Written By:
notices and features - Date published:
6:28 pm, March 5th, 2020 - 55 comments
Categories: Daily review -
Tags:
The current rise of populism challenges the way we think about people’s relationship to the economy.We seem to be entering an era of populism, in which leadership in a democracy is based on preferences of the population which do not seem entirely rational nor serving their longer interests. ...
The server will be getting hardware changes this evening starting at 10pm NZDT.
The site will be off line for some hours.
Newshub: Non-ministerial Green MPs' average flight-spending trumps other backbenchers
https://www.newshub.co.nz/home/politics/2020/03/non-ministerial-green-mps-average-flight-spending-trumps-other-backbenchers.html
Air travel can depend on where list MPs are based, but this does look a bit hypocritical, especially at the same time as this:
https://www.greens.org.nz/greens_celebrate_kiwisaver_divestment_win_call_for_further_and_faster_action
Leadership should start at the top, but sometimes leaders just try to force things on those lower down.
Is a few thousand bucks of air travel by a few MPs in the course of their work really something we need to be all that concerned about?
You can't make an omelette without breaking some eggs, Humpty.
Wow, those Green MPs sure work very hard, good on them.
So, your only contribution here is to quote and also parrot David Seymour’s line?
If you were a journalist, I’d call this lazy journalism. As it is, it is wasting TS bandwidth.
And no, I’m not addressing this any further and waste more time on it.
Of course I'm not being a journalist when I comment here.
Again you're diverting from the issue. I'd call this lazy blogging.
"The issue"?
The JLR story is "the issue", Pete – what ya got for us on that juicy reveal? National and the Chinese Communist Party!! Not healthy for our democracy, Pete, is it!!
I've got nothing on that story. You'd have to ask Ross or Peters, who seem in cahoots over getting it out. I didn't realise it was a new story.
Here's one that wasn't popular KB today, on National hypocrisy on getting tough on gangs with firearms but getting soft on extremists getting firearms license.
https://www.kiwiblog.co.nz/2020/03/general_debate_5_march_2020.html/comment-page-1#comment-2654157
If you go and uptick it it may take it out of downtick hiding.
Here, Pete, have a listen:
Jami-Lee Ross in Parliament links National donations to Communist Party
https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/political/411056/jami-lee-ross-in-parliament-links-national-donations-to-communist-party
I did flick through the transcript of him 'questioning Peters, Did he make more accusations in a speech? Has he got evidence? or is he just using the protection of Parliament to make publicise claims.
If you want to learn more about the depth of the accusations I suggest checking The BFD tomorrow, they usually promote Ross and Peters attacks there.
Edit: I’ve just seen the link that Cinny has posted below, it was in a speech. I don’t have time to check all that out now, but there should be news reports by morning.
But again, I’d be looking for evidence to back up his accusations. Otherwise it looks a bit devious.
He had evidence, from the SFO no less…. watch/listen to the full speech.
QED
But who’s “diverting from the issue” now, Pete?
Another story today is National MP David Bennett staying stupid things on radio suggesting people do some panic buying…
https://twitter.com/rnz_news/status/1235428899967758338
… and then denying he said it on camera (1 news, can't find it online).
Not so much an issue as an embarrassment for Bennett and National.
David Clark seems to be struggling a bit with his job as Minister of Health, but I think National (mostly Bridges) are being irresponsible trying to stir up muck over Covid-19.
https://www.tvnz.co.nz/one-news/new-zealand/people-being-urged-ignore-national-mp-encouraged-coronavirus-panic-buying
Strait out barefaced lies, I can see a great future for him in the National party.
The PM should fire him. The Health portfolio is a breeze and Mr Clark could make an attempt at least to make it look easy. That nasty little virus is just a pesky inconvenience that should be dealt with in the same way MPI and the farmer’s community dealt with M. bovis.
QED
You were wearing your MAGA cap (Make ACT Great Again).
Just make sure you take screenshots of your comments here and to send them to David.
Funny you accusing me of having a cap. False implication there. I quote MPs from all parties at various times. So do authors here. It's sort of common on political blogs.
I included Seymour's quote because I think that's how quite a few people will the Green MP use of air travel. And to see what reaction it got here. Expected.
