Hard to deny i think monumental changes are happening around the world
Especially in America .While the Trump campaign was gathering momentum i watched and i thought this is good because for sure he will be the 'spanner in the works ' , but brother was that an understatement !!!!!!!
Before Trump while the Biden establishment meandered through a year and a half or so of genocide enabling for Israel and obviously for its own racist maniacs and even as the bodies of innocents grew ever higher daily you got the impression many didnt even notice and mind bogglingly many knew even here on TS and forgave them .
Its a chilly overcast morn where i am with a promise of blustery rain an imo theres nothing like a dose of realism on such a monday morning wakey wakey
Sure…we used to be what trump is now going to end… namely if you are born in nz…you are a nz citizen..
Clark/labour removed that right in 2006..
..and this is now being highlighted by the 19 yr old born/educated here…to parents who are not here legally…is to be deported to India…a country he has never been to/does not speak the language..
This is inhumane ..in any language. .
This 19 yr old is a nz citizen…to my mind ..
And must be allowed to stay in the country of his birth ..
Does he have a birth certificate? I suspect he doesn't if his parents are here illegally since the birth would probably not have been regisgtered . Would that make a difference?
The 14 th Amendment in the USA States that anyone born in the USA is automatically a citizen. Trump would have to cancel the Amendment which needs I think 2 thirds majority +++
The whole birth rights thing is a problem because it invites people to gain an advantage by being sneaky or just plane dishonest. That said give the boy residency send his parents home.
I know a successful young couple who intend to have there children over sees solely because they get dual citizenship.
I tend to agree. This young man should have residency.
But if someone has a baby while here on a working holiday visa for instance, I can't see the rationale for the child being a resident. Are there issues with the parent’s nationality and that country giving residency to the child?
England does not have birthright citizenship. One of my nephews was born in England while his parents were there working. They had to register him in New Zealand for New Zealand citizenship when they returned here and he has no right to UK citizenship or residency.
Up until recently – Yes. I'm unsure of the current situation. But as both my parents were from UK in the 1920's and I was born in NZ in the 1940's, I can apply for a British passport.
I'm not sure that Australia does either. Our son, daugter in law and their eldest son (our grandson) moved to Australia in 2004, their second son was born in 2005 in Melbourne and had was registered as a New Zealand citizen. I also can't be absolutely sure, but I believe he is now eligible for Australian citizenship.
I agree. So draw a line under it from today. Everyone who was born here before this time gets assessed and granted citizenship if the situation warrants it, but going forward it depends on the circumstances.
We drew the line under it back in 2005. At that time we said that anyone born here before 1/1/2006 was a citizen. Anyone born after that date was a citizen only if at least one of their parents was a citizen or had permanent residency.
Why re-open it? Because we have a case that we don't like? What will we do in 2045 when in comes up again? Simply decide to start again and grant everyone born here between 2025 and 2045 gets retroactive citizenship in the same way as you appear to be proposing for the period between 2006 and 2025?
Sorry but this is the law and has been so since 2006. It is the hard cases like this for which the Ministerial discretion applies. If the Minister won't apply it we can complain but someone has to choose. We can't just say that we shouldn't have any laws because we get the rare problem occasionally.
You go on to say "Everyone who was born here before this time gets assessed and granted citizenship if the situation warrants it" followed by "going forward it depends on the circumstances". Can you tell me the difference between these statements? All you appear to be saying is that we may or may not give citizenship in either situation.
Personally I would allow the boy to stay but deport the parents who have been overstayers for at least 20 years. Why should they be allowed to continue here?
I agree with Alwyn. We have drawn a line under it.
Personally I would allow the boy to stay but deport the parents who have been overstayers for at least 20 years. Why should they be allowed to continue here?
If Penk is really that stupid, I have to admit I expected better from him. Someone ought to give him a bit of a talking to. Obviously anyone born in Aotearoa is an Aoteoroan naturally. If the state can't get real, it becomes disposable. So common sense must prevail.
That said, the state of NZ hasn't featured common sense much during my adult life. There did seem to be a semblance of it when I was young, but clueless dork syndrome has been prevalent for a long time. I agree there have been fairly brief periods when a semblance of competence has also shown up, as if to give us hope for the future…
The parents may have 'cooked the goose for the son', unfortunately. By not regularising their residency it has affected him. What were the reasons that their applications were declined in the 2010s?
Has he a right to leave but then apply for a work permit /residency for himself?
It is hard.
Then I would feel more sympathy if it can be shown that the parents have been working/paying taxes and not claiming benefits over the years but is this enough to knock out the basic illegality of overstaying.
Agree with the ‘clueless dork syndrome has been prevalent for a long time.’ Prime examples in this case are INZ not following up the refusal of work and other visas applied for in the 2010s.
..and how can those who voted for this aberration not be shifting uneasily in their seats…?
And there is an economic argument also to be made here..
In that we as a country have invested in the education etc of these young people….and just as they are about to become contributers to the economy we throw them out..
But the strongest arguments for birthright restoration must be against the limbo these young new Zealanders find themselves trapped in..
This is a cruel/unjust life for them..and all through no faults of their own…
I agree totally with your argument for the son. I am not sure if he holds Indian citizenship as well?
I don't see that at present the parents can hang a 'remaining in NZ argument' off an argument for a right for him to remain because he was born here.
Sunita Devi had not held a valid visa since 2004, and "because she was unlawfully in New Zealand at the time of Daman's birth, he therefore inherits her immigration status as being unlawfully in New Zealand", he said.
Ministerial intervention for temporary work permits in 2010 was declined and after another failed application in 2011 the family had no further contact with Immigration New Zealand until 2024, when they applied for visitor visas under section 61 of the Immigration Act, he said.
These were also declined.
As always the truism 'hard cases make bad law' applies.
Is everyone in work?
The problem seems difficult to solve, exacerbated by lax follow-up of the visas that have been granted*, and overstaying. For instance in the Kumar family temporary work permits were declined in 2010. So why was enforcement action to remove not taken then?
NZ makes a rod for our own backs by not doing this follow-up. Not all of the lack of followup can be laid at the door of staffing pressures from the current govt. Then we get the tugging at the heartstrings situations such as here. Also while the current son can recieve an eduation to secondary school level as an overstayer this ability stops then and he is not eligible to go to University. We may possibly be seeing other under educated though capable people here in NZ and that is a waste.
His parents surely would have a connection to India? One doesn't lose a connection to a place where one is born & brought up in the time of 20 or so years, otherwise this would also happen to NZers who have spent their significant parts of their lives overseas. The overstaying argument has no connection to this.
We've being 501ing PI citizens who were born in NZ, and may have never been to the Island they came from for a long time. The same issue of unsupported, possibly violent, young men being dropped into a country they know nothing about happens in those Islands. The hypocricy is ours.
Why did this legislation come about? I may be completely wrong here but I vaguely recall that it might have been in relation to not nessecarily a scam, but a movement of sorts, of couples or individuals moving here for a very short while just so their child could get citizenship and the parents later being eligible for the family reunification scheme. The US rings a bell, of course it was a fairly expensive exercise so I imagine it was a bit out of touch for those from poorer countries. There was also a no fly rule which may even still exist if the mother was within 4 weeks os birthing. Please correct me if I’m wrong on any of this. What is being forced on this young man is cruel and harsh and I don’t support it at all.
Agree. This seems actually to be what has happened here but as often happens the results fall heavily on those who are the least infringing ie the son.
The parents have applied and been turned down twice in the 2010s and have just stayed on…….
But it occurs in a nation with poor access to dentists and poor dental care has wider health consequences. In a nation with declining access to primary health care.
It does not develop good national policy.
New Zealand First proposed a Member's Bill the day after the WDC meeting aimed at returning flouridation decision-making power to local communities.
"All the council is fighting for is to have a referendum on the matter so locals can have a voice," Peters said.
The 'Fluoridation (Referendum) Legislation Bill' seeks to repeal the Health (Fluoridation of Drinking Water) Amendment Act 2021 that granted centralised authority to the director-general of health and mandated the fluoridation of local water supplies.
It will also amend the Local Government Act 2002 and Health Act 1956 mandating local authorities to hold a binding referendum on water fluoridation.
"This bill reinstates the fundamental right for communities to determine through democracy whether or not their water supply is fluoridated," Peters said.
Ireland, first 1.0 to half the population, then 0.8 to all. 1960. Now it is 0.6-0.8, target 0.7.
Facts. China, India have high levels in their water, so does half the UK (the rest gets fluoridation, if councils seek it).
Germany – use of iodine salt with fluoride as well as fluoride tablets and washes is strongly encouraged by their Ministry of Health – leading to a remarkable drop in caries prevalence in Germany since the early 1990ies.
Switzerland, Austria and France also fluoridate table salt.
In 2011 the U.S. DHHS and EPA proposed to reduce the recommended level of fluoride in drinking water to the lowest end of the current range, 0.7 milligrams per liter of water (mg/L), from the previous recommended maximum of 0.7 to 1.2 mg/L in recognition of the increase in sources of fluoride such as fluoridated toothpastes and mouthwashes.
Israel demonstrates the problems of politicians acting in ways that harm public health.
The "Cookers" packing out council meetings, to intimidate councilors, and cherry picked "evidence" plus endless repetition of fairly obvious pseudo science from the USA, notably on community Facebook pages, and mobbing character assisination of anyone who questions them, shows they don't really want a referendum of well informed citizens.
Why bother dropping levels? I remember the dental nurse/murder house on Willis St, where they trucked us in to get out little teeth drilled by learner dental nurses, with no anaesthetic. My son, born after fluoridation, had no fillings at the age of 20, and no evidence of fluorodosis (as evidenced by flecked teeth).
Like immunisation, water supply fluoridisation benefits those who are poor, and likely to be unable to afford washed, etc the most.
Hmmm, I've read the 'neurotoxicity' science previously. Much of it is based on comparing individuals who come from areas where water is naturally low (F 1ppm and under) and areas, such as those with granite, where F may be 2-3 x higher, if not more.
The US Toxicology Service analysed the published literature and says 'The NTP monograph concluded, with moderate confidence, that higher levels of fluoride exposure, such as drinking water containing more than 1.5 milligrams of fluoride per liter, are associated with lower IQ in children.'
Confounding factors:. Research reviewed are population studies, not science experiments. 1. heavy metals which also affect brain development may be in the naturally-high F water sources. None of which were tested for such contaminants. Iodine deficiency also causes brain retardation. 2. Poor-quality high F drinking water occurs mostly in poor rural areas, associated with economic and social deprivation. A good population study can manage this by pairing each low and high factor person with someone of similar economic and social background. But none of the studies did. 3. A standard IQ test has a huge economic/cultural bias.
Yesterday, I happened upon a council-run 'free' supply of water without added fluoride or chlorine – it's towards the hospital side of Papaioea Park in Palmy North.
For goodness sake. Palmy has an excellent water supply, from the rainfall on the hills, or from a 200m deep clean bore in Highbury and surrounds. Fluoride has NO effect on adult cognition. The council does us proud. At my age, (and, I'm guessing, yours), keeping teeth intact is vital. Fluoridated water helps, a lot.
The irony is that Peters looks, talks, and acts like he’s a long-serving member of the Politburo; I even detect a slight Russian slur in his speech at times – those were the days when men worn suits & ties.
Not sure what it is about gNActoids with their trying to be as punitive and nasty as possible – just to show us all how tuff they are. Pathetic is probably the best way to describe them – especially since in the case of the Dalit, they've put their want to be cruel, egotistical wankers out their for all to see.
I had hopes that Penk was going to be one of the better gNats. (Alongside people such as Finlayson, at a pinch – Bolger , McKinnon – who was sincere in his concern for rehabilitation of prisoners rather than simply punishing them then shoving them out on the street to a life of recidivism).
Unfortunately he (the Penkster) is proving to be pretty bloody useless – using all the usual excuses – such as the ill-defined "Operational Matter". Was it maybe a bit of drama he craved, or maybe just that he was a useless tit.
Phil Ure is correct in my mind. Daman Kumar is as much a NZer as youse all and moi. Is, was, and always will be. He certainly meets the 'good character' test, which if applied equitably, would see the likes of Peter Thiel deported to whichever country he'd bought citizenship from.
Quite a few moons ago, it used to be that even if one was born on a vessel whose destination was lil 'ole NuZull that punches above its weight, he/she/it was a NZer – and that's as it should be Not sure what H1 did, or why, but I'd give Her the benefit of the doubt and suggest she might have had Her reasons at the time.
We need to simplify things rather than keep trying to complicate everything – just to show how clever we are.
Similarly, thankfully those that pay taxes here do, and should get voting rights – if only after a couple of election cycles which would show their commitment to the country. (Apologies to a TDB contributor @ Castro – who, it seems to me just doesn't really like Indians. But he wouldn't be alone – there's an entire Munstry staffed in senior positions by people from the Empire – sometimes parachuted in – who think the same. And no amounting a spreadsheet risk analysis bullshit that told us that's not how they did things will alter that.
Yes….. yet another example of enshittification/crapification.
Penk: If you don't want to be seen as a complete R Sole, give it a rest and don't buy into your colleagues' Trumpian bullshit ideology. This whole sad story has not served the gNats image too well. Too bad, never mind!
(Apologies if this is a double post – previous submission produced "Site can't be reached")
'Devastating': Hundreds of engineers leaving NZ due to infrastructure delays, CEO claims [RNZ; 16 Feb 2025]
"The shutdown of education rebuilds, the shutdown of hospital builds and upgrades, the slow down on roading, the changes in the Three Waters space has meant that New Zealand engineers and New Zealand constructors, the people who build the roads, waters network and buildings, have all had to look for work elsewhere and that has seen people heading overseas or contracting to work overseas and significant numbers."
"Hundreds" of engineers were also losing their jobs, Templer added.
Imho, our CoC is making a bigger pig's breakfast than the usual Nat-led lot. Don't know how much is deliberate, but if govt ministers learn from their mistakes, then the cabinet should be full of self-taught geniuses by now.
Britain’s official state propaganda arm is right behind this latest show of insane jingoism….
Sir Keir Starmer has said he is "ready and willing" to put UK troops on the ground in Ukraine to help guarantee its security as part of a peace deal.
The UK prime minister said securing a lasting peace in Ukraine was "essential if we are to deter Putin from further aggression in the future".
Before attending an emergency summit with European leaders in Paris on Monday, Sir Keir said the UK was prepared to contribute to security guarantees to Ukraine by "putting our own troops on the ground if necessary".
"I do not say that lightly," he wrote in the Daily Telegraph. "I feel very deeply the responsibility that comes with potentially putting British servicemen and women in harm's way."
The prime minister added: "But any role in helping to guarantee Ukraine's security is helping to guarantee the security of our continent, and the security of this country." ….
US President Donald Trump’s hostile regime has finally forced Europe to wake up. With US officials calling into question the transatlantic alliance, Germany’s incoming chancellor, Friedrich Merz, recently persuaded lawmakers to revise the country’s debt ...
We need to establish clearer political boundaries around national security to avoid politicising ongoing security issues and to better manage secondary effects. The Australian Federal Police (AFP) revealed on 10 March that the Dural caravan ...
The NZCTU Te Kauae Kaimahi have reiterated their call for Government to protect workers by banning engineered stone in a submission on MBIE’s silica dust consultation. “If Brooke van Velden is genuine when she calls for an evidence-based approach to this issue, then she must support a full ban on ...
