Tory Whanau leaves Wellington mayoral race for Māori ward

Written By: - Date published: 8:54 am, April 29th, 2025 - 59 comments
Categories: Andrew Little, local body elections, local government, uncategorized - Tags:

Wellington mayor Tory Whanau has announced she won’t run for mayor again at this year’s local body elections. She names two reasons: one is former Labour Party leader Andrew Little stepping into the race, and her desire to continue working for Wellington as a Māori ward councillor.

Good interview snip her on Stuff with her explaining the why.

Longer read from RNZ.

This is great news for the left, and smart. Andrew Little is a strong contender and has the backing of the Labour Party. Whanau stepping aside will stop the vote from being split* while keeping Whanau as a Green candidate potentially in council and focused on Māori representation. Win/win for the green and the left.

Whanau also spoke in the Stuff piece about the personal difficulties she has had in her term as mayor, and how her generation tends to be more open about those. She makes the very good point that more support is needed for people going through diagnoses of ADHD. Neurodiverse people bring important perspectives and processes that enhance governance, and having people supported well in order to do those jobs matters as a disability access principle as well.

Whanau as whahine Māori will have faced abuse far beyond what is acceptable in politics. Again, we need a diverse range of people in positions of power, or we just end up with a monoculture with limited understanding of the world and approaches. That abuse culture is now an entrenched part of the political landscape and one of the most pressing issues we have.

I have mixed feelings about the whole Millennials wearing it all on their sleeve thing. As a society we need to be more open about personal difficulties instead of people being shamed or ostracised. But there is a limit on that once one is running a city, in part because of perceptions of competency. I can’t imagine the difficulty of finding that balance for Whanau given being neurodivergent in a still largely ableist system, and on the receiving end of serious political and personalised abuse on top of the ordinary pressures of the job.

I hope she is able to find a better path in her next endeavours and that people step up with support and protection so she can use her skills in serving the community to the best of her ability.

update: * Belladonna has pointed out in comments that under the STV voting system that Wellington uses, vote splitting is unlikely.

59 comments on “Tory Whanau leaves Wellington mayoral race for Māori ward ”

  1. SPC 1

    Little saying that contracts for the Golden Mile project (one funded by the Labour government) would be honoured made it easier.

    Thus despite opposition from Ministers in the Coalition of Chaos government and also within council some legacy.

  2. Res Publica 2

    I'd be inclined to agree with the core of your analysis, Weka.

    It's been clear for some time that, irrespective of her leadership qualities, integrity, and intelligence, Whanau’s mayoralty had become politically untenable in an increasingly toxic and fractious environment. The combination of being a young wāhine Māori, openly neurodiverse, and aligned with progressive values made her an irresistible target for reactionaries desperate to reassert traditional hierarchies.

    The electorate has been whipped into a frenzy over the past few years — not just locally but nationally — by a narrative that casts any challenge to the status quo as a form of betrayal. Localism was loudly espoused in 2023 as a weapon against central government reforms, yet the same voices calling for "local democracy" balked when that democracy elected someone they didn't like. They were never seeking genuine community leadership; they were seeking control.

    In that, Tory Whanau has been an unfairly public and publicised victim.

    I also hope that the struggles and public difficulties Whanau faced don’t end up unfairly damaging the broader progressive brand. It would be a tragedy if the political risks she took by being authentic, visible, and vulnerable were weaponised not just against her, but against the next generation of progressive candidates coming through.

    Whanau has a great deal to offer, and her choice here shows exactly the kind of principled leadership that should be valued, not vilified.

    I hope she gets the time and support she deserves to continue contributing meaningfully to Wellington’s future.

    • AB 2.1

      Yes – very well said. If I had one niggle, it's that Whanau and others on the left don't appear to realise just what targets they are. Maybe they take too benign a view of their opponents. But the Right despise any sign of personal weakness, of emotional fragility and of not being, or appearing to be, in control. They attack relentlessly when they see any of these things.

      • weka 2.1.1

        I suspect they understand themselves as targets well enough (given how common this is now), but lack strategy for dealing with it differently.

      • barry 2.1.2

        The right don't despise weakness. They love to see it in their opponents, and attack it mercilessly.

        They are quite capable of being compassionate when it suits them (i.e. when it is one of them) – remember Muller's problems when he got compassion from both sides.

    • Ad 2.2

      OMG it's the media's fault.

      Like she didn't try to sell a major asset, lose control of the budget, smash her car and evade Police, lie, not apologize, screw the unions, screw council staff, leave Wellington Water to the Select Committee and let its Board burn, screw the Wellington Greens…

      … and leave like it was a beautiful graceful plan.

      • SPC 2.2.1

        smash her car and evade Police

        Please explain who this was about.

        Are you mimicking people who appear on the Platform and lie about the Mayor?

        screw the unions

        How?

        Etc.

      • Res Publica 2.2.2

        Better than doing all that, then clinging to your position for dear life while everyone else takes the heat from you torching the political brand on your way out.

        There’s something to be said for falling on your sword: a certain class and self-awareness wholly absent from other Green or Green-aligned politicians who’ve managed to shoot themselves in both feet and still tried to limp around pretending it didn’t happen.

        • SPC 2.2.2.1

          Green trait … OK

          • Res Publica 2.2.2.1.1

            I’m not convinced it’s a uniquely Green failing. Every party has had its share of elected officials who tried to zig when they should have zagged.

            But it’s hard to argue that the fallout from Elizabeth Kerekere, Golriz Gharahman, and Darleen Tana wouldn’t have been much smaller if they’d had the good political sense and moral courage to do what Tory Whanau has done and step down, rather than clinging on and forcing the party to bleed out slowly around them.

            I guess it wouldn’t be quite so noticeable if it hadn’t happened three times in the last couple of years. That’s a full 20% of caucus.

            • Belladonna 2.2.2.1.1.1

              Except that's exactly what Gharahman did. Left Parliament when the issue blew up.
              I suppose that you could argue that the GP 'should' have been aware of the pressure and the effects on Gharahman earlier. Or that she should have resigned pre-emptively once the problem became evident (both to herself and the GP).

              But that's hair splitting.
              Her actions were pretty principled, in putting the GP before herself.

              Kerekere, Tana and Doyle, however all put themselves ahead of their party.

              • Res Publica

                A fair point.

                I think the public outside of the talkback/NZ Herald outrage mob is more or less understanding of the situation Golriz was in. And she did take eventually do the right thing and took accountability for her actions.

                But the political management from the party was still incredibly piss-poor.

      • arkie 2.2.3

        smash her car and evade Police

        Yikes Ad, all brown women in politics look the same to you, huh?

        • weka 2.2.3.1

          more like green women all look the same.

          But your comment is a lazy form of argument, and specious. I see nothing in what Ad has said to suggest he has a problem with Māori or Pasifika women. If you do you should point it out.

          • arkie 2.2.3.1.1

            Are you also confusing Tory Whanau (Green) with Kiritapu Allan (former Labour)?

            • weka 2.2.3.1.1.1

              me? no.

              • arkie

                Then what do you mean by this: more like green women all look the same.

                • weka

                  Ad doesn't like the Greens much and frequently criticises them.

                  I mean, I get now you made an oblique point about Allan and Whanau, but it wasn't clear to me at the time and I seem to remember you throwing out that kind of argument before.

                  I really wish people would just use a few more words instead of trying to be clever.

                  • arkie

                    You didn't get my initial point and called my argument lazy and specious, of which it is neither, and now you say

                    and I seem to remember you throwing out that kind of argument before.

                    I don't think this is a particularly effective approach to moderation.

                    • weka

                      I'm not moderating you. If I was moderating, I'd make that clear.

                      Initially I thought your comment was lazy and specious. Now that I know what you are talking about I think it's lazy and lazy. I can't spell it out any more clearly, if people (not just you) prefer clever over communicating well, it will have an impact. Ad does it too btw.

                    • arkie

                      You're critiquing how my comment is written including your judgements on the validity of my phrasing. This may not be official moderation but as a commentor this is an uncomfortable level of scrutiny that's not applied evenly.

                    • weka

                      whereas from my perspective I'm feeling grumpy fairly evenly with a number of people across a number of spaces today.

                      I commented on TS commenting culture for a long before I became a moderator or author. It's just what I think about something I think about a lot.

            • weka 2.2.3.1.2.1

              I thought he might have mistook Whanau for Allen, I doubt he is lying though, more that he just forgot.

      • Dennis Frank 2.2.4

        Politics is a performance art, so we ought to give credit for the quality of the performance. What better way to illustrate the point than floundering around for a while then exiting stage left? You know, as if she were an authentic leftist.

        So I'm inclined to see your side of her whilst agreeing with how Weka framed her. One could call that ambidextry or two-faced, but I tend to go with being born when the midpoint of Libra was rising. I also agree with you that it's the media's fault, as usual. They haven't explained that she's symptomatic of general social trends, have they? To err is human, and each new generation popularises new forms of error.

        Yet we must try for compassion toward news media pros. The market has whacked them around substantially this century, so they're all running scared. "Merchants of Truth: inside the news revolution", by top insider Jill Abramson, was a revelation. As for Tory, best to learn the art of the comeback, although Trump as exemplar is doing his share of floundering as performance art too…

      • Rodel 2.2.5

        settle down Donald.

      • Bearded Git 2.2.6

        Agree Ad-she stuffed up badly on the airport issue.

        There was no need to sell this core asset to pay for earthquake insurance-that was a smokescreen she somehow bought into.

        But overall she was eloquent and motivated and has achieved as much as any mayor could hope to achieve given she is only one vote around the table.

        • SPC 2.2.6.1

          It was not to pay for earthquake insurance.

          It was to have assets held outside of Wellington property and a minority ownership share of a business located there. It is called risk management.

  3. Obtrectator 3

    Payback for Andy – the Great Enabler of '17 has now himself been enabled (we hope).

  4. Corey 5

    Good. I have ADHD too, I'm also a millennial (I'm in that weird in-between gen y and Gen z, a 90s gen y) and from a mixed race family, I get her struggles and the abuse she's experienced

    However, sheesh she's been a terrible mayor.

    She's refused to consult with unions over her councils plans for privatization of assets, nearly every time she does an interview she says something that's not true (the selling her car to pay her mortgage lie will never not be funny) the drunken fights it's all way too messy.

    Refusing to meet with unions because her and her staff thought unions saying they wanted to "hold her feet to the fire" about air port privatization was "violent"

    She behaves like a gen y character written by a hacky boomer Hollywood screenwriter.

    Her behavior gives older generations a reason not to vote for gen y or gen z politicians even though the majority of gen y and Gen z politicians aren't as dramatic as her, Jacinda Ardern and Chloe Swarbrick, Kieren Mcanulty for example.

    I wish her well but running around town drunkenly shouting "I'm the f**king mayor" while funny at first is unbecoming of the office.

  5. Belladonna 6

    Vote splitting is a red herring for local Wellington elections. They have STV (single transferrable vote) – so you rank your candidates in order of preference. When your top preference drops out of contention, your vote automatically switches to the next person in your preference list who is still in contention.

    The order is bottom up: lowest scoring candidate is eliminated and their votes distributed, and so on up the list.

    https://wellington.govt.nz/your-council/elections/electoral-systems

    It seems likely that left voters would have ranked Little, Whanau, or Whanau, Little. Meaning that if/when one dropped out of contention (not in the top two), 'their' votes would have transferred to the other candidate.

    I guess that there is a risk that Green voters would only have selected Whanau (i.e. not completing the rest of the preferences) – so there was no preference to be transferred if/when she dropped out of contention. But there is also a risk that Green voters will now not bother to vote at all.

  6. Ad 7

    NZ's political economy is that Wellington Mayors will get carpet bombed by Ministers – because Ministers live there.

    Whanau was weak on her own accounting, so she got a Crown Observer.

    Little can handle that scrutiny fine.

    Lordy the moist excuses are sickening. It's not about her. Council leadership is about the lives of 180,000 people.

    • SPC 7.1

      So try hard and dry.

      They were required to manage the insurance risk to the council in an earthquake, as all their financial assets were all in the capital, including the airport shares.

      The 4 right wing councillors accepted the Mayor's (and some of the Greens) approach to sell off those shares and diversify their assets out of Wellington property/local business activity.

      They turned with the change in government and so the budget had to be re-done and the Minister used it as an excuse to infer the council was not working well. This was after they ended funding for Wellington’s Plan (the only part fully funded by the previous Labour government, the Golden Mile).

  7. DS 8

    Couldn't care less about her skin colour.

    Care rather more about privatisation. The excuses people round here make for neoliberalism in ostensibly left-wing parties is just disgusting. Are we still reliving the 1980s here?

    • SPC 8.1

      You are aware it is a minority holding?

      • DS 8.1.1

        Stop excusing it.

        A cocktail of gross incompetence and economic neoliberalism is not something I particularly want in the political Left. The notion that attacks on her are just evil racist misogynists is practically a stereotype of Identity Politics ("she's godawful at her job, and thoroughly neoliberal, but she belongs to a particular demographic so we'll excuse her").

        I'm reminded of Alamein Kopu. She used to accuse her critics of racism, and absolutely no-one bought it. Clearly Kopu was a woman ahead of her time – we are in a state of utter regression.

        • SPC 8.1.1.1

          You have given no reason why I should.

          Your claim it was an attempt at a privatisation was and is untrue.

          You are the one, conflating transfer of council held assets from a minority holding in an airport to other assets held out of the earthquake area for financial risk management reasons, as a "neo-liberal privatisation".

          It is not. And that is simply a fact.

          Your aside, about identity politics is irrelevant to the issue of decision-making competence.

  8. Rodel 9

    At last! Someone on the left (Whanau) who thinks strategically.The left will not win while they compete against each other. I dislike the National – Act dodgy &,dishonest arrangement in Epsom but what is the answer?.

    • Belladonna 9.1

      STV election in Wellington, not MMP or FPP.
      Which means that there is little, if any, risk of the left 'competing against itself'

    • Incognito 9.2

      One possible answer is to do away with electorate seats altogether. Strengthen local government and let Parliament/Government focus on law-making and governing the country.

  9. Belladonna 10

    I did wonder what the current Maori Ward councillor in Wellington, Nīkau Wi Neera, thought about Whanau's proposal to parachute herself into that role.

    But see, today (posted yesterday) that he is not standing.

    https://wellington.scoop.co.nz/?p=169971

Leave a Comment