Clark takes round 2

Written By: - Date published: 8:36 pm, November 3rd, 2008 - 149 comments
Categories: election 2008, helen clark, john key - Tags:

A much better performance from Clark saw her best Key in tonight’s debate.

As well as being on top of all the issues, as always, she took the fight to Key, calling him up on his lies. After not doing as well as she had expected in the first debate, Clark had adapted.

Key was weak and, enitrely predictably, he stuck to the same forumla that had won him through last time (interrupting Clark, keeping it vague, and running those same old lies). He even looked scared when Campbell asked him about National’s old neo-liberals on the front-bench. He looked very bad when he made a personal attack on Cullen. He started reasonably strongly but seemed actually physically tired by the end.

Clark was visionary at moments too. The defining moment of the debate was when the leaders were asked about freedom. Clark said her purpose in politics is to create more freedom for people – through better education, better health, more jobs, and higher wages. That’s what real freedom in the social democratic ideal is about, freeing people from the constraints of the class they are born into in a capitalist system. Key’s response on freedom was ‘lightbulbs, they’re taking away our lightbulbs’. It made him look petty and small-minded.

At that point, we had the measure of them both. We saw that Clark’s politics arises from deep, principled conviction. We saw that Key is about jumping on the latest populist bandwagon.

149 comments on “Clark takes round 2 ”

  1. marco 1

    I agree Clark won that debate, but Key didnt make any fatal errors and I have to say I agree with the pundits from TV3 right at the end, with the Melbourne Cup tomorrow and the American election and its aftermath about to consume the rest of the week it was to little to late to make a difference to Saturday.

  2. I think you need to open the other eye, Clark was visionary????

    This debate did nothing for Labour or even National, which is good for national since they are ahead in all polls.

  3. bobo 3

    Labour written off by the debates commentators, can’t get over how they say both parties are exactly the same when its National who have adopted most of Labours policies to get in, the parties ideology are opposites.

    Cambell on the whole was better than weak old Sainsbury on TV1 , Key looked more defensive and couldn’t come up with a 3rd example of Nanny state apart from phased out light bulbs and shower heads..

    Another interesting reference Key made was to call the Maori vote a “franchise” which made the indigenous people of New Zealand sound like a KFC outlet..

  4. brett. but you’ll be casting your vote for NZF eh? That’s where your beliefs lie and I believe you’ve expressed opposition to tactical voting.

  5. mike 5

    You weren’t watching tonights debate SP.
    I loved the bit where Clark invited Key to interupt as she thought he would stumble and he took it by the scruff of the neck – she looked very silly.

    All 3 of the commentators (including 2 lefties) said at the end that helens gone – sorry kids but it’s all over.

  6. r0b 6

    Good summary Steve.

    I was disappointed in the post debate commentary however – shallow stuff. Especially the woman form Farifax (forget the name) – her ACT agenda was pretty full on and coloured everything she said. Disappointing.

  7. coge 7

    That was no debate. More like marriage guidance councelling. Anyone else get that impression?

  8. tsmithfield 8

    I have to agree that Clark had more energy in this debate. She needed to, though, given the monumental Williams stuff-up and the continuing Peter’s sideshow. It came across as a desperate rescue mission on her part.

    It now seems clear that Peter’s is not going to make it back. Even Clark seems to accept that. So, there is probably one less coalition partner on the left. If NZ first doesn’t make it back, their votes that will be effectively redistributed undoubtably in National’s favour. The Williams fiasco has killed off any “trust” arguement for Labour.

    So, even if Clark came out slightly ahead in a very boring debate, I doubt it is going to make much difference at all.

    I was so bored with this debate; very predictable and sanitised. I don’t think I’ll watch the next one. I have decided I was voting National weeks ago anyway. If I watch much more of this tripe I’ll end up voting Act.

  9. Ianmac 9

    Yes the experts at the end were a bit strange. Actually good to see people other than the same old political hacks and really pleased that they kept Garner well away.
    They all thought that Key will be the next PM yet they were very luke-warm about his leadership qualities. I think that Helen was formidable but she gets criticized for that. It is true that there were no charismatic moments but the Centre has made elbow room impossible.
    If National do get in I think that they will bring in the hidden right policies with the excuse that “It is the Economy that forced us to do this stupid!” If John is removed as PM then Bill or whoever, will say but John said that not us. Expediency!

  10. Tane 10

    r0b, it’s Jenni McManus, class warrior for the bosses and journalist at the Independent. The change she’s after, according to a recent column, is extreme right-wing labour law that would make the ECA look weak.

    You’d never see a commentator as left-wing as she is right-wing allowed on the television.

  11. Akldnut 11

    The proof is in the pudding and every dog has it’s day and it’s not over till the fat lady sings, or until the final whistle blows so all you tories who are so quick to pass judgement had better not count your eggs until they’re hatched.
    Done it before – you’ll no doubt do it again, might be at your peril again.
    BTW mike how many got it right last time. Methinks none of those clowns!!!

  12. higherstandard 12

    According to John Campbell I expect he won the debate jumped up twit that he is.

  13. r0b 13

    r0b, it’s Jenni McManus, class warrior for the bosses and journalist at the Independent.

    Cheers Tane. Guess I’m not an Independent reader eh!

    You’d never see a commentator as left-wing as she is right-wing allowed on the television.

    Given her performance tonight let’s hope they won’t be calling on her services again.

  14. mike 14

    “BTW mike how many got it right last time. Methinks none of those clowns!!!”

    Its all about momentum and thanks to Mr Williams and Mr Peters its all Nationals now.

    Think how much different things would have been if she had acted bravely and ditched those two liabilities months ago!

  15. Akldnut 15

    Ianmac “If John is removed as PM then Bill or whoever, will say but John said that not us”

    And what will happen about his personal guarantee on his pledge card? “But John pledged that not us”

  16. Lew 16

    Anyone got a copy of the video which doesn’t require the fucking worthless tv3 website to function? Youtube would be fine.


  17. Kinoy001 17

    That debate was won by Helen Clark. She did a great job of showing NZ the awful flip flops that JK has made.
    He got way to much airtime tonight and John Campbell just let it happen. That analysis was also a joke….. That Jenni was awful.

    Does anyone know when the next poll is coming out? Hasnt been any for a while…. Surely tommorow???

    would love to hear from anyone???

  18. Francois 18

    I think it’s quite sad that Campbell is one of the most fair and effective debate moderators/commentators around…

  19. Danny 19

    Key appears more like a 90’s Nat with every appearance he makes.

    He also lacked energy, which is suprising.

  20. Ianmac 20

    Bet the text poll will crown John Boy King. I sent two for Helen just to see if I could and they went through. Pity the technology couldn’t stop multiple votes.The computer ones can do multiples by the thousand with a simple piece of software.

  21. tsmithfield 21

    The way Key was debating, it was as if he was playing it really safe; basically running the clock down without letting in any last minute trys that might destabilise a won position.

    On the other hand, Clark was playing it as if she knew she was well behind and had to attack with all her energy to score an unlikely victory.

  22. Carol 22

    Someone said there’s a poll out Thursday.

  23. Clark calling herself ” a free spirit” was the unintentional comedy gold moment of the whole debate…

  24. Akldnut 24

    WTF was that thing on the big screen – showed absolutely nothing to me and who was it polling to get those lines?
    Was somebody hooked up to a heart moniter at some stage? opps sorry it must’ve been Key cause he was flatlining throughout the whole thing!!!

  25. Daveski 25

    Who needs the Dim Post when you’ve got SP an ode to Helen.

    This will be a fascinating place to be next week although there won’t be a lot of room – what with all those chickens looking for somewhere to roost.

  26. Steve

    I have given NZfirst my party in the last two elections, not this time, its a straight out, National/National for me.

    But yeah your right, I don’t like tactical voting.

  27. I share the commentators’ frustration. I could not work out the policy differences. I do not agree with them however that there are two centerist parties.

    The national “me too” campaign was alive and well. If national were going to be centre left and continue the policies of Helen and Labour then I would be relieved if they won. The only problem is that I do not trust them and I fear for my country if they win.

  28. Bill 28

    Maybe the debate should merely have let the politicians speak for themselves using their own words.

    Like JK here. If you haven’t seen this, it’s a must. John wants the money and trade at any cost.

    In fact. Labour should have run this as an ad rather than the insipid ‘mother and babe’ trash.

  29. mike 29

    Looks like Armstrong disagrees with you SP

  30. Monty 30

    Not a good day for the socialists – Firstly two of the highest profile and respected Samoans have endorsed John Key. That is huge – and will be worth a few more points to the Nats. Then in the debate … – well don’t take my word for John Key winning – take respected (left leaning ) journalist John Armstrong’s word

    “The pressure was on her to land some telling hits on John Key. She failed to do so. That is one reason why, if there has to be a winner, it was Key. He was even more self-assured and thus more relaxed than three weeks ago.

    The other reason why Key took the honours was his decision to talk positive, while Clark, forced on the attack, correspondingly sounded more negative and abrasive.”

    I suppose Clark better start clearing out her office. Aftert he debate I put the Veuve Clicquot Ponsardin (Brut) in the fridge to be nice and chilled for Saturday Afternoon (exit polls will give it to the Nats in a landslide by then.

  31. Monty 31

    BB – I thought the comedy moment when the PM in waiting said the difference between Cullen and Bill English was that Bill English had charm.

    John looked very good and Clark was just nasty agressive and looks resigned to a massive Labour defeat.

  32. Smokie 32

    Mike – You’re fucking perceptive aren’t you? The Herald called it a narrow Key victory? Well blow me down, blow me up again, and call me Peter Dunne’s hair-do. That’s a surprise.

    I think Linda Clark was right when she called it for Helen Clark. She was by any objective measure the better debater – no matter whether you agree with her or not.

  33. John 33

    It’s over.
    The stupid stupid decision to send Mike Williams to Aussie last week has cost NZ a centre-left govt. The Greens have yet again been shafted by Labour.

  34. Rodel 34

    The loser tonight was Campbell- and us. You did the NZ public a disservice Mr Campbell,seeking attention like Donkey in Shrek, “Pick me! Pick me! and as for the bunch of Paris Hilton soundalikes (including the guy) on the panel.

    Why Oh why can’t we get TV presenters who can ask insightful questions instead of acting like a child? and ….Why Oh why can’t we get non confabulating analysts?
    Even an analyst who could anchor onto just one fact would do.Couldn’t we get a bunch of POLSCI 101 students.They’d have much more depth than celebrity journalists.

    Is there a journalist in NZ with some degree of intellect who can give an honest considered account of what’s going on. Maybe all the real journalists have gone offshore.The Fairfax one was appalling, the university guy was shallow.Linda Clark nearly got there but they all failed to demonstrate anything but fluffy fabrications- about as empty and meaningless as John Key’s ‘oh so genuine’ compassionate philosophy I guess.
    Grizzle Grizzle!!

  35. Smokie 35

    Monty, if you’re seriously calling John Armstrong a left-leaning journalist, you’ve the got the political intelligence of a squashed ant.

  36. r0b 36

    John looked very good and Clark was just nasty agressive and looks resigned to a massive Labour defeat.

    Yeah righto Monty – in your dreams!

  37. Monty

    They are two rich ex all blacks. Their complaint about the anti maiming bill is difficult to understand because National supported it.

    I suspect that Lockwood Smith’s comments more than compensate for this. The Samoans that I have talked to will never forgive National for this. Arthur Anae’s comments were especially helpful.

    Key talked Crosby Textor. After the end I felt like I had been to McDonalds, eaten a lot but felt bloated and dissatisfied.

  38. GordonF 38

    Monty, you need to lay off the bevvy.
    Both the ex All Blacks are right wing christians, against civil union for example. Backed Graham (sp) Capill in a previous election!!
    Sorry, but I have yet to hear John Key make a positive statement, it’s all “look at how bad Labour have been” Followed by the standard quotes (lies).
    Don’t choke on the plonk:-)

  39. Akldnut 39

    They should have just gone outside and had a punch up. I reckon Helen would have delt to him in that too.

  40. Fred 40

    TV1, TV3 – Fair debates – it’s all a joke! ‘Panel of so-called ‘experts’? – any one could see that Helen clearly won this debate, giving plenty of eloquent,strong answers . The Herald are also saying no-one won??? WTF….
    Hopefully… the public can see how the media are attempting to control them and manipulate the outcome of this election.
    Polls??? I have never been polled (and I am 54) or know anybody who has been polled. Who is actually polled?

  41. Tamaki resident 41

    I didn’t see the debate, but as the best that Farrar could come up with was “CLARK AND KEY COME OUT EVEN IN SECOND LEADERS DEBATE” from NZPA, on that basis I would give it to Clark.

  42. Mike Collins 42

    I thought the smaller parties’ debate was much better personally.

  43. Speaking about polls, why has there been no national poll results over the past week or so? I seem to recall last time that we were awash with them.

  44. Daveski 44

    Yep, the NZH got it wrong, Stuff stuffed up, every journalist in NZ who didn’t say Clark won got it wrong.

    At least the panel got it right about Batman too.

  45. r0b 45

    Polls??? I have never been polled (and I am 54) or know anybody who has been polled. Who is actually polled?

    I’m a bit of a cynic about polls, but I can report that I was polled (for the first time ever) tonight on voting intentions.

    I was happy to report that I have already voted, two ticks for Labour.

  46. randal 46

    because “they” know that the more “they” press the case for keys the more the people will go off him
    no substance to the man and the electorate knows it
    now its all cheese to the finish line

  47. Akldnut 47

    Daveski I think you can add yourself to the list whadya reckon!

  48. ziuzou 48

    Monty –
    John Armstrong as a left-leaning journalist?! You need to read more…

    As a Samoan, I am outraged that Michael Jones and Vaiga Tuigamala use their short-sighted Christian conservative values to support National. They forget about the traumas their previous generation went through under Muldoon in the 1980s and the Nats in the 1990s. MJ and VT rail against what they personally disagree with and this is an endorsement? As the Chinese curse goes “Be careful for what you wish for…

  49. Rex 49

    I am very disapointed in how Helen is handling the ex-all blacks National endorsement.

    Wouldn’t it be better to ignore it? She will only come off second best by having a go at them. Both are very popular.

    The All Blacks even changed what day they play tests to suit Michael Jones.

    Also, I don’t understand why people say their is no difference between national and Labour. Why is that? Because National will not roll back Labour’s policies like Working for Families? I believe the changes they will make differentiate the Parties.
    Surely it would cost a lot of money for National to roll back Labour policies?

    What policies of Roger Douglas has Labour rolled back? Same reason, they become entrenched and cant be changed easily.

    I will be honest, Labour lost my vote with the Electoral Finance Act. I just hope that if they lose this election, they see it as an opportunity to introduce new blood and take the party back to its former greatness.

    I believe John Key won the debate as he at least attempted to provide a vision. A vision that didn’t just rely on bringing the building of new state housing forward.

  50. Pixie 50

    Monty said: “The other reason why Key took the honours was his decision to talk positive, while Clark, forced on the attack, correspondingly sounded more negative and abrasive.”

    Helen Clark at least started talking about what Labour has done and intends to do. John Key’s opening was to throw rocks at Labour. And he spent a large part of the debate doing much the same.

    Making the Govt the problem without offering alternatives may be a justifiable strategy when you’re in opposition, but not when you’re tipped to take over as PM in less than a week – especially when we are facing the biggest financial challenges in nearly 80 years.

    I’ve been more than open to being swept off my feet by National this Election. But I’m afraid that I am totally underwhelmed.

    Then again, Helen looked tired and strained tonight.

    So.. I’ve finally decided to party vote Green.

  51. Dan 51

    John Key with the two ex All Blacks tonight looked fascinating. It was hardly sports jocks support John, but the black suits behind looked very Destiny Church. Conservative church, but not the Brethren this time.

  52. Akldnut 52

    Randal – totally agree. Funny how even Mamanus said she thinks he’s quite likely to go back on everything he says. Even amongst ardent righties they don’t trust him

  53. Alexandra 53


    “All 3 of the commentators (including 2 lefties) said at the end that helens gone – sorry kids but it’s all over.”

    The conclusions of the commentors, may well give confidence to the right. However, the remarkable prime time verdict will serve as a reminder of what is at stake should a National and Act be elected to govern. Rather than the serve the interests of the right, the opinions of all three provide a real incentive for people on the left, and the undecided to make their vote count. Your smug celebration of a national win is premature, given the clear message from the very right and self righteous Jenny McManus, that Key will say anything to be PM!

  54. r0b 54

    I will be honest, Labour lost my vote with the Electoral Finance Act.

    And National didn’t lose it with the underhand 2005 campaign where the public outrage cost the National Party their last leader, and that made the EFA necessary? Takes all sorts I suppose.

  55. Ianmac 55

    Bill @ 9:24. What a hoot Youtube. Great Parliamentary TV, and wouldn’t it leave a sharp image/impact!

  56. Daveski 56

    Akldnut – I hate it when one of you makes me laugh 🙂

  57. Matthew Pilott 57

    Jeez monty, what are you, lower middle class white trash?

    The Veuve Clicquot Ponsardin Brut goes in the chiller with the chardonnay, not a bloody fridge. It’s not a 6-pack you’re cooling down for the game y’know. Besides, if you think it’s something worth celebrating you could at least crack out a Louis Roederer ’02 or something decent.

  58. Rex 58

    r0b, National 2005 is a different party to National 2008.

    The only thing I can actually remember about the 2005 aftermath was Winston suing and Labour being asked to pay back money?

    I only get political every 3 years.

  59. Ianmac 59

    If Nats win I wonder what they will actually do? Stay centred or self-centred?
    And Mistress McManus was very clever in predicting the downturn of the Economy a year ago even though so far it has been a Money crisis with Economy to follow in a month or two.

  60. r0b 60

    National 2005 is a different party to National 2008.

    No Rex, the lineup is almost identical. Brash is gone, Key took over, the rest of the front bench is almost unchanged.

    The only thing I can actually remember about the 2005 aftermath was Winston suing and Labour being asked to pay back money?

    So the Don Brash’s secret deals with the Brethren for a covert $1.3 million advertising campaign, his lies about it, being caught in his lies, and his subsequent resignation, all that has slipped your memory?

    I only get political every 3 years.

    A longer term perspective might give you more insight in to what the parties are offering once every three years, and their credibility.

  61. Rex 61

    r0b – im not trying to be inflammatory.

    What were Labour asked to pay back money for?

  62. John 62

    What possessed Labour to adopt an American style campaign??
    Kiwis generally can’t stand W or Palin and don’t like negative name calling. All Labour had to do was keep it positive.
    Hodgson and Williams have significantly under delivered in terms of strategy.

  63. Jon 63

    Matthew Pilott, you show your ignorance again. Put Veuve in the refrigerator an hour and half before serving – or in an ice bucket with an ice-water mixture at least 20 minutes before serving. For vintage-dated you should let the bottle then warm up a bit if you don”t want to miss out on the mature character for which you would be paying extra.

    Stick with your cheap chardonnay Matthew. You can share your casks with all your friends

  64. FRANcOwsarse 64

    Once again key didn’t have any specifics on what he would do – just attacked the labour record.

    the rapidly deteriorating Campbell, (though better than papa smurf)- just got in the way too often, surely he could of orchestrated just one news-worthy moment.

    He would not let Clark get started on an answer before changing the subject, yet on most occasions let key complete his debate winning banalities

    thank goodness for small mercies – the smug, rotund & usually wrong gardner nowhere to be seen.

    Now the long campaign to slay Winston is almost over & the pundits unanimous, – the message for the remaining days appears to be to tell the National base that it’s safe to vote ACT.

    Though unlike the US this one does not smell like a landslide

  65. Chris G 65

    Rex: “r0b, National 2005 is a different party to National 2008.”

    Worst call of the day award. Look at the party list, compare and contrast.

    Monty: Spoke of two samoans endorsing Key,
    “two of the highest profile and respected Samoans have endorsed John Key. That is huge – and will be worth a few more points to the Nats”

    The fact that they are christian conservatives eg. didnt like civil union. Doesnt suprise me in the slightest as to who they vote for… Point of information please?

    And as for their high profile and respect….What about TV personality Oscar Kightley, rappers Savage and Scribe all giving their support to Labour. You act as if the Nats got some killer blow. When there are a number of Samoan high profiles who support Labour.

  66. r0b 66

    r0b – im not trying to be inflammatory. What were Labour asked to pay back money for?

    All parties in parliament receive an allocation of public money for publicity and advertising, but they are not supposed to use this for “electioneering”. This money is administered (spent) by parliamentary services at the request of the parties.

    After the last election all parties (except the Progressives) were found to have asked for, and had approved, spending on material that the Auditor General considered to be electioneering. All parties (including ACT and National) were judged to have got it wrong – even the Greens, whose MP Rod Donald had written the rules! Labour was the party with the largest sum involved.

    Although not legally required to do so (legally this was inappropriate spending by parliamentary services) all parties (eventually sort of including NZ First / Winston) as a sign of good faith refunded the money which the Auditor General judged had been spent on inappropriate electioneering.

  67. bobo 67

    Just curious do prisoners get to vote? As all the libertarians go on about their rights..

  68. Mike Collins 68

    Prisoners don’t get to vote. I have never personally heard a libertarian say they should be able to either. I have heard libertarians say that only those that contribute in taxes (ie net tax payer) should be able to vote, as why should someone be able to vote themselves someone elses money.

  69. Lew 69

    bobo: I think you’re mistaking civil libertarians (ie, people affiliated with, for instance, the Civil Liberties Union, who tend to believe people hold innate rights by virtue of being human) for Libertarians (who tend to believe in liberty until it impinges upon their property rights, at which point people lose all their liberties).


  70. Tane 70

    Mike, you wonder why people confuse right-libertarianism with fascism. “They’re completely different!” you lot say.

    When you start talking about taking away the franchise they both just look like systems designed to entrench the power of those at the top and keep the weak in their place.

  71. bobo 71

    Sorry civil libertarians , amazing what a difference the word “civil” can make..

  72. Mike Collins 72

    Tane I never said I agreed with it, I’ve just heard it said. People that make that comparison (between fascism and libertarianism) in my opinion are usually intelligent, but are being mischievous. They know it is false. Mind you I suppose I could say the way you lefties go on about class systems and bosses vs workers, that you are communists. That would be a tad cheeky though.

    Lew, you are so far wrong with that comment. Libertarians hold that each person should be able to lead the life they choose, so long as they don’t impinge on anyones else’s rights to life, liberty and property. In that sense liberty isn’t defined as something which is given by the state and curtailed at whim.

  73. Tane 73

    Mike, glad to hear it’s not something you agree with. It is, however, something I’ve heard a fair few libertarians argue, and there is a strong anti-democratic current throughout Randian thought. But anyway, this isn’t the thread to argue it. Perhaps another time.

  74. I didn’t watch the two party debates – either one.

    I refuse to support the softening-up process of the campaign already underway to dump MMP if National finds itself able to put up a referendum on it.

    The NZ Herald has – for the same reason – declared all parties other than Labour and National as surplus to (their) requirements.

    ….and they have the gall to accuse Labour of arrogance!

    It would be bad fiction if you read it in a novel.

  75. Lew 75

    Mike: “so long as they don’t impinge on anyones else’s rights to life, liberty and property”

    Right – at which point all their rights end. That was my ultimate point, nothing to do with the state. Because ultimately it doesn’t matter who deprives you of your rights.

    It’s the matter of proportion with which true-blue don’t tread on me libertarians normally take a few too many, erm, liberties.


  76. Jared 76

    Do you think TheStandard could ever call a debate in Nationals favour…ever? Im starting to get used to the fact that everytime a debate rolls around, or a contentious issue where Labour are actually worse off, the Standard almost never reflects this sentiment. Could Helen ever do wrong?

    [I wrote that Key won the first debate. SP]

  77. Lew 77

    Jared: How about the first Key v Clark debate on One, which Steve called (like everyone else) a win for Key?


  78. Ari 78

    I certainly would not have called Clark “visionary”. I would have called her statements about giving people more freedom a spirited defense.

    Personally my thoughts on the debate is that Helen Clark did okay, but wasn’t very engaging and was very vague in her plans. She did, however, manage to make John Key look even worse, what with his completely passionless answers and abject failure to differentiate himself from Clark. The only part of the analysis I disagreed with was that the election is a forgone conclusion for National. They could still screw it up in the last few days if they’re not careful- but it may be that it’s theirs to lose. That prospect should be scary to a lot of New Zealanders, I think.

    What possessed Labour to adopt an American style campaign??
    Kiwis generally can’t stand W or Palin and don’t like negative name calling. All Labour had to do was keep it positive.
    Hodgson and Williams have significantly under delivered in terms of strategy.

    I should point out that even before the various Campaign launches, National was happily plugging away with its negative PR without offering any alternative to Labour policies. Labour merely joined in the depressingly dull campaign. What both of these centre parties seem to have failed to realise is that running campaigns that are negative- even if they’re acceptably negative- just scares voters and makes them more likely to either vote for minor parties or not vote at all. I’d actually attribute most of National’s gains to pure frustration with Labour due to the shape of international events- which not many voters seem to realise are mostly outside of the Government’s control.

    Also, I don’t understand why people say their is no difference between national and Labour. Why is that? Because National will not roll back Labour’s policies like Working for Families? I believe the changes they will make differentiate the Parties.
    Surely it would cost a lot of money for National to roll back Labour policies?

    National has not commited to any major changes. Just shuffling money between some policies, including taking a lot of money from highly successful ones like Kiwisaver and ACC. In effect, he’s offering Labour with a splash of economic anarchism, and Labour is offering to be a little bit more leftist than last time and do some proactive protection of our economy.

    Do some policy analysis. National now has more in common with Labour than it does with either United Future or Act. The only thing that’s really stopping them from getting in bed together is that they disagree on how big the public service should be and how tight regulations on the economy should be.

    Open your wallets, girls and boys, we’re almost ready for the tired old olds to merge together and become the Free Market At All Costs Party 😛

    Pixie- Good on you! I hope we don’t let down your trust.

  79. bobo 79

    Ok in Starwars terms….. the last 8 years we’ve had “a new hope” now the next 9 years is “the empire strikes back”…

  80. “Mike Collins
    Prisoners don’t get to vote. I have never personally heard a libertarian say they should be able to either. I have heard libertarians say that only those that contribute in taxes (ie net tax payer) should be able to vote, as why should someone be able to vote themselves someone elses money.”

    Always a bit of a joke around lefties about what might happen to the rates of tax evasion and avoidance amongst libertarians if the value of their vote was made proportionate to the amount of tax they paid.

  81. Ms M 81

    Who else swore at their televisions when Key made his petulant aside about us not always having to follow Australia when Clark pointed out Australia had legislation for eco light bulbs one and a half years before us?

    Isn’t this the same man who wants us to wait until Australia has their own Emissions Trading Scheme before we implement one?

    Isn’t this the same man who has made numerous claims we need to be more like Australia?

    Call it a quirk, but I found the comment from him akin to being a politician bereft of a well rounded argument.

  82. tsmithfield 82

    I think that Clark was on a lose/lose with this debate the more I think about it.

    The harder she tried the more she came across as the perceived bossy, aggressive, interfering person that people are getting rapidly sick of. Even if she had technically won the debate, it was irrelevant to the impression she is confirming on people IMO. I am coming to see that these debates are not so much about who wins or loses. They are more about impression management IMO.

    I actually think Labour has made a strategic blunder in not getting rid of her before the election.

  83. 83

    Helen Clark – the little old lady who hasnt a nice word to say about anyone.

    And THATS why she’ll get voted out.

  84. Carol 84

    Strange criticism of Clark.

    Clark has often praised others in many ways.

    Clark takes the honours in tight TV tussle
    By Dene Mackenzie on Tue, 4 Nov 2008

    Prime Minister Helen Clark saved her best for last during the TV3 leaders’ debate last night when she could point confidently to her record of leading a government during the past nine years with five different parties.

    National Party leader John Key said he had shown he had been able to work under MMP in the two years he had led his party but he ruled out having the debate in the media about potential partners after the election.

    But he has already ruled out New Zealand First leader Winston Peters, and the Greens will not work with National.

    That leaves Act New Zealand and United Future and the Maori Party, if the latter is prepared to talk to National after voters have made their choice.

    In a tight contest, Miss Clark came out the winner on the night.

    The final leaders’ debate will be held on TV One tomorrow.

    However, the debate degenerated into a shambles because the mediator, John Campbell, did not mediate.

    Instead, he added to the general mayhem of the hour-long shouting match by trying to shout down both Miss Clark and Mr Key at various times.

    Mr Campbell is experienced enough to know that both leaders were only going to answer his questions in a way that suited them, not him, and he should have been prepared for that.

    He trivialised what should have been an important time for voters as they make up their mind before Saturday.

    While Miss Clark could point to her strong record of leadership as prime minister, Mr Key claimed he would bring with him to a National-led government the strongest economic management of any prime minister.

    That prompted Miss Clark to point to long-serving MPs Bill English, Lockwood Smith, Maurice Williamson and Murray McCully, all of whom were on former leader Don Brash’s front bench.

    Mr Campbell tried to tempt Mr Key into announcing who he would take into the Cabinet, claiming his top 12 MPs were as “fresh as old snapper”.

    Mr Key again would not be drawn, instead using his favourite phrase of “what I can tell you” when saying each leader put his or her stamp on the party and he had put his stamp on National.

    Miss Clark was not questioned on her likely front bench but she should have been, given that many of her Cabinet had been ministers for nine years.

    She acknowledged it was time for Labour to move on and the party had done so by developing its party list with an “incredible range of new candidates”.

    What was disappointing was the “me too” attitude of both leaders.

    Their policies on the economy were uninspiring, there were no fresh initiatives for the likely rise in unemployment as the recession bites and there was acknowledgement of a bipartisan agreement on the bank deposit guarantees.

    Miss Clark proved stronger than Mr Key on questions around “nanny state”.

    Mr Key claimed the Government was “storming through your door” but when challenged to find an example he struggled.

    In the end, he resorted to long-life light-bulbs and shower flows, something Miss Clark swooped on.

    “There are a lot of urban myths about this,” she said.

    “I’m a free spirit and don’t like people telling me how to live my life. I would never accept a government telling me how much water to have through a shower.”

    Strangely, while Mr Campbell tried to express concern about the state of the economy and the effects on New Zealand, he introduced at the end of the debate a futures trading market on the outcome of the election.

  85. exbrethren 86

    I thought Clark was just about passable, but no more. Key was woeful, a stunningly boring performance just repeating the usual slogans. NZs Barack Obama? God we’d be the laughing stock of the world if that was true.

    Only telling point was McManus about Key being willing to sell out any policy to get elected.

    Still think the Nats / ACT will be in charge after the weekend with Douglas dragging the country back to the soup kitchen, while poring money into John’s kids school because why should the rich have to pay for elitism?

  86. I guess all the real commentators have jumped ship? what a pathetic bunch at the end there!

    CAPTCHA: Do remedy

    Do remedy indeed!!

  87. Gary R 88

    Are you kidding? Clark won that debate? I know you are Labour party supporters, but how anyone can claim that Clark won that debate is beyond me.

    It was clearly not a decisive victory either way. If anything, and I disclose I am a little right-leaning in my politics, I would say Key was a bit stronger at times. But overall I thought it was a draw. Clark had some strong points, Key had some stutters, but for anyone to come out and declare a clear win for Clark is ridiculous.

    Unfortunately for Clark and Labour, I think the moderator got it right – people are tired of the incumbent government and are going to vote them out, rather than vote National and friends in.

  88. higherstandard 89


    What part of “Douglas won’t be around the cabinet table” don’t you understand. He was politically relevant and necessary during the late eighties and early nineties he isn’t today, especially as ACT at the most will probably only bring a small percentage of the voting publics support to any coalition.

  89. exbrethren 90

    “What part of “Douglas won’t be around the cabinet table’ don’t you understand.”

    In MMP coalitions those kind of things can change. Rodney said that to paraphrase “we’ll revisit that during negotiations”.

    Key has already backed away from so many previous stances that he could from this one. Labour would do similar things to hold onto power as well.

  90. theodoresteel 91

    Carol, do not cite Dene McKenzie ever. The man has no integrity, and no intelligence. He had a very public breakdown when he wasn’t allowed to interview Key one on one when he was in Dunedin, and until the editor stepped in was calling every day of the campaign a labour victory, despite what happened.

    He has no credibility and not only because of a slight left-wing bias but some kind of serious crusade against National because he believed they slighted him.

    The way to get Dene to report anything was always to ring him up and tell him to spit out what you said verbatim. He just doesn’t have what it takes to construct an article himself.

    Sorry, he’s just not a good journalist and why the ODT keep him on is completely beyond my comprehension.

    Also, I think Clark won that debate. Key was just very uninspiring. And I’m an insipid rightie, so that must be a balances opinion

  91. higherstandard 92


    “In MMP coalitions those kind of things can change. Rodney said that to paraphrase “we’ll revisit that during negotiations’.

    Sure but the amount of leaning over backwards a party has to do in the beast that is MMP is dependent on the size of their mandate – to some extent it’s what’s also taken the Greens, Progressive, ACT, UF out of the mix to a large extent, all of these parties have publicly stated that they will only go with one or other of the larger parties this time around making it apart from the Maori party a bit like a FPP election.

  92. Kerry 93

    The PM was excellent lastnight and was the true winner.

    Obviously most nats are living with there heads in the clouds if they think for one moment Douglas wont be a cabinate minister……mind you considering his age they might want to give him a slightly less challenging portfolio….eg Tourism??!! oh forgot Keys grabbed that already….nothing to heavy cause he needs to take off to his Hawaiian hideaway every few months for a bit of R & R…it will, i suspect give old Bill a chance to shaft keys when hes out of the country…..

  93. Gary R 94

    Kerry – nice to see you have your head in the clouds as well. And love how you managed to get in a dig about John Key owning property in Hawaii – heaven forbid that someone should actually make a success of themselves and be able to afford something like that eh? Better that instead we stay as an average performing country with no success.

  94. Kerry 95

    I find Jareds comments interesting, re panning The Standard for bias….Jared, how bout you speak to the Herald for the obviously bias toward the Nats???

    Herald make a mockery out of fairplay and there journos i suspect are all old men….or eeek people like Hooton who is surely a disgrace to the human race.

  95. Kerry 96

    I have no problem with Keys having a property in Hawaii…..i just wish he would stay there!

  96. vto 97

    Douglas in cabinet? ha ha that’s the biggest joke. He was in a labour govt at the time he was in cabinet. and with helen clark too… Clark was entirely complicit with the Douglas reforms.

    Surely that’s not too hard to understand

  97. Kerry 98

    oh vto….you are right…it is a joke…and the joke is Douglas will be a Cabinet Minister……as for Key saying he wont….WHATEVER?

  98. vto 99

    Kerry, I’ll bet you your credibility he won’t.

  99. Phil 100

    mind you considering his age they might want to give him a slightly less challenging portfolio .eg Tourism??!! oh forgot Keys grabbed that already

    Tourism; New Zealand’s second biggest export earner, after broad agriculture. Yeah, not even remotely a challenging portfolio like “The Arts”.

  100. insider 101


    And of course Clark has no overseas property….

  101. vto 102

    One thing during the debate which highlighted Clark’s less than tolerant view of certain types was when the matter of Michael Jones and Inger the Winger’s support for the nats came up. Clark sneered that it was a *curled-up nose* christian conservative vote, not a PI vote. Why does labour have such an intolerance towards this minority group and not others?

  102. Carol 103

    It’s the intolerance of Christian conservatives that bother some of us on the left. I always liked Jones & Inga – great rugby players. But I disagree with their politics. As a lesbian, the message I got from their explanation for their political endorsement, is that if you’re anti LGBT rights, then key is your man and National is your party.

    Christian Conservatives, whatever their ethnic background, tend to want to limit the civil rights of others who they disagree with.

    I want to add that it is mainly conservative Christians that have this tendency. There are plenty of Christians who are more supportive of the rights of others.

  103. vto 104

    I don’t disagree with that summation Carol. Part of their principles nd beliefs is the desire to impose their view on others, or at least convince avidly. But that is very very similar to the impositions that the left tries on – hence the constant cries of nanny state. Too much imposition of the left’s own views.

    Anyway, my point was really that Clark’s at times sneering nature is a bad look. And it is practised by others such as Cullen. Would Clark have the same sneering tone towards say a muslim voting block? I think not. Just a little ugly and intolerant.

  104. vto 105

    and just a bit more… this attitude I think is ingrained in the current labour lot’s thinking. Exhibited last night with Clark’s sneer, and can be tracked all the way back to Cullen’s maiden parliamentary speech where the same attitude was shown by his willingness to rip off the farmers who had just paid for his private schooling.

    The knowledge of that ingrained attitude is now also ingrained in many many voters.

  105. Ianmac 106

    Pinched this from Russel Brown’s blog re Michael Jones and Inga Tuigamala :
    They’re very conservative Christians — Jones is on the “board of reference” of Family First, and presumably, helped create its policy platform — including comprehensively banning abortion — and both men signed Family First’s open letter to MPs during the progress of Sue Bradford’s bill.

  106. r0b 107

    Anyway, my point was really that Clark’s at times sneering nature is a bad look. And it is practised by others such as Cullen. Would Clark have the same sneering tone towards say a muslim voting block? I think not. Just a little ugly and intolerant.

    Irrational hatred twisting your perceptions there at all vto? How’s that working out for you?

  107. Tim Ellis 108

    Ianmac said:

    Pinched this from Russel Brown’s blog re Michael Jones and Inga Tuigamala : They’re very conservative Christians

    That’s not really very surprising, though, is it? The vast majority of the Pacific Island community are conservative Christians. Do they not have a right to hold political opinions as well? Or should all conservative Christians be abused, slandered and silenced, as Helen Clark did when she and senior Labour Party colleagues used such expressions as “chinless scarf-wearers”?

    There are many parts of the Labour Party that have a pathological hatred towards conservative Christians and their moral positions.

  108. Phil 109


    It seems to me that religious belief and participation within a ‘church’ community plays a far more pivotal role in the life of the average Pacific Island NZer than it does in the average European NZer…

  109. r0b 110

    There are many parts of the Labour Party that have a pathological hatred towards conservative Christians and their moral positions.

    That’s odd, I’ve been in the Labour Party for nearly a decade and I’ve never met any. I think Tim that this is another of your wee lies.

  110. vto 111

    ay r0b? Irrational hatred? I don’t understand – merely passing comment on one part of Clark’s performance and comparing it to similar attributes in Cullen. In fact ‘irrational hatred’ is pretty much the precise point of Clark’s sneer – hence the post.

    You believe a sneering attitude does not seep out between the rivets of Clark and Cullen at times?

    You think perhaps Mallard would not label muslims ‘chinless towelheads’ or some other such abuse? Would he?

  111. r0b 112

    You believe a sneering attitude does not seep out between the rivets of Clark and Cullen at times?


    Or rather, I believe that such judgments tell us much more about the attitudes of the critic (you) than the criticised (Clark and Cullen).

  112. Daveski 113

    Carol and others

    This is Labour’s biggest challenge problem. The Grand Old Alliance – “workers”, beneficiaries, Maori, PI, younger left, elderly – looks unsustainable.

    Given Clark’s personal values and beliefs, Aunty Helen cuddling up to the congregation has got to by a flip flop of proportions Key could only dream.

    The cultural gaps – particularly around religion-flavoured beliefs – will drive a wedge through Labour’s traditional strongholds so it’s no surprise to see PI start to migrate towards the economic centre/right which is where there natural instincts lie.

    Conversely, the Greens look like cannibalising Labour’s left.

    The sneering of Clark and Cullen will turn off some of the middle and bingo welcome to opposition.

  113. r0b 114

    Daveski – what a load of old cobblers! And another with the “sneering” thing – are you guys all reading from some National “talking points of the day” script? The coincidence is remarkable!

    And the incessant personal attacks on Clark are such a good look for the Right…

  114. Daveski 115


    Let’s try analysis and discussion shall we?

    So what part is cobblers? The fact that Helen’s anti-smacking, pro-liberal views are diametrically opposed to the PI church views? I wasn’t passing an opinion on anyone’s views but it must be obvious even to you that there isn’t a lot of synergy there!

    The Green’s cannibalising the left of Labour? SP apparently is one.

    I give SP credit for his analysis. I’ve tried to provide some analysis (not to SP’s level I admit) but you simply dismiss it with “old cobblers”. You can do better. Which part do you disagree with? Why?

    The sneering issue wouldn’t be one if you and others could take a warts and all view of Cullen and Clark. There is a tendency to sneer, particularly Cullen, but this is part of politics. Admit it and get over it.

  115. Tim Ellis 116

    Maybe, despite your decade in the Labour Party, r0b, you haven’t come across Rainbow Labour. It’s not unreasonable to say they are driven in a large part by a contempt for the christian conservative movement, as are the CC’s driven by a contempt for the LGBT lobby, much of which makes up the Rainbow Labour faction within Labour.

    I’m not a Christian Conservative, but I think it’s perfectly reasonable to point out that the Labour Party has long been supported by the PI community, of which almost all hold conservative Christian values, and that those values are at odds with the values promoted by Rainbow Labour. It isn’t a happy marriage by any means.

    Back in 1996 Winston Peters’ party consisted of conservative elderly who wanted to ban immigration, rednecks, and Maori. That wasn’t a happy combination either. He was pretty quickly exposed, and the connection didn’t last.

    I think we’re seeing a shift in the PI community, in that they realise that such a dominant feature of the Labour Party, through Rainbow Labour, is very much at odds with their moral positions.

  116. Jackson 117

    It’s surprising Helen Clark does not wear a permanent sneer having to endure on a daily basis the moralising right who would be far more accepted and acceptable if they ran hysterical and emotionally charged campaigns against “the love of money.” After all, Jesus drove money changers from the temple, not single mothers or civil unionists. And, Christians, if they were truly christian, would be campaigning against Key ‘the money changer’, not hobnobbing around factories with him nor musing about the day when they too could be the ‘big boss’.

  117. vto 118

    oh ok r0b, Mallard was exhibiting his lovely side when he referred to ‘chinless scarfwearers’, Clark had nothing like a sneer in the way she referred to the ‘christian conservatives’ and Cullen was just joking in his inaugural speech.

    Cullen is known far and wide for his bitter sneering ways.

    It’s ok though – it is only a few days from the election. Can’t expect much else from a labour party member.

    oh, and yes we are all readin off the same script. ha ha ha ha ha ha. We’re part of a big secret conspiracy!

    And as for you despairing of personal attacks on the labour leader – seriously, wtf are 90% of the threads posted here about? Key, Key, Key and his personality.

    Try keeping a level head in these last few daze.

  118. Daveski 119

    hey vto – you must have the old version of the script – that was supposed to be my line!!!

  119. I think it’s a mistake to treat PIs as one dimensional (they’re morally conservative, they all go to church and base their views on that). National continues to treat people as just falling into a demographic with one box to tick, then they’ll continue to be the party of old rich white men.

  120. r0b 121

    Maybe, despite your decade in the Labour Party, r0b, you haven’t come across Rainbow Labour. It’s not unreasonable to say they are driven in a large part by a contempt for the christian conservative movement

    Tim, I’m working side by side with Rainbow Labour every day. And if you want to compare the “contempt” that they feel for aspects of conservative Christianity with the genuine hatred and persecution that conservative Christianity has unleashed on homosexuals over the ages, well then be my guest.

    And if that’s the best you can do after claiming “There are many parts of the Labour Party that have a pathological hatred towards conservative Christians and their moral positions” – then you’re a liar once again.

  121. Daveski 122

    Come on SP

    You’re the one who said National had no natural link with Maori (beneficiaries and “workers” – poorly paraphrased).

    Politics is about aggregating groups of interested parties. The righties here are arguing (very nicely too!) an issue that could be a defining one for Labour and the left are running for cover?

  122. r0b 123

    oh, and yes we are all readin off the same script. ha ha ha ha ha ha. We’re part of a big secret conspiracy!

    Ahaha! I knew it! And now I have proof!

    And as for you despairing of personal attacks on the labour leader – seriously, wtf are 90% of the threads posted here about? Key, Key, Key and his personality.

    No, Key Key Key and his policies and credibility. Valid political material, not these petty personal attacks that the Right has always been obsessed with when it comes to Helen Clark.

  123. r0b 124

    So what part is cobblers? The fact that Helen’s anti-smacking, pro-liberal views are diametrically opposed to the PI church views?

    You mean Helen and John’s (and Sue’s) anti-smacking views? Why does everyone on the Right try to conveniently ignore that?

    The Green’s cannibalising the left of Labour?

    That’s pretty much the only part of your comment that was true. And it works fine for me, I’d like to see Labour dragged further to the left by the Greens.

  124. vto 125

    r0b, I’ll give you one thing and that is your point about the poor old homosexuals suffering at the hands of many over the eons, including the conservative christians.

    To move on – imo Key seems to be making a good hack at opening up the nats to those who have previously been presumed to be shut out. It seems he is moving to actually completely transform the perception and the reality of the nats. It will be very very interesting to see how this transpires – one aspect I suspect will be the carving off of the old guard Lockwood Maurice etc. (presuming a win of course).

  125. Phil 126


    You might be happy to see Labour dragged further left, but what about the big chunk of New Zealand that swings between the Nats and Labour?

    While your conviction to the cause is admirable, I suspect such a government is not, to use a green phrase, sustainable.

  126. Tim Ellis 127

    r0b, you appear to be using persecution of homosexuals by christian groups, throughout history, as a justification for the pathological hatred that the likes of Rainbow Labour members show towards Christian conservatives.

    I’m not arguing that there hasn’t been historical justification. I’m just saying that the pathological hatred exists, and it’s reasonable to say that the hatred is mutual between the LGBT community and christian conservatism.

    Rainbow Labour is a major component in the Labour Party. That isn’t a secret. So although I know you enjoy calling people liars to wind them up in the hope that they will respond irrationally, you haven’t shown anything of the kind.

  127. exbrethren 128

    Deleted for fear of religous right.

  128. Ben R 129

    “old rich white men.”

    The one group who you are happy to demonise? They’ve never done anything good for anyone or society have they.

  129. Chris G 130

    Of course they have, but they’ve done a Lot of bad shit Ben R and it takes one (or a history lesson) to know one.

  130. rave 131

    The Christian conservatism of Tuigamala and Jones is a colonial hangover. Polynesia was colonised by Europeans who imposed their ‘values’ on the natives. The market, money and monotheism. These neo-conservative ‘values’ serve to regulate society by promoting peace and harmony in a conflict ridden society. They justify war against others in the name of peace. It is convenient to have people in church where they can be bombed efficiently.

    The new right use the religious right to re-colonise those who are de-colonising their minds. The problem is that secular values are those of individuals and can lead to social conflict when those values are exposed as hollow by capitalist crisis such as we are facing. Hence the neo-conservatism of the religious right is wheeled out to shut up the people. No accident that Oscar Knightly has chosen to stand up for Labour. Who could watch broTown and be a slave to colonial mentality. No surprise that Tuigamala has had some entertaining texts probably in the language of broTown.

    Labour as a modern and secular social democratic party stands against subordinating politics to religion. Its problem is that secular values of equality cannot survive when capitalist economic crisis threatens social harmony. Those who see equality as a lie then blame Labour instead of capitalism and look for magical solutions from the left and the right.

    Key as the latter day re-coloniser of NZ on behalf of international finance, wants to exploit the religious right to gain power. Its fitting in the sense that those who put their faith in the money market to provide humanity with a future, are making common cause with those who preach acceptance of the wrongs of this world and permanent peace and harmony in the next world.

  131. Ben R 132

    “Of course they have, but they’ve done a Lot of bad shit Ben R and it takes one (or a history lesson) to know one.”

    Can you tell me any group of males in history that haven’t done a lot of ‘bad sh8t’?

  132. Ben R 133

    “Of course they have, but they’ve done a Lot of bad shit Ben R and it takes one (or a history lesson) to know one.”

    Can you tell me of any group of males in history who haven’t done a lot of ‘bad sh8t’?

  133. Ben R 134

    “The Christian conservatism of Tuigamala and Jones is a colonial hangover. Polynesia was colonised by Europeans who imposed their ‘values’ on the natives. ”

    What makes you think that they did not have relatively conservative social values in the first place? I thought that the traditional customs and rituals of fa’a Samoa co-existed with their Christian beliefs. Also, was the taupou system a Colonial hangover?

  134. Carol 135

    There’s some good blogs and comments on this: Russell Browm’s commenters draw attention to the diversity of views within Pacific Island communities. I don’t think they can be claimed to be the “natural” voters for any one party.

    Tim Watkin on Pundit talks of the need to keep a separation between church and state, which I agree with. I wouldn’t criticise anyone’s choice of religion. I also have no idea what motivates people to participate in a religion, or whether it results in people’s minds being colonised. Tho, I do find it curious that the coloniser’s religion has come to be considered to be a central part of the culture of some colonised groups. However, it can still be a vehicle of resistance to colonisation for some people, I think..

    IMO, people should be free to practice their religion. They can harbour homophobic, and/or anti-abortion thoughts or ideas, and consider them to be part of their religion.That’s their choice and right. However, I will strongly criticise them if they then try to incorporate those views into politics and law, because that will grossly limit the rights of others..

  135. bill brown 136

    The churches in Sth Auckland are a money spinning exercise, similar to religious TV in the US.

    Preying on the poor to line their own pockets.

    Of course Key and his flunkies are into this – along with pokie machines it keeps the poor in their place – out of site and out of mind until 2011.

  136. r0b 137

    So although I know you enjoy calling people liars to wind them up in the hope that they will respond irrationally, you haven’t shown anything of the kind.

    No Tim, I call people liars when the tell lies, as you do. Your lie again, for the record, was “There are many parts of the Labour Party that have a pathological hatred towards conservative Christians and their moral positions’.

    If you wish to continue this further you can start by enumerating these “many parts” and proving the existence of their “pathological hatred”. Good luck with that, liar.

    (And for the record, the campaign committee that I work with, which includes Rainbow members, also includes a priest and church activists. This discussion which has touched on the ills of aspects of fundamentalist conservative Christianity should be taken to apply to all forms of Christianity – of course. Rainbow and Christian can get along just fine!).

  137. r0b 138

    Epic edit FAIL. Above “should be taken to apply to all forms of Christianity” should read “should NOT be taken to apply to all forms of Christianity”.

  138. Paul Robeson 139

    A much better performance from Helen.

    Is there another debate?

    I thought she was to kind on him at times. She could have skewered his continual lines about tax cuts. Tax cuts are the solution to all for the Nats (thanks G.Campbell at Scoop), but Labour is tax cuts plus- R & D, savings schemes.

    There has to be plenty of lines of rebuttal for the highest numbers of kiwis are leaving.

    I wish she had also picked him up on the own the factory thing at Proggressive- bloody good job to have the Pacific Island unemployment figures on hand.

    She had some good flowing moments, and stated her position well.

    I thought she could have got more into some of her statements, and at time had more effective pieces of rebuttal as lead ins.

    At times John Key’s language was more effective than hers, and at times he engaged in a debate better, despite frequently having weaker points.

    Why can’t we trust John? In this debate alone he said he would cut bureacracy, and now he is only intending to cap it.

    Also John Campbell did a far better job, picked candidates up and allowed a debate, not the farce that occurred at TVNZ.

  139. Ben R 140

    “Of course Key and his flunkies are into this – along with pokie machines it keeps the poor in their place – out of site and out of mind until 2011.”

    Bill Brown, what the hell are you talking about?

  140. Paul Robeson 141

    oh and surely

    New Zealand First voters don’t wish to see private prisons, ACC privatised or the super fund put at greater risk.

    Surely if you both want this it would be wrong to allow the things mentioned above to happen, because you didn’t like the leader.

    John Key can rule them out because they don’t support him on a large number of issues. Can’t wait to see him rule out Peter Dunne before due process.

    exams for 5 and 6 year olds? Do we want to scar them for life with exam pressures just as they start school? how has that gone in the United States? and wasn’t that George Bushes policy? Isn’t his thinking now a tad out of favour?

  141. Rochelle 142

    I missed the debate – like with everything else I assumed I would be able to watch it later. Any idea where I can find it? Youtube?

  142. Tim Ellis 143

    Good luck with that, liar.

    As ever, r0b, you show that it’s pointless debating with you when you consistently descend to personal attacks.

  143. r0b 144

    As ever Tim, you lie, get called on it, and then slink of claiming “personal attacks”.

    Your lie again, for the record, was “There are many parts of the Labour Party that have a pathological hatred towards conservative Christians and their moral positions’.

  144. Felix 145

    Careful r0b, next he’ll accuse you of being anonymous on teh interwebz and therefore not worthy of his grace.

  145. Pat 146

    Was reflecting last night (with the benefit of hindsight) on Labour’s mistakes in their campaign. There are the obvious ones:

    – the failed smear campaign on Key – in particular the H Bomb..
    – clinging onto Peters in the hope he would make it.

    But I think the biggest mistake may have been Helen’s decision to have head-to-head debates with Key instead of full leaders debates. In a full leaders debate Key would have had less time to speak, and be more likely to be thrown off balance by other antogonists. Instead, Key has had much more time to present himself to the NZ public (most of whom had only seen him in news soundbites) and he only had to compete well with Helen in the debates to look good.

    Conversely, in a full leaders debate Helen’s “stick with me in a crisis” approach may have had more appeal, simply due to the lack of air-time Key would have got.

    It’s not over yet, but if Labour loses the government benches on Saturday, I wonder if they will see the decision on the head-to-head debates as a defining error.

  146. Vinsin 147

    Pat – Interesting point. I think the biggest mistake Labour made is running a Presidential style campaign; however this is a result of National running one. I do think however that the less time Key has is actually better for him; he gets to spout rhetoric and stay on script, on message, and has less time to get muddled.

  147. Pat 148

    It was always going to be hard for Labour when they were consistently so far behind in the polls. But when I have recently chatted with ordinary National voters, it was clear that most of them had never really heard Key speak before the leaders debates. Many watched with the first debate with fear and trepidation expected Key to get slaughtered ala Don Brash.

    Instead Clark has failed to land a killer blow, and any tepid support for Key has probably solidified as a result of the debates. Hence why I think the head-to-head debate strategy has not worked as Labour would have hoped.

  148. banjo 149

    Helen Clark is variously, ignored by the media, cast in a bad light by the media, misquoted by the media, smeared by association with Peters by the media. A media who incidentally never fail to quote word for negative word what Key says/thinks about her. Mate! it is bloody miracle she is even still standing but she is and she does the debate thing extremely well.

    Plus… she is also a very good looking woman. Not that looks matter in the overall scheme of things, but everything helps.

    We are damned lucky to have her…Helen Clark is the girl for me and gets my two ticks come election day.

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

  • Climate Adam: Why we're still losing the fight against Methane
    This video includes conclusions of the creator climate scientist Dr. Adam Levy. It is presented to our readers as an informed perspective. Please see video description for references (if any). Carbon dioxide is the main culprit behind climate change. But in second place is methane: a greenhouse gas stronger than CO2, ...
    7 hours ago
  • Climate Change: More ETS failure
    A few weeks ago, I blogged about the (then) upcoming ETS auction, raising the prospect of it failing, leaving the government with a messy budget hole. The auction was today, and indeed, it failed. In fact, it was such a failure that no-one even bothered to bid. Its easy to ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    10 hours ago
  • The Return of Jacinda.
    Oh, take me, take me, take meTo the dreamer's ballI'll be right on time and I'll dress so fineYou're gonna love me when you see meI won't have to worryTake me, take mePromise not to wake me'Til it's morningIt's all been trueEarly morning yesterday, well before dawn, doom-scrolling.Not intentionally, that’s ...
    Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel
    17 hours ago
  • How good is the interim NW busway?
    This is a guest post by Pshem Kowalczyk, a long-time follower of the blog. With great fanfare, just over six months ago (on 12 November 2023), AT launched its interim busway for the NorthWest region, with the new WX express service at the heart of the changes. I live ...
    Greater AucklandBy Guest Post
    18 hours ago
  • Consumer confidence collapses after Budget, in contrast with rest of world
    The first widespread survey of consumers and voters since the Budget on May 30 shows a collapse in confidence. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāTL;DR: The belt-tightening and tax-cutting Budget delivered on May 30 has not delivered the boost to confidence in the economy the National-ACT-NZ First Government might have ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    18 hours ago
  • The end for the Air Force 757s
    The Air Force 757 that broke down with the Prime Minister on board in Port Moresby on Sunday is considered so unreliable that it carries a substantial stock of spare parts when it travels overseas. And the plane also carries an Air Force maintenance team on board ready to make ...
    PolitikBy Richard Harman
    21 hours ago
  • At a glance – Was 1934 the hottest year on record?
    On February 14, 2023 we announced our Rebuttal Update Project. This included an ask for feedback about the added "At a glance" section in the updated basic rebuttal versions. This weekly blog post series highlights this new section of one of the updated basic rebuttal versions and serves as a ...
    1 day ago
  • It's not New Zealand they've never heard of, it's him
    Sometimes you’ll just be so dog-tired, you can only keep yourself awake with a short stab of self-inflicted pain.A quick bite of the lip, for instance.Maybe a slight bite on the tongue or a dig of the nails.But what if you’re needing something a bit more painful?The solution is as ...
    More Than A FeildingBy David Slack
    1 day ago
  • Some “scrutiny” II
    Last month I blogged about the Ministry of Justice's Open Government Partnership commitment to strengthen scrutiny of Official Information Act exemption clauses in legislation", and how their existing efforts did not give much reason for confidence. As part of that, I mentioned that I had asked the Ministry for its ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 day ago
  • Gordon Campbell on why the Biden “peace plan” for Gaza is doomed
    After months and months of blocking every attempt by the UN and everyone else to achieve a Gaza ceasefire, US President Joe Biden is now marketing his own three-stage “peace plan” to end the conflict. Like every other contribution by the US since October 7, the Biden initiative is hobbled ...
    WerewolfBy lyndon
    2 days ago
  • Raised crossings: hearing the voice of vulnerable pedestrians
    This is a guest post by Vivian Naylor, who is the Barrier Free Advisor and Educator at CCS Disability Action, Northern Region, the largest disability support and advocacy organisation in Aotearoa New Zealand. She also advises on AT’s Public Transport and Capital Projects Accessibility Groups. Vivian has been advocating and ...
    Greater AucklandBy Guest Post
    2 days ago
  • Leaving on a Jet Plane
    So kiss me and smile for meTell me that you'll wait for meHold me like you'll never let me go'Cause I'm leavin' on a jet planeDon't know when I'll be back againOh babe, I hate to go“The true measure of any society can be found in how it treats its ...
    Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel
    2 days ago
  • Bernard's mid-winter pick 'n' mix for Tuesday, June 18
    The election promises of ‘better economic management’ are now ringing hollow, as NZ appears to be falling into a deeper recession, while other economies are turning the corner. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāTL;DR: The economy and the housing market are slumping back into a deep recession this winter, contrasting ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    2 days ago
  • Scrutiny week off to rocky start
    Parliament’s new “Scrutiny” process, which is supposed to allow Select Committees to interrogate Ministers and officials in much more depth, has got off to a rocky start. Yesterday was the first day of “Scrutiny Week” which is supposed to see the Government grilled on how it spends taxpayers’ money and ...
    PolitikBy Richard Harman
    2 days ago
  • The choice could not be more stark’: How Trump and Biden compare on climate change
    This is a re-post from Yale Climate Connections by Barbara Grady Illustration by Samantha Harrington. Photo credits: Justin Lane-Pool/Getty Images, Win McNamee/Getty Images, European Space Agency. In an empty wind-swept field in Richmond, California, next to the county landfill, a company called RavenSr has plotted out land and won ...
    2 days ago
  • Differentiating between democracy and republic
    Although NZ readers may not be that interested in the subject and in lieu of US Fathers Day missives (not celebrated in NZ), I thought I would lay out some brief thoughts on a political subject being debated in the … Continue reading ...
    KiwipoliticoBy Pablo
    3 days ago
  • Bernard's mid-winter pick 'n' mix for Monday, June 17
    TL;DR: Chris Bishop talks up the use of value capture, congestion charging, PPPs, water meters, tolling and rebating GST on building materials to councils to ramp up infrastructure investment in the absence of the Government simply borrowing more to provide the capital.Meanwhile, Christopher Luxon wants to double the number of ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    3 days ago
  • You do have the power to change things
    When I was invited to come aboard and help with Greater Auckland a few months ago (thanks to Patrick!), it was suggested it might be a good idea to write some sort of autobiographical post by way of an introduction. This post isn’t quite that – although I’m sure I’lll ...
    Greater AucklandBy Connor Sharp
    3 days ago
  • Turning Away – Who Cares If We Don't?
    On the turning awayFrom the pale and downtroddenAnd the words they say which we won't understandDon't accept that, what's happeningIs just a case of other's sufferingOr you'll find that you're joining inThe turning awayToday’s guest kōrero is from Author Catherine Lea. So without further ado, over to Catherine…I’m so honoured ...
    Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel
    3 days ago
  • Dissecting Tickled
    Hi,Tickled was one of the craziest things that ever happened to me (and I feel like a lot of crazy things have happened to me).So ahead of the Webworm popup and Tickled screening in New Zealand on July 13, I thought I’d write about how we made that film and ...
    David FarrierBy David Farrier
    3 days ago
  • New Zealand Webworm Popup + Tickled!
    Hi,I’m doing a Webworm merch popup followed by a Tickled screening in Auckland, New Zealand on July 13th — and I’d love you to come. I got the urge to do this while writing this Webworm piece breaking down how we made Tickled, and talking to all the people who ...
    David FarrierBy David Farrier
    3 days ago
  • What China wants from NZ business
    One simple statistic said it all: China Premier Li Qiang asked Fonterra CEO Miles Hurrell what percentage of the company’s overall sales were made in China. “Thirty per cent,” said Hurrell. In other words, New Zealand’s largest company is more or less dependent on the Chinese market. But Hurrell is ...
    PolitikBy Richard Harman
    3 days ago
  • Review: The Worm Ouroboros, by E.R. Eddison (1922)
    One occasionally runs into the question of what J.R.R. Tolkien would have thought of George R.R. Martin. For years, I had a go-to online answer: we could use a stand-in. Tolkien’s thoughts on E.R. Eddison – that he appreciated the invented world, but thought the invented names were silly, and ...
    3 days ago
  • 2024 SkS Weekly Climate Change & Global Warming News Roundup #24
    A listing of 35 news and opinion articles we found interesting and shared on social media during the past week: Sun, June 9, 2024 thru Sat, June 15, 2024. Story of the week A glance at this week's inventory of what experts tell us is extreme weather mayhem juiced by ...
    3 days ago
  • Sunday Morning Chat
    After a busy week it’s a good day to relax. Clear blues skies here in Tamaki Makaurau, very peaceful but for my dogs sleeping heavily. In the absence of a full newsletter I thought I’d send out a brief update and share a couple of posts that popped up in ...
    Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel
    4 days ago
  • The Book of Henry
    Now in the land of Angus beef and the mighty ABsWhere the steaks were juicy and the rivers did run foulIt would often be said,This meal is terrible,andNo, for real this is legit the worst thing I've ever eatenBut this was an thing said only to others at the table,not ...
    More Than A FeildingBy David Slack
    4 days ago
  • Fact Brief – Is ocean acidification from human activities enough to impact marine ecosystems?
    Skeptical Science is partnering with Gigafact to produce fact briefs — bite-sized fact checks of trending claims. This fact brief was written by Sue Bin Park in collaboration with members from the Skeptical Science team. You can submit claims you think need checking via the tipline. Is ocean acidification from human ...
    4 days ago
  • Happiness is a Warm Gun
    She's not a girl who misses muchDo do do do do do, oh yeahShe's well-acquainted with the touch of the velvet handLike a lizard on a window paneI wouldn’t associate ACT with warmth, other than a certain fabled, notoriously hot, destination where surely they’re heading and many would like them ...
    Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel
    5 days ago
  • Still doing a good 20
    Hello! Here comes the Saturday edition of More Than A Feilding, catching you up on the past somewhat interrupted week. Still on the move!Share Read more ...
    More Than A FeildingBy David Slack
    5 days ago
  • Coalition of the Unwilling?
    What does Budget 2024 tell us about the current government? Muddle on?Coalition governments are not new. About 50 percent of the time since the first MMP election, there has been a minority government, usually with allied parties holding ministerial portfolios outside cabinets. For 10 percent of the time there was ...
    PunditBy Brian Easton
    5 days ago
  • Of red flags and warning signs in comments on social media
    Somewhat surprisingly for what is regarded as a network of professionals, climate science misinformation is getting shared on LinkedIn, joining other channels where this is happening. Several of our recent posts published on LinkedIn have attracted the ire of various commenters who apparently are in denial about human-caused climate change. Based ...
    5 days ago
  • All good, still
    1. On what subject is Paul Henry even remotely worth giving the time of day?a. The state of our nationb. The state of the ACT partyc. How to freak out potential buyers of your gin palace by baking the remains of your deceased parent into its fittings2. Now that New ...
    More Than A FeildingBy David Slack
    5 days ago
  • The looting is the point
    Last time National was in power, they looted the state, privatising public assets and signing hugely wasteful public-private partnership (PPP) contracts which saw foreign consortiums provide substandard infrastructure while gouging us for profits. You only have to look at the ongoing fiasco of Transmission Gully to see how it was ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    5 days ago
  • The Illusion of Power: How Local Government Bureaucrats Overawe Democratically-Elected Councillors..
    The Democratic Façade Of Local Government: Our district and city councillors are democratically elected to govern their communities on one very strict condition – that they never, ever, under any circumstances, attempt to do so.A DISINTEGRATION OF LOYALTIES on the Wellington City Council has left Mayor Tory Whanau without a ...
    6 days ago
  • Lowlights & Bright Spots
    I can feel the lowlights coming over meI can feel the lowlights, from the state I’m inI can see the light now even thought it’s dimA little glow on the horizonAnother week of lowlights from our government, with the odd bright spot and a glow on the horizon. The light ...
    Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel
    6 days ago
  • Weekly Roundup 14-June-2024
    Another week, another roundup of things that caught our eye on our favourite topics of transport, housing and how to make cities a little bit greater. This Week in Greater Auckland On Monday, Connor wrote about Kāinga Ora’s role as an urban development agency Tuesday’s guest post by ...
    Greater AucklandBy Greater Auckland
    6 days ago
  • The Hoon around the week to June 14
    Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāTL;DR: The podcast above of the weekly ‘hoon’ webinar for paying subscribers features co-hosts and talking with:The Kākā’s climate correspondent about the National-ACT-NZ First Government’s moves this week to take farming out of the ETS and encourage more mining and oil and ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    6 days ago
  • Climate policy axed in broad daylight, while taxpayer liabilities grow in the dark
    In 2019, Shane Jones addressed the “50 Shades of Green” protest at Parliament: Now he is part of a government giving those farmers a pass on becoming part of the ETS, as well as threatening to lock in offshore oil exploration and mining for decades. Photo: Lynn GrievesonTL;DR: Here’s the ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    6 days ago
  • Rage Bait!
    Hi,Today’s newsletter is all about how easy it is to get sucked into “rage bait” online, and how easy it is to get played.But first I wanted to share something that elicited the exact opposite of rage in me — something that made me feel incredibly proud, whilst also making ...
    David FarrierBy David Farrier
    6 days ago
  • Bernard's Dawn Chorus and pick 'n' mix for Friday, June 14
    Seymour said lower speed limits “drained the joy from life as people were forced to follow rules they knew made no sense.” File Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāTL;DR: My six things to note in Aotearoa-NZ’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty on Friday, June 14 were:The National/ACT/NZ First ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    6 days ago
  • Friendly but frank talks with China Premier
    It sounded like the best word to describe yesterday’s talks between Chinese Premier Li Qiang and his heavyweight delegation of Ministers and officials and Prime Minister Christopher Luxon and New Zealand Ministers and officials was “frank.” But it was the kind of frankness that friends can indulge in. It ...
    PolitikBy Richard Harman
    6 days ago
  • Skeptical Science New Research for Week #24 2024
    Open access notables Wildfire smoke impacts lake ecosystems, Farruggia et al., Global Change Biology: We introduce the concept of the lake smoke-day, or the number of days any given lake is exposed to smoke in any given fire season, and quantify the total lake smoke-day exposure in North America from 2019 ...
    6 days ago
  • Join us for the weekly Hoon on YouTube Live
    Photo by Mathias Elle on UnsplashIt’s that new day of the week (Thursday rather than Friday) when we have our ‘hoon’ webinar with paying subscribers to The Kākā for an hour at 5 pm.Jump on this link on YouTube Livestream for our chat about the week’s news with special guests:5.00 ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    6 days ago
  • Geoffrey Miller: China’s message to New Zealand – don’t put it all at risk
    Don’t put it all at risk. That’s likely to be the take-home message for New Zealand Prime Minister Christopher Luxon in his meetings with Li Qiang, the Chinese Premier. Li’s visit to Wellington this week is the highest-ranking visit by a Chinese official since 2017. The trip down under – ...
    Democracy ProjectBy Geoffrey Miller
    6 days ago
  • The Real Thing
    I know the feelingIt is the real thingThe essence of the soulThe perfect momentThat golden momentI know you feel it tooI know the feelingIt is the real thingYou can't refuse the embraceNo?Sometimes we face the things we most dislike. A phobia or fear that must be confronted so it doesn’t ...
    Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel
    7 days ago
  • Gordon Campbell on how moderates empower the political right
    Struth, what a week. Having made sure the rural sector won’t have to pay any time soon for its pollution, PM Christopher Luxon yesterday chose Fieldays 2024 to launch a parliamentary inquiry into rural banking services, to see how the banks have been treating farmers faced with high interest rates. ...
    7 days ago
  • Bernard's Dawn Chorus and pick 'n' mix for Thursday, June 13
    In April, 17,656 people left Aotearoa-NZ to live overseas, averaging 588 a day, with just over half of those likely to have gone to Australia. Photo: Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāTL;DR: My six things to note in Aotearoa-NZ’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty on Thursday, June 13 ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    7 days ago
  • Our guide to having your say on the draft RLTP 2024
    Auckland’s draft Regional Land Transport Plan (RLTP) 2024 is open for feedback – and you only have until Monday 17 June to submit. Do it! Join the thousands of Aucklanders who are speaking up for wise strategic investment that will dig us out of traffic and give us easy and ...
    Greater AucklandBy Connor Sharp
    7 days ago
  • The China puzzle
    Chinese Premier Li Qiang arrives in Wellington today for a three-day visit to the country. The visit will take place amid uncertainty about the future of the New Zealand-China relationship. Li hosted a formal welcome and then lunch for then-Prime Minister Chris Hipkins in Beijing a year ago. The pair ...
    PolitikBy Richard Harman
    7 days ago
  • Fossil fuels are shredding our democracy
    This is a re-post of an article from the Climate Brink by Andrew Dessler published on June 3, 2024. I have an oped in the New York Times (gift link) about this. For a long time, a common refrain about the energy transition was that renewable energy needed to become ...
    1 week ago
  • Life at 20 kilometres an hour
    We are still in France, getting from A to B.Possibly for only another week, though; Switzerland and Germany are looming now. On we pedal, towards Budapest, at about 20 km per hour.What are are mostly doing is inhaling a country, loving its ways and its food. Rolling, talking, quietly thinking. ...
    More Than A FeildingBy David Slack
    1 week ago
  • Hipkins is still useless
    The big problem with the last Labour government was that they were chickenshits who did nothing with the absolute majority we had given them. They governed as if they were scared of their own shadows, afraid of making decisions lest it upset someone - usually someone who would never have ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • Exercising with the IDF.
    This morning I did something I seldom do, I looked at the Twitter newsfeed. Normally I take the approach of something that I’m not sure is an American urban legend, or genuinely something kids do over there. The infamous bag of dog poo on the front porch, set it on ...
    Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel
    1 week ago
  • Helm Hammerhand Anime: First Pictures and an Old English ‘Hera’
    We have some news on the upcoming War of the Rohirrim anime. It will apparently be two and a half hours in length, with Peter Jackson as Executive Producer, and Helm’s daughter Hera will be the main character. Also, pictures: The bloke in the middle picture is Freca’s ...
    1 week ago
  • Farmers get free pass on climate AND get subsidies
    The cows will keep burping and farting and climate change will keep accelerating - but farmers can stop worrying about being included in the ETS. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāTL;DR: My six things to note in Aotearoa-NZ’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty on Wednesday, June 12 were:The ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    1 week ago
  • Six ideas to secure Te Huia’s Future
    This is a guest post by our friend Darren Davis. It originally appeared on his excellent blog, Adventures in Transitland, which features “musings about public transport and other cool stuff in Aotearoa/ New Zealand and around the globe.” With Te Huia now having funding secure through to 2026, now is ...
    Greater AucklandBy Darren Davis
    1 week ago
  • The methane waka sinks
    In some ways, there may be less than meets the eye to the Government announcement yesterday that the He Waka Eke Noa proposal for farmers to pay for greenhouse gas emissions has been scrapped. The spectre of farmers still having to pay at some point in the future remains. That, ...
    PolitikBy Richard Harman
    1 week ago
  • At a glance – Does positive feedback necessarily mean runaway warming?
    On February 14, 2023 we announced our Rebuttal Update Project. This included an ask for feedback about the added "At a glance" section in the updated basic rebuttal versions. This weekly blog post series highlights this new section of one of the updated basic rebuttal versions and serves as a ...
    1 week ago
  • Climate Change: Farmers get what they wanted – for now
    Since entering office, National has unravelled practically every climate policy, leaving us with no effective way of reducing emissions or meeting our emissions budgets beyond magical thinking around the ETS. And today they've announced another step: removing agriculture entirely. At present, following the complete failure of he waka eka noa, ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • Presumed Innocent?
    The blue billionaireDistraction no interactionOr movement outside these glazed over eyesThe new great divideFew fight the tide to be glorifiedBut will he be satisfied?Can we accept this without zoom?The elephant in the roomNot much happens in politics on a Monday. Bugger all in fact. Although yesterday Christopher Luxon found he ...
    Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel
    1 week ago
  • Gordon Campbell on our doomed love affair with oil and gas
    What if New Zealand threw a fossil fuel party, and nobody came? On the weekend, Resources Minister Shane Jones sent out the invitations and strung up the balloons, but will anyone really want to invest big time in resuming oil and gas exploration in our corner of the planet? Yes, ...
    WerewolfBy lyndon
    1 week ago
  • Building better housing insights
    This is a guest post by Meredith Dale, senior urban designer and strategist at The Urban Advisory. There’s a saying that goes something like: ‘what you measure is what you value’. An RNZ article last week claimed that Auckland was ‘hurting’ because of a more affordable supply of homes, particularly townhouses ...
    Greater AucklandBy Guest Post
    1 week ago
  • Putin would be proud of them
    A Prime Minister directs his public service to inquire into the actions of the opposition political party which is his harshest critic. Something from Orban's Hungary, or Putin's Russia? No, its happening right here in Aotearoa: Prime Minister Christopher Luxon has announced the Public Service Commission will launch an ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • Resources for debunking common solar and wind myths
    This is a repost from a Yale Climate Connections article by SueEllen Campbell published on June 3, 2024. The articles listed can help you tell fact from fiction when it comes to solar and wind energy. Some statements you hear about solar and wind energy are just plain false. ...
    1 week ago
  • Juggernaut
    Politics were going on all around us yesterday, and we barely noticed, rolling along canal paths, eating baguettes. It wasn’t until my mate got to the headlines last night that we learned there had been a dismayingly strong far right result in the EU elections and Macron had called a ...
    More Than A FeildingBy David Slack
    1 week ago
  • Numbers Game.
    Respect Existence, Or Expect Resistance? There may well have been 50,000 pairs of feet “Marching For Nature” down Auckland’s Queen Street on Saturday afternoon, but the figure that impresses the Coalition Government is the 1,450,000 pairs of Auckland feet that were somewhere else.IN THE ERA OF DRONES and Artificial Intelligence, ...
    1 week ago
  • Media Link: AVFA on post-colonial blowback.
    Selwyn Manning and I discuss varieties of post colonial blowback and the implications its has for the rise of the Global South. Counties discussed include Palestine/Israel, France/New Caledonia, England/India, apartheid/post-apartheid South Africa and post-colonial New Zealand. It is a bit … Continue reading ...
    KiwipoliticoBy Pablo
    1 week ago
  • Policy by panic
    Back in March, Ombudsman Peter Boshier resigned when he hit the statutory retirement age of 72, leaving the country in the awkward (and legally questionable) position of having him continue as a temporay appointee. It apparently took the entire political system by surprise - as evinced by Labour's dick move ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • PSA: NZ's Richest Company, Zuru, Sucks
    Hi,Today the New Zealand press is breathlessly reporting that the owners of toy company Zuru are officially New Zealand’s wealthiest people: Mat and Nick Mowbray worth an estimated $20 billion between them.While the New Zealand press loses its shit celebrating this Kiwi success story, this is a Webworm reminder that ...
    David FarrierBy David Farrier
    1 week ago
  • Bernard's Dawn Chorus and pick 'n' mix for Monday, June 10
    TL;DR: The six things to note in Aotearoa-NZ’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty in the past day to 8:36 pm on Monday, June 10 were:20,000 protested against the Fast-track approval bill on Saturday in Auckland, but PM Christopher Luxon says ‘sorry, but not sorry’ about the need for ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    1 week ago
  • In Defence of Kāinga Ora
    Given the headlines around the recent findings of the ‘independent’ review of Kāinga Ora by Bill English, you might assume this post will be about social housing, Kāinga Ora’s most prominent role. While that is indeed something that requires defending, I want to talk about the other core purpose of ...
    Greater AucklandBy Connor Sharp
    1 week ago
  • Baby You're A Rich Man
    “How does it feel to beOne of the beautiful peopleNow that you know who you areWhat do you want to beAnd have you traveled very far?Far as the eye can see”Yesterday the ACT party faithful were regaled with craven boasts, sneers, and demands for even more at their annual rally.That ...
    Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel
    1 week ago
  • Stopping a future Labour government from shutting down gas exploration
    A defiant Resources Minister Shane Jones has responded to Saturday’s environmental protests by ending Labour’s offshore oil exploration ban and calling for long-term contracts with any successful explorers. The purpose would be to prevent a future Labour Government from reversing any licence the explorers might hold. Jones sees a precedent ...
    PolitikBy Richard Harman
    1 week ago
  • 2024 SkS Weekly Climate Change & Global Warming News Roundup #23
    A listing of 32 news and opinion articles we found interesting and shared on social media during the past week: Sun, June 2, 2024 thru Sat, June 8, 2024. Story of the week Our Story of the Week is Yale Climate Connection's Resources for debunking common solar and wind myths, by ...
    1 week ago
  • Fission by the river
    This is where we ate our lunch last Wednesday. Never mind your châteaux and castles and whatnot, we like to enjoy a baguette in the shadow of a nuclear power plant; a station that puts out more than twice as much as Manapouri using nothing more than tiny atoms to bring ...
    More Than A FeildingBy David Slack
    2 weeks ago

  • Prime Minister wraps up visit to Japan
    Prime Minister Christopher Luxon has just finished a successful three-day visit to Japan, where he strengthened political relationships and boosted business links. Mr Luxon’s visit culminated in a bilateral meeting with Japanese Prime Minister Kishida Fumio followed by a state dinner. “It was important for me to meet Prime Minister Kishida in person ...
    2 hours ago
  • Major business deals signed on PM’s Japan trip
    Significant business deals have been closed during the visit of Prime Minister Christopher Luxon to Japan this week, including in the areas of space, renewable energy and investment.  “Commercial deals like this demonstrate that we don’t just export high-quality agricultural products to Japan, but also our world-class technology, expertise, and ...
    10 hours ago
  • Strategic Security speech, Tokyo
    Minasan, konnichiwa, kia ora and good afternoon everyone. Thank you for the invitation to speak to you today and thank you to our friends at the Institute for International Socio-Economic Studies and NEC for making this event possible today.  It gives me great pleasure to be here today, speaking with ...
    11 hours ago
  • National Infrastructure Pipeline worth over $120 billion
    The National Infrastructure Pipeline, which provides a national view of current or planned infrastructure projects, from roads, to water infrastructure, to schools, and more, has climbed above $120 billion, Infrastructure Minister Chris Bishop says. “Our Government is investing a record amount in modern infrastructure that Kiwis can rely on as ...
    13 hours ago
  • Making it easier to build infrastructure
    The Government is modernising the Public Works Act to make it easier to build infrastructure, Minister for Land Information Chris Penk announced today. An independent panel will undertake an eight-week review of the Act and advise on common sense changes to enable large scale public works to be built faster and ...
    1 day ago
  • NZ enhances North Korea sanctions monitoring
    New Zealand will enhance its defence contributions to monitoring violations of sanctions against North Korea, Prime Minister Christopher Luxon announced today.  The enhancement will see the New Zealand Defence Force (NZDF) increase its contributions to North Korea sanctions monitoring, operating out of Japan. “This increase reflects the importance New Zealand ...
    1 day ago
  • Speech to Safeguard National Health and Safety Conference
    Good afternoon everyone. It’s great to be with you all today before we wrap up Day One of the annual Safeguard National Health and Safety Conference. Thank you to the organisers and sponsors of this conference, for the chance to talk to you about the upcoming health and safety consultation. ...
    1 day ago
  • Ōtaki to north of Levin alliance agreements signed
    Transport Minister Simeon Brown has welcomed an important milestone for the Ōtaki to north of Levin Road of National Significance (RoNS), following the NZ Transport Agency (NZTA) signing interim alliance agreements with two design and construction teams who will develop and ultimately build the new expressway.“The Government’s priority for transport ...
    1 day ago
  • Improvements to stopping Digital Child Exploitation
    The Department of Internal Affairs [Department] is making a significant upgrade to their Digital Child Exploitation Filtering System, which blocks access to websites known to host child sexual abuse material, says Minister of Internal Affairs Brooke van Velden.  “The Department will incorporate the up-to-date lists of websites hosting child sexual ...
    2 days ago
  • New vaccine research aims to combat prevalent bovine disease
    A vaccine to prevent an infectious disease that costs New Zealand cattle farmers more than $190 million each year could radically improve the health of our cows and boost on-farm productivity, Associate Agriculture Minister Andrew Hoggard says. The Ministry for Primary Industries is backing a project that aims to develop ...
    2 days ago
  • Making it easier to build granny flats
    The Government has today announced that it is making it easier for people to build granny flats, Acting Prime Minister Winston Peters and RMA Reform Minister Chris Bishop say. “Making it easier to build granny flats will make it more affordable for families to live the way that suits them ...
    2 days ago
  • High Court Judge appointed
    Attorney-General Judith Collins today announced the appointment of Auckland King’s Counsel Gregory Peter Blanchard as a High Court Judge. Justice Blanchard attended the University of Auckland from 1991 to 1995, graduating with an LLB (Honours) and Bachelor of Arts (English). He was a solicitor with the firm that is now Dentons ...
    5 days ago
  • Health workforce numbers rise
    Health Minister Dr Shane Reti says new data released today shows encouraging growth in the health workforce, with a continued increase in the numbers of doctors, nurses and midwives joining Health New Zealand. “Frontline healthcare workers are the beating heart of the healthcare system. Increasing and retaining our health workforce ...
    5 days ago
  • Government to overhaul firearms laws
    Associate Justice Minister Nicole McKee has today announced a comprehensive programme to reform New Zealand's outdated and complicated firearms laws. “The Arms Act has been in place for over 40 years. It has been amended several times – in a piecemeal, and sometimes rushed way. This has resulted in outdated ...
    6 days ago
  • Government delivers landmark specialist schools investment
    The coalition Government is delivering record levels of targeted investment in specialist schools so children with additional needs can thrive. As part of Budget 24, $89 million has been ringfenced to redevelop specialist facilities and increase satellite classrooms for students with high needs. This includes: $63 million in depreciation funding ...
    6 days ago
  • Major health and safety consultation begins
    A substantial consultation on work health and safety will begin today with a roadshow across the regions over the coming months, says Workplace Relations and Safety Minister Brooke van Velden.  This the first step to deliver on the commitment to reforming health and safety law and regulations, set out in ...
    6 days ago
  • Growing the potential of New Zealand’s forestry sector in partnership
    Forestry Minister Todd McClay, today announced the start of the Government’s plan to restore certainty and confidence in the forestry and wood processing sector. “This government will drive investment to unlock the industry’s economic potential for growth,” Mr McClay says. “Forestry’s success is critical to rebuilding New Zealand’s economy, boosting ...
    6 days ago
  • Government cancels forestry ETS annual service charges for 2023-24
    Annual service charges in the forestry Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS) will be cancelled for 2023/24, Forestry Minister Todd McClay says. “The sector has told me the costs imposed on forestry owners by the previous government were excessive and unreasonable and I agree,” Mr McClay says. “They have said that there ...
    6 days ago
  • Speech to the LGNZ Infrastructure Symposium
    Introduction Thank you for having me here today and welcome to Wellington, the home of the Hurricanes, the next Super Rugby champions. Infrastructure – the challenge This government has inherited a series of big challenges in infrastructure. I don’t need to tell an audience as smart as this one that ...
    6 days ago
  • Government boosts Agriculture and food trade with China
    Trade and Agriculture Minister Todd McClay and Food Safety Minister Andrew Hoggard welcomed outcomes to boost agricultural and food trade between New Zealand and China. A number of documents were signed today at Government House that will improve the business environment between New Zealand and China, and help reduce barriers, including on infant formula ...
    6 days ago
  • NZ and China launch Services Trade Negotiations
    Trade Minister Todd McClay, and China’s Commerce Minister Wang Wentao, today announced the official launch of Negotiations on Services Trade between the two countries.  “The Government is focused on opening doors for services exporters to grow the New Zealand’s economy,” Mr McClay says.  As part of the 2022 New Zealand-China Free Trade Agreement Upgrade ...
    6 days ago
  • Prime Minister Luxon meets with Premier Li
    Prime Minister Christopher Luxon met with Chinese Premier Li Qiang at Government House in Wellington today.  “I was pleased to welcome Premier Li to Wellington for his first official visit, which marks 10 years since New Zealand and China established a Comprehensive Strategic Partnership,” Mr Luxon says. “The Premier and ...
    6 days ago
  • Government and business tackling gender pay gap
    The coalition Government is taking action to reduce the gender pay gap in New Zealand through the development of a voluntary calculation tool. “Gender pay gaps have impacted women for decades, which is why we need to continue to drive change in New Zealand,” Acting Minister for Women Louise Upston ...
    6 days ago
  • Funding Boost for Rural Support Trusts
    The coalition Government is boosting funding for Rural Support Trusts to provide more help to farmers and growers under pressure, Rural Communities Minister Mark Patterson announced today. “A strong and thriving agricultural sector is crucial to the New Zealand economy and one of the ways to support it is to ...
    6 days ago
  • Latest data shows size of public service decreasing
    Spending on contractors and consultants continues to fall and the size of the Public Service workforce has started to decrease after years of growth, according to the latest data released today by the Public Service Commission. Workforce data for the quarter from 31 December 23 to 31 March 24 shows ...
    6 days ago
  • Speech to the Law Association
    Thank you to the Law Association for inviting me to speak this morning. As a former president under its previous name — the Auckland District Law Society — I take particular satisfaction in seeing this organisation, and its members, in such good heart. As Attorney-General, I am grateful for these ...
    6 days ago
  • 25 years on, NZ reaffirms enduring friendship with Timor Leste
    New Zealand is committed to working closely with Timor-Leste to support its prosperity and resilience, Foreign Minister Winston Peters says.   “This year is the 25th anniversary of New Zealand sending peacekeepers to Timor-Leste, who contributed to the country’s stabilisation and ultimately its independence,” Mr Peters says.    “A quarter ...
    6 days ago
  • Inquiry requested into rural banking
    Promoting robust competition in the banking sector is vital to rebuilding the economy, Finance Minister Nicola Willis says.  “New Zealanders deserve a banking sector that is as competitive as possible. Banking services play an important role in our communities and in the economy. Kiwis rely on access to lending when ...
    6 days ago
  • Ministry for Regulation targets red tape to keep farmers and growers competitive
    Regulation Minister David Seymour, Environment Minister Penny Simmonds, and Food Safety Minister Andrew Hoggard have today announced a regulatory sector review on the approval process for new agricultural and horticultural products.    “Red tape stops farmers and growers from getting access to products that have been approved by other OECD countries. ...
    7 days ago
  • Government to reverse blanket speed limit reductions
    The Coalition Government will reverse Labour’s blanket speed limit reductions by 1 July 2025 through a new Land Transport Rule released for public consultation today, Transport Minister Simeon Brown says.  The draft speed limit rule will deliver on the National-ACT coalition commitment to reverse the previous government’s blanket speed limit ...
    7 days ago
  • Chair appointments for NZSO, CNZ and NZ On Air
    Minister Paul Goldsmith is making major leadership changes within both his Arts and Media portfolios. “I am delighted to announce Carmel Walsh will be officially stepping into the role of Chair of the New Zealand Symphony Orchestra, having been acting Chair since April,” Arts Minister Paul Goldsmith says.  “Carmel is ...
    7 days ago
  • Government focus on long-term food, fibre growth
    Food and fibre export revenue is tipped to reach $54.6 billion this year and hit a record $66.6b in 2028 as the Government focuses on getting better access to markets and cutting red tape, Agriculture Minister Todd McClay and Oceans and Fisheries Minister Shane Jones say. “This achievement is testament ...
    7 days ago
  • Govt consulting on cutting red tape for exporters
    A new export exemption proposal for food businesses demonstrates the coalition Government’s commitment to reducing regulatory barriers for industry and increasing the value of New Zealand exports, which gets safe New Zealand food to more markets, says Food Safety Minister Andrew Hoggard.  “The coalition Government has listened to the concerns ...
    1 week ago
  • New Zealand and Philippines elevating relationship
    New Zealand and Philippines are continuing to elevate our relationship, Foreign Minister Winston Peters says.   “The leaders of New Zealand and Philippines agreed in April 2024 to lift our relationship to a Comprehensive Partnership by 2026,” Mr Peters says. “Our visit to Manila this week has been an excellent ...
    1 week ago
  • Paid Parental Leave increase to help families
    Workplace Relations and Safety Minister, Brooke van Velden says paid parental leave increase from 1 July will put more money in the pockets of Kiwi parents and give them extra support as they take precious time off to bond with their newborns. The increase takes effect from 1 July 2024 ...
    1 week ago
  • Defence increases UN Command commitment
    The number of New Zealand Defence Force (NZDF) personnel deployed to the Republic of Korea is increasing, Defence Minister Judith Collins and Foreign Minister Winston Peters announced today.  NZDF will deploy up to 41 additional personnel to the Republic of Korea, increasing the size of its contribution to the United ...
    1 week ago
  • New Zealand to attend 'Summit on Peace in Ukraine' in Switzerland
    New Zealand will be represented at the Summit on Peace in Ukraine by Minister Mark Mitchell in Switzerland later this week.    “New Zealand strongly supports Ukraine’s efforts to build a comprehensive, just, and lasting peace,” Foreign Minister Winston Peters says.   “Minister Mitchell is a senior Cabinet Minister and ...
    1 week ago
  • Big step forward for M.bovis programme
    Farmers’ hard work is paying off in the fight against Mycoplasma bovis (M. bovis) with the move to a national pest management plan marking strong progress in the eradication effort, says Biosecurity Minister Andrew Hoggard.  “The plan, approved by the Coalition Government, was proposed by the programme partners DairyNZ, Beef ...
    1 week ago
  • Build To Rent opening welcomed by Housing Minister
    Prime Minister Christopher Luxon and Housing Minister Chris Bishop formally opened a new Build to Rent development in Mt Wellington this morning. “The Prime Minister and I were honoured to cut the ribbon of Resido, New Zealand’s largest Build to Rent development to date.  “Build to Rent housing, like the ...
    1 week ago
  • Agriculture to come out of the ETS
    The Government will deliver on its election commitment to take agriculture out of the New Zealand Emissions Trading Scheme (NZ ETS) and will establish a new Pastoral Sector Group to constructively tackle biogenic methane, Coalition Government Agriculture and Climate Change Ministers say. Agriculture Minister Todd McClay says New Zealand farmers ...
    1 week ago

Page generated in The Standard by Wordpress at 2024-06-19T13:37:18+00:00