The Labour Inspectorate could soon be knocking on the door of hundreds of businesses nation-wide, as it launches a major crackdown on those not abiding by the law. NorthTec staff are on edge as Northland’s leading polytechnic proposes to stop 11 programmes across primary industries, forestry, and construction. Union coverage ...
It’s one thing for military personnel to hone skills with first-person view (FPV) drones in racing competitions. It’s quite another for them to transition to the complexities of the battlefield. Drone racing has become a ...
Seymour says there will be no other exemptions granted to schools wanting to opt out of the Compass contract. Photo: Lynn GrievesonLong stories shortest:David Seymour has denied a request from a Christchurch school and any other schools to be exempted from the Compass school lunch programme, saying the contract ...
Russian President Boris Yeltsin, U.S. President Bill Clinton, Ukrainian President Leonid Kuchma, and British Prime Minister John Major signed the Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty in ...
Edit: The original story said “Palette Cleanser” in both the story, and the headline. I am never, ever going to live this down. Chain me up, throw me into the pit.Hi,With the world burning — literally and figuratively — I felt like Webworm needed a little palate cleanser at the ...
This is a re-post from Yale Climate Connections by Sarah Wesseler(Image credit: Antonio Huerta) Growing up in suburban Ohio, I was used to seeing farmland and woods disappear to make room for new subdivisions, strip malls, and big box stores. I didn’t usually welcome the changes, but I assumed others ...
Myanmar was a key global site for criminal activity well before the 2021 military coup. Today, illicit industry, especially heroin and methamphetamine production, still defines much of the economy. Nowhere, not even the leafiest districts ...
What've I gotta do to make you love me?What've I gotta do to make you care?What do I do when lightning strikes me?And I wake up and find that you're not thereWhat've I gotta do to make you want me?Mmm hmm, what've I gotta do to be heard?What do I ...
Here’s my selection1 of scoops, breaking news, news, analyses, deep-dives, features, interviews, Op-Eds, editorials and cartoons from around Aotearoa’s political economy on housing, climate and poverty from RNZ, 1News, The Post-$2, The Press−$, Newsroom3, NZ Herald, Stuff, BusinessDesk-$, NBR-$, Reuters, FT-$, WSJ-$, Bloomberg-$, New York Times-$, The Atlantic-$, The Economist-$ ...
Whenever Christopher Luxon drops a classically fatuous clanger or whenever the government has a bad poll – i.e. every week – the talk resumes that he is about to be rolled. This is unlikely for several reasons. For starters, there is no successor. Nicola Willis? Chris Bishop? Simeon Brown? Mark ...
Australia, Britain and European countries should loosen budget rules to allow borrowing to fund higher defence spending, a new study by the Kiel Institute suggests. Currently, budget debt rules are forcing governments to finance increases ...
The NZCTU remains strongly committed to banning engineered stone in New Zealand and implementing better occupational health protections for all workers working with silica-containing materials. In this submission to MBIE, the NZCTU outlines that we have an opportunity to learn from Australia’s experience by implementing a full ban of engineered ...
The Prime Minister has announced a big win in trade negotiations with India.It’s huge, he told reporters. We didn't get everything we came for but we were able to agree on free trade in clothing, fabrics, car components, software, IT consulting, spices, tea, rice, and leather goods.He said that for ...
I have been trying to figure out the logic of Trump’s tariff policies and apparent desire for a global trade war. Although he does not appear to comprehend that tariffs are a tax on consumers in the country doing the tariffing, I can (sort of) understand that he may think ...
As Syria and international partners negotiate the country’s future, France has sought to be a convening power. While France has a history of influence in the Middle East, it will have to balance competing Syrian ...
One of the eternal truths about Aotearoa's economy is that we are "capital poor": there's not enough money sloshing around here to fund the expansion of local businesses, or to build the things we want to. Which gets used as an excuse for all sorts of things, like setting up ...
National held its ground until late 2023 Verion, Talbot Mills & Curia Polls (Red = Labour, Blue = National)If we remove outlier results from Curia (National Party November 2023) National started trending down in October 2024.Verion Polls (Red = Labour, Blue = National)Verian alone shows a clearer deterioration in early ...
In a recent presentation, I recommended, quite unoriginally, that governments should have a greater focus on higher-impact, lower-probability climate risks. My reasoning was that current climate model projections have blind spots, meaning we are betting ...
Daddy, are you out there?Daddy, won't you come and play?Daddy, do you not care?Is there nothing that you want to say?Songwriters: Mark Batson / Beyonce Giselle Knowles.This morning, a look at the much-maligned NZ Herald. Despised by many on the left as little more than a mouthpiece for the National ...
Employers, unions and health and safety advocates are calling for engineered stone to be banned, a day before consultation on regulations closes. On Friday the PSA lodged a pay equity claim for library assistants with the Employment Relations Authority, after the stalling of a claim lodged with six councils in ...
Long stories shortest in Aotearoa’s political economy:Christopher Luxon surprises by announcing trade deal talks with India will start next month, and include beef and dairy. Napier is set to join Whakatane, Dunedin and Westport in staging a protest march against health spending restraints hitting their hospital services. Winston Peters ...
At a time of rising geopolitical tensions and deepening global fragmentation, the Ukraine war has proved particularly divisive. From the start, the battle lines were clearly drawn: Russia on one side, Ukraine and the West ...
Here’s my selection1 of scoops, breaking news, news, analyses, deep-dives, features, interviews, Op-Eds, editorials and cartoons from around Aotearoa’s political economy on housing, climate and poverty from RNZ, 1News, The Post-$2, The Press−$, Newsroom3, NZ Herald, Stuff, BusinessDesk-$, Newsroom-$, Politik-$, NBR-$, Reuters, FT-$, WSJ-$, Bloomberg-$, New York Times-$, The Atlantic-$, ...
A listing of 26 news and opinion articles we found interesting and shared on social media during the past week: Sun, March 9, 2025 thru Sat, March 15, 2025. This week's roundup is again published by category and sorted by number of articles included in each. We are still interested ...
Max Harris and Max Rashbrooke discuss how we turn around the right wing slogans like nanny state, woke identity politics, and the inefficiency of the public sector – and how we build a progressive agenda. From Donald Trump to David Seymour, from Peter Dutton to Christopher Luxon, we are subject to a ...
The Government dominated the political agenda this week with its two-day conference pitching all manner of public infrastructure projects for Public Private Partnerships (PPPs). Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāLong stories shortest in our political economy this week: The Government ploughed ahead with offers of PPPs to pension fund managers ...
You know that it's a snake eat snake worldWe slither and serpentine throughWe all took a bite, and six thousand years laterThese apples getting harder to chewSongwriters: Shawn Mavrides.“Please be Jack Tame”, I thought when I saw it was Seymour appearing on Q&A. I’d had a guts full of the ...
So here we are at the wedding of Alexandra Vincent Martelli and David Seymour.Look at all the happy prosperous guests! How proud Nick Mowbray looks of the gift he has made of a mountain of crap plastic toys stuffed into a Cybertruck.How they drink, how they laugh, how they mug ...
Skeptical Science is partnering with Gigafact to produce fact briefs — bite-sized fact checks of trending claims. You can submit claims you think need checking via the tipline. Is waste heat from industrial activity the reason the planet is warming? Waste heat’s contribution to global warming is a small fraction of ...
Some continue to defend David Seymour on school lunches, sidestepping his errors to say:“Well the parents should pack their lunch” and/or “Kids should be grateful for free food.”One of these people is the sitting Prime Minister.So I put together a quick list of why complaint is not only appropriate - ...
“Bugger the pollsters!”WHEN EVERYBODY LIVED in villages, and every village had a graveyard, the expression “whistling past the graveyard” made more sense. Even so, it’s hard to describe the Coalition Government’s response to the latest Taxpayers’ Union/Curia Research poll any better. Regardless of whether they wanted to go there, or ...
