Alone in Douma, Hassan Abdelrahman is weighing his options. The 37-year-old grocery store owner’s wife and three children left the rebel-held East Ghouta city for government-held Damascus this week, and he is struggling to decide whether or not to follow them.
“I am afraid to stay in Douma and face a new massacre,” Abdelrahman tells Syria Direct’s Ammar Hamou, “but I am afraid to leave for government areas and face the security risks.”
“Q: Were you in contact with your wife after she left? What did she tell you about the Syrian government shelters for people leaving East Ghouta?”
I have remained in contact with her, of course. She was at a shelter in the city of Adra for less than 24 hours, just long enough for her to settle her status with the regime and prepare to leave the shelter.
Most of the women who have children with them have an easier time leaving the shelters [than men], but some procedures are required. Women cannot leave the center unless they have a relative in Damascus or a sponsor who can come, sign some paperwork and pick them up. My wife’s father came to the Adra center and signed them out.
“Q: To your knowledge, are you wanted by the government? And if not, are you considering following your wife?”
I don’t think that I am wanted. I finished my military service years before the revolution, and never took up arms or worked with any civilian or military opposition group. Of course, I oppose the regime and participated in peaceful demonstrations all throughout the past years.
Anything is possible from the regime. I might be taken for military reserve duty, or just the fact that I have been in an opposition area all this time could be enough for them to accuse me [of a crime].
I’m trying to find out how the regime is dealing with people in the shelters, hoping to meet up with my wife and family. That would be a better option, in my opinion, than being displaced to the north and leaving my land and home behind.
But since my wife left, I’ve been struggling even more [with the decision] because of conflicting rumors about what happens to the men who leave. Some people say that there is a resolution to recruit them [by the military], others say they are subject to arrest and torture.
Until now, I don’t know any men who have left the shelters and gone to Damascus. My wife and a lot of people whose families left are saying that none of the men have left the shelters.
Hassan Abdelrahman, the 37-year-old grocery store owner in Eastern Ghouta, quoted above, faces a sickening life or death choice.
Flee to rebel held Idlib and again risk death under the continual hail of regime and Russian bombs. Or take his chances with the regime.
What decision would you make if you were Hassan?
1/ Leave your family and flee to Idlib?
2/ Take your chances with the regime?
Give the reasons for your choice.
A chilling new Amnesty International report published today has exposed the “cold-blooded killing of thousands of defenceless prisoners” in a Syrian government jail where an estimated 13,000 people have been hanged in the past five years, and where mass hangings of up to 50 people at a time occur every week, sometimes twice a week.
The mass hangings have taken place at Saydnaya military prison near Damascus between 2011 and 2015 – and there are clear indications that the mass hangings are ongoing.
Most of those hanged were civilians believed to have been opposed to the government, with the killings taking place in great secrecy in the middle of the night. The executions take place after one- or two-minute lawyer-less “trials” using “confessions” extracted through torture.
Survivors of Saydnaya have also provided spine-chilling and shocking testimonies about life inside the prison. They evoke a world carefully designed to humiliate, degrade, sicken, starve and ultimately kill those trapped inside. These harrowing accounts (see below) have led Amnesty to conclude that the suffering and appalling conditions at Saydnaya have been deliberately inflicted on detainees as a policy of “extermination”.
It will be interesting to see if Guyon Espiner will still be as supportive of Paul Buchanan today after his “New Zealand’s claim it has no Russian spies is perplexing. Why is it isolating itself?” opinion piece in the Guardian overnight. It was opened for comment, with most of the responders (over 1400 at 7:00am) making it clear they did not support his sycophantic endorsement of Theresa May’s support club. Perhaps there is an ex-USA spy that should be considered for expulsion.
“New Zealand’s decision not to participate in the solidarity coalition was made in the face of a direct request from the May government ….” Paul Buchanan.
In international terms, the request was made by the British government. From what Ardern says, it involved consultation between 5-eyes partners and set criteria for who would be expelled.
Australia found two people who met those criteria. Two. The SIS says none meet the criteria. That being so, who should be picked for expulsion?
Of course Australia found 2 people who meet the criteria. They will do anything to look good or win we only have to look at their cricket and they are very bad losers. They need to clean up their own backyard they treat their indigenous people appallingly (high incarceration rates, high suicide rates )
If I were nominating suspects in the little criminal nation england …. with extensive form ….. Billionaire Zionists line up very well as motivated thugs . https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Israeli_assassinations …. And they have form for poisoning people in sly ways too
They have murderous motivation against Russia …. As the disintegration of Syria would make permanent their theft of the Golan heights … and they hoped their proxy war would destroy Hamas.
At about the 15 minute mark of this doco you hear how their war of aggression helped them steal more land from Palestine , Egypt and Syria https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TOaxAckFCuQ
Geezuz man! Ya can’t say THAT!!!!
– NEXT thingbya know, you’ll have ‘the authorities knocking on the straw and clay bathroom window threatening to take away your arse wash
And people need to be clear what that criteria as to who would be expelled was/is – “undeclared intelligence staff/agents” – a very specific category of intelligence operatives.
Andrew Geddis at Pundit (and at Stuff?) has done a superb job of defining exactly what an “Undeclared intelligence agent” is – and why this category of agents/diplomats has been targetted.
I won’t do an extract as to get the full context takes up most of Geddis’ post, but if you want to see the main points I have done an extract here on TS already in slightly different responses to two other comments:
But people need to understand the criteria – ie this specific category – to understand why NZ has not expelled anyone. Nor by the way have 40% of EU countries according to Winston Peters under Q8 yesterday in the House. See the second link above for this and my addendum comment immediately under that.
That is one of the clearest explanations I have ever seen. NZSIS and GCSB should plagarize it! i was trying to put it into a short definition but was getting twisted about, so full marks to Geddis.
It’s fairly obvious you’ve experienced 76uin both the world of the Humphrey, and the world of what is best described as the job of a Jitter Jitter noooo KKKKKITERIDGE WUNCE d d d ddid.
Before you sign my expulsion orders, have a look at my original thoughts on the affair. A lot got spun off and/or edited down in the aftermath of my writing it, but the bottom line is this: the spy comments by the PM were not only silly but a diversion from the main issue. That issue is the reason(s) why the Labour government chose not to join its major security partners in this (largely symbolic) act of collective repudiation of Russian misbehaviour abroad. We have yet to hear about those, which is the only thing I am particularly interested in. http://www.kiwipolitico.com/2018/03/new-zealand-goes-it-alone/
Must be the wrong clip. She talks about different types of intel officers (and it is a very incomplete one at that), but never mentions the reasons why NZ did not respond favorably to the UK request. Surely it is not just because there were no people who “met the criteria,” because if so that would demonstrate that the government focused on the tactical instrumentalities of a reply rather than the substance of the request as framed against NZ’s global interests.
Put another way: was there any other reason other than the absence of people “who met the criteria” behind the rejection of the request to join the “expulsion coalition?” I mention a few possible reasons in my essay linked above but have heard nothing one way or the other from our foreign policy leaders.
As she points out in the clip, Australia identified two individuals. All two of them will be expelled. Not that hard to believe NZ turning up zero especially since it’s also been reported that:
People in the Five Eyes have consulted with us on our decision, understand our decision, and did so before the decision was made.
As Geddis says, expelling people who don’t meet the criteria goes further than other countries have.
Travel bans and other sanctions to follow, they say. Hardly a “refusal”.
No, which is why that phrase is unhelpful. The big difference in HUMINT is that between Official Cover (those with diplomatic passports) and Unofficial Cover (those without diplomatic passports and hence immunity). OC’s who are discovered get expelled; UC’s get arrested and imprisoned/executed. All those expelled in this action were OCs and regular diplomats who were not working outside the job description in their credentials (OCs tend to work the outer margins of what they are credentialed to do). No UCs were expelled, and those are the ones that decline to “declare” their status because they are working covertly under the cover of an assumed identity. So the phraseology being used by the PM is obtuse, and I am not sure that is by accident.
Again, all of this diverts attention from the main issue.
I thought the ones supposed to be expelled were OCs in that they were officially regular diplomats but were also doing intelligence work without telling the host nation? So in order to expel them you’d have to know about their actual intelligence work.
Once upon a time a relative went to school with ‘Beks’
Interesting (as i’ve siad elsewhere) how people get caotured….. whether its PService snr nanagement complaceenxy…..I just got put off by the chuckles of Wallace’s ‘Panel’ (sitting invfor the Mora) apologiesles.
Ew!
Why was a diplomatic repudiation initiated in relation to the nerve agent attack, and not for the arguably equally abhorrent attack on democracy inherent in the interference with the US Presidential election? Have or should either of these issues been raised with the United Nations? And have there been any developments giving evidence of culpability or otherwise? Is diplomacy to be seen as a diversion from reality?
Well I for one have yet to see ANY evidence of Kremlin involvement, so far all we have is “its the only logical conclusion”.. well I don’t buy that at all. given the crap going down in the USA at the moment i consider a CIA false flag operation as worthy of proper consideration.
Strawmen and hyperbole. It was the Czechs! It was the CIA! They’re all crisis actors! “Those who serve us with poison will eventually swallow it and poison themselves,” oops sorry, I slipped and Vladimir Putin’s thuggish direct threats somehow fell into the narrative by accident.
The only people who haven’t given the idea of the skripal poisonings being a CIA or UK “deep state” false-flag op “serious consideration” are the people demanding it have serious consideration.
Lots of risk, no reward unless Putin has never had a single political opponent murdered. Otherwise all they’d need to do is wait.
It says: “Not only can we poison traitors, we can brag about it, so toe the line or else!” And the target of these threats? Why, the Russian peoples and other existing military personnel.
Cf: people seeking the death penalty for Chelsea Manning.
Edit: I note that your Telegraph link reports that Kremlin thugs were convicted of murder in Qatar. So much for Putin’s assurances.
Still waiting for you to find me any spy , previous to Skripal ,who has been pardoned by the Russians and released in a spy swap who has then been killed by the Russians
Qatar:2004
Litvinenko:2006
Putin’s speech”Secret services no longer kills traitors”:2010
Abbreviated 2010 speech “traitors will choke etc” published in March 2018 to imply it was made in relation to the Skripal poisoning
OAB thinks he’s got a scoop: 29 March 2018
So blind obedience to the old Cold War propaganda recipe is a ‘comfy chair’? I am 71, read and heard all this Russian scare stuff before.. My guess is that Terrorism has now lost its bite as a fearful external enemy, and our thought masters are resurrecting the old tried, tested and proven cold war tactic. We have even just had scary news about stunning new Russian weapons. We had that bullshit all through the 50s till the late 80s. Tedious.
A metaphor about fences says what about “blind obedience”? Does the observation that the Kremlin is run by untouchable murderous kleptocrats who’ve completely compromised the British government look “comfy” to you?
You appear to be comfy with that slightly tendentious proposition. I am wary of it. Russia has always been ruled by ruthless megalomaniacs when strong. I admire the historian who called Stalin the most recent of the great Tsars, despite all the theory about revolution and class warfare. I also distrust the simplistic bullshit we get served up from a system which us far less democratic than it claims to be.
Guardian commenters will be mostly left-wing Momentum types. A bit like Lalia Harre in her views of the poisoning. Not a good guide in how to conduct foreign policy.
Even Corbyn has to had to back May to some extent, though presumably Momentumers wish he did not have to. Many of Corbyn’s Labour party MP’s have been highly critical of him on the Russia issue, but realistically they are powerless against Momentum. The British Labour Party is starting to be more like the Alliance Party of New Zealand, rather than the current NZLP.
As for there being no Russian undeclared spies In NZ, I think it is unlikely there are none, but who knows?
In some respects it is not really about undeclared spies, it is just sending someone home to make the point about solidarity. I imagine this is what most of the UK’s allies have done (but not us). Sending home one out of 17 would be no great hardship for the Russian Embassy.
We might find we are now on the slow track for a FTA with the UK.
Jacinda might have an awkward meeting or two with May and others in the UK next month. She might wish she had sent a Russian Embassy cook or driver home. Drivers are frequently spies.
Xanthe,
What fanciful conspiracy theory crap. Absolutely zero evidence for your assertion.
And if it was true, it would be fraught with enormous risk if it was discovered. It would just about destroy the US/UK relationship if it became public. Just do a risks/benefits analysis of such an operation to see whether it is even remotely plausible.
There’s an opening for you Wayne, in Northcote for the Natz, only 1 nomination if the post by James below is correct…
We all know parliament needs more lawyers (sarcasm) – one law for them, and one for everyone else.
Kinda a world trend to move everything away from people and put it into a series of lobbyist laws that have become narrower and narrower and more challenged over time by lawyers getting richer and richer, so that the public good and practicality aspects from our laws are being eroded, even if you do have enough money and time to challenge them.
The British Labour Party is starting to be more like the Alliance Party of New Zealand, rather than the current NZLP.
Which is probably good for the British and bad for NZ. It was, after all, the policies of National and the NZLP of the last few decades that have caused so much increase in poverty in this Land of Plenty. And the same goes for the UK.
We might find we are now on the slow track for a FTA with the UK.
You say that like it’s a Bad Thing when it’s the exact opposite. In fact, we should be dropping out of all exiting FTAs and the WTO and putting in place a set of standards that other countries need to meet before we will trade with them.
Make it a Race to the Top rather than the Race to the Bottom that it has been for the last 30+ years.
Well to be fair, we probably won’t be on a slow track for a FTA. Too important for both countries for this relatively minor matter to derail it.
The main consequence will a few awkward meetings. jacinda can use her charm to get through that easily enough.
The FTA with the UK really will matter. We will be aiming for tariff free entry of our foodstuffs. The UK could once again become a major market.
You do realise that New Zealand’s wealth was basically built on tariff free entry of our lamb, butter, cheese and wool to the UK from 1870 to 1970. This was the imperial preference, so it gave NZ a trade advantage above the US, South America and Europe, the other places capable of producing temperate agricultural products.
So rather than making us poorer, the tar if free entry of our products actually made us one of the most wealthy countries in the world. At the peak in the early 1950’s no 3 in living standards in the world.
Of course a 2020 FTA won’t produce quite the same effect, but it will certainly help, and will be 100% better for NZ than the EU’s highly restrictive agricultural import policy.
Britain leaving the EU is basically a net positive for NZ. We suffered a lot when they entered, we will gain as they leave.
But I guess ideology has blinded you to these rather obvious and well known facts.
You do realise that New Zealand’s wealth was basically built on tariff free entry of our lamb, butter, cheese and wool to the UK from 1870 to 1970.
You do understand that that is a load of bollocks right?
NZ wealth is our resources and our skills. If we hadn’t had that tariff free entry into the UK market we’d probably be richer as we would have been forced to develop more skills. There is, after all, only so much lamb that a small nation can eat.
But I guess ideology has blinded you to these rather obvious and well known facts.
Actually, it’s your ideology that’s blinding you to the facts.
Wayne and his ilk should be in prison for crimes** against humanity…
Having had opportunity to positively impact large numbers of those who genuinely need the most assistance…instead Wayne and his ilk simply move on with their organic being and planetary destructive indeology…
Most of everything Wayne was involved in government life has been a negative outcome against the most vulnerable…
No – I just don’t fix my ideology to the point where I get blinded by it.
i.e – I can hold two contradictory POV’s and examine them against each other to see which makes most sense rather than rejecting something out of hand because it doesn’t fit my rigid beliefs. F. Scott Fitzgerald put it well when he said –
“The test of a first-rate intelligence is the ability to hold two opposed ideas in mind at the same time and still retain the ability to function.”
“New Zealand’s wealth was basically built on tariff free entry of our lamb, butter, cheese and wool to the UK from 1870 to 1970”
You forgot to mention, Wayne, what tariffs successive NZ governments imposed on those same goods, and numerous others.
Which incidentally gave us all permanent, full time, secure jobs.
How can the utterly ideologically-driven, scared and in the pockets of those who’ve exchanged their fluids and who’ve only ever invested in propping up each other’s egos ever hope “to be fair” (going forward, ez a meta of fek, ekshuuly – even with the new found learnings of ear politikle circumstance).
Btw Wayne… how long does your current mefia gig contract last, and any plans for whennir expures?
“In fact, we should be dropping out of all exiting FTAs and the WTO and putting in place a set of standards that other countries need to meet before we will trade with them.”
That’s correct, and the way to do that is by creating the localised structures, whereby business chains for products can be established, self regulated & self represented within different industries, but not ‘needing to’ ban practises that under-cut necessarily but having them represented to the consumer for what they are in industry grading trade marks or seals that the govt provides the frameworks of, for their industries to co-ordinate in setting standards under.
And with the majority of consumers employed by such chains/organisations/guilds, they will vote with their wallets and employment interests, which whenever people have the opportunity to do so, is for higher value and quality.
That i believe, is the essence of what has economically built up, sustained & nourished the higher civilisations in the west over the centuries, despite the many historic follies or one type or another of their times.
What a pathetic response from wayne. Trying to have it all ways? Just send anyone home to appease the hawks in the British and US governments eh? Who cares who it is, the caretaker will do.
In case you have forgotten wayne, this government campaigned on transparent governance.
We are lead to understand the British government asked our government for support by way of expelling any “undeclared embassy attaches” who are suspected of intelligence activity. The government asked the NZSIS if we had any. The SIS apparently said no. I cannot see any reason why the SIS would lie about such a matter.
There are some parallels here with Helen Clark’s government who decided not to join the Coalition of the Willing when they invaded Iraq. Remember the hue and cry? I do… and many of the same faces are screaming hysterically again. Who was right? Helen Clarks’ government of course. There were no weapons of mass destruction – just a lie perpetuated by the British and American hawkes in order to get the masses on board with them.
I expect there are under-cover Russian agents in NZ. But they’re not – it would seem – directly attached to their Embassy. That would make it very difficult to flush them out. I’m sure if the SIS do manage to find them, they would be deported forthwith.
The guy never ceases to amaze, an in the abscence of 4th Estate, I guess his faux wisdom (just like that of a number of others) will go unchallenged. Or will it?
As we all now know in this day and age ofvthw 15 mins of fame and fortune and stardom
Pretty much the only thing that otivates the political class, politicians and their spin meisters, is the degree to which they sense potential embarrassment (alobgside their ability to either tolerate it or bury it.
Cynical I know but I think the record speaks for itself.
There is a level at which the politican, or the DHB Chief, or the ‘head of munstry or department’ can no longer survive
Thing is, it may well be that we’ll HAVE to resort to the dlovenly underhand nastiness opponents seem comfortable with (indeed tactics they consider normal) in order to survive I rue that day!)
Include jounalists in that first paragraph because we could include Sth Africans as members of a 4th Estate and their propensity for attraction to ‘daddy figures’ and raspy voices … even though they’re prepared to feel qualified to comment on thinga like domestic violence.
Or that ‘celebate’ thing that sits above an Eastern Suburbs sewerage plant whose no doubt familiar with its walking rracks where little Fijian BOIS claim to have had ‘encounters’….?True or False….doesn’t seem to matter.
Let’s not even begin with a Pulla BentFFS!
First up, other countries besides NZ have refused to take action. Second up, if the Guardian is a momentum shang li ra, then why the takedown of Corbyn when he called for more evidence after apparently seeing everything that had been shared with foreign governments (unprecedented amounts of info apparently).
And why the resurgent cries of antisemitism from the Guardian being leveled at Corbyn and UK Labour? Again.
The Guardian is a mouth piece for liberal interventionists. In my memory that’s been the case since Yugoslavia.
And alongside anti-Corbyn, anti-Labour, anti-Russia, we’re getting a pivot to anti-Chinese too. A piece from the other day about a purported war of human rights by Russia and China via the UN or somesuch?
Sorry I don’t have time to dig out links or take part in this exchange beyond this sole comment. There’s an ugly head of steam building behind something that would roll over anything not firmly behind western liberalism’s aggressive and interventionist stance/positioning in foreign policy and/or against domestic policies of violence via the economics of austerity.
Maybe in a day or two when I have some free time available again, I’ll look at a post on this slide the west is on.
There’s an ugly head of steam building behind something that would roll over anything not firmly behind western liberalism’s aggressive and interventionist stance/positioning in foreign policy and/or against domestic policies of violence via the economics of austerity.
Yes. The hysteria our government is currently experiencing from the Nats and their MSM acolytes (and hysteria is not too strong a word imo) over matters of a relatively trivial nature is beginning to look like it might be part of a much larger strategy encompassing most of the so-called Western world.
In other words, setting up the masses for a major international power-play that could end in nuclear war-fare.
Xanthe,
What fanciful conspiracy theory crap. Absolutely zero evidence for your assertion.
yes and thats is exactly the same amount of evidence so far raised for “the Kremlin done it” your “cost benefit” argument also works either way.
I am not arguing either case , just pointing out that the evidential standard for action is not yet met.
expelling diplomatic staff on the basis of an untested assumption is just dumb, others may do so to symbolize which “side” they are on. our government has wisely declined to do so.
There is large amount of published evidence against Russia.
They are the only ones who produce the agent, and have a track record of using it. That is the prime evidence to date.
The evidential gap is which Russian operative(S) actually deposited the agent, both when and how.
But your post makes you seem like a Russian apologist believing everything Putin says.
As for our government “wisely” declining action, well I guess that is your view. Not mine however. In my view our government has looked rather foolish and naive.
True but we should still operate on more than well, these guys made this stuff back in the early 1970s and may possibly have used it before.
Especially when you consider how easy getting hold of that 1970s stuff would have been since the collapse of the USSR and that it’s highly unlikely that they’d still be using it.
Plus the nature of the target.
Plus the track record of similar people being murdered.
Plus the comments of putin & co.
Plus the tenuous nature of anyone else’s motive vs the risks to them if it backfires.
if you are going by court of law analogies then there is more than one piece of circumstantial evidence.
Russia is the only one known to produce said agent, the targeted individual was a known associate and critic of Russia and Russia has a track record of this sort of thing.
Once the circumstantial evidence mounts what is more likely? It is a false flag which requires more variables to succeed as a case or was it Russia which needs less variables. In scientific theory the theory that requires less variables is dominant over that which requires more. In the court of law it is similar in that simpler the explanation which has the most evidence is more often than not the case.
You’re quite simply wrong
Iran managed to synthesise it in late 2016 under the auspices of the OPCW, which indicates it is possible for countries other than Russia to do the same
Skripal was not a critic of Russia. He was paid good money to betray it
It has been reported that he missed Russia and wanted to return
He visited the Russian Embassy in London every month
I will supply links if you like
Wayne, your published evidence please
This is the first time that Novichok has been used as an assassination attempt.
please link to your assertion Wayne.
It has killed one Russian chemist accidentally , and may or may not have been used by Russian gangsters against a Russian banker and his secretary. That remains purely hearsay as no chemicals in that case were analysed
The Soviet Union developed it, if they weaponised it, no one knows
The Soviet Union is not Russia
Uzbekistan anyone ?
The US decommissioning the Novichok facility in the 1990s?
Soviet chemists decamping to the west with all their knowledge and experience?
Seriously Wayne, it beggars belief that you are unaware of this
Several countries have had access to it
Iran under the auspices of the OPCW managed to synthesise it in late 2016
It is not uniquely Russian
Does all of your info come from newspapers and television?
