The Canterbury rebuild

Written By: - Date published: 11:58 am, July 9th, 2015 - 20 comments
Categories: blogs, christchurch earthquake, democratic participation, disaster, Gerry Brownlee, national, same old national - Tags:

Christchurch and the West Coast-1

Canterbury’s rebuild has been going on for a number of years now.  The country’s economy has benefitted.  Without the disaster it is likely the economy would have slipped into recession a while ago.  But rebuilding a major urban area after the trauma and disaster of multiple earthquakes should not be the basis for an economic policy.  And you have to wonder what sort of country we live in when expensive convention centres can be planned but locals do not have enough blankets.

I spent a bit of time walking around the city recently.  Things are improving.  Cathedral Square is again accessible and people obviously want to again make it a gathering point.  Nearby there is a neat pop up market where the shops are constructed out of containers and good food and coffee and interesting things can be bought.  But the signs of devastation are still clear even though some of the anchor projects are well under way.

A recent post by Barnaby Bennett has attracted a lot of attention.  He is a director of Freerange Press (www.projectfreerange.com), has edited two books about the rebuild (Christchurch: The Transitional City and Once in a lifetime: City-building after disaster in Christchurch).  He obviously has some expertise and some understanding and clearly has spent a lot of time thinking and writing about the rebuild.

His latest post Yeah yeah yeah, nah Minister: Why Brownlee is unfit to lead the recovery needs to be read in full.  And recent Government decisions about the rebuild perfectly amplify what he has written.  The announcement of the formation of Regenerate Canterbury and the disestablishment of CERA is as clear an admission of failure as you could hope for.

Bennett sets out ten clear reasons why Brownlee should not be in charge of the rebuild.  These include Brownlee attacking others rather than acknowledging mistakes, his misleading of the public over things such as the potential rebuild cost of the town hall, his inability to work with others and his quickness to bully them, the farce over the proposed convention centre, his disdain for the city’s heritage, his lack of engagement with the city, his failure to understand how the rebuild could be ecologically focussed, his failure to make decisions in a timely manner, that he thinks EQC has performed well and last but not least because he does not understand what makes a city function properly.

This is a quick grab of the essence of Bennett’s article but as I said read the whole post to get a more comprehensive understanding of what is going wrong.

To emphasise the state of the relationship between Christchurch City Council and Brownlee two councillors liked Barnaby’s article on Facebook but after some publicity in the Christchurch Press both councillors removed the post from their facebooks.  Their response I found quite unsettling because they said the post was thought provoking and the contends needed discussion and clearly this is true.  I guess the disdain the Government has for democracy in Canterbury is cause for them to be concerned.

Politicians ought to be able to criticise each other publicly.  Councillors ought to be able to disagree with Ministers without fear.  And Bennett’s critiques of Brownlee’s performance ought to be subject to the most public examination possible.  Democracies function better that way.

20 comments on “The Canterbury rebuild ”

  1. IMO local government in NZ has been hamstrung for decades by :
    the constraints on how councils can raise funds and being largely reliant on local rates, i.e. very little central tax revenue is devolved to them;
    what councils are allowed to spend rates on, which is mostly focussed on compliance with central government generated laws;
    the contract culture and the uncritical acceptance of the pre-eminence of private enterprise with no accounting of the long term social costs of what businesses do;
    the notion of an easily defined and administered management/governance split;
    the mechanism by which public sector pay rates for CEOs and senior management are set and the insistence that they have to match the private sector;
    and,
    a deliberately fostered lack of transparency around the political affiliations of people standing for council election which tends to benefit the Right more than the Left.

    ECAN was sacked in the interests of big business – that much is so obvious it’s only the terminally stupid or the profoundly ideological who seek to deny it. The subsequent natural disaster was cynically used by Key’s government to entrench – and then to widen and deepen – its direct control over the city and the province.

    The most astonishing thing about what has happened and is continuing to happen in NZ’s second city and the province of Canterbury, is how little opposition there is to it – both from those it directly affects and from the rest of the country which is also affected by this calculated erosion of democracy.

  2. dukeofurl 2

    Interesting points that Bennett makes, but this surprises me :

    “Christchurch can, and probably will, become a city that learnt from the quakes about how to live closer to nature, about to grow healthy food, and to live with the habitats we share”
    Its preposterous he can say ‘grow healthy food’ – after learning from the earthquake.

    I bet the guy has never been – a like Brownlee- to any of the regional market gardens where the ‘unhealthy’ food comes from.

    Just what exactly being closer to nature means, I suppose having the liquefaction silt inside your house means that ‘next time its just a natural process that we can embrace’

    Being a hard green means that a lot of Bennetts observations are lost for others looking for local feedback.

    • mickysavage 2.1

      Why is that? All modern cities should aim for self sufficiency in food. And the Canterbury Plains ought to be able to provide a wide variety of different sorts of foods.

      I would not call Bennett a hard green, just someone looking into the future.

      • Colonial Viper 2.1.1

        Why is that? All modern cities should aim for self sufficiency in food.

        And this was precisely the idea behind the original “quarter acre section” concept.

        • dukeofurl 2.1.1.1

          So no carrots from Ohakune then ? Pukekohe has moved up the scale to higher value greens.

          Isnt this all very elitist , local kale, local wine, local chocolate

          And then there is butter !

          • greywarshark 2.1.1.1.1

            Try to think wider dukeofurl. For example how NZ imports so much of its basic requirements which it used to make for itself, using local labour, but now we are now dependent on supplies from overseas, like those of the ‘cargo culture’ of some Pacific islands after WW2.

            Also it has been pointed out by people who think wider that most people have enough food and water for only about three days. Don’t you think it might be an intelligent way to prepare for challenging times ahead, to have available food growing near to a city? Importing some things, but having a good supply of basics grown locally, using local labour. It seems logical doesn’t it.

            And then thinking wider still, the understanding of why we are in an employment poor, poverty for many, high overseas debt situation in NZ. Not so different to Greece, but while we can pay our interest bills, no-one is going to confront us with the dirty truth.

  3. Capn Insano 3

    Regenerate Canterbury doesn’t need a degenerate like Brownlee involved.

    • Chooky 3.1

      +100 to that …Christchurch is the poorer for having had Brownlee in charge

      …and great Post

  4. G C 4

    Gerry Brownlee and the Christchurch City Council by all accounts harbour harsh feelings towards each-other.

    Either the CCC needs ousting or Minister Brownlee. I imagine this strained working relationship could turn toxic quick. National seem to be backing Brownlee though, so the CCC is in for a shake up.

    Local body elections aren’t far away. Cantabrians are known for giving Councillors a chance AND punishing Councillors for lacklustre performance. If the National government embarks on a stimulus package, it would be prudent so send some down here. I’m sure such stimulus could massage some tensions.

    • Mark 4.1

      There is not much you got right in that post. The previous council headed by Sir “sideshow” Bob was absolutely hopeless and was dealt to at the last local boby elections. This council headed by Lianne Dalziel are performing as well as they can in the circumstances and have made a lot of progress and you hear few if any complaints against them down here. Billy Bunter Brownlee on the other hand is just an old fashioned bully and has had a bad last few months with several of his pet projects in trouble. Any attempt to sideline the council down here will be the last straw for a lot of people and won’t be accepted.

      • G C 4.1.1

        I’m in Christchurch also Mark, certainly Sideshow Bob’s Council got kicked to the curb. There are more new City Councillors than returning Councillors sitting on the City Council today.

        I didn’t mention Lianne Dalziel, though she has been known to be missing from events Gerry Brownlee attends. Moonlighting inside the City Council has been an on-going concern. Also disloyalty within the ranks can be seen when reading between the lines. Gerry Brownlee is no saint either though.

        They’re all mucking through nicely, however there is room and need for improvement. I’m certainly not sold on the Lianne Dalziel & Gerry Brownlee combo.

        • Mark 4.1.1.1

          I don’t know what lines you are reading between but you need to get some new specs.
          Gerry is having a terrible run and has been more pig headed than normal lately if thats possible. If it comes to a full on brawl between Dalziel and Brownlee then Billy Bunter is in trouble. This council has a big chance of being re-elected on its performance todate and any attempt to sideline either the council or Dalziel will be the straw that breaks the camels back for many in Christchurch.

          • G C 4.1.1.1.1

            I vote in the local body elections and will vote for who I believe the best candidates are. If Lianne Dalziel and Gerry Brownlee have a “full on brawl” or can’t work together, of course that will reflect in my decision making. I’ll vote for the best Mayoral candidate at the time.

            Gerry Browning might be “pig headed” yet sometimes “pig headed” gets the job done. You say the council are performing well, yet acknowledge Lianne Dalziel and Gerry Brownlee could have a “full on brawl”.

            CCC has advisers, CEO’s, paid consultants, general stuff, etc. Voting for different City Councillors or Mayoral candidates wont make Christchurch fall to pieces. Scare Tactics.

