Mehdi Hasan, like a number here, has been a true believer in the regime change conspiracy theory, and even gone as far as justifying Russian and Iranian intervention as being necessary to counter it.
But in his latest essay Mehdi Hasan has taken on the issue that many here have assiduously avoided, the massive war crimes amounting to genocide committed by the Assad regime.
The many links attached to his essay are worth reading on their own.
Personally I don’t agree with Hasan’s view that the rebels are as bad as the regime. And I think the jury is still out on the issue of the gas attack in Douma, which even a close reading of Robert Fisk’s essay allows.
But the fact that someone like Mehdi Hasan can shift his opinion gives me hope that someone like Bill and others like him could shift their opinion. And that my efforts here have not been wasted.
Sorry to interrupt: I know you’re very busy right now trying to convince yourselves, and the rest of us, that your hero couldn’t possibly have used chemical weapons to kill up to 70 people in rebel-held Douma on April 7. Maybe Robert Fisk’s mysterious doctor has it right — and maybe the hundreds of survivors and eyewitnesses to the attack are all “crisis actors.”……
……Now, I totally understand why those of you on the MAGA-supporting far right who cheer for barrel bombs don’t give a damn about any of this. But to those of you on the anti-war far left who have a soft spot for the dictator in Damascus: Have you lost your minds? Or have you no shame?……
……The truth is that Bashar al-Assad is not an anti-imperialist of any kind, nor is he a secular bulwark against jihadism; he is a mass murderer, plain and simple. In fact, the Syrian dictator long ago booked his place in the blood-stained pantheon of modern mass murderers, alongside the likes of Hitler, Stalin, Mao, Pol Pot, Henry Kissinger, and George W. Bush. I can think of few human beings alive today who have more blood on their hands than he has.
So, why defend him? Why indulge in conspiracy theories on his behalf? Why minimize his crimes and abuses? And isn’t it more than a little hypocritical of you to constantly call out the violence of the West or the Gulf states or the rebels, while ignoring or downplaying the violence of Assad?
Bill, if you accept that it’s possible this boy was duped and bribed to appear in a “fake news” video showing people dealing with the effects of gas, why can’t you accept that it’s possible that the boy and his father were intimidated and bribed into appearing in a fake news denouncement of that earlier video?
And even the story in your link says 75 people were killed. Were they also crisis actors?
I’m not claiming great expertise in this area, I just tend to question conspiracy theories.
The “bribed” theory contradicts the story told to Fisk that:
People began to arrive here suffering from hypoxia, oxygen loss. Then someone at the door, a “White Helmet”, shouted “Gas!”, and a panic began. People started throwing water over each other. Yes, the video was filmed here, it is genuine, but what you see are people suffering from hypoxia – not gas poisoning.”
So someone touting the “it never happened” theory is almost certainly making shit up. Cue a complicated explanation for the plot holes in this latest farce…
I expect the answer to”So, why defend him?” is simple.
The crimes of Hitler, Stalin, Mao, Pol Pot, Henry Kissinger, and George W. Bush are well documented.
There is no evidence the Bashar Assad has committed any crime.
Surely it is for Syrians, who live in, and have recently returned to Syria,and in 2014 voted overwhelmingly for him as their President, to judge their President.
Not you, nor I nor Mehdi Hasan who is an Al Jazeera reporter.
You will know that Al Jazeera is a owned by Qatar and that Qatar has funded the extremists in Syria.
Mehdi Hassan is an emotive fool. I’ve seen him debate Richard Dawkins and Dawkins (not a great debater himself and philosophically naive when it comes to religion) wiped the floor with him.
Anyone trying to bring modern, secular and ultimately civilised rule to a disparate unruly and fundamentally backward people has to resort to stern measures, and unfortunately there will be collateral damage. But the alternatives are far worse.
Then Mehdi trots out the usual parade of Western caricatured ‘dictators’ mixed in with his own liberal establishment anointed villains such as Kissinger and Bush. Kissinger had many redeeming qualities, and Stalin and Mao are among the greatest figures in world history, true titans who changed the world for the better.
“Anyone trying to bring modern, secular and ultimately civilised rule to a disparate unruly and fundamentally backward people has to resort to stern measures,”
Just calling you out on your cultural racism again.
Dirty racist.
It’s absolute common sense that different peoples are at different stages of civilisational development.
For example the Chinese openly admit to having fallen behind culturally and scientifically the past few centuries. They need a strong hand to guide them to a higher stage of cultural and social and economic accomplishment.
The real racists are those who want to keep non-western people down by lauding the backward practices of the latter —knowing that cultural ignorance and superstition will keep people of colour mired in the shit forever.
You would make a great colonist. Or maybe you could try the modern equivalent of the missionaries that went forth to save the souls of the unfortunate heathens by starting an NGO to educate and assimillate the diverse people of the world to suit your taste of what civilized means. I’d go with keepcalmcarryon on this one and say definitely racist. Give me the shit mire any day over your pompous venom
Thanks for putting up this link. AsleepWhileWalking* put up a Herald article on the Marton Countdown on Open mike yesterday, but that article did not answer my questions in my reply to AWW as to frequency and whether Countdown were trialling this in Marton for possible rollout throughout NZ as they are doing with instore pharmacies. This Stuff article has these details.
The instore pharmacies are excellent for being open seven days a week and for about 12 hours per day, and their lower per item prescription charges of $3 as opposed to the standard $5.
Jenny, I’m confused, I read your post and watched the video clip of Eva Bartlett, and they seen to be saying two entirely different things.
Medhi Hasan is saying we shouldn’t make a hero of Assad – which I don’t believe any commentator on here has attempted to do. He’s a vile dictator, with few redeeming virtues.
On the other hand Eva Bartlett is saying that the rebels are worse – which again most commentators would accept.
What most people here are suggesting is that Assad, for all his faults, is not stupid. Why would he use chemical weapons, a red rag to a bull for the West, when he’s all but winning? That is the not-credible part.
And most commentators are asking for evidence of the crime and who perpetrated it before going in boots and all and bombing the hell out of Syria.
“the rebels are worse – which most commentators would accept.”
What complete nonsense. Assad has killed literally hundreds of thousands of people, the majority being civilians. He has used massive airstrikes, used gas, used barrel bombs on residential neighbourhoods, hospitals and schools.
His brutality opened the way for ISIS (also brutal) in both Syria and Iraq.
The Arab Spring in Syria never needed to be like this. It wasn’t in other countries. He could have accepted some of the demands of the protests back in 2011. Instead he massacred them, just like his father.
It would not be unreasonable, given your background and ‘experience’, Wayne…
To expect that you mght back up the comments you post here with a link, some well reasoned explanations which include the mainstream interference of ‘The West SAUDI and Israel’…who are directly responsible for IsIs…IRAQ, LIBYA, YEMEN, SOUTH SUDAN, LEBANON…ETC
Instead you take another huge turd and run away…not a cursory attempt to substantiate, by my count at least 13 highly suspect aspects in your comment…
A number of which have been openly including via MSM sources…rebuked and shown to be incorrect…and outright bullshit…
So the question becomes…
Why do you continue on this path, Wayne…what drives your behaviour…
As we move through stages of life, we should learn and grow…not remain static or regress…which is what your comments indicate…
His brutality opened the way for ISIS (also brutal) in both Syria and Iraq.
Roight. So the destruction of Iraq had nothing to do with the rise of ISIS. I’m glad we have that one out of the way.
What about Timber Sycamore? The clandestine funding and arming of groups in Syria by the US (US$1 Billion worth according to the NYT). The US knew their stuff was falling into the hands of the likes of Al Nusra. I guess that has nothing whatsoever to do with the rise of Jahidist elements in Syria either.
Roight. So the destruction of Iraq had nothing to do with the rise of ISIS
I think prefer this bloke’s reasoning on why ISIS fancied Syria.
A warning I direct to the world: If you don't do something soon to help #Syria's people, it will become a jihadist magnet. Big time.— İyad el-Baghdadi | إياد البغدادي (@iyad_elbaghdadi) December 20, 2011
Oh yes thats for sure. Just as well “something was done” about Libya and Iraq to make sure they didnt become magnets for Jihadis and that “something is being done” about Yemen to stop that becoming a Jihadi magnet. Wherever would we be if “something” wasn’t being done somewhere? Maybe people would be able to make decisions about their own futures but then I suppose that “something would have to be done” about that
The Free Syrian Army were a legitimate opposition force comprised of Syrian soldiers who defected from Assad with the understanding that the west would aid them in removing him.
The west didn’t assist the FSA and members defected again to join well armed, cashed up militias.
And here we are, sitting on our hands while Assad goes about doing what any half decent despot does, slaughtering any and all opposition with impunity.
Which is the proper place for our hands to be unless you think Libya was a good idea or along with Albright you think the suffering of Yemen is “worth it”
It’s all kind of like the abusive home thing – someone always knows, never do anything about it, and after the fact it’s all it’s not good but we did nothing, because.
A pretty bad analogy I would say and most people would recognize that violence in the form of bullets, grenades and missiles is a pretty inappropriate response to domestic violence.
The “Free Syrian Army” was a fiction. Nevertheless, the US threw at least US$1 billion in the general direction of that fiction through Timber Sycamore. The arms wound up in the non-fictional hands of Al Nusra and other Jihadist gangs that were as bent as the US on getting rid of Assad.
The FSA (or so we are told) is now aiding and abetting Turkey in its “Operation Olive Branch”. Funnily enough, all these stories of Jihadists just keep coming out of the Turkish/FSA efforts.
In short. Armed Jihadists never defected to well armed, cashed up militias. The FSA was only ever armed Jihadists/”well armed, cashed up militias”.
Here in New Zealand we tolerate dissent because we know that dissenters are not likely to be biffing molotov cocktails around. I think we would be being somewhat ethnocentric if we thought that this also applied in all other countries.
Yeah Wayne he is a ruthless murderous dictator who will allow no political opposition – he is also a secular dictator who allowed minorities to live safely and allowed woman equality.
The Al Queda (whatever their current label) and ISIS groups are lunatic murdering Sunni Wahhabist zealots who gleefully (and have a compulsion for) murder and enslaving all those who do not follow their branch of faith – they also wouldn’t know what women’s rights were if they were tattooed on their damn foreheads.
Don’t be so ridiculous as to suggest I support ISIS.
It may have escaped your notice, but the US, UK and France have all had a vigorous campaign against ISIS. NZ has also been involved in the coalition against ISIS with trainers and intelligence staff (which seems to be now supported by the coalition – they have not done anything to withdraw them).
It is actually possible to oppose both Assad and ISIS.
However the west seems to have given up on trying to oust Assad. Their recent actions are merely to restrain him from using gas.
“It is simply irresponsible to focus criticism on inadvertent casualties caused by the Coalition’s war to defeat ISIS,” Col. Thomas Veale, a spokesperson for the coalition, told the AP.
…the US, UK and France have all had a a vigorous campaign against ISIS.
Timber Sycamore. Western government funding of the White Helmets. Funding and advising terrorists on media matters. Not exactly indicative of a “vigorous campaign against ISIS”.
In fact, the only “vigorous campaign against” that the US, UK and France have had (for right or wrong) is the one they have mounted against the government of Syria.
And when that has meant aiding and abetting Al Nusa/Al Qaeda/ISIS, then it’s okay “because Assad”.
Either ISIS will win or Assad will win. It is difficult not to have an opinion as to which outcome would be better. In other words it would not be be possible to “oppose both sides” as Wayne was claiming.
Geez Wayne. A vigorous campaign against would not include funnelling arms by the truckload from Libya to Syria nor supporting ngos that operate solely for the benefit of head choppers. If there were a vote in Syria today Assad would win hands down.I don’t know what his poularity was before the war but there is a lot of evidence that the US believed his popularity was such that a revolution would not take hold.
So if you want to do a study of comparative evil so that we may once again be coralled into supporting your lesser evil doctrines thats fine but please leave me out. It is for the Syrian people to decide their future and the more the USA supports the head choppers and their misogynist philosophy the more the Syrian people will stick with Assad
Be fair, Barfly – I don’t think Wayne is supporting either group. He’s already said ISIS are also brutal and he’s expressed sorrow that this awful situation has arisen.
Why do you continue to post unsubstantiated, and more roundly…refuted statements on a site which is in no alignment with your blatant ideological bent…
What drives your behaviour, Wayne…
Raise the level, Wayne…you’re not even fooling yourselves with the nonsense comments you post…
So you might as well stop trying…and take a good long look in the mirror…hang your head…
If the implementation of Law No. 10 of 2018 is anything like that of prior redevelopment regulations, including Decree No. 66 of 2012, which the new law amends and expands, the legislation can be expected not only to line the pockets of Assad regime cronies through new redevelopment projects at the expense of dispossessed property owners who receive insufficient compensation, but also to disproportionately target previous opposition strongholds for demographic change. Decree No. 66 allowed Syrian authorities to “redevelop areas of unauthorized housing and informal settlements” in two specifically designated locations in Damascus. Although the areas were in fact lower and middle-class neighborhoods that could—to a casual observer—seem to be legitimate targets for redevelopment, they were unique in being opposition strongholds. In fact, similar neighborhoods that were largely aligned with the Assad government and at similar socioeconomic backgrounds were left untouched by this displacement and redevelopment scheme.
When it comes to road safety, there’s a whole lot of really simple, cheap improvements that could be done and aren’t. Starting with just some yellow paint.
How many of the little white crosses on the roadside are very close to short visibility corners where the centreline is marked with a single dashed white line?
On SH1, just north of Puhoi where the speed limit goes back up to 100, the centreline has just been changed to a wide double yellow with rumble strips. That appears to have dropped average speeds by around 10km/h.
Meanwhile further north in Dome Valley where the speed limit is 80, the centreline is still marked with single dashed white (including around blind corners), and they’ve just installed a speed camera in the middle of the first long straight going north where it’s viable to pass a particularly slow vehicle. But no surprise, in this stretch typical speeds are still nudging much closer to a safe limit than on the stretch further south marked with double yellow lines.
Ffs, even Zimbabwe in the late 90s was able to paint double yellow lines around pretty much all blind corners, with arrows in the roadway telling drivers to get back on their correct side an appropriate distance before the corner.
Rumble strips have an amazing cost-benefit rating. We can also afford lots of them if the money is not being squandered on a handful of gold-plated duplicate highways.
While they may be cost effective, the problem with rumble strips is they don’t physically stop cars from crossing the centre line. Take a sleeping driver for example, by the time they are alerted from the rumble, they’ll potentially be looking at a head on.
Lol Hooch, it had mark richardson throwing a tanty on morning TV.
Super funny, richardson is having great difficulty dealing with the popularity of our new PM. mark richardson was sweet as with john key getting attention on the world stage, but dang, Jacinda is cleaning up and richardson quite possibly needs counselling to get through it.
If there’s a video link, will post he was angry as, I couldn’t stop laughing.
I’m sure everyone will agree that the National government did good work in this area and hopefully the present government will continue along the same lines
The Youth Justice Indicators Summary report shows that actually youth offending has been dropping under the last Government. It compares 2009/10 to 2016/17. The findings are:
Child (10 to 13) offending rate down 59%
Youth (14 to 16) offending rate down 63%
Pasifika youth offending rate down 61%
Maori youth offending rate down 59%
It may indeed be a National government that can take a lot of the credit, but it might be Bolger’s, not Key’s. Leaded petrol was finally banned in New Zealand in 1996 for road use, although there’s still some in aviation fuel.
I seem to recollect a change in police procedure whereby minor offences were treated by police warnings rather than arrests – great way to juke comparative stats PR – a bit like when National redefined unemployment and knocked half a % from the unemployment (official) rate and proclaimed their governance skills loudly.
Murder charges laid in Hawke’s Bay this week underscore a troubling trend – young offenders are responsible for or accused of a growing proportion of overall crime.
The proportion of young people whose offending was serious enough to lead to court action or family group conferences has risen by 19 per cent between 2013/14 and 2016/17, after very little change from 2009/10 to 2013/14.
Police altered official crime statistics to make hundreds of burglaries disappear, a Herald on Sunday investigation has found.
A damning report obtained by the newspaper reveals the burglaries were instead recorded as more minor crimes, or as incidents, which are not counted in crime statistics at all.
It’s unfortunate that I have to have doubts in what the police say but they do have form.
the trick looking at population stats is to look at them per thousand(s) population in the relevant demographic. That gets rid of those pesky issues of shifting demographics.
Otherwise the stats aren’t really worth even looking at. They are just PR froth.
Which is what your numbers look like. Doesn’t make me want to read the report. Makes you look like a mindless shock jock wanking
Farah Hancock reporting on Food Symposium.
Dr Mike Joy:
To produce one gram of protein from beef, one square metre of land is required. To get one gram of protein from rice requires just .02 of a square metre of land.
For one litre of milk, 13,600 litres of water are needed. Joy said this figure represents the total water “footprint” required to nourish cows – and to dilute the nitrogen produced by them in order to have clean aquifers and drinkable water.
Kathryn Ryan, the scourge of helpless civil servants
RNZ National, Friday 20 April 2018, 9:10 a.m.
I’ve just heard Kathryn Ryan conduct a sarcastic, hectoring, bumptious interrogation of Census general manager Denise McGregor. “I know“, Ryan scolded her several times during the mauling. What a pity Ryan saves all of her unpleasantness for underlings and civil servants; in stark contrast, she simpers and agrees with the politicians who are responsible for debacles like this year’s census.
I’d agree except that in many cases the scourge of helpless civil servants seems to be, more often than not, their own senior corporatised management.
As we’re seeing more and more, there are some real muppets amongst them and they have a vested interest in preserving the status quo.
Quite true, Tim. However, in this case Kathryn Ryan was simply unleashing her full retinue of sarcasm and feigned exasperation on an underling. The contrast to her handling of genuinely nasty people like Matthew Hooton and Dame Ann Leslie could not be any greater….
Have you got any proof that this years census was a debacle?
Everything I saw while working there indicated that it went off pretty well. There were a few issues but, as the Stats people said, it usually takes months to complete the census anyway.
This was the first time that they did it this way. There was bound to be mistakes made and lessons learned. That doesn’t make it a debacle.
How many people have been recorded so far? What percentage of the total is that and how does it compare to the percentage after 6 weeks last time?
You say you worked there. I assume therefore you can answer such simple questions?
You’d have to ask Stats for the answers to those questions. I just related that it was going fairly well when I worked there. At the time, the Stats people seemed happy with the way it was going. Some three million people filled the form in online by the 7th which is pretty good.
Most of what I’ve seen when people have said that it’s all a fuckup it seems to come down to ZOMG, it’s different from before and I don’t like it so therefore it can’t be working well.
Well Stats certainly aren’t being proactive.
The last release they gave was dated 20 March. That was when they were up to about 3.5 million out of an anticipated 4.8 million.
Since then there hasn’t been a peep out of them. https://www.stats.govt.nz/news/census-on-track-for-70-percent-online
Traditionally they get about 98% all up.
So, listening to the interview that you obviously didn’t (although to be fair it’s not like Morrissey listend to what was there, either), they’re working on roughly the last ten percent of the population, this isn’t that different from last census (as far as that comparison is relevant), but exact numbers are difficult to track at this stage because things like collation of household resident numbers against individual returns without addresses is actually part of the process they are undertaking at the moment.
My guess is that the initial release was of the low-hanging fruit (returned forms that all tabulated perfectly) and that you’re literally asking for information that doesn’t exist yet.
No, not a debacle, more bugger’s muddle.
I was out of the country, tho’ I had a friend also ‘working there’ (in that place….ooops ‘space’ you apparently were).
More a bugger’s muddle that’ll eventually sort itself out……possibly…..maybe…..hopefully.
Pretty bluddy marvellous for one whose Honeymoon is said to be over?
“Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern makes Time magazine’s 100 most influential list.”
“”A designation of individuals whose time, in our estimation, is now”, Time said.”
“In a world that too often tells women to stay small, keep quiet—and that we can’t have both motherhood and a career—Jacinda Ardern proves how wrong and outdated those notions of womanhood are.”
Hopefully MSM will accord our PM the praise she deserves after the impact and impression she has made overseas. I have never seen Angela Merkel quite so warm and smiley! And to use the word “fun”. The world needs a smile in the midst of the turmoil. The Daily Mail has some great photos of Jacinda and she looks so gracious and dignified. Yes, we should be very proud of her.
Anyone else disappointed by Jacinda saying NZ accepted the US, UK and France striking out at Syria, despite there being insufficient evidence to do so?
Draco – firstly you on two occasions accused me of making an argument from authority when A) I hadn’t and B) you made no attempt at refuting what I was saying and just accused me of making a fallacy as if that disproved the point I was making (it didn’t). That is the fallacy fallacy at work – same as here. You didn’t address the points made, just accused the poster of making a fallacy as if that wins the argument. It doesn’t because you are making the fallacy fallacy.
Secondly I am under no obligation to retract. You have on several occasions accused me of being a right-winger (again – to some how claim victory in debate without actually addressing the points I may have been making) without any evidence whatsoever so you are hardly in any position to demand others to provide evidence or retract given your own past history of making claims about others.
So I guess what I am saying is – fuck you. You have no moral or intellectual high ground here.
Draco Draco Draco, PLEASE! Don’t back down!
Fuk ’em! PLEASE! Your ego and ideology is at stake!
(It’s increasingly hard to agree with many of your points of view when you are increasingly becoming a complete fucking wanker. I used to see a DracotB worthy of an opinion – usually with evidence based kaka that at least propped up his view. Not so lately.
People can challenge you with an opposing view based on lived experiences, yet – yea well…..
No ………. pfffffffffft.
I’ll continue to consider your ideas and contributions, but ffs – your cock isn’t actually as big as you think it is
firstly you on two occasions accused me of making an argument from authority when A) I hadn’t and B) you made no attempt at refuting what I was saying and just accused me of making a fallacy as if that disproved the point I was making (it didn’t). That is the fallacy fallacy at work – same as here. You didn’t address the points made, just accused the poster of making a fallacy as if that wins the argument. It doesn’t because you are making the fallacy fallacy.
You demanded to know who had filled in the Political Compass in such a way as to say that the who was important when it wasn’t. You even specifically asked what authority they had. An appeal to authority.
I wasn’t using it to debunk your argument (you hadn’t made one after all) but using it to say that the who simply wasn’t important.
And I did address your point. I explained why it was useful and the methodology that they used (The same methodology that I was taught in uni political science).
At no point did you counter my points. You just made assertions about it being an anonymous survey when it obviously isn’t.
Corbyn was against them. Sanders was against them. Sturgeon was against them. Melenchon was against them.
These are the people who represent the politics that are on the cusp of usurping Liberalism. So there’s hope of sanity prevailing in the ‘not too distant’.
P.S. It’s pretty obvious to all but the most one-eyed that there was no gas attack.
Have people heard that the health committee responding to submitters on the medical cannabis bill had their emails published in the clear. Meaning when you got an email from them, you got everyone else’s email address. Including those people who wanted to do submissions anomisiously.
Must be fun to be part of government, smash people’s privacy apart, then offer up a lame excuse.
It gets worse, the replies people have sent into the committee, have been sent in the clear to other submitters as well.
Looking on bright side, let me know when you find one…
It’s the effect of doing things on the cheap rather investing in proper software. It’s why I think the NZ Government needs an IT department that produces all of it’s software from OS up. Make it so shit like this simply cannot happen because they got a good deal from Microsoft for Office and use the completely inadequate Outlook for email.
I think my favourite example was whena local campaigner sent email #500 to a local council organisation, and the frontline recipient forwarded to their manager (who had been a corecipient of the original email) something like “do you want to handle this? I can’t deal with this bloody idiot anymore”. Hit “reply all” instead of “forward”…
Yes, there’s certainly some of that but software in that sort of situation shouldn’t even allow such a breach of privacy. All sorts of restrictions on who can see and do what has been around in software for decades now. It shouldn’t be that hard to understand that we need to have the software doing that for government as well.
The Nats are running an attack line at the moment accusing the government of not knowing how to make decisions and not having sound policy, relying too much on working groups etc.
Andrew Little has walked into the entrance of Pike River mine with family representatives in a heavily symbolic, emotional gesture.
Inside the entrance shaft, the minister embraced Sonya Rockhouse, whose son Ben died in the 2010 explosion and Anna Osborne, whose husband Milton was also killed.
“This wouldn’t have happened if it wasn’t for Andrew Little and the Labour Government.
“This is the start of something huge for us. We believe it’s going to be done.”
Despite Key telling the families privately that he would get their family out from a mine death that should never have happened if there was proper regulation and oversight. Despite National reneging on that private assurance and attempt to seal the mine off forever, Andrew Little has brought dignity and grace to this issue.
His mana only continues to build with the humanity and intelligence he uses to every portfolio he is given.
The only effective thing he did for Labour was to stand down.
Lets do a big “yay” for his work on Pike river when they actually go in the mine proper – of course they will have to go in behind Winson – he wanted to be the first in there.
Andrew Little gives more power to the Privacy Commissioner in new bill
Andrew Little reaffirms commitment to tackling workplace harassment
Ngai Tahu and Waikato-Tainui receive substantial treaty payments to acknowledge historical deal
Andrew Little says three strikes law will be repealed
Little confirms Pora compensation will be adjusted
ODT editorial
Justice Minister Andrew Little is embarking on a task which is sure to divide New Zealand, as most people have strong views on prisons, probation and sentences.
Mr Little, who is already developing into one of the Government’s most considered ministers, is proposing reform to the country’s criminal justice system and a rejection of “getting tough on crime”, a view long-held by many politicians and voters.
His vision has been called the boldest political move in criminal justice since former justice minister Ralph Hannan convinced his National Party colleagues to abolish the death penalty in 1961.
Jacinda does look incredible in the korowai with the baby bump.
(Apparently causing a massive positive media reaction, positive change and hope + China possibly having a military presence in Vanuatu has renewed interest in the Pacific and their leaders?).
I agree Savenz – she looked stunning in her NZ designed gown and the Korowai cloak. Like the ad on TV in the old days “she will stop traffic” – good on her for her gracious charming manner – it’s all good for NZ on the world stage. Onwards and upwards for her in her career and family life.
Funny chap are you Puckish. You join the outrage that there has been no consultation about some matters then outraged because there is consultation. You are a bit like Duncan Garner. Hey! Are you Duncan Garner?
I’d have thought you wouldn’t have any journalists on there (same view as Little by the way) especially those with a bit of a conflict of interest going on
If they’re advising on specific known instances and getting super-top-secret-pinky-swear clearance to do so, yeah, maybe.
But if the panel just advises in principle to balance against advocacy from within the services, you’d actually want as diverse a mix as possible to help you balance the conflict between security and freedom. It’s a good way to avoid bureaucratic capture.
This government is awash with panels and reviews achieving nothing except reports for the shelf and Welly-churn to keep retired (consulting) public servants voting the right way.
Christ Ad!!! you’re worried about ‘clearances’ rather than …
You know I was chastised not too long ago by a moderator for suggesting that I was ‘potentially’ familiar with who you might be.
At the time, nothing was further from my mind, although I do continue wonder whether you’re a progressive (by ANY stretch of the definition), or whether you’re better suited to some comfortably-off senior public servant (or contractual advisor thereof) wanting to preserve his role – and one that’s ‘down’ with the big boys
Did you ever wonder WHY they might be “awash with panels and reviews”?
If so, you’ll be disappointed.
There may be a shitload more to come if a new coalition government is able to clutch its balls.
But @Ad … you may be in luck. People get tired and complacent and used to the American Express Gold Card, so we’ll see
Whoar (as Phil Ure would have said)
Why even ask that question Chuck-the-deliverance-from-all-evil-and-savior-with-an-excessively-sized-PENIS?
Maaate! ya fucking gorjiss,,,,, and hey….. are you rilly rilly an Amirrrikin without a gun?
Is there a possibility we could hook up sometime?
that ”
I feel sorry for the impersonator!! Why choose Clare Curran” statement really showed the size of your impedimenta.
The paramount consideration for all non-Western peoples is DEVELOPMENT.
That is the creation of modern secular societies with cities, and skyscrapers, medical care, electricity, and high speed computers and jet aircraft and strong high-tech military forces capable of defending against the depredations of Western imperialism.
The ends justify the means.
Bashar al-Assad is a fucken hero!
[lprent: Ok, in my view that is yet another quite deliberate attempt to start a flame war and followed by deliberate provocation in this thread. I’m tired of seeing every conversation you are involved in winding up in a stupid wankfest. It appears to be the only thing that you are good at.
You are obviously incapable of participating in debate at any level, preferring instead to make each debate purely about yourself. And you add absolutely nothing much to it apart from inducing bans all around.
Do not come back under any guise ever. I really don’t like moronic trolls and I think that you are simply too stupid to learn to be anything else. ]
The same western imperialism giving you the internet and the free speech to inflict your hate on those you deem culturally inferior, no less.
What a massive hypocrite.
So it is hypocritical for a victim to turn the weapons invented by the aggressor on to the aggressor himself?
I’m not a hypocrite, and you are a numbnuts
By the way, Asians, Chinese are Indians, are way over-represented in IT and the computer industry, and were pioneers in the development of the modern PC: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/An_Wang
I taught in China for over three years. I still remember the shock on day 1 on learning that Wikipedia was not available because it’s an open source platform and contained articles critical of China.
On day 2 us foreign teacher were told NEVER to mention the 3 Ts: Taiwan. Tibet and Tiananmen Square.
I used to watch the CCTV English news, but soon gave up – first fifteen minutes positive things happening in China, next ten minutes how China was influencing the rest of the world, then five minutes of weather – the only part worth watching.
After a while the whole atmosphere (and the pollution) became quite oppressive.
I think the goal is to swamp the site.
Best to ignore.
Many positives to discuss this week.
Jacinda in Europe making a positive impact for New Zealand.
Andrew Little being true to his word to Pike River miners.
The government sending a firm message to the fossil fuel industry.
Did you just claim that “natives” the world over should be thankful for having been colonised?!
For having their cultures eradicated? For having genocide visited on them?
And not only that, but you have the audacity to point the high and mighty accusing finger at oppression, that in terms of scale,barely register by any measure that includes those of western liberal democracy these past few hundred years, and also accuse others of being ‘one eyed’ , hypocritical and possible trolls?
Wei feels that “ You can’t bring liberal democracy to people who run around like 7th century savages slitting throats and beheading people for believing the ‘wrong’ god. You have to use very heavy handed means and crush this sort of shit. Then put in a secular schooling system and develop the economy. Then after two or three generations the people may well be ready for ‘liberal democracy’”
Pretty much he’s for ramming his superior culture down anyone else’s throat because western imperialism.
Take your blinkers off
It’s my reasonable interpretation of your Pythonesque “What’s the Romans done for us” apologist tripe. If you’d care to explain how else to take your lauding of this western imperialism giving you the internet and the free speech…, then I’m all ears.
So you believe that liberal democracy is obsolete. And regard the complete mobilization of society under a totalitarian one-party state as necessary to prepare a nation for armed conflict and to respond effectively to economic difficulties? Such a state is led by a strong leader—such as a dictator and a martial government composed of the members of the governing party—to forge national unity and maintain a stable and orderly society. And clearly you reject assertions that violence is automatically negative in nature and view political violence, war and imperialism as means that can achieve national rejuvenation?
That’s a word for word quote from wikis definition of fascism.
Couple that with constant assertions of cultural superiority and racism and you know what we call it?
How did liberal democracy get to be liberal democracy?
By having the economic and cultural conditions and optimum social stratification that enabled it.
The economic conditions achieved by extremely illiberal means, off the backs of black, brown, and yellow folk.
You can’t bring liberal democracy to people who run around like 7th century savages slitting throats and beheading people for believing the ‘wrong’ god. You have to use very heavy handed means and crush this sort of shit. Then put in a secular schooling system and develop the economy. Then after two or three generations the people may well be ready for ‘liberal democracy’
Ok that was clearly too difficult.
Does China deserve to expand to develop in your opinion? Eg the Spratly Islands or Tibet?
We can even call it lebensraum if it makes you feel more comfortable.
[Yup The baiting. Did you not see the moderation notes I’ve left “everywhere” for xenophobic idiots like you to read? Because I’m kind, I’m going to give you the benefit of the doubt and assume you missed them. And I’m assuming you will notice this one (because I’m dropping a direct reply to this comment in a sec). Having read this one, you now have the chance hunt them out, read them, understand them, and then desist with this type of exchange you’re engaging in, and so avoid a very, very long holiday from the site. ] – Bill
I thought the ends justified the means when a “more civilised” society used a heavy hand on the less developed until they were “ready for democracy”?
hypocritical again wei.
Spratly Islands?
Huh? China did not expand into Tibet because Tibet is a part of China, and is recognized as such by every single sovereign state in the world, New Zealand included.
The long standing US position, way before the communists took power:
“The United States considers the Tibet Autonomous Region or TAR (hereinafter referred to as “Tibet”) as part of the People’s Republic of China. This longstanding policy is consistent with the view of the entire international community, including all China’s neighbors: no country recognizes Tibet as a sovereign state. Moreover, U.S. acceptance of China’s claim of sovereignty over Tibet predates the establishment of the People’s Republic of China. In 1942, we told the Nationalist Chinese government then headquartered in Chongqing (Chungking) that we had “at no time raised (a) question” over Chinese claims to Tibet. Because we do not recognize Tibet as an independent state, the United States does not conduct diplomatic relations with the representatives of Tibetans in exile.” http://dosfan.lib.uic.edu/ERC/bureaus/eap/950907WiedemannTibet.html
FYI, Keepcalmcarryon, until China turned Communist, the USA recognised Tibet as the 5th province of China. “Why we Fight” is a documentary produced by the US Dept of Information during WW2. If you watch the “China” episode, you will clearly see Tibet named as China’s 5th province. (Whenever a Chinese dynasty was strong, China always ruled Tibet.)
Unfortunately after WW2 China turned Communist. Oh dear! So capitalist USA suddenly realised that Tibet has always been and should always be a free, independent country.
Sorry, but shades of 1984 here… (Edit -I now see Wei has beaten me to it.)
Similar in a way – when China was strong, it probably ruled them. When China wasn’t strong, the stronger/strongest of many other countries all took turns.. No doubt they all have historical claims. Cue the USA (and others) all trying to push their own interests the hardest. Plus ça change, plus c’est la meme chose.
Go fuck yourself Bill. Racist enabler.
Don’t moderate the troll yesterday, allow abuse, then start banning everyone else because if baiting.
What a disgrace.
There you go I agree strongly with Marxism and Engels Capitol has to be Socialise what they say about class struggle has happened for centuries and it always end in that thing I say is for idiots here’s the link
There you go another pukana to the establishment what you going to do sandflies arrest me for excising my RIGHT TO FREE SPEECH see what happens .
At the minute One can be arrested and locked up for months with anything being proven as fact thats leaves the door left right open for minuplation by the state I hope you can see this. Ana to kai Ka kite ano
Wow a few marked cop cars hanging around Eco Maori ——- you think I don’t no that every form of comunacation I have you are gathering to try and use against me hence the saying if Eco Maori farts you will try and create a ——– storm over what I say muppets Ana to kai
People are learning the truth about plastics they are bad for the environment an for our health the price of wool is rising ka pai wool carpets is best anyway.
Ka kite ano .
Good evening Newshub there you go social media has a lot of good components like that app that will alert a medic/ nurse doctor first aid person that is closes to the heart attack patient and direct them to the patient . Alex the Matariki is not far away about a month to six weeks Maori use the Stars to predict seasonal weather time fishing expeditions when to plant crops when to harvest crops . I will get my cousin to tell me when he has the knowledge on that subject and many others. The Last Flying Flag looks like a movie Eco Maori would watch
Our sports Stars are still shining bright Kia Kaha te tangata Ka kite ano
Hi,Back in September of 2023, I got pitched an interview:David -Thanks for the quick response to the DM! Means the world. Re-stating some of the DM below for your team’s reference -I run a business called Animal Capital - we are a venture capital fund advised by Noah Beck, Paris ...
I didn’t want to write about this – but, alas, the 2020s have forced my hand. I am going to talk about the Trump Tariffs… and in the process probably irritate nearly everyone. You see, alone on the Internet, I am one of those people who think we need a ...
Maybe people are only just beginning to notice the close alignment of Russia and China. It’s discussed as a sudden new phenomenon in world affairs, but in fact it’s not new at all. The two ...
The High Court has just ruled that the government has been violating one of the oldest Treaty settlements, the Sealord deal: The High Court has found the Crown has breached one of New Zealand's oldest Treaty Settlements by appropriating Māori fishing quota without compensation. It relates to the 1992 ...
Darwin’s proposed Middle Arm Sustainable Development Precinct is set to be the heart of a new integrated infrastructure network in the Northern Territory, larger and better than what currently exists in northern Australia. However, the ...
Local body elections are in October, and so like a lot of people, I received the usual pre-election enrolment confirmation from the Orange Man in the post. And I was horrified to see that it included the following: Why horrified? After all, surely using email, rather ...
Australia needs to deliver its commitment under the Seoul Declaration to create an Australian AI safety, or security, institute. Australia is the only signatory to the declaration that has yet to meet its commitments. Given ...
Ko kōpū ka rere i te paeMe ko Hine RuhiTīaho mai tō arohaMe ko Hine RuhiDa da da ba du da da ba du da da da ba du da da da da da daDa da da ba du da da ba du da da da ba du da da ...
Army, Navy and AirForce personnel in ceremonial dress: an ongoing staffing exodus means we may get more ships, drones and planes but not have enough ‘boots on the ground’ to use them. Photo: Lynn GrievesonLong stories short in Aotearoa’s political economy this morning:PM Christopher Luxon says the Government can ...
If you’re a qualified individual looking to join the Australian Army, prepare for a world of frustration over the next 12 to 18 months. While thorough vetting is essential, the inefficiency of the Australian Defence ...
I’ve inserted a tidbit and rumours section1. Colonoscopy wait times increase, procedures drop under NationalWait times for urgent, non-urgent and surveillance colonoscopies all progressively worsened last year. Health NZ data shows the total number of publicly-funded colonoscopies dropped by more than 7 percent.Health NZ chief medical officer Helen Stokes-Lampard blamed ...
Three billion dollars has been wiped off the value of New Zealand’s share market as the rout of global financial markets caught up with the local market. A Sāmoan national has been sentenced for migrant exploitation and corruption following a five-year investigation that highlights the serious consequences of immigration fraud ...
This is a guest post by Darren Davis. It originally appeared on his excellent blog, Adventures in Transitland, which we encourage you to check out. It is shared by kind permission. Rail Network Investment Plan quietly dropped While much media attention focused on the 31st March 2025 announcement that the replacement Cook ...
Amendments to Indonesia’s military law risk undermining civilian supremacy and the country’s defence capabilities. Passed by the House of Representatives on 20 March, the main changes include raising the retirement age and allowing military officers ...
The StrategistBy Alfin Febrian Basundoro and Jascha Ramba Santoso
So New Zealand is about to spend $12 billion on our defence forces over the next four years – with $9 million of it being new money that is not being spent on pressing needs here at home. Somehow this lavish spend-up on Defence is “affordable,” says PM Christopher Luxon, ...
Donald Trump’s philosophy about the United States’ place in the world is historically selfish and will impoverish his country’s spirit. While he claimed last week to be ‘liberating’ Americans from the exploiters and freeloaders who’ve ...
China’s crackdown on cyber-scam centres on the Thailand-Myanmar border may cause a shift away from Mandarin, towards English-speaking victims. Scammers also used the 28 March earthquake to scam international victims. Australia, with its proven capabilities ...
At the 2005 election campaign, the National Party colluded with a weirdo cult, the Exclusive Brethren, to run a secret hate campaign against the Greens. It was the first really big example of the rich using dark money to interfere in our democracy. And unfortunately, it seems that they're trying ...
Many of you will know that in collaboration with the University of Queensland we created and ran the massive open online course (MOOC) "Denial101x - Making sense of climate science denial" on the edX platform. Within nine years - between April 2015 and February 2024 - we offered 15 runs ...
How will the US assault on trade affect geopolitical relations within Asia? Will nations turn to China and seek protection by trading with each other? The happy snaps a week ago of the trade ministers ...
I mentioned this on Friday - but thought it deserved some emphasis.Auckland Waitematā District Commander Superintendent Naila Hassan has responded to Countering Hate Speech Aotearoa, saying police have cleared Brian Tamaki of all incitement charges relating to the Te Atatu library rainbow event assault.Hassan writes:..There is currently insufficient evidence to ...
With the report of the recent intelligence review by Heather Smith and Richard Maude finally released, critics could look on and wonder: why all the fuss? After all, while the list of recommendations is substantial, ...
Well, I don't know if I'm readyTo be the man I have to beI'll take a breath, I'll take her by my sideWe stand in awe, we've created lifeWith arms wide open under the sunlightWelcome to this place, I'll show you everythingSongwriters: Scott A. Stapp / Mark T. Tremonti.Today is ...
Staff at Kāinga Ora are expecting details of another round of job cuts, with the Green Party claiming more than 500 jobs are set to go. The New Zealand Defence Force has made it easier for people to apply for a job in a bid to get more boots on ...
Australia’s agriculture sector and food system have prospered under a global rules-based system influenced by Western liberal values. But the assumptions, policy approaches and economic frameworks that have traditionally supported Australia’s food security are no ...
Following Trump’s tariff announcement, US stock values fell by the most ever in value terms (US$6.6 trillion). Photo: Getty ImagesLong story shortest in Aotearoa’s political economy this morning:Donald Trump just detonated a neutron bomb under the globalised economy, but this time the Fed isn’t cutting interest rates to rescue ...
A listing of 36 news and opinion articles we found interesting and shared on social media during the past week: Sun, March 30, 2025 thru Sat, April 5, 2025. This week's roundup is again published by category and sorted by number of articles included in each. The formatting is a ...
This is a longer read.Summary:Trump’s tariffs are reckless, disastrous and hurt the poorest countries deeply. It will stoke inflation, and may cause another recession. Funds/investments around the world have tanked.Trump’s actions emulate the anti-economic logic of another right wing libertarian politician - Liz Truss. She had her political career cut ...
We are all suckers for hope.He’s just being provocative, people will say, he wouldn’t really go that far. They wouldn’t really go that far.Germany in the 1920s and 30s was one of the world’s most educated, culturally sophisticated, and scientifically advanced societies.It had a strong democratic constitution with extensive civil ...
Skeptical Science is partnering with Gigafact to produce fact briefs — bite-sized fact checks of trending claims. You can submit claims you think need checking via the tipline. Is Mars warming? Mars’ climate varies due to completely different reasons than Earth’s, and available data indicates no temperature trends comparable to Earth’s ...
Max Harris and Max Rashbrooke discuss how we turn around the right wing slogans like nanny state, woke identity politics, and the inefficiency of the public sector – and how we build a progressive agenda. From Donald Trump to David Seymour, from Peter Dutton to Christopher Luxon, we are subject to a ...
Max Harris and Max Rashbrooke discuss how we turn around the right wing slogans like nanny state, woke identity politics, and the inefficiency of the public sector – and how we build a progressive agenda. From Donald Trump to David Seymour, from Peter Dutton to Christopher Luxon, we are subject to a ...
I was interested in David Seymour's public presentation of the Justice Select Committee's report after the submissions to the Treaty Principles Bill.I noted the arguments he presented and fact checked him. I welcome corrections and additions to what I have written but want to keep the responses concise.The Treaty of ...
Well, he runs around with every racist in townHe spent all our money playing his pointless gameHe put us out; it was awful how he triedTables turn, and now his turn to cryWith apologies to writers Bobby Womack and Shirley Womack.Eight per cent, asshole, that’s all you got.Smiling?Let me re-phrase…Eight ...
In short this morning in our political economy:The S&P 500 fell another 5.6% this morning after China retaliated with tariffs of 34% on all US imports, and the Fed warned of stagflation without rate cut relief.Delays for heart surgeries and scans are costing lives, specialists have told Stuff’s Nicholas Jones.Meanwhile, ...
When the US Navy’s Great White Fleet sailed into Sydney Harbour in 1908, it was an unmistakeable signal of imperial might, a flexing of America’s newfound naval muscle. More than a century later, the Chinese ...
While there have been decades of complaints – from all sides – about the workings of the Resource Management Act (RMA), replacing is proving difficult. The Coalition Government is making another attempt.To help answer the question, I am going to use the economic lens of the Coase Theorem, set out ...
2027 may still not be the year of war it’s been prophesised as, but we only have two years left to prepare. Regardless, any war this decade in the Indo-Pacific will be fought with the ...
Australia must do more to empower communities of colour in its response to climate change. In late February, the Multicultural Leadership Initiative hosted its Our Common Future summits in Sydney and Melbourne. These summits focused ...
Questions 1. In his godawful decree, what tariff rate was imposed by Trump upon the EU?a. 10% same as New Zealandb. 20%, along with a sneer about themc. 40%, along with an outright lie about France d. 69% except for the town Melania comes from2. The justice select committee has ...
Yesterday the Trump regime in America began a global trade war, imposing punitive tariffs in an effort to extort political and economic concessions from other countries and US companies and constituencies. Trump's tariffs will make kiwis nearly a billion dollars poorer every year, but Luxon has decided to do nothing ...
Here’s 7 updates from this morning’s news:90% of submissions opposed the TPBNZ’s EV market tanked by Coalition policies, down ~70% year on yearTrump showFossil fuel money driving conservative policiesSimeon Brown won’t say that abortion is healthcarePhil Goff stands by comments and makes a case for speaking upBrian Tamaki cleared of ...
It’s the 9 month mark for Mountain Tūī !Thanks to you all, the publication now has over 3200 subscribers, 30 recommendations from Substack writers, and averages over 120,000 views a month. A very small number in the scheme of things, but enough for me to feel satisfied.I’m been proud of ...
The Justice Committee has reported back on National's racist Principles of the Treaty of Waitangi Bill, and recommended by majority that it not proceed. So hopefully it will now rapidly go to second reading and be voted down. As for submissions, it turns out that around 380,000 people submitted on ...
We need to treat disinformation as we deal with insurgencies, preventing the spreaders of lies from entrenching themselves in the host population through capture of infrastructure—in this case, the social media outlets. Combining targeted action ...
After copping criticism for not releasing the report for nearly eight months, Prime Minister Anthony Albanese released the Independent Intelligence Review on 28 March. It makes for a heck of a read. The review makes ...
After copping criticism for not releasing the report for nearly eight months, Prime Minister Anthony Albanese released the Independent Intelligence Review on 28 March. It makes for a heck of a read. The review makes ...
In short this morning in our political economy:Donald Trump has shocked the global economy and markets with the biggest tariffs since the Smoot Hawley Act of 1930, which worsened the Great Depression.Global stocks slumped 4-5% overnight and key US bond yields briefly fell below 4% as investors fear a recession ...
Hi,I’ve been imagining a scenario where I am walking along the pavement in the United States. It’s dusk, I am off to get a dirty burrito from my favourite place, and I see three men in hoodies approaching.Anther two men appear from around a corner, and this whole thing feels ...
Since the announcement in September 2021 that Australia intended to acquire nuclear-powered submarines in partnership with Britain and the United States, the plan has received significant media attention, scepticism and criticism. There are four major ...
On a very wet Friday, we hope you have somewhere nice and warm and dry to sit and catch up on our roundup of some of this week’s top stories in transport and urbanism. The header image shows Northcote Intermediate Students strolling across the Te Ara Awataha Greenway Bridge in ...
On a very wet Friday, we hope you have somewhere nice and warm and dry to sit and catch up on our roundup of some of this week’s top stories in transport and urbanism. The header image shows Northcote Intermediate Students strolling across the Te Ara Awataha Greenway Bridge in ...
The podcast above of the weekly ‘Hoon’ webinar for paying subscribers on Thursday night features co-hosts & talking about the week’s news with regular and special guests, including: and Elaine Monaghan on the week in geopolitics and climate, including Donald Trump’s tariff shock yesterday; and,Labour’s Disarmament and Associate ...
I'm gonna try real goodSwear that I'm gonna try from now on and for the rest of my lifeI'm gonna power on, I'm gonna enjoy the highsAnd the lows will come and goAnd may your dreamsAnd may your dreamsAnd may your dreams never dieSongwriters: Ben Reed.These are Stranger Days than ...
With the execution of global reciprocal tariffs, US President Donald Trump has issued his ‘declaration of economic independence for America’. The immediate direct effect on the Australian economy will likely be small, with more risk ...
The StrategistBy Jacqueline Gibson, Nerida King and Ned Talbot
AUKUS governments began 25 years ago trying to draw in a greater range of possible defence suppliers beyond the traditional big contractors. It is an important objective, and some progress has been made, but governments ...
I approach fresh Trump news reluctantly. It never holds the remotest promise of pleasure. I had the very, very least of expectations for his Rumble in the Jungle, his Thriller in Manila, his Liberation Day.God May 1945 is becoming the bitterest of jokes isn’t it?Whatever. Liberation Day he declared it ...
Beyond trade and tariff turmoil, Donald Trump pushes at the three core elements of Australia’s international policy: the US alliance, the region and multilateralism. What Kevin Rudd called the ‘three fundamental pillars’ are the heart ...
So, having broken its promise to the nation, and dumped 85% of submissions on the Treaty Principles Bill in the trash, National's stooges on the Justice Committee have decided to end their "consideration" of the bill, and report back a full month early: Labour says the Justice Select Committee ...
The 2024 Independent Intelligence Review offers a mature and sophisticated understanding of workforce challenges facing Australia’s National Intelligence Community (NIC). It provides a thoughtful roadmap for modernising that workforce and enhancing cross-agency and cross-sector collaboration. ...
OPINION AND ANALYSIS:Chief Ombudsman Peter Boshier’s comments singling out Health NZ for “acting contrary to the law” couldn’t be clearer. If you find my work of value, do consider subscribing and/or supporting me. Thank you.Health NZ has been acting a law unto itself. That includes putting its management under extraordinary ...
Southeast Asia’s three most populous countries are tightening their security relationships, evidently in response to China’s aggression in the South China Sea. This is most obvious in increased cooperation between the coast guards of the ...
In the late 1970s Australian sport underwent institutional innovation propelling it to new heights. Today, Australia must urgently adapt to a contested and confronting strategic environment. Contributing to this, a new ASPI research project will ...
In short this morning in our political economy:The Nelson Hospital waiting list crisis just gets worse, including compelling interviews with an over-worked surgeon who is leaving, and a patient who discovered after 19 months of waiting for a referral that her bowel and ovaries were fused together with scar tissue ...
Plainly, the claims being tossed around in the media last year that the new terminal envisaged by Auckland International Airport was a gold-plated “Taj Mahal” extravagance were false. With one notable exception, the Commerce Commission’s comprehensive investigation has ended up endorsing every other aspect of the airport’s building programme (and ...
Movements clustered around the Right, and Far Right as well, are rising globally. Despite the recent defeats we’ve seen in the last day or so with the win of a Democrat-backed challenger, Dane County Judge Susan Crawford, over her Republican counterpart, Waukesha County Judge Brad Schimel, in the battle for ...
In February 2025, John Cook gave two webinars for republicEN explaining the scientific consensus on human-caused climate change. 20 February 2025: republicEN webinar part 1 - BUST or TRUST? The scientific consensus on climate change In the first webinar, Cook explained the history of the 20-year scientific consensus on climate change. How do ...
After three decades of record-breaking growth, at about the same time as Xi Jinping rose to power in 2012, China’s economy started the long decline to its current state of stagnation. The Chinese Communist Party ...
The Pike River Coal mine was a ticking time bomb.Ventilation systems designed to prevent methane buildup were incomplete or neglected.Gas detectors that might warn of danger were absent or broken.Rock bolting was skipped, old tunnels left unsealed, communication systems failed during emergencies.Employees and engineers kept warning management about the … ...
Regional hegemons come in different shapes and sizes. Australia needs to think about what kind of hegemon China would be, and become, should it succeed in displacing the United States in Asia. It’s time to ...
RNZ has a story this morning about the expansion of solar farms in Aotearoa, driven by today's ground-breaking ceremony at the Tauhei solar farm in Te Aroha: From starting out as a tiny player in the electricity system, solar power generated more electricity than coal and gas combined for ...
After the Berlin Wall came down in 1989, and almost a year before the Soviet Union collapsed in late 1991, US President George H W Bush proclaimed a ‘new world order’. Now, just two months ...
Warning: Some images may be distressing. Thank you for those who support my work. It means a lot.A shopfront in Australia shows Liberal leader Peter Dutton and mining magnate Gina Rinehart depicted with Nazi imageryUS Government Seeks Death Penalty for Luigi MangioneMangione was publicly walked in front of media in ...
Today, the Oranga Tamariki (Repeal of Section 7AA) Amendment Bill has passed its third and final reading, but there is one more stage before it becomes law. The Governor-General must give their ‘Royal assent’ for any bill to become legally enforceable. This means that, even if a bill gets voted ...
Abortion care at Whakatāne Hospital has been quietly shelved, with patients told they will likely have to travel more than an hour to Tauranga to get the treatment they need. ...
Thousands of New Zealanders’ submissions are missing from the official parliamentary record because the National-dominated Justice Select Committee has rushed work on the Treaty Principles Bill. ...
Today’s announcement of 10 percent tariffs for New Zealand goods entering the United States is disappointing for exporters and consumers alike, with the long-lasting impact on prices and inflation still unknown. ...
The National Government’s choices have contributed to a slow-down in the building sector, as thousands of people have lost their jobs in construction. ...
Willie Apiata’s decision to hand over his Victoria Cross to the Minister for Veterans is a powerful and selfless act, made on behalf of all those who have served our country. ...
The Privileges Committee has denied fundamental rights to Debbie Ngarewa-Packer, Rawiri Waititi and Hana-Rawhiti Maipi-Clarke, breaching their own standing orders, breaching principles of natural justice, and highlighting systemic prejudice and discrimination within our parliamentary processes. The three MPs were summoned to the privileges committee following their performance of a haka ...
April 1 used to be a day when workers could count on a pay rise with stronger support for those doing it tough, but that’s not the case under this Government. ...
Winston Peters is shopping for smaller ferries after Nicola Willis torpedoed the original deal, which would have delivered new rail enabled ferries next year. ...
The Government should work with other countries to press the Myanmar military regime to stop its bombing campaign especially while the country recovers from the devastating earthquake. ...
The Green Party is calling for the Government to scrap proposed changes to Early Childhood Care, after attending a petition calling for the Government to ‘Put tamariki at the heart of decisions about ECE’. ...
New Zealand First has introduced a Member’s Bill today that will remove the power of MPs conscience votes and ensure mandatory national referendums are held before any conscience issues are passed into law. “We are giving democracy and power back to the people”, says New Zealand First Leader Winston Peters. ...
Welcome to members of the diplomatic corp, fellow members of parliament, the fourth estate, foreign affairs experts, trade tragics, ladies and gentlemen. ...
In recent weeks, disturbing instances of state-sanctioned violence against Māori have shed light on the systemic racism permeating our institutions. An 11-year-old autistic Māori child was forcibly medicated at the Henry Bennett Centre, a 15-year-old had his jaw broken by police in Napier, kaumātua Dean Wickliffe went on a hunger ...
Confidence in the job market has continued to drop to its lowest level in five years as more New Zealanders feel uncertain about finding work, keeping their jobs, and getting decent pay, according to the latest Westpac-McDermott Miller Employment Confidence Index. ...
The Greens are calling on the Government to follow through on their vague promises of environmental protection in their Resource Management Act (RMA) reform. ...
“Make New Zealand First Again” Ladies and gentlemen, First of all, thank you for being here today. We know your lives are busy and you are working harder and longer than you ever have, and there are many calls on your time, so thank you for the chance to speak ...
Hundreds more Palestinians have died in recent days as Israel’s assault on Gaza continues and humanitarian aid, including food and medicine, is blocked. ...
National is looking to cut hundreds of jobs at New Zealand’s Defence Force, while at the same time it talks up plans to increase focus and spending in Defence. ...
It’s been revealed that the Government is secretly trying to bring back a ‘one-size fits all’ standardised test – a decision that has shocked school principals. ...
The Government’s new planning legislation to replace the Resource Management Act will make it easier to get things done while protecting the environment, say Minister Responsible for RMA Reform Chris Bishop and Under-Secretary Simon Court. “The RMA is broken and everyone knows it. It makes it too hard to build ...
Trade and Investment Minister Todd McClay has today launched a public consultation on New Zealand and India’s negotiations of a formal comprehensive Free Trade Agreement. “Negotiations are getting underway, and the Public’s views will better inform us in the early parts of this important negotiation,” Mr McClay says. We are ...
More than 900 thousand superannuitants and almost five thousand veterans are among the New Zealanders set to receive a significant financial boost from next week, an uplift Social Development and Employment Minister Louise Upston says will help support them through cost-of-living challenges. “I am pleased to confirm that from 1 ...
Progressing a holistic strategy to unlock the potential of New Zealand’s geothermal resources, possibly in applications beyond energy generation, is at the centre of discussions with mana whenua at a hui in Rotorua today, Resources and Regional Development Minister Shane Jones says. The Coalition Government is in the early stages ...
New annual data has exposed the staggering cost of delays previously hidden in the building consent system, Building and Construction Minister Chris Penk says. “I directed Building Consent Authorities to begin providing quarterly data last year to improve transparency, following repeated complaints from tradespeople waiting far longer than the statutory ...
Increases in water charges for Auckland consumers this year will be halved under the Watercare Charter which has now been passed into law, Local Government Minister Simon Watts and Auckland Minister Simeon Brown say. The charter is part of the financial arrangement for Watercare developed last year by Auckland Council ...
There is wide public support for the Government’s work to strengthen New Zealand’s biosecurity protections, says Biosecurity Minister Andrew Hoggard. “The Ministry for Primary Industries recently completed public consultation on proposed amendments to the Biosecurity Act and the submissions show that people understand the importance of having a strong biosecurity ...
A new independent review function will enable individuals and organisations to seek an expert independent review of specified civil aviation regulatory decisions made by, or on behalf of, the Director of Civil Aviation, Acting Transport Minister James Meager has announced today. “Today we are making it easier and more affordable ...
The Government will invest in an enhanced overnight urgent care service for the Napier community as part of our focus on ensuring access to timely, quality healthcare, Health Minister Simeon Brown has today confirmed. “I am delighted that a solution has been found to ensure Napier residents will continue to ...
Health Minister Simeon Brown and Mental Health Minister Matt Doocey attended a sod turning today to officially mark the start of construction on a new mental health facility at Hillmorton Campus. “This represents a significant step in modernising mental health services in Canterbury,” Mr Brown says. “Improving health infrastructure is ...
Finance Minister Nicola Willis has welcomed confirmation the economy has turned the corner. Stats NZ reported today that gross domestic product grew 0.7 per cent in the three months to December following falls in the June and September quarters. “We know many families and businesses are still suffering the after-effects ...
The sealing of a 12-kilometre stretch of State Highway 43 (SH43) through the Tangarakau Gorge – one of the last remaining sections of unsealed state highway in the country – has been completed this week as part of a wider programme of work aimed at improving the safety and resilience ...
A scary look inside the inboxes of two recent politicians. Damon has worked as a social media content creator for the Green Party and helps create content for Wellington mayor Tory Whanau. This piece is written in his own capacity as a private citizen. Opinions do not represent the Wellington ...
In a selection of anonymous quotes, a group of female parliamentarians from across the political spectrum give an insight into what they deal with. A study published today has called for urgent action in response to harassment of female MPs in New Zealand. The researchers from the department of psychological ...
A recent High Court ruling has raised alarm bells about the long-term integrity of Treaty settlements – and concern over how a little-known clause in the Fisheries Act could cost iwi millions. In 1992, the Crown and Māori reached what was meant to be a “full and final” settlement over ...
Temepara Bailey and Leana de Bruin can read each other’s minds. They can glance across the netball court and communicate with a simple nod. They finish each other’s sentences.Their relationship has built over 25 years to ‘best mate’ status, and it’s about to take on a new dimension as they ...
Consumers just aren’t feeling it. It’s been clear enough in the anecdote. But, over the past couple of weeks, we’ve seen an unsettling sputtering in a broadening suite of retail spending indicators as well.It started with a sharp and unexpected drop in Westpac’s consumer confidence index for the March quarter. ...
Comment: When the US launched fresh airstrikes on Yemen last month, it signalled the continuation of a strategy that has failed for more than 20 years to weaken the Houthi rebels. While bombing Houthi assets in Yemen will reduce the group’s ability to attack ships in the Red Sea, such ...
Three Te Pāti Māori MPs have two weeks to end their deadlock with the Privileges Committee over their refusal to front up at a hearing into their haka last November, or they’ll face serious consquences.They can’t be sacked or imprisoned – The Privileges Committee tried to imprison someone once but ...
Analysis: Researching my book The Science of the Māori Lunar Calendar has deepened my appreciation of Mātauranga Māori and its importance to the lives of New Zealanders past and present. Not long ago, Māori knowledge was largely disregarded by the scientific community and treated as little more than myth and ...
The bus heading south from Cork airport left twenty minutes before my plane arrived, on time, from London. The next one was not due for another two hours. From all the stereotypes I had inherited, this seemed very Irish. As did the moniker “Emerald Isle”. Flying in, the June landscape ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Kaitlyn DeGhetto, Associate Professor of Management, University of Dayton To attract business investment, American cities and states offer companies billions of dollars in incentives, such as tax credits. As the theory goes, when governments create a business-friendly environment, it encourages investment, leading ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra The election’s first debate, on Sky News on Tuesday night, was disappointingly dull. Viewers who’d been following the campaign would have learned little. There was minimal spontaneity. Among the 100 undecided voters in the room, ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Corey J. A. Bradshaw, Matthew Flinders Professor of Global Ecology and Node Leader in the ARC Centre of Excellence for Indigenous and Environmental Histories and Futures, Flinders University A coral ‘rope’ nursery in the MaldivesLuca Saponari/University of Milan, CC BY-ND Coral ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Andy Marks, Vice-President, Public Affairs and Partnerships, Western Sydney University Prime Minister Anthony Albanese and Opposition Leader Peter Dutton have faced off in the first leaders’ debate of the 2025 federal election. The debate, hosted by Sky News and The Daily Telegraph, ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Dorina Pojani, Associate Professor in Urban Planning, The University of Queensland Fizkes/Shutterstock In the pre-industrial era, people often lived and worked in the same building. This removed the need to travel to work. The separation of home and work occurred much ...
The plan would ensure that Aotearoa meets its climate obligations and guarantees a just transition for the workers and communities who will bear the brunt of the climate crisis and technological change. ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Sebastian Rosenberg, Associate Professor, Health Research Institute, University of Canberra, and Brain and Mind Centre, University of Sydney mooremedia/Shutterstock The Labor government has announced it would invest A$1 billion in mental health if re-elected to provide more Australians – particularly young ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Fergus Edwards, Lecturer in English, University of Tasmania Amazon MGM Studios Last One Laughing is a battle royale for stand-ups. Ten comedians, one room, surrounded by cameras. Laugh once and they’re warned. Laugh again, and they’re out. Last comic left wins. ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Ben Singh, Research Fellow, Allied Health & Human Performance, University of South Australia Centre for Ageing Better/Unsplash Many of us turn to Sudoku, Wordle or brain-training apps to sharpen our minds. But research is increasingly showing one of the best ways ...
The coalition government is scrapping the 30-day rule that automatically signs an employee up to the collective agreement when they sign on to a new job. ...
Greenpeace says that the Federated Farmers list of Greenpeace protests is far from comprehensive and omits dozens of examples of direct action that have played a key role in bringing about positive change in Aotearoa and beyond. ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Christina McCabe, PhD Candidate in Interdisciplinary Ecology, University of Canterbury Shutterstock/synthetick If left unaddressed, many environmental changes in Aotearoa New Zealand could threaten livelihoods, health, quality of life and infrastructure for generations to come, according to the latest update on the ...
By Susana Suisuiki, RNZ Pacific journalist Pasifika comedy troupe Naked Samoans is facing a backlash from some members of the Pacific community over its promotional poster. In the image, which has now been taken down, the Naked Samoans depicted themselves as the 12 disciples surrounding Jesus, a parody of The ...
Liv Sisson reads the roller coaster that is Naomi Arnold’s epic account of walking Te Araroa. Every fucking inch. That’s the approach some trampers take to Te Araroa – the long distance hiking track that runs the length of Aotearoa New Zealand. Others are happy to hitchhike the road sections. ...
Make no mistake, this is a deliberate attempt to undermine the role of unions in workplaces and prevent working people from securing good pay and conditions when they take on a job in a new workplace. ...
Mehdi Hasan, like a number here, has been a true believer in the regime change conspiracy theory, and even gone as far as justifying Russian and Iranian intervention as being necessary to counter it.
But in his latest essay Mehdi Hasan has taken on the issue that many here have assiduously avoided, the massive war crimes amounting to genocide committed by the Assad regime.
The many links attached to his essay are worth reading on their own.
Personally I don’t agree with Hasan’s view that the rebels are as bad as the regime. And I think the jury is still out on the issue of the gas attack in Douma, which even a close reading of Robert Fisk’s essay allows.
But the fact that someone like Mehdi Hasan can shift his opinion gives me hope that someone like Bill and others like him could shift their opinion. And that my efforts here have not been wasted.
“Dear Bashar al-Assad Apologists: Your Hero Is a War Criminal Even If He Didn’t Gas Syrians”
Or Maybe readers here would like more Eva Bartlett
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jhUXBI2LHsM
Any takers?
Definitely more Eva Bartlett for me thanks
Yeah, I guess Assad should just lie down and play dead; and let ISL overrun his country.
Hassan Diab was a wee boy filmed being doused in water after that supposed chemical attack. He says…
http://metro.co.uk/2018/04/19/russia-says-video-boy-doused-water-syria-chemical-attack-fake-news-7480472/
Bill, if you accept that it’s possible this boy was duped and bribed to appear in a “fake news” video showing people dealing with the effects of gas, why can’t you accept that it’s possible that the boy and his father were intimidated and bribed into appearing in a fake news denouncement of that earlier video?
And even the story in your link says 75 people were killed. Were they also crisis actors?
I’m not claiming great expertise in this area, I just tend to question conspiracy theories.
The “bribed” theory contradicts the story told to Fisk that:
So someone touting the “it never happened” theory is almost certainly making shit up. Cue a complicated explanation for the plot holes in this latest farce…
I expect the answer to”So, why defend him?” is simple.
The crimes of Hitler, Stalin, Mao, Pol Pot, Henry Kissinger, and George W. Bush are well documented.
There is no evidence the Bashar Assad has committed any crime.
Surely it is for Syrians, who live in, and have recently returned to Syria,and in 2014 voted overwhelmingly for him as their President, to judge their President.
Not you, nor I nor Mehdi Hasan who is an Al Jazeera reporter.
You will know that Al Jazeera is a owned by Qatar and that Qatar has funded the extremists in Syria.
https://gulfnews.com/news/gulf/qatar/how-qatar-funded-extremists-in-syria-1.2040774
“Maybe Robert Fisk’s mysterious doctor has it right — and maybe the hundreds of survivors and eyewitnesses to the attack are all “crisis actors.”……”
Crisis Actors would be a great name for a punk band right now
Mehdi Hassan is an emotive fool. I’ve seen him debate Richard Dawkins and Dawkins (not a great debater himself and philosophically naive when it comes to religion) wiped the floor with him.
Anyone trying to bring modern, secular and ultimately civilised rule to a disparate unruly and fundamentally backward people has to resort to stern measures, and unfortunately there will be collateral damage. But the alternatives are far worse.
Then Mehdi trots out the usual parade of Western caricatured ‘dictators’ mixed in with his own liberal establishment anointed villains such as Kissinger and Bush. Kissinger had many redeeming qualities, and Stalin and Mao are among the greatest figures in world history, true titans who changed the world for the better.
“Anyone trying to bring modern, secular and ultimately civilised rule to a disparate unruly and fundamentally backward people has to resort to stern measures,”
Just calling you out on your cultural racism again.
Dirty racist.
It’s absolute common sense that different peoples are at different stages of civilisational development.
For example the Chinese openly admit to having fallen behind culturally and scientifically the past few centuries. They need a strong hand to guide them to a higher stage of cultural and social and economic accomplishment.
The real racists are those who want to keep non-western people down by lauding the backward practices of the latter —knowing that cultural ignorance and superstition will keep people of colour mired in the shit forever.
Re read your own vomitus from the last 48 hours.
Good on ya! Appreciate it.
You would make a great colonist. Or maybe you could try the modern equivalent of the missionaries that went forth to save the souls of the unfortunate heathens by starting an NGO to educate and assimillate the diverse people of the world to suit your taste of what civilized means. I’d go with keepcalmcarryon on this one and say definitely racist. Give me the shit mire any day over your pompous venom
Calmer supermarketing – a great idea: https://www.stuff.co.nz/business/103229404/retailers-conscious-of-need-to-provide-for-all-customers-including-special-needs
This a great initiative.
Thanks for putting up this link. AsleepWhileWalking* put up a Herald article on the Marton Countdown on Open mike yesterday, but that article did not answer my questions in my reply to AWW as to frequency and whether Countdown were trialling this in Marton for possible rollout throughout NZ as they are doing with instore pharmacies. This Stuff article has these details.
The instore pharmacies are excellent for being open seven days a week and for about 12 hours per day, and their lower per item prescription charges of $3 as opposed to the standard $5.
* https://thestandard.org.nz/open-mike-19-04-2018/#comment-1476108
Jenny, I’m confused, I read your post and watched the video clip of Eva Bartlett, and they seen to be saying two entirely different things.
Medhi Hasan is saying we shouldn’t make a hero of Assad – which I don’t believe any commentator on here has attempted to do. He’s a vile dictator, with few redeeming virtues.
On the other hand Eva Bartlett is saying that the rebels are worse – which again most commentators would accept.
What most people here are suggesting is that Assad, for all his faults, is not stupid. Why would he use chemical weapons, a red rag to a bull for the West, when he’s all but winning? That is the not-credible part.
And most commentators are asking for evidence of the crime and who perpetrated it before going in boots and all and bombing the hell out of Syria.
Sorry, meant to be a reply to Jenny @2
“the rebels are worse – which most commentators would accept.”
What complete nonsense. Assad has killed literally hundreds of thousands of people, the majority being civilians. He has used massive airstrikes, used gas, used barrel bombs on residential neighbourhoods, hospitals and schools.
His brutality opened the way for ISIS (also brutal) in both Syria and Iraq.
The Arab Spring in Syria never needed to be like this. It wasn’t in other countries. He could have accepted some of the demands of the protests back in 2011. Instead he massacred them, just like his father.
Bit of a head chopper fan there huh Wayne?
It would not be unreasonable, given your background and ‘experience’, Wayne…
To expect that you mght back up the comments you post here with a link, some well reasoned explanations which include the mainstream interference of ‘The West SAUDI and Israel’…who are directly responsible for IsIs…IRAQ, LIBYA, YEMEN, SOUTH SUDAN, LEBANON…ETC
Instead you take another huge turd and run away…not a cursory attempt to substantiate, by my count at least 13 highly suspect aspects in your comment…
A number of which have been openly including via MSM sources…rebuked and shown to be incorrect…and outright bullshit…
So the question becomes…
Why do you continue on this path, Wayne…what drives your behaviour…
As we move through stages of life, we should learn and grow…not remain static or regress…which is what your comments indicate…
Gosh… all those ellipses… seem mighty.. familiar.
See my response to you in the daily review, sacha…if you haven’t already…
Your bitterness is still showing…
Jumping on my response to Wayne, says that…
when I need an amateur psychologist I’ll let you know phil.
Shoot the messenger.
Ignore the message.
Message corrupted. Please retransmit en clair.
The pidgin has reached the target.
Further confirmation that Douma was a lie.
Got this off Robin Westenra’s excellent website.
Douma: a staged chemical weapons attack
Agreed Wayne.
His brutality opened the way for ISIS (also brutal) in both Syria and Iraq.
Roight. So the destruction of Iraq had nothing to do with the rise of ISIS. I’m glad we have that one out of the way.
What about Timber Sycamore? The clandestine funding and arming of groups in Syria by the US (US$1 Billion worth according to the NYT). The US knew their stuff was falling into the hands of the likes of Al Nusra. I guess that has nothing whatsoever to do with the rise of Jahidist elements in Syria either.
We’re often on opposite sides Bill – but you’re quite right: Assad had nothing to do with the rise of ISIS.
I think prefer this bloke’s reasoning on why ISIS fancied Syria.
Oh yes thats for sure. Just as well “something was done” about Libya and Iraq to make sure they didnt become magnets for Jihadis and that “something is being done” about Yemen to stop that becoming a Jihadi magnet. Wherever would we be if “something” wasn’t being done somewhere? Maybe people would be able to make decisions about their own futures but then I suppose that “something would have to be done” about that
The Free Syrian Army were a legitimate opposition force comprised of Syrian soldiers who defected from Assad with the understanding that the west would aid them in removing him.
The west didn’t assist the FSA and members defected again to join well armed, cashed up militias.
And here we are, sitting on our hands while Assad goes about doing what any half decent despot does, slaughtering any and all opposition with impunity.
Which is the proper place for our hands to be unless you think Libya was a good idea or along with Albright you think the suffering of Yemen is “worth it”
It’s all kind of like the abusive home thing – someone always knows, never do anything about it, and after the fact it’s all it’s not good but we did nothing, because.
/
It’s nothing like that in the slightest…
Russophobia paralyzes your thinking…
Every aspect of Syria then must bend to fit around it…and therefore rational thought is impossible…
That is clear!
A pretty bad analogy I would say and most people would recognize that violence in the form of bullets, grenades and missiles is a pretty inappropriate response to domestic violence.
“The Arab Spring in Syria never needed to be like this.”
Yeah they could have chosen the model failed state pathway like Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya, Egypt did…
A lot of Arab countries felt they were halfway failed states already. They never devolved much power to their people.
“…the rebels are worse – which again most commentators would accept.”
You are wrong.
Well, Wayne and Ad, we won’t quibble over degrees of vileness! Suffice to say that I wouldn’t want to live under either of them.
But that’s missing the point – why would Assad act the way he is said to have?
Because he is extremely ruthless, just like his father. Their power comes from fear and repression of any one who would dare oppose.
The gas attacks, even after they had succeeded in Douma, are designed to underscore the point that those who leave will never come back.
And Russia has no influence over this monster? Or are the Russians just as bad – which seems to be the prevailing narrative?
Here in New Zealand we tolerate dissent because we know that dissenters are not likely to be biffing molotov cocktails around. I think we would be being somewhat ethnocentric if we thought that this also applied in all other countries.
Here in NZ we do trumped up terrorists raids and send real want to be terrorists to play golf.
http://www.newshub.co.nz/home/new-zealand/2018/04/radicalised-teen-who-planned-terrorist-style-attack-takes-up-golf-in-rehabilitation-process.html
Yeah Wayne he is a ruthless murderous dictator who will allow no political opposition – he is also a secular dictator who allowed minorities to live safely and allowed woman equality.
The Al Queda (whatever their current label) and ISIS groups are lunatic murdering Sunni Wahhabist zealots who gleefully (and have a compulsion for) murder and enslaving all those who do not follow their branch of faith – they also wouldn’t know what women’s rights were if they were tattooed on their damn foreheads.
Which group do you support again Wayne? Really?
Barfly
Don’t be so ridiculous as to suggest I support ISIS.
It may have escaped your notice, but the US, UK and France have all had a vigorous campaign against ISIS. NZ has also been involved in the coalition against ISIS with trainers and intelligence staff (which seems to be now supported by the coalition – they have not done anything to withdraw them).
It is actually possible to oppose both Assad and ISIS.
However the west seems to have given up on trying to oust Assad. Their recent actions are merely to restrain him from using gas.
“His brutality opened the way for ISIS (also brutal) in both Syria and Iraq”
Err no Wayne that would be Bush and the bleeping USA in Iraq
The Syrian Free Army has exposed as a myth.
You have not taken issue with Al Queda in Syria.
So do you oppose that particular bunch of lunatic murdering Sunni Wahhabist zealots? If so who is it that you support?
“NZ has also been involved in the coalition ”
“It is simply irresponsible to focus criticism on inadvertent casualties caused by the Coalition’s war to defeat ISIS,” Col. Thomas Veale, a spokesperson for the coalition, told the AP.
https://www.vox.com/world/2017/12/20/16800510/mosul-death-toll-isis-trump-war
another war crime Wayne?
Timber Sycamore. Western government funding of the White Helmets. Funding and advising terrorists on media matters. Not exactly indicative of a “vigorous campaign against ISIS”.
In fact, the only “vigorous campaign against” that the US, UK and France have had (for right or wrong) is the one they have mounted against the government of Syria.
And when that has meant aiding and abetting Al Nusa/Al Qaeda/ISIS, then it’s okay “because Assad”.
“It is actually possible to oppose both Assad and ISIS.”
Rather difficult I would have thought.
It was difficult – but the ruins of Mosul show that it was done.
Don’t be ridiculous, mikesh. Both can be seen as extremists and damaging. Not all conflicts have good guys and bad guys.
Either ISIS will win or Assad will win. It is difficult not to have an opinion as to which outcome would be better. In other words it would not be be possible to “oppose both sides” as Wayne was claiming.
Rubbish. ISIS have basically lost already. Assad’s forces are not significant in that fight, his war is on ‘his’ own citizens.
Geez Wayne. A vigorous campaign against would not include funnelling arms by the truckload from Libya to Syria nor supporting ngos that operate solely for the benefit of head choppers. If there were a vote in Syria today Assad would win hands down.I don’t know what his poularity was before the war but there is a lot of evidence that the US believed his popularity was such that a revolution would not take hold.
https://gowans.wordpress.com/?s=origin+of+syrian+war
So if you want to do a study of comparative evil so that we may once again be coralled into supporting your lesser evil doctrines thats fine but please leave me out. It is for the Syrian people to decide their future and the more the USA supports the head choppers and their misogynist philosophy the more the Syrian people will stick with Assad
Be fair, Barfly – I don’t think Wayne is supporting either group. He’s already said ISIS are also brutal and he’s expressed sorrow that this awful situation has arisen.
“the rebels are worse – which most commentators would accept.”
“What complete nonsense. ” Comment by Wayne
That comment irked me RB -The rebels are a lot worse IMO.
That opinion of yours doesn’t seem to be all that “humble”, based on the evidence shown in this discussion, Barfly.
I said IMO not IMHO
Why do you continue to post unsubstantiated, and more roundly…refuted statements on a site which is in no alignment with your blatant ideological bent…
What drives your behaviour, Wayne…
Raise the level, Wayne…you’re not even fooling yourselves with the nonsense comments you post…
So you might as well stop trying…and take a good long look in the mirror…hang your head…
So, on the brink of victory, he risks defeat, with the one thing that will prompt foreign intervention.
Assad is not stupid.
He’s killed a shitload of people for a ‘smart guy’.
And legislation to make damn sure.
If the implementation of Law No. 10 of 2018 is anything like that of prior redevelopment regulations, including Decree No. 66 of 2012, which the new law amends and expands, the legislation can be expected not only to line the pockets of Assad regime cronies through new redevelopment projects at the expense of dispossessed property owners who receive insufficient compensation, but also to disproportionately target previous opposition strongholds for demographic change. Decree No. 66 allowed Syrian authorities to “redevelop areas of unauthorized housing and informal settlements” in two specifically designated locations in Damascus. Although the areas were in fact lower and middle-class neighborhoods that could—to a casual observer—seem to be legitimate targets for redevelopment, they were unique in being opposition strongholds. In fact, similar neighborhoods that were largely aligned with the Assad government and at similar socioeconomic backgrounds were left untouched by this displacement and redevelopment scheme.
https://timep.org/commentary/with-new-law-assad-tells-syrians-not-to-come-home/
Informed comment on road safety stories: https://www.greaterauckland.org.nz/2018/04/20/covering-news-motorways-safety/
When it comes to road safety, there’s a whole lot of really simple, cheap improvements that could be done and aren’t. Starting with just some yellow paint.
How many of the little white crosses on the roadside are very close to short visibility corners where the centreline is marked with a single dashed white line?
On SH1, just north of Puhoi where the speed limit goes back up to 100, the centreline has just been changed to a wide double yellow with rumble strips. That appears to have dropped average speeds by around 10km/h.
Meanwhile further north in Dome Valley where the speed limit is 80, the centreline is still marked with single dashed white (including around blind corners), and they’ve just installed a speed camera in the middle of the first long straight going north where it’s viable to pass a particularly slow vehicle. But no surprise, in this stretch typical speeds are still nudging much closer to a safe limit than on the stretch further south marked with double yellow lines.
Ffs, even Zimbabwe in the late 90s was able to paint double yellow lines around pretty much all blind corners, with arrows in the roadway telling drivers to get back on their correct side an appropriate distance before the corner.
Rumble strips have an amazing cost-benefit rating. We can also afford lots of them if the money is not being squandered on a handful of gold-plated duplicate highways.
While they may be cost effective, the problem with rumble strips is they don’t physically stop cars from crossing the centre line. Take a sleeping driver for example, by the time they are alerted from the rumble, they’ll potentially be looking at a head on.
True. I understand they are better at stopping single vehicle crashes off the side of the road.
Meet the councillors moonlighting as West Auckland’s booze and gambling tsars
https://thespinoff.co.nz/business/13-04-2018/meet-the-councillors-moonlighting-as-west-aucklands-booze-and-gambling-tsars/
Palmerston North council draws fire for housing rent-hike plan
https://www.stuff.co.nz/manawatu-standard/news/103156209/palmerston-north-council-draws-fire-for-housing-renthike-plan
It seems the Palmerston North City Council expect the city’s most vulnerable to pay (via a rent hike) for additional council housing.
Council housing portfolio holder Susan Baty said the proposal was the best overall solution.
“There’s a real need for additional council housing, but there wasn’t any funds available for that in the 10-year-plan. This was a way around that.”
Gordon Campbell on the GCSB’s security hang-up with Russia
http://www.scoop.co.nz/stories/HL1804/S00060/gordon-campbell-on-the-gcsbs-security-hang-up-with-russia.htm
PM makes Time Top 100 Most Influential
“She’s not just leading a nation, she’s changing the game”, – Sheryl Sandberg, Facebook chief operating officer.
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=12036134
Not sure if anyone from Facebook is worth quoting at the moment
Aww…..little sausage get all bent cos gurlie swat gets a mention.
/
That’ll get the RWNJ foaming at the mouth
Not at all.
Good on her.
Odd that you confess to being a not job but cheers for your honesty
Thank you James. It is a warming thing when you meet someone and think “WOW you will be a mover and a shaker, but in a real grounded warm way”.
She is the real deal.
Lol Hooch, it had mark richardson throwing a tanty on morning TV.
Super funny, richardson is having great difficulty dealing with the popularity of our new PM. mark richardson was sweet as with john key getting attention on the world stage, but dang, Jacinda is cleaning up and richardson quite possibly needs counselling to get through it.
If there’s a video link, will post he was angry as, I couldn’t stop laughing.
Haha, there is a clip of the bitter mark richardson from this morning….
http://www.newshub.co.nz/home/new-zealand/2018/04/mark-richardson-sick-of-media-s-jacinda-ardern-sanctimony.html
N and I cracked up Cinny.
Changing the game?
Slightly adjusting the team roster.
Posted yesterday but deserves to be so again….some enlightened thinking, well expressed.
https://www.radionz.co.nz/national/programmes/ninetonoon/audio/2018641349/reserve-bank-governor-adrian-orr
I’m sure everyone will agree that the National government did good work in this area and hopefully the present government will continue along the same lines
https://www.kiwiblog.co.nz/2018/04/youth_offending_down.html
The Youth Justice Indicators Summary report shows that actually youth offending has been dropping under the last Government. It compares 2009/10 to 2016/17. The findings are:
Child (10 to 13) offending rate down 59%
Youth (14 to 16) offending rate down 63%
Pasifika youth offending rate down 61%
Maori youth offending rate down 59%
Heres the report:
https://www.justice.govt.nz/assets/Documents/Publications/Youth-Justice-Indicators-Summary-Report-201804.pdf
Will be interesting to see the stats in a few years.
It may indeed be a National government that can take a lot of the credit, but it might be Bolger’s, not Key’s. Leaded petrol was finally banned in New Zealand in 1996 for road use, although there’s still some in aviation fuel.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lead-crime_hypothesis
Well that might be a reason
I seem to recollect a change in police procedure whereby minor offences were treated by police warnings rather than arrests – great way to juke comparative stats PR – a bit like when National redefined unemployment and knocked half a % from the unemployment (official) rate and proclaimed their governance skills loudly.
I also recall previous governments refining unemployed as sickness beneficiaries to lower the unemployment rate
I see you aren’t disagreeing with me that the last National Government juked the stats by changing procedures and definitions. Thank you for that.
If thats how you want to take it then bully for you I guess
Yes Barfly. Collin’s contribution!!
Yet in Herald today
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=12036187
Murder charges laid in Hawke’s Bay this week underscore a troubling trend – young offenders are responsible for or accused of a growing proportion of overall crime.
The proportion of young people whose offending was serious enough to lead to court action or family group conferences has risen by 19 per cent between 2013/14 and 2016/17, after very little change from 2009/10 to 2013/14.
There is a useful graph in the article.
Or they could just be getting it wrong:
It’s unfortunate that I have to have doubts in what the police say but they do have form.
Perhaps they are dead?
https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/health/96217175/national-suicide-numbers-rise-three-years-in-a-row
Don’t crow over some doctored stats until you fix the important stuff, we know the Nats don’t actually give a shit about anyone that isn’t rich.
the trick looking at population stats is to look at them per thousand(s) population in the relevant demographic. That gets rid of those pesky issues of shifting demographics.
Otherwise the stats aren’t really worth even looking at. They are just PR froth.
Which is what your numbers look like. Doesn’t make me want to read the report. Makes you look like a mindless shock jock wanking
Feeling hungry? You ain’t seen nothing yet!
Farah Hancock reporting on Food Symposium.
Dr Mike Joy:
https://www.newsroom.co.nz/2018/04/19/105585/a-future-where-food-is-off-the-menu
Which is something that I and many others have been asking for awhile: How many people can the Earth sustainably hold?
It appears to be significantly below the number that presently live. And the only way that can end is in tragedy.
Kathryn Ryan, the scourge of helpless civil servants
RNZ National, Friday 20 April 2018, 9:10 a.m.
I’ve just heard Kathryn Ryan conduct a sarcastic, hectoring, bumptious interrogation of Census general manager Denise McGregor. “I know“, Ryan scolded her several times during the mauling. What a pity Ryan saves all of her unpleasantness for underlings and civil servants; in stark contrast, she simpers and agrees with the politicians who are responsible for debacles like this year’s census.
I’d agree except that in many cases the scourge of helpless civil servants seems to be, more often than not, their own senior corporatised management.
As we’re seeing more and more, there are some real muppets amongst them and they have a vested interest in preserving the status quo.
Quite true, Tim. However, in this case Kathryn Ryan was simply unleashing her full retinue of sarcasm and feigned exasperation on an underling. The contrast to her handling of genuinely nasty people like Matthew Hooton and Dame Ann Leslie could not be any greater….
https://thestandard.org.nz/open-mike-03122015/#comment-1104309
https://thestandard.org.nz/open-mike-06102015/#comment-1078888
Have you got any proof that this years census was a debacle?
Everything I saw while working there indicated that it went off pretty well. There were a few issues but, as the Stats people said, it usually takes months to complete the census anyway.
This was the first time that they did it this way. There was bound to be mistakes made and lessons learned. That doesn’t make it a debacle.
How many people have been recorded so far? What percentage of the total is that and how does it compare to the percentage after 6 weeks last time?
You say you worked there. I assume therefore you can answer such simple questions?
You’d have to ask Stats for the answers to those questions. I just related that it was going fairly well when I worked there. At the time, the Stats people seemed happy with the way it was going. Some three million people filled the form in online by the 7th which is pretty good.
Most of what I’ve seen when people have said that it’s all a fuckup it seems to come down to ZOMG, it’s different from before and I don’t like it so therefore it can’t be working well.
Well Stats certainly aren’t being proactive.
The last release they gave was dated 20 March. That was when they were up to about 3.5 million out of an anticipated 4.8 million.
Since then there hasn’t been a peep out of them.
https://www.stats.govt.nz/news/census-on-track-for-70-percent-online
Traditionally they get about 98% all up.
Yawn.
So, listening to the interview that you obviously didn’t (although to be fair it’s not like Morrissey listend to what was there, either), they’re working on roughly the last ten percent of the population, this isn’t that different from last census (as far as that comparison is relevant), but exact numbers are difficult to track at this stage because things like collation of household resident numbers against individual returns without addresses is actually part of the process they are undertaking at the moment.
My guess is that the initial release was of the low-hanging fruit (returned forms that all tabulated perfectly) and that you’re literally asking for information that doesn’t exist yet.
This will
shutcheer you up, Alwyn:http://www.radionz.co.nz/national/programmes/ninetonoon/audio/2018641517/census-reminder-letters-sent-to-180k-households
http://www.radionz.co.nz/news/national/355615/tens-of-thousands-of-nzers-still-to-complete-census
No, not a debacle, more bugger’s muddle.
I was out of the country, tho’ I had a friend also ‘working there’ (in that place….ooops ‘space’ you apparently were).
More a bugger’s muddle that’ll eventually sort itself out……possibly…..maybe…..hopefully.
Pretty bluddy marvellous for one whose Honeymoon is said to be over?
“Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern makes Time magazine’s 100 most influential list.”
“”A designation of individuals whose time, in our estimation, is now”, Time said.”
“In a world that too often tells women to stay small, keep quiet—and that we can’t have both motherhood and a career—Jacinda Ardern proves how wrong and outdated those notions of womanhood are.”
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=12036134
After the honeymoon, of course, comes hopefully a lifetime of domestic harmony and bliss!
Whoever believed the honeymoon was the only pleasurable and productive part of marriage?
Yep Mac1. The real proof is the overcoming of the adversities with strength and humour. Good on yer Jacinda.
Hopefully MSM will accord our PM the praise she deserves after the impact and impression she has made overseas. I have never seen Angela Merkel quite so warm and smiley! And to use the word “fun”. The world needs a smile in the midst of the turmoil. The Daily Mail has some great photos of Jacinda and she looks so gracious and dignified. Yes, we should be very proud of her.
Anyone else disappointed by Jacinda saying NZ accepted the US, UK and France striking out at Syria, despite there being insufficient evidence to do so?
Nope, not disappointed at all
Do you hold shares in weapon manufacturing?
http://fortune.com/2017/04/07/syria-airstrikes-tomahawk-missile-boeing-raytheon-stock/
http://www.newshub.co.nz/home/politics/2018/04/syria-pm-s-position-firmly-on-the-fence-isn-t-good-enough.html
• Australia says it “supports” the airstrikes in Syria – it’s even considering joining the next round.
• Canada “supports” them too.
• Germany called them “necessary and appropriate” and also used the S-word, “support”.
• NATO “supports” them.
• The European Union “stands with our allies on the side of justice”.
The attacks came after yet another gas attack that killed 75 people, including children.
And Bandwagoning is still a logical fallacy.
So is the fallacy fallacy…something you are often guilty of
Point to all of them.
Or retract.
Well, you are keen on using the word.
27 uses in comments on the first search page, you have 9 of them.
But I’m sure you’re right to use it 100% of the time lol
johnSellway made a very specific accusation which is not covered by your simplistic search. I want him to back it up or retract.
“Often” is not specific.
He accused me of using the fallacy fallacy often. He needs to prove it or retract.
Draco – firstly you on two occasions accused me of making an argument from authority when A) I hadn’t and B) you made no attempt at refuting what I was saying and just accused me of making a fallacy as if that disproved the point I was making (it didn’t). That is the fallacy fallacy at work – same as here. You didn’t address the points made, just accused the poster of making a fallacy as if that wins the argument. It doesn’t because you are making the fallacy fallacy.
Secondly I am under no obligation to retract. You have on several occasions accused me of being a right-winger (again – to some how claim victory in debate without actually addressing the points I may have been making) without any evidence whatsoever so you are hardly in any position to demand others to provide evidence or retract given your own past history of making claims about others.
So I guess what I am saying is – fuck you. You have no moral or intellectual high ground here.
Unless you’re arguing that you’ve never tried to dismiss an entire perspective or comment because it uses a fallacy, how do you define “often”?
Draco Draco Draco, PLEASE! Don’t back down!
Fuk ’em! PLEASE! Your ego and ideology is at stake!
(It’s increasingly hard to agree with many of your points of view when you are increasingly becoming a complete fucking wanker. I used to see a DracotB worthy of an opinion – usually with evidence based kaka that at least propped up his view. Not so lately.
People can challenge you with an opposing view based on lived experiences, yet – yea well…..
No ………. pfffffffffft.
I’ll continue to consider your ideas and contributions, but ffs – your cock isn’t actually as big as you think it is
You demanded to know who had filled in the Political Compass in such a way as to say that the who was important when it wasn’t. You even specifically asked what authority they had. An appeal to authority.
I wasn’t using it to debunk your argument (you hadn’t made one after all) but using it to say that the who simply wasn’t important.
And I did address your point. I explained why it was useful and the methodology that they used (The same methodology that I was taught in uni political science).
At no point did you counter my points. You just made assertions about it being an anonymous survey when it obviously isn’t.
That’s not how the appeal to authority works
Even it was appeals to authority are not always falicious
The methodology isn’t clear at all
It was completed anonymously
Four strikes, pal.
Corbyn was against them. Sanders was against them. Sturgeon was against them. Melenchon was against them.
These are the people who represent the politics that are on the cusp of usurping Liberalism. So there’s hope of sanity prevailing in the ‘not too distant’.
P.S. It’s pretty obvious to all but the most one-eyed that there was no gas attack.
British Major General Jonathan Shaw sounds like he was against them.
But then we don’t know.
Because Sky News does not believe in free speech,
It was good she didn’t fully support it but disappointing she accepted it considering there is insufficient evidence to lay blame at this stage.
Have people heard that the health committee responding to submitters on the medical cannabis bill had their emails published in the clear. Meaning when you got an email from them, you got everyone else’s email address. Including those people who wanted to do submissions anomisiously.
Must be fun to be part of government, smash people’s privacy apart, then offer up a lame excuse.
It gets worse, the replies people have sent into the committee, have been sent in the clear to other submitters as well.
Looking on bright side, let me know when you find one…
It’s the effect of doing things on the cheap rather investing in proper software. It’s why I think the NZ Government needs an IT department that produces all of it’s software from OS up. Make it so shit like this simply cannot happen because they got a good deal from Microsoft for Office and use the completely inadequate Outlook for email.
That’s not about choice of software, it’s people not knowing how to use it.
I think my favourite example was whena local campaigner sent email #500 to a local council organisation, and the frontline recipient forwarded to their manager (who had been a corecipient of the original email) something like “do you want to handle this? I can’t deal with this bloody idiot anymore”. Hit “reply all” instead of “forward”…
good for popcorn consumption, that one.
Yes, there’s certainly some of that but software in that sort of situation shouldn’t even allow such a breach of privacy. All sorts of restrictions on who can see and do what has been around in software for decades now. It shouldn’t be that hard to understand that we need to have the software doing that for government as well.
Unsurprising. This was always going to be made difficult.
I’d love to know exactly who benefits most from the status quo.
My bet this is not an oopsie moment.
It’s deterrent.
The Nats are running an attack line at the moment accusing the government of not knowing how to make decisions and not having sound policy, relying too much on working groups etc.
Here’s a good list of the 73 working groups, committees and enquiries set up by the Nats in their first 6 months, put together by Luke Christensen on Twitter. (It took them 6 months and 1 week to get to 75.) He’s also prepared a good graphic. I don’t know of a way to include that in a comment on this site, but you can check it out for yourselves.
i heard 75 working groups…its called democracy and getting things done…the Nats sat on their hands and did nothing.
The Nats had 73 working groups at the same stage of their first term.
The idiots don’t seem to think we can fact check there claims.
I think he may have forgotten the infamous National Party Cabinet Club.
Andrew Little.
What an effective politician.
http://www.newshub.co.nz/home/politics/2018/04/start-of-something-huge-families-re-enter-pike-river-with-andrew-little.html
https://thedailyblog.co.nz/2018/04/20/look-at-this-picture-the-national-party-said-this-could-never-happen/
Look at this picture – the National Party said this could never happen
“Andrew Little.
What an effective politician.”
The only effective thing he did for Labour was to stand down.
Lets do a big “yay” for his work on Pike river when they actually go in the mine proper – of course they will have to go in behind Winson – he wanted to be the first in there.
No James He is that rare thing… A truly upright man. He might disagree with your politics but he would defend your rights to the end.
Effective.
Andrew Little gives more power to the Privacy Commissioner in new bill
Andrew Little reaffirms commitment to tackling workplace harassment
Ngai Tahu and Waikato-Tainui receive substantial treaty payments to acknowledge historical deal
Andrew Little says three strikes law will be repealed
Little confirms Pora compensation will be adjusted
ODT editorial
https://www.odt.co.nz/opinion/editorial/challenging-process-justice-reform
At least Andrew Little made the right call on this…
“The government will not release two serial rapists from prison anytime soon despite a United Nations’ recommendation to do so.”
https://www.msn.com/en-nz/news/national/govt-wont-release-rapists-despite-un-recommendation/ar-AAw59SY?ocid=spartanntp
Holy shit that’s a bit extreme for a parole violation!
I had to look twice McFlock…
It’s extreme and impressive at the same time that this Government has the ability to achieve that outcome!!
I’m very interested in the method they intend to use
Great Malapropism!! A classic.
I cannot work out whether this would be good or bad Karma …
Jacinda does look incredible in the korowai with the baby bump.
(Apparently causing a massive positive media reaction, positive change and hope + China possibly having a military presence in Vanuatu has renewed interest in the Pacific and their leaders?).
https://www.radionz.co.nz/news/political/355550/chogm-ardern-to-toast-commonwealth-at-leaders-banquet
I think she has already done the Toast and used a Maori saying.
P.M. did us proud IMHO.
I agree Savenz – she looked stunning in her NZ designed gown and the Korowai cloak. Like the ad on TV in the old days “she will stop traffic” – good on her for her gracious charming manner – it’s all good for NZ on the world stage. Onwards and upwards for her in her career and family life.
https://www.odt.co.nz/opinion/editorial/intelligence-panel-step-too-far
Interesting to see if this leads to anything
Funny chap are you Puckish. You join the outrage that there has been no consultation about some matters then outraged because there is consultation. You are a bit like Duncan Garner. Hey! Are you Duncan Garner?
You’re going to have to take my word I’m not David Garner
However based on this:
Inspector-general Cheryl Gwyn has formed the panel to help her “stand in the shoes of the public” when viewing New Zealand’s intelligence services.
Then i’d suggest shes got it really wrong as the list provided seem to be more of the…left shall we say
Who do you think should be on a such a panel Mr Rogue? Hosking? A Young? Puckish?
I’d have thought you wouldn’t have any journalists on there (same view as Little by the way) especially those with a bit of a conflict of interest going on
If they’re advising on specific known instances and getting super-top-secret-pinky-swear clearance to do so, yeah, maybe.
But if the panel just advises in principle to balance against advocacy from within the services, you’d actually want as diverse a mix as possible to help you balance the conflict between security and freedom. It’s a good way to avoid bureaucratic capture.
Yep…Cheryl Gwyn may have overstepped the mark in making those appointments.
Andrew Little was surprised when questioned the other day on the panel makeup.
Egregious pointless pandering.
What clearance do they have, and if any, why?
This government is awash with panels and reviews achieving nothing except reports for the shelf and Welly-churn to keep retired (consulting) public servants voting the right way.
Christ Ad!!! you’re worried about ‘clearances’ rather than …
You know I was chastised not too long ago by a moderator for suggesting that I was ‘potentially’ familiar with who you might be.
At the time, nothing was further from my mind, although I do continue wonder whether you’re a progressive (by ANY stretch of the definition), or whether you’re better suited to some comfortably-off senior public servant (or contractual advisor thereof) wanting to preserve his role – and one that’s ‘down’ with the big boys
Did you ever wonder WHY they might be “awash with panels and reviews”?
If so, you’ll be disappointed.
There may be a shitload more to come if a new coalition government is able to clutch its balls.
But @Ad … you may be in luck. People get tired and complacent and used to the American Express Gold Card, so we’ll see
sorry in advance, but you really are full of a load of shit at times – ekshully most times
Clare Curran victim of fake Facebook page.
Makes you wonder who could possibly gain from such dirty tricks:
https://www.odt.co.nz/news/national/facebook-profile-impersonated-digital-minister
I feel sorry for the impersonator!! why choose Clare Curran?
Maybe it was a friend of Carol Hirschfeld? looking for some pay-back with Curran destroying a 34-year career…
Whoar (as Phil Ure would have said)
Why even ask that question Chuck-the-deliverance-from-all-evil-and-savior-with-an-excessively-sized-PENIS?
Maaate! ya fucking gorjiss,,,,, and hey….. are you rilly rilly an Amirrrikin without a gun?
Is there a possibility we could hook up sometime?
that ”
I feel sorry for the impersonator!! Why choose Clare Curran” statement really showed the size of your impedimenta.
Might pay to lay off the sauce OnceWasTim, you seem to have an obsession with male genitalia their buddy.
I don’t think National need to do anything to make CC look foolish, shes quite capable of doing a very good job of it all by herself
Sadly, Carol Hirshfield made a choice.
The paramount consideration for all non-Western peoples is DEVELOPMENT.
That is the creation of modern secular societies with cities, and skyscrapers, medical care, electricity, and high speed computers and jet aircraft and strong high-tech military forces capable of defending against the depredations of Western imperialism.
The ends justify the means.
Bashar al-Assad is a fucken hero!
[lprent: Ok, in my view that is yet another quite deliberate attempt to start a flame war and followed by deliberate provocation in this thread. I’m tired of seeing every conversation you are involved in winding up in a stupid wankfest. It appears to be the only thing that you are good at.
You are obviously incapable of participating in debate at any level, preferring instead to make each debate purely about yourself. And you add absolutely nothing much to it apart from inducing bans all around.
Do not come back under any guise ever. I really don’t like moronic trolls and I think that you are simply too stupid to learn to be anything else. ]
The same western imperialism giving you the internet and the free speech to inflict your hate on those you deem culturally inferior, no less.
What a massive hypocrite.
So it is hypocritical for a victim to turn the weapons invented by the aggressor on to the aggressor himself?
I’m not a hypocrite, and you are a numbnuts
By the way, Asians, Chinese are Indians, are way over-represented in IT and the computer industry, and were pioneers in the development of the modern PC:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/An_Wang
How’s the freedom of expression in China these days, hypocrite?
Don’t live there, but I’ve heard its pretty good actually, Mr numbnuts
Izzat so? No state control or anything? How did that protest in the square end up again?
How did that protest in the square end up again?
Pretty good. Those hippies got what was coming to them.
Thanks for playing
I taught in China for over three years. I still remember the shock on day 1 on learning that Wikipedia was not available because it’s an open source platform and contained articles critical of China.
On day 2 us foreign teacher were told NEVER to mention the 3 Ts: Taiwan. Tibet and Tiananmen Square.
I used to watch the CCTV English news, but soon gave up – first fifteen minutes positive things happening in China, next ten minutes how China was influencing the rest of the world, then five minutes of weather – the only part worth watching.
After a while the whole atmosphere (and the pollution) became quite oppressive.
What’s noticeable with wei is there is not a single acknowledgement of anything negative about China. It’s possible he’s a paid troll of course.
I think the goal is to swamp the site.
Best to ignore.
Many positives to discuss this week.
Jacinda in Europe making a positive impact for New Zealand.
Andrew Little being true to his word to Pike River miners.
The government sending a firm message to the fossil fuel industry.
Did you just claim that “natives” the world over should be thankful for having been colonised?!
For having their cultures eradicated? For having genocide visited on them?
And not only that, but you have the audacity to point the high and mighty accusing finger at oppression, that in terms of scale,barely register by any measure that includes those of western liberal democracy these past few hundred years, and also accuse others of being ‘one eyed’ , hypocritical and possible trolls?
wow
No Bill that is your warped subjective viewpoint.
Wei feels that “ You can’t bring liberal democracy to people who run around like 7th century savages slitting throats and beheading people for believing the ‘wrong’ god. You have to use very heavy handed means and crush this sort of shit. Then put in a secular schooling system and develop the economy. Then after two or three generations the people may well be ready for ‘liberal democracy’”
Pretty much he’s for ramming his superior culture down anyone else’s throat because western imperialism.
Take your blinkers off
It’s my reasonable interpretation of your Pythonesque “What’s the Romans done for us” apologist tripe. If you’d care to explain how else to take your lauding of this western imperialism giving you the internet and the free speech…, then I’m all ears.
Make it good though, aye?
No, see below.
So you believe that liberal democracy is obsolete. And regard the complete mobilization of society under a totalitarian one-party state as necessary to prepare a nation for armed conflict and to respond effectively to economic difficulties? Such a state is led by a strong leader—such as a dictator and a martial government composed of the members of the governing party—to forge national unity and maintain a stable and orderly society. And clearly you reject assertions that violence is automatically negative in nature and view political violence, war and imperialism as means that can achieve national rejuvenation?
That’s a word for word quote from wikis definition of fascism.
Couple that with constant assertions of cultural superiority and racism and you know what we call it?
How did liberal democracy get to be liberal democracy?
By having the economic and cultural conditions and optimum social stratification that enabled it.
The economic conditions achieved by extremely illiberal means, off the backs of black, brown, and yellow folk.
You can’t bring liberal democracy to people who run around like 7th century savages slitting throats and beheading people for believing the ‘wrong’ god. You have to use very heavy handed means and crush this sort of shit. Then put in a secular schooling system and develop the economy. Then after two or three generations the people may well be ready for ‘liberal democracy’
“violence is automatically negative in nature….”
Liberal democracy = non violence:
https://tinyurl.com/y7772yoj
Do go on. Do China and these other aggrieved nations also need more room to expand to develop as they deserve?
Huh? What’s your question, numbnuts?
Ok that was clearly too difficult.
Does China deserve to expand to develop in your opinion? Eg the Spratly Islands or Tibet?
We can even call it lebensraum if it makes you feel more comfortable.
[Yup The baiting. Did you not see the moderation notes I’ve left “everywhere” for xenophobic idiots like you to read? Because I’m kind, I’m going to give you the benefit of the doubt and assume you missed them. And I’m assuming you will notice this one (because I’m dropping a direct reply to this comment in a sec). Having read this one, you now have the chance hunt them out, read them, understand them, and then desist with this type of exchange you’re engaging in, and so avoid a very, very long holiday from the site. ] – Bill
“Lebensraum”?
Are you talking of the expansion of the Anglo Saxon race into the Americas and Australasia – places they had absolutely no historical connection with?
I thought the ends justified the means when a “more civilised” society used a heavy hand on the less developed until they were “ready for democracy”?
hypocritical again wei.
Spratly Islands?
Huh? China did not expand into Tibet because Tibet is a part of China, and is recognized as such by every single sovereign state in the world, New Zealand included.
The long standing US position, way before the communists took power:
“The United States considers the Tibet Autonomous Region or TAR (hereinafter referred to as “Tibet”) as part of the People’s Republic of China. This longstanding policy is consistent with the view of the entire international community, including all China’s neighbors: no country recognizes Tibet as a sovereign state. Moreover, U.S. acceptance of China’s claim of sovereignty over Tibet predates the establishment of the People’s Republic of China. In 1942, we told the Nationalist Chinese government then headquartered in Chongqing (Chungking) that we had “at no time raised (a) question” over Chinese claims to Tibet. Because we do not recognize Tibet as an independent state, the United States does not conduct diplomatic relations with the representatives of Tibetans in exile.”
http://dosfan.lib.uic.edu/ERC/bureaus/eap/950907WiedemannTibet.html
FYI, Keepcalmcarryon, until China turned Communist, the USA recognised Tibet as the 5th province of China. “Why we Fight” is a documentary produced by the US Dept of Information during WW2. If you watch the “China” episode, you will clearly see Tibet named as China’s 5th province. (Whenever a Chinese dynasty was strong, China always ruled Tibet.)
Unfortunately after WW2 China turned Communist. Oh dear! So capitalist USA suddenly realised that Tibet has always been and should always be a free, independent country.
Sorry, but shades of 1984 here… (Edit -I now see Wei has beaten me to it.)
Thanks vino, it’s had a long history hasn’t it. A better example might be the Spratly Islands which seems to have elicited silence.
Similar in a way – when China was strong, it probably ruled them. When China wasn’t strong, the stronger/strongest of many other countries all took turns.. No doubt they all have historical claims. Cue the USA (and others) all trying to push their own interests the hardest. Plus ça change, plus c’est la meme chose.
Maybe China thinks Vietnam is ready for reclaiming too.
Where does it stop.
They have tried and failed in Vietnam too many times, I suspect. French and USA not the only ones to find it a thorny nest..
Spratly claim by China only made since ww2 , convoluted history( scroll down)
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spratly_Islands_dispute
many and varied compositions
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_Chinese_history
The reply.
Go fuck yourself Bill. Racist enabler.
Don’t moderate the troll yesterday, allow abuse, then start banning everyone else because if baiting.
What a disgrace.
[Good bye. Don’t come back.] – Bill
There you go I agree strongly with Marxism and Engels Capitol has to be Socialise what they say about class struggle has happened for centuries and it always end in that thing I say is for idiots here’s the link
https://www.google.co.uk/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=https://www.theguardian.com/news/2018/apr/20/yanis-varoufakis-marx-crisis-communist-manifesto&ved=2ahUKEwj1gOuw6snaAhVKE5QKHSirCV0QFjAAegQIAhAB&usg=AOvVaw3GkzNuAXH4NwKKpMODoreG Kia kaha he tangata Ka kite ano P.S. I have to use my Phone to post this because those pesky sandflys are at it again
There you go another pukana to the establishment what you going to do sandflies arrest me for excising my RIGHT TO FREE SPEECH see what happens .
At the minute One can be arrested and locked up for months with anything being proven as fact thats leaves the door left right open for minuplation by the state I hope you can see this. Ana to kai Ka kite ano
Wow a few marked cop cars hanging around Eco Maori ——- you think I don’t no that every form of comunacation I have you are gathering to try and use against me hence the saying if Eco Maori farts you will try and create a ——– storm over what I say muppets Ana to kai
Prince Charles will lead the Common Wealth Ka pai
Here we go this is what we need trade deals with our Common Wealth Partners heres the link.
https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/politics/103293616/winston-peters-says-commonwealth-countries-open-to-multilateral-trade-deal Ka kite ano
https://i.stuff.co.nz/world/europe/103293607/commonwealth-leaders-choose-prince-charles-as-next-head-of-organisation
People are learning the truth about plastics they are bad for the environment an for our health the price of wool is rising ka pai wool carpets is best anyway.
Ka kite ano .
https://www.stuff.co.nz/business/farming/sheep/103262572/crossbred-wool-market-rises-across-types-and-styles-at-christchurch
Good evening Newshub there you go social media has a lot of good components like that app that will alert a medic/ nurse doctor first aid person that is closes to the heart attack patient and direct them to the patient . Alex the Matariki is not far away about a month to six weeks Maori use the Stars to predict seasonal weather time fishing expeditions when to plant crops when to harvest crops . I will get my cousin to tell me when he has the knowledge on that subject and many others. The Last Flying Flag looks like a movie Eco Maori would watch
Our sports Stars are still shining bright Kia Kaha te tangata Ka kite ano