Tory welfare bashing

Written By: - Date published: 7:30 am, August 10th, 2010 - 98 comments
Categories: benefits, class war, welfare - Tags:

If the political world can be split into Left and Right, is there any issue which is better at dividing us than welfare?

Here’s a triplet of facts. 1) Every “developed” country needs a welfare system to take care of those who are, for whatever reason unable to support themselves. 2) The majority of welfare recipients are exactly the cases of genuine need that welfare systems are designed for. 3) A minority of welfare recipients are lazy bludgers who game the system to try and extract benefits when they could support themselves.

I don’t think anyone seriously questions point 1 anymore. The Left won that argument. What still separates us clearly into Left and Right today, it seems to me, is how we respond to 2 and 3. A Lefty will generously support a comprehensive welfare system to provide a decent quality of life for those in need (they accept the minority of bludgers as a cost of doing business). But nothing shrivels a Tory heart like the idea of sharing their wealth. While unable to deny the need, they become so obsessed with the small minority of bludgers that they can’t help but attack the system, and in doing so they attack the support for the overwhelming majority of perfectly genuine welfare recipients.

And so it begins (again) in New Zealand. I was going to write on the Rebstock report, but others have already done it far better than I could. Gordon Campbell:

The government’s welfare working group has dutifully delivered the findings the government wants to hear. To Paula Rebstock and her colleagues, being on welfare is primarily a failure of attitude by beneficiaries and has little or nothing to do with failures by government or business to create jobs, or with cutbacks to Social Welfare staff, or with any other structural factor beyond the education system which gets a few lumps for not providing business with the kind of drones it needs to fit into the job slots available, assuming such slots existed, which they currently don’t.

There is a peculiarly airless quality to the working paper, driven as it is by ideology and not by any discernible engagement with New Zealand, 2010. Because the panel pays so little attention to events in the real world newsflash : the job market has not yet recovered from the worst economic recession since WW11, and that global recession seems about to recur it could have been written at any time over the last four decades.

The scare scenario that it offers to justify change in welfare policy is bogus: if nothing is done, the working paper says, the welfare system that currently costs $6.5 billion could end up costing $50 billion which would be unsustainable. Duh. But that would only happen, it also concedes, if everyone currently on a benefit stayed on it for life. Yet that doesn’t happen. The vast majority of those on the DPB use it entirely as intended as a temporary shelter until they find work. The $50 billion scare number is a dishonest attempt to get headlines by libeling people on the DPB, and on other benefits.

The reality is far less dramatic. Elsewhere within the working paper, the level of those reliant on welfare is predicted to rise from 13% now to 16% in 2050. That’s only a three per cent rise spread over 40 years, in the context of an ageing population that will inevitably generate more people on sickness and invalids benefits. So, where’s the crisis? In that sense, there isn’t one. ‘Crisis’ is a word that I would reserve for the health system, under Tony Ryall. A ruckus over welfare is merely a political diversion from the debacle unfolding in health.

The driver here is ideology, not reality. The Key government seems to believe that being on welfare is caused by a failing in the person concerned, and by their enablers in the medical and education system. This is a ideologically blinkered approach that sees society as essentially individualistic one looks in vain in the working paper for any recognition that getting people back into work involves a triangular partnership between the individual, government and the private sector. … this working group is not engaged in a genuine consultation. It is on a journey towards pre-determined solutions.

And at No Right Turn:

If public service cuts, mass-unemployment, and health cuts weren’t enough to convince you National was taking us back to the 90’s, they’ve moved on to the next component in their recipe: beneficiary-bashing. Their right-wing “Welfare Working Group” has dutifully reported back that the welfare system is “unsustainable”, complete with a scare figure of $50 billion to manufacture a sense of crisis to drive “reform”. But delving into their extremely shallow working papers, their big findings seem to be:

  • the welfare system has become more generous since the 1960’s, when we dumped sick people on their relatives and left solo parents destitute;
  • people are likely to stay on the unemployment benefit for longer at the moment due to the lack of jobs;
  • people with longer-term problems (such as solo parents, those with long-term illnesses, and those with permanent disabilities) tend to stay on benefits for longer;
  • people who are unable to work don’t get pushed into it by WINZ;
  • people who spend long periods of time on benefits are poorer (but because benefit adequacy was excluded from their terms of reference, they can’t talk about why that might be).

For most of us, these “discoveries” are so obvious and banal as to cause us to question how much these “experts” were paid (or indeed, why they were paid at all). For the Welfare Working Group, however, it is apparently a reason to dismantle the entire welfare system and replace it with an insurance-based model which will deliver less, and leave more people in poverty.

I guess the government got what it paid for then. But the rest of us should demand a better justification for such radical changes affecting so many people than the usual right-wing kneejerk of “benefit bad! Poor lazy!”

Meanwhile, if the government is serious about reducing the welfare bill, here’s a few suggestions:

  • If the government is concerned about too many people on the unemployment benefit, it could do something to create jobs, rather than simply expecting them to magically appear if it makes people desperate enough;
  • If the government is concerned about too many people on the sickness benefit, it could ensure they get treated for their conditions, rather than left to rot. Sickness benefit numbers represent a failure of our public health system, not of the sick;
  • If the government is concerned specifically about the number of people receiving the sickness benefit due to mental health or addiction issues, it could reduce inequality. These problems are strongly correlated with inequality (and for good reason), and more equal societies have less of them.
  • If the government is concerned about solo parents not working, it could provide better access to childcare and further education, rather than cutting both.

But somehow, I suspect the government will do none of these things. They would rather demonise the poor and grind their faces further into the mud than actually do anything to help. …

These are the real issues that distinguish governments of the Left and Right. As times continue hard, and could well get harder yet, the country may just wake up and remember these facts by the time 2011 rolls around.

98 comments on “Tory welfare bashing”

  1. Bored 1

    How utterly predictable, I was lucky the TV got muted during the News last night as the deplorable Rebstock and the poisonous Key warbled on about “welfare”. Their earnest expressions spoke for them, their faces screamed “poor little us, we wealthy really think you could be like us too if you would only create your own welfare consultancy, or start a steel mill…and we wont have to part with our ill gotten gains to prop you bennies up”.

    Make no bones about this, National are the party of class warfare, Labour need to harden up and start serving it back in a meaningful way.

  2. RedLogix 2


    Brilliant post. I’m both impressed and slightly envious. One of the best points is surely the dog begging question of who the hell paid these so called experts to waste taxpayer money delivering up this bleedingly obvious dreck? That strikes me as a at least one worthwhile line of attack.

    • Bored 2.1

      Good point. An obvious question, which is why I said Labour need to harden up and demand answers to this, and in reality score some points by anticipating the answer. Who went public and stated that this was going to be the end result of such a sham BEFORE it came out? If somebody did I did not hear it.

      • Tigger 2.1.1

        Of course we all know they need this ‘dreck’ as legitimacy for making radical change. National are proposing or discussing these ‘expert’ think tanks in several areas that they want kick right on.

        Labour can harden up all they like, but if the media will insist on swallowing the Nat spin it will prove a difficult task turning this Titanic around.

        And we are on the Titanic now. Icebergs ahead but no one seems to care – the rich get the lifeboats, the rest of us get the icy water.

        • Carol

          And not just happening here – similar attacks on the welfare state in the UK and all sorts of public provisions in the US:

          The rich across the developing world seem to be acting in concert, with Key & co. being right in there with them.

          • prism

            The English disease Carol? “The rich across the developing world” – it is mainly the English speaking one that NZ turns to for guidance, does it trickle out from the anti-‘commonwealth’ of USA to Britain and then on to Canada, Australia, NZ or does it ricochet between the USA and Britain? If we could learn other languages what would be better – French or Scandinavian or Dutch…? Where could we look for more sensible economics with a human face.

          • Draco T Bastard

            The rich have always acted in concert against everyone else.

    • r0b 2.2

      Cheers RL. I’m always impressed with the thinking in others’ posts and comments (frequently yours) much more than my own. But that’s why we all get together to share our ideas here I guess!

    • Cnr Joe (withasparemoment) 2.3

      You what? They were paid for this?Are they not beneficiaries (as they merrily benefit from the public purse) ?.
      Then this is a money go-round in a sideshow of shadowy puppets and vicious clowns.

      Trickle-down has turned to Swirl-around.

  3. RedLogix 3

    And of course there is no serious analysis of WHY sickness benefit numbers have trended upwards;

    1. The closing down state mental health and disability sheltering institutions diectly transfered these people onto benefits.

    2. The raising of the retirement age to 65 has created a gap for many older workers, too old to sustain the physical or mental demands of their line of work, and too young to qualify for superannuation.

    3. Increasing incidence of crippling depression and anxiety illnesses … again the result of an unequal, stressful society.

    This report is really an appallingly narrow and vile bit of victim bashing and needs putting down. That we have a Prime Minister willing to endorse and defend it is even more chilling.

    • regstalin 3.1

      There is no serious analysis in the tediously predictable WWG report. MSD’s “Growth in numbers of Sickness and Invalids Benefit recipients19932002” does however offer some insight into this; In respect of the IB “The independent effects of the four factors explain 88% of the actual change in inflows, with the net effect of interactions between them explaining the remaining 12%. Between 1993 and 2002: population growth accounted for an estimated 11% of the growth in inflows, population ageing accounted for 6% of the growth, increased rates of entry among those aged 6064, largely attributable to the rise in the NZS age of entitlement, accounted for 20% of the growth and increased rates of entry among those aged 1559 accounted for 52% of the growth. (pg 20)
      – i.e. 37% of the growth appears fairly inevitable given the demographic and policy changes that occurred.
      Of the growth in inflow rates among those aged 1559, 60% is explained by the increase in direct transfers from other benefits (pg 24) – I take this to be in part the logical progression of some from SB to IB and in part the kind of administrative sorting that dumps anyone that can be dumped off UB rolls onto SB and IB (even if they want to be classed as unemployed)

      • ZB 3.1.1

        A bit of history, under Labour unemployment fell, Labour put money into the hands of employers to take on those with ‘problems’. Now the economy has turned those workers often were the last in, and are flowing back onto the dole.
        And now for some economic geography, Australia pays better, so those who can move, are likely to get work do so, leaving behind the less capable and less employable (who self-eliminate themselves).
        Third ‘insight’, mental illness – from my own experience and those of family, is typically (as a pure amateur) a identity crisis. Basically a person will build themselves a identity, but the world changes and shows the individuals identity to be false, this causes a ‘identity crisis’ leading into depression and mental instability. Some key factors, are loss of job, loss of home, loss of status as breadwinner, politicians tell you you’re scum by being on the dole and you believing it because the whole time you were in work you looked down on the scum.

        Key is evil. Key would rather not target unemployment and despite the obvious changes in the economy, in the debt and oil economies, continue the same tired old slogans that may have had merit 5 years ago when jobs were available and economies were working. I think Key has broken a fundamental taboo in a Democracy, he is living in a fantasy world where anything in his way is wrong and should be cut. And anything he wants to cut he can.

        We have a dictator ruling us people. No linkage to reality. The great recession hasn’t come to them yet.

      • Draco T Bastard 3.1.2

        Yes, the 4th National government caused a huge amount of social stress as can be seen by “Growth in numbers of Sickness and Invalids Benefit recipients19932002″ – the years most directly affected by their ideological mismanagement of the economy.

    • RobertM 3.2

      Red Logix your stupidity and predjudice is blinding. The institutions were largely closed down 20 years ago and had been reducing since the l960s. It is no explanation for the increase in invalids and sickness beneficiaries over the last 20 years. These days people in their brief spell in the bins stay on the benefit it is simply reduced for the few who stay longer than 6 weeks.
      There are 4 problems with the lefts arguements re welfare.
      (1) In most advanced western democracies women are expected to return to work after one year off for a child not five like here
      (2) In Australia and the UK physical disability tests for benefits are far more stringent than here.
      (3) The modern psychiatric drugs introduced since about l995 should have allowed most sufferers to return to employment or full time study if the health dept, psychiatrists and health teams used intelligently. In New Zealand there was a complete refusal to accept the new drugs were entirely different and changed everything. They have been applied in too high doses for sedation and control like the old drugs frequently requiring old dangerous and disabling drugs like Lithium to be used for balance. The main cause of welfare dependency in New Zealand is the militant recalcitarance of psychatrists who refuse to admit they are largely wrong. The psychatrists pine for the return of large hospitals and refuse to accept or hear andy evidence to the contrary. Now they are determined to break away from American psychiatry which sees mental illness as a continum of degrees of fragility and resilience a continum which we all are on and would widely describe psychiatric drugs to the general community to boost confidence and sex lives. Our psychatrist favour the British eEuropean model which is hopelessly out of date and reactionary which regards people as either one thing or the other mental or sane and favours large hospitals.
      The attitude of psychiatrist mean a significant people with degrees, intelligent and beautiful are denied the chance to work and thrive. Psychaitry is one of the main causes of the welfare problem because it refuses to accept people can be cured or capable of work. To work or not work should be everyones right.
      The welfare, social work industry is largely an employment creating racket for a certain type of people who would be better employed as beauticians, sex workers, factory workers and in retail. To the community and public the purpose of social and mental health work is revenge and control. Similar comments could be made about much of the health workforce which could better be replaced as in America with the abolition of pharmac and more emphasis on spending on modern drugs rather than hospitals and a low grade health and social workforce .
      I have spent time on most benefits, been a university student for many years, worked full and part time and are now have a modest private means to live for pleasure becasue my family were reasonably well off, Oxford university educated and lower upper middle class.

      • NickS 3.2.1

        The modern psychiatric drugs introduced since about l995 should have allowed most sufferers to return to employment or full time study if the health dept, psychiatrists and health teams used intelligently.



        At present the mechanisms of how antidepressants work in the brain more conjecture that theory, we know they work, and some of the biochemical and gene regulation changes, but at present there are no indicators that are easily usable to figure out whether or not a particular antidepressant will work for a person without them trying it out first. And the testing period for a drug is usually about a month, then there’s mucking around with dosage measure , meaning that finding a antidepressant that works can take up to a year, or otherwise finding out they don’t work at all.

        And even then, it takes time to overcome depression symptoms even with help, case in point while my concentration (and grumpiness) has dramatically improved since starting on citalopram, motivation however is pretty dead for long term stuff such as assignments. Despite the annoying fact I can now think and weave evidence and arguments much more smoothly since last year, and can get high marks when the motivation is there. And it took till the end of last semester to notice this, leading to a late course withdrawl and a drop down to one course for this semester. All of which, seems to me from my doctors and counsellor’s responses to be a rather normal occurrence. Fun fun.

        Which leads me to believe that your knowledge of antidepressants is based not off any mucking about in the literature, let alone science blogs or articles in reputable science mags, but rather pop media. So please, shut the fuck up and go at least read wikipedia you ignorant fuck.

        Secondly, psychiatric drugs for conditions other than depression aren’t a panacea either, and dependant on other factors can have anything making a condition next to unnoticeable, to only barely managing it. And then there’s all the lovely side effects. Meaning that for some, they need considerable support to get into work, ontop of understanding employers and co-workers, otherwise they’ll be in and out of work constantly. Not to mention, a disabled person generally comes off second best when applying for jobs, unless the employers not a dickwad.

        Is the metal health system working properly? Probably not, but besides that, it’s so abundantly clear that drugs, counselling and behavioural therapy take time not just to do, but figure out which ones will work. Even if it was working properly. So again, the claims you make ascertaining to other mental illnesses appears to be a giant load of shit. To put it bluntly.

      • Puddleglum 3.2.2

        RobertM, there’s something quite appalling about your position on psychiatric drugs and your argument about welfare dependency. Let me try to explain what I mean.

        First, the literature on the efficacy of psychiatric drugs is very uncertain and has recently been rocked by studies that have revealed the widespread suppression of publication of the results of many pharmaceutical company sponsored trials that show no effect or negative effects of many standard issue drugs – and this is true of the incidence of reports of these studies in the most reputable medical journals. Hence, any ‘meta-analyses’ based on peer-reviewed studies have themselves been skewed towards signs of effectiveness.

        Second, recent advances in our understanding of neurodevelopment and general psychological development (including the ‘Dunedin Study’) are making it increasingly clear that what exposes people to psychological ‘risk’ is the dance between the conditions within which development occurs and DNA activity (regulated by itself and by input from external processes).

        Think of the process of becoming ‘mentally ill’ like this: people are on different rungs of a ladder (by analogy, a rung represents some genotype developmentally expressed via the environment as some phenotype). Then, a tsunami is created by external factors. Those lower on the rungs get swamped and drown.

        The much-used phrase ‘predisposition’ for X or Y mental illness is basically a ranking of where you are standing on the ladder. Hence, those lower on the ladder have a ‘predisposition’ for mental illness X which, in this scenario, is a predisposition for drowning (i.e., predisposition is tautologically defined in relation to the condition of interest).

        Fortunately, some researchers are beginning to realise that actually that’s an odd way of putting it. The alternative is to realise that the tsunami is the primary cause of drowning, not where you stand on the rungs. Why? Well, imagine if, instead of a tsunami, a hurricane came along. Then, all of a sudden, it would be those on the higher rungs who would be most vulnerable and who would cop the most damage. They would have a predisposition for being blown away. Those on the bottom rungs would cope relaatively well, thank you.

        Third, it’s now well-established that rates of depression, anxiety, substance abuse, etc., etc. have been increasing in developed societies over recent decades – especially, but by no means solely, with youth. That is, oddly, more and more people are now predisposed to these so-called illnesses. A tsunami has come – lots more people are drowning.

        RobertM, our society is the tsunami so, frankly, it’s a bit sick to then suggest that drugs are the answer to get people back into a life that has caused them so much pain. The alternative, of course, is to change how we all live and organise ourselves. But who is going to accept that or even believe it is possible?

        The practice of prescribing psychiatric drugs for those with no problems but who want to ‘improve’ their psychology is a brilliant example of how markets must always expand and commodify more and more rarefied phenomena. Previously, making money out of people’s concerns about their psychological state was the province of psychiatrists, psychologists and counsellors and, for the ‘sub-clinical’, the plethora of ‘self help’ books. Now, it seems, commodification of the mind has gone hi-tech – it’s all in the pill, you know.

        Fortunately, the hype over this kind of cosmetic psychopharmacology is principally bluster – but it clearly shows the agenda. The late consumer capitalist ‘ideal’ is a world where we won’t even think a thought, remember a memory or feel a feeling without someone ringing the till.

        Paradise! Soma for every possible psychological want or desire. Who needs a society?

        • just saying

          Superbly well said Puddleglum!

        • loota

          Frak you’re clever. Suppression of evidence is only part of the story, don’t forget about the child psychiatrists in the US who were found to have pushed the use of ADHD drugs for children throughout the US health system in the 1990’s – never once revealing they were providing highly paid services to the big pharma companies at the same time.

        • Pascal's bookie

          Nice one Puddlegum, thanks.

        • Bill

          Wonderfully clear and precise comment.

          Nothing to add except a response to the following sentences :- “The alternative, of course, is to change how we all live and organise ourselves. But who is going to accept that or even believe it is possible?”

          Me, for one.

        • RobertM

          Puddlegum I’ve read the literature you refer to, with social scientists and dissident psychiatrists claiming the modern serotonin based SSRIs and the similar serotonin based anti psychotics, do not induce a real improvement and are really no better than the old drugs.
          I don’t agree from my own experience and from the life experiences of many put on these drugs whose life experience were revolutionised by the new drugs. People feel a glow of confidence and can often move house, move to a new city, go back to varisity or even get a job. Scientific proof is rare in psychiatry. In a hospital setting and remembering many patients in the UK and Europe will still be long term hospitalised the new drugs might well be only marginally better, but out in the real world I believe they result in a hugely better life particularly if the patient has control of their own medication.
          With many diagnoses the attitute of the specialists, GPs and social teams usually remains so negative and the expectations so low, that few probably have the opportunity to attempt to go back to work- but in many cases it is an option that should be given. And I’m not talking about basket weaving or makework. I believe there are those who are schizo effective, asbergers or autistic who could succed in any walk of life if given the chance/ In most cases I’m not arguing people should be forced to work or even that it will necessarily be good for them, I’m saying people should have the chance.
          Generally a significant number of people out of the workforce could be efficient in paid work and many in work not efficient. So we need a GMI and a somewhat different system and option for all people.
          In terms of why there are more mental illness diagnoses and beneficiaries, one reason may be we have more psychologists and therefore more diagnoses. Possibly more people are interested in being treated with more attractive drugs.
          For good mental health people have to be happy and often they need good sex and the opportuntiy to socialise which in NZ means the option of drinking should not be precluded. In my view relatively low doses are highly desirable because they reduce weight gain and diminished sexual performance and sperm count. What the dissident psychiatrist David Healy says that the modern serotonin drugs give the patient the ability to tune there sex drive and performance up and down is true. Even drugs like Risperidine are used recrationally in the US as kickers, smoother, relaxers and sexual extenders to increase sexual endurance without ejeculating.

    • Deborah Kean 3.3

      “2. The raising of the retirement age to 65 has created a gap for many older workers, too old to sustain the physical or mental demands of their line of work, and too young to qualify for superannuation.”

      That’s sort-of where I find myself RedLogix, not because I can’t sustain the demands of my job, but because I had the bad luck to work for a crazy unethical bitch who drove her comany into bankruptcy and me on the dole. Then – guess what? It appears that the “tits and teeth” Janet Wilson talked about are actually requirements for office work! I can do the job, but I am an “older worker” and men my own age would rather look at someone sexy when they see the view from their corner offices. (And yes at least one guy who interviewed me actually said so!)

  4. roger nome 4

    aww – i could have cooked up a more in-depth and insightful report commissioning the work out to the street kids that hang out down the way from my business. Would have given them something to do aside from skating and handing out those little bundles of tin-foil too.

  5. wyndham 5

    The exaggerations used by the review panel ( “unsustainable”, “50 billion” etc. ) are exactly the same tactics used by Nick Smith in his attacks on ACC.

  6. roger nome 6

    lol – the report reades like an ACT Party porn script –

    Featuring “Rod Hide” and “Panty Wong” in:

    New Zealand gets it hard in the under-class, part two.

  7. Olwyn 7

    If you look at the poll on stuff you will see that about 65% of respondents think that either the welfare state should go or else be radically reformed. What the hell do these people think they might replace it with? Return to a policy of full employment? Certainly no promises there. The workhouse? Marauding hordes? That they all just disappear somewhere but everything else remain as it is? It is not just the lack of compassion that is silly, or the cowardice of lashing out at people who are not in the position to punish you, but the assumption these 65% must have that they themselves are invulnerable to the vicissitudes of fortune.

    • roger nome 7.1

      Yeah Olwyn – ‘cos we all know that on-line polls are a fair representation of NZ’s class strata. What with all those shift workers reading the internet news on thier lap-top with a cappacino before heading infor the daily grind…

  8. vto 8

    Agreed that this report is simply a shallow piece of politically driven drivel. To be honest I dont think anyone other than pollie-hounds will take the slightest bit of notice of it. It all just sounds so similar to so many other of these things which crop up from time to time. blah blah blah, yadda yadda yadda. It is all rather boring while we masses attend to the more exciting and pressing requirements of life.

    But one point of yours must be taken up r0b ” But nothing shrivels a Tory heart like the idea of sharing their wealth.”. In my experience that statement belongs most definitely with the left-voting middle (and upper if we have one) class liberal. Not with the classic tory-voting conservative. This is my experience in too many years on the planet.

    And I see that experience is supported by a recent survey showing that the most philanthropic were the poorest, followed by the right end of the spectrum. The left end of the spectrum trundled along at the end as the “least keen to share their wealth”.

    Ideology spectacles ay. Not always useful.

    • roger nome 8.1

      VTO – could that be because left-leaning people believe in a systemic solution to social problems rather than the right’s case-by-case “deserving poor” ego-boosting patronage approach?

    • r0b 8.2

      Be good if you could find and link to your source vto. It’s true that I was being deliberately contentious with that comment, but there is much truth in it. And I agree with roger nome – there is a style of Tory giving that likes to “pick winners” and judge the undeserving, likes to be ostentatiously seen to be doing (occasional) “good works”, makes it too much about it’s own ego and not enough about systemic need. Tory Charity. I have very mixed feelings about it.

      Alas, I can’t hang about and chat in this thread until later this arvo.

      • vto 8.2.1

        Well Mr Nome that could be a factor but I suspect it would be minor. “Systemic solution” is one way of describing it, but the left’s addiction to a gummint solution for all of society’s ills is not healthy in the bigger picture imo.

        And being “philanthropic for ego reasons” is still way off the mark. Most tories go to great lengths to hide their philanthropy. The fact you think the opposite indicates a significant misunderstanding of tories. And that cannot help when you fullas go into battle with them.

        Tried to find link but couldnt r0b

        • felix

          Appreciated v, but the old fashioned tories you describe are fairly thin on the ground these days.

          Most of the battle is with the post-baby boom generations of selfish ego-dwelling “me first and fuck anyone else” mentality cretins.

          • Rex Widerstrom

            I agree. But vto is right, that mentality increasingly crosses (major) party lines. It’s blindingly evident in Australia, less so at this stage in NZ but I suspect it will become more evident.

            You’re also right, felix, about the dearth of old-fashioned, philanthropic, traditional tories. But it is they (and the really poor, as BLiP cites below) who prop up the voluntary sector, not the middle classes who’d rather add to their haul of big screen TVs and jetskis. And large numbers of them vote Labo(u)r.

            Such people claim to be egalitarian and are happy to see government money spent on the less fortunate, as long as it doesn’t in any way affect their spending power. When Labor announced the “mining tax” there was some initial support from these people till the mining companies ran a TV campaign appealing to self interest by claiming that they would get “whacked by the tax. Sentiment changed overnight and Labor has been back-peddaling since.

            Self-interest is the primary driver for these people, and vto is right that r0b’s characterisation of them as “tories” falls well short of reality. With no principles other than personal benefit, they’ll vote for whoever offers them the most. And their numbers are growing.

            • Gosman

              As you state Rex, acting in ones self-interest is not ‘class’ dependent.

              The whole idea behind the Roman concept of ‘Bread and Circuses’ is evidence of how it manifests amongst a broad cross section of society not just the middle and upper classes.

      • BLiP 8.2.2

        The poor are the most generous.

        The lowest-income fifth (of the population) always give at more than their capacity,” said Virginia Hodgkinson, former vice president for research at Independent Sector, a Washington-based association of major nonprofit agencies. “The next two-fifths give at capacity, and those above that are capable of giving two or three times more than they give.

        • Rex Widerstrom

          Nice link, BLiP. And since I stole it to advance the debate on Kiwiblog, I’d better restore my karma by offering up another one (pdf file):

          The personal wealth of Australia’s richest people has grown at a much faster rate than their charitable giving, according to a QUT study. Charitable contributions by the rich rose to just under a half per cent from 0.36 per cent in the last decade despite their average household income rising by 36 percent, research by The Australian Centre for Philanthropy and Nonprofit Studies shows.

          Researcher Dr Kym Madden said while many of the wealthy were very generous, a lot of others gave little if anything to charitable causes and some who did give did so at a lower level than the rest of the

          “Australia’s affluent continue to give at a lower level on average than their counterparts in the UK, USA and Canada despite comparable wealth levels,’ Dr Madden said.

          The World Wealth Report of 2007 estimates that the top 17 per cent of ultra rich donors globally give away about 10 percent of their assets annually. Dr Madden said only about six in 10 of the wealthiest Australians claimed deductions for their charitable giving.

          “This indicates 40 per cent of the wealthy appear to be engaged in minimal if any giving,’ she said.

          • prism

            Surprising RW that there has been so little rise in charitable giving. A point to remember is that ‘charity’ may mean funding art or sports or the needy in another country whose privations and difficulties seem more deserving than those of the strugglers close at hand. In short there deesn’t seem much trickle down between the class levels.

  9. “Here’s a triplet of facts. 1) Every “developed’ country needs a welfare system to take care of those who are, for whatever reason unable to support themselves. 2) The majority of welfare recipients are exactly the cases of genuine need that welfare systems are designed for. 3) A minority of welfare recipients are lazy bludgers who game the system to try and extract benefits when they could support themselves.”

    1/ Yes, but NZ is unusual in how it funds its system and the report explores this
    2/ Other welfare systems have different rules eg they work-test single mothers when their children are very young, particularly Nordic countries. So the definition of “genuine need” varies across jurisdictions.
    3/ The number of people who “could support themselves” but receive welfare has grown disproportionate to the population. You characterise them as “lazy bludgers”. I don’t. They are merely people who the current system allows to stay on welfare long-term.

    “A Lefty will generously support a comprehensive welfare system to provide a decent quality of life for those in need (they accept the minority of bludgers as a cost of doing business). But nothing shrivels a Tory heart like the idea of sharing their wealth. While unable to deny the need, they become so obsessed with the small minority of bludgers that they can’t help but attack the system, and in doing so they attack the support for the overwhelming majority of perfectly genuine welfare recipients.”

    For a great many people wanting reform isn’t about meanness. It’s about wanting a welfare system that doesn’t drag more children into poverty; that doesn’t damage the constructive inter-dependence between individuals;that doesn’t teach learned helplessness. The report is about long-term welfare dependence, what drives it (unemployment is only one factor and not the most important) and what effect it has on the beneficiary and their children.

    One of the most important factors identified is that teenagers (16,17,18) entering the benefit system have the greatest risk of staying there long-term and they swell the numbers at any point in time. I would argue that an expectation of eligibility for a benefit leads to educational under-effort and the failure to acquire skills or qualifications. Just going into denial about what the report uncovers isn’t going to improve the circumstances of young New Zealanders or increase their potential to lead more fulfilling lives.

    • millsy 9.1


      If you want the poor and single mother to live on the streets, then I suggest you and your ACT mates fuck off to somewhere like the UK, the USA, China, or India. You know, where single mothers, the sick, the lame and the old have to go and live on the streets, in alleys, under bridges, and in their cars.

      Like that place you go on about, Wisconsin. Heaps of single mothers living in their cars there, but of course, your solution is to take their babies of them and still leave them in the streets.

      You want to smash the welfare state, then be prepared for homelessness on a grand scale.

      The Welfare state may not be perfect, but it give people a roof over their head and a decent standard of living,, something that I have no idea why you begrudge single mothers.

    • Ag 9.2

      The very fact that you wring your hands about the welfare system “dragging children into poverty” demonstrates that you have no understanding of why we have a welfare system. The market system we have now, which we have adopted for good reasons, does not guarantee full employment and does not guarantee that incomes will be distributed in a way that avoids creating obvious public bads.

      Just go away and get yourself an education. Your post is embarrassing.

      • prism 9.2.1

        Our economic system guarantees we will always be confused about employment levels. Because it states that full employment is reached when the economists say it is, ie under an actual and considerable percentage of registered unemployed which is some figure that does not have wage inflation consequences.

    • bbfloyd 9.3

      lyndsay.. as usual, an apologist has managed to couch their ignorance of economic realities as they apply to humans in excessive verbiage. just once, i would like to see conservative commentators showing, or at least making an attempt to show an understanding of the REAL reasons that young people end up on welfare. if it is acceptable to point to the end result, then maybe we should try to stop playing silly partisan word games, and take a mature view of what creates the need for welfare in the first place.
      simply pointing at the recipients of said welfare and criticizing their motivations, or assuming greed, laziness etc do no more than move the debate further from where it needs to go.

    • NickS 9.4

      For a great many people wanting reform isn’t about meanness. It’s about wanting a welfare system that doesn’t drag more children into poverty;

      Easy, provide targeted benefits that are only for clothing, shoes, books, hell it could even be just a voucher system, while better budgeting skills and education make being poor less of a day by day struggle. Especially when the benefit amounts is increased regularly to match CPI and inflation.

      that doesn’t damage the constructive inter-dependence between individuals;that doesn’t teach learned helplessness.

      [Citation Needed]

      lolwut? Most of the poor I’ve known (and observed) rely on friends, family and neighbours for all sorts of things, from small things to a shoulder to lean on and vis versa. A benefit only isolates people if there’s bigots around, or there’s underlying mental health issues/neurological variations that make connecting to people more difficult. Sure there are some that are hopeless, but in order to say the “benefit” caused it you need to actually show some fucking solid research that controls for all the other numerous little fuck-ups life provides to show that the benefit alone was the causative agent of their behaviours.

      Anything less is only useful for figuring out what methodologies are useless or show possible promise. Of course though I fully expect you to quote some RW Christian “research” on this as evidence, which will lead to the merry lands “lets see just how fucked up their logic is?”. TO which I have a bottle of whisky waiting to help me with.

      The report is about long-term welfare dependence, what drives it (unemployment is only one factor and not the most important) and what effect it has on the beneficiary and their children.

      Why exactly aren’t unemployment levels so important? Because often during times of peak employment that only people typically left on benefits are those with significant disabilities, or those who due to the lack of free child care have under 14’s to take care of*. Then there’s the geographic areas where you do get high levels of unemployment, however the problem is, is that moving them to Auckland, with it’s lack of accommodation, or other major centres needs to be balanced against the cost of fostering local jobs and business development to see which solution(s) will give the best result. It might even only need a small push, or an initial seed funding to get off the ground and provide long term jobs, r.e. the iwi-started kiwi fruit farms in the historically poorer parts of the Bay of Plenty.

      *note, solutions which force an individual to stay with an abusive partner, or someone they’ve kicked out for being a douchebag (my dad was kicked out not stopping smoking pot lawl) generally lead to future problems, not to mention either, they tend to regard women as property and tread all over the individuals human rights…

    • Deborah Kean 9.5

      If you are the Lindsay I believe you to be, the woman with a huge hate-on against the DPB, (Lindsay Mitchell) then you are being very disingenuous!
      I believe you are forgetting why the DPB was brought in – which was so that women could have a means of raising their children in safety, instead of creaing a bunch of latch-key kids whilst Mum was raising the kids and scrubbing the floors of the upper crust!
      When I was on the DPB, I took raising my kids as my job. A job I took very seriously. As a result, I have sons with tertiary qualifications, responsible jobs and stable lives and relationships. (The baby I had as a teenager, pre-DPB who was adopted out to a middle aged married couple is a P using truck driver! Turns out Child Welfare as it was at the time, weren’t too fussed about the fact that middle class Daddy was an abusive unfaithful alkie…)
      Ms Mitchell, I fear you really have no idea! Are you perhaps the second or third wife of a man who has always claimed that his Liable Parent Contribution stops him buying the house and the holidays to which you feel entitled?

  10. KJT 10

    Yeah we should be doing something about those on State welfare.

    Banks and finance companies who fail with Government guarantees.
    Employers who can pay low wages because the state takes up the slack with WFF and childcare allowances.
    Poor employers who drive good ones out of business because labour laws are so slack.
    State owned companies given away to corporates.
    External subsidies from ratepayers to dirty Dairy.
    Employers given handouts to employ people who then get rid of them when the subsidy ends so they can get someone else who is subsidised.
    Banks getting windfall profits when the OCR is raised.
    Currency speculators who short the NZ dollar.
    Gravy train of committees on welfare reform getting thousands per day to come up with such obvious bunkum.

    Yep we really do need to cut welfare.

    • Olwyn 10.1

      Not to mention the accommodation supplement, which has helped to make landlording lucrative.

      • bbfloyd 10.1.1

        olwyn.. you probably shouldn’t have mentioned it then.(accommodation supp). i have had the displeasure of reading some obnoxious, ignorant statements coming from the nact apologists lately, but i would characterize that statement as coming from a total lack of understanding of economic realities coupled with rabid bigotry. i am hoping this was an attempt at irony. if so, then well done, you got me. if not, then i think you need to consult a professional mental health practitioner

        • Olwyn

          Not sure what you are getting at bbfloyd. I am far from being a right-winger, and cited the accommodation supplement in the belief that it is (a) a benefit that goes straight to a landlord, briefly mediated by the bank account of a beneficiary or low-income wage-earner. (2) a benefit that bridges the gap between overpriced property and under-priced workers.

          When right wingers bleat about getting rid of welfare, they do not consider that one, because if it was not there they would have to face up to either a reduction in what they can charge as rent, or if they are employers, an increase in what they would need to pay their employees.

          • KJT

            WFF families and the accommodation supplement etc are not often recognized for what they are. A subsidy from the taxes of those in well paid employment to those whose employers do not pay a living market rate. A subsidy from good employers to poor ones if you like!

  11. Ag 11

    The WWG was obviously and predictably thick, but everyone knows it’s a political group, not a genuine research group.

    But stuff like this doesn’t help:

    Every “developed’ country needs a welfare system to take care of those who are, for whatever reason unable to support themselves.

    The whole notion of “supporting themselves” is seriously misleading. It buys into the right’s dubious evaluation of welfare as an entitlement. It isn’t.

    The real reason we have welfare is that a market system does not distribute incomes in an efficient manner. The market is not able secure our needs for streets free of homeless lunatics or supermarkets where we don’t have to endure feeling sick at the sight of old people buying dog food because they can’t afford anything else. Doing something about it is therefore an improvement to everyone’s quality of life. Because these goods are non-excludable, the market does a poor job of supplying them, so we must be compelled to pay for them the same way we are compelled to pay for the police and fire service.

    Talking about welfare as entitlements obscures the fact that welfare is a really good deal for most of us. Altruism is not the guiding principle. Welfare is in everyone’s interest.

    If the government won’t run a policy of full employment, then we will need more welfare to deal with the social problems that unemployment causes. The WWG seems content to let these problems multiply and negatively impact everyone’s quality of life unless we live in a gated community, which most of us do not.

    Again, welfare is not primarily a system of moral entitlements it is a means of securing goods that a market system cannot efficiently secure.

    • roger nome 11.1

      The market does a poor job of providing people like DPF and whale oil any fashion sense too. I have to wince every time i see an image of them. IMO they are a drain on the aesthetics of society. They should be publically lampooned and hauled into a state-run fashion class at least once a moth. Why should those of us who put some effort into the way we dress have to put up with these sartorial slackers?

      • Ag 11.1.1

        Alas, the negative externalities generated by conservatives’ fashion sense and general demeanour are not preventable at a sufficiently low cost.

        Having said that we need a NZ version of the North Korean hair cutting reality show.

    • loota 11.2

      Talking about welfare as entitlements obscures the fact that welfare is a really good deal for most of us. Altruism is not the guiding principle. Welfare is in everyone’s interest.

      Maybe the elite want their kids escorted to Kings in bullet proof Humvees under armed guard?

      Have the rich and wealthy not figured out that their kids are also heavily impacted by increasing crime and drug activity spurred on by social inequality?

      The real reason we have welfare is that a market system does not distribute incomes in an efficient manner.

      Ah yes, it is well recognised that a so-called market system is typically skewed by the ‘market makers’ to generate outsize benefits for themselves, quaint concepts like ‘fairness’ and ‘income equality’ be damned.

  12. roger nome 12

    Lindsay –

    So in the Nordic countries there are lots of people on the streets ‘cos they were kicked off welfare huh? Nah – the system doesn’t work like that over there. People are provided with options. i.e. In Sweden, after recieving 75% of the average wage (in NZ it’s about 35%) for 6 months, people on welfare are provided with training, and solo parents are provided with fully subsidised child care etc. Your story is always the same (i.e. the Nordic countries have better welfare states because they work test, and the benefit has a time limit) and you only tell half of it (the half you like).

    You should stop doing this. It makes you look dishonest.

  13. regstalin 13

    Here is an explaination for at least part of the rise in IB you won’t here from the WWG
    “Growth in IB inflow rates was more rapid for those aged 3039 and 4049 than for those aged 1519 and 2029. There is something different about the cohorts that experienced the economic restructuring of the 1980s and early 1990s in their early to middle years compared to those that entered the labour market either during or after the restructuring.” (Wilson, M., McLeod, K., & Sathiyandra, S. (2005). Growth in numbers of Sickness and Invalids Benefit recipients 19932002: Cohort analysis technical report. Ministry of Social Development, Wellington. pg 104)

    • roger nome 13.1

      That squares with the fact that the youth suicide rate trippled from 1988-1996. The Nats just made it that much harder to enjoy life for for the hundreds of thousands in John Key’s “under class”. That’s what can happen when you get a coup led by a bunch of ideological nutters who use the shock doctrine to impose thier seriously warped world-view on everyone else. All with only 35% of the popular vote. So glad that FPP’s gone.

  14. MikeG 14

    I would like to know how many hours Rebstock et al have spent in a WINZ office or a City Mission soup kitchen interacting with the people who form the statistics they are so concerned about.

  15. BLiP 16

    You gotta admit its a pretty nifty way of reducing the number of beneficiaries: no benefit = no beneficiaries. Simple, really.

  16. loota 17

    You treat people like dregs, with disdain and disrespect and surprise surprise, they act in ways to fulfill your expectations.

    You treat people wit respect, with dignity, let them hold their heads up and give them the means to reach their best expectations of themselves, and surprise surprise, they act in ways to fulfill that too.

  17. Bill 18

    So the government is attacking beneficiaries.
    And workers.( eg fire at will)
    And the environment. (eg mining and drilling)
    And the integrity of health system (eg Dunedin surgeons)
    The integrity of the education system (eg standards)

    And I’m sure there is more. But the point is a simple one.

    We can have (minimally) five separate sets of coalitions, with all their inevitable internal warring, fighting on five or more separate fronts…reducing complex matters to slogans, shutting out discussion in favour of preserving and presenting false fronts….and ultimately gouging one another for the sake of boosting their own participation rates etc.


    We can begin to build a movement that encompasses all the above and allows debate/discussion, thereby giving expression to the rich diversity of thought and analysis that naturally flows from large numbers of people.

    • loota 18.1

      We can begin to build a movement that encompasses all the above and allows debate/discussion, thereby giving expression to the rich diversity of thought and analysis that naturally flows from large numbers of people.

      They’ll put you away if you carry on with this kind of talk.

      (Where do I sign up?)

  18. prism 19

    Great post. Nothing shrivels a Tory heart like having to share their wealth and then finding that some creeps are gaming the system, they then target and want to destroy the whole system that is supposed to be supporting society. “Why should I pay for some other blokes kid” mentality.

    Anybody with any rational thought would know that for sure some beneficiary will play the ‘game’ – it’s part of human behaviour and probably mentioned in the list in book ‘The Games that People Play’ by Eric Fromm I think. How come we don’t go into extreme angst at the financiers who game the business system and rip off all that individuals have. Both types of trickster deserve scorn and be guarded against.

    There is a term that right-wingers like to use in denigration of welfare beneficiaries, that of ‘learned helplessness’ which does exist. It can happen when someone can’t see a clear way out of the problem of trying to climb out of poverty or whatever. But the system despite all that is shouted about it ‘getting people back to work, supporting families’ etc often does little to help the beneficiary who has the ability and desire to work, and the parent who needs part-time work so they can be good parents as well.

    And the government often despises what they are achieving in their lives as unpaid workers. Volunteer work a la Marilyn Waring is not yet recognised as work, and child raising is not, even family care of invalids or elderly may not be. There could be specified guidelines on how such work should be conducted to register as ‘work’ but the present attitude is too prescriptive for that – it’s reducing names on lists and ticking off boxes rather than recognising useful work that aids society.

    • Bored 19.1

      Nothing shrivels a Tory heart like having to share their wealth and then finding that some creeps are gaming the system,

      Now there Prism, no exposing Tories underwear! They actually dont like anybody else but themselves “gaming the system”… else did they get their ill gotten gains if not by “gaming” their employees etc?

  19. prism 20

    Bored – a bit too sweeping for me. I know that employers make profit from workers production but all wealth doesn’t come from having ‘gamed’ anyone. It just often has.

    I think that the trouble with Tories is another human characteristic like the one of gaming and that is to not admit that often they have just been lucky, and to have an addiction for acquiring money and power, and for the plotting to acquire. And there is such self-satisfaction and hubris in them.

    The elegant money-making scheme is a work of art in many ways, and when one project finishes the money machine rolls on carrying its addicted Tory with it. The idea of sharing some of the product of their art and skill with others who are part of the society that enabled their wealth-making is anathema to them.

    • vto 20.1

      Why do so many of you think that heaps of business people “game” the system???

      In my experience that is a very small minority, which usually comes unstuck somewhere along the line due exactly to the “gaming” of the system.

      Most people in the wealth creation ‘game’ recognise that there are only 3 ways to make money – inheritance, hard work and luck. Usually it is a combination of the second and third.

      Talk about tories gaming the system is no different to talk about beneficiaries gaming the system – and I bet those bene’s who do that also come unstuck at some point. There is only one shortcut in this world and that is the shortcut to ruin.

    • Draco T Bastard 20.2

      I know that employers make profit from workers production but all wealth doesn’t come from having ‘gamed’ anyone. It just often has.

      In reality it’s actually worse than gaming the system as it is, quite simply, legalised theft. The political right, and even some on the left, consider workers to be an expense of the administration (and the capitalists (which is why Jonkey wants wages to drop)) when, as a matter of fact, the administration is an expense on the workers. The worker s create the wealth – not the administrators and certainly not the capitalists.

      • vto 20.2.1

        Yes well Draco tax has long been regarded as the biggest “legalised theft” in the land. It is at the top of the list above poor regulations and the like that Fay and Hotchina and Watson have taken advantage of.

        In fact there are probably countless things people would regard as criminal but are yet legal – prostitution, alcohol when compared to drugs, trespass (police and taxman and etc), assault (arrest),kidnapping (incarceration) the list goes on.

        And workers create the wealth???? wha …? That surprises me but it sounds good. If so then you lot should stick the big finger to the capitalists. Get those ideas and wealth creation activities underway. If you are right the funding will follow and the relative positions of power between workers and capitalists will be reversed.

        • Draco T Bastard

          The administration is needed, I don’t dispute that, I just dispute that they’re worth more than the people doing the work. Of course, over the centuries, the administrators are the ones who wrote the laws.

          PS, Tax is only seen as theft by the psychopaths on the right – the rest of us realise that it’s a necessary cost to maintain a civil society.

        • Draco T Bastard

          That surprises me but it sounds good. If so then you lot should stick the big finger to the capitalists.

          We would – if the capitalists didn’t control the wealth through the laws that they’ve written.

          • Gosman

            Well you say you want a revolution…

          • Bill

            It’s not Capitalists who write laws.

            Veritable armies of well rewarded and utterly co-opted legislators, bureaucrats, lawyers, politicians and such like do that.

            Then there are the well rewarded police forces and armed forces should the status quo become threatened by any worker upstarts ignoring said laws.

            As an aside. Any western nation where the army hasn’t been deployed on to the streets to crush the demands of said nation’s citizens ?

            • Gosman

              How about you change that slightly to in the past 60 years.

              You can’t really compare our society today with what it was pre 1960.

              You might as well ask what Western nation hasn’t outlawed homosexual acts between consenting adults.

      • Gosman 20.2.2

        I do love your old school hard core leftist thinking DTB.

        It is so refreshingly old fashioned that I sometimes expect Joesph Stalin to pop out of the woodwork and threaten to purge everybody.

      • Deborah Kean 20.2.3

        Your absolutely right Draco! “The workers create the wealth not the administrators and certainly not the capitalists.”
        Quoto al 100%!

    • Bored 20.3

      Prism / VTO, I exaggerate. As a “business” person, I have long understood where profit comes from, in short its the difference between the combined sales cost you buy in at and the sales price you sell out at. One of the sales costs you buy in is labour….the old Marxist surplus value issue. Thats where my tongue in cheek sweeping statement about “gaming” fits in….my profits rely upon my exploitation of somebody elses hard work (as well as my own). Its a bastard of a strategy as Draco notes.

  20. Draco T Bastard 21

    Well, reading that, all I can say is that it probably would have been cheaper to buy everyone a copy of the Spirit Level. The data in it is more accurate as it’s been accumulated from decades of research and it actually shows the problem (although not directly) – capitalism.

  21. roger nome 22

    Maybe our rightists cold do with listening to more of the music that expresses problems to do with poverty, alienation and the stress and istability that it causes (it’s pretty much the only medium where you get genuine artists breaking through the class-relation of the spectical). This is what were taliking about. No amount of market discipline is going to get the 10-15% of clinically depressed people in NZ to go looking for a job that isn’t there. But rightis just don’t get it. Thier experience is too limited. Thier hearts and minds are too small.

    Something to chew on maybe.

  22. roger nome 23

    Here you go Gos:

    In the UK, according to the SAD Association, 500,000 people experience some form of winter depression, while in Sweden doctors have estimated that 20 percent of the population — almost 2 million people — are affected.

  23. roger nome 24

    In answer to your question, yes Gos. I wouldn’t want to live there – i find Dunedin winters hard enough to cope with.

    • Gosman 24.1

      So if your theory held true, countries with a similar climate AND social welfare systems would have a similar rate of mental illness prevalent in society.

      Does Ireland and the UK have a similar rate to NZ?

      • roger nome 24.1.1

        It’s a major cause Gos – not the only. I’d say conservative repression of sexuality (queer people are far over-represented in suicide, drug and depression stats) fear of pergatory in Catholic countries, childhood abuse and drug abuse account for a fair amount of mental illness as well. In Sweden you don’t get to stay on the dole for long anyhow – only 6 months then you have to train or work, so it’s not like people are left with long periods of time without anything to do.

        I’ve learned that a lot of what keeps people happy is hope for a good future – it’s hard to think like that if you’re stuck alienated from mainstream society with lack of funds, and a lack of confidence and self-esteem (part of depression) means you’re discouraged from looking for more demanding work

        In this situation it’s easy to spiral downwards. That’s why it’s self-evedent to me that the destitute state the market ensures for those that fall between the cracks leads to depression – and the deep the hole, the harder the cimb.

        In Sweden they have shallow holes. Ours are significantly deeper.

        • Gosman

          I’d say you are essentially making a lot of what you are writing up. Not that it doesn’t have a certain amount of logic behind it but it smacks of someone inserting their personal bias into deciding what does or doesn’t cause mental illness.

          Your theory should be easy to validate though. Places where unemployment rates have increased by a lot, say Greece for example, should have an explosion in cases of mental illness.

          Do you have any evidence that this is the case?

          • regstalin

            There are myriad studies on the link between mental ill health and unemployment, as well as huge debate over the direction of causation, however recent meta analysis (237 cross sectional and 87 longitudinal studies) of the existent evidence (Paul, K. I., & Moser, K. (2009). Unemployment impairs mental health: Meta-analyses. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 74(3), 264-282.) concludes that “The average number of persons with psychological problems among the unemployed was 34%, compared to 16% among employed individuals. Moderator analysis demonstrated that men and people with blue-collar-jobs were more distressed by unemployment than women and people with white-collar jobs. Linear and curvilinear moderating effects of the duration of unemployment were also identified. Furthermore, the negative effect of unemployment on mental health was stronger in countries with a weak level of economic development, unequal income distributions, or weak unemployment protection systems compared to other countries. Meta-analyses of longitudinal studies and natural experiments endorsed the assumption that unemployment is not only correlated to distress but also causes it.”

            • Bill

              Call me a contrarian, but I’ve always found that having a job is less than optimal situation for my mental health as compared to not having a job.

              See, I reckon it’s not the unemployment per se that’s the problem but a couple of related factors such as the fact that we are told that to be out of a job makes us somewhat less than useful as a person and tends us towards worthlessness.

              As a result of the need to perpetuate the mentality behind that myth, we deny ourselves and each other the opportunities gifted us in the absence of the need to regulate and prescribe our activities as we would need to were we in a job.

              And then there is the simple reward/punishment/addiction dynamics of jobs. You get a job and you get yourself dependent on the money and materials that might flow your way from having a job. And then when you don’t have a job you get a package deal of withdrawal symptoms.

              Where were we? Yup. The sense and sensibility of having a job. Way to go.

              Godley and Creme or whatever kind of summed it up with their wee ditty that ran…

              “Here boy, there boy.
              The boss’s got you running everywhere boy.
              You got no money and you got less sense,
              And you ain’t going nowhere.”

  24. Rosy 26

    I’d love to see a ‘Stuff’ poll asking what level of street-begging is acceptable after a restructure of the welfare system:
    10-19 people on the main street every day?
    Any number as long as they’re over 16?
    Whatever it takes?

    It’s something that’s starting to bother me. A few years ago I was relatively sure the homeless in NZ could access at least some form of benefit. Now I’m not at all convinced that they can – and the numbers, although still small, appear to be growing. Do people who support get tough welfare realise they may pass by the people they reduce to penury every day whereas at the moment most are conveniently hidden in the ‘burbs?

    • loota 26.1

      I see a report recommending the strictly enforced banning of street begging as the solution to this problem.

      Works in many areas of asia to solve the problem of street begging.

      Move street beggars far enough into the country side so by the time they make it back into the city the Olympics will be over etc.

  25. roger nome 27

    Gos – it’s true that there’s no scientific consensus as to what causes depression (by far the most wide-spread mental illness in the western world with 1 in 4 people suffering from at least moderate depression at some stage in their lives). It’s difficult to really grasp what it means to be depressed unless you’ve gone through it yourself. A depressed mind doesn’t think like a healthy mind. A depressed mind appears to be irrationally pessimistic to people who haven’t experienced it. In non-physiological cases (i.e. SAD, or brain damage), it’s basically a person’s mind attempting to self-destructive, strangely enough, to adapt to the circumstances it has become accustomed to.

    In the past this meant a subordinate primate lowering their own self-esteem to adapt to a position of low social status, as challenging the alpha male/female could well mean not “living to mate another day”. That’s it explained in evolutionary terms anyhow, and i think it’s a fairly rational hypothesis (this “social rank” theory of depression is also supported by the statistics which show younger siblings to be much more prone to depression than the first-born – in a competitive environment people often adopt a depressive/subordinate state as a survival instinct).

    Now you probably see where i’m going with this. In a competitive capitalist economy low income means low status. If you’re not “rewarded by the market” you are seen to be a “loser” and of low-status (money is the overwhelmingly important social metric by which status is measured). So, cetrus paribus, the poorer you are, the lower your status, and the more likely you are to suffer from depression (this is also supported by the stats, which show that people from disadvantaged backgrounds are more likely to suffer from mental illness).

    “Of nine studies, eight provide evidence of an association between one or more markers of less privileged social position and higher prevalence of common mental disorders.”

    So, a necessary part of combating this social disease is limiting income inequality – because its correlation with depression is compelling.

    (incidentally – sunny socialist countries like Spain and Greece have very low income inequality, and very low suicide rates) – suicide is the most useful metric here, because of reporter bias in studies involving other indices).

    • ZB 27.1

      So tripping a blind person so they fall to their death is wrong, but bullying a
      depressed person by making them less secure – facing up to their social lower status –
      so they commit suicide is not wrong. Because if it was Bennett and the whole
      culture of WINZ would be…. …what was it Bennett said ‘living the dream’.

      Kids bullied ruthlessly by their peers and commit suicide – should teachers,
      school principles and the bullies themselves be facing charges of manslaughter?
      Should schools be better targetting those who are likely to be bullies and
      doing some behavior management with them.

      Oh, wait, Schools look to government for leadership, and our present governments
      of left and right find it all too easy to attack the weakest poorest to get an extra voter.
      Their eating your taxes on their fat behinds, lets all be nasty to the bludgers –
      finance companies lose hundreds of millions but wait if we push sickness benefitaries
      back on the unemployment benefit and spend money on them that’ll save money!

      Income inequality is the budgetry problem – billions in debt are accumulated and
      National give the wealthy a tax cut that fuels further inequality. Good Job all round.

  26. roger nome 28

    Oh – and here’s another uber-talanted musician that uses song-writing to express thier experience of poverty, alienation, abuse and depression. Will probably just go over the top of the heads of our right-wingers.

    • Gosman 28.1

      And here’s one just for you from a mildly talented pop band from the 1960’s which probably will go over your head.

Links to post

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

  • Swinson’s swithering
    Jo Swinson is doing even worse at this Being Sensible lark that I'd thought.  I've just become aware of the following utterance
    .@KayBurley presses Lib Dem leader @joswinson on whether she would agree to a #Brexit deal 'no matter how bad a deal it is' as long as it had ...
    11 hours ago
  • Women’s rights, trans ideology and Gramsci’s morbid symptoms
    by John Edmundson The International Socialist Organisation (ISO) have recently reposted a February article, by Romany Tasker-Poland, explaining ISO’s position in the “trans rights” debate.  It is available on their website and on their Facebook Page.  The article sets out to explain why “socialists support trans rights”.  It reads more ...
    RedlineBy Admin
    17 hours ago
  • We need to take guns off police
    Today's IPCA report of police criminality: a police officer unalwfully tasered a fleeing suspect who posed no threat to anyone:The police watchdog has found an officer unlawfully tasered an Auckland man who broke his ankle jumping off a balcony to escape arrest. [...] To avoid arrest, the man jumped over ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    17 hours ago
  • “Bringing kindness back”
    "Auckland City Mission: 10% of Kiwis experiencing food insecurity", RNZ, 16 October 2019:About half a million people are experiencing food insecurity, according to new research from the Auckland City Mission. Food insecurity, or food poverty, is defined as not having enough appropriate food. The City Mission said over the last ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    18 hours ago
  • Press Release: “Fake News” from Auckland City Council CCOs Board Chairs re pay and performance b...
    Media Statement for Immediate Release 16th October 2019 “Fake News” from Auckland City Council CCOs Board Chairs re pay and performance bonuses for top managers Despite comments from Auckland City Council CCOs Board Chairs re pay and performance bonuses for top managers—Herald Newspaper Tuesday Oct 15th–there is very little evidence ...
    Closing the GapBy Tracey Sharp
    18 hours ago
  • Ever-So-Slightly Bonkers: Simon Bridges Plays To His Base.
    Would You Buy A Used Propaganda Video From This Man? Bridges and the National Party’s strategists have discovered that the ideas and attitudes considered acceptable by today’s editors and journalists are no longer enforceable. The rise and rise of the Internet and the social media platforms it spawned means that ...
    20 hours ago
  • Asking for food
    There is plenty of evidence of the way the business mentality has permeated every level of society since the recrudescence of market liberalism 35 years ago. You only need to think of how citizens in need of help from their government, their state, their country, are now routinely described as ...
    Opposable ThumbBy Unknown
    20 hours ago
  • Forty years of change in the jobs Kiwi do and the places they call home
    John MacCormick Over the last 40 years, New Zealanders – and people in other countries – have experienced big changes in the jobs they do and where they live and work. These changes include: a decline in manufacturing jobs an increase in jobs in ‘information-intensive’ industries (which are better paid ...
    SciBlogsBy Guest Author
    20 hours ago
  • Protecting Fresh Waterways in Aotearoa/NZ: The Strong Public Health Case
    Nick Wilson, Leah Grout, Mereana Wilson, Anja Mizdrak, Phil Shoemack, Michael Baker Protecting waterways has the benefits of: (1) protecting water from hazardous microbes; (2) minimising cancer risk and other problems from nitrates in water; (3) avoiding algal blooms that are hazardous to health; (4) protecting mahinga kai uses (cultural ...
    SciBlogsBy Public Health Expert
    1 day ago
  • Massey University triggered to rebrand
    by The Council of Disobedient Women In a press release today Massey University announced it has decided to rebrand and reorientate after struggling to be a University for grown-ups. For some time the University has wanted to be a safe play space for wee-woke-misogynists who have been really badly triggered ...
    RedlineBy Daphna
    1 day ago
  • Swinson backing calls for a second referendum (again)
    After a brief dalliance with 'hard Revoke' it looks like the Lib Dems are changing ground on on Brexit, with leader Jo Swinson reverting to calling for a second referendum on Johnson's deal.The party has tabled an amendment to the Queen’s speech requesting that any deal brought back from Brussels ...
    2 days ago
  • An odious bill
    The government has decided that someone has done Something Bad. But despite their belief, there seems to be no evidence that they have actually broken the law. So the government's solution is to pass a retrospective law allowing them to be punished anyway, on a lower standard of proof. If ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    2 days ago
  • National is now the party of climate arson
    So, Judith Collins has done a Facebook rant about climate change, peddling the same shit National has been shovelling for the past twenty years: the impacts are overstated, there's no need to do anything about it, and its too hard anyway (oh, and its so unfair that people who peddle ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    2 days ago
  • The environmental footprint of electric versus fossil car
    Climate Explained is a collaboration between The Conversation, Stuff and the New Zealand Science Media Centre to answer your questions about climate change. If you have a question you’d like an expert to answer, please send it to There is a lot of discussion on the benefits of ...
    SciBlogsBy Guest Author
    2 days ago
  • “Manifest” by Andrew Bird – A Song For The Times.
    I came across this song quite by accident. If it isn't one of Greta Thunberg's favourites - it should be.Video courtesy of YouTube.This post is exclusive to Bowalley Road. ...
    2 days ago
  • Passing the buck
    Last month, NZDF's shoddy coverup of what it knew about civilian casualties in Operation Burnham began to fall apart, with the revelation that a report on the matter, which NZDF claimed not to have, had been sitting in an NZDF safe for the past nine years. Yesterday, the man responsible ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    2 days ago
  • India a major player in Earth observation satellites
    While many imagine that countries like the USA and Europe dominate space activities, in fact India is now a major player on this stage. It launches satellites for its own purposes and also commercially, and has constellations orbiting our planet and returning data of vital importance to that nation in ...
    SciBlogsBy Duncan Steel
    3 days ago
  • The rot at the top (2).
    Thanks to a report from the Acting Inspector General of Intelligence and Security following a complaint by Nicky Hager, we have come to find out that the SIS illegally spied on Mr. Hager on behalf of the NZDF after publication of Hager’s 2011 book, Other People’s Wars. The NZDF justified ...
    KiwipoliticoBy Pablo
    3 days ago
  • Common misconceptions about “Global Warming”
    COMMON MISCONCEPTIONS ABOUT GLOBAL WARMING MYTH 1: Global temperatures are rising at a rapid, unprecedented rate. FACT: The HadCRUT3 surface temperature index, produced by the Hadley Centre of the UK Met Office and the Climate Research Unit of the University of East Anglia, shows warming to 1878, cooling to 1911, ...
    An average kiwiBy
    3 days ago
  • A climate of tyranny
    For the past week, Extinction Rebellion has been peacefully protesting in London to demand action on climate change. The British government's response? Ban their protests:Police have banned Extinction Rebellion protests from continuing anywhere in London, as they moved in almost without warning to clear protesters who remained at the movement’s ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    3 days ago
  • Collins crushes climate
    An essay by Judith Collins MP reported on Carbon News yesterday seems to show an alarming shift in attitude within the National Party. Collins argues against the Zero Carbon Bill, the Paris Agreement, and downplays the magnitude of climate impacts. The Paris Agreement was adopted in December 2015 and ratified ...
    SciBlogsBy Robert McLachlan
    3 days ago
  • More disappointment
    When they were running for election, Labour promised to overhaul the Employment Relations Act and introduce fair pay agreements to set basic pay and conditions on an industry level, preventing bad employers from undercutting good ones. They followed this up by establishing a working group, which reported back in January ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    3 days ago
  • What do these mother-child studies really say about fluoridation?
    A list of indicators of bad science – many of these are found in articles promoted by anti-fluoride activists. Anti-fluoride activists have been pouring money into a scaremongering campaign warning pregnant women not to drink fluoridated water. They claim fluoride will lower the IQ of their future child. Fluoride ...
    3 days ago
  • Losing Labour’s Mills-Tone.
    Nothing Left To Say: Labour's pollster, Stephen Mills, remains swaddled-up in the comforting myths of the 1980s. As if the experience of Roger Douglas’s genuinely radical post-Muldoon policy agenda was literally a once-in-a-lifetime thing – as much as the party could possibly absorb for at least the next 50 years.MEMO ...
    3 days ago
  • Speaker: Disability and the Royal Commission of Inquiry into Historical Abuse
    The Royal Commission on abuse in care is very significant for the disability community. For many decades last century, thousands of disabled children, and adults who managed to survive, were locked away from families and communities. This was not for anything they had done, but for the perceived threat their ...
    3 days ago
  • Spain is not a democracy
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    3 days ago
  • UK Conservatives hate democracy
    With an unfair voting system, uneven electorates and an un-elected upper house, the UK's "democracy" is barely worthy of the name. But now the government wants to make it worse:The government has been accused of suppressing voters’ rights with the potential disenfranchisement of tens of thousands of people after plans ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    4 days ago
  • What is wrong with our building industry?
    Back in the 90's and early 2000's, the building industry was building leaky homes which should never have been granted consent. Now it turns out they've been building dodgy office blocks as well:New imaging technology has revealed hundreds of major buildings nationwide have defective or missing concrete or reinforcing steel. ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    4 days ago
  • Local bodies
    Local body election results were released over the weekend, to joy or despair depending on where you live. In Auckland, Phil Goff trounced John Tamihere, who is muttering darkly about running for Parliament again (but which party would want him?) Wellington is now a wholly-owned subsidiary of Weta Workshop, except ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    4 days ago
  • A future of government
      How could government evolve over the next decades? Reports of democracy’s imminent demise are greatly exaggerated.  However, satisfaction with political systems in many countries is low, so there is much to do for governments of all political stripes to improve relevance and trust. Digital technologies are seen as one ...
    SciBlogsBy Robert Hickson
    6 days ago
  • Speaker: Catalonia, interrupted
    Two years have now gone by since the Friday afternoon when my university-student son and I headed out of our Barcelona flat to a nearby primary school, designated as a polling station for the vote that was to be held the following Sunday: the referendum on Catalonia’s independence from Spain ...
    6 days ago
  • Sage Decisions Unwisely Over-Ruled.
    Overruled: The joint decision of Finance Minister, Grant Robertson (Labour) and his Associate Minister, David Parker (Labour) arguably the two most powerful ministers in Jacinda Ardern’s government, to grant OceanaGold the consents which Land Information Minister, Eugenie Sage (Greens) had earlier denied them, offers bitter proof of how hard fighting ...
    6 days ago
  • Government may ban voting in effort to get more people to do it
    More than double the number of people who will vote in this year’s local body elections have tried marijuana or urinated somewhere they shouldn’t have. As local elections look set for the lowest turnout in decades, with many regions falling well short of 40%, the Government is exploring a number ...
    The CivilianBy admin
    6 days ago
  • Woman: Deleted.
    A Statement on Abortion Law Reform by the Council of Disobedient Women   On the eve of bringing an end to antiquated, anti-women abortion laws Green MP Jan Logie intends to write women out of the Bill. With a stroke of the pen, the woke are aiming for total erasure ...
    RedlineBy Daphna
    7 days ago
  • The Hollowest of Men Ride Again… SURPRISE!
    Musings continue apace about “the experienced businessman!” soon to be taking up a National Party MP position. Or to be more accurate, being parachuted into a seat to shut down their former MP Jamie-Lee Ross, who despite his own shortcomings shed at least some more light on the inner workings ...
    exhALANtBy exhalantblog
    7 days ago
  • Barbaric
    The Ugandan government wants to murder gay people:Uganda has announced plans to impose the death penalty on homosexuals. The bill, colloquially known as “Kill the Gays” in Uganda, was nullified five years ago on a technicality, but the government said on Thursday it plans to resurrect it within weeks. The ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    7 days ago
  • Fighting Monsters.
    Freedom Of Speech? The Säuberung (cleansing by fire) was the work of the German Student Union which, on 10 May 1933, under the watchful eye of the Nazi Reichminister for Propaganda, Joseph Goebbels, consigned 25,000 books to the flames in a ritual exorcism of “un-German thought”. According to the logic of the ...
    7 days ago
  • The next wave of kaupapa Māori politics: its constitutional, it must be.
      “There can be no such thing as kaupapa Māori political parties or politics in Aotearoa” (Willie Jackson, Labour Party (2017). Māori TV, General/List Election Special) I begin with that claim because at the time, I was confounded at first that it fell out of Willie Jackson’s mouth, and then ...
    EllipsisterBy Ellipsister
    1 week ago
  • Night lights of NZ from orbit
    New Zealand has prided itself for decades with regard to its lack of pollution, and all will be aware that the ‘100% Pure New Zealand‘ meme is under threat through land, water and air pollution of various causes. There is another type of contamination that the country also faces: light ...
    SciBlogsBy Duncan Steel
    1 week ago
  • Reporters deliver uplifting news to fleeing Japanese residents: they won’t miss any rugby
    New Zealand’s media is doing its part in Japan, reassuring those in the path of the storm that they won’t miss any rugby while away from their flooded homes. New Zealand sports reporters stationed in Japan for the Rugby World Cup have had the rare and heartwarming opportunity to inform ...
    The CivilianBy admin
    1 week ago
  • Government in contentious discussions about whether to put surplus on red or black
    Regional Development Minister Shane Jones is the only Cabinet member in favour of putting it all on green. As Finance Minister Grant Robertson finds himself with an enormous $7.5 billion surplus, the Government has begun intense, at times contentious conversations about whether to put the money on red or black at ...
    The CivilianBy admin
    1 week ago
  • Jordanian teachers’ successful strike has lessons for here
    by Susanne Kemp At the start of September close to 100,000 school teachers went on strike in Jordan.  They demanded a 50% pay rise.  A pay rise actually agreed to by the regime back in 2014. In early October, however, in the face of government repression and threats, the teachers’ ...
    RedlineBy Admin
    1 week ago
  • Why some people still think climate change isn’t real
    Climate Explained is a collaboration between The Conversation, Stuff and the New Zealand Science Media Centre to answer your questions about climate change. If you have a question you’d like an expert to answer, please send it to Why do people still think climate change isn’t real? David ...
    SciBlogsBy Guest Author
    1 week ago
  • The SIS unlawfully spied on Nicky Hager
    Back in 2011, journalist Nicky Hager published Other People's Wars, an expose on NZDF's activities over the previous decade of the "war on terror". NZDF didn't like this, and especially didn't like the fact that it was base don leaks from their own. So, they had the SIS investigate him ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • October 2019 – Newsletter ...
    Closing the GapBy Tracey Sharp
    1 week ago
  • And they wonder why we think they’re environmental vandals…
    The Zero Carbon Bill is due back from select committee in two weeks, and will likely pass its final stages in November. So naturally, farmers are planning a hate-march against it. But they're not just demanding lower methane targets so they can keep on destroying the planet; they're also demanding ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • Climate Change: Paying the price in California
    Last year, California burned. This year, to stop it happening again (or rather, to stop themselves from being found liable if it happens again), Pacific Gas and Electric is cutting power to half the state for a week:Schools are closed. Traffic lights down. Tunnels dark. Businesses unopened. Hospitals running on ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • Let’s Hear It For Up-Close-And-Personal, Hard-Copy Democracy!
    The Best Way: Missing from the on-line voting debate is any reference to the voting system that produces turn-out figures ranging from 77 to 93 percent of registered voters. The voting system used to collect and count the votes cast in our parliamentary elections. The system that involves citizens making ...
    1 week ago
  • 10/10: World Day Against the Death Penalty
    Today, October 10, is the world day against the death penalty. Out of 195 UN member states, 84 still permit capital punishment. Today is the day we work to change that. This year's theme is children. Having a parent sentenced to death or executed causes long-term trauma and stigmatization which ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • Talking Freer Lives: a Marxist gender-critical perspective from Australia
    Among the great new bunch of political friends we have been making recently is the excellent Australian-based Marxist gender-critical site, Freer Lives.  So we asked the comrade who set up that blog to write something for Redline on the blog, himself, his analysis of the rise of gender politics and ...
    RedlineBy Admin
    1 week ago
  • Government spin accepted by union leadership
    by Don Franks  The Auckland City Mission is struggling with a 40 percent increase in demand for food parcels this year. A total of 23,020 were needed by June. Last month Missioner Chris Farrelly told the Herald the “cupboards are bare” and without an emergency food drive, he can’t see ...
    RedlineBy Daphna
    1 week ago
  • Forbidden Thoughts
    by The Council of Disobedient Women   Massey Wellington Student Association had a sit-in today. Imagine a sit-in. On a campus. Against a women’s rights meeting. Did the ’60s really happen or did we fucking dream it? They gathered in the student square, an echo chamber. Sitting on soft pillows ...
    RedlineBy Daphna
    1 week ago
  • Much love to my loyal Ukrainian readership
    For some reasons, my post about the mystery message from inside the Downing Street bunker seemed to catch people's attention.  Quite a lot of hits from NZ (unsurprisingly) and the USA (a bit more puzzlingly, but hi there, USAians!!) and 76 views from the Ukraine.I've celebrated my Ukrainian readers in ...
    1 week ago
  • Another day of bonkers GNUmours (again, sorry)
    First, almost a score of Labour MPs seem to have sent a letter to the EU basically begging them to accept a deal - any deal - just so Britain can get the Heck on with Brexiting instead of being trapped in limbo:
    To avoid no deal, deliver on the ...
    1 week ago
  • Labour vs working class immigrants – again!
    by Phil Duncan In 2016 the National-led government suspended the Parent Visa Category, through which migrants were able to bring their parents into New Zealand.  Since then over 5,700 people have been in immigration limbo, stuck on the visa wait list. Labour is now bringing back the scheme.  Well, sort ...
    RedlineBy Admin
    1 week ago
  • Speak Up for Women press statement: on Massey University and Feminism 2020
    The following was released yesterday (Tues, October 8) by the women’s liberation organisation Speak Up for Women. On 23 September Speak Up For Women announced that we would be holding an event at the Massey University Theaterette in Wellington. The event is called Feminism 2020. The intention of the event ...
    RedlineBy Admin
    1 week ago
  • Farmers support dirty rivers
    The government is currently consulting on plans to improve freshwater quality. So naturally, farmers oppose it:South Taranaki farmers are preparing to fight proposed national freshwater changes that some fear will bankrupt them. The Government's proposed National Environment Standard on Freshwater Management, released in September, rated the Waingongoro River as one ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • No-one cares about local government
    Yesterday was the last day for (reliably) posting your vote away in local body elections. Turnouts are mostly much lower than the equivalent time last year (Palmerston North is down 2.3%), and so naturally people are pushing their online-voting snake oil again. Because the online census worked so well, lets ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • The political ghosts of eugenics may matter more than the genetic
    This essay, on the political legacy of the eugenics movement, by Kenan Malik was originally published in the Observer on 6 October 2019, under the headline ‘The spirit of eugenics is still with us, as immigrants know to their cost’. Birth control. Intelligence tests. Town planning. Immigration controls. It’s striking how ...
    RedlineBy Daphna
    1 week ago
  • “Surplus” again
    Another year, and the government has announced another enormous government "surplus". And just like last year, its nothing of the sort. When we have people homeless and sick and hungry, when we have schools and hospitals still falling down, when we have underpaid public servants and infrastucture unmaintained or unbuilt, ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • Inside the Downing Street bunker
    James Forsyth at The Spectator (I know, I know) has tapped one of his contacts inside Number Ten for an insight into the Johnson administration's thinking and strategy.It is fascinating, unsettling and quite, quite mad.  Some key points:Negotiations have stalled and the Johnson administration are keen to blame the EU: ...
    1 week ago
  • Taking Control Of The Nation’s Story.
    Fatal Contact: With the arrival of captain James Cook in October 1769, the islands of what would become New Zealand ceased to be the preserve of Polynesian navigators and settlers and became a part of both the world’s map and the world’s history.THE MAORI NATIONALIST assault upon the historical meaning ...
    1 week ago
  • Are GNUs extinct?
    Another round of tactical talks about forming a Government of National Unity have come to nothing with the Liberal Democrats still refusing countenance putting Jeremy Corbyn into Downing Street:Opposition talks on Monday made little headway over when to try and vote down Boris Johnson's government and who might succeed him as ...
    1 week ago
  • Labour chickens out again
    When the government was elected, it promised to lead the way on electric vehicles, and specifically to make the government vehicle fleet emissions-free where-practicable by 2025.They lied:There are 15,473 vehicles in the government fleet and only 78 are electric. When the coalition Government came into power in late 2017, the ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • Transgender extremism, violence at work against feminist meeting at British Labour Party conference
    by Nick Rogers The debate around the meaning of sex and gender made an appearance at this year’s British Labour Party conference in Brighton. Women’s Place UK – an organisation that questions the demand that biological males who self-identify as woman should have access to women’s spaces, to all-women shortlists, ...
    RedlineBy Admin
    1 week ago
  • Rebelling in Wellington
    Yesterday I went down to Wellington to participate in the Extinction Rebellion protest. Its part of the latest global wave of XR actions, with actions happening all over the world. Some of those protests are massively disruptive: in Canada, XR is blocking major bridges, stopping people from getting to work. ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • ‘The Workshop’ – Report: Talking about Poverty and Welfare Reform: A Guide to Strategies that ...
    The Workshop is a charitable trust for public good. The Workshop undertake research to find ways of communicating that will build support for the solutions that work to solve complex social and environmental problems. See their Report on Talking about Poverty and Welfare Reform below. ...
    Closing the GapBy Tracey Sharp
    2 weeks ago
  • Exclusive language
    What is language? We generally assume that it a facility unique to humans, allowing us to share what’s in and on our minds. We can tell of our plans, our past exploits, our knowledge. It also allows us to lie. And yet there are vast numbers of people we can’t ...
    SciBlogsBy Michael Corballis
    2 weeks ago
  • April 2018 – Submission to the NZ Govt Tax Working Group
    You can read our submission HERE ...
    Closing the GapBy Tracey Sharp
    2 weeks ago
  • 2018 – Submission to the NZ Government Tax Working Group
    Read our submission here ...
    Closing the GapBy Tracey Sharp
    2 weeks ago
  • Guardian: Poll shows DISASTER for Corbyn and the End of Times
    The Guardian - ever eager to forewarn of doom and disaster on the left - are leading with a new poll from Opinium, which puts the Conservatives 15% clear of Labour.Con 38% +2Lab 23% -1Lib Dem 15% -5Brexit 12% +1Green 4% +2This isn't good news, and it would be very ...
    2 weeks ago
  • How prostitution became the world’s most modern profession
    Being and Being Bought (Spinifex Press, 2013) by Kajsa Ekis Ekman  A synopsis and commentary of Chapters 1-2 by Daphna Whitmore Ekman, a Swedish journalist and critic, brings together a Marxist and feminist analysis of prostitution and surrogacy in this groundbreaking book She opens the discussion with a definition of ...
    RedlineBy Daphna
    2 weeks ago
  • Clever legal fellow on Scottish challenge to Brexit
    I make no claims to having much legal knowledge,  so I defer to those trained in this area.I am very much enjoying this twitter stream from m'learned friend in Edinburgh, deciphering the legal arguments around the Scottish court challenge to Boris Johnson, based on the charmingly obscure principle of Nobile ...
    2 weeks ago
  • An Open Letter From Closed Minds.
    Ivory Folly? The University of Auckland’s Vice-Chancellor, Professor Stuart McCutcheon, upheld the right of the radical nationalist group, Action Zealandia to exercise their freedom of speech – not matter how distasteful that speech might be. A wiser community of students and scholars would have nodded their agreement and moved on. ...
    2 weeks ago
  • Extinction Rebellion members want to “eat babies”
    If you are not convinced terrorist Organisation ‘Extinction Rebellion’ is very, very dangerous – watch this video at one of their recent meetings. Not only is this obviously mentally ill Woman begging the other terrorists to promote killing and “eating” babies and children, if you watch carefully other members nod ...
    An average kiwiBy
    2 weeks ago

  • Proposals to curb environmental damage help our coasts and the oceans
    Government Ministers today welcomed the release of a marine environment report highlighting the four key issues affecting our oceans, estuaries and coastlines.  The release underlines the importance of government proposals to combat climate pollution, ensure clean freshwater, protect biodiversity, make land use more sustainable, and reduce waste and plastic.    Environment ...
    14 hours ago
  • New mental health facility for Waikato
    The Government has approved funding for a new acute mental health facility for Waikato which will provide better care and support to people with mental health and addiction issues. Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern and Health Minister Dr David Clark announced the $100 million project to replace the aging Henry Rongomau ...
    18 hours ago
  • 500 new te reo Māori champions in our classrooms
    The Government is making progress on its goal to integrate te reo Māori into education by 2025, with over 500 teachers and support staff already graduating from Te Ahu o te Reo Māori,  Associate Education Minister Kelvin Davis announced today. Kelvin Davis made the announcement at an awards ceremony in Waikanae today, for ...
    20 hours ago
  • Minister James Shaw welcomes 2018 Census first release
    Statistics Minister James Shaw has welcomed the first release of 2018 Census data. The first release of data today, 23 September, includes key data on population, regional growth, the number of homes and the size of different ethnic groups in New Zealand. Data from the 2018 Census will support the ...
    20 hours ago
  • Driving transparency, ethics and accountability in government use of algorithms
    Minister for Statistics James Shaw today announced a public consultation on a proposed algorithm charter for government agencies. The charter has been developed by the Government Chief Data Steward in response to growing calls for more transparency in government use of data. Computer algorithms – procedures or formulas for solving ...
    21 hours ago
  • New Zealand and the Netherlands working together on climate change
    Agriculture Minister Damien O’Connor, Climate Change Minister James Shaw and visiting Dutch Prime Minister Mark Rutte co-hosted a business roundtable in Auckland this morning focused on working together to address climate change.  “The Netherlands is an important partner for New Zealand. We share a strong agricultural history. Sustainable agribusiness and ...
    21 hours ago
  • Protecting fairness for workers and businesses
    The Government is taking action to build an inclusive economy where more of us receive our fair share at work and businesses can compete on great products and services, not undercutting wages and conditions, Immigration and Workplace Relations and Safety Minister Iain Lees-Galloway says. Two consultations launched today seek feedback ...
    21 hours ago
  • Indigenous Freshwater Fish Bill Passes
    The future for New Zealand’s threatened indigenous freshwater fish looks brighter with the passing of the Conservation (Indigenous Freshwater Fish) Amendment Bill in Parliament today said Minister of Conservation, Eugenie Sage. “Until now, our freshwater fish legislation has been 20 years out of date. We have lacked effective tools to ...
    1 day ago
  • Kiwis to take part in world’s biggest earthquake drill
    At 1.30pm tomorrow, hundreds of thousands of Kiwis will join about 65 million people around the globe in ShakeOut, the world’s biggest earthquake drill. The annual drill is to remind people of the right action to take during an earthquake which is to Drop, Cover, Hold, and to practise their ...
    2 days ago
  • Rising wages and low inflation supporting Kiwis
    Kiwis are benefiting from higher wage growth and low inflation under the Coalition Government. Stats NZ data out today shows the rise in the cost of living remains low, as annual Consumers Price Index (CPI) inflation fell to 1.5% in September from 1.7% in June. “The low inflation comes as ...
    2 days ago
  • NZ economy strong amid global headwinds
    New Zealand’s economic strength and resilience has been recognised in a major update on the state of the global economy. The IMF’s latest World Economic Outlook released overnight shows a reduced global growth forecast over the next two years as issues like the US-China trade war and Brexit take hold. ...
    2 days ago
  • Keeping New Zealanders safer with better counter-terrorism laws
    Justice Minister Andrew Little has today introduced a new Bill to prevent terrorism and support the de-radicalisation of New Zealanders returning from overseas. The Terrorism Suppression (Control Orders) Bill gives the New Zealand Police the ability to apply to the High Court to impose control orders on New Zealanders who ...
    2 days ago
  • Improved succession and dispute resolution core of Ture Whenua changes
    A Bill that proposes targeted changes to simplify the processes for Māori land owners when engaging with the Māori Land Court has had its First Reading today. “The approach taken by the Government is to ensure that the protection of Māori land remains a priority as we seek to improve ...
    2 days ago
  • Speech to CTU Biennial Conference
    Let me first thank all the new unionists and members in the room. There is nothing more important to improving people’s working lives than people making the decision to care, to get on board and help, to take up the reins and get involved. Congratulations to you. You bring the ...
    2 days ago
  • Minister ensures continued Whenuapai flight operations
    Minister of Defence Ron Mark has signed a certificate exempting the activity of engine testing at Whenuapai Airbase from the Resource Management Act 1991. The Act gives the Minister of Defence the power to exempt activities for the purposes of national security.  The certificate will mean the recent Environment Court ...
    2 days ago
  • NZ joins Coalition of Finance Ministers for Climate Action
    Finance Minister Grant Robertson has announced New Zealand will join the Coalition of Finance Ministers for Climate Action while attending APEC meetings in Chile. The objective of the 39 member Coalition is to share information and promote action to tackle climate change. It was formed in April this year, in ...
    2 days ago
  • CTU speech – DPM
    Ladies and gentlemen, NZCTU President Richard Wagstaff, members of respective unions – thank you for the invitation to speak to you today. This might be preaching to the choir, but the importance of trade unions in New Zealand’s historical arch is difficult to understate. And it is my belief that ...
    3 days ago
  • Police Association Annual Conference
    "Let’s start by acknowledging that it has been a huge year. " Police Association Annual Conference James Cook Grand Chancellor Hotel Wellington Nau mai, haere mai. Tēnā koutou, tēnā koutou, ka nui te mihi, ki a koutou katoa. President of the Police Association, Chris Cahill; Members of the Association and ...
    3 days ago
  • New Zealand announces a further P-3 deployment in support of UN sanctions
    Minister of Foreign Affairs Winston Peters and Minister of Defence Ron Mark have announced the New Zealand Government’s decision to again deploy a Royal New Zealand Air Force P-3K2 (P-3) maritime patrol aircraft to support the implementation of United Nations Security Council (UNSC) resolutions imposing sanctions against North Korea. New ...
    3 days ago
  • New Zealand deeply concerned at developments in north-east Syria
    Foreign Affairs Minister Winston Peters says New Zealand continues to have serious concerns for peace and stability in north-east Syria. “Recent reports that hundreds of ISIS-affiliated families have fled from a camp are deeply concerning from a humanitarian and security perspective”, Mr Peters says. “While we acknowledge Turkey’s domestic security ...
    3 days ago
  • Government on high alert for stink bugs
    Biosecurity Minister Damien O’Connor is warning travelling Kiwis to be vigilant as the high-season for the crop-eating brown marmorated stink bug (BMSB) is under way. “We’re on high alert to stop BMSB arriving in NZ. The high season runs until April 30 and we’ve strengthened our measures to stop stink ...
    3 days ago
  • Better protections for students in halls of residence
    The Government is moving swiftly to change the law to improve the welfare and pastoral care of students living in university halls of residence and other tertiary hostels. Cabinet has agreed to several changes, including creating a new mandatory Code of Practice that sets out the duty of pastoral care ...
    4 days ago
  • New trapping guide for community and expert trappers alike
    The Minister for Conservation Eugenie Sage has launched a new comprehensive trapping guide for community trappers to help them protect our native birds, plants and other wildlife, at Zealandia in Wellington today. ‘A practical guide to trapping’, has been developed by the Department of Conservation (DOC), and was launched during ...
    4 days ago
  • Widening Access to Contraceptives Welcomed
    Associate Health Minister Julie Anne Genter welcomes PHARMAC’s move to improve access to long-acting reversible contraception (LARCs). PHARMAC has today announced it will fund the full cost of Mirena and Jaydess for anyone seeking long term contraception, lifting previous restrictions on access to Mirena. “I welcome women having greater choices ...
    4 days ago
  • Major upgrade for Taranaki Base Hospital
    The Government has approved the next stage of a major redevelopment of Taranaki Base Hospital, which will deliver new and improved facilities for patients. Health Minister Dr David Clark has announced details of a $300 million dollar project to build a new East Wing at the New Plymouth hospital. It ...
    5 days ago
  • Extra support for rural families
    Extra funding will allow Rural Support Trusts to help farming families, says Minister for Rural Communities and Agriculture Damien O’Connor. “I know that rural families are worried about some of the challenges facing them, including the ongoing uncertainty created by the Mycoplasma bovis outbreak. “Those concerns sit alongside ongoing worries ...
    6 days ago
  • Howard Leaque Beekeeper programme graduation
    Thank you for the opportunity to be here to present certificates to the 16 graduates who have completed a beekeeping course delivered by the Howard League.  Let us start by acknowledging Auckland Prison’s Deputy Prison Director Tom Sherlock, and Acting Assistant Regional Commissioner of Corrections Northern Region Scott Walker - ...
    7 days ago
  • Finance Minister to attend APEC meetings
    Finance Minister Grant Robertson leaves this weekend to attend the APEC Finance Ministers meeting in Santiago, Chile. Discussions between APEC Finance Ministers at the meeting will include the effects of the current global economic uncertainty, risks for APEC economies and sustainable development of the region. While at APEC Grant Robertson ...
    7 days ago
  • Pacific languages are a source of strength, they ground us and build confidence
    The Minister for Pacific Peoples Aupito William Sio says for Pacific people, language can be a source of strength. It can help ground us and give us confidence. When we speak them, our languages provide us with an immediate and intimate access to our identity and our story - and ...
    7 days ago
  • Major boost to support disabled people in sport and recreation
    The Coalition Government has announced an action plan to improve the wellbeing of disabled New Zealanders by addressing inequalities in play, active recreation and sport. The initiative includes training to develop a workforce that understands the needs of children and young people with a range of impairments, advocacy for fit ...
    7 days ago
  • More prefab homes to be built as red tape cut
    The construction sector is being freed up to allow more homes to be built more quickly as the Government cuts through some of the red tape of the Building Act.  “Every New Zealander deserves a warm, dry, safe home and old inefficiencies in the Building Act make building slow and ...
    7 days ago
  • Further details of Prince of Wales and Duchess of Cornwall visit to New Zealand
    Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern has welcomed further details on the Prince of Wales and Duchess of Cornwall’s visit to New Zealand next month. Their Royal Highnesses will visit New Zealand from 17-23 November – their third joint visit to New Zealand and first in four years. They arrive in Auckland ...
    7 days ago
  • O’Connor in Thailand to push for RCEP deal
    Minister of State for Trade and Export Growth and Minister of Agriculture, Damien O’Connor, heads to Thailand today to attend the final Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP) Ministerial meeting, as negotiations enter their final stages. “The RCEP Agreement would anchor New Zealand in a regional agreement that covers 16 countries, ...
    7 days ago
  • Young Pacific people can access earning and learning opportunities in Hawke’s Bay, Otago and South...
    Pacific young people living in the Hawke’s Bay, Southland and Otago regions will have access to support services that have proved successful in helping young people find new earning and learning opportunities. “Tupu Aotearoa is about changing Pacific young peoples’ lives. Our young people are talented, they are smart, they ...
    1 week ago
  • Protecting wellbeing – ACC HQSC Trauma Forum
    Introduction As the Minister for ACC I thank you all for the work that you do supporting New Zealanders in their literally most vulnerable moments. From those who hold people’s lives in their hands, to the people who research technique, technology and trends, your work is highly valued. A special ...
    1 week ago
  • NZ economy in good shape – notes prepared for speeches in Christchurch
    Notes prepared for speeches in Christchurch – Wednesday 9 October 2019 Today’s topic, “trends and opportunities for the New Zealand economy,” is certainly one getting a great deal of commentary at the moment. Looking across the media landscape lately you’ll notice we aren’t the only ones having this discussion. There ...
    1 week ago
  • World Mental Health Day a reminder of the importance of mental health work
    Minister of Health Dr David Clark and Associate Minister of Health Peeni Henare say this year’s World Mental Health Day theme is a reminder of why the Government’s work on mental health is so important. “This year the World Federation for Mental Health has made suicide prevention the main theme ...
    1 week ago
  • Cultural Ministers Meeting
    Associate Arts, Culture and Heritage Minister Carmel Sepuloni will represent the government at Australia’s Meeting of Cultural Ministers in Adelaide this week. “This year’s meeting is special because New Zealand is expected to become an International Member of the Meeting of Cultural Ministers at this Australian forum,” Carmel Sepuloni said. “The meeting is an opportunity to ...
    1 week ago
  • 608 claims resolved by GCCRS in first year
    The Greater Christchurch Claims Resolution Service has resolved 608 insurance and EQC claims in its first year in operation, Minister Megan Woods has announced. The government service, which celebrates its first birthday today, provides a one stop shop to help Cantabrians still battling to get their homes repaired or rebuilt ...
    1 week ago
  • NZ economy in good shape
    Today’s topic, “trends and opportunities for the New Zealand economy,” is certainly one getting a great deal of commentary at the moment. Looking across the media landscape lately you’ll notice we aren’t the only ones having this discussion. There has been an increasing amount of attention paid to the outlook ...
    1 week ago