She who channels her inner Monroe
Written By:
- Date published:
1:34 pm, March 22nd, 2023 - 138 comments
Categories: feminism, gender critical feminism -
Tags: kellie jay keen, Let Women Speak, Women Speak
Post by Lynn Williams. Originally published on twitter in early March.
Re the vexed questions posed by “she who channels her inner Monroe”, her apparent preparedness to ally with religious fundies and right wing extremists, and the predictable calls from sections of the left for her to be banned from entering/speaking in Australia and NZ.
My view on it is, if you sup with the devil, even if you use a very long spoon, you risk becoming the devil’s supper. The question is whether Kellie Jay Keen is merely looking for a free meal, or is she helping to plan and prepare the menu, and if the latter, who’s likely to be on it?
We surely all agree that religious ultra-conservatives and the secular ultra-right hold a range of political beliefs and positions which are inimical to women’s and rainbow rights, even to a narrow view of those rights as structured in law.
They want to roll back both formal equality and changes in the social contract which are arguably just as important. They’re capable of conducting witch hunts that would make the pink-hued, soft-focus McCarthyism of the so-called “progressive” trans allies look like a picnic.
There can be no safe alliance with such forces. Women will not get to use them to their advantage. That aside, viewed tactically, the extremes of both sides of this issue are NOT where the battle will be won – that’s in the broad centre.
The religious and secular right know this but the tactically challenged on the neo-liberal left have yet to realise it. If it came to a choice between an alliance with political and religious forces promoting patriarchal family values, and so-called gender progressives I’d have to choose the latter because, viewed more widely than the narrow prism of gender identity politics permits, I have more in common with most of them. That some of them are so blinded by the identity prism they cast socialist feminists as the enemy is their failing.
Despite the numbers in the broad left who are still in full knee-jerk mode, I see more common sense, political probity and tactical logic in putting my time and energy into promoting my views on gender identity on the left because it’s my political home base and I know I won’t change hearts and minds that are set in the millennia old cement of patriarchal monotheism and modern forms of ultra-conservatism – let alone make headway against all the other malign interests that are coat-tailing this issue for political and financial gain.
People on the left need to realise that the moment it suits the suits, i.e. whatever track the money train is currently on, corporate capitalism will switch from support for social transgressivism into support for social conservatism, and it will do so in a heart beat.
In a world teetering on the edge of a perfect storm of social and natural catastrophes, surely the broad left needs, more than at any point in human history, to be united. A start point would be to focus on why this relatively marginal issue has become the focus of so much political energy and investment of so much political capital. Who really benefits from it? Hint: it’s not women; it’s not the broad left, and it’s certainly not the genuinely vulnerable trans people at the heart of it.
End sermon.
138 comments on “She who channels her inner Monroe ”
- Comments are now closed
- Comments are now closed
CommentsOpinions
Recent Comments
FeedsPartyGovtMedia
- Weekly Roundup 22-November-2024
It’s another Friday and we’re inching closer to the end of the year. Here’s some of the stories that have caught our attention this week. This post, like all our work, is brought to you by a largely volunteer crew and made possible by generous donations from our readers and ...43 minutes ago - Beyond Question?
Record Numbers: The Hīkoi mō te Tiriti, which began at the tip of the North, and the tail of the South, on 11 November, culminated outside Parliament on Tuesday, 19 November 2024, in one of the largest demonstrations in New Zealand’s political history.ACCORDING TO TE ARA, the Ministry of Culture ...1 hour ago - The Rush To Blame “The Activists”
Activists are such easy scapegoats. The right and center have been conditioned for decades to roll their eyes at all protests. The left are easily aggravated over students leading movements they see as belonging to grownups, who have more important concerns like the economy and whether the trains come on ...1 hour ago - Cutting Through An Inundation of Dipshit Racists
Hi,Watching New Zealand from afar offers a strange perspective. It can be a good thing — distance from Aotearoa helped keep me sane while I reported on abuse at New Zealand’s biggest megachurch over the course of a year. It helps fuel my silly podcast. But it can also be ...2 hours ago - This is bad news
The speech yesterday by Treasury’s Chief Economic Advisor warning that the books are in worse shape than forecasted looks like it’s part of a softening-up process for either more cuts or a longer wait to get back into surplus. The speech was a highly unusual public preview of Treasury’s Half-Yearly ...4 hours ago - Skeptical Science New Research for Week #47 2024
Open access notables Projected increase in the frequency of extremely active Atlantic hurricane seasons, Lopez et al., Science Advances: Future changes to the year-to-year swings between active and inactive North Atlantic tropical cyclone (TC) seasons have received little attention, yet may have great societal implications in areas prone to hurricane ...13 hours ago - Chicken Kiev
Chatting in the supermarket this morning, I found I needed to lunge for the chicken drumsticks.Coping mechanisms: who hasn’t felt a greater need for them lately?When it all gets too much, I turn to demonstrating handy butchery hacks.It wasn’t that she’d said anything wrong, our friend, not at all. We ...16 hours ago - The year is 2024 and it’s 1984
This is written in response to the highly significant open letter from a group of economists that was today addressed to Christopher Luxon. The year is 2024, and it’s 1984. The country is reeling from a record Olympic medal gold haul, while the globe grapples with the choice of the ...17 hours ago - The IPCA has failed
Back in 2022, RNZ took an in-depth look at the "Independent" Police Conduct Authority and its handling of killings by police. These are the most serious test of oversight, and you would expect the police's use of lethal force to receive the most severe scrutiny. But despite the police regularly ...21 hours ago - Thursday 21 November 2024
The Hīkoi mō Te Tiriti arrived at Parliament on Tuesday – the size is being debated but estimates range from 42,000 to 100,000. The Prime Minister is defending not attending due to some of the organisers being affiliated with Te Pāti Māori. The national gang patch ban came into force ...21 hours ago - ‘These budget cuts are counter-productive and make no sense’
I spoke to former Productivity Chair Nana this morning about the letter he and a group of other economists sent to PM Christopher Luxon to urge the Government to urgently suspend cuts to spending and investment for the sake of the economy, struggling businesses and the wellbeing of vulnerable ...22 hours ago - ACT’s Astroturfing & A Co-ordinated Attack on Te Pati Māori
Unity on the Streets / Unity at the TableAfter the Hīkoi, all three right wing Coalition leaders came together to push the idea that the 42,000 - 50,000 + strong Hikoi was somehow less potent and brave, and more illegitimate than the energy and crowd displayed.Prime Minister Christopher Luxon 20-November: ...23 hours ago - Durability of carbon dioxide removal is critical for stabilizing temperatures
This is a re-post from the Climate Brink The world is emitting over 40 gigatons of CO2 per year, contributing to an accelerating warming of the planet. The world needs to cut emissions rapidly to be remotely on track to meet our Paris Agreement goals of limiting warming to well-below 2C, and we ...24 hours ago
- I Love My Leather Jacket
I wear my leather jacket like a great big hugRadiating charm - a living cloak of luckIt's the only concrete link with an absent friendIt's a symbol I can wear 'till we meet againOr it's a weight around my neck while the owner's freeBoth protector and reminder of mortalityIt's a ...1 day ago - Throwback Thursday: Will “Auckland Transport” Survive?
With Auckland Transport’s future up in the air under Mayor Wayne Brown’s proposed CCO reform, we’ve dug way back into the archives, to unearth this post originally published in March 2010. As you’ll see, many of the debates that were being had when AT was first proposed continue to ...1 day ago
- Economists call on PM to suspend budget cuts for the sake of the economy
Nicola Willis’ budget cuts are under fire from economists for having no clear rationale and worsening the recession. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāKia ora. Long stories short, here’s my top things to note in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty on Thursday, November 21: The news at ...1 day ago
- The end of policing by consent
National has appointed a new police commissioner. And he explicitly rejects policing by consent: Asked if he subscribed to policing by consent, he said he did not. “I don’t talk about policing by consent. I talk about trust and confidence, and it is fundamentally important that the police have ...2 days ago
- The Treaty Principles Bill: A Who’s Who
David Horatio Waterbed SeymourFringe politician and dweeb transformed successfully by ThinkTank money into a well-oiled soundbite robot.Currently programmed to say: Equal rights for all New Zealanders Equal rights for all New Zealanders Equal rights for all New Zealanders Was previously programmed to say:I am a proud libertarian andI am a ...2 days ago - Kinleith mill closure shows need for industrial strategy
NZCTU Te Kauae Kaimahi President Richard Wagstaff is calling on the Government to deliver an economic and industrial strategy for regional manufacturing, rather than just expressing sympathy for job losses, following the announced closure of Kinleith mill in Tokoroa. “The closure Kinleith mill in Tokoroa is not just devastating for ...2 days ago
- 27% of kids going hungry, up from 21% in a year
One in four Kiwi children live in households where food runs out often or sometimes. Photo: Getty ImagesKia ora. Long stories short, here’s my top things to note in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty on Wednesday, November 20: The lead: The official annual Health Survey found sharp ...2 days ago - Transport modelling is an illusion
This guest post by Tim Adriaansen, an advocate for accessibility and sustainable transport, originally published on LinkedIn and cross posted here with permission. People prefer cars, right? Probably not. Here’s why. Granted, most people in English-speaking countries use a car to get around. This simple reality underpins our transport ...2 days ago
- Young Maori take over
Neither Wellington nor Parliament has ever seen anything like it before. The Police said there were more than 40,000 but however many there were, yesterday’s Hikoi to Parliament was a monumental event. It was almost three times the Foreshore and Seabed martch of 2004 and many,many times bigger than ...2 days ago
- Gordon Campbell On The Hikoi Aftermath
The euphoria from yesterday’s hikoi may be transitory, but is no less valuable for that. It is pretty rare for the left to feel itself to be in the overwhelming majority, and speaking as the voice of the people. Lest that momentum be lost, the organisers will no doubt be ...2 days ago - Sabin 33 #3 – Solar panels generate too much waste and will overwhelm landfills
On November 1, 2024 we announced the publication of 33 rebuttals based on the report "Rebutting 33 False Claims About Solar, Wind, and Electric Vehicles" written by Matthew Eisenson, Jacob Elkin, Andy Fitch, Matthew Ard, Kaya Sittinger & Samuel Lavine and published by the Sabin Center for Climate Change Law at Columbia ...3 days ago
- What’s the time Mr Seymour?
Mr David Seymour crawling up to the ceilingThe sun don't shine the sun don't shine the sun don't shine at allMamma Pappa say you should go to school, I don't know what forNow that I've grown up and seen the world and all its liesSong: Southside of Bombay"Ake, ake, ake" ...3 days ago - Submit to defend te Tiriti!
The Justice Committee has called for submissions on National's racist and constitutionally radical Principles of the Treaty of Waitangi Bill. Submissions can be made at the link above or by post, and are due by Tuesday, 7 January 2025. But I'd get in quick, in case National grows a spine ...3 days ago
- We need to talk about Kevin
All happy families are alike; each unhappy family has a Drunk Uncle Kevin in there somewhere. If your Kevin is anything like the ones I know, he was getting along happily enough without having to think too much about the Treaty Principles Bill apart from bloody good job, onya guys ...3 days ago - The hikoi
Like everyone else (everyone who wasn't there, anyway), I've spent the morning watching the hikoi march on Parliament. The pictures are astounding: parliament grounds and the surrounding streets are full, and there are still people backed up along Lambton Quay. The police are estimating 35,000 people, and that's a floor ...3 days ago
- Why Govt & NZ Inc should boycott & regulate Facebook
3 days ago - How should we talk about change?
A better world isn’t just possible, it’s desirable. And that’s how we should frame a lot of our conversations around making a greater Auckland. As an example take urban climate action. A climate friendly Auckland: Is free from congestion Enables people to travel how they choose Is filled with ...3 days ago
- AMA + Holiday Webworm Merch!
3 days ago - Discount Code for Webworm Merch!
Hi,So there’s a bunch of new stuff on the Webworm store (www.webworm.store) — just in time for the Holidays. Read more ...3 days ago - Trying to defuse the tension
There were urgent moves yesterday at Parliament to try and defuse the tension building up over ACT’s Treaty Principles Bill. The Bill’s author, ACT leader David Seymour, told reporters that he understood the Justice Select Committee met yesterday to discuss how long it should take to consider submissions on the ...3 days ago
- An Irritable NZ Pawn – David Seymour Admits Treaty Principles Bill will clear the way for deve...
3 days ago - Gordon Campbell On The Hikoi Arrival, And Tyler Childers
Politicians like to bang on all about the need to heal society’s racial/economic divisions, but in their actions they’re more keen on stoking those divisions, with the Treaty Principles Bill being the classic example. The Bill seeks to dilute the Crown’s responsibilities to Māori at the same time as it ...3 days ago
- Socially Backwards and Fiscally Forwards: the False Ideological Divide and the “Conservative” Li...
3 days ago - Kaamos: Accepted
I appreciate that A Phuulish Fellow has been fairly quiet recently. That’s a combination of two things – comparatively little in the way of relevant material to discuss (at least until The War of the Rohirrim comes out next month), and my general work on The Secret Non-Fiction Writing Project. ...4 days ago - Here’s how governments could fix their Paris climate commitment failures
This is a re-post from Yale Climate Connections Governments around the world face a conundrum. Virtually none are on track to meet their Paris climate commitments. That includes the United States, which committed to cut its emissions at least 50% below 2005 levels by 2030 but is only on track for 32-43% cuts ...4 days ago
- Unstoppable.
4 days ago
- Katherine Trebeck – An Alternative Economic Narrative
The era of neoliberalism has been destructive on so many levels, with a huge growth in wealth and privilege for the one percent. A hollowing out of the state; fraying of the safety net; inadequate government investment in infrastructure; and continued environmental degradation has resulted in damage on a vast ...4 days ago - In a Manner of Speaking
In a manner of speakingI just want to sayThat I could never forget the wayYou told me everythingBy saying nothingOh, give me the wordsGive me the wordsThat tell me nothingOh, give me the wordsGive me the wordsThat tell me everythingSongwriter: Winston TongNext Tuesday, the subscription price for Nick’s Kōrero will ...4 days ago - Monday 18 November 2024
The NZNO have announced a nationwide strike for December over its pay dispute with Health NZ, who have put a 1 per cent cap on pay rises. The Hīkoi mō Te Tiriti and Treaty Principles Bill remain front and centre in the media, with the impacts of the Hana-Rawhiti Maipi-Clarke-led ...4 days ago
- Shipley warns Seymour’s bill is ‘inviting civil war’
The divisive Treaty Principles Bill is not just a risk for the National Party, it’s a risk to civil order and unity, warns a National Party grandee. Photo: Getty ImagesKia ora. Long stories short, here’s my top things to note in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty on ...4 days ago - A clearer network for the City Rail Link?
This post was originally published on Linked In by Nicolas Reid. It is republished here with permission. Auckland is now just a year or so away from having the keystone of its urban rail network complete. As I wrote about here, the City Rail Link will be a literal game changer for ...4 days ago
- National’s support base is wobbling
If ACT leader David Seymour intended the Treaty Principles Bill to drive a wedge into National’s support base, he may well already be succeeding. By midnight on Thursday after the Maori Party haka in Parliament, National MPs were being deluged with emails and messages from their members calling them out ...4 days ago
- 2024 SkS Weekly Climate Change & Global Warming News Roundup #46
A listing of 33 news and opinion articles we found interesting and shared on social media during the past week: Sun, November 10, 2024 thru Sat, November 16, 2024. Story of the week Our Story of the Week is completely "meta" (no, not that Meta). It's about our exploring how ...4 days ago
- Grifter Eftpos Tamaki at it again
..Thanks for reading Frankly Speaking ! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.Self-appointed “Bishop” and proto-fascist, Brian Tamaki was at it again on 16 November, blocking Auckland’s southern motorway, SH1.This time, the target of his ire wasn’t the Civil Unions Act; covid lock-downs; mask mandates; or ...5 days ago - Rip up a bill, lead a haka are words to live by
I cannot stop grabbing people by the lapels, or shoulders, or similar, and raving at them about the tiny miracles in my ears.I can hear again! There could not be a more satisfied customer in all the world.In a noisy cafe I am even catching words that Karren cannot, she ...5 days ago - Unintended Consequences
Take the baitYou pay the priceIt's much too lateFor good adviceYou know and I know that our good things' throughBecause there's consequences for what we doConsequences for me and youWriters: Kevin Robert Hayes, David Nagier, Bonnie Adele Hayes.Fallout from the first readingOne News began last night by saying that tens ...6 days ago - Thank you, driver!
Today, Saturday 16th of November, is Auckland Transport’s Bus Driver Appreciation Day! Saturday 16 November marks the third annual Auckland Transport (AT) ‘Bus Driver Appreciation Day’, and this year we are encouraging all of New Zealand to thank their driver or let the bus go first if you are in ...6 days ago
- Totally Normal: Holiday Edition
Hi,If I was to accurately sum up my mental state over the week, I’d just say that I got a huge fright from my own shadow.I’d nipped out for an 11pm neighborhood stroll, just to calm down after a day of stress and screens. The Cure and Fazerdaze’s new record ...6 days ago - We Are Not Listening
The current rise of populism challenges the way we think about people’s relationship to the economy.We seem to be entering an era of populism, in which leadership in a democracy is based on preferences of the population which do not seem entirely rational nor serving their longer interests. ...
7 days ago - More lawlessness from National
On Tuesday, sick of government stonewalling, the Waitangi Tribunal issued a rare court order, ordering the Minister of Health to release unredacted documents within 48 hours showing its reasoning for disestablishing Te Aka Whai Ora, the Māori Health Authority. The government's response to the lawful order of a court? Yeah, ...7 days ago
- National’s tyrannical “foreign interference” law
Yesterday, under cover the the biggest political fight of the year, National quietly - covertly, even - introduced anti-foreign interference legislation. The bill is the product of a years-long work-program aimed at countering shit like this and this, and there's unquestionably a need to do something to counter foreign states' ...7 days ago
- The Haka Represents The Best Of Us
A few months ago, I was in an audience watching a Haka-Kapa and as I watched children dance and sing and sway and shout and beat, I couldn’t help but think “The Haka represents the best of us.”Yes, yes - there will be a thousand voices that rush forth to ...7 days ago
- Adding up the climate cost
St Mary’s Bay housing left hanging: Climate risk is systemically underestimated in the climate scenarios used by central banks, and a new report warns 10,000 houses are set to become uninsurable in Aotearoa. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāLong stories short, here’s the top six news items of note in ...7 days ago
- Auckland chafing at Bishop’s housing intensification orders
One of the major problems the Government has in implementing its ‘going for housing growth’ strategy is that it isn’t giving much funding help to councils. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāKia ora. Long stories short, here’s my top things to note in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate and ...7 days ago - Friday 15 November 2024
The Treaty Principles Bill continues to dominate political news, with it passing its first reading in the House. Parliament was briefly suspended and Te Pāti Māori MP Hana-Rawhiti Maipi-Clarke suspended for 24 hours after leading a haka that was joined by opposition MPs and the public in the gallery. Willie ...7 days ago
- Weekly Roundup 15-November-2024
Happy Friday, welcome to another round-up of interesting stories about what’s happening in Auckland and other cities. Feel free to add your links in the comments! This post, like all our work, is brought to you by a largely volunteer crew and made possible by generous donations from our readers ...1 week ago
- Are We The Waiting?
And screamingAre we we are, are we we are the waitingAnd screamingAre we we are, are we we are the waitingForget me nots, second thoughts live in isolationHeads or tails and fairy tales in my mindAre we we are, are we we are the waiting unknownThe rage and love, the ...1 week ago - The Hoon around the week to November 15
The podcast above of the weekly ‘Hoon’ webinar for paying subscribers on Thursday night features co-hosts & talking about the week’s news with:The Kākā’s climate correspondent on the latest climate news, including from COP29 this week; on the US Presidential elections, Israel vs Gaza/Iran/Lebanon, Ukraine/Nato vs Russia/North ...1 week ago
- First Tea and Toast, now Milo — why do NZ’s best beverages need so much defending?
Only two months ago, Nicola Willis had to step in to stop Health New Zealand cutting tea and toast for post-birth parents, and now Lester Levy is riding to the rescue with a welcome message for all: our health workers can once again drink Milo, and will no longer need ...1 week ago - Gordon Campbell on the folly of making apologies in a social vacuum.
Day One of the Treaty Principles Bill…and everyone got what they wanted, and did what they liked. Heated words were exchanged. Culturally appropriate acts of outrage were performed. David Seymour got to play the victim card. Willie Jackson got kicked out of class. A comically red-faced Mr Speaker bellowed “Order, ...1 week ago
- Skeptical Science New Research for Week #46 2024
Open access notables Microbial solutions must be deployed against climate catastrophe, Peixoto et al., Nature Communications [comment]: The climate crisis is escalating. A multitude of microbe-based solutions have been proposed, and these technologies hold great promise and could be deployed along with other climate mitigation strategies. However, these solutions have ...1 week ago
- The PM gets some extremely valuable legal advice for free
You can pay a great deal of money for the services of a KC. So just what would some peerless legal writing from 40 or so of them be worth, do you reckon?Priceless, that’s what. It’s not even the half of it, but this is my favourite part of the ...1 week ago - D-day for the government
The government's Treaty Principles Bill is up for its first reading today - bought forward in a rush in a desperate effort to avoid the hikoi which is currently marching on Wellington. But the Prime Minister won’t be there for it – he’s literally running away to Peru! But he ...1 week ago
- 97% of submissions did not want no-cause evictions, Trump chooses a Russian spy for US Intelligence ...
Good morning, and I’m sorry I’ve been away for a couple of days.I’ve been focusing on the Hikoi, and also testing out sentiment on the Treaty Principles Bill. It’s complicated, and the Treaty Principles Bill will be debated in the House today. The Government’s own lawyers have told them the ...1 week ago - Government must vote down ACT Members Bill that would undermine workers’ rights
NZCTU Te Kauae Kaimahi President Richard Wagstaff is calling on the Government to vote down an ACT Party Members Bill that would undermine workers’ rights by making it easier for employers to fire workers. Last week ACT MP Laura Trask’s Employment Relations (Termination of Employment by Agreement) Amendment Bill was ...1 week ago
- Seymour causes thousands of unjustified absences by forcing kids to fight for their rights instead o...
The State would like to remind you that they are in control. They manage your employment prospects, and can destroy the job market you and yours rely on by mass-cancelling construction projects, cutting funding, and firing a good chunk of our public servants. They wield the mechanisms that provide scrutiny ...1 week ago - The Weight of the World
As the weight of the world Hangs on your shoulders The weight of the world Starts to take over again And over again All that you once loved, now you hate So slowly relearn how to meditate To have and to hold And never let go Can you feel it ...1 week ago - Thursday 14 November 2024
The Treaty Principles Bill is set to have its First Reading in the House today, as the Hīkoi mō Te Tiriti continues. More than 40 KCs have written to the Prime Minister and Attorney-General outlining their “grave concerns” about the substance of the Treaty Principles Bill, while an academic and ...1 week ago
- Trump’s return to White House brings the climate’s ‘find out’ phase closer
As we absorb the news of Trump's victory in the US Presidential election, here’s a wrap compiled just before the result of what it might mean for climate action: The UN Secretary General says the prospective departure of the United States would cripple the Paris Agreement, likening it to the ...1 week ago
- Time and Space in the City Centre
Patrick Reynolds is deputy chair of the City Centre Advisory Panel. The header image is from Walthamstow, London The city centre now has a few stretches of street where the space has been repurposed to a people and place focused design from full time traffic use. These are a great ...1 week ago
- An opportunity for a pro-growth tax switch
As the Hikoi against it swells into the tens of thousands, KCs call on National to kill off ACT’s divisive Treaty Principles Bill. Photo: Getty ImagesKia ora. Long stories short, here’s my top things to note in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty on Thursday, November 14: The ...1 week ago - Dealing to the big Aussie banks
The big question hovering over the Select Committee Inquiry into banking is what the Government will do with its findings. If yesterday’s hearing is anything to go by there is a tidal wave of discontent about the four big Australian Banks crashing through the Committee which may force it to ...1 week ago
- NZ’s global climate rankings plummet as Govt removes agriculture from ETS
The Government has passed legislation to remove agriculture from the Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS) while Aotearoa’s reputation on climate action plummets. ...15 hours ago - Failed boot camp experiment must end
As legislation to set up boot camps passed its first reading, the Green Party urged the Government to abandon this failed policy experiment for the good of our rangatahi. ...16 hours ago
- Gender-affirming care must centre evidence and health needs, not political posturing
The Ministry of Health has today released an evidence brief regarding the use of puberty blockers in gender-affirming healthcare, amid moves by the government to limit access. ...16 hours ago
- Release: National doesn’t care about manufacturing
The National Government is walking away from our manufacturing sector with constant reports of closures and job losses. ...18 hours ago - Release: David Parker speech – Piketty, Inequality and Climate Change
David Parker's speech from the University of Auckland's forum on Piketty, Inequality and Climate Change in September 2024. ...18 hours ago
- Release: Youth mental wellbeing no longer a priority for Child Poverty Minister
Louise Upston has revealed her diminished vision for vulnerable youth against a backdrop of snubbed advice, scrapped priorities, shifted goal posts and thousands more children projected to fall into poverty. ...19 hours ago
- Release: National’s lack of climate action taking NZ backwards
National Government’s backward-looking climate policy has seen New Zealand fall seven places on the Climate Change Performance Index to 41 out of 63 countries measured. ...19 hours ago
- Release: Simple reason for drop in emergency housing
When the Government says it has reduced the number of people in emergency housing, what it means is it is stopping people from accessing it in the first place. ...22 hours ago
- Govt’s child wellbeing strategy ‘shallow and shameful’
The Government is turning its back on children by not only weakening child poverty reduction targets, but also removing child mental wellbeing as a priority focus in their Child and Youth Wellbeing Strategy. ...23 hours ago
- Release: A historic win for Samoan communities
Labour warmly welcomes the Restoring Samoan Citizenship Bill as it passes its third reading, before becoming law. ...24 hours ago
- Government plan to reinstate live animal exports a “national disgrace”
The Government has taken a giant step backwards by reinstating live animal exports. ...2 days ago
- Pasifika justice as Member’s Bill passes final reading
Teanau Tuiono’s Member’s Bill, the Citizenship (Western Samoa Restoration) Amendment Bill, has passed its third reading and will become law. ...2 days ago
- Release: Minister of Education thinks New Zealand ends at the Bombay Hills
The Minister of Education has shown complete disregard for rural communities and their school bus routes in Question Time today. ...2 days ago
- Economists sound alarm on Government’s slash-and-burn approach
A group of prominent economists has released an open letter to the Government, raising grave concerns about the far-reaching consequences of its fiscal policy. ...2 days ago
- Release: Smoking numbers up under Costello’s watch
National’s repeal of Labour’s smokefree legislation has taken New Zealand further away from achieving a Smokefree 2025 and a smokefree generation. ...2 days ago
- Release: Call for Palestine recognition by NZ, Australian and Canadian MPs
Parliamentarians from Australia, Canada and New Zealand have written an open letter to their respective Prime Ministers calling on them to recognise Palestine. ...2 days ago
- Justice Select Committee opens floor for Treaty Principles submissions
Today, the Justice Select Committee has decided to officially open submissions for the controversial Treaty Principles Bill. ...3 days ago
- Power of the people on full display as hīkoi approaches Parliament
Today, Hīkoi mō te Tiriti arrived in Wellington, with thousands gathering to march in unity against the divisive Treaty Principles Bill. ...3 days ago
- Hypocrisy as Te Whatu Ora contractor bill balloons
Te Whatu Ora’s bill for contracting and consulting staff has ballooned by nearly 20 percent under the National Government, breaking a promise they made during the election campaign to cut contractors. ...4 days ago
- Release: Growing pressure to scrap Section 7AA Repeal Bill
The newly released Section 7AA Repeal Bill's select committee report is further evidence that the Government should scrap it. ...5 days ago
- Government’s move to monetise access to nature a slippery slope
The Green Party is voicing serious concerns over the Government’s proposal to charge for access to public conservation land, released today. ...7 days ago
- Green Party condemns the passage of Treaty Principles Bill
The Green Party condemns the passing of the Treaty Principles Bill at first reading, and is clear that the fight is not over. ...1 week ago
- Stand Up for Te Tiriti
Te Tiriti o Waitangi is our country’s founding document. It forms the basis of the relationship between Māori and the Crown – and the Aotearoa New Zealand we live in today. ...1 week ago
- Release: Over 15,000 sign Labour’s open letter to Luxon
As the hīkoi to Parliament continues, Labour has sent an open letter to Prime Minister Christopher Luxon in a last-ditch attempt to get him to kill the Treaty Principles Bill. ...1 week ago
- Fast Track Bill threatens environment, climate and reputation
The fast-track legislation passing its second reading in Parliament is another step towards environmental ruin. ...1 week ago
- Greens join King’s Counsel in calling for Treaty Principles Bill to be abandoned
The Prime Minister must answer the call from a group of senior lawyers of the King’s Counsel to abandon the divisive Treaty Principles Bill. ...1 week ago
- Chris Hipkins’ apology statement to state and faith-based care survivors
...1 week ago
- Release: Labour formally apologises to state and faith-based care survivors
Labour joins with the Government in unreservedly apologising for the abuse, neglect and trauma including torture in state and faith-based care and for ignoring the voices of survivors for too long. ...1 week ago
- Green Party stands in support of survivors of abuse in care
Today, the Green Party stands alongside the survivors of abuse in state care and faith-based care as the Government issues an historic apology. ...1 week ago
- Green Party calls for conscience vote on Treaty Principles Bill
The Green Party has written to the Speaker of the House requesting he enable a personal vote on the Treaty Principles Bill. ...2 weeks ago
- Govt move to exclude journalist risks chilling effect
The Green Party is alarmed by the Government’s move to exclude a journalist from covering this week’s apology for the survivors of abuse in state and faith-based care. ...2 weeks ago
- Without action, an apology will be empty air
For tomorrow’s apology to survivors of abuse in state and faith-based care to hold any water, the Government must not pursue the same policies that drove the abuse in the first place. ...2 weeks ago
- Release: Concerns remain over tobacco interference
Concerns about the tobacco industry’s ability to interfere in government policy making remain, despite the inability of the Office of the Auditor-General to investigate the Government’s decision to halve the excise tax on heated tobacco products. ...2 weeks ago
- Urgent wake-up call on climate
The Climate Change Commission’s latest advice indicates Aotearoa needs to be stepping up on climate action. ...2 weeks ago
- Green MP’s Meme-ber’s Bill set to save the world
Break out the punchlines and dust off your meme folder: Green Party MP Kahurangi Carter’s Copyright (Parody and Satire) Amendment Bill was pulled from the Ballot yesterday. ...2 weeks ago
- Release: Poroporoaki: Ta Robert (Bom) Gillies
Kua hinga te manawa kairākau o Te Rua Tekau Ma Waru Tiwhatiwha te po! Kakarauru i te po! Ka rapuhia kei hea koe kua riro! Haere e te Ika a Whiro ki o tini hoa kua ngaro atu ki te Pō ...2 weeks ago
- Labour, Greens and Te Pāti Māori call on the Prime Minister to block the Treaty Principles Bill
The opposition parties stand united for an Aotearoa that honours Te Tiriti, rather than seeking to rewrite it. Labour, the Greens and Te Pāti Māori are working together against the Government’s divisive Treaty Principles Bill. ...2 weeks ago
- Release: Labour, Greens and Te Pāti Māori call on the Prime Minister to block the Treaty Principle...
The opposition parties stand united for an Aotearoa that honours Te Tiriti, rather than seeking to rewrite it. Labour, the Greens and Te Pāti Māori are working together against the Government’s divisive Treaty Principles Bill. ...2 weeks ago
- NZ must pursue independent foreign policy
The Green Party says the need is greater than ever for Aotearoa New Zealand to pursue an independent foreign policy. ...2 weeks ago
- Release: Winston Peters must apologise
The Deputy Prime Minister should apologise to the public servant he named and blamed for something they did not do, and for misusing the rules of Parliament. ...2 weeks ago
- Government action provides Southland farmers more time to meet plan requirements
The Government is taking action to ensure Southland farmers and growers are not affected by unreasonable regional farm plan deadlines, Agriculture Minister Todd McClay, Environment Minister Penny Simmonds and Associate Environment Minister Andrew Hoggard say.“Cabinet has agreed to provide more time for farmers and growers to comply with regional rules ...16 hours ago - Bill reaffirms Government’s commitment to crack down on serious youth offending
The Oranga Tamariki (Responding to Serious Youth Offending) Bill had its first reading at Parliament today. The Bill reaffirms the Government’s commitment to crack down on serious youth offending, Minister for Children Karen Chhour says. “In recent years we have seen an unacceptable spike in youth offending. “This Bill makes ...16 hours ago
- Critical milestones for earthquake buildings review
Fairer, more sensible rules about managing earthquake risks are a step closer with the passing of legislation and the appointment of an independent chair to provide expert advice, Minister for Building and Construction Chris Penk says. “The Government is committed to reinvigorating our cities and regions to support economic growth, ...17 hours ago
- State of the art radiology machine for Auckland
People in Northland and Auckland will benefit from a new machine for cancer treatment installed at the Regional Cancer and Blood Service at Auckland City Hospital. The MV5 linear accelerator, or LINAC machine, officially opened today targets cancer tumours with pinpoint accuracy. Health Minister Dr Shane Reti says this new, ...17 hours ago
- Foreign Minister to visit Europe
Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Minister Winston Peters will travel to Europe for high-level talks with France, Germany and the United Kingdom next week. "Since taking office almost a year ago, the Coalition Government has emphasised the importance we place on New Zealand's traditional and likeminded diplomatic and ...18 hours ago
- First arrests made under gang patch ban
Police have made their first arrests under the new gang patch legislation, with two gang members arrested, says Police Minister Mark Mitchell. “Just before 11 this morning, Police in Wairoa apprehended a gang member for wearing a patch to the supermarket. He has been arrested and will now face enforcement ...19 hours ago
- Better support for victims of sexual violence
The Government is proposing two major changes to name suppression laws that will put the views of victims of sexual violence first, Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith says. “We are committed to restoring law and order and these two proposed changes will help ensure the victims of crime are put at ...20 hours ago
- Government moving forward with Regional Deals
Cabinet has agreed to invite all regions to submit proposals for Regional Deals between central and local government that drive economic growth and deliver the infrastructure our country needs, Local Government Minister Simeon Brown and Infrastructure Minister Chris Bishop say. Inviting all regions to propose a Regional Deal that boosts ...20 hours ago
- MSA pilot participant update
One of the ten young men selected to participate in the Military-Style Academy Pilot has allegedly reoffended. Children’s Minister Karen Chhour is disappointed but says it would be naïve to think that none of these young men would reoffend. “I’m saddened that this young person has not taken this opportunity ...21 hours ago
- Attendance rates increase, again
Associate Education Minister David Seymour says that school attendance is continuing to rise. In Term 3 of 2024 51.3 per cent of students attended school regularly, an increase of 5.3 percentage points from 46 per cent in Term 3 of 2023. “This Government has prioritised student attendance and it is ...22 hours ago
- Improving the lives of young New Zealanders
Ensuring New Zealand is the best place in the world for children and young people is the vision at the heart of the Government’s new Child and Youth Strategy, Child Poverty Reduction Minister Louise Upston says. “Childhood represents a huge opportunity to set people on a positive path towards living ...1 day ago
- Government continues work to reinstate livestock exports by sea
The Government is reinstating the trade of livestock exports by sea while ensuring the highest standards of animal welfare, says Associate Minister of Agriculture Andrew Hoggard.“The Government will introduce legislation changes to reinstate the trade, enhance oversight, and strengthen requirements for exporters to identify risks and manage the welfare of ...2 days ago
- Speech to the National Quality Forum 2024
Tēnā koutou katoa – it is a pleasure to be here today. I would like to begin by acknowledging the important leadership role you all play in ensuring a quality health system New Zealanders can trust. There is enormous clinical expertise in this room covering a wide range of disciplines. ...2 days ago
- New Zealand’s COP29 National Statement
Tēnā koutou katoa. Mr President, Excellencies, Delegates. New Zealand, and all nations represented here today, are already dealing with the impacts of climate change. Our households, businesses, and economies are bearing the costs of its effects. The choices we make now will shape the severity of these impacts for generations ...2 days ago
- Latest Quarterly Investment Report released
The Government has released its second Quarterly Investment Report (QIR) which shows substantial work still to be done by agencies to improve investment reporting and meet the Government’s expectations, Infrastructure and Acting Finance Minister Chris Bishop says. “New Zealand has significant infrastructure and investment needs. The Government is determined to get ...2 days ago
- New Zealand supporting loss and damage fund
Climate Change Minister Simon Watts announced New Zealand will contribute NZ$10 million to the new Fund for Responding to Loss and Damage while at the annual United Nations Climate Change Conference (COP29) in Baku, Azerbaijan. “New Zealand is joining the global effort to address the significant challenge of responding to ...2 days ago
- Gang crackdown begins at stroke of midnight
The free ride for gangs is over when the clock strikes midnight tonight, with tough new laws officially coming into effect, Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith and Police Minister Mark Mitchell say. “Gang patches will no longer be able to be worn in public. To earn the right to wear a ...2 days ago
- LGFA increases borrowing capacity to support high growth councils
The Government is welcoming the decision by the Local Government Funding Agency to increase access to financing tools for fast growing councils to support greater investment in critical infrastructure, Local Government Minister Simeon Brown says.“Communities across the country are facing an infrastructure deficit and significant population growth is projected in ...2 days ago
- Temporary Traffic Management costs revealed
The Government has revealed that over the past three years, the New Zealand Transport Agency (NZTA) has spent an eyewatering $786 million of taxpayers’ money on road cones and temporary traffic management (TTM), Transport Minister Simeon Brown says.“When I became Minister, I was surprised to learn that that NZTA did ...2 days ago
- Jurisdiction of Disputes Tribunal to double
Legislation that will double the financial jurisdiction of the Disputes Tribunal from $30,000 to $60,000 has passed first reading in Parliament today, Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith. “We need to improve court timeliness and access to justice so that Kiwis and get on with their lives. Court delays affect everyone, the ...3 days ago
- Protecting New Zealand from foreign interference
Legislation that will specifically criminalise foreign interference and strengthen espionage offences has passed first reading in Parliament today, Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith says. “It is normal and appropriate for states to interact and work to influence one another. This encourages cooperation and can have mutually beneficial outcomes. “However, the reality ...3 days ago
- Significant milestone for Canterbury Road of National Significance
Transport Minister Simeon Brown has welcomed news that the NZ Transport Agency (NZTA) Board has approved funding towards pre-implementation and early works on the State Highway 1 (SH1) Belfast to Pegasus Motorway and Woodend Bypass Road of National Significance (RoNS). “Reaching this significant milestone is a reflection of our Government’s ...3 days ago
- Health survey results to help drive change
Health Minister Dr Shane Reti says findings from the annual Health Survey highlight the need to continue driving better health outcomes for New Zealanders. The New Zealand Health Survey is an annual snapshot of key metrics measured from July 2023 – July 2024. Findings released this morning include: In 2023/24, ...3 days ago
- Final push needed to get to Smokefree 2025
A renewed effort to get people to quit smoking will build on what has worked to date and target the groups who most need support, Associate Health Minister Casey Costello said today. “The latest New Zealand Health Survey results show the daily smoking rate at 6.9 per cent and we ...3 days ago
- New diplomatic appointments
Foreign Affairs Minister Winston Peters has announced four new diplomatic appointments. “Our diplomats play an important role in ensuring New Zealand’s interests are maintained and enhanced across the world,” Mr Peters says. “It is a pleasure to announce the appointment of these senior diplomats from the Ministry of Foreign ...3 days ago
- Next steps for Regulatory Standards Bill
Regulation Minister David Seymour has today announced the next steps in the Government’s plan improve the quality of regulation by opening consultation on a proposed Regulatory Standards Bill. “New Zealand's low wages can be blamed on low productivity, and low productivity can be blamed on poor regulation,” says Mr Seymour. ...3 days ago
- Red Tape Tipline goes live
Minister for Regulation David Seymour has today announced that the Ministry for Regulation’s Red Tape Tipline is now live. “We want to hear about your red tape horror stories. From today, New Zealanders will have a say on how they are regulated through an online portal,” says Mr Seymour. The ...3 days ago
- Youth Parliament 2025 announced
The Minister for Youth Matt Doocey has today announced the eleventh Youth Parliament will be taking place in 2025. “Youth Parliament offers a unique youth development opportunity to young people from across New Zealand to experience the political process and learn about how government works,” says Mr Doocey. “The two-day ...4 days ago
- Police stats show promising change
After nearly a year in Government, Kiwis have seen significant change across law and order with promising early results shown across some Police statistics, says Police Minister Mark Mitchell. “In August 2023, I told New Zealanders that if they had not started to see a change in public safety within ...4 days ago
- Better coordination of anti-scam efforts
With the launch of Fraud Awareness Week, the Government is committing to new coordination efforts across industry and government to combat online scams, Commerce and Consumer Affairs Minister Andrew Bayly says. “Online financial scams are a growing problem for New Zealand. New data released today shows that Kiwis lost nearly ...4 days ago
- Minister to consider 7AA select committee report
Minister for Children Karen Chhour will consider the recommendations made by the Social Services and Community Committee in its report back to Parliament on the Oranga Tamariki (Repeal of Section 7AA) Amendment Bill. “I want to thank the people who made submissions and those who appeared before the committee in ...4 days ago
- Defence Minister to attend ASEAN meeting
Defence Minister Judith Collins will this week attend the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) Defence Ministers’ Meeting-Plus in Vientiane, Laos. “We need to take every opportunity to engage with our international partners, given the increasingly unstable geo-political situation,” Ms Collins says. “New Zealand has a long-standing commitment to this ...4 days ago
- Launching the White Ribbon Ride
The Minister for the Prevention of Family and Sexual Violence, Karen Chhour, was on hand to wish riders well at the start of the North Island leg of the White Ribbon Ride in Whakatāne this morning. The ride helps mark the International Day for the Elimination of Violence against Women, ...5 days ago
- Construction to begin on next stage of Papakura to Drury
Construction on the next stage of the SH1 Papakura to Drury project will begin early next month, with the contract for works awarded to Fulton Hogan, Transport Minister Simeon Brown says. "SH1 Papakura to Drury is a key project that will drive economic growth and productivity, reduce congestion, and enable people ...6 days ago
- NZ signs trade deal with Costa Rica, Iceland and Switzerland
Trade and Agriculture Minister Todd McClay has signed a pioneering trade agreement that prioritises New Zealand’s sustainable exports at a ceremony during APEC in Peru today. “The Agreement on Trade and Sustainability (ACCTS), between Costa Rica, Iceland, and Switzerland was concluded in July of this year and opens up significant ...6 days ago
- Government and iwi work together on aquaculture
Five new Aquaculture Settlement Areas will help ensure Ngāi Tahu shares in the opportunities aquaculture offers for Southland’s economy, Oceans and Fisheries Minister Shane Jones says. “The Aquaculture Settlement Areas (ASAs) I’m announcing today set aside space so the Crown and Ngāi Tahu can assess their potential for aquaculture development. ...7 days ago
- Government launches review to ensure electricity market is fit-for-purpose
The terms of reference for a review of the performance of the electricity market have been released. The review, initiated by the Coalition Government during the power crisis in winter will look at whether current regulations and market design support economic growth and access to reliable and affordable electricity, Energy Minister ...7 days ago
- Speech to Social Investment Hui: Jack and his whānau need our help
Kia ora koutou katoa. Nau mai, haere mai, piki mai. Ki te mihi atu ahau, ki te manwhenua nei, Te Atiawa, Ngāti toa rangatira, tēnā koutou, tēnā koutou, tēnā koutou katoa. Thank you, Andy, for your introduction. Let me acknowledge you as the new Chief Executive of the Social Investment ...7 days ago
- Minister of State for Trade heads to Brisbane for PACER Plus meeting
Minister of State for Trade Nicola Grigg has travelled to Australia to attend the PACER Plus Ministers Meeting in Brisbane. “Trade plays a critical role in driving employment, economic growth, and improving the standards of living in the Pacific Region. The Government is strongly committed to supporting Pacific Island countries ...7 days ago
- Proposals to modernise conservation released
Toitū te taiao – Our environment endures The Government is consulting on proposals to modernise New Zealand’s conservation management system, aiming to protect relevant natural areas while supporting sustainable growth in tourism and regional economies, Conservation Minister Tama Potaka says. “Today, the Department of Conservation – Te Papa Atawhai is ...1 week ago
- Knowing superstitions aren’t real doesn’t stop us behaving superstitiously – why?
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Stephanie Gomes-Ng, Senior Lecturer of Psychology, Auckland University of Technology Getty Images Former New Zealand prime minister John Key has three white rabbits painted on his helicopter, a nod to his “massively superstitious” habit of repeating “white rabbits” three times at ...2 hours ago - Government slammed for pushing ahead with boot camps while trial still under way
The coalition has "absolutely no intention of listening to the evidence that comes out of their experiment", Labour MP says. ...3 hours ago - Smoke and mirrors in heated tobacco debate
Labour claims Government is ‘cherry-picking’ smoking trends data to hide decade-first increase in daily smokers The post Smoke and mirrors in heated tobacco debate appeared first on Newsroom. ...3 hours ago - Smoke and mirrors in tobacco debate
Labour claims Government is ‘cherry-picking’ smoking trends data to hide decade-first increase in daily smokers The post Smoke and mirrors in tobacco debate appeared first on Newsroom. ...3 hours ago
- Treasury bangs the drum on ‘unsustainable’ superannuation
The Government’s economic adviser is sending a message it doesn’t want to hear – superannuation is increasingly unaffordable The post Treasury bangs the drum on ‘unsustainable’ superannuation appeared first on Newsroom. ...3 hours ago
- Victims of sex offending welcome shift on name suppression laws
A man abused by a former political figure is "immensely relieved" at a government proposal to end secrecy around sex offenders' identities. ...3 hours ago
- This week three parties stood together – can they withstand the storm to come?
There is plenty yet to play out, but the next election is at this rate shaping up as trio versus trio, writes Toby Manhire. A subplot of this week’s historic hīkoi mō te Tiriti has been the sight of the three opposition parties presenting a unified front. Te Pāti Māori ...4 hours ago - All 33 malls in Auckland ranked from worst to best
From the low lows of abandon empires to the high highs of a mall done just right. This is the second in the Malls of New Zealand series, where we rank the malls in major centres. Next week: Wellington. A note from the editor: This is the hardest ranking we’ve ...4 hours ago
- The cost of being: A clothes-mad 20-something who walks everywhere
As part of our series exploring how New Zealanders live and our relationship with money, a 27-year-old apartment-dwelling marketing exec explains her approach to spending and saving. Want to be part of The Cost of Being? Fill out the questionnaire here. Gender: Female. Age: 27. Ethnicity: Pākehā. Role: Marketing exec at ...4 hours ago
- Newsroom daily quiz, Friday 22 November
Loading…(function(i,s,o,g,r,a,m){var ql=document.querySelectorAll('A[data-quiz],DIV[data-quiz]'); if(ql){if(ql.length){for(var k=0;k<ql.length;k++){ql[k].id='quiz-embed-'+k;ql[k].href="javascript:var i=document.getElementById('quiz-embed-"+k+"');try{qz.startQuiz(i)}catch(e){i.start=1;i.style.cursor='wait';i.style.opacity='0.5'};void(0);"}}};i['QP']=r;i[r]=i[r]||function(){(i[r].q=i[r].q||[]).push(arguments)},i[r].l=1*new Date();a=s.createElement(o),m=s.getElementsByTagName(o)[0];a.async=1;a.src=g;m.parentNode.insertBefore(a,m)})(window,document,'script','https://take.quiz-maker.com/3012/CDN/quiz-embed-v1.js','qp');Got a good quiz question? Send Newsroom your questions.The post Newsroom daily quiz, Friday 22 November appeared first on Newsroom. ...4 hours ago
- Daily crossword, Friday 22 November
The post Daily crossword, Friday 22 November appeared first on Newsroom. ...4 hours ago
- China likely to strengthen regional relationships in response to another Trump term
Opinion: Recent discussions in Shanghai provide some insight into what’s likely to be on the table The post China likely to strengthen regional relationships in response to another Trump term appeared first on Newsroom. ...4 hours ago
- Nuclear winters know no borders
Opinion: The immediate horror of nuclear weapon explosions – the blinding flash, crushing blast wave, and radioactive inferno – is well documented.But what nuclear-armed nations either don’t grasp or won’t admit, is far more chilling: how their weapons could devastate even countries thousands of kilometres from any mushroom clouds.The collapse ...4 hours ago
- This week’s bestselling books – November 22
FICTION1 Kāwai: Tree of Nourishment by Monty Soutar (David Bateman, $39.99)Sample dialogue, all from one chapter:“That can’t be,” replied Taona doubtfully.“You were right. The pā is unnervingly quiet,” Taona murmured.“The Hākuwai,” Motukia breathed. “Our grandfathers told us they rarely saw the Hākuwai in daylight,” Motukia muttered.“Their fight would have been futile ...4 hours ago
- Burma the flying elephant
After about two and a half years of planning and waiting, New Zealand’s last elephant has moved to her new home at Monarto Safari Park in South Australia.Burma and her “human herd”, that is, her keepers, arrived last week, and she’s settling in well, according to Auckland Zoo’s Andrew Coers.“Something ...4 hours ago
- NZ’s membership of Beyond Oil and Gas Alliance in jeopardy
Senior ministers in the coalition suggested NZ’s membership will be re-evaluated if it restarts offshore oil and gas drilling The post NZ’s membership of Beyond Oil and Gas Alliance in jeopardy appeared first on Newsroom. ...4 hours ago
- Raw Politics: Six months in a leaky Bill
Prime Minister Christopher Luxon did not meet the Treaty Principles Bill hikoi crowd, sees “nothing” of merit in the Act-proposed law but the Parliament his Government dominates will spend six months debating a “divisive” measure.That’s because he has accepted there needs to be “aeration” of people’s views on the Treaty, ...4 hours ago
- Taken to the brink, Govt is now close to selling big Whakapapa ski field
Bidder Whakapapa Holdings walked away from the sales process last year, but says it’s now ‘95% there’ on a purchase agreement – so who blinked first? The post Taken to the brink, Govt is now close to selling big Whakapapa ski field appeared first on Newsroom. ...4 hours ago
- Watts nears a landmark deal on global carbon trading
A framework for global carbon trading under the Paris Agreement is finally nearing completion at COP29 in Baku, Azerbaijan after years of halting talks.Climate Change Minister Simon Watts is one of two ministers tasked by the COP29 hosts with landing a long-sought deal on Article 6 of the climate accord, ...4 hours ago
- Grattan on Friday: Marles plays a defensive bat on nuclear as the government rushes to get though la...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra Richard Marles is an ambitious man who hasn’t given up the dream of one day reaching the top job. But, despite being deputy prime minister, his profile is much lower than that of Treasurer Jim ...9 hours ago
- Fears Māori will pay heaviest price if police carry guns
"Overwhelmingly, those people who die will be young Māori men," the spokesperson for People Against Prisons Aotearoa says. ...11 hours ago
- NEW POLL: Kiwis Overwhelmingly Support MPs’ Expenses Transparency Law Change
62% of respondents support the extension of the OIA to cover MPs’ spending, compared to just 13% opposed and 24% were unsure. ...11 hours ago - The House: Meanwhile, a week of passing law
The political week has been packed with worthy distractions, but all week Parliament has focused on passing new laws. Here are the highlights. ...11 hours ago
- The biggest difference between Hīkoi mō te Tiriti and past hīkoi: More support from non-Māori
Analysis - The diversity of voices during the hīkoi was noticeable - from tangata moana to young immigrants to elderly Pākehā from the South Island. ...12 hours ago
- The House: Samoan citizenship restoration – ‘It means we belong to this land’
When the bill to restore NZ citizenship to some Samoans passed this week, Parliament's galleries were full to the brim with members of the community. ...13 hours ago
- More Delays In Action On Use Of Puberty Blockers With Children
Women’s Rights Party Co-leader Jill Ovens says the Ministry has put New Zealand children at risk by continuing to allow “off-label” prescribing of puberty blockers at far higher rates than other similar countries. ...14 hours ago
- Police Minister adamant he wasn’t aware of gang members training at gun clubs
That is despite two papers from police that raised the matter with him. ...14 hours ago
- Shorten declares himself ‘a proud moderate’, saying Australians ‘in the middle’ shouldn’t ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra Bill Shorten has declared himself “a proud moderate” in a valedictory speech declaring parliament has the responsibility to ensure the extremes of left and right do not set the terms of political debate. Shorten, ...15 hours ago
- New ‘best practice’ principles for superannuation products are coming. We asked a panel of exper...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Matt Garrow, Editorial Web Developer Studio Romantic/Shutterstock We all know how important it is to save enough money for retirement – but what about spending it wisely when we get there? Even for those who have built up a suitable ...15 hours ago
- Government accused of betraying Kiwis’ trust over lack of consultation on live exports
The government has always vowed to reinstate live exports by sea, which was banned by the previous Labour government. ...15 hours ago
- 7 things you can do if you think you sweat too much
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Michael Freeman, Associate Professor of Dermatology, Bond University ERIK Miheyeu/Shutterstock Sweating is our body’s way of cooling down, a bit like an internal air conditioner. When our core temperature rises (because it’s hot outside, or you’re exercising), sweat glands all ...15 hours ago
- Phenergan for under 6s is now banned due to hallucination fears. Here’s what to use instead
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Nial Wheate, Professor of Pharmaceutical Chemistry, Macquarie University Australia’s drug regulator has issued a safety warning over the medicine Phenergan and related products containing the antihistamine drug promethazine. The Therapeutic Goods Administration said the over-the-counter products should not be given to children ...15 hours ago
- A new stage adaptation of Peter Carey’s Jack Maggs is a delightful homage to theatrical storytelli...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Catherine Campbell, Lecturer, Performing Arts, UniSA Creative, University of South Australia Matt Byrne/STCSA Jack Maggs is a delight and a homage to theatrical storytelling in Australia. Based on Peter Carey’s bestselling novel, Jack Maggs follows the ex-convict as he lands ...15 hours ago
- The government has introduced laws for its social media ban. But key details are still missing
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Daniel Angus, Professor of Digital Communication, Director of QUT Digital Media Research Centre, Queensland University of Technology Ron Lach/Pexels The federal government today introduced into parliament legislation for its social media ban for people under 16 years. Communications Minister Michelle ...16 hours ago
- Archives NZ, National Library to cut 27 roles
The Department of Internal Affairs wants to bring the two organisations under the joint leadership of the Chief Archivist and National Librarian. ...16 hours ago
- Gang patch ban: Members warn of potential for violence to ‘erupt’ as new laws enforced
"I can't see this lasting unless they have a budget to lock fullas up in jail which I think is absolutely stupid, really it's ludicrous," Ngavii Pekapo, who set up a Mongrel Mob chapter 54 years ago, says. ...16 hours ago
- ACT leader David Seymour raises doubts about Waikato medical school
Government documents show ACT leader David Seymour told the government he was "dissatisfied" with a cost-benefit analysis. ...16 hours ago
- National’s Erica Stanford allegedly calls Labour’s Jan Tinetti a ‘stupid bitchR...
The Education Minister has apologised in Parliament for her remark. ...16 hours ago
- Labour backs new Police Commissioner – but warns against routine arming
The alternative to policing by consent would be a police state, which New Zealanders don't want, the party says. ...18 hours ago
- Youth on boot camp pilot re-offended five weeks after release
Children's Minister Karen Chhour said while it was disappointing, it would naïve to think none of the participants would lapse. ...18 hours ago
The server will be getting hardware changes this evening starting at 10pm NZDT.
The site will be off line for some hours.
NZ Herald have a piece by Bryon Clark asking the Minister of Immigration to refuse KJK entry. It's got some inaccuracies in it and some omissions. There's a fair amount of bias in the MSM coverage, so it's worth pointing out the details here.
https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/byron-clark-an-open-letter-to-the-minister-of-immigration-about-anti-trans-activist-posie-parker/ZPTRWH4ZDJHOHCE6JTSYIFRK5Y/
https://twitter.com/aniobrien/status/1638306173396090880
https://www.districtcourts.govt.nz/assets/secure/2023-02-21/d237647a0a/2022-NZDC-23665_R-v-Burgess.pdf
From NZH's own piece on the arson,
https://twitter.com/SelinaStreet100/status/1638334073964986369
Ani is also repeating inaccuracies. From the article:
Thanks arkie – hate crimes (and slurs) against LGBTQ and non-binary communities do happen. Why is it apparently important to some people that the Rainbow Youth building arson in Tauranga not be considered a hate crime?
Possibly accuracy.
But then
'I couldn't possibly comment'
Accuracy is "possibly" an important consideration for some – I was thinking more about the other 'some', and there will be some (unavoidable) overlap.
Best of luck to all who are and/or feel under attack, which will cover pretty much everyone – if it doesn't already.
Sorry I don't follow you and not really interested in doing a cryptic cross word.
Unless it is accurate it is misinformation.
After seeing the world at Covid time and reading all the misinformation and seeing the people damaged by it I have no time for misinformation.
Say loud say it proud, accurately!
While it is accurate to say the crime wasn't considered to reach the level of a hate crime, it is inaccurate to say that it wasn't targeted towards LGBTQ+; they were not, as is claimed in Ani O'Brien's tweet about inaccuracies, targeting the Turning Point Trust. Why the distortion?
distortions on both side. It's good you bring it up. I'm sick of it all round tbh (and I pull Ani up on it when I've got the spoons).
When two or more apparently accurate fragments of information are incompatible ("An unhatecrime." @1.1 vs arkie @1.1.1), then imho either at least one fragment is inaccurate, or there is a bigger picture.
The 'heat' here is rising – I'm leaving this ‘kitchen’ and may be some time.
My suggestion is to take the successful approach of the gay rights campaigners of the 70s and 80s, who often took the approach of letting bigots speak to as many people as possible for as long as possible. Because if the views of this person are really so awful, terrible, no-good, and very-bad, then spread them far and wide and offend as many people as possible.
But, of course, for some fellow travellers on the left, that's a risk, because it may just turn out that she's not a bigot, just (shock, horror) a woman with an opinion and a forthright speaking style, and a person saying quite reasonable things that were totally uncontroversial 15 years ago.
What's the harm? If she's really such an awful bigot, please, spread her views far and wide and watch the public turn on her.
And I repeat: why hand power to Nazis by allowing them to shut down any movement they don't like by simply showing up and saying "we're with them"?
Hear her own views about New Zealand, from 19 January 2023 at her Facebook page. I am not a FB member, so the link may not work as a direct link, but won't know until I post. Apologies, it takes you to FB login only. Going in another way to her FB Kellie-Jae Kellie, eg through Duckduckgo, may get you there.
https://m.facebook.com/kelliejaykeen/videos/farewell-to-a-leader-who-robbed-women-of-their-rights-jacindaardern-letwomenspea/1984028738457867/?m_entstream_source=timeline&__tn__=-R
Oops, FB Kellie-Jae Keen.
Double Oops, please look at the FB address. I have seen her name spelt assortedly in the last few days, and that was the one that stuck.
Charming commenters on her page calling Jacinda Ardern a bitch. How can you say you support women while tearing one down.
Those people can't. Ardern was, is and will continue to be a legend in my book.
I'm not them.
And here Kellie-Jay Keen is with Sean Plunkett on The Platform five days ago
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=__BF6ex9CO8
Can anyone update me on KJK's story of a NZ girl getting suspended after a transgender teen complained about her shutting herself away in a changing room cubicle when they walked in?
All I can find is this item from 2017
https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/trans-community-hits-back-after-teen-slams-schools-trans-toilet-policy/ABSY5R4AH5PKN3GDXYET66KYEM/
The girl in question, in an all-girls' school posted a video saying she was shocked when her school accepted a transgender student, then spoke out on social media when that student successfully petitioned the school to use the girls' toilets rather than unisex facilities. The shocked girl said she and other girls weren't consulted by the school. The school had told her she could use the unisex toilet if she felt uncomfortable.
No hint of a changing room ambush or of a suspension, although she may have copped one for the social media post.
Transgender support organisations said the story had happened in the past, had been resolved at the time, and was being reheated by Family First.
Is KJK conflating this with an ambush story from the US? This same story appears in her FB post.
Things are different now. In the 70's and 80's they didn't have social media or even cell phones. This restricted both the rate and coverage of misinformation. People had time to think about the things they heard before passing them on. Nowadays folks are sharing stuff without even considering the accuracy or intent of the information.
I think this is a good point but I'm still not ready to give up on the concept of "sunlight is the best disinfectant". So the question is, how can this concept work in the internet / SM age? And I don't have a simple answer and I would value your thoughts.
That's why I put up KJK's own post on NZ, and her interview with Sean Plunkett. Lots of sunlight indeed. I made my mind up about KJK as a person from her political statements about Jacinda Ardern. She lost my respect completely when she showed she amplifies ‘news’ from Fox Media and Alan Jones.
Senator Pauline Hanson spoke at her #LetWomenSpeak rally today in Canberra. Firebrand Senator Lydia Thorpe, draped in a First Nation flag and wearing lovely slingback heels and a cute black dress, fell to the ground when tackled by police. She wanted to express her disagreement with the rally and with Hanson by stepping up to the mic.
https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2023/mar/23/senator-lidia-thorpe-knocked-to-ground-in-struggle-with-police-anti-trans-rally-kellie-jay-keen-posie-parker-canberra-australia
#LetSomeWomenSpeak is the correct hashtag for KJK's tour.
then why didn't Thorpe just ask to speak? Any woman is allowed to speak, that's the whole point. Afaik you just have to let the organisers know.
Coming up behind KJK while she is speaking and interrupting her with a shouting protest is not speaking at the mike. It's a protest. Good on her, she's free to do that. And protest that crosses boundaries usually ends up with policy involvement.
Why would an indigenous woman need the consent of visitors to speak on the grounds of the legislature she's a member of?
who was stopping her speaking on parliament grounds?
This may provide context for Lidia Thorpe's rage. KJK apparently in Hobart described parents of transgender youth as 'groomers'. It is unclear whether she mentioned anyone by name, and it's unlikely.
However, the trans stepson of Greens Senator for Tasmania, Nick McKim, was 'deadnamed' and abused for being trans on social media on the same day.
Thorpe is a previous collegue of McKim, and would have heard his speech in the Senate on the 22nd.
https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/video/2023/mar/22/greens-mp-condemns-kellie-jay-keen-in-parliament-for-treatment-of-trans-stepson-video
KJK verbally attacked a named Green MP multiple times who was standing with the trans rights activists, including calling her groomer for transitioning her child.
Groomer here means someone who grooms children to be trans.
The Green MP later went and stood behind KJK with a sign and was moved on by the police. Then later still she tweeted about KJK and what happened but did so in misleading ways.
https://twitter.com/CassyOConnorMP/status/1638029168691781635
https://twitter.com/wekatweets/status/1638044802460811266
My position:
.https://thestandard.org.nz/why-is-the-uks-only-youth-gender-identity-clinic-closing-and-what-does-this-mean-for-new-zealand/
All of which is to say this is a very complex situation with lots of layers and grey areas. It's easy enough to condemn KJK, for good reasons, but the TAs are also shutting down the debate so that we don't talk about the very real problems that she is highlighting.
Women aren't going to go away on this. More and more women will become aware of the issues and say no, this is not ok. It has the potential to stop the left from governing. It's a massive own goal for the left.
Thugs.
https://static3.stuff.co.nz/ezgif-com-video-to-gif-b07ba798.gif
Again, why would an indigenous woman need the consent of manuheri to speak on country?
Here's another view
Thorpe is an attention seeker. She tried to disrupt the event and knew exactly this would be the result. She is also bat shit crazy. Here's two more of her more insane moments;
Greens senator Lidia Thorpe apologises to Liberal Hollie Hughes after 'disgusting' comment – YouTube
Lidia Thorpe receives ‘brilliant takedown’ after ‘white man’ comments – YouTube
Stryne for indigenous woman.
/
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/zcxhKqbHoKI
Please don't embed gifs, there's no way for some of us to stop autoplay. I've replace it with a link. Better to use a tweet or YT with time stamp.
what's happening there is she went up to KJK speaking to protest. And because of the violence directed at women at LWS and other events, they now have security. Afaik, providing security is a condition of their permit.
The security dude pushed her away and then the police took over. This is normal for situations like this.
If this was about her wanting to speak on parliament grounds, I think she could have set up her own space to speak and/or talked to the media that were there.
I wish TAs would be honest. Your argument hinges in your antipathy to women's sex based rights.
Let me give that some thought and get back to you, TG.
I am tired of doing minor formatting on this site and finding that my whole post is lost.
It is happening so often and this time it happened while I was highlighting 4 points to indent/number and the whole draft post is deleted.
Grrrrrr
Just in case it is my fault PC wise I will restart. I've been in the online formatting world since the 1980s and only on this site do things like this happen.
Don’t write your comments in the TS Text Editor. Write them off-line and when ready copy & paste in Text Editor, do the required formatting, and submit. Doing it this way, you minimise timing out. HTH.
I've been losing comments lately too since I started using Safari browser. Firefox is much more stable because the back button will show the comment box with text in it.
But TS is buggy, pays as Incog says to put a copy in another app.
Switch to Brave.
Don't care ; She is coming. I for one won't be wasting my time on such a Posie. She is a sideshow in the real world for most people who are more worried about how to pay their bills or stop the planet burning.
Truly ironic then to hear at Hobart meeting, the older woman speaker saying she wanted to be fighting for the planet and against climate change and she was boo-ed! By the trans activists.
My first thought when I saw 'the photo' for the first time. Does she think she's Marilyn Monroe reincarnated? The more I hear about her the more assured I am she is an imposter.
The author has got it right.
Oh dear this is unexpected from you Anne. Is Desley Simpson less of a person with a political view because she is blond and wears bright coloured dresses?
Are the points about dress, looks sex that had a part in PM Ardern resigning so far in the past. Have we forgotten these?
Does it matter what she looks like, dresses like?
I liked Marilyn Monroe and I like Posey Parker. I like feisty women. I may not agree with all they say but I'm not going to criticise because she is a woman (immutable) and her dress sense.
That was a passing shot Shanreagh. Sorry. Didn't mean to offend but couldn't resist. I am not a fan of flashiness in clothing or hairdos but then I'm old school.
My quibble is that there are far more important issues we need to face. I certainly don't like the thought of anyone other than persons who are genuinely female entering a women’s toilet because there is a safety issue at stake. But by the same token I don't hold grudges against trans people. Having met the late Georgina Beyer and seeing what a super intelligent and genuine person she was, I object to trans people being sidelined because they can't help what they are. They are entitled to the same rights as everyone else.
How are they sidelined, Anne?
“Having met the late Georgina Beyer and seeing what a super intelligent and genuine person she was, I object to trans people being sidelined because they can't help what they are.”
Georgina Beyer was a transsexual, many of whom are not al all impressed being called transgenders, its just another Trans-ideology coup.
Transsexuals have very little to do with trans-identified males.
Think about the differences in motivation /health issues.
There are many pictures and/or list of names of persons published who see themselves as trans-identified males who have raped, assaulted, abused and/or murdered women and/or children. Not a very intelligent thing to do.
Yes quote is spot on. Couldn't have said it better.
''Re the vexed questions posed by “she who channels her inner Monroe”, her apparent preparedness to ally with religious fundies and right wing extremists.''
You need to back that statement up with facts. It seems to me, like the majority of people who have no interest in feminism or transgender activists, that this section of society, including Kellie-Jay Keen, are getting way more media coverage then they deserve, or the public want.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11456405/Police-threaten-arrest-womens-rights-campaigner-doesnt-attend-voluntary-interview.html
The unfortunate situation for the Left is this issue is becoming a millstone around their necks as the push back from conservatives and the general public is starting in earnest. People are waking up to how pervasive and powerful gender identity politics has become in societies and especially in schools in the US. There are many YouTube clips showing parents making school boards accountable for their perverse acceptance of schools teaching gender issues without parental input.
discussion about KJK’s connections to the far right and fundamentalists have been widely had for a long time including in the past week. If you would like to know something specific please ask.
In the meantime, don’t tell authors what to do, especially Guest Post authors, that’s just rude.
KJK denies any connections to far right groups and other undesirables. She says her Wiki page has been tampered with. I have seen allegations she's appeared on supposed Nazi broadcasts and has said derogatory things about Muslims. However, she denies that in this interview: ( link not given as Sean is considered offensive to some. It's a simple Google search)
[deleted quote without link]
What solid evidence is there against her being a hate filled anti trans nut job, Weka?
And… let's say evidence comes to light that she has lied and is exposed as a covert right wing agitator. Should she still be allowed into NZ?
she has indeed appeared online with far rightists. And she's made a least one derogatory comment about Muslims that I've seen. These are not difficult to substantiate.
Who said she was that exactly?
If you quote you have to link. You know this. Quote without linking again and I will ban you because I'm sick of telling regulars to do this.
''What solid evidence is there against her being a hate filled anti trans nut job, Weka?
Who said she was that exactly?''
https://aucklandpride.org.nz/articles/auckland-pride-calls-city-to-action-to-stand-up-for-trans-communities-against-posie-parker-s-hateful-agenda/
Plus, in a similar vain, by quote and inference, the media and politicians.
''If you quote you have to link. You know this. Quote without linking again and I will ban you because I'm sick of telling regulars to do this.''
I don’t know what your point is. Why don’t you read the post and comment on that?
Given the turn of events since we posted above, the issue has now become very political. In fact, apart from the debate about free speech that many believe we shouldn't have unless it is ''right think; right speak, '' things may turn out to be the first real shots fired in the election campaign. Should KJKM be denied entry into NZ via a high court appeal, that'll supply endless ammo for the RIGHT of politics and conservative hardliners. Should she be cleared to enter NZ and her rallies result in violence, the media and the LEFT of politics would have a field day saying ''we told you so''. Chippy would feel chipper. And more repressive hate speech legislation would be tabled again by a re elected Labour Party.
My view is this:
Let us quit the talking. The Govt will not to anything to recognise womens rights. Men on the left, if my reading of many of the posts here is correct mainly see the issue through a trans lens ie a male oriented view. or say safe spaces is not a right and even if it was it is not an issue……so the old staying schtum/staunch argument
Women make up 51% apx of the population, We have rights.
https://www.speakupforwomen.nz/post/media-release-march-21-2023
Women are always so reasonable and perhaps we need to say
'We won't put up with this any longer'
PS The reason why some women's rights campaigners have found a listening ear on the conservative side is that often people on that side 'get it', they get the conflict of rights argument.
As a former leftie and Labour Party member I am more frightened of the left than the right.
I know my own views on abortion etc and so don't share a lot of right wings views. It is patronizing to suggest to women that they don't know their own minds.
Agree totally Anker.
I also resent anyone telling me my (read woman's) hard fought rights are less in the scale of things than those of a group that is in the minority. Not saying that this is an argument of numbers.
I resent people saying
a I have no rights to safe spaces,
b) it is ok for me to have no choice about being counselled by a man about male violence, being sheltered in a rape crisis centre that includes males, or even of having to share my prison space with an intact male.
As Anker says 'It is patronizing to suggest to women that they don't know their own minds.'
I agree.
I am so, so tired of the opinions and rights of women being shouted down, mostly by people who speak with all of the entitlement and centering that comes from growing up as a man. I know how it works, I am one.
That_guy, Thank you. I value your input.
I know we haven’t always agreed, but we sure do on this stuff and I guess it is healthy that we haven’t always agreed
Cheers Anker I know I am in for a good read when I see your posts, esp on this issue.
Hi Shanreagh, You said:
"I resent people saying… it is ok for me to have no choice about being counselled by a man about male violence, being sheltered in a rape crisis centre that includes males, or even of having to share my prison space with an intact male."
I'm wondering why it's okay to be biased against men in these situations but not okay to do the same toward PoC, Muslims, LGBTQ+?
I don't understand your points or perhaps you don't understand mine?
Women's rights is a set of issues that has been around since women originally fought for, and got the vote here in NZ in 1893 and we had the likes of the suffragettes in the UK.
This is based on biology. Males are different from females, biology-wise and by act/s of the patriarchy over thousands of years what was biology became supremacy over females,
It was often accompanied by explicit laws preventing women from working or if they worked prevented them from getting the same pay rates as men.
Most census figures give women as a group around 51% of the population.
Now up until later in June when women went to a Rape Crisis centre they could be assured that the counsellors & helpers there were female, biological females. Many women in extreme crisis cannot bear anything to do with males esp if there has been domestic violence involved.
Most females in crisis do not expect or accept that they will be counselled by a male. Many women would class trans females as males. A changed birth certificate is usually not evidence that would contradict one's eyes.
The experience in women's prisons where transwomen have been placed is not inspiring. There are several well known transwomen who were placed in women's prisons one called Isla Bryson
"Isla Bryson, who transitioned from a man to a woman while awaiting trial for raping two women in 2016 and 2019, was sentenced Tuesday to eight years in prison in Scotland. The case sparked a heated debate as Bryson was briefly placed in an all-women's prison before being moved to a men's facility amid a public outcry." Wiki
There have been cases where transwomen have assaulted females and in a couple of cases pregnancies have resulted.
Women being prison is often a frightening experience. They are at their lowest ebb and often come from abusive households. It is unconscionable for a transwoman to be placed in a female prison especially where this person has not fully transitioned or transitioned at all.
So rape crisis centres & prisons need to be able to place transwomen in prison where they cannot force themselves on women and rape crisis centres need to be able to appoint bio females to staff, to only have bio females on staff if need be..
The argument is male/female. The argument is women should maintain the ability to have a choice as to whether they are helped/counselled etc by a male or a female. The experience in some jurisidications is that they won't.
Hopefully in NZ we will through HR Act. safe spaces and protected spaces that mean that bearing in mind the clientele the employers can offer a choice.
It is not about POC/Muslims, green eyes/ blue eyes/Anglican/short people/tall people/fat people/thin people/whether people are union members etc or issues of culture or colour. Though I know that woman of colour may want to have the choice to be counselled by another bio woman of colour
The concept seems hard to grasp for some. It may be that many are not aware of the struggles that woman have had to gain acceptance. Work, lives for themselves with people they love who may be other women, let alone issues of birth control & access to abortion. We have had cases of gross medical misadventure on woman as a class 'the unfortunate experiment'
https://www.brightonandhovenews.org/2022/05/05/brighton-rape-crisis-centre-sued-over-refusal-to-offer-female-only-groups/
Sorry for length.
Thank you for your in-depth response.
You said:
"I don't understand your points or perhaps you don't understand mine?"
That is entirely possible.
I'll get back to you once I've had a chance to find the examples you gave and get a better picture of where you're coming from.
Hi Shanreagh, thanks for your patience.
I understand the points you're seeking to make, I'll attempt to steel-man your POV and you can tell me if I have it wrong.
You believe that females have experienced systemic & personal harm from males due to the male domination of females throughout history to the present day. You believe there are innate 'qualities' in males that are biological in origin which contribute to their potential for harm toward females. You believe these qualities persist after transitioning and are present in MtF transgender persons. You believe that the rights of victims to feel safe and be attended to in their times of need and vulnerability supersedes the rights of transwomen to be recognised and treated as women.
My position is that it's discriminatory to restrict or negate the basic human rights of any group and I'm morally challenged to balance that with the needs of victims of violence.
I acknowledge that a battered woman may find the idea of being counselled by a man or transwoman distressing and the victim absolutely should have a choice about who attends to her needs but that choice should not be inferred and should not extend to employment bans in shelters for men or transwomen.
I don't think it's reasonable to treat all males as though they are all responsible for all the horrific violence in our society. Research shows that 96-99% of males are not violent and that a mere 1 % of the population is accountable for 63 % of all violent crime convictions (and yes, I know men are the majority perpetrators of violence).
You said:
"So rape crisis centres & prisons need to be able to place transwomen in prison where they cannot force themselves on women"
Research shows that among female former state prisoners, the rate of inmate-on-inmate sexual victimization was 13.7% meaning female inmates have more to fear from other female inmates than they do from transwomen.
You said:
"The argument is male/female."
No it isn't. Whilst it is true that men and women have biological differences we cannot reasonable boil down those differences to a binary equation. What makes us men and women is on a spectrum that we have only just begun to understand.
It is the persistent divide of male/female enacted in gender roles and attributes that continues to fuel gender violence. We know this because societies that are highly egalitarian have much less domestic and sexual violence. The Batek people of Malaysia are a perfect example of this. I've included some links in case you wanted to read research about this.
The relationship between egalitarianism, dominance, and violence in intimate relationships
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3485398/
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/263388649_Violence_Fear_and_Anti-Violence_the_Batek_of_Peninsular_Malaysia
You said:
"It is not about POC/Muslims,… or issues of culture or colour."
Actually, it is (although I'm ignoring your attempt to delegitimise my point). When we allow discrimination that favours the rights of one group over another we set ourselves up for future harm. What if women decided that they didn't feel safe around Muslims because some Muslim beliefs are misogynistic?
We need to find solutions that don't involve suppressing the rights of others and I know that will be a very difficult thing to do but it's never ok to discriminate against an entire group over the actions of the few.
Gender ID is of the socially liberal, acceptance of diversity within society, ideology. It's not left wing.
Which is why some on the left, who link sex and race based equality on a par to working class struggle, have concerns.
No non left parties opposed the self ID law here, neither National nor ACT. And it’s similar in Oz and many nations in Europe.
And more women support gender ID recognition than men.
Those who ally to the GCF cause are often social conservative (some identitarian) groups involved in culture wars in matters of sexuality and race.
That KJK herself also says that the threat is from the left, confusing it with neo-liberal acceptance of the equality of citizens despite difference within the market, is not helpful to the success of the cause (with one exception the Tory government in the UK blocking self ID in Scotland – though that also involved JKR). But will guarantee further support from social conservatives.
Ok I'll bite why is it not women who benefit from safe spaces, being able to chose one's counsellor, expect that a Rape Crisis centre will be staffed by females, or that a prison won't women's prison won't have intact males in it?
I note that woman often come into these places at crisis points in their lives and many have no money. So being denied access to a counsellor provided at low cost or no cost because of a wish not to be counselled by a man in effect may mean she gets no counselling at all.
We have seen in the UK that this has happened.
https://www.brightonandhovenews.org/2022/05/05/brighton-rape-crisis-centre-sued-over-refusal-to-offer-female-only-groups/
https://www.crowdjustice.com/case/help-sarahs-legal-challenge/
I think she is channeling her inner-trump..
She is certainly using the trump-playbook…
So Trump is a serial sexual abuser who boasted about "grabbing women by the pussy" and this women wants women to have spaces where it's impossible for a man to ever do any such thing.
I'm not seeing the connection, sorry.
No me neither. I didn't think Trump was especially noted for his strength on women's issues such as access to safe spaces or general women's rights.
Perhaps Phillip Ure could find us the links to support his view.
Though I won't be holding my breath.
KJM is here on a campaign about Women's rights.
I would refer you to her final line in that posted tweet..(that I watched ..)
Where after issuing legal threats she stared down the camera and said:..'I never lose..!' .
How is that not pure trump..?
Braggadocio with a big ‘b’..
And of course I am not comparing their politics ..it is the way she plays the media/her audience…
She is using the Trump-playbook…
And the Trump playbook is?
So anyone who says bring it on when people try to wrongfully bully is using a Trump play book.
Surely you know as well as anyone to deny entry to someone on spurious grounds is subject to appeal, to censure even up to UN level and also to personal threats of libel or slander.
Officials have to make decisions on legit grounds only and not to do so exposes the decision maker to legal action on the grounds of natural justice and misreading/misapplication of the statutory provisons.
If you know that the so called grounds to deny her being put forward, the high test, the previous court cases are worthless then you could be pretty confident in saying 'bring it on'.
I am sure she is aware of all the rubbish being spoken about her and knows where she is personally.
I guess some may think that being forthright is a man's position only and this may have shocked some.
I personally love it when people say 'up yours with bells on' when they know they are in the right. I especially like it when the person saying it is in the right and a woman.
I feel that there may be a challenge by a pro bono group to the decision much like the Recordon challenge to the Springbok tour. INZ has been challenged in the past and hopefully they have got their ducks in a legislative row on this.
You don't usually hear women saying "I never lose" so good on her. She has got real ovaries.
Of course at Trump rallies he was always keen to hand over the microphone to let them speak.
Women have been cancelled from holding meetings in public venues to talk about their concerns over legislative and policy changes.
So, the #LetWomenSpeakApproach has been to take the events to the public square, so they can't be cancelled.
Permits are obtained when necessary.
The platform is that KJK acts as MC, and invites women up to speak.
There is no curating of women or their speeches.
Have you listened to any of these women? How does this compare to Trump?
https://twitter.com/EdgeWatching/status/1637296808622985216?s=20
In the sense that GCF reject gender ID as not real, it is sort of funny that RNZ are discussing this and referring to Kellie-Jay Keen as "Posie Parker", not her full twitter handle Posie (conscious rebel) Parker. The real question is whether her name was formally changed to Kellie-Jay Keen-Minshall on marriage or not.
Everything but, what she would say and why is covered.
It's fairly standard, the neo-liberal centre consensus and identifying conservative social critics via association with extremists on the right from international sources (not mentioned WLF).
I think you are trying too hard when saying women's rights activist reject gender. Gender is a continuum.
I don't think how KJM or PP wants to be dealt with is anything to do with gender but is rude & bad manners like putting a Mrs in front of s person who is married but goes by Ms, using someone's 'dead name' ie he name they used before transitioning etc.
It is accepted and dealt with like any belief system such as a belief in a gendered soul, or the afterlife. Sensitively as well all have beliefs.
It is a bit different when you are talking about biology or science..
No, while one can be a womens rights activist and recognise gender is a continuum (within birth sex and onto transbirthsexgender) – there are those who reject the validity/reality of gender ID.
The perspective here is a objection to stating both a female birth sex and a female gender (because of not recognising any gender not in accord with birth sex … )
https://www.speakupforwomen.nz/post/so-you-don-t-want-to-fill-in-the-census
https://www.speakupforwomen.nz/post/census-questions-let-s-get-writing
Yes, SPC, you can be a women's rights activist and not agree on issues with other women's rights activists.
I have read the links and don't understand where you are coming from.
The first one is what to do if you don't want to answer any of the questions on gender. Many woman don't like this question as they think male/female is all they need. Others don't want to participate in the Rainbow idea and wanted to have a button where they answered "I don't want to answer this question"
The advice is not just aimed at women but anyone who did not want to answer the question. It is not only women who are concerned. Not all women are concerned.
The next one has a suggested draft letter.
There have been concerns that unless we have a general idea of what the specific birth sex was we won't have good data for health planning. Just because you now have a female birth cert if you were born man you still may need monitoring for prostate cancer etc, Then 'acquired' sex may show needs is need for other types of planning.
You asked for evidence of GCF who do not regard gender ID as real. I provided links
The first – no gender ID, so cannot say male or female or other
The second –
Again I am not sure of the point…..as someone upthread or might have been in previous threads said that accepting gender is like accepting a soul or the afterlife.
Clearly there will be people who accept the soul and afterlife and some that don't some will be female and some will be males.
i really have no concern about gender as long as it is not used to hurt or harm me or mine in any way and it 'doesn't scare the horses'. My objection is to people trying to pull the wool, or should that be the knickers, over my eyes and saying this bio man is a real ie bio woman.
Quite happy to have my tax dollars used to provide safe spaces/rape crisis centres/special spaces in prisons for transwomen but please don't make me disbelieve the evidence of my eyes.
The Neonazis that turned in Melbourne are probably laughing… they got to harass Trans activists and smear a feminist all at the same time.
They're friends of neither, they way we're reporting it here and not to mention the political comment doesn't reflect that reality.
Agree totally.
It also puts the power in the Nazis to say who is a person worth listening to. They don't agree with KJM or transactivists but in Nazi things.
I somehow don't thinks my dad & his brothers fought in WW2 to have people say because Nazis interrupted a meeting that they are the ones worth listening to instead of the actual speaker.
They used her right to free speech to assert their own. The police having to separate them from the protestors led to the proximity.
That said, her willingness to appear on right wing forums has taken her to some dubious places.
100% Crinklewood. Well done Nazis …job done (huge amount of sarc).
Left smearing Kellie Jae playing into Nazi handbook
I
The total left smearing has left the field wide open for…….
ta dah
the conservatives yet again…..
and our OP is bemused that women's rights activists 'talk' to the right.
I'm not at all bemused, Shanreagh. I understand fully why some women's rights activists have come to believe that the only course of action left open to them is to ally with political forces which, by any objective measure, are inimical to women's rights. I even sympathise but I think it is wrong.
Sure I agree but what do women do?
Keep banging heads against the broader left wing, & getting nowhere
or
get their voices heard, at least, by listening people.
I think by looking at the history of Women's Rights nothing has been given to us by those holding power because it seemed like a fair and good idea. Women have had to make the case for change.
I regret that Women have had to go to conservative people to get a hearing. I think women are wasting our time trying to get LW men to think through the issues. The boat for the legislation change has sailed with the con "No Debate'.
We are now left with a small window, possibly, to effect change to policy/procedures. The legislation comes into force on 15/6/23. After that we will need to have a watching brief to see that Women remain safe and are enabled to access women only facilities if this is safest for them.
The legislation is not as bad as some in that some steps along the way to transition have to be made before an application is made.
We hopefully will not get to the stage where women have to sue to get access to counselling facilities that do not include men (transwomen are not bio women) as in Brighton England
https://www.crowdjustice.com/case/help-sarahs-legal-challenge/
https://www.brightonandhovenews.org/2022/05/05/brighton-rape-crisis-centre-sued-over-refusal-to-offer-female-only-groups/
Which people specifically?
The writer seems to be of the (erroneous) belief that sexual transgressiveness is a moral good:
People on the left need to realise that the moment it suits the suits, i.e. whatever track the money train is currently on, corporate capitalism will switch from support for social transgressivism into support for social conservatism, and it will do so in a heart beat.
It is not, and never was. It is – at best – a value neutral stance, possible enjoyed by its adherents, but merely tolerated by the much more numerous socially progressive. The affected proportion of our society is remarkably small – fractions of a percent – but somehow they feel entitled to demand to strip away the protections from 51% of the population. It's about time this unruly tail stopped trying to wag the dog.
The decline of public debate arises from the spread of postmodernism – a philosophical error preferred by groups addicted to special pleading – cognizant of the fact that objective treatment will see their stances debunked. Dugin is one example. And contemporary Trans activism is another. Thus it is that they mobilize anonymous quasi-paramilitaries, the so-called pound shop ninjas, and try to silence dissenting opinions having no hope whatsoever of winning support by argument.
The writer holds no such belief, Stuart, but is utterly fascinated by how you arrived at that conclusion. And it's social transgressivism, I refer to not sexual.
It really makes no odds – flouting social conventions that evolved to achieve an approximation of representative justice is no virtue either.
I love TS.
I love TS even more when we have such great posts as
Stuart Munro's.
Thank you Stuart, I learn something every day from colleagues on TS. This is my 'lolly' for today!
Once again 100% Stuart Munro.
Stuart Munro,those at either extreme of this debate are so passionate because they experience the position of the other side as an existential threat. That saddens me. Inclusivity is about 'and', not 'or'. It is very possible to have the 'and' with a bit of thoughtful consensus.
I feel we also need to remember that NZ is not the UK or the US. More real action will be achieved when we focus on the sticking points in this debate in our own society. That goes for both sides.
tWiggle my very rude 14 year old self would have said
'dream on'
Unfortunately because the left was totally consumed by the 'No debate' idealogy it effectively means there is no debate. We have no levers to sit down and discuss and work together.
Trans activists have the legislation and they do not have to build up a constituency for change which is where the rough edges are rubbed off many of the ideas in a democracy. The ones left at the margins, perhaps up to 51% of the population know that there is no ability by either side to compromise and so nothing to be gained. We either have to be quiet or make ourselves safe by other means.
Hence my view above that we quit trying to change this legislation, that we concentrate fully on the legislation/policy of safe spaces etc, looking at Human Rights etc
We boost these up, work with experts to see how safe spaces can work. We empower by legislation to support our Corrections people to refuse to place untransitioned males in female prisons and we empower organisations such as Rape Crisis Centres, who may come under safe spaces anyway to have the ability to appoint women to women counselling services when this is best practice.
Here is a very careful analysis of the Scotish and England postion from Julie Bindel, a feminist who has published in Al Jazeera.
https://www.aljazeera.com/opinions/2023/2/3/scotlands-gender-recognition-bill-would-have-harmed-women
Because NZ rushed this legislation through we have missed out on the consensus/possible best practice that is evident in the debate in UK.
The legislation comes into force on 15 June 2023
https://www.justice.govt.nz/family/change-the-sexgender-on-a-birth-certificate/
The trans lobby has nothing to talk to women or anyone else about. They are now focussed on shutting up all non believers hence the OTT Nazis etc tropes.
There was no debate here because there was cross-party consensus in parliament (same as in Oz and many EU states).
You are right about the strategic approach.
Others
1. allow women's refuges to determine their own safety policy, right to exclude people deemed to make the women there feel unsafe.
2. allow women's groups (including lesbians) to set their own definitions for inclusion (as per religious groups), in real life, or online.
Legislative
3. legislative change – private members bill – no self ID for those who have committed violence.
There was debate – there were hundreds of submissions in opposition to the Bill. They was ignored and the submitters were abused by some of the Parliamentarians on the Committee.
Not really, if there is cross party consensus SC submissions do not lead to debate. Media barely cover it.
SPC the impetus to this change in the BDM categories was world-wide and entitled No Debate. The reason for the cross party consensus in NZ was that all parties were conned by this world-wide No Debate cause.
In fact in NZ many of us tried to turn it into a debate by using the only means available to us and that was to make submissions to the SC. As Visubversa says many subs were given a once over lightly and some in person presenters were treated very rudely by members of the SC.
Hearings by the SC can in fact lead to changes to the legislation, even if it is cross party.
Agree with these.
I was about to say the same. The 'no debate' policy is in and of itself divisive – at odds with the principles of democracy that its proponents are trying to use to enact law that lacks rationality, much less public assent.
The small minority which is the LGBT&etc community is no more appropriate an oligarchy than the usual clique of billionaires – neither is capable of representing society at large on its own. Disproportionate influence by either group, or indeed on the part of any similar minority interest group that lacks broad support needs to be handled with restraint, not autocratic impositions upon the public at large.
Beginning a post with a title, and continuing with a first paragraph which primarily addresses the appearance of a woman with whom the author disagrees, is profoundly misogynistic.
Does it matter that she is blonde – and apparently reminds you (or those you are quoting) of a mid-20th-century movie star?
Surely the most important thing is what she says, rather than how she looks.
afaik KJK looks like Marilyn Monroe intentionally. I don't think it's disparaging to reference that.
The post says channelling her inner Monroe, it doesn't say PP is a bimbo.
You mistake my point. I don't care whether the OP approves of the way KJK looks, or disapproves. It is not, nor should it ever be, the lead point of a story about a woman politician or activist (or whatever KJK is).
The way she looks is totally irrelevant to what she says. And it is misogynistic to tie a woman's appearance, in any way, to the validity of her argument.
I cannot believe that this debate is still being had, on the left, in the 2020s.
You brought up the issue of being a bimbo – so it sounds as though the subtext of the MM reference has achieved exactly what the author intended.
I didn't say anything about the OP approval or disapproval of KJK's looks. I said that it's not even about her looks, it's about the inner Monroe. You appear to be taking any mention of Marilyn Monroe as being about her looks. I mentioned bimbo because you seemed to be saying there was something wrong with MM or KJK's appearance or mentioning.
You'd have to ask Lynn what she meant, but the way I took it is that KJK has an inner sense of herself as Monroe-esque.
If the reference to her looks is neutral I can't see the problem. Women have bodies, we're allowed to note when women look like other women.
Guess we'll just have to agree to disagree.
I certainly know that in any professional situation, I would be *profoundly* unhappy if the lead was my appearance. What I wear or don't wear, the colour of my hair, my size, etc. – has absolutely nothing to do with what I have to say.
I choose to extend the same courtesy to female politicians and/or activists – from any political orientation.
Treat others as you would like to be treated.
Clearly, as this debate has been had before on TS, others here disagree.
Probably the biggest disagreement is that I don't think the OP says anything about KJK's appearance.
I agree Belladonna it is a 'tricky' approach. Thanks Lynn Williams below.
I remember the furore that Siouxsie Wiles got about the colour of her hair & believability and ex PM Ardern about everything about her femaleness. Desley Simpson could also be 'ironically' said to be channelling her inner Marilyn Monroe, though I doubt she is.
It is there in the article but it adds nothing to it. Comments on appearances in a serious thoughtful matters rarely do.
I am a specialist of irony, I like to think. I did not read the comments about JKM's appearance as irony. I read them as those type of comments people say about Siouxsie Wiles hair, about fat people and ex PM Ardern.
From this I deduce that for irony to work the information needs to be known in advance or shared by reference. The lay reader about KJM, like I am, did not know if she did or did not channel herself in this way.
There was no image popped into my thread. The first image is is in Weka's thread and is not a cartoon.
Thank you for making the effort, Belladonna, but I don't need a lecture about misogyny or ideal feminist praxis, and your suggestion that I intended to make readers think of PP as a "bimbo" is a stretch – almost into the realms of snark.
The piece is a verbatim Twitter thread that was turned into a post for TS. As Twitter threads don't have a title, the heading was by default.
You will also note that the phrase in the text is in inverted commas which signals such things as it is meant to be read advisedly, is intended to be ironic, or it is a quote. In this instance it's meant to be ironic, and as PP's supporters have produced a cartoon image of her in a classic 1950s Monroesque style, I popped it into the thread.
The fact that you have ignored the content of the rest of the thread to focus negatively on that one point serves to illustrate how divisive and diversionary all of this is.
I don't agree with Kelly's tactics, and my politics and theoretical approach to women's rights and to gender identity differs from hers but I quite like her personal style as it happens and I acknowledge she is gutsy and way more outspoken in public than I'd be prepared to be.
Please re-read the comment thread, Weka brought up the phrase bimbo.
My comment was entirely around how inappropriate it was to begin any piece of political commentary about a woman, by referencing her appearance.
Perhaps this is a case where the 'irony' was apparent in the original Twitter feed – but none of that background was available when it was 'translated' into a TS post.
The fact that the rest of the content is derailed by the initial paragraph – perhaps illustrates just how divisive and diversionary it was.
I'm aware Weka brought it up, Belladonna, and you then turned into an attack on me -suggesting that had been my intention in using the phrase which so offended you.
I agree that the way headlines and first sentences are written in the modern media are critical as a lot of readers don't go beyond that ,or they allow the initial impression to influence their view of the rest of a piece.
I expect a more nuanced reader on a site like TS; readers who don't allow a heading or a sentence, or in this case a single phrase, to colour their view of the whole argument.
If you knew me, you would know that my line on this issue is principled, well researched, and very long-standing. My political loyalties lie on the left. The fact that corporate capitalism has gutted the left and frog marched parts of it up the political and critical culture-de- sac of identity politics, does not mean I am going to abandon my principles and join hands with those forces which, on every other issue and level, are my political opponents.
Why dream on? I take it the law you disagree with is the self-identification of transgender part https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Births,_Deaths,_Marriages,_and_Relationships_Registration_Act_2021, bolstered by protection against discrimination on the basis of gender in the Human Rights Act 1993, right?
The proof of the pudding is in the eating, I say. Legislation is law, not policy, not institutions, not how the practical nuts and bolts will be carried out.
This was where my views were aimed. The boat has sailed with the legislation, we have the policy to work on and procedures etc.
Of course but we can still work hopefully within the law as it is now to boost up safe spaces etc. Railing against the legislation is a dead duck unless the Nats see an opportunity to say they will have a close look, and I am doubting that they would.
Many of the transactivists seem anti women, or perhaps distaining of women, from my foray into their twitter world. or perhaps it is the concept of women. Apart from trying to explain that being pro women does not mean anti trans, I get very little sense of them being aware of any risks to anyone else, how to counter the risks, how to get others along etc etc.
So that is why I am pinning my work for the future on safe spaces, women being able to accept/expect to be counselled by bio women if need be. Those sorts of things.
At times the transgender activists (not all transgender, mostly the TIM’s identifying as women) seem to offer a parody of out and proud on the one hand and on the other incels Q'ed via 4 chan to strike at women's safety, so women know they exist. The hybrid between the two appears to have been "sissy porn".
The idea that some of this is reactionary misogyny and deliberately crafted as a culture war issue is a plausible plot for a mini-series. Maybe, The Culture War Card. The House of Cards has some spare actors.
This is why some of the transsexuals (as they were known before they had the right to identify as women) were/are/have been wary of the gender identity movement's activism. Thus a generational division between them and younger transgender women. Both of these have been able to identify as women through a (health system managed) process.
The problems in the health system with younger people (medicalisation in error) has paralleled the arrival of the self ID movement. This is another area for some activism.
Bearing mind the whole current shambles on Self ID came about because of the dead rat No Debate ideology being swallowed holus polus by several parties in the NZ Govt….this comment is interesting.
It provides a welcome change from the comments on SM that have excelled themselves in denying people their right to be people with opinions by serving out a range of slurs. Some of them are such dead boring slurs that are often inherently contradictory.
I guess calling people names just carries on the No Debate mantra to a conclusion. They seem fiendishly angry as well.
Let us hope that the policing of the events is better than it was in Australia.
https://plainsight.nz/is-the-no-debate-strategy-working/
Rachel Smalley with a good article.
https://www.todayfm.co.nz/home/opinion/2023/03/rachel-smalley-no-one-has-the-right-to-stop-women-from-speaking.html
She is particularly powerful with the point about politicians stepping away from taking sides
and this
'What is the logical solution? It’s really simple. Let’s speak. Let’s talk. Let’s korero. Let’s find a way to support women and girls who say they feel concerned for their safety in some environments, and to enable transgender women to co-exist in a space where they also feel safe and validated too. There absolutely IS a conversation to be had.
You cannot silence people on the basis that you don't agree with them. This is New Zealand – not Russia or Saudi Arabia.'
@ 2:47 minutes
"….the majority of the reception we got in Australia was very positive"
Stefan Molyneux
@9:48 minutes
"Oh trust me, the audience [in New Zealand] was very interested in what we had to say, that is why we sold out a venue"
Stefan Molyneux
2018 – Far Right Canadian anti-Islam extremists Lauren Southern and Stefan Molyneux, are allowed entry to New Zealand and Australia to give a speaking tour.
2019 – Far Right Australian anti-Islamist extremist commits a massacre of Muslims in Christchurch.
I shot an arrow into the air, it fell to earth, I knew not where….
Are you saying that the Chch murderer was influenced into murder by NZ allowing Southern and Molyneux into the country?
If that's not your point, please explain what it is. If it is your point, it still needs explaining.
Normalise hate against a minority in society; and the alienated, the impressionable, the angry, in that society are sure to act on it.
Not long after the Christchurch massacre I was visiting the Springhill prison. If you have ever been to the Springhill prison, you will know that you have to park your car some distance from the prison gates and walk the last 200 or so meters on foot.
As I walked on the footpath to the prison gates, I happened to fall into step with an elegant tall woman in an immaculate business suit, who didn't look at all like the average prison visitor. Out of curiosity I asked her. And she informed me that she was an anger management counsellor.
I asked her does it work?
She said it does.
As we were at a penitentiary and as the Christchurch atrocity was fresh in my mind.
Conversationally I remarked; 'That young man in Christchurch could maybe have benefited from some anger management."
I wasn't ready for her sharp retort. "No he wouldn't He is an Australian"
Surely you don't mean that? How can you justify generalising against Australians like that?
She then became quite animated and passionate and quite heated, (for an anger management person).
She said, "I know what I am talking about I worked in Australia for four years." She looked distressed and angry at the recollection.
I mentioned my encounter with this anger management counsellor in a phone call to my brother who lives and works in Perth in Western Australia. In an understated way he simply said, of Australians. "They have issues."
In my opinion you normalise hatred against any minority you are going to have issues.
Lauren Southern and Stefan Molyneux, Posy Parker are political opportunists who have monetised hate, funded to fly round the world by their backers. What do they care about the fall out. They will be long gone and can wash their hands of the violence and intolerance they normalise.
that's well argued Jenny. I disagree that KJK is simply a grifter, she seems clearly invested in women's rights within the scope of her own politics.
The problems is that despite her anti-trans rhetoric, she is right about women's rights. And the reason Posie Parker exists is because No Debate silenced left wing voices who would have argued for women's and trans rights had we been allowed. Now women are being forced to choose between the own politics/rights and gender ideology and its zero surprise to me that many choose women.
I don't get this. Why are you platforming these people Jenny? Do you agree with them? If so why put them on a thread to do with women's rights.
The issues are not remotely similar to the issues of Women's rights.
If you don't agree with the point above please explain.
Being a Bad Person (and this person definitely qualifies as such, IMHO) is not grounds to stop them entering New Zealand.
The Transgender Activists trying to get a Judicial Review of Wood's decision are wasting their time and money, unfortunately.
People on the Left need to realise that corporate capitalism has embraced social liberalism because social liberalism is zero threat to capitalism.
Exactly. Corporate rainbow washing is completely absent in majority Muslim countries.
I think we may have known this or sensed this DS. Those in the 'fight' have had thier opinions validated or at least seemingly heard by those on the Right.
Men on the left seem to decry Women's sex based rights, if not decrying them our sex based rights seem to be invisible. Why is this?
With my 1970s feminist hat on it seems an instance of continuing misogyny. But I couldn't possibly comment.
My nuanced 2020s hat is puzzled that some thing so positive, the granting of rights to people to live as themselves, has degenerated into a movement that unashamedly says for this people to be able to live as themselves we have to take away the sex based rights of women. I struggle not to see this as misogyny of some sort.
As Weka says
Back in the late sixties/early 70's ponsonby was a very interesting place to live..lots of maori/pacific islanders..students..hippies…artists..activists..Junkies…the gluepot pumped most nites..
Also in the lineup were sally and tilly..they were both males and somewhere on that spectrum..and dressed/wore makeup accordingly..
(I am unsure which bathroom they used.. would probably have been accepted in both..)
And they were friends…and fellow druggies…
And there was never any sense of them being 'the other'…in any way…they were just sally and tilly..part of that kaleidoscope..
And that is what disturbs me about this dialogue..
It is making the sally's and Tilly's of today..the other..
And that is not good..
I agree that's not good. Also not good is dehumanising women by calling them menstruators while still calling men men. Or the women in prison who've been sexually assaulted by violent men who self ID. It's shit all around. What I don't understand is why progressive men can see it's shit for trans women but not for women.
I never heard sally and tilly…or anyone else..use that term to describe women..
And that touches on an offensive presumption in this dialogue..that men opposing this 'other' poison being peddled..are somehow automatically anti-women in some way..
That is just bullshit on a stick..
I think I will stand behind Chloe swarbrick on this..
She will be there.. protesting against this travesty ..
And I don't think she can be called anti-women…
I didn't call progressive men anti-women, I'm asking why they support trans rights but not women's sex based rights.
If you don't know who is calling women menstruators, you could educate yourself, because right now it looks like you are talking on a topic where you are unaware of what the issues are.
https://www.google.com/search?client=firefox-b-d&q=menstruators
Ya see Phillip Ure I was also around in those times and was actual friends with two, we called them transvestites/transsexuals who lived in Grey Lynn/College Hill. Their names were M**** and F**** & they used their male names as they worked (pay was better as a male in the PS).
The women's clothing they wore was strictly an aid to finding other males. They were gay you see. Homosexuality was still illegal in those days They went to the male loos unless their going out clothes were too awkward such as hot pants when used the female loos. At work they used the male loos as they were males.
They were not anti bio women. I guess their views were a bit as Georgina Beyer's were reported to be. Not sure about what is currently going on.
Today with homosexuality legalised and civil unions there is no need really to use these same sex attracting outfits per se though obviously it provides an extra frisson and who would deny that!
So Phillip Ure what do you say about lesbians, women who love women being forced by legislation, when on dating pages, to accept that male bodied people may apply as they call themselves lesbians too.
Here is how it happens male bodied person get female birth certificate, he may not have fully transitioned to being a female, so still has the male bits..
Says they are a female looking for female when they are untransitioned male looking for female
I scratch my head
Wouldn't it be easier to stay as a male and seek a female partner?
If anyone wants to fully transition to the opposite sex and seek partners that is fine
Fully transitioning though is not what is required by the legislation we have that comes into force on 15/6.
Then there are all the concerning stories about women's sport, about the staffing of rape crisis centres, counselling groups not being able/wanting to restrict their group participants to bio females, of prisons.
On Twitter yesterday it was reported that a Maori Woman who had been raped/domestic violence was concerned that she would have to accept males in her safe spaces. Many woman, and esp those affected by male violence, can pick out a male at a 1000 paces and it does not matter that said male has a piece of paper saying they are now a female. She was lambasted by the 'caring' trans community.
We truly are out of our collective minds not to turn our minds as to how we will help women.
There are downsides and unintended consequences to most social justice legislation. The adult way is to accept these and mitigate them not shout down anyone who brings them up.
Unsure of the point you are trying to make with your gay-anecdote..
Cd u plse clarify that…?
And you are really leaning into the hypotheticals there..eh..?
And just a quick factchech on your stated concerns re rape-crisis shelters..
Rnz on breakfast show had a quote from a person running one of those services for hurt/damaged women..
She said they had been accepting trans people for about ten years…and had never had any problems as you describe..
Where does that leave your alarmist claims/what if?'s..?
So much of all this seems to be catastrophising..
There's a phrase in GC circles about 'things that never happen'. TAs like yourself assert the things that women are concerned about never happen.
Meanwhile,
https://www.womenarehuman.com/male-transgender-boasts-of-harassing-women-in-crisis-shelter/
Now you will say that it's only one example. There are more, but many TAs are wilfully blind.
One of the women speaking at LWS in Canberra talked about the genre of porn where men masturbate in women's toilets. It's on pornhub. I don't know how long that's been a thing, but I do know I've seen enough examples in GC twitter of trans identified males masturbating or exposing themselves in women's spaces (toilets, changing rooms, Wi Spa, refuges) to know that it's a valid issue. Some of the males are predatory, some are exhibitionists, some are AGP (look that up if you are not already familiar, because it's central to the whole thing).
My question to you is how many of those examples are enough for women to be allowed to raise the issue and talk about it, without being told we’re catastrophising or bigots/nazis? That’s not a rhetorical question, I’d like to know the number at which point you would take it seriously.
I have commented several times about finding males in womens changing rooms masturbating. The place I first came across it was in Sydney in 1979. Male came in dressed vaguely female with clothes in arms. Stripped down and began. We left. told the staff and were told it happens & if they look like women they have to let them in. Now I never go into large open changing rooms, only cubicles, so shops have lost my shopping $$$$.
This was well before any of the trans stuff we are hearing now. At that stage i had come across two workmates who were male who dressed as female and used our female facilities with no problems. I had been in pub toilets where, depending on how they were dressed, trans people used either the male or female toilets. No problem as these people were male focussed.
Today it seems very much more violent especially against bio females.
Weka, we are not allowed to think ahead and take steps to prevent/mitigate. I have worked that much out.
We have to have the types of Isla Brysons and others causing damage I suspect. Though Corrections at the moment does segregate trans people, that is allowable under their current legislation/policy. Not sure if this has to change come 15/6/23.
https://www.corrections.govt.nz/resources/policy_and_legislation/Prison-Operations-Manual/Induction/I.08-Shared-Accommodation-Cell-Risk-Assessment
what does it say about showers and toilets and recreational areas?
@ weka..
First things first..
What is a TA…?
trans activist and/or trans ally.
Thanks for not reading Philip URE, I knew I could depend on you,
Rape Crisis comment was built on happenings in Canada re staffing and on the Brighton case.
https://www.crowdjustice.com/case/help-sarahs-legal-challenge/
The point was about places that have no right to chose totally bio females as counsellors, they had to choose male (trans) as well…this was by the Human Rights laws they had in Canada. It was not about Rape Crisis centres not allowing trans people in.
If trans females want to go rape crisis centres that is fine & if trans people want to counsel at these places too that is fine. What is not fine is if by dogma or law bio females are not able to access help because a centre will not provide them with a bio female counsellor.
These cases are readily available to read for those with a genuine interest, which you clearly have not.
At least since the 1970s I have constantly and consistently followed the debates around women's rights and latterly Trans rights where they impinge on women's rights. You seem stuck in denialism and a tally ho its all jolly when chaps get their (female) gear on.
Most of all you seem anti female? Am I right?
Please educate yourself and please read my post. I know it has some big words, dense prose and paragraphs that have more than one sentence …….
I ended with this plea above . Denialism is not an answer and goes nowhere to mitigate.
How would you mitigate the possible harms to bio women?
There are issues all over the place with the way the Trans issue is being pursued.
You might consider the popular motto "Trans rights are human rights". While it is true to the point of being a tautology, like other tautologies it is semantically empty, the meaning it bears lies in confusing what human rights we have.
Consider the propositions:
Incel rights are human rights
Murderers rights are human rights
Homonid rights are human rights
These tautologies are unlikely to expand the range of 'rights' available to the trans community.
If the authors were being candid, the motto would read "Trans heteronymous desires are human rights", but that assertion is patently false.
I know the issues are all over the place.
I am happy that trans people have rights, I always have been and always will be. The issues of trans rights and women's rights are not mutually exclusive.
The issue for me is women's rights. No right given to another should infringe my rights as a woman.
Speak up for Women said in part in their press release
https://www.speakupforwomen.nz/post/media-release-march-21-2023
"The protesters who gate-crashed the event in Melbourne have unfortunately been allowed to completely hijack the purpose of the event and sideline the women who spoke. These women speakers are mothers and grandmothers, aunties, daughters and sisters. They are non-violent and only wish to gather and voice their concerns, to speak about how their rights are being impacted with the introduction of gender identity in legislation, and to share their own experiences.
We all have and deserve human rights and transgender people are no exception. However, accessing sex segregated or same-sex spaces and services, designated for people of the opposite sex, is not a human right.
As women’s rights campaigners we are extremely concerned about this conflict of rights."