Well if the so called 'left' had not gone to war against science on behalf of woke bs, then maybe we wouldn't be facing what we are currently facing. Here is a former Green/Labour voter who voted National this time round, almost purely on the disregard of ...
Advantage is a consistent apologist for US empire. That a so called 'left' website should publish his misinformation is frankly disgraceful. [This is rich coming from a PRC shill. Everybody is free to comment here and contribute to robust debate. You ...
Many countries do not, including Russia, China, and Iran. In fact most countries do not. If Hamas is a terrorist organisation, so much more must be the US military and IDF.
In my own reading of history, it was Germany and Japan who were the aggressors in WW2 Whereas the Palestinians have not invaded anyone else, do not have a proper standing army, and are for the most part refugees having been ethnically cleansed out of their...
What on earth does China's position on Taiwan have to do with New Zealand? The 'position' on Taiwan has not changed for many decades, and after all, all Western countries accept the one-China policy and that includes NZ. You could perhaps explicate on ...
Have always voted Labour. I am a trade unionist. So many in the union have come up to me and said they would not vote Labour. The fact is people are sick and tired and disgusted with woke virtue signalling. The Left has to get back to traditional left ...
In the end poverty is eliminated by heaving a flourishing and growing economy. Yep, change the taxation regime so that the rich pay their fair share. But in the end that constraints on national wealth is national output. Yet many on the left hate farmers, ...
"There might be other reasons why Islamic countries might not openly criticise China, which is notoriously touchy & grumpy about any form of criticism and which responds with idiosyncratic ‘diplomatic’ responses." There might be (althought doubtful), at ...
No. Not whataboutery at all. I have not tried to justify what China is accused of by saying that Israel is guilty of similar. I have simply said the Islamic world hates Israel (that is not too strong a term) in a way they do not hate China (in spite of ...
Of course, it is important to note that even if China was guilty of everything Advantage claims, it is ambitious to claim because of the way China runs China they are a threat to New Zealand's freedoms, or indeed anyone elses. That is as absurd as saying ...
I said you come across as an apologist for US empire. Of course I have no proof, you just sound like one. Indeed no proof is required because the threshold for apologist is subjective. Of course if I said you were a CIA asset that would be a truth claim ...
[deleted] [I will restore your comment if/when you successfully get out of Pre-Moderation. Only then might I respond to this – Incognito] [restored comment below] A valid observation is all we have typically, when it comes to political or social issues, or...
And you come across as a transparent apologist for US empire [You are proving to be exactly who I thought you are. Provide an example with link to support your baseless and fact-free accusation. Old proverb: He who seeks truth does not accuse He who ...
I think it is a valid point to make that hardly any others in the Islamic world give a stuff about Xinjiang, and some have even applauded the policies of the Chinese government. Contrast that with the Palestinian cause, from Malaysia to Tunisia to Iran, ...
May be more helpful to go to the actual facts and then construct your own narrative, irather than quoting sources that mutually quote one another. A starting point is the increase in life expectancy and population of the Uighur population since 1949, ...
When one resorts to labelling or name calling, it's an obvious omission that one has lost the argument and has nothing more to contribute.
What about the 'treatment' of the Uighurs? That they have massively increased in population under socialism, enjoy a standard of living far higher than what was the case in the past, have significant affirmative action benefits, have their culture, ...
Awesome comment.
"Clark is identical to Key in their deep trust in mercntilist Chinese compacts." With good reason. The China trade has benefitted NZ (and Australia) enormously in recent decades, without which we would have experience Great Depression levels of poverty.
"But Xi is rapidly replacing a market economy with a fully state directed corporate economy." And how on earth is that a strategic or military threat to New Zealand? Please explain.
Providing seminars sharing one developing country's experience to another on how to rapidly lift developing countries out of poverty is surely a good thing? Or are only Westerners allowed a point of view. You appear to imply that. Regardless, if that is ...
"We are part of the free world, China isn’t, and we must join with other countries to ensure that we triumph against the form of world that China wants to impose." Where is your evidence that China wants to impose its ways on the rest of the world? ...
There is even less excuse for it in the age of the internet, where a huge variety of viewpoints abound, but more importantly where facts are must more easily discoverable. Perhaps there is a will to believe what one wishes to believe, and there are reasons...
Would have been difficult to distinguish between local and international Chinese buyers, and even if Labour's research was statistically valid (something I've never looked into and don't have an opinion on), they would not pull the same stunt on any other ...
"as buyers of oil we developed a dependency on it to the point where the seller can dictate the terms of the sale" Well of course, and on this point Seymour is completely correct and we should lift all restrictions on oil and gas exploration. Beggars ...
"...why we have so much trade with a totalitarian state baffles me." What's so baffling about it. The answer is obvious. We sell to whoever has the capacity and willingness to buy our stuff. And btw no-one gets cancelled for attacking China or the Chinese ...
Great comment.
"The government of the People’s Republic of China is ruled by a totalitarian ideology under a one-party communist state. It deprives citizens of human rights on a sweeping scale and systematically curtails freedoms in order to retain power. People in China...
The same sort of demonisation of foreign countries as a way to setup public opinion to meet the war ends of the US empire has happened over and over again. Surprised that we see this BS on a blog that purports to be left-wing. [Before you make even more of...
Probably a lot less wrong than aligning with the US, which will either assassinate leaders they don't like, or outright invade with scant regard for civilian casualties resulting in a hecatomb of corpses of innocent men, women, and children. China's ...
"We probably don’t need reminding that the nearby island nation of Kiribati also switched official relations to Beijing in 2019." Sorry, that's arrogant neocolonial thinking. So there is something untoward about Kiribati switching official relations to ...
Recent Comments