“Hundreds of thousands of people rallied on Saturday afternoon in the German capital against the massive Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP) accord being negotiated by the European Union and the United States. Critics say the trade deal will benefit large corporations at the expense of average Europeans.” http://www.commondreams.org/news/2015/10/10/hundreds-thousands-march-berlin-against-ttip-trade-deal
There was a big wooden horse being rolled along too – also appropriate.
“Everything that we know about this secretive trade deal shows that it is very little about trade and very much about enshrining a massive corporate power-grab.” Nick Dearden, director of Global Justice Now, at the Common Dreams link.
If our Labour Party has wet its finger and is holding it in the air to determine which way the wind is blowing, it might want to look at that photo of about 250,000 people marching against the TTIP. When we go to make a law in NZ we don’t want our first consideration to be “are we likely to be sued in an ISDS if we make this law?” TPP has this chilling effect.
Our first consideration should be “Is this law good for New Zealand, both for the people and the environment (and not detrimental to the world in general.)
Labour, if you are listening, we don’t wan’t this TPP. We lose more than we gain.
(Note the Herald title to Bernard Hickey’s article is incomplete.
Yes. “While the EU has an impressively alliterative “farm to fork” strategy, for instance, regulating each link in the food chain, Americans pump their cattle and pigs with growth-promoting hormones banned in the EU. As a result, most US beef can’t be sold in the EU.
Matthew Hooton (in his piece: Labour lurches to the extreme left over TPP) has used the possibility of Labour withdrawing from the TPP to scare potential supporters off Labour, undermining the Party’s efforts to build business support.
Labour would discuss its position on the TPP at its up and coming caucus meeting.
Audrey Young asks: will Labour be better off supporting the deal than not supporting it?
Will it be any better off sounding as though it opposes it but supporting it in the end?
Whatever they do you can bet the likes of hootten and all the other players will spin this in nacts favour so the rehetoric must be simple, short and snappy so it sticks in peoples minds despite the DP treatment.
Good to see King calling matty over his allegations, the electorate is crying out for a front foot approach to take back the argument to ordinary kiwis and away from the hollowmen and their shills in the msm.
Exactly. Labour needs to have a clear position, state that position and then stick to it. We’re getting fucked over by their ambivalence and their compromising with the RWNJs that just sees our country going ever more to the right and thus getting higher levels of poverty.
Labour should not support TPP. Period. It is very different to the China trade deal.
Supporting TPP which Hillary Clinton, Bernie Sanders, Corbyn etc do not support. There is massive mainstream political and public support AGAINST TPP.
They don’t have to agree with everything the Nats do in a NatLite way, now is the time for Labour to cut away from the 1980’s and the Clark era, and start looking at what Kiwis want, not want Labour think the country may or may not need. We are in a brave new technological world and the TPP aims to keep us in the past and the current powers dominant with outdated practises. History shows that those in power cling on and try to destroy as they are being replaced because they can’t or will not adapt.
One of the biggest mistakes Labour is making is sitting on the fence and using ‘confusion’ about it’s position to somehow try to be everything to all people, but instead looking like a completely untrustworthy party than just goes where the tide turns and gets bogged down in details oh I support this in this way but not in this way and maybe in this way, but not in this way (details all missing). Too complicated Labour!
“One of the biggest mistakes Labour is making is sitting on the fence and using ‘confusion’ about it’s position to somehow try to be everything to all people, but instead looking like a completely untrustworthy party than just goes where the tide turns and gets bogged down in details oh I support this in this way but not in this way and maybe in this way, but not in this way (details all missing). Too complicated Labour!”
Won’t Labour and everyone else need to see the whole document before stating a position? If Little was to say now that he/they oppose the TPP he would be trounced for being against something unseen/unconsidered.
Wait folks.
Taking into account Labour put forward their bottom lines. Coupled with the breach of their bottom lines (which Little concedes) in the info released thus far, a number expect Labour would oppose it on that alone.
However, Little says they’re certainly opposed to what they see at the moment, but they still want to see the final text. Which, with that said, implies there’s a possibility they may not oppose it.
And it is that lack of total commitment that leaves a number questioning why?
Your average person sees Labour making bottom lines, hears they’ve been breached, thus expects Labour to come out and totally oppose the deal on that basis.
I don’t see any confusion TC. It’s the pro-TPP mob – including much of the media – and the NActs sowing the seed of so-called confusion. Matthew Hooton’s latest attempt to suggest there’s ructions in the L. caucus over the TPP is a good example. Little squashed that load of bullshit once and for all this morning.
The bottom lines are still there and Little made it clear they will pass legislation to counter adverse effects when they are the government. When posed the question… what if the US (or who ever else) take retaliatory action, he [effectively] said… they can shit themselves as much as they like, but if it’s not in the best interest of our citizens we will not play ball. Good answer. Call their bluff.
The confusion lays with Ardern saying Labour will face the consequences (implying Labour will refuse to be bound by the TPP) and Robertson saying Labour will weigh up the consequences. Implying if the consequences are to severe, Labour will breach their 5 bottom lines.
Leaving a number wondering why make bottom lines when you may accept them being breached?
Hooton did more than claim the Party is divided. He went on to paint a withdrawal from the deal as Labour lurching towards the extreme left. Saying, the lunatics now running Labour’s asylum must never be let near power.
IMO, Hooton is not only trying to scare potential supporters off Labour, he’s also trying to scare Labour from withdrawing.
IMO, Hooton is not only trying to scare potential supporters off Labour, he’s also trying to scare Labour from withdrawing.
Exactly what he’s doing imo.
What appalling arrogance! He’s a pip-squeak among many other pip-squeaks who have a vastly over-rated opinion of themselves. I may not be able to abide him as a person/ politician, but at least John Key has some legitimacy when it comes to playing these games.
The other big problem in farming is that they have been encouraged to expand and have too much stock and then have to buy in supplementary feed which is very expensive and often using Palm Kernel expeller which is imported from Indonesia where it is contributed to massive rain forest destruction and climate change.
Where is the support for farmers farming in a sustainable way and research to support that from government?
Do we want to be a low end commodity producer ALL our life as a country or when is someone going to say – lets move up the value chain?
For example Lactoferrin is approx $500,000 per ton and milk solids $3000 a ton?
Nutricuticials should be top on the list of where our milk industry is heading not ‘lets produce more milk for less money’.
Do we want to be a low end commodity producer ALL our life as a country
According to National that’s exactly what we are and should be. It’s why they keep making getting a good education harder and why they keep pushing dairying.
My company manufactures a highly value added product 100% here in NZ Draco, but at the moment that product is effectively locked out of lucrative markets such as Canada, Japan, and the US by 20-30% tariffs that are designed to make our end price uncompetitive.
If the TPP goes ahead those tariffs will disappear and we would immediately set out on a major expansion into those markets.
All going well, we would be looking at many new high value NZ jobs and significant flow on benefits down through all the companies that supply us raw materials and services.
I know several other NZ Made Manufacturers who are in exactly the same situation……
So everything else aside, I can see some outcomes from the TPPA that would create opportunities for people who are trying to add value to the NZ economy. Just saying, but it ain’t all bad.
If the TPP goes ahead those tariffs will disappear and we would immediately set out on a major expansion into those markets.
Even without tariffs it’ll still cost more to get your products to market in those nations because of the added costs of transporting them. The only way you’d be able to compete would be if you lowered wages.
As I say. If there’s a level playing field in world trade (Which was the point of the WTO/GATT) then there wouldn’t be any world trade. A manufacturer in NZ cannot compete with a manufacturer in Canada/US/Australia when under the same conditions. That’s physical reality.
@ The Lost Sheep, if you can’t make it in NZ or China then you probably are not going to make it in, the rest of the world. The tariffs do not stop trade so the TPP is not going to miraculously make a market for new NZ products. In fact more likely under TPP someone bigger will come along steal your idea and litigate you, so go under. The copywrite laws are intended to be protectionist to the current status quo.
All wrong savenz.
Tariffs do in fact stop trade. That is largely the point of them.
In the case of my business area, removal of tariffs will create huge new markets that we can effectively compete in.
I’m not generalising a theoretical case here, I’m talking about a specific opportunity that we have spent years investigating and are absolutely certain of.
That’s good isn’t it?
Maybe you have a great idea or product but when you look at Dragon’s Den like entrepreneurs – quite a few people are absolutely certain they have some amazing product the world is dying to obtain. But quite often the people are fruit cakes and with or without TPP are going to fail. Not sure if this is you, but NZ is an easy market to get a product out in, and TPP does not actually remove all tarrifs in fact there is only about 10% difference from now in some areas.
But we certainly DO KNOW under TPP medicine will be more expensive as even Key has said, patents for longer, protectionist measures, etc
We know NZ can be sued and our government and courts won’t be deciding the outcome but 3 international judges than have never found against the US historically.
The opposite of ‘free trade’.
In the US/OZ free trade deal they are both worse off 10 years later.
So should the rest of the country be worse off, because MAYBE someone is slightly better off, and again corporate welfare. i.e. taxpayers helping business at the expense of the rest of the population who have to pay more individually to subsidise the business?
quite a few people are absolutely certain they have some amazing product the world is dying to obtain. But quite often the people are fruit cakes and with or without TPP are going to fail. Not sure if this is you,
No. I have very well established growing business that already sells to people throughout the world. So no need to do Dragons Den.
So should the rest of the country be worse off, because MAYBE someone is slightly better off, and again corporate welfare. i.e. taxpayers helping business at the expense of the rest of the population who have to pay more individually to subsidise the business?
Well, if you believe, as many do here, that our Govt. would deliberately negotiate a deal that guaranteed a negative overall outcome for our country, or you believe that Govt. in NZ pays anything like significant subsidies to business, then you might say that.
But I think that is rubbish.
Like all the trade negotiations I have ever seen, this one is a result of the compromise process that occurs when every country is trying to stimulate growth, but at the same time trying to gain more access to other markets than they give away in their own.
There are opportunities for NZ’ers in this deal, if it goes ahead. My plan is to take maximum advantage of the ones in front of me.
I just hope enough NZ’ers do the same to make it an overall positive net outcome.
Orchard manager Evan Heywood said the lack of rain would hurt fruit growers in areas, such as Waimea, where the water supply was limited.
This is one of the big environmental problems we face – a lot of people actually think that the water supply we have is unlimited. The reality is that the water supply is limited and we need to live within those limits.
It’s true we have a problem with out attitude towards water (thinking it’s endless). Water’s not the main problem in how to grow food in dry climates though, it’s how we use land. Current agricultural practices, including irrigation, encourage drought.
Here’s establishing food producing trees in the first year on one of the driest place on earth (on salinated soil). They used 1/5th the amount of water used in that area normally.
Thanks! That’s a very good interview (yes, smart people), and has a good explanation of how to manage water differently (at start and then half way through).
We have had an ‘endless supply’ mentality to H2O here in NZ. Here in the Waikato, arguably the greenest of this green and pleasant land, we now have irrigation booms, a la Canterbury Plains.
When we were building in the country 18 years ago we designed the house for maximum rain collection and chucked in a couple of BIG tanks.
Neighbours suggested putting down a bore…plenty of groundwater they said.
This was because we refused to water the veg plants….(we still got bumper crops) to conserve our house supply.
Drought of 2007/2008 saw those neighbours’ bores all dry up.
Local 1000 cow dairy farm had their pump on the lowest point in the area…had sucked the aquifer dry.
They are the ones with the boom…I presume sucking the water from the river.
In the 50s isn’t that what the refugees flooding into Israel did to green the desert? (Recently I scooped buckets of beach sand and pebbles to put on a small patch. Weed-cloth then the salt laden beach sand. The weeds grew prolifically!)
I don’t know ian. Permacuture (which is the design technique used in that video) was invented in the 1970s, but it is based in many existing traditional systems, so it’s possible that swales were used in the situation you refer to.
Why were you putting beach sand and pebbles in your garden?
It was a small patch of ground in which I aimed to grow a lemon tree and a shrub. Since we were seldom there to weed I thought that the salty beach sand would block the weeds, but no.
This is what irrigation should be used for. A prop at times of drought, and perhaps an aid to encourage an early start to the growing season so as to get crops well on their way before known seasonal weather bringing heat and moisture deficits occur.
Personally I know several people who will not support Labour precisely because it has not come out definitely against the TPP. Labour is not opposed to free trade agreements per se, but the positive amount of free trade in this agreement for NZ is small compared to the negatives of ISDS, the inability to prevent foreign ownership of land and yet to be revealed final rules on SOEs and other hidden fishhooks.
Labour seem to be waiting for the final text so that their arguments will be based on fact’
Here’s Audrey Young:
“It will be passed by the Cabinet and National has the numbers with Act and Peter Dunne to pass any legislation required.
But the Government would prefer to pass it with as much cross-party support as possible.
The campaign against the TPP has shifted the default position of the public from a generally pro-FTA position to neutral.
In the Herald’s DigiPoll survey in August, only 22.9 per cent said they supported it generally on the basis that New Zealand’s economic well-being depended on increased trade with the world; 31.3 per cent opposed it on the basis of investor-state dispute procedures and 45 per cent had no view.
Labour has been pivotal in shifting public opinion, shifting its own position last year from a pro starting point to a neutral one.”
OK Labour. Let’s move it from neutral to NEGATIVE!
To me, this is the most important sentence. Audrey Young again:
“My prediction is that Labour will spend the next month sounding as though it opposes the TPP, pointing out where it could have been better, condemning the Government for not getting a perfect deal, but end up supporting it. In the process it will be sending mixed messages.”
This must not happen. Stop equivocating, Labour. There’s enough info out with the latest leak. You’ll gain more by opposing the TPP. It’s an up or down decision now- liking bits of the agreement is not enough.
This must not happen. STOP equivocating, Labour. There’s enough info out with the latest leak. You’ll gain more by opposing the TPP. It’s an up or down decision now- liking bits of the agreement is not enough.
I know you’ve been anxious to hear an unequivocal statement against the TPP… How ’bout the Greens?
James Shaw MP on Tuesday, October 6, 2015 – 10:03
The Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement (TPPA) makes it more likely that everyday New Zealanders will become tenants in our own land, while private companies snap up the limited gains of about one percent of GDP, the Green Party said today.
“The TPPA is a bad deal because the costs will be worn by everyday New Zealanders while the benefits will go to private companies,” Green Party Co-leader James Shaw said.
“New Zealanders are more likely to become tenants in our own land, because the TPPA slackens the overseas investment rules and takes away our right to limit overseas speculators from buying up our land.
“It’s becoming clear that it will be harder, take longer, and be more expensive to access next generation medicines in New Zealand and in developing countries.
“Multinational companies will be able to sue New Zealand if it takes action to protect our environment, for example strengthening the protection for the critically endangered Maui’s dolphins.
“Trade Minister Tim Groser can’t avoid the fact that the TPPA doesn’t actually break down trade barriers with markets like Canada, and it will be another 25 years before milk powder tariffs in the United States market are gone.
“Whichever way you look at the TPPA, it’s a bad deal.
