NZ: No jobs, expensive housing, time to leave
Written By:
- Date published:
4:26 pm, August 21st, 2024 - 63 comments
Categories: Economy, employment, RBNZ, superannuation, unemployment -
Tags: australia, NACT1, stagflation
It gets rather depressing reading the statistics on National’s induced recession as they steadily push New Zealand into stagflation. The Reserve Bank’s previously unsignaled OCR decision last week wasn’t a hopeful sign.
Rather than sticking to their planned reductions over the next couple of years, they would up responding to unplanned rapid increases in unemployment and slumps in demand. Kiwis have already recognised the failing economy – they are rapidly leaving.
If you want to look at why this was so unexpected by the RBNZ, then you don’t have to look further than an earlier denial of entering a stagflation economic cycle from RBNZ chief economist Paul Conway on the 19th of June.
The key part of the planned approach was the rate at which ‘spare capacity’, employees would ’emerge’ in sectors of the economy that were short of capacity to drive down mainly domestic inflation. The expectation was that unemployment would rise slowly as employees transferred jobs between sectors of the economy.
The problem is that existing employees in New Zealand aren’t shifting between parts of the economy, kiwis are simply leaving the economy and mostly heading to Australia. As Liam Dann put it
New Zealand had a net migration gain of 73,300 in the June 2024 year, down from the peak of 136,600 in the October 2023 year, Stats NZ says.
But the net migration loss of New Zealand citizens was at record levels over the period, with more than half of those departing headed for Australia.
There was a provisional net migration loss of 55,300 New Zealand citizens in the June 2024 year.
That was below the record set last month, for the year to May, when more than 60,000 citizens departed.
Before the current high levels, the record annual net migration loss of New Zealand citizens was 44,400 in February 2012 year.
The net migration loss of New Zealand citizens in the June 2024 year comprised 24,900 migrant arrivals and 80,200 migrant departures.
For every migrant arrival of a New Zealand citizen, there were more than three migrant departures, Stats NZ said.
“Despite the recent fall, the net migration gain in the June 2024 year is the third largest net gain ever for a June year,” Stats NZ population indicators manager Tehseen Islam said.
However, Westpac senior economist Michael Gordon noted that the estimated net inflow of 2700 people in June, was the smallest monthly inflow since August 2022, and “notably lower than the average of around 4000 a month that we saw in the years before Covid”.
The effect is getting worse, not better. In 2023, we wound up with a total nett incoming migration of 126,000. This year we will be lucky to get 50,000. This is a combination of NZ being less attractive to immigrants, anecdotally mainly because of cost of housing, and Kiwis wanting to get away from the ongoing disaster of the flailing Luxon government and high housing costs.
But we’re currently still getting nett inwards migration. Thus, in theory, relieving capacity issues in skilled and unskilled employees. All things being equal, this should in the RBNZ model have resulted in capacity expansions, but no rapid increases in unemployment. Paul Conway made his speech in June when the Q1 2024 employment was 4.3% and the RBNZ expectation was that it would peak at 5.0% at the end of Q4 2024.
But preliminary modelling estimates are that the July unemployment probably has already increased to 4.8%, well in advance of the RBNZ expectations. See “Why the unemployment rate is worse than you think” for the results of a model based data on benefits and filled jobs.
Based on my experience this year, I suspect even that approach is going to be systematically inaccurate. It doesn’t account for the rapidly increasing flood of boomers like me (born 1959) who start receiving superannuation this year. We’re not going into unemployment, but mostly we will be employable.
Boomers on superannuation who will probably still be or still wanting to work. Either because of housing costs or because we’re still healthy and not interested in golf or overseas trips or anything similar. Unlike younger workers, people who have super and a stash of released Kiwisaver are less likely to head over the Tasman. It will be interesting to see to what extent their increasing numbers buffer the future employment market in a way that NZ hasn’t seen before.
Anyway if the modelled unemployment levels are correct, then the real unemployment is more likely to be closer to 5.0% next month than it will be in December. It wouldn’t surprise me, given the weak economy at present if we hit 5.4% very early next year, and that it doesn’t peak at that level, but heads towards 6%. I’d also suspect that the next Household Labour Force Survey results are going to be interesting when looking at who’d like work but can’t find it.
In any case, the early drop in the OCR, and consequent fall in mortgage rates are obvious stimulation effects for an economy. Presumably the RBNZ are trying to prevent the economy from going deeper into a domestic recession and into a stagflation.
The Q1 GDP results showed a minuscule 0.2% growth a series of mostly negative quarterly, after worsening growth through 2022 and 2023.
| Quarter | Quarterly growth (%) | Annual growth (%) |
| Mar-22 | -0.1 | 4.6 |
| Jun-22 | 1 | 0.7 |
| Sep-22 | 1.8 | 2.5 |
| Dec-22 | -0.5 | 2.4 |
| Mar-23 | -0.3 | 2.7 |
| Jun-23 | 0.5 | 3 |
| Sep-23 | -0.3 | 1.2 |
| Dec-23 | -0.1 | 0.6 |
| Mar-24 | 0.2 | 0.2 |
The Q2 June quarter is going to be low, probably negative, as well, and I strongly suspect that Q3 and Q4 is going to be awful as the effects of widespread public service cuts and other employers cut further into domestic demand. There is absolutely nothing going on economically that indicates any areas of profit. This includes farming where the “July 2024 New-Season Farm Confidence Survey” shows both current and future profitability to be in short supply. Business where it appears that the only hope in July was that the RBNZ may start cutting OCR rates at year end – in other words that consumers would start spending if that happened. However I don’t think that a 0.25% change in interest rates will do much.
Meanwhile the beneficiaries of this governments largess; the landlords, banks and other rentiers, the farmers passing their costs on to future taxpayers. None adding anything of significiant utility to the domestic economy, most having detrimental economic and environmental effects well into the future. Like farmers in Canterbury being given permission to spread more pollution into already toxic water systems “Govt answers industry pleas to weaken freshwater law“.
Peanut tax-cuts in times of inflation do little to benefit anyone apart from the already affluent, a point made in “What will tax cuts mean for households?”
“They’re small tax cuts,” said Kiwibank chief economist Jarrod Kerr.
“They’re not life-changing. They’ll definitely help some households a little bit. I just don’t feel they’re going to be spent the way you might think – people running down to the retail store and buying some clothes. I think this will just be absorbed into people’s budgets.
“There is a lot of stress out there at the moment. If you’re a renter, your rents have gone up 5 percent in the last year. If you own your own home, interest rates have tripled, your council rates have gone up quite a lot, your insurance has gone up more than 20 percent. There are some big costs households are facing. $20 a week will help, but it’s not going to solve any of those problems.”
Susan St John, associate professor at the University of Auckland, said the lowest quintile of earners would get just 5.4 percent of the total tax cut, and 64 percent would go to the top two quintiles of earners. “About 130,000 households get nothing at all and 8000 are slightly worse off.”
The bulk of the recipients of the this governments largess are more likely to just use it to just use it to cover inflationary costs or interest accumulated between the time of the election and now. Or if already wealthy, to go on holiday somewhere offshore.
Tax cuts in the past have shown no positive trickle down effects into the economy apart from an effect that seems like a 1950s and later experiments of stimulating the pleasure centres of brains. A short term forced orgasm followed by a reversion into normal usage as the mechanism is removed. A common effect for Act voters whenever one of their favoured schemes are tried and found to be a complete failures. As most of them will be seen after this term.
If you think about it from a local employers perspective, they are currently looking at a dead flat economy. There is rapidly increasing unemployment cutting into domestic demand. Their cost inflation is still high.
They can’t get the types of employees they want or need to drive growth because the ones that they would need have gone to Australia where wages are higher and housing costs relative to wages are far lower. What they have are mostly recent migrants who require training not only in the job, but also in the culture, and frequently in the language.
Meanwhile interest rates on capital are still high, so it isn’t worth investing in productivity enhancers. Similarly investing in marketing is probably not worth it without having an existing cutting technical advantage over competitors. But they don’t have that because, again, it requires that they invest in R&D for what is currently a flat economy and they just came out of a pandemic which was when the R&D should have been done.
Why would they spend for growth when they can currently get a better return on their capital by putting it on term deposits with effectively no risk?
In the past, National under John Key has bypassed this economic philosophical roadblock in their worldview by simply opening the immigration tap. This stimulated domestic economic demand for the goods and services by new customers, and activity fuelled by the money that immigrants brought into the economy. But that is close to impossible in the extremely tight housing market with both rents and house prices still soaring well above incomes.
In the past, National’s magical hand waving has conjured up visions of the private sector building houses to fill the gap. Something that simply didn’t happen. Instead almost all of the available spare residential housing capacity got filled to brim with incoming migrants. It still is.
This is obvious when you look at the volume of residential consents issued. See the May 2024 stats press release “Annual number of homes consented down 23 percent“.
But is even clearer when you look at the seasonally adjusted pace of completed buildings over the past few years in “Value of building work put in place: March 2024 quarter“.
In the absence of forward work, builders and construction companies are letting their staff go and folding. Meanwhile this government has now effectively shut down all building of affordable housing with the signalling of future housing policies.
But we still have high levels of net incoming migration. Certainly higher than the increases in housing stock.
There is no economic capacity in housing for the sugar rush of new migrants. Nor are we building enough new infrastructure or even maintaining our existing infrastructure to sustain more.
The NACT1 government have been announcing small numbers of new infrastructure developments. While they’re touting $11.4b (11.7%) in increased infrastructural pipeline values this is just PR bullshit. 5.3 billion is merely from cost rises mainly from inflation. Most provide few new significiant economic benefits.
Fixing previous under-investment in existing infrastructure especially water systems like fresh water, sewerage, and storm water protection doesn’t provide much capacity for new inwards migration. Fixing neglected government buildings from the Key era especially schools, hospitals and prisons doesn’t help increase economic capacity apart from construction sugar rushes. Fixing potholes and slips in degraded roads without apparently looking at what is damaging them, ie trucks, earthquakes,and climate change, is pretty pointless without looking at how to prevent damage in the future. They have axed a number of projects whose absence will significantly degrade economic benefits from transport – notably the continuation of the Cook Strait transport links.
About the only thing that looks like a useful new infrastructural project (actually pretty old as work started in 2008) is allowing congestion charging in Auckland and other cities. “Government accelerates congestion charging plans” describes changes to legislation to enable it for limited times in the day.
Of course that legislation will have a massive set of NACT1 holes in it. There won’t be corresponding infrastructural commitment funding alternate transport like public transport or safe bike paths to help people who can’t pay the charge. As importantly, employers will not required to have flexible work and stop times for on-site work which is the underlying cause for congestion peaks in the first place.
If I was 20 years younger, I’d be leaving New Zealand as well. Because “NZ: No jobs, expensive housing -> time to leave” isn’t getting better. With National around as the party for rentiers, it will only get worse, as it has through my working life.
Get out while you still can. Preferably before you sink too much effort in paying an Aussie bank for a expensive millstone or a gentailer a fortune for power that was largely already paid for by previous generations. Ask your parents, after they finish wailing about the grandkids, they will probably give you the same advice.
