Written By:
notices and features - Date published:
6:30 am, December 9th, 2016 - 222 comments
Categories: bill english, national, same old national -
Tags:
https://player.vimeo.com/api/player.jsShe chooses poems for composers and performers including William Ricketts and Brooke Singer. We film Ricketts reflecting on Mansfieldâs poem, A Sunset on a ...
https://player.vimeo.com/api/player.jsKatherine Mansfield left New Zealand when she was 19 years old and died at the age of 34.In her short life she became our most famous short story writer, acquiring an international reputation for her stories, poetry, letters, journals and reviews. Biographies on Mansfield have been translated into 51 ...
The server will be getting hardware changes this evening starting at 10pm NZDT.
The site will be off line for some hours.
Look, if we can’t have Judith Collins (aka Electoral Death), then Bill English (aka Charismatic Void) will do nicely. I am sure this guy can put accountants to sleep.
It makes the 2017 election a whole lot more interesting.
Also see for typical reactions
The Civilian “20.9% of country thrilled”
Brian Edwards “Memo to National Party Caucus: Please Pick Bill. Please, Please, Pretty Please!”
I’m thrilled, Merry Christmas, bye bye national lead government. Nzer’s don’t want more of the same, but it’s obvious that the Nat Cacus does, because they are freaking out, their whole brand has gone poof. I’m loving this.
Whale Blubber is seriously putting the boot into Bill, i can see the nat supporters are oh so supportive of the choice, not.
Hey Billy Boy remember when I protested you in Motueka, yelled all through your one hour speech, drowning you out so your elderly supporters couldn’t hear you. You told me that you had never seen your name on a protest sign before and was secretly delighted to see your name on my sign, well Bill, come back, let’s do it again, I’ve got more to tell the world. Do you remember? I’ve got photos.
All the people walking past telling me nice things and offering their support, the people calling out ‘fuck john key’ because this one woman protest machine encouraged them to have a say.
Come back Bill, I’m waiting for you…. best you get Maureen List MP Pugh a new office in Motueka, otherwise, how are you going to hold a meeting?
Early election is on the cards, can’t wait, I’ve already worked out a question for the meet the candidates debates. Just bring it, we are ready.
You sound like Penny Bright.
I’ll take that as a compliment, after all she is strong intelligent woman. So thanks BM.
Well she’s a woman at least.
Are you really a fish?
A strong, intelligent fish?
More like a carp.
You sound like Penny Dreadful
certainly not penny dropped….
@BM
You sound like your nuts – but they still allow you to post here.
If you have nothing to positive to say, ……
Sounds like its the highlight of your life, I can imagine you at parties regaling people with the time you “took down” Bill English đ
I can imagine you at parties saying mean-spirited things about people with principles
I’ve got the theme song here:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6vQpW9XRiyM
and the movie as well:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Return_of_the_Secaucus_7
Does Puckish even get to be invited to party’s,… that is the real question here,….
Nope I’d rather listen when at parties, to find out how people really feel.
Sorries I’ve already got a theme song, movie will be out soon, I’ll keep you posted.
That’ll show Thatcher
You just come on the site to throw barbs at people.
Please go away.
Margaret ‘ Poll Tax ‘ Thatcher and the neo liberal backing choir…
Hey Billy Boy remember when I protested you in Motueka, yelled all through your one hour speech, drowning you out so your elderly supporters couldnât hear you.
I doubt he does. But it’s easy to appreciate how you could be so proud of this achievement – no doubt all those elderly people were thoroughly persuaded by your thoughtful and charming presentation of compelling arguments.
Brian Edwards âMemo to National Party Caucus: Please Pick Bill. Please, Please, Pretty Please!â
It’s almost like Edwards hasn’t noticed we’ve had PM’s after Lange.
Of the three most recent long-term PM’s, Key exhibits all the charm and charisma of the worst kind of try-hard ‘cool dad’ wanna-be. Clark always appeared ‘distant’ to the point you needed a telescope to see her. Bolger couldn’t work a room to save himself.
Bill fits neatly into that mold.
Wow…just wow, talk about being negative
Key always seems affable, Clark always seemed competent and as for Bolger:
“Retiring politician journalist Peter Luke said that Bolger was “the most under-estimated prime minister I have come across. He made up for his lack of education by having an innate ability to relate to the aspirations of ordinary Kiwis. And, as many civil servants discovered to their cost, his image of being a simple King Country farmer did not mean that he would not understand their reports and unfailingly point to the flaws in them.”
I’m not trying to be negative about English, or any other former PM for that matter.
I’m just pointing out that when Edwards says fucking stupid things (presumably sarcastically) like…
Bill is stupendous, charismatic, a master of oratory and, no point in denying it, a real stud.
Charisma, mastery of the language, sex appeal. Itâd be riveting, wouldnât it?
… he’s ignoring the fact New Zealand has quite happily voted again and again for PM’s over the last 30 years who pretty clearly have not exhibited many of those traits.
Bill’s a pretty good looking guy in a rugged way. He is charming, and at times I’ve seen him electrifying. He’s sincere and quite endearing. You make a good point, but I don’t think Brian Edwards is correct anyway.
Nothing wrong with Bill English’s temperament or measured way of speaking – quite like that in a politician.
But his neo liberalism is….
What do you expect from a friend of Michelle Boag’s? I gave up on Edwards years ago (and turn the panel off the moment they come on).
“Billâs a pretty good looking guy in a rugged way. He is charming, and at times Iâve seen him electrifying.”
Christ O Mighty … I was just in the middle of eating dinner …
He’s a dead rat. Eat up: yum yum yum đ
Edwards is a good friend of Boag.
Enough said.
I like this comment from Ben Thomas
“I was listening to Bill English being interviewed as I drove home last night. It was more potent than barbiturates. Future interviews should come with a health warning to those driving.”
Its a pity Judith didnt sneak into the top Job. It would have made for great entertainment đ
Yeah! That’s all it is to you.
Entertainment.
Says it all about you and your values really.
Fuck yeah đ
Judith would do the Job very well, maybe a bit more to the right than is currently on offer with Bill.
The screaming of the outraged lefties would just be a bonus đ
Judith is vile, corrupt and toxic, and the whole nation knows it. She would have made National unelectable and it’s a shame they realise it.
“The screaming of the outraged lefties would just be a bonus đ”
đ
Your definition of screaming is questionable. Although I have to say if that post is all that it takes to make you happy then I envy you the life of bliss you must lead.
Simple things amuse simple minds.
The weak attempt of right-wingers to sound superior would make them a laughing-stock
so why do you think the nats arent going with judith, david?
She is too far Right for an MMP election.
She would bolt in if it was FPP
đ
“She would bolt in if it was FPP”
she looks more like a jockey thrower to me
id have to check the teeth tho……
@ david c
….This isn’t Italy during the 1930’s, though….
Earth to moron: I welcomed the idea. English will lose the next election too, but Collins embodies National Party values so precisely she’d have made much better sport.
Basically every credible lefty has at one point said something along the lines of “I almost hope Judith Collins does get to be National Leader someday, I’ve always wanted to see their party implode.”
Some of us are being a bit more cautious about such ideas on a post-Trump world, of course.
@david c (2)
How can someone with an elephants foot sneak anywhere , though….?
Bill will kill any euthanasia bill.
Pardon the pun; it is a sensitive subject, but like John Key it would seem that Bill English is likely to refuse to go certain places because of personal convictions and plain old stubbornness AKA ‘farmer mentality’.
The difference between National and Labour is, for me: whatâs in it for me compared to whatâs in it for us?
Would never happen in an election year, far too controversial.
Agree with that BM
I was not referring to (the) election year; John Key had already essentially vetoed a Bill being passed because of people in National caucus like Bill English who are opposed to it. Even Billâs wife Mary apparently is an outspoken opponent: http://www.nzherald.co.nz/politics/news/article.cfm?c_id=280&objectid=11763645
If Bill English becomes the (re)elected PM next year I think it is highly likely that we wonât get any progress with this sensitive and indeed controversial issue for another term.
This is disappointing and frustrating given that apparently public support for this has been consistently high for quite some time: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euthanasia_in_New_Zealand#Support
My point remains that personal views should not get in the way of fulfilling oneâs duty as political representative for the good of the whole population. Simon OâConnor is also a National MP and Chairperson of Health Select Committee that is currently taking submissions regarding medically-assisted dying. Mr OâConnor is (a) Catholic and completed his training to become a priest but was not ordained. Clearly it does not prevent him to do his job âŚ
Lastly, controversial issues are defining issues IMO. It is a pity that the political âleadershipâ in NZ is marked by lack of vision, courage, and a will to change things and just plays it safe all the time, which comes at the detriment of many in our society. But apparently this is what voters donât mind or even like, according to Audrey Young today in the NZ Herald: http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=11763876
Headline should be:
“Bill English to be
electedappointed as National Leader”try anointed
A much better description of the process.
I’m sure many Christians will agree that he’s “anointed by God” & having a good Catholic as PM will straighten out NZ. đ
disclaimer: not my position at all. I think English has been a politician for too long, does not show the virtues of charity and humility and honesty, and is a dangerous right wing ideologue.
https://thestandard.org.nz/collins-withdraws-and-pledges-to-support-english/#comment-1272341
On environmental issues; climate change, mining, GMO etc. Bill’s views were formed on the farm. Ask Southland farmers about those issues and you’ll know where Bill’s coming from.
You dont value university education then?
You don’t have to go to university to understand environmental issues.
That certainly reflects the way the Green Party thinks about GMOs.
No science, just religion.
Where as English is “just religion, no science”, is that what you mean, David C?
Pretty sure his degree wasn’t in science.
Yeah no science.
Head boy at Scots, then commerce and literature degrees.
Real thicko farmer for sure.
Why do you call farmers “thicko”, David C?
Do you use a derogatory term when describing Catholics as well?
He was actually head boy at Silverstream.
You and David brothers?
Who is David brothers?
Right-wing troll. Likes to begin his surname lowercase.
Scots Silverstream. It was called “Colditz” in my day. đ
The creative writing element was a good investment for Bill’s career.
A university degree or two doesnt mean a hell of a lot in terms of who is smart. Like everyone, I know some people without degrees who are way smarter than the middle of the bell curve, and vice versa.
If you want to argue the toss, commerce and literature double qualify you for flipping burgers.
Jonothan Colemans medical degree might earn him points had he used it for actually helping people instead of political advancement.
“commerce and literature degrees.”
you know you can get those just buy showing up to every scheduled lecture dont you …??
How about we agree that theoretical knowledge backed up with practical experience is a better option then either one individually?
In theory, Pucky, but practically speaking…
During our fights, I’ve seen a lot of changing, in the way you feel about me, and in the way I feel about you. In here, there were two guys killing each other, but I guess that’s better than 4 million. I guess what I’m trying to say, is that if I can change, and you can change, everybody can change!
Damn straight!
That’s the problem with ‘dialogue’ you actually start to understand where people are coming from and then next thing you know you are sitting down for a nice cup of tea instead of lobbing nukes at each other
We should all get together in a pub and discuss the current political landscape over a few drinks
Nothing could possibly go wrong đ
I hear there’s a cafe in Epsom serves a damn fine cup of tea….
*Note to self*
Siobhan is NOT to be invited due to poor choice in beverage suggestion
Hmm, the last time i went to a bloggers drinks things went pear shaped. There are some real nutcases online đ
” Thatâs the problem with âdialogueâ you actually start to understand where people are coming from and then next thing you know you are sitting down for a nice cup of tea instead of lobbing nukes at each other ”
Hasn’t helped the neo liberal right wing , though…
They are in a bubble of Faux News apocalyptic religious propaganda
I must break you.
Oh the irony. The person responsible for giving Little the biggest chance at being prime minister is the person the Left has despised the most.
Judith Collins dropped out – what are you talking about?
Yeah English is far from being the most despised figure in the National Party, (that’s Collins, hands down) let alone by the NZ left in general. (I’m pretty sure that’s actually Winston, although it’s a weird love-hate relationship with him so you have to pick your time right)
@Mattew Whitehead (6.2)
Pullyer Benefit wins a consolation award for runner up in a category all of her own for the most despised National party figure due to her outstanding under – performance over the housing crisis – and the outlandish fetish she has of wearing fake leopards skins in an age of conservation awareness…
Parata and Tolley are mounting a strong challenge for the uselessness award
Parata did the most useful thing she possibly could though and resigned.
Paula Bennet definitely deserves some hatred, (mostly for pulling the ladder up after herself in terms of yanking training allowances away from other women trying to eventually get off a benefit- there’s a very special place in hell as far as I’m concerned for people who forget what it’s like to live in hardship) but she won’t be anywhere close to contending for the top spot until/unless Collins resigns.
I think you’ll find that Pullya Benefit never lived in hardship. Back when she was on the DPB our welfare system still provided people with enough to live on. Sure, it wasn’t easy but it was enough.
Of course, a lot of the reason for it being not enough any more is because of the cuts that she’s made.
And the costs of living have shot up way past any commensurate benefit increase
Auckland rental and house prices over the past 20 years
That’s from a report published in 2014. Things have gotten worse since then
There’s a difference between actual material hardship and hardship in general. I imagine Paula had a fair amount of experience of status anxiety and financial shame, and that she’s learned the wrong lessons from that. (ie. “I will never be poor again” rather than “society should provide for everyone”)
It’s a totally fair point though that being on a benefit today vs back then is a very different experience and it’s well-taken.
if we have to have a nat pm , i guess old bill is better than what else was on offer, he seemed to take a dim view of keys use of slater and co.
And let’s face it key was probably unbeatable in the next election ,it’s going to be interesting to see where bill takes the nats,
Do you think having Bill English in charge will help with the rural vote?
What help does the “rural vote” need?
Dyed in the wool, that.
Apparently, farmers are getting a bit grizzly, feel like they’re not being listened to.
Peters election strategy was going to be centred around targeting the rural vote, having English in charge may encourage many swing voters to stay with National.?
Peters is too fucking lazy to go around and talk to farmers.
Unless there is whiskey involved of course.
ha – all key needed was a pony tail and he’d settle for the tail of a pony…
Farmers are too busy to talk to Peters, whiskey or no whiskey. And what would they ask for that he could deliver after the 30 odd years he’s had making fuck all difference ?
Farmers getting grizzly? Get away!
Bill’s crew have been selling New Zealand farmland off to foreigners like there’s no tomorrow, so grizzly? You bet! Peter’s will stir that grizzle into a storm aimed at Bill, who after all, was/is part of the flog-it-off team.
People will care about whether they’re actually listened to, not whether the PM was once one of theirs. They all know he’s essentially a banker now.
It’s just a matter of whether they’re angry enough to consider their other options.
“Peters election strategy was going to be centred around targeting the rural vote,”
More centred on Provincial Cities, I would have thought.
most farmers blindly vote national , despite the fact i’ve had two respected cockies tell me farmers always do better under labour , so i think the nats could run attila the hun for pm and they would still get the rural vote
+1
@ BM (7.1)
Sure.
People will be flocking to NZ First in droves from here on in.
English is a city boy, every Southland farmer knows he hasn’t been “looking the sheep” for decades.
Southland farmers haven’t been “looking the sheep” for decades. Too busy dairy farming.
Whaleoil isn’t happy, that has to be good news for everyone.
WO is a funny chap.
Absolute blinkered hypocrite, does he actually think he HELPS Judith by throwing his toys like this?
Yeah, she must wish he’d just fuck off and leave her alone.
A slater endorsement is the kiss of death.
Too late. She knew he was toxic: that’s why she advanced his interests. They’re aligned with hers.
You sleep with the devil, you have to expect he’ll give you a clap…
There’s no evidence at all that she wishes that. Quite the opposite if anything. Like attracts like.
Indeed. She was offered a few chances during the short contest to distance herself from Slater and she refused to take all of them.
Either she likes being in bed with him or he’s got some blackmail material on her. I’m not sure which option is worse tbqh.
The fact that she’s associated with him would have blackmail value if it weren’t common knowledge already đ
Well, having read DP, I think the more likely option is actually that she enjoys keeping company with Slater.
IKR and it’s super amusing. Especially reading all the comments from nat supporters whom don’t want to support the blues anymore, because their leader gave up and English is in charge.
Oh dear Whale Blubber you are upset… do you know something boy? I bet you like to think you do.
Some of Slaters recent comments….
” Labour may be led by a fool but he isn’t evil or inherently dishonest. Bill English is both.”
“Bill English is a nasty vindictive man who holds grudges for years. He gets others to do his knifing and smiles like he knew nothing about it.
He was a disaster last time and will be a disaster this time. I couldn’t care less that he is Catholic, he is a nasty vindictive man. If you only knew what has gone on the past couple of days then you would shocked”
“Nicky Hager has finally won.
This blog (WO) will get stronger with a Labour/Green/NZ First government.
It isn’t what I want, but I am telling you that is what you will get. A greatly diminished National party.”
have you dick pounders above lost your bookmark for kiwiblog or something?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dick_Pound
He did have quite the career đ
I googled dick pounders to see what it actually meant, didn’t find anything but I did come across an interesting article about a german man with a 10 pound penis.
http://www.redbookmag.com/life/news/a21374/meet-the-man-with-the-10-pound-penis/
Those crazy Germans,
Reminds me of the joke about how to make a donkey laugh then cry
Indeed… just give the DonKey a few honest Treasury reports and a housing crisis that’s about to blow and watch it bolt….
Someone just drew attention to their own trite stupidity.
…
Right-wing trolls. Nothing valuable to say or contribute.
…
*Yawn*…*Sips coffee*
Sorry is David feeling left out? Oh dear.. does he need some attention? As I’ve neither those sites bookmarked should I do a google and copy paste some of his comments on the matter. LMFAO, the only person whom has been pounded by a Dick was dildo Joyce at Waitangi, and has hence forth become known by school kids across the land as Mr Dildo. What a statesman lmfaoooooooo !!! Introducing the new minister of finance… Mr Dildo, how proud is NZ now? Shameful
Bill English will do a pretty good job.
I’d like to see Bridges as Deputy rather than Bennett.
To me hes the best (for lack of a better word) of a bad situation, Coleman (my choice) has about as much charisma as Bill but at least Bill has the respect of being one of the best finance ministers NZ has ever had and Jude (who would have been awesome) has been unfairly targeted by the left and is thus a bit tarnished
So by default its Bill but I guess, in trying to salvage something positive, he’ll be able to work with Winston so even National drop down to 40% they’ll still be able to form a government with NZFirst
Why john why? Why did you have to go, a fourth term was yours for the taking…oh the humanity
Do we need to set up a support group for you?
Hug please
Pucky’s been shafted – his God has gone from cloud-hopper to clod-hopper.
https://awesomeashild.files.wordpress.com/2013/07/meerkat-hugging.jpg
That’s…actually pretty cute, I mean Meerkats are pretty unpleasant creatures but that’s cute
jude unfairly targeted my arse puckie , the horrible cow is isn’t fit for politics unless she moved to some african third would outfit ,
every time you talk here up you lose a bit more credibility as being someone who gets politics.
Its true I do have a blind spot when it comes to Jude, she will be PM one day, oh yes she will đ
leader of the nats when they lose their second election in 2020 to Mr Little is more likely to be her future.
I don’t know about that, I can easily see a National/NZFirst government leading for another two elections
do you think key quit to make your scenario possible? not that i think it will happen.
That’s a tough one to answer…I think no, I think he just didn’t want to be PM anymore. I’m not sure why he did that when he would have won a fourth term but he obviously marches to the beat of his own drum
I think he gave great consideration to all the factors surrounding his resignation and probably considered Winston to be a happy coincidence
If Judith ever gets a chance to be passed the PM baton (presumably by assassinating English before he can call for the election next year) she’ll lose the next election so fast it’ll still be spinning by the time the Leader of the Opposition gets ahold of it.
“Bill English will do a pretty good job. Iâd like to see Bridges as Deputy”
Two social conservatives leading a Party that won the last 3 Elections partly by making significant in-roads into morally liberal sections of the swing vote.
From a Left point of view – that sounds good !
Bill on Radio NZ this morning declaring his abhorrence of ‘injustice’.
So looking forward to some resolution on Pike River, a full inquiry on abuse in State Care, proper funding in Health Care, so, you know, hard working people don’t go blind and lame waiting to see the specialist……oh the list goes on.
But luckily Bill, a man of fine Roman Catholic morals and principles, he’ll see us right.
Yeah ,Right!
Bill is a good choice – for the left – thanks gnats, thanks keyhole.
Why?, I would have thought having a more staid person in charge would help Nationals chances.
He’s up against Andrew Little, who’s biggest selling point was going to be his staid non-flashiness.
You’re going to get that in spades with Bill English, so why change?
Plus Winston Peters will be able to provide all the charisma and personality National requires đ
Yep, the straight guy/funny guy combo, always a winner.
Winston can be the new JK.
Well its funny but originally the left wanted MMP because it’d make things “fairer” and by fairer they mean they’d be in power more often but its the right that seems to have adapted MMP better
Of the seven elections held under MMP National have won four and look good to extend that to five from eight elections
“the left wanted MMP because itâd make things âfairerâ and by fairer they mean theyâd be in power more often”
made up bullshit to spin your lies
you really are a cowardly little puck aren’t you
Oh please, quit with your faux out rage:
https://fmacskasy.files.wordpress.com/2013/05/want-a-good-reason-for-voting-for-mmp.jpg?w=595
It was pretty common knowledge that National didn’t want MMP and it was the left, mostly, pushing MMP
yes for a different reason than you spin – fairness, not to just stay in power. Just pointing that out doofus because your whole comment was based on that rubbish – a pretty standard rightie trick and irritating nevertheless.
and of course if that fairness just so happens to deliver more left wing governments then well that’s just a happy coincidence isn’t it
but it didn’t did it? Some idioto has already smashed your lines with this cutting slash – “Of the seven elections held under MMP National have won four and look good to extend that to five from eight elections”
Have a kit kat mate and look out the window at the other building really close to you because you are well off form. Are you okay?
You miss my point which was the left wanted MMP but the right have used it best so far
so, “and of course if that fairness just so happens to deliver more left wing governments then well thatâs just a happy coincidence isnât it” is rubbish then because it doesn’t ‘just so happens’ at all based on what you are saying.
even for you it is a pointless argument – must be bloody boring at your work – oh, the PM’s office is, isn’t it lol.
GCSB isn’t an interesting you’d think it would be that’s for sure
sorry, apologies I thought you had a window – sorry again.
Arguably MMP has forced National into the centre (in their PR, at least) and prevented governments running out of control to quite the degree we saw with Lab4 + Nat4
I concede you might have a point
Except if a fairer system advantaged the Right I’d still want the fairer system. In fact I have consistently advocated for lowering the party vote threshold even though I’ve never voted for a Party that falls below it.
It’s projection in the extreme to suggest that every single supporter of electoral reform only supports it because they’re interested in gaming the system.
National wouldn’t win a thing if the Right didn’t own the media.
+100
And they plan to keep it that way….
http://thedailyblog.co.nz/2016/12/08/nz-on-air-turns-down-funding-for-waatea-5th-estate-back-to-the-same-bullshit-current-affairs-we-always-get/
I don’t disagree. đ
I’m saying that there are people, even a few on the right-wing, who don’t mind voting for fairer elections even though it might hurt their candidates/parties in the short run, because they think it will ultimately lead to better candidates.
” Yep, the straight guy/funny guy combo, always a winner.
Winston can be the new JK. ”
……………………………………………………………………………..
@ BM (13.1.1.1)
Except Peters hates neo liberalism.
And Bill English IS neo liberalism.
BM “Yep, the straight guy/funny guy combo, always a winner.”
Puckish Rogue = Good Cop ?
BM = Bad Cop ?
English has already shown he doesn’t have what it takes. Little will make him look even more out of his comfort zone – it’s gonna be mayhem – little has got a sense of humour and a glint in his eye – with Bill in front of him not key he will be smiling.
Yeah, what would Bill know it’s not like he’s been helping to run the country for the last 8 years in conjunction with one of the best and most popular PMs NZ has ever had.
Up against Andrew Little who only made it in last time as a list MP by the skin of his teeth ,was handed the labour leaders job by the Unions and has taken labour to it’s lowest polling position in the history of the party , you’re right he hasn’t got a chance
You just said it – key was the man, Bill’s a backroom dude. You don’t bring the backroom to the frontroom for a number of reasons but hey – good move gnats – for the left!!!
Edit – whats the problem anyway bm, you righties happy, me leftie happy – you sound a little desperate, like you may not actually be happy – is it that the slippery snake is feathering his own nest and leaving the pigs to the muck, like bleating sheep the fish is on the hook and no amount of rat eating will get the cats paws clean.
Key v Clark was great viewing, Key v Goff was entertaining, Key v Cunliffe was compelling
English v Little is going to be of interest to masochists and insomniacs only
May be interesting to those who care who leads the country – not many gnats in there I’d agree – more interested in what’s in it for them.
I see a polite, friendly, calm, and reasoned debate – which will degenerate into baiting, insults, smears, loud voices, pushing and swearing – only from john campbell though. The pillars will stand there looking unconcerned…
I think someone might need to check their pulses half way through to make sure they’re both alive
maybe the deputies will pull up their pants and get into it too, to liven it all up – they could be gooses to bill and andrew maverick’s.
Well said… marty,… I think its high time we got rid of a lot of these egotistical wannabe rock stars and got back to a more measured and civil approach in politics…
And if boring politicians means that’s what we need to achieve that – so be it.
Yeah he’s trying to convince himself not us, lol.
The problem for Little is that Bill has all of his strengths, but has additional qualities. Bill is an intellectual. Bill is humble and affable, and his laconic speech isn’t forced. If you want to compare the calibre look at Little’s speech in reply on the budget debate for the last budget, then watch Bill’s response later in the debate. It was quite astounding.
put a link up I’d like to look at that.
Bill has had key running interference and has had it cushy. When he is running out there all alone in the spotlight he won’t like it, won’t do well at it, and in fact will probably avoid it. That may actually be all good.
The more I think about it the more I am looking forward to these debates between little and english (if he is in fact still there by then).
Don’t forget the Left is still up against that fuckwit Carter in the House.
It’s 2015:
Here’s Andrew’s: http://www.inthehouse.co.nz/video/37078
(Look at Annette King’s expression during the cacophany).
Here’s Bill’s in response: http://www.inthehouse.co.nz/video/37607
I think Collins was potentially more of a win for the left, because she would have been hated by so many centrist and swing voters. But she would also have caused a a lot of chaos and drama, too much, and we don’t need a chaotic election. We need one where people can focus on which are the best parties to run the country.
English vs Little, two steady as she goes, sensible leaders. Which means the debate will be around policy and messaging not personalities. That’s a good thing for NZ and for the left.
(if Gareth Morgan stays in, that will be the dramatic element).
So Finally got round to watching Morgan v Henry and all I can say is Morgan should hire someone to speak for him…that voice makes him hard to be taken seriously
Yes I am shallow, why do you ask?
[Morgan’s] voice makes him hard to be taken seriously
Counterpoint: John Major was UK PM from ’90 to ’97 despite sounding exactly like every hack comedian’s impression of a reedy upperclass english twat.
I seem to recall a prominent recent politician that talked in a tumble of jargon, slurred and sounded like he had a mouth full of marbles. Was quite popular I think.
But JK would never have been ruffled by Paul Henry’s antics, he would probably have stepped back and asked Henry if he wanted the interview to continue or not, because he was being extremely rude
“So Finally got round to watching Morgan v Henry and all I can say is Morgan should hire someone to speak for himâŚthat voice makes him hard to be taken seriously”
True, a face like a dropped mince pie isnt helping either.
@ weka…
I’m with you on that… Collins… only good for the scandal bait. Nothing more. We don’t need that sort of thing in this critical era for NZ.
I don’t mind English in some ways, I recall for publicity reasons he got into the boxing ring… for a charitable cause a long time back. For publicity as well , obviously ,… but the guy gave it a go and showed he wasn’t all shallow tinsel like the last idiot we’ve been continually embarrassed by. Nor was he a pony tail puller.
Thank goodness the corporate show pony’s gone.
Halle – bloody – lujah !!!
I certainly dont mind English’s much talked about ‘ blandness’.
Fact is,… regarding issues of politics that shouldn’t even be an issue . I’ll defend English from that point of view as I do Andrew Little,… another one described as being ‘ bland’.
It is just unfortunate that Bill English is disadvantaged by being an adherent to the odious , contemptible ideology of neo liberalism. It also didn’t help that ( quite rightly ) he earned himself the title of the ‘ Double Dipper’ .
He should have known better.
The most devastating dismissal of Bill English came from Helen Clark on 23 May 2002, following a disastrously inept speech by the double dipper during the Budget Debate. The chamber was waiting for her to deliver the coup de grâce and, with an exquisite sense of timing, she obliged:
http://www.vdig.net/hansard/content.jsp?id=94034
What Hansard fails to record is the absolute thunderstorm of hilarity and derision of Bill English that followed those words. That speech more than any other showed that English was finished.
Yet the National caucus, in its infinite wisdom, has brought the zombie back to the table.
Let the hilarity ensue….
Morrissey…does your memory of the ‘Dipton double dipper’ incident extend to a brief comment Butcher Bill made on camera in an on the run interview that went something like….
Crooked smirk ….”If there’s a loophole you’d be a fool not to exploit it.” More crooked smirking, then exit stage left into the bowels of Parliament.
I have hunted futilely for this footage….
That’s a very Trumpian thing to say. Unfortunately for English, he lacks Trump’s charisma.
Agreed Morrissey…but the footage???
I have in mind a gif.
To be posted each and every time Our New Leader pretends, when announcing and justifying the inevitable further crackdowns on those he sees as being the ‘hard lump of wasted human potential…the huge liability’, that these ideologies apply to all.
I can’t find any footage of that particular episode, but here’s one of English looking aggrieved after being asked about his involvement in a housing rort….
http://cdn.newsapi.com.au/image/v1/8e02ef407cce064a952a578e03a5bce5?width=650
And here’s one of someone English praised on RNZ this morning for his “relentless optimism and positivity”….
http://www.radionz.co.nz/assets/news/22085/eight_col_key_glum.jpg?1408311557
So Christian of him.
There’s also also a speech from 2002-3 where he said “The National Party is deeply rooted…. ( very long pause in best Lincoln public speaking style) in it’s membership”
Was delivered to an electorate or grey power meeting in Gore and remember it being broadcast, but could have just been audio on National Radio.
Hah! You sure it wasn’t “…deeply rooted……by it’s…”?
The delivery was so wooden and forced it was quite funny and has stuck in my mind since. It was pre-internet, and thankfully hasn’t turned up as a gif….yet
Get what you say about by, the same lot selected Todd Barclay to be our MP
Natz like to cheat so although great news noticing that the Natz have no suitable leaders to fill Key’s corporate + entertainment jack boots
English (corporate minus entertainment),
Bennett (entertainment minus corporate),
Coleman (void),
Collins (just plain scary, a bit like Missy from Dr Who)
I would not count a victory for the left yet.
Last election Labour should have won, but didn’t.
I think Labour will win….but only if Labour really work hard to collaborate, not get complacent, read the economic climate that seems to be declining (but not be doom and gloom party – lets solve Natz mistakes with some more taxes for voters!) and not repeat last elections mistakes.
The other thing we need ,save nz ,is some of the media to be on our side for a change. Their relentless sycophancy is extremely hard to combat.
I see BM and Puckish are into the denial stage. Although BM does have anger flowing through him at the best of times, so one can never be too sure.
Doubt it. If you had your finger on the pulse, you’d see that most nzers don’t want change at the moment. Anyone but bill would be big change. Big change will lose the next election.
“Use your aggressive feelings boy, let the hate flow through you.”
Big change will lose the next election.
Yes. Key’s whole schtick has been about not doing more than tinkering with Labour’s programme, and it’s served him well. Collins and Coleman maybe thought it was time some of the political capital that Key built up should be spent on an actual right-wing programme, but if they’d got their way they’d have found the political capital was Key’s, not National’s. Looks like a majority of their MPs are aware of it, even if Collins isn’t.
I wonder if Whaleoil will list himself as âcry baby of the weekâ
he’s a fucking idiot. Anyone else would have sunk National. No one likes Judith Collins. All she would have done is bought back the National of old, which the country has moved on from.
With reference to your previous comment infused, I would suggest your “most NZers ” is not what you think it is. Many people have fallen off Key’s wagon since the last election.
Interesting allegations being made over at Whaleoil
There is now deep divisions inside National.
English has threatened MPs.
Hekia Parata is playing a role in threatening and strong arming MPs.
As a result, anger is brewing within.
Whaleoil can no longer support National with Bill as leader and expects the Party to suffer an immediate tanking in the polls.
He believes John Keyâs legacy will be one of wrecking a successful government. And Bill English will make Andrew Little look dynamic.
Slater is a deluded fuckwit who still thinks he’s a player , he’s got about as much credibility as that other asshat Martyn Bradbury.
One wonders if his agenda is to undermine Bill in an effort to advance Collins?
Nevertheless, there could be some truth in what he’s asserted.
It seems the knives are being drawn and Key has even left yet.
Likely, but who gives a shit about him. He thinks far too highly of himself.
I know more about what is going on there than him. Like his back bencher comments. He has no clue.
It will be interesting to see if National suffer an immediate tanking in the polls.
Yep he is about as deluded as some here who think suddenly because jk goes Angry Andy, Wobbo and his green buddies suddenly become attractive, The recent polls would suggest otherwise, How much government support is simply the jk factor is not measured, only pm popularity in contrast to Mr 8pc and other contenders Time will tell, as early as the next poll. Here I will suggest the left will be devestated when they realise that their unpopularity is not an external jk issue but simply people are not buying their kool aid Hopefully this will lead to some deep soul searching and reflection on how KDS had blinded them to their real issues
I think you’ll find that objections to charter schools, for example, are based entirely on undisputed data, not KDS. Try and get past your emotion and look at the evidence.
Indeed. I’m not overly optimistic about a change of government next year. But some people are very worried about the poverty and inequalities, and hopefully desire for change will build over the next year or two.
Just listened to a concerned Dunedin Head teacher on Checkpoint, talking about the children who are not getting the help and support they need. She says they can easily end up on the wrong side of the law.
She talked about the costs of keeping people in prison, compared with the cost of provisions that will give children better futures, and help them stay out of prison.
Checkpoint tweets on it
Sooner or later Red(hopefully sooner ) the people will realise that the Right is wrong. Your free market policies of aspirational greed are destroying the decent society, and rapidly at that. Kiwis still have a sense of fairness and will respond accordingly.
What values make you vote for the Neo-liberal right?
“Aspiration” to maintain your tax free property portfolio and extract rents from working people.
@ Red….. (18.1.2 )
Hilarious !!!
Absolutely hilarious !!!!
Here is evidence of yet another neo liberal right winger who indulges in the use of recently invented acronyms that are not listed in either modern psychiatry or in the official English language …
However , we do have a word that IS included in the English language and that word fits people like Red perfectly .
SYCOPHANT.
Who are Wobbo and Mr 8pc ?
Kanye Slater is just being Kanye. Did you see his post when JK left “Prime Minister’s come and go, but I’ll always remain in Tel Aviv” of something hilarious like that.
Say what you like about conservatives, they can certainly organise an election. Sorry …. a selection.
Of fools.
No, no, it’s a divine anointing, we figured it out upthread đ
How many Nat voters will change their vote? I’m guessing: very few. Those who do are likely to go NZFirst, not Labour. Winston will not go Lab/Green/First.
Labour has a lot of work to do.
Mind you…. the almost guaranteed vote for the National party will be starting to dry up when immigration is returned to a more realistic equilibrium…
Hard times ahead for National when they have to campaign like REAL politicians now the pony tail puller has left them in the lurch….
Hold on to that thought.
They don’t need to change their vote that much, they can also just not show up at the election because the only thing they like about the Nats was John Key. That works just as well from the perspective of Labour and the Greens, even if it’s not exactly great for democracy.
Now, that said, I think polling is likely to prove over the next few months that National is gonna be a bit of a sinking ship post-Key, but I’m willing to revise my position if evidence doesn’t support it.
It only takes about a 3-5% shift towards Labour and the Greens to have them governing outright, depending on how accurate the sampling from polls has been.
“How many Nat voters will change their vote?”
Latest Fairfax-Nielsen Poll says potentially … 16%
(admittedly, that’s as a % of all respondents)
http://subzpsubzp.blogspot.co.nz/
English is a neo-liberal technocrat who opposes public sector provision of anything. That said, he doesn’t look like the sort of guy who will go round getting off on pulling ponytails or making out he is a ‘regular kiwi bloke’.
With Double Dipper informing us of his intention to increase social spending do not believe one word of it. He has a long term agenda which is drier than a really dry gin – it was only Key who held him back from completely dismantling the public service of this country. Key’s reasoning behind this was not altruisic, he was just a money trader so he gambled with the electorate, tempering down the right wing agenda and kept his eye on keeping in power so he could enjoy the selfies and big noting for which he loved so much. When situations became uncomfortable and he lacked the bottle for it – Pike River, inconvenient earthquakes and probing interviewers like Kim Hill he decided he couldn’t take the heat in the kitchen and piked.
I think Double Dipper is of the Jesuit kind of Catholic, enjoys being the stern punishing side of the church – he probably self flagellates at night to make himself feel rightous. Be careful, very careful what we wish for – having the jester in charge may not be as bad as what we are heading for with the Dipper calling the chips.
BDSM……LOL