Just testing the waters here (off the back of this) but are there any women here who would find value in having a daily “dick free” post/thread – a bit like Open Mike but with no male contributions?
Hardly possible to make it perfect since a commentator’s gender isn’t always obvious, but the idea would be that any comments from people known to be male would simply be shunted to Open Mike in the first instance, and anyone seeking to masquerade as female would have the known threat of a ban (to be counted in years?) hanging over any possible discovery of their shenanigans.
More than that very rudimentary level of moderation would be contingent on a women with back end access and permissions taking up the baton. (Which may never happen.)
sigh – painful to feel this necessity to state the obvious, but this comment is seeking responses only from women who frequent the site.
“The Guardian’s Alarming Recent Record Of Propaganda, Misinformation, And Slander
As has often happened to progressive-minded people who’ve reached a more radical point in their political evolutions, I’ve become disillusioned with many organizations, leaders and media sources that I used to rely on. One of these dubious sources is The Guardian.
At first, it seemed to me like The Guardian is a good alternative to the American mainstream media outlets. It’s often featured quality articles about subjects like climate change, and its columnist George Monbiot is the one who first taught me what the term “neoliberal” means. But this good material is what gives a feel of reliability to the misleading claims that The Guardian very often puts out……”
Good Morning to you Ed, From the link you have provided, What you and your writer object to is the Guardian’s exposure of your other’s fascism denial, and the Guardian’s continued exposure and coverage of the genocide being carried out by your favourite dictator. I have no doubt you find this exposure “alarming”. And it is your alarm and fear of being exposed that fuels your hatred of the Guardian
However what I sense is that lately your and others support for fascism has become somewhat muted, for fear of being laughed out of court. Witness the long winded lead in before this writer dares to mention their real gripe with the Guardian, their coverage of Syria.
But this good material is what gives a feel of reliability to the misleading claims that The Guardian very often puts out.
And Monbiot himself has been one of The Guardian’s main sources of these claims. In a 2014 essay, the journalist Jonathan Cook called Monbiot “the left’s McCarthy,” and wrote that Monbiot “is not a guardian of our moral consciences, as he likes to think, but a guardian of the outer limits of a corporate-sanctioned consensus.” Cook provided good reasons for these characterizations; when the scholars Ed Herman and David Peterson argued that recent conflicts in Rwanda and the Balkans have been falsely characterized as “genocides” to benefit Western narratives, Monbiot wrote a 2011 column in The Guardian denouncing these scholars as genocide deniers……
……..I’m referring to Monbiot’s coverage of Syria in the last eight years. In 2011, Monbiot used two expat businessmen and one British man as his personal consultants over whether the West should impose sanctions on Syria-while the opinions of the Syrian people were completely ignored. This journalistic practice was biased to say the least, and it indicated that Monbiot would stay within official Western narratives in his reporting on Syria.
Monbiot has since consistently pushed narratives about Assad’s government that help advance the U.S./NATO empire’s goals for Syrian intervention. In 2014, Monbiot wrote a column in The Guardian which characterized an al-Qaeda fighter’s act of terrorism as an “act of extraordinary courage” because the fighter had targeted an Assad-controlled prison. In November 2016, Monbiot tweeted that Assad and Putin had been carrying out a “destruction in Aleppo” when there had been no massacre in Aleppo, and when the rebel fighters were allowed to leave with their families and their weapons. And whenever Monbiot’s fellow journalists have questioned Assad’s role in Syrian chemical incidents, Monbiot has attacked them in the same aggressive and closed-minded way he attacked Herman and Peterson……
I find it breathtaking myself that the Standard tolerates Ed’s fascist propagandizing for a moment. He was running some crap yesterday about world war two in the Ukraine, as part of his campaign manufacturing consent for Putin’s invasion there.
I guess all the old tropes are being shown to be true – the intellectually weak being susceptible to propaganda, and the mild liberals being too nice to reject fascism and trying to accommodate it. It’s as if all the lessons of the early twentieth century were forgotten. Though of course it’s a generational thing – they never learned it.
[My “breathtaking” is to be found in my hitherto tolerance for your tiresome and dishonest hounding of contributors to the site over days and weeks – for your apparent presumption to determine who should and should not comment here; to determine what political opinions ought to be allowed and not allowed; to openly lie about peoples’ political leanings and motivations…Etc.
Notice the word “hitherto”? The tolerance has been chibbed, and this is the only warning you’ll be getting to pull your head in, stop disrupting the flow of comments with your vendettas or whatever the hell it is you think your doing, and engage solely with the topic or arguments at hand.] – B.
It’s funny you should say it’s a generational thing, Stuart, because Ed does kinda remind me of a particularly naive commenter from years back, Kiwiteen 123.
The nice thing about Ed’s contributions is that he occasionally hits the nail on the head, so it’s probably better to encourage him when he does get it right, rather than get overly negative on his dictator boostering. Like all of us, Ed’s a work in progress and every day’s a learning day.
As for Kiwiteen 123, I reckon he’s at uni now and every bit as annoying:
I’ll fess up now @ Stuart M and a few others. My penis is considerably CONSIDERABLY less in length than yours.
I console myself in the knowledge that its girth is something to behold.
And while I’m in the confessional, it’s possible I’ve sometimes told a little white lie or two – definitely two at least. One as to its length, the other its girth.
@ Jenny@Stuart Munro@te reo putake….Ed is exactly right to feel disillusioned with The Guardian, I take it you all don’t?
Yet The Guardian is plainly biased against the first tangible Left Wing political movement to give a viable alternative to Liberalism to emerge in the UK for a couple of generations…so I take it from your vocal defense of The Guardian that you all have more sympathy for a the New Labour Blairite style Labour, rather than a Socialist Labour?
I have considerable reservations about the Guardian’s anti-Corbyn campaigns and similar nonsense. But when we look at what Ed does endorse the Guardian starts to look pretty good.
Jenny Monbiot is just one journalist.
The Guardian deliberately puts forward opposing views.
Your description of Assad is only an opinion.
The Syrian war is a power grab by Putin pushing back the Arab spring Obama cockup who followed George W’s cock up.
If the US got more involved we would have seen more wars breaking out.
While Assad is a nasty Dictator who would have replaced him IsIs.
GH Bush warned his son not to invade Iraq as it would open an hornets nest
Guess what the hornets nest has been opened and its never going to be closed.
Religious fanatics from all sides will ensure that peace will never be achieved.
Arms sales will go up and who are the 2 biggest arms exporters they will want continuous dysfunction in the Middle East.
You’ll be liking this article Ed.
The Guardian explaining that the Saudis were actually quite a progressive and reasonable state with a restrained attitude who have, under Prince Mohammed, had a fine respect for human life and freedoms, its just that they are falling under the evil and nefarious influence of Putin.
“The Russian president’s role in the Middle East had suddenly expanded and his footprint throughout Europe and the US was growing just as rapidly. The young prince seemed curious about what the mercurial Putin had been up to: annexation, intimidation, deflection, the denial of objective facts. But he kept coming back to one question, the officials recalled: how does he get away with it? “He was fascinated by him,” one of the Britons told the Observer. “He seemed to admire him. He liked what he did.” Two years later Prince Mohammed is embroiled in a crisis unlike any other in his short, combustible time as the world’s most powerful thirtysomething. The crown prince stands accused of ordering the brutal death of a prominent critic on foreign soil – a state-sanctioned hit that is without precedent in the kingdom’s modern history, but is not quite so unknown in Russia.”
You’d be right in thinking I’ve sneakily linked to some sabre rattling paranoia and misinformation in the Daily Mail, but no, it really is the Guardian blaming Putin for prince Muhammad’s ‘misstep’. poor boy gullible that he is.
Nicely put Siobhan
The Guardian really has become shameless and reckless about fact checking;
seemingly these are the Guardian’s “values” now
Chulov has always been more of an opinion piece guy, but this is passed off as news!
MSB was never a reformer, as shown by the provided links https://www.amnesty.org.nz/free-saudi-women-who-fought-right-drive
If it’s a bad news story, there’s always a Russian angle to be had.
Nice (though painfully see through) cover for, or deflection from, all the diplomatic, economic and military support afforded SA by the UK and others though, aye?
Sioban the Saudi govt is playing Putin off against Trump another Syria in the making.
Like Trump says if we don’t supply them with the US$120 billion arms deal Russia will.
You’d be right in thinking I’ve sneakily linked to some sabre rattling paranoia and misinformation in the Daily Mail, but no, it really is the Guardian blaming Putin for prince Muhammad’s ‘misstep’. poor boy gullible that he is.
Sioban
I think Sioban that the Guardian article is hysterical and more balanced than you give them credit for.
Blaming Trump as much as Putin as setting the low bar on human rights and international norms of behaviour.
From the linked article you supplied:
Trump repeatedly claims that the US no longer sets the world order – except on Iran – and has pointedly eased pressure on states that previous administrations claimed had long fallen short on human rights and governance. The result has been a vacuum in global leadership, emboldening leaders who might otherwise have checked their behaviour, a Riyadh-based western ambassador said.
“Relationships are being redefined. People know there are no limits,” the ambassador said. “If ever there was a case study of the post-fact Middle East, this is it. There is impunity all around.”
Back in 1990(?) The Guardian (then still in a broadsheet format) ran a front page consisting of a full page, disturbing photo of a dead man’s face. It was in the lead-up to what would become the break up of Yugoslavia, and The Guardian was baying for war/intervention.
Back then, The Guardian was considered to be the middle class, sandal wearing peoples’ rag that offered the ‘correct’ spelling of youghourt, the mis-spelling of just about everything else (their typos were a running joke), alongside many articles on the fine art of hand wringing and “first world” problems.
So they haven’t really changed. And there is still the occasional nugget to be found in their pages.
It was The Guardian (accidentally or otherwise) that published an article based on official government documents that exposed UK government funding to Syrian Jihadists.(I’ve linked to it a few times) And sure, they never built on it and it ran entirely counter to their editorial line – which is and always has been crap.
Meanwhile, Monbiot does some good stuff on the environment, but is otherwise a complete waste of time and space. Larry Elliot has written some good stuff on the economics front. And they otherwise sometimes carry good opinion pieces.
It was the Grauniad that broke the Murdoch newspapers phone hacking scandal, which ended in the closure of the News of the World. And there’s their work with Edward Snowden and others. The Panama Papers was theirs in part as well.
It’s always worth remembering that the paper itself doesn’t claim to be left wing, though obviously a lot of its writers are. There are alternatives in the UK (the Mirror is surprisingly good on politics and the Morning Star is devoted to left wing analysis), however there isn’t another major English language newspaper in the world that is as consistently progressive as the Guardian.
In a wider sense, the problem is that the Russians and others have devalued ‘news’ to the point where even the concept of journalism is a mystery to a lot of people and opinion writers get confused with reporters of fact as if they were one and the same thing.
I wouldn’t characterise the Guardian as “progressive”. It’s liberal and always has been, which is fine unless the reader expects a perspective coming from the left.
Devaluing news? Dumbing down? That started back before the internet and I’d think more or less coincided with the reprise of liberalism across the Anglosphere.
There’s a pattern here.
Short staffing.
Wonder if RNZ noticed it and could join the dots.
“Workloads and pay would need to improve before NZ teacher Michael Harvey would consider returning as part of the government’ recruitment drive, he says.”
What nonsense blaming the teacher shortage on neo-liberalism. Teachers have been complaining about workload and class sizes all my adult life. In the late sixties when I was at school the typical fifth form class was a little over 30 students.
On the views of the PPTA the teaching “crisis” must have been continuously running for over 50 years.
Same with nurses. Hospitals seem to have had similar staffing ratios for just about forever.
It suits the unions to say everything is a crisis because they know the government will give in. It is after all the government the unions financed so these pay rounds are just their due reward.
Same across the entire state sector. Just about everyone will get pay rises over the next 3 years of between 5 and 10% per year.
Hard to disagree with that since it concords with my experience too. Important for teachers to bleat in general terms rather than blame the evil controller who keeps refusing to give them more money. Serves the subsidiary purpose of reinforcing the public view that teachers are unable to connect cause & effect.
It doesn’t occur to you that cost of living has grown rapidly under neo-liberalism Wayne? Of course it wouldn’t – such stresses do not touch insiders. Particularly expensive cities now represent a losing deal for teachers and nurses unless they already own their own housing, which is no incentive to stay in the profession.
The stress this generates is worsened by ill-conceived reforms and gratuitous dead weight nuisances like the Novapay debacle. But by all means keep whistling in the dark – it’s going to be a long time before the Gnats see the light at the end of the tunnel.
No, your talking through a hole in your head. I have worked in Health for forty odd years, clinical management for half of them. Its only in the last few years that we have had massive shortages, you should try being confronted with up to 50% shortages for night shift and thats before Nurses ring in sick. Sick because they had worked 16 hr shifts the previous day and the day before. This is all because of a lack of work force planning for the last decade, poor wages in comparrison to other professions and countries.
The majority of Nurses like Teachers are fast approaching retirement age, still no planning to replace them other than poaching a workforce from third world countries who need their own health and Education workers.
Wayne So Simple Soimens smaller class sizes are going to be achieved by sinking lid policies that National do to any publicly funded service govt provides so we end up with as in the education sector a shortage of teachers.
Poor education outcomes 96,000 unemployed under 24 year old when we have massive shortages in construction, IT, nursing teaching agriculture, tourism.
National is a short sighted win power at all cost’s let the invisible hand of the market sort it out.
If you ran a business like that it would fail.
Investing in education was identified as important back in the latter part of the 19 th century when Germany began investing in education for economic and strategic military reasons other countries watching quickly jumped on the band wagon realising that superior economic, technology and industrial power would leave those left behind in a very weak strategic position.
National are guilty of under investing in our most valuable resource.
NZ knows this hence Simple Siomon’s massive U turn on Nationals woeful history on education spending.