I don't send screenshots of anything to MPs. Do you?
You seem to be still wearing your 'diversion from things you want to discredit' hat. Why don't you try to discuss the matters raised instead of just drawing attention to them with lame diversions?
You’re not getting it, Pete.
When you and others (e.g. David Seymour of all) use hypocrisy against CC activists, for example, you’re attacking the messenger and diverting away from the issue that these activists are trying to tackle. It is that simple. It’s like you’re accusing the surgeon of hurting you and making you bleed when they’re supposed to make you better. The hypocrisy accusation is the one you’d expect from a child. Expected.
So, you’re the one that keeps bringing up these lame diversions and when I point them out to you, you accuse me of … wait for it … diverting 😉
Don’t send screenshots, send links; much easier.
The amount of air travel by Green MP's is a reasonable comment point. If they were around the average of other list MP's, it wouldn't be an issue. But being at the top is not what should be expected.
They could for instance use their MP's from specific regions to do the things in their region. But it looks like they all fly everywhere, criss crossing the country. They can expect to be called on that.
There’s a good headline in there, Wayne 😉
I'd rather they spent taxpayers' money than a corrupt dictatorship's money.
Yes that's right, it is ridiculous that the Greens have spokespeople. How silly. As they are so much more intelligent than MPs from other parties they should all be experts on every subject and communicate telepathically.
They will get pinged for that closer to the election.
At very least they should be publishing their Air NZ carbon offsets.
Back in the day this government were promising to convert the entire government fleet to electric. Plus ca change.
And which part of this govt torpedoed that plan?
Offsetting you say .
You mean destroying rural communities by funding the planting of trees while achieving fuck all around reducing carbon emissions
Non-ministerial Green MPs' average flight-spending trumps other backbencher
Jesus Fucking H Christ Pete, "Green MPs fly around the country, lol hypocrites" was some pretty lame bullshit to run with 15 years ago, let alone now.
I guess when David Seymour needs to travel he thumbs a lift.
Nope, he gets his lift from the slipstream of hot air coming from National. They’re hoping that others can fly in on his coat-tails.
Jami lee had a few words to say in Parliament regarding $150k 💰 in donations to the nats, straight out of China. 🇨🇳
https://www.parliament.nz/en/watch-parliament/ondemand?itemId=211353
Dodgy as dealings… Professor Anne-Marie Brady kindly sheds some more light on the subject via twitter.
https://twitter.com/Anne_MarieBrady/status/1235425637378097155
Yeah, the reason the Nats split $200K of donations (that we know about, because the truth is probably in the millions ever single year) is because they were afraid of being seen as the Party doing China's bidding.
Unfortunately for New Zealand I think the problem with National taking money from China is a lot deeper than first thought. Despite their best efforts to distance themselves from the China link they will be tied to it for the foreseeable future.
Sunlight is the best disinfectant and all that.
Here's Ross claiming a further $150K direct from China and laundered through local conduits made its way into National Party coffers.
https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/political/411056/jami-lee-ross-in-parliament-links-national-donations-to-communist-party
We know money from China distorted our housing market via local proxies, and it seems we are only just finding out it distorted our democracy too.
Remember when Phil Twyford was eviscerated by daring to suggest that the Chinese were distorting our housing market and causing it to go through the roof.
Racism, racism were the screams. And I recall our old friend CV was leading the pack on this site.
Thanks for the link Muttonbird, much appreciated.
Calling Pete George! Here's the issue for you, Pete; let's hear what you make of JLR's expose regarding the Chinese Communist Party and the National Party; it's a story you can really get your teeth into!
But a Green MP took a plane when Greta Thunberg says we should all be taking boats.
That is concerning.
I've responded above where you also asked.
I am just in from splitting wood and haven't been pouring over Parliament. if you want to put together a summary I will post it on KB and see what they say about it there.
See: “Ross also sought to make public two flow-charts prepared by the Serious Fraud Office (SFO) which he said showed the flow of money, but was blocked by the Speaker due to legal concerns.”
So Ross seems to be trying to use court documents in the SFO prosecution he is facing.
Do you think what he claims is trustworthy? He has come up short in delivering on accusations in the past.
He didn't say they were court documents, that’s merely your own spin petegeorge.
What he did say was that he couldn't assure the speaker that the charts weren't intergral in any matter currently before the courts. Fair enough too, as how would he know exactly which documents would be before the court at this stage? 10:10 onwards, fascinating.
Thanks Cinny – it was fascinating.
I'm guessing the flow chart and associated evidence against the National Party will have its day in the sun, in court, eventually.
However, that will be after the election and I'm sure it is in the interest of the New Zealand public to have that information before the election.
I wonder if a decent journalist might be able to help the New Zealand public on this?
Hope so.
What is this a euphemism for?
Pete, you should contribute to my "Farrar watch:" initiative.
All are welcome.
I think it's important to keep a close eye on the National Party funded spin doctor. Could use your formidable forensic analysis which seeks out hypocrisy wherever it may reside.
" if you want to put together a summary I will post it on KB and see what they say about it there."
Truly stunned by that proposal from you, Pete; you want me to do what, so that you could do what so that they could do what???
WHY???
Perhaps a stick of kindling flew up from the axe and struck you on the brain, is all I can think!
I think you misread Pete’s offer, Robert. Pete’s MO is to quote ad nauseam stuff written by others and then adding some comment, often a one-liner. He seems to call that “journalism”, which is actually a fairly accurate description of NZ journalism in its present state.
Indeed
You seem to have an obsession with making false assertions about me and journalism.
Have you noticed that posts here often extensively quote from other sources and add their own comments? It's sort of quite common on blogs. Journalists even do it sometimes too, actually quite often.
I'm not sure why you seem to think it's a bad thing (but it seems only when I do it).
https://thestandard.org.nz/what-was-winston-thinking/#comment-1685353
Your words, Pete.
Do you drop your journalistic standards when you comment here? Do you swap virtual hats?
Real professional (i.e. the good ones) journalists use data, facts, information from reliable sources, do background checks, et cetera. They don’t just copy & paste (AKA quoting) or parrot lines from others (yes, this happens all the time in MSM, literally). They don’t make up stories about perceived collusion or conspiracy based on innuendo and watching clips of Parliamentary debates when they have nothing else to write about and in absence of any substantial evidence (i.e. when they’ve got nothing on the real story).
IMO
I’d be most interested if you could point out the “false assertions” I’ve made about you and journalism, according to you. In fact, you seem to repeat and agree with my “assertions”!? Your blogsite would seem to lend further support.
If you feel singled out, Pete, it is because you’re not just any commenter here and the style and content of your comments attract attention, not just mine, which is how you want it, apparently.
Wow this is disappointing…
https://i.stuff.co.nz/national/politics/119931204/rome-continues-to-burn-fourteen-new-mines-being-built-on-conservation-land
NZ First's influence again? Shit like this gets damaging.
If Eugenie Sage rolled over any faster she'd be a seal.
This prick.
https://twitter.com/AnshelPfeffer/status/1235248018800234504
Yeah !!!!! bibi didn't crack the numbers, again lololz Hahahahahahahahaaaa!
There's a large arab population in Israel, it's plain out nasty that bibi's in denial over their democratically won seats.
bibi's in court in two weeks time and it can't come soon enough.
Racists gonna racist.
It is amusing watching Natshub trying to concoct an anti-government story in the face of National Party MPs losing the plot by politicising Coronavirus, and the revelation that CCP money is funding the Nats’ 2020 campaign.
Wild Turkeys.
https://www.twitter.com/ASBreakingNews/status/1235295752915648513
Must have touched a raw nerve.
Things are going well in Turkey…
Stuff article on what the govt is actually doing.
My only query would be leaving USians to use the customs e-gates. Not sure the yank policy of bullshit&pray is an effective containment measure. For a supposedly developed nation, they have a lot of self-built hurdles between them and not being completely in the toilet.
“My only query would be leaving USians to use the customs e-gates.”
The insurance industry has sorted that one. No travel insurance for COVID19 effects.
https://www.stuff.co.nz/business/119953122/coronavirus-most-travel-insurers-not-offering-kiwis-cover-for-virusrelated-claims
Presume US insurers did this as well, and probably last week. Don't think we'll be seeing many travellers from US for a while, tourists or on business.
Tourism will be in for some changes, and probably very suddenly in all markets including domestic.