CommentsOpinions
Recent Comments
FeedsPartyGovtMedia
- Skeptical Science New Research for Week #37 2024
Open access notables Early knowledge but delays in climate actions: An ecocide case against both transnational oil corporations and national governments, Hauser et al., Environmental Science & Policy: Cast within the wide context of investigating the collusion at play between powerful political-economic actors and decision-makers as monopolists and debates about ‘the modern ...10 hours ago - What it is
I liked what Kieran McAnulty had to say about the Treaty Principles bill this morning so much I've written it down and copied it out for you. He was saying that rather than let this piece of ordure spend six months in Select Committee, the Prime Minister could stop making such ...12 hours ago - A government-funded hate campaign
Cabinet discussed National's constitutionally and historically illiterate "Treaty Principles Bill" this week, and decided to push on with it. The bill will apparently receive a full six month select committee process - unlike practically every other policy this government has pushed, and despite the fact that if the government is ...14 hours ago - How Substack works to take (some) craziness out of America’s elections
I spoke with Substack co-founder yesterday, just before the Trump-Harris debate, about how Substack is doing its thing during the US elections. He talks in particular about how Substack’s focus on paid subscriptions rather than ads has made political debate on the platform calmer, simpler, deeper and more satisfying ...16 hours ago - Kamala Harris Did Something Unthinkable
16 hours ago - Kamala Harris Did Something Unthinkable
16 hours ago
- Kamala Harris Did Something Unthinkable
16 hours ago
- David Seymour is such a loser
For paid subscribersNot content with siphoning off $230,000,000 of taxpayers money for his hobby projects - and telling everyone his passion is education and early childcare - an intersection painfully coincidental to the interests of wealthy private families like Sean Plunkett’s1 backers, the Wright Family, Seymour is back in the ...16 hours ago - Cross-party consensus: there’s no pipeline without good faith
There’s been a lot of talk recently about a cross-party agreement to develop a pipeline for infrastructure, including transport. Last month, outgoing CRL boss Sean Sweeney talked about the importance of securing an enduring infrastructure programme. He outlined the high costs of the relentless political flip-flopping of priorities, which drives ...21 hours ago - Voters love this climate policy they’ve never heard of
This is a re-post from Yale Climate Connections by Karin Kirk The Inflation Reduction Act is the Biden administration’s signature climate law and the largest U.S. government investment in reducing climate pollution to date. Among climate advocates, the policy is well-known and celebrated, but beyond that, only a minority of Americans ...21 hours ago
- ACC wants to administer inflation at more than double the RBNZ’s target rate
ACC levies are set to rise at more than double the inflation rate targeted by the RBNZ. Photo: Lynn GrievesonKia ora. Long stories short, here’s my top six things to note in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty on Thursday, September 12:The state-owned monopoly for accident insurance wants ...21 hours ago - Harris vs Trump
22 hours ago - Treaty Bill “a political stunt”
Prime Minister Christopher Luxon appears to have given ACT Leader David Seymour more than he has been admitting in the proposals to go forward with a Treaty Principles Bill.All along, Luxon has maintained that the Government is proceeding with the Bill to honour the coalition agreement.But that is quite specific.It ...24 hours ago
- An average 219 NZers migrated each day in July
Kia ora. Long stories short, here’s my top six things to note in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty on Wednesday, September 11:Annual migration of New Zealanders rose to a record-high 80,963 in the year to the end of July, which is more than double its pre-Covid levels.Two ...1 day ago - What you’re wanting to win more than anything is The Narrative
Hubris is sitting down on election day 2016 to watch that pig Trump get his ass handed to him, and watching the New York Times needle hover for a while over Hillary and then move across to Trump where it remains all night to your gathering horror and dismay. You're ...1 day ago - National’s automated lie machine
The government has a problem: lots of people want information from it all the time. Information about benefits, about superannuation, ACC coverage and healthcare, taxes, jury service, immigration - and that's just the routine stuff. Responding to all of those queries takes a lot of time and costs a lot ...2 days ago
- Christopher Luxon: A Man of “Faith” and “Compassion” Speaks on the Treaty Pr...
Synopsis: Today - we explore two different realities. One where National lost. And another - which is the one we are living with here. Note: the footnote on increased fees/taxes may be of interest to some readers.Article open.Subscribe nowIt’s an alternate timeline.Yesterday as news broke that the central North Island ...2 days ago - Member’s Day
Today is a Member's Day. First up is the third reading of Dan Bidois' Fair Trading (Gift Card Expiry) Amendment Bill, which will be followed by the committee stage of Deborah Russell's Family Proceedings (Dissolution for Family Violence) Amendment Bill. This will be followed by the second readings of Katie ...2 days ago
- Northern Expressway Boondoggle
Transport Minister Simeon Brown has been soaring high with his hubris of getting on and building motorways but some uncomfortable realities are starting to creep in. Back in July he announced that the government was pushing on with a Northland Expressway using an “accelerated delivery strategy” The Coalition Government is ...2 days ago
- Never Enough
However much I'm falling downNever enoughHowever much I'm falling outNever, never enough!Whatever smile I smile the mostNever enoughHowever I smile I smile the mostSongwriters: Robert James Smith / Simon Gallup / Boris Williams / Porl ThompsonToday in Nick’s Kōrero:A death in the Emergency Department at Rotorua Hospital.A sad homecoming and ...2 days ago - Question Two of The Kākā Project of 2026 for 2050 (TKP 26/50)
Kia ora.Last month I proposed restarting The Kākā Project work done before the 2023 election as The Kākā Project of 2026 for 2050 (TKP 26/50), aiming to be up and running before the 2025 Local Government elections, and then in a finalised form by the 2026 General Elections.A couple of ...2 days ago
- Why is God Obsessed with Spanking?
Hi,If you’ve read Webworm for a while, you’ll be aware that I’ve spent a lot of time writing about horrific, corrupt megachurches and the shitty men who lead them.And in all of this writing, I think some people have this idea that I hate Christians or Christianity. As I explain ...2 days ago - Inside the public service
In 2023, there were 63,117 full-time public servants earning, on average, $97,200 a year each. All up, that is a cost to the Government of $6.1 billion a year. It’s little wonder, then, that the public service has become a political whipping boy castigated by the Prime Minister and members ...2 days ago
- New Models Show Stronger Atlantic Hurricanes, and More of Them
This is a re-post from This is Not Cool Here’s an example of some of the best kind of climate reporting, especially in that it relates to impacts that will directly affect the audience. WFLA in Tampa conducted a study in collaboration with the Department of Energy, analyzing trends in ...2 days ago
- Where ever do they find these people?
A riddle wrapped in a mystery inside an enigma, is how Winston Churchill described the Soviet Union in 1939. How might the great man have described the 2024 government of New Zealand, do we think? I can't imagine he would have thought them all that mysterious or enigmatic. I think ...3 days ago - Motorway madness
How mad is National's obsession with roads? One of their pet projects - a truck highway to Whangārei - is going to eat 10% of our total infrastructure budget for the next 25 years: Official advice from the Infrastructure Commission shows the government could be set to spend 10 ...3 days ago
- Our transport planning system is fundamentally broken
Ever since Wayne Brown became mayor (nearly two years ago now) he’s been wanting to progress an “integrated transport plan” with the government – which sounded a lot like the previous Auckland Transport Alignment Project (ATAP) with just a different name. It seems like a fair bit of work progressed ...3 days ago
- Thou Shalt Not Steal
And they taught usWhoa-oh, black woman, thou shalt not stealI said, hey, yeah, black man, thou shalt not stealWe're gonna civilise your black barbaric livesAnd we teach you how to kneelBut your history couldn't hide the genocideThe hypocrisy to us was realFor your Jesus said you're supposed to giveThe oppressed ...3 days ago - How mismanagement, not wind and solar energy, causes blackouts
This is a re-post from Yale Climate Connections In February 2021, several severe storms swept across the United States, culminating with one that the Weather Channel unofficially named Winter Storm Uri. In Texas, Uri knocked out power to over 4.5 million homes and 10 million people. Hundreds of Texans died as a ...3 days ago
- The ‘Infra Boys’ Highway to Budget Hell
Chris Bishop has enthusiastically dubbed himself and Simeon Brown “the Infra Boys”, but they need to take note of the sums around their roading dreams. Photo: Lynn GrievesonMōrena. Long stories short, here’s my top six things to note in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty on Tuesday, September ...3 days ago - Media Link: “AVFA” on the politics of desperation.
In this podcast Selwyn Manning and I talk about what appears to be a particular type of end-game in the long transition to systemic realignment in international affairs, in which the move to a new multipolar order with different characteristics … Continue reading ...3 days ago - The cost of flying blind
Just over two years ago, when worries about immediate mass-death from covid had waned, and people started to talk about covid becoming "endemic", I asked various government agencies what work they'd done on the costs of that - and particularly, on the cost of Long Covid. The answer was that ...4 days ago
- Seymour vs The Clergy
For paid subscribers“Aotearoa is not as malleable as they think,” Lynette wrote last week on Homage to Simeon Brown:In my heart/mind, that phrase ricocheted over the next days, translating out to “We are not so malleable.”It gave me comfort. I always felt that we were given an advantage in New ...4 days ago - Unstoppable Minister McKee
All smiles, I know what it takes to fool this townI'll do it 'til the sun goes downAnd all through the nighttimeOh, yeahOh, yeah, I'll tell you what you wanna hearLeave my sunglasses on while I shed a tearIt's never the right timeYeah, yeahSong by SiaLast night there was a ...4 days ago - Could outdoor dining revitalise Queen Street?
This is a guest post by Ben van Bruggen of The Urban Room,.An earlier version of this post appeared on LinkedIn. All images are by Ben. Have you noticed that there’s almost nowhere on Queen Street that invites you to stop, sit outside and enjoy a coffee, let alone ...4 days ago
- Hipkins challenges long-held Labour view Government must stay below 30% of GDP
Hipkins says when considering tax settings and the size of government, the big question mark is over what happens with the balance between the size of the working-age population and the growing number of Kiwis over the age of 65. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāMōrena. Long stories short; here’s ...4 days ago - Your invite to Webworm Chat (a bit like Reddit)
Hi,One of the things I love the most about Webworm is, well, you. The community that’s gathered around this lil’ newsletter isn’t something I ever expected when I started writing it four years ago — now the comments section is one of my favourite places on the internet. The comments ...4 days ago - Seymour’s Treaty bill making Nats nervous
A delay in reappointing a top civil servant may indicate a growing nervousness within the National Party about the potential consequences of David Seymour’s Treaty Principles Bill. Dave Samuels is waiting for reappointment as the Chief Executive of Te Puni Kokiri, but POLITIK understands that what should have been a ...4 days ago
- 2024 SkS Weekly Climate Change & Global Warming News Roundup #36
A listing of 34 news and opinion articles we found interesting and shared on social media during the past week: Sun, September 1, 2024 thru Sat, September 7, 2024. Story of the week Our Story of the Week is about how peopele are not born stupid but can be fooled ...4 days ago
- Time for a Change
You act as thoughYou are a blind manWho's crying, crying 'boutAll the virgins that are dyingIn your habitual dreams, you knowSeems you need more sleepBut like a parrot in a flaming treeI know it's pretty hard to seeI'm beginning to wonderIf it's time for a changeSong: Phil JuddThe next line ...5 days ago - Security Politics in Peripheral Democracies: Excerpt Six.
The “double shocks” in post Cold War international affairs. The end of the Cold War fundamentally altered the global geostrategic context. In particular, the end of the nuclear “balance of terror” between the USA and USSR, coupled with the relaxation … Continue reading ...5 days ago
- Buried deep
Here's a bike on Manchester St, Feilding. I took this photo on Friday night after a very nice dinner at the very nice Vietnamese restaurant, Saigon, on Manchester Street.I thought to myself, Manchester Street? Bicycle? This could be the very spot.To recap from an earlier edition: on a February night ...5 days ago - Security Politics in Peripheral Democracies, Excerpt Five.
Military politics as a distinct “partial regime.” Notwithstanding their peripheral status, national defense offers the raison d’être of the combat function, which their relative vulnerability makes apparent, so military forces in small peripheral democracies must be very conscious of events … Continue reading ...6 days ago
- Leadership for Dummies
If you’re going somewhere, do you maybe take a bit of an interest in the place? Read up a bit on the history, current events, places to see - that sort of thing? Presumably, if you’re taking a trip somewhere, it’s for a reason. But what if you’re going somewhere ...6 days ago - Home again
6 days ago - Dead even tie for hottest August ever
Long stories short, here’s the top six news items of note in climate news for Aotearoa-NZ this week, and a discussion above between Bernard Hickey and The Kākā’s climate correspondent Cathrine Dyer:The month of August was 1.49˚C warmer than pre-industrial levels, tying with 2023 for the warmest August ever, according ...6 days ago
- The Hoon around the week to Sept 7
The podcast above of the weekly ‘Hoon’ webinar for paying subscribers on Thursday night features co-hosts and talking about the week’s news with:The Kākā’s climate correspondent on the latest climate science on rising temperatures and the debate about how to responde to climate disinformation; and special guest ...6 days ago
- Have We an Infrastructure Deficit?
An Infrastructure New Zealand report says we are keeping up with infrastructure better than we might have thought from the grumbling. But the challenge of providing for the future remains.I was astonished to learn that the quantity of our infrastructure has been keeping up with economic growth. Your paper almost ...6 days ago - Councils reject racism
Last month, National passed a racist law requiring local councils to remove their Māori wards, or hold a referendum on them at the 2025 local body election. The final councils voted today, and the verdict is in: an overwhelming rejection. Only two councils out of 45 supported National's racist agenda ...6 days ago
- Homage to Simeon Brown
7 days ago
- Government of deceit
When National cut health spending and imposed a commissioner on Te Whatu Ora, they claimed that it was necessary because the organisation was bloated and inefficient, with "14 layers of management between the CEO and the patient". But it turns out they were simply lying: Health Minister Shane Reti’s ...7 days ago
- The professionals actually think and act like our Government has no fiscal crisis at all
Treasury staff at work: The demand for a new 12-year Government bond was so strong, Treasury decided to double the amount of bonds it sold. Photo: Lynn GrievesonMōrena. Long stories short; here’s my top six things to note in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty on Friday, September ...7 days ago - Weekly Roundup 6-September-2024
Welcome to another Friday and another roundup of stories that caught our eye this week. As always, this and every post is brought to you by the Greater Auckland crew. If you like our work and you’d like to see more of it, we invite you to join our regular ...7 days ago
- Security Politics in Peripheral Democracies; Excerpt Four.