Highlighting Nationals failure.
Kids behaved themselves back then or they got beaten wayney. And the stroppy ones were out by age 15. Marking was tick/cross/ x/10 with a rare as hen’s teeth comment in actual words.
Obviously you went to a very different school to me (mine was Reporoa College). I had very decent and highly motivated teachers (mostly). At least in the sixth and seventh forms (20 students and 8 students respectively) the teachers went to huge lengths to lift the aspirations of the students. To be fair, not so much in the fifth form (65 students in two classes).
In the 1960’s there was country service. So we got some extremely good young teachers.
I did get caned on a fair bit, but not in the 6th and 7th form. We were treated as young adults, and we lifted our own standards accordingly.
Both Wayne and Gabby: Caning kids did not actually make teaching them easier. I think the difficulty of teaching them remains constant.
What changes is support and obstacles.
Support has diminished. Teachers are less often backed by parents and the legal system. Govt (through Ministry) has so often prompted teachers to ‘work smarter, not harder’, while ‘doing more with less’. That cracked old record broke apart long ago… And salaries have slipped inexcusably because of penny-pinching Govts of both Right and Left.
Obstacles: Workload was massively increased over the years, with increased paperwork in that 80s period of ‘increased transparency’.. one had not only to do the same work, but write screeds for ERO about how one did it as well. Bollocks. Then came NCEA for secondary teachers – another big shift of workload onto teachers with Internal Assessment (teachers had now to make up their tests and mark them and have them moderated) along with other extra paperwork.. And I gather Primary teachers got much the same thing with National Standards.
All this is symptomatic of Govts wanting to impose austerity instead of social well-being. (Yuk – I hate that phrase.)
Low pay has now become an Obstacle as well. Dedicated teachers who 30 years ago would stay in the profession are now leaving after a few years, after they realise what the job is now actually like.
I began in 1970. I am now semi-retired. NO WAY will I return to full time under current conditions. Your time as part of Govt helped create this, Wayne.
My family has turned it’s back on RNZ as we see it now simply as a right wing media platform.
We have been denied any media coverage of our community transport problems since labour took over and the Government have done nothing to fix this right wing misuse of our public media.
Last week the sharemarket plunged over the course of two intense days, shedding enormous value off major stocks. While the chaos was concentrated in the US market, the impact spread across the world and also hit New Zealand. In what was one of the worst days in the history of the NZ sharemarket, S&P/NZX50, which tracks the top 50 stocks in New Zealand, dropped 3.64 per cent. While the market did recover on Friday, it caused many to question whether the next big crash was on the horizon…..’
He could now be involved with taking a ‘financial hedge’ against the NZ dollar again as he did in 1987 with has high flying buddy Andy Krieger?
Key & his Wall St mate Andy Krieger just may actually repeat what they did when Labour booted National out in 1984!!!!!
Key will leave NZ after pushing up the dollar with their money, and then pulling it out and slumping the dollar and again making yet another $40 million again.
Key and Krieger were written up in global news as one of the most successful raids ever made on a county’s currency.
So don’t have any illusions that this man known as the smiling assassin is nice, he is ruthless.
The timing of his elevation, in the midst of a financial crisis, may be quite prophetic. After all, Key’s rise to prominence in foreign exchange circles came after he struck a rewarding relationship at Bankers Trust with Andy Krieger, a daring New York-based trader who launched a legendary raid against the NZ dollar in 1987.
John Key is living proof that not all heads of derivatives operations for large US investment banks end up in the dog house. Some get to run their own country.
The obvious expectation upon retirement was that the Bilderbergers would offer him a coordinating role at the top level. The only evidence we’re likely to get on that is if he was reported as routinely travelling overseas (to foreign capitals, Geneva, NY). Alternatively, just as likely he told the truth about wanting to relax into family life.
It’s quite often when these predictions come out that they do not happen. Crashes happen when no one is predicting them. When everyone is bullish. Currently there are a lot of people with cash on the sidelines because they think the market has got ahead of itself. When that is the case it is not the right environment for a crash.
Do I think stocks are overvalued? Maybe a bit. Average PE’s are high but that is exacerbated by a few larger companies that dominate these indexes. Time will tell, but every year you have these commentators that cry doom and gloom. One year they will be right.
I will look for the full article in North and South later this week.
Curiously, there was a similar plot line in a Danish drama series that showed in the last year on NZ TV. It was a drama about a family headed by a patriarchal priest. His priest son served with the military, and while accompanying soldiers on a mission, he was encouraged to shoot at an alleged sniper – it was in fact an innocent woman.
Like the NZ medic in Hager’s report he was afterwards so totally tortured by the killing, he left the church and became an independent minster working with street people. But his crime was also covered up by the establishment.
I suspect such incidents are not isolated occurrences.
“there was a similar plot line in a Danish drama series”.
Well Nicky has to get his plot lines from somewhere. You might call it plagiarism but Nicky would just say he was doing a bit of creative interpretation.
Listening to him on Morning Report today leaves me thinking that he only has to change a couple of names and he can sell the story again.
Just change NZDF to NZ Labour Party and SAS to Young Labour and he can publish it again.
How is the coverup of the Labour Party sex scandal going by the way? Have the Police Force started obeying orders from the Boss and quietly dropped all the charges yet?
On Wednesday, we’re holding a rally in Wellington at William Colenso Square on Molesworth Street at 4:30pm. Come along and tell the NZDF that you condemn its war crimes and culture of sexual abuse and homophobia! https://www.facebook.com/events/2245324562207138/ …
Mr Hager, probably needs to understand the difference between a combat medic and your bog standard medic that you would see in Regimental Aid Post/ Casualty Clearing Post at A Echelon or B Echelon. The days of a medic armed with his Red Cross and his medical gear running around a battlefield ended around the latter stages of WW2/ Korean War due to a number of Nations had a habit of shooting Medics on the battlefield.
A Combat Medic is an Infantryman within a section, a Tankie within an Armoured Vehicle Crew, A Gunner within a Gun section, a Field Engineer within a section, Airforce Gound Defence Section (Airforce Infantry) and in Special Forces Ptl or Section etc.
A Combat Medic role is a secondary role within the Fighting unit/ Combat Platoon/ Team. As a result some Combat Medics are more highly trained than others within a Combat Medic role. For example some Combat Medics can perform basic minor surgery on the casualty or trained similar to that of a Para Medic, A&E or ICU Nurse/ Doc and in my case as a basic Combat First Aid dealing dealings trauma wounds, Minor first aid injuries, using drugs/ drips, stabilise the casualty IOT safety move the casualty back to the A Ech or help other Medics at a Cleaning Station or during clinics at local villages etc.
So in my humble opinion, I don’t think it would be Vampire (Military slang for a Medic) running around battlefield kicking doors in and shooting up the place. Or else this person is in the wrong job for starters, as all the medic’s I’ve come across or worked alongside do take their Red Cross obligations quite seriously which than I could say about some Medical NGO’s over the years.
The headline has it that unions are to blame for low wages. So if there’d been no unions in New Zealand workers would be highly paid. Yes Mike Hosking I believe you. Not.
With household inflation forecast to be in the range of 3% (and this was before the massive fuel increases) teachers are being told a 3% increase in wages is a good thing by the govt ?
And notice the language that Chris Hipkins is using by aggregating the 3 year increase of $7k in his interviews.
Teaching friends of mine accept that this govt is currently better then the last, but they are becoming very frustrated in the rhetoric that the govt is using and its lack of action in addressing this crisis. https://www.rbnz.govt.nz/statistics/m13
This was a Road transport association (RTA) orchestrated attack on our Minister of Transport Phil Twyford, as he is taking some money from the “Land Transport ‘consolidated fund” and using it to fund rail repairs and urgently needed upgrades.
Truckles fear they may loose freight around the country to rail.
But the roads are now falling to bits by the large road freight increases in the last 10 yrs!!!!
So road user charges now must increase dramatically;
Or road taxes must increase to make roads safer.
Many people are dying under trucks see here last weekend again a death with accidental truck incident.
Gosman South America is under the CIA’s influence since the US decided to become a super power.
Gossipboy Dogmatic till the end. Your never going to get anyone to listen or change if you carry on with your un yielding unscientific rants.
Despot dictators have been installed where ever possible mainly murderous Fascists.
Who buy military hardware from the US and use it to suppress democracy.
The left end up just as nasty as the right.
If not for the US Colonialist meddling you would have moderate Democracies by now.
The cold War is over communism and Fascism are a complete failure.
So Gosman and DTB both of you are extremists ideologues who think their utopic ideology will work both have failed miserably.
Argentina trialled pure capitalism it lasted 18months it was a disaster.
Cuba and Venezuela tried communism it has failed.
*yawn* still with b.s. about Venezuela ah Gosman. Why don’t you just publish John Oliver’s piece while your at it, it’s full of out right misinformation.
People wanting to run their own country is a crime. What next Gosman, the US has to invade….
– Venezuela is in serious crisis as evidenced by the massive outward migration to other nations
– Many, many companies and businesses have closed; it is difficult to get a formal job; there is a dramatic shortage in food and medicine; wages are low; the prices of products found in commerce are high; there is a hyperinflation that causes prices to rise every day.
– Maduro and the Chavista regime is in large part, to blame for the tragedy. Due to bad decisions and the confrontational attitude of his government. He has also contributed to the legal insecurity in Venezuela, which drives away investments and discourages entrepreneurs.
Gossipboy ranting in your Silo again
ffs try something new for godsake.
Surely someone as intelligent and well educated widely read as your self can come up with something new and better than reheating the same stale mouldy old story.
Gossipboy I’ll bet you anything you like that Bolisarno will be as corrupt as any previous Brazilian leader.
And Brazil will do no better corruption is endemic this will not change in our lifetimes.
Dictatorship’s aren’t corrupt Gossipboy
Your dictating of only one side of the story boringly corrupt.
Repeating the failure of Venezuela ruins any argument you may have had.
Dictatorship’s are Dogmatic like spin lies while murdering the truth just like you gossip boy.
By comparing a country which is controlled by drug Cartels with any form of democracy looses the point of your pathetic arguments.
And Besides Brazils economy is much larger with much more money to corrupt.
Lift your game Gossipboy boring people with your repetitive dreary Dogma barking madly and incessantly.
Not a reply to Bill’s top-of-thread comment, but inspired by it:
The Standard has traditionally been a forum for arguing – vigorously – frequently descending into slanging matches and abuse. Not only the commenters but also some authors and moderators have behaved in this way. This seems OK to me, there is a niche for this kind of site, it gives people a bit of interest in their lives and keeps them coming back.
It does however put off many people particularly women, right-wingers, centrists, people with good manners and normal people in general.
Mods need to decide what the Standard is for.
Is it still for arguing and wrangling? Then fine, just go on as you are. (Probably some commentators will leave in disgust. Some will come back in time.)
Or is it for reasoned, measured, sometimes impassioned but basically polite discussion? Then you need to make some very significant changes. Starting by taking a good hard look at yourselves and your own conduct. (I’m looking at lprent, TRP, Bill among others.) You will probably have to get rid of quite a few ‘old guard’ commenters who cannot be reformed as well.
I think Weka was trying to take the Standard down the latter route. It proved unachievable for her.
“particularly women, right-wingers, centrists, people with good manners and normal people in general“..
I notice you forgot to include Left wingers in your list.
Nearly all my commited left wing friends, a good percentage of whom are male, refuse to comment or even read the Standard because of the abusive tone.
That and the perception that its dominated by Labour Party fan boys and girls who tolerate no questioning of the Party line. Particularly scary when they form packs and start accusing every man, woman and his dog of being a troll, which happens far too often.
Personally I walked through the ring of fire, being called an ‘arsehole’, a ‘nutter’, a ‘gormless idiot’, ‘disappointingly boring and quite predictable’ (ouch!!), among other things, by The Sysop in the course of one memorable week. Which I guess I’m grateful for, as it left me with no illusions about the nature of this site. But on the other hand I really doubt there is any strong appetite and commitment for change.
And, in a way, I understand why many of those who dominate this site are happy with its culture, and don’t want it to change. When people have a little status in a little domain, they are unwilling to give it up.
But it doesn’t represent the wider left – although, as I have said previously, all the big left wing blogs are male dominated, in one way or another.
And there’s no major left site really providing much space for socialist feminists, or even social democratic women, or LGBT+ people, or people of colour/Maori/Pacific people – except in a pretty marginal way.
However, i would have expected a little more self reflection from those who dominate this site, as presumably committed lefties, on the male dominance herrre
To a large extent, it’s up to the commenters what TS is, or becomes. The site has certainly evolved over the years (google Robinsod if you want to get a flavour of the anarchic early days). I see it now as reasonably mature in a blog sense, with a distinct tone and an engaged community.
There has been a good effort from the authors in recent times to guide commenters rather than argue with them or simply ban them. In the few months I’ve been back I’ve binned a few comments, gave some clear direction to a couple of folk and banned nobody. Last month only 5 people got banned, all for short periods.
I think the authors are much more aware these days of the power imbalance, too. I’ve even walked away from a couple of discussions where my status appeared to be affecting other commenter’s ability to say what they wanted to.
None of us writers are paid, though we all try to write in a professional way. Just for the record, even a simple ‘notices and features’ post takes 10-15 minutes to put together. The more involved opinion pieces can take an hour or more. Then add in the time taken to monitor comments and you’ve got a significant commitment to the site.
It’s a job, really. No monetary reward, however some occasional, fleeting satisfaction at a turn of phrase, a heartfelt comment or an issue elevated into the public consciousness.
1) There’s been a lot of handwringing in the media pundit corps and centrist politicians these days about the loss of comity, post-Kavanaugh. And then Donald Trump made them all look absurd with his remarks at his rally last night. Thread follows.
Thread is about how the RWNJs in the US are promoting civil war.
