web analytics

Polity: Income mobility

Written By: - Date published: 12:43 pm, November 21st, 2014 - 17 comments
Categories: David Farrar, treasury - Tags: ,

polity_square_for_lynnReposted from Polity.

Recently Treasury has published a paper showing that most people do not stay at the same point on the income scale for an extended period. That is assuredly true, and is also a good thing in as far as it goes.

DPF believes it goes really far, and thinks income mobility is a better measure than income inequality for measuring our health as a decent society:

I have often blogged that in NZ we should focus more on income mobility, and less on income inequality. An income inequality focus means you are comparing a 18 year old first time worker with a 45 year old experienced worker, and complaining they don’t get paid the same.

First off, nobody is arguing they should all be paid the same. That is a canard. There is widespread concern, however, that levels of inequality are getting wider and wider, particularly when you account for accumulated wealth rather than just annual income.

Also, income mobility has similar issues. Does it really tell you much about New Zealand to know that an 18 year old school leaver will very likely earn more once she is 26, or that a 60 year old worker will probably drop down the salary rankings when he retires? Those things demonstrate “income mobility” all right, but say nothing at all about the health of our society.

UPDATE: To be fair to the Treasury authors, they were wise to this issue and concentrated their analysis only on 25-55 year olds. But the examples I give above are simply the clearest cases of a continuous process. People acquire significant skills and experience, for example, between ages 26 and 34, and we would expect that those skills drive wages higher over that period, too. But that is still a lifecycle effect, not an indication of egalitarianism.

There is nothing wrong with the fact that some jobs and people get paid a lot less than others. What would be concerning is if those on low incomes stay there their entire life.

I agree. It is worth noting, however, from the Treasury report that “The movements in income groups were more likely to be of a short distance (to adjacent income groups) rather than long distance.” This means that while most people do not stay in exactly the same income decile for eight years, most people in the bottom, say, four deciles do in fact stay in that broader group, while most people in the top, say, four deciles stay in that broader category, too. “The poor” stay broadly poor, even if “the poorest 10%” don’t usually stay in the bottom 10%.

We need a focus on opportunity, not on outcome. Labour’s core policy is to try and ensure equality of outcome, while I believe it is equality of opportunity that counts.

Again with the canard. Labour has no belief that everyone should be paid the same, or even close to it. DPF is as delusional about Labour as he is about the income mobility tonic.

17 comments on “Polity: Income mobility ”

  1. tc 1

    Another DP weasel and shill for team shonkey who has been given a pat on the back and would be feeling pretty smug about getting at least another 3 years for more of the same.

  2. r0b 2

    Round we go and round we go on this “equality of opportunity” nonsense.

    Equality of opportunity

    Nats floundering on inequality

    • lprent 2.1

      I’m all for equality of opportunity. However the first step is to improve the income equality so that ALL kids have the opportunities.

      The DPF way of looking at things says that if kids from a poor family *could* if their parents were nearly unique and if they wanted to put themselves into a lifetime of debt and they happened to have some good teachers – that is sufficient.

      Of course he doesn’t look at it the other way which is to remove all ability of affluent families to pay directly or indirectly for their kids to get a good start. That is a whole lot easier to do.

      • Tom Jackson 2.1.1

        The problem with EOO is that actually doing it demonstrates how vacuous the idea really is. If we really controlled for all advantages save merit in order to equalise opportunities, we would end up with the sort of materially egalitarian society that people who promote equality of opportunity want to avoid (since the point of EOO is usually to try justify wealth differences whilst still maintaining a veneer of egalitarianism).

        It seems a gargantuan and hopeless task to make sure that opportunities are even approximately equal, since you would have to control for social connections, geography, parental quality and all sorts of other things besides wealth. Reducing inequalities of wealth turns out to be much easier, so we should probably do that.

        Some people are always going to receive unfair advantages, so we should probably stop believing in meritocracy as a principle of social reward and just get on with our lives. I don’t think you’re ever going to stop people gaining undeserved advantages at an acceptable cost, so maybe we should just stop treating their beneficiaries as somehow more morally deserving than everyone else. In the end, I think it’s just dumb to treat life as if it were a contest, and that’s what EOO does.

        • miravox 2.1.1.1

          Yep, equal opportunity is ridiculous as a concept unless everyone is starting in the same place with the same set of skills and the same context. It’s not just about income. I can’t see the ‘haves’ going for that either.

          I also have problems with the idea of a meritocracy. It’s ill-defined and can only be used after a certain poorly articulated baseline for social reward is met.

  3. Macro 3

    The simple fact is that social mobility has declined under the neo-liberal economy http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/the-prison-of-the-minimum-wage-only-a-quarter-of-lowpaid-workers-will-move-up-the-income-ladder-9852461.html
    and its only going to get worse.
    Farrar et al can look to the past and think that that is what happens now – and Labour are just as much to blame as Nact, for our current poor situation. But “free trade” deals are not fair trade deals, and the exportation of work overseas only reduces social mobility. We now live in a society of “haves” and “have nots”. The “haves” mostly vote for themselves, and the “have nots” see no point in voting.

  4. ghostwhowalksnz 4

    I had a laugh when I glanced it this on Farragoblog, and I thought someone is going to rip him another one over this.
    I suppose he thought it safe coming from ‘Treasury’ but then he will ignore any Treasury fine print and show why he failed his only economics paper at Otago (taught by H2) and leaving without a degree.

    ( another thing he said that Grant Roberston had never worked for a company so was unqualified to be Finance Minister, forgetting that his mentor Bill English only paid employment was at Treasury)

    • Tracey 4.1

      if you buy or inherit a farm but never work it you can be called a farmer. apparently. bill is a career bureaucrat. an academic of the type the right decries in all but their own.

      • ghostwhowalksnz 4.1.1

        And Cullen before him never worked for a private business either, so its another Reductio ad absurdum approach from Farrar, which not surprisinly he is full of.

        • lprent 4.1.1.1

          It wouldn’t be hard to argue that Farrar himself never appears to have worked for a private business before either..

          He appears (to me) to have been a bludger on the state his entire working life.

  5. RedLogix 5

    Whenever some Tory quotes you a document:

    1. Probably they have not read all of it and have merely skimmed for a headline or selective quote.

    2. Or the source is hopelessly compromised by either vested or commercial interest.

    3. Or it’s such a shrill piece of drek that it’s been thoroughly debunked by others already.

    4. Or their argument is so thin that you feel embarrassed to type out the blindly obvious rebuttal.

    5. Or it’s Farrar in which case all four cases above probably apply.

  6. One Anonymous Bloke 6

    Income (or social) mobility is one of the variables in the GINI.

    There is nothing wrong with the fact that some jobs and people get paid a lot less than others.

    Yes, there is: the wider the gaps the worse the society, for everyone, even Princess Party goers.

  7. AB 7

    From the Spirit Level – social mobility was greatest in those societies which were already the most equal.
    Or put another way – GENUINE or SUBSTANTIVE equality of opportunity requires relatively high levels of pre-existing equality.

    Nats like to couch equality of opportunity in a purely formal terms – as in the absence of any legal restraints against pursuing any opportunity you want to.
    It’s self-serving tripe, genuine equality of opportunity would threaten their unearned privilege.

  8. Lindsey 8

    Farrar’s job – diminish, divert, distract. That is what he is there for.

  9. aerobubble 9

    Mutual benefit reigns our bodies, society, even our businesses. The common trading of goods and services where both parties benefit. Though the outcomes and effects arent necessarily good, self-suffient, sustainable, etc. Enter government whose role is to stop or deincentivize bad practices. Unfortuately the creed of the modern media political world ignores this bulk nature of this mutual benefit (even as it extols the virtue of markets), and replaces, frames, the debate solely around profits and growth, and sustaining wealth gains for the few (free markets govt butt out).

    Recently we’ve heard about how only wealthy companies will be able to sue governments, before judges of their own kind (ttp). Is it any wonder then that social decay, improvisement in a time of plenty could happen. That the same talking heads attract the great bulk of our time with their disingenious belief driven views.

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

  • Construction Skills Action Plan delivering early on targets
    The Construction Skills Action Plan has delivered early on its overall target of supporting an additional 4,000 people into construction-related education and employment, says Minister for Building and Construction Poto Williams. Since the Plan was launched in 2018, more than 9,300 people have taken up education or employment opportunities in ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 hours ago
  • Youth Justice residence offers new pathway
    An innovative new Youth Justice residence designed in partnership with Māori will provide prevention, healing, and rehabilitation services for both young people and their whānau, Children’s Minister Kelvin Davis announced today.  Whakatakapokai is located in South Auckland and will provide care and support for up to 15 rangatahi remanded or ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 hours ago
  • The Duke of Edinburgh
    Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern today expressed New Zealand’s sorrow at the death of His Royal Highness The Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh. “Our thoughts are with Her Majesty The Queen at this profoundly sad time.  On behalf of the New Zealand people and the Government, I would like to express ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Five Country Ministerial Communiqué
    We, the Home Affairs, Interior, Security and Immigration Ministers of Australia, Canada, New Zealand, the United Kingdom and the United States of America (the ‘Five Countries’) met via video conference on 7/8 April 2021, just over a year after the outbreak of the COVID-19 global pandemic. Guided by our shared ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Inspiring creativity through cultural installations and events
    Arts, Culture and Heritage Minister Carmel Sepuloni has today announced the opening of the first round of Ngā Puninga Toi ā-Ahurea me ngā Kaupapa Cultural Installations and Events. “Creating jobs and helping the arts sector rebuild and recover continues to be a key part of the Government’s COVID-19 response,” Carmel ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Drug-testing law to be made permanent
    Interim legislation that is already proving to keep people safer from drugs will be made permanent, Health Minister Andrew Little says. Research by Victoria University, on behalf of the Ministry of Health, shows that the Government’s decision in December to make it legal for drug-checking services to operate at festivals ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Better rules proposed for freedom camping
    Public consultation launched on ways to improve behaviour and reduce damage Tighter rules proposed for either camping vehicles or camping locations Increased penalties proposed, such as $1,000 fines or vehicle confiscation Rental companies may be required to collect fines from campers who hire vehicles Public feedback is sought on proposals ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Government backs Air New Zealand as Trans-Tasman bubble opens
    The Government is continuing to support Air New Zealand while aviation markets stabilise and the world moves towards more normal border operations. The Crown loan facility made available to Air New Zealand in March 2020 has been extended to a debt facility of up to $1.5 billion (an additional $600 ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Building gifted for new community hub in Richmond red zone
    Christchurch’s Richmond suburb will soon have a new community hub, following the gifting of a red-zoned property by Land Information New Zealand (LINZ) to the Richmond Community Gardens Trust. The Minister for Land Information, Damien O’Connor said that LINZ, on behalf of the Crown, will gift a Vogel Street house ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Pacific languages funding reopens
      Minister for Pacific Peoples Aupito William Sio says the reopening of the Ministry for Pacific Peoples’ (MPP) Languages Funding in 2021 will make sure there is a future for Pacific languages. “Language is the key to the wellbeing for Pacific people. It affirms our identity as Pasifika and ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • ERANZ speech April 2021
    It is a pleasure to be here tonight.  Thank you Cameron for the introduction and thank you for ERANZ for also hosting this event. Last week in fact, we had one of the largest gatherings in our sector, Downstream 2021. I have heard from my officials that the discussion on ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Strengthening Māori knowledge in science and innovation
    Research, Science and Innovation Minister Megan Woods has today announced the 16 projects that will together get $3.9 million through the 2021 round of Te Pūnaha Hihiko: Vision Mātauranga Capability Fund, further strengthening the Government’s commitment to Māori knowledge in science and innovation.  “We received 78 proposals - the highest ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Government delivers next phase of climate action
    The Government is delivering on a key election commitment to tackle climate change, by banning new low and medium temperature coal-fired boilers and partnering with the private sector to help it transition away from fossil fuels. This is the first major announcement to follow the release of the Climate Commission’s ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Continued investment in Central Otago schools supports roll growth
    Six projects, collectively valued at over $70 million are delivering new schools, classrooms and refurbished buildings across Central Otago and are helping to ease the pressure of growing rolls in the area, says Education Minister Chris Hipkins. The National Education Growth Plan is making sure that sufficient capacity in the ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Two more Christchurch schools complete
    Two more schools are now complete as part of the Christchurch Schools Rebuild Programme, with work about to get under way on another, says Education Minister Chris Hipkins. Te Ara Koropiko – West Spreydon School will welcome students to their new buildings for the start of Term 2. The newly ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Independent experts to advise Government on post-vaccination future
    The Government is acting to ensure decisions on responding to the next phase of the COVID-19 pandemic are informed by the best available scientific evidence and strategic public health advice. “New Zealand has worked towards an elimination strategy which has been successful in keeping our people safe and our economy ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Supporting Māori success with Ngārimu Awards
    Six Māori scholars have been awarded Ngārimu VC and the 28th (Māori) Battalion Memorial scholarships for 2021, Associate Education Minister and Ngārimu Board Chair, Kelvin Davis announced today. The prestigious Manakura Award was also presented for the first time since 2018. “These awards are a tribute to the heroes of the 28th ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Global partnerships propel space tech research
    New Zealand’s aerospace industry is getting a boost through the German Aerospace Centre (DLR), to grow the capability of the sector and potentially lead to joint space missions, Research, Science and Innovation Minister Megan Woods has announced. 12 New Zealand organisations have been chosen to work with world-leading experts at ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Government backs more initiatives to boost food and fibre workforce
    The Government is backing more initiatives to boost New Zealand’s food and fibre sector workforce, Agriculture Minister Damien O’Connor announced today. “The Government and the food and fibres sector have been working hard to fill critical workforce needs.  We've committed to getting 10,000 more Kiwis into the sector over the ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Minister welcomes Bill to remove Subsequent Child Policy
    Minister for Social Development and Employment Carmel Sepuloni has welcomed the first reading of the Social Security (Subsequent Child Policy Removal) Amendment Bill in the House this evening. “Tonight’s first reading is another step on the way to removing excessive sanctions and obligations for people receiving a Main Benefit,” says ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Mental Health Amendment Bill passes first reading
    The Government has taken a significant step towards delivering on its commitment to improve the legislation around mental health as recommended by He Ara Oranga – the report of the Government Inquiry into Mental Health and Addiction, Health Minister Andrew Little says. The Mental Health (Compulsory Assessment and Treatment) Amendment ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Whenua Māori Rating Amendment Bill passes third reading
    Local Government Minister Nanaia Mahuta has welcomed the Local Government (Rating of Whenua Māori) Amendment Bill passing its third reading today. “After nearly 100 years of a system that was not fit for Māori and did not reflect the partnership we have come to expect between Māori and the Crown, ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Trans-Tasman bubble to start 19 April
    New Zealand’s successful management of COVID means quarantine-free travel between New Zealand and Australia will start on Monday 19 April, Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern announced today. Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern and COVID-19 Response Minister Chris Hipkins confirmed the conditions for starting to open up quarantine free travel with Australia have ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Ngāti Hinerangi Claims Settlement Bill passes Third Reading
    Minister for Treaty of Waitangi Negotiations Andrew Little welcomed ngā uri o Ngāti Hinerangi to Parliament today to witness the third reading of their Treaty settlement legislation, the Ngāti Hinerangi Claims Settlement Bill. “I want to acknowledge ngā uri o Ngāti Hinerangi and the Crown negotiations teams for working tirelessly ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Independent group announced to advise on firearms matters
    Minister of Police Poto Williams has announced the members of the Ministers Arms Advisory Group, established to ensure balanced advice to Government on firearms that is independent of Police. “The Ministers Arms Advisory Group is an important part of delivering on the Government’s commitment to ensure we maintain the balance ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Kiri Allan to take leave of absence
    Kiri Allan, Minister of Conservation and Emergency Management will undertake a leave of absence while she undergoes medical treatment for cervical cancer, Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern announced today. “I consider Kiri not just a colleague, but a friend. This news has been devastating. But I also know that Kiri is ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Excellent progress at new Waikeria prison build
    Excellent progress has been made at the new prison development at Waikeria, which will boost mental health services and improve rehabilitation opportunities for people in prison, Corrections Minister Kelvin Davis says. Kelvin Davis was onsite at the new build to meet with staff and see the construction first-hand, following a ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Expert panel proposes criminal limits for drug driving
    To reduce the trauma of road crashes caused by drug impaired drivers, an Independent Expert Panel on Drug Driving has proposed criminal limits and blood infringement thresholds for 25 impairing drugs, Minister of Police Poto Williams and Transport Minister Michael Wood announced today. The Land Transport (Drug Driving) Amendment Bill ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 weeks ago
  • Covid-19 imgration powers to be extended
    Temporary COVID-19 immigration powers will be extended to May 2023, providing continued flexibility to support migrants, manage the border, and help industries facing labour shortages, Immigration Minister Kris Faafoi announced today. “Over the past year, we have had to make rapid decisions to vary visa conditions, extend expiry dates, and ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 weeks ago
  • Covid-19 immigration powers to be extended
    Temporary COVID-19 immigration powers will be extended to May 2023, providing continued flexibility to support migrants, manage the border, and help industries facing labour shortages, Immigration Minister Kris Faafoi announced today. “Over the past year, we have had to make rapid decisions to vary visa conditions, extend expiry dates, and ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 weeks ago
  • More support for mums and whānau struggling with alcohol and other drugs
    The Government is expanding its Pregnancy and Parenting Programme so more women and whānau can access specialist support to minimise harm from alcohol and other drugs, Health Minister Andrew Little says. “We know these supports help improve wellbeing and have helped to reduce addiction, reduced risk for children, and helped ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 weeks ago
  • Ahuwhenua Trophy Competition Field Day – Tātaiwhetū Trust at Tauarau Marae, Rūātoki
    *** Please check against delivery *** It’s an honour to be here in Rūātoki today, a rohe with such a proud and dynamic history of resilience, excellence and mana. Tūhoe moumou kai, moumou taonga, moumou tangata ki te pō. The Ahuwhenua Trophy competition is the legacy of a seed planted ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 weeks ago
  • Crown accounts again better than forecast
    The economic recovery from COVID-19 continues to be reflected in the Government’s books, which are again better than expected. The Crown accounts for the eight months to the end of February 2021 showed both OBEGAL and the operating balance remain better than forecast in the Half Year Economic and Fiscal ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 weeks ago
  • FIFA Women’s World Cup to open in New Zealand
    Sport and Recreation Minister Grant Robertson and Economic Development Minister Stuart Nash have welcomed confirmation New Zealand will host the opening ceremony and match, and one of the semi-finals, of the FIFA Women’s World Cup in 2023. Grant Robertson says matches will be held in Auckland, Hamilton, Wellington and Dunedin, ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 weeks ago
  • 1 April changes raise incomes for 1.4 million New Zealanders
    Changes to the minimum wage, main benefit levels and superannuation rates that come into force today will raise the incomes for around 1.4 million New Zealanders. “This Government is committed to raising the incomes for all New Zealanders as part of laying the foundations for a better future,” Minister for ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 weeks ago
  • New Dunedin Hospital – Whakatuputupu approved for fast track consenting process
    The New Dunedin Hospital – Whakatuputupu has been approved for consideration under the fast track consenting legislation.  The decision by Environment Minister David Parker signifies the importance of the project to the health of the people of Otago-Southland and to the economy of the region.  “This project ticks all the ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 weeks ago
  • Next steps for Auckland light rail
    Transport Minister Michael Wood is getting Auckland light rail back on track with the announcement of an establishment unit to progress this important city-shaping project and engage with Aucklanders. Michael Wood said the previous process didn’t involve Aucklanders enough.                       ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 weeks ago
  • Tourism fund to prioritise hard-hit regions
    The Minister of Tourism is to re-open a government fund that supports councils to build infrastructure for visitors, with a specific focus on regions hardest hit by the loss of overseas tourists. “Round Five of the Tourism Infrastructure Fund will open for applications next month,” said Stuart Nash. It ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 weeks ago
  • Governance Group to lead next phase of work on a potential new public media entity
    A Governance Group of eight experts has been appointed to lead the next phase of work on a potential new public media entity, Minister for Broadcasting and Media Kris Faafoi announced today.  “The Governance Group will oversee the development of a business case to consider the viability of a new ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 weeks ago
  • New funding to keep tamariki and rangatahi Māori active
    Minister for Māori Development Willie Jackson today helped launch a new fund to provide direct financial support for tamariki and rangatahi Māori throughout the South Island who is experiencing financial hardship and missing out on physical activity opportunities. “Through Te Kīwai Fund, we can offer more opportunities for Māori to ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 weeks ago