The $8 billion robbery

Written By: - Date published: 3:44 pm, May 31st, 2009 - 44 comments
Categories: bill english, economy - Tags:

On Q+A this morning Guyon Espiner interviewed Bill English. Guyon had received papers from a treasury official that apparently show the cost of cancelling the government’s contributions to the Cullen Fund for 10 years will be $8 billion over and above the cost of borrowing to fund the contributions. $3.5 billion from lower value of the Fund and $4.5 billion from lower tax take. The Cullen Fund is one of the largest tax-payers.

Which makes a lot of sense. The long-run cost of borrowing government is 6% a year according to Treasury. That’s lower than the long-run return on the Cullen Fund of 6.57%, after tax (and on top of that there’s the tax that flows to the government). Even if the exact numbers are different in the end, the long-run return for a managed fund like the Cullen Fund is going to be higher than the interest rate on essentially risk-free debt issued by a government.

Put on the spot English couldn’t just say ‘Treasury’s wrong’ so his response was ‘well, the Cullen Fund lost money last year and was making 14% a year when it started’. Yeah, as Guyon pointed out, that’s why it’s called a long-run average. Some years are good, some are awful. The long-run is going to be better than the cost of government borrowing.

So, English had to try another angle. ‘If you have a mortgage and hire purchase and credit card debt , and you go to your bank manager and say ‘I want a hundred grand to play on the stockmarket’, see what kind of answer you get’.

Firstly, the government is not heavily indebted like English describes it. Our debt is actually very low by international standards (Ireland’s is over 45% of GDP, UK and US even higher, many OECD countries have more than 100% of GDP debt).

Secondly, the argument is basically that you shouldn’t have savings on borrowed money (as English said in his speech on Friday). Well, that’s plainly dumb. Anyone who has a mortgage and savings effectively has savings funded by borrowing. What’s more, if you extend English’s argument we should liquidate the Cullen Fund altogether, along with the ACC Fund, the EQC Fund, and any other financial assets we have to pay down our debt. Sometimes having an asset while also having debt makes sense. Especially when, like the government with the Cullen Fund, your expected return is greater than your cost of borrowing.

English is going to need to come up with a better excuse for starving the Cullen Fund to death and quick. Because right now it looks like he’s ripping off our country to the tune of $8 billion because of an ideological opposition to ensuring the future of superannuation.

44 comments on “The $8 billion robbery ”

  1. rave 1

    National’s ideological opposition to public funded super is based on the profit motive. The bosses keep their ideology in their hip pocket. English figures that the loss of $8 billion to workers in retirement is a gain of $8 billion to bosses profits instead.
    They object to ‘savings’ going to pay for workers retirement when these savings could be creamed by the banks and siphoned out by multinationals.
    Workers are expected to save as private individuals out of their measly wages to pay for their retirement or work until they drop.
    These guys are bosses. English is a farmer/bankster. He has no interest in seeing the social wage increase at the expense of profits.

    • indiana 1.1

      If individuals can’t save because of their measly wages, where do they find money for Sky TV subscriptions?

  2. cocamc 2

    so why did the legislation get written to suspend funds, surely Cullen knew something about the pro’s and con’s of borrowing to invest in the markets to have that provision made

    • Eddie 2.1

      Because it would be insane not to give the government the power to suspend payments in truely exceptional situations – war, major disaster, etc.

      That’s a pretty last ditch defence there, mate.

      • Pascal's bookie 2.1.1

        “That’s a pretty last ditch defence there, mate”

        Yeah.

        “Hey look 8 Billion dollars”

        “Yeah but the legislation says we can, and Cullen wrote it, so um, gotcha?”

        “Not even close. 8 Billion dollars short in fact.”

        • croong 2.1.1.1

          Haw haw haw

          • Pascal's bookie 2.1.1.1.1

            If you’re going to keep changing your handle you should try also changing the writing style. I’d suggest ‘smart’, or at a pinch, ‘not retarded’

            captcha: wilting doctor. Haw Haw

  3. Kelsey 3

    There are a number of things wrong with this article:

    1. “past returns are not an indicator of future performance”

    2. You use an analogy of someone with savings and a mortgage. Bad analogy. The only reason to do that is to retain some “buffer” money in case you have an emergency. These days people manage that with revolving credit, there by reducing the principle. Having the buffer costs money – specifically the difference between the mortgage rate and the post-tax savings.

    3. You ignore the risk profile, which is critical in analyzing investments.

    There are good reasons to criticize this budget, but this isn’t one of them. The point that nobody seems to be discussing is that the superfund is all about saving enough for future liabilities. Those liabilities have not gone away. If the liability were “on the balance sheet” the choice to put money in vs. not put in doesn’t change the total liability on the balance sheet.

    So by ceasing payments into the fund (which I support), we have not made a difference to our future liabilities. Given that govt spending is currently structurally higher than govt incomes, fundamentally something will need to change, sooner or later – reduced spending, higher taxes – or a larger economy (increased productivity). Fiddling with the Cullen fund is tinkering around the edges.

    CAPTCHA: The twigging

    • rave 3.1

      Yeah arent you being disingenuous? Liability?
      Its only a liability until Government can swing its repeal. a la Muldoon.
      Like preparation for privatisation elsewhere it is preparation for private pensions. Or raising the retirement age. Or shooting us at age 70.

  4. Bill 4

    Isn’t it odd that we, the workers, are asked to (and do ) invest a proportion of our wages into speculative schemes founded from the proceeds of the thievery perpetrated on us on a daily basis?

    Wonder how far a bag snatchers defence would get if they argued that although they had stolen the money, the victim seemed to be unaware of it and anyway, it was okay because they would use it to fund visits to the casino and return any resulting profit minus ‘administration costs’ to the victim?

    What if the victim could choose from a range of casino gambling games that moderated the level of potential returns and potential loss?

    I’m no lawyer, but reckon any variation on the above would be a lead balloon defence. And yet….

  5. wibblewithoutapause 5

    I grew up a Thatcher’s child. Saw the false promises from the UK Tories playing on peoples greed and delivering, to a small number of risk-takers, large wealth but the majority the loss of a real state pension and in many cases loss of any private retirement savings too. I saw first hand my working class parents work hard for everything they got and saw them lose it with redundancy when globalisation kicked in and jobs were off shored, bad financial advice for their meagre savings, and now minimum retirement since their private pensions didnt pan out like they were promised when taken out to supplement the lack of future planning for state pensions.

    WIth my experience of 80s Britain behind me I believe in a social contract between state and the individual. I am childless but am happy to pay the requisite tax levels to support the state benefit for parents, unemployment provision, health and welfare for everyone, education of the young. I I would like to think I would be able to call on the younger generations to provide a little for me in the future when I finally retire. If countries are being governed well then they will expand and their societies become more affluent through each generation.

    Why is a state pension system considered to be so wrong in the minds of the right wing..? The previous generations help the following generation grow up in a secure place so that the country grows and develops. Is it that bad for society then to help by paying into an ongoing social fund for retirement of the generation before them.

    The lack of ongoing government investment in the superannuation scheme is frightening. Isn’t a large shared pot better than many small investment pots? Given the dearth of trustworthy small scale financial managers available to the majority, where do you turn to to provide a scheme that may still be solvent in 20-30 years and doesn’t the shared costs of investment amongst many reduce the risks and charges to the individual? Why shouldn’t this be via the state?

  6. tsmithfield 6

    $8 billion is a mere projection. It doesn’t necessarily mean that if the money was invested there would be an $8b profit. If circumstances change, the Treasury projection could well change. Borrowing money to invest in the Cullen fund is mortgaging the future of us and our children for a possible return that carries a lot of risk.

    As someone pointed out on an earlier post, if it is soooo good, why do international lenders lend to governments for a low return rather than investing directly into shares themselves?

    Risk v Return people.

    If you’re borrowing the money, then you need to have a lot more certainty about the return than you would if it was money in the bank being invested. This is because the borrowed money plus interest still needs to be repaid if it all goes pear-shaped.

  7. albie 7

    So lets get this straight. You are arguing the government should be borrowing money at 6% to generate a 6.57% return. Are you serious or is this a joke? If the returns are guaranteed in the long run why stop at borrowing $2b? why not $4b or $10b?

    • Zetetic 7.1

      Just because you can make a profit borrowing a little more doesn’t mean you should borrow up to any level. Borrowing for the Cullen Fund would add a few % to gross debt in return for an even greater improvement to gross assets. We don’t want gross debt to get too high without good reason though.

      I thought you rightwingers were meant to be the economically smart ones. YOu don’t even understand the basics.

      • SPC 7.1.1

        I agree that borrowing has to be affordable.

        The thing is, buying is cheap now (and borrowing is cheap now) and if we simply borrow at $2B pa for 10 years the stock values would have recovered by then and borrowing costs will be higher (the consequences of government debt rising around the world).

