One more day, one more lie, one more smile, one more wave.
Some old joke wants my vote. Aspirational fail.
Did you see on TV? The third world disease on her face.
Unlike me, all you see, are scabs not your first world disgrace.
You’re the faeces of the species, you’re the disease, you’re the plague on the face of that girl.
You’re the hunger, you’re the plunder, all asunder, heaven wonder if there’s oil on the moon (in our bones).
You’re the statistic, optimistic, pessimist e-con-o-mystic, you’re the waste in the space.
Merchant banker, supertanker, deep drill wanker, pull your anchor, just get out of the way.
And we’ll rise. And when we rise up.
We will sing, and we will be glorious.
One more try, one more bribe, one more tea for your friend.
Some old bloke on a rope while they bury his dead.
Did you see on tv? The mould on kids in their bed.
Unlike me, all you see, is dirt and the profits from rent.
You’re the faeces of the species, you’re a disease, you’re a plague on the backs of us all.
You’re the sadistic, little twisted, first world gifted, Mi-pad whiz kid, the foul wind in the sales.
You’re the hunter, you’re the blunder, toxic numbers, six foot under, and you’re the slag of good grace.
Mother cluster, bunker buster, colonel mustard, general custard, just get out of our way.
And we’ll rise. And when we rise up.
We will sing, and we will be glorious.
19 on the daily chart, 304 on the wildcard chart, from two votes.
We’re all lefties here, right? we’re all anti poverty and pro children in need, right?
Two clicks, and you don’t even have to listen to the song to vote.
Pass the link around, and we’ll all have played a part in forcing the issue of child hunger and inept government in NZ in the faces of a head under the cover, not really listening public.
Surely you can see what the songs about, so please click to fight to win.
Underneath the title and band name, there’s an orange ‘vote’ button
Or click or mouse over the Al1en head picture and there’s an orange java vote button.
I’d do a screenshot if I knew how post it.
You can vote everyday until we win.
Viva revolution.
I have to to log in using my facebook details to access my profile, but if I log out, return to the site and dismiss the login screen, I always go straight to song page.
I don’t know why you can’t access the page, but I appreciate your efforts in trying.
Thanks.
Sometimes I like a crooked day dream to keep me company at work.
My fave is the song does well using the government’s (ours) money, and the pm handing over an award at the tuis (or whatever they’re called), to a stunt double dressed in an alien suit, with the whole nation knowing it’s about his premiership and him doing sod all to help our children out of poverty, live on TV.
It makes international news reels, and as we know, there’s no such thing as bad, free publicity.
Then my boss comes and wakes me and tells me he’s made my coffee.
I voted. But it still asks for some silly flash player, I have never had any trouble playing anything from the net before It would be nice to know what I voted for
My respect to all those who have voted.
231 after 7 votes.
You see how easy this could be to win if the just the site stalwarts here gifted a daily vote over the next couple of weeks.
Tell your friends, use the pc at work and home and we could all be having a right old laugh at Teflon john expense.
I don’t want to spam more than I have, and certainly don’t want to wear out my welcome here, so for bearing with me, ta very much.
Just in case anybody is still awake and or interested, I’ve made a Dr Evil pic to accompany the vote link if anyone wants it.
Right click, save as, and email away. http://www.al1en.org
Puff piece in the Herald today on Maggie Barry, written by Audrey Young, headlined ‘Maggie’s Way’.
A Q&A style article. She talks about the insults and bullying nature of parliament and it’s from her point of view all Labour’s fault. Gets politely and super lightly called on insulting and bullying Jacinda Adern, and it turns out it’s all because of Trevor Mallard twitter twatting or something.
Maggie doesn’t do insults or bullying, neither does National, its all Labour and the Greens fault. Of course Young leaves that and moves on to bigger more pressing issues.
Which MP outside your party impresses you?
That’s a hard one. Can I get back to you on that? That’s a really hard one.
Classy, there are good people on both sides of the house doing good work and you can’t even mention one, you f&^*ing work there on committees with these people . Says more about Barry than any of her other answers.
Maggie this may be the zenith of your political career, may your years of seat warming ahead be good for your garden.
This article was so light and fluffy from our hard hitting gallery journo I think the paper floated in from the letterbox this morning on its own.
All the Maori party mps, for services to the National party.
John Banks, that he’s still clinging on to his salary, despite everything that says he shouldn’t.
Simon Bridges, for carrying on and making the best of it, despite taking a severe beating with the wanker stick.
And last and very much least, Paula Bennett, for her continued support for NZ tent makers in these troubled times, and popularising the moo moo all over again, even if she does need help to zip it.
Audrey young doing her bit for the party her daddy served and her herald masters.
Maggie Barry is a vacuous nasty piece of work, can’t even shut the f up and learn the ropes. Finally got selected for one of the safest seats as they couldn’t risk her in anything less.
“I personally think that men and men and women and women should be allowed to marry if that’s what they want. Frankly, I don’t quite understand why they want to do it. I’ve never got married in my life.”
She even manages to screw up her pro-marriage equality stance. It’s like a pre-women’s vote man telling a woman ‘I don’t know why you want the right to vote, I’ve never done it’.
Yes Maggie, we shouldn’t marry because you think it’s silly.
On the subject of student loan defaulters, I have no idea why the IRD cannot just make an agreement with the tax collection agencies of the UK, USA, Ireland, and Aus to have the student debt recovered through their respective tax systems?
Probably because those countries want nothing to change. At the moment, they get all our educated people improving their economy / society.
Not only would it cost their tax systems to chase kiwis, but it would stem the tide of highly educated people working within their country.
I don’t know how anyone could really confuse the two though, the writing styles are worlds apart. “Cactus Kate” is just a horrible bogan wrapped in a logical fallacy.
I actually quite like Cactus’s writing. Sure she is a right wing bogan but at least she is an up front bogan and she writes and thinks rationally. Her principles may be different to ours but at least she has some principles. And unlike Key she is exactly who she is. There is not pretension. She is not trying to make out she is something she is not.
That’s very true micky, and I don’t doubt her sincerity one bit. She’s a straight up honest bastard.
However she does rely on some pretty flimsy logic. For example on RNZ she tried to argue that Matt McCarten shouldn’t criticise the operators of the Pike River mine because he wouldn’t want to run a mine himself.
Also there are times I think a responsible host should hide the keys to her computer…
That is a horrible accusation. I have never been on red radio.
And you’ve misrepresented the comments I did actually make on another station which were in relation to a defamatory comment made by another guest. One who consistently accuses directors of companies of all manner of bad behaviour, so I was merely making a point that it is not as easy and glamorously well remunerated that he may think it is and if it was he should be a mining company director.
What is the world coming to, with Hooton cheer leading for team Shearer, and Cactus Kate arguing (albeit in a nuanced sense) in favour of team Cunliffe. As I read her, she wants to see actual political engagement and a proper battle of ideas, rather than both left and right racing to see who can do the best job of cosseting the middle class. And I have to say, it is a lovely piece of writing.
Odgers can’t write to save herself. I find her at times close to illiterate. On top of this, no matter how much she tries to dress things up for her audience, her words are invariably littered with a belief that greed is good and spiked with a hatred for anyone she thinks may impede that pursuit. I would’ve loved to have seen her in parliament, getting roasted on a daily basis, away from the safety of her computer screen. Small fish in an even smaller pond.
Of all the things to talk about you are all hung up on whinging about grammar and calling me a bogan.
Little wonder Cunliffe cannot gain momentum in a working class party.
His supporters are a bunch of snobby toffs.
This kind of grammar policing, of anyone, really makes me cringe. The style of my writing is often poor and ungrammatical. Yet somehow, I feel entitled to have my say. If I felt insecure about all this, as so many people do, reading these kinds of comments would make me even more reticent about participating in conversations at the Standard.
Looks like you’re hung up on issues with your bad writing, too. There was this, you know:
“On top of this, no matter how much she tries to dress things up for her audience, her words are invariably littered with a belief that greed is good and spiked with a hatred for anyone she thinks may impede that pursuit.”
I hope you aren’t implying that those who are put off speaking out by comments deriding others for their writing deficits, are just being “oversensitive”.
I’m never too bothered about clumsy or wrong grammar, but “CK’s” summary of my post as:
The silly policy to build homes for middle class kiddies screaming poverty is an excellent example of this Cunliffe v Shearer tension. “Karol” has an excellent post on this and has thought of the conspiracy that capitalism in fact is to blame in forcing this idea that owning your own home is aspirational to all.
…. is just inaccurate, whether as result of clumsy use of words, or just a poor interpretation. I was critical of the political position and policy of the current Labour caucus leadership (Team Shearer really), but I’m pretty sure I never referred to Cunliffe directly or indirectly in my ‘state housing vs home ownership’ post. And “conspiracy” is not what I think of when I am writing about the way the loose networks of the wealthy and powerful operate to further their own interests.
So she doesn’t have much of an idea of what I was thinking, but then maybe the entity that is “karol” is just a quotation, a figment of someone’s (or some group’s) imagination?
You’re being far too charitable, Karol. Anyone who refers to the poor as the “pathetic heaving underclass”, believes beneficiaries should be paid not to “breed” and thinks Slater’s blog has anything to offer other than a window into how nasty the right can get can’t be taken seriously. Just as QoT saw the hook in Fran O’Sullivan’s piece, no matter how hard she tries Odgers cannot help but let her true colours show, even when she posts on The Standard as happened again throughout today. I do not see how some on the Left can place genuine value in anything she says.
There were some points of agreement between my views on home ownership & CK’s, but she went off on her own little tangent about the (allegedly continuing) Cunliffe-Shearer tension.
I’m more curious as to why TS suddenly got so much attention over the last 24 hours or so, from CK, MH, and a Labour MP and an LP policy person. Some things seem to be bubbling away out of my sight. Yes, FO’S was still being pretty right wing, but, also seemed to shift her position somewhat.