Prof Jane Kelsey examines what the ACT party and the NZ Initiative are up to as they seek to impose on the country their hardline, right wing, neoliberal ideology. A progressive government elected in 2026 would have a huge job putting Humpty Dumpty together again and rebuilding a state that ...
See I try to make a differenceBut the heads of the high keep turning awayThere ain't no useWhen the world that you love has goneOoh, gotta make a changeSongwriters: Arapekanga Adams-Tamatea / Brad Kora / Hiriini Kora / Joel Shadbolt.Aotearoa for Sale.This week saw the much-heralded and somewhat alarming sight ...
Here’s my selection1 of scoops, breaking news, news, analyses, deep-dives, features, interviews, Op-Eds, editorials and cartoons from around Aotearoa’s political economy on housing, climate and poverty from RNZ, 1News, The Post-$2, The Press−$, Newsroom3, NZ Herald, Stuff, BusinessDesk-$, NBR-$, Reuters, FT-$, WSJ-$, Bloomberg-$, New York Times-$, The Atlantic-$, The Economist-$ ...
By international standards the New Zealand healthcare system appears satisfactory – certainly no worse generally than average. Yet it is undergoing another redisorganisation.While doing some unrelated work, I came across some international data on the healthcare sector which seemed to contradict my – and the conventional wisdom’s – view of ...
When Russian President Vladimir Putin launched his full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, he knew that he was upending Europe’s security order. But this was more of a tactical gambit than a calculated strategy ...
Mountain Tui is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.Over the last year, I’ve been warning about Luxon’s pitch to privatise our public assets.He had told reporters in October that nothing was off the cards:Schools, hospitals, prisons, and ...
When ASPI’s Cyclone Tracy: 50 Years On was published last year, it wasn’t just a historical reflection; it was a warning. Just months later, we are already watching history repeat itself. We need to bake ...
1. Why was school lunch provider The Libelle Group in the news this week?a. Grand Winner in Pie of The Yearb. Scored a record 108% on YELP c. Bought by Oravida d. Went into liquidation2. What did our Prime Minister offer prospective investors at his infrastructure investment jamboree?a. The Libelle ...
South Korea has suspended new downloads of DeepSeek, and it was were right to do so. Chinese tech firms operate under the shadow of state influence, misusing data for surveillance and geopolitical advantage. Any country ...
Previous big infrastructure PPPs such as Transmission Gully were fiendishly complicated to negotiate, generated massive litigation and were eventually rewritten anyway. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / Getty ImagesLong stories shortest: The Government’s international investment conference ignores the facts that PPPs cost twice as much as vanilla debt-funded public infrastructure, often take ...
Woolworths has proposed a major restructure of its New Zealand store operating model, leaving workers worried their hours and pay could be cut. Public servants are being asked how productive their office is, how much they use AI, and whether they’re overloaded with meetings as part of a “census”. An ...
Robert Kaplan’s book Waste Land: A World in Permanent Crisis paints a portrait of civilisation in flux. Drawing insights from history, literature and art, he examines the effect of modern technology, globalisation and urbanisation on ...
Sexuality - Strong and warm and wild and freeSexuality - Your laws do not apply to meSexuality - Don't threaten me with miserySexuality - I demand equalitySong: Billy Bragg.First, thank you to everyone who took part in yesterday’s survey. Some questions worked better than others, but I found them interesting, ...
Hi,I just got back from a week in Japan thanks to the power of cheap flights and years of accumulated credit card points.The last time I was in Japan the government held a press conference saying they might take legal action against me and Netflix, so there was a little ...
The podcast above of the weekly ‘Hoon’ webinar for paying subscribers on Thursday night features co-hosts & talking about the week’s news with regular and special guests, including: on the week in geopolitics, including Donald Trump’s wrecking of the post-WW II political landscape; andHealth Coalition Aotearoa co-chair Lisa ...
Hi,I just got back from a short trip to Japan, mostly spending time in Tokyo.I haven’t been there since we shot Dark Tourist back in 2017 — and that landed us in a bit of hot water with the Japanese government.I am glad to report I was not thrown into ...
I’ve been on Substack for almost 8 months now.It’s been good in terms of the many great individuals that populate its space. So much variety and intelligence and humour and depth.I joined because someone suggested I should ‘start a Substack,’ whatever that meant.So I did.Turning on payments seemed like the ...
Open access notables Would Adding the Anthropocene to the Geologic Time Scale Matter?, McCarthy et al., AGU Advances:The extraordinary fossil fuel-driven outburst of consumption and production since the mid-twentieth century has fundamentally altered the way the Earth System works. Although humans have impacted their environment for millennia, justification for ...
Australia should buy equipment to cheaply and temporarily convert military transport aircraft into waterbombers. On current planning, the Australian Defence Force will have a total of 34 Chinook helicopters and Hercules airlifters. They should be ...
Indonesia’s government has slashed its counterterrorism (CT) budgets, despite the persistent and evolving threat of violent extremism. Australia can support regional CT efforts by filling this funding void. Reducing funding to the National Counterterrorism Agency ...
A ballot for a single Member's Bill was held today, and the following bill was drawn: Resource Management (Prohibition on Extraction of Freshwater for On-selling) Amendment Bill (Debbie Ngarewa-Packer) The bill does exactly what it says on the label, and would effectively end the rapacious water-bottling industry ...
Twilight Time Lighthouse Cuba, Wigan Street, Wellington, Sunday 6 April, 5:30pm for 6pm start. Twilight Time looks at the life and work of Desmond Ball, (1947-2016), a barefooted academic from ‘down under’ who was hailed by Jimmy Carter as “the man who saved the world”, as he proved the fallacy ...
Foreign aid is being slashed across the Global North, nowhere more so than in the United States. Within his first month back in the White House, President Donald Trump dismantled the US Agency for International ...
Nicola Willis has proposed new procurement rules that unions say will lead to pay cuts for already low-paid workers in cleaning, catering and security services that are contracted by government. The Crimes (Theft by Employer) Amendment Bill passed its third reading with support from all the opposition parties and NZ ...
Most KP readers will not know that I was a jazz DJ in Chicago and Washington DC while in grad school in the early and mid 1980s. In DC I joined WPFW as a grave shift host, then a morning drive show host (a show called Sui Generis, both for ...
Long stories shortest: The IMF says a capital gains tax or land tax would improve real economic growth and fix the budget. GDP is set to be smaller by 2026 than it was in 2023. Compass is flying in school lunches from Australia. 53% of National voters say the new ...
Last year in October I wrote “Where’s The Opposition?”. I was exasperated at the relative quiet of the Green Party, Labour and Te Pati Māori (TPM), as the National led Coalition ticked off a full bingo card of the Atlas Network playbook.1To be fair, TPM helped to energise one of ...
This is a re-post from The Climate BrinkGood data visualizations can help make climate change more visceral and understandable. Back in 2016 Ed Hawkins published a “climate spiral” graph that ended up being pretty iconic – it was shown at the opening ceremony of the Olympics that year – and ...
An agreement to end the war in Ukraine could transform Russia’s relations with North Korea. Moscow is unlikely to reduce its cooperation with Pyongyang to pre-2022 levels, but it may become more selective about areas ...
This week, the Government is hosting a grand event aimed at trying to interest big foreign capital players in financing capital works in New Zealand, particularly its big rural motorway programme. Financing vs funding: a quick explainer The key word in the sentence above is financing. It is important ...
In a month’s time, the Right Honourable Winston Peters will be celebrating his 80th birthday. Good for him. On the evidence though, his current war on “wokeness” looks like an old man’s cranky complaint that the ancient virtues of grit and know-how are sadly lacking in the youth of today. ...
As noted, early March has been about moving house, and I have had little chance to partake in all things internet. But now that everything is more or less sorted, I can finally give a belated report on my visit to the annual Regent Booksale (28th February and 1st March). ...
Information operations Australia has banned cybersecurity software Kaspersky from government use because of risks of espionage, foreign interference and sabotage. The Department of Home Affairs said use of Kaspersky products posed an unacceptable security ...
The StrategistBy Linus Cohen, Astrid Young and Alice Wai
One of the best understood tropes of screen drama is the scene where the beloved family dog is barking incessantly and cannot be calmed. Finally, somebody asks: What is it, girl? Has someone fallen down a well? Is there trouble at the old John Key place?One is reminded of this ...
The ’ndrangheta, the Calabrian mafia, plays a significant role in the global cocaine trade and is deeply entrenched in Australia, influencing the cocaine trade and engaging in a variety of illicit activities. A range of ...
The Green Party stands in support of volunteer firefighters petitioning the Government to step up and change legislation to provide volunteers the same ACC coverage and benefits as their paid counterparts. ...
Living Strong, Aging Well There is much discussion around the health of our older New Zealanders and how we can age well. In reality, the delivery of health services accounts for only a relatively small percentage of health outcomes as we age. Significantly, dry warm housing, nutrition, exercise, social connection, ...
Shane Jones’ display on Q&A showed how out of touch he and this Government are with our communities and how in sync they are with companies with little concern for people and planet. ...
Labour does not support the private ownership of core infrastructure like schools, hospitals and prisons, which will only see worse outcomes for Kiwis. ...
The Green Party is disappointed the Government voted down Hūhana Lyndon’s member’s Bill, which would have prevented further alienation of Māori land through the Public Works Act. ...
The Labour Party will support Chloe Swarbrick’s member’s bill which would allow sanctions against Israel for its illegal occupation of the Palestinian Territories. ...
The Government’s new procurement rules are a blatant attack on workers and the environment, showing once again that National’s priorities are completely out of touch with everyday Kiwis. ...
With Labour and Te Pāti Māori’s official support, Opposition parties are officially aligned to progress Green Party co-leader Chlöe Swarbrick’s Member’s Bill to sanction Israel for its unlawful presence in Palestine. ...
Te Pāti Māori extends our deepest aroha to the 500 plus Whānau Ora workers who have been advised today that the govt will be dismantling their contracts. For twenty years , Whānau Ora has been helping families, delivering life-changing support through a kaupapa Māori approach. It has built trust where ...
Labour welcomes Simeon Brown’s move to reinstate a board at Health New Zealand, bringing the destructive and secretive tenure of commissioner Lester Levy to an end. ...
This morning’s announcement by the Health Minister regarding a major overhaul of the public health sector levels yet another blow to the country’s essential services. ...
New Zealand First has introduced a Member’s Bill that will ensure employment decisions in the public service are based on merit and not on forced woke ‘Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion’ targets. “This Bill would put an end to the woke left-wing social engineering and diversity targets in the public sector. ...
Police have referred 20 offenders to Destiny Church-affiliated programmes Man Up and Legacy as ‘wellness providers’ in the last year, raising concerns that those seeking help are being recruited into a harmful organisation. ...
Te Pāti Māori welcomes the resignation of Richard Prebble from the Waitangi Tribunal. His appointment in October 2024 was a disgrace- another example of this government undermining Te Tiriti o Waitangi by appointing a former ACT leader who has spent his career attacking Māori rights. “Regardless of the reason for ...
Police Minister Mark Mitchell is avoiding accountability by refusing to answer key questions in the House as his Government faces criticism over their dangerous citizen’s arrest policy, firearm reform, and broken promises to recruit more police. ...
The number of building consents issued under this Government continues to spiral, taking a toll on the infrastructure sector, tradies, and future generations of Kiwi homeowners. ...
The Green Party is calling on the Prime Minister to rule out joining the AUKUS military pact in any capacity following the scenes in the White House over the weekend. ...
The Green Party is appalled by the Government’s plan to disestablish Resource Teachers of Māori (RTM) roles, a move that takes another swing at kaupapa Māori education. ...
The Government’s levies announcement is a step in the right direction, but they must be upfront about who will pay its new infrastructure levies and ensure that first-home buyers are protected from hidden costs. ...
The Government’s levies announcement is a step in the right direction, but they must be upfront about who will pay its new infrastructure levies and ensure that first-home buyers are protected from hidden costs. ...
After months of mana whenua protecting their wāhi tapu, the Green Party welcomes the pause of works at Lake Rotokākahi and calls for the Rotorua Lakes Council to work constructively with Tūhourangi and Ngāti Tumatawera on the pathway forward. ...
New Zealand First continues to bring balance, experience, and commonsense to Government. This week we've made progress on many of our promises to New Zealand.Winston representing New ZealandWinston Peters is overseas this week, with stops across the Middle East and North Asia. Winston's stops include Saudi Arabia, the ...
Opinion: I was too young to remember, but when my father heard I was researching public opinions on gene technologies, he recalled a television interview that became known as ‘Corngate’. John Campbell put the then-Prime Minister Helen Clark on the spot about the suspected release of genetically modified corn seed, ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra Peter Dutton, when he gets on his favoured ground of security, too often goes for the quick hit, and frequently over-reaches. His suggestion of running a possible referendum to facilitate the removal of bad ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Marika Sosnowski, Postdoctoral research fellow, The University of Melbourne When a ceasefire in the war between Hamas and Israel finally came into effect on January 19, the world breathed a collective sigh of relief. However, that ceasefire agreement, and its associated ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Marika Sosnowski, Postdoctoral research fellow, The University of Melbourne When a ceasefire in the war between Hamas and Israel finally came into effect on January 19, the world breathed a collective sigh of relief. However, that ceasefire agreement, and its associated ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Marika Sosnowski, Postdoctoral research fellow, The University of Melbourne When a ceasefire in the war between Hamas and Israel finally came into effect on January 19, the world breathed a collective sigh of relief. However, that ceasefire agreement, and its associated ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra Next week’s budget will have cost-of-living assistance that will be meaningful and substantial but “responsible”, Treasurer Jim Chalmers has said. In a Tuesday speech framing the budget Chalmers said, “it will be a responsible ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra The Greens have heaped a lot of pressure on the government during this term, from issues of the environment, housing, and Medicare, to the war in the Middle East. With the polls close to a ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Gabrielle Meagher, Professor Emerita, School of Society, Communication and Culture, Macquarie University On Monday, an ABC’s Four Corners investigation reported shocking cases of abuse and neglect in Australian childcare centres. This included examples of children being sexually abused, restrained for hours in ...
By Caleb Fotheringham, RNZ Pacific journalist Papua New Guinea being declared a Christian nation may offer the impression that the country will improve, but it is only “an illusion”, according to a Catholic priest in the country. Last week, the PNG Parliament amended the nation’s constitution, introducing a declaration in ...
Asia Pacific Report A national Palestinian advocacy group has called on the Aotearoa New Zealand government to immediately condemn Israel for its resumption today of “genocidal attacks” on the almost 2 million Palestinians trapped in the besieged Gaza enclave. Media reports said that more than 230 people had been killed ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Adam Cohen, Senior Lecturer, University of Technology Sydney The National Rugby League has recently made headlines for trying to crack the American sporting landscape by hosting matches in Las Vegas. But the NRL’s great rival, the Australian Football League (AFL), has been ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By John L. Hopkins, Associate Professor of Management, Swinburne University of Technology The reality of shorter working hours could be one step closer for many Australians, pending the outcome of the federal election. The Greens, who could control crucial cross bench votes in ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Nial Wheate, Professor, School of Natural Sciences, Macquarie University areeya_ann/Shutterstock From May 1, the oral contraceptive Slinda (drospirerone) will be listed on the Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme (PBS). This means the price will drop for the more than 100,000 Australian women who ...
Taxpayers’ Union Investigations Coordinator Rhys Hurley said: “Wellington commuters should be fur-ious that KiwiRail is prioritising feel-good pet projects while services go to the dogs.” ...
Analysis by Keith Rankin. Keith Rankin, trained as an economic historian, is a retired lecturer in Economics and Statistics. He lives in Auckland, New Zealand. As most of us appreciate, there is a whole geopolitical world that overlays the formal political world of about 200 ‘nation states’ (aka ‘polities’). Geopolitical ...
Opinion-Analysis – by Keith Rankin. Keith Rankin, trained as an economic historian, is a retired lecturer in Economics and Statistics. He lives in Auckland, New Zealand. Former ambassador Phil Goff is the latest (so far) and (probably) the least of many ‘statesmen’ who have invoked Munich and the ‘resolute’ Winston ...
Staff were told today of the latest proposed job cuts which could result in the net loss of 64 permanent roles, plus 69 fixed term roles which are not being renewed beyond 1 September, for a total reduction of 133 roles. These are spread across all ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Kamil Zuber, Senior Industry Research Fellow, Future Industries Institute, University of South Australia ShowRecMedia/Shutterstock It’s annoying to open your dishwasher after the cycle is finished only to find half of the dishes still wet. Instead of being able to stack them ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Denise Varney, Professor of Theatre Studies, The University of Melbourne Pia Johnson/MTC The Removalists was first performed in 1971 at La Mama Theatre, Carlton, by the Australian Performing Group, an ensemble of young graduates, artists and friends. A beacon of the ...
Whether by choice or circumstance, a growing number of people are leaving ‘real jobs’ for more flexible modes of employment. Frances Cook spoke to one such self-employed slashie about how she’s made it work for her. Beth Vickers never planned to run her own business. She had a solid, stable career, ...
Corey Hebberd, Kaiwhakahaere Matua of Rangitāne o Wairau, presented to the Finance and Expenditure Select Committee today, outlining the Bill’s serious failings and the devastating impact it will have on iwi, councils, and communities, with a particular ...
Every worker deserves a wage they can live on. That remains out of reach for many. On April 1st, the minimum wage will rise by just 35 cents. This is effectively a pay cut for thousands of workers as it is a below inflation adjustment. ...
The US forcing Ukraine into a peace deal that favours Putin would set a disastrous precedent "unacceptable" to New Zealand, an international relations expert says. ...
ANALYSIS:By Matthew Sussex, Australian National University Has any nation squandered its diplomatic capital, plundered its own political system, attacked its partners and supplicated itself before its far weaker enemies as rapidly and brazenly as Donald Trump’s America? The fiery Oval Office meeting between Trump and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky ...
In the final episode of Bryn & Ku’s Singles Club, the pair travel to Thames to get some wisdom from those who have been on the dating scene since long before they were born.Bryn & Ku’s Singles Club is a new documentary series for The Spinoff following ...
Blisters, sunburn and tinnitus be damned, Wellington needs Homegrown Festival – or at least something to replace it.The mood of the day at Homegrown was set early and forcefully: “local heroes” Dartz had a message for the afternoon early birds wasting no time in getting thrash punk through the ...
Columbia Journalism School Freedom of the press — a bedrock principle of American democracy — is under threat in the United States. Here at Columbia University Graduate School of Journalism we are witnessing and experiencing an alarming chill. We write to affirm our commitment to supporting and exercising First Amendment ...
There may be a lot of acronyms, but caring for an electric vehicle, and getting the most out of it, can be very simple.You’ve brought home a shiny new treat. It’s got two darling little ears, four rubbery feet, multiple glowing eyes and oh! – no tail at the ...
A new report suggests a focus on export industries will provide the best opportunity for growth in an expanding Māori economy.The Māori economy is at a turning point, with rapid growth, a diversifying asset base and untapped export potential creating new opportunities. But despite nearly doubling in five years ...
“If Brooke van Velden is genuine when she calls for an evidence-based approach to this issue, then she must support a full ban on engineered stone products,” said NZCTU President Richard Wagstaff. ...
As part of our series exploring how New Zealanders live and our relationship with money, a ‘broke’ volunteer and former policy adviser explains how he gets by. Want to be part of The Cost of Being? Fill out the questionnaire here.Gender: Man. Age: 31. Ethnicity: Mixed ethnicity. Role: Unemployed (ex-policy ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Randall Wayth, SKA-Low Senior Commissioning Scientist and Adjunct Associate Professor, Curtin Institute of Radio Astronomy, Curtin University The first image from an early working version of the SKA-Low telescope, showing around 85 galaxies.SKAO Part of the world’s biggest mega-science facility – ...
THE REVOLUTION IS HERE
Especially in America .While the Trump campaign was gathering momentum i watched and i thought this is good because for sure he will be the 'spanner in the works ' , but brother was that an understatement !!!!!!!
Before Trump while the Biden establishment meandered through a year and a half or so of genocide enabling for Israel and obviously for its own racist maniacs and even as the bodies of innocents grew ever higher daily you got the impression many didnt even notice and mind bogglingly many knew even here on TS and forgave them .
Its a chilly overcast morn where i am with a promise of blustery rain an imo theres nothing like a dose of realism on such a monday morning wakey wakey
So h. clark/labour took away birthright rights in nz ..(doing what everyone is now horrified about because trump is doing it..)
Labour needs to promise to restore those rights…to right that clear wrong/mistake on the part of h.clark/2006 labour…
And while they are at it they can overturn the legislation enacted by Clark/labour that entrenched child poverty…
This is the economic apartheid inherent in the working for families act ..
..which differentiates between (in Clarks words) the 'deserving' and the 'undeserving' families..
In that working families ..the 'deserving'.. receive that family support ..
Whereas those families who (for whatever reasons) are not in paid work…and are thus 'undeserving'..
..and get no family support from this act…
This cruel/unjust reality would have been felt particularly hard by the recent waves of fired workers..
Not only is their work income ended..they get a double kick in the guts when they realize that now they are the 'undeserving'…
..and their family support is also taken away from them ..
How can anyone be ok with such blatant crueltyinjustice done to the poorest/workers in nz ..?
Labour need to promise to end that discrimination..
..to right that wrong..
Hi Phil, can you expand a little on the birthright rights that were removed plz?
Sure…we used to be what trump is now going to end… namely if you are born in nz…you are a nz citizen..
Clark/labour removed that right in 2006..
..and this is now being highlighted by the 19 yr old born/educated here…to parents who are not here legally…is to be deported to India…a country he has never been to/does not speak the language..
This is inhumane ..in any language. .
This 19 yr old is a nz citizen…to my mind ..
And must be allowed to stay in the country of his birth ..
..and birthright for all must be restored. .
Does he have a birth certificate? I suspect he doesn't if his parents are here illegally since the birth would probably not have been regisgtered . Would that make a difference?
Ahh, thanks Phil, I get it now. I was thinking of Birthright the charity.
FWIW, I agree with you about the young fella facing deportation.
Just to be a bit curly, what if he was the child of parents who, for example, were guilty of, say, migrant exploitation and facing deportation?
The 14 th Amendment in the USA States that anyone born in the USA is automatically a citizen. Trump would have to cancel the Amendment which needs I think 2 thirds majority +++
The whole birth rights thing is a problem because it invites people to gain an advantage by being sneaky or just plane dishonest. That said give the boy residency send his parents home.
I know a successful young couple who intend to have there children over sees solely because they get dual citizenship.
I tend to agree. This young man should have residency.
But if someone has a baby while here on a working holiday visa for instance, I can't see the rationale for the child being a resident. Are there issues with the parent’s nationality and that country giving residency to the child?
England does not have birthright citizenship. One of my nephews was born in England while his parents were there working. They had to register him in New Zealand for New Zealand citizenship when they returned here and he has no right to UK citizenship or residency.
Was the registration a formality? ie the child was guaranteed citizenship, because the parents were NZ citizens, so long as the paper work was done?
I think thinking the other way around. If an English woman had a child in NZ while on a WHV, does the child automatically have UK citizenship?
Up until recently – Yes. I'm unsure of the current situation. But as both my parents were from UK in the 1920's and I was born in NZ in the 1940's, I can apply for a British passport.
https://www.gov.uk/apply-citizenship-british-parent
It's not automatic, you have to apply for UK citizenship and meet certain criteria.
Not just the UK, applies in most countries where citizenship is sought after.
so what happens if a child is born in NZ to UK parents and the UK refuses citizenship?
If a child would be otherwise be stateless, they are NZ citizens by birth (Citizenship Act 1977 No 61 (as at 26 November 2024), Public Act 6 Citizenship by birth – New Zealand Legislation).
That said, the child would automatically qualify for UK citizenship at birth if either parent was a UK citizen and they were able to pass on their citizenship (similar rules to NZ's citizenship by descent) – Apply for citizenship if you have a British parent: You were born on or after 1 July 2006 – GOV.UK.
I'm not sure that Australia does either. Our son, daugter in law and their eldest son (our grandson) moved to Australia in 2004, their second son was born in 2005 in Melbourne and had was registered as a New Zealand citizen. I also can't be absolutely sure, but I believe he is now eligible for Australian citizenship.
I like that for federal positions in oz you have to only have Australian citizenship. You have to actively renounce other citizen rights.
Thanks guess they're in for a surprise then , !
The 'rub' here is that there are many young people ….born here….grown up here..
..but who have this hanging over them/their lives…
..this must be put right…
I agree. So draw a line under it from today. Everyone who was born here before this time gets assessed and granted citizenship if the situation warrants it, but going forward it depends on the circumstances.
Legislation restoring birthright in nz…and guaranteeing citizenship to those born here since 2006…
.. would be the simplest way to fix this…
please explain why someone on a WHV should have their baby born here become a NZ citizen.
That could be put down to luck thru accident of birth..
There is a bit of it about..
The mother of my son is German..
..so he has birthright rights here..and in Germany…and in the e.u…
..and to further cite your example…his mother was here on holiday…when/where she met me..
"So draw a line under it from today".
We drew the line under it back in 2005. At that time we said that anyone born here before 1/1/2006 was a citizen. Anyone born after that date was a citizen only if at least one of their parents was a citizen or had permanent residency.
Why re-open it? Because we have a case that we don't like? What will we do in 2045 when in comes up again? Simply decide to start again and grant everyone born here between 2025 and 2045 gets retroactive citizenship in the same way as you appear to be proposing for the period between 2006 and 2025?
Sorry but this is the law and has been so since 2006. It is the hard cases like this for which the Ministerial discretion applies. If the Minister won't apply it we can complain but someone has to choose. We can't just say that we shouldn't have any laws because we get the rare problem occasionally.
You go on to say "Everyone who was born here before this time gets assessed and granted citizenship if the situation warrants it" followed by "going forward it depends on the circumstances". Can you tell me the difference between these statements? All you appear to be saying is that we may or may not give citizenship in either situation.
Personally I would allow the boy to stay but deport the parents who have been overstayers for at least 20 years. Why should they be allowed to continue here?
fair point. I do think periodic amnesties serve NZ's interests. Twenty years is a long time in a community, lots of ties there that matter.
Agree with the periodic amnesty idea..
'cos really… people who have the motivation to become economic refugees…
..to face all the challenges of such a life..
..and usually for the opportunity to make a better life for their families..
.. aren't these the sort of people we want here..?
..and isn't that what we all are..?
..the descendants of economic refugees ..
..who came here for those self-same better-life reasons..?
How can we be churlish now…about others doing what brought us here..?
Yes .!…to amnesties …
I agree with Alwyn. We have drawn a line under it.
Latest:
https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/national/542071/new-zealand-born-teen-s-deportation-to-india-paused-at-last-minute
What have the parents been doing here occupation-wise over the last 20 years?
If Penk is really that stupid, I have to admit I expected better from him. Someone ought to give him a bit of a talking to. Obviously anyone born in Aotearoa is an Aoteoroan naturally. If the state can't get real, it becomes disposable. So common sense must prevail.
That said, the state of NZ hasn't featured common sense much during my adult life. There did seem to be a semblance of it when I was young, but clueless dork syndrome has been prevalent for a long time. I agree there have been fairly brief periods when a semblance of competence has also shown up, as if to give us hope for the future…
I agree for the son. It is sensible. I note though he was issued with an Indian passport so it seems as though he is not stateless, see Craig's post:
The parents may have 'cooked the goose for the son', unfortunately. By not regularising their residency it has affected him. What were the reasons that their applications were declined in the 2010s?
Has he a right to leave but then apply for a work permit /residency for himself?
It is hard.
Then I would feel more sympathy if it can be shown that the parents have been working/paying taxes and not claiming benefits over the years but is this enough to knock out the basic illegality of overstaying.
Agree with the ‘clueless dork syndrome has been prevalent for a long time.’ Prime examples in this case are INZ not following up the refusal of work and other visas applied for in the 2010s.
So we can be infinitely scathing about what Australia's doing to the 501s, yet we do the exact same thing to this young man.
Yes..the hypocrisies are rife here..
..and how can those who voted for this aberration not be shifting uneasily in their seats…?
And there is an economic argument also to be made here..
In that we as a country have invested in the education etc of these young people….and just as they are about to become contributers to the economy we throw them out..
But the strongest arguments for birthright restoration must be against the limbo these young new Zealanders find themselves trapped in..
This is a cruel/unjust life for them..and all through no faults of their own…
They are why birthright rights must be restored…
I agree totally with your argument for the son. I am not sure if he holds Indian citizenship as well?
I don't see that at present the parents can hang a 'remaining in NZ argument' off an argument for a right for him to remain because he was born here.
As always the truism 'hard cases make bad law' applies.
Is everyone in work?
The problem seems difficult to solve, exacerbated by lax follow-up of the visas that have been granted*, and overstaying. For instance in the Kumar family temporary work permits were declined in 2010. So why was enforcement action to remove not taken then?
NZ makes a rod for our own backs by not doing this follow-up. Not all of the lack of followup can be laid at the door of staffing pressures from the current govt. Then we get the tugging at the heartstrings situations such as here. Also while the current son can recieve an eduation to secondary school level as an overstayer this ability stops then and he is not eligible to go to University. We may possibly be seeing other under educated though capable people here in NZ and that is a waste.
*See below in this article.
https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/indonz/496521/i-don-t-have-a-right-to-dream-teen-overstayer-faces-a-life-of-uncertainty
The Australian 501 pertains to failing of a character test, so how’s that “the exact same thing” in this single individual NZ case?
People getting sent to places where they have no connection to. So apart from the abject hypocrisy, it's in fact worse.
His parents surely would have a connection to India? One doesn't lose a connection to a place where one is born & brought up in the time of 20 or so years, otherwise this would also happen to NZers who have spent their significant parts of their lives overseas. The overstaying argument has no connection to this.
I'm not talking about the young chap's parents.
We've being 501ing PI citizens who were born in NZ, and may have never been to the Island they came from for a long time. The same issue of unsupported, possibly violent, young men being dropped into a country they know nothing about happens in those Islands. The hypocricy is ours.
Yes, the hypocrisy is ours, and even more so given your example.
Why did this legislation come about? I may be completely wrong here but I vaguely recall that it might have been in relation to not nessecarily a scam, but a movement of sorts, of couples or individuals moving here for a very short while just so their child could get citizenship and the parents later being eligible for the family reunification scheme. The US rings a bell, of course it was a fairly expensive exercise so I imagine it was a bit out of touch for those from poorer countries. There was also a no fly rule which may even still exist if the mother was within 4 weeks os birthing. Please correct me if I’m wrong on any of this. What is being forced on this young man is cruel and harsh and I don’t support it at all.
It was introduced because a significant number were rorting birthright citizenship.
Though I suspect nowhere near as many, as our education for residency scam run by tertiary institutions, or the temporary visa employer scams.
Stay long enough to have a child in NZ. Then push for residency on the basis their NZ born child will be on their own, here.
Agree. This seems actually to be what has happened here but as often happens the results fall heavily on those who are the least infringing ie the son.
The parents have applied and been turned down twice in the 2010s and have just stayed on…….
Grandstanding is the NZF way.
But it occurs in a nation with poor access to dentists and poor dental care has wider health consequences. In a nation with declining access to primary health care.
It does not develop good national policy.
https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/ldr/542106/winston-peters-says-whangarei-fluoridation-mandate-a-despotic-soviet-era-disgrace
Three nations have compulsory fluoridation.
Singapore, Ireland and now Enzed.
Singapore – 0.4-0.6 mg per litre from 1956
Ireland, first 1.0 to half the population, then 0.8 to all. 1960. Now it is 0.6-0.8, target 0.7.
Facts. China, India have high levels in their water, so does half the UK (the rest gets fluoridation, if councils seek it).
Germany – use of iodine salt with fluoride as well as fluoride tablets and washes is strongly encouraged by their Ministry of Health – leading to a remarkable drop in caries prevalence in Germany since the early 1990ies.
Switzerland, Austria and France also fluoridate table salt.
In 2011 the U.S. DHHS and EPA proposed to reduce the recommended level of fluoride in drinking water to the lowest end of the current range, 0.7 milligrams per liter of water (mg/L), from the previous recommended maximum of 0.7 to 1.2 mg/L in recognition of the increase in sources of fluoride such as fluoridated toothpastes and mouthwashes.
Israel demonstrates the problems of politicians acting in ways that harm public health.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_fluoridation_by_country
New Zealand
We have 0.7 and 1.0 milligrams per liter, this is now generally seen as too high.
If we continue with a national standard we have two choices – added to water as now or added to salt (and also promote fluoride mouth washes).
For mine, if water we should reduce it to a lower range 0.5-0.7.
And if we allow opt out, supply fluoride mouth washes and add fluoride to iodised salt for those in regions that do this.
The "Cookers" packing out council meetings, to intimidate councilors, and cherry picked "evidence" plus endless repetition of fairly obvious pseudo science from the USA, notably on community Facebook pages, and mobbing character assisination of anyone who questions them, shows they don't really want a referendum of well informed citizens.
The same tactics as the anti-vaccers!
And MAGA!
Why bother dropping levels? I remember the dental nurse/murder house on Willis St, where they trucked us in to get out little teeth drilled by learner dental nurses, with no anaesthetic. My son, born after fluoridation, had no fillings at the age of 20, and no evidence of fluorodosis (as evidenced by flecked teeth).
Like immunisation, water supply fluoridisation benefits those who are poor, and likely to be unable to afford washed, etc the most.
Fancy mouth washes, etc.
Because the 0.7-1.0 is one of the highest (added to water) rates in the world.
The two other nations making it compulsory, have lower rates.
The US has lowered its rate to 0.7.
At above 1.5, there are neurotoxity impacts (thus 1.5 is the WHO maximum).
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_fluoridation
The laternatice
Hmmm, I've read the 'neurotoxicity' science previously. Much of it is based on comparing individuals who come from areas where water is naturally low (F 1ppm and under) and areas, such as those with granite, where F may be 2-3 x higher, if not more.
The US Toxicology Service analysed the published literature and says 'The NTP monograph concluded, with moderate confidence, that higher levels of fluoride exposure, such as drinking water containing more than 1.5 milligrams of fluoride per liter, are associated with lower IQ in children.'
Confounding factors:. Research reviewed are population studies, not science experiments. 1. heavy metals which also affect brain development may be in the naturally-high F water sources. None of which were tested for such contaminants. Iodine deficiency also causes brain retardation. 2. Poor-quality high F drinking water occurs mostly in poor rural areas, associated with economic and social deprivation. A good population study can manage this by pairing each low and high factor person with someone of similar economic and social background. But none of the studies did. 3. A standard IQ test has a huge economic/cultural bias.
Yesterday, I happened upon a council-run 'free' supply of water without added fluoride or chlorine – it's towards the hospital side of Papaioea Park in Palmy North.
https://www.pncc.govt.nz/Parks-recreation/Parks-and-reserves/Papaioea-Park
Recent analysis of water sampled from nine city sites found fluoride at 0.63 – 0.82 ppm.
https://www.pncc.govt.nz/Services/Water/Drinking-water
I should drink more water – fluoride isn't a personal concern.
For goodness sake. Palmy has an excellent water supply, from the rainfall on the hills, or from a 200m deep clean bore in Highbury and surrounds. Fluoride has NO effect on adult cognition. The council does us proud. At my age, (and, I'm guessing, yours), keeping teeth intact is vital. Fluoridated water helps, a lot.
And you'll have to give up drinking tea, which is a significant source of fluoride.
The irony is that Peters looks, talks, and acts like he’s a long-serving member of the Politburo; I even detect a slight Russian slur in his speech at times – those were the days when men worn suits & ties.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Politburo_of_the_Communist_Party_of_the_Soviet_Union#Ethnicity,_age_and_sex
Lacks the furry hat.
Not sure what it is about gNActoids with their trying to be as punitive and nasty as possible – just to show us all how tuff they are. Pathetic is probably the best way to describe them – especially since in the case of the Dalit, they've put their want to be cruel, egotistical wankers out their for all to see.
I had hopes that Penk was going to be one of the better gNats. (Alongside people such as Finlayson, at a pinch – Bolger , McKinnon – who was sincere in his concern for rehabilitation of prisoners rather than simply punishing them then shoving them out on the street to a life of recidivism).
Unfortunately he (the Penkster) is proving to be pretty bloody useless – using all the usual excuses – such as the ill-defined "Operational Matter". Was it maybe a bit of drama he craved, or maybe just that he was a useless tit.
Phil Ure is correct in my mind. Daman Kumar is as much a NZer as youse all and moi. Is, was, and always will be. He certainly meets the 'good character' test, which if applied equitably, would see the likes of Peter Thiel deported to whichever country he'd bought citizenship from.
Quite a few moons ago, it used to be that even if one was born on a vessel whose destination was lil 'ole NuZull that punches above its weight, he/she/it was a NZer – and that's as it should be Not sure what H1 did, or why, but I'd give Her the benefit of the doubt and suggest she might have had Her reasons at the time.
We need to simplify things rather than keep trying to complicate everything – just to show how clever we are.
Similarly, thankfully those that pay taxes here do, and should get voting rights – if only after a couple of election cycles which would show their commitment to the country. (Apologies to a TDB contributor @ Castro – who, it seems to me just doesn't really like Indians. But he wouldn't be alone – there's an entire Munstry staffed in senior positions by people from the Empire – sometimes parachuted in – who think the same. And no amounting a spreadsheet risk analysis bullshit that told us that's not how they did things will alter that.
Yes….. yet another example of enshittification/crapification.
Penk: If you don't want to be seen as a complete R Sole, give it a rest and don't buy into your colleagues' Trumpian bullshit ideology. This whole sad story has not served the gNats image too well. Too bad, never mind!
(Apologies if this is a double post – previous submission produced "Site can't be reached")
out their for all to see.
*out THERE for all
And no amounting a spreadsheet
* and no amount of risk analysis spreadsheet bullhit
(Shoot me)
What, me worry? Are our coalition of the 'wealthier-by-the-day and sorted' bovvered?
Imho, our CoC is making a bigger pig's breakfast than the usual Nat-led lot. Don't know how much is deliberate, but if govt ministers learn from their mistakes, then the cabinet should be full of self-taught geniuses by now.
This lot have wilfully crashed the economy in such a ham fisted way it's hard not to notice.
Key was clever about it, this lot are in an Atlas funded fire sale mode flooding the zone and they're not done yet.
Part of the cocs Got To Go campaign?
Britain’s official state propaganda arm is right behind this latest show of insane jingoism….