Bugger Gosman, I was too slow to open a sweep stake on the Standard as to how long it would take you to mention your beloved Zimmers. Cuba 10 to 1 anybody?
So now Spain’s in the headlines Gosman, it’s a little more difficult for you to argue irresponsible Government spending, given their fiscal prudence leading up to the GFC.
No their problem was a property bubble, who inflates those again? Oh, that’s right, bankers! And where does the responsibility for the GFC lie, oh, that’s right, speculators and bankers. Where was it’s epicenter, oh, that’s right, Wall St.
But I admire you’re faith, it takes an extraordinary effort to achieve such willful blindness, most don’t know cause they ignore – Adam Curtis notes that economics is boring, and so that is why economists manage to get away with such restlessness – but you clearly read about these things….
Spain isn’t exactly a libertarian free market paradise so I’m not sure why you seem to imply the problems are caused just by banks.
Spain has youth unemployment of around 50%. That suggests there is something wrong with their labour market flexibility. Also the problem is not just dodgy banks but the fact that the Central Government hasn’t got an awful lot of control over regional government’s spending.
Great logic Gos, its all the fault of “labour market flexibility”, superb sidestep of an undeniable criticism of globalisation. Sort of “kill them harder and it will all get better”. And what if it were your children?
If it was my kids I’d want to live in a country where the labour market wasn’t so inflexible that they had a one in two chance of being unemployed for a long time. Luckily that is the case.
What’s your solution to the problem of Spanish youth unemployment by the way? More training perchance? If you read that link you will see that many of the youth unemployed are actually highly educated.
What’s your solution to the problem of Spanish youth unemployment by the way?
Less globalisation, eradication of capitalism and a rationalisation of the economy so that it actually does what it’s supposed to – support the people and not just the psychopathic few.
So Gosman, that logic eventually leads you to moving your kids to China or Thailand or Cambodia.
And, don’t we have a balance of payments issue in Europe, and artificially suppressed wages in Germans, the deck you’re playing with is rigged, but then that goes back to the link about the death of Capitalism.
What’s your evidence that Spain’s 50% youth unemployment rate (I’m taking your word for that) is due to labour market inflexibility? (I’m asking for evidence, not assertion of ideological presuppositions.)
An interesting editorial in today’s Guardian on Spain and the Euro crisis: Until the eve of the banking crisis in 2007, Spain’s unemployment rate was 7.9% and Spain had sounder public finances than Germany.
Which brings us to one of the most important yet under-remarked aspects of the euro meltdown. What has been painted as a battle between the virtuous, hardworking north and the lazy, feckless south should instead be depicted as a banking crisis. This is the crucial point made in a new paper published by Manchester’s centre for research on socio-cultural change. Deep Stall, it compares the eurozone collapse with a plane crash and finds one big difference: whereas everyone in the aviation industry – from passengers to planemakers to airlines – has a vested interest in keeping planes up in the air, the banks have no such commitment to keeping the rest of the financial system afloat as long as they get paid out.
The implication is clear: rather than devote efforts to ruining the lives of southern Europeans, a far more effective way to deal with the continent’s crisis would be to restructure the banks, then rein them in for good. The alternative is to trust in austerity for the public and generously allow the banks to “deleverage” and shrink their balance sheets at their own pace. This is exactly the policy that has turned a Greek tragedy into an existential threat to the entire euro.
I heard this morning on Euronews that Mario Monti, the technocrat economist in charge in Italy, is working on labour reform – making it easier to fire people but at the same time make it harder to put people on short-term low wage contracts.
Luigi Spinola, a political and economic analyst in Rome, spoke to euronews about the prospects.
Claudio Rosmino, euronews: Labour reform is the biggest, most dangerous challenge facing the Monti government. What are the key points, the most sensitive points?
Spinola: The labour market is divided in two. You’ve got your stable permanent fulltime contracts on one hand, which offer workers numerous guarantees but which are costly and therefore employers only offer a limited number of these.
And then there’s a parallel work sector with short term contracts, atypical contracts that pay very little and give very few guarantees.
Monti’s challenge is to find a kind of redistribution of rights, in two ways: make it easier to fire people, and make access to work more strict.
I’ll explain this second point, otherwise it might appear paradoxical. It’s really about making it more costly for employers to resort to those atypical, flexible contracts.
Apparently Italy’s firing rules mean that the worker almost always gets the job back if it is legally challenged, meaning employers prefer contract workers.
Interesting take on labour flexibility. The main aim is to make it is easier for workers to get full-time, permanent jobs and reduce short-term contracts because labour market instability is a bad thing.
“and calls Key and English liars despite denials they knew about it. ”
Actually no PG, she said “Liars if they say it’s nothing to do with us”.
Of course this sale is something to do with National – they decided not to get work done in New Zealand, leading to a lack of work at Hillside. Key and English may deny having been told of this sale of state assets, but they cannot deny the link between putting work offshore and an effect locally.
Is a deliberate misquote a lie or incompetence, Pete G?
This Sky City tender just gets worse and worse. If any other ordinary public servant had conducted a tender process so very badly they would be disciplined at the least; quite possibly sacked
What gets me is the absolute hyposcrisy. Helen Clark signs a painting to raise some money for a charity and it’s the crime of the fucking century.
John Key grossly inteferes in a major tender process, playing very lose with the law over a matter that involves hundreds of millions and substantial social harm…. and all that happens in the media is a mild round of tut-tutting.
It’s like a Labour PM has to be pure and holy, while there’s this understanding that we elect National PM’s to be venal and a little bit corrupt.
My summary of the whole saga: the clearest (but by no means only) example we have so far in this government of that nasty old Tory corruption, that uses political power personally linked to big bucks to take more money out of less well off pockets, and put it into better off: and then barefacedly deny they have done anything wrong, or hurt anyone.
That’s most people’s expectations of a Nat govt RL, those with memories of Muldoon would be aghast at the naked corruption and complete arrogance not caring about the wreckage both in NZ and their own part.
Reading gossie etc reminds me of people who would be cheering at a stoning or hanging, what sad trolls. The MSM is not out to do anything therein lies one of the problems.
Shearer’s living wage campaign thingy is brilliant.
It should be made clearer to the public that it is not possible to live on the minimum wage. That we effectively have a wage system that is worse than slavery – at least as a slave you were housed and fed whereas it is not possible to do that on the minimum wage – it needs to be topped up by other taxpayers through various subsidies and handouts like WFF. Effectively the taxpayers are subsidising business.
This should be made clearer.
Of course lifting wages like this would require some heavish adjustments across the economy that would take time and some pain here and there. But the alternative is taxpayers paying for business and wages that one cannot live on. Same amount of money in the economy just spread differently (and its current spread is the result of govt intervention so please no rants that such intervention will distort).
It is actually quite astounding that we have a minimum wage that cannot be survived on. It is a barbaric situation.
Are you suggesting that those on the minimum wage aren’t surviving?
The “living wage” idea potentially has some good points, but it’s very difficult to specify one wage that covers many different circumstances and locations. An eighteen year old living with his parents on a farm in Tuatapere has quite different financial needs to a father of five living in Remuera.
As for the differing circumstances, lets run an anecdotal test right here – hands up all those who could survive in their current circumstances in NZ on the minimum wage. No subsidides, handouts, supplements, WFFs allowed, just the wage.
‘…hands up all those who could survive in their current circumstances in NZ on the minimum wage.’
That is a tautological statement.
Of course the circumstances will change if the income decreases. That is a completely different argument to the one that people are unable to survive on the minimum wage.
So you can survive on minimum wage in this country. You just can’t live in places where the living expenses are greater. Excellent, we have now established that the situation in NZ follows standard economic theory. Do you want to ask us whether we will fall to our deaths if we jump out of plane without a parachute now?
Where’s the evidence that anyone is dying as a result of this?
Lol – you mean you’re once again asking for direct observational evidence of something that is happening right now, when that evidence takes a year or two to collate? Even though the literature in the field strongly indicates that any tory interwebz warrior who argues that the situation does not exist is a bit of a tool?
the situation in NZ follows standard economic theory.
And standard economic theory suggests those who live in cheaper places are living where there are fewer jobs, so will have to move to more expensive places to improve employment options, making the minimum wage much less than a living wage than it was before. Maybe we should have a flexible minimum wage to go with those flexible employment options.
For the record, I couldn’t live on the minimum – a long-term medical condition with a lot of out-of-pocket medical expenses.
Gosman, let me try to put this in terms that – I think – you’ll understand.
There are two ways to ‘survive’ (i.e., to be ‘sustainable’).
The first way is to keep regenerating your ‘capital’ (i.e., your health, your mental resilience, your ability to participate in society, etc.).
The second way is to live off your ‘capital’ (i.e,. your health, your mental resilience, your ability to participate in society, etc.) and so gradually reduce it while you are physically and biologically ‘surviving’ (i.e., physically and biologically continuing or ‘sustaining’ yourself).
People on the minimum wage are most likely ‘surviving’ in the latter rather than the former sense.
Bollocks fair enough VTO. Gos is just being his usual prize arsehole with some rancid economic rationalist argument to justify people not being able to survive in decent conditions. He does not give a fuck so long as he is OK.
Oh right, I forgot, you have selective blindness. Because the evidence on poverty leading to increases in death rates is fairly well established in the health and sociology literature and mentioned here oft…
Sounds as though we now have a growing number of ‘third world disease’ in this country. Some of these leading to death. Pretty sure it’s not the rich suffering from this.
The cause of the higher rates of ‘third world’ diseases can largely be attributed to substandard accomodation. Whether or not someone can survive on minimim wage plays only a very small part in this. That stated I have yet to read an article where mortality has been attributed to ‘third world’ diseases in NZ. Perhaps you can provide a link to something that backs your case up?
So Gos (aka I Am All Right Jack) you say The cause of the higher rates of ‘third world’ diseases can largely be attributed to substandard accommodation… as if this is some absolution from any spurious arguments you have raised prior.
It is easily demonstrable from your statement that according to you this substandard accommodation exists, and that there is a problem. So Gos, do you care?
so if it’s not the wage earner’s fault i guess it’s the landlords for not doing their bit to keep housing standards up, and the landlords are ???? the very investment addicts that gave us the bubbles that inevitably burst, soaking the fruit of community with poison debt that causes them to fall broken upon the ground like scattered weeds, leaving no option than to be sprayed with the stigma of un-met aspirations and covered with the weedmat of bene bashing!
(hyperbole aside, sooner or later gosman you have to face the truth that capitalism is little more than an ouroborus on steroids)
hands up all those who could survive in their current circumstances in NZ on the minimum wage. No subsidides, handouts, supplements, WFFs allowed, just the wage.
I could, but then I am the exception (being on UB at the minute, I’d be better off on minimum wage!) But that just shows the comparative unlivability of the UB!
Also, I am single and a miser by nature… 🙂
“An eighteen year old living with his parents on a farm in Tuatapere has quite different financial needs to a father of five living in Remuera.”
You’re right Pete, a father of five living in Remuera should get less than an imaginary rural teen, because to be there in the first place, and then with five dependents, he’d have few “needs”. Remuera is overun with breadline solo Dads. Doss-houses everywhere, and cheap slum rentals. The place is a magnet for the hard up. A complete horror.
You could be imaginative, though, and choose a rural setting much further north, where there is no farm, but lots of space and no family and not much of a farmhouse. Then you could really lean into the stereotypes. Can’t have society without castes and heirachy, eh Pete?
How is the grass on the octagon this morning, Pete? Anyone muss it up during the night? Bloody scallywags. We should have a discussion about it, about when to have the discussion about doing something, something about something – that should do it. If the situation doesn’t change for the better by itself.
So PG the whole concept of somebody wanting fracking banned is disagreeable to you? Regardless of who and how unheard they are? Go frack in your own backyard.
“it is not possible to do that on the minimum wage – it needs to be topped up by other taxpayers through various subsidies and handouts like WFF. ”
You seem to try and play the ‘middle of the road’ type character Pete. But you do it badly. Mostly because you just come across as a slightly more apolegetic National supporter.
From what I have read your a Peter Dunne follower-which makes a lot of sense. I reckon it’s time to pick a side.
Anyway, being in a postion where I make a lot more than minimum wage and having times where I wonder where my money has gone I often ponder how someone making 13 bucks an hour; A. gets by and B. can afford any type of simple luxury. Which in my opinion any working person should be able to.
A person should not have to work 40 hours a week for just food and shelter in this day and age.
When a person is seen as causing harm to you or your power, then get right up close and friendly. Charm him and make it harder for him to sting.
Patrick Gower is in the swim with John Key and no doubt will be a little less enthusiastic with his stories. Not many political reporters get to swim with the shark PM. http://www.nzherald.co.nz/entertainment/news/article.cfm?c_id=1501119&objectid=10800105#
You mean ‘del’ where the ‘s’ should be -inside the ?
Be good to update the FAQ. I spent ages trying to figure out what I was doing wrong the other day.
Some US researchers have done a series of pieces of research that through a bit of light on how wealth/prestige reduces compassion for others – especially others in difficult situations or less powerful positions.:
But research suggests the opposite is true: as people climb the social ladder, their compassionate feelings towards other people decline.
[…]
Berkeley psychologists Paul Piff and Dacher Keltner ran several studies looking at whether social class (as measured by wealth, occupational prestige, and education) influences how much we care about the feelings of others.
The research included observing that drivers of more expensive cars were more likely to ignore pedestrians waiting at crossings, and more likely to cut-up other drivers instead of waiting their turn. They also did other research involving keeping “candy” for yourself and leaving some for children.
A related set of studies published by Keltner and his colleagues last year looked at how social class influences feelings of compassion towards people who are suffering.
These findings build upon previous research showing how upper class individuals are worse at recognizing the emotions of others and less likely to pay attention to people they are interacting with (e.g. by checking their cell phones or doodling).
[…]
Piff and his colleagues suspect that the answer may have something to do with how wealth and abundance give us a sense of freedom and independence from others. The less we have to rely on others, the less we may care about their feelings. This leads us towards being more self-focused. Another reason has to do with our attitudes towards greed. Like Gordon Gekko, upper-class people may be more likely to endorse the idea that “greed is good.” Piff and his colleagues found that wealthier people are more likely to agree with statements that greed is justified, beneficial, and morally defensible. These attitudes ended up predicting participants’ likelihood of engaging in unethical behavior.
They should add Key, Nacts and their cronyist, legislation for sale antics to their studies.
It’s a good thing most bankers including John Key are psychopaths. Psychopaths don’t feel anxiety like you and I do which mean they can still sleep soundly in the face of what is coming at us and is created by them.
In fact John Key advising himself in what is arguably to most stunning example of Psychopathic behaviour of a New Zealand Prime Minister is your typical number two of the Hare check-list of Psychopathy: A grandiose sense of self worth.
Gosman, have you watched The Corporation ? i mean actually watched it, scraped the wax from the ol’ lugholes and listened to its clear and concise information. You know… applied critical thought to new information? Not simply glance up from the Biggles Annual all bleary eyed as Mummy puts milk on your Kornies?
There is a lot of well researched data that shows the psychological behaviour expressed by Companies, and those who run them is nothing short of Psychotic. Have you considered the common ground that supports comments from many of the well educated and highly respected individuals who actually have studied the topic. Have you wondered why so many people came to the same conclusions? Remember, if these companies want to be legal people then the values and standards that we hold people to, should apply to them also.
e.g. how much fun would it be to charge a corporation proper income tax, seeing as they are a legal person and all that.
The weasel ones just say, but they are a business and as such get to pick and choose what is of benefit to us and what is of damage to the people we take from.
There is a word for that: Psychopath
(a person suffering from a disorder characterized by a pervasive pattern of disregard for the rights of others and the rules of society)
I stated like becoming legal people like the rest of us. None of the links you provided suggested thay have the same rights as the rest of us.
In fact to quote ‘. Legal entities cannot marry, they usually cannot vote or hold public office,[3] and in most jurisdictions there are certain positions which they cannot occupy’.
No, you asked “who is pushing” for it, not what it is now.
I gave you two links that provide a decent background to the issue, which is incredibly longstanding and has progressively expanded over centuries. Those links included actual references (should you choose to speak from a position of knowledge, rather than just being a dissembling cocksucker. I should have known better).
Eve I seriously doubt you have ever seen or met a psychopath and I really hope you never do.
I met a person that the consulting psychiatrist had diagnosed being as close to a pure psychopath as diagnostic tests allowed some years ago and it was an extremely disturbing experience.
I can assure you that although many of our politicians merit all the distrust and abuse you can muster none are psychopaths.
Well actually HS both my husband and I are both diagnosed with PTSD after a five year encounter with a serious Psychopath and the experience has given us a unique view on what these assholes are capable off and I can smell a Psychopath from a mile a way as a result.
John Key is a Psychopath and by the time he is done with this country and sashays back into the world he feels best in filled with fellow Psycho’s, I can assure you there will be a lot more people with PTSD in NZ.
Most likely people who lost their income, jobs, benefits, schooling chances, Housing, Houses and ACC compensations and who as a result have to live in cars, garages, and on the streets.
But don’t worry the pretty girls can find jobs in the super brothel and the boys can be croupiers in Sky city and if your not so pretty but you are lucky you can become a dishwasher in the new convention centre or work in the cigarette packing factory owned by Aussie owners who like our low wages and easy 90 day fire at will clause courtesy of Psycho John Key.
And this is why religious classes are problematic as standard social primate behaviours lead to exclusion and coercion and the usual suspects aren’t all that interested in discussing other religions, except in how Christianity is better than them. Usually.
Religion should not be taught in school time. If the religious nutters want to teach their kids to be as stupid as them then they can do it after school.
I hope you know that the Education Act says that it can’t be? I know this Peter Harrison person of old, and he’s not beyond inventing things to whip up hysteria about – he is a ‘poor pitiful us’ atheist… one of those who claims persecution 100 times a day. 😀
If the religious nutters want to teach their kids to be as stupid as them then they can do it after school.
Bigotry.
(Back in the 1960s, we had a prayer at assembly, before school began, and I well remember one girl who was horribly miserable when her parents came to make a big stink and a loud performance out of dragging her out, loudly proclaiming that as atheists, they disapproved. We her classmates didn’t harass her, the teachers didn’t harass her, her parents harassed her to say that she wanted to be excused, even though she couldn’t have cared less about a 30 second prayer. My father was an atheist, but he didn’t want to make a meal out of it.)
I hope you know that the Education Act says that it can’t be?
Which means that the Education Act is wrong.
Bigotry.
Generally speaking, I couldn’t care less about the religious. I get pissed off when they demand that we make allowances for them and that their religion be forced upon society.
We her classmates didn’t harass her, the teachers didn’t harass her, her parents harassed her to say that she wanted to be excused, even though she couldn’t have cared less about a 30 second prayer.
Which just shows that you missed the point and haven’t learned anything since – she, and the rest of the children, shouldn’t have had religion forced upon.
BTW, the children did try to harass me when I decided (yes, me not my parents) to ignore religious class at school. The bible thumping teachers weren’t too happy about it either.
Ah, if you think so, take it up with the Min of Ed. 😀
Generally speaking, I couldn’t care less about the religious. I get pissed off when they demand that we make allowances for them and that their religion be forced upon society.
An attack of the poor pitifuls there, mate! Who’s forcing it on you? Maybe you hate that we breathe the same air you do… would you choose Sam Harris’ and Dawkins’ solution? (For the record, forcible incarceration in mental hospitals, which goes with automatic loss of custody of our kids, and I assume, sterilisation, all “for the good of society”. Given Harris is an American, it’s hard to know what he means by society…
Which just shows that you missed the point and haven’t learned anything since – she, and the rest of the children, shouldn’t have had religion forced upon.
Obviously, I did miss the point then. I thought she wanted to do what most of us did, which was to ignore a very tiny part of the day and get on with our Larry’s Rebels fantasies, I didn’t realise anything was being forced on us! (Which of course it wasnt’. Teenagers, even if they are girls I add for your benefit) are capable of ignoring something they don’t want to hear.
BTW, the children did try to harass me when I decided (yes, me not my parents) to ignore religious class at school. The bible thumping teachers weren’t too happy about it either.
Oh, a proper little Dawkins in the making, what a precious, precocious wee genius you were! Your parents must have been so proud. Bible thumping teachers – what was your school, Dotheboys Hall? Sir Lord Herr Professor Dawkins tells the same story – about how he as a 6 year old impressed parents and grandparents with his precocious infant grasp of subtleties and arguments undreamt of by generations that had lived and died before him. ‘Scuse me while I giggle and snort… and oh dear, I had better stop here – with an ego the size of yours, comes great sensitivity to even imaginary slights…
We’re not talking about ‘teenagers’ Vicky. It’s primary schools.
And where do you get off just assumming that the story is a lie?
Honestly, do you think it’s good enough that primary school children who are not part of these programmes are looked after in a way that makes them feel like they are being punnished?
Do you think it’s appropriate for religious instructers to be telling primary age kids that dinosaurs didn’t exist?
It looks to me like you are the one with the ‘poor ;little me’ syndrome going on. it looks like just because someone is criticising something allegedly Christian, you feel the need to jump in and attack the people complaining about it.
I was talking with a woman today about this story, and she told me she opted out of the classes after her 5 year old daughter was told by the instructer that “didn’t have god in her heart” and that she would “burn like toast”.
Now 5 yr olds sometimes hear things in a way that they weren’t intended, but that means adults have to be pretty careful in how they talk about things with them.
These classes are due for a bit of a looking at I reckon, and schoools absolutely need to have good systems in place for the children who do not take part.
And where do you get off just assumming that the story is a lie?
What story are you saying I said was a lie?
Do you think it’s appropriate for religious instructers to be telling primary age kids that dinosaurs didn’t exist?
Of course it’s not appropriate – if it is happening! Given that the Education Act says that education in NZ must be “free, secular and compulsory”, I really don’t see that what’s alleged can be blamed on the school.
I was talking with a woman today about this story, and she told me she opted out of the classes after her 5 year old daughter was told by the instructer that “didn’t have god in her heart” and that she would “burn like toast”.
Sorry, that’s a story I really don’t believe! I know Christians, even the kind I now avoid, the evangelicals who are portrayed in the media as saying such things – and I know that in reality they don’t say such things to children!
(They do in Hollywood, and on HBO, of course, but not in NZ, and certainly not in schools.)
These classes are due for a bit of a looking at I reckon, and schoools absolutely need to have good systems in place for the children who do not take part.
Definitely, if they are what you say they are. My son was at school from 1992 to 2007, and I assure you that ‘Bible in Schools’ in the 1990s, consisted of 10 minutes before 08.30. Leon opted out with my blessing, despite my being a Christian, I have always believed that the Education Act is fine as it is. In fact, almost everybody opted out as it was simply too early for everyone, including parents who, like us, lived 5 minutes walk from the school.
I know this Peter Harrison person of old, and he’s not beyond inventing things to whip up hysteria about – he is a ‘poor pitiful us’ atheist… one of those who claims persecution 100 times a day?
I assumed this was in relation to the story linked to.
And I’m not sure from the rest of your comment that you actually know how this stuff works in many schools. It’s not ten minutes before class, it’s often 1/2 an hour during the day. To comply with the education act the school ‘closes’ for the time of the classes. The instructers are not employed by the school, they are usually volunteers, but the school is very much responsible for chooing who will be running the program. If inapropriate things are going on, the school has the responsibility to sort it out.
And as for you calling my acquaintence a liar based on nothing more than your alleged knowledge of what all christians in NZ would say? Umm, perhaps re-read what I wrote.
Do you really think it unbelievable that an untrained but enthusiastic evangelical might phrase things poorly, such that a 5 year old child might think they were talking to and about them rather than generally?
Do you honestly think it is not possible that an evangelical might evangelise to children, and talk about the consequences of not having ‘Jesus in your heart’?
And I’m not sure from the rest of your comment that you actually know how this stuff works in many schools. It’s not ten minutes before class, it’s often 1/2 an hour during the day. To comply with the education act the school ‘closes’ for the time of the classes. The instructers are not employed by the school, they are usually volunteers, but the school is very much responsible for chooing who will be running the program. If inapropriate things are going on, the school has the responsibility to sort it out.
Happen it’s changed since L, was at school? How is it you know? From my reading of the Standard, I know that maybe 5 Standardistas actually have children, and of the regulars, maybe 2 have… You are not one of them. Still, that’s not relevant, and too easily twisted by you, so moving on..
Do you really think it unbelievable that an untrained but enthusiastic evangelical might phrase things poorly, such that a 5 year old child might think they were talking to and about them rather than generally?
Yes, I do find it completely unbelievable! As I said I actually know Christians, and not just as characters in HBO dramas, or hate figures and no evangelical would ever say such a thing to a 5 year old as your friend quoted them as saying. Now you’re back-tracking, and claiming it was something different, so what was it, an ‘untrained but enthusiastic evangelical’ or what my old mother would have called a ‘complete and utter luniac’? If it’s the luniac saying “burn in hell”, there’s no way that’s true, and mother no doubt invented what daughter said, dreaming it all up through the veil of her own fears and prejudice.
Do you honestly think it is not possible that an evangelical might evangelise to children, and talk about the consequences of not having ‘Jesus in your heart’?
Not in the words you claimed, no. Not to 5 year olds. I find it somewhat amusing that you are frantically back-pedalling. Did you have a chat to your friend in the mean time? Did she tell you that exaggeration can amount to lying as Peter Woss-name no doubt did? (In his case to great effect – a TV item no less!)
Most of the authors have kids at various ages. The only one I know who doesn’t is me. I just got to be uncle across my nieces, nephews, cousins, etc – especially when they hit their teens.
I was talking with a woman today about this story, and she told me she opted out of the classes after her 5 year old daughter was told by the instructer that “didn’t have god in her heart” and that she would “burn like toast”.
Now 5 yr olds sometimes hear things in a way that they weren’t intended, but that means adults have to be pretty careful in how they talk about things with them.
That was what I said, and I haven’t ‘backtracked’ in the slightest from it, so your amusement is based on your failure to read what I said.
The education Act hasn’t changed on this for a long time. I’ve Known how it works since I was at school, where we had a similar program. It is also discussed in the article from yesterday:
Schools are legally obliged to be secular, but under the Education Act they are allowed to close for an hour a week for instruction, as long as children can opt out.
You seem to be remembering the way your sons school did things, and assuming that all schools do it that way. There is no basis for this belief, which you know if you had bothered to read the links, and think about them, rather than get all defensive about ‘atheists’.
I’m done with this. I’m taking my son (who I have mentioned numerous times on this blog, so you may need to update your spreadsheet of standartista famial status) to a comic convention today.
“From my reading of the Standard, I know that maybe 5 Standardistas actually have children, and of the regulars, maybe 2 have… You are not one of them. Still, that’s not relevant, and too easily twisted by you, so moving on.. “
lolz. Oh Vicky, you do say some fucking ridiculous things when you’re speaking in tongues.
lolz. Oh Vicky, you do say some fucking ridiculous things when you’re speaking in tongues.
And oh so predictable too…
We can’t have any semi-civil discussions here about secularism without Vicky turning up and playing the persecution complex card /smugface
And of course, she misses the whole human rights issue concerning witnessing and it’s exploitative nature in terms of social networks and the negative consequences therein on children. Particularly in teh context of school environs and bullying…
The religious are and it’s not upon me but upon children who are incapable of differentiating between truth and BS. The schools should not have to make time available for religion.
(Which of course it wasnt’)
Yes it was – you had to go to the assembly and listen to the prayer didn’t you? That’s force because you had no choice.
Oh, a proper little Dawkins in the making, what a precious…
What a surprise, not happy with the message you then resort to ad hominem attack
I quite liked the allegation that wanting a genuinely secular education equalled wanting religious people forcibly detained on mental health grounds.
And that’s how people like you end up ruining the reputation of the people who comment here that y’all have decided to hate – by pretending we said things we didn’t say! I have a degree in education. I have said loud and long through out this thread that I want and agree with the secular education that is mandated by the Education Act. Yet you pretend I said otherwise. Read back to what I actually said, and try to restrain your impulse to lie about what Christians say. I was quoting Sam Harris, numb-nuts, he’s the one who said he wants Christians locked up so they can’t indoctrinate ‘innocent children’.
lulz, I do <3 it when apologists quote mine atheists and claim Harris and Dawkins want parents incarcerated for forcing their religious beliefs on their children (and others), when all they did is point out the exploitative nature of much of conversion and it's occasional perturbing closeness to non-physical forms of child abuse.
So, by all means Vicky, provide us with teh quotes that show they want to do what you claim they do. Or make a retraction.
“Yes it was – you had to go to the assembly and listen to the prayer didn’t you? That’s force because you had no choice.”
Yes, that’s my experience at primary school too. We had a Jewish girl in our class who was made to stand outside the hall during religious education – stand, not sit, and nor was she allowed to go elsewhere. I thought she was lucky (I didn’t understand religious intolerance then, but that was a good starting point in learning) and I tried to see if I could join her, but sadly I had no letter from my parents asking to be excused. So yeah – forced religious instruction for the masses.
Yes, that’s my experience at primary school too. We had a Jewish girl in our class who was made to stand outside the hall during religious education – stand, not sit, and nor was she allowed to go elsewhere. I thought she was lucky (I didn’t understand religious intolerance then, but that was a good starting point in learning) and I tried to see if I could join her, but sadly I had no letter from my parents asking to be excused. So yeah – forced religious instruction for the masses.
Really, I don’t know what to say to this! Will the story include a yellow star and a Judenfrei banner next time?
Where did you go to school? New Zealand? Seriously, I doubt it. I attended a state primary school in New Zealand (a state one, note – I wasn’t in the socio-economic band for private education, and we didn’t have any such thing as RE.) The girl I spoke of at our High School was the child of campaigning atheists, and was excluded by them, and was very unhappy about it (I would have been as well, being made the subject of such a drama.) I am sorry for waxing sarcastic above – but seriously, the story of the poor little Jewish girl made to adopt a stress position outside the classroom, seems such a novelistic one! HBO strikes again – the Jewish kids in Rotorua primary, intermediate and secondary schools that I attended, all two of them, were the children of my Mum’s best childhood friend, and always made a point of flaunting their superior socio-economic status at us, carrying on Esther’s childhood rivalry with our Mum…
Oh, so, I am the intolerant one? Don’t be absurd. I asked you a heap of questions, because your story doesn’t sound very true to me… not true of a state school in NZ anyway, but instead of answering, you make with the insults.
I am reminded of the IDF, and their charming habits when it comes to tormenting Palestinian children. Sorry, Jews have used up all their sympathy chips with me…
The schools should not have to make time available for religion.
What part of the Education Act (which I keep quoting) do you not understand? Schools do not have to make time available for religion!
Yes it was – you had to go to the assembly and listen to the prayer didn’t you? That’s force because you had no choice.
Cry me a river. No, we didn’t have to go to assembly. We could do as half the school did, and be late! To you all these years later, it’s a massively big deal – to us in 1966 to 1971, it was literally nothing. As I say, my father was an atheist, but a far more tolerant fair-minded one than most I’ve met, especially here! (Working class, English, a far cry from the upper middle class New Zealander with the massive chip on theshoulder that one encounters on the Standard.) He was ‘down the school’ at any hint of anything unjust, but not about this – he was not as insecure about his childrens’ intelligence as you are (although I assume that as you don’t have children, your concern is for theoretical children, whom you assume are all a bit thick…
Schools do not have to make time available for religion!
Then why is this shit happening at school and in school time? Oh, that’s right, because some religious arseholes decided to make it available and then when children opt out they get ostracised. All the act should say is that religion should not be taught at school in school time.
BTW, you haven’t quoted the educationact yet – you’ve merely said what you believe it contains.
He was ‘down the school’ at any hint of anything unjust, but not about this
Perhaps he didn’t realise that it was unjust.
Cry me a river. No, we didn’t have to go to assembly. We could do as half the school did, and be late!
Really? If I did that at any of the schools I went to I ended up in detention and/or getting caned.
Anyhow, I find it most interesting that Vicky’s avoiding the current issue via diving into the past and trying to establish some sort of ground on which to normalise religious instruction in state schools.
Anyhow, I find it most interesting that Vicky’s avoiding the current issue via diving into the past and trying to establish some sort of ground on which to normalise religious instruction in state schools.
Good grief you are a moron aren’t you?! How many times do I have to say that I don’t support religious education in state schools? Could I say it any more plainly? I am reminded of the way y’all distort what Gosman and Pete George say, and then work your way up to a few cluster f bombs, and shit-storms of hate and indignation about what you said they said, not what they said! Because what I just said will turn into my supporting Pete and Gosman I want it on record that I don’t support them, I just think it would be a much better look for the Standard if you actually answered what they say and not what you wish they had said…
My crime seems to be that I questioned the truthfulness of some of the bizarre novelistic stories people here are telling about friends, and their children, and the children of friends of friends, and their own primary schooling any time between 5 and 55 years ago… I well know the temptation to exaggerate to make a good story better – the only problem is, that you risk losing all credibility 🙂 especially when you tell the exaggerated story to someone who happens to actually know something about the subject – in my case, of state schooling in New Zealand between the 1960s and the 2000s.
BTW, you haven’t quoted the educationact yet – you’ve merely said what you believe it contains.
What I know it contains, idiot. Look it up!
Perhaps he didn’t think that it was unjust. (FIFY)
Working class, English, but he was still intelligent. You ‘lefties’ amuse me greatly, you’re all such snobs! Real lefties would make a meal of you…
Really? If I did that at any of the schools I went to I ended up in detention and/or getting caned.
Boys’ and boarding schools obviously! Are you one of those self-pitying men who constantly wail that it’s so unfair that girls weren’t caned? (Cause we weren’t 😀 ) You miss the point that because assembly was officially before school started (or there couldn’t have been a prayer, could there?) it wasn’t compulsory?
My kids primary school closed once a week for religious indoctrination. For half an hour. Unfortunately it was after my kids bus arrived so they were at school, anyway.
Because a few religious parents had taken over the board.
After my 5 year old started going on about nailing people up, including waking up with nightmares about it, I withdrew them.
We would never allow 5 year olds to be told about such extreme torture and violence except under the cover of religion.
The schools “Christians’ put all the kids who were not doing religion in the hall with no books, games, or anything else to do, or supervision.
Just recently a gay teenager of my acquaintance was told by the Baptist paster of a youth group that he was going to burn in hell.
Lovely people, Christians.
Not to mention all the adds for teachers, for publicly funded schools, which say that teachers must support the “special character”, i.e. religious indoctrination of students, of the school.
My experience is that those who believe in one load of crap, like sky fairies, are much more likely to believe in others, like creationism, Austrian economics or John Key.
I think you have made the very common, and understandable error of confusing people who believe in a God, with fundamentalists…. who fool everyone and themselves that they believe in a God… but who don’t.
In my world fundamentalists are people who are completely blind and unaware of the real nature of religion which is actually about abstract and evanescent qualities such as justice, compasssion and dignity. Because of this blindness they construct instead a facade of a religion based on institutions, rituals and rules.
Which is what you experienced. I’m saddened and sorry to read how it has hurt people you know.
I think you have made the very common, and understandable error of confusing people who believe in a God, with fundamentalists…. who fool everyone and themselves that they believe in a God… but who don’t.
and what ???? the OIA spinmeisters can go fly a kite, it is easy to release a document that supports pre-determined findings. The facts remain that NZ was simply not given the same opportunities to buy these farms that were offered overseas.
Which Government in 2005 revised the Overseas Investment Commission to the Overseas Investment Office with many changed directions – which have now been fullfilled.
We,as in the we of New Zealand would seem to have 2 choices vis a vis the looming rental ‘price crunch’ facing those whose only means of accommodation is ‘to rent’,
Choice 1 is to build our way out of a situation where for many of those on low and fixed incomes accommodation costs take between 50 and 70% of their income, a situation destined to become progressively worse as capital and labour are directed into the Christchurch rebuild leaving tenants in other city’s to face a growing shortage of accommodation along with the inevitable ‘rack renting’ that comes with such shortages,
Choice 2 is to simply enact legislation requiring rental accommodation to be leased on the basis of 25% of the income of any and all tenants to be housed in that particular accommodation….
The United States’ global trade representative has strongly criticised a perceived preference on the part of large Australian organisations for hosting their data on-shore in Australia, claiming it created a significant trade barrier for US technology firms and was based on a misinterpretation of the US Patriot Act.
opinion/analysis
This is pretty much what you’d expect from the US Government — it’s looking out for its own interests and trying to push Australia to conform with it. However, I don’t view the US Trade Representative’s views as legitimate, when examined from an Australian perspective. US cloud computing companies such as Salesforce.com, Rackspace, Amazon and Google have committed very little infrastructure to the Australian market, and analysis after analysis has warned of the data security dangers of storing sensitive data in jurisdictions covered by US legislation, which can, at times, allow the US Government unprecedented access to private data.
So, the “trade barrier” that the US is complaining about is the fact that the US government isn’t trusted.
“Today’s New Zealand Roy Morgan Poll shows Prime Minister John Key’s National Party (49.5%, up 5.5%) improving its standing to its highest since last year’s NZ Election. The improvement in National’s vote comes at the expense of the two main Opposition parties — Labour (26.5%, down 4%) and the Greens (12.5%, down 4.5%) — the Greens result is similar to their polling achieved prior to the high achieved in the last Morgan Poll conducted at the time of Earth Hour.
I can’t find ACT. Anyone know what happened to them? The gap between the current Government and the opposition is still just a few points and this poll was conducted before Jackpot John outed himself as a casino shill.
If it’s not a rogue poll for Labour, they have a fair bit of work ahead of them 😛
I recon it’s more a rogue poll for the Nat’s as they seem to be registering a bit too high given current events. National is serving up their unpopular legislation early in their term to get it out of the way, and hope people forget about it come next election season. So yeah 49.5% sounds a tad high. I would have thought some kind of slight decline would make more sense, so maybe this is the rogue.
Greens are probably registering a bit low, 15%+/- seems more reasonable, they have been very effective and confident in parliament. They raise good points, they are definitely set to become our third major party imo.
Of course I have no frigging idea how people would vote, just basing all this conjecture on my personal theories and observations of attitudes of people whom I interact with.
Agree, ACT are a joke. They won’t be there next time.
Regardless of the non too subtle swings between polls, public support for the Nats is likely to still sit well above Labour, and still around the same as Labour/Greens combined. All this after a difficult few weeks for the government.
John Key must be pleased.
NZ know Act are a joke – but Epsom know that it’s an extra electorate seat for the nats. So – barring personal tragedy or criminal proceedings – banks will be there next time. The tosser.
Left and right are always going to balance out broadly. A year ago National could have comfortably governed alone – even up to or over 60 with its coalition partners.
So far it is a spike against the trend. Key must be relieved that the knives that were half drawn have gone a bit back into the sheath. But I think he’d be looking for it to go back down to ~45-6 on a good day next time, and the knives will be out if it goes to 44-3.
I’m not sure that the Epsom seat is worth forgoing seeing as they poll so low (or not at all) and won’t take additional seats with them. They only cause unneeded embarrassment to National.
I don’t think Key will be relieved, I dont think he was worried to begin with. And I’m not sure where you’re suggesting these knives were being drawn from?
Tories are like sharks. If one starts to bleed, the others attack it.
As for the relative value of a single seat – they know that right now. It is a single seat that will let them sell public assets, sell legislation to casinos, and continue selling New Zealanders down the river.
Thread in question was called something like “Occupying mp” and anout about some crap or other, with the commenters all calling Dalziell a drunk and blah blah blah.
Remember that time dpf had a hissy fit when Idiot Savant said a Nat mp was drunk in the house, and I/S apologised and stuff.
Ok, that apology gets Farrar of the hook. Probably. But where does that leave David Garrett? KB was just the conduit for his outburst. I’m guessing that Dalziell has a far more actionable case than Judith Collins could ever hope to muster on the basis of his repeated and, clearly, unprovable allegations. How many strikes is it now for Garrett?
I read that post yesterday and thought he was taking “a readers email” a bit far. According to Farrar it was beyond scrutiny and 100% accurate. And he was basing all these accusations and things on this “readers email”.
A judgment based solely on the prosecution is a worthless judgment.
worthless ..,
and now sheesh you should that old horse david garrett going crazy. what a cesspit – stinky stinky bleeaargh …
I know – that milford dart tunnel. Gotta get more and faster – its the only way. But once there is more and faster and it all settles down, how are they going to get even morer and even fasterer? That’s what I would like to know because I don’t think they have actually thought about that. Or rather, they dont really care about that. It’s all just a good capital making exercise.
fucking ridiculous things when you’re speaking in tongues.
No reply button under this little gem, and I can’t remember who said it now, as every man and his dog seems to have decided to get in on the more-atheist-than-you act… 😀
I am not a fundamentalist, therefore I don’t speak in tongues, but that doesn’t even matter as whoever said it was typing one handed, he was so in love with his own cleverness
I don’t go in for effing and blinding, and insults, as I don’t see the need. Pity you do!
For whoever it was said he was taking his son to Armageddon, all I can say it, I hope my son doesn’t meet you there, and that you can’t identify him… He’s an atheist right now, but things like facts don’t stop you men when you’re on a roll making with the ‘cleverness’!
It was me who mentioned my son, because you claimed he doesn’t exist. Just another thing you were wrong about in this thread.
Other things you were wrong about includes how the religious education in schools program operates. Contra what you were saying, it isn’t at all limited to ten minutes before school, and it often is in the middle of the day, for uop to an hour a week. These facts were noted in the story linked to in the comment that started the discussion.
Aside from that your comments have mainly been that evryone else must be lying about their experiences because , umm, you can vouch for how all christians in NZ would act, because you know some, and everyone else here just gets their views about Christians from the TV. Or something.
And by the way, speaking in tongues is a pentacostal thing, not all pentacostalists are fundamentalist, and by an even greater stretch nor are all fundamentalists are pentacostal.
South Korea and Australia should enhance their cooperation to secure submarine cables, which carry more than 95 percent of global data traffic. As tensions in the Indo-Pacific intensify, these vital connections face risks from cyber ...
The Parliament Bill Committee has reported back on the Parliament Bill. As usual, they recommend no substantive changes, all decisions having been made in advance and in secret before the bill was introduced - but there are some minor tweaks around oversight of the new parliamentary security powers, which will ...
When the F-47 enters service, at a date to be disclosed, it will be a new factor in US air warfare. A decision to proceed with development, deferred since July, was unexpectedly announced on 21 ...
