web analytics

Open mike 07/05/2022

Written By: - Date published: 6:00 am, May 7th, 2022 - 85 comments
Categories: open mike - Tags:


Open mike is your post.

For announcements, general discussion, whatever you choose.

The usual rules of good behaviour apply (see the Policy).

Step up to the mike …

85 comments on “Open mike 07/05/2022 ”

  1. tsmithfield 1

    From the "Whoops I did it again file." It looks like the Russians have lost another ship. This time one of their most modern frigates, the Admiral Makarov.

    Insanity has been defined as the act of doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results. First, it was the Moskva which came within range of Ukrainian missiles. Then it was two patrol boats close to shore taken out by a Ukrainian drone. And, again, the Russians sent the Makarov close to shore to a similar location within the range of Ukrainian neptune missiles again. I wonder if they will keep up the insanity and send another one close to shore.

    Thus far, the verified toll against the Russian navy in the Black Sea has been:

    1 x landing ship, 2 x patrol boats, 1 x Cruiser, 1x frigate.

    All this from a country that doesn't have a navy.

  2. Ad 2

    Is Sinn Fein getting the majority in the Northern Ireland Parliament the equivalent of the Maori Party getting the majority in the New Zealand Parliament?

    Local elections 2022: Tories lose hundreds of seats to Labour and Lib Dems; Sinn Féin set to become largest party in NI elections – live (theguardian.com)

    There's some real fun in some of these results today.

    • Kiwijoker 2.1

      The bloody people have stolen our election!

    • Corey Humm 2.2

      Not unless the Maori party has a murderous, bank robbing military wing.

      Northern Ireland's two biggest parties Sin Fein and the equally murderous DUP had military wings.

      Whoever wins I'll doubt theyll win a majority more likely a plurality but whoever wins .. I hope there's calm and understanding not bloodshed.

  3. DB Brown 3

    OK. The gist of this post is simple. If we do not add water capturing earthworks to our catchments we can expect to be left high and dry. No groundwater flow = no hydro power.

    I'm quite sick of repeating myself on this, but I will continue. Also, TOLD YOU SO.

    https://www.stuff.co.nz/environment/climate-news/128551741/drought-conditions-threaten-southlands-power-supply

    The rain cycle used to be that that lost to sea was equivalent to that gained from rain. Now the rains arrive less frequently, and more severely. That lost to sea is continuously increasing. That captured on land is continuously decreasing. It is a compounding problem that arrived very fast since predictions made only a few years back.

    How hard is it to admit we can't manage land properly, and correct it.

    Get this in your thick government heads or we shall certainly face disaster the likes of which we are utterly unprepared for.

    And have a great weekend, HA!

    • weka 3.1

      NZ is so complacent about water. We think it's always going to be there no matter what we do. This is some kind of stupid really, given we have the science and history to understand the dynamics you are referring to.

  4. Ad 4

    For French specialists: does unifying the French left into a bloc give Melenchon a shot at being Prime Minister?

    France: Socialist Party joins leftist coalition against President Emmanuel Macron | News | DW | 06.05.2022

    • Sabine 4.1

      Sadly the left in france will splinter at some time again, so i guess no.

    • Ghostwhowalksnz 4.2

      Macrons party is also forming a coalition with other centre right parties too

      Insoumise only strong in the Paris region and 2 other low population places .

      I dont think forming an election alliance committs them to a parliamentary bloc after the election

  5. Anne 5

    Yeah, I know, they're committing crimes but good on them.

    https://www.1news.co.nz/2022/05/07/climate-protest-group-deflating-auckland-tyres-first-action-in-new-wave/

    I live in a part of Auckland where they are prevalent. Nothing incenses me more than SUVs dominating the streets, the parking lots and generally making life miserable for other road users – not to mention the environmental damage.

    • JanM 5.1

      Yes those awful SUVs are really the ultimate in self-centred stupidity. They make driving for others risky and unpleasant. They take up too much space and reduce visibility . Worse, it seems from the way drivers often use them, their main purpose is to bully others by tail-gating and dangerous exits from side streets etc.. However, I don't think letting down tyres is a good idea – likely to make them worse!

      • Robert Guyton 5.1.1

        How might it make them worse, Jan?

      • Shanreagh 5.1.2

        Worse, it seems from the way drivers often use them, their main purpose is to bully others by tail-gating and dangerous exits from side streets etc..

        I agree. thoroughly informal and anecdotal surveys while travelling up and back to Otaki regularly indicate that they are:

        • most likely to tail-gate
        • most likely not to use the 'merge like a zip' concept
        • least likely to acknowledge the good manners of other drivers in letting them in
        • least likely to obey the sometimes very slow speed limits, thus kicking up stones for others, while the new Expressway is being built.
        • most likely to have tyres that are unsuitable for highway driving, I may be wrong but I had thought that using the incorrect tyres adds to wear and tear on highways and is less fuel efficient.

        Then don't get me started on my partner's view that they are penis extensions for inadequate males…he puzzles over the irony of making a penis extension the 'family' car so the female partner has to collect children from city based sport, activities driving these vehicles.

      • Mike the Lefty 5.1.3

        I am a driver who has worked on the roads for over 26 years. My observations are that there are two main types of people on the road who don't care a monkeys about safety, courtesy, respect for road rules and just plain commonsense – those who drive black cars and those who drive large overpowered SUVs.

    • Shanreagh 5.2

      I quite agree. What amazed me, watching as I did the whole of the convoy arriving in Wellington for the protest, was how many of these utes/SUVs were in it driven mainly by the scowling demographic that I believe is behind the 'pretty communist' and other misogynistic thoughts/ideas.

      Then I look at the tradies I use with their fit for purpose sign written trade vehicles that are much more practical than utes with low canopies. They have no place in towns and cities.

      My farmer bro in law believes in many lowland farms they have no place either. On his lowland Southland farm he used a combo of tractor and ancient old station wagons for all his farming ops. Yet the people who rent most of the land as a dairy run-off to a man, and they mostly are all men, need SUVs, Utes to work on the same land. Most have legs just painted on as well.

      Vanity not need accounts for much of the growth of Utes/SUVs.

      In the Wellington they park right on the street corners and to see the road around them you need to get right out sometimes into the face of oncoming traffic.

      Perhaps they could blitz just with the leaflets rather than letting down the tyres tho' I do/did snicker at the thought of the scowling ones being forced to deal with a flat tyre.

      • Rosemary McDonald 5.2.1

        … watching as I did the whole of the convoy arriving in Wellington for the protest, was how many of these utes/SUVs were in it driven mainly by the scowling demographic…

        So. Those activists were not concealing their faces? Not hiding behind anonymity or a silly pseudonym? For "security reasons" ?

        Your anti-SUV saboteurs lack the courage of their convictions. Cowards.

        • Shanreagh 5.2.1.1

          I don't understand this at all so whatever point you are making is lost on me.

          I was able to watch the arrival in slow motion as it were and did not expect to see masked people in their cars.

          I made comment at the time about these surly Ute drivers in the convoy, usually by themselves, a few with an equally surly mate. Of course at that stage we thought they were all going to make a protest, make a point then away again. As it is now whatever point they were making, and it become very difficult to find a common cause, is remembered only by a riot, fires.

          I have no idea whether those letting tyres down were masked, or had a pseudonym.

          And still the PM is subjected to macho posturing and innuendo.

          • Rosemary McDonald 5.2.1.1.1

            I have no idea whether those letting tyres down were masked, or had a pseudonym.

            You didn't actually read the article Anne linked to? Then of course you would not have understood what I was referring to.

            You decided to bring up the Freedom protest and you chose comment on the scowling ute/SUV drivers you observed as these anti-mandate activists rolled into Wellington. Clearly you could see their faces.

            I know some of those people. All are fully committed to the mission, and none would use a false name or hide behind a stupid sounding organisation. Up front and in your face. At least you know who you are dealing with..or perhaps you prefer…

            …the activists who let the SUV tyres down who were too cowardly to do so out in the open, and hid behind silly names.

            Anonymous activism? Worthless.

            (Oh, an as an aside…very seldom, as you will have noticed, did any of the 'river of filth' wear medical masks or face coverings of any kind. 'Filth' that they were.

            Only on that last day did there suddenly appear men wearing various full face masks, designed more to conceal their identity rather than protect against viruses or police pepper spray. These were the guys filmed near the first tent that caught fire. No one recalled seeing these guys in the Freedom Village until that morning. Funny that.)

            • Shanreagh 5.2.1.1.1.1

              I did read the article.

              My comment built on the SUV part. I was amazed by the number of SUV/Utes etc in the convoy. The demographic riding around in Utes/SUVs here in Wellington is much of the same, scowling late 30s/40s males. So I was surprised to see them in the convoy until I realised that they were the anti PM brigade/anti women, rather than strictly anti vax, coming along – the ones that had the 'pretty little communist' type placards in the Groundswell convoys.

              So good on them up in Auckland. They have got publicity and they may get a conversation going.

              The depth of feeling about vehicles that are unsuitable for city/town traffic is not one that country dwellers will be really aware of. They make getting around much more difficult as sight lines are impeded for other traffic and pedestrians.

              So I'm not interested in masks except to studiously wear one, respect others who do, avoid situations or people who do not. I am not interested in who did what in the protest.

              In fact the protest and the whole anti vax is the stuff of irrelevance and yawn making to me, now. If I think about the protest at all it is to wonder how NZ got caught up in manufactured protests from overseas and I sometimes indulge in idle speculation about the finances, and 'dark' people behind it. We needed a public health response to a pandemic. We got one. The majority went along with it, some did not.

              We have to deal with climate change, it is with us forever. Drawing attention to it is what the SUV protestors and the ones at the Southland coal mine are doing, on my behalf, as a 'ginger' group.

              • Rosemary McDonald

                I realised that they were the anti PM brigade/anti women, rather than strictly anti vax, coming along – the ones that had the 'pretty little communist' type placards in the Groundswell convoys. Evidence of this?

                …to wonder how NZ got caught up in manufactured protests from overseas err…you do realize that the Tyre Extinguishers are a proud overseas organisation?

                How is it that its acceptable for Kiwis to join in protest actions that originate overseas, such as Black Lives Matter, Me Too, Extinction Rebellion, Greenpeace etc…but not in protest action that happens to also have activists in other countries… that is centered around draconian government laws that effectively force people to take an experimental pharmaceutical product with known performance issues and very real adverse effects for far too many people?

                For a disease that failed to reach the projected case fatality rates forecast by the modellers?

                Closing our borders helped reduce our case load and fatality rates…the so called 'vaccines'…not so much. Double and triple jabbed folk are getting infected at a higher rate than the unvaccinated. An awful lot are still getting sick and still ending up in hospital…at rates not much lower that us filthy unvaxxed, and people jabbed and unjabbed, are still dying with, but not necessarily of Covid.

                A Health Ministry, truly committed to Medical Science, would have initiated a study comparing outcomes between eligible unvaccinated and eligible vaccinated. Like the Pfizer Trial… but this time doing an actual Long Term study.

                Good that the whole thing is an irrelevance to you now…for some of us the unjustified discrimination still impacts our lives, every day.

    • Ross 5.3

      Yeah, I know, they're committing crimes but good on them.

      Protestors taking such action clearly don't have much between their ears.

      We've never had so many EVs in New Zealand or around the world. Yet climate change continues to worsen. The more EVs we buy, the worse climate change gets!