“After five years of talking, Tim Groser and the National Government have failed to achieve an agreement that is in New Zealand’s best interests,” Mr Shaw said.
so Greens will repeal signing of TPP?…has Shaw said this specifically or is he equivocating?
…the Greens are in agreement with NZF then!?
…so where is bloody Labour?!
…they should be forming a united front saying “NO” to the TPP when they ALL form the next coalition Government
If the TPP is bad enough for both Republican Trump and Democrat Saunders to have the courage to stick their necks out and say “NO”!….surely NZ Labour can do the same!….and stop sitting on the fence
‘Bernie Sanders, Donald Trump slam Trans-Pacific Partnership deal as ‘disastrous’ & ‘terrible’ ‘
“Trump, a 69-year-old billionaire real estate mogul, entered the US presidential race in June, seeking the Republic nomination. He is currently leading in the polls.”
I have not heard an unequivocal rejection of the TPP from either Labour or the Greens.
Statements like “The TPP was not voted in democratically by the New Zealand people. We shall repeal it once we are in power.”
agreed …the Greens, like Labour, have not come out unequivocally against the TPP
…if they must fence sit ….why not a NZ referendum on the TPP?….why allow the secrecy and lack of democracy?
…if it is good enough to have a referendum on the flag (when most NZers want to keep the existing flag)…it should be good enough to have a democratic referendum on deciding whether to adhere to jonkey Nacts secret deal on the TPP?
Why hide it from the people if it’s such a good deal, it can speak for itself, without the need for well placed media megaphones selectively pushing aspects of it?
seem to recall you expressing with complete certainty this morning that once in place no government (in NZ) will leave…are you saying youve changed your mind Matthew?
Incredibly……no, he wasn’t challenged. Neither by Dallow (who’s surprised ?……Dallow was relating as one would to the AB captain after a successful international campaign)….. nor by Little.
‘Dallow was educated at Liston College and St Peter’s College. He completed his tertiary education at Auckland University, where he studied law. After completing his legal studies, Dallow practised as a litigation and insurance lawyer in Auckland, New Zealand.
Whilst on his OE, the 1987 stock market crash occurred, causing him to change careers, as a future in bankruptcy law was unappealing. Dallow then spent the next six years as a tour director in Europe. He returned to New Zealand in 1993.’
A litigation lawyer before the ’87 crash.
These people are not independent.
Dallow’s mediocrity as a journalist and the fact he does not ask any difficult questions of the powerful has ensured his promotion at TVNZ.
Dallow is incompetent. He seems always to be under-prepared and is therefore nervous and unsure of himself in interviews. He knows enough, though, to side with power, as demonstrated by his outrageously biased performance in “chairing” the discussion with Charles Finny, Helen Kelly and Professor Steve Hoadley on Q+A this morning.
Well he was riding on the coat tails of his former wife after all. Not surprising she saw the light.
God how a pray to be around when the inevitable clean out occurs. It’ll be a therapist’s dream come true. Maybe I should write a few things down.
I hope when it comes to pass, the very same methods used to implement the culture of a neo-liberal agenda is used to rid us all of it.
I can think of several ways to cleanup TVNZ for a start and to return it to a form that serves its public (rather than its consumer).
We should keep it in perspective though – this sort of shit is even infecting that supposed bastion of the Educate Inform and Entertain triumvirate (the Aunty BBC)
His father Ross was a local body politico out West, of the Right persuasion. Got Marier Hasler a plumb position in a Sports Trust (which she was ill equipped to do) after she lost her seat in Parliament. She had to be let go after only a few months ith a severance package. Dallow hoped it would further his career.
To be fair Groser and Little were interviewed individually and in the case of Little he was confined to the questions asked of him by Dallow. I thought his responses were strong and left no doubt Labour will take action against aspects of the deal (eg. foreign property speculation) if they become the government. At the same time he intimated Labour has to look at the details – when they finally emerge – but my impression is they are not going to budge on their bottom lines.
He also made it clear the caucus was totally united on those “bottom lines”, so Hooten’s [excited] claims to the contrary were bullshit. I wonder who the insiders were? Pagani et al?
Little lost any credibility he might have had when he assented, reluctantly, to the Key regime’s snooping legislation. After assuring reporters how unhappy he was, he then assured reporters that would be the last time Labour would cave in like that.
He has virtually no respect from the government, and it’s all his own fault.
Hooton is a spin doctor whose rabid support for the TPP and personal attacks on opponents to the deal suggests it is in his interest that the deal gets passed whatever is in it.
Has he seen the full text? I doubt it, but that isn’t important for him. The only interest I have in Hooton is finding out who he is working for. Possibly nobody is paying him at this stage but he is hoping for work in the future. Who knows, but in my opinion the acquisition of money and/or power is the main motivator for the actions of those on the right, and I see no reason to believe any thing they say.
Hooton has chosen 2 particular parts of the agreement to argue. Someone has given him sufficient assurances that he is not on shakey ground pushing those 2 things. He might not have seen the full text but he has been given a very good (and directed) nod and a wink)
I took it Labour oppose the TPP. But opposing the deal means little as Labour’s support isn’t necessary for the deal to pass.
And to safeguard their bottom lines, Labour are considering legislating against the ordinances of the TPP.
However, as Labour are talking about facing the consequences of legislating against the ordinances of the TPP, it indicates they don’t plan to totally withdraw from the deal.
Therefore, Little’s responses were far from strong (taking the middle ground) or left enough.
Your argument has a whacking great logical hole in it. Are you saying that Labour should not oppose TPPa supporting legislation that gets introduced between now and 2017.
You sound like an unthinking dingbat. Labour isn’t on the treasury benches. So that is the Only way that can prospectus agreement.
Why would they? The problem isn’t with making trade deals. The problem is with making bad trade deals.
The last thing I saw from them (in the Herald today?) was that the TPP appears to have failed on 4 out of 5 of their base points, and that is what they want to fix.
Asked if that includes pulling out of the TPP, Mr Little said his party would always reserve the right to do so.
“In the end you know every government’s duty is to act in the best interests of its people, of its citizens and we will do that, and if it means that we would have to do things that would be in breach of the TPP, because we wouldn’t walk out of it, we would do those things. If we have opportunities to renegotiate things that are less favourable to us, we will.”
In other words, if this crap deal doesn’t improve a lot then Labour will withdraw from it.
For all of the stupidity of this government in getting involved with this idiotic “trade” deal, they have also sunk a hell of a lot of money into trying to do so – probably well in excess of $100 million since 2009 after the US got involved and converted a free trade agreement to a restraint of trade agreement. It’d be good to recover that.
But if that isn’t possible and it continues to look like constraining our trade development, then the damn thing should be dumped.
Labour won’t be able to fix all the breaches. And Little clearly didn’t commit to walking away, though he implied they may.
As I stated above, to save face on their bottom lines, they are considering legislating against the ordinances of the TPP. Which Little has confirmed.
However, as Labour are talking about facing the consequences of legislating against the ordinances of the TPP, it indicates they don’t plan to totally withdraw from the deal.
Little helps confirm this by not fully committing to withdrawing from the deal.
Additionally, the cat was let out of the bag when Robertson said the Party would weigh up the consequences, implying if the consequences are to severe, Labour will back down.
So brace yourself for that excuse coming into play later on down the track.
Labour seems to be using one of their common tactics. They make a big song and dance opposing something, but in the end, they support it. Which tends to put voters off voting Labour.
Though, in saying that, the stuff article tends to lay some foundation (appeasing exporter concern) for walking away.
how can anyone measure future legal action by organisations that may as yet be unformed?….one of the problems for ANY group seeking to quantify the costs/benefits, even after all the text is released is we have no possible way of quantifying the ISDS provisions….on these provisions alone I would walk away but then, im not seeking election.
It is worth posting the complete quote here as it appeared in the NZH:
’ “I think that is almost inconceivable, given the safe cards our international lawyers have negotiated, that anyone will take a case against New Zealand in the next X years,” he said.’
In his opinion Timmy reckons that NZ will be untouchable, legally speaking, and even the US Litigation Army will avoid us like the plague because it will be ‘mission impossible’. The fact that all law needs to be tested in court has escaped Timmy.
what international lawyers? Have their costs been included in the Fact Sheets? (rhetorical cos they have not) – Unless our lawyers have been able to change the intent and meaning of the investor relations clauses in the final text, they can’t guarantee anything.
More TPP propaganda from the Herald/Pravda.
This time they give air space to an ex-leader of the ACT Party, a party that gets under 1% of the electoral vote.
Still, it’s nearly appropriate.
The Herald does represent the views of the 0.01%.
And just like you, he has no actual argument to counter the TPPA.
Simply a personal attack on Jane Kelsey.
So typical for the extreme neo-liberal ideologues.
You have no moral or practical argument, so you resort to personal insults.
The same was done to Mike Joy, Jon Stephenson, Nicky Hager, Glenn Greenwald……
Matthew R X Dentith @HORansome 1h1 hour ago
Rodney Hide’s latest column is so bad that if he submitted it as an essay I’d refuse to mark it unless he & I had a meeting to discuss it
‘And on rolls the NZH’s relentless pro-TPPA propaganda machine. On today’s menu: a quick and dirty hit job on Jane Kelsey. Slap a “Marxist” label on her and be done with it, won’t you Rodney? Actually arguing the points is too much like hard work, isn’t it? Plus one might end up looking a bit foolish, like your friend Mike. She is a law professor after all, and has actually spent a significant part of her life analysing the subject matter. It’s so much easier just to shoot the messenger. Oh, and nice work on choosing that photo, NZH editors. It goes well with the whole Marxist theme.’
It’s ok. Wayne Mapp’s theory applies here. If you have NEVER opposed a FTA (and Hide has not) then we can discount his opinion as being so heavily jaundiced as to be lacking any credibility.
“Columnist Pat Buchanan predicted that the debate on the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) would be after the “early primaries” and the deal “is in real trouble” on Friday’s “McLaughlin Group.”
Buchanan said, “These are trade deals put together by transnational corporations and trade ministries to globalize the world economy, basically to enable these powerful corporations to move their factories and plants out of countries where the wages are high, to countries where the wages are low, so they can bring their products back…free of charge into the United States. In the last month, our trade deficit’s running at 600 billion overall this year, and with China at $400 billion, John. But I will you this, the forces that oppose these transnational trade deals are getting stronger and stronger. Not only [Sen.] Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT)16% and Hillary Clinton in the Democratic Party, but Mr. Trump in the Republican Party, this deal is in real trouble, and I predict that they’re going to have to throw the deal — the discussion in the House — or the Congress over past — certainly past the early primaries.” http://www.breitbart.com/video/2015/10/10/buchanan-tpp-in-real-trouble-debate-in-congress-will-be-after-early-primaries/
The Trans-Pacific Partnership’s two solitudes: Burman – Toronto Star
Comparison of TPP and refugee issues.
Tony Burman writes:
“In one case, when corporate and political power works in tandem, borders are a detail to be dispensed with. In the other case, when it’s simply about the powerless, borders are to be strengthened and made impenetrable. It all seems to depend on whose interests you value most.”
Shouldn’t it be handled as foreign aid by MFAT?
Did he ever consider that given a clear choice many taxpayers may not choose to donate to this particular charity to help in this part of the world?
This is not a post about whether or not people in this region need help – many will.
Just the question of is this how the government has released funds for it “crony charity?”
So Key’s personal donation was afternoon tea at his electorate office? Even that is likely to be paid for out of his office running budget.
It seems our multi-millionaire PM is happy to play the big benefactor with tax payer’s money but is keeping his hands out of his own pockets. What a guy!
Getting in first to counter the much quoted claim he donates his salary to charity that claim soon changed to a proportion of his salary and he has always refused to say what proportion.
It would be nice to see Key apologise to Stephenson though, or at least have something to say about the Defence Force slandering a journalist.
Is Matthew Hooton well?
He is coming across, in my opinion, somewhat ‘unhinged’ as he desperately attempts to ‘spin’ opponents of the TPPA as being ‘extreme’?
FYI (hopefully Matthew, you will see this either on Kiwiblog – or here?)
_______________________________________________________
A belated reply to Matthew Hooton’s (Kiwiblog) post October 9th, 2015 at 5:49 pm
Gee Matthew!
For a purportedly experienced ‘spin doctor’ / Media Commentator – that is a rather, (in my view), apoplectic and intemperate response, to my arguably straightforward questions?
Sheesh!
You were more pleasant when you were drinking!
(If you’re stressed, for whatever reason, try Spirulina, those ‘B’ vitamins can really help).
_____________________________________________________________
2. I don’t give a fuck who Tim Groser or Len Brown meet with. But it would make sense for the trade minister to brief the mayor of Auckland on his work from time to time.
Respect for those who refuse to be intimidated.
Or? Amusement at the simplicity who gather together all the principled and thinking people in one spot so they can be conveniently annihilated.
Protest in the streets like this can be futile, and destructive to the cause weakening numbers by decimation, and strengthening the triumphant vicious over-riding group. Repeating protests after attacks, should be the last resort. Better if other measures can be planned and the vicious attacked from behind, and through other ways where they have weaknesses.
You see, Planned Parenthood has a political action committee called Planned Parenthood Action Fund (hereinafter, PP Action Fund). In the 2012 elections, of the $5,141,216 the PP Action Fund spent on either supporting candidates who supported reproductive rights or opposing candidates who were antagonistic to such rights, the Return on Investment in these races was a flabbergasting 98.1%.
[…]
The second reason the Republicans tremble when they see Cecile Richards marching toward them in stilettos prepared to walk all over them is that the PP Action Fund is highly effective at getting out the vote, especially the votes of young women who tend to vote Democratic. They did this in the races of Senator Franken and of Mark Dayton (D), Governor of Minnesota. Without their help, Minnesota could have gone to the darkside and Al Franken would be home writing a sequel about the liars he has personally known in Congress
Thanks for this. It definitely explains the willingness of the GOP to look stupid, while pulling out every trick in the book (including out right fabrication and bare-faced lying), to try to destroy PP.
Good time to watch ‘the fog of war’ and remember the lessons supposedly learned by Vietnam… Parallels to all the other US run occupations in particular around the middle East.
Iraq, a problem that only existed in the US and UK imagination, but by which they have made a reality of the problem (with many profiting from it, while millions suffer).
Robert McNamara’s 11 lessons from Vietnam[edit]
From Robert McNamara’s 1995 book “In Retrospect: The Tragedy and Lessons of Vietnam”.[7]
We misjudged then — and we have since — the geopolitical intentions of our adversaries … and we exaggerated the dangers to the United States of their actions.
We viewed the people and leaders of South Vietnam in terms of our own experience … We totally misjudged the political forces within the country.
We underestimated the power of nationalism to motivate a people to fight and die for their beliefs and values.
Our misjudgments of friend and foe, alike, reflected our profound ignorance of the history, culture, and politics of the people in the area, and the personalities and habits of their leaders.
We failed then — and have since — to recognize the limitations of modern, high-technology military equipment, forces, and doctrine. We failed, as well, to adapt our military tactics to the task of winning the hearts and minds of people from a totally different culture.