Pointing out facts should never be the trigger to calling someone an apologist of any order
well according to my reading wayne ANY half decent lab with suitably qualified technicians could make this stuff and interestingly inorder for the poms to correctly identify the nerve agent they would have to possess an identical match !!!
Wayne
Don’t you think Putin would have done a cost/benefit analysis of his own?
Putin and his administration are not stupid. If you think they are I seriously doubt your intelligence on these matters
A cost/benefit analysis done by the Kremlin would quickly have shown that the target and poison chosen would have at first glance pointed to the Kremlin, and would have inevitably put at risk Nordstream 2, the World cup, the Astana group negotiations, and the exposure to OPCW investigations that would negate Russia’s much lauded destruction of chemical weapons in 2017.
I for one would be extremely proud if NZ was to regain its reputation as an honest broker in international affairs.
Why even pay lip service to the rule of law if we are prepared to deliver the verdict and divvy out the punishment before the investigation is complete?
I am glad we had a Labour govt headed by a feisty female PM that refused to “join the club” in Iraq in 2003
Who knows how long Jacinda and Winston can hold out against the pressures that are being brought to bear on them.
But I applaud them for their stand
Their “stand” is that they’re looking at sanctions and travel bans against a range of individuals because there’s no plausible alternative explanation other than Kremlin involvement.
The Kremlin isn’t being “stupid”, by the way – punishments have to be consistent, and in the case of traitors, harsh. These are practical measures to enforce discipline.
Spare me your disbelief and smears upon my character or cognitive abilities – I’ll take them as read.
And this would be another first.
The spy swap program has always left ex spies off limits
Keeping it that way is to everyones interests
A breach means the collapse of the system, and it’s never been done before
I challenge you to show me where a spy who has been swapped and pardoned has then been knocked off, it is most definitely not consistent
Russian security services also denied involvement when a former separatist president of Chechnya, Zelimkhan Yandarbiyev, was killed in a bomb explosion in Qatar in 2004, but two Russian intelligence agents were convicted in Qatar and later returned to Russia
Putin said “traitors”. The Kremlin doesn’t regard Chechen fighters as traitors?
Other analysis, mind you, has it that the Kremlin doesn’t have control over its various factions, who will often take unilateral actions in attempts to curry favour. A bit like running a crime family, I suppose.
I’ve been struck particularly by the way the Kremlin often comes across like Pauli Walnuts when discussing these matters. “Who knows what happened to your face? Maybe you fell over. Better be more careful next time.”
On the basis of relative western inaction in the past on things like the invasion of Georgia, retaking Crimea, supporting Ukrainian separatists, supplying the missiles that shot down MH17, killing agents with polonium and nerve agents, interfering in elections, cyber attack against Estonia, he would have assumed no real reaction this time. In short he assumed he would get away with it, just as he had before.
I think this attack proved to be a straw that broke the camels back, just one too many annoying things that he has done, especially after the interference in both the US and the French elections.
It won’t result in war or anything like that, but it will mean a deep distrust of Putin and his circle. Will he want to reverse that?
Who knows, but historically Russia has not always been on the outer. For much of the nineteenth century they were valued allies, the Crimea war excepted.
Really!! Sanctions that have reduced economic growth, being kicked off the G8, the Mistral deal reneged on,Bulgaria heavied in to blocking south stream, the pain of Russian paraplegics as a group and other athletes not allowed to compete under their own flag, and the relentless and quite unhinged vilifications
I’m not even going to bother with the Russia meddled theme, it seems to be Cambridge Analytica after all…the upper levells of Brit society
Russia interfered in the French elections?
Do tell …France says otherwise
I doubt he did a cost/ benefit analysis Wayne.
More likely he just did a macho man ego who are my whorshippers analysis.
Not to dissimilar from you ( or indeed a Hosking). Only difference being you did it under ther cover of being a mild mannered plonker whose managed to capture the 4th Estate into believing you’re fair and readobsblw. A bit like the Fair and balanced routine.
KEEP the chummy smarm up will you… it’ll ensure you continue to be a media rent-a-voice on Sundays alongside that thing called Boag…. and probably even a Wilson.
Apologies if I confuse a Q+A with a NATION.
they’ll consider me a philistine as they knock back a toast or two to the day’s achievement.
Geez Wayne! I’d thought you’d be all for making a buck and resume trade with Russia. What would 4 eyes say? We trade with China, and there not Lilly white.
yeah, Chuck, he was just so damned keen to out the highly secretive and illegal Novichok program that he’d kept under wraps, for the past 10 years, evading the gimlet eyes of the OPCW who were crawling all over Russia’s facilities.
Phew! he thought, got away with it, the bastards will never know, and here’s me with a clean slate.
Less than 6 months later….I’ve got a good idea , lets knock off that used up spy Skripal we pardoned yonks ago, and we’ll use Novichok to send a message to Europe and the US that a floundering UK needs to be rallied around and supported
That’ll show em!
And the World cup and Nordstream? fuckem, I just want to see the look on their faces
I guess Putin in his heart of hearts wanted to get caught, eh?
We might find the UK is still leaving Europe and still on the lookout for trading partners, even ones that don’t habitually obey her in foreign policy matters, wayney.
Thanks for the pull up Marco … I must have had May subconsciously connected to Paula Hanson …. another disgusting politician.
Of course I meant theresa may …. who interestingly enough is friendly with the NZ connected Legatum stink tank … having spoken in front of the hypocrites.
The Legatum charade is a think tank that has been pumping out anti-russia propaganda for a while now https://pando.com/2015/05/17/neocons-2-0-the-problem-with-peter-pomerantsev/ ” Legatum turns out to be a project of the most secretive billionaire vulture capital investor you’ve (and I’d) never heard of: Christopher Chandler, a New Zealander who, along with his billionaire brother Richard Chandler, ran one of the world’s most successful vulture capital funds”
I call Legatum a charade because they produce this ” prosperity index” … where they rank countries.
But the New Zealand funders and founders run their business / vulture funds from tax havens like Dubai ….
Which makes them like traders in kiddie porn lecturing people about child abuse ,,,,
As Oxfam has correctly pointed out Tax havens, shadow banking and their corruption are the biggest drivers of poverty and inequality in the world.
So Legatum is a stink tank as opposed to think Tank …
Whats the difference between a vulture and a vulture fund Marco ???
A vulture fund is worse and actually makes the food for the vultures …
Why the issue of UNDECLARED spies amongst the diplomats.
This.
“Colonel Skripal was convicted of passing the identities of Russian intelligence agents working UNDERCOVER in Europe to the UK’s Secret Intelligence Service, MI6.”
Thing is, our SIS does not know of any here (and if they did they are not silly enough to say they do so they get replaced by someone they do not know about – unlike the so called smart guys overseas who think they know better).
Intrustung the riddle little blubble that follows… rspeshlillyvant
Ex one labours under the lek o toim stemps and othe info the sage has omittedn ez relevant going forwid (or wid out)
A bit ssssprizing tho a prents own parna rwcently visited slightly less remoteness on mutha Erf to locationas on the GPS spatial plam I did
Maybe herein lies the tensions and elitism claims thst exist between a Prent TS AND A bradbury TDB.
MAY I SAY TO YOU BOTH how utterly fuvkkng gorgeus you BOTH are.
Goes without saying to your dedication to the very broad leff principills
Goes without saying that indupitably, indisoutavly, absoluterry there’s an overweighr inyoletant piece of blubber that happens to be the whurl’s bestest developerer of computer thingies ( and modest with it).
The beauty of the fishinsy an fektivness of his code is a thing to behold
Wel obsly, ya ken orl C the phet fungas en remote intermittance (that’s even been known to corrupt the character set).
Or maybe not.
Interesting times as I watch the policy ANALists from a dysfunctional PS Srutting their shit as forcibly as their future career patterns aĺlow them, and their seniors worrying about what and how their new munsters will be satisfied with the advice requested of ‘officials’…. JUST enough to look to be in tune with the new Munster, though not enough to be obstructive of any new policy or the pteservarion of a Statiss Kwo.
I have looked at the pattern of “beat-ups” occurring and have become convinced they are all “Look over here” strategies by the opposition to distract from their serious past misdemeanors.
Almost “False news”, as the importance is magnified by the style of reporting.
The coalition is moving fast on many fronts, and the opposition have wanted to paint Jacinda as “muddled indecisive and not in control of her troops.”
Everything that has happened has had that same response.
It is orchestrated and there must be an opposition group planning for this, like a web.
What finally convinced me DP is again alive and well, was reading that Griffin had rung Lee before he published Hurshfield’s resignation.
I wonder who Ms Lee informed? And why? Just saying.
DP never died, Slater was a loose cannon, Hooten/Farrar/Eade/Williams etc all still at it and it’s up to the govt to own the narrative over the damage done by 3 terms of nact.
You’ve looked at all the incompetence and misbehaviour and concluded that the only reason for it all is that it’s been pointed out and highlighted and publicised?
You have terrific powers of deduction.
I suppose Minister Salesa has a national plant in her staff booking her the hotels in the good end of town and business class flights everywhere to make her look bad?
But draco gave you three internet points, so you must on to something.
I watched “The Hollow Men “again last night, along with the 20 minute interview with Nicky Hager
Its co ordinated alright , it has all the hallmarks , and our media is even less “big picture” than before, running like yapping dogs to the next beat up scandal of their own making.
Never asking the big questions and generally serving right wing interests
patricia bremner if your idea of DP is that the media or the opposition should not react to the incompetent bumbling of this current Government, then you will forever be outraged.
The opposition does not have any misdemeanours they need to cover up.
In case you have not noticed, National is simply doing what opposition’s are supposed to do. Holding the government to account. In this instance ably assisted by numerous government faux pas.
The difference to past oppositions is that there is 56 of them, with lots of parliamentary resource (the staff including research staff are proportional to their size). So they can do way more than an opposition of say 27 MP’s.
Perhaps the Easter break will give the government a chance to sort itself out.
The opposition does not have any misdemeanours they need to cover up.
Finlayson breaking the law is probably something that they wish would go away and National’s Dirty Politics seems to be working there.
We’re definitely not seeing any calls for criminal charges to be laid, an investigation or even his resignation. Instead we get the beat up about Clare Curran blown up out of all proportion.
So, yeah, after being found to have broken the law in his capacity as AG I would expect him to resign at the very least as he’s obviously not fit for the position. I would prefer that criminal charges be brought against him and those he worked with.
No, better have a 3 month reveiw first. make sure all the process are perfect and bow down to expert knowledge. Need to be sure he actually has broken the law
… and dead Three year old children among the broken bodies of Civilians …. with Waynes bloody palm prints at the crime scene … or just at the cover up ?
Also before this warmonger Mapp was calling for any inquiry … there was a well coordinated and scripted smear campaign going on against Nicky Hager … it was almost identical to the one used against Jeremy Scahill …. when he exposed usa night raids in Afghanistan … killing pregnant women etc
Mapp was always going to kill children on the road he took us on.
What has he ever said about Nick Hager here on ‘ The Standard ‘??? … google that
And historians will pronounce upon that failure, hopefully in ringing terms of denunciation. The poets, including the songwriters, will have their turn, as well.
I think of the Rois Faléants of the Merovingian Dynasty in France in such times- the Do-Nothing Kings.
Or the Grand Old Duke of York whose military skills and decisiveness are still mocked in children’s rhymes.
Or that great Scottish ballad , “Flowers of Scotland”, where the English are told to go home and “think again.” As the National Party too has been told.
The judgment of history will not be kind in social histories written about this period. I hope I’m alive to read them……..
And in answer, Stuart Munro,to your 6.3 above, For why? So that the rich would pay less tax.
It’s all about priorities, and why people prioritise the way they do- from laziness, to carelessness, to narcissism to full-blown sociopathy; or from compassion, concern for justice, and humanitarian inclusiveness.
In fact if we assessed the Gnats by the ancient code of Ma’at, which considerably predates Ramses, they’re an abject failure:
4. I have not caused terror, nor have I worked affliction;
5. I have caused none to feel pain, nor have I worked grief;
6. I have done neither harm nor ill, nor I have caused misery;
7. I have done no hurt to man, nor have I wrought harm to beasts;
8. I have made none to weep;
9. I have had no knowledge of evil, neither have I acted wickedly, nor have I wronged the people;
10. I have not stolen, neither have I taken that which does not belong to me, nor that which belongs to another, nor have I taken from the orchards, nor snatched the milk from the mouth of the babe;
11. I have not defrauded, neither I have added to the weight of the balance, nor have I made light the weight in the scales;
12. I have not laid waste the plowed land, nor trampled down the fields;
13. I have not driven the cattle from their pastures, nor have I deprived any of that which was rightfully theirs;
Or these for our Gnats.
23. I have caused no wrong to be done to the servant by his master;
24. I have not been angry without cause;
25. I have not turned back water at its springtide, nor stemmed the flow of running water;
26. I have not broken the channel of a running water;
27. I have never fouled the water, nor have I polluted the land;
“National has no misdemeanors to cover up” LOL LOL Best laugh of the week.
National’s Attorney General found guilty of breaching Dotcom’s privacy, and refusing him his personal information…. leading to a $90 000 payment to Dotcom, and giving grounds for further litigation……
I accept there are more “soldiers on the ground” Wayne. It is how they fight….. a bit like the Aussie cricket team…. “must win at all costs” bugger democracy!!
Skripal’s poisoning may have been aimed at destabilising Corbyn’s poll momentum by reviving cold war phobia, catching the Ardern government in its wake.
Never waste a classic response, but can fear and dread be sustained until the election ?
The Ardern government can ride it out but it will be an interesting shake-down cruise testing resilience, teamwork, judgement .. and a young mum.
“Personal attacks”?
I realise that you are a bit upset about yesterday adam but when you make such an absolute idiot of yourself as you did then it is only to be expected that people may point out that you are talking rubbish.
You would be far better to follow Mark Twains advice
“It is better to keep your mouth closed and let people think you are a fool than to open it and remove all doubt”.
Yesterday you removed all doubt.
Your a low life alwyn, you discredited and lied about people yesterday, and did not even have the decency to own up to your own lies and spin . Because let’s start being honest, spin these these days from Tory hacks who infest the internet are just lies – clever lies, but still lies all the same. You spent the whole day defending a lie to discredit people.
So maybe if you acted with some respect towards human beings who have served the community for 40+ years. I wouldn’t have to call you piece of *&^% that you are.
There, there.
As far as I can see the only people I might have been even the slightest condemnatory to were the people shown, on TV3, in the gaggle of people at the protest yesterday who were described as blocking an Emergency exit from the TSB Arena.
Surely you weren’t one of them? And surely you don’t think that that is an acceptable way to behave? The penny drops. You were blocking the door and you do think that is an acceptable way to behave. No wonder I am not your favourite person.
Not to worry. I shall try and have a look over the weekend to see whether it was a door that can be used for an emergency exit from the Arena premises. Would you like me to tell you my conclusion?
Oh, a window can be used as an emergency exit.
Just show us the signage that the protestors should have seen. To distinguish it from any old back door polluters might want to sneak out of.
I had dinner last night with a friend who has worked for the Fire Service. He says, and his statement is hard to argue with, that anyone who blocks any access from a building so that people on the inside can get out in an emergency is crazy. It doesn’t matter in the slightest whether it is marked from the outside or not.
After all, as you say, people will use a window if necessary.
The only place that signage is desirable to point to exits is inside the building for the benefit of people trying to escape. People on the outside should NEVER block exits, marked or unmarked, that would allow people inside the building to get out.
In his opinion the people who blocked up a door, any door, so that people couldn’t get out from inside in an emergency were, as I noted above, crazy.
I will still have a look over the weekend but I really don’t see that any protester can argue that it was excusable to prevent people getting out of the building because they didn’t put up a sign saying I shouldn’t.
I suppose you would say I can let off fireworks inside a building. I’ve never seen a sign telling me that I shouldn’t.
So now you’ve set the field for it to be a crime against humanity regardless of whether the dickheads knew the single-width door around the back (next to two freight doors) was a fire exit for a 500-person conference centre, you believe that blocking that exit compromised the safety of everyone inside (even with all the double-width crash doors running the length of the building around the front). Your commitment to workplace safety is commendable, and no doubt you will be wondering why the building wasn’t evacuated due to the imminent danger.
Of course, this is irrelevant to whether tv3 were adding a bit of creativity when they called it a “fire exit”.
I’m pleased to see that at least you class the people who blocked the doorway as being “dickheads”.
The rest is contemptible.
Were you a little embarrassed by the fact that you didn’t notice that the google earth photos you thought proved your case were in fact more that 3 years old?
Don’t be. I didn’t see it myself for at least 20 seconds.
Meanwhile I hope you don’t block doors from the outside in the future. Earthquakes and fires can happen any time.
Is “dickhead” substantively different from the “dicks” I called them two days ago?
The protestors’ actions weren’t going to trap anyone inside if there was a fire or earthquake in that instant. On your wee recon trip tomorrow, count all the other exits around the building, “fire” or just general.
The protestors were dicks because the pile of pallets served no purpose, they had enough people to cordon the building and see if anyone was sneaking out the back (yeah, it has happened before in the days of decent campus protests).
The pile did, however, give 3news the opportunity to give you guys something other than fossil fuel use and climate change to talk about. Now you’re quibbling over Streetview datestamps because fire exits in fixed structures are known for suddenly changing /sarc
So did you bother checking out the supposed “fire exit” on Saturday like you said you would? Or should we just figure that the streetview images were still pretty much the state of play and 3news iced the cake a bit much?
Oh, there you are, adam. Talking about taking bets, that reminded me that I have been meaning to ask you how things are going with your prediction at 4.2 on Open Mike on 22 March.
In response to savenz’s provision at 4 of a link to an article re US Treasury Secretary Mnuchin saying that the US will consider re-entering TPP, you said at 4.2 that:
As I said, by the end of March the USA will be back in.
It’s now 29 March, so only a few days to go to the end of March. Shall we take bets or have a countdown?
Washington DC is currently 17 hours behind NZ but this falls back to 16 hours at 2am on Sunday, 1 April in NZ with the end of Daylight saving. So midnight on Saturday, 31 March in Washington DC is 4pm on Sunday, 1 April in NZ. That is just under 75 hours from now.
My prediction is that those “goals on its other trading relationships” are going to take a very, very long time – years, and probably never as long as Trump is President.
PS – And as you can see, I am trying to engage – as you told me to do back in February.
You may be right. Perhaps you think I should follow the example given in this comment. He is demonstrating that you should only think kind things about your fellow man.
And where exactly in there did I go around claiming that an MP had incontinence and criticising someone on that basis?
Don’t dissemble away from the fact that your statements aren’t acceptable.
“the 59 psychopathic brainwashed bastards known as the National Party MPs “.
Could you demonstrate, to at least a reasonable level of certainty that they were ALL psychopathic individuals. Signed diagnoses by qualified and registered Psychiatrists (or should it be Psychologists?) who have examined each of them would seem to be required.
Also can you please prove that in every case their parents were not married? Otherwise I must assume that they were just wild claims with not the slightest hint of truth to them.
But you know that don’t you?
I am very much in favour of the sack everyone approach, and the nationalise everything approach. This is mostly because weaker options repeatedly fail.
+1 Kereru – just ignore it , or do a Natz are get the media in a lather with fake news about your rivals. In the case of the Natz, any scandal is probably is not fake.
Also be normal. Say the previous government left the country in a horrible state with mouldy hospitals, public services in disarray, democracy on the decline and biohazards… and the governments priority is to concentrate on that….
I think the destabilising of the Govt is opposition priority and it appears to be aiming at Jacinda like a juggernaut. I hope that she has seen the tv bit where Kieran Read is advising the warriors on what to do when play gets a bit disjointed and out of sorts. His advice was just to stop and breathe and clear your mind and reset. Good advice and it worked for the Warriors. I hope she keeps on believing in herself ands not give in to the baying hybrid terriers across tbe room. Most of them are incompetents who ate just there to say their lines. Govt should have a pushback for any accusation delivered by Si et am. Goodness knows there is plenty of dirt there. All they have is the battering ram approach which will eventually show them up to be totally bereft of any ideas as shown in last 9 years. Bullying is ugly and does nobody any favours. Stay serene and classy Jacinda. And breathe!
To Ffloyd at * : + 1000 and I know our P.M. is well able to cope with the onslaught. I have disdain though to those who would add to her burdens, in particular those involved in DP.
Sam, Constant unremitting attacks for every little thing from MSM and National quarters echoing each other is telling. Similar tone and content, full of words which lead to innuendo. Mostly nasty.
Heather Grimwood, being the PM of a country is not for the faint of heart. If you want Ardern wrapped up in cotton wool then you better suggest to her a change of occupation.
Finally some sense in the legal system… climate change has gone from being in the domain of climate denialisms to actually being taking seriously as an issue in the legal system.
Didn’t the Natz changed the law to have the special courts for oil exploration?Interesting to see how it goes.
Increasingly citizens are having to deal with environmental issues themselves legally aka Sarah Thompson and all around the world, as inexplicably government lawmakers feel it is irrelevant and profits is the only thing of importance than long term survival of resources.
From Greenpeace
“This is huge! 13 people were arrested protesting construction of a fracked-gas pipeline because of its contribution to climate change. Yesterday, the judge agreed the climate crisis made their actions a legal necessity—and set them free. This is unprecedented. And relevant now in NZ as Greenpeace NZ’s Russel Norman prepares to head to court next month to defend charges brought against him and Greenpeace for a protest at sea against oil exploration on similar grounds.”
This report that a judge aquitted people because of climate change seemed so unlikely that I checked reports on the case. In fact Greenpeace was wrong. The legal necessity point was never able to argued in front of the judge. They were not convicted but for other reasons, basically they had not really affected the pipeline construction.
“It does not matter what is true, it only matters what people believe is true.”
“Paul Watson (a Greenpeace founder) attributes this quote to Dr. Patrick Moore, another Greenpeace founder, in 1981. Others have attributed it to Paul Watson or to David McTaggert (yet another founder of Greenpeace). Either way it was frequently said by the leaders of the organization. It has been sort of a mantra for them. ” https://andymaypetrophysicist.com/greenpeace-crimes-and-lies-2/
If it was a nasty Russian nerve poison used, why did it take such a long time to act? Since it reportedly causes instant death how could father and daughter have travelled from home to go for a coffee in town? And they still live. (Police say now that the greatest concentration was at their front door.)
Be devastating if it was not the Russian poison. It would leave NZ as above the chaos (though one Bridges would somehow claim victory for him) and where would it leave May?
It causes instant death? I’m sure you checked before saying so, but I just wonder whether you can provide a source for your assertion. Just in case for example, the systemic effects can be delayed by up to eighteen hours or something.
I believe that the news report was that the poison written about is skin touch instant death. Of course I don’t know the detail but I am just wondering if the whole issuen is genuine. If not….
If you mean “instant death”, I don’t think so. From reading other material, I’ve come to the conclusion that one of the reasons this particular nerve agent was used is that it provides for a very painful slow death with maximum humiliation inflicted. People experience terrifying hallucinations and lose control of their bodily functions.
Colonel Skripal will have been under no illusions as to what was happening to himself and his daughter, just as Alexander Litvenenko was given weeks to contemplate his inevitable death.
Lots of context to consider. Especially if, as alleged, the Kremlin continues to maintain chemical weapon R&D and production facilities. So the Skripals et al may have been poisoned by something newer than the existing knowledge about “Novichok”.
But broadly speaking, based on what I’ve seen in news reports, yes.
Table 5.1 says “Inhaled: seconds to minutes
Skin contact: minutes to hours” for nerve agents as a class.
Inhalation is quicker because it’s a more direct and higher volume path to the bloodstream and distribution throughout the body. Because that’s exactly what the lungs are supposed to do. Whereas skin is a protective barrier.
But there’s often an argument about the phrase “instant death” between medics who might see a significant window of opportunity to save the life of an unresponsive patient and those people who are simply interested in the practicality of when that patient becomes unresponsive and generally stops moving.
edit: and the varying timeframes will be mostly related to dose and individual physiology (e.g. exercising when dosed = stronger blood flow = quicker poison distribution).
The Galapagos are one of the world’s last havens for wildlife — pristine islands where giant tortoises, blue-footed boobies, and penguins live as they have for thousands of years.
But tourism and development have recently skyrocketed, destroying the home of animals and plants found nowhere else on the planet — leaving many species on the brink of extinction.
Basically their habitat being destroyed to make way for all the hotels and so forth for the tourists to come and see the endangered native species…
Yeah – Completely full of himself – never understood what the Green Party actually stands for. I wonder if he had ever read the charter?
Fits into the Nat Party profile perfectly.
“Im guessing he knows more about the Green party and what it stands for than yourself.”
Except he had to leave the party because he was working against what the party was and wanted, so I wouldn’t see him as a good source of what the GP is or should be. Better to see him for what he is, a RW greenie who wanted the GP to form governments with National.
I’d take Macro’s views on the GP more seriously than Tava’s, on the basis of what each of them has said and done.
Fwiw, when he was pushing his agenda in the Greens, I engaged openly with him online and only later realised that he really did want the GP to form govt with National. He wasn’t honest about that at the time. That alone is a big red flag. He is way better suited to being with National.
I’ve never spoken to him. But the way I have read it was that (in his view) the green should be “open” to working with any party of it achieved some of the GP goals.
The Greens are open to working with any party, that is both history and current position. The Greens will work with any party where there is shared policy.
Tava wanted the Greens to actively open the way to working with National by supporting them to govt via C/S or coalition. The problem with that is there is very little shared policy, so it would mean losing a whole bunch of LW voters for very little useful policy gain. No-one in the Greens wants to do that. It’s not a matter of being aligned with Labour, it’s a matter of which parties align with GP policy and principles?
I know that there are righties that want the GP to support a Nat govt because they want the Nats to be more environmental. But the Nats aren’t, that is the whole point. Key’s govt was the antithesis what the Greens are doing and there is no middle ground on which to meet unless National changes.
Far better for people like Tava to be in National and try and make changes there and then potentially down the line the two parties might work on policy together again. Hard to see coalition or C/S on the horizon though.
Tava will misrepresent the Greens because that’s how he does politics. This is another reason why he shouldn’t be in the Greens. I would have far more respect for him even as a National MP if he wasn’t doing that.
Hey Robert – Im making an effort on my post not to try and start flame wars.
Your petty snide comments are the kind of thing that simply encourage it (or indeed start it)
Yes I was out by one on the Rugby results – WOW! big deal yet you seem to be fixated on it.
I dont think I said National would win – I was always comfortable that they were going to get a lot more votes than Labour.
What I think I said was that NZF would go with National. And yep – I got that one right. Then came on here – admitted I was wrong and congratulated Labour on the win – yet (again) you are petty and keep raising it like its a huge thing.
So how about you try to raise your game as well and comment on the points huh?
Relax, James; there’s no shame in being completely wrong.
Try to enter into the spirit of things here; you’re amongst friends (just taihoa on the pronouncements, see, we don’t rate your ‘reckons”
Just reposting this extract By Donna Miles… in the context of is this the society we want to become???
“If you want to get a feel for how far economic markets can encroach on our everyday lives then you can do no better than to read Michael Sandel’s book on this very subject, titled: “What Money Can’t Buy: The Moral Limits Of The Markets”.
Sandel, a professor of government at Harvard University, offers many examples that clearly demonstrate how market thinking can easily cross the moral line and lead to shocking degradation of societal values.
Sandel mentions the “dead peasants” insurance policies.
Imagine taking out a life insurance policy on a person totally unrelated to you.
A lawsuit in the US revealed that Walmart had hundreds of thousands of such policies on its employees and enjoyed a small windfall whenever one of them died.
And how about the “viaticals”? A new market, where investors can invest in buying out life insurance policies of people with Aids.
Aids sufferers taking part in this scheme are offered a cash lump sum as well as payments for their treatment until they die- after which, the investors receive the full value of their life policy.
Sandel’s examples are not limited to the insurance industry. Students in the UK were encouraged by an advertising agency to rent out their foreheads for about $8 NZ dollars per hour for a temporary tattooed advertising space.
A single mother auctioned off her forehead for a permanently tattooed advertising space to pay for her son’s education. The winning bid, Sandel says, came from an online casino.
There is a charity that invites donors to contribute to reducing the birth of children to drug and alcohol addicted women by offering 300 US dollars cash incentive for every female addict willing to get sterilized.
And if you are a prisoner in Santa Barbara in California, you can pay to upgrade your cell for 82 US dollars per night.
You see, in a market society, there is almost nothing money cannot buy.”
“And how about the “viaticals”?”
Most of the things you mention sound appalling but I am not sure about this one.
If you had no dependents who deperately needed the money from your life insurance policy why not sell it?
Remember the old saw about “‘Do you want to be the richest corpse in the graveyard”?
I think that forfeiting wealth after you die to get the benefit of the money for treatment now could be a very sensible choice.
Two possible reasons.
The first is that I meant this as a single phrase
“If you had no dependents who deperately needed the money”.
If your kids have grown up and are all in successful careers they no longer need money from you. You can give up on the Life Insurance you used to require. However you may have chosen to keep it.
The second is that you may have taken insurance when you were young, or got married, because you might need the cover in the future and weren’t sure you would be able to get it at a later time. If you go back to my era that would be whole of life as the term insurance wasn’t as readily available.
Either way you could have historical policies that aren’t needed now but could still exist.
Just clarifying the Walmart insurance, its wasnt for its everyday staff, just high level employees.
Just as you cant insure someone elses car ( you dont have an insurable interest) you only insure senior employees who you can show their death will affect your business.
That sounds rather more reasonable.
It really isn’t that different from a company insuring the two principals in a small jointly owned business. If one dies the money will pay out the widow, or family , of that person. It is much simpler than keeping the ownership shared between the active, surviving, partner and the silent partner ownership of someone who doesn’t know that much about the business but has inherited half the shares.
If you think some of that is sounding depraved… taking out insurance on your employees so you make money when they die…. make a submission ….. I guess in the single mother’s case, what to do if your WINZ payments are not enough.
NZ needs the right to make it’s own rules about the society it wants, not have subtle and unsubtle pressure to go in a market driven direction where anything goes…
Ecuador says they took Jule’s internet connection off him because Spain was pissed off over him putting his oar into the Catalan dispute.
/ QUITO, Ecuador (AP) — Ecuador’s government said Wednesday it has cut off WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange’s internet connection at the nation’s London embassy after his recent activity on social media decrying the arrest of a Catalan separatist politician.
In a statement, officials said Assange’s recent posts “put at risk” the good relations Ecuador maintains with nations throughout Europe and had decided as of Tuesday to suspend his internet access “in order to prevent any potential harm.”
In response to allegations reported in the stuff article below, is it now time to shed some additional light into the spread of Palantir’s activities within NZ which seem to be shrouded in a lot of secrecy still?;
And given Peter Thiel’s and Facebook’s alleged links to Cambridge Analytica, is it time that ministers of the NZ Government review seriously the past approval of NZ citizenship to Mr Thiel, and the associated approval of land purchases within our country?
Don’t worry. Mr Shaw has succeeded in meeting your wish.
As of about 3 weeks after the census we have only recorded about 3.5 million people in the country. That’s if I remember accurately what last weekend’s paper said.
That is a drop in the recorded population of the country of about 10 times the population of Dunedin. I’m sure you will be pleased.
Alwyn, you keep on sowing these seeds of distrust.
“We expect at least a 70 percent online response and combined with paper forms, the total response rate is anticipated to be well above 90 percent and on a par with previous censuses,” 2018 Census general manager Denise McGregor said.
…
“Response rates from all regions of New Zealand are tracking well as we head into the final follow-up period for the census.”
I have no idea of those newspaper items you are referring to because you have not provided a single link. As for your memory, I do worry about your reading comprehension, your biased way of ‘arguing’, your single-minded bashing of Labour and particularly the Greens, and your obsessive-compulsive erecting of strawmen and then burning them. To paraphrase your quote: “is this really necessary?”.
Are you going to claim I was exaggerating because I said “spending $27,000 or so” and it was only $26,712?
As far as the carbon goes even a single passenger from Wellington to Paris generates 15.8 tonne in Business class. I believe there was another person along so it really should be doubled. https://co2.myclimate.org/en/portfolios?calculation_id=1114198
There, does that satisfy your thirst for knowledge?
Thank you for the link to the Stuff article, which was very informative. However, as far as I can tell it did not include the key piece of information regarding the anticipated total response rate at the end of the census data collection period, which is had not yet ended, which could (would?) have corrected your comment @ 17.1, which turns out to be baseless:
That is a drop in the recorded population of the country of about 10 times the population of Dunedin.
As to your other comments regarding James Shaw and you exaggerating, I have already told you that your strawman is on fire. But you already know this, don’t you?
“which turns out to be baseless”.
Rubbish. In places where I mentioned the population I carefully said “recorded population”. I said
“we have only recorded about 3.5 million” and “drop in the recorded population” and finally “two weeks AFTER census date they have accounted for about 3.46 million”.
Those statements were all accurate. That is all that they have so far accounted for.
I cannot remember in previous occurrences of the census that they had to keep trying to get information and having to take out forms for months after the actual day.
They sent everyone forms in the past. They sent people, lots and lots of people, out to collect them in the week or two after the day. They weren’t left with only a few people trotting out with forms and trying to track down at least a quarter of the population ages after census day. I don’t remember the collection period being measured in many months. Memory says they collected ours within a week. Perhaps those people were expected to cost more. At least the results would have some similarity to reality.
The organisation of this years version was a shambles and Shaw has to wear the blame for not making sure that it could work. He can’t claim it wasn’t him. Meanwhile he was off at a talkfest on the other side of the world.
Please God the same people aren’t allowed to try and put the election on line.
Do you really believe the first statement you made?
“As far as I know this was the first Census that could be completed online”.
Oh dear. For your information.
“In 2006, New Zealand was one of the first countries in the world to test-run an online census. There was a seven per cent online completion rate.”
and
“By the 2013 census, just over a third of New Zealanders – 34 per cent – took part online”
These are both from https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/101266340/onlinefirst-census-to-revamp-unsustainable-pen-and-paper-model
You appear to have linked to it but not bothered to have read it.
They were simply trying to save money on this census and thought they could get away with only supplying forms for people who contacted them to ask for the forms. Naturally a hell of a lot of people who were going to need them didn’t do so.
They also didn’t provide id numbers to a lot of people. Retirement homes were a particular problem.
Now, even when they do get hold of uncounted people they are going to have to remember who was actually in the house on Census day. In a lot of homes, and flats, that isn’t actually as easy as it sounds as the days, and weeks, and shortly months tick away.
The Stats department are desperately trying to catch up. Even now they are making statements about “the total response rate is anticipated to be well above 90 percent “. It has been historically about 98% in recent censuses. When I see “well above 90%” I don’t think 98%. I think about 93% is what he means.
They have stuffed up and stuffed up badly.
The real shame is that it will affect the low-income areas as services to places often depend on the numbers counted in the census and I think they will be disproportionally omitted.
I suspect in another month or to there will be an unannounced forced resignation or two from the Stats Department.
The “interesting” aspects of this whole sorry saga from my perspective, apart from the obvious goodwill towards the victims and desire to see justice done, are the reasons the British government cannot go after all the laundered property in London, rather than this rather feeble stand.
For if they go after Kremlin-laundered cash in London, then that is a much larger can of worms involving far more individuals from far more nations.
Fully Informed? Labour’s 2017 promises raised expectations that were little short of revolutionary. Unfortunately, they were never adequately shaken through the fiscal sieve. The hard economic work was not done – and it shows. Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern’s critics have long complained that her grasp of the way the New ...
You cannot expect to pound communities into the ground day after day, year after year, decade after decade and just expect them to take it lying down. There’s a point at which the place will explode. And we’re faced with some very big ructions on both sides of the Atlantic ...
Back in May, Destiny Church leaders Brian and Hannah Tamaki launched another political party. Despite consisting entirely of followers of their religion, they grandly called it "Coalition New Zealand", in a vain effort to suggest it was something broader. But when they applied for registration, submitters opposed the name, as ...
The following article is excerpted and translated from two articles in recent issues of Lutte de Classe (Class Struggle), the magazine of Lutte Ouvrière (Workers Struggle), the revolutionary workers group active in France. We don’t necessarily agree with everything in it – for instance, the 1956-62 war for independence involved rather more revolutionary forces than ...
The Pacific is on the front line of climate change, and if we don't cut emissions quickly, some countries are literally going to be underwater. Because of this, small Pacific states had tried to use this week's Pacific Islands Forum meeting to get Pacific countries to agree to ending coal ...
To Limit Another's Rights Is To Limit One's Own: Is it too much to expect senior members of our Government to be capable of explaining that we protect the rights of human-beings precisely because not even the most depraved act can cancel-out the fact that its perpetrator is also a ...
Going Down? Once truth and propaganda become fused in the minds of one’s followers, debate and discussion become redundant. If one’s opponents are all outrageous liars, then engaging with them in any way is pointless. Rather than waste its time, a political party should, instead, target all its messages at ...
This section builds on Part 1 of this series to provide a theoretical basis for the final instalment (part 3 – to come). Self-determination: law or resurgence — or both? International law promotes the principal of equal treatment and self-determination, which includes peoples’ rights to freely pursue their social, cultural and ...
Everyone was outraged yesterday to learn that the Christchurch shooting accused had been able to send mail from prison to his Nazi fans, apparently pushing more hate. "How could this possibly happen", people asked. Simple: because New Zealand is a civilised country, and so we let prisoners send and receive ...
If we are to avoid dangerous anthropogenic climate change, we need to rapidly decarbonise our transport fleet. The good news: its starting to happen:The number of electric vehicles on New Zealand's roads have nearly tripled in the past two years. There are currently 15,453 registered electric vehicles (EVs), up ...
We need to fundamentally reframe our systems settings to address the drivers causing and underpinning inequality; structural change in systems especially financial. The Equality Network Hui was held in Wellington on 27 June 2019. The hui covered important topics such as child poverty; a living wage; taxation; public health; mental ...
The views-per-page for some of my recent postings:Depressing, isn't it? Provide thoughtful and wise commentary on the mainstream of British politics and no-one notices. Make a passing reference to Tommy DICKHEAD Robinson in a thread title and you get hundreds of views. Write something about anti-Semitism and you get another ...
The government has announced plans to move the Treaty of Waitangi and other taonga to a new site. Great news! So where are they going? Right next to the old one:The new plan will see a new 22,000-square-metre archive built on the former site of Defence House - the former ...
Back in June, StatsNZ went public about a project to track population data on an hourly level by using people's cellphones. It wasn't as bad as it initially looked - they were receiving no individual data, only counts by suburb - but there was still a huge consent problem, so ...
Most economists agree that a currently slowing economy could do with some stimulus – and they would also agree that there is no shortage of infrastructure projects which could be brought to productive fruition with help from that stimulus. In view of the current practice of sub-contracting economic policy decisions ...
I did an interview on the TVNZ Breakfast Show about the situation in Hong Kong. I tried to frame the issue as a collective action problem between two sides with very different end games. The video is here. Because of time constraints we could not discuss the fact that the ...
Image Credit: Wild Rose College A new study reporting the ranges of values for kidney and liver parameters in a healthy population is being actively misrepresented by anti-fluoride campaigners. The Fluoride Action Network’s (FAN) latest ...
Image Credit: Wild Rose College A new study reporting the ranges of values for kidney and liver parameters in a healthy population is being actively misrepresented by anti-fluoride campaigners. The Fluoride Action Network’s (FAN) latest ...
AN OPEN LETTER FOR SIGN ON BY ORGANISATIONS AND MOVEMENTS ACROSS THE WORLD, ALLIED IN THE FIGHT AGAINST INEQUALITY. This letter was released at the UN Political Forum on 9 July, where the Sustainable Development Goal on inequality was reviewed. The purpose of the letter is to call out the ...
We asked a young gay science student and critic of trans ideology and the trans activists’ assault on women’s and gay rights to outline his views on Redline. Thanks to him for his article. by Cian Ó Catháin Gender identity ideology (Gender ID) is ripping through western society at full ...
The Environment Committee is currently hearing submissions on the Zero Carbon Bill, and Stuff is reporting on the submissions. Today, they're covering yesterday they heard from "NZ" Steel:NZ Steel has told MPs it may be forced to close with the loss of thousands of jobs if changes aren't made to ...
Students are striking against climate change on September 27. And this time, they're asking everyone to join them:Students are taking to the streets, beaches and parks on 27 September, and we're inviting everyone to join us. That's right, this is an intergenerational issue, and you're all invited to put pressure ...
Peter McKenzie has a piece on Newsroom this morning about how local body politics is awash with property developer cash. 70% of all the donations in the 2016 Wellington mayoral election came from property developers. And its pretty obvious what they want in exchange:That’s particularly important in local government, according ...
Source: Unknown, twitter user Recently, I wrote a (relatively) short paper titled as above, to explore what self-determination could like in a practical sense. Maybe I’m a bit of an international trade truther or something, but I absolutely believe trade is at the heart of achieving peace and self-determination. Since ...
In the 1960s, after I had graduated with a first-class Oxford postgraduate law degree, I joined the British Foreign Office as the top entrant of my year. There, I worked for a couple of years on European affairs and was eventually posted to the Embassy in Brussels. After this exposure ...
Alone, Alone. All, All Alone: Will it be a good or a bad thing, when humanity’s bright blue spacecraft is stricken by the civilisation-destroying problem of Climate Change, that no Huston Control will be standing-by to rescue the crew?“WE HAVE A PROBLEM, HUSTON.” These were the words used by the ...
I heard a 45 minute interview with Monica Lewinsky talking to TED’s Chris Anderson on BBC Radio 4 over the weekend, and have listened to it another two times out walking. I recommend it. Highly. Man, I am so impressed with how this woman has integrated her life experiences and ...
Jonathan Haidt and Greg Lukianoff, The Coddling of the American Mind: how good intentions and bad ideas are setting up a generation for failure, London, Penguin, 2019, 352pp; reviewed by Gearóid Ó Loingsigh Jonathan Haidt and Greg Lukianoff’s book The Coddling of the American Mind is a timely book, whose ...
When the Justice Committee reported back on the Administration of Justice (Reform of Contempt of Court) Bill, free speech advocates breathed a sigh of relief. As originally introduced, the Bill reitered the ancient offence of "scandalising the court" - basicly, a special sedition law protecting judges from criticism. The select ...
Eighteen months ago, the government promised to strengthen the Bill of Rights Act, by explicitly affirming the power of the courts to issue declarations of inconsistency and requiring Parliament to formally respond to them. Since then - crickets. Which raises the obvious question: are they actually going to do this, ...
Back in March, the Ministry of Justice conducted a public consultation exercise on whether to hold a review of the Official Information Act. 285 people submitted on it. Now, Stuff has trawled through those submissions, and the case for reform is strong:The Justice Ministry asked Kiwis what they thought was ...
National's prisoner voting ban has gone down as one of the worst laws in New Zealand history. Passed after a farcical debate (including this farcial speech from ACT MP Hilary Calvert), it has subsequently been found to be inconsistent with the Bill of Rights Act by the High Court, Court ...
Divided Loyalties: Can the Prime Minister, Jacinda Ardern, be relied upon? That’s what the boys and girls at Foggy Bottom and the Pentagon needed to be reassured about. Because, from the perspective of Washington, it’s looking more and more like Jacinda Ardern and her Labour Party comrades are getting ready ...
This handy Queer Theory Glossary is from thetranswidow.com In case you’ve had trouble keeping up with the spate of new queer theory terms, here’s a handy glossary for your reference. Queer – A straight person with an interesting haircut. Non-binary/genderqueer – A chubby young female, typically 16-28, who has ...
by Daphna Whitmore US social psychologist and author Jonathan Haidt spoke on 1 August in Auckland to a crowd of around one thousand people. He is best known for his bookThe Coddling of the American Mind which examines the new climate of trigger warnings and acute sensitivity of Gen Z. ...
What an extraordinarily depressing experience it is to be compelled to watch, at 12,000 miles distance, the contortions and machinations of the British political class as they set about their determined attempt to overturn the decision taken by the British people that they wish to leave the European Union. The ...
The winter grazing issue is becoming a highly sensitised one that I hope will not become so politicised that it delays solutions and results in the suicides of some very stressed farmers.Winter grazing has hit the headlines after a determined campaign, including the release of a video of some very ...
by Don Franks Way back when British guitar virtuoso Joe Brown was a beginning session guy he got to back a visiting American artist. Young Joe was an able technician but had yet to learn some points of professionalism. Part way through “Five foot high and rising” Joe tired of ...
Since scientists started studying climate change, they have warned that it will reduce food production. And now, its happening:The climate crisis is damaging the ability of the land to sustain humanity, with cascading risks becoming increasingly severe as global temperatures rise, according to a landmark UN report compiled by some ...
The Abortion Legislation Bill just passed its first reading, 94-23. Its a far bigger margin than I expected, even allowing for the Winston factor, and it reflects the overwhelming support there is in this country for reform. but that support isn't a new thing - it has existed for literally ...
The Justice Committee has called for submissions on the Referendums Framework Bill. The Bill does what it says on the label - establishes a framework for referenda. Things you may want to address in your submission: Whether the bill should apply only at the 2020 election, or whether it should ...
The Thompson and Clark / MBIE spying scandal continues to result in fallout, this time in the form of a report on the implementation of MBIE's "Operation Exploration", its internal operation to enforce the infamous Anadarko Amendment which criminalised protests against the oil industry. MBIE's enforcement operation was tainted by ...
So, Winston Peters is defending his last-minute demand for a referendum on abortion by claiming he was "blindsided" by the bill. Really? The bill is a government bill. It has been working through the cabinet approval process since December last year. As part of that process, NZ First was consulted, ...
The Green Part has been accused of lack of transparency in two recent situations. The first was the claimed media lockdown during Green's annual conference and the second was Julie Ann Genter's refusal to release a letter she had sent to Phil Twyford.I do get frustrated when journalist's succumb to ...
The Green Part has been accused of lack of transparency in two recent situations. The first was the claimed media lockdown during Green's annual conference and the second was Julie Ann Genter's refusal to release a letter she had sent to Phil Twyford.I do get frustrated when journalist's succumb to ...
Last week, the ongoing democracy protests in Hong Kong saw a pro-Hong Kong student assaulted at the University of Auckland. The Chinese consulate in Auckland followed this up with a press release "express[ing] its appreciation to the students for their spontaneous patriotism" - effectively condoning the assault and inciting further ...
Only those who close their eyes and minds to the evidence can still be in any doubt that we are facing a climate change crisis. The evidence is conclusive that the world is not only getting inexorably hotter, but also that the rising temperatures are creating a number of other ...
Rural communities are wailing about forestry conversions "taking land out of production" and putting it into locking up carbon. Its driven purely by economics: there's more money and lower costs in carbon than in sheep or beef, and if carbon prices rise, there'll be more net money than dairy even. ...
This week, the government introduced its (underwhelming) Abortion Legislation Bill. And despite having negotiated the text of the bill through the coalition process, Winston Peters is now suggesting that he will demand a referendum on it:NZ First leader Winston Peters has hinted that his party may only support the Government's ...
Blowing-Up The House: Is Winston Peters planning to put himself at the head of all those New Zealanders who refuse to countenance the Coalition Government caving-in to the Ihumatao protesters? The most effective way of doing this would be to issue Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern with an ultimatum. If she ...
Last night the police dramatically incresed their numbers at Ihumātao, shoving over protestors and threatening them with arrest. Despite police talk about the need to maintain "public order" and prevent a "breach of the peace", there appeared to be absolutely no justification for this: the protest camp is, was, and ...
A Cult, that many actors, politicians, and those with a low IQ are joining is sweeping across civilisation, with one main intention – ending humans reign on Earth. Starting as a well meaning though deeply flawed theory, that the Earth was warming due to mankind emitting greenhouse gasses, it was ...
Today's abortion reform announcement is just the latest in a long line of disappointing decisions or outright failures from the Labour government. The 90-day law. KiwiBuild. A capital gains tax. Climate change. Every time they make one of those decisions, we hope for better next time. No repeal of the ...
The Greens used their party conference over the weekend to push for a rent-to-own scheme, where people would be able to work towards home ownership by renting from the government. Its a sensible policy, and one which could make a real difference to home ownership rates. But its also basicly ...
by Daphna Whitmore Over the past fortnight, thousands of people have come to the Ihumātao land protest in South Auckland. On 23 July police prepared to evict a few dozen people who had maintained the encampment at Ihumātao for the past three years. As hundreds of supporters arrived the ...
The following article is translated from an article in Lutte de Classe (Class Struggle), the magazine of the French revolutionary workers’ organisation Lutte Ouvrière (Workers Struggle). The United States’ blacklisting of the Chinese telecommunications company Huawei, which took shape in Google’s ban on Huawei using its systems on its phones, marks a ...
There is a military phrase: “Full spectrum dominance”. It refers to the all-encompassing policy to dominate across all spheres of war. Lately, that has come to include the internet – in other words, cyberwarfare initiatives. That is in addition to land, sea, air and the like. Now, if ...
The IMF issued a Report on the state of the Economy as it is at present. Some of it points out significant issues that certainly warrant attention, but that we know already exist. Some of it is very much tied to the very obvious context of global concerns, that everyone ...
I'm glad to see the Lib Dems won.I had a moment of terror yesterday thinking that the Conservatives might cling on, due to a combination of Johnson's elevation to the premiership, the apparent uselessness of the Lib Dem candidate (who had failed to be elected in other constituencies) and the ...
. . Current Leader of the National Party, Simon Bridges gave the usual rah-rah speech to the Loyal & Faithful in Christchurch today (27 July). With National’s party polling and his own personal popularity sliding steadily in the polls, Mr Bridges has not much left to reverse his fortunes. ...
Those concerned for Langridge’s wellbeing say they hope he’ll change his mind when he sees the ocean coming. The protester who has vowed to stand outside Parliament every day until the Government announces a climate emergency says he accepts that his quest will most likely end in drowning. Ollie Langridge, ...
What will climate change do to our capital city? The Wellington City Council has updated its projections, ditching its optimistic 0.6m estimate for sea-level rise in favour of a more realistic 1.5m. And the result is devastating:Wellington City Council has unofficially ditched an optimistic sea-level rise scenario in favour of ...
Image Credit: How To Start a Blog – Beginner’s Guide for 2019 I notice a few regulars no longer allow public access to the site counters. This may happen accidentally when the blog format is altered. ...
More complaints have been aired about the Royal Commission of Inquiry (RCICh) into the Christchurch terrorist attacks. These have centred on the perception that the RBICh has not paid enough attention to the Muslim community who were the targets of the attacks and the sole victims of them. Even though ...
Opportunities to dodge tax are shrinking with the completion of a new tax agreement with Switzerland, Revenue Minister Stuart Nash announced today. Mr Nash and the Swiss Ambassador David Vogelsanger have today signed documents to update the double tax agreement (DTA). The previous DTA was signed in 1980. “Double tax ...
Small Business Minister Stuart Nash says the report of the Small Business Council will help maintain the momentum for innovation and improvements in the sector. Mr Nash has thanked the members of the Small Business Council (SBC) who this week handed over their report, Empowering small businesses to aspire, succeed ...
Extra Police officers are being deployed from Northland to Southland with the graduation of a new wing of recruits from the Royal New Zealand Police College. “The graduation of 78 constables today means that 1524 new constables have been deployed since the government took office,” says Police Minister Stuart Nash. ...
Almost $600 million has been paid into taxpayers’ bank accounts in the past two months, after the first season of automatic tax assessments. Revenue Minister Stuart Nash says the completion of this year’s tax refund season is a significant milestone. “The ability of Inland Revenue to run auto calculations for ...
The Government’s proposed rescue plan must be strengthened because it is the last chance to save Māui dolphins from extinction and secure the future for Hector’s dolphins, Forest & Bird says. ...
Simon Shepherd: Roads, schools, hospitals, prisons, the building blocks that keep society functioning. And we don't have enough. It's called the infrastructure deficit and will be the focus of a major conference this coming week. The man charged with ...
New Zealand has been issued a stark challenge from Pacific leaders to dramatically upscale its action to address climate breakdown, Oxfam says, after a clear rallying cry from nations at this week’s Pacific Islands Forum. ...
Support for Recreational Dope Going ‘Up in Smoke’ Family First NZ is welcoming yet another poll showing plummeting support for legalising cannabis in New Zealand. The Horizon Research poll shows support for legalising has plummeted from 60% last ...
The prospect of ending wider cannabis prohibition looks increasingly unlikely. Over the last nine months, the percentage of New Zealanders who would vote for legalising the personal use of cannabis has declined at a near linear rate of around 10% per ...
“It’s disappointing that news out of the United States of hospitalisations linked to illegal street drugs is somehow seen as relevant to the New Zealand vaping scene,” says Ben Pryor, Director of Alt New Zealand – the largest Kiwi-owned vaping company. ...
The Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists (RANZCP) welcomes the successful passing of Misuse of Drugs Amendment Bill through parliament, by the New Zealand Government. ...
Today’s news from the Electoral Commission has provided the party with the clarity it was seeking around use of the word “Coalition” being used as the brand name of the party. ...
A recently released Otago University study has provided further evidence that low-quality housing is a significant problem in Aotearoa. This has prompted the Chief Executive of the Association of Consulting Engineers (ACENZ) Paul Evans to question “why ...
With the BNZ-Business NZ PMI signaling manufacturing is contracting , the Government needs to seriously consider tax relief, says the New Zealand Taxpayers’ Union . ...
The New Zealand Maori Council has called for an overhaul of the Public Services executive ranks as the Corrections debacle shows mis-management and incompetence at the highest level. Matthew Tukaki, Executive Director of the New Zealand Maori Council has said ...
Findings from the 2018 New Zealand Consumer Survey have been released and the results are in; 48 per cent of respondents consider their purchases based on how ethically employees are treated. ...
The responsibility for the fact that Westland Milk Products is now in the hands of an overseas conglomerate 25% owned by the Chinese government can be laid fair and square at our government's doorstep. ...
As Fonterra is projecting multi million dollar losses for the second year in a row, it is clear the writing is on the wall for dairy as more and more Kiwis turn to plant milks. 22nd August is International Plant Milk Day and there is now a different plant ...
The $65,000 granted to Interislander so it can install electric vehicle chargers on its ferries is the most absurd waste of money yet to be delivered by the “Low Emissions” vehicle fund, says the New Zealand Taxpayers’ Union. ...
Wellingtonians will have the chance to hear international child rights experts from Ireland, Scotland and Samoa speak at the Making Child Rights Real in Aotearoa New Zealand seminar to be held in the city on Wednesday 21 August. ...
Paul Evans, Chief Executive of the Association of Consulting Engineers (ACENZ), is advocating a balanced approach to the development of productive land. ...
CPAG (Child Poverty Action Group) says that new research from the University of Otago provides a solid foundation for why the Government must not delay instating a comprehensive Warrant of Fitness for tenanted homes in Aotearoa-New Zealand, and ...
The Independent Police Conduct Authority has found that an officer drove carelessly during a pursuit and that this was the primary cause of a collision with a motorcycle that injured the rider. ...
Responding to the Prime Minister’s commitment of $150 million in funding for climate change response in the Pacific, New Zealand Taxpayers’ Union spokesman Louis Houlbrooke says: “It is no secret that many Pacific nations lack serious oversight when it ...
AUT research not only shows an increase in political affiliation, but that candidates affiliated to a central political party are more likely to win seats in Auckland local government. ...
On the 23rd of August School Strike NZ will join Ollie Langridge in his 100th day of sitting outside of New Zealand Parliament calling for the government to declare a climate emergency. School Strike 4 Climate NZ also demand that Parliament acknowledge ...
You have stood up for what is fair, and I am sure you will speak for over 7 million people who have been muted and rendered voiceless in Indian occupied Kashmir for more than a 10 days now. I am writing to bring to your notice the plight of Kashmiri ...
In the last 10 months alone, 11 petitions have been delivered to Parliament calling for medicines to be funded by Pharmac. Today, another nine petitions have been launched by Patient Voice Aotearoa (PVA) members asking that life changing, saving and extending ...
When we were first working to get Miscanthus approved for import into New Zealand, the Environmental Risk Management Authority (ERMA) waived the fee for their work because they thought that having Miscanthus in New Zealand was so very much in the ...
PHARMAC’s recent decision to fund two additional drugs from December this year has been widely welcomed by patients and the general public alike. The drugs, Kadcyla and Ibrance, are used in the treatment of advanced lung and breast cancers and will ...
Animal rights organisation SAFE is urging the Government to include experts and advocates from outside the agriculture industry on its newly announced winter crop grazing taskforce. ...
The Government’s plans to prohibit housing on ‘productive’ farmland will serve as yet another regulatory tax on housing, and is a shameful breach of Jacinda Ardern’s promise to fix housing supply, says the New Zealand Taxpayers’ Union . ...
The latest round of the Ethnic Communities Development Fund opens today, supporting projects that grow the leadership and capability of ethnic groups, improve cultural understanding, and ensure our ethnic communities are a vibrant and celebrated part ...
The New Zealand Taxpayers’ Union is warning of the dangers of hiking excise tax, in response to calls from a former Prime Minister for stronger action on alcohol harm. Taxpayers’ Union spokesman Louis Houlbrooke says, “It seems inevitable ...
LGNZ will be cautiously assessing the wider implications of the newly proposed National Position Statement on Highly Productive Land (NPS-HPL), noting that that it traverses a number of highly complex policy areas including housing affordability and property ...
Horticulture New Zealand has welcomed the Government’s draft National Policy Statement on Highly Productive Land, saying it will help ensure that New Zealand can grow its own vegetables and fruit. ...
Background documents for Budget 2019 are now available from on the Treasury website: https://treasury.govt.nz/publications/information-release/budget-2019-information-release ...
The Abuse in Care Royal Commission of Inquiry has welcomed a move by Crown agencies to lift confidentiality obligations on survivors of abuse in State care arising from settlement agreements with the Crown. ...
An evaluation of New Zealand’s first sexual violence court has confirmed that the approach taken in the judge-led pilot considerably reduces the time that cases take to reach trial. ...
The National Party is pleased to announce the appointment of Paula Bennett as our Campaign Chair for the 2020 General Election, President Peter Goodfellow says. ...
14 August 2019 – 18 senior business leaders and employment experts have been appointed as judges for New Zealand’s sixth annual Equal Pay Awards reflecting the breadth of companies who have entered. The Awards added three new categories in 2018: Innovation, ...
Taxpayers’ Union spokesman Louis Houlbrooke says, “This is more proof that bureaucrats do not make good tech tycoons, no matter how much taxpayer money they throw at geeks in Silicon Valley.” ...
August marks five years of the Community Finance initiative. In addition to its well established Financial Mentoring service, The Salvation Army has held more than 5800 financial conversations with Community Finance clients. The loan program helps ...
Today 14/8/19 on news hub AM show Duncan Garner asked National Party leader Simon Bridges ‘what would he do to combat climate change and improve the economy again if he is the next PM”. https://www.newshub.co.nz/home/politics/2019/08/simon-bridges-says-most-kiwis-believe-system-gamed-at-last-election.html ...
DairyNZ Chief Executive Dr Tim Mackle is urging the Government to work with agricultural groups to drive real behaviour change on farm, instead of imposing a broad-based tax. Sector organisations have put forward an alternative Primary Sector Climate ...
Iwi forging closer relationship with Stats NZ over Māori data solutions The Data Iwi Leaders Group supports the findings of an independent review into the 2018 New Zealand Census – but says its failings provide a unique opportunity to co-design ...
“Any justification for paying exorbitant salaries to senior managers in business has just been buried in the Fonterra debacle” said Peter Malcolm spokesperson for Income Equality Aotearoa New Zealand Inc---“Closing the Gap” ...
Good on their own, even better with cheese – these crisp, moreish crackers are destined to become your new go-to savoury snack.These crackers have been on high rotation in our household – they’ve filled lunchboxes, accompanied fine cheeses on evening platters and been eaten by the fistful straight from the jar. ...
Lists are good and so are Sundays. We combine both those things in a new Spinoff feature. This week: Headlines from the past six months about the the Reserve Bank governor, Adrian OrrRBNZ prepares to stick its Orr inASB, March 29Banks Orr-struck yet againThe Australian, April 10Big banks brace for ...
Over 300 hours of interviews condensed into five episodes that cover the entirety of New Zealand’s comedy history – how do you even start to approach that? Sam Brooks interviews Paul Horan, the documentarian behind the show.It’s one of those projects that sounds utterly futile – how does one cover ...
Judgement prevents understanding, which in itself is a barrier to preventing unsafe behaviour. Are different approaches to harm reduction in the Rainbow community needed? Sex. Drugs. Carly Rae Jepsen. This is the iconography that tends to be massaged into mainstream conceptions of gay culture. Depictions in TV/film see us railing lines ...
The Spinoff is covering local elections across the country with a new pop-up section. To kick things off, Hayden Donnell went to a mayoral debate at Grey Power on the North Shore of Auckland.John Tamihere walked into the mayoral debate at North Shore Grey Power on Friday just minutes after ...
The Spinoff is covering local elections across the country with a new pop-up section. To kick things off, Hayden Donnell went to a mayoral debate at Grey Power on the North Shore of Auckland.John Tamihere walked into the mayoral debate at North Shore Grey Power on Friday just minutes after ...
Things I Learned at Art School is a new series featuring artists discussing how they do what they do and know what they know. In the second instalment, Megan Dunn talks to Berlin-based New Zealander Simon Denny about Michael Parekowhai, teaching and technology, and an idea involving the online shoe ...
With the acquisition of global rugby streaming leader RugbyPass, Sky might have just secured its future, writes Trevor McKewen.For several months now, the war between Sky and Spark Sport for the peerless prize of All Blacks and New Zealand rugby rights from 2021 onwards has been escalating. Every week, one ...
The Lightbulb asks innovators and entrepreneurs how they turned their ideas into reality. This week we talk to Jamie Cashmore, co-founder of Auckland-based edible packaging company Twiice. First of all, give us your elevator pitch for Twiice.Twiice is a company making edible coffee cups with plans to progress into other areas ...
The recent discovery of a fossil parrot the size of a human toddler is even more reason for Foulden Maar to be protected, writes the chairperson of Save Foulden Maar, Kimberley Collins.Last week, scientists discovered a new species of extinct parrot in the St Bathans Fauna. Weighing in at seven ...
Could a new hybrid of all the government’s major media holdings solve multiple media and government problems? Duncan Greive assesses the case.The media industry, despite what some of us might like to believe, really doesn’t matter all that much economically. Doesn’t employ all that many people. Relatively low wage. ...
The three governing parties are turning their attention to next year’s general election. RNZ‘s Jo Moir surveys the field.The night New Zealand First formed a government with Labour and the Greens, its leader Winston Peters quoted the song “You Can’t Always Get What You Want”.Almost two years later all three ...
Analysis: The botched census brings down a chief executive, there's another wave of speculation about Christopher Luxon standing for National and NZ First could sink an attempt to reverse the ban on prisoner voting. ...
Pacific Media Centre Newsdesk Wording has played a crucial role in a reportedly “fierce” Pacific Islands Forum in Tuvalu with Australia allegedly managing to alter documental terms to downplay its commitment to climate change mitigation. According to RNZ Pacific, a communiqué and separate statement on climate change was released ...
Australia’s coal policy and its use of carry over credits to fulfill its obligations under the Paris Agreement have come under fire and been major points of contention at this year’s 50th Pacific Islands Forum (PIF) Meeting in Funafuti, Tuvalu. READ MORE: ‘We should have done more for our ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Michael O’Keefe, Head of Department, Politics and Philosophy, La Trobe University The Pacific Islands Forum meeting in Tuvalu this week has ended in open division over climate change. Australia ensured its official communique watered down commitments to respond to climate change, gaining ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Xanthe Mallett, Forensic Criminologist, University of Newcastle Even in death, the voice of Carl Williams is louder than that of his victims. Intimate prison letters written by the convicted murderer and drug trafficker to his ex-wife, Roberta – herself arrested this month ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Brianna Chesser, Senior Lecturer in Criminology and Justice, RMIT University In September 2018, a prominent Melbourne surgeon and academic was charged with rape and sexual assault for alleged offences committed a year earlier against a male doctor. The surgeon and doctor had ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By John Dearnaley, Associate Professor, University of Southern Queensland The blotched butterfly orchid (Sarcochilus weinthalii) looks fairly unremarkable when it’s not flowering, generally resembling the far more common orange blossom orchid. But when it flowers, it is exquisite. Dark purple blotches stand out ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Simon Cropper, Senior Lecturer, Melbourne School of Psychological Sciences, University of Melbourne Almost every person throughout the existence of humankind has looked up at the night sky and seen more than just a random scattering of light. Constellations of stars have helped ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Ben Desbrow, Associate Professor, Nutrition and Dietetics, Griffith University A recent study published in the journal Depression and Anxiety has attracted widespread media attention. Media reports said eating chocolate, in particular, dark chocolate, was linked to reduced symptoms of depression. Unfortunately, we ...
He’s the artist who launched a million memes and over a billion streams. Sam Brooks picks out Bazzi’s best moments so far, from his career-making breakthrough to his mature new mixtape Soulsearching.1. ‘Mine’“You’re so fuckin’ precious when you smile.”It’s the line that didn’t just launch a million memes, it’s the ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Mark Crosby, Professor, Monash University Since President Trump tweeted about imposing new tariffs on China, global equity markets have gone into a tailspin. Trump’s more recent announcement that the new tariffs would be delayed has not calmed the markets, with recent days ...
A new poem by Waikato poet Loren Thomas.to convince myself we’re dreamingwe were walking through suburbia houses kissing front lawns copied one after anotheryou tasted like mint leaves and chlorophyll that’s been pissed on by catsI held your hand and we walked towards the ocean dodging planks from dead train ...
The ancient Australian shock-jock yesterday targeted Jacinda Ardern, urging Australia’s PM to ‘shove a sock down her throat’. It’s all in keeping with a substantial history of being an arse.The plucky nation of Australia excels in a range of endeavours, but nowhere more than the angry, anguished howls of bloated, ...
Today, TVNZ released its latest findings on who is watching what on TVNZ OnDemand. Sam Brooks analyses the results.Today, TVNZ released the 2019 figures for who is watching TVNZ OnDemand, what they’re watching and in what kind of numbers. The big numbers are hopeful – over 1.4 million people reached ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Jock Collins, Professor of Social Economics, UTS Business School, University of Technology Sydney The federal government wants to boost the number of migrants moving to regional areas in Australia to fill job vacancies and reduce the pressure on our cities. That’s why ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Anastasia Powell, Associate Professor, Criminology and Justice Studies, RMIT University There can be no doubt violence against women is a national crisis. On average in Australia, one woman every week is killed. A 2016 survey found one in four women experienced violence ...
One dignified resignation was a bouquet in a sea of brickbats this week as low levels of accountability had eyes rolling. James Elliott has the news of the week. ...
Sleater-Kinney’s Carrie Brownstein on the band’s ninth studio album, working with St Vincent, and the departure of bandmate and drummer, Janet Weiss.It’s been almost five years since Sleater-Kinney broke their decade-long hiatus with an album that received almost near-universal praise. It was “raw”, “bristling”, “emotive”, “taut” – all adjectives you’d ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Colleen Murrell, Associate Professor, Journalism, Swinburne University of Technology When news of the stabbings in Sydney on Tuesday afternoon came through, one of the first tweets about the incident came from Sky News reporter Laura Jayes. Immediately it got retweeted and sent ...
The only published and available best-selling indie book chart in New Zealand is the top 10 sales list recorded every week at Unity Books’ stores in High St, Auckland, and Willis St, Wellington.AUCKLAND1 Normal People by Sally Rooney (Faber & Faber, $23)Sally Rooney Sally Rooney Sally Rooney Sally Rooney2 An ...
When Emily Writes reviewed a life-changing sex toy, the response from orgasm-starved women was huge. So why are so many having so few orgasms, and what can be done?For the last two years I’ve been running a pretty small – about 600-odd member – group for mostly New Zealand women ...
When Josie Adams broke her laptop last week, she knew she’d never find love like that again. Can the Asus Chromebook Flip C213SA offer a new kind of technological relationship? She reviews how it stands up to everyday use and the cosmic forces that seek to destroy her.Last Thursday I ...
Wine should be fun, not intimidating, all you need is a little knowledge. Yvonne Lorkin co-founder and chief tasting officer of WineFriend provides some simple tips to help you empower your palate. Even I can get scared by wine. I’m usually super-meek and a tad feeble at high-brow, ‘industry’ wine tastings. ...
Pacific Media Watch NewsdeskBy Makereta Komai in Funafuti, Tuvalu Tonga’s Prime Minister, ‘Akilisi Pohiva, has delivered a stinging attack against regionalism and the Pacific Islands Forum’s stance of leaving no one behind, for failing to amicably resolve the issue of West Papua. Pohiva admitted the issue has divided ...