All my best memoriesCome back clearly to meSome can even make me cry.Just like beforeIt's yesterday once more.Songwriters: Richard Lynn Carpenter / John BettisYesterday, Winston Peters gave a State of the Nation speech in which he declared War on the Woke, described peaceful protesters as fascists, said he’d take our ...
Regardless of our opinions about the politicians involved, I believe that every rational person should welcome the reestablishment of contacts between the USA and the Russian Federation. While this is only the beginning and there are no guarantees of success, it does create the opportunity to address issues ...
Once upon a time, the United States saw the contest between democracy and authoritarianism as a singularly defining issue. It was this outlook, forged in the crucible of World War II, that created such strong ...
A pre-Covid protest about medical staffing shortages outside the Beehive. Since then the situation has only worsened, with 30% of doctors trained here now migrating within a decade. File Photo: Lynn GrievesonMōrena. Long stories shortest: The news this morning is dominated by the crises cascading through our health system after ...
Bargaining between the PSA and Oranga Tamariki over the collective agreement is intensifying – with more strike action likely, while the Employment Relations Authority has ordered facilitation. More than 850 laboratory staff are walking off their jobs in a week of rolling strike action. Union coverage CTU: Confidence in ...
Foreign Minister Penny Wong in 2024 said that ‘we’re in a state of permanent contest in the Pacific—that’s the reality.’ China’s arrogance hurts it in the South Pacific. Mark that as a strong Australian card ...
Here’s my selection1 of scoops, breaking news, news, analyses, deep-dives, features, interviews, Op-Eds, editorials and cartoons from around Aotearoa’s political economy on housing, climate and poverty from RNZ, 1News, The Post-$2, The Press−$, Newsroom/$3, NZ Herald/$, Stuff, BusinessDesk/$, Politik-$, NBR-$, Reuters, FT/$, WSJ/$, Bloomberg/$, New York Times/$, Washington Post/$, Wired/$, ...
In the past week, Israel has reverted to slaughtering civilians, starving children and welshing on the terms of the peace deal negotiated earlier this year. The IDF’s current offensive seems to be intended to render Gaza unlivable, preparatory (perhaps) to re-occupation by Israeli settlers. The short term demands for the ...
A listing of 31 news and opinion articles we found interesting and shared on social media during the past week: Sun, March 16, 2025 thru Sat, March 22, 2025. This week's roundup is again published by category and sorted by number of articles included in each. We are still interested ...
In recent months, I have garnered copious amusement playing Martin, chess.com’s infamously terrible Chess AI. Alas, it is not how it once was, when he would cheerfully ignore freely offered material. Martin has grown better since I first stumbled upon him. I still remain frustrated at his capture-happy determination to ...
Every time that I see ya,A lightning bolt fills the room,The underbelly of Paris,She sings her favourite tune,She'll drink you under the table,She'll show you a trick or two,But every time that I left her,I missed the things she would doSongwriters: Kelly JonesThis morning, I posted - Are you excited ...
Long stories shortest this week in our political economy:Standard & Poor’s judged the Government’s council finance reforms a failure. Professional investors showed the Government they want it to borrow more, not less. GDP bounced out of recession by more than forecast in the December quarter, but data for the ...
Each day at 4:30 my brother calls in at the rest home to see Dad. My visits can be months apart. Five minutes after you've left, he’ll have forgotten you were there, but every time, his face lights up and it’s a warm happy visit.Tim takes care of almost everything ...
On the 19th of March, ACT announced they would be running candidates in this year’s local government elections. Accompanying that call for “common-sense kiwis” was an anti-woke essay typifying the views they expect their candidates to hold. I have included that part of their mailer, Free Press, in its entirety. ...
Even when the darkest clouds are in the skyYou mustn't sigh and you mustn't crySpread a little happiness as you go byPlease tryWhat's the use of worrying and feeling blue?When days are long keep on smiling throughSpread a little happiness 'til dreams come trueSongwriters: Vivian Ellis / Clifford Grey / ...
Here’s my selection1 of scoops, breaking news, news, analyses, deep-dives, features, interviews, Op-Eds, editorials and cartoons from around Aotearoa’s political economy on housing, climate and poverty from RNZ, 1News, The Post-$2, The Press−$, Newsroom/$3, NZ Herald/$, Stuff, BusinessDesk/$, Politik-$, NBR-$, Reuters, FT/$, WSJ/$, Bloomberg/$, New York Times/$, Washington Post/$, Wired/$, ...
ACT up the game on division politicsEmmerson’s take on David Seymour’s claim Jesus would have supported ACTACT’s announcement it is moving into local politics is a logical next step for a party that is waging its battle on picking up the aggrieved.It’s a numbers game, and as long as the ...
1. What will be the slogan of the next butter ad campaign?a. You’re worth itb.Once it hits $20, we can do something about the riversc. I can’t believe it’s the price of butter d. None of the above Read more ...
It is said that economists know the price of everything and the value of nothing. That may be an exaggeration but an even better response is to point out economists do know the difference. They did not at first. Classical economics thought that the price of something reflected the objective ...
Political fighting in Taiwan is delaying some of an increase in defence spending and creating an appearance of lack of national resolve that can only damage the island’s relationship with the Trump administration. The main ...
The unclassified version of the 2024 Independent Intelligence Review (IIR) was released today. It’s a welcome and worthy sequel to its 2017 predecessor, with an ambitious set of recommendations for enhancements to Australia’s national intelligence ...
Yesterday outgoing Ombudsman Peter Boshier published a report, Reflections on the Official Information Act, on his way out the door. The report repeated his favoured mantra that the Act was "fundamentally sound", all problems were issues of culture, and that no legislative change was needed (and especially no changes to ...
The United States government is considering replacing USAID with a new agency, the US Agency for International Humanitarian Assistance (USIHA), according to documents published by POLITICO. Under the proposed design, the agency will fail its ...
Hi,Journalism was never the original plan. Back in the 90s, there was no career advisor in Bethlehem, New Zealand — just a computer that would ask you 50 questions before spitting out career options. Yes, I am in this photo. No, I was not good at basketball.The top three careers ...
Mōrena. Long stories shortest: Professional investors who are paid a lot of money to be careful about lending to the New Zealand Government think it is wonderful place to put their money. Yet the Government itself is so afraid of borrowing more that it is happy to kill its own ...
As space becomes more contested, Australia should play a key role with its partners in the Combined Space Operations (CSpO) initiative to safeguard the space domain. Australia, Britain, Canada and the United States signed the ...
Ooh you're a cool catComing on strong with all the chit chatOoh you're alrightHanging out and stealing all the limelightOoh messing with the beat of my heart yeah!Songwriters: Freddie Mercury / John Deacon.It would be a tad ironic; I can see it now. “Yeah, I didn’t unsubscribe when he said ...
The PSA are calling the Prime Minister a hypocrite for committing to increase defence spending while hundreds of more civilian New Zealand Defence Force jobs are set to be cut as part of a major restructure. The number of companies being investigated for people trafficking in New Zealand has skyrocketed ...
Another Friday, hope everyone’s enjoyed their week as we head toward the autumn equinox. Here’s another roundup of stories that caught our eye on the subject of cities and what makes them even better. This week in Greater Auckland On Monday, Connor took a look at how Auckland ...
The podcast above of the weekly ‘Hoon’ webinar for paying subscribers on Thursday night features co-hosts & talking with special guest author Michael Wolff, who has just published his fourth book about Donald Trump: ‘All or Nothing’.Here’s Peter’s writeup of the interview.The Kākā by Bernard Hickey Hoon: Trumpism ...
Wolff, who describes Trump as truly a ‘one of a kind’, at a book launch in Spain. Photo: GettyImagesIt may be a bumpy ride for the world but the era of Donald J. Trump will die with him if we can wait him out says the author of four best-sellers ...
Australia needs to radically reorganise its reserves system to create a latent military force that is much larger, better trained and equipped and deployable within days—not decades. Our current reserve system is not fit for ...
Here’s my selection1 of scoops, breaking news, news, analyses, deep-dives, features, interviews, Op-Eds, editorials and cartoons from around Aotearoa’s political economy on housing, climate and poverty from RNZ, 1News, The Post-$2, The Press−$, Newsroom/$3, NZ Herald/$, Stuff, BusinessDesk/$, Politik-$, NBR-$, Reuters, FT/$, WSJ/$, Bloomberg/$, New York Times/$, Washington Post/$, Wired/$, ...
I have argued before that one ought to be careful in retrospectively allocating texts into genres. Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein (1818) only looks like science-fiction because a science-fiction genre subsequently developed. Without H.G. Wells, would Frankenstein be considered science-fiction? No, it probably wouldn’t. Viewed in the context of its time, Frankenstein ...
Elbridge Colby’s senate confirmation hearing in early March holds more important implications for US partners than most observers in Canberra, Wellington or Suva realise. As President Donald Trump’s nominee for under secretary of defence for ...
China’s defence budget is rising heftily yet again. The 2025 rise will be 7.2 percent, the same as in 2024, the government said on 5 March. But the allocation, officially US$245 billion, is just the ...
Concern is growing about wide-ranging local repercussions of the new Setting of Speed Limits rule, rewritten in 2024 by former transport minister Simeon Brown. In particular, there’s growing fears about what this means for children in particular. A key paradox of the new rule is that NZTA-controlled roads have the ...
Speilmeister:Christopher Luxon’s prime-ministerial pitches notwithstanding, are institutions with billions of dollars at their disposal really going to invest them in a country so obviously in a deep funk?HAVING WOOED THE WORLD’s investors, what, if anything, has New Zealand won? Did Christopher Luxon’s guests board their private jets fizzing with enthusiasm for ...
Christchurch City Council is one of 18 councils and three council-controlled organisations (CCOs) downgraded by ratings agency S&P. Photo: Lynn Grieveson / The KākāMōrena. Long stories shortest:Standard & Poor’s has cut the credit ratings of 18 councils, blaming the new Government’s abrupt reversal of 3 Waters, cuts to capital ...
Figures released by Statistics New Zealand today showed that the economy grew by 0.7% ending the very deep recession seen over the past year, said NZCTU Te Kauae Kaimahi Economist Craig Renney. “Even though GDP grew in the three months to December, our economy is still 1.1% smaller than it ...
What is going on with the price of butter?, RNZ, 19 march 2025: If you have bought butter recently you might have noticed something - it is a lot more expensive. Stats NZ said last week that the price of butter was up 60 percent in February compared to ...
I agree with Will Leben, who wrote in The Strategist about his mistakes, that an important element of being a commentator is being accountable and taking responsibility for things you got wrong. In that spirit, ...
You’d beDrunk by noon, no one would knowJust like the pandemicWithout the sourdoughIf I were there, I’d find a wayTo get treated for hysteriaEvery dayLyrics Riki Lindhome.A varied selection today in Nick’s Kōrero:Thou shalt have no other gods - with Christopher Luxon.Doctors should be seen and not heard - with ...
Two recent foreign challenges suggest that Australia needs urgently to increase its level of defence self-reliance and to ensure that the increased funding that this would require is available. First, the circumnavigation of our continent ...
Here’s my selection1 of scoops, breaking news, news, analyses, deep-dives, features, interviews, Op-Eds, editorials and cartoons from around Aotearoa’s political economy on housing, climate and poverty from RNZ, 1News, The Post-$2, The Press−$, Newsroom/$3, NZ Herald/$, Stuff, BusinessDesk/$, Politik-$, NBR-$, Reuters, FT/$, WSJ/$, Bloomberg/$, New York Times/$, The Atlantic-$, The ...
According to RNZ’s embedded reporter, the importance of Winston Peters’ talks in Washington this week “cannot be overstated.” Right. “Exceptionally important.” said the maestro himself. This epic importance doesn’t seem to have culminated in anything more than us expressing our “concern” to the Americans about a series of issues that ...
Up until a few weeks ago, I had never heard of "Climate Fresk" and at a guess, this will also be the case for many of you. I stumbled upon it in the self-service training catalog for employees at the company I work at in Germany where it was announced ...
Japan and Australia talk of ‘collective deterrence,’ but they don’t seem to have specific objectives. The relationship needs a clearer direction. The two countries should identify how they complement each other. Each country has two ...
The NZCTU strongly supports the OPC’s decision to issue a code of practice for biometric processing. Our view is that the draft code currently being consulted on is stronger and will be more effective than the exposure code released in early 2024. We are pleased that some of the revisions ...
Australia’s export-oriented industries, particularly agriculture, need to diversify their markets, with a focus on Southeast Asia. This could strengthen economic security and resilience while deepening regional relationships. The Trump administration’s decision to impose tariffs on ...
Minister Shane Jones is introducing fastrack ‘reforms’ to the our fishing industry that will ensure the big players squeeze out the small fishers and entrench an already bankrupt quota system.Our fisheries are under severe stress: the recent decision by theHigh Court ruling that the ...
In what has become regular news, the quarterly ETS auction has failed, with nobody even bothering to bid. The immediate reason is that the carbon price has fallen to around $60, below the auction minimum of $68. And the cause of that is a government which has basically given up ...
US President Donald Trump’s tariff threats have dominated headlines in India in recent weeks. Earlier this month, Trump announced that his reciprocal tariffs—matching other countries’ tariffs on American goods—will go into effect on 2 April, ...
Hi,Back in June of 2021, James Gardner-Hopkins — a former partner at law firm Russell McVeagh — was found guilty of misconduct over sexually inappropriate behaviour with interns.The events all related to law students working as summer interns at Russell McVeagh:As well as intimate touching with a student at his ...
Climate sceptic MP Mark Cameron has slammed National for being ‘out of touch’ by sticking to our climate commitments. Photo: Lynn GrievesonMōrena. Long stories shortest:ACT’s renowned climate sceptic MP Mark Cameron has accused National of being 'out of touch' with farmers by sticking with New Zealand’s Paris accord pledges ...
Now I've heard there was a secret chordThat David played, and it pleased the LordBut you don't really care for music, do you?It goes like this, the fourth, the fifthThe minor falls, the major liftsThe baffled king composing HallelujahSongwriter: Leonard CohenI always thought the lyrics of that great song by ...
People are getting carried away with the virtues of small warship crews. We need to remember the great vice of having few people to run a ship: they’ll quickly tire. Yes, the navy is struggling ...
Mōrena. Here’s my selection1 of scoops, breaking news, news, analyses, deep-dives, features, interviews, Op-Eds, editorials and cartoons from around Aotearoa’s political economy on housing, climate and poverty from RNZ, 1News, The Post-$2, The Press−$, Newsroom/$3, NZ Herald/$, Stuff, BusinessDesk/$, Politik-$, NBR-$, Reuters, FT/$, WSJ/$, Bloomberg/$, New York Times/$, The Atlantic-$, ...
US President Donald Trump’s hostile regime has finally forced Europe to wake up. With US officials calling into question the transatlantic alliance, Germany’s incoming chancellor, Friedrich Merz, recently persuaded lawmakers to revise the country’s debt ...
We need to establish clearer political boundaries around national security to avoid politicising ongoing security issues and to better manage secondary effects. The Australian Federal Police (AFP) revealed on 10 March that the Dural caravan ...
The NZCTU Te Kauae Kaimahi have reiterated their call for Government to protect workers by banning engineered stone in a submission on MBIE’s silica dust consultation. “If Brooke van Velden is genuine when she calls for an evidence-based approach to this issue, then she must support a full ban on ...
The Labour Inspectorate could soon be knocking on the door of hundreds of businesses nation-wide, as it launches a major crackdown on those not abiding by the law. NorthTec staff are on edge as Northland’s leading polytechnic proposes to stop 11 programmes across primary industries, forestry, and construction. Union coverage ...
It’s one thing for military personnel to hone skills with first-person view (FPV) drones in racing competitions. It’s quite another for them to transition to the complexities of the battlefield. Drone racing has become a ...
Seymour says there will be no other exemptions granted to schools wanting to opt out of the Compass contract. Photo: Lynn GrievesonLong stories shortest:David Seymour has denied a request from a Christchurch school and any other schools to be exempted from the Compass school lunch programme, saying the contract ...
Russian President Boris Yeltsin, U.S. President Bill Clinton, Ukrainian President Leonid Kuchma, and British Prime Minister John Major signed the Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty in ...
Edit: The original story said “Palette Cleanser” in both the story, and the headline. I am never, ever going to live this down. Chain me up, throw me into the pit.Hi,With the world burning — literally and figuratively — I felt like Webworm needed a little palate cleanser at the ...
This is a re-post from Yale Climate Connections by Sarah Wesseler(Image credit: Antonio Huerta) Growing up in suburban Ohio, I was used to seeing farmland and woods disappear to make room for new subdivisions, strip malls, and big box stores. I didn’t usually welcome the changes, but I assumed others ...
Myanmar was a key global site for criminal activity well before the 2021 military coup. Today, illicit industry, especially heroin and methamphetamine production, still defines much of the economy. Nowhere, not even the leafiest districts ...
What've I gotta do to make you love me?What've I gotta do to make you care?What do I do when lightning strikes me?And I wake up and find that you're not thereWhat've I gotta do to make you want me?Mmm hmm, what've I gotta do to be heard?What do I ...
Hundreds more Palestinians have died in recent days as Israel’s assault on Gaza continues and humanitarian aid, including food and medicine, is blocked. ...
National is looking to cut hundreds of jobs at New Zealand’s Defence Force, while at the same time it talks up plans to increase focus and spending in Defence. ...
It’s been revealed that the Government is secretly trying to bring back a ‘one-size fits all’ standardised test – a decision that has shocked school principals. ...
The Green Party is calling for the compassionate release of Dean Wickliffe, a 77-year-old kaumātua on hunger strike at the Spring Hill Corrections Facility, after visiting him at the prison. ...
The Green Party is calling on Government MPs to support Chlöe Swarbrick’s Member’s Bill to sanction Israel for its unlawful presence and illegal actions in Palestine, following another day of appalling violence against civilians in Gaza. ...
The Green Party stands in support of volunteer firefighters petitioning the Government to step up and change legislation to provide volunteers the same ACC coverage and benefits as their paid counterparts. ...
At 2.30am local time, Israel launched a treacherous attack on Gaza killing more than 300 defenceless civilians while they slept. Many of them were children. This followed a more than 2 week-long blockade by Israel on the entry of all goods and aid into Gaza. Israel deliberately targeted densely populated ...
Living Strong, Aging Well There is much discussion around the health of our older New Zealanders and how we can age well. In reality, the delivery of health services accounts for only a relatively small percentage of health outcomes as we age. Significantly, dry warm housing, nutrition, exercise, social connection, ...
Shane Jones’ display on Q&A showed how out of touch he and this Government are with our communities and how in sync they are with companies with little concern for people and planet. ...
Labour does not support the private ownership of core infrastructure like schools, hospitals and prisons, which will only see worse outcomes for Kiwis. ...
The Green Party is disappointed the Government voted down Hūhana Lyndon’s member’s Bill, which would have prevented further alienation of Māori land through the Public Works Act. ...
The Labour Party will support Chloe Swarbrick’s member’s bill which would allow sanctions against Israel for its illegal occupation of the Palestinian Territories. ...
The Government’s new procurement rules are a blatant attack on workers and the environment, showing once again that National’s priorities are completely out of touch with everyday Kiwis. ...
With Labour and Te Pāti Māori’s official support, Opposition parties are officially aligned to progress Green Party co-leader Chlöe Swarbrick’s Member’s Bill to sanction Israel for its unlawful presence in Palestine. ...
Te Pāti Māori extends our deepest aroha to the 500 plus Whānau Ora workers who have been advised today that the govt will be dismantling their contracts. For twenty years , Whānau Ora has been helping families, delivering life-changing support through a kaupapa Māori approach. It has built trust where ...
Labour welcomes Simeon Brown’s move to reinstate a board at Health New Zealand, bringing the destructive and secretive tenure of commissioner Lester Levy to an end. ...
This morning’s announcement by the Health Minister regarding a major overhaul of the public health sector levels yet another blow to the country’s essential services. ...
New Zealand First has introduced a Member’s Bill that will ensure employment decisions in the public service are based on merit and not on forced woke ‘Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion’ targets. “This Bill would put an end to the woke left-wing social engineering and diversity targets in the public sector. ...
Police have referred 20 offenders to Destiny Church-affiliated programmes Man Up and Legacy as ‘wellness providers’ in the last year, raising concerns that those seeking help are being recruited into a harmful organisation. ...
Te Pāti Māori welcomes the resignation of Richard Prebble from the Waitangi Tribunal. His appointment in October 2024 was a disgrace- another example of this government undermining Te Tiriti o Waitangi by appointing a former ACT leader who has spent his career attacking Māori rights. “Regardless of the reason for ...
The challenge now is to get the best possible outcome from the split Act model. We will be working closely with the Government over the course of this year to that end. We simply must have a more nuanced outcome from this process than from the Fast-track ...
The Free Speech Union has made two submissions advocating for more speech, not less, on the Media Reform Proposals and the Regulatory Systems (Occupational Regulation) Amendment Bill, says Jonathan Ayling, Chief Executive of the Free Speech Union. “Our ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Eric Windholz, Associate Professor, Faculty of Law, Monash University Last week, the Novak Djokovic-led Professional Tennis Players Association (PTPA) announced it was suing the sport’s governing bodies – the men’s (ATP) and women’s (WTA) tours, the International Tennis Federation (ITF) and the ...
The Children's Minister says Oranga Tamariki's breaching of confidential information of children and families could not be allowed to continue under this government's watch. ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By William Alexander Donald, Professor of Chemistry, UNSW Sydney Irene Miller/Shutterstock Silicosis is an incurable but entirely preventable lung disease. It has only one cause: breathing in too much silica dust. This is a risk in several industries, including tunnelling, stone masonry ...
By Patrick Decloitre, RNZ Pacific correspondent French Pacific desk Southern Cross, a French-hosted regional military exercise, is moving to Wallis and Futuna Islands this year. The exercise, which includes participating regional armed and law enforcement forces from Australia, Fiji, New Zealand, Papua New Guinea and Tonga every two years, is ...
“The Government has rightly decided to scrap Councils’ focus on social and cultural ‘wellbeings’ and get them back to getting the basics right first, and it’s time Dunedin Council followed suit.” ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Christina McCabe, PhD Candidate in Interdisciplinary Ecology, University of Canterbury Shutterstock/S Watson When we think about flood management, higher stop banks, stronger levees and concrete barriers usually come to mind. But what if the best solution – for people and nature ...
Report by Dr David Robie – Café Pacific. – Like a relentless ocean, wave after wave of pro-Palestinian pro-human rights protesters disrupted New Zealand deputy Prime Minister Winston Peters’ state of the nation speech at the Christchurch Town Hall yesterday. A clarion call to Trumpism and Australia’s One Nation ...
Pacific Media Watch Paris-based global media freedom watchdog Reporters Without Borders (RSF) has recalled that 20 journalists were killed during the six-year Philippines presidency of Rodrigo Duterte, a regime marked by fierce repression of the press. Former president Duterte was arrested earlier this week as part of an International Criminal ...
"The councillors were given tickets because they are councillors, at the very same time they're considering the future of the stadium. It's beyond belief that anyone is defending this." ...
SPECIAL REPORT:By Saige England in Christchurch Like a relentless ocean, wave after wave of pro-Palestinian pro-human rights protesters disrupted New Zealand deputy Prime Minister Winston Peters’ state of the nation speech at the Christchurch Town Hall yesterday. A clarion call to Trumpism and Australia’s One Nation Party, the speech ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Adrian Beaumont, Election Analyst (Psephologist) at The Conversation; and Honorary Associate, School of Mathematics and Statistics, The University of Melbourne A national Morgan poll, conducted March 10–16 from a sample of 2,097, gave Labor a 54.5–45.5 lead by headline respondent preferences, a ...
Julie Hill reviews the Meta exposé written by the New Zealander who used to work there. Sarah Wynn-Williams begins to get a sense that she isn’t in for a normal life when, at 13, she is munched by a shark. The Christchurch teenager is at the beach, on holiday with ...
The proposal to remove the living wage requirement from public sector procurement rules turns back the clock on a progressive step towards valuing essential workers, argues Lyndy McIntyre.On April 1, workers on the minimum wage will get their annual pay rise, with their hourly rate moving from $23.15 to ...
Lyric Waiwiri-Smith recalls a serene week eating raw fish and swimming in Samoa.In June 2023, I travelled from Tāmaki Makaurau to Samoa with my (now) ex-boyfriend’s family (love (most of) you guys). We spent a beautiful nearly two weeks with sand stuck to our skin and salt water dripping ...
The Labour Party’s Tangi Utikere is Palmerston North’s biggest champion and an MP on the come-up. There’s an ancient adage familiar to Palmerstonians (as in, people from Palmerston North), uttered by a British explorer after a voyage through the land of the long white cloud: “if you wish to kill ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Olivia Fisher, Senior Research Fellow, Applied Implementation Science, Charles Darwin University Seven million Australians live in rural and remote areas and many struggle to access the same quality of health care as those in metropolitan areas. More than 18,000 Australians have no ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Kate Holland, Principal Research Scientist, Water Security, CSIRO A dry farm dam in Montacute, Adelaide Hills, March 2025. Ilan Sagi. The Adelaide Hills are experiencing severe water shortages. The root cause? A prolonged dry period and not enough water tankers to ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Erin O’Brien, Associate Professor, School of Government and International Relations, Griffith University Getty Images When the United States starts a trade war with your country, how do you fight back? For individuals, one option is to wage a personal trade war ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By John Hawkins, Senior Lecturer, Canberra School of Politics, Economics and Society, University of Canberra Treasurer Jim Chalmers will bring down the federal budget on Tuesday. It’s likely most of the major spending initiatives have already been announced. An extra A$8.5 billion in ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Alexis Weaver, Associate Lecturer in Music Technology, University of Sydney Shutterstock With artificial intelligence programs that can now generate entire songs on demand, you’d be forgiven for thinking AI might eventually lead to the decline of human-made music. But AI can ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Justin Bergman, International Affairs Editor Both Labor and the Coalition are considering an increase to defence spending ahead of the federal election. Defence spending is currently at about 2% of gross domestic product (GDP), or around A$56 billion per year. The Coalition ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Janeen Baxter, Director, ARC Life Course Centre and ARC Kathleen Fitzpatrick Laureate Fellow, The University of Queensland Australia has a gender problem. Despite social, economic and political reform aimed at improving opportunities for women, gender gaps are increasing and Australia is falling ...
Based on the 2023 and 2024 Budget Summary of Initiatives, CPAG refers to estimates of the cost of restoring school lunches to their 2024 standard, between $107-115 extra a year. ...
In a speech that channelled Trump-style rhetoric but stuck to old Peters themes, the NZ First leader mixed nationalism, culture war grievances and economic blame, writes Catherine McGregor in today’s extract from The Bulletin. To receive The Bulletin in full each weekday, sign up here.An ‘outright litany’ of grievances Winston ...
The government is spending $2.7 billion on tertiary courses this year, but there are early signs it will not be enough to cover all the enrolments. ...
If you want to understand where this coalition Government is coming from, with its disdain for impoverished families and hungry children, Freddy the Frog, Te Tiriti, democratic conventions and other Kiwi decencies, George Monbiot’s The Invisible Doctrine: The Secret History of Neoliberalism is illuminating.The book is short and vividly written, ...
Alice Robinson is slightly disoriented. It can’t be blamed on altitude, or the weight of the World Cup medals she’s hauled in this season.When LockerRoom caught up with the Kiwi giant slalom star by video call last week, she had to think for a moment where in the world she ...
http://gowans.wordpress.com/2008/09/30/stephen-zunes%E2%80%99-false-statements-on-zimbabwe-and-woza/
So very funny.
The sort of typical leftist thinking I read on here all the time.
It all boils down to the big bad neo-imperial capitalistic USA’s fault. Either that or the bankers.
Bugger Gosman, I was too slow to open a sweep stake on the Standard as to how long it would take you to mention your beloved Zimmers. Cuba 10 to 1 anybody?
Do you disagree with the bloggers’ comments Bored?
So now Spain’s in the headlines Gosman, it’s a little more difficult for you to argue irresponsible Government spending, given their fiscal prudence leading up to the GFC.
No their problem was a property bubble, who inflates those again? Oh, that’s right, bankers! And where does the responsibility for the GFC lie, oh, that’s right, speculators and bankers. Where was it’s epicenter, oh, that’s right, Wall St.
But I admire you’re faith, it takes an extraordinary effort to achieve such willful blindness, most don’t know cause they ignore – Adam Curtis notes that economics is boring, and so that is why economists manage to get away with such restlessness – but you clearly read about these things….
Spain isn’t exactly a libertarian free market paradise so I’m not sure why you seem to imply the problems are caused just by banks.
Spain has youth unemployment of around 50%. That suggests there is something wrong with their labour market flexibility. Also the problem is not just dodgy banks but the fact that the Central Government hasn’t got an awful lot of control over regional government’s spending.
Good article on Spain here (admittedly was in 2010)
http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=127069441
Great logic Gos, its all the fault of “labour market flexibility”, superb sidestep of an undeniable criticism of globalisation. Sort of “kill them harder and it will all get better”. And what if it were your children?
If it was my kids I’d want to live in a country where the labour market wasn’t so inflexible that they had a one in two chance of being unemployed for a long time. Luckily that is the case.
What’s your solution to the problem of Spanish youth unemployment by the way? More training perchance? If you read that link you will see that many of the youth unemployed are actually highly educated.
Less globalisation, eradication of capitalism and a rationalisation of the economy so that it actually does what it’s supposed to – support the people and not just the psychopathic few.
Nah, Capitalism’s already dead..
http://www.marketwatch.com/story/capitalism-is-dead-credit-new-king-says-duncan-2012-04-18
So Gosman, that logic eventually leads you to moving your kids to China or Thailand or Cambodia.
And, don’t we have a balance of payments issue in Europe, and artificially suppressed wages in Germans, the deck you’re playing with is rigged, but then that goes back to the link about the death of Capitalism.
this from Berlin last week might also help you understand the banks role in strangling us with debt Gosman
What’s your evidence that Spain’s 50% youth unemployment rate (I’m taking your word for that) is due to labour market inflexibility? (I’m asking for evidence, not assertion of ideological presuppositions.)
Does anything else play a causal role?
Did you bother reading that link I provided? That delves into that very question.
Why do you think there is such high youth unemployment in places like Italy, Greece, and Spain then?
An interesting editorial in today’s Guardian on Spain and the Euro crisis: Until the eve of the banking crisis in 2007, Spain’s unemployment rate was 7.9% and Spain had sounder public finances than Germany.
I heard this morning on Euronews that Mario Monti, the technocrat economist in charge in Italy, is working on labour reform – making it easier to fire people but at the same time make it harder to put people on short-term low wage contracts.
Apparently Italy’s firing rules mean that the worker almost always gets the job back if it is legally challenged, meaning employers prefer contract workers.
Interesting take on labour flexibility. The main aim is to make it is easier for workers to get full-time, permanent jobs and reduce short-term contracts because labour market instability is a bad thing.
So, have the various measures taken by the US (as described in the post you link to) had any effect on the economic viability of Zimbabwe?
If not, are those measures pointless exercises on the part of the US (and, hence, should be withdrawn)?
Clare Curran steams more than Josephine over the Hillside Workshops sale announcement, and calls Key and English liars despite denials they knew about it.
While most of Dunedin is looking for and seems to want to work on positives Curran talks of starting yet another anti campaign, with Metiria Turei.
“and calls Key and English liars despite denials they knew about it. ”
Actually no PG, she said “Liars if they say it’s nothing to do with us”.
Of course this sale is something to do with National – they decided not to get work done in New Zealand, leading to a lack of work at Hillside. Key and English may deny having been told of this sale of state assets, but they cannot deny the link between putting work offshore and an effect locally.
Is a deliberate misquote a lie or incompetence, Pete G?
Surely a combined Union purchase would be acceptable to keep the Dunedin workshop.
There is enough expertise to run it.
This Sky City tender just gets worse and worse. If any other ordinary public servant had conducted a tender process so very badly they would be disciplined at the least; quite possibly sacked
What gets me is the absolute hyposcrisy. Helen Clark signs a painting to raise some money for a charity and it’s the crime of the fucking century.
John Key grossly inteferes in a major tender process, playing very lose with the law over a matter that involves hundreds of millions and substantial social harm…. and all that happens in the media is a mild round of tut-tutting.
It’s like a Labour PM has to be pure and holy, while there’s this understanding that we elect National PM’s to be venal and a little bit corrupt.
That’s right. The media and everyone else is out to get you Red. Suck it up.
That just doesn’t deserve a response…
My summary of the whole saga: the clearest (but by no means only) example we have so far in this government of that nasty old Tory corruption, that uses political power personally linked to big bucks to take more money out of less well off pockets, and put it into better off: and then barefacedly deny they have done anything wrong, or hurt anyone.
That’s most people’s expectations of a Nat govt RL, those with memories of Muldoon would be aghast at the naked corruption and complete arrogance not caring about the wreckage both in NZ and their own part.
Reading gossie etc reminds me of people who would be cheering at a stoning or hanging, what sad trolls. The MSM is not out to do anything therein lies one of the problems.
Shearer’s living wage campaign thingy is brilliant.
It should be made clearer to the public that it is not possible to live on the minimum wage. That we effectively have a wage system that is worse than slavery – at least as a slave you were housed and fed whereas it is not possible to do that on the minimum wage – it needs to be topped up by other taxpayers through various subsidies and handouts like WFF. Effectively the taxpayers are subsidising business.
This should be made clearer.
Of course lifting wages like this would require some heavish adjustments across the economy that would take time and some pain here and there. But the alternative is taxpayers paying for business and wages that one cannot live on. Same amount of money in the economy just spread differently (and its current spread is the result of govt intervention so please no rants that such intervention will distort).
It is actually quite astounding that we have a minimum wage that cannot be survived on. It is a barbaric situation.
Are you suggesting that those on the minimum wage aren’t surviving?
The “living wage” idea potentially has some good points, but it’s very difficult to specify one wage that covers many different circumstances and locations. An eighteen year old living with his parents on a farm in Tuatapere has quite different financial needs to a father of five living in Remuera.
Yes I am suggesting that.
As for the differing circumstances, lets run an anecdotal test right here – hands up all those who could survive in their current circumstances in NZ on the minimum wage. No subsidides, handouts, supplements, WFFs allowed, just the wage.
‘…hands up all those who could survive in their current circumstances in NZ on the minimum wage.’
That is a tautological statement.
Of course the circumstances will change if the income decreases. That is a completely different argument to the one that people are unable to survive on the minimum wage.
Fair enough. Hands up everyone who could survive on the minimum wage, those with families, those who are single, those with other circumstances.
If both my wife and I were on the minimum wage we could manage the mortgage and survive financially.
40 hours at 13.50 = gross pay of $540.00
On an ME tax code net pay is $465.17 per week.
Well that’s good, I guess the cheap property values (buy and rent) in Dunedin help. We, in our circumstances, haven’t a hope in hell.
Score so far: 1-1
So you can survive on minimum wage in this country. You just can’t live in places where the living expenses are greater. Excellent, we have now established that the situation in NZ follows standard economic theory. Do you want to ask us whether we will fall to our deaths if we jump out of plane without a parachute now?
No. So far the score is 1-1. That means one family dies and the other scrimps by. Lovely place innit…
Where’s the evidence that anyone is dying as a result of this?
You egg. Surviving has many levels of definition. waster…
True surviving has multiple meanings. Dies tends to be quite restricted. Unless you are meaning the family fails miserably performing on stage.
Lol – you mean you’re once again asking for direct observational evidence of something that is happening right now, when that evidence takes a year or two to collate? Even though the literature in the field strongly indicates that any tory interwebz warrior who argues that the situation does not exist is a bit of a tool?
the situation in NZ follows standard economic theory.
And standard economic theory suggests those who live in cheaper places are living where there are fewer jobs, so will have to move to more expensive places to improve employment options, making the minimum wage much less than a living wage than it was before. Maybe we should have a flexible minimum wage to go with those flexible employment options.
For the record, I couldn’t live on the minimum – a long-term medical condition with a lot of out-of-pocket medical expenses.
Gosman, let me try to put this in terms that – I think – you’ll understand.
There are two ways to ‘survive’ (i.e., to be ‘sustainable’).
The first way is to keep regenerating your ‘capital’ (i.e., your health, your mental resilience, your ability to participate in society, etc.).
The second way is to live off your ‘capital’ (i.e,. your health, your mental resilience, your ability to participate in society, etc.) and so gradually reduce it while you are physically and biologically ‘surviving’ (i.e., physically and biologically continuing or ‘sustaining’ yourself).
People on the minimum wage are most likely ‘surviving’ in the latter rather than the former sense.
Bollocks fair enough VTO. Gos is just being his usual prize arsehole with some rancid economic rationalist argument to justify people not being able to survive in decent conditions. He does not give a fuck so long as he is OK.
Where’s the evidence for the increase in death’s as a result of not being able to survive?
lolwut?
Oh right, I forgot, you have selective blindness. Because the evidence on poverty leading to increases in death rates is fairly well established in the health and sociology literature and mentioned here oft…
In other words, go google scholar it.
I already have and have posted the result in another thread here. There is no evidence that the death rate has increased over the past 4 or so years.
Keep moving those goalposts and failing reading comprehension 101 Gosikins.
Do yYou disagree that poverty has increased over the past 4 or 5 years in NZ?
Gos, how many people died last year, by cause?
Grouping causes by ICD10-AM chapter heading is fine.
Then get tell me where you got reliable data with <3% variation over the following 12 months.
Sounds as though we now have a growing number of ‘third world disease’ in this country. Some of these leading to death. Pretty sure it’s not the rich suffering from this.
The cause of the higher rates of ‘third world’ diseases can largely be attributed to substandard accomodation. Whether or not someone can survive on minimim wage plays only a very small part in this. That stated I have yet to read an article where mortality has been attributed to ‘third world’ diseases in NZ. Perhaps you can provide a link to something that backs your case up?
So Gos (aka I Am All Right Jack) you say The cause of the higher rates of ‘third world’ diseases can largely be attributed to substandard accommodation… as if this is some absolution from any spurious arguments you have raised prior.
It is easily demonstrable from your statement that according to you this substandard accommodation exists, and that there is a problem. So Gos, do you care?
so if it’s not the wage earner’s fault i guess it’s the landlords for not doing their bit to keep housing standards up, and the landlords are ???? the very investment addicts that gave us the bubbles that inevitably burst, soaking the fruit of community with poison debt that causes them to fall broken upon the ground like scattered weeds, leaving no option than to be sprayed with the stigma of un-met aspirations and covered with the weedmat of bene bashing!
(hyperbole aside, sooner or later gosman you have to face the truth that capitalism is little more than an ouroborus on steroids)
Yep, and people on minimum wage can’t afford better accommodation.
I could, but then I am the exception (being on UB at the minute, I’d be better off on minimum wage!) But that just shows the comparative unlivability of the UB!
Also, I am single and a miser by nature… 🙂
Wow! Someone can live on an income less than the minimum wage. Amazing! Someone inform Ripely’s believe it or not.
“An eighteen year old living with his parents on a farm in Tuatapere has quite different financial needs to a father of five living in Remuera.”
You’re right Pete, a father of five living in Remuera should get less than an imaginary rural teen, because to be there in the first place, and then with five dependents, he’d have few “needs”. Remuera is overun with breadline solo Dads. Doss-houses everywhere, and cheap slum rentals. The place is a magnet for the hard up. A complete horror.
You could be imaginative, though, and choose a rural setting much further north, where there is no farm, but lots of space and no family and not much of a farmhouse. Then you could really lean into the stereotypes. Can’t have society without castes and heirachy, eh Pete?
How is the grass on the octagon this morning, Pete? Anyone muss it up during the night? Bloody scallywags. We should have a discussion about it, about when to have the discussion about doing something, something about something – that should do it. If the situation doesn’t change for the better by itself.
The ex Octagon grass mussers are trying to get the DCC to ban fracking now, saying “many people” support them. I doubt they have 1% support on that.
So PG the whole concept of somebody wanting fracking banned is disagreeable to you? Regardless of who and how unheard they are? Go frack in your own backyard.
Pete’s right: any group that had such a pathetic level of support has no business dictating policy to anyone.
I doubt he’s right about the level of concern about fracking though.
Petes entirely wrong about people with a low level of support not having a valid argument. They are not “dictating” to anybody, try “advocating”.
Yes, I know, I just doubt that anti-fracking groups enjoy such a low level of support. United Follicles, on the other hand…
“it is not possible to do that on the minimum wage – it needs to be topped up by other taxpayers through various subsidies and handouts like WFF. ”
You seem to try and play the ‘middle of the road’ type character Pete. But you do it badly. Mostly because you just come across as a slightly more apolegetic National supporter.
From what I have read your a Peter Dunne follower-which makes a lot of sense. I reckon it’s time to pick a side.
Anyway, being in a postion where I make a lot more than minimum wage and having times where I wonder where my money has gone I often ponder how someone making 13 bucks an hour; A. gets by and B. can afford any type of simple luxury. Which in my opinion any working person should be able to.
A person should not have to work 40 hours a week for just food and shelter in this day and age.
When a person is seen as causing harm to you or your power, then get right up close and friendly. Charm him and make it harder for him to sting.
Patrick Gower is in the swim with John Key and no doubt will be a little less enthusiastic with his stories. Not many political reporters get to swim with the
sharkPM.http://www.nzherald.co.nz/entertainment/news/article.cfm?c_id=1501119&objectid=10800105#
Oops. “shark” was supposed to be shark. strikethrough.
Edit: still doesn’t work?
Still doesn’t work?
[Bunji: hashtag for strikethrough is “del”]
You mean ‘del’ where the ‘s’ should be -inside the ?
Be good to update the FAQ. I spent ages trying to figure out what I was doing wrong the other day.
Thanks bunji.
SharkIt was in Guides.
Great, love using strikethrough and could never get it to work either.
does that really work?I swear it wasn’t when I looked it up the other day. It said ‘s’
Trying this[lprent: The pages get adjusted when things get pointed out. I guess someone did. ]
Well this is what can happen when you swim with sharks
http://www.stuff.co.nz/world/africa/6778063/Giant-shark-kills-man
But but… John Key was the dolphin swimming with sharks
Some US researchers have done a series of pieces of research that through a bit of light on how wealth/prestige reduces compassion for others – especially others in difficult situations or less powerful positions.:
http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=how-wealth-reduces-compassion
The research included observing that drivers of more expensive cars were more likely to ignore pedestrians waiting at crossings, and more likely to cut-up other drivers instead of waiting their turn. They also did other research involving keeping “candy” for yourself and leaving some for children.
They should add Key, Nacts and their cronyist, legislation for sale antics to their studies.
It’s a good thing most bankers including John Key are psychopaths. Psychopaths don’t feel anxiety like you and I do which mean they can still sleep soundly in the face of what is coming at us and is created by them.
In fact John Key advising himself in what is arguably to most stunning example of Psychopathic behaviour of a New Zealand Prime Minister is your typical number two of the Hare check-list of Psychopathy: A grandiose sense of self worth.
Do you realise that when you bandy about words like ‘psychopath’ all it does is make you appear very silly.
I’d hate to see Travellerev’s psychological report though. I imagine the phrase ‘paranoid conspiracy theorist’ might pop up though.
Gosman, have you watched The Corporation ? i mean actually watched it, scraped the wax from the ol’ lugholes and listened to its clear and concise information. You know… applied critical thought to new information? Not simply glance up from the Biggles Annual all bleary eyed as Mummy puts milk on your Kornies?
There is a lot of well researched data that shows the psychological behaviour expressed by Companies, and those who run them is nothing short of Psychotic. Have you considered the common ground that supports comments from many of the well educated and highly respected individuals who actually have studied the topic. Have you wondered why so many people came to the same conclusions? Remember, if these companies want to be legal people then the values and standards that we hold people to, should apply to them also.
e.g. how much fun would it be to charge a corporation proper income tax, seeing as they are a legal person and all that.
The weasel ones just say, but they are a business and as such get to pick and choose what is of benefit to us and what is of damage to the people we take from.
There is a word for that: Psychopath
(a person suffering from a disorder characterized by a pervasive pattern of disregard for the rights of others and the rules of society)
Plus an extreme lack of empathy and the inability to feel any responsibility for their actions.
Who is pushing for corporations becoming legal people like the rest of us?
Wow. 200 years out of date, and you still have an inflated ego. Fool.
Ummmmmm…..
I stated like becoming legal people like the rest of us. None of the links you provided suggested thay have the same rights as the rest of us.
In fact to quote ‘. Legal entities cannot marry, they usually cannot vote or hold public office,[3] and in most jurisdictions there are certain positions which they cannot occupy’.
No, you asked “who is pushing” for it, not what it is now.
I gave you two links that provide a decent background to the issue, which is incredibly longstanding and has progressively expanded over centuries. Those links included actual references (should you choose to speak from a position of knowledge, rather than just being a dissembling cocksucker. I should have known better).
Denying the truth makes you insane.
O dear, the resident idjit calls me silly and that should worry me how?
Eve I seriously doubt you have ever seen or met a psychopath and I really hope you never do.
I met a person that the consulting psychiatrist had diagnosed being as close to a pure psychopath as diagnostic tests allowed some years ago and it was an extremely disturbing experience.
I can assure you that although many of our politicians merit all the distrust and abuse you can muster none are psychopaths.
http://www.zerohedge.com/contributed/new-study-%E2%80%93-traders-are-worse-psychopaths
Well actually HS both my husband and I are both diagnosed with PTSD after a five year encounter with a serious Psychopath and the experience has given us a unique view on what these assholes are capable off and I can smell a Psychopath from a mile a way as a result.
John Key is a Psychopath and by the time he is done with this country and sashays back into the world he feels best in filled with fellow Psycho’s, I can assure you there will be a lot more people with PTSD in NZ.
Most likely people who lost their income, jobs, benefits, schooling chances, Housing, Houses and ACC compensations and who as a result have to live in cars, garages, and on the streets.
But don’t worry the pretty girls can find jobs in the super brothel and the boys can be croupiers in Sky city and if your not so pretty but you are lucky you can become a dishwasher in the new convention centre or work in the cigarette packing factory owned by Aussie owners who like our low wages and easy 90 day fire at will clause courtesy of Psycho John Key.
Derp:
http://tvnz.co.nz/national-news/kids-punished-opting-bible-class-4842662
And this is why religious classes are problematic as standard social primate behaviours lead to exclusion and coercion and the usual suspects aren’t all that interested in discussing other religions, except in how Christianity is better than them. Usually.
Religion should not be taught in school time. If the religious nutters want to teach their kids to be as stupid as them then they can do it after school.
I hope you know that the Education Act says that it can’t be? I know this Peter Harrison person of old, and he’s not beyond inventing things to whip up hysteria about – he is a ‘poor pitiful us’ atheist… one of those who claims persecution 100 times a day. 😀
Bigotry.
(Back in the 1960s, we had a prayer at assembly, before school began, and I well remember one girl who was horribly miserable when her parents came to make a big stink and a loud performance out of dragging her out, loudly proclaiming that as atheists, they disapproved. We her classmates didn’t harass her, the teachers didn’t harass her, her parents harassed her to say that she wanted to be excused, even though she couldn’t have cared less about a 30 second prayer. My father was an atheist, but he didn’t want to make a meal out of it.)
Which means that the Education Act is wrong.
Generally speaking, I couldn’t care less about the religious. I get pissed off when they demand that we make allowances for them and that their religion be forced upon society.
Which just shows that you missed the point and haven’t learned anything since – she, and the rest of the children, shouldn’t have had religion forced upon.
BTW, the children did try to harass me when I decided (yes, me not my parents) to ignore religious class at school. The bible thumping teachers weren’t too happy about it either.
Ah, if you think so, take it up with the Min of Ed. 😀
An attack of the poor pitifuls there, mate! Who’s forcing it on you? Maybe you hate that we breathe the same air you do… would you choose Sam Harris’ and Dawkins’ solution? (For the record, forcible incarceration in mental hospitals, which goes with automatic loss of custody of our kids, and I assume, sterilisation, all “for the good of society”. Given Harris is an American, it’s hard to know what he means by society…
Obviously, I did miss the point then. I thought she wanted to do what most of us did, which was to ignore a very tiny part of the day and get on with our Larry’s Rebels fantasies, I didn’t realise anything was being forced on us! (Which of course it wasnt’. Teenagers, even if they are girls I add for your benefit) are capable of ignoring something they don’t want to hear.
Oh, a proper little Dawkins in the making, what a precious, precocious wee genius you were! Your parents must have been so proud. Bible thumping teachers – what was your school, Dotheboys Hall? Sir Lord Herr Professor Dawkins tells the same story – about how he as a 6 year old impressed parents and grandparents with his precocious infant grasp of subtleties and arguments undreamt of by generations that had lived and died before him. ‘Scuse me while I giggle and snort… and oh dear, I had better stop here – with an ego the size of yours, comes great sensitivity to even imaginary slights…
We’re not talking about ‘teenagers’ Vicky. It’s primary schools.
And where do you get off just assumming that the story is a lie?
Honestly, do you think it’s good enough that primary school children who are not part of these programmes are looked after in a way that makes them feel like they are being punnished?
Do you think it’s appropriate for religious instructers to be telling primary age kids that dinosaurs didn’t exist?
It looks to me like you are the one with the ‘poor ;little me’ syndrome going on. it looks like just because someone is criticising something allegedly Christian, you feel the need to jump in and attack the people complaining about it.
I was talking with a woman today about this story, and she told me she opted out of the classes after her 5 year old daughter was told by the instructer that “didn’t have god in her heart” and that she would “burn like toast”.
Now 5 yr olds sometimes hear things in a way that they weren’t intended, but that means adults have to be pretty careful in how they talk about things with them.
These classes are due for a bit of a looking at I reckon, and schoools absolutely need to have good systems in place for the children who do not take part.
What story are you saying I said was a lie?
Of course it’s not appropriate – if it is happening! Given that the Education Act says that education in NZ must be “free, secular and compulsory”, I really don’t see that what’s alleged can be blamed on the school.
Sorry, that’s a story I really don’t believe! I know Christians, even the kind I now avoid, the evangelicals who are portrayed in the media as saying such things – and I know that in reality they don’t say such things to children!
(They do in Hollywood, and on HBO, of course, but not in NZ, and certainly not in schools.)
Definitely, if they are what you say they are. My son was at school from 1992 to 2007, and I assure you that ‘Bible in Schools’ in the 1990s, consisted of 10 minutes before 08.30. Leon opted out with my blessing, despite my being a Christian, I have always believed that the Education Act is fine as it is. In fact, almost everybody opted out as it was simply too early for everyone, including parents who, like us, lived 5 minutes walk from the school.
What story are you saying I said was a lie?
I assumed this was in relation to the story linked to.
And I’m not sure from the rest of your comment that you actually know how this stuff works in many schools. It’s not ten minutes before class, it’s often 1/2 an hour during the day. To comply with the education act the school ‘closes’ for the time of the classes. The instructers are not employed by the school, they are usually volunteers, but the school is very much responsible for chooing who will be running the program. If inapropriate things are going on, the school has the responsibility to sort it out.
And as for you calling my acquaintence a liar based on nothing more than your alleged knowledge of what all christians in NZ would say? Umm, perhaps re-read what I wrote.
Do you really think it unbelievable that an untrained but enthusiastic evangelical might phrase things poorly, such that a 5 year old child might think they were talking to and about them rather than generally?
Do you honestly think it is not possible that an evangelical might evangelise to children, and talk about the consequences of not having ‘Jesus in your heart’?
Happen it’s changed since L, was at school? How is it you know? From my reading of the Standard, I know that maybe 5 Standardistas actually have children, and of the regulars, maybe 2 have… You are not one of them. Still, that’s not relevant, and too easily twisted by you, so moving on..
Yes, I do find it completely unbelievable! As I said I actually know Christians, and not just as characters in HBO dramas, or hate figures and no evangelical would ever say such a thing to a 5 year old as your friend quoted them as saying. Now you’re back-tracking, and claiming it was something different, so what was it, an ‘untrained but enthusiastic evangelical’ or what my old mother would have called a ‘complete and utter luniac’? If it’s the luniac saying “burn in hell”, there’s no way that’s true, and mother no doubt invented what daughter said, dreaming it all up through the veil of her own fears and prejudice.
Not in the words you claimed, no. Not to 5 year olds. I find it somewhat amusing that you are frantically back-pedalling. Did you have a chat to your friend in the mean time? Did she tell you that exaggeration can amount to lying as Peter Woss-name no doubt did? (In his case to great effect – a TV item no less!)
Most of the authors have kids at various ages. The only one I know who doesn’t is me. I just got to be uncle across my nieces, nephews, cousins, etc – especially when they hit their teens.
I was talking with a woman today about this story, and she told me she opted out of the classes after her 5 year old daughter was told by the instructer that “didn’t have god in her heart” and that she would “burn like toast”.
Now 5 yr olds sometimes hear things in a way that they weren’t intended, but that means adults have to be pretty careful in how they talk about things with them.
That was what I said, and I haven’t ‘backtracked’ in the slightest from it, so your amusement is based on your failure to read what I said.
The education Act hasn’t changed on this for a long time. I’ve Known how it works since I was at school, where we had a similar program. It is also discussed in the article from yesterday:
You seem to be remembering the way your sons school did things, and assuming that all schools do it that way. There is no basis for this belief, which you know if you had bothered to read the links, and think about them, rather than get all defensive about ‘atheists’.
I’m done with this. I’m taking my son (who I have mentioned numerous times on this blog, so you may need to update your spreadsheet of standartista famial status) to a comic convention today.
“From my reading of the Standard, I know that maybe 5 Standardistas actually have children, and of the regulars, maybe 2 have… You are not one of them. Still, that’s not relevant, and too easily twisted by you, so moving on.. “
lolz. Oh Vicky, you do say some fucking ridiculous things when you’re speaking in tongues.
And oh so predictable too…
We can’t have any semi-civil discussions here about secularism without Vicky turning up and playing the persecution complex card /smugface
And of course, she misses the whole human rights issue concerning witnessing and it’s exploitative nature in terms of social networks and the negative consequences therein on children. Particularly in teh context of school environs and bullying…
The kids shouldn’t need to opt out – religion shouldn’t be in schools during school time. Really, how hard is it to understand that?
The religious are and it’s not upon me but upon children who are incapable of differentiating between truth and BS. The schools should not have to make time available for religion.
Yes it was – you had to go to the assembly and listen to the prayer didn’t you? That’s force because you had no choice.
What a surprise, not happy with the message you then resort to ad hominem attack
I quite liked the allegation that wanting a genuinely secular education equalled wanting religious people forcibly detained on mental health grounds.
That logical leap certainly suggested that one religious advocate might be closer to quaifying than others.
And that’s how people like you end up ruining the reputation of the people who comment here that y’all have decided to hate – by pretending we said things we didn’t say!
I have a degree in education. I have said loud and long through out this thread that I want and agree with the secular education that is mandated by the Education Act. Yet you pretend I said otherwise. Read back to what I actually said, and try to restrain your impulse to lie about what Christians say. I was quoting Sam Harris, numb-nuts, he’s the one who said he wants Christians locked up so they can’t indoctrinate ‘innocent children’.
lulz, I do <3 it when apologists quote mine atheists and claim Harris and Dawkins want parents incarcerated for forcing their religious beliefs on their children (and others), when all they did is point out the exploitative nature of much of conversion and it's occasional perturbing closeness to non-physical forms of child abuse.
So, by all means Vicky, provide us with teh quotes that show they want to do what you claim they do. Or make a retraction.
“Yes it was – you had to go to the assembly and listen to the prayer didn’t you? That’s force because you had no choice.”
Yes, that’s my experience at primary school too. We had a Jewish girl in our class who was made to stand outside the hall during religious education – stand, not sit, and nor was she allowed to go elsewhere. I thought she was lucky (I didn’t understand religious intolerance then, but that was a good starting point in learning) and I tried to see if I could join her, but sadly I had no letter from my parents asking to be excused. So yeah – forced religious instruction for the masses.
Really, I don’t know what to say to this! Will the story include a yellow star and a Judenfrei banner next time?
Where did you go to school? New Zealand? Seriously, I doubt it. I attended a state primary school in New Zealand (a state one, note – I wasn’t in the socio-economic band for private education, and we didn’t have any such thing as RE.) The girl I spoke of at our High School was the child of campaigning atheists, and was excluded by them, and was very unhappy about it (I would have been as well, being made the subject of such a drama.) I am sorry for waxing sarcastic above – but seriously, the story of the poor little Jewish girl made to adopt a stress position outside the classroom, seems such a novelistic one! HBO strikes again – the Jewish kids in Rotorua primary, intermediate and secondary schools that I attended, all two of them, were the children of my Mum’s best childhood friend, and always made a point of flaunting their superior socio-economic status at us, carrying on Esther’s childhood rivalry with our Mum…
Gosh Vicky, you do exaggerate – stress position… 🙄
On cue – that sort of religious intolerance lol.
Oh, so, I am the intolerant one? Don’t be absurd. I asked you a heap of questions, because your story doesn’t sound very true to me… not true of a state school in NZ anyway, but instead of answering, you make with the insults.
I am reminded of the IDF, and their charming habits when it comes to tormenting Palestinian children. Sorry, Jews have used up all their sympathy chips with me…
State primary school – Waikato.
btw – a Jewish primary school girl in NZ !=Zionist thugs in Palestine. So yes, that sort of intolerance.
What part of the Education Act (which I keep quoting) do you not understand? Schools do not have to make time available for religion!
Cry me a river. No, we didn’t have to go to assembly. We could do as half the school did, and be late! To you all these years later, it’s a massively big deal – to us in 1966 to 1971, it was literally nothing. As I say, my father was an atheist, but a far more tolerant fair-minded one than most I’ve met, especially here! (Working class, English, a far cry from the upper middle class New Zealander with the massive chip on theshoulder that one encounters on the Standard.) He was ‘down the school’ at any hint of anything unjust, but not about this – he was not as insecure about his childrens’ intelligence as you are (although I assume that as you don’t have children, your concern is for theoretical children, whom you assume are all a bit thick…
Then why is this shit happening at school and in school time? Oh, that’s right, because some religious arseholes decided to make it available and then when children opt out they get ostracised. All the act should say is that religion should not be taught at school in school time.
BTW, you haven’t quoted the education act yet – you’ve merely said what you believe it contains.
Perhaps he didn’t realise that it was unjust.
Really? If I did that at any of the schools I went to I ended up in detention and/or getting caned.
lulz.
Anyhow, I find it most interesting that Vicky’s avoiding the current issue via diving into the past and trying to establish some sort of ground on which to normalise religious instruction in state schools.
Good grief you are a moron aren’t you?!
How many times do I have to say that I don’t support religious education in state schools? Could I say it any more plainly? I am reminded of the way y’all distort what Gosman and Pete George say, and then work your way up to a few cluster f bombs, and shit-storms of hate and indignation about what you said they said, not what they said! Because what I just said will turn into my supporting Pete and Gosman I want it on record that I don’t support them, I just think it would be a much better look for the Standard if you actually answered what they say and not what you wish they had said…
My crime seems to be that I questioned the truthfulness of some of the bizarre novelistic stories people here are telling about friends, and their children, and the children of friends of friends, and their own primary schooling any time between 5 and 55 years ago… I well know the temptation to exaggerate to make a good story better – the only problem is, that you risk losing all credibility 🙂 especially when you tell the exaggerated story to someone who happens to actually know something about the subject – in my case, of state schooling in New Zealand between the 1960s and the 2000s.
You mean when I tell you what is happening in the real world, right now, and you pooh pooh it because it does not fit your pre-conceived ideas.
Not exaggerated stories. fact!
What I know it contains, idiot. Look it up!
Working class, English, but he was still intelligent. You ‘lefties’ amuse me greatly, you’re all such snobs! Real lefties would make a meal of you…
Boys’ and boarding schools obviously! Are you one of those self-pitying men who constantly wail that it’s so unfair that girls weren’t caned? (Cause we weren’t 😀 ) You miss the point that because assembly was officially before school started (or there couldn’t have been a prayer, could there?) it wasn’t compulsory?
Vicky.
You are the one talking crap.
My kids primary school closed once a week for religious indoctrination. For half an hour. Unfortunately it was after my kids bus arrived so they were at school, anyway.
Because a few religious parents had taken over the board.
After my 5 year old started going on about nailing people up, including waking up with nightmares about it, I withdrew them.
We would never allow 5 year olds to be told about such extreme torture and violence except under the cover of religion.
The schools “Christians’ put all the kids who were not doing religion in the hall with no books, games, or anything else to do, or supervision.
Just recently a gay teenager of my acquaintance was told by the Baptist paster of a youth group that he was going to burn in hell.
Lovely people, Christians.
Not to mention all the adds for teachers, for publicly funded schools, which say that teachers must support the “special character”, i.e. religious indoctrination of students, of the school.
My experience is that those who believe in one load of crap, like sky fairies, are much more likely to believe in others, like creationism, Austrian economics or John Key.
I think you have made the very common, and understandable error of confusing people who believe in a God, with fundamentalists…. who fool everyone and themselves that they believe in a God… but who don’t.
In my world fundamentalists are people who are completely blind and unaware of the real nature of religion which is actually about abstract and evanescent qualities such as justice, compasssion and dignity. Because of this blindness they construct instead a facade of a religion based on institutions, rituals and rules.
Which is what you experienced. I’m saddened and sorry to read how it has hurt people you know.
No True Scotsman alert.
And no, your version of religion is not the one “real” one as any look at believers beliefs quickly shows…
Seconded, RedLogix! 😀
Crafar Farms official status: SOLD,
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/business/news/article.cfm?c_id=3&objectid=10800234
funny how the Chinese owners seem ok to talk about selling farms to NZ interests,
So i guess it was just the National party who didn’t like the idea
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/business/news/article.cfm?c_id=3&objectid=10800148
http://www.linz.govt.nz/sites/default/files/docs/overseas-investment/oio-recommendation-crafar-farms-20120420.pdf
and what ???? the OIA spinmeisters can go fly a kite, it is easy to release a document that supports pre-determined findings. The facts remain that NZ was simply not given the same opportunities to buy these farms that were offered overseas.
OIO does as it’s told and it’s been a rubber stamp for selling out NZ ever since it was created.
Draco
Which Government in 2005 revised the Overseas Investment Commission to the Overseas Investment Office with many changed directions – which have now been fullfilled.
What’s that got to do with anything? The OIO doesn’t see itself as regulating the selling off of NZ but assisting with that sell off.
Yup. OIO might as well rename itself National’s Divestment Office.
We,as in the we of New Zealand would seem to have 2 choices vis a vis the looming rental ‘price crunch’ facing those whose only means of accommodation is ‘to rent’,
Choice 1 is to build our way out of a situation where for many of those on low and fixed incomes accommodation costs take between 50 and 70% of their income, a situation destined to become progressively worse as capital and labour are directed into the Christchurch rebuild leaving tenants in other city’s to face a growing shortage of accommodation along with the inevitable ‘rack renting’ that comes with such shortages,
Choice 2 is to simply enact legislation requiring rental accommodation to be leased on the basis of 25% of the income of any and all tenants to be housed in that particular accommodation….
Celebrating 50 years of dumbing down and brainwashed people, yay!
US slams Australia’s on-shore cloud fixation
So, the “trade barrier” that the US is complaining about is the fact that the US government isn’t trusted.
So once they push the TPPA through, how will that keep the “Yanks” out…
Interesting article – thanks for the link.
One quick reboot coming up. Looks like there is a problem in the network today..
Back again… Now does that correct the slow comments issue.
Ah. I wondered. So far it’s much faster for me.
I wonder if shark swimmer works now? (Strikeout)
Edit: No it doesn’t.
Naturally poisonous water?
There is nothing natural about our waterways becoming poisonous!
Reminds me of the lies that were told about the “e-coli cucumbers” in Europe.
Yup it was all the fault of the organic farmers!
Is anyone else getting an email from Iprent regarding subscription manager? It is in a foreign language. Germam? Dutch?
What? Checking. It probably the frigging jetpack reactivating.
Nope. There is an option to get emails of comments on a post (just under the reply box). Did you hit that? What post….
“Today’s New Zealand Roy Morgan Poll shows Prime Minister John Key’s National Party (49.5%, up 5.5%) improving its standing to its highest since last year’s NZ Election. The improvement in National’s vote comes at the expense of the two main Opposition parties — Labour (26.5%, down 4%) and the Greens (12.5%, down 4.5%) — the Greens result is similar to their polling achieved prior to the high achieved in the last Morgan Poll conducted at the time of Earth Hour.
So, between this one and the last one, which of the two do you think is most likely to be the rogue one?
Do you have a link Doug? I can only find Australian poll. Thanks.
I can’t find ACT. Anyone know what happened to them? The gap between the current Government and the opposition is still just a few points and this poll was conducted before Jackpot John outed himself as a casino shill.
If it’s not a rogue poll for Labour, they have a fair bit of work ahead of them 😛
I recon it’s more a rogue poll for the Nat’s as they seem to be registering a bit too high given current events. National is serving up their unpopular legislation early in their term to get it out of the way, and hope people forget about it come next election season. So yeah 49.5% sounds a tad high. I would have thought some kind of slight decline would make more sense, so maybe this is the rogue.
Greens are probably registering a bit low, 15%+/- seems more reasonable, they have been very effective and confident in parliament. They raise good points, they are definitely set to become our third major party imo.
Of course I have no frigging idea how people would vote, just basing all this conjecture on my personal theories and observations of attitudes of people whom I interact with.
NZ1 seems pretty constant.
ACT are a joke – at least the electorate recognise that much 🙂
If nats go up next poll I’ll get drunk. I suspect they might not, though 🙂
Agree, ACT are a joke. They won’t be there next time.
Regardless of the non too subtle swings between polls, public support for the Nats is likely to still sit well above Labour, and still around the same as Labour/Greens combined. All this after a difficult few weeks for the government.
John Key must be pleased.
And you coming from your usual impartial perspective sound happy too.
Just an observation Fendles
NZ know Act are a joke – but Epsom know that it’s an extra electorate seat for the nats. So – barring personal tragedy or criminal proceedings – banks will be there next time. The tosser.
Left and right are always going to balance out broadly. A year ago National could have comfortably governed alone – even up to or over 60 with its coalition partners.
So far it is a spike against the trend. Key must be relieved that the knives that were half drawn have gone a bit back into the sheath. But I think he’d be looking for it to go back down to ~45-6 on a good day next time, and the knives will be out if it goes to 44-3.
I’m not sure that the Epsom seat is worth forgoing seeing as they poll so low (or not at all) and won’t take additional seats with them. They only cause unneeded embarrassment to National.
I don’t think Key will be relieved, I dont think he was worried to begin with. And I’m not sure where you’re suggesting these knives were being drawn from?
Tories are like sharks. If one starts to bleed, the others attack it.
As for the relative value of a single seat – they know that right now. It is a single seat that will let them sell public assets, sell legislation to casinos, and continue selling New Zealanders down the river.
ianmac
http://www.roymorgan.com/news/polls/2012/4764/
cheers.
Anne 5.1.1.1
13 April 2012 at 10:47 am
“when is it going to start penetrating skulls and being reflected in the polls?”
Your average Kiwi has a skull as thick as a Neanderthal and a brain to match.
Can anyone (rwnj’s excepted) doubt it now?
Lol, Looks like dpf deleted a post:
http://www.kiwiblog.co.nz/2012/04/general_debate_20_april_2012.html#comment-958211
Thread in question was called something like “Occupying mp” and anout about some crap or other, with the commenters all calling Dalziell a drunk and blah blah blah.
Remember that time dpf had a hissy fit when Idiot Savant said a Nat mp was drunk in the house, and I/S apologised and stuff.
Yeah.
Cache
…and an apology post appears…
http://www.kiwiblog.co.nz/2012/04/retraction.html
I didn’t bother soiling my eyeballs by clicking on the links, but I get the impression that Judith Collins should get Leanne Dalziell’s lawyers 🙂
Hehe
There is one problem though. Collins needs to show that Mallard and Little were also talking crap …
I wonder if the slithery one has also retracted his post?
Ok, that apology gets Farrar of the hook. Probably. But where does that leave David Garrett? KB was just the conduit for his outburst. I’m guessing that Dalziell has a far more actionable case than Judith Collins could ever hope to muster on the basis of his repeated and, clearly, unprovable allegations. How many strikes is it now for Garrett?
I read that post yesterday and thought he was taking “a readers email” a bit far. According to Farrar it was beyond scrutiny and 100% accurate. And he was basing all these accusations and things on this “readers email”.
A judgment based solely on the prosecution is a worthless judgment.
worthless ..,
and now sheesh you should that old horse david garrett going crazy. what a cesspit – stinky stinky bleeaargh …
I wonder if the “reader” who sent the “email” is a mate of “Bill and Mary Smith” 😀
Ta-Nehisi Coates: The Blacks and the Conservatives and his follow-up post: Racism vs. the Race Card. The video in his second post is well worth the watch.
I find myself up late and working – what’s everyone talking about? It always helps me get my work done quicker ha..
I know – that milford dart tunnel. Gotta get more and faster – its the only way. But once there is more and faster and it all settles down, how are they going to get even morer and even fasterer? That’s what I would like to know because I don’t think they have actually thought about that. Or rather, they dont really care about that. It’s all just a good capital making exercise.
No reply button under this little gem, and I can’t remember who said it now, as every man and his dog seems to have decided to get in on the more-atheist-than-you act… 😀
I am not a fundamentalist, therefore I don’t speak in tongues, but that doesn’t even matter as whoever said it was typing one handed, he was so in love with his own cleverness
I don’t go in for effing and blinding, and insults, as I don’t see the need. Pity you do!
For whoever it was said he was taking his son to Armageddon, all I can say it, I hope my son doesn’t meet you there, and that you can’t identify him… He’s an atheist right now, but things like facts don’t stop you men when you’re on a roll making with the ‘cleverness’!
It was me who mentioned my son, because you claimed he doesn’t exist. Just another thing you were wrong about in this thread.
Other things you were wrong about includes how the religious education in schools program operates. Contra what you were saying, it isn’t at all limited to ten minutes before school, and it often is in the middle of the day, for uop to an hour a week. These facts were noted in the story linked to in the comment that started the discussion.
Aside from that your comments have mainly been that evryone else must be lying about their experiences because , umm, you can vouch for how all christians in NZ would act, because you know some, and everyone else here just gets their views about Christians from the TV. Or something.
And by the way, speaking in tongues is a pentacostal thing, not all pentacostalists are fundamentalist, and by an even greater stretch nor are all fundamentalists are pentacostal.