is my community where this topic can be aired – not many places like this. Would banning this topic would be adopting 'No Debate'.?
Thanks Beverly. I agree so few places where GC views get any airing whatsoever.
I was thinking I would heed some of the voices on this site and stop posting about GC stuff for a week or so and I didn't mean anyone else should do this.
In posting on GC stuff, I do have the hope that some people who are unsure about the issue will start to read stuff and realize the debate isn't about trans people, but an ideology that is highly problematic.
Like with any intense arguement, sometimes time out isn't a bad idea.
An idea I have about the debate is to keep it to the absolute basics (see Bwagons comment) e.g Should someone who identifies as a women but is a biological male be allowed in womens spaces? changing rooms, sport,prisons etc. Almost like a survey, tick yes or no. Then give reasons why. Should we have to use someone's pro nouns yes or no?
From my point of view the Standard has provided outstanding information from a gender critical view and I thank Weka, Shanreagh, Molly, Sabine, Visu, Roblogic, Gsays, Bwagon, Liberty Belle and my apologies for those who have been left out.
I am going to make a commitment though. From this afternoon for a week I will refrain from raising GC with the priviso that if there are any significant developements I reserve the right to comment.
An idea I have about the debate is to keep it to the absolute basics (see Bwagons comment) e.g Should someone who identifies as a women but is a biological male be allowed in womens spaces? changing rooms, sport,prisons etc. Almost like a survey, tick yes or no. Then give reasons why. Should we have to use someone's pro nouns yes or no?
That is a great idea.
I think the ones ticking yes could be the ones who could be asked to do the explainer. Other than these
transwomen are women, which is not an argument more of a circle.
it won't be banned. At some point I might put up some dedicated posts like we have for other hot topics in the past, and ask that people comment there.
In the back-end. Can’t remember exactly when. I remember seeing the bush fires flaring up frequently then too here and that it was having a divisive negative effect on TS. Things are worse now, IMO.
it does take a fair amount of work. I'm tossing up whether it's more work than what I'm having to currently do. Also waiting to see if things settle down post KJK, and whether the right are intent on making it an election issue.
Weka, my suggestion is that you could do realitively short, concise posts on the topic for comment focussed on specific issues. Then, the topic stays available for comment, but doesn't require huge amounts of work and research.
I made this suggestion (sorry I don't know how to create a link to it)
Comment:Open mike 30/09/2021
I certainly don't support banning a topic but if there had been a "Daily GC Chat" thread the animosity that has developed (on both sides of the argument) may not have developed.
If you click on the time/date stamp of any comment, it changes the address in the address bar to a permanent direct link. You can then copy and paste it into a comment (put a . at the start so it embeds right).
Thanks Weka, and my apologies, it was addressed to The Moderators and rereading it you weren't part of any of that thread, but I stand by the suggestion that a Daily GC Chat would give everyone the option of sharing their opinions without monopolising Open Mike.
the main difference between the BDMRR debate and now is that then there were lots of days when there were no comments on that topic. Atm there are comments on gender/sex daily. I’ll have a look this week at putting up a dedicated post, it won’t be daily but people can keep commenting under it over successive days. Maybe a new post a few times a week.
Not really. From a moderator perspective hot topics having a dedicated post can improve debate.
when this was raised during the BDMRR debate, it looked like some people wanted the conversations to not be happening, but here the overriding issue is simply whether OM is overloaded.
there’s a risk that dedicated posts will end up being an echo chamber of GCs. If that happens I suggest using the threads to do something constructive 😈
My sole reason for saying is so as not to add to your workload.
It seems that the possible inablity for others to cope with scrolling past an issue they are not interested in means that to meet these 'concerns' the workload fall on another person.
I did ask if it was a data/tech problem as I used to have when I was on my old dial up. If it is a tech problem then by all means look for a way around this and separate topics might be a way
I have the idea though it is not this but a 'I can't be bothered with this issue and so everyone who is should go away'
If you, on whom the solution rests, are happy then that is fine. perhaps the ones with the concerns could lend a hand moderating or post writing. (you know learning by doing)
you seem to be missing the point Shanreagh. If OM gets overloaded on a hot topic (it happens periodically, it’s not about gender/sex), then debate improves when we create dedicated posts. I’ve been waiting until it’s been sufficient a problem to warrant spending my time on it. People wanting the gender/sex debate to go away aren’t my primary motivation (or any motivation at all really). People saying that there’s too much and OM is overloaded matters.
I think this whole area of the increasing influence of state and media on our lives needs to be debated, given there is an election coming up.
I see a useful analogy being that of an incoming tide.
For some of us, especially on the right, we feel we have been flooded years ago. However, the tide seems to keep coming in, progressively swamping those with more liberal mindsets. So, eventually, we all feel we are in the same situation of being flooded by ideology we don't want.
However, at its core is the same ideology. It is just creeping further and further into our lives.
Smithy, welcome to a country/globe coping with a climate catastrophe.
There is no way, no way 'individual rights' will overcome the climate crisis. That will take concerted state action – ie, the state will have to become much more intrusive in our everyday lives – if we are going to have a snowball's hope in hell of getting through what's coming.
the state will have to become much more intrusive in our everyday lives – if we are going to have a snowball's hope in hell of getting through what's coming.
I would probably agree with you on that score if states (with the emphasis on states) can get their act together in a co-ordinated manner. Especially the large ones who are the biggest contributors to the problem. If they can't then I really do despair.
I have already suggested in earlier posts that there needs to be an internationally co-ordinated approach for how we do farming, with farming taking place in the most productive parts of the world so the planet can be fed and carbon emissions from agriculture minimised.
But we are talking about an existential crisis for many in this case.
However, a lot of the other stuff I am concerned about has nothing to do with an existential crisis. But more to do with creeping state control and intrusion into our lives.
Well-ordered, legitimate democratic states are much less of a threat to our freedom than the unaccountable and unelected private power that results from having lots of money. As TV implies at 5.1, it is this private power that has stalled state action on climate change.
Put another way, the greatest threat to our freedom is inequality. That formulation, which is true, stands on its head the nonsensical neoliberal formulation, that inequality is a sign of our freedom
Put another way, the greatest threat to our freedom is inequality.
I actually agree with you, and see that inequality so far as education goes is the most important area of inequality.
IMO people who go to a state school should be able to expect a standard of education that equates to what children from rich parents can get from a private school. Hence, why I have been banging on about this topic.
I believe that good education is the doorway out of poverty, as I am sure many could attest to.
Meanwhile, TRAs are promoting suicide. This is fucked up for its primary message but it also contaminates NZ’s already dangerous culture around suicide.
Could be a false flag op. But it’s consistent with TRA approaches so either way genderist progressives need to stop denying the problems and step up and address them.
Possibly. Which political party wants people to discuss this issue when they get to work – and wants workplace consequences stories in the public media?
Do you know I am sure this is going to be put in the too hard basket by NZ Police just like the assault by a transactivist on a 71 year old woman on 25/3/23 seems to have been.
Also in the basket is unactioned thoughts and plans to police public events so that they do not not get overrun by antis,
Another weird chapter is being played out in the bizarre world of US politics with Donald Trump moving to block Mike Pence from testifying in the special counsel's Jan. 6 probe.
When the Jan 6 Committee was organised claims were made that those who had vital information wouldn't be heard. To accentuate the point Jim Jordan violated House ethics by defying subpoenas to appear. Those who had most intimate knowledge and involvement refused to give evidence then complained that the 'true story' wasn't coming out.
It seems now Pence won't appeal a federal judge's order that he testify before the grand jury in special counsel Jack Smith’s investigation so maybe more of the real story will emerge.
Clearly Trump wanted Pence, in whatever way, to be 'taken out' on Jan 6. Now he's is trying other strategies to shut him up.
Some weeks after cloaking a jury in complete anonymity to preside over E. Jean Carroll’s lawsuit accusing former President Donald Trump of rape, a federal judge refused to relax that ruling even enough to confidentially share their identities with the attorneys.
Senior U.S. District Judge Lewis Kaplan said he couldn’t issue such an order in “good conscience,” especially in light of Trump’s continuing attacks on the jurist presiding over the former president’s criminal case.
Something else that concerns me about our education system is that it appears to be churning out people who have lost the ability to debate issues in a reasoned fashion.
It seems that today, the only way many see to counter views they dislike is to shout people down and belittle them with irrational claims about them being Nazis or whatever. We see this a lot in cancel culture, where the goal seems to be to challenge ideas by preventing them from being voiced, rather than by countering those views with better ideas.
I really don't know how this method of dealing with uncomfortable ideas has developed. Is it perhaps because schools overemphasise the value of protest? And, protest certainly has its place. But, I think the contest of ideas needs to be won first.
This often happens when views become so extreme in one direction that many become concerned and reject said views.
I certainly would agree with the sentiment of a lot of what is suggested, in that I think my views are fairly clear that a lot of this stuff falls well outside the responsibility of schools to provide a good grounding in core subjects.
But, whether it is throwing the baby out with the bathwater? It certainly seems a very hard core rejection of woke culture.
I haven't given it enough thought to have a firm view on that. Banning books etc seems a bit extreme, and seems to be taking a similar approach to many of the “woke” academics who have been doing the same sort of thing in the opposite direction.
The nature of a pendulum is that it swings both sides. Life is very much a pendulum, and always remember ' this too shall pass' be it good, bad or just mediocre.
Banning books or 'challenging them' is quite a normal thing and is happening to many many books in the US. A list here
And some of Dr Seus's books etc so far as children's books go.
I don't think banning books, or banning people from speaking etc does any good for a cause ultimately. All ideas are contestable IMO and should be available to read. As should books or information that counter views expressed in said books.
I had a valuable lesson in this as a teenager. I was right into a book called “Chariots of the Gods” by Erich Von Daniken. The thesis of his book was that ancient technology could only be explained by earth being visited by aliens, and the result being a quantum leap in human knowledge.
However, my mother was very wise, and gave me another book “Crash go the chariots”. This book dismantled the Von Daniken’s thesis completely.
The unwise approach would have been for her to take the Von Daniken’s book away and forbid me from reading it.
I enjoyed Von Daniken. Not that I believed it, but it's like Fantasy fiction … 'what if' it were true!
There's a lovely reference in one of David Brin's novels – ("Sundiver" I think) – where there really are aliens, and they are massively insulted by the Von Danikenite assumption that they would have just walked off and abandoned the primitive cultures!
I was a gullible teenager back then, so was quite taken in by it until I read the book my mother gave me.
But some of the stuff in there was still incredibly interesting. Like those massive ground paintings of animals and such in Peru I think, that can only be viewed from the air. I think Van Daniken argued that they were to guide in space ships or something similar.
But, I think a more logical explanation is that they were sun god worshippers back then, and so probably thought they were making things big enough to be seen by their god as it was.
Von Daniken always reminded me of the 'just so stories' (how the elephant got it's trunk) – inventing a story to explain a physical artefact – based on internal 'logic' rather than external validated data.
I was not allowed to read certain books at the convent, so at age 9 i head read all the roman catholic gore that exists, and there is a lot of it. Believe me there are not many patron saints that did not die horrible death of burnings, stabbings, removing the intestines, quartering/drawing, drowning, rape, etc etc etc etc.
St. Sabine was either devoured by a lion, or killed otherwise in the circus for not wanting to sex with the murderer of her husband.
Sometimes what is forbidden might be an easier read then what is allowed.
Geisel’s stepdaughter, Lark Grey Dimond-Cates, told the New York Post there “wasn’t a racist bone in that man’s body”, but also said suspending publication of the six titles was “a wise decision”. But the controversy left many perplexed, since the decision was made by Dr Seuss Enterprises and not as a result of public pressure that has preceded other such decisions.
Nel said the decision to no longer publish titles that include racist caricatures showed just one way to address problematic material.
“[The books are] not going to disappear,” he said. “They’re not being banned. They’re not being cancelled. It’s just a decision to no longer sell them.”
The Governor of Florida gets bad press. When I saw a headline "No One Is Talking About What Ron DeSantis Has Actually Done to Florida" I presumed I'd see the ledger put right. Wrong.