            • Mark 4.1.1.1.1.1

              Anyone who thinks Billy Bunter has done a good job of the Christchurch rebuild has had their head up their arse for 4 1/2 years or else lives in areas unaffected by the useless dictator.
              Best of luck voting for someone other than Dalziel but the job is hers for as long as she wants it.
              But if that fat fuckwit Billy Bunter tries to sideline her and the council, the shit will well and truly hit the fan in this town.

              • G C

                All the candidates I voted for in the last Local Body Election took office – including Lianne Dalziel. I’m not saying Gerry Brownlee is the best person for the job – I’m saying he looks set to keep the job.

                One thing about Lianne Dalziel, after the earthquakes she was out in public helping people. That’s not a media report, that’s from eye-whiteness, people I know. That speaks volumes.

                There is heaps of construction and innovation happening here in Christchurch. It would be a lie to say “Gerry Brownlee hasn’t done ANY good work”. Put it this way though, I don’t hold your strong disdain for Gerry Brownlee against you.

      • greywarshark 4.1.2

        Did you mean ‘local booby elections’? You seem to have some good ones down there so perhaps you are on the winning side with the local body.

  5. Pat 5

    you mean theyre going to start the rebuild in Christchurch now?….well about time

    • ropata 5.1

      They don’t want to rush it. Got to keep house prices bubbling along for the well heeled Nat voters of Merivale.

  6. Stuart Munro 6

    Christchurch is not where it should be and feeling the cold. Brownlee is pretty much an archetypical fat cat, and not a charm school graduate on his best day. Dalziel may be ok, but the return of Vicki Buck has not gone unmarked by those who remember probably the best period of local government in Christchurch history. Gerry is on black ice.

  7. Yes a new name is needed.

    Gerrygate. Cos a man named Gerry is presiding over one of the biggest scandal’s in New Zealand history: the mangling of the revival of New Zealand’s second city.

    No one would sit still if this was Auckland (presumably post-eruption x years from now). But down here in Canterbury where a National social experiment is grinding through its fifth year, its quite okay because people still believe the smiling assassin and his woodwork teacher mate are good sods.

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

  • Ministers visit Hawke’s Bay to grasp recovery needs
    Prime Minister Christopher Luxon joined Cyclone Recovery Minister Mark Mitchell and Transport and Local Government Minister Simeon Brown, to meet leaders of cyclone and flood-affected regions in the Hawke’s Bay. The visit reinforced the coalition Government’s commitment to support the region and better understand its ongoing requirements, Mr Mitchell says.  ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 hours ago
  • New Zealand condemns malicious cyber activity
    New Zealand has joined the UK and other partners in condemning malicious cyber activity conducted by the Russian Government, Minister Responsible for the Government Communications Security Bureau Judith Collins says. The statement follows the UK’s attribution today of malicious cyber activity impacting its domestic democratic institutions and processes, as well ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    12 hours ago
  • Disestablishment of Te Pūkenga begins
    The Government has begun the process of disestablishing Te Pūkenga as part of its 100-day plan, Minister for Tertiary Education and Skills Penny Simmonds says.  “I have started putting that plan into action and have met with the chair and chief Executive of Te Pūkenga to advise them of my ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 day ago
  • Climate Change Minister to attend COP28 in Dubai
    Climate Change Minister Simon Watts will be leaving for Dubai today to attend COP28, the 28th annual UN climate summit, this week. Simon Watts says he will push for accelerated action towards the goals of the Paris Agreement, deliver New Zealand’s national statement and connect with partner countries, private sector leaders ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 day ago
  • New Zealand to host 2024 Pacific defence meeting
    Defence Minister Judith Collins yesterday announced New Zealand will host next year’s South Pacific Defence Ministers’ Meeting (SPDMM). “Having just returned from this year’s meeting in Nouméa, I witnessed first-hand the value of meeting with my Pacific counterparts to discuss regional security and defence matters. I welcome the opportunity to ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 day ago
  • Study shows need to remove distractions in class
    The Government is committed to lifting school achievement in the basics and that starts with removing distractions so young people can focus on their learning, Education Minister Erica Stanford says.   The 2022 PISA results released this week found that Kiwi kids ranked 5th in the world for being distracted ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 day ago
  • Minister sets expectations of Commissioner
    Today I met with Police Commissioner Andrew Coster to set out my expectations, which he has agreed to, says Police Minister Mark Mitchell. Under section 16(1) of the Policing Act 2008, the Minister can expect the Police Commissioner to deliver on the Government’s direction and priorities, as now outlined in ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • New Zealand needs a strong and stable ETS
    New Zealand needs a strong and stable Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS) that is well placed for the future, after emission units failed to sell for the fourth and final auction of the year, Climate Change Minister Simon Watts says.  At today’s auction, 15 million New Zealand units (NZUs) – each ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • PISA results show urgent need to teach the basics
    With 2022 PISA results showing a decline in achievement, Education Minister Erica Stanford is confident that the Coalition Government’s 100-day plan for education will improve outcomes for Kiwi kids.  The 2022 PISA results show a significant decline in the performance of 15-year-old students in maths compared to 2018 and confirms ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Collins leaves for Pacific defence meeting
    Defence Minister Judith Collins today departed for New Caledonia to attend the 8th annual South Pacific Defence Ministers’ meeting (SPDMM). “This meeting is an excellent opportunity to meet face-to-face with my Pacific counterparts to discuss regional security matters and to demonstrate our ongoing commitment to the Pacific,” Judith Collins says. ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Working for Families gets cost of living boost
    Putting more money in the pockets of hard-working families is a priority of this Coalition Government, starting with an increase to Working for Families, Prime Minister Christopher Luxon says. “We are starting our 100-day plan with a laser focus on bringing down the cost of living, because that is what ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Post-Cabinet press conference
    Most weeks, following Cabinet, the Prime Minister holds a press conference for members of the Parliamentary Press Gallery. This page contains the transcripts from those press conferences, which are supplied by Hansard to the Office of the Prime Minister. It is important to note that the transcripts have not been edited ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Lake Onslow pumped hydro scheme scrapped
    The Government has axed the $16 billion Lake Onslow pumped hydro scheme championed by the previous government, Energy Minister Simeon Brown says. “This hugely wasteful project was pouring money down the drain at a time when we need to be reining in spending and focussing on rebuilding the economy and ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • NZ welcomes further pause in fighting in Gaza
    New Zealand welcomes the further one-day extension of the pause in fighting, which will allow the delivery of more urgently-needed humanitarian aid into Gaza and the release of more hostages, Foreign Minister Winston Peters said. “The human cost of the conflict is horrific, and New Zealand wants to see the violence ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Condolences on passing of Henry Kissinger
    Foreign Minister Winston Peters today expressed on behalf of the New Zealand Government his condolences to the family of former US Secretary of State Henry Kissinger, who has passed away at the age of 100 at his home in Connecticut. “While opinions on his legacy are varied, Secretary Kissinger was ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Backing our kids to learn the basics
    Every child deserves a world-leading education, and the Coalition Government is making that a priority as part of its 100-day plan. Education Minister Erica Stanford says that will start with banning cellphone use at school and ensuring all primary students spend one hour on reading, writing, and maths each day. ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • US Business Summit Speech – Regional stability through trade
    I would like to begin by echoing the Prime Minister’s thanks to the organisers of this Summit, Fran O’Sullivan and the Auckland Business Chamber.  I want to also acknowledge the many leading exporters, sector representatives, diplomats, and other leaders we have joining us in the room. In particular, I would like ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Keynote Address to the United States Business Summit, Auckland
    Good morning. Thank you, Rosemary, for your warm introduction, and to Fran and Simon for this opportunity to make some brief comments about New Zealand’s relationship with the United States.  This is also a chance to acknowledge my colleague, Minister for Trade Todd McClay, Ambassador Tom Udall, Secretary of Foreign ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • India New Zealand Business Council Speech, India as a Strategic Priority
    Good morning, tēnā koutou and namaskar. Many thanks, Michael, for your warm welcome. I would like to acknowledge the work of the India New Zealand Business Council in facilitating today’s event and for the Council’s broader work in supporting a coordinated approach for lifting New Zealand-India relations. I want to also ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Coalition Government unveils 100-day plan
    Prime Minister Christopher Luxon has laid out the Coalition Government’s plan for its first 100 days from today. “The last few years have been incredibly tough for so many New Zealanders. People have put their trust in National, ACT and NZ First to steer them towards a better, more prosperous ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • New Zealand welcomes European Parliament vote on the NZ-EU Free Trade Agreement
    A significant milestone in ratifying the NZ-EU Free Trade Agreement (FTA) was reached last night, with 524 of the 705 member European Parliament voting in favour to approve the agreement. “I’m delighted to hear of the successful vote to approve the NZ-EU FTA in the European Parliament overnight. This is ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 weeks ago

Page generated in The Standard by Wordpress at 2023-12-08T07:07:52+00:00