Who Pays the Price of Sanctions
Written By:
- Date published:
4:32 pm, March 20th, 2022 - 194 comments
Categories: boycott, China, Diplomacy, Economy, energy, Europe, exports, farming, food, Gerry Brownlee, Iran, Japan, monetary policy, Peace, Peace, Russia, same old national, trade, uk politics, Ukraine, United Nations, us politics, war -
Tags:
New Zealand’s sanctions on Russia have not stopped the war in Ukraine. They may have made our parliamentarians feel better, and Tony Blinken was quick to congratulate us on falling into line with the US “high-impact sanctions.” The language is combative, but the evidence shows sanctions do not work. They can have significant blow-back effects, particularly if not combined with effective diplomacy.
There are already signs that Western sanctions will impose significant blow-back on the sanctioners. Russia has watched the way the US-led west has used sanctions to impose its own laws on other countries, and has prepared its defences. It is one of the most autarkic countries in the world, a major oil and gas producer, the main source of grain exports, has extensive rare earth materials, and is a major exporter of fertilisers.
Europe is dependent on its natural gas for heating and for industry, and the price of oil and as has risen to add to already rapidly rising inflation across the world. Russian consumers will be less impacted by sanctions than the rest of the world. We will certainly feel the effects here, as the price of fertilisers as well as petrol rises.
Not only that, there are signs that sanctions on Russia will expedite moves to replace the US dollar as the preferred payment for oil and gas. China, Iran, and India are moving to pay for these materials in their own currencies. The US’s ability to run massive deficits and pay for its bloated military are heavily dependent on the privileged status of the dollar. Reports are emerging of the Saudis moving to consider payment for oil in other currencies. That could be huge in its effects on world trade and US hegemony.
Russia has identified what it calls ‘unfriendly countries,” who have imposed sanctions against it. Apart from occupied Japan, South Korea and Micronesia, they are almost all white and colonisers, or in our case colonised. A map of the sanctioners shows that it is by no means most of the world. Writing in the Guardian, columnist David Adler considers this might be the shape of a new non-aligned world for the global south. It’s also where most of the world’s resources and people are.
Russia has so far not imposed any counter-sanctions. That will depend on events, but if imposed will be proportional and significant.
On top of the Russia-specific sanctions legislation, our government has indicated it will also consider moving to legislate for an autonomous sanctions regime. That would be a major change in New Zealand’s supposedly independent foreign policy of many years’ standing. We have always stood for a multilateral approach to such measures, and this was the main reason why we did not support the US-led “coalition of the willing” in Iraq, against John Key’s taunts that we were “missing in action.”
US Secretary of State Tony Blinken was quick to note that “For the first time, New Zealand has extended its sanctions authorities beyond its UN Security Council obligations.”
Gerry Brownlee has led the charge for the National Party, but additional support has come surprisingly, or perhaps unsurprisingly, from Simon O’Connor and Louisa Wall, New Zealand’s representatives on the Inter-Parliamentary Alliance on China. O’Connor has promoted so-called Magnitsky sanctions, named after lawyer accountant for their main promoter, former Soviet oligarch Bill Browder. Browder’s background is here where he is described as a ‘billionaire accused of being a fraud and a liar.”
The Inter-Parliamentary Alliance is an international self-selecting informal body of individual politicians, who are not supportive of China. It is funded by George Soros’ Open Society Foundation, known for funding colour revolution regime change operations, the National Endowment for Democracy ‘we do openly what the CIA used to do in secret,” and the Democracy Foundation of Taiwan. Both of the latter are foreign government-funded front organisations and advocates for political change. Soros and the NED were active in funding the so-called Maidan colour revolution in Kyiv in 204, which saw the ouster of the Russian-supporting President Yanukovich.
This raises the question of whether the purpose of Magnitsky sanctions would also be to give the government power to propose sanctions on China. In a recent article in the Herald advocating Magnitsky sanctions for New Zealand, O’Connor highlights his criticisms of China. This association would take us into a completely new dimension as it would mark a major shift away from Labour’s platform commitment to multilateral diplomacy. Magnitsky sanctions legislation so far has been limited to the FiveEyes countries, so this shift would be just another way of bringing us into line and effectively signalling the end of any pretension on our part to an independent foreign policy. There was no opportunity for select committee submission or wider discussion on the Russia-only sanctions legislation, and once imposed sanctions are hard to back down from. That debate is urgently needed now.
Guardian columnist Simon Jenkins has written extensively about the nugatory effect of sanctions, most recently in relation to those imposed by the United Kingdom on Iran, but also last year in relation to those imposed on Belarus. His words apply to Britain but they have some resonance here as well.
As for the crisis in Ukraine, the sanctions monitors at the American Peterson Institute for International Economics can find no sign that the severest economic aggression in modern history has yielded “the slightest evidence that Moscow will change course and ‘rehabilitate’ itself in the eyes of the west”.
The glib reply of proponents of sanctions is that they are better than war. In other words, it is taken as read that the west has an obligation to “do something” about evil regimes wherever they exist. The weapon appeals to democratic politicians as seeming tough without being violent. It offers a quick headline with no need for subsequent validation.
…while sanctions may not achieve their objective, they do exact a human price. They block the restoration of relations between disagreeing states. They deny the liberalising effect of trade and of intellectual and humanitarian exchange. Soft power is denied its potency. Worse, by being so vacuous, sanctions become almost impossible to withdraw.
Unless wonders happen, Ukraine should expose the hypocrisy of the “age of sanctions”. It has Britain traipsing round the Middle East begging for cheaper fuel, so it can pretend it is saving the planet by not drilling its own. It has had to negotiate with one regime, Iran, that it purports to detest, while pleading with another, Saudi Arabia, that it refuses to detest. All because of sanctions. Has British diplomacy ever looked more shabby?
One thing that is noticeably missing from the debate is how to we may be able to stop the war and return to peace. Western media, including our own, has gone full-blown frantic into disaster porn, and one suspects that the rush to judgment represented by the Russia bill represents more a response to blinkered and ahistorical media pressure than to any real intention to work to bring about a change to peace. Sanctions are intended as a punishment, but all too often the wrong people are punished. The supposed causal chain is that by imposing punishment on a people, their leaders will be overturned. All the evidence is that this does not happen, and all that does happen is that ordinary people are subjected to harsher living conditions.
Not only that, any chance of us considering ourselves as peace-making brokers is gone, now that we are aligned. In my opinion the most depressing idea in this sorry saga is that put forward by Gerry Brownlee calling for the expulsion of the Russian ambassador. Who do we expect to call to discuss how to get to peace if there’s nobody there to answer the phone? One thing you can say about Russian diplomats headed by the incomparable Sergei Lavrov is that they are very competent. They want to bring this war to an end.
194 comments on “Who Pays the Price of Sanctions ”
- Comments are now closed
- Comments are now closed
CommentsOpinions
Recent Comments
FeedsPartyGovtMedia
- Skeptical Science New Research for Week #47 2024
Open access notables Projected increase in the frequency of extremely active Atlantic hurricane seasons, Lopez et al., Science Advances: Future changes to the year-to-year swings between active and inactive North Atlantic tropical cyclone (TC) seasons have received little attention, yet may have great societal implications in areas prone to hurricane ...9 hours ago - Chicken Kiev
Chatting in the supermarket this morning, I found I needed to lunge for the chicken drumsticks.Coping mechanisms: who hasn’t felt a greater need for them lately?When it all gets too much, I turn to demonstrating handy butchery hacks.It wasn’t that she’d said anything wrong, our friend, not at all. We ...12 hours ago - The year is 2024 and it’s 1984
This is written in response to the highly significant open letter from a group of economists that was today addressed to Christopher Luxon. The year is 2024, and it’s 1984. The country is reeling from a record Olympic medal gold haul, while the globe grapples with the choice of the ...13 hours ago - The IPCA has failed
Back in 2022, RNZ took an in-depth look at the "Independent" Police Conduct Authority and its handling of killings by police. These are the most serious test of oversight, and you would expect the police's use of lethal force to receive the most severe scrutiny. But despite the police regularly ...17 hours ago - Thursday 21 November 2024
The Hīkoi mō Te Tiriti arrived at Parliament on Tuesday – the size is being debated but estimates range from 42,000 to 100,000. The Prime Minister is defending not attending due to some of the organisers being affiliated with Te Pāti Māori. The national gang patch ban came into force ...17 hours ago - ‘These budget cuts are counter-productive and make no sense’
I spoke to former Productivity Chair Nana this morning about the letter he and a group of other economists sent to PM Christopher Luxon to urge the Government to urgently suspend cuts to spending and investment for the sake of the economy, struggling businesses and the wellbeing of vulnerable ...18 hours ago - ACT’s Astroturfing & A Co-ordinated Attack on Te Pati Māori
Unity on the Streets / Unity at the TableAfter the Hīkoi, all three right wing Coalition leaders came together to push the idea that the 42,000 - 50,000 + strong Hikoi was somehow less potent and brave, and more illegitimate than the energy and crowd displayed.Prime Minister Christopher Luxon 20-November: ...19 hours ago - Durability of carbon dioxide removal is critical for stabilizing temperatures
This is a re-post from the Climate Brink The world is emitting over 40 gigatons of CO2 per year, contributing to an accelerating warming of the planet. The world needs to cut emissions rapidly to be remotely on track to meet our Paris Agreement goals of limiting warming to well-below 2C, and we ...19 hours ago
- I Love My Leather Jacket
I wear my leather jacket like a great big hugRadiating charm - a living cloak of luckIt's the only concrete link with an absent friendIt's a symbol I can wear 'till we meet againOr it's a weight around my neck while the owner's freeBoth protector and reminder of mortalityIt's a ...21 hours ago - Throwback Thursday: Will “Auckland Transport” Survive?
With Auckland Transport’s future up in the air under Mayor Wayne Brown’s proposed CCO reform, we’ve dug way back into the archives, to unearth this post originally published in March 2010. As you’ll see, many of the debates that were being had when AT was first proposed continue to ...21 hours ago - Economists call on PM to suspend budget cuts for the sake of the economy
Nicola Willis’ budget cuts are under fire from economists for having no clear rationale and worsening the recession. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāKia ora. Long stories short, here’s my top things to note in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty on Thursday, November 21: The news at ...21 hours ago
- The end of policing by consent
National has appointed a new police commissioner. And he explicitly rejects policing by consent: Asked if he subscribed to policing by consent, he said he did not. “I don’t talk about policing by consent. I talk about trust and confidence, and it is fundamentally important that the police have ...1 day ago
- The Treaty Principles Bill: A Who’s Who
David Horatio Waterbed SeymourFringe politician and dweeb transformed successfully by ThinkTank money into a well-oiled soundbite robot.Currently programmed to say: Equal rights for all New Zealanders Equal rights for all New Zealanders Equal rights for all New Zealanders Was previously programmed to say:I am a proud libertarian andI am a ...2 days ago - Kinleith mill closure shows need for industrial strategy
NZCTU Te Kauae Kaimahi President Richard Wagstaff is calling on the Government to deliver an economic and industrial strategy for regional manufacturing, rather than just expressing sympathy for job losses, following the announced closure of Kinleith mill in Tokoroa. “The closure Kinleith mill in Tokoroa is not just devastating for ...2 days ago
- 27% of kids going hungry, up from 21% in a year
One in four Kiwi children live in households where food runs out often or sometimes. Photo: Getty ImagesKia ora. Long stories short, here’s my top things to note in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty on Wednesday, November 20: The lead: The official annual Health Survey found sharp ...2 days ago - Transport modelling is an illusion
This guest post by Tim Adriaansen, an advocate for accessibility and sustainable transport, originally published on LinkedIn and cross posted here with permission. People prefer cars, right? Probably not. Here’s why. Granted, most people in English-speaking countries use a car to get around. This simple reality underpins our transport ...2 days ago
- Young Maori take over
Neither Wellington nor Parliament has ever seen anything like it before. The Police said there were more than 40,000 but however many there were, yesterday’s Hikoi to Parliament was a monumental event. It was almost three times the Foreshore and Seabed martch of 2004 and many,many times bigger than ...2 days ago - Gordon Campbell On The Hikoi Aftermath
The euphoria from yesterday’s hikoi may be transitory, but is no less valuable for that. It is pretty rare for the left to feel itself to be in the overwhelming majority, and speaking as the voice of the people. Lest that momentum be lost, the organisers will no doubt be ...2 days ago - Sabin 33 #3 – Solar panels generate too much waste and will overwhelm landfills
On November 1, 2024 we announced the publication of 33 rebuttals based on the report "Rebutting 33 False Claims About Solar, Wind, and Electric Vehicles" written by Matthew Eisenson, Jacob Elkin, Andy Fitch, Matthew Ard, Kaya Sittinger & Samuel Lavine and published by the Sabin Center for Climate Change Law at Columbia ...2 days ago
- What’s the time Mr Seymour?
Mr David Seymour crawling up to the ceilingThe sun don't shine the sun don't shine the sun don't shine at allMamma Pappa say you should go to school, I don't know what forNow that I've grown up and seen the world and all its liesSong: Southside of Bombay"Ake, ake, ake" ...2 days ago - Submit to defend te Tiriti!
The Justice Committee has called for submissions on National's racist and constitutionally radical Principles of the Treaty of Waitangi Bill. Submissions can be made at the link above or by post, and are due by Tuesday, 7 January 2025. But I'd get in quick, in case National grows a spine ...2 days ago
- We need to talk about Kevin
All happy families are alike; each unhappy family has a Drunk Uncle Kevin in there somewhere. If your Kevin is anything like the ones I know, he was getting along happily enough without having to think too much about the Treaty Principles Bill apart from bloody good job, onya guys ...3 days ago - The hikoi
Like everyone else (everyone who wasn't there, anyway), I've spent the morning watching the hikoi march on Parliament. The pictures are astounding: parliament grounds and the surrounding streets are full, and there are still people backed up along Lambton Quay. The police are estimating 35,000 people, and that's a floor ...3 days ago
- Why Govt & NZ Inc should boycott & regulate Facebook
3 days ago - How should we talk about change?
A better world isn’t just possible, it’s desirable. And that’s how we should frame a lot of our conversations around making a greater Auckland. As an example take urban climate action. A climate friendly Auckland: Is free from congestion Enables people to travel how they choose Is filled with ...3 days ago
- AMA + Holiday Webworm Merch!
3 days ago - Discount Code for Webworm Merch!
Hi,So there’s a bunch of new stuff on the Webworm store (www.webworm.store) — just in time for the Holidays. Read more ...3 days ago - Trying to defuse the tension
There were urgent moves yesterday at Parliament to try and defuse the tension building up over ACT’s Treaty Principles Bill. The Bill’s author, ACT leader David Seymour, told reporters that he understood the Justice Select Committee met yesterday to discuss how long it should take to consider submissions on the ...3 days ago
- An Irritable NZ Pawn – David Seymour Admits Treaty Principles Bill will clear the way for deve...
3 days ago - Gordon Campbell On The Hikoi Arrival, And Tyler Childers
Politicians like to bang on all about the need to heal society’s racial/economic divisions, but in their actions they’re more keen on stoking those divisions, with the Treaty Principles Bill being the classic example. The Bill seeks to dilute the Crown’s responsibilities to Māori at the same time as it ...3 days ago
- Socially Backwards and Fiscally Forwards: the False Ideological Divide and the “Conservative” Li...
3 days ago - Kaamos: Accepted
I appreciate that A Phuulish Fellow has been fairly quiet recently. That’s a combination of two things – comparatively little in the way of relevant material to discuss (at least until The War of the Rohirrim comes out next month), and my general work on The Secret Non-Fiction Writing Project. ...3 days ago - Here’s how governments could fix their Paris climate commitment failures
This is a re-post from Yale Climate Connections Governments around the world face a conundrum. Virtually none are on track to meet their Paris climate commitments. That includes the United States, which committed to cut its emissions at least 50% below 2005 levels by 2030 but is only on track for 32-43% cuts ...4 days ago
- Unstoppable.
4 days ago - Katherine Trebeck – An Alternative Economic Narrative
The era of neoliberalism has been destructive on so many levels, with a huge growth in wealth and privilege for the one percent. A hollowing out of the state; fraying of the safety net; inadequate government investment in infrastructure; and continued environmental degradation has resulted in damage on a vast ...4 days ago - In a Manner of Speaking
In a manner of speakingI just want to sayThat I could never forget the wayYou told me everythingBy saying nothingOh, give me the wordsGive me the wordsThat tell me nothingOh, give me the wordsGive me the wordsThat tell me everythingSongwriter: Winston TongNext Tuesday, the subscription price for Nick’s Kōrero will ...4 days ago - Monday 18 November 2024
The NZNO have announced a nationwide strike for December over its pay dispute with Health NZ, who have put a 1 per cent cap on pay rises. The Hīkoi mō Te Tiriti and Treaty Principles Bill remain front and centre in the media, with the impacts of the Hana-Rawhiti Maipi-Clarke-led ...4 days ago
- Shipley warns Seymour’s bill is ‘inviting civil war’
The divisive Treaty Principles Bill is not just a risk for the National Party, it’s a risk to civil order and unity, warns a National Party grandee. Photo: Getty ImagesKia ora. Long stories short, here’s my top things to note in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty on ...4 days ago - A clearer network for the City Rail Link?
This post was originally published on Linked In by Nicolas Reid. It is republished here with permission. Auckland is now just a year or so away from having the keystone of its urban rail network complete. As I wrote about here, the City Rail Link will be a literal game changer for ...4 days ago
- National’s support base is wobbling
If ACT leader David Seymour intended the Treaty Principles Bill to drive a wedge into National’s support base, he may well already be succeeding. By midnight on Thursday after the Maori Party haka in Parliament, National MPs were being deluged with emails and messages from their members calling them out ...4 days ago
- 2024 SkS Weekly Climate Change & Global Warming News Roundup #46
A listing of 33 news and opinion articles we found interesting and shared on social media during the past week: Sun, November 10, 2024 thru Sat, November 16, 2024. Story of the week Our Story of the Week is completely "meta" (no, not that Meta). It's about our exploring how ...4 days ago
- Grifter Eftpos Tamaki at it again
..Thanks for reading Frankly Speaking ! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.Self-appointed “Bishop” and proto-fascist, Brian Tamaki was at it again on 16 November, blocking Auckland’s southern motorway, SH1.This time, the target of his ire wasn’t the Civil Unions Act; covid lock-downs; mask mandates; or ...4 days ago - Rip up a bill, lead a haka are words to live by
I cannot stop grabbing people by the lapels, or shoulders, or similar, and raving at them about the tiny miracles in my ears.I can hear again! There could not be a more satisfied customer in all the world.In a noisy cafe I am even catching words that Karren cannot, she ...5 days ago - Unintended Consequences
Take the baitYou pay the priceIt's much too lateFor good adviceYou know and I know that our good things' throughBecause there's consequences for what we doConsequences for me and youWriters: Kevin Robert Hayes, David Nagier, Bonnie Adele Hayes.Fallout from the first readingOne News began last night by saying that tens ...6 days ago - Thank you, driver!
Today, Saturday 16th of November, is Auckland Transport’s Bus Driver Appreciation Day! Saturday 16 November marks the third annual Auckland Transport (AT) ‘Bus Driver Appreciation Day’, and this year we are encouraging all of New Zealand to thank their driver or let the bus go first if you are in ...6 days ago
- Totally Normal: Holiday Edition
Hi,If I was to accurately sum up my mental state over the week, I’d just say that I got a huge fright from my own shadow.I’d nipped out for an 11pm neighborhood stroll, just to calm down after a day of stress and screens. The Cure and Fazerdaze’s new record ...6 days ago - We Are Not Listening
The current rise of populism challenges the way we think about people’s relationship to the economy.We seem to be entering an era of populism, in which leadership in a democracy is based on preferences of the population which do not seem entirely rational nor serving their longer interests. ...
6 days ago - More lawlessness from National
On Tuesday, sick of government stonewalling, the Waitangi Tribunal issued a rare court order, ordering the Minister of Health to release unredacted documents within 48 hours showing its reasoning for disestablishing Te Aka Whai Ora, the Māori Health Authority. The government's response to the lawful order of a court? Yeah, ...6 days ago
- National’s tyrannical “foreign interference” law
Yesterday, under cover the the biggest political fight of the year, National quietly - covertly, even - introduced anti-foreign interference legislation. The bill is the product of a years-long work-program aimed at countering shit like this and this, and there's unquestionably a need to do something to counter foreign states' ...7 days ago
- The Haka Represents The Best Of Us
A few months ago, I was in an audience watching a Haka-Kapa and as I watched children dance and sing and sway and shout and beat, I couldn’t help but think “The Haka represents the best of us.”Yes, yes - there will be a thousand voices that rush forth to ...7 days ago
- Adding up the climate cost
St Mary’s Bay housing left hanging: Climate risk is systemically underestimated in the climate scenarios used by central banks, and a new report warns 10,000 houses are set to become uninsurable in Aotearoa. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāLong stories short, here’s the top six news items of note in ...7 days ago
- Auckland chafing at Bishop’s housing intensification orders
One of the major problems the Government has in implementing its ‘going for housing growth’ strategy is that it isn’t giving much funding help to councils. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāKia ora. Long stories short, here’s my top things to note in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate and ...7 days ago - Friday 15 November 2024
The Treaty Principles Bill continues to dominate political news, with it passing its first reading in the House. Parliament was briefly suspended and Te Pāti Māori MP Hana-Rawhiti Maipi-Clarke suspended for 24 hours after leading a haka that was joined by opposition MPs and the public in the gallery. Willie ...7 days ago
- Weekly Roundup 15-November-2024
Happy Friday, welcome to another round-up of interesting stories about what’s happening in Auckland and other cities. Feel free to add your links in the comments! This post, like all our work, is brought to you by a largely volunteer crew and made possible by generous donations from our readers ...7 days ago
- Are We The Waiting?
And screamingAre we we are, are we we are the waitingAnd screamingAre we we are, are we we are the waitingForget me nots, second thoughts live in isolationHeads or tails and fairy tales in my mindAre we we are, are we we are the waiting unknownThe rage and love, the ...7 days ago - The Hoon around the week to November 15
The podcast above of the weekly ‘Hoon’ webinar for paying subscribers on Thursday night features co-hosts & talking about the week’s news with:The Kākā’s climate correspondent on the latest climate news, including from COP29 this week; on the US Presidential elections, Israel vs Gaza/Iran/Lebanon, Ukraine/Nato vs Russia/North ...7 days ago
- First Tea and Toast, now Milo — why do NZ’s best beverages need so much defending?
Only two months ago, Nicola Willis had to step in to stop Health New Zealand cutting tea and toast for post-birth parents, and now Lester Levy is riding to the rescue with a welcome message for all: our health workers can once again drink Milo, and will no longer need ...1 week ago - Gordon Campbell on the folly of making apologies in a social vacuum.
Day One of the Treaty Principles Bill…and everyone got what they wanted, and did what they liked. Heated words were exchanged. Culturally appropriate acts of outrage were performed. David Seymour got to play the victim card. Willie Jackson got kicked out of class. A comically red-faced Mr Speaker bellowed “Order, ...1 week ago
- Skeptical Science New Research for Week #46 2024
Open access notables Microbial solutions must be deployed against climate catastrophe, Peixoto et al., Nature Communications [comment]: The climate crisis is escalating. A multitude of microbe-based solutions have been proposed, and these technologies hold great promise and could be deployed along with other climate mitigation strategies. However, these solutions have ...1 week ago
- The PM gets some extremely valuable legal advice for free
You can pay a great deal of money for the services of a KC. So just what would some peerless legal writing from 40 or so of them be worth, do you reckon?Priceless, that’s what. It’s not even the half of it, but this is my favourite part of the ...1 week ago - D-day for the government
The government's Treaty Principles Bill is up for its first reading today - bought forward in a rush in a desperate effort to avoid the hikoi which is currently marching on Wellington. But the Prime Minister won’t be there for it – he’s literally running away to Peru! But he ...1 week ago
- 97% of submissions did not want no-cause evictions, Trump chooses a Russian spy for US Intelligence ...
Good morning, and I’m sorry I’ve been away for a couple of days.I’ve been focusing on the Hikoi, and also testing out sentiment on the Treaty Principles Bill. It’s complicated, and the Treaty Principles Bill will be debated in the House today. The Government’s own lawyers have told them the ...1 week ago - Government must vote down ACT Members Bill that would undermine workers’ rights
NZCTU Te Kauae Kaimahi President Richard Wagstaff is calling on the Government to vote down an ACT Party Members Bill that would undermine workers’ rights by making it easier for employers to fire workers. Last week ACT MP Laura Trask’s Employment Relations (Termination of Employment by Agreement) Amendment Bill was ...1 week ago
- Seymour causes thousands of unjustified absences by forcing kids to fight for their rights instead o...
The State would like to remind you that they are in control. They manage your employment prospects, and can destroy the job market you and yours rely on by mass-cancelling construction projects, cutting funding, and firing a good chunk of our public servants. They wield the mechanisms that provide scrutiny ...1 week ago - The Weight of the World
As the weight of the world Hangs on your shoulders The weight of the world Starts to take over again And over again All that you once loved, now you hate So slowly relearn how to meditate To have and to hold And never let go Can you feel it ...1 week ago - Thursday 14 November 2024
The Treaty Principles Bill is set to have its First Reading in the House today, as the Hīkoi mō Te Tiriti continues. More than 40 KCs have written to the Prime Minister and Attorney-General outlining their “grave concerns” about the substance of the Treaty Principles Bill, while an academic and ...1 week ago
- Trump’s return to White House brings the climate’s ‘find out’ phase closer
As we absorb the news of Trump's victory in the US Presidential election, here’s a wrap compiled just before the result of what it might mean for climate action: The UN Secretary General says the prospective departure of the United States would cripple the Paris Agreement, likening it to the ...1 week ago
- Time and Space in the City Centre
Patrick Reynolds is deputy chair of the City Centre Advisory Panel. The header image is from Walthamstow, London The city centre now has a few stretches of street where the space has been repurposed to a people and place focused design from full time traffic use. These are a great ...1 week ago
- An opportunity for a pro-growth tax switch
As the Hikoi against it swells into the tens of thousands, KCs call on National to kill off ACT’s divisive Treaty Principles Bill. Photo: Getty ImagesKia ora. Long stories short, here’s my top things to note in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty on Thursday, November 14: The ...1 week ago - Dealing to the big Aussie banks
The big question hovering over the Select Committee Inquiry into banking is what the Government will do with its findings. If yesterday’s hearing is anything to go by there is a tidal wave of discontent about the four big Australian Banks crashing through the Committee which may force it to ...1 week ago
- 20 fact briefs published in collaboration with Gigafact!
In April 2024 we announced the (renewed) collaboration between Gigafact and Skeptical Science to create fact briefs, short but credibly sourced summaries that offer “yes/no” answers in response to claims found online. Our initial plan had been to publish one fact brief per week on Saturdays but - as happens ...1 week ago
- Instead of axing the HRC, ACT corruptly installed a racist, transphobic “Gay Human Rights Commissi...
On November 5th, the Spinoff published a very interesting article on Stephen Rainbow, the Human Rights Commission’s latest recruitment, and how he came to get the controversial appointment. Naturally because of the excitement of the US election, it’s flown a little below the radar. https://thespinoff.co.nz/politics/05-11-2024/i-didnt-get-the-hrc-job-stephen-rainbows-human-rights-commission-appointment-just-got-weirderThe article details evidence of the ...1 week ago - Injustice for torture
Between 1950 and 1993 the New Zealand government tortured and abused up to 250,000 children in residential care facilities. Yesterday, following formal findings from a royal commission, it finally apologised for that abuse. The next step is redress and restitution - compensating the surviving victims for the appalling harm they ...1 week ago
- Voices echo
1 week ago - Hīkoi over the Harbour
Kia mau ra, kia mau raKi te mana motuhakeMe te arohaHold fast, hold fastTo your sovereigntyAnd to love and compassionLyrics: Hīrini Melbourne. “Ngā Iwi E passionately calls for unity among the peoples of the Pacific, a cause deeply cherished by Melbourne himself.”I sat at my desk this morning and thought ...1 week ago
- NZ’s global climate rankings plummet as Govt removes agriculture from ETS
The Government has passed legislation to remove agriculture from the Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS) while Aotearoa’s reputation on climate action plummets. ...11 hours ago - Failed boot camp experiment must end
As legislation to set up boot camps passed its first reading, the Green Party urged the Government to abandon this failed policy experiment for the good of our rangatahi. ...12 hours ago
- Gender-affirming care must centre evidence and health needs, not political posturing
The Ministry of Health has today released an evidence brief regarding the use of puberty blockers in gender-affirming healthcare, amid moves by the government to limit access. ...12 hours ago
- Release: National doesn’t care about manufacturing
The National Government is walking away from our manufacturing sector with constant reports of closures and job losses. ...14 hours ago - Release: David Parker speech – Piketty, Inequality and Climate Change
David Parker's speech from the University of Auckland's forum on Piketty, Inequality and Climate Change in September 2024. ...14 hours ago
- Release: Youth mental wellbeing no longer a priority for Child Poverty Minister
Louise Upston has revealed her diminished vision for vulnerable youth against a backdrop of snubbed advice, scrapped priorities, shifted goal posts and thousands more children projected to fall into poverty. ...15 hours ago
- Release: National’s lack of climate action taking NZ backwards
National Government’s backward-looking climate policy has seen New Zealand fall seven places on the Climate Change Performance Index to 41 out of 63 countries measured. ...15 hours ago
- Release: Simple reason for drop in emergency housing
When the Government says it has reduced the number of people in emergency housing, what it means is it is stopping people from accessing it in the first place. ...18 hours ago
- Govt’s child wellbeing strategy ‘shallow and shameful’
The Government is turning its back on children by not only weakening child poverty reduction targets, but also removing child mental wellbeing as a priority focus in their Child and Youth Wellbeing Strategy. ...19 hours ago
- Release: A historic win for Samoan communities
Labour warmly welcomes the Restoring Samoan Citizenship Bill as it passes its third reading, before becoming law. ...20 hours ago
- Government plan to reinstate live animal exports a “national disgrace”
The Government has taken a giant step backwards by reinstating live animal exports. ...1 day ago
- Pasifika justice as Member’s Bill passes final reading
Teanau Tuiono’s Member’s Bill, the Citizenship (Western Samoa Restoration) Amendment Bill, has passed its third reading and will become law. ...1 day ago
- Release: Minister of Education thinks New Zealand ends at the Bombay Hills
The Minister of Education has shown complete disregard for rural communities and their school bus routes in Question Time today. ...1 day ago
- Economists sound alarm on Government’s slash-and-burn approach
A group of prominent economists has released an open letter to the Government, raising grave concerns about the far-reaching consequences of its fiscal policy. ...1 day ago
- Release: Smoking numbers up under Costello’s watch
National’s repeal of Labour’s smokefree legislation has taken New Zealand further away from achieving a Smokefree 2025 and a smokefree generation. ...2 days ago
- Release: Call for Palestine recognition by NZ, Australian and Canadian MPs
Parliamentarians from Australia, Canada and New Zealand have written an open letter to their respective Prime Ministers calling on them to recognise Palestine. ...2 days ago
- Justice Select Committee opens floor for Treaty Principles submissions
Today, the Justice Select Committee has decided to officially open submissions for the controversial Treaty Principles Bill. ...3 days ago
- Power of the people on full display as hīkoi approaches Parliament
Today, Hīkoi mō te Tiriti arrived in Wellington, with thousands gathering to march in unity against the divisive Treaty Principles Bill. ...3 days ago
- Hypocrisy as Te Whatu Ora contractor bill balloons
Te Whatu Ora’s bill for contracting and consulting staff has ballooned by nearly 20 percent under the National Government, breaking a promise they made during the election campaign to cut contractors. ...4 days ago
- Release: Growing pressure to scrap Section 7AA Repeal Bill
The newly released Section 7AA Repeal Bill's select committee report is further evidence that the Government should scrap it. ...4 days ago
- Government’s move to monetise access to nature a slippery slope
The Green Party is voicing serious concerns over the Government’s proposal to charge for access to public conservation land, released today. ...7 days ago
- Green Party condemns the passage of Treaty Principles Bill
The Green Party condemns the passing of the Treaty Principles Bill at first reading, and is clear that the fight is not over. ...1 week ago
- Stand Up for Te Tiriti
Te Tiriti o Waitangi is our country’s founding document. It forms the basis of the relationship between Māori and the Crown – and the Aotearoa New Zealand we live in today. ...1 week ago
- Release: Over 15,000 sign Labour’s open letter to Luxon
As the hīkoi to Parliament continues, Labour has sent an open letter to Prime Minister Christopher Luxon in a last-ditch attempt to get him to kill the Treaty Principles Bill. ...1 week ago
- Fast Track Bill threatens environment, climate and reputation
The fast-track legislation passing its second reading in Parliament is another step towards environmental ruin. ...1 week ago
- Greens join King’s Counsel in calling for Treaty Principles Bill to be abandoned
The Prime Minister must answer the call from a group of senior lawyers of the King’s Counsel to abandon the divisive Treaty Principles Bill. ...1 week ago
- Chris Hipkins’ apology statement to state and faith-based care survivors
...1 week ago
- Release: Labour formally apologises to state and faith-based care survivors
Labour joins with the Government in unreservedly apologising for the abuse, neglect and trauma including torture in state and faith-based care and for ignoring the voices of survivors for too long. ...1 week ago
- Green Party stands in support of survivors of abuse in care
Today, the Green Party stands alongside the survivors of abuse in state care and faith-based care as the Government issues an historic apology. ...1 week ago
- Green Party calls for conscience vote on Treaty Principles Bill
The Green Party has written to the Speaker of the House requesting he enable a personal vote on the Treaty Principles Bill. ...2 weeks ago
- Govt move to exclude journalist risks chilling effect
The Green Party is alarmed by the Government’s move to exclude a journalist from covering this week’s apology for the survivors of abuse in state and faith-based care. ...2 weeks ago
- Without action, an apology will be empty air
For tomorrow’s apology to survivors of abuse in state and faith-based care to hold any water, the Government must not pursue the same policies that drove the abuse in the first place. ...2 weeks ago
- Release: Concerns remain over tobacco interference
Concerns about the tobacco industry’s ability to interfere in government policy making remain, despite the inability of the Office of the Auditor-General to investigate the Government’s decision to halve the excise tax on heated tobacco products. ...2 weeks ago
- Urgent wake-up call on climate
The Climate Change Commission’s latest advice indicates Aotearoa needs to be stepping up on climate action. ...2 weeks ago
- Green MP’s Meme-ber’s Bill set to save the world
Break out the punchlines and dust off your meme folder: Green Party MP Kahurangi Carter’s Copyright (Parody and Satire) Amendment Bill was pulled from the Ballot yesterday. ...2 weeks ago
- Release: Poroporoaki: Ta Robert (Bom) Gillies
Kua hinga te manawa kairākau o Te Rua Tekau Ma Waru Tiwhatiwha te po! Kakarauru i te po! Ka rapuhia kei hea koe kua riro! Haere e te Ika a Whiro ki o tini hoa kua ngaro atu ki te Pō ...2 weeks ago
- Labour, Greens and Te Pāti Māori call on the Prime Minister to block the Treaty Principles Bill
The opposition parties stand united for an Aotearoa that honours Te Tiriti, rather than seeking to rewrite it. Labour, the Greens and Te Pāti Māori are working together against the Government’s divisive Treaty Principles Bill. ...2 weeks ago
- Release: Labour, Greens and Te Pāti Māori call on the Prime Minister to block the Treaty Principle...
The opposition parties stand united for an Aotearoa that honours Te Tiriti, rather than seeking to rewrite it. Labour, the Greens and Te Pāti Māori are working together against the Government’s divisive Treaty Principles Bill. ...2 weeks ago
- NZ must pursue independent foreign policy
The Green Party says the need is greater than ever for Aotearoa New Zealand to pursue an independent foreign policy. ...2 weeks ago
- Release: Winston Peters must apologise
The Deputy Prime Minister should apologise to the public servant he named and blamed for something they did not do, and for misusing the rules of Parliament. ...2 weeks ago
- Government action provides Southland farmers more time to meet plan requirements
The Government is taking action to ensure Southland farmers and growers are not affected by unreasonable regional farm plan deadlines, Agriculture Minister Todd McClay, Environment Minister Penny Simmonds and Associate Environment Minister Andrew Hoggard say.“Cabinet has agreed to provide more time for farmers and growers to comply with regional rules ...12 hours ago - Bill reaffirms Government’s commitment to crack down on serious youth offending
The Oranga Tamariki (Responding to Serious Youth Offending) Bill had its first reading at Parliament today. The Bill reaffirms the Government’s commitment to crack down on serious youth offending, Minister for Children Karen Chhour says. “In recent years we have seen an unacceptable spike in youth offending. “This Bill makes ...12 hours ago
- Critical milestones for earthquake buildings review
Fairer, more sensible rules about managing earthquake risks are a step closer with the passing of legislation and the appointment of an independent chair to provide expert advice, Minister for Building and Construction Chris Penk says. “The Government is committed to reinvigorating our cities and regions to support economic growth, ...13 hours ago
- State of the art radiology machine for Auckland
People in Northland and Auckland will benefit from a new machine for cancer treatment installed at the Regional Cancer and Blood Service at Auckland City Hospital. The MV5 linear accelerator, or LINAC machine, officially opened today targets cancer tumours with pinpoint accuracy. Health Minister Dr Shane Reti says this new, ...13 hours ago
- Foreign Minister to visit Europe
Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Minister Winston Peters will travel to Europe for high-level talks with France, Germany and the United Kingdom next week. "Since taking office almost a year ago, the Coalition Government has emphasised the importance we place on New Zealand's traditional and likeminded diplomatic and ...14 hours ago
- First arrests made under gang patch ban
Police have made their first arrests under the new gang patch legislation, with two gang members arrested, says Police Minister Mark Mitchell. “Just before 11 this morning, Police in Wairoa apprehended a gang member for wearing a patch to the supermarket. He has been arrested and will now face enforcement ...15 hours ago
- Better support for victims of sexual violence
The Government is proposing two major changes to name suppression laws that will put the views of victims of sexual violence first, Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith says. “We are committed to restoring law and order and these two proposed changes will help ensure the victims of crime are put at ...16 hours ago
- Government moving forward with Regional Deals
Cabinet has agreed to invite all regions to submit proposals for Regional Deals between central and local government that drive economic growth and deliver the infrastructure our country needs, Local Government Minister Simeon Brown and Infrastructure Minister Chris Bishop say. Inviting all regions to propose a Regional Deal that boosts ...16 hours ago
- MSA pilot participant update
One of the ten young men selected to participate in the Military-Style Academy Pilot has allegedly reoffended. Children’s Minister Karen Chhour is disappointed but says it would be naïve to think that none of these young men would reoffend. “I’m saddened that this young person has not taken this opportunity ...17 hours ago
- Attendance rates increase, again
Associate Education Minister David Seymour says that school attendance is continuing to rise. In Term 3 of 2024 51.3 per cent of students attended school regularly, an increase of 5.3 percentage points from 46 per cent in Term 3 of 2023. “This Government has prioritised student attendance and it is ...18 hours ago
- Improving the lives of young New Zealanders
Ensuring New Zealand is the best place in the world for children and young people is the vision at the heart of the Government’s new Child and Youth Strategy, Child Poverty Reduction Minister Louise Upston says. “Childhood represents a huge opportunity to set people on a positive path towards living ...21 hours ago
- Government continues work to reinstate livestock exports by sea
The Government is reinstating the trade of livestock exports by sea while ensuring the highest standards of animal welfare, says Associate Minister of Agriculture Andrew Hoggard.“The Government will introduce legislation changes to reinstate the trade, enhance oversight, and strengthen requirements for exporters to identify risks and manage the welfare of ...1 day ago
- Speech to the National Quality Forum 2024
Tēnā koutou katoa – it is a pleasure to be here today. I would like to begin by acknowledging the important leadership role you all play in ensuring a quality health system New Zealanders can trust. There is enormous clinical expertise in this room covering a wide range of disciplines. ...2 days ago
- New Zealand’s COP29 National Statement
Tēnā koutou katoa. Mr President, Excellencies, Delegates. New Zealand, and all nations represented here today, are already dealing with the impacts of climate change. Our households, businesses, and economies are bearing the costs of its effects. The choices we make now will shape the severity of these impacts for generations ...2 days ago
- Latest Quarterly Investment Report released
The Government has released its second Quarterly Investment Report (QIR) which shows substantial work still to be done by agencies to improve investment reporting and meet the Government’s expectations, Infrastructure and Acting Finance Minister Chris Bishop says. “New Zealand has significant infrastructure and investment needs. The Government is determined to get ...2 days ago
- New Zealand supporting loss and damage fund
Climate Change Minister Simon Watts announced New Zealand will contribute NZ$10 million to the new Fund for Responding to Loss and Damage while at the annual United Nations Climate Change Conference (COP29) in Baku, Azerbaijan. “New Zealand is joining the global effort to address the significant challenge of responding to ...2 days ago
- Gang crackdown begins at stroke of midnight
The free ride for gangs is over when the clock strikes midnight tonight, with tough new laws officially coming into effect, Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith and Police Minister Mark Mitchell say. “Gang patches will no longer be able to be worn in public. To earn the right to wear a ...2 days ago
- LGFA increases borrowing capacity to support high growth councils
The Government is welcoming the decision by the Local Government Funding Agency to increase access to financing tools for fast growing councils to support greater investment in critical infrastructure, Local Government Minister Simeon Brown says.“Communities across the country are facing an infrastructure deficit and significant population growth is projected in ...2 days ago
- Temporary Traffic Management costs revealed
The Government has revealed that over the past three years, the New Zealand Transport Agency (NZTA) has spent an eyewatering $786 million of taxpayers’ money on road cones and temporary traffic management (TTM), Transport Minister Simeon Brown says.“When I became Minister, I was surprised to learn that that NZTA did ...2 days ago
- Jurisdiction of Disputes Tribunal to double
Legislation that will double the financial jurisdiction of the Disputes Tribunal from $30,000 to $60,000 has passed first reading in Parliament today, Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith. “We need to improve court timeliness and access to justice so that Kiwis and get on with their lives. Court delays affect everyone, the ...2 days ago
- Protecting New Zealand from foreign interference
Legislation that will specifically criminalise foreign interference and strengthen espionage offences has passed first reading in Parliament today, Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith says. “It is normal and appropriate for states to interact and work to influence one another. This encourages cooperation and can have mutually beneficial outcomes. “However, the reality ...2 days ago
- Significant milestone for Canterbury Road of National Significance
Transport Minister Simeon Brown has welcomed news that the NZ Transport Agency (NZTA) Board has approved funding towards pre-implementation and early works on the State Highway 1 (SH1) Belfast to Pegasus Motorway and Woodend Bypass Road of National Significance (RoNS). “Reaching this significant milestone is a reflection of our Government’s ...3 days ago
- Health survey results to help drive change
Health Minister Dr Shane Reti says findings from the annual Health Survey highlight the need to continue driving better health outcomes for New Zealanders. The New Zealand Health Survey is an annual snapshot of key metrics measured from July 2023 – July 2024. Findings released this morning include: In 2023/24, ...3 days ago
- Final push needed to get to Smokefree 2025
A renewed effort to get people to quit smoking will build on what has worked to date and target the groups who most need support, Associate Health Minister Casey Costello said today. “The latest New Zealand Health Survey results show the daily smoking rate at 6.9 per cent and we ...3 days ago
- New diplomatic appointments
Foreign Affairs Minister Winston Peters has announced four new diplomatic appointments. “Our diplomats play an important role in ensuring New Zealand’s interests are maintained and enhanced across the world,” Mr Peters says. “It is a pleasure to announce the appointment of these senior diplomats from the Ministry of Foreign ...3 days ago
- Next steps for Regulatory Standards Bill
Regulation Minister David Seymour has today announced the next steps in the Government’s plan improve the quality of regulation by opening consultation on a proposed Regulatory Standards Bill. “New Zealand's low wages can be blamed on low productivity, and low productivity can be blamed on poor regulation,” says Mr Seymour. ...3 days ago
- Red Tape Tipline goes live
Minister for Regulation David Seymour has today announced that the Ministry for Regulation’s Red Tape Tipline is now live. “We want to hear about your red tape horror stories. From today, New Zealanders will have a say on how they are regulated through an online portal,” says Mr Seymour. The ...3 days ago
- Youth Parliament 2025 announced
The Minister for Youth Matt Doocey has today announced the eleventh Youth Parliament will be taking place in 2025. “Youth Parliament offers a unique youth development opportunity to young people from across New Zealand to experience the political process and learn about how government works,” says Mr Doocey. “The two-day ...4 days ago
- Police stats show promising change
After nearly a year in Government, Kiwis have seen significant change across law and order with promising early results shown across some Police statistics, says Police Minister Mark Mitchell. “In August 2023, I told New Zealanders that if they had not started to see a change in public safety within ...4 days ago
- Better coordination of anti-scam efforts
With the launch of Fraud Awareness Week, the Government is committing to new coordination efforts across industry and government to combat online scams, Commerce and Consumer Affairs Minister Andrew Bayly says. “Online financial scams are a growing problem for New Zealand. New data released today shows that Kiwis lost nearly ...4 days ago
- Minister to consider 7AA select committee report
Minister for Children Karen Chhour will consider the recommendations made by the Social Services and Community Committee in its report back to Parliament on the Oranga Tamariki (Repeal of Section 7AA) Amendment Bill. “I want to thank the people who made submissions and those who appeared before the committee in ...4 days ago
- Defence Minister to attend ASEAN meeting
Defence Minister Judith Collins will this week attend the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) Defence Ministers’ Meeting-Plus in Vientiane, Laos. “We need to take every opportunity to engage with our international partners, given the increasingly unstable geo-political situation,” Ms Collins says. “New Zealand has a long-standing commitment to this ...4 days ago
- Launching the White Ribbon Ride
The Minister for the Prevention of Family and Sexual Violence, Karen Chhour, was on hand to wish riders well at the start of the North Island leg of the White Ribbon Ride in Whakatāne this morning. The ride helps mark the International Day for the Elimination of Violence against Women, ...4 days ago
- Construction to begin on next stage of Papakura to Drury
Construction on the next stage of the SH1 Papakura to Drury project will begin early next month, with the contract for works awarded to Fulton Hogan, Transport Minister Simeon Brown says. "SH1 Papakura to Drury is a key project that will drive economic growth and productivity, reduce congestion, and enable people ...6 days ago
- NZ signs trade deal with Costa Rica, Iceland and Switzerland
Trade and Agriculture Minister Todd McClay has signed a pioneering trade agreement that prioritises New Zealand’s sustainable exports at a ceremony during APEC in Peru today. “The Agreement on Trade and Sustainability (ACCTS), between Costa Rica, Iceland, and Switzerland was concluded in July of this year and opens up significant ...6 days ago
- Government and iwi work together on aquaculture
Five new Aquaculture Settlement Areas will help ensure Ngāi Tahu shares in the opportunities aquaculture offers for Southland’s economy, Oceans and Fisheries Minister Shane Jones says. “The Aquaculture Settlement Areas (ASAs) I’m announcing today set aside space so the Crown and Ngāi Tahu can assess their potential for aquaculture development. ...7 days ago
- Government launches review to ensure electricity market is fit-for-purpose
The terms of reference for a review of the performance of the electricity market have been released. The review, initiated by the Coalition Government during the power crisis in winter will look at whether current regulations and market design support economic growth and access to reliable and affordable electricity, Energy Minister ...7 days ago
- Speech to Social Investment Hui: Jack and his whānau need our help
Kia ora koutou katoa. Nau mai, haere mai, piki mai. Ki te mihi atu ahau, ki te manwhenua nei, Te Atiawa, Ngāti toa rangatira, tēnā koutou, tēnā koutou, tēnā koutou katoa. Thank you, Andy, for your introduction. Let me acknowledge you as the new Chief Executive of the Social Investment ...7 days ago
- Minister of State for Trade heads to Brisbane for PACER Plus meeting
Minister of State for Trade Nicola Grigg has travelled to Australia to attend the PACER Plus Ministers Meeting in Brisbane. “Trade plays a critical role in driving employment, economic growth, and improving the standards of living in the Pacific Region. The Government is strongly committed to supporting Pacific Island countries ...7 days ago
- Proposals to modernise conservation released
Toitū te taiao – Our environment endures The Government is consulting on proposals to modernise New Zealand’s conservation management system, aiming to protect relevant natural areas while supporting sustainable growth in tourism and regional economies, Conservation Minister Tama Potaka says. “Today, the Department of Conservation – Te Papa Atawhai is ...7 days ago
- Grattan on Friday: Marles plays a defensive bat on nuclear as the government rushes to get though la...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra Richard Marles is an ambitious man who hasn’t given up the dream of one day reaching the top job. But, despite being deputy prime minister, his profile is much lower than that of Treasurer Jim ...5 hours ago - NEW POLL: Kiwis Overwhelmingly Support MPs’ Expenses Transparency Law Change
62% of respondents support the extension of the OIA to cover MPs’ spending, compared to just 13% opposed and 24% were unsure. ...7 hours ago - The House: Meanwhile, a week of passing law
The political week has been packed with worthy distractions, but all week Parliament has focused on passing new laws. Here are the highlights. ...7 hours ago - The biggest difference between Hīkoi mō te Tiriti and past hīkoi: More support from non-Māori
Analysis - The diversity of voices during the hīkoi was noticeable - from tangata moana to young immigrants to elderly Pākehā from the South Island. ...8 hours ago
- The House: Samoan citizenship restoration – ‘It means we belong to this land’
When the bill to restore NZ citizenship to some Samoans passed this week, Parliament's galleries were full to the brim with members of the community. ...9 hours ago
- More Delays In Action On Use Of Puberty Blockers With Children
Women’s Rights Party Co-leader Jill Ovens says the Ministry has put New Zealand children at risk by continuing to allow “off-label” prescribing of puberty blockers at far higher rates than other similar countries. ...10 hours ago
- Police Minister adamant he wasn’t aware of gang members training at gun clubs
That is despite two papers from police that raised the matter with him. ...10 hours ago
- Shorten declares himself ‘a proud moderate’, saying Australians ‘in the middle’ shouldn’t ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra Bill Shorten has declared himself “a proud moderate” in a valedictory speech declaring parliament has the responsibility to ensure the extremes of left and right do not set the terms of political debate. Shorten, ...11 hours ago
- New ‘best practice’ principles for superannuation products are coming. We asked a panel of exper...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Matt Garrow, Editorial Web Developer Studio Romantic/Shutterstock We all know how important it is to save enough money for retirement – but what about spending it wisely when we get there? Even for those who have built up a suitable ...11 hours ago
- Government accused of betraying Kiwis’ trust over lack of consultation on live exports
The government has always vowed to reinstate live exports by sea, which was banned by the previous Labour government. ...11 hours ago
- 7 things you can do if you think you sweat too much
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Michael Freeman, Associate Professor of Dermatology, Bond University ERIK Miheyeu/Shutterstock Sweating is our body’s way of cooling down, a bit like an internal air conditioner. When our core temperature rises (because it’s hot outside, or you’re exercising), sweat glands all ...11 hours ago
- Phenergan for under 6s is now banned due to hallucination fears. Here’s what to use instead
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Nial Wheate, Professor of Pharmaceutical Chemistry, Macquarie University Australia’s drug regulator has issued a safety warning over the medicine Phenergan and related products containing the antihistamine drug promethazine. The Therapeutic Goods Administration said the over-the-counter products should not be given to children ...11 hours ago
- A new stage adaptation of Peter Carey’s Jack Maggs is a delightful homage to theatrical storytelli...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Catherine Campbell, Lecturer, Performing Arts, UniSA Creative, University of South Australia Matt Byrne/STCSA Jack Maggs is a delight and a homage to theatrical storytelling in Australia. Based on Peter Carey’s bestselling novel, Jack Maggs follows the ex-convict as he lands ...11 hours ago
- The government has introduced laws for its social media ban. But key details are still missing
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Daniel Angus, Professor of Digital Communication, Director of QUT Digital Media Research Centre, Queensland University of Technology Ron Lach/Pexels The federal government today introduced into parliament legislation for its social media ban for people under 16 years. Communications Minister Michelle ...12 hours ago
- Archives NZ, National Library to cut 27 roles
The Department of Internal Affairs wants to bring the two organisations under the joint leadership of the Chief Archivist and National Librarian. ...12 hours ago
- Gang patch ban: Members warn of potential for violence to ‘erupt’ as new laws enforced
"I can't see this lasting unless they have a budget to lock fullas up in jail which I think is absolutely stupid, really it's ludicrous," Ngavii Pekapo, who set up a Mongrel Mob chapter 54 years ago, says. ...12 hours ago
- ACT leader David Seymour raises doubts about Waikato medical school
Government documents show ACT leader David Seymour told the government he was "dissatisfied" with a cost-benefit analysis. ...12 hours ago
- National’s Erica Stanford allegedly calls Labour’s Jan Tinetti a ‘stupid bitchR...
The Education Minister has apologised in Parliament for her remark. ...12 hours ago
- Labour backs new Police Commissioner – but warns against routine arming
The alternative to policing by consent would be a police state, which New Zealanders don't want, the party says. ...14 hours ago
- Youth on boot camp pilot re-offended five weeks after release
Children's Minister Karen Chhour said while it was disappointing, it would naïve to think none of the participants would lapse. ...14 hours ago
- In photos: People of the hīkoi, and why they marched
Hikoi mō Te Tiriti has come to an end, going down in history as the largest march to Parliament in Aotearoa. ...14 hours ago
- ‘Everything is becoming a culture war’: Jon Ronson on conspiracies and cycleways
Ahead of his appearance in Aotearoa, the acclaimed British journalist, podcaster and documentarian talks to Stewart Sowman-Lund about why people are still fascinated by the fringes. The last place I would expect to find Jon Ronson is relaxing in the countryside. The iconic British journalist and writer is best known ...15 hours ago - Kia kaha Lebanon: NZ media only tell half your story of struggle
The United States has vetoed a UN Security Council ceasefire resolution — for the fourth time — in Israel’s war on Gaza, while Hezbollah demands a complete ceasefire and “protection of Lebanon’s sovereignty” in any deal with Israel. Amid the death and devastation, Joe Hendren reflects on his time in ...15 hours ago
- ‘Deserves a Bafta’: After the Party premieres in the UK to five-star reviews
The acclaimed New Zealand drama has just premiered on TV in the United Kingdom, and the five-star reviews are already flowing in. Six months after it was called a “blistering” “tour de force” by Australian critics, and nearly a year since The Spinoff declared it the best drama New Zealand ...15 hours ago
- Drugs are getting cheaper and easier to find in Aotearoa
New Zealanders are drinking and smoking less, but most other recreational drugs are becoming cheaper, more popular and more available, two new reports show. Two significant new surveys about drugs in Aotearoa were released this week, offering a rare insight into New Zealanders’ choice of substances, which ones are becoming ...15 hours ago
- COP29: ‘climate finance’ for the Pacific is mostly loans, saddling small island nations with mor...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Steven Ratuva, Director, Macmillan Brown Centre for Pacific Studies, University of Canterbury Lenora Qereqeretabua, the deputy speaker of Fiji’s Parliament, at the COP29 climate summit. IISD/ENB/Mike Muzurakis, CC BY-SA As this year’s UN climate summit reaches its final stage of negotiations, Pacific ...16 hours ago
- Review: The magic of Wicked and the curse of corporate greed
The new movie musical is undoubtedly a fun watch, but it’s also proof that bigger isn’t always better, writes Stewart Sowman-Lund. Contains minor spoilers for Wicked. There’s no doubt that Wicked is going to be huge. No other pop culture event this year, save from maybe Charli XCX’s Brat, has ...17 hours ago
- Dame Jacinda Ardern to be given United Nations leadership award
She will get the champion for global change award from the United Nations Foundation at a ceremony in New York tomorrow. ...18 hours ago
- NZ will resume live animal exports – to low demand
Analysis: NZ is lifting what was supposed to be a permanent ban on live animal exports. But it’s not the lucrative industry it once was. The post NZ will resume live animal exports – to low demand appeared first on Newsroom. ...18 hours ago - Financial forms of family violence affect one in seven of us – but the law is lagging
There are calls for New Zealand’s Family Violence Act to name economic harm as a standalone type of violence, rather than a subcategory of psychological abuse, to bring it in line with the United Kingdom and Australia. Economic harm – restricting access to, sabotaging or exploiting another person’s financial resources, ...18 hours ago
- Downside Risks To Treasury’s Economic And Fiscal Forecasts
New Zealand is currently running a structural fiscal deficit, with expenditure exceeding revenue. Economic growth falling short of expectations has been making it harder for the Government to bring the books back into balance. ...19 hours ago
- Science continues to exclude Indigenous communities. Fixing this benefits everyone
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Jordan Peter Anthony Pitt, Associate Dean of Indigenous Strategy and Services (Faculty of Science), University of Sydney An enduring challenge facing science around the world is how to best include and engage Indigenous communities. In Australia, for example, 0.5% of Indigenous ...20 hours ago
- Why is cricket so popular on the Indian sub-continent?
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Vaughan Cruickshank, Senior Lecturer in Health and Physical Education, University of Tasmania Cricket originated in England, but has been spread worldwide by British soldiers and settlers in the past few hundred years. It is now the second most popular sport in ...20 hours ago
- Disinformation and deepfakes played a part in the US election. Australia should expect the same
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Renee Barnes, Associate professor of Journalism, University of the Sunshine Coast Mladen Zivkovic/Shutterstock As America takes stock after Donald Trump’s re-election to the presidency, it’s worth highlighting the AI-generated fake photos, videos and audio shared during the campaign. A slew ...20 hours ago
- Is thunderstorm asthma becoming more common?
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Kira Morgan Hughes, PhD Candidate in Allergy and Asthma, School of Life and Environmental Sciences, Deakin University When spring arrives, so do warnings about thunderstorm asthma. But a decade ago, most of us hadn’t heard of it. So where did thunderstorm asthma ...20 hours ago
- Overwhelmed by ever more clothing donations, charities are exporting the problem. Local governments ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Yassie Samie, Postdoctoral Researcher in Fashion and Textiles, RMIT University anna.spoka/Shutterstock What happens to your clothes after you don’t want them any more? Chances are, you will donate them to op shops run by a charity organisation. There are more ...20 hours ago
- Friendly fire: a nuclear push by allies at COP29 poses a sticky problem for Albanese
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By John Quiggin, Professor, School of Economics, The University of Queensland IndustryAndTravel/Shutterstock Prime Minister Anthony Albanese didn’t see this coming. At the global COP29 climate talks in Baku, the Australian government was indirectly criticised by two allies, the United States and the ...20 hours ago
- Nugget Is Dead brings queer love, multiculturalism and Aussie flair to the Christmas movie formula
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Phoebe Hart, Associate Professor, Film Screen & Animation, Queensland University of Technology Julia Firak Stan’s new Christmas film Nugget is Dead is a colourful production that follows the rules of the seasonal genre film to a tee – with an Aussie ...20 hours ago
- Help Me Hera: Should I cut contact with my ex-stepdad?
My parents are finally getting divorced. So why do I feel like my stepdad’s feelings are still my problem? Want Hera’s help? Email your problem to helpme@thespinoff.co.nz Dear Hera My parents recently announced their separation. This in itself isn’t a problem. I’ve already gone through this once before in my early childhood, so ...20 hours ago
- New Zealand Drops In Global Ranking On Climate Action
If the government won’t hold polluters to account, then people will. People are increasingly taking to the streets and the courtrooms, putting their bodies on the line to shut down polluting industries. This will only escalate further unless New ...20 hours ago
The server will be getting hardware changes this evening starting at 10pm NZDT.
The site will be off line for some hours.
Good piece, thank you….just imagine if any of our media (including RNZ) allowed this sort of narrative to get even a little air or print time…just to, you know, offer a bit of balance, but no…just one singular narrative is ever allowed on MSM when it comes to Russia….as I mentioned earlier, it is exactly like when they were pushing the Trump/Russia conspiracy…no counter narrative allowed..ever, no matter how ridiculous and absurd their stories became….it was jaw dropping to watch.
"so this shift would be just another way of bringing us into line and effectively signalling the end of any pretension on our part to an independent foreign policy. There was no opportunity for select committee submission or wider discussion on the Russia-only sanctions legislation, and once imposed sanctions are hard to back down from. That debate is urgently needed now."
There will be no debate…in case you haven't noticed….debating to not allowed.
It is, here on TS
That is true Incognito….unfortunately the debate that should be happening and actually matters is not held on small forums such as these ( as fun and informative as they are)..debates and just mature conversations should obviously just be a regular and normal part of the MSM news cycle for all citizens to be informed by…why isn’t that happening do you think?
The thing that always comes to mind to me on this subject is Malcom X and Huey P Newton..now here are people that we know that the establishment in the US considered to be an radical and dangerous extremists…but were regularly interviewed and debated on MSM in the US, even from a prison cell no less!…do you think that Malcom X or Newrton would be respectfully interviewed and debated on MSM today?..can you remember the last time Assange was interviewed by MSM?
I’d like to think that debates on important issues are much more than “fun and informative”. They’re important for participation and engagement of all people who want it – freedom of speech is critical to an inclusive pluriform society. MSM don’t seem to have a functional debating feature and only comment sections and open letters (letters to the Editor) at most. If we want more and better debate we need to have and set examples and make it happen – be the change you want to see. So, why not here, on TS?
Sorry I didn’t mean to belittle the place of TS as an important place where ordinary citizens can engage one another in meaningful political debate and discourse, I think it is all of those things and is a great asset to all who use it..I should have chosen my words with more care.
However I am still interested in your answer to my primary question, which was, why has discussion and debate on extremely important issues like Trump/Russia and Ukraine/Russia, for all intent and purposes been completely deleted from MSM output?
Clearly you must have a very limited and highly select view of media (doesn't surprise me after reading your waffle in recent weeks).
It has pretty much been the consistent topic of all the printed and net media that I have read for 3 weeks.
I can't speak for broadcast media like radio or TV because I seldom bother with it. But RNZ website have about 4 articles on their main page on aspects of the conflict in Ukraine as it relates to NZ today. Stuff has at least 7 articles. abc.net.au has about 5 articles. Washington post, BBC world news, NY Times have a *lot* of articles and opinion pieces. The Economist that I read on Sunday had about 15% allocated to discussions of the economic and political effects.
Even mainly tech sites like The Register, Ars technicia, Quora, and other that I routinely read have articles on various aspects.
Medium has gone mad with opinions on the politics and the conflict.
Military analysis sites like Janes have been awash with information. I won't even mention the war blogs.
Perhaps you just need to learn to read wider than your own navel?
As far as those other sites go..of course these is plenty of good information on the net if you know where to find it..or more importantly have the inclination to do so…which, let's be honest here, most people don't..most people still rely heavily on MSM for their news and views, so it is vital that these outlets are fair and balanced…which as far as I have seen they are not.. show us some recent links to MSM presenting a fair and balanced Russian perspective of why they have gone into the Ukraine….I am happy to be proved wrong.
It seems to me that many people disagree on what, how, when or who decides what is “good information”. Do people have to decide on an ad hoc basis and for and by themselves, i.e. reinvent the wheel each and every time, or are there rules of thumb or guidelines that they can use? What role does one’s education, experience, scepticism & independent critical thinking, values & morals, ideology & tribalism, or prejudice, for example, play in all this? What role do role models, experts & expert authority, or peer pressure, for example, play in all this?
The view that I would think is fair and balanced is highly unlikely to be one that you would consider to be fair and balanced.
Since the topic is sanctions. I have been impressed with the quality of analysis in the last two issues of The Economist on the effects of currently added sanctions and blocks against Russia on both Russia and Europe. Those are free falling the Russian economy as we speak.
The effects on Europe are limited as few of the gas pipelines are currently configured to send gas to China or anywhere apart from west to Europe. Bearing in mind that they are just about the only large hard currency export that Russia has at present. It makes it hard to rearm a army that is expending munitions at the rate that Russia is without hard currency to buy machine tools or munitions. Unlike the US or NATO countries at present, China isn’t noted for giving things away.
https://www.economist.com/printedition/2022-03-19
https://www.economist.com/printedition/2022-03-12
To a much lesser extent on raw material supplies for the world if Russia decides to try to leverage sanctions on hydrocarbons, nickel and wheat. That winds up as cost increases but ones that aren’t hard to work around for the sanctioning and sanctioned nations – except for Russia – which has a real problem with spare parts and payment with a falling currency.
Wheat has a limited effect because there will be a lot of response to increase production from other wheat growing areas. It is also likely that the biggest issue about wheat i not Russia doing sanctions. It is the effective closure of the Black Sea ports of both Ukraine and Russia by a combination of each others forces, those of Turkey, and the cost of insurance. Since that is where most of Russia and Ukraine ship most of their wheat and raw materials from apart from gas, There is already an effective blockage of most Russian hard currency exports.
Unfortunately for Russia going into summer is the worst time to try to use sanctions on gas. And there is a lot of spare gas and oil producing capacity at prices rise. Fracking in the US and elsewhere will have a field day.
Nickel is interesting. The main market for Russian high quality Nickel is actually China these days for EV batteries and stainless steel. Trying to get China to sanction anyone is going to be tricky if they make profit out of it.
But there are a number of sites in the US and other places that become viable for fast production wind ups. All that takes is a change in attitude and a rise in prices. Try WSJ. But the same issues apply for places like Canada and Australia.
After all that is what markets are good to respond to – price increases are opportunities.
Basically Russia has virtually no additional leverage except for gas – and no other way of generating income to support their war for very long without hard currency.
"The view that I would think is fair and balanced is highly unlikely to be one that you would consider to be fair and balanced."…so just to be clear, are you saying that overall you would consider MSM coverage of the Ukraine crisis to be 'fair and balanced' or not?
Nope – that is your way of trying to shove word into my throat to satisfy your simple and limited nuance world view.
Let me ask you some questions to see where you stand around some of the more obvious media
It depends which MSM you're talking about. FFS: it isn't monolithic to the point that anyone could say "MSM says…".
For instance Russia Today is about as uselessly unbalanced as it is possible to get. But the Russia owners asserts that it is free and fair media. It didn't look that way to me the other day – I could damn near see the wires opening and shutting the anchors mouths. It claims to have a world wide audience. I have it on my TV apps along DW, EuroNews and a number of others that I occassionally glance at.
Do you consider RT to be MSM? What do you think about their coverage?
Going to a RNZ, which is also is a state supported organisation that in my view produces reasonably factual and often quite detailed written analysis. Its radio shows usually top the reported listener ship ratings of all radio stations in NZ. I listen to that regularly to track NZ news.
Do you consider them to be MSM?
Mike Hosking operates what is reputed to be the most popular radio show in the private sector for NZ. I find that he operates a fact and news free zone where he blows arbitrary 'reckons' that appear to arise mostly arise from forms of ignorance and outright bigotry. He just labels something without ever bothering looking at the detail. I characterise him as simple parasitical entertainer who is only really interested in his pay packet.
Do you consider them to be MSM?
Fox News has a massive audience in the US and elsewhere. Personally I find it really hard to find any interesting factual information in the opinion leaders. Most of the time they seem to simply repeating other Fox news heads talking points – sort of a incestuous Jörmungandr.
Do you consider them to be MSM?
What do you consider to be MSM? Because I don't have a definition that goes beyond that it is vast range of organisations and people – that doesn't appear to have a definition.
//———–
Basically if you want an actual answer rather than getting blown off as a idiot shithead who asks leading pig-fucker questions (third interpretation), then I suggest that you get quite specific in your questions.
If that means your questions will expose your actual opinions and ideas more clearly that you usually do, and therefore to criticism. Well, then it would be a nice change from your usual lazy critic s role where you say nothing much of interest and as you act as like a particularly stupid religious policeman.
"that is your way of trying to shove word into my throat to satisfy your simple and limited nuance world view."
"Nope – that is your way of trying to shove word into my throat to satisfy your simple and limited nuance world view"
Iprent, why don't you settle the hell down for once for fucks sake man…all I was doing was asking you to clarify your previous statement..nothing more, nothing less…I will go through your questions later an answer them respectfully, maybe you could try doing that in kind for me in future.
Nope you asked for my opinion on something that has a very broad definition, and for which you provided no bounds to describe what you were requesting it on.
You were asking me to express an opinion on an unbounded something that I don't know and could never know without reading your mind. Because you didn’t provide and explanation of what you were asking about.
There is a reason that such questions are limited in virtually all work and legal settings.
If I had someone ask me something like "how long do you think that X would take?" in a work situation, I'd be asking for a specification or clarification – and I wouldn't be polite about it.
It is a classic ploy by police in interviews and interrogations, and it isn't hard to find even death row convictions based on such questions solely based on such questions – which is why they are often called pig-fucker questions.
It is a standard ploy for lawyers to people on the stand, and also the cause of probably about half of all objections in court by opposing barristers.
And of course it is a common and very familiar evasion tactic on on-line forums to try to snarl debate up into definitions of discussion – that the original author should have taken the time to define in the first place. The person deliberately using that reprehensible tactic is usually after a situation where they can write a soothing remark saying essentially “I don’t know what you’re upset about” so they can feel they pwned the discussion.
Basically, in all circumstances, just asking pig-fucker questions has to be viewed as an indication towards stupidity, ignorance or malevolence.
You haven't exactly engendered trust from me on the latter motivation – so I assume malevolence. My responses to the tactic usually just tear a strip of flesh as a reminder not to do it again.
So your behaviour really does look that of a horrible pigfucker. Would you like me to adjust your handle to reflect that?
Umm. I do take your point if you were talking about the local blogs.
Just had a look at TDB and KB. Posts and even the discussion there is pretty muted. Even Bowalley is light (and kind of confused).
Not so muted here …
Just bloody noisy. Robust debate generates a lot of steam as friction warms up the usual social lubricants.
"So your behaviour really does look that of a horrible pigfucker. Would you like me to adjust your handle to reflect that?"…..
Thanks for exposing to everyone exactly what you are….a disgusting low life.
Perhaps you should look back at the names and debating techniques you had been applying to others who disagreed with you before I intervened.
I wrote a comment about what I was planning to do to you.
I just took your behaviour and amplified it because you appear to not be considering your own behaviour and how it appears to others.
Found a label that you objected to and keep piling it on. Kept demanding that you answer questions and justify your opinions on some arbitrary basis that you were being judged on. Never dealt with any point that you raised, but instead deliberately dealt with a misinterpretation of it. Demanded that my way set how you should judge yourself. In short I acted like your sanctimonious self.
In other words it was a mirror. I guess you liked as much as others liked dealing with you doing it to them.
If you don't like it, then you should look to your own behaviour. In an exaggerated way, that is what you look like on this forum to me and to others.
In case you hadn't realised it, part of my role on this site is to act as the shit hammer. The reason for that is obvious. Someone has to to do it to make sure that the place doesn’t wind up as a shit pit. I have a longer history and more resources at stake in this site than anyone else, so I tend to do it when I have time.
If you don't like it, then I'd be happy to point you to the last paragraph on the about.
/torment
TDB seems a bit like blocked plumbing these days–KB denizens who have slipped their collars often feature–and Bowalley is rather turgid in terms of the commenters.
The Standard, though I despair at the world view of some here, is more free flowing and more useful links imo.
Nothing sharpens your views as being put on the spot.
They want to bring this war to an end.
Just so – and they are prepared to sacrifice the last Ukrainian to do it.
George Soros’ Open Society Foundation, known for funding colour revolution regime change operations,
Better known for reprinting Popper's The Open Society and its Enemies.
As Putin goes full totalitarian, Russia's defeat is increasingly desirable. The question the West (and that includes NZ) must answer, is whether the minimal level of our aid is unnecessarily prolonging the conflict.
As Sun Tzu says I have known bad short wars, but I have never known a good war that went on for any length of time. The rump of the Soviet regime has been tolerated for far too long, at tremendous cost to Russians and to their neighbours – half of Chechnya died at Putin's direction in the second Chechen War.
Putin is a war criminal, and must be treated as such. The Ukraine invasion is criminal. The Chechen Genocide and Citrus Wars were criminal. And whining about America doesn't make it any better.
That said, almost no-one will object to Bush fils meeting justice for using white phosphorus in Fallujah – apparently to make sure no child was left behind.
"The rump of the Soviet regime has been tolerated for far too long, at tremendous cost to Russians and to their neighbours – half of Chechnya died at Putin's direction in the second Chechen War"
By Soviet regime I assume you are referring to the democratically elected Putin govt?…anyway that aside, I fully agree with your statement Re;Chechnya, but just wondering if you think we should ally that level of culpability to the the USA, and the rest of the world should stop also stop tolerating the USA regime for all their well know world wide inflicted destruction and chaos?
By Soviet regime I assume you are referring to the democratically elected Putin govt?
You are perhaps unaware of the story that won the Russian Journalism Award in the year of his first election, which detailed scores of large scale systematic electoral frauds. It has largely been excised from the net, along with the institution that published it. Putin was at the peak of his popularity at the time, in the wake of his successful genocide in Chechnya, and would have won on the second ballot – but he cheated anyway. And the journalists (about thirty of them) who contributed to that story confirm that he has cheated in every election since. So, democratically elected? No.
we should ally that level of culpability to the the USA, and the rest of the world should stop also stop tolerating the USA regime for all their well know world wide inflicted destruction and chaos?
There are indeed many sins that can be laid at the door of the US, but there are leavening instances of appropriate behaviour, like the rescue of South Korea from the invasion of the Stalinist north and subsequently the Chinese human wave attacks.
It is the level of oppression the US visits on its own citizens not approaching that of either period or contemporary Stalinism, that makes regime change both viable and desirable for Russia, but not the US, at this time.
Putin is the rump of a failed Soviet leadership, with no vision for the world beyond banditry. He is illegitimate, having no genuine mandate from the Russian people, nor is he a popular or effective administrator. We need hardly make such calculations however, since he made himself president for life! No-one is that good, though Tito and some others were able to achieve something similar, without cheating.
First let me make it crystal clear, I do not like nor do I endorse Putin or his many nefarious and horrific actions…however your comment is so full half-truths, straight out inaccuracies and misdirection, you leave one no choice but rebut your comment…Putin has so many faults I don’t understand why you and so many on this site insist on doing this…why not just stick to the facts…
“and would have won on the second ballot – but he cheated anyway. And the journalists (about thirty of them) who contributed to that story confirm that he has cheated in every election since. So, democratically elected? No”
Creditable academic link to those assertions please…
and also a creditable link to establish if there is any factual truth that Putin doesn’t enjoy overwhelming support from the Russian population…which would of course establish as a fact that he has been democratically elected.
“like the rescue of South Korea from the invasion of the Stalinist north and subsequently the Chinese human wave attacks.”
I assume that you are not aware that the US Military version of the Korean War that you and I consumed most of our lives has been thoroughly debunked (mainly by US historians I might add), as is much of our perception of The Eastern Front in WW2 ( if you are actually seriously interested in this history I strongly recommend you read ‘Operation Barbarossa and Germany's Defeat in the East’)
The Mistaken History of the Korean War: What We Got Wrong Then and Now
https://www.kobo.com/ph/en/ebook/the-mistaken-history-of-the-korean-war
Maybe read his preface here
Further the barbaric actions of the US military in “saving” South Korea is now widely regarded as a war crime…as it should have been at the time….
US destruction of North Korea must not be forgotten
https://asiatimes.com/2020/06/us-destruction-of-north-korea-must-not-be-forgotten/
Can the United States Own Up to Its War Crimes During the Korean War?
https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/can-united-states-own-its-war-crimes-during-korean-war/
There is plenty more in your comment I could rebut but lets start with these first few points shall we…
You know I get really tired of your prating, fatuous ignorance. I spent getting on for fifteen years in Korea, and discussed the war at length with quite a few people, including Park's chief economist and a history professor. It's fair to say that you don't know wtf you are talking about.
There is plenty more in your comment I could rebut
You should abandon hope of rebutting people, until you have taken the trouble to learn something about the subjects in which you improperly claim expertise.
Do you really imagine that I, and the other people you argue with here, are ignorant of US war crimes in Korea? Or of MacArthur's plan to nuke and invade China? Of the bombing of civilians, or the hunting of the Cheju dissenters?
I do not like nor do I endorse Putin
Yet you miss no opportunity to parrot his foolish propaganda, and take his side at every opportunity. I'm not sure if you are fooling yourself, but you certainly aren't fooling us.
Of course, as suspected, no links to back up anything you say, in this comment, or for the links I asked for to verify your assertions in your last comment…so in other words, you must think everyone should just believe everything you say…because…well, you said it?…it doesn't work like that pal…put up, or shut up.
I would have thought that, you know, the actual Russian Communist Party (which opposes the War) would have been the rump of the actual Soviet leadership. Putin is no Communist, of course. His brand of nationalistic reaction is basically the Tsarist Empire – minus the Tsar.
that, you know, the actual Russian Communist Party (which opposes the War) would have been the rump of the actual Soviet leadership.
In a better world perhaps.
Putin's inheritance is less ideological, and more of the style of governance practiced by the Soviets, and yes, the Tsars before him – autocratic repression with lashings of Russian imperialism.
Sometimes doing the right thing costs. So, sanctions on Russia will certainly be very costly for the west as well as Russia.
Sure, a few countries like Russia and China may set up their alternative to the SWIFT system. But that those sort of moves will take time.
The point at the moment is to run Russia out of funds so they can't continue the war effort. If it wasn't for this, then Russia would have the military might to eventually overcome Ukraine. But, the effect of sanctions will be to run them out of money for the fight. Thus, the longer Ukraine can hang on the more difficult it becomes for Russia
In the longer term, the big issue for Russia is that European countries are looking for ways to free themselves from dependency on Russian energy. I suspect that many Western countries will start to view China in a similar way. Thus, I don't think China will be happy with what is happening in Ukraine at the moment.
Also, many of the Western companies that have withdrawn from Russia may well not return.
Thus, Russia is going to be much poorer and weaker at the end of all this.
Russians might be poorer but they’ll be a lot healthier , McDonalds, Pepsi, Coca cola Starbucks, British America tobacco,Nestle…whoosh! Gone!! whats not to like
LOL. Fair point.
MacDonalds stores In Russia are being rebranded as Uncle Vanya's ( from the Chekov play)
You may notice the logo seems familiar ( V is written as B in cryrillic)
These same sanctions were enacted against Russia circa 2014-2015 after the C.I.A funded coup that deposed the russia friendly Ukraine Govt.
Russia will have been expecting them.
German acceptance of sanctions on Russian banks and via SWIFT was not expected, nor the immediate doubling of its defence budget and suspension of Nordstrom (this led the wider western move away from Russian oil and gas).
Oil and Gas arent under sanction ( of course its not)
Gazprombank and Sberbank arent excluded from Swift ( of course they arent)
Utter nonsense – these sanctions, in many cases bordering on embargoes, are far deeper than anything ever imposed on any nation ever. They go well beyond even government actions – global companies are pulling back as fast and deeply as possible.
Putin's war in the Ukraine is going to degenerate into a brutal stalemate; the Russian's know they cannot win anything meaningful in the political sense, so now they are going to inflict as much misery and suffering as possible with the goal of terrifying not so much the Ukrainians, but the rest of the world into surrender.
Putin has degenerated into pure evil mode. His western cheerleaders are supping with a fucking short spoon.
Yes the U.S seems steadfast in their refusal to accept Russias really quite understandable demands.
Pity it's the Ukrainians that suffer because of U.S recalcitrance.
There can be no stalemate…Putin would find that too much to …bear.
It is the Ukrainian people who are rejecting these 'reasonable' Russian demands with their lives.
Right now as you type.
It is the Ukrainian people whose lives are being lost and ruined ,not its puppet master who pulls their strings.
Not yet a month has gone by since the real conflict began.
It certainly looks like Russia under estimated the opposition.
Whether it takes 1 month or 3 months the result will be the same.
It is another american inspired…tragedy imo.
Despite all the 'blue-eye' flag waving and Russia phobic ranting, it is interesting to note from today's Ukrainian death toll that is still less than the accumulated losses in the Donbass which was supposed to be protected from Ukraine by the Minsk Accords which were ignored, no doubt with NATO blessing.
It is about time the world got beyond living under tyranny of every shade, especially that perpetrated by the hypocrisy soaked enforced alliance we have now been firmly signed up to under our 'Independent foreign policy'.
Ahh The keyboard warriors have spoken. 3 cheers for the Qwerty Brigade
Ctrl Alt , Crtl Alt , Ctrl Alt.
Those are not the decisions that the US can make. They are decisions for Ukraine.
Tell me – do you also wish that Australia or the US makes the foreign policy and security decisions for us? I suspect that you'd be up in arms at the idea..
Yet you have the unmitigated gall to try to say that the USA (and presumably Russia) as an imperial power can make those decisions for other nations – presumably also supporting Russia's right to invade, destroy, and plunder Ukraine on their search for it.
It looks to me like you need to return to the 19th century along with the other pig-ignorant imperialists.
There is nothing quite as obnoxious as ignorant unthinking regressive progressive – apart from a imperialist like you.
'Tell me – do you also wish that Australia or the US makes the foreign policy and security decisions for us? I suspect that you'd be up in arms at the idea..'
As a very junior party in 5 eyes…I always thought they did.
'Those are not the decisions that the US can make. They are decisions for Ukraine.'
The U.S funded regime change in the Ukraine in 2014 and continue to do so…those are …facts.
How naive are you?
You appear to be illiterate and ignorant.
Perhaps you should take a look at the actual decisions of the 5 eyes. Or even just read the statements made about 5 eyes by New Zealand
No they aren't bloody facts. The claims about US involvement are mostly supposition, speculation and outright bullshit. Sure there were US diplomats and probably US intelligence people observing the protests against a unilateral decision of the Ukrainian president and prime minister.
There were also Russian ones and they had some much clearer involvement in forcing a political confrontation that resulted in months of large and persistent protests. In particular with quite overt propaganda campaigns
Most of the claims that I presume you are going to pull up will be probably be based on the allegations made the rapidly departing president and the Russia that he fled to. But there is a no credible information that I am aware of that indicates either an overt or covert effort by the US government to support the protests.
Basically you're probably just an parrot or a unread fool. I'll be generous and assume the latter.
U.S funds the Ukraine with billions and billions=fact.
As the U.S is not known for altruism…the Q is why?
House passes Ukraine aid in government funding bill (cnbc.com)
IF12040 (congress.gov)
I was tempted to describe you as either a dimwitted half wit…or a half witted dimwit…but couldn't decide.
Evidently you haven't been reading the news. On the 24th of February 2022 some nation that appears to be as thick as you are invaded Ukraine. Your article comes from the 3rd of March 2022.
The reason for the 'altruism' is to provide a defence of Ukraine, a nation attacked without provocation, without a declaration of war, attacked in violation of explicit guarantees from 1994 by the invading nation that they wouldn't attack Ukraine and would respect its borders, and who borders the nations that
Other nations who have sent similar material and financial support include Germany, Poland, all of the Baltic states, Sweden, France, Hungary, France, UK, Netherlands, Australia, Japan, South Korea, and many more. Like the US they are responding to the requests by Ukraine for material and humanitarian aid to help to repel an aggressive invader.
The UN itself would have probably have passed a motion condemning the aggressor nation, if Russia had not voted against it in the Security council. Russia being the aggressor nation.
You are describing yourself quite well. Somehow you responded to a refutation of events eight years ago in 2014 in the Maiden protests with a link that is from earlier this month. It has no particular relevance to either my comment, your previous comment, or even to the post.
To me, it either means that you're detached from reality, or your have some kind of temporal mind-shift screwing up your brain. Or you’re just dim-witted.
The link shows the U.S funding every year from 2014 till today.
The political landscape in Ukraine has changed often since independence…any guarantees and agreements by all parties seem to have been disregarded.
The point you do make ,is that myself and others have veered away from the actual…thread topic.-noted.
Sure and what happened in 2014 ? Russia unlawfully made acts of aggression against a bordering state – Ukraine.
Wasn’t that the year that Russia invaded with unmarked troops and then annexed Crimea. 2014 – wasn’t that the year that Russia encouraged and supported a violent succession movement with Russian ‘volunteer’ soldiers and equipment in the Donbas?
Couldn’t that be the reason that the US and other countries who support the UN charter, while unable to get UN action because of Russia using its veto to prevent chapter 7 provisions against such aggression, provide military assistance at the request of Ukraine. Russia and you are complaining about the reaction to events that Russia itself triggered.
Nope – Ukraine has closely abided by all the provisions of its agreements and guarantees as far as I can tell. So have all other parties to agreements and guarantees to Ukraine – except for Russia who appears to regard them as guidelines to be overstepped.
Russia complains about some ‘agreement’ about NATO, one that never written down or signed as an agreement anywhere. That ‘guarantee’ moreover, if explicitly made, was actually made to a state that no longer exists – the USSR. If Ukraine or Georgia or Lithuania or Baltic states, who were also part of the defunct state don’t appear to see that the growth of NATO is a problem, and all have joined or wanted to join NATO – why should Russia’s delusions on the subject overrule theirs?
Damn good idea, perhaps you’d stop trying to have the final word so I don’t have to keep pointing out your delusions.
So different from 1948 when a 'state' that existed 2000 years ago was suddenly bought into existence in an existing territory.
The US strong armed a few General Assembly members to get the vote passed with 2/3 as required which partitioned Palestine
( Thailands delegation was revoked after their first vote of No)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Nations_Partition_Plan_for_Palestine#The_vote
All territories on the planet are existing. Palestine was not existing as a nation state, it was a former territory of the Ottoman empire.
Palestine did exist as mandate of the league of Nations. Like Syria
It wasnt self governing but it did exist as a nation of its people like all the other ex Ottoman territories
viz Aotearoa existed as the nation of the Maori people even though its wasnt a nation state in the western sense. But I digress
https://www.britannica.com/place/Syria/The-French-mandate
Greece was once part of the Ottoman empire too, like the other other Balkan states
Israel didnt exist under the ottoman empire it was created by essentially US soft power in its 'sphere of influence' THE UN
Not only creating a state that only existed 2000 years ago , the partition plan could only find 1 district that had a jewish majority and that was Tel Aviv – and that only worked by excluding its contiguous port city of Jaffa which was Arab.
Creating a minority jewish state out of a majority arab territory – no problem when it serves US interests. NO can do do to carve a russian majority territory out of Ukraine.
Oh and the jewish terrorist gangs started the war of expulsion agaisnt the arab villages even before the British left
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Hametz
No siree no comparison with Putins war in Ukraine ( barrel bombs in Arab villages came later)
https://etzel.org.il/english/photo/chavit.htm
Funny how history repeats even when some say its doesnt
Ottoman sanjaks which comprised Palestine: Accre , Nablus and Jerusalem Basically from coast to Jordan river valley as the natural line
Palestinian self-governance of any form had not existed in that land for for 2000 years – Jewish, or otherwise.
The 1947 partition included only two parts – one of which had a Jewish majority.
Not at all . The palestine territory didnt have a jewish majority
[deleted mostly copy-pasta without a referencing link, but rather ironically, too many links that triggered Auto-Moderation]
Mod note for you.
I disagree on that .
You said 'too many links' but Im 'missing links' as well Surely a note to fix the missing ones in a a reply could have worked?
But Ive got the message .
You can disagree all you like, with a computer, which is essentially what Auto-Moderation is.
What was missing was the source link of your copy-pasta and it looked like something taken from Wikipedia.
Surely, you were in the wrong and wasting Moderator time.
I’m so glad that you’ve got the message though.
Imbedded links in wikipedia copy and pastes need to be removed.
Paste as plain text or Ctrl+Shift+V and embedded links will be converted to plain text.
The creation of a partitioned Palestine was a complete mess forced by the US – agreed.
However your assertion of an "existing territory" was more than a little (and probably deliberately) ambiguous.
Palestine was seized by the British in 1917 while in a state of war declared against them by the Ottoman empire in 1914. It was conceded by the Ottomans to the British in 1918 as part of the peace settlement.
In 1920 it was made a "mandate" of the British by the League of Nations. The Balfour declaration by the British caused a mass of Jewish migration to the mandate, aggravated by pre-WW2, and post-WW2 by the German (and other countries) persecutions.
Both Jewish and Arab populations were large and this caused a problem about how to withdraw the mandate by the UN post-war. Especially considering the ongoing conflicts between ethnic and religious communities inside the mandate territories in the 3 decades of occupation.
In 1945, the British announced that they would be not be interested in the UN Trusteeship. They proposed several plans to the UN between 1945 to 1947. The US rejected them and as they have a veto on the security council, the British eventually handed the problem to the UN.
UNSCOP, a UN committee proposed the plan that was eventually followed on 1947. As far as I am aware, that was the only vaguely viable plan that was available for the UN to vote on. Although I suspect that simply forcing Jordan to accept Palestine under UN supervision would have been preferable.
It was a shit plan voted on by the UN, and the US role was mostly shoehorning votes in the UN to adopt the plan in absence of anything else being available as an alternative. The British weren't staying. In 1948, there were no UN peace keepers. No-one else really wanted the place or had the credibility that they would even try to stop ethnic cleansing.
Which is what happened anyway as the Israeli republic did their best to drive out and block the Arab citizens from returning.
I can't see how that post-war fiasco has much to do with Russia invading Ukraine. Not unless you do what you did and smudge historical facts to try to makeup a story to fit your prejudices.
The US had changed their mind over partition,and wanted Palestine under UN trusteeship,it was NZ who torpedoed Trumans plan.
https://ir.canterbury.ac.nz/bitstream/handle/10092/12117/McKay_thesis.pdf
That is actually right. Thanks, I'd forgotten that bit of drama.
I vaguely remember that being part of the UK dislike of being potentially pushed back into Palestine as part of any trusteeship. They were well underway with their withdrawal at the time. The biggest problem with the US change of position was who was going to run the trusteeship.
https://ir.canterbury.ac.nz/bitstream/handle/10092/103474/Galvin_1982.pdf?sequence=1
It wasn't exactly a ringing endorsement. 56 voting or abstaining. There are now 193 Member States
The UK at that time had severe economic constraints,housing shortage,reconfiguring industry from war to civilian production,large debts to the US and US political constraints on how you can use US dollars without having to bow to oversight from US politicos.
It is hard to judge political decision historically without viewing the full bed of constraints.
I was amused by the begging trip to Maduro.Whatever happened to Juan Guaido ?
As to the sanctions turning Russians against the Kremlin, that has never happened , it just reinforces in Russian minds the hostility the west has for Russia.
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/mar/19/vladimir-putin-waves-the-flag-in-a-polarised-country-where-views-are-hard-to-shift
And of course Russia is not about to default when it can repay its foreign debts with oil and gas prices through the roof
https://adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-93-russias-720m-per-day?s=r
Russia is not about to default when it can repay its foreign debts with oil and gas prices through the roof
It's funny how easy it is to repay your foreign debts when you can unilaterally opt to to repay them in worthless rubles. The effect is not dissimilar to outright seizure of assets, something which has been known to attract military responses. Russia issues list of ‘unfriendly’ countries amid Ukraine crisis | Russia-Ukraine war News | Al Jazeera
As to the sanctions turning Russians against the Kremlin, that has never happened
The combination of propaganda and state repression are hard to overcome – but Putin no longer has the mirage of communism with which to distract his victims. Moreover, it's a more joined up world, and the people are not quite as illiterate:
In 1917, within the remaining Tsarist territories, an estimated 37.9% of the male population above seven years old was literate and only 12.5% of the female population was literate.
In 2018, adult literacy rate for Russian Federation was 99.7 %. Adult literacy rate of Russian Federation increased from 98 % in 1989 to 99.7 % in 2018 growing at an average annual rate of 0.59%.
That doesn't necessarily make them smart enough to reject Putin (it hasn't for you after all roflmao), but as a percentage, their credulity will be sensibly reduced.
What a strange comment. Of course Russia will pay in rubles, that is all they can do with ill considered sanctions imposed by hypocritical states under the control of an immoral regime – one that will greatly profit while the poodles have to suck up the consequences.
By the way Stuart, have you not realised that the majority of the world's population has not signed up the Western Accord or whatever you want to describe it as.
Yes the West is allowing SWIFT to be used to pay for any Russian oil and gas they still use.
https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2022/3/17/russia-says-it-transferred-bond-payment-to-avoid-default
Lucy Komisar was on to the Bill Browder fraud in detail years ago .For us to be swallowing the Magnitsky story, (via O'Connor) is shameful.
There is so much out there showing him to be a total fraud, but of course he's singing the anti Russia /Putin song that we apparently like to hear.
Look up Komisar's stuff, she used to write on Common Dreams.She's an investigative journalist specialising in financial fraud.
https://usrussiaaccord.org/lucy-komisar-danish-press-board-says-report-on-browder-is-true/
A list of her articles, covering all manner of financial fraud, including the Bill Browder, Magnitsky reports
https://muckrack.com/lucy-komisar/articles
Yes Francesca. Putin demanded that all those that had made out like bandits in the Yeltsin years, recieving state owned assets at a level that makes NZs Roger Douglas years look amateurish, at least start paying taxes on their ill gotten wealth. It made him a lot of enemies and was the beginning of the attempt to reclaim Russian resources for the Russian people.
For the Putin cheerleaders here:
An interview with a Russian Putin critic who has survived two poisonings from the Putin regime.
For some balance you should list all the assassinations of enemies of America…where people died.
Apparently there were about 50 assassination attempts made on Castro alone over the years.
Umm no you are way short
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assassination_attempts_on_Fidel_Castro
it's well into the hundreds
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/638_Ways_to_Kill_Castro
This phrase says it all ' It is one of the most autarkic countries in the world, a major oil and gas producer, the main source of grain exports, has extensive rare earth materials, and is a major exporter of fertilisers.'
This is the prize the US wants, this is their hegmonic dream, Regime change of a US flavour, but as with all US fantasies, it wont happen. More likely if there was to be a change, it would be the second most popular Party that could prevail and far from being a dream change for the US that 2nd most popular Party is the Communist Party far far removed from Putin capitalist party of greed which is closer in nature to the US. Hope this scenario comes to fruition, welcome back Karl.
It is always difficult to determine, let alone prove motives.
But America has learned harsh lessons about crude resource grabs, and compounding Iraq with a much larger geographic occupation of Russia is implausible at this time.
It would quite like to be rid of Putin however. Happily for the US, Putin is expending his military stockpiles far faster than he will be able to replace them. In a crude balance of power sense, the longer Russian forces bleed in Ukraine, the better it suits US interests. Putin without a capable military is not harmless, but much less of a nuisance.
Oh right. That lesson must be that when you attempt to launch chaos and misery on some poor but resource rich country (Yemen) keep it out of the news, sell as much weaponry as you can to the agressor (Saudi Arabia) and fill in all the gaps that are less visible (targeting, naval blockade support and fighter refuelling)
Not only that, there are signs that sanctions on Russia will expedite moves to replace the US dollar as the preferred payment for oil and gas. China, Iran, and India are moving to pay for these materials in their own currencies.
Typical anti-American wet-dream. The exact opposite has actually happened. Flight capital has been flooding into the US Dollar as one of the few safe currencies in the world.
The Euro is a regional currency.
The Ruble is worthless as no-one will reliably exchange it for anything.
Every time the Yuan is opened up to free exchange the capital flight is unsustainable for more than a few weeks
No-one will ever let the Poms be in charge of anything ever again
One thing that is noticeably missing from the debate is how to we may be able to stop the war and return to peace. Western media, including our own, has gone full-blown frantic into disaster porn,
Again completely divorced from reality. Putin started it, he has threatened to go nuclear against NATO if they do anything directly concrete to stop it. Smith is using the word diplomacy when he really means that Ukraine should surrender and let the Russians roll over the rest of Europe as he clearly would like them to do. Bombing cities into rubble as they go.
There is only one path through this now – Ukraine is turned into a killing field where both sides grind themselves to a standstill and the Russian military have nothing conventional left and not much of Urkaine left standing. What we have to fear is not Russian strength, it is their weakness. At the point where they are at a stalemate on the ground, their choice will be between humiliating defeat and the removal of Putin, or they resort to nuking the rest of the world for the sheer nihilism of it.
That is what we are up against – and Mike Smith is obviously backing Putin; his posts condemn everything Western and remain silent on Russia. He even manages to describe media coverage of Russian destruction as 'war porn', implying that like the Russian media the rest of the world should be gagged so as to ignore what is happening.
His motives are clearly rooted in his long-standing and clearly articulated hatred of anything American that leads him into a full-throated support for both Xi Xinping and Putin – both of whom indisputably lead vile, authoritarian, anti-democratic regimes. There is no moral difference between Smith and the useful idiots in the 20' and 30's who thought Stalin was wonderful.
Dunno what youre on about red ?" Russians rolling into the rest of europe bombing cities into rubble as they go " What rubbish theres zero evidence of that ,and anyway how could they ?,if you listened to your own properganda press theyre meant to be losing the war theyre poorly trained running out of food cant fly their planes etc etc etc you cant have it both ways red lol .
actually it looks to me like a peace deal is about to be struck with zelensky publicly making concessions .I get the impression that some people are almost disappointed and they actually wanted ukraine to fight to the very bitter end with everyone dead and everything destroyed !!
Pure diatribe from you as usual RL.
If the UN had bothered to debate Russian concerns about the threat to it's security from the NATO expansion and billions of dollars worth of weaponary to an illegal Ukrainian regime post the 2014 coup, there would not have been a conflict of war.
Under their own NATO rules, this Ukraine would need to clean up it's politics and corruption before it could join Nato. So they have used an innocent Country to needle the Bear knowing full well they would not help Ukraine except to feed them with WMD on Russias border. That is arrogance of the first order and every country aligned to the UN is complicit in this disaster. What major power would accept such weaponry on its border, come on get real.
It is Ukraine being raped right now – and you are blaming them.
You are a total fucking moron.
I think you will find that you are the fuckin moron. If your one eye was able to read the comment, you would see I was blaming NATO and the non action of the UN over Russian security concerns, not as your one eye suggested, blaming UKRAINE. Duh
[Take the rest of the day off to chill down – Incognito]
Mod note for you.
To clarify, RedLogix got one warning, also because his past here as Moderator and Author. You have a much more checkered history and happened to be the next one stepping over the line. It’s only for one day, so stop your moaning.
' Ukraine should surrender and let the Russians roll over the rest of Europe as he clearly would like them to do'
Utter stupidity….not even entertained by Russia .
This is a totally unnecessary conflict .
The Ukraine has stated they feel betrayed and left on their…own.
Putin was led into a trap by western intransigence. Zelensky will take the regret to the grave that he did not do a deal with a Putin (Macron was the only one looking out for Ukraine within NATO) – an armed neutrality for Ukraine, compensation for cession of Crimea, and EU/UN oversight over plebiscites determining the eastern border was possible.
Now Putin will seek to siege cities until Ukraine accepts de-militarisation (vassal status), and loss of nova Russia. And leave Zelensky in place to make the deal so as to gain international acceptance.
One little problem – in UN determined in 1949 that changes in borders realised by war would not be seen as legitimate internationally.
Russia would require plebiscites for border change credibility. If the public mood in Kherson is any indication … and the bombing of Mariupol to ethnically cleanse the area …
So Putin is left with all Ukraine or withdraw from Novarussia in return for demilitarisation.
Putin was led into a trap by western intransigence
Why the fuck should anyone let Putin turn Eastern Europe into his backyard?
Everyone saw what he did in Chechnya, Georgia and Syria. And every country bordering with Russia knows that they could easily be next. This is pure ‘blame the victim’ apologetics.
This war is Russia's last gasp, geographic and demographic concerns alone mean that either Putin succeeds in expanding the Russian borders back to that of the old Soviet Union, or they will cease to be a functional nation within decades.
Their only path out of this fate is to join with the EU, but Putin's racist, homophobic vision of a morally superior Rus people defending themselves from the decadence of the West will preclude them from this as long as he lives. Which hopefully will not be long.
Accepting the loss of territory occupied by Russia since 2014-2015 is not letting Putin do anything that has not already been done.
The fault is with those turning Russia and Ukraine into victims to restore unity of NATO at the expense of those outside of it.
The Russians will only feel equal to those in the West and thus part of their Europe, once the Americans depart.
There were two scenarios for this.
The easy way.
1. Putin did not invade Ukraine, via talks with Macron, the new German leadership, Poland and Zelensky – a neutral and armed (Russian air defence system) Ukraine ceding Crimea and allowing EU/UN managed plebescites to determine borders. Ukraine joining the EU and a Russia-EU FTA (building on Nordstrom).
Germany keeping defence spending at 1% and other EU members reducing spending down to this level, and forming a EU – Russia defence pact. The EU nations separating from the real NATO – Norway/UK/Canada/USA, and NATO forces leaving the European continent with the EU taking over all NATO bases.
2. the hard way, coz it is inevitable.
PS Russian occupation of their "Vladimir of Kiev homeland" is a poisoned chalice. The madness of King Putin has turned it to a Han Chinese occupation of Tibet or the NW, it is a warning to Beijing about the importance of getting the how of incorporating Taiwan right.
The fault is with those turning Russia and Ukraine into victims to restore unity of NATO at the expense of those outside of it.
The fault is with the evil madman who has ordered his tanks and missiles to murder a country. Your pathetic, groveling disgusts me.
it is a warning to Beijing about the importance of getting the how of incorporating Taiwan right.
Getting the apologetics in early for that one as well. Is there no totalitarian shit-head you won't rent yourself out to?
Those who are not capable of rational discourse, resort to their primal capacity to hate and how to insult. They are unfit to set a moral course, thus their ways lead to war and not peace.
Not me giving cover for Russian tanks and missiles murdering a country. I am of course perfectly capable of rational discourse and I have been doing it here for a lot longer than you. So you are dead wrong on that.
But I am going to call out all the Putin cheerleaders here as devoid of all human morals. There comes a point when disgust and anger is indeed the correct response.
Not one word of your response to my posts was rational.
It seems you are trapped in some sort of either goodies or baddies mode for the duration.
It's sort of sad how Putin, and the leader of their Night Wolves, wrap themselves up in the same sort of white race moral Christian cause as the goodies in the West. But in each case, the lives of others are so easily sacrificed.
That may be so, but please take your foot off the insult accelerator.
Kosovo?
Hmmm. Kosovo …
One of the best French takes on the current situation is that of Dominique de Villepin here:
https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1505396482274304000.html
Secession into an independent state is not acquisition by an existing nation state (for example the Albanians did not annex Kosovo).
And nations can allow secession by plebisicite – for example Scotland referendums or deny them (Catalonia).
Russia backed the independence of Abkhazia from Georgia and recognises its independence and South Ossetia from Georgia also – few other nations have recognised either. However, what it has not done is allow a merger of North Ossetia (within Russia) and South Ossetia.
If Zelenskyy was brave he would have stood up to the Nazis and the United States, instead of being a puppet that put his citizens in danger by not living up to the agreements with Russia that Ukraine has been breaking for 8 years.
Leading your nation to war against an overwhelming foe, and refusing to surrender in the face of likely death from Russian bombs, is not enough bravery for you?
You have a slave mentality that would put Ukraine back in chains under the Russian yoke.
The implications of New Zealand stepping outside the UN umbrella with the special Russia sanctions legislation is most concerning. “Rules based” international consensus and negotiation has long been this country's approach to armed conflicts.
The Labour Caucus has taken the Anglophile 5 Eyes bait and we are now undeniably linked to US Imperialism again. Bad move. Because a reasonably independent foreign policy and bilateral trade and cultural ties with individual smaller countries was the way forward for Aotearoa NZ in the era of climate disaster, COVID collapsed supply chains and imperialist driven aggression.
@Tiger Mountain +1
It is a big step, Good to see us acting when the UN Security Council can't.
Let's see exactly how big a step it really is the next time the US does something really stupid.
Do we really need to wait before we know?
Come on, I think we already know we are small and gutless.The US is already committing genocide on the Afghans by divvying up Afghanistan's money amongst well off US citizens, family of 9/11
I'm waiting to hear the squeaks from Mahuta, who supposedly stands up for the rights of indigenous peoples.Palestinians ditto
The question posed on this thread is "Who pays the price of sanctions".
Well, for one, I am willing to pay the price. Whether that be in higher fuel prices or inflation, or helping poorer nations affected by Putin's madness.
The hypocrisy of those who appear to be supportive of what Putin and Russia is doing astounds me.
For one, they are happy to enjoy all the west has to offer while at the same time pouring scorn on it.
Secondly, they are happy to use the freedoms of expression the west offers to spew their bile. But I have no doubt they would be the first to complain if their rights to express those views were removed, in the same way freedom of expression is repressed in Russia.
So far as I am concerned, people who think and feel that way should at least be consistent with their beliefs and emigrate to Russia and see how they enjoy living there.
The old “Nu Zilund–love it or leave it” shtick eh smithfield…
At the end of the day as a former NZ PM used to say, Russians will have sort out their own country with mass participation and some international solidarity. A mate of mine based in Geneva works for the IUF a union Federation that assists organising millions of workers including in Russia.
Interestingly in the USA mass participation is also needed right now to avert official authoritarianism likely in the event of a Republican win in the 2022 mid term and 2024 elections. Further voter suppression laws are being installed at state level where there are Republican Governors.
So it's now hypocrisy to exercise one's right of free speech?
Criticism of hubristic foreign policy and recognition of Russia's security concerns now means whole hearted approval of all things Russia/Putin.? I think it is you who is suggesting a soviet style group think as the only way to go .Dissenters should be excised and exiled?
"You're with us or against us "
"Criticism of hubristic foreign policy and recognition of Russia's security concerns now means whole hearted approval of all things Russia/Putin.?"
I have no problems at all with discussing international issues as they affect various countries.
But the target of my comment was those whose arguments are used to justify or minimise what is happening in Ukraine by Russia against innocent civilians at the moment. Those who view what is going on in Maruipol at the moment as collateral damage rather than deliberate targeting of civilians and war crimes.
https://youtu.be/AbTwyb1gcPo
Those who criticise my comment, please watch the video above and let me know your position on that. Then I will know where you stand.
Here is an overview of the whole situation by the U.K Daily Mail journalist Martin Jay.He makes some very salient points.
Well worth reading.
'The theme of meddling in the domestic politics of countries that are politically finding their own feet after the fall of communism, by backing so-called “revolutions” but then failing to support their friends when the blood starts to flow is really what Biden is all about. '
Ukraine War Will Bring NATO to New All-Time Low When Biden Arrives at Brussels Meeting — Strategic Culture (strategic-culture.org)
I already know where you stand.
Yesterday you made the comment:
"Your video does not convince me that civilians were deliberately targeted."
By deduction then, you would just view this situation as "collateral damage".
But then again, cool. That article you linked to is asserting that the west should be doing more not less so far as supporting Ukraine is concerned.
"The danger of being weak, which is clear to see with the Ukraine situation where NATO hasn’t the courage to threaten Putin with a nuclear or even conventional war, is that people remember it for a very long time and in terms of PR and its own identity, the failure to support Ukraine will reverberate for decades to come"
So, the article is arguing that the west should be stronger not weaker with respect to Russia.
I am glad you are starting to see sense.
You need to broaden your outlook.
What were the catalysts that resulted in this tragic conflict?
If you are objective ,you can easily find the…answer.
"collateral damage"interesting you use an American term for their killing of civilians.
"…Russia has so far not imposed any counter-sanctions. That will depend on events, but if imposed will be proportional and significant…"
Russia is a literal petro-state that can't keep it's fifty year old tanks fueled up 70km from it's own border and has to resort to 1940s style indiscriminate bombardment to match it's 1940s style aggression. It has an economy roughly the size of Italy except Russia actually is run by the mafia and relies exclusively on energy and nuclear blackmail to maintain the pretense it is a superpower. In fact, Russia is a fascist gangster state that is so enfeebled by larceny and corruption as to barely be a regional power and has an army that is making an absolute meal of trying to overcome the fierce resistance of one of the poorest countries in Europe, and that country is situated right next door to Russia.
The world got on fine without the much trade with the USSR and it will again – in fact this war is probably the kick up the pants a complacent Europe needed to get serious about removing it's energy dependence on Russia. China might fill the gap, but the relationship will not be one of equals and Putin will quickly discover that being a Chinese vassal isn't as much fun as playing the bully boy on the forecourt of Europe's gas station has been.
It must be the most highly armed country in Europe as well as one of the poorest.
It’s been receiving arms since 2014, plus its been propped up with IMF loans, had already received 5 billion US $ before the coup in 2014, and is even now being sent further billions courtesy of the US taxpayer.
If the country wasn’t so riddled with thieving oligarchs like Ihor Kolomoisky, (sponsor of Zelensky)they’d be a damned sight better off
https://www.post-gazette.com/news/crime-courts/2022/02/20/Ihor-Kolomoisky-US-banks-warren-ohio-steel-plant-ukraine/stories/202202200063
https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/mikesallah/ukraine-billionaire-oligarch-money-laundering-investigation
Maybe Russia and Ukraine and the US share common values
It’s a war of oligarchs?
"It's a war of oligarchs?"
Isn't it always. We can say it's oil or minerals or arable land… but it's the rich people who think it's their right to control said oil, minerals and arable land who battle each other over such things and drag the rest of us into it. Religion, race, politics… find some way to define the differences between two mobs and set them at each other. Supply the weapons, food, healthcare, etc and cash in.
Everyone's a winner if you stand back far enough.
So what. Right now tens of thousands of Ukrainian people don't give a shit about your demands for historic political perfection – they just want Putin out of their land.
And their sacrifice is giving birth to a new nation right before our eyes. Yet you would have it strangled.
I don't think that they have a lot of choice about the indiscriminate bombardment. Apart from going through much of their stockpile of precision bombs in the first week of the war. The military analysis indicates that Russia hasn't managed to take control of air, and have mostly been doing the bombing of positions in cities at night. It is pretty pointless using their remaining precision weapons at night, so they're often way off target with dumb weapons.
By all accounts, they haven't managed to do much better with artillery. Due to the lack of observers from drones or air, the viscous counter battery fire from the Ukrainians, and a presumed inability to get relevant information from satellites to the arty – they appear to have been pretty indiscriminate on that as well.
It has been notable to me that most of the recent precision strikes recently have been using cruise missiles fired from Russian soil against previously known and mapped sites like barracks and underground military warehouses.
Basically, the Iranians and Yemenis with their drone strikes and relatively primitive missiles against the UAE and Saudis could give the Russian forces some useful pointers and lessons in precision strikes.
Just about any other armed forces in the world could give them lessons in logistics.
While we're on Ukraine , what are your comments on this?
All in the past?
No interest?
https://www.hrw.org/news/2014/07/24/ukraine-unguided-rockets-killing-civilians
How about a week ago?
https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2022/3/14/ukraine-missile-debris-kill-16-in-donetsk-separatists
My simple response to that is: "two wrongs don't make a right".
But really, you are pointing to a huge false equivalence in the links you have given.
If those actions in the past by Ukraine appall you, then what do you think of the video I posted?
Appalling.War is appalling .
But the US and the EU chose to turn a blind eye to what Ukraine was doing for 8 years, Ukraine chose not to implement the Minsk accords, relying on EU/US complicity and encouragement and sending of arms so that Poroshenko and Zelensky could believe in a military solution
Where is their military solution now?
History does not start today
You choose to turn a blind eye to one of the wrongs in favour of the other .There is your hypocrisy
As in many situations there is no clear beginning and ending to conflicts, and in some cases, chains of injustice go back centuries or longer.
Look at the history of Afghanistan for example.
But, can you agree with me that surrounding a city with artillery and shelling it constantly knowing many civilians still live there, frequently preventing civilians to evacuate, shelling hospitals, shelling civilians waiting for bread, bombing civilians sheltering in a facility clearly labelled "children", refusing to allow humanitarian supplies to come in, is totally wrong and immoral, whatever the historical context is?
Yet you have stated Russia has already lost!
Where is your hard evidence backing your assertions of pre meditated crimes against… civilians?
FFS. If the evidence that is already out there isn't enough to convince you, then nothing will. I think you should definitely emigrate to Russia as you seem to be Putin's cheerleader.
Let me spell it out to you.
If a military intentionally surrounds a city with artillary knowing that many civilians are there, and intentionally shells that city to the point of destruction, then it is intentionally targeting civilians. Because a known consequence of that action will be many civilian deaths.
If that same military blocks humanitarian aid getting in, and prevents civilians from leaving, or shells civilians who are fleeing, then I don't know how a rational person could view it as anything other than targeting civilians.
And Russia has already lost. It has lost in so many ways. Even if it meets all its military objectives it is lost in the longterm as has been explained to you numerous times.
Scott Ritter – twitter
The replies…
https://twitter.com/UrbanAchievr/status/1505629139952443392
You often play the man, not the ball. Same with Douglas Macgregor a few days ago.
Irrespective of elements of their background, they have training, experience and credentials to base their comments on.
Lending credence to the utterings of a twice-busted wannabe kiddie fucker says an awful lot about those who do, sport.
no kiddy fucking took place .It was a sting operation, that doesn't detract from his knowledge of military intelligence and strategies one little bit.
Paul Gauguin? Michel Jackson? says a lot more that most people can separate the personal issues from the art and music.
Actually aj, here's an interesting take from Christopher Black, Canadian criminal lawyer who has been involved in war crime tribunals…on the legality of the invasion
https://christopher-black.com/the-legality-of-war/
Brilliant ,and' good to know ' thanks fancesca
The entire case rests on one key sentence:
First, the Kiev regime was mounting a major offensive with NATO’s help against the Donbass Republics with the intent of destroying them.
That is the lie. The rest unravels into nonsense.
Thanks Red, couldn't find the lie in your link , but great link!
https://greekreporter.com/2022/02/22/history-donbas-donetsk-luhansk/
Seems like the Donbas has wished for its close ties with Russia to be recognised since at least 1994.
The OSCE reported a buildup of Ukrainian troops at the LOC prior to the invasion, weapons were being pumped in, encouraging the Ukr. army a military solution was possible
Let me see – Australia decides to send lots and lots of people to say Northland. And once those people become a majority they declare themselves a Republic and then elect a government that has a policy of becoming another state of Australia.
Then when the NZ govt decides to take Northland back, the Australians invade the whole country and bomb old peoples homes to rubble as a means of persuading us.
I guess you would be good with this. No?
Texas. But yeah R
Russia had mobilised an army to move into Ukraine, and any activity by Ukraine is intent to attack the areas seeking autonomy … ?
I note that when Russia advanced deeper into Mariupol, it is then that the humanitarian corridors became viable.
Note Patrick Lancaster moving towards the centre of Maruipol through Russian cleared territory, and the direction of travel of the refugee cars
And also the plight of the civilians on foot , who think all the warring parties are dicks
Plus the drunken civilian idiot in possession of a machine gun firing at random.Great idea to let out the prisoners, hand anyone a gun .God knows where these guns will end up via the black market
Yeah, the Russian army has been SO nice to the people of Mariupol.
https://www.emergency-live.com/news/ukraine-under-attack-msf-the-humanitarian-situation-in-mariupol-is-catastrophic/
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/mar/08/ukraine-war-civilians-sumy-irpin-refugees-russia
One side is heroically engaged in a existential battle for the very survival of their country. The other is engaged in a brutal and unnecessary war of aggression. That's it. There is nothing else to consider.
And I'll admit it – the Ukrainians have my admiration, they are to a man a shit ton braver than I'll ever be and their will to fight and utter determination to resist the invader is worthy of the highest accolades. If they win this war, they'll have paid for their independence in their own blood. Would we be as so determined to resist an invader? I doubt it. Reading this site tells me a lot of people have no idea how important being independent and governed by laws of your own making is.
Who started the war? Who was to blame for area bombing, Churchill or Hitler? Remember, we declared war on the Germans so were we the aggressors?
I don’t get all this bending over backwards from elements of the left to accommodate a fascist dictatorship waging a war of aggression using facile whataboutism and wailing finger pointing at the horrors of war to create a false equivalence.
We can talk about the state of the Ukraine once they have won the right with their own blood to decide that for themselves.
Exactly. I think there is a form of cognitive dissonance going on here with some of those who try to deny, minimise, or refuse to condemn, what is happening in Ukraine at the moment.
I don't think they can reconcile their favourable view of Russia and Putin with the horrors happening to civilians in Ukraine at the moment. So, the way to deal with the inconsistency is to find some way to justify, or at least minimise what Russia is doing in Ukraine.
I think if it was the US behaving in exactly the same way to some other country their response would be quite different.
'I think if it was the US behaving in exactly the same way to some other country their response would be quite different'
As would yours…guaranteed.
If the US was doing what I described above:
"surrounding a city with artillery and shelling it constantly knowing many civilians still live there, frequently preventing civilians to evacuate, shelling hospitals, shelling civilians waiting for bread, bombing civilians sheltering in a facility clearly labelled "children", refusing to allow humanitarian supplies to come in"
Then, yes, I would be responding in exactly the same way. Because such behaviour is totally inhumane, and those who in anyway support such behaviour are tainted by implication IMO.
You must be horrified at what is happening in Yemen right now then!
Did you see the school bus blown to pieces by a U.S bomb?
US supplied bomb that killed 40 children on Yemen school bus | Yemen | The Guardian
More whataboutism.
Complete false equavalence. Did the US directly drop the bomb? No.
However, I think if countries supply munitions to other countries and those countries misuse the munitions in human rights abuses, then the country that supplied in the first place should certainly not supply more, and should condemn the action.
If the US hasn't taken that step, then they should.
So aside from the U.S supplying the bomb and supporting the Saudi regime….you are o.k with the actual conflict?
I love the disdain for whataboutism, since it was a default rejoinder when the Natz were in power='Labour did it…too'…!
It is a convenient device in a wider context now…as used by you re the U.S.
You really do live in a black and white universe…that is your personal…tragedy.
The Yemen conflict is a nasty proxy war between Saudi and Iran – two countries that hate each other without limits.
Both sides are using weapons supplied from all over the planet – and if the US didn't supply them someone else would.
It would of course be hypothetically good if someone invaded Saudi Arabia and removed the pack of psychopathic princelings who run the place. Or the thugs who run Iran, preferably both. But then all the tyrant loving rent-boys here would predictably fall into line, run apologist lines for them and blame the US.
Capt America…'logix'
' and if the US didn't supply them someone else would.'
There are plenty of countries that make armaments – do you imagine that if the the west embargoed selling to Saudi that the Russians or Chinese would not rush to fill the orders?
Feeble justification.
Apply that logic to anything you like.
@incognito…is today ad hominem day?
RL replied to me-'do you imagine that if the the west embargoed selling to Saudi that the Russians or Chinese would not rush to fill the orders?
He also then stated that-' Chinese firms accounted for 13 per cent of total Top 100 arms sales in 2020'
So the basis for his premise is clearly flawed ,and nothing more than a reflection of his own prejudice.
When in doubt use the Duck Test combined with Occam’s Razor.
Your logic seems flawed to but feel free to have another attempt at faulting RL’s premise. I think it’ll be an exercise in futility (actually, a mission impossible), but who am I to stop you from trying. Just stop the willy-waving contest.
"The Yemen conflict is a nasty proxy war between Saudi and Iran – two countries that hate each other without limits"…..you are a smart guy RL, you must understand that the conflict in Ukraine is a also proxy war between US-NATO/Russian right?
"It would of course be hypothetically good if someone invaded Saudi Arabia"….name one country that has US protection, that has been invaded in the past twenty years?..apart from the Ukraine?.
” do you imagine that if the the west embargoed selling to Saudi that the Russians or Chinese would not rush to fill the orders?”…..you or I don’t know that, from what I can make out, the Chinese position is generally they prefer countries to be at peace so they can trade with them and in the surrounding area’s more smoothly.
Oh well never mind:
Vey selective ..'whataboutry' there Red…
'Chinese firms accounted for 13 per cent of total Top 100 arms sales in 2020,'
Misleading bold header.
@Blazer
Finally I understand what your problem is. You are a fuckwit.
The words in the article are plain enough – Chinese companies comprise the second largest group of armament sales globally.
Which blows the other fuckwit’s claim literally out of the water.
Well this fuckwit can read your link and the main takeaway is this…
'US companies amounted to $285 billion—an increase of 1.9 per cent compared with 2019—and accounted for 54 per cent of the Top 100’s total arms sales. Since 2018, the top five companies in the ranking have all been based in the USA.
God knows what point you are trying to…make.
I have to agree that your comments read as if they’re made by a simpleton fuckwit. The point made was clear enough and in direct, appropriate, and relevant response to Adrian Thornton @ 8:19 am (https://thestandard.org.nz/who-pays-the-price-of-sanctions/#comment-1877347).
Maybe it’s time to call a peaceful end to this willy-waving contest.
"According to the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute's latest report on the global arms sales in 2020, U.S. companies continue to dominate the ranking. Together, the arms sales of the 41 U.S. companies amounted to 285 billion U.S. dollars, an increase of 1.9 percent compared with 2019. And since 2018, the top five companies in the ranking have all been based in the United States"
http://www.news.cn/english/2021-12/06/c_1310355141.htm
US strides ahead of competition in global arms sales results
https://www.shephardmedia.com/news/defence-notes/global-arms-sales-sees-us-stride-ahead-of-competit/
Combine the 39% of world wide arms sale coming out of the USA with those of it's allies in Europe the UK and elsewhere..and a clear image starts to emerge….over 60% of the worlds arms trade originates from the so called defenders of Democracy…isn't that strange?..it is almost as if they more interested in destabilizing certain parts of the world….unless of course you believe democracy is best delivered at the gun of a gun?
"The 26 European arms companies in the Top 100 jointly accounted for 21 percent of total arms sales, or $109bn"
"The seven UK companies recorded arms sales of $37.5bn in 2020, up by 6.2 percent compared with 2019"
Another one who’s so close yet so far. Did you all fail reading comprehension at school or is it just selective blindness with obnoxiousness? Why are you bleating on about Europe and the UK? Why are you quoting those irrelevant stats? The point/premise was that China (and Russia) would be rushing in to fill arms orders “if the the west embargoed selling” [sic]. Unless the West ≠ US, UK and Europe. In fact, China is already the second largest arms trader in the world, as RL pointed out.
Exactly. And that is the polite version.
The U.S military/industrial complex meddles in the affairs of other nations….because they…can.
The U.S is responsible for more death and destruction in the world in the last 50 years than all other actors…combined.
In what way does what the US has or hasn't done in the past in anyway justify what Russia is doing to innocent civilians right now?
It doesn't.
But you have yet to prove that Russia is deliberately targeting civilians.
We can prove the U.S has deliberately targeted civilians on a number of…ocassions.
But you have yet to prove that Russia is deliberately targeting civilians.
Producing that proof is an impossible demand – for the simple reason that no-one has reliable access to what the Russian military's intentions are.
But we can sure as hell make some pretty good deductions based on all the images of destroyed civilian apartment blocks and similar such devastation now flooding the internet.
“But you have yet to prove that Russia is deliberately targeting civilians.”
Oh right.. so what would be an acceptable standard of "proof'" to you?
Or is this just a little game you are playing where nothing would be acceptable as "proof'" no matter how good it was?
But here is a list of a few of the ”alleged” war crimes:
https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/russias-most-barbaric-war-crimes-26490300
The U.S is responsible for more death and destruction in the world in the last 50 years than all other actors…combined.
And paradoxically also responsible for more peace and human development than at any time ever in our human history.
There are no perfect human polities, they all make mistakes and become entangled in disasters. But the redeeming features of the Western model are:
These mechanisms, again all imperfect, nonetheless mean that we self-correct. And that people like you are free to speak out, which means that mistakes instead of compounding eventually die away. By contrast the strong man autocrats you love so much, invariably become isolated and lacking anyone to correct them – fall into madness.
Try seeing how long you would last in Red Square protesting against this war.
You version of Ripley's …'believe it or…not'….with disclaimers…of course.
I watched a video this morning of Ukrainian troops in Mariupol fighting at point blank range a street battle with Russian armour, using a heavy calibre automatic weapon on an armoured vehicle to destroy an infantry fighting vehicle and a tank at less than 25m range.
It was an uncomfortably voyeuristic experience. Ferocious combat, close range, intense and terrifyingly violent and it showed an inevitable truth of modern war – when two equally heavily equipped and determined adversaries decide to fight extreme violence will happen. War has a remorseless logic of its own and savagery enters the souls of the good and the bad alike. That is why we must always condemn in the strongest terms those who start wars as war criminals, and Putin is without doubt a war criminal for starting this needless war. The blame is entirely his, and his alone, and all his generals are accomplices in his crime.
It if it wasn't so chilling it would be ironic. Putin claims he wants to "denazify" Ukraine. But he is behaving like the biggest Nazi of them all.
Yes the historic parallels are obvious and downright chilling.
Here is some balance for you Red…a renown U.K journo who actually lived in Russia.
'
We have been utter fools.
We have treated Russia with amazing stupidity. Now we pay the price for that. We had the chance to make her an ally, friend and partner.
Instead we turned her into an enemy by insulting a great and proud country with greed, unearned superiority, cynicism, contempt and mistrust.
I have to endure, often several times a day, listening to people who are normally perfectly sensible and reasonable, raging wildly against Russia and Russians.
Once, I was just like them. I had the normal anti-Russian prejudice of so many Western people. '
PETER HITCHENS: Why I blame the arrogant, foolish West for the Ukraine crisis | Daily Mail Online
Show me where I have said anything anti-Russian. It is Putin and his cronies who are the filth, not the Russian people who I have a genuine respect for. Quite the contrary as a consequence of living and working in the country for a period during 2001 I came away wanting only the best for them.
Tragically it is not only the Ukrainian people who are going to suffer catastrophically as a result of this madness.
That was from the rally he made? The most chilling bit for me was..
Now that has to be chilling after Putin pulling the whole Russian ethnic superiority shtick, making threats against all of the "opponents, who are branded traitors and “fifth columnists” by authorities.". Apparently ordering students and state employees to attend.
He even went to far as doing what I'd describe as raising a pogrom or a crusade.
It would appear that even being being a member the Ukrainian Eastern Orthodox christian in Ukraine means that christian soldiers from Russia should try to kill you. Anyone who supports that, (including Mike) should really satrt to have a clsoe look at who they are supporting.
What I saw of it just reminded me of the film shot with all of the pageantry, christian and racial fervour that was displayed at the Nuremberg rallies in Germany in 1936 and 1937.
State control of a country's major corporations through autocratic command is pretty much a definition of National Socialism.
So the label fits Putin pretty well.
Na John Raulston Saul defined it well in the unconscious civilization
And defines well the courtiers who never quite get to seat at high table.
JR Saul might want to better investigate Russia and the Putin-Ologarchy State.
and their Arabian friendships.
https://twitter.com/JavierBlas/status/1504955027672158209?cxt=HHwWgsCytfin1uIpAAAA
IMHO, we shouldn't rely on phenomenological observations of the nature of the Russian gangster klepto-state to decide whether or not Putin is a Fascist.
If we examine the situational development of the Russian state rather than trying to work out if Putin meets a set criteria of style over substance (is that "Z" a fascist symbol? is Putin a sufficiently charismatic strongman to qualify? Does his economic model meet the criteria?) and instead see fascism as a process then we can instead replace procedure with some questions. Does Putinism claim there is a crisis that cannot be solved by traditional methods? Does his Russia demand the individual be subordinated to the group? Does he believe Russia is a victim, legitimising extra-legal action against his enemies? Is exclusionary violence part of an effort to reverse decline?
By these criteria then the undeniability of the Fascism of Putin's Russia comes into sharp focus.
As an aside, if we treat Fascism as a process then it should be clear that Trumpism and our own Voices For Freedom crowd are Fascist movements at different points along the above questions of process. Of course, Claire Deeks would refuse to identify as a Fascist – to paraphrase the fascist Primo de Rivera she isn't a fascist, she is a patriot. She is from a middle New Zealand, but she rejects mainstream New Zealand.
Wearing a $20k jacket to M
ARGA .https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10628565/Vladimir-Putin-dons-10-000-Loro-Piana-jacket-worth-twice-average-yearly-salary-rally.html
Yes . NZ joined the harsh Nato sanctions against its member Turkey for the unprovoked war and invasion of neighbour Independent and commonwealth member Cyprus.
Ahh. No they or we didnt do anything
Then there was the invasion of East Timor… I think you get the drift
Lest not forget the invasion by US of Panama ,(89-90) an independent state which just happened to have a canal.
Footnote Panama was created out of Colombia by 'the locals' (after Colombia rejected the proposed new canal) who just so happened to have US Marines stationed in the main city. So we can relax , as Panama was totally in US sphere of Influence and they do as they pleased
Indonesia withdrew from East Timor before the "invasion".
It's a rules based world.
No one confronts nations with nukes directly, no one sanctions allies and when ethnic groups get their self determination, it is good or bad based on who does it (Kosovo good, South Ossetia and Abkhazia bad etc).
Noriega had been indicted for drug trafficking.
Looks totally generic to me .I see middle class matrons any day of the week wearing something similar in Wanaka .Any verification thats a genuine Loro Piana coat?
Can't see the label from here , and Putin hasn't hung his coat on my hook for a while now.
I'd say the shoes are Bata though, definitely.
What would the EU and NATO consequences be if Belarus sent its own troops and airforces into Ukraine?
The buildups along this northern border to block NATO nation resupply routes look convincing.
There is a good reason Belarus is cautious about joining the war directly (although they are supporting indirectly in other ways).
Firstly, it would be hugely unpopular at home.
Secondly, the Belarusian forces simply aren't up to it.
"There’s a good reason for that caution. Joining the attack against Ukraine would be hugely unpopular — a survey found that only 3 percent of Belarusians support such an idea, according to Ryhor Astapenia, who leads Belarus Initiative at Chatham House’s Russia and Eurasia Program — and it could break the military, which is one of the key pillars keeping Lukashenko in power.
“The Belarusian army has never fought anywhere, the army is not prepared for external conflicts,” said Valery Sakhashchyk, a retired army lieutenant colonel and former commander of the 38th Airborne Brigade based in the city of Brest near the border with Ukraine. “Lukashenko is far from being a fool. He understands that there is a large risk that the Belarusian army will not succeed, that it will suffer heavy losses, and then his last supporters could very well turn away from him — and that would be a disaster [for Lukashenko].”""
https://www.politico.eu/article/belarus-ukraine-war-russia-alexander-lukashenko-dodges-weaves/
Glad to see Mike is calling Russia's despicable war a "War" in this article, unlike in his first where he stuck to Kremlin-friendly terminology such as "Russia’s territorial incursion"
Of course, calling the war a "war" could catch you a lengthy prison term in Russia these days.
Dont be silly . People will call it what they want . The official line is 'special operation' but web sites that say war only get blocked
Remember Operation Iraqi Freedom ? or OIF has the military love of acronyms came to call it
'"My fellow citizens. At this hour, American and coalition forces are in the early stages of military operations to disarm Iraq, to free its people and to defend the world from grave danger."
No mention of war or invasion
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2003/mar/20/iraq.georgebush
The official history of the US navy doesnt call it war either, and also falsely claims it was 'authorised by UN '!
https://www.history.navy.mil/browse-by-topic/wars-conflicts-and-operations/middle-east/operation-iraqi-freedom.html
Whadabout…?
I don't ever recall saying the murderous war in Iraq was justified or not a war.
Just saying that political leaders have a 'special speak' all of their own. Trying to pharse what people say when is fraught with difficulty
But this is more your thing , surely you stand up for Freedom every where not just Russia
And talking of political protests this gets you jailed in Singapore – yes that freedom loving Singapore
'Singaporean activist was jailed for three weeks Monday [2021] after pleading guilty to holding a small protest aboard a metro train.
https://www.france24.com/en/live-news/20210215-singapore-activist-jailed-for-train-protest
This whataboutism is all you have. It's a transparent ploy to distract and derail from the obvious – that you are here giving cover to a monster, excusing and minimising hellish suffering and misery we can see with our own eyes.
This is just a gaslighting game to you.
I want the sanctions to work.
But lets face it, they can't be targeted against the bastards who need their assets stopped.
Oh the right wing how I love thee stupidity. Remember when John Key and company wanted to make our trust laws more like North Dakota. Turn us into the protectors/hidden guardians of the greedy and scummy.
Oh wait, he got stopped when the Panama Papers came to light. And his slimy little hand was all up inside these greedy grubby scum bags. The public was like, no thanks not in NZ.
Well it seems all to many others, are happy to hide the money of these Russian scum bags behind shell companies and trusts. It looks these sanctions are going to mean sweet bugger all to them.
How about our government, puts some pressure on the places who let these scummy SOB's hide their money.
https://www.icij.org/investigations/russia-archive/icij-releases-the-russia-archive-an-inside-look-at-how-elites-close-to-putin-hide-wealth-offshore/
Well said Mike. It is disturbing that this Labour government has gone so far, so deep and so quickly into this war, to the point where the prime minister is saying we would give missiles to Ukraine if we had any to spare. What an anti-socialist party Labour has become.
Cite?
When in fact, we are only sending defensive equipment soldiers wear (body armour etc) …
Think its Seymour EP.And Robert Patman wants to send lethal military aid as well
https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/russia-invasion-of-ukraine-act-partys-david-seymour-calls-for-nz-to-send-missile-launchers/ELKZ75S6EPQLDCOMTUE6TRSJ7A/
We are well and truly a US satellite
'who pays the price of sanctions'?
History shows ordinary civilians in the country sanctioned pay…the biggest..price.