We discussed this a little after the parliamentary protest when we were pondering, well some of us were, how to prevent people from being swayed by basically hoax material. Critical thinking etc, in the old sense of the word. Sharpening our wits etc
Is people losing the ability to debate issues in a reasoned fashion the fault of the formal education system? Did you mean society is churning out people who have lost the ability to debate issues in a reasoned fashion?
Kids are strongly discouraged from debate – there is the 'received wisdom' and arguing a contrary point of view will get you a trip to the principal – because you are racist/sexist/phobic or whatever other buzzword you've offended against.
Your teachers and peers are special snowflakes, who are wholly unable to cope with a different viewpoint.
The new religion?…the west (mainly) has abandoned formal religions and so creates de facto replacements…and we have become increasingly sectarian…some align with Mammon, others hedonism.and a multitude of alternatives.
But it appears many are seeking meaning(?) as a replacement….perhaps our ancestors understood something we have forgotten?…and yet the argument against formal religion is valid.
Ha ha as my former boss Labour Minister) used to say 'once they start laughing at you….'The Greens and Hipkins may find that laughter has a duration they were not expecting.
Justin Jones shows the power of oratory, steeped in the glorious rythms and language of the black preachers like MLK. He really kicks of at about the five minute mark, searing stuff.
Ardern’s office told The Spinoff that the listing is fake – and Ardern herself had no idea it existed. “Ms Ardern was not aware of this website page before now, and the listing is certainly not authorised by her,” a government spokesperson said.
Despite this, Sean Plunket’s media outlet The Platform has pushed the idea that Ardern has been hiding her new speaking engagement from the public. A post on The Platform’s Facebook yesterday teased “the new job Ardern doesn’t want you to know about” and said that Plunket would be revealing the “untold truth” on Tuesday morning. “A truth legacy media kept secret or didn’t want to ask about,” the post continued. The claims were shared by users on Twitter.
Plunket later tweeted: “nice work if you can get it” with a screenshot of the fake Ardern listing.
See joe90’s comment to which I replied and form your own judgement.
PS I had another longer answer for you typed out but my sense of humour is not welcome here and I don’t really want to rile up others. It’s a pity because it is actually quite good 😉
An insightful article on declining trust in the media that contains good info & analysis.
“People are really grumpy with the government and if you go through a pandemic, a cyclone – all the things that New Zealand's been through – emotionally, you want to take it out on someone,” he said.
…
There's a whole lot of feelings that come up for people who are news consumers, and even if it's falling parallel to the loss of trust in government or education or other things in an increasingly polarised society … trust is falling and it is a big issue,” he said.
So time to do a Chasers style collection for the farmers, from people who’ve just lost their home to a flood or just from the rest of us struggling with inflation?
‘And on that point, we should remember that any failure to meet our Paris target can be laid at the feet of one noisy, greedy, selfish group: farmers. Less than 5% of the population, they produce 50% of our emissions, and are refusing to reduce them. …
…
Their refusal is on-track to cost us $24 billion. Its only fair that they should be the ones who pay for it.’
This video includes personal musings and conclusions of the creator climate scientist Dr. Adam Levy. It is presented to our readers as an informed perspective. Please see video description for references (if any). Wherever you look, you'll hear headlines claiming we've passed 1.5 degrees of global warming. And while 2024 saw ...
Photo by Heather M. Edwards on UnsplashHere’s the key news, commentary, reports and debate around Aotearoa’s politics and economy in the week to Feb 10 below. That’s ahead of live chats on the Substack App and The Kākā’s front page on Substack at 5pm with: on his column in The ...
Is there anyone in the world the National Party loves more than a campaign donor? Why yes, there is! They will always have the warmest hello and would you like to slip into something more comfortable for that great god of our age, the High Net Worth Individual.The words the ...
Waste and fraud certainly exist in foreign aid programs, but rightwing celebration of USAID’s dismantling shows profound ignorance of the value of soft power (as opposed to hard power) in projecting US influence and interests abroad by non-military/coercive means (think of “hearts and minds,” “hugs, not bullets,” “honey versus vinegar,” ...
Health New Zealand is proposing to cut almost half of its data and digital positions – more than 1000 of them. The PSA has called on the Privacy Commissioner to urgently investigate the cuts due to the potential for serious consequences for patients. NZNO is calling for an urgent increase ...
We may see a few more luxury cars on Queen Street, but a loosening of rules to entice rich foreigners to invest more here is unlikely to “turbocharge our economic growth”. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāLong stories short, the top six things in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate ...
Let us not dance daintily around the elephant in the room. Our politicians who serve us in the present are not honest, certainly not as honest as they should be, and while the right are taking out most of the trophies for warping narratives and literally redefining “facts”, the kiwi ...
A few weeks ago I took a look at public transport ridership in 2024. In today’s post I’m going to be looking a bit deeper at bus ridership. Buses make up the vast majority of ridership in Auckland with 70 million boardings last year out of a total of 89.4 ...
Oh, you know I did itIt's over and I feel fineNothing you could say is gonna change my mindWaited and I waited the longest nightNothing like the taste of sweet declineSongwriters: Chris Shiflett / David Eric Grohl / Nate Mendel / Taylor Hawkins.Hindsight is good, eh?The clarity when the pieces ...
Photo by Towfiqu barbhuiya on UnsplashHere’s what we’re watching in the week to February 16 and beyond in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty:Monday, February 10The Kākā’s weekly wrap-up of news about politics and the economy is due at midday, followed by webinar for paying subscribers in Substack’s ...
A listing of 23 news and opinion articles we found interesting and shared on social media during the past week: Sun, February 2, 2025 thru Sat, February 8, 2025. This week's roundup is again published soleley by category. We are still interested in feedback to hone the categorization, so if ...
Today, I stumbled across a Twitter Meme: the ending of The Lord of the Rings as a Chess scenario: https://x.com/mellon_heads/status/1887983845917564991 It gets across the basic gist. Aragorn and Gandalf offering up ‘material’ at the Morannon allows Frodo and Samwise to catch Sauron unawares – fair enough. But there are a ...
Last week, Kieran McAnulty called out Chris Bishop and Nicola Willis for their claims that Kāinga Ora’s costs were too high.They had claimed Kāinga Ora’s cost were 12% higher than market i.e. private devlopersBut Kāinga Ora’s Chair had already explained why last year:"We're not building to sell, so we'll be ...
Stuff’s Political Editor Luke Malpass - A Fellow at New Zealand IniativeLast week I half-joked that Stuff / The Post’s Luke Malpass1 always sounded like he was auditioning for a job at the New Zealand Initiative.Mountain Tui is a reader-supported publication. For a limited time, subscriptions are 20% off. Thanks ...
At a funeral on Friday, there were A4-sized photos covering every wall of the Dil’s reception lounge. There must have been 200 of them, telling the story in the usual way of the video reel but also, by enlargement, making it more possible to linger and step in.Our friend Nicky ...
Skeptical Science is partnering with Gigafact to produce fact briefs — bite-sized fact checks of trending claims. This fact brief was written by Sue Bin Park from the Gigafact team in collaboration with members from our team. You can submit claims you think need checking via the tipline. Is methane the ...
The Government’s idea is that the private sector and Community Housing Providers will fund, build and operate new affordable housing to address our housing crisis. Meanwhile, the Government does not know where almost half of the 1,700 children who left emergency housing actually went. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāLong ...
Oh, home, let me come homeHome is wherever I'm with youOh, home, let me come homeHome is wherever I'm with youSongwriters: Alexander Ebert / Jade Allyson CastrinosMorena,I’m on a tight time frame this morning. In about an hour and a half, I’ll need to pack up and hit the road ...
This is a post about the Mountain Tui substack, and small tweaks - further to the poll and request post the other day. Please don’t read if you aren’t interested in my personal matters. Thank you all.After oohing-and-aahing about how to structure the Substack model since November, including obtaining ...
This transcript of a recent conversation between the Prime Minister and his chief economic adviser has not been verified.We’ve announced we are the ‘Yes Government’. Do you like it?Yes, Prime Minister.Dreamed up by the PR team. It’s about being committed to growth. Not that the PR team know anything about ...
The other day, Australian Senator Nick McKim issued a warning in the Australian Parliement about the US’s descent into fascim.And of course it’s true, but I lament - that was true as soon as Trump won.What we see is now simply the reification of the intention, planning, and forces behind ...
Among the many other problems associated with Musk/DOGE sending a fleet of teenage and twenty-something cultists to remove, copy and appropriate federal records like social security, medicaid and other supposedly protected data is the fact that the youngsters doing the data-removal, copying and security protocol and filter code over-writing have ...
Jokerman dance to the nightingale tuneBird fly high by the light of the moonOh, oh, oh, JokermanSong by Bob Dylan.Morena folks, I hope this fine morning of the 7th of February finds you well. We're still close to Paihia, just a short drive out of town. Below is the view ...
It’s been an eventful week as always, so here’s a few things that we have found interesting. We also hope everyone had a happy and relaxing Waitangi Day! This week in Greater Auckland We’re still running on summer time, but provided two chewy posts: On Tuesday, a guest ...
Queuing on Queen St: the Government is set to announce another apparently splashy growth policy on Sunday of offering residence visas to wealthy migrants. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāLong stories short, the top six things in our political economy around housing, climate and poverty on Friday, February 7:PM Christopher ...
The fact that Waitangi ended up being such a low-key affair may mark it out as one of the most significant Waitangi Days in recent years. A group of women draped in “Toitu Te Tiriti” banners who turned their backs on the politicians’ powhiri was about as rough as it ...
Hi,This week’s Flightless Bird episode was about “fake seizure guy” — a Melbourne man who fakes seizures in order to get members of the public to sit on him.The audio documentary (which I have included in this newsletter in case you don’t listen to Flightless Bird) built on reporting first ...
This is a re-post from Yale Climate Connections by Karin Kirk The 119th Congress comes with a price tag. The oil and gas industry gave about $24 million in campaign contributions to the members of the U.S. House and Senate expected to be sworn in January 3, 2025, according to a ...
Early morning, the shadows still long, but you can already feel the warmth building. Our motel was across the road from the historic homestead where Henry Williams' family lived. The evening before, we wandered around the gardens, reading the plaques and enjoying the close proximity to the history of the ...
Thanks folks for your feedback, votes and comments this week. I’ll be making the changes soon. Appreciate all your emails, comments and subscriptions too. I know your time is valuable - muchas gracias.A lot is happening both here and around the world - so I want to provide a snippets ...
Data released today by Statistics NZ shows that unemployment rose to 5.1%, with 33,000 more people out of work than last year said NZCTU Te Kauae Kaimahi Economist Craig Renney. “The latest data shows that employment fell in Aotearoa at its fastest rate since the GFC. Unemployment rose in 8 ...
The December labour market statistics have been released, showing yet another increase in unemployment. There are now 156,000 unemployed - 34,000 more than when National took office. And having thrown all these people out of work, National is doubling down on cruelty. Because being vicious will somehow magically create the ...
Boarded up homes in Kilbirnie, where work on a planned development was halted. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāLong stories short, the top six things in our political economy around housing, climate and poverty on Wednesday, February 5 are;Housing Minister Chris Bishop yesterday announcedKāinga Ora would be stripped of ...
This week Kiwirail and Auckland Transport were celebrating the completion of the summer rail works that had the network shut or for over a month and the start of electric trains to Pukekohe. First up, here’s parts of the press release about the shutdown works. Passengers boarding trains in Auckland ...
Through its austerity measures, the coalition government has engineered a rise in unemployment in order to reduce inflation while – simultaneously – cracking down harder and harder on the people thrown out of work by its own policies. To that end, Social Development Minister Louise Upston this week added two ...
This year, we've seen a radical, white supremacist government ignoring its Tiriti obligations, refusing to consult with Māori, and even trying to legislatively abrogate te Tiriti o Waitangi. When it was criticised by the Waitangi Tribunal, the government sabotaged that body, replacing its legal and historical experts with corporate shills, ...
Poor old democracy, it really is in a sorry state. It would be easy to put all the blame on the vandals and tyrants presently trashing the White House, but this has been years in the making. It begins with Margaret Thatcher and Ronald Reagan and the spirit of Gordon ...
The new school lunches came in this week, and they were absolutely scrumptious.I had some, and even though Connor said his tasted like “stodge” and gave him a sore tummy, I myself loved it!Look at the photos - I knew Mr Seymour wouldn’t lie when he told us last year:"It ...
The tighter sanctions are modelled on ones used in Britain, which did push people off ‘the dole’, but didn’t increase the number of workers, and which evidence has repeatedly shown don’t work. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāLong stories short, the top six things in our political economy around housing, ...
Catching you up on the morning’s global news and a quick look at the parallels -GLOBALTariffs are backSharemarkets in the US, UK and Europe have “plunged” in response to Trump’s tariffs. And while Mexico has won a one month reprieve, Canada and China will see their respective 25% and 10% ...
This post by Nicolas Reid was originally published on Linked in. It is republished here with permission. Gondolas are often in the news, with manufacturers of ropeway systems proposing them as a modern option for mass transit systems in New Zealand. However, like every next big thing in transport, it’s hard ...
This is a re-post from The Climate BrinkBoth 2023 and 2024 were exceptionally warm years, at just below and above 1.5C relative to preindustrial in the WMO composite of surface temperature records, respectively. While we are still working to assess the full set of drivers of this warmth, it is clear that ...
Hi,I woke up feeling nervous this morning, realising that this weekend Flightless Bird is going to do it’s first ever live show. We’re heading to a sold out (!) show in Seattle to test the format out in front of an audience. If it works, we’ll do more. I want ...
From the United-For-Now States of America comes the thrilling news that a New Zealander may be at the very heart of the current coup. Punching above our weight on the world stage once more! Wait, you may be asking, what New Zealander? I speak of Peter Thiel, made street legal ...
Even Stevens: Over the 33 years between 1990 and 2023 (and allowing for the aberrant 2020 result) the average level of support enjoyed by the Left and Right blocs, at roughly 44.5 percent each, turns out to be, as near as dammit, identical.WORLDWIDE, THE PARTIES of the Left are presented ...
Back in 2023, a "prominent political figure" went on trial for historic sex offences. But we weren't allowed to know who they were or what political party they were "prominent" in, because it might affect the way we voted. At the time, I said that this was untenable; it was ...
I'm going, I'm goingWhere the water tastes like wineI'm going where the water tastes like wineWe can jump in the waterStay drunk all the timeI'm gonna leave this city, got to get awayI'm gonna leave this city, got to get awayAll this fussing and fighting, man, you know I sure ...
Waitangi Day is a time to honour Te Tiriti o Waitangi and stand together for a just and fair Aotearoa. Across the motu, communities are gathering to reflect, kōrero, and take action for a future built on equity and tino rangatiratanga. From dawn ceremonies to whānau-friendly events, there are ...
Subscribe to Mountain Tūī ! Where you too can learn about exciting things from a flying bird! Tweet.Yes - I absolutely suck at marketing. It’s a fact.But first -My question to all readers is:How should I set up the Substack model?It’s been something I’ve been meaning to ask since November ...
Here’s the key news, commentary, reports and debate around Aotearoa’s political economy on politics and in the week to Feb 3:PM Christopher Luxon began 2025’s first day of Parliament last Tuesday by carrying on where left off in 2024, letting National’s junior coalition partner set the political agenda and dragging ...
The PSA have released a survey of 4000 public service workers showing that budget cuts are taking a toll on the wellbeing of public servants and risking the delivery of essential services to New Zealanders. Economists predict that figures released this week will show continued increases in unemployment, potentially reaching ...
The Prime Minister’s speech 10 days or so ago kicked off a flurry of commentary. No one much anywhere near the mainstream (ie excluding Greens supporters) questioned the rhetoric. New Zealand has done woefully poorly on productivity for a long time and we really need better outcomes, and the sorts ...
President Trump on the day he announced tariffs against Mexico, Canada and China, unleashing a shock to supply chains globally that is expected to slow economic growth and increase inflation for most large economies. Photo: Getty ImagesLong stories short, the top six things in our political economy around housing, climate ...
Photo by Towfiqu barbhuiya on UnsplashHere’s what we’re watching in the week to February 9 and beyond in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty:Monday, February 3Politics: New Zealand Government cabinet meeting usually held early afternoon with post-cabinet news conference possible at 4 pm, although they have not been ...
Trump being Trump, it won’t come as a shock to find that he regards a strong US currency (bolstered by high tariffs on everything made by foreigners) as a sign of America’s virility, and its ability to kick sand in the face of the world. Reality is a tad more ...
A listing of 24 news and opinion articles we found interesting and shared on social media during the past week: Sun, January 26, 2025 thru Sat, February 1, 2025. This week's roundup is again published soleley by category. We are still interested in feedback to hone the categorization, so if ...
What seems to be the common theme in the US, NZ, Argentina and places like Italy under their respective rightwing governments is what I think of as “the politics of cruelty.” Hate-mongering, callous indifference in social policy-making, corporate toadying, political bullying, intimidation and punching down on the most vulnerable with ...
If you are confused, check with the sunCarry a compass to help you alongYour feet are going to be on the groundYour head is there to move you aroundSo, stand in the place where you liveSongwriters: Bill Berry / Michael Mills / Michael Stipe / Peter Buck.Hot in the CityYesterday, ...
Shane Jones announced today he would be contracting out his thinking to a smarter younger person.Reclining on his chaise longue with a mouth full of oysters and Kina he told reporters:Clearly I have become a has-been, a palimpsest, an epigone, a bloviating fossil. I find myself saying such things as: ...
Warning: This post contains references to sexual assaultOn Saturday, I spent far too long editing a video on Tim Jago, the ACT Party President and criminal, who has given up his fight for name suppression after 2 years. He voluntarily gave up just in time for what will be a ...
Skeptical Science is partnering with Gigafact to produce fact briefs — bite-sized fact checks of trending claims. This fact brief was written by Sue Bin Park from the Gigafact team in collaboration with members from our team. You can submit claims you think need checking via the tipline. Is global warming ...
Our low-investment, low-wage, migration-led and housing-market-driven political economy has delivered poorer productivity growth than the rest of the OECD, and our performance since Covid has been particularly poor. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāLong stories short, the top six things in our political economy around housing, climate and poverty this ...
..Thanks for reading Frankly Speaking ! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.As far as major government announcements go, a Three Ministers Event is Big. It can signify a major policy development or something has gone Very Well, or an absolute Clusterf**k. When Three Ministers assemble ...
One of those blasts from the past. Peter Dunne – originally neoliberal Labour, then leader of various parties that sought to work with both big parties (generally National) – has taken to calling ...
Completed reads for January: I Am Legend, by Richard Matheson The Black Spider, by Jeremias Gotthelf The Spider and the Fly (poem), by Mary Howitt A Noiseless Patient Spider (poem), by Walt Whitman August Heat, by W.F. Harvey Charlotte’s Web, by E.B. White The Shrinking Man, by Richard Matheson ...
Do its Property Right Provisions Make Sense?Last week I pointed out that it is uninformed to argue that the New Zealand’s apparently poor economic performance can be traced only to poor regulations. Even were there evidence they had some impact, there are other factors. Of course, we should seek to ...
Richard Wagstaff It was incredibly jarring to hear the hubris from the Prime Minister during his recent state of the nation address. I had just spent close to a week working though the stories and thoughts shared with us by nearly 2000 working people as part of our annual Mood ...
Odd fact about the Broadcasting Standards Authority: for the last few years, they’ve only been upholding about 5% of complaints. Why? I think there’s a range of reasons. Generally responsible broadcasters. Dumb complaints. Complaints brought under the wrong standard. Greater adherence to broadcasters’ rights to freedom of expression in the ...
And I said, "Mama, mama, mama, why am I so alone"'Cause I can't go outside, I'm scared I might not make it homeWell I'm alive, I'm alive, but I'm sinking inIf there's anyone at home at your place, darlingWhy don't you invite me in?Don't try to feed me'Cause I've been ...
Climate Change Minister Simon Watts’ star is on the rise, having just added the Energy, Local Government and Revenue portfolios to his responsibilities - but there is nothing ambitious about the Government’s new climate targets. Photo: SuppliedLong stories short, the top six things in our political economy around housing, climate ...
New Zealand First has introduced a Member’s Bill aimed at preventing banks from refusing their services to businesses because of the current “Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) Framework”. “This Bill ensures fairness and prevents ESG standards from perpetuating woke ideology in the banking sector being driven by unelected, globalist, climate ...
Erica Stanford has reached peak shortsightedness if today’s announcement is anything to go by, picking apart immigration settings piece by piece to the detriment of the New Zealand economy. ...
Our originating document, theTreaty of Waitangi, was signed on February 6, 1840. An agreement between Māori and the British Crown. Initially inked by Ngā Puhi in Waitangi, further signatures were added as it travelled south. The intention was to establish a colony with the cession of sovereignty to the Crown, ...
Te Whatu Ora Chief Executive Margie Apa leaving her job four months early is another symptom of this government’s failure to deliver healthcare for New Zealanders. ...
The Green Party is calling for the Prime Minister to show leadership and be unequivocal about Aotearoa New Zealand’s opposition to a proposal by the US President to remove Palestinians from Gaza. ...
The latest unemployment figures reveal that job losses are hitting Māori and Pacific people especially hard, with Māori unemployment reaching a staggering 9.7% for the December 2024 quarter and Pasifika unemployment reaching 10.5%. ...
Waitangi 2025: Waitangi Day must be community and not politically driven - Shane Jones Our originating document, theTreaty of Waitangi, was signed on February 6, 1840. An agreement between Māori and the British Crown. Initially inked by Ngā Puhi in Waitangi, further signatures were added as it travelled south. ...
Despite being confronted every day with people in genuine need being stopped from accessing emergency housing – National still won’t commit to building more public houses. ...
The Green Party says the Government is giving up on growing the country’s public housing stock, despite overwhelming evidence that we need more affordable houses to solve the housing crisis. ...
Before any thoughts of the New Year and what lies ahead could even be contemplated, New Zealand reeled with the tragedy of Senior Sergeant Lyn Fleming losing her life. For over 38 years she had faithfully served as a front-line Police officer. Working alongside her was Senior Sergeant Adam Ramsay ...
Green Party co-leader Marama Davidson will return to politics at Waitangi on Monday the 3rd of February where she will hold a stand up with fellow co-leader Chlöe Swarbrick. ...
Te Pāti Māori is appalled by the government's blatant mishandling of the school lunch programme. David Seymour’s ‘cost-saving’ measures have left tamariki across Aotearoa with unidentifiable meals, causing distress and outrage among parents and communities alike. “What’s the difference between providing inedible food, and providing no food at all?” Said ...
The Government is doubling down on outdated and volatile fossil fuels, showing how shortsighted and destructive their policies are for working New Zealanders. ...
Green Party MP Steve Abel this morning joined Coromandel locals in Waihi to condemn new mining plans announced by Shane Jones in the pit of the town’s Australian-owned Gold mine. ...
The Green Party is calling on the Government to strengthen its just-announced 2030-2035 Nationally Determined Contribution (NDC) under the Paris Agreement and address its woeful lack of commitment to climate security. ...
Today marks a historic moment for Taranaki iwi with the passing of the Te Pire Whakatupua mō Te Kāhui Tupua/Taranaki Maunga Collective Redress Bill in Parliament. "Today, we stand together as descendants of Taranaki, and our tūpuna, Taranaki Maunga, is now formally acknowledged by the law as a living tūpuna. ...
Labour is relieved to see Children’s Minister Karen Chhour has woken up to reality and reversed her government’s terrible decisions to cut funding from frontline service providers – temporarily. ...
It is the first week of David Seymour’s school lunch programme and already social media reports are circulating of revolting meals, late deliveries, and mislabelled packaging. ...
The Green Party says that with no-cause evictions returning from today, the move to allow landlords to end tenancies without reason plunges renters, and particularly families who rent, into insecurity and stress. ...
The Government’s move to increase speed limits substantially on dozens of stretches of rural and often undivided highways will result in more serious harm. ...
In her first announcement as Economic Growth Minister, Nicola Willis chose to loosen restrictions for digital nomads from other countries, rather than focus on everyday Kiwis. ...
The Government’s commitment to get New Zealand’s roads back on track is delivering strong results, with around 98 per cent of potholes on state highways repaired within 24 hours of identification every month since targets were introduced, Transport Minister Chris Bishop says. “Increasing productivity to help rebuild our economy is ...
The former Cadbury factory will be the site of the Inpatient Building for the new Dunedin Hospital and Health Minister Simeon Brown says actions have been taken to get the cost overruns under control. “Today I am giving the people of Dunedin certainty that we will build the new Dunedin ...
From today, Plunket in Whāngarei will be offering childhood immunisations – the first of up to 27 sites nationwide, Health Minister Simeon Brown says. The investment of $1 million into the pilot, announced in October 2024, was made possible due to the Government’s record $16.68 billion investment in health. It ...
New Zealand’s strong commitment to the rights of disabled people has continued with the response to an important United Nations report, Disability Issues Minister Louise Upston has announced. Of the 63 concluding observations of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (UNCRPD), 47 will be progressed ...
Resources Minister Shane Jones has launched New Zealand’s national Minerals Strategy and Critical Minerals List, documents that lay a strategic and enduring path for the mineral sector, with the aim of doubling exports to $3 billion by 2035. Mr Jones released the documents, which present the Coalition Government’s transformative vision ...
Firstly I want to thank OceanaGold for hosting our event today. Your operation at Waihi is impressive. I want to acknowledge local MP Scott Simpson, local government dignitaries, community stakeholders and all of you who have gathered here today. It’s a privilege to welcome you to the launch of the ...
Racing Minister, Winston Peters has announced the Government is preparing public consultation on GST policy proposals which would make the New Zealand racing industry more competitive. “The racing industry makes an important economic contribution. New Zealand thoroughbreds are in demand overseas as racehorses and for breeding. The domestic thoroughbred industry ...
Business confidence remains very high and shows the economy is on track to improve, Economic Growth Minister Nicola Willis says. “The latest ANZ Business Outlook survey, released yesterday, shows business confidence and expected own activity are ‘still both very high’.” The survey reports business confidence fell eight points to +54 ...
Enabling works have begun this week on an expanded radiology unit at Hawke’s Bay Fallen Soldiers’ Memorial Hospital which will double CT scanning capacity in Hawke’s Bay to ensure more locals can benefit from access to timely, quality healthcare, Health Minister Simeon Brown says. This investment of $29.3m in the ...
The Government has today announced New Zealand’s second international climate target under the Paris Agreement, Climate Change Minister Simon Watts says. New Zealand will reduce emissions by 51 to 55 per cent compared to 2005 levels, by 2035. “We have worked hard to set a target that is both ambitious ...
Nine years of negotiations between the Crown and iwi of Taranaki have concluded following Te Pire Whakatupua mō Te Kāhui Tupua/the Taranaki Maunga Collective Redress Bill passing its third reading in Parliament today, Treaty Negotiations Minister Paul Goldsmith says. “This Bill addresses the historical grievances endured by the eight iwi ...
As schools start back for 2025, there will be a relentless focus on teaching the basics brilliantly so all Kiwi kids grow up with the knowledge, skills and competencies needed to grow the New Zealand of the future, Education Minister Erica Stanford says. “A world-leading education system is a key ...
Housing Minister Chris Bishop and Associate Agriculture Minister Mark Patterson have welcomed Kāinga Ora’s decision to re-open its tender for carpets to allow wool carpet suppliers to bid. “In 2024 Kāinga Ora issued requests for tender (RFTs) seeking bids from suppliers to carpet their properties,” Mr Bishop says. “As part ...
Associate Education Minister David Seymour has today visited Otahuhu College where the new school lunch programme has served up healthy lunches to students in the first days of the school year. “As schools open in 2025, the programme will deliver nutritious meals to around 242,000 students, every school day. On ...
Minister for Children Karen Chhour has intervened in Oranga Tamariki’s review of social service provider contracts to ensure Barnardos can continue to deliver its 0800 What’s Up hotline. “When I found out about the potential impact to this service, I asked Oranga Tamariki for an explanation. Based on the information ...
A bill to make revenue collection on imported and exported goods fairer and more effective had its first reading in Parliament, Customs Minister Casey Costello said today. “The Customs (Levies and Other Matters) Amendment Bill modernises the way in which Customs can recover the costs of services that are needed ...
Minister of Internal Affairs Brooke van Velden says the Department of Internal Affairs [the Department] has achieved significant progress in completing applications for New Zealand citizenship. “December 2024 saw the Department complete 5,661 citizenship applications, the most for any month in 2024. This is a 54 per cent increase compared ...
Reversals to Labour’s blanket speed limit reductions begin tonight and will be in place by 1 July, says Minister of Transport Chris Bishop. “The previous government was obsessed with slowing New Zealanders down by imposing illogical and untargeted speed limit reductions on state highways and local roads. “National campaigned on ...
Finance Minister Nicola Willis has announced Budget 2025 – the Growth Budget - will be delivered on Thursday 22 May. “This year’s Budget will drive forward the Government’s plan to grow our economy to improve the incomes of New Zealanders now and in the years ahead. “Budget 2025 will build ...
For the Government, 2025 will bring a relentless focus on unleashing the growth we need to lift incomes, strengthen local businesses and create opportunity. Prime Minister Christopher Luxon today laid out the Government’s growth agenda in his Statement to Parliament. “Just over a year ago this Government was elected by ...
Associate Education Minister David Seymour welcomes students back to school with a call to raise attendance from last year. “The Government encourages all students to attend school every day because there is a clear connection between being present at school and setting yourself up for a bright future,” says Mr ...
The Government is relaxing visitor visa requirements to allow tourists to work remotely while visiting New Zealand, Economic Growth Minister Nicola Willis, Immigration Minister Erica Stanford and Tourism Minister Louise Upston say. “The change is part of the Government’s plan to unlock New Zealand’s potential by shifting the country onto ...
The opening of Kāinga Ora’s development of 134 homes in Epuni, Lower Hutt will provide much-needed social housing for Hutt families, Housing Minister Chris Bishop says. “I’ve been a strong advocate for social housing on Kāinga Ora’s Epuni site ever since the old earthquake-prone housing was demolished in 2015. I ...
Trade and Investment Minister Todd McClay will travel to Australia today for meetings with Australian Trade Minister, Senator Don Farrell, and the Australia New Zealand Leadership Forum (ANZLF). Mr McClay recently hosted Minister Farrell in Rotorua for the annual Closer Economic Relations (CER) Trade Ministers’ meeting, where ANZLF presented on ...
A new monthly podiatry clinic has been launched today in Wairoa and will bring a much-needed service closer to home for the Wairoa community, Health Minister Simeon Brown says.“Health New Zealand has been successful in securing a podiatrist until the end of June this year to meet the needs of ...
The Judicial Conduct Commissioner has recommended a Judicial Conduct Panel be established to inquire into and report on the alleged conduct of acting District Court Judge Ema Aitken in an incident last November, Attorney-General Judith Collins said today. “I referred the matter of Judge Aitken’s alleged conduct during an incident ...
Students who need extra help with maths are set to benefit from a targeted acceleration programme that will give them more confidence in the classroom, Education Minister Erica Stanford says. “Last year, significant numbers of students did not meet the foundational literacy and numeracy level required to gain NCEA. To ...
Foreign Affairs Minister Winston Peters has announced three new diplomatic appointments. “Our diplomats play an important role in ensuring New Zealand’s interests are maintained and enhanced across the world,” Mr Peters says. “It is a pleasure to announce the appointment of these senior diplomats from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and ...
Ki te kahore he whakakitenga, ka ngaro te Iwi – without a vision, the people will perish. The Government has achieved its target to reduce the number of households in emergency housing motels by 75 per cent five years early, Associate Housing Minister Tama Potaka says. The number of households ...
The opening of Palmerston North’s biggest social housing development will have a significant impact for whānau in need of safe, warm, dry housing, Associate Housing Minister Tama Potaka says. The minister visited the development today at North Street where a total of 50 two, three, and four-bedroom homes plus a ...
Foreign Minister Winston Peters has announced the new membership of the Public Advisory Committee on Disarmament and Arms Control (PACDAC), who will serve for a three-year term. “The Committee brings together wide-ranging expertise relevant to disarmament. We have made six new appointments to the Committee and reappointed two existing members ...
Ka nui te mihi kia koutou. Kia ora, good morning, talofa, malo e lelei, bula vinaka, da jia hao, namaste, sat sri akal, assalamu alaikum. It’s so great to be here and I’m ready and pumped for 2025. Can I start by acknowledging: Simon Bridges – CEO of the Auckland ...
The Government has unveiled a bold new initiative to position New Zealand as a premier destination for foreign direct investment (FDI) that will create higher paying jobs and grow the economy. “Invest New Zealand will streamline the investment process and provide tailored support to foreign investors, to increase capital investment ...
Science, Innovation and Technology Minister Judith Collins today announced the largest reset of the New Zealand science system in more than 30 years with reforms which will boost the economy and benefit the sector. “The reforms will maximise the value of the $1.2 billion in government funding that goes into ...
Turbocharging New Zealand’s economic growth is the key to brighter days ahead for all Kiwis, Prime Minister Christopher Luxon says. In the Prime Minister’s State of the Nation Speech in Auckland today, Christopher Luxon laid out the path to the prosperity that will affect all aspects of New Zealanders’ lives. ...
The latest set of accounts show the Government has successfully checked the runaway growth of public spending, Finance Minister Nicola Willis says. “In the previous government’s final five months in office, public spending was almost 10 per cent higher than for the same period the previous year. “That is completely ...
The Government’s welfare reforms are delivering results with the number of people moving off benefits into work increasing year-on-year for six straight months. “There are positive signs that our welfare reset and the return consequences for job seekers who don't fulfil their obligations to prepare for or find a job ...
Jon Kroll and Aimee McCammon have been appointed to the New Zealand Film Commission Board, Arts Minister Paul Goldsmith says. “I am delighted to appoint these two new board members who will bring a wealth of industry, governance, and commercial experience to the Film Commission. “Jon Kroll has been an ...
Finance Minister Nicola Willis has hailed a drop in the domestic component of inflation, saying it increases the prospect of mortgage rate reductions and a lower cost of living for Kiwi households. Stats NZ reported today that inflation was 2.2 per cent in the year to December, the second consecutive ...
Two new appointed members and one reappointed member of the Employment Relations Authority have been announced by Workplace Relations and Safety Minister Brooke van Velden today. “I’m pleased to announce the new appointed members Helen van Druten and Matthew Piper to the Employment Relations Authority (ERA) and welcome them to ...
Yasser Abdulaal, who has lived in Ōtautahi Christchurch for five years, said his two sisters had lost their homes in the 15-month-long war. “Toxic wasteland” . . . Palestinians take shelter in tents set up amid heavily damaged buildings in Jabalia in the northern Gaza Strip. Image: Al Jazeera screenshot ...
RNZ PacificMarshall Islands Journal editor Giff Johnson says US President Donald Trump’s decision on aid “is an opening for anybody else who wants to fill the gap” in the Pacific. Trump froze all USAID for 90 days on his first day in office and is now looking to significantly ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Danielle Mazza, Director, SPHERE NHMRC Centre of Research Excellence in Women’s Sexual and Reproductive Health in Primary Care and Professor and Head of the Department of General Practice, Monash University PeopleImages.com – Yuri A/Shutterstock Ahead of the government’s response this week ...
COMMENTARY:By Eugene Doyle It generally ends badly. An old tyrant embarks on an ill-considered project that involves redrawing maps. They are heedless to wise counsel and indifferent to indigenous interests or experience. Before they fail, are killed, deposed or otherwise disposed of, these vicious old men can cause immense ...
The Cook Islands PM is in Beijing to sign an agreement with China - but the government says he failed to consult with NZ on the matter, as is required. ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Katinka van de Ven, Alcohol and other drug specialist, UNSW Sydney Fewer young Australians are drinking. And when they do drink, they are drinking less and less often than previous generations at the same age. It’s a trend happening all around the ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Flavio Macau, Associate Dean – School of Business and Law, Edith Cowan University Hitra/Shutterstock Coles is reducing its product range by at least 10%, a move that has sparked public backlash and renewed discussions about the role of supermarkets in the ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Jacinta Humphrey, Research Fellow in Urban Ecology, RMIT University Golf courses are sometimes seen as harmful to the environment. According to the popular notion, the grass soaks up too much water, is cut too short and sprayed with dangerous chemicals. But in ...
New Zealand has long championed a fair, stable, and resilient global order. As a nation with deep ties to the Pacific and beyond, we cannot afford to be passive in the face of these shifts. ...
Things are going to look a little different this year. Here’s what to expect.Good news, Shortland Street fans: after a well-earned summer holiday, New Zealand’s longest running drama returns to TVNZ2 and TVNZ+ tonight. Ahead of us is a fresh year of living, loving and laughing in the nation’s ...
The poll, conducted between 02 and 04 February, shows National up 2.3 points to 31.9 percent, while Labour has risen 0.4 points from last month to 31.3 percent. ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Katrina McFerran, Professor and Head of Creative Arts and Music Therapy Research Unit; Director of Researcher Development Unit, The University of Melbourne New York Public Library Many of us take pleasure in listening to music. Music accompanies important life events and ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Katrina McFerran, Professor and Head of Creative Arts and Music Therapy Research Unit; Director of Researcher Development Unit, The University of Melbourne New York Public Library Many of us take pleasure in listening to music. Music accompanies important life events and ...
The Cook Islands finds itself in a precarious dance — one between the promises of foreign investments and the integrity of our own sovereignty. As the country sways between partners China and Aotearoa New Zealand, the Cook Islands News asks: “Do we continue to haka with the Taniwha, our constitutional ...
A diplomatic scuffle with the Cook Islands. Plus: What went down at Waitangi. The Cook Islands prime minister, Mark Brown, has provoked the wrath of the New Zealand foreign minister with his decision to head to China to sign a new strategic deal. By failing to consult on the ...
The deputy chairperson of the Australasian College of Emergency Medicine, Dr Michael Connelly, said simply setting targets without "resourcing" them was a pointless exercise, as the number of patients - and their acuity - continuing to grow. ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Suvradip Maitra, PhD Student, Australian National University Tero Vesalainen/Shutterstock Late last year, ChatGPT was used by a Victorian child protection worker to draft documents. In a glaring error, ChatGPT referred to a “doll” used for sexual purposes as an “age-appropriate toy”. ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Niven Winchester, Professor of Economics, Auckland University of Technology Getty Images Donald Trump has already made good on his threat to impose an additional 10% tax on Chinese goods, and is due to announce a 25% tariff on all steel and ...
Diplomatic tension between the Cook Islands and New Zealand is growing. Here's what it's about about, what China has to do with it, and why it matters. ...
Sick of human reality TV? Alex Casey has found a perfect solution in David Attenborough’s latest. I’m know I’m not alone when I say this: humans are bleaking me out at the moment. Turn on the news for the bleakest updates imaginable. Try to numb the pain with Married at ...
The Director of Public Health is a statutory role providing public health leadership across the Public Health Agency, within the Ministry of Health, and the National Public Health Service within Health NZ. ...
Zachary Forbes, a maths teacher from Whanganui, has started an unusual initiative on videogame streaming service Twitch. Shanti Mathias interviews him. “The people want First Samuel,” says the man who calls himself Brother Zac. Brown hair, headphones on, a wall behind him, he pauses and reflects on the comments he’s ...
Endless New Zealand politicians, including the present government, have pointed to our support for a rules-based international system, says PSNA National Chair John Minto. ...
In January, the reversals to speed limit reductions on the state highway network began. Councils have been asked to reverse all reduced speed limits since 2020 by July. A retired rural healthcare worker found something missing from the conversation – a maths equation she learned in high school. As told ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Natarsha McPherson, PhD Candidate in Spatial Ecology, University of Adelaide Rob D / Shutterstock On the vast expanse of the Nullarbor Plain in South Australia, two very different creatures live side by side – but not always peacefully. One is ...
There seemed to be quite a lot of discussion generated yesterday around the comment I made about the apparent move by the MOE to introduce critical maths into our education system.
For me, education is one of those things that should transcend politics, and we should all be working together to ensure our children get the best possible education to set them up for life.
Just some further thoughts on the critical maths aspect.
Firstly, I think it is important to distinguish between critical maths and applied maths.
Applied maths deals with how maths can be applied to various practical problems in a wide variety of settings. So, in framing maths scenarios (rather than "problems") I don't see any problem using a wide variety of cultural settings for these scenarios. It doesn't change the underlying maths, and if it helps children relate better to learning maths, then I am all for that.
The difference with critical maths is that it appears, according to the Wiki article, to try and shape the view children have of the world, and how they fit into it. In that way, it appears to go beyond the objective of teaching children how to do maths.
Many of us who are parents or have young grandchildren are concerned about the state taking control of the education of our children and perhaps instilling them with values we don't agree with.
An example that will likely resonate here is the current discussion around women's rights in the context of transgenderism. I am sure many here would not approve of schools instilling the belief in children that they may not be the right gender and they should do something about it, for example.
It seems to me that there is at least grounds for suspicion that the MOE may be attempting to politicise maths in this way. If that is the case, then it should be put under the scrutiny of public debate so kiwis have input into how their children are taught.
The other concern I have is whether critical maths approach will actually be effective in teaching maths, The reason is that, according the the Wiki article, critical maths teaching does not rely on a set curriculum.
The problem I have with this approach is that growing in learning maths requires understanding prior principles. If teachers are going to pick and choose what they teach, then there could be a lot of students who never grasp those prior principles, and hence struggle with learning new ones.
In the MoE video on their critical maths policy project I did get the impression of a hostage situation out of some participants. There was apparently 'robust' disagreement within the group, leading up to its teaching guidelines. I was also informed language can shape our reality and got the impression that the strong language of one participant might have shaped the reality of the project.
MoE source.
Second video (it has a transcript).
Thanks. I will definitely have a look at that when I get a break.
I support you bringing this up Tsmithfield. I think your concerns are very valid.
"… growing in learning maths requires understanding prior principles"? Isn't all learning laddered on prior learning, mental and physical?
Concerned about the state taking control of the education of our children and perhaps instilling them with values we don't agree with? Values are being learned through everything done in school, it is simply an environment, some of the learning is planned, some is incidental, some is accidental, but it will happen.
Natural clashes may happen when the values a child has been exposed to since birth and lived minute by minute for years meet something totally new in their very limited time at school. Like finding the kid with the brown face is normal. And nice. And bright.
The only way to be sure of avoiding the risk of offspring being instilled at school with values we don't agree with, is to keep them away from school.
To a degree, yes. But, with maths I think it is especially so.
Agreed. But it is a bit different if there is a state agenda to instill values without that information being conveyed clearly to parents.
Or to send children to a school that isn't subject to that sort of influence as much. But that is where huge inequities can start to arise.
If rich parents believe their children will get a crap education in the state system due to also sorts of extraneous woolly factors, they will likely pay to have their kids go to a private school where the education sandards are much higher.
However, parents who can't afford to do that, may have no choice but to leave their children in the state school environment.
Personally, I believe all children should be entitled to a high standard of education where the focus is strongly on gaining the necessary skills to succeed in life. So, to me, it is vitally important that our state system meets those standards.
"Personally, I believe all children should be entitled to a high standard of education where the focus is strongly on gaining the necessary skills to succeed in life. So, to me, it is vitally important that our state system meets those standards."
Agree. Delivering quality education should be focused on how to achieve competence in learners not (assumed) comfort for learners.
An understanding of prior principals building on each other is an overly simplistic way of looking at the topic. A lot of the university courses are covering subjects already fully covered by secondary school. The difference at university is that the topic is dealt with in excruciating detail. A second year calculus course begins with limit series needed to construct calculus, where secondary school would likely make do with a bit of a hand wave over what makes calculus work. A third year group theory course is really a more general description of basic arithmetic.
Also with any subject you will find many students who didn't get the earlier material and a range of proficiencies. For any subject it gets repeated multiple times year on year as thats more or less the nature of teaching it.
but with math repetition only works to a degree…the door opens or it dosnt.
"prior principals building on each other"
God forbid we have principals doing that.
After adjusting for socio-economic factors, private schools and states schools have similar outcomes. You don't get a better education at a private school, you get a more advantaged network.
I had a quick browse through the docs. I don't think they are using critical, for maths, in the way that is being implied here. They mean critical as in "vital" – skills that are vital for living as an active citizen. They do talk about using maths in other areas as a way of providing evidence. I take all that to mean understanding percents, interest rates, proportional representation calculations, what makes a good survey, experiment or trial, being able to estimate things as a check to see if something makes sense.
The document seems to be about lifting the tail. The only talk about giftedness is bracketed with learning difficulties. I can see quite a bit of push-back coming from that area.
Bingo!
Some call it Vitamin R, the R standing for relationships aka networks.
If rich parents believe their children will get a crap education in the state system due to also sorts of extraneous woolly factors, they will likely pay to have their kids go to a private school where the education standards are much higher.
Many of those schools teach you that god exists so I hardly think standards are higher. I'd argue the standards are pretty awful.
And from my experience this is much more accurate than your statement.
If rich white parents believe their children will go to school with too many non-white children in the state system they will likely pay to have their kids go to another state or a private school where the white proportions are much higher.
Algebra with its basis in simple arithmetic loses me and is akin to me watching someone do a magic spell that I don't have the recipe for.
Whereas I got the magic of algebra at an early age – well before high school but found trigonometry boring as anything. Like magic and much more exciting algebra and elegantly designed algorithms.
As one who missed out on basic arithmetic at primary school by the absence of our noted arithmetic teacher and the hopelessness of the reliever in the olden days I agree with the continued discussion on this point.
It was much later when an adult that I learned about maths people such as Fibonacci. (who is one of my 'heroes' now along with William Morris) I was taught tricks to help me with addition by my parents.
I loved trig and geometry. I was able to do these to 6th form level. This I put down to other influences reinforcing what was taught eg Brownies/Guides, time telling, compass work that focussed on the circle or sphere.
Algebra with its basis in simple arithmetic loses me and is akin to me watching someone do a magic spell that I don't have the recipe for.
So primary school maths needs to be basic and the teaching of it reinforced across all teachers, including relievers. It should not be possible for children in a primary school class to just lose maths ability because their teacher was sick for a month or so. We had remedial reading but no remedial maths.
I was similar. But I missed out in one of my high school years due to having a teacher with absolutely no class control. We called him "baldy King". The sole object of maths classes with him was for students to wind him up until he threw a wobbly and grabbed someone out of the class to cane them.
It became macarbe entertainment. He was probably brilliant at maths, but IMO should never have been a teacher.
I picked it up again at Uni where I did a couple of maths papers that caught me up with what I had missed out on.
I really love maths. Not because I am really good at it. But I admire greatly those who have a gift in that area.
I do too. I especially came to love it when I knew of its value/history in observation of the natural world and in basic design principles such as the golden ratio/perspective that we seem to know instinctively. In art I learned about these 'rules' so I could competently break them, to make people think and that was how I first researched Fibonnaci.
https://www.mathsisfun.com/numbers/golden-ratio.html
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fibonacci
In art playing with perspective is fun and thought provoking. I have looked for, but cannot locate yet, a link that had very young children learning to add geometrical perpsective to their drawings. Including the concept of infinity and roads and lines leading to where we cannot exactly see.
While we love the house with the windows, door and perhaps a chimney that we get from our children, children themselves are not convinced apparently that it represents the real world they are trying to convey. Because they can see that the house has a side as well as a front.
Teaching children about perspective, which is a difficult concept for many to put down on paper, or think about was accepted by children in the study as a much appreciated way to represent the world.
If the concepts are taught young they can be built in/on later in formal maths teaching.
How about some reality! The NZ Government or “ the State,” has ALWAYS controlled NZ Education. The Department of Education as specifically set up to do just that. Then and now! Politicians are the problem, they can’t keep their stick fingers off Education!
I was involved in teacher education in mathematics for 10 years. My Masters thesis examined the barriers and affordances that teachers faced when teaching mathematics for social justice or critical maths. The case study had teachers present data that looked at inequity in wages, unemployment, housing, life expectancy as well as whether you could live on the minimum wage.
Student engagement was high and the students from Pacific nations over the period of the study moved from blaming themselves for inequity to realizing that the inequity was a result of systemic racism.
The mathematics learning was incredible but so was the integration with social science and that the students were talking about their learning at home with Aiga.
The teachers in the study also grew and when students made statements like Pacific people do not get high paying jobs because they do not do well at school, they were able to flip this to do Pacific talavou not do well at school or do schools not do well at teaching Pacific students?
I have done similar research in high decile schools and had similar results. Improved learning in mathematics as well as critical analysis of inequity. Done well it is a win win. Paulo Freire was an outstanding educator and if New Zealand schools were to introduce his pedagogy our society would be a far more equitable place than it currently is.
I have a suggestion – can we have a ban on trans debate until after the election?
The general comments section on this site would give an aspirin a headache at the moment.
can we ban men talking about their politics until after the election? (one man's trans debate is another woman's sex based rights debate)
We've always had times when topics take up a lot of space on TS eg Assange, or the 2016 US election, or the anti-mandate protests.
Well there are other things hapening and it's killing the site.
I guess that it ultimately depends on whether or not you want the comments section to be your personal platform to flog your hobby horse to death to an ever diminishing audience.
Still, if your ears are painted on and you don't want to listen then go for the doctor.
The comments are all structured as a tree. So if you don't like the way 2 is going you can skip 2.1, 2.1.1, 2.2 etc. Your welcome.
someone always ways that, every single time there is a hot topic that gets a lot of comments. Usually someone who doesn't like the topic. I empathise, there are plenty of conversations here that I'm sick of too. Imagine what it's like being a moderator. You at least can scroll on by. Better yet, put up some content to get people engaged in the things you want to talk about.
My problem is it shouldn't even be a debate, if you have a penis ypu don't go into womans only spaces!!its that simple,
Of you have or ever had a penis you don't compete in sports of a physical nature, it's that simple.
Transitioning a kid under the age of 18 should be illegal
Amen.
@ bwag..
claps hands, well said.
And it is that simple. We had a process that worked for the few who needed to transtion and that could have been tweeaked,
Instead we had the No Debate and 'men are women when we want to be' mindset rammed down our throats. This was followed by a baying crowd a beating or two to keep us in our place. I find the women-hate mind boggling, not to mention a little frightening.
When parts of the state seem to be part of this movement such as the Police non presence on 25/3 and the signing by the Human Rights Commissioner, Paul Hunt, who I assumed was non biased in appearance and fact to the Yogyakarta prinicples that have never been accepted by the UN.
the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yogyakarta_Principles
You would think that bwaghorn, its not as if its tricky. Why the obfuscation and deflection on something so self evident ( to me anyway) is bewildering.
Do you say the same about the people who usually have threads on Russia/Ukraine?
Hmmmmm I didn't think so….only threads relating to 'women's stuff'
Oh, get off the grass!
One is a clear political wedge issue, certainly here on TS, which is what we’re talking about, and the other is not. For example, did shit hit the fan when Zelenskyy spoke before NZ Parliament?
You’re comparing apples with oranges.
Yes I know 'wedge issue' is the minimising phrase du jour.
Sorry not biting either to this framing or to you missing my point.
Luke Malpass in his article in Stuff mentioned culture wars and I don't accept this minimising phrase du jour as I noted in my post on 8/4/23
Shanreagh
8 April 2023 at 10:45 am
I can see your point. I sort of stopped reading Open Mike, because of the "trans debate". Every now and then I scroll through to find the bits I'm interested in, which hardly exist nowadays.
I suggest to split those "small culture war discussions", that's where I place trans debate (how many trans people are in the general population? More than 1%?), into a separate post. Or even better, people should fight it out on Facebook or Twitter etc.
It is not killing it. It is polarising it and wedging it into two sides on one site.
Trying to create a safe space were some commenters can talk safely amongst themselves is or should not be an issue – whether it is genuine debate is debatable. However, when this space is so tightly controlled & defended and others are not welcome unless they know the secret handshake and sing from the exact same and only sheet, then it runs contra to the kaupapa of this site, which is robust debate that is inclusive.
For my two pennies worth, the reason I don't comment much on Kiwiblog these days is that the comments section seems to have become infested with anti-vaxxers and climate change deniers, and commentors there seem quite boorish, and don't really enter into reasoned debate.
I haven't picked up the same vibe here yet with respect to women's rights etc. Probably the key difference is that people are at least prepared to discuss ideas politely.
if during the election campaign there is this level of sustained debate, I will probably start putting up some dedicated posts and asking people to comment there. Like we have done for the 2016 US election, or the parliament grounds occupation. But I am waiting to see if it settles down post KJK, and because I don't have time atm.
Looking at the number of posts, the site is doing well, but perhaps it would be better if topics with a large number of posts are reacted to by starting a new "thread", without needing much more than a paragraph outlining the topic and any obvious limits on the discussion. So for example a separate thread for trans debate may have been useful a week ago; it may have run for three or four days, and enabled Open Mike to cover a large number of other topics. Yes there is overlap and it gets a bit messy, but it would make it easier to track comments on a particular issue – and if the topic is kept ''alive'' by sufficient reasonable posts, it could be re-opened in a new thread every so often.
A separate issue is that I value the posts that are written by individuals to start a thread. The "right" have no similar equivalent – Kiwiblog remains a dog-whistle sewer, but the right do have a lot of blatant propaganda sites covering a wide range of extremism with a common link of being anti-government, and anti-this government in particular. I am not criticising those like MickySavage, MikeSmith, Weka and GuestPost that have written material that make good conversation starters and give good information; I just think that the left needs more people helping by bringing different views and covering other topics – refuting some of the bizarre assertions from the right, but also celebrating success and explaining difficulties rather than blaming. With an election coming up, there is a greater need than ever to counter mis-information through advertising facts about past performance and policies to help those supporting the left make informed choices and be able to counter lies from elsewhere.
the only reason I haven't set up a dedicated gender/sex post is that it's a fair amount of work to do and run and I've been busy. I've definitely been thinking about it. Too much of my time on TS has been taken up with moderating for things done by regulars who should know better.
I agree we need more peopel writing. I've been toying with the idea of a Debate of the Day post, where we post a topic and people can go discuss it here. I like the idea of using comments from regulars as Dotd, because lots of people bring good intros to the table.
Some Posts or topics do well in terms of numbers because people are emotionally (and/or ideologically) invested in them. Identity Politics ranks right up there [no pun intended]. Posts or topics with heavy intellectual [for want of a better word] investment are not so common because they require much more effort on behalf of the Author. They also require more mental work from commenters (and readers!). Don’t forget TS is competing with MSM and SM, among others, for time & attention of people. TS does not have anything to gain or lose in terms of advertisers on the site!!
I had thought of some subjects being used say once a week – examples could be Water, or Climate Change, or Celebrating success (of government), or Transport – they may concentrate discussion for that day, but also make it easier to track issues on Open Mike if there are a reduced number of concurrent threads. I appreciate the work done by the moderators; I was not wanting to make that work harder!
Understood. However, I won’t comment further because the ball is not in my court.
"I have a suggestion – can we have a ban on trans debate until after the election?"
Going too far but I second the sentiment. It is clearly putting commenters off this site. You only have to look at the OM posts to see that is happening. Perhaps the one trick ponies could be discouraged from hogging the posts and let other commenters introduce other arguably more urgent issues which beset the nation and elsewhere.
The Letting Women Speak post had the highest comments TS has seen in while. It got 4,800 views, most posts get under 1,000. My casual observation is that OM views and comments are high atm too (for a range of reasons).
Perhaps the people with antipathy towards women's sex based rights debate could start talking about the things they want to talk about instead of telling women to shut up. Anyone can post in OM. How about you put up a topic for discussion today Anne.
Unreal Weka. We shut up so 'others' can debate 'other' things that 'others' have deemed more worthy.
If someone wants to read different topics then put up some different topics to discuss.
Go back on the boards and find a topic you would like to explore further and comment on that. It will show in the index of posts and people may find here is a topic I'd like to comment on/read.
Or is this related to serious techno things like in the olden days our dial ups couldn't cope with massive amounts of data coming in? If it is seriously related to constraints on data then perhaps there is a point. If it is constrained then how can we get more is it band width? I could put some $$$ forward.
I'm in agreement with Weka and Shanreagh here. A while ago, someone suggested that those who want to learn more could do a bit more listening, rather than blurting their 2c all the time.
I've been doing that (as in reading, rather than 'listening'), and have been well rewarded by the quality of argument.
Please don't ban this discussion, just because someone's 'tired' of it.
Yup, it takes up bandwidth & oxygen here, but some seem to regard this as good & desirable, apparently.
If the wishes of one group interfere with the quality of experience (aka enjoyment) of another group and start to become detrimental to the general good I think we have a problem. But not everybody sees it this way or wants to see it this way and if there’s no problem or the problem is downplayed there’s no need to change anything, is there?
I agree to an extent, this election is going to be won and lost on the economy, cost of living and housing. Everything else is window dressing.
The public are hurting, badly and they expect our politicians to be dedicating ALL of their time to the cost of living and housing crises, instead what a furious public see is left wing politicians and activists obsessing over skin colour, gender and sexuality and fighting amongst themselves and the public get angrier.
None of it puts food on tables or gets people in houses and that's all poll after poll tells us the public care about…. So yes I agree the left in general should stfu about identity politics till after the election
Buuuut at the same time, certain debates need to be had, the amount of rampant homophobia and misogyny coming from mainstream lefty's is scary to a lot of people.
When I was growing up it was the right and religious who didn't like gays, now it's the left, media, academia and "queer " organizations that hate gay men and women and call us genital fetishists, bigots, say we chose to be gay and reduce our sexuality to a preference that can be cured by being more open minded and we're not allowed to disagree or we could lose our jobs and be ostracized
And as for women, if they speak out about any concerns on sex based rights they get called a nazi and lose their jobs and risk getting punched over and having the left celebrate it.
And that loses us voters too.. not to mention, this is probably the only left wing place in NZ or indeed the internet that won't outright ban users for wanting to have cordial debate about concerns about gender ideology, so it not here, where?
And while I'd love for the election to be about the issues that matter, this is labour and the Greens we're talking about, they have no intention of campaigning or addressing cost of living and housing beyond band aid tweaks.
Labour and the Greens have shown zero ability to debate populist soc dem economic policy, their caucuses have almost zero first hand experience with poverty and they can't bring themselves to say the word poverty without the word child being in front of it.
Without identity politics the NZ has nothing! A few tweaks. A few payment increases.
So why can lesbians gays and women air their concerns about gender ideology? It's not like the left have anything resembling social democratic economic policies to debate.
Sanctuary – have to agree with your comments above. When one topic is constantly discussed day after day other important and interesting topics get lost or little opportunity for comment.
And me….the trans issue, though important, tends to dominate the blog at the expense of other key issues.
best way to remedy that is to go comment on posts that aren't about women's rights rather than expecting OM to be limited. Generate some discussion on other topics.
Surely putting up one's own posts is the answer instead of moaning that the ones other posters are discussing are not your cup of tea.
I don't get that type of comment when the remedy is their own typing fingers and agile minds.
Come on weka. For some time now when people have tried to introduce another subject, their comments are often cancelled out by a sudden rush of trans and related subjects which leaves the unfortunate commenter's comment alone and unloved.
I am exaggerating to make a point.
Some are commenting on the maths topic.
Those putting up topics can keep them going…..
It is not as if we are limited to the putting these on OM.
Nah. The GC debates generate energy which is why people are in them. There are non GC comments today and yet here you are talking about this instead of other topics. Can’t blame the GC debate for that.
Sorry weka but I am not wrong.
Two weeks ago following the Posie P debacle it was noticeable – not so much now. Soon after some comments appeared on another topic, there was a GC pile-on following it so that it got lost in the melee. I doubt I was the only one who picked it up. It may have been a case where one person made an effort to start off the debate again and that pulled in the rest of them.
It is not good for this site's previous reputation for wide ranging and mostly informed conversations about topical issues both in NZ and overseas. That I am sure is what pulled in the lurkers who largely never comment but like to read the posts and some may even read the comments.
I suspect there are those who entered the GC debate on the basis of misinformation being promulgated (not by all commenters of course) and they felt compelled to say something.
totally agree anne. Im so over it, this is the first time for over a week that Ive looked in to TS. the topic seems to have overwhelmed the site. on behalf of the VAST majority who dont give a phuck about sexuality., can TS have a seperate page for the sex obsessed.
… on behalf of the VAST majority who dont give a phuck about sexuality.,
My sentiments too. "Each to his/her own" is my motto. If you are a decent person who is not hurting anyone then go for it.
But that is not the issue Anne.
The issue is if intact males are able to enter female safe spaces as per new rules for magically turning a male to a female.
The more the actual issue is minimised the more it becomes of concern.
As Queen Victoria is alleged to have said I don't care what they do 'as long as it does not frighten the horses'. But that is NOT the issue.
I do not believe women should have to give up their safe spaces to cater for males.
How about we get men thinking about how to keep non conforming males safe in their spaces or if that is a bridge too far, then we get our best architects/ policy analysts on the job to design/plan for by alocation of $$$, the best spaces that allow for trans people while keeping women safe.
I find if difficult to understand why there is still this myth that women are concerned about what other people do sexually. For most/many/all of us who have commented here it has never been about this.
The reason why intact or minimally transitioned men will be able to enter women's spaces is because of the changes to the BDM Act allowing men to ostensibly change sex from male to female. And the reason this was a 'shoo in' was becasue of the 'No Debate' self ID that has whipped around the world.
Hopefully I have explained it clearly enough so that all who think it is about what people do privately can see this is not the issue/point.
There are calls to stop talking about the issue. With the lack of knowledge about what the issue is for women it seems many have remained stuck in their own one track of what they think the issue is.
Bwaghorn succinctly summed up the issues here
bwaghorn2.1.1.2.1
11 April 2023 at 10:15 am
Why is it so difficult?
I know he/she used the wrong word, but the rest of the comment is true. "The vast majority who don't give a phuck…"
It has been taken to a level beyond that which is appropriate. By all means lobby the government vociferously for whatever changes in the legislation you think would solve the problem.
Trans people also have safety fears if this opinion piece is any guide:
https://www.stuff.co.nz/pou-tiaki/300850151/the-long-shadow-cast-by-the-posie-parker-show
Look I am willing to take a break from the Gender critical stuff for a week or so, just to give everyone a breather.
However I don't like the idea of banning a topic, any topic that is.
The Standard is one of the few places that issue of gender ideology is debated and gender critical people such as myself get a chance to be heard.
If the msm were doing a balanced job then probably the Standard would not have been the place where the issue got brought up so much. And the recent events around Posie Parker of course escabated that. Women again were silenced, this time by an angry violent mob.
So look, I'll hold back from GC for a week (I still intend to comment on other issues).
I am not suggesting this for anyone else. Up to them.
If I can think of a way that debate could me more constructive about the issue then I will.
Please don't take a break Anker. I don't comment much but I am an avid reader of this topic – its like this is my community where this topic can be aired – not many places like this. Would banning this topic would be adopting 'No Debate'.?
Thanks Beverly. I agree so few places where GC views get any airing whatsoever.
I was thinking I would heed some of the voices on this site and stop posting about GC stuff for a week or so and I didn't mean anyone else should do this.
In posting on GC stuff, I do have the hope that some people who are unsure about the issue will start to read stuff and realize the debate isn't about trans people, but an ideology that is highly problematic.
Like with any intense arguement, sometimes time out isn't a bad idea.
An idea I have about the debate is to keep it to the absolute basics (see Bwagons comment) e.g Should someone who identifies as a women but is a biological male be allowed in womens spaces? changing rooms, sport,prisons etc. Almost like a survey, tick yes or no. Then give reasons why. Should we have to use someone's pro nouns yes or no?
From my point of view the Standard has provided outstanding information from a gender critical view and I thank Weka, Shanreagh, Molly, Sabine, Visu, Roblogic, Gsays, Bwagon, Liberty Belle and my apologies for those who have been left out.
I am going to make a commitment though. From this afternoon for a week I will refrain from raising GC with the priviso that if there are any significant developements I reserve the right to comment.
I would be utterly against a ban though
That is a great idea.
I think the ones ticking yes could be the ones who could be asked to do the explainer. Other than these
transwomen are women, which is not an argument more of a circle.
and
it’s basic human rights?
I have not read any arguments for the concept
Don't be too harsh on yrself. I have learnt, grown and had a few attitudes shift during this debate.
It is a welcome break from the willie-waving war porn,
it won't be banned. At some point I might put up some dedicated posts like we have for other hot topics in the past, and ask that people comment there.
Yes that is a good idea.
In the past when there been tooic that takes huge band width it's had its own daily post, that's the best option in this case
I see weha is planning that as we type
I’ve suggested this. It was declined.
I even made a logo.
where did you suggest that?
In the back-end. Can’t remember exactly when. I remember seeing the bush fires flaring up frequently then too here and that it was having a divisive negative effect on TS. Things are worse now, IMO.
ah, so not GC debate, but something more general? What was the idea?
WTF?
Bwaghorn: can GC debate be shifted to its own daily post?
Incog: I suggested this a few years ago and made a logo
weka: ok, not GC debate posts but something more general? What was your idea?
Incog: wtf?
weka: if you don’t understand can you please explain?
it does take a fair amount of work. I'm tossing up whether it's more work than what I'm having to currently do. Also waiting to see if things settle down post KJK, and whether the right are intent on making it an election issue.
Weka, my suggestion is that you could do realitively short, concise posts on the topic for comment focussed on specific issues. Then, the topic stays available for comment, but doesn't require huge amounts of work and research.
The work is in the set up, the moderation and herding cats.
Eg I’m on my phone right now which on its own doubles moderation work
I made this suggestion (sorry I don't know how to create a link to it)
Comment:Open mike 30/09/2021
I certainly don't support banning a topic but if there had been a "Daily GC Chat" thread the animosity that has developed (on both sides of the argument) may not have developed.
are you sure that's the right date?
If you click on the time/date stamp of any comment, it changes the address in the address bar to a permanent direct link. You can then copy and paste it into a comment (put a . at the start so it embeds right).
.https://thestandard.org.nz/open-mike-30-09-2021/#comment-1820120
Thanks Weka, and my apologies, it was addressed to The Moderators and rereading it you weren't part of any of that thread, but I stand by the suggestion that a Daily GC Chat would give everyone the option of sharing their opinions without monopolising Open Mike.
thanks. It's something I've been thinking about, but it's a workload thing.
. https://thestandard.org.nz/open-mike-30-09-2021/#comment-1820338
If it helps this was way down the thread. You must have been away and responded later. Cheers.
Thanks! That helped me find the back end thread.
the main difference between the BDMRR debate and now is that then there were lots of days when there were no comments on that topic. Atm there are comments on gender/sex daily. I’ll have a look this week at putting up a dedicated post, it won’t be daily but people can keep commenting under it over successive days. Maybe a new post a few times a week.
I'm sure that many of us have got the message here. No support for womens rights, again.
It is seemingly Ok for intact males to share the safe spaces with women. Play sports against women, share prisons with women etc.
Just so we know. That is the issue.
Not really. From a moderator perspective hot topics having a dedicated post can improve debate.
when this was raised during the BDMRR debate, it looked like some people wanted the conversations to not be happening, but here the overriding issue is simply whether OM is overloaded.
there’s a risk that dedicated posts will end up being an echo chamber of GCs. If that happens I suggest using the threads to do something constructive 😈
My sole reason for saying is so as not to add to your workload.
It seems that the possible inablity for others to cope with scrolling past an issue they are not interested in means that to meet these 'concerns' the workload fall on another person.
I did ask if it was a data/tech problem as I used to have when I was on my old dial up. If it is a tech problem then by all means look for a way around this and separate topics might be a way
I have the idea though it is not this but a 'I can't be bothered with this issue and so everyone who is should go away'
If you, on whom the solution rests, are happy then that is fine. perhaps the ones with the concerns could lend a hand moderating or post writing. (you know learning by doing)
you seem to be missing the point Shanreagh. If OM gets overloaded on a hot topic (it happens periodically, it’s not about gender/sex), then debate improves when we create dedicated posts. I’ve been waiting until it’s been sufficient a problem to warrant spending my time on it. People wanting the gender/sex debate to go away aren’t my primary motivation (or any motivation at all really). People saying that there’s too much and OM is overloaded matters.
I think this whole area of the increasing influence of state and media on our lives needs to be debated, given there is an election coming up.
I see a useful analogy being that of an incoming tide.
For some of us, especially on the right, we feel we have been flooded years ago. However, the tide seems to keep coming in, progressively swamping those with more liberal mindsets. So, eventually, we all feel we are in the same situation of being flooded by ideology we don't want.
However, at its core is the same ideology. It is just creeping further and further into our lives.
Smithy, welcome to a country/globe coping with a climate catastrophe.
There is no way, no way 'individual rights' will overcome the climate crisis. That will take concerted state action – ie, the state will have to become much more intrusive in our everyday lives – if we are going to have a snowball's hope in hell of getting through what's coming.
I would probably agree with you on that score if states (with the emphasis on states) can get their act together in a co-ordinated manner. Especially the large ones who are the biggest contributors to the problem. If they can't then I really do despair.
I have already suggested in earlier posts that there needs to be an internationally co-ordinated approach for how we do farming, with farming taking place in the most productive parts of the world so the planet can be fed and carbon emissions from agriculture minimised.
But we are talking about an existential crisis for many in this case.
However, a lot of the other stuff I am concerned about has nothing to do with an existential crisis. But more to do with creeping state control and intrusion into our lives.
Well-ordered, legitimate democratic states are much less of a threat to our freedom than the unaccountable and unelected private power that results from having lots of money. As TV implies at 5.1, it is this private power that has stalled state action on climate change.
Put another way, the greatest threat to our freedom is inequality. That formulation, which is true, stands on its head the nonsensical neoliberal formulation, that inequality is a sign of our freedom
I actually agree with you, and see that inequality so far as education goes is the most important area of inequality.
IMO people who go to a state school should be able to expect a standard of education that equates to what children from rich parents can get from a private school. Hence, why I have been banging on about this topic.
I believe that good education is the doorway out of poverty, as I am sure many could attest to.
Nailed it Tsmithfield. 100%
Meanwhile, TRAs are promoting suicide. This is fucked up for its primary message but it also contaminates NZ’s already dangerous culture around suicide.
https://twitter.com/aniobrien/status/1645553757269409793
Are we sure this is TRAs and not some false flag op? How the hell is this supposed to attract anyone to the cause? Just grotesque, whichever it is.
Could be a false flag op. But it’s consistent with TRA approaches so either way genderist progressives need to stop denying the problems and step up and address them.
Possibly. Which political party wants people to discuss this issue when they get to work – and wants workplace consequences stories in the public media?
which activist community wants to cast all criticism of gender ideology as fascist and promotes violence against GC women?
Do you know I am sure this is going to be put in the too hard basket by NZ Police just like the assault by a transactivist on a 71 year old woman on 25/3/23 seems to have been.
Also in the basket is unactioned thoughts and plans to police public events so that they do not not get overrun by antis,
Another weird chapter is being played out in the bizarre world of US politics with Donald Trump moving to block Mike Pence from testifying in the special counsel's Jan. 6 probe.
When the Jan 6 Committee was organised claims were made that those who had vital information wouldn't be heard. To accentuate the point Jim Jordan violated House ethics by defying subpoenas to appear. Those who had most intimate knowledge and involvement refused to give evidence then complained that the 'true story' wasn't coming out.
It seems now Pence won't appeal a federal judge's order that he testify before the grand jury in special counsel Jack Smith’s investigation so maybe more of the real story will emerge.
Clearly Trump wanted Pence, in whatever way, to be 'taken out' on Jan 6. Now he's is trying other strategies to shut him up.
https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/donald-trump/trump-moves-block-pence-testifying-jan-6-probe-rcna78962
He's being treated like the mobster he is, too.
Some weeks after cloaking a jury in complete anonymity to preside over E. Jean Carroll’s lawsuit accusing former President Donald Trump of rape, a federal judge refused to relax that ruling even enough to confidentially share their identities with the attorneys.
Senior U.S. District Judge Lewis Kaplan said he couldn’t issue such an order in “good conscience,” especially in light of Trump’s continuing attacks on the jurist presiding over the former president’s criminal case.
https://lawandcrime.com/live-trials/e-jean-carroll-rape-suit/citing-trumps-attacks-on-hush-money-judge-court-keeps-e-jean-carroll-rape-jury-completely-anonymous/
Something else that concerns me about our education system is that it appears to be churning out people who have lost the ability to debate issues in a reasoned fashion.
It seems that today, the only way many see to counter views they dislike is to shout people down and belittle them with irrational claims about them being Nazis or whatever. We see this a lot in cancel culture, where the goal seems to be to challenge ideas by preventing them from being voiced, rather than by countering those views with better ideas.
I really don't know how this method of dealing with uncomfortable ideas has developed. Is it perhaps because schools overemphasise the value of protest? And, protest certainly has its place. But, I think the contest of ideas needs to be won first.
Have you read of the schools programme of the Governor of Florida?
I just googled that. It looks like a giant pendulum swing in the opposite direction.
https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/23593369/ron-desantis-florida-schools-higher-education-woke
This often happens when views become so extreme in one direction that many become concerned and reject said views.
I certainly would agree with the sentiment of a lot of what is suggested, in that I think my views are fairly clear that a lot of this stuff falls well outside the responsibility of schools to provide a good grounding in core subjects.
But, whether it is throwing the baby out with the bathwater? It certainly seems a very hard core rejection of woke culture.
I haven't given it enough thought to have a firm view on that. Banning books etc seems a bit extreme, and seems to be taking a similar approach to many of the “woke” academics who have been doing the same sort of thing in the opposite direction.
The nature of a pendulum is that it swings both sides. Life is very much a pendulum, and always remember ' this too shall pass' be it good, bad or just mediocre.
Banning books or 'challenging them' is quite a normal thing and is happening to many many books in the US. A list here
https://www.ala.org/advocacy/bbooks/frequentlychallengedbooks/classics
Animal Farm, The catcher of the rye, 1984, Slaughterhouse 5 and some more……so many classics.
And some of Dr Seus's books etc so far as children's books go.
I don't think banning books, or banning people from speaking etc does any good for a cause ultimately. All ideas are contestable IMO and should be available to read. As should books or information that counter views expressed in said books.
I had a valuable lesson in this as a teenager. I was right into a book called “Chariots of the Gods” by Erich Von Daniken. The thesis of his book was that ancient technology could only be explained by earth being visited by aliens, and the result being a quantum leap in human knowledge.
However, my mother was very wise, and gave me another book “Crash go the chariots”. This book dismantled the Von Daniken’s thesis completely.
The unwise approach would have been for her to take the Von Daniken’s book away and forbid me from reading it.
Going to see the movie "The Chariots of the Gods" was a scheduled school trip for Standards 1- 4, Form 1&2 at my primary school.
Other movie outings were:
Watership Down, Beautiful People, The Gods Must Be Crazy, the animation of Lord if the Rings.
Huff! Much better than our school. Movie outing? You've got to be kidding!
70's NZ mid-lower class area with mixed demographic.
Movie outings were rare, I think I've recalled all from the eight years there. They were often end-of-the year celebrations.
Mary Poppins for us. but so loved it!
Johnathon Livingstone Seagull and 2001 Space Odyssey for us.
Forgot about Johnathon Livingstone Seagull!
(Still haven’t made it through 2001 Space Odyssey …)
I enjoyed Von Daniken. Not that I believed it, but it's like Fantasy fiction … 'what if' it were true!
There's a lovely reference in one of David Brin's novels – ("Sundiver" I think) – where there really are aliens, and they are massively insulted by the Von Danikenite assumption that they would have just walked off and abandoned the primitive cultures!
I was a gullible teenager back then, so was quite taken in by it until I read the book my mother gave me.
But some of the stuff in there was still incredibly interesting. Like those massive ground paintings of animals and such in Peru I think, that can only be viewed from the air. I think Van Daniken argued that they were to guide in space ships or something similar.
But, I think a more logical explanation is that they were sun god worshippers back then, and so probably thought they were making things big enough to be seen by their god as it was.
https://www.atlasobscura.com/places/nazca-lines-peru
Von Daniken always reminded me of the 'just so stories' (how the elephant got it's trunk) – inventing a story to explain a physical artefact – based on internal 'logic' rather than external validated data.
Nice storytelling. But not science.
I was not allowed to read certain books at the convent, so at age 9 i head read all the roman catholic gore that exists, and there is a lot of it. Believe me there are not many patron saints that did not die horrible death of burnings, stabbings, removing the intestines, quartering/drawing, drowning, rape, etc etc etc etc.
St. Sabine was either devoured by a lion, or killed otherwise in the circus for not wanting to sex with the murderer of her husband.
Sometimes what is forbidden might be an easier read then what is allowed.
The books were not banned and nor was there public pressure to do so.
https://www.theguardian.com/books/2021/mar/07/dr-seuss-books-product-recall-cancel-culture
Geisel’s stepdaughter, Lark Grey Dimond-Cates, told the New York Post there “wasn’t a racist bone in that man’s body”, but also said suspending publication of the six titles was “a wise decision”. But the controversy left many perplexed, since the decision was made by Dr Seuss Enterprises and not as a result of public pressure that has preceded other such decisions.
Nel said the decision to no longer publish titles that include racist caricatures showed just one way to address problematic material.
“[The books are] not going to disappear,” he said. “They’re not being banned. They’re not being cancelled. It’s just a decision to no longer sell them.”
The Governor of Florida gets bad press. When I saw a headline "No One Is Talking About What Ron DeSantis Has Actually Done to Florida" I presumed I'd see the ledger put right. Wrong.
https://time.com/6266618/ron-desantis-florida-governance-essay/
We discussed this a little after the parliamentary protest when we were pondering, well some of us were, how to prevent people from being swayed by basically hoax material. Critical thinking etc, in the old sense of the word. Sharpening our wits etc
I'll try to find and link back.
Is people losing the ability to debate issues in a reasoned fashion the fault of the formal education system? Did you mean society is churning out people who have lost the ability to debate issues in a reasoned fashion?
Quite possibly. And, of course, our education system fits within our society, so it could be a bit of both.
Kids are strongly discouraged from debate – there is the 'received wisdom' and arguing a contrary point of view will get you a trip to the principal – because you are racist/sexist/phobic or whatever other buzzword you've offended against.
Your teachers and peers are special snowflakes, who are wholly unable to cope with a different viewpoint.
What bullshit.
Debate is encouraged, and critical thinking thought.
Your understanding of the current education system is somewhat dated.
I don't think so. Kids in the school system right now.
As a parent, I've been summoned in to the principal's office to 'discuss' why my kid is questioning the teacher's point of view.
How about you? What's your perspective on the school system?
Questioning or arguing with a teacher, in class, is not the same as class-debate, is it?
Class debate isn't a thing – certainly not in primary school.
What do you think the average of debater is here on TS?
What you’re describing, and I’m not saying you’re wrong, must have been going for yonks, by the looks of it.
The new religion?…the west (mainly) has abandoned formal religions and so creates de facto replacements…and we have become increasingly sectarian…some align with Mammon, others hedonism.and a multitude of alternatives.
But it appears many are seeking meaning(?) as a replacement….perhaps our ancestors understood something we have forgotten?…and yet the argument against formal religion is valid.
Where to?
https://www.patreon.com/posts/terms-of-into-81119691
I am sorry I know this won’t appeal to everyone’s sense of humour. So a warning, if you are tried and true Greens, you may not enjoy this
Ha ha as my former boss Labour Minister) used to say 'once they start laughing at you….'The Greens and Hipkins may find that laughter has a duration they were not expecting.
Well as far as Dancehall Riddims go, she could have done a lot worse:
Shaggy, My Cry, Crybaby Riddim:
https://youtu.be/kSJqMi3j32E?list=PL0988F4F0277D9F87
The good ole boys would've loved this.
https://twitter.com/TheTNHoller/status/1645563847552663552
https://www.npr.org/2023/04/10/1169154500/tennessee-rep-justin-jones-unanimously-reappointed-to-house-by-nashville-council
Justin Jones shows the power of oratory, steeped in the glorious rythms and language of the black preachers like MLK. He really kicks of at about the five minute mark, searing stuff.
Just awesome thanks Sanctuary.
Uplifting.
One of my law tutors, Hon Simon France, died on 8/4/23. Our tutorial groups were small that year.
https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/crime/131731201/court-of-appeal-judge-simon-france-dies
“Simon was respected and loved by his former students, by his colleagues from his years in practice, and by his judicial peers."
lol
https://twitter.com/theplatform_nz/status/1645635856357801984
Ardern’s office told The Spinoff that the listing is fake – and Ardern herself had no idea it existed. “Ms Ardern was not aware of this website page before now, and the listing is certainly not authorised by her,” a government spokesperson said.
Despite this, Sean Plunket’s media outlet The Platform has pushed the idea that Ardern has been hiding her new speaking engagement from the public. A post on The Platform’s Facebook yesterday teased “the new job Ardern doesn’t want you to know about” and said that Plunket would be revealing the “untold truth” on Tuesday morning. “A truth legacy media kept secret or didn’t want to ask about,” the post continued. The claims were shared by users on Twitter.
Plunket later tweeted: “nice work if you can get it” with a screenshot of the fake Ardern listing.
https://thespinoff.co.nz/politics/11-04-2023/no-jacinda-ardern-isnt-joining-the-paid-speaker-circuit
Surely, Sean should not have done that, but he’s a good man
Why do you think he's a good man?
He's never struck me as particularly good.
We obviously need larger emoticons.
Good is what good does.
See joe90’s comment to which I replied and form your own judgement.
PS I had another longer answer for you typed out but my sense of humour is not welcome here and I don’t really want to rile up others. It’s a pity because it is actually quite good 😉
Sure,
. Couldn't find the "good" reference in joe90's comment so it appeared to come out of the blue – now I know it came out of you.
(Now I've inflicted bad rhyming humour on TS, your efforts will be a step up. I'm sure any levity will be appreciated ATM.)
An insightful article on declining trust in the media that contains good info & analysis.
https://www.rnz.co.nz/national/programmes/mediawatch/audio/2018885345/mediawatch-turning-off-the-news
So time to do a Chasers style collection for the farmers, from people who’ve just lost their home to a flood or just from the rest of us struggling with inflation?
Cost of climate inaction NRT
‘And on that point, we should remember that any failure to meet our Paris target can be laid at the feet of one noisy, greedy, selfish group: farmers. Less than 5% of the population, they produce 50% of our emissions, and are refusing to reduce them. …
…
Their refusal is on-track to cost us $24 billion. Its only fair that they should be the ones who pay for it.’