web analytics

Rushed policy is bad policy

Written By: - Date published: 7:10 am, May 19th, 2015 - 24 comments
Categories: capital gains, housing, national, tax - Tags: , , ,

When Labour presented its capital gains tax policy it spent months in development. It consulted widely and presented a robust policy that won the media battle (despite National’s usual hysterics). In contrast, The Nats have rushed and bungled the process (all the while assuring us that there is no housing crisis!). National’s definitely not a capital gains tax that just happens to be a tax on capital gains is being made up on the hoof:

Capital gains tax policy rushed through development

It’s emerged the Government’s new policy stance on property taxes has only just been developed. … Minister of Revenue Todd McClay confirms they were developed recently. “We’ve been working through a number of things through a period of time. The current one is for a 4-5 week period.

Green Party Co-Leader Metiria Turei … says it shows the Government’s desperate to take measures to cool the housing market. “A month ago John Key was saying that a capital gains tax was off the table. Now he’s done a massive u turn.

As is usually the case with rushed policy, they have made a mess of it:

New property rules too little too late

From a tax policy perspective the rule appears so narrow as to be almost inconsequential. … The Government has been arm-twisted by its critics into a tax response to address Auckland property prices. But from the range of options available it has come up with the least effective.

In short, National have opened the door to more effective capital gains tax, thus irritating investors and their base, while probably not achieving anything in practice. From their point of view that’s the worst of both worlds. Labour is right, the whole process is “panic-Key”:

“It is panic stations at the Beehive. These are rushed and ill-conceived measures that experts have said will have negligible impact. “Even the Government’s former tax advisor John Shewan says it won’t curb skyrocketing house prices or deter speculators.

“These are the actions of a bystander Government that has watched the Auckland housing crisis unfold and then done too little too late,” Andrew Little says.

It just might be at that.


Bonus question:

Yesterday Jessica Williams sparked an interesting discussion:

nat-cgt-discussion

So (asks Keith Ng) – are the Nats effectively underwriting losses when the property bubble bursts? Free money!


Bonus John Key lie:

“Housing crisis worse under Clark’s Government – Key”. Bernard Hickey called him out:

24 comments on “Rushed policy is bad policy”

  1. Lanthanide 1

    Re the losses thing: it is likely you won’t be able to claim losses. Someone said on National Radio that in most other countries, losses can’t be claimed at all, or can only be offset against future payable capital gains.

    • mickysavage 1.1

      This is the sort of detail that the Government should have worked through already. The fact they do not have a response shows how ruched this policy is.

      • stever 1.1.1

        🙂 “ruched”

        ….how appropriate…the Nats are ruffled!

      • John 1.1.2

        It’s so rushed, that the same tax applied under Labour over a decade age.

        The difference is that back then there were so many loopholes that nobody paid anything.

        After ordering the IRD to clamp down on people using loopholes in this tax in 2010, and again in 2012, 2013, and 2014, we now have yet another clamp down in 2015.

        After five years of consistently clamping down on a tax that’s been around for decades, it’s now a “rushed policy” “made up on the hoof”

        Yesterday, five years of consistent clamping down on an old tax was a called a “u-turn”.

        What will it be called tomorrow?

    • alwyn 1.2

      Are you sure that they said that you won’t be able to claim capital losses?
      I is fairly common, eg Australia, UK and the US to write them off against Capital Gains, and to be able to carry any excess losses forward but I don’t know of countries where you can’t claim them at all.
      Even the NZ Labour Party policy in 2014 was going to allow them, although there seemed to be a bit of confusion about it early in the piece.

      • Lanthanide 1.2.1

        I said it was likely you wouldn’t be able to claim losses, not that they have said that you can’t. And again, if you can claim losses, it will likely be against future capital gains – but some people will end up in a position where they can never claim them.

        • alwyn 1.2.1.1

          “some people will end up in a position where they can never claim them”
          I know that only to well. I left Australia just after the start of a tax year and, while tidying up our affairs, I ended up with a CGT loss for that final year. It was only a couple of hundred dollars but they have owed it to me for nearly 20 years…….
          Sob, sob, sob.
          I’m not planning to go back there to live though.

      • Enough is Enough 1.2.2

        David got himself tied up in knots a bit explaining losses during the campaign at a meeting I attended in Hamilton, but yes my understanding was that under the Labour policy you would be able to claim losses.

        • Herodotus 1.2.2.1

          Losses, were under labours proposal were able to be offset only by any future capital gains, and was not able to be offset by other forms of income. From memory this had a time out clause of about 6 years.

  2. Colonial Rawshark 2

    The NATs are still bungling the PR of this big time. They’ve lost their focus on who they are presenting their policy to. It’s like their PR advisors are still on holiday in Scotland.

  3. Old Mickey 3

    “Rushed policy is bad policy” except for Andrew Little’s promised R&D policy.

    • One Anonymous Bloke 3.1

      “Promised” – ie: not yet delivered.

      “Rushed” – ie: delivered too soon or with insufficient attention to detail.

      We need better wingnuts.

    • joe90 3.2

      Yes, three years before an election a proposal is rushed policy.

      idiot trool

  4. esoteric pineapples 4

    It may be rushed, it may be far from perfect – but it has been presented by National whereas anything from Labour, Greens etc would not be acceptable to New Zealand’s conservative voters. This means the most difficult task of introducing the concept has been done. Now I expect it to be incrementally improved over a period of time.

  5. Enough is Enough 5

    I am not going to criticise this. This government does many nasty things to Society on a daily basis so when they actually come out with something half decent we shouldn’t just all automatically oppose it.

    The best analysis I have seen of the policy is right here on The Standard.

    “The real effect will be to slow down the property market in Auckland, and elsewhere. It will knock the top edge off the market, winding it back just a little bit. Together with the Reserve Bank’s new rules about the deposits that Auckland property buyers must have, the heat may be taken out of the property market. There will still be pressure due to inwards migration, but frantic speculation in property should calm down.”

    That can only be a good thing.

    • alwyn 5.1

      Go on. Pretend you are the Labour Party leader.
      Tom Scott got Little’s approach perfectly this morning.
      If John Key announces something, anything, it is evil

      http://www.stuff.co.nz/blogs/opinion/cartoons/6736460/Tom-Scott-Murdoch-and-others

      • Lanthanide 5.1.1

        Reminds me of when Cullen suggested indexing the tax bands to inflation and it was derided as a ‘chewing gum tax cut’.

        Then Labour announced tax cuts in the 2008 budget and National said it wasn’t big enough, and promised “north of $50 a week” for someone on the average wage, which they then failed to deliver.

        The whole point of the opposition is to point out when the government isn’t doing a good job. So actually all you’ve highlighted is that Little is doing his job well. I sincerely hope National will be just as effective when they’re in opposition.

        • Enough is Enough 5.1.1.1

          “So actually all you’ve highlighted is that Little is doing his job well”

          Really?…I think Tom is trying to take the piss out of Andrew Little

    • Lanthanide 5.2

      You shouldn’t give them a free pass, though.

      Just because they’ve done “something”, doesn’t mean what they’ve done is sufficient, or even the right thing to do. 2 years isn’t much of a burden to work around at all – 5 years would be, and would have some real impact.

      Another thing they could do which would make quite a different for investors is simply restrict the availability of interest free loans, which are used by investors but not owner-occupiers. If there was a speed limit, say only 10% of the banks mortgages by volume could be interest-only, they’d really put a crimp on how many people could get them. They could even put in time-limits, so no more than 3 years IO loan for a particular property; gets tricky if people can shuffle the houses between different entities to keep resetting the 3 years though.

      Anyone who is routinely using IO loans is sending clear signals that they’re only in it for the capital gains.

      • Enough is Enough 5.2.1

        Yes and No.

        I think as far as a CGT goes the electorate has well and truly told Parliament over the past two elections what is acceptable, and a comprehensive broad tax is for better or worse, not an option in New Zealand. I think Andrew Little and Labour have accepted this.

        Key’s announcement is not a silver bullet and won’t in itself fix the problem. But it is a step in the right direction.

      • miravox 5.2.2

        “Another thing they could do”

        Remove tax loopholes on rental income.

        • John 5.2.2.1

          Like changing depreciation rules and tightening up claiming loses via LAQCs.

          Except that was done in 2010.

          • miravox 5.2.2.1.1

            That’s cool. So the people we know who tell us they still buy unseen rentals in places they’ve never been to write off their rental expenses against PAYE tax are telling porkies and will soon end up in court.

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

  • Wellington rail upgrade full steam ahead
    Transport Minister Phil Twyford today announced construction is underway on Wellington commuter rail upgrades which will mean more frequent services and fewer breakdowns. The upgrades include converting the Trentham to Upper Hutt single track section to a double track, with a new signalling system, upgraded stations and level crossings, and ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    31 mins ago
  • Defence Climate Change Implementation Plan released
    Minister of Defence Ron Mark and Minister for Climate Change James Shaw have announced the release of a Defence Climate Change Implementation Work Plan, titled Responding to the Climate Crisis: An Implementation Plan.  The plan sets out a series of recommendations based on the 2018 New Zealand Defence Assessment, The ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    32 mins ago
  • Govt releases funding to support South Canterbury
    A medium-scale adverse event has been declared for the South Canterbury district, which will see up to $50,000 in funding made available to support farming communities which have been significantly affected by recent heavy rain and flooding in the area, says Agriculture Minister Damien O’Connor. “Two weeks of solid rain ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    19 hours ago
  • Govt pledges next steps on plastic waste
    The Government will phase out more single-use plastics following the success of its single-use plastic bag ban earlier this year and the release today of a pivotal report for dealing with waste. Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern has welcomed the Rethinking Plastics in Aotearoa New Zealandreport, released by her Chief Science Advisor ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 day ago
  • International student enrolments grow in universities and the regions
    International education continues to thrive as the Government focuses on quality over quantity, Education Minister Chris Hipkins said. The tuition revenue from international education increased to $1.16 billion last year with the average tuition fee per student increasing by $960. The total number of international students enrolled in New Zealand ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • DHB leadership renewed and strengthened
    Health Minister Dr David Clark says new appointments to DHBs represent a significant changing of the guard, with 13 new chairs including four Māori chairs. Today 76 appointments have been announced to complement elected board members, as well as eight elected members appointed as either chair or deputy chair.  Four ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • Tabuteau to advance New Zealand’s trade and political interests with European partners
    Parliamentary Under-Secretary for Foreign Affairs, Fletcher Tabuteau, is travelling to Germany, Poland, Austria, and Spain next week to bolster New Zealand’s political and trade relationships in Europe. While in Spain, Mr Tabuteau will represent New Zealand at the 14th Asia-Europe (ASEM) Foreign Ministers’ Meeting in Madrid. “New Zealand strongly supports ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Statement from the Prime Minister on Kris Faafoi
    “I’ve spoken to Minister Faafoi, who has apologised for his poor handling of this issue,” Jacinda Ardern said. “I have confidence in Kris as a hardworking and effective Minister, but this should have been dealt with in a much clearer manner, and I’ve made my views on that very clear ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Tonga-New Zealand Joint Ministerial Forum
    Deputy Prime Minister Winston Peters met with Tongan Prime Minister and Foreign Minister Pohiva Tu'i'onetoa in Wellington today. The pair signed a Statement of Partnership setting out joint priorities for cooperation out to 2023.  “We welcomed Prime Minister Tu'i'onetoa on his first visit to New Zealand as Prime Minister. Tonga ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Shooting in Kurow
    The Minister of Police Stuart Nash says his sympathies are with the family of a man who died after being shot by Police in Kurow. “Initial reports are that Police were called by a family member to help the man who was threatening to harm himself,” Mr Nash says. “However ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Government delivers funding boost for ethnic communities
    Ethnic communities will be able to plan and deliver more community initiatives thanks to an increase in Government funding, Minister for Ethnic Communities Hon Jenny Salesa said today. “Ensuring Aotearoa New Zealand is a place we can all be proud to call home has been a key priority of our ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Govt supports Southland farmers in sustainability
    Healthier waterways, better productivity and farmer wellbeing are front and centre in a new project involving more than 1000 Southland farmers and growers. Minister of Agriculture Damien O’Connor today announced that the Thriving Southland Change and Innovation Project is the first region-wide extension programme supported by the $229 million Sustainable ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Flood of support for Top of the South catchment
    Work to look after nature and restore freshwater quality in Te Hoiere/Pelorus River catchment is getting a significant boost, thanks to new Government funding support Minister for Conservation Eugenie Sage announced in Canvastown today. “Every New Zealander should be able to swim in their local river without getting sick, and ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Eight Queen’s Counsel appointed under new criterion
    Eight Queen’s Counsel have been appointed under a process that includes the new criterion of a commitment to improving access to justice, Attorney-General David Parker announced today. “The new criterion was included this year. It emphasises that excellence and leadership in the profession can be seen through a wider, community ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Major expansion for Wellington’s Onslow College
    Onslow College in Wellington will get 20 new classrooms for more than 400 students, Education Minister Chris Hipkins announced today. The much-needed investment will relieve growth pressure the school has been experiencing for some time. Seven existing classrooms which have deteriorated over time will also be replaced, bringing the total ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Talented young Kiwis awarded PM’s Scholarships to Asia and Latin America
    More than 250 young New Zealanders will add international experience to their education, thanks to the latest Prime Minister’s Scholarships for Asia (PMSA) and Latin America (PMSLA), Education Minister Chris Hipkins announced today. This round of scholarships supports 252 recent graduates or current students to undertake study, research or internships ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Government to improve competitiveness and transparency in the retail fuel market
    Consumers will benefit from a more competitive, transparent retail fuel market as a result of changes the Government will be making in response to the findings of the Commerce Commission’s study of the fuel sector. “We accept the Commission’s findings and, as the Prime Minister has said, we’re ready to ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • More cancer medicines for more people
    Five new cancer medicines have now been funded this year, meaning thousands of people have more treatment options PHARMAC has today announced that it has approved two new medicines for funding – fulvestrant for breast cancer and olaparib for ovarian cancer. This follows earlier decisions on advanced lung cancer treatment alectinib, ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Government acts to sort out electoral ‘coin toss’ problem
    The Minister of Local Government, Hon Nanaia Mahuta says the Government will consider making changes to local electoral legislation before the 2022 elections to fix the problems that have arisen where elections are settled by a coin toss.  The Minister says the recount process in the Murupara- Galatea ward at ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • NZ to Join IMO Convention to Reduce Ship Emissions
    New Zealand will sign up to new international maritime regulations to reduce ship emissions and lift air quality around ports and harbours, Associate Transport Minister Julie Anne Genter announced today. Subject to completion of the Parliamentary treaty examination process, New Zealand will sign up to Annex VI of MARPOL, an ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Bill to empower urban development projects
    New legislation to transform our urban areas and create sustainable, inclusive and thriving communities will tomorrow be introduced to Parliament, Urban Development Minister Phil Twyford said. “The Urban Development Bill gives Kāinga Ora-Homes and Communities the tools it needs to partner with councils, communities, mana whenua and private developers to ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Early Learning Action Plan to kickstart long term change
    Today’s launch of He taonga te Tamaiti: Every child a taonga: The Early Learning Action Plan 2019-2029 provides the foundation for long-lasting changes to early learning, Education Minister Chris Hipkins says.   “Early learning will be one of the Government’s top education priorities going into 2020,” Chris Hipkins said.   ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Climate change lens on major Government decisions
    Major decisions made by the Government will now be considered under a climate change lens, Minister for Climate Change James Shaw announced today. “Cabinet routinely considers the effects of its decisions on human rights, the Treaty of Waitangi, rural communities, the disability community, and gender – now climate change will ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • New Tertiary Education Commission Board announced
    Education Minister Chris Hipkins today announced the appointment of Māori education specialist Dr Wayne Ngata and Business NZ head Kirk Hope to the Board of the Tertiary Education Commission (TEC). Dr Alastair MacCormick has been reappointed for another term. “Wayne Ngata, Kirk Hope and Alastair MacCormick bring a great deal ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Next phase of Pike River recovery underway in time for Christmas
    The next phase of the Pike River Re-entry project is underway, Minister Responsible for Pike River Re-entry Andrew Little says. “Fresh air will be pumped into the Pike River Mine drift this week, following acceptance of the plan for re-entry beyond the 170m barrier by New Zealand’s independent health and ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Insurance contracts to become easier to understand and fairer for consumers
    New Zealand consumers will have greater certainty about their insurance cover when they need to make claims as a result of proposed government changes. “Insurance is vitally important in supporting consumers and businesses to be financially resilient when unexpected events happen,” Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs Kris Faafoi said. ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • A new opportunity for Ngāpuhi collective and regional negotiations
    The Crown is providing an opportunity for the hapu of Ngāpuhi to rebuild its framework from the ground up for collective negotiations to deal with its historical Treaty claims, Minister for Treaty of Waitangi Negotiations Andrew Little and Minister for Māori Development Nanaia Mahuta announced today. The Crown is also ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Referendums Framework Bill passes third reading
    A Bill enabling referendums to be held with the 2020 General Election has passed its third reading. Justice Minister Andrew Little says the Act is important for upholding the integrity of New Zealand’s electoral process. “The Government has committed to holding a referendum on legalising recreational cannabis at the next ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Referendums website and initial cannabis Bill launched
    The first release of public information on the two referendums to be held at next year’s General Election was made today with an informative new Government website going live. Additionally, the draft Cannabis Legalisation and Control Bill has been released, showing the strict controls on cannabis that will apply if ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Government to ban foreign donations
    The Government is taking action to protect New Zealand from foreign interference in our elections by banning foreign donations to political parties and candidates, Justice Minister Andrew Little announced today. Legislation will be introduced to Parliament this afternoon and passed under urgency. “There’s no need for anyone other than New ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Governments and tech converge to strengthen joint response to online terror events
    Governments and tech companies are holding a two-day workshop, hosted by YouTube/Google in Wellington, to test the Christchurch Call Shared Crisis Response Protocol. The workshop aims to refine and strengthen the response in the event of a terrorist attack with online implications. Companies, governments, civil society experts and NGOs will ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Cancer Control Agency to drive improved care
    The new independent Cancer Control Agency has formally opened today, delivering on the Government’s plan to improve cancer care in New Zealand.         Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern and Minister of Health David Clark marked the occasion by announcing the membership of the Advisory Council that will be supporting ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Supporting small business to prosper
    Small businesses who deal with government departments are set to be paid faster and have improved cash flow as a result, under a new strategy released today. The Government is backing recommendations from the Small Business Council (SBC) and has agreed to implement three initiatives immediately to support business and ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • Bill has biggest education changes in decades
    The Education and Training Bill 2019, introduced in Parliament today, proposes the biggest education changes in decades and is an important step towards improving success for all our learners, Education Minister Chris Hipkins said. “The Bill’s rewrite of education legislation is long overdue. Indeed one Education Act, parts of which ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • Bali Democracy Forum to focus on democracy and inclusivity
    Minister for Pacific Peoples Aupito William Sio will travel to Bali to represent New Zealand at the 12th Bali Democracy Forum that will be held on the 5-6 December. “The Forum is a valuable opportunity for Asia-Pacific countries to share experiences and best practice in building home-grown democracy and fostering ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • Innovative technology and tools to better manage freedom camping
    A package of new and expanded technology and other tools will encourage responsible camping and help communities and local councils better manage freedom camping this summer, Tourism Minister Kelvin Davis announced today. “Our Government has been investing to improve the freedom camping experience for everyone because we want to support ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Improving wellbeing by understanding our genes
    The government is laying the groundwork to understanding our genes – work that can help us tackle some of our biggest health challenges, like heart disease and diabetes, says Research, Science and Innovation Minister Megan Woods. $4.7 million has been invested in the Genomics Aotearoa Rakeiora programme. The programme will ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Government investing to future proof school property
    Nearly every state schools will receive a capital injection next year valued at $693 per student to bring forward urgent school property improvements, Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern and Education Minister Chris Hipkins announced today.  The one-off cash injection is the first project to be announced from the Government’s infrastructure package ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Infrastructure investments to be brought forward
    The Government has decided to bring forward major investments in New Zealand’s infrastructure to future proof the economy. “Cabinet has agreed to a significant boost to infrastructure investment. I have directed the Treasury to help bring together a package of projects that can be brought into the Government’s short and ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Future-proofing New Zealand
    It is a great pleasure to be with you today in Whanganui. Like the Prime Minister I grew up with the TV clip of Selwyn Toogood booming “What do you say Whanganui, the money or the bag?” to an unsuspecting ‘It’s in the Bag’ audience. For those under the age ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago