Back to High School for English

Written By: - Date published: 6:20 am, June 15th, 2011 - 85 comments
Categories: bill english, education, wages - Tags:

My jaw dropped when I heard this listening to Question Time yesterday:

Hon Trevor Mallard: Does he understand that real average wages go up when high-income earners get massive tax cuts-$1,000 a week, in his case, and low-income workers lose their jobs?

Hon Bill English: No, I do not understand that, because it is not true.

Does English really not understand this, or does he just not want to acknowledge the truth?

The points that Mallard rises are undeniably true and pretty basic stuff. Of course giving tax cuts to the rich while the poor are losing their jobs means the average wage goes up even though most are no better off and some are worse off.

English must know this but doesn’t want to admit it because his ludicrous claim that Kiwis are better off despite 3 years of recession or near recession and rapidly rising prices relies on using the average after-tax full-time wage as his measure of Kiwi incomes. When you look at broader measures like the median household income, which captures all income, not just that of full-time workers, you see that incomes have clearly fallen. Which is what you would expect given the state of the economy.

Honestly, who feels 10% better off than 3 years ago? Very few people I would suggest, but English uses tricky statistics to avoid reality in favour of spin.

I remember my maths teacher in 3rd form explaining to us the different limitations of using averages (ie means), medians, and modes.

Two of the limitations of averages are relevant.

Our teacher had 10 of us line up at the front of the class and measured our heights. From that she calculated an average.

Then, she got the tallest boy to stand on a chair and measured his height again. He was now 50cm higher. The average of the ten kids went up 5cm. But nearly all of were the same height.

That was the first lesson: average does not mean typical, it can be influenced by movements in outliers.

Next, the teacher told the shortest 2 kids to sit down. The average height of the standing kids rose even though none of the heights of those remaining standing had changed.

That was the second lesson: a change in the composition of your population can distort the average even though the values of the individuals within the population haven’t changed.

Pretty simple stuff.

Does English need to go back to High School?

– Bright Red

85 comments on “Back to High School for English”

  1. Lazy Susan 1

    Would that be the same English who reduced the incentives from Kiwisaver to “encourage saving” and didn’t know where he lived? I think High School might be setting the bar a bit high – maybe back to Primary.

    • Jim Nald 1.1

      Sheesh. Is he for real about this?
      Or trying to put us in two minds whether he is being double dipton or dipstick.

    • National’s problem – any neo-liberal party’s problem – is that ideology (faith, actually…) makes the facts irrelevant. It is no accident that parties most likely to be attractive to religious people demonstrate a powerful and dangerous capacity to ignore evidence and believe whatever they want…..just because. Religion as we know it wouldn’t exist otherwise. Neo-liberalism has become a religion for people who don’t really understand economics is behaviour and the consequences of behaviour are not always good or optimal.

  2. Peter 2

    Household incomes is said to be the far more meaningful measure.

  3. ghostwhowalksnz 3

    Surely the way to pin the lying prick down is to ask about ‘ wage bands’.- $25,000-30,000 and so on.

    And to rub salt in the wound , ask for ‘treasurys figures’ not his own office.

  4. The fact that average wage figures are skewed upwards by a relatively small number of very high earners is exactly the reason the govt uses it rather than the median – and exactly why English pretends it’s impervious to being skewed, despite the fairly obvious fact that it isn’t. Are there politicians anywhere who won’t use a bullshit figure for how well off the voters are, if the real figure would be lower?

    • lprent 4.1

      Yep I have seen some bullshit numbers used inappropiately from politicians. However this is the first time I have seen a minister of finance confess that they didn’t understand basic statistics.

      Likke BR, my jaw dropped when I read that. At many levels, I suddenly got worried about the money I was giving to him to play with.

      What else doesn’t he understand? The difference between the states bank accounts and his own?

      • Psycho Milt 4.1.1

        I don’t believe for a moment that he fails to understand it. I believe he’s assuming no-one in the media will call him on such an obvious and blatant lie – unfortunately, that’s probably a very safe assumption on his part.

  5. ZeeBop 5

    Citizens seek help from WINZ because they have problem making ends meet. So National have decided that NZ international obligations to provide that assistance requires testing. Not just testing when the benefit is first applied for, but again and again and again. Just to make sure that the citizen knows that they are a failure, again, and again, and again. This of course costs more money to provide staff to ask, again, and again, and again for information they already have. Now to add to this tragedy National have decided to extend this regime to those who have medical problems, and have a good laugh asking them, again, and again, and again.
    This is torture. State torture. Humiliation. And how does National justify it? Well they tell citizens that the citizen’s problem is just that, the citizen apply for the benefits ‘problem’. So, to put it more clearly, a citizen goes to get their rightful entitlement to support their income and they can be rejected because they have a problem that would entitle them to paid support. And therein lies the breach of Human Rights, the right to paid support isn’t conditional on the recipient, its conditional on the relative poverty to the rest of society. So when English tells us he doesn’t know that tax cuts for the top earners means the average disposal-able income goes up, he also is going to pay for it by breaching Human Rights of the poorest by reducing their right to basic social security (and drive down wages at the other end of the income scale).
    So when you ask where is the Human Rights Commissioner, you’ll know the answer, spending his tax cuts bonus paid for by taxpayers who now are carrying a larger burden of the tax take because National reduce the top band.

  6. Craig Glen Eden 6

    This is a shocking admission from English why have the media not started asking questions of him or his Boss? Would any one have a person working in accounts who dosent understand the difference between average and median average. Quite simply this is outrageous.

  7. Jenny 7

    Who said that he used statistics?

    He may have just done a vox pop of the sort of people he meets everyday, probably millionaires all.

    Insulated inside this incestuous little circle of the population, English could honestly be of the opinion that National’s policies were working and incomes were growing.

    • Carol 7.1

      Agreed. National is all spin, PR and self-congratulations, and avoidance of economic and financial realities as experienced by the majority of kiwis, especially those on the lower incomes. I saw Blingish’s performance on TV yesterday and, apart from his dissembling, I was increasingly POed by the irritating blond who is always positioned behind the top Nat brass during Qu-Time. She behaves like a sycophantic, visual echo – a cheerleading Greek-bot chorus who is part of the PR spin machine designed to present a positive face to Nat, whatever tripe they are presenting as facts.

      • Jum 7.1.1

        I’ve watched her too.

        She can’t close her mouth properly and she laughs at the opposition over such matters as Finlayson telling New Zealanders that because NActMU is in power that the Hobbit is more important than fair workplace rules; that it’s funny for English and Key to lie in answer to questions like how fair the pay structure is for CEOs and minimum wage earners and for the Speaker to help them do so.

        Occasionally, she lets her guard down and you see the real nastiness of the character, The arrogance and the ignorance of plain facts and the NAct spinning of lies never interferes in her ‘smile’ but the eyes never lie.

  8. nadis 8

    Actually, English is correct if he is answering the part of the question about wage cuts raising the average wage – they dont. This is yet another example of a stupidly worded question (dont worry, National was just as guilty when in opposition).

    Income stats gathered by IRD and Dept of Statistics are pre-tax. Ergo, tax levels have no effect on income levels as measured by department of stats.

    Don’t get confused by the word “real”. That implies inflation adjusted not what you really get in your hand after tax. Browse some of the user guides on the Dept of Stats website.

    English is perfectly correct, had Mallard asked a question regarding after tax incomes, then he would (or should) have got a different answer. English’s answer is one that Cullen would have been proud of.

    • freedom 8.1

      sorry Nadis but do you read what you write?  If pre-tax is your start point, there is still the small issue of those pesky growing unemployment figures which does raise the ‘average’ number describing the income of wage earners
       
      less workers means a smaller pool of income earners
      which means a higher average,
       

    • Lanthanide 8.2

      nadis – Trevor asked only 1 question. The case where ministers are allowed to answer only 1 question out of a group of questions is when a group of questions is asked.
       
      If you read the quote, you will see there is only a single question mark – only a single question. The question has an “and” in it, but it is still only one question.

    • Bunji 8.3

      There’s a dissonance between what English repeatedly quotes as his income figures (average, after-tax, only those working, excluding any overtime etc), and what his answer to this question is though. If he’s going to refer to ‘real’ wages as his skewed statistic all the time in the media, it’s incredibly slippery at best (if not downright dishonest) to suddenly go back to everyone else’s definitions in parliament…

    • Blighty 8.4

      um, where is English asked about wage cuts?

      “Does he understand that real average wages go up when high-income earners get massive tax cuts-$1,000 a week, in his case, and low-income workers lose their jobs?”

  9. Splitting Hairs 9

    The only part of Mallard’s question that is accurate is that as lower income people lose jobs average wage rates are affected. His reference to tax change effects on wage rates is inaccurate, other things being equal. He poorly phrased his question giving English an out.

    Aftertax income is affected by changes in tax rates but before tax income isn’t, other things being equal. Wage rates and hours worked help determine the size of a person’s before tax income. They don’t determine the size of a person’s aftertax income – tax rates and ACC levies do. Hence people receiving tax cuts doesn’t necessarily affect their wage rates. But if it did it may be more likely to depress wage rate increases over time as businesses try to justify lower increases because earners are taking home more of their aftertax wage income.

    The reference to “real” is a red herring – the same is true for either nominal or real wage rates.

    It’s also interesting that he refers to high income earners “being on wages” – they generally aren’t – they are on salaries. Stats NZ makes this distinction between wage and salary earners.

    Happy to be corrected…

    And for the rabid lefties on here I’m not suggesting the general thrust of Mallard’s enquiry is incorrect – merely how he phrased it.

    • Colonial Viper 9.1

      WTF English has no idea neither do you

      Hence people receiving tax cuts doesn’t necessarily affect their wage rates. But if it did it may be more likely to depress wage rate increases over time as businesses try to justify lower increases because earners are taking home more of their aftertax wage income.

      THis is particularly stupid rationalising. You did get one thing right though, people receiving tax cuts may not actually be any better off. That was the case for about 50% of workers. The top 5% of earners did bloody well though thank you.

      • Splitting Hairs 9.1.1

        As I said I’m happy to be corrected but thus far you haven’t contributed anything that suggests my analysis is incorrect… Perhaps you can step through how changes in tax rates actually affect wage rates. I do enjoy how you try to stay in”viper” character so indulge me.

        • freedom 9.1.1.1

          Pre-tax or Post-tax it is the same mathematical law, there are no hairs to split.  Are you honestly defending a man who is ignoring basic mathematics that many primary school children easily comprehend.

          • Colonial Viper 9.1.1.1.1

            🙂

            NATs are screwed. The more they try this obfuscation tactic the more people are going to look into their wallets and realise that there is no extra money there, despite what English is claiming.

            Which makes English a liar.

          • Splitting Hairs 9.1.1.1.2

            As I said in my first post:

            1) lower income people losing their jobs will impact on average wage rates as it does change the population variable being measured – so I agree with that
            2) Changes in tax rates don’t affect wage rates to any meaningful degree in the short-term (wage rates are the dependent variable in Mallard’s question)
            3) Given that,Mallard phrased his question poorly by suggesting that changes in tax rates (independent variable) do affect average wage rates (dependent variable)
            4) Hence, English could answer as he did
            5) I’m not disagreeing with Mallard’s general thrust of enquiry ie that people are most likely by and large not better off on average than they were a few years ago – the reasons for that are complex

            In other words Mallard tried to establish a causal relationship between two independent variables and a dependent variable – he screwed up on one independent variable – hence the relationship outlined in the question is not true as English answered.

            But again happy to be corrected but thus far all the responses have been hubris. Please educate me on the mathematical law as it might be the new thing I learn for the day.

            • Colonial Viper 9.1.1.1.2.1

              ?

              Yes you can blame the questioner for not being pedantic enough. Or not using wording sufficiently tight from a legal languaging standpoint.

              Doesn’t change the fact that English was never going to tell the truth about the pathetic income situation that 75% or more of NZ’ers are finding themselves in.

            • freedom 9.1.1.1.2.2

              100 dollars divided by 20 workers = 5 dollars a worker
              100 dollars divided by 18 workers = 5 dollars 55 cents
               
              do you need some mat time now or a story? or can you admit the issue here is the Minister of Finance is either  an idiot or a devious and dishonest employee of the people.

              • Splitting Hairs

                I think you need the mat time – you’re changing the NUMBER of PEOPLE which as I said is fair enough.

                • Colonial Viper

                  Changing the NUMBER of people?

                  What did you do to dispose of those two missing people? Where have the bodies been buried?

                • freedom

                  it is called job losses, unemployment, a variable in the average generated.  Which if you actually read the question from Malllard, you can plainly see is a major factor of what we are discussing here

                  • Splitting Hairs

                    and which if you read my comments above you’d see I’ve acknowledged in every post

                    • Pascal's bookie

                      Think about it.

                      One variable has an effect. (we’ll call this one A)

                      One has no effec t at all. (and this one B)

                      What will happen if

                      1)A changes

                      2)A and B change.

                      If B has no effect at all, then 1 and 2 will have the same outcome.

                    • Splitting Hairs

                      Yes I accept that Pascal – I have no problem with that – but English doesn’t have to answer in that regard

                      I would prefer that House conducted its affairs in a different manner but for as long as I have followed it Ministers have taken any out they can to avoid answering questions. Cullen was a master of it

                    • Pascal's bookie

                      He was asked if he understood that if A and B happened then we would see the effect.

                      He said we wouldn’t.

                    • Splitting Hairs

                      Yes I understand the point you’re making but English has an out since the implied effect of B in the question isn’t (necessarily) true. He doesn’t have to go into any nuances to help Mallard get to the answer he was seeking. Its Mallard’s responsibility to ask the right question to obtain the answer he is seeking.

                    • Pascal's bookie

                      “hence the relationship outlined in the question is not true as English answered. ”

                      So you retract this then? Because the realationship “A and B leading to effect C” is real, even though B doesn’t matter.

                      coz that’s all I’m getting at.

                      It’s obvious that English is allowed to answer the question in any way he wants. the question was basically, “hey bill, are you an idiot?” and folks here are laughing coz bill answered. “Why yip, I say, ahuh”.

                      Folks are further talking about how it’s a bit sad that the media are a bit thick also, and too.

                    • Splitting Hairs

                      No I don’t retract it but acknowledge that someone smarter or more knowledgeable than myself could prove me wrong.

                      I’ve acknowledged your point as correct but simply suggest that because the implied effect of B is not true than English can state that the assertion of the question is not true – he doesn’t need to help Mallard out.

                      While I have sympathy for Mallard’s line of enquiry as I’ve stated previously – he needs to ask better questions. English isn’t at fault for his answer – its perfectly legitimate and I don’t think should be construed as showing his lack of understanding – merely the inadequacy of the question.

                    • Pascal's bookie

                      The relationship outlined in the question is that

                      “A and B lead to effect C”

                      You say you accept this, but also say it is “not true”. That’s daft.

                      the only thing implied in the question is that “A and B lead to effect C”

                      This could be because either ‘A’ or ‘B’, or ‘A and B together’ are sufficient for ‘C’, but the way the question is worded implies no preference.

                      One could infer for example, that ‘B’ is important and counteracts ‘A’ and thereby arrive at the conclusion that “A and B lead to effect C” is not true.

                      But you’d be an idiot, agreed?

                    • Splitting Hairs

                      Now Pascal is there really any need to start throwing around insults when I have been polite and open-minded? That seems rather poor form for a moderator.

                      All I’m saying is that the way the question is phrased suggests that both tax rate changes AND low income people leaving the labour market can each have an effect on average real wage rates rather than it merely being inequitable to give tax cuts to the rich while low income people lose their jobs then claiming that people are better off because average wage rates are increasing. I think we’re splitting hairs.

                      [lprent:

                      1. He isn’t a moderator but I am – you can tell the difference because I can write in your comment and he didn’t and cannot.

                      2. Read the policy if you want to know what kinds of things will and will not be tolerated here. We are pretty tolerant provided people aren’t repetitively trolling boring crap. With insults the only ones we tend to get concerned about are ones that the moderators judge are pointless.

                      3. If you think that Pb insulted you then you probably shouldn’t get involved in a political blog of this open robust type. You will get a lot worse from some (especially me when I’m commenting rather than moderating) because politics by its nature is about conflict and some of the most useful discussions happen when people are encouraged to think past their rigidity. There are other blogs around with more polite (academic) comment policies.

                      ]

                    • Pascal's bookie

                      Firstly, I’m not moderator

                      secondly, I didn’t insult anyone, I asked if infering that the tax rates would affect the average wage would make one an idiot. I thought you agreed with me about that so I’m confused at your response.

                      And you seem to be not so much splitting hairs, as you are backpeddling.

                    • Splitting Hairs

                      My mistake – apologies

                      All Mallard needed to do was ask “Does he understand that real average AFTERTAX INCOMES go up when high-income earners get massive tax cuts-$1,000 a week, in his case, and low-income workers lose their jobs?”

                      Then he should have got the answer he wanted and no one would have to quibble over:
                      1) Interpretations of the question
                      2) Validity

                      As I said – a poorly phrased question that doesn’t get the answer sought and leads to 1 and 2 above

          • Mike 9.1.1.1.3

            Sorry, I’m no fan of the National Party by any stretch but English was correct. It’s not the same mathematical law at all. Pre-tax is the same, post tax is different after tax cuts. Simple really. All Mallard had to do was say “after tax wages” instead of “real wages”. But in wording the question poorly the way he did, he gave English a legitimate out. Tax cuts will raise the average after tax earnings, not before tax earnings. Lower income earners job losses will raise the average, but that was part of the same question.

        • Blighty 9.1.1.2

          you’re missing the context. the whole discussion to that point had concerned after-tax real wages. It was clear that that was what Trev was talking about

          • Splitting Hairs 9.1.1.2.1

            He needs to phrase in that way then or English can answer as he did – he’s probably better also talking in terms of income rather than wage rates

            • freedom 9.1.1.2.1.1

              which will only ever prove how averages are a faulted mechanism for assessing a society’s wealth for work contract.  Income brackets are more based in reality but these often highlight how disparate those figures are

            • Blighty 9.1.1.2.1.2

              you know that he was speaking off the top of his head, eh?

              • Splitting Hairs

                You know he’s paid probably 4 to 5 times the average income right and has been a member of the house for what 15 years?

                • Colonial Viper

                  He’s a career bureaucrat who has spent his whole working life sucking off the public teat

                  • Splitting Hairs

                    I have no problem with bureaucrats – I was one. But he’s paid well enough to be incentivised to perform, has been a Minister of the Crown, and a member of the house for years so I think doesn’t have the option of “oh I was only thinking off the top of my head.”

                    • Draco T Bastard

                      Money provides no incentive.

                    • Splitting Hairs

                      Oh right he’s a Knight not a Knave. Thank you for the clarification.

                    • Colonial Viper

                      But he’s paid well enough to be incentivised to perform

                      Milton Freidman really had no idea of what motivates human beings, so I wouldn’t use his rationalisations.

                    • Splitting Hairs

                      Money is our current method of exchange for numerous things that people desire – some people even think of their status in terms of money. So while I agree that money in and of itself is only a means to an end – its a very important means to an end for many people as demonstrated, for example, by the amount of people that are motivated enough to go out to buy lotto tickets

  10. tsmithfield 10

    Just going to say the same thing.

    Mallard should have asked about the after tax income. English was accurate in answering the question that was given. Mallard needs to ask better questions to get better answers.

    • Pascal's bookie 10.1

      What happens to an average when you chop some of the lower numbers off?

      • Colonial Viper 10.1.1

        Heh I just figured out that the average wage in this country would sky rocket if you made unemployed everyone earning less than $15/hr!

        That’s cool, we can close the gap with Australia like, tomorrow!

        Of course this approach completely destroys our society on the basis of what will happen to median incomes (it will plummet as a huge number of people go on the dole).

        But that’s OK because average wages will have skyrocketed!

    • William Joyce 10.2

      It was a bad question composed off the cuff. But the after tax issue is slightly irrelevant.
      Mallard made two mistakes – he used the word AND and he got the wrong measure (ie. “real average wage” should have been “average after tax wage).
      Based on what he asked then he should have used OR
      Case A  AND Case B  = C
      C. Do “real average wages” go up if…
      A. The rich get tax cuts – NO
      B. Low-income worker lose their jobs – YES
      Strictly, because of the AND it would be necessary for both A AND B to be true before C was true.
      A is false AND B is true therefore C is false.
      In reality, it should have been an OR situation and not an AND situation because C (real average wages) would be true if either one of A or B was true.

      However,
      A AND B = C would work is C was reworded to Average  After Tax Wage
       
      Although is galls me, Bill was right.

      • Pascal's bookie 10.2.1

        nah, he is describing a world where i) low wage jobs have gone and ii) the rich have got tax cuts, and asking what would happen to average wages in such a world.

        1) If low wage workers lose their jobs, the average wage will rise. (if p then q)

        “[do] average wages go up when high-income earners get massive tax cuts-$1,000 a week, … and low-income workers lose their jobs?”

        plain old Modus Ponens. the tax cuts are irrelevant.

      • Pascal's bookie 10.2.2

        For further befuddlement, an analogy:

        “Does he understand that you get wet when you go out in the rain and whistle a happy tune?”

        • William Joyce 10.2.2.1

          I may be a bit hard of learning but if I phrase it like this…
          If (A is true AND B is true) then C is true.
          It is counter intuitive to say that because of the above formula
          “Does he understand that you get wet when you go out in the rain and whistle a happy tune?”
          is therefore false. That is why I used the word “strictly”.
          You can only make C true is you factor out B which is what you have done by reason of affect or benefit of the doubt (i.e. I know what you mean Trev’)
          But strictly, he was wrong, IMHO.

          • Pascal's bookie 10.2.2.1.1

            I get what you are saying, and it’s much better said that the hair splitter, but think of it this way.

            Everyone agrees that

            i) If A then C

            (and no one disputes A.)

            Let’s introduce B

            ii) A and B therefore C

            (B happens to also be true.)

            A is sufficient for C. (i, modus ponens)

            B happens to also be true.

            So if we look about the place and find that A and B are true, and accept that A is sufficient for C, seems hard, to me, to deny that C is true unless you can demonstrate that;

            If A and B, then ~C.

            To actually hair split, the point is about what does the ‘when’ mean in the question. I feel like Clinton here, but hair we s(pl)it.

            I interpret it as ‘Given’ or as a description of facts (A and B are True, therefore C),

            rather than as an ‘If’ which would make the statement “If (A and B) then, (and only then), C”

            • William Joyce 10.2.2.1.1.1

              My first year phil is failing me but if as you say, in Mallard’s question, part B is sufficient for C (and we can identify the mechanism that make a relationship between).
              But if we conjunct B with A as conditional to C then we have qualified the idea that B is sufficient for C.
              So, PB, are you saying that because B is always going to infer C we are allowed to overlook “A and”?

            • Pascal's bookie 10.2.2.1.1.2

              I don’t think he did conjunct And B as being necessary for C.

              He observed that A an B are true, and said that means C must be also true.

              He did fuck up, and could have made his point better, but the way he did phrase it doesn’t make it false.

              It still is true that in a world where low wage jobs are lost, and high wage people get tax cuts, the average wage will increase.

              The tax cuts are not relevant to it, but they don’t counteract the fact that by necessity the average goes up when you drop some of the low numbers, which is what they would have to do to make his claim false.

              Look at English’s counter-claim, he claims that when high-income earners get massive tax cuts-$1,000 a week … and low-income workers lose their jobs, it is not true that the average wage goes up.

              That just doesn’t work

              • William Joyce

                Thanks, I guess I was trying too hard to apply a cookie-cutter to a bad question.
                The end result is pleasing – once again (and again today) English is a plonker.

              • Hi William, I think the confusion arises from the fact that you (and Splitting Hairs and TS) are confounding the tests for the validity of a proposition that arise from Truth Tables (invented by my favourite philosopher, Wittgenstein – in his early work) with fallacies surrounding conditional ‘If-Then’ reasoning.

                In Truth Tables, the conjunction fallacy is as you say: for the proposition to be true both ‘A’ and ‘B’ must be true. But, in this case, that ‘compound’ proposition would be something like “The rich have been given tax cuts AND low income earners have lost their jobs”. I think it is uncontroversial, as it happens, that both terms of that proposition are true, hence the entire ‘compound’ proposition is true when expressed as a conjunction.

                Now, where it gets tricky is that Splitting Hairs, TS and yourself (but you perhaps express the view with appropriate caution) believe that the test of the truth of Mallard’s question must be that both ‘A causes C’ and ‘B causes C’ must be ‘true’ for the question to be able to be answered unequivocally with ‘yes’ from Bill English. (i.e., ‘If A causes C and B causes C, then C’). Otherwise he can ‘wiggle out’ of a ‘yes’ answer. In fact, it’s the opposite. Mallard made no claim about which of A and B might be causal for C, so the conjunction fallacy doesn’t apply. All Mallard posed was that, given two logical variables, C will happen.
                There is a sense in which Mallard has been quite clever – although probably unintentionally. By including two terms, A and B, he makes the answer to his question true (i.e., the appropriate, logical response is ‘yes’) in a way that someone who was thinking ‘off the top of their head’ – despite being Minister of Finance, paid a large amount, been in Parliament for decades, etc. (i.e., all the sorts of things that Splitting Hairs believes mean there are no excuses for sloppy thinking and wording) – might not follow. That is, he – again, probably unintentionally – exposes illogical reasoning.
                All of what I’ve just said becomes clear when it is realised that Mallard could equally have said “Is the Minister aware that if pigs cannot fly and low income earners lose their jobs then the average wage goes up?” and the answer should be ‘yes’. It is entirely irrelevant to the ‘truth’ presented in the question that pigs not being able to fly has no effect on average wages.

                Oddly, I’d have to conclude that Mallard’s question was not ‘badly worded’ at all – unless by ‘badly worded’ all we mean is that people who do not follow a strict logical analysis of a question will be tripped up by it. Given that so many people here who are criticising the question are doing so because they believe it leaves logical ‘wiggle room’ for Bill English, it is quite ironic that if we are really strict in our logical dissection of the question it turns out to be absolutely fine.

                But English got the analysis wrong. There’s no logical justification for a ‘no’ answer, unless we think there’s something wrong with the logic entailed in mathematical averages – which would be a risky line to argue.

                And, I think, that is the point of the post.

                Edit: P’s B said it more clearly than me – but it is a slightly subtle point and probably bears restating.

  11. freedom 11

    Speaking of going back to school
    whilst the poodles were licking their wounds, and the journos were playing three card Monty with the truth,  it seems the Education Minister has been busy planning the destruction of one of the few programmes that has consistently helped thousands of POOR children recieve much need assistance for over fifty years
    Tolley wants to close the Health Camps and is not saying what will replace them
    This is a very serious attack on one of our country’s most internationally applauded Child-assistance policies.  Does anyone have any detail?
    http://www.stuff.co.nz/manawatu-standard/news/5140699/Letter-an-insult-to-board

  12. speaking of duncery, did anyone notice that in his interview with Sean Plunket,
    John Key said that WW2 started in 1938! 😆

    • Colonial Viper 12.1

      Given Key’s Jewish background he may have an interesting point.

    • freedom 12.2

      had a quiet chuckle at that, but then again maybe he knows something we don’t.  Lots of lunches over the years and some of those seated would certainly  have some interesting chit chat

    • William Joyce 12.3

      I noticed that but I gave him a free pass. I think his mother was an Austrian Jew and so I guess for her the war  started with the Anschluss in 1938 and he may have fixed that fact in his other wise empty head.
       
      What disturbed me more was
       
      – his refusal to talk about his father (by avoiding the questions),
       
      – his professed ignorance about the relationship between his mother and father (as if we are expected to believe he “had no advice on that”)
       
      – his “apparent” lack of self-awareness of his thinking and values as a teenager/young adult unless it was part of the PR crafted narrative about the poor boy with an influential, “aspirational” Jewish mother and how that boy wants to give all NZdrs the same treatment.
       
      For an interview that was supposed to be an insight into the real John Key it was a failure. We looked into the real John Key and, as we suspected, there’s nothing there.
       
       

    • Luxated 12.4

      What is 20 years between friends? It started on the 28th of June 1919, no?

    • Daveosaurus 12.5

      A strong case could be made that the Second World War started in the early 1930s, with the Japanese invasion of China.

  13. Carol 13

    And Idiot Savant points out that Bill English repeated his fallacy today:

    http://norightturn.blogspot.com/2011/06/more-maths-denial.html

    Hon Trevor Mallard: Does he understand that real average wages go up when high-income earners get massive tax cuts—$1,000 a week, in his case—and low-income workers lose their jobs?

    Hon BILL ENGLISH: No, I do not understand that, because it is not true.

    Moana Mackay said in the general debate today, that if John Key was the only employed person in NZ, the average wage would be EXTREMELY high.

    • ianupnorth 13.1

      No Carol, the average wage would be very low because Herr Key allegedly gives away all his money to charity…

      Fact is NZ needs to wake up to the fact we are being frequently misled by this shower.

      • ZeeBop 13.1.1

        So to clarify, if Key paid his fair share and only earner, the average would be very very high.

        Its commonly understood by everyone who has had time to think about it, that the
        amount of money someone has little to do with whether they deserve it or not,
        just as the wage a person earns really show little reflection of their worth.

        Labour need to change that debate, make people realize that people are more
        than if they work or not, more than the car they drive or don’t, that devaluing
        humanity devalues the de-valuer.

        Small minded men don’t deserve your respect.

        And NZ has a huge dose of humility coming, with oil drips, they won’t be buying our
        quality they will be buying Australian Soy beans. So we better start getting our
        economy wide and deep, and we won’t do that if every second minute someone
        worries the pitiful amount the beanies get is too much but they are happy to pay
        $100,000 a year to keep them locked up, and destroy the world to keep economic
        activity up.

        Death happens, you will always be on the losing side eventually.

    • toad 13.2

      Yep, Carol, I could hardly believe that he hadn’t learned some basic maths overnight.  And he also stumbled and stammered and had no idea what he was talking about in response to Metiria Turei’s questions about inequality.

      • ianupnorth 13.2.1

        That’s because Bill English is as thick as two short planks – time he went back to playing at farming.

        • ZeeBop 13.2.1.1

          Does Manure rot the brain? Or work leave people old and thick?

          No. What’s with fascists why do they think they are social progressives?

          We know oil is running out, we know people who have jobs are no better
          than those who don’t. We know old people can be stupid, and we also
          know that boomers are full of shit they think that they did us all a favour.

          Look the conceited self-congratulatory elites are crashing the world in
          social, economic, environmental debt, and those who know better should
          stop helping them delay the inevitable because they would have been chucked
          out already. Just let them get on with the destruction, help it along, tell
          them their geniuses, that yes income does jump every time they speak.

          Until the cult of growth is ended we stand no chance. And you
          know what’s worth than the failed empathic people we have now,
          the socio-paths that will take their place. We need a healthy dose
          of humbleness injected in the working classes who seem
          untiring in their disgust and disregard for their unemployed mates.

  14. Jum 14

    I’ve listened to the spin of English and can well understand how he would tie NZers’ understanding of finance up in knots in much the same way that Douglas spills out figures that no one else can prove to refute him there and then. He does it in election debates. Someone needs to be at every election campaign place with a calculator and knowledge of policy and history to stop these liars from, well, lying, and manipulating the figures and the minds of the voters.

    I also begin to understand why some remaining seemingly unsympathetic (or maybe just desperate) workers might think they’ll earn more if fellow workers are sacked but we all know that does not happen. It goes into the profit side and the expenses side is reduced. Whoever invented the profit and loss and balance sheets hated workers.

    I say ‘unsympathetic’ because Key is still popular in the polls, no doubt with people still in jobs and with landlines.

  15. Jum 15

    So, maybe Mallard can ask this question and see what happens…

    “Splitting Hairs …
    15 June 2011 at 2:08 pm
    My mistake – apologies

    All Mallard needed to do was ask “Does he understand that real average AFTERTAX INCOMES go up when high-income earners get massive tax cuts-$1,000 a week, in his case, and low-income workers lose their jobs?”

    Then he should have got the answer he wanted and no one would have to quibble over:
    1) Interpretations of the question
    2) Validity

    As I said – a poorly phrased question that doesn’t get the answer sought and leads to 1 and 2 above”.

    Then we’ll all be looking askance at Splitting Hairs to explain why Slippery Bill, indulged by Lockwood, fudged the answer.

  16. Jan 16

    Pigs all fed… I’m feeling better off already!!;-)
    Has anyone thought of doing an OIA on the Minister’s sources. The calculations and the banding of after tax increases in wage rate would indicate the unpalatable truth masked by the averages. Secondly this information does not appear to exist in the public domain at the moment. No government websites (except the Beehive and Parliament web-pages referencing this story have any information on after tax wages).

    Indeed the Stats NZ (QES survey) figures that the Finance Minister’s statement is said to be based is not the same information at all. It:
    deals in means and medians rather than averages.
    is based on before tax income.
    doesn’t have any information on after-tax wages.
    acknowledges that “average earnings statistics reflect not only changes in wages and salaries, but also compositional and other changes across and within the paid workforce.

    Oh dear!

    Maybe because the Minister’s statement does have all the hallmarks of an ideological fart there is little on it in the MSM. Oh for Labour’s earnest, well-researched and tedious good news statistics!

Links to post

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

  • Close Tiwai Point
    Tiwai Point's electricity contract is up for renewal. And as usual, they're sticking their hand out, demanding a government subsidy, and threatening to close if they don't get one:The owners of the aluminium smelter said on Wednesday that there were seeking talks with the Government amid a strategic review which ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    5 hours ago
  • How volcanoes influence climate and how their emissions compare to what we produce
    Climate Explained is a collaboration between The Conversation, Stuff and the New Zealand Science Media Centre to answer your questions about climate change. If you have a question you’d like an expert to answer, please send it to climate.change@stuff.co.nz Everyone is going on about reducing our carbon footprint, zero ...
    SciBlogsBy Guest Author
    7 hours ago
  • ACT: Backed by Nazis
    So, it turns out that the ACT Party - which previously called itself "the liberal party" - is financed by Nazis:ACT Party leader David Seymour says his party will not return a donation from Mike Allen, a Christchurch businessman who sells mock "Make America Great Again" hats to fund advertising ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    8 hours ago
  • Counting Barretts
    Just in case you don’t have a seven-year-old boy in your house (in which case this will be obvious) a well-known brand of breakfast cereal here in NZ is currently coming with All-Blacks stats cards. Perfect for finding out your favourite rugby player’s height, number of caps, and how much ...
    SciBlogsBy Marcus Wilson
    8 hours ago
  • Bullying their critics
    Over the past month we've heard some horrific stories about bullying in the police. The police's response? Try to bully people into silence:The police have told a whistleblower to retract his statements to RNZ about being bullied or face legal action. The demand came just hours after Police Commissioner Mike ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    12 hours ago
  • Member’s Day: End of Life Choice, part 5
    Today is a Member's Day, which should see the final part of the committee stage of David Seymour's End of Life Choice Bill. The big question today is the referendum clause: will it be necessary, or can the bill pass without it? While the majorities for his amendments during the ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    12 hours ago
  • There is no ‘gendered brain’
    One of the key arguments used by trans ideologists is that some male-bodied people (ie men) are women because they ‘feel’ they are women.  To make this hocus-pocus sound a bit more credible, some will argue that such men have a ‘female brain’.  But this is thoroughly anti-scientific too. . ...
    RedlineBy Admin
    12 hours ago
  • Canada’s electoral system is broken
    Canadians went to the polls today in parliamentary elections, and appear to have re-elected blackface wearer Justin Trudeau. Unfortunately, they use first-past-the-post, and they've provided a perfect demonstration of how unfair this system is:PartySeats% Seats% VoteLiberal15746.4%33.1%Conservative12135.8%34.4%Bloc Québécois329.5%7.7%New Democratic Party247.1%15.9%Green Party30.9%6.5%Other10.3%2.4% [Results from Elections Canada] Yes, the Liberals got fewer votes ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 day ago
  • Measles: the quackery that is homeopathic “vaccination”
    A few days ago, a friend sent me a link to a health-related FB page that had published a post from a homeopathist, offering homeopathic “vaccination”¹ against measles (using something called a “Morbillinum nosode” at a “potency” of 200C, which I’ll explain shortly). I followed the link, left a comment ...
    SciBlogsBy Alison Campbell
    1 day ago
  • Colombia: 20th anniversary of La Gabarra massacre
    by Gearóid Ó Loingsigh This year marks the 20th anniversary of the La Gabarra massacre. The community organised an event to remember the most well-known of the horrendous heart-breaking events that befell the communities of this area of the municipality of Tibú: the massacre carried out on August 21st 1999. ...
    RedlineBy Admin
    1 day ago
  • A prediction
    There was another police chase in Christchurch this morning, resulting in a crash which killed one person and injured five more. Because someone died, the chase is being investigated by the Independent Police Conduct Authority. And based on previous reports by the IPCA, we know how it will go: the ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 day ago
  • Climate Change: The Zero Carbon Bill
    Just a month ago we saw the biggest protest in a generation as people marched to demand stronger action on climate change. A core demand of the protesters was to strengthen the Zero Carbon Bill's target to net-zero by 2040. So what is the government's response? Judging by the ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    2 days ago
  • Zombie ants, updated
    Back in 2010, I wrote about the strange tale of the zombie ants, which do the bidding of their fungal overlords. (They’re not an isolated example; a range of parasites change their hosts’ behaviour. See here and here for example – though as you’ll find, the toxoplasmosis story may be ...
    SciBlogsBy Alison Campbell
    2 days ago
  • Paying For Our Pakeha “Guilt” And “Privilege”.
    Shouldn't That Be: "Wrong White Crowd"? Rather than apportion guilt, would it not have been wiser for the makers of Land Of The Long White Cloud to accept that the Pakeha of 2019 are not – and never will be – “Europeans”? Just as contemporary Maori are not – and ...
    2 days ago
  • A Bodyguard of Truths.
    One, Two, Many Truths: With the collapse of “actually existing socialism” in 1991, the universities of the West found themselves saddled with a new mission. With their ideological competitors now soundly defeated they were no longer required to demonstrate the superiority of capitalist values. Their job now was to cement ...
    2 days ago
  • A call to unionists
    by the Council of Disobedient Women   We call on the Council of Trade Unions to show some fortitude and take a stand with your sisters. Unionists know that there is a material world, otherwise workers could simply identify out of poverty. They could declare themselves Well Paid. Why stop ...
    RedlineBy Daphna
    2 days ago
  • Sophistry and bullshit
    I spent some time reading the Regulatory Impact Statement and Bill of Rights Act advice for the government's odious control order scheme today. I am not impressed with either of them. Starting with the RIS, it is built on some pretty questionable assumptions. For example:Unless individuals have been convicted of ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    2 days ago
  • I’m so fly, I’m #NoFly!
    #NoFly: Walking the talk on climate change, by Shaun Hendy. BWB Texts, 2019. Reviewed by Robert McLachlan In June 2018, Swede Maja Rosén founded We stay on the ground with a pledge not to fly in 2019, and a goal of persuading 100,000 other Swedes to join her. In August, ...
    SciBlogsBy Guest Author
    2 days ago
  • Punishing the young
    We all know that NZ First is a party of and for old people who hate the young. But they've topped their previous pedophobia with a proposal that all young people be forced to do 100 hours community work:NZ First wants all young people to do 100 hours of community ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    2 days ago
  • Journalism, clickbait, & ideas of classical beauty – but not science
    A couple days ago the NZ Herald published a story with the headline, “Science says Bella Hadid is world’s most beautiful woman“, and followed up with the ridiculous statement that Supermodel Bella Hadid has been declared as the world’s most beautiful woman following a scientific study into what constitutes as ...
    SciBlogsBy Alison Campbell
    2 days ago
  • Is Simon’s Smile Sustainable?
    A Sustainable Proposition: With as much as 18 percent of the electorate declaring itself “undecided” about who to vote for, there is obviously plenty of space for a party like former Green Party member, Vernon Tava's, about-to-be-launched "Sustainable NZ Party" to move into. The most hospitable political territory for such ...
    3 days ago
  • What the actual Hell?
    Keir Starmer has hinted that Labour might vote in favour of the Johnson government's shoddy deal, with the proviso that a second referendum is attached:Speaking to BBC One’s The Andrew Marr Show, he said: “We will see what that looks like but it makes sense to say that by whatever ...
    3 days ago
  • Hard News: Dealer’s Choice, an oral history from Planet 1994
    In 1994, I was the editor for an issue of Planet magazine focused on cannabis, its culture and the prospects for the end of its prohibition. Part of that issue was an interview with 'Ringo', an experienced cannabis dealer.I recently posted my essay from that issue, and I figured it ...
    4 days ago
  • The invasion of women’s sports by men: some facts
    Dr Helen Waite, sports sociologist and former elite athlete, on the invasion of women’s sport by men and the anti-scientific and misogynist ideology used to rationalise it.   ...
    RedlineBy Admin
    4 days ago
  • Remainers starting to sound like fascists
    As Brexit comes to a grisly conclusion (perhaps) people on all sides are saying intemperate and uwise things.  Some, like the Daly Mail, have been doing it for years.People as normally level headed as Jon Lansman are calling for automatic deselection of MPs who vote against a (likely) Labour three ...
    4 days ago
  • Labour MPs supporting Johnson’s turd-sandwich deal?
    I find this unbelievable:
    I've got one source saying more Labour MPs than expected are mulling whether to vote for the deal - including names who were not on the letter to Juncker and Tusk— Emilio Casalicchio (@e_casalicchio) 17 October 2019 I've compiled a list of possible reasons why Labour ...
    5 days ago
  • Why do we need control orders again?
    On Wednesday, the government was loudly telling us that it needed to legislate to allow it to impose "control orders" - effectively a parole regime, but imposed without charge, prosecution, conviction or real evidence - on suspected terrorists because they couldn't be prosecuted for their supposed crimes. Today, it turns ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    5 days ago
  • Bullshitting the Minister
    On Monday, the Hit and Run inquiry heard from NZDF's former director of special operations, who claimed that the defence Minister knew everything about the Operation Burnham raid. Today, the inquiry heard from that (former) Minister - and it turns out that he didn't know nearly as much as NZDF ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    5 days ago
  • Speaker: Extinction Rebellion is not a cult (but ecstasy for the people)
    Yoga gurus and cult leaders – I’ve seen a few. Two weeks ago, I unknowingly joined an alleged new-age cult at the Kāpiti coast, together with a giant kraken and some neatly dressed pensioners who would make any book club proud.They were among the two hundred people of all ages ...
    5 days ago
  • We need to bring the police under control
    The last decade has seen a trend of increasing weapons availability to police. Assault rifles. Tasers on every hip. Guns in cars. And following the march 15 massacre, pistols on every hip, all over the country. At the same time, its also seen an increase in the abuse of force: ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    5 days ago
  • If you can’t measure it, does it exist?
    In the last couple of weeks, I’ve been busy preparing for our summer paper on Science Communication. Looking for something amusing about ‘risk’ in science, I came across this neat xkcd.com cartoon about why so many people come knocking on my door (or phoning me, or emailing me) desperately wanting ...
    SciBlogsBy Marcus Wilson
    6 days ago
  • Swinson’s swithering
    Jo Swinson is doing even worse at this Being Sensible lark that I'd thought.  I've just become aware of the following utterance
    .@KayBurley presses Lib Dem leader @joswinson on whether she would agree to a #Brexit deal 'no matter how bad a deal it is' as long as it had ...
    6 days ago
  • Women’s rights, trans ideology and Gramsci’s morbid symptoms
    by John Edmundson The International Socialist Organisation (ISO) have recently reposted a February article, by Romany Tasker-Poland, explaining ISO’s position in the “trans rights” debate.  It is available on their website and on their Facebook Page.  The article sets out to explain why “socialists support trans rights”.  It reads more ...
    RedlineBy Admin
    6 days ago
  • We need to take guns off police
    Today's IPCA report of police criminality: a police officer unalwfully tasered a fleeing suspect who posed no threat to anyone:The police watchdog has found an officer unlawfully tasered an Auckland man who broke his ankle jumping off a balcony to escape arrest. [...] To avoid arrest, the man jumped over ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    6 days ago
  • “Bringing kindness back”
    "Auckland City Mission: 10% of Kiwis experiencing food insecurity", RNZ, 16 October 2019:About half a million people are experiencing food insecurity, according to new research from the Auckland City Mission. Food insecurity, or food poverty, is defined as not having enough appropriate food. The City Mission said over the last ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    6 days ago
  • Press Release: “Fake News” from Auckland City Council CCOs Board Chairs re pay and performance b...
    Media Statement for Immediate Release 16th October 2019 “Fake News” from Auckland City Council CCOs Board Chairs re pay and performance bonuses for top managers Despite comments from Auckland City Council CCOs Board Chairs re pay and performance bonuses for top managers—Herald Newspaper Tuesday Oct 15th–there is very little evidence ...
    Closing the GapBy Tracey Sharp
    6 days ago
  • Ever-So-Slightly Bonkers: Simon Bridges Plays To His Base.
    Would You Buy A Used Propaganda Video From This Man? Bridges and the National Party’s strategists have discovered that the ideas and attitudes considered acceptable by today’s editors and journalists are no longer enforceable. The rise and rise of the Internet and the social media platforms it spawned means that ...
    7 days ago
  • Asking for food
    There is plenty of evidence of the way the business mentality has permeated every level of society since the recrudescence of market liberalism 35 years ago. You only need to think of how citizens in need of help from their government, their state, their country, are now routinely described as ...
    Opposable ThumbBy Unknown
    7 days ago
  • Forty years of change in the jobs Kiwi do and the places they call home
    John MacCormick Over the last 40 years, New Zealanders – and people in other countries – have experienced big changes in the jobs they do and where they live and work. These changes include: a decline in manufacturing jobs an increase in jobs in ‘information-intensive’ industries (which are better paid ...
    SciBlogsBy Guest Author
    7 days ago
  • Protecting Fresh Waterways in Aotearoa/NZ: The Strong Public Health Case
    Nick Wilson, Leah Grout, Mereana Wilson, Anja Mizdrak, Phil Shoemack, Michael Baker Protecting waterways has the benefits of: (1) protecting water from hazardous microbes; (2) minimising cancer risk and other problems from nitrates in water; (3) avoiding algal blooms that are hazardous to health; (4) protecting mahinga kai uses (cultural ...
    SciBlogsBy Public Health Expert
    7 days ago
  • Massey University triggered to rebrand
    by The Council of Disobedient Women In a press release today Massey University announced it has decided to rebrand and reorientate after struggling to be a University for grown-ups. For some time the University has wanted to be a safe play space for wee-woke-misogynists who have been really badly triggered ...
    RedlineBy Daphna
    1 week ago
  • Swinson backing calls for a second referendum (again)
    After a brief dalliance with 'hard Revoke' it looks like the Lib Dems are changing ground on on Brexit, with leader Jo Swinson reverting to calling for a second referendum on Johnson's deal.The party has tabled an amendment to the Queen’s speech requesting that any deal brought back from Brussels ...
    1 week ago
  • An odious bill
    The government has decided that someone has done Something Bad. But despite their belief, there seems to be no evidence that they have actually broken the law. So the government's solution is to pass a retrospective law allowing them to be punished anyway, on a lower standard of proof. If ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • National is now the party of climate arson
    So, Judith Collins has done a Facebook rant about climate change, peddling the same shit National has been shovelling for the past twenty years: the impacts are overstated, there's no need to do anything about it, and its too hard anyway (oh, and its so unfair that people who peddle ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • The environmental footprint of electric versus fossil car
    Climate Explained is a collaboration between The Conversation, Stuff and the New Zealand Science Media Centre to answer your questions about climate change. If you have a question you’d like an expert to answer, please send it to climate.change@stuff.co.nz There is a lot of discussion on the benefits of ...
    SciBlogsBy Guest Author
    1 week ago
  • “Manifest” by Andrew Bird – A Song For The Times.
    I came across this song quite by accident. If it isn't one of Greta Thunberg's favourites - it should be.Video courtesy of YouTube.This post is exclusive to Bowalley Road. ...
    1 week ago
  • Passing the buck
    Last month, NZDF's shoddy coverup of what it knew about civilian casualties in Operation Burnham began to fall apart, with the revelation that a report on the matter, which NZDF claimed not to have, had been sitting in an NZDF safe for the past nine years. Yesterday, the man responsible ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • India a major player in Earth observation satellites
    While many imagine that countries like the USA and Europe dominate space activities, in fact India is now a major player on this stage. It launches satellites for its own purposes and also commercially, and has constellations orbiting our planet and returning data of vital importance to that nation in ...
    SciBlogsBy Duncan Steel
    1 week ago
  • The rot at the top (2).
    Thanks to a report from the Acting Inspector General of Intelligence and Security following a complaint by Nicky Hager, we have come to find out that the SIS illegally spied on Mr. Hager on behalf of the NZDF after publication of Hager’s 2011 book, Other People’s Wars. The NZDF justified ...
    KiwipoliticoBy Pablo
    1 week ago
  • Common misconceptions about “Global Warming”
    COMMON MISCONCEPTIONS ABOUT GLOBAL WARMING MYTH 1: Global temperatures are rising at a rapid, unprecedented rate. FACT: The HadCRUT3 surface temperature index, produced by the Hadley Centre of the UK Met Office and the Climate Research Unit of the University of East Anglia, shows warming to 1878, cooling to 1911, ...
    An average kiwiBy admin@averagekiwi.com
    1 week ago
  • A climate of tyranny
    For the past week, Extinction Rebellion has been peacefully protesting in London to demand action on climate change. The British government's response? Ban their protests:Police have banned Extinction Rebellion protests from continuing anywhere in London, as they moved in almost without warning to clear protesters who remained at the movement’s ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • Collins crushes climate
    An essay by Judith Collins MP reported on Carbon News yesterday seems to show an alarming shift in attitude within the National Party. Collins argues against the Zero Carbon Bill, the Paris Agreement, and downplays the magnitude of climate impacts. The Paris Agreement was adopted in December 2015 and ratified ...
    SciBlogsBy Robert McLachlan
    1 week ago
  • More disappointment
    When they were running for election, Labour promised to overhaul the Employment Relations Act and introduce fair pay agreements to set basic pay and conditions on an industry level, preventing bad employers from undercutting good ones. They followed this up by establishing a working group, which reported back in January ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • What do these mother-child studies really say about fluoridation?
    A list of indicators of bad science – many of these are found in articles promoted by anti-fluoride activists. Anti-fluoride activists have been pouring money into a scaremongering campaign warning pregnant women not to drink fluoridated water. They claim fluoride will lower the IQ of their future child. Fluoride ...
    1 week ago
  • Losing Labour’s Mills-Tone.
    Nothing Left To Say: Labour's pollster, Stephen Mills, remains swaddled-up in the comforting myths of the 1980s. As if the experience of Roger Douglas’s genuinely radical post-Muldoon policy agenda was literally a once-in-a-lifetime thing – as much as the party could possibly absorb for at least the next 50 years.MEMO ...
    1 week ago
  • Speaker: Disability and the Royal Commission of Inquiry into Historical Abuse
    The Royal Commission on abuse in care is very significant for the disability community. For many decades last century, thousands of disabled children, and adults who managed to survive, were locked away from families and communities. This was not for anything they had done, but for the perceived threat their ...
    1 week ago
  • Spain is not a democracy
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • UK Conservatives hate democracy
    With an unfair voting system, uneven electorates and an un-elected upper house, the UK's "democracy" is barely worthy of the name. But now the government wants to make it worse:The government has been accused of suppressing voters’ rights with the potential disenfranchisement of tens of thousands of people after plans ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • What is wrong with our building industry?
    Back in the 90's and early 2000's, the building industry was building leaky homes which should never have been granted consent. Now it turns out they've been building dodgy office blocks as well:New imaging technology has revealed hundreds of major buildings nationwide have defective or missing concrete or reinforcing steel. ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • Local bodies
    Local body election results were released over the weekend, to joy or despair depending on where you live. In Auckland, Phil Goff trounced John Tamihere, who is muttering darkly about running for Parliament again (but which party would want him?) Wellington is now a wholly-owned subsidiary of Weta Workshop, except ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • A future of government
      How could government evolve over the next decades? Reports of democracy’s imminent demise are greatly exaggerated.  However, satisfaction with political systems in many countries is low, so there is much to do for governments of all political stripes to improve relevance and trust. Digital technologies are seen as one ...
    SciBlogsBy Robert Hickson
    2 weeks ago
  • Speaker: Catalonia, interrupted
    Two years have now gone by since the Friday afternoon when my university-student son and I headed out of our Barcelona flat to a nearby primary school, designated as a polling station for the vote that was to be held the following Sunday: the referendum on Catalonia’s independence from Spain ...
    2 weeks ago
  • Sage Decisions Unwisely Over-Ruled.
    Overruled: The joint decision of Finance Minister, Grant Robertson (Labour) and his Associate Minister, David Parker (Labour) arguably the two most powerful ministers in Jacinda Ardern’s government, to grant OceanaGold the consents which Land Information Minister, Eugenie Sage (Greens) had earlier denied them, offers bitter proof of how hard fighting ...
    2 weeks ago
  • Government may ban voting in effort to get more people to do it
    More than double the number of people who will vote in this year’s local body elections have tried marijuana or urinated somewhere they shouldn’t have. As local elections look set for the lowest turnout in decades, with many regions falling well short of 40%, the Government is exploring a number ...
    The CivilianBy admin
    2 weeks ago
  • Woman: Deleted.
    A Statement on Abortion Law Reform by the Council of Disobedient Women   On the eve of bringing an end to antiquated, anti-women abortion laws Green MP Jan Logie intends to write women out of the Bill. With a stroke of the pen, the woke are aiming for total erasure ...
    RedlineBy Daphna
    2 weeks ago
  • The Hollowest of Men Ride Again… SURPRISE!
    Musings continue apace about “the experienced businessman!” soon to be taking up a National Party MP position. Or to be more accurate, being parachuted into a seat to shut down their former MP Jamie-Lee Ross, who despite his own shortcomings shed at least some more light on the inner workings ...
    exhALANtBy exhalantblog
    2 weeks ago
  • Barbaric
    The Ugandan government wants to murder gay people:Uganda has announced plans to impose the death penalty on homosexuals. The bill, colloquially known as “Kill the Gays” in Uganda, was nullified five years ago on a technicality, but the government said on Thursday it plans to resurrect it within weeks. The ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    2 weeks ago
  • Is this study legit? 5 questions to ask when reading news stories of medical research
    Hassan Vally, La Trobe University Who doesn’t want to know if drinking that second or third cup of coffee a day will improve your memory, or if sleeping too much increases your risk of a heart attack? We’re invested in staying healthy and many of us are interested in reading ...
    SciBlogsBy Guest Author
    2 weeks ago
  • Fighting Monsters.
    Freedom Of Speech? The Säuberung (cleansing by fire) was the work of the German Student Union which, on 10 May 1933, under the watchful eye of the Nazi Reichminister for Propaganda, Joseph Goebbels, consigned 25,000 books to the flames in a ritual exorcism of “un-German thought”. According to the logic of the ...
    2 weeks ago
  • The next wave of kaupapa Māori politics: its constitutional, it must be.
      “There can be no such thing as kaupapa Māori political parties or politics in Aotearoa” (Willie Jackson, Labour Party (2017). Māori TV, General/List Election Special) I begin with that claim because at the time, I was confounded at first that it fell out of Willie Jackson’s mouth, and then ...
    EllipsisterBy Ellipsister
    2 weeks ago
  • Night lights of NZ from orbit
    New Zealand has prided itself for decades with regard to its lack of pollution, and all will be aware that the ‘100% Pure New Zealand‘ meme is under threat through land, water and air pollution of various causes. There is another type of contamination that the country also faces: light ...
    SciBlogsBy Duncan Steel
    2 weeks ago
  • Reporters deliver uplifting news to fleeing Japanese residents: they won’t miss any rugby
    New Zealand’s media is doing its part in Japan, reassuring those in the path of the storm that they won’t miss any rugby while away from their flooded homes. New Zealand sports reporters stationed in Japan for the Rugby World Cup have had the rare and heartwarming opportunity to inform ...
    The CivilianBy admin
    2 weeks ago
  • Government in contentious discussions about whether to put surplus on red or black
    Regional Development Minister Shane Jones is the only Cabinet member in favour of putting it all on green. As Finance Minister Grant Robertson finds himself with an enormous $7.5 billion surplus, the Government has begun intense, at times contentious conversations about whether to put the money on red or black at ...
    The CivilianBy admin
    2 weeks ago
  • Jordanian teachers’ successful strike has lessons for here
    by Susanne Kemp At the start of September close to 100,000 school teachers went on strike in Jordan.  They demanded a 50% pay rise.  A pay rise actually agreed to by the regime back in 2014. In early October, however, in the face of government repression and threats, the teachers’ ...
    RedlineBy Admin
    2 weeks ago
  • Why some people still think climate change isn’t real
    Climate Explained is a collaboration between The Conversation, Stuff and the New Zealand Science Media Centre to answer your questions about climate change. If you have a question you’d like an expert to answer, please send it to climate.change@stuff.co.nz Why do people still think climate change isn’t real? David ...
    SciBlogsBy Guest Author
    2 weeks ago

  • Minister of Finance and Sport and Recreation to visit Japan and Vietnam
    Finance Minister Grant Robertson departs tomorrow for events and meetings in Japan and Vietnam.  While in Japan, he will discuss economic and fiscal issues including meeting with the Minister of Finance, Taro Aso, and Minister of Economic and Fiscal Policy, Yasutoshi Nishimura. He will meet with the Minister of Education, ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 hours ago
  • Dashboard tracks housing progress
    The Government’s Housing Dashboard released today confirms record numbers of state houses are under construction and shows the Government build programme is gaining momentum.  “After nine years of inaction, and a hands-off attitude from the previous government we’re starting to see things move in the right direction for housing,” says ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    9 hours ago
  • Ministerial Statement on the International Convention Centre fire
    Mr Speaker, I wish to make a ministerial statement relating to the Auckland fire. The Government is closely monitoring the situation with the fire at the NZ International Convention Centre and is thankful that everyone is now safe. Firefighters are doing an incredible job managing the fire and bringing it ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    10 hours ago
  • Government invests in Te Reo, environmental data research
    The Government is investing in ambitious research that will digitise Te Reo, grow the low-carbon protein efficient aquaculture industry, help interpret environmental trends, and large data sets says Research, Science and Innovation Minister Megan Woods. The four projects range from teaching Siri to speak Te Reo to crunching large environmental ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    15 hours ago
  • Government announces next steps as part of a comprehensive plan to fix skills gap
    A new education-to-employment brokerage service to strengthen connections between local employers and schools. Funding for more trades focused ‘speed-dating’ events to connect schools with employers. Promotional campaign to raise profile of vocational education. The Government is taking action to increase the number of young people taking up vocational education and ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    16 hours ago
  • Corrections Amendment Bill passes third reading
    A Bill to improve prison security and ensure the fair, safe, and humane treatment of people in prison while upholding public safety has passed its third reading. Corrections Minister Kelvin Davis says the Corrections Amendment Bill makes a number of changes to ensure the Corrections Act 2004 is fit for ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 day ago
  • Ngāi Tahu CEO appointed to NZ-China Council
    Minister for Māori Development, Nanaia Mahuta, has selected Arihia Bennett MNZM, Chief Executive Officer of Te Rūnanga o Ngāi Tahu, as the Te Puni Kōkiri appointed representative on the New Zealand-China Council. The New Zealand-China Council (the Council) was established in 2012 as a New Zealand led and funded organisation ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 day ago
  • Southern Response claims move to EQC
    Responsibility for processing the small number of Southern Response claims still to be settled will be transferred to EQC by the end of the year. “As claim numbers reduce, it no longer makes sense for the Crown to have two organisations processing the remaining Canterbury claims,” Grant Robertson says. “Since ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • Bowel screening starts in Whanganui
    Health Minister David Clark is encouraging Whanganui residents to take up the opportunity for free bowel screening, which can detect cancer early when it’s easier to treat.   Over the next two years 12,000 Whanganui locals, aged 60 to 74 will be invited to participate in the National Bowel Screening ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • Pacific Peoples Minister to attend Our Ocean Conference in Norway
    Minister for Pacific Peoples Aupito William Sio, heads to Oslo today to represent New Zealand at the sixth Our Ocean Conference, which is being hosted by the Norwegian Government from the 23-24 October. “The Our Ocean Conference mobilises real action on issues like marine plastic pollution and the impacts of ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • Government announces 27 percent increase in Trades Academy places
    Two secondary-school initiatives are being expanded as part of the Government’s plan to see more young New Zealanders take up a trade to help close the skills gap.   This includes the largest single increase in Trades Academy places in recent years. Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern and Education Minister Chris ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Speech to the New Zealand Institute of International Affairs, Pacific Futures Conference: Connection...
    Session 4: Pacific Connectivity – Youth, Media and New Opportunities   Kia ora tatou katoa and Warm Pacific greetings to one and all. Representatives of Tainui, the local people of the land, or manawhenua – the indigenous peoples of this area – have welcomed you this morning in accordance with ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Methane reducing cattle feed one step closer
    The Government today announced its support for a project that could substantially reduce agricultural greenhouse gas emissions from cattle. The announcement was made as part of Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern’s and Agriculture Minister Damien O’Connor’s visit to Nelson’s Cawthron Aquaculture Park. The Cawthron Institute will receive $100,000 from the Government’s ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Bill to refresh superannuation system passes first reading
    Social Development Minister Carmel Sepuloni has welcomed the first reading of the New Zealand Superannuation and Veteran’s Pension Legislation Amendment Bill. “Every New Zealander has a stake in New Zealand Superannuation and Veteran’s Pension,” says Carmel Sepuloni. “They are our most common form of social assistance – nearly 800,000 New ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Government announces next steps in fight against measles
    Babies in Auckland aged six months and over can receive a free vaccination and children will all have access to vaccines, Associate Minister of Health Julie Anne Genter announced today at Papatoetoe High School.   The move comes as part of Government efforts to step up the fight against measles. ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Speech to the New Zealand Institute of International Affairs, Pacific Futures: Connections, Identity...
    ***Check against delivery*** Good morning. It is a pleasure to be here, and to have the honour of opening this important conference on behalf of the New Zealand Institute of International Affairs. Let us take the opportunity to acknowledge all the people who have helped make today possible, including our special ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Police trial new response to high risk events
    Police Minister Stuart Nash says the safety of frontline officers and members of the public will be the focus of a new trial of specialist Police response teams in three of our largest urban centres. Police have this morning released details of an initiative to be trialled in Counties Manukau, ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • New awards celebrate fisheries sustainability
    The Minister of Fisheries is calling for entries for a new public award to celebrate innovation in our seafood sector. “I have established the Seafood Sustainability Awards to recognise and celebrate those throughout industry, tangata whenua and communities who demonstrate outstanding dedication and innovation towards the sustainability of New Zealand’s ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • More progress for women and we can do more
    Minister for Women Julie Anne Genter welcomes leaders in the private sector taking action on closing their gender pay gaps to ensure a fairer workplace for all New Zealanders. Ms Genter today launched a new report, Addressing the gender pay gap and driving women’s representation in senior leadership, from the Champions for ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Proposals to curb environmental damage help our coasts and the oceans
    Government Ministers today welcomed the release of a marine environment report highlighting the four key issues affecting our oceans, estuaries and coastlines.  The release underlines the importance of government proposals to combat climate pollution, ensure clean freshwater, protect biodiversity, make land use more sustainable, and reduce waste and plastic.    Environment ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • New mental health facility for Waikato
    The Government has approved funding for a new acute mental health facility for Waikato which will provide better care and support to people with mental health and addiction issues. Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern and Health Minister Dr David Clark announced the $100 million project to replace the aging Henry Rongomau ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • 500 new te reo Māori champions in our classrooms
    The Government is making progress on its goal to integrate te reo Māori into education by 2025, with over 500 teachers and support staff already graduating from Te Ahu o te Reo Māori,  Associate Education Minister Kelvin Davis announced today. Kelvin Davis made the announcement at an awards ceremony in Waikanae today, for ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • Minister James Shaw welcomes 2018 Census first release
    Statistics Minister James Shaw has welcomed the first release of 2018 Census data. The first release of data today, 23 September, includes key data on population, regional growth, the number of homes and the size of different ethnic groups in New Zealand. Data from the 2018 Census will support the ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • Driving transparency, ethics and accountability in government use of algorithms
    Minister for Statistics James Shaw today announced a public consultation on a proposed algorithm charter for government agencies. The charter has been developed by the Government Chief Data Steward in response to growing calls for more transparency in government use of data. Computer algorithms – procedures or formulas for solving ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • New Zealand and the Netherlands working together on climate change
    Agriculture Minister Damien O’Connor, Climate Change Minister James Shaw and visiting Dutch Prime Minister Mark Rutte co-hosted a business roundtable in Auckland this morning focused on working together to address climate change.  “The Netherlands is an important partner for New Zealand. We share a strong agricultural history. Sustainable agribusiness and ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • Protecting fairness for workers and businesses
    The Government is taking action to build an inclusive economy where more of us receive our fair share at work and businesses can compete on great products and services, not undercutting wages and conditions, Immigration and Workplace Relations and Safety Minister Iain Lees-Galloway says. Two consultations launched today seek feedback ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • Indigenous Freshwater Fish Bill Passes
    The future for New Zealand’s threatened indigenous freshwater fish looks brighter with the passing of the Conservation (Indigenous Freshwater Fish) Amendment Bill in Parliament today said Minister of Conservation, Eugenie Sage. “Until now, our freshwater fish legislation has been 20 years out of date. We have lacked effective tools to ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Kiwis to take part in world’s biggest earthquake drill
    At 1.30pm tomorrow, hundreds of thousands of Kiwis will join about 65 million people around the globe in ShakeOut, the world’s biggest earthquake drill. The annual drill is to remind people of the right action to take during an earthquake which is to Drop, Cover, Hold, and to practise their ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Rising wages and low inflation supporting Kiwis
    Kiwis are benefiting from higher wage growth and low inflation under the Coalition Government. Stats NZ data out today shows the rise in the cost of living remains low, as annual Consumers Price Index (CPI) inflation fell to 1.5% in September from 1.7% in June. “The low inflation comes as ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • NZ economy strong amid global headwinds
    New Zealand’s economic strength and resilience has been recognised in a major update on the state of the global economy. The IMF’s latest World Economic Outlook released overnight shows a reduced global growth forecast over the next two years as issues like the US-China trade war and Brexit take hold. ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Keeping New Zealanders safer with better counter-terrorism laws
    Justice Minister Andrew Little has today introduced a new Bill to prevent terrorism and support the de-radicalisation of New Zealanders returning from overseas. The Terrorism Suppression (Control Orders) Bill gives the New Zealand Police the ability to apply to the High Court to impose control orders on New Zealanders who ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Improved succession and dispute resolution core of Ture Whenua changes
    A Bill that proposes targeted changes to simplify the processes for Māori land owners when engaging with the Māori Land Court has had its First Reading today. “The approach taken by the Government is to ensure that the protection of Māori land remains a priority as we seek to improve ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Speech to CTU Biennial Conference
    Let me first thank all the new unionists and members in the room. There is nothing more important to improving people’s working lives than people making the decision to care, to get on board and help, to take up the reins and get involved. Congratulations to you. You bring the ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Minister ensures continued Whenuapai flight operations
    Minister of Defence Ron Mark has signed a certificate exempting the activity of engine testing at Whenuapai Airbase from the Resource Management Act 1991. The Act gives the Minister of Defence the power to exempt activities for the purposes of national security.  The certificate will mean the recent Environment Court ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • NZ joins Coalition of Finance Ministers for Climate Action
    Finance Minister Grant Robertson has announced New Zealand will join the Coalition of Finance Ministers for Climate Action while attending APEC meetings in Chile. The objective of the 39 member Coalition is to share information and promote action to tackle climate change. It was formed in April this year, in ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Feedback Sought – Section 71 – Lyttelton Parking
    Feedback sought– Lyttelton commercial zone parking  The Associate Minister for Greater Christchurch Regeneration, Poto Williams, is seeking feedback on a proposal to remove on-site car parking requirements for new developments in the Lyttelton commercial zone.  The proposal, by Christchurch City Council, asks that powers under section 71 of the Greater ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Feedback Sought – Section 71 – Hagley Oval
    Hon Minister Poto Williams Associate Minister for Greater Christchurch Regeneration   MEDIA STATEMENT       Tuesday 15 October 2019 Feedback sought – Hagley Oval The Associate Minister for Greater Christchurch Regeneration, Poto Williams, is seeking feedback on a proposal about Hagley Oval. The proposal was developed by Regenerate Christchurch ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • CTU speech – DPM
    Ladies and gentlemen, NZCTU President Richard Wagstaff, members of respective unions – thank you for the invitation to speak to you today. This might be preaching to the choir, but the importance of trade unions in New Zealand’s historical arch is difficult to understate. And it is my belief that ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Police Association Annual Conference
    "Let’s start by acknowledging that it has been a huge year. " Police Association Annual Conference James Cook Grand Chancellor Hotel Wellington Nau mai, haere mai. Tēnā koutou, tēnā koutou, ka nui te mihi, ki a koutou katoa. President of the Police Association, Chris Cahill; Members of the Association and ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • New Zealand announces a further P-3 deployment in support of UN sanctions
    Minister of Foreign Affairs Winston Peters and Minister of Defence Ron Mark have announced the New Zealand Government’s decision to again deploy a Royal New Zealand Air Force P-3K2 (P-3) maritime patrol aircraft to support the implementation of United Nations Security Council (UNSC) resolutions imposing sanctions against North Korea. New ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago