Open Mike 12/06/2017

Written By: - Date published: 6:00 am, June 12th, 2017 - 129 comments
Categories: open mike - Tags:

Open mike is your post.

For announcements, general discussion, whatever you choose. The usual rules of good behaviour apply (see the Policy).

Step up to the mike …

129 comments on “Open Mike 12/06/2017”

  1. Ed 1

    ‘Labour AHEAD of Tories by six points in stunning new poll as public say Theresa May should resign.

    Jeremy Corbyn would be Prime Minister if an election was held tomorrow, according to the pollster which most accurately predicted Thursday’s election result.

    A new poll by Survation puts Labour six points ahead of the Tories on 45% of the vote.
    The Tories, meanwhile, polled 39% – almost four points below their result in the general election.
    It is the first time since Theresa May took power that any poll has put Labour ahead of the Conservatives.’

    http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/politics/most-accurate-pollster-suggests-labour-10602762

    • Ed 1.1

      And the good news keeps coming……

      Richard Burgon
      “In last 3 days, 150,000 people have joined Labour. We now have 800,000 members. Great news! Let’s make it a million! ”

      ‘Just days after the election, Labour has received two bits of very good news. Firstly, its membership has surged to a stunning 800,000. Secondly, a new poll suggests that, were there to be another general election, Labour would now beat the Conservatives by a country mile.
      By the end of the New Labour era, Labour’s membership had dropped to just over 150,000. Now Corbyn has attracted that number of new members in just three days:
      The party, already the largest social democratic one in Europe, now has 800,000 – and has the million mark in its sights.’

      https://www.thecanary.co/2017/06/11/labour-good-news-corbyn-surge-ballistic/

  2. Tony Veitch (not the partner-bashing 3rd rate broadcaster 2

    Bugger! I’ll have to stop watching The Canary! Far too much unrealistic enthusiasm! Far too much fallacious hope!

    Back home: it is a truism that Opposition Parties don’t win elections, Government Parties lose them.

    Well, come September, enough centrist voters might, just might, change their votes to give the Labour/Greens enough seats to continue doing the same as National, only in a nicer, friendlier way. Neoliberalism with a smiling face!

    A million people still will not bother voting, but there will be a small surge of hope when a Labour/Green administration, with necessary support from NZ First, becomes government. Nothing much else will change, of course, but we’ll all feel momentarily better.

    Oh, they’ll do their best to put a dent in some of the big issues the election was fought on. But, apart from those efforts, nothing fundamental will be any different! The poor might be better cared for, but the rich will still get richer!

    And the rampant enthusiasm expressed above will carry us on to victory. Wah!

    Man, there are goals worth making an effort for! I’m all fired up! I feel inspired! Not quite like Corbyn inspired the left in the UK, but hey, this is NZ after all. We don’t do passion – except in sport.

    • Ed 2.1

      And isn’t Jonathan Pie brilliant?

    • garibaldi 2.2

      Nice rant TV, but “neoliberalism with a smiling face” just won’t cut it anymore.
      This British election proves that Labour has to turn left.

      • BM 2.2.1

        The British election doesn’t prove shit.

        Are 90% of the people who post here ex-poms or something? guys NZ is not at all like the UK completely different country and attitudes.

        • ScottGN 2.2.1.1

          Same issues bubbling to the surface though with respect to young people. The burden of student loan debt, housing affordability and the declining prospects of home-ownership, a sense that they’re getting screwed in some generational war where older voters have circled the wagons around all their entitlements and bugger everyone else.

        • One Anonymous Bloke 2.2.1.2

          If people here are so wildly different, how come the National Party uses the same right wing talking points as the Conservatives?

          • ScottGN 2.2.1.2.1

            In fact how come they use the same strategists?

            • Wayne 2.2.1.2.1.1

              From what I can see National doesn’t have the same approach as the Conservatives.

              They are campaigning from fundamentally a better economic base, so no emphasis on fear.

              But there is the real issue of younger people finding it harder to buy a house, especially in Auckland.

              Bill English also looks much more comfortably connected to the electorate than Theresa May.

              • bwaghorn

                yeah because he can shear a sheep and make shit pizza and and …..

                • Exactly, Bill English doesnt have it, never had it, and he wont get it.

                • AB

                  …and tell us we are “pretty useless” and rort his housing allowance for a sum greater than the median wage.
                  He’s a dull and depressing ex-Treasury ideologue – Don Brash without the charisma.
                  Truly – I really mean that last bit – Don was riveting because you never knew if he was about to say something totally insane.

              • ScottGN

                You reckon? It depends which electorate you’re talking about I guess.

              • Carolyn_nth

                They are campaigning from fundamentally a better economic base, so no emphasis on fear.

                Unless you’re a beneficiary or one of the precariously employed, or just low income.

                Edit: of course, what they campaign on, and how they perform in government are not the same things.

              • Bill

                Not meaning to distract you here Wayne. But back in April you posted comments relating to a Tory surge in Scotland. (I, me – egg on my face over that one 😉 ). But given that elsewhere you readily admit to being too far way to have any insight into UK politics, and given that the Tories in Scotland could have been counted on a careless sawmill worker’s remaining fingers since the 1980s…just wondering if there’s anything any little birdies told you that you might want to share?

              • “From what I can see National doesn’t have the same approach as the Conservatives.”
                Something’s changed then. They used to be Tweedledum and Tweedledee, shaped by Crosby/Textor and sharing ideas like old school chums – at least they were when I saw the video-link between the two parties at a Blue/Green meeting – those Tory chaps and ours were full of bonhomie (and other stuff but that’s another matter).

              • Stuart Munro

                ‘They are campaigning from a fundamentally better economic base.’

                It didn’t have to be that way Wayne, NZ’s economy could have been as strong as Britain’s if that braindead moron Bill English had grown the productive sector instead of relabeling real estate inflation and migrant capital inflows as growth.

                The Gnats have been a shamefully lazy as well as a corrupt and socially backward government.

                • Wayne

                  The NZ economy, on any objective measure, is doing better than the UK and has done so for years. I think you will find even NZ Labour admits that.
                  This shows up in the “right direction/wrong direction” polls. In NZ has been positive for years, in the UK it has been negative.
                  Of course in MMP that is no guarantee for the government. Even with National at 47% the govt only has a one seat majority.
                  So it is all up in the air.

                  • Stuart Munro

                    You persist in trying to reinforce your fiction – objective measures like the inflation adjusted cost of living obviously form no part of your calculations.

                    The Gnat ‘strong economy’ is an artifact constructed from spurious data which has no basis in reality.

                    Slow immigration with its attendant capital inflows and the illusion will fade away overnight.

                    You’ve made a complete fuck of it.

                    Balance of payments gives the lie to all your nonsense.

                  • Draco T Bastard

                    The NZ economy, on any objective measure, is doing better than the UK and has done so for years.

                    Only in the minds of the delusional who deny the ever increasing poverty that present policies produce because a few people are getting richer.

                    I think you will find even NZ Labour admits that.

                    If so then it would show their own disconnection from reality.

                    • Enough is Enough

                      Yes – but it still doing better than the UK where the Tories have made deeper cuts than here, and seen unemployment grow a lot higher.

                      Not saying New Zealand is good. Just pointing out that the UK has been hit harder by the rabid Conservative Government.

              • Gabby

                His don’t really give a shit attitude certainly resonates.

        • Draco T Bastard 2.2.1.3

          NZ is not at all like the UK completely different country and attitudes.

          He says of a country that once prided itself on being more British than the British.

          We still haven’t got rid of that cultural cringe factor.

          • BM 2.2.1.3.1

            Nah, long gone.

            We’re about as similar to the UK as the Canadians are to the USA.

            • One Anonymous Bloke 2.2.1.3.1.1

              “…how come the National Party uses the same right wing talking points as the Conservatives?”

              Why can I find all your opinions in The Daily Mail?

            • Draco T Bastard 2.2.1.3.1.2

              Nope, still pretty much in place. You can tell by the fact that some people complain about the use of Māori names for the islands that we inhabit.

              It’s not as bad as it once was but it is still there.

        • Robert Guyton 2.2.1.4

          “The British election doesn’t prove shit.”

          You’re going to have to squeal louder, BM. The sound of NZ’s left wing’s joyous celebrating is making such wheedles as yours all but impossible to hear.

          • Alan 2.2.1.4.1

            Did i miss something? Did Labour UK win the election and Jeremy Corbyn is British PM for the next 5 years and is about to implement all his policies?
            No?
            Thought not

            • Robert Guyton 2.2.1.4.1.1

              Did you miss something, Alan?
              Oh yes, you did.
              Here’s a helpful clue. Millions of left wingers are revived, empowered, expectant and celebrating. Watch out!

            • greywarshark 2.2.1.4.1.2

              Alan
              Sorry TS doesn’t supply a nice simple explanation for political behaviour so that it is easy to understand. Did you understand that? No. Thought not. More thought by you is needed as for all of us. It is complex.

            • ScottGN 2.2.1.4.1.3

              It may well be that Jeremy Corbyn does become PM and perhaps sooner rather than later. In the meantime though he’s best to sit back and let the Tories go to town on each other.

          • BM 2.2.1.4.2

            Why would the left be celebrating Labour not getting decimated in the UK election?

            Seriously how does that help the NZ Labour party?, apart from a few political junkies who frequent boards such as this one or Kiwiblog, no one even knew there was an election in the UK or even cared.

            These days the UK has about as much relevance to NZ as Madagascar

            • One Anonymous Bloke 2.2.1.4.2.1

              Which is why the National Party parrots right wing talking points conceived in Madagascar.

              • AB

                Obviously they already have a brighter future in Madagascar!
                What do they call it?
                Are they “on the cusp of a brighter present”

            • Robert Guyton 2.2.1.4.2.2

              Why would the left be celebrating, BM?
              Puzzling for you, isn’t it!
              They are though, really cock-a-hoop, the lot of them!
              Maybe they’ve enjoyed a success that you just can’t see.
              I’m sure though, you wish them well in their happiness.
              After all, they’re just ordinary folk, like you.

              • Ethica

                Yay, neoliberalism is dead. Socialism is electorally popular, particularly with young people. Lots to celebrate.

            • marty mars 2.2.1.4.2.3

              Based on that logic BM why are you going on about it? No one cares, it’s not relevant and so on.

              Sure a lot of UKians are still very attached to their old country and comment accordingly – not really a surprise and sure it can be irritating ☺

              For me this election have given me some hope. And in these days hope is worth a lot mate.

            • mauī 2.2.1.4.2.4

              Just to clarify the people who frequent this blog and the other one are people like yourself and chuck and blade steaks.

      • Tony Veitch (not the partner-bashing 3rd rate broadcaster 2.2.2

        Garibaldi:
        My point exactly!

        • garibaldi 2.2.2.1

          Right on TV.
          Sorry about that, but it certainly brought out the right wing apologists. They just don’t get it. It is inconceivable to them that Jeremy is on to something decent.

  3. Ed 3

    However,The Guardian cannot be trusted.

    http://theguardian.fivefilters.org/?v1

  4. AsleepWhileWalking 4

    https://www.peakprosperity.com/blog/109221/why-markets-overdue-gigantic-bust

    Global economic growth is weak, has been weak, and will continue to be weak for many reasons. Not least of which is the massive overhanging piles of accumulated debt across the global economy, which are very growth unfriendly.

    As Professor Steve Keen has shown, if your debt grows at 10%, and this enables your economy to grow at 5%, anything less than a more rapid rate of credit growth in the future will cause your economy to contract.

    Said another way, as long as you can grow your debts at a faster pace than your income — forever — you’ll never have to experience another economic downturn.

    That statement right there, lays bare the entire ridiculousness of everything the central banks have, and are currently trying to engineer.

    Eventually, reality always catches up

    • Draco T Bastard 4.1

      Eventually, reality always catches up

      Eventually, but the capitalists will try kicking the can down the road for awhile more yet.

  5. I wrote a post, Deportee, in December 2015 about a young man who was send here from Oz, despite having no close family, no friends, no links in NZ.

    The inevitable has happened.

    If any readers want to help the family get Matt’s body home to Oz there is now a fundraising page.

    https://www.gofundme.com/bring-matty-home

    Any donation, no matter how small, will help end Matt’s story on a good note.

    The original post can be found here: /deportee/

    An updated version is here: https://tereoputake.wordpress.com/2017/06/08/death-of-a-deportee/

    Cheers, TRP.

    • greywarshark 5.1

      I read your story yesterday TRP. It was very affecting. He was a rough diamond, had work, was an employer, had family and was sent into exile by the Australians on spurious grounds. Totally medieval. I’m putting something in wish I could give more. Everyone deserves fair treatment, and just treatment, this chap had neither.

      And Gerry Brownlee’s bulk is all marshmallow. This morning on Radionz he didn’t have much to say about how OZ needs to behave with respect to we NZrs. Just a bunch of excuses for them doing what they feel like. Unfortunately our countries are infected by neoliberal economic lack of ethical belief in the way that people are viewed. So RW NZ and OZ are in each others’ pockets, and a pocketful of mumbles is all they have to say about decent behaviour.OzKiwi wants stronger advocacy for expats from NZ government

      From Morning Report, 7:28 am today 5.42m
      The Foreign Affairs Minister is advising New Zealanders living in Australia they should seek dual citizenship or realise they’ll have fewer rights. Tim Gassin from Oz Kiwi is in our Wellington studio and says…..

      http://www.radionz.co.nz/national/programmes/morningreport/audio/201847152/ozkiwi-wants-stronger-advocacy-for-expats-from-nz-government

    • Thanks TRP

      A very sad ending to this story. But of course it is the end for Matt but not his child or his family.

      I hope his body can get back to his home.

      Kia kaha.

  6. lprent 6

    After a series of kernel stoppages in the last week, usually during the morning load winding up, the server is now on a late 4.4.0 kernel. So far that is stable.

    Which is a great relief as I have been stuck on other critical house move tasks but have been frustrated by the need to remain close to that damn machine.

    But I have noticed few quirks like slow saves of post settings. Hardly surprising as the 4.4 kernel doesn’t know much about the hardware on the server. I am also expecting some operations to be slow.

    Let me know here if you see anything odd that shows up today and later.

  7. One Anonymous Bloke 7

    Remember all those outraged stories about Salman Abedi’s family being let into the UK by MI5, implicating them in his crimes?

    Looks like they may well have been ‘fake news’: all suspects released without charge.

    • Bill 7.1

      no, I don’t recall any such stories OAB.

      Salman Abedi’s family were political refugees from Gadaffi’s Libya. His father was accused by Gadaffi of giving a heads up to targets of the then Libyan intelligence/security community. His father returned to Libya after the ouster of Gadaffi and has some position relating to UN recognised government factions or some such.

      • One Anonymous Bloke 7.1.1

        FT.

        Daily Fail.

        • Bill 7.1.1.1

          So the first link is to a subscription offer (not happening) and the second hasn’t got anything in it about Salman Abedi’s family being let into the UK by MI5.

          • One Anonymous Bloke 7.1.1.1.1

            “A subscription…”

            That’s weird.

            I found the FT piece using Google – could read it without being asked to subscribe.

            The title is: “Terrorism: Libya’s civil war comes home to Manchester.”

            …the attack raises serious questions over their assessment of it. MI5, the UK’s domestic intelligence agency, facilitated the travel of many Islamist Mancunians back to Libya…

            They weren’t the only two links I found.

            Perhaps RT’s report is a better fit for you.

            Allegations have also emerged that in 2011, the UK may have relaxed restrictions on LIFG fighters based in the UK and helped them return to Libya to fight Gaddafi.

            • Bill 7.1.1.1.1.1

              Those stories are about suspected or known Islamists being allowed to travel. Your comment was about Abedi’s family.

              • One Anonymous Bloke

                His father isn’t part of his family? See 7.1.2.1.

                • Bill

                  His father was a refugee. His father lives in Libya again. His father was questioned as was his sister. That would be normal procedure after a bombing.

                  And again. Nothing anywhere about any conspiracy involving the family being in cahoots with MI5 and directly involved in the Manchester bombing – as per the claims in your original comment.

                  • One Anonymous Bloke

                    Sure, none of the stories would have influenced a jury in any way whatsoever, had any of them been charged /sarc.

      • joe90 7.1.2

        no, I don’t recall any such stories OAB.

        Really?.

        Open Mike 26/05/2017

        • One Anonymous Bloke 7.1.2.1

          …in the ’90s, no-one would have given much of a second thought to offering asylum to the likes of Ramadan Abedi (the father), but…

          😆

          • Bill 7.1.2.1.1

            You’re not going to continue with what that “but” was about?

            Here, let me.

            …all this extremism was ‘contained’ by the security forces in countries like Libya, Iraq and Syria. They were the ones with skin in the game who kept tabs on shit, and western governments used their intel.

            I then went on to question why western governments chose to overthrow the governments that were known to be ‘containing’ the self-same terrorist threat that has now spilled into Europe.

            There is something comical about that observation OAB?

        • Bill 7.1.2.2

          What the fuck is wrong with people? Yes. I made a comment about the refugee status of Abedi’s family from the 90s. I reiterated that above.

          Now, how the fuck does anyone get from that to OABs comment about some conspiracy whereby the family was in cahoots with MI5 and directly involved in the Manchester bombing?

          And where have there been such stories? None of the links provided, in psite of AOBs comment, make that claim.

          • One Anonymous Bloke 7.1.2.2.1

            Whatever.

            My point is that after all that published front page innuendo, none of them have been charged, and that story has been all but buried.

            • Bill 7.1.2.2.1.1

              Your point was bullshit. There was no “front page innuendo” about the family in the way you claim.

              • Nah you are splitting hairs OAB’s point in his initial comment was valid with links imo.

                • Bill

                  Sure. There were no “outraged stories about Salman Abedi’s family being let into the UK by MI5, implicating them in his crimes”. And no links to any such stories.

                  But I’m splitting hairs.

                  • One Anonymous Bloke

                    Tetrapyloctomy. Let’s just assume in future that you aggressively disagree with whatever you think my point is at any given time, eh?

                    • Bill

                      You smeared unsubstantiated bullshit over a thread in Open Mike. I’d rather you didn’t.

                    • One Anonymous Bloke

                      Yes boss.

                    • The point was all held in connection set free. I’ll say thanks for putting it up because I want to know that.

                      As for the other – pretty mild compared to what governments and security services do to achieve their aims. Harder to believe it didn’t happen than did.

              • One Anonymous Bloke

                In fact, you’ve done sweet fuck all to refute my point. The rash of stories examining the Abedi family’s alleged links to Libyan Islamist fighters and MI5 were given far greater prominence than the reality of their being released without charge.

                Whether or not my summary of the narrative is 100% accurate is incidental.

                • Bill

                  You haven’t linked to a single one of this supposed “rash of stories examining the Abedi family’s alleged links to Libyan Islamist fighters and MI5”

                  There were some stories on the fathers extremism and his application for asylum in the 90s.

                  And there have been stories suggesting known or suspected Islamist terrorists (not specifically members of Abedi’s family) have found travel easy enough.

                  There has been nothing about any links between Abedi’s family and MI5.

                  Next time there’s a piece of crap propaganda – I guess you prefer the term “fake news” – are you going to hold to the line that accuracy or lack thereof is incidental?

                  • One Anonymous Bloke

                    Whereas I think a lot of dogwhistling went on, designed to give precisely that impression. An impression that will stick, especially since the lack of charges will not be given anything like as much prominence.

                    • Bill

                      There was no dogwhistling with regards Adebi’s family and MI5 or whatever and that was what your original comment focused on: his family.

                      Suspected collusion between known Islamist terrorists and MI5? Yup. There’s been reporting to that effect.

                      Is there anything to those stories? I dunno. But I wouldn’t be surprised if there was.

                      Thinking here of Shajul Islam, a UK trained doctor who was charged in connection with the kidnapping of John Cantlie, but who walked free from the High Court when all charges were dropped at the last minute (Cantlie had been kidnapped again). He subsequently turned up in Khan Shaykhun having his tweets uncritically reported by the western msm as though he was a neutral source of info.

                    • One Anonymous Bloke

                      “No dogwhistling”.

                      Here’s The Times,

                      from the visible part of the article…

                      Salman Abedi was linked to a group of disaffected young men who went to fight in Libya with their fathers before switching allegiance to Islamic State, The Times can reveal.

                      The bomber is understood to have been in Libya at the same time as some of the youths, all about the same age, who later faced terrorism charges.

                      Salman Abedi is believed to have turned to Isis while in Libya, where he had gone with his father.

                      It is thought that one of the counterterrorism raids yesterday was connected to the gang of Libyan extremists after police received a tip-off. Greater Manchester police have been told that Abedi was friends with at least two members of the group, who are all linked to Manchester…

                      And here’s Pilger.

                      …why the security service MI5 maintained terrorist “assets” in Manchester…

                      We’ve already established that you disagree, but perhaps others might be interested and offer their own take on it.

                    • McFlock

                      here’s a good one from stuff: in the article headlined “Britain says some of Manchester bomber’s network potentially still at large” there’s a nice teaser for a related story “Terror runs in the family”, the actual story headline “Manchester bombing: Police arrest suspected attacker’s family as they investigate terror ‘network'”.

                      Might not be a “rash”, but there was a consistent narrative.

  8. greywarshark 8

    Electricity suppliers 29 of them in NZ, electricity business of 4 million people oversupplied and overtapped as is anything remotely likely to be a business in NZ, are not putting money back into their systems – their infrastructure is ‘past its use by date’. Another example of business in NZ over-competitive, only able to succeed by underinvesting in everything including people being paid low wages. Wages are kept down by creating a pool of unemployed people with many immigrants seeking work so driven by high supply wages stay low.

    But one of the reasons that we had to change from a government managed country was because government wasn’t providing the infrastructure that business wanted. All these self-made men needed government and resented that. They should be able to own stuff and supply stuff to other businessmen. Now we have gone full circle under business control which is probably from offshore.

    Many electric lines companies have outdated equipment -ComCom
    From Morning Report
    Listen duration 3′ :29
    http://www.radionz.co.nz/national/programmes/morningreport/audio/201847167/many-electric-lines-companies-have-outdated-equipment-comcom
    A report by the Commerce Commission says many electric lines companies have outdated equipment that should have been replaced years ago. Our reporter Eric Frykberg has been looking into it.

    An item on a refugee from Eritrea, says very hard to get jobs. He knows of some with university degrees unable to find work. On radio this morning but not new news.

    English says that we need immigrants and talks about near full employment, but how reliable are those figures. We know how rain is measured, a straightforward method. But employment figures, are those ones that are catch-all for every bit of ‘paid’ work done starting from one hour per week?

    Politics
    12 June 2017
    http://www.radionz.co.nz/news/political/332798/slashing-immigration-would-be-unwise-pm – vid report
    Prime Minister Bill English says any drastic cuts to immigration would be bad for New Zealand’s economic growth.

    English told Morning Report that, with near-full employment in some areas, slashing immigration when there was a need for workers would not be sensible.
    Labour, which is expected to announce its immigration policy shortly, has accused the National government of failing to adequately plan for what has been record immigration – putting pressure on infrastructure, housing, and public services.

    “We’ve been planning for a growing economy and adapting to that growth, because it’s been more sustained I think than people expected – more successful than people expected,” Mr English said.
    “We need the people to do the jobs. Right now, the demands in the construction sector are as high as they have ever been.”

    He said if Labour announced a plan to cut net migration by 20,000-30,000 people a year, as has been reported, it would stall the economy.
    “We have to build the houses, we have to build the roads and the water pipes to support the houses – that’s for people who are here now.

    “Slashing the immigration – whatever you think of it – slashing it when you need the people to do the jobs that must be done, it doesn’t make any sense.”

    What’s this about planning for growth? National Party? Blunderbuss boys!
    Actually poor helpless, hapless Bull English charges into every problem without any finesse as he is a product of the economic Dr Dolittle business ‘intelligence’ system.

    Has he not heard of targeted immigration which we have in NZ had before and which needs to be used as a tool right now. All people who have applications in at present should be fairly treated and go through the system as is if they have paid a large sum of money. But then there should be a break where only applications from potential employers for waiting jobs in certain skills should be considered for say two years. ‘Something could be done, but nothing must be done for the first time!’

  9. Bill 9

    This is one for geeks.

    Just been reading an article in The Independent and came across this comment in the section below the article that appears to contain some very on point and informative links concerning the whole BREXIT malarkey. I’ve quickly checked out a couple of the links so far and yup, they’re nuts and bolts type stuff . I know we’re a long way away, but I’m aware that some (the geeks) are interested, so I’m posting the comment in its entirety for those interested in exploring the linked documents etc.
    ______________________-

    @SoManyStupidPeopleSoLittleTime”There is a HUGE difference between Hard Brexit and soft Brexit. You don’t get it?”-

    The EU27 leaders have explained many times that ‘soft Brexit’ does not exist. It is a delusional British fabrication that the Brits have been fighting about for months. You are fighting about unicorns in your distant galaxy.

    Read Article 50: There is only ONE kind of Brexit = the UK 100% out of the EU = all EU treaties cease to apply to the UK on 30 March 2019. The UK supreme court said so too.

    Barnier said there is only one kind of Brexit. Tusk said hard Brexit or no Brexit (which also means only ONE kind of Brexit). Schaeuble and Juncker said OUT IS OUT. Etc. etc.

    The UK cannot ‘keep’ anything it had as an EU member.

    After exit, the UK can start begging the EU27 for some limited access to the EU single market in exchange for UK’s large trade-offs.

    How many times do the Brits need to be told this?

    Unless of course by ‘hard Brexit’ you mean the UK crashing out of the EU without an exit agreement, whereas ‘soft Brexit’ means the UK exiting the EU with an exit agreement (about citizens’ rights, Irish border, financial obligations and many aspects of disentangling the UK from the EU as specified in the EU27 Brexit Directives). These two possibilities do exist.

    Instead of fighting about unicorns, I strongly recommend you read the EU27 Brexit documents – please explain where you see any kind of a ‘soft Brexit’:

    KEY DOCUMENTS ABOUT THE BREXIT NEGOTIATIONS ISSUED BY THE EU27

    Here is the trio of absolutely BINDING instructions for the EU27 Brexit negotiators = for the European Commission and Barnier’s team:

    (1) EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT RESOLUTION ON NEGOTIATIONS WITH THE UNITED KINGDOM
    adopted on 5 April 2017 = seven days after the UK’s exit notification!!!
    (516 MEPs in favour, 133 against, 50 abstain)

    http://www.europarl.europa.eu/sides/getDoc.do?type=TA&reference=P8-TA-2017-0102&language=EN&ring=P8-RC-2017-0237

    (2) EU27 COUNCIL’S GUIDELINES FOR BREXIT NEGOTIATIONS
    from 29 April 2017
    (unanimously adopted by 27 PMs/presidents)

    http://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/press/press-releases/2017/04/29-euco-brexit-guidelines/

    (3) THE EU27 DIRECTIVES FOR THE BREXIT NEGOTIATIONS
    unanimously adopted by EU27 General Affairs Council on 22 May 2017

    http://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/meetings/gac/2017/05/Directives-for-the-negotiation-xt21016-ad01re02_en17_pdf/

    The above trio is what the EU27 are putting on the table. When the UK gets its act together and finally crawls to the negotiating table, the EU27 negotiators will explain more details to the UK negotiators (whoever they are – the UK has not yet appointed any!!!).

    Oh, and shock and horror for Theresa No-Running-Commentary May, the EU27 GAC has also adopted

    (4) GUIDING PRINCIPLES FOR TRANSPARENCY IN NEGOTIATIONS UNDER ARTICLE 50 TEU

    http://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/meetings/gac/2017/05/transparency-xt21023_en17_pdf(1)/

    As a further clarification in more details of the Directives, the European Commission published two working papers specifying in more detail the EU27’s negotiating position on two topics of the exit agreement:

    (5) WORKING PAPER “ESSENTIAL PRINCIPLES ON CITIZENS’ RIGHTS” (4 pages)
    published on 29 May 2017, discussed by the EU27 representatives on 30 May

    https://ec.europa.eu/commission/sites/beta-political/files/citizens-rights-essential-principles-draft-position-paper_en.pdf

    (6) WORKING PAPER “ESSENTIAL PRINCIPLES ON FINANCIAL SETTLEMENT” (10 pages)
    published on 29 May 2017, discussed by the EU27 representatives on 1 June

    https://ec.europa.eu/commission/sites/beta-political/files/financial-settlement-essential-principles-draft-position-paper_en.pdf

    If the UK had a responsible government, it would now be working on examining in very great detail the EU27’s negotiating position as specified in the above documents and preparing its reply, e.g. which items the UK agrees about and for which it has counter-proposals or counter-arguments.

    Indeed, the ONLY way to start constructively sorting out the huge self-imposed Brexit mess is formation of a government of national unity with all parliamentary parties working together (without new elections). But sadly the Brits are not capable of working together even when faced with a major (self-imposed) notional crisis.

  10. weka 10

    Oh joy, Mike Williams and Matthew Hooton are the political commentators on RNZ this morning, talking about the about to be released Labour immigration policy and the UK situation. Is this really the best you can do RNZ?

  11. joe90 11

    The EDL marched in Manchester.

    EDL guy extends hand and Cop says "I'm not shaking your hand – and I am NOT your mate" Brilliant 🙂 #manchester pic.twitter.com/UGVvbvTSuV— Cliff O'Sullivan (@cliffsull) June 11, 2017

  12. greywarshark 12

    The project proceeds. The Hundertwasser museum and virant showcase for Maori has 3 weeks to raise it’s last money – $1.25 million. It will be something that will remain beautiful even when our reputation as clean, green and honest is tarnished.
    So we must intend that they make it.

    We need something that we have provided for ourselves, showcasing that Europe that has given us so much in the way of culture, from the beginning of NZ and then after WW2 where we were visited by people with deeper thoughts and ideas than we had ever envisaged. Mixed with Maori culture, the cultural centre will be a jewel on our emerald bosom. Poetic eh!

    http://www.nzherald.co.nz/northern-advocate/news/article.cfm?c_id=1503450&objectid=11869900

  13. greywarshark 13

    To the NZ Herald it is just a sensational story about a teacher posing like a showgirl wearing startling blue contact lenses. To me it’s worrying as I note that she is called a math teacher and is from a charter school in the USA. And is an example of the sort of teacher with extracurricular activities that should not be their business to teach children.

    A 25-year-old maths teacher at a North Carolina public charter school has been arrested on suspicion of carrying on sexual relationships with three male students.
    http://www.nzherald.co.nz/world/news/article.cfm?c_id=2&objectid=11874179

    (Seeing that there are extremely low barriers to qualifications and teaching at our charters it isn’t impossible that people with skewed attitudes would get involved.)

  14. Karen 15

    I admit that I was nervous about Labour’s new immigration policy announcement, but It looks to me that they have managed to produce a really good policy that just makes cuts in the dodgy, exploitative areas.

    http://img.scoop.co.nz/media/pdfs/1706/Immigration_factsheet_12Jun17_FIN.pdf

  15. Tony Veitch (not the partner-bashing 3rd rate broadcaster 16

    Somehow we need to get this message across to the NZ Labour Party!
    From Jacobin online magazine.

    Why Corbyn Won
    • BHASKAR SUNKARA

    “The Labour left remembered that you don’t win by tacking to an imaginary centre — you win by letting people know you feel their anger and giving them a constructive end to channel it towards. “We demand the full fruits of our labour,” the party’s election video said it all.”

    https://www.jacobinmag.com/2017/06/jeremy-corbyn-election-results-labour-theresa-may-left

  16. saveNZ 17

    Officials fear $140m charity tax rort

    “One senior lawyer involved in the foreign trusts industry, speaking on condition of anonymity, said expenses incurred by the charities looked at in Operation Timepiece seemed high.

    In the past three years for which accounts for the charities are available, a total of $4.1m was paid in legal, structure and trustee fees, while $5.7m was distributed – the majority to Fondation Eagle, controlled by many of the same lawyers.

    “This seems to be more of a charity for lawyers,” the senior lawyer said.”

    http://www.nzherald.co.nz/index.cfm?objectid=11872252&ref=twitter

  17. Ad 18

    NZ Treasury’s last fiscal update before the election is a gift to the government:

    “The OBEGAL was a surplus of $2.5 billion for the ten months to 30 April 2017, compared to a forecast surplus of $1.0 billion. This favourable variance of $1.5 billion was largely due to the higher than forecast core Crown tax revenue and lower than forecast core Crown expenses discussed above.”

    Plenty of room for National campaign lollies.

    I suspect Joyce will manifesto another positive shift to the tax brackets for lower income people.

  18. Ed 19

    Oh my !!!!!!
    There’s a celebrity in New Zealand and the NZ Herald is so excited.
    The New Herald is a cringeworthy tabloid rag

    http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=11874800

    Meanwhile the British ignore their establishment neo-liberal media and vote for socialism.

    Can we learn from them?

  19. Blade 20

    Still smarting from that kicking I gave you yesterday? Another worthless troll post from someone who had no answers when called out.

    [TheStandard: A moderator moved this comment to Open Mike as being off topic or irrelevant in the post it was made in. Be more careful in future.]

    • Stuart Munro 20.1

      Oh you poor baby – Poor ignorant backward baby blade!

      Who of course cannot answer any real question in someone else’s professional discipline.

      Go home – you demean yourself (and that’s not easy! 😀 )

      • Blade 20.1.1

        Thanks for reminding me…I am still waiting on Robert Guyton to tell me the years he was at teachers college and the actual years he spent teaching.

        As for the rest of your post..your were quite correct to use a smiley face imoge. It’s good to see you don’t take yourself seriously. Neither do I.

        • Robert Guyton 20.1.1.1

          Jeepers, Blade, I had no idea you were suspended with anticipation of my personal details. Let’s see, I was at Dunedin Teachers College for 2 years, some 33 years ago, or there abouts. I taught for 15 years at a primary school, then several more at high school, including filling the role of Head of Department, Maori studies, where I taught te reo and other associated things Maori. Thank goodness for my knowledge of Te Tiriti o Waitangi, eh taku hoa! I’ve also taught in a museum classroom, where I introduced children to the marvels of the tuatara, carefully handling those ancient sphenodons so as not to hurt them, the children or myself. I’ve done tutoring for university level learners and worked alongside of Steiner trained early childhood teachers, as well as several other teaching positions that I’ll not mention for the sake of brevity. Hope that satisfies your seemingly insatiable curiosity – that’s something I like in a learner, curiosity, I have to say.

      • In Vino 20.1.2

        Baby-blade.. Not bad, but I think I prefer Bladey-boy. I think that sums up his(?) faux bluster.

    • One Anonymous Bloke 20.2

      You didn’t “call him out”, you witless parrot: you parroted a load of rote-learned gobshite and offered nothing of substance whatsoever.

      Funny that you describe it as “a kicking” too, considering the contempt in which pwned drivel is held around here. I’m picking you for a real tough guy so long as you’ve got a keyboard to cower behind.

  20. Muttonbird 21

    You’re a right wing nut job is what you are.

    [TheStandard: A moderator moved this comment to Open Mike as being off topic or irrelevant in the post it was made in. Be more careful in future.]

    • BM 21.1

      You’re an angry man Muttonbird, ever thought of going and seeing a psychiatrist and getting it sorted?

      Must be tough on the wife and kids all that rage and aggression, poor things are probably terrified.

      • Muttonbird 21.1.1

        Ha! You’re an embarrassment mate. That sort of personal abuse is way over the top and shows you can’t behave yourself on this forum.

        Your post is internet bullying and worthy of a report. Hoping one of the moderators sees this because you are clearly in breach of the HDCA.

        • Muttonbird 21.1.1.1

          The reverse would be someone calling me a swivel-eyed leftie loon or similar. If I attacked them and their family because of that, in the way BM has done, I would expect to get at least a week off.

          I’m pretty pissed off right now that this scumbag mentioned my family.

          Halfcrown, where did your comment go?

          • mauī 21.1.1.1.1

            Yep, one of the worst comments I’ve seen.

            • James 21.1.1.1.1.1

              Really ? There are a lot worse post on here against “righties” sometimes with a lot of mob mentality following on.

              Or there have been some down right disgusting ones like the one a day after the WINZ workers were murdered and a poster said the killer should be hailed as a hero.

              there have been threats of real world violence (in respect to this every time I have seen this the mods banned and edited).

              So what muttonbird is crying about isn’t that bad in the scheme of things.

              • joe90

                down right disgusting

                millsy, always the prick and fuck him

                • Yep him and his fucken piano wire – often quoted by righties saying the left is just as bad as they are.

                  • james

                    Marty – even us righties know not all lefties are as bad as him. Was mainly pointing out to Maui – that its really isnt one of the worse comments on here by a long way.

                    • Yep fair point james

                    • Muttonbird

                      You seem to be saying because it’s not the worst it’s totally fine?

                      That a commenter can bully someone on mental health and accuse them of domestic abuse clearly breaches any measure of decency.

                      You’re fine with it though…

              • millsy

                I have since changed my stance on Tully. Given that news emerged that police have drawn connections between him and the Kirsty Bentley case (the extent of which is not known), and that his actions have led to the intimidating security policies in place at WINZ offices, I do not belive that he is a ‘hero’ anymore.

                Though I do think he should be in a mental health unit, not a prison.

  21. Halfcrown 22

    “Halfcrown, where did your comment go”

    I dunno I think I must have an error deleted it trying to edit.
    But I thought that was a pretty low comment

    I think I wrote something like this.

    Come on BM that is far below your normal standard. As much as I don’t agree with your comments at times you do put up an intelligent valid point of view. You are far above that type of comment so don’t lower yourself. That definitely was not called for.

    • Muttonbird 22.1

      Thanks for replying.

      That no action has been taken against BM must mean his comments are fine.

      • In Vino 22.1.1

        Or just not quite despicable enough..

      • marty mars 22.1.2

        Mods will make their own decision on the day. So if you cut and pasta BMs offensive comment back to him in the future at an opportune time YOU may get bolded. It is good to hold it for when he goes complete bullshitty and moaning about quality of comments or nastiness of the left.

        Truth is you made him skip his nice guy persona and show his nasty gnat side – still it is understandable that his comment has upset you.

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

  • New digital service to make business easy
    A new digital platform aims to make it easier for small businesses to access services from multiple government agencies, leaving them more time to focus on their own priorities. Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern and Minister for Small Business Stuart Nash ...
    5 days ago
  • Million-dollar start to gun collection events
    Million-dollar start to gun collection events  Police Minister Stuart Nash says a solid start has been made to the gun buyback and amnesty after the first weekend of community collection events. “Gun owners will walk away with more than ...
    6 days ago
  • Praise after first firearms collection event
    Police Minister Stuart Nash has praised Police and gun owners after the first firearms collection event saw a busy turnout at Riccarton Racecourse in Christchurch. “Police officers and staff have put a tremendous effort into planning and logistics for the ...
    6 days ago
  • New Police constables deployed to regions
    Seventy-eight new Police constables are heading out to the regions following today’s graduation of a new recruit wing from the Royal New Zealand Police College. Police Minister Stuart Nash says the record high number of new Police officers being recruited, ...
    2 weeks ago