It’s not “800 pages culled”. It’s another 800 pages on top of previous take downs and shut downs that are being done largely at the behest of four designated organisations acting as approved censors for facebook.
That aside. The unnecessary personal dig included your comment? Leave it out, aye?
How many pages have been reinstated from those previous take-downs?
And the personal dig also pointed out that FB is not essential to “the left”. Adam was commenting here, and AFAIK this is the only place I see their comments. Even if zucks were trying to turn FB into FoxNews Social Media, it’s not the only platform in town.
I don’t know how many have since been re-instated. I also don’t know what knock-on effect the loss of a fb page has for a news or info source, though given the large percentage of people who apparently get their news from fb, it’s unlikely to be having a minimal impact.
There’s quite a bit of dodgy stuff going on with regards the web and censorship that affects a huge chunk of the web (ie – google, fb and youtube).
Thoughtful and thought provoking articles, info and analysis are there to be had if information and controlling access to it interests you.
There is also a lot of dodgy stuff going on with regards to lack of censorship on the web, too. Bullying, bots, phishing, etc.
It’s sort of a microcosm of society – if there’s no sherriff, society usually becomes parasitic and toxic. If there’s too much sherriff, it becomes a police state.
I like how you shift the point to avoid the point. The problem is the broad sweep censorship, with a big chuck of what is being hit is left wing voices. Not parasites and generally not toxic, but you only want to listen to your take on the left – so I get why your clapping and cheering on this sort of stuff.
A big chuck of right wing voices are hit, too. The question is how many of these left and right “voices” deserve to be taken down because they are outright dangerous. And the question of any screening system is how false negatives and false positives are caught and re-evaluated, hence my question of how many are reinstated after appeal.
Because “generally” non-toxic means that even you would admit that some toxic content occurs even from the left, no?
You and I do toxic ever once in a while, so yes it exists on the left. But the point of the post was the blanket approach used by the monolith that is facebook – has a tendency to target social activists and left leaning people rather than toxic and vial idiots you are talking about. Yes it got a few of those, but people like
are not in that group. If anything, the outright dangerous like Alex Jones, have profited by the facebook doing this sort of thing. And grown in support – so blocking them is not working either.
That’s an odd site, and hardly left wing. Looking at some of its stories I’d want to see what they were sharing via FB before making a call on their case.
Bullying, bots, phishing, etc. would strike me as coming down to moderation (not censorship), bullshit chasing money or rating (as far as I understand bots) and security against….well, I was gong to say malware, but nothing really protects a person from their own stupidity.
Censorship of information by arguably monopolistic platforms is something else entirely, but hey…
The point is that censorship itself isn’t a bad thing. Sometimes it’s necessary, whichever the platform. The existence isn’t the problem, the balance is the issue. I think bringing the reins in a bit is necessary. As long as the good outweighs the bad of overreach in individual cases, it’s a positive.
Here’s a case in point about censorship that you may or may not want to consider.
That post on Zionism I did a week or so back involved sourcing info on Kastner. Google ‘curates’ searches to such a degree that I simply couldn’t break through from one side of the story and finally dumped google in favour of duckduckgo.
I was free to express myself, but I had some problems informing myself because of the censorious effect of algorithms – put in place by a company that’s signed up to a deal with the Chinese government promising to ensure no searches in China will go to any info the government would rather remained unseen.
Another case would be facebook responding to something like 80% or 90% of Israeli takedown requests when the people in Gaza use facebook for almost all of their news access.
And then there’s the ‘deplatforming’ and ‘demonetising’ malarky that’s going on with youtube…
So yeah, maybe anyone’s free to express whatever (assuming the platform they use remains open to them) , but the library shelves are going to have all these huge gaps and/or the books containing the info we really need are going to be in storage (and so require a presence of prior knowledge to be specifically requested ) rather than happened upon by browsing.
The point is that many people use duckduckgo because google doesn’t serve their needs.
I bet you lots of people in Gaza are now beginning to use something other than FB, too.
Which is what we never really got with libraries – if one library wasn’t making some subject areas accessible, say didn’t have a large section on medieval armour, there were a lot more barriers. You couldn’t just type in a new address and thereby visit a completely different library. And if somoene blocks that library, you figure out a way to another address.
Facebook, meanwhile, had empowered the right-wing outlet the Weekly Standard to “fact check” articles. The Weekly Standard, invested in Kavanaugh’s confirmation, deemed the Think Progress article “false.” The story was effectively nuked from Facebook, with other outlets threatened with traffic and monetary consequences if they shared it. The story is republished below, with permission from Think Progress, though not from Facebook or the Weekly Standard.
Fetlife would be more interesting. NSFW if you google it.
Amazing the, er, “niche” platforms out there if you just want to connect with likeminded folks. And when all else fails, opensource content managers can be knocked up into social media pretty quickly.
Thanks for your backgrounding of that McFlock. I should use duckduckgo and just haven’t got it into my daily practice. And
thanks for your argument path that seeks to be objective and winds its way between alternatives.
cheers. Yeah I set ddg as my default search engine a while ago 🙂
Private browsing windows are also good for minimising cookies and tracking, not just for tinfoil hat reasons but also to stop ads crossing over now that google is doing cross-platform matching more often. I don’t need my home searches turning up at work, people will think I’m goofing off more than usual lol
This fellow was hopeless, but I’ve heard worse today.
Just heard a disastrously inept performance from High Performance Sport New Zealand’s CEO Michael Scott. He was being interviewed on RNZ National, and he came across as panicked and inarticulate.
Still better than that shower in the National Party “leadership”, however.
Here’s a bit of an update from the Wentworth Races (Not the NSW Town btw). Since my last post a couple of days ago, the mud throwing has started with Liberal candidate saying a vote the Phelps is a vote for a hung parliament etc etc. Yesterday and today old Phelps has said again the she will vote for the Coalition on matters for supply and on confidence if elected and all this talk is from the Lib candidate is BS. Anyway I find old Shifty Bill won’t be doing many walk abouts this week (or does this include his front bench as well), which has me thinking have Labour given up and now realise it’s now a 2 horse race between Phelps and old mate Sharma? As ScoMo and his front bench have hit streets running about the place like a headless chickens or one arm plumber from Baghdad trying fix million to one leaks.
So someone is shit scared atm.
I leave you with comment from a Lib Coalition pollie flying back into Canberra on Sunday when asked about this Saturday’s by-election “Well we are going to be in the Penthouse or the Shit House after next Saturday”. Yes mate from what the polls are saying atm, I’ll say the Shit House atm.
So Aussie. Penthouse or shithouse. Well-chosen words. It must be like the old Roman days, watching the fights at the Colosseum, and they had them in the Senate too.
Kia ora The Am Show congratulations to the couple expecting their new baby .
I get what our All Blacks Coach up to Stue Wilson ?????????.Its cool that Stue talks about his alcohol experiences on the show lets the youth no some of the side effects of the stuff.
I had that problem a company payed with a credit card they were taking money when there service was cancelled send them a email they will most times refund your money.
I wondered whats world he is IN.
Amanda that black bear cub with the bucket stuck on his head they tracked it for 3 days and tranquilised it to get the bucket off its ka pai to see people care for animals .
I agree with Jacinda our political seen needs to change a bit what stop the mud sling and get on with running the country it’s not a good look for the mokos and is not good for te wairua.
The Air New Zealand flying taxis to commute people to the Auckland city is a great goal to have Ka pai.
Wars like this War in YEMEN need to stop all the wars around the Papatuanuku need to stop .I don’t know the reason they give for this war but I do know that its the rich who start wars for power and money . I do know that its the common poor man who fights these stupid wars the common mothers and fathers lose their offspring to wars .P.S I do know that rich men do not fight in these wars
I do know that its the common tangata /people who are dieing because of the rich MANS WAR we need to fight climate change and not each other this is so backwards to the Dark ages I say humans have never left that era .
Ka kite ano
International trasport of the future here are some new designs link below Ka kite ano
I laws were made to encourage this leap forward in air planes that would speed up the development of low carbon passenger planes link below ka kite ano
Electric Container Ships another blow to the Human Caused Climate Change deniers
EGO P.S I seen some trolls quoting that air travel and container ships could not be carbon free.
Kia ora Newshub I don’t like kicking a person when they are down bridges & ross .
It give me a sore face when some people start writing about New Zealand and Australia becoming a republic when the Royal Family is so popular there dreaming.
That’s a od phenomenon compressed air is safer and better for some patients I say big company interference in reality once again .
I see that company teaming up with Air New Zealand in designing and testing auto flying vehicles my guess is that Aotearoa’s air traffic laws are not as stringent as other country’s but Its cool we will be pioneers in this industry.
Paul Allan one of the Microsoft founders condolences to his whano.
I say with the organ donation problem could be solved with a opted out clause if you don’t want to donate you have to say know problem solved business people use this very effectively Ka kite ano
The Cowd Goes Wild Mulls & Storm Ka pai to the young Aotearoa Ferns win in Gold.
congratulations to all the Kiwis at the youth game’s .
Josh Rugby mana all around Papatuanuku that’s cool.
Wairangi sore face E hoa don’t count Mals men out to soon they are world champions .
Ka kite ano P.S Eco know what that is like Bolt
This video includes personal musings and conclusions of the creator climate scientist Dr. Adam Levy. It is presented to our readers as an informed perspective. Please see video description for references (if any). 2025 has only just begun, but already climate scientists are working hard to unpick what could be in ...
The maxim is as true as it ever was: give a small boy and a pig everything they want, and you will get a good pig and a terrible boy.Elon Musk the child was given everything he could ever want. He has more than any one person or for that ...
A food rescue organisation has had to resort to an emergency plea for donations via givealittle because of uncertainty about whether Government funding will continue after the end of June. Photo: Getty ImagesLong stories short in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, poverty and climate on Wednesday, January 22: Kairos Food ...
Leo Molloy's recent "shoplifting" smear against former MP Golriz Ghahraman has finally drawn public attention to Auror and its database. And from what's been disclosed so far, it does not look good: The massive privately-owned retail surveillance network which recorded the shopping incident involving former MP Golriz Ghahraman is ...
The defence of common law qualified privilege applies (to cut short a lot of legal jargon) when someone tells someone something in good faith, believing they need to know it. Think: telling the police that the neighbour is running methlab or dobbing in a colleague to the boss for stealing. ...
NZME plans to cut 38 jobs as it reorganises its news operations, including the NZ Herald, BusinessDesk, and Newstalk ZB. It said it planned to publish and produce fewer stories, to focus on those that engage audience. E tū are calling on the Government to step in and support the ...
Data released by Statistics New Zealand today showed that inflation remains unchanged at 2.2%, defying expectations of further declines, said NZCTU Te Kauae Kaimahi Economist Craig Renney. “While inflation holding steady might sound like good news, the reality is that prices for the basics—like rent, energy, and insurance—are still rising. ...
I never mentioned anythingAbout the songs that I would singOver the summer, when we'd go on tourAnd sleep on floors and drink the bad beerI think I left it unclearSong: Bad Beer.Songwriter: Jacob Starnes Ewald.Last night, I was watching a movie with Fi and the kids when I glanced ...
Last night I spoke about the second inauguration of Donald Trump with in a ‘pop-up’ Hoon live video chat on the Substack app on phones.Here’s the summary of the lightly edited video above:Trump's actions signify a shift away from international law.The imposition of tariffs could lead to increased inflation ...
An interesting article in Stuff a few weeks ago asked a couple of interesting questions in it’s headline, “How big can Auckland get? And how big is too big?“. Unfortunately, the article doesn’t really answer those questions, instead focusing on current growth projections, but there were a few aspects to ...
Today is Donald J Trump’s second inauguration ceremony.I try not to follow too much US news, and yet these developments are noteworthy and somehow relevant to us here.Only hours in, parts of their Project 2025 ‘think/junk tank’ policies — long planned and signalled — are already live:And Elon Musk, who ...
How long is it going to take for the MAGA faithful to realise that those titans of Big Tech and venture capital sitting up close to Donald Trump this week are not their allies, but The Enemy? After all, the MAGA crowd are the angry victims left behind by the ...
California Burning: The veteran firefighters of California and Los Angeles called it “a perfect storm”. The hillsides and canyons were full of “fuel”. The LA Fire Department was underfunded, below-strength, and inadequately-equipped. A key reservoir was empty, leaving fire-hydrants without the water pressure needed for fire hoses. The power companies had ...
The Waitangi Tribunal has been one of the most effective critics of the government, pointing out repeatedly that its racist, colonialist policies breach te Tiriti o Waitangi. While it has no powers beyond those of recommendation, its truth-telling has clearly gotten under the government's skin. They had already begun to ...
I don't mind where you come fromAs long as you come to meBut I don't like illusionsI can't see them clearlyI don't care, no I wouldn't dareTo fix the twist in youYou've shown me eventually what you'll doSong: Shimon Moore, Emma Anzai, Antonina Armato, and Tim James.National Hugging Day.Today, January ...
Is Rwanda turning into a country that seeks regional dominance and exterminates its rivals? This is a contention examined by Dr Michela Wrong, and Dr Maria Armoudian. Dr Wrong is a journalist who has written best-selling books on Africa. Her latest, Do Not Disturb. The story of a political murder ...
The economy isn’t cooperating with the Government’s bet that lower interest rates will solve everything, with most metrics indicating per-capita GDP is still contracting faster and further than at any time since the 1990-96 series of government spending and welfare cuts. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāLong stories short in ...
Hi,Today is the day sexual assaulter and alleged rapist Donald Trump officially became president (again).I was in a meeting for three hours this morning, so I am going to summarise what happened by sharing my friend’s text messages:So there you go.Welcome to American hell — which includes all of America’s ...
This is a re-post from the Climate BrinkI have a new paper out today in the journal Dialogues on Climate Change exploring both the range of end-of-century climate outcomes in the literature under current policies and the broader move away from high-end emissions scenarios. Current policies are defined broadly as policies in ...