Internal versus external security. Regardless of who rules, large countries can afford to separate external and internal security functions (even if internal control functions predominate under authoritarian regimes). In fact, given the logic of power concentration and institutional centralization of … Continue reading ...7 days ago
- A Hole In The River
There's a hole in the river where her memory liesFrom the land of the living to the air and skyShe was coming to see him, but something changed her mindDrove her down to the riverThere is no returnSongwriters: Neil Finn/Eddie RaynerThe king is dead; long live the queen!Yesterday was a ...7 days ago - Bright Blue His Jacket Ain’t But I Love This Fellow: A Review and Analysis of The Rings of Power E...
My conclusion last week was that The Rings of Power season two represented a major improvement in the series. The writing’s just so much better, and honestly, its major problems are less the result of the current episodes and more creatures arising from season one plot-holes. I found episode three ...1 week ago - Who should we thank for the defeat of the Nazis
As a child in the 1950s, I thought the British had won the Second World War because that’s what all our comics said. Later on, the films and comics told me that the Americans won the war. In my late teens, I found out that the Soviet Union ...1 week ago - Skeptical Science New Research for Week #36 2024
Open access notables Diurnal Temperature Range Trends Differ Below and Above the Melting Point, Pithan & Schatt, Geophysical Research Letters: The globally averaged diurnal temperature range (DTR) has shrunk since the mid-20th century, and climate models project further shrinking. Observations indicate a slowdown or reversal of this trend in recent decades. ...1 week ago
- Join us for the weekly Hoon on YouTube Live at 5pm
Photo by Jenny Bess on UnsplashCome and join us for our weekly ‘Hoon’ webinar with paying subscribers to The Kākā for an hour at 5 pm.Jump on this link on YouTube Livestream for our chat about the week’s news with special guests:5.00 pm - 5.10 pm - Bernard and ...1 week ago - Media Link: Discussing the NZSIS Security Threat Report.
I was interviewed by Mike Hosking at NewstalkZB and a few other media outlets about the NZSIS Security Threat Report released recently. I have long advocated for more transparency, accountability and oversight of the NZ Intelligence Community, and although the … Continue reading ...1 week ago
- How do I make this better for people who drive Ford Rangers?
Home, home again to a long warm embrace. Plenty of reasons to be glad to be back.But also, reasons for dejection.You, yes you, Simeon Brown, you odious little oik, you bible thumping petrol-pandering ratfucker weasel. You would be Reason Number One. Well, maybe first among equals with Seymour and Of-Seymour ...1 week ago - A missed opportunity
The government introduced a pretty big piece of constitutional legislation today: the Parliament Bill. But rather than the contentious constitutional change (four year terms) pushed by Labour, this merely consolidates the existing legislation covering Parliament - currently scattered across four different Acts - into one piece of legislation. While I ...1 week ago
- Nicola Willis Seeks New Sidekick To Help Fix NZ’s Economy
Synopsis:Nicola Willis is seeking a new Treasury Boss after Dr Caralee McLiesh’s tenure ends this month. She didn’t listen to McLiesh. Will she listen to the new one?And why is Atlas Network’s Taxpayers Union chiming in?Please consider subscribing or supporting my work. Thanks, Tui.About CaraleeAt the beginning of July, Newsroom ...1 week ago - Inflation alive and kicking in our land of the long white monopolies
The golden days of profit continue for the the Foodstuffs (Pak’n’Save and New World) and Woolworths supermarket duopoly. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāMōrena. Long stories short; here’s my top six things to note in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty on Thursday, September 5:The Groceries Commissioner has ...1 week ago - The thermodynamics of electric vs. internal combustion cars
This is a re-post from The Climate Brink by Andrew Dessler I love thermodynamics. Thermodynamics is like your mom: it may not tell you what you can do, but it damn well tells you what you can’t do. I’ve written a few previous posts that include thermodynamics, like one on air capture of ...1 week ago
- Security Politics in Peripheral Democracies: Excerpt Three.
The notion of geopolitical “periphery.” The concept of periphery used here refers strictly to what can be called the geopolitical periphery. Being on the geopolitical periphery is an analytic virtue because it makes for more visible policy reform in response … Continue reading ...1 week ago
- Venus Hum
Fill me up with soundThe world sings with me a million smiles an hourI can see me dancing on my radioI can hear you singing in the blades of grassYellow dandelions on my way to schoolBig Beautiful Sky!Song: Venus Hum.Good morning, all you lovely people, and welcome to the 700th ...1 week ago - I Went to a Creed Concert
Note: The audio attached to this Webworm compliments today’s newsletter. I collected it as I met people attending a Creed concert. Their opinions may differ to mine. Read more ...1 week ago - Government migration policy backfires; thousands of unemployed nurses
The country has imported literally thousands of nurses over the past few months yet whether they are being employed as nurses is another matter. Just what is going on with HealthNZ and it nurses is, at best, opaque, in that it will not release anything but broad general statistics and ...1 week ago
- A Time For Unity.
Emotional Response: Prime Minister Christopher Luxon addresses mourners at the tangi of King Tuheitia on Turangawaewae Marae on Saturday, 31 August 2024.THE DEATH OF KING TUHEITIA could hardly have come at a worse time for Maoridom. The power of the Kingitanga to unify te iwi Māori was demonstrated powerfully at January’s ...1 week ago - Climate Change: Failed again
National's tax cut policies relied on stealing revenue from the ETS (previously used to fund emissions reduction) to fund tax cuts to landlords. So how's that going? Badly. Today's auction failed again, with zero units (of a possible 7.6 million) sold. Which means they have a $456 million hole in ...1 week ago
- Security Politics in Peripheral Democracies: Excerpt Two.
A question of size. Small size generally means large vulnerability. The perception of threat is broader and often more immediate for small countries. The feeling of comparative weakness, of exposure to risk, and of potential intimidation by larger powers often … Continue reading ...1 week ago
- Nicola Willis’s Very Unserious Bungling of the Kiwirail Interislander Cancellation
Open to all with kind thanks to all subscribers and supporters.Today, RNZ revealed that despite MFAT advice to Nicola Willis to be very “careful and deliberate” in her communications with the South Korean government, prior to any public announcement on cancelling Kiwirail’s i-Rex, Willis instead told South Korea 26 minutes ...1 week ago - Satisfying the Minister’s Speed Obsession
The Minister of Transport’s speed obsession has this week resulted in two new consultations for 110km/h speed limits, one in Auckland and one in Christchurch. There has also been final approval of the Kapiti Expressway to move to 110km/h following an earlier consultation. While the changes will almost certainly see ...1 week ago
- What if we freed up our streets, again?
This guest post is by Tommy de Silva, a local rangatahi and freelance writer who is passionate about making the urban fabric of Tāmaki Makaurau-Auckland more people-focused and sustainable. New Zealand’s March-April 2020 Level 4 Covid response (aka “lockdown”) was somehow both the best and worst six weeks of ...1 week ago
- Potential intelligence sharing with Israel must be investigated
Concerns have been raised that our spy arrangements may mean that intelligence is being shared between Aotearoa and Israel. An urgent inquiry must be launched in response to this. ...11 hours ago - Release: Charter schools undermine our education system
The Government is taking a wrecking ball to our public education system by reinstating charter schools. ...14 hours ago - Youngest MP to travel to Canada to accept Politician of the Year Award
Aotearoa’s Youngest Member of Parliament, and Te Pāti Māori MP, Hana-Rawhiti Maipi-Clarke, will travel to Montreal to accept the One Young World Politician of the Year Award next week. The One Young World Politician of the Year Award was created in 2018 to recognise the most promising young politicians between ...16 hours ago
- Greens celebrate huge step forward for ADHD community
The Greens welcome today’s long-coming announcement by Pharmac of consultation to remove the special authority renewal criteria for methylphenidate, dexamfetamine and modafinil and to fund lisdexamfetamine. ...18 hours ago
- Release: Millions to be spent dividing NZ for no reason
The National Party is wasting millions of dollars allowing David Seymour’s Treaty Principals Bill to be drafted and go to Select Committee. ...20 hours ago
- Release: New Zealanders departing our shores at a record rate
The Migration figures released by Stats NZ today show National is continuing to drive Kiwis away from New Zealand in record numbers. ...20 hours ago
- Te Tai Tokerau MP Slams Govt Overreach in Scrapping Māori Wards
Mema Paremata for Te Tai Tokerau, Mariameno Kapa-Kingi, has reflected on the decisions made by the councils of the North amidst the government’s push to remove Māori Wards and weaken mana whenua representation. “Actions taken by the Kaipara District Council to remove Māori Wards are the embodiment of the eradication ...1 day ago
- Govt already seeking advice on Treaty referendum
On one hand, the Prime Minister has assured Aotearoa that his party will not support the Treaty Principles Bill beyond first reading, but on the other, his Government has already sought advice on holding a referendum on our founding document. ...2 days ago
- Release: Aged care will be worse off if redesign rushed
New Zealanders needing aged care support and the people who care for them will be worse off if the Government pushes through a flawed and rushed redesign of dementia and aged care. ...2 days ago
- Release: Govt fails hundreds of workers as mills close
Labour is devastated at news hundreds of workers are set to lose their jobs following the closure of Winstone Pulp mills. ...2 days ago
- Job losses from mill closures consequence of Govt inaction
Hundreds of jobs lost as a result of pulp mill closures in the Ruapehu District are a consequence of government inaction in addressing the shortfalls of our electricity network. ...2 days ago
- Ngarewa-Packer devastated for Ruapehu following WPI closure
Te Pāti Māori Co-Leader and MP for Te Tai Hauāuru is devastated for the Ruapehu community following today’s decision to close two Winstone Pulp mills. “My heart goes out to all the workers, their whānau, and the wider Ruapehu community affected by the closure of Winstone Pulp International,” said Ngarewa-Packer. ...3 days ago
- Release: Cabinet should stop the Treaty Principles Bill
National Party Ministers have a majority in Cabinet and can stop David Seymour’s Treaty Principles Bill, which even the Prime Minister has described as “divisive and unhelpful.” ...4 days ago
- Release: Staff gagged to keep fast track list secret
The National Government is so determined to hide the list of potential projects that will avoid environmental scrutiny it has gagged Ministry for the Environment staff from talking about it. ...4 days ago
- Release: Labour challenges Te Whatu Ora gag orders
Labour has complained to the Te Kawa Mataaho Public Service Commission about the high number of non-disclosure agreements that have effectively gagged staff at Te Whatu Ora Health NZ from talking about anything relating to their work. ...4 days ago
- Greens call on Treaty Principles Bill to be abandoned after letter from Christian leaders
The Green Party is once again urging the Prime Minister to abandon the Treaty Principles Bill as a letter from more than 400 Christian leaders calls for the proposed legislation to be dropped. ...4 days ago
- Sign the petition: Keep military-style firearms off our streets
Help us tell the Government that reintroducing military-style firearms should not be up for debate. ...6 days ago
- Vast majority of councils support Māori wards
Councils across the country have now decided where they stand regarding Māori wards, with a resounding majority in favour of keeping them in what is a significant setback for the Government. ...6 days ago
- Release: Government on the wrong side of Māori wards
The National-led government has been given a clear message from the local government sector, as almost all councils reject the Government’s bid to treat Māori wards different to other wards. ...7 days ago
- Release: Labour congratulates Kuīni Ngā Wai hono i te po Paki
The Labour Party congratulates Kuīni Ngā Wai hono i te po Paki on being crowned as the eighth Te Ariki Nui – head of Te Kiingitanga. ...1 week ago
- Green Party welcomes new Maaori Kuiini
The Green Party welcomes the coronation of the new Maaori Kuiini, Te Arikinui Nga Wai Hono i te Po, today in Turangawaewae. ...1 week ago
- ECE teachers deserve better than this Government
The Green Party is unsurprised but disappointed by today’s announcement from the Government that will see our Early Childhood Centre teachers undermined and pay parity pushed further out of reach. ...1 week ago
- Urgent intervention needed on supermarkets
The Green Party is calling on the Government to intervene in the supermarket duopoly dominating our supply of groceries following today’s report from the Commerce Commission. ...1 week ago
- Release: Rainbow youth neglected in mental health funding
Labour backs the call from The Rainbow Support Collective members for mental health funding specifically earmarked for grassroots and peer led community organisations to be set up in a way that they are able to access. ...1 week ago
- Release: Transport in NZ has to be more than just roads
As expected, the National Land Transport Programme lacks ambition for our cities and our country’s rail network and puts the majority of investment into roads. ...1 week ago
- Speech: Barbara Edmonds Building Nations 2024
Tēnā koutou katoa, Thank you for your warm welcome and for having my colleagues and I here today. Earlier you heard from the Labour Leader, Chris Hipkins, on our vision for the future of infrastructure. I want to build on his comments and provide further detail on some key elements ...1 week ago
- Govt transport plan deepens fossil fuel fix
The Green Party says the Government’s new National Land Transport Programme marks another missed opportunity to take meaningful action to fight the climate crisis. ...2 weeks ago
- Greens call for public to back Wrybill in BOTY and beyond
The Green Party is calling on the public to support the Ngutu Pare Wrybill not just in this year’s Bird of the Year competition but also in pushing back against policies that could lead to the destruction of its habitat and accelerate its extinction. ...2 weeks ago
- Building consents data bad news for construction
News that the annual number of building consents granted for new homes fell by more than 20 percent for the year ended July 2024, is bad news for the construction industry. ...2 weeks ago
- Te Pāti Māori Pay Tribute to Kiingi Tūheitia Pōtatau Te Wherowhero VII
Papā te whatitiri, hikohiko te uira, i kanapu ki te rangi, i whētuki i raro rā, rū ana te whenua e. Uea te pou o tōku whare kia tū tangata he kapua whakairi nāku nā runga o Taupiri. Ko taku kiri ka tōkia ki te anu mātao. E te iwi ...2 weeks ago
- Release: Gaps still to be addressed in callouts response
