Winning ugly

Written By: - Date published: 7:19 am, June 21st, 2023 - 146 comments
Categories: Christopher Luxon, health, national, racism, same old national - Tags:

Another week and another example of National using dog whistle racism to stir up hatred and try and gain political advantage.

This time it is to attack the notion that our health system should be seeking to look after those most in need.

During Covid the Auckland District Health Board’s Clinicians noticed that the list system did not favour Maori and Pasifeka and set out to address this problem.  The primary consideration was still need.  But extra points were awarded to those ethnicities in an attempt to ensure that the allocation process produced a statistically fairer result.

Jo Moir at Newsroom describes the background:

During Covid-19 medical professionals in Auckland identified that Māori and Pasifika were disproportionately waiting for surgery compared with other population groups and sought to fix it when operating theatres were back up and running after the 2020 lockdowns.

All the health data pointed to ethnicity being a significant factor, so alongside clinical need – how urgently someone requires surgery – Auckland hospitals started working its way through waitlists using those two criteria for routine surgeries.

When doctors decide who should be front of the queue, everyone is first and foremost put into a clinical priority category of urgent, semi-urgent, or routine.

Duncan Bliss, Te Toka Tumai surgical services manager, is part of the team who created the algorithm for a new equity adjustor score that was rolled out in Auckland in February.

He tells Newsroom he can’t stress enough that clinical need “always takes precedence and the equity adjustor doesn’t interfere with that”.

So the policy, created by clinicians, appears to be rational.

And Sir Colin Tukuitonga has explained why results were so bad for Maori and Pasifeka and why an adjustment is appropriate.  From the Herald:

Sir Collin Tukuitonga, a leading expert in Pasifika health, said Māori and Pasifika patients could be moved to the front of surgical lines due to the inequalities in the previous stages of the health system, such as the referral process.

“Māori and Pacific people tend to linger on the referral list… and inevitably, I think people will say that there’s also an institutional bias, possibly a racism that doesn’t put them where they need to be in order to get the surgery,” Tukuitonga said.

“The referral pathways are not that straightforward.”

Tukuitonga specifically used the example of bariatric surgery, which helps to aid those with morbid obesity, which he said was “much more” prevalent in Māori and Pacific communities than in Pākehā. He said this could be another reason why these patients are being brought forward in the waiting times.

“For most of the surgical interventions, Māori and the Pacific people don’t get to get the rates of interventions that might be warranted given their conditions,” Tukuitonga said.

He added: “In other words, it’s not acceptable to have a group in the population where obesity is a major problem and yet they’re not getting the physical intervention that they require.”

And the consequences of what Tukuitonga described are clear.

But National, egged on by the Herald and Newstalk ZB, sensed a chance to blow that dog whistle hard.  And blow it they did.  As well as blame the Government for something that Auckland’s clinicians had decided on.

And Luxon was not going to worry about reality getting in the way of a good old racist smear as this interaction with media yesterday shows:

Q – What evidence do you have to support the fact that there was a government directive?
A – Clearly the clinicians are saying there’s criteria that’s been passed down to them that they are expected to activate or to make priority and ranking decisions around patients on. In this case, what we’re saying is look, there is just no need for that.
Q – That criteria has been given to the clinicians by a multidisciplinary team who designed the algorithm. They were the same team who in COVID decided their clinical need and ethnicity should be the only two measures for waiting lists that’s now broadened out to five criteria, which is what we’re talking about today. So a multidisciplinary team of medical professionals, Maori Primary care groups, a whole bunch of medical professionals and clinicians came up with this. So what’s your evidence that the government told them to do this?
A – Very simple, very, very simple, there is no room or no need, we always look to prioritise health services and people’s medical needs and surgical needs not their ethnicity.
Q – That doesn’t answer the question. What evidence do you have that the government directed this?
A – Well, it’s clear you’ve had a reaction from from the surgeons to say that this is not something that we are comfortable with at all.
Q – I’ve just explained to you that a team of medical professionals …
A – I don’t care. There is no room.
Q – You don’t care about the facts?
A – There is no room for health services to be based on basis of ethnicity rather than the facts.

This transaction shows how disingenuous Luxon is.

Getting back to the heading of this post there is a saying in sport that winning ugly is fine as winning is the only important thing.  Clearly National believes that this applies to politics too and is willing to win this election using ugly tactics and completely indifferent to the damage that it will cause to the country.

I hope they lose.  If they gain power they will wreck the place.

146 comments on “Winning ugly ”

  • Comments are now closed

  1. SPC 1
    21 June 2023 at 7:44 am

    Part of the problem is lack of home ownership – moving from rental to rental and not being able to register with a GP. One reason for the lower rate of vaccination for Maori children in recent years. Which is why alternative approaches – used in the pandemic – should be rolled out.

    The USA's average life expectancy has fallen to 76.4 in 2023. There caused by restricting health care to employment (limited welfare support related transiency high drug addiction and imprisonment rates) or otherwise to medicaid and medicare.

    https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/news/hsph-in-the-news/whats-behind-shocking-u-s-life-expectancy-decline-and-what-to-do-about-it/

  2. Thinker 2
    21 June 2023 at 7:44 am

    … Although 'ethnicity' could be a proxy for other underlying factors, so I think the medical profession shouldn't rest on that aspect. You can't really fix 'ethnicity' by itself and prevention is better than cure.

    Regarding the Luxon comments, a party that behaved such that Hager's Dirty Politics book was largely accepted will likely do dog-whistle politics.

    Unfortunately, while I don't think National will win this election, it's possible that Labour could lose it, thereby Luxon drifting to power despite many seeing him as unsuited to the role.

  3. Ad 3
    21 June 2023 at 8:15 am

    Well Mickey thank God for you and the few who defended this minor and rational adjustment to the surgery lists.

    The number of sad old Labour people on this site yesterday who just did the standard howl-with-the-dogs without a shred of investigation into the basic ethnic divide in health inequalities was frankly depressing.

    • SPC 3.1
      21 June 2023 at 8:43 am

      19th? Most of it was led by those not old Labour who flock here when there is the chance of undermining support for an incumbent Labour government (by such methods).

      But sure it is disappointing how readily some fall for the inference of unfair support for Maori – which speaks more to concern about limited/scarce health resources. In times of insecurity, those who exploit rather than those who build come to the fore.

      There are those manipulated by it and those who recognise it for what it is. The lesser and the greater society weighed in the balance.

    • miravox 3.2
      21 June 2023 at 9:42 am

      I guess we all should have known an unpaywalled NZ Herald article by Jason Walls and Barry Soper was mischief making.

      • adam 3.2.1
        22 June 2023 at 1:56 am

        The tory press being the tory press.

        Welcome to NZ, we like our papers white with black lettering thanks.

  4. roblogic 4
    21 June 2023 at 8:35 am

    Vile tactics. I had hoped that Luxon would steer away from dirty politics, but this race baiting is even worse. Scummy and immoral

  5. tc 5
    21 June 2023 at 8:41 am

    Add this to their stated abolishment of the Maori health authority if elected.

    Sad how this is playing out with their desperation to grab power and damm the consequences.

  6. tsmithfield 6
    21 June 2023 at 9:27 am

    While there may not have been an explicit government directive, it has been implimented by the government-established health body and was intended to be rolled out across the country.

    Te Whatu Ora – Health New Zealand has introduced an Equity Adjustor Score, which aims to reduce inequity in the system by using an algorithm to prioritise patients according to clinical priority, time spent on the waitlist, geographic location (isolated areas), ethnicity, and deprivation level.

    And, Hipkins has seen fit to press pause on the policy, pending further investigation.

    So, if the policy was merely clinical, then Hipkins, presumably, would have left it to the clinicians.

    But, the whole idea is completely illogical for a number of reasons:

    Firstly, the idea of ethnicity being a reason for inequity in surgery access is really conflating a number of factors such as need, location, access to primary health care etc. Given those factors are already largely covered in the criterea, it seems to me that it is highly questionable as to whether ethnicity adds anything further of value other than to have the effect it currently is on the public debate.

    Secondly, the policy makes the logical error of applying general statistical data to individual circumstances. Undoubtably, it is true that on average, Maori and PI people are disadvantaged in terms of health generally for a wide variety of reasons. But, the statistical data often may not apply on an individual level. For example, people such as Shane Reti and David Seymour who likely do not have the risk factors of people living in isolated communities for example.

    Thirdly, the policy does nothing about the factors that drive the general health disadvantage for Maori and PI people. For instance, access to doctors, smoking cessation programs, education etc.

    • Ad 6.1
      21 June 2023 at 9:37 am

      So despite all those criteria all concentrated around one ethnicity, we are so afraid that we can't even mention its name. After 200 years of living together.

      Hipkins is doing his blue-lizard-tongued usual move of killing anything that doesn't eat a sausage roll with tomato sauce. He will kill the measure of course because it's in his way, like he does everything else.

      I'm just guessing you're an epidemilolgical expert who can generate reasons other than ethnicity for measurable differences in surgical referrals, treatments, and positive outcomes for Maori.

      • tsmithfield 6.1.1
        21 June 2023 at 9:47 am

        I think that if all those problems are bundled under the construct "ethnicity", then, firstly is doesn't actually help solve the underlying problems because "ethnicity'' itself is seen as the problem.

        Secondly, a lot of people who have a similar bundle of problems but happen to not be in that ethnic group will likely miss out on help they need, simply because they are not in the target ethnic group.

        Finally, don't you think it is a bit racist in a strange sort of way? Implying to people that they are somehow disadvantaged because of their ethinicity is a bit insulting to those of that ethnicity who have made a success of themselves through their own merits. It is a bit like giving someone a five metre head start in a 100 metre race on the basis of ethnicity, even though through their own hard work they have made themselves the fastest in the field on their own merits.

        • SPC 6.1.1.1
          21 June 2023 at 9:56 am

          Do you have a problem with a points system in migration, or a move from the old decile system to another for school funding?

          You refer to historic factors that may contribute to more health problems within one sector – but resent any effort at redress. The infer its about equal accountability at the individual level, because not all Maori faced those problems equally. Guess what they are not likely to be in need of the health services, and might be on private health insurance anyhow.

          It seems reasons for obstruction/opposition are diverse and varied and inconsistent.

          • Molly 6.1.1.1.1
            21 June 2023 at 10:26 am

            I don't understand the point you are attempting to make here.

            • Shanreagh 6.1.1.1.1.1
              21 June 2023 at 10:52 am

              Yes Molly, thanks.

              It seems reasons for obstruction/opposition are diverse and varied and inconsistent.

              Clearly an example from SPC of the old 'if you don't say you are for it, right away you are threfore against it' argument. Gee whiz in my working life I got so tired of this……thrown at people who want to ask questions, tease out the rationale. And then who may be in favour, or not.

              People to the left are not a hive mind and neither should we expect them to be.

              • SPC …
                21 June 2023 at 11:01 am

                I would say you are not characterising this very well

                But, the whole idea is completely illogical for a number of reasons:

                That is not

                people who want to ask questions, tease out the rationale.

                Saying his reasoning was inconsistent is merely an observation.

                But you do the talking about others on the left.

        • Shanreagh 6.1.1.2
          21 June 2023 at 10:54 am

          Valuable points to put forward and to discuss tsmithfield. I am not always in agreement with what you say, but in many cases I am because it is commonsense and dogma free.

        • James Simpson 6.1.1.3
          21 June 2023 at 11:24 am

          Secondly, a lot of people who have a similar bundle of problems but happen to not be in that ethnic group will likely miss out on help they need, simply because they are not in the target ethnic group.

          That's how I see it.

          Bob and Peter have the same health issue. They both live in rural Northland. They are both in their mid 40s. They have both been waiting 14 months for their surgery.

          Bob has Maori ancestry. Peter is an immigrant from India.

          Should their ethnicity in this instance be taken into account when prioritising treatment?

          I don’t think it really advances the issue, by calling people racist, or dog whistling, simply because they question this system.

          • SPC 6.1.1.3.1
            21 June 2023 at 11:43 am

            But it's OK to propose

            any effort to redress inequality in access to primary care leading to higher levels of Maori in treatment categories than their relative population

            as racist?

            As it’s something determined on by Auckland’s clinicians, it would have come under front line service delivery focus on effective performance in improving health outcomes.

      • Molly 6.1.2
        21 June 2023 at 9:57 am

        Just because there is a concentration of poor outcomes for Māori, does not mean that contributing factors have been identified.

        Unless you are saying the primary contributing factor is that of Māori ancestry? If you are, what evidence do you have to base this supposition on?

        "I'm just guessing you're an epidemilolgical expert who can generate reasons other than ethnicity for measurable differences in surgical referrals, treatments, and positive outcomes for Maori."

        Do you not see the contradiction in this statement?

        Economic disparity, lack of access to primary and specialist care, reluctance to visit health practitioners and follow treatments, previous disparity in DHB treatments meaning location played a part, etc…

        These are possible factors that are not ethnicity based, but may have more impact on Māori because of their representation in these groups.

      • tWiggle 6.1.3
        21 June 2023 at 3:36 pm

        https://www.newsroom.co.nz/ethnicity-a-factor-in-surgery-waitlists-for-years

        Interestingly, the ethnicity factor could potentially be assigned to other ethnic groups over-represented in waiting lists, not only to Maori and Pasifika (which are 2 ethnicities, not one, by the way).

        'The four measures that come underneath the priority, clinical need, have all been given a weighting, but Bliss [surgical services manager] says it varies from service to service. “Take neurosurgery for instance, clinical priority and days waiting absolutely take precedence over everything else,” he says.

        But when it comes to low-end routine surgeries Bliss says if the proportion of Māori and Pasifika on the waitlist exceeds their population percentage then a higher weighting is given to ethnicity.'

        Technically, if SE Asians were over-represented in the waiting lists compared to their proportion of the population, then the ethnicity weighting could be applied to them. If it were only Treaty political pressure, Pasifika would not be on the current ethnicity list.

    • miravox 6.2
      21 June 2023 at 9:52 am

      "Firstly, the idea of ethnicity being a reason for inequity in surgery access is really conflating a number of factors such as need, location, access to primary health care etc. Given those factors are already largely covered in the criterea, it seems to me that it is highly questionable as to whether ethnicity adds anything further of value other than to have the effect it currently is on the public debate."

      No, there other factors that relate to ethnic differences are not related factors such as need, location, access to primary health care etc. How do I know this? My PhD thesis (and work i continue to do) was investigating access to a particular specialty, it looked at patient experience, as well as GP, specialist and administrative staff views and adminstrative data.

      While the factors you mention are important for everyone, they don't explain why there were fewer Māori on the waiting list, who took longer to get their first specialist appointment. Structural (and personal) racism is most definitely a thing and it affects how Māori interact with the health system.

      • tsmithfield 6.2.1
        21 June 2023 at 9:58 am

        While the factors you mention are important for everyone, they don't explain why there were fewer Māori on the waiting list, who took longer to get their first specialist appointment. Structural (and personal) racism is most definitely a thing and it affects how Māori interact with the health system.

        Fair enough. So, it seems that institutionalised racism is a problem that needs to be solved. That is why actually specifying in detail the issues, rather than bundling them under a nebulous concept such as "ethnicity". If the bundle of problems that are represented by that label can be unpacked then they can be targeted and dealt with.

        I think this leads to far more fundamental change than the model that was being implimented.

        • miravox 6.2.1.1
          21 June 2023 at 10:08 am

          " If the bundle of problems that are represented by that label can be unpacked then they can be targeted and dealt with."

          They've been unpacked for years.

          https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C5&q=access+to+healthcare+M%C4%81ori&btnG=

          • Molly 6.2.1.1.1
            21 June 2023 at 10:16 am

            First paper I clicked on did not define ethnicity as a factor:

            https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/10376178.2016.1195238

            ' This paper argues that socio-political factors resulting from the entrenchment of colonialism have produced significant personal and structural barriers to the utilisation of healthcare services and directly impact the health status of these two vulnerable groups. Design: Discussion Paper. Conclusions: Understanding the actual barriers preventing the utilisation of healthcare facilities, as perceived by Indigenous people, is essential in reducing the gross disparity between Indigenous and non-Indigenous morbidity and mortality in Australia and New Zealand."

            Waiting for someone to point out correlation is not causation – but apparently it does need to be said – Ethnicity is not necessarily the cause.

            • tWiggle 6.2.1.1.1.1
              21 June 2023 at 3:44 pm

              https://www.newsroom.co.nz/ethnicity-a-factor-in-surgery-waitlists-for-years

              'Bliss says the equity adjustor score is designed from a health perspective, not a political one. “We haven’t looked at it from race or whether it might be controversial, it was based on data.” Life expectancy and mortality rates paint a bleak picture for Māori and Pasifika in New Zealand with European or other males having a life expectancy of 81 years compared with 73.4 years for Māori and 75.4 years for Pacific males.

              Bliss says that is data that could potentially be used in place of ethnicity, but he hadn’t looked closely enough at it to know if it was a fair comparator. “I think we’d have to look at it but also ask why. Why would we try and do that? “Not using the word 'ethnicity' because it’s too political doesn’t feel like the right thing to be doing in health,” Bliss says. “We treat patients based on need and ensure there aren’t inequities.” '

              Semantics.

          • tsmithfield 6.2.1.1.2
            21 June 2023 at 10:17 am

            I am genuinely interested, from a research perspective, how ethnicities are specified for research purposes. Because, there are varying degrees of most ethnicities, so attempting to isolate specific ethnicities for study must be a bit difficult, as to where the line is drawn. And, if there is not a consistent definition then it must make it difficult to replicate previous studies.

            For instance, I think my son's partner is 1/16th Maori. So, would she be included in your research?

            • Molly 6.2.1.1.2.1
              21 June 2023 at 10:25 am

              "For instance, I think my son's partner is 1/16th Maori. So, would she be included in your research?"

              Interesting question. Another could be, how is the preferential treatment ethnicity identified?

              Is it dependent on how someone fills in their GP form? Which is a self-declaration requiring no supporting documentation.

              Can someone change this information perhaps attached to their NHI number?

      • Molly 6.2.2
        21 June 2023 at 10:11 am

        "While the factors you mention are important for everyone, they don't explain why there were fewer Māori on the waiting list, who took longer to get their first specialist appointment. Structural (and personal) racism is most definitely a thing and it affects how Māori interact with the health system."

        Then this factor should be weighted in terms of how much it contributes to poor outcomes, and not be assumed to be the only factor. It should also be addressed by metrics to do with training and transparency – not imposition of a ethnicity based merit system.

        Anecdotal only: My Māori and non-Māori relatives taken as separate demographics indicate a different approach to healthcare. Māori relatives are often more involved in natural therapies and will persist in that approach for longer before going to health practitioners. A Māori woman on a hospital ward with me, gave a familiar excuse for not getting treatment for bowel cancer diagnosed two years earlier – she was busy, it was not that intrusive on her feelings of well-being etc, she had other things she wanted to get done.

        I don't know how prevalent this approach is to personal healthcare among Māori, – I'm just saying perhaps these other factors need to be investigated and addressed for more effective long-term solutions.

        And it is fundamentally – and unequivocally – an institutionally racist system to give preferential treatment on the basis of ethnicity.

        • miravox 6.2.2.1
          21 June 2023 at 10:24 am

          "And it is fundamentally – and unequivocally – a institutionally racist system to give preferential treatment on the basis of ethnicity."

          Except, as the Jo Moir article explains, that's not what is happening.

          I also have relatives who are in the socially deprived end of practically any socio-economic system. My sister died younger than she should have, from lung cancer, so totally understand from on an individual basis how crucial fair access to advanced healthcare is – especially for people who don't have much faith in institutions.

          I also know, at a systemic level what that means – which is why I'm so pissed off we don't have reform of the health system that wipes out private care that effectively pits underserved demographic groups against each other while the rich pay to avoid the waiting lists.

          I have no problem at all with the Auckland solution in the public system as explained in Jo Moir's article. I certainly would, if it were as described in the NZ Herald hit-piece (which seems to have done what it intended – stir up divisions in groups who have common interests in system change).

          • Molly 6.2.2.1.1
            21 June 2023 at 10:37 am

            You seem to be mixing inequity due to access to healthcare, with poorer outcomes due to ethnicity.

            The Jo Muir article seeks to provide justification for an algorithm that does not address the underlying factors but will produce results that will improve the statistics:

            "Hipkins tells Newsroom there is clear evidence Māori, Pasifika, rural people, and those in low-income communities have had to wait longer for clinical care than others and have been discriminated against."

            It's the equivalent of "teaching to test" – ie. test results may be improved, but the knowledge of students often suffers.

            It's a lazy way of redressing outcomes.

            • miravox 6.2.2.1.1.1
              21 June 2023 at 10:54 am

              "You seem to be mixing inequity due to access to healthcare, with poorer outcomes due to ethnicity"

              No, I'm not. both these things are real. One (improved access) can help address the other (outcomes). I do agree however, that unless that there are other issues. Some reform on persons/cultural/financial barriers is happening in tandem with waiting list criteria. The success of those may mean that we don't need to have waiting list criteria at all.

              On broadly ethnic grounds, don't you think its unfair that people can avoid waiting lists altogether by paying for private care that takes nurses and doctors out of the public system? Who are the people at the top of that shorter waiting list? What about those who aren't quite so rich but can scrape up the cash for one specialist assessment in private care (again, mainly pākehā) and then jump back in the queue in public care for their free follow-up treatment – ahead of those people still waiting for assessment?

              • Molly …
                21 June 2023 at 10:57 am

                "On broadly ethnic grounds, don't you think its unfair that people can avoid waiting lists altogether by paying for private care that takes nurses and doctors out of the public system?"

                These are individual wealth grounds. You are conflating them with ethnicity,

                The failure of our public health system to acquire and retain quality staff is a separate issue.

                • miravox …
                  21 June 2023 at 11:27 am

                  "These are individual wealth grounds. You are conflating them with ethnicity"

                  It's individual and group wealth. I've said before I believe the waiting list criteria to be a blunt tool. But short of reforming the capitalist system, I don't expect Māori and Pacific people (as a demographic) to languish on the the waiting list, for longer that their Pākehā fellow citizens (the data is in – it's a fact). The criteria always puts clinical need first – and rurality and social deprivation.

                  According to the article above "if the proportion of Māori and Pasifika on the waitlist exceeds their population percentage then a higher weighting is given to ethnicity".

                  I simply don't have a problem with ensuring pākehā are seen proportionate to their population percentage (especially knowing how many of us have skipped up places on the waiting lists in ways that are not available to socially deprived people of whatever ethnicity).

                  Again, I'd be happy if we didn't need balancing criteria, but until we work through the myriad of issues involved in delivering good public healthcare for all, a blunt tool is better than no tool at all.

                  I think I'll leave it there – this is my view, based on the research I've spent a lot of time studying and I won't be changing it quickly. I suspect your view is quite settled too.

                  • tsmithfield …
                    21 June 2023 at 11:41 am

                    Again, I'd be happy if we didn't need balancing criteria, but until we work through the myriad of issues involved in delivering good public healthcare for all, a blunt tool is better than no tool at all.

                    I think it is not only a blunt tool, but also a highly ineffective in both outcomes and targeting, and just likely to cause more trouble than it is worth, as is being discovered now.

                    The reason I say that, is because the problems run much deeper than just access to operations.

                    For example, access to primary health care due to a lack of GPs in isolated areas, poor prognosis for recovery from operations due to underlying conditions such as diabeties, high smoking rates amongst Maori and Pacifica making them more vulnerable, poor education and information about health screening in various areas etc.

                    So, I think if there is a lot more attention paid to these areas, then the health outcomes as a whole for Maori and Pacifica, and other ethnicities with similar issues, will be a lot better as a whole.

                    • SPC …
                      21 June 2023 at 11:52 am

                      It's going to be hard to improve primary health care for that sector of the population if they have a higher number of people waiting for treatment than the rest of us.

                    • tWiggle …
                      21 June 2023 at 3:54 pm

                      Well, tsmithfield, looks as if you have argued yourself into supporting Labour's Maori health authority, initiated in 2022.

                      https://www.futureofhealth.govt.nz/maori-health-authority/

                    • tsmithfield …
                      21 June 2023 at 11:08 pm

                      Well, tsmithfield, looks as if you have argued yourself into supporting Labour's Maori health authority, initiated in 2022.

                      I don't have a problem with too much of that, other than I would remove the ethnicity part of it, for the reasons I have already given, and would focus the initiatives on need generally, which in turn would include vulnerable Maori communities.

            • weka 6.2.2.1.1.2
              21 June 2023 at 4:11 pm

              The Jo Muir article seeks to provide justification for an algorithm that does not address the underlying factors…

              What does that mean? Do you mean that surgeons making decisions about waiting lists shouldn't be taking into account factors in addition to clinical issues? That they should be helping patients with poverty? What?

              but will produce results that will improve the statistics:

        • SPC 6.2.2.2
          21 June 2023 at 10:37 am

          I guess we know where you would stand in the American pantheon, opposing affirmative action.

          • Molly 6.2.2.2.1
            21 June 2023 at 10:41 am

            Would "we"?

            Affirmative actions re opportunity, is a different situation to healthcare don't you think?

            Why not stick to the discussion regarding using ethnicity instead of factors addressing poverty, unequal access, transparency of care etc.?

            • SPC 6.2.2.2.1.1
              21 June 2023 at 10:52 am

              Your claim

              And it is fundamentally – and unequivocally – an institutionally racist system to give preferential treatment on the basis of ethnicity.

              And

              unequal access

              Affirmative action was about unequal access (background factors such as poverty).

              All other health factors being equal, and knowing of the historic inequality in lifetime outcomes etc, why not add ethnicity/being an indigenous people as a factor?

              • Molly …
                21 June 2023 at 10:54 am

                "All other health factors being equal, and knowing of the historic inequality in lifetime outcomes etc, why not add ethnicity/being an indigenous people as a factor?"

                Correlation is not causation.

                • SPC …
                  21 June 2023 at 11:10 am

                  Correlation is not causation.

                  So what! If we want to improve the relative health of Maori this involves both primary care and treatment access. And if we will not do this for the indigenous people what does it say about our signing UNDRIP?

                  • Molly …
                    21 June 2023 at 5:07 pm

                    "So what!"?

                    I support policy based on robust evidence, which I believe has a better likelihood of achieving long-term sustainable change.

                    I don't have the motivation of politicians to produce well-packaged, easily digestible, simplistic answers to complex issues.

                    My power lies in my electoral votes, and my ability to critique policies as they are released in the hopes that they will be improved upon.

    • Muttonbird 6.3
      21 June 2023 at 12:29 pm

      How odd. We should discard general statistical data for Māori because there are two rich Māori over there.

      • tsmithfield 6.3.1
        21 June 2023 at 2:19 pm

        No. We should apply problems highlighted by statistical data at the population level not the individual level.

        If we apply statistical data to individual cases, there will continually be instances where the shoe doesn't fit, and injustices will occur elsewhere as a result.

    • Anker 6.4
      21 June 2023 at 4:23 pm

      100% TSmithfield. All well made points.

      • weka 6.4.1
        21 June 2023 at 4:55 pm

        all your comments are going into trash until you reply to moderation. Please look at the Replies list for my comments.

  7. SPC 7
    21 June 2023 at 10:05 am

    The effort seems to be to frame any inclusion of ethnicity as a factor amongst others as a move to an ethnicity/race based system.

    Misrepresentation, the new pretty legal.

    • Molly 7.1
      21 June 2023 at 10:19 am

      "The effort seems to be to frame any inclusion of ethnicity as a factor amongst others as a move to an ethnicity/race based system."

      In terms of healthcare and giving precedence using ethnicity – rather than medical factors only – how is this not "an ethnicity/race based system"?

      • SPC 7.1.1
        21 June 2023 at 10:34 am

        If that was a fair description – how would one describe any state subsidy of the private education and health insurance system reserved for those who can afford the cost of entry – given the under-representation of Maori in that group?

        • Molly 7.1.1.1
          21 June 2023 at 10:38 am

          As one based on individual wealth – not ethnicity.

          • SPC 7.1.1.1.1
            21 June 2023 at 10:44 am

            Sure – akin to the lack of tax on CG, wealth and estate common in other OECD countries, a favoured class (of those with private wealth) notable for the relative lack of indigenous people in its make-up.

            • Molly 7.1.1.1.1.1
              21 June 2023 at 10:53 am

              Due to my ethnicity, you speak of me as a cohort apart from you.

              I personally find it insulting, and indicative of a racist perspective stemming from a (misplaced) sense of guilt and perhaps superiority.

              The pursuit of neo-liberal ideas in government and policy has affected many whose lives were based on the ability to live a well-balanced life in a one-income working class household.

              There is racism in New Zealand. But it is not necessarily the sole factor in poor outcomes.

              Improving access for ALL to high quality healthcare, education and opportunity is needed. Work-life balance and well-being should be able to be attainable on a working class wage – regardless of ethnicity.

              • SPC …
                21 June 2023 at 11:14 am

                Due to your ethnicity … you lost me there. What was your point again?

                I get the one New Zealand brand, but some aspiration to improve the lot of the indigenous people is not based on guilt or supremacism, but acceptance of Treaty redress and UNDRIP.

                And the old egalitarian dream requires tax on wealth.

                • Molly …
                  21 June 2023 at 3:24 pm

                  "Due to your ethnicity … you lost me there. "

                  You keep referring to me as indigenous – as if that is my primary identification factor. I find it absurdly racist, when I am on the receiving end of it. It assumes the actual contributing factors of poverty, housing overcrowding etc are a fundamental and unavoidable part of being Māori. There is also an implication that non-Māori are excluded from these factors – so a double hit.

                  " …get the one New Zealand brand, but some aspiration to improve the lot of the indigenous people is not based on guilt or supremacism, but acceptance of Treaty redress and UNDRIP."

                  So says you. I disagree. I believe belated reference to a two hundred year old document, can be easily manipulated to give credence to a wide range of racist and undemocratic policies – that will benefit individuals within the political class – including those who are Māori.

                  "And the old egalitarian dream requires tax on wealth."

                  So says you. Again, I disagree. For the reasons stated on my past comments you are probably referring to.

                  Which also didn't include the probable occurrence that the really well-off hold their assets in business and overseas, which as far as I know aren't affected. The more I consider "the compelled donation to the government to obscure past and current failures" that you call the wealth tax – and look policies such as this, it is a blueprint for how not to govern for health and well-being of all.

                  • SPC …
                    21 June 2023 at 3:58 pm

                    I was referring to your stressing the irrelevance of ethnicity, then mentioning your own.

                    And for someone who posts so much about being a woman with woman's identity, are you going to call it sexist if one mentions need to focus some attention to neglected women's health (certainly at the issue of well known common conditions of women that are not well diagnosed and thus lead to years of delay for operations – as happens to some Maori for other reasons).

                    I believe belated reference to a two hundred year old document, can be easily manipulated to give credence to a wide range of racist and undemocratic policies – that will benefit individuals within the political class – including those who are Māori.

                    Sure claim other Maori are racist and have an undemocratic agenda, once assimilated into private wealth class culture.

                    It's related to iwi property claim. Nothing wrong with owning stuff and claiming compensation for theft.

                    Ask those who do not own property, how they rate in terms of wealth to others, have spare resources to cope with cost of living emergencies and obtain healthy housing in which to raise a family.

                    There is a reason why the aggregate statistics do not lie.

                    As to the past nostalgia (one income earner and home ownership and the 5 day week) – it was financed with a top rate of tax at 66%, subsidised home ownership (including the mortgage payment rebate) and family benefit etc.

                    And assets held offshore are already in the tax orbit.

                    • Molly …
                      21 June 2023 at 4:46 pm

                      "I was referring to your stressing the irrelevance of ethnicity, then mentioning your own."

                      You write of indigenous in terms of "the other". It's relevant to point this out, and attempt to avoid accusations of racism towards Māori, by informing you I am one. But it appears you are not easily embarassed – so be it.

                      "And for someone who posts so much about being a woman with woman's identity,"

                      … I've never posted about having a woman's identity….

                      are you going to call it sexist if one mentions need to focus some attention to neglected women's health (certainly at the issue of well known common conditions of women that are not well diagnosed and thus lead to years of delay for operations..

                      Sex, being both binary and immutable – has clear divisions in medicine. These sex based factors have been identified. Your comparator is poor.

                      "– as happens to some Maori for other reasons)."

                      How do you define ethnicity? And it is the throwaway phrase "for other reasons" which should be the most significant.

                      “It’s related to iwi property claim. Nothing wrong with owning stuff and claiming compensation for theft.”
                      Apparently this is only true – depending on ethnicity.

                    • Shanreagh …
                      22 June 2023 at 2:00 pm

                      As to the past nostalgia (one income earner and home ownership and the 5 day week) – it was financed with a top rate of tax at 66%, subsidised home ownership (including the mortgage payment rebate) and family benefit etc.

                      You write about this, it seems to me with a hint of criticism.

                      I can actually see nothing wrong with

                      • one income earner families, if they want to be ie choice
                      • home ownership
                      • 5 day week
                      • top tax rate of 66%
                      • subsidised home ownership including mortgage interest payment tax rebate
                      • family benefit paid to the non working partner if wanted.

                      when we look at what is available now.

                      For me the price for changes to these aspects have mainly been paid by the workers while benefitting bosses

                      eg

                      • we have frantic workers working 60-80 hours a week, often with no extra pay or OT
                      • we have workers on ghastly split shifts that enable a firm to maintain 24 or 16 hour coverage but do nothing for home/family life
                      • we have families of portfolio workers ie those holding down several jobs each, every day….
                      • we have diminishing levels of home ownership
                      • we have tax rates that favour the wealthy and do not use the tax system to best advantage. The Greens tax rates proposal is part of the 'wealth' tax proposal I support but it should be unlinked from the rest of the proposal

                      I feel that we could do worse than to be aspirational for some of these aims. We should not lock in regimes where everyone in a family has to work as a matter of survival

                    • SPC …
                      22 June 2023 at 2:40 pm

                      You write about this, it seems to me with a hint of criticism.

                      It was written to note howthe that society Molly misses was afforded (I could have added tariffs and strong unions to ensure higher wages), with some cynicism as to whether she would support measures of that sort to realise it.

                      The main problem with making that work today is the upward pressure on land values and how high our infrastructure costs have got.

                      In terms of employment law – we had the 40 hour week and overtime hours/penal rates. The ECA reforms allowed employers to break up jobs into segments and make people travel between jobs in their own time and at their own cost and without penal rates (for shift and weekend work). This single reform undermined our quality of life. For mine, people should not be required to be available for shift or weekend work to get a job.

                      The other issue is support for the non working partner. It's long past time for there to be partner access to income support between jobs (no work test if children are under 5). This would help disabled people who find partners and also those on the DPB as they begin to form new partnerships.

  8. Darien Fenton 8
    21 June 2023 at 1:09 pm

    Seemed fair to me : Factors : 1. clinical priorities, 2. time spent on the waitlist, 3. geographical location, 4. deprivation level. 5. ethnicity. It's not new btw : it has been used in DHBs before but just a beat up and opportunity to have another go at dividing the country.

    • Molly 8.1
      21 June 2023 at 4:48 pm

      I understand 1. and 2., but how did 3., 4. and 5. make it into the algorithm?

      Why geographical location?

      How is both 4. and 5. ascertained? I've never been asked my socio-economic group in forms completed for the Ministry of Health.

      • Shanreagh 8.1.1
        21 June 2023 at 6:38 pm

        How is both 4. and 5. ascertained? I've never been asked my socio-economic group in forms completed for the Ministry of Health.

        Yes quite.

        If the same methodolgy is used here as was used in a much derided funding provision in my suburb to enable older villas to be be upgraded for bathroom & kitchen facilities, it was done by access to stats (from the census) down to mesh block level. This showed that those living in the western part of the suburb had lower incomes than those on the eastern part. Western part was had a higher proportion of rented accomodation while the eastern part had young families renovating with sweat equity, multiple jobs etc .

        The funds were not targetted at landlords but at those with a higher place on the deprivation index because they were renting. But renters could not access the funds. While the ones in east probably had higher gross incomes but mortgages and high costs of renovation and maintenance that they were doing the hard yards and could really have done with help, which came with low cost architectural advice.

        So mesh block or postcodes can be analysed from the census and 'conclusions' made. To say that when using this kind of data you need to be careful with assumptions and conclusions and look at all elements would be a basic thought. The allocation of funds in this case in my suburb that did not give enough weight to ownership patterns and looked at incomes only and got way off track..

        And again Molly, to do this kind of study properly we get back to the idea you have mentioned before and that is net income as others may have low cost or subsidised housing and other $$$ plans that give them more in the hand than others who are perceived to be on a higher gross income and therefore 'wealthier'.

        Having worked in the health sector we need to be looking at what happens before we get to the lists (or doesn't happen) as well as managing the lists.

        Rural people, low income people also have poorer access to basic health care. So a drive to a centre with a medical centre may be problematic because of transport issues.

        For some, including Maori there is a need to be able to access care from their own, at marae etc, having people who can work across traditional and Rongoa Maori remedies.

        In some areas great strides have been made doing this (Kokiri marae (Seaview) and Papawai marae (Greytown) are two in my area. They have clinics and focus on wellness for their populations. Wainuiomata marae holds wellness clinics and works in with local practitioners and in the area of Southland where my sister lives some of the 'heavy lifting' as far as timely access to vaccinations for Covid for all the population in the small area were handled by one of the marae there…..a tiny marae that geared up.

        Bonding or pay scales to encourage a rural presence may be good.

        But it is not only Maori but often women too who have to accept a lesser service in rural areas. One car, don't drive, no public transport, single sex (male) practices, no ethnic diversity, no money……

        All parts of the algorithm need to be looked at. This week we have seen inadvertent double counting in the roading/speed limits proposal in Wellington. So each element in the algorithm needs to be interrogated to make sure that it does not include elements of the others, to avoid double counting.

        So from Darien's post

        1. clinical priorities, 2. time spent on the waitlist, 3. geographical location, 4. deprivation level. 5. ethnicity

        Is time spent on the waiting list linked to geographical location? In some areas it will be because all residents in a location eg say Wairoa in Nthn HB would need to travel for specialist advice, All Whanganui residents access some specialists at mid Central (Palmerston North). Clinics by bringing specialists to the centre are a way but people in Wairoa rural and Whanganui rural areas will still need to travel.

        I can see that there could be some fuzziness in thinking here between 2 & 3.

  9. Gosman 9
    21 June 2023 at 1:54 pm

    ACT managed this brilliantly in the house yesterday as they put forward all their MP's who have Maori whakapapa to ask questions over why should they get preferential treatment over others due to their ethnicity. It led to Marama Davidson being ejected for allegations of racism which looks foolish when the people she is accusing of this can claim to be Maori as well.

    • weka 9.1
      21 June 2023 at 2:06 pm

      Māori people can ask racist questions too Gosman.

    • SPC 9.2
      21 June 2023 at 2:24 pm

      So people who can afford health insurance and represent class interest are not supportive of provision based on greater need, including an ethnic group suffering health disadvantage …

      And use the excuse that the targeting in this case is based on ancestry/ethnicity being one of the indigenous people. Do they recall ACT offering confidence and supply to the government that signed UNDRIP?

      • Shanreagh 9.2.1
        21 June 2023 at 6:50 pm

        This is a generalisation.

        So people who can afford health insurance and represent class interest are not supportive of provision based on greater need, including an ethnic group suffering health disadvantage …

        One of the reasons that some take out privately paid health insurance is that they see it as a way to ease pressure on the public health system by doing their bit and paying for themselves.

        I have health insurance and have had it for over 40 years…..it was available through our union when I started in the PS. The sentence above was one of the points made in favour of taking it out.

        I would venture to say that if the health needs are catered for by interventions paid for by individuals this still takes pressure off the public hospitals. Any pressure taken off surely helps others access health care.

        This comment about class, health insurance is very similar to some of the arguments advanced to tax the so-called 'wealthy' A little kneejerk in my view perhaps not in the class of the politics of envy but somewhere along that line……

    • adam 9.3
      22 June 2023 at 2:05 am

      The best thing about Quentin Tarantino is he puts on screen some of the ugly aspects of the human condition for all to see. What I don't understand from the act members in the house is, why they felt they each had to give us their impression of Stephen Warren.

  10. pat 10
    21 June 2023 at 2:20 pm

    Its an upside down world when those opposing race based assumptions are labelled racist.

    • weka 10.1
      21 June 2023 at 2:30 pm

      it's not opposing race based assumptions. It's opposing redressing systemic racism that means that Māori and Pasifika people are badly served by the health system. Why anyone would oppose that is not yet clear, other than that they don't understand the policy and what it is based on.

      • Molly 10.1.1
        21 June 2023 at 3:27 pm

        Because it is not evidenced that the outcomes are due to ethnicity alone.

        And it should be addressed by identifying those contributing factors and implementing effective means to address them.

        What is being provided is a way to manipulate the outcome figures, without addressing the why.

        • weka 10.1.1.1
          21 June 2023 at 4:02 pm

          Because it is not evidenced that the outcomes are due to ethnicity alone.

          there are no single causes. Clinical issues don't sit in isolation either. Why do you expect ethnicity to?

          And it should be addressed by identifying those contributing factors and implementing effective means to address them.

          We already do this, or know but don't do it. Meanwhile, one of the drivers of poor health outcomes is poverty, and neither Labour nor National are willing to seriously address that. Why should Māori, who are disproportionately affected, put up with shitty health care in the meantime. And, poverty as a driver doesn't sit alone either.

          What is being provided is a way to manipulate the outcome figures, without addressing the why.

          That could be said about a very large chunk of the health system. Why do so many people need surgery in the first place? Shouldn't we be addressing poverty, diet, lifestyle, stress before giving people surgery? Yes, but the person needing surgery this year won't be helped by that.

        • Craig H 10.1.1.2
          21 June 2023 at 4:20 pm

          https://journal.nzma.org.nz/journal-articles/disparities-in-post-operative-mortality-between-maori-and-non-indigenous-ethnic-groups-in-new-zealand-open-access

          Results

          From nearly 3.9 million surgical procedures (876,976 acute, 2,990,726 elective/waiting list), we observed ethnic disparities in post-operative mortality across procedures, with the largest disparities occurring between Māori and Europeans. Māori had higher rates of 30- and 90-day post-operative mortality across most broad procedure categories, with the disparity between Māori and Europeans strongest for elective/waiting list procedures (eg, elective/waiting list musculoskeletal procedures, 30-day mortality: adj. HR 1.93, 95% CI 1.56–2.39).

          Seems to be a problem even after adjusting for other factors like age.

          • Molly 10.1.1.2.1
            21 June 2023 at 4:31 pm

            So, identify and address those identified factors.

            See if it is related to:

            Income: eg. returning to work earlier, not able to get support people, returning to an unheated overcrowded house,

            Work: Is work more physical in nature, shift-work etc.

            Access: Is access to aftercare not suitable for those on shift-work, unaffordable etc.

            Information: Are patients well-informed about aftercare and how to access help and support?

            It is the identification of contributing factors that will provide for everyone.

      • pat 10.1.2
        21 June 2023 at 5:05 pm

        The reality is everyone is being failed by a failing health system….you dont remedy that by prioritising on any basis other than need….that is what triage is.

        • Molly 10.1.2.1
          21 June 2023 at 5:08 pm

          Agree, pat.

        • weka 10.1.2.2
          21 June 2023 at 6:15 pm

          The reality is everyone is being failed by a failing health system….you dont remedy that by prioritising on any basis other than need

          They are prioritising on need.

        • weka 10.1.2.3
          21 June 2023 at 6:33 pm

          If two people of the same age with the same medical condition, the same general health, and having been on the waiting list for the same time present to a surgeon, how should the surgeon decide who goes first?

          • pat 10.1.2.3.1
            21 June 2023 at 6:58 pm

            if everything else is equal, toss a coin.

            • Incognito 10.1.2.3.1.1
              21 June 2023 at 7:03 pm

              Nope, you select the one who took longest to get on the waiting list.

              • weka …
                21 June 2023 at 7:18 pm

                it's like people haven't even thought about the rationales.

                • Incognito …
                  21 June 2023 at 10:20 pm

                  But it is more than just “rationales’; it’s based on real clinical experience in hospitals in Auckland and Northland accrued over some time (since 2020).

                  The cognitive dissonance here is strong today coupled with poor reading comprehension and not being familiar with the topic & facts. Plus a few other factors that I won’t mention because it will trigger the usual kneejerk responses from some.

              • pat …
                21 June 2023 at 7:20 pm

                "if everything else is equal"…im sure you can read.

              • Shanreagh …
                21 June 2023 at 7:36 pm

                Yes this is my point as well Incognito…..what happens prior to getting on the list?

                Remembering that all sorts of 'Micky Mouse' tricks have been done to 'manage' waiting lists over the years and people have been 'on' or 'off' or sent back to their GPs to manage.

                In some parts of NZ it is a postcode generated lottery, people who access healthcare ie on boundaries can work across the postcodes and get access to a couple of places (public hospitals in a couple of cities) with surgical facilities. They may have specialists who work in two public hospitals.

                Others have to rely on tertiary facilities half an island away (Gisborne/East Coast/Northern HB, rural Whanganui) getting an appt at a clinic is the first and often very difficult part. This is after your GP has felt you need more attention that they can give, and even bfore getting on the list.

                But before that is the provision of primary healthcare……Marae can provide wellness checks and a venue for specialists.

                All these points have been known for ages and ages. Health is the usual political football.

                Are we getting any better at all?

                Judging by Corey's views not much. Yet there has been a power of work done over the years by dedicated people wanting to solve the problems.

                Quite frankly, and you will scold as I've gone away from the topic, my belief is that the neo-lib crock has a lot to answer for. I feel sad that this current govt with its eye watering election result in 2020 and mandate has not explicitly unwrapped some of the stuff that was done then. Buying back the family farm/silver is always more $$$$-wise than you got from selling it in the first place……

        • Shanreagh 10.1.2.4
          21 June 2023 at 6:57 pm

          Agree with that wholeheartedly. The point being is that we are a poor-ish country and our people need early health interventions and we need to find a way to do that across cultural etc factors.

          If we generate more $$$ by bringing more new $$$$ in by selling goods that others want then we can lift up the income of the country. At the moment we seem to cutting a cake that is getting smaller and smaller while the numbers of people needing a piece gets larger and larger.

          NB easier said than done.wink

          • weka 10.1.2.4.1
            21 June 2023 at 7:21 pm

            NZ is not a poor-ish country though. And perpetual growth will block our ability to both mitigate and adapt to the climate/eco crises.

            early health interventions happen before someone needs even a GP. Eliminating poverty reduces the negative health impacts of poverty and takes the pressure off the health system and budget because less people get ill in the first place.

            • pat 10.1.2.4.1.1
              21 June 2023 at 7:44 pm

              If NZ is not a 'poorish country' why is our health system failing at the most basic level?

              Is it a lack of political will?

              A lack of expertise?

              A lack of funds?

              • Shanreagh …
                21 June 2023 at 7:51 pm

                Yes indeed.

                Our 'lucky country' neighbours with access to natural resources have untold advantages over NZ.

                • weka …
                  21 June 2023 at 8:26 pm

                  Australia is going to have a very hard time as the climate crisis deepens. Minerals are less important than rivers and the ability to grow food.

              • weka …
                21 June 2023 at 8:25 pm

                Decades of neoliberalism has put the wealth in the hands of people who don't hold values around things like public health good or raising all people out of poverty or stablising/lowering housing costs.

                We can try and increase wealth via traditional economic theory, but the transfer of that wealth will continue (look at what happened in the pandemic). The system needs an underclass to function, and it needs power and money to be in the hands of the few. These are features not bugs.

                Lack of political will? I guess. I think it's also lack of imagination expertise. It's not like we don't have alternatives, but few will take something like Doughnut Economics seriously, because they can't see how to get there from here (and tbf, we're not well socialised to be able to imagine such things and politicians are no exception).

          • miravox 10.1.2.4.2
            21 June 2023 at 9:24 pm

            The cake is getting smaller?

            https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/NZL/new-zealand/gdp-per-capita

            I don't think so, it's just bigger slices of the larger cake are going into fewer hands, not more hands, destroying the environment and egalitarianism in the process.

  11. tWiggle 11
    21 June 2023 at 4:11 pm

    Ask an engineer – a working model that fits 80% of cases is a pretty good one for most applications. I learnt the difference between the ideal research world and real-life applications when retraining into an engineering field. It doesn’t need to be perfect to work well.

    It appears you want a perfect surgical prioritisation algorithm, Molly, to address your ideal of perfect justice. And you seem to demand perfect definitions for grab-bag words like ethnicity used to evaluate surgical schedules.

    As commentators at TS are neither professional philosophers nor surgical staff or clinicians, I predict that you will not find the answers you seek here. An 80% approximation is good enough for most.

  12. Corey 12
    21 June 2023 at 4:24 pm

    I think they should add age to these criteria. Below 40 should get priority.

    The life expectancy for gen z and gen y has got to be low 70s if not mid 60s.

    Generation debt, with no assets, no hope of getting assets, lower buying power compared to previous generations due to decades of wages falling and not keeping up with growth, most of our incomes go to paying obscene amounts in rent for cold damp houses that make us sick, power and heating is disgustingly expensive, and healthy food or food in general in NZ is full on daylight robbery.

    Forget race. My generation is absolutely fucked. Period. Most of us will not make it to a pension if we do, pensions will not exist.

    Add to that climate change and paying of older generations debt.

    We are fucked beyond belief.

    And with obesity only getting worse and worse (some experts think 50% of the world will be obese by 2035) we probably won't even have a health system in 2050 because obesity at those levels will be unaffordable.

    If we're going to have no assets our entire lives swimming to work and working constantly, just so most of our wages can go to renting a damp box, and the rest of our money goes on luxuries like groceries, power and if the rich get our way , water! Working hard to make sure the state gives well housed older people pensions that we will never get, I think….

    People under 40 should get priority too.

    • Molly 12.1
      21 June 2023 at 4:53 pm

      "People under 40 should get priority too."

      Problem with such an approach, is that it is another value judgement. And if you prioritise location, deprivation, ethnicity and then youth, you will also be asked to prioritise carers – whose ill-health impacts on others, business owners – whose health may be a priority for ensuring workplaces continue supporting workers, people involved in health care – self explanatory, etc….

      Eventually, everyone is included and the priority becomes those with the most pressing clinical diagnosis or need.

      • Patricia Bremner 12.1.1
        21 June 2023 at 6:12 pm

        Well that went round the mulberry bush. crying I suppose I should just accept that family and friends got diabetes from sugar and flour, and or died early from smoking or drinking with related cancers, as their ancestors had not developed what was needed over generations to fight off the effects due to their ethnicity.

        Remember how we killed Indian children with the gift of milk biscuits. They lacked an enzyme needed, having been weened early. It was as if they were eating bricks. Their gut needed rice milk biscuits. Now they were disadvantaged through their ethnic diet. Why could we not accept the same could be happening here?

        Dead is dead, Your use of "causation". The surgeons and clinicians are looking for what is equitable… and sometimes they suggest ethnicity may play a part.. just as my red hair makes me prone to certain disorders or disadvantages.angry

        Why such a list stirs such hyperbole and loaded comments brings many of us to despair.

        • Molly 12.1.1.1
          21 June 2023 at 8:01 pm

          "as their ancestors had not developed what was needed over generations to fight off the effects due to their ethnicity"

          When this is directly evidenced – it should play a part in diagnostics.

          Like Sickle Cell Beta Thalassemia Disease – http://www.idph.state.il.us/HealthWellness/fs/sickle_beta_thalassemia.htm#:~:text=Sickle%20cell%20beta%20thalassemia%20(Hb,in%20people%20of%20Mediterranean%20descent.

          or Huntington's disease etc.

          Where is the clinical (not assumptive) evidence?

          • miravox 12.1.1.1.1
            22 June 2023 at 8:47 am

            I know I said I'd leave it, but just to understand how far you'd accept genetic differences by ethnicity…

            "When this is directly evidenced – it should play a part in diagnostics."

            And treatment that improves the lives of whole communities – not just the diagnosed person? Just one example – would you mind Māori and Pacific people's being at the head of the queue for one of our most common chronic and disabling diseases, i.e. gout?*

            https://bpac.org.nz/bpj/2008/may/docs/bpj13_gout_pages_29-31.pdf

            …Until recently very little information about the genetic basis of hyperuricaemia and gout in any population has been available. … A genetic variant within the GLUT9 gene which encodes for a glucose transporter has been associated with susceptibility to hyperuricaemia and gout… The initial results indicate a higher level of the GLUT9 variant in Māori, which may partly explain why Māori have inherently higher uric acid levels [and Gout]."

            And would you mind more resources, that could prevent gout and associated cardio-vascular disease and T2 Diabetes (and disability and death), being used to prevent gout attacks and disability in Maōri and Pacific communities (currently Māori and Pacific peoples are less likely to receive preventative treatment consistently). Thereby reducing waiting lists for everyone who have these serious health issues e.g. waiting for surgery for heart disease and diabetes-related amputations?

            Because that's the type of ethnicity-related waiting lists/differences in health resources we've been talking about for years and the complications of gout are particularly relevant to the Auckland waiting lists decisions.

            As the Jo Moir article states (and I paraphrase because waiting lists are for all medical conditions – not just the surgery that headlines to stir up public outrage)

            "… if the proportion of Māori and Pasifika on the waitlist exceeds their population percentage then a higher weighting is given to ethnicity… Clinical need is still the first consideration, however."

            *For people aged 20–44 years, the prevalence of identified gout for Māori and Pacific peoples is three and seven times that of non-Māori, non-Pacific populations. (HQSC Gout Atlas)

            • Incognito 12.1.1.1.1.1
              22 June 2023 at 9:12 am

              Thank you.

              There are other examples of genetic differences underlying increased prevalence and poorer prognosis in Māori and Pacifica peoples – more will come to light, as this is an active area of study & research. However, I fear your efforts will be in vain.

            • Molly 12.1.1.1.1.2
              22 June 2023 at 3:26 pm

              This is an attempt to isolate a preponderance of a particular disease amongst Maōri and Pacific communities – and use it to justify an argument for preferential consideration across all diagnoses.

              It is a fundamental flaw, not offset by what you have provided.

              " The initial results indicate a higher level of the GLUT9 variant in Māori, which may partly explain why Māori have inherently higher uric acid levels [and Gout]."

              The gout experienced by non-Maōri and Pacific people, is just as painful, just as debilitating, and just as detrimental to well-being.

              The information you have provided, indicates an option to test everyone who is diagnosed, to see if they have the GLUT9 variant, then their families can be informed. Much as women with the BRCA variant can inform those in their families of their higher risk for breast and ovarian cancer.

              "And would you mind more resources, that could prevent gout and associated cardio-vascular disease and T2 Diabetes (and disability and death), being used to prevent gout attacks and disability in Maōri and Pacific communities" …

              Health resources allocated for prevention should be spent with these outcomes for patients in mind, whether used by Te Whatu Ora, or any other government funded organisation. Access to healthcare providers who receive government funding, should not be limited to patients of certain ethnicities. Or is that what you are suggesting?

              "(currently Māori and Pacific peoples are less likely to receive preventative treatment consistently)."

              And the hard part is figuring out exactly why. Then determining which factors play the biggest part, and also what resources are required to change those factors to produce better outcomes.

              I understand completely that this logical pathway to long term improvement is not one you support.

              You (and others here) prefer to artificially improve the statistical outcomes for Māori and Pacific identified patients – and discount identifying and addressing all the contributors to current outcomes, or the negative impact on other patients with the same clinical profiles.

              So far, so unpersuasive.

              • miravox …
                22 June 2023 at 4:57 pm

                "And the hard part is figuring out exactly why. Then determining which factors play the biggest part, and also what resources are required to change those factors to produce better outcomes.

                I understand completely that this logical pathway to long term improvement is not one you support."

                Ha! that's funny. I have a PhD in doing exactly this. Here's a paper from it. Just so you know I’m not kidding. This is the the administrative data bit – from there, I asked people why they what prevented them early treatment, and what made making appointments difficult. I could see who got a second chance at an appointment if they missed one, and who didn't, I could see primary care providers consider what they termed 'poor behaviours' when they made decisions about who they would refer – because they felt the need to ration referrals. You can take a wild guess on who got the second chance appointments and early referrals.

                TLDR To achieve equitable access and outcomes, I found that health services needed to invest in communities in all sorts of ways, including considering ethnic differences in barriers to care.

                Again, until we can change our economic system, remove institutional racism and change priortising based on the ability to pay (private health care facilities) then the changes Auckland have made in their waiting list prioritisation (noting clinical need comes first) seem eminently practical and ethical to me. Fighting for the scraps is not the way forward, but nor is having another generation of Māori wait at the end of the queue until that happens.

                • Molly …
                  22 June 2023 at 10:34 pm

                  "Conclusion: Non-attendance is associated with ethnicity, age and waiting times. It is likely that high deprivation influences ethnic variations in attendance but reasons for young people's non-attendance were difficult to identify. Patients domiciled further from the main rheumatology clinic were also less likely to attend. The influence of ethnicity and deprivation may be underestimated in this study as high Maori and Pacific ethnic populations live closer to well-resourced clinics. Focusing administrative resources on at-risk groups and restructuring the clinical service to improve uneven waiting times would be expected to improve attendance rates across the region."

                  Your own conclusion has not managed to identify the contributing factors.

                  "Again, until we can change our economic system, remove institutional racism and change priortising based on the ability to pay (private health care facilities)…

                  Eliminate opportunities for institutional racism. Once again, you conflate private care access with equal access to public health.

                  then the changes Auckland have made in their waiting list prioritisation (noting clinical need comes first) seem eminently practical and ethical to me. "

                  Seems eminently political and unethical to me. Clinical needs should be the sole criteria.

                  "Fighting for the scraps is not the way forward, but nor is having another generation of Māori wait at the end of the queue until that happens."

                  You are supporting a fundamentally flawed solution by redirecting in a variety of ways.

                  Despite your research and PhD – I find them all unconvincing.

                  • Incognito …
                    22 June 2023 at 10:52 pm

                    Clinical needs should be the sole criteria.

                    Nope, clinical/health outcomes should be the sole criteria used to guide and justify decision-making. Therefore, ethnicity must be included as a confounding factor. NB this has already shown to improve health inequities in hospitals in Auckland and Northland, which is why it is now rolled out elsewhere too.

                    Your denial and wilful ignorance are inexcusable.

                    • Molly …
                      23 June 2023 at 11:03 am

                      "Your denial and wilful ignorance are inexcusable."

                      I guess I'll have to live with your condemnation.

                    • Incognito []
                      23 June 2023 at 9:44 pm

                      Nope, you’ll have to live with an inexplainable closed-off mind.

                    • miravox …
                      23 June 2023 at 9:53 pm

                      Nope, you’ll have to live with an inexplainable closed-off mind.

                      ^ This.

                    • Molly …
                      24 June 2023 at 9:31 am

                      Having failed to persuade via non-conclusive evidence supporting incoherent reasoning, it all boils down to: "^ This.".

                      laugh

                  • miravox …
                    23 June 2023 at 9:10 am

                    "Your own conclusion has not managed to identify the contributing factors."

                    The conclusion to a paper on administrative data wouldn't do that – it just gives broad categories – like ethnicity and age and location etc. You don't have to agree with me. Just do a google scholar search – I'd suggest "why maori dont get healthcare early"

                    The issue of of ethnic differences in healthcare access is long, but maybe it's getting a bit boring with researchers finding the same things over and over again – you could go back to the 1999 'closing the gaps' to see it was known back then that ethnicity is an important factor in delays to care – over and above socio-economic deprivation. That being Māori and living in socio-econimic deprivation was effectively a double banger for delayed care.

                    Reserchers have focussed on reasons for this situation and how to make equitable adjustments to improve access for people least likely to get early treatment since at least this time. Waiting list adjustments are by no means the only tool being used to do this.

                    "Clinical needs should be the sole criteria."

                    I don't know why you would think that is ever the case in a health system that has to ration it's resources and is staffed by real people with real biases. In an ideal world that might happen – people can turn up with identical problems and the staff, beds and other resources are available for the patients at the same time for surgery or consultation and these are completed for both patients. And the outcomes are the same (meaning their next lot of healthcare is the equally the same).

                    In our world none of that happens. Clinicians make judgements about who gets what when every consultation they have. Who gets referred, who gets surgery first? Is it the mum with no family support? The sole earner who might lose their job? or maybe the patient that needs a tweak to correct the outcome of the first problem.? Of course they make decisions that take into account social and other health circumstances.

                    And because they have to make judgements, clinicians can also (unwittingly maybe) let their biases show. Research has found (see google scholar search list, if you did one) that Māori are disproprtionately affected by this – whether they have a genetic predisposition or not.

                    "You are supporting a fundamentally flawed solution by redirecting in a variety of ways"

                    I take issue with your view I'm redirecting. I've been quite clear I believe we have a fundamentally flawed health system and that waiting lists and choices about where people are on them, is a blunt tool to compensate.

                    And until the system is perfected, my view is that equity is the best we have at compensating.

                    /ENDS.

                    • pat …
                      23 June 2023 at 10:05 am

                      A better use of (increasingly limited) resources for everyone would be to address the causes of the FSA DNA rate…not to reduce the effective throughput of the system by prioritising the non attendant cohort.

                    • Molly …
                      23 June 2023 at 10:59 am

                      "/ENDS."

                      /REBOOTS

                      "The conclusion to a paper on administrative data wouldn't do that – it just gives broad categories – like ethnicity and age and location etc. You don't have to agree with me. Just do a google scholar search – I'd suggest "why maori dont get healthcare early""

                      Sure. First paper is here:

                      https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1470538/

                      "EXPLANATIONS FOR HEALTH DISPARITY

                      A number of different explanations have been suggested for the inequalities in health between Maoris and non-Maoris. One common suggestion is that these differences are due to genetic factors.19 However, about 85% of genetic variation occurs randomly and is not related to race or ethnicity. The striking time trends in Maori mortality and morbidity during the 20th century demonstrate that environmental factors played the major role.20 Thus, although genetic factors may contribute to differences in health status between Maoris and non-Maoris in the case of certain specific conditions, they do not play a major role in population and public health terms.

                      Nongenetic explanations for differences in health between Maoris and non-Maoris can be grouped into 4 major areas focusing on socioeconomic factors, lifestyle factors, access to health care, and discrimination. These explanations are not mutually exclusive, but it is useful to consider them separately while bearing in mind that they are inextricably linked."

                      Now the disccrimination factor is the one that probably is the crux of the current policy. Let's see how that is determined and addressed;

                      The conclusions of this 2006 paper are interesting, especially given that some of concerns about Māori proiders have now been redressed. Funding is stabilised and patient bases should be as established as regular GP appointments

                      So, it seems instead of investigating further – and understanding why these changes have not had marked differences, the assumption of institutional racism takes precedence.

                      What other solutions could be proposed, implemented and measured? A proposal that comes to mind fairly easily, if we are talking prevention rather than ill-conceived "cure".:

                      1. Free yearly checkup for all NZer's to allow early identification of disease or areas of concern, Many people get this through workplaces, but not all and not typically those in lower-income employment and definitely those not employed. This would be a full bloodworks, and any other regular screening process. Train phlebotemists and other personnel to the level required to do this annual check – recording of blood pressure, weight, etc. People will only be called in if there are anomalies, and they should also be able to access the results themselves,
                      2. Make such checkups – and other services such as after-care – more accessible to shift-workers by having evening or weekend clinics.

                      We need a better health service for all.

                      ""Clinical needs should be the sole criteria.""

                      Fair enough that you point out this is not the sole criteria, i should have said the priority criteria, and pointed out that the standard resourcing constraints apply.

                      But it is interesting that your focus is on unconscious bias, and so your conclusion is to offset that with "conscious bias" for treatment.

                      "And until the system is perfected, my view is that equity is the best we have at compensating."

                      Your equity is based on assumption that ethnicity is THE reason that Māori can't see over the fence. I don't think your assumption is necessarily true. None of the recommendations you have made or provided actually isolate ethnicity or bias as the main contributing factors.

                      The solution is a poor attempt to redress an unknown and unevidenced factor – and call it racism when this is pointed out.

                    • miravox …
                      23 June 2023 at 11:51 am

                      A better use of (increasingly limited) resources for everyone would be to address the causes of the FSA DNA rate…not to reduce the effective throughput of the system by prioritising the non attendant cohort.

                      Hi Pat,

                      From administrative data, the standout reason for Māori FSA non-attendance in my field is long waiting times. Māori are likely to have been waiting longer to even get on the waiting list. Go figure.

                      Of course there are other reasons, and there are various ways these are being addressed, and yes, some of these are tailored to ethniticy, and also to other factors like age, rurality and gender.

                      Meanwhile – what to do about Māori (and Pacific peoples) who are over-represented, popoulation-wise on waiting lists, and have probably taken longer to get on the list in the first place. I support an equity approach that Auckland has taken to address this.

                    • pat …
                      23 June 2023 at 1:48 pm

                      Hi Miravox

                      From a public health user perspective getting a FSA (and subsequently joining a waiting list) is an unmeasured.

                      Referrals for basic investigation, nevermind specialist appraisal are regularly declined due to a lack of capacity….the circumstance of those declined is not known .

                      This is (again) not a policy designed to address the health issues of the community but a political statement.

                    • miravox …
                      23 June 2023 at 2:17 pm

                      Hi Pat

                      You might be better discussing your view with Duncan Bliss, Director Adult Surgery – ORLHN, OMS, ARHSD, Neurosurgery, Orthopaedics, Ophthalmology.. His data-driven view is: [my bold]

                      When Moir spoke to one of the people behind the algorithm, Te Toka Tumai surgical services manager Duncan Bliss, he told her that there was no arguing that what ethnicity you are has an impact on what sort of healthcare you get in New Zealand.

                      In every piece of data from the health system, Māori and Pasifika people were falling behind, he said.

                      "I said to him, 'Did you take into consideration how [the algorithm] would be received? Have you been surprised by the backlash that's come from this?'

                      "And his response to me was, 'Well, we haven't looked at it from race … it was based on data. We come at these things from a health perspective, we don't come at it from a political one',"

                      Maybe he can tell you whether he got his data from administrative systems of political actors.

                      DHBs might not be able to afford to do the research into such things who has who has been waiting longest, where they come from, and why, but doctors are often academics too, and use those resources, using a variety of methods, to investigate disparities in healthcare.

                    • pat …
                      23 June 2023 at 2:41 pm

                      Claiming political indifference dosnt make it so….if the policy is solely data driven then it should have been rejected as the data clearly shows it will make the system less efficient.

                    • miravox …
                      23 June 2023 at 2:54 pm

                      Claiming political indifference dosnt make it so….if the policy is solely data driven then it should have been rejected as the data clearly shows it will make the system less efficient

                      1. I think you're mixing up the fact that some people will use data as a political statement and some people will use data to improve systems despite others using it to sow dissent rather than understanding.

                      2. Can you give me a link that in your considered view will tell me how and why "the data clearly shows it will make the the system less efficient"?

                    • pat …
                      23 June 2023 at 4:02 pm

                      You provided the link yourself Miravox.

                      If you have a limited capacity to screen (as we do) and you increase the proportion of screenees who have a greater propensity to not attend you must decrease your throughput…and reduced screening throughput flows through to a reduced successful (treatment) outcome….do the math.

                      Data.

                    • miravox …
                      23 June 2023 at 4:19 pm

                      Really? That's a callous way of looking at things.

                      That data shows we need to do more to reduce barriers and improve access, not to leave a whole bunch of people on the healthcare scrap heap! – for people with long waiting times, one of those things was as simple as sending reminders (which is pretty routine now) before the appointments, given how far away the appointments are.

                      For others its to ensure the timing of the appointment fits within their employment commitments, to ask if the patient has transport/childcare and ensure they understand there importance of the appointment (i.e. improving health literacy).

                      A win-win for patients and EDs (which would have to deal with very sick patients who end up there because they were struck of the list).

                    • pat …
                      23 June 2023 at 5:13 pm

                      It is not callous…it is data driven (as the good doctor claimed)

                      What the data suggests is we need to address the causes of DNAs to FSAs and that will lead to an improved effective use of limited resources AND better outcomes for Maori and Pacifica (and young people, rural people and all those with a greater than average propensity to attend FSAs)

                    • miravox …
                      23 June 2023 at 5:21 pm

                      What the data suggests is we need to address the causes of DNAs to FSAs and that will lead to an improved effective use of limited resources AND better outcomes for Maori and Pacifica (and young people, rural people and all those with a greater than average propensity to attend FSAs)

                      That doesn't mean whe knock people off the waiting list. That means we address the causes of non-attendance so they (especially Māori and Pasifika and others with problems attending) can attend! Jeez.

                    • pat …
                      23 June 2023 at 5:35 pm

                      That means we dont try and solve a problem of non attendance by increasing the proportion of non attendees to pre treatment assessment …jeeez.

                      Talk about trying to solve a problem by ignoring the cause.

                    • miravox …
                      23 June 2023 at 9:19 pm

                      I'm sorry but we're miles apart in our interpretation of this subject that there is no point at all in continuing the conversation.

                    • pat …
                      23 June 2023 at 10:18 pm

                      It would appear so

                      I support changes that improve the effectiveness of a limited resource and you appear more concerned with making political statements.

      • Shanreagh 12.1.2
        21 June 2023 at 7:04 pm

        They used to look at families and earners before in an ad hoc manner ……another reason why for me as a mostly single person earning my priority was to keep myself earning. Having a health insurance was a way of doing this as well as keeping out of the public health system so others could access it.

    • weka 12.2
      21 June 2023 at 5:02 pm

      except there are people in all generations that live under those conditions.

    • SPC 12.3
      21 June 2023 at 11:16 pm

      Life expectancy is still on the upward trend. And there are no forecasts saying otherwise.

      Housing standards are not in decline (legislative requirements). And despite aggregate health supply demand factors being a concern, there are constant advances in medicine.

      Debt levels to GDP are not high by historic standards, but low. And not even with the cost of super to boomers will that change (there is $60B in the Cullen Fund)

      Whether Generation X and Y support the continuation of tax paid super is a decision that they will make – atm no one is proposing a move to contribution based super and means tested pensions which is the alternative.

      There will be a local capacity shortage of care to old boomers – lack of carers 9But hat is resolved by willingness to use migrants). But that is because of a demographic bulge – this does not apply to those of the younger generations (and is resolved by use of migrants as we do with medical staff).

      And while the impact of rising sea levels and more extreme weather events during the 21st C might well become greater than one of coastal erosion and inability to insure housing in flood prone areas, it's unlikely to impact on the working life period (more one of waiting for the retirement village to become a coastal resort).

      The real problem might be coping with the stress of being unable to save to own property and lack of rental security (one answer is long term housing supply by Investment Funds). There are political solutions, make sure the next Labour government has progressive tax and incomes policies.

  13. pat 13
    21 June 2023 at 6:00 pm

    I note the title of this post …Winning Ugly.

    It is the opposite…we are 'losing ugly' and its time to recognise the fact

    • Patricia Bremner 13.1
      21 June 2023 at 7:12 pm

      Winning ugly refers to Dirty Politics and Hollow Men, good descriptions of characters who fight ugly/dirty.sad

      • pat 13.1.1
        21 June 2023 at 7:25 pm

        Winning ugly in this post refers to abandoning the fundamental principle of treating everyone the same regardless of wealth, intellect, race or culture etc so as to atempt to retain the levers of power for a further 3 years so as to acheive SFA as has been demonstrated for the past 6.

        You can dress it up any way you like but that is the guts of it.

        • Shanreagh 13.1.1.1
          21 June 2023 at 7:47 pm

          Wow Pat yours and Corey's posts (at 4.24pm) are the most heartfelt and sad I have read for a while…….

          Thank you both.

          Yes holding on the levers of power, and what for, so we can throw out or abandon policies that will/may frighten the horses and hold on to the levers of power for another 3 years after this?

          • pat 13.1.1.1.1
            21 June 2023 at 7:54 pm

            "attempt"

            • adam 13.1.1.1.1.1
              22 June 2023 at 2:13 am

              Come on pat get real, the Tories are a leaderless mess at best, self interested to a fault and so far up their masters back passage it's xmas.

              Not saying labour much better, but I'm voting the maori party just to give all those corporate dogs the shits.

              • Shanreagh …
                22 June 2023 at 2:08 pm

                Good onya Adam.

              • pat …
                22 June 2023 at 2:41 pm

                "Come on pat get real, the Tories are a leaderless mess at best, self interested to a fault and so far up their masters back passage it's xmas."

                The 'real' that should concern you greatest is the fact that over 70% of those who intend to vote are willing to do so for organisations that consistently demonstrate a complete lack of ability to address the issues which afflict us.

            • Shanreagh 13.1.1.1.1.2
              22 June 2023 at 2:11 pm

              Yes Pat 'attempt' is much better and so having been circumspect, non threatening and therefore non adventurous for another three years where does that get us?

  14. Shanreagh 14
    23 June 2023 at 12:54 pm

    @ Molly

    The conclusions of this 2006 paper are interesting, especially given that some of concerns about Māori proiders have now been redressed. Funding is stabilised and patient bases should be as established as regular GP appointments

    So, it seems instead of investigating further – and understanding why these changes have not had marked differences, the assumption of institutional racism takes precedence.

    Yes this seems to be the case. Identify the problem, do nothing to follow up the findings and if called upon blame it on racism.

    Though in some cases there have been successes with strong marae based access. This goes only so far. Clinics and visiting specialists are great. But still for treatment many need to travel to access something that may alleviate symptoms. This happens for all rural dwellers and in areas where Maori are the majority in rural dwellers. Have they done studies on rural dwellers taking the next steps?

    Two interesting papers/thoughts in Stuff today 23/6/23

    Prof Dr Peter Davis who has been a researcher in health related population based issues for many years

    https://www.stuff.co.nz/opinion/132396631/using-ethnicity-to-decide-hospital-waitlists-doesnt-solve-the-real-issues

    So this is not just about hospital waiting lists. It is about issues of inequality and legitimacy in health more broadly and goes to the heart of our political and decision-making system.

    …

    It is estimated that maybe 20% of differences in health outcomes are due to health and medical care. So, if we want to reduce inequalities between ethnic groups, we should be looking at factors like housing, income, education, alcohol, smoking, diet, injury and so on.

    This does not let the health system off the hook, but it does bring home that fundamentally we have to look at wider social and economic policy.

    …

    It is striking that even corporates and conservative politicians are starting to lend weight to this argument: thus the UK president of Danone a major food corporate urges taxes on unhealthy foods, and a former UK Conservative Prime Minister, William Hague, argues that we should be treating our ultra-processed salt- and sugar-laden diet as we have tobacco.

    But the health system does have a major role to play, particularly for disadvantaged groups. In particular, as we would hope, it is well established that people who are registered with a family doctor are less likely to die of causes of death that are amenable to medical treatment.

    And yet, one of the most striking items of information I witnessed on the ADHB was the very high proportion of Maori and Pacific children who ended up in hospital despite suffering from conditions that were treatable in primary care.

    …

    In other words, we have a problem in the organisation, funding, and access of our community and primary care health services: far too many of our most disadvantaged groups are just not getting the care that would prevent hospital admissions and extend their healthful lives.

    When I worked in health in the 1990s (RHA) we looked at setting up GP clinics at hospitals to siphon off the common presenting GP-type issues, we encouraged clinics on marae, after hours clinics, Rongoa Maori.

    Since then work has been done to lessen payment, which had been identified as an issue. I have seen reports of a number of studies saying there are issues accessing primary health care but not very many seem to drill down and look at why? Are any of these initiatives still going? What were the conclusions?

    I do know that at the time there was a quiet/unstated resistance (primary & hospital care levels) to looking at population based funding/demographics and working to what that told us, particularly in areas where there was a high Maori population.

    Crudely, at that time, it seemed every hospital wanted the latest whizz bang technology, very few were interested in working as a centre of excellence or even just meeting the need for interventions, in Maori child health needs, or adolescent psychiatric conditions, family health. In the parlance of the time these were just not 'sexy'. We had a clinical leader at the time who said that depsite the need to fix our whole society really, that scope existed within the health sector for innovative work to ensure health needs were met especially in community and primary health care as Prof Davis is saying.

    Also in Stuff is this article

    https://www.stuff.co.nz/opinion/132392765/fairness-and-the-lack-of-transparency-about-elective-surgery

    Professor John McMillan is chair of the National Ethics Advisory Committee (NEAC) and editor in chief of The Journal of Medical Ethics (JME).

    I am grateful to see input on the ethical side of this.

    While he thinks that equity adjusters may work well he states

    But how can anyone reach an informed view about whether the equity adjusters are fair when they are not made publicly available? The lack of transparency about what they are and how they operate within algorithms creates an opening for those who want to discuss them in a negative way.

    …

    This problem is not confined to the equity adjusters; the elective treatment algorithms themselves are not as transparent as they once were.

    …

    We led the world in developing Clinical Priority Assessment Criteria (CPACs), and scoring systems were created for a range of elective treatments.

    CPACs drew upon the views of specialists about how patient need should be assessed. Then there was a national process where specialists within fields such as orthopaedics, cardiology and ophthalmology agreed the clinical criteria and how they should be weighted.

    …

    Prioritisation decisions involve deciding which patient should be treated first out of a set of patients who need treatment. While these are “clinical” judgments, they’re also fundamentally ethical judgments and, given the likelihood of reasonable disagreement about who should be treated first and for which reason, fairness requires that decisions are made in a consistent way using transparent criteria.

    The centrality of transparency for the fairness of publicly funded health care systems has been described in the British Medical Journal as accountability for reasonableness.

    Linking (my links) to the article about reasonableness highlights that

    To hold decision makers accountable for the reasonableness of their decisions, we have argued that the process must be public (fully transparent) about the grounds for its decisions; the decision must rest on reasons that stakeholders can agree are relevant; decisions should be revisable in light of new evidence and arguments; and there should be assurance through enforcement that these conditions (publicity, relevance, and revisability) are met.

    https://www.bmj.com/content/337/bmj.a1850

    Prof McMillan concludes

    This current heated discussion of equity adjusters has been fuelled by our losing sight of the importance of accountability and transparency when prioritising elective health care.

    I think the concern about the way the algorithms may be used has arisen because we do not know how they were developed, how they will be used etc. So their use falls over at a very early stage as there seemingly is not widespread knowledge about them,

    Just looking in from away it seems to me that this crude index may be a culmination of stalled, uncompleted, unacknowledged work across the health sectors on barriers to primary health care. Also we do not have any indication, that I have seen, whether access, including ethnicity being dealt with by special clinics, would have meant the ability to treat earlier in the ilness ie before they got to a hospital waiting list stage.

    Waiting lists and the people and conditions that have their lives tied up on them used to be intensively managed, it is hugely administrative and a mix of clercial and clinical expertise. With the clerical expertise needed it does fall into thos areas of not being 'sexy' and 'bureaucrats' and 'midddle management' and 'we need nurses' arguments.

    Actually you need both. Some work that was done a million years ago indicated that each surgeon. specialist operated, in the widest sense of the word, effectively with an average of 7 support people throughout the system. Clearly they'd share a part of the waiting list managers & their staff.

    This is this is the article about the CPACs.

    https://www.bmj.com/content/suppl/1999/02/04/314.7074.131.DC1

    Developed under the auspices of the Regional Health Authorities back in the day, as were the demographics and most of the studies I have mentioned here. Hopefully, finally, Te Whatu Ora will be able to build on the start made by this group.

    • Molly 14.1
      24 June 2023 at 9:07 am

      @Shanreagh

      Thanks for that. Very interesting reading, and salient points to the topic at hand.

      Your work in the health sector seems to be recorded in the 2006 paper I looked at above after miravox's recommendation:

      https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1470538/

      I had a couple of friends work in marae based primary care, and it seemed chaotic – whether due to funding issues, the expected disruption of new organisations before systems are established, or something other – I don't know.

      What did attract patients to register, was the fees free service.

      I come from a family with Maori ancestry on both maternal and paternal sides. However, there is a closer connection to marae etc from my mother's side.

      There is also a noticeable difference in personal motivation to see access healthcare between the two groups of relatives – which includes follow up when something is identified.

      .y family is large – over 70 first cousins on the maternal side, and around 27 on the other. So while not conclusive, it may indicate possible places to concentrate research to identify the reasons for such reticence.

      I'm basically a solutions person. I also want there to be no disparity in health outcomes – I just believe this is not only the wrong way to achieve it, but also yet another policy that feeds division.

      I'm warming towards the idea of a free, full annual workup – that would reduce some of the more expensive costs of treating advanced stages of disease if identified earlier, regular monitoring of our children's health, and making this yearly occurrence as accepted as possible.

      Specifically trained personnel – not fully trained nurses, could do most – if not all – of the assessment processes.

      All NZers would have a personal reference for their own health indicators.

      • Shanreagh 14.1.1
        24 June 2023 at 6:13 pm

        I'm warming towards the idea of a free, full annual workup – that would reduce some of the more expensive costs of treating advanced stages of disease if identified earlier, regular monitoring of our children's health, and making this yearly occurrence as accepted as possible.

        I think this is a great idea too.

        How do we deliver it? Have multiple ways and non threatening ways I am picking

        I also want there to be no disparity in health outcomes – I just believe this is not only the wrong way to achieve it, but also yet another policy that feeds division.

        I agree with this. Apparently the CPAC concept did stirling work, was publicly available and the able to be tested. Why is something like this not being updated? To me the Auckland scenario seems a bit (lot) kneejerk especially when well known 'elders' in the public health and medical ethics world have some concerns.

        I rank Prof Peter Davis highly.

  15. Drowsy M. Kram 15
    24 June 2023 at 11:20 am

    Imho, an adequate explanation for some of the opposition to positive discrimination / affirmative action programmes that aim to improve health outcomes for Māori and Pasifika communities in Aotearoa NZ can be found in this NZMJ article.

    Pākehā/Palangi positionality: disentangling power and paralysis
    [2 Sept 2022; PDF]
    Until Pākehā/Palangi recognise our power is strengthened by racist systems we will continue to look outside of ourselves for solutions rather than within.
    …
    “Proactive, mutually supportive, and innovative relationships between Tangata Whenua and Tangata Tiriti are our future. We should embrace the change and reflect it within our new outcome-focused and equitable health system.” [ – Sharon Shea]

    Individual and systemic (institutional/national) racial bias can be mutually-reinforcing. If observations of bias and iniquitous outcomes seem too close to home, it may be helpful to consider relevant health systems research and perspectives from other countries.

    Equity, Diversity & Inclusion: Race, Ethnicity & Culture [Toronto Uni]
    This Libguide is about equality, diversity, and inclusion in healthcare.

    Researching unconscious bias in health care – Michelle van Ryn, Ph.D. [2:34 mins]

    Affirmative action and equity in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health [Sept 2005]
    The most obvious difficulty faced by Indigenous people who are beneficiaries of affirmative action is the self-doubt stemming from accusations that we do not merit such support. Unfortunately, it appears that many Australians still think Indigenous people get “too many benefits”. In one survey, almost a third of participants believed that car loans are paid for us by the government, and almost two-thirds thought that we receive more social security benefits than non-Indigenous people. In another survey, more than half of respondents believed Indigenous people were “treated over generously by the government”. The hostility to affirmative action programs, which is compounded by these misconceptions, can only be reduced through education that explains the benefits of diversity and the need to remedy historical injustice.

    Partnership for Justice in Health:
    Scoping Paper on Race, Racism and the Australian Health System         [May 2021; PDF]
    However, what is not considered here is the extent to which those very same organisations subscribing to the notion of a ‘representative organisation’ remain institutionally racist. High attrition rates such as seen in the teaching profession and examples of racial discrimination, as documented by Aboriginal police officer Veronica Gorrie in her memoir ‘Black and Blue’, suggest that unless institutions take steps to address racism within their own ranks, the ‘representative organisation’ approach will remain largely a ‘tick box’ exercise that effects no substantive change.

    I'm lumbered with several unreasonable personal biases that are so deeply ingrained they cannot be purged – all I can do is counteract them as best I can when they arise.
    If only I could counteract the biases that I'm unaware of – best of luck there.

  16. Shanreagh 16
    24 June 2023 at 6:31 pm

    I'm lumbered with several unreasonable personal biases that are so deeply ingrained they cannot be purged – all I can do is counteract them as best I can when they arise.
    If only I could counteract the biases that I'm unaware of – best of luck there.

    Thank you Drowsy. Very interesting links.

    I actually don't believe that the critiques by the people here and the ones I have linked to are personal biases. Certainly I know the work by Davis/McMillan is scholarly and Peter Davis is achieving doyen status as far as being a voice for funding being allocated from population or epidemiological work.

    Molly/me have a difference with the Auckland model on its benefits/ability to deliver while Miravox comes from the other way. I don't think any of us are expressing bias in a pejorative sense.

    As far as your last sentence is concerned, with a HR hat on, you would be the expressing the view that there is knowledge that you don't know..i.e 'knows what they don't know'. It will sing out a cautionary note as you have found, you know there are 'unaware biases'. This trait is a most desirable one for an employee to have…..And for a colleague poster here on TS to have. smiley

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

  • Bernard’s Saturday Soliloquy for the week to July 27

    Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāTL;DR: My top six things to note around housing, climate and poverty in Aotearoa’s political economy in the week to July 27 were:1. The Minister for Ford Rangers strikes againTransport Minister Simeon Brown was again the busiest of the Cabinet ministers this week, announcing an ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    26 mins ago
  • Ticket To Anywhere

    You got a fast carAnd I want a ticket to anywhereMaybe we make a dealMaybe together we can get somewhereAny place is betterYesterday’s newsletter, Trust In Me, on the report of abuse in state care, and by religious organisations, between 1950 and 2019, coupled with the hypocrisy of Christopher Luxon ...
    Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel
    1 hour ago
  • Stories of varying weight

    Hello! Here comes the Saturday edition of More Than A Feilding, catching you up on anything you may have missed. Share Read more ...
    More Than A FeildingBy David Slack
    6 hours ago
  • Balancing External Security and the Economy

    New Zealand is again having to reconcile conflicting pressures from its military and its trade interests. Should we join Pillar Two of AUKUS and risk compromising our markets in China? For a century after New Zealand was founded in 1840, its external security arrangements and external economics arrangements were aligned. ...
    PunditBy Brian Easton
    18 hours ago
  • Weekly Climate Wrap: The unravelling of the offsets

    The ‘50 Shades of Green’ farmers’ protest in 2019 was heavy on climate change denial, but five years on, scepticism and criticism about the idea that pine forests can save us is growing across the board. File photo: Lynn GrievesonTL;DR: Here’s the top six news items of note in climate ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    23 hours ago
  • What makes us tick

    This morning the sky was bright.The birds, in their usual joyous bliss. Nature doesn’t seem to feel the heat of what might angst humans.Their calls are clear and beautiful.Just some random thoughts:MāoriPaul Goldsmith has announced his government will roll back the judiciary’s rulings on Māori Customary Marine Title, which recognises ...
    Mountain TuiBy Mountain Tui
    1 day ago
  • Foreshore and seabed 2.0

    In 2003, the Court of Appeal delivered its decision in Ngati Apa v Attorney-General, ruling that Māori customary title over the foreshore and seabed had not been universally extinguished, and that the Māori Land Court could determine claims and confirm title if the facts supported it. This kicked off the ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 day ago
  • Gordon Campbell on the Royal Commission report into abuse in care

    Earlier this week at Parliament, Labour leader Chris Hipkins was applauded for saying that the response to the final report of the Royal Commission of Inquiry into Abuse in Care had to be “bigger than politics.” True, but the fine words, apologies and “we hear you” messages will soon ring ...
    WerewolfBy lyndon
    1 day ago
  • The Kākā’s Pick 'n' Mix for Friday, July 26

    TL;DR: In news breaking this morning:The Ministry of Education is cutting $2 billion from its school building programme so the National-ACT-NZ First Coalition Government has enough money to deliver tax cuts; The Government has quietly lowered its child poverty reduction targets to make them easier to achieve;Te Whatu Ora-Health NZ’s ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    1 day ago
  • Weekly Roundup 26-July-2024

    Kia ora. These are some stories that caught our eye this week – as always, feel free to share yours in the comments. Our header image this week (via Eke Panuku) shows the planned upgrade for the Karanga Plaza Tidal Swimming Steps. The week in Greater Auckland On ...
    Greater AucklandBy Greater Auckland
    1 day ago
  • God what a relief

    1. What's not to love about the way the Harris campaign is turning things around?a. Nothingb. Love all of itc. God what a reliefd. Not that it will be by any means easye. All of the above 2. Documents released by the Ministry of Health show Associate Health Minister Casey ...
    More Than A FeildingBy David Slack
    1 day ago
  • Trust In Me

    Trust in me in all you doHave the faith I have in youLove will see us through, if only you trust in meWhy don't you, you trust me?In a week that saw the release of the 3,000 page Abuse in Care report Christopher Luxon was being asked about Boot Camps. ...
    Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel
    1 day ago
  • The Hoon around the week to July 26

    TL;DR: The podcast above of the weekly ‘hoon’ webinar for paying subscribers last night features co-hosts and talking about the Royal Commission Inquiry into Abuse in Care report released this week, and with:The Kākā’s climate correspondent on a UN push to not recognise carbon offset markets and ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    1 day ago
  • The Kākā’s Journal of Record for Friday, July 26

    TL;DR: As of 6:00 am on Friday, July 26, the top six announcements, speeches, reports and research around housing, climate and poverty in Aotearoa’s political economy in the last day are:Transport: Simeon Brown announced $802.9 million in funding for 18 new trains on the Wairarapa and Manawatū rail lines, which ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    1 day ago
  • Radical law changes needed to build road

    The northern expressway extension from Warkworth to Whangarei is likely to require radical changes to legislation if it is going to be built within the foreseeable future. The Government’s powers to purchase land, the planning process and current restrictions on road tolling are all going to need to be changed ...
    PolitikBy Richard Harman
    1 day ago
  • Skeptical Science New Research for Week #30 2024

    Open access notables Could an extremely cold central European winter such as 1963 happen again despite climate change?, Sippel et al., Weather and Climate Dynamics: Here, we first show based on multiple attribution methods that a winter of similar circulation conditions to 1963 would still lead to an extreme seasonal ...
    Skeptical Science
    2 days ago
  • First they came for the Māori

    Text within this block will maintain its original spacing when publishedFirst they came for the doctors But I was confused by the numbers and costs So I didn't speak up Then they came for our police and nurses And I didn't think we could afford those costs anyway So I ...
    Mountain TuiBy Mountain Tui
    2 days ago
  • Join us for the weekly Hoon on YouTube Live

    Photo by Joshua J. Cotten on UnsplashWe’re back again after our mid-winter break. We’re still with the ‘new’ day of the week (Thursday rather than Friday) when we have our ‘hoon’ webinar with paying subscribers to The Kākā for an hour at 5 pm.Jump on this link on YouTube Livestream ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    2 days ago
  • Will the real PM Luxon please stand up?

    Notes: This is a free article. Abuse in Care themes are mentioned. Video is at the bottom.BackgroundYesterday’s report into Abuse in Care revealed that at least 1 in 3 of all who went through state and faith based care were abused - often horrifically. At least, because not all survivors ...
    Mountain TuiBy Mountain Tui
    2 days ago
  • Will debt reduction trump abuse in care redress?

    Luxon speaks in Parliament yesterday about the Abuse in Care report. Photo: Hagen Hopkins/Getty ImagesTL;DR: The top six things I’ve noted around housing, climate and poverty in Aotearoa’s political economy today are:PM Christopher Luxon said yesterday in tabling the Abuse in Care report in Parliament he wanted to ‘do the ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    2 days ago
  • Olywhites and Time Bandits

    About a decade ago I worked with a bloke called Steve. He was the grizzled veteran coder, a few years older than me, who knew where the bodies were buried - code wise. Despite his best efforts to be approachable and friendly he could be kind of gruff, through to ...
    Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel
    2 days ago
  • Why were the 1930s so hot in North America?

    This is a re-post from Yale Climate Connections by Jeff Masters and Bob Henson Those who’ve trawled social media during heat waves have likely encountered a tidbit frequently used to brush aside human-caused climate change: Many U.S. states and cities had their single hottest temperature on record during the 1930s, setting incredible heat marks ...
    Skeptical Science
    2 days ago
  • Throwback Thursday – Thinking about Expressways

    Some of the recent announcements from the government have reminded us of posts we’ve written in the past. Here’s one from early 2020. There were plenty of reactions to the government’s infrastructure announcement a few weeks ago which saw them fund a bunch of big roading projects. One of ...
    Greater AucklandBy Greater Auckland
    2 days ago
  • The Kākā’s Pick 'n' Mix for Thursday, July 25

    TL;DR: My pick of the top six links elsewhere around housing, climate and poverty in Aotearoa’s political economy in the last day or so to 7:00 am on Thursday, July 25 are:News: Why Electric Kiwi is closing to new customers - and why it matters RNZ’s Susan EdmundsScoop: Government drops ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    2 days ago
  • The Possum: Demon or Friend?

    Hi,I felt a small wet tongue snaking through one of the holes in my Crocs. It explored my big toe, darting down one side, then the other. “He’s looking for some toe cheese,” said the woman next to me, words that still haunt me to this day.Growing up in New ...
    David FarrierBy David Farrier
    2 days ago
  • Not a story

    Yesterday I happily quoted the Prime Minister without fact-checking him and sure enough, it turns out his numbers were all to hell. It’s not four kg of Royal Commission report, it’s fourteen.My friend and one-time colleague-in-comms Hazel Phillips gently alerted me to my error almost as soon as I’d hit ...
    More Than A FeildingBy David Slack
    2 days ago
  • The Kākā’s Journal of Record for Thursday, July 25

    TL;DR: As of 6:00 am on Thursday, July 25, the top six announcements, speeches, reports and research around housing, climate and poverty in Aotearoa’s political economy in the last day were:The Abuse in Care Royal Commission of Inquiry published its final report yesterday.PM Christopher Luxon and The Minister responsible for ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    2 days ago
  • A tougher line on “proactive release”?

    The Official Information Act has always been a battle between requesters seeking information, and governments seeking to control it. Information is power, so Ministers and government agencies want to manage what is released and when, for their own convenience, and legality and democracy be damned. Their most recent tactic for ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    3 days ago
  • 'Let's build a motorway costing $100 million per km, before emissions costs'

    TL;DR: The top six things I’ve noted around housing, climate and poverty in Aotearoa’s political economy today are:Transport and Energy Minister Simeon Brown is accelerating plans to spend at least $10 billion through Public Private Partnerships (PPPs) to extend State Highway One as a four-lane ‘Expressway’ from Warkworth to Whangarei ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    3 days ago
  • Lester's Prescription – Positive Bleeding.

    I live my life (woo-ooh-ooh)With no control in my destinyYea-yeah, yea-yeah (woo-ooh-ooh)I can bleed when I want to bleedSo come on, come on (woo-ooh-ooh)You can bleed when you want to bleedYea-yeah, come on (woo-ooh-ooh)Everybody bleed when they want to bleedCome on and bleedGovernments face tough challenges. Selling unpopular decisions to ...
    Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel
    3 days ago
  • Casey Costello gaslights Labour in the House

    Please note:To skip directly to the- parliamentary footage in the video, scroll to 1:21 To skip to audio please click on the headphone icon on the left hand side of the screenThis video / audio section is under development. ...
    Mountain TuiBy Mountain Tui
    3 days ago
  • Why is the Texas grid in such bad shape?

    This is a re-post from the Climate Brink by Andrew Dessler Headline from 2021 The Texas grid, run by ERCOT, has had a rough few years. In 2021, winter storm Uri blacked out much of the state for several days. About a week ago, Hurricane Beryl knocked out ...
    Skeptical Science
    3 days ago
  • Gordon Campbell on a textbook case of spending waste by the Luxon government

    Given the crackdown on wasteful government spending, it behooves me to point to a high profile example of spending by the Luxon government that looks like a big, fat waste of time and money. I’m talking about the deployment of NZDF personnel to support the US-led coalition in the Red ...
    WerewolfBy lyndon
    3 days ago
  • The Kākā’s Pick 'n' Mix for Wednesday, July 24

    TL;DR: My pick of the top six links elsewhere around housing, climate and poverty in Aotearoa’s political economy in the last day or so to 7:40 am on Wednesday, July 24 are:Deep Dive: Chipping away at the housing crisis, including my comments RNZ/Newsroom’s The DetailNews: Government softens on asset sales, ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    3 days ago
  • LXR Takaanini

    As I reported about the city centre, Auckland’s rail network is also going through a difficult and disruptive period which is rapidly approaching a culmination, this will result in a significant upgrade to the whole network. Hallelujah. Also like the city centre this is an upgrade predicated on the City ...
    Greater AucklandBy Patrick Reynolds
    3 days ago
  • Four kilograms of pain

    Today, a 4 kilogram report will be delivered to Parliament. We know this is what the report of the Royal Commission of Inquiry into Abuse in State and Faith-based Care weighs, because our Prime Minister told us so.Some reporter had blindsided him by asking a question about something done by ...
    More Than A FeildingBy David Slack
    3 days ago
  • The Kākā’s Journal of Record for Wednesday, July 24

    TL;DR: As of 7:00 am on Wednesday, July 24, the top six announcements, speeches, reports and research around housing, climate and poverty in Aotearoa’s political economy in the last day are:Beehive: Transport Minister Simeon Brown announced plans to use PPPs to fund, build and run a four-lane expressway between Auckland ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    3 days ago
  • Luxon gets caught out

    NewstalkZB host Mike Hosking, who can usually be relied on to give Prime Minister Christopher Luxon an easy run, did not do so yesterday when he interviewed him about the HealthNZ deficit. Luxon is trying to use a deficit reported last year by HealthNZ as yet another example of the ...
    PolitikBy Richard Harman
    3 days ago
  • A worrying sign

    Back in January a StatsNZ employee gave a speech at Rātana on behalf of tangata whenua in which he insulted and criticised the government. The speech clearly violated the principle of a neutral public service, and StatsNZ started an investigation. Part of that was getting an external consultant to examine ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    4 days ago
  • Are we fine with 47.9% home-ownership by 2048?

    Renting for life: Shared ownership initiatives are unlikely to slow the slide in home ownership by much. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāTL;DR: The top six things I’ve noted around housing, climate and poverty in Aotearoa’s political economy today are:A Deloitte report for Westpac has projected Aotearoa’s home-ownership rate will ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    4 days ago
  • Let's Win This

    You're broken down and tiredOf living life on a merry go roundAnd you can't find the fighterBut I see it in you so we gonna walk it outAnd move mountainsWe gonna walk it outAnd move mountainsAnd I'll rise upI'll rise like the dayI'll rise upI'll rise unafraidI'll rise upAnd I'll ...
    Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel
    4 days ago
  • Waimahara: The Singing Spirit of Water

    There’s been a change in Myers Park. Down the steps from St. Kevin’s Arcade, past the grassy slopes, the children’s playground, the benches and that goat statue, there has been a transformation. The underpass for Mayoral Drive has gone from a barren, grey, concrete tunnel, to a place that thrums ...
    Greater AucklandBy Connor Sharp
    4 days ago
  • A major milestone: Global climate pollution may have just peaked

    This is a re-post from Yale Climate Connections Global society may have finally slammed on the brakes for climate-warming pollution released by human fossil fuel combustion. According to the Carbon Monitor Project, the total global climate pollution released between February and May 2024 declined slightly from the amount released during the same ...
    Skeptical Science
    4 days ago
  • The Kākā’s Pick 'n' Mix for Tuesday, July 23

    TL;DR: My pick of the top six links elsewhere around housing, climate and poverty in Aotearoa’s political economy in the last day or so to 7:00 am on Tuesday, July 23 are:Deep Dive: Penlink: where tolling rhetoric meets reality BusinessDesk-$$$’s Oliver LewisScoop: Te Pūkenga plans for regional polytechs leak out ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    4 days ago
  • The Kākā’s Journal of Record for Tuesday, July 23

    TL;DR: As of 6:00 am on Tuesday, July 23, the top six announcements, speeches, reports and research around housing, climate and poverty in Aotearoa’s political economy in the last day are:Health: Shane Reti announced the Board of Te Whatu Ora- Health New Zealand was being replaced with Commissioner Lester Levy ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    4 days ago
  • HealthNZ and Luxon at cross purposes over budget blowout

    Health NZ warned the Government at the end of March that it was running over Budget. But the reasons it gave were very different to those offered by the Prime Minister yesterday. Prime Minister Christopher Luxon blamed the “botched merger” of the 20 District Health Boards (DHBs) to create Health ...
    PolitikBy Richard Harman
    4 days ago
  • 2500-3000 more healthcare staff expected to be fired, as Shane Reti blames Labour for a budget defic...

    Long ReadKey Summary: Although National increased the health budget by $1.4 billion in May, they used an old funding model to project health system costs, and never bothered to update their pre-election numbers. They were told during the Health Select Committees earlier in the year their budget amount was deficient, ...
    Mountain TuiBy Mountain Tui
    4 days ago
  • Might Kamala Harris be about to get a 'stardust' moment like Jacinda Ardern?

    As a momentous, historic weekend in US politics unfolded, analysts and commentators grasped for precedents and comparisons to help explain the significance and power of the choice Joe Biden had made. The 46th president had swept the Democratic party’s primaries but just over 100 days from the election had chosen ...
    PunditBy Tim Watkin
    5 days ago
  • Solutions Interview: Steven Hail on MMT & ecological economics

    TL;DR: I’m casting around for new ideas and ways of thinking about Aotearoa’s political economy to find a few solutions to our cascading and self-reinforcing housing, poverty and climate crises.Associate Professor runs an online masters degree in the economics of sustainability at Torrens University in Australia and is organising ...
    The KakaBy Steven Hail
    5 days ago
  • Reported back

    The Finance and Expenditure Committee has reported back on National's Local Government (Water Services Preliminary Arrangements) Bill. The bill sets up water for privatisation, and was introduced under urgency, then rammed through select committee with no time even for local councils to make a proper submission. Naturally, national's select committee ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    5 days ago
  • Vandrad the Viking, Christopher Coombes, and Literary Archaeology

    Some years ago, I bought a book at Dunedin’s Regent Booksale for $1.50. As one does. Vandrad the Viking (1898), by J. Storer Clouston, is an obscure book these days – I cannot find a proper online review – but soon it was sitting on my shelf, gathering dust alongside ...
    A Phuulish FellowBy strda221
    5 days ago
  • Gordon Campbell On The Biden Withdrawal

    History is not on the side of the centre-left, when Democratic presidents fall behind in the polls and choose not to run for re-election. On both previous occasions in the past 75 years (Harry Truman in 1952, Lyndon Johnson in 1968) the Democrats proceeded to then lose the White House ...
    WerewolfBy lyndon
    5 days ago
  • Joe Biden's withdrawal puts the spotlight back on Kamala and the USA's complicated relatio...

    This is a free articleCoverageThis morning, US President Joe Biden announced his withdrawal from the Presidential race. And that is genuinely newsworthy. Thanks for your service, President Biden, and all the best to you and yours.However, the media in New Zealand, particularly the 1News nightly bulletin, has been breathlessly covering ...
    Mountain TuiBy Mountain Tui
    5 days ago
  • Why we have to challenge our national fiscal assumptions

    A homeless person’s camp beside a blocked-off slipped damage walkway in Freeman’s Bay: we are chasing our tail on our worsening and inter-related housing, poverty and climate crises. Photo: Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāTL;DR: The top six things I’ve noted around housing, climate and poverty in Aotearoa’s political economy ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    5 days ago
  • Existential Crisis and Damaged Brains

    What has happened to it all?Crazy, some'd sayWhere is the life that I recognise?(Gone away)But I won't cry for yesterdayThere's an ordinary worldSomehow I have to findAnd as I try to make my wayTo the ordinary worldYesterday morning began as many others - what to write about today? I began ...
    Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel
    5 days ago
  • A speed limit is not a target, and yet…

    This is a guest post from longtime supporter Mr Plod, whose previous contributions include a proposal that Hamilton become New Zealand’s capital city, and that we should switch which side of the road we drive on. A recent Newsroom article, “Back to school for the Govt’s new speed limit policy“, ...
    Greater AucklandBy Guest Post
    5 days ago
  • The Kākā’s Pick 'n' Mix for Monday, July 22

    TL;DR: My pick of the top six links elsewhere around housing, climate and poverty in Aotearoa’s political economy in the last day or so to 7:00 am on Monday, July 22 are:Today’s Must Read: Father and son live in a tent, and have done for four years, in a million ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    5 days ago
  • The Kākā’s Journal of Record for Monday, July 22

    TL;DR: As of 7:00 am on Monday, July 22, the top six announcements, speeches, reports and research around housing, climate and poverty in Aotearoa’s political economy in the last day are:US President Joe Biden announced via X this morning he would not stand for a second term.Multinational professional services firm ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    5 days ago
  • 2024 SkS Weekly Climate Change & Global Warming News Roundup #29

    A listing of 32 news and opinion articles we found interesting and shared on social media during the past week: Sun, July 14, 2024 thru Sat, July 20, 2024. Story of the week As reflected by preponderance of coverage, our Story of the Week is Project 2025. Until now traveling ...
    Skeptical Science
    6 days ago
  • I'd like to share what I did this weekend

    This weekend, a friend pointed out someone who said they’d like to read my posts, but didn’t want to pay. And my first reaction was sympathy.I’ve already told folks that if they can’t comfortably subscribe, and would like to read, I’d be happy to offer free subscriptions. I don’t want ...
    Mountain TuiBy Mountain Tui
    6 days ago
  • For the children – Why mere sentiment can be a misleading force in our lives, and lead to unex...

    National: The Party of ‘Law and Order’ IntroductionThis weekend, the Government formally kicked off one of their flagship policy programs: a military style boot camp that New Zealand has experimented with over the past 50 years. Cartoon credit: Guy BodyIt’s very popular with the National Party’s Law and Order image, ...
    Mountain TuiBy Mountain Tui
    6 days ago
  • A friend in uncertain times

    Day one of the solo leg of my long journey home begins with my favourite sound: footfalls in an empty street. 5.00 am and it’s already light and already too warm, almost.If I can make the train that leaves Budapest later this hour I could be in Belgrade by nightfall; ...
    More Than A FeildingBy David Slack
    6 days ago
  • The Chaotic World of Male Diet Influencers

    Hi,We’ll get to the horrific world of male diet influencers (AKA Beefy Boys) shortly, but first you will be glad to know that since I sent out the Webworm explaining why the assassination attempt on Donald Trump was not a false flag operation, I’ve heard from a load of people ...
    David FarrierBy David Farrier
    6 days ago
  • It's Starting To Look A Lot Like… Y2K

    Do you remember Y2K, the threat that hung over humanity in the closing days of the twentieth century? Horror scenarios of planes falling from the sky, electronic payments failing and ATMs refusing to dispense cash. As for your VCR following instructions and recording your favourite show - forget about it.All ...
    Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel
    1 week ago
  • Bernard’s Saturday Soliloquy for the week to July 20

    Climate Change Minister Simon Watts being questioned by The Kākā’s Bernard Hickey.TL;DR: My top six things to note around housing, climate and poverty in Aotearoa’s political economy in the week to July 20 were:1. A strategy that fails Zero Carbon Act & Paris targetsThe National-ACT-NZ First Coalition Government finally unveiled ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    1 week ago
  • Pharmac Director, Climate Change Commissioner, Health NZ Directors – The latest to quit this m...

    Summary:As New Zealand loses at least 12 leaders in the public service space of health, climate, and pharmaceuticals, this month alone, directly in response to the Government’s policies and budget choices, what lies ahead may be darker than it appears. Tui examines some of those departures and draws a long ...
    Mountain TuiBy Mountain Tui
    1 week ago
  • Flooding Housing Policy

    The Minister of Housing’s ambition is to reduce markedly the ratio of house prices to household incomes. If his strategy works it would transform the housing market, dramatically changing the prospects of housing as an investment.Leaving aside the Minister’s metaphor of ‘flooding the market’ I do not see how the ...
    PunditBy Brian Easton
    1 week ago
  • A Voyage Among the Vandals: Accepted (Again!)

    As previously noted, my historical fantasy piece, set in the fifth-century Mediterranean, was accepted for a Pirate Horror anthology, only for the anthology to later fall through. But in a good bit of news, it turned out that the story could indeed be re-marketed as sword and sorcery. As of ...
    A Phuulish FellowBy strda221
    1 week ago
  • The Kākā's Chorus for Friday, July 19

    An employee of tobacco company Philip Morris International demonstrates a heated tobacco device. Photo: Getty ImagesTL;DR: The top six things I’ve noted around housing, climate and poverty in Aotearoa’s political economy on Friday, July 19 are:At a time when the Coalition Government is cutting spending on health, infrastructure, education, housing ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    1 week ago
  • The Kākā’s Pick 'n' Mix for Friday, July 19

    TL;DR: My pick of the top six links elsewhere around housing, climate and poverty in Aotearoa’s political economy in the last day or so to 8:30 am on Friday, July 19 are:Scoop: NZ First Minister Casey Costello orders 50% cut to excise tax on heated tobacco products. The minister has ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    1 week ago
  • Weekly Roundup 19-July-2024

    Kia ora, it’s time for another Friday roundup, in which we pull together some of the links and stories that caught our eye this week. Feel free to add more in the comments! Our header image this week shows a foggy day in Auckland town, captured by Patrick Reynolds. ...
    Greater AucklandBy Greater Auckland
    1 week ago
  • Weekly Climate Wrap: A market-led plan for failure

    TL;DR : Here’s the top six items climate news for Aotearoa this week, as selected by Bernard Hickey and The Kākā’s climate correspondent Cathrine Dyer. A discussion recorded yesterday is in the video above and the audio of that sent onto the podcast feed.The Government released its draft Emissions Reduction ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    1 week ago
  • Tobacco First

    Save some money, get rich and old, bring it back to Tobacco Road.Bring that dynamite and a crane, blow it up, start all over again.Roll up. Roll up. Or tailor made, if you prefer...Whether you’re selling ciggies, digging for gold, catching dolphins in your nets, or encouraging folks to flutter ...
    Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel
    1 week ago
  • Trump’s Adopted Son.

    Waiting In The Wings: For truly, if Trump is America’s un-assassinated Caesar, then J.D. Vance is America’s Octavian, the Republic’s youthful undertaker – and its first Emperor.DONALD TRUMP’S SELECTION of James D. Vance as his running-mate bodes ill for the American republic. A fervent supporter of Viktor Orban, the “illiberal” prime ...
    Bowalley Road
    1 week ago
  • The Kākā’s Journal of Record for Friday, July 19

    TL;DR: As of 6:00 am on Friday, July 19, the top six announcements, speeches, reports and research around housing, climate and poverty in Aotearoa’s political economy in the last day are:The PSA announced the Employment Relations Authority (ERA) had ruled in the PSA’s favour in its case against the Ministry ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    1 week ago

  • Joint statement from the Prime Ministers of Canada, Australia and New Zealand

    Australia, Canada and New Zealand today issued the following statement on the need for an urgent ceasefire in Gaza and the risk of expanded conflict between Hizballah and Israel. The situation in Gaza is catastrophic. The human suffering is unacceptable. It cannot continue.  We remain unequivocal in our condemnation of ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    18 hours ago
  • AG reminds institutions of legal obligations

    Attorney-General Judith Collins today reminded all State and faith-based institutions of their legal obligation to preserve records relevant to the safety and wellbeing of those in its care. “The Abuse in Care Inquiry’s report has found cases where records of the most vulnerable people in State and faith‑based institutions were ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    20 hours ago
  • More young people learning about digital safety

    Minister of Internal Affairs Brooke van Velden says the Government’s online safety website for children and young people has reached one million page views.  “It is great to see so many young people and their families accessing the site Keep It Real Online to learn how to stay safe online, and manage ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    21 hours ago
  • Speech to the Conference for General Practice 2024

    Tēnā tātou katoa,  Ngā mihi te rangi, ngā mihi te whenua, ngā mihi ki a koutou, kia ora mai koutou. Thank you for the opportunity to be here and the invitation to speak at this 50th anniversary conference. I acknowledge all those who have gone before us and paved the ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    23 hours ago
  • Employers and payroll providers ready for tax changes

    New Zealand’s payroll providers have successfully prepared to ensure 3.5 million individuals will, from Wednesday next week, be able to keep more of what they earn each pay, says Finance Minister Nicola Willis and Revenue Minister Simon Watts.  “The Government's tax policy changes are legally effective from Wednesday. Delivering this tax ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 day ago
  • Experimental vineyard futureproofs wine industry

    An experimental vineyard which will help futureproof the wine sector has been opened in Blenheim by Associate Regional Development Minister Mark Patterson. The covered vineyard, based at the New Zealand Wine Centre – Te Pokapū Wāina o Aotearoa, enables controlled environmental conditions. “The research that will be produced at the Experimental ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 day ago
  • Funding confirmed for regions affected by North Island Weather Events

    The Coalition Government has confirmed the indicative regional breakdown of North Island Weather Event (NIWE) funding for state highway recovery projects funded through Budget 2024, Transport Minister Simeon Brown says. “Regions in the North Island suffered extensive and devastating damage from Cyclone Gabrielle and the 2023 Auckland Anniversary Floods, and ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 day ago
  • Indonesian Foreign Minister to visit

    Indonesia’s Foreign Minister, Retno Marsudi, will visit New Zealand next week, Foreign Minister Winston Peters has announced.   “Indonesia is important to New Zealand’s security and economic interests and is our closest South East Asian neighbour,” says Mr Peters, who is currently in Laos to engage with South East Asian partners. ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 day ago
  • Strengthening partnership with Ngāti Maniapoto

    He aha te kai a te rangatira? He kōrero, he kōrero, he kōrero. The government has reaffirmed its commitment to supporting the aspirations of Ngāti Maniapoto, Minister for Māori Development Tama Potaka says. “My thanks to Te Nehenehenui Trust – Ngāti Maniapoto for bringing their important kōrero to a ministerial ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • Transport Minister thanks outgoing CAA Chair

    Transport Minister Simeon Brown has thanked outgoing Chair of the Civil Aviation Authority, Janice Fredric, for her service to the board.“I have received Ms Fredric’s resignation from the role of Chair of the Civil Aviation Authority,” Mr Brown says.“On behalf of the Government, I want to thank Ms Fredric for ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • Test for Customary Marine Title being restored

    The Government is proposing legislation to overturn a Court of Appeal decision and amend the Marine and Coastal Area Act in order to restore Parliament’s test for Customary Marine Title, Treaty Negotiations Minister Paul Goldsmith says.  “Section 58 required an applicant group to prove they have exclusively used and occupied ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • Opposition united in bad faith over ECE sector review

    Regulation Minister David Seymour says that opposition parties have united in bad faith, opposing what they claim are ‘dangerous changes’ to the Early Childhood Education sector, despite no changes even being proposed yet.  “Issues with affordability and availability of early childhood education, and the complexity of its regulation, has led ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • Kiwis having their say on first regulatory review

    After receiving more than 740 submissions in the first 20 days, Regulation Minister David Seymour is asking the Ministry for Regulation to extend engagement on the early childhood education regulation review by an extra two weeks.  “The level of interest has been very high, and from the conversations I’ve been ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • Government upgrading Lower North Island commuter rail

    The Coalition Government is investing $802.9 million into the Wairarapa and Manawatū rail lines as part of a funding agreement with the NZ Transport Agency (NZTA), KiwiRail, and the Greater Wellington and Horizons Regional Councils to deliver more reliable services for commuters in the lower North Island, Transport Minister Simeon ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • Government moves to ensure flood protection for Wairoa

    Local Government Minister Simeon Brown has announced his intention to appoint a Crown Manager to both Hawke’s Bay Regional and Wairoa District Councils to speed up the delivery of flood protection work in Wairoa."Recent severe weather events in Wairoa this year, combined with damage from Cyclone Gabrielle in 2023 have ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • PM speech to Parliament – Royal Commission of Inquiry’s Report into Abuse in Care

    Mr Speaker, this is a day that many New Zealanders who were abused in State care never thought would come. It’s the day that this Parliament accepts, with deep sorrow and regret, the Report of the Royal Commission of Inquiry into Abuse in Care.  At the heart of this report are the ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Government acknowledges torture at Lake Alice

    For the first time, the Government is formally acknowledging some children and young people at Lake Alice Psychiatric Hospital experienced torture. The final report of the Royal Commission of Inquiry into Abuse in State and Faith-based Care “Whanaketia – through pain and trauma, from darkness to light,” was tabled in Parliament ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Government acknowledges courageous abuse survivors

    The Government has acknowledged the nearly 2,400 courageous survivors who shared their experiences during the Royal Commission of Inquiry into Historical Abuse in State and Faith-Based Care. The final report from the largest and most complex public inquiry ever held in New Zealand, the Royal Commission Inquiry “Whanaketia – through ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Half a million people use tax calculator

    With a week to go before hard-working New Zealanders see personal income tax relief for the first time in fourteen years, 513,000 people have used the Budget tax calculator to see how much they will benefit, says Finance Minister Nicola Willis.  “Tax relief is long overdue. From next Wednesday, personal income ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Paid Parental Leave improvements pass first reading

    Workplace Relations and Safety Minister Brooke van Velden says a bill that has passed its first reading will improve parental leave settings and give non-biological parents more flexibility as primary carer for their child. The Regulatory Systems Amendment Bill (No3), passed its first reading this morning. “It includes a change ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Rebuilding the economy through better regulation

    Two Bills designed to improve regulation and make it easier to do business have passed their first reading in Parliament, says Economic Development Minister Melissa Lee. The Regulatory Systems (Economic Development) Amendment Bill and Regulatory Systems (Immigration and Workforce) Amendment Bill make key changes to legislation administered by the Ministry ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • ‘Open banking’ and ‘open electricity’ on the way

    New legislation paves the way for greater competition in sectors such as banking and electricity, Commerce and Consumer Affairs Minister Andrew Bayly says. “Competitive markets boost productivity, create employment opportunities and lift living standards. To support competition, we need good quality regulation but, unfortunately, a recent OECD report ranked New ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Charity lotteries to be permitted to operate online

    Minister of Internal Affairs Brooke van Velden says lotteries for charitable purposes, such as those run by the Heart Foundation, Coastguard NZ, and local hospices, will soon be allowed to operate online permanently. “Under current laws, these fundraising lotteries are only allowed to operate online until October 2024, after which ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Accelerating Northland Expressway

    The Coalition Government is accelerating work on the new four-lane expressway between Auckland and Whangārei as part of its Roads of National Significance programme, with an accelerated delivery model to deliver this project faster and more efficiently, Transport Minister Simeon Brown says. “For too long, the lack of resilient transport connections ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Sir Don to travel to Viet Nam as special envoy

    Sir Don McKinnon will travel to Viet Nam this week as a Special Envoy of the Government, Foreign Minister Winston Peters has announced.    “It is important that the Government give due recognition to the significant contributions that General Secretary Nguyen Phu Trong made to New Zealand-Viet Nam relations,” Mr ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Grant Illingworth KC appointed as transitional Commissioner to Royal Commission

    Minister of Internal Affairs Brooke van Velden says newly appointed Commissioner, Grant Illingworth KC, will help deliver the report for the first phase of the Royal Commission of Inquiry into COVID-19 Lessons, due on 28 November 2024.  “I am pleased to announce that Mr Illingworth will commence his appointment as ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • NZ to advance relationships with ASEAN partners

    Foreign Minister Winston Peters travels to Laos this week to participate in a series of Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN)-led Ministerial meetings in Vientiane.    “ASEAN plays an important role in supporting a peaceful, stable and prosperous Indo-Pacific,” Mr Peters says.   “This will be our third visit to ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Backing mental health services on the West Coast

    Construction of a new mental health facility at Te Nikau Grey Hospital in Greymouth is today one step closer, Mental Health Minister Matt Doocey says. “This $27 million facility shows this Government is delivering on its promise to boost mental health care and improve front line services,” Mr Doocey says. ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • NZ support for sustainable Pacific fisheries

    New Zealand is committing nearly $50 million to a package supporting sustainable Pacific fisheries development over the next four years, Foreign Minister Winston Peters and Oceans and Fisheries Minister Shane Jones announced today. “This support consisting of a range of initiatives demonstrates New Zealand’s commitment to assisting our Pacific partners ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Students’ needs at centre of new charter school adjustments

    Associate Education Minister David Seymour says proposed changes to the Education and Training Amendment Bill will ensure charter schools have more flexibility to negotiate employment agreements and are equipped with the right teaching resources. “Cabinet has agreed to progress an amendment which means unions will not be able to initiate ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Commissioner replaces Health NZ Board

    In response to serious concerns around oversight, overspend and a significant deterioration in financial outlook, the Board of Health New Zealand will be replaced with a Commissioner, Health Minister Dr Shane Reti announced today.  “The previous government’s botched health reforms have created significant financial challenges at Health NZ that, without ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Minister to speak at Australian Space Forum

    Minister for Space and Science, Innovation and Technology Judith Collins will travel to Adelaide tomorrow for space and science engagements, including speaking at the Australian Space Forum.  While there she will also have meetings and visits with a focus on space, biotechnology and innovation.  “New Zealand has a thriving space ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Climate Change Minister to attend climate action meeting in China

    Climate Change Minister Simon Watts will travel to China on Saturday to attend the Ministerial on Climate Action meeting held in Wuhan.  “Attending the Ministerial on Climate Action is an opportunity to advocate for New Zealand climate priorities and engage with our key partners on climate action,” Mr Watts says. ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Oceans and Fisheries Minister to Solomons

    Oceans and Fisheries Minister Shane Jones is travelling to the Solomon Islands tomorrow for meetings with his counterparts from around the Pacific supporting collective management of the region’s fisheries. The 23rd Pacific Islands Forum Fisheries Committee and the 5th Regional Fisheries Ministers’ Meeting in Honiara from 23 to 26 July ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • Government launches Military Style Academy Pilot

    The Government today launched the Military Style Academy Pilot at Te Au rere a te Tonga Youth Justice residence in Palmerston North, an important part of the Government’s plan to crackdown on youth crime and getting youth offenders back on track, Minister for Children, Karen Chhour said today. “On the ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • Nine priority bridge replacements to get underway

    The Government has welcomed news the NZ Transport Agency (NZTA) has begun work to replace nine priority bridges across the country to ensure our state highway network remains resilient, reliable, and efficient for road users, Transport Minister Simeon Brown says.“Increasing productivity and economic growth is a key priority for the ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Update on global IT outage

    Acting Prime Minister David Seymour has been in contact throughout the evening with senior officials who have coordinated a whole of government response to the global IT outage and can provide an update. The Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet has designated the National Emergency Management Agency as the ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • New Zealand, Japan renew Pacific partnership

    New Zealand and Japan will continue to step up their shared engagement with the Pacific, Foreign Minister Winston Peters says.    “New Zealand and Japan have a strong, shared interest in a free, open and stable Pacific Islands region,” Mr Peters says.    “We are pleased to be finding more ways ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • New infrastructure energises BOP forestry towns

    New developments in the heart of North Island forestry country will reinvigorate their communities and boost economic development, Regional Development Minister Shane Jones says. Mr Jones visited Kaingaroa and Kawerau in Bay of Plenty today to open a landmark community centre in the former and a new connecting road in ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • 'Pacific Futures'

    President Adeang, fellow Ministers, honourable Diet Member Horii, Ambassadors, distinguished guests.    Minasama, konnichiwa, and good afternoon, everyone.    Distinguished guests, it’s a pleasure to be here with you today to talk about New Zealand’s foreign policy reset, the reasons for it, the values that underpin it, and how it ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago

Page generated in The Standard by Wordpress at 2024-07-27T00:52:35+00:00