Long story short: I chatted last night with ’s on the substack app about the appointment of Chris Bishop to replace Simeon Brown as Transport Minister. We talked through their different approaches and whether there’s much room for Bishop to reverse many of the anti-cycling measures Brown adopted.Our chat ...
Last night I chatted with Northland emergency doctor on the substack app for subscribers about whether the appointment of Simeon Brown to replace Shane Reti as Health Minister. We discussed whether the new minister can turn around decades of under-funding in real and per-capita terms. Our chat followed his ...
Christopher Luxon is every dismal boss who ever made you wince, or roll your eyes, or think to yourself I have absolutely got to get the hell out of this place.Get a load of what he shared with us at his cabinet reshuffle, trying to be all sensitive and gracious.Dr ...
The text of my submission to the Ministry of Health's unnecessary and politicised review of the use of puberty blockers for young trans and nonbinary people in Aotearoa. ...
Hi,Last night one of the world’s biggest social media platforms, TikTok, became inaccessible in the United States.Then, today, it came back online.Why should we care about a social network that deals in dance trends and cute babies? Well — TikTok represents a lot more than that.And its ban and subsequent ...
Sometimes I wake in the middle of the nightAnd rub my achin' old eyesIs that a voice from inside-a my headOr does it come down from the skies?"There's a time to laugh butThere's a time to weepAnd a time to make a big change"Wake-up you-bum-the-time has-comeTo arrange and re-arrange and ...
Former Health Minister Shane Reti was the main target of Luxon’s reshuffle. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāLong stories short to start the year in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, poverty and climate: Christopher Luxon fired Shane Reti as Health Minister and replaced him with Simeon Brown, who Luxon sees ...
Yesterday, Prime Minister Christopher Luxon announced a cabinet reshuffle, which saw Simeon Brown picking up the Health portfolio as it’s been taken off Dr Shane Reti, and Transport has been given to Chris Bishop. Additionally, Simeon’s energy and local government portfolios now sit with Simon Watts. This is very good ...
The sacking of Health Minister Shane Reti yesterday had an air of panic about it. A media advisory inviting journalists to a Sunday afternoon press conference at Premier House went out on Saturday night. Caucus members did not learn that even that was happening until yesterday morning. Reti’s fate was ...
Yesterday’s demotion of Shane Reti was inevitable. Reti’s attempt at a re-assuring bedside manner always did have a limited shelf life, and he would have been a poor and apologetic salesman on the campaign trail next year. As a trained doctor, he had every reason to be looking embarrassed about ...
A listing of 25 news and opinion articles we found interesting and shared on social media during the past week: Sun, January 12, 2025 thru Sat, January 18, 2025. This week's roundup is again published soleley by category. We are still interested in feedback to hone the categorization, so if ...
After another substantial hiatus from online Chess, I’ve been taking it up again. I am genuinely terrible at five-minute Blitz, what with the tight time constraints, though I periodically con myself into thinking that I have been improving. But seeing as my past foray into Chess led to me having ...
Rise up o children wont you dance with meRise up little children come and set me freeRise little ones riseNo shame no fearDon't you know who I amSongwriter: Rebecca Laurel FountainI’m sure you know the go with this format. Some memories, some questions, letsss go…2015A decade ago, I made the ...
In 2017, when Ghahraman was elected to Parliament as a Green MP, she recounted both the highlights and challenges of her role -There was love, support, and encouragement.And on the flipside, there was intense, visceral and unchecked hate.That came with violent threats - many of them. More on that later.People ...
It gives me the biggest kick to learn that something I’ve enthused about has been enough to make you say Go on then, I'm going to do it. The e-bikes, the hearing aids, the prostate health, the cheese puffs. And now the solar power. Yes! Happy to share the details.We ...
Skeptical Science is partnering with Gigafact to produce fact briefs — bite-sized fact checks of trending claims. This fact brief was written by Sue Bin Park from the Gigafact team in collaboration with members from our team. You can submit claims you think need checking via the tipline. Can CO2 be ...
The old bastard left his ties and his suitA brown box, mothballs and bowling shoesAnd his opinion so you'd never have to choosePretty soon, you'll be an old bastard tooYou get smaller as the world gets bigThe more you know you know you don't know shit"The whiz man" will never ...
..Thanks for reading Frankly Speaking ! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.The Numbers2024 could easily have been National’s “Annus Horribilis” and 2025 shows no signs of a reprieve for our Landlord PM Chris Luxon and his inept Finance Minister Nikki “Noboats” Willis.Several polls last year ...
This Friday afternoon, Māori Development Minister Tama Potaka announced an overhaul of the Waitangi Tribunal.The government has effectively cleared house - appointing 8 new members - and combined with October’s appointment of former ACT leader Richard Prebble, that’s 9 appointees.[I am not certain, but can only presume, Prebble went in ...
The state of the current economy may be similar to when National left office in 2017.In December, a couple of days after the Treasury released its 2024 Half Year Economic and Fiscal Update (HEYFU24), Statistics New Zealand reported its estimate for volume GDP for the previous September 24 quarter. Instead ...
So what becomes of you, my love?When they have finally stripped you ofThe handbags and the gladragsThat your poor old granddadHad to sweat to buy you, babySongwriter: Mike D'aboIn yesterday’s newsletter, I expressed sadness at seeing Golriz Ghahraman back on the front pages for shoplifting. As someone who is no ...
It’s Friday and time for another roundup of things that caught our attention this week. This post, like all our work, is brought to you by a largely volunteer crew and made possible by generous donations from our readers and fans. If you’d like to support our work, you can join ...
Note: This Webworm discusses sexual assault and rape. Please read with care.Hi,A few weeks ago I reported on how one of New Zealand’s richest men, Nick Mowbray (he and his brother own Zuru and are worth an estimated $20 billion), had taken to sharing posts by a British man called ...
The final Atlas Network playbook puzzle piece is here, and it slipped in to Aotearoa New Zealand with little fan fare or attention. The implications are stark.Today, writes Dr Bex, the submission for the Crimes (Countering Foreign Interference) Amendment Bill closes: 11:59pm January 16, 2025.As usual, the language of the ...
Excitement in the seaside village! Look what might be coming! 400 million dollars worth of investment! In the very beating heart of the village! Are we excited and eager to see this happen, what with every last bank branch gone and shops sitting forlornly quiet awaiting a customer?Yes please, apply ...
Much discussion has been held over the Regulatory Standards Bill (RSB), the latest in a series of rightwing attempts to enshrine into law pro-market precepts such as the primacy of private property ownership. Underneath the good governance and economic efficiency gobbledegook language of the Bill is an interest to strip ...
We are concerned that the Amendment Bill, as proposed, could impair the operations and legitimate interests of the NZ Trade Union movement. It is also likely to negatively impact the ability of other civil society actors to conduct their affairs without the threat of criminal sanctions. We ask that ...
I can't take itHow could I fake it?How could I fake it?And I can't take itHow could I fake it?How could I fake it?Song: The Lonely Biscuits.“A bit nippy”, I thought when I woke this morning, and then, soon after that, I wondered whether hell had frozen over. Dear friends, ...
This is a re-post from Yale Climate Connections Asheville, North Carolina, was once widely considered a climate haven thanks to its elevated, inland location and cooler temperatures than much of the Southeast. Then came the catastrophic floods of Hurricane Helene in September 2024. It was a stark reminder that nowhere is safe from ...
Early reports indicate that the temporary Israel/Hamas ceasefire deal (due to take effect on Sunday) will allow for the gradual release of groups of Israeli hostages, the release of an unspecified number of Palestinian prisoners from Israeli jails (likely only a fraction of the total incarcerated population), and the withdrawal ...
My daily news diet is not what it once was.It was the TV news that lost me first. Too infantilising, too breathless, too frustrating.The Herald was next. You could look past the reactionary framing while it was being a decent newspaper of record, but once Shayne Currie began unleashing all ...
Hit the road Jack and don't you come backNo more, no more, no more, no moreHit the road Jack and don't you come back no moreWhat you say?Songwriters: Percy MayfieldMorena,I keep many of my posts, like this one, paywall-free so that everyone can read them.However, please consider supporting me as ...
This might be the longest delay between reading (or in this case re-reading) a work, and actually writing a review of it I have ever managed. Indeed, when I last read these books in December 2022, I was not planning on writing anything about them… but as A Phuulish Fellow ...
Kia Ora,I try to keep most my posts without a paywall for public interest journalism purposes. However, if you can afford to, please consider supporting me as a paid subscriber and/or supporting over at Ko-Fi. That will help me to continue, and to keep spending time on the work. Embarrassingly, ...
There was a time when Google was the best thing in my world. I was an early adopter of their AdWords program and boy did I like what it did for my business. It put rocket fuel in it, is what it did. For every dollar I spent, those ads ...
A while back I was engaged in an unpleasant exchange with a leader of the most well-known NZ anti-vax group and several like-minded trolls. I had responded to a racist meme on social media in which a rightwing podcaster in the US interviewed one of the leaders of the Proud ...
Hi,If you’ve been reading Webworm for a while, you’ll be familiar with Anna Wilding. Between 2020 and 2021 I looked at how the New Zealander had managed to weasel her way into countless news stories over the years, often with very little proof any of it had actually happened. When ...
It's a long white cloud for you, baby; staying together alwaysSummertime in AotearoaWhere the sunshine kisses the water, we will find it alwaysSummertime in AotearoaYeah, it′s SummertimeIt's SummertimeWriters: Codi Wehi Ngatai, Moresby Kainuku, Pipiwharauroa Campbell, Taulutoa Michael Schuster, Rebekah Jane Brady, Te Naawe Jordan Muturangi Tupe, Thomas Edward Scrase.Many of ...
Last year, 292 people died unnecessarily on our roads. That is the lowest result in over a decade and only the fourth time in the last 70 years we’ve seen fewer than 300 deaths in a calendar year. Yet, while it is 292 people too many, with each death being ...
This is a re-post from Yale Climate Connections by Jeff Masters and Bob HensonFlames from the Palisades Fire burn a building at Sunset Boulevard amid a powerful windstorm on January 8, 2025 in the Pacific Palisades neighborhood of Los Angeles, California. The fast-moving wildfire had destroyed thousands of structures and ...
..Thanks for reading Frankly Speaking ! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.The Regulatory Standards Bill, as I understand it, seeks to bind parliament to a specific range of law-making.For example, it seems to ensure primacy of individual rights over that of community, environment, te Tiriti ...
Happy New Year!I had a lovely break, thanks very much for asking: friends, family, sunshine, books, podcasts, refreshing swims, barbecues, bike rides. So good to step away from the firehose for a while, to have less Trump and Seymour in your day. Who needs the Luxons in their risible PJs ...
Patrick Reynolds is deputy chair of the Auckland City Centre Advisory Panel and a director of Greater Auckland In 2003, after much argument, including the election of a Mayor in 2001 who ran on stopping it, Britomart train station in downtown Auckland opened. A mere 1km twin track terminating branch ...
For the first time in a decade, a New Zealand Prime Minister is heading to the Middle East. The trip is more than just a courtesy call. New Zealand PMs frequently change planes in Dubai en route to destinations elsewhere. But Christopher Luxon’s visit to the United Arab Emirates (UAE) ...
A listing of 23 news and opinion articles we found interesting and shared on social media during the past week: Sun, January 5, 2025 thru Sat, January 11, 2025. This week's roundup is again published soleley by category. We are still interested in feedback to hone the categorization, so if ...
The decade between 1952 and the early 1960s was the peak period for the style of music we now call doo wop, after which it got dissolved into soul music, girl groups, and within pop music in general. Basically, doo wop was a form of small group harmonising with a ...
The future teaches you to be aloneThe present to be afraid and coldSo if I can shoot rabbits, then I can shoot fascists…And if you tolerate thisThen your children will be nextSongwriters: James Dean Bradfield / Sean Anthony Moore / Nicholas Allen Jones.Do you remember at school, studying the rise ...
When National won the New Zealand election in 2023, one of the first to congratulate Luxon was tech-billionaire and entrepreneur extraordinaire Elon Musk.And last year, after Luxon posted a video about a trip to Malaysia, Musk came forward again to heap praise on Christopher:So it was perhaps par for the ...
Hi,Today’s Webworm features a new short film from documentary maker Giorgio Angelini. It’s about Luigi Mangione — but it’s also, really, about everything in America right now.Bear with me.Shortly after I sent out my last missive from the fires on Wednesday, one broke out a little too close to home ...
So soon just after you've goneMy senses sharpenBut it always takes so damn longBefore I feel how much my eyes have darkenedFear hangs in a plane of gun smokeDrifting in our roomSo easy to disturb, with a thought, with a whisperWith a careless memorySongwriters: Andy Taylor / John Taylor / ...
Can we trust the Trump cabinet to act in the public interest?Nine of Trump’s closest advisers are billionaires. Their total net worth is in excess of $US375b (providing there is not a share-market crash). In contrast, the total net worth of Trump’s first Cabinet was about $6b. (Joe Biden’s Cabinet ...
Welcome back to our weekly roundup. We hope you had a good break (if you had one). Here’s a few of the stories that caught our attention over the last few weeks. This holiday period on Greater Auckland Since our last roundup we’ve: Taken a look back at ...
Sometimes I feel like I don't have a partnerSometimes I feel like my only friendIs the city I live in, The City of AngelsLonely as I am together we crySong: Anthony Kiedis, Chad Smith, Flea, John Frusciante.A home is engulfed in flames during the Eaton fire in the Altadena area. ...
The Green Party is calling on the Government to stand firm and work with allies to progress climate action as Donald Trump signals his intent to pull out of the Paris Climate Accords once again. ...
The Green Party has welcomed the provisional ceasefire deal between Israel and Hamas, and reiterated its call for New Zealand to push for an end to the unlawful occupation of Palestine. ...
The Green Party welcomes the extension of the deadline for Treaty Principles Bill submissions but continues to call on the Government to abandon the Bill. ...
Complaints about disruptive behaviour now handled in around 13 days (down from around 60 days a year ago) 553 Section 55A notices issued by Kāinga Ora since July 2024, up from 41 issued during the same period in the previous year. Of that 553, first notices made up around 83 ...
The time it takes to process building determinations has improved significantly over the last year which means fewer delays in homes being built, Building and Construction Minister Chris Penk says. “New Zealand has a persistent shortage of houses. Making it easier and quicker for new homes to be built will ...
Minister of Internal Affairs Brooke van Velden is pleased to announce the annual list of New Zealand’s most popular baby names for 2024. “For the second consecutive year, Noah has claimed the top spot for boys with 250 babies sharing the name, while Isla has returned to the most popular ...
Work is set to get underway on a new bus station at Westgate this week. A contract has been awarded to HEB Construction to start a package of enabling works to get the site ready in advance of main construction beginning in mid-2025, Transport Minister Simeon Brown says.“A new Westgate ...
Minister for Children and for Prevention of Family and Sexual Violence Karen Chhour is encouraging people to use the resources available to them to get help, and to report instances of family and sexual violence amongst their friends, families, and loved ones who are in need. “The death of a ...
Uia te pō, rangahaua te pō, whakamāramatia mai he aha tō tango, he aha tō kāwhaki? Whitirere ki te ao, tirotiro kau au, kei hea taku rātā whakamarumaru i te au o te pakanga mo te mana motuhake? Au te pō, ngū te pō, ue hā! E te kahurangi māreikura, ...
Health Minister Dr Shane Reti says people with diabetes and other painful conditions will benefit from a significant new qualification to boost training in foot care. “It sounds simple, but quality and regular foot and nail care is vital in preventing potentially serious complications from diabetes, like blisters or sores, which can take a long time to heal ...
COMMENTARY:By Saige England Celebration time. Some Palestinian prisoners have been released. A mother reunited with her daughter. A young mother reunited with her babies. Still in prison are people who never received a fair trial, people that independent inquirers say are wrongly imprisoned. Still in prison kids who cursed ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Luis Gómez Romero, Senior Lecturer in Human Rights, Constitutional Law and Legal Theory, University of Wollongong On his first day in office, Donald Trump launched his second term with a barrage of executive orders. Unsurprisingly, many could have a major impact on ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Nial Wheate, Professor of Pharmaceutical Chemistry, Macquarie University Nial Wheate Australia’s Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA) recently issued a safety alert requiring extra warnings to be included with the asthma and hay fever drug montelukast. The warnings are for users and their ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Carolina Quintero Rodriguez, Senior Lecturer and Program Manager, Bachelor of Fashion (Enterprise) program, RMIT University When a tennis player serves at 200km/h in 30°C heat, their clothing isn’t just fabric. It becomes a key part of their performance. Modern tennis wear ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Jayashri Kulkarni, Professor of Psychiatry, Monash University Last week, Australian Open player Destanee Aiava revealed she had struggled with borderline personality disorder. The tennis player said a formal diagnosis, after suicidal behaviour and severe panic attacks, “was a relief”. But “it ...
Research methods in this project included healing Kauri trees through using "sonic samples of healthy whales to construct a tapestry of rejuvenation and wellbeing.” ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Amy Hume, Lecturer In Theatre (Voice), Victorian College of the Arts, The University of Melbourne A24 The Brutalist has drawn attention this week for its use of artificial intelligence (AI) to refine some of the actors’ dialogue. Emilia Pérez, a ...
Welcome to The Spinoff Books Confessional, in which we get to know the reading habits of Aotearoa’s writers, and other guests. This week: Jenny Pattrick, playwright of Hope, which runs at Circa Theatre from January 25 – February 23.The book I wish I’d writtenHow to choose? Let’s say ...
SPECIAL REPORT:By Lagipoiva Cherelle Jackson and Lilomaiava Maina Vai The Speaker of the House, Papali’i Li’o Taeu Masipau, decisively addressed a letter from FAST, which informed him of the removal of Fiame along with Deputy Prime Minister Tuala Tevaga Ponifasio, Leatinu’u Wayne Fong, Olo Fiti Vaai, Faualo Harry Schuster, ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Anna Marie Brennan, Senior Lecturer in Law, University of Waikato Shutterstock/KV4000 Every day, about 48.5 tonnes of space rock hurtle towards Earth. Meteorites that fall into the ocean are never recovered. But the ones that crash on land can spark debates ...
New year, same friendly local politics podcast. The political year kicked off with a dramatic reshuffle that sees Shane Reti removed from health in favour of Simeon Brown, James Meager made minister for the fiefdom that is the South Island and Nicola Willis in the renamed role of minister for ...
Alex Casey and Tara Ward assemble a list of demands for James Meager, the first minister for the South Island. South islanders, rejoice, for there is now one man dedicated to ensuring that each and every 1,260,000 of us has our voices heard in parliament. This week Rangitata MP James ...
COMMENTARY:By Steven Cowan, editor of Against The Current New Zealand’s One News interviewed a Gaza journalist last week who has called out the Western media for its complicity in genocide. For some 15 months, the Western media have framed Israel’s genocidal rampage in Gaza as a “legitimate” war. Pretending ...
Prime Minister Christopher Luxon says the government has been taking the problem of economic growth seriously, and its work on that so far has been "significant". ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Marta Yebra, Professor of Environmental Engineering, Australian National University Picture this. It’s a summer evening in Australia. A dry lightning storm is about to sweep across remote, tinder-dry bushland. The next day is forecast to be hot and windy. A lightning strike ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Joanne Orlando, Researcher, Digital Literacy and Digital Wellbeing, Western Sydney University Wachiwit/Shutterstock Roblox isn’t just another video game – it’s a massive virtual universe where nearly 90 million people from around the world create, play and socialise. This includes some 34 ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Nicole Lee, Adjunct Professor at the National Drug Research Institute (Melbourne based), Curtin University Dragana Gordic/Shutterstock Anecdotal reports from some professionals have prompted concerns about young people using prescription benzodiazepines such as Xanax for recreational use. Border force detections of ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Judy Lundy, Lecturer in Management, Edith Cowan University Vitalii Vodolazskyi/Shutterstock It’s been a significant day for diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) programs in the United States. Such initiatives are about providing equality of opportunity and a sense of being valued ...
Filmmaker Ahmed Osman reflects on the many challenges the screen industry is facing this year – and what needs to change. I grew up in front of the TV. For me, it was more than just background noise: it was connection. Shows like bro’Town, Street Legal, and Outrageous Fortune weren’t ...
The government last year created a new Ministry for Regulation, with ACT leader David Seymour in charge, to review regulations and, in Seymour’s words, “to look for red tape to cut.” ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Kimberley Connor, Postdoctoral Scholar at Stanford Archaeology Center, Stanford University Sydney’s Hyde Park Barracks photographed in 1871, when the building served as a women’s immigration depot and asylum.City of Sydney Archives. Sydney’s Hyde Park Barracks was built between 1817 and ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Robert McLachlan, Professor in Applied Mathematics, Te Kunenga ki Pūrehuroa – Massey University NASA/Earth Observatory, CC BY-SA It’s now official. Last year was the warmest year on record globally and the first to exceed 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels. This doesn’t mean ...
Analysis - The political year is kicking off with a flurry of gatherings and speeches after the Prime Minister used Wellington Anniversary weekend to get his team in order. ...
There’s been a major shake-up at the Waitangi Tribunal, with more than half of the current members, including some esteemed Māori academics, losing their places to make way for some controversial new appointments.Established in 1975, the Waitangi Tribunal investigates alleged Crown breaches of the promises made to Māori in ...
PFAS chemicals are omnipresent, enduring, and almost certainly in your bloodstream. Here’s a guide to where they come from, why there are concerns about their use and what regulations are in place to help you avoid exposure. Your raincoat, beading with water. The slippery smooth surface of your non-stick pans. ...
Comment: If you’ve ever wondered how Omni Consumer Products became the government in the 1987 Paul Verhoeven film, Robocop, you’re about to find out. As Donald J. Trump, a convicted felon and a man who tried to violently seize power through a failed coup in 2020, begins his second term ...
Opinion: Austria is poised to become the next European country to fall to the far right. There is only one option for mainstream parties to break this cycle. The post Europe’s far-right dominoes knock down democracy appeared first on Newsroom. ...
Prime Minister Christoper Luxon has turned Finance Minister Nicola Willis into a ‘super minister’ by adding the rebranded economic portfolio to her plate and bolstering her ability to implement change.Luxon announced his decision to appoint Nicola Willis to the role of Minister for Economic Growth as part of a wider ...
Loading…(function(i,s,o,g,r,a,m){var ql=document.querySelectorAll('A[data-quiz],DIV[data-quiz]'); if(ql){if(ql.length){for(var k=0;k<ql.length;k++){ql[k].id='quiz-embed-'+k;ql[k].href="javascript:var i=document.getElementById('quiz-embed-"+k+"');try{qz.startQuiz(i)}catch(e){i.start=1;i.style.cursor='wait';i.style.opacity='0.5'};void(0);"}}};i['QP']=r;i[r]=i[r]||function(){(i[r].q=i[r].q||[]).push(arguments)},i[r].l=1*new Date();a=s.createElement(o),m=s.getElementsByTagName(o)[0];a.async=1;a.src=g;m.parentNode.insertBefore(a,m)})(window,document,'script','https://take.quiz-maker.com/3012/CDN/quiz-embed-v1.js','qp');Got a good quiz question?Send Newsroom your questions.The post Newsroom daily quiz, Wednesday 22 January appeared first on Newsroom. ...
When I reflect on my life, I look at how everything changed on the evening of June 22, 1970.I was lying in bed when the phone went late one night. My father picked it up. He was on the phone for what seemed like an eternity, and I could tell ...
Opinion: After an exhaustive period of consultation spanning almost two years, the Privacy Commissioner, in the week before Christmas, released the draft version of the Biometric Processing Privacy Code he intends to issue under the Privacy Act.Biometric information, collected through the likes of facial recognition technology, is personal information covered ...
Just testing the waters here (off the back of this) but are there any women here who would find value in having a daily “dick free” post/thread – a bit like Open Mike but with no male contributions?
Hardly possible to make it perfect since a commentator’s gender isn’t always obvious, but the idea would be that any comments from people known to be male would simply be shunted to Open Mike in the first instance, and anyone seeking to masquerade as female would have the known threat of a ban (to be counted in years?) hanging over any possible discovery of their shenanigans.
More than that very rudimentary level of moderation would be contingent on a women with back end access and permissions taking up the baton. (Which may never happen.)
sigh – painful to feel this necessity to state the obvious, but this comment is seeking responses only from women who frequent the site.
The dislike of patriarchal culture and related abusive comments is not an MOR (or even right wing) thing as you are trying to paint it, Bill.
It is very radical against abuse, support, and reinforcement of long time conventions of power and privilege.
I’d rather see leadership on such matters from an author or commenter who understands the problem.
Sorry, I mixed this up with Antoine’s comment below:
https://thestandard.org.nz/open-mike-15-10-2018/#comment-1535865
Thought provoking for a Monday morning.
“The Guardian’s Alarming Recent Record Of Propaganda, Misinformation, And Slander
As has often happened to progressive-minded people who’ve reached a more radical point in their political evolutions, I’ve become disillusioned with many organizations, leaders and media sources that I used to rely on. One of these dubious sources is The Guardian.
At first, it seemed to me like The Guardian is a good alternative to the American mainstream media outlets. It’s often featured quality articles about subjects like climate change, and its columnist George Monbiot is the one who first taught me what the term “neoliberal” means. But this good material is what gives a feel of reliability to the misleading claims that The Guardian very often puts out……”
https://t.co/So4F8z76JQ?amp=1
Good Morning to you Ed, From the link you have provided, What you and your writer object to is the Guardian’s exposure of your other’s fascism denial, and the Guardian’s continued exposure and coverage of the genocide being carried out by your favourite dictator. I have no doubt you find this exposure “alarming”. And it is your alarm and fear of being exposed that fuels your hatred of the Guardian
However what I sense is that lately your and others support for fascism has become somewhat muted, for fear of being laughed out of court. Witness the long winded lead in before this writer dares to mention their real gripe with the Guardian, their coverage of Syria.
The Guardian’s Alarming Recent Record Of Propaganda, Misinformation, And Slander
Rainer Shea – October 14, 2018
I find it breathtaking myself that the Standard tolerates Ed’s fascist propagandizing for a moment. He was running some crap yesterday about world war two in the Ukraine, as part of his campaign manufacturing consent for Putin’s invasion there.
I guess all the old tropes are being shown to be true – the intellectually weak being susceptible to propaganda, and the mild liberals being too nice to reject fascism and trying to accommodate it. It’s as if all the lessons of the early twentieth century were forgotten. Though of course it’s a generational thing – they never learned it.
[My “breathtaking” is to be found in my hitherto tolerance for your tiresome and dishonest hounding of contributors to the site over days and weeks – for your apparent presumption to determine who should and should not comment here; to determine what political opinions ought to be allowed and not allowed; to openly lie about peoples’ political leanings and motivations…Etc.
Notice the word “hitherto”? The tolerance has been chibbed, and this is the only warning you’ll be getting to pull your head in, stop disrupting the flow of comments with your vendettas or whatever the hell it is you think your doing, and engage solely with the topic or arguments at hand.] – B.
Breathless, and suggesting a ban at the same time…
Nice one, Stu!
…
It’s funny you should say it’s a generational thing, Stuart, because Ed does kinda remind me of a particularly naive commenter from years back, Kiwiteen 123.
The nice thing about Ed’s contributions is that he occasionally hits the nail on the head, so it’s probably better to encourage him when he does get it right, rather than get overly negative on his dictator boostering. Like all of us, Ed’s a work in progress and every day’s a learning day.
As for Kiwiteen 123, I reckon he’s at uni now and every bit as annoying:
That special sort of rant that Rik Mayall delivered. What a loss – his bio:
(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rik_Mayall
Do you think that Jonathan Pie has followed in his footsteps?
Thanks Grey, that was a hoot.
No I don’t t think Pie is channeling Rik, in fact Rik is what Pie is railing against.
Long past uni unless he has started a doctorate.
Funnily enough Rik is the character I think if when you get on your high horse, Te Reo.
I’ll fess up now @ Stuart M and a few others. My penis is considerably CONSIDERABLY less in length than yours.
I console myself in the knowledge that its girth is something to behold.
And while I’m in the confessional, it’s possible I’ve sometimes told a little white lie or two – definitely two at least. One as to its length, the other its girth.
@ Jenny@Stuart Munro@te reo putake….Ed is exactly right to feel disillusioned with The Guardian, I take it you all don’t?
Yet The Guardian is plainly biased against the first tangible Left Wing political movement to give a viable alternative to Liberalism to emerge in the UK for a couple of generations…so I take it from your vocal defense of The Guardian that you all have more sympathy for a the New Labour Blairite style Labour, rather than a Socialist Labour?
“Our report found that 75% of press coverage misrepresents Jeremy Corbyn – we can’t ignore media bias anymore”
https://www.independent.co.uk/voices/jeremy-corbyn-media-bias-labour-mainstream-press-lse-study-misrepresentation-we-cant-ignore-bias-a7144381.html
And The Guardian response…
“Yes, Jeremy Corbyn has suffered a bad press, but where’s the harm?”
https://www.theguardian.com/media/greenslade/2016/jul/19/yes-jeremy-corbyn-has-suffered-a-bad-press-but-wheres-the-harm
How the Guardian Changed Tack on Corbyn, Despite Its Readers
https://novaramedia.com/2017/01/08/how-the-guardian-changed-tack-on-corbyn-despite-its-readers/
How The Guardian Undermines Jeremy Corbyn and the Left
https://www.telesurtv.net/english/opinion/Liberal-Journalism-and-Its-Corporate-Sponsors-Interview-20160704-0024.html
Fuck The Guardian, just guard dogs of the establishment liberal status quo, and if you can’t see that plainly obvious truth, well then….
I have considerable reservations about the Guardian’s anti-Corbyn campaigns and similar nonsense. But when we look at what Ed does endorse the Guardian starts to look pretty good.
Jenny Monbiot is just one journalist.
The Guardian deliberately puts forward opposing views.
Your description of Assad is only an opinion.
The Syrian war is a power grab by Putin pushing back the Arab spring Obama cockup who followed George W’s cock up.
If the US got more involved we would have seen more wars breaking out.
While Assad is a nasty Dictator who would have replaced him IsIs.
GH Bush warned his son not to invade Iraq as it would open an hornets nest
Guess what the hornets nest has been opened and its never going to be closed.
Religious fanatics from all sides will ensure that peace will never be achieved.
Arms sales will go up and who are the 2 biggest arms exporters they will want continuous dysfunction in the Middle East.
You’ll be liking this article Ed.
The Guardian explaining that the Saudis were actually quite a progressive and reasonable state with a restrained attitude who have, under Prince Mohammed, had a fine respect for human life and freedoms, its just that they are falling under the evil and nefarious influence of Putin.
“The Russian president’s role in the Middle East had suddenly expanded and his footprint throughout Europe and the US was growing just as rapidly. The young prince seemed curious about what the mercurial Putin had been up to: annexation, intimidation, deflection, the denial of objective facts. But he kept coming back to one question, the officials recalled: how does he get away with it? “He was fascinated by him,” one of the Britons told the Observer. “He seemed to admire him. He liked what he did.” Two years later Prince Mohammed is embroiled in a crisis unlike any other in his short, combustible time as the world’s most powerful thirtysomething. The crown prince stands accused of ordering the brutal death of a prominent critic on foreign soil – a state-sanctioned hit that is without precedent in the kingdom’s modern history, but is not quite so unknown in Russia.”
You’d be right in thinking I’ve sneakily linked to some sabre rattling paranoia and misinformation in the Daily Mail, but no, it really is the Guardian blaming Putin for prince Muhammad’s ‘misstep’. poor boy gullible that he is.
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/oct/13/saudi-arabia-khashoggi-chulov
Nicely put Siobhan
The Guardian really has become shameless and reckless about fact checking;
seemingly these are the Guardian’s “values” now
Chulov has always been more of an opinion piece guy, but this is passed off as news!
MSB was never a reformer, as shown by the provided links
https://www.amnesty.org.nz/free-saudi-women-who-fought-right-drive
https://theintercept.com/2018/10/12/jamal-khashoggi-saudi-arabia-dissidents/
If it’s a bad news story, there’s always a Russian angle to be had.
Nice (though painfully see through) cover for, or deflection from, all the diplomatic, economic and military support afforded SA by the UK and others though, aye?
Sioban the Saudi govt is playing Putin off against Trump another Syria in the making.
Like Trump says if we don’t supply them with the US$120 billion arms deal Russia will.
You’d be right in thinking I’ve sneakily linked to some sabre rattling paranoia and misinformation in the Daily Mail, but no, it really is the Guardian blaming Putin for prince Muhammad’s ‘misstep’. poor boy gullible that he is.
Sioban
I think Sioban that the Guardian article is hysterical and more balanced than you give them credit for.
Blaming Trump as much as Putin as setting the low bar on human rights and international norms of behaviour.
From the linked article you supplied:
Back in 1990(?) The Guardian (then still in a broadsheet format) ran a front page consisting of a full page, disturbing photo of a dead man’s face. It was in the lead-up to what would become the break up of Yugoslavia, and The Guardian was baying for war/intervention.
Back then, The Guardian was considered to be the middle class, sandal wearing peoples’ rag that offered the ‘correct’ spelling of youghourt, the mis-spelling of just about everything else (their typos were a running joke), alongside many articles on the fine art of hand wringing and “first world” problems.
So they haven’t really changed. And there is still the occasional nugget to be found in their pages.
It was The Guardian (accidentally or otherwise) that published an article based on official government documents that exposed UK government funding to Syrian Jihadists.(I’ve linked to it a few times) And sure, they never built on it and it ran entirely counter to their editorial line – which is and always has been crap.
Meanwhile, Monbiot does some good stuff on the environment, but is otherwise a complete waste of time and space. Larry Elliot has written some good stuff on the economics front. And they otherwise sometimes carry good opinion pieces.
In other words, the paper isn’t a total loss.
Definitely not a total loss, Bill.
It was the Grauniad that broke the Murdoch newspapers phone hacking scandal, which ended in the closure of the News of the World. And there’s their work with Edward Snowden and others. The Panama Papers was theirs in part as well.
It’s always worth remembering that the paper itself doesn’t claim to be left wing, though obviously a lot of its writers are. There are alternatives in the UK (the Mirror is surprisingly good on politics and the Morning Star is devoted to left wing analysis), however there isn’t another major English language newspaper in the world that is as consistently progressive as the Guardian.
In a wider sense, the problem is that the Russians and others have devalued ‘news’ to the point where even the concept of journalism is a mystery to a lot of people and opinion writers get confused with reporters of fact as if they were one and the same thing.
I wouldn’t characterise the Guardian as “progressive”. It’s liberal and always has been, which is fine unless the reader expects a perspective coming from the left.
Devaluing news? Dumbing down? That started back before the internet and I’d think more or less coincided with the reprise of liberalism across the Anglosphere.
There’s a pattern here.
Short staffing.
Wonder if RNZ noticed it and could join the dots.
“Workloads and pay would need to improve before NZ teacher Michael Harvey would consider returning as part of the government’ recruitment drive, he says.”
https://www.radionz.co.nz/news/national/368643/survey-of-dhb-staff-describes-dangerous-levels-of-short-staffing
“Health workers have described how “dangerous levels” of short-staffing across the country’s hospitals is putting patients and staff at risk.”
https://www.radionz.co.nz/news/national/368650/teacher-recruitment-drive-risks-creating-conveyor-belt
Neoliberalism.
Death by 1000 cuts for New Zealand citizens.
What nonsense blaming the teacher shortage on neo-liberalism. Teachers have been complaining about workload and class sizes all my adult life. In the late sixties when I was at school the typical fifth form class was a little over 30 students.
On the views of the PPTA the teaching “crisis” must have been continuously running for over 50 years.
Same with nurses. Hospitals seem to have had similar staffing ratios for just about forever.
It suits the unions to say everything is a crisis because they know the government will give in. It is after all the government the unions financed so these pay rounds are just their due reward.
Same across the entire state sector. Just about everyone will get pay rises over the next 3 years of between 5 and 10% per year.
Hard to disagree with that since it concords with my experience too. Important for teachers to bleat in general terms rather than blame the evil controller who keeps refusing to give them more money. Serves the subsidiary purpose of reinforcing the public view that teachers are unable to connect cause & effect.
It doesn’t occur to you that cost of living has grown rapidly under neo-liberalism Wayne? Of course it wouldn’t – such stresses do not touch insiders. Particularly expensive cities now represent a losing deal for teachers and nurses unless they already own their own housing, which is no incentive to stay in the profession.
The stress this generates is worsened by ill-conceived reforms and gratuitous dead weight nuisances like the Novapay debacle. But by all means keep whistling in the dark – it’s going to be a long time before the Gnats see the light at the end of the tunnel.
No, your talking through a hole in your head. I have worked in Health for forty odd years, clinical management for half of them. Its only in the last few years that we have had massive shortages, you should try being confronted with up to 50% shortages for night shift and thats before Nurses ring in sick. Sick because they had worked 16 hr shifts the previous day and the day before. This is all because of a lack of work force planning for the last decade, poor wages in comparrison to other professions and countries.
The majority of Nurses like Teachers are fast approaching retirement age, still no planning to replace them other than poaching a workforce from third world countries who need their own health and Education workers.
Wayne So Simple Soimens smaller class sizes are going to be achieved by sinking lid policies that National do to any publicly funded service govt provides so we end up with as in the education sector a shortage of teachers.
Poor education outcomes 96,000 unemployed under 24 year old when we have massive shortages in construction, IT, nursing teaching agriculture, tourism.
National is a short sighted win power at all cost’s let the invisible hand of the market sort it out.
If you ran a business like that it would fail.
Investing in education was identified as important back in the latter part of the 19 th century when Germany began investing in education for economic and strategic military reasons other countries watching quickly jumped on the band wagon realising that superior economic, technology and industrial power would leave those left behind in a very weak strategic position.
National are guilty of under investing in our most valuable resource.
NZ knows this hence Simple Siomon’s massive U turn on Nationals woeful history on education spending.
Highlighting Nationals failure.
Kids behaved themselves back then or they got beaten wayney. And the stroppy ones were out by age 15. Marking was tick/cross/ x/10 with a rare as hen’s teeth comment in actual words.
Gabby,
Obviously you went to a very different school to me (mine was Reporoa College). I had very decent and highly motivated teachers (mostly). At least in the sixth and seventh forms (20 students and 8 students respectively) the teachers went to huge lengths to lift the aspirations of the students. To be fair, not so much in the fifth form (65 students in two classes).
In the 1960’s there was country service. So we got some extremely good young teachers.
I did get caned on a fair bit, but not in the 6th and 7th form. We were treated as young adults, and we lifted our own standards accordingly.
Both Wayne and Gabby: Caning kids did not actually make teaching them easier. I think the difficulty of teaching them remains constant.
What changes is support and obstacles.
Support has diminished. Teachers are less often backed by parents and the legal system. Govt (through Ministry) has so often prompted teachers to ‘work smarter, not harder’, while ‘doing more with less’. That cracked old record broke apart long ago… And salaries have slipped inexcusably because of penny-pinching Govts of both Right and Left.
Obstacles: Workload was massively increased over the years, with increased paperwork in that 80s period of ‘increased transparency’.. one had not only to do the same work, but write screeds for ERO about how one did it as well. Bollocks. Then came NCEA for secondary teachers – another big shift of workload onto teachers with Internal Assessment (teachers had now to make up their tests and mark them and have them moderated) along with other extra paperwork.. And I gather Primary teachers got much the same thing with National Standards.
All this is symptomatic of Govts wanting to impose austerity instead of social well-being. (Yuk – I hate that phrase.)
Low pay has now become an Obstacle as well. Dedicated teachers who 30 years ago would stay in the profession are now leaving after a few years, after they realise what the job is now actually like.
I began in 1970. I am now semi-retired. NO WAY will I return to full time under current conditions. Your time as part of Govt helped create this, Wayne.
Ed,
My family has turned it’s back on RNZ as we see it now simply as a right wing media platform.
We have been denied any media coverage of our community transport problems since labour took over and the Government have done nothing to fix this right wing misuse of our public media.
‘Seven tell-tale signs the next crash is coming
Last week the sharemarket plunged over the course of two intense days, shedding enormous value off major stocks. While the chaos was concentrated in the US market, the impact spread across the world and also hit New Zealand. In what was one of the worst days in the history of the NZ sharemarket, S&P/NZX50, which tracks the top 50 stocks in New Zealand, dropped 3.64 per cent. While the market did recover on Friday, it caused many to question whether the next big crash was on the horizon…..’
https://www.nzherald.co.nz/business/news/article.cfm?c_id=3&objectid=12142148
I wonder how Sir Ponyboy’s portfolio’s looking.
I believe his children are doing well.
I Trust he’s not neglecting his own interests.
Ponyboy is as usual scamming the system again.
He could now be involved with taking a ‘financial hedge’ against the NZ dollar again as he did in 1987 with has high flying buddy Andy Krieger?
Key & his Wall St mate Andy Krieger just may actually repeat what they did when Labour booted National out in 1984!!!!!
Key will leave NZ after pushing up the dollar with their money, and then pulling it out and slumping the dollar and again making yet another $40 million again.
Key and Krieger were written up in global news as one of the most successful raids ever made on a county’s currency.
So don’t have any illusions that this man known as the smiling assassin is nice, he is ruthless.
http://www.businessspectator.com.au/article/2008/11/10/financial-markets/keys-house
The timing of his elevation, in the midst of a financial crisis, may be quite prophetic. After all, Key’s rise to prominence in foreign exchange circles came after he struck a rewarding relationship at Bankers Trust with Andy Krieger, a daring New York-based trader who launched a legendary raid against the NZ dollar in 1987.
John Key is living proof that not all heads of derivatives operations for large US investment banks end up in the dog house. Some get to run their own country.
I believe as a parent he has the interests of his children at heart.
He has been very successful over a long time – so I’m guessing he’s all good.
Probably missing the limelight and freebies and ‘donations’ for policy, bet he is yearning to get back into politics and the control of others.
The obvious expectation upon retirement was that the Bilderbergers would offer him a coordinating role at the top level. The only evidence we’re likely to get on that is if he was reported as routinely travelling overseas (to foreign capitals, Geneva, NY). Alternatively, just as likely he told the truth about wanting to relax into family life.
It’s quite often when these predictions come out that they do not happen. Crashes happen when no one is predicting them. When everyone is bullish. Currently there are a lot of people with cash on the sidelines because they think the market has got ahead of itself. When that is the case it is not the right environment for a crash.
Do I think stocks are overvalued? Maybe a bit. Average PE’s are high but that is exacerbated by a few larger companies that dominate these indexes. Time will tell, but every year you have these commentators that cry doom and gloom. One year they will be right.
Prof Tim Naish is my touchstone on climate change:
Thank you. I’ll listen later on today when I get the chance.
I find Kevin Anderson excellent.
Investigative journalist Nicky Hager reveals a culture of impunity and cover-ups within the NZDF https://www.noted.co.nz/currently/social-issues/defence-force-new-claims-of-war-crimes-and-sex-assaults/
Apparently in North and South coming out today.
Also Nicky Hager was interviewed on Morning Report.
And on a a separate note, that dreadful Giles Beckworth has taken Espiner ‘s spot.
Don’t we have better journalists?
I know, he doesn’t like squawky seabirds eddy. What’s with that?
RNZ’s report on it:
https://www.radionz.co.nz/news/national/368668/nicky-hager-reveals-fresh-allegations-on-nzdf-cover-ups-and-abuse
I will look for the full article in North and South later this week.
Curiously, there was a similar plot line in a Danish drama series that showed in the last year on NZ TV. It was a drama about a family headed by a patriarchal priest. His priest son served with the military, and while accompanying soldiers on a mission, he was encouraged to shoot at an alleged sniper – it was in fact an innocent woman.
Like the NZ medic in Hager’s report he was afterwards so totally tortured by the killing, he left the church and became an independent minster working with street people. But his crime was also covered up by the establishment.
I suspect such incidents are not isolated occurrences.
“there was a similar plot line in a Danish drama series”.
Well Nicky has to get his plot lines from somewhere. You might call it plagiarism but Nicky would just say he was doing a bit of creative interpretation.
Listening to him on Morning Report today leaves me thinking that he only has to change a couple of names and he can sell the story again.
Just change NZDF to NZ Labour Party and SAS to Young Labour and he can publish it again.
How is the coverup of the Labour Party sex scandal going by the way? Have the Police Force started obeying orders from the Boss and quietly dropped all the charges yet?
There’s a demo planned for Wednesday in Wellington by Organise Aotearoa:
https://twitter.com/OrgAotearoa/status/1051626761220308992
Mr Hager, probably needs to understand the difference between a combat medic and your bog standard medic that you would see in Regimental Aid Post/ Casualty Clearing Post at A Echelon or B Echelon. The days of a medic armed with his Red Cross and his medical gear running around a battlefield ended around the latter stages of WW2/ Korean War due to a number of Nations had a habit of shooting Medics on the battlefield.
A Combat Medic is an Infantryman within a section, a Tankie within an Armoured Vehicle Crew, A Gunner within a Gun section, a Field Engineer within a section, Airforce Gound Defence Section (Airforce Infantry) and in Special Forces Ptl or Section etc.
A Combat Medic role is a secondary role within the Fighting unit/ Combat Platoon/ Team. As a result some Combat Medics are more highly trained than others within a Combat Medic role. For example some Combat Medics can perform basic minor surgery on the casualty or trained similar to that of a Para Medic, A&E or ICU Nurse/ Doc and in my case as a basic Combat First Aid dealing dealings trauma wounds, Minor first aid injuries, using drugs/ drips, stabilise the casualty IOT safety move the casualty back to the A Ech or help other Medics at a Cleaning Station or during clinics at local villages etc.
So in my humble opinion, I don’t think it would be Vampire (Military slang for a Medic) running around battlefield kicking doors in and shooting up the place. Or else this person is in the wrong job for starters, as all the medic’s I’ve come across or worked alongside do take their Red Cross obligations quite seriously which than I could say about some Medical NGO’s over the years.
Investigations take up valuable time that could be better used in haka practice.
The leak saga continues.
They want you gone’ – duncan garner confronts simon bridges with fresh leaks
https://www.newshub.co.nz/home/politics/2018/10/they-want-you-gone-duncan-garner-confronts-simon-bridges-with-fresh-leaks.html
Cinny, the natz elected an AI robot as their leader. High on the Artificial and a bit low on the intelligence.
Bahahahaha, nice one Nick.
Lol, even Garner doesn’t like him.
Coincidentally, I want dunkers gone.
Keep it under your hat.
The headline has it that unions are to blame for low wages. So if there’d been no unions in New Zealand workers would be highly paid. Yes Mike Hosking I believe you. Not.
@Pete +1, more fake news from Hosking. That’s a good one.
With household inflation forecast to be in the range of 3% (and this was before the massive fuel increases) teachers are being told a 3% increase in wages is a good thing by the govt ?
And notice the language that Chris Hipkins is using by aggregating the 3 year increase of $7k in his interviews.
Teaching friends of mine accept that this govt is currently better then the last, but they are becoming very frustrated in the rhetoric that the govt is using and its lack of action in addressing this crisis.
https://www.rbnz.govt.nz/statistics/m13
In the Herald this am
The truckies are flooding Auckland in a protest over petri tax.
GOVT- OK we will axe the tax.
TRUCKIES AND NATZ – Yippee Yah
GOVT – THE road need money to be maintained.
TRUCKIES AND NATZ – Yes the roads are in a terrible state, sort them OUT!!
GOVT Ok will do – road user charges will go up by …..say x10.
TRUCKIES AND NATZ ——Hey you can’t dot that!!!
In the Herald this am
The truckies are flooding Auckland in a protest over petri tax.
GOVT- OK we will axe the tax.
TRUCKIES AND NATZ – Yippee Yah
GOVT – THE road need money to be maintained.
TRUCKIES AND NATZ – Yes the roads are in a terrible state, sort them OUT!!
GOVT Ok will do – road user charges will go up by …..say x10.
TRUCKIES AND NATZ ——Hey you can’t do that!!!
This was a Road transport association (RTA) orchestrated attack on our Minister of Transport Phil Twyford, as he is taking some money from the “Land Transport ‘consolidated fund” and using it to fund rail repairs and urgently needed upgrades.
Truckles fear they may loose freight around the country to rail.
But the roads are now falling to bits by the large road freight increases in the last 10 yrs!!!!
So road user charges now must increase dramatically;
Or road taxes must increase to make roads safer.
Many people are dying under trucks see here last weekend again a death with accidental truck incident.
https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/107786920/Crashes-claim-three-lives-in-deadly-five-hours-on-North-Island-roads
The failure of Socialism in Venezuela is influencing electoral politics in other countries in the region
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/oct/11/brazil-venezuela-jair-bolsonaro-workers-party
Congrats supporters of Bolivarian socialism. The failure of your former ‘poster boy’ is leading to the rise of fascism in other countries.
Gosman South America is under the CIA’s influence since the US decided to become a super power.
Gossipboy Dogmatic till the end. Your never going to get anyone to listen or change if you carry on with your un yielding unscientific rants.
Despot dictators have been installed where ever possible mainly murderous Fascists.
Who buy military hardware from the US and use it to suppress democracy.
The left end up just as nasty as the right.
If not for the US Colonialist meddling you would have moderate Democracies by now.
The cold War is over communism and Fascism are a complete failure.
So Gosman and DTB both of you are extremists ideologues who think their utopic ideology will work both have failed miserably.
Argentina trialled pure capitalism it lasted 18months it was a disaster.
Cuba and Venezuela tried communism it has failed.
So THAT’s what caused the shitty mess in Syria and Libya gozzer.
*yawn* still with b.s. about Venezuela ah Gosman. Why don’t you just publish John Oliver’s piece while your at it, it’s full of out right misinformation.
People wanting to run their own country is a crime. What next Gosman, the US has to invade….
Here is an article analysing the situation in Venezuela from a left wing perspective.
https://venezuelanalysis.com/analysis/14091
Key points:
– Venezuela is in serious crisis as evidenced by the massive outward migration to other nations
– Many, many companies and businesses have closed; it is difficult to get a formal job; there is a dramatic shortage in food and medicine; wages are low; the prices of products found in commerce are high; there is a hyperinflation that causes prices to rise every day.
– Maduro and the Chavista regime is in large part, to blame for the tragedy. Due to bad decisions and the confrontational attitude of his government. He has also contributed to the legal insecurity in Venezuela, which drives away investments and discourages entrepreneurs.
Gossipboy ranting in your Silo again
ffs try something new for godsake.
Surely someone as intelligent and well educated widely read as your self can come up with something new and better than reheating the same stale mouldy old story.
He needs the toilet paper…
grant robertson the maestro.
now the nationals party apologist is whining on rnz about petrol tax.
blerrrkkkk.
more sly nationals party memes.
there is a price to pay for everything.
Gossipboy I’ll bet you anything you like that Bolisarno will be as corrupt as any previous Brazilian leader.
And Brazil will do no better corruption is endemic this will not change in our lifetimes.
But will it be as corrupt as Venezuela is now?
Dictatorship’s aren’t corrupt Gossipboy
Your dictating of only one side of the story boringly corrupt.
Repeating the failure of Venezuela ruins any argument you may have had.
Dictatorship’s are Dogmatic like spin lies while murdering the truth just like you gossip boy.
By comparing a country which is controlled by drug Cartels with any form of democracy looses the point of your pathetic arguments.
And Besides Brazils economy is much larger with much more money to corrupt.
Lift your game Gossipboy boring people with your repetitive dreary Dogma barking madly and incessantly.
The chocapocalypse is coming!
https://www.nzherald.co.nz/business/news/article.cfm?c_id=3&objectid=12142488
ARGH!
The market will prevail. Prices may rise but the spice will flow.
(I suspect most ‘chocolate’ currently sold in the world contains very little cocoa anyway)
A.
Well, someone’s telling porkies.
https://screenshots.firefox.com/KAjXJ9bu7ZlMFEm2/www.whittakers.co.nz
Of course I know Whittakers has cocoa in it! The percentage is clearly printed on the packet!!
But how much cocoa do you think there is in a Mars Bar or a pack of M&Ms?
A.
I’ve never eaten either, so I wouldn’t know.
“You were probably right, Antoine. Sorry for calling you a liar” – joe90
Aww, pwecious.
/
Not a reply to Bill’s top-of-thread comment, but inspired by it:
The Standard has traditionally been a forum for arguing – vigorously – frequently descending into slanging matches and abuse. Not only the commenters but also some authors and moderators have behaved in this way. This seems OK to me, there is a niche for this kind of site, it gives people a bit of interest in their lives and keeps them coming back.
It does however put off many people particularly women, right-wingers, centrists, people with good manners and normal people in general.
Mods need to decide what the Standard is for.
Is it still for arguing and wrangling? Then fine, just go on as you are. (Probably some commentators will leave in disgust. Some will come back in time.)
Or is it for reasoned, measured, sometimes impassioned but basically polite discussion? Then you need to make some very significant changes. Starting by taking a good hard look at yourselves and your own conduct. (I’m looking at lprent, TRP, Bill among others.) You will probably have to get rid of quite a few ‘old guard’ commenters who cannot be reformed as well.
I think Weka was trying to take the Standard down the latter route. It proved unachievable for her.
A.
Good commenters also need to choose carefully who they engage with and why, and figure out quickly who is just not worth their while.
“particularly women, right-wingers, centrists, people with good manners and normal people in general“..
I notice you forgot to include Left wingers in your list.
Nearly all my commited left wing friends, a good percentage of whom are male, refuse to comment or even read the Standard because of the abusive tone.
That and the perception that its dominated by Labour Party fan boys and girls who tolerate no questioning of the Party line. Particularly scary when they form packs and start accusing every man, woman and his dog of being a troll, which happens far too often.
Personally I walked through the ring of fire, being called an ‘arsehole’, a ‘nutter’, a ‘gormless idiot’, ‘disappointingly boring and quite predictable’ (ouch!!), among other things, by The Sysop in the course of one memorable week. Which I guess I’m grateful for, as it left me with no illusions about the nature of this site. But on the other hand I really doubt there is any strong appetite and commitment for change.
it is what it is.
Yep.
And, in a way, I understand why many of those who dominate this site are happy with its culture, and don’t want it to change. When people have a little status in a little domain, they are unwilling to give it up.
But it doesn’t represent the wider left – although, as I have said previously, all the big left wing blogs are male dominated, in one way or another.
And there’s no major left site really providing much space for socialist feminists, or even social democratic women, or LGBT+ people, or people of colour/Maori/Pacific people – except in a pretty marginal way.
However, i would have expected a little more self reflection from those who dominate this site, as presumably committed lefties, on the male dominance herrre
Thanks, Antoine.
To a large extent, it’s up to the commenters what TS is, or becomes. The site has certainly evolved over the years (google Robinsod if you want to get a flavour of the anarchic early days). I see it now as reasonably mature in a blog sense, with a distinct tone and an engaged community.
There has been a good effort from the authors in recent times to guide commenters rather than argue with them or simply ban them. In the few months I’ve been back I’ve binned a few comments, gave some clear direction to a couple of folk and banned nobody. Last month only 5 people got banned, all for short periods.
I think the authors are much more aware these days of the power imbalance, too. I’ve even walked away from a couple of discussions where my status appeared to be affecting other commenter’s ability to say what they wanted to.
None of us writers are paid, though we all try to write in a professional way. Just for the record, even a simple ‘notices and features’ post takes 10-15 minutes to put together. The more involved opinion pieces can take an hour or more. Then add in the time taken to monitor comments and you’ve got a significant commitment to the site.
It’s a job, really. No monetary reward, however some occasional, fleeting satisfaction at a turn of phrase, a heartfelt comment or an issue elevated into the public consciousness.
According to Stuff, Jamie Lee Ross was the leak!!!!!
David Neiwert
@DavidNeiwert
Thread is about how the RWNJs in the US are promoting civil war.
Must say so impressed with all the anti-free speech people you have your wish – facebook is shutting down the left.
Who would have thought it. (well myself and few others here – you know who you are)
It’s all this our source is better than your source B.S. which has made it here as well has finally led to this.
So when they shut down the last of the dissenting voices, blame yourselves folks – you did this – you let the corporations walk all over you.
https://www.commondreams.org/news/2018/10/12/facebook-accused-full-frontal-suppression-dissent-after-independent-media-swept-mass?mc_cid=0da54e4c72&mc_eid=524e48683c
The left has been shut down? Gosh. 800 pages culled and the entire Left is ended. Who knew victory for the tories would be so easy.
Such a tragedy that I’ll no longer see your comments.
It’s not “800 pages culled”. It’s another 800 pages on top of previous take downs and shut downs that are being done largely at the behest of four designated organisations acting as approved censors for facebook.
That aside. The unnecessary personal dig included your comment? Leave it out, aye?
How many pages have been reinstated from those previous take-downs?
And the personal dig also pointed out that FB is not essential to “the left”. Adam was commenting here, and AFAIK this is the only place I see their comments. Even if zucks were trying to turn FB into FoxNews Social Media, it’s not the only platform in town.
I don’t know how many have since been re-instated. I also don’t know what knock-on effect the loss of a fb page has for a news or info source, though given the large percentage of people who apparently get their news from fb, it’s unlikely to be having a minimal impact.
There’s quite a bit of dodgy stuff going on with regards the web and censorship that affects a huge chunk of the web (ie – google, fb and youtube).
Thoughtful and thought provoking articles, info and analysis are there to be had if information and controlling access to it interests you.
There is also a lot of dodgy stuff going on with regards to lack of censorship on the web, too. Bullying, bots, phishing, etc.
It’s sort of a microcosm of society – if there’s no sherriff, society usually becomes parasitic and toxic. If there’s too much sherriff, it becomes a police state.
I like how you shift the point to avoid the point. The problem is the broad sweep censorship, with a big chuck of what is being hit is left wing voices. Not parasites and generally not toxic, but you only want to listen to your take on the left – so I get why your clapping and cheering on this sort of stuff.
A big chuck of right wing voices are hit, too. The question is how many of these left and right “voices” deserve to be taken down because they are outright dangerous. And the question of any screening system is how false negatives and false positives are caught and re-evaluated, hence my question of how many are reinstated after appeal.
Because “generally” non-toxic means that even you would admit that some toxic content occurs even from the left, no?
You and I do toxic ever once in a while, so yes it exists on the left. But the point of the post was the blanket approach used by the monolith that is facebook – has a tendency to target social activists and left leaning people rather than toxic and vial idiots you are talking about. Yes it got a few of those, but people like
https://thefreethoughtproject.com/about-us/
are not in that group. If anything, the outright dangerous like Alex Jones, have profited by the facebook doing this sort of thing. And grown in support – so blocking them is not working either.
That’s an odd site, and hardly left wing. Looking at some of its stories I’d want to see what they were sharing via FB before making a call on their case.
Bullying, bots, phishing, etc. would strike me as coming down to moderation (not censorship), bullshit chasing money or rating (as far as I understand bots) and security against….well, I was gong to say malware, but nothing really protects a person from their own stupidity.
Censorship of information by arguably monopolistic platforms is something else entirely, but hey…
Could you explain more about the distinction between moderation and censorship?
Censorship deletes or makes invisible – eradicates. Moderation doesn’t.
But don’t moderators here sometimes redact some or all parts of a particular comment? In extreme cases, yes, but does it happen?
Yes, it happens – ie, moderation can slip over into censorship. What’s your point?
Doesn’t that count as “deletes or makes invisible”?
When it slips over from being one thing to being another? Why yes, it does.
So I guess I’m not sure what your point is. FB censorship isn’t a bad thing, just how extensive it might be becoming is the problem?
Good gawd. There is no way you misunderstood the term “from one to the other” – ie, two different things.
Can’t be arsed with the level of sophistry your indulging in.
The point is that censorship itself isn’t a bad thing. Sometimes it’s necessary, whichever the platform. The existence isn’t the problem, the balance is the issue. I think bringing the reins in a bit is necessary. As long as the good outweighs the bad of overreach in individual cases, it’s a positive.
Why do I always think of this song when I see your comments Mcflock?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CJQU22Ttpwc&ab_channel=waverlyflams
.
I would give you a considered answer, but it would be a personal dig.
I was hoping you could laugh at yourself, but you know, dreams are, well for the time being anyway – free.
What I’m laughing at is how severely you’ve been censored and are no longer free to express yourself because the left is being shut down.
Good, better than your usual grump self 🙂
Here’s a case in point about censorship that you may or may not want to consider.
That post on Zionism I did a week or so back involved sourcing info on Kastner. Google ‘curates’ searches to such a degree that I simply couldn’t break through from one side of the story and finally dumped google in favour of duckduckgo.
I was free to express myself, but I had some problems informing myself because of the censorious effect of algorithms – put in place by a company that’s signed up to a deal with the Chinese government promising to ensure no searches in China will go to any info the government would rather remained unseen.
Another case would be facebook responding to something like 80% or 90% of Israeli takedown requests when the people in Gaza use facebook for almost all of their news access.
And then there’s the ‘deplatforming’ and ‘demonetising’ malarky that’s going on with youtube…
So yeah, maybe anyone’s free to express whatever (assuming the platform they use remains open to them) , but the library shelves are going to have all these huge gaps and/or the books containing the info we really need are going to be in storage (and so require a presence of prior knowledge to be specifically requested ) rather than happened upon by browsing.
The point is that many people use duckduckgo because google doesn’t serve their needs.
I bet you lots of people in Gaza are now beginning to use something other than FB, too.
Which is what we never really got with libraries – if one library wasn’t making some subject areas accessible, say didn’t have a large section on medieval armour, there were a lot more barriers. You couldn’t just type in a new address and thereby visit a completely different library. And if somoene blocks that library, you figure out a way to another address.
Facebook, meanwhile, had empowered the right-wing outlet the Weekly Standard to “fact check” articles. The Weekly Standard, invested in Kavanaugh’s confirmation, deemed the Think Progress article “false.” The story was effectively nuked from Facebook, with other outlets threatened with traffic and monetary consequences if they shared it. The story is republished below, with permission from Think Progress, though not from Facebook or the Weekly Standard.
https://theintercept.com/2018/09/14/facebook-weekly-standard-suppressed-a-story-about-brett-kavanaughs-opposition-to-roe-v-wade-were-republishing-it/
So, there’s that. The censors with vested interests.
And you reckon people in Gaza can just choose to dump facebook and access news through…what, myspace maybe?
Fetlife would be more interesting. NSFW if you google it.
Amazing the, er, “niche” platforms out there if you just want to connect with likeminded folks. And when all else fails, opensource content managers can be knocked up into social media pretty quickly.
Niche platform versus ubiquitous platform. For general and/or important news and information – both the gathering and disseminating thereof. Hmm.
Maybe you honestly can’t see the issues around what is beginning to happen with google and facebook and youtube, or maybe you can but just don’t care.
I’d like to believe it’s the former.
I’m aware of the dangers. I’m also aware of the dangers of the monoliths’ previous almost-anything-goes approach.
It’s a balancing act, sure. But the nice thing about the internet is that the startup costs are minimal. And my nieice tells me FB is old-hat anyway.
Thanks for your backgrounding of that McFlock. I should use duckduckgo and just haven’t got it into my daily practice. And
thanks for your argument path that seeks to be objective and winds its way between alternatives.
cheers. Yeah I set ddg as my default search engine a while ago 🙂
Private browsing windows are also good for minimising cookies and tracking, not just for tinfoil hat reasons but also to stop ads crossing over now that google is doing cross-platform matching more often. I don’t need my home searches turning up at work, people will think I’m goofing off more than usual lol
McFlock
Hard to believe – never!
This fellow was hopeless, but I’ve heard worse today.
Just heard a disastrously inept performance from High Performance Sport New Zealand’s CEO Michael Scott. He was being interviewed on RNZ National, and he came across as panicked and inarticulate.
Still better than that shower in the National Party “leadership”, however.
Here’s a bit of an update from the Wentworth Races (Not the NSW Town btw). Since my last post a couple of days ago, the mud throwing has started with Liberal candidate saying a vote the Phelps is a vote for a hung parliament etc etc. Yesterday and today old Phelps has said again the she will vote for the Coalition on matters for supply and on confidence if elected and all this talk is from the Lib candidate is BS. Anyway I find old Shifty Bill won’t be doing many walk abouts this week (or does this include his front bench as well), which has me thinking have Labour given up and now realise it’s now a 2 horse race between Phelps and old mate Sharma? As ScoMo and his front bench have hit streets running about the place like a headless chickens or one arm plumber from Baghdad trying fix million to one leaks.
So someone is shit scared atm.
I leave you with comment from a Lib Coalition pollie flying back into Canberra on Sunday when asked about this Saturday’s by-election “Well we are going to be in the Penthouse or the Shit House after next Saturday”. Yes mate from what the polls are saying atm, I’ll say the Shit House atm.
http://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-10-13/inside-the-race-for-malcolm-turnbull-wentworth-kingdom/10364908
http://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-10-15/wentworth-dave-sharma-treatment-of-malcolm-turnbull-appalling/10377790
So Aussie. Penthouse or shithouse. Well-chosen words. It must be like the old Roman days, watching the fights at the Colosseum, and they had them in the Senate too.
Kia ora The Am Show congratulations to the couple expecting their new baby .
I get what our All Blacks Coach up to Stue Wilson ?????????.Its cool that Stue talks about his alcohol experiences on the show lets the youth no some of the side effects of the stuff.
I had that problem a company payed with a credit card they were taking money when there service was cancelled send them a email they will most times refund your money.
I wondered whats world he is IN.
Amanda that black bear cub with the bucket stuck on his head they tracked it for 3 days and tranquilised it to get the bucket off its ka pai to see people care for animals .
I agree with Jacinda our political seen needs to change a bit what stop the mud sling and get on with running the country it’s not a good look for the mokos and is not good for te wairua.
The Air New Zealand flying taxis to commute people to the Auckland city is a great goal to have Ka pai.
Wars like this War in YEMEN need to stop all the wars around the Papatuanuku need to stop .I don’t know the reason they give for this war but I do know that its the rich who start wars for power and money . I do know that its the common poor man who fights these stupid wars the common mothers and fathers lose their offspring to wars .P.S I do know that rich men do not fight in these wars
I do know that its the common tangata /people who are dieing because of the rich MANS WAR we need to fight climate change and not each other this is so backwards to the Dark ages I say humans have never left that era .
Ka kite ano
https://edition.cnn.com/2018/10/15/middleeast/yemen-famine-war/index.html
Eco did a bit of research I got what going on in the middle east .
I don’t back ether side ECO MAORI BACKS PEACE AND HUMANITY.
International trasport of the future here are some new designs link below Ka kite ano
I laws were made to encourage this leap forward in air planes that would speed up the development of low carbon passenger planes link below ka kite ano
https://www.euronews.com/2018/10/15/futuris-reaches-for-the-sky-with-the-wings-of-the-future
Electric Container Ships another blow to the Human Caused Climate Change deniers
EGO P.S I seen some trolls quoting that air travel and container ships could not be carbon free.
I’ll have to thank my neo liberal capitalist red neck neighbour for helping with the
Eco Maori effect ka pai ka kite ano
Kia ora Newshub I don’t like kicking a person when they are down bridges & ross .
It give me a sore face when some people start writing about New Zealand and Australia becoming a republic when the Royal Family is so popular there dreaming.
That’s a od phenomenon compressed air is safer and better for some patients I say big company interference in reality once again .
I see that company teaming up with Air New Zealand in designing and testing auto flying vehicles my guess is that Aotearoa’s air traffic laws are not as stringent as other country’s but Its cool we will be pioneers in this industry.
Paul Allan one of the Microsoft founders condolences to his whano.
I say with the organ donation problem could be solved with a opted out clause if you don’t want to donate you have to say know problem solved business people use this very effectively Ka kite ano
The Cowd Goes Wild Mulls & Storm Ka pai to the young Aotearoa Ferns win in Gold.
congratulations to all the Kiwis at the youth game’s .
Josh Rugby mana all around Papatuanuku that’s cool.
Wairangi sore face E hoa don’t count Mals men out to soon they are world champions .
Ka kite ano P.S Eco know what that is like Bolt