web analytics

UK government signals urgent inquiry into overmedicalisation of gender non-conforming children

Written By: - Date published: 11:24 am, April 24th, 2022 - 40 comments
Categories: feminism, gender, gender critical feminism, health - Tags: , , ,

One of a number of things around gender identity ideology unravelling in the UK at the moment. I’ll preface this post with stating clearly that the problem here is not trans people, but the gender identity activism which has forced so many changes on society without adequate examination. In this case, it’s the surgical and hormonal treatment of children. From the Times on Friday,

The health secretary thinks the system is “failing children” and is planning an overhaul of how health service staff deal with under-18s who question their gender identity.

Javid is understood to have likened political sensitivities over gender dysphoria to the fears of racism in Rotherham over grooming gangs.

(The Rotherham reference is to a child sexual abuse scandal in the UK that ran for years because of sexism, and the fears of people in positions of power too afraid to talk about the perpetrators who were from an ethnic minority).

The context for Javid’s announcement,

  • the number of children presenting at gender clinics in the UK has increased exponentially in the past decade.
  • this includes a substantial increase in gender non-conforming girls being referred.
  • the clinics, and wider NHS, GP, and psychology/psychiatric services have used, or been forced to use, the ‘affirmation only’ approach advocated by gender identity lobbyists and activists. This is the practice of affirming a child’s verbal expression of their gender identity. If a boy says the are a girl, or a girl says they are boy, then they are to be believed and treated as if this is real and permanent.
  • Affirmation only has meant that other issues the child may be dealing with have been ignored or inadequately addressed eg sexual or physical abuse, eating disorders, depression, mental illness, the physical and emotional distress of puberty, and the increasing societal pressures to be gender conforming (including sexism and misogyny leading to girls believing their lives would be better if they were boys). A significant number of the children are autistic.
  • Instead of looking at the whole child and their environment, affirmation only narrows treatment options to the single path of transition. Social transition, hormonal treatments (puberty blockers, and later cross sex hormones), and eventual surgery.

Whistleblower Sue Evans, a nurse at Gender Identity Development Service at the Tavistock and Portman NHS Trust in London, first raised concerns in 2004 about the fast tracking of GNC children into medical and surgical treatment. She was ignored and left the service.

When Evans started at the Tavistock in 2003, she was “proud to be working in a tiny team at a pioneering organisation”. But on hearing a colleague describe how, after only a few assessments, they had referred a distressed 16-year-old boy who thought of himself as female for hormone treatment, her “jaw dropped”. She recalls feeling “something was very, very wrong with the GIDS approach”.

In her early years as a psychiatric nurse, she had witnessed treatments, such as electroconvulsive therapy, that are now widely condemned: “I know enough of the history of psychiatry to always be cautious about intervention.”

Evans had assumed she would be able to use her psychotherapeutic skills to support the scores of children referred each year. When she raised the possibility of alternatives to medication, Evans was advised the service would not have any patients without the offer of puberty blockers. Last year, GIDS had 2,590 children referred for them, compared with 77 patients a decade ago.

(it’s generally accepted that a small number of children may need medical intervention, but that most need other kinds of support until they mature enough to make decisions about medical pathway treatments. There’s a lot of debate about the research, and we probably don’t have enough yet, but there are studies that show that most children/teens who say they are the opposite sex later desist and continue life as their biological sex).

In the intervening years mostly women, often grass roots, have been working hard to get the issue looked at. Many women who do this work publicly face abuse, threats, and doxing, and risk job and career loss.

Detrans women (who transitioned as girls, but later regretted this or realised their gender dysphoria was still the same) have been organising and lobbying. Often under intense social pressure to stfu from trans activists and allies, their cause has been marginalised by rhetoric of them being very small in number, or that they weren’t really trans in the first place, or they were trans and didn’t have enough support so they’re not really detrans. GIDS don’t provide services for detrans children/teens.

Keira Bell was referred to GIDS at 15 and put on puberty blockers when she was 16. The following year she was given the cross sex hormone testosterone, and when she was 20 she had a double mastectomy,

But the further my transition went, the more I realized that I wasn’t a man, and never would be. We are told these days that when someone presents with gender dysphoria, this reflects a person’s “real” or “true” self, that the desire to change genders is set. But this was not the case for me. As I matured, I recognized that gender dysphoria was a symptom of my overall misery, not its cause.

Five years after beginning my medical transition to becoming male, I began the process of detransitioning. A lot of trans men talk about how you can’t cry with a high dose of testosterone in your body, and this affected me too: I couldn’t release my emotions. One of the first signs that I was becoming Keira again was that—thankfully, at last—I was able to cry. And I had a lot to cry about.

The consequences of what happened to me have been profound: possible infertility, loss of my breasts and inability to breastfeed, atrophied genitals, a permanently changed voice, facial hair. When I was seen at the Tavistock clinic, I had so many issues that it was comforting to think I really had only one that needed solving: I was a male in a female body. But it was the job of the professionals to consider all my co-morbidities, not just to affirm my naïve hope that everything could be solved with hormones and surgery.

Bell took Tavistock and Portman NHS Foundation Trust(who run GIDS) to Judicial Review in front of three high court judges in 2020, arguing that the Trust had failed to protect children and teens and that its practice was essentially and experiment. The judges found in Bell’s favour unanimously. (PDF of judgement). Bell gives an explanation of this and the wider culture here.

Of particular note is that GIDS weren’t keeping records of what they were doing and weren’t doing adequate follow up.

Another group that has been working to get this issue addressed is parents. Seven years ago Stephanie Davies-Arai set up Transgender Trend, an organisation of parents, professionals and academics looking at issues of self-ID, ROGD (rapid onset gender dysphoria often associated with social contagion on social media), legislative and social changes affecting girls and young women in regards to sex and gender. The website is a clearing house for the various and interlocking issues, and it’s been instrumental in presenting information and analysis that most of the mainstream media ignored for many years.

One of the consequences of the Bell case, and gender critical activism, has been the Cass Review, an independent review commissioned by the NHS which released its interim report in February. From the Observer’s editorial statement on on gender identity services for children,

The Cass review’s interim report finds children with gender identity issues are ill served by adults who shut down debate

The report highlights a profound lack of evidence and medical consensus about the best approach to treating gender dysphoria in children.

This report has led to the UK government to launch the urgent inquiry, which is to be integrated into the ongoing Cass Review. From Transgender Trend’s response to the announcement,

The Times reports that Javid is also preparing legal changes that would give Hilary Cass access to an NHS database of children treated by the service to see how many later regretted taking puberty-blockers and cross-sex hormones.

The politicisation of a childhood condition and adolescent identity development has led to catastrophic failings in the health system’s duty of care to children. An ideological system based on faith rather than facts and evidence has led to numerous children and young people being harmed irreversibly by the medical profession. The independent Cass Review has shone a light on a medical experiment on children that was previously obscured by dogma and an adult political agenda.

The consequences of giving one group of diverse children the simplistic political label ‘transgender’ has led to an unquestioning acceptance of a child’s self-diagnosis by the health profession and a complete abdication of duty to provide normal standards of paediatric care. We are grateful that Sajid Javid has listened to Cass and we hope that the days of listening to activist groups on the subject of healthcare for children are well and truly over.

The question here is why GIDS has such complete ideological capture. This is another whole post, which rests largely on why progressives have uncritically adopted gender identity ideology and the degree to which well funded lobbyists have been successful (especially Stonewall UK and Mermaids).

Of particular concern here is the No Debate position taken by gender identity activists. This has been phenomenally successful at shutting down debate, in large part by attacking people who speak up, calling them bigots and using social media and other social pressures to marginalise and deter them. This includes within many institutions in the UK, where academics and medical professionals are afraid to say anything other than the gender ideology lines. The people that have broken that have faced extreme pressure, abuse, “shocking levels of vilification and attempts to undermine their professional integrity” and sometimes lost their jobs. The left has largely sat by and let this happen, where it wasn’t been actively endorsing and supporting it.

If women in particular had been free to raise concerns and we had had the debates on the left, then the problems with organisations like GIDS would have been addressed in the first years. It’s taken nearly 20 years to blow this open enough for appropriate institutions to begin to mend what has happened, and I expect it will take a number of more years due to the ideological capture and the less powerful but still functional No Debate.

I don’t know the state of play in New Zealand with affirmation only (no doubt there will be comments and links below on this). I do know that No Debate functions here as well, that the left is largely complicit in this, and that we still don’t have the freedom to debate without censure or risk. The government has at least twice done major legislative and policy changes where it explicitly didn’t consult women’s groups, and no platforming has attempted to shut down public meetings. The government appears intent on replacing sex with gender identity as the default within policy and legislation. People are afraid to speak out, and the Greens and Labour have inhibited debate within their parties.

These are complex issues. Obviously transgender people need protection and their human rights upheld just like everyone else. I trust gender critical feminists and detrans women as the groups that will work for the rights and wellbeing of both trans and women, while large parts of the left hold to the idea that women are bigots if they talk about a conflict of rights. I also at this point trust the UK tory government more than I do UK Labour/Greens or NZ Labour/Greens on issues of overmedicalisation. I hope NZ proves me wrong.

40 comments on “UK government signals urgent inquiry into overmedicalisation of gender non-conforming children ”

  1. Molly 1

    Thanks, weka.

    Well outlined post in response to UK's latest announcement.

    The ideological capture is one that can be partly explained by the tactics outlined in the Denton's document, reported in The Spectator by James Upkirk.

    (Archived copy here: https://t.co/6nRi9PHXO4)

    "As you’d expect of a report co-written by the staff of a major law firm, it’s a comprehensive and solid document, summarising law, policy and 'advocacy' across several countries. Based on the contributions of trans groups from around the world (including two in the UK, one of which is not named), it collects and shares 'best practice' in 'lobbying' to change the law so that parents no longer have a say on their child’s legal gender.

    In the words of the report:

    “'It is recognised that the requirement for parental consent or the consent of a legal guardian can be restrictive and problematic for minors.'

    You might think that the very purpose of parenting is, in part, to 'restrict' the choices of children who cannot, by definition, make fully-informed adult choices on their own. But that is not the stance of the report."

    For those following this issue, the dismantling of the parent-child relationship by accusations of owners-property is common. This is reinforced in education policies that transition children without parent's input or knowledge, and by organisations and individuals that deem any parental questioning or concerns as abusive.

    Hence the proliferation of people like this on social media:

    With good intentions, people have accepted that in this one area – people (including children) can self-diagnose, pick from a set menu of options and treatments – and no robust or exploratory scrutiny is required.

    As gender ideologists pushed for breaking boundaries, and ever widening expansion of parameters, and unquestioning medical treatment, the systems that are meant to protect us all from iatrogenic harm, and maintain appropriate safeguards stood aside.

    In NZ, we have the equivalent methods and institutional capture. #NoDebate has been much more successful here with our limited media offerings – in print, broadcasting and online. But the voices are still there, asking to be heard.

    The recently added Relationships and Sexuality Curriculum is an unnecessary adjunct to the curriculum in terms of knowledge, but was required to introduce the gender ideology concepts to students at primary, intermediate and secondary school level.'

    I've posted on this before, most recently yesterday, but have added excerpt here to keep thread on topic:

    For those unaware, the TKI guidelines set out the curriculum for all primary and secondary students in NZ. They specify what learning outcomes are needed, to meet curriculum requirements. Curriculum resources can therefore be created by teachers, schools or purchased from third-party organisations.

    https://hpe.tki.org.nz/guidelines-and-policies/relationships-and-sexuality-education/

    Guidelines can be found here on this page for both primary and secondary students as a pdf download.

    There is a lot to unpick – and justifiably critique in these documents – but the one relevant to this point can be found in both documents (Pg 30 of Yrs 1-8 guide):

    In science, ākonga can:

    • consider variations in puberty, including the role of hormone blockers

    This means that every child within the NZ education system is introduced to the idea – (and due to the diversity of curriculum that can be taught we have no idea how) – that puberty is something that can reasonably be avoided, and puberty blockers are the method to do so.

    Our Ministry of Health follows "gender affirming health care" for transgender NZers, including children. (Without getting into details, note that "gender affirming healthcare" is a pre-determined diagnosis and treatment, not equal to quality healthcare).

    https://www.health.govt.nz/your-health/healthy-living/transgender-new-zealanders/transgender-new-zealanders-children-and-young-people

    Puberty blockers

    For young people where these feelings continue into puberty or emerge during puberty, particularly if associated with distress, it is important to see a health professional. Puberty blockers are a medication that can be used to halt the physical changes of an unwanted puberty.

    Blockers are a safe and fully reversible medicine that may be used from early puberty through to later adolescence to help ease distress and allow time to fully explore gender health options.

    Service providers that can help access blockers include:

    • paediatric services
    • youth health services
    • endocrinologists
    • primary health care teams.

    Late to the party, and staying for the hangover. NZ education normalises the idea of delayed puberty, while offering – without reserve – off-label medications that have no robust clinical evidence of benefit.

    I think part of the institutional capture is the use of individuals that belong to certain communities as unchallenged authors of documents that are used for policy.

    There is a temerity not associated with robust process, that comes from a discomfort with questioning the assertions or demands of someone who belongs to a recognised marginalised community. That is a possibility.

    (I have suspicions that the same is happening in Maturanga Maori changes in the curriculum. To my mind, this is disrespectful to both the institution and the community they wish to include).

    I hope that people will be writing to both the Ministry of Health, and the Ministry of Education regarding these points.

    I haven't met a convincing argument about why "affirming health care only" is an achievement. I also haven't found a response to why the state is paying for what is essentially cosmetic surgery if the reality of gender identity is innate, and not a medical disorder.

    And despite looking for it, I – like many others, including countries apparently – have found no conclusive evidence that the social, medical and surgical transition of children has net benefits – either long or short term.

    • Molly 1.1

      There is also a lot of grants, monies and scholarships and employment opportunities for those involved in Diversity Inclusion consultations, workshops, programmes and organisations.

      Companies and government departments inviting in external advisors, are unlikely to then robustly critique any information provided. That's one of the recognised problems of outsourcing, your quality control is limited, and sometimes impossible to maintain.

    • weka 1.2

      the boundary breaking stuff really needs examining. Just been listening to JCJ talking about this with Helen Staniland. Jones talks about the ideological drive to remove all boundaries and social norms as a core principle of queer theory.

      It's hard to explain to liberals, because of course why wouldn't we want to challenge norms?! JCJ's point is that we should be looking at the boundaries, seeing which are useful, which aren't, why and how we want to change them.

      No Debate allows creepy vibe guys like Jeffrey to be promoting the idea that queer culture is inherently trustworthy and parent's aren't. There's also something odd about the position that trans kids all come from families where they're not accepted, and the solution to that is to create separation between parents and children.

      Then we have queer culture doing dildo butt monkey and Family Sex Show with kids, and some wonder why there's a conservative backlash.

      Will try and find the time stamp later.

    • weka 1.3

      I haven't met a convincing argument about why "affirming health care only" is an achievement. I also haven't found a response to why the state is paying for what is essentially cosmetic surgery if the reality of gender identity is innate, and not a medical disorder.

      If 'trans' is a range of experiences, some of which are gender dysphoric, then I can see why body modification is part of public health. But like other extreme interventions, it's about how and why it's used.

      Of course, the ideology wants trans to be one thing, a big umbrella, and looking at the detail is frowned upon. That some trans women are gender dysphoric males from childhood, and some are AGP, for instance, would enable a much more nuance public debate about the impact on women's rights.

      Trying to have it both ways.

  2. Molly 2

    One unmentioned aspect of the gender ideology that is repeatedly messaged to children and young people, is that they will be universally rejected by society, their families and anyone not in the transgender community.

    How is this healthy? How is the suicidal ideation not criticised or rejected?

    [image resized]

    • weka 2.1

      imagine thinking continually telling anyone, let alone kids, that they're not safe is a good idea.

      there's been a lot of good critique about the breaching of guidelines around how we talk about suicide.

      • Molly 2.1.1

        The effects of hormones (or lack of) on mental health is another really interesting topic to delve into.

        We can look at suicide stats and research for menopausal women to attempt to find a basic understanding:

        https://www.hippocraticpost.com/womens-health/suicide-rates-in-menopausal-women-up-6/

        Suicide statistics for women with peri-menopause, and menopause are significant.

        Suicide rates among women aged 45 to 54 — the most common age to be experiencing menopause and perimenopause — have risen 6% in the last 20 years, defying a trend for falling rates among older women[1], reveals research by Menopause Experts Group.

        Those aged 45 to 54 have the highest suicide rate among women, with 7.1 deaths per 100,000 females aged 45 to 49, and a rate of 6.9 for 50 to 54-year-olds. By comparison, the rate for 65 to 69-year-olds was only 3.7 per 100,000 in the latest figures.

        Effects of testosterone levels in bi-polar women:

        https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4329970/

        There's quite a lot of research on some of the mental health impacts of suppressed or elevated hormone levels.

        • weka 2.1.1.1

          have you come across international stats on women, menopause and suicide? Because not all cultures experience menopause the same way, and some cultures give women major negatives messaging about growing older.

          Not to dismiss the impact of hormones, I thought Bell's sharing of what it was like to not cry and then cry was really important.

          Interview Page because she's a public figure going through a tough experience, but putting someone up with gender dysphoria as if they are a useful expert on healthy GNC is hugely problematic. And Page gets the facts wrong a lot. This is dangerous.

          • Molly 2.1.1.1.1

            Re cultural effect on mental health, the Gusset Grips video was good, where she spoke about avoidable incontinence restricting women's social circles, and how lack of muscle control and vaginal atrophy affected sex lives, and sometimes created distance with long-time partners that lead to separation. All those aspects might play a part in the increase in suicides and decrease in mental health for those age groups.

            I have a memory of a television interview when Viagra was introduced. A person on there was saying that aside from known heart damage for men, they wondered about the social implications.

            At a time when both partners may have decreasing libido, male partners in a heterosexual relationship now could take a medication to both increase libido and extend performance time. At the same time his partner may be experiencing vaginal dryness, intercourse pain and decreased libido, and so the natural decline of the importance of sex for both would be changed. Not necessarily for the better in terms of the relationship.

            The varying aspects of this would be very interesting to follow up.

  3. I distrust the pharmaco-surgical and symptomatic paradigms that dominate medicine, so a government putting the brakes on these treatments for kids is a good thing in my view but we shouldn't lose sight of all the wider political and economic agendas. If Javid was standing up to his own party on its appalling social policies including the erosion of wider health care and the NHS itself; if he was pointing the finger at the role his party played in creating the situation in the UK today around gender identity – eg address why it was his party under May's leadership which threw the dead cat of GRA review onto the table, and why it has done sod all to date to detoxify the debate….I might be a bit more inclined to view this as a good thing and not have the sneaking suspicion that this is just a bid to win socially conservative votes in advance of the local govt elections May 5.

    • weka 3.1

      yep, and it's not like any of the centre left parties can make that argument.

      I assume it's politicking as well. But I also think it's likely that there are tories who just think what has happened is wrong and needs to be sorted out. I think most people will think that once they understand the issues and facts.

    • Molly 3.2

      Do you mind me asking how much time you have spent looking into these suspicions, TeWhareWhero? Just because I know that with a minimum of effort, you can easily find information from both sides of the discussion, and sift through it all to find coherent arguments and data.

      It's not a good thing that it is the conservatives in England that have called for the review. But as the review is something that should have occurred long ago, every delay may be creating iatrogenic harm that could be avoided. Cannot wait for either Labour support or government, if your concern is for the health and wellbeing of children and young people that identify as transgender.

      Quite easily, you can put the politics aside and read the reviews from governments of the Netherlands, Finland, Sweden, France and the UK Interim Cass Review. The Cass Review is now asking for permission to access the records of all gender patients so they can do the long-term follow up and studies that will inform of outcomes, and help design best practice.

      SEGM – Society for Evidence Based Gender Medicine is a good place to start. It has numerous detractors, but not of the evidence. Of the team, of the team's tweets, etc. Read and assess for yourself.

      There are good articles regarding the transgender market, worth reading and considering. IIRC, Francesca has posted several times on this before and her comments are worth reading.

      Here's two that may provide a jumping off point:

      Constructing the Legal Lie of the Transgender Child – Part I

      Constructing The Legal Lie Of The Transgender Child – Part II

      In my last post, I speculated about why Dentons, the largest law firm in the world, and Reuters, a media, corporate tax, and law conglomerate are interested in constructing (For Free!) the legal lie of “transgender children.”

      In an effort to find answers to anything, my MO is to always #FollowTheMoney. Let’s follow the money trail back from ILGYO, the small LGBT NGO for which Dentons and Reuters collaborated on a guide.

      ILGYO is part of the Transgender Europe network, the largest funding and political apparatus driving the normalization and depathologizing of transgenderism in Europe. It consists of 129 member organizations across Europe and Central Asia in 44 different countries. TGEU is in turn funded hundreds of thousands of dollars by Arcus Foundation, one of the two largest LGBT NGOs in America, whose founder funds his foundation from the profits of his medical supply corporation. So we have a medical corporation worth over 13 billion dollars, whose heir is funding the normalization of transgender children from his own medical fortune. Arcus supports myriad programs across the globe, to drive the idea that children can be the opposite sex, such as Gender Spectrum and GLSEN (whose founder, Kevin Jennings, was brought to Arcus in 2012 as Executive Director).

    • Molly 3.3

      Sorry, may have misread your comment.

      Yes, I too have strong suspicions that the Conservatives are following polling on this matter. I don't care about that, as I believe the inquiry is overdue, and may prevent further harms.

      I despair that the left-wing politicians are not concerned about the evidence at all, and will continue in their political stance thinking also that it is a vote winner.

      As you say this is political posturing.

  4. Sabine 4

    It will be interesting to watch this unfold. Also, on Monday starts the case of Alison Bailey against Stonewall. That too will be interesting to watch.

    Thanks for this post Weka.

    • weka 4.1

      so many active cases in the UK. I wonder if we can list them (and chronologically).

      Not in order, off the top of my head,

      Alison Bailey suing Stonewall.

      Keira Bell, judicial review (she won), and then the appeal (lost parts if it?)

      Maya Forstater, employment tribunal (lost), appeal (won).

      The Labour MP who called Twitter to parliament to hold them account over abuse of GCFs, and the use of the word terf.

      Baroness Nicholson's investigation into single sex wards and the gaslighting of a woman who was raped while in hospital.

      Raquel Rosario Sanchez complaint to her university for not protecting her from bullying and harassment over her GC beliefs (lost, haven't had time yet to look at the judgement).

      Fair Cop case, he won.

      What's happening with the other cases of people arrested for tweets?

      In Canada, the HRT case involving Jessica Yaniv's complaint about not being able to get their balls waxed by beauticians (JY lost, badly). I'll point out here that almost no MSM covered this landmark case, except maybe one right wing media outlet. GCFs live tweeted it.

  5. Anker 5

    Thank you so much Weka, and Molly too for posting and comments.

    hope that many of The Standards readers read this post.

    It remains hard to understand how this ideology has been able to infiltrate our institutions, including education and health. I still find it hard to believe people can think it is o.k. for children to be prescribed these drugs and life alterating surgery. The lack of critical thinking of people, particularly on the left shocks me.

  6. Jan Rivers 6

    Thanks very much for another post with a really solid base of verified information. How long can NZ continue with its Wild West approach to children and gender medicine when other countries are drawing back?

    So far the New Zealand transgender lobby continues as if everything is fine even though New Zealand's practice is more extreme than the UK. I have noted the following ways:

    There are no data kept on puberty blockers usage and the service is highly devolved even to GP and youth practices compared with the UK where it is available only through specialist clinics.

    But they are used 'very freely' up to the age of 20 and prescribing is even begun in some cases where puberty is already complete

    No diagnosis is required. The young person's self-assessment as trans (or even their parent's assessment) is all that is required.

    Mental health conditions nor causative factors have to be investigated prioor to starting treatment. All that is required is that mental health issues are relatively well
    controlled.
    The child can be treated with PBs while not even being able to verbalise that this is what they want. (It is not clear what the NZ guideline means in this respect but presumably it allows for treatment if sex atypical body language or preferences with toys allows them to be construed as "trans".)

    Social transition is encouraged (clothes, hairstyles, oppoisite sex names and pronouns) are encouraged leading to greater likelihood of going onto blockers.

    Apparently there are very high levels of prescribing to confused children compared with some other jurisdications. (The only stats available are from the Christchurch youth clinic (based in a DHB serving a total population of about 1/2 million) where a year ago it was reported that 65 of about 100 (about 65% of referred children) were being prescribed puberty blockers. This compares with the whole of Ireland where 11 children were on blockers (in a total population of 5 million) and the UK where in 2019/20 161 children were prescribed blockers from a referred cohort of more than 2000 or a rate of less than 8% (the 2018 figure was 2519). See Bell vs Tavistock Judgment

    • Molly 6.1

      The situation in NZ is a concern.

      Educational capture, affirming healthcare. Still de-platforming and self censorship in broadcasting and print media making the #NoDebate unnecessary.

      Even here on TS, the high possibility of iatrogenic harm to children and youth is a topic to be ignored. It's been a lesson in left wing politics alright.

    • weka 6.2

      that's shocking Jan. Do you know why we ended up with that degree of usage? I'm guessing the GP pattern varies?

      • Tabletennis 6.2.1

        Thank you for your post Weka. I'm so demoralised as so many women politicians, including ex teachers who you’ll would think they know what a child is.
        have failed to look into the unintended consequences of their policies on minors.
        I'll also mention Suzanne Doig, General Manager Policy group, Internal Affairs, who advised the Government with some sloppy assessment on risk and consequences.

        Apparently MoH has no stats on gender affirming surgeries. If any are done in NZ it's via the private sector with either private money or publicly funded.
        Although the Government has allocated even more money.I believe the intention is to attract surgeons from overseas, to deal with the waiting lists..

        • weka 6.2.1.1

          There was a US doctor (specialist) on twitter today saying that males who take puberty blockers before puberty and then transition have female physiology. This is where we are at.

          • Molly 6.2.1.1.1

            Australian university based endocrinologist who (unconvincingly) spoke last week on SBS episode on transwoman in sport.

            Obviously, thinking she could have done better she then posted a somewhat juvenile thread on Twitter where both her argument and evidence were torn to shreds.

            • weka 6.2.1.1.1.1

              very interesting programme, thanks.

              Do you know what the universal sport option is about? The women who worked on the UK protocol said it's likely to be the future of sport, and that the requirement to define oneself by sex or gender would be removed, probably with modified rules and/or scoring.

              • weka

                around 45m

              • Molly

                I believe they are referring to the guide issued by the UK Sports Council in 2021. One of the commentators was involved with it:

                https://equalityinsport.org/resources/index.html

                From guidance:

                Create additional versions (universal admission)

                A third option for many sports would focus on universal community inclusion which may not require estimation of ability.

                NGBs and SGBs are encouraged to develop a model of their sport in which participation is not dependent on a competitor’s sex or gender, and the classification based on the sex binary is withdrawn for this competition. Registration for these competitions will not require declaration of any determinant beyond entry above a nominal age (this may be above the age of 12, depending on the rules of sport competition and physical contact level). All people, including transgender people who are transitioning, those who do not seek to transition, and those who may de-transition or be gender fluid, should be able to compete within a universal admission policy.

                Sports which are not gender-affected may choose to offer universal admission as the primary form of competition. However, it must be recognised that a universal admission policy may not equate to full participation for many reasons, one of which may be self-exclusion.

                How best to develop a model of this will be based on decisions relating to how a sport manifests being ‘gender-affected’ and whether this relates to level of contact, and hence safety, or whether it is because of the physical nature of competition which is relevant to fairness (or both). Further, an understanding of the role of the competition is important; whether it is purely for recreational participation or whether it offers meaningful competition. For many sports it will be a combination of factors. In keeping with Principle 6 (case-by-case assessment), it is likely to be impractical and invalid for methodology around body type to be instituted for categorisation.

                Sport with a universal admission policy will have modified rules such that it can be played by all people, and for which fairness and safety can be optimised. These models may already exist in some sports. As much as is possible all adults, including disabled people, should be factored into these offerings. Adaptations of rules include non-contact versions of team sports, handicap competitions, modified playing areas or implements/balls, walking versions of team sports, multi-events and non-traditional formats, distances or length of play. Some sports (such as golf) already have an acknowledgement of ‘handicap’, and others have options for such modifications (some running, swimming and cycling events). Modern sports allow opportunities to adapt scoring systems to accommodate a wide range of participants, as practiced in some para sports.

                It is acknowledged that for some NGBs there will not be an option for universal admission, and this includes those sports which are inherently gender-affected due primarily to safety concerns: modifications to remove physical contact may be impractical, and this includes most of the combat sports. However, elements of such sport, such as competitive ‘kata’ in karate, may be appropriate.

    • Psycho Milt 6.3

      All those people who watched the Lake Alice abuse in care enquiry and wondered how people could have just allowed that to happen can stop wondering. They're allowing something similar to happen right now and thinking of themselves as "progressive" for endorsing it.

      • Anker 6.3.1

        100% Psycho Milt

      • weka 6.3.2

        Yep.

        Cross posting from OM, and noting the number of UK people pointing to the Jimmy Saville case and why people were blind. I don't think the Family Sex Show people are paedophiles, but I do think they are blind and complicit in creating a society with less safeguarding, and in this too they get progressive brownie points.

        • Psycho Milt 6.3.2.1

          That case was just bizarre. I'm nothing like as smart as Jane Clare Jones, but you don't have to be a genius to figure out that a social theory based on transgressing social norms (queer theory) is going to run into trouble because some social norms exist for really good reasons. In short, if you don't want people to think you're a paedophile, don't go trying to involve children in adult sexuality.

      • Tabletennis 6.3.3

        Psycho Milt – here is but another example of an unproven medical intervention – the lobotomy, it even won a nobel prize for medicines in 1949.
        It compares itself well with the transmedicine…

        • roblogic 6.3.3.1

          Wow. That was exceptionally powerful. Difficult truths to hear, but should be necessary viewing for anyone engaging this debate. It’s bad medicine driven by a mad social contagion.

          🧵:

  7. Anker 7

    Thanks Jan for an update re NZ. As Weka says shocking that we ended up with this degree of usage. The push to affirm and confirm young peoples gender identity by activists has likely fuelled this situation.

  8. roblogic 8

    Children who buy into this toxic slime are often suffering from psychological trauma, were abused in some way, or have autistic traits. Often very intelligent, but they spend far too much time on devices taking in false narratives espoused by influencers (the worst humans in our culture IMHO). Dysphoria is a defense mechanism of abuse victims where one spends a lot of time in a fantasy world not connected to their physical reality.

    I have been blocked by a few prominent NZ lefty tweeters for contradicting some of their more obnoxious strident claims in defense of trans ideology. The cartoonist Tatsuya Ishida captures the gender crticial position well. Trans activists feel deeply that they are on the progressive side, defending the oppressed, and that a bunch of radical feminists and JKR became horrible bigots overnight. These people are either cognitively limited or sincerely misguided.

    Critics of the new gender ideology sometimes overstep, and no doubt there is occasional bigoted abuse of trans people, which I deplore. However several transgender folks are also critical of the ideological capture of public institutions, cancel culture, doxxing, and denial of reality from the trans-activist radicals.

    • Molly 8.1

      All true, Rob.

      The more I read from transgender authors and allies, there almost seems to be a thread of jingoism there as well. Encouraging others to fight the good fight, and put their bodies on the line in this 'war'.

Leave a Comment

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

  • New Government plan helps support older workers
    Supporting older people to stay in the workforce and transition their skills as they age and their circumstances change is a key part of the new Older Workers Employment Action Plan, Minister for Social Development and Employment Carmel Sepuloni and Minister for Seniors Dr Ayesha Verrall announced today. “The Government ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 hours ago
  • Flora, fauna and communities set to flourish through Jobs for Nature
    An initiative that has provided tourism workers with alternative employment into the lead up to New Zealand’s borders reopening is being extended to ensure staff are retained, Conservation Minister Kiri Allan says. It is one of two projects in the Waikato-Maniapoto to receive funding through the Government’s Jobs for Nature ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 hours ago
  • Supporting communities to prepare for climate impacts
    From today New Zealanders can have their say on a proposed National Adaptation Plan to help communities across the country adapt to the unavoidable impacts of climate change. “Aotearoa will soon have a plan to bring down our emissions and help prevent the worst effects of climate change, but we ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 hours ago
  • Conservation cup win runs in the family
    Wetlands expert and advocate Dr Beverley Clarkson was today presented with New Zealand’s most prestigious conservation award, the Loder Cup by Minister of Conservation Kiri Allan. Dr Clarkson is a plant ecologist based at Manaaki Whenua Landcare Research in Hamilton. She is nationally renowned for her knowledge and championing of ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 hours ago
  • New mask exemption card to remove uncertainty
    People who have genuine reasons for not being able to wear a face mask can access a new personalised exemption card from the end of May, Minister for COVID-19 Response Chris Hipkins and Minister for Disability Issues Carmel Sepuloni announced today. “We know that face masks are a crucial part ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 hours ago
  • Shining a light on unfairness in our tax system
      Victoria University 26 April, 2022   Those coming here expecting announcements of new tax policy will be disappointed. None are being made. We have no secret plan to introduce a CGT nor a wealth tax or a deemed income tax, nor others. The IRD is not doing any work ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 day ago
  • Auckland harbour goes electric
    Auckland harbour ferries are set to get quieter, cleaner and greener, thanks to two new fully-electric ferries for commuters and sightseers to travel on, Minister for Energy and Resources Dr Megan Woods announced today. Auckland Transport will operate the two electric fast ferries across all major inner and mid-harbour services, ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 day ago
  • Helping some of New Zealand’s highest energy users slash their emissions
    Backing 15 big businesses to move away from fossil fuels in their production processes Equal to taking 14,400 cars off the road   $13 million of Government funding matched by $32.66 million from industry Achieves a total of 900,631 t of carbon emissions saved over the project lifetimes The Government is ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 day ago
  • Boosting biggest city’s environment cred
    More than 50 jobs are being created across Tāmaki Makaurau/Auckland with the launch of three new Government-backed initiatives, Conservation Minister Kiri Allan says. “Tāmaki Makaurau has taken quite a hit over the past two years, with the region experiencing longer lockdown restrictions than anywhere else in the country. “Jobs for ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 day ago
  • Celebrating 30 years of Great Walks
    The opening of the 2022-23 Great Walks booking season next week heralds 30 years of epic adventures in our backyard throughout the country, says Minister of Conservation Kiri Allan. Speaking from the Tongariro Northern Circuit,, the Minister acknowledged the importance of the Great Walks for conservation, recreation and tourism in ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 day ago
  • Prime Minister's Speech to Mt Albert Anzac Day Service
    Let me start by saying how wonderful it is to see people up and down the country gathering together in person again this year, in commemoration of Anzac Day. At a time when the global pandemic has so often cancelled public gatherings, it is all the more precious to be ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • Rangiriri Pa trench rebuild shines a light on our shared histories
    The shared nineteenth-century histories of Aotearoa-New Zealand have come to life with the official opening today of one of the most culturally significant sites of the 1860s New Zealand Wars.   The Government-financed rebuild of the Rangiriri Pa Trenches complex in Waikato is the first project completed from a special ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Statement on Cooperation in Agriculture between Japan and New Zealand
    Japan and New Zealand’s strong partnership is built on a long tradition of official and industry engagement, underpinned by our natural complementarities and strong business relationships. Both countries share many similarities. Japan and New Zealand are island nations in the Pacific with rich soils and climates suited to temperate agriculture.  Agriculture, ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Commissioners reappointed to Tauranga City Council
    Local Government Minister Nanaia Mahuta today announced the reappointment of four commissioners to the Tauranga City Council. “As the Council continues to face substantial infrastructure and funding challenges, it is clear that ensuring certainty for Tauranga is more important than ever,” Nanaia Mahuta said. “The reappointment of the current Tauranga ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Next steps in Declaration Plan
    “We’ve now completed the first stage of the two-step engagement process to develop a Declaration Plan. This has provided us with valuable feedback to help with drafting a Declaration Plan that we will then take out to wider consultation,” Willie Jackson said.  “Almost 70 targeted engagement workshops were held mainly ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Public Media entity Establishment Board appointments
    The Minister for Broadcasting and Media has confirmed the nine-member Establishment Board to lead the work on creating a new public media entity in New Zealand. “The Establishment Board will oversee the detailed design of the new entity and the change required to create it,” Kris Faafoi said. “The make-up ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Prime Minister has productive meeting with Prime Minister of Japan
    Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern had a productive meeting with Japanese Prime Minister Fumio Kishida in Tokyo today.  “Japan is one of New Zealand’s closest and most important partners in the Indo-Pacific region. We have a strong trade relationship, common values and a shared commitment to an open, inclusive, stable and ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Joint Statement: Japan and Aotearoa New Zealand: a Strategic Cooperative Partnership for Common Pea...
    Strengthening the Strategic Cooperative Partnership 1.     The Prime Minister of Japan His Excellency KISHIDA Fumio and the Prime Minister of New Zealand the Right Honourable Jacinda Ardern held a productive and substantive meeting in Tokyo on 21 April 2022. Acknowledging the Summit Meeting was taking place at a significant time as the two ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • NZ, Japan team up on renewable energy
    Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern today welcomed two renewable energy initiatives that highlight the growing partnership between Japan and New Zealand as both countries work towards a greener future. “New Zealand, like Japan, is embarking on a journey to become carbon neutral by 2050,” Jacinda Ardern said. “We need to significantly ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Veterans Minister congratulates RSA on 100 years since first Poppy Appeal
    Veterans Minister Meka Whaitiri has congratulated the Royal New Zealand Returned and Services’ Association (RSA) on 100 years since the first Poppy Appeal in New Zealand, held on April 24, 1922. “This is an incredible century of work by the RSA that has provided thousands of New Zealanders the opportunity ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • New technology for e-waste switched on
    A new state-of-the-art machine that sorts and shreds electronic waste has officially started operation in Auckland today. Environment Minister David Parker pressed start on Computer Recycling Ltd’s new BLUBOX machine, which was supported by a $1.5 million grant from the Waste Minimisation Fund. “The BLUBOX machine is a step forward ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • CPI figures highlight global economic challenges
    Further increases in consumer prices are a reminder of the current global economic challenges and the need for responsible fiscal policy in New Zealand, Grant Robertson said today. The Consumer Price Index released by Stats NZ today showed a 1.8 percent increase in prices over the March quarter, taking the ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Government supports more people off benefit
    Minister for Social Development and Employment Carmel Sepuloni says the Government’s response to COVID-19 has helped keep people in work, with March Quarter Benefit statistics showing a further fall in the number of people receiving a main benefit and jobseeker assistance. “There are 19,883 fewer people on a main benefit ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Andrew Little Locality network announcement speech, Levin | Taitoko, 21 April 2022
    Kia ora koutou, Thank you for having me here today. I begin by acknowledging my colleague, Peeni Henare, the Associate Minister for Māori Health, who cannot be with us due to other commitments. Peeni and I have worked closely on today’s kaupapa - as we have with the rest of ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Health Reform – Govt ensures local say in health services
    The Government has announced how New Zealanders will have a real voice in determining the health services provided in their community as part of the new health system. “Today we’re announcing nine locality network pilots to improve how healthcare is delivered in local communities,” Health Minister Andrew Little said. The ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Sustainable Aviation Arrangement signed with Singapore
    A New Zealand-Singapore Sustainable Aviation Arrangement signed today marks the start of greater collaboration as both countries move towards low carbon economies, Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern says.  The Arrangement is the first bilateral cooperation in sustainable aviation for both New Zealand and Singapore, and its signing was witnessed by Prime Minister Jacinda ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • NZ, Singapore join forces on supply chain disruptions
    New Zealand and Singapore have pledged to continue working together on supply chains following global disruptions caused by COVID-19, Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern and her Singapore counterpart, Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong, announced today. “The global COVID-19 pandemic has showed us just how vulnerable economies of all sizes can be ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Taking action on biodiversity challenges
    The Aotearoa New Zealand Biodiversity Strategy 2020 - Te Mana o te Taiao – now has an accompanying implementation plan, aimed at driving collective action to tackle New Zealand’s biodiversity crisis. “It is the first time key conservation activities across all government departments and regional councils have been identified in ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • New rules to include all finfish in combined daily bag limit for recreational fishers
    Rules for daily limits on recreationally caught finfish will change to include species that previously had no limit, Oceans and Fisheries Minister, David Parker announced today. There are over 1,000 finfish species found in New Zealand waters, and of those only 43 species have been subject to a daily recreational ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Government takes action to future proof supply chain
    A more resilient, productive and lower carbon freight and supply chain sector that will play a pivotal role in growing the economy, and future proof it from further international shocks, is now a step closer, Transport Minister Michael Wood announced today. The Minister has launched Te rautaki ueā me te ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Kūwaha unveiled at Singapore’s Gardens by the Bay by Prime Minister
    A carving celebrating the long-standing friendship between Aotearoa New Zealand and Singapore was today unveiled by Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern at Singapore’s Gardens by the Bay. “Tāne Te Waiora is a bespoke carving which takes the form of a kūwaha and represents a symbolic doorway. It is a metaphor for ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Opening remarks at joint press conference with Prime Minister Lee
    Prime Minister Lee – thank you for the very warm welcome to Singapore.   I would like to start by expressing to you, Prime Minister Lee, our appreciation for how New Zealanders resident in Singapore have been looked after during COVID-19. I also, on a personal note, wish to thank you ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • NZ, Singapore Prime Ministers meet in Singapore
    Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern and Singapore counterpart Lee Hsien Loong discussed global and regional challenges and opportunities, their countries’ responses to COVID-19 and the next steps to enhancing the bilateral relationship when they met in Singapore today. Jacinda Ardern is visiting Singapore and Japan, accompanied by Minister for Trade and ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Russian banks targeted under latest round of sanctions
    Foreign Minister Nanaia Mahuta has announced new sanctions against Russia’s largest banks and financial institutions, as part of the Government’s ongoing response to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. “Aotearoa New Zealand is imposing sanctions on eighteen financial entities, including Russia’s central bank, sovereign wealth fund and the largest financial institutions in ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Joint Statement by the Prime Ministers of New Zealand and Singapore
    1. Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong hosted Prime Minister Rt Hon Jacinda Ardern on an Official Visit to Singapore on 19 April 2022. The Prime Ministers acknowledged the longstanding friendship and multi-faceted, wide-ranging cooperation between Singapore and New Zealand across many fields, in spite of the challenges presented by COVID-19. ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • 50 projects fast-tracked under Govt scheme
    Projects could create more than 18,000 jobs Over 8000 houses receive fast-track consent Fast-track process have saved, on average, 15 months per project The Government has approved three more projects under the fast-track consenting process, bringing the number of projects that are eligible to apply for resource consents to 50. ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • NZ to expand Working Holiday Scheme with Singapore
    New Zealand is relaunching and expanding its Working Holiday Scheme with Singapore and will welcome applications from May 5, Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern announced today. During her first international trip since the Covid pandemic began, the Prime Minister met with young people in Singapore who have been on the Scheme ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • New High Commissioner to Tonga announced
    Foreign Minister Nanaia Mahuta today announced the appointment of Matt Howell as new High Commissioner to Tonga. “Aotearoa New Zealand and Tonga have a long history and the Kingdom is one of our closest neighbours in the Pacific,” Nanaia Mahuta said. “Last year we proudly marked 50 years of formal diplomatic ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • New Chair to lead Oranga Tamariki Ministerial Advisory Board
    Respected Māori leader Tā Mark Solomon has been appointed Chair of the Oranga Tamariki Ministerial Advisory Board, Children’s Minister Kelvin Davis has announced. The Board’s report into Oranga Tamariki, Te Kahu Aroha, was delivered to the Minister last year and highlighted a need for substantial change within the organisation. To ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Geotech investigations to get underway for pumped hydro at Lake Onslow
    Drilling is about to get underway for one of the key options of the NZ Battery Project geotechnical feasibility investigations, in what has the potential to be the largest hydro project in New Zealand, Minister of Energy and Resources Megan Woods has announced.  “The geotechnical investigations starting at Lake Onslow ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 weeks ago