Australia, you’re being a dick

Written By: - Date published: 8:35 am, November 6th, 2017 - 139 comments
Categories: australian politics, Donald Trump, International, jacinda ardern, labour - Tags: ,

Jacinda Ardern had her first international outing as Prime Minister on the weekend and flew over the Tasman to meet Australian Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull.

The most important subject related to 600 people originally from third world nations who are on Manus Island in Papua New Guinea.  They are only there because Australia refused to comply with its legal obligation to process people seeking refugee status who present themselves at Australia’s boarder.  Turnbull’s Government claims that deterrence of others necessitates such cruel and inhumane treatment.  But it is strange that a right wing Government, who normally talk about the rule of law as if it is a given, should violate its legal obligations in such a clear and calculating way.

And lets be absolutely clear here.  Yes there is a crisis but it is one created by deliberate decisions by Turnbull and Co.  Deliberately shutting off power and water and stopping the supply of food to the inhabitants of the camp is as inhumane an act as you can think of.

Ardern offered again an original offer made by John Key and apparently accepted by Julia Gillard for New Zealand to take 150 refugees from Australia each year including potentially Manus Island residents.

But this very generous offer has been declined.

The reason?  From Radio New Zealand:

At their first official meeting since Ms Ardern became Prime Minister, Mr Turnbull also declined to take up a renewed offer from the New Zealand government to take Manus Island and Nauru refugees.

About 600 refugees remain holed up on the detention centre, which Australia closed last week.

Australia is coming under pressure over its handling of the situation with the United Nations calling on it to restore food, water and health services.

New Zealand’s offer to take 150 refugees was first made in 2013.

However, it has been rejected several times, most recently in February, on the basis refugees could use coming to New Zealand as a back door into Australia.

Mr Turnbull said he thanked Ms Ardern but he did not want to do anything that might encourage a return of people smuggling into Australia.

He said his country was focused on a deal that would see 1250 refugees resettled in America.

He said Australia would consider other options only if that did not succeed.

“We are pursuing those arrangements [with the US] at the moment and that is our commitment,” Mr Turnbull said.

“We want to pursue those, conclude those arrangements and then in the wake of that, obviously we can consider other ones.”

But how likely is it that the deal with the United States will resolve matters?  This transcript of the famous Trump Turnbull telephone call from earlier on in his term suggests not very.  Trump was reported as saying this:

Here I am calling for a ban where I am not letting anybody in and we take 2,000 people. Really it looks like 2,000 people that Australia does not want and I do not blame you by the way, but the United States has become like a dumping ground. You know Malcom [sic], anybody that has a problem – you remember the Mariel boat lift, where Castro let everyone out of prison and Jimmy Carter accepted them with open arms. These were brutal people. Nobody said Castro was stupid, but now what are we talking about is 2,000 people that are actually imprisoned and that would actually come into the United States. I heard about this – I have to say I love Australia; I love the people of Australia. I have so many friends from Australia, but I said – geez that is a big ask, especially in light of the fact that we are so heavily in favor, not in favor, but we have no choice but to stop things. We have to stop. We have allowed so many people into our country that should not be here. We have our San Bernardino’s, we have had the World Trade Center come down because of people that should not have been in our country, and now we are supposed to take 2,000. It sends such a bad signal. You have no idea. It is such a bad thing.

Then there was this exchange.  Prepare to have your basic sense of humanity shaken:

Turnbull: Yes, but let me describe what it is. I think it is quite consistent. I think you can comply with it. It is absolutely consistent with your executive order so please just hear me out. The obligation is for the United States to look and examine and take up to and only if they so choose – 1,250 to 2,000. Every individual is subject to your vetting. You can decide to take them or to not take them after vetting. You can decide to take 1,000 or 100. It is entirely up to you. The obligation is to only go through the process. So that is the first thing. Secondly, the people — none of these people are from the conflict zone. They are basically economic refugees from Iran, Pakistan, and Afghanistan. That is the vast bulk of them. They have been under our supervision for over three years now and we know exactly everything about them.

Trump: Why haven’t you let them out? Why have you not let them into your society?

Turnbull: OK, I will explain why. It is not because they are bad people. It is because in order to stop people smugglers, we had to deprive them of the product. So we said if you try to come to Australia by boat, even if we think you are the best person in the world, even if you are a Noble [sic] Prize winning genius, we will not let you in. Because the problem with the people —

Trump: That is a good idea. We should do that too. You are worse than I am.

Get all that?  Turnbull said that the Manus Island residents did not present any threat to Australia, they were economic refugees.  And Trump formed the opinion that Turnbull was worse than him.

But if the offer is still there and America is doing the vetting then why cut off the food and water and power?  Ardern indicated that she was prepared to look at giving the refugees so that they could not travel to Australia under New Zealand’s open access agreement.  Turnbull’s response appears to be focus group motivated belligerence.

Twitter has given Turnbull a lashing. Some favourites:

https://twitter.com/MrDenmore/status/926735746626498560

139 comments on “Australia, you’re being a dick ”

  1. Carolyn_nth 1

    Ardern has come across well int he media on this.

    But, re-the argument about not encouraging more people to try to get to Aussie….

    Why is no one considering why so many people are trying to get into relatively wealthy countries?

    Hint: global inequalities.

    • RedLogix 1.1

      We all are all to some degree victims of a massive global inequality. Look at today’s new around the “Paradise Papers”. When less than 50 people now control more wealth than the bottom 50% of the planet’s people, then something is deeply, grotesquely wrong.

      • Angel Fish 1.1.1

        lol you can blame the consumers that feed these corporations then!
        Take responsibility as a consumer!

    • This is absolutely about global inequalities.

      What I find astounding is the author of this article thinks offering to take 150 people is generous! New Zealand takes very very few refugees and is ranked 110th in the world, per capita, adjusted for GDP.

      Ardern merely repeated Key’s offer, except she knew it would be refused having been rejected previously. It seems going through the motions of making tiny gestures is what Standardistas call progressive government.

  2. Matthew Whitehead 2

    Sure, Australia is being terrible on this issue, yet again. Quelle surprise, the only Australian party that has anything considering a reasonable policy on refugees is the Australian Greens.

    At least in New Zealand Labour acknowledges some degree of responsibility on this issue, but the line of daylight between Ardern’s “we need to stop boat operators endangering the lives of refugees” and noted reactionary Mike Hosking’s “refugees need to get back in line even if that means they die waiting” takes is nowhere near enough for someone who is now the leader of our country, and whose ambition is to centre kindness as a quality we ask for in our leaders. At the least she should be looking to take more than 150 refugees, even if that involves going over our quota this year- it’s supposed to be a minimum, not a maximum.

    • greywarshark 2.1

      Matthew W
      +100

    • McFlock 2.2

      Totally. Offer to take the lot. It’s the humane thing to do.

      • RedLogix 2.2.1

        But now three months later imagine we read in the news of a large ship with 5,000 crammed on board now heading across the Tasman with the declared aim of reaching NZ. Exactly how would this unwelcome news be treated domestically?

        Like Rudd before her, Adern would be crucified.

        Ultimately these people should enter a standard UN refugee program and progress from there. Anything else validates the criminal business model of the people smugglers.

        • marty mars 2.2.1.1

          Yes they are feared by some, so what, what else is new.

          Imagine in 3 months that nothing else happens – ummm yep that seems closer to reality than the shootem on the beach zombie scenario.

          • RedLogix 2.2.1.1.1

            Not at all, at least one vessel declared an intention to reach NZ, although in that instance it may have been more a distraction rather than a reality.

            It may suit your argument to discount the possibility of large vessels making it across the Tasman to zero, but a glance at any of our busy ports suggest that it is possible.

            • McFlock 2.2.1.1.1.1

              Ok, so maybe one vessel has ever tried. Maybe.

              Because your fear (shared by dunnokeyo, I seem to recall) is based on a reality that has four contradictory constraints:

              – smugglers want to maximise their profit
              – refugees are usually poor
              – seaworthy ships are expensive
              – the Tasman Sea is quite big.

              We’re not talking about stowaways, who we won’t detect until they’re here. We’re talking about a dedicated vessel, with a crew that’s either paid off to accept a fall, or inexperienced refugees told “keep it pointed in that direction”. If they genuinely try to make that trip, they’re screwed.

              • RedLogix

                Yes there are hurdles and hazards, but hell I’ve sailed across the Tasman in a smallish yacht years back. In the right weather window it’s quite doable.

                Of course it’s a one way trip, but that’s not a show stopper. All I am suggesting is that it is quite possible to do and pretending otherwise is not really a feasible argument.

                • McFlock

                  possible is not the same as likely. Enough boats sunk trying to cross the straits with indonesia, ffs – any refugee ship that makes it to Auckland Harbour should have the entire crew put into America’s Cup and Whitbread training immediately. They’ll make us millions.

                  • RedLogix

                    And yachties on much smaller boats regularly make the trip too. With modern GPS and weather predictions (nowadays good for almost 14 days out) it’s nothing like the madly dangerous proposition you are making out.

                    Again I’m not trying to suggest it’s a dead cert, but I’d give it a substantial 20% probability of happening once it became common knowledge that NZ was open to accepting refugees.

                    • McFlock

                      And in what volume? I’d say “well under our current dismal refugee quota”. In which case, why worry about it.

                    • RedLogix

                      That’s probably what Rudd thought at the outset.

                    • McFlock

                      He didn’t have 2000km of ocean providing enough delay to reconsider.

                      Besides, Rudd never really spun with the average Australian knee-jerker. To sophisticated by half.

                    • I’d say “well under our current dismal refugee quota”.

                      And you’d be wrong. Australia, before implementing their present policies, had 25000+ people turning up every year. And that had been steadily increasing.

                    • McFlock

                      Again, try that on the Tasman Sea.

              • Gabby

                How poor are these refugees? How seaworthy are the boats?

                • McFlock

                  If they were rich, they’d have been flooding in via Emirate Air after making donations to the national party.

                  And the boats sink trying to cross from Indonesia to Aus, so I don’t give many of them a chance of getting to NZ.

                  • Gabby

                    So the boats are pretty cheap then. Writeoffs maybe.

                    • McFlock

                      It’s a one trip deal, and you can’t collect cash from them at the other end – and if you could, it wouldn’t be that much.

                      You’re welcome to speculate how much investment in marine safety an unscrupulous people smuggler might make.

                    • David Mac

                      This from an Aussie ABC 2014 report.

                      “Like any organised crime outfit, people smuggling networks are nimble and respond quickly to what CEOs would call “political challenges to their business environment”.

                      For smuggling networks operating through Indonesia, that has been a series of changes to Australian policy.

                      Passengers from the only boat known to have reached Australian territory this year have told the ABC they paid as little as $1,000 per person for the voyage.

                      According to passengers from a boat that was turned back in December, they paid between $1,200 and $2,500 per person.

                      While this represents a massive discount on the up to $13,000 that was being charged just a couple of years ago, a cut-price offer is not the only thing that has changed in the smuggling trade.

                      The available evidence suggests that smuggling networks have been trying out new routes and offering to keep sending people until they make it to Australia.”

                      http://www.abc.net.au/news/2014-03-24/people-smugglers-adapting-methods-to-combat-australian-policies/5342276

            • OnceWasTim 2.2.1.1.1.2

              “at least one vessel declared an intention to reach NZ”
              Don’t you mean Australian media reported that one vessel declared that intention?
              At least you have the decency to add “it may have been more a distraction rather than a reality” if it was actually their stated intent. In fact now I come to think about it, I remember placards on an overloaded leaky boat
              You’re a bit of a surprise sometimes @RL.
              I realise NZ can’t be the world’s bleeding heart, but at least can do all it can when things go tits up, AND call out the arseholes that are causing the problems.
              Better still – it can also get its own house in order. Like for example the economic refugees heading our own various governmental agencies making judgements on others with much the same ambitions.

        • McFlock 2.2.1.2

          Ok.

          Firstly, See if they’re in our SAR area – the boat will probably sink, and we don’t want 5000 people to drown.

          Secondly, Apply to the UNHCR for help.

          Thirdly, bring them in when they reach our SAR area.

          Fourthly, find the people smugglers and break their parasitic organisation. Somebody bought a big freaking boat that was pretty much unprecedented in size. The Tampa had less than 10% that number.

          • RedLogix 2.2.1.2.1

            Exactly all the steps the Australians attempted. But in practical terms exactly what do you do with a shipload of people determined not to return to where they came from? Yes the humane, intelligent thing is to let them ashore and give them residency.

            But that comes with consequences as Rudd found out.

            • McFlock 2.2.1.2.1.1

              Are we as bad as Australia? Really?

              • RedLogix

                Maybe I’m biased because I have lived here almost five years now and have noticed that Australians generally don’t seem to be the horned devils most of The Standard regulars make them out to be.

                The big difference is that they on average are a little more socially conservative than us, and tend to speak their minds freely. You’re rarely left in much doubt as to where you stand with them. But otherwise we’ve encountered pretty much the same range of values and opinions as you would find back in NZ.

                But for an accident of geography and distance we would be struggling with the exact same issue and be doing no better. We have nothing to be smug about.

                • McFlock

                  It’s quite likely that Australians alive today chased indentured Aborigine slaves down and took them back in chains.

                  Aborigines weren’t classes as “human” until 1967.

                  That’s not an “accident of geography”. We’re well short of perfect, but we are at least better than that.

                  • RedLogix

                    Again the same moral smugness that has no place in this debate. Maori were always a highly politically aware and engaged peoples; by contrast the social, technical and cultural distance between the European colonists (many of whom arrived under damned difficult circumstances themselves) and the Aboriginal peoples was huge. If ever the stage was set for a disastrous meeting of two peoples, colonial Australia had to be it.

                    Moreover we cannot neglect the impact of geography; until roughly the 1960’s Australia was a much tougher and challenging place to live. A brutal climate, prone to drought, storms and flood, combined with huge distances and isolation made for a tough outlook in those who could tolerate it. Put simply the country itself shaped a people with hard attitudes. A far more prominent Catholic Church inculcated a deep social conservatism. These really only started to change when roads, cars and electricity started to transform Australian life and the iron grip of the Churches relaxed in the 60’s and 70’s.

                    Nor can it be said that all white Australians treated Aboriginals as sub-humans; there are plenty of examples of those who did not. But universally everyone on both sides of the divide struggled to adapt to each other to some degree. Again I’m not for an instant defending what happened, just suggesting that there is no reason to think us kiwis would have done any better if faced with the same context.

                    • McFlock

                      All that’s as may be – but that’s their background.

                      We can, should, and I think given the opportunity would do better than them now.

                      We should be offering to take the lot.

                    • RedLogix

                      So now the smuggler’s gambit is; leaky ship to somewhere off the Aussie coast, get rescued by their navy, a few years in an open PNG transition camp, and then quick smart to soft touch NZ and six months later, bingo into Aus!

                      OK that’s not what might happen, but it’s certainly how it will be sold.

                      Truly if there have been two issues that have torn Australian politics inside out this past decade it’s climate change and boat people. We’re jumping up and down on one of their big bright red hot buttons here and should proceed intelligently.

                      Ultimately I’m OK for us to take the 150 we’ve offered, but we need to be absolutely onside with the Australians to ensure the optics and messaging works. Because if it doesn’t we will have brought ourselves one ugly shitstorm, both internationally and domestically.

                      This isn’t about us ‘being better than them’. Jeeze that’s so patronising and unhelpful. It’s about working constructively with our nearest neighbouring nation (one that we are deeply linked with) to solve an ugly problem with a now hopelessly tragic human face.

                    • McFlock

                      Except they’ve shut the camp because the aussie court finally declared it illegal. That’s why the refugees are running out of food and water.

                      So, like I say: Manus is a one-off deal. No slippery slope, no moral hazard, no floodgates.

                      Applying their problems to us, when we have a massive natural bulwark against their problem, is silly.

                      25k is something like 0.1% of their population, by the way, equivalent to 4,000 people in NZ. Can we really not handle two or three times that a year, especially if it comes off the immigration visa quota?

                    • RedLogix

                      But pretending we’re somehow better than the Australians just because of that ocean is equally silly.

                      Yes we can take these people as a one-off. But there is a real finite probability that it will not end there. As I said above, once you start paying kidnappers all you are doing is validating their business model. Much the same with people smugglers.

                      The Australians have been dealing with this godawful issue for some time now. Having NZ stick it’s naive little nose in, stinking of ‘holier than thou’ really won’t be welcome. We can do it, but Adern needs to be really smart about it’s done.

                      PS. And quit the irritating obfuscation. The refugees are running out of supplies because they refuse to leave the detention camp that the PNG Supreme Court has declare must be shut, and move to open, transition camps PNG have provided where there is plenty of food, water, medical care and security provided.

                      The only reason why they are doing this is to attempt to continue to pressure Australia into granting them asylum, when everyone knows they simply don’t qualify.

                • But otherwise we’ve encountered pretty much the same range of values and opinions as you would find back in NZ.

                  People are people the world over.

                  But for an accident of geography and distance we would be struggling with the exact same issue and be doing no better.

                  Yep. If we had 25000+ people turning up every year as illegal immigrants we’d looking at ways to limit that as well as immigrants cost a huge amount to prepare, assimilate and generally provide for. When it’s uncontrolled it costs even more.

                  • McFlock

                    Which is a bloody stupid way of looking at it.

                    We have 60k people turning up every year, long term. Shit planning might cause some issues, but yeah, nah, we can handle it.

                    • Once we start allowing in illegal immigrants the number will rise again and again. It would only be a few years before it gets to well over a 100k and still be climbing.

                      And that’s not a fear – that’s actually what happens.

                      So, no, we can’t handle it.

                    • Lol that isn’t what that study showed – so it is your own fear – deal with YOUR stuff and stop projecting it.

                    • McFlock

                      First of all, they’re not “illegal immigrants”, they’re asylum seekers. If the asyum bid fails, they get deported.

                      The floodgate thing is a wonderful theory, it’s about as good as the domino theory the yanks had after WW2. But there are 2000 choppy, blinding, sweltering, chilling, contrary reasons why even a draconian Australia will be the preferred first stop for the desperate.

                    • RedLogix

                      If their ‘asylum bid’ fails and they refuse to return … now what? (Oddly enough even the ‘dumb’ Australians realised that forcing them onto planes and trying to send them back to countries that were not going to accept them back was probably not smart.)

                      Given the vast majority of boat people failed even the most elementary ‘asylum bid’, it was reasonable to assume they were really just attempting to bypass the normal immigration process everyone else has to abide by.

                      Quibble the words all you like, but in the end for most it was an attempt to enter the country illegally. And no-one had any humane solution for dealing with the mess once they were on Australian territory, but without any legal path to residency.

                      And DtB’s reference proves exactly what he contended; that in the years were boat people were permitted residency unchecked, their numbers increased year on year. Note particularly the drop in the year 2013 from 300 boats to just 1 in 2014 after Abbott’s election.

                    • McFlock

                      The vast majority fail in asylum bids?

                      When they shut Nauru “Only 45 of the 1,637 asylum seekers detained in Nauru were found not to be refugees.[2]”.

                      45 nasty, law breaking illegal immigrants abusing the poor aussies, to 1600-odd legitimate refugees.

          • OnceWasTim 2.2.1.2.2

            @McFlock
            Yep indeed!.
            I always wondered why Okkers are perfectly prepared to spend millions and millions outsourcing their ‘problem’ to those they recognise are in need of a few dollars, yet they can’t see their way clear to invest the same amount of the almighty A$ in tracking down those whose intent is to get an earn in people trafficking. (and that’s as opposed to those smugglers with a genuine concern for refugee’s plight with minimal means)
            Still, I suppose it’s far easier to label and demean and spin, and invent language and terms like “Queue Jumpers”, or “Economic Refugees” or “Low Quality Immigrants”, etc., etc., and question their integrity rather than own up to their own. Besides, they’re probably all fuckn rapists and murderers anyway.
            But mmmmmmaaaaaaaaaaaaate! Did you see that Chickie Babe Jacinta!? She’s that fukn new Koiwoi Prime Minister or sumthing.
            Whoooooar! Hot pants brutha! Move over!
            Actually, it’s a bit of an admission that their intelligence capability is actually up to SFA. If it’s not that and they’re not able to locate those whose intent is more about people for money, then it’s down to – well take a guess (you just have to listen to a Dutton or a Corman or a Yabbit or two)

            • Draco T Bastard 2.2.1.2.2.1

              I always wondered why Okkers are perfectly prepared to spend millions and millions outsourcing their ‘problem’ to those they recognise are in need of a few dollars, yet they can’t see their way clear to invest the same amount of the almighty A$ in tracking down those whose intent is to get an earn in people trafficking.

              I suspect that has to do with those traffickers being in other countries and thus outside of Australia’s jurisdiction. About the only thing that Australia could do is ask those countries to look into it and those probably don’t care enough to do so.

              The other option would be to send the spies in to try and find them but if they did that then we certainly won’t hear about it.

              • OnceWasTim

                Are you trying to tell me the Australian Navy hasn’t entered into waters not within their ‘jurisdiction’ in the past?
                NEVER taken boats with queue jumper boat people economic immigrants under tow and directed them -TOWED them back ?
                Maaaate, Are you interested in buying the Sydney Harbour Bridge by any chance?

                • OnceWasTim

                  I know I know Drac T B. It was for their own good!
                  What else could they have done!
                  Actually rather than the Sydney Harbour Bridge, I’ve got a Rohingya I could sell you. Make very good servant! Just feed flour and water once a day, mattress under house, all good

                • [Citation needed]

                  And will towing a ship back to port catch the people organising the ship? The people getting the money?

        • Matthew Whitehead 2.2.1.3

          If Australia is so opposed to people smuggling, they should be going after the operators, not trying to keep refugees out of its territorial waters and illegally detaining them.

          I don’t disagree that Australia does have a hard lot being the destination for these people coming by boat from various places in Asia and surrounding countries, but it also doesn’t have a land border, so it has to accept that refugees not able to wait for the paperwork of the UN refugee program will come by boat, and it’s simply a matter of making sure they’re safe when they do so, and if they can’t arrange for safe travel by boat, then Australia will have to deal with the realities of unsafe travel by boat. If Australia can’t accept them all permanently, that’s fine, they should house them temporarily in Australia (instead of farming them out to their neighbours so that they can avoid making a decision on whether or not they’re actually refugees) while they look for a permanent solution- likely, some of those refugees would end up in NZ or the USA. It’s totally reasonable if Australia can’t find space in their own refugee program to take all arrivals. What’s not reasonable is them trying to stop refugees from arriving at all under the guise of opposing dangerous “smuggling” of refugees by boat- I think if we’re being absolutely real, we all know Australia would still oppose these trips even if they were safe, because what they really oppose is having to make a decision on whether these people are refugees and thus being legally obliged to make sure they’re taken care of, simply because of their own domestic politics around immigration colouring the issue of refugees. (who aren’t even immigrants)

          New Zealand is already doing our part in this equation by putting our hand up to take refugees Australia doesn’t want when they arrive this way, and I hope we will continue to take increasing numbers as time goes on.

          But to say that all refugees must apply with proper paperwork when they are fleeing government persecution or war zones is more than a little ridiculous. The inability to wait to save your life is part of what qualifies you as a refugee, and if there’s no completely safe way to flee, sometimes they will balance their dangers and take an unsafe boat because it’s still less likely to kill them than their own government.

  3. RedLogix 3

    Not accurate at all mickey. As far as I am aware these people are free to leave the now closed camp (hence no food and water) and live on Manus alongside the rest of the local population. Closing the Manus Is camp was not optional, it was ordered closed by the PNG Supreme Court April last year and the Australian govt had to comply.

    Three other camps run by PNG are now open and available for the refugees:

    Three other centres in the nearby town of Lorengau, built at the expense of the Australian taxpayer, are ready to receive the asylum seekers. They are all open facilities, where no one is detained. Two of these facilities are for people who’ve had their status confirmed as refugees.

    One of these is the East Lorengau Refugee Transit Centre, which was finished three years ago. It has room for 400 people, according to federal government figures provided to a Senate estimates committee two weeks ago. Seventy-seven refugees are living there already. It has health care and it has security for the protection of residents.

    The other is the West Lorengau Haus. It has capacity for another 300 refugees. So total capacity for refugees is 700. For confirmed refugees, the PNG government pays an allowance for food and other necessities but they need to cook their own food.

    The third facility is designated for the people whose claims for refugee status failed, non-refugees. This is Hillside Haus, which can accommodate 198 people. For non-refugees, to whom PNG pays no allowance, the facility will supply catered meals.

    http://www.smh.com.au/comment/what-do-refugee-advocates-hope-to-achieve-on-manus-20171103-gzeeiu.html

    In other words closing the Australian camp was ordered by the PNG Supreme Court and alternative accommodation provided by the PNG govt, to which the refugees are entirely free to go. They may not want to, but this is not Australia’s fault. Omitting this information is dishonestly selective and invalidates your OP entirely.

    • Sure and go back to blaming the people smugglers too but for gods sake don’t blame the aussies cos they’re our brothers – get real mate the aussies ARE to blame.

      • RedLogix 3.1.1

        The core problem here is that tragically these people by a cruel and hopeless stroke of fate have made themselves outcasts everywhere. The moment they paid the illegal people smugglers for their passage on got on those damn boats their fate was sealed. That and some very unfortunate timing. After all they had every expectation their illegal passage would see them safe in Australia, much as 51,000 others before them.

        The problem is now no-one really wants them, other than Cambodia, the US and NZ. And if by some miracle they could be re-homed tomorrow and we could be certain the people smugglers would not restart their vile trade in response … there would be no problem with resettlement.

        It’s very analogous to the strict policy most governments have around never paying out kidnappers. Because paying out a ransom validates a business model that criminals quickly take advantage of. People smugglers are much the same, except their victims are not innocents, but for the most part people driven to find a better life.

        The people to blame here are the people smugglers primarily, with the refugees themselves seeking bypass a legal migration process must also bear some responsibility for their choices as well. Australia did not invite them to illegally migrate, nor a any moral obligation to accept them as refugees just on their say so.

        The rest of the editorial I linked to is a reasonable read as well. It’s a tough issue with no easy answers. Sorry I can’t be more fluffy ducky on this.

        • greywarshark 3.1.1.1

          Red L
          The core problem here is that tragically these people by a cruel and hopeless stroke of fate have made themselves outcasts everywhere.

          ‘Made themselves outcasts’? I think somebody else made them outcasts.
          Sure it is tragic. Paying money to be transported hopefully, is just a final blow to these dejected, rejected outcasts.

          Don’t blame them for world, religious, political, oil resource….conflicts. They are only little people, as ultimately all of us are, living our small lives. And only about half of this small country try to do anything to better the situation, using the small resources that each of us has.

          • RedLogix 3.1.1.1.1

            Of course they did. These people committed a crime by trying to enter Australia illegally. They had every expectation they would get away with it, but they didn’t. Exactly whose fault is that?

            The problem we both have here gw is that none of us can really know their exact motives for migrating. Because if living in a shitty corrupt poverty-ridden country is justification for illegal migration then you have just validated several billion people mass migrating without restriction.

            Already there are some 65m refugees in the world and over time this will become a more fraught issue. Imagine for instance if in say 2025 the WAIS suddenly begins it’s almost inevitable terminal breakup. By say 2028 sea level has risen 2m and most Pacific Islands are now uninhabitable. Vast areas of Bangladesh are now gone, and so on. Such a crisis would render Manus Is a mere picnic.

            I truly don’t have a good answer for any of this within a politically conventional framework. Open borders utterly disintegrates any sense of national identity or integrity. None of us are ready for that and I make no apologies for being appalled by such a prospect myself. But I’ve made this basic proposition many times before and been roundly ignored: All the real problems in the world now are global in nature, and demand solutions imposed at the level of global governance.

            Australia cannot fix this on it’s own, nor can NZ. No single nation on it’s own can address the complex issues of gross economic inequality, corruption, war-mongering and social injustice that drives this story. Until the human race as a whole accepts the critical need for a global government, capable of imposing it’s policy universally, then we will be left helpless in the face of these intractable tragedies.

            • McFlock 3.1.1.1.1.1

              what crime did they commit?

              I’ve always been a bit unclear on that. My understanding is that their objective was not to “enter Australia illegally”, it was to get to Australia and go through the regular asylum process on Australian soil.

              • RedLogix

                Try embarking on an aircraft to NZ in say Hong Kong without a valid visa or passport. It’s just not going to happen; almost all nations have clamped down on people travelling on false documents trying to arrive on their territory in order to claim asylum.

                What Australia was faced with was not handfuls of people arriving by plane, but tens of thousands in large boats, but in principle they have the same right to prevent these people from arriving on Australian soil whether they arrive by plane or boat. That’s not the real issue here.

                The core of the problem is simple; too many people abusing a ‘regular political asylum process’ in order to bypass the normal immigration process that everyone else has to undertake. I’m personally in no position to judge why these people were trying to apply for political asylum, but clearly Australia has had reason to determine them as ‘economic migrants’. As I mentioned above, this whole question of who is or isn’t a ‘refugee’ will only become more vexed as time goes on.

                Of course the downside is that this wholesale abuse has made it far harder for genuine political refugees.

                • McFlock

                  Travelling on false documents is very illegal.

                  Simply turning up on aussie soil, as the refugees try to do, is not.

                  Australia’s reason to call them economic immigrants is illegal, as is their detention. As for “tens of thousands” – 12,000 boat people from 1999-2001, dribs and drabs thereafter. If you’re lucky, in the next few years they’ll reach something approaching the 50k Vietnamese boat people let in after the war in Vietnam ended.

                  • RedLogix

                    Simply turning up on aussie soil, as the refugees try to do, is not.

                    Are you arguing for open borders? Because the problem is that by ‘just turning up’ and claiming political asylum creates the problem that most refuse to return of their countries of origin, or any other alternative, when the authorities determine they are not genuine.

                    Now they are stuck with people who have no legal path to residency, yet no other place they can go to. They effectively make themselves stateless. Rudds’ answer which was to just let them in anyway saw over 51,000 people exploit this opportunity in just a few short years, and the numbers just kept rising until Abbott put a stop to it.

                    As I mentioned a few days ago, through sheer social accident I’ve just spent five days with a senior Australian military diplomat based in Asia. What was never made public by the Rudd govt was the sheer scale of some of the planned ‘shipments’ their intelligence services got wind of. Smugglers were scouting out for end of life ships capable of carrying tens of thousands to Australia. The idea was to just run them ashore at speed and there would little the Australian navy could do to stop them. The potential profits were astounding.

                    Now there may not be a law against ‘just arriving on Australian soil’, but such mass arrivals are not easily tolerated domestically. It sank both Rudd and Gillard and tossed Abbott a priceless political lifeline. You only have to consider the turmoil it is causing in Europe.

                    • McFlock

                      Those who refuse get deported.

                      The problem arises becausemost if not all of them have legitimate asylum grounds, but Australia doesn’t want to abide by international law.

                      As for what intelligence services get wind of – unless they’ve sabotaged one or two then all they got wind of were grand schemes.

                      51000, over years, in a country of 20-odd million. Practical problems don’t strike me as being insurmountable. The character of the people and politicians who literally made shit up and formented the scare on the issue, on the other hand…

                    • RedLogix

                      Political asylum was originally intended to have an individual scope; something that related to the specific circumstances of a natural person.

                      But in reality there is no clean boundary between a ‘politically persecuted’ refugee and one that’s ‘economically oppressed’. When the notion of refugee is expanded to encompass and entire group, culture, nation or religion of people even … the concept becomes strained.

                      I accept there is no clean definition that will satisfy everyone here on this thread; however in this case the Naura and PNG govts have determined that around 80% do qualify as refugees. There is a lot of solid information here:

                      https://www.aph.gov.au/About_Parliament/Parliamentary_Departments/Parliamentary_Library/pubs/rp/rp1617/Quick_Guides/Offshore

                      In this case the primary requirement is to resettle them in any country where they will be safe. Accommodating their desire to settle in any specific country is a secondary matter. The fact that that these people have spurned resettlement offers to Cambodia, and insist the only place they will go is Australia inevitably casts a shadow over their motives. They may well be refugees, but the opportunity to improve their lifestyles at the same time seems very high on their collective agenda.

                      In the event of war or upheaval that does affect entire groups of people, there is every good reason to find ways to temporarily resettle and protect them until they can be returned to their native land. But enabling permanent mass migration to another country is a tough ask for any host nation. It may well fall under the concept of asylum, it may well be humane and compassionate … but ultimately there will be a domestic backlash if the process is seen, or feared to be spirally out of control.

                      That both Howard and Abbott were able to exploit this to their own political advantage was of course deplorable; but there is an object lesson in it for NZ to observe. Ask Winston.

            • mauī 3.1.1.1.1.2

              Weren’t historical white settlers of Australia and New Zealand also committing a crime too? Can we really judge? It’s not like my ancestors got permission to come here or anything. Maybe they had permission from the Queen I guess. In this context I can’t see how the current situation is much different.

              The other similarity is that many kiwis/aussies are from economic migrant stock aren’t they.

              Personally I would like it if New Zealand maintained a small population so we don’t wreck the country. But having to defend your borders to do it seems crazy, a huge waste of money and human cost as you’re essentially at war.

              • RedLogix

                You are right in a moral sense. But that was almost 200 years ago, and how far back in history do you want to go to redress all the wrongs inflicted by one tribe upon another?

                But in terms of addressing the modern world, the open borders our ancestors enjoyed are no longer possible. Or at least not in our current context. I can imagine some more distant, ideal future when this might be possible, but not now. Or maybe even this hope is futile, maybe the billions of dispossessed and desperate will just arrive anyway and there will be nothing we can do. You are right, we cannot morally wage war on them, but neither could we be oblivious to their sheer numbers.

                Again, most people just want a quiet life, most people love the land they grew up in and the last thing they really want is to uproot themselves and start over in a strange place. But two things we cannot ignore; gross global inequalities and an internet which cast this in a harsh relief to anyone connected to it.

                Manus Is is a mere prelude to something much larger.

        • marty mars 3.1.1.2

          No mate the people s.mugglers are a result not a cause. A cause would be the economuc system that some have grown fat on whilst others struggle and suffer. Or perhaps the western insatiable need for trinkets and toys which cost other countries their forests and land and water and air. Or maybe the weaponary sold to the poor and their governments or the child slave labour to produce fake sneakers – no. The blame is set fairly on us. Pity some won’t try and help people seeing as how we have caused it in many ways.

          • RedLogix 3.1.1.2.1

            I’m mostly on the same page with that marty. But just ‘blaming us’ isn’t going to fix much. My fuller answer is above to gw at 10:46

        • OnceWasTim 3.1.1.3

          Jesus RedL, I don’t know where to begin – others have picked up on the spin and inaccuracies better than I can in response. (greyw, McFlock , etc).
          Wonderful spin you’ve managed to put on it all with your interpretation of the PNG supreme court decision, the way they ‘made themselves’ victims, etc, etc.

          I think One Nation are looking for a few candidates at the mo!
          You’d have to renounce the privilege of your citizenship though.

      • greywarshark 3.1.2

        It’s like the stupid slogans thrown around after gun murders about whether it is the guns or the people who are responsible. And what is actually happening and needs attention is sidelined.

        Fancy Jacinda coming out with that ‘people smugglers/boat operators blame’. They are just behaving like we do in NZ when there is illicit money and opportunity around. We have seized the day and the opportunity to enrich ourselves. All countries and people do things not good, but hey if there’s money in it, there is temptation and the rich fall for it as well as the strugglers.

        The refugees are desperate, they have money to pay for sea transport. The final solution (the word solution has a sinister ring whether it is the Aussie or Pacific solution) is to take the money and get rid of them. A sweet-and-sour deal for the Indonesians or whoever is closest to Australia.

    • mickysavage 3.2

      I agree that the PNG Supreme Court ruled that the camp was in breach of the inhabitants human rights. I have read that they inhabitants do not want to move because of safety concerns.

      As far as I am aware there is no court imposed timeline for closing the camp.

      http://www.aljazeera.com/news/2017/10/manus-detention-centre-closed-171024212852806.html

      • RedLogix 3.2.1

        I find that an odd answer. Surely Courts are not in the habit of allowing their rulings to be complied with entirely at leisure?

        It would have better if these people had been more concerned about their safety before they got on those boats. Besides some 77 others seem to have taken up the offer to leave without any reported problems so far.

        • mickysavage 3.2.1.1

          And I am finding your critisism odd. The Supreme Court decision says that the whole setup was illegal. I did not think about the decision when I read the post but have had a read through what I can find of it. The original decision said “[b]oth the Australian and Papua New Guinea governments shall forthwith take all steps necessary to cease and prevent the continued unconstitutional and illegal detention of the asylum seekers or transferees at the relocation centre on Manus Island and the continued breach of the asylum seekers or transferees constitutional and human rights”. This was back in March.

          You seem to be saying that allowing them to go elsewhere on Papua New Guinea fixes this breach. It doesn’t. Australia still has an obligation to process their refugee applications. Saying that they can remain on Papua New Guinea validates an arrangement that should never have been made.

          • RedLogix 3.2.1.1.1

            If you want to get technical, as I understand it Australia only has an obligation to process their refugee applications once they reach Australian territory. OK so I didn’t write the rules, but that’s how it is I think.

            Of course the Australians do know a great deal about these people, they have had them in detention for a considerable period after all, and have concluded (and I we can only take their word for this) that these people are ‘economic migrants’. Just claiming you are frightened to return to your home country is not really good enough when it comes to legal procedure. Such a claim has to be scrutinised and tested, and apparently most would fail.

            Of course the Australians never wanted these people to arrive illegally and had every right to try and prevent them from doing so. Logically the boats should have been turned back to their port of departure at Indonesia, but they would not take them back either.

            But my real criticism lies with your OP, where is implies by my reading, that the Australians have abandoned these refugees in a prison camp they cannot leave with no food or water. That simply is not true.

            • mickysavage 3.2.1.1.1.1

              The residents have major fears of leaving. They have been left with no food or water. If the US was going to take them why shut things off now? Why not wait for the decision to be made?

              • RedLogix

                Because PNG wants them out of the detention camp they are in, and into the open transition camps PNG have ready for them. What you need to say out loud, is these people are not in any sense trapped in this now closed facility with no food or water, they are refusing to leave.

                • mickysavage

                  They are afraid to leave. They are living in this particular hell hole. The US of A is meant to take them. Why upset them by making them leave?

          • Gabby 3.2.1.1.2

            Why is it important that they go to Australia? They’ve escaped the oppression from which they fled.

    • greywarshark 3.3

      Red L
      There is an important follow-on from the above. And that is explaining why each of those actions and reactions happened. Some context is necessary for understanding, not simple rebuttal of criticism of Australia or indeed PNG.

      • RedLogix 3.3.1

        Indeed. The editorial is clearly written more in sorrow than anger. Everyone here wishes this never happened; and much of the blame for that must lie with Kevin Rudd.

    • DH 3.4

      So what are their future options RedLogix? Have they been offered permanent residency in PNG or is the new situation temporary as well?

      • RedLogix 3.4.1

        As far as I am aware only three countries have offered a place for them. Cambodia where all but one has refused to go; the USA under the Obama Administration and an offer that Trump has put into doubt, and NZ who has offered places for only 150 of them.

        Otherwise the only other practical option is a UN Refugee program, but I’ve no idea what the status of this option is either. PNG will house them temporarily in transition as refugees, but I don’t think even they want to offer them residency. And I doubt such an offer would get a better reception than Cambodia’s.

        I’m not trying to defend any of this mess; just pointing out that it’s not the black and white issue some people here want to make it out as. It’s a complex muddle of global issues, tensions with Indonesia, ugly domestic politics, and criminals making huge profits from desperate people who took a gamble and lost. Shitty all round, but I don’t imagine for one second NZ would have handled it any better than Australia.

        • DH 3.4.1.1

          Thanks. I’m staying out of the debate, it has no ‘right’ ending, but what you’ve said here has resonated. It wasn’t that long ago we were up in arms over all the refugees drowning en-route to Aus, at least that has pretty much ceased. I don’t agree with Turnbull’s assertion that granting residency after a 3-4yr wait in a bumhole camp will tempt the smugglers to start up again but it has to be said this isn’t a simple black and white picture here.

  4. Zorb6 4

    Ardern’s response was the correct one.Turnbull has a point about rewarding this type of behaviour.This Govt has plenty of business to attend to without this distraction.

  5. Cinny 5

    NZer’s are being dicks as well. They had a poll on newshub this morning re refugees, the majority of people who responded to the poll do not want these refugees.

    For all those that say ‘we need to do more to help our own people’, ask yourself, what are you doing to help ‘our own people’, chances are most people who think like that aren’t doing much for anyone except themselves.

    Rant over

    Proud of our PM and it’s a beautiful day out there.

    • gsays 5.1

      To be fair cinny, the poll respondents were of the folk who choose to watch/read/listen to newshub’s product.

      Unfortunately these folk get to vote as well.

      • Cinny 5.1.1

        Thats a darn good point G. It was like a wtf moment, are kiwis really that selfish, turns out the newshubAM listeners/viewers are.
        Even after the wonderful Aziz (?) explained that he was a refugee, and what himself and his family went through, even after his touching truthful story, the poll remained the same.

    • greywarshark 5.2

      Rhanks Cinny
      We need to remind ourselves and be thankful for what we have got this day – a beautiful day and a potentially great PM. But being great is hard work, so all the best Jacinda with your greatness, try harder.

      • Cinny 5.2.1

        So looking forward to tomorrow, 2pm, Parliament is back on, this political junkie has been missing it.

  6. Wayne 6

    MickySavage,

    Manus Island was not the most important issue at this meeting.

    The upcoming APEC talks and TPP were almost certainly the biggest things that would have occupied the two leaders. Also this will be the first time the PM meets Trump, and as we know Turnbull has his own issues with him. So I am sure they would have talked about the best way to deal with him, given the importance of the US in the Asia Pacific region. Plus the continuing rise of China, especially following the 5 year congress. And Abe has increased his power base.

    So lots of changing realities, all of which are more important to New Zealand’s future.

    • Stating the obvious for cred – lol – wow, did you write down their briefing notes

    • Chris 6.2

      Another hateful right wing idiot putting a monetary price on human lives. Such a fuckwit.

      • Wayne 6.2.1

        Chris and DoublePlusGood

        You are obviously talking about the Prime Minister because it was her meeting.

        She didn’t go beyond the 150 that New Zealand had already offered to take.

        • Chris 6.2.1.1

          I was referring specifically to this part of your comment:

          “Manus Island was not the most important issue at this meeting.

          The upcoming APEC talks and TPP were almost certainly the biggest things that would have occupied the two leaders…”

          That’s your spin on what was more important to Ardern. A childish attempt at deflection common to those of your ilk. Watching you pontificate on national television really is quite painful, by the way.

    • DoublePlusGood 6.3

      Sad that you care more about economics than human rights

  7. Antoine 7

    I appreciate Ardern’s desire to speak out on behalf of the powerless, but I hope we come out of this with a functional relationship between the two Governments. We need a lot of favours from Australia…

    • Sabine 7.1

      We do?

      Which favours from OZ do we need?

      • Antoine 7.1.1

        We want better treatment for New Zealanders who live there.

        • Sabine 7.1.1.1

          we could get this by treating Australians here the same.

          We really don’t have to continue that drop roll over game National started on that particular item of your list.

          what ‘favours’ do we need?

          • Antoine 7.1.1.1.1

            > we could get this by treating Australians here the same

            We could not. We need them more than they need us.

            (Edit: because the % of NZers living in Aussie is much higher than the % of Aussies living in NZ)

            A.

            • Draco T Bastard 7.1.1.1.1.1

              We need them more than they need us.

              Why?

              And then there’s the obvious. If the NZers living is Aus are having such a hard time but don’t want to return to NZ then why don’t they become Australians?

                • Yep, they’re being ripped off. No doubt about it. Perhaps they should take the hint that Australia just doesn’t want them.

                  NZ really can’t do much about that except put in place the exact same rules for Australians as Australia has for NZers. And even doing that won’t change anything – the Australian government will still continue shafting immigrants. I thought that was obvious by now as they’ve been doing it for a long time.

                  My two youngest sisters are Australian but my parents had to move on to NZ after Australia changed the immigration rules. And that was back in the 1960s.

                  • Antoine

                    > NZ really can’t do much about that except put in place the exact same rules for Australians as Australia has for NZers.

                    That would be counter productive IMO, it would lead to a ‘tit for tat’ exchange

                    A.

                    • DoublePlusGood

                      Eh, just do it to members of the government – doesn’t harm your average australian, pisses off their government

                    • Antoine

                      > pisses off their government

                      Can you see that pissing them off might not be the best way of persuading them to do what we want?

                      A.

                    • So, we should just roll over and take whatever Australia dishes out and not stand up for ourselves?

                      And if we put in p;ace the exact same rules for Australians immigrating to NZ as they have for NZers going to Aus then they really can’t complain now, can they?

                    • Chris

                      It wouldn’t be tit-for-tat. It’d be adapting to reflect the nature of the relationship, which by the way isn’t *special* anymore.

                      People opposed to treating Australians the same as they treat us seem to think there’s still a chance the Australian government “will see sense”. They’re holding out for things to improve. Well, they’re never going to improve for as long as Australia knows it can treat NZers like crap without any repercutions.

                      Unfortunately, the only way things might change is when there are cases of Australian families who’ve made NZ their home getting ripped apart through deportation. Harsh, I know, but it’s the only way things might change.

                      As for other things like restricting health care and welfare for Australians, Ardern and Peters should just do this.

                    • Gabby

                      it would lead to a ‘tit for tat’ exchange if the ockers felt they had to stay one up on us, otherwise, one tit, one tat and we’re even. They wouldn’t feel they had to stay one up on us, would they?

                    • Antoine

                      @Gabby What are the odds of Aussies being bloody minded?

                      A.

  8. But it is strange that a right wing Government, who normally talk about the rule of law as if it is a given, should violate its legal obligations in such a clear and calculating way.

    No it’s not. How else do you think they justify avoiding paying the taxes that they legally owe?

    They’ll look for a loophole and this one’s clear: …who present themselves at Australia’s boarder.

    The refugees are not making it to the border and so Australia doesn’t have any legal obligations.

  9. Whispering Kate 9

    Personally I think we need to begin a slow withdrawal from our relationship with Australia. Frankly Australia is becoming a rogue state – treating whoever they want with contempt. They treat their own indigenous people shamefully which for the 21st century is unexcusable from a supposedly civilised society. They do not accept gay marriage and treat our own people over there with insults daily. They can’t even be sportsmen when they play us and will live forever as being under arm bowlers – what do you expect from them, they are a nasty lot.

    We need to step up and have as little to do with them as possible, they taint us with their disgraceful behaviour. I have it on good authority from a family member who has lived for there on the Gold Coast for years that they are bloody lazy workers and prejudiced as well. I say good riddance to them. I often wonder why they are absolutely so different from us – so full of themselves for god knows why. We have stood up to greater powers than them in the past and didn’t we feel good about it. We can do it again.

    • greywarshark 9.2

      Yes that underam bowling – it just epitomises the Aussie attitude. It’s getting what you want using the best methods available to you at the time.

      We are being treated like Mexico is by the USA. Oz has long been even more drawn to their style of ruling than our pollies. Extreme conditions build hard people and as times get tougher there the people will get worse, and any pollies with values will just be sacrificed in their parliamentary house in various rituals meant to demoralise them. So we need to be prepared for it.

      We opened up our systems to embrace CER whatever that is. We forget. But it doesn’t seem to give us much, and left us with Oz as our No.1 trading partner. What do we get out of it besides inflated house prices underwritten by the Scarlet Banks’ profits.

      Apparently many in Oz don’t know what ANZAC means. They have moved on and embraced neo lib completely, and we are an externality.

  10. Keith 10

    What do deprived, homeless or badly housed Kiwis think of our magnanimous government’s gesture to take in and support these refugees?

    We have so many pressing, serious needs for our own people, right here, right now that saving the world takes a back seat to getting our own house in order I would have thought!

    • McFlock 10.1

      Actually, it would be better to do both.

      And this isn’t a systemic issue, like poverty. Manus Island is a one-off.

    • greywarshark 10.2

      Keith
      I thought I read this a few days ago. Perhaps you are repeating it, or someone else thought it too.

      Unfortunately we are not Fortress NZ. Or perhaps fortunately. It’s impossible to think on the spot about whether we would have been better off to never engage much with the world at all, not trade overseas much, and not send trained military forces overseas, etc. But – we did, and we are involved with the world.

      If we want to respect ourselves as decent human beings, we can’t always turn away from difficulties and mumble that we’re too small, we can’t afford it, we don’t want to know, it’s not our fault and why should we have to care if everybody else isn’t rushing in to do something. Which is our regular approach. And that is with those things that we deign to pay attention to. Thousands of things happen while we are too busy filling our lives with alternatives to thought.

      FFS stop moaning, we won’t have the moral standing to ask for things to be attended to here if we don’t care about fellow human beings elsewhere…sometimes. And when we need help from overseas, can we demand it then? Would we get it from Australia I wonder? Probably I think, at a price though.

      We need to care for and help our NZ people, yes. Unfortunately the same people who have hurt thee refugees so much that they have desperately fled their own lands, are present in our society and close connections. But we have a better chance of surviving their malpractice than the detained on Manus Island. They feel so unsafe they are desperate to find help. We are better off, with all our problems than those poor people.

      As Shakespeare had one of his characters say:

      Hath not [any man or woman] hands, organs, dimensions, senses, affections, passions; fed with the same food, hurt with the same weapons, subject to the same diseases, healed by the same means, warmed and cooled by the same winter and summer as [anyone] is?
      If you prick us, do we not bleed?

      • Keith 10.2.1

        For those here without a stable roof over their heads who wonder how they are going to get through next week I am sure their hearts will be warmed while those from Manus Island will have immediate accommodation and assistance.

        We are no longer first world!

        • Cinny 10.2.1.1

          We are no longer a first world, correct, but we have a future.

          Not into a divisive narrative determined by who is suffering the most, that solves nada.

  11. Delia 11

    It is all noise Malcolm is happy to leave them there with some future ‘plan’ that the USA will gradually transport the 600 to the USA…like sure they will, in 2030. It is cynical. Jacinda should go to the United Nations and get them to do their job by telling the PNG govt that NZ is coming to collect the 150 people (with any conditions NZ allows) to expediate the situation.

  12. greywarshark 12

    Keith
    If you are speaking from the position of knowing first hand about the conditions people are suffering in NZ you will feel that pain of knowing that we are not in the first world, and sinking. With yawning gaps between upper and lower classes.
    It’s disgraceful and not what I ever imagined that I might see in NZ.

    But we are in a position to improve things here. And still have obligations to people elsewhere who are caught in the coils of vicious and callous self-seeking pollies and there funders and mates. A decent country does what it can, it tries. Australia is not a decent country, and we are going downhill. We must pull out even our loose change and do something for these poor people with nothing. We know already what can happen to people with more opportunities – news this morning said that there were 6 suicides of Otago University students.
    ‘ But after a bad year in which there were at least six suicides in the wider campus area, Otago University is trying a range of new responses.’
    http://www.radionz.co.nz/national/programmes/morningreport/audio/2018620514/surge-in-mental-health-help-for-otago-students

    So those who can get to uni are suffering, those who can’t get that far are suffering. And too many of us are in this soup, it’s everywhere. We have to hang together or assuredly we will hang separately. And humans are under attack and despised by others – the curiosity and triumphs of robot devisers. The machine mad are diminishing the world we live in.

    How does that help needy people here – you would say. Well first it is a help to realise the width of the problem, and that others are trying to find ways to help, both here and overseas. If something positive even small, can be done by helpers or the struggler, gradually things can improve. Larger things can help – like a change of government. Keep watching, and asking.

  13. jimekus 13

    “Deliberately shutting off power and water and stopping the supply of food to the inhabitants”

    Sounds like it’s straight out of the Apartheid State’s current training manual which is being actively marketed around the globe..

  14. Sparky 14

    I guess as someone with dual citizenship I’d make the point its not “Australia” its the “Australian government”. A small group of people whose attitudes I’m guessing are not indicative of the attitudes of all Australians (myself included).

    The average Aussie has no more control over their pollies than we do over ours. If we did I would not expect a supposedly left leaning government to back the TPP deals……

  15. David Mac 15

    I’d rather the refugees we welcome didn’t have the desire or funds to pay exorbitant fees to criminal smugglers.

    Whatever the Western world does, it’s a token effort. There are 6 billion people in the world living on less than $2 a day.

    Eventually, with the exception of submarining nations, we will need to help the 6 billion where they live.

    Maybe the Manus island boys can be dropped back home. Teach them to skydive and a military transport plane can fly them home. They can keep the chute, give them $2000 re-integration money and they can choose the homelands field they wish to land in.

    We need to help them where they live. Training and educating 1000’s and sending them home to spread their wisdom is the path to helping millions find a life that they don’t wish to abandon.

  16. Tanz 16

    Good call, Australia. We don’t know enough about these refugees. We need to take in refugees who go through due process. (possibly I may be banned again, lol).
    National would not have made such an irresponsible call, they are more responsible. They are still the preferred govt too, latest Roy Morgan poll. And where is Winston now? Gone to ground it seems, now that he has his baubles. Australia made the right call.

  17. OnceWasTim 17

    “Get all that? Turnbull said that the Manus Island residents did not present any threat to Australia, they were economic refugees. ”

    Yep, I get all that. As I’ve mentioned on other posts in comments – they’re not unlike NZ and Australian refugees – those that cross the Tasman, or to Mother England, the You Ess of Aye? or the UAE in search of better prospects.
    Or even those from Mother England whose currency is worth more than NZ$ who want to retire to a better lifestyle and mansion.
    Except in this case it’s worse – most have been declared ‘genuine’ refugees escaping various forms of persecution, only to be persecuted further.
    Geeze those Aussies are so tough eh? I wish I could be like them (/sarc)

  18. David Mac 18

    A gang of Somalian pirates, their respective whanau and a Shanghai’d crew running a 150 metre long container ship up onto Matauri Bay would probably be the lead news story that night.

  19. Ian 19

    China will take them. They are now the biggest donor to Papua . Problem solved

    • David Mac 19.1

      The internet has enabled those in the most dire of circumstances to window shop the reception they may receive around the globe. Nobody is racing to scratch plastic bottles out of a Chinese dump.

      Who can blame them, we shoot through to Aussie for an extra $20 an hour, what lengths would we stretch to for a doctor, roof, child with a full belly?

  20. rhinocrates 20

    Some people need to be reminded that being a colossal dick won’t give you one.

  21. Angel Fish 21

    Not wanting to incentivize smugglers and more “refugees” from trying to illegally migrate makes perfect sense. However, keeping them detained there for so long doesn’t make any sense. They should be returned back to the country of their origin.

  22. Joseph Levonian 22

    Australia is not a dick!
    A dick is a good thing.
    It is not judgemental, welcomes all (especially after a few drinks) and helps make the world a happier place for many.

    May I suggest that we launch a complaints commission to investigate this misuse of the word ‘dick’ and find a better alternative so as to exonerate the appendage that has innocently been portrayed as a politician!

Links to post

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

  • At a glance – Does CO2 always correlate with temperature?
    On February 14, 2023 we announced our Rebuttal Update Project. This included an ask for feedback about the added "At a glance" section in the updated basic rebuttal versions. This weekly blog post series highlights this new section of one of the updated basic rebuttal versions and serves as a ...
    51 mins ago
  • Bernard’s six-stack of substacks at 6.06 pm on Tuesday, March 19
    TL;DR: In today’s ‘six-stack’ of substacks at 6.06pm on Tuesday, March 19:Kāinga Ora’s dry rot The Spinoff DailyBill McKibben on ‘Climate Superfunds’ making Big Oil pay for climate damage The Crucial YearsPreston Mui on returning to 1980s-style productivity growth NoahpinionAndy Boenau on NIMBYs needing unusual bedfellows Urbanism SpeakeasyNed Resnikoff's case ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    2 hours ago
  • Relentlessly negative
    Negative yesterday, negative today. Negative all year, according to one departing reader telling me I’ve grown strident and predictable. Fair enough. If it’s any help, every time I go to write about a certain topic that begins with C and ends with arrrrs, I do brace myself and ask: Again? Are ...
    More Than A FeildingBy David Slack
    3 hours ago
  • Scoring 4.6 out of 10, the new Government is struggling in the polls
    Bryce Edwards writes –  It’s been a tumultuous time in politics in recent months, as the new National-led Government has driven through its “First 100 Day programme”. During this period there’s been a handful of opinion polls, which overall just show a minimal amount of flux in public support ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    4 hours ago
  • Promiscuous Empathy: Chris Trotter Replies To His Critics.
    Inspirational: The Family of Man is a glorious hymn to human equality, but, more than that, it is a clarion call to human freedom. Because equality, unleavened by liberty, is a broken piano, an unstrung harp; upon which the songs of fraternity will never be played. “Somebody must have been telling lies about ...
    4 hours ago
  • Don’t run your business like a criminal enterprise
    The Detail this morning highlights the police's asset forfeiture case against convicted business criminal Ron Salter, who stands to have his business confiscated for systemic violations of health and safety law. Business are crying foul - but not for the reason you'd think. Instead of opposing the post-conviction punishment and ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    4 hours ago
  • Misremembering Justinian’s Taxes.
    Tax Lawyer Barbara Edmonds vs Emperor Justinian I - Nolo Contendere: False historical explanations of pivotal events are very far from being inconsequential.WHEN BARBARA EDMONDS made reference to the Roman Empire, my ears pricked up. It is, lamentably, very rare to hear a politician admit to any kind of familiarity ...
    5 hours ago
  • Bryce Edwards: Scoring 4.6 out of 10, the new Government is struggling in the polls
    It’s been a tumultuous time in politics in recent months, as the new National-led Government has driven through its “First 100 Day programme”. During this period there’s been a handful of opinion polls, which overall just show a minimal amount of flux in public support for the various parties in ...
    Democracy ProjectBy bryce.edwards
    6 hours ago
  • Bishop scores headlines with crackdown on unwelcome tenants – but Peters scores, too, as tub-thump...
    Buzz from the Beehive Housing Minister Chris Bishop delivered news – packed with the ingredients to enflame political passions – worthy of supplanting Winston Peters in headline writers’ priorities. He popped up at the post-Cabinet press conference to promise a crackdown on unruly and antisocial state housing tenants. His ...
    Point of OrderBy Bob Edlin
    7 hours ago
  • Will it make the boat go faster?
    Ele Ludemann writes – The Reserve Bank is advertising for a Diversity, Equity and Inclusion advisor. The Bank has one mandate – to keep inflation between one and three percent. It has failed in that and is only slowly getting inflation back down to the upper limit. Will it ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    9 hours ago
  • Bryce Edwards: Is Simon Bridges’ NZTA appointment a conflict of interest?
    Last week former National Party leader Simon Bridges was appointed by the Government as the new chair of the New Zealand Transport Agency Waka Kotahi (NZTA). You can read about the appointment in Thomas Coughlan’s article, Simon Bridges to become chair of NZ Transport Agency Waka Kotahi The fact that a ...
    Democracy ProjectBy bryce.edwards
    10 hours ago
  • Is Simon Bridges’ NZTA appointment a conflict of interest?
    Bryce Edwards writes – Last week former National Party leader Simon Bridges was appointed by the Government as the new chair of the New Zealand Transport Agency Waka Kotahi (NZTA). You can read about the appointment in Thomas Coughlan’s article, Simon Bridges to become chair of NZ Transport Agency ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    10 hours ago
  • Bernard's Top 10 @ 10 'pick 'n' mix' at 10:10am on Tuesday, March 19
    TL;DR: My top 10 news and analysis links this morning include:Today’s must-read: Gavin Jacobson talks to Thomas Piketty 10 years on from Capital in the 21st Century The SalvoLocal scoop: Green MP’s business being investigated over migrant exploitation claims Stuff Steve KilgallonLocal deep-dive: The commercial contractors making money from School ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    10 hours ago
  • Bernard's six newsy things on Tuesday, March 19
    It’s a home - but Kāinga Ora tenants accused of “abusing the privilege” may lose it. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāTL;DR: The Government announced a crackdown on Kāinga Ora tenants who were unruly and/or behind on their rent, with Housing Minister Chris Bishop saying a place in a state ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    11 hours ago
  • New Life for Light Rail
    This is a guest post by Connor Sharp of Surface Light Rail  Light rail in Auckland: A way forward sooner than you think With the coup de grâce of Auckland Light Rail (ALR) earlier this year, and the shift of the government’s priorities to roads, roads, and more roads, it ...
    Greater AucklandBy Guest Post
    12 hours ago
  • Why Are Bosses Nearly All Buffoons?
    Note: As a paid-up Webworm member, I’ve recorded this Webworm as a mini-podcast for you as well. Some of you said you liked this option - so I aim to provide it when I get a chance to record! Read more ...
    David FarrierBy David Farrier
    14 hours ago
  • Bernard’s six-stack of substacks at 6.06 pm on March 18
    TL;DR: In my ‘six-stack’ of substacks at 6.06pm on Monday, March 18:IKEA is accused of planting big forests in New Zealand to green-wash; REDD-MonitorA City for People takes a well-deserved victory lap over Wellington’s pro-YIMBY District Plan votes; A City for PeopleSteven Anastasiou takes a close look at the sticky ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    1 day ago
  • Peters holds his ground on co-governance, but Willis wriggles on those tax cuts and SNA suspension l...
    Buzz from the Beehive Here’s hoping for a lively post-cabinet press conference when the PM and – perhaps – some of his ministers tell us what was discussed at their meeting today. Until then, Point of Order has precious little Beehive news to report after its latest monitoring of the ...
    Point of OrderBy Bob Edlin
    1 day ago
  • Labour’s final report card
    David Farrar writes –  We now have almost all 2023 data in, which has allowed me to update my annual table of how  went against its promises. This is basically their final report card. The promise The result Build 100,000 affordable homes over 10 ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    1 day ago
  • “Drunk Uncle at a Wedding”
    I’m a bit worried that I’ve started a previous newsletter with the words “just when you think they couldn’t get any worse…” Seems lately that I could begin pretty much every issue with that opening. Such is the nature of our coalition government that they seem to be outdoing each ...
    Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel
    1 day ago
  • Wang Yi’s perfectly-timed, Aukus-themed visit to New Zealand
    Geoffrey Miller writes – Timing is everything. And from China’s perspective, this week’s visit by its foreign minister to New Zealand could be coming at just the right moment. The visit by Wang Yi to Wellington will be his first since 2017. Anniversaries are important to Beijing. ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    1 day ago
  • Gordon Campbell on Dune 2, and images of Islam
    Depictions of Islam in Western popular culture have rarely been positive, even before 9/11. Five years on from the mosque shootings, this is one of the cultural headwinds that the Muslim community has to battle against. Whatever messages of tolerance and inclusion are offered in daylight, much of our culture ...
    1 day ago
  • New Rail Operations Centre Promises Better Train Services
    Last week Transport Minster Simeon Brown and Mayor Wayne Brown opened the new Auckland Rail Operations Centre. The new train control centre will see teams from KiwiRail, Auckland Transport and Auckland One Rail working more closely together to improve train services across the city. The Auckland Rail Operations Centre in ...
    2 days ago
  • Bernard's six newsy things at 6.36am on Monday, March 18
    Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāTL;DR: Retiring former Labour Finance Minister Grant Robertson said in an exit interview with Q+A yesterday the Government can and should sustain more debt to invest in infrastructure for future generations. Elsewhere in the news in Aotearoa-NZ’s political economy at 6:36am: Read more ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    2 days ago
  • Geoffrey Miller: Wang Yi’s perfectly-timed, Aukus-themed visit to New Zealand
    Timing is everything. And from China’s perspective, this week’s visit by its foreign minister to New Zealand could be coming at just the right moment. The visit by Wang Yi to Wellington will be his first since 2017. Anniversaries are important to Beijing. It is more than just a happy ...
    Democracy ProjectBy Geoffrey Miller
    2 days ago
  • The Kaka’s diary for the week to March 25 and beyond
    TL;DR: The key events to watch in Aotearoa-NZ’s political economy in the week to March 18 include:China’s Foreign Minister visiting Wellington today;A post-cabinet news conference this afternoon; the resumption of Parliament on Tuesday for two weeks before Easter;retiring former Labour Finance Minister Grant Robertson gives his valedictory speech in Parliament; ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    2 days ago
  • Bitter and angry; Winston First
    New Zealand First Leader Winston Peters’s state-of-the-nation speech on Sunday was really a state-of-Winston-First speech. He barely mentioned any of the Government’s key policies and could not even wholly endorse its signature income tax cuts. Instead, he rehearsed all of his complaints about the Ardern Government, including an extraordinary claim ...
    PolitikBy Richard Harman
    2 days ago
  • 2024 SkS Weekly Climate Change & Global Warming News Roundup #11
    A listing of 35 news and opinion articles we found interesting and shared on social media during the past week: Sun, March 10, 2024 thru Sat, March 16, 2024. Story of the week This week we'll give you a little glimpse into how we collect links to share and ...
    2 days ago
  • 2024 SkS Weekly Climate Change & Global Warming News Roundup #11
    A listing of 35 news and opinion articles we found interesting and shared on social media during the past week: Sun, March 10, 2024 thru Sat, March 16, 2024. Story of the week This week we'll give you a little glimpse into how we collect links to share and ...
    2 days ago
  • Out of Touch.
    “I’ve been internalising a really complicated situation in my head.”When they kept telling us we should wait until we get to know him, were they taking the piss? Was it a case of, if you think this is bad, wait till you get to know the real Christopher, after the ...
    Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel
    2 days ago
  • Bring out your Dad
    Happy fourth anniversary, Pandemic That Upended Bloody Everything. I have been observing it by enjoying my second bout of COVID. It’s 5.30 on Sunday morning and only now are lights turning back on for me.Allow me to copy and paste what I told reader Sara yesterday:Depleted, fogged and crappy. Resting, ...
    More Than A FeildingBy David Slack
    3 days ago
  • Bring out your Dad
    Happy fourth anniversary, Pandemic That Upended Bloody Everything. I have been observing it by enjoying my second bout of COVID. It’s 5.30 on Sunday morning and only now are lights turning back on for me.Allow me to copy and paste what I told reader Sara yesterday:Depleted, fogged and crappy. Resting, ...
    More Than A FeildingBy David Slack
    3 days ago
  • Bring out your Dad
    Happy fourth anniversary, Pandemic That Upended Bloody Everything. I have been observing it by enjoying my second bout of COVID. It’s 5.30 on Sunday morning and only now are lights turning back on for me.Allow me to copy and paste what I told reader Sara yesterday:Depleted, fogged and crappy. Resting, ...
    More Than A FeildingBy David Slack
    3 days ago
  • The bewildering world of Chris Luxon – Guns for all, not no lunch for kids
    .“$10 and a target that bleeds” - Bleeding Targets for Under $10!.Thanks for reading Frankly Speaking ! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.This government appears hell-bent on either scrapping life-saving legislation or reintroducing things that - frustrated critics insist - will be dangerous and likely ...
    Frankly SpeakingBy Frank Macskasy
    3 days ago
  • Expert Opinion: Ageing Boomers, Laurie & Les, Talk Politics.
    It hardly strikes me as fair to criticise a government for doing exactly what it said it was going to do. For actually keeping its promises.”THUNDER WAS PLAYING TAG with lightning flashes amongst the distant peaks. Its rolling cadences interrupted by the here-I-come-here-I-go Doppler effect of the occasional passing car. ...
    3 days ago
  • Manufacturing The Truth.
    Subversive & Disruptive Technologies: Just as happened with that other great regulator of the masses, the Medieval Church, the advent of a new and hard-to-control technology – the Internet –  is weakening the ties that bind. Then, and now, those who enjoy a monopoly on the dissemination of lies, cannot and will ...
    3 days ago
  • A Powerful Sensation of Déjà Vu.
    Been Here Before: To find the precedents for what this Coalition Government is proposing, it is necessary to return to the “glory days” of Muldoonism.THE COALITION GOVERNMENT has celebrated its first 100 days in office by checking-off the last of its listed commitments. It remains, however, an angry government. It ...
    3 days ago
  • Can you guess where world attention is focussed (according to Greenpeace)? It’s focussed on an EPA...
    Bob Edlin writes –  And what is the world watching today…? The email newsletter from Associated Press which landed in our mailbox early this morning advised: In the news today: The father of a school shooter has been found guilty of involuntary manslaughter; prosecutors in Trump’s hush-money case ...
    Point of OrderBy Bob Edlin
    3 days ago
  • Further integrity problems for the Greens in suspending MP Darleen Tana
    Bryce Edwards writes – Is another Green MP on their way out? And are the Greens severely tarnished by another integrity scandal? For the second time in three months, the Green Party has secretly suspended an MP over integrity issues. Mystery is surrounding the party’s decision to ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    3 days ago
  • Jacqui Van Der Kaay: Greens’ transparency missing in action
    For the last few years, the Green Party has been the party that has managed to avoid the plague of multiple scandals that have beleaguered other political parties. It appears that their luck has run out with a second scandal which, unfortunately for them, coincided with Golraz Ghahraman, the focus ...
    Democracy ProjectBy bryce.edwards
    3 days ago
  • Bernard’s Dawn Chorus with six newsey things at 6:46am for Saturday, March 16
    TL;DR: The six newsey things that stood out to me as of 6:46am on Saturday, March 16.Andy Foster has accidentally allowed a Labour/Green amendment to cut road user chargers for plug-in hybrid vehicles, which the Government might accept; NZ Herald Thomas Coughlan Simeon Brown has rejected a plea from Westport ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    4 days ago
  • How Did FTX Crash?
    What seemed a booming success a couple of years ago has collapsed into fraud convictions.I looked at the crash of FTX (short for ‘Futures Exchange’) in November 2022 to see whether it would impact on the financial system as a whole. Fortunately there was barely a ripple, probably because it ...
    PunditBy Brian Easton
    4 days ago
  • Elections in Russia and Ukraine
    Anybody following the situation in Ukraine and Russia would probably have been amused by a recent Tweet on X NATO seems to be putting in an awful lot of effort to influence what is, at least according to them, a sham election in an autocracy.When do the Ukrainians go to ...
    4 days ago
  • Bernard’s six stack of substacks at 6pm on March 15
    TL;DR: Shaun Baker on Wynyard Quarter's transformation. Magdalene Taylor on the problem with smart phones. How private equity are now all over reinsurance. Dylan Cleaver on rugby and CTE. Emily Atkin on ‘Big Meat’ looking like ‘Big Oil’.Bernard’s six-stack of substacks at 6pm on March 15Photo by Jeppe Hove Jensen ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    4 days ago
  • Buzz from the Beehive Finance Minister Nicola Willis had plenty to say when addressing the Auckland Business Chamber on the economic growth that (she tells us) is flagging more than we thought. But the government intends to put new life into it:  We want our country to be a ...
    Point of OrderBy Bob Edlin
    4 days ago
  • National’s clean car tax advances
    The Transport and Infrastructure Committee has reported back on the Road User Charges (Light Electric RUC Vehicles) Amendment Bill, basicly rubberstamping it. While there was widespread support among submitters for the principle that EV and PHEV drivers should pay their fair share for the roads, they also overwhelmingly disagreed with ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    4 days ago
  • Government funding bailouts
    Peter Dunne writes – This week’s government bailout – the fifth in the last eighteen months – of the financially troubled Ruapehu Alpine Lifts company would have pleased many in the central North Island ski industry. The government’s stated rationale for the $7 million funding was that it ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    4 days ago
  • Two offenders, different treatments.
    See if you can spot the difference. An Iranian born female MP from a progressive party is accused of serial shoplifting. Her name is leaked to the media, which goes into a pack frenzy even before the Police launch an … Continue reading ...
    KiwipoliticoBy Pablo
    4 days ago
  • Treaty references omitted
    Ele Ludemann writes  – The government is omitting general Treaty references from legislation : The growth of Treaty of Waitangi clauses in legislation caused so much worry that a special oversight group was set up by the last Government in a bid to get greater coherence in the public service on Treaty ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    4 days ago
  • The Ghahraman Conflict
    What was that judge thinking? Peter Williams writes –  That Golriz Ghahraman and District Court Judge Maria Pecotic were once lawyer colleagues is incontrovertible. There is published evidence that they took at least one case to the Court of Appeal together. There was a report on ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    4 days ago
  • Bernard's Top 10 @ 10 'pick 'n' mix' for March 15
    TL;DR: My top 10 news and analysis links this morning include:Today’s must-read: Climate Scorpion – the sting is in the tail. Introducing planetary solvency. A paper via the University of Exeter’s Institute and Faculty of Actuaries.Local scoop: Kāinga Ora starts pulling out of its Auckland projects and selling land RNZ ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    4 days ago
  • The day Wellington up-zoned its future
    Wellington’s massively upzoned District Plan adds the opportunity for tens of thousands of new homes not just in the central city (such as these Webb St new builds) but also close to the CBD and public transport links. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāTL;DR: Wellington gave itself the chance of ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    4 days ago
  • Weekly Roundup 15-March-2024
    It’s Friday and we’re halfway through March Madness. Here’s some of the things that caught our attention this week. This Week in Greater Auckland On Monday Matt asked how we can get better event trains and an option for grade separating Morningside Dr. On Tuesday Matt looked into ...
    Greater AucklandBy Greater Auckland
    5 days ago
  • That Word.
    Something you might not know about me is that I’m quite a stubborn person. No, really. I don’t much care for criticism I think’s unfair or that I disagree with. Few of us do I suppose.Back when I was a drinker I’d sometimes respond defensively, even angrily. There are things ...
    Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel
    5 days ago
  • The Hoon around the week to March 15
    Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāTL;DR: The five things that mattered in Aotearoa’s political economy that we wrote and spoke about via The Kākā and elsewhere for paying subscribers in the last week included:PM Christopher Luxon said the reversal of interest deductibility for landlords was done to help renters, who ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    5 days ago
  • Labour’s policy gap
    It was not so much the Labour Party but really the Chris Hipkins party yesterday at Labour’s caucus retreat in Martinborough. The former Prime Minister was more or less consistent on wealth tax, which he was at best equivocal about, and social insurance, which he was not willing to revisit. ...
    PolitikBy Richard Harman
    5 days ago
  • Skeptical Science New Research for Week #11 2024
    Open access notables A Glimpse into the Future: The 2023 Ocean Temperature and Sea Ice Extremes in the Context of Longer-Term Climate Change, Kuhlbrodt et al., Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society: In the year 2023, we have seen extraordinary extrema in high sea surface temperature (SST) in the North Atlantic and in ...
    5 days ago
  • Melissa remains mute on media matters but has something to say (at a sporting event) about economic ...
     Buzz from the Beehive   The text reproduced above appears on a page which records all the media statements and speeches posted on the government’s official website by Melissa Lee as Minister of Media and Communications and/or by Jenny Marcroft, her Parliamentary Under-secretary.  It can be quickly analysed ...
    Point of OrderBy Bob Edlin
    5 days ago
  • The return of Muldoon
    For forty years, Robert Muldoon has been a dirty word in our politics. His style of government was so repulsive and authoritarian that the backlash to it helped set and entrench our constitutional norms. His pig-headedness over forcing through Think Big eventually gave us the RMA, with its participation and ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    5 days ago
  • Will the rental tax cut improve life for renters or landlords?
    Bryce Edwards writes –  Is the new government reducing tax on rental properties to benefit landlords or to cut the cost of rents? That’s the big question this week, after Associate Finance Minister David Seymour announced on Sunday that the Government would be reversing the Labour Government’s removal ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    5 days ago
  • Geoffrey Miller: What Saudi Arabia’s rapid changes mean for New Zealand
    Saudi Arabia is rarely far from the international spotlight. The war in Gaza has brought new scrutiny to Saudi plans to normalise relations with Israel, while the fifth anniversary of the controversial killing of Jamal Khashoggi was marked shortly before the war began on October 7. And as the home ...
    Democracy ProjectBy Geoffrey Miller
    5 days ago
  • Racism’s double standards
    Questions need to be asked on both sides of the world Peter Williams writes –   The NRL Judiciary hands down an eight week suspension to Sydney Roosters forward Spencer Leniu , an Auckland-born Samoan, after he calls Ezra Mam, Sydney-orn but of Aboriginal and Torres Strait ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    5 days ago
  • It’s not a tax break
    Ele Ludemann writes – Contrary to what many headlines and news stories are saying, residential landlords are not getting a tax break. The government is simply restoring to them the tax deductibility of interest they had until the previous government removed it. There is no logical reason ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    5 days ago
  • The Plastic Pig Collective and Chris' Imaginary Friends.
    I can't remember when it was goodMoments of happiness in bloomMaybe I just misunderstoodAll of the love we left behindWatching our flashbacks intertwineMemories I will never findIn spite of whatever you becomeForget that reckless thing turned onI think our lives have just begunI think our lives have just begunDoes anyone ...
    Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel
    5 days ago
  • Who is responsible for young offenders?
    Michael Bassett writes – At first reading, a front-page story in the New Zealand Herald on 13 March was bizarre. A group of severely intellectually limited teenagers, with little understanding of the law, have been pleading to the Justice Select Committee not to pass a bill dealing with ram ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    5 days ago
  • Gordon Campbell on National’s fantasy trip to La La Landlord Land
    How much political capital is Christopher Luxon willing to burn through in order to deliver his $2.9 billion gift to landlords? Evidently, Luxon is: (a) unable to cost the policy accurately. As Anna Burns-Francis pointed out to him on Breakfast TV, the original ”rock solid” $2.1 billion cost he was ...
    5 days ago
  • Bernard's Top 10 @ 10 'pick 'n' mix' for March 14
    TL;DR: My top 10 news and analysis links this morning include:Today’s must-read: Jonathon Porritt calling bullshit in his own blog post on mainstream climate science as ‘The New Denialism’.Local scoop: The Wellington City Council’s list of proposed changes to the IHP recommendations to be debated later today was leaked this ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    5 days ago
  • No, Prime Minister, rents don’t rise or fall with landlords’ costs
    TL;DR: Prime Minister Christopher Luxon said yesterday tenants should be grateful for the reinstatement of interest deductibility because landlords would pass on their lower tax costs in the form of lower rents. That would be true if landlords were regulated monopolies such as Transpower or Auckland Airport1, but they’re not, ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    5 days ago
  • Cartoons: ‘At least I didn’t make things awkward’
    This is a re-post from Yale Climate Connections by Tom Toro Tom Toro is a cartoonist and author. He has published over 200 cartoons in The New Yorker since 2010. His cartoons appear in Playboy, the Paris Review, the New York Times, American Bystander, and elsewhere. Related: What 10 EV lovers ...
    5 days ago
  • Solving traffic congestion with Richard Prebble
    The business section of the NZ Herald is full of opinion. Among the more opinionated of all is the ex-Minister of Transport, ex-Minister of Railways, ex MP for Auckland Central (1975-93, Labour), Wellington Central (1996-99, ACT, then list-2005), ex-leader of the ACT Party, uncle to actor Antonia, the veritable granddaddy ...
    Greater AucklandBy Patrick Reynolds
    6 days ago
  • I Think I'm Done Flying Boeing
    Hi,Just quickly — I’m blown away by the stories you’ve shared with me over the last week since I put out the ‘Gary’ podcast, where I told you about the time my friend’s flatmate killed the neighbour.And you keep telling me stories — in the comments section, and in my ...
    David FarrierBy David Farrier
    6 days ago
  • Invoking Aristotle: Of Rings of Power, Stones, and Ships
    The first season of Rings of Power was not awful. It was thoroughly underwhelming, yes, and left a lingering sense of disappointment, but it was more expensive mediocrity than catastrophe. I wrote at length about the series as it came out (see the Review section of the blog, and go ...
    6 days ago
  • Van Velden brings free-market approach to changing labour laws – but her colleagues stick to distr...
    Buzz from the Beehive Workplace Relations and Safety Minister Brooke van Velden told Auckland Business Chamber members they were the first audience to hear her priorities as a minister in a government committed to cutting red tape and regulations. She brandished her liberalising credentials, saying Flexible labour markets are the ...
    Point of OrderBy Bob Edlin
    6 days ago
  • Why Newshub failed
    Chris Trotter writes – TO UNDERSTAND WHY NEWSHUB FAILED, it is necessary to understand how TVNZ changed. Up until 1989, the state broadcaster had been funded by a broadcasting licence fee, collected from every citizen in possession of a television set, supplemented by a relatively modest (compared ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    6 days ago
  • Māori Party on the warpath against landlords and seabed miners – let’s see if mystical creature...
    Bob Edlin writes  –  The Māori Party has been busy issuing a mix of warnings and threats as its expresses its opposition to interest deductibility for landlords and the plans of seabed miners. It remains to be seen whether they  follow the example of indigenous litigants in Australia, ...
    Point of OrderBy Bob Edlin
    6 days ago

  • Government moves to quickly ratify the NZ-EU FTA
    "The Government is moving quickly to realise an additional $46 million in tariff savings in the EU market this season for Kiwi exporters,” Minister for Trade and Agriculture, Todd McClay says. Parliament is set, this week, to complete the final legislative processes required to bring the New Zealand – European ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 hours ago
  • Positive progress for social worker workforce
    New Zealand’s social workers are qualified, experienced, and more representative of the communities they serve, Social Development and Employment Minister Louise Upston says. “I want to acknowledge and applaud New Zealand’s social workers for the hard work they do, providing invaluable support for our most vulnerable. “To coincide with World ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    8 hours ago
  • Minister confirms reduced RUC rate for PHEVs
    Cabinet has agreed to a reduced road user charge (RUC) rate for plug-in hybrid electric vehicles (PHEVs), Transport Minister Simeon Brown says. Owners of PHEVs will be eligible for a reduced rate of $38 per 1,000km once all light electric vehicles (EVs) move into the RUC system from 1 April.  ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    10 hours ago
  • Trade access to overseas markets creates jobs
    Minister of Agriculture and Trade, Todd McClay, says that today’s opening of Riverland Foods manufacturing plant in Christchurch is a great example of how trade access to overseas markets creates jobs in New Zealand.  Speaking at the official opening of this state-of-the-art pet food factory the Minister noted that exports ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    11 hours ago
  • NZ and Chinese Foreign Ministers hold official talks
    Minister of Foreign Affairs Winston Peters met with Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi in Wellington today. “It was a pleasure to host Foreign Minister Wang Yi during his first official visit to New Zealand since 2017. Our discussions were wide-ranging and enabled engagement on many facets of New Zealand’s relationship with China, including trade, ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 day ago
  • Kāinga Ora instructed to end Sustaining Tenancies
    Kāinga Ora – Homes & Communities has been instructed to end the Sustaining Tenancies Framework and take stronger measures against persistent antisocial behaviour by tenants, says Housing Minister Chris Bishop. “Earlier today Finance Minister Nicola Willis and I sent an interim Letter of Expectations to the Board of Kāinga Ora. ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 day ago
  • Speech to Auckland Business Chamber: Growth is the answer
    Tēna koutou katoa. Greetings everyone. Thank you to the Auckland Chamber of Commerce and the Honourable Simon Bridges for hosting this address today. I acknowledge the business leaders in this room, the leaders and governors, the employers, the entrepreneurs, the investors, and the wealth creators. The coalition Government shares your ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Singapore rounds out regional trip
    Minister Winston Peters completed the final leg of his visit to South and South East Asia in Singapore today, where he focused on enhancing one of New Zealand’s indispensable strategic partnerships.      “Singapore is our most important defence partner in South East Asia, our fourth-largest trading partner and a ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Minister van Velden represents New Zealand at International Democracy Summit
    Minister of Internal Affairs and Workplace Relations and Safety, Hon. Brooke van Velden, will travel to the Republic of Korea to represent New Zealand at the Third Summit for Democracy on 18 March. The summit, hosted by the Republic of Korea, was first convened by the United States in 2021, ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Insurance Council of NZ Speech, 7 March 2024, Auckland
    ICNZ Speech 7 March 2024, Auckland  Acknowledgements and opening  Mōrena, ngā mihi nui. Ko Andrew Bayly aho, Nor Whanganui aho.  Good morning, it’s a privilege to be here to open the ICNZ annual conference, thank you to Mark for the Mihi Whakatau  My thanks to Tim Grafton for inviting me ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Five-year anniversary of Christchurch terror attacks
    Prime Minister Christopher Luxon and Lead Coordination Minister Judith Collins have expressed their deepest sympathy on the five-year anniversary of the Christchurch terror attacks. “March 15, 2019, was a day when families, communities and the country came together both in sorrow and solidarity,” Mr Luxon says.  “Today we pay our respects to the 51 shuhada ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Speech for Financial Advice NZ Conference 5 March 2024
    Speech for Financial Advice NZ Conference 5 March 2024  Acknowledgements and opening  Morena, Nga Mihi Nui.  Ko Andrew Bayly aho, Nor Whanganui aho. Thanks Nate for your Mihi Whakatau  Good morning. It’s a pleasure to formally open your conference this morning. What a lovely day in Wellington, What a great ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Early visit to Indonesia strengthens ties
    Foreign Minister Winston Peters held discussions in Jakarta today about the future of relations between New Zealand and South East Asia’s most populous country.   “We are in Jakarta so early in our new government’s term to reflect the huge importance we place on our relationship with Indonesia and South ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • China Foreign Minister to visit
    Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Foreign Affairs Winston Peters has announced that the Foreign Minister of China, Wang Yi, will visit New Zealand next week.  “We look forward to re-engaging with Foreign Minister Wang Yi and discussing the full breadth of the bilateral relationship, which is one of New Zealand’s ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Minister opens new Auckland Rail Operations Centre
    Transport Minister Simeon Brown has today opened the new Auckland Rail Operations Centre, which will bring together KiwiRail, Auckland Transport, and Auckland One Rail to improve service reliability for Aucklanders. “The recent train disruptions in Auckland have highlighted how important it is KiwiRail and Auckland’s rail agencies work together to ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Celebrating 10 years of Crankworx Rotorua
    The Government is proud to support the 10th edition of Crankworx Rotorua as the Crankworx World Tour returns to Rotorua from 16-24 March 2024, says Minister for Economic Development Melissa Lee.  “Over the past 10 years as Crankworx Rotorua has grown, so too have the economic and social benefits that ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Government delivering on tax commitments
    Legislation implementing coalition Government tax commitments and addressing long-standing tax anomalies will be progressed in Parliament next week, Finance Minister Nicola Willis says. The legislation is contained in an Amendment Paper to the Taxation (Annual Rates for 2023–24, Multinational Tax, and Remedial Matters) Bill issued today.  “The Amendment Paper represents ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Significant Natural Areas requirement to be suspended
    Associate Environment Minister Andrew Hoggard has today announced that the Government has agreed to suspend the requirement for councils to comply with the Significant Natural Areas (SNA) provisions of the National Policy Statement for Indigenous Biodiversity for three years, while it replaces the Resource Management Act (RMA).“As it stands, SNAs ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Government classifies drought conditions in Top of the South as medium-scale adverse event
    Agriculture Minister Todd McClay has classified the drought conditions in the Marlborough, Tasman, and Nelson districts as a medium-scale adverse event, acknowledging the challenging conditions facing farmers and growers in the district. “Parts of Marlborough, Tasman, and Nelson districts are in the grip of an intense dry spell. I know ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Government partnership to tackle $332m facial eczema problem
    The Government is helping farmers eradicate the significant impact of facial eczema (FE) in pastoral animals, Agriculture Minister Todd McClay announced.  “A $20 million partnership jointly funded by Beef + Lamb NZ, the Government, and the primary sector will save farmers an estimated NZD$332 million per year, and aims to ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • NZ, India chart path to enhanced relationship
    Foreign Minister Winston Peters has completed a successful visit to India, saying it was an important step in taking the relationship between the two countries to the next level.   “We have laid a strong foundation for the Coalition Government’s priority of enhancing New Zealand-India relations to generate significant future benefit for both countries,” says Mr Peters, ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Ruapehu Alpine Lifts bailout the last, say Ministers
    Cabinet has agreed to provide $7 million to ensure the 2024 ski season can go ahead on the Whakapapa ski field in the central North Island but has told the operator Ruapehu Alpine Lifts it is the last financial support it will receive from taxpayers. Cabinet also agreed to provide ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Govt takes action to drive better cancer services
    Health Minister Dr Shane Reti says the launch of a new mobile breast screening unit in Counties Manukau reinforces the coalition Government’s commitment to drive better cancer services for all New Zealanders. Speaking at the launch of the new mobile clinic, Dr Reti says it’s a great example of taking ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Govt takes action to drive better cancer services
    Health Minister Dr Shane Reti says the launch of a new mobile breast screening unit in Counties Manukau reinforces the coalition Government’s commitment to drive better cancer services for all New Zealanders. Speaking at the launch of the new mobile clinic, Dr Reti says it’s a great example of taking ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Work begins on SH29 upgrades near Tauriko
    Unlocking economic growth and land for housing are critical elements of the Government’s plan for our transport network, and planned upgrades to State Highway 29 (SH29) near Tauriko will deliver strongly on those priorities, Transport Minister Simeon Brown says. “The SH29 upgrades near Tauriko will improve safety at the intersections ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Work begins on SH29 upgrades near Tauriko
    Unlocking economic growth and land for housing are critical elements of the Government’s plan for our transport network, and planned upgrades to State Highway 29 (SH29) near Tauriko will deliver strongly on those priorities, Transport Minister Simeon Brown says. “The SH29 upgrades near Tauriko will improve safety at the intersections ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Fresh produce price drop welcome
    Lower fruit and vegetable prices are welcome news for New Zealanders who have been doing it tough at the supermarket, Finance Minister Nicola Willis says. Stats NZ reported today the price of fruit and vegetables has dropped 9.3 percent in the 12 months to February 2024.  “Lower fruit and vege ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Statement to the 68th United Nations Commission on the Status of Women
    Tēnā koutou katoa and greetings to you all.  Chair, I am honoured to address the sixty-eighth session of the Commission on the Status of Women. I acknowledge the many crises impacting the rights of women and girls. Heightened global tensions, war, climate related and humanitarian disasters, and price inflation all ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Speech to the 68th United Nations Commission on the Status of Women (CSW68)
    Tēnā koutou katoa and greetings to you all.  Chair, I am honoured to address the 68th session of the Commission on the Status of Women. I acknowledge the many crises impacting the rights of women and girls. Heightened global tensions, war, climate related and humanitarian disasters, and price inflation all ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Government backs rural led catchment projects
    The coalition Government is supporting farmers to enhance land management practices by investing $3.3 million in locally led catchment groups, Agriculture Minister Todd McClay announced. “Farmers and growers deliver significant prosperity for New Zealand and it’s vital their ongoing efforts to improve land management practices and water quality are supported,” ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Speech to Auckland Business Chamber
    Good evening everyone and thank you for that lovely introduction.   Thank you also to the Honourable Simon Bridges for the invitation to address your members. Since being sworn in, this coalition Government has hit the ground running with our 100-day plan, delivering the changes that New Zealanders expect of us. ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Commission’s advice on ETS settings tabled
    Recommendations from the Climate Change Commission for New Zealand on the Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS) auction and unit limit settings for the next five years have been tabled in Parliament, Climate Change Minister Simon Watts says. “The Commission provides advice on the ETS annually. This is the third time the ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Government lowering building costs
    The coalition Government is beginning its fight to lower building costs and reduce red tape by exempting minor building work from paying the building levy, says Building and Construction Minister Chris Penk. “Currently, any building project worth $20,444 including GST or more is subject to the building levy which is ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Trustee tax change welcomed
    Proposed changes to tax legislation to prevent the over-taxation of low-earning trusts are welcome, Finance Minister Nicola Willis says. The changes have been recommended by Parliament’s Finance and Expenditure Committee following consideration of submissions on the Taxation (Annual Rates for 2023–24, Multinational Tax, and Remedial Matters) Bill. “One of the ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Minister’s Ramadan message
    Assalaamu alaikum. السَّلَام عليكم In light of the holy month of Ramadan, I want to extend my warmest wishes to our Muslim community in New Zealand. Ramadan is a time for spiritual reflection, renewed devotion, perseverance, generosity, and forgiveness.  It’s a time to strengthen our bonds and appreciate the diversity ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Minister appoints new NZTA Chair
    Former Transport Minister and CEO of the Auckland Business Chamber Hon Simon Bridges has been appointed as the new Board Chair of the New Zealand Transport Agency (NZTA) for a three-year term, Transport Minister Simeon Brown announced today. “Simon brings extensive experience and knowledge in transport policy and governance to the role. He will ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Speech to Life Sciences Summit
    Good morning all, it is a pleasure to be here as Minister of Science, Innovation and Technology.  It is fantastic to see how connected and collaborative the life science and biotechnology industry is here in New Zealand. I would like to thank BioTechNZ and NZTech for the invitation to address ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Progress continues apace on water storage
    Regional Development Minister Shane Jones says he is looking forward to the day when three key water projects in Northland are up and running, unlocking the full potential of land in the region. Mr Jones attended a community event at the site of the Otawere reservoir near Kerikeri on Friday. ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Government agrees to restore interest deductions
    Associate Finance Minister David Seymour has today announced that the Government has agreed to restore deductibility for mortgage interest on residential investment properties. “Help is on the way for landlords and renters alike. The Government’s restoration of interest deductibility will ease pressure on rents and simplify the tax code,” says ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Minister to attend World Anti-Doping Agency Symposium
    Sport and Recreation Minister Chris Bishop will travel to Switzerland today to attend an Executive Committee meeting and Symposium of the World Anti-Doping Agency (WADA). Mr Bishop will then travel on to London where he will attend a series of meetings in his capacity as Infrastructure Minister. “New Zealanders believe ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago

Page generated in The Standard by Wordpress at 2024-03-19T07:13:51+00:00