Loans to feed kids are income and disqualify benefit, says MSD

Written By: - Date published: 7:30 am, October 26th, 2017 - 85 comments
Categories: Abuse of power, benefits, class war, welfare - Tags: , , ,

Cross-posted with permission, this post is by Barrister and journalist Catriona MacLennan.
_________________________________________________________________

Beneficiaries who borrow money to feed their children should have their benefits cut but those who borrow to buy shares should be entitled to benefit support, according to the Ministry of Social Development.

The Auckland High Court will hear the closing day of argument in a test case about benefit entitlement on 27 October.

MSD argues that loans taken out by beneficiaries to survive comprise “income,” and accordingly disqualify them from benefit support.

The hearing started in July but could not be completed then, so will wind up this Friday.

The case involves Ms X,* a woman with two children who was on a Domestic Purposes Benefit between 2005 and 2010 and at times received other support such as the Accommodation Supplement, Special Benefit, Temporary Additional Support and a Special Needs Grant.

In 2010, Ms X’s abusive former partner made a complaint to the Ministry of Social Development about her, alleging that she had received financial support from her mother and had bought and sold houses while on a benefit.

The Ministry began an investigation into Ms X’s circumstances and entitlement to the benefit.

Her former partner later admitted that his complaint had been malicious and unfounded, but that did not stop the Ministry’s action against Ms X.

The Ministry concluded that, as Ms X had borrowed money and spent it on basic necessities for herself and her children, she had not been entitled to a benefit and was accordingly required to repay $120,398.38.

This was despite the fact that Ms X was specifically told by her Work and Income case managers that she did not have to declare loans, irrespective of whether the loans were from banks, credit cards or family members.

As benefits in Aotearoa are deliberately set at levels which are too low to live on, Ms X borrowed from her bank, her mother and her credit card to stay afloat.

She lived outside Auckland at the time and owned a property, which she was trying to hang on to so that her children would have a home. She borrowed to buy paint for the property and to fix a leak to prevent sewage from running through the floor.

The benefit review form did not ask Ms X to list loans – in contrast to the United Kingdom form which has a question about this.

Ms X also provided detailed information to MSD showing that the loans had been repaid.

MSD’s argument is that the loans, even though they have been repaid, were “income” and accordingly disqualified her from benefit support.

The case has already been to the Benefits Review Committee and the Social Security Appeal Authority. Ms X has spent hundreds of hours providing details of her situation and explaining her finances – at the same time as caring for her children, studying for a degree and trying to start a business to support her family.

The amount she is alleged to owe has been adjusted several times, so that the figure has ranged between $109,852.91 and $127,275.05.

The Social Security Appeal Authority ruled that two bank loans should not have been treated as income, but held that other loans were income and that Ms X should be required to repay $109,852.91.

The Authority also said that the forms used by Work and Income were clearly inadequate to notify beneficiaries of the information MSD alleged they needed to provide.

The Ministry of Social Development appealed to the High Court against the Authority’s decision that bank loans were not to be treated as income. Ms X also appealed, arguing that money she borrowed from her mother and others was not income.

Section 3 of the Social Security Act 1964 defines “income.” The definition is more than one-and-a-half pages long. Section 3(b) states that income includes

“..whether capital or not and as calculated before the deduction (where applicable) of income tax, any periodical payments made, and the value of any credits or services provided periodically, from any source for income-related purposes and used by the person for income-related purposes;”

Section 3 defines “income-related purpose” as meaning the purpose of –

“(a) replacing lost or diminished income; or

(b) maintaining the person or a member of his or her family; or

(c) purchasing goods or services for the person or a member of his or her family, being goods or services of a kind that are commonly paid for from income; or

(d) enabling the person to make payments that he or she is liable to make and that are commonly made from income.”

When the case was in the High Court in July, the judge asked the Crown lawyer whether there was any loan that would not be counted as income and he replied that, if credit was used to buy shares, it might not be counted.

That response illustrates the level of unreality of MSD’s approach.

It is arguing that borrowing for the most basic necessities should disqualify people from benefits, but loans for the luxury of share-buying should not.

Does the Ministry seriously believe that beneficiaries are share buyers ?

The answer can be set alongside the response of a different Crown lawyer to a judge’s question in an earlier case I acted in.

MSD was trying to recover approximately $120,000 from a chronically-ill beneficiary in her 50s who will never be able to work again. The Ministry has pursued her for years and spent a large amount on the case, even though it is plain the woman has no money and her health will never allow her to work again.
The judge asked the Crown lawyer whether it was worth continuing to pursue the beneficiary.

The lawyer responded that it was, as the beneficiary might win Lotto and would then be able to repay the money.

Neither Crown lawyer’s reply relates in any way to the reality of the lives beneficiaries actually lead.

The absurdity of MSD’s argument in Ms X’s case can be clearly illustrated by applying it to someone in work.

If loans really are income, then employees with mortgages and other debt would be required to pay tax on their loans.

Or, is it one rule for beneficiaries, and another for the rest of Aotearoa ?

*Ms X has name suppression.

_________________________________________________________________

The story of the second beneficiary referred to in the post can be seen here (PDF).

85 comments on “Loans to feed kids are income and disqualify benefit, says MSD”

  1. Dean Reynolods 1

    FFS, the sooner the new Government sorts out MSD, the better!

    • Completely agree. Massive change urgently needed.

      • Jane England 1.1.1

        My heart breaks over this. The poor woman. All the hours of stress and anxiety while mothering. Bad enough having a vengeful abusive ex husband (I know that one) but trying to provide the basics on the benefit is impossible. We all know this. Do we prevent our kids from going on school trips? Do we fail to buy the school jersey? Do we forget about holidays? Do we fail to ever buy an ice-cream or block of chocolate. It is a nightmare. So many men owe tens of thousands in child support and just what is happening to them? Some, like my ex, have earned a huge income. I’m owed over $30,000 but cannot afford court costs or the risk that this man will be clever enough to bury more of his income and have his debts reduced. Time and again it is the mothers and grandmothers in court, the woman who are left to struggle to provide are punished over and again.

    • + 1 yes this utter madness must be stopped immediately. The new Government have to make helping the most vulnerable a priority and I believe they will. Thank the Gods the gnats are gone – they would have given the MSD and their lawyers a bonus imo.

  2. Kate 2

    This kind of “Alice Through the Looking Glass” thinking has cost beneficiaries their lives and sanity as well as costing MSD and the Crown a ridiculous amount of money that cannot be described as well-spent in pursuing these Catch-22 “breaches”. Is a food parcel income then, or a donation to the children from Kids Can? It seems it might be under the rules as interpreted by the Crown lawyers. Nice work if you can get it, and apparently many lawyers can.

    • Patricia Bremner 2.1

      If these “lawyers” are being paid by us at an hourly rate that would make any benefit income look minute, how does that improve the human condition?

      New Zealand is in grave danger of losing its way if such becomes case law.

      Monty Python stuff!! With no humour.

  3. Chris 3

    Unfortunately it’s one rule for beneficiaries and another for the rest of Aotearoa. Has been for a long time now.

    Anyway, I thought this issue had been sorted out when Work and Income tried to say the living component of the student loan was income.

    http://www.nzlii.org/nz/cases/NZHC/1997/18.pdf

  4. lprent 4

    FFS.

    This is completely and utterly ridiculous. Why don’t we just plan on sacking all of the MSD staff and start again – with a computer program.

    • Stunned Mullet 4.1

      Person progamming the computer will likely be a moron from the same group that manufactured this clusterwhatsit.

    • DoublePlusGood 4.3

      Well, certainly the upper three tiers of management in their entirety.

    • Takere 4.4

      Absolutely agree!
      7000 MSD/WINZ to reapply for their roles. Also, a ‘decent’ union active onsite & in the employment agreement.
      And also, get them off their arses and out into the communities they provide support too! Reduce the number of bullssit external service providers too. Thats just the start.

  5. vto 5

    If the loan counts as positive income on drawdown of the loan

    Then the loan counts as negative income on repayment of the loan

    Net income change is therefore nil and the benefit is unaffected.

    ffs

    • Chris 5.1

      That’s what the High Court said in 1997. The very nature of a loan means that it cannot be income. Work and Income appealed unsuccessfully to the High Court back then on the exact same issue. Now it’s having another crack.

      This sort of behaviour from Work and Income and Crown Law has been going on for decades. If Ardern et al are serious about fixing the social security system they could start by telling MSD as well as Crown Law to pull their heads in.

      • Stunned Mullet 5.1.1

        NZ bureaucracy has always had a good proportion of Sir Humphrey Applebys and non thinking drones regardless of the flavour of government, can’t see that that changing anytime soon.