The Government must guarantee New Zealanders will not be at risk after making changes to the way mental health callouts are handled. ...2 weeks ago
- Poroporoaki: Kiingi Tuheitia passing
Haere e te Kīngi o te kotahitangi Haere ki o nui, ki o rahi I te pō ...2 weeks ago
- Green Party pays respects to Kiingi Tuuheitia
The Green Party is paying tribute to the Māori King, Kiingi Tuuheitia Pootatau Te Wherowhero XVII, after he passed away earlier this morning. ...2 weeks ago
- Potaka Brings Whakaata Māori to its Knees
Today’s Whakaata Māori announcement is yet another colossal failure from Minister Potaka, who has turned his back on te reo Māori, forcing a channel offline, putting whānau out of jobs, and cutting Māori content, says Te Pāti Māori. “A Senior Māori Minister has turned his back on Te Reo Māori. ...2 weeks ago
- Release: National restricts access to disability care homes
With disability communities still reeling from the diminishing of Whaikaha, a leaked document now reveals another blow with National restricting access to residential care homes. ...2 weeks ago
- Release: Govt must help save 230 manufacturing jobs
Labour is calling on the Government and Mercury Energy to find a solution to the proposed Winstone Pulp mill closure and save 230 manufacturing jobs. ...2 weeks ago
- Govt shirks its responsibility to Whakaata Māori
The Green Party has called out the Government for allowing Whakaata Māori to effectively collapse to a shell of its former self as job cuts and programming cuts were announced at the broadcaster today. ...2 weeks ago
- NZ First Member’s Bill To Disestablish Auckland Transport
Today New Zealand First has introduced a Member’s Bill that will restore democratic control over transport management in Auckland City by disestablishing Auckland Transport (AT) and returning control to Auckland Council. The ‘Local Government (Auckland Council) (Disestablishment of Auckland Transport) Amendment Bill’ intends to restore democratic oversight, control, and accountability ...2 weeks ago - Release: PM fails in constitutional role and leadership
The failure of the Prime Minister to condemn his Minister for personally attacking the judiciary is another example of this Government riding roughshod over important constitutional rules. ...2 weeks ago
- Waititi urges Rotorua Lakes Council to immediately stop works at Lake Rotokākahi
Te Pāti Māori co-leader and Member of Parliament for Waiariki, which includes Rotorua, has written to Rotorua Lakes Councillors requesting they immediately stop sewerage piping works at Lake Rotokākahi in Rotorua. “Mana whenua have been urging Rotorua Lakes Council to stop works and look at alternative plans to protect the ...2 weeks ago
- New Bill to crack down on youth vaping
The coalition Government has introduced legislation to tackle youth vaping, Associate Health Minister Casey Costello announced today. “The Smokefree Environments and Regulated Products Amendment Bill (No 2) is aimed at preventing youth vaping. “While vaping has contributed to a significant fall in our smoking rates, the rise in youth vaping ...12 hours ago - Interest in agricultural and horticultural products regulatory review welcomed
Regulation Minister David Seymour, Environment Minister Penny Simmonds, and Food Safety Minister Andrew Hoggard have welcomed interest in the agricultural and horticultural products regulatory review. The review by the Ministry for Regulation is looking at how to speed up the process to get farmers and growers access to the safe, ...13 hours ago
- Bill to allow online charity lotteries passes first reading
Minister of Internal Affairs Brooke van Velden says the Government is moving at pace to ensure lotteries for charitable purposes are allowed to operate online permanently. Charities fundraising online, such as those run by the Heart Foundation, Coastguard NZ, Auckland Rescue Helicopter Trust and local hospices will continue to do ...13 hours ago
- Tax exempt threshold changes to benefit startups
Technology companies are among the startups which will benefit from increases to current thresholds of exempt employee share schemes, Science, Innovation and Technology Minister Judith Collins and Revenue Minister Simon Watts say. Tax exempt thresholds for the schemes are increasing as part of the Taxation (Annual Rates for 2024-25, Emergency ...13 hours ago
- Getting the healthcare you need, when you need it
The path to faster cancer treatment, an increase in immunisation rates, shorter stays in emergency departments and quick assessment and treatments when you are sick has been laid out today. Health Minister Dr Shane Reti has revealed details of how the ambitious health targets the Government has set will be ...17 hours ago
- Targeted supports to accelerate reading
The coalition Government is delivering targeted and structured literacy supports to accelerate learning for struggling readers. From Term 1 2025, $33 million of funding for Reading Recovery and Early Literacy Support will be reprioritised to interventions which align with structured approaches to teaching. “Structured literacy will change the way children ...17 hours ago
- Survivors invited to Abuse in Care national apology
With two months until the national apology to survivors of abuse in care, expressions of interest have opened for survivors wanting to attend. “The Prime Minister will deliver a national apology on Tuesday 12 November in Parliament. It will be a very significant day for survivors, their families, whānau and ...19 hours ago
- Rangatahi inspire at Ngā Manu Kōrero final
Ehara taku toa i te toa takitahi, engari he toa takitini kē - My success is not mine alone but is the from the strength of the many. Aotearoa New Zealand’s top young speakers are an inspiration for all New Zealanders to learn more about the depth and beauty conveyed ...20 hours ago
- Driving structured literacy in schools
The coalition Government is driving confidence in reading and writing in the first years of schooling. “From the first time children step into the classroom, we’re equipping them and teachers with the tools they need to be brilliant in literacy. “From 1 October, schools and kura with Years 0-3 will receive ...1 day ago
- Labour’s misleading information is disappointing
Labour’s misinformation about firearms law is dangerous and disappointing, Associate Justice Minister Nicole McKee says. “Labour and Ginny Andersen have repeatedly said over the past few days that the previous Labour Government completely banned semi-automatic firearms in 2019 and that the Coalition Government is planning to ‘reintroduce’ them. ...1 day ago
- Govt takes action on mpox response, widens access to vaccine
The Government is taking immediate action on a number of steps around New Zealand’s response to mpox, including improving access to vaccine availability so people who need it can do so more easily, Health Minister Dr Shane Reti and Associate Health Minister David Seymour announced today. “Mpox is obviously a ...2 days ago
- Next steps agreed for Treaty Principles Bill
Associate Justice Minister David Seymour says Cabinet has agreed to the next steps for the Treaty Principles Bill. “The Treaty Principles Bill provides an opportunity for Parliament, rather than the courts, to define the principles of the Treaty, including establishing that every person is equal before the law,” says Mr Seymour. “Parliament ...2 days ago
- Government unlocking potential of AI
Science, Innovation and Technology Minister Judith Collins today announced a programme to drive Artificial Intelligence (AI) uptake among New Zealand businesses. “The AI Activator will unlock the potential of AI for New Zealand businesses through a range of support, including access to AI research experts, technical assistance, AI tools and resources, ...2 days ago
- Government releases Wairoa flood review findings
The independent rapid review into the Wairoa flooding event on 26 June 2024 has been released, Environment Minister Penny Simmonds, Local Government Minister Simeon Brown and Emergency Management and Recovery Minister Mark Mitchell announced today. “We welcome the review’s findings and recommendations to strengthen Wairoa's resilience against future events,” Ms ...2 days ago
- Promoting faster payment times for government
The Government is sending a clear message to central government agencies that they must prioritise paying invoices in a timely manner, Small Business and Manufacturing Minister Andrew Bayly says. Data released today promotes transparency by publishing the payment times of each central government agency. This data will be published quarterly ...2 days ago
- Acknowledgement to Kīngi Tuheitia speech
E te māngai o te Whare Pāremata, kua riro māku te whakaputa i te waka ki waho moana. E te Pirimia tēnā koe.Mr Speaker, it is my privilege to take this adjournment kōrero forward. Prime Minister – thank you for your leadership. Taupiri te maunga Waikato te awa Te Wherowhero ...3 days ago
- Interim fix to GST adjustment rules to support businesses
Inland Revenue can begin processing GST returns for businesses affected by a historic legislative drafting error, Revenue Minister Simon Watts says. “Inland Revenue has become aware of a legislative drafting error in the GST adjustment rules after changes were made in 2023 which were meant to simplify the process. This ...3 days ago
- Strong uptake for cervical screening self-test
More than 80 per cent of New Zealand women being tested have opted for a world-leading self-test for cervical screening since it became available a year ago. Minister of Health Dr Shane Reti and Associate Minister Casey Costello, in her responsibility for Women’s Health, say it’s fantastic to have such ...3 days ago
- Ministry for Regulation’s first Strategic Intentions document sets ambitious direction
Regulation Minister David Seymour welcomes the Ministry for Regulation’s first Strategic Intentions document, which sets out how the Ministry will carry out its work and deliver on its purpose. “I have set up the Ministry for Regulation with three tasks. One, to cut existing red tape with sector reviews. Two, ...3 days ago
- Māori Education Advisory Group established
The Education Minister has established a Māori Education Ministerial Advisory Group made up of experienced practitioners to help improve outcomes for Māori learners. “This group will provide independent advice on all matters related to Māori education in both English medium and Māori medium settings. It will focus on the most impactful ways we can lift ...3 days ago
- Government welcomes findings of NZ Superannuation Fund review
The Government has welcomed the findings of the recent statutory review into the Guardians of New Zealand Superannuation and the New Zealand Superannuation Fund, Minister of Finance Nicola Willis says. The 5-yearly review, conducted on behalf of Treasury and tabled in Parliament today, found the Guardians of New Zealand Superannuation ...3 days ago
- First of five new Hercules aircraft takes flight
Defence Minister Judith Collins today welcomed the first of five new C-130J-30 Hercules to arrive in New Zealand at a ceremony at the Royal New Zealand Air Force’s Base Auckland, Whenuapai. “This is an historic day for our New Zealand Defence Force (NZDF) and our nation. The new Hercules fleet ...3 days ago
- Have your say on suicide prevention
Today, September 10 is World Suicide Prevention Day, a time to reflect on New Zealand’s confronting suicide statistics, Mental Health Minister Matt Doocey says. “Every death by suicide is a tragedy – a tragedy that affects far too many of our families and communities in New Zealand. We must do ...3 days ago
- Action to grow the rural health workforce
Scholarships awarded to 27 health care students is another positive step forward to boost the future rural health workforce, Associate Health Minister Matt Doocey says. “All New Zealanders deserve timely access to quality health care and this Government is committed to improving health outcomes, particularly for the one in five ...4 days ago
- Pharmac delivering more for Kiwis following major funding boost
Associate Health Minister with responsibility for Pharmac David Seymour has welcomed the increased availability of medicines for Kiwis resulting from the Government’s increased investment in Pharmac. “Pharmac operates independently, but it must work within the budget constraints set by the Government,” says Mr Seymour. “When our Government assumed office, New ...4 days ago
- Sport Minister congratulates NZ’s Paralympians
Sport & Recreation Minister Chris Bishop has congratulated New Zealand's Paralympic Team at the conclusion of the Paralympic Games in Paris. “The NZ Paralympic Team's success in Paris included fantastic performances, personal best times, New Zealand records and Oceania records all being smashed - and of course, many Kiwis on ...4 days ago
- Government progresses response to Abuse in Care recommendations
A Crown Response Office is being established within the Public Service Commission to drive the Government’s response to the Royal Commission into Abuse in Care. “The creation of an Office within a central Government agency was a key recommendation by the Royal Commission’s final report. “It will have the mandate ...7 days ago
- Passport wait times back on-track
Minister of Internal Affairs Brooke van Velden says passport processing has returned to normal, and the Department of Internal Affairs [Department] is now advising customers to allow up to two weeks to receive their passport. “I am pleased that passport processing is back at target service levels and the Department ...7 days ago
- New appointments to the FMA board
Commerce and Consumer Affairs Minister has today announced three new appointments and one reappointment to the Financial Markets Authority (FMA) board. Tracey Berry, Nicholas Hegan and Mariette van Ryn have been appointed for a five-year term ending in August 2029, while Chris Swasbrook, who has served as a board member ...7 days ago
- District Court judges appointed
Attorney-General Hon Judith Collins today announced the appointment of two new District Court judges. The appointees, who will take up their roles at the Manukau Court and the Auckland Court in the Accident Compensation Appeal Jurisdiction, are: Jacqui Clark Judge Clark was admitted to the bar in 1988 after graduating ...7 days ago
- Government makes it faster and easier to invest in New Zealand
Associate Minister of Finance David Seymour is encouraged by significant improvements to overseas investment decision timeframes, and the enhanced interest from investors as the Government continues to reform overseas investment. “There were about as many foreign direct investment applications in July and August as there was across the six months ...7 days ago
- New Zealand to join Operation Olympic Defender
New Zealand has accepted an invitation to join US-led multi-national space initiative Operation Olympic Defender, Defence Minister Judith Collins announced today. Operation Olympic Defender is designed to coordinate the space capabilities of member nations, enhance the resilience of space-based systems, deter hostile actions in space and reduce the spread of ...1 week ago
- Government commits to ‘stamping out’ foot and mouth disease
Biosecurity Minister Andrew Hoggard says that a new economic impact analysis report reinforces this government’s commitment to ‘stamp out’ any New Zealand foot and mouth disease incursion. “The new analysis, produced by the New Zealand Institute of Economic Research, shows an incursion of the disease in New Zealand would have ...1 week ago
- Improving access to finance for Kiwis
5 September 2024 The Government is progressing further reforms to financial services to make it easier for Kiwis to access finance when they need it, Commerce and Consumer Affairs Minister Andrew Bayly says. “Financial services are foundational for economic success and are woven throughout our lives. Without access to finance our ...1 week ago
- Prime Minister pays tribute to Kiingi Tuheitia
As Kiingi Tuheitia Pootatau Te Wherowhero VII is laid to rest today, Prime Minister Christopher Luxon has paid tribute to a leader whose commitment to Kotahitanga will have a lasting impact on our country. “Kiingi Tuheitia was a humble leader who served his people with wisdom, mana and an unwavering ...1 week ago
- Resource Management reform to make forestry rules clearer
Forestry Minister Todd McClay today announced proposals to reform the resource management system that will provide greater certainty for the forestry sector and help them meet environmental obligations. “The Government has committed to restoring confidence and certainty across the sector by removing unworkable regulatory burden created by the previous ...1 week ago
- More choice and competition in building products
A major shake-up of building products which will make it easier and more affordable to build is on the way, Building and Construction Minister Chris Penk says. “Today we have introduced legislation that will improve access to a wider variety of quality building products from overseas, giving Kiwis more choice and ...1 week ago
- Joint Statement between the Republic of Korea and New Zealand 4 September 2024, Seoul
On the occasion of the official visit by the Right Honourable Prime Minister Christopher Luxon of New Zealand to the Republic of Korea from 4 to 5 September 2024, a summit meeting was held between His Excellency President Yoon Suk Yeol of the Republic of Korea (hereinafter referred to as ...1 week ago
- Comprehensive Strategic Partnership the goal for New Zealand and Korea
Prime Minister Christopher Luxon held a bilateral meeting today with the President of the Republic of Korea, Yoon Suk Yeol. “Korea and New Zealand are likeminded democracies and natural partners in the Indo Pacific. As such, we have decided to advance discussions on elevating the bilateral relationship to a Comprehensive ...1 week ago
- International tourism continuing to bounce back
Results released today from the International Visitor Survey (IVS) confirm international tourism is continuing to bounce back, Tourism and Hospitality Minister Matt Doocey says. The IVS results show that in the June quarter, international tourism contributed $2.6 billion to New Zealand’s economy, an increase of 17 per cent on last ...1 week ago
- Couple convicted of exploiting Pacific migrants have convictions thrown out
By Anusha Bradley, RNZ investigative reporter A Hamilton couple convicted of exploiting Pacific migrants have had their convictions quashed after the New Zealand’s Court of Appeal ruled there had been a miscarriage of justice. Anthony Swarbrick and Christina Kewa-Swarbrick were found guilty on nine representative charges of aiding and abetting, ...5 hours ago - Exceptional new fish fossil sparks rethink of how Earth’s geology drives evolution
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Alice Clement, Research Associate in the College of Science and Engineering, Flinders University An illustration of the _Ngamugawi wirngarri_ coelacanth in its natural habitat Katrina Kenny Coelacanths are deep-sea fish that live off the coasts of southern Africa and Indonesia and can ...6 hours ago
- Grattan on Friday: Coalition backs Labor’s heavy lifting on aged care, hoping to reap the benefit ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra In agreeing earlier to the Albanese government’s changes to the NDIS and now endorsing its aged care reforms, Peter Dutton is calculating it’s easier for Labor than the Coalition to find big savings that produce ...6 hours ago
- Open letters on Gaza that The Press shunned – the Handala protest
Pacific Media Watch Two open letters on the genocidal Israeli war against Palestinian sent to The Press for publication that have been ignored in the continued Aotearoa New Zealand media silence over 11 months of atrocities. Both letters have been sent to the Christchurch morning daily newspaper by the co-presenter ...6 hours ago
- Experts sceptical health targets can be met without extra funding
Health Minister Shane Reti says he has been assured by Health NZ commissioner Lester Levy the targets can be met within existing funding. ...7 hours ago - Call for inquiry into NZ intelligence Gaza links
A group of legal experts has asked the spy watchdog to investigate whether New Zealand intelligence is aiding Israel’s war in Gaza, arguing there is a “plausible case” that the country is complicit in breaches of international law.Concern over the situation in Gaza is growing as the war’s one-year anniversary ...8 hours ago - Does the Albanese government’s proposed ‘hate speech’ law give us what we need?
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Luke McNamara, Professor, UNSW Sydney Back in May, the Albanese government told us to expect strict new hate speech laws. In its bill introduced to parliament this week, though, the government has stepped back from the plan to criminalise racist hate ...8 hours ago
- The government has a new plan for residential aged care. Here’s what’s changing
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Nicole Sutton, Associate Professor of Accounting, University of Technology Sydney In Green/Shutterstock After months of negotiations between the major parties, the government has announced it will implement the Aged Care Taskforce recommendations. The government already signalled back in March that ...8 hours ago
- South Waikato District Council considers whether to fund Tokoroa Santa parade
South Waikato District Council next week will debate whether Anzac memorial events and Christmas parades are core council business they should help fund - or not. ...9 hours ago
- Treasury urged govt to scrap Gumboot Friday funding, delay changes to tax package
Investment was "better directed to preventative initiatives", officials said ahead of this year's Budget. ...9 hours ago
- Sneesby’s resignation from Nine points to host of problems besetting commercial TV networks
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Denis Muller, Senior Research Fellow, Centre for Advancing Journalism, The University of Melbourne Mike Sneesby’s resignation as chief executive of the Nine Entertainment Company completes a cleanout at the top of an organisation besieged by the consequences of cultural toxicity. These consequences ...9 hours ago
- Ministry for Regulation sets out timetable for action
The new ministry has laid out some time frames for getting things done. ...10 hours ago
- Farm fences trouble turtles in search of water. Here’s how to help
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Eric Nordberg, Senior Lecturer (Applied Ecology and Landscape Management), University of New England Eric Nordberg Freshwater turtles live in farm dams, creeks and wetlands across Australia. They often travel over land when these wetlands or farm dams dry up, or during ...10 hours ago
- Kids under 13 use social media. How can parents help keep them safe online?
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Karley Beckman, Senior Lecturer in Digital Technologies for Learning, University of Wollongong Luiza Kamalova/Shutterstock , CC BY Earlier this week, the federal government announced it is going to introduce a social media ban for children. It hasn’t nominated a minimum ...10 hours ago
- Aged care reform: self-funded retirees and part-pensioners to pay more as government aims to shore u...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra Self-funded retirees and many part pensioners will pay more for their aged care under the government’s reform package, endorsed by the opposition and announced on Thursday. The changes involve a $930 million extra spend ...10 hours ago
- Instead of banning kids from online spaces, here’s what we should offer them instead
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Amanda Third, Co-Director, Young and Resilient Research Centre/Professorial Research Fellow, Institute for Culture and Society, Western Sydney University Banning children under 16 from social media sounds like a seductive idea. For overwhelmed parents navigating their kids’ lives in a digital age, this ...11 hours ago
- Age care changes will hit self-funded retirees and many part pensioners to sustain the system long t...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra Self-funded retirees and many part pensioners will pay more for their aged care under the government’s reform package, endorsed by the opposition and announced on Thursday. The changes involve a $930 million extra spend ...11 hours ago
- New polling: half of Australians want gambling ads banned entirely; LNP has big Queensland lead
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Adrian Beaumont, Election Analyst (Psephologist) at The Conversation; and Honorary Associate, School of Mathematics and Statistics, The University of Melbourne A national Resolve poll for Nine newspapers, conducted September 3–7 from a sample of 1,614 people, gave Labor a 51–49% lead using ...12 hours ago
- Facebook has scraped public data from Australian users without an opt out. What can we do?
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Heather Ford, Associate Professor, University of Technology Sydney vectorfusionart/Shutterstock Facebook acknowledged in a Senate inquiry yesterday that it is scraping the public photos of Australian users to train its artificial intelligence (AI) models. Facebook’s parent company Meta claims this excludes ...12 hours ago
- Long-overdue Australian privacy law reform is here – and it’s still not fit for the digital era
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Katharine Kemp, Associate Professor, Faculty of Law & Justice; Lead, UNSW Public Interest Law & Tech Initiative, UNSW Sydney Wirestock Creators/Shutterstock Almost four years since the Privacy Act review commenced, the Australian government has introduced a reform bill that fails to ...12 hours ago
- Which gut drugs might end up in a lawsuit? Are there really links with cancer and kidney disease? Sh...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Nial Wheate, Professor and Director – Academic Excellence, Macquarie University Doucefleur/Shutterstock Common medicines used to treat conditions including heartburn, reflux, indigestion and stomach ulcers may be the subject of a class action lawsuit in Australia. Lawyers are exploring whether long-term use ...12 hours ago
- PNG’s Marape remains PM after no confidence vote against him fails
By Scott Waide, RNZ Pacific PNG correspondent Papua New Guinea’s Prime Minister James Marape has successfully thwarted a vote of no confidence after 75 MPs backed him and 32 voted for the opposition. But the session was not without drama. Just after 10am, after the opposition leader moved a motion ...12 hours ago
- In sports-mad Australia, new research suggests physical education can be undervalued at school
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Casey Peter Mainsbridge, Senior Lecturer in Personal Devlopment, Health and Physical Education, University of New England WBMUL/Shutterstock Sport is a significant part of Australian culture and for many represents national pride and social connection. So, it would be fair to ...13 hours ago
- The House: Analysing government answers on guns
Even when ministers are trying not to answer questions, they frequently give away a lot of information, writes Phil Smith for The House. ...13 hours ago
- ‘Insane, ridiculous and gross’: Under the skin of local body horror Grafted
Alex Casey talks to the creative team behind Grafted, a skin-crawling new local body horror. There’s a crumbling empty McMansion somewhere in Coatesville that became the “beating heart” of new local body horror Grafted, director Sasha Rainbow tells me. “When you walked in there, it had this creepy feeling, like ...14 hours ago - NZ concern over China-linked Pacific cyber breach
The Government is concerned by news of a cyber attack linked to the Chinese government against the Pacific Islands Forum secretariat , with the Asian superpower vehemently denying the claims.Newsroom understands the forum secretariat called in Australian cybersecurity experts in February over a potential cyber attack against its network.After investigating ...14 hours ago
- Alex Greenwich’s defamation win against Mark Latham shows political spite is not above the law
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Rick Sarre, Emeritus Professor of Law and Criminal Justice, University of South Australia Independent Sydney MP Alex Greenwich has been awarded $140,000 in his defamation suit against One Nation New South Wales leader Mark Latham over a homophobic tweet. Latham posted ...14 hours ago
- Auckland Mayor Wayne Brown proposes Point Chevalier-North Shore bridge
Wayne Brown is urging the government to build bridge from Pt Chevalier to the North Shore. ...16 hours ago
- Should school nurses weigh students? We asked 5 experts
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Fron Jackson-Webb, Deputy Editor and Senior Health Editor Drazen Zigic/Shutterstock One in four Australian children aged two to 17 are classified as above a healthy weight, based on their body mass index (or BMI, which is weight divided by height squared). ...16 hours ago
- Understanding risks for Australia of China’s slowing economy is Chalmers’ top priority at upcomi...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By James Laurenceson, Director and Professor, Australia-China Relations Institute (ACRI), University of Technology Sydney SURKED/Shutterstock When Treasurer Jim Chalmers travels to Beijing later this month, he and his counterpart at China’s peak economic agency, the National Development and Reform Commission, won’t be ...16 hours ago
- Kid Snow takes a stab at exploring masculinity in the gritty outback, but fails to land
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Gemma Blackwood, Lecturer, Media, University of Tasmania Madman Director Paul Goldman’s new Australian film Kid Snow is set in the gritty, male-dominated world of tent boxing in outback Western Australia. The film presents itself as a reflection on the intergenerational ...16 hours ago
- Darleen Tana says Greens broke own constitution by asking her to resign
Lawyers for the former Green Party MP are making their case that she was ejected from the party unlawfully. ...16 hours ago
- The inside scoop on being a teenager in a 700-person town
Phitcha, the star of the latest episode of Takeout Kids, tells Alex Casey about coming of age in the small tourist town of Akaroa. It’s very hard not to be charmed by Akaroa, the small Banks Peninsula town with a population of just 770 people. Best known for frolicking dolphins, ...16 hours ago
- Single-sex or co-ed? How to pick the right school for your child
While some academic results might put single-gender schools in the lead, there is much more to consider than test results. ...16 hours ago
- Blowing the dust off NZ’s ‘founding documents’ reveals the hold they still have on today’s T...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Paul Moon, Professor of History, Auckland University of Technology Getty Images There is power in paper. Anyone who denies the potency of history’s dusty documents needs only look at the current incendiary debates over proposed legislation tackling the “principles” of the ...16 hours ago
- New ministry spending more than $400,000 on contractors
A new ministry set up to slash red tape spent more than $400,000 on contractors in six months. ...17 hours ago
- Māori health leaders demand government kill Treaty Principles Bill
Māori health leaders are calling on the government to scrap the Treaty Principles Bill, fearing it will lead to even less equitable healthcare. ...17 hours ago
- Former Cabinet minister Aussie Malcolm dies
The former National MP and businessman was 83. ...17 hours ago
- Was the Trump-Harris debate an election game-changer?
An in-control Kamala Harris won the night by baiting her opponent into increasingly incoherent rage. And then Taylor Swift weighed in. This is an excerpt from The World Bulletin, our weekly global current affairs newsletter exclusively for Spinoff Members. Sign up here. Trump takes the bait The debate’s first question ...18 hours ago
- Watch: Health Minister announces details on government’s new health targets
Shane Reti has laid out a plan for achieving the government's big health goals. ...18 hours ago
I'm picking there's about 200 people in ohakune and raetihi seriously looking at oz about now because the last 3 governments where so useless they can't keep the lights on, having just bought my 1st home since I fell out of the housing market I'm shitting myself as to what's going to happen to house values,
Didn;t know what you were referring to until I just saw this on The Kākā by Bernard Hickey
The flow on will be huge , young family man a golf with, the mills 75% of his work , the 3 man logging crew doing some trees for us are probably going to be told to stop 7 months early.
Cheers PB selfish boss forced me into it , had a plan in hand that would have been far cheaper, but needs must.
It is a turn of the interest rate curve. Look out for the best one year rate in the next 3 months. By 2026 the rates will be down to 4to 5 %You will always be better off than renting. Cheers.
Rates may drop for awhile but they will start moving back by market forces. Owning great as long as u don't do any maintenance
Listen to the first 20 minutes of The Panel on RNZ yesterday (wednesday) and you will hear the exasperation in the voices about why Oz has 30 percent of houses with solar power and NZ has 2 per cent.
If Jacinda hadn't had COVID to deal with and had been a 9-yeat PM she would have sorted this.
Labour MUST run on a solar power with battery storage attached platform in 2 years ..there are votes in this because it is the right thing to do.
Jacinda was the one who created this mess! Though I don't agree with everything this govt is doing, at least they are doing something to try and fix the mess the last Government made, who were very likely the worst Govt NZ has ever had!
Housing availability and cost of living is biting hard across the ditch.
However the bipartisan approach to education, health and infrastructure through the state/federal system across Oz sees them so far ahead.
Someone should Photoshop the key billboard from 08 with luxon saying goodbye to the loved ones as that's exactly what hes done.
Yeah, but aussie has a different scale. Or is at a different stage.
I grew up in Auckland, lived here most of my life apart from a year wandering around on farms and in the army followed by a stint in Hamilton for university, and then few years later a stint in Dunedin for university. I had a rule after watching my mother doing uni in Auckland – never do that!
I realised a few years ago that I can’t really afford to live in any of houses that I grew up in Auckland. I have an apartment with my partner just off the end of K Rd and Ponsonby Rd. It is virtually opposite the flat that I was born in on the opposite side of Newton Gully. It used to be the slum, as was 3 Lamps in Ponsonby, Mt Albert was solidly working class, Kingsland was a slum. I couldn’t have afforded to buy any of them for at least the last decade.
I have up until this year earned well within the upper few percent of salary earners in NZ for at least the last 20 years. I could afford the apartment because it has no no significiant land. All of the houses I have ever lived in Auckland now have at least a million dollars of land value in their sections alone. That is at least 10 years of nett earnings, assuming that I concentrated on land alone and forgot to eat. And those aren’t even large plots of land.
The land values in Aussie are nowhere near as bad relative to income. Even in places like Sydney.
The problem is that land values are related to the infrastructure investment attached to them. Effectively the location isn’t so much as where it is, it is what it is related to. Where I live is now perfect for everything except work. Because of the land values and the leases involved those engineering industries that I like working for are further away in 3 different directions. North, South and East. Those jobs at peak hour traffic are now an hour away. Only 10-15km, but anything from a 1.5 hour to 2.5 hour commute per day.
I could move to ChCh or Hamilton where the traffic isn’t too bad and where there are interesting engineering firms. But my partner moved to Auckland because it was the only city in NZ that supports what she is interested in working on. Pity she dislikes Aussie after living there for a while – she has met the worst of Australians – the average ones. I certainly don’t want to move to either LA or the UK.
Guess I will be writing a lot of open source in our centrally situated apartment 🙂
All the best to you both.
Thanks for your observation. Mentioned Sydney as an example, but isn't it expensive too ( have never been there) , so based on secondary data? Many are moving to Brisbane, specifically Sunshine coast cos weather, cost of living etc. But you are right the way Auckland prices are now for land.
If you look carefully at my comment, it wasn't about land prices, it was about commute times and the access between homes and work.
Most of the Aussie cities have commuter towns with reasonable transport, both public and personal vehicles.
The problem with Auckland is that we live on an isthmus between two harbours. That provides a massive issue for road transport as we keep pumping migrants into the urban area.
In 1990, I had a job in Manakau City while living in Central Auckland. That is about 23km. I could commute that in about 20-30 minutes at peak traffic most days by car. That compares to about 45-65 minutes now. Back then it was about 50 minutes by bus. Now it is about an hour by train (when it is running).
So then I wound up with a 40 minute to 60 minute daily commute, these days it is about 90-130 minutes. Note that this is going against the prevailing traffic.
That is supposing there was no serious accidents.
That is a good route. They added SH16/SH20 which more than doubled the capacity going south.
Going west, east and north have much worse times. Wellington has much less population, and overall better public transport system – but has the same kinds of constraints on land for housing and transport to move around.
Christchurch, Sydney, Melbourne, Brisbane, or Perth are less constrained by topography. They also make it easier to live and work from commuterville.
Melbourne sydney and Brisbane all have massive rail upgrades to cope with their growth underway.
Cycleways have helped, especially in flat Melbourne. Whereas here as you point out a bad situation is only getting worse.
Some parts of the system are now pretty good.
I drove down to Morningside station at 1550, parked and hopped on the train at 1604 (ie the end of school and the start of rush hours). Took 15 minutes to get to Glen Eden. Same on the way back a few hours later.
The interval between trains was something like 10 minutes. The AT mobile app was dead accurate. Train was probably half full.
I would have taken the e-bike to Morningside. But I wasn't sure about the arrangements on the train – which turned out to be easy. Also biking down the roads from home to Morningside Station is really dangerous in the rush hours traffic.
Right now that would take 20 minutes by car from Morningside station to Glen Eden station. Google estimates that it would be 22-50 minutes by car on Thursday at 1600.
Can't wait until they get the K Rd station open. There is a cycle lane down K Rd.
Hopefully Cubic* will do a good job on the Hop card replacement. I loved that the AT Hop dongle that I last used in 2022 just tagged on and off perfectly using the ~$100 I’d left on it.
On Friday, I went down and got the AT Hop Gold dongle! First thing I have found to use the SuperGold card on.
Not everyone is unhappy.
High income earners and property investors are doing very nicely thank you very much.
Now how much of the population does that cover?
10% at the very very most?
Just what we thought would happen under the CoC.
The 10% have it nicely set up to make a mint.
Everyone else gets sod all.
As Bomber on TDB might say: You muppets voted National!
Spare a thought for those of us permanently trapped here with no escape possible
Yeah. My sympathies. I suspect that I will be staying here in Auckland at least until we figure out something that both of us can agree to.
But everything is paid off. There is a large dollop of cash in various investments. I get super and a SuperGold. Finally found a use for that, just have to get a AT gold key dongle and I can ride the local rails with the e-bike.
I can keep an eye out for an interesting job that can use my skills and that won't suck up all of my time.
I have a pile of ideas to code for open-source or light commercial.
Epic.
LPrent you sound liberated.
The Wanaka-Wakanda-Elysium shtick we did is an early version of many multiple degree couples we know who've escaped to London and Canberra after being canned in Wellington.
The remaining core of our R&D is in our public servants, and Luxon has gutted them, and us.
I think this is worse than Bolger-Richardson.
Interesting to see Tony Alexander singing the same tune. hat-tip: Kat
"Tony Alexander: Rock star economy? More like economy on the rocks"
Etc.
The other issue is that we have a very strong export tech sector that has developed over the past 30 years. It is probably out 3rd biggest export profit earner (farming hasn't actually made large profits for decades now).
Right now that is pretty quiescent simply because it is watching to see what policy screwups NAct1 actually will do in the tech and science sectors. I'm having a look around to see what Judith Collins has been doing after her disastrous start … described here "Never mind the roads, fix the potholes in R&D funding"
Looks like a Endeavour Fund Investment Plan is ok.
Just as an example if you look at stats "New Zealand business sector R&D expenditure reaches $3.7 billion" from business sector expenditure as a scale factor. That is mostly as a result of Research and Development Tax Incentive. Looks like that hasn't changed.
Callaghan Innovation looks ok as well.
Personally I could only ever trust Judith Collins to screw things up. But she doesn't appear to have done so this time.
Labour made a big mistake pandering to business (and National) demand for workers post pandemic borders – and the related lack of management of who was coming in etc. Not only did we get migrants without jobs in hardship, we had the rent hikes and high OCR to suppress demand.
Do you recall that year we had no one to do our horticulture and hospitality? We had 3.1% unemployed and apples rotting on the ground.
Yes. Horticultures and hospitalties inefficient business model, of exploiting migrant and temporary visa workers to cover their lack of business viability, subsidised by the rest of us, was exposed to sunlight!
Better known as our export economy. Pays lots of tax.
"Pays lots of tax". How?
Ah no. You're doing the Shane Jones thing, conflating export revenues with profit. Yes there may be profits somewhere. Probably mostly in banks and largely exported to offshore shareholders. But taxes – definitely not.
The amount of tax paid by the all kinds of farmers in 2020/2021 tax year which wasn't a bad year for agriculture was minuscule. There was an OIA on it. 2021/22 would have been a bit better. The last few years would have been far worse.
Less than $1.5 billion out of a total tax take of $23.9 billion across all sector industries. There are caveats on the data-collection, but it covered GST, PAYE, Income Tax via various kinds of entities.
If you look at scale, the total assessed tax revenue from all sources in 2021 was 93.8 billion.
There is probably other tax collected in processing and shipping. But it is unlikely to be that high. Similarly there will be taxes from direct suppliers to farming.
But over all, I'd be surprised if the total tax received from all sources related to agriculture exceeds the range of $3-5 billion. ie roughly 3-5% of the central tax take.
The processing plants and trucking aren't particularly high profit, they automate highly, and the number of people employed isn't high compared to the overall PAYE. People who work on farms including fencers, spreaders of fertilizer, and even vets aren't paid that much.
There will be local taxes. However I would tend to discount them as they're mainly used in rural areas for maintaining the non-state highway rural roading network.
Meh, how many of the migrant workers allowed in worked in hospitality and horticulture …
That was the work of tourists and seasonal workers – some of that need due to the lack of utilisation of harvesting tech.
The unemployed are not going to move to areas either without housing (camper van Queenstown) or only seasonal work.
Only partly true. We also had over production and more to sell than markets to sell to. Some orchardists had also not up-dated their trees to modern varieties. You're not going to pay to pick apples you have no market for.
All horticulture areas over produce. Many vegetable growers are paid to bulldoze the surplus – lower prices versus guaranteed payment ever since the auction houses went.
You have to over produce in case some of the crop gets wiped out e.g. hail risk. That is clearly preferable to having to cancel orders.
Yeah the outflow of citizens and inflow of migrants is telling.
The 4th big outflow. First late 1970's (no longer a UK farm economy limitation – the pavlova paradise now a past golden age). Second 1990's (unemployment and low wage growth – leading to their 2001 rule change). The third post earthquakes (c2012 era – insurance payouts).
Oz is doing infrastructure better (PT and energy – solar and battery). And its paying salaries sufficient to keep its health system functional.
A bit like "degrowth" winding back consumption and carbon dioxide release?
Surely we should be celebrating that?
Ah stirring..
Degrowth is a bit of a myth beloved of the right who also seem to be in love with survivalist tropes and people who don’t understand history. You can't do it rapidly unless you want to have a rapid human diebacks, which typically will involve conflicts. Those generally release copious quantities of CO2.
The trick about CO2 reduction is to find alternative ways to generate power that don't require burning fossil carbon to release energy from C-H bonds. You can't do that kind of investment if you don't have surplus capital to do it. For instance putting in solar, wind, geothermal, or hydro power systems.
Of course the problem in NZ is that we don't do that because of the Max Bradford stupidity in our 'deregulated' power systems which prioritise extracting profit and capital out of existing assets, producing generating capacity, and actively preventing household generation.
If we want to reduce greenhouse gases rapidly, the a different course should be taken. That is to reduce methane and nitrous oxide emissions which will have nearly immediate climate cooling effects. To do that we just have to correctly tax farming of emissions from rumens and nitrate fertilisers to encourage farmers to either reduce emissions or stop farming those polluting activities.
https://climatenetwork.org/resource/fossil-of-the-day-3-december-new-zealand-japan-usa/
Cluxon's on the case!
Replacing gas with electric appliances was one of the first things I did at my home. Healthier, safer, better for the climate and cooking with induction is superior to a gas stove*.
How much is the standing charge for a gas connection nowadays? At least $1.50 / day?
Did the change over 10 years ago, so that saved me over $5,000 just in standing charges. Even from a financial point it makes sense.
And we reduced our meat & dairy consumption by 90%.
___
* Cooked daily with gas over 10 years and now over 10 years with induction. When cooking at my partner's parents' place, with gas, it just strikes you how backward a gas stove really is: With induction, no need for a kettle to heat water, no need for a slow cooker to avoid burning food… much more relaxing experience when "entertaining guests" while cooking.
My latest toy is a hot water dispenser. Cost me about $140 on special from Farmers.
I drink a lot of coffee when coding. This is way more efficient than a kettle because it only heats the water as it measures it out. Also I can set it to do the 92C I want for coffee. Just have to fill the 2.7 litre flask at the rear about once a day.
Ah! So "degenerative" farming. Next Farmers will be taking up Coding … and flooding that market.
Personally I would prefer that farmers just pay the full costs of what they generate. In the longer term that would cause a massive increase in innovation to control it.
In the short term it’d separate the efficient farmers from the inefficient ones, and cause farmers to get serious about value-added exports rather than simply shipping commodity product.
FFS have you ever closely looked at the profitability of farming in NZ. It absolutely sucks.
That they pollute like crazy is just a typical side-effect of their inherent inefficiency. Farming in NZ should be able to run pretty close to a closed cycle.
But at present they have no incentives to do so. So they remain at the vagaries of pricing on world markets and live hand-to-mouth hoping for good seasons to survive, and making bank rich from interest payments.
They make their profit eventually from what are effectively speculative capital gains after they sell and retire.
Yeah! I know this only too well. After the start of the Key govt with their hatred of the Public Service and the slashing of jobs. Remember the ad – "Stop waving goodbye to your loved ones". What a load of BS that was! My family immediately lost their jobs. Our son-in law is a qualified specialist in after care for persons suffering brain trauma. Aussie welcomed him with increased salary and permanent employment. He's now managing the total operation for the whole of Perth WA. He also serves on a panel advising the state Governor on care for homeless and care for the mentally ill. The family have taken Aussie citizenship. My daughter with Masters(Hons) in both science and community development is involved in education in Perth. So great work by the Nats sending our best and brightest offshore.
They specifically said that too –
Social Development and Employment Minister Louise Upston has admitted New Zealand could lose some of its "best and brightest" overseas while in recession.
Upston said Treasury was forecasting jobseeker numbers to go up, hitting a peak next January.
"People who are in that set of circumstances, and I really feel for them, have to make some tough choices, and for some that may well mean that we lose a range of people, including some of our best and brightest, offshore," she said.
Upston said job losses were the reality of being in a recession, which she blamed on decisions the previous government made…
Labour leader Chris Hipkins said it was a government's job to make New Zealand a place people wanted to live, work, and stay.
"To see a senior government minister predicting that we're going to have a brain drain, and effectively shrugging their shoulders and saying 'oh that would be a rational choice on the part of the people leaving the country' is pretty disgraceful really," he said.
https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/political/512721/recession-could-lead-to-brain-drain-employment-minister-louise-upston-says
I'm still very intrigued by all the government picks for MSD Ministers. Certainly since 1990 they've all been female- a political ploy because traditionally women are seen as more nurturing/kind? Or because all the Male MPs refuse to do it?
Obviously, Jenny Shipley, Paula Bennet, Anne Tolley and now Upston knock that idea out of the water. Sepaloni could at least pretend to be caring, and tweak around the edges a bit to make our lives a bit more tolerable.
I stand by my observation for years now, that there is something seriously wrong with the Nat picks for MSD Minister (and currently Finance Minister)- there is simply no way on earth that any 'normal' person (male or female) would be capable of inflicting so much harm onto so many people without batting an eyelid, and can still sleep at night. Sociopathy is the only obvious reason.
I can't disagree with your analysis. It is a huge issue for NZ as people flood to the exit doors. But from a personal perspective I will be staying.
I'm 40 year old kiwi born and bred in the Waikato. I have lived in New Zealand, Australia and the UK. In my working life, it has always been more attractive to work outside of New Zealand. Over that time Australia has offered, better weather, higher wages, stronger unions, better infrastructure, public services and healthcare, and better Super.
But its not New Zealand. It doesn't have Manu Bay, it doesn't have Whakapapa and Cardrona, it doesn't have the Milford Track, it doesn't have the All Blacks and the Warriors, New Years at Whangamata with your mates on the beach, Matariki and Waitangi Day, Kapa Haka competitions, or Auckland 1A.
There is nobody in this country that wouldn't be better of financially if they moved abroad. But I for 1 stay for something bigger than that.
I’d definitely like to stay. Mostly I don’t think that I can stay in Auckland because of the housing prices and the commute issues.
I know what you mean. Living in Auckland is a fight for survival now. I don't know how people, on even good incomes, live there with the cost of property.
Have it paid off. Took a while. From 1998, through a leaky building rebuild (and eventual settlement from the council) until about 2017.
The NZ economy is getting it's version of 'shock therapy' – a significant and rapid increase in un-employment and the collapse of smaller business in the tens of thousands – so far. The economic purpose of this deliberate approach is to create an environment of cheap labor and distressed business assets that will draw investment into the economy.
But there is a silence from our media overall – it's not something they dwell on – the same stories about local crime, the All Blacks and entertainment figures etc. are most prominent.
The closure of Winstone Pulp International is a very significant economic story and it is now off the headlines in a day or less. In Hawkesbay the personal financial impact on those losing their jobs will be devastating. But the impact will spread further across the regions economy.
What are the implications for inflation overall if energy prices remain high? Energy is an input cost to almost everything else. Why is no-one in the business commentariat looking at this with concern? Is it because they all have shares in the power companies?
For all Shane Jones bluster he's made it obvious he plans to do nothing other than point the finger at others. Note that the government itself will benefit from the higher power company profits as a holder of shares. The whole situation seems really fucked up and no-one want's to talk about it.
If they have the scientists available – it is time to assess whether this dry and calm year is going to occur again any time soon.
Or just go big on solar now, as Oz has already. And this and battery storage is known to reduce power cost.
It looks to me based on the last couple of cycles like the ENSO is cycling faster. I think that this last year was mostly el nino -neutral here, heading to la nina now.
The ENSO forecast seems to point that way here and in the north.
But the climate is pretty damn variable at present. I think that we are just short of capacity to deal with the variability. We also have the wrong system for dispersing risks, it actually incentives living too close to the edge because that enhances profit.
House solar + battery is what I want. But I’ll have to wait until I own my own roof and garage. With apartments I have to deal with 60 other roof and garage owners.
Why would they want to reduce the cost of power? They’re there to make a profit, not provide cheap electricity.
They wouldn't. That's why we need the industry restructured.
To be fair to part of this government, Shane Jones seems to be pushing for that.
Worldwide recession and reserve bank induced. It isn't national causing the recession they have speed it up by reducing government spending but it needed to be reduced, the country isn't generating enough tax to support the services it already provides. Any larger taxes would impact everyone and cause further recessionary pressures so it is good they are instead reducing spending and cutting costs in the public sector.
They have sped it up, and extended its duration with excessive levels of austerity.
There was no need for larger income taxes. There was also no need to try to reduce taxes largely for the affluent alone. Which is effectively what was done.
Just shifting the tax boundaries with ‘block of cheese’ shifts in the lower brackets only would been sufficient. Or putting in a tax free bracket because the cost of getting taxes from anyone with little income is way too high relative to wajht is collected.
The country needs to have more taxes over the next few years because
Clearly your grasp of basic economics is severely limited. I’d suggest that you find a different economics primer.
Taxes that are paid to provide immediate services increase the velocity of money (usually measured by the number of times it circulates ina given time period), effectively increasing the efficiency of money in the economy. It makes little negative difference to the economy overall if paid to civil servants. It can made a large positive difference if the money is used to provide productive services and infrastructure.
In any case the usual problem with government spending is not recessionary, it is inflationary. That is because the government via the reserve bank can effectively create money. That is what its job is and effectively what the OCR is all about. That is potentially inflationary if it gets out of whack.
What taxes does do is to reduce the hoarding of money into static often speculative capital – like housing prices spirals. Hoarding without a productive use effectively withdraws money from the economy. That is recessionary and is the fundamental reason that we have a recession at present.
Basically we should have an effective capital gains tax, like every other developed nation does.
Anyway, if you ever stop being a cost accountant trying to discuss economics (which is what you sound like), then we can chat about economic reality.
BTW: there is currently not a world wide recession. The reserve bank hasn’t induced this recession, they are just trying to control the inflationary effects of having supported the country through a pandemic and the near cessation of most of the economy. National isn’t causing the recession, they are just making it worse and longer. That is because they are effectively have left the totally non-productive landlords able to make excessive profits in speculative house prices – they have freed up what capital gains controls we had, and donated the landlords relief from the cost of being taxes on interest they pay. Both will maintain and extend the unproductive tying up of capital in speculation of housing.
I said this lot would screw over the economy – if we slip into stagflation which I hope to God we don't. That is it folks, it will be official – the national party are, "the party of no idea about how an economy works".
You mean "Labour's induced recession", not National's.
Nope. The recession was a side-effect from the pandemic responses which triggered inflation and a deflationary response from the RBNZ, coupled with really shit prices for agriculture prices in 2023, and a couple of other structural problems with profits from ‘exports’ like tourism and a dry year for power production.
Keeping an economy alive during a pandemic while having large countries of the economy in lockdown carries inflationary issues and overshoot is pretty inevitable. The choices with National would have been similar, but probably with a higher death toll and even more economic disruption.
However we were starting to peek out of post-pandemic recession towards the end of 2023. See the GDP figures in the post and the inflation estimates from the RBNZ/stats.
What is happening with National’s policies is that they are liable to induce stagflation and lock a recession into place and leave it there. They do that by effectively dropping the velocity of money in the economy because people become unwilling to spend because of uncertainty of income. Effectively they have induced unemployment to rise through a vast range of the economy through policy changes that target employment and planned programmes. From public servants, the programmes that they have cut, the suppliers that they will stop buying from etc… That spreads out into things like baristas that don’t have customers. People culling possums that have funding cuts. The companies that supply those..
The only place that they have produced a counter stimulation are economically hoarders. Landlords by enabling their leveraged buyouts of housing and banks via customers including landlords and renters paying their mortgages from tax reductions. That reduces money velocities.
So National has pushed the economy towards reduced business and personal confidence which has been the feature of term so far. The effect is pronounced enough that the RBNZ has been pushed to start considering that we may now be in stagflation cycle where no-one is taking risks or spending money in case their job disappears, so businesses are seeing less business and starting to shed staff to reduce costs, and no-one is investing in new business – all because of uncertainty.
If you listen to the economic pundits, that is what they worried about as well. That especially the rapid drop off rate of people migrating here and the even more rapid rate of people exiting the country was why the RBNZ dropped rates early. Stagflation is really hard to break out of.
National should know. They managed to do this several times in the past. It will be harder to get out of now because of our ageing demographics. We may get caught in the same economic stagflation/deflation trap that Japan got into
The last 9 months proves the sceptics of National's tax plans were right.
It was either 'Tax Cuts for all with rainbows and unicorns' (National) or 'tough out the cost of living issue and keep jobs and government services’ (Labour)
If anyone wants to look back it wasn't only Labour warning the tax cuts could only come with massive cuts to govt spending, it was almost every economist in the country. Not only we have cuts but to make their numbers add up the Nat's have more new borrowing than Labour.
And of course most taxpayers are worse off now.
I'm not as patient or educated as lprent, but I'd say briefly – there was no induced recession from Labour. Far from it. The global credit ratings agencies all gave positive feedback and maintained top tier credit ratings AA+/AAA
In addition, Treasury etc all forecast a very soft landing with strong optimism up to and including November results.
Instead National started with their "We are so fragile" BS so they could use an excuse to implement an austerity budget, fire thousands, halt the large majority of construction, cancel infrastructure programs and then borrow an ADDITIONAL $12bn for tax cuts that are more than eaten up by their games on 3 Waters (council rates), climate change driven insurance hikes, etc even as they increased car registration, public transport fees, prescription fees, GP fees and the like.
Very interesting article. I would observe that we are caught up by poor governance at a central government level (Accelerated recession) and local council level (Cannot live within a normal budget). But as a self employed person whose superannuation savings is three small apartments (not negatively geared) I can assure you that people in our position are not laughing 'all the way to the bank.' Here in the Wellington City Council area rates have been rising for the last few years at double and now triple the rate of CPI – while the city population has not changed in 5 years. Landlord insurances like house and content insurances have been rising at double figures for the last few years, and this years contents policy went up 35%. Like responsible landlords we don't hike up rents. So – in practical terms it means that this can only be survived if we sell up and move to the southern Mediterranean or Asia where the cost of living is so much lower (We have lived 15 years in Australia in our lives – thats even less an economic option that NZ). Or try renting them out and renting in Portugal, Spain, Vietnam, or Italy. Losing the NZ Govt Super would still not be a disincentive as the buying and renting, and all other aspects of costs of living (except cars which you don't need) are so much lower in regional cities and most rural areas in these countries. And – they really want modestly self funded international retirees. So sadly – we have to leave, along with other kiwis now engaged with European and South East Asian immigration agents. (Maybe we should have got normal jobs and the retirement schemes that go with that – but too late now).
Those rates will keep rising because of 3 waters issues and climate change. Both are directly the result of chronic 60+ years under-funding of water handling.
The problem is that generally rate payers don't like paying for things mainly benefit future generations. But installing water infrastructure is inherently aimed 50-100 years down the line. It is hard to do it piecemeal because it has to be integrated into a plan.
So it gets stuck in once (in NZ typically somewhere between 1900 and 1960) and not continuously upgraded for changing circumstances. It just gets extended as subdivisions go into place, but leaving the old infrastructure in place. Or it gets upgraded when the previous endpoint don't have capacity (ie new or larger dams or sewerage treatment plants), or when the storm water system can't handle excess rain and flooding starts to happen.
Labour's response was Three Waters legislation, which wasn't about either stealing assets either from councils or Maori control. That was just racist dog-whistling by Act, National, and NZ First to collect votes.
It was to allow central capital funding for the major upgrades across all of the failing infrastructure in NZ. It would also mean that the really large lumpy investments required wouldn't add to debt or cause massive increases in rates.
It would mean that the scatter gun responses of fixing after failures could slowly switch to preventing disasters in the first place. It would mean that the very limited supply of water engineers and funding could be focused on the major upcoming problems, rather than relying on the ad-hoc scare campaigns by local politicians to motivate
National threw that away. So now councils have to raise rates to upgrade within their fiscal limits. Insurance companies raise premiums because they see no or little progress on fixing risks like sloped undercut by more water crushing house, or weather causing floods that century old storm water systems can't handle.
All they are offering is central funding when ignorant NAct1 MPs (who know nothing about water or earth sciences) approve of the local council policies. Something that may or may not start happening outside of Auckland* and probably Christchurch** next year.
Yep.
* Auckland because it has been continuously growing, so has by and large kept up with its infrastructure spending. Especially in the last 3 decades as systems started failing because of in-fill housing.
** Christchurch because of its earthquakes in 2010-11
What a pity you choose to omit information when reporting. This recession was predicted last year when Labour was in charge of the piggy bank. Another example of poor inaccurate left wing reporting.
Clearly you are unable to read past the first sentence. The key word wasn’t recession. It was stagflation. My first sentence was:-
I guess that you are too economically illiterate to know what that is. Stagflation arises out of an recessionary climate but is induced to take a turn for the worse, usually because of governmental policies. Wikipedia
What I was pointing out was that appears to be exactly the dilemma that the RBNZ is now trying to correct for after National’s stupid economic mistakes since taking office. That was obvious because the next thing I said was …
So I guess that either you are too lazy to read past the first part of the fist sentence (as would be usual for many NAct1 supporters), or you were just fingering your genitals and pissing with excitement about your own one liner like a good troll.
In either come back when you have actually learnt some basic high school grade economics and can contribute to an intelligent discussion.
Interesting article what a shame you have such an obvious political bias.
Every political party in the last forty years has enthusiastically supported the extreme neoliberal orthodoxy first foisted on us by Roger Douglas and Labour in 1984.
Given that what we are witnessing is the entirely predictable outcome of these policies (eg hollowing out of education sector, collapse of manufacturing, jobs outsourced overseas, rampant price-gouging by corporate monopolies), to say that one party is far worse than the another is to miss the point entirely :
Until we have structural reform of the idiotic economic policies that have lead to this mess – and have thus been proven not to work! – it really doesn't matter who one votes for. Its the equivalent of rearranging deckchairs on the Titanic
Perhaps you should read our about. It will explain our general ‘bias’. Your obvious ‘bias’ appears to be that a prig and stupid troll who can’t read.
My personal bias is that of a reluctant socialist tech geek with a MBA and a working life in private industry. Which is why this post was about current economic policies rather than political theories or parties.
I doubt that you noticed or even read anything past the first sentence. That is probably why you missed that there was exactly one mention of the current National party in the post by me. It was put in there as a test specifically for stupid trolls who didn’t actually read the post (usually those on the right).
There are a couple of references to economic policies of the previous Key National government related to current economic policies, and to the direct policies of current NAct1 government (which is a 3 party coalition).
Somehow I never mentioned any other parties.
This probably should have given you a hint that I’m less concerned about the politics and more concerned about the current economic policies at present.
After all we have this foolish policy stupidity for another 2 years. This is probably economically more relevant right now than event that happened about 40 years ago. Perhaps you might want to try to enter the 21st century at some point.
I do have a bias in that I rather suspect that you are just a stupid ignorant troll who didn’t actually read the post.
Call me old fashioned but ad hominem insults neither strengthen debate nor serve the wider interests of the left. I detest the man but Churchill did have a great line in aphorisms – “You will never reach your destination if you stop and throw stones at every barking dog”, being an especially pertinent one.
Your statement of "being less concerned about the politics and more concerned about the current economic policies at present”, (my emphasis) fascinates me as I can’t work out how it's possible to extrapolate one from the other given they have a common origin and are mutually reinforcing.
The claim that the coalition’s “foolish policy stupidity” is “economically more relevant” than what the infiltrated LP did to NZ in the 1980s in the service of emergent global (hyper) capitalism, makes no sense to me.
How can you analyse this government’s crude mishmash of economic policies without rooting the analysis in that historic capitulation and the ensuing four decades of subservience to global capitalism by successive governments which are differentiated largely by how they manage the margins of the system.
Some more aphorisms: people who don’t learn the lessons of history are doomed to repeat its mistakes, and mainstream economic theory is capitalist ideology wearing the cap and gown of a pseudo-science. 🙂
Perhaps I should have said ideology. And shortish-term economic issue – that can stretch out for a long time.
The problem is that stagflation is one of the hardest of economic traps to get out of. It has nothing much to do with ideology because…
It has been obvious in a number of types of economies from rampant capitalism to full blown socialism and everything in between. It usually happens when an economy is shifting between modes, typically demographic or technological or cost shocks or even just something like strict price controls. You can see it running through past histories history once it became obvious after the 1970s oil shocks.
It is characterised by persistently simultaneous high inflation, low growth, high unemployment, and productivity blockages. It jams an economy into a horrible persistent recessionary balance.
As Investopedia puts it when discussing how to get out of stagflation..
There have been other routes. Ideally to be avoided
In our case I think it arises from shocks rippling down from the pandemic responses coupled with the changes in our trading relationships. In particular the ones related to the Chinese economy either directly from exports, or via Australia whose iron commodity trade is crashing down to low prices as the building boom in China slows to a crawl.
But the austerity focus of this government are precisely the wrong things to prevent it from correcting incipient stagflation.
I don’t think the politics or ideology has much to do with it. Just a fatal unawareness of the risks.
A quote that was more about wasting time unproductively than “ad hominem insults”. Churchill relished those when they were useful.
I’m not that interested in the wider interests of the ‘left’. They invariably seem to mean some kind of quasi-religious adherence to some vaguely defined principles and are usually only useful for chopping up the ‘left’ into small congregations of believers who can’t work together. It is kind of pointless huddling teeny echo chambers if you’re interested in actually improving how systems work.
I’m mostly interested in functional disagreement and exploring ideas about how to make things work, short or long term. Which surprise, surprise is also the standing policy on the site (and no I didn’t write these bits).
Read the about and the start of the policy on robust debate (my italics).
Which is why this site tolerates a pretty wide range of views between authors and commenters, and has a habit of breaking up comment threads that revert into ideological echo chambers trying to exclude disbelievers.
Personally as I have said many times, I am a reluctant socialist, a extreme individualist, and that I don’t think that ideology is particularly useful for dealing with many situations. I prefer looking across the views to pick out identification of problems and ways to deal with them. Which is why I tend to leave a lot of comments and replies on my posts, frequently critical of the views of others because I can’t see any point to them.
Dealing with ‘barking dogs’ is part of that, which is why Jakem’s first ever comment was let through. We exclude trolls by requiring that first comments by a new handle are all auto-moderated. I excluded a number of first comments that didn’t manage to raise any point at all apart from that they didn’t like the post.
But ‘robust debate’ includes that personal goads are often useful for driving home behavioural changes on the site.
In this case that while Jakem looked like they were trying to make an argument, they also they didn’t appear to me to have actually have read the whole of the post that they were criticising. So they sprouted dogma rather than an argument based on that dogma. So I pointed that out while also offering my personal opinion about how they looked to me – probably ignorant troll as a goad to do better.
I then dropped them into provisional approval for further moderation. If they only focus on the goad, then they probably are a troll. If, unlike you, they were astute enough to see the point that they hadn’t offered any argument and offered one – then they drop out of auto-moderation.
Hmm. Moderators can't handle the truth?
[lprent: We just have a policy about first time commenters. All new handles in use have to have one comment passed by a moderator before they can comment freely. Since we are a voluntary site, you will find that moderators will deal with comments in auto-moderation when they get around to it.
We use this human oversight to weed out robots, idiots, and trolls. But also from stupid people who can’t write a coherent comment that contributes to a robust debate (see the policy). That latter describes you.
Looking at your first comment…
Overall you read like a very dumb troll possibly writing in from overseas without any current knowledge of NZ. Also one who appears to be trying to use content from the stats to cover a stupid comment. That is may pass automated spam chasers. But is pretty useless when a human analyzes the comment.
I have left your handle on moderation probation, because it’d amuse me to see if you answer these points. ]