web analytics

Of Leaks and Hacks

Written By: - Date published: 3:23 pm, December 20th, 2016 - 24 comments
Categories: uncategorized - Tags:

Maybe the Russians weren’t coming. Or we must believe that “KGB chief Vladimir Putin put Inspector Clouseau in charge of Russian security and left him to get on with it.” George Washington discusses the evidence. Fodder for the net-savvy

24 comments on “Of Leaks and Hacks”

  1. Nice find. I must say that Craig Murray’s prose has been growing on me lately.

    ‘Despite himself being a former extremely competent KGB chief, Vladimir Putin [is alleged to have] put Inspector Clouseau in charge of Russian security and left him to get on with it. The Russian Bear has been the symbol of the country since the 16th century. So we have to believe that the Russian security services set up top secret hacking groups identifying themselves as “Cozy Bear” and “Fancy Bear”. Whereas no doubt the NSA fronts its hacking operations by a group brilliantly disguised as “The Flaming Bald Eagles”, GCHQ doubtless hides behind “Three Lions on a Keyboard” and the French use “Marianne Snoops”.’

    • Conal 1.1

      Yes, funny, but to be fair, the names “Cozy Bear” and “Fancy Bear” are code names made up by the IT security firm who the DNC contracted to audit their security breaches. The naming scheme uses the “Bear” suffix to designate an apparently Russian group.

      No-one is saying the names are self-assigned by the hacker groups, though of course in the breathless media reports denouncing Russian interference in the US political system, this kind of detail is usually omitted.

      • That in itself should be an alarm bell – if you’re supposed to be investigating a group’s origin, but you’ve already essentially decided they’re Russian state sponsored or affiliated and named them after bears, then you’ve basically guaranteed that your investigation will fit that bill.

        Far more likely that the security firm have no idea who they are, but if they can brand themselves as the group which ‘busted’ Russia, rather than the group that cleaned up the mess after the DNC got done over by script kiddies from Iowa, then the contracts you receive in the future will be far, far more lucrative.

        • Andre 1.1.1.1

          As I understand it, Cozy Bear and Fancy Bear were given those names by security researchers long before the DNC hacks were investigated.

          https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/jul/29/cozy-bear-fancy-bear-russia-hack-dnc

        • Conal 1.1.1.2

          The two “Bear” groups identified by CrowdStrike in the DNC case were not new, and had already been designated “Russian” based on analysis of their earlier operations.

          These hacking groups are known as “Advanced Persistent Threats” in the IT security industry. “Advanced” because they have technical chops, and “Persistent” because observers believe that they can recognise the same actors again and again in different situations, on the basis of the hacking methods that they may reuse from time to time. This makes plenty of sense, in principle, though of course it’s not foolproof, because their “tradecraft” or hacking methods (and particular the malware used) are tradeable items; they can be passed from one agent to another, and even stolen by adversary agencies and reused. Hacking tools belonging to an APT called “the Equation Group” (apparently part of the NSA) were scandalously leaked online in August this year. That kind of leak would make it harder to distinguish attacks made by the Equation Group from attacks by other groups using their tools.

          I don’t know enough about these APTs and the CrowdStrike investigation to know how much confidence one can put on their correct identification of the APTs in this case, or on their identification of the APTs with particular Russian intelligence agencies, or on the assertion that Putin himself must have ordered it because the targets were so important, or that the emails which WikiLeaks published actually came from these sources (rather than a whistle-blower), but going through that list of unknowns I think you’d be less and less confident of each one.

      • Psycho Milt 1.1.2

        Yes, funny, but to be fair, the names “Cozy Bear” and “Fancy Bear” are code names made up by the IT security firm who the DNC contracted to audit their security breaches. The naming scheme uses the “Bear” suffix to designate an apparently Russian group.

        Yes, and that ought to have been obvious to Murray for the same reason it isn’t the Russians who give their planes names like Badger and Frogfoot. He doesn’t seem like someone who should be taken seriously.

    • JonL 1.2

      Putin was NOT KGB chief – he was a mid-level Intelligence officer with the rank of Lt Colonel when he left the KGB after 16 yrs in 1991 to enter politics!
      He was , however, director of the FSB for 13 months, 1998-99
      Now George Bush Snr was head of the CIA……….

      • I was quoting Murray’s statement as an example of his excellent sarcasm. But you are correct that often his KGB credentials are talked up to make him sound more of a villain or badass.

        Bush Snr. must have some dark stuff floating around in what’s left of his 92 year old grey matter from the Zapata Oil days.

  2. Bill 2

    It’s a kind of moot point now given the acres of newsprint that’s been devoted to people who can fairly be described as neo-McCarthyites.

    There’s was no need to be any kind of web geek, or to be in the least bit net savvy to understand that a complete lack of named sources should be a descending rubber stamp engraved with the word BULLSHIT! stamped on all the vacuous articles that claimed Russia had spread nefarious tentacles.

    But it’s ‘mission achieved’. The Ruskies are baddies. The Ruskies back Trump. The Ruskies stole US democracy. The Ruskies are out to destroy German democracy. The Ruskies, basically, is out to get you they is.

    And no amount of retrospective analysis as to the veracity of claims made by anonymous people apparently hailing from nebulous western intelligence agencies, and that liberal media outlets gleefully ran with, will change that for those who bought into it.

    One thing maybe worth noting is that, like Syria, the comments below articles of outlets that still leave their comments sections open brim with skepticism and outright dismissal/rejection of said outlet’s breathless reporting of ‘official’ lines.

    (And the liberal establishment wonders where it has all gone wrong 🙄 )

    • One thing maybe worth noting is that, like Syria, the comments below articles of outlets that still leave their comments sections open brim with skepticism and outright dismissal/rejection…

      Funny you should mention that, seeing as Putin also runs an extensive and vigorous troll army…

    • philj 2.2

      +1 Bill
      What is the difference between ‘Fake News’ and good old fashioned propaganda? You don’t hear the term propaganda much these days. At least you can put BS on your rhubarb. Cheers.

      • JonL 2.2.1

        ” good old fashioned propaganda?”
        Most of the MSM around the world these days……..especially if it brushes against Murdoch and his cronies…..

  3. One Anonymous Bloke 3

    The fact that counter-narratives emerge is evidence of nothing.

    Knowing how US foreign policy works, who wouldn’t want to give them a dose of their own medicine?

  4. philj 4

    Copy of email sent to Kim Hill on Saturday Mornings interview with Charles Lane, arch propagandist, re. Russian hacking and US election

    Bold type is my highlighting

    LANE ( re. supposed Russian ‘hacking’ ) : “Just going by what we read in the press …”
    ” Intel source cited by reports ….. seems to say…”

    KIM ” Hillary believes Russia’s hacking …. cost her the election ”

    No questioning of whether there is any proof that:

    1. There was any hacking
    2. It was Russian

    This interview accepts the assumption that both are true. Yet no proof or hard evidence is asked for or offered.

    The New York Times says Wikileaks is ” becoming a de facto instrument of Russian Intelligence ”

    LANE: ” The best anyone can determine …”
    ” They seem to have intervened … ”
    ” Channeled apparently by Russian Intelligence ”
    ” Trump openly sympathized with Putin…. the most pro Russian President since WW 2 ”
    ” Certainly the objective of Trump is to move closer to Russia ”

    Kim could have asked Mr Lane what he thought about the possibility of a closer USA/Russia relationship.

    ME: Could Mr Lane have been asked for, or provided any actual proof or evidence of his assertion of Russian hacking? Hearsay from US Intelligence isn’t factual proof.

    KIM: ” The CIA says Russia intervened in the election … Intel chiefs agreed on this. This is quite damming, isn’t it? ”

    ME: Is this the same intelligence agencies that informed the world about Iraq’s weapons of mass distraction? How ‘mistaken’ that has proven to be.

    LANE: ” There was some debate within the Intelligence community …” ???

    This begs the question.

    What was debate was about?
    Was the hacking real?
    Apparently so. We are all talking about it.
    This is all smoke and mirrors.
    One needs to beware of PR spin, smooth talkers and the BS that is promoted in this murky field.

    Charles Lane concludes:-

    ” …. best guess they ( US intelligence agencies ) are telling the truth … Democracies were not intended to be run on the basis of what we are told by secret ( US Government ) agencies”

    Are you saying, Mr Lane, that the USA Government is currently running on such a basis of secrecy?
    Mr Lane is an “opinion writer” and a regular on Fox TV. He is not a coherent analyst, more a ‘talking point’ salesman masquerading as an obscurantist obsfucationalist!

    I have little regard for the quality of this smooth talker’s opinions. Goodness, he even admits he never thought Trump could win and is trying to blame The Russians for the loss! He is of the establishment and couldn’t even see the growing desperation of an increasing number of fellow Americans under his nose whilst blinded from seeing the real reasons for The Democratic Party’s electoral failure.

    There are far more knowledgeable people which would bring greater insight at these interesting times. There are plenty if you wish to find them. Hint: They are not on Fox TV. They are the folk who got it all wrong. More NZ commentary from our own academics would be a better idea, in my view.

    We live a Post Truth world awash with media which is struggling to sort the Truth from the Fake. RNZ is essential for producing the highest quality of journalism and broadcasting. The public good and our democracy depends on it.

    N.B. The bold type has not copied from the original. You will have to imagine it.
    Cheers and solace.
    Philg

  5. KJT 6

    “Nothing to hide. Nothing to fear”.

  6. KJT 7

    Actually. Anecdotal evidence says it is a pair of New Zealand high school children.

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

  • TOP’s environmental policy no threat to ours
      When a new political party like Gareth Morgan‘s Opportunities Party (TOP) launches, its promoters obviously see a gap in the political line-up, an area where it can promote policies and actions that other parties aren’t. That’s why the environmental policy released by ...
    GreensBy Eugenie Sage
    3 hours ago
  • Gareth Morgan and TOP’s environmental policy a pick and mix assortment
      When a new political party like Gareth Morgan‘s Opportunities Party (TOP) launches, its promoters obviously see a gap in the political line-up, an area where it can promote policies and actions that other parties aren’t. That’s why the environmental policy released by ...
    GreensBy Eugenie Sage
    3 hours ago
  • Social housing crisis at record levels
    National’s failure to provide sufficient social housing for vulnerable families has been underscored by latest figures showing a record number of families on the waiting list, says Labour Housing Spokesperson Phil Twyford. “Some 6,110 families were in need of social ...
    6 hours ago
  • Wilderlands community in need of our support
    This week, a large fire burnt down six homes near Whitianga and destroyed parts of the organic farm and community Wilderlands, a sustainable food producer since 1964. I first came to the Hauraki/Coromandel in 1972 and by then Dan and ...
    GreensBy Catherine Delahunty
    8 hours ago
  • National denies kids their free school education
    The National Government’s ongoing underfunding and recent funding freeze is denying Kiwi kids their right to a free schooling, says Labour’s Education spokesperson Chris Hipkins. “By law, schooling in New Zealand is supposed to be free, but under National that’s ...
    11 hours ago
  • A chance to help sea life in the Hauraki Gulf
    The Sea Change Tai Timu Tai Pari report (Hauraki Gulf Marine Spatial Plan) launched last month makes a strong case for ending bottom trawling, purse seining, and dredging in the Gulf as fishing methods which damage the seabed.  The report ...
    GreensBy Eugenie Sage
    1 day ago
  • Taxpayers deserve better oversight on big money projects
    The latest scorecard on National’s management of major infrastructure projects shows that the Government is letting New Zealanders down when it comes to managing significant investments, says Labour’s Finance Spokesperson Grant Robertson. The Treasury today released the November 2016 Interim ...
    1 day ago
  • Emergency food grants rocketing under National
    More and more Kiwis are going hungry under National with hardship grants for food jumping 14 per cent in the last year alone, says Labour Leader Andrew Little. “That’s a damning indictment of how Bill English’s government has let things ...
    1 day ago
  • Something dramatic is taking place in the Antarctic
    * Yesterday, James Shaw and Eugenie Sage paid a visit to the Antarctic Research Centre at Victoria University to meet with leading climate scientists. James shares his reflections on their vital work. Something dramatic is taking place in the Antarctic. ...
    GreensBy James Shaw
    1 day ago
  • The Security Council and Israel – where power meets law
    Since the UN Security Council adopted resolution 2234, there has been more heat than light shed on the continuing Israel-Palestine crisis and the faltering prospects for peace.  Israel, claiming it has been abandoned and betrayed by its traditional supporters, especially ...
    GreensBy Kennedy Graham
    1 day ago
  • The Security Council and Israel – where power meets law
    Since the UN Security Council adopted resolution 2234, there has been more heat than light shed on the continuing Israel-Palestine crisis and the faltering prospects for peace.  Israel, claiming it has been abandoned and betrayed by its traditional supporters, especially ...
    GreensBy Kennedy Graham
    1 day ago
  • Ending homelessness
    Homelessness is a disgrace. It’s ugly and dehumanising and I can’t bear to see it every day in my home town of Wellington. Unlike Sir Robert Jones, though, I’ve never thought about blaming the victims for their situation. That’s bully ...
    GreensBy James Shaw
    2 days ago
  • Bill English needs to back Pike River Bill
    Labour is challenging the Government to support a Bill to remove any legal barrier to the recovery of the 29 Pike River miners, says Labour Leader Andrew Little. “Bill English has been hiding behind the legal excuse that any attempt ...
    2 days ago
  • Dumb ideas that wreck the planet: Microbeads
    I don’t know who thought of it first but some years ago some petro-chemical chemist somewhere decided putting plastic into the products we buy to clean our bodies would give us extra oomph.  And so producers added ‘microbeads’ to some ...
    GreensBy Denise Roche
    2 days ago
  • Labour and Green Party to host joint State of the Nation event
    For the first time Labour and the Green Party are holding a joint State of the Nation event. Labour Leader Andrew Little and Green Party Co-Leader Metiria Turei will speak about their priorities for the year in Auckland on Sunday ...
    3 days ago
  • Organised crime getting easy ride under National
    Under-resourcing from the National-led Government is seriously undermining the Police’s ability to combat organised crime, says Labour’s Police spokesperson Stuart Nash. “In answers to my questions, the Minister of Police has confirmed that the numbers of Police officers dedicated to ...
    4 days ago
  • Wages and housing keys to fixing inequality
    Better wages and restoring the Kiwi dream of homeownership are fundamental to reducing inequality, says Leader of the Opposition Andrew Little. ...
    4 days ago
  • Motorcyclists deserve safety they’ve paid for
    Motorcyclists deserve an explanation from the Government about why just one fifth of the money they have been charged has been spent on safety while the carnage continues on the roads, says Labour’s ACC and Transport Spokesperson Sue Moroney. ...
    1 week ago
  • Cross-party approach needed as homeownership hits new low
    New data showing homeownership has hit a record low shows the need for political parties to come together to enact Labour’s KiwiBuild and Healthy Home Bills, which are currently before Parliament, says Leader of the Opposition Andrew Little. ...
    1 week ago
  • New year, same old story for underfunded health
    While the New Year often heralds resolutions to improve, the industrial strife currently wracking ambulance workers shows the Government has little interest in properly investing in the health sector, says Labour’s Health Spokesperson Annette King. “The tense stand-off between ambulance ...
    2 weeks ago
  • Government’s EV charge runs flat
    New figures obtained by Labour show that the National Government has left the handbrake on over its purchasing of electric vehicles, with less than 0.4 per cent of its All-Of-Government Panel purchases being EVs since Minister Simon Bridges announced that ...
    2 weeks ago
  • Keep road police numbers up, says Labour
    After an increase in this year's Christmas holiday road toll by nearly 40 per cent, now is not the time to cut road policing numbers says Labour's Police spokesperson Stuart Nash. "Former Police Minister Judith Collins announced last year that ...
    2 weeks ago
  • Well, THAT happened: Julie Anne Genter reflects on 2016
    The end of the year! 2016 has been…a mixed bag – Trump-ism, losing Bowie, Prince, Leonard Cohen et al, and the creeping malaise of a tired government. Green Party MP Julie Anne Genter shares her year. My highlights of 2016 ...
    GreensBy Julie Anne Genter
    3 weeks ago
  • Well, THAT happened: David Clendon reflects on 2016
    The end of the year! 2016 has been…a mixed bag – Trump-ism, losing Bowie, Prince, Leonard Cohen et al, and the creeping malaise of a tired government. Green Party MP David Clendon shares his year. My highlight of 2016 By ...
    GreensBy David Clendon
    3 weeks ago
  • Well, THAT happened: Mojo Mathers reflects on 2016
    The end of the year! 2016 has been…a mixed bag – Trump-ism, losing Bowie, Prince, Leonard Cohen et al, and the creeping malaise of a tired government. Green Party MP Mojo Mathers shares her year. My highlights of 2016 Moving ...
    GreensBy Mojo Mathers
    3 weeks ago
  • Well, THAT happened: Catherine Delahunty reflects on 2016
    The end of the year! 2016 has been…a mixed bag – Trump-ism, losing Bowie, Prince, Leonard Cohen et al, and the creeping malaise of a tired government. Green Party MP Catherine Delahunty shares her year. My highlights of 2016 Sometimes ...
    GreensBy Catherine Delahunty
    3 weeks ago
  • Well, THAT happened: Barry Coates reflects on 2016
    The end of the year! 2016 has been…a mixed bag – Trump-ism, losing Bowie, Prince, Leonard Cohen et al, and the creeping malaise of a tired government. Green Party MP Barry Coates shares his year. My highlights of 2016 Definitely, ...
    GreensBy Barry Coates
    3 weeks ago
  • Denise Roche: My year – with some numbers
    It feels like 2016 was exceptionally busy – and this was confirmed when I checked my diary. Looking at just my Ethnic Communities portfolio, between February and December this year I visited or attended celebrations with 25 different organisations ...
    GreensBy Denise Roche
    3 weeks ago
  • Well, THAT happened – Kennedy Graham reflects on 2016
    Every year is special, but 2016 has been extraordinary. We are, I think, witness to two global revolutions, occurring simultaneously. One is of a world uniting. The other is of a world fragmenting. This push-and-pull, yin and yang, will go ...
    GreensBy Kennedy Graham
    3 weeks ago
  • Well, THAT happened: Gareth Hughes reflects on 2016
    The end of the year! 2016 has been…a mixed bag – Trump-ism, losing Bowie, Prince, Leonard Cohen et al, and the creeping malaise of a tired government. Green Party MP Gareth Hughes shares his year. My highlight of 2016 So ...
    GreensBy Gareth Hughes
    3 weeks ago
  • National should review safer road strategy
    National needs to urgently review its “Safer Journeys” road safety strategy with the road toll increasing for the third year in a row making 2016 the deadliest year on New Zealand roads for six years, says Labour’s Transport spokesperson Sue ...
    3 weeks ago