Editor’s Note: Here below is a list of the main issues currently under discussion in New Zealand and links to media coverage.New Zealand Parliament Buildings, Wellington, New Zealand.Today’s content by Dr Bryce Edwards.Corrections, Christchurch mosque shootings Chris Trotter (Daily Blog): Upholding The Accused’s Right To Write Mark Daalder ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Amber Marshall, Research fellow, Queensland University of Technology Farming families and communities in Queensland’s remote north are being left behind by the digital economy, putting them at significant social and economic disadvantage. Our report, launched in Cairns today, details the impacts of ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Adrian Cameron, Associate professor, and Associate Director of the Global Obesity Centre, Deakin University Half-price chips, “two for one” chocolates, “buy one get one free” soft drinks: Australian supermarkets make it very easy for us to fill our trolleys with junk food. ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Richard Trethowan, Director, IA Watson Research Centre, Narrabri Plant Breeding Institute, University of Sydney A UN report released last week found a quarter of the world’s carbon emissions come from the food chain, particularly meat farming. This has prompted calls to sharply ...
Open Mike 29/03/2018 
Fully Informed? Labour’s 2017 promises raised expectations that were little short of revolutionary. Unfortunately, they were never adequately shaken through the fiscal sieve. The hard economic work was not done – and it shows. Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern’s critics have long complained that her grasp of the way the New ...31 mins ago
You cannot expect to pound communities into the ground day after day, year after year, decade after decade and just expect them to take it lying down. There’s a point at which the place will explode. And we’re faced with some very big ructions on both sides of the Atlantic ...2 days ago
Back in May, Destiny Church leaders Brian and Hannah Tamaki launched another political party. Despite consisting entirely of followers of their religion, they grandly called it "Coalition New Zealand", in a vain effort to suggest it was something broader. But when they applied for registration, submitters opposed the name, as ...2 days ago
The following article is excerpted and translated from two articles in recent issues of Lutte de Classe (Class Struggle), the magazine of Lutte Ouvrière (Workers Struggle), the revolutionary workers group active in France. We don’t necessarily agree with everything in it – for instance, the 1956-62 war for independence involved rather more revolutionary forces than ...2 days ago
2 days ago
Going Down? Once truth and propaganda become fused in the minds of one’s followers, debate and discussion become redundant. If one’s opponents are all outrageous liars, then engaging with them in any way is pointless. Rather than waste its time, a political party should, instead, target all its messages at ...2 days ago
This section builds on Part 1 of this series to provide a theoretical basis for the final instalment (part 3 – to come). Self-determination: law or resurgence — or both? International law promotes the principal of equal treatment and self-determination, which includes peoples’ rights to freely pursue their social, cultural and ...3 days ago
We need to fundamentally reframe our systems settings to address the drivers causing and underpinning inequality; structural change in systems especially financial. The Equality Network Hui was held in Wellington on 27 June 2019. The hui covered important topics such as child poverty; a living wage; taxation; public health; mental ...4 days ago
The views-per-page for some of my recent postings:Depressing, isn't it? Provide thoughtful and wise commentary on the mainstream of British politics and no-one notices. Make a passing reference to Tommy DICKHEAD Robinson in a thread title and you get hundreds of views. Write something about anti-Semitism and you get another ...4 days ago
The government has announced plans to move the Treaty of Waitangi and other taonga to a new site. Great news! So where are they going? Right next to the old one:The new plan will see a new 22,000-square-metre archive built on the former site of Defence House - the former ...4 days ago
Back in June, StatsNZ went public about a project to track population data on an hourly level by using people's cellphones. It wasn't as bad as it initially looked - they were receiving no individual data, only counts by suburb - but there was still a huge consent problem, so ...4 days ago
Most economists agree that a currently slowing economy could do with some stimulus – and they would also agree that there is no shortage of infrastructure projects which could be brought to productive fruition with help from that stimulus. In view of the current practice of sub-contracting economic policy decisions ...4 days ago
I did an interview on the TVNZ Breakfast Show about the situation in Hong Kong. I tried to frame the issue as a collective action problem between two sides with very different end games. The video is here. Because of time constraints we could not discuss the fact that the ...4 days ago
Image Credit: Wild Rose College A new study reporting the ranges of values for kidney and liver parameters in a healthy population is being actively misrepresented by anti-fluoride campaigners. The Fluoride Action Network’s (FAN) latest ... 4 days ago
Alone, Alone. All, All Alone: Will it be a good or a bad thing, when humanity’s bright blue spacecraft is stricken by the civilisation-destroying problem of Climate Change, that no Huston Control will be standing-by to rescue the crew?“WE HAVE A PROBLEM, HUSTON.” These were the words used by the ...5 days ago
Divided Loyalties: Can the Prime Minister, Jacinda Ardern, be relied upon? That’s what the boys and girls at Foggy Bottom and the Pentagon needed to be reassured about. Because, from the perspective of Washington, it’s looking more and more like Jacinda Ardern and her Labour Party comrades are getting ready ...6 days ago
This handy Queer Theory Glossary is from thetranswidow.com In case you’ve had trouble keeping up with the spate of new queer theory terms, here’s a handy glossary for your reference. Queer – A straight person with an interesting haircut. Non-binary/genderqueer – A chubby young female, typically 16-28, who has ...7 days ago
The winter grazing issue is becoming a highly sensitised one that I hope will not become so politicised that it delays solutions and results in the suicides of some very stressed farmers.Winter grazing has hit the headlines after a determined campaign, including the release of a video of some very ...1 week ago
The Green Part has been accused of lack of transparency in two recent situations. The first was the claimed media lockdown during Green's annual conference and the second was Julie Ann Genter's refusal to release a letter she had sent to Phil Twyford.I do get frustrated when journalist's succumb to ...2 weeks ago
Blowing-Up The House: Is Winston Peters planning to put himself at the head of all those New Zealanders who refuse to countenance the Coalition Government caving-in to the Ihumatao protesters? The most effective way of doing this would be to issue Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern with an ultimatum. If she ...2 weeks ago
A Cult, that many actors, politicians, and those with a low IQ are joining is sweeping across civilisation, with one main intention – ending humans reign on Earth. Starting as a well meaning though deeply flawed theory, that the Earth was warming due to mankind emitting greenhouse gasses, it was ...2 weeks ago
There is a military phrase: “Full spectrum dominance”. It refers to the all-encompassing policy to dominate across all spheres of war. Lately, that has come to include the internet – in other words, cyberwarfare initiatives. That is in addition to land, sea, air and the like. Now, if ...2 weeks ago
The IMF issued a Report on the state of the Economy as it is at present. Some of it points out significant issues that certainly warrant attention, but that we know already exist. Some of it is very much tied to the very obvious context of global concerns, that everyone ...2 weeks ago
I'm glad to see the Lib Dems won.I had a moment of terror yesterday thinking that the Conservatives might cling on, due to a combination of Johnson's elevation to the premiership, the apparent uselessness of the Lib Dem candidate (who had failed to be elected in other constituencies) and the ...2 weeks ago
. . Current Leader of the National Party, Simon Bridges gave the usual rah-rah speech to the Loyal & Faithful in Christchurch today (27 July). With National’s party polling and his own personal popularity sliding steadily in the polls, Mr Bridges has not much left to reverse his fortunes. ...2 weeks ago
Those concerned for Langridge’s wellbeing say they hope he’ll change his mind when he sees the ocean coming. The protester who has vowed to stand outside Parliament every day until the Government announces a climate emergency says he accepts that his quest will most likely end in drowning. Ollie Langridge, ...2 weeks ago
Image Credit: How To Start a Blog – Beginner’s Guide for 2019 I notice a few regulars no longer allow public access to the site counters. This may happen accidentally when the blog format is altered. ... 2 weeks ago
Opportunities to dodge tax are shrinking with the completion of a new tax agreement with Switzerland, Revenue Minister Stuart Nash announced today. Mr Nash and the Swiss Ambassador David Vogelsanger have today signed documents to update the double tax agreement (DTA). The previous DTA was signed in 1980. “Double tax ...1 week ago
The Government’s proposed rescue plan must be strengthened because it is the last chance to save Māui dolphins from extinction and secure the future for Hector’s dolphins, Forest & Bird says. ...38 mins ago
Good on their own, even better with cheese – these crisp, moreish crackers are destined to become your new go-to savoury snack.These crackers have been on high rotation in our household – they’ve filled lunchboxes, accompanied fine cheeses on evening platters and been eaten by the fistful straight from the jar. ...2 hours ago
Over 300 hours of interviews condensed into five episodes that cover the entirety of New Zealand’s comedy history – how do you even start to approach that? Sam Brooks interviews Paul Horan, the documentarian behind the show.It’s one of those projects that sounds utterly futile – how does one cover ...6 hours ago
Judgement prevents understanding, which in itself is a barrier to preventing unsafe behaviour. Are different approaches to harm reduction in the Rainbow community needed? Sex. Drugs. Carly Rae Jepsen. This is the iconography that tends to be massaged into mainstream conceptions of gay culture. Depictions in TV/film see us railing lines ...6 hours ago
The Spinoff is covering local elections across the country with a new pop-up section. To kick things off, Hayden Donnell went to a mayoral debate at Grey Power on the North Shore of Auckland.John Tamihere walked into the mayoral debate at North Shore Grey Power on Friday just minutes after ...19 hours ago
The Spinoff is covering local elections across the country with a new pop-up section. To kick things off, Hayden Donnell went to a mayoral debate at Grey Power on the North Shore of Auckland.John Tamihere walked into the mayoral debate at North Shore Grey Power on Friday just minutes after ...19 hours ago
The three parties in the coalition have to negotiate compromises, concessions and conquests week after week. ...1 day ago
Things I Learned at Art School is a new series featuring artists discussing how they do what they do and know what they know. In the second instalment, Megan Dunn talks to Berlin-based New Zealander Simon Denny about Michael Parekowhai, teaching and technology, and an idea involving the online shoe ...1 day ago
With the acquisition of global rugby streaming leader RugbyPass, Sky might have just secured its future, writes Trevor McKewen.For several months now, the war between Sky and Spark Sport for the peerless prize of All Blacks and New Zealand rugby rights from 2021 onwards has been escalating. Every week, one ...1 day ago
Today, a short story from the late 1920s, published in a posthumous new collection by Marlborough writer Eileen Duggan. Photo by Peter Black. ...1 day ago
The Lightbulb asks innovators and entrepreneurs how they turned their ideas into reality. This week we talk to Jamie Cashmore, co-founder of Auckland-based edible packaging company Twiice. First of all, give us your elevator pitch for Twiice.Twiice is a company making edible coffee cups with plans to progress into other areas ...1 day ago
Black Fern Aleisha-Pearl Nelson was told by doctors, twice, that her rugby days were over - after serious horse-riding accidents. ...1 day ago
The recent discovery of a fossil parrot the size of a human toddler is even more reason for Foulden Maar to be protected, writes the chairperson of Save Foulden Maar, Kimberley Collins.Last week, scientists discovered a new species of extinct parrot in the St Bathans Fauna. Weighing in at seven ...1 day ago
The three governing parties are turning their attention to next year’s general election. RNZ‘s Jo Moir surveys the field.The night New Zealand First formed a government with Labour and the Greens, its leader Winston Peters quoted the song “You Can’t Always Get What You Want”.Almost two years later all three ...1 day ago
Protests in Hong Kong have attracted worldwide attention - but are we ignoring a more serious situation across the sea? ...2 days ago
Analysis: The botched census brings down a chief executive, there's another wave of speculation about Christopher Luxon standing for National and NZ First could sink an attempt to reverse the ban on prisoner voting. ...2 days ago
Pacific Media Centre Newsdesk Wording has played a crucial role in a reportedly “fierce” Pacific Islands Forum in Tuvalu with Australia allegedly managing to alter documental terms to downplay its commitment to climate change mitigation. According to RNZ Pacific, a communiqué and separate statement on climate change was released ...2 days ago
Australia’s coal policy and its use of carry over credits to fulfill its obligations under the Paris Agreement have come under fire and been major points of contention at this year’s 50th Pacific Islands Forum (PIF) Meeting in Funafuti, Tuvalu. READ MORE: ‘We should have done more for our ...2 days ago
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Michael O’Keefe, Head of Department, Politics and Philosophy, La Trobe University The Pacific Islands Forum meeting in Tuvalu this week has ended in open division over climate change. Australia ensured its official communique watered down commitments to respond to climate change, gaining ...2 days ago
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Xanthe Mallett, Forensic Criminologist, University of Newcastle Even in death, the voice of Carl Williams is louder than that of his victims. Intimate prison letters written by the convicted murderer and drug trafficker to his ex-wife, Roberta – herself arrested this month ...2 days ago
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Brianna Chesser, Senior Lecturer in Criminology and Justice, RMIT University In September 2018, a prominent Melbourne surgeon and academic was charged with rape and sexual assault for alleged offences committed a year earlier against a male doctor. The surgeon and doctor had ...2 days ago
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By John Dearnaley, Associate Professor, University of Southern Queensland The blotched butterfly orchid (Sarcochilus weinthalii) looks fairly unremarkable when it’s not flowering, generally resembling the far more common orange blossom orchid. But when it flowers, it is exquisite. Dark purple blotches stand out ...2 days ago
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Simon Cropper, Senior Lecturer, Melbourne School of Psychological Sciences, University of Melbourne Almost every person throughout the existence of humankind has looked up at the night sky and seen more than just a random scattering of light. Constellations of stars have helped ...2 days ago
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Ben Desbrow, Associate Professor, Nutrition and Dietetics, Griffith University A recent study published in the journal Depression and Anxiety has attracted widespread media attention. Media reports said eating chocolate, in particular, dark chocolate, was linked to reduced symptoms of depression. Unfortunately, we ...2 days ago
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Mark Crosby, Professor, Monash University Since President Trump tweeted about imposing new tariffs on China, global equity markets have gone into a tailspin. Trump’s more recent announcement that the new tariffs would be delayed has not calmed the markets, with recent days ...2 days ago
Today, TVNZ released its latest findings on who is watching what on TVNZ OnDemand. Sam Brooks analyses the results.Today, TVNZ released the 2019 figures for who is watching TVNZ OnDemand, what they’re watching and in what kind of numbers. The big numbers are hopeful – over 1.4 million people reached ...2 days ago
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Jock Collins, Professor of Social Economics, UTS Business School, University of Technology Sydney The federal government wants to boost the number of migrants moving to regional areas in Australia to fill job vacancies and reduce the pressure on our cities. That’s why ...2 days ago
One dignified resignation was a bouquet in a sea of brickbats this week as low levels of accountability had eyes rolling. James Elliott has the news of the week. ...2 days ago
Corrections has referred a letter written by the alleged Christchurch terrorist to police for further investigation. ...2 days ago
Sky Television is purchasing online rugby streaming service RugbyPass for $US40 million ($NZ62m). ...2 days ago
Jewellery retailer Michael Hill International has reported a lift in profit but is feeling the pinch of lower sales and squeezed margins. ...2 days ago
Sleater-Kinney’s Carrie Brownstein on the band’s ninth studio album, working with St Vincent, and the departure of bandmate and drummer, Janet Weiss.It’s been almost five years since Sleater-Kinney broke their decade-long hiatus with an album that received almost near-universal praise. It was “raw”, “bristling”, “emotive”, “taut” – all adjectives you’d ...2 days ago
When Emily Writes reviewed a life-changing sex toy, the response from orgasm-starved women was huge. So why are so many having so few orgasms, and what can be done?For the last two years I’ve been running a pretty small – about 600-odd member – group for mostly New Zealand women ...2 days ago
Wine should be fun, not intimidating, all you need is a little knowledge. Yvonne Lorkin co-founder and chief tasting officer of WineFriend provides some simple tips to help you empower your palate. Even I can get scared by wine. I’m usually super-meek and a tad feeble at high-brow, ‘industry’ wine tastings. ...2 days ago
Pacific Media Watch Newsdesk By Makereta Komai in Funafuti, Tuvalu Tonga’s Prime Minister, ‘Akilisi Pohiva, has delivered a stinging attack against regionalism and the Pacific Islands Forum’s stance of leaving no one behind, for failing to amicably resolve the issue of West Papua. Pohiva admitted the issue has divided ...2 days ago
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Amber Marshall, Research fellow, Queensland University of Technology Farming families and communities in Queensland’s remote north are being left behind by the digital economy, putting them at significant social and economic disadvantage. Our report, launched in Cairns today, details the impacts of ...2 days ago
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Adrian Cameron, Associate professor, and Associate Director of the Global Obesity Centre, Deakin University Half-price chips, “two for one” chocolates, “buy one get one free” soft drinks: Australian supermarkets make it very easy for us to fill our trolleys with junk food. ...2 days ago
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Richard Trethowan, Director, IA Watson Research Centre, Narrabri Plant Breeding Institute, University of Sydney A UN report released last week found a quarter of the world’s carbon emissions come from the food chain, particularly meat farming. This has prompted calls to sharply ...2 days ago
Leaving Ghouta
“one father faces a difficult choice”
“Q: Were you in contact with your wife after she left? What did she tell you about the Syrian government shelters for people leaving East Ghouta?”
“Q: To your knowledge, are you wanted by the government? And if not, are you considering following your wife?”
Hassan Abdelrahman, the 37-year-old grocery store owner in Eastern Ghouta, quoted above, faces a sickening life or death choice.
Flee to rebel held Idlib and again risk death under the continual hail of regime and Russian bombs. Or take his chances with the regime.
What decision would you make if you were Hassan?
1/ Leave your family and flee to Idlib?
2/ Take your chances with the regime?
Give the reasons for your choice.
Jenny
In case your mother didn’t tell you.
Lies BAD
Truth GOOD
Good on you Brigid … perhaps Jenny should write with a decoder …. Rebel = Al Quada Or ISIS types would be a good place for her to start ….
Just like the Libyan ‘rebels’ ….
For more balanced reporting ….. Fisk is reasonable https://www.independent.co.uk/voices/eastern-ghouta-syria-robert-fisk-camps-bashar-al-assad-a8275711.html
Can we conclude from this that you were orphaned at birth?
We?
How many are there of you? Do you know? Does anyone know?
Do you each have a unique char or numerical attribute?
Or not. in which case that’d be a bitch of a database to manage; in fact impossible.
Just asking..
13,000 – AI
Moderate Rebels
Abu Gharib
Iraq
Libya
Palistine
Lebanon
South Sudan
Et al
PNAC , Jenny…
Your extreme bias on this issue bring nothing but disrepute to those who are suffering on all sides..
You’ve chosen a side…that is to have failed in what I assume you’re hoping to achieve…
If you can’t understand how choosing sides fails those you purport to care about…then reconsider how your energy might be feeding the fire…
It will be interesting to see if Guyon Espiner will still be as supportive of Paul Buchanan today after his “New Zealand’s claim it has no Russian spies is perplexing. Why is it isolating itself?” opinion piece in the Guardian overnight. It was opened for comment, with most of the responders (over 1400 at 7:00am) making it clear they did not support his sycophantic endorsement of Theresa May’s support club. Perhaps there is an ex-USA spy that should be considered for expulsion.
Whatever his reaction, I doubt he will indulge himself in puerile Kremlin-apologist lines like “Theresa May’s support club”.
“New Zealand’s decision not to participate in the solidarity coalition was made in the face of a direct request from the May government ….” Paul Buchanan.
In international terms, the request was made by the British government. From what Ardern says, it involved consultation between 5-eyes partners and set criteria for who would be expelled.
Australia found two people who met those criteria. Two. The SIS says none meet the criteria. That being so, who should be picked for expulsion?
Of course Australia found 2 people who meet the criteria. They will do anything to look good or win we only have to look at their cricket and they are very bad losers. They need to clean up their own backyard they treat their indigenous people appallingly (high incarceration rates, high suicide rates )
Well that was a reasoned argument. Positively brimming with careful consideration 🙄
To true Michelle ….
If I were nominating suspects in the little criminal nation england …. with extensive form ….. Billionaire Zionists line up very well as motivated thugs . https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Israeli_assassinations …. And they have form for poisoning people in sly ways too
They have murderous motivation against Russia …. As the disintegration of Syria would make permanent their theft of the Golan heights … and they hoped their proxy war would destroy Hamas.
At about the 15 minute mark of this doco you hear how their war of aggression helped them steal more land from Palestine , Egypt and Syria https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TOaxAckFCuQ
Geezuz man! Ya can’t say THAT!!!!
– NEXT thingbya know, you’ll have ‘the authorities knocking on the straw and clay bathroom window threatening to take away your arse wash
🙂
And people need to be clear what that criteria as to who would be expelled was/is – “undeclared intelligence staff/agents” – a very specific category of intelligence operatives.
Andrew Geddis at Pundit (and at Stuff?) has done a superb job of defining exactly what an “Undeclared intelligence agent” is – and why this category of agents/diplomats has been targetted.
https://www.pundit.co.nz/content/my-spy-boy-told-your-spy-boy-im-gonna-set-you-flag-on-fi-yo
I won’t do an extract as to get the full context takes up most of Geddis’ post, but if you want to see the main points I have done an extract here on TS already in slightly different responses to two other comments:
But people need to understand the criteria – ie this specific category – to understand why NZ has not expelled anyone. Nor by the way have 40% of EU countries according to Winston Peters under Q8 yesterday in the House. See the second link above for this and my addendum comment immediately under that.
people need to understand the criteria
Why try to understand anything when you either want to look tough, or like the wisest sceptic in the room?
Thanks for the Geddis link. I expect he’s a crisis actor in disguise 😉
That is one of the clearest explanations I have ever seen. NZSIS and GCSB should plagarize it! i was trying to put it into a short definition but was getting twisted about, so full marks to Geddis.
It’s not bad eh @vv
It’s fairly obvious you’ve experienced 76uin both the world of the Humphrey, and the world of what is best described as the job of a Jitter Jitter noooo KKKKKITERIDGE WUNCE d d d ddid.
aom:
Before you sign my expulsion orders, have a look at my original thoughts on the affair. A lot got spun off and/or edited down in the aftermath of my writing it, but the bottom line is this: the spy comments by the PM were not only silly but a diversion from the main issue. That issue is the reason(s) why the Labour government chose not to join its major security partners in this (largely symbolic) act of collective repudiation of Russian misbehaviour abroad. We have yet to hear about those, which is the only thing I am particularly interested in.
http://www.kiwipolitico.com/2018/03/new-zealand-goes-it-alone/
Professor Geddis’ remarks may interest you.
As for the reasons, we aren’t “yet to hear about those” – Ardern has addressed them specifically.
Geddis is wrong about those with diplomatic passports being expelled. A number of them had nothing to do with intelligence matters.
As for the reasons, can you point me to where these have been enunciated?
Don’t know if it’s been published elsewhere; here’s the PM on Facebook.
Must be the wrong clip. She talks about different types of intel officers (and it is a very incomplete one at that), but never mentions the reasons why NZ did not respond favorably to the UK request. Surely it is not just because there were no people who “met the criteria,” because if so that would demonstrate that the government focused on the tactical instrumentalities of a reply rather than the substance of the request as framed against NZ’s global interests.
Put another way: was there any other reason other than the absence of people “who met the criteria” behind the rejection of the request to join the “expulsion coalition?” I mention a few possible reasons in my essay linked above but have heard nothing one way or the other from our foreign policy leaders.
As she points out in the clip, Australia identified two individuals. All two of them will be expelled. Not that hard to believe NZ turning up zero especially since it’s also been reported that:
As Geddis says, expelling people who don’t meet the criteria goes further than other countries have.
Travel bans and other sanctions to follow, they say. Hardly a “refusal”.
A number of them had nothing to do with intelligence matters.
Isn't that the point of being an "undeclared intelligence operative", until you get found out?
No, which is why that phrase is unhelpful. The big difference in HUMINT is that between Official Cover (those with diplomatic passports) and Unofficial Cover (those without diplomatic passports and hence immunity). OC’s who are discovered get expelled; UC’s get arrested and imprisoned/executed. All those expelled in this action were OCs and regular diplomats who were not working outside the job description in their credentials (OCs tend to work the outer margins of what they are credentialed to do). No UCs were expelled, and those are the ones that decline to “declare” their status because they are working covertly under the cover of an assumed identity. So the phraseology being used by the PM is obtuse, and I am not sure that is by accident.
Again, all of this diverts attention from the main issue.
I understood from the PM that the criterion was embassy staff whose job descriptions don’t match their activities.
Not UCs, although perhaps their ‘controllers’, if anyone still calls them that.
I thought the ones supposed to be expelled were OCs in that they were officially regular diplomats but were also doing intelligence work without telling the host nation? So in order to expel them you’d have to know about their actual intelligence work.
…which means you’d be expelling the incompetent ones, and leaving the undiscovered skillful operatives remaining.
Good to know @Pablo that your reading is as wide as it is (such as to include TS) – contrutors and commenters alike.
Once upon a time a relative went to school with ‘Beks’
Interesting (as i’ve siad elsewhere) how people get caotured….. whether its PService snr nanagement complaceenxy…..I just got put off by the chuckles of Wallace’s ‘Panel’ (sitting invfor the Mora) apologiesles.
Ew!
Let it play out is probably the best option
Why was a diplomatic repudiation initiated in relation to the nerve agent attack, and not for the arguably equally abhorrent attack on democracy inherent in the interference with the US Presidential election? Have or should either of these issues been raised with the United Nations? And have there been any developments giving evidence of culpability or otherwise? Is diplomacy to be seen as a diversion from reality?
If it was Blobby Jobby asking, one would have to think twice.
Well I for one have yet to see ANY evidence of Kremlin involvement, so far all we have is “its the only logical conclusion”.. well I don’t buy that at all. given the crap going down in the USA at the moment i consider a CIA false flag operation as worthy of proper consideration.
But but but, we don’t need evidence. Drug cheats, election hackers, plane crashers, the kgb, the kremlin. They are the most evil… most definitely.
Get some guts and join the right side!
Get in behind May and the rest of the free world!
Strawmen and hyperbole. It was the Czechs! It was the CIA! They’re all crisis actors! “Those who serve us with poison will eventually swallow it and poison themselves,” oops sorry, I slipped and Vladimir Putin’s thuggish direct threats somehow fell into the narrative by accident.
The only people who haven’t given the idea of the skripal poisonings being a CIA or UK “deep state” false-flag op “serious consideration” are the people demanding it have serious consideration.
Lots of risk, no reward unless Putin has never had a single political opponent murdered. Otherwise all they’d need to do is wait.
“Those who serve us with poison “etc
It didn’t occur to you that the quote in question might have been abbreviated to serve propagandistic purposes?
https://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/40900/did-putin-threaten-to-have-traitors-assassinated
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/russia/8207750/Vladimir-Putin-Russian-secret-services-dont-kill-traitors.html
Of course it serves propagandistic purposes!
It says: “Not only can we poison traitors, we can brag about it, so toe the line or else!” And the target of these threats? Why, the Russian peoples and other existing military personnel.
Cf: people seeking the death penalty for Chelsea Manning.
Edit: I note that your Telegraph link reports that Kremlin thugs were convicted of murder in Qatar. So much for Putin’s assurances.
The Chechen was a spy from a spyswap?
Do tell
Still waiting for you to find me any spy , previous to Skripal ,who has been pardoned by the Russians and released in a spy swap who has then been killed by the Russians
Curiously narrow hoop you have there. If I try and jump through it I’m afraid my ears will get stuck.
I wish you’d stop saying “Russians”, by the way. The thugs in the Kremlin are about as representative of Russia as the Mongrel Mob is of NZ.
Qatar:2004
Litvinenko:2006
Putin’s speech”Secret services no longer kills traitors”:2010
Abbreviated 2010 speech “traitors will choke etc” published in March 2018 to imply it was made in relation to the Skripal poisoning
OAB thinks he’s got a scoop: 29 March 2018
When the OPCW releases its findings, you won’t see the evidence then either. That won’t turn your fence into a comfy chair though.
So blind obedience to the old Cold War propaganda recipe is a ‘comfy chair’? I am 71, read and heard all this Russian scare stuff before.. My guess is that Terrorism has now lost its bite as a fearful external enemy, and our thought masters are resurrecting the old tried, tested and proven cold war tactic. We have even just had scary news about stunning new Russian weapons. We had that bullshit all through the 50s till the late 80s. Tedious.
What “blind obedience”? Don’t put words in my mouth.
You made it sound like you already had a ‘comfy chair’. Do you?
Why imply someone else seeks one?
A metaphor about fences says what about “blind obedience”? Does the observation that the Kremlin is run by untouchable murderous kleptocrats who’ve completely compromised the British government look “comfy” to you?
You appear to be comfy with that slightly tendentious proposition. I am wary of it. Russia has always been ruled by ruthless megalomaniacs when strong. I admire the historian who called Stalin the most recent of the great Tsars, despite all the theory about revolution and class warfare. I also distrust the simplistic bullshit we get served up from a system which us far less democratic than it claims to be.
Sure, you’re the wisest sceptic in the room 🙄
Guardian commenters will be mostly left-wing Momentum types. A bit like Lalia Harre in her views of the poisoning. Not a good guide in how to conduct foreign policy.
Even Corbyn has to had to back May to some extent, though presumably Momentumers wish he did not have to. Many of Corbyn’s Labour party MP’s have been highly critical of him on the Russia issue, but realistically they are powerless against Momentum. The British Labour Party is starting to be more like the Alliance Party of New Zealand, rather than the current NZLP.
As for there being no Russian undeclared spies In NZ, I think it is unlikely there are none, but who knows?
In some respects it is not really about undeclared spies, it is just sending someone home to make the point about solidarity. I imagine this is what most of the UK’s allies have done (but not us). Sending home one out of 17 would be no great hardship for the Russian Embassy.
We might find we are now on the slow track for a FTA with the UK.
Jacinda might have an awkward meeting or two with May and others in the UK next month. She might wish she had sent a Russian Embassy cook or driver home. Drivers are frequently spies.
Xanthe,
What fanciful conspiracy theory crap. Absolutely zero evidence for your assertion.
And if it was true, it would be fraught with enormous risk if it was discovered. It would just about destroy the US/UK relationship if it became public. Just do a risks/benefits analysis of such an operation to see whether it is even remotely plausible.
The Guardian’s not so bad – we can’t all be cryptofascist authoritarians like Wayne.
There’s an opening for you Wayne, in Northcote for the Natz, only 1 nomination if the post by James below is correct…
We all know parliament needs more lawyers (sarcasm) – one law for them, and one for everyone else.
Kinda a world trend to move everything away from people and put it into a series of lobbyist laws that have become narrower and narrower and more challenged over time by lawyers getting richer and richer, so that the public good and practicality aspects from our laws are being eroded, even if you do have enough money and time to challenge them.
Which is probably good for the British and bad for NZ. It was, after all, the policies of National and the NZLP of the last few decades that have caused so much increase in poverty in this Land of Plenty. And the same goes for the UK.
You say that like it’s a Bad Thing when it’s the exact opposite. In fact, we should be dropping out of all exiting FTAs and the WTO and putting in place a set of standards that other countries need to meet before we will trade with them.
Make it a Race to the Top rather than the Race to the Bottom that it has been for the last 30+ years.
“Make it a Race to the Top rather than the Race to the Bottom that it has been for the last 30+ years.”
+1
Well to be fair, we probably won’t be on a slow track for a FTA. Too important for both countries for this relatively minor matter to derail it.
The main consequence will a few awkward meetings. jacinda can use her charm to get through that easily enough.
The FTA with the UK really will matter. We will be aiming for tariff free entry of our foodstuffs. The UK could once again become a major market.
An FTA with the UK will just do what all FTAs have done – make us poorer.
Draco,
You do realise that New Zealand’s wealth was basically built on tariff free entry of our lamb, butter, cheese and wool to the UK from 1870 to 1970. This was the imperial preference, so it gave NZ a trade advantage above the US, South America and Europe, the other places capable of producing temperate agricultural products.
So rather than making us poorer, the tar if free entry of our products actually made us one of the most wealthy countries in the world. At the peak in the early 1950’s no 3 in living standards in the world.
Of course a 2020 FTA won’t produce quite the same effect, but it will certainly help, and will be 100% better for NZ than the EU’s highly restrictive agricultural import policy.
Britain leaving the EU is basically a net positive for NZ. We suffered a lot when they entered, we will gain as they leave.
But I guess ideology has blinded you to these rather obvious and well known facts.
You do understand that that is a load of bollocks right?
NZ wealth is our resources and our skills. If we hadn’t had that tariff free entry into the UK market we’d probably be richer as we would have been forced to develop more skills. There is, after all, only so much lamb that a small nation can eat.
Actually, it’s your ideology that’s blinding you to the facts.
“Actually, it’s your ideology that’s blinding you to the facts.”
It’s actually both of you.
To paraphrase – ideology is the last refuge of the scoundrel
Wayne and his ilk should be in prison for crimes** against humanity…
Having had opportunity to positively impact large numbers of those who genuinely need the most assistance…instead Wayne and his ilk simply move on with their organic being and planetary destructive indeology…
Most of everything Wayne was involved in government life has been a negative outcome against the most vulnerable…
That’s the legacy of Wayne and his ilk…
Selway – do you really repudiate all ideology and have none yourself? If so, you are a hollow man.
No – I just don’t fix my ideology to the point where I get blinded by it.
i.e – I can hold two contradictory POV’s and examine them against each other to see which makes most sense rather than rejecting something out of hand because it doesn’t fit my rigid beliefs. F. Scott Fitzgerald put it well when he said –
“The test of a first-rate intelligence is the ability to hold two opposed ideas in mind at the same time and still retain the ability to function.”
That sounds better, JohnSelway, assuming this reply appears where I hope it will.
Did Fitzgerald include chewing gum at the same time?
“New Zealand’s wealth was basically built on tariff free entry of our lamb, butter, cheese and wool to the UK from 1870 to 1970”
You forgot to mention, Wayne, what tariffs successive NZ governments imposed on those same goods, and numerous others.
Which incidentally gave us all permanent, full time, secure jobs.
Remember?
But which failed to develop our economy due to the reliance upon exporting lamb to the UK.
How can the utterly ideologically-driven, scared and in the pockets of those who’ve exchanged their fluids and who’ve only ever invested in propping up each other’s egos ever hope “to be fair” (going forward, ez a meta of fek, ekshuuly – even with the new found learnings of ear politikle circumstance).
Btw Wayne… how long does your current mefia gig contract last, and any plans for whennir expures?
“In fact, we should be dropping out of all exiting FTAs and the WTO and putting in place a set of standards that other countries need to meet before we will trade with them.”
That’s correct, and the way to do that is by creating the localised structures, whereby business chains for products can be established, self regulated & self represented within different industries, but not ‘needing to’ ban practises that under-cut necessarily but having them represented to the consumer for what they are in industry grading trade marks or seals that the govt provides the frameworks of, for their industries to co-ordinate in setting standards under.
And with the majority of consumers employed by such chains/organisations/guilds, they will vote with their wallets and employment interests, which whenever people have the opportunity to do so, is for higher value and quality.
That i believe, is the essence of what has economically built up, sustained & nourished the higher civilisations in the west over the centuries, despite the many historic follies or one type or another of their times.
What a pathetic response from wayne. Trying to have it all ways? Just send anyone home to appease the hawks in the British and US governments eh? Who cares who it is, the caretaker will do.
In case you have forgotten wayne, this government campaigned on transparent governance.
We are lead to understand the British government asked our government for support by way of expelling any “undeclared embassy attaches” who are suspected of intelligence activity. The government asked the NZSIS if we had any. The SIS apparently said no. I cannot see any reason why the SIS would lie about such a matter.
There are some parallels here with Helen Clark’s government who decided not to join the Coalition of the Willing when they invaded Iraq. Remember the hue and cry? I do… and many of the same faces are screaming hysterically again. Who was right? Helen Clarks’ government of course. There were no weapons of mass destruction – just a lie perpetuated by the British and American hawkes in order to get the masses on board with them.
I expect there are under-cover Russian agents in NZ. But they’re not – it would seem – directly attached to their Embassy. That would make it very difficult to flush them out. I’m sure if the SIS do manage to find them, they would be deported forthwith.
Anne….stop making sense, Wayne can’t handle it.
The guy never ceases to amaze, an in the abscence of 4th Estate, I guess his faux wisdom (just like that of a number of others) will go unchallenged. Or will it?
As we all now know in this day and age ofvthw 15 mins of fame and fortune and stardom
Pretty much the only thing that otivates the political class, politicians and their spin meisters, is the degree to which they sense potential embarrassment (alobgside their ability to either tolerate it or bury it.
Cynical I know but I think the record speaks for itself.
There is a level at which the politican, or the DHB Chief, or the ‘head of munstry or department’ can no longer survive
Thing is, it may well be that we’ll HAVE to resort to the dlovenly underhand nastiness opponents seem comfortable with (indeed tactics they consider normal) in order to survive I rue that day!)
Include jounalists in that first paragraph because we could include Sth Africans as members of a 4th Estate and their propensity for attraction to ‘daddy figures’ and raspy voices … even though they’re prepared to feel qualified to comment on thinga like domestic violence.
Or that ‘celebate’ thing that sits above an Eastern Suburbs sewerage plant whose no doubt familiar with its walking rracks where little Fijian BOIS claim to have had ‘encounters’….?True or False….doesn’t seem to matter.
Let’s not even begin with a Pulla BentFFS!
First up, other countries besides NZ have refused to take action. Second up, if the Guardian is a momentum shang li ra, then why the takedown of Corbyn when he called for more evidence after apparently seeing everything that had been shared with foreign governments (unprecedented amounts of info apparently).
And why the resurgent cries of antisemitism from the Guardian being leveled at Corbyn and UK Labour? Again.
The Guardian is a mouth piece for liberal interventionists. In my memory that’s been the case since Yugoslavia.
And alongside anti-Corbyn, anti-Labour, anti-Russia, we’re getting a pivot to anti-Chinese too. A piece from the other day about a purported war of human rights by Russia and China via the UN or somesuch?
Sorry I don’t have time to dig out links or take part in this exchange beyond this sole comment. There’s an ugly head of steam building behind something that would roll over anything not firmly behind western liberalism’s aggressive and interventionist stance/positioning in foreign policy and/or against domestic policies of violence via the economics of austerity.
Maybe in a day or two when I have some free time available again, I’ll look at a post on this slide the west is on.
New Zealand hasn’t “refused to take action”.
Yes. The hysteria our government is currently experiencing from the Nats and their MSM acolytes (and hysteria is not too strong a word imo) over matters of a relatively trivial nature is beginning to look like it might be part of a much larger strategy encompassing most of the so-called Western world.
In other words, setting up the masses for a major international power-play that could end in nuclear war-fare.
Xanthe,
What fanciful conspiracy theory crap. Absolutely zero evidence for your assertion.
yes and thats is exactly the same amount of evidence so far raised for “the Kremlin done it” your “cost benefit” argument also works either way.
I am not arguing either case , just pointing out that the evidential standard for action is not yet met.
expelling diplomatic staff on the basis of an untested assumption is just dumb, others may do so to symbolize which “side” they are on. our government has wisely declined to do so.
There is large amount of published evidence against Russia.
They are the only ones who produce the agent, and have a track record of using it. That is the prime evidence to date.
The evidential gap is which Russian operative(S) actually deposited the agent, both when and how.
But your post makes you seem like a Russian apologist believing everything Putin says.
As for our government “wisely” declining action, well I guess that is your view. Not mine however. In my view our government has looked rather foolish and naive.
Purely circumstantial and would never get a conviction in court.
So, the missing part is any evidence that they did it.
I really do prefer having a government that doesn’t work on hearsay.
One minor problem: diplomacy is not a judicial proceeding. As if the Kremlin would ever extradite anyone eventually charged, cf: Andrey Lugovoy.
True but we should still operate on more than well, these guys made this stuff back in the early 1970s and may possibly have used it before.
Especially when you consider how easy getting hold of that 1970s stuff would have been since the collapse of the USSR and that it’s highly unlikely that they’d still be using it.
Wow! It has that long a shelf-life! Are you sure? 🙄
reminds me of Battlefield Earth lol
Set a thousand years in the future, the humans use nukes and harrier jets that were sitting in an abandoned US base all that time…
Ugghhhh Battlefield Earth – I had almost expunged that crud from my memory.
One of L Ron’s biggest loads of cak – and that’s saying something.
Forgive me Tom Cuise !
Plus the nature of the target.
Plus the track record of similar people being murdered.
Plus the comments of putin & co.
Plus the tenuous nature of anyone else’s motive vs the risks to them if it backfires.
if you are going by court of law analogies then there is more than one piece of circumstantial evidence.
Russia is the only one known to produce said agent, the targeted individual was a known associate and critic of Russia and Russia has a track record of this sort of thing.
Once the circumstantial evidence mounts what is more likely? It is a false flag which requires more variables to succeed as a case or was it Russia which needs less variables. In scientific theory the theory that requires less variables is dominant over that which requires more. In the court of law it is similar in that simpler the explanation which has the most evidence is more often than not the case.
In this case – Russia
You’re quite simply wrong
Iran managed to synthesise it in late 2016 under the auspices of the OPCW, which indicates it is possible for countries other than Russia to do the same
Skripal was not a critic of Russia. He was paid good money to betray it
It has been reported that he missed Russia and wanted to return
He visited the Russian Embassy in London every month
I will supply links if you like
Pooty could’ve had him poisoned to send a message to some other loaded emigre he wants to toe the line fran, hard to know.
the baby talks a bit of a giveaway Gab
McFlock put it more simply than I:
Wayne, your published evidence please
This is the first time that Novichok has been used as an assassination attempt.
please link to your assertion Wayne.
It has killed one Russian chemist accidentally , and may or may not have been used by Russian gangsters against a Russian banker and his secretary. That remains purely hearsay as no chemicals in that case were analysed
The Soviet Union developed it, if they weaponised it, no one knows
The Soviet Union is not Russia
Uzbekistan anyone ?
The US decommissioning the Novichok facility in the 1990s?
Soviet chemists decamping to the west with all their knowledge and experience?
Seriously Wayne, it beggars belief that you are unaware of this
Several countries have had access to it
Iran under the auspices of the OPCW managed to synthesise it in late 2016
It is not uniquely Russian
Does all of your info come from newspapers and television?
Pointing out facts should never be the trigger to calling someone an apologist of any order
Take the childs blood out of your eyes and you’ll see more clearly Wayne …
According to Wikipedia Israel Zionists assassinate far more people …
And they use exotic poisons …. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KBT7o0piZ8E
well according to my reading wayne ANY half decent lab with suitably qualified technicians could make this stuff and interestingly inorder for the poms to correctly identify the nerve agent they would have to possess an identical match !!!
“left-wing Momentum types”
Almost as bad as ‘Socialists’, ay Wayne? Don’t want them Socialists.
Wayne
Don’t you think Putin would have done a cost/benefit analysis of his own?
Putin and his administration are not stupid. If you think they are I seriously doubt your intelligence on these matters
A cost/benefit analysis done by the Kremlin would quickly have shown that the target and poison chosen would have at first glance pointed to the Kremlin, and would have inevitably put at risk Nordstream 2, the World cup, the Astana group negotiations, and the exposure to OPCW investigations that would negate Russia’s much lauded destruction of chemical weapons in 2017.
I for one would be extremely proud if NZ was to regain its reputation as an honest broker in international affairs.
Why even pay lip service to the rule of law if we are prepared to deliver the verdict and divvy out the punishment before the investigation is complete?
I am glad we had a Labour govt headed by a feisty female PM that refused to “join the club” in Iraq in 2003
Who knows how long Jacinda and Winston can hold out against the pressures that are being brought to bear on them.
But I applaud them for their stand
Their “stand” is that they’re looking at sanctions and travel bans against a range of individuals because there’s no plausible alternative explanation other than Kremlin involvement.
The Kremlin isn’t being “stupid”, by the way – punishments have to be consistent, and in the case of traitors, harsh. These are practical measures to enforce discipline.
Spare me your disbelief and smears upon my character or cognitive abilities – I’ll take them as read.
That doesn’t stack up I’m afraid OAB
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/russia/8207750/Vladimir-Putin-Russian-secret-services-dont-kill-traitors.html
And this would be another first.
The spy swap program has always left ex spies off limits
Keeping it that way is to everyones interests
A breach means the collapse of the system, and it’s never been done before
I challenge you to show me where a spy who has been swapped and pardoned has then been knocked off, it is most definitely not consistent
From your link:
Perhaps you should’ve read your link.
The Chechen was a spy from a spyswap?
Do tell
Putin said “traitors”. The Kremlin doesn’t regard Chechen fighters as traitors?
Other analysis, mind you, has it that the Kremlin doesn’t have control over its various factions, who will often take unilateral actions in attempts to curry favour. A bit like running a crime family, I suppose.
I’ve been struck particularly by the way the Kremlin often comes across like Pauli Walnuts when discussing these matters. “Who knows what happened to your face? Maybe you fell over. Better be more careful next time.”
Never been done before?
It says in the lead of your own link that it was a practise used by the Soviets.
the Soviet Union is not Russia
move on
Oh, ok, so your idea of “never” is “not in the last thirty years, that I choose to know of”.
Putin probably did do a cost/benefit analysis.
On the basis of relative western inaction in the past on things like the invasion of Georgia, retaking Crimea, supporting Ukrainian separatists, supplying the missiles that shot down MH17, killing agents with polonium and nerve agents, interfering in elections, cyber attack against Estonia, he would have assumed no real reaction this time. In short he assumed he would get away with it, just as he had before.
I think this attack proved to be a straw that broke the camels back, just one too many annoying things that he has done, especially after the interference in both the US and the French elections.
It won’t result in war or anything like that, but it will mean a deep distrust of Putin and his circle. Will he want to reverse that?
Who knows, but historically Russia has not always been on the outer. For much of the nineteenth century they were valued allies, the Crimea war excepted.
Give your perspective, Wayne…for comparative reference…
Israel >> Palestine [any other local the rogue state is committing atrocities]
USA >> committing atrocities [pick a location]
Which nation has the highest known number of biological and chemical labs around the world?…
As for you continued parroting about election interference….you should be ashamed…no chance that you are though….
My guess is you appreciate the Rothschild banker…
Wayne is a known agent of the HAARP cabal and has links to Buzz Aldrin. Watch what you say 🙄
Buzz Aldrin you say… any link to the reverse vampires and the illuminati ?
Really!! Sanctions that have reduced economic growth, being kicked off the G8, the Mistral deal reneged on,Bulgaria heavied in to blocking south stream, the pain of Russian paraplegics as a group and other athletes not allowed to compete under their own flag, and the relentless and quite unhinged vilifications
I’m not even going to bother with the Russia meddled theme, it seems to be Cambridge Analytica after all…the upper levells of Brit society
Russia interfered in the French elections?
Do tell …France says otherwise
https://www.apnews.com/fc570e4b400f4c7db3b0d739e9dc5d4d
I’m staggered!
Russia attacked Georgia??
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-georgia-russia-report/georgia-started-war-with-russia-eu-backed-report-idUSTRE58T62120090930
oh dear me
I doubt he did a cost/ benefit analysis Wayne.
More likely he just did a macho man ego who are my whorshippers analysis.
Not to dissimilar from you ( or indeed a Hosking). Only difference being you did it under ther cover of being a mild mannered plonker whose managed to capture the 4th Estate into believing you’re fair and readobsblw. A bit like the Fair and balanced routine.
KEEP the chummy smarm up will you… it’ll ensure you continue to be a media rent-a-voice on Sundays alongside that thing called Boag…. and probably even a Wilson.
Apologies if I confuse a Q+A with a NATION.
they’ll consider me a philistine as they knock back a toast or two to the day’s achievement.
Geez Wayne! I’d thought you’d be all for making a buck and resume trade with Russia. What would 4 eyes say? We trade with China, and there not Lilly white.
francesca don’t fool yourself. Putin wanted the world to know.
yeah, Chuck, he was just so damned keen to out the highly secretive and illegal Novichok program that he’d kept under wraps, for the past 10 years, evading the gimlet eyes of the OPCW who were crawling all over Russia’s facilities.
Phew! he thought, got away with it, the bastards will never know, and here’s me with a clean slate.
Less than 6 months later….I’ve got a good idea , lets knock off that used up spy Skripal we pardoned yonks ago, and we’ll use Novichok to send a message to Europe and the US that a floundering UK needs to be rallied around and supported
That’ll show em!
And the World cup and Nordstream? fuckem, I just want to see the look on their faces
I guess Putin in his heart of hearts wanted to get caught, eh?
Yup – no deterrence from your murders if they look like natural causes.
Gotta use something really exotic – Novichok, Thalium, Polonium – see the pattern?
Patterns you say…
Yes, they’re all replicable…
Polonium was also used on Arafat.
I doubt very much by Russia
We might find the UK is still leaving Europe and still on the lookout for trading partners, even ones that don’t habitually obey her in foreign policy matters, wayney.
100% + aom …. Paula May is a puerile disgusting politician
she’s as dishonest as David Cameron ….. who is as dishonest as John Key … who is as dishonest as Bill English is .. Blair , Clinton, Trump etc etc
Who is Paula May?
Thanks for the pull up Marco … I must have had May subconsciously connected to Paula Hanson …. another disgusting politician.
Of course I meant theresa may …. who interestingly enough is friendly with the NZ connected Legatum stink tank … having spoken in front of the hypocrites.
The Legatum charade is a think tank that has been pumping out anti-russia propaganda for a while now https://pando.com/2015/05/17/neocons-2-0-the-problem-with-peter-pomerantsev/ ” Legatum turns out to be a project of the most secretive billionaire vulture capital investor you’ve (and I’d) never heard of: Christopher Chandler, a New Zealander who, along with his billionaire brother Richard Chandler, ran one of the world’s most successful vulture capital funds”
I call Legatum a charade because they produce this ” prosperity index” … where they rank countries.
But the New Zealand funders and founders run their business / vulture funds from tax havens like Dubai ….
Which makes them like traders in kiddie porn lecturing people about child abuse ,,,,
As Oxfam has correctly pointed out Tax havens, shadow banking and their corruption are the biggest drivers of poverty and inequality in the world.
So Legatum is a stink tank as opposed to think Tank …
Whats the difference between a vulture and a vulture fund Marco ???
A vulture fund is worse and actually makes the food for the vultures …
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_vulture_and_the_little_girl
I mean it when I say the T Mays … D Camerons … J Keys … and W Mapps of this world are disgusting people.
Of course any one of them would poison a couple of Russians …
But the Israelies have the most motive and past form for carrying out assassinations ….
Why the issue of UNDECLARED spies amongst the diplomats.
This.
“Colonel Skripal was convicted of passing the identities of Russian intelligence agents working UNDERCOVER in Europe to the UK’s Secret Intelligence Service, MI6.”
Thing is, our SIS does not know of any here (and if they did they are not silly enough to say they do so they get replaced by someone they do not know about – unlike the so called smart guys overseas who think they know better).
He wasn’t entirely supportive of Todd Mclazy’s baarping.
Intrustung the riddle little blubble that follows… rspeshlillyvant
Ex one labours under the lek o toim stemps and othe info the sage has omittedn ez relevant going forwid (or wid out)
A bit ssssprizing tho a prents own parna rwcently visited slightly less remoteness on mutha Erf to locationas on the GPS spatial plam I did
Maybe herein lies the tensions and elitism claims thst exist between a Prent TS AND A bradbury TDB.
MAY I SAY TO YOU BOTH how utterly fuvkkng gorgeus you BOTH are.
Goes without saying to your dedication to the very broad leff principills
Goes without saying that indupitably, indisoutavly, absoluterry there’s an overweighr inyoletant piece of blubber that happens to be the whurl’s bestest developerer of computer thingies ( and modest with it).
The beauty of the fishinsy an fektivness of his code is a thing to behold
Wel obsly, ya ken orl C the phet fungas en remote intermittance (that’s even been known to corrupt the character set).
Or maybe not.
Interesting times as I watch the policy ANALists from a dysfunctional PS Srutting their shit as forcibly as their future career patterns aĺlow them, and their seniors worrying about what and how their new munsters will be satisfied with the advice requested of ‘officials’…. JUST enough to look to be in tune with the new Munster, though not enough to be obstructive of any new policy or the pteservarion of a Statiss Kwo.
https://t.co/zWLQ2cAe2X
Julian Assange’s Internet access cut again by Ecuador embassy
I have looked at the pattern of “beat-ups” occurring and have become convinced they are all “Look over here” strategies by the opposition to distract from their serious past misdemeanors.
Almost “False news”, as the importance is magnified by the style of reporting.
The coalition is moving fast on many fronts, and the opposition have wanted to paint Jacinda as “muddled indecisive and not in control of her troops.”
Everything that has happened has had that same response.
It is orchestrated and there must be an opposition group planning for this, like a web.
What finally convinced me DP is again alive and well, was reading that Griffin had rung Lee before he published Hurshfield’s resignation.
I wonder who Ms Lee informed? And why? Just saying.
+111
National’s Dirty Politics never stops.
DP never died, Slater was a loose cannon, Hooten/Farrar/Eade/Williams etc all still at it and it’s up to the govt to own the narrative over the damage done by 3 terms of nact.
You’ve looked at all the incompetence and misbehaviour and concluded that the only reason for it all is that it’s been pointed out and highlighted and publicised?
You have terrific powers of deduction.
I suppose Minister Salesa has a national plant in her staff booking her the hotels in the good end of town and business class flights everywhere to make her look bad?
But draco gave you three internet points, so you must on to something.
I watched “The Hollow Men “again last night, along with the 20 minute interview with Nicky Hager
Its co ordinated alright , it has all the hallmarks , and our media is even less “big picture” than before, running like yapping dogs to the next beat up scandal of their own making.
Never asking the big questions and generally serving right wing interests
Thanks Francesca. Yes Hallmarks. Too many coincidental memes. Hager was awake to this very early. We have to stay awake as well.
“The coalition is moving fast on many fronts,”
Agree out the beehive door come 2020!
patricia bremner if your idea of DP is that the media or the opposition should not react to the incompetent bumbling of this current Government, then you will forever be outraged.
The opposition does not have any misdemeanours they need to cover up.
In case you have not noticed, National is simply doing what opposition’s are supposed to do. Holding the government to account. In this instance ably assisted by numerous government faux pas.
The difference to past oppositions is that there is 56 of them, with lots of parliamentary resource (the staff including research staff are proportional to their size). So they can do way more than an opposition of say 27 MP’s.
Perhaps the Easter break will give the government a chance to sort itself out.
Finlayson breaking the law is probably something that they wish would go away and National’s Dirty Politics seems to be working there.
We’re definitely not seeing any calls for criminal charges to be laid, an investigation or even his resignation. Instead we get the beat up about Clare Curran blown up out of all proportion.
Not the AG any more draco? not the government. the left were anointed by peters remember?
And he’s still in parliament as Shadow Attorney General.
https://www.parliament.nz/en/mps-and-electorates/members-of-parliament/finlayson-christopher/
So, yeah, after being found to have broken the law in his capacity as AG I would expect him to resign at the very least as he’s obviously not fit for the position. I would prefer that criminal charges be brought against him and those he worked with.
No, better have a 3 month reveiw first. make sure all the process are perfect and bow down to expert knowledge. Need to be sure he actually has broken the law
He’s already been found to have broken the law and that alone should result in his resignation.
What’s needed now is an investigation into if he did it on purpose and if it was part of a conspiracy by the National Party caucus to break the law.
… and dead Three year old children among the broken bodies of Civilians …. with Waynes bloody palm prints at the crime scene … or just at the cover up ?
🙄 That must be why he’s called for an inquiry.
I must have missed Wayne calling for an inquiry …. prior to Hager and Stephenson The authors of Hit & Run … made the initial case for one.
Wayne was a bellicose loud trumpet of a man … Along with get some guts key ,,, bemoaning our lack of participation in illegal wars.
Whereas mark Mitchell clearly proves there was some big money to be made in the Iraqi slaughter house.
Wayne was on the road to killing three year olds right from the beginning
Too lazy to Google it for yourself?
Waynes trash .. and thank you for giving me another chance to reiterate it … “Mapp said his role as Defence Minister meant he also knew people had been killed during Operation Burnham, and these were people acting as insurgents.” https://static1.squarespace.com/static/58bcc6ac893fc04255abbbcc/t/58cfb45a37c5819ccd2bfd50/1490014002150/?format=750w
Remember this war clown wanted New Zealand to be exempt from war crimes … about the same time he wanted to pile into illegal wars http://norightturn.blogspot.co.nz/2009/09/our-government-wants-us-to-be-rogue.html
Also before this warmonger Mapp was calling for any inquiry … there was a well coordinated and scripted smear campaign going on against Nicky Hager … it was almost identical to the one used against Jeremy Scahill …. when he exposed usa night raids in Afghanistan … killing pregnant women etc
Mapp was always going to kill children on the road he took us on.
What has he ever said about Nick Hager here on ‘ The Standard ‘??? … google that
9 years in government leaving a litany of abject social failure and corrupted activity lead from top down…
Makes holding the current govt to account all very hypocritical eh, Wayne
You must be so very pleased with the ‘systems’
Yup Operation Burnham was business as usual – a bit of “collateral damage”, a few brown kids, is no skin off Wayne’s nose.
The wretched state of the hospitals, the rivers that run with filth, the unreconstructed ruins of Christchurch – Wayne is proud of these things.
Look on these my works ye mighty and despair.
“Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare
The lone and level sands stretch far away.”
Nothing else remains but the judgment of historians, and poets.
The point of the poem was that Ramses II actually did accomplish great things, which after millenia had almost entirely decayed into nothingness.
Nat5 accomplished nothing great except fail.
And historians will pronounce upon that failure, hopefully in ringing terms of denunciation. The poets, including the songwriters, will have their turn, as well.
I think of the Rois Faléants of the Merovingian Dynasty in France in such times- the Do-Nothing Kings.
Or the Grand Old Duke of York whose military skills and decisiveness are still mocked in children’s rhymes.
Or that great Scottish ballad , “Flowers of Scotland”, where the English are told to go home and “think again.” As the National Party too has been told.
The judgment of history will not be kind in social histories written about this period. I hope I’m alive to read them……..
Rois Fainéants. Je suis désolé d’avoir mal écrit.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roi_fainéant
C’est la faute au portable?
Non, seulement mon erreur………..
One of Ramses’ achievements did survive – he set a standard for government by which lazy pretenders like the Gnats can be measured and discarded.
And in answer, Stuart Munro,to your 6.3 above, For why? So that the rich would pay less tax.
It’s all about priorities, and why people prioritise the way they do- from laziness, to carelessness, to narcissism to full-blown sociopathy; or from compassion, concern for justice, and humanitarian inclusiveness.
Agreed.
In fact if we assessed the Gnats by the ancient code of Ma’at, which considerably predates Ramses, they’re an abject failure:
4. I have not caused terror, nor have I worked affliction;
5. I have caused none to feel pain, nor have I worked grief;
6. I have done neither harm nor ill, nor I have caused misery;
7. I have done no hurt to man, nor have I wrought harm to beasts;
8. I have made none to weep;
9. I have had no knowledge of evil, neither have I acted wickedly, nor have I wronged the people;
10. I have not stolen, neither have I taken that which does not belong to me, nor that which belongs to another, nor have I taken from the orchards, nor snatched the milk from the mouth of the babe;
11. I have not defrauded, neither I have added to the weight of the balance, nor have I made light the weight in the scales;
12. I have not laid waste the plowed land, nor trampled down the fields;
13. I have not driven the cattle from their pastures, nor have I deprived any of that which was rightfully theirs;
https://gateway2thegods.com/2014/09/20/42-principles-of-maat-2000-years-before-ten-commandments/
The Gnats – 5000 years behind the times.
Or these for our Gnats.
23. I have caused no wrong to be done to the servant by his master;
24. I have not been angry without cause;
25. I have not turned back water at its springtide, nor stemmed the flow of running water;
26. I have not broken the channel of a running water;
27. I have never fouled the water, nor have I polluted the land;
Wonderful link, Stuart Munro! Thanks.
27 is a beaut.
Perhaps the Easter break will give the National Opposition a chance to overcome feigned hysteria and let sanity reign.
Unlikely. They’ll double down instead.
Yes. I was being tongue in cheek. Still, there’s always hope miracles will occur.
“National has no misdemeanors to cover up” LOL LOL Best laugh of the week.
National’s Attorney General found guilty of breaching Dotcom’s privacy, and refusing him his personal information…. leading to a $90 000 payment to Dotcom, and giving grounds for further litigation……
I accept there are more “soldiers on the ground” Wayne. It is how they fight….. a bit like the Aussie cricket team…. “must win at all costs” bugger democracy!!
Personally (as they say) i reckon CF has a number of things he should be worrying about..and I say that with genuine pity for the bloke
“The difference to past oppositions is that there is 56 of them”
The total is not a difference. Being in the same party is. Just a matter of coordinating different factions rather than different parties.
Skripal’s poisoning may have been aimed at destabilising Corbyn’s poll momentum by reviving cold war phobia, catching the Ardern government in its wake.
Never waste a classic response, but can fear and dread be sustained until the election ?
The Ardern government can ride it out but it will be an interesting shake-down cruise testing resilience, teamwork, judgement .. and a young mum.
Whose nappies will end up drying in the Beehive ?
“Whose nappies will end up drying in the Beehive”.
Probably Winston’s.
He is getting on a bit you know and really hasn’t treated his body very well.
https://www.weareverincontinence.com/incontinence-blog/alcohol-incontinence/
Good to see your personal attacks just don’t stop ah, alwyn. Not happy unless your deriding people, or putting them down.
Taking bets folks, what lie will alwyn try to perpetuate next, what piece of spin to discredit someone will fall from this Tory lick spittles mouth.
“Personal attacks”?
I realise that you are a bit upset about yesterday adam but when you make such an absolute idiot of yourself as you did then it is only to be expected that people may point out that you are talking rubbish.
You would be far better to follow Mark Twains advice
“It is better to keep your mouth closed and let people think you are a fool than to open it and remove all doubt”.
Yesterday you removed all doubt.
You could also do with dialing back the personal shit and focus on the politics.
Your a low life alwyn, you discredited and lied about people yesterday, and did not even have the decency to own up to your own lies and spin . Because let’s start being honest, spin these these days from Tory hacks who infest the internet are just lies – clever lies, but still lies all the same. You spent the whole day defending a lie to discredit people.
So maybe if you acted with some respect towards human beings who have served the community for 40+ years. I wouldn’t have to call you piece of *&^% that you are.
There, there.
As far as I can see the only people I might have been even the slightest condemnatory to were the people shown, on TV3, in the gaggle of people at the protest yesterday who were described as blocking an Emergency exit from the TSB Arena.
Surely you weren’t one of them? And surely you don’t think that that is an acceptable way to behave? The penny drops. You were blocking the door and you do think that is an acceptable way to behave. No wonder I am not your favourite person.
Not to worry. I shall try and have a look over the weekend to see whether it was a door that can be used for an emergency exit from the Arena premises. Would you like me to tell you my conclusion?
There you go again, a lying make shit up creep.
Oh, a window can be used as an emergency exit.
Just show us the signage that the protestors should have seen. To distinguish it from any old back door polluters might want to sneak out of.
I had dinner last night with a friend who has worked for the Fire Service. He says, and his statement is hard to argue with, that anyone who blocks any access from a building so that people on the inside can get out in an emergency is crazy. It doesn’t matter in the slightest whether it is marked from the outside or not.
After all, as you say, people will use a window if necessary.
The only place that signage is desirable to point to exits is inside the building for the benefit of people trying to escape. People on the outside should NEVER block exits, marked or unmarked, that would allow people inside the building to get out.
In his opinion the people who blocked up a door, any door, so that people couldn’t get out from inside in an emergency were, as I noted above, crazy.
I will still have a look over the weekend but I really don’t see that any protester can argue that it was excusable to prevent people getting out of the building because they didn’t put up a sign saying I shouldn’t.
I suppose you would say I can let off fireworks inside a building. I’ve never seen a sign telling me that I shouldn’t.
So now you’ve set the field for it to be a crime against humanity regardless of whether the dickheads knew the single-width door around the back (next to two freight doors) was a fire exit for a 500-person conference centre, you believe that blocking that exit compromised the safety of everyone inside (even with all the double-width crash doors running the length of the building around the front). Your commitment to workplace safety is commendable, and no doubt you will be wondering why the building wasn’t evacuated due to the imminent danger.
Of course, this is irrelevant to whether tv3 were adding a bit of creativity when they called it a “fire exit”.
I’m pleased to see that at least you class the people who blocked the doorway as being “dickheads”.
The rest is contemptible.
Were you a little embarrassed by the fact that you didn’t notice that the google earth photos you thought proved your case were in fact more that 3 years old?
Don’t be. I didn’t see it myself for at least 20 seconds.
Meanwhile I hope you don’t block doors from the outside in the future. Earthquakes and fires can happen any time.
Is “dickhead” substantively different from the “dicks” I called them two days ago?
The protestors’ actions weren’t going to trap anyone inside if there was a fire or earthquake in that instant. On your wee recon trip tomorrow, count all the other exits around the building, “fire” or just general.
The protestors were dicks because the pile of pallets served no purpose, they had enough people to cordon the building and see if anyone was sneaking out the back (yeah, it has happened before in the days of decent campus protests).
The pile did, however, give 3news the opportunity to give you guys something other than fossil fuel use and climate change to talk about. Now you’re quibbling over Streetview datestamps because fire exits in fixed structures are known for suddenly changing /sarc
So did you bother checking out the supposed “fire exit” on Saturday like you said you would? Or should we just figure that the streetview images were still pretty much the state of play and 3news iced the cake a bit much?
Hard to see how that’s anything other than a personal attack too adam. Maybe add some actual argument to your comment.
Oh, there you are, adam. Talking about taking bets, that reminded me that I have been meaning to ask you how things are going with your prediction at 4.2 on Open Mike on 22 March.
In response to savenz’s provision at 4 of a link to an article re US Treasury Secretary Mnuchin saying that the US will consider re-entering TPP, you said at 4.2 that:
As I said, by the end of March the USA will be back in.
It’s now 29 March, so only a few days to go to the end of March. Shall we take bets or have a countdown?
Washington DC is currently 17 hours behind NZ but this falls back to 16 hours at 2am on Sunday, 1 April in NZ with the end of Daylight saving. So midnight on Saturday, 31 March in Washington DC is 4pm on Sunday, 1 April in NZ. That is just under 75 hours from now.
Can’t see it happening myself and the very first paragraph of the CNN article on Mnunchin’s statement did qualify it by saying The United States will consider re-entry to the Trans Pacific Partnership once Washington accomplishes its goals on other trading relationships, U.S. Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin said while on an official visit to Chile on Wednesday.”
https://www.cnbc.com/2018/03/21/us-will-consider-re-entering-tpp-treasury-secretary-mnuchin-says.html?__source=sharebar%7Cfacebook&par=sharebar#_gus&_gucid=&_gup=Facebook&_gsc=6Zy6dBd
My prediction is that those “goals on its other trading relationships” are going to take a very, very long time – years, and probably never as long as Trump is President.
PS – And as you can see, I am trying to engage – as you told me to do back in February.
I’ll admit I was wrong if the USA don’t sign up by the end of the month. Big deal I’m not perfect, nor do I think I am.
Friday afternoon pedantry …..You’re = you are.
Its Thursday!!
That’s just really completely inappropriate behaviour, alwyn.
You may be right. Perhaps you think I should follow the example given in this comment. He is demonstrating that you should only think kind things about your fellow man.
And where exactly in there did I go around claiming that an MP had incontinence and criticising someone on that basis?
Don’t dissemble away from the fact that your statements aren’t acceptable.
“the 59 psychopathic brainwashed bastards known as the National Party MPs “.
Could you demonstrate, to at least a reasonable level of certainty that they were ALL psychopathic individuals. Signed diagnoses by qualified and registered Psychiatrists (or should it be Psychologists?) who have examined each of them would seem to be required.
Also can you please prove that in every case their parents were not married? Otherwise I must assume that they were just wild claims with not the slightest hint of truth to them.
But you know that don’t you?
😆 doubleplusgood looking more like trebleXhypocrisy.
Actually, he (or she) is one of the politer ones. Sometimes gets a bit carried away of course, but doesn’t everyone?
I am very much in favour of the sack everyone approach, and the nationalise everything approach. This is mostly because weaker options repeatedly fail.
Jeepers. The conspiracy theorists are out in force on Open Mike today.
+1 Kereru – just ignore it , or do a Natz are get the media in a lather with fake news about your rivals. In the case of the Natz, any scandal is probably is not fake.
Also be normal. Say the previous government left the country in a horrible state with mouldy hospitals, public services in disarray, democracy on the decline and biohazards… and the governments priority is to concentrate on that….
I think the destabilising of the Govt is opposition priority and it appears to be aiming at Jacinda like a juggernaut. I hope that she has seen the tv bit where Kieran Read is advising the warriors on what to do when play gets a bit disjointed and out of sorts. His advice was just to stop and breathe and clear your mind and reset. Good advice and it worked for the Warriors. I hope she keeps on believing in herself ands not give in to the baying hybrid terriers across tbe room. Most of them are incompetents who ate just there to say their lines. Govt should have a pushback for any accusation delivered by Si et am. Goodness knows there is plenty of dirt there. All they have is the battering ram approach which will eventually show them up to be totally bereft of any ideas as shown in last 9 years. Bullying is ugly and does nobody any favours. Stay serene and classy Jacinda. And breathe!
To Ffloyd at * : + 1000 and I know our P.M. is well able to cope with the onslaught. I have disdain though to those who would add to her burdens, in particular those involved in DP.
So strong opposition and holding the Government account is now “Dirty Politics” is it? Good to know.
This isn’t strong opposition – no principles. Noisy though.
to Sam at 8.1.1: Your words, not mine.
Sam, Constant unremitting attacks for every little thing from MSM and National quarters echoing each other is telling. Similar tone and content, full of words which lead to innuendo. Mostly nasty.
Heather Grimwood, being the PM of a country is not for the faint of heart. If you want Ardern wrapped up in cotton wool then you better suggest to her a change of occupation.
1000% Ffloyd.
Finally some sense in the legal system… climate change has gone from being in the domain of climate denialisms to actually being taking seriously as an issue in the legal system.
Didn’t the Natz changed the law to have the special courts for oil exploration?Interesting to see how it goes.
Increasingly citizens are having to deal with environmental issues themselves legally aka Sarah Thompson and all around the world, as inexplicably government lawmakers feel it is irrelevant and profits is the only thing of importance than long term survival of resources.
From Greenpeace
“This is huge! 13 people were arrested protesting construction of a fracked-gas pipeline because of its contribution to climate change. Yesterday, the judge agreed the climate crisis made their actions a legal necessity—and set them free. This is unprecedented. And relevant now in NZ as Greenpeace NZ’s Russel Norman prepares to head to court next month to defend charges brought against him and Greenpeace for a protest at sea against oil exploration on similar grounds.”
This report that a judge aquitted people because of climate change seemed so unlikely that I checked reports on the case. In fact Greenpeace was wrong. The legal necessity point was never able to argued in front of the judge. They were not convicted but for other reasons, basically they had not really affected the pipeline construction.
Greenpeace and the truth…not happy companions.
Yes, because the environment is so +++healthy and happy+++. No pollution or climate change happening at all… la la la
Oh I wouldn’t say that. It’s just a shame the environment has such a rotten advocate.
Baba Yaga National and the truth? Key, Joyce, Bennett, …. Slater, Ede, Barclay, Collins, English and Uncle Tom Cobley and all. LOL LOL.
Greenpeace are very known for being painfully honest.
“Greenpeace are very known for being painfully honest.”
Snort.
Greenpeace lies at will. It is an inherently dishonest organisation that breaks the law at will.
Here’s some additions to my previous list:
https://www.vitalchoice.com/article/greenpeace-pulls-a-pinocchio-on-alaska-pollock
“It does not matter what is true, it only matters what people believe is true.”
“Paul Watson (a Greenpeace founder) attributes this quote to Dr. Patrick Moore, another Greenpeace founder, in 1981. Others have attributed it to Paul Watson or to David McTaggert (yet another founder of Greenpeace). Either way it was frequently said by the leaders of the organization. It has been sort of a mantra for them. ”
https://andymaypetrophysicist.com/greenpeace-crimes-and-lies-2/
https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/92308256/greenpeace-lying-for-financial-gain-professor-says-of-seismic-surveying-opposition
[citation needed]
Seriously?
http://roughlydrafted.com/RD/Home/ABC6DFDA-9DE9-4EA8-A269-65EAAB628676.html
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/greenpeace-accused-of-telling-lies-in-advert-watchdog-bans-anti-nuclear-image-1447196.html
https://myaccount.news.com.au/sites/couriermail/subscribe.html?sourceCode=CMWEB_WRE170_a&mode=premium&dest=http://www.couriermail.com.au/news/queensland/greenpeace-again-caught-using-misleading-photos-in-great-barrier-reef-campaign/news-story/7d2dd346c69006b3db81ec65c9768ad4?memtype=anonymous
https://www.thegwpf.com/green-activists-withdraw-adverts-which-falsely-claim-price-of-wind-energy-has-fallen-by-50-per-cent/
None of which addresses what I asked a citation for.
Perhaps be clearer about what you want a citation for?
I replied to Wayne. Baba Yaga responded as if I responded to him.
Apologies…I thought you were responding to my post /open-mike-29-03-2018/#comment-1467460. My bad.
Brilliant news. Perhaps the “age of denial” has begun to end!!
If it was a nasty Russian nerve poison used, why did it take such a long time to act? Since it reportedly causes instant death how could father and daughter have travelled from home to go for a coffee in town? And they still live. (Police say now that the greatest concentration was at their front door.)
Be devastating if it was not the Russian poison. It would leave NZ as above the chaos (though one Bridges would somehow claim victory for him) and where would it leave May?
It causes instant death? I’m sure you checked before saying so, but I just wonder whether you can provide a source for your assertion. Just in case for example, the systemic effects can be delayed by up to eighteen hours or something.
I believe that the news report was that the poison written about is skin touch instant death. Of course I don’t know the detail but I am just wondering if the whole issuen is genuine. If not….
Always pays to check the shit journalists write.
a tl;dr would be that yes the chemical could have acted in the way posited?
If you mean “instant death”, I don’t think so. From reading other material, I’ve come to the conclusion that one of the reasons this particular nerve agent was used is that it provides for a very painful slow death with maximum humiliation inflicted. People experience terrifying hallucinations and lose control of their bodily functions.
Colonel Skripal will have been under no illusions as to what was happening to himself and his daughter, just as Alexander Litvenenko was given weeks to contemplate his inevitable death.
I meant the original theory about what had happened i.e. not always instant death (haven’t been following that closely).
Lots of context to consider. Especially if, as alleged, the Kremlin continues to maintain chemical weapon R&D and production facilities. So the Skripals et al may have been poisoned by something newer than the existing knowledge about “Novichok”.
But broadly speaking, based on what I’ve seen in news reports, yes.
Thanks OAB. Appreciated the correction.
They still have to find out who delivered it.
How do you know what “they” have discovered?
And yet Yulia’s condition is much improved!
To your disappointment, medical care will do that. The link also provides info regarding treatment.
Table 5.1 says “Inhaled: seconds to minutes
Skin contact: minutes to hours” for nerve agents as a class.
Inhalation is quicker because it’s a more direct and higher volume path to the bloodstream and distribution throughout the body. Because that’s exactly what the lungs are supposed to do. Whereas skin is a protective barrier.
But there’s often an argument about the phrase “instant death” between medics who might see a significant window of opportunity to save the life of an unresponsive patient and those people who are simply interested in the practicality of when that patient becomes unresponsive and generally stops moving.
edit: and the varying timeframes will be mostly related to dose and individual physiology (e.g. exercising when dosed = stronger blood flow = quicker poison distribution).
This is ironic.. in a bad way.
The Galapagos are one of the world’s last havens for wildlife — pristine islands where giant tortoises, blue-footed boobies, and penguins live as they have for thousands of years.
But tourism and development have recently skyrocketed, destroying the home of animals and plants found nowhere else on the planet — leaving many species on the brink of extinction.
Basically their habitat being destroyed to make way for all the hotels and so forth for the tourists to come and see the endangered native species…
Former Green Party looking to stand for the Nats:
http://www.newshub.co.nz/home/politics/2018/03/vernon-tava-tipped-to-seek-national-nomination-for-northcote-by-election.html
Will be interesting.
Makes sense.
Anyone know when the by-election is?
Yeah – Completely full of himself – never understood what the Green Party actually stands for. I wonder if he had ever read the charter?
Fits into the Nat Party profile perfectly.
Im guessing he knows more about the Green party and what it stands for than yourself.
He has been very clear on how he believes the Greens have changed.
Obviously your guesses aren’t much cop.
“Im guessing he knows more about the Green party and what it stands for than yourself.”
Except he had to leave the party because he was working against what the party was and wanted, so I wouldn’t see him as a good source of what the GP is or should be. Better to see him for what he is, a RW greenie who wanted the GP to form governments with National.
I’d take Macro’s views on the GP more seriously than Tava’s, on the basis of what each of them has said and done.
Fwiw, when he was pushing his agenda in the Greens, I engaged openly with him online and only later realised that he really did want the GP to form govt with National. He wasn’t honest about that at the time. That alone is a big red flag. He is way better suited to being with National.
I’ve never spoken to him. But the way I have read it was that (in his view) the green should be “open” to working with any party of it achieved some of the GP goals.
As opposed to alignment with labour only.
The Greens are open to working with any party, that is both history and current position. The Greens will work with any party where there is shared policy.
Tava wanted the Greens to actively open the way to working with National by supporting them to govt via C/S or coalition. The problem with that is there is very little shared policy, so it would mean losing a whole bunch of LW voters for very little useful policy gain. No-one in the Greens wants to do that. It’s not a matter of being aligned with Labour, it’s a matter of which parties align with GP policy and principles?
I know that there are righties that want the GP to support a Nat govt because they want the Nats to be more environmental. But the Nats aren’t, that is the whole point. Key’s govt was the antithesis what the Greens are doing and there is no middle ground on which to meet unless National changes.
Far better for people like Tava to be in National and try and make changes there and then potentially down the line the two parties might work on policy together again. Hard to see coalition or C/S on the horizon though.
Tava will misrepresent the Greens because that’s how he does politics. This is another reason why he shouldn’t be in the Greens. I would have far more respect for him even as a National MP if he wasn’t doing that.
+1
3-0, All Blacks, Lions.
National will win.
James’ guesses rock!
Hey Robert – Im making an effort on my post not to try and start flame wars.
Your petty snide comments are the kind of thing that simply encourage it (or indeed start it)
Yes I was out by one on the Rugby results – WOW! big deal yet you seem to be fixated on it.
I dont think I said National would win – I was always comfortable that they were going to get a lot more votes than Labour.
What I think I said was that NZF would go with National. And yep – I got that one right. Then came on here – admitted I was wrong and congratulated Labour on the win – yet (again) you are petty and keep raising it like its a huge thing.
So how about you try to raise your game as well and comment on the points huh?
My suggestion is to just ignore it.
Relax, James; there’s no shame in being completely wrong.
Try to enter into the spirit of things here; you’re amongst friends (just taihoa on the pronouncements, see, we don’t rate your ‘reckons”
Robert – You need to take trolling classes. This attempt is pathetic.
I would not advise him to take those classes from whoever taught you, James.
He couldn’t afford to – it comes as part of my get paid per post deal.
I can remember him mansplaining the Charter during the co-leader election.
Yep I recall that.
Just reposting this extract By Donna Miles… in the context of is this the society we want to become???
“If you want to get a feel for how far economic markets can encroach on our everyday lives then you can do no better than to read Michael Sandel’s book on this very subject, titled: “What Money Can’t Buy: The Moral Limits Of The Markets”.
Sandel, a professor of government at Harvard University, offers many examples that clearly demonstrate how market thinking can easily cross the moral line and lead to shocking degradation of societal values.
Sandel mentions the “dead peasants” insurance policies.
Imagine taking out a life insurance policy on a person totally unrelated to you.
A lawsuit in the US revealed that Walmart had hundreds of thousands of such policies on its employees and enjoyed a small windfall whenever one of them died.
And how about the “viaticals”? A new market, where investors can invest in buying out life insurance policies of people with Aids.
Aids sufferers taking part in this scheme are offered a cash lump sum as well as payments for their treatment until they die- after which, the investors receive the full value of their life policy.
Sandel’s examples are not limited to the insurance industry. Students in the UK were encouraged by an advertising agency to rent out their foreheads for about $8 NZ dollars per hour for a temporary tattooed advertising space.
A single mother auctioned off her forehead for a permanently tattooed advertising space to pay for her son’s education. The winning bid, Sandel says, came from an online casino.
There is a charity that invites donors to contribute to reducing the birth of children to drug and alcohol addicted women by offering 300 US dollars cash incentive for every female addict willing to get sterilized.
And if you are a prisoner in Santa Barbara in California, you can pay to upgrade your cell for 82 US dollars per night.
You see, in a market society, there is almost nothing money cannot buy.”
https://thedailyblog.co.nz/2018/03/29/tppa-from-a-market-economy-to-a-market-society/
“And how about the “viaticals”?”
Most of the things you mention sound appalling but I am not sure about this one.
If you had no dependents who deperately needed the money from your life insurance policy why not sell it?
Remember the old saw about “‘Do you want to be the richest corpse in the graveyard”?
I think that forfeiting wealth after you die to get the benefit of the money for treatment now could be a very sensible choice.
If you had no dependants why would you have life insurance?
Two possible reasons.
The first is that I meant this as a single phrase
“If you had no dependents who deperately needed the money”.
If your kids have grown up and are all in successful careers they no longer need money from you. You can give up on the Life Insurance you used to require. However you may have chosen to keep it.
The second is that you may have taken insurance when you were young, or got married, because you might need the cover in the future and weren’t sure you would be able to get it at a later time. If you go back to my era that would be whole of life as the term insurance wasn’t as readily available.
Either way you could have historical policies that aren’t needed now but could still exist.
Don’t some banks demand you have life insurance when your deposit on a mortgage is < 80%?
Just clarifying the Walmart insurance, its wasnt for its everyday staff, just high level employees.
Just as you cant insure someone elses car ( you dont have an insurable interest) you only insure senior employees who you can show their death will affect your business.
That sounds rather more reasonable.
It really isn’t that different from a company insuring the two principals in a small jointly owned business. If one dies the money will pay out the widow, or family , of that person. It is much simpler than keeping the ownership shared between the active, surviving, partner and the silent partner ownership of someone who doesn’t know that much about the business but has inherited half the shares.
If you think some of that is sounding depraved… taking out insurance on your employees so you make money when they die…. make a submission ….. I guess in the single mother’s case, what to do if your WINZ payments are not enough.
NZ needs the right to make it’s own rules about the society it wants, not have subtle and unsubtle pressure to go in a market driven direction where anything goes…
https://www.parliament.nz/en/pb/sc/make-a-submission/document/52SCFD_SCF_ITE_76583/international-treaty-examination-of-the-comprehensive-and
Ecuador says they took Jule’s internet connection off him because Spain was pissed off over him putting his oar into the Catalan dispute.
/
QUITO, Ecuador (AP) — Ecuador’s government said Wednesday it has cut off WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange’s internet connection at the nation’s London embassy after his recent activity on social media decrying the arrest of a Catalan separatist politician.
In a statement, officials said Assange’s recent posts “put at risk” the good relations Ecuador maintains with nations throughout Europe and had decided as of Tuesday to suspend his internet access “in order to prevent any potential harm.”
Assange has since gone silent on social media.
http://www.stltoday.com/news/world/ecuador-cuts-wikileaks-founder-assange-s-internet-at-embassy/article_b6c51587-ebf3-5d93-8e65-170239c06fd8.html
In response to allegations reported in the stuff article below, is it now time to shed some additional light into the spread of Palantir’s activities within NZ which seem to be shrouded in a lot of secrecy still?;
https://www.stuff.co.nz/technology/digital-living/102690350/emails-link-peter-thiels-palantir-to-facebooks-cambridge-analytica-fiasco
And given Peter Thiel’s and Facebook’s alleged links to Cambridge Analytica, is it time that ministers of the NZ Government review seriously the past approval of NZ citizenship to Mr Thiel, and the associated approval of land purchases within our country?
These yearly population blow outs need to be turned around in my view.
https://www.odt.co.nz/news/national/nz-hits-record-net-migration-gains
That’s over half the population of Dunedin in 10 years. Kiwi build will have to become city build. And in order to supply cheap labour too.
Free Trade fiasco economics. Totally at odds with NZ’s traditional first world economic value system and societal cohesion.
Don’t worry. Mr Shaw has succeeded in meeting your wish.
As of about 3 weeks after the census we have only recorded about 3.5 million people in the country. That’s if I remember accurately what last weekend’s paper said.
That is a drop in the recorded population of the country of about 10 times the population of Dunedin. I’m sure you will be pleased.
Alwyn, you keep on sowing these seeds of distrust.
Posted 20 March 2018, 11:30am.
https://www.stats.govt.nz/news/census-on-track-for-70-percent-online
So two weeks AFTER census date they have accounted for about 3.46 million people out of the 4.8 million or so that most people would have said lived here.
Seems quite close to my memory of what was in last weekends paper doesn’t it?
I wonder how many they will get to after a few more months.
Perhaps Mr Shaw should have spent some time in New Zealand seeing that the Census was on track rather than spending $27,000 or so and generating tons of carbon emissions on a jaunt to Paris.
I suppose we should just enquire of James that famous quote from during the war.
“Is your journey really necessary?”
https://www.google.com/search?q=is+your+journey+really+necessary+ww2+poster&rls=com.microsoft:en-NZ:IE-SearchBox&tbm=isch&source=iu&ictx=1&fir=4znBbbHLVxPFjM%253A%252CNmoJwVw_cNISRM%252C_&usg=__VpDLrTXq6sldvXjQvHWX1M8CreQ%3D&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjCxOictpLaAhWFKJQKHfrjBWwQ9QEIKTAA#imgrc=TCRFVQK1vaq3bM:&spf=1522357130993
Alwyn, your strawman is on fire!
I have no idea of those newspaper items you are referring to because you have not provided a single link. As for your memory, I do worry about your reading comprehension, your biased way of ‘arguing’, your single-minded bashing of Labour and particularly the Greens, and your obsessive-compulsive erecting of strawmen and then burning them. To paraphrase your quote: “is this really necessary?”.
If you want accurate and up-to-date information with minimal spin you should go to a verifiable trustworthy primary source, e.g. https://www.stats.govt.nz/news/census-on-track-for-70-percent-online in this instance. For everything else you go to MSM or RWNJ blog sites.
I really didn’t think you would need a reference to the newspaper given that you had the “Accurate” etc etc data, and I mentioned it also.
Here is the stuff article which I talked about
https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/102523003/census-2018–filling-in-the-gaps
3.2 million on line and 300,000 via forms as I said.
And here is Jame’s jaunt to Paris.
” Climate Change Minister James Shaw spent $26,712 on international travel – he travelled to Europe for climate change meetings”
https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/politics/102175450/ministerial-spending-figures-show-crown-limos-put-to-use-by-new-government
If you don’t like the numbers from the paper here is the amount from Internal Affairs.
https://www.dia.govt.nz/diawebsite.nsf/Files/Ministers-Expenses-Oct-Dec-2017/$file/Ministers-Expenses-Oct-to-Dec-2017.pdf
Are you going to claim I was exaggerating because I said “spending $27,000 or so” and it was only $26,712?
As far as the carbon goes even a single passenger from Wellington to Paris generates 15.8 tonne in Business class. I believe there was another person along so it really should be doubled.
https://co2.myclimate.org/en/portfolios?calculation_id=1114198
There, does that satisfy your thirst for knowledge?
Thank you for the link to the Stuff article, which was very informative. However, as far as I can tell it did not include the key piece of information regarding the anticipated total response rate at the end of the census data collection period, which is had not yet ended, which could (would?) have corrected your comment @ 17.1, which turns out to be baseless:
As to your other comments regarding James Shaw and you exaggerating, I have already told you that your strawman is on fire. But you already know this, don’t you?
“which turns out to be baseless”.
Rubbish. In places where I mentioned the population I carefully said “recorded population”. I said
“we have only recorded about 3.5 million” and “drop in the recorded population” and finally “two weeks AFTER census date they have accounted for about 3.46 million”.
Those statements were all accurate. That is all that they have so far accounted for.
I cannot remember in previous occurrences of the census that they had to keep trying to get information and having to take out forms for months after the actual day.
They sent everyone forms in the past. They sent people, lots and lots of people, out to collect them in the week or two after the day. They weren’t left with only a few people trotting out with forms and trying to track down at least a quarter of the population ages after census day. I don’t remember the collection period being measured in many months. Memory says they collected ours within a week. Perhaps those people were expected to cost more. At least the results would have some similarity to reality.
The organisation of this years version was a shambles and Shaw has to wear the blame for not making sure that it could work. He can’t claim it wasn’t him. Meanwhile he was off at a talkfest on the other side of the world.
Please God the same people aren’t allowed to try and put the election on line.
As far as I know this was the first Census that could be completed online. As far as I know they’ve always had an extended period of data collection.
Given these considerations, this assertion of yours is therefore completely unfounded (i.e. baseless) and you know it:
Meanwhile I can still smell smoke; something is on fire …
Edit: https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/101266340/onlinefirst-census-to-revamp-unsustainable-pen-and-paper-model
Have a good Easter, Alwyn.
Do you really believe the first statement you made?
“As far as I know this was the first Census that could be completed online”.
Oh dear. For your information.
“In 2006, New Zealand was one of the first countries in the world to test-run an online census. There was a seven per cent online completion rate.”
and
“By the 2013 census, just over a third of New Zealanders – 34 per cent – took part online”
These are both from
https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/101266340/onlinefirst-census-to-revamp-unsustainable-pen-and-paper-model
You appear to have linked to it but not bothered to have read it.
They were simply trying to save money on this census and thought they could get away with only supplying forms for people who contacted them to ask for the forms. Naturally a hell of a lot of people who were going to need them didn’t do so.
They also didn’t provide id numbers to a lot of people. Retirement homes were a particular problem.
Now, even when they do get hold of uncounted people they are going to have to remember who was actually in the house on Census day. In a lot of homes, and flats, that isn’t actually as easy as it sounds as the days, and weeks, and shortly months tick away.
The Stats department are desperately trying to catch up. Even now they are making statements about “the total response rate is anticipated to be well above 90 percent “. It has been historically about 98% in recent censuses. When I see “well above 90%” I don’t think 98%. I think about 93% is what he means.
They have stuffed up and stuffed up badly.
The real shame is that it will affect the low-income areas as services to places often depend on the numbers counted in the census and I think they will be disproportionally omitted.
I suspect in another month or to there will be an unannounced forced resignation or two from the Stats Department.
to Sam at 8.1.1: Your words, not mine.
So, the capitalists keep telling us how great capitalism is. And then we get news like this which shows socialism doing better.
I find his writing a bit turgid at times, but he’s always interesting
Thank you Scoop
http://www.scoop.co.nz/stories/WO1803/S00160/diplomatic-madness-the-expulsion-of-russian-diplomats.htm
The “interesting” aspects of this whole sorry saga from my perspective, apart from the obvious goodwill towards the victims and desire to see justice done, are the reasons the British government cannot go after all the laundered property in London, rather than this rather feeble stand.
For if they go after Kremlin-laundered cash in London, then that is a much larger can of worms involving far more individuals from far more nations.
Pauli Walnuts would rub their faces in it.
It is wrong to attribute guilt for an assassination attempt against private Russian wealth in the UK.
It’s a state-directed action.
If Corbyn wants to go after ill-gotten capital gains, they may as well wipe out The City. Which would not be a bad thing., on the whole.
I didn’t attribute guilt to private Russian wealth, except inasmuch as Kremlin kleptocrats with relatively modest salaries launder their money in London.
London’s money laundering activities go far beyond that, though, which is why they won’t do anything about it.