We failed to draw Congress and the American people into a full and frank discussion and debate of the pros and cons of a large-scale military involvement … before we initiated the action.
After the action got under way, and unanticipated events forced us off our planned course … we did not fully explain what was happening, and why we were doing what we did.
We did not recognize that neither our people nor our leaders are omniscient. Our judgment of what is in another people’s or country’s best interest should be put to the test of open discussion in international forums. We do not have the God-given right to shape every nation in our image or as we choose.
We did not hold to the principle that U.S. military action … should be carried out only in conjunction with multinational forces supported fully (and not merely cosmetically) by the international community.
We failed to recognize that in international affairs, as in other aspects of life, there may be problems for which there are no immediate solutions … At times, we may have to live with an imperfect, untidy world.
Underlying many of these errors lay our failure to organize the top echelons of the executive branch to deal effectively with the extraordinarily complex range of political and military issues.
The activity of banking is issuing more promises than can ever be kept. Bankers’ ‘promises-to-pay’ circulate as money, and for as long as they circulate, the banking system (taken as a whole) never has to pay out on them. Bankers’ ‘promises-to-pay’ are claims on assets that, for the most part, don’t exist and never will exist.
The law of 1707 made lending a much more attractive proposition. Normally, when someone lends money, they say goodbye for a time to the money they have lent. But if lenders get a piece of paper acknowledging the debt, and if that piece of paper can be freely bought and sold, then lenders may sacrifice little or nothing by lending: they may even make an immediate gain, as Adam Smith notes below.
So – people were happier to lend. The government began to borrow spectacular amounts of money, to make war in Europe. This began the age of the national debt: nations borrowing off their rich, at no expense to the rich, who are paid interest (and eventually capital) out of taxes on the productive part of the nation.
This is why we had to sell out power generation, our telecommunications and pretty much everything else. Our banking system is pretty much designed to shift wealth to the few and thus make the rest of us slaves to those few.
It’s amazing, frustrating, and terrifying to note the difference in coverage right now between the Radio New Zealand and the New Zealand Herald regarding the horrible terrorist attack in Turkey. It’s been the lead story all morning on the RNZ website but at the NZH website it falls faster than an anchor. The Herald fills their page up with several rugby stories, something about Susan Wood and Chris Cairns before we get to the Turkish story.
The reporting is strikingly different too. Radio Zealand calls the victims labour activists whereas the Herald calls the victims hard-line Marxists. Basically, for the Herald the attack doesn’t warrant significant outrage because the victims were left-wing despite the attack being conducted by war-mongering flavour-of-the-month ISIL. Anyone who thinks the Herald is balanced and non-tabloid needs to get their head checked.
The day after the TPP was signed these were the main headlines in the corporate media in NZ.
From The Daily Blog.
‘Here is what the NZ Herald and Stuff decided was more important than a corporate coup removing NZs economic and political sovereignty the day after the TPPA was signed.
Sports gamblers panicking that the All Blacks won’t win the Rugby World Cup.
A porn renovation TV show might make some more money than they first thought.
A boat falls off a trailer.
A bad bus trip.
The world didn’t end after a religious prophecy
A radio host wears the same togs as Kylie Jenner.
An Apartment that got flooded by a fish tank was sold.
Government spends $600 000 on flowers
A dog gets put down.’
More propaganda from the Herald as they publicise the US media’s attempt to shut down Clinton. The corporate media are working overtime to ‘seal the deal’, aren’t they?
‘Clinton is wrong on the Trans-Pacific Partnership’
Jane Kelsey on Tim Groser who was trying to justify the secrecy of TPP in the interview this morning, Tim said he was “very pleased” tobacco control measures exempted from Investor State Dispute Settlement provisions and “I can almost guarantee you that if we had made that public, we would not have got it”
The tobacco carve out was one of the few bits of the TPP that WAS publicly discussed way back. In 2013.
“The United States and 11 countries bordering the Pacific Ocean had been engaged in the latest round of negotiations over a treaty intended to lower tariffs and other barriers to commerce. One of the issues was whether tobacco should be included in such a treaty or “carved out” so that health considerations could take precedence over expanded trade. The issue pits health advocates against the tobacco industry and other commercial interests. http://www.nytimes.com/2013/09/01/opinion/sunday/the-hazard-of-free-trade-tobacco.html?_r=0
and in 2014 Reuters
“U.S. floats cutting tobacco from part of Pacific trade pact -sources”
“Dropping tobacco from the investor-state dispute settlement, or ISDS, section of the Trans-Pacific Partnership would prevent tobacco companies taking action against any TPP government under those legal protections, for example over health care measures.” http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/10/21/usa-trade-tpp-idUSL2N0SG1WO20141021
Another issue: Tim believes ISDS wouldn’t stop NZ introducing a policy like plain packaging for fizzy drinks; “I believe you probably could as long as you had a good health-based case and you’re ready to defend it”
Does being ready to defend that mean in an “inconceivable” ISDS tribunal?
Toronto’s newspaper The Star has released a poll which has the Liberals under Justin Trudeau within reach of a ‘strong minority’. The Liberals are at 37% versus Harper’s Conservatives on 31%. Mulcair and the NDP are trailing at 23% which is an extraordinary turnaround from their frontrunner position going in to the campaign. http://www.thestar.com/news/canada/2015/10/10/liberals-within-reach-of-majority-poll.html
For a start, yesterday/today…..the sun shines…..blah blah blah. Who knows what’s in this deal ? Sovereignty’s hardly a thing “gone by lunchtime”.
Then pulling the ‘Commie Card’ re Jane Kelsey.
OK…..with as much ground for it I’ll pull the ‘Traitor Card’. Which is the canary suited has-been gargoyle aka Mr Love-Perks-Hypocrite Extraordinaire. And honours for Jane Kelsey.
I think he was stating the obvious. Her communism means that she opposes markets and globalisation. She has been doing so for 30 years. Her Wikipedia entry which she could edit if she wants reads like a horror story.
Too funny: Rodney Hide’s opinions are “obvious” to S Rylands.
S Rylands thinks that editing ones own Wikipedia entry is a good idea, whether or not it mentions “communism” (Kelsey’s doesn’t at the time of writing).
No wonder S Rylands reacts with “horror”: conflict of interest much?
There have been accusations and counter accusations about who is siding with which side in the war in Syria. There is sufficient proof that the FSA (Free Syrian Army), supported by the US and some Gulf states have been fighting alongside Al Nusra Front, an Al Qaeda associated group.
As it is going, I hardly see a problem with that, given that the murderous Assad has been siding with Hezbollah and Iran, who have their own human rights issues.
We see a situation in Syria, that deserves more scrutiny and effort to get all parties around a table to discuss a hopefully peaceful solution to the civil war, but bombings from the air by either the US or the Russians will hardly assist such a process, it will only fuel the situation and war there.
You ask a completely valid question. The sad truth is that the fronts are so hardened and there is such hostility, there will only be some prospect for peace if one of the sides puts the other under so much pressure that they will be prepared to negotiate. I doubt whether it is such a good idea by Putin and the Russians to keep Assad in place, that solves nothing and will only escalate and prolong the war there.
In the meantime refugees will flow into Europe and elsewhere and can only hope that the situation in Syria will somehow be resolved over future years. Not a great prospect, as also refugees face increased pressures and hostility in the places they have fled to. In Germany there have already been arson attacks on refugee homes, there are protests and the government is cutting benefits for refugees.
The EU is planning to fast track sending back hundreds of thousands that are presumed to rather be economic refugees.
The world is not a great place at present, for too many to live in.
” I doubt whether it is such a good idea by Putin and the Russians to keep Assad in place, that solves nothing and will only escalate and prolong the war there.”
I share your doubts.
Sadly, recent history also teaches us that over-throwing the selected undemocratic leader doesn’t solve the problem either. God forbid we look for a completely different solution rather than trying the same old failed ones over and over and over. I say selected because Saudi Arabia gets to be very undemocratic but untouched by Western superiority.
With the execution of global reciprocal tariffs, US President Donald Trump has issued his ‘declaration of economic independence for America’. The immediate direct effect on the Australian economy will likely be small, with more risk ...
The StrategistBy Jacqueline Gibson, Nerida King and Ned Talbot
AUKUS governments began 25 years ago trying to draw in a greater range of possible defence suppliers beyond the traditional big contractors. It is an important objective, and some progress has been made, but governments ...
I approach fresh Trump news reluctantly. It never holds the remotest promise of pleasure. I had the very, very least of expectations for his Rumble in the Jungle, his Thriller in Manila, his Liberation Day.God May 1945 is becoming the bitterest of jokes isn’t it?Whatever. Liberation Day he declared it ...
Beyond trade and tariff turmoil, Donald Trump pushes at the three core elements of Australia’s international policy: the US alliance, the region and multilateralism. What Kevin Rudd called the ‘three fundamental pillars’ are the heart ...
So, having broken its promise to the nation, and dumped 85% of submissions on the Treaty Principles Bill in the trash, National's stooges on the Justice Committee have decided to end their "consideration" of the bill, and report back a full month early: Labour says the Justice Select Committee ...
The 2024 Independent Intelligence Review offers a mature and sophisticated understanding of workforce challenges facing Australia’s National Intelligence Community (NIC). It provides a thoughtful roadmap for modernising that workforce and enhancing cross-agency and cross-sector collaboration. ...
OPINION AND ANALYSIS:Chief Ombudsman Peter Boshier’s comments singling out Health NZ for “acting contrary to the law” couldn’t be clearer. If you find my work of value, do consider subscribing and/or supporting me. Thank you.Health NZ has been acting a law unto itself. That includes putting its management under extraordinary ...
Southeast Asia’s three most populous countries are tightening their security relationships, evidently in response to China’s aggression in the South China Sea. This is most obvious in increased cooperation between the coast guards of the ...
In the late 1970s Australian sport underwent institutional innovation propelling it to new heights. Today, Australia must urgently adapt to a contested and confronting strategic environment. Contributing to this, a new ASPI research project will ...
In short this morning in our political economy:The Nelson Hospital waiting list crisis just gets worse, including compelling interviews with an over-worked surgeon who is leaving, and a patient who discovered after 19 months of waiting for a referral that her bowel and ovaries were fused together with scar tissue ...
Plainly, the claims being tossed around in the media last year that the new terminal envisaged by Auckland International Airport was a gold-plated “Taj Mahal” extravagance were false. With one notable exception, the Commerce Commission’s comprehensive investigation has ended up endorsing every other aspect of the airport’s building programme (and ...
Movements clustered around the Right, and Far Right as well, are rising globally. Despite the recent defeats we’ve seen in the last day or so with the win of a Democrat-backed challenger, Dane County Judge Susan Crawford, over her Republican counterpart, Waukesha County Judge Brad Schimel, in the battle for ...
In February 2025, John Cook gave two webinars for republicEN explaining the scientific consensus on human-caused climate change. 20 February 2025: republicEN webinar part 1 - BUST or TRUST? The scientific consensus on climate change In the first webinar, Cook explained the history of the 20-year scientific consensus on climate change. How do ...
After three decades of record-breaking growth, at about the same time as Xi Jinping rose to power in 2012, China’s economy started the long decline to its current state of stagnation. The Chinese Communist Party ...
The Pike River Coal mine was a ticking time bomb.Ventilation systems designed to prevent methane buildup were incomplete or neglected.Gas detectors that might warn of danger were absent or broken.Rock bolting was skipped, old tunnels left unsealed, communication systems failed during emergencies.Employees and engineers kept warning management about the … ...
Regional hegemons come in different shapes and sizes. Australia needs to think about what kind of hegemon China would be, and become, should it succeed in displacing the United States in Asia. It’s time to ...
RNZ has a story this morning about the expansion of solar farms in Aotearoa, driven by today's ground-breaking ceremony at the Tauhei solar farm in Te Aroha: From starting out as a tiny player in the electricity system, solar power generated more electricity than coal and gas combined for ...
After the Berlin Wall came down in 1989, and almost a year before the Soviet Union collapsed in late 1991, US President George H W Bush proclaimed a ‘new world order’. Now, just two months ...
Warning: Some images may be distressing. Thank you for those who support my work. It means a lot.A shopfront in Australia shows Liberal leader Peter Dutton and mining magnate Gina Rinehart depicted with Nazi imageryUS Government Seeks Death Penalty for Luigi MangioneMangione was publicly walked in front of media in ...
Aged care workers rallying against potential roster changes say Bupa, which runs retirement homes across the country, needs to focus on care instead of money. More than half of New Zealand workers wish they had chosen a different career according to a new survey. Consumers are likely to see a ...
The scurrilous attacks on Benjamin Doyle, a list Green MP, over his supposed inappropriate behaviour towards children has dominated headlines and social media this past week, led by frothing Rightwing agitators clutching their pearls and fanning the flames of moral panic over pedophiles and and perverts. Winston Peter decided that ...
Twilight Time Lighthouse Cuba, Wigan Street, Wellington, Sunday 6 April, 5:30pm for 6pm start. Twilight Time looks at the life and work of Desmond Ball, (1947-2016), a barefooted academic from ‘down under’ who was hailed by Jimmy Carter as “the man who saved the world”, as he proved the fallacy ...
The landedAnd the wealthyAnd the piousAnd the healthyAnd the straight onesAnd the pale onesAnd we only mean the male ones!If you're all of the above, then you're ok!As we build a new tomorrow here today!Lyrics Glenn Slater and Allan Menken.Ah, Democracy - can you smell it?It's presently a sulphurous odour, ...
US President Donald Trump’s unconventional methods of conducting international relations will compel the next federal government to reassess whether the United States’ presence in the region and its security assurances provide a reliable basis for ...
Things seem to be at a pretty low ebb in and around the Reserve Bank. There was, in particular, the mysterious, sudden, and as-yet unexplained resignation of the Governor (we’ve had four Governors since the Bank was given its operational autonomy 35 years ago, and only two have completed their ...
Long story short:PMChristopher Luxon said in January his Government was ‘going for growth’ and he wanted New Zealanders to develop a ‘culture of yes.’ Yet his own Government is constantly saying no, or not yet, to anchor investments that would unleash real private business investment and GDP growth. ...
Long story short:PMChristopher Luxon said in January his Government was ‘going for growth’ and he wanted New Zealanders to develop a ‘culture of yes.’ Yet his own Government is constantly saying no, or not yet, to anchor investments that would unleash real private business investment and GDP growth. ...
For decades, Britain and Australia had much the same process for regulating media handling of defence secrets. It was the D-notice system, under which media would be asked not to publish. The two countries diverged ...
For decades, Britain and Australia had much the same process for regulating media handling of defence secrets. It was the D-notice system, under which media would be asked not to publish. The two countries diverged ...
This post by Nicolas Reid was originally published on Linked in. It is republished here with permission.In this article, I make a not-entirely-serious case for ripping out Spaghetti Junction in Auckland, replacing it with a motorway tunnel, and redeveloping new city streets and neighbourhoods above it instead. What’s ...
This post by Nicolas Reid was originally published on Linked in. It is republished here with permission.In this article, I make a not-entirely-serious case for ripping out Spaghetti Junction in Auckland, replacing it with a motorway tunnel, and redeveloping new city streets and neighbourhoods above it instead. What’s ...
In short this morning in our political economy:The Nelson Hospital crisis revealed by 1News’Jessica Roden dominates the political agenda today. Yet again, population growth wasn’t planned for, or funded.Kāinga Ora is planning up to 900 house sales, including new ones, Jonathan Milne reports for Newsroom.One of New Zealand’s biggest ...
In short this morning in our political economy:The Nelson Hospital crisis revealed by 1News’Jessica Roden dominates the political agenda today. Yet again, population growth wasn’t planned for, or funded.Kāinga Ora is planning up to 900 house sales, including new ones, Jonathan Milne reports for Newsroom.One of New Zealand’s biggest ...
The war between Russia and Ukraine continues unabated. Neither side is in a position to achieve its stated objectives through military force. But now there is significant diplomatic activity as well. Ukraine has agreed to ...
One of the first aims of the United States’ new Department of Government Efficiency was shutting down USAID. By 6 February, the agency was functionally dissolved, its seal missing from its Washington headquarters. Amid the ...
If our strategic position was already challenging, it just got worse. Reliability of the US as an ally is in question, amid such actions by the Trump administration as calling for annexation of Canada, threating ...
Small businesses will be exempt from complying with some of the requirements of health and safety legislation under new reforms proposed by the Government. The living wage will be increased to $28.95 per hour from September, a $1.15 increase from the current $27.80. A poll has shown large opposition to ...
Summary A group of senior doctors in Nelson have spoken up, specifically stating that hospitals have never been as bad as in the last year.Patients are waiting up to 50 hours and 1 death is directly attributable to the situation: "I've never seen that number of patients waiting to be ...
Although semiconductor chips are ubiquitous nowadays, their production is concentrated in just a few countries, and this has left the US economy and military highly vulnerable at a time of rising geopolitical tensions. While the ...
Health and Safety changes driven by ACT party ideology, not evidence said NZCTU Te Kauae Kaimahi President Richard Wagstaff. Changes to health and safety legislation proposed by the Minister for Workplace Relations and Safety Brooke van Velden today comply with ACT party ideology, ignores the evidence, and will compound New ...
In short in our political economy this morning:Fletcher Building is closing its pre-fabricated house-building factory in Auckland due to a lack of demand, particularly from the Government.Health NZ is sending a crisis management team to Nelson Hospital after a 1News investigation exposed doctors’ fears that nearly 500 patients are overdue ...
Exactly 10 years ago, the then minister for defence, Kevin Andrews, released the First Principles Review: Creating One Defence (FPR). With increasing talk about the rising possibility of major power-conflict, calls for Defence funding to ...
In events eerily similar to what happened in the USA last week, Greater Auckland was recently accidentally added to a group chat between government ministers on the topic of transport.We have no idea how it happened, but luckily we managed to transcribe most of what transpired. We share it ...
Hi,When I look back at my history with Dylan Reeve, it’s pretty unusual. We first met in the pool at Kim Dotcom’s mansion, as helicopters buzzed overhead and secret service agents flung themselves off the side of his house, abseiling to the ground with guns drawn.Kim Dotcom was a German ...
Come around for teaDance me round and round the kitchenBy the light of my T.VOn the night of the electionAncient stars will fall into the seaAnd the ocean floor sings her sympathySongwriter: Bic Runga.The Prime Minister stared into the camera, hot and flustered despite the predawn chill. He looked sadly ...
Has Winston Peters got a ferries deal for you! (Buyer caution advised.) Unfortunately, the vision that Peters has been busily peddling for the past 24 hours – of several shipyards bidding down the price of us getting smaller, narrower, rail-enabled ferries – looks more like a science fiction fantasy. One ...
Completed reads for March: The Heart of the Antarctic [1907-1909], by Ernest Shackleton South [1914-1917], by Ernest Shackleton Aurora Australis (collection), edited by Ernest Shackleton The Book of Urizen (poem), by William Blake The Book of Ahania (poem), by William Blake The Book of Los (poem), by William Blake ...
First - A ReminderBenjamin Doyle Doesn’t Deserve ThisI’ve been following posts regarding Green MP Benjamin Doyle over the last few days, but didn’t want to amplify the abject nonsense.This morning, Winston Peters, New Zealand’s Deputy Prime Minister, answered the alt-right’s prayers - guaranteeing amplification of the topic, by going on ...
US President Donald Trump has shown a callous disregard for the checks and balances that have long protected American democracy. As the self-described ‘king’ makes a momentous power grab, much of the world watches anxiously, ...
They can be the very same words. And yet their meaning can vary very much.You can say I'll kill him about your colleague who accidentally deleted your presentation the day before a big meeting.You can say I'll kill him to — or, for that matter, about — Tony Soprano.They’re the ...
Back in 2020, the then-Labour government signed contracted for the construction and purchase of two new rail-enabled Cook Strait ferries, to be operational from 2026. But when National took power in 2023, they cancelled them in a desperate effort to make the books look good for a year. And now ...
The fragmentation of cyber regulation in the Indo-Pacific is not just inconvenient; it is a strategic vulnerability. In recent years, governments across the Indo-Pacific, including Australia, have moved to reform their regulatory frameworks for cyber ...
Welcome to the March 2025 Economic Bulletin. The feature article examines what public private partnerships (PPPs) are. PPPs have been a hot topic recently, with the coalition government signalling it wants to use them to deliver infrastructure. However, experience with PPPs, both here and overseas, indicates we should be wary. ...
Willis announces more plans of plans for supermarketsYesterday’s much touted supermarket competition announcement by Nicola Willis amounted to her telling us she was issuing a 6 week RFI1 that will solicit advice from supermarket players.In short, it was an announcement of a plan - but better than her Kiwirail Interislander ...
This was the post I was planning to write this morning to mark Orr’s final day. That said, if the underlying events – deliberate attempts to mislead Parliament – were Orr’s doing, the post is more about the apparent uselessness of Parliament (specifically the Finance and Expenditure Committee) in holding ...
Taiwanese chipmaking giant TSMC’s plan to build a plant in the United States looks like a move made at the behest of local officials to solidify US support for Taiwan. However, it may eventually lessen ...
This is a Guest Post by Transport Planner Bevan Woodward from the charitable trust Movement, which has lodged an application for a judicial review of the Governments Setting of Speed Limits Rule 2024 Auckland is at grave risk of having its safer speed limits on approx. 1,500 local streets ...
We're just talkin' 'bout the futureForget about the pastIt'll always be with usIt's never gonna die, never gonna dieSongwriters: Brian Johnson / Angus Young / Malcolm YoungMorena, all you lovely people, it’s good to be back, and I have news from the heartland. Now brace yourself for this: depending on ...
Today is the last day in office for the Governor of the Reserve Bank, Adrian Orr. Of course, he hasn’t been in the office since 5 March when, on the eve of his major international conference, his resignation was announced and he stormed off with no (effective) notice and no ...
Treasury and Cabinet have finally agreed to a Crown guarantee for a non-Government lending agency for Community Housing Providers (CHPs), which could unlock billions worth of loans and investments by pension funds and banks to build thousands of more affordable social homes. Photo: Lynn GrievesonMōrena. Long stories shortest:Chris Bishop ...
Australia has plenty of room to spend more on defence. History shows that 2.9 percent of GDP is no great burden in ordinary times, so pushing spending to 3.0 percent in dangerous times is very ...
In short this morning in our political economy:Winston Peters will announce later today whether two new ferries are rail ‘compatible’, requiring time-consuming container shuffling, or the more efficient and expensive rail ‘enabled,’ where wagons can roll straight on and off.Nicola Willisthreatened yesterday to break up the supermarket duopoly with ...
A listing of 31 news and opinion articles we found interesting and shared on social media during the past week: Sun, March 23, 2025 thru Sat, March 29, 2025. This week's roundup is again published by category and sorted by number of articles included in each. The formatting is a ...
For prospective writers out there, Inspired Quill, the publisher of my novel(s) is putting together a short story anthology (pieces up to 10,000 words). The open submission window is 29th March to 29th April. https://www.inspired-quill.com/anthology-submissions/ The theme?This anthology will bring together diverse voices exploring themes of hope, resistance, and human ...
Prime minister Kevin Rudd released the 2009 defence white paper in May of that year. It is today remembered mostly for what it said about the strategic implications of China’s rise; its plan to double ...
In short this morning in our political economy:Voters want the Government to retain the living wage for cleaners, a poll shows.The Government’s move to provide a Crown guarantee to banks and the private sector for social housing is described a watershed moment and welcomed by Community Housing Providers.Nicola Willis is ...
The recent attacks in the Congo by Rwandan backed militias has led to worldwide condemnation of the Rwandan regime of Paul Kagame. Following up on the recent Fabian Zoom with Mikela Wrong and Maria Amoudian, Dr Rudaswinga will give a complete picture of Kagame’s regime and discuss the potential ...
New Zealand’s economic development has always been a partnership between the public and private sectors.Public-Private-Partnerships (PPPs) have become fashionable again, partly because of the government’s ambitions to accelerate infrastructural development. There is, of course, an ideological element too, while some of the opposition to them is also ideological.PPPs come in ...
How Australia funds development and defence was front of mind before Tuesday’s federal budget. US President Donald Trump’s demands for a dramatic lift in allied military spending and brutal cuts to US foreign assistance meant ...
Questions 1. Where and what is this protest?a. Hamilton, angry crowd yelling What kind of food do you call this Seymour?b.Dunedin, angry crowd yelling Still waiting, Simeon, still waitingc. Wellington, angry crowd yelling You’re trashing everything you idiotsd. Istanbul, angry crowd yelling Give us our democracy back, give it ...
Two blueprints that could redefine the Northern Territory’s economic future were launched last week. The first was a government-led economic strategy and the other an industry-driven economic roadmap. Both highlight that supporting the Northern Territory ...
Abortion care at Whakatāne Hospital has been quietly shelved, with patients told they will likely have to travel more than an hour to Tauranga to get the treatment they need. ...
Thousands of New Zealanders’ submissions are missing from the official parliamentary record because the National-dominated Justice Select Committee has rushed work on the Treaty Principles Bill. ...
Today’s announcement of 10 percent tariffs for New Zealand goods entering the United States is disappointing for exporters and consumers alike, with the long-lasting impact on prices and inflation still unknown. ...
The National Government’s choices have contributed to a slow-down in the building sector, as thousands of people have lost their jobs in construction. ...
Willie Apiata’s decision to hand over his Victoria Cross to the Minister for Veterans is a powerful and selfless act, made on behalf of all those who have served our country. ...
The Privileges Committee has denied fundamental rights to Debbie Ngarewa-Packer, Rawiri Waititi and Hana-Rawhiti Maipi-Clarke, breaching their own standing orders, breaching principles of natural justice, and highlighting systemic prejudice and discrimination within our parliamentary processes. The three MPs were summoned to the privileges committee following their performance of a haka ...
April 1 used to be a day when workers could count on a pay rise with stronger support for those doing it tough, but that’s not the case under this Government. ...
Winston Peters is shopping for smaller ferries after Nicola Willis torpedoed the original deal, which would have delivered new rail enabled ferries next year. ...
The Government should work with other countries to press the Myanmar military regime to stop its bombing campaign especially while the country recovers from the devastating earthquake. ...
The Green Party is calling for the Government to scrap proposed changes to Early Childhood Care, after attending a petition calling for the Government to ‘Put tamariki at the heart of decisions about ECE’. ...
New Zealand First has introduced a Member’s Bill today that will remove the power of MPs conscience votes and ensure mandatory national referendums are held before any conscience issues are passed into law. “We are giving democracy and power back to the people”, says New Zealand First Leader Winston Peters. ...
Welcome to members of the diplomatic corp, fellow members of parliament, the fourth estate, foreign affairs experts, trade tragics, ladies and gentlemen. ...
In recent weeks, disturbing instances of state-sanctioned violence against Māori have shed light on the systemic racism permeating our institutions. An 11-year-old autistic Māori child was forcibly medicated at the Henry Bennett Centre, a 15-year-old had his jaw broken by police in Napier, kaumātua Dean Wickliffe went on a hunger ...
Confidence in the job market has continued to drop to its lowest level in five years as more New Zealanders feel uncertain about finding work, keeping their jobs, and getting decent pay, according to the latest Westpac-McDermott Miller Employment Confidence Index. ...
The Greens are calling on the Government to follow through on their vague promises of environmental protection in their Resource Management Act (RMA) reform. ...
“Make New Zealand First Again” Ladies and gentlemen, First of all, thank you for being here today. We know your lives are busy and you are working harder and longer than you ever have, and there are many calls on your time, so thank you for the chance to speak ...
Hundreds more Palestinians have died in recent days as Israel’s assault on Gaza continues and humanitarian aid, including food and medicine, is blocked. ...
National is looking to cut hundreds of jobs at New Zealand’s Defence Force, while at the same time it talks up plans to increase focus and spending in Defence. ...
It’s been revealed that the Government is secretly trying to bring back a ‘one-size fits all’ standardised test – a decision that has shocked school principals. ...
The Green Party is calling for the compassionate release of Dean Wickliffe, a 77-year-old kaumātua on hunger strike at the Spring Hill Corrections Facility, after visiting him at the prison. ...
The Green Party is calling on Government MPs to support Chlöe Swarbrick’s Member’s Bill to sanction Israel for its unlawful presence and illegal actions in Palestine, following another day of appalling violence against civilians in Gaza. ...
The Green Party stands in support of volunteer firefighters petitioning the Government to step up and change legislation to provide volunteers the same ACC coverage and benefits as their paid counterparts. ...
At 2.30am local time, Israel launched a treacherous attack on Gaza killing more than 300 defenceless civilians while they slept. Many of them were children. This followed a more than 2 week-long blockade by Israel on the entry of all goods and aid into Gaza. Israel deliberately targeted densely populated ...
Living Strong, Aging Well There is much discussion around the health of our older New Zealanders and how we can age well. In reality, the delivery of health services accounts for only a relatively small percentage of health outcomes as we age. Significantly, dry warm housing, nutrition, exercise, social connection, ...
Shane Jones’ display on Q&A showed how out of touch he and this Government are with our communities and how in sync they are with companies with little concern for people and planet. ...
The Government’s new planning legislation to replace the Resource Management Act will make it easier to get things done while protecting the environment, say Minister Responsible for RMA Reform Chris Bishop and Under-Secretary Simon Court. “The RMA is broken and everyone knows it. It makes it too hard to build ...
Trade and Investment Minister Todd McClay has today launched a public consultation on New Zealand and India’s negotiations of a formal comprehensive Free Trade Agreement. “Negotiations are getting underway, and the Public’s views will better inform us in the early parts of this important negotiation,” Mr McClay says. We are ...
More than 900 thousand superannuitants and almost five thousand veterans are among the New Zealanders set to receive a significant financial boost from next week, an uplift Social Development and Employment Minister Louise Upston says will help support them through cost-of-living challenges. “I am pleased to confirm that from 1 ...
Progressing a holistic strategy to unlock the potential of New Zealand’s geothermal resources, possibly in applications beyond energy generation, is at the centre of discussions with mana whenua at a hui in Rotorua today, Resources and Regional Development Minister Shane Jones says. The Coalition Government is in the early stages ...
New annual data has exposed the staggering cost of delays previously hidden in the building consent system, Building and Construction Minister Chris Penk says. “I directed Building Consent Authorities to begin providing quarterly data last year to improve transparency, following repeated complaints from tradespeople waiting far longer than the statutory ...
Increases in water charges for Auckland consumers this year will be halved under the Watercare Charter which has now been passed into law, Local Government Minister Simon Watts and Auckland Minister Simeon Brown say. The charter is part of the financial arrangement for Watercare developed last year by Auckland Council ...
There is wide public support for the Government’s work to strengthen New Zealand’s biosecurity protections, says Biosecurity Minister Andrew Hoggard. “The Ministry for Primary Industries recently completed public consultation on proposed amendments to the Biosecurity Act and the submissions show that people understand the importance of having a strong biosecurity ...
A new independent review function will enable individuals and organisations to seek an expert independent review of specified civil aviation regulatory decisions made by, or on behalf of, the Director of Civil Aviation, Acting Transport Minister James Meager has announced today. “Today we are making it easier and more affordable ...
The Government will invest in an enhanced overnight urgent care service for the Napier community as part of our focus on ensuring access to timely, quality healthcare, Health Minister Simeon Brown has today confirmed. “I am delighted that a solution has been found to ensure Napier residents will continue to ...
Health Minister Simeon Brown and Mental Health Minister Matt Doocey attended a sod turning today to officially mark the start of construction on a new mental health facility at Hillmorton Campus. “This represents a significant step in modernising mental health services in Canterbury,” Mr Brown says. “Improving health infrastructure is ...
Finance Minister Nicola Willis has welcomed confirmation the economy has turned the corner. Stats NZ reported today that gross domestic product grew 0.7 per cent in the three months to December following falls in the June and September quarters. “We know many families and businesses are still suffering the after-effects ...
The sealing of a 12-kilometre stretch of State Highway 43 (SH43) through the Tangarakau Gorge – one of the last remaining sections of unsealed state highway in the country – has been completed this week as part of a wider programme of work aimed at improving the safety and resilience ...
Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Minister Winston Peters says relations between New Zealand and the United States are on a strong footing, as he concludes a week-long visit to New York and Washington DC today. “We came to the United States to ask the new Administration what it wants from ...
Associate Justice Minister Nicole McKee has welcomed changes to international anti-money laundering standards which closely align with the Government’s reforms. “The Financial Action Taskforce (FATF) last month adopted revised standards for tackling money laundering and the financing of terrorism to allow for simplified regulatory measures for businesses, organisations and sectors ...
Associate Health Minister David Seymour says he welcomes Medsafe’s decision to approve an electronic controlled drug register for use in New Zealand pharmacies, allowing pharmacies to replace their physical paper-based register. “The register, developed by Kiwi brand Toniq Limited, is the first of its kind to be approved in New ...
The Coalition Government’s drive for regional economic growth through the $1.2 billion Regional Infrastructure Fund is on track with more than $550 million in funding so far committed to key infrastructure projects, Regional Development Minister Shane Jones says. “To date, the Regional Infrastructure Fund (RIF) has received more than 250 ...
[Comments following the bilateral meeting with United States Secretary of State, Marco Rubio; United States State Department, Washington D.C.] * We’re very pleased with our meeting with Secretary of State Marco Rubio this afternoon. * We came here to listen to the new Administration and to be clear about what ...
The intersection of State Highway 2 (SH2) and Wainui Road in the Eastern Bay of Plenty will be made safer and more efficient for vehicles and freight with the construction of a new and long-awaited roundabout, says Transport Minister Chris Bishop. “The current intersection of SH2 and Wainui Road is ...
The Ocean Race will return to the City of Sails in 2027 following the Government’s decision to invest up to $4 million from the Major Events Fund into the international event, Auckland Minister Simeon Brown says. “New Zealand is a proud sailing nation, and Auckland is well-known internationally as the ...
Improving access to mental health and addiction support took a significant step forward today with Mental Health Minister Matt Doocey announcing that the University of Canterbury have been the first to be selected to develop the Government’s new associate psychologist training programme. “I am thrilled that the University of Canterbury ...
Health Minister Simeon Brown has today officially opened the new East Building expansion at Manukau Health Park. “This is a significant milestone and the first stage of the Grow Manukau programme, which will double the footprint of the Manukau Health Park to around 30,000m2 once complete,” Mr Brown says. “Home ...
The Government will boost anti-crime measures across central Auckland with $1.3 million of funding as a result of the Proceeds of Crime Fund, Auckland Minister Simeon Brown and Associate Justice Minister Nicole McKee say. “In recent years there has been increased antisocial and criminal behaviour in our CBD. The Government ...
The Government is moving to strengthen rules for feeding food waste to pigs to protect New Zealand from exotic animal diseases like foot and mouth disease (FMD), says Biosecurity Minister Andrew Hoggard. ‘Feeding untreated meat waste, often known as "swill", to pigs could introduce serious animal diseases like FMD and ...
Prime Minister Christopher Luxon and Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi held productive talks in New Delhi today. Fresh off announcing that New Zealand and India would commence negotiations towards a Comprehensive Free Trade Agreement, the two Prime Ministers released a joint statement detailing plans for further cooperation between the two countries across ...
Agriculture and Trade Minister Todd McClay signed a new Memorandum of Cooperation (MOC) today during the Prime Minister’s Indian Trade Mission, reinforcing New Zealand’s commitment to enhancing collaboration with India in the forestry sector. “Our relationship with India is a key priority for New Zealand, and this agreement reflects our ...
Agriculture and Trade Minister Todd McClay signed a new Memorandum of Cooperation (MOC) today during the Prime Minister’s Indian Trade Mission, reinforcing New Zealand’s commitment to enhancing collaboration with India in the horticulture sector. “Our relationship with India is a key priority for New Zealand, and this agreement reflects our ...
Attorney-General Judith Collins today announced the appointment of two new Family Court Judges. The new Judges will take up their roles in April and May and fill Family Court vacancies at the Auckland and Manukau courts. Annette Gray Ms Gray completed her law degree at Victoria University before joining Phillips ...
Health Minister Simeon Brown has today officially opened Wellington Regional Hospital’s first High Dependency Unit (HDU). “This unit will boost critical care services in the lower North Island, providing extra capacity and relieving pressure on the hospital’s Intensive Care Unit (ICU) and emergency department. “Wellington Regional Hospital has previously relied ...
Namaskar, Sat Sri Akal, kia ora and good afternoon everyone. What an honour it is to stand on this stage - to inaugurate this august Dialogue - with none other than the Honourable Narendra Modi. My good friend, thank you for so generously welcoming me to India and for our ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra Prime Minister Anthony Albanese and Opposition Leader Peter Dutton both agree Australia should react to US President Donald Trump’s aggressive tariff regime by continuing to seek a special deal. They just disagree about which of ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Joanne Orlando, Researcher, Digital Literacy and Digital Wellbeing, Western Sydney University UK Prime Minster Keir Starmer met with Adolescence writer Jack Thorne to discuss adolescent safety at Downing Street on Monday. Jack Taylor/ GettyImages Netflix’s Adolescence has ignited global debate. ...
By Anneke Smith,RNZ News political reporter A stoush between the Chief Human Rights Commissioner and a Jewish community leader has flared up following a showdown at Parliament. Appearing before a parliamentary select committee today, Dr Stephen Rainbow was asked about his recent apology for incorrect comments he made about ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Rakesh Gupta, Associate Professor of Accounting & Finance, Charles Darwin University US President Donald Trump’s new trade war will not only send shockwaves through the global economy – it also upsets efforts to tackle the urgent issue of climate change. Trump has ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Lisa Toohey, Professor of Law, UNSW Sydney It had the hallmarks of a reality TV cliffhanger. Until recently, many people had never even heard of tariffs. Now, there’s been rolling live international coverage of so-called “Liberation Day”, as US President Donald Trump ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Nick Fuller, Clinical Trials Director, Department of Endocrinology, RPA Hospital, University of Sydney mavo/Shutterstock In the ever-changing wellness industry, one diet obsession has captured and held TikTok’s attention: protein. Whether it’s sharing snaps of protein-packed meals or giving tutorials to ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Sebastian Maslow, Associate Professor, International Relations, University of Tokyo Two months into US President Donald Trump’s second term, the liberal international order is on life support. Alliances and multilateral institutions are now seen by the United States as burdens. Europe and ...
Starving public services of resources, gutting the workforce and then proposing private market solutions has been a key strategy of this government, says Vanessa Cole, spokesperson for Public Housing Futures. ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Hayley Geyle, Ecologist, Charles Darwin University Sarah Maclagan/Author provided The greater bilby (Macrotis lagotis) is one of Australia’s most iconic yet at-risk animals — and the last surviving bilby species. Once found across 70% of Australia, its range has contracted by ...
The government’s own Regulatory Impact Statement acknowledges that organic producers will bear the financial burden of adapting to the risks posed by GMO expansion. ...
The committee has "rammed it through with outrageous haste", with a report now expected tomorrow, but excluding thousands of submissions, Duncan Webb says. ...
The US president’s sweeping programme of global tariffs will hit every country abroad, including New Zealand, and dramatically raise prices at home. This is an excerpt from The World Bulletin, our weekly global current affairs newsletter exclusively for Spinoff Members. Sign up here.In a dramatic, flag-draped address from the White ...
Alex Casey talks to Bariz Shah and Saba Afrasyabi, the couple who launched a project to change 51 lives in honour of those lost in the Christchurch mosque attacks. When Bariz Shah and Saba Afrasyabi walked into Naeem’s house in Jalalabad, Afghanistan, they knew immediately that he needed their help. ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Felicity Deane, Professor of Trade Law, Taxation and Climate Change, Queensland University of Technology US President Donald Trump has imposed a range of tariffs on all products entering the US market, with Australian exports set to face a 10% tariff, effective April ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra US President Donald Trump singled out Australia’s beef trade for special mention in his announcement that the United States would impose a 10% global tariff as well as “reciprocal tariffs” on many countries. In ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Hayley Geyle, Ecologist, Charles Darwin University Sarah Maclagan/Author provided The greater bilby (Macrotis lagotis) is one of Australia’s most iconic yet at-risk animals — and the last surviving bilby species. Once found across 70% of Australia, its range has contracted by ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra US President Donald Trump singled out Australia’s beef trade for special mention in his announcement that the United States would impose a 10% global tariff as well as “reciprocal tariffs” on many countries. In ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Christopher Rudge, Law lecturer, University of Sydney Shutterstock Recent media coverage in the Nine newspapers highlights a surge in non-medical ultrasound providers offering “reassurance ultrasounds” to expectant parents. The service has resulted in serious harms, such as misdiagnosed ectopic pregnancies and ...
The three MPs whose rule-breaking haka caught the world’s attention didn’t attend their scheduled hearing yesterday. Constitutional law expert Andrew Geddis has the rundown of what happened, why, and what’s likely to come next. I see Te Pāti Māori and the privileges committee are in some sort of stand-off – ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Simon Turner, Professor, School of Natural Sciences, Macquarie University The Eurasian and North American tectonic plates in Thingvellir National Park, Iceland.Nido Huebl/Shutterstock Earth is the only known planet which has plate tectonics today. The constant movement of these giant slabs of ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra US President Donald Trump singled out Australia’s beef trade for special mention in his announcement that the United States would impose a 10% global tariff as well as “reciprocal tariffs” on many countries. In ...
Meta has stolen millions of books to train its AI, including books by kaituhi Māori. What does that mean for mātauranga and its status as taonga? New Zealand authors are among the millions whose books have been pirated and scraped by Meta to train its AI. The New Zealand Society of ...
Some hoped the open of the New Zealand markets would open with a bounce as certain tariffs fell short of the worst-case scenario, but investors were met with a deflated thud.The New Zealand market fell immediately as stock market darling Fisher & Paykel Healthcare’s shares were punished, with no update ...
Healthcare dominated the debate in an unusually sober and serious question time. “Hey David!” a group of high school students in the public gallery called out as Act leader David Seymour entered the debating chamber. Standing in the middle of the floor, before any other MPs had arrived, he happily ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Matthew Heaslip, Senior Lecturer in Naval History, University of Portsmouth How the Shuqiao barges may be used to ferry troops ashore. X (formerly Twitter) China’s intentions when it comes to Taiwan have been at the centre of intense discussion for years. ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Kiera Vaclavik, Professor of Children’s Literature & Childhood Culture, Queen Mary University of London This spring, Babe is returning to cinemas to mark the 30th anniversary of its release in 1995. The much-loved family film tells the deceptively simple but emotionally powerful ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Sophie King-Hill, Associate Professor at the Health Services Management Centre, University of Birmingham Netflix television series Adolescence follows a 13-year-old boy accused of the murder of his female classmate. It touches upon incel online hate groups, toxic influencers and the misogynistic online ...
I don’t want my neuroses about someone being ‘good enough’ to keep me from finding love. But choosing to be with someone who isn’t quite right seems like a death sentence.Want Hera’s help? Email your problem to helpme@thespinoff.co.nzDear Hera,I’m a straight single woman in my late 20s ...
http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2015-10-10/biggest-protest-country-has-seen-years-quarter-million-germans-protest-obama-free-tr
I particularly like the photo of people in wolf masks and suits… how appropriate
“Hundreds of thousands of people rallied on Saturday afternoon in the German capital against the massive Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP) accord being negotiated by the European Union and the United States. Critics say the trade deal will benefit large corporations at the expense of average Europeans.”
http://www.commondreams.org/news/2015/10/10/hundreds-thousands-march-berlin-against-ttip-trade-deal
There was a big wooden horse being rolled along too – also appropriate.
“Everything that we know about this secretive trade deal shows that it is very little about trade and very much about enshrining a massive corporate power-grab.” Nick Dearden, director of Global Justice Now, at the Common Dreams link.
If our Labour Party has wet its finger and is holding it in the air to determine which way the wind is blowing, it might want to look at that photo of about 250,000 people marching against the TTIP. When we go to make a law in NZ we don’t want our first consideration to be “are we likely to be sued in an ISDS if we make this law?” TPP has this chilling effect.
Our first consideration should be “Is this law good for New Zealand, both for the people and the environment (and not detrimental to the world in general.)
Labour, if you are listening, we don’t wan’t this TPP. We lose more than we gain.
(Note the Herald title to Bernard Hickey’s article is incomplete.
Tautoko Mango Mata, No Labour is not listening, they have never listened, they are having a bob each-way. No spine for a straight forward wager.
More on the quarter of million march in Berlin.
http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/2015/10/10/ttip-ceta-protest-berlin-germany_n_8273948.html
http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/oct/10/berlin-anti-ttip-trade-deal-rally-hundreds-thousands-protesters
Well using Keys logic, that is a rather a large uninformed rent-a -crowd.
tpp is the last of the Germans worries.
It’s what the TPP is like that scares the Germans as the TTIP is shaping up to be a similar agreement.
Yes. “While the EU has an impressively alliterative “farm to fork” strategy, for instance, regulating each link in the food chain, Americans pump their cattle and pigs with growth-promoting hormones banned in the EU. As a result, most US beef can’t be sold in the EU.
“Worse, Americans use 82 pesticides banned in the EU. They wash their chicken in chlorinated water to kill bacteria. Ninety per cent of their soya, cotton and corn is genetically modified, while the EU allows member states to ban GM production. ”
http://www.theguardian.com/business/2015/aug/03/ttip-what-why-angry-transatlantic-trade-investment-partnership-guide
When Andrew Little set out the “bottom lines” he objected to the Herald story saying Labour had set out its conditions for support.
He tweeted the reporter to say “we set out what we’re opposed to”.
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/politics/news/article.cfm?c_id=280&objectid=11526651
Matthew Hooton (in his piece: Labour lurches to the extreme left over TPP) has used the possibility of Labour withdrawing from the TPP to scare potential supporters off Labour, undermining the Party’s efforts to build business support.
Labour would discuss its position on the TPP at its up and coming caucus meeting.
Audrey Young asks: will Labour be better off supporting the deal than not supporting it?
Will it be any better off sounding as though it opposes it but supporting it in the end?
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/politics/news/article.cfm?c_id=280&objectid=11526651
Thoughts?
Whatever they do you can bet the likes of hootten and all the other players will spin this in nacts favour so the rehetoric must be simple, short and snappy so it sticks in peoples minds despite the DP treatment.
Good to see King calling matty over his allegations, the electorate is crying out for a front foot approach to take back the argument to ordinary kiwis and away from the hollowmen and their shills in the msm.
Problem is, Little puts himself in these predicaments.
No point attacking Hooton. You should be asking for better from Little.
At this point he’s fucked which ever way he goes. Kinda like Red Peak.
I wasn’t attacking Hooton, merely highlighting his piece.
By attempting to appease both the left and right in the manner in which they do, I agree, Labour have largely brought this upon themselves.
Not having a clear position has allowed Hooton to control the narrative and fill in the blanks.
+1
Exactly. Labour needs to have a clear position, state that position and then stick to it. We’re getting fucked over by their ambivalence and their compromising with the RWNJs that just sees our country going ever more to the right and thus getting higher levels of poverty.
Labour are probably being ambivalent about it because the whole damned thing is an ambiguous, deceptive, misleading crock.
They keep getting suckered by the glossy ‘free trade’ wrapper while refusing to name the stinking mess inside.
Labour are probably being ambivalent about it because the whole damned thing is an ambiguous, deceptive, misleading crock.
They keep getting suckered by the glossy ‘free trade’ wrapper while refusing to name the stinking mess inside.
usual tactic though, distract by focus on Labour (despite the fact they have NOTHING to do with it), why fall for it?
“usual tactic though, distract by focus on Labour (despite the fact they have NOTHING to do with it), why fall for it?”
Exactly, and you must remember that it all Labour’s fault whatever it is.
Don’t be so shortsighted. It’s not distracting. It’s encompassing the opposition’s position on the deal.
Infused ? In your Opinion
From the comments I’ve seen here, it seems to be many peoples opinion.
Where the hell is little? Heard nothing for days.
Little is back and was on Q&A today.
http://tvnz.co.nz/q-and-a-news/tpp-done-deal-labour-responds-video-6400126
Labour should not support TPP. Period. It is very different to the China trade deal.
Supporting TPP which Hillary Clinton, Bernie Sanders, Corbyn etc do not support. There is massive mainstream political and public support AGAINST TPP.
They don’t have to agree with everything the Nats do in a NatLite way, now is the time for Labour to cut away from the 1980’s and the Clark era, and start looking at what Kiwis want, not want Labour think the country may or may not need. We are in a brave new technological world and the TPP aims to keep us in the past and the current powers dominant with outdated practises. History shows that those in power cling on and try to destroy as they are being replaced because they can’t or will not adapt.
One of the biggest mistakes Labour is making is sitting on the fence and using ‘confusion’ about it’s position to somehow try to be everything to all people, but instead looking like a completely untrustworthy party than just goes where the tide turns and gets bogged down in details oh I support this in this way but not in this way and maybe in this way, but not in this way (details all missing). Too complicated Labour!
“One of the biggest mistakes Labour is making is sitting on the fence and using ‘confusion’ about it’s position to somehow try to be everything to all people, but instead looking like a completely untrustworthy party than just goes where the tide turns and gets bogged down in details oh I support this in this way but not in this way and maybe in this way, but not in this way (details all missing). Too complicated Labour!”
+1
Little is on Q&A now.
Won’t Labour and everyone else need to see the whole document before stating a position? If Little was to say now that he/they oppose the TPP he would be trounced for being against something unseen/unconsidered.
Wait folks.
Good response. Thanks ianmac.
Taking into account Labour put forward their bottom lines. Coupled with the breach of their bottom lines (which Little concedes) in the info released thus far, a number expect Labour would oppose it on that alone.
However, Little says they’re certainly opposed to what they see at the moment, but they still want to see the final text. Which, with that said, implies there’s a possibility they may not oppose it.
And it is that lack of total commitment that leaves a number questioning why?
Your average person sees Labour making bottom lines, hears they’ve been breached, thus expects Labour to come out and totally oppose the deal on that basis.
I don’t see any confusion TC. It’s the pro-TPP mob – including much of the media – and the NActs sowing the seed of so-called confusion. Matthew Hooton’s latest attempt to suggest there’s ructions in the L. caucus over the TPP is a good example. Little squashed that load of bullshit once and for all this morning.
The bottom lines are still there and Little made it clear they will pass legislation to counter adverse effects when they are the government. When posed the question… what if the US (or who ever else) take retaliatory action, he [effectively] said… they can shit themselves as much as they like, but if it’s not in the best interest of our citizens we will not play ball. Good answer. Call their bluff.
The confusion lays with Ardern saying Labour will face the consequences (implying Labour will refuse to be bound by the TPP) and Robertson saying Labour will weigh up the consequences. Implying if the consequences are to severe, Labour will breach their 5 bottom lines.
Leaving a number wondering why make bottom lines when you may accept them being breached?
Hooton did more than claim the Party is divided. He went on to paint a withdrawal from the deal as Labour lurching towards the extreme left. Saying, the lunatics now running Labour’s asylum must never be let near power.
IMO, Hooton is not only trying to scare potential supporters off Labour, he’s also trying to scare Labour from withdrawing.
Exactly what he’s doing imo.
What appalling arrogance! He’s a pip-squeak among many other pip-squeaks who have a vastly over-rated opinion of themselves. I may not be able to abide him as a person/ politician, but at least John Key has some legitimacy when it comes to playing these games.
+100 savenz
El Nino is going to cause serious problems for agriculture this summer.
‘Federated Farmers Golden Bay president Sue Brown said many farmers were still struggling to cope with last year’s drought.
If conditions worsened in the coming months, farmers would be driven towards cost-cutting measures like slaughtering surplus stock, Brown said.
“Farmers definitely feel it in the pocket.
“They are already getting their heads around alternatives.”
Orchard manager Evan Heywood said the lack of rain would hurt fruit growers in areas, such as Waimea, where the water supply was limited.
“If the weather carries on like this, so hot and dry, people will need to look at irrigation.
“That is unheard of at this time of year.” ‘
http://www.stuff.co.nz/nelson-mail/news/72861781/El-Nino-set-to-scorch-Nelson
The other big problem in farming is that they have been encouraged to expand and have too much stock and then have to buy in supplementary feed which is very expensive and often using Palm Kernel expeller which is imported from Indonesia where it is contributed to massive rain forest destruction and climate change.
Where is the support for farmers farming in a sustainable way and research to support that from government?
Do we want to be a low end commodity producer ALL our life as a country or when is someone going to say – lets move up the value chain?
For example Lactoferrin is approx $500,000 per ton and milk solids $3000 a ton?
Nutricuticials should be top on the list of where our milk industry is heading not ‘lets produce more milk for less money’.
According to National that’s exactly what we are and should be. It’s why they keep making getting a good education harder and why they keep pushing dairying.
My company manufactures a highly value added product 100% here in NZ Draco, but at the moment that product is effectively locked out of lucrative markets such as Canada, Japan, and the US by 20-30% tariffs that are designed to make our end price uncompetitive.
If the TPP goes ahead those tariffs will disappear and we would immediately set out on a major expansion into those markets.
All going well, we would be looking at many new high value NZ jobs and significant flow on benefits down through all the companies that supply us raw materials and services.
I know several other NZ Made Manufacturers who are in exactly the same situation……
So everything else aside, I can see some outcomes from the TPPA that would create opportunities for people who are trying to add value to the NZ economy. Just saying, but it ain’t all bad.
Even without tariffs it’ll still cost more to get your products to market in those nations because of the added costs of transporting them. The only way you’d be able to compete would be if you lowered wages.
As I say. If there’s a level playing field in world trade (Which was the point of the WTO/GATT) then there wouldn’t be any world trade. A manufacturer in NZ cannot compete with a manufacturer in Canada/US/Australia when under the same conditions. That’s physical reality.
No, no, and no Draco.
You are completely wrong in all the reasons you give why we would not be able to compete.
No I’m not. As I say – it’s simple physical reality. The problem is that our financial system has been developed so as to deny that physical reality.
@ The Lost Sheep, if you can’t make it in NZ or China then you probably are not going to make it in, the rest of the world. The tariffs do not stop trade so the TPP is not going to miraculously make a market for new NZ products. In fact more likely under TPP someone bigger will come along steal your idea and litigate you, so go under. The copywrite laws are intended to be protectionist to the current status quo.
All wrong savenz.
Tariffs do in fact stop trade. That is largely the point of them.
In the case of my business area, removal of tariffs will create huge new markets that we can effectively compete in.
I’m not generalising a theoretical case here, I’m talking about a specific opportunity that we have spent years investigating and are absolutely certain of.
That’s good isn’t it?
Maybe you have a great idea or product but when you look at Dragon’s Den like entrepreneurs – quite a few people are absolutely certain they have some amazing product the world is dying to obtain. But quite often the people are fruit cakes and with or without TPP are going to fail. Not sure if this is you, but NZ is an easy market to get a product out in, and TPP does not actually remove all tarrifs in fact there is only about 10% difference from now in some areas.
But we certainly DO KNOW under TPP medicine will be more expensive as even Key has said, patents for longer, protectionist measures, etc
We know NZ can be sued and our government and courts won’t be deciding the outcome but 3 international judges than have never found against the US historically.
The opposite of ‘free trade’.
In the US/OZ free trade deal they are both worse off 10 years later.
So should the rest of the country be worse off, because MAYBE someone is slightly better off, and again corporate welfare. i.e. taxpayers helping business at the expense of the rest of the population who have to pay more individually to subsidise the business?
quite a few people are absolutely certain they have some amazing product the world is dying to obtain. But quite often the people are fruit cakes and with or without TPP are going to fail. Not sure if this is you,
No. I have very well established growing business that already sells to people throughout the world. So no need to do Dragons Den.
So should the rest of the country be worse off, because MAYBE someone is slightly better off, and again corporate welfare. i.e. taxpayers helping business at the expense of the rest of the population who have to pay more individually to subsidise the business?
Well, if you believe, as many do here, that our Govt. would deliberately negotiate a deal that guaranteed a negative overall outcome for our country, or you believe that Govt. in NZ pays anything like significant subsidies to business, then you might say that.
But I think that is rubbish.
Like all the trade negotiations I have ever seen, this one is a result of the compromise process that occurs when every country is trying to stimulate growth, but at the same time trying to gain more access to other markets than they give away in their own.
There are opportunities for NZ’ers in this deal, if it goes ahead. My plan is to take maximum advantage of the ones in front of me.
I just hope enough NZ’ers do the same to make it an overall positive net outcome.
There is no denying there will be some benefits, but going from what’s been reported, they’re modest (1% of GDP).
Moreover, it will only have a direct benefit to less than 25% of all firms (mostly private and some offshore owned).
Over 75 per cent of all NZ firms have never generated overseas income.
This is consistent with most small businesses reporting that they either cannot or are not interested in exporting.
97 per cent of enterprises in New Zealand are small businesses.
http://tinyurl.com/oa5kzdf
This is one of the big environmental problems we face – a lot of people actually think that the water supply we have is unlimited. The reality is that the water supply is limited and we need to live within those limits.
It’s true we have a problem with out attitude towards water (thinking it’s endless). Water’s not the main problem in how to grow food in dry climates though, it’s how we use land. Current agricultural practices, including irrigation, encourage drought.
Here’s establishing food producing trees in the first year on one of the driest place on earth (on salinated soil). They used 1/5th the amount of water used in that area normally.
Other examples here,
http://thestandard.org.nz/the-drought/#comment-967704
This is being done here….
http://www.radionz.co.nz/national/programmes/countrylife/20151009#audio-201774020
Very clever.
Thanks! That’s a very good interview (yes, smart people), and has a good explanation of how to manage water differently (at start and then half way through).
We have had an ‘endless supply’ mentality to H2O here in NZ. Here in the Waikato, arguably the greenest of this green and pleasant land, we now have irrigation booms, a la Canterbury Plains.
When we were building in the country 18 years ago we designed the house for maximum rain collection and chucked in a couple of BIG tanks.
Neighbours suggested putting down a bore…plenty of groundwater they said.
This was because we refused to water the veg plants….(we still got bumper crops) to conserve our house supply.
Drought of 2007/2008 saw those neighbours’ bores all dry up.
Local 1000 cow dairy farm had their pump on the lowest point in the area…had sucked the aquifer dry.
They are the ones with the boom…I presume sucking the water from the river.
easy come, easy go.
Sweet, thanks for the interesting small farming links – makes a lot of sense.
In the 50s isn’t that what the refugees flooding into Israel did to green the desert? (Recently I scooped buckets of beach sand and pebbles to put on a small patch. Weed-cloth then the salt laden beach sand. The weeds grew prolifically!)
I don’t know ian. Permacuture (which is the design technique used in that video) was invented in the 1970s, but it is based in many existing traditional systems, so it’s possible that swales were used in the situation you refer to.
Why were you putting beach sand and pebbles in your garden?
It was a small patch of ground in which I aimed to grow a lemon tree and a shrub. Since we were seldom there to weed I thought that the salty beach sand would block the weeds, but no.
Presumably local weeds adapted to the salty sand?
This is what irrigation should be used for. A prop at times of drought, and perhaps an aid to encourage an early start to the growing season so as to get crops well on their way before known seasonal weather bringing heat and moisture deficits occur.
Ad el nino to lack of snow pack to fill up those irrigation dams and it could be very bumpy for some.http://i.stuff.co.nz/business/farming/72589956/worries-of-another-disastrous-summer
Climate change.
Pity Key and his mates are ignoring it.
Personally I know several people who will not support Labour precisely because it has not come out definitely against the TPP. Labour is not opposed to free trade agreements per se, but the positive amount of free trade in this agreement for NZ is small compared to the negatives of ISDS, the inability to prevent foreign ownership of land and yet to be revealed final rules on SOEs and other hidden fishhooks.
Labour seem to be waiting for the final text so that their arguments will be based on fact’
Here’s Audrey Young:
“It will be passed by the Cabinet and National has the numbers with Act and Peter Dunne to pass any legislation required.
But the Government would prefer to pass it with as much cross-party support as possible.
The campaign against the TPP has shifted the default position of the public from a generally pro-FTA position to neutral.
In the Herald’s DigiPoll survey in August, only 22.9 per cent said they supported it generally on the basis that New Zealand’s economic well-being depended on increased trade with the world; 31.3 per cent opposed it on the basis of investor-state dispute procedures and 45 per cent had no view.
Labour has been pivotal in shifting public opinion, shifting its own position last year from a pro starting point to a neutral one.”
OK Labour. Let’s move it from neutral to NEGATIVE!
To me, this is the most important sentence. Audrey Young again:
“My prediction is that Labour will spend the next month sounding as though it opposes the TPP, pointing out where it could have been better, condemning the Government for not getting a perfect deal, but end up supporting it. In the process it will be sending mixed messages.”
This must not happen. Stop equivocating, Labour. There’s enough info out with the latest leak. You’ll gain more by opposing the TPP. It’s an up or down decision now- liking bits of the agreement is not enough.
+1 – Tautoko Mangō Mata
This must not happen. STOP equivocating, Labour. There’s enough info out with the latest leak. You’ll gain more by opposing the TPP. It’s an up or down decision now- liking bits of the agreement is not enough.
My vote goes to a party that makes a proper stand against the TPP.
+100 Paul…at the moment it is going to NZF
I know you’ve been anxious to hear an unequivocal statement against the TPP… How ’bout the Greens?
https://www.greens.org.nz/news/article/bad-tppa-deal-will-cost-new-zealanders
Just because MSM doesn’t cover it doesn’t mean it’s not happening.
so Greens will repeal signing of TPP?…has Shaw said this specifically or is he equivocating?
…the Greens are in agreement with NZF then!?
…so where is bloody Labour?!
…they should be forming a united front saying “NO” to the TPP when they ALL form the next coalition Government
If the TPP is bad enough for both Republican Trump and Democrat Saunders to have the courage to stick their necks out and say “NO”!….surely NZ Labour can do the same!….and stop sitting on the fence
‘Bernie Sanders, Donald Trump slam Trans-Pacific Partnership deal as ‘disastrous’ & ‘terrible’ ‘
https://www.rt.com/usa/317718-sanders-trump-candidates-tpp/
‘ ‘Extraordinary person’ Donald Trump invited to visit Crimea – as US president’
https://www.rt.com/politics/318004-extraordinary-person-donald-trump-invited/
“Trump, a 69-year-old billionaire real estate mogul, entered the US presidential race in June, seeking the Republic nomination. He is currently leading in the polls.”
I have not heard an unequivocal rejection of the TPP from either Labour or the Greens.
Statements like “The TPP was not voted in democratically by the New Zealand people. We shall repeal it once we are in power.”
agreed …the Greens, like Labour, have not come out unequivocally against the TPP
…if they must fence sit ….why not a NZ referendum on the TPP?….why allow the secrecy and lack of democracy?
…if it is good enough to have a referendum on the flag (when most NZers want to keep the existing flag)…it should be good enough to have a democratic referendum on deciding whether to adhere to jonkey Nacts secret deal on the TPP?
The Greens under Shaw are not impressing me.
Groser on Q+A…….’almost inconceivable that anyone will take a case against NZ in “X years”.’
The man’s dishonesty screams. He purports to tell us something and advisedly tells us nothing.
Yes, and lets make it a prison sentence for those that bring it in, if someone does sue us.
Wonder if the Nats would be supporting it then? If they are personally bought to account for their treachery with a prison sentence?
Why imprison anyone when the revolution comes? Why not just withdraw from the deal?
Why hide it from the people if it’s such a good deal, it can speak for itself, without the need for well placed media megaphones selectively pushing aspects of it?
seem to recall you expressing with complete certainty this morning that once in place no government (in NZ) will leave…are you saying youve changed your mind Matthew?
I presume he was allowed to make that statement without it being challenged.
Incredibly……no, he wasn’t challenged. Neither by Dallow (who’s surprised ?……Dallow was relating as one would to the AB captain after a successful international campaign)….. nor by Little.
From wikipedia.
‘Dallow was educated at Liston College and St Peter’s College. He completed his tertiary education at Auckland University, where he studied law. After completing his legal studies, Dallow practised as a litigation and insurance lawyer in Auckland, New Zealand.
Whilst on his OE, the 1987 stock market crash occurred, causing him to change careers, as a future in bankruptcy law was unappealing. Dallow then spent the next six years as a tour director in Europe. He returned to New Zealand in 1993.’
A litigation lawyer before the ’87 crash.
These people are not independent.
Dallow’s mediocrity as a journalist and the fact he does not ask any difficult questions of the powerful has ensured his promotion at TVNZ.
Dallow is incompetent. He seems always to be under-prepared and is therefore nervous and unsure of himself in interviews. He knows enough, though, to side with power, as demonstrated by his outrageously biased performance in “chairing” the discussion with Charles Finny, Helen Kelly and Professor Steve Hoadley on Q+A this morning.
A puppet of the establishment.
Well he was riding on the coat tails of his former wife after all. Not surprising she saw the light.
God how a pray to be around when the inevitable clean out occurs. It’ll be a therapist’s dream come true. Maybe I should write a few things down.
I hope when it comes to pass, the very same methods used to implement the culture of a neo-liberal agenda is used to rid us all of it.
I can think of several ways to cleanup TVNZ for a start and to return it to a form that serves its public (rather than its consumer).
We should keep it in perspective though – this sort of shit is even infecting that supposed bastion of the Educate Inform and Entertain triumvirate (the Aunty BBC)
His father Ross was a local body politico out West, of the Right persuasion. Got Marier Hasler a plumb position in a Sports Trust (which she was ill equipped to do) after she lost her seat in Parliament. She had to be let go after only a few months ith a severance package. Dallow hoped it would further his career.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marie_Hasler
To be fair Groser and Little were interviewed individually and in the case of Little he was confined to the questions asked of him by Dallow. I thought his responses were strong and left no doubt Labour will take action against aspects of the deal (eg. foreign property speculation) if they become the government. At the same time he intimated Labour has to look at the details – when they finally emerge – but my impression is they are not going to budge on their bottom lines.
He also made it clear the caucus was totally united on those “bottom lines”, so Hooten’s [excited] claims to the contrary were bullshit. I wonder who the insiders were? Pagani et al?
Little lost any credibility he might have had when he assented, reluctantly, to the Key regime’s snooping legislation. After assuring reporters how unhappy he was, he then assured reporters that would be the last time Labour would cave in like that.
He has virtually no respect from the government, and it’s all his own fault.
Hooton is a spin doctor whose rabid support for the TPP and personal attacks on opponents to the deal suggests it is in his interest that the deal gets passed whatever is in it.
Has he seen the full text? I doubt it, but that isn’t important for him. The only interest I have in Hooton is finding out who he is working for. Possibly nobody is paying him at this stage but he is hoping for work in the future. Who knows, but in my opinion the acquisition of money and/or power is the main motivator for the actions of those on the right, and I see no reason to believe any thing they say.
QFT
Hooton has chosen 2 particular parts of the agreement to argue. Someone has given him sufficient assurances that he is not on shakey ground pushing those 2 things. He might not have seen the full text but he has been given a very good (and directed) nod and a wink)
Anne
I took it Labour oppose the TPP. But opposing the deal means little as Labour’s support isn’t necessary for the deal to pass.
And to safeguard their bottom lines, Labour are considering legislating against the ordinances of the TPP.
However, as Labour are talking about facing the consequences of legislating against the ordinances of the TPP, it indicates they don’t plan to totally withdraw from the deal.
Therefore, Little’s responses were far from strong (taking the middle ground) or left enough.
Your argument has a whacking great logical hole in it. Are you saying that Labour should not oppose TPPa supporting legislation that gets introduced between now and 2017.
You sound like an unthinking dingbat. Labour isn’t on the treasury benches. So that is the Only way that can prospectus agreement.
No.
I’m highlighting, given the opportunity, ( i.e. if they attain power) Labour are indicating they won’t totally withdraw from the TPP.
Opposing supporting legislation is a hollow effect because we both know Labour doesn’t have the numbers to prevent supporting legislation passing.
To save face on their bottom lines, instead of totally withdrawing, Labour are considering legislating against the ordinances of the TPP.
That’s how Little’s comments on Q&A came across to me.
Why would they? The problem isn’t with making trade deals. The problem is with making bad trade deals.
The last thing I saw from them (in the Herald today?) was that the TPP appears to have failed on 4 out of 5 of their base points, and that is what they want to fix.
Ummm http://m.nzherald.co.nz/business/news/article.cfm?c_id=3&objectid=11527509
But…
In other words, if this crap deal doesn’t improve a lot then Labour will withdraw from it.
For all of the stupidity of this government in getting involved with this idiotic “trade” deal, they have also sunk a hell of a lot of money into trying to do so – probably well in excess of $100 million since 2009 after the US got involved and converted a free trade agreement to a restraint of trade agreement. It’d be good to recover that.
But if that isn’t possible and it continues to look like constraining our trade development, then the damn thing should be dumped.
Because the deal is pitiful, that’s why.
Moreover, it has breached a number of their bottom lines.
Thanks for the link to the Herald’s piece. I can work with that (see below).
I was going to highlight Little’s comments in stuff, which, like the Herald’s piece, goes on to further substantiate my points and sentiments above.
http://www.stuff.co.nz/national/politics/72904296/andrew-little-bigger-gains-for-dairy-in-india-and-indonesia-than-tppa
Labour won’t be able to fix all the breaches. And Little clearly didn’t commit to walking away, though he implied they may.
As I stated above, to save face on their bottom lines, they are considering legislating against the ordinances of the TPP. Which Little has confirmed.
However, as Labour are talking about facing the consequences of legislating against the ordinances of the TPP, it indicates they don’t plan to totally withdraw from the deal.
Little helps confirm this by not fully committing to withdrawing from the deal.
Additionally, the cat was let out of the bag when Robertson said the Party would weigh up the consequences, implying if the consequences are to severe, Labour will back down.
So brace yourself for that excuse coming into play later on down the track.
Labour seems to be using one of their common tactics. They make a big song and dance opposing something, but in the end, they support it. Which tends to put voters off voting Labour.
Though, in saying that, the stuff article tends to lay some foundation (appeasing exporter concern) for walking away.
I wonder what Labour will measure the deal on? The $$$ or the people, or both?
So far Groser’s Pr campaign has been all about the $$$ (and mostly only the claimed increases, less precise about the $$$ losses).
how can anyone measure future legal action by organisations that may as yet be unformed?….one of the problems for ANY group seeking to quantify the costs/benefits, even after all the text is released is we have no possible way of quantifying the ISDS provisions….on these provisions alone I would walk away but then, im not seeking election.
Indeed, what value does one put on our sovereignty?
Vizzini is obviously his role model. “Inconceivable!”
It is worth posting the complete quote here as it appeared in the NZH:
’ “I think that is almost inconceivable, given the safe cards our international lawyers have negotiated, that anyone will take a case against New Zealand in the next X years,” he said.’
In his opinion Timmy reckons that NZ will be untouchable, legally speaking, and even the US Litigation Army will avoid us like the plague because it will be ‘mission impossible’. The fact that all law needs to be tested in court has escaped Timmy.
Is that meant to be a Roman “X”?
what international lawyers? Have their costs been included in the Fact Sheets? (rhetorical cos they have not) – Unless our lawyers have been able to change the intent and meaning of the investor relations clauses in the final text, they can’t guarantee anything.
More TPP propaganda from the Herald/Pravda.
This time they give air space to an ex-leader of the ACT Party, a party that gets under 1% of the electoral vote.
Still, it’s nearly appropriate.
The Herald does represent the views of the 0.01%.
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/business/news/article.cfm?c_id=3&objectid=11527183
He’s been a writer there for sometime, so not sure where the act party comes in to it.
Maybe you should start writing Paul? I’m sure you’d have lots to say.
I would.
And just like you, he has no actual argument to counter the TPPA.
Simply a personal attack on Jane Kelsey.
So typical for the extreme neo-liberal ideologues.
You have no moral or practical argument, so you resort to personal insults.
The same was done to Mike Joy, Jon Stephenson, Nicky Hager, Glenn Greenwald……
I liked this review of Hide’s latest column:
Matthew R X Dentith @HORansome 1h1 hour ago
Rodney Hide’s latest column is so bad that if he submitted it as an essay I’d refuse to mark it unless he & I had a meeting to discuss it
Here’s another.
‘And on rolls the NZH’s relentless pro-TPPA propaganda machine. On today’s menu: a quick and dirty hit job on Jane Kelsey. Slap a “Marxist” label on her and be done with it, won’t you Rodney? Actually arguing the points is too much like hard work, isn’t it? Plus one might end up looking a bit foolish, like your friend Mike. She is a law professor after all, and has actually spent a significant part of her life analysing the subject matter. It’s so much easier just to shoot the messenger. Oh, and nice work on choosing that photo, NZH editors. It goes well with the whole Marxist theme.’
Almost universal disapproval of his view.
+1 Karen
It’s ok. Wayne Mapp’s theory applies here. If you have NEVER opposed a FTA (and Hide has not) then we can discount his opinion as being so heavily jaundiced as to be lacking any credibility.
“Columnist Pat Buchanan predicted that the debate on the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) would be after the “early primaries” and the deal “is in real trouble” on Friday’s “McLaughlin Group.”
Buchanan said, “These are trade deals put together by transnational corporations and trade ministries to globalize the world economy, basically to enable these powerful corporations to move their factories and plants out of countries where the wages are high, to countries where the wages are low, so they can bring their products back…free of charge into the United States. In the last month, our trade deficit’s running at 600 billion overall this year, and with China at $400 billion, John. But I will you this, the forces that oppose these transnational trade deals are getting stronger and stronger. Not only [Sen.] Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT)16% and Hillary Clinton in the Democratic Party, but Mr. Trump in the Republican Party, this deal is in real trouble, and I predict that they’re going to have to throw the deal — the discussion in the House — or the Congress over past — certainly past the early primaries.”
http://www.breitbart.com/video/2015/10/10/buchanan-tpp-in-real-trouble-debate-in-congress-will-be-after-early-primaries/
Yeah but Buchanan is a hard left Marxist, right Rodney, Matthew and Wayne?
Q+A viewers saw Anat Shenker-Osorio this morning;
Unlike the NZ Labour Party, she spoke forthrightly about the importance of unions.
She has also had the courage to speak out against terrorism….
—-Anat Shenker-Osorio, 3 March 2015
https://twitter.com/anatosaurus/status/572805519393476608
The Trans-Pacific Partnership’s two solitudes: Burman – Toronto Star
Comparison of TPP and refugee issues.
Tony Burman writes:
“In one case, when corporate and political power works in tandem, borders are a detail to be dispensed with. In the other case, when it’s simply about the powerless, borders are to be strengthened and made impenetrable. It all seems to depend on whose interests you value most.”
http://ustad.science/the-trans-pacific-partnerships-two-solitudes-burman-toronto-star/
Ain’t that the truth!
+1
Thanks for sharing that TMM
I really hope I misread this one. Looks like Key goes to an expensive charity bash and then donates taxpayer funds as his contribution.
John Key donates taxpayer funds at charity bash?
Shouldn’t it be handled as foreign aid by MFAT?
Did he ever consider that given a clear choice many taxpayers may not choose to donate to this particular charity to help in this part of the world?
This is not a post about whether or not people in this region need help – many will.
Just the question of is this how the government has released funds for it “crony charity?”
Wrong link Red Baron?
Trying again – thanks
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=11527197
What was that?
The Grinning Fools’ Big Night Out?
So Key’s personal donation was afternoon tea at his electorate office? Even that is likely to be paid for out of his office running budget.
It seems our multi-millionaire PM is happy to play the big benefactor with tax payer’s money but is keeping his hands out of his own pockets. What a guy!
Getting in first to counter the much quoted claim he donates his salary to charity that claim soon changed to a proportion of his salary and he has always refused to say what proportion.
Only rich folk invited. Special form of arrogance to promise the money earned by others.
Rich Pricks are great at spending Other Peoples money.
He should just make a better effort as PM to assist refugees.
Charity then would not be necessary.
Interesting cast at the gala dinner…
It would be nice to see Key apologise to Stephenson though, or at least have something to say about the Defence Force slandering a journalist.
Is Matthew Hooton well?
He is coming across, in my opinion, somewhat ‘unhinged’ as he desperately attempts to ‘spin’ opponents of the TPPA as being ‘extreme’?
FYI (hopefully Matthew, you will see this either on Kiwiblog – or here?)
_______________________________________________________
A belated reply to Matthew Hooton’s (Kiwiblog) post October 9th, 2015 at 5:49 pm
Gee Matthew!
For a purportedly experienced ‘spin doctor’ / Media Commentator – that is a rather, (in my view), apoplectic and intemperate response, to my arguably straightforward questions?
Sheesh!
You were more pleasant when you were drinking!
(If you’re stressed, for whatever reason, try Spirulina, those ‘B’ vitamins can really help).
_____________________________________________________________
Dear Penny
1. Would you like to provide any evidence that any of the statements in these unscholarly press statements is true: http://info.scoop.co.nz/Professor_Jane_Kelsey ?
2. I don’t give a fuck who Tim Groser or Len Brown meet with. But it would make sense for the trade minister to brief the mayor of Auckland on his work from time to time.
3. Pay your rates.
4. Check yourself into a mental hospital.
Best as always
Matthew
+100 GO PENNY !
In the meantime,
http://www.radionz.co.nz/news/world/286663/death-toll-up-to-97-in-turkey
and
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/turkey/11923935/Turkey-Ankara-bomb-kills-30-at-pro-Kurdish-rally.html
Peace marchers attacked by terrorists,
so,
there’s ANOTHER march organised to protest the attack on the original march.
Respect for those who refuse to be intimidated.
Respect for those who refuse to be intimidated.
Or? Amusement at the simplicity who gather together all the principled and thinking people in one spot so they can be conveniently annihilated.
He that fights and runs away,
May turn and fight another day;
But he that is in battle slain,
Will never rise to fight again.
Tacitus
Read more at http://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/quotes/t/tacitus118925.html#hXAax5WE4GjmAOZ0.99
Guerilla tactics are perhaps the only ones that will work when society descends from reason.
guerilla – a member of an irregular armed force that fights a stronger force by sabotage and harassment
guerrilla, irregular, insurgent
Based on WordNet 3.0, Farlex clipart collection. © 2003-2012 Princeton University, Farlex Inc.
Protest in the streets like this can be futile, and destructive to the cause weakening numbers by decimation, and strengthening the triumphant vicious over-riding group. Repeating protests after attacks, should be the last resort. Better if other measures can be planned and the vicious attacked from behind, and through other ways where they have weaknesses.
“Better if other measures can be planned and the vicious attacked from behind, and through other ways where they have weaknesses.”
Isn’t that kinda like playing the terrorists/oppressive state at their own game?
Lowering to the level of the enemy?
Looking into the abyss and all that?
But I do get your point…you might end up with only the rights of a few to defend.
Power at any cost.
http://www.dailykos.com/story/2015/10/10/1430345/-Planned-Parenthood-Why-the-Republicans-Really-Want-to-Axe-it#
Thanks for this. It definitely explains the willingness of the GOP to look stupid, while pulling out every trick in the book (including out right fabrication and bare-faced lying), to try to destroy PP.
Good time to watch ‘the fog of war’ and remember the lessons supposedly learned by Vietnam… Parallels to all the other US run occupations in particular around the middle East.
Iraq, a problem that only existed in the US and UK imagination, but by which they have made a reality of the problem (with many profiting from it, while millions suffer).
Robert McNamara’s 11 lessons from Vietnam[edit]
From Robert McNamara’s 1995 book “In Retrospect: The Tragedy and Lessons of Vietnam”.[7]
We misjudged then — and we have since — the geopolitical intentions of our adversaries … and we exaggerated the dangers to the United States of their actions.
We viewed the people and leaders of South Vietnam in terms of our own experience … We totally misjudged the political forces within the country.
We underestimated the power of nationalism to motivate a people to fight and die for their beliefs and values.
Our misjudgments of friend and foe, alike, reflected our profound ignorance of the history, culture, and politics of the people in the area, and the personalities and habits of their leaders.
We failed then — and have since — to recognize the limitations of modern, high-technology military equipment, forces, and doctrine. We failed, as well, to adapt our military tactics to the task of winning the hearts and minds of people from a totally different culture.
We failed to draw Congress and the American people into a full and frank discussion and debate of the pros and cons of a large-scale military involvement … before we initiated the action.
After the action got under way, and unanticipated events forced us off our planned course … we did not fully explain what was happening, and why we were doing what we did.
We did not recognize that neither our people nor our leaders are omniscient. Our judgment of what is in another people’s or country’s best interest should be put to the test of open discussion in international forums. We do not have the God-given right to shape every nation in our image or as we choose.
We did not hold to the principle that U.S. military action … should be carried out only in conjunction with multinational forces supported fully (and not merely cosmetically) by the international community.
We failed to recognize that in international affairs, as in other aspects of life, there may be problems for which there are no immediate solutions … At times, we may have to live with an imperfect, untidy world.
Underlying many of these errors lay our failure to organize the top echelons of the executive branch to deal effectively with the extraordinarily complex range of political and military issues.
savenz; Should be compulsory reading and understanding forObama and Key.
Bank Robbery: Economists and the Banking System
This is why we had to sell out power generation, our telecommunications and pretty much everything else. Our banking system is pretty much designed to shift wealth to the few and thus make the rest of us slaves to those few.
It’s amazing, frustrating, and terrifying to note the difference in coverage right now between the Radio New Zealand and the New Zealand Herald regarding the horrible terrorist attack in Turkey. It’s been the lead story all morning on the RNZ website but at the NZH website it falls faster than an anchor. The Herald fills their page up with several rugby stories, something about Susan Wood and Chris Cairns before we get to the Turkish story.
The reporting is strikingly different too. Radio Zealand calls the victims labour activists whereas the Herald calls the victims hard-line Marxists. Basically, for the Herald the attack doesn’t warrant significant outrage because the victims were left-wing despite the attack being conducted by war-mongering flavour-of-the-month ISIL. Anyone who thinks the Herald is balanced and non-tabloid needs to get their head checked.
The day after the TPP was signed these were the main headlines in the corporate media in NZ.
From The Daily Blog.
‘Here is what the NZ Herald and Stuff decided was more important than a corporate coup removing NZs economic and political sovereignty the day after the TPPA was signed.
Sports gamblers panicking that the All Blacks won’t win the Rugby World Cup.
A porn renovation TV show might make some more money than they first thought.
A boat falls off a trailer.
A bad bus trip.
The world didn’t end after a religious prophecy
A radio host wears the same togs as Kylie Jenner.
An Apartment that got flooded by a fish tank was sold.
Government spends $600 000 on flowers
A dog gets put down.’
http://thedailyblog.co.nz/2015/10/08/why-the-tppa-is-a-corporate-coup-and-stories-the-nz-mainstream-media-thought-were-more-important/
More propaganda from the Herald as they publicise the US media’s attempt to shut down Clinton. The corporate media are working overtime to ‘seal the deal’, aren’t they?
‘Clinton is wrong on the Trans-Pacific Partnership’
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/business/news/article.cfm?c_id=3&objectid=11526439
the Herald should be boycotted…i am pleased I dont live in Auckland…why cant an alternative to the Herald be produced?
Money.
Nobody reads it anymore, which is as good as a boycott, I guess.
Or they just ridicule it.
Jane Kelsey on Tim Groser who was trying to justify the secrecy of TPP in the interview this morning, Tim said he was “very pleased” tobacco control measures exempted from Investor State Dispute Settlement provisions and “I can almost guarantee you that if we had made that public, we would not have got it”
“Farce of TPPA secrecy must end, Groser must stop misleading statements” – Kelsey – See more at: http://foreignaffairs.co.nz/2015/10/11/farce-of-tppa-secrecy-must-end-groser-must-stop-misleading-statements-kelsey/#sthash.q0CCAIhJ.dpuf
The tobacco carve out was one of the few bits of the TPP that WAS publicly discussed way back. In 2013.
“The United States and 11 countries bordering the Pacific Ocean had been engaged in the latest round of negotiations over a treaty intended to lower tariffs and other barriers to commerce. One of the issues was whether tobacco should be included in such a treaty or “carved out” so that health considerations could take precedence over expanded trade. The issue pits health advocates against the tobacco industry and other commercial interests.
http://www.nytimes.com/2013/09/01/opinion/sunday/the-hazard-of-free-trade-tobacco.html?_r=0
and in 2014 Reuters
“U.S. floats cutting tobacco from part of Pacific trade pact -sources”
“Dropping tobacco from the investor-state dispute settlement, or ISDS, section of the Trans-Pacific Partnership would prevent tobacco companies taking action against any TPP government under those legal protections, for example over health care measures.”
http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/10/21/usa-trade-tpp-idUSL2N0SG1WO20141021
Another issue: Tim believes ISDS wouldn’t stop NZ introducing a policy like plain packaging for fizzy drinks; “I believe you probably could as long as you had a good health-based case and you’re ready to defend it”
Does being ready to defend that mean in an “inconceivable” ISDS tribunal?
But lying is what the Right does… seemingly even when the argument for the TPP is so obvious and compelling they still lie…
Toronto’s newspaper The Star has released a poll which has the Liberals under Justin Trudeau within reach of a ‘strong minority’. The Liberals are at 37% versus Harper’s Conservatives on 31%. Mulcair and the NDP are trailing at 23% which is an extraordinary turnaround from their frontrunner position going in to the campaign.
http://www.thestar.com/news/canada/2015/10/10/liberals-within-reach-of-majority-poll.html
What alot of shit that canary suited ‘has-been’ gargoyle Hide talks –
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/business/news/article.cfm?c_id=3&objectid=11527183
For a start, yesterday/today…..the sun shines…..blah blah blah. Who knows what’s in this deal ? Sovereignty’s hardly a thing “gone by lunchtime”.
Then pulling the ‘Commie Card’ re Jane Kelsey.
OK…..with as much ground for it I’ll pull the ‘Traitor Card’. Which is the canary suited has-been gargoyle aka Mr Love-Perks-Hypocrite Extraordinaire. And honours for Jane Kelsey.
Don Brash was right about only one thing. Hyde being toxic.Still is.
If you look closely you will see Alan Gibbs hand up Hide’s arse when Hide speaks or writes.
Charming
So does your shade of lipstick come from Hide’s arse or Gibbs’ hand?
It’s his paycheck.
interesting about his sun shines comment. Same was made by one of our regular righties when it was signed…
The fact that the treaty is not yet in effect doesn’t seem to stop the ideologues chirping away…
I think he was stating the obvious. Her communism means that she opposes markets and globalisation. She has been doing so for 30 years. Her Wikipedia entry which she could edit if she wants reads like a horror story.
Too funny: Rodney Hide’s opinions are “obvious” to S Rylands.
S Rylands thinks that editing ones own Wikipedia entry is a good idea, whether or not it mentions “communism” (Kelsey’s doesn’t at the time of writing).
No wonder S Rylands reacts with “horror”: conflict of interest much?
There have been accusations and counter accusations about who is siding with which side in the war in Syria. There is sufficient proof that the FSA (Free Syrian Army), supported by the US and some Gulf states have been fighting alongside Al Nusra Front, an Al Qaeda associated group.
As it is going, I hardly see a problem with that, given that the murderous Assad has been siding with Hezbollah and Iran, who have their own human rights issues.
We see a situation in Syria, that deserves more scrutiny and effort to get all parties around a table to discuss a hopefully peaceful solution to the civil war, but bombings from the air by either the US or the Russians will hardly assist such a process, it will only fuel the situation and war there.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xowl9-tnuEY
that is just the inevitable evidence of organised opposition fighting, maybe the US want to come clean on Al Qaeda!?
Who is siding with the innocent civillians? No one. No fucking One
You ask a completely valid question. The sad truth is that the fronts are so hardened and there is such hostility, there will only be some prospect for peace if one of the sides puts the other under so much pressure that they will be prepared to negotiate. I doubt whether it is such a good idea by Putin and the Russians to keep Assad in place, that solves nothing and will only escalate and prolong the war there.
In the meantime refugees will flow into Europe and elsewhere and can only hope that the situation in Syria will somehow be resolved over future years. Not a great prospect, as also refugees face increased pressures and hostility in the places they have fled to. In Germany there have already been arson attacks on refugee homes, there are protests and the government is cutting benefits for refugees.
The EU is planning to fast track sending back hundreds of thousands that are presumed to rather be economic refugees.
The world is not a great place at present, for too many to live in.
” I doubt whether it is such a good idea by Putin and the Russians to keep Assad in place, that solves nothing and will only escalate and prolong the war there.”
I share your doubts.
Sadly, recent history also teaches us that over-throwing the selected undemocratic leader doesn’t solve the problem either. God forbid we look for a completely different solution rather than trying the same old failed ones over and over and over. I say selected because Saudi Arabia gets to be very undemocratic but untouched by Western superiority.
How can peace be achieved with these forces stating so clearly their issues?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LyRhn0qqQsY
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nfSKkdgrPc8
Most are dreaming in NZ about peace long lost.