      • Sabine 5.1.2

        The hall mark of the right – every time they will have a chance re-litigate the same issue until they have an outcome that favors them and their enterprise. I look at the US as the TRAP-laws in regards to Abortion rights. If you can’t outright ban a service they – Republicans – will try to restrict it as much as possible with the aim of rendering service providers as non compliant and thus shut the provider. Theoretical. you still have the right, you just have no where to claim it.
        So i am not surprised to see National again try this via the courts. After all the Tax payer pays the piper and the poor schmuck who will be saddled with tens of thousands of dollars matters not – collateral damage.
        Essentially if loans were to be counted as income – you could a. tax them and b. force anyone who needs temporary assistance to get a loan. Voila, then numbers of beneficiaries drop, and the ‘market provided’ and with the class of forever indebted created you have a steady stream of cheap labour. The end of the state providing cheap assistance to people in need – go git yer loan.

    • Richard Christie 5.2

      @vto
      exactly

    • Matthew Whitehead 5.3

      Depends if there’s ever an intention to repay the loan, of course. Bank loans definitely shouldn’t count as income ever, but they’re arguing essentially that personal loans are income because they may never be repaid.

      It’s a little ridiculous when in reality the burden should be on MSD to prove it’s paying people enough to live.

      • weka 5.3.1

        Do you mean loans from family? Had Ms X been properly advised by WINZ (aka WINZ doing their job) she should have been told under what conditions she had to declare loans, that if she wasn’t paying the loans back then the loan *might be counted as income, and that if she was paying the loan back and it was for essential things then she could include that loan repayment in her claim for Special Benefit or Temporary Additional Support as a cost (i.e. WINZ would help with the repayments. Probably not for living expenses, but for things like a new washing machine).

        The great thing about borrowing from family is that the interest is usually low or zero, certainly cheaper than borrowing from banks etc. WINZ should be encouraging people to borrow from family not penalising them for it, because once you start getting hardship assistance it’s a requirement to lessen any unnecessary financial burden i.e. WINZ are working against their own policy here. But seeing as how they’re working in their own interests (i.e. to pay out less entitlements to NZ citizens), there is a clear conflict that has been created by National between policy and direction. And beneficiaries are the ones paying for that.

        There are so many things wrong with this case it’s hard to know where to begin. Clusterfuck of epic proportions is where I’ve gotten to.

        *I say might, because I’m guessing that WINZ have discretion in this.

        • Matthew Whitehead 5.3.1.1

          Yes, sorry, loans from family or friends that come with no interest and may realistically not have an expectation of repayment. I forgot for a moment that technically any loan you take for yourself is a “personal loan,” and was thinking in an entirely different context, lol.

          WINZ probably do not have discretion in what counts as income- that’s down to the law and legal precedent. What they do have discretion over is WINZ policy, and whether to continue legal action. The Minister can instruct them to drop the case if she so chooses, if she determines it is no longer within the interest of the NZ public to pursue it. In some ways, we’re lucky it’s been postponed long enough that there’s a very small window for Carmel Sepuloni to act.

          • weka 5.3.1.1.1

            We probably don’t have enough information to go on, but I’m reasonably sure that WINZ historically hasn’t routinely counted loans as income. I’m not aware of an recent legislation that would force WINZ to do so, so it’s policy, which means its discretionary (there could also be a Ministerial Directive).

            So there will be many beneficiaries in NZ who have taken out loans, told WINZ, and it not been counted against their benefit. Possibly what’s at issue here is what she spent the money on (e.g. general living expenses).

            That the court is now differentiating between family loans and bank loans also suggests that up until now there has been discretion. I think MSD are using this to establish precedent but that that precedent doesn’t already exist.

          • One Anonymous Bloke 5.3.1.1.2

            If the money will never be repaid, most families would consider it a gift.

            What’s the legal status of gifts in this context?

            Dropping the case will not stop the sadists having another go the moment the National Party manages to enable them again.

            The best way for the government to defend New Zealand citizens against them is to entrench the BoRA, and make breaches of human rights by public servants subject to the Crimes Act, whether or not they’re following National Party orders.

            • weka 5.3.1.1.2.1

              Gifts are income, when WINZ want them to be.

              • One Anonymous Bloke

                Indeed. Looks like they need a therapeutic dose of “obeying the law or facing the consequences”, like the rest of us.

        • Chris 5.3.1.2

          Whether something’s income or not comes down to the definition. There’s no discretion around what is income and what isn’t. The definition is wider than other definitions, for example under tax legislation, and it can in some instances capture capital payments, but it doesn’t go so far as capturing loans. The High Court made that clear in its 1997 decision about whether the living component of the student loan was income. Those payments on the face of it did meet the definition, but the High Court said that the very basis of a loan means that it cannot be income. Without knowing anything more than what’s been said in the post I’m going to boldly say that MSD’s attempt at the High Court tomorrow will fail abysmally for precisely this reason.

          • One Anonymous Bloke 5.3.1.2.1

            Bloody well hope so. When do we get to sue the perpetrators for wasting the court’s time? Personal responsibility means not Paula Bennett, that’s f’sure.

            • Chris 5.3.1.2.1.1

              One of the changes Labour introduced in the 2007 amendment Act was the ability to make regulations that could override the s 3 definition of income. Highly unconstitutional at best. Income is central to benefit entitlement. Giving the government the power to unilaterally override the principal Act regarding something so fundamental as that is quite despicable. I don’t think the power’s been used yet, but Labour wanted that power and now the government of the day has it. Pretty surprising the nats didn’t use it when it had the chance. Ironically, if the case tomorrow at the High Court ends up in favour of beneficiaries the government could overturn it by regulation. This government thankfully wouldn’t, you’d hope, but the power’s certainly there when it shouldn’t be. That was Clark’s Labour for you.

              • One Anonymous Bloke

                I’m guessing (wishful thinking?) that Lab5’s intention was to capture tax evasion, as opposed to enabling human rights violations.

                • weka

                  It’s handy when you have a core value that being on a benefit is wrong. That way you don’t have to protect the rights of people on benefits quite as much as others.

                • Chris

                  I can’t see how widening the definition of income under the SSA with the objective of curbing entitlement to social security benefits could be for the purpose of capturing tax evasion. Tax legislation remains unchanged. The 2007 amendment Act contained a raft of changes that were plainly attacks on the poor. The regulation making power was just one of those attacks. Against that, I suppose you could say that the regulation making power could potentially have been used to loosen the definition of income, but the overall context of those changes was pretty clearly aimed at doing the poor over. The real point, though, is that government shouldn’t have that power in the first place.

              • weka

                Is that amendment something that can be easily repealed? Or does it tie into other things?

                • Chris

                  It’d just have to go through the usual legislative process – that and a whole bunch of other stuff previous Labour and National governments have introduced to screw the poor. Getting rid of sections 1A and 1B and reintroducing the long title to the 1938 Act that those sections in effect ousted would be a start, but realistically the whole Act needs an overhaul. Good to see the current government announce getting rid of sanctions, including the punitive attack on sole parents not naming the other parent. There’s a social security rewrite Bill currently before the House, but you can imagine what that does. The new mob needs to clear out all the officials who’ve invested themselves into that work and bring in groups like the Auckland Action Against Poverty to tell them about all the nasty things that need to be dealt to. There’s a whole stack of things that need fixing and current officials are the same ones who’ve been around for years and who’ve written that despicable rewrite Bill so talking to them would be a waste of time. The government needs to make sure it gets its advice from the right people. Current officials ain’t them.

  6. Richard Christie 6

    Loans are not permanent income. It’s f*ing ludicrous to consider them so. They’re temporary liabilities.

    Payments, when income, are the property of the recipient able to be disposed of as they seem fit or are obliged to by separate agreements (debts etc).

    Repaid loans are retired liabilities. It is insane to treat the beneficiary in a manner identical to that where they permanently pocket the loan.

  7. Sabine 7

    WINZ is creating an awful lot of people with debt instead of providing them with the social services and benefits needed to lift themselves up. Has WINZ become a Profit Center under the care of the National Party?

    • Chris 7.1

      Was the same between 1999 and 2008. In some respects worse.

      • Sabine 7.1.1

        care to elaborate?

        • Chris 7.1.1.1

          Abolished the special benefit in 2004, combined with this: http://www.cpag.org.nz/assets/Wgtn%20People%27s%20Centre.pdf followed by the devastation caused by the Social Security Amendment Act 2007. There’s more if you care to look into it. Few do.

          • weka 7.1.1.1.1

            Would you be interested in writing a Guest Post on some of the history Chris?

            • Chris 7.1.1.1.1.1

              Have thought about it at times, out of anger more than anything. Usually when something happens, like Labour voting with the nats for even more anti-beneficiary “reform”.

              • greywarshark

                Chris
                Having thought about it again, can you now write one while there is the 100 days to go through and so keep it in the minds of those in a position to make a positive difference? Even just getting started on one aspect with an anecdote then a second and third similar. There must be a lot to say about the shallow attitudes towards helping citizens to come to a reasonable sort of equality in this part of the 21st century.

          • beatie 7.1.1.1.2

            Don’t forget that it was Labour (in 2007) who appointed the dreadful Dr David Bratt, a Wellington GP, as Chief Medical Adviser to Winz. Dr Bratt believes in work as the cure for illness (arbeit macht frei?) and coined the term ”worklessness”

            https://accforum.org/forums/index.php?/topic/12615-dr-david-bratt/

            https://nzsocialjusticeblog2013.wordpress.com/category/winz-designated-
            doctors/

            Winz were intent on introducing the British welfare model, the one so cruelly portrayed in ”I, Daniel Blake”.

            I don’t hold much hope for the proposed ”overhaul of welfare”

            Meanwhile the long-term sick and disabled are expected to survive, year in and year out on $230 per week.

  8. JustMe 8

    I used to work for WINZ and this matter in regards to Ms X is the most ridiculous thing I have ever read.
    Shame on you WINZ, MSD or whatever you want to call yourselves now.
    Surely WINZ should come across as more caring for NZers. Why should WINZ attack and witch-hunt a simple little NZer just because she is like so many others here in NZ i.e a beneficiary?
    When I was working for WINZ I came across a former Team Leader of WINZ who used multiple names to get more than $1million in benefits. He was repaying that debt by about $10.00 a week.
    The pathetic reasoning of the MSD lawyer shows him or her to be grossly out of touch with reality. The hypothetical ‘she may win lotto….’ shows to me this lawyer hasn’t yet evolved yet into an intelligent person. Perhaps he/she never will. The Gravy Boat of being paid per year by MSD on a probably much better wage/income than Ms X was expected to pay back to WINZ is too much of a draw-card for such a self-serving person as the MSD lawyer.
    Will he or she next crop up as a potential National Party MP in the next election? Lets hope not. Best thing for THAT one is to send them to North Korea.
    My brother has a saying that we have a better chance of getting a kiss from the Pope than us winning lotto.
    But then for an overpaid lawyer like the one working for MSD I guess every pay day is Lotto day for them.

  9. savenz 9

    The Natz are malicious, dishonest, sore losers who will spend any amount of money to harass someone, and they have moulded the public service in their image in the 9 years and enriched private legal practises with their obsessions. Funny enough, they can’t actually get it right legally themselves aka their copywriter fraud and damages to Eminin.

    A lot of work to be done in this area by the new government. Oh, and don’t expect any of the public complaints authority to be working either, crammed full of Natz crony troughers.

    BIG clear out, needed in public service.

  10. Sabine 10

    So if that person will be saddles with the debts can she declare bankruptcy?

    • UncookedSelachimorpha 10.1

      Not sure – but there are moves in the USA to make all sorts of debt (particularly the types that poor people accumulate, e.g. education debt) excluded from discharge on bankcruptcy. I expect the Natz would love to take us down that path.

      • James Thrace 10.1.1

        Debts owed to government agencies are not discharged upon filing for bankruptcy. National changed this at the same time they imposed criminal sanctions on student loan defaulters.
        It was changed in response to evidence that there were student loan defaulters, living overseas, filing for bankruptcy in NZ to avoid student loan defaults.

        Filing for bankruptcy in NZ avoided any ramifications to those defaulters if they were living in say, the UK. If they were living in Australia, bankruptcy here has impacts there given the close relationship with dun and Bradstreet, baycorp etc, who have offices in both countries.

  11. Et Tu Brute 11

    Only makes sense if the repayment of the loan is taken off income.

    Also need to look at predatory lending and what terms money is lent to people in such a position.

    • greywarshark 11.1

      I’m interested in how contra preferentem might have a place here. Poor people are unlikely to understand all the ins and outs of financial matters. Say you were told the interest was 1% a day for a temporary loan. It wouldn’t sound much and if you were stuck you would probably not think too much about the sums.

      There is a power and knowledge imbalance.

      The contra proferentem rule – the rule of interpretation that says the words of written documents are interpreted more forcibly against the party putting forward the document – is long-standing in contract law and insurance law.
      http://www.parkerandassociates.co.nz/blog/role-of-contra-proferentem-when-interpreting-contracts

  12. UncookedSelachimorpha 12

    I downloaded the full report at the pdf link at the bottom of the post – impressively thorough and insightful work by Catriona MacLennan, everyone should read it.

    It is also very uncomfortable and distressing reading – we can do much, much, much better than this in NZ.

  13. Et Tu Brute 13

    There is one red flag here: the loan was from the mother. And of course, in hindsight it is okay, because Ms X paid it back in full. That should have ended any investigation. One potential loophole with such loans is a person can declare nil income, gain a ‘benefit’ for themselves or their children (such as student allowance) and have money lent to them via family or trust with the unstated intention of not paying it back. After their kids finish university, or the need ends, the loan is either not repaid or is written off. MSD never gets to hear about it. Again, obviously this is not the case here, but any policy work around ‘loans as income’ probably was designed for this instance and then misused in this case. Such schemes have historically been used, as another example, to mask political donations.

  14. Ad 14

    Makes me sick reading it.

  15. Bill 15

    @ Catriona

    I’m assuming the supposed income (the sum total of the loans) has got no bearing at all on that repayment figure ranging between $109,852.91 and $127,275.05.

    That is, I’m assuming the figure is simply a case of WINZ calculating and recalculating the supposed sum total of benefit received during a period of supposedly “fraudulent” applications.

    Can you clarify or confirm that please? Cheers.

    • weka 15.1

      yeah, I’m struggling to see what they’ve done too. Are you thinking they’re wanting her to pay back all the benefits not just the bits she was allegedly not entitled to?

      Base DPB is currently $376/wk. $120,000 divided by 5 years, then 52 weeks = $461.

      • James Thrace 15.1.1

        Winz will seek repayment of the entire benefit amount provided. Not just the alleged overpayment. Extremely punitive and no doubt led to the suicide of Wendy Shoebridge.

        • Bill 15.1.1.1

          Winz will seek repayment of the entire benefit amount provided. Not just the alleged overpayment.

          That’s what I’ve maintained before now on cases where alleged fraud stacks up to six figure sums. Some people have kind of refused to accept that’s the scenario and since Catriona seems to be familiar with this case, I thought she might see my comment and be able to put the question to bed.

          As it is, some people are going to assume the woman in question borrowed somewhere in the region of $109 000 – $127 000.

          • Patricia Bremner 15.1.1.1.1

            I notice one of the agreements for the new government listed removing and/or altering punitive penalties for beneficiaries. (Greens Labour)

            I’m operating on extremely expensive broadband ’till next week. Perhaps some kind soul could look that up for us.

            This case could come under punitive penalties?

            Seems similar to when IRD were causing suicides at one time.

            Punitive tax came back with the Nats. Much higher penalties for getting it wrong.

            • weka 15.1.1.1.1.1

              While the Greens have been given the go to make some changes at WINZ, I haven’t seen any detail yet about which things they will look at. I really hope the Greens start listening to beneficiaries directly on this. It’s almost like we need a truth and reconciliation process. I see some good things that the Greens can do, but I think we are going to be disappointed somewhat too (probably because of Labour and possibly NZF).

              If you look at Chris’ comments in this thread you will se example of what Labour govts have done. In essence Ardern’s Labour needs to break from Clark’s Labour on welfare, and I haven’t seen that happen yet, although there have been smaller shifts.

              • Patricia Bremner

                Jacinda’s statement as a government of “Empathy” Is a beginning.

                • weka

                  Yes, and I definitely think there will be improvements. But because of their history, on welfare they have to earn the trust again.

        • weka 15.1.1.2

          WINZ will sometimes seek repayment of the whole benefit. It’s unclear under what conditions eg those deemed fraud? It’s also unclear what authority they have to do that.

  16. Macro 16

    Unfortunately this is now a typical, and far from an unusual response, from a government bureaucracy with such a toxic culture. Regretfully this all stems from a New Zealand society that is now so engrossed in materialism and self that such uncaring and disregard for the more vulnerable in our communities is the main widespread attitude. I’m not saying this is applies to all, but when 44% of the voting public can vote for a party that fosters these attitudes one can see that the culture of self over society is common.
    On tuesday evening I had the opportunity to watch a very powerful film recently released by 8 amazing wahine directors. “Waru” is a film in 8 parts set around the tangi of a tamariki killed whilst in care.
    One of the short episodes covered the situation of a solo mum, Mihi, who struggles to cope with little food in the house, a young baby, no petrol in the car, unable to pay school fees or money for field trips, and no money. This is the case for 100’s of thousands of NZers, including 200,000+ children, living in poverty.
    If you have not seen this movie I strongly recommend it. Especially if you are of a right wing persuasion, because this film is real. Single shot. Immediate and direct.
    A pre release review of the film is here:

  17. silvertuatara 17

    Well if National were collectively under paying persons on benefits by $200 Million annually http://www.newshub.co.nz/home/election/2017/09/winz-creating-two-classes-of-kiwis-labour.html, they certainly have had the financial resource to be able to game the system to the detriment of persons trying to make ends meet.

    What a shadow the National government placed over social security support between 2008 and 2017. I am so glad that the new coalition is setting about addressing these issues positively, and hopefully for the betterment of all those whom find themselves in the position that they require assistance.

  18. Al 18

    Some of the lawyers comments are beyond belief in their stupidity and ignorance of the people aspect of these cases … e.g. buying shares okay but not buying neccessities and the killer – but she might win lotta then could pay the loan back – WTF? All I can say is that MSD are damned lucky there are no laws that allow for sueing here.

    • weka 18.1

      I’m still trying to figure out how the shares thing would work.

      Beneficiary borrows money to buy shares. Has to pay back the loan money plus interest, and they have to declare the shares to WINZ as both an asset and any income derived from the shares. If they borrow enough money and make enough money from the shares then their benefit will be abated like all other income. If the shares are high enough then once the loan is paid back the shares become an asset that means you can’t have many of the supplementary benefits. It’s a daft idea from people who have no idea how WINZ entitlements work.

      • James Thrace 18.1.1

        Not to mention that borrowing money to purchase shares, as long as the shares produce some form of taxable income, means that the interest paid on money borrowed to buy shares is tax deductible from your PAYE at year’s end.

  19. Delia 19

    Shares are different, rich people profit of them.

  20. Delia 20

    I might add I hope her stupid ex partner is happy.

  21. Matthew Whitehead 21

    I would like to note that Catriona, as well as Russel Brown, have both been pressuring the new Minister Carmel Sepuloni on social media to take action on this case, (check out @CatMacLennanNZ if you want to retweet her) and there is a chance for them to instruct their lawyers ahead of Friday to drop this action, if they act quickly, or even to instruct the Ministry to forgive the debt afterwards if they don’t.

    I don’t care what avenue she takes, but I really hope the new Minister does instruct her department to take mitigating action in this case either today or within the next few days, and to urgently review all future cases for consistency with forthcoming changes to benefit policies. It might not be the most important of her new duties in terms of scale of impact, but it is urgent, and it would be an important symbol of how the new government will change MSD’s culture.

    • weka 21.1

      Yes on the symbology and urgency.

      I’m also worried about the implications for other beneficiaries if MSD win this. Does this then mean that no beneficiary can borrow money except through high interest paying businesses like banks? (or they can but can expect to be penalised for it).

      “or even to instruct the Ministry to forgive the debt afterwards if they don’t.”

      This is the thing that’s fucking me off. They don’t have to be doing what they are doing, which begs the question of why they are doing it. And that takes us to see fairly horrendous implications about just how bad MSD is now. I really hope that the new government takes this on board fully but I’m concerned because of Labour’s own history and there is still no clear indication from Labour that they will treat beneficiaries the same as other NZ citizens.

      Yes, the Greens will be allowed to sort out WINZ to an extent, but this goes much deeper than that and it’s going to need Labour to make a stand that I haven’t yet seen them make.

      • One Anonymous Bloke 21.1.1

        it’s going to need Labour to make a stand that I haven’t yet seen them make.

        Yep. I hope the Greens use their leverage to fix this before our government ends up defending itself at the Hague. The National Party should already be there.

  22. weka 22

    Here’s the relevant bit of the Act if anyone wants to look at it,

    http://www.legislation.govt.nz/act/public/1964/0136/332.0/DLM359124.html

  23. Richard Christie 23

    What would they say if you sold one of your kidneys to pay an unexpected bill?

  24. Korero Pono 24

    Classing loans as income beggars belief. If MSD apply their own logic (or lack thereof) then every time they loan beneficiaries money to pay for unexpected costs, shouldn’t that also be treated as income? I wonder how often beneficiaries seeking help are still being told to ask their friends and family for help first – are they wanting to set beneficiaries up for a fall when they do that? The great tragedy in all this (besides the stress and hardship endured by any beneficiary affected by this farce), are the costs and lengths that MSD will go, to litigate and punish people. Their approach shows just how far removed they have become from human reality and the sooner MSD is overhauled and reined in the better. Culling staff from the top down to eradicate the mean spirited culture that has been allowed to develop over the years would be a good place to start. Maybe even psychological testing of staff, their advisers and legal team to weed out sociopaths and the like would also not go amiss. Perhaps they could also do with a community advisory board that is made up of beneficiary advocates and beneficiaries.

    • Richard Christie 24.1

      It’s a fucking war alright. MSD really are out to exterminate their “clients”.

    • weka 24.2

      “Classing loans as income beggars belief. If MSD apply their own logic (or lack thereof) then every time they loan beneficiaries money to pay for unexpected costs, shouldn’t that also be treated as income? I wonder how often beneficiaries seeking help are still being told to ask their friends and family for help first – are they wanting to set beneficiaries up for a fall when they do that?”

      I think this is why I found the post so hard to read. It’s the no way out potential of it that makes me think there is something truly wrong with some of the people running the MSD and WINZ. I’ve know good people working at WINZ too, so I’m still struggling to see how they can coexist.

      I’ve started thinking we need something like a truth and reconciliation process.

  25. Matthew 25

    an income is something you don’t pay back. a loan is a loan of money you didn’t earn and have to repay. big diference. msd is cruel and pathetic. way to ruin your reputation. oh hang on. you only have one for causing harm. way to improve your rep

  26. Brian Tregaskin 26

    A restructure of MSD is urgently needed.
    This is a govt dept with a toxic culture that needs to be restructured out from the top down.

  27. Thinkerr 27

    Simple.

    Following from the last point, suggesting that if the MSD argument is true, then mortgages of employees should be taxed, why not:

    Request the mortgage and other loans details of the head of SSC and the senior management team of MSD and their families, and tell them how much they will need to be liable for in tax if they win their case and their argument.

    Ditto the lawyer for the prosecution.

    Then watch the problem go away in a hurry.

  28. JeffB 28

    I just couldn’t believe what I was hearing when this story came out. Any loan is not income, they have to pay it back FFS! And to go after the most vulnerable in this way is disgusting.

Links to post

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

  • The persecution of feminist folk singer and activist Thistle Petterson
    Some of us at Redline are part of a Marxist and anarchist gender-critical e-group that consists of activists in several countries – trade unionists, women’s liberation activists, gay and straight, male and female.  Through this we became aware of the case outlined below.  Thanks to Thistle for writing this for ...
    RedlineBy Admin
    33 mins ago
  • Close Tiwai Point
    Tiwai Point's electricity contract is up for renewal. And as usual, they're sticking their hand out, demanding a government subsidy, and threatening to close if they don't get one:The owners of the aluminium smelter said on Wednesday that there were seeking talks with the Government amid a strategic review which ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    13 hours ago
  • How volcanoes influence climate and how their emissions compare to what we produce
    Climate Explained is a collaboration between The Conversation, Stuff and the New Zealand Science Media Centre to answer your questions about climate change. If you have a question you’d like an expert to answer, please send it to climate.change@stuff.co.nz Everyone is going on about reducing our carbon footprint, zero ...
    SciBlogsBy Guest Author
    15 hours ago
  • ACT: Backed by Nazis
    So, it turns out that the ACT Party - which previously called itself "the liberal party" - is financed by Nazis:ACT Party leader David Seymour says his party will not return a donation from Mike Allen, a Christchurch businessman who sells mock "Make America Great Again" hats to fund advertising ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    16 hours ago
  • Counting Barretts
    Just in case you don’t have a seven-year-old boy in your house (in which case this will be obvious) a well-known brand of breakfast cereal here in NZ is currently coming with All-Blacks stats cards. Perfect for finding out your favourite rugby player’s height, number of caps, and how much ...
    SciBlogsBy Marcus Wilson
    16 hours ago
  • Bullying their critics
    Over the past month we've heard some horrific stories about bullying in the police. The police's response? Try to bully people into silence:The police have told a whistleblower to retract his statements to RNZ about being bullied or face legal action. The demand came just hours after Police Commissioner Mike ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    20 hours ago
  • Member’s Day: End of Life Choice, part 5
    Today is a Member's Day, which should see the final part of the committee stage of David Seymour's End of Life Choice Bill. The big question today is the referendum clause: will it be necessary, or can the bill pass without it? While the majorities for his amendments during the ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    20 hours ago
  • There is no ‘gendered brain’
    One of the key arguments used by trans ideologists is that some male-bodied people (ie men) are women because they ‘feel’ they are women.  To make this hocus-pocus sound a bit more credible, some will argue that such men have a ‘female brain’.  But this is thoroughly anti-scientific too. . ...
    RedlineBy Admin
    20 hours ago
  • Canada’s electoral system is broken
    Canadians went to the polls today in parliamentary elections, and appear to have re-elected blackface wearer Justin Trudeau. Unfortunately, they use first-past-the-post, and they've provided a perfect demonstration of how unfair this system is:PartySeats% Seats% VoteLiberal15746.4%33.1%Conservative12135.8%34.4%Bloc Québécois329.5%7.7%New Democratic Party247.1%15.9%Green Party30.9%6.5%Other10.3%2.4% [Results from Elections Canada] Yes, the Liberals got fewer votes ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 day ago
  • Measles: the quackery that is homeopathic “vaccination”
    A few days ago, a friend sent me a link to a health-related FB page that had published a post from a homeopathist, offering homeopathic “vaccination”¹ against measles (using something called a “Morbillinum nosode” at a “potency” of 200C, which I’ll explain shortly). I followed the link, left a comment ...
    SciBlogsBy Alison Campbell
    2 days ago
  • Colombia: 20th anniversary of La Gabarra massacre
    by Gearóid Ó Loingsigh This year marks the 20th anniversary of the La Gabarra massacre. The community organised an event to remember the most well-known of the horrendous heart-breaking events that befell the communities of this area of the municipality of Tibú: the massacre carried out on August 21st 1999. ...
    RedlineBy Admin
    2 days ago
  • A prediction
    There was another police chase in Christchurch this morning, resulting in a crash which killed one person and injured five more. Because someone died, the chase is being investigated by the Independent Police Conduct Authority. And based on previous reports by the IPCA, we know how it will go: the ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    2 days ago
  • Climate Change: The Zero Carbon Bill
    Just a month ago we saw the biggest protest in a generation as people marched to demand stronger action on climate change. A core demand of the protesters was to strengthen the Zero Carbon Bill's target to net-zero by 2040. So what is the government's response? Judging by the ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    2 days ago
  • Zombie ants, updated
    Back in 2010, I wrote about the strange tale of the zombie ants, which do the bidding of their fungal overlords. (They’re not an isolated example; a range of parasites change their hosts’ behaviour. See here and here for example – though as you’ll find, the toxoplasmosis story may be ...
    SciBlogsBy Alison Campbell
    2 days ago
  • Paying For Our Pakeha “Guilt” And “Privilege”.
    Shouldn't That Be: "Wrong White Crowd"? Rather than apportion guilt, would it not have been wiser for the makers of Land Of The Long White Cloud to accept that the Pakeha of 2019 are not – and never will be – “Europeans”? Just as contemporary Maori are not – and ...
    2 days ago
  • A Bodyguard of Truths.
    One, Two, Many Truths: With the collapse of “actually existing socialism” in 1991, the universities of the West found themselves saddled with a new mission. With their ideological competitors now soundly defeated they were no longer required to demonstrate the superiority of capitalist values. Their job now was to cement ...
    2 days ago
  • A call to unionists
    by the Council of Disobedient Women   We call on the Council of Trade Unions to show some fortitude and take a stand with your sisters. Unionists know that there is a material world, otherwise workers could simply identify out of poverty. They could declare themselves Well Paid. Why stop ...
    RedlineBy Daphna
    3 days ago
  • Sophistry and bullshit
    I spent some time reading the Regulatory Impact Statement and Bill of Rights Act advice for the government's odious control order scheme today. I am not impressed with either of them. Starting with the RIS, it is built on some pretty questionable assumptions. For example:Unless individuals have been convicted of ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    3 days ago
  • I’m so fly, I’m #NoFly!
    #NoFly: Walking the talk on climate change, by Shaun Hendy. BWB Texts, 2019. Reviewed by Robert McLachlan In June 2018, Swede Maja Rosén founded We stay on the ground with a pledge not to fly in 2019, and a goal of persuading 100,000 other Swedes to join her. In August, ...
    SciBlogsBy Guest Author
    3 days ago
  • Punishing the young
    We all know that NZ First is a party of and for old people who hate the young. But they've topped their previous pedophobia with a proposal that all young people be forced to do 100 hours community work:NZ First wants all young people to do 100 hours of community ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    3 days ago
  • Journalism, clickbait, & ideas of classical beauty – but not science
    A couple days ago the NZ Herald published a story with the headline, “Science says Bella Hadid is world’s most beautiful woman“, and followed up with the ridiculous statement that Supermodel Bella Hadid has been declared as the world’s most beautiful woman following a scientific study into what constitutes as ...
    SciBlogsBy Alison Campbell
    3 days ago
  • Is Simon’s Smile Sustainable?
    A Sustainable Proposition: With as much as 18 percent of the electorate declaring itself “undecided” about who to vote for, there is obviously plenty of space for a party like former Green Party member, Vernon Tava's, about-to-be-launched "Sustainable NZ Party" to move into. The most hospitable political territory for such ...
    3 days ago
  • What the actual Hell?
    Keir Starmer has hinted that Labour might vote in favour of the Johnson government's shoddy deal, with the proviso that a second referendum is attached:Speaking to BBC One’s The Andrew Marr Show, he said: “We will see what that looks like but it makes sense to say that by whatever ...
    3 days ago
  • Hard News: Dealer’s Choice, an oral history from Planet 1994
    In 1994, I was the editor for an issue of Planet magazine focused on cannabis, its culture and the prospects for the end of its prohibition. Part of that issue was an interview with 'Ringo', an experienced cannabis dealer.I recently posted my essay from that issue, and I figured it ...
    5 days ago
  • The invasion of women’s sports by men: some facts
    Dr Helen Waite, sports sociologist and former elite athlete, on the invasion of women’s sport by men and the anti-scientific and misogynist ideology used to rationalise it.   ...
    RedlineBy Admin
    5 days ago
  • Remainers starting to sound like fascists
    As Brexit comes to a grisly conclusion (perhaps) people on all sides are saying intemperate and uwise things.  Some, like the Daly Mail, have been doing it for years.People as normally level headed as Jon Lansman are calling for automatic deselection of MPs who vote against a (likely) Labour three ...
    5 days ago
  • Labour MPs supporting Johnson’s turd-sandwich deal?
    I find this unbelievable:
    I've got one source saying more Labour MPs than expected are mulling whether to vote for the deal - including names who were not on the letter to Juncker and Tusk— Emilio Casalicchio (@e_casalicchio) 17 October 2019 I've compiled a list of possible reasons why Labour ...
    6 days ago
  • Why do we need control orders again?
    On Wednesday, the government was loudly telling us that it needed to legislate to allow it to impose "control orders" - effectively a parole regime, but imposed without charge, prosecution, conviction or real evidence - on suspected terrorists because they couldn't be prosecuted for their supposed crimes. Today, it turns ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    6 days ago
  • Bullshitting the Minister
    On Monday, the Hit and Run inquiry heard from NZDF's former director of special operations, who claimed that the defence Minister knew everything about the Operation Burnham raid. Today, the inquiry heard from that (former) Minister - and it turns out that he didn't know nearly as much as NZDF ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    6 days ago
  • Speaker: Extinction Rebellion is not a cult (but ecstasy for the people)
    Yoga gurus and cult leaders – I’ve seen a few. Two weeks ago, I unknowingly joined an alleged new-age cult at the Kāpiti coast, together with a giant kraken and some neatly dressed pensioners who would make any book club proud.They were among the two hundred people of all ages ...
    6 days ago
  • We need to bring the police under control
    The last decade has seen a trend of increasing weapons availability to police. Assault rifles. Tasers on every hip. Guns in cars. And following the march 15 massacre, pistols on every hip, all over the country. At the same time, its also seen an increase in the abuse of force: ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    6 days ago
  • If you can’t measure it, does it exist?
    In the last couple of weeks, I’ve been busy preparing for our summer paper on Science Communication. Looking for something amusing about ‘risk’ in science, I came across this neat xkcd.com cartoon about why so many people come knocking on my door (or phoning me, or emailing me) desperately wanting ...
    SciBlogsBy Marcus Wilson
    6 days ago
  • Swinson’s swithering
    Jo Swinson is doing even worse at this Being Sensible lark that I'd thought.  I've just become aware of the following utterance
    .@KayBurley presses Lib Dem leader @joswinson on whether she would agree to a #Brexit deal 'no matter how bad a deal it is' as long as it had ...
    6 days ago
  • Women’s rights, trans ideology and Gramsci’s morbid symptoms
    by John Edmundson The International Socialist Organisation (ISO) have recently reposted a February article, by Romany Tasker-Poland, explaining ISO’s position in the “trans rights” debate.  It is available on their website and on their Facebook Page.  The article sets out to explain why “socialists support trans rights”.  It reads more ...
    RedlineBy Admin
    7 days ago
  • We need to take guns off police
    Today's IPCA report of police criminality: a police officer unalwfully tasered a fleeing suspect who posed no threat to anyone:The police watchdog has found an officer unlawfully tasered an Auckland man who broke his ankle jumping off a balcony to escape arrest. [...] To avoid arrest, the man jumped over ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    7 days ago
  • “Bringing kindness back”
    "Auckland City Mission: 10% of Kiwis experiencing food insecurity", RNZ, 16 October 2019:About half a million people are experiencing food insecurity, according to new research from the Auckland City Mission. Food insecurity, or food poverty, is defined as not having enough appropriate food. The City Mission said over the last ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    7 days ago
  • Press Release: “Fake News” from Auckland City Council CCOs Board Chairs re pay and performance b...
    Media Statement for Immediate Release 16th October 2019 “Fake News” from Auckland City Council CCOs Board Chairs re pay and performance bonuses for top managers Despite comments from Auckland City Council CCOs Board Chairs re pay and performance bonuses for top managers—Herald Newspaper Tuesday Oct 15th–there is very little evidence ...
    Closing the GapBy Tracey Sharp
    7 days ago
  • Ever-So-Slightly Bonkers: Simon Bridges Plays To His Base.
    Would You Buy A Used Propaganda Video From This Man? Bridges and the National Party’s strategists have discovered that the ideas and attitudes considered acceptable by today’s editors and journalists are no longer enforceable. The rise and rise of the Internet and the social media platforms it spawned means that ...
    7 days ago
  • Asking for food
    There is plenty of evidence of the way the business mentality has permeated every level of society since the recrudescence of market liberalism 35 years ago. You only need to think of how citizens in need of help from their government, their state, their country, are now routinely described as ...
    Opposable ThumbBy Unknown
    7 days ago
  • Forty years of change in the jobs Kiwi do and the places they call home
    John MacCormick Over the last 40 years, New Zealanders – and people in other countries – have experienced big changes in the jobs they do and where they live and work. These changes include: a decline in manufacturing jobs an increase in jobs in ‘information-intensive’ industries (which are better paid ...
    SciBlogsBy Guest Author
    7 days ago
  • Protecting Fresh Waterways in Aotearoa/NZ: The Strong Public Health Case
    Nick Wilson, Leah Grout, Mereana Wilson, Anja Mizdrak, Phil Shoemack, Michael Baker Protecting waterways has the benefits of: (1) protecting water from hazardous microbes; (2) minimising cancer risk and other problems from nitrates in water; (3) avoiding algal blooms that are hazardous to health; (4) protecting mahinga kai uses (cultural ...
    SciBlogsBy Public Health Expert
    1 week ago
  • Massey University triggered to rebrand
    by The Council of Disobedient Women In a press release today Massey University announced it has decided to rebrand and reorientate after struggling to be a University for grown-ups. For some time the University has wanted to be a safe play space for wee-woke-misogynists who have been really badly triggered ...
    RedlineBy Daphna
    1 week ago
  • Swinson backing calls for a second referendum (again)
    After a brief dalliance with 'hard Revoke' it looks like the Lib Dems are changing ground on on Brexit, with leader Jo Swinson reverting to calling for a second referendum on Johnson's deal.The party has tabled an amendment to the Queen’s speech requesting that any deal brought back from Brussels ...
    1 week ago
  • An odious bill
    The government has decided that someone has done Something Bad. But despite their belief, there seems to be no evidence that they have actually broken the law. So the government's solution is to pass a retrospective law allowing them to be punished anyway, on a lower standard of proof. If ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • National is now the party of climate arson
    So, Judith Collins has done a Facebook rant about climate change, peddling the same shit National has been shovelling for the past twenty years: the impacts are overstated, there's no need to do anything about it, and its too hard anyway (oh, and its so unfair that people who peddle ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • The environmental footprint of electric versus fossil car
    Climate Explained is a collaboration between The Conversation, Stuff and the New Zealand Science Media Centre to answer your questions about climate change. If you have a question you’d like an expert to answer, please send it to climate.change@stuff.co.nz There is a lot of discussion on the benefits of ...
    SciBlogsBy Guest Author
    1 week ago
  • “Manifest” by Andrew Bird – A Song For The Times.
    I came across this song quite by accident. If it isn't one of Greta Thunberg's favourites - it should be.Video courtesy of YouTube.This post is exclusive to Bowalley Road. ...
    1 week ago
  • Passing the buck
    Last month, NZDF's shoddy coverup of what it knew about civilian casualties in Operation Burnham began to fall apart, with the revelation that a report on the matter, which NZDF claimed not to have, had been sitting in an NZDF safe for the past nine years. Yesterday, the man responsible ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • India a major player in Earth observation satellites
    While many imagine that countries like the USA and Europe dominate space activities, in fact India is now a major player on this stage. It launches satellites for its own purposes and also commercially, and has constellations orbiting our planet and returning data of vital importance to that nation in ...
    SciBlogsBy Duncan Steel
    1 week ago
  • The rot at the top (2).
    Thanks to a report from the Acting Inspector General of Intelligence and Security following a complaint by Nicky Hager, we have come to find out that the SIS illegally spied on Mr. Hager on behalf of the NZDF after publication of Hager’s 2011 book, Other People’s Wars. The NZDF justified ...
    KiwipoliticoBy Pablo
    1 week ago
  • Common misconceptions about “Global Warming”
    COMMON MISCONCEPTIONS ABOUT GLOBAL WARMING MYTH 1: Global temperatures are rising at a rapid, unprecedented rate. FACT: The HadCRUT3 surface temperature index, produced by the Hadley Centre of the UK Met Office and the Climate Research Unit of the University of East Anglia, shows warming to 1878, cooling to 1911, ...
    An average kiwiBy admin@averagekiwi.com
    1 week ago
  • A climate of tyranny
    For the past week, Extinction Rebellion has been peacefully protesting in London to demand action on climate change. The British government's response? Ban their protests:Police have banned Extinction Rebellion protests from continuing anywhere in London, as they moved in almost without warning to clear protesters who remained at the movement’s ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • Collins crushes climate
    An essay by Judith Collins MP reported on Carbon News yesterday seems to show an alarming shift in attitude within the National Party. Collins argues against the Zero Carbon Bill, the Paris Agreement, and downplays the magnitude of climate impacts. The Paris Agreement was adopted in December 2015 and ratified ...
    SciBlogsBy Robert McLachlan
    1 week ago
  • More disappointment
    When they were running for election, Labour promised to overhaul the Employment Relations Act and introduce fair pay agreements to set basic pay and conditions on an industry level, preventing bad employers from undercutting good ones. They followed this up by establishing a working group, which reported back in January ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • What do these mother-child studies really say about fluoridation?
    A list of indicators of bad science – many of these are found in articles promoted by anti-fluoride activists. Anti-fluoride activists have been pouring money into a scaremongering campaign warning pregnant women not to drink fluoridated water. They claim fluoride will lower the IQ of their future child. Fluoride ...
    1 week ago
  • Losing Labour’s Mills-Tone.
    Nothing Left To Say: Labour's pollster, Stephen Mills, remains swaddled-up in the comforting myths of the 1980s. As if the experience of Roger Douglas’s genuinely radical post-Muldoon policy agenda was literally a once-in-a-lifetime thing – as much as the party could possibly absorb for at least the next 50 years.MEMO ...
    1 week ago
  • Speaker: Disability and the Royal Commission of Inquiry into Historical Abuse
    The Royal Commission on abuse in care is very significant for the disability community. For many decades last century, thousands of disabled children, and adults who managed to survive, were locked away from families and communities. This was not for anything they had done, but for the perceived threat their ...
    1 week ago
  • Spain is not a democracy
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • UK Conservatives hate democracy
    With an unfair voting system, uneven electorates and an un-elected upper house, the UK's "democracy" is barely worthy of the name. But now the government wants to make it worse:The government has been accused of suppressing voters’ rights with the potential disenfranchisement of tens of thousands of people after plans ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • What is wrong with our building industry?
    Back in the 90's and early 2000's, the building industry was building leaky homes which should never have been granted consent. Now it turns out they've been building dodgy office blocks as well:New imaging technology has revealed hundreds of major buildings nationwide have defective or missing concrete or reinforcing steel. ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • Local bodies
    Local body election results were released over the weekend, to joy or despair depending on where you live. In Auckland, Phil Goff trounced John Tamihere, who is muttering darkly about running for Parliament again (but which party would want him?) Wellington is now a wholly-owned subsidiary of Weta Workshop, except ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • A future of government
      How could government evolve over the next decades? Reports of democracy’s imminent demise are greatly exaggerated.  However, satisfaction with political systems in many countries is low, so there is much to do for governments of all political stripes to improve relevance and trust. Digital technologies are seen as one ...
    SciBlogsBy Robert Hickson
    2 weeks ago
  • Speaker: Catalonia, interrupted
    Two years have now gone by since the Friday afternoon when my university-student son and I headed out of our Barcelona flat to a nearby primary school, designated as a polling station for the vote that was to be held the following Sunday: the referendum on Catalonia’s independence from Spain ...
    2 weeks ago
  • Sage Decisions Unwisely Over-Ruled.
    Overruled: The joint decision of Finance Minister, Grant Robertson (Labour) and his Associate Minister, David Parker (Labour) arguably the two most powerful ministers in Jacinda Ardern’s government, to grant OceanaGold the consents which Land Information Minister, Eugenie Sage (Greens) had earlier denied them, offers bitter proof of how hard fighting ...
    2 weeks ago
  • Government may ban voting in effort to get more people to do it
    More than double the number of people who will vote in this year’s local body elections have tried marijuana or urinated somewhere they shouldn’t have. As local elections look set for the lowest turnout in decades, with many regions falling well short of 40%, the Government is exploring a number ...
    The CivilianBy admin
    2 weeks ago
  • Woman: Deleted.
    A Statement on Abortion Law Reform by the Council of Disobedient Women   On the eve of bringing an end to antiquated, anti-women abortion laws Green MP Jan Logie intends to write women out of the Bill. With a stroke of the pen, the woke are aiming for total erasure ...
    RedlineBy Daphna
    2 weeks ago
  • The Hollowest of Men Ride Again… SURPRISE!
    Musings continue apace about “the experienced businessman!” soon to be taking up a National Party MP position. Or to be more accurate, being parachuted into a seat to shut down their former MP Jamie-Lee Ross, who despite his own shortcomings shed at least some more light on the inner workings ...
    exhALANtBy exhalantblog
    2 weeks ago
  • Barbaric
    The Ugandan government wants to murder gay people:Uganda has announced plans to impose the death penalty on homosexuals. The bill, colloquially known as “Kill the Gays” in Uganda, was nullified five years ago on a technicality, but the government said on Thursday it plans to resurrect it within weeks. The ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    2 weeks ago
  • Is this study legit? 5 questions to ask when reading news stories of medical research
    Hassan Vally, La Trobe University Who doesn’t want to know if drinking that second or third cup of coffee a day will improve your memory, or if sleeping too much increases your risk of a heart attack? We’re invested in staying healthy and many of us are interested in reading ...
    SciBlogsBy Guest Author
    2 weeks ago
  • Fighting Monsters.
    Freedom Of Speech? The Säuberung (cleansing by fire) was the work of the German Student Union which, on 10 May 1933, under the watchful eye of the Nazi Reichminister for Propaganda, Joseph Goebbels, consigned 25,000 books to the flames in a ritual exorcism of “un-German thought”. According to the logic of the ...
    2 weeks ago
  • The next wave of kaupapa Māori politics: its constitutional, it must be.
      “There can be no such thing as kaupapa Māori political parties or politics in Aotearoa” (Willie Jackson, Labour Party (2017). Māori TV, General/List Election Special) I begin with that claim because at the time, I was confounded at first that it fell out of Willie Jackson’s mouth, and then ...
    EllipsisterBy Ellipsister
    2 weeks ago
  • Night lights of NZ from orbit
    New Zealand has prided itself for decades with regard to its lack of pollution, and all will be aware that the ‘100% Pure New Zealand‘ meme is under threat through land, water and air pollution of various causes. There is another type of contamination that the country also faces: light ...
    SciBlogsBy Duncan Steel
    2 weeks ago
  • Reporters deliver uplifting news to fleeing Japanese residents: they won’t miss any rugby
    New Zealand’s media is doing its part in Japan, reassuring those in the path of the storm that they won’t miss any rugby while away from their flooded homes. New Zealand sports reporters stationed in Japan for the Rugby World Cup have had the rare and heartwarming opportunity to inform ...
    The CivilianBy admin
    2 weeks ago
  • Government in contentious discussions about whether to put surplus on red or black
    Regional Development Minister Shane Jones is the only Cabinet member in favour of putting it all on green. As Finance Minister Grant Robertson finds himself with an enormous $7.5 billion surplus, the Government has begun intense, at times contentious conversations about whether to put the money on red or black at ...
    The CivilianBy admin
    2 weeks ago
  • Jordanian teachers’ successful strike has lessons for here
    by Susanne Kemp At the start of September close to 100,000 school teachers went on strike in Jordan.  They demanded a 50% pay rise.  A pay rise actually agreed to by the regime back in 2014. In early October, however, in the face of government repression and threats, the teachers’ ...
    RedlineBy Admin
    2 weeks ago

  • More homes where they are needed
    More houses for homeless New Zealanders are being opened today in Tauranga by Associate Housing Minister Kris Faafoi. Six 2-bedroom quality units are being opened at 878 Cameron Road by Minister Faafoi and Accessible Properties, a local Community Housing Provider (CHP). Accessible Properties now provides more than 1,700 community housing ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    51 mins ago
  • Minister of Finance and Sport and Recreation to visit Japan and Vietnam
    Finance Minister Grant Robertson departs tomorrow for events and meetings in Japan and Vietnam.  While in Japan, he will discuss economic and fiscal issues including meeting with the Minister of Finance, Taro Aso, and Minister of Economic and Fiscal Policy, Yasutoshi Nishimura. He will meet with the Minister of Education, ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    15 hours ago
  • Dashboard tracks housing progress
    The Government’s Housing Dashboard released today confirms record numbers of state houses are under construction and shows the Government build programme is gaining momentum.  “After nine years of inaction, and a hands-off attitude from the previous government we’re starting to see things move in the right direction for housing,” says ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    16 hours ago
  • Ministerial Statement on the International Convention Centre fire
    Mr Speaker, I wish to make a ministerial statement relating to the Auckland fire. The Government is closely monitoring the situation with the fire at the NZ International Convention Centre and is thankful that everyone is now safe. Firefighters are doing an incredible job managing the fire and bringing it ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    18 hours ago
  • Government invests in Te Reo, environmental data research
    The Government is investing in ambitious research that will digitise Te Reo, grow the low-carbon protein efficient aquaculture industry, help interpret environmental trends, and large data sets says Research, Science and Innovation Minister Megan Woods. The four projects range from teaching Siri to speak Te Reo to crunching large environmental ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    23 hours ago
  • Government announces next steps as part of a comprehensive plan to fix skills gap
    A new education-to-employment brokerage service to strengthen connections between local employers and schools. Funding for more trades focused ‘speed-dating’ events to connect schools with employers. Promotional campaign to raise profile of vocational education. The Government is taking action to increase the number of young people taking up vocational education and ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 day ago
  • Corrections Amendment Bill passes third reading
    A Bill to improve prison security and ensure the fair, safe, and humane treatment of people in prison while upholding public safety has passed its third reading. Corrections Minister Kelvin Davis says the Corrections Amendment Bill makes a number of changes to ensure the Corrections Act 2004 is fit for ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • Ngāi Tahu CEO appointed to NZ-China Council
    Minister for Māori Development, Nanaia Mahuta, has selected Arihia Bennett MNZM, Chief Executive Officer of Te Rūnanga o Ngāi Tahu, as the Te Puni Kōkiri appointed representative on the New Zealand-China Council. The New Zealand-China Council (the Council) was established in 2012 as a New Zealand led and funded organisation ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • Southern Response claims move to EQC
    Responsibility for processing the small number of Southern Response claims still to be settled will be transferred to EQC by the end of the year. “As claim numbers reduce, it no longer makes sense for the Crown to have two organisations processing the remaining Canterbury claims,” Grant Robertson says. “Since ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • Bowel screening starts in Whanganui
    Health Minister David Clark is encouraging Whanganui residents to take up the opportunity for free bowel screening, which can detect cancer early when it’s easier to treat.   Over the next two years 12,000 Whanganui locals, aged 60 to 74 will be invited to participate in the National Bowel Screening ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • Pacific Peoples Minister to attend Our Ocean Conference in Norway
    Minister for Pacific Peoples Aupito William Sio, heads to Oslo today to represent New Zealand at the sixth Our Ocean Conference, which is being hosted by the Norwegian Government from the 23-24 October. “The Our Ocean Conference mobilises real action on issues like marine plastic pollution and the impacts of ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Government announces 27 percent increase in Trades Academy places
    Two secondary-school initiatives are being expanded as part of the Government’s plan to see more young New Zealanders take up a trade to help close the skills gap.   This includes the largest single increase in Trades Academy places in recent years. Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern and Education Minister Chris ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Speech to the New Zealand Institute of International Affairs, Pacific Futures Conference: Connection...
    Session 4: Pacific Connectivity – Youth, Media and New Opportunities   Kia ora tatou katoa and Warm Pacific greetings to one and all. Representatives of Tainui, the local people of the land, or manawhenua – the indigenous peoples of this area – have welcomed you this morning in accordance with ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Methane reducing cattle feed one step closer
    The Government today announced its support for a project that could substantially reduce agricultural greenhouse gas emissions from cattle. The announcement was made as part of Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern’s and Agriculture Minister Damien O’Connor’s visit to Nelson’s Cawthron Aquaculture Park. The Cawthron Institute will receive $100,000 from the Government’s ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Bill to refresh superannuation system passes first reading
    Social Development Minister Carmel Sepuloni has welcomed the first reading of the New Zealand Superannuation and Veteran’s Pension Legislation Amendment Bill. “Every New Zealander has a stake in New Zealand Superannuation and Veteran’s Pension,” says Carmel Sepuloni. “They are our most common form of social assistance – nearly 800,000 New ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Government announces next steps in fight against measles
    Babies in Auckland aged six months and over can receive a free vaccination and children will all have access to vaccines, Associate Minister of Health Julie Anne Genter announced today at Papatoetoe High School.   The move comes as part of Government efforts to step up the fight against measles. ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Speech to the New Zealand Institute of International Affairs, Pacific Futures: Connections, Identity...
    ***Check against delivery*** Good morning. It is a pleasure to be here, and to have the honour of opening this important conference on behalf of the New Zealand Institute of International Affairs. Let us take the opportunity to acknowledge all the people who have helped make today possible, including our special ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Police trial new response to high risk events
    Police Minister Stuart Nash says the safety of frontline officers and members of the public will be the focus of a new trial of specialist Police response teams in three of our largest urban centres. Police have this morning released details of an initiative to be trialled in Counties Manukau, ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • New awards celebrate fisheries sustainability
    The Minister of Fisheries is calling for entries for a new public award to celebrate innovation in our seafood sector. “I have established the Seafood Sustainability Awards to recognise and celebrate those throughout industry, tangata whenua and communities who demonstrate outstanding dedication and innovation towards the sustainability of New Zealand’s ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • More progress for women and we can do more
    Minister for Women Julie Anne Genter welcomes leaders in the private sector taking action on closing their gender pay gaps to ensure a fairer workplace for all New Zealanders. Ms Genter today launched a new report, Addressing the gender pay gap and driving women’s representation in senior leadership, from the Champions for ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Proposals to curb environmental damage help our coasts and the oceans
    Government Ministers today welcomed the release of a marine environment report highlighting the four key issues affecting our oceans, estuaries and coastlines.  The release underlines the importance of government proposals to combat climate pollution, ensure clean freshwater, protect biodiversity, make land use more sustainable, and reduce waste and plastic.    Environment ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • New mental health facility for Waikato
    The Government has approved funding for a new acute mental health facility for Waikato which will provide better care and support to people with mental health and addiction issues. Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern and Health Minister Dr David Clark announced the $100 million project to replace the aging Henry Rongomau ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • 500 new te reo Māori champions in our classrooms
    The Government is making progress on its goal to integrate te reo Māori into education by 2025, with over 500 teachers and support staff already graduating from Te Ahu o te Reo Māori,  Associate Education Minister Kelvin Davis announced today. Kelvin Davis made the announcement at an awards ceremony in Waikanae today, for ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • Minister James Shaw welcomes 2018 Census first release
    Statistics Minister James Shaw has welcomed the first release of 2018 Census data. The first release of data today, 23 September, includes key data on population, regional growth, the number of homes and the size of different ethnic groups in New Zealand. Data from the 2018 Census will support the ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • Driving transparency, ethics and accountability in government use of algorithms
    Minister for Statistics James Shaw today announced a public consultation on a proposed algorithm charter for government agencies. The charter has been developed by the Government Chief Data Steward in response to growing calls for more transparency in government use of data. Computer algorithms – procedures or formulas for solving ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • New Zealand and the Netherlands working together on climate change
    Agriculture Minister Damien O’Connor, Climate Change Minister James Shaw and visiting Dutch Prime Minister Mark Rutte co-hosted a business roundtable in Auckland this morning focused on working together to address climate change.  “The Netherlands is an important partner for New Zealand. We share a strong agricultural history. Sustainable agribusiness and ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • Protecting fairness for workers and businesses
    The Government is taking action to build an inclusive economy where more of us receive our fair share at work and businesses can compete on great products and services, not undercutting wages and conditions, Immigration and Workplace Relations and Safety Minister Iain Lees-Galloway says. Two consultations launched today seek feedback ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • Indigenous Freshwater Fish Bill Passes
    The future for New Zealand’s threatened indigenous freshwater fish looks brighter with the passing of the Conservation (Indigenous Freshwater Fish) Amendment Bill in Parliament today said Minister of Conservation, Eugenie Sage. “Until now, our freshwater fish legislation has been 20 years out of date. We have lacked effective tools to ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Kiwis to take part in world’s biggest earthquake drill
    At 1.30pm tomorrow, hundreds of thousands of Kiwis will join about 65 million people around the globe in ShakeOut, the world’s biggest earthquake drill. The annual drill is to remind people of the right action to take during an earthquake which is to Drop, Cover, Hold, and to practise their ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Rising wages and low inflation supporting Kiwis
    Kiwis are benefiting from higher wage growth and low inflation under the Coalition Government. Stats NZ data out today shows the rise in the cost of living remains low, as annual Consumers Price Index (CPI) inflation fell to 1.5% in September from 1.7% in June. “The low inflation comes as ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • NZ economy strong amid global headwinds
    New Zealand’s economic strength and resilience has been recognised in a major update on the state of the global economy. The IMF’s latest World Economic Outlook released overnight shows a reduced global growth forecast over the next two years as issues like the US-China trade war and Brexit take hold. ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Keeping New Zealanders safer with better counter-terrorism laws
    Justice Minister Andrew Little has today introduced a new Bill to prevent terrorism and support the de-radicalisation of New Zealanders returning from overseas. The Terrorism Suppression (Control Orders) Bill gives the New Zealand Police the ability to apply to the High Court to impose control orders on New Zealanders who ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Improved succession and dispute resolution core of Ture Whenua changes
    A Bill that proposes targeted changes to simplify the processes for Māori land owners when engaging with the Māori Land Court has had its First Reading today. “The approach taken by the Government is to ensure that the protection of Māori land remains a priority as we seek to improve ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Speech to CTU Biennial Conference
    Let me first thank all the new unionists and members in the room. There is nothing more important to improving people’s working lives than people making the decision to care, to get on board and help, to take up the reins and get involved. Congratulations to you. You bring the ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Minister ensures continued Whenuapai flight operations
    Minister of Defence Ron Mark has signed a certificate exempting the activity of engine testing at Whenuapai Airbase from the Resource Management Act 1991. The Act gives the Minister of Defence the power to exempt activities for the purposes of national security.  The certificate will mean the recent Environment Court ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • NZ joins Coalition of Finance Ministers for Climate Action
    Finance Minister Grant Robertson has announced New Zealand will join the Coalition of Finance Ministers for Climate Action while attending APEC meetings in Chile. The objective of the 39 member Coalition is to share information and promote action to tackle climate change. It was formed in April this year, in ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Feedback Sought – Section 71 – Lyttelton Parking
    Feedback sought– Lyttelton commercial zone parking  The Associate Minister for Greater Christchurch Regeneration, Poto Williams, is seeking feedback on a proposal to remove on-site car parking requirements for new developments in the Lyttelton commercial zone.  The proposal, by Christchurch City Council, asks that powers under section 71 of the Greater ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Feedback Sought – Section 71 – Hagley Oval
    Hon Minister Poto Williams Associate Minister for Greater Christchurch Regeneration   MEDIA STATEMENT       Tuesday 15 October 2019 Feedback sought – Hagley Oval The Associate Minister for Greater Christchurch Regeneration, Poto Williams, is seeking feedback on a proposal about Hagley Oval. The proposal was developed by Regenerate Christchurch ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • CTU speech – DPM
    Ladies and gentlemen, NZCTU President Richard Wagstaff, members of respective unions – thank you for the invitation to speak to you today. This might be preaching to the choir, but the importance of trade unions in New Zealand’s historical arch is difficult to understate. And it is my belief that ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Police Association Annual Conference
    "Let’s start by acknowledging that it has been a huge year. " Police Association Annual Conference James Cook Grand Chancellor Hotel Wellington Nau mai, haere mai. Tēnā koutou, tēnā koutou, ka nui te mihi, ki a koutou katoa. President of the Police Association, Chris Cahill; Members of the Association and ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago