web analytics

Open mike 29/04/2022

Written By: - Date published: 6:00 am, April 29th, 2022 - 82 comments
Categories: open mike - Tags:

Open mike is your post.

For announcements, general discussion, whatever you choose.

The usual rules of good behaviour apply (see the Policy).

Step up to the mike …

82 comments on “Open mike 29/04/2022 ”

  1. Temp ORary 1

    Toast to the ones here today
    Toast to the ones that we lost on the way
    'Cause the drinks bring back all the memories
    And the memories bring back, memories bring back you

    Respects Poli:

    Born mid August 1980 –

    Murdered some time between the last Friday night of April,

    and the early hours of the following Saturday, 2021.

    But it is the life in-between that matters most &

    He did the best he could with the time he had.

  2. Dennis Frank 2

    Newsroom's senior political reporter:

    In the face of record high autumn deaths and the prospect of another surge in sickness, the Government appears to have no strategy whatsoever. Ministers have given up on handling Covid-19 and seem content just to plug their ears and pretend it isn't happening.

    Hipkins didn't answer Newsroom's questions about whether the Government's current approach was likely to lead to no excess deaths.

    When asked how he would describe New Zealand's current Covid-19 strategy, Hipkins effectively said it was only vaccination.


    I'm surprised that Hipkins has abandoned mask-wearing as strategy! Even more surprised that cabinet has apparently made that official. I still wear mine in supermarkets & at public events.

    As for his reliance on vaccination, how will that play to senior citizens? I went in to the local govt vaccination center on April 8th, to get my second booster, and was told the govt hadn't authorised it. Well, their own goddam website told me a while back that the first booster was only 50% effective after 3 months, and my first booster was exactly 3 months before April 8th. How many senior citizens in Aotearoa are only 50% protected now?

    Being Labour, he'll dodge the question so no point asking. Commenters here who persist in defending Labour even when there's no reasonable basis for doing so, and who are senior citizens with 50% protection, ought to have a go at explaining govt policy, huh? See if it really is credible. Here's a clue:

    Additional boosters are not currently part of the COVID-19 vaccine rollout in New Zealand. We're currently considering who, if anyone, would be suitable for a second booster dose. Any decision to offer additional booster doses is likely to be made prior to winter 2022.


    Well, we're already a month into autumn. Time for Hipkins to pull finger?? And Labour also has a minister for seniors, who does monthly emails to us. Why did she not foreshadow a roll-out of a the second booster in her most recent bulletin? Explain how the official vaccine reliance strategy, as declared above by Hipkins, fits in with this omission. Can you?

    • weka 2.1

      My guess is this is why Bloomfield and other senior MOH bods resigned. Unconscionable and unnecessary.

      (afaik, masks are still official policy)

    • Kiwijoker 2.2

      No Dennis, they’re just implementing Nationals well thought through Omicron Strategy of having everyone take personal responsibility for their own health. So Dennis rather than whining that you couldn’t get a second booster from our socialist free public health system you take personal responsibility and pay for your own shot rather than trying to jump the queue when and if the Goverment decide whether a second booster is desirable.

    • Heather Grimwood 2.3

      To Dennis Frank at 2 : Surely you have seen and heard repeated advice from Chris Hipkins , other M.P.'s and epidemiologists that wearing of masks, distancing, good hygiene practice are advised, meaning that mature commonsense should prevail.

      • Dennis Frank 2.3.1

        mature commonsense

        Don't see any evidence Labour does that! I agree that it ought to prevail, Heather. That's why mentioned that I still wear one for indoor public situations.

        I notice that you didn't try to explain why Hipkins seems to have changed his policy. Does that mean you're a typical Labour supporter?

    • Two experts strongly endorsed mask wearing on Morning Report this morning (RNZ).

    • Patricia Bremner 2.5

      If the Government is giving out a personalised mask exemptions in May, your premise is wrong. Chris may not have mentioned mask wearing in close quarters but the PM and others still choose it, as it states when masks are mandatory under Orange setting.

      WHO is still mulling 4th shot but want all nations to have two shots. So is Australia, our Dr. says no plan for a 2nd booster/ 4th shot as yet.

      Getting used to Orange settings takes time. It has not abandoned masks. Read the site.

    • McFlock 2.6

      I suspect the govt feel that any mandate measure has been effectively undermined by the fuckwits, so the next-least-bad is to "encourage".

      Pisses me off, but at least we got to a position that saved thousands of lives before the wreckers succeeded.

      • Dennis Frank 2.6.1

        None of the commenters have addressed my point of concern: protection of seniors. I have no problem with encouraging as official stance. I just see the lack of addressing the follow-up to the booster as weird.

        I mean, if they just want to allow the darwinian norm to prevail, can't they be honest and say so? If they felt discouraged by the mandate outcome, why not share their feelings with voters? It's human. We don't actually want robot politicians, do we??

        I think seniors as a group are likely to know they have collective vulnerability and I expected those commenting here to comment on that basis. I'm puzzled by their aversion to doing so…

        • McFlock

          I missed that this was your particular point of concern. Frankly, how it "plays" to seniors (or at least those who are aware of the realities of endemic c19) is how it plays to everyone else who understands that one can't just stare down a virus.

          The trouble is, we're not just in the "endemic" phase, we're in the phase where laziness-inspired optimism has taken over for a lot of folks. They might not be "sherrifs" or any of that bullshit, but they'll happily forget their masks and then ask if they should go back to their car to get it. Looking for a sanction for the easy way out.

          Specifics of 4th shots or whatever are likely in the pipeline once the current situation has been assessed. Will we stay at daily-double-digit-deaths, or will it genuinely get down to flu/traffic levels. Are the deceased boosted, or are they barely-vaxxed? And so on.

          Me, I'm liking the actual nano-tech US military vaccine that's being trialled at the moment (last I heard). But I guess we'll see what we see.

  3. Jenny how to get there 3

    Why don't you surrender already!


    The people of Ukraine know why they cannot surrender to the Russian Federation.

    War crimes and genocide committed by Putin's fascist ally Bashar Assad in Syria are an example what Ukraine will suffer under Russian occupation.

    Already Russia is recruiting thousands of Assad's armed forces linked to war crimes and atrocities in Syria for the invasion and occupation of Ukraine.


  4. Ad 4

    Everyone: time to stock up on your cooking oil, the shelves are going to get tight.

    The world's largest producer of cooking oil, Indonesia, banning all exports – the Ukraine war has stuffed this market as well.

    Indonesia widens export ban to include crude palm oil | Food News | Al Jazeera

    But do our dairy farmers still get to import Palm Kernel Expeller for feed?

    • weka 4.1

      fortunately NZ is replete with butter.

      • Anne 4.1.1

        and margarine.

      • Ad 4.1.2

        $6 a block at New World and rising weekly.

        Great for baking but not for an average family shop.

        • Patricia Bremner

          PaknSave have butter Tararua at $5.49.

        • weka

          neoliberal chickens. Time for a conversation about globalisation and why we produce so much dairy but it's so expensive to buy here*.

          Indonesia just protected its people, maybe NZ should be thinking about how to do this as well.

          *or maybe it's not, and this is the real cost of food.

          • weka

            Or we could wait until people here are desperate enough to protest.

            Local shortages of edible oils has roiled Indonesia, leading to street protests over high food prices and the detention of a trade official in a corruption case. The turbulence has become a key political issue for President Joko Widodo as cooking oil costs could push other food prices higher ahead of the Eid al-Fitr holiday, which is usually marked with feasts and celebration.

    • weka 4.2

      But do our dairy farmers still get to import Palm Kernel Expeller for feed?

      Hope not. If they start whining, point them in the direction of organics and regenag and tell them to get with the programme.

      • RosieLee 4.2.1

        And tell them to stock only the number of cattle/sheep that their farm can sustain.

        • weka


        • Cricklewood

          Where we got ourselves in deep trouble is farm values and the amount that could be borrowed were based on high milk prices and ridiculous stock numbers supported by supplementary feed and irrigation. Bit of a ponzi scheme really with the real winners been the banks.

          Quite frightening to go to a small beach settlement for the first time in 5 years recently, lots of irrigation and cows on sand. The creek feed from a small dune lake would just about dry up every summer now flows strongly even in drought. Basically we're emptying aquifers and running nutrient and shit rich water into the sea.

    • pat 4.3

      Difficult to see PKE being available (at anything like current levels) if the oil production is slashed….but perhaps Indonesia uses vast quantities of palm oil domestically, whether enough to supply 2 million tons PKE pa that NZ uses would seem unlikely.

      We produce food oils here but current prices will make most blanche….imported canola at around 3-4 dollars a litre as opposed to NZ produced at around 12 dollars…..that'll hurt.

      • pat 4.3.1

        Have just looked up Indonesian consumption, and it looks like enough PKE would be available to meet NZ consumption assuming its not caught up in the export ban….and is also available from Malaysia.

    • Bruce 4.4

      This guy has a good information on the oil situation. As Weka points out we have plenty of butter but for many from Asia its use is a big part of cooking .

      • weka 4.4.1

        we will all have to adapt. People that rely on wheat bread might want to be thinking about this now. Not stockpiling, but learning how to eat local and more variety.

    • lprent 4.5

      I wasn't aware that Indonesia was a exporter of Olive oil?

      Decided long ago that it was worth the price every 2-3 months. As the primary cook I don’t use much oil anyway.

  5. Gosman 5

    Just wanting the opinions of any Labour supporters here about the actions of Labour to block requests by Select committees to call government officials to answer questions on various topics. This is something that Labour has stopped for a range of political parties including The Greens. Surely you can see this is not good for open and transparent governance.


    • Dennis Frank 5.1

      Nothing wrong with wanting them but you aint gonna get them. I went fishing for the same thing yesterday & got no response (OM #1).

      Just the usual syndrome you get from Labour supporters is retreat into denial: this ain't happening. So they move on, hurriedly & nervously, hoping nobody will notice.

      • Temp ORary 5.1.1

        Well: Gosman & DF, maybe people are so accustomed to scrolling past your comments unread that they miss it when you do have something of substance to contribute? I was reading that Boy Who Cried Wolf story to my kids at bedtime the other day, perhaps you should re-read it yourself?

        But then I am usually a Green Party supporter, if not member at the moment. I really should sign up once more to get a vote on the list rankings next year, but that means getting spammed with donations requests again. I do agree with Swarbrick and Willis on this; select committees are the workhorses of parliament (question time as a rodeo?), they need their feed of good quality information to be able to pull their weight.

        But if it comes down to numbers, even all the opposition (and loosely aligned – with coleaders in the stable of cabinet eating fine oats, while the rest of the GP MPs shiver under horse-blankets out in the fields) parties combined couldn't pass a motion of no confidence over this. I generally support the actions of this Ardern government (with some reservations), but hopefully next election no party will be able to secure an absolute majority and will instead have to seek meaningful consensus with at least one other party, preferably several, in order to operate. Until then, they get to run rough-shod as they will, until they face the muster of the hustings (apologies for all the equine metaphors, not quite sure how I started galloping into that conceit).

        Swarbrick said it made no sense for MPs to be that concerned about discussions or releasing information.

        “There is definitely a long shadow of partisanship which means we are not able to get outcomes or access to information which improves democracy for all of us. In turn, that means the public trust politicians less – which is a bad thing.”

        Willis and Swarbrick teamed up to try to get the briefing, with the deputy National leader saying Labour’s committee members needed to act in the public interest: “There shouldn’t be anything to hide here.”

        Swarbrick said there had been agreement from the entire Opposition that Labour appeared to be getting in the way of the free flow of information.

        • Dennis Frank

          Aversion to negative feedback tends to produce a failure to learn from what happens. It's why leftists tend to be chronic under-performers in politics…

          • Temp ORary


            People have limited time for online reading and commenting on the Social Media Platform that is The Standard. What many call; Cancelling, or; Aversion to Negative Feedback, is simply boredom with tiresome drivel. Freedom to express oneself is not a guarantee of an attentive audience.

            I personally think we need to distinguish between malicious; Trashing, and disinterested removal of attention. But that is a topic for another discussion; which I have had before, and will no doubt have again in the future (plus I can't be bothered hunting out the links just now).

            It is a poor author who disparages their audience for failing to bask in glow of their genius. The golden showers falling upon those upturned faces eager for illumination may feel like something other than sunlight to those below. In which case; who can blame them for turning elsewhere?

            • Dennis Frank

              Yeah but addiction to trivia is a poor excuse for coming onsite here & demonstrating an inability to get a grip on the issues discussed…

          • Incognito

            That’s rather presumptuous of you on a number of counts:

            1) You presume that one can learn something from your copy & pasta comments with short ‘snappy’ yet verbose commentary.

            2) You presume something negative about leftists in general.

            3) You presume you are able to judge everything on which and everybody on whom you provide negative feedback.

            4) You presume that negative feedback is similar or equivalent to constructive feedback.

            5) You presume that ignoring your comments is their loss.

        • Bearded Git

          Well said Temp-too many meaningless posts and too many long posts from Gosman and DF means I often skim past.

          • Dennis Frank

            Gosman does long posts too? Hadn't noticed any. Anyway since the essays are usually twice or three times longer than my comments I commend your diligence in spending the inordinate amount of time it takes to work your way thro. smiley

          • bad politics baby

            Yep, regular DF, ALwyn, Gos etc scroller here, life's too short.

            [Any reason why you changed your user name? – Incognito]

      • lprent 5.1.2

        Just the usual syndrome you get from Labour supporters is..

        To point out the constitutional aspects that they clearly know, and you appear to have missed.

        • Dennis Frank

          You reckon Labour's strategy is constitutionally correct? Interesting. If so, I'd change my tune on the topic. Let's assume you are right in that assessment. It would imply that the Greens/ACT/National are either ignorant of the relevant clause in our constitutional law or are being disingenuous.

          Or perhaps it comes down to competing interpretations of the relevant section of constitutional law? In which case there is no correct answer until a court judges the issue, eh? I'm open to enlightenment if you want to elaborate…

          • lprent

            These are MPs, not constitutional lawyers. Quite why you expect them to be aware of the limitation of their role is beyond me. That is why they have to get advice on what they can or cannot do. You'll notice the absence of any advice or legal basis for their blathering?

            Or perhaps it comes down to competing interpretations of the relevant section of constitutional law?

            Bloody unlikely. You'd have to find the 'section' first. Select committees are an internal convenience for Parliament. They are raised via the standing orders of parliament. Select committees have no constitutional standing at all – they are just a internal parliamentary tool to allow smaller groups to advise the whole of the house.

            More a case of trying to find any part of the law that claims select committees to do anything unless parliament as a whole authorises it. Even then parliament itself is severely contained by how little direct power parliament itself has.

            Parliaments direct power is strictly limited by what the crown allows them and little of that is present outside of taxation, funding and passing legislation – which has to be approved. The actual direct powers are held by the governor general or the executive council – both of whom 'advise' the crown.

            In practice of course the 'crown', Executive Council and the GG all tend to defer to parliament for year to year operations within limits. That the Executive Council is almost entirely made up of ministers helps with that. But Parliament only really rules itself.

            That is because anything that isn't explicitly stated in law of regulations derived from laws as being a requirement is simply not a requirement. This is how our legal system works.

            Again, you'll notice the complete lack of any discussion of any detail of anything that would authorise select committees to compel testimony or attendance?

            That is because even the bullshitting dickheads like Luxon are probably aware of this and are relying that most citizens of NZ aren't. The alternative is that we have a fool like Trump who can't distinguish between running a rorting company and being a more limited servant of the state.

            Basically NZ and even its MPs could do to get a good education in civics.

            • Dennis Frank

              MPs could do to get a good education in civics

              One wonders what their induction course actually covers, eh? I'm inclined to suspect that you're right to suspect Luxon of grandstanding but I doubt Chloe would get sucked in on that basis – she must see a principled stand in the troika, which suggests the induction didn't cover select committee appearances by public servants sufficiently well.

    • Craig H 5.2

      They shouldn't be doing it, it makes a mockery of select committees.

    • Jimmy 5.3

      Amazing that the Greens (Swarbrick) and Nats and Act all agreeing on something! Labour are not a transparent government.

    • Muttonbird 5.4

      These stories are months old now.

      I'm sure the way these select committees operate is the same as the way they have always operated, the difference being we have not had a one party government recently.

      For that, opposition parties can only blame themselves.

      • Descendant Of Smith 5.4.1

        It is difficult to assess without more detail.

        1. If the information requested relevant to the particular select committee or whether National are trying to use the select committee processes to get access to information they would not normally be able to get i.e. they are abusing the select committee processes – call me cynical.
        2. Why was it withheld? e.g. budget sensitive has been used in the past for instance.

        I do take solace that their are select committees – National solved that issue by doing lots of things under urgency. Noting also that some Labour governments in my view have also done too many things under urgency as well.

        Someone should ask Luxon though whether they are saying they would not block things if they were government. Are they saying if in government they would be releasing all and sundry?

      • Gosman 5.4.2

        It isn't just the opposition parties that are complaining about this. The Greens are annoyed as well.

    • lprent 5.5

      I wasn't aware that there was a right for members of select committees to call them at all, ever.

      Public servants are employed by the crown – not by parliament. Parliament merely provides the funding, laws and policy direction – all on behalf of the crown. Outside of the speakers control over Parliamentary services parliament has their most influence on the public services via ministers of the crown (usually MPs) and the funding and laws. They don't have direct operational control.

      The Public Service Commission is the effective head of the Public Service employees. Ministers have some operational influence (but not control) over a lot of the public service. Except for course for things like military, police, probably customs and a few other branches which answer directly to the crown.

      To me it just sounds like Luxon is just being a stupid wanker waving his dick in public.

      Clearly has watched too much US TV. He really is a pathetic ignorant dipshit and appears profoundly unprepared to be a MP. He'd be useless as a minister.

      • Gosman 5.5.1

        Your awareness is flawed. A Select committee can call upon government officials to act as either a Witness or Advisor on various matters. Ultimately the officials responsibility is to the Minister in charge though so they have to defer to them but it is quite clear that the Select committee can request they appear before them.


        • lprent

          You're an idiot… The select committee or members thereof can request or ask. So can anyone.

          Hell I can ask as well in my capacity as person who wants to request an answer to something. I cannot demand or assert a right to compel. MPs and select committees have no rights more than anyone else outside of the public servants operational hierarchy, or the various rights of the justice system or some of te intelligence community.

          The only avenue that I or an MP can demand with is via a OIA or by bringing a case in court or possibly appealing to the public services commission. The select committee as a body lacks the ability to do the OIA or the courts because they have little legal presence.

          To demand a public servant to front up to a select committee is objectionable, ignorant, and unavailable. Luxon and you are complete dickheads if you think that is possible or even desirable.

          Not even the Ministers can demand that. They can only request that of someone in the public service in a position of operational control of an employee.

          • lprent

            I'd add that there are a couple of bits of legislation and regulation that compel some public servants to submit reports to parliament. For instance the auditor-general for instance. Parliament often passes perusing these tasks to select committees as a convention.

            But the select committees themselves have no significant powers themselves outside of the responsibility to look at things that parliament chooses them to look at (just as they do with legislation), and expressing their opinions on those matters. They have no judicial powers what so ever.

          • Dennis Frank

            Looks like you're right, but it would be clearer if both you & Gosman cited the actual bit of the pdf that made you each believe what you believe.

            The Minister ultimately has the right to decide who should represent the Government before a select committee, whether or not a committee has requested attendance of a named official. In practice, the departmental chief executive or his or her delegate will normally judge when it is necessary to consult the Minister, in the absence of any direction from the Minister

            That's #20 on the Officials and Select Committees – Guidelines pdf.

            Not definitive, since it does not mention any right of refusal by the department which the request addressed. Can they refuse?

            • lprent

              They can't refuse to appear before the Public Service Commission, maybe not the Executive Council, most of the Justice system, and probably parts of the Intelligence system. There are other situations like being a state of war or civil emergency that would give other bodies partial control as well.

              The only ones that I would be sure of is the Public Service Commission for direct control and the Justice system for judicial control.

              The minister themselves probably could only request. With more weight given to the Ministers of the crown on Executive Council.

              ..cited the actual bit of the pdf that made you each believe what you believe.

              I didn’t read it, I only looked at it for the legal reasoning. There wasn’t any. So my basic background knowledge is what I presented.

              That came out of the history, the army (very finicky on things like this), general law courses in undergraduate and graduate degrees, having to suffer with a partner doing her law degree, and general reading on history and law.

              In other words this for me is general knowledge.

              If you ask for a reference on a general topic, then wikipedia is your friend. I’ll be happy to dig references out – if I have spare time.

              If you want something difficult – like how to crack into an embedded system on the other side of the world or how to do impossible things with code – then you’re clean out of luck. Other people already pay me to do those things.

              • Dennis Frank

                Good stuff, thanks. Reminds us that a lot of what happens in governance is based on convention rather than law. And conventions evolve…

          • Gosman

            You stated there was no right for members of Select committee to call for officials to appear before them. There is. What there isn't is an ability to OBLIGE them to appear before them. Language matters.

    • Foreign waka 5.6

      Its not good for democracy either, but we are told that we have to "tweak" that because democracy is changing. Well, just in this country though and I don't know to what.
      Just as I posed I looked at Jimmy’s comment…..hmmmm

  6. Jimmy 6

    You just know this was crap from the start, when even David Parker who is on your team doesn't like it!

    Rotorua District Council agrees to pause its representation bill | Stuff.co.nz

  7. Muttonbird 7

    Contrary to some angry comments here, the MIQ case is not a win for expat Grounded Kiwis. I suspect they and some media are suggesting it is a win are trying to save face.

    Obviously Grounded Kiwis is lauding this as a success for their side and the judge does say they have succeeded. However, if you look at the entirety of the 140-page judgment, the Government has won on all the major points. And in fact, the court rejected most of Grounded Kiwis' submissions.

    The judge did not recommend abandoning the lottery system, rather making a few places available outside it, noting that this could create, "a whole new set of grievances".


    Still, Grounded Kiwis and other pandemic sceptics have what they wanted now, no MIQ.

    And people are dying.

    • lprent 7.2

      I read the decision.

      I also read the grounded kiwis take on it.

      Came to the conclusion that they had read a different decision – probably one that Ian Taylor fetched out of Cameron Slaters arse. It really was that delusional.

      My opinion of their ability to understand anything dropped even lower.

      The MIQ was going to be phased out in the first quarter of this year anyway. I guess the numbskulls of NZ don't actually listen to news and the explore the actual requirements about as well as they read legal decisions.

      Covid-19 is endemic. We have put in about as much protection as is possible based on the available vaccines (although Dennis Frank is right, the second booster is due about now). The trick now is to let the un-vaccinated to vaccinated the traditional way while the vast majority of the vaccinated to still have a functioning hospital system.

    • McFlock 7.3

      Basically seems to say that next time we should have an "urgent" category as well, i.e. everyone gets evaluated as "emergency" (within 2 weeks), "Urgent" (priority place in a month or two, the Bellis situation), and the rest take their chances once the first two have been filled.

  8. Alan 8

    Robertson and Mahuta have just announced that they want Labour to lose the next election in a land slide, great work you guys.

    • Dennis Frank 8.1

      Aw, you tease. You come here, dangle something like that, and provide no link – not even a quote. Do you hang out on K Rd in fishnet stockings too?

    • AB 8.2

      3 Waters. The "terra nullius" racists will scream – and so will thieves, opportunists and privatisers with their eyes on water as a monetisable commodity. The rest of us get to see if it actually works before it is sabotaged by some future Nat/ACT government seeking to enable the aforesaid groups.

      • Foreign waka 8.2.1

        And who is to say that all that 3 water work is not in preparation for precisely that: privatisation.

    • Dennis Frank 9.1

      Cabinet has agreed to the bulk of 47 working group recommendations for the planned overhaul of the country's three waters – drinking, waste, and storm water systems – which it hopes to complete by July 2024. The proposed co-governance of regional groups which will appoint the new entitys’ governance boards and provide public accountability for the entities is set to remain.

      Good on them. I'm glad to be able to say something nice about Labour today! Will be fascinating to see the media analysis & commentary ensuing…

  9. Dennis Frank 10

    Here's the guts then:

    Local Government Minister Nanaia Mahuta and Infrastructure Minister Grant Robertson have this morning laid out next steps. The reforms would move responsibility for the management of drinking, waste and stormwater from 67 local councils to four large, specialised water management organisations.

    However, after months of deliberations, they confirmed councils would be given non-financial shareholding interests in the four water service entites, guaranteeing ownership – one of the key concerns raised over the government's initial model.

    This would be allocated based on population – with one share per 50,000 people, rounded up to ensure at least one share per council – and would be reassessed to account for population changes every five years.

    The co-governance provisions proposed – to have mana whenua and councils given equal number of seats on a representation group which sets the entites' strategic direction but has no say in operational matters – would remain, with the additional option of having co-chairs.

    The separate boards of the entities themselves would be appointed by the regional representation group, based on competency requirements with a ban on conflicts of interest – including a prohibition for councillors to be on the entity boards. There will also be extra protections against privatisation which would require at least three quarters of Parliament to agree before any sale or merger could be done.


    • Dennis Frank 10.1

      Stuff has put up a compilation of verdicts: https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/300576023/three-waters-reaction-mayor-phil-goff-says-auckland-is-being-penalised-lgnz-welcomes-ratepayer-certainty

      Professor Troy Baisden from the School of Environment at the University of Auckland stated that the number of failures should point to the reason for the change. "New Zealand’s performance on the Three Waters has been poor by the standards of peer nations: for every success that can be pointed to as a case to retain the status quo there are multiple failures,” Baisden said.

      Continuing with the current status quo wasn’t an option, according to Lokesh Padhye from the Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering at the University of Auckland.

      "The New Zealand water sector needs reforms, and there is not much debate in the science and engineering community that the status quo is not working when it comes to improving water quality and water management practices,” Padhye said. "The government-established Working Group has provided some excellent suggestions to the Government in that regard. It is good to see that the Government has taken most of the recommendations on board."

      • Alan 10.1.1

        The science/engineering is not the issue Dennis, as you well know.

        • Dennis Frank

          You can't read my mind. The policy change will influence politics more via the general view in the body politic, ultimately. I reckon those who want cleaner water will have an effective majority there easily. The science & engineering view are two bodies of expert opinion likely to influence most punters. Those doing turf-protection will struggle to catch up – probably only getting traction where councils have been traditionally competent…

          • Alan

            "the majority", you say.

            When it was one person, one vote, that concept worked well.

            Under co- governance, well……….

            • Foreign waka

              "tweaking" democracy its called. Democracy is changing, maybe to autocracy?

  10. Patricia Bremner 11

    Waiting waiting for the Right wing response…. Yeah/ Nah.

    • Alan 11.1

      watch the Act response on the Herald web site.

      • Dennis Frank 11.1.1

        For a laugh?

        New Zealand Taxpayers’ Union spokesperson Jordan Williams has said Grant Robertson’s claim that “this co-governance model is supported by most councils is laughable”.

        Given that neither produced stats to back up their competing views, their dumb & dumber routine is indeed entertaining.

        Communities 4 Local Democracy labelled the Government’s move as a “worrying attack on property rights and community voice”.

        “This is a dark day for local democracy as the Government has continued to force this reform through without the consent of its stakeholders or their communities,” said C4LD Chair and Manawatu District Mayor Helen Worboys.

        No evidence from her either.

        Local Government New Zealand President Stuart Crosby also welcomed the Government’s decisions on the Three Waters to provide certainty for ratepayers. “Councils face big future bills for water services given the new regulator, the unknown condition of many pipes and the impact of climate change. Without reform, ratepayers will be hit in the pocket,” Crosby said.

        “Everyone in the local government sector is advocating for change to our water systems, even those opposed to the Government’s model. No one thinks the status quo is sustainable."

        The relevant authority figure must believe the woman is from another planet.

        “The current system is not up to scratch, but the Government’s Three Waters reforms are not the answer,” said ACT’s local government spokesperson Simon Court. “Taking control of water assets away from councils is wrong. Moving water assets from one government body to another is a recipe for more bureaucracy and less local input.”

        I'll give him credit for acknowledging the status quo is shit. I even agree that Labour's penchant for padding bureaucrats into governance structures has had a legendary tendency to clog them up & make them dysfunctional. However, it is always possible for Labour to exhibit competence. We live in hope.

  11. Starting to make sense now.

    Russia may not be so concerned about reviving Russian glory and exterminating Nazis in its campaign in Ukraine. And Europe may have more tangible interests that may outweigh the humanitarian concerns and moral outrage at Russia's behaviour.

    It turns out that Ukraine has huge untapped resources of a wide variety of minerals and commodities under its soil. So it starts to make sense why Europe is so enthusiastic about protecting Ukrainian sovereignty and why Russia is so keen to grab it.

    • joe90 12.1

      Purely coincidental of course that most of Ukraine's fossil fuel resources sit under Luhansk, Donetsk, and Southern Ukraine. Funny how Moldov's Transnistria region is disputed territory, too.

      Untapped Potential

      Excluding Russia’s gas reserves in Asia, Ukraine today holds the second biggest known gas reserves in Europe. As of late 2019, known Ukrainian reserves amounted to 1.09 trillion cubic meters of natural gas, second only to Norway’s known resources of 1.53 trillion cubic meters. Yet, these enormous reserves of energy remain largely untapped. Today, Ukraine has a low annual reserve usage rate of about 2 percent. Moreover, more active exploration may yield previously undiscovered gas fields, which would further increase the overall volume of Ukraine’s deposits.


      • tsmithfield 12.1.1

        Yes, and I am sure that Europe would like to be customers to Ukraine who would likely be much more cooperative suppliers than Russia and its random tantrums.

  12. Jenny how to get there 13

    And you thought '1984' was just a book.

    Following the crackdown on anti-war protesters and independent news outlets, the Russian Federation further cracks down on free thought by targeting artists.

    The government directive for the Arts and culture community, is War.

    The Muses Are Silenced: Russian Arts Community Targeted As State Imposes Conformity Over Ukraine War

    ….Shortly after Russia's February 24 invasion of Ukraine, Moscow adopted new laws and regulations aimed at stifling dissent over the war and preventing the spread of information other than that provided by the government….

    ….huge banners featuring the Z symbol have festooned theaters, museums, and other cultural institutions across the country, as the government has pushed the country's cultural communities to publicly express their support for the war, the military, and President Vladimir Putin.

    ….Sergei Levitsky, the former artistic director of the Russian Drama Theater in Ulan-Ude, the capital of the Buryatia region, who was fired on March 22 for speaking out against the war…..

    …..Prominent Buryatia actress Svetlana Polyanskaya told RFE/RL that with Levitsky's dismissal, the theater has lost its "locomotive."

    "The theater was pulsating, thoughtful, and compelled others to think," she said. "It fostered empathy and discussed some very important and necessary themes. It attracted a young generation of theatergoers. It was alive and now it is dead."

    "Now it is just a building," she concluded.


Leave a Comment

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

  • Budget 2022 invests to keep Kiwi kids in class and learning
    The Government is committed to improving student attendance at school and kura, Education Minister Chris Hipkins and Associate Education Minister Jan Tinetti said in a pre-Budget announcement today. “It’s clear that young people need to be at school, and yet attendance rates haven’t been good for a long time. It’s ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 hour ago
  • Workers make their voices heard
    Essential workers sent a clear message today that they no longer want to see their pay and conditions set through a race to the bottom, and that they support fair, good faith bargaining with employers through Fair Pay Agreements. On International Workers’ Day, Minister of Workplace Relations and Safety Michael ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 hour ago
  • Govt and Air New Zealand to trial innovative and accurate new COVID-19 test
    The Government is partnering with Air New Zealand to trial an innovative new COVID-19 testing solution that uses Loop-Mediated Isothermal Amplification (LAMP) technology, Associate Minister for COVID-19 Response Dr Ayesha Verrall announced today. “As New Zealand reconnects with the world, we are exploring innovative COVID-19 testing technology to help keep ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 hours ago
  • Government’s Winter Energy Payment kicks in for over 1 million Kiwis
    A warmer winter is on the horizon for over 1 million New Zealanders receiving either a main benefit or New Zealand Superannuation as the Winter Energy Payment begins today. “When we first came into office, we introduced the Winter Energy Payment as part of our Government’s December 2017 Families Package. ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 hours ago
  • Govt launches Smokefree May campaign
    Associate Minister of Health Dr Ayesha Verrall launched ‘Smokefree May’ today at an event at Manurewa Marae. This new campaign, developed with Hāpai Te Hauora, supports the Government’s plan to make New Zealand smokefree by 2025. At the event, a new brand was also unveiled for the Smokefree 2025 Action ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 day ago
  • Government partners with Ka Uruora to deliver up to 172 new homes for whānau
    Minister of Housing Hon Dr Megan Woods and Associate Minister of Housing (Māori Housing) Peeni Henare have today announced a new investment partnership with Ka Uruora to build up to 172 new homes for whānau who need them most. Ministers Henare and Jackson joined partners Ka Uruora at an event ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • Pacific Business Village launched in Tauranga
    A new  Pacific Business Village that will grow Pacific businesses, fundamental to our COVID-19 recovery, was launched by the Minister for Pacific Peoples Aupito William Sio in Tauranga today. “The Government wants the Village used as a strategic framework for any long-term economic development work in our regions for Pacific ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • Another COVID-19 drug in the medicine chest
    Health Minister Andrew Little says New Zealanders who contract COVID-19 now have access to six medicines proven to safely prevent the most severe and life-threatening symptoms of the virus. Andrew Little was in Auckland this afternoon to see the first shipment of molnupiravir, the second oral anti-viral COVID-19 medicine to ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Changes to intensive winter grazing regulations better for farmers and environment
    Changes to intensive winter grazing rules will make them more practical for farmers and effective in lifting environmental outcomes, Environment Minister David Parker and Agriculture Minister Damien O’Connor announced today.  “For New Zealand, our economy depends on our environment. Cleaning up our winter grazing practices protects our freshwater resources, the welfare of our animals, ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Government supports extra housing development
    Five Auckland suburbs to get improved infrastructure to boost supply of new housing, and support existing homes Up to 16,000 new homes enabled on crown-owned land including public, affordable and market homes Capacity created for an extra 11,000 homes on surrounding privately owned land. Projects include water main renewal, sewage ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Government puts port safety under the spotlight
    The health and safety practices at our nation’s ports will be investigated as part of a range of actions taken by the Minister for Workplace Relations and Safety in response to two deaths in the space of a week. “All New Zealanders should return from work safe and unharmed. Recently ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • New Government plan helps support older workers
    Supporting older people to stay in the workforce and transition their skills as they age and their circumstances change is a key part of the new Older Workers Employment Action Plan, Minister for Social Development and Employment Carmel Sepuloni and Minister for Seniors Dr Ayesha Verrall announced today. “The Government ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Flora, fauna and communities set to flourish through Jobs for Nature
    An initiative that has provided tourism workers with alternative employment into the lead up to New Zealand’s borders reopening is being extended to ensure staff are retained, Conservation Minister Kiri Allan says. It is one of two projects in the Waikato-Maniapoto to receive funding through the Government’s Jobs for Nature ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Supporting communities to prepare for climate impacts
    From today New Zealanders can have their say on a proposed National Adaptation Plan to help communities across the country adapt to the unavoidable impacts of climate change. “Aotearoa will soon have a plan to bring down our emissions and help prevent the worst effects of climate change, but we ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Conservation cup win runs in the family
    Wetlands expert and advocate Dr Beverley Clarkson was today presented with New Zealand’s most prestigious conservation award, the Loder Cup by Minister of Conservation Kiri Allan. Dr Clarkson is a plant ecologist based at Manaaki Whenua Landcare Research in Hamilton. She is nationally renowned for her knowledge and championing of ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • New mask exemption card to remove uncertainty
    People who have genuine reasons for not being able to wear a face mask can access a new personalised exemption card from the end of May, Minister for COVID-19 Response Chris Hipkins and Minister for Disability Issues Carmel Sepuloni announced today. “We know that face masks are a crucial part ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Government plans to amend Dairy Industry Restructuring Act
    The Government intends to amend the Dairy Industry Restructuring Act 2001 (DIRA) to support Fonterra’s move to a new capital structure, Agriculture Minister Damien O’Connor announced today. “The Fonterra cooperative is a key part of New Zealand’s world-leading dairy industry and a major export earner for our economy, sending product ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Shining a light on unfairness in our tax system
      Victoria University 26 April, 2022   Those coming here expecting announcements of new tax policy will be disappointed. None are being made. We have no secret plan to introduce a CGT nor a wealth tax or a deemed income tax, nor others. The IRD is not doing any work ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Auckland harbour goes electric
    Auckland harbour ferries are set to get quieter, cleaner and greener, thanks to two new fully-electric ferries for commuters and sightseers to travel on, Minister for Energy and Resources Dr Megan Woods announced today. Auckland Transport will operate the two electric fast ferries across all major inner and mid-harbour services, ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Spray-free target for New Zealand apples and pears to boost export growth
    New Zealand’s apples and pears industry is aiming to become spray-free by 2050 through a new Government-backed programme focused on world-leading sustainable production practices, Agriculture Minister Damien O’Connor announced today. The Government is investing in a seven-year programme through the Ministry for Primary Industries’ (MPI) Sustainable Food and Fibre Futures ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Helping some of New Zealand’s highest energy users slash their emissions
    Backing 15 big businesses to move away from fossil fuels in their production processes Equal to taking 14,400 cars off the road   $13 million of Government funding matched by $32.66 million from industry Achieves a total of 900,631 t of carbon emissions saved over the project lifetimes The Government is ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Boosting biggest city’s environment cred
    More than 50 jobs are being created across Tāmaki Makaurau/Auckland with the launch of three new Government-backed initiatives, Conservation Minister Kiri Allan says. “Tāmaki Makaurau has taken quite a hit over the past two years, with the region experiencing longer lockdown restrictions than anywhere else in the country. “Jobs for ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Celebrating 30 years of Great Walks
    The opening of the 2022-23 Great Walks booking season next week heralds 30 years of epic adventures in our backyard throughout the country, says Minister of Conservation Kiri Allan. Speaking from the Tongariro Northern Circuit,, the Minister acknowledged the importance of the Great Walks for conservation, recreation and tourism in ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Prime Minister's Speech to Mt Albert Anzac Day Service
    Let me start by saying how wonderful it is to see people up and down the country gathering together in person again this year, in commemoration of Anzac Day. At a time when the global pandemic has so often cancelled public gatherings, it is all the more precious to be ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Rangiriri Pa trench rebuild shines a light on our shared histories
    The shared nineteenth-century histories of Aotearoa-New Zealand have come to life with the official opening today of one of the most culturally significant sites of the 1860s New Zealand Wars.   The Government-financed rebuild of the Rangiriri Pa Trenches complex in Waikato is the first project completed from a special ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Statement on Cooperation in Agriculture between Japan and New Zealand
    Japan and New Zealand’s strong partnership is built on a long tradition of official and industry engagement, underpinned by our natural complementarities and strong business relationships. Both countries share many similarities. Japan and New Zealand are island nations in the Pacific with rich soils and climates suited to temperate agriculture.  Agriculture, ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Commissioners reappointed to Tauranga City Council
    Local Government Minister Nanaia Mahuta today announced the reappointment of four commissioners to the Tauranga City Council. “As the Council continues to face substantial infrastructure and funding challenges, it is clear that ensuring certainty for Tauranga is more important than ever,” Nanaia Mahuta said. “The reappointment of the current Tauranga ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Next steps in Declaration Plan
    “We’ve now completed the first stage of the two-step engagement process to develop a Declaration Plan. This has provided us with valuable feedback to help with drafting a Declaration Plan that we will then take out to wider consultation,” Willie Jackson said.  “Almost 70 targeted engagement workshops were held mainly ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Public Media entity Establishment Board appointments
    The Minister for Broadcasting and Media has confirmed the nine-member Establishment Board to lead the work on creating a new public media entity in New Zealand. “The Establishment Board will oversee the detailed design of the new entity and the change required to create it,” Kris Faafoi said. “The make-up ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Prime Minister has productive meeting with Prime Minister of Japan
    Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern had a productive meeting with Japanese Prime Minister Fumio Kishida in Tokyo today.  “Japan is one of New Zealand’s closest and most important partners in the Indo-Pacific region. We have a strong trade relationship, common values and a shared commitment to an open, inclusive, stable and ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Joint Statement: Japan and Aotearoa New Zealand: a Strategic Cooperative Partnership for Common Pea...
    Strengthening the Strategic Cooperative Partnership 1.     The Prime Minister of Japan His Excellency KISHIDA Fumio and the Prime Minister of New Zealand the Right Honourable Jacinda Ardern held a productive and substantive meeting in Tokyo on 21 April 2022. Acknowledging the Summit Meeting was taking place at a significant time as the two ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • NZ, Japan team up on renewable energy
    Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern today welcomed two renewable energy initiatives that highlight the growing partnership between Japan and New Zealand as both countries work towards a greener future. “New Zealand, like Japan, is embarking on a journey to become carbon neutral by 2050,” Jacinda Ardern said. “We need to significantly ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Veterans Minister congratulates RSA on 100 years since first Poppy Appeal
    Veterans Minister Meka Whaitiri has congratulated the Royal New Zealand Returned and Services’ Association (RSA) on 100 years since the first Poppy Appeal in New Zealand, held on April 24, 1922. “This is an incredible century of work by the RSA that has provided thousands of New Zealanders the opportunity ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • New technology for e-waste switched on
    A new state-of-the-art machine that sorts and shreds electronic waste has officially started operation in Auckland today. Environment Minister David Parker pressed start on Computer Recycling Ltd’s new BLUBOX machine, which was supported by a $1.5 million grant from the Waste Minimisation Fund. “The BLUBOX machine is a step forward ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • CPI figures highlight global economic challenges
    Further increases in consumer prices are a reminder of the current global economic challenges and the need for responsible fiscal policy in New Zealand, Grant Robertson said today. The Consumer Price Index released by Stats NZ today showed a 1.8 percent increase in prices over the March quarter, taking the ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Government supports more people off benefit
    Minister for Social Development and Employment Carmel Sepuloni says the Government’s response to COVID-19 has helped keep people in work, with March Quarter Benefit statistics showing a further fall in the number of people receiving a main benefit and jobseeker assistance. “There are 19,883 fewer people on a main benefit ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Andrew Little Locality network announcement speech, Levin | Taitoko, 21 April 2022
    Kia ora koutou, Thank you for having me here today. I begin by acknowledging my colleague, Peeni Henare, the Associate Minister for Māori Health, who cannot be with us due to other commitments. Peeni and I have worked closely on today’s kaupapa - as we have with the rest of ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Health Reform – Govt ensures local say in health services
    The Government has announced how New Zealanders will have a real voice in determining the health services provided in their community as part of the new health system. “Today we’re announcing nine locality network pilots to improve how healthcare is delivered in local communities,” Health Minister Andrew Little said. The ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Sustainable Aviation Arrangement signed with Singapore
    A New Zealand-Singapore Sustainable Aviation Arrangement signed today marks the start of greater collaboration as both countries move towards low carbon economies, Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern says.  The Arrangement is the first bilateral cooperation in sustainable aviation for both New Zealand and Singapore, and its signing was witnessed by Prime Minister Jacinda ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 weeks ago
  • NZ, Singapore join forces on supply chain disruptions
    New Zealand and Singapore have pledged to continue working together on supply chains following global disruptions caused by COVID-19, Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern and her Singapore counterpart, Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong, announced today. “The global COVID-19 pandemic has showed us just how vulnerable economies of all sizes can be ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 weeks ago