        Cash is king now and the Super Fund with $12B in assets has the ability to borrow (and repay interest from the earnings flow of its assets). Once the ability to develop savings for the capital investment is gone the next stage is to borrow to maintain growth. Borrowing affordable because of the historic capital invested (this is how businesses operate).

        This would not require any financial assistance from government.

        It should be able to borrow up to half its asset portfolio (50% capital/50% debt financed). A first step would be to borrow 6 to $7B now and ivnest that (thus 1/3rd of the asset portfolio would be fianced by debt). If the Fund forecast of its $12.5B rising to $18B over 5 years is right, then 18B should rise to 25-27B in 5 years.

  8. Nickc 8

    Ha robbery? Getting the money used to pay for the super fund is far closer to robbery than not putting money into the superfund. One is actually activily stealing something someone has earned. The other is simply not giving someone free stuff.

  9. tsmithfield 9

    I agree albie.

    On the news tonight they actually gave the interest rates.

    The government borrows at between 4% & 5% (or sometimes higher). The projected return on the Cullen fund was around 6%. That is not a safe profit IMO. I certainly would not borrow to get that sort of return, especially on dodgy Treasury projections.

    It also says something about the quality of investment management they are getting. As I said in another post, these are fund managers employed to manage other peoples money. If they were so damn good at this, why aren’t they all self-made millionaires by now? A 6% return is pathetic. I would be wanting around 20% or better on this type of investing before I would consider it worth putting any money in at all considering the risk.

    I have seen in earlier posts that some here are having orgasms over the fact that the fund has recovered $1 billion or so recently. Lets not lose sight of the fact that it has lost a lot more than that recently, so it is still well down.

    I actually find it quite amusing that those here with a socialist bent are suddenly becoming rabid capitalists (when it comes to other peoples money). However, it was not too long ago when there was a plethora of articles here about how the capitalist system had screwed the world. Talk about having your cake and eating it too.

  10. Pascal's bookie 10

    I would be wanting around 20% or better on this type of investing before I would consider it worth putting any money in at all considering the risk.

    Oh yeah. fascinating. Why twenty, rather than twenty five, or twenty plus a pony?
    The return for the risk is priced at what it is, that’s the way it works. There aren’t twenty percent options available for this level of risk. At twenty percent return the risk would be much higher. What the hell are you talking about? And what do you mean by ‘this type of investing’. Sovereign funds? Take a look around, plenty of countries have got them. Those that set them up a while ago, had a field day last year buying up the collapsing private sector assets in the US and other places.

    I actually find it quite amusing that those here with a socialist bent are suddenly becoming rabid capitalists

    OK, define socialism as you are using it here, and capitalist, and give me an example of an actual poster or commenter that you think your criticism applies to. Do you think the Labour party is of a socialist bent? They created this fund, so your accusation looks pretty stupid already.

    Learn what ‘social democratic’ means, and ‘mixed economy’.

  11. Zaphod Beeblebrox 11

    I doubt that National will be able to sustain this in political terms for very long.
    As Arsineau said on Q and A this morning- the one thing that governments are expected to do is look after the elderly.

    • Steve 11.1

      I think what she actually said was that in politcal surveys most people felt governments had a responsibility to look after the elderly. There is a subtle difference. This government thru Key, says it does but the likes of English et al behind the scenes don’t feel this same responsibility.

      • Zaphod Beeblebrox 11.1.1

        I’m sure they do take their responsibilities seriously, otherwise why go to so much effort to get elected. Personally, I’d prefer they lifted their horizons a little higher.

  12. SPC 12

    The Super Fund should borrow up to its debt free value.

    Thus 50% capital (now $12.5 billion) and 50% borrowed funds. The return (dividends, rents etc) from the $25B would cover the cost of borriwing 12.5B
    Thus the capital gain would be derived from the $25 B total. This should be done while there are good buying opportunities.

    Thus the Fund can maximise profits which are there to be made, but within its own capacity to sustain the risk (on-going cost of the debt).

    A more conservative strategy would be to borrow only 1/3 of the fund value (thus $6-7 in the short-term).

    I have no confidence in their (honesty, saying no changes on Super during their term in office while leaving future governments with a hospital pass) capability to do the right thing in economic management, more especially where they are agenda driven.

    The idea that 40% of the 12.5 B should be invested in New Zealand is a sure way to diminsih its growth potential and ensure tax paid super is unaffordable. Its just a way of boosting local shares held by National Party friends – its just a boost to private profots. Shame.

  13. Anthony Karinski 13

    There’s no reason to borrow for the Cullen Fund specifically. The government could easily fulfill it’s payment from non borrowed sources. They could choose to borrow money for other things, like the cost of the recent tax-cuts or the Waterview connection. Alternatively they could cancel these and put the savings in the Cullen Fund. Shows the government’s priorities. Tax cuts for those least in need: 1 Old blue collar workers: 0

  14. gomango 14

    Here’s a quiz….

    Choose a few asset classes – lets say NZ Govt bonds, NZ Equities, Global Equities, US Equities. Could be anything. Data from 1991 – guess what the highest returning asset class over that entire period is?

    (I’m using EFFAS NZ Govt bond index, NZX50 and certain predecessors, MSCI Global, S&P500 but pretty much any index tells the same story).

    Yes – NZ govt bonds have the highest returns for those market betas. Check out the data, it’s very easy to see. Thats the dirty secret of the funds management industry. On average, the risk adjusted return for any risky asset class has to equal the risk free return. Add in management fees and particularly performance fees and the risk adjusted return for risky asset classes will often be less than the risk free rate. We live in an arbitrage free world. You can find evidence of certain excess risk premia that tend to exist ie small cap premia for instance but this is most likely due to selection bias and survivorship bias.

    The best analogy for taking overweight positions in risky assets is the old options analogy – which makes sense as portfolio theory is essentially the selling of put options on risky assets – the analogy is “snatching nickels from in front of a steamroller.” Yes you can make money most of the time but every now and then you get your arm ripped off.

    Do a portfolio optimisation using long run historic data, with unconstrained allocations and a NZ funded investor will always get a portfolio constructed alomost entirely of fixed income assets.

    The argument about borrowing to invest only makes sense if the quality of your management or manager selection can consistently beat the average manager by a margin greater than the fee burden. Yet almost every piece of research I have ever seen shows that the number of managers who actually perform better than the market in the long run is exactly the number you’d expect to do so in a statistical sense. There are also studies that show the best indicator of a good performance by a manager next year is a bad performance last year, and vice versa. A Random Walk down Wall Street.

    The other point most people seem to miss about sovereign wealth funds is that there are very few globally that work like NZ and Aus, ie funded out of general tax revenues. Most sovereign wealth funds are either commodity revenue stores (Dubai, Abu Dhabi, Norway, Brunei, Saudi Arabia, Alaska, Alberta, Kuwait, Iran etc), or created from Foreign Exchange sterilisation (Singapore, China, Taiwan, South Korea, etc). Our situation is actually unusual in global terms which is why when it was set up under Cullen great care was taken re the mechanism to delay contributions in times of budget deficit. The current debate reminds me of other garbage in garbage out public sector finance debates in the past like the extinction of government debt markets in (variously) NZ, Aus, USA, Canada, Germany etc. Look at it now.

    The right debate to have here is not about contributions in times of budget deficit – even Cullen would likely delay them in the current environment. The right debate is about the best shape of revenue collection and expenditure, but that is a little difficult when the only parties on the record with detailed budget numbers are National (obviously), Act (ignore them – worthy objectives but socially too painful to implement) and the Greens (again noble intentions but unrealistic to 85% of NZ’ers).

  15. OhPlease 15

    This raises the question of why English did not raise taxes to pay into the Cullen Fund ?

    In my opinion the Cullen Fund was always political rather than economic.It was designed to make it politically harder for echo boomers to renege on baby boomers’ entitlements. For this reason continuing to pay in to it gives retirees the ability to say “my taxes pad for the super- and I am therefore entitled to it”.

    The analogy that is being used to equate borrowing by Government to a household to investing in shares is completely spurious.

    Unlike firms, households etc, revenue for Governments is not capped. It is completely in their hands whether they raise tax rates or raise borrowing. A Budget is about choices over tax, borrowing and spending. Our tax rates are not that high. Although the burden is disproportionately on some high income tax payers, the reason is not that we have high EMTRs but that we have a unequal underlying income distribution. Given that life expectancy increases with wealth, taxing to pay for Cullen Fund is almost a user-pays charge – the richer who pay now will have a longer retirement.

    The question is not whether we should borrow to pay for the fund, but why we don’t raise taxes to pay for the fund. Since most of the tax burden falls on those who will retire in the next 20 years, seems a very reasonable thing to do.

    • aj 15.1

      last para above: exactly.

      • RedLogix 15.1.1

        Although the burden is disproportionately on some high income tax payers, the reason is not that we have high EMTRs but that we have a unequal underlying income distribution.

        Some very good observations in this comment. Welcome to The Standard; looking forward seeing more from you.

        Actually this whole thread has been good reading.

    • Zaphod Beeblebrox 15.2

      The question is why is it that we don’t have enough money to give everybody a dignified retirement?
      It can’t be that we overpay our doctors and teachers- they leave to go O/S for more pay.
      It can’t be that our schools and hospitals are over resourced, our hospitals struggle and our school donations are increasing.
      It can’t be that we are over governed and have too many public servants. We only have 2 tiers or government and our ratio of public servants to population is lower than OZ.
      The only explanation could be that we don’t raise enough tax- we don’t have a CGT and we don’t have stamp duty for property transactions, even without these taxes we wouldn’t need much of an increase of marginal rates to properly fund retirement.

  16. tsmithfield 16

    Pascal:

    “Oh yeah. fascinating. Why twenty, rather than twenty five, or twenty plus a pony?
    The return for the risk is priced at what it is, that’s the way it works.”

    You obviously don’t understand the concept of risk and return. The return determines how quickly you can get your original capital amount back out again. The quicker this happens, the lower your risk. You probably also want to consider the NPV v NFV of money, as you will want to get the inflation adjusted amount back. In the case of borrowed money, you also will want to get the interest paid on the principal invested back as well to completely cover your risk.

    To keep things simple, lets just consider recovering the original principal. At 20% the capital will be returned in 5 years. At 6% it will be returned in nearly 17 years. When adjustments are made for inflation and recovering interest paid, at 6% return it could take 25-30 years to get the original sum back.

    The recent recession has been described in a once in 60 year event by some commentators. So, by accepting 25-30 years to get your money back you are accepting a reasonably high degree of risk that there could be another once in 60 year event in that time frame that wipes out your investment. Especially considering the tenuous situation with oil etc over the coming period.

    So, I stand by what I stated. 6% return is pathetic and unacceptable for this type of investment.

    Pascal:

    “Do you think the Labour party is of a socialist bent? They created this fund, so your accusation looks pretty stupid already.”

    Given my analysis above, then, yes. I think it was a stupid investment decision.

    • Zaphod Beeblebrox 16.1

      TS- I agree about the risk, but doesn’t risk even out over an extended period?
      Surely an objective of the government should be to encourage more saving, less spending. We could use this saving to reduce the current account deficit and free up capital for investment in productive enterprises in NZ.
      Reducing taxation and at the same time reducing our savings for retirement would have to be antithetical to this.

    • Pascal's bookie 16.2

      The return determines how quickly you can get your original capital amount back out again. The quicker this happens, the lower your risk.

      I’ll happily admit to not being anything like an expert on this sort of stuff, but it was my impression that higher returns were related higher risk, which seems to be the opposite of what you are saying. I had thought that to get a 20% return, you had to be prepared to run a higher risk of also losing capital if the investment went bad for whatever reason. Certainly if one could guarantee a 20 % return, then one could obviously get a much quicker 100% return from the capital invested. If you are saying that this sort of investment should be put into riskier high returning options because given the time frame a few bad years won’t matter, as they can be made up in the good years, then I understand, but you don’t seem to be saying that. Where am I going wrong?

      Given my analysis above, then, yes. I think it was a stupid investment decision.

      That wasn’t the question. Funnily enough, in your other comments about what we should be doing with the fund you take a far more ‘socialist’ line, with the govt. effectively hoovering up parts of the economy.

      With regard to investing overseas is there not some merit in the idea that the returns garnered have the benefit of not being extracted from our domestic economy but someone elses?

  17. tsmithfield 17

    Zaphod “We could use this saving to reduce the current account deficit and free up capital for investment in productive enterprises in NZ.”

    Yes, I think this is a much better strategy than the risky Cullen fund.

    We could invest the money in SOEs that could provide infrastructure services and charge market rates for these that are passed on to the consumer. Thus, consumers pay no more than they would have otherwise paid and the country builds up very safe, profit producing enterprises.

    For instance, we could have an SOE that provides sewage services for the country. Scales of economy, planning etc should allow them to provide services at a cheaper rate than councils individually. The SOE could charge the councils who would pass the cost on through rates, at hopefully a cheaper rate than consumers pay now.

    • Zaphod Beeblebrox 17.1

      No problem with infrastructure, but what about stuff like helping farmers and tourism. For instance, we could increase food production massively by lending for farmers to help them build dams (kiwis seem to think we don’t need them for some reason) thereby reducing losses during droughts.
      Read about the Chinese being keen for healthy, safe food products- the Aussies are pouring massive amounts of money into food research. How about a food institute for researching new products, we could not only export the products but the patents as well.

  18. tsmithfield 18

    Zaphod “but what about stuff like helping farmers and tourism. For instance, we could increase food production massively by lending for farmers to help them build dams (kiwis seem to think we don’t need them for some reason) thereby reducing losses during droughts.”

    Would have no problems with this either so long as “risk and return” principles are followed. I would prefer to see the funds invested in our own country where we have much more control than in the overseas environment where we have little control.

  19. gomango 19

    OhPlease – thats exactly the point I was trying to make. The argument isnt about whether we should contribute to the cullen fund in times of budget deficit. The answer to that in rational economic terms is no and always will be on a risk adjusted, cost of equity basis. The structure of the fund is designed so that in times of budget deficit contributions are withheld. That is not a political , left versus right argument.

    The question to debate is as you point out is what is the right mix between governement revenue and expenditure. We cant have it all ways. We can’t have stimulus a la the US and UK (which is incredibly inefficient and gone straight to the people lamented on this website – bank and business owners with political clout. What homeowner is getting direct assistance via a large check from the US Treasury?), we cant also have large tax cuts, we can’t also have 8% growth in public sector spending, we can’t also have massive infrastructure all at the same time. Something has to give – the two easiest things are Cullen fund contributions following the formula set by D Cullen, then tax cuts, then unconstrained public sector spending growth etc.

    The US and UK stimulus packages will be seen with history to be follies – necessary to maintain a functioning bank system but otherwise incredibly wasteful and inefficiently applied.

    And while not dismissing the potential pain of many over the next 18 months in NZ, no projections I have seen for unemployment reach the terrible times we experienced in the late 80’s early 90’s where too rapid adjustments were accompanied by a far less sympathetic social welfare approach than we have now. I’d rather be unemployed now than in 1991 (which is lucky because I am! though I will never draw a benefit, and hence won’t show up in the stats).

    Until there is a bi-partisan approach in NZ to three big issues – superannuation entitlements, compulsory savings and taxation of savings (including capital gains on property investment) we will always lurch from one policy to another, and as a result always – no matter who is in power – need to fund superannuation out of general, current tax revenue.

    Think how we’d look if the cullen fund broken up to individual accounts for everyone in NZ, contributions became compulsory and tax free for individuals, the govt mandated a minimum retirement income which is set off against each persons individual retirement account and topped up if necessary out of general revenue. Leave the cullen fund as the default provider of investment services. When surpluses return the govt can do what Singapore does – every now and then declare a dividend which is given to the individual account holder for their pension fund. And on retirement age individuals can do whatever they like with their money but how about these for options individuals:

    1 disappear into the sunset with their money and receive nothing in superannuation from the govt, unless the individual chooses to buy an annuity from the govt
    2 buy an annuity from the govt with their capital – if this is grater than the super entitlement , well and good. The govt has no additional obligation to you.
    3 buy an annuity from the govt – if this is less than the super entitlement then the govt agrees to top it up to the minimum for life.

    If you have more money than required, then happy days – you don’t need the government anymore in your retirement. If not the govt guarantees minimum super as it does now.

    Set the annuity levels based on 10 year govt bond rates plus say 1% and everyone is happy. Start the retirement end of the scheme in say 25 years to allow people time to adjust and we’d be in a much better place as a country.

    Pretty simple stuff – not much different to what happens now but formalising the situation, encouraging us to save, not taxing at all retirement savings and giving individuals an ownership incentive to look after themselves would be a big step forward.

    • Pascal's bookie 19.1

      We can’t have stimulus a la the US and UK (which is incredibly inefficient and gone straight to the people lamented on this website – bank and business owners with political clout. What homeowner is getting direct assistance via a large check from the US Treasury?)…

      …The US and UK stimulus packages will be seen with history to be follies – necessary to maintain a functioning bank system but otherwise incredibly wasteful and inefficiently applied.

      The bank bailouts are separate from the stimulus packages aren’t they? I mean , they weren’t ‘sold’ as being stimulus, and that’s not what they intended to. It seems silly to judge them, or the idea of stimulus, based on what stimulatory effects and costs the bailouts have.

    • SPC 19.2

      “The argument isnt about whether we should contribute to the cullen fund in times of budget deficit. The answer to that in rational economic terms is no and always will be on a risk adjusted, cost of equity basis.’

      Then why did the Minister of Finance write otherwise in February of this year?

      “Something has to give – the two easiest things are Cullen fund contributions following the formula set by D Cullen, then tax cuts, then unconstrained public sector spending growth etc.”

      The forumla specified by Cullen was not to be pre-determined for a 10 year period. What the government did was determine it had other priorities on which it use any possible surplus in the meantime. My guess is that this National government intends to offer a tax reform programme involving a top rate of tax at 30% during the 10 year period.

      In 1990 they cut benefits because of a deficit and then back in surplus they gave it to middle class tax payers in a tax cut. This government intends to end savings while in deficit and then when back in surplus (or before) hand out a tax cut. Same old routine.

    • SPC 19.3

      “Think how we’d look if the cullen fund broken up to individual accounts for everyone in NZ, contributions became compulsory and tax free for individuals, the govt mandated a minimum retirement income which is set off against each persons individual retirement account and topped up if necessary out of general revenue. Leave the cullen fund as the default provider of investment services. When surpluses return the govt can do what Singapore does – every now and then declare a dividend which is given to the individual account holder for their pension fund. And on retirement age individuals can do whatever they like with their money but how about these for options individuals:

      1 disappear into the sunset with their money and receive nothing in superannuation from the govt, unless the individual chooses to buy an annuity from the govt
      2 buy an annuity from the govt with their capital – if this is grater than the super entitlement , well and good. The govt has no additional obligation to you.
      3 buy an annuity from the govt – if this is less than the super entitlement then the govt agrees to top it up to the minimum for life.

      If you have more money than required, then happy days – you don’t need the government anymore in your retirement. If not the govt guarantees minimum super as it does now.

      Set the annuity levels based on 10 year govt bond rates plus say 1% and everyone is happy. Start the retirement end of the scheme in say 25 years to allow people time to adjust and we’d be in a much better place as a country.

      Pretty simple stuff – not much different to what happens now but formalising the situation, encouraging us to save, not taxing at all retirement savings and giving individuals an ownership incentive to look after themselves would be a big step forward.”

      You and the Kiwiblog host should get a room or form a club.

  20. tsmithfield 20

    Pascal:

    “I had thought that to get a 20% return, you had to be prepared to run a higher risk of also losing capital if the investment went bad for whatever reason.”

    As I understand it, the money invested in the fund is invested as totally unsecured. That is risky in anyones books. 6% is simply not high enough return.

    Pascal

    “Funnily enough, in your other comments about what we should be doing with the fund you take a far more ‘socialist’ line, with the govt. effectively hoovering up parts of the economy.”

    Probably right. However, I don’t see myself as purely capatilist. I take a more pragmatic approach. However, I think any government involvement in the economy needs to be at market rates to avoid distortions in the economy. It would be important to ensure that consumers are not adversely impacted by this sort of move.

    My point is that there is a much more certain business case for investing in our own economy in SOE’s and the like. SOE’s that are providing necessary services have to be very safe, will provide an ongoing return, and provide an asset that could be sold in the future if necessary. Looks a lot better bet than the uncertainties involved in the Cullen fund, and I bet they would provide a much better return than 6%.

  21. SPC 21

    So the risk premium in saving with the NZ Government (bonds) is the highest in the investment world – as gomango claims

    The problem for the Super Fund is of course its ability to take advantage of this is is limited to the level of government debt. Good news, this debt is rising, so why limit investment into the Fund now? Or why not simply demand that the Super Fund lend its $12.5B to the government -then the interest paid would go to the Fund sans tax paid on this income.

    Joking aside, this would imply that we have more reason than other countries with lower bond rates to consider innovative (or just loose monetary policy – free credit to government) forms of finance, as here the comparative inflation cost is lower than the cost of debt. So why our hardline RB policy?

    PS gomango chooses to make his case based on a large fall in stock values – hardly a case for a fair comparison.

  22. SPC 22

    gomango

    “The argument isnt about whether we should contribute to the cullen fund in times of budget deficit. The answer to that in rational economic terms is no and always will be on a risk adjusted, cost of equity basis.”

    Then why did the Minister of Finance write otherwise in February of this year?

Links to post

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

  • Misremembering Justinian’s Taxes.
    Tax Lawyer Barbara Edmonds vs Emperor Justinian I - Nolo Contendere: False historical explanations of pivotal events are very far from being inconsequential.WHEN BARBARA EDMONDS made reference to the Roman Empire, my ears pricked up. It is, lamentably, very rare to hear a politician admit to any kind of familiarity ...
    27 mins ago
  • Bryce Edwards: Scoring 4.6 out of 10, the new Government is struggling in the polls
    It’s been a tumultuous time in politics in recent months, as the new National-led Government has driven through its “First 100 Day programme”. During this period there’s been a handful of opinion polls, which overall just show a minimal amount of flux in public support for the various parties in ...
    Democracy ProjectBy bryce.edwards
    1 hour ago
  • Bishop scores headlines with crackdown on unwelcome tenants – but Peters scores, too, as tub-thump...
    Buzz from the Beehive Housing Minister Chris Bishop delivered news – packed with the ingredients to enflame political passions – worthy of supplanting Winston Peters in headline writers’ priorities. He popped up at the post-Cabinet press conference to promise a crackdown on unruly and antisocial state housing tenants. His ...
    Point of OrderBy Bob Edlin
    2 hours ago
  • Will it make the boat go faster?
    Ele Ludemann writes – The Reserve Bank is advertising for a Diversity, Equity and Inclusion advisor. The Bank has one mandate – to keep inflation between one and three percent. It has failed in that and is only slowly getting inflation back down to the upper limit. Will it ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    5 hours ago
  • Bryce Edwards: Is Simon Bridges’ NZTA appointment a conflict of interest?
    Last week former National Party leader Simon Bridges was appointed by the Government as the new chair of the New Zealand Transport Agency Waka Kotahi (NZTA). You can read about the appointment in Thomas Coughlan’s article, Simon Bridges to become chair of NZ Transport Agency Waka Kotahi The fact that a ...
    Democracy ProjectBy bryce.edwards
    5 hours ago
  • Is Simon Bridges’ NZTA appointment a conflict of interest?
    Bryce Edwards writes – Last week former National Party leader Simon Bridges was appointed by the Government as the new chair of the New Zealand Transport Agency Waka Kotahi (NZTA). You can read about the appointment in Thomas Coughlan’s article, Simon Bridges to become chair of NZ Transport Agency ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    5 hours ago
  • Bernard's Top 10 @ 10 'pick 'n' mix' at 10:10am on Tuesday, March 19
    TL;DR: My top 10 news and analysis links this morning include:Today’s must-read: Gavin Jacobson talks to Thomas Piketty 10 years on from Capital in the 21st Century The SalvoLocal scoop: Green MP’s business being investigated over migrant exploitation claims Stuff Steve KilgallonLocal deep-dive: The commercial contractors making money from School ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    6 hours ago
  • Bernard's six newsy things on Tuesday, March 19
    It’s a home - but Kāinga Ora tenants accused of “abusing the privilege” may lose it. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāTL;DR: The Government announced a crackdown on Kāinga Ora tenants who were unruly and/or behind on their rent, with Housing Minister Chris Bishop saying a place in a state ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    7 hours ago
  • New Life for Light Rail
    This is a guest post by Connor Sharp of Surface Light Rail  Light rail in Auckland: A way forward sooner than you think With the coup de grâce of Auckland Light Rail (ALR) earlier this year, and the shift of the government’s priorities to roads, roads, and more roads, it ...
    Greater AucklandBy Guest Post
    8 hours ago
  • Why Are Bosses Nearly All Buffoons?
    Note: As a paid-up Webworm member, I’ve recorded this Webworm as a mini-podcast for you as well. Some of you said you liked this option - so I aim to provide it when I get a chance to record! Read more ...
    David FarrierBy David Farrier
    10 hours ago
  • Bernard’s six-stack of substacks at 6.06 pm on March 18
    TL;DR: In my ‘six-stack’ of substacks at 6.06pm on Monday, March 18:IKEA is accused of planting big forests in New Zealand to green-wash; REDD-MonitorA City for People takes a well-deserved victory lap over Wellington’s pro-YIMBY District Plan votes; A City for PeopleSteven Anastasiou takes a close look at the sticky ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    22 hours ago
  • Peters holds his ground on co-governance, but Willis wriggles on those tax cuts and SNA suspension l...
    Buzz from the Beehive Here’s hoping for a lively post-cabinet press conference when the PM and – perhaps – some of his ministers tell us what was discussed at their meeting today. Until then, Point of Order has precious little Beehive news to report after its latest monitoring of the ...
    Point of OrderBy Bob Edlin
    1 day ago
  • Labour’s final report card
    David Farrar writes –  We now have almost all 2023 data in, which has allowed me to update my annual table of how  went against its promises. This is basically their final report card. The promise The result Build 100,000 affordable homes over 10 ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    1 day ago
  • “Drunk Uncle at a Wedding”
    I’m a bit worried that I’ve started a previous newsletter with the words “just when you think they couldn’t get any worse…” Seems lately that I could begin pretty much every issue with that opening. Such is the nature of our coalition government that they seem to be outdoing each ...
    Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel
    1 day ago
  • Wang Yi’s perfectly-timed, Aukus-themed visit to New Zealand
    Geoffrey Miller writes – Timing is everything. And from China’s perspective, this week’s visit by its foreign minister to New Zealand could be coming at just the right moment. The visit by Wang Yi to Wellington will be his first since 2017. Anniversaries are important to Beijing. ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    1 day ago
  • Gordon Campbell on Dune 2, and images of Islam
    Depictions of Islam in Western popular culture have rarely been positive, even before 9/11. Five years on from the mosque shootings, this is one of the cultural headwinds that the Muslim community has to battle against. Whatever messages of tolerance and inclusion are offered in daylight, much of our culture ...
    1 day ago
  • New Rail Operations Centre Promises Better Train Services
    Last week Transport Minster Simeon Brown and Mayor Wayne Brown opened the new Auckland Rail Operations Centre. The new train control centre will see teams from KiwiRail, Auckland Transport and Auckland One Rail working more closely together to improve train services across the city. The Auckland Rail Operations Centre in ...
    1 day ago
  • Bernard's six newsy things at 6.36am on Monday, March 18
    Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāTL;DR: Retiring former Labour Finance Minister Grant Robertson said in an exit interview with Q+A yesterday the Government can and should sustain more debt to invest in infrastructure for future generations. Elsewhere in the news in Aotearoa-NZ’s political economy at 6:36am: Read more ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    1 day ago
  • Geoffrey Miller: Wang Yi’s perfectly-timed, Aukus-themed visit to New Zealand
    Timing is everything. And from China’s perspective, this week’s visit by its foreign minister to New Zealand could be coming at just the right moment. The visit by Wang Yi to Wellington will be his first since 2017. Anniversaries are important to Beijing. It is more than just a happy ...
    Democracy ProjectBy Geoffrey Miller
    1 day ago
  • The Kaka’s diary for the week to March 25 and beyond
    TL;DR: The key events to watch in Aotearoa-NZ’s political economy in the week to March 18 include:China’s Foreign Minister visiting Wellington today;A post-cabinet news conference this afternoon; the resumption of Parliament on Tuesday for two weeks before Easter;retiring former Labour Finance Minister Grant Robertson gives his valedictory speech in Parliament; ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    1 day ago
  • Bitter and angry; Winston First
    New Zealand First Leader Winston Peters’s state-of-the-nation speech on Sunday was really a state-of-Winston-First speech. He barely mentioned any of the Government’s key policies and could not even wholly endorse its signature income tax cuts. Instead, he rehearsed all of his complaints about the Ardern Government, including an extraordinary claim ...
    PolitikBy Richard Harman
    1 day ago
  • 2024 SkS Weekly Climate Change & Global Warming News Roundup #11
    A listing of 35 news and opinion articles we found interesting and shared on social media during the past week: Sun, March 10, 2024 thru Sat, March 16, 2024. Story of the week This week we'll give you a little glimpse into how we collect links to share and ...
    1 day ago
  • 2024 SkS Weekly Climate Change & Global Warming News Roundup #11
    A listing of 35 news and opinion articles we found interesting and shared on social media during the past week: Sun, March 10, 2024 thru Sat, March 16, 2024. Story of the week This week we'll give you a little glimpse into how we collect links to share and ...
    1 day ago
  • Out of Touch.
    “I’ve been internalising a really complicated situation in my head.”When they kept telling us we should wait until we get to know him, were they taking the piss? Was it a case of, if you think this is bad, wait till you get to know the real Christopher, after the ...
    Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel
    2 days ago
  • Bring out your Dad
    Happy fourth anniversary, Pandemic That Upended Bloody Everything. I have been observing it by enjoying my second bout of COVID. It’s 5.30 on Sunday morning and only now are lights turning back on for me.Allow me to copy and paste what I told reader Sara yesterday:Depleted, fogged and crappy. Resting, ...
    More Than A FeildingBy David Slack
    2 days ago
  • Bring out your Dad
    Happy fourth anniversary, Pandemic That Upended Bloody Everything. I have been observing it by enjoying my second bout of COVID. It’s 5.30 on Sunday morning and only now are lights turning back on for me.Allow me to copy and paste what I told reader Sara yesterday:Depleted, fogged and crappy. Resting, ...
    More Than A FeildingBy David Slack
    2 days ago
  • Bring out your Dad
    Happy fourth anniversary, Pandemic That Upended Bloody Everything. I have been observing it by enjoying my second bout of COVID. It’s 5.30 on Sunday morning and only now are lights turning back on for me.Allow me to copy and paste what I told reader Sara yesterday:Depleted, fogged and crappy. Resting, ...
    More Than A FeildingBy David Slack
    2 days ago
  • The bewildering world of Chris Luxon – Guns for all, not no lunch for kids
    .“$10 and a target that bleeds” - Bleeding Targets for Under $10!.Thanks for reading Frankly Speaking ! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.This government appears hell-bent on either scrapping life-saving legislation or reintroducing things that - frustrated critics insist - will be dangerous and likely ...
    Frankly SpeakingBy Frank Macskasy
    3 days ago
  • Expert Opinion: Ageing Boomers, Laurie & Les, Talk Politics.
    It hardly strikes me as fair to criticise a government for doing exactly what it said it was going to do. For actually keeping its promises.”THUNDER WAS PLAYING TAG with lightning flashes amongst the distant peaks. Its rolling cadences interrupted by the here-I-come-here-I-go Doppler effect of the occasional passing car. ...
    3 days ago
  • Manufacturing The Truth.
    Subversive & Disruptive Technologies: Just as happened with that other great regulator of the masses, the Medieval Church, the advent of a new and hard-to-control technology – the Internet –  is weakening the ties that bind. Then, and now, those who enjoy a monopoly on the dissemination of lies, cannot and will ...
    3 days ago
  • A Powerful Sensation of Déjà Vu.
    Been Here Before: To find the precedents for what this Coalition Government is proposing, it is necessary to return to the “glory days” of Muldoonism.THE COALITION GOVERNMENT has celebrated its first 100 days in office by checking-off the last of its listed commitments. It remains, however, an angry government. It ...
    3 days ago
  • Can you guess where world attention is focussed (according to Greenpeace)? It’s focussed on an EPA...
    Bob Edlin writes –  And what is the world watching today…? The email newsletter from Associated Press which landed in our mailbox early this morning advised: In the news today: The father of a school shooter has been found guilty of involuntary manslaughter; prosecutors in Trump’s hush-money case ...
    Point of OrderBy Bob Edlin
    3 days ago
  • Further integrity problems for the Greens in suspending MP Darleen Tana
    Bryce Edwards writes – Is another Green MP on their way out? And are the Greens severely tarnished by another integrity scandal? For the second time in three months, the Green Party has secretly suspended an MP over integrity issues. Mystery is surrounding the party’s decision to ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    3 days ago
  • Jacqui Van Der Kaay: Greens’ transparency missing in action
    For the last few years, the Green Party has been the party that has managed to avoid the plague of multiple scandals that have beleaguered other political parties. It appears that their luck has run out with a second scandal which, unfortunately for them, coincided with Golraz Ghahraman, the focus ...
    Democracy ProjectBy bryce.edwards
    3 days ago
  • Bernard’s Dawn Chorus with six newsey things at 6:46am for Saturday, March 16
    TL;DR: The six newsey things that stood out to me as of 6:46am on Saturday, March 16.Andy Foster has accidentally allowed a Labour/Green amendment to cut road user chargers for plug-in hybrid vehicles, which the Government might accept; NZ Herald Thomas Coughlan Simeon Brown has rejected a plea from Westport ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    3 days ago
  • How Did FTX Crash?
    What seemed a booming success a couple of years ago has collapsed into fraud convictions.I looked at the crash of FTX (short for ‘Futures Exchange’) in November 2022 to see whether it would impact on the financial system as a whole. Fortunately there was barely a ripple, probably because it ...
    PunditBy Brian Easton
    4 days ago
  • Elections in Russia and Ukraine
    Anybody following the situation in Ukraine and Russia would probably have been amused by a recent Tweet on X NATO seems to be putting in an awful lot of effort to influence what is, at least according to them, a sham election in an autocracy.When do the Ukrainians go to ...
    4 days ago
  • Bernard’s six stack of substacks at 6pm on March 15
    TL;DR: Shaun Baker on Wynyard Quarter's transformation. Magdalene Taylor on the problem with smart phones. How private equity are now all over reinsurance. Dylan Cleaver on rugby and CTE. Emily Atkin on ‘Big Meat’ looking like ‘Big Oil’.Bernard’s six-stack of substacks at 6pm on March 15Photo by Jeppe Hove Jensen ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    4 days ago
  • Buzz from the Beehive Finance Minister Nicola Willis had plenty to say when addressing the Auckland Business Chamber on the economic growth that (she tells us) is flagging more than we thought. But the government intends to put new life into it:  We want our country to be a ...
    Point of OrderBy Bob Edlin
    4 days ago
  • National’s clean car tax advances
    The Transport and Infrastructure Committee has reported back on the Road User Charges (Light Electric RUC Vehicles) Amendment Bill, basicly rubberstamping it. While there was widespread support among submitters for the principle that EV and PHEV drivers should pay their fair share for the roads, they also overwhelmingly disagreed with ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    4 days ago
  • Government funding bailouts
    Peter Dunne writes – This week’s government bailout – the fifth in the last eighteen months – of the financially troubled Ruapehu Alpine Lifts company would have pleased many in the central North Island ski industry. The government’s stated rationale for the $7 million funding was that it ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    4 days ago
  • Two offenders, different treatments.
    See if you can spot the difference. An Iranian born female MP from a progressive party is accused of serial shoplifting. Her name is leaked to the media, which goes into a pack frenzy even before the Police launch an … Continue reading ...
    KiwipoliticoBy Pablo
    4 days ago
  • Treaty references omitted
    Ele Ludemann writes  – The government is omitting general Treaty references from legislation : The growth of Treaty of Waitangi clauses in legislation caused so much worry that a special oversight group was set up by the last Government in a bid to get greater coherence in the public service on Treaty ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    4 days ago
  • The Ghahraman Conflict
    What was that judge thinking? Peter Williams writes –  That Golriz Ghahraman and District Court Judge Maria Pecotic were once lawyer colleagues is incontrovertible. There is published evidence that they took at least one case to the Court of Appeal together. There was a report on ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    4 days ago
  • Bernard's Top 10 @ 10 'pick 'n' mix' for March 15
    TL;DR: My top 10 news and analysis links this morning include:Today’s must-read: Climate Scorpion – the sting is in the tail. Introducing planetary solvency. A paper via the University of Exeter’s Institute and Faculty of Actuaries.Local scoop: Kāinga Ora starts pulling out of its Auckland projects and selling land RNZ ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    4 days ago
  • The day Wellington up-zoned its future
    Wellington’s massively upzoned District Plan adds the opportunity for tens of thousands of new homes not just in the central city (such as these Webb St new builds) but also close to the CBD and public transport links. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāTL;DR: Wellington gave itself the chance of ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    4 days ago
  • Weekly Roundup 15-March-2024
    It’s Friday and we’re halfway through March Madness. Here’s some of the things that caught our attention this week. This Week in Greater Auckland On Monday Matt asked how we can get better event trains and an option for grade separating Morningside Dr. On Tuesday Matt looked into ...
    Greater AucklandBy Greater Auckland
    4 days ago
  • That Word.
    Something you might not know about me is that I’m quite a stubborn person. No, really. I don’t much care for criticism I think’s unfair or that I disagree with. Few of us do I suppose.Back when I was a drinker I’d sometimes respond defensively, even angrily. There are things ...
    Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel
    4 days ago
  • The Hoon around the week to March 15
    Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāTL;DR: The five things that mattered in Aotearoa’s political economy that we wrote and spoke about via The Kākā and elsewhere for paying subscribers in the last week included:PM Christopher Luxon said the reversal of interest deductibility for landlords was done to help renters, who ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    4 days ago
  • Labour’s policy gap
    It was not so much the Labour Party but really the Chris Hipkins party yesterday at Labour’s caucus retreat in Martinborough. The former Prime Minister was more or less consistent on wealth tax, which he was at best equivocal about, and social insurance, which he was not willing to revisit. ...
    PolitikBy Richard Harman
    4 days ago
  • Skeptical Science New Research for Week #11 2024
    Open access notables A Glimpse into the Future: The 2023 Ocean Temperature and Sea Ice Extremes in the Context of Longer-Term Climate Change, Kuhlbrodt et al., Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society: In the year 2023, we have seen extraordinary extrema in high sea surface temperature (SST) in the North Atlantic and in ...
    5 days ago
  • Melissa remains mute on media matters but has something to say (at a sporting event) about economic ...
     Buzz from the Beehive   The text reproduced above appears on a page which records all the media statements and speeches posted on the government’s official website by Melissa Lee as Minister of Media and Communications and/or by Jenny Marcroft, her Parliamentary Under-secretary.  It can be quickly analysed ...
    Point of OrderBy Bob Edlin
    5 days ago
  • The return of Muldoon
    For forty years, Robert Muldoon has been a dirty word in our politics. His style of government was so repulsive and authoritarian that the backlash to it helped set and entrench our constitutional norms. His pig-headedness over forcing through Think Big eventually gave us the RMA, with its participation and ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    5 days ago
  • Will the rental tax cut improve life for renters or landlords?
    Bryce Edwards writes –  Is the new government reducing tax on rental properties to benefit landlords or to cut the cost of rents? That’s the big question this week, after Associate Finance Minister David Seymour announced on Sunday that the Government would be reversing the Labour Government’s removal ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    5 days ago
  • Geoffrey Miller: What Saudi Arabia’s rapid changes mean for New Zealand
    Saudi Arabia is rarely far from the international spotlight. The war in Gaza has brought new scrutiny to Saudi plans to normalise relations with Israel, while the fifth anniversary of the controversial killing of Jamal Khashoggi was marked shortly before the war began on October 7. And as the home ...
    Democracy ProjectBy Geoffrey Miller
    5 days ago
  • Racism’s double standards
    Questions need to be asked on both sides of the world Peter Williams writes –   The NRL Judiciary hands down an eight week suspension to Sydney Roosters forward Spencer Leniu , an Auckland-born Samoan, after he calls Ezra Mam, Sydney-orn but of Aboriginal and Torres Strait ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    5 days ago
  • It’s not a tax break
    Ele Ludemann writes – Contrary to what many headlines and news stories are saying, residential landlords are not getting a tax break. The government is simply restoring to them the tax deductibility of interest they had until the previous government removed it. There is no logical reason ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    5 days ago
  • The Plastic Pig Collective and Chris' Imaginary Friends.
    I can't remember when it was goodMoments of happiness in bloomMaybe I just misunderstoodAll of the love we left behindWatching our flashbacks intertwineMemories I will never findIn spite of whatever you becomeForget that reckless thing turned onI think our lives have just begunI think our lives have just begunDoes anyone ...
    Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel
    5 days ago
  • Who is responsible for young offenders?
    Michael Bassett writes – At first reading, a front-page story in the New Zealand Herald on 13 March was bizarre. A group of severely intellectually limited teenagers, with little understanding of the law, have been pleading to the Justice Select Committee not to pass a bill dealing with ram ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    5 days ago
  • Gordon Campbell on National’s fantasy trip to La La Landlord Land
    How much political capital is Christopher Luxon willing to burn through in order to deliver his $2.9 billion gift to landlords? Evidently, Luxon is: (a) unable to cost the policy accurately. As Anna Burns-Francis pointed out to him on Breakfast TV, the original ”rock solid” $2.1 billion cost he was ...
    5 days ago
  • Bernard's Top 10 @ 10 'pick 'n' mix' for March 14
    TL;DR: My top 10 news and analysis links this morning include:Today’s must-read: Jonathon Porritt calling bullshit in his own blog post on mainstream climate science as ‘The New Denialism’.Local scoop: The Wellington City Council’s list of proposed changes to the IHP recommendations to be debated later today was leaked this ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    5 days ago
  • No, Prime Minister, rents don’t rise or fall with landlords’ costs
    TL;DR: Prime Minister Christopher Luxon said yesterday tenants should be grateful for the reinstatement of interest deductibility because landlords would pass on their lower tax costs in the form of lower rents. That would be true if landlords were regulated monopolies such as Transpower or Auckland Airport1, but they’re not, ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    5 days ago
  • Cartoons: ‘At least I didn’t make things awkward’
    This is a re-post from Yale Climate Connections by Tom Toro Tom Toro is a cartoonist and author. He has published over 200 cartoons in The New Yorker since 2010. His cartoons appear in Playboy, the Paris Review, the New York Times, American Bystander, and elsewhere. Related: What 10 EV lovers ...
    5 days ago
  • Solving traffic congestion with Richard Prebble
    The business section of the NZ Herald is full of opinion. Among the more opinionated of all is the ex-Minister of Transport, ex-Minister of Railways, ex MP for Auckland Central (1975-93, Labour), Wellington Central (1996-99, ACT, then list-2005), ex-leader of the ACT Party, uncle to actor Antonia, the veritable granddaddy ...
    Greater AucklandBy Patrick Reynolds
    5 days ago
  • I Think I'm Done Flying Boeing
    Hi,Just quickly — I’m blown away by the stories you’ve shared with me over the last week since I put out the ‘Gary’ podcast, where I told you about the time my friend’s flatmate killed the neighbour.And you keep telling me stories — in the comments section, and in my ...
    David FarrierBy David Farrier
    5 days ago
  • Invoking Aristotle: Of Rings of Power, Stones, and Ships
    The first season of Rings of Power was not awful. It was thoroughly underwhelming, yes, and left a lingering sense of disappointment, but it was more expensive mediocrity than catastrophe. I wrote at length about the series as it came out (see the Review section of the blog, and go ...
    6 days ago
  • Van Velden brings free-market approach to changing labour laws – but her colleagues stick to distr...
    Buzz from the Beehive Workplace Relations and Safety Minister Brooke van Velden told Auckland Business Chamber members they were the first audience to hear her priorities as a minister in a government committed to cutting red tape and regulations. She brandished her liberalising credentials, saying Flexible labour markets are the ...
    Point of OrderBy Bob Edlin
    6 days ago
  • Why Newshub failed
    Chris Trotter writes – TO UNDERSTAND WHY NEWSHUB FAILED, it is necessary to understand how TVNZ changed. Up until 1989, the state broadcaster had been funded by a broadcasting licence fee, collected from every citizen in possession of a television set, supplemented by a relatively modest (compared ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    6 days ago
  • Māori Party on the warpath against landlords and seabed miners – let’s see if mystical creature...
    Bob Edlin writes  –  The Māori Party has been busy issuing a mix of warnings and threats as its expresses its opposition to interest deductibility for landlords and the plans of seabed miners. It remains to be seen whether they  follow the example of indigenous litigants in Australia, ...
    Point of OrderBy Bob Edlin
    6 days ago
  • There’s a name for this
    Every year, in the Budget, Parliament forks out money to government agencies to do certain things. And every year, as part of the annual review cycle, those agencies are meant to report on whether they have done the things Parliament gave them that money for. Agencies which consistently fail to ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    6 days ago
  • Echoes of 1968 in 2024?  Pocock on the repetitive problems of the New Left
    Mike Grimshaw writes – Recent events in American universities point to an underlying crisis of coherent thinking, an issue that increasingly affects the progressive left across the Western world. This of course is nothing new as anyone who can either remember or has read of the late ...
    Point of OrderBy poonzteam5443
    6 days ago
  • Two bar blues
    The thing about life’s little victories is that they can be followed by a defeat.Reader Darryl told me on Monday night:Test again Dave. My “head cold” last week became COVID within 24 hours, and is still with me. I hear the new variants take a bit longer to show up ...
    More Than A FeildingBy David Slack
    6 days ago
  • Bernard's Top 10 @ 10 'pick 'n' mix' for March 13
    TL;DR: My top 10 news and analysis links this morning include:Today’s must-read: Angus Deaton on rethinking his economics IMFLocal scoop: The people behind Tamarind, the firm that left a $500m cleanup bill for taxpayers at Taranaki’s Tui oil well, are back operating in Taranaki under a different company name. Jonathan ...
    The KakaBy Bernard Hickey
    6 days ago
  • AT Need To Lift Their Game
    Normally when we talk about accessing public transport it’s about improving how easy it is to get to, such as how easy is it to cross roads in a station/stop’s walking catchment, is it possible to cycle to safely, do bus connections work, or even if are there new routes/connections ...
    6 days ago
  • Christopher's Whopper.
    Politicians are not renowned for telling the truth. Some tell us things that are verifiably not true. They offer statements that omit critical pieces of information. Gloss over risks, preferring to offer the best case scenario.Some not truths are quite small, others amusing in their transparency. There are those repeated ...
    Nick’s KōreroBy Nick Rockel
    6 days ago

  • Positive progress for social worker workforce
    New Zealand’s social workers are qualified, experienced, and more representative of the communities they serve, Social Development and Employment Minister Louise Upston says. “I want to acknowledge and applaud New Zealand’s social workers for the hard work they do, providing invaluable support for our most vulnerable. “To coincide with World ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 hours ago
  • Minister confirms reduced RUC rate for PHEVs
    Cabinet has agreed to a reduced road user charge (RUC) rate for plug-in hybrid electric vehicles (PHEVs), Transport Minister Simeon Brown says. Owners of PHEVs will be eligible for a reduced rate of $38 per 1,000km once all light electric vehicles (EVs) move into the RUC system from 1 April.  ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 hours ago
  • Trade access to overseas markets creates jobs
    Minister of Agriculture and Trade, Todd McClay, says that today’s opening of Riverland Foods manufacturing plant in Christchurch is a great example of how trade access to overseas markets creates jobs in New Zealand.  Speaking at the official opening of this state-of-the-art pet food factory the Minister noted that exports ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 hours ago
  • NZ and Chinese Foreign Ministers hold official talks
    Minister of Foreign Affairs Winston Peters met with Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi in Wellington today. “It was a pleasure to host Foreign Minister Wang Yi during his first official visit to New Zealand since 2017. Our discussions were wide-ranging and enabled engagement on many facets of New Zealand’s relationship with China, including trade, ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    20 hours ago
  • Kāinga Ora instructed to end Sustaining Tenancies
    Kāinga Ora – Homes & Communities has been instructed to end the Sustaining Tenancies Framework and take stronger measures against persistent antisocial behaviour by tenants, says Housing Minister Chris Bishop. “Earlier today Finance Minister Nicola Willis and I sent an interim Letter of Expectations to the Board of Kāinga Ora. ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    24 hours ago
  • Speech to Auckland Business Chamber: Growth is the answer
    Tēna koutou katoa. Greetings everyone. Thank you to the Auckland Chamber of Commerce and the Honourable Simon Bridges for hosting this address today. I acknowledge the business leaders in this room, the leaders and governors, the employers, the entrepreneurs, the investors, and the wealth creators. The coalition Government shares your ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Singapore rounds out regional trip
    Minister Winston Peters completed the final leg of his visit to South and South East Asia in Singapore today, where he focused on enhancing one of New Zealand’s indispensable strategic partnerships.      “Singapore is our most important defence partner in South East Asia, our fourth-largest trading partner and a ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Minister van Velden represents New Zealand at International Democracy Summit
    Minister of Internal Affairs and Workplace Relations and Safety, Hon. Brooke van Velden, will travel to the Republic of Korea to represent New Zealand at the Third Summit for Democracy on 18 March. The summit, hosted by the Republic of Korea, was first convened by the United States in 2021, ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Insurance Council of NZ Speech, 7 March 2024, Auckland
    ICNZ Speech 7 March 2024, Auckland  Acknowledgements and opening  Mōrena, ngā mihi nui. Ko Andrew Bayly aho, Nor Whanganui aho.  Good morning, it’s a privilege to be here to open the ICNZ annual conference, thank you to Mark for the Mihi Whakatau  My thanks to Tim Grafton for inviting me ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Five-year anniversary of Christchurch terror attacks
    Prime Minister Christopher Luxon and Lead Coordination Minister Judith Collins have expressed their deepest sympathy on the five-year anniversary of the Christchurch terror attacks. “March 15, 2019, was a day when families, communities and the country came together both in sorrow and solidarity,” Mr Luxon says.  “Today we pay our respects to the 51 shuhada ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Speech for Financial Advice NZ Conference 5 March 2024
    Speech for Financial Advice NZ Conference 5 March 2024  Acknowledgements and opening  Morena, Nga Mihi Nui.  Ko Andrew Bayly aho, Nor Whanganui aho. Thanks Nate for your Mihi Whakatau  Good morning. It’s a pleasure to formally open your conference this morning. What a lovely day in Wellington, What a great ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Early visit to Indonesia strengthens ties
    Foreign Minister Winston Peters held discussions in Jakarta today about the future of relations between New Zealand and South East Asia’s most populous country.   “We are in Jakarta so early in our new government’s term to reflect the huge importance we place on our relationship with Indonesia and South ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • China Foreign Minister to visit
    Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Foreign Affairs Winston Peters has announced that the Foreign Minister of China, Wang Yi, will visit New Zealand next week.  “We look forward to re-engaging with Foreign Minister Wang Yi and discussing the full breadth of the bilateral relationship, which is one of New Zealand’s ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Minister opens new Auckland Rail Operations Centre
    Transport Minister Simeon Brown has today opened the new Auckland Rail Operations Centre, which will bring together KiwiRail, Auckland Transport, and Auckland One Rail to improve service reliability for Aucklanders. “The recent train disruptions in Auckland have highlighted how important it is KiwiRail and Auckland’s rail agencies work together to ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Celebrating 10 years of Crankworx Rotorua
    The Government is proud to support the 10th edition of Crankworx Rotorua as the Crankworx World Tour returns to Rotorua from 16-24 March 2024, says Minister for Economic Development Melissa Lee.  “Over the past 10 years as Crankworx Rotorua has grown, so too have the economic and social benefits that ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Government delivering on tax commitments
    Legislation implementing coalition Government tax commitments and addressing long-standing tax anomalies will be progressed in Parliament next week, Finance Minister Nicola Willis says. The legislation is contained in an Amendment Paper to the Taxation (Annual Rates for 2023–24, Multinational Tax, and Remedial Matters) Bill issued today.  “The Amendment Paper represents ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Significant Natural Areas requirement to be suspended
    Associate Environment Minister Andrew Hoggard has today announced that the Government has agreed to suspend the requirement for councils to comply with the Significant Natural Areas (SNA) provisions of the National Policy Statement for Indigenous Biodiversity for three years, while it replaces the Resource Management Act (RMA).“As it stands, SNAs ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Government classifies drought conditions in Top of the South as medium-scale adverse event
    Agriculture Minister Todd McClay has classified the drought conditions in the Marlborough, Tasman, and Nelson districts as a medium-scale adverse event, acknowledging the challenging conditions facing farmers and growers in the district. “Parts of Marlborough, Tasman, and Nelson districts are in the grip of an intense dry spell. I know ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Government partnership to tackle $332m facial eczema problem
    The Government is helping farmers eradicate the significant impact of facial eczema (FE) in pastoral animals, Agriculture Minister Todd McClay announced.  “A $20 million partnership jointly funded by Beef + Lamb NZ, the Government, and the primary sector will save farmers an estimated NZD$332 million per year, and aims to ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • NZ, India chart path to enhanced relationship
    Foreign Minister Winston Peters has completed a successful visit to India, saying it was an important step in taking the relationship between the two countries to the next level.   “We have laid a strong foundation for the Coalition Government’s priority of enhancing New Zealand-India relations to generate significant future benefit for both countries,” says Mr Peters, ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Ruapehu Alpine Lifts bailout the last, say Ministers
    Cabinet has agreed to provide $7 million to ensure the 2024 ski season can go ahead on the Whakapapa ski field in the central North Island but has told the operator Ruapehu Alpine Lifts it is the last financial support it will receive from taxpayers. Cabinet also agreed to provide ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Govt takes action to drive better cancer services
    Health Minister Dr Shane Reti says the launch of a new mobile breast screening unit in Counties Manukau reinforces the coalition Government’s commitment to drive better cancer services for all New Zealanders. Speaking at the launch of the new mobile clinic, Dr Reti says it’s a great example of taking ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Govt takes action to drive better cancer services
    Health Minister Dr Shane Reti says the launch of a new mobile breast screening unit in Counties Manukau reinforces the coalition Government’s commitment to drive better cancer services for all New Zealanders. Speaking at the launch of the new mobile clinic, Dr Reti says it’s a great example of taking ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Work begins on SH29 upgrades near Tauriko
    Unlocking economic growth and land for housing are critical elements of the Government’s plan for our transport network, and planned upgrades to State Highway 29 (SH29) near Tauriko will deliver strongly on those priorities, Transport Minister Simeon Brown says. “The SH29 upgrades near Tauriko will improve safety at the intersections ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Work begins on SH29 upgrades near Tauriko
    Unlocking economic growth and land for housing are critical elements of the Government’s plan for our transport network, and planned upgrades to State Highway 29 (SH29) near Tauriko will deliver strongly on those priorities, Transport Minister Simeon Brown says. “The SH29 upgrades near Tauriko will improve safety at the intersections ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Fresh produce price drop welcome
    Lower fruit and vegetable prices are welcome news for New Zealanders who have been doing it tough at the supermarket, Finance Minister Nicola Willis says. Stats NZ reported today the price of fruit and vegetables has dropped 9.3 percent in the 12 months to February 2024.  “Lower fruit and vege ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Statement to the 68th United Nations Commission on the Status of Women
    Tēnā koutou katoa and greetings to you all.  Chair, I am honoured to address the sixty-eighth session of the Commission on the Status of Women. I acknowledge the many crises impacting the rights of women and girls. Heightened global tensions, war, climate related and humanitarian disasters, and price inflation all ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Speech to the 68th United Nations Commission on the Status of Women (CSW68)
    Tēnā koutou katoa and greetings to you all.  Chair, I am honoured to address the 68th session of the Commission on the Status of Women. I acknowledge the many crises impacting the rights of women and girls. Heightened global tensions, war, climate related and humanitarian disasters, and price inflation all ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Government backs rural led catchment projects
    The coalition Government is supporting farmers to enhance land management practices by investing $3.3 million in locally led catchment groups, Agriculture Minister Todd McClay announced. “Farmers and growers deliver significant prosperity for New Zealand and it’s vital their ongoing efforts to improve land management practices and water quality are supported,” ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Speech to Auckland Business Chamber
    Good evening everyone and thank you for that lovely introduction.   Thank you also to the Honourable Simon Bridges for the invitation to address your members. Since being sworn in, this coalition Government has hit the ground running with our 100-day plan, delivering the changes that New Zealanders expect of us. ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • Commission’s advice on ETS settings tabled
    Recommendations from the Climate Change Commission for New Zealand on the Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS) auction and unit limit settings for the next five years have been tabled in Parliament, Climate Change Minister Simon Watts says. “The Commission provides advice on the ETS annually. This is the third time the ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Government lowering building costs
    The coalition Government is beginning its fight to lower building costs and reduce red tape by exempting minor building work from paying the building levy, says Building and Construction Minister Chris Penk. “Currently, any building project worth $20,444 including GST or more is subject to the building levy which is ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Trustee tax change welcomed
    Proposed changes to tax legislation to prevent the over-taxation of low-earning trusts are welcome, Finance Minister Nicola Willis says. The changes have been recommended by Parliament’s Finance and Expenditure Committee following consideration of submissions on the Taxation (Annual Rates for 2023–24, Multinational Tax, and Remedial Matters) Bill. “One of the ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Minister’s Ramadan message
    Assalaamu alaikum. السَّلَام عليكم In light of the holy month of Ramadan, I want to extend my warmest wishes to our Muslim community in New Zealand. Ramadan is a time for spiritual reflection, renewed devotion, perseverance, generosity, and forgiveness.  It’s a time to strengthen our bonds and appreciate the diversity ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Minister appoints new NZTA Chair
    Former Transport Minister and CEO of the Auckland Business Chamber Hon Simon Bridges has been appointed as the new Board Chair of the New Zealand Transport Agency (NZTA) for a three-year term, Transport Minister Simeon Brown announced today. “Simon brings extensive experience and knowledge in transport policy and governance to the role. He will ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Speech to Life Sciences Summit
    Good morning all, it is a pleasure to be here as Minister of Science, Innovation and Technology.  It is fantastic to see how connected and collaborative the life science and biotechnology industry is here in New Zealand. I would like to thank BioTechNZ and NZTech for the invitation to address ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Progress continues apace on water storage
    Regional Development Minister Shane Jones says he is looking forward to the day when three key water projects in Northland are up and running, unlocking the full potential of land in the region. Mr Jones attended a community event at the site of the Otawere reservoir near Kerikeri on Friday. ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Government agrees to restore interest deductions
    Associate Finance Minister David Seymour has today announced that the Government has agreed to restore deductibility for mortgage interest on residential investment properties. “Help is on the way for landlords and renters alike. The Government’s restoration of interest deductibility will ease pressure on rents and simplify the tax code,” says ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Minister to attend World Anti-Doping Agency Symposium
    Sport and Recreation Minister Chris Bishop will travel to Switzerland today to attend an Executive Committee meeting and Symposium of the World Anti-Doping Agency (WADA). Mr Bishop will then travel on to London where he will attend a series of meetings in his capacity as Infrastructure Minister. “New Zealanders believe ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Pacific Language Weeks celebrate regional unity
    This year’s Pacific Language Weeks celebrate regional unity and the contribution of Pacific communities to New Zealand culture, says Minister for Pacific Peoples Dr Shane Reti.  Dr Reti announced dates for the 2024 Pacific Language Weeks during a visit to the Pasifika festival in Auckland today and says there’s so ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago

Page generated in The Standard by Wordpress at 2024-03-19T02:49:35+00:00