web analytics

Farce

Written By: - Date published: 10:01 pm, October 7th, 2008 - 17 comments
Categories: kiwisaver, tax - Tags:

It was with wry amusement I read Bill Ralston’s revisionist history of New Zealand superannuation today. According to Bill it was Muldoon who created an “unsupportable” super scheme as an election bribe in 1975. Of course anyone who remembers the situation (as Bill certainly should) knows full well that the real story was big Norm’s compulsory super scheme and the fact that Muldoon scrapped it in order to push cash into the pockets of voters in the face of what were looking to be, and indeed became, very dark economic times.

Over a year ago AYB discussed that super scheme and the fact that it would have provided for more than $280bn in investment capital for New Zealand today if it had been kept, so I won’t go into great detail about it but Muldoon’s scrapping of it was a truly grand political error that we are still paying the price for.

Bill Ralston may have got his facts wrong but that point in New Zealand’s economic history is one that is particularly pertinent as it is tomorrow that National will announce its tax cuts which are expected to be funded by cuts to the employer contribution to Kiwisaver. That would free up the $20 a week credit the government provides to employers for every worker in the scheme. An opportunist political decision made at our expense as we head into dark economic times. Sound familiar?

As I’ve written before cutting the employer contribution to Kiwisaver would cost an average worker with forty years of work ahead of them up to $190,000.

But the loss won’t just be to New Zealanders in Kiwisaver but to the businesses now and in the future that would have been able to access that capital.

In short it would be a move that sacrificed long-term stability and wealth for short-term political gain. Exactly the mistake Muldoon made over thirty years ago and one that Bryan Gaynor has described as our worst economic decision over the past 40 years.

We know Key has claimed an admiration of Rob Muldoon in the past but I can only hope that doesn’t extend to cutting a hole in New Zealand’s economic future just so he can save face on his over-hyped tax cut promises.

Because despite Marx’s claim history repeats itself first as tragedy and second as farce, I’d prefer if this particular piece of our history didn’t repeat itself at all.

Update: after re-reading this post this morning I’ve tightened the description of the outcome of Muldoon’s cutting of Kirk’s scheme to more accurately reflect its political implications.

17 comments on “Farce”

  1. Tane 1

    Word I heard was that the Nats were going to reduce the minimum employee contribution to 2% and halve the government contribution to a maximum of $10 a week. Of course, that’s just a rumour.

  2. randal 2

    and what about the 410,000 jobs…that pig didn,t fly.

  3. IrishBill 3

    Tane, assuming 700,000 workers in Kiwisaver, just cutting the employer contribution would free up $728m a year for National’s tax cuts and have the beneficial side-effect of letting their business support base off the hook for super payments.

    Of course workers get a 9% super contribution from employers in Aussie so a loss of all employer contributions here will make crossing the ditch an even more inviting prospect for Kiwi talent.

  4. Pascal's bookie 4

    If they are stupid enough to do this, Labour’s tv campaign ad’s pretty much write themselves.

  5. the sprout 5

    Ralston has become the new Garth George.
    It’s terrible what old age can do to a person.

  6. In Canada, the province of Alberta has charged a royalty on every barrel of oil pumped out of the ground or extracted from the tar sands. That royalty has gone into a “Heritage Fund” against the day when the oil runs out as it surely will.

    “As of June 30, 2008, the fair value of the Heritage Fund stood at $17.1 billion. Throughout its 32-year history, the Fund has generated approximately $30 billion in investment income that has improved the quality of life in the province.”

    The return on that fund allows Alberta to be the only province in Canada without a provincial sales tax. Albertans pay only the federal GST.

    There is nothing like savings to help a jurisdiction build wealth and prosperity…..which is why it is fascinating to the watch the party that would have us all believe it offers wealth and prosperity undermine saving and instead turn to borrowing.

    There is no doubt Kiwis are not savers. Most have incomes too low to allow them to save any significant amounts of capital out of cash on hand. Instead, they must rely on their homes appreciating in value as population grows over time. They don’t make land anymore, but we keep making more and more people every day.

    Cullen was doing a not-bad job at saving for all of us who can’t….and the usual squanderers rubbished him for it.

    Sad, really…..but there it is. The parties of the left have proven to be fiscally responsible and the parties of the Right want to pillage the piggy bank….bare though it is.

  7. deemac 7

    Rod Oram on Radio NZ today was carefully balanced but made it clear that he was as baffled as the rest of us by Key’s remarks today about tax cuts. When Oram said that no politician could “repeal the laws of arithmetic” it was obvious to me at any rate who he meant…

  8. According to Bill it was Muldoon who created an “unsupportable’ super scheme as an election bribe in 1975.

    Um, that’s true.

    Of course anyone who remembers the situation (as Bill certainly should) knows full well that the real story was big Norm’s compulsory super scheme and the fact that Muldoon scrapped it in order to pay for a series of election bribes in the face of what were looking to be, and indeed became, very dark economic times.

    Not true. As the Gaynor column you linked to explains, Muldoon’s scheme removed compulsory contributions from workers and employers and loaded the entire obligation onto the taxpayer. It cost money — heaps of it.

    But your contention is otherwise right: had Labour’s scheme been retained to the present day, New Zealand would be in a vastly better position, and far more in control of its economic destiny. And screwing KiwiSaver risks a repeat performance.

    Where Ralston is completely wrong is his claim that Muldoon’s scheme was “scrapped”. It wasn’t. It’s what we have today.

    IrishBill: My reading was that he was mistakenly talking about the Kirk fund because (as you point out) he described it as being scrapped and went on to draw parallels between it and Kiwisaver (a scheme much closer in nature to the Kirk fund than Muldoon’s superannuation scheme). Having read Bill’s post again I concede you may be right but it’s sufficiently lacking in clarity that it’s hard to tell if he has mixed his schemes up or if he’s just stretching the interpretation of the situation to create a tenuous and confused comparison.

  9. sean 9

    “An opportunist political decision made at our expense as we head into dark economic times. Sound familiar?”

    No – not at all, its actually a response to Cullen screwing the pooch and not having anything left out of the billions in surpluses that Labour so proudly parroted about.

    [lprent: They were only surpluses by one of the measurements used. When calculated with forward liabilities (ie super) then they were still deficits. Of course people like yourself only read the headlines.

    Besides the government wasn’t trumpeting the surpluses – that was coming from the pathetically short-term thinkers in the opposition]

  10. Ari 10

    No – not at all, its actually a response to Cullen screwing the pooch and not having anything left out of the billions in surpluses that Labour so proudly parroted about.

    Because he already spent it all on the tax cuts you were clamouring for so loudly?

    Come on, be fair.

  11. Spider_Pig 11

    You’re kidding right? National are likely to remove the employer contribution tax credit, not the employer contributions themselves. This will save the government $750 million pa, but not at all impact the overall contributions to employees Kiwisaver accounts.

    Employers will be placated by an ongoing lowering of the company tax rate and policies to improve productivity.

    I would have thought that stopping the handout to employers would have been right down The Standards alley?

  12. Paul 12

    Yeah what Russell said – I distinctly remember that election – Muldoon not only offered a better scheme from the point of view of voters but arguably a more socialistic one (the irony of which was certainly pointed out at the time) – it was also unsustainable in the long term

  13. jcuknz 13

    While I agree that Muldoon made a seriopus mistake from the Country’s point of view I personally am damm glad he did it becuase I now have my personal superanuation to help above the barely adequate national super us older folk get.

  14. Er

    I really like the Standard and most of the comments are spot on.

    I think that Ralston was talking about National Superannuation however which the nats brought in. Piggy Muldoon destroyed the Roger Douglas superannuation scheme and promised universal superannuation. It was unsustainabile, not funded, but the elderly loved it and this helped get him elected.

    9 years later we had a 9 billion deficit. Piggy called the 1984 election early because he was unable to write a choerent budget.

    Makes you realise how lucky we are under Helen!

    IrishBill: I think you might mean “Kirk’s” superfund.

    IrishBill: Actually, scratch that, I’d forgotten Douglas designed it! Probably the only decent thing he ever did in his life.

  15. Janet 15

    I had just started contributing to Norm Kirk and Labour’s compulsory NZ Super Scheme as a new worker when Muldoon came in and scrapped that NZ Super Scheme and just promised everyone super without having to pay for it in advance. So I got my contributions back. I put them in the PSIS which soon collapsed (although it was rescued and survived strongly).

    Those who don’t learn from history are really doomed to repeat it.

    I predict Key will have a go at the Cullen Fund, the ACC fund and Kiwisaver to pay for short term tax cuts.

    The other thing I remember about the 1975 election was the day after the election and the shock of Muldoon’s landslide win everyone was jolted into action and there was a huge revival and rejuvenation in the Labour Party and the left in the following years, so by 1978 Labour won more votes than National (but not more seats in the unfair FPP era). Also some huge political demonstrations were common place after Muldoon cut the public service and did other short sighted and dangerous things.

  16. Dom 16

    I wonder if National have underestimated how the public feel about Kiwisaver being tampered with – the same underestimation of how they felt about Kiwibank being sold…

  17. Oh it’s a farce alright… But one of those cruel and dark ones like something by Beckett…

Links to post

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

  • Government to fund lion’s share of Ohakea water scheme
    The Government will fund the bulk of the cost of a rural water supply for the Ohakea community affected by PFAS contamination, Environment Minister David Parker announced today at a meeting of local residents. This new water scheme will provide a reliable and clean source of drinking water to the ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 hours ago
  • Prime Minister statement on White Island eruption
    I have had the opportunity to be briefed on the details of the volcanic eruption of Whakaari/White Island, off the coast of Whakatane in the Bay of Plenty.  The eruption happened at 2.11pm today.  It continues to be an evolving situation.  We know that there were a number of tourists ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 hours ago
  • Govt funds $100k for weather-hit communities
    Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern and Minister of Civil Defence Peeni Henare have today confirmed initial Government support of $100,000 for communities affected by the severe weather that swept across the South Island and lower North Island over the weekend. The contribution will be made to Mayoral relief funds across the ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    8 hours ago
  • Death of NZ High Commissioner to Cook Islands
    New Zealand's High Commissioner to the Cook Islands, Tessa Temata, died in Palmerston North over the weekend, Foreign Minister Winston Peters said today. Ms Temata, 52, had recently returned to New Zealand for medical treatment. "On behalf of the Government and the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade, we extend ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    12 hours ago
  • Wellington rail upgrade full steam ahead
    Transport Minister Phil Twyford today announced construction is underway on Wellington commuter rail upgrades which will mean more frequent services and fewer breakdowns. The upgrades include converting the Trentham to Upper Hutt single track section to a double track, with a new signalling system, upgraded stations and level crossings, and ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    14 hours ago
  • Defence Climate Change Implementation Plan released
    Minister of Defence Ron Mark and Minister for Climate Change James Shaw have announced the release of a Defence Climate Change Implementation Work Plan, titled Responding to the Climate Crisis: An Implementation Plan.  The plan sets out a series of recommendations based on the 2018 New Zealand Defence Assessment, The ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    14 hours ago
  • Govt releases funding to support South Canterbury
    A medium-scale adverse event has been declared for the South Canterbury district, which will see up to $50,000 in funding made available to support farming communities which have been significantly affected by recent heavy rain and flooding in the area, says Agriculture Minister Damien O’Connor. “Two weeks of solid rain ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 day ago
  • Speech at launch of Rethinking Plastics Report
    Thank you Professor Juliet Gerrard and your team for the comprehensive and extremely helpful report and recommendations. Thank you too to all the stakeholders and interested parties who have contributed ideas and thinking to it. “Making best practice, standard practice” is a great framework for change and the action plan ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • Govt pledges next steps on plastic waste
    The Government will phase out more single-use plastics following the success of its single-use plastic bag ban earlier this year and the release today of a pivotal report for dealing with waste. Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern has welcomed the Rethinking Plastics in Aotearoa New Zealandreport, released by her Chief Science Advisor ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • International student enrolments grow in universities and the regions
    International education continues to thrive as the Government focuses on quality over quantity, Education Minister Chris Hipkins said. The tuition revenue from international education increased to $1.16 billion last year with the average tuition fee per student increasing by $960. The total number of international students enrolled in New Zealand ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • DHB leadership renewed and strengthened
    Health Minister Dr David Clark says new appointments to DHBs represent a significant changing of the guard, with 13 new chairs including four Māori chairs. Today 76 appointments have been announced to complement elected board members, as well as eight elected members appointed as either chair or deputy chair.  Four ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Tabuteau to advance New Zealand’s trade and political interests with European partners
    Parliamentary Under-Secretary for Foreign Affairs, Fletcher Tabuteau, is travelling to Germany, Poland, Austria, and Spain next week to bolster New Zealand’s political and trade relationships in Europe. While in Spain, Mr Tabuteau will represent New Zealand at the 14th Asia-Europe (ASEM) Foreign Ministers’ Meeting in Madrid. “New Zealand strongly supports ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Statement from the Prime Minister on Kris Faafoi
    “I’ve spoken to Minister Faafoi, who has apologised for his poor handling of this issue,” Jacinda Ardern said. “I have confidence in Kris as a hardworking and effective Minister, but this should have been dealt with in a much clearer manner, and I’ve made my views on that very clear ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Tonga-New Zealand Joint Ministerial Forum
    Deputy Prime Minister Winston Peters met with Tongan Prime Minister and Foreign Minister Pohiva Tu'i'onetoa in Wellington today. The pair signed a Statement of Partnership setting out joint priorities for cooperation out to 2023.  “We welcomed Prime Minister Tu'i'onetoa on his first visit to New Zealand as Prime Minister. Tonga ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Shooting in Kurow
    The Minister of Police Stuart Nash says his sympathies are with the family of a man who died after being shot by Police in Kurow. “Initial reports are that Police were called by a family member to help the man who was threatening to harm himself,” Mr Nash says. “However ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Government delivers funding boost for ethnic communities
    Ethnic communities will be able to plan and deliver more community initiatives thanks to an increase in Government funding, Minister for Ethnic Communities Hon Jenny Salesa said today. “Ensuring Aotearoa New Zealand is a place we can all be proud to call home has been a key priority of our ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Govt supports Southland farmers in sustainability
    Healthier waterways, better productivity and farmer wellbeing are front and centre in a new project involving more than 1000 Southland farmers and growers. Minister of Agriculture Damien O’Connor today announced that the Thriving Southland Change and Innovation Project is the first region-wide extension programme supported by the $229 million Sustainable ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Flood of support for Top of the South catchment
    Work to look after nature and restore freshwater quality in Te Hoiere/Pelorus River catchment is getting a significant boost, thanks to new Government funding support Minister for Conservation Eugenie Sage announced in Canvastown today. “Every New Zealander should be able to swim in their local river without getting sick, and ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Eight Queen’s Counsel appointed under new criterion
    Eight Queen’s Counsel have been appointed under a process that includes the new criterion of a commitment to improving access to justice, Attorney-General David Parker announced today. “The new criterion was included this year. It emphasises that excellence and leadership in the profession can be seen through a wider, community ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Major expansion for Wellington’s Onslow College
    Onslow College in Wellington will get 20 new classrooms for more than 400 students, Education Minister Chris Hipkins announced today. The much-needed investment will relieve growth pressure the school has been experiencing for some time. Seven existing classrooms which have deteriorated over time will also be replaced, bringing the total ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Talented young Kiwis awarded PM’s Scholarships to Asia and Latin America
    More than 250 young New Zealanders will add international experience to their education, thanks to the latest Prime Minister’s Scholarships for Asia (PMSA) and Latin America (PMSLA), Education Minister Chris Hipkins announced today. This round of scholarships supports 252 recent graduates or current students to undertake study, research or internships ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Government to improve competitiveness and transparency in the retail fuel market
    Consumers will benefit from a more competitive, transparent retail fuel market as a result of changes the Government will be making in response to the findings of the Commerce Commission’s study of the fuel sector. “We accept the Commission’s findings and, as the Prime Minister has said, we’re ready to ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • More cancer medicines for more people
    Five new cancer medicines have now been funded this year, meaning thousands of people have more treatment options PHARMAC has today announced that it has approved two new medicines for funding – fulvestrant for breast cancer and olaparib for ovarian cancer. This follows earlier decisions on advanced lung cancer treatment alectinib, ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Government acts to sort out electoral ‘coin toss’ problem
    The Minister of Local Government, Hon Nanaia Mahuta says the Government will consider making changes to local electoral legislation before the 2022 elections to fix the problems that have arisen where elections are settled by a coin toss.  The Minister says the recount process in the Murupara- Galatea ward at ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • NZ to Join IMO Convention to Reduce Ship Emissions
    New Zealand will sign up to new international maritime regulations to reduce ship emissions and lift air quality around ports and harbours, Associate Transport Minister Julie Anne Genter announced today. Subject to completion of the Parliamentary treaty examination process, New Zealand will sign up to Annex VI of MARPOL, an ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Bill to empower urban development projects
    New legislation to transform our urban areas and create sustainable, inclusive and thriving communities will tomorrow be introduced to Parliament, Urban Development Minister Phil Twyford said. “The Urban Development Bill gives Kāinga Ora-Homes and Communities the tools it needs to partner with councils, communities, mana whenua and private developers to ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Early Learning Action Plan to kickstart long term change
    Today’s launch of He taonga te Tamaiti: Every child a taonga: The Early Learning Action Plan 2019-2029 provides the foundation for long-lasting changes to early learning, Education Minister Chris Hipkins says.   “Early learning will be one of the Government’s top education priorities going into 2020,” Chris Hipkins said.   ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Climate change lens on major Government decisions
    Major decisions made by the Government will now be considered under a climate change lens, Minister for Climate Change James Shaw announced today. “Cabinet routinely considers the effects of its decisions on human rights, the Treaty of Waitangi, rural communities, the disability community, and gender – now climate change will ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • New Tertiary Education Commission Board announced
    Education Minister Chris Hipkins today announced the appointment of Māori education specialist Dr Wayne Ngata and Business NZ head Kirk Hope to the Board of the Tertiary Education Commission (TEC). Dr Alastair MacCormick has been reappointed for another term. “Wayne Ngata, Kirk Hope and Alastair MacCormick bring a great deal ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Next phase of Pike River recovery underway in time for Christmas
    The next phase of the Pike River Re-entry project is underway, Minister Responsible for Pike River Re-entry Andrew Little says. “Fresh air will be pumped into the Pike River Mine drift this week, following acceptance of the plan for re-entry beyond the 170m barrier by New Zealand’s independent health and ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Insurance contracts to become easier to understand and fairer for consumers
    New Zealand consumers will have greater certainty about their insurance cover when they need to make claims as a result of proposed government changes. “Insurance is vitally important in supporting consumers and businesses to be financially resilient when unexpected events happen,” Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs Kris Faafoi said. ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • A new opportunity for Ngāpuhi collective and regional negotiations
    The Crown is providing an opportunity for the hapu of Ngāpuhi to rebuild its framework from the ground up for collective negotiations to deal with its historical Treaty claims, Minister for Treaty of Waitangi Negotiations Andrew Little and Minister for Māori Development Nanaia Mahuta announced today. The Crown is also ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Referendums Framework Bill passes third reading
    A Bill enabling referendums to be held with the 2020 General Election has passed its third reading. Justice Minister Andrew Little says the Act is important for upholding the integrity of New Zealand’s electoral process. “The Government has committed to holding a referendum on legalising recreational cannabis at the next ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Referendums website and initial cannabis Bill launched
    The first release of public information on the two referendums to be held at next year’s General Election was made today with an informative new Government website going live. Additionally, the draft Cannabis Legalisation and Control Bill has been released, showing the strict controls on cannabis that will apply if ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Government to ban foreign donations
    The Government is taking action to protect New Zealand from foreign interference in our elections by banning foreign donations to political parties and candidates, Justice Minister Andrew Little announced today. Legislation will be introduced to Parliament this afternoon and passed under urgency. “There’s no need for anyone other than New ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • Governments and tech converge to strengthen joint response to online terror events
    Governments and tech companies are holding a two-day workshop, hosted by YouTube/Google in Wellington, to test the Christchurch Call Shared Crisis Response Protocol. The workshop aims to refine and strengthen the response in the event of a terrorist attack with online implications. Companies, governments, civil society experts and NGOs will ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • Cancer Control Agency to drive improved care
    The new independent Cancer Control Agency has formally opened today, delivering on the Government’s plan to improve cancer care in New Zealand.         Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern and Minister of Health David Clark marked the occasion by announcing the membership of the Advisory Council that will be supporting ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • Supporting small business to prosper
    Small businesses who deal with government departments are set to be paid faster and have improved cash flow as a result, under a new strategy released today. The Government is backing recommendations from the Small Business Council (SBC) and has agreed to implement three initiatives immediately to support business and ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Bill has biggest education changes in decades
    The Education and Training Bill 2019, introduced in Parliament today, proposes the biggest education changes in decades and is an important step towards improving success for all our learners, Education Minister Chris Hipkins said. “The Bill’s rewrite of education legislation is long overdue. Indeed one Education Act, parts of which ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Bali Democracy Forum to focus on democracy and inclusivity
    Minister for Pacific Peoples Aupito William Sio will travel to Bali to represent New Zealand at the 12th Bali Democracy Forum that will be held on the 5-6 December. “The Forum is a valuable opportunity for Asia-Pacific countries to share experiences and best practice in building home-grown democracy and fostering ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago