Someone in our public service is trying to undermine Labour – using the MIQ strategy.
The latest MIQ battle to make headlines – pregnant Kiwi journalist Charlotte Bellis finding refuge in Afghanistan thanks to the Taliban – again shows how inhumane the system is, Act leader David Seymour says. "Normally I joke about the New Zealand Government being less humane than the Taliban, but sadly in this case it's true.
Little hitlers in the bureaucracy again. Probably male, since the victim of their arbitrary decision-making is female. Defenders of the patriarchy.
"There's no rhyme nor reason. Often people mysteriously get a spot if enough drama is made, and I've noticed the profile of a person can have an effect, too."
Make it up as you go along. The ideal way to govern! Bureaucrats really get off on having total control. The one controlling the outcome for Charlotte is obviously in the running for a lifetime achievement award.
"I think most New Zealanders reading the story would say it's a no-brainer for her to be offered a [MIQ spot] … that's precisely why the emergency [MIQ] allocation exists."
But David, having no brains is how you get recruited into the public service in the first place. Perpetuating neocolonialism requires obedient automatons.
Will a minister take charge of the situation? Unlikely. For any Labour minister to spot subversion in the first place would be a miracle, and then brainwashing them to make them feel impotent is part of the culture of governance. Any natural problem-solver would get marginalised real fast. So I reckon the apparatchik will get the lifetime award for making Labour seem worse than the Taliban.
[here’s what Hipkins and the person running MiQ actually said. Putting this up in bold because we’re in a global crisis, this is a serious issue, and we should be looking at the whole picture. – weka]
Covid Response Minister Chris Hipkins responds:
A senior National Party MP contacted me on Wednesday with information about this case and the circumstances about their declined application, which appeared at first sight to warrant further explanation.
My office passed this information onto officials to check whether the proper process was followed.
I’m unable to provide any further comment on MIQ at this stage as a court case against MIQ is being prepared and expected to be heard soon.”
Head of MIQ Chris Bunny responds:
Charlotte Bellis emergency allocation case
In the case of Charlotte Bellis, she applied for an emergency allocation MIQ voucher on Monday 24 January. The date she requested (27 February) was not within the 14 day window required for an emergency allocation (the travel must be time-critical). She received a response deactivating the application and inviting her to reapply within the 14 day window, and to contact MIQ if she intended to change her flights to return to New Zealand earlier. We have not received any subsequent confirmation that Ms Bellis intends to bring her flights forward.
We have a team of people who manage emergency allocation requests and the team keep a close eye on applications, and Charlotte’s location of Afghanistan came to their attention. Thirty minutes after the initial decline email, they reached out to inform her that if she intended to change her flights to an earlier return date, that more supporting information would be required to process a subsequent application and they highlighted the evidence requirements. This is not uncommon and is an example of the team being helpful to New Zealanders who are in distressing situations.
It is not uncommon for people who have been declined an emergency allocation to reach out to a Member of Parliament. There are a lot of people in really difficult situations around the world. When anyone brings individual cases to our attention, we look into the case and the process that was followed. This is standard practice. There is also a process in place for people to seek reviews of their own applications.
All applications for emergency allocations of an MIQ voucher are assessed case-by-case, there is no preferential treatment – it is a fair and consistent process.
MBIE regularly evaluates its Emergency Allocations criteria and will continue to do so.
Emergency allocations process in MIQ
New Zealand’s a small country—we’ll all know people who have struggled to return home.
We want every New Zealander who’s currently abroad who wants to come home to be able to do so. However, we want them to come home to a safe New Zealand, in a safe way. Over the last two years our managed isolation system has been what has kept New Zealanders safe.
MIQ has been a success for New Zealand, helping to safely bring more than 218,000 people here in the midst of a global pandemic, as well as care for over 3600 community cases.
Every month in managed isolation we accommodate the equivalent of a small New Zealand town – around 12,600 people in 9000 rooms per 28 days.
There is finite capacity within the MIQ system though, and that’s for good reason – Covid-19 is still spreading around the world, and we need to keep New Zealand safe. We constantly have to strike a balance between bringing people into New Zealand and protecting us all from Covid entering the community.
We are seeing a large increase of Omicron cases at the border which means more rooms are needed for Quarantine. We are also monitoring the number of community cases, some of whom are required to come into MIQ.
Managed Isolation and Quarantine is aware that travelling around the world right now is not simple or easy and acknowledges that there are many people in really difficult situations as a result of this global pandemic.
MIQ has an emergency allocation process which exists for limited situations which require urgent travel to New Zealand within the next 14 days. There are currently 400 rooms per fortnight set aside for those who need to travel urgently. This is a last resort option with a very high threshold.
All applications for emergency allocation places in managed isolation are assessed on a case-by-case basis, against a set criteria. These decisions are not easy ones to make and we are sympathetic to the distressing situations people applying for an emergency allocation are in.
To be eligible for an emergency allocation, the applicant must be legally entitled to enter New Zealand and the travel must be time-critical (within fourteen days of their intended date of departure). Evidence is required to support all applications to ensure a fair and consistent process.
Right now, MIQ is under pressure like never before and we are currently experiencing very high volumes of emergency allocation requests due to widespread travel disruption around the world.
From 30 October 2020 to 23 January 2022, MIQ processed 8,863 completed applications and approved 5,396 applications for emergency allocations.
Emergency Allocation criteria and pregnancy
Pregnancy in and of itself is not considered an emergency under the emergency allocation criteria but certain conditions during pregnancy may mean that the high bar for an emergency is met.
The criteria – Category 1a could apply to someone who is pregnant if they require access to time-critical medical treatment which has been scheduled in New Zealand and is unavailable or inaccessible in their current location.
Category 2a allows people to urgently return to New Zealand to provide critical care for a dependent (i.e: their spouse/partner who is pregnant). To meet the ‘critical care’ requirement, an applicant’s situation must be very serious, and no one else is in a position to assist the person that the application refers to.
Sorry, but why did Belgium not take them? Why is it incumbent upon NZ to take them, are we a soft touch now? My reading of it is that part of the delay concerned his application for a critical purpose visitor visa.
I admire Charlotte Bellis, she is s brave soul, but this is a 1 in 100 year pandemic. Pissing about in third world war zones in a pandemic is a very high risk thing to do, particularly when she was warned to get out before Kabul fell.
Has it?? Haven't seen evidence in the media that it has. Meanwhile, there could be a pile-on starting…
GB News presenter Wootton, who was born in New Zealand, says it shows there is "nothing kind about Dear Leader Ardern".
"More unimaginable cruelty from Jacinda Ardern in her hermit kingdom," he tweeted. "The full story is astonishing and very much worth your time. This is what New Zealand passport holders are having to endure, even though it is a legal right for us to return. Ardern's Government is clearly breaking the law."
Nothing new there. Wootton works for GB News and is constantly bashing left wing governments wherever he sees them.
Try to focus on the issue rather than the person. Otherwise, all those negative and personal comments about John Key could have been swept away with a big STFU. Serious issues don’t deserve a childish response.
Oh and left wing vs right wing went out in the 80s, didn’t it?
Wootton was not the TV editor during the phone hackings. They took place before 2006 and he did not join the News of the World until 2007 and did not become the TV editor until November 2007.
Are you really going to hang a man for something he had nothing to do with?
NZ should get Charlotte Bellis back here asap and set her up to sort out the international problems relating to the Taliban on behalf of the Government. She appears to be able to communicate very effectively without having to resort to the bluster, bullshit and threats and has obviously had results from the moment the illegal combatants had their arses kicked out of Afghanistan.
Oh, must be dreaming – the US and its pathetic hangers on won't allow NZ to be an honest broker. They are obviously more intent on holding onto the billions in gold that belongs to Afghanistan and are quite happy to starve the inhabitants for propaganda purposes.
The Critical Purpose Visitor Visa. If you hold a Critical Purpose Visitor Visa you can travel to New Zealand even though the border is closed. This is a temporary visa that allows you to come to New Zealand for 6-12 months.
While the EU is similar offering the standard Schengen visa for 3 months in any 6, she'd used half of hers already.
It's all risky stuff, these foreign correspondent jobs.
she applied for an emergency MIQ spot but received a rejection letter on January 24. Among the reasons given were that she and her partner's travel dates were more than 14 days away and she did not provide evidence she had scheduled medical treatment in New Zealand.
Being pregnant is unscheduled according to the bureaucrat who issued the rejection. God scheduled the baby but any little hitler knows he is above God.
My take is that they put one & one together to make one, but it doesn't happen automatically. Some deity must authorise it first. Don't like God? Choose Gaia then.
Someone in our public service is trying to undermine Labour – using the MIQ strategy
The buck stops with the PM and this Government. Excuses don't wash.
And this isn't just about Bellis. As Stuff reported back in October 2021, one couple took the Government to court to get redress. The Government will have been well aware of the issue before Bellis' application:
Sami knew of nine couples with babies due in the next three months and wanted a court ruling to help them. Since she started the campaign on September 23, two women had already had traumatic births without their partners to help, after their MIQ applications were refused.
“I never want anyone to go through what I’ve gone through. We need a policy change. It’s just crazy. It can’t be that you have to take the government to court to get entry, if pregnancy is an issue with MIQ…There's just too much risk for a very vulnerable time in your life.”
But the very vulnerable Taika Waititi just made into MIQ for at least the second time. Woohoo!!
But the very vulnerable Taika Waititi just made into MIQ for at least the second time. Woohoo!!
They have a completely separate system for emergency MiQ, for bloody obvious reasons. Obviously there are long standing problems with MiQ, but no need to make the debate stupider than it has to be.
Hmmm so Bellis made the mistake of applying for emergency MIQ rather than the run-of-the-mill MIQ. Let's be empathetic towards her because it was a rookie error.
Dopey fuck went there to further her career and when it looks like she might have fucked up and she has to join the queue, despite her immediate option of a safe third country, mutts like yourself swallow her special pleading. Idiots.
So now if someone offends another person's sensitivities, in relation to a third party who is not without resources, it is vile?
Actually, NZ should accommodate Ms Bellis immediately – she could teach the Minister of Foreign Affairs how to chart an independent diplomatic course. Someone needs to negotiate with the Taliban in good faith to save the millions of starving Afghanis that too many countries couldn't give a stuff about.
Funny how the MIQ bunny thinks he can bamboozle everyone with lots of words. Dunno if it will work all that well as an evasion strategy.
Notice how he fails to explain why the 14 day window is necessary. I suppose we must wait to see if Charlotte is able to jump through this particular hoop but whoever created it lacks credibility. Wanker?
I was pretty disgusted you misrepresenting the situation so you can take a pop at civil servants. Which is why I added the note.
Notice how he fails to explain why the 14 day window is necessary. I suppose we must wait to see if Charlotte is able to jump through this particular hoop but whoever created it lacks credibility.
Yep, he could have taken twice as many words to explain something that is extraneous to solving Bellis' situation right now. Or he could have stayed focused on the issue at hand. MSM could of course now pick up the issue and explain to the public what is going on and why, instead of going off on one.
My guess, without looking too hard, is that they need some boundaries in the system. If they don't create that structurally, then it comes down to the staff person on the day. Is that really how you think MiQ should be run? Letting individual staff make decisions about who should be let in and who shouldn't?
No, I don't agree that some bureaucratic scumbag hiding behind anonymity ought to be allowed to get away with discriminating against women in traumatic situations instead of helping them. Simple! It's sickening.
yes, she is. Because she's pregnant in a country where giving birth or having a pregnancy complication might kill her or her baby. They should be letting anyone back in pronto in that situation.
I wondered that too at first, but what country do you think would give her a visa right now? And it's a pretty easy lie to get caught out in when going majorly public if it's not true.
You have already confirmed that she had 6 months in Belgium and did not use it.
Where did I say that?
I am presuming you can apply for an M.I.Q spot in NZ from…Belgium…doesn't make such a heart string story though.
Your own link says,
Unable to legally remain in Belgium,
I thought the lottery is closed currently. Without going through the emergency process she would have to wait until the end of February, assuming that NZ actually opens the borders to Kiwis at that time and doesn't have to delay further.
She is a champion of womens rights,yet worked for Al Jazeera owned by according to her, an anti woman Qatar Govt.
It seems she had a Schengen visa which allows free travel to 26 member countries.
So she could have left Belgium and gone to any of 25 other countries-mostly first world.
She will not reveal the name of the country who is offering asylum…wonder why.
Btw my mistake(re you posting) the 180 day visa with 90 days to use is a bit confusing…whatever ,she could still apply from Belgium without political grandstanding.
'On the other hand, nationals of visa-exempt countries can remain in Belgium for up to 90 days, within a 180 day period. The time spent in other countries within the Schengen Area is also counted in this period.
We pondered about where to wait. We flew to Jim's home country of Belgium, but I was not a resident. New Zealanders can only spend three of every six months in the Schengen zone and I had eaten through half of that by the time January came around. We wanted to keep time up our sleeves for an emergency, so decided to rebase.
' We wanted to keep time up our sleeves for an emergency, so decided to rebase.'
Is the situation she found herself in an…emergency?
No, she's trying to pre-empt an emergency that could kill her or harm her baby. Think about it, if she stayed in Belgium (or wherever) she would have to leave in Feb before the NZ borders open. What happens if the borders don't open? Or she didn't get an emergency MiQ place?
How much do you know about pregnancy complications? Or flying in the third trimester?
'If she was in Belgium, or wherever, how would she get back into NZ?' -so why would going back to Afghanistan be any better?
Afaik the only other visa she had was for Afghanistan.
'is the implication there that only people who don't champion women's rights should work for Al Jazeera?'
Not necessarily,but apparantly her regard for the Qatar govt is very flexible.
If a blatantly racist employer offered you a job,would you take it using the same logic?
Well here I am writing on TS despite the sexism.
how can it be contrived if she had nowhere else to go?
We know she could have gone to at least 25 other member countries on her existing visa.
Sigh, we've already covered this.
I'm wondering how the partner feels…now he's about to be a dad,presuming she told him ,she can't get ..pregnant.
Yes she's a journo and knows how to get..attention=horrible creature AFAIC.
'It is very important to be aware that it is illegal for an unmarried woman to be pregnant in Qatar. The consequences of the authorities discovering that a single woman is pregnant include jail and deportation, and even physical punishment (lashings) in some extreme circumstances.
For that reason, women who are not married and find themselves pregnant while living in Qatar should plan to head for home, or to another country. As a marriage certificate is required to have access to maternity care, even getting married after conception will not resolve the situation. Unmarried women who do leave Qatar due to becoming pregnant may also face problems if they return to Qatar after giving birth.
It seems to me that the emotional reaction is foremost in people before the logical questions get asked. This is a woman who was in Afghanistan as a journalist and had contact as such with Taliban. Subsequently according to the Guardian of UK, she found herself pregnant when in Quatar. She left Al Jazeera and went to Belgium which is the country of the baby's father but there she has no entry rights and seemingly he isn't helping? From a safe place in Belgium because NZ was closed with Covid regulations, she decided to go back to Afghanistan with assurances from the Taliban? Is this really true or even possible and who in their right minds would choose to go back there when not even employed any more as a journalist and pregnant? Just to use speciall allocation rights for quick entry back home? Apparently the dates offered were not OK for her so she chose to delay. I can't believe following this that the immediate sinners are apparently the inhumane government services in NZ. What is wrong with logic and responsability today? The rest of the world looks at NZ with admiration and this story shows the lack of respect for rights of one young NZ lady. Amazing. So easy to criticize knowing little of the real facts and so easy to abuse the good countries with good systems.
Very soon a few thousand Onicron cases coming across the border will be like pissing in the sea.
Our much bigger problem now is that our labour market is already struggling to keep up. And we have the big sick coming.
So we are going to desperately need kiwis to come home to help fill the gaps. For instance if quarter of our hospital staff are sick or isolating wouldn’t it be great to have doctors and nurses coming in from overseas. Or if supermarket shelves aren’t being stocked due to a lack of truck drivers, having some more coming across the border would be great.
MIQ has already lost any of its asset value and is now a major liability IMO.
It’s useful for keeping out the hundreds of thousands of pissed off kiwi’s who won’t be able to not vote labour at the next election, as they’ve fallen foul of electoral qualification to vote in 2023
For instance if quarter of our hospital staff are sick or isolating wouldn’t it be great to have doctors and nurses coming in from overseas.
Kiwi nurses and doctors rushing back from overseas during our Omicron wave (February – March)? Mate, you're dreeeaming.
Once NZ's new case numbers top 500 per day (~10 per day in the region I live in), I'm planning to hunkering down so as not to trouble healthcare and supermarket workers. Omicron too shall pass.
I guess by now you have received Omicron, the unwanted visitor that we in Australia hosted over the Christmas season (and beyond – the guest that stayed all summer!)
No doubt you have been busy preparing for this guest – extending your isolation requirements, promoting booster shots and tightening restrictions. But a crucial form of preparation is the one you do in your head.
Going from having very few Covid cases to thousands of cases a day in the community is a mental shift that is hard to prepare for – but having just had a summer of Omicron, I’m writing to tell you what may await.
I’m not writing to instruct you – just to offer some solidarity, the advice I wish I’d been given, a glimpse from the immediate future.
…
So be calm, kind and try not to panic. This too shall pass.
A lot of them also probably have some experience of what it's like to be a healthcare professional during an Omicron wave. I'm not expecting recent returnees to make a big dent in nurse/doctor shortages during our Omicron wave – just hoping that a few will stick around when the pandemic finally winds down.
Patients who are fully vaccinated are faring better than others, Rokach reported, voicing support for Israeli moves to broaden eligibility for fourth vaccine doses. “It’s true that the vaccine isn’t so effective in preventing infection, but we see that it makes a big difference in preventing severe disease,” Rokach said. “We’re really lucky that most of the population took vaccinations, and I think this is the reason Omicron is not causing many more cases of severe disease.”
Rokach thinks that while the current peak in coronavirus cases will push teams like his to their limits, they will cope — even if the national serious case count doubles to 2,000, far beyond predictions. “We are optimistic,” he said, “As we believe the next two weeks will be very very difficult but after that, it will be easier.
Very soon a few thousand Onicron cases coming across the border will be like pissing in the sea.
You appear to either not to understand how much protecting our health system is part of the current pandemic response, or you don't care. Arguing for opening the borders going into an omicron outbreak is basically throwing a whole bunch of more people under the bus.
It isn’t going to take very long before the benefit of keeping cases out will be far outweighed by the shortage of critically needed personnel that MIQ is causing.
Where do you think that tipping point is? Because waiting until we have reached the tipping point will be too late.
Do you agree that we will reach a tipping point where the benefit of keeping cases out will be outweighed by the critical labour shortages in areas including health?
If so do you think it is wise to wait until the tipping point is reached before we do anything about it?
I think bringing in workers with omicron will make that situation worse. The only way your suggestion makes sense if you believe that we should let omicron run free (or freeish). That's a completely different strategic approach, and again you haven't actually explained how that would work for the whole situation but instead have just taken one isolated aspect and suggested a quick fix.
We're heading into a crisis, potential a very serious one. There are no easy answers here, not matter how much we are tempted by the thought of silver bullets.
My own view is that we should all be being very careful right now. One thing people could do, that we were asked to do going into the first lockdown, is not take unnecessary risks with our physical health. I'm thinking about the number of A and E visits over the next month or two and how many could be avoided with people being more cautious for a period of time.
I think Omicron will soon be running free whatever we do.
Imagine a situation where we have 100000 people with Omicron, and all their close contacts are self isolating. Even if it were on five close contacts each that would mean 600000 isolating at once. So, it will quickly come to a point where isolation becomes counter-productive, and the focus will be on keeping as many people productive as possible.
So there will be some point in the fairly near future where the government has no option but to give up on restrictions because they will be counter-productive.
Removing the need for MIQ for returning kiwis doesn’t mean they can’t be self-isolating at home btw. At least then they will be available to help fill the many gaps that are soon going to appear.
you're conflating self-isolation with border control. You've avoided addressing the issue of letting people into NZ now with omicron (or delta for that matter) and how this would impact on the health system, health workers and all the flow on effects.
Removing the need for MIQ for returning kiwis doesn’t mean they can’t be self-isolating at home btw. At least then they will be available to help fill the many gaps that are soon going to appear.
You've just said that self-isolation isn't going to work.
Oh come on. You are completely exaggerating. How is a few extra cases coming across the border going to make a blind bit of difference when Omicron is already endemic in the community and spreading rapidly?
Sure, MIQ slowed down the inevitable. But here we are now. Where we stand now, MIQ might as well have not have existed so far as the current Omicron outbreak is concerned.
It's hardly exaggeration. Getting rid of MIQ will almost certainly mean a lot more than "a few extra cases" coming across the border. And what about the next variant?
Once Omicron has gone through most of us will have good immunity against later variations of Covid, at least in terms of seriousness of disease.
We need to get to a point where we can live with Covid. MIQ is becoming unsustainable. We can't lock our own citizens out of their own country forever.
[citation needed for this claim of fact: “Once Omicron has gone through most of us will have good immunity against later variations of Covid, at least in terms of seriousness of disease.”
By citation I mean a reliable source, an explanation from your, some quotes, and a link. A link on its own is insufficient. If using video, there needs to be clear time stamps and explanation of who the people are as well – weka]
Fair enough. I thought it was fairly well established that previous Covid infections reduce the severity of future infections, so didn't bother with the cite.
But here is one from the monthly news letter from the National Institute of Health US.
Here is a quote from the link above that demonstrates that a previous Covid infection provides protection against future Covid infections:
"After having COVID-19, most people’s bodies develop antibodies to help fight it off. These are special molecules made by the body’s disease defense system, the immune system. A study found that people with these antibodies were less likely to get COVID-19 again."
The main issue I see is that it doesn't say how long the partial anti-body protection lasts. Probably because it was early research.
NIH’s Dr. Lynn Penberthy, who led the research team, explains that more questions still need to be answered. “We are nevertheless encouraged by this early finding,” she says.
You claimed,
Once Omicron has gone through most of us will have good immunity against later variations of Covid, at least in terms of seriousness of disease.
'good immunity' is incredibly imprecise. Your link doesn't support the assertion of seriousness of disease.
meanwhile, this piece from the Guardian last week shows a different picture. Still a lot to learn, and we don't know what it means for long covid or other long term damage.
It's entirely possible that what you hope for (the virus settles into a pattern of waves of less infectious and less harmful infections), but I see no evidence that we are close to that yet and still too many unknowns. Lynn has talked about a five year time frame.
You have to remember that we would be combining natural infection with high rates of vaccination. There is evidence that the combination of both can produce "super immunity".
From the link below:
"Scientists have claimed that a so-called "super-immunity" to Covid-19 can be achieved by people who have been infected by the virus after receiving the vaccine for the disease.
"In a new paper, Oregon Health and Science University (OHSU), experts say the same is also true for people who get infected before getting two jabs.
It was publicised fairly widely at the time that the reason Covid was so aggressive is that the human species had little experience with this particular flu hence had little in the way of natural immunity to it.
However, one of reasons postulated to explain why Omicron is considered to not be as harmful as previous iterations is due to immunisation and previous Covid infection in populations:
"Scientists are trying to determine the extent to which this is because of higher immunity rates engendered by vaccination or past illness, or Omicron is intrinsically less nasty."
'good immunity' is incredibly imprecise. Your link doesn't support the assertion of seriousness of disease.
So far as "good immunity" is concerned I mean less likely to develop severe infection rather than not being infected at all, as per this definition from the Merriam-Webster online dictionary:
"having or producing antibodies or lymphocytes capable of reacting with a specific antigen"
It's entirely possible that what you hope for (the virus settles into a pattern of waves of less infectious and less harmful infections), but I see no evidence that we are close to that yet and still too many unknowns. Lynn has talked about a five year time frame.
So,
"These results, together with our previous work, point to a time when SARS-CoV-2 may become a mostly mild endemic infection like a seasonal respiratory tract infection, instead of a worldwide pandemic."
Point to a time.
We're not there yet. Opening up the borders and letting covid run free in NZ at this time would be a disaster. The strategy is to slow spread as much as we can, and I presume immunise further. By the time the omicron vax becomes available we may well have a much better understanding of both immunity and timeframes.
The problem with an Omicron Vax is that we may well be through this wave before the vaccine becomes available.
I guess we will see how this plays out over the next few months. But my thoughts are that the whole isolation system will become so unworkable that it will be abandoned fairly quickly. I have talked to quite a number of people who have said they will simply ignore being tested if the isolation regime stays as it is. If there is mass civil disobedience in this respect, then there will be little to stop the virus from spreading.
What we are doing now may slow progression down for a week or two. But I think we end up with "let it rip" eventually whether we like it or not.
Anyway, that is just speculation, so we will have to wait to see what happens in reality.
So there will be some point in the fairly near future where the government has no option but to give up on restrictions because they will be counter-productive.
I understand the impulse to return to 'normal' life, but "give up on [all?] restrictions"? During a pandemic? Imho that would be an imprudent response, and a fair indicator of just how dire the prospects for this iteration of civilisation have become.
Omnibus Omicron Intelligence [24 January 2022]
“We have to remain on our toes,” he [Lemieux] said, “because there is still a lot we don’t know about the virus.”
2022’s Imperative: Letting Go of Our Past to Birth Our Future [18 January 2022]
The epic disruptions wrought by a dramatic surge in heat waves, storms, floods, droughts, fires, and now the COVID-19 pandemic leave us desperate to return to life as we previously knew it. In our growing panic, we forget that it is exactly that previous way of living that created the current emergency.
This is not a temporary problem that we can put behind us by electing new political leaders or reducing our use of plastic bags. We are dealing with false assumptions about what and who we are that lead to deeply flawed collective choices. We must publicly challenge those false assumptions and replace them with our deepening understanding of how life works.
I predict that within two months MIQ will be abandoned.
Unless the Team manages to significantly slow Omicron transmission (unlikely, as only China and Taiwan have managed this so far), then within two months Kiwis will be on the far side of our Omicron wave.
And if that turns out to be NZ's only significant wave of COVID-19 cases (which would be an achievement in itself) on the way to a more benign endemic disease globally (keep an eye on South Aftica, the UK, Canada, Ireland, Australia and other countries which already have decreasing numbers of active cases), then by all means abandon MIQ, although imho it would be prudent to retain some MIQ capacity for a little longer, if only on standby.
Omnibus Omicron Intelligence [24 January 2022]
“We have to remain on our toes,” he [Lemieux] said, “because there is still a lot we don’t know about the virus.”
During this on-going viral pandemic, I'm happy to be guided by the consensus opinions of health experts (virologists, epidemiologists, vaccinologists, etc.) Prioritising health will continue to serve us well.
It's already a nightmare trying to get any treatment through A&E – at least in Auckland (I don't have evidence for the rest of the country).
This is all anecdata – but numerous friends report waits of up to 18 hours to be seen over Dec/Jan. None of them were there for anything other than emergency situations (1 broken leg, 1 chest pains with a history of heart trouble, 1 severe abdominal pain).
Our A&E is already overwhelmed long before any impact from Covid.
In a zeitgeist current sweeping through islamic nations, folks are realising doctrinal adherence fails to produce effective governance.
The failure of Islamists to bring about change and effective governance was brought vividly to the fore with the fall of the moderate Islamist party Ennahda in Tunisia on July 25th, 2021, after Tunisian President Kais Saied invoked emergency powers to fire the prime minister and suspend parliament (in which Ennahda had been the largest party). The fall of the Islamist government was largely supported by the public.
Just a day prior to Saied’s suspension of parliament, the country had been gripped by anti-government protests demanding the dissolution of parliament, with groups in the cities of Kairouan and Sousse storming local Ennahda offices and tearing down banners. In the city of Tozeur, a party headquarters was set ablaze.
Saied’s seizure of power, despite being condemned by almost all political parties and civil society organizations within Tunisia as a coup, has been successful because he has tapped into rising public anger over a stagnating economy, political paralysis, and an incompetent response to the COVID-19 crisis. At the time of the coup, Tunisia had recorded the highest per capita death rate from COVID-19 in Africa, while a sluggish vaccine rollout had seen only eight percent of the population fully vaccinated by July 28th.
Meanwhile in Morocco, another moderate Islamist party, the Justice and Development Party (PJD), was removed from power not by a coup but through the ballot box. On September 8th, 2021, Moroccan voters handed the PJD a crushing defeat, with the party losing some 90 percent of the seats it held in parliament.
Sudan saw the most spectacular fall from grace of any Islamisation project across the Muslim world. In April 2019, a peaceful popular uprising led to the downfall of the military dictator Omar al-Bashir, and with him, 30 years of authoritarian rule by the Islamist National Congress Party (NCP).
In August 2021, Malaysia surpassed India’s per-capita COVID-19 death toll. For a country in which race and religion dominate public discourse, the collapse of a coalition ostensibly united by the ideologies of Malay and Islamic supremacism demonstrates, in many ways, the hollowness of the Malay Agenda in the face of a complete inability to govern.
one could argue that the political power of Islamists in Indonesia has been overstated. As noted by Indonesian researcher Nick Kuipers in one pre-election study of the campaign platforms of 72,486 candidates at all levels of government (including for national, provincial, and district legislatures), it was found that only 5.7 percent of candidates had actually explicitly referred to religious themes in their platforms.
In early November 2021, the FBI raided his apartment, handcuffed him in his underwear and seized two phones. He was not arrested. Reportedly, the feds swooped in connection with the disappearance and unauthorized publication of a diary kept by Ashley Biden, the president’s daughter.
Project Veritas never wrote anything on the topic and handed the document over. The justice department had placed the first amendment and O’Keefe’s civil liberties in its crosshairs, notwithstanding a court-ordered warrant. But that is only part of the story.
Problem is, we never get the full story. Intriguing hints tantalise but never go anywhere. Readers roll their eyes & move on…
And we must keep in mind that Aotearoa's cheerleader for selling out to China was John Key. Thought it was such a brilliant idea that a Chinese govt spook became a National MP to facilitate the process…
Yeah, the American sell-out to China was bipartisan. Led by Clinton but since Nixon had launched the trend in '71 can't blame the Dems for jumping aboard later.
Reps would argue that Nixon was merely doing triangulation on the Russians, using China as a tool for that. True. However the capitalists drove the process on a bipartisan basis. The idea was traditional: use cheap labour. China had plenty to offer. Destroying unionism in the USA was just a bonus.
New Zealand [exporters] owe [their] material wellbeing to Chinese customers
The evidence we are richer is actually pretty thin on the ground:
We find that even though the NZ export sector experienced gains from the 2008 FTA, this FTA did not have any observable impact on real GDP per capita, where GDP per person is an informative indicator of welfare across a broad range of countries.
I suspect that Ad meant we as in the upper class plus the upper middle class, with the strugglers getting a trickle-down you need a microscope to measure as per the classic neoliberal prescription…
Ad not all New Zealanders are richer with the relationship with China, a select few are making good coin, however with the importation of Chinese House Farmers our real estate prices have gone through the roof and the Average Joe can not afford a house especially if they are on minimum wages trying to bring up a family.
Jesse sweating the destruction of the fabric of society.
Classic Disney cartoon figure Minnie Mouse is donning a tailored suit for the 30th anniversary of Disneyland Paris, and conservative critics aren’t happy, describing the outfit change as perpetuating the destruction of the “fabric of our society.” society”.
“Why are they doing this?” Fox News host Jesse Watters asked. “They’re bored out of their minds,” he said of those who decided it was a good idea to give the famous Disney mouse a makeover.
When they start teaching the new version of NZ History, warts and all, will the nature of Imperialism be taught alongside or will that be ignored, because that wart is not just history, it is an ongoing evil?.
More than ongoing evil, capitalist economics predicated on endless 'growth' which gave rise to expansionism beyond national borders to seize colonies and resources, eventually crashing up against the borders of other rival capitalist powers attempting to do the same, which inevitably leads to world war, has led to something even worse.
The endless growth economy that gave rise to imperialism, colonialism and world war has now crashed up against the natural finite limits of the planet.
The growth economy that gave rise to colonialism and imperialism and world war, is now threatening the existence of all life on earth, through climate change.
Will this be taught in schools?
While we are still embarked on the same MAD course.
It's worth the risk of repeating the story to highlight the crap that is coming from some quarters. I appreciate we have to be understanding and be constructive but retards should be called out. Is it possible from social media platforms to identify those responsible for stories such as this? Let them stand on their hind feet and address the nation with their wisdom.
"Reports of death at West Coast vaccination clinic ‘complete load of rubbish’, says mayor
Grey District mayor Tania Gibson has debunked a false rumour that a child died at a Covid-19 vaccination clinic in Greymouth.
Misinformation circulating on social media alleged a 12-year-old child died at a vaccination clinic in Greymouth on Friday. The posts claimed a cover-up.
“That is an absolute complete load of rubbish,” said Gibson.
“But seeing these complete and utter fabrications coming from people who are choosing not to get vaccinated… These people are very dangerous and just very stupid.”
Gaslight? Really. I thought anti vaxxers were as OK with their views as pro vaxxers were of thiers.
Who is doing the gaslighting?
All of us who have had the vaccine, really? I don't think so. AV are fighting some mindless battle when all they need to do is make their decision and hold to it. I am assuming those making an anti vaxx decsion are making this in the knowledge of the consequences. I don't think I have seen reports of pro vaxxers shouting down people at meetings, behaving appallingly badly outside vaccination clinics.
This so called gaslighting sounds very like a poor me attitude – viz I've made a decision that I am comfortable with and now I want to be a toad to the rest, dare I say the majority who have also made a decision and just want to get on with it.
Is gaslighting in your world just to have a contrary stance? So all of those who are gaslighting are the ones who have had a vaccine? Really?
Frankly I think the branch covidians have hatched a cunning plan to make up these stories so they can then go "but if it was so safe, why do the authorities have to keep denying that kids are dying?"
They've been promised victims. Unfortunately, all those folk keeling over in the street following adverse reactions have been kept double-dare hush-hush so to fulfill the prophecy, they've had a crack at martyring themselves.
But still no luck and now it's make up wtf you like.
I've been called a covidian cultist by a certain someone here, no prizes for guessing.
But I think the Covidians should be the name assigned to the anti-vaxxers. After all they have chosen to embrace the covid by inviting it into their temple with such dedication as to decline any defensive shield. That sounds like someone happy to dice with death and worthy of the name Covidian.
Vaccinian could then be the name for those pro vaccine people the Covidians like to berate for their choice not to join the Covidian Cultists.
Andre had a good 'un in june 2020 calling dolt45 the "coronakoresh" and his followers the "Branch Covidians", but it seems I Feel Love was the first to use the term in a comment.
Only 26 per cent of voters support the Government’s Three Waters reform, according to the latest 1News Kantar Public Poll. The poll indicates 40 per cent of voters are opposed to the reforms, while 35 per cent were either unsure or didn’t know they were happening.
Since the status quo seems to be nationwide mismanagement with pockets of competence here & there, a genuinely progressive policy containing realistic solutions is what we need. What we lack is faith in Labour's ability to provide that…
I agree. The upside for Labour is that all they need to do to rescue the thing is a classic sales job. Hire a pr company or ad agency if there's nobody capable on the team!
Moreover, SII has been conducting a phase 3 efficacy trial of Novavax since last February. Grant, India's task force member, said SII told him the Novavax vaccine is "extremely effective" against Omicron, in the vicinity of 90%.
He added: "I think it is extremely important that everybody be given the third shot and as quickly as possible. Now, what we have found is that people who are taking Covishield, the third shot has not been so effective. But the new vaccine that is coming out from Serum Institute, Covovax, is very, very effective. In fact, against the Omicron virus, if you've taken the new vaccine of Serum, we are finding fantastic results."
I think most investors didn't see the interview on Indian TV. When SII announces the results, it could be a game-changer by making Novavax the only vaccine with high efficacy against Omicron. Novavax has also been doing a large booster trial during the Omicron wave in the US. I expect it will announce results in March or April.
It's incorrect to predict Covid is becoming endemic or that future variants won't be more severe
In September, a physician wrote: "Covid will soon be endemic…" and "widespread immunity, vaccinated and natural, will bring control and a full return to normal". Since then, the delta and omicron waves have killed another 180,000 in the US. Now, some media outlets and officials are repeating the same mistake by predicting Covid will be endemic this year.'
Ad not all New Zealanders are richer with the relationship with China, a select few are making good coin, however with the importation of Chinese House Farmers our real estate prices have gone through the roof and the Average Joe can not afford a house especially if they are on minimum wages trying to bring up a family.
A group of vaccine-sceptic writers are generating revenues of at least $2.5m (£1.85m) a year from publishing newsletters for tens of thousands of followers on the online publishing platform Substack, according to new research.
Prominent figures in the anti-vaccine movement including Dr Joseph Mercola and Alex Berenson have large followings on Substack, which has more than 1 million paying subscribers who sign up for individual newsletters from an array of authors who include novelist Salman Rushdie, the writer musician Patti Smith and former Downing Street adviser Dominic Cummings.
Mercola, a US alternative medicine doctor and prolific producer of anti-vaccine content, and Alex Berenson, a journalist banned from Twitter last year after questioning the efficacy of Covid-19 vaccines, are among five vaccine sceptics on the platform who earn themselves and Substack a minimum of $2.5m a year from their newsletters. Under Substack’s business model, writers keep about 90% of the subscription income, with the platform taking 10% and payment company Stripe charging the writers 3% of their take.
Here is what Robert Malone, the vaccine skeptic reportedly interviewed by Rogan in a favourable manner on Spotify [I haven't heard the interview], has been been saying about Covid vaccines.
Genuinely in the running for a Nobel, but too eccentric to be a team player is my take. Anti-establishment (like me). I agree he's onto something here:
“Mass formation psychosis” is not an academic term recognized in the field of psychology, nor is there evidence of any such phenomenon occurring during the COVID-19 pandemic, multiple experts in crowd psychology have told Reuters.
Experts playing it safe is nothing new. The thing is happening. It will become clear to them in retrospect. However this expert is credible as a sceptic:
Reuters also spoke to Steven Reicher, Professor of Social Psychology at the University of St Andrews, who has studied crowd psychology for more than 40 years. He described the concept of a “mass psychosis” as “more metaphor than science, more ideology than fact”.
“It arises out of mass society theories and crowd psychology theories which developed in the 19th century, and which reflected a fear of the masses,” he said. “The claim was that people in the mass lose their sense of identity and their ability to reason, they regress to an inferior mental state where they are manipulable by unscrupulous leaders. It has been totally discredited by contemporary work on groups and crowds.”
There was a famous 19th book on the madness of crowds and one sees it in capitalist bubbles & crashes. The phenomenon is real. I suspect the expert sees a technical distinction between that & nazism but cultism is a common feature of mass psychology. Perhaps the ivory tower syndrome is at play here – invent a complex meme & the academic herd collectively shudder at you…
In DSM-IV it is called shared psychotic disorder. The term was first coined by Lasegue and Falret in 1877. It refers to several syndromes in which mental symptoms, particularly paranoid delusions, are transmitted from one person to one or more others with whom the apparent instigator is in some way intimately associated
In some way intimately associated nowadays points to social media. Like-mindedness was a characteristic of in-crowd groups centuries ago. Freemasonry developed into a force at the top level of politics on exactly that basis, and of course there was the history of christianity exemplifying it before that.
The scaling up from a small group to larger groups via contagion is the thing that the competing label ownership bitching amongst professionals seems to focus on. Consultancy generates a money flow – you can see why they get dollar signs in their eyes.
Did that. All you get is a focus on the past. To figure out what's happening now, we need a focus on current belief-based forums & media – to suss out the contagion mechanism. Although the term mechanism is itself antique.
What causes the interpersonal resonance that produces mimetics seems the most promising place to start…
There is no contagion mechanism. There's only people rightly shit-scared of being infected by a virus that can invade and jigger almost very organ and system in your carcass and then for shit and giggles, cross the blood brain barrier and fuck with pretty much every aspect of your neurology.
These rules are just ridiculous. Basically it's a cross-dresser allowed to compete against woman. I must be slow because I was under the impression a trans whatever had undergone a sex change. Clearly I need to do more homework.
You are not slow. This stuff is happening by stealth. None of what is going on overseas is published in the NZ msm. Just puff pieces about being non binary etc.
The gender self id bill that was passed by NZ parliament just before Christmas allows anyone to change the sex on their birth certificate with merely a sign off from a Justice of the Peace. So you don't need to change a thing e.g. have cross sex hormones or surgery. If you are a man, you don't even have to present as a women.
There are huge safe guarding issues here. Not only are these women in the US having competitions stolen from them, they have to put up with seeing male genitals in their change rooms. And they don't speak up because they are competing for sponsorship, scholarships etc. If they did speak up (other than anonymously) they will be accused of transphobia
I don't believe that men pretending to be woman should be allowed to enter a women's event. It's deception and cheating to call yourself a woman until you've at least had the courage of your convictions to have surgery to resemble a woman physically. If these new rules are universal then what happens when a rugby team fields fifteen men pretending to be woman in order to win the Womans Rugby World Cup.
The simplest and fairest way around all this nonsense is to have a completely new category for competition. Nobody can fake a disability and enter the Special Olympics, so why is this charade going on.
I don't think surgery removes the physical advantage that males have over females, so from my perspective surgery wouldn't change the situation much. A lot of the advantage is conferred at puberty, and in Thomas's case from a career as a male swimmer.
The trans umbrella now covers transsexuals (the kind of trans you are thinking of, typically have gender dysphoria and medical/surgical transition gives them a better quality of life), cross-dressing men, non-binary males, gender fluid males, and the transness that gender identity activists won't talk about: autogynephillia. In addition there will be men who fake it. Who knows which Thomas is.
"I don't think surgery removes the physical advantage that males have over females, so from my perspective surgery wouldn't change the situation much."
I agree. Heard an interview on RNZ last year where it was explained how the high testosterone levels during puberty increased muscle power to such a degree that it's patently unfair. New categories are the only fair way for these sporting events to have any integrity.
You are right Fender, the surgery is just cosmetic and imo should only be offered to people who are 25 years old or so (brain fully developed then). It is plastic surgery, so will never alter the dna, bone structure, muscle structure, larger heart and lungs, adventageous hip bones, bigger hands and feet, all of which are some of the advantages male bodied people have over females in sport.
this article is interesting. Comparing the situation with doping, and pointing out that Thomas isn't doping. But in a way they are. If they are taking a drug to alter their performance so that it gives them an advantage (in this case allows them to change categories), then it's not substantially different.
I wonder if the issue wouldn't be better resolved by allow trans women to compete in male categories and have rules around drug use for that. No idea if that would work, but given that TW athlete's bodies are much closer to men's than women's it makes more sense.
I showed my German friend the Kraftwerk Hokey Cokey. His response was the most German thing ever. “Yes it’s very good! It sounds just like Kraftwerk but the German is COMPLETELY WRONG! He says he’s omitting his arm IN when he’s stretching it OUT!”https://t.co/QG0zfJ1WKY
So sad the sociopath won't be able to turn a dollar on his notoriety.
A U.S. judge on Friday approved an agreement by lawyers to destroy the assault-style rifle that Kyle Rittenhouse used to kill two people and wound a third during a 2020 street protest in Wisconsin.
So twice as many people are coming in than 2 years ago, possibly some who sat out their two year visas or more likely stupidly left NZ and went Tiki-touring , like Dippy Jamie Ridge or the pair who motorhomed around the Aussie grandkids "cos we hadn't seen them for two years and its not fair they won't let us back in ". Its a fucking world wide pandemic killing millions and millions you dumb fucks , what were you thinking, oh that right, you bloody weren't!
There is also something of a bullshit story here with Charlotte Bellis, international journalist living overseas in all sorts of places and 6 months pregnant, suddenly needs to be in NZ to have a baby , Why? Flies to Afghanistan for fucks sake, that world exemplar of natal care, Why ?. To garner fucking sympathy. What's wrong with the fathers home country? Have your baby in a bloody cave the same way that the poor, put upon, disadvantaged Afghani women have had to do do for millennia. You created this situation, you deal with it. Supreme entitlement syndrome.
We haven't seen our London based daughter for years and miss her lots but we aren't grandstanding on the media with choruses of it's not fairs.
and despite what Joe said, that graph has nothing to do with Bellis' case. She applied under the emergency provisions. Of course those cases should get priority.
There is also something of a bullshit story here with Charlotte Bellis, international journalist living overseas in all sorts of places and 6 months pregnant, suddenly needs to be in NZ to have a baby , Why?
Because it's routine for women to die in child birth in Afghanistan.
Flies to Afghanistan for fucks sake, that world exemplar of natal care, Why ?. To garner fucking sympathy.
Because she had nowhere else to go. She was in Qatar when she found out she is pregnant, and it's illegal there to be unmarried and pregnant. She initially thought she was going to be able to get back to NZ in Feb, then the government cancelled the border opening because of omicron.
What's wrong with the fathers home country?
He's Belgian, and as a non-resident she's only allowed there for 3 out of 6 months at a time. She's already used up half of that. She had no visa to anywhere else other than Afghanistan.
Have your baby in a bloody cave the same way that the poor, put upon, disadvantaged Afghani women have had to do do for millennia. You created this situation, you deal with it. Supreme entitlement syndrome.
Not surprising I guess all things considered, but seeing the misogyny arising in this way on the left is always shocking. Even if you don't give a shit about the safety of a pregnant woman, there's still the wellbeing of the child.
She didn't create the situation. She was told by doctors that she couldn't get pregnant, the pregnancy was unplanned. I also think there are few things off about the story, but I don't for one minute think she, or any pregnant NZ woman in a country without NZ standard of medical care shouldn't be let back in as a priority. Wtaf?
She's trying to manipulate the system using emotional tactics to gain sympathy and preferential treatment. I would hazard a guess she knew when she was still in Belgium that she did not fit the criteria for an emergency entry back to NZ. Is that why she returned to Afghanistan? She thought she could garner leverage for her 'emergency' status by being there?
There have been plenty of people who have been in equal or worse circumstances than Ms Bellis – including pregnant women – but they have accepted their misfortune without indulging in public hysteria.
She claims she returned to Afghanistan because she couldn't go anywhere else. That is garbage. Why didn't she contact the British Embassy for help, or one of the other Commonwealth countries? Surely one of them would have allowed her to stay until she was able to return to NZ.
There have been plenty of people who have been in equal or worse circumstances than Ms Bellis – including pregnant women – but they have accepted their misfortune without indulging in public hysteria.
Really? Bellis' lawyer has been taken a number of other cases of pregnant women who've been denied emergency MiQ.
She claims she returned to Afghanistan because she couldn't go anywhere else. That is garbage. Why didn't she contact the British Embassy for help, or one of the other Commonwealth countries? Surely one of them would have allowed her to stay until she was able to return to NZ.
"Surely" 🙄
She's not British.
Please note the following important information:
The United Kingdom authorities determine the conditions under which New Zealand passport holders may enter the UK.
It is your responsibility to ensure that you comply with entry requirements for the United Kingdom.
Failure to meet these requirements could result in you being refused entry and returned to New Zealand or your last point of embarkation.
The New Zealand High Commission cannot interfere in this decision. We have no authority or ability to influence the decisions made by the Border Force or Border Force officers, or make representations on an individual's behalf.
Weka, See Joe90 at 12pm there is a graph in a tweet in his post.. I couldn't believe it either. Bellis's partner is Belgian, and she left Belgium?. Shes Anglican but asked the Catholic Church if she could get married there in Belgium, but there's a 6 month wait. Oh Christ the unfairness, won't somebody think of poor me.
It seems really hard to believe but as a Kiwi you need a Visa for the countries that abide by the Schengen Accord.
What she should have done is take the next train to Germany, or even do it in Belgium/Holland/Luxemburg/France and simply ask for Asylum as a stateless person. She would have been granted it, pretty sure of it.
No, there are different criteria for asylum in europe. For what its worth, she could have demanded asylum in a roman catholic church and would have been granted it at least for a wee while, and during this time she could have sorted something more permanent with a different host country.
She is defacto stateless as are all other Kiwis that can not simply board a plane and come back home. In essence she is dependend on good fortune and a government willing to allow people to come back, and it appears she is out of luck on that one.
I have been waiting for something like this to happen, in fact i am waiting for someone to take the government to the human rights tribunal over this.
But as a stateless person she can apply for Asylum and she would be granted it.
While stateless people can be recognized as refugees and can apply for asylum the regular way, they are more vulnerable and often enjoy fewer rights than other refugees: … – Stateless people can be at greater risk of being detained or forcibly returned because of lack of identity documents.
And i would like to point out that if NZ'lers overseas now can't even vote in the next election then they are truly stateless and without a government.
New Zealanders stranded overseas should be allowed to vote in next year’s local government elections and the 2023 general election, the Green Party said today.
“The reality of this pandemic is lots of people cannot renew their voting rights when they are home as they normally would. The Government must extend the three-year timeframe so New Zealanders can still exercise their democratic rights,” Green Party electoral reform spokesperson Golriz Ghahraman said.
Anyways, it still changes nothing on the fact that the stranded kiwis overseas are essentially stateless unless they are allowed without and ifs whys and buts to return.
Well that press relieve was from September last year, lets hope they get cracking on that, a lot of the overseas vote does tend to go to L or G. Maybe that will help them getting it done. 🙂
heh, probably. I reckon it won't be top of Labour's list at the moment given it's more than 18 months until the next election. They still seem to think the borders are going to be open in a few months.
She still has a NZ passport, and she's still allowed back in via the lottery system. The lottery system is fucked up, and it may well be making people temporarily defacto stateless, but I doubt international law will see it that way (we will see I guess).
The passport is useless without a spot in MIQ. If she can't come home because she will be denied entry then she is stateless and should / could demand asylum elsewhere.
Currently her passport has about as much value as a call to Winz that is not answered. You might have theoretical access, but it is not given or granted.
To be published in Refuge, Volume 22:2, Summer 2004
IV. Determining Statelessness
27. The 1954 Convention provides the internat ionally recognized definition of a
stateless person in Article 1 of the instrum ent.21 This is the ba sis on which States c an
determine at the nation al lev el to whom the Convention will app ly. It is also th e
appropriate basis for harmonization of approaches as between States. Each State Party
determines through its own proced ures whet her a person fits th e definition of a
stateless person outlined in Article 1. Clearly, th e first criterion for application of the
Convention to an individual is that the pe rson is found by the State concerned to be
stateless.22
28. If the person is found not to be st ateless, the Convention will not be
applicable. Existing State pr actice in the EU varies, with very f ew of the M ember
States possessing a specialised procedure dedi cated to examining an applicant’s claim
of stateles sness. If, however, States do not approach Article 1 with a comm on
interpretation or application, it will be impossible to harmonize implementation of the
Convention overall or, indeed, for decisions taken by one State party to be recognized
as between States parties. Th is could m ean that a s ingle case will arriv e at vary ing
results depending on the State in which the stateless person makes an application. A s
one of the key objectives of the 1954 Conven tion is to prom ote the acquisition of a
legal identity for a stateless person in one State, which will be widely recognized by
other States, a lack of harm onized interpretation or implementation of Article 1 r isks
limiting the benefits of this instrument for both States and individuals concerned.
i. Definition of a stateless person
29. The definition, set out in Article 1( 1) provides that a stateless person is one
“who is not considered as a national by any State under the operation of its law.” Thi s
is the definition used at the international level and is incorporated into the nationality
laws of m any States. 23 By indicating that a statele ss person is som eone who is not
considered a national by any State under the operation of its law , the drafters refer to
a legal bond between an indivi dual and a State w hich is based on the internal laws of
the State concerned.
it still does not change anything for anyone over seas.
Asylum is for everyone, anyone can claim it. It is up to the host country if this person fits into international agreements and treaties. And if she was offered Asylum as a de facto stateless person rather then say a refugee of war (and i guess one could claim this status too considering we are at 'war' with this virus) than that is up to the host country.
It is up to NZ to find a better solution to this current debacle, and the NZ Political elite would do better to come up with a more humane set up and process.
but maybe these guy can give you an answer more to your liking?
And under the guise of Covid measures, Kiwis right to return is severely curtailed if not outright made impossible – under the guise of 'keeping people here safe'. Ergo, They are Stateless.
stateless
/ˈsteɪtləs/
(of a person) not recognized as a citizen of any country.
And unless she is one of the lucky few to win in a lottery (hunger games by any other name) then yeah, she is not recognized a citizen.
Comparing MIQ to the hunger games is not hyperbole, its been a fucking reality for people stuck overseas that can't come home, or for people here that need to travel (NEED, not want) but can't unless they win the lottery. What needs to happen now is actually for lefties to demand better of their own parties and their own government. Not that your party and the ruling party would listen.
As for the international rules regarding refugees, every country has their own interpretation underneath the rules that you listed. So if a country decides that that women is akin to being a refugee – or is seeking refugee because her own country, her own government refuses to let her travel back 'home', then yes she is a refugee. It does not matter one bit how bad that makes the country or the current lot in parliament look to the world. That is something for this government to consider and maybe even do something about it, someday. surely.
There was no reason for Germany to take up one million Syrian refugees in 2015 -by international standard and law, but they did take up one million Syrian refugees because of humanitarian reasons. While the two go hand in hand, they are quite different from each others. Refuge is something in Europe that anyone can claim, Refuge or Asylum is still granted in Churches, and not everything fits into some neat and tidy laws that allow others to point out why they should not have done what they did on the basis that it might not be explicitely listed as a ‘valid’ reason for a refugee and asylum claim.
She was granted refuge by a host country because the host country decided that she fit that host countries requirements, under the current laws. And the shame about this is for NZ to bear.
ME : And unless she is one of the lucky few to win in a lottery (hunger games by any other name) then yeah, she is not recognized a citizen.
Weka: This hyperbole doesn't help. She still has rights, overseas, as a NZ passport holder. Those didn't disappear because of MiQ
Yes, you said what you said, and i read past your line, hence why i stated that right now anyone who can not get in NZ because of the fuckwittery that is MIQ – and the refusal over the last two years to refuse any changes to the MIQ system, means her rights are not being upheld by this government.
And frankly for what its worth, the government is having so much egg on their faces that the best they now can do is put a category up for pregnant beings that need to come home. She is not hte only one, she is just someone with enough clout to make a ruckus and its obvious she really don't care anymore.
This government has made people a. stateless, b. dependent on the generosity of other countries, and hopes that other countries not only vaccinate these people, but house them – if they can't afford it anymore without working visas, feed them, and medically take care of them.
This government has totally dropped the ball on the people stuck overseas, so much so that the Green Party at this stage must fear for their voters overseas, as evidenced by the link from yesterday that i posted for you, because these guys will loose their right to vote if laws are applies as they stand. So no right to retun and a possible loss of the vote. That is not Hyperbole Weka, that is reality for people overseas under this government.
Personally i believe that the Kiwis stuck in OZ should all start committing crimes in OZ so that they are deported as 503 back to NZ. Maybe that will allow poeple to come back home.
some of her rights, she hasn't lost all her rights. That's the hyberbole that I think is unhelpful. I know it's your commenting style, but I think the point is important.
(haven't read the rest of that comment either, because I really don't want to spend time on things where I'm being misunderstood, sorry. I think your comments about the legal and human rights issues re MiQ are important, I just can't dig through all of that atm).
'Personally i believe that the Kiwis stuck in OZ should all start committing crimes in OZ so that they are deported as 503 back to NZ. Maybe that will allow poeple to come back home.'
It seems that people who are sentenced for 12 months or more are the ones selected for deportation.
Doubt your advice would be viewed as helpful by any sane…person.
Asylum has a stateless aspect to it as well, Which Bellis would meet as the States which she is resident of, or citizen of, are unable to provide the care of the state for a variety of reasons.
She could have hopped over the Channel to England, which isn't in Schengen. After 3 months you can go back into any Schengen country. She sounds a pretty ballsy woman and rightly pissed off about misjudging her return to NZ, but hardly anything she wouldn't have been prepared for staying on in Afghanistan when she could have returned earlier.
Nationals of certain countries, enjoy visa-free travel to these countries for stays of up to 90 days. There are 62 countries whose citizens do not need to visa'
Yes, New Zealanders can work in Europe without having to apply for a work visa beforehand.
However, upon their arrival to the country where they will be working, NZ passport holders are required to apply for their local residence and work permit.
So she did not need a Visa to travel to Belgium, and if only staying there as a tourist can stay there for up to three month – ditto for someone from Belgium coming here, but anything more then that she needs to apply for a visa, and that visa can be refused, and in her case was probably refused because she is pregnant and will need neonatal, birthing, and post natal care.
What she should have done is fly to OZ, commit a crime and get deported to NZ. s/
'It is very important to be aware that it is illegal for an unmarried woman to be pregnant in Qatar. The consequences of the authorities discovering that a single woman is pregnant include jail and deportation, '
She worked for the Qatar Govt and is well connected enought to even ring the Taleban hierarchy .
She will be jailed. She will be jailed for as long as it takes to get there their deportation case actioned. \
She is pregnant. She is a citizen. She wants to come home. And fwiw, she would not be applying to MIQ if she weren't pregnant.
And last, she is a Citizen. She has a right to return to NZ. And hte government has dropped the ball on MIQ sometime ago and decided that they just could not be bothered picking that ball up and making it workable.
I just right now enjoy how she upsets all the 'kind' and 'loving' and 'empathic' lefties into a frothy furor at her audacity to call out the bullshittery that is MIQ, and the fact that Kiwis overseas are stateless and are being granted Refugee Status by the likes of hte Taliban. You can't make that shit up actually. How dare she, to witch i say, behold her field of fucks to grow and see it is barren.
Adrian I see where you are coming from on your comments. A bit harsh on the hapless folk overseas but yes you are right. People who think two years is a vast time to be apart from family just need to take a reality check. Missing grandchildren after a two year absence is a nonsense – use Zoom its fun and wow – actually seeing their faces like they are in the same room as you.
We also have absent family and haven't seen them for over three years, they have been living overseas now for 23 years. Its the way of the world these days, the planet has shrunk and we just have to adjust and get on with our lives. I also cannot understand why anybody would want to go overseas doing this pandemic. The PM has advised often enough how uncertain getting back might be for them. They just need a reality check and get used to the idea. Keep up the zooming, its a lot of fun and better than the weekly aerogram I sent to my parents when I was on my OE many years ago. We don't know how lucky we are.
my reading of Ellis, supposition really, is that given the kind of work she does she was ok with getting stuck outside of NZ and taking risks with her personal safety. Pregnancy changed that, not hard to understand.
From Bernard Hickey's current summary on happenings:
<i>Meanwhile, the top selling vehicle by a country mile last year was the diesel-powered Ford Ranger (12,580 sales), which weighs in at two tonnes and generates 20 times more carbon emissions per kilometre as a petrol-electric hybrid hatchback.</i>
We are getting hassled about cars, parking being taken away, being menaced by fast-ridden bikes and electric skateboards on the footpath and yet some controlling rules on behemoths that straddle one and a half lanes, block vision on forward traffic, and are a big blot on the landscape, are absent or making little effect.
Today I found out that if you google your favourite animal on a smartphone, it gives you an option to use the camera to project a full scale 3D image. And you can embiggen it.
And there was me thinking they're Canadians, they're alright.
While Indigenous and Black people are killed for speaking up, white supremacists get a free pass in Canada. Just look at the convoy
This convoy, which I refuse to link with truckers or “freedom”, shows us who is allowed to speak up in this country, and who will be arrested, attacked and threatened for doing so, Joy Henderson writes.
To Weka, I had intended to wish the child to be all the best but ran out of time and forgot for which I am sorry, and far from misogynistic I like most am appalled by the lot of women in places such as Afghanistan and such travesty’s have hardened my attitude to religion and the patriarchy that run most of them. A pox on all thier houses. I am only a few generations away in this country, much like the rest of the world from having been born in a cave or other less than suitable accommodation.
A weekly study of converging right-wing conspiracy theories and faux-progressive wellness utopianism. At best, the conspirituality movement attacks public health efforts in times of crisis. At worst, it fronts and recruits for the fever-dream of QAnon. As the alt-right and New Age horseshoe toward each other in a blur of disinformation, clear discourse and good intentions get smothered.
Charismatic influencers exploit their followers by co-opting conspiracy theories on a spectrum of intensity ranging from vaccines to child trafficking. In the process, spiritual beliefs that have nurtured creativity and meaning are transforming into memes of a quickly-globalizing paranoia. Conspirituality Podcast attempts to bring understanding to this landscape. A journalist, a cult researcher, and a philosophical skeptic discuss the stories, cognitive dissonances, and cultic dynamics tearing through the yoga, wellness, and new spirituality worlds. Mainstream outlets have noticed the problem. We crowd-source, research, analyze, and dream answers to it.
Weka, you completely miss the point, getting pregnant wasn’t a poor choice but going to Afghanistan was an appallingly bad choice, not getting her shit together months ago by joining the MIQ queue and not following the entry requirements properly was, and now using the fact that she is pregnant in a country with sub standard maternity services as leverage is cynical in the extreme.
Weka, you completely miss the point, getting pregnant wasn’t a poor choice but going to Afghanistan was an appallingly bad choice,
why? She's a journalist. Are you saying that journalists should go home and not report from countries like Afghanistan when Afghanistan is in the middle of a massive sociopolitical crisis?
not getting her shit together months ago by joining the MIQ queue
When did she find out she was pregnant? When did she apply for the emergency MiQ? What should she have done if she didn't win the MiQ lottery?
and not following the entry requirements properly was,
That one I agree with.
and now using the fact that she is pregnant in a country with sub standard maternity services as leverage is cynical in the extreme.
Ok, let's leave her there then and let her and her baby be at risk. That's cynical in the extreme.
It is not just her and her child, it is everyone who can not come home. It is down right ugly, never mind illegal – unless human rights are something now that is only for Kiwis who live here -, and so unkind.
Sad thing really is that in two years time now this fucked up MIQ process was the best our highly expensive and highly educated doodahs in government and government agencies could come up with.
We just have to accept that the logistics and resources needed to cater for the numbers of people wanting to come home during a pandemic are too great for us to handle. What could have been done short of building a new city to complete such an exercise?
I wonder then where people would go once exiting MIQ. We already can't house the people we have. The more coming would have lead to more leakage and outbreaks. But it looks conceivable that in the not too distant future there could be so much Omicron around there won't be much of a requirement for the system?
well when Labour open the borders and let all the tourists, workers and immigration back in, there won't be enough housing for returning Kiwis then either.
(doubt we have a shortage of accommodation currently, more it's the cost issue and logistics).
Our response at keeping NZers as safe as possible has been better than any other country, 55 deaths in 2 years, minimal Long Covid as far as we know. The World Standard. Right at the start everybody overseas was told come home now or you are on your own, or face isolation on return. It worked and a lot of people we all know are almost certainly only alive today because of the superb management. Do not forget that. The carping and whinging and attempts at gaming the system going on now pisses me off.
"The carping and whinging and attempts at gaming the system going on now pisses me off."
Yep. Its only a minority of NZers who are doing it. The majority accept things are the way they are for good reason, and though it might have gone against them are prepared to wait patiently for when they can also return.
It seems to me that the emotional reaction is foremost in people before the logical questions get asked. This is a woman who was in Afghanistan as a journalist and had contact as such with Taliban. Subsequently according to the Guardian of UK, she found herself pregnant when in Quatar. She left Al Jazeera and went to Belgium which is the country of the baby's father but there she has no entry rights and seemingly he isn't helping? What about a visa and self-financing until able to go home? From a safe place in Belgium because NZ was closed with Covid regulations, she decided to go back to Afghanistan with assurances from the Taliban? Is this really true or even possible and who in their right minds would choose to go back there when not even employed any more as a journalist and pregnant? Just to use speciall allocation rights for quick entry back home? Apparently the dates offered were not OK for her so she chose to delay. I can't believe following this that the immediate sinners are apparently the inhumane government services in NZ. What is wrong with logic and responsability today? The rest of the world looks at NZ with admiration. This story shows the lack of respect for rights of real cases of desperation in Afghanistan from one young NZ lady. Amazing. So easy to criticize knowing little of the real facts and so easy to abuse the good countries with good systems. I am not a NZer. I think you should be applauding your government trying to keep you healthy and instill a bit of responsability on people in their twenties who seem to think everything should go their way and instantly.
Some defenders of Ukrainian neo-Nazis claim Nashi is a Russian neo-Nazi group or at least links the Kremlin to a neo-Nazi subculture. Image credit: Wikipedia Moving on in my critique of the article mentioned in the first post of this series (see Confusion about ...
Some people are still in the denial stage regarding the presence and role of neo-Nazis in Ukraine. OK, I can understand how people who don’t know the history behind this current war and are influenced by the wartime campaigns of virtue-signalling may hold to this denial stage. It’s not ...
Dawn Felagund over at The Silmarillion Writers Guild has been putting together an interesting look at the ways in which Tolkien fandom changed as a result of the Peter Jackson movies. In addition to the Tolkien Fanfiction Survey, she has been getting direct feedback from fans who were around ...
Australia went to the polls on Saturday, and while the preferences are still being counted, clearly voted for a change of government. Unfortunately, this being Australia, this meant swapping one coal-loving, refugee-hating racist for another. Which is perhaps why Labor's primary vote share decreased this election, with voters instead turning ...
Australia’s new PM Anthony Albanese faces an obvious dilemma, barely before he gets his feet under the desk. Australia is the world’s leading exporter of coal. Will the new Labor government prioritise the jobs for Queensland/NSW workers in its mining-dependent communities – or will Labor start to get serious about ...
From Public Housing To The Lodge: Anthony Albanese wins the Australian Federal Election, bringing the career of Scott Morrison and his boofhead Coalition government to an end. The defeat of the boofheads was the victory Australia had to have.CRIKEY! Those Aussies are pissed-off. To appreciate just how pissed-off they are ...
Jacinda Ardern’s trip to the United States this week has been months in the making. A stop in Washington DC is already locked in, but the Prime Minister’s recent positive test for Covid-19 has delayed the official announcement of a meeting with President Joe Biden. Reports now suggest Ardern is ...
This post is a response to a request from Peter Baillie. I don’t know him from Adam and I suspect he was attempting sarcasm but I offered to give him a response. I would welcome any comments or discussion he could add – but that is up to him. ...
In the wake of an otherwise unremarkable New Zealand Budget, I was not expecting to supply much in the way of political commentary. Why would I? The most notable aspect was Grant Robertson throwing a one-off $350 at anyone who earns less than $70,000 a year and who doesn’t ...
Finland, Sweden, Novorossiya, and Incorrect AnalysesSince Russia's invasion of Ukraine, Putin has made much of NATO's supposed expansion to the east. As I wrote on 1 April:Much has been made of Putin's apparent anger that Ukraine was on the verge of joining NATO.However, this has been over-stated by both Western ...
Hoopla And Razzamatazz: Putting the country into debt allows a Minister of Finance to keep the lights on and the ATMs working without raising taxes. That option may become unavoidable at some future time, for some future government, but that is not the present government’s concern – not in the ...
Speaking Truth To Power: Greta Thunberg argues that the fine sounding phrases of well-meaning politicians changes nothing. The promises made, the targets set – and then re-set – are all too familiar to the younger generations she has encouraged to pay attention. They have heard it all before. Accordingly, she ...
The Spiral of Silence Problem As climate communicator John Cook cleverly illustrates below, a big obstacle to raising awareness about climate change is the "spiral of silence," a reluctance to talk about it. There are many reasons for this reluctance we can speculate about. Perhaps people don't want to be ...
The informed discussion on the next steps in tax policy is about improving the income tax base, not about taxing wealth directly.David Parker, the Minister for Inland Revenue, gave a clear indication that his talk on tax was to be ‘pointy-headed’ by choosing a university venue for his presentation. As ...
A couple of weeks ago, Newsroom reported that the government was failing to meet its proactive release obligations, with Ministers releasing less than a quarter of cabinet papers and in many cases failing to keep records. But Chris Hipkins was already on the case, and in a recent cabinet paper ...
Why are the New Zealand media so hostile to the government – not just this government, but any government? The media I have in mind are not NZME-owned outlets like the Herald or Newstalk ZB, whose bias is overtly political and directed at getting rid of the current Labour government. ...
Dr Amanda Kvalsvig, Prof Michael Baker, Dr Jennifer Summers, Dr Lucy Telfar Barnard, Dr Andrew Dickson, Dr Julie Bennett, Carmen Timu-Parata, Prof Nick Wilson Kvalsvig A, Baker M, Summers J, Telfar Barnard L, Dickson A, Bennett J, Timu-Parata C, Wilson N. The urgent need for a Covid-19 Action Plan for ...
In this week’s “A View from Afar” podcast Selwyn Manning and I speculate on how the Ruso-Ukrainian War will shape future regional security dynamics. We start with NATO and work our way East to the Northern Pacific. It is not comprehensive but we outline some potential ramifications with regard to ...
At base, the political biffo back and forth on the merits of Budget 2022 comes down to only one thing. Who is the better manager of the economy and better steward of social wellbeing – National or Labour? In its own quiet way, the Treasury has buried a fascinating answer ...
by Don Franks Poverty in New Zealand today has new ugly features. Adequate housing is beyond the reach of thousands. More and more people full time workers must beg food parcels from charities. Having no attainable prospects, young people lash out and steal. A response to poverty from The Daily ...
Drought: the past is no longer prologue Drought management in the United States (and elsewhere) is highly informed by events of the past, employing records extending 60 years or longer in order to plan for and cope with newly emerging meterorological water deficits. Water resource managers and agricultural concerns use ...
The government announced its budget today, with Finance Minister Grant Robertson giving the usual long speech about how much money they're spending. The big stuff was climate change and health, with the former being pre-announced, and most of the latter being writing off DHB's entirely fictional "debt" to the the ...
Finance Minister Grant Robertson has delivered a Budget that will many asking “Is that all there is?” There is a myriad of initiatives and there is increased spending, but strangely it doesn’t really add up to much at all for those hoping for a more traditional Labour-style Budget. The headline ...
Last year, Cook Islands Deputy Prime Minister Robert Tapaitau stood down as a minister after being charged with conspiracy to defraud after an investigation into corruption in Infrastructure Cook Islands and the National Environment Service. He hasn't been tried yet, but this week he has been reinstated: The seven-month ...
A ballot for three member's bills was held today, and the following bills were drawn: Repeal of Good Friday and Easter Sunday as Restricted Trading Days (Shop Trading and Sale of Alcohol) Amendment Bill (Chris Baillie) Electoral (Strengthening Democracy) Amendment Bill (Golriz Ghahraman) Increased Penalties for ...
No Jesus Here.She rises, unrested, and stepsOnto the narrow balconyTo find the day. To greetThe Sunday God she sings to.But this morning His face is clouded.Grey and wet as a corpseWashed by tears.Behind her, in the tangled bedding,the children bicker and whine.Worrying the cheap furnitureLike hungry puppies.They clutch at her ...
After two years of Corona-induced online meetings in 2020 and 2021, this year's General Assembly of the European Geosciences Union (EGU) will take place as a hybrid conference in both Vienna and online from May 23 to 27. To take hybrid and necessary hygiene restrictions into account, there (unfortunately) will be no ...
“Māori star lore was, and still remains, a blending together of both astronomy and astrology, and while there is undoubtedly robust science within the Māori study of the night sky, the spiritual component has always been of equal importance” writes Professor Rangi Matamua in his book Matariki – Te whetū tapu ...
The foibles of the Aussie electoral system are pretty well-known. The Lucky Country doesn’t have proportional representation. Voting for everyone over 18 is compulsory, but within a preferential system. This means that in the relatively few key seats that decide the final result, it can be the voters’ second, third ...
Julia Steinberger is an ecological economist at the University of Lausanne in Switzerland. She first posted this piece at Medium.com, and it was reposted on Yale Climate Connections with her permission. Today I went to give a climate talk at my old high school in Geneva – and was given a ...
A/Prof Ben Gray* Gray B. Government funding of interpreters in Primary Care is needed to ensure quality care. Public Health Expert Blog.17 May 2022. The pandemic has highlighted many problems in the NZ health system. This blog will address the question of availability of interpreters for people with limited English ...
I have suggested previously that sometimes Tolkien’s writer-instincts get the better of him. Sometimes he departs from his own cherished metaphysics, in favour of the demands of story – and I dare say, that is a good thing. Laws and Customs of the Eldar might be an interesting insight ...
One of the key planks of yesterday's Emissions Reduction Plan is a $650 million fund to help decarbonise industry by subsidising replacement of dirty technologies with clean ones. But National leader Chris Luxon derides this as "corporate welfare". Which probably sounds great to the business ideologues in the Koru club. ...
Poisonous! From a very early age New Zealanders are warned to give small black spiders with a red blotch on their abdomens a wide berth. The Katipo, we are told, is venomous: and while its bite may not kill you, it can make you very unwell. That said, isn’t the ...
“The truth prevails, but it’s a chore.” – Jan Masaryk: The intensification of ideological pressures is bearable for only so-long before ordinary men and women reassert the virtues of tolerance and common sense.ON 10 MARCH 1948, Jan Masaryk, the Foreign Minister of Czechoslovakia, was found dead below his bathroom window. ...
Clearly, the attempt to take the politics out of climate change has itself been a political decision, and one meant to remove much of the heat from the global warming issue before next year’s election. What we got from yesterday’s $2.9 billion Emissions Reduction Plan was a largely aspirational multi-party ...
Michelle Uriarau (Mana Wāhine Kōrero) talks to Dane Giraud of the Free Speech Union LISTEN HERE Michelle Uriarau is a founding member of Mana Wāhine Kōrero – an advocacy group of and for Māori women who took strong positions against the ‘Self ID’ and ‘Conversion Practises Bills’. One of the ...
If we needed any confirmation, we have it in spades in today’s edition of the Herald; our supposedly leading daily newspaper is determined to do what it can to decide the outcome of the next election – to act, that is, not as a newspaper but as the mouthpiece for ...
Sean Plunkett, founding editor of the new media outlet, The Platform, was interviewed on RNZ's highly regarded flagship programme "Mediawatch".Mr Plunkett has made much about "cancel culture" and "de-platforming". On his website promoting The Platform, he outlines his mission statement thusly:The Platform is for everyone; we’re not into cancelling or ...
“That’s a C- for History, Kelvin!”While it is certainly understandable that Māori-Crown Relations Minister Kelvin Davis was not anxious to castigate every Pakeha member of the House of Representatives for the crimes committed against his people by their ancestors; crimes from which his Labour colleagues continue to draw enormous benefits; the ...
The Government promised a major reform of New Zealand’s immigration system, but when it was announced this week, many asked “is that it?” Over the last two years Covid has turned the immigration tap off, and the Government argued this produced the perfect opportunity to reassess decades of “unbalanced immigration”. ...
While the new fiscal rules may not be contentious, what they mean for macroeconomic management is not explained.In a pre-budget speech on 3 May 2022, the Minister of Finance, Grant Robertson, made some policy announcements which will frame both this budget and future ones. (The Treasury advice underpinning them is ...
Under MMP, Parliament was meant to look like New Zealand. And, in a lot of ways, it does now, with better representation for Māori, tangata moana, women, and the rainbow community replacing the old dictatorship of dead white males. But there's one area where "our" parliament remains completely unrepresentative: housing: ...
Justice Denied: At the heart of the “Pro-Life” cause was something much darker than conservative religious dogma, or even the oppressive designs of “The Patriarchy”. The enduring motivation – which dares not declare itself openly – is the paranoid conviction of male white supremacists that if “their” women are given ...
In case of emergency break glass— but glass can cut Fire extinguishers, safety belts, first aid kits, insurance policies, geoengineering: we never enjoy using them. But given our demonstrated, deep empirical record of proclivity for creating hazards and risk we'd obviously be foolish not to include emergency responses in our inventory. ...
After a brief hiatus, the “A View from Afar” podcast is back on air with Selwyn Manning leading the Q&A with me. This week is a grab bag of topics: Russian V-Day celebrations, Asian and European elections, and the impact of the PRC-Solomon Islands on the regional strategic balance. Plus ...
Last year, Vanuatu passed a "cyber-libel" law. And predictably, its first targets are those trying to hold the government to account: A police crackdown in Vanuatu that has seen people arrested for allegedly posting comments on social media speculating politicians were responsible for the country’s current Covid outbreak has ...
Could it be a case of not appreciating what you’ve got until it’s gone? The National Party lost Simon Bridges last week, which has reinforced the notion that the party still has some serious deficits of talent and diversity. The major factor in Bridges’ decision to leave was his failed ...
Who’s Missing From This Picture? The re-birth of the co-governance concept cannot be attributed to the institutions of Pakeha rule, at least, not in the sense that the massive constitutional revisions it entails have been presented to and endorsed by the House of Representatives, and then ratified by the citizens of New ...
Fiji signed onto China’s Belt and Road initiative in 2018, along with a separate agreement on economic co-operation and aid. Yet it took the recent security deal between China and the Solomon Islands to get the belated attention of the US and its helpmates in Canberra and Wellington, and the ...
This is a re-post from Yale Climate Connections by Lexi Smith and Bud Ward “CRA” It’s one of those acronyms even many-a-veteran environmental policy geek may not recognize. Amidst the scores and scores of acronyms in the field – CERCLA, IPCC, SARA, LUST, NPDES, NDCs, FIFRA, NEPA and scores more – ...
In a nice bit of news in a World Gone Mad, I can report that Of Tin and Tintagel, my 5,800-word story about tin (and political scheming), is now out as part of the Spring 2022 edition of New Maps Magazine (https://www.new-maps.com/). As noted previously, this one owes a ...
Dr Jennifer Summers, Professor Michael Baker, Professor Nick Wilson* Summers J, Baker M, Wilson N. Covid-19 Case-Fatality Risk & Infection-Fatality Risk: important measures to help guide the pandemic response. Public Health Expert Blog. 11 May 2022. In this blog we explore two useful mortality indicators: Case-Fatality Risk (CFR) and Infection-Fatality ...
In the depths of winter, most people from southern New Zealand head to warmer climes for a much-needed dose of Vitamin D. Yet during the height of the last Ice Age, one species of moa did just the opposite. I’m reminded of Bill Bailey’s En Route to Normal tour that visited ...
In the lead-up to the Budget, the Government has been on an offensive to promote the efficiency and quality of its $74 billion Covid Response and Recovery Fund -especially the Wage Subsidy Scheme component. This comes after criticisms and concerns from across the political spectrum over poor-quality spending, and suggestions ...
Elizabeth Elliot Noe, Lincoln University, New Zealand; Andrew D. Barnes, University of Waikato; Bruce Clarkson, University of Waikato, and John Innes, Manaaki Whenua – Landcare ResearchUrbanisation, and the destruction of habitat it entails, is a major threat to native bird populations. But as our new research shows, restored ...
Unfinished: Always, gnawing away at this government’s confidence and empathy, is the dictum that seriously challenging the economic and social status-quo is the surest route to electoral death. Labour’s colouring-in book, and National’s, have to look the same. All that matters is which party is better at staying inside the lines.DOES ...
Radical As: Māori healers recall a time when “words had power”. The words that give substance to ideas, no matter how radical, still do. If our representatives rediscover the courage to speak them out loud.THERE ARE RULES for radicalism. Or, at least, there are rules for the presentation of radical ...
This is a re-post from Yale Climate Connections by Jeff Masters A brutal, record-intensity heat wave that has engulfed much of India and Pakistan since March eased somewhat this week, but is poised to roar back in the coming week with inferno-like temperatures of up to 50 degrees Celsius (122°F). The ...
The good people at the Reading Tolkien podcast have put out a new piece, which spends some time comparing the underlying moral positions of George R.R. Martin and J.R.R. Tolkien: (The relevant discussion starts about twenty-seven minutes in. It’s a long podcast). In the interests of fairness, ...
Crime is becoming a key debate between Labour and National. This week they are both keen to show that they are tough on law and order. It’s an issue that National has a traditional advantage on, and is one that they’re currently getting good traction from. In response, Labour is ...
So far, the excited media response to the spike in “ram-raid” incidents is being countered by evidence that in reality, youth crime is steeply in decline, and has been so for much of the past decade. Who knew? Perhaps that’s the real issue here. Why on earth wasn’t the latest ...
The Green Party of Aotearoa New Zealand is welcoming the Government’s latest step toward electoral reform, which begins to fulfil an important part of the Co-operation Agreement between the two parties. ...
CHECK AGAINST DELIVERY Mr Speaker, It has taken four-and-a-half years to even start to turn the legacy of inaction and neglect from the last time they were in Government together. And we have a long journey in front of us! ...
Today Greens Te Mātāwaka Chair and Health Spokesperson, Dr Elizabeth Kerekere, said “The Greens have long campaigned for an independent Māori Health Authority and pathways for Takatāpui and Rainbow healthcare. “We welcome the substantial funding going into the new health system, Pae Ora, particularly for the Māori Health Authority, Iwi-Partnership ...
Budget 2022 shows progress on conservation commitments in the Green Party’s cooperation agreement Green Party achievements in the last Government continue to drive investment in nature protection Urgent action needed on nature-based solutions to climate change Future budget decisions must reflect the role nature plays in helping reduce emissions ...
Landmark week for climate action concludes with climate budget Largest ever investment in climate action one of many Green Party wins throughout Budget 2022 Budget 2022 delivers progress on every part of the cooperation agreement with Labour Budget 2022 is a climate budget that caps a landmark week ...
Green Party welcomes extension to half price fares Permanent half price fares for Community Services Card holders includes many students, which helps implement a Green Party policy Work to reduce public transport fares for Community Services Card holders started by Greens in the last Government Budget 2022 should be ...
New cost of living payment closely aligned to Green Party policy to expand the Winter Energy Payment Extension and improvement of Warmer Kiwi Homes builds on Green Party progress in Government Community energy fund welcomed The Green Party welcomes the investment in Budget 2022 to expand Warmer Kiwi ...
Budget 2022 support to reduce homelessness delivers on the Green Party’s cooperation agreement Bespoke support for rangatahi with higher, more complex needs The Green Party welcomes the additional investment in Budget 2022 for kaupapa Māori support services, homelessness outreach services, the expansion of transitional housing, and a new ...
Green Party reaffirms call for liveable incomes and wealth tax Calls on Government to cancel debt owed to MSD for hardship assistance such as benefit advances, and for over-payments The Green Party welcomes the support for people on low incomes Budget 2022 but says more must be done ...
Our Government has just released this year’s Budget, which sets out the next steps in our plan to build a high wage, low carbon economy that gives economic security in good times and in bad. It’s full of initiatives that speed up our economic recovery and ease cost pressures for ...
A stronger democracy is on the horizon, as Golriz Ghahraman’s Electoral (Strengthening Democracy) Amendment Bill was pulled from the biscuit tin today. ...
Tomorrow, the Government will release this year’s Budget, setting out the next steps in our plan to build a high wage, low carbon economy that gives economic security in good times and in bad. While the full details will be kept under wraps until Thursday afternoon, we’ve announced a few ...
As a Government, we made it clear to New Zealanders that we’d take meaningful action on climate change, and that’s exactly what we’ve done. Earlier today, we released our next steps with our Emissions Reduction Plan – which will meet the Climate Commission’s independent science-based emissions reduction targets, and new ...
Emissions Reduction Plan prepares New Zealand for the future, ensuring country is on track to meet first emissions budget, securing jobs, and unlocking new investment ...
The Greens are calling for the Government to reconsider the immigration reset so that it better reflects our relationship with our Pacific neighbours. ...
Hamilton City Council and Whanganui District Council have both joined a growing list of Local Authorities to pass a motion in support of Green Party Drug Reform Spokesperson Chlöe Swarbrick’s Members’ bill to minimise alcohol harm. ...
Today, Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern announced a major package of reforms to address the immediate skill shortages in New Zealand and speed up our economic growth. These include an early reopening to the world, a major milestone for international education, and a simplification of immigration settings to ensure New Zealand ...
Proposed immigration changes by the Government fail to guarantee pathways to residency to workers in the types of jobs deemed essential throughout the pandemic, by prioritising high income earners - instead of focusing on the wellbeing of workers and enabling migrants to put down roots. ...
Ehara taku toa i te toa takatahi, engari taku toa he toa takimano – my strength is not mine alone but the strength of many (working together to ensure safe, caring respectful responses). We are striving for change. We want all people in Aotearoa New Zealand thriving; their wellbeing enhanced ...
The Green Party is throwing its support behind the 10,000 allied health workers taking work-to-rule industrial action today because of unfair pay and working conditions. ...
Since the day we came into Government, we’ve worked hard to lift wages and reduce cost pressures facing New Zealanders. But we know the rising cost of living, driven by worldwide inflation and the war in Ukraine, is making things particularly tough right now. That’s why we’ve stepped up our ...
Education Minister Chris Hipkins and Associate Education Minister Kelvin Davis have welcomed the release of a paper from independent advisory group, Taumata Aronui, outlining the group’s vision for Māori success in the tertiary education system. “Manu Kōkiri – Māori Success and Tertiary Education: Towards a Comprehensive Vision – is the ...
The best way to have economic security in New Zealand is by investing in wāhine and our rangatahi says Minister for Māori Development. Budget 2022, is allocating $28.5 million over the next two years to strengthen whānau resilience through developing leadership within key cohorts of whānau leaders, wāhine and rangatahi ...
Whānau Ora Commissioning Agencies will receive $166.5 million over four years to help whānau maintain and build their resilience as Aotearoa moves forward from COVID-19, Minister for Whānau Ora Peeni Henare announced today. “Whānau Ora Commissioning Agencies and partners will remain a key feature of the Government’s support for whānau ...
The development of sustainable, plant-based foods and meat alternatives is getting new government backing, with investment from a dedicated regional economic development fund. “The investment in Sustainable Foods Ltd is part of a wider government strategy to develop a low-emissions, highly-skilled economy that responds to global demands,” said Stuart Nash. ...
With New Zealand expecting to see Omicron cases rise during the winter, the Orange setting remains appropriate for managing this stage of the outbreak, COVID-19 Response Minister Chris Hipkins said today. “While daily cases numbers have flattened nationally, they are again beginning to increase in the Northern region and hospitalisation ...
Justice Minister Kris Faafoi today announced appointments to the independent panel that will lead a review of New Zealand’s electoral law. “This panel, appointed by an independent panel of experts, aim to make election rules clearer and fairer, to build more trust in the system and better support people to ...
Honourable Dame Fran Wilde will lead the board overseeing the design and construction of Auckland’s largest, most transformational project of a generation – Auckland Light Rail, which will connect hundreds of thousands of people across the city, Minister of Transport Michael Wood announced today. “Auckland Light Rail is New Zealand’s ...
Boost to Māori Medium property that will improve and redevelop kura, purchase land and build new facilities Scholarships and mentoring to grow and expand the Māori teaching workforce Funding to continue to grow the Māori language The Government’s commitment to the growth and development of te reo Māori has ...
On the eve of Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern’s trade mission to the United States, New Zealand has joined with partner governments from across the Indo-Pacific region to begin the next phase of discussions towards an Indo-Pacific Economic Framework for Prosperity (IPEF). The Framework, initially proposed by US President Biden in ...
As part of New Zealand’s ongoing response to the war in Ukraine, New Zealand is providing further support and personnel to assist Ukraine to defend itself against Russia’s unprovoked and illegal invasion, Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern announced today. “We have been clear throughout Russia’s assault on Ukraine, that such a ...
Budget 2022 is providing investment to crackdown on tobacco smuggling into New Zealand. “Customs has seen a significant increase in the smuggling of tobacco products into New Zealand over recent years,” Minister of Customs Meka Whaitiri says. This trend is also showing that tobacco smuggling operations are now often very ...
Prime Minister to lead trade mission to the United States this week to support export growth and the return of tourists post COVID-19. Business delegation to promote trade and tourism opportunities in New Zealand’s third largest export and visitor market Deliver Harvard University commencement address Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern ...
Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern has congratulated Anthony Albanese and the Australian Labor Party on winning the Australian Federal election, and has acknowledged outgoing Prime Minister Scott Morrison. "I spoke to Anthony Albanese early this morning as he was preparing to address his supporters. It was a warm conversation and I’m ...
Tiwhatiwha te pō, tiwhatiwha te ao. Tiwhatiwha te pō, tiwhatiwha te ao. Matariki Tapuapua, He roimata ua, he roimata tangata. He roimata e wairurutu nei, e wairurutu nei. Te Māreikura mārohirohi o Ihoa o ngā Mano, takoto Te ringa mākohakoha o Rongo, takoto. Te mātauranga o Tūāhuriri o Ngai Tahu ...
Three core networks within the tourism sector are receiving new investment to gear up for the return of international tourists and business travellers, as the country fully reconnects to the world. “Our wider tourism sector is on the way to recovery. As visitor numbers scale up, our established tourism networks ...
The Minister of Customs has welcomed legislation being passed which will prevent millions of dollars in potential tax evasion on water-pipe tobacco products. The Customs and Excise (Tobacco Products) Amendment Act 2022 changes the way excise and excise-equivalent duty is calculated on these tobacco products. Water-pipe tobacco is also known ...
The Government is contributing $100,000 to a Mayoral Relief Fund to help the Levin community following this morning’s tornado, Minister for Emergency Management Kiri Allan says. “My thoughts are with everyone who has been impacted by severe weather events in Levin and across the country. “I know the tornado has ...
The Quintet of Attorneys General have issued the following statement of support for the Prosecutor General of Ukraine and investigations and prosecutions for crimes committed during the Russian invasion of Ukraine: “The Attorneys General of the United Kingdom, the United States of America, Australia, Canada, and New Zealand join in ...
Morena tatou katoa. Kua tae mai i runga i te kaupapa o te rā. Thank you all for being here today. Yesterday my colleague, the Minister of Finance Grant Robertson, delivered the Wellbeing Budget 2022 – for a secure future for New Zealand. I’m the Minister of Health, and this was ...
Urgent Budget night legislation to stop major supermarkets blocking competitors from accessing land for new stores has been introduced today, Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs Dr David Clark said. The Commerce (Grocery Sector Covenants) Amendment Bill amends the Commerce Act 1986, banning restrictive covenants on land, and exclusive covenants ...
It is a pleasure to speak to this Budget. The 5th we have had the privilege of delivering, and in no less extraordinary circumstances. Mr Speaker, the business and cycle of Government is, in some ways, no different to life itself. Navigating difficult times, while also making necessary progress. Dealing ...
Budget 2022 provides funding to implement the new resource management system, building on progress made since the reform was announced just over a year ago. The inadequate funding for the implementation of the Resource Management Act in 1992 almost guaranteed its failure. There was a lack of national direction about ...
The Government is substantially increasing the amount of funding for public media to ensure New Zealanders can continue to access quality local content and trusted news. “Our decision to create a new independent and future-focused public media entity is about achieving this objective, and we will support it with a ...
$662.5 million to maintain existing defence capabilities NZDF lower-paid staff will receive a salary increase to help meet cost-of living pressures. Budget 2022 sees significant resources made available for the Defence Force to maintain existing defence capabilities as it looks to the future delivery of these new investments. “Since ...
More than $185 million to help build a resilient cultural sector as it continues to adapt to the challenges coming out of COVID-19. Support cultural sector agencies to continue to offer their important services to New Zealanders. Strengthen support for Māori arts, culture and heritage. The Government is investing in a ...
It is my great pleasure to present New Zealand’s fourth Wellbeing Budget. In each of this Government’s three previous Wellbeing Budgets we have not only considered the performance of our economy and finances, but also the wellbeing of our people, the health of our environment and the strength of our communities. In Budget ...
It is my great pleasure to present New Zealand’s fourth Wellbeing Budget. In each of this Government’s three previous Wellbeing Budgets we have not only considered the performance of our economy and finances, but also the wellbeing of our people, the health of our environment and the strength of our communities. In Budget ...
Four new permanent Coroners to be appointed Seven Coronial Registrar roles and four Clinical Advisor roles are planned to ease workload pressures Budget 2022 delivers a package of investment to improve the coronial system and reduce delays for grieving families and whānau. “Operating funding of $28.5 million over four ...
Establishment of Ministry for Disabled People Progressing the rollout of the Enabling Good Lives approach to Disability Support Services to provide self-determination for disabled people Extra funding for disability support services “Budget 2022 demonstrates the Government’s commitment to deliver change for the disability community with the establishment of a ...
Fairer Equity Funding system to replace school deciles The largest step yet towards Pay Parity in early learning Local support for schools to improve teaching and learning A unified funding system to underpin the Reform of Vocational Education Boost for schools and early learning centres to help with cost ...
$118.4 million for advisory services to support farmers, foresters, growers and whenua Māori owners to accelerate sustainable land use changes and lift productivity $40 million to help transformation in the forestry, wood processing, food and beverage and fisheries sectors $31.6 million to help maintain and lift animal welfare practices across Aotearoa New Zealand A total food and ...
House price caps for First Home Grants increased in many parts of the country House price caps for First Home Loans removed entirely Kāinga Whenua Loan cap will also be increased from $200,000 to $500,000 The Affordable Housing Fund to initially provide support for not-for-profit rental providers Significant additional ...
Child Support rules to be reformed lifting an estimated 6,000 to 14,000 children out of poverty Support for immediate and essential dental care lifted from $300 to $1,000 per year Increased income levels for hardship assistance to extend eligibility Budget 2022 takes further action to reduce child poverty and ...
More support for RNA research through to pilot manufacturing RNA technology platform to be created to facilitate engagement between research and industry partners Researchers and businesses working in the rapidly developing field of RNA technology will benefit from a new research and development platform, funded in Budget 2022. “RNA ...
A new Business Growth Fund to support small and medium sized enterprises (SMEs) to grow Fully funding the Regional Strategic Partnership Fund to unleash regional economic development opportunities Tourism Innovation Programme to promote sustainable recovery Eight Industry Transformation Plans progressed to work with industries, workers and iwi to transition ...
Budget 2022 further strengthens the economic foundations and wellbeing outcomes for Pacific peoples in Aotearoa, as the recovery from COVID-19 continues. “The priorities we set for Budget 2022 will support the continued delivery of our commitments for Pacific peoples through the Pacific Wellbeing Strategy, a 2020 manifesto commitment for Pacific ...
Boost for Māori economic and employment initiatives. More funding for Māori health and wellbeing initiatives Further support towards growing language, culture and identity initiatives to deliver on our commitment to Te Reo Māori in Education Funding for natural environment and climate change initiatives to help farmers, growers and whenua ...
New hospital funding for Whangārei, Nelson and Hillmorton 280 more classrooms over 40 schools, and money for new kura $349 million for more rolling stock and rail network investment The completion of feasibility studies for a Northland dry dock and a new port in the Manukau Harbour Increased infrastructure ...
$168 million to the Māori Health Authority for direct commissioning of services $20.1 million to support Iwi-Māori Partnership Boards $30 million to support Māori primary and community care providers $39 million for Māori health workforce development Budget 2022 invests in resetting our health system and gives economic security in ...
Biggest-ever increase to Pharmac’s medicines budget Provision for 61 new emergency vehicles including 48 ambulances, along with 248 more paramedics and other frontline staff New emergency helicopter and crew, and replacement of some older choppers $100 million investment in specialist mental health and addiction services 195,000 primary and intermediate aged ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Christian Moro, Associate Professor of Science & Medicine, Bond University Shutterstock You showered this morning, are wearing fresh clothes and having an otherwise normal day, when suddenly you notice that stench. Why do our armpits smell, and why more ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Lucinda McKnight, Senior Lecturer in Pedagogy and Curriculum, Deakin University Pixabay The war in Ukraine is being described as the first social media war, even as “the TikTok war”. Memes, tweets, videos and blog posts communicate both vital information and ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Andrew Stewart, John Bray Professor of Law, University of Adelaide Industrial relations issues were front and centre when federal Labor last won office from opposition in 2007. The backlash against John Howard’s “Work Choices” reforms cost both his government and his own ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Tim Soutphommasane, Acting Director, Sydney Policy Lab & Professor of Practice (Sociology and Political Theory), University of Sydney The message from Saturday’s election result was clear: Australians want a political reset. And not just about issues such as government integrity and climate ...
The Education and Workforce Committee is calling for submissions on the Employment Relations (Extended Time for Personal Grievance for Sexual Harassment) Amendment Bill. This bill would extend the period of time available to raise a personal grievance ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Kelly Menzel, Assistant Professor – First Nations Health, Bond University GettyImages Workplaces can be hostile, overwhelming and unwelcoming places for many First Nations Peoples. My research has explored how this is the case in many organisations, including universities. White organisations ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Peter Breadon, Program Director, Health and Aged Care, Grattan Institute CDC/Unsplash Anthony Albanese campaigned on better pandemic management. Giving the vaccination program a shot in the arm will be his first test. Not long ago, every shipment of vaccines was ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Simon Kingham, Professor, University of Canterbury Shutterstock/Tanya NZ The Dutch have long been recognised as leaders in cycling. Denmark is not far behind, with more bikes than cars in its capital Copenhagen. This is the result of many years of ...
Remaining in the orange traffic light setting is not a constraint or handbrake to accelerating business recovery, rebuilding, and planning for growth, says Auckland Business Chamber CEO Michael Barnett. “Businesses can do everything under Orange, ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Peter Breadon, Program Director, Health and Aged Care, Grattan Institute CDC/Unsplash Anthony Albanese campaigned on better pandemic management. Giving the vaccination program a shot in the arm will be his first test. Not long ago, every shipment of vaccines was ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Jen Purdie, Senior Research Fellow, University of Otago Getty Images If your next car is not electric, then it must be much smaller than your last one. Scientists have warned that the world needs to halve emissions every decade to ...
Not many New Zealanders may have noticed what is happening in China or India – but their economies appear to be tracking in opposite directions. Those movements could have a powerful impact in turn on NZ’s economic fortunes. Point of Order is indebted to two remarkable pieces of journalism for ...
Northland District Commander Superintendent Tony Hill: Police agree with the findings of an IPCA report, which concluded a Police officer was justified in using force against a man during an arrest in Northland. On 27 May 2021, Police were witness ...
Napier man, Alister Robertson, says the lack of any proper funding in the Budget for the proposed Dementia Mate Wareware Action Plan is really disappointing and concerning. “This Budget announcement is very underwhelming. It’s hardly a wellbeing Budget ...
Tauranga City Council’s commissioners have resolved to write directly to Government Ministers to detail their concerns that a lack of alignment between agencies and legislation is impacting the planning and funding of urban development in New Zealand’s ...
The Office for Seniors has released a new guide that will help inform the best urban design practices to benefit older people. The Age friendly urban places guide is a technical resource targeted at local and central government urban planning practice ...
RNZ Pacific A commemoration has been held in French Polynesia to mark the 20th anniversary of the disappearance of a leading opposition politician in the Tuamotus. Boris Léontieff, who headed the Fetia Api party, was among four politicians travelling in a small plane on a campaign trip when it disappeared ...
Feedback from our consultation on the rules governing policyholder security in our insurance legislation will help to shape the final policy. An important purpose of New Zealand’s insurance legislation is to promote a financially sound insurance ...
E tū/NZNO/PSA media release After rallying around Aotearoa for a better pay offer, care and support workers and their unions are delivering their messages to Parliament in a petition signed by thousands in just 10 days. They will hand over the petition, ...
“Jacinda Ardern’s visit comes immediately on the heels of Joe Biden’s trip to Japan for a meeting of the ‘Quad’ - the US, Australia, India and Japan - that intends to dramatically increase militarisation of the Pacific region. Ardern’s ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Sam Baron, Associate professor, Australian Catholic University ShutterstockI’m curious about what will happen if, hypothetically, someone moves with speed (that is) twice the speed of light? – Devanshi, age 13, Mumbai Hi Devanshi! Thanks for this ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Frank Bongiorno, Professor of History, ANU College of Arts and Social Sciences, Australian National University Wes Mountain/The Conversation, CC BY-ND Political commentators often use the idea of a political spectrum from left to right as shorthand for understanding political ideologies, ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Patricia A. O’Brien, Faculty Member, Asian Studies Program, Georgetown University; Visiting Fellow, Department of Pacific Affairs, Australian National University; Adjunct Fellow, Center for Strategic and International Studies, Washington DC., Georgetown University The federal election has delivered a monumental win for Australia’s relations ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Sarah Hellewell, Research Fellow, Faculty of Health Sciences, Curtin University, and The Perron Institute for Neurological and Translational Science, Curtin University Shutterstock Loss or alteration of taste (dysgeusia) is a common symptom of COVID. It’s also a side effect of ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By James Bell, Professor of Marine Biology, Te Herenga Waka — Victoria University of Wellington Despite New Zealanders’ close connection with the oceans, very few will have heard of “temperate mesophotic ecosystems” (TMEs). Even fewer will appreciate their importance for coastal fisheries, and ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Eleanor Cowan, Lecturer in Ancient History, University of Sydney Francesco Solimena, Death of Messalina (about 1704/1712)The GettyReaders are advised this story includes depictions of domestic violence and violence against women. Domestic violence was endemic in the Roman world. Rome ...
23 May US President Biden unveiled his long-awaited Indo-Pacific Economic Framework (IPEF) in Tokyo tonight, supported by a small group of allies, including New Zealand’s Prime Minister Arden by zoom. “The low-key event was overshadowed by the elephant ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Adrian Beaumont, Honorary Associate, School of Mathematics and Statistics, The University of Melbourne AAP/Lukas Coch With 73% of enrolled voters counted, the ABC is calling 73 of the 151 House of Representatives seats for Labor, 54 for the Coalition, 15 Others ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra The transition from one government to another involves a democratic miracle and a physical mess. In parliament house’s ministerial wing on Monday, shredding machines were working flat out, fragments of their massive output leaving ...
OP-ED by Armida Salsiah Alisjahbana, Armida Salsiah Alisjahbana is the United Nations Under-Secretary-General and Executive Secretary of the Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific.Armida Salsiah Alisjahbana is the United Nations Under-Secretary-General and Executive Secretary of the Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific (ESCAP). ...
Australia has a new political leader at the helm after nine years governed by conservatives but what does the change of hands mean for New Zealand? ...
RNZ Pacific A female candidate in the Papua New Guinea elections believes it is more important than ever that the country has women MPs in Parliament. Dulciana Somare-Brash is the daughter of the late Sir Michael Somare and she unsuccessfully stood in the East Sepik regional seat in 2017, finishing ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Stephen Garnett, Professor of Conservation and Sustainable Livelihoods, Charles Darwin University Gilbert’s potoroo, a marsupial that may be extinct in 20 years.Shutterstock It feels a bit strange to publish a paper that we want proved wrong – we have identified the ...
PNG Post-Courier “Powes! Powes! Powes!” The city of Port Moresby was ringing with chants of support for its governor for the past 15 years — Powes Parkop. Hundreds of men, women and children from the settlements to the suburbs flocked at the weekend in support of the three-term politician who ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Kim Beasy, Lecturer in Curriculum and Pedagogy, University of Tasmania You’d be forgiven for not having heard about the long-awaited new Australian Curriculum, which was released with little fanfare in the midst of the election campaign. But this update to the national ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Nancy Baxter, Professor and Head of Melbourne School of Population & Global Health, The University of Melbourne In a poll conducted by the Guardian in August of 2021 about the number of deaths Australians would be willing to accept as restrictions eased, ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By John Quiggin, Professor, School of Economics, The University of Queensland Shutterstock As the polls closed on Saturday night, most election commentary focused on the dispiriting campaign where both major parties avoided any substantial division on policy issues and instead focused on ...
The Environment Committee Komiti Taiao invites public submissions on Aotearoa New Zealand’s emissions budgets and the emissions reduction plan, Te Hau mārohi ki anamata Towards a productive, sustainable and inclusive economy—Aotearoa New Zealand’s ...
The announcement in Budget 2022 to build 300 affordable homes for Pasefika families in Porirua will be transformational, says the Central Pacific Collective (CPC). The homes will be built over 10 years through “Our Whare Our Fale” – ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Jarryd Bartle, Sessional Lecturer, RMIT University Shutterstock One of the surprising results from the federal election was a record vote for Legalise Cannabis Australia, a minor party previously known as the Help End Marijuana Prohibition (HEMP) party. The party ...
Stuff business writer John Anthony was still focused on businessman Simon Henry’s widely reported remarks about My Food Bag co-founder Nadia Lim, a day after the company posted its latest annual results. His report on Saturday began with news that – according to its chief executive – My Food Bag’s ...
The Bus and Coach Association welcomes the recent budget announcement by the Labour Government to invest $61 million over the next four years towards ensuring a sustainable, skilled workforce of bus drivers nationwide. “This is great news” says CEO Ben ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Rebecca Strating, Director, La Trobe Asia and Associate Professor, La Trobe University, La Trobe University During the election campaign, Anthony Albanese singled out Indonesia as a key regional partner. The new prime minister made a point of declaring he intended his first ...
New Zealand’s export industries are looking to a new era in the wake of life returning to something like normal in international markets. The Prime Minister, Jacinda Ardern, will head a mission to the US to promote trade and tourism opportunities in our third largest export and visitor market, saying this ...
Budget 2022’s multi-million dollar spend on “service recognition” awards exemplifies the growing fiscal indulgence of the public sector, says the New Zealand Taxpayers’ Union . The Budget’s Summary of Initiatives reveals the Department of Prime Minister ...
Thank you for your invitation to close this semester for your class. There was a time when foreign policy was nonpolitical and when politicians held the view, that offshore, we would face the world as one people. Sadly, that is not the case today ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Sally Casswell, Professor of public health policy, Massey University Getty Images The World Health Organization’s newly released report on regulating cross-border alcohol marketing raises the alarm for countries like Australia and New Zealand, given their light touch towards alcohol advertising. ...
The country’s international relationships have loomed large in Beehive announcements since Friday. One press statement – from the PM – congratulated Anthony Albanese and the Australian Labor Party on winning the Australian Federal election. Jacinda Ardern said: “Australia is our most important partner, our only official ally and single economic ...
RNZ News A New Caledonian anti-independence candidate has withdrawn from the race for a seat in the French National Assembly just hours before nominations closed. Vaea Frogier pulled out, citing concern about the splits in the anti-independence camp. Seventeen candidates in New Caledonia are standing in next month’s election, with ...
Right to Life requests that Christopher Luxon becomes the truly pro-life leader that National and our nation desperately needs, by seeking the repeal of the Abortion Legislation Act 2019 and legislating for the recognition of the humanity of unborn ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Shaun Carney, Vice-Chancellor’s professorial fellow, Monash University Elections are a test – the ultimate test, really – of those who serve as parliamentarians and those who aspire to serve. Scott Morrison asserted quite absurdly early in the 2022 campaign that the election ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Mark Kenny, Professor, Australian Studies Institute, Australian National University AAP/James Ross It is pretty human to crave the approval of peers and to hope for more of the same, even if unconsciously. But for political parties selling themselves as unifying ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Greg Barton, Chair in Global Islamic Politics, Alfred Deakin Institute for Citizenship and Globalisation, Deakin University Lukas Coch/AAP Extreme weather events are the new normal. The use of nuclear weapons by Vladimir Putin’s Russian military is now an unthinkable possibility. And ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Catharine Coleborne, Dean of Arts/Head of School Humanities, Creative Industries and Social Sciences, University of Newcastle Higher education did not figure prominently in the election campaign. The biggest issues facing the sector, in particular the arts, humanities and social sciences, could never ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Saul Eslake, Vice-Chancellor’s Fellow, University of Tasmania Shutterstock Labor has inherited an economy with a pretty full “head of steam”. Domestic demand is growing strongly, fuelled by households flush with cash (and enriched by big increases in ...
The election of left-leaning Labor across the ditch may mean a change for several pressing issues in New Zealand's relationship with its closest neighbour. ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By John Phillimore, Executive Director, John Curtin Institute of Public Policy, Curtin University Western Australia’s promise to be the kingmaker on federal election night has finally been delivered. During the count, the rest of the country saw a slow but steady accumulation ...
RNZ News Joe Hawke — the prominent kaumātua and activist who led the long-running Takaparawhau occupation at Auckland’s Bastion Point in the late 1970s — has died, aged 82. Born in Tāmaki Makaurau in 1940, Joseph Parata Hohepa Hawke of Ngāti Whātua ki Ōrākei, led his people in their efforts ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Camilla Nelson, Associate Professor in Media, University of Notre Dame Australia Joel Carrett/AAP Women were everywhere and nowhere in the 2022 federal election. The message from the weekend’s vote was that the things that really matter to women and their ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Paul Williams, Associate Professor, Griffith University, Griffith University Darren England/AAP There’s an ancient observance in Chinese history that an earthquake is an ominous omen of coming political change. When the ground shakes it’s said the heavens are withdrawing an emperor’s ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Gregory Melleuish, Professor, School of Humanities and Social Inquiry, University of Wollongong original The most amazing thing about the election was the very low primary vote for the ALP and the Liberal Party. The Liberal Party has lost seats to ...
Someone in our public service is trying to undermine Labour – using the MIQ strategy.
Little hitlers in the bureaucracy again. Probably male, since the victim of their arbitrary decision-making is female. Defenders of the patriarchy.
Make it up as you go along. The ideal way to govern! Bureaucrats really get off on having total control. The one controlling the outcome for Charlotte is obviously in the running for a lifetime achievement award.
But David, having no brains is how you get recruited into the public service in the first place. Perpetuating neocolonialism requires obedient automatons.
Will a minister take charge of the situation? Unlikely. For any Labour minister to spot subversion in the first place would be a miracle, and then brainwashing them to make them feel impotent is part of the culture of governance. Any natural problem-solver would get marginalised real fast. So I reckon the apparatchik will get the lifetime award for making Labour seem worse than the Taliban.
[here’s what Hipkins and the person running MiQ actually said. Putting this up in bold because we’re in a global crisis, this is a serious issue, and we should be looking at the whole picture. – weka]
Sorry, but why did Belgium not take them? Why is it incumbent upon NZ to take them, are we a soft touch now? My reading of it is that part of the delay concerned his application for a critical purpose visitor visa.
I admire Charlotte Bellis, she is s brave soul, but this is a 1 in 100 year pandemic. Pissing about in third world war zones in a pandemic is a very high risk thing to do, particularly when she was warned to get out before Kabul fell.
I'm glad it has been resolved.
Has it?? Haven't seen evidence in the media that it has. Meanwhile, there could be a pile-on starting…
Nothing new there. Wootton works for GB News and is constantly bashing left wing governments wherever he sees them.
Nothing new there. Wootton works for GB News and is constantly bashing left wing governments wherever he sees them.
Try to focus on the issue rather than the person. Otherwise, all those negative and personal comments about John Key could have been swept away with a big STFU. Serious issues don’t deserve a childish response.
Oh and left wing vs right wing went out in the 80s, didn’t it?
No it did not.
That was facile neo-liberal cant.
It would have, had neoliberalism delivered what its acolytes promised.
But it did not deliver, so we have a precipitous decline in home ownership and productivity, and meteoric rises in poverty and inequality.
Lying is evidently easier than sound economic policy.
Wootton was Murdoch's News of the World TV editor during the vile phone hacking shenanigans. Scum.
https://www.stuff.co.nz/business/5254072/News-of-the-Worlds-Kiwi-showbiz-editor-speaks-out
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/News_International_phone_hacking_scandal
Wootton was not the TV editor during the phone hackings. They took place before 2006 and he did not join the News of the World until 2007 and did not become the TV editor until November 2007.
Are you really going to hang a man for something he had nothing to do with?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dan_Wootton#:~:text=Wootton%20joined%20the%20News%20of,at%2Dlarge%20for%20Now%20magazine.
Of course all the fuckery was done and dusted when wee Danny took the reins.
/
NZ should get Charlotte Bellis back here asap and set her up to sort out the international problems relating to the Taliban on behalf of the Government. She appears to be able to communicate very effectively without having to resort to the bluster, bullshit and threats and has obviously had results from the moment the illegal combatants had their arses kicked out of Afghanistan.
Oh, must be dreaming – the US and its pathetic hangers on won't allow NZ to be an honest broker. They are obviously more intent on holding onto the billions in gold that belongs to Afghanistan and are quite happy to starve the inhabitants for propaganda purposes.
Because she is a NZ citizen, not a Belgian citizen. Do you want NZ taking Belgian citizens now?
But are a couple not equal partners? Not sure why her citizenship trumps his.
He was offered a Critical Purpose Visitor Visa for 6-12 months:
While the EU is similar offering the standard Schengen visa for 3 months in any 6, she'd used half of hers already.
It's all risky stuff, these foreign correspondent jobs.
Her situation' developed because she says she was told by some doctors ,she couldn't conceive.
She didn't seem to understand the travel within 14 days requiremen when she made her application.
The real culprits are these…doctors,maybe she should sue them.
Being pregnant is unscheduled according to the bureaucrat who issued the rejection. God scheduled the baby but any little hitler knows he is above God.
Eh? Was it not Jim and Charlotte who, "scheduled the baby"?
My take is that they put one & one together to make one, but it doesn't happen automatically. Some deity must authorise it first. Don't like God? Choose Gaia then.
" Probably male, since the victim of their arbitrary decision-making is female. Defenders of the patriarchy"
What a load of horseshit
zero evidence
just bias
horse
shit
you doubling down in your own shit?
Just trying to suss out why you feel a need to defend the indefensible…
Someone in our public service is trying to undermine Labour – using the MIQ strategy
The buck stops with the PM and this Government. Excuses don't wash.
And this isn't just about Bellis. As Stuff reported back in October 2021, one couple took the Government to court to get redress. The Government will have been well aware of the issue before Bellis' application:
But the very vulnerable Taika Waititi just made into MIQ for at least the second time. Woohoo!!
https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/health/coronavirus/300436891/miq-spot-granted-to-pregnant-couple-who-took-government-to-court
https://www.stuff.co.nz/entertainment/127636833/taika-waititi-back-in-nz-shares-glimpse-of-stay-in-miq
Movie Stars and Musicians have a higher ranking than International Journalists.
They have a completely separate system for emergency MiQ, for bloody obvious reasons. Obviously there are long standing problems with MiQ, but no need to make the debate stupider than it has to be.
Hmmm so Bellis made the mistake of applying for emergency MIQ rather than the run-of-the-mill MIQ. Let's be empathetic towards her because it was a rookie error.
No, she correctly applied for the emergency one and apparently didn't follow instructions.
You were the one making an unhelpful comparison between the two systems.
I see Darien Fenton has been kind to Bellis. Jacinda's meme is really working lol
https://www.newshub.co.nz/home/new-zealand/2022/01/covid-19-ex-labour-mp-darien-fenton-slammed-for-vile-tweet-about-pregnant-kiwi-reporter-denied-miq-spot.html
Oh please, won't someone feel for the
missingstranded white woman!ffs/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Missing_white_woman_syndrome
You've done well, Joe. Sexism and racism all in the one line. I'm good but not that good lol
Dopey fuck went there to further her career and when it looks like she might have fucked up and she has to join the queue, despite her immediate option of a safe third country, mutts like yourself swallow her special pleading. Idiots.
Another kind, caring comment just dripping with empathy. 🙂
I see she is nearly 6 months pregnant….did she recently find out?…and of pregnant women applying for spots,around 10% are ..successful.
Blaming bureaucrats and the Govt makes her appear very…entitled .
did you read her letter? She explains what happened.
I have read MSM reports about her situation…no first person 'letter'.
So now if someone offends another person's sensitivities, in relation to a third party who is not without resources, it is vile?
Actually, NZ should accommodate Ms Bellis immediately – she could teach the Minister of Foreign Affairs how to chart an independent diplomatic course. Someone needs to negotiate with the Taliban in good faith to save the millions of starving Afghanis that too many countries couldn't give a stuff about.
I've added the statements from the Minister and the head of MiQ to your comment.
Funny how the MIQ bunny thinks he can bamboozle everyone with lots of words. Dunno if it will work all that well as an evasion strategy.
Notice how he fails to explain why the 14 day window is necessary. I suppose we must wait to see if Charlotte is able to jump through this particular hoop but whoever created it lacks credibility. Wanker?
I was pretty disgusted you misrepresenting the situation so you can take a pop at civil servants. Which is why I added the note.
Yep, he could have taken twice as many words to explain something that is extraneous to solving Bellis' situation right now. Or he could have stayed focused on the issue at hand. MSM could of course now pick up the issue and explain to the public what is going on and why, instead of going off on one.
My guess, without looking too hard, is that they need some boundaries in the system. If they don't create that structurally, then it comes down to the staff person on the day. Is that really how you think MiQ should be run? Letting individual staff make decisions about who should be let in and who shouldn't?
No, I don't agree that some bureaucratic scumbag hiding behind anonymity ought to be allowed to get away with discriminating against women in traumatic situations instead of helping them. Simple! It's sickening.
You don't actually know that is what happened though. Looks like your antipathy towards bureaucratic scumbags is more important than the actual story.
Pattern recognition drives interpretation. I've seen so many similar instances since I first detected their behavioural pattern half a century back.
But I do agree we need more info & it's reasonable to give authorities time to get their act together. I'll try not to comment further for now!
Confirmation bias drives perception too.
The thing that interests me about the story is what the policy settings are that mean that Bellis' isn't the first pregnant woman to experience this.
Dennis you are pulling your own chain.
Dunno what you mean by that Patricia. Try another random guess??
Faux outrage Dennis.
But Charlotte's special.
/
yes, she is. Because she's pregnant in a country where giving birth or having a pregnancy complication might kill her or her baby. They should be letting anyone back in pronto in that situation.
No more so than any other pregnant, uninsured New Zealander who's had to cool their heels and wait in a third country.
I completely agree, they should all be getting high up the priority list. Bellis' yelling about it may change the policy for other pregnant women.
Not sure about you,but I find it hard to believe that Afghanistan was the only country in the world…she could travel..to.
I wondered that too at first, but what country do you think would give her a visa right now? And it's a pretty easy lie to get caught out in when going majorly public if it's not true.
bearing in mind she needs a country that will provide her with maternity care that she can afford.
Not sure what her choices could have been….but choosing Afghanistan makes a good story….shamelessly contrived imo.
how can it be contrived if she had nowhere else to go?
How do we know she had nowhere else to go?
My understanding was she didn't even have to leave Belgium.
Do you know when she discovered she was…pregnant?
She's due in May, so I'm guessing she conceived in the Spring.Nee
Citation needed. Needs to be a reliable link and a quote.
You have already confirmed that she had 6 months in Belgium and did not use it.
I am presuming you can apply for an M.I.Q spot in NZ from…Belgium…doesn't make such a heart string story though.
And she has been offered asylum in another country…
Kiwi journalist Charlotte Bellis offered asylum by another country, but no help yet from New Zealand | Stuff.co.nz
Where did I say that?
Your own link says,
I thought the lottery is closed currently. Without going through the emergency process she would have to wait until the end of February, assuming that NZ actually opens the borders to Kiwis at that time and doesn't have to delay further.
Lots of holes in her story.
She is a champion of womens rights,yet worked for Al Jazeera owned by according to her, an anti woman Qatar Govt.
It seems she had a Schengen visa which allows free travel to 26 member countries.
So she could have left Belgium and gone to any of 25 other countries-mostly first world.
She will not reveal the name of the country who is offering asylum…wonder why.
Btw my mistake(re you posting) the 180 day visa with 90 days to use is a bit confusing…whatever ,she could still apply from Belgium without political grandstanding.
'On the other hand, nationals of visa-exempt countries can remain in Belgium for up to 90 days, within a 180 day period. The time spent in other countries within the Schengen Area is also counted in this period.
Please make sure you understand the 90/180 Schengen Visa Rule. Do not violate this rule, not even for one day, since you may face consequences for overstaying in the Schengen territory.'
https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/covid-19-omicron-charlotte-bellis-an-open-letter-on-miq/U4WQGYTJHUP36AGVOBN3F6PJSE/
What is it about that risk assessment you don't understand?
If she was in Belgium, or wherever, how would she get back into NZ?
is the implication there that only people who don't champion women's rights should work for Al Jazeera?
' We wanted to keep time up our sleeves for an emergency, so decided to rebase.'
Is the situation she found herself in an…emergency?
'If she was in Belgium, or wherever, how would she get back into NZ?' -so why would going back to Afghanistan be any better?
'is the implication there that only people who don't champion women's rights should work for Al Jazeera?'
Not necessarily,but apparantly her regard for the Qatar govt is very flexible.
If a blatantly racist employer offered you a job,would you take it using the same logic?
'
how can it be contrived if she had nowhere else to go?
We know she could have gone to at least 25 other member countries on her existing visa.
I'm wondering how the partner feels…now he's about to be a dad,presuming she told him ,she can't get ..pregnant.
Yes she's a journo and knows how to get..attention=horrible creature AFAIC.
No, she's trying to pre-empt an emergency that could kill her or harm her baby. Think about it, if she stayed in Belgium (or wherever) she would have to leave in Feb before the NZ borders open. What happens if the borders don't open? Or she didn't get an emergency MiQ place?
How much do you know about pregnancy complications? Or flying in the third trimester?
Afaik the only other visa she had was for Afghanistan.
Well here I am writing on TS despite the sexism.
Sigh, we've already covered this.
Ok, making shit up now.
Why did she try to get married?
'Afaik the only other visa she had was for Afghanistan.'
Sigh, we've already covered this.'
Sigh..I don't think we have.
'Ok, making shit up now.'…what 'shit' would that be then?
She has stated she was told by doctors she could not conceive,it appears the pregnancy was a surprise!
I notice she has never bothered to admit her application re the 14 days was not valid.
where does she say that?
What other countries could she have gone to other than the EU ones we've already discussed?
'
'It is very important to be aware that it is illegal for an unmarried woman to be pregnant in Qatar. The consequences of the authorities discovering that a single woman is pregnant include jail and deportation, and even physical punishment (lashings) in some extreme circumstances.
For that reason, women who are not married and find themselves pregnant while living in Qatar should plan to head for home, or to another country. As a marriage certificate is required to have access to maternity care, even getting married after conception will not resolve the situation. Unmarried women who do leave Qatar due to becoming pregnant may also face problems if they return to Qatar after giving birth.
'Having a Baby in Qatar – Qatar – Angloinfo
It seems to me that the emotional reaction is foremost in people before the logical questions get asked. This is a woman who was in Afghanistan as a journalist and had contact as such with Taliban. Subsequently according to the Guardian of UK, she found herself pregnant when in Quatar. She left Al Jazeera and went to Belgium which is the country of the baby's father but there she has no entry rights and seemingly he isn't helping? From a safe place in Belgium because NZ was closed with Covid regulations, she decided to go back to Afghanistan with assurances from the Taliban? Is this really true or even possible and who in their right minds would choose to go back there when not even employed any more as a journalist and pregnant? Just to use speciall allocation rights for quick entry back home? Apparently the dates offered were not OK for her so she chose to delay. I can't believe following this that the immediate sinners are apparently the inhumane government services in NZ. What is wrong with logic and responsability today? The rest of the world looks at NZ with admiration and this story shows the lack of respect for rights of one young NZ lady. Amazing. So easy to criticize knowing little of the real facts and so easy to abuse the good countries with good systems.
MIQ needs to be dismantled immediately.
Very soon a few thousand Onicron cases coming across the border will be like pissing in the sea.
Our much bigger problem now is that our labour market is already struggling to keep up. And we have the big sick coming.
So we are going to desperately need kiwis to come home to help fill the gaps. For instance if quarter of our hospital staff are sick or isolating wouldn’t it be great to have doctors and nurses coming in from overseas. Or if supermarket shelves aren’t being stocked due to a lack of truck drivers, having some more coming across the border would be great.
MIQ has already lost any of its asset value and is now a major liability IMO.
Where are they all going to live? I suppose we could force Airbnb’ers, and amateur and absentee landlords to rent out their ghost houses.
That is the next problem. But not unsolvable.
The bigger problem will be the huge labour shortage running right through the economy.
Since I am talking about kiwis, a lot of those coming in will already have homes here, or family who could put them up as a short term fix anyway.
It’s useful for keeping out the hundreds of thousands of pissed off kiwi’s who won’t be able to not vote labour at the next election, as they’ve fallen foul of electoral qualification to vote in 2023
Kiwi nurses and doctors rushing back from overseas during our Omicron wave (February – March)? Mate, you're dreeeaming.
Once NZ's new case numbers top 500 per day (~10 per day in the region I live in), I'm planning to hunkering down so as not to trouble healthcare and supermarket workers. Omicron too shall pass.
“New Zealand PM in isolation after close contact with COVID-19 case”
https://www.cgtn.com/special/The-latest-on-the-COVID-19-pandemic.html
A lot of them have likely already had Omicron so won’t be bothered about our outbreak. Just glad to get home.
A lot of them also probably have some experience of what it's like to be a healthcare professional during an Omicron wave. I'm not expecting recent returnees to make a big dent in nurse/doctor shortages during our Omicron wave – just hoping that a few will stick around when the pandemic finally winds down.
hunkering down, this is the best strategy providing you can do this for 8 weeks.
Does an isolation period start from the time a person had close contact with a case, even if the case did not know they had Covid?
You appear to either not to understand how much protecting our health system is part of the current pandemic response, or you don't care. Arguing for opening the borders going into an omicron outbreak is basically throwing a whole bunch of more people under the bus.
It isn’t going to take very long before the benefit of keeping cases out will be far outweighed by the shortage of critically needed personnel that MIQ is causing.
Where do you think that tipping point is? Because waiting until we have reached the tipping point will be too late.
Do you agree that we will reach a tipping point where the benefit of keeping cases out will be outweighed by the critical labour shortages in areas including health?
If so do you think it is wise to wait until the tipping point is reached before we do anything about it?
I think bringing in workers with omicron will make that situation worse. The only way your suggestion makes sense if you believe that we should let omicron run free (or freeish). That's a completely different strategic approach, and again you haven't actually explained how that would work for the whole situation but instead have just taken one isolated aspect and suggested a quick fix.
We're heading into a crisis, potential a very serious one. There are no easy answers here, not matter how much we are tempted by the thought of silver bullets.
My own view is that we should all be being very careful right now. One thing people could do, that we were asked to do going into the first lockdown, is not take unnecessary risks with our physical health. I'm thinking about the number of A and E visits over the next month or two and how many could be avoided with people being more cautious for a period of time.
I think Omicron will soon be running free whatever we do.
Imagine a situation where we have 100000 people with Omicron, and all their close contacts are self isolating. Even if it were on five close contacts each that would mean 600000 isolating at once. So, it will quickly come to a point where isolation becomes counter-productive, and the focus will be on keeping as many people productive as possible.
So there will be some point in the fairly near future where the government has no option but to give up on restrictions because they will be counter-productive.
Removing the need for MIQ for returning kiwis doesn’t mean they can’t be self-isolating at home btw. At least then they will be available to help fill the many gaps that are soon going to appear.
you're conflating self-isolation with border control. You've avoided addressing the issue of letting people into NZ now with omicron (or delta for that matter) and how this would impact on the health system, health workers and all the flow on effects.
You've just said that self-isolation isn't going to work.
MIQ hasn't actually worked now, has it? Otherwise we wouldn't have Omicron in the community.
The prevalence of Omicron in the community will soon be so great that cases through the border will make very little difference to the overall impact.
And home isolation does away with the capacity restraints at MIQ.
I have only suggested home isolation as a solution for those who feel a bit squeamish. I don't think it will make a lot of difference in the end.
mod note for you below. Please attend to this before commenting further.
You patently don't understand (or care) why we have controlled borders, nor why imperfect is still bloody useful.
Sounds like you are ok if lots more people get sick, end up in hospital, get PTSD or burnout, die, get long covid, and so on.
Oh come on. You are completely exaggerating. How is a few extra cases coming across the border going to make a blind bit of difference when Omicron is already endemic in the community and spreading rapidly?
Sure, MIQ slowed down the inevitable. But here we are now. Where we stand now, MIQ might as well have not have existed so far as the current Omicron outbreak is concerned.
All it took was one case getting through.
@tsmithfield
It's hardly exaggeration. Getting rid of MIQ will almost certainly mean a lot more than "a few extra cases" coming across the border. And what about the next variant?
Once Omicron has gone through most of us will have good immunity against later variations of Covid, at least in terms of seriousness of disease.
We need to get to a point where we can live with Covid. MIQ is becoming unsustainable. We can't lock our own citizens out of their own country forever.
[citation needed for this claim of fact: “Once Omicron has gone through most of us will have good immunity against later variations of Covid, at least in terms of seriousness of disease.”
By citation I mean a reliable source, an explanation from your, some quotes, and a link. A link on its own is insufficient. If using video, there needs to be clear time stamps and explanation of who the people are as well – weka]
Fair enough. I thought it was fairly well established that previous Covid infections reduce the severity of future infections, so didn't bother with the cite.
But here is one from the monthly news letter from the National Institute of Health US.
https://newsinhealth.nih.gov/2021/04/antibodies-protect-against-covid-19-reinfection
please reread my mod note and provide proper citation.
Here is a quote from the link above that demonstrates that a previous Covid infection provides protection against future Covid infections:
"After having COVID-19, most people’s bodies develop antibodies to help fight it off. These are special molecules made by the body’s disease defense system, the immune system. A study found that people with these antibodies were less likely to get COVID-19 again."
This is very weak.
The article is nearly a year old.
The main issue I see is that it doesn't say how long the partial anti-body protection lasts. Probably because it was early research.
You claimed,
'good immunity' is incredibly imprecise. Your link doesn't support the assertion of seriousness of disease.
meanwhile, this piece from the Guardian last week shows a different picture. Still a lot to learn, and we don't know what it means for long covid or other long term damage.
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/jan/21/covid-reinfection-how-likely-are-you-to-catch-virus-multiple-times
It's entirely possible that what you hope for (the virus settles into a pattern of waves of less infectious and less harmful infections), but I see no evidence that we are close to that yet and still too many unknowns. Lynn has talked about a five year time frame.
You have to remember that we would be combining natural infection with high rates of vaccination. There is evidence that the combination of both can produce "super immunity".
From the link below:
"Scientists have claimed that a so-called "super-immunity" to Covid-19 can be achieved by people who have been infected by the virus after receiving the vaccine for the disease.
"In a new paper, Oregon Health and Science University (OHSU), experts say the same is also true for people who get infected before getting two jabs.
https://www.nzherald.co.nz/world/covid-19-omicron-outbreak-scientists-say-a-covid-infection-after-vaccination-triggers-super-immunity/MRTMRO73NMUUXNWVI6337NTMQU/
It was publicised fairly widely at the time that the reason Covid was so aggressive is that the human species had little experience with this particular flu hence had little in the way of natural immunity to it.
However, one of reasons postulated to explain why Omicron is considered to not be as harmful as previous iterations is due to immunisation and previous Covid infection in populations:
"Scientists are trying to determine the extent to which this is because of higher immunity rates engendered by vaccination or past illness, or Omicron is intrinsically less nasty."
https://www.reuters.com/business/healthcare-pharmaceuticals/safrican-study-suggests-omicron-less-severe-even-unvaccinated-2022-01-14/
'good immunity' is incredibly imprecise. Your link doesn't support the assertion of seriousness of disease.
So far as "good immunity" is concerned I mean less likely to develop severe infection rather than not being infected at all, as per this definition from the Merriam-Webster online dictionary:
"having or producing antibodies or lymphocytes capable of reacting with a specific antigen"
https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/immune
Right, this is what I meant when I said,
So,
Point to a time.
We're not there yet. Opening up the borders and letting covid run free in NZ at this time would be a disaster. The strategy is to slow spread as much as we can, and I presume immunise further. By the time the omicron vax becomes available we may well have a much better understanding of both immunity and timeframes.
The problem with an Omicron Vax is that we may well be through this wave before the vaccine becomes available.
I guess we will see how this plays out over the next few months. But my thoughts are that the whole isolation system will become so unworkable that it will be abandoned fairly quickly. I have talked to quite a number of people who have said they will simply ignore being tested if the isolation regime stays as it is. If there is mass civil disobedience in this respect, then there will be little to stop the virus from spreading.
What we are doing now may slow progression down for a week or two. But I think we end up with "let it rip" eventually whether we like it or not.
Anyway, that is just speculation, so we will have to wait to see what happens in reality.
do you know what the government's three phase plan is? They've already said that isolation rules will change as numbers of infections increase.
People talking about or planning on ignoring the plan is just dangerous.
I understand the impulse to return to 'normal' life, but "give up on [all?] restrictions"? During a pandemic? Imho that would be an imprudent response, and a fair indicator of just how dire the prospects for this iteration of civilisation have become.
That was my prediction rather than an argument. I will be more specific. I predict that within two months MIQ will be abandoned.
Lets see if that happens.
This is what Labour are already saying. Not two months but the first half (?) of the year. Hipkins has been talking about this in the past week.
Unless the Team manages to significantly slow Omicron transmission (unlikely, as only China and Taiwan have managed this so far), then within two months Kiwis will be on the far side of our Omicron wave.
And if that turns out to be NZ's only significant wave of COVID-19 cases (which would be an achievement in itself) on the way to a more benign endemic disease globally (keep an eye on South Aftica, the UK, Canada, Ireland, Australia and other countries which already have decreasing numbers of active cases), then by all means abandon MIQ, although imho it would be prudent to retain some MIQ capacity for a little longer, if only on standby.
During this on-going viral pandemic, I'm happy to be guided by the consensus opinions of health experts (virologists, epidemiologists, vaccinologists, etc.) Prioritising health will continue to serve us well.
Let’s see what happens.
It's already a nightmare trying to get any treatment through A&E – at least in Auckland (I don't have evidence for the rest of the country).
This is all anecdata – but numerous friends report waits of up to 18 hours to be seen over Dec/Jan. None of them were there for anything other than emergency situations (1 broken leg, 1 chest pains with a history of heart trouble, 1 severe abdominal pain).
Our A&E is already overwhelmed long before any impact from Covid.
If we'd listened to the white-anters and plan B jerks, we'd have had thousands of dead from OG covid and delta, let alone omicron.
Some people are far too eager to welcome their new virus overlords.
In a zeitgeist current sweeping through islamic nations, folks are realising doctrinal adherence fails to produce effective governance.
The report also features Malaysia and Indonesia:
Anyone interested in the underbelly of American politics can find food for thought here: https://www.theguardian.com/books/2022/jan/29/bidens-american-muckrackers-red-handed-book-review
Problem is, we never get the full story. Intriguing hints tantalise but never go anywhere. Readers roll their eyes & move on…
Speaking of the seedy underbellies…not saying this doesn't happen in the Republican party either:
And we must keep in mind that Aotearoa's cheerleader for selling out to China was John Key. Thought it was such a brilliant idea that a Chinese govt spook became a National MP to facilitate the process…
Yeah, the American sell-out to China was bipartisan. Led by Clinton but since Nixon had launched the trend in '71 can't blame the Dems for jumping aboard later.
Reps would argue that Nixon was merely doing triangulation on the Russians, using China as a tool for that. True. However the capitalists drove the process on a bipartisan basis. The idea was traditional: use cheap labour. China had plenty to offer. Destroying unionism in the USA was just a bonus.
New Zealand owes its material wellbeing to Chinese customers buying our products and services.
And through the Free Trade Agreement two decades ago, we made that dependence willingly and with our eyes open.
We are a richer and more culturally diverse country because of it.
The evidence we are richer is actually pretty thin on the ground:
University of Otago Economics Discussion Papers No. 1906
I suspect that Ad meant we as in the upper class plus the upper middle class, with the strugglers getting a trickle-down you need a microscope to measure as per the classic neoliberal prescription…
Ad not all New Zealanders are richer with the relationship with China, a select few are making good coin, however with the importation of Chinese House Farmers our real estate prices have gone through the roof and the Average Joe can not afford a house especially if they are on minimum wages trying to bring up a family.
Jesse sweating the destruction of the fabric of society.
Classic Disney cartoon figure Minnie Mouse is donning a tailored suit for the 30th anniversary of Disneyland Paris, and conservative critics aren’t happy, describing the outfit change as perpetuating the destruction of the “fabric of our society.” society”.
“Why are they doing this?” Fox News host Jesse Watters asked. “They’re bored out of their minds,” he said of those who decided it was a good idea to give the famous Disney mouse a makeover.
https://today.in-24.com/entertainment/News/346569.html
Readers roll their eyes and giggle about dildo boy.
Props
1. condom jar
2. dildos
3. Music
a. Alicia keys [sic]
b. 80s romance songs, things that are typically James
c. avoid Marvin Gaye as too cliche
4. lube
5. ceiling mirror
6. posters and paintings of naked women
7. playboys [sic] and pornographic magazines
8. candles
9. Viagra and stamina pills
10. fuzzy handcuffs
11. blindfold[24]
http://edition.cnn.com/interactive/2010/09/specials/cnn.caper/index.html
http://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php/James_O%27Keefe#Alleged_seduction_attempt
When they start teaching the new version of NZ History, warts and all, will the nature of Imperialism be taught alongside or will that be ignored, because that wart is not just history, it is an ongoing evil?.
More than ongoing evil, capitalist economics predicated on endless 'growth' which gave rise to expansionism beyond national borders to seize colonies and resources, eventually crashing up against the borders of other rival capitalist powers attempting to do the same, which inevitably leads to world war, has led to something even worse.
The endless growth economy that gave rise to imperialism, colonialism and world war has now crashed up against the natural finite limits of the planet.
The growth economy that gave rise to colonialism and imperialism and world war, is now threatening the existence of all life on earth, through climate change.
Will this be taught in schools?
While we are still embarked on the same MAD course.
Of course not.
Well articulated, thanks.'Of course not' being the point, which means the new versian of NZ History will be sadly lacking.
It's worth the risk of repeating the story to highlight the crap that is coming from some quarters. I appreciate we have to be understanding and be constructive but retards should be called out. Is it possible from social media platforms to identify those responsible for stories such as this? Let them stand on their hind feet and address the nation with their wisdom.
"Reports of death at West Coast vaccination clinic ‘complete load of rubbish’, says mayor
Grey District mayor Tania Gibson has debunked a false rumour that a child died at a Covid-19 vaccination clinic in Greymouth.
Misinformation circulating on social media alleged a 12-year-old child died at a vaccination clinic in Greymouth on Friday. The posts claimed a cover-up.
“That is an absolute complete load of rubbish,” said Gibson.
“But seeing these complete and utter fabrications coming from people who are choosing not to get vaccinated… These people are very dangerous and just very stupid.”
https://www.stuff.co.nz/the-press/news/west-coast/127636498/reports-of-death-at-west-coast-vaccination-clinic-complete-load-of-rubbish-says-mayor
Yep, Voltaire saw the danger of these people…
"those who are capable of believing the unbelievable are capable of committing atrocities"
This is the risk we confront on a daily basis with our neighbours today
This is what happens when you gaslight sections of society. Personally I've got more faith in the typical coaster than the mayor.
Do you have more faith in the mayor or the purveyors of the bullshit about the kid dying at the vaccine centre?
Gaslight? Really. I thought anti vaxxers were as OK with their views as pro vaxxers were of thiers.
Who is doing the gaslighting?
All of us who have had the vaccine, really? I don't think so. AV are fighting some mindless battle when all they need to do is make their decision and hold to it. I am assuming those making an anti vaxx decsion are making this in the knowledge of the consequences. I don't think I have seen reports of pro vaxxers shouting down people at meetings, behaving appallingly badly outside vaccination clinics.
This so called gaslighting sounds very like a poor me attitude – viz I've made a decision that I am comfortable with and now I want to be a toad to the rest, dare I say the majority who have also made a decision and just want to get on with it.
Is gaslighting in your world just to have a contrary stance? So all of those who are gaslighting are the ones who have had a vaccine? Really?
Frankly I think the branch covidians have hatched a cunning plan to make up these stories so they can then go "but if it was so safe, why do the authorities have to keep denying that kids are dying?"
that would imply a reasonable level of strategic planning that is defied by what we've seen so far.
They've been promised victims. Unfortunately, all those folk keeling over in the street following adverse reactions have been kept double-dare hush-hush so to fulfill the prophecy, they've had a crack at martyring themselves.
But still no luck and now it's make up wtf you like.
I've been called a covidian cultist by a certain someone here, no prizes for guessing.
But I think the Covidians should be the name assigned to the anti-vaxxers. After all they have chosen to embrace the covid by inviting it into their temple with such dedication as to decline any defensive shield. That sounds like someone happy to dice with death and worthy of the name Covidian.
Vaccinian could then be the name for those pro vaccine people the Covidians like to berate for their choice not to join the Covidian Cultists.
Did a search for first use of it at TS.
Andre had a good 'un in june 2020 calling dolt45 the "coronakoresh" and his followers the "Branch Covidians", but it seems I Feel Love was the first to use the term in a comment.
Govt needs a marketing wiz:
Since the status quo seems to be nationwide mismanagement with pockets of competence here & there, a genuinely progressive policy containing realistic solutions is what we need. What we lack is faith in Labour's ability to provide that…
'while 35 per cent were either unsure or didn’t know they were happening.'
I imagine this would be a consistent faction about most things ,that people think don't impact them…directly.
I agree. The upside for Labour is that all they need to do to rescue the thing is a classic sales job. Hire a pr company or ad agency if there's nobody capable on the team!
Just catching up with yesterday's Open Mike: my God, Weka has the patience of a saint!
And I notice the negativity became so pronounced that several others commented on it as well.
Well done all those who do what is best for our whole society!
mate, you should have seen what my morning's been like. I’m alternating TS with gardening to retain my composure 😇
Sandra and others have been waiting awhile…Australia recently approved Novavax
Novavax's strength in cross-protection against new variants was further demonstrated in the stellar results of its booster study showing its vaccine produced high levels of neutralizing antibodies against Omicron. Its booster increased antibodies against the omicron 73.5-fold, and was more effective in stopping Omicron from entering cells than other vaccines.
Moreover, SII has been conducting a phase 3 efficacy trial of Novavax since last February. Grant, India's task force member, said SII told him the Novavax vaccine is "extremely effective" against Omicron, in the vicinity of 90%.
He added: "I think it is extremely important that everybody be given the third shot and as quickly as possible. Now, what we have found is that people who are taking Covishield, the third shot has not been so effective. But the new vaccine that is coming out from Serum Institute, Covovax, is very, very effective. In fact, against the Omicron virus, if you've taken the new vaccine of Serum, we are finding fantastic results."
I think most investors didn't see the interview on Indian TV. When SII announces the results, it could be a game-changer by making Novavax the only vaccine with high efficacy against Omicron. Novavax has also been doing a large booster trial during the Omicron wave in the US. I expect it will announce results in March or April.
It's incorrect to predict Covid is becoming endemic or that future variants won't be more severe
In September, a physician wrote: "Covid will soon be endemic…" and "widespread immunity, vaccinated and natural, will bring control and a full return to normal". Since then, the delta and omicron waves have killed another 180,000 in the US. Now, some media outlets and officials are repeating the same mistake by predicting Covid will be endemic this year.'
Ad not all New Zealanders are richer with the relationship with China, a select few are making good coin, however with the importation of Chinese House Farmers our real estate prices have gone through the roof and the Average Joe can not afford a house especially if they are on minimum wages trying to bring up a family.
Just love the 'house farmers' quote.
' with the importation of Chinese House Farmers '-no.no…they only had Chinese sounding….names…they weren't Chinese…the Natz said so.
Oh, look! It's all about the money!
/
A group of vaccine-sceptic writers are generating revenues of at least $2.5m (£1.85m) a year from publishing newsletters for tens of thousands of followers on the online publishing platform Substack, according to new research.
Prominent figures in the anti-vaccine movement including Dr Joseph Mercola and Alex Berenson have large followings on Substack, which has more than 1 million paying subscribers who sign up for individual newsletters from an array of authors who include novelist Salman Rushdie, the writer musician Patti Smith and former Downing Street adviser Dominic Cummings.
Mercola, a US alternative medicine doctor and prolific producer of anti-vaccine content, and Alex Berenson, a journalist banned from Twitter last year after questioning the efficacy of Covid-19 vaccines, are among five vaccine sceptics on the platform who earn themselves and Substack a minimum of $2.5m a year from their newsletters. Under Substack’s business model, writers keep about 90% of the subscription income, with the platform taking 10% and payment company Stripe charging the writers 3% of their take.
https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2022/jan/27/anti-vaxxers-making-at-least-25m-a-year-from-publishing-on-substack
Well he's not able to enter the pub, so is currently getting bounced on his mummy's knee, but will be along shortly to give you a telling off.
& the likes of Rogan et al will say any old bullshit if it pays well. Suckers lap it up.
Here is what Robert Malone, the vaccine skeptic reportedly interviewed by Rogan in a favourable manner on Spotify [I haven't heard the interview], has been been saying about Covid vaccines.
https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2021/08/robert-malone-vaccine-inventor-vaccine-skeptic/619734/
Interesting. I wonder why he bailed out before getting his PhD? Instead of becoming a fully-fledged microbiologist he switched & got an MD instead.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_W._Malone
Genuinely in the running for a Nobel, but too eccentric to be a team player is my take. Anti-establishment (like me). I agree he's onto something here:
https://www.reuters.com/article/factcheck-coronavirus-psychology-idUSL1N2TN1RE
Experts playing it safe is nothing new. The thing is happening. It will become clear to them in retrospect. However this expert is credible as a sceptic:
There was a famous 19th book on the madness of crowds and one sees it in capitalist bubbles & crashes. The phenomenon is real. I suspect the expert sees a technical distinction between that & nazism but cultism is a common feature of mass psychology. Perhaps the ivory tower syndrome is at play here – invent a complex meme & the academic herd collectively shudder at you…
Also, there's a balanced, nuanced appraisal here: https://www.psychologytoday.com/nz/blog/psych-unseen/202201/does-mass-formation-psychosis-really-exist
Google 28 Jan 2018 – 28 Jun 2020 and zip references to mass formation psychosis.
Well I struck gold with one of them:
In some way intimately associated nowadays points to social media. Like-mindedness was a characteristic of in-crowd groups centuries ago. Freemasonry developed into a force at the top level of politics on exactly that basis, and of course there was the history of christianity exemplifying it before that.
The scaling up from a small group to larger groups via contagion is the thing that the competing label ownership bitching amongst professionals seems to focus on. Consultancy generates a money flow – you can see why they get dollar signs in their eyes.
Well you would if you googled shared psychotic disorder.
Did that. All you get is a focus on the past. To figure out what's happening now, we need a focus on current belief-based forums & media – to suss out the contagion mechanism. Although the term mechanism is itself antique.
What causes the interpersonal resonance that produces mimetics seems the most promising place to start…
There is no contagion mechanism. There's only people rightly shit-scared of being infected by a virus that can invade and jigger almost very organ and system in your carcass and then for shit and giggles, cross the blood brain barrier and fuck with pretty much every aspect of your neurology.
Nacts in all their glory.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10445679/Lia-Thomas-UPenn-teammate-says-trans-swimmer-doesnt-cover-genitals-locker-room.html
Article from the Daily Mail about trans swimmer Lia Thomas who is male bodied but under inclusionary policies is allowed to compete in womens swimming competitions and they are smashing swimming records in the womens division.
young women are speaking up about having Lia in their change room. It’s not pretty.
cue liberal men telling women they should just look the other way.
Or cue liberal men just ignorning it……………..afterall Lia's rights more important in women and girls feeling deeply uncomfortable in their change room
These rules are just ridiculous. Basically it's a cross-dresser allowed to compete against woman. I must be slow because I was under the impression a trans whatever had undergone a sex change. Clearly I need to do more homework.
Thanks Fender.
You are not slow. This stuff is happening by stealth. None of what is going on overseas is published in the NZ msm. Just puff pieces about being non binary etc.
The gender self id bill that was passed by NZ parliament just before Christmas allows anyone to change the sex on their birth certificate with merely a sign off from a Justice of the Peace. So you don't need to change a thing e.g. have cross sex hormones or surgery. If you are a man, you don't even have to present as a women.
There are huge safe guarding issues here. Not only are these women in the US having competitions stolen from them, they have to put up with seeing male genitals in their change rooms. And they don't speak up because they are competing for sponsorship, scholarships etc. If they did speak up (other than anonymously) they will be accused of transphobia
I don't believe that men pretending to be woman should be allowed to enter a women's event. It's deception and cheating to call yourself a woman until you've at least had the courage of your convictions to have surgery to resemble a woman physically. If these new rules are universal then what happens when a rugby team fields fifteen men pretending to be woman in order to win the Womans Rugby World Cup.
The simplest and fairest way around all this nonsense is to have a completely new category for competition. Nobody can fake a disability and enter the Special Olympics, so why is this charade going on.
I don't think surgery removes the physical advantage that males have over females, so from my perspective surgery wouldn't change the situation much. A lot of the advantage is conferred at puberty, and in Thomas's case from a career as a male swimmer.
The trans umbrella now covers transsexuals (the kind of trans you are thinking of, typically have gender dysphoria and medical/surgical transition gives them a better quality of life), cross-dressing men, non-binary males, gender fluid males, and the transness that gender identity activists won't talk about: autogynephillia. In addition there will be men who fake it. Who knows which Thomas is.
"I don't think surgery removes the physical advantage that males have over females, so from my perspective surgery wouldn't change the situation much."
I agree. Heard an interview on RNZ last year where it was explained how the high testosterone levels during puberty increased muscle power to such a degree that it's patently unfair. New categories are the only fair way for these sporting events to have any integrity.
You are right Fender, the surgery is just cosmetic and imo should only be offered to people who are 25 years old or so (brain fully developed then). It is plastic surgery, so will never alter the dna, bone structure, muscle structure, larger heart and lungs, adventageous hip bones, bigger hands and feet, all of which are some of the advantages male bodied people have over females in sport.
this article is interesting. Comparing the situation with doping, and pointing out that Thomas isn't doping. But in a way they are. If they are taking a drug to alter their performance so that it gives them an advantage (in this case allows them to change categories), then it's not substantially different.
https://www.swimmingworldmagazine.com/news/without-ncaa-action-the-effects-of-lia-thomas-situation-are-akin-to-doping/
I wonder if the issue wouldn't be better resolved by allow trans women to compete in male categories and have rules around drug use for that. No idea if that would work, but given that TW athlete's bodies are much closer to men's than women's it makes more sense.
TS thread cleanser,
So sad the sociopath won't be able to turn a dollar on his notoriety.
A U.S. judge on Friday approved an agreement by lawyers to destroy the assault-style rifle that Kyle Rittenhouse used to kill two people and wound a third during a 2020 street protest in Wisconsin.
https://www.ctvnews.ca/world/kyle-rittenhouse-gun-from-kenosha-shootings-to-be-destroyed-1.5758029
So twice as many people are coming in than 2 years ago, possibly some who sat out their two year visas or more likely stupidly left NZ and went Tiki-touring , like Dippy Jamie Ridge or the pair who motorhomed around the Aussie grandkids "cos we hadn't seen them for two years and its not fair they won't let us back in ". Its a fucking world wide pandemic killing millions and millions you dumb fucks , what were you thinking, oh that right, you bloody weren't!
There is also something of a bullshit story here with Charlotte Bellis, international journalist living overseas in all sorts of places and 6 months pregnant, suddenly needs to be in NZ to have a baby , Why? Flies to Afghanistan for fucks sake, that world exemplar of natal care, Why ?. To garner fucking sympathy. What's wrong with the fathers home country? Have your baby in a bloody cave the same way that the poor, put upon, disadvantaged Afghani women have had to do do for millennia. You created this situation, you deal with it. Supreme entitlement syndrome.
We haven't seen our London based daughter for years and miss her lots but we aren't grandstanding on the media with choruses of it's not fairs.
what?
one year ago, not two years ago.
and despite what Joe said, that graph has nothing to do with Bellis' case. She applied under the emergency provisions. Of course those cases should get priority.
Because it's routine for women to die in child birth in Afghanistan.
Because she had nowhere else to go. She was in Qatar when she found out she is pregnant, and it's illegal there to be unmarried and pregnant. She initially thought she was going to be able to get back to NZ in Feb, then the government cancelled the border opening because of omicron.
He's Belgian, and as a non-resident she's only allowed there for 3 out of 6 months at a time. She's already used up half of that. She had no visa to anywhere else other than Afghanistan.
Not surprising I guess all things considered, but seeing the misogyny arising in this way on the left is always shocking. Even if you don't give a shit about the safety of a pregnant woman, there's still the wellbeing of the child.
She didn't create the situation. She was told by doctors that she couldn't get pregnant, the pregnancy was unplanned. I also think there are few things off about the story, but I don't for one minute think she, or any pregnant NZ woman in a country without NZ standard of medical care shouldn't be let back in as a priority. Wtaf?
"She was in Qatar when she found out she is pregnant, and it's illegal there to be unmarried and pregnant."
I've been reading that some media people in the UK have scorned New Zealand as the most inhumane place on the planet, a most disgusting place.
I'm wondering why so many are wanting to come here. And wondering if in the god forsaken place it's illegal to be unmarried and pregnant.
I agree Adrian @ 17.
She's trying to manipulate the system using emotional tactics to gain sympathy and preferential treatment. I would hazard a guess she knew when she was still in Belgium that she did not fit the criteria for an emergency entry back to NZ. Is that why she returned to Afghanistan? She thought she could garner leverage for her 'emergency' status by being there?
There have been plenty of people who have been in equal or worse circumstances than Ms Bellis – including pregnant women – but they have accepted their misfortune without indulging in public hysteria.
She claims she returned to Afghanistan because she couldn't go anywhere else. That is garbage. Why didn't she contact the British Embassy for help, or one of the other Commonwealth countries? Surely one of them would have allowed her to stay until she was able to return to NZ.
Really? Bellis' lawyer has been taken a number of other cases of pregnant women who've been denied emergency MiQ.
"Surely" 🙄
She's not British.
https://www.mfat.govt.nz/en/countries-and-regions/europe/united-kingdom/new-zealand-high-commission/living-in-the-uk/uk-citizenship-and-visas/
Weka, See Joe90 at 12pm there is a graph in a tweet in his post.. I couldn't believe it either. Bellis's partner is Belgian, and she left Belgium?. Shes Anglican but asked the Catholic Church if she could get married there in Belgium, but there's a 6 month wait. Oh Christ the unfairness, won't somebody think of poor me.
I just explained why she can't stay in Belgium.
Are you saying that she could get married now and then get residency in Belgium?
It seems really hard to believe but as a Kiwi you need a Visa for the countries that abide by the Schengen Accord.
What she should have done is take the next train to Germany, or even do it in Belgium/Holland/Luxemburg/France and simply ask for Asylum as a stateless person. She would have been granted it, pretty sure of it.
Would that have affected her other options?
Isn't asylum for people being persecuted? Maybe she doesn't think she should be using that process given who it is designed for.
No, there are different criteria for asylum in europe. For what its worth, she could have demanded asylum in a roman catholic church and would have been granted it at least for a wee while, and during this time she could have sorted something more permanent with a different host country.
She is defacto stateless as are all other Kiwis that can not simply board a plane and come back home. In essence she is dependend on good fortune and a government willing to allow people to come back, and it appears she is out of luck on that one.
I have been waiting for something like this to happen, in fact i am waiting for someone to take the government to the human rights tribunal over this.
But as a stateless person she can apply for Asylum and she would be granted it.
And i would like to point out that if NZ'lers overseas now can't even vote in the next election then they are truly stateless and without a government.
Why can't they vote?
I'd like to see something official saying that any NZer overseas currently is stateless.
i think it is to do with time requirements as to how long you are out of the country.
Here is the Green Party on that issue:
https://www.greens.org.nz/kiwis_overseas_must_be_allowed_to_vote_next_year
Anyways, it still changes nothing on the fact that the stranded kiwis overseas are essentially stateless unless they are allowed without and ifs whys and buts to return.
ah, that makes sense. They should definitely change that.
Well that press relieve was from September last year, lets hope they get cracking on that, a lot of the overseas vote does tend to go to L or G. Maybe that will help them getting it done. 🙂
heh, probably. I reckon it won't be top of Labour's list at the moment given it's more than 18 months until the next election. They still seem to think the borders are going to be open in a few months.
Can't see how Bellis' fit this criteria,
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statelessness
She still has a NZ passport, and she's still allowed back in via the lottery system. The lottery system is fucked up, and it may well be making people temporarily defacto stateless, but I doubt international law will see it that way (we will see I guess).
The passport is useless without a spot in MIQ. If she can't come home because she will be denied entry then she is stateless and should / could demand asylum elsewhere.
Currently her passport has about as much value as a call to Winz that is not answered. You might have theoretical access, but it is not given or granted.
I'm still wanting to see something official that says she, and others, fit the international legal definition of stateless.
https://www.refworld.org/docid/415c3cfb4.html
it still does not change anything for anyone over seas.
Asylum is for everyone, anyone can claim it. It is up to the host country if this person fits into international agreements and treaties. And if she was offered Asylum as a de facto stateless person rather then say a refugee of war (and i guess one could claim this status too considering we are at 'war' with this virus) than that is up to the host country.
It is up to NZ to find a better solution to this current debacle, and the NZ Political elite would do better to come up with a more humane set up and process.
but maybe these guy can give you an answer more to your liking?
https://news.aut.ac.nz/news/the-legal-rights-of-kiwis-coming-home
And under the guise of Covid measures, Kiwis right to return is severely curtailed if not outright made impossible – under the guise of 'keeping people here safe'. Ergo, They are Stateless.
stateless
/ˈsteɪtləs/
And unless she is one of the lucky few to win in a lottery (hunger games by any other name) then yeah, she is not recognized a citizen.
I've been saying for ages that MiQ needs to be fixed.
This hyperbole doesn't help. She still has rights, overseas, as a NZ passport holder. Those didn't disappear because of MiQ.
Comparing MIQ to the hunger games is not hyperbole, its been a fucking reality for people stuck overseas that can't come home, or for people here that need to travel (NEED, not want) but can't unless they win the lottery. What needs to happen now is actually for lefties to demand better of their own parties and their own government. Not that your party and the ruling party would listen.
As for the international rules regarding refugees, every country has their own interpretation underneath the rules that you listed. So if a country decides that that women is akin to being a refugee – or is seeking refugee because her own country, her own government refuses to let her travel back 'home', then yes she is a refugee. It does not matter one bit how bad that makes the country or the current lot in parliament look to the world. That is something for this government to consider and maybe even do something about it, someday. surely.
There was no reason for Germany to take up one million Syrian refugees in 2015 -by international standard and law, but they did take up one million Syrian refugees because of humanitarian reasons. While the two go hand in hand, they are quite different from each others. Refuge is something in Europe that anyone can claim, Refuge or Asylum is still granted in Churches, and not everything fits into some neat and tidy laws that allow others to point out why they should not have done what they did on the basis that it might not be explicitely listed as a ‘valid’ reason for a refugee and asylum claim.
She was granted refuge by a host country because the host country decided that she fit that host countries requirements, under the current laws. And the shame about this is for NZ to bear.
btw, those million syrians are doing well.
https://www.cgdev.org/blog/five-years-later-one-million-refugees-are-thriving-germany#:~:text=In%202015%2C%20large%20numbers%20of,Iraq%20arrived%20on%20Europe's%20shores.&text=In%202015%20and%202016%2C%20Germany,million%20first%2Dtime%20asylum%20applications.
Just as well I didn't say that then. Didn't read past that sentence, because it's a waste of time if you are not going to understand my points.
Weka: This hyperbole doesn't help. She still has rights, overseas, as a NZ passport holder. Those didn't disappear because of MiQ
Yes, you said what you said, and i read past your line, hence why i stated that right now anyone who can not get in NZ because of the fuckwittery that is MIQ – and the refusal over the last two years to refuse any changes to the MIQ system, means her rights are not being upheld by this government.
And frankly for what its worth, the government is having so much egg on their faces that the best they now can do is put a category up for pregnant beings that need to come home. She is not hte only one, she is just someone with enough clout to make a ruckus and its obvious she really don't care anymore.
This government has made people a. stateless, b. dependent on the generosity of other countries, and hopes that other countries not only vaccinate these people, but house them – if they can't afford it anymore without working visas, feed them, and medically take care of them.
This government has totally dropped the ball on the people stuck overseas, so much so that the Green Party at this stage must fear for their voters overseas, as evidenced by the link from yesterday that i posted for you, because these guys will loose their right to vote if laws are applies as they stand. So no right to retun and a possible loss of the vote. That is not Hyperbole Weka, that is reality for people overseas under this government.
Personally i believe that the Kiwis stuck in OZ should all start committing crimes in OZ so that they are deported as 503 back to NZ. Maybe that will allow poeple to come back home.
some of her rights, she hasn't lost all her rights. That's the hyberbole that I think is unhelpful. I know it's your commenting style, but I think the point is important.
(haven't read the rest of that comment either, because I really don't want to spend time on things where I'm being misunderstood, sorry. I think your comments about the legal and human rights issues re MiQ are important, I just can't dig through all of that atm).
'Personally i believe that the Kiwis stuck in OZ should all start committing crimes in OZ so that they are deported as 503 back to NZ. Maybe that will allow poeple to come back home.'
It seems that people who are sentenced for 12 months or more are the ones selected for deportation.
Doubt your advice would be viewed as helpful by any sane…person.
It appears that's what has happened
https://www.odt.co.nz/news/national/stranded-kiwi-journalist-offered-asylum
No details where, but not Belgium or Afghanistan
Asylum has a stateless aspect to it as well, Which Bellis would meet as the States which she is resident of, or citizen of, are unable to provide the care of the state for a variety of reasons.
+1
She could have hopped over the Channel to England, which isn't in Schengen. After 3 months you can go back into any Schengen country. She sounds a pretty ballsy woman and rightly pissed off about misjudging her return to NZ, but hardly anything she wouldn't have been prepared for staying on in Afghanistan when she could have returned earlier.
She was not pregnant earlier and thus had no need to return earlier and thus made no attempt to return.
NZ included-'
'Who doesn’t need a Schengen Visa?
Nationals of certain countries, enjoy visa-free travel to these countries for stays of up to 90 days. There are 62 countries whose citizens do not need to visa'
Who Needs a Schengen Visa and Who Doesn't – Eligible and Visa Free Countries – Visa Reservation
yes, and no.
sorry dude.
So she did not need a Visa to travel to Belgium, and if only staying there as a tourist can stay there for up to three month – ditto for someone from Belgium coming here, but anything more then that she needs to apply for a visa, and that visa can be refused, and in her case was probably refused because she is pregnant and will need neonatal, birthing, and post natal care.
What she should have done is fly to OZ, commit a crime and get deported to NZ. s/
ETIAS for New Zealanders | Europe Visa Waiver Requirements
Why bother with..OZ…
'It is very important to be aware that it is illegal for an unmarried woman to be pregnant in Qatar. The consequences of the authorities discovering that a single woman is pregnant include jail and deportation, '
She worked for the Qatar Govt and is well connected enought to even ring the Taleban hierarchy .
did you read the word "jail' before deportation?
or did you miss that?
She will be jailed. She will be jailed for as long as it takes to get there their deportation case actioned. \
She is pregnant. She is a citizen. She wants to come home. And fwiw, she would not be applying to MIQ if she weren't pregnant.
And last, she is a Citizen. She has a right to return to NZ. And hte government has dropped the ball on MIQ sometime ago and decided that they just could not be bothered picking that ball up and making it workable.
I just right now enjoy how she upsets all the 'kind' and 'loving' and 'empathic' lefties into a frothy furor at her audacity to call out the bullshittery that is MIQ, and the fact that Kiwis overseas are stateless and are being granted Refugee Status by the likes of hte Taliban. You can't make that shit up actually. How dare she, to witch i say, behold her field of fucks to grow and see it is barren.
No,I didn't miss the word 'jail'.
I also understand that she worked for this repressive regime at AJ,with no qualms.
Qatar is hosting the worlds biggest sporting event this year…The Football World Cup.
It would be political suicide to jail this woman on that score…alone.
Adrian I see where you are coming from on your comments. A bit harsh on the hapless folk overseas but yes you are right. People who think two years is a vast time to be apart from family just need to take a reality check. Missing grandchildren after a two year absence is a nonsense – use Zoom its fun and wow – actually seeing their faces like they are in the same room as you.
We also have absent family and haven't seen them for over three years, they have been living overseas now for 23 years. Its the way of the world these days, the planet has shrunk and we just have to adjust and get on with our lives. I also cannot understand why anybody would want to go overseas doing this pandemic. The PM has advised often enough how uncertain getting back might be for them. They just need a reality check and get used to the idea. Keep up the zooming, its a lot of fun and better than the weekly aerogram I sent to my parents when I was on my OE many years ago. We don't know how lucky we are.
my reading of Ellis, supposition really, is that given the kind of work she does she was ok with getting stuck outside of NZ and taking risks with her personal safety. Pregnancy changed that, not hard to understand.
From Bernard Hickey's current summary on happenings:
<i>Meanwhile, the top selling vehicle by a country mile last year was the diesel-powered Ford Ranger (12,580 sales), which weighs in at two tonnes and generates 20 times more carbon emissions per kilometre as a petrol-electric hybrid hatchback.</i>
https://twitter.com/bernardchickey?ref_src=twsrc%5Egoogle%7Ctwcamp
%5Eserp%7Ctwgr%5Eauthor
(Don't know how to manage Twitter)
We are getting hassled about cars, parking being taken away, being menaced by fast-ridden bikes and electric skateboards on the footpath and yet some controlling rules on behemoths that straddle one and a half lanes, block vision on forward traffic, and are a big blot on the landscape, are absent or making little effect.
Today I found out that if you google your favourite animal on a smartphone, it gives you an option to use the camera to project a full scale 3D image. And you can embiggen it.
https://developerpublish.com/google-3d-animals-a-detailed-explanation/
So really bigly, so it becomes yuge?
And there was me thinking they're Canadians, they're alright.
While Indigenous and Black people are killed for speaking up, white supremacists get a free pass in Canada. Just look at the convoy
This convoy, which I refuse to link with truckers or “freedom”, shows us who is allowed to speak up in this country, and who will be arrested, attacked and threatened for doing so, Joy Henderson writes.
https://www.thestar.com/opinion/contributors/2022/01/29/while-indigenous-and-black-people-are-killed-for-speaking-up-white-supremacists-get-a-free-pass-in-canada-just-look-at-the-convoy.html
To Weka, I had intended to wish the child to be all the best but ran out of time and forgot for which I am sorry, and far from misogynistic I like most am appalled by the lot of women in places such as Afghanistan and such travesty’s have hardened my attitude to religion and the patriarchy that run most of them. A pox on all thier houses. I am only a few generations away in this country, much like the rest of the world from having been born in a cave or other less than suitable accommodation.
then why on earth would you want a woman to "have your baby in a bloody cave"?
That's the misogyny right there, not Afghanistan, but thinking that any woman should do that because you see them as having made poor choices.
Who recently got angry and said "Fuck Labour" by implication Ardern. We all say and write things in anger which don't represent us.
Please explain how saying fuck Ardern would be misogynistic.
(if I wanted to say fuck Ardern, I would say fuck Ardern, not fuck Labour).
heh
https://conspirituality.buzzsprout.com/1875696
Weka, you completely miss the point, getting pregnant wasn’t a poor choice but going to Afghanistan was an appallingly bad choice, not getting her shit together months ago by joining the MIQ queue and not following the entry requirements properly was, and now using the fact that she is pregnant in a country with sub standard maternity services as leverage is cynical in the extreme.
The “queue” implies you join in an orderly fashion and when it’s your turn it’s your turn.
nothing in my previous sentence can be applied to the New Zealand MiQ procedure
why? She's a journalist. Are you saying that journalists should go home and not report from countries like Afghanistan when Afghanistan is in the middle of a massive sociopolitical crisis?
When did she find out she was pregnant? When did she apply for the emergency MiQ? What should she have done if she didn't win the MiQ lottery?
That one I agree with.
Ok, let's leave her there then and let her and her baby be at risk. That's cynical in the extreme.
It is not just her and her child, it is everyone who can not come home. It is down right ugly, never mind illegal – unless human rights are something now that is only for Kiwis who live here -, and so unkind.
Sad thing really is that in two years time now this fucked up MIQ process was the best our highly expensive and highly educated doodahs in government and government agencies could come up with.
We just have to accept that the logistics and resources needed to cater for the numbers of people wanting to come home during a pandemic are too great for us to handle. What could have been done short of building a new city to complete such an exercise?
increased MiQ facilities? It's not like NZ is short of hotels.
I wonder then where people would go once exiting MIQ. We already can't house the people we have. The more coming would have lead to more leakage and outbreaks. But it looks conceivable that in the not too distant future there could be so much Omicron around there won't be much of a requirement for the system?
well when Labour open the borders and let all the tourists, workers and immigration back in, there won't be enough housing for returning Kiwis then either.
(doubt we have a shortage of accommodation currently, more it's the cost issue and logistics).
Our response at keeping NZers as safe as possible has been better than any other country, 55 deaths in 2 years, minimal Long Covid as far as we know. The World Standard. Right at the start everybody overseas was told come home now or you are on your own, or face isolation on return. It worked and a lot of people we all know are almost certainly only alive today because of the superb management. Do not forget that. The carping and whinging and attempts at gaming the system going on now pisses me off.
"The carping and whinging and attempts at gaming the system going on now pisses me off."
Yep. Its only a minority of NZers who are doing it. The majority accept things are the way they are for good reason, and though it might have gone against them are prepared to wait patiently for when they can also return.
It seems to me that the emotional reaction is foremost in people before the logical questions get asked. This is a woman who was in Afghanistan as a journalist and had contact as such with Taliban. Subsequently according to the Guardian of UK, she found herself pregnant when in Quatar. She left Al Jazeera and went to Belgium which is the country of the baby's father but there she has no entry rights and seemingly he isn't helping? What about a visa and self-financing until able to go home? From a safe place in Belgium because NZ was closed with Covid regulations, she decided to go back to Afghanistan with assurances from the Taliban? Is this really true or even possible and who in their right minds would choose to go back there when not even employed any more as a journalist and pregnant? Just to use speciall allocation rights for quick entry back home? Apparently the dates offered were not OK for her so she chose to delay. I can't believe following this that the immediate sinners are apparently the inhumane government services in NZ. What is wrong with logic and responsability today? The rest of the world looks at NZ with admiration. This story shows the lack of respect for rights of real cases of desperation in Afghanistan from one young NZ lady. Amazing. So easy to criticize knowing little of the real facts and so easy to abuse the good countries with good systems. I am not a NZer. I think you should be applauding your government trying to keep you healthy and instill a bit of responsability on people in their twenties who seem to think everything should go their way and instantly.