Nine years is more than enough time for any administration to achieve their policy goals.
Even in 6 years a less common two term government can enact a lot. And if a lot of what they enact is unpopular, we can remove them before they can enact (and embed), even more unpopular legislation
We need more youth engagement in our democracy, not less.
Moving to a 4 year term will disenfranchise young people even more than our electoral system does now.
If a young person turns 18 just after an election, they will not be able to vote for the first time until they are 22.
If a four year term is enacted it must also enact young people's demand to ‘Make It 16’.
Make It 16 is a youth-led, non-partisan campaign aiming to uplift and strengthen youth voices by lowering the voting age to 16. We believe 16 and 17-year-olds are just as affected by government decisions as people over 18
P.S. As most wars are over in four years. A four year term government could take us into a war and not have to account for their actions for four long years. Four years is way too long for New Zealanders to be dying and killing in an upopular war, without democratic oversight.
If there was a war that NZ were to be involved then that is for the government and parliament, who have been democratically elected by the people of this country.
It is unlikely that NZ would become involved with the war in the Ukraine. But worst case scenario, we certainly won’t be on the side of Russia.
Should things go to custard in the Middle East, which I doubt, NZ is most likely to be neutral or on the side of NATO.
….As most wars are over in four years. A four year term government could take us into a war and not have to account for their actions for four long years. Four years is way too long for New Zealanders to be dying and killing in an upopular war, without democratic oversight…..
…..If there was a war that NZ were to be involved then that is for the government and parliament, who have been democratically elected by the people of this country.
…..A steadier supply of men was needed to keep a fighting force in the field, and in July 1940 the choice of whether or not to sign up for war ceased to exist. The introduction of conscription meant that every man between 19 and 45 was liable for service. No one could escape the net as the government trawled for men.
Not only could a government take us into a war with out a clear mandate from the voting public, and keep us in that war, without any democratic oversight for four long years, a sizable number of 19 to to 23 year olds could be consripted and forced to kill and die for that government, a government that they never voted for, or were even allowed to vote for.
Crunching the Numbers: 1 in 5 Kiwis spending half of income on rent
[5 Aug 2024]
In RNZ's new series Crunching the Numbers, we're out chatting to Kiwis about all things affecting their wallets. Our first story takes a look at renting, with research showing almost 1 in 5 New Zealanders are spending more than half of their household income on rent, while home ownership has fallen to below 60%.
Playing another referendum distraction card <1 year after our CoC govt (by landLords, for landLords) was formed seems panicked – 'honest' John waited 5 years to float the idea of a new flag referendum <9 months before Election 2014.
Expect further distractions to flow thick and quick from our self-serving CoC govt, while they get the flow of gravy temporarily "back on track".
Government On The Wrong Side Of Māori Wards [16 Sept 2024]
This Bill has shown this government’s true self and true agenda, but so far forty-three councils have said no to Simeon Brown and his deliberate moves to divide and distract our country.
Mike Joy’s grave new world [10 Sept 2024]
On a recent Tuesday afternoon at Victoria University, I watched freshwater ecologist and longtime environmental champion Mike Joy tell an undergraduate class that their world was headed off a cliff. He was being generous; the way he sees things, the cliff has well and truly been run over. He told the students green technologies were not going to save them, the world’s climate is going to break, and that a tipping point in the next few years will upend life as they know it.
When he was finished, the class murmured and packed their bags and headed out. A group of boys discussed drink options for the evening. Two friends agreed to study outside later. A grand total of three students went to the front of the room to ask questions. On the walk back to his office, Mike figured the content might be gone from their minds in about an hour. This wasn’t his usual class, after all. These were mostly business students, and in their world, exponential growth is a good thing.
Surplus Energy Economics Project 2050, part one – The end of modernity and a race to the bottom
…well before 2050, what we think of as “modernity” will have come to an end.
==============
The laws of thermodynamics clearly dictate that long-term sustainability of civilization is impossible. Any actions we take to prolong civilization will inevitably have negative impacts on the natural world.
The most sustainable course of action is to minimize our activities and consumption as much as possible. This includes:
Ceased all mining and burning of fossil fuels.
Reduced consumption and waste.
Protected biodiversity and ecosystems.
Promoted social justice and equity.
While this may seem drastic, it’s the only way to truly minimize our impact on the natural world and improve the chances of a sustainable future.
It’s important to remember that the goal is not to prolong civilization indefinitely, as this is ultimately impossible. Rather, the goal should be to minimize the suffering and destruction caused by human activity and to preserve as much of the natural world as possible for future generations.
==============
If I can get that (from Gemini), then I suspect the leaders/elite etc of the world already know from more powerful A.I.s than the free ones we have access to.
But that's no reason for Mike Joy and others to give up fighting for clean water.
How will our ‘anthropocene civilisation’ measure up in terms of longevity?
He told the students green technologies were not going to save them, the world’s climate is going to break, and that a tipping point in the next few years will upend life as they know it.
I am actually for 16 and 17 year olds being able to vote because of the three year cycle, even more so if it's a four year cycle. It seem crazy that for some people the first time they get to vote is not until they are almost 21, or almost 22 if it goes to a four year cycle.
And they could make it a national standard for year 10 in schools – NZ govt and voting.
Shifting the voting age earlier, simply shifts the window of age for the people who 'miss out'. If you shift it to 16, then you have all of the 15-year-olds who will be shock, horror almost 19 before they get to vote for the first time.
Given that virtually no 16-year-olds are living independently in NZ anymore, it doesn't seem like a huge ask for them to wait to 18 before they can vote.
Teenagers are not adults. They don't have fully developed brains (brain re-wiring in teens is well known, and not even controversial), which is why we limit their liability for criminal penalties, and limit their ability to drive (among other things, requiring the ability to predict the future consequences of their actions) – why should voting be different?
…..If you shift it to 16, then you have all of the 15-year-olds who will be shock, horror almost 19 before they get to vote for the first time……
I well remember the stulpifying and patrlponising mock elections teachers made us suffer at highschool when the election cycle came around. Nothing surer would turn young people away from political engagement than having to sit in faux voting civic lessons.
I don't know whether high schools still do this, maybe instead they ignore the national ballot altogether. Different method same result. Disengagement in our democratic process. The lesson being, elections are not important.
……Given that virtually no 16-year-olds are living independently in NZ anymore, it doesn't seem like a huge ask for them to wait to 18 before they can vote.
All the more reason that the age of franchise should be lowered. At 18 young people have a lot going on, leaving home, starting work, flatting, finding life partners.
Taking the time to consider and discuss the wider issues with their peers and mentors,and making informed decisions and voting, maybe not so much.
Studies have shown that young people who don't vote the first time, are likely to make a habit of it.
…..high levels of youth non-voting may have serious implications for long-term turnout decline in the future, as more young people establish a life-habit of non-voting.
Personally I would advocate the lowering of the voting age to 15. So that young people would have the experience of democracy and voting at least once during their formative years while they are still at High School and at home, to form those habits, befor negotiating the burdens and complexities of young adulthood.
All political parties that want the youth vote should have to put their arguments before young people, address their school assemblies, let them read their pamphlets, encourage them to watch their debates on the media of their choice.
Rather than sterile ethics lessons. Let them know their views and opinions count. By making their opinions count.
This can only enrich our democracy.
….Teenagers are not adults. They don't have fully developed brains (brain re-wiring in teens is well known, and not even controversial),..
Many pundits have remarked on the many young people in the most prestigous uniiversities in the Western world taking up the cause of the Palestinians in Gaza.
Why? many have asked, have the sons and daughters of the most privileged sections of society who as adults will be those who benefit from the most from privileges of empire and colonialism, have empathy for those most oppressed by empire and colonialism.
Maybe it is because their brains are still re-wiring. Maybe it is because their brains have not become calcified by adulthood,
The rolling back of environmental protections and climate action advanced by the previous Labour administration comes as no surprise.
With no new investment to combat climate change in last month’s budget, and a long list of cuts to climate and environment-related areas, the government risks damaging its global reputation…..
On Friday 15 March 2019, tens of thousands of young students marched in towns and cities throughout Aotearoa New Zealand. United by their concern for the future of the planet, they joined a global campaign known as School Strike 4 Climate Action.
As you can see for yourself Belladonna, climate change is an issue that young people are concerned about, concerned enough about to protest in tens of thousands. And probably, if they were allowed to vote, they would vote in the same numbers against the parties you support.
Make it 16
Supreme Court of New Zealand declares that preventing 16 and 17 year olds from voting is unjustified age discrimination and in breach of the Bill of Rights Act
In my opinion the test for franchise should be; can X years old organise collective political action on a local or national scale?
If we are going to be reductive, could 1 year olds, or even 10 year olds organise a nationwide strike for the climate, or for any other issue affecting them?
I've yet to see any argument from you explaining why 16 is more justifiable than 18.
Your entire argument seems to be that 16-year-olds are more likely to vote left, so we should encourage them.
Meanwhile – there are plenty of 40 year olds who can't organize collective political action on a local or national scale. Why should they be able to vote – if that is your entry level criteria?
For that matter, I've yet to see any 16 year olds organizing a nationwide strike for climate (or any other issue). The best they've been able to achieve is a nice day out protesting – 'but don't let it affect my exam results….'
My argument is that 18 is currently the closest we come to an 'official' adult level of responsibility in NZ. It's recognized in a whole lot of legislative and legal areas. The only thing that 16 is a threshold for, is beginning the process of getting your driving license, and legal sex.
I've yet to see any argument from you explaining why 16 is more justifiable than 18.
Many have argued to make it 16, and I like the idea – agree to disagree?
Busting the myths about voting at 16 [27 Nov 2022]
It’s common to hear that young people are not mature enough to vote because their brains are still developing. Our brains do develop rapidly until our mid-20s. However, as leading adolescent neurologists like Professor Sara Johnson from the Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine have shown, this also means young people can learn more quickly – yet we don’t presume to deny older people, who may struggle with processing large amounts of new information, the right to vote.
…
Research also indicates that when 16- or 17-year-olds cast a vote, they are more likely to continue to vote into the future. Enabling younger people to vote not only increases turnout, it is also correlated with other pro-social behaviours including volunteering, and local civic engagement.
…
From 14 years, a ‘young person’, can be held criminally responsible for breaking any law; and at 16 can apply for a firearms licence, leave school, and agree to or refuse medical treatment, pay tax, and work full time.
[“My argument is that 18 is currently the closest we come to an ‘official’ adult level of responsibility in NZ.“]
As the UK Liberal Democratic Peer, Sir Norman Lamb put it, the decision to enfranchise 16 to 17-year-olds is not a decision about when one becomes an adult, but a decision about who is able to have a voice in the process of determining the nation’s future direction.
…..I could be open to a conditional argument – if you are aged 16, living independently, and have a full-time job – then you're contributing to the tax base, and are entitled to vote
Hey Sunshine, it's disappointing that B, a self-declared respectful political centrist, might be open to relaxing their resistance to 'Make it 16' only for young Kiwis who are "contributing to the tax base".
Not contributing to the tax base, pensioners, pernanent invalids, sickness benificiaries, unemployed, sole parents on the DPB, injured people on ACC.
There are many categories of voters who are not contributing to the tax base.
Belladonna is clutching at straws.
Contributing, or not contributing to the tax base are not grounds for withholding the franchise from anyone.
To which I migt add, we go to extraordianry lengths to make sure those who ar incapitated in one way or the other, (whether they are taxpayers or not), can vote.
And so we should.
New Zealand Electoral Act (1993, last amended 2014)
(1) Any elector who is wholly or partially blind, or (whether because of physical handicap or otherwise) is unable to read or write or has severe difficulty in reading or writing, or is not sufficiently familiar with the English language to vote without assistance, may vote in accordance with the provisions of this section…
(2) At the request of any such voter, any person nominated by the voter, or, if no person is so nominated, the issuing officer, shall accompany the voter into one of the inner compartments provided for the marking of ballot papers, and the ballot paper may there be marked by the voter with the assistance of the person nominated or, as the case may be, of the issuing officer, or may be marked by the person nominated or, as the case may be, by the issuing officer in accordance with the instructions of the voter….
Belladonna may well be a self-declared respectful political centrist, but this debate reveals herself as being at home with Right Wing voter suppression based on tax paying status and age
Voter suppression is a strategy used to influence the outcome of an election by discouraging or preventing specific groups of people from voting…..
[You’re back to your old habits of overly long comments containing too many links and relying (too much) on quotes from others. I remind you of a previous warning regarding this behaviour here: https://thestandard.org.nz/open-mike-06-01-2024/#comment-1983432 – Incognito]
I've yet to see any argument from you explaining why 16 is more justifiable than 18…..
…..My argument is that 18 is currently the closest we come to an 'official' adult level of responsibility in NZ…..
……The only thing that 16 is a threshold for, is beginning the process of getting your driving license, and legal sex.
Wrong on both counts.
In this country the threshold for attaining the majority of 'official adult levels of responsibility' is not '18' it is 16.
The exceptions are:
You can't get a sex change until you are 18
You can't get married until you are 18
You can't smoke until you are 18
You can't vote until you are 18
In NZ at age 16 you can:
Hold a learner driver licence
Leave school.
Leave home permanently without permission.
Be paid at least the minimum wage.
Consent in writing to having your name changed.
Get a passport without parental consent.
Have consenting sex (heterosexual or gay).
Apply for a firearms licence.
Hold a Class 2 Aviation Pilot's Licence
Legally get a tatoo. (though tatooists will generally ask for parental consent)
In NZ You can't join the army until you are 17
Though abortion without parental consent is legal at all ages, generally can't get an abortion (without adult or guardian consent) until you are 17
Can't enforce a legal contract under 18.
While you can begin the process to acquire a firearms license or pilot license – at 16 (like a driver's license) you're most unlikely to gain one under 18.
If you can't see that the privilege of voting is equivalent to the other age-restricted activities of 18+ – then I guess that there is no point in discussing further.
I could be open to a conditional argument – if you are aged 16, living independently, and have a full-time job – then you're contributing to the tax base, and are entitled to vote. NB: I'd say there are very few Kiwis who would fall into this category.
Problem for you, is that the majority of people who would fall into this category are unlikely to be left-wing voters.
If you're interested in the voting patterns of pensioners, then I suggest you do the research.
Meanwhile – I note that you haven't actually responded to the points I made – no doubt that is too great a challenge for you.
Any evidence that the majority of under-18-year olds are actually tax-positive members of society (that is, they contribute more in taxes than they consume)? It seems highly unlikely. Especially given that the majority of them are in school.
That's not in itself bad, education is a pathway to a better job (or, at least it is for most people). However, it's difficult to argue that they are therefore more entitled than (say) 10-year-olds to a be allowed to vote.
Requiring 16-year-olds to wait for 2 years before they can vote, is hardly a major infringement of their political rights.
…..Your entire argument seems to be that 16-year-olds are more likely to vote left, so we should encourage them.
And your entire argument seems to be that 16-year-olds are more likely to vote left, so we should discourage them.
I am not afraid of how 16 year olds will vote, but you are. And as you have argued, you have a good reason to be afraid.
Your fear of extending the franchise to 16 year olds is the same fear conservatives had to extending the franchise to working people, to black people, to women,
A) there is a difference in cognitive development between 16 and 18.
B) the qualifying age for voting at 18 is similar to other privileges accrued at the same age (there are no learning wheels for voting – unlike driver's licenses).
C) Whichever age you choose, there will be the same number of people who 'unfairly' miss out because they're just under the magic number.
Quite frankly, I don't believe that there would be thousands of voters (for any political party) in the 16-18 band. Most teens don't care – and they go on not caring right through their 20s and 30s (there's a tiny boost in the excitement of first time voting – which quickly tails off)
And, if the limitation of the franchise to 18+ is perceived as so grossly unfair, by those it applies to – they'll be highly motivated to get out and vote when they qualify. Clearly they aren't …..
Jenny has made it quite clear that she is hopeful that young voters will vote left.
Her anticipation is of gaining left votes, rather than rights for young voters, per se.
Just as politically corrupt, as she's accusing me of being.
I never accused you of being corrupt, politically or otherwise.
Personally, I don't think you are corrupt, Belladonna.
You are just defending your class position.
And are most likely completely sincere in your views.
I just pointed out the flaws in your argument and mirroried them back to you.
The fact that you unfortunately feel I accused you of being politically corrupt, when I ddn't do so, says more about you than it does about me.
Quite frankly, I agree with you that most16 and 17 year olds won't care. But it's worth that so that people don't have to wait until they are almost 21 to be able to vote. And if 18-30 years old don't bother to vote, that is not a good reason to take away their ability to vote.
….Her [Jenny] anticipation is of gaining left votes, rather than rights for young voters, per se.
Not at all. I am just in love with democracy.
Everyone should have a say in the decisions that affect them, (and their families)
Demoeracy should be a for all, for young and old, the healthy, the sick, the enfeeblied, the well, the incarcerated the free, the rich the poor the taxpayers the benificiaries. Regardless of race religion ethniticy or origin.
Every, single one of us, every Goddamned soul!
I would like to empower all our citizens, by extending democracy into all areas of collective decision making that affects society.
I have long argued, in these pages, and other place, for the full return of the franchise to all New Zealand citizens in our our prison system, that were last granted to prisoners during the Kirk/Rowling administration. (arguably the most left Post WWII government of this country) and partially restored under during the Ardern/Hipkins administration. (arguably the second most left Post WWII government of this country)
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia;
…..The only time that all prisoners have been allowed to vote in elections in New Zealand was from 1975 to 1977. In 2010 the Electoral Act was amended to disqualify all prisoners from voting (regardless of the length of sentence imposed). In 2020 this law was amended so that only persons serving a sentence of imprisonment for a term of three years or more are disenfranchised.[1][2].
It is important to remember Belladonna is conservative right wing posing as a centrist, which to be frank is something all people claiming to be centrist are, and do.
It's important to remember that Muttonbird translates all political views through his filter as a hard left apologist.
He's clearly unacquainted with any people who have right wing views, or centrists ones for that matter – and must live entirely in a rose-coloured bubble of left-wing propaganda.
If you deny that political centrists exist, and characterize them all as right-wing, you'd better get used to the political wilderness – because Centrists are the ones who decide governments in NZ.
It is important to remember Belladonna is conservative right wing posing as a centrist…
B's commenting history here does seem more consistent with a right-wing political perspective than a centrist perspective, which is fine as far as it goes. However, imho the taint of deceit (i.e. the "respectful centrist" claim) does B's comments no favours– it's a distracting inconsistency. Still, self-serving righties (and lefties) will have their reasons for attempting to project/adopt false personas/identities.
…..Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold;
Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world,
The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere
The ceremony of innocence is drowned;
The best lack all conviction, while the worst
Are full of passionate intensity…..
At just 10 years old, a [NZ] child can’t smoke, drink or have their own Facebook page, but they can be held criminally responsible for violent crimes such as murder or manslaughter.
…..I could be open to a conditional argument – if you are aged 16, living independently, and have a full-time job – then you're contributing to the tax base, and are entitled to vote
…..I could be open to a conditional argument – if you are aged 16, living independently, and have a full-time job – then you're contributing to the tax base, and are entitled to vote
Hey Sunshine, it's disappointing that B, a self-declared respectful political centrist, might be open to relaxing their resistance to 'Make it 16' only for young Kiwis who are "contributing to the tax base".
The Universal Declaration of Human Rights places no such condition on voting rights, but some Kiwis will have little time for a declaration which makes no mention of tax, or a Taxpayers' Union
Everyone has the right to take part in the government of his country, directly or through freely chosen representatives.
Everyone has the right of equal access to public service in his country.
The will of the people shall be the basis of the authority of government; this will shall be expressed in periodic and genuine elections which shall be by universal and equal suffrage and shall be held by secret vote or by equivalent free voting procedures.
“However, Austria was the first European nation to lower its voting age in 2011.“, so it is possible for a capitalist country to make such a progressive change without everything going to hell in a handbasket.
10 years olds can smoke and drink – they just aren't allowed to purchase alcohol or cigarettes.
Applying the same reductionist logic of Belleadonna
10 years olds, would be allowed to purchase alcohol, cigarettes.and guns, 'conditional' on them being in the right tax bracket.
Putting aside all reductionist absurdity Belladonna's claim that she would be open for granting voting rights to young people conditonal on their tax status is not new idea.
At the beginning of parliamentary politics in this country, and indeed in most capitalist countries of the time the franchise was granted on property rights.
The New Zealand Constitution Act, passed by the British Parliament in 1852, established a system of government for the colony. This act also set the rules for voting in New Zealand’s first parliamentary and provincial elections, which took place in 1853. But not everyone was able to participate. As in Britain at this time, voting was not seen as an individual right of citizenship, but as a ‘privilege’ or ‘trust’ that should be exercised by some on behalf of others.
In keeping with British tradition, the right to vote was defined by:
sex (voters had to be male)
age (they had to be at least 21 years old)
nationality (they had to be British subjects)
property (they had to possess property of a certain value).
I would argue that a three-year term is too short. I don't think history of how long each government lasts – one, two or more terms – is the key issue here.
The key issue is that the electoral cycle of three years means more or less constant politicking. The first year of a government doing what it has promised to do (yeah right), one year of doing what it REALLY wants to do (and we are getting a whiff of that now) and a year of making promises for the next election.
Most comparable democracies run over a four or five year term legislature. I would support a four year term with one proviso: that we also have an upper house. New Zealand is almost unique in that it has a unicameral parliamentary system. That, in my mind, gives too much untrammelled power to the Executive Council which is essentially the PM, Finance Minister and other senior ministers.
However I doubt that an upper house would get much support. Also the timing of this referendum is important: Whenever a referendum like this is held the result tends to mirror the present state of popularity of the ruling government. If the government is popular then more people will like a four-year term. If it is unpopular then more people will favour a three-year term because they want the b..s out. The last referendum on a four year term was in the 1990 election and it was pretty soundly defeated along with the Rogernome government.
This is also what happened in the 1993 vote for MMP or FPP. I believe that MMP won, at least in part, because both National and Labour had lost popularity and many voters felt that supporting a new system that neither Labour nor National particularly liked was a good way of showing both the middle finger.
…..The key issue is that the electoral cycle of three years means more or less constant politicking.
The Right often claim there is 'too much politiks', (sic). What the Right really mean when they say there is too much politics, is that there is too much democracy.
Wanting to “Keep Politics Out of It” is an inherently political statement which means taking a political position. This keeps society from discussing the hidden economic forces behind our decisions.
Being able to keep politics out of something, whether it's a discussion or sports or even media is an immediate move to take a position affirming a persons endorsment of the current position of society.
The more places politics is kept out of, the less places discussions can take place, new ideas can be formed and most importantly minds can be molded. Wanting to keep politics out of something is saying that a person wants to remain ignorant of new ideas and they fear that their method of distraction will be interrupted. By that same vien those who are currently in power have a vested interest in trying to stop politics from encroaching into as many places as possible…..
I support Make it 16 as a matter of general principal. In my opinion the more democracy the better.
I have suggested that if we have to go to four year term, (a move I don'support), then lowering the age of franchise must be a minimum demand of the Left.
If we have to go to four year term a minimum demand of the Lef, must be the return of the primacy of parliament over government.
If a government is acting so egregiously against the welfare of this country and its people that some government MPs are moved to cross the floor to vote with the opposition, they won't be expelled from parliament.
Until that happens, we don't have a genuine democracy, we have an unfettered elected dictatorship. The only real check we have on that elected dictatorship is to remove it every three years, For those who quite like elected dictatorships, once every three years is not enogh to do whatever they like with us, four years would be better Those who support elected dictatorship would be quite comfortable efor an elected dictatorship to even order us into war, whether we wanted to, or not. Whether it is a just war, or not, Whether we supported it or not.
P.S. As most wars are over in four years. A four year term government could take us into a war and not have to account for their actions for four long years. Four years is way too long for New Zealanders to be dying and killing in an upopular war, without democratic oversight.
If there was a war that NZ were to be involved then that is for the government and parliament, who have been democratically elected by the people of this country.
The last Labour Government had set in place economic arrangements with the plan of completing the embedding over the 3rd term. Alas they lost and the CoC were able to abolish so much because the plans were not embedded enough.
They had a majority with no coalition partners to halt them (unlike the first term where NZ First prevented them from doing progressive things).
It was a once in a generation opportunity to do brave things. Everyone knew that even if Labour won in 2023, they would lose that absolute majority. But in knowing that they failed to deliver the restructure we needed, an will struggle to ever that opportunity again.
All those working from home who have been ordered back to the workplace have been told by the lovely Willis and Luxon that they must buy coffees and their lunches and pay transport fares and after school care and spend plenty in the shops as well. The sheer gall as they try to deflect the outcome of their policies.
But not one word about the effect of all those she ordered to be made redundant who are not out spending.
As for the word "entitlementl" they used – Mr Entitlement himself and his $56,000 to live in his own apartment!
The sheer hypocrisy, arrogance and impudence of the 'order' staggers me. As you say, it is an attempt to place the blame of the outcome of their own actions onto public servants. But its more than just that. They have an ideologically-based hatred of public servants and institutions and are out to demonise them at every possible turn.
Nicola Willis has to be the most venal and arrogant woman politician who has ever graced a NZ parliament and that's saying something because there's strong competitors past and present.
"….the most venal and arrogant woman politician who has ever graced a NZ parliament "
Bit early for that IMO, stanford, upston and fan favorite judith probably be in for that also with pullya benefits advice available if required from her sinecure at pharmac.
How to live large with those tax cuts Movie ticket (but likely no cinema snacks) – Nicola Willis said last year that a family’s fortnightly tax relief could mean “instead of movie night being DVDs and Tip Top at home, we might go out to the movies”.
With movie ticket prices upwards of $25 (and nearly $20 for children in many places), some families might have to choose which children get to go to the movies. Popcorn or ice cream is also probably off the menu.
Nicola Willis has to be the most venal and arrogant woman politician who has ever graced a NZ parliament and that's saying something because there's strong competitors past and present.
Could be – Nicotine Willis is quick out of the blocks, insincere, and giving Richardson a run for all money when it comes to punching down on 'bottom feeders'.
Yes. It's interesting how some on the Right viewed the stay at home orders during the pandemic as coercive government over-reach. But it is apparently OK to order people back into the office when there is no evidence presented showing that the current arrangements around work from home make the Public Service less effective.
So for the right-wing mind, coercion is bad if it's in the common good (public health during a pandemic), but great if it serves the interests of inner city Wellington businesses.
They are the new authoritarians – who are just the same as the old authoritarians.
Government wants to order the public servants working from home to go back to the office.
Inner city cafes and restaurant owners and other inner city businesses say they need the foot traffic.
As Reality says above, no mention of the public service workers laid off and no longer coming into town. And who without jobs are probably spending less in their community as wll
….Public Service Minister Nicola Willis said; "updated guidance for the public service will make clear that working from home is not an entitlement and must be agreed and monitored". A number of Wellington businesses spoke to Stuff about what they saw as a need to order workers back into the office, with some calling it an easy fix for the local economy.
Working from home is a cost saving, eating and cooking groceries at home, is much cheaper than buying lunch at a cafe, or lunch bar. Then there is the cost of transport.
The government expect public servants to bear all this cost to subsidise private business.
If Willis is ordering public servant back to the office so they can put money in the pockets of inner city business owners. Then she must first put more money in the pockets of the public servants..
And government having a lot of now under-utilised office space now that they've laid off 6000 public servants, most of them were probably in the office.
Once the leases run out they'll probably not renew some spaces and encourage some staff to WFH again to reduce the footprint.
Which is how WFH came about, to reduce the amount of office space the government, or private employer had to lease, and shift the cost of that onto the employee.
But hey, framing it all about productivity, rather than layoffs, is really just an admission that the layoffs have tanked outputs and hence productivity.
While the world is focused on the plight of Gazans Sudan's healthcare and education systems have collapsed, 19 million Sudanese face food insecurity, 13 million Sudanese have been displaced and an estimated 75,000 people have died.
But never let a crisis go unexploited…
/
'Threat to culture' in Sudan is unprecedented
"The situation is really bad," says Munich Museum of Egyptian Art director, Arnulf Schlüter.
He does not know whether the archaeological project will ever be resumed.
"Most of the excavation workers have fled, the excavation house has been broken into and the tires of the vehicles have been stolen. The antiquities site lies defenseless."
Museums and artifacts are being destroyed and looted across the country amid a severe humanitarian crisis — more than 10 million Sudanese people are displaced and half of the country's 50 million inhabitants are experiencing hunger.
September 22, 2024 (PORT SUDAN) — A Russian trade delegation has been in talks with Sudanese officials about starting gold extraction from multiple sites in the country as soon as next month, government sources told Sudan Tribune.
The discussions follow the signing in June of an agreement for gold exploration and extraction between Sudan’s Ministry of Minerals and the Russian company Zarubezhgeologiya.
He going to be the new chief of the Social Investment Agency. Not good for women after coming from such a male dominated area – both the villains and the police.
Willis is telling government departments how to manage staff – not 'companies'.
Outside the beltway, with the class of Kiwis who have to be present in their workplaces to do their jobs (tradies, cleaners, nurses, etc.) – this will go down very well indeed. Perks for civil servants are rarely popular.
And are all of your colleagues equally outraged that Wellington civil servants may have to work in the office, rather than from home? I think it highly unlikely.
I have three children who work in the private sector in three different cities in two different countries. All three work from home and get bonuses and pay increases due to their high productivity.
All of them have no local manager but meet with their managers mainly on-line and every now and then (two monthly to quarterly) the manager will tour around and one on one with the staff.
The savings on not needing a local manager and the same office space as previously is quite large. Technology has enabled this for all of them and was happening anyway. All that happened really is that the COVID response sped up the software development and the thinking and the practice e.g. online conferencing now is miles better than the start of COVID with much better integration into other mail, etc. Minute taking in one son’s case is done automatically as a meeting progresses using AI.
Much more work can be done from anywhere and this will continue to grow and develop – just like on-line shopping has gone from niche to mainstream. Just like good restaurants pivoted from predominantly customers in the door to home delivery (and even beyond that to ghost kitchens).
Many businesses are no longer constrained by only having access to the best local talent – they now have access to a broader range. My kids are constantly being head hunted with job offers – from businesses not even in their locality.
Tis a new world and Luxon is behaving like a Luddite.
No doubt. I'm just pointing out that much of the private sector has realised the benefits, productivity gains and cost savings.
I'm old fashioned and concerned about office costs being effectively pushed on to them but the one in Oz earns miles more than I do plus gets 14% super so is not overly worried about that. He is also totally flexible about going into the office when needed so tis a mutual win/win for both him and his employer.
The problem I see is that his generation are much more likely to up and leave which doesn't bode well I suspect for the future public service. Maybe that is the intention……..
I think that the ones who are likely to leave (because the allure of higher wages is greater than the tug of home) – will do so in any case. You're not going to suddenly decide to immigrate to Australia because you have to work in the office – there will be plenty of other factors in play.
I work in a place where hybrid (WFH and in office) and entirely remote are both accommodated. It's very much based on productivity (not entitlement), and is sometimes a way of retaining highly valued staff who are not able to work in the office for a period of time.
It can work. Some jobs are more 'friendly' to this than others – and typically jobs which can be siloed off, or are highly measurable are more successful. However, there is no denying that some of the other benefits of working in the office (e.g. collaborative decision making, innovation, training, coaching and mentoring) simply don't work as well with remote staff.
I've been working over the last 6 weeks implementing a contract with a government department. All of the people I've been working with are largely (or entirely) WFH. It's been a nightmare trying to co-ordinate their staff for meetings, and/or decision-making. I don't know how much of this is public service slowness, and how much is the fact that they're never together to talk issues through. But the whole implementation schedule has already blown out to double the scheduled time – and I'm picking 4x before we're operational.
"And are all of your colleagues equally outraged that Wellington civil servants may have to work in the office, rather than from home? I think it highly unlikely."
Who new blue collar workers were so progressive?
One colleague reckons ns good on them, if it's available go for it. The other doesn't have an opinion on it.
The nurse ( my SO), reckons from what she has heard, productivity goes up when work from home is available so is a good thing.
All of which is a distraction from my point, this regime is looking to micro manage the trivial while making a right royal balls-up of the important stuff. eg Rail able ferries ($1B so far and nothing to show for it).
The (right wing) government meddling in the classroom and now meddling in the workplace.
Exactly the kind of thing the same people would have been appopletic about if it had been a Labour government. Flexibility appears to no longer be welcomed in the workplace.
And note the hospitality industry naively thinking everything will be business as usual once everyone is ordered back to the office.
Minus the thousands who will no longer have a job, of course.
Why are the people trying to strong-arm me into buying a coffee and brunch during the day the same people telling me the reason I can't afford a house is because I'm spending too much on lunches?
On Nicola Willis’ Perverse Hostility To Working From Home [24 Sept 2024]
On RNZ this morning, Luxon had no clue how many public servants would be affected by this edict. Or how this directive would impact on road congestion, let alone how the hours of sitting in traffic might reduce productivity, staff morale and household budgets via the added transport costs.
On Nicola Willis’ Perverse Hostility To Working From Home [24 Sept 2024]
On RNZ this morning, Luxon had no clue how many public servants would be affected by this edict. Or how this directive would impact on road congestion, let alone how the hours of sitting in traffic might reduce productivity, staff morale and household budgets via the added transport costs.
Of course Luxon/Willis have no clue, It was a fact-free reckon and they never have research but have an enormous whipping power over their loyal subject-voters, as all the Reddits and Tweets are showing them all out for a bash.
Also many of us will have forgotten the predilection of RW govts to grind down on public servants who traditionally are not able to defend themselves, sort of bully governing.
Incidentally I worked from home first in the early 1980s and then at various times during my career. My staff did as well. As a manager of staff I did not find it difficult to manage out of office workers. Mine were always in Wgtn but colleagues managed staff across NZ. They have work programmes and deadlines and with tech it is much easier than it used to be.
So a smokescreen so what are they using this to divert our attention from?
Not the first display of contradiction. I speculate that we may be entering a political epoch characterised by hypocricy. Seymour, the right wing libertarian wants to centralise the lunch supply of hungry children.
Not trying to undermine the working from home vibe, but why do these folk seem to 'have' to buy their lunch. I make my lunch 4 days a week, often leftovers and once a week support the local tuck shop. Or is it a city folk thing?
Many do make their lunches and many don't join the coffee throngs, many eat their lunch at their desks and don't take a break of half an hour let alone an hour.
It was the juxtaposition of moaning coffee bar owners swiftly followed by a edict to cease work from home that had many puzzling as to whether the Nacts were doing this to ensure that staff were in town buying.
Many don't buy in town but now have to meet increased travel costs. I doubt in Wgtn whether the bus transport could cope if all workers went back to working in town. Generally in my 35 or so years catching them to work here in Wgtn they were P**s P**r, unreliable and hence the reason I walked to the next suburb to catch buses as several routes came through. This was good exercise but was of necessity as the buses could not be relied on to get you in to town for a specific time. Ok if you had flexible hours but perhaps Nicola Wlllis has a friend that is not supportive of flexible hours ans this will be the next to be questioned
I remember times when Nats were in Govt and the ethos was very cruel and unashamedly and blatantly so. I worked in the Beehive on one of these ocasions Nat appointed staff seemed to have the idea that public servants were political appointments or if they were not, brought political sentiments to the job. The concept of apolitical was unknown to them…..after a year or so they got out of this mindset. It amused me that one of the most recalcitrant 'public servants as political animals' believers later was proud to be headhunted into one of these so-called 'political' agencies.
The first year of a right wing govt is usually hell on wheels for public servants/public sector agencies, the first year of a left wing one not so much. The old concept of 'gentlemanly' old school Nats who were good Ministers from the beginning is long gone.
Hi,This week’s Flightless Bird episode was about “fake seizure guy” — a Melbourne man who fakes seizures in order to get members of the public to sit on him.The audio documentary (which I have included in this newsletter in case you don’t listen to Flightless Bird) built on reporting first ...
This is a re-post from Yale Climate Connections by Karin Kirk The 119th Congress comes with a price tag. The oil and gas industry gave about $24 million in campaign contributions to the members of the U.S. House and Senate expected to be sworn in January 3, 2025, according to a ...
Early morning, the shadows still long, but you can already feel the warmth building. Our motel was across the road from the historic homestead where Henry Williams' family lived. The evening before, we wandered around the gardens, reading the plaques and enjoying the close proximity to the history of the ...
Thanks folks for your feedback, votes and comments this week. I’ll be making the changes soon. Appreciate all your emails, comments and subscriptions too. I know your time is valuable - muchas gracias.A lot is happening both here and around the world - so I want to provide a snippets ...
Data released today by Statistics NZ shows that unemployment rose to 5.1%, with 33,000 more people out of work than last year said NZCTU Te Kauae Kaimahi Economist Craig Renney. “The latest data shows that employment fell in Aotearoa at its fastest rate since the GFC. Unemployment rose in 8 ...
The December labour market statistics have been released, showing yet another increase in unemployment. There are now 156,000 unemployed - 34,000 more than when National took office. And having thrown all these people out of work, National is doubling down on cruelty. Because being vicious will somehow magically create the ...
Boarded up homes in Kilbirnie, where work on a planned development was halted. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāLong stories short, the top six things in our political economy around housing, climate and poverty on Wednesday, February 5 are;Housing Minister Chris Bishop yesterday announcedKāinga Ora would be stripped of ...
This week Kiwirail and Auckland Transport were celebrating the completion of the summer rail works that had the network shut or for over a month and the start of electric trains to Pukekohe. First up, here’s parts of the press release about the shutdown works. Passengers boarding trains in Auckland ...
Through its austerity measures, the coalition government has engineered a rise in unemployment in order to reduce inflation while – simultaneously – cracking down harder and harder on the people thrown out of work by its own policies. To that end, Social Development Minister Louise Upston this week added two ...
This year, we've seen a radical, white supremacist government ignoring its Tiriti obligations, refusing to consult with Māori, and even trying to legislatively abrogate te Tiriti o Waitangi. When it was criticised by the Waitangi Tribunal, the government sabotaged that body, replacing its legal and historical experts with corporate shills, ...
Poor old democracy, it really is in a sorry state. It would be easy to put all the blame on the vandals and tyrants presently trashing the White House, but this has been years in the making. It begins with Margaret Thatcher and Ronald Reagan and the spirit of Gordon ...
The new school lunches came in this week, and they were absolutely scrumptious.I had some, and even though Connor said his tasted like “stodge” and gave him a sore tummy, I myself loved it!Look at the photos - I knew Mr Seymour wouldn’t lie when he told us last year:"It ...
The tighter sanctions are modelled on ones used in Britain, which did push people off ‘the dole’, but didn’t increase the number of workers, and which evidence has repeatedly shown don’t work. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāLong stories short, the top six things in our political economy around housing, ...
Catching you up on the morning’s global news and a quick look at the parallels -GLOBALTariffs are backSharemarkets in the US, UK and Europe have “plunged” in response to Trump’s tariffs. And while Mexico has won a one month reprieve, Canada and China will see their respective 25% and 10% ...
This post by Nicolas Reid was originally published on Linked in. It is republished here with permission. Gondolas are often in the news, with manufacturers of ropeway systems proposing them as a modern option for mass transit systems in New Zealand. However, like every next big thing in transport, it’s hard ...
This is a re-post from The Climate BrinkBoth 2023 and 2024 were exceptionally warm years, at just below and above 1.5C relative to preindustrial in the WMO composite of surface temperature records, respectively. While we are still working to assess the full set of drivers of this warmth, it is clear that ...
Hi,I woke up feeling nervous this morning, realising that this weekend Flightless Bird is going to do it’s first ever live show. We’re heading to a sold out (!) show in Seattle to test the format out in front of an audience. If it works, we’ll do more. I want ...
From the United-For-Now States of America comes the thrilling news that a New Zealander may be at the very heart of the current coup. Punching above our weight on the world stage once more! Wait, you may be asking, what New Zealander? I speak of Peter Thiel, made street legal ...
Even Stevens: Over the 33 years between 1990 and 2023 (and allowing for the aberrant 2020 result) the average level of support enjoyed by the Left and Right blocs, at roughly 44.5 percent each, turns out to be, as near as dammit, identical.WORLDWIDE, THE PARTIES of the Left are presented ...
Back in 2023, a "prominent political figure" went on trial for historic sex offences. But we weren't allowed to know who they were or what political party they were "prominent" in, because it might affect the way we voted. At the time, I said that this was untenable; it was ...
I'm going, I'm goingWhere the water tastes like wineI'm going where the water tastes like wineWe can jump in the waterStay drunk all the timeI'm gonna leave this city, got to get awayI'm gonna leave this city, got to get awayAll this fussing and fighting, man, you know I sure ...
Waitangi Day is a time to honour Te Tiriti o Waitangi and stand together for a just and fair Aotearoa. Across the motu, communities are gathering to reflect, kōrero, and take action for a future built on equity and tino rangatiratanga. From dawn ceremonies to whānau-friendly events, there are ...
Subscribe to Mountain Tūī ! Where you too can learn about exciting things from a flying bird! Tweet.Yes - I absolutely suck at marketing. It’s a fact.But first -My question to all readers is:How should I set up the Substack model?It’s been something I’ve been meaning to ask since November ...
Here’s the key news, commentary, reports and debate around Aotearoa’s political economy on politics and in the week to Feb 3:PM Christopher Luxon began 2025’s first day of Parliament last Tuesday by carrying on where left off in 2024, letting National’s junior coalition partner set the political agenda and dragging ...
The PSA have released a survey of 4000 public service workers showing that budget cuts are taking a toll on the wellbeing of public servants and risking the delivery of essential services to New Zealanders. Economists predict that figures released this week will show continued increases in unemployment, potentially reaching ...
The Prime Minister’s speech 10 days or so ago kicked off a flurry of commentary. No one much anywhere near the mainstream (ie excluding Greens supporters) questioned the rhetoric. New Zealand has done woefully poorly on productivity for a long time and we really need better outcomes, and the sorts ...
President Trump on the day he announced tariffs against Mexico, Canada and China, unleashing a shock to supply chains globally that is expected to slow economic growth and increase inflation for most large economies. Photo: Getty ImagesLong stories short, the top six things in our political economy around housing, climate ...
Photo by Towfiqu barbhuiya on UnsplashHere’s what we’re watching in the week to February 9 and beyond in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty:Monday, February 3Politics: New Zealand Government cabinet meeting usually held early afternoon with post-cabinet news conference possible at 4 pm, although they have not been ...
Trump being Trump, it won’t come as a shock to find that he regards a strong US currency (bolstered by high tariffs on everything made by foreigners) as a sign of America’s virility, and its ability to kick sand in the face of the world. Reality is a tad more ...
A listing of 24 news and opinion articles we found interesting and shared on social media during the past week: Sun, January 26, 2025 thru Sat, February 1, 2025. This week's roundup is again published soleley by category. We are still interested in feedback to hone the categorization, so if ...
What seems to be the common theme in the US, NZ, Argentina and places like Italy under their respective rightwing governments is what I think of as “the politics of cruelty.” Hate-mongering, callous indifference in social policy-making, corporate toadying, political bullying, intimidation and punching down on the most vulnerable with ...
If you are confused, check with the sunCarry a compass to help you alongYour feet are going to be on the groundYour head is there to move you aroundSo, stand in the place where you liveSongwriters: Bill Berry / Michael Mills / Michael Stipe / Peter Buck.Hot in the CityYesterday, ...
Shane Jones announced today he would be contracting out his thinking to a smarter younger person.Reclining on his chaise longue with a mouth full of oysters and Kina he told reporters:Clearly I have become a has-been, a palimpsest, an epigone, a bloviating fossil. I find myself saying such things as: ...
Warning: This post contains references to sexual assaultOn Saturday, I spent far too long editing a video on Tim Jago, the ACT Party President and criminal, who has given up his fight for name suppression after 2 years. He voluntarily gave up just in time for what will be a ...
Skeptical Science is partnering with Gigafact to produce fact briefs — bite-sized fact checks of trending claims. This fact brief was written by Sue Bin Park from the Gigafact team in collaboration with members from our team. You can submit claims you think need checking via the tipline. Is global warming ...
Our low-investment, low-wage, migration-led and housing-market-driven political economy has delivered poorer productivity growth than the rest of the OECD, and our performance since Covid has been particularly poor. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāLong stories short, the top six things in our political economy around housing, climate and poverty this ...
..Thanks for reading Frankly Speaking ! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.As far as major government announcements go, a Three Ministers Event is Big. It can signify a major policy development or something has gone Very Well, or an absolute Clusterf**k. When Three Ministers assemble ...
One of those blasts from the past. Peter Dunne – originally neoliberal Labour, then leader of various parties that sought to work with both big parties (generally National) – has taken to calling ...
Completed reads for January: I Am Legend, by Richard Matheson The Black Spider, by Jeremias Gotthelf The Spider and the Fly (poem), by Mary Howitt A Noiseless Patient Spider (poem), by Walt Whitman August Heat, by W.F. Harvey Charlotte’s Web, by E.B. White The Shrinking Man, by Richard Matheson ...
Do its Property Right Provisions Make Sense?Last week I pointed out that it is uninformed to argue that the New Zealand’s apparently poor economic performance can be traced only to poor regulations. Even were there evidence they had some impact, there are other factors. Of course, we should seek to ...
Richard Wagstaff It was incredibly jarring to hear the hubris from the Prime Minister during his recent state of the nation address. I had just spent close to a week working though the stories and thoughts shared with us by nearly 2000 working people as part of our annual Mood ...
Odd fact about the Broadcasting Standards Authority: for the last few years, they’ve only been upholding about 5% of complaints. Why? I think there’s a range of reasons. Generally responsible broadcasters. Dumb complaints. Complaints brought under the wrong standard. Greater adherence to broadcasters’ rights to freedom of expression in the ...
And I said, "Mama, mama, mama, why am I so alone"'Cause I can't go outside, I'm scared I might not make it homeWell I'm alive, I'm alive, but I'm sinking inIf there's anyone at home at your place, darlingWhy don't you invite me in?Don't try to feed me'Cause I've been ...
Climate Change Minister Simon Watts’ star is on the rise, having just added the Energy, Local Government and Revenue portfolios to his responsibilities - but there is nothing ambitious about the Government’s new climate targets. Photo: SuppliedLong stories short, the top six things in our political economy around housing, climate ...
It may have been a short week but there’s been no shortage of things that caught our attention. Here is some of the most interesting. This week in Greater Auckland On Tuesday Matt took a look at public transport ridership in 2024 On Thursday Connor asked some questions ...
The East Is Red: Journalists and commentators are referring to the sudden and disruptive arrival of DeepSeek as a second “Sputnik moment”. (Sputnik being the name given by the godless communists of the Soviet Union to the world’s first artificial satellite which, to the consternation and dismay of the Americans, ...
Hi,Back on inauguration day we launched a ridiculous RFK Jr. “brain worms” tee on the Webworm store, and I told you I’d be throwing my profits over to Mutual Aid LA and Rainbow Youth New Zealand. Just to show I am not full of shit, here are the receipts. I ...
The podcast above of the weekly ‘Hoon’ webinar for paying subscribers on Thursday night features co-hosts & talking about the week’s news with regular and special guests, including: on the week in geopolitics, including the latest from Donald Trump over Gaza and Ukraine.Health expert and author David Galler ...
In an uncompromising paper Treasury has basically told the Government that its plan for a third medical school at Waikato University is a waste of money. Furthermore, the country cannot afford it. That advice was released this week by the Treasury under the Official Information Act. And it comes as ...
Back in November, He Pou a Rangi provided the government with formal advice on the domestic contribution to our next Paris target. Not what the target should be, but what we could realistically achieve, by domestic action alone, without resorting to offshore mitigation. Their answer was startling: depending on exactly ...
Photo by Mauricio Fanfa on UnsplashKia oraCome and join us for our weekly ‘Hoon’ webinar with paying subscribers to The Kākā for an hour at 5 pm today.Jump on this link on YouTube Livestream for our chat about the week’s news with myself , plus regular guest David Patman and ...
I don't like to spend all my time complaining about our government, so let me complain about the media first.Senior journalistic Herald person Thomas Coughlan reported that Treasury replied yeah nah, wrong bro to Luxon's claim that our benighted little country has been in recession for three years.His excitement rose ...
Back in 2022, when the government was consulting internally about proactive release of cabinet papers, the SIS opposed it. The basis of their opposition was the "mosaic effect" - people being able to piece together individual pieces of innocuous public information in a way which supposedly harms "national security" (effectively: ...
With The Stroke Of A Pen:Populism, especially right-wing populism, invests all the power of an electoral/parliamentary majority in a single political leader because it no longer trusts the bona fides of the sprawling political class among whom power is traditionally dispersed. Populism eschews traditional politics, because, among populists, traditional politics ...
I’ve spent the last week writing a fairly substantial review of a recent book (“Australia’s Pandemic Exceptionalism: How we crushed the curve but lost the race”) by a couple of Australian academic economists on Australia’s pandemic policies and experiences. For all its limitations, there isn’t anything similar in New Zealand. ...
Mr Mojo Rising: Economic growth is possible, Christopher Luxon reassures us, but only under a government that is willing to get out of the way and let those with drive and ambition get on with it.ABOUT TWELVE KILOMETRES from the farm on the North Otago coast where I grew up stands ...
You're nearly a good laughAlmost a jokerWith your head down in the pig binSaying, 'Keep on digging.'Pig stain on your fat chinWhat do you hope to findDown in the pig mine?You're nearly a laughYou're nearly a laughBut you're really a crySongwriter: Roger Waters.NZ First - Kiwi Battlers.Say what you like ...
This is a re-post from the Climate Brink by Andrew Dessler Climate denial is dead. Renewable energy denial is here. As “alternative facts” become the norm, it’s worth looking at what actual facts tell us about how renewable energy sources like solar and wind are lowering the price of electricity. As ...
SIR GEOFFREY PALMER is worried about democracy. In his Newsroom website post of 27 January 2025 he asserts that “the future of democracy across the world now seems to be in question.” Following a year of important electoral contests across the world, culminating in Donald Trump’s emphatic recapture of the ...
The Government hasn’t stopped talking about growth since the Prime Minister made his “yes” speech at the Auckland Chamber of Commerce last week. But so far, the measures announced would seem hardly likely to suddenly pitch New Zealand into the fast-growth East Asian league. The digital nomad announcement hardly deserved ...
It's election year for Wellington City Council and for the Regional Council. What have the progressive councillors achieved over the last couple of years. What were the blocks and failures? What's with the targeting of the mayor and city council by the Post and by central government? Why does the ...
Someone defames you anonymously online. Can you find out who it is? Maybe. There are legal avenues to seek a court order that an internet host reveal the identity of the person. One of them is called a Norwich Pharmacal order, but as Hugh Tomlinson KC points out, it only ...
The results of the 2025 Mood of the Workforce survey have been released, with working people revealing deep concerns regarding their work lives, housing, health care, and perceptions of the coalition government in Aotearoa New Zealand.Christopher Luxon has signalled that National may campaign on asset sales in the next election, ...
Hey, hey, heyJust think, while you've been gettin' down and out about the liarsAnd the dirty, dirty cheats of the worldYou could've been gettin' down to this sick beatSongwriters: Taylor Swift / Shellback / Martin Max. Read more ...
Luxon has once again let National’s junior coalition partner, ACT, set the political agenda, dragging him and National into another politically draining debate. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāLong stories short, the top six things in our political economy around housing, climate and poverty on Wednesday, January 29 are:PM Christopher ...
..Thanks for reading Frankly Speaking ! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.Fresh from the maelstrom surrounding the Treaty Principles Bill, and before fury and dust from that toxic piece of rubbish has settled, Act Leader, David Seymour has launched a new narrative into the public ...
Note: This video featuring speakers such as Finlayson, Waring, Kelsey and Little is a long one - 35 minutes. In the first 9 of 80 hours that the Justice Select Committee will spend on Treaty Principles Bill public hearings1, from a smidgeon of the 343,000 record submissions2, in a months ...
When I created a Youtube channel, I labelled the playlist for National: “National Privatize NZ Party”.Now, why did I do that?It’s late and my brain isn’t working at full capacity, so my off the cuff answer is - 1. I follow far too much of this Government’s statements, actions, and ...
The latest unemployment figures reveal that job losses are hitting Māori and Pacific people especially hard, with Māori unemployment reaching a staggering 9.7% for the December 2024 quarter and Pasifika unemployment reaching 10.5%. ...
Waitangi 2025: Waitangi Day must be community and not politically driven - Shane Jones Our originating document, theTreaty of Waitangi, was signed on February 6, 1840. An agreement between Māori and the British Crown. Initially inked by Ngā Puhi in Waitangi, further signatures were added as it travelled south. ...
Despite being confronted every day with people in genuine need being stopped from accessing emergency housing – National still won’t commit to building more public houses. ...
The Green Party says the Government is giving up on growing the country’s public housing stock, despite overwhelming evidence that we need more affordable houses to solve the housing crisis. ...
Before any thoughts of the New Year and what lies ahead could even be contemplated, New Zealand reeled with the tragedy of Senior Sergeant Lyn Fleming losing her life. For over 38 years she had faithfully served as a front-line Police officer. Working alongside her was Senior Sergeant Adam Ramsay ...
Green Party co-leader Marama Davidson will return to politics at Waitangi on Monday the 3rd of February where she will hold a stand up with fellow co-leader Chlöe Swarbrick. ...
Te Pāti Māori is appalled by the government's blatant mishandling of the school lunch programme. David Seymour’s ‘cost-saving’ measures have left tamariki across Aotearoa with unidentifiable meals, causing distress and outrage among parents and communities alike. “What’s the difference between providing inedible food, and providing no food at all?” Said ...
The Government is doubling down on outdated and volatile fossil fuels, showing how shortsighted and destructive their policies are for working New Zealanders. ...
Green Party MP Steve Abel this morning joined Coromandel locals in Waihi to condemn new mining plans announced by Shane Jones in the pit of the town’s Australian-owned Gold mine. ...
The Green Party is calling on the Government to strengthen its just-announced 2030-2035 Nationally Determined Contribution (NDC) under the Paris Agreement and address its woeful lack of commitment to climate security. ...
Today marks a historic moment for Taranaki iwi with the passing of the Te Pire Whakatupua mō Te Kāhui Tupua/Taranaki Maunga Collective Redress Bill in Parliament. "Today, we stand together as descendants of Taranaki, and our tūpuna, Taranaki Maunga, is now formally acknowledged by the law as a living tūpuna. ...
Labour is relieved to see Children’s Minister Karen Chhour has woken up to reality and reversed her government’s terrible decisions to cut funding from frontline service providers – temporarily. ...
It is the first week of David Seymour’s school lunch programme and already social media reports are circulating of revolting meals, late deliveries, and mislabelled packaging. ...
The Green Party says that with no-cause evictions returning from today, the move to allow landlords to end tenancies without reason plunges renters, and particularly families who rent, into insecurity and stress. ...
The Government’s move to increase speed limits substantially on dozens of stretches of rural and often undivided highways will result in more serious harm. ...
In her first announcement as Economic Growth Minister, Nicola Willis chose to loosen restrictions for digital nomads from other countries, rather than focus on everyday Kiwis. ...
The Green Party is calling on the Government to stand firm and work with allies to progress climate action as Donald Trump signals his intent to pull out of the Paris Climate Accords once again. ...
The Government’s commitment to get New Zealand’s roads back on track is delivering strong results, with around 98 per cent of potholes on state highways repaired within 24 hours of identification every month since targets were introduced, Transport Minister Chris Bishop says. “Increasing productivity to help rebuild our economy is ...
The former Cadbury factory will be the site of the Inpatient Building for the new Dunedin Hospital and Health Minister Simeon Brown says actions have been taken to get the cost overruns under control. “Today I am giving the people of Dunedin certainty that we will build the new Dunedin ...
From today, Plunket in Whāngarei will be offering childhood immunisations – the first of up to 27 sites nationwide, Health Minister Simeon Brown says. The investment of $1 million into the pilot, announced in October 2024, was made possible due to the Government’s record $16.68 billion investment in health. It ...
New Zealand’s strong commitment to the rights of disabled people has continued with the response to an important United Nations report, Disability Issues Minister Louise Upston has announced. Of the 63 concluding observations of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (UNCRPD), 47 will be progressed ...
Resources Minister Shane Jones has launched New Zealand’s national Minerals Strategy and Critical Minerals List, documents that lay a strategic and enduring path for the mineral sector, with the aim of doubling exports to $3 billion by 2035. Mr Jones released the documents, which present the Coalition Government’s transformative vision ...
Firstly I want to thank OceanaGold for hosting our event today. Your operation at Waihi is impressive. I want to acknowledge local MP Scott Simpson, local government dignitaries, community stakeholders and all of you who have gathered here today. It’s a privilege to welcome you to the launch of the ...
Racing Minister, Winston Peters has announced the Government is preparing public consultation on GST policy proposals which would make the New Zealand racing industry more competitive. “The racing industry makes an important economic contribution. New Zealand thoroughbreds are in demand overseas as racehorses and for breeding. The domestic thoroughbred industry ...
Business confidence remains very high and shows the economy is on track to improve, Economic Growth Minister Nicola Willis says. “The latest ANZ Business Outlook survey, released yesterday, shows business confidence and expected own activity are ‘still both very high’.” The survey reports business confidence fell eight points to +54 ...
Enabling works have begun this week on an expanded radiology unit at Hawke’s Bay Fallen Soldiers’ Memorial Hospital which will double CT scanning capacity in Hawke’s Bay to ensure more locals can benefit from access to timely, quality healthcare, Health Minister Simeon Brown says. This investment of $29.3m in the ...
The Government has today announced New Zealand’s second international climate target under the Paris Agreement, Climate Change Minister Simon Watts says. New Zealand will reduce emissions by 51 to 55 per cent compared to 2005 levels, by 2035. “We have worked hard to set a target that is both ambitious ...
Nine years of negotiations between the Crown and iwi of Taranaki have concluded following Te Pire Whakatupua mō Te Kāhui Tupua/the Taranaki Maunga Collective Redress Bill passing its third reading in Parliament today, Treaty Negotiations Minister Paul Goldsmith says. “This Bill addresses the historical grievances endured by the eight iwi ...
As schools start back for 2025, there will be a relentless focus on teaching the basics brilliantly so all Kiwi kids grow up with the knowledge, skills and competencies needed to grow the New Zealand of the future, Education Minister Erica Stanford says. “A world-leading education system is a key ...
Housing Minister Chris Bishop and Associate Agriculture Minister Mark Patterson have welcomed Kāinga Ora’s decision to re-open its tender for carpets to allow wool carpet suppliers to bid. “In 2024 Kāinga Ora issued requests for tender (RFTs) seeking bids from suppliers to carpet their properties,” Mr Bishop says. “As part ...
Associate Education Minister David Seymour has today visited Otahuhu College where the new school lunch programme has served up healthy lunches to students in the first days of the school year. “As schools open in 2025, the programme will deliver nutritious meals to around 242,000 students, every school day. On ...
Minister for Children Karen Chhour has intervened in Oranga Tamariki’s review of social service provider contracts to ensure Barnardos can continue to deliver its 0800 What’s Up hotline. “When I found out about the potential impact to this service, I asked Oranga Tamariki for an explanation. Based on the information ...
A bill to make revenue collection on imported and exported goods fairer and more effective had its first reading in Parliament, Customs Minister Casey Costello said today. “The Customs (Levies and Other Matters) Amendment Bill modernises the way in which Customs can recover the costs of services that are needed ...
Minister of Internal Affairs Brooke van Velden says the Department of Internal Affairs [the Department] has achieved significant progress in completing applications for New Zealand citizenship. “December 2024 saw the Department complete 5,661 citizenship applications, the most for any month in 2024. This is a 54 per cent increase compared ...
Reversals to Labour’s blanket speed limit reductions begin tonight and will be in place by 1 July, says Minister of Transport Chris Bishop. “The previous government was obsessed with slowing New Zealanders down by imposing illogical and untargeted speed limit reductions on state highways and local roads. “National campaigned on ...
Finance Minister Nicola Willis has announced Budget 2025 – the Growth Budget - will be delivered on Thursday 22 May. “This year’s Budget will drive forward the Government’s plan to grow our economy to improve the incomes of New Zealanders now and in the years ahead. “Budget 2025 will build ...
For the Government, 2025 will bring a relentless focus on unleashing the growth we need to lift incomes, strengthen local businesses and create opportunity. Prime Minister Christopher Luxon today laid out the Government’s growth agenda in his Statement to Parliament. “Just over a year ago this Government was elected by ...
Associate Education Minister David Seymour welcomes students back to school with a call to raise attendance from last year. “The Government encourages all students to attend school every day because there is a clear connection between being present at school and setting yourself up for a bright future,” says Mr ...
The Government is relaxing visitor visa requirements to allow tourists to work remotely while visiting New Zealand, Economic Growth Minister Nicola Willis, Immigration Minister Erica Stanford and Tourism Minister Louise Upston say. “The change is part of the Government’s plan to unlock New Zealand’s potential by shifting the country onto ...
The opening of Kāinga Ora’s development of 134 homes in Epuni, Lower Hutt will provide much-needed social housing for Hutt families, Housing Minister Chris Bishop says. “I’ve been a strong advocate for social housing on Kāinga Ora’s Epuni site ever since the old earthquake-prone housing was demolished in 2015. I ...
Trade and Investment Minister Todd McClay will travel to Australia today for meetings with Australian Trade Minister, Senator Don Farrell, and the Australia New Zealand Leadership Forum (ANZLF). Mr McClay recently hosted Minister Farrell in Rotorua for the annual Closer Economic Relations (CER) Trade Ministers’ meeting, where ANZLF presented on ...
A new monthly podiatry clinic has been launched today in Wairoa and will bring a much-needed service closer to home for the Wairoa community, Health Minister Simeon Brown says.“Health New Zealand has been successful in securing a podiatrist until the end of June this year to meet the needs of ...
The Judicial Conduct Commissioner has recommended a Judicial Conduct Panel be established to inquire into and report on the alleged conduct of acting District Court Judge Ema Aitken in an incident last November, Attorney-General Judith Collins said today. “I referred the matter of Judge Aitken’s alleged conduct during an incident ...
Students who need extra help with maths are set to benefit from a targeted acceleration programme that will give them more confidence in the classroom, Education Minister Erica Stanford says. “Last year, significant numbers of students did not meet the foundational literacy and numeracy level required to gain NCEA. To ...
Foreign Affairs Minister Winston Peters has announced three new diplomatic appointments. “Our diplomats play an important role in ensuring New Zealand’s interests are maintained and enhanced across the world,” Mr Peters says. “It is a pleasure to announce the appointment of these senior diplomats from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and ...
Ki te kahore he whakakitenga, ka ngaro te Iwi – without a vision, the people will perish. The Government has achieved its target to reduce the number of households in emergency housing motels by 75 per cent five years early, Associate Housing Minister Tama Potaka says. The number of households ...
The opening of Palmerston North’s biggest social housing development will have a significant impact for whānau in need of safe, warm, dry housing, Associate Housing Minister Tama Potaka says. The minister visited the development today at North Street where a total of 50 two, three, and four-bedroom homes plus a ...
Foreign Minister Winston Peters has announced the new membership of the Public Advisory Committee on Disarmament and Arms Control (PACDAC), who will serve for a three-year term. “The Committee brings together wide-ranging expertise relevant to disarmament. We have made six new appointments to the Committee and reappointed two existing members ...
Ka nui te mihi kia koutou. Kia ora, good morning, talofa, malo e lelei, bula vinaka, da jia hao, namaste, sat sri akal, assalamu alaikum. It’s so great to be here and I’m ready and pumped for 2025. Can I start by acknowledging: Simon Bridges – CEO of the Auckland ...
The Government has unveiled a bold new initiative to position New Zealand as a premier destination for foreign direct investment (FDI) that will create higher paying jobs and grow the economy. “Invest New Zealand will streamline the investment process and provide tailored support to foreign investors, to increase capital investment ...
Science, Innovation and Technology Minister Judith Collins today announced the largest reset of the New Zealand science system in more than 30 years with reforms which will boost the economy and benefit the sector. “The reforms will maximise the value of the $1.2 billion in government funding that goes into ...
Turbocharging New Zealand’s economic growth is the key to brighter days ahead for all Kiwis, Prime Minister Christopher Luxon says. In the Prime Minister’s State of the Nation Speech in Auckland today, Christopher Luxon laid out the path to the prosperity that will affect all aspects of New Zealanders’ lives. ...
The latest set of accounts show the Government has successfully checked the runaway growth of public spending, Finance Minister Nicola Willis says. “In the previous government’s final five months in office, public spending was almost 10 per cent higher than for the same period the previous year. “That is completely ...
The Government’s welfare reforms are delivering results with the number of people moving off benefits into work increasing year-on-year for six straight months. “There are positive signs that our welfare reset and the return consequences for job seekers who don't fulfil their obligations to prepare for or find a job ...
Jon Kroll and Aimee McCammon have been appointed to the New Zealand Film Commission Board, Arts Minister Paul Goldsmith says. “I am delighted to appoint these two new board members who will bring a wealth of industry, governance, and commercial experience to the Film Commission. “Jon Kroll has been an ...
Finance Minister Nicola Willis has hailed a drop in the domestic component of inflation, saying it increases the prospect of mortgage rate reductions and a lower cost of living for Kiwi households. Stats NZ reported today that inflation was 2.2 per cent in the year to December, the second consecutive ...
Two new appointed members and one reappointed member of the Employment Relations Authority have been announced by Workplace Relations and Safety Minister Brooke van Velden today. “I’m pleased to announce the new appointed members Helen van Druten and Matthew Piper to the Employment Relations Authority (ERA) and welcome them to ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra The battle to contain antisemitism in Australia finds both sides of politics embracing measures they’d otherwise abhor. Spectacularly, the government capitulated this week to include mandatory minimum sentences of between one and six years ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Henry Cutler, Professor and Director, Macquarie University Centre for the Health Economy, Macquarie University This week, the federal government announced it will pay states and territories an extra, one-off, A$1.7 billion for public hospitals. This has been billed as a way ...
From the dawn ceremony to the numerous local performances and powerful words, Waitangi Day 2025 was one to remember, but a highlight would have to be the record turn-out of waka. ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Joshua Black, Visitor, School of History, Australian National University The Albanese government is trying once more to legislate wide-ranging changes to the way federal elections are administered. The 200-page Electoral Reform Bill, if passed, would transform the electoral donation rules by ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Lorana Bartels, Professor of Criminology, Australian National University Shutterstock Weeks after Opposition Leader Peter Dutton announced his support for mandatory minimum jail terms for antisemitic offences, the government has legislated such laws. Minister for Home Affairs Tony Burke stated the federal ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Moninya Roughan, Professor in Oceanography, UNSW Sydney Australia’s sea surface temperatures were the warmest on record last year, according to a snapshot of the nation’s climate which underscores the perilous state of the world’s oceans. The Bureau of Meteorology on Thursday released ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Amanda Meyer, Senior Lecturer, Anatomy and Pathology, James Cook University A common anatomical variation is being born with more than ten fingers or more than ten toes. Former Doctor Who actor David Tennant this week confirmed he has 11 toes. He says ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Mandy Hagstrom, Senior Lecturer, Exercise Physiology. School of Health Sciences, UNSW Sydney Sokirlov/Shutterstock Callisthenics is a type of training where you do bodyweight exercises to build strength. It’s versatile, low cost, and easy to start. Classic callisthenics moves include: ...
The Mood of the Workforce survey, conducted annually by the New Zealand Council of Trade Unions Te Kauae Kaimahi, lays bare the brutal reality of life under capitalism in Aotearoa New Zealand. ...
Some aspects of next year’s Waitangi commemorations could be moved back down to Te Tii Marae, with both political leaders and Māori leaders saying the lower marae is an appropriate place for political debates.Waitangi Treaty Grounds Trust chair Pita Tipene said he supported moving some aspects of Waitangi week commemorations ...
Inundated with end-of-year lists, we all had big plans to do a lot of reading-for-pleasure over the holidays. Here’s what we ended up reading. Despite the gazillion end-of-year reading lists and recommendations for the very latest books, summer is often a time for reading wildly. Whether it’s finally pulling a ...
How do I deal with the fact my own flesh and blood would rather listen to Mumford & Sons than Talking Heads? Want Hera’s help? Email your problem to helpme@thespinoff.co.nzKia ora!As a recovering music snob who once preferred the bands’ older stuff, hated “mainstream music” and actively avoided ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Milad Haghani, Associate Professor & Principal Fellow in Urban Risk & Resilience, The University of Melbourne Edward Lorenz’s mathematical weather model showed solutions with a butterfly-like shape.Wikimol In 1972, the US meteorologist Edward Lorenz asked a now-famous question: Does the ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Fan Yang, Research fellow at Melbourne Law School, the University of Melbourne and the ARC Centre of Excellence for Automated Decision-Making and Society., The University of Melbourne Shutterstock Migrants in Australia often encounter disinformation targeting their communities. However, disinformation circulated in ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Anna Lintern, Senior Lecturer in Civil Engineering, specialising in water quality, Monash University Polluted runoff is still smothering the Great Barrier Reef, our first national assessment of water quality trends in Australian rivers has revealed. The problem on the reef is getting ...
Comment: As a parent approaching the first ‘back to school’ week with my oldest child, the end of summer break is bittersweet.It’s safe to say my partner and I are relieved we won’t parenting 24/7, but with our kids getting back ‘out there’, I know they, along with the thousands ...
A year after the Treaty principles bill was first debated on the Treaty Grounds, mana whenua are now turning their backs to David Seymour.Our Waitangi 2025 coverage is possible because of the 13,000-plus Spinoff members who regularly pay to support our work. If you aren’t a member yet, now is the time. ...
Treaty of Waitangi negotiations minister Paul Goldsmith is eager to see a Ngāpuhi settlement, as are leaders from within the iwi. What’s stopping progress? Our Waitangi 2025 coverage is possible because of the 13,000-plus Spinoff members who regularly pay to support our work. If you aren’t a member yet, now is ...
Six years ago, most New Zealanders assumed the state’s practice of uplifting children from their families and placing them in foster care was almost always justified.It seemed unimaginable our child welfare agency, Oranga Tamariki, would remove a mother’s baby without good reason.But that all changed on June 6, 2019, when ...
Loading…(function(i,s,o,g,r,a,m){var ql=document.querySelectorAll('A[data-quiz],DIV[data-quiz]'); if(ql){if(ql.length){for(var k=0;k<ql.length;k++){ql[k].id='quiz-embed-'+k;ql[k].href="javascript:var i=document.getElementById('quiz-embed-"+k+"');try{qz.startQuiz(i)}catch(e){i.start=1;i.style.cursor='wait';i.style.opacity='0.5'};void(0);"}}};i['QP']=r;i[r]=i[r]||function(){(i[r].q=i[r].q||[]).push(arguments)},i[r].l=1*new Date();a=s.createElement(o),m=s.getElementsByTagName(o)[0];a.async=1;a.src=g;m.parentNode.insertBefore(a,m)})(window,document,'script','https://take.quiz-maker.com/3012/CDN/quiz-embed-v1.js','qp');Got a good quiz question?Send Newsroom your questions.The post Newsroom daily quiz, Thursday 6 February appeared first on Newsroom. ...
New Zealand is now a real force in ice swimming after team members returned from the sixth ice swimming world championships with four world titles and six world records.Per capita, New Zealand was top of the open medal table after being off the podium two years ago. The Frozen Ferns, the ...
Brian Turner has died. A major New Zealand author, primarily as a poet of the Otago landscape but also as a sometimes intensely argumentative essayist with a very real loathing of forces and people wishing to destroy the Otago landscape, Turner died yesterday morning, at sunrise, after a heart attack. ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Tamer Morris, Senior lecturer, international law, University of Sydney In an astonishing news conference in Washington, US President Donald Trump proposed the United States “take over” the Gaza Strip and permanently relocate the nearly two million Palestinians living there to neighbouring countries. ...
The chair of the Waitangi National Trust says among the politicking and challenges of what has fast become a controversial pōwhiri, Chris Hipkins’ vision for moving forward together presents “a ray of sunshine”.Pita Tipene said the Labour leader offered “a whole lot of hope” in his promises to return each ...
Nicola Willis’ plans for corporate tax reform need to have more meat than the paltry income ‘tax relief’ delivered last year, which failed to even account for bracket creep. ...
We need more democratic accountability, not less.
On the goverment referendum on a four year term.
Most NZ governments, serve more than one term.
There have only been two -one term – governments in New Zealand's entire history of parliamentary politics.
Nine years is more than enough time for any administration to achieve their policy goals.
Even in 6 years a less common two term government can enact a lot. And if a lot of what they enact is unpopular, we can remove them before they can enact (and embed), even more unpopular legislation
We need more youth engagement in our democracy, not less.
Moving to a 4 year term will disenfranchise young people even more than our electoral system does now.
If a young person turns 18 just after an election, they will not be able to vote for the first time until they are 22.
If a four year term is enacted it must also enact young people's demand to ‘Make It 16’.
We need more democracy, not less.
Don't vote for less democracy.
Vote no to a four year electoral term
P.S. As most wars are over in four years. A four year term government could take us into a war and not have to account for their actions for four long years. Four years is way too long for New Zealanders to be dying and killing in an upopular war, without democratic oversight.
We need less wars, not more.
Vote no to a four year electoral term
What war Jenny?
If there was a war that NZ were to be involved then that is for the government and parliament, who have been democratically elected by the people of this country.
It is unlikely that NZ would become involved with the war in the Ukraine. But worst case scenario, we certainly won’t be on the side of Russia.
Should things go to custard in the Middle East, which I doubt, NZ is most likely to be neutral or on the side of NATO.
David @1.1.1 makes it very clear, why lengthening the parliamentary term and lowering the age of Franchise are inextricably linked.
Not only could a government take us into a war with out a clear mandate from the voting public, and keep us in that war, without any democratic oversight for four long years, a sizable number of 19 to to 23 year olds could be consripted and forced to kill and die for that government, a government that they never voted for, or were even allowed to vote for.
Sounds more fascist than democratic to me.
Yet another distraction folks.
Indeed.
Playing another referendum distraction card <1 year after our CoC govt (by landLords, for landLords) was formed seems panicked – 'honest' John waited 5 years to float the idea of a new flag referendum <9 months before Election 2014.
Expect further distractions to flow thick and quick from our self-serving CoC govt, while they get the flow of gravy temporarily "back on track".
Correct; no civilisation lasts (just look at the Romans). People, especially politicians who like to talk big, need to remember that.
The universe will end one day too, according to Brian Cox on BBC's The Infinite Monkey Cage, series 22.
But that's no reason for Mike Joy and others to give up fighting for clean water,.
Yup, another red flag referendum.
Jenny @1
24 September 2024 at 9:00 am
Democracy, or more pointedly, efforts to limit democracy, are an important issue.
Yes , they are trying to distract you, they are trying to distract you with what they can do over a longer term with less accountability.
I am actually for 16 and 17 year olds being able to vote because of the three year cycle, even more so if it's a four year cycle. It seem crazy that for some people the first time they get to vote is not until they are almost 21, or almost 22 if it goes to a four year cycle.
And they could make it a national standard for year 10 in schools – NZ govt and voting.
Shifting the voting age earlier, simply shifts the window of age for the people who 'miss out'. If you shift it to 16, then you have all of the 15-year-olds who will be shock, horror almost 19 before they get to vote for the first time.
Given that virtually no 16-year-olds are living independently in NZ anymore, it doesn't seem like a huge ask for them to wait to 18 before they can vote.
Teenagers are not adults. They don't have fully developed brains (brain re-wiring in teens is well known, and not even controversial), which is why we limit their liability for criminal penalties, and limit their ability to drive (among other things, requiring the ability to predict the future consequences of their actions) – why should voting be different?
Unpacking unsubstantiated prejudice
I well remember the stulpifying and patrlponising mock elections teachers made us suffer at highschool when the election cycle came around. Nothing surer would turn young people away from political engagement than having to sit in faux voting civic lessons.
I don't know whether high schools still do this, maybe instead they ignore the national ballot altogether. Different method same result. Disengagement in our democratic process. The lesson being, elections are not important.
All the more reason that the age of franchise should be lowered. At 18 young people have a lot going on, leaving home, starting work, flatting, finding life partners.
Taking the time to consider and discuss the wider issues with their peers and mentors,and making informed decisions and voting, maybe not so much.
Studies have shown that young people who don't vote the first time, are likely to make a habit of it.
Personally I would advocate the lowering of the voting age to 15. So that young people would have the experience of democracy and voting at least once during their formative years while they are still at High School and at home, to form those habits, befor negotiating the burdens and complexities of young adulthood.
All political parties that want the youth vote should have to put their arguments before young people, address their school assemblies, let them read their pamphlets, encourage them to watch their debates on the media of their choice.
Rather than sterile ethics lessons. Let them know their views and opinions count. By making their opinions count.
This can only enrich our democracy.
Many pundits have remarked on the many young people in the most prestigous uniiversities in the Western world taking up the cause of the Palestinians in Gaza.
Why? many have asked, have the sons and daughters of the most privileged sections of society who as adults will be those who benefit from the most from privileges of empire and colonialism, have empathy for those most oppressed by empire and colonialism.
Maybe it is because their brains are still re-wiring. Maybe it is because their brains have not become calcified by adulthood,
Gosh, that boils down to: 'I think younger teens are more likely to vote for my party, so they should be allowed to vote'
Gosh, that boils down to;
'I think younger teens are more likely to vote against my party, so they should not be allowed to vote'
And you wouldn't be wrong.
University of Waikato
https://www.waikato.ac.nz › news-events › news › budg…
17 Jun 2024
The rolling back of environmental protections and climate action advanced by the previous Labour administration comes as no surprise.
With no new investment to combat climate change in last month’s budget, and a long list of cuts to climate and environment-related areas, the government risks damaging its global reputation…..
As you can see for yourself Belladonna, climate change is an issue that young people are concerned about, concerned enough about to protest in tens of thousands. And probably, if they were allowed to vote, they would vote in the same numbers against the parties you support.
Make it 16
But you knew that, even if only instinctivly.
The thing is that you are not asking them to wait until 18 to vote, you are asking some of them to wait until they are almost 21 to vote.
Noone is saying that 16 and 17 years old must vote – only that 1/3 of them (on average) would get the choice.
The same is true whichever age you pick. There will always be those who 'just' miss out on turning X and have to wait until the next election.
Really Belladonna?
Is that your argument? Reductive reasoning, taken to its extreme?
In my opinion the test for franchise should be; can X years old organise collective political action on a local or national scale?
If we are going to be reductive, could 1 year olds, or even 10 year olds organise a nationwide strike for the climate, or for any other issue affecting them?
Obviously not.
I've yet to see any argument from you explaining why 16 is more justifiable than 18.
Your entire argument seems to be that 16-year-olds are more likely to vote left, so we should encourage them.
Meanwhile – there are plenty of 40 year olds who can't organize collective political action on a local or national scale. Why should they be able to vote – if that is your entry level criteria?
For that matter, I've yet to see any 16 year olds organizing a nationwide strike for climate (or any other issue). The best they've been able to achieve is a nice day out protesting – 'but don't let it affect my exam results….'
My argument is that 18 is currently the closest we come to an 'official' adult level of responsibility in NZ. It's recognized in a whole lot of legislative and legal areas. The only thing that 16 is a threshold for, is beginning the process of getting your driving license, and legal sex.
Many have argued to make it 16, and I like the idea – agree to disagree?
https://nzccss.org.nz/submission/inquiry-into-the-2023-general-election/
https://nzhistory.govt.nz/te-akomanga/contexts-activities/should-voting-age-be-lowered-to-16
https://www.makeit16.org.nz/
Lowering voting age to 16 'not a matter of if, but when' [2 June 2024]
Not contributing to the tax base, pensioners, pernanent invalids, sickness benificiaries, unemployed, sole parents on the DPB, injured people on ACC.
There are many categories of voters who are not contributing to the tax base.
Belladonna is clutching at straws.
Contributing, or not contributing to the tax base are not grounds for withholding the franchise from anyone.
To which I migt add, we go to extraordianry lengths to make sure those who ar incapitated in one way or the other, (whether they are taxpayers or not), can vote.
And so we should.
Belladonna may well be a self-declared respectful political centrist, but this debate reveals herself as being at home with Right Wing voter suppression based on tax paying status and age
[You’re back to your old habits of overly long comments containing too many links and relying (too much) on quotes from others. I remind you of a previous warning regarding this behaviour here: https://thestandard.org.nz/open-mike-06-01-2024/#comment-1983432 – Incognito]
Mod note
Wrong on both counts.
In this country the threshold for attaining the majority of 'official adult levels of responsibility' is not '18' it is 16.
The exceptions are:
In NZ at age 16 you can:
Can't enforce a legal contract under 18.
While you can begin the process to acquire a firearms license or pilot license – at 16 (like a driver's license) you're most unlikely to gain one under 18.
If you can't see that the privilege of voting is equivalent to the other age-restricted activities of 18+ – then I guess that there is no point in discussing further.
I could be open to a conditional argument – if you are aged 16, living independently, and have a full-time job – then you're contributing to the tax base, and are entitled to vote. NB: I'd say there are very few Kiwis who would fall into this category.
Problem for you, is that the majority of people who would fall into this category are unlikely to be left-wing voters.
According to Belladonna young left wing voters are dependent unemployed bludgers who shouldn't be allowed to vote.
Using Belladonna's reductionist logic –
I would suggest that Belladonna try telling this to pensioners and come back to us with the results.
Then she might get some inkling into why 16 year olds want the right to vote.
If you're interested in the voting patterns of pensioners, then I suggest you do the research.
Meanwhile – I note that you haven't actually responded to the points I made – no doubt that is too great a challenge for you.
Any evidence that the majority of under-18-year olds are actually tax-positive members of society (that is, they contribute more in taxes than they consume)? It seems highly unlikely. Especially given that the majority of them are in school.
That's not in itself bad, education is a pathway to a better job (or, at least it is for most people). However, it's difficult to argue that they are therefore more entitled than (say) 10-year-olds to a be allowed to vote.
Requiring 16-year-olds to wait for 2 years before they can vote, is hardly a major infringement of their political rights.
And your entire argument seems to be that 16-year-olds are more likely to vote left, so we should discourage them.
I am not afraid of how 16 year olds will vote, but you are. And as you have argued, you have a good reason to be afraid.
Your fear of extending the franchise to 16 year olds is the same fear conservatives had to extending the franchise to working people, to black people, to women,
No sunshine, my argument is that:
Quite frankly, I don't believe that there would be thousands of voters (for any political party) in the 16-18 band. Most teens don't care – and they go on not caring right through their 20s and 30s (there's a tiny boost in the excitement of first time voting – which quickly tails off)
https://elections.nz/media-and-news/2023/election-turnout-by-age-and-descent/
And, if the limitation of the franchise to 18+ is perceived as so grossly unfair, by those it applies to – they'll be highly motivated to get out and vote when they qualify. Clearly they aren't …..
I never accused you of being corrupt, politically or otherwise.
Personally, I don't think you are corrupt, Belladonna.
You are just defending your class position.
And are most likely completely sincere in your views.
I just pointed out the flaws in your argument and mirroried them back to you.
The fact that you unfortunately feel I accused you of being politically corrupt, when I ddn't do so, says more about you than it does about me.
Quite frankly, I agree with you that most16 and 17 year olds won't care. But it's worth that so that people don't have to wait until they are almost 21 to be able to vote. And if 18-30 years old don't bother to vote, that is not a good reason to take away their ability to vote.
Not at all. I am just in love with democracy.
Everyone should have a say in the decisions that affect them, (and their families)
Demoeracy should be a for all, for young and old, the healthy, the sick, the enfeeblied, the well, the incarcerated the free, the rich the poor the taxpayers the benificiaries. Regardless of race religion ethniticy or origin.
Every, single one of us, every Goddamned soul!
I would like to empower all our citizens, by extending democracy into all areas of collective decision making that affects society.
I have long argued, in these pages, and other place, for the full return of the franchise to all New Zealand citizens in our our prison system, that were last granted to prisoners during the Kirk/Rowling administration. (arguably the most left Post WWII government of this country) and partially restored under during the Ardern/Hipkins administration. (arguably the second most left Post WWII government of this country)
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia;
It is important to remember Belladonna is conservative right wing posing as a centrist, which to be frank is something all people claiming to be centrist are, and do.
That bit does seem to be corrupt.
It's important to remember that Muttonbird translates all political views through his filter as a hard left apologist.
He's clearly unacquainted with any people who have right wing views, or centrists ones for that matter – and must live entirely in a rose-coloured bubble of left-wing propaganda.
If you deny that political centrists exist, and characterize them all as right-wing, you'd better get used to the political wilderness – because Centrists are the ones who decide governments in NZ.
B's commenting history here does seem more consistent with a right-wing political perspective than a centrist perspective, which is fine as far as it goes. However, imho the taint of deceit (i.e. the "respectful centrist" claim) does B's comments no favours – it's a distracting inconsistency. Still, self-serving righties (and lefties) will have their reasons for attempting to project/adopt false personas/identities.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Garrett_(politician)#Criminal_offences
The centre cannot hold
Fintan O’Toole on Pre-fascism and the ‘Yeats test’
https://soundcloud.com/irishtimes-politics/fintan-otoole-on-pre-fascism
https://newsroom.co.nz/2024/09/10/govt-resolute-in-allowing-10yos-to-be-treated-as-criminals/
Belladonna has made it quite clear that she is fearful that young voters will vote left.
Her fear is not of young voters per se, but of young left voters.
Belladonna writes she 'could be open' to young people voting, 'conditional' to young people who might vote right.
Jenny has made it quite clear that she is hopeful that young voters will vote left.
Her anticipation is of gaining left votes, rather than rights for young voters, per se.
Just as politically corrupt, as she's accusing me of being.
Hey Sunshine, it's disappointing that B, a self-declared respectful political centrist, might be open to relaxing their resistance to 'Make it 16' only for young Kiwis who are "contributing to the tax base".
The Universal Declaration of Human Rights places no such condition on voting rights, but some Kiwis will have little time for a declaration which makes no mention of tax, or a Taxpayers' Union

Article 21
“However, Austria was the first European nation to lower its voting age in 2011.“, so it is possible for a capitalist country to make such a progressive change without everything going to hell in a handbasket.
https://www.worldatlas.com/articles/legal-voting-age-by-country.html
10 years olds can smoke and drink – they just aren't allowed to purchase alcohol or cigarettes.
Applying the same reductionist logic of Belleadonna
10 years olds, would be allowed to purchase alcohol, cigarettes.and guns, 'conditional' on them being in the right tax bracket.
Putting aside all reductionist absurdity Belladonna's claim that she would be open for granting voting rights to young people conditonal on their tax status is not new idea.
At the beginning of parliamentary politics in this country, and indeed in most capitalist countries of the time the franchise was granted on property rights.
I would argue that a three-year term is too short. I don't think history of how long each government lasts – one, two or more terms – is the key issue here.
The key issue is that the electoral cycle of three years means more or less constant politicking. The first year of a government doing what it has promised to do (yeah right), one year of doing what it REALLY wants to do (and we are getting a whiff of that now) and a year of making promises for the next election.
Most comparable democracies run over a four or five year term legislature. I would support a four year term with one proviso: that we also have an upper house. New Zealand is almost unique in that it has a unicameral parliamentary system. That, in my mind, gives too much untrammelled power to the Executive Council which is essentially the PM, Finance Minister and other senior ministers.
However I doubt that an upper house would get much support. Also the timing of this referendum is important: Whenever a referendum like this is held the result tends to mirror the present state of popularity of the ruling government. If the government is popular then more people will like a four-year term. If it is unpopular then more people will favour a three-year term because they want the b..s out. The last referendum on a four year term was in the 1990 election and it was pretty soundly defeated along with the Rogernome government.
This is also what happened in the 1993 vote for MMP or FPP. I believe that MMP won, at least in part, because both National and Labour had lost popularity and many voters felt that supporting a new system that neither Labour nor National particularly liked was a good way of showing both the middle finger.
I also support lowering the voting age to 16.
'Keep politics out of politics'
The Right often claim there is 'too much politiks', (sic). What the Right really mean when they say there is too much politics, is that there is too much democracy.
In line with the Right keeping politics out of 'as many places as possible' Mike the Lefty, wants to keep 'politiks' (sic) out of parliament.
What the hell?
Parliament is where the most politics should be encouraged.
Mike the Lefty @1.4
24 September 2024 at 3:4
…..I also support lowering the voting age to 16.
Good to hear.
I support Make it 16 as a matter of general principal. In my opinion the more democracy the better.
I have suggested that if we have to go to four year term, (a move I don'support), then lowering the age of franchise must be a minimum demand of the Left.
If we have to go to four year term a minimum demand of the Lef, must be the return of the primacy of parliament over government.
If a government is acting so egregiously against the welfare of this country and its people that some government MPs are moved to cross the floor to vote with the opposition, they won't be expelled from parliament.
Until that happens, we don't have a genuine democracy, we have an unfettered elected dictatorship. The only real check we have on that elected dictatorship is to remove it every three years, For those who quite like elected dictatorships, once every three years is not enogh to do whatever they like with us, four years would be better Those who support elected dictatorship would be quite comfortable efor an elected dictatorship to even order us into war, whether we wanted to, or not. Whether it is a just war, or not, Whether we supported it or not.
Yay, for elected dictatorship from David
The last Labour Government had set in place economic arrangements with the plan of completing the embedding over the 3rd term. Alas they lost and the CoC were able to abolish so much because the plans were not embedded enough.
So a 4 year term would not have helped would it.
What stopped them?
They had a majority with no coalition partners to halt them (unlike the first term where NZ First prevented them from doing progressive things).
It was a once in a generation opportunity to do brave things. Everyone knew that even if Labour won in 2023, they would lose that absolute majority. But in knowing that they failed to deliver the restructure we needed, an will struggle to ever that opportunity again.
All those working from home who have been ordered back to the workplace have been told by the lovely Willis and Luxon that they must buy coffees and their lunches and pay transport fares and after school care and spend plenty in the shops as well. The sheer gall as they try to deflect the outcome of their policies.
But not one word about the effect of all those she ordered to be made redundant who are not out spending.
As for the word "entitlementl" they used – Mr Entitlement himself and his $56,000 to live in his own apartment!
The sheer hypocrisy, arrogance and impudence of the 'order' staggers me. As you say, it is an attempt to place the blame of the outcome of their own actions onto public servants. But its more than just that. They have an ideologically-based hatred of public servants and institutions and are out to demonise them at every possible turn.
Nicola Willis has to be the most venal and arrogant woman politician who has ever graced a NZ parliament and that's saying something because there's strong competitors past and present.
"….the most venal and arrogant woman politician who has ever graced a NZ parliament "
Bit early for that IMO, stanford, upston and fan favorite judith probably be in for that also with pullya benefits advice available if required from her sinecure at pharmac.
Honorable mentions to Tolley, Parata IMO
Ruth Richardson and Jenny Shipley were not particularly pleasant either.
Could be – Nicotine Willis is quick out of the blocks, insincere, and giving Richardson a run for all money when it comes to punching down on 'bottom feeders'.
https://waateanews.com/2024/05/21/hardly-the-mother-of-all-budgets-more-like-a-miser-on-the-beads-and-blankets/
Yes. It's interesting how some on the Right viewed the stay at home orders during the pandemic as coercive government over-reach. But it is apparently OK to order people back into the office when there is no evidence presented showing that the current arrangements around work from home make the Public Service less effective.
So for the right-wing mind, coercion is bad if it's in the common good (public health during a pandemic), but great if it serves the interests of inner city Wellington businesses.
They are the new authoritarians – who are just the same as the old authoritarians.
Government wants to order the public servants working from home to go back to the office.
Inner city cafes and restaurant owners and other inner city businesses say they need the foot traffic.
As Reality says above, no mention of the public service workers laid off and no longer coming into town. And who without jobs are probably spending less in their community as wll
Working from home is a cost saving, eating and cooking groceries at home, is much cheaper than buying lunch at a cafe, or lunch bar. Then there is the cost of transport.
The government expect public servants to bear all this cost to subsidise private business.
If Willis is ordering public servant back to the office so they can put money in the pockets of inner city business owners. Then she must first put more money in the pockets of the public servants..
It is about the landlords losing tenants and rental income and property value.
They don't really care about the small business owners.
And government having a lot of now under-utilised office space now that they've laid off 6000 public servants, most of them were probably in the office.
Once the leases run out they'll probably not renew some spaces and encourage some staff to WFH again to reduce the footprint.
Which is how WFH came about, to reduce the amount of office space the government, or private employer had to lease, and shift the cost of that onto the employee.
But hey, framing it all about productivity, rather than layoffs, is really just an admission that the layoffs have tanked outputs and hence productivity.
Hopefully they will take turns parking in the boss's space.
While the world is focused on the plight of Gazans Sudan's healthcare and education systems have collapsed, 19 million Sudanese face food insecurity, 13 million Sudanese have been displaced and an estimated 75,000 people have died.
But never let a crisis go unexploited…
/
'Threat to culture' in Sudan is unprecedented
"The situation is really bad," says Munich Museum of Egyptian Art director, Arnulf Schlüter.
He does not know whether the archaeological project will ever be resumed.
"Most of the excavation workers have fled, the excavation house has been broken into and the tires of the vehicles have been stolen. The antiquities site lies defenseless."
Museums and artifacts are being destroyed and looted across the country amid a severe humanitarian crisis — more than 10 million Sudanese people are displaced and half of the country's 50 million inhabitants are experiencing hunger.
https://www.dw.com/en/war-torn-sudan-faces-cultural-ruin/a-70284737
September 22, 2024 (PORT SUDAN) — A Russian trade delegation has been in talks with Sudanese officials about starting gold extraction from multiple sites in the country as soon as next month, government sources told Sudan Tribune.
The discussions follow the signing in June of an agreement for gold exploration and extraction between Sudan’s Ministry of Minerals and the Russian company Zarubezhgeologiya.
https://sudantribune.com/article291246/
https://www.cfr.org/global-conflict-tracker/conflict/power-struggle-sudan
Tough break Police Commissioner Coster.
You're definitely leaving with your head held high.
Hope you aren't lost to New Zealand.
Agree 100% I think Coster has done a good job despite having been criticised badly especially by the like of Simon Bridges ex National Party Leader.
He has got my vote. What a guy.
The Right hated him.
The right hated what Labour was making him do. The right actually like him or else he wouldn't have been appointed to the new role.
He going to be the new chief of the Social Investment Agency. Not good for women after coming from such a male dominated area – both the villains and the police.
The proof of the pudding is in the eating. It will be interesting to see what he does in this role.
I wonder how long it will be before the Nanny State meme takes hold regards this coalition.
Seymour micro managing school lunches now Willis telling companies how to deal with staff.
There have been a couple of other examples but they slip my mind at the moment.
Exactly. If it had been Labour doing the same thing ZB Newstalk trolls would be working overtime.
But strangely not a murmur.
It's a daddy state.
Controlling, do as I say not as I do, paternalistic, uncaring, cold, might is right, survival of the fittest, …….
Thanks for the reminder about gender in phrases.
What was fine in the 20th century is now a bit dodge.
Willis is telling government departments how to manage staff – not 'companies'.
Outside the beltway, with the class of Kiwis who have to be present in their workplaces to do their jobs (tradies, cleaners, nurses, etc.) – this will go down very well indeed. Perks for civil servants are rarely popular.
Yeah, nah.
I'm one of what you describe, a school caretaker and see, once again, the hypocricy of this regime.
When Labour do it, they shriek overreach.
And are all of your colleagues equally outraged that Wellington civil servants may have to work in the office, rather than from home? I think it highly unlikely.
Yes, I'm sure it's another gendered issue.
“And are all of your colleagues equally outraged that Wellington civil servants may have to work in the office, rather than from home? ”
I'll ask.
I'll also ask at home (a nurse).
I have three children who work in the private sector in three different cities in two different countries. All three work from home and get bonuses and pay increases due to their high productivity.
All of them have no local manager but meet with their managers mainly on-line and every now and then (two monthly to quarterly) the manager will tour around and one on one with the staff.
The savings on not needing a local manager and the same office space as previously is quite large. Technology has enabled this for all of them and was happening anyway. All that happened really is that the COVID response sped up the software development and the thinking and the practice e.g. online conferencing now is miles better than the start of COVID with much better integration into other mail, etc. Minute taking in one son’s case is done automatically as a meeting progresses using AI.
Much more work can be done from anywhere and this will continue to grow and develop – just like on-line shopping has gone from niche to mainstream. Just like good restaurants pivoted from predominantly customers in the door to home delivery (and even beyond that to ghost kitchens).
Many businesses are no longer constrained by only having access to the best local talent – they now have access to a broader range. My kids are constantly being head hunted with job offers – from businesses not even in their locality.
Tis a new world and Luxon is behaving like a Luddite.
No doubt this will also be available to the Wellington civil servants, should they decide that WFH is more valuable to them than their current jobs.
No doubt. I'm just pointing out that much of the private sector has realised the benefits, productivity gains and cost savings.
I'm old fashioned and concerned about office costs being effectively pushed on to them but the one in Oz earns miles more than I do plus gets 14% super so is not overly worried about that. He is also totally flexible about going into the office when needed so tis a mutual win/win for both him and his employer.
The problem I see is that his generation are much more likely to up and leave which doesn't bode well I suspect for the future public service. Maybe that is the intention……..
I think that the ones who are likely to leave (because the allure of higher wages is greater than the tug of home) – will do so in any case. You're not going to suddenly decide to immigrate to Australia because you have to work in the office – there will be plenty of other factors in play.
I work in a place where hybrid (WFH and in office) and entirely remote are both accommodated. It's very much based on productivity (not entitlement), and is sometimes a way of retaining highly valued staff who are not able to work in the office for a period of time.
It can work. Some jobs are more 'friendly' to this than others – and typically jobs which can be siloed off, or are highly measurable are more successful. However, there is no denying that some of the other benefits of working in the office (e.g. collaborative decision making, innovation, training, coaching and mentoring) simply don't work as well with remote staff.
I've been working over the last 6 weeks implementing a contract with a government department. All of the people I've been working with are largely (or entirely) WFH. It's been a nightmare trying to co-ordinate their staff for meetings, and/or decision-making. I don't know how much of this is public service slowness, and how much is the fact that they're never together to talk issues through. But the whole implementation schedule has already blown out to double the scheduled time – and I'm picking 4x before we're operational.
"And are all of your colleagues equally outraged that Wellington civil servants may have to work in the office, rather than from home? I think it highly unlikely."
Who new blue collar workers were so progressive?
One colleague reckons ns good on them, if it's available go for it. The other doesn't have an opinion on it.
The nurse ( my SO), reckons from what she has heard, productivity goes up when work from home is available so is a good thing.
All of which is a distraction from my point, this regime is looking to micro manage the trivial while making a right royal balls-up of the important stuff. eg Rail able ferries ($1B so far and nothing to show for it).
The (right wing) government meddling in the classroom and now meddling in the workplace.
Exactly the kind of thing the same people would have been appopletic about if it had been a Labour government. Flexibility appears to no longer be welcomed in the workplace.
And note the hospitality industry naively thinking everything will be business as usual once everyone is ordered back to the office.
Minus the thousands who will no longer have a job, of course.
Enjoyed this comment on reddit:
Of course Luxon/Willis have no clue, It was a fact-free reckon and they never have research but have an enormous whipping power over their loyal subject-voters, as all the Reddits and Tweets are showing them all out for a bash.
Also many of us will have forgotten the predilection of RW govts to grind down on public servants who traditionally are not able to defend themselves, sort of bully governing.
Incidentally I worked from home first in the early 1980s and then at various times during my career. My staff did as well. As a manager of staff I did not find it difficult to manage out of office workers. Mine were always in Wgtn but colleagues managed staff across NZ. They have work programmes and deadlines and with tech it is much easier than it used to be.
So a smokescreen so what are they using this to divert our attention from?
Not the first display of contradiction. I speculate that we may be entering a political epoch characterised by hypocricy. Seymour, the right wing libertarian wants to centralise the lunch supply of hungry children.
Not trying to undermine the working from home vibe, but why do these folk seem to 'have' to buy their lunch. I make my lunch 4 days a week, often leftovers and once a week support the local tuck shop. Or is it a city folk thing?
Commuting/parking/travel costs I understand.
Never developed packed lunch skills, so usually did without – not ideal; not lethal.
In my last year of paid employment, I developed a taste for cranberry OSM* bars – made in NZ, just not by me!
https://www.osm.nz/
* I have no pecuniary interest in OSM®
Many do make their lunches and many don't join the coffee throngs, many eat their lunch at their desks and don't take a break of half an hour let alone an hour.
It was the juxtaposition of moaning coffee bar owners swiftly followed by a edict to cease work from home that had many puzzling as to whether the Nacts were doing this to ensure that staff were in town buying.
Many don't buy in town but now have to meet increased travel costs. I doubt in Wgtn whether the bus transport could cope if all workers went back to working in town. Generally in my 35 or so years catching them to work here in Wgtn they were P**s P**r, unreliable and hence the reason I walked to the next suburb to catch buses as several routes came through. This was good exercise but was of necessity as the buses could not be relied on to get you in to town for a specific time. Ok if you had flexible hours but perhaps Nicola Wlllis has a friend that is not supportive of flexible hours ans this will be the next to be questioned
I remember times when Nats were in Govt and the ethos was very cruel and unashamedly and blatantly so. I worked in the Beehive on one of these ocasions Nat appointed staff seemed to have the idea that public servants were political appointments or if they were not, brought political sentiments to the job. The concept of apolitical was unknown to them…..after a year or so they got out of this mindset. It amused me that one of the most recalcitrant 'public servants as political animals' believers later was proud to be headhunted into one of these so-called 'political' agencies.
The first year of a right wing govt is usually hell on wheels for public servants/public sector agencies, the first year of a left wing one not so much. The old concept of 'gentlemanly' old school Nats who were good Ministers from the beginning is long gone.
No, because it's the natses, it'll be A Firm Hand On The Tiller.