If your posts are coming through, albeit it may be a bit later to allow for 'inspection', it is a little OTT to say that you are being affected by being 'in moderation' otherwise we would not have seen this post I am replying to. As someone who had the ...
Here is the second tranche of rebuttal on the myths on the Cass Review. This is done by an organisation call Quackometer. NB I have not purity tested the organisation but the work done seems level headed and fair. https://www.quackometer.net/blog/2024/04/...
tWig I don't think I mentioned any version of the womens rights movements or parties, just that I wanted to come back when I read Weka's posts and read the replies. I'll go away just as quickly, as life is too short. I tend not support parties as such. I ...
Yes indeed. Just a little addition though a D & C is not necessarily thought of by lay people as an 'abortion' if performed to remove the remains of a non viable fetus/miscarriage. Tiny shifts of meaning/nuances make a difference. D & Cs are not only ...
I have just watched this documentary. It is called The Lost Boys - searching for Manhood. It follows several detransitioners and desisters (you'll hear the difference in the documentary) This is a sad gentle film. 'These 5 young men walked the path of ...
Thanks James, another thoughtful response.
I'm tired too Molly. As far as Women's issues is concerned I have have been fighting seriously since I first joined the PS when I took a case to the Public Service Commission on not being given access to the Public Servant on transfer allowances and pool ...
I left in Aug23 mainly because of being justly moderated off after becoming annoyed at the continual non participation, socratic type style or reckons of one poster. I maintained a 'watching brief', ha ha, looking at TS every day. At first I had a sticky ...
Thank you Molly.
"That is my issue with this. State why you have the right to remove choices from others. So far all I see is that you want to play god with other peoples genitals without their consent. Crimes act anyone.." I suggest you stop this attempt at redirection, ...
The final report is a carefully worded document designed particularly for the systems of power in charge of child health, wellbeing and safeguarding: health systems and their managers, medical practitioners and their professional bodies, MPs and ...
Thanks David. You are a very courageous person. The road for people with ADHD/Autism can be hard enough without it being some sort of semi-automatic pathway to gender issues being raised. And the example about the accident/concussion rings bells with me ...
As a woman I actually support the views against Drags in libraries both from a taste/exposure point of view and because I think it is a waste of money for Councils in these straitened times to be paying for this. Opportunities exist for parents keen to go ...
There is a wider agenda here, to get the working class angry about gender theory, instead of much more acute and urgent class injustices that are more mundanely eroding lives and the wellbeing of entire nations. I might be a bit thick tonight or ...
Sorry I was not. I was posting an old article by Jennifer Bilek reported in First Things which shock horror is some sort of Christian magazine. If you had read my post you will have noted it was about who and when we were being warned about these wealthy ...
Here is another article setting out the myths that have been promulgated about the Cass Review. https://www.quackometer.net/blog/2024/04/breaking-down-cass-review-myths-and-misconceptions-what-you-need-to-know.html Many trans advocacy groups appear to be ...
Robert I used art as an example to show how this step by step reading/learning goes. I have a degree in fine art and learning art is somewhat of a topic in the art world with some saying you have to be a natural at art to learn art and others saying that ...
You have missed my point. If you actually did know and read the Cass Review in depth you wouldn't actually be ascribing 'reasonableness' to the PATHA link. As a learner you'd be asking how is it that this group seems not to believe the Cass Review? Seeking...
I agree Visubversa. 'No Debate' and those stealthy figures such as the pharmaceutical industry the Pritzker family and Jon Stryker/Arcus foundation have been working for years on this. See this article from 2022. https://www.nationalreview.com/corner/the-...
"you literally just said that PATHA's position sounded reasonable, and I pointed out they told a blatant lie, and you want to equivocate with me over trust?" I said it sounded reasonable. Are you expecting me to abandon my opinion after just one claim ...
Does this mean that even lies are useful in forming an opinion? Perhaps in a philosophical way they are as they can point towards a truth. To do this though we need to know the truth or the least worst way of looking at something. We need to look at: are ...
and lacks relevance in an Aotearoa context This is not explained. How? Why have we got 10 times the numbers on irreversible drugs than other western countries? As it is from a NZ body I am sure they will recognise the NZ vernacular/meaning when I respond ...
I agree with all of this Molly. I grieve for the vulnerability of the young people caught up in this. The autistic, the non-regressive-stereotypical, the same-sex oriented, the ones with co-morbidities. Going down a path that is non reversible is tragic. ...
Weka, this is excellent. Thank you My thought is that this should be a time of reflection about medical 'misadventure'. My initial thoughts are that it is similar to The Unfortunate Experiment (Cartwright report) https://www.womens-health.org.nz/the-...
Robert, hopefully the setting out of the tweet & analysis and the link to the BMJ article will alleviate some of your pain. Peter Davis quotes, presumably approvingly,* from the BMJ's review of the Cass report. * ie he does not allude to anything he ...
I have read and reread the BMJ & Peter Davis' X (Twitter) comment. I cannot work out how Philip Ure has read what he has into it. Peter Davis makes a couple of comments based on the BMJ which in turn has some quotes from the Cass Report. X (Twitter) ...
It is the children that I really get riled up about. A girl child I know of had a phase of telling her mother "I a boy, I a boy". From this in the next few years up until now this child was subjected to all sorts of chemical interventions. This idea, as a ...
Let that sink in. Medical professionals refused to share crucial information with an independent review that was trying to see if children were being harmed by medical treatment. Double bad in my books Weka. First from the Hippocratic oath that all Drs ...
Weka There was a good press release from SUFW on X and now I see that Peter Davis has also put up something linking to BMJ https://twitter.com/SpeakUp4WomenNZ
I don't understand what you mean by "trans logic". Robert Guyton 9.1.1.1.1.1 10 April 2024 at 2:39 pm It is this I am trying to explain. Perhaps it would be clearer if you accepted I have (tried) to answer this, thanked me and then moved on to your ...
Robert The examples of the trans logic we are facing is 1 when a person feels that dressing means morphing into a woman, 2 that dressing entitles a man to go into women's toilets 3 that dressing entitles a man to play in women's sports. Are you able to ...
Recent Comments