Written By:
geoff - Date published:
2:04 pm, August 30th, 2014 - 113 comments
Categories: accountability, capitalism, corruption, crosby textor, election 2014, Judith Collins, kremlinology, Politics -
Tags:
So Judith Collins is gone.
This is English’s faction taking control of dealing with the Dirty Politics mess. There’s no way Bronwyn Puller would have placed a privacy complaint against Collins without English knowing. She’s still tight with the National Party and with his faction.
I have no doubt the email that Key used to sink her came from inside the National Party. Why else would it go straight to Key’s chief of staff and why would it be taken so seriously if he didn’t know its provenance?
I’d say that since English deliberately distanced himself from Collins in his PREFU stand up – which was coordinated with Key changing his position to say she was
“unwise” – they have been working to get to this point and cauterize the wound.
About the same time Steven Joyce dropped away from commenting on it.
It’s not taken much for National’s factions to come to the surface as I’ve previously posted there’s been a cold war on for a while:
It’s no secret that the small but vicious Collins faction has been worrying the rest of the party for some time. Fran O’Sullivan points to her sacking of John Judge as a reason for this, but Collins has caused many other, less public ructions and her proxies, Cameron Slater and Simon Lusk many more again.
There’s no doubt now that English is running the show. The question is will the remnants of Collins’ crew fight back or is it all over for them? And what happens to Steven Joyce?
This will really be a test of that famous National Party discipline.
The current rise of populism challenges the way we think about people’s relationship to the economy.We seem to be entering an era of populism, in which leadership in a democracy is based on preferences of the population which do not seem entirely rational nor serving their longer interests. ...
The server will be getting hardware changes this evening starting at 10pm NZDT.
The site will be off line for some hours.
Doesn’t this story actually present us with even more questions about Key’s role in the Dirty Politics saga?
Yep. He’ll be hoping it’ll take the heat off, it’s more a case of “one down, now, who’s next?” The spotlight turns to point directly at the PM(‘s office). The Slater/Ede correspondence is yet to be released, unless I’ve missed something. 🙂
I think the cold war, just became a hot war.
Those who live by “Dirty Politics”, die by “Dirty Politics”.
[Paraphrasing Matthew 26:52]
Another thought.
Jarred Savage and the Herald needs investigating for their role in the whole Dirty Politics saga.
http://jononatusch.wordpress.com/2014/08/30/serious-questions-for-jared-savage-the-nz-herald/
The Herald already has dirty hands with Glucina drip feeding gossip from these vile sources, now one of their journalists implicated.
Questions should be asked about why Key got the chance to release the email and herald got to break the story. I wonder if it was related to Fisher’s mea culpa a couple of days ago?
The Herald’s editors could be shown to have very grubby hands on this.
http://www.stuff.co.nz/national/politics/10442284/Judith-Collins-resigns-says-shes-a-victim
Stuff are saying the SST were working on a story about these emails for tomorrow’s paper:
Vigilante hacker Rawshark is the man who hacked Slater’s emails then gave them to Nicky Hager .
Since the book Dirty Politics release Rawshark has also been parcelling out caches of emails to media.
Fairfax’s Sunday Star Times newspaper had flagged it was due to print a story about the emails tomorrow.
The emails detail a covert public relations campaign including attacks on the credibility of the SFO and Financial Markets Authority.”
So it was damage minimisation …
Well, Gower is till calling at a National Party inside job – Hager also, saying they wanted a reason to ax her, but not to blame it on Hager’s book.
We’ll see tomorrow I guess, if whaledump releases an identical screen grab then it might explain the surprisingly shoddy cellphone picture that the PM’s office released.
Hager didn’t seem to think it was among the whaledump emails he received and used for his book.
Depends if Hager was given absolutely everything. The book barely mentions this, and the hacker seems pretty adept at media management and might have their own agenda.
Also, the SST seems well set to run with something big tomorrow, interviews with Adam Feeley etc. Will all depend on what runs tomorrow.
This is what Gower said tonight on 3 News – and it’s in print under the video:
redacted? if it isnt one of the recipients isnt the pm worried it has been sourced illegally.
I really can’t recall reading any of Savage’s stuff. Does he show a bias to the right or does he play it straight down the middle? And by bias, I don’t mean simply break stories that don’t help the left, I mean clearly and unfairly slant his writing?
As this article says, serious questions for Jared Savage and the NZ Herald.
Remember the Herald’s Glucina’s role also in Dirty Politics.
http://jononatusch.wordpress.com/2014/08/30/serious-questions-for-jared-savage-the-nz-herald/
A quick search of Savage’s articles in the Herald show a lot of reporting on the Donghua Liu story.
Wonder who his sources were?
http://m.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=11316711
Of the dirty dozen Collins is first off the rank next could be either Ede or another shadowy Office of the PM figure, but Key will burn anyone in his sights to stay on top of the pile.
It’s in his genes, remember the smiling assassin case where his job was to sack 300 Merrill Lynch employees, when stock market crashed in 2007?
While at Merrill lynch in 2001 “Some co-workers called John Key “the smiling assassin” for maintaining his usual cheerfulness while sacking (some say hundreds) of staff after heavy losses from the 1998 Russian financial crisis.”
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Key
These are mean assed people we are dealing with, they eat each other.
I seriously thought the impact of Hagar’s book would be limited. Now the floodgates of revenge are unstopped within National.
I predict -5% from National
+3% to New Zealand First to about 8%
+ 1 to Labour to 27%
+ 1 to Greens to 14%
Also a Cabinet-wide ban on using Whaleoil, whoever is in power
And a big welcome back to National Party Leader Bill English.
Deputy: Paula Crusher Bennett?
Next Gone Key please
Back in Wikapeadia filles ShonKey was hauled before SFO.
mmmmm!
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Key
Key forestalled the accusation by declaring that he had left Elders months before the event, that he had no knowledge of the deal, and that his interview with the Serious Fraud Office during the investigation into the affair could only have helped to convict the people involved. This statement was supported publicly by then-SFO director Charles Sturt.[24][25]
Labour MPs criticised Key for not releasing specific policy information at their annual conference. Key responded that National would set its own policy agenda and that there was adequate time before the next election for voters to digest National Party policy proposals.[26]
Next thought,
This was also on the link I sent above,
Wikipedia records Key hauled in front of the same SFO that Collins interfered with, any similarities?
Key forestalled the accusation by declaring that he had left Elders months before the event, that he had no knowledge of the deal, and that his interview with the Serious Fraud Office during the investigation into the affair could only have helped to convict the people involved. This statement was supported publicly by then-SFO director Charles Sturt.[24][25]
Labour MPs criticised Key for not releasing specific policy information at their annual conference. Key responded that National would set its own policy agenda and that there was adequate time before the next election for voters to digest National Party policy proposals.[26]
How strange I was just dropping off a billboard in Karori.
And drove past a very grey looking Bill English going into his house just as the news came on RNZ about Collins,
It was quite surreal
It would have been more surreal if he had been humming “Happy Days”
Time to cancel you NZ Herald subscription?
To speak to a Customer Representative, call 0800 100 888
between 6am & 5pm Monday to Friday, or 6am & 10am Saturday and Sunday
Or email them on subscriptions@nzherald.co.nz.
If you want to make a stronger complaint contact the two APN Directors who control the NZ Herald. They are
[deleted]
And
[deleted]
This information came from the NZ Herald site and from The Companies Office.
It was not supplied by Judith Collins or Cathy Odgers.
[lprent: Don’t put people’s names and *home* addresses up on the site. ]
Dont be silly.
Did you know subscriptions are a money loser for the Herald, so they save money when they dont have to print and deliver a newspaper.
Geoff. Judith Collin’s isn’t gone. She’s simply no longer a minister and JK stated quite unequivocally that when/if her name is cleared, she’s back on board. Also National got the opportunity to go into damage control and kill a story before it was published by the SST. That’s no small thing to be gifted on a plate.
I’ve no idea where you’re getting ‘Camp English’ on the ascendency from. Key is (still) king of the castle and is (still) untarnished and (still) has all his players in play.
Bet SST still run a story tomorrow. I doubt the story is dead. Both Key and Collins are running the line that she will be cleared. From Key’s pserpective all he has to do is defer things until after the election. But if more comes out tomorrow that will be harder to do. Twitter speculation is that there will be a full whaledump tomorrow.
https://twitter.com/toad001/status/505541093497532416
Bet SST still run a story tomorrow. I doubt the story is dead. Both Key and Collins are running the line that she will be cleared. From Key’s pserpective all he has to do is defer things until after the election. But if more comes out tomorrow that will be harder to do. Twitter speculation is that there will be a full whaledump tomorrow.
twitter.com/toad001/status/505541093497532416
Nom nom nom, Prime Minister 😈
nom nom nom …
I heard Key say she wouldn’t be back after the election. Sounded to me like he felt it was a hanging offence.
Step 1 During the debate Cunliffe asks what Key is going to do about Collins.
Step2 Winston claims that Collin’s people ask if he’ll join them after ousting John Key.Collins denies.( ‘He’s a liar’)
Step 3 Key suddenly releases an old (2011) email from Slater implicating Collins
Step 3 Key sacks Collins- well… accepts her resignation
Step 4. Collins unfriends Slater
Step 5. Benson Pope relaxes over a whisky.
Step 5. I have a whisky too.
Sorry but this looks very suspicious. Key has now been given the excuse to get rid of Collins without backtracking on his previous stance. If he had changed his mind, without new information, he would have looked weak and given credence to the seriousness of the allegations in “Dirty Politics”
Collins, in particular, has been his achilles heel for the last couple of weeks. In addition he says this new email is ” far more serious” than the matters, relating to Collins, that have gone before. So in one hit he has:
Sadly, to me, looks like the Nats knew this info was on the way anyway and have used it to benefit Brand Key. What we don’t know yet is how deep the fissures in the National Party are and whether they’re enough for them to eat their very own darling Mr Key.
I suspect things are about to become even more interesting over the next 3 weeks as the NATS appear to be now donky deep in this stuff.
Some rumours about that Cactus Kate delivered the email.
she who must be redacted ??
Damage control. But that won’t lessen the unease but deny the disease.
With all respect to Geoff who said:
they have been working to get to this point and cauterize the wound ,
I had suggested what Nats need is political chemotherapy.
IMPORTANT, – URGENT.
Today we call officially on all opposition parties.
They must join together and must meet in an emergency forum to set the discussion surrounding the whole matter of political corruption within the Hager book and the laying of the grounds for the public interest in a truly independent commission of enquiry into the whole Slater gate affair with Team Key and His “black ops” “Dirty Politics” scandal reaching right back to when the records start with the Key Government and before.
There will never be a more correct urgent time to jump on this issue and destroy the cancer before it destroys us all.
fully agree.
couldn’t agree more there needs be a royal commission to restore confidence in the system the key government needs investigating there corrupt they are not of good character they need to take close look at what these vile people have been up to it needs to extended to the media ,corporates and cronies .
‘
I call bulshit. The email, most likely, did not come from inside National Ltd™ and nor has National Ltd™ any intention of cleaning up this shit heap of FAIL. Right now, inside National Ltd™, even as I type, its about cover your arse, duck for cover, or head for the hills and wait for a cushy job to come up. Any National Ltd™ member who has been selected to stand for the party and won their seat since Nicky Hager’s “The Hollow Men” is now suspect. Any National Ltd™ MP who has been involved with John Key’s dirty-ops department is now suspect. The rot starts at the head and, when it comes to National Ltd™, the rot is complete, from gills to tail.
Russell Brown’s theory is that Key needed a reason to dump Collins that wasn’t from Hager’s book, and then this email appeared.
I’m not sure though, because presumably Hager and/or his informants had this email too? And more to come tomorrow from whaledump.
It isn’t a whaledump email. Gower said it was sent to news media and JK from a known source who prefers not to be named.
Do you mean the information meant to come out tomorrow, or the email from today? Both?
The email that caused Collins to resign; copy of it was sent from someone known to Key.
Wouldn’t they just use it as a threat to make her to resign without the rigmarole then so she could take stress leave or whatever on her own terms? She might be super cray and resist, but this seems way too pyrrhic to be anything other than last minute harm minimisation.
If this email is the best case scenario then what was the worst case?
Yes. It seems a lot of people think it’s harm minimisation.
“Wouldn’t they just use it as a threat to make her to resign”
Not if the media also has the email and it was about to be published tomorrow.
“It isn’t a whaledump email.”
I could be an email that whaledump has as well. Which begs the question of why Hager didn’t use it. Didn’t have it?
Karol
Wouldn’t be KFC, sorry I mean KDC would it?
Doubt it. If he had something, he’d use it himself.
Also KDC wants Key, not the also rans.
At the end of the day, and then …
Tomorrow, and tomorrow, and tomorrow,
Creeps in this petty pace from day to day,
To the last syllable of recorded time;
And all our yesterdays have lighted fools
The way to dusty death. Out, out, brief candle!
As in that dark and powerful Shakespearean tragedy, the lady went first …
’tis thought, by self and violent hands / Took off her [political] life
and then Macbeth was defeated.
“and then Macbeth was defeated.”
….muttering the words, ‘Et tu, Slate?’
A bit of an aside, but I bet there’s not extensive quoting of Shakespeare on WhaleOil.
I’m from working class origins yet embrace literary and artistic insight (i.e., I don’t see it as ‘elitist’ but, rather, something to have access to and enrich myself from). I despise the attitude that determinedly does not want to enlighten and improve itself.
I think St Augustine said something similar to some Greek/Turkish fishermen who asked him whether or not they’d be sent to hell for being ignorant. His response? “No, but God will punish you for not wanting to be less ignorant” (or words to that effect).
Slater’s into hunting in a big way, isn’t he? Does he have his own guns?
Yes. He often writes about them. For some unknown reason, he is considered a fit and proper person to hold a firearms licence.
Hmm…
Laura McQuillan @mcquillanatorz · 3h
Asked if the redacted email recipient is John Key’s source, Cameron Slater says “I doubt that she passed it on” –
twitter.com/mcquillanatorz/status/505552726516719616
So who is it they they claim we all now know is the source? – [feeling stupid]
‘
Whaledump, surely? He/she gave it to the media which, in turn, provided a copy to John Key so that he could comment on an upcoming story. Rather than simply wait until publication, John Key is trying to seize the situation and hamper any momentum it has before it reaches him personally. As Mr Gould has pointed out, we can now expect lines like “National Ltd™ has recognised there is an issue and it is being dealt with”, “move along now, nothing to see here”, “we are focussed on the issues that matter and New Zealanders will judge for themselves who is behind all this”, “its time to talk about law and order, health, education, and the economy” . . . never mind the fact that this issue is now the defining issue of the election. It is John Key’s legacy, after six years, this is what he has left New Zealand to deal with.
Well, that’s my guess.
Gower reckons Key’s office know the name of the person that sent this latest email. Whaledump would not be disclosing any real name to Key.
PS: check the comments below the tweet linked to above.
‘
Patrick Gover and the rest of the MSM cannot be trusted with any speculation because we don’t know who’s feeding it into the narrative. I’m going for Occam’s Razor on this one. Whaledump has handed the media a portion of the emails and has shot off to Valuatu, probably at the MSM’s expense. Also, if Gover is correct, the fact that John Key knows the name of the person who sent the copy of the email he released does not mean that the person is a not journalist. IMHO.
Gower says this is what the PM’s office told him. See my quote and link above as to what Gower actually said.
Hmmm, trust Gower and/or the PM’s office, tricky isn’t it.
‘
Hmmm . . . okay, fair nuff, and thank you. Now that I think a little more about it. an email like the one released by John Key would, I believe, have featured writ-large in “Dirty Politics”. So, yeah, I’m the the same boat, now; where did it come from?
Odgers.
Thanks.
When you read the email, it reads as if Cactus was a party to it. Eg ‘Cathy can update separately….’
There is a redacted name at the top. Put 2 and 2 together?
Also, as Paddy Gower raised on the news tonight, who is the addressee ‘mark?’
Full inquiry please. This stinks.
sorry. we onky get inquiries into things judith and john millhouse nixon key want
Yeshua.
Patrick Gower @patrickgowernz 11m
Was Mark Hotchin involved in the campaign to get rid of Adam Feeley? If so, huge questions about state of NZ politics.
twitter.com/melmac21/status/505613881515851776
edit: with bells
Auckland’s most expensive house, the seven-bedroom mansion on exclusive Paritai Drive partly financed by former Hanover Finance director Mark Hotchin, has been sold to businessman Deyi Shi for $39 million.
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=11164421
Tweet from David Lawson:
who is lawson…
with bells
Auckland’s most expensive house, the seven-bedroom mansion on exclusive Paritai Drive partly financed by former Hanover Finance director Mark Hotchin, has been sold to businessman Deyi Shi for $39 million.
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=11164421
Yeshua.
Patrick Gower @patrickgowernz 11m
Was Mark Hotchin involved in the campaign to get rid of Adam Feeley? If so, huge questions about state of NZ politics.
twitter.com/melmac21/status/505613881515851776
Auckland’s most expensive house, the seven-bedroom mansion on exclusive Paritai Drive partly financed by former Hanover Finance director Mark Hotchin, has been sold to businessman Deyi Shi for $39 million.
nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=11164421
http://www.stuff.co.nz/national/politics/10442284/Judith-Collins-resigns-says-shes-a-victim
703 comments, and on a read of the first 20 the only favourable ones will be paid for and as rare as hen’s teeth. It is not possible for this current government to win this election. It is possible for them to take it, but not to win it.
Yep noticed that. Had a islay. Joined up and started thumbing up. Never seen a Stuff reaction like this one.
it will cross 7,000 when Key resigns.
I just googled ‘Cameron slater mark hotchin’ out of morbid interest. Back in 2011 when crown law/FMA froze hotchin’s assets, whale oil ran a series of posts defending the guy…
This is potentially huge.
And Slater is laying a complaint with the Privacy Commissioner against the PM for releasing one of his emails. Really?
…when bubby toothy sharky things run out of chum….. 😉
Slater needs to go hard on this one to cover his tracks.
If Odgers was the leaker (and it’s hard to imagine that it could be anyone else) then that means a decision was made to throw Collins under the bus as a last-ditch attempt to preserve the right’s chances of an election victory.
Slater professes a personal friendship with Collins, so he couldn’t be the one to swing the axe. Odgers had to do it. But the question is, was Slater complicit in it?
Nah, Odgers panicked. There’s no strategy here other than avoiding prison.
Peter Aranyi – 2 July 2011 :Hotchins Carrick Graham connection.(scroll down}.
h/t Morgan Godfery.
?
it’s probably this post.
ah. thanks.
Ta karol, posting isn’t going too well.
It might be this post on The Paepae.
And now Slater has laid a complaint against the PM. For those who can appreciate a good metaphor, this scene from Skyfall reminds me a lot of the current state of the National Party.
http://youtu.be/_yI1hjITn8Q
And from the NBR article.
“Mr Hooton’s company Exceltium has had a longtime contract to promote the iPredict political marketplace, which is run by Victoria University and lets its 7000 registered users bet on the likelihood of various political events.”
How much money are our young people having to borrow to pay fees to Victoria so they can support expenses of this sort?
I was at a session at Vic some years back when a staff member appeared in the room to promote ipredict. I had a look and was sure it wasn’t operating as it should -possible to make money by placing a straddle – I’ve said so on here before.
So what exactly does Vic think it’s doing?? Is it spending funds on ipredict, facilitating it, something else?
Like all gambling, at some point – the fix is in.
From the link to the sale of the Hotchin mansion:
“Mr Shi [the purchaser] speaks limited English and is more at home on the golf course, playing daily. He has teed off with Prime Minister John Key, whose portrait hangs in the company’s boardroom.“
He’s teed off with PM Jokeyhen. We’re peed off with PM Jokeyhen.
God we are a bloody laughing stock
100% dirty New Zealand
http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/aug/30/judith-collins-resigns-as-nz-justice-minister-over-ties-to-blogger
Well it has given me a shit eating grin from ear to ear.
Can’t hardly wait for tomorrows instalment!
Can it get any better?
More popcorn anyone?
yes, with butter and vegemite please 😀
Try this one c/- KDC’s Twitter:
http://www.lemonde.fr/pixels/article/2014/08/30/en-nouvelle-zelande-l-etrange-scandale-qui-mele-le-premier-ministre-et-un-blogueur_4479076_4408996.html
Perhaps might give fdx an even wider grin?
[sans the http part]
Ooo spooky the ‘http’ part added itself automatically
Why is KDC mentioned in the headline?
think it’s because it came from his twitter account ..
While I don’t read french fluently, it is pretty clear the article is a run-down of John Key’s leadership and the scandal regarding Collins, it goes onto explain about whaledump and Kim Dot Com’s involvement in politics and concludes by explaining another revelation is set to occur on the 15th of September with Greenwald present. (I guess they may have thought KDC was more of a draw card than a picture of Collins or Slater)
Fascinating how these political happenings in little ol’ NZ are making waves around the world.
Foreigners can see here in Aotearoa a pattern of political malfeasance interwoven with media complicity and the surveillance state, a pattern which has parallels in other western countries.
Yes! Hager made that point too and I like it.
At the moment I’ve been feeling a real pride in the people in New Zealand who are getting active in fighting past the spin to get the truth out. It has seemed that we have been collectively asleep for so many years and now there are people really pushing to get things cleaned up.
We have much more chance of turning this issue into a positive shift because we are a small country and because of the nature of our voting system.
I will truly be glowing with pride in NZ (for once) if New Zealanders really wake up to what is at stake and do something about it with their votes and get rid of this bunch of degenerates.
We need a functioning democracy – not a bunch of loons deceiving people into voting against their own best interests. I hope we collectively are up to ensuring this trend is halted and democracy is improved.
That was written by;
Grégor Brandy (Journaliste)
Can we get some of those in this country after the election?
Here you go fdx, just up on twitter,
Today’s front page: The minister and the money man, the real story behind @JudithCollinsMP’s demise – a @SundayStarTimes investigation.
https://twitter.com/SundayStarTimes/status/505690901075599360
Here you go fdx, just up on twitter,
Today’s front page: The minister and the money man, the real story behind @JudithCollinsMP’s demise – a @SundayStarTimes investigation.
twitter.com/SundayStarTimes/status/505690901075599360
thanks weka … wonder which ‘money’ man they mean ? there are so many …. should be quite a day tomorrow !
Hotchin.
Poo, meet Fan. Fan, meet poo.
😀 nice one CM !
Maybe Jones WAS right.
http://www.stuff.co.nz/national/politics/9826439/Shane-Jones-apologises-over-Collins-comments
“Yesterday, Jones alleged Collins had been living at the Auckland mansion formerly owned by failed finance director Mark Hotchin, now owned by Oravida chairman Stone Shi.
Collins had earlier said she and her husband had not stayed at the former Hotchin mansion, which is in Auckland’s upmarket Paritai Drive. Suggestions they had stayed there while their own house was being renovated were wrong.
An emotional Collins said Jones’ comments were “hurtful” but she would not elaborate on what the comments might have meant.
Well I doubt he came out with it just out of his head, same with Winston saying Judith sent a messenger to talk with him.
I wonder if Jones knew too much, and was ‘enticed’ by the Nats to get him out of the way?