web analytics
The Standard
Advertising

No details, please, we’re gallery hacks

Written By: - Date published: 1:17 pm, January 31st, 2014 - 174 comments
Categories: david cunliffe, john key, labour, making shit up, Media, Politics - Tags:

The situation David Cunliffe has found himself in this week over Labour’s new early childhood policies neatly demonstrates one of big problems with Labour’s communications strategy – information overload.

Perhaps it is something of a hangover from the days of Helen Clark, who was on top of every little detail at any given moment, but Labour seems to think that producing screeds of information on their policies is both necessary and desirable. They think people will be impressed by how clever they are.

In fact, all they are doing is giving the media more rope to fashion a noose for Labour’s neck.

Political journalists do not require any special qualifications. They go to journalism school to learn how to structure an article and avoid being sued. There is no test you must pass to become a Gallery hack proving that you understand policy, economics or statistics.

Gallery hacks don’t know any of this stuff because they don’t need to. Their job is write ‘colour’ pieces about the ‘cut and thrust’ of politics. Long, boring wordy stuff with charts and numbers is both too much for their brains to handle and not what they are looking to write about anyway.

Put simply, a political reporter is only interested in one thing – who is winning or losing. The way they decide who is winning is based on what they decide public opinion on an issue is. Their opinion is not shaped by facts or charts or graphs, but on behaviour. They watch for every little stumble, every umm or aah, every nervous tic or slight change in the tone of a voice. They don’t really care who is right or wrong, only who looks and sounds convincing. When they smell uncertainty they start circling like sharks who’ve spotted a bleeding surfer.

Contrast National’s media strategy on their recent education announcement. John Key rocks up, announces something out of the blue, gives a bare minimum of detail and saunters away. The media spend their time frantically ringing around getting opinions from people and typing furiously about how National’s policy will be received. Hardly anything is known about how this policy will actually work in practice, but no one cares. The media pronounces it a winner because the people they have rung for comment by and large support it.

No journalist spends much time dogging Key with questions about the detail, because they have gotten what they wanted and moved on.

Labour, on the other hand, puts out a great deal of detail, leaves itself open to an easy attack by John Key, the journos smell blood and start ripping chunks off Cunliffe and he starts playing their game, apologising and promising to be more careful in future. Then he gets defensive and starts complaining about their bias.

Reactions like these get you nowhere with the media. Being meek marks you out as a victim for the slaughter and being defensive leaves you looking like a sore loser. The John Key playbook – acting like you’ve done nothing wrong even if you have committed a howling error – is a much better move here. Confidence marks a person as a winner, no matter what the facts are.

If Labour is going to win the election this year then they need to smarten up their game. No details, please, we’re New Zealanders.

Blue

174 comments on “No details, please, we’re gallery hacks”

  1. Paul 1

    A corrupted corporate media

  2. lprent 2

    Looking at the front page today, we seem to be having a media morning. No, it isn’t some vast conspiracy – just happens to be what turns up.

    In this case the reaction of the media to Labour this week was somewhat marked when compared to their credulous awe they displayed in the previous week at Nationals completely vague announcement about paying star teachers more.

    Somehow I never saw ANY journalists asking the obvious question. With all of these 5000 or so teachers partially removed from the schools that they are working at. Then where the schools are going to get the money to pay for reliefs whilst the stars are off elsewhere. That didn’t appear to have been part of Nationals announcement?

    It is hard enough for schools to get teachers already without pulling a pile of them off into some kind of mentoring/training role. Are we going to train more teachers to fill this gap?

    But then I guess few journalists have had to actually run an organisation with all of the basic management involved with missing staff eh?

    They really do appear to be just as shallow in their depth of understanding of the real world as Blue suggests. I suspect that his prescription is correct. Feed them less information and count on them being too over-worked or just damn lazy to dig for anything more.

    • Hayden 2.1

      Then where the schools are going to get the money to pay for reliefs whilst the stars are off elsewhere. That didn’t appear to have been part of Nationals announcement?

      I vaguely recall seeing something about schools being funded for replacements, both for teachers and principals. It didn’t address where all this relieving capacity was coming from, or how parents might feel about their “best” teachers being taken away.

      • PapaMike 2.1.1

        Am unsure how many of the “top” teachers actually now take classes.
        Our local Primary Head is more an Administrator, so am unsure how good he will be visiting/working in another school, as he is out of practice.
        I understand that there are many recently qualified teachers who cannot get a job at present, so more opportunities present themselves to get integrated into the system.

        • alwyn 2.1.1.1

          If that is the case then he won’t be one of the teachers chosen will he?
          As I understand the scheme they are going to be the ones who display great results in the classroom. If he isn’t doing that he won’t be an appropriate choice for an “Expert Teacher” or “Leader Teacher” roles.
          He could, on the other hand be eligible for an “Executive Principal” or “Change Principal” if he is good enough. They will be expected to be Administrators.

      • lprent 2.1.2

        I think that it was that they were going to talk about it. But if there are no funds allocated for it, then it can be considered to not exist. What is the bet that the schools will *eventually* be told after the election that they will have to take it from their own budgets.

        In which case, think of the economic reasons to keep a overpaid part-time teacher compared to firing them and getting a cheaper fulltime teacher.

    • Matthew Hooton 2.2

      I think the details of the government’s education announcement are to be worked out in consultation with trustees, principals and teacher unions. That is why there wasn’t much detail – although some in the education sector argued that not even the broad outline of the policy should have been announced without prior consultation with the unions and other groups.

      When it came to the opposition announcement, I don’t think it was the provision of detail that was the problem but that the speech misrepresented the detail. The guest poster is surely not arguing that the policy details should have been kept secret and the erroneous speech been given and not corrected?

      • lprent 2.2.1

        …surely not arguing that the policy details should have been kept secret…

        You mean like National did? There is no difference between keeping implementation and budget as secret and “…to be worked out in consultation with…” when what was announced has less than half of the required costs attached to the aspiration.

        Labours policy could have been expressed as being aspirational with a similar (near criminal?) lack of detail. I think that is what Blue is suggesting should have happened…

        • Matthew Hooton 2.2.1.1

          Yes there is. It seems that decisions have not been made how to implement the government’s policy – that will be worked out in good faith in consultation with the profession. So there is nothing to keep secret. The prime minister announced all there was to announce at this stage.

          • blue leopard (Get Lost GCSB Bill) 2.2.1.1.1

            Be better that National don’t bother wasting money on fleshing out that dreg of a policy – National’s own spin will be used against them on this one – creating greater bureaucracy and more ‘middlemen’ is not the answer to the problems with our education system.

            • Matthew Hooton 2.2.1.1.1.1

              I agree with you on the substance of the policy, which I oppose and criticised in the media. But the point is, it wasn’t that they held back detail – they are promising to develop the detail in consultation with the teaching profession – so that the detail does not yet exist. That is very different from the Cunliffe issue where he misrepresented the detail.

              • Tracey

                You are right. They didnt hold back detail. Tbey had none. But which news channels radios and newspapers Pressed that with the pm or concluded it was empty and Redundant cos it is Nothing more than an idea. Thats right. None.

              • Draco T Bastard

                So what you and the other political journos should have been doing in relation to Key’s education announcement is demanding where’s the money rather than giving them a free-ride.

          • Tracey 2.2.1.1.2

            So key should have said… we have an idea but dont know anymore than that yet. He made it sound concrete.

          • KJT 2.2.1.1.3

            Translation. “It will be worked out with some in the profession, who can be bought to go along with their policy.

            • TightyRighty 2.2.1.1.3.1

              yes, the teacher unions will be sure to be silent on that one. given the outcry over national standards from that quarter i don’t think it likely that the patsies will be given an easy run.

              How about this. maybe it could actually work?

              as far as performance pay goes, it is a model that would work very well for the private sector. i like the fact nothing is entrenched. it’s all about making sure that performance is sustained and consistent. if the unions are cautiously agreeing, having them at the table with input will surely benefit the entire sector.

              Coaching programs could be offered by the union to struggling members to help them achieve the pay bonuses?

              it’s all a bit to much effort for the old work shy KJT though

              • KJT

                Try and keep up, TR.

                If you kept up with the management literature, you would know that top performing companies have long abandoned individual performance pay. Because it doesn’t work in the private sector, either.

                The companies with the highest paid executives are the worst performers overall.

                A glaring example of the effects of performance pay, in the form of share options, was ENRON.

                Solid Energy, is, of course, a local example.

                • TightyRighty

                  Oh yeah, I forgot that only company wide bonuses reward those who perform the strongest.

                  ENRON? are we even in the same century. if i wasn’t a touch over thirty i would have no idea what the hell you are talking about.

                  please explain how google, vying with apple for most valuable company in the world, best place to work pretty much since it was founded only reward all staff when the achievements of a few really create the wins?

                  Oh that is right, they don’t. GMAIL team? BSD’s. innovative, forward thinking, killing it on the bonus front. Google+? yeah, nuff said.

                  Those who can are managing and earning bonuses. those who can’t are writing books telling those others who can’t why bonus’ suck and don’t work. no surprise you are quoting them.

                  ENRON! LOL. you all right there old timer? bet your still reading your “latest” management literature in a book.

                  I find it weird you’d do that? that would involve actually showing enough initiative to go the book store or wherever the fuck you purchase dead trees from

          • emergency mike 2.2.1.1.4

            “It seems that decisions have not been made how to implement the government’s policy – that will be worked out in good faith in consultation with the profession.”

            Translation – no one’s got a clue how this is going to work.

          • Tautoko Viper 2.2.1.1.5

            Since when have National negotiated in good faith with teachers?

          • lprent 2.2.1.1.6

            Matthew: So if I understand you correctly, you are agreeing with Blue?

            Key didn’t have to release details because work was required to finalize those details.

            Because following that same logic, Cunliffe should have not have released any details because it would have (as they said) required working out in the basis of the budget at the time.

            Or you could simply be saying that you apply a double standard – which would be somewhat hypocritical eh?

      • blue leopard (Get Lost GCSB Bill) 2.2.2

        “When it came to the opposition announcement, I don’t think it was the provision of detail that was the problem but that the speech misrepresented the detail.”

        ….And nothing to do whatsoever with the fact that the right-wing went into overdrive to condemn the only thing that they could with regard to a good policy that will be popular…./sarc

        “The guest poster is surely not arguing that the policy details should have been kept secret and the erroneous speech been given and not corrected?”

        Logical fallacy alert: Strawman

        • Matthew Hooton 2.2.2.1

          There is no fallacy or straw man. If Labour’s policy was that people on PPL would only get 26 weeks of the $60/week payment then that is what the speech should have said. The poster seems to be saying the speech was ok as written and the problem was that the details of the policy were released – i.e., the erroneous speech should have been released but not the correct fact sheet (or at least its second version).

          • blue leopard (Get Lost GCSB Bill) 2.2.2.1.1

            You questioned and implied that the guest poster was arguing that the policy details should have been kept secret and the erroneous speech been given and not corrected.

            This is nonsense that Blue would be doing this.

            Perhaps you don’t understand what the strawman fallacy entails – I did supply a link for you to follow:

            “By exaggerating, misrepresenting, or just completely fabricating someone’s argument, it’s much easier to present your own position as being reasonable, but this kind of dishonesty serves to undermine honest rational debate.”

            • Matthew Hooton 2.2.2.1.1.1

              No, the poster, Blue, said the political mistake was that Labour issued the details. S/he says they should not have. But that was not the problem. The problem was that the speech doubled the value of the handout compared with what the detailed policy statement did. So, really, Blue’s post should have been “Labour must not exaggerate value of policies in summary speeches” rather than attacking the media for reading through the material provided and finding that the speech was inaccurate. It is like the Budget. Vast amounts of detail are provided and the Minister of Finance’s speech must accurately summarise that. If, say, a National government was cutting tax and the minister said the tax cut was worth $2000 a year to a family when the true amount was $1000, that would be appalling. It would be no good to say that the problem was that the media bothered to read the detail and discover the misrepresentation or lie.

              • blue leopard (Get Lost GCSB Bill)

                Ah! I see where you are coming from – yes you have a point – you are taking what is offered by Blue and following through on what might have occurred had Labour taken Blue’s approach and on rereading Blue’s post I would agree, that certainly can be read into what Blue is saying.

                This doesn’t explain the angle of the error being promoted as a ‘deliberate lie’ nor the requirement that the media has for Labour to cross all its ‘i’s’ and dot all its ‘t’s’ while JK gets to lie wholesale to us on a regular basis.

                Nor does it acknowledge that the people missing out may not need or care about missing out on $60

                However you have a point – my apologies for the accusation.

                • Matthew Hooton

                  If the people who might miss out on the $60 may neither need it or care about it, why on earth would you tax other people to pay it to them in the first place?

                  • blue leopard (Get Lost GCSB Bill)

                    People on paid parental leave may not need it and they are not being paid it – that is the error that was ‘discovered’ by the media – isn’t it??

                    • Matthew Hooton

                      My point is that if $60 a week is going to solve or significantly reduce child poverty then getting it for 26 weeks or 52 weeks must matter. If it is argued that it really doesn’t matter that the people concerned won’t be getting it for the first six months, then how can it matter whether or not they get it for the second six months? And of course it gets cancelled just as soon as the baby gets old enough to start costing series money.

                    • blue leopard (Get Lost GCSB Bill)

                      Because those on paid parental leave are receiving another greater payment therefore don’t qualify for it in the first six months. They then lose that greater payment and therefore require it for the next 6 months – [perhaps encouraging a parent to stay at home for longer - which has proven advantages for the child.]

                    • Colonial Viper

                      So you would speak in favour of it being a full 52 weeks for struggling parents then Matthew?

                      Or would you prefer it to be zero weeks? Please be honest.

                    • blue leopard (Get Lost GCSB Bill)

                      @ CV

                      It is interesting how even the most deceptive people have difficulty telling direct lies.

                    • bad12

                      Dance wee Matty dance, careful tho lest you slip off of the head of the pin upon which you spin…

      • Anne 2.2.3

        You’re ‘misrepresenting’ again Matthew Hooton. He didn’t misrepresent the policy.

        Were you there? Doubt it. I was. His explanation of the detail was clear enough for me . I knew what he meant and I bet the vast majority of the audience did too. Sure, there was room for improvement, but I suspect at least some of those gallery hacks also knew what he meant but it suited them to turn dirty on Cunliffe on the ‘implied instruction’ of lover-boy, J Key. And my God, listen to who is talking. Key can hardly string two sentences together without committing every grammatical and diction error in the book.

        … Labour seems to think that producing screeds of information on their policies is both necessary and desirable. They think people will be impressed by how clever they are.

        There’s certainly an element of truth in that Blue but it goes back further than Helen Clark. I can remember LP people making the same accusation back in the 1970s. Helen Clark was on top of every detail, but by and large she simplified her explanations for public consumption. Cunliffe has the same ability to be on top of detail, but maybe he needs to learn to be more simplistic in his public utterances. Sounds insulting I know, but for many of the punters out there they only seem to understand simplistic language.

      • QoT 2.2.4

        “We don’t have the solutions, we don’t know how it’s going to work or how we’ll implement it, but we definitely know it will cost $359 million.”

        That’s National Party “governance” for you.

    • greywarbler 2.3

      lprent
      It must be annoying for knowledgable people to hear their topic bandied around in a misinformed or misleading manner. Perhaps some of the progressive academics could be asked if they would like to put a paragraph opinion piece that would give some hard base to discussion. Either to lead some, or to add to some already under way. Have you had that in mind Lynn? I envisage it would go up with the body of the post under their name perhaps with a disclaimer if they felt that was best. Or even a thinkpiece by anonymous who had some years experience and a point that was illuminating.

  3. McFlock 3

    Perhaps it is something of a hangover from the days of Helen Clark, who was on top of every little detail at any given moment, but Labour seems to think that producing screeds of information on their policies is both necessary and desirable. They think people will be impressed by how clever they are.

    to be fair, if labour don’t produce screeds of information on each policy, they get shit for being too vague and allegations that any gap in the policy description is incompetently handled and an indication that some people will be neglected.

    I suspect the main issue at the moment is that one particular hack has his knickers in a twist about not being sucked up to. But he’ll either get over himself or get reduced to being as useful as a soggy teabag left over from the 2011 Cup of Tea

  4. blue leopard (Get Lost GCSB Bill) 4

    I think your article has relevance, Blue, however I think you are being too charitable toward what has recently occurred in the media.

    The issue over Mr Cunliffe ‘lying’ came straight out of John Key’s mouth and the media continued to repeat it. This is more than simply looking for the winner – this is an attempt to create the winner.

  5. Colonial Viper 5

    If a journalist insists on “reporting” a story as if he works for News of the World, sanction them. As I mentioned yesterday, cut their access back and give their competitors exclusives and information first.

    • This should be trialled on Gower.

    • weka 5.2

      Years ago Tariana Turia started to refuse to speak to the MSM because they were so completely shit at reporting on Maori issues. She instead talked to Maori media. This seems to have worked. As the mP gained power the MSM had to take Maori issues more seriously and get to grips with how to report them. I wouldn’t go so far as to say they’re doing well with that, but I do think her actions forced change.

    • alwyn 5.3

      I hope that you don’t work for the CIA.
      If you do that talk of “sanction them” may really get people scared.
      Wasn’t that the polite way of saying “poison the bastards” in JFK’s time?

    • blue leopard (Get Lost GCSB Bill) 5.4

      @ CV

      I suggest that Labour, the Greens & any other decent party that understands the importance of accurate information for democracy to function to use some of their resources to go behind the scenes and investigate the connections as to why our media are choosing to act in this way.

      There is very little doubt in my mind that there is major corruption going on with this current government and our media

  6. Skinny 6

    As you rightly point out some of them couldn’t really give 2 hoots and it’s all about the ratings and their own ego. I stay friendly with a number of the ones that are useful to hang one on National like a sloppy Minister, provided the oil you have will be of interest to the public and boost the jurno’s esteem. If you line up a few opposition party MP’s in on the act your away laughing. The beauty is a good journalist never reveals their sources.

  7. Murray Olsen 7

    I think I agree with this. The detail can be given in supporting documents. Of course, one problem is that while our cringing Tory hack journalists will accept this from their side, they’ll push against it when it comes from the left. In any case, I think we can and need to do better.

    • weka 7.1

      The irony there Murray is that apparently the press gallery were given an edited, shorter version.

      btw, is that version in the public domain yet?

  8. Tracey 8

    Little repeated fact about the building consent rjse which national attribute to its policies. Did national orchestrate the earthquakes? Thats the only way their misleading statements today make sense. Twyford spoke well but didnt say smith is being deliberately misleading.

    ” Westpac Banking Corp senior economist Michael Gordon said in a note. “The Canterbury rebuild continues to dominate the totals, but the re-emergence of the Auckland apartment market is a notable recent trend.” “

  9. greywarbler 9

    The ‘cut and thrust’ of politics.
    Stream of consciousness. Sort of amusing, strangely.
    (I just had an inkling about this strangeness, and it’s that most of us have a bit of neanderthal in us, our past people before they found out what a past participle was, interbred so they could get some cool jeans, I mean genes, so they could cope in cooler climes after having come out of Africa. True, this was an interesting piece quoted from magazine Nature I think)

    What does cut and thrust bring to mind :
    The pen is mightier than the sword.
    Ultimate fighting.
    He who lives by the sword, dies by the sword.
    Sounds like a job working in a butcher’s shop or an abbatoir.
    A job for those interested in blood sports, and not smart or quick enough to take on the sport of fencing, rather than putting up enclosures on farms.
    It’s for people who need people, they’re the loveliest people in the world.
    Entitlement, one feels the need to try and show the lower classes where they are going wrong.
    It’s passing that course in business law and defamation, most important to get good marks there.
    Need to be able to drink, and take a p..sss together, that’s important for getting the best scuttlebutt.
    That’s for men usually, but women aren’t precluded, no sirree. Did I tell you the one about the femme who could drink everyone under the table, and when she got you under there….well!
    Have to be able to read and write, type, and use all manner of technological devices, some more vice than deee. Know what I mean, nudge, nudge.

    Cripes mate. There is hardly any room in this CV for being able to understand political ethics, policy fashions and foibles, the various shapes of organisations for running countries, hegemony, anything about money and where it comes from, (and where it goes nudge, nudge again), and the needs of the modern society, trading patterns, medical and nutrition effects on longevity and fertility and morbidity, and population growth, and the population drift through war and climate disruption and………….

  10. weka 10

    The satire tag is missing.

    Fuck the gallery hacks, and fuck letting them choose the next govt because they’re too lazy to do a good job. I and many others here are old enough to remember when journalists served the common good. We should be fighting for that.

    “Hardly anything is known about how this policy will actually work in practice, but no one cares”

    I care. I do agree that Labour need to sharpen their act up, but they’re getting better. That the policy detail was online pretty much as soon as Cunliffe’s speech was finished was good and improvement on pre-DC Labour.

    Yes, they fucked up re the PPL thing, but that we all know what the policy is this week, in detail, is a good thing.

    Maybe the real problem this week was that the MSM was thrown by a Labour party being an actual labour party. Yeah Labout made a mistake, but they also produced something bloody interesting. The gallery reaction to the mistake allowed everyone to see what a complete tosser Gower is. The more that kind of shit is made visible the better. Time to stand up to that kind of sloppy, self-serving, egotistical jonolism.

    • blue leopard (Get Lost GCSB Bill) 10.1

      +1 I agree with all you say here apart from ” and fuck letting them choose the next govt because they’re too lazy to do a good job.”

      As I said above – I think this is far too charitable with what is going on in our media. It has got beyond the point of ‘laziness’ – it appears to be a very ‘energetic’ push to promote the right-wing parties’ policies and keep them in power; of encouraging right-wing interests (i.e. the very small group of very wealthy peoples’ interests) to keep their self-absorbed, narrow-minded, mean and greedy hold on this country.

      Someone should be tailing Gower and his ilk and finding out the connections between him and the National party. What has occurred in the last week and since Nat have been in power reeks of right-wing government influence of our information sources and we need to know how this is occurring.

      The media wasn’t excellent prior to this government coming into power – it has degenerated severely since it has been in power, though. Recall all the informative channels we have lost TV7, SBS One & Two, Stratos – all these channels had good informative programmes and we have lost all but a very few of those programmes.

      Here is a starting point for making the connections: TV3 got a big handout from this government and it is the worst TV channel for right wing bias.

      • weka 10.1.1

        The lazy bit was simply that the information they wanted was already online and none of them bothered to check.

        TV3 also have Campbell Live.

        • blue leopard (Get Lost GCSB Bill) 10.1.1.1

          My point being:

          It is not laziness that lead them to promote this angle on Cunliffe and Labour – this was right-wing spin- and they were very energetic in promoting such.

          • weka 10.1.1.1.1

            I suppose I’m not willing to assume that all political journalists are as you describe, despite some being so.

            • blue leopard (Get Lost GCSB Bill) 10.1.1.1.1.1

              I would agree with that – TV3 is the worst and appears to be where most of the trouble is originating. As for newspapers – don’t read a lot out of them – because I can’t stand the bias, opinionated unsigned articles and inaccuracies I always find in them when I do.

          • fisiani 10.1.1.1.2

            The problem for The Cunliffe is that now the year has begun with him saying one thing and then admitting he was wrong not once but now three times, PPL, tax credits and antenatal care. The Cunliffe has lost any last vestige of credibility with the media and the public. Watch for The Cunliffe fake Polynesian accent video clip of 2011 to be replayed over and over. The only question is what digit will follow the 2 in the next poll. Not even I can expect that it will be what digit follows the 1.

            • blue leopard (Get Lost GCSB Bill) 10.1.1.1.2.1

              Sometimes it is interesting to read the thoughts of someone lost in their own fantasies, Fisiani, thanks for that.

    • Matthew Hooton 10.2

      But the gallery, particularly TV3, wasn’t lazy and did do a good job. They read all the background material and found that Cunliffe had misrepresented his own policy, deliberately or otherwise.

      • Colonial Viper 10.2.1

        Of course. Its merely investigating John Key’s policy spending claims where they get lazy.

      • Hayden 10.2.2

        …deliberately…

        If you believe that you probably also believe that he’d falsify his CV in a way that could be easily checked, perhaps by asking his old employer, examining time-sheets, that sort of thing.

        Here, I’ll fix the speech:

        There is no year more critical than the first. That’s why today, I am announcing that for 59,000 families with new-born babies, they will all receive a Best Start payment of $60 per week, for the first year of their child’s life.

        becomes:

        There is no year more critical than the first. That’s why today, I am announcing that for 59,000 families with new-born babies, they will all receive a Best Start payment of $60 per week, for the first year of their child’s life, once Paid Parental Leave entitlements have ended.

        Seven words; bit of an oversight, hardly a sustained campaign of disinformation.

        • Matthew Hooton 10.2.2.1

          Quite an important seven words though. Your first par would be untrue and the second would be true. The first par doubles the true value of the handout, which is not trivial.

          • Hayden 10.2.2.1.1

            No-one said it was trivial, but it’s easy to miss seven words out of 2510 (as published) words, and it’s one point out of a whole lot of points that was missed.

            If you really want to play games with semantics, you could argue that it was left unsaid that the Best Start payment would have an abatement rate of 100% against Paid Parental Leave. An important omission, but not technically a lie.

            • Matthew Hooton 10.2.2.1.1.1

              Usually politicians are more careful or honest when it comes to the key paragraph in a speech announcing a policy. Finance ministers, for example, summarise dozens of policy and spending changes in their Budget speeches without making this sort of “error”.

              • KJT

                Like “we will not raise GST” Key?

                You are a joke, Hooton, Though rather a sick one.

                • fisiani

                  Want to find a citation for that. People tried and failed in 2011. I challenge you to find any evidence of him stating “we will not raise GST”. Note the closed quotation mark. Find a clip with his quotation finishing at that point . You are simply misquoting by selection of 5 words in sequence without allowing people to remember the rest of his answer. Typical Leftist attempted smear. Didn’t work in 2011 and will not work in 2014.

                    • fisiani

                      Epic Fail blue leopard. Want another try? Still not a shred of evidence of those 5 words in isolation and no acknowledgment that the response was to a different question.

                    • blue leopard (Get Lost GCSB Bill)

                      What is wrong with it? I am on dial-up so couldn’t check – although I tried.

                      The article quotes Mr Key

                      “In the video, taken during a press conference in 2008, Mr Key was asked to rule out a hike in GST after suggestions the next government would have no choice but to raise GST to 15 per cent, and raise taxes.

                      Mr Key’s response to the question was: “National is not going to be raising GST. National wants to cut taxes not raise taxes. We acknowledge the point [made], which is that there is a decade of deficits facing New Zealand. But that comes back to our core point …the fastest way to eliminate those deficits and get New Zealand back into surplus is to get New Zealand growing again.”

                      Are they misquoting the video?
                      Sounds reasonable to assume that National are not going to be raising GST from that quote.

                    • blue leopard (Get Lost GCSB Bill)

                      Gee…is that all you’ve got for your ‘he didn’t really say it’ theory??

              • Tracey

                Lololololol

                • fisiani

                  Blue Leopard again EPIC Fail. You have misquoted yet again.

                  • blue leopard (Get Lost GCSB Bill)

                    I haven’t misquoted anything – that was a direct cut and paste from Stuff- if you have a problem with what they reported perhaps you might want to lodge a formal complaint to them.

                    Your argument is obscure Fisiani and if you don’t want to explain – it is going to stay that way.

                    That is one hell of a way to make a point you’ve got there; one where no one apart from yourself understands what you are wittering on about.

              • Hayden

                170,000 jobs?

              • McFlock

                surplus?
                cost of asset sales?
                income from asset sales?

              • Anne

                Unlike most Tories Matthew Hooton, David Cunliffe is able to make a full speech without notes in front of him. He made a mistake leaving out a handful of words, but what he subsequently said adequately explained what he had previously omitted in error. Just as well isn’t it, those hacks don’t apply the same blow torch to their beloved master, John Key. Phew, that must be a relief given the unforgivable lies Key frequently utters.

                You see, Cunliffe made it clear – and I paraphrase – that no-one was going to be allowed to rort the system, and only one ‘payment’ would be available to parents at any given time. That was my understanding anyway.

              • mickysavage

                Usually politicians are more careful or honest when it comes to the key paragraph in a speech

                Careful Matthew. Remember when you had to apologise for calling David a liar previously? Details are at http://thestandard.org.nz/matthew-hooton-apologises-sort-of/ if you forget.

                Do I sense a campaign of denigration attacking David’s honesty? After all the reality does not matter, all that is important is the creation of an illusion …

          • blue leopard (Get Lost GCSB Bill) 10.2.2.1.2

            Whilst clarifying information is good – I think compared to what people are receiving on paid parental leave it is a very trivial point for the mainstream media to be making a big song and dance over.

            Or do you think that those receiving paid parental leave are in such great need that an extra 60 bucks is substantial ‘loss’ for them?

            • Matthew Hooton 10.2.2.1.2.1

              For the 270,000 children Labour claims are living in “poverty”, I would have thought the difference between PPL+$3120 and PPL+$1560 – an average of $30 a week in that first year or life – would be material. It is odd for anyone in Team Cunliffe to be saying that it wasn’t an important enough issue for the media to be highlighting because $1560 a year is not all that much.

              • McFlock

                Wow, so suddenly a nat spin doctor cares about making a [positive] difference for the poor.

                labgrn are beginning to look like the harbingers of real [positive] change…

                • Matthew Hooton

                  I am neither claiming to care nor not care. It is just that if you announce a policy you claim will end poverty for 270,000 children it is material whether or not the handout is $3120 or $1560 – and if you say the former when the truth is that latter, you can hardly bleat about media bias when they point out your error.

                  • McFlock

                    I am neither claiming to care nor not care.

                    Hooten refuses to confirm or deny caring about the poor.
                    Got that.

                    It is just that if you announce a policy you claim will end poverty for 270,000 children

                    bold claim for a policy that only affects ~59k babies a year, I agree. Got a source?

                    Your real difficulty with this policy is (that regardless of whether it’s $1500 or $3000) poorer parents still know that it’s $1500 or $3000 more than you bastards will ever do for them.

                  • Hayden

                    policy you claim will end poverty for 270,000 children

                    Speaking of inaccuracy…

                    • Matthew Hooton

                      Ok, fair enough, if you claim it will materially address child poverty …

                    • McFlock

                      if you claim it will materially address child poverty

                      in that case, either $1.5k or $3k will “materially address child poverty”. So no problem, because it’s still more than nactoids would do.

                  • blue leopard (Get Lost GCSB Bill)

                    @ Matthew Hooton

                    Do you think that those in the 270 000 children category are receiving paid parental leave?

                    I assumed paid parental leave comes with well paid jobs – not poorly paid ones

                  • emergency mike

                    “you can hardly bleat about media bias when they point out your error.”

                    If they had ‘pointed out an error’ that would be fine Matthew, it’s the anguished, outraged, over the top reaction from certain corners of the media that is objectionable.

                    Key announces an education policy which despite being apparently costed out to the nearest $10m is horribly vague and devoid of any meaningful details, and the media pack calls it a good un’.

                    Nah no media bias here.

          • Puddleglum 10.2.2.1.3

            Matthew, it’s actually less than seven words astray of your sudden and selective logical stringency over sentence formation and truth value.

            Simply change the word ‘will’ to ‘can’ and it’s true. (PPL is an entitlement that does not have to be taken).

            Did you fail to notice – despite your deep and genuine concern over truth value in relation to political speeches – that in John Key’s speech (and consistently repeated in Hekia Parata’s subsequent interviews) there were completely untrue statements to the effect that research overwhelmingly shows that teacher quality is the most important influence on student achievement?

            Do you agree that that statement fundamentally misled the New Zealand public? Also, given that it represented the rationale for the policy – rather than ‘merely’ a detail of the policy – don’t you think it represents a far more worrying misrepresentation?

            • Hayden 10.2.2.1.3.1

              Yes, it’s about #54 on the Hattie (PBUH) Index, isn’t it?

              • Hayden

                To answer my own question, it’s #56:

                http://visible-learning.org/hattie-ranking-influences-effect-sizes-learning-achievement/

                “Pre-term birth weight” is #38, and “Not labelling children” (goodbye National Standards!) is #20. I expect David Farrar to be on this any minute now…

              • Matthew Hooton

                Are you sure Hattie doesn’t say teachers are the most important influence on student achievement than students themselves? Read this: http://www.education.auckland.ac.nz/webdav/site/education/shared/hattie/docs/teachers-make-a-difference-ACER-(2003).pdf

                But it teacher quality doesn’t affect student achievement, then the Treasury will be delighted because they can all be sacked and replaced with minimum-wage baby-sitters and the students will be no worse off!

                • McFlock

                  Once again a tory shill thinks that “not the most important” means “completely unimportant”.

                  Either than, or once again a tory shill turns out to be a barefaced liar and unprincipled sophist.

                • blue leopard (Get Lost GCSB Bill)

                  How about you read this article from Puddleglums – ‘The Political Scientist’ BlogSpot Mr Hooton and tell me why the media didn’t pick up on this error in Key’s State of the Nation speech:

                  “A mountain of evidence shows that the quality of teaching – inside the classroom – is the biggest influence on kids’ achievement.” [- From Key's SON speech]

                  [....There’s a slight problem with this statement...]

                  “A study published earlier this month by researchers at North Carolina State University, Brigham Young University and the University of California-Irvine, for example, finds that parental involvement — checking homework, attending school meetings and events, discussing school activities at home — has a more powerful influence on students’ academic performance than anything about the school the students attend. Another study, published in the Review of Economics and Statistics, reports that the effort put forth by parents (reading stories aloud, meeting with teachers) has a bigger impact on their children’s educational achievement than the effort expended by either teachers or the students themselves. And a third study concludes that schools would have to increase their spending by more than $1,000 per pupil in order to achieve the same results that are gained with parental involvement….”

                  “So parents matter — a point made clear by decades of research showing that a major part of the academic advantage held by children from affluent families comes from the “concerted cultivation of children” as compared to the more laissez-faire style of parenting common in working-class families….”

                  “In fact, the Prime Minister didn’t even have to read “decades of research” or go to sociology conferences to discover this point.”

                  Research on student learning consistently shows that the largest source of variation in student learning is attributable to differences in what students bring to school – their abilities and attitudes, and family and community background – factors that difficult for policy makers to influence, at least in the short-run.

                  Perhaps John Key just ‘mis-spoke’ on that claim that “[a] mountain of evidence shows that the quality of teaching – inside the classroom – is the biggest influence on kids’ achievement“. Perhaps he meant to say “[a] mountain of evidence shows that – inside the classroom – the quality of teaching is the biggest influence on kids’ achievement“.

                  Or maybe not.” – Puddleglum

                • Hayden

                  It’s just a little joke about DPF claiming that Metiria Turei was lying about the effect on poverty on the change in educational achievements, apparently arrived at by counting the items on the list. To be consistent he should be jumping on anyone who claims the most important factor in education is anything other than “Self-report grades”.

                  If you look at the graphic on the linked page it’s essentially meaningless in terms of comparing one influence to another, for example the list also contains “Drugs” and “Mathematics”.

                  By the way, from your link:

                  Students which account for about 50% of the variance of achievement. It is what students brings to the table that predicts achievement more than any other variable. The correlation between ability and achievement is high, so it is no surprise that bright students have steeper trajectories of learning than their less bright students. Our role in schools is to improve the trajectory of all these
                  students, and I note the recent PIRLS and TIMMS studies which have shown
                  that our trajectory for the not so bright students is one of the flattest in the
                  OECD worlds.

                  Home which accounts for about 5-10% of the variance – considering that the major effects of the home are already accounted for by the attributes of the student. The home effects are more related to the levels of expectation and
                  encouragement, and certainly not a function of the involvement of the parents
                  or caregivers in the management of schools.

                  Teachers who account for about 30% of the variance. It is what teachers know, do, and
                  care about which is very powerful in this learning equation.

                  (italics mine)

                  So the home and the student are largely inseparable, and together have nearly/exactly twice the influence of the teacher.

                • Matthew,

                  My point was that research shows that teachers are not the most important influence on student achievement.

                  As all researchers in the area know, the most important influences on achievement are outside the school. If National had $379m it wanted to spend on improving student achievement over the long-run it would have been far better to spend it on those external factors.

                  As for what Treasury knows, here’s an extract from their Advice on Lifting Student Achievement in 2012:

                  Research on student learning consistently shows that the largest source of variation in student learning is attributable to differences in what students bring to school – their abilities and attitudes, and family and community background – factors that difficult for policy makers to influence, at least in the short-run.

                  [BTW, it is highly debatable that such factors are "difficult for policy makers to influence" and, in any case, such a claim goes against most of the welfare reforms instituted by this government. Those reforms are based on the belief that you certainly can change the "family and community background" and, indeed, the "attitudes" of individuals to make them more 'responsible'. But that's another argument.]

                  Perhaps John Key just ‘mis-spoke’ in his claim that “[a] mountain of evidence shows that the quality of teaching – inside the classroom – is the biggest influence on kids’ achievement“. Perhaps he meant to say “[a] mountain of evidence shows that – inside the classroom – the quality of teaching is the biggest influence on kids’ achievement“.

                  But I know that you’re against people retrospectively adjusting the sentences in politicians’ speeches, so we have to conclude that Key misled New Zealand with his statement.

                  A very serious case of misrepresentation of the rationale for a policy, don’t you agree?

                  Edit: I see that extracts from my post on this have just been extracted by blue leopard.

                  • blue leopard (Get Lost GCSB Bill)

                    @ Puddleglum

                    An excellent point that you make – yet more evidence our media are blatantly biased – it is very telling that Hooton doesn’t answer to your point.

                    Excellent article, by the way, Puddleglum, thanks.

                  • Tracey

                    Oh dear… johnny lied and matthew ran away from answering.

                    Ssdd

                • Tautoko Viper

                  reductio ad absurdum argument, Matthew.

                • KJT

                  Hattie himself said he was excluding outside school influences for the purpose of that study.

                  But you know that don’t you, Hooton?

                  I hear you are now part of the “party for individual responsibility” the one whose members never take individual responsibility for anything.
                  Including their own criminal ACT’s and, the disaster, their policies have inflicted on New Zealand, for 3 decades.

                • Tracey

                  Is one person a mountain of research or evidence

      • weka 10.2.3

        “But the gallery, particularly TV3, wasn’t lazy and did do a good job. They read all the background material and found that Cunliffe had misrepresented his own policy, deliberately or otherwise.”

        Yeah, nah. The version I read online was up soon after the speech. What happened on ts is that we read or listened to the speech, and then we started asking questions. Some of us went and found answers to those questions by looking at the Labour Party website. The thing about the $60/wk starting after PPL ends is on the front page of the main document. It wasn’t hard to find, and many of us had already read it before Gower started his little ego trip.

        If the Press Gallery had access to different material, and wanted to know about whether the child payment was on top of PPL, all they had to do was ask. Or go online. I’m sure some of them even have smart phones.

        Gower made it into a big fucking issue, and as per usual, made shit up. That’s not doing a good job. Do you really think that it serves NZ for the focus to be on a Labour Party communications mistake and for that mistake to be spun into lies, or on the actual policy?

        • Matthew Hooton 10.2.3.1

          So when a party leader stands up and announces in a major policy speech a policy that s/he says is worth $3120, and then the press gallery reads the background documents and finds out it is worth only $1560, then they should say “oh well, no big deal, at least it was correct in the fact sheet” and decide it is not news? Disagree with you sorry. That sounds like lead story material to me.

          • Tracey 10.2.3.1.1

            So you agree the media has failed to make alot of le
            ad stories about key’s misleading statements… given you think such things are not trivial.

          • weka 10.2.3.1.2

            I didn’t say that, so stop spinning that line.

            Gower spun that Cunliffe had deliberately misled the media and the public. But at the very same time he was doing that, the actual policy was online for anyone to see. If you really think that Cunliffe was trying to mislead everyone intentionally, please tell me how that planning session would have played out, I’d love to know.

            It was mistake. By all means point it out. But don’t tell lies.

          • emergency mike 10.2.3.1.3

            “they should say “oh well, no big deal, at least it was correct in the fact sheet” and decide it is not news? Disagree with you sorry. That sounds like lead story material to me.”

            No Matthew, they should point out that Labour has made a slightly embarrasing error in the presentation on their policy, ask for clarifiaction, and move on. Hysterical claims and attacks about Cunliffe ‘deliberately misleading’ at the same time as the correct information is freely and clearly available, not so much.

            • TightyRighty 10.2.3.1.3.1

              slightly embarrassing that he got caught out lying.

              • emergency mike

                Whatever works for you righty, I’m sure those parents who miss out on the $60 per week in the first 6 months are totally gutted to realize that they’re only getting paid parental leave. Oh that sneaky ol’ Cunliffe.

          • Skinny 10.2.3.1.4

            The problem for Labour is they don’t have many paid staffers around them to act quickly when a slip up is made. Of course on the other side of the fence there is countless paid spin merchants such as yourself Matthew to pick up any flaws. Bit average the caucus didn’t pick it up or did they?

          • BLiP 10.2.3.1.5

            So when the PRIME MINISTER stands up and announces in a major policy speech a policy that HE DOESN’T KNOW HOW WILL IT WORK OR HOW MUCH IT WILL COST, and then the press gallery reads the background documents and finds out JOHN KEY IS LYING THROUGH HIS TEETH ABOUT ALL SORTS OF THINGS THROUGHOUT THE SPEECH, then they should say nothin and decide it is not news? Disagree with you sorry. That sounds like lead story material to me.

            Yep, sure does.

          • RedLogix 10.2.3.1.6

            So when a party leader stands up and announces in a major policy speech a policy that s/he says is worth $3120, and then the press gallery reads the background documents and finds out it is worth only $1560,

            Only in the case they have already chosen to receive PPL. I went to the DoL web calculator: http://www.dol.govt.nz/paidparental/

            I entered the details for an employed mum who had been working for 3 years with the same employer on $45,000 pa. and the result was:

            You are entitled to (unpaid) statutory parental leave of:
            special leave (up to 10 days during your pregnancy e.g. for doctor visits)
            maternity leave (up to 14 weeks – up to 6 before the birth and the balance of the 14 weeks after the birth)
            extended leave (up to 52 weeks, including the 14 weeks maternity leave and including any extended leave taken by your partner – this entitlement may be shared with your partner).
            If you choose to take parental leave, you are entitled to the statutory parental leave payment. Your payment will be $488.17 per week before tax. This will be paid from the start of your parental leave until the earlier of the following:

            the end of 14 weeks; or

            the date you return to work; or

            if you resign, the date you resign.

            Whichever way you cut it, all new parents will be at least better off by $60 pw under either of these schemes. I repeat Mathew – why would anyone think it reasonable to doubled-dip Best Start and PPL?

    • Tim 10.3

      +1 !
      Ignore the hacks and simply deal with the genuine 4th Estate.
      (e.g. Maori Television and parts of RNZ – and occasionally TV3 where it is directed to specific programmes)

      Engage in ‘live’ debate with the likes of gower and other lazy, egotistical, Max Headroom, self-promoting hacks only – i.e. ‘live and direct/real time’ in a forum that doesn’t allow them the luxury of their applying lack-lustre interpretive skills (they have none).

      Live Morning Report, Live Checkpoint, Live crosses, Live Campbell Live, Maori Television, etc.
      Ignore Gower doorstops and so on – except to say …. “Paddy, I’ll speak with you live and direct”

      I mean if Key can do it – why not others (note …. Key is too gutless to front up on RNZ most times – especially with the likes of Kim Hill and others – he simply goes with the lazy and the ‘sympathetic/pathetic).

      ….. even issue a press release explaining the policy stating that certain in the media appear to be intent on misrepresentation, and the safest way to avoid that is to front up ‘live’.

  11. Jan 11

    Gosh, weka, you must be positively ancient if you can remember when journalists served the common good!
    In the early 1970s my then partner was a parliamentary journalist. My observation was (and I had plenty of opportunity to observe – the Nats, especially were only too ready to pour alcohol down their throats on the slightest of excuses) that they were a right wing bunch, some worse than others, who quite unashamedly wrote biased pieces almost as a matter of course and thought they were jolly clever fellows! The major difference between then and now seems to me to be a matter of degree – they were quite a lot more subtle about it back then. Just as now they weren’t terribly bright, really – I think journalism attracts a lot of dross.

    • weka 11.1

      I was speaking more generally Jan than just the parliamentary reporters. I remember when Gordon Campbell left the Listener, and the general shift that occured in the 80s. I’m not that old ;-) I’m also thinking about the shift to celebrity journalism and what happened with the coming of Paul Holmes.

      Do you think that even in the 70s where there was obvious bias that there was a different set of ethics. I actually don’t have a problem with bias so long as its explicit. What Gower did wasn’t political bias so much as turning political reporting into his own little high drama circus.

      What the post here seemed to be arguing is that this is the way jonolism is, so political parties should accept that, and adapt their strategy. I’m saying there is a limit to how much that should happen, and jonolism shouldn’t be left to set the agenda.

      • Jan 11.1.1

        In a way that 1970s bias was more harmful than what is happening now – it wasn’t explicit, it was quite subtle, at least as far as ‘man in the street’ was concerned. . Hopefully Gower’s ‘circus’ is so blatant as to be outrageously obvious, if not now , then eventually.
        The only difference in ethics that I can see is that back then they forbore to uncover the sexual indiscretions of members of both sides of the house (and they were many and varied!). A sort of gentleman’s agreement, if you like ????????????
        Celebrity journalism was another ball of wax – it was who they chose that was the insult to our intelligence. Ethics had very little to do with it, either personally or professionally.
        And don’t even get me started on the decline of the Listener!

  12. Matthew Hooton 12

    “Perhaps it is something of a hangover from the days of Helen Clark, who was on top of every little detail at any given moment.”

    Yes, that is probably right. Helen Clark was a hard worker who would have read through and understood all the details of the policy before approving and giving her speech. David Cunliffe does not appear to have her work ethic.

    • McFlock 12.1

      Well, he’d have to work fucking hard to be as lazy as U-key-lele.

    • ghostwhowalksnz 12.2

      How jolly, Cunliffe doesnt have her work ethic ?

      Meanwhile, you would wouldnt dare state what is common knowledge in Wellingtom, John Key has the attention span of a spider and has absolutely no interest in details.

      Rodney Hide famously described him as lazy in cabinet- and has paid the price by not getting a government job for the last couple of years.

      Does Key pay a price- well he avoids any sort of serious interview, and if trapped will offer up any old nonsense, but never be held to account.
      No doubt if any journalist tried to pin him down, they would be accused of “politicking” and using the “labour partys lines”

    • idlegus 12.3

      im pretty sure you said sometime last year that you worked with cunliffe on that car park tax thing & you found cunliffe to be hard working. that was during your “shit stirring with shearer vs cunliffe” phase.

  13. TightyRighty 13

    So, your saying the public believe national is winning and labour is losing?

  14. captain hook 14

    well hooton if $1500 is not that much then what is donkeyote and his gang of pennypinching high rollers going to do about it.
    Where are the jobs?

  15. Hayden 15

    This just in: the mountain in question is only 1192m* high. When will David Cunliffe stop lying?

    * I made that up

  16. Hami Shearlie 16

    Is it David Cunliffe’s fault that Patrick Gower is incapable of thoroughly reading Labour’s Policy notes online? Is it David Cunliffe’s fault that Patrick Gower is so ill-informed? Maybe Mr Gower should spend less time in the toilet providing crude sound effects for youtube, and more time actually reading and digesting Labour’s policy announcment! Time for Mr Gower to acknowledge HIS failings instead of attributing his mistakes to others – I’m not holding my breath though – Gower is as crazy as a rabid dog, but not as beautiful!!

  17. Matthew Hooton 17

    But Gower is capable of and did in fact read the detail which is how he was able to report that Cunliffe has misrepresented his own policy.

    • blue leopard (Get Lost GCSB Bill) 17.1

      What I want to know is what reward does he receive from the small groups of wealthy businesspeople for the work he does for them? How much is it, Hooton? How much is it these days to betray the general public in the way he does?

    • Lanthanide 17.2

      And then Gower himself misrepresented Labour’s mistake as some sort of deliberate deception.

    • Tim 17.3

      Read above Mattieu – Gower is also intent on arse licking and misrepresentation – I mean ASIDE from the self-promotion and little dickery that he’s obviously afflicted with.

      When you think about it ‘in the long term’ – it’s not really a smart thing for them to be doing.
      NZ’s mainstream media as a 4th Estate is ekshly almost defunct. In the not too distant – it will be restored and various audiences will be able to see what they’ve been missing out on.

      30-40 years ago, I was appalled at the state of Australian media as a recent arrival (comparing it with NZ at the time).
      We’ve overtaken them in terms of brain-deadism. We’ve utterly outdone them.
      I suspect in a few years, there’ll be a Gower or two hawking their CVs around various Australian and other ‘FOX-style’ media organisations – an of course when he does he’ll be quite disappointed.

      Today …. EVEN right leaning MSM in OZ (such as Skoi News) don’t pretend as to their journalistic credentials. They may be right leaning, but at least they’re more open and honest about it. And at least there are forums such as “The Nation” and various other FTA programmes that are live and direct whereby an opposition can state their case without Max Headrooms monopolising the debate.
      (Ekshly to the extent that their gubbamint is running SO scared, they’re about to construct ‘an inquiry’ into PSB – and their loyalty to “The Australian People”).

      Christ!…. If Gower were a decade or so younger and fronted up to one of the most basic journalism courses at a former Wgtn Polytech – he’d achieve a D+ at best! – and even that’d be from a certain right-leaning ‘professor’ !).

      • Tim 17.3.1

        Ekshly Mattieu – I don’t expect a reply from you anytime soon. maybe when you’ve thought about it and come up with some smarmy smart-arse retort – one which, of course is considered, and bland enough so as not to be too offensive such that it jeopardises any cute little media slot where you appear as a sage for a ‘fee’.

    • mickysavage 17.4

      Matthew do you see the irony? In a previous comment in this post you said that David Cunliffe said the policy would solve child poverty when he clearly did not.

      So do we take it that you were blatantly misrepresenting his position or should we accept that you were mistaken?

    • Anne 17.5

      Crosby/Textor been on the phone Matthew?

      Keep using the word misrepresentation over and over again. Doesn’t matter that it isn’t true. Keep saying it…. misrepresentation misrepresentation misrepresentation misrepresentation misrepresentation. The more you say it the better. Eventually people will think it might be true.

      Is that what its all about Matthew? The old transference trick?

    • RedLogix 17.6

      I’m utterly baffled by this entire episode.

      In exactly what universe did anyone think that they would be able to double-dip on both PPL and Best Start?

      Like for more than 200 msec?

      • Lanthanide 17.6.1

        It doesn’t matter whether it’s “reasonable” or “correct” or whatever, in your or anyone else’s opinion.

        What matters is that Cunliffe’s speech was crucially wrong, to a very large degree, in how the policy was outlined.

        Basically what you are doing is excusing the error because “reasons”. Actually I’d rather point out that there was an error, and that it’s not good enough, not matter what party it comes from.

        • RedLogix 17.6.1.1

          The error could only arise in the mind of someone who imagined it was going to be possible to double-dip both provisions.

          I’ve listened to the speech twice and the second time through I listened to the pertinent paras with the PPL question in mind.

          If you want to make an unreasonable literal interpretation of DC’s words (in other words you are being an pedantic dickhead) then yes you can have a go like Gower did. But any reasonable person would understand exactly what DC meant.

          You’ve fallen for Gower’s dickhead framing. Never ever give their hatred of us any oxygen Lanth. Never.

          • Lanthanide 17.6.1.1.1

            “The error could only arise in the mind of someone who imagined it was going to be possible to double-dip both provisions.”

            There’s no “imagining” necessary there, because Cunliffe’s speech out-right states that you get $60/week payment and they are also lengthening PPL to 6 months.

            Actually I think it is you who is trying to re-interpret Cunliffe’s speech in the best possible light after the fact. He has in fact already admitted to the mistake and taken fair cop on it, so he believes it was wrong even if you don’t.

            “But any reasonable person would understand exactly what DC meant.”

            I mustn’t be be a “reasonable person” then, because when I read in the online FAQ sheet that you don’t get the $60 payment until after the PPL period ends I was surprised but that is not at all how I understood it from Cunliffe’s speech (which I read, not watched). That was before any of this was caught and blown up by the media.

            “You’ve fallen for Gower’s dickhead framing.”

            No, not at all. As above, I discovered this myself before Gower did. If you read my other comments on this matter, you’ll also see that I consider this to be a minor footnote of the policy and Gower has massively overplayed the issue. But it IS an issue.

      • gem 17.6.2

        But a person is entitled to Super, and still earn a wage or salary, so isn’t a similar assumption reasonable with PPL and Best Start? Yes the reaction has been histrionic, and there was clearly no intent to mislead, but it was a mistake to omit it.

        • RedLogix 17.6.2.1

          @gem & Lanth

          I think the clue is in the term “Universal Superannuation”.

          If Best Start had been designed and named as a “Universal Child Allowance” then you would have a fair point.

          Instead Best Start is intended to rather modestly fill in the gap for those people who cannot access PPL – in which case it’s rather obvious that there was no intention to allow double-dipping.

          Imagine if Best Start was universal in the sense you are thinking of – what then? Gower would have attacked it as ‘double-dipping’, ‘middle-class’ welfare. No winning with dickheads like him.

          Incidentally it’s this sort of political nonsense which always arises from targeted benefits/tax credits. Which is one of the reasons why I’m personally so very strong (ideological even) on the idea of a clean, non-targeted UBI across the board.

          • gem 17.6.2.1.1

            Best Start cannot be a universal entitlement, because that would highlight the huge amount of wealth locked at the very top.
            Labour is not going to target the financial elite apart from a modest tax increase. The 1% are not part of the community in any meaningful sense, so the ”near universal” Best Start is not about them.

            ”In 2013 the wealthiest 1% of New Zealand adults own three times more wealth than the
            poorest 50%.”
            (Source: Service and Food Workers Union Living Wage fact-sheet)

            • RedLogix 17.6.2.1.1.1

              Yes – we’re on the same page there. The 1% (or more realistically the top 0.01%) are not on the same planet as the rest of us.

              But in real terms if you did make Best Start truly universal who cares if a family with a net worth over $10m or more and an income in excess of $1m pa gets an extra $60 pw for a year or so? It’s of zero significance anyway you look at it, either in terms of the impact on that household or the total amount paid out.

              In the big picture it’s a tiny, insignificant ‘so fucking what’ moment. In the big picture that wealthy household should have paid a fair old whack of tax, therefore who cares if they get a tiny fraction of it back? It just does not matter. The only reason we can’t go there politically is because of unreasoning arseholes like Gower.

              The real point to get here is that tory pricks like Gower are the enemy. You can never, ever win with them. No matter how carefully you frame the policy, or word the speech. The only thing he understands or respects is a greater force – maximum deliverable smackdown.

              Everytime.

              • gem

                ”But in real terms if you did make Best Start truly universal who cares if a family with a net worth over $10m or more and an income in excess of $1m pa gets an extra $60 pw for a year or so?”
                Of course it makes little difference to the very wealthy, and it wouldn’t have cost the state much more to make it universal. That’s not the point.
                If universality was proposed, the political debate would encompass the very wealthy, which would have been very interesting. So, at the moment (putting aside the silly business of what was and wasn’t disclosed about the eligibility criteria) the political debate is focused on the rights and wrongs of whether households earning up to $150,000 should receive Best Start. So it neuters the debate because it exempts those at the top from scrutiny.
                An opportunity has been lost to start a discussion about inequality and citizenship.

                • RedLogix

                  Oh I see your point now.

                  Yes I agree totally. I would have indeed made Best Start universal for exactly the reasons you outline – albeit if I can see it in hindsight.

                  At the same time if Cunliffe had been going down the universal path I would have expected him to have clearly, loudly signaled that in the speech. Which of course he didn’t – so no-one had any reasonable basis to assume otherwise.

                  • Colonial Viper

                    I’m still concerned that policy calls are being made from the perspective of the Thorndon Bubble.

                    i.e. what makes sense and seems clever from inside the Bubble, is actually at best deficient from the perspective of ‘real NZ’, or at worst, a complete clanger.

                    For instance, I am now hearing feedback from strong Labour supporters that they are peeved with the $150K pa threshold – far too high and untargeted they say.

                    In a way gem has a very good point the discussion which could have been had should universality have been used.

            • Anne 17.6.2.1.1.2

              Labour is not going to target the financial elite apart from a modest tax increase.

              I (partially) disagree there gem. I think Cunliffe is brave enough to stick it to them. Not as much as we might like, but it will be more than modest.

              Why do you think the Right are behaving the way they are? They’re in full panic mode and its not just because they see some power slipping from their fingers.

          • Lanthanide 17.6.2.1.2

            “Gower would have attacked it as ‘double-dipping’, ‘middle-class’ welfare. No winning with dickheads like him.”

            You keep focussing on Gower, as if it’s somehow Gower’s fault that Cunliffe didn’t get the details in his speech correct.

            Gower is irrelevant to whether the speech was correct.

            By all means, talk about Gower’s reaction to the details being wrong – he’s a dickhead and made a massive deal about this, including saying that it was a deliberate deception by Labour.

            But don’t use Gower’s response as a way to minimise what happened – Cunliffe made a mistake in his speech. Labour screwed up and gave reporters a cut-down version of the fact sheet that didn’t show that the $60 payment started after the PPL ended. Jacinda Ardern authorised printed material the likewise implies that everyone simultaneously receives $60/week payment and also PPL at the same time.

            • RedLogix 17.6.2.1.2.1

              But don’t use Gower’s response as a way to minimise what happened – Cunliffe made a mistake in his speech

              The mistake was not in the speech. It was in leaving a tiny loophole for a gumball like Gower to exploit.

              Gower would have found something to attack no matter how carefully worded the speech was. He would smeared Cunliffe no matter. You only have to go back to Gower’s treatment of Cunliffe at Labour’s 2011 Convention to see exactly the same pattern. That behaviour lies with Gower, not Cunliffe.

              Arguably the only mistake Labour made was in handing out a fact-sheet in the first place. As more than a few people have pointed out that when dealing with arseholes it’s better to keep your mouth shut and give them as little ammunition in the first place.

              The only way to respond to the likes of Gower is to take it back to them. Can you imagine Key ever, ever apologising? First rule of the corporate shark-pool – never admit to a mistake.

              • KJT

                I find it refreshing that a politician has the guts to say, “I fucked up”.

                An apology from those, in Labour, who participated in the great 1984 shafting, of New Zealanders, would be nice, though!

    • BLiP 17.7

      But Gower is capable of and did in fact read the detail which is how he was able to report that Cunliffe has misrepresented his own policy.

      Sure, Gower is capable. He displayed that when working for the New Zealand Fox News Herald. Trouble is, he’s become lazy and captured, and not God’s brightest little candle. The “media celebrity” ego doesn’t help much. Meanwhile, a journalist would, after having read the background material, sussed it wasn’t right and sought comment from the source to clarify. A journalist with contacts in the world of WINZ or ACC customers would know silly little loop holes like he imagined just do not exist. Instead, Gower, in an act of confirmation-bias, found his angle and went out full tit in repeating the line cunts like you have been whispering in his ear since last year when you called David Cunliffe a liar. Bit of meme, eh?

    • Hami Shearlie 17.8

      The pages he supposedly read seem to differ from what others have read! Maybe he was lost in a cloud of cannabis smoke that day – he does seem to be obsessed with it at the moment!

  18. Whatever next? 18

    Mathew Hooten, you remind me of Sarah Palin, so passionate and convinced by her own words, forgets to consider she is wrong, and therefore not worth the time of day( politically that is)

  19. RedBaronCV 19

    Look Matty, there is a vaste difference between the two policies:

    JKey has chucked some money on the table and is leaving it there until he figures out who can be bought to do the Nact dirty work for him, or something very like that.

    David Cunliffe has put a policy on the table that values children and those who bring them up – of course people want as much detail as possible and more than you would get in a speech, hence the desire to know more. That doesn’t make Cunliffe a liar, it makes him many times more principaled than the opposition and those who seek to denigrate the policy.

  20. Bill 20

    Journalists work for right wing institutions. That’s what the corporate msm are. Within those institutions there is a ‘natural’ self selecting censorship with regards what stories and angles are permissible or favoured. It’s not conspiracy. Along with the censorship, comes a flow on selection process for journalists. No thinking person with left wing political views who is a journalist working in a msm institution will be so for long.
    Put simply, they won’t get to cover the stories they think are important. Neither will they get the opportunity to do in depth pieces. Then there are the cut-backs in organisations on top of all that, and the need to ‘fill copy’ with fewer staff and resources. And so it goes.

    The good thing about all this, if it can be called a good thing, is that the media can become as out of touch with common sentiment, reality and feeling as most politicians already are. Most people don’t really ‘believe’ what the 6 O’Clock news or whatever is saying on a number of fronts at the moment. If the msm go negative on stuff that people are generally well disposed towards (perhaps Labour Green policies?) then what they may well achieve is a groundswell of extra support for the Labour/Green parties. Is it so far fetched to imagine a backlash against the msm and the Tories they identify with, and who identify with them, arising from a small but critical increase in the already widespread cynicism felt with regards the integrity of our so-called news sources?

    • Bill, I was agreeing until you said “Most people don’t really ‘believe’ what the 6 O’Clock news or whatever is saying …”

      Matthew Hooton is fun isn’t he. Such a nice conservative who takes the time to discuss but can’t see the wood for the trees, can’t see his own mistakes. Reminds me of earnest religionists knocking on the door.

      So Matthew, were you misrepresenting, as micksavage said? I’d love to hear an apology.

      • weka 20.1.1

        “So Matthew, were you misrepresenting, as micksavage said? I’d love to hear an apology.”

        What leads you to think you might get an apology when its his job to misrepresent? ;-)

    • Jan 20.2

      Thank you, Bill, for that superb piece of logical analysis – I would love to think that there will be a backlash, but where will it come from?

      • Bill 20.2.1

        It’s already under way. I think it’s fair to say that most people take the information coming from ‘the news’ with a pinch of salt where they have any knowledge on what is being said. Years back, people took the news as gospel.

        Next step along the route we’re on is where people grab a bag of salt for anything coming from the msm. I don’t think that point is too far away, and in NZ, with a small, fairly tightly packed population (small geography) that is more ‘in touch’ with itself (communication wise) due to our society being ‘shallower’ and therefore easier to penetrate, it should be a quicker process than will be for the say 60 odd million in the UK or the hundreds of millions in the US.

        Maybe. ;-)

    • gem 20.3

      There are some good points here, but it should be acknowledged that before all the buy-ups, cutbacks, and consolidation, the media largely bought the Rogernomics shock doctrine.
      This removed a potential hurdle for the Labour Party’s programme of a fire sale of assets, corporatising the public sector, introducing GST, slashing personal income tax for the wealthy, embedding structural employment in the name of monetarism, decimating rural NZ.
      An out of touch media is nothing new.

  21. newsense 21

    How much is Hooton getting paid to be here? At least he can’t shout over us here

    • rhinocrates 21.1

      At least we don’t have that fool Williams saying “Iagreewithmatthew” to his every post.

  22. freedom 22

    Reading the above comments, I count a half dozen framings of the same question to Hooton.
    Not one of them has he even attempted to answer.
    The question is [paraphrasing]:

    If it is good that journalists gather like emaciated hyena and pick apart policy announcements from Labour and the Green party, why do they not give the exact same attention to National party policy?

    • well I never 22.1

      “……..why do they not give the exact same attention to National party policy?”

      Exactly, that is what we are asking, but asking the guys that are doing it will not yield anything, is there anyone impartial left to raise the question with? Sky seems to be paying alot of retainers for questionable returns to people with a voice/sway with the electorate

Links to post

Important links

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

  • On arguing by analogy
    Climate blogs and comment threads are full of ‘arguments by analogy’. Depending on what ‘side’ one is on, climate science is either like evolution/heliocentrism/quantum physics/relativity or eugenics/phrenology/Ptolemaic cosmology/phlogiston. Climate contrarians are either like flat-earthers/birthers/moon-landing hoaxers/vaccine-autism linkers or Galileo/stomach ulcer-Heliobacter proponents/Wegner/Copernicus....
    Real Climate | 02-09
  • Unforced variations: September 2014
    This month’s open thread. People could waste time rebunking predictable cherry-picked claims about the upcoming Arctic sea ice minimum, or perhaps discuss a selection of 10 climate change controversies from ICSU… Anything! (except mitigation)....
    Real Climate | 02-09
  • Greens’ commitment to pay equity welcomed by workers
    The Public Service Association (PSA) says the 58,000 workers they represent will benefit from the announcement by the Green Party...
    PSA | 02-09
  • John Key’s Top 69 Lies: Today no. 18 – Capital gains tax will put u...
      Capital Gains Tax Fact Check  The Reality Labour’s CGT only applies to the sale of assets, it will exclude the family home, and will not push up rents. Every New Zealander should pay their fair share of tax. It is...
    Arch Rival | 02-09
  • Guest Author: The Rock Fuels NZ Roastbuster Rape Culture
    - by Jessie Hume . . This is making me feel pretty uncomfortable. Here we have an instance of Jono and Ben posing like “exposed celebrities”. But do you know what I’m seeing? I’m seeing two dudes who basically “roasted”...
    Frankly Speaking | 02-09
  • Dunne won’t read ‘muck-raking’ Dirty Politics
    .   . Full story: Dunne won’t read ‘muck-raking’ Dirty Politics Because as we all know, ignorance is such bliss. Eh, Mr Dunne? . . = fs =Filed under: On A Lighter Note Tagged: Dirty Politics, Peter Dunne...
    Frankly Speaking | 02-09
  • Whale spotted off Wellington
    .   . Full story: Whale spotted off Wellington Shouldn’t that be a “Southern Right Wing Whale”?! . . = fs =Filed under: On A Lighter Note Tagged: Whaleoil...
    Frankly Speaking | 02-09
  • A Not-So-Foreign Country
    The Shadow Of The Past: The only positive aspect of Watergate was the way in which the venerable US Constitution was able to defuse what could have exploded into a full-blown “legitimation crisis”. Is New Zealand’s unwritten and historically untested...
    Bowalley Road | 02-09
  • An admission of failure; too little, too late
    The Prime Minister announced today that if re-elected, after the election, he would look to merge CERA into the department of Prime Minister and Cabinet. This is an admission that the CERA model – authoritarian, dictatorial and deaf to the...
    Rebuilding Christchurch | 02-09
  • Stuart’s 100 #18 A Great South Rd?
    18: A Great South Road? What if Great South Road truly was great? The creation of Great South Road was one of the great formational moves in the early expansion of Auckland. Starting in 1861, some 12,000 soldiers built the...
    Transport Blog | 02-09
  • New Fisk
    Israel’s ‘land for lives’ is theft. Pure and simple...
    No Right Turn | 02-09
  • Waiariki: Marae digi poll has Flavell losing support, Sykes up.
    The Marae digi poll on the Waiariki electorate came out yesterday - for what it's worth. They are notoriously unreliable.  The landline polls are increasingly picking up older householders and skewing to the middle class establishment that still maintain a...
    Tumeke | 02-09
  • Spying on their allies again
    The Intercept has a major new story about the US's intelligence relationship with Turkey, and how the US monitors the Kurds for the Turkish government, even helping them target hit squads. But at the same time as they're spying for...
    No Right Turn | 02-09
  • The Press Debate – tonight, livestreamed on Stuff
    The second big head-to-head between David Cunliffe and John Key will be livestreamed on Stuff from 7pm! The Press leaders’ debate is where Key pulled his “show me the money” quote in 2011. And he’s going to be taking this...
    Boots Theory | 02-09
  • Not business as usual: Key’s leadership style & the bloggersphere
    Two weeks ago I suggested this could turn into New Zealand's first policy-free election; my instinct seems to have been proven correct. While policy debates are still occuring around the fringes, there is no way now that with just two...
    Pundit | 02-09
  • Rock Star or Rock Bottom
    There was a story in the Press yesterday about 14 people sharing a small 3 bedroom house in Hornby after a family of 6 lost their rental and all their (uninsured) possessions in a fire and had to move in...
    Te Whare Whero | 02-09
  • Greens workers policy supported by union movement
    The CTU is supporting the Green Party’s policy launched today focused on improving life for working New Zealanders. Photo:  ...
    CTU | 02-09
  • To drive or not to drive, that is the question: generation Y research
    This is a guest post from Dr Debbie Hopkins, a Postdoctoral Research Fellow at the University of Otago – she’s currently doing some research for the NZTA on non-drivers. Read on to find out more and see if you might...
    Transport Blog | 02-09
  • Reclaiming the Third Way & why it’s not a sell-out
    During a visit he made to Melbourne in 2000, I joined some colleagues to sit down for a chat with Dick Morris, the self-proclaimed strategic mastermind who claimed to have single-handedly rescued Bill Clinton's flailing presidency and coined the term...
    Pundit | 02-09
  • The Greens on work and wages
    The Greens released their work and wages policy today, targeted firmly at improving living standards and reducing inequality. The headline policy is an immediate increase in the minimum wage to $16/hour, followed by annual increases to reach $18/hour in 2017....
    No Right Turn | 01-09
  • America, America ….
    We hear a lot about American exceptionalism – what they lead the world in, what they think they lead the world in, and their unshakeable belief in their god-given right to do so.  The USA has the highest per capita ownership of...
    Te Whare Whero | 01-09
  • The caretaker convention and elections
    There was an interesting discussion on Twitter yesterday between Dean Knight and Graeme Edgeler about the caretaker convention and elections. Dean highlighted the fact that Key had a perfect right to call for whatever sort of inquiry he felt like,...
    No Right Turn | 01-09
  • A clayton’s inquiry
    That's the only way to describe John Key's proposed "inquiry" into Judith Collins:An inquiry into the events surrounding Judith Collins' downfall will not examine the relationship between her and Whale Oil blogger Cameron Slater or the Serious Fraud Office investigation...
    No Right Turn | 01-09
  • YahooNZ’s news polls
    Another YahooNZ poll': September 1st"Do you think Dirty Politics is distracting from more important issues this election?" Results at the time of writing this:Yes. absolutely77%  (5622)  No, it's important22%  (1619)   I'm not sure1%  (66)    The capitals on 'Dirty Politics' clearly...
    Te Whare Whero | 01-09
  • Vote Choice: ACT’s Jamie Whyte – a ‘Narrow’ Ally?
    This week, the Vote Choice series looks at Dr Jamie Whyte, the leader of the ACT party, and his views on abortion and decriminalisation. A google search of Whyte and abortion provides little in the way of his opinion but...
    ALRANZ | 01-09
  • Who is Carrick Graham?
    Carrick GrahamIn damage control since their campaign officially began derailing a couple of weeks ago, things took another terrible turn for the National party last weekend. Not only did the corrupt Judith Collins have to resign on Saturday because of...
    The Jackal | 01-09
  • Judith, Cam, and the phantom FB messages
    I see that Judith Collins and Cameron Slater believe the hacker has simply invented Facebook conversations between the two of them. Insitnctively I don;t believe the denials, but I have an idea that could help Collins clear her name. Facebook...
    Polity | 01-09
  • Judith, Cameron, and the phantom FB messages
    I see that Judith Collins and Cameron Slater believe the hacker has simply invented Facebook conversations between the two of them. Insitnctively I don;t believe the denials, but I have an idea that could help Collins clear her name. Facebook...
    Polity | 01-09
  • Matthew Hooton’s dirty tactics
    Outside observers might be watching the National party unravelling and wondering what the hell is going on. This is especially the case with one particular right wing propagandist, Matthew Hooton.At first Hooton’s behaviour might seem a bit strange. He has...
    The Jackal | 01-09
  • Is Petrol cheap?
    I don’t tend to look at the motoring section of the Herald much however every now and then something stands out - often for its comedy value - and that was the case yesterday in an article titled Motoring Mythbusting. The article covers off...
    Transport Blog | 01-09
  • People of Turkey, Ukraine, I salute you!
    For some reason, I seem to be getting a lot of visits from Turkey.  Or perhaps that's just where IP address disguisers are presenting as at the moment.  But I like to thin the Ruritanian nature of New Zealand politics...
    Left hand palm | 01-09
  • The health pillar of good government
    Whatever the result on September 20, John Key will start the next term with diminished personal authority. Our democracy’s health is also diminished. Key’s inch-by-inch retreat to the point where his imagined leftwing conspiracy turned into a rightwing one and...
    Colin James | 01-09
  • Keystone XL: Oil Markets and Emissions
    Estimates of the incremental emission effects of individual oil sands projects like the Keystone XL (KXL) pipeline are sensitive to assumptions about the response of world markets and alternative transportation options. A recent Nature Climate Change paper by Erickson and...
    Skeptical Science | 01-09
  • Union to support Work and Income staff following tragedy
    The Public Service Association (PSA) says today’s shooting at a Work and Income office is a tragedy, and nobody should...
    PSA | 01-09
  • We no longer have a Prime Minister
    Having just listened to an item featuring John Key on Checkpoint (National Radio) I now have to announce that New Zealand has no-one at present performing the proper role of Prime Minister. John Key could not have acted less Prime Ministerial if he had...
    Political Scientist | 01-09
  • We no longer have a Prime Minister
    Having just listened to an item featuring John Key on Checkpoint (National Radio) I now have to announce that New Zealand has no-one at present performing the proper role of Prime Minister. John Key could not have acted less Prime Ministerial if he had...
    The Political Scientist | 01-09
  • Ashburton, 1 September 2014.
    Crime Scene: The murder of two WINZ workers and the wounding of another in Ashburton adds another tragic chapter to New Zealand's grim history of lone men committing multiple murders.I NEVER WENT BACK to Aramoana after the killing. I had...
    Bowalley Road | 01-09
  • Radio NZ: Politics with Matthew Hooton and Mike Williams – 1 September 20...
    . - Politics on Nine To Noon - . - Monday 1 September 2014 - . - Kathryn Ryan, with Matthew Hooton & Mike Williams - . Today on Politics on Nine To Noon, Mike Williams and Matthew Hooton on...
    Frankly Speaking | 01-09
  • Radio NZ: Politics with Matthew Hooton and Mike Williams – 1 September 20...
    . - Politics on Nine To Noon - . - Monday 1 September 2014 - . - Kathryn Ryan, with Matthew Hooton & Mike Williams - . Today on Politics on Nine To Noon, Mike Williams and Matthew Hooton on...
    Frankly Speaking | 01-09
  • John Key’s Top 69 Lies, Today no. 19 – The SkyCity deal doesn’t m...
     SkyCity deal doesn't mean more pokies – Key SkyCity is understood to be seeking law changes allowing 300 to 500 additional pokie machines and wider use of technology which would increase gambling revenue in return for building the $350 million facility...
    Arch Rival | 01-09
  • Will an inquiry make it all better?
    So far, the Dirty Politics book has generated two inquiries. The first is into the release  of information from the SIS to a certain blogger whom we don't name. The second is into Judith Collins' alleged involvement with an alleged...
    Pundit | 01-09
  • We Play Dirty at the Climate Talks Too: New Zealand’s Dirty Politics of C...
    This guest post is by David Tong, an Auckland based community lawyer working on his Master’s in Law on the UN climate talks. He chairs the P3 Foundation and co-chairs the Aotearoa New Zealand Human Rights Lawyers Association, and last...
    Hot Topic | 01-09
  • The trouble with liars
    A group of habitual liars try to get their story straight....
    Imperator Fish | 01-09
  • Photo of the day: Mitre 10′s bike parking
    The other weekend I went to the Mitre 10 Mega in Wairau Road to pick up some building supplies. To my surprise, they’ve put in a bike rack near the store entrance. I’m not sure how much use it’s going...
    Transport Blog | 01-09
  • TEU VICTORIA UNIVERSITY BRANCH NEWSLETTER – SEPTEMBER 2014
      TEU Victoria University Branch Newsletter – September 2014 In this issue: AGM-a-calling: Welcome from the Branch President Ask them Anything: TEU Presidential Election Election Special: Union members could make the difference Election Special: 3 Reasons to Vote Bringing Back Dignity:...
    Tertiary Education Union | 01-09
  • Stumbling towards Power?
    Let's be honest about it.  Labour have absolutely nothing to celebrate just now.The last few days have been fantastic for the left and in particular for a certain Mr D Cunliffe.  But before we get too deliriously joyous, let's face...
    Left hand palm | 01-09
  • Will the police investigate?
    John Key is busy putting together an inquiry into Judith Collins' attempt to undermined SFO Chief Executive Adam Feeley. The effectiveness of any inquiry will ultimately depend on its terms of reference, and the signs are not good; Key looks...
    No Right Turn | 01-09
  • Dirty Politics symposium on Friday
    Otago University will be holding an online symposium this Friday on "Debating 'Dirty Politics': Media, Politics and Law". Andrew Geddis has more details on the agenda: 1:00-1:15: Opening interview with Mr Nicky Hager 1:15-2:05: Media panel with Dr Rosemary Overell;...
    No Right Turn | 01-09
  • Debating “Dirty Politics”: Media, Politics and Law
    Love it or loathe it, Nicky Hager's Dirty Politics and its aftermath has lit a fire under our perception of "politics as usual" in New Zealand. Exactly how all that plays out come September 20th is an as yet unknown...
    Pundit | 01-09
  • More British collusion in torture
    This time in Nepal, where they funded, equipped and supported a regime torture-squad:British authorities have been accused of funding a four-year intelligence operation in Nepal that led to Maoist rebels being arrested, tortured and killed during the country’s civil war....
    No Right Turn | 01-09
  • There’s Only One Poll That Counts
    “One of the oldest sayings in politics is that there is only one poll that counts – the one on Election Day – and that’s the one that I am focusing on” remarked the MANA Movement candidate for Waiariki, Annette...
    Mana | 02-09
  • Local communities critical to Civil Defence
    Labour will focus on empowering New Zealand communities to be resilient in Civil Defence disasters, says Labour’s Civil Defence spokesperson Clare Curran. Announcing Labour’s Civil Defence policy, she says that Labour will work with schools, voluntary agencies and community groups...
    Labour | 02-09
  • Labour looks to long-life passports, gambling harm review
    A return to 10 year passports and a review of gambling laws are highlights of Labour’s Internal Affairs policy released today. “More than 15,000 New Zealanders signed a petition calling on the Government to revert to the 10 year system...
    Labour | 02-09
  • MANA Movement Leadership stands strong behind Internet MANA relationship
    “There is now, and always will be, a range of views about many issues within our movement and members are free to express them, but Georgina’s views on Kim Dotcom are not shared by the MANA Movement leadership or the vast majority...
    Mana | 01-09
  • Rebuilding the New Zealand Defence Force
    A Labour Government will make it a priority to rebuild the capacity of the Defence Force to carry out the tasks expected of it, says Labour’s Defence Spokesperson Phil Goff. Releasing Labour’s Defence Policy today he said the NZDF has...
    Labour | 01-09
  • Speech to Canterbury Chamber of Commerce
    Today I'm going to talk about our policy package to upgrade and grow our economy and how we turn that growth into a foundation for a decent and fair society. But first I want to address the issue of our...
    Labour | 01-09
  • Commission of Inquiry must have bipartisan support
    The Labour Party is drafting terms of reference for a Commission of Inquiry, Labour’s Shadow Attorney-General David Parker says. “It is abundantly clear there is a need for an independent Commission of Inquiry, chaired by a High Court Judge, into...
    Labour | 01-09
  • Rapid Transit to unclog Christchurch
    Labour will build a 21st century Rapid Transit system for Christchurch, says Labour Leader David Cunliffe. “The long delayed recovery of Christchurch hinges on a modern commuter system for the city. “We will invest $100 million in a modern rail plan...
    Labour | 31-08
  • Labour’s commitment to public broadcasting
    A Labour Government will set up a working group to re-establish a public service television station as part of our commitment to ensuring New Zealand has high quality free-to-air local content. “We will set up a working group to report...
    Labour | 31-08
  • A new deal for the conservation estate
    The health of our economy depends on New Zealand preserving and restoring our land, air, water and indigenous wildlife, says Labour’s Conservation spokesperson Ruth Dyson. Announcing Labours Conservation policy, she said that there will be a comprehensive plan to restore...
    Labour | 31-08
  • Labour’s plan to end homelessness
    Labour has a comprehensive approach to end homelessness starting with the provision of emergency housing for 1000 people each year and putting an end to slum conditions in boarding houses, Labour Leader David Cunliffe says. “Labour believes that homelessness is not...
    Labour | 30-08
  • Labour: A smarter approach to justice
    A Labour Government will improve the justice system to ensure it achieves real public safety, provides equal access to justice and protects human rights, Labour’s Justice spokesperson Andrew Little says. “Our approach is about tackling the root causes of crime, recognising...
    Labour | 29-08
  • Labour to foster Kiwi love of sport and the great outdoors
    A Labour Government will promote physical activity, back our top athletes and help foster Kiwis’ love of the great outdoors by upgrading tramping and camping facilities. Trevor Mallard today released Labour’s sports and recreation policy which will bring back a...
    Labour | 29-08
  • Pacific languages recognised under Labour
    Labour will act to recognise the five main Pacific languages in New Zealand including through the education system, said Pacific Affairs spokesperson Su’a William Sio. Announcing Labour’s Pacific Island policy he said that there must be a strong commitment to...
    Labour | 29-08
  • No healthy economy without a healthy environment
    Labour recognises that we cannot have a healthy economy without a healthy environment, says Environment spokesperson Moana Mackey announcing Labour’s environment policy. “New Zealand’s economy has been built on the back of the enormous environmental wealth we collectively enjoy as...
    Labour | 28-08
  • Better protection, fairer deal for Kiwi consumers
    Tackling excessive prices, ensuring consumers have enough information to make ethical choices and giving the Commerce Commission more teeth are highlights of Labour’s Consumer Rights policy. “The rising cost of living is a concern for thousands of Kiwi families. A...
    Labour | 28-08
  • Media Advisory – MANA Movement Candidate for Waiariki Annette Sykes, Waia...
    Media are advised that this coming weekend, the MANA Movement Candidate for Waiariki, Annette Sykes, will be on the Internet MANA Road Trip within the electorate of Waiariki. Speakers confirmed are Annette Sykes, Hone Harawira, John Minto, Laila Harre and Kim...
    Mana | 27-08
  • Internet MANA – Waiariki Road Trip: 29, 30, 31 Aug 2014
    The Internet MANA Road Trip hits Waiariki this weekend. It would be great if all MANA members in Waiariki could especially attend the public meetings and show their support for our Waiariki candidate Annette Sykes. Confirmed speakers Hone Harawira (except Taupo), Annette...
    Mana | 27-08
  • First home buyers $200 a week better off with Labour
    A couple earning around $75,000 a year would be $200 a week better off buying a two bedroom terraced Labour KiwiBuild home instead of an equivalent new build under National’s housing policy, says Labour Leader David Cunliffe.  “National’s policy to...
    Labour | 26-08
  • Another Day – Another big power profit
    The latest profit announcement from Genesis Energy shows that the power company was sold for a song to the detriment of the country’s power consumers, says Labour’s Energy spokesperson David Shearer. “A net profit of $ 49.2 million follows hard...
    Labour | 26-08
  • Labour embraces the rainbow
    Labour will work hard to ensure all New Zealanders enjoy the freedom to grow up and live their lives in dignity and security. Labour’s Rainbow policy, released tonight in Wellington, focuses on International Relations, Human Rights and Education....
    Labour | 26-08
  • National gets fast and loose with the facts
    In their desperation to make it look as though they are doing something about the housing crisis, National is playing fast and loose with the facts, says Labour’s housing spokesperson Phil Twyford....
    Labour | 26-08
  • Labour will drop power prices for Kiwi families
    New Zealanders will get cheaper power prices under NZ Power, says Labour Leader David Cunliffe. “The electricity market is clearly broken. With falling demand for electricity, prices should be going down. Instead prices are going up and companies are extracting...
    Labour | 26-08
  • Labour: Promoting sustainable tourism
    Ensuring New Zealand’s clean, green status continues to be an international tourism benchmark and reviewing MBIE’s oversight of the tourism sector will be on the radar under a Labour Government. Releasing Labour’s Tourism policy today, spokesperson Darien Fenton said tourism...
    Labour | 26-08
  • Skills shortage a result of National’s complacency
    The fact that there is still a severe shortage of skilled tradespeople, despite a growth in the number of apprentices, is a result of National’s failure to plan and develop the workforce, Grant Robertson, Labour Employment, Skills and TrainingSpokesperson says."The...
    Labour | 26-08
  • How much tax does John Key pay compared to a minimum wage worker?? – Mint...
    MANA Movement Economic Justice spokesperson John Minto is calling for a radical overhaul of New Zealand’s taxation system with calculations showing that a minimum wage worker pays a ten times higher tax rate than the Prime Minister. o Minimum wage...
    Mana | 25-08
  • Labour’s culture of science and innovation
    Labour will create a culture of science and innovation in New Zealand that will be the envy of the world, says Labour’s Innovation, Research and Development spokesperson Megan Woods. “Labour believes that good science lies at the heart of a...
    Labour | 25-08
  • Improving life for our new New Zealanders
    New Zealand’s international standing as a community that encourages and fosters all cultures will be bolstered under a Labour Government with an upgrade of the present Office of Ethnic Affairs to a Ministry. Releasing Labour’s Ethnic Affairs policy, spokesperson Phil...
    Labour | 25-08
  • South Auckland housing crisis
    National’s HomeStart package is nothing more than a political stunt designed to beguile South Auckland voters, said Labour’s Pacific Affairs spokesperson Su’a William Sio. “Few working Pasifika and Maori workers in South Auckland will be able to buy their own...
    Labour | 25-08
  • Home buyer subsidy discredited in Oz
    Treasury advised against National’s policy of ramping up home buyer subsidies after it was discredited in Australia because it pushed house prices even higher, Labour’s Housing spokesperson Phil Twyford says. “Documents released under the OIA (attached) show Treasury advised the...
    Labour | 25-08
  • Nursing hours explain turnover and high-stress culture
    A staff survey supports concerns nursing staff at Dunedin Hospital are under increasing pressure and that the emergency department is in a critical state, says Labour’s Associate Health Spokesperson David Clark.  “An ED nursing survey at Dunedin found that 80...
    Labour | 24-08
  • Underhand tactics prove case for axing donations
    Revelations that schools are using underhand tactics to coerce donations from cash-strapped parents further highlights the need for Labour's plan to increase funding so they aren't dependent on contributions from parents, Labour's Education spokesperson Chris Hipkins says. “By law New...
    Labour | 24-08
  • National applies band-aid to housing crisis
    The Government’s flagship housing announcement is a band-aid approach that will push up prices rather than solve the housing crisis, says Labour Leader David Cunliffe. “House sales to first home buyers have collapsed as a direct result of the Government’s...
    Labour | 24-08
  • Climate change focus on the now for the future
    A Labour Governmentwill put in place a comprehensive climate change strategy focusing on bothmitigation and adaptation, establish an independent Climate Commission andimplement carbon budgeting, says Labour Climate Change spokesperson MoanaMackey."This is about future-proofing our economy. Making the transition to alow-carbon...
    Labour | 24-08
  • Labour’s 21st century transport pledge
    The next Labour-led Government will create a 21st century transport system for New Zealand that promotes the most efficient and sustainable combination of transport options, says Labour’s Transport spokesperson Phil Twyford. “Labour will rebalance the Government's transport spending away from...
    Labour | 23-08
  • Housing under National: the facts
    1.       House prices in Auckland Council valuations indicate Auckland house prices have gone up by one-third over the last three years. (Auckland Council) The average Auckland house price has gone up by nearly $225,000 since 2008, up over $75,000 in...
    Labour | 23-08
  • Labour irons out low income tax issue
    The increasing casualisation of work has led to many New Zealand families being disadvantaged through the tax they pay, Labour Leader David Cunliffe says. "Many low paid workers are having to work two or three jobs to make ends meet...
    Labour | 22-08
  • Cornered Government comes out swinging
    The National Government is so desperate to keep its dead-in-the-water expert teachers policy alive, it has refused to rule out forcing schools to participate through legislation, Labour’s Education spokesperson Chris Hipkins says. “John Key today attacked the Educational Institute for...
    Labour | 22-08
  • Pacific people continue to go backwards under National
    A report from Victoria University highlights the fact that Pacific people are continuing to go backwards under a National Government, said Labour’s Pacific Affairs spokesperson Su’a William Sio.  “The report shows the largest inequality increases were in smoking, obesity, tertiary...
    Labour | 22-08
  • Wellington transport plan needs to keep moving
    The failure of the Transport Agency to properly look at alternatives to the Basin Reserve flyover is not a good reason for further delays to improving transport in Wellington, Labour MPs Grant Robertson and Annette King say. “The Board of...
    Labour | 22-08
  • Labour’s focus on inequality, kids and better job prospects
    Tackling child poverty and removing barriers to people working part time to enhance their prospects of moving into a fulltime job are highlights of Labour’s Social Development policy. Releasing the policy today, spokesperson Sue Moroney said while part-time work was...
    Labour | 21-08
  • Political staff should give answers under oath
    The Inspector General of Security and Intelligence should use her full statutory powers to question witnesses under oath about the leak of SIS information, says Labour MP Phil Goff. “Leakage of confidential information from the SIS for political purposes is...
    Labour | 21-08
  • High dollar, hands-off Govt sends workers to dole queue
    The loss of up to 100 jobs at Croxley stationery in Auckland is devastating news for their families and the local Avondale community, Labour’s Employment, Skills and Training spokesperson Grant Robertson says. “The company’s inability to compete in international markets...
    Labour | 21-08
  • National’s flagship education policy dead in the water
    National’s plan to create executive principals and expert teachers is effectively dead in the water with news that 93 percent of primary teachers have no confidence in the scheme, Labour’s Education spokesperson Chris Hipkins says. “The fact that teachers are...
    Labour | 21-08
  • Dunedin will be a knowledge and innovation centre under Labour
    Dunedin will become a knowledge and innovation centre under a Labour Government that will back local businesses, support technology initiatives and fund dynamic regional projects, Labour Leader David Cunliffe says. “Nowhere has the National Government’s short-sightedness been more apparently than...
    Labour | 21-08
  • Inquiry into SIS disclosures the right decision
    Labour MP Phil Goff says the Inspector-General of Intelligence and Security has done the right thing by launching an inquiry into the disclosure of SIS documents about a meeting between himself and the agency’s former director-general. “This inquiry is necessary...
    Labour | 20-08
  • Labour – supporting and valuing carers and the cared for
    Placing real value on our elderly and the people who care for them will be a priority for a Labour Government, Labour Leader David Cunliffe says. Releasing Labour’s Senior Citizens policy today David Cunliffe promised that a Labour Government would...
    Labour | 20-08
  • By Hoki! It’s Labour’s fisheries policy
    A Labour Government will protect the iconic Kiwi tradition of fishing by improving access to the coast, protecting the rights of recreational fishers and reviewing snapper restrictions, Labour’s Fisheries spokesperson Damien O’Connor says. “Catching a fish from the rocks, beach...
    Labour | 20-08
  • Mighty River – Mighty Profits – Mighty hard to swallow
    Mighty River Power’s profit increase of 84 per cent is simply outrageous, says Labour’s Energy spokesperson David Shearer. “Demand for electricity is flat or declining yet the company has made enormous profits. It is the latest power company to celebrate...
    Labour | 19-08
  • Collins’ actions were wrong, not unwise
    John Key’s moral compass remains off-kilter as he cannot bring himself to declare Judith Collins’ actions outright wrong, not simply ‘unwise’, said Labour MP Grant Robertson. “Under pressure John Key is finally shifting his stance but his failure to condemn...
    Labour | 19-08
  • The Press Leaders Debate – proof a newspaper can kill the internet
    No more beersies for you Mr Key. Seriously – was the Prime Minister drunk during this debate? I am so sickened by what passed as a Leaders debate, I will make this review short and vicious. Everyone involved in putting...
    The Daily Blog | 02-09
  • Voting starts tomorrow!
    On the telly, in the papers, on the Net, billboards on almost every street corner – it’s hard to miss the fact that there’s an election coming up. Everyone’s trying to win your vote on Election Day, September 20, (this...
    The Daily Blog | 02-09
  • Collins inquiry a whitewash before it has even started
    The farce whitewash that Key is trying to push through here for the inquiry into Judith Collins role in a hit on the SFO should enrage any NZer, regardless of how they vote. Whaleoil won’t be forced to appear, it’s...
    The Daily Blog | 02-09
  • Press Leaders Debate – Round 2 – 7pm tonight
    This debate is live in a Town Hall, Key has done well at these in the past, but since the hate politics exposed in Dirty Politics, expect real fury directed at Key. My guess is that Key will attempt to use whatever he...
    The Daily Blog | 02-09
  • MANA hit speed wobbles – why Annette Sykes will win Waiariki
    MANA are my favourites. But of late, their transition from crawling to sprinting has hit some speed wobbles. Hone’s and Pam’s aggressive attitude towards the media recently is very understandable in light of how connected many of the media were to...
    The Daily Blog | 02-09
  • Soz Cam – PaknSave boycott of whaleoil continues – time to start a boyc...
    Cam is so carcinogenic now, not even his mates in the Tobacco Industry are talking to him any longer. I suspect only the Israeli Defence Force propaganda department are paying for content on whaleoil now. Cam says that PaknSave have dropped their problems...
    The Daily Blog | 02-09
  • The Rock Fuels NZ Roastbuster Rape Culture
    This is making me feel pretty uncomfortable. Here we have an instance of Jono and Ben posing like “exposed celebrities”. But do you know what I’m seeing? I’m seeing two dudes who basically “roasted” a woman online (exposed pictures of...
    The Daily Blog | 02-09
  • GUEST BLOG: Kate Davis – Why beneficiaries need advocacy
    There are times when I am wrong. I was wrong recently when someone suggested to me that AAAP should be eligible for government funding to continues its advocacy work. That was before. Before dealing with advocacy on a weekly basis...
    The Daily Blog | 01-09
  • TheDailyBlog September Political Poll Has Been Kicked Off
    The Daily Blog’s August poll has concluded and the September poll has been kicked off, asking readers: What party will you likely vote for at this year’s General Election? You will see this month’s poll in the right-hand sidebar of...
    The Daily Blog | 01-09
  • GUEST BLOG: Kelly Ellis – Jamie Whyte, leave that poor seal alone!
    Worse than showing mere lip service to Rainbow inclusion, ACT leader Jamie Whyte showed stunning arrogance when appeared at a candidates debate on rainbow issues hosted by the Auckland University Students’ Association last Thursday. The stunning hypocrisy was evident as...
    The Daily Blog | 01-09
  • Right wing can’t help but use scum
    Some people have been shocked that the traditional right wing party in New Zealand politics is so deeply embedded with scum like the blogger Whale Oil. We need not be so surprised. It takes a certain type to support the...
    The Daily Blog | 01-09
  • EXCLUSIVE: National’s Ohariu candidate admits contact by Simon Lusk
    . . Wellington, NZ, 31  August – At a meet-the-candidates public meeting in the Rongotai Electorate, National’s Ohariu candidate, Brett Hudson, confirmed that he had been approached by “a mate”, who passed on a message from  National Party operative, Simon...
    The Daily Blog | 01-09
  • Coalition for Better Broadcasting – Auckland Broadcasting Debate 2014
    Coalition for Better Broadcasting – Auckland Broadcasting Debate 2014...
    The Daily Blog | 01-09
  • Petition for Governor General of New Zealand to Investigate all the allegat...
      Now we see the inquiry will be a whitewash, that is secret, won’t be consulted with the Opposition, will have limited scope and will ignore Nicky Hager’s book, we must demand the Governor General step in and demand an...
    The Daily Blog | 01-09
  • Ashburton, 1 September 2014
    I NEVER WENT BACK to Aramoana after the killing. I had been a frequent visitor to the tiny seaside village back in the late 1970s and throughout the 80s. Its tall cliffs and broad beaches providing a colourful backdrop to...
    The Daily Blog | 01-09
  • Checkmate in 1 move – how could Slater have known what was in OIA request...
    And now we get down to the final few moves before checkmate. If the following investigation is right, how could Slater and Collins have known what was in the Secret Intelligence Service Official Information Act request that hadn’t been released...
    The Daily Blog | 01-09
  • The Edge Posts Naked Photos Of Jennifer Lawrence Without Consent
    Today the Edge website – owned by Media Works – published fully naked photographs of Jennifer Lawrence without her consent. It is not OK to publish naked media of any woman without her consent, full stop. It is absolutely disgusting...
    The Daily Blog | 01-09
  • Bomber, Laila and Maggie – a highlight from Auckland Broadcasting Debate ...
    Bomber, Laila and Maggie – a highlight from Auckland Broadcasting Debate 2014...
    The Daily Blog | 01-09
  • Jeremy Wells’ Mike Hosking rant on Radio Hauraki: Today, how good was I i...
    Jeremy Wells’ Mike Hosking on Radio Hauraki...
    The Daily Blog | 31-08
  • Maggie Barry slags Laila Harre & blogger, audience erupt
    The Coalition for Better Broadcasting held their public meeting in Auckland last night and it became a fiery shouting match when Maggie Barry decided to slag Laila Harre and me off. 250 people packed into the Pioneer Hall off High...
    The Daily Blog | 31-08
  • It has to be a full independent public inquiry and Key MUST front
      You know things are bad when images like this start appearing in the media.  It isn’t a ‘left wing conspiracy’ to point out the over whelming evidence of what is clearly a right wing conspiracy! If it looks like a conspiracy, sounds like a conspiracy...
    The Daily Blog | 31-08
  • Political Party social media stats – National playing Dirty Politics on s...
    Interesting data from friend of the blog, Marty Stewart, on social media likes and it shows an interesting question that post Dirty Politics should probably get asked…   …it’s interesting that Key has so many personal followers.  One wonders if...
    The Daily Blog | 31-08
  • The depth of the National rot and the compliance of our news media
    I’m so tired. Aren’t you? I don’t want to read the news anymore. It’s awful and I feel ashamed of it. We live in a country that people all over the world would give an arm, a leg; their life...
    The Daily Blog | 31-08
  • Conservative Party candidate links smacking ban with suicide, sexually tran...
    If Chemtrails, faked moon landings and climate change denial weren’t enough, welcome to your new Minister for Spanking,  Edward Saafi... The anti-smacking law is to blame for youth suicide, youth prostitution and even sexually-transmitted infections, a leading Conservative party candidate...
    The Daily Blog | 31-08
  • A brief word on the canonisation of Matthew Hooton
    Before we all start the canonisation of Matthew Hooton, let’s consider some home truths here shall we? While the Wellington Ruminator Blog, the blog who was previously mates with Judith Collins, now seems to have a crush on Matthew Hooton… …I...
    The Daily Blog | 31-08
  • A brief word on undercover cops in bars
    Dunedin police booze operation labelled ‘creepy’ Undercover police officers drank in Dunedin bars as part of an operation targeting liquor licensing offences. While police said the inaugural operation was a success — with most bars found compliant — the Hospitality...
    The Daily Blog | 31-08
  • Judith Collins press conference
    Judith Collins press conference...
    The Daily Blog | 31-08
  • GUEST BLOG: Angry Lawyer – Collins, Odgers, Williams and legal ethics
    We deserve better lawyers than Judith Collins Three of the worst offenders exposed in Dirty Politics are lawyers: Judith Collins, Cathy Odgers, and Jordan Williams. What Nicky Hager exposed them doing would be out of line for anyone, but from...
    The Daily Blog | 31-08
  • GUEST BLOG: Pat O’Dea – Necessary Defence
    Increasingly climate change is becoming the main fracture line between political parties. Where political parties stand on climate change defines political parties and movements like no other issue. The Mana Movement like the Maori Party it sprang from, came out...
    The Daily Blog | 31-08
  • Why it is all over for John Key
    Image: Melanie D I’ve been confident that National will lose this election and that our focus should be on what a progressive Government needs to establish as its agenda in the first 100 days. Past that point, the establishment pushes back...
    The Daily Blog | 31-08
  • A brief word to everyone who voted National in 2011
    I received this interesting email from a National Party supporter today… …let me say this to anyone who voted National last election – you should be ashamed by what has been revealed and what your vote ended up enabling but...
    The Daily Blog | 31-08
  • EXCLUSIVE: Déjà Vu All Over Again: John Ansell confirms his participation...
      THE MAN BEHIND the Iwi-Kiwi billboards that very nearly won the 2005 election for Don Brash and the National Party has confirmed his involvement in businessman John Third’s and former Act MP Owen Jennings’ campaign to drive down the...
    The Daily Blog | 31-08
  • Public Broadcasting Auckland debate 6.30pm tonight now with Colin Craig &am...
    The Coalition for Better Broadcasting debate on public broadcasting happens tonight at 6.30pm in Auckland at the Pioneer Women’s Hall, High Street, Auckland City.  In the light of Dirty Politics and the manipulation of the media, public broadcasting is more important for...
    The Daily Blog | 30-08
  • Winners & Losers in Collins sacking plus what’s the latest on Slater...
      Make no mistake, there was no way this was a resignation, it’s a face saving way out for Collins, she was sacked.  My understanding is that National internal polls are haemorrhaging and that the powers that be within National...
    The Daily Blog | 30-08
  • Third party propaganda attacks incoming Labour-led government
    . . Further to a report by Daily Blogger, Chris Trotter, on receiving information regarding planned attack-billboards, the following billboard is highly visible to traffic on the southbound lane of the Wellington motorway, just prior to the Murphy St turn-off....
    The Daily Blog | 30-08
  • Labour wins the Internet
    I’m sure I’m not the only one who tried to vote online for the leaders debate and couldn’t because the website was down. The next option was the txt vote, 75c a pop of course. So I’m not surprised that...
    The Daily Blog | 30-08
  • GUEST BLOG: Anjum Rahman – Rotherham and the need to challenge willful bl...
    I haven’t been following the events in Rotterham too closely.  I’ve read about the basic issues and the culture of silence that stopped action been taken even after complaints were made.  That culture of silence is incredibly familiar, and described...
    The Daily Blog | 30-08
  • Review: Hairspray
      Oh Hairspray! What fun! Somehow I managed to miss the movie when it came out, I had no idea really what it was about though I felt it had a vague relation to High School Musical. In retrospect, that...
    The Daily Blog | 30-08
  • Mounting global pressure against Timor-Leste’s ‘death sentence’ media...
    East Timor’s José Belo … courageous fight against ‘unconstitutional’ media law.Image: © Ted McDonnell 2014 CAFÉ PACIFIC and the Pacific Media Centre Online posted challenges to the controversial ‘press law’ nine months ago when it emerged how dangerous this draft...
    The Daily Blog | 30-08
  • GUEST BLOG: Curwen Rolinson – Spies, Lies and When Campaigns Are Fried
    Like most of the rest of the nation’s political classes, I was eagerly affixed to TV One from 12:30 on Saturday afternoon to witness the downfall of Judith Collins.Whenever we witness the crumbling of a titan of the political landscape...
    The Daily Blog | 30-08
  • BREAKING: Whaleoil crushes Crusher
    Judith ends up shooting herself A new email has been released suggesting that Collins was attempting to undermine the head of Serious Fraud Office with the help of far right hate speech merchant Cameron Slater. Unbelievable!   She has been forced...
    The Daily Blog | 30-08
  • BREAKING: Rumours Judith Collins gone at lunchtime
    Brook Sabin first of the mark with rumours Judith Collins is about to resign – PM announcing a statement at 12.30pm… …Paddy follows… …Vance confirms..   …if Collins is gone by lunchtime, it will be because the PM understands the...
    The Daily Blog | 29-08
  • BREAKING: UPDATE on DIRT ALERT!
    Thanks to the information passed to Chris Trotter by “Idiot/Savant” from No Right Turn it is now possible to identify at least some of the persons involved in this latest example of attack politics. What follows is Chris’s response to Idiot/Savant’s timely assistance: Well done...
    The Daily Blog | 29-08
  • Comparing burning puppets, hip hop lyrics and drunk student chants to black...
    Watching the mainstream media try and obscure Cunliffe’s surprise win in the leaders debate  is a reminder the Press Gallery is in depressed shock. The current spin line from the Wellington bubble media in the wake of Dirty Politics is that...
    The Daily Blog | 29-08
  • Why has it all gone quiet on Charter Schools?
    They’re one of ACT’s flagship policies and the National Party have been gung ho in supporting them. So how come we’re not hearing Hekia Parata, Jamie Whyte, Catherine Isaac, et al singing from the rafters about what a resounding success charter...
    The Daily Blog | 29-08
  • Moment of Truth – September 15th – Auckland Town Hall
    Moment of Truth – September 15th – Auckland Town Hall...
    The Daily Blog | 29-08
  • EXCLUSIVE: Dirt Alert! Are the Greens and Labour about to become the target...
    WE’VE SEEN IT ALL BEFORE. In 2005 pamphlets began appearing all over New Zealand attacking Labour and the Greens. For a couple of days both the parties targeted and the news media were flummoxed. Who was behind such an obviously...
    The Daily Blog | 29-08
  • The Donghua Liu Affair: the Press Council’s decision
    . . 1. Prologue . The Donghua Liu Affair hit  the headlines on 18 June, with allegations that David Cunliffe wrote a letter in 2003,  on  behalf of  business migrant, Donghua Liu. Four days later, on Sunday 22 June, the...
    The Daily Blog | 29-08
  • The difference between Cunliffe & Key in the debate
    It was with much interest that I watched the leaders debate on Thursday night.  I watched with an open mind, always happy to have my opinion changed.  Maybe John Key is all the wonderful things that many say about him,...
    The Daily Blog | 29-08
  • GUEST BLOG: Denis Tegg – When Did We Agree To Our Data Being Shared with ...
    New shocking evidence has emerged from Edward Snowden’s trove of documents about a program called ICREACH under which data collected by the GCSB is shared with 23 US spy agencies. Under new sharing agreements which appear to have commenced immediately after...
    The Daily Blog | 28-08
  • Independent Epsom Candidates ‘One Strike’ Crime Policy
    Best wishes to all of those who live in Epsom, Mount Eden, New Market, Remuera and of course the rest of New Zealand....
    Scoop politics | 02-09
  • Large majorities of NZ First voters would prefer Labour deal
    67% of those who voted for New Zealand First at the 2011 general election would prefer Labour to lead a coalition government if one is needed after September 20’s general election....
    Scoop politics | 02-09
  • Jointly owned urban development agency for Christchurch
    “Given the strategic importance of the Canterbury rebuild, it is logical that the transition from emergency governance arrangements is overseen by the Prime Minister’s office, but to maintain momentum in the city centre an expert development agency...
    Scoop politics | 02-09
  • Collins inquiry at best a Band-Aid, a permanent fix needed
    Collins inquiry at best a Band-Aid, a permanent fix is needed The Public Service Association (PSA) says the inquiry into Judith Collins’ behaviour must be accompanied by a process to restore the lost trust between Ministers and public servants if...
    Scoop politics | 02-09
  • Association welcomes new Chief Executive
    “The New Zealand Police Association is pleased to announce the appointment of Heather Verry to Chief Executive. Heather picks up the mantle from Chris Pentecost, who recently retired from this position,” Police Association President Greg O’Connor said...
    Scoop politics | 02-09
  • Young Voters Want Politicians to Grow Up
    Young voters want answers to the questions that directly affect them – but it seems as much as anything, they want politicians to grow up....
    Scoop politics | 02-09
  • Climate Voter election debate to get big audience
    Auckland, 2 September 2014 - Tickets to tomorrow night’s first-ever Climate Voter election debate have sold out but an online audience will also get to see the event live....
    Scoop politics | 02-09
  • The Edge show disregard for consent
    The Edge has shown complete disregard for consent, for women’s bodies and in doing so has contributed to the wider issue of rape culture in New Zealand says specialist sexual violence prevention organisation, Sexual Abuse Prevention Network. Yesterday,...
    Scoop politics | 02-09
  • The Rock is Fuelling New Zealand’s Roastbuster Rape Culture
    The Rock are still displaying without-consent images of Jennifer Lawrence and other celebrities online. They are making fun of this without-consent action, saying that she was "asking for it", etc. They appear to be supporting this kind of...
    Scoop politics | 02-09
  • HRLA Condemns Murder of Filipino Human Rights lawyer
    Attorney Rodolfo R. Felicio, a member of the National Union of Peoples Lawyers , was gunned down while working on a land dispute in Rizal, east of Manila. Two caretakers of the disputed land were also injured in the attack....
    Scoop politics | 02-09
  • SFO lays charges for procurement fraud
    Two individuals have been charged in the Auckland District Court today with Crimes Act charges laid by the Serious Fraud Office for alleged fraud against Mighty River Power Limited relating to procurement for the Company’s Southdown power station....
    Scoop politics | 02-09
  • Commitment to lifting wages good for New Zealand
    The Service and Food Workers Union has applauded the Green Party workers’ policy announced today....
    Scoop politics | 02-09
  • Sykes: There’s Only One Poll That Counts
    “One of the oldest sayings in politics is that there is only one poll that counts – the one on Election Day – and that’s the one that I am focusing on” remarked the MANA Movement candidate for Waiariki, Annette...
    Scoop politics | 02-09
  • Winston Peters Shown up by the Civilian Party
    Even the satirical 'Civilian Party' has now offered the Taxpayers’ Union more credible figures for the ' Bribe-O-Meter ' than Winston Peters’ New Zealand First. The Taxpayers’ Union Bribe-O-Meter now includes, National, Labour, the Greens,...
    Scoop politics | 02-09
  • Further criminal investigation into CTV Building collapse
    Police has today confirmed it will be advancing the criminal investigation into the collapse of the CTV building in February 2011....
    Scoop politics | 02-09
  • Greens policy to restore link between effort and reward
    The Green Party’s new workers policy articulates an alternative to wage repression and job insecurity based on restoring the link between effort and reward, according to FIRST Union. The core tenets of the policy include implementing an $18 minimum...
    Scoop politics | 02-09
  • Greens workers policy supported by union movement
    The CTU is supporting the Green Party’s policy launched today focused on improving life for working New Zealanders. “This policy shows the Greens commitment to collective bargaining as the best and fairest way to improve workers terms and conditions. It...
    Scoop politics | 02-09
  • Research Scholarships for Cannabis Treatments
    Medical cannabis research will be boosted by $140 million if the Aotearoa Legalise Cannabis Party is elected on September 20. Pediatric epilepsy treatment will be one of the main priorities for the research scholarships....
    Scoop politics | 01-09
  • Ngai Te Rangi Change to Tribal Elections
    Ngai Te Rangi has begun a postal vote of beneficiaries to change the way representatives are elected to the two Ngai Te Rangi tribal organisations....
    Scoop politics | 01-09
  • Greens’ commitment to pay equity welcomed by workers
    The Public Service Association (PSA) says the 58,000 workers they represent will benefit from the announcement by the Green Party of a commitment to pay equity and to a living wage for core public servants and contractors....
    Scoop politics | 01-09
  • Real People Powering Real Policy
    New Zealanders from all walks of life have helped the Internet Party create a full platform of strong, progressive and realistic policies that will create a better future for everyone, says leader Laila Harré....
    Scoop politics | 01-09
  • University of Canterbury to help with forestry safety
    The University of Canterbury is to launch a new research project to make sure New Zealand’s new forestry roads are safe and are established with minimal environmental impact....
    Scoop politics | 01-09
  • Time to get serious about ending homelessness!
    New Zealand needs a comprehensive set of policies that address the housing and support needs of homeless people as well as significantly increasing the supply of affordable, good quality houses and flats....
    Scoop politics | 01-09
  • Hundreds to join domestic, sexual violence march
    Several social service providers from across New Zealand have come together to call for an end to the epidemic level of domestic and sexual violence in New Zealand....
    Scoop politics | 01-09
  • Students helped with debt repayments
    New Zealand students now living in Australia are being reminded not to ignore their student loan debt as Inland Revenue expands its latest tool to help with repayments....
    Scoop politics | 01-09
  • Launch of GenderNeutral.co.nz website
    GenderNeutral.co.nz are excited to announce the launch of their new website, GenderNeutral.co.nz ....
    Scoop politics | 01-09
  • Factory farming debaters to look chicken in the eye
    MPs participating in a panel discussion about factory farming will come face-to-face with a real live hen, rescued from the claws of the intensive farming industry. Hettie the Hen will demonstrate to the MPs what little space is afforded to...
    Scoop politics | 01-09
  • Leadership stands strong behind Internet MANA relationship
    “There is now, and always will be, a range of views about many issues within our movement and members are free to express them, but Georgina’s views on Kim Dotcom are not shared by the MANA Movement leadership or the...
    Scoop politics | 01-09
  • Personal Statement by Matthew Hooton
    Personal Statement by Matthew Hooton 1 September 2014 For Immediate Release “This morning I made comments on Radio New Zealand’s Nine to Noon programme about an attempt by staff in the Prime Minister’s Office to interfere in the appointment...
    Scoop politics | 01-09
  • The Worm turns down for John Key
    John Key struggled to coax The Worm above the line in Thursday’s Leaders Debate, according to Roy Morgan’s Reactor, the original Worm. John Key struggled to coax The Worm above the line in Thursday’s Leaders Debate, according to Roy Morgan’s...
    Scoop politics | 01-09
  • The Edge Posts Naked Photos Without Consent
    The Edge website, owned by Media Works have published fully naked photographs of Jennifer Lawrence without her consent....
    Scoop politics | 01-09
  • Statement from the Governor-General on Ashburton Shootings
    The Governor-General, Lt Gen The Rt Hon Sir Jerry Mateparae, has expressed his deep shock following the shooting of three people in Ashburton today....
    Scoop politics | 01-09
  • Update on IGIS inquiry into release of NZSIS information
    In recognition of the public interest, the Inspector-General of Intelligence and Security, Cheryl Gwyn, took the unusual step of providing an update during the course of an inquiry and confirmed today that she would be summoning a number of individuals...
    Scoop politics | 01-09
  • An Open Government Plan developed in secrecy
    The State Services Commission sent NZ’s Open Government Action Plan to the international Open Government Partnership (OGP) Secretariat on 31 July. The countries involved in the OGP since its inception - from the UK and US to Indonesia and Brazil...
    Scoop politics | 01-09
  • KiwiRail; another year older and deeper in debt
    That is a lot of money and there are lessons that need to be learnt before we pour in another $1 billion....
    Scoop politics | 01-09
  • Fonterra China Deal Demands Safe Supply Chain
    The future success of Fonterra’s deal to sell infant formula in China [1] requires all milk it uses be safe and for Fonterra to secure its supply chain from contamination by GE DNA and pesticide residues. There is now significant...
    Scoop politics | 01-09
  • HRC praises Auckland mum for speaking out
    Race Relations Commissioner Dame Susan Devoy has praised an Auckland mother of four who went public after humiliating treatment by staff at The Warehouse....
    Scoop politics | 01-09
  • Southern DHB refers disputed issue to Serious Fraud Office
    Following advice from forensic investigation firm Beattie Varley Limited, Southern District Health Board has referred the expenditure at the centre of its long running dispute with South Link Health to the Serious Fraud Office. The parties have been...
    Scoop politics | 01-09
  • The Letter 1 September 2014
    Last night’s TVNZ Colmar Brunton poll puts the left and right 60 MPs each. United and the Maori Party say they will go with the side that gets to 61 MPs. ACT just needs just 1.3% or 28 thousand Party...
    Scoop politics | 01-09
  • Shopping Giveaway Harmless Fun For Kids
    Family First NZ is rubbishing claims by critics including Gareth Morgan that the New World ‘Little Shop’ promotion is harmful for kids, and says that kids should be allowed to be kids. “Children love acting like their parents and pretending...
    Scoop politics | 01-09
  • Red Cross launches employment service for former refugees
    New Zealand Red Cross is encouraging employers to give refugees a fresh startwith the launch of Pathways to Employment, a nationwide work assistance service....
    Scoop politics | 01-09
  • EDS welcomes Labour’s Conservation Policy
    The Environmental Defence Society has welcomed Labour’s Conservation Policy including the key objective of halting the current pattern of indigenous biodiversity decline within ten years....
    Scoop politics | 01-09
  • Poverty is falling and income inequality is not rising
    “A Roy Morgan poll shows that the issue people are most concerned about is income inequality. This just goes to show how the persistent repetition of a lie bewilders the public. Income inequality is not in fact rising. And the...
    Scoop politics | 01-09
  • Rotary NZ responding to Fiji water and sanitation issues
    Clean water and sanitation are vital to health. In Fiji Rotary New Zealand have been targeting 22 communities that are experiencing severe hardship mainly because they don’t have access to clean water for their drinking, cleaning and cooking needs....
    Scoop politics | 01-09
  • Work & Income shooting a Tragedy
    Kay Brereton speaking on behalf of the National Beneficiary Advocacy Consultancy group says; “Two people shot and another wounded, this is a tragedy and our deepest sympathy goes out to the family and whanau of the victims, as well as...
    Scoop politics | 01-09
  • 1080 Poison Deer Repellent not Effective – Farmers
    Four deer have been found dead within a farmer's bush block, after an aerial 1080 poison drop applied with deer repellent. The drop was part of a 30,000 hectare drop across the Northern Pureora Forest Park....
    Scoop politics | 01-09
  • Employment Charter will strengthen migrants’ rights
    Establishing an Employment Charter for construction companies is a critical step to strengthening the rights of migrant workers that are fast becoming the face of the Christchurch rebuild, according to an alliance of union groups. The charter has...
    Scoop politics | 01-09
  • Global March For Elephants and Rhino
    It’s a trans-national business that funds terrorist organisations, fuels conflict in Africa, and poses environmental, development and security challenges. The illegal wildlife trade is also a lucrative business, generating an estimated USD$20 billion...
    Scoop politics | 01-09
  • New series of videos aimed at disengaged youth
    From the people who brought you 'NZ Idle' (NZ's favourite web series about an artist on the dole) comes a new series about election time: Choice Lolz....
    Scoop politics | 01-09
  • Picket Of Leaders Christchurch Debate
    KEEP OUR ASSETS PICKET OF LEADERS CHRISTCHURCH DEBATE TUESDAY SEPTEMBER 2nd, 6 p.m. ST MARGARETS COLLEGE, SHREWSBURY STREET, MERIVALE...
    Scoop politics | 01-09
Images of the election
Public service advertisements by The Standard