      Deflating the tyres of SUVs will have zero effect on climate change, as will buying an EV. We need better protestors.

      https://www.carsguide.com.au/ev/advice/how-many-electric-cars-are-there-in-the-world-85961

  6. pat 6

    Interesting further information from the author of a link I posted yesterday….

    "We owe thanks to Interest.co. for journalistic bravery.

    This article was sent to Newsroom – no acknowledgement, not even a ' no thanks'.

    It was sent to Kim Hill, Kathryn Ryan, Bryan Crump and Jim Mora – collectively the journalism end of RNZ. I'm picking there will be no reply, and no coverage (will edit this post should that happen).

    My question to all those folk, is this: If this article contains the truth of our predicament (rebuttal invited); how do we describe journalism which avoids the topic? What, indeed, is the difference between silence and falsehood-peddling?"

    https://www.interest.co.nz/public-policy/115678/murray-grimwood-outlines-why-and-how-be-believes-our-relationship-and

  7. weka 7

    Thought experiment: what would happen if NZ grew most of its own food? Not coffee or chocolate or vanilla, but our staples and seasonal produce. We could still export what we we could produce sustainably and regeneratively that we didn’t need. For the experiment assume that enough people were ok with this because they understood the urgency of climate action, and food security, so it didn’t prompt political outrage. Eg maybe we’d had a year of many crop failures globally.

    are the issues here mainly trade agreements? Perceptions of government policies interference?

    • pat 7.1

      We already do….around 20% of food products are imported, though that may be increasing.

      https://www.infometrics.co.nz/article/2020-03-nz-continues-to-produce-and-import-food-so-theres-no-need-to-panic-buy

    • Belladonna 7.2

      I don't think that it's predominantly trade agreements or government policies preventing people eating home-grown. It's that other countries grow X crops cheaper/better and the economics of shipping them here is viable. And that Kiwis want to eat X crops.

      For example, while it's technically possible to grow bananas in NZ (Far North) it's not an ideal climate for them. While Queensland and/or Fiji are ideal banana-growing climates. [And, while Fiji may have cheaper labour, I don't think Australia does – so that's not necessarily a factor]

      Growing crops in ideal climates is both quicker and cheaper – and they often taste better (Italian tinned tomatoes are way tastier than kiwi ones). And, while there is a cost of shipping them to NZ – it clearly doesn't outweigh the cost of growing them here.

      NZ could live on what we grow. But our choices at the supermarket/greengrocer would be a lot more limited; and probably more expensive (NZ olive oil is way more expensive than Italian, for example)

      It's not just the fancy flavourings. Think rice, wheat flour (NZ wheat isn't good for baking), sugar, etc.

      • Rosemary McDonald 7.2.1

        …while it's technically possible to grow bananas in NZ (Far North) it's not an ideal climate for them … Commercial banana growing is a thing up here. Bonza

        Smaller fruit than the inferior tasting Cavendish variety, the things grow like weeds up here. Our Misi Luki plants have been in for 18 months, and each of the original three plants have large bunches of fruit. Other than removing the excess daughters, (which transplant really well) they get next to no attention. I have papaya trees, (grown from seed) and I'm just beginning to cover them with frost cloth on cold nights. Some commercial blueberry growers up here (often grown in high gro tunnels) are pulling out the blueberries and planting papaya.

        We also have coffee growing up here….so its not all avos and citrus.

        Much of the produce is sold at Farmers Markets…these guys are not big enough to take on the supermarket duopoly in order to get a fair price.

        Bananas grow and fruit all over the show…Whanganui, Gisborne.smiley

        Climate change…if we can't beat it…

        • Belladonna 7.2.1.1

          Well, Rosemary – you live and learn!

          I had no idea that commercial banana plantations were a thing up north.

          How about sugar cane? IIRC it needs roughly the same climate as bananas – but it may need a bigger area in order to be commercially viable.

          • Robert Guyton 7.2.1.1.1

            I have bananas and sugar cane growing in Riverton 🙂

            • Belladonna 7.2.1.1.1.1

              Good Lord! Outdoors? Or in some form of climate control?

              I'd have thought that frost would be a killer for both of them.

              • Robert Guyton

                In a big tunnel house and out of doors as well. Frost certainly can set them back 🙂 but we have few if any frosts (we're southern but we're coastal). My out of door bananas are Cook Island plantains which are pretty hardy. I have misiluki (Samoan bananas) and others growing in the tunnel house.Thai ginger (galangal) grows readily outside here and has done for many years. Under the cover of plastic, it booms! I have Amarillo fruiting under cover. The plants are 3 or 4 metres tall. Lemons and grapefruit. Fruiting cherry guava, fig, Elephant grass, 5 metres tall (higher than an elephants eye 🙂 Brugmansias throughout the garden. Many of these plants look "scrappy" during the winter months, but bounce back strongly.

                • Belladonna

                  That is so cool. I'd love to see it!

                  • Robert Guyton

                    You are most welcome to visit. If you are unable to do so, we have a short-film by Happen Films about to be released – I'll let you know when. As well, there is this: An invitation for wildness – our first film about our forest-garden, you might enjoy 🙂

                  • Ad

                    It's worth it.

      • weka 7.2.2

        so there would be no international pressure if a NZ government tried to transition us to eating mostly from what we grow ourselves?

        • Belladonna 7.2.2.1

          Well, you'd have to define how you'd envisage the 'government transition'.

          If they use tariffs to make imported goods more expensive, then you'd fall foul of a whole host of international trade treaties (nuking NZ export trade).

          If you give NZ goods a tax cut (e.g. no GST on NZ produce) then I think you run foul of the trade treaties again.

          If they require local produce to be sold at a reasonable mark-up (thinking milk & cheese, NZ lamb, etc here) then I *think* they'd be OK with trade treaties (pretty sure France do this…)

          If they require mandatory food labelling (and are very specific about what qualifies as NZ produce) – then there's no comeback.

          If they run advertising campaigns (hopefully better ones than the disastrous 3 waters) and 3rd party organisations campaign for NZ produce to be promoted – and it becomes patriotic to buy Kiwi – then again no comeback. That's consumer choice.

          Remember, that NZ is also vulnerable to the need to export in order to afford imports.

          And that many essentials, sugar, rice, etc. are either not grown in NZ or will never be grown in the quantities that Kiwi consumers want them.

        • Belladonna 7.2.2.2

          Just come across this list of countries which are self-sufficient in food (of course some continue to import – but they don't have to).

          The only country in Europe that’s self-sufficient is France. Other countries in the exclusive club of self sufficiency: Canada, Australia, Russia, India, Argentina, Burma, Thailand, the U.S. and a few small others.

          https://www.nationalgeographic.com/culture/article/is-your-country-food-independent

          Article is from 2014 – so subject to being corrected by later-arriving information.

          There's a link in the article to a nice source map – with the relative proportions of imports (NZ at the 30% level)

          By and large it tends to be the largest countries which cross a wide latitude which are self-sufficient (wide variety of micro-climates and growing conditions). A fair split between authoritarian and democratic governments – so that's not an obvious factor.

    • Populuxe1 7.3

      You'd be cutting off revenue to a lot of developing countries that rely heavily on it.

      • KJT 7.3.1

        They may be able to get back to growing their own food on their own land, instead of it being taken for growing monocultures, for export for corporate profits, while they have to migrate in desperation to outer city shanty towns.

        Terrible!

        • Populuxe1 7.3.1.1

          That depends on the country. Assuming it isn't a totally corrupt one, you can't make infrastructure and healthcare with bananas. And in an increasingly uncertain climate future, some countries may not be able to rely exclusively on domestic agriculture, including our own.

        • Belladonna 7.3.1.2

          Subsistence farming – which is what you're talking about – with airy assumptions that developing countries will be "able to get back to growing their own food on their own land" isn't really a very attractive modern lifestyle. Especially without the technical support and infrastructure that you need foreign sales to bring in.

          No tractors built in Fiji (for example) or diesel to run them. No communications gear (so no phone or IT infrastructure). Little medical infrastructure (apart from the most basic of care), etc., etc.

          All of those are 'bought' by the export of commodities (e.g. raw sugar – and, bizarrely, bottled water, in the case of Fiji – who knew? But it it's a money-spinner for them – why take it away?).

          https://oec.world/en/profile/country/fji

          • KJT 7.3.1.2.1

            No. It is not what I'm talking about.

            But keep your simplistic assumptions.

            • Belladonna 7.3.1.2.1.1

              How about you give a real life example of a country which could "get back to growing their own food on their own land" without killing off their external trade and therefore their imports of all the things they are unable to produce.

              There have been several examples given in-thread of countries for which this would be disastrous.

              Where's your counter example?

              • KJT

                Funny that you gave Fiji as an example.. Fiji is one where locals retain ownership of their land.

                We will forget about the many places where large scale agriculture, and other resource extraction, benefits a very few, mostly offshore, profit takers, while the locals are forced into poverty and even, starvation!

                South American countries were called, banana Republics, for a reason.

                There are too many examples to count.

                We will also forget about other examples. Such as African grain farmers who lost their livilihoods after being undercut by grain imported from the West.

                Believers in the “Free trade” religion, like other believers in “Woo”, ignore the disasters it has caused. Including preventing third world countries from developing the protected internal economies that made Western countries prosperous.

                • Populuxe1

                  But are you saying Fiji wouldn't be affected though? Also you have a very strange idea of the history of economic development in the West – that prosperity mostly came off the back of centuries of feudalism and imperial conquest.

      • weka 7.3.2

        You'd be cutting off revenue to a lot of developing countries that rely heavily on it.

        Can you please give some examples?

        • Populuxe1 7.3.2.1

          Well, in our immediate vicinity, Samoa's economy is largely agricultural exports, fish, and foreign manufacturing. Fiji, which is arguably the most developed economy in the region outside Australia and New Zealand is also a major exporter of sugar cane, coconuts, cassava, rice, sweet potato, bananas, ginger, taro etc. Further afield, Ghana is heavily dependent on exporting cacao.

  8. Stephen D 8

    A sure winner for the government, taxing the company, not the individual. Put the money to helping families over the cost of living until Fair Pay agreements kick in.

    https://www.stuff.co.nz/business/opinion-analysis/128536233/why-are-we-not-discussing-a-windfall-tax

  9. joe90 9

    Gotta keep the domestic supply going.

    //

    • Ross 9.1

      What's your point, Joe?

      Here's an article from 2006 discussing the baby trade, or "reproductive market", in the US. Fewer abortions may help to make it easier, and cheaper, for couples to become parents. The gay community, in particular, could benefit from fewer abortions.

      It is entirely possible to conceive of the reproductive market in the United States as a small enclave of science. The market is irrelevant to 85% to 90% of the population—that is, to those lucky enough to conceive children the old-fashioned way. Nearly by definition, then, it shouldn’t share the traits that characterize the markets for potato chips or sneakers or even general health services. It is a niche market, one that is unlikely to expand beyond a small segment of customers. Most of these potential customers, moreover, never avail themselves of any form of treatment: Only 36% of infertile women in the United States seek medical assistance in conceiving, 15% use fertility drugs, 5.5% employ artificial insemination, and only 1% try IVF or other high-tech treatments.

      In the baby business, even private transactions can impose costs on the rest of society. Consider, for instance, the babies born to 25-year-old Teresa Anderson of Mesa, Arizona, in April 2005. Anderson was a gestational surrogate who, for $15,000, had agreed to carry a child for Enrique Moreno, a landscaper, and his 32-year-old wife, Luisa Gonzalez. To increase the chance of pregnancy, doctors transplanted five embryos into Anderson’s womb. They all survived, and Anderson subsequently bore quintuplets for the couple. When the babies arrived, the news media showed the smiling surrogate, the delighted couple, and the five relatively healthy babies. These babies, however, were extraordinarily expensive: The costs of delivery almost certainly ran to well over $400,000. Gonzalez and Moreno paid to conceive these children, but U.S. consumers—through increased insurance fees and hospital costs—are paying, too. According to one recent study, the total cost of delivering a child born through IVF ranges between $69,000 and $85,000. If the child is born to an older woman, the cost rises to between $151,000 and $223,000. The prospective parents in these cases pay for part of these costs—the IVF, the hormones, the multiple medical visits—but their fellow citizens are paying as well. (See the exhibit “What Price Babies?”)

      https://hbr.org/2006/02/where-babies-come-from-supply-and-demand-in-an-infant-marketplace

      • Ad 9.1.1

        Presumably the author is setting up a public debate between the ethical and commercial costs of adoption versus the ethical and commercial costs of aborting unborn children.

        The US movement against abortion will be seeking to push this kind of contest worldwide through the media, as distinct from the narrow band of international aid and development as they did under Bush.

        Abortion laws worldwide: In what countries is abortion legal? (nbcnews.com)

        The upcoming abortion argument contest is going to make the Trans debate look like a very, very small thing in comparison.

        • weka 9.1.1.1

          The upcoming abortion argument contest is going to make the Trans debate look like a very, very small thing in comparison.

          gee, I wonder what both those things have in common.

        • Molly 9.1.1.2

          The upcoming abortion argument contest is going to make the Trans debate look like a very, very small thing in comparison.

          I don't think so, Ad. Firstly, discussing rights for women, while reframed as a trans debate, is more of a maintaining of boundaries. However, the infiltration of institutions, companies and schools, and the negative effect on children and young people has meant that more people are getting interested in exploring past the #NoDebate edicts. That's going to take a while.

          The abortion debate has never been hampered by #NoDebate tactics, and those who want to be informed will have plenty of opportunities to do so, with articles and television broadcasts from both sides.

          It will be interesting to see on TS which of the male commentators will be able to demonstrate their knowledge of the aspects of the abortion topic.

      • joe90 9.1.2

        What's your point, Joe?

        Women aren't brood mares producing a fucking commodity to be traded.

        • weka 9.1.2.1

          useful I guess to hear it said outloud.

        • Sabine 9.1.2.2

          shh, you need to get on with times

          They are birthing bodies with unproductive uteruses that need to be put to work. And yes, quite a few people are not at all fussed by the idea that birthing bodies are nothing more then bipedal gestation units for lease and profit, to be hired and discarded at will.

          There will be a future were fertile wombs will be told by WINZ that if they need a job they could gestate a human being for a paying third party. Its like slavery but kind and inclusive.

        • Ross 9.1.2.3

          Women aren't brood mares producing a fucking commodity to be traded.

          Thats an opinion rather than fact. Adoption has been around for quite a while, and to a lesser extent surrogacy and IVF. What benefits have these brought parents-to-be and wider society? Where would we be without these options?

          • weka 9.1.2.3.1

            Thats an opinion rather than fact

            Ross, are you expressing the opinion that women are brood mares?

            • Ross 9.1.2.3.1.1

              Weka

              I was commenting on Joe’s opinion. To repeat: adoption has been around a while and to a lesser extent surrogacy and IVF. Do the existence of each of these imply or suggest that women are broodmares? I wouldn’t have thought so but you may disagree.

              Similarly, should men be allowed to sell sperm? What are the pros and cons of allowing such a transaction?

      • weka 9.1.3

        have you ever given birth Ross? Do you have *any sense of what that process involves for women, and why many of us don't want to go through it unnecessarily.

        • Sabine 9.1.3.1

          they really don't care.

          did you see this?

          https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10788221/Call-Mothers-Day-renamed-transgender-men-classified-giving-birth.html

          Can't have motherday now that 'men' give birth.

          There was a slogan a while back in regards to the violence against women. 'She is not your therapy'. I guess the woke left saw that and decided that 'She is your therapy' was the correct way to go forward.

          • weka 9.1.3.1.1

            A progressive activist has suggested Mother's Day be renamed to reflect how transgender men are now classified as giving birth.

            Norrie May-Welby, who was born a male and had gender reassignment surgery at age 28, said the term 'mother' was not exclusive to females.

            So a man is telling us to stop calling mothers mothers. Not hidden agenda there.

            Probably the most disturbing thing about that is the degree to which society (looking at you liberals) think that we should centre people with mental health distress (gender dysphoria) and base our cultural practices on what they want. And invent whole new sets of language to do that. Have we lost our goddamn minds?

            • Visubversa 9.1.3.1.1.1

              The left have had all those years of screaming "TERF" at us when we said that biological sex existed and was important. Meanwhile the right wingers in the reality based world where biological sex not only exists but functions as a weapon to control women were organising and strategising for this victory. You cannot identify out of this one kiddies – enjoy your pronouns.

            • Rosemary McDonald 9.1.3.1.1.2

              Have we lost our goddamn minds? I'm surprised you need to ask.

        • Ross 9.1.3.2

          Weka

          As has been discussed previously, abortion is not an absolute right. Similarly, people who chose (perhaps sensibly) not to be vaccinated against COVID-19 apparently didn’t have the right to choose. I imagine that losing their job and possibly their home was quite inconvenient and upsetting.

          As English author Julian Barnes once said: we can have our cake and eat it. The trouble is, we get fat.

          • weka 9.1.3.2.1

            rights are granted and taken away by society. In that sense no-one has an absolute right to anything.

            I see you ignored my point about the impact on women of unnecessary pregnancy, childbirth and post-partum.

            • Ross 9.1.3.2.1.1

              There are costs and benefits to any course of action. Your focus is on the costs while ignoring the benefits. The costs of IVF are discussed above. Some of those costs are born by taxpayers. Should that be the case? Maybe society thinks the benefits outweigh the costs.

              • Sabine

                do you consider birthing bodies to be even human?

              • Molly

                Given how little you appear know about the difference between producing a child and producing sperm – "Similarly, should men be allowed to sell sperm?", I'm trying to gauge where your level of knowledge is on this topic.

                1. a) What are the possible negative effects (physical, financial, social, psychological) of producing sperm on the male body?

                b) What are the possible negative effects (physical, financial, social, psychological) of pregnancy on the female body?

                c) Which one of these two will have an ongoing effect after production?

                "Fewer abortions may help to make it easier, and cheaper, for couples to become parents. The gay community, in particular, could benefit from fewer abortions."

                The quotes you provided specifically talk about women's bodies in production lines terms, and a child as a commodity.

                There is a conversation to be had about the provision of IVF, and adoption. If you have spent time investigating adoption you may find that regardless of the care and love provided by adoptive parents, a significant percentage of adoptees have had disrupted lives due to their emotional reaction to their adoptive status.

                But I'd be interested in hearing what you understand of the possible costs of pregnancy, just to get started.

  10. Ross 10

    Given how little you appear know

    That's never a great start to a discussion lol.

    a significant percentage of adoptees have had disrupted lives due to their emotional reaction to their adoptive status.

    Yep life isn't fair. I'm sure a significant percentage of adoptees from Ukraine have had more than disrupted lives given that both of their biological parents may be dead. We should stop the war there.

    Once you select your child, and the documents are prepared, you will be accompanied to the local court, where the adoption will be granted. There is now a 10 day appeal period following the court. It might be extended ONLY if there are serious complications, which happens extremely rarely. Then an additional 7 – 10 days is required to obtain the child’s documents. Families may choose to return to the U.S. until their adoption order is final and documents are ready. You will return to Kiev and be accompanied to the U.S. Embassy to undergo the required medical exams and receive your immigrant visa for new your child.

    What are the possible negative effects (physical, financial, social, psychological) of pregnancy on the female body?

    What are the positive effects of pregnancy on the female body?

    The quotes you provided specifically talk about women's bodies in production lines terms, and a child as a commodity.

    A woman who makes a logical and well-thought out decision to have one or more babies may be nothing more than a production line? That's fairly insulting towards women who wish to be a surrogate or to place their child for adoption. It suggests that they are incapable of making good decisions about their own body. That sort of attitude may be behind the (interim) decision to overturn Roe v Wade.

    https://www.opendooradoption.org/adoption-services/international-adoptions/ukraine/

    • Molly 10.1

      "Given how little you appear know

      That's never a great start to a discussion lol."

      Actually, it was a thinly veiled suggestion to go away and inform yourself before participating further. Sometimes it is clear that a comment is made from someone who hasn't explored the topic before submitting their reckons. This was one such time.

      Now I've seen your reply, I still don't rate it highly, because it is a simplistic – and therefore basic understanding of what is being discussed.

      "A woman who makes a logical and well-thought out decision to have one or more babies may be nothing more than a production line? That's fairly insulting towards women who wish to be a surrogate or to place their child for adoption. It suggests that they are incapable of making good decisions about their own body. That sort of attitude may be behind the (interim) decision to overturn Roe v Wade."

      That position assumes that there are no forms of coercion, or exploitation of women' bodies happening. If you know of such a place, do tell.

      If women are in a tenuous or vulnerable position, and have choices other than adoption or surrogacy, and still choose them, then I'd say that choice is fairly autonomous, but still not without harm. Given that the majority of women in commercial surrogacy are there for financial relief or in desperate circumstances – I'd say there is something else occurring other than autonomy. There are also knock on social effects – on the child, the purchasing parents, and the wider community, that need to be recognised and assessed for harm.

      But I’m game to learn of a different perspective, so have at it, what are the "positive effects of pregnancy on the female body?"

      (I know of a couple, but would be interested in seeing your list, since you seem to want to avoid any mention of the negative effects that IIRC were not limited to physical, but included social, financial, psychological.)

Leave a Comment

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

  • New Zealand Sign Language Week 2022 recognises ‘essential’ workers
    This week (9 – 15 May 2022) is New Zealand Sign Language Week (NZSL), a nationwide celebration of NZSL as an official language of New Zealand. “This year’s theme ‘New Zealand Sign Language is essential’ recognises the prominence and importance of our third official language, and draws a spotlight on ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    15 hours ago
  • Government’s Wage Subsidies support people in nearly half of NZ jobs
    The Government’s swift action to secure our economic recovery in the midst of a pandemic has seen 47 per cent of jobs in New Zealand protected by at least one of the 2021 wage subsidies, Minister for Social Development and Employment Carmel Sepuloni said. The Ministry of Social Development’s new ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    15 hours ago
  • Budget 2022 supports 38,000 apprentices to accelerate recovery
    Apprenticeship Boost extended to the end of 2023, supporting 38,000 apprentices Support for 1600 Mana in Mahi places to help people into work Funding to continue the Māori Trades and Training Fund, building on the 17 established partnerships that are supporting more than 800 people The Government is extending ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    19 hours ago
  • Aotearoa sets course to net-zero with first three emissions budgets
    Climate Change Minister James Shaw today announced New Zealand’s first three emissions budgets, another milestone on of the journey toward a zero-carbon future. “Today’s announcement means our net-zero future is closer than ever before. There’s much more to do, but having these binding budgets in place is a critical part ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    24 hours ago
  • Building a low-carbon future
    Tēnā koutou, tēnā koutou, tēnā koutou katoa. Ngā mihi o te ata. Good morning. Thank you, Stephen, for that kind introduction. And thank you, again, to ASB for hosting us today. *** I grew up in a big, old Victorian ‘character home’ in Aro Valley. Like so many here in ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 day ago
  • Safety front of mind as new cycleway opens
    As Road Safety Week officially commences, Auckland’s busiest cycling route has just received a $14.4 million upgrade, paving the way to get more Aucklanders out of their cars and onto their bikes. The new Tamaki Drive cycleway was opened today by Minister of Transport, Michael Wood following an official dawn ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 day ago
  • Budget 2022: More police to target gangs
    Delivers largest Police force ever and continues investment in frontline Police after the goal of an additional 1800 Police will be achieved by the end of this year - six months ahead of schedule Extra funding set aside to grow Police to match population growth. This will ensure there ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • Rotuman’s strongly support their language revival in Aotearoa
    Vetḁkia ‘os Fäega ma Ag fak hanua  -  Sustaining our Language and Culture is showcased in this year’s Rotuman Language Week – the first of nine Pacific Language Weeks, said Minister for Pacific Peoples Aupito William Sio. “With just 2,000 Rotuman speakers on the islands of Rotuma, nurturing the growing  ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • Funding for Pacific Stop Smoking Services to support Smokefree 2025 goal
    Pacific communities can expect more support to go smokefree as Associate Ministers of Health Dr Ayesha Verrall and Aupito William Sio launched one of the new Pacific stop smoking services at K’aute Pasifika Trust in Hamilton today. The Smokefree Pacific Advisory Group, chaired by Associate Professor Dr Collin Tukuitonga, was ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Buses take to the road on Northern Busway
    Northshore commuters now have access to congestion free travel to and from the city, as far north as Albany, thanks to the completion of the latest Northern Busway extension which was opened today by the Minister of Transport, Michael Wood. The four year project has delivered an additional five kilometres ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • All coal boilers to be removed from schools
    Thanks to a $10 million dollar investment, all remaining coal boilers in New Zealand schools will be replaced with renewable woody biomass or electric heating sources by 2025 reducing carbon emissions by around 35,400 tonnes over 10 years, Climate Change Minister James Shaw announced today. The move is part of ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Technical innovation to revolutionise forestry
    An innovative high-tech approach to forestry management is set to transform New Zealand’s forestry industry, Forestry Minister Stuart Nash and Agriculture Minister Damien O’Connor announced today. The Government is backing Precision Silviculture, a $25.5 million, seven-year programme led by Forest Growers Research Limited (FGR). “The investment is part of the ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • New links in chain of Great Rides cycle trails
    More of New Zealand’s most stunning landscapes, culture and heritage destinations will be showcased by the addition of two new cycle trails to the Ngā Haerenga Great Rides network. Tourism and Economic and Regional Development Minister Stuart Nash has today opened the Whakarewarewa Forest Loop trail near Rotorua, and announced ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Proposals aimed at user-friendly, up-to-date conservation processes
    Public feedback is being sought on proposed changes to improve management planning and concession processes in conservation legislation. “Management strategies and plans are key tools which help manage natural and historic resources by providing guidance on what can and cannot be done in our national parks and conservation areas,” Conservation ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Next steps for two new schools for Ōmokoroa
    Planning for two new schools on the Bay of Plenty’s Ōmokoroa Peninsula is underway as part of the Government’s comprehensive plan to support growth in the fast-growing Otumoetai catchment. Ongoing housing development will see 1,200 new homes in Ōmokoroa by 2025, and another development area in the west of the ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Travel trade show reconnects with Australia
    A government-backed push to reconnect the tourism and travel industry with our largest market in Australia will see Tourism Minister Stuart Nash head to Sydney next week. Stuart Nash is leading a delegation to one of the first major international trade events by Tourism New Zealand since the COVID-19 outbreak ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Budget 22 investing in biosecurity for future economic security
    Budget 22 invests $110.9 million into New Zealand’s biosecurity work $42.9 million to bolster New Zealand’s biosecurity readiness for future incursions $68 million over the coming year to continue the M. bovis eradication momentum Protection of primary sector vital with exports forecast to hit record $50.8 billion for year-end 2022 ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Joint M. bovis eradication plan reaches significant milestone
    Mycoplasma bovis (M. bovis) down to one infected property 271 farms cleared of M. bovis No working farms currently confirmed infected Plans for next steps towards a national pest management plan under way Hundreds of thousands of milk samples and animals tested last year   Four years into a world-first attempt to ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Crown accounts reflect strong economy
    The Crown accounts are continuing to reflect the strong position New Zealand is in to manage the challenging global environment, Grant Robertson said. For the nine months to the end of March, the Operating Balance before Gains and Losses (OBEGAL) deficit was $8.1 billion, $4.1 billion below that forecast in ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Budget 2022: Government clears road for 64,000 people to get driver licenses
    The Government is:  Increasing funding for driver licence support Removing barriers for people who have trouble obtaining driver licences Strengthening testing infrastructure and making it more equitable Reviewing the Graduated Driver Licensing System regulatory framework to ensure it is fit for purpose Budget 2022 will see an estimated 64,000 New ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Speech at announcement of nationwide plan to tackle hospital waiting lists, Auckland, 4 May 2022
    Today I am setting out our plan to deal with growing hospital waiting lists. COVID-19 has been hugely disruptive to hospital systems all over the world. In England, for example, there was a 200-fold increase in the number of people waiting more than a year for planned care, from just ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Nationwide plan to tackle hospital waiting lists
    Hospital waiting lists will be managed nationally under the Labour Government’s plan to cut the time people who need operations and appointments have to wait, Health Minister Andrew Little says. “COVID-19 has been hugely disruptive to hospital systems all over the world,” Andrew Little told health users, providers and unions ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Speech to the New Zealand Institute of International Affairs – Whare Tawāhi-a-mahi i Aotearoa
    It is a pleasure to be here tonight addressing you all and continuing to showcase New Zealand’s reconnection to the world. It was fantastic to be travelling again and promoting New Zealand with the Prime Minister a couple of weeks ago to Singapore and Japan. However these are challenging times for trade. ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • Record 50,000 homes consented in a year
    In the year ended March 2022, 50,858 new homes were consented, up 24 per cent from the March 2021 year. 21,477 new homes were consented in Auckland in the year ended March 2022, driven largely by an increase in multi-unit dwellings. 5,303 new homes were consented in March 2022 alone. ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • Broadened criteria for returning visa holders
    The Government is broadening the ability for residence class visa holders to re-enter New Zealand, Minister for COVID-19 Response Chris Hipkins has announced. The change means residence class visa holders not vaccinated against COVID-19 will be able to enter New Zealand from 6 May. The change allows New Zealand Permanent ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • Mānawatia a Matariki – te whakanui i a Matariki
    I tāpaea i te rangi nei Te Tohu o Matariki ki te iwi tūmatanui e te Minita mō te Kōtuinga o Ngāi Māori me te Karauna: Te Arawhiti, Kelvin Davis rāua ko te Minita Tuarua mō te Toi, te Ahurea, me te Tukuihotanga, a Kiri Allan. Hei tā Kelvin Davis, ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • Pre-budget speech to Rabobank breakfast
    I want to thank Rabobank for hosting us this morning, and all of you for making it along for an early start. Yesterday, New Zealand opened its borders again to tourists and business visitors from around 60 visa waiver countries as we continue our reconnection with the world. The resumption ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Budget 22: New fiscal rules to be put in place
    Surpluses will be kept within a band of zero to two percent of GDP to ensure new day‑to‑day spending is not adding to debt. A new debt measure to be introduced to bring New Zealand closer in line with other countries. A debt ceiling will ensure New Zealand maintains some ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Strategy highlights pathway to reduce infrastructure deficit
    The Government has welcomed Te Waihanga/New Zealand Infrastructure Commission’s first infrastructure strategy as a major milestone in building a more prosperous, resilient and sustainable future for all New Zealanders. Rautaki Hanganga o Aotearoa – New Zealand Infrastructure Strategy 2022–2052 set out the infrastructure challenges and opportunities facing New Zealand ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • New Zealand and the United States – Dynamic Economic Partners in the Indo-Pacific
    It is a pleasure to participate today in the United States Business Summit and to have the opportunity to speak to you about the US-New Zealand trade and economic relationship. I would like to join the Prime Minister in thanking the organisers – especially Fran O’Sullivan and Michael Barnett who I ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • More political elites and defence entities sanctioned, and prohibitions extended
    Foreign Affairs Minister Nanaia Mahuta has today announced further sanctions on Russian politicians and defence entities supporting Putin’s actions in Ukraine, as part of the Government’s ongoing response to the war. “Through these sanctions, we are demonstrating our intention to continue going after those who are responsible for Russia’s invasion ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Government supports grass roots emergency resilience initiatives
    Supporting preparations for a potential Alpine Fault rupture on the West Coast is one of several grass roots initiatives benefitting from a Government funding package to strengthen community resilience to emergencies. “Due to its isolation, its topography, and its proximity, the West Coast is particularly vulnerable to the impacts of ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Speech to Te Waihanga Symposium
    Introduction Kia ora koutou katoa, Today is a significant day for infrastructure in New Zealand. And that means it is a significant day for our productivity, our environment, our wellbeing and connections as people. That is because good quality infrastructure is core to improving all of those things. Today we ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Speech to New Zealand US Business Summit
    Ringitia mai, waetia mai Tuhi tuhia mai e Kei te manawa tonu te aroha me te whakapono   Can I please acknowledge our co-chairs today Fran O’Sullivan and Michael Barnett. US Ambassador to New Zealand Tom Udall. The Minister for Trade and Export Growth Damien O’Connor. And the really excellent ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Tourism and travel back on the world map
    New Zealand is back on the world map for international tourism and business travellers as the country opens up to visitors from around 60 visa-waiver countries who enjoy freer travel here from today. Tourism Minister Stuart Nash and Immigration Minister Kris Faafoi say the welcome mat is out for citizens ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Budget 2022 invests to keep Kiwi kids in class and learning
    The Government is committed to improving student attendance at school and kura, Education Minister Chris Hipkins and Associate Education Minister Jan Tinetti said in a pre-Budget announcement today. “It’s clear that young people need to be at school, and yet attendance rates haven’t been good for a long time. It’s ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Workers make their voices heard
    Essential workers sent a clear message today that they no longer want to see their pay and conditions set through a race to the bottom, and that they support fair, good faith bargaining with employers through Fair Pay Agreements. On International Workers’ Day, Minister of Workplace Relations and Safety Michael ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • New sea level data underlines need for action
    Climate Change Minister James Shaw says the release of new sea level rise data underlines the importance of the work the Government is doing to build a low emission, climate resilient future for Aotearoa. “Data from the NZ SeaRise programme confirms why this Government is right to prioritise action to ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Govt and Air New Zealand to trial innovative and accurate new COVID-19 test
    The Government is partnering with Air New Zealand to trial an innovative new COVID-19 testing solution that uses Loop-Mediated Isothermal Amplification (LAMP) technology, Associate Minister for COVID-19 Response Dr Ayesha Verrall announced today. “As New Zealand reconnects with the world, we are exploring innovative COVID-19 testing technology to help keep ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Government’s Winter Energy Payment kicks in for over 1 million Kiwis
    A warmer winter is on the horizon for over 1 million New Zealanders receiving either a main benefit or New Zealand Superannuation as the Winter Energy Payment begins today. “When we first came into office, we introduced the Winter Energy Payment as part of our Government’s December 2017 Families Package. ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago