web analytics

Tax Working Group is inherently flawed.

Written By: - Date published: 3:40 pm, January 8th, 2010 - 16 comments
Categories: tax - Tags:

Marty wrote on taxation expert Craig Elliffes opinion series in the Herald a few days ago. The third in the series wound up with statement at the end that exemplifies the major issue with the Tax Working Group and its process.

At the tax conference of the Tax Working Group, Susan St John of the University of Auckland questioned whether it was appropriate that the group had embraced the objective of aligning tax rates which aimed at improving efficiency while not making equity (the transfer of taxes to the needy and the poor) any worse.

She asked whether “is not making equity worse” an appropriate equity goal?

It was a poignant question. Maybe it would have been a good idea to have had a wider representation in this review group.

Perhaps someone other than a male earning over $100,000?

Craig, thank you for pointing out the basic flaw in the group makeup and focus. As well as the group ignored equity issues, many startup companies and talented people in the industries I’ve been associated with over the year would argue that many of the basic objectives and assumptions of the TWG are flawed.

As Craig points out the government is only interested in a basic fix.

It quickly emerged in the discussions at the Victoria University Tax Working Group that any recommended changes to the tax system would have to be revenue-neutral at least. The financial position of the government is such that any proposal that increases the budget deficit is unacceptable.

The main intent of the tax changes appears to be related to a precept from treasury. It looks like simply an article of faith at the treasury rather than anything supported by evidence at small changes in tax rates.

A reduction in personal rates will also assist in retaining and attracting highly mobile individuals and it is the view of Treasury that reducing business and personal taxation will increase productivity and the growth of the economy.

From my experience around innovative businesses and the people that work in them, that is utter bullshit. In NZ the major reason people leave is because of either a hankering for travel when they are younger. The best immediate way of getting productivity is to be able to invest money into productivity improving systems and technology. To get long term productivity gains you need

The reason that they don’t return, or older more experienced people leave is the same – lack of an appropriate opportunity to work further in their fields of expertise. The main reason that we don’t have the types of innovative businesses around that can employ them and which they can grow their skills in is the incredible constraints on getting working and development capital. Virtually all major capital in NZ gets sucked into the safer property market rather than into productive businesses.

The capital available for startup businesses, especially the ones working on export markets, comes at such a cost that it amounts to giving away your business to the capital provider and working as an employee to them.

Highly mobile people with talents move away from NZ because they cannot find opportunities to work in NZ. Personal tax rates seldom have much of an impact. Virtually everywhere else that our people go to, the effective tax rates are higher once you add in all of the taxes and account for the reductions in services and the prices to get them.

This is clearly the case for Australia, the UK, and for much of US, which are the major locations of the kiwi diaspora. What is different in these markets is that the market is larger, it is usually easier to get capital at a reasonable rate, and there are more interesting smaller startup companies to work for.

It is clear from the proposed likely changes that the impacts will effectively shift the burden of tax from the more affluent in society to the less affluent. This may be in the form of increased GST or increased rents. This is the essence of Susan St Johns argument.

It also does little or nothing to increase the amount and availability of startup capital in NZ. While we are currently getting an influx of returning kiwis due to the global recession. We will continue to bleed talent as soon as the global recession starts weakening because there aren’t the small startups here to soak up our talent.

The results of this look at tax, assuming that the government takes up the ideas will probably be an effective shift of taxation from the affluent to the less affluent, partially concealed in higher rents. But there will be no significant change in anything productive for the economy. Structurally we will probably just see some tinkering at the edges and a lot of people who cannot afford it getting more costs lumped onto them.

Craig Elliffe: Some taxing problems built into system
Craig Elliffe: Time for tax reform but alternatives present new issues
Craig Elliffe: The $1.6b question – How to fill tax hole

16 comments on “Tax Working Group is inherently flawed. ”

  1. yesss 1

    With due respect to those musing as above, the TAX working group isn’t a WELFARE working group and as such their remit was tax reform.

    • prism 1.1

      yesss
      Tax and welfare go together. People in the past have known that very well when kings put an impost on them that left them with little. Fair taxation leaving people with a living wage sufficient to enable them to carry out their responsibilities and have some left over for discretionary spending too, is part of a well-run country’s revenue system.

      • yesss 1.1.1

        It’s a TAX working group not a 3rd form social studies essay on medieval feudalism.

        • prism 1.1.1.1

          The same problem of needing money for running things in a geographical area occurred in both medieval times then and now. It’s the same object only the taxation method may be different.
          The taxation burden is quite high on ordinary workers with GST on most things as well as PAYE and secondary tax and marginal taxes that affect low income people. I wonder what the clever lot on the TWG will do about those?
          But I get the feeling that you are not ordinary yessssss so you would be above and apart from these basic tax problems.

  2. infused 2

    I think you’re wrong about the statement saying people want to travel. That is part of it. Of all my mates that are now overseas, it’s about the money, honey.

  3. tc 3

    The premise and intent is all wrong…..there’s plenty to go around as long as those at the top accept reasonable reward and pay appropriate tax…..companies and individuals.

    But the top tier want more more more….whine on and on about how much tax they pay, how long it takes them to get to their beach houses, how tough it is etc etc

    The gap between ‘have and have not’ grows ever wider….this is all a load of BS to make it appear like NACT are into radical reform………yeah right !

    The mindset is all me me me and greed………..look where we are as a result.

  4. infused 4

    It’s not the top tier leaving over seas. Greed? How about wanting to get somewhere in life? Yeah, lets work in nz for $45k or go to aussie for 90k. Not only is the money better, so is the weather 😛

  5. Norma 5

    Whay don’t you all wait until the Report of the Tax Working Group is released and see what it says instead of making inane comments. You don’t even know what’s in it.

    • jarbury 5.1

      Yeah but expecting a bunch of rich white guys to promote tax changes that reduce inequality is like expecting a bunch of turkeys to vote for Xmas.

    • handle 5.2

      Norma, how about reading the linked stories. They talk explicitly about what is likely to be in the report, by one of its authors.

  6. Dr Graham Tayler, Ph.D Accounting & Finance) 6

    Imputed rental value of owner occupied housing (net of mortgage interest) should be taxed as income. This was the case in the UK until the 1960’s. It’s explained on the internet – just Google it. No great mystery. The policymakers are undoubtedly quite aware of it but they choose to overlook it because it is politically very contentious. Clearly, failure to tax it amounts to a subsidy to owner occupiers effectively capitalised into higher house prices. Also it is inequitable that rent payers effectively do pay tax at income tax rates on the rental value of the property they occupy (they have to find a gross amount of income and pay tax on that before having a net amount of income with which to pay rent). Introduction, would broaden the tax base, remove a subsidy capitalised into higher house prices and remove a gross inequity.

    • prism 6.1

      Imputed rental value of owner occupied housing (net of mortgage interest) –
      Governments find it contentious no wonder. Getting a dwelling that people can afford and which gives them security of tenure, a place where they belong and are settled and can live their lives should not be turned into an object for grasping taxation organised by the haves of our society.
      People on modest incomes who have bought a house can maintain it and invest in safety, and have real monetary return when they sell rather than an illusory pot of gold from investment in cold-hearted business schemes.
      It’s the difference between the greys who exist for themselves and money, status and orderliness and the others who may get along in a haphazard way, but just being people trying to make a happy, fulfilling life even at the unwealthy level of society. Taxing personal housing is similar to taxing every little amount of savings so that cents of tax are being drawn from bank accounts. We know that people have been discouraged from saving and tilted towards borrowing, not for capital investment in a house but consumer spending and borrowing. The government is always mouthing off about its bad consequences for a healthy national economy. Don’t try to quench people’s enthusiasm for investment in their own homes which help give a stable life and sure financial independence. This imputed rent idea would be self-defeating from a national point of view because it would increase more ‘nomadic’ living, which tends to
      social conditions deteriorating. Trying to tip more tax from the shoulders of the big earners to the middle and lower incomes in this way is contemptible.

  7. randal 7

    the tax working group eh?
    has anybody heard of welfare for out of work central bank governors and other panjandrums who need a bit of taxpayer money for their services.
    nice work if yu can get it.

  8. “No taxation without representation”.

    Why would you give any representation on a tax working group to groups in society who don’t actually have large amounts of members who are net contributors of tax?

    Bit like whinging why there aren’t more Chinese immigrants on a Treaty Grievance Review Committee..

  9. Pascal's bookie 9

    No house music without MDMA.

    /= only people listening to house music should be allowed MDMA.

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

  • NZ announces a third P-3 deployment in support of UN sanctions
    The Government has deployed a Royal New Zealand Air Force P-3K2 Orion (P-3) maritime patrol aircraft to support the implementation of United Nations Security Council (UNSC) resolutions imposing sanctions against North Korea, announced Minister of Foreign Affairs Winston Peters and Minister of Defence Ron Mark. “New Zealand has long supported ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 day ago
  • Pacific trade and development agreement a reality
    Pacific regional trade and development agreement PACER Plus will enter into force in 60 days now that the required eight countries have ratified it. Trade and Export Growth Minister David Parker welcomed the announcement that the Cook Islands is the eighth nation to ratify this landmark agreement. “The agreement represents ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Securing a pipeline of teachers
    The Government is changing its approach to teacher recruitment as COVID-19 travel restrictions continue, by boosting a range of initiatives to get more Kiwis into teaching. “When we came into Government, we were faced with a teacher supply crisis,” Education Minister Chris Hipkins said. “Over the past three years, we ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Border exceptions for a small number of international students with visas
    The Government has established a new category that will allow 250 international PhD and postgraduate students to enter New Zealand and continue their studies, in the latest set of border exceptions. “The health, safety and wellbeing of people in New Zealand remains the Government’s top priority. Tight border restrictions remain ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • First COVID-19 vaccine purchase agreement signed
    The Government has signed an agreement to purchase 1.5 million COVID-19 vaccines – enough for 750,000 people – from Pfizer and BioNTech, subject to the vaccine successfully completing all clinical trials and passing regulatory approvals in New Zealand, say Research, Science and Innovation Minister Megan Woods and Health Minister Chris Hipkins. ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • International statement – End-to-end encryption and public safety
    We, the undersigned, support strong encryption, which plays a crucial role in protecting personal data, privacy, intellectual property, trade secrets and cyber security.  It also serves a vital purpose in repressive states to protect journalists, human rights defenders and other vulnerable people, as stated in the 2017 resolution of the ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Ministry of Defence Biodefence Assessment released
    The Ministry of Defence has today released a Defence Assessment examining Defence’s role across the spectrum of biological hazards and threats facing New Zealand. Biodefence: Preparing for a New Era of Biological Hazards and Threats looks at how the NZDF supports other agencies’ biodefence activities, and considers the context of ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • New Approaches to Economic Challenges: Confronting Planetary Emergencies: OECD 9 October 2020
    New Approaches to Economic Challenges: Confronting Planetary Emergencies: OECD 9 October 2020 Hon David Parker’s response following Thomas Piketty and Esther Duflo. Good morning, good afternoon, and good evening, wherever in the world you might be. I first acknowledge the excellent thought provoking speeches of Thomas Piketty and Esther ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Kaipara Moana restoration takes next step
    A Memorandum of Understanding has been signed today at Waihāua Marae between the Crown, local iwi and councils to protect, restore and enhance the mauri of Kaipara Moana in Northland. Environment Minister David Parker signed the document on behalf of the Crown along with representatives from Ngā Maunga Whakahī, Ngāti ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 weeks ago
  • New Zealand and Uruguay unite on reducing livestock production emissions
    Agriculture Minister Damien O’Connor and Uruguayan Minister of Livestock, Agriculture and Fisheries Carlos María Uriarte have welcomed the launch of a three-year project that will underpin sustainable livestock production in Uruguay, Argentina, and Costa Rica.  The project called ‘Innovation for pasture management’ is led by Uruguay’s National Institute of Agricultural ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 weeks ago
  • 3100 jobs created through marae upgrades
    Hundreds of marae throughout the country will be upgraded through investments from the Provincial Growth Fund’s refocused post COVID-19 funding to create jobs and put money into the pockets of local tradespeople and businesses, Regional Economic Development Minister Shane Jones and Māori Development Minister Nanaia Mahuta have announced. “A total ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 weeks ago
  • Health volunteers recognised in annual awards
    Health Minister Chris Hipkins has announced 9 teams and 14 individuals are the recipients of this year’s Minister of Health Volunteer Awards.  “The health volunteer awards celebrate and recognise the thousands of dedicated health sector volunteers who give many hours of their time to help other New Zealanders,” Mr Hipkins ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 weeks ago
  • Community COVID-19 Fund supports Pacific recovery
    The Minister for Pacific Peoples, Aupito William Sio says a total of 264 groups and individuals have successfully applied for the Pacific Aotearoa Community COVID-19 Recovery Fund, that will support Pacific communities drive their own COVID-19 recovery strategies, initiatives, and actions. “I am keen to see this Fund support Pacific ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 weeks ago
  • Community benefits from Māori apprenticeships
    Up to 50 Māori apprentices in Wellington will receive paid training to build houses for their local communities, thanks to a $2.75 million investment from the Māori Trades and Training Fund, announced Employment Minister Willie Jackson today. “This funding will enable Ngāti Toa Rangatira Incorporated to provide its Ngā Kaimahi ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 weeks ago
  • Training fund supports Māori jobseekers
    Rapidly growing sectors will benefit from a $990,000 Māori Trades and Training Fund investment which will see Wellington jobseekers supported into work, announced Employment Minister Willie Jackson today. “This funding will enable Sapphire Consultants Ltd. to help up to 45 Māori jobseekers into paid training initiatives over two years through ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 weeks ago
  • Ruakura Inland Port development vital infrastructure for Waikato
    The Government is investing $40 million to develop an inland port at Ruakura which will become a freight super-hub and a future business, research and residential development for the Waikato, Urban Development and Transport Minister Phil Twyford, and Māori Development Minister Nanaia Mahuta announced today. The funding has been has ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 weeks ago
  • Appointments made to Defence Expert Review Group
    Defence Minister Ron Mark announced today the establishment of an Expert Review Group to review a number of aspects of the New Zealand Defence Force’s (NZDF) structure, information management and record-keeping processes.  The Expert Review Group’s work arises out of the first recommendation from the Report of the Government’s Inquiry ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 weeks ago
  • No active community cases of COVID-19
    There are no active community cases of COVID-19 remaining in the country after the last people from the recent outbreak have recovered from the virus, Health Minister Chris Hipkins said today. “This is a big milestone. New Zealanders have once again through their collective actions squashed the virus. The systems ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 weeks ago
  • Clean energy upgrade for more public buildings
    More public buildings will be supported by the Government to upgrade to run on clean energy, the Minister for Climate Change James Shaw announced today. Minister Shaw announced that Lincoln and Auckland universities will receive support through the Clean-Powered Public Service Fund to replace fossil fuel boilers. Southern, Taranaki, and ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 weeks ago
  • Schools back donations scheme for the second year
    More schools have opted in to the donations scheme for 2021, compared to 2020 when the scheme was introduced. “The families of more than 447,000 students will be better off next year, with 94% of eligible schools and kura opting into the scheme,” Education Minister Chris Hipkins said. “This is ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 weeks ago
  • Ruapehu cycle trails gets PGF boost
    The spectacular Mountains to Sea cycle trail in Ruapehu District will receive $4.6 million in funding from the Provincial Growth Fund for two additional trails, Regional Economic Development Minister Shane Jones announced today. “This is an exciting development for the local community, and one that will provide significant economic opportunities ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 weeks ago
  • Update to air border order strengthens crew requirements
    Additional measures coming into effect on Monday will boost our defence against COVID-19 entering New Zealand through the air border, Health Minister Chris Hipkins said today. “As part of our precautionary approach and strategy of constant review, we’re tightening the requirements around international aircrew,” Chris Hipkins said. The COVID-19 Public ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 weeks ago
  • A true picture of Māori business activity
    A better picture of the contribution Māori businesses make to the economy will be possible with changes to the way information is collected about companies and trading enterprises. Māori Development Minister Nanaia Mahuta and Small Business Minister Stuart Nash have announced a new option for Māori enterprises who are part ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 weeks ago
  • PGF funding for Taranaki projects
    The South Taranaki museum, a New Plymouth distillery and a Pasifika building firm will benefit from a Government investment totalling more than $1 million, Regional Economic Development Minister Shane Jones says. The $1.05m in grants and loans from the Provincial Growth Fund (PGF) will help the recipients expand and create ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 weeks ago
  • Fijian Language Week 2020 inspires courage and strength during COVID-19 pandemic
    The Minister for Pacific Peoples, Aupito William Sio says the theme for the 2020 Fijian Language Week reflects the strong belief by Fijians that their language and culture inspires courage and strength that is strongly needed in times of emergencies, or through a significant challenge like the global COVID-19 pandemic ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 weeks ago
  • Trades training builds on iwi aspirations
    An investment of $2.025 million from the Māori Trades and Training Fund will support Māori to learn new skills while making a positive difference for their communities, announced Employment Minister Willie Jackson today. “K3 Development Limited Partnership will receive $2,025,000 for its Takitimu Tuanui apprenticeship programme, which will support the ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 weeks ago
  • Conservation Minister plants two millionth tree in Raglan restoration
    A long-term conservation project led by the Whaingaroa Harbour Care group in the western Waikato reaches a significant milestone this week, with the planting of the two millionth tree by the Minister of Conservation Eugenie Sage. “Planting the two millionth tree crowns 25 years of commitment and partnership involving Whaingaroa ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 weeks ago
  • Seniors – our parents and grandparents
    International Older Persons Day is a chance to think about the individual older New Zealanders we know and to confront ageism, Seniors Minister Tracey Martin said today. “What happened around COVID-19 is a reminder that our over-65s are a very large and diverse group of people and we need to ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 weeks ago
  • Residential building sector growing stronger
    Figures released by Statistics New Zealand today show healthy growth in residential building consents in an environment of Government support for the sector during COVID-19, says Housing Minister Dr Megan Woods. Statistics New Zealand reported today that a record 10,063 townhouses, flats, and units were consented in the August 2020 ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 weeks ago
  • PGF helps Bay of Plenty youth find jobs
    Provincial Growth Fund (PGF) support for a pathways to work hub in Tauranga will help address high youth unemployment in the Bay of Plenty by connecting young people with training and meaningful employment opportunities, Parliamentary Under-Secretary for Regional Economic Development Fletcher Tabuteau has announced. “Priority One Western Bay of Plenty ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 weeks ago