I’m wondering if it’s part of a growing sense of uncertainty about changes happening that some political people feel they are losing control of. While some may be just trying to manoeuvre so they’ll be in a relatively favourable position when the dust settles.
Hi weka, the game is far bigger than February, important as that is. Leaders come and go, MPs come and go, neither Shearer nor Cunliffe will be relevant 10-15 years from now. The real sea change has to happen at the Labour membership and constitutional level. And we’ve only just started.
As I read her, she sees the Shearer/Cunliffe tension as arising from the courting of the middle class by the Shearer people, and the desire for a genuinely left orientation by a lot of left wing people. And she sees the housing policy and your response to it as exemplifying this tension. But I agree that beyond those points, she does go off on her own tangent.
Queue some b/s about ck’s post being proof positive that ‘misguided’ types of the left are unwittingly in cahoots with portions of the right and in effect undermining the ‘nice’ Labour Party just as the ‘right’ wants, and how every one counted within the ‘misguided left’ ought now, and once and for all, STFU.
In fact. Haven’t I already read that line somewhere here at ts?
Does ‘indeed’ indicate you think that’s a reasonable line to spin, McFlock? The reason I ask is your follow-on, which I guess is attempting to posit the opposite of what I’d call a b/s line. And it’s another b/s line. No-one is calling on DS to resign the leadership. But lots of people are wanting to see democracy really exist within the Labour Party. And, I guess, pressure might be applied to mp’s who’d rather deny democracy in Feb.
Now, you might not agree with that sentiment or goal. Fine. But don’t mis-call it as a call for DS to resign.
Well, I have seen arguments that posit Hooten’s support for shearer is evidence that shearer is not fit to be leader.
If I were to make a similar quibble about your phrasing, I don’t recall seeing anyone here specifically demand that critics of the Labour party should “STFU”.
Yep things are getting really strange. Chris Trotter thinks the nats have a mandate to sell our assets and the right are calling for tax increases for the wealthy.
Has it ever occurred to any of you lot that most people don’t have a blindly ideological approach to every issue unlike yourselves – that there are good points and bad points to both sides of most given arguments? That most peoples views may shift back and forth somewhat over time?
I guess it is because you lot are in constant battle mode fighting the good war against the forces of evil, you have developed an us vs them mentality – “you are either with us or against us!”.
You are left exasperated an confused when you can’t squeeze someone into one of a few pigeon holes.
Has it ever occurred to you that us lot don’t give one big fat f**k what you ‘think’ and we only tolerate you as an object of mirth to bestow the odd piece of spittle upon when we have run out of jokes about the Prime Minister Slippery’s bad habit of public displays of ‘spastic dancing’…
Neo marxism is dead in the water – who’s suppose to be the Agent of change since the proletariat failed to turn up to the party? Why should anyone believe that knowledge is only ever Historical never Universal?
Has it ever occurred to any of you lot that most people don’t have a blindly ideological approach to every issue unlike yourselves – that there are good points and bad points to both sides of most given arguments? That most peoples views may shift back and forth somewhat over time?
Sounds like poststructuralist mumbo-jumbo to me…isn’t that usually your target?
No its not poststructurlist, its Humanist. I believe there is an objective reality and objective universal values about ethics/justice.
Post structuralists/Deconstructionist/various Feminists splinter groups/Neo Marxists/Cultural Relativists/Multiculturalists – they all suffer from hyper relativism and symptoms of solipsism of varying severity.
Makes it hard to pin that lot down as they twist and squirm, grabbing a bit of this and a bit of that to create what can only be described as very bad philosophy.
well, that is where we part ways friend; existence precedes essence; consider the “existence” of people born with profound impairments (at Templeton there were “patients” that resembled sun-fish, to put it politely); consider the “essence” of so-called “schizophrenics”; I have followed your comments over the year, and like mine, there is nothing “objective” about them. (we need new lock-nuts)
Ah, k-p, why so keen to put people in boxes? I do have difficulty following a party line or any one theory – the best still have their weaknesses. It depends on the context and the issue as to which is most useful. I am a little bit neo-Marxist and quite a bit post-structuralist. There are some things in postmodernism I agree with. There is no theory of everything. But I am for democratic socialism, social and economic justice/fairness, and am against violence, prejudice, persecution and oppression.
And I am for evidence-based research, knowledge, understanding and argument.
I do think there is an objectively (scientifically) verifiable material reality. I see objectivity as a process, not an end point. And it doesn’t necessarily cancel out subjectivity, especially when it comes to human activities and communications. Objectivity is haunted by subjectivity, as you demonstrated with that sentence of yours I quoted above. But, that’s the thing about language and human communications.
You seem to miss your own contradictions. “believing” in something is a subjective statement.
Yep. I’d say it’s an odd sort of humanism that fails to recognise that humans interpret reality both subjectively, and through socially constructed lenses.
not that flakey Post Modernist stuff which I think QofT suffers from.
No, please, do go on.
I’ll just be over here having a chuckle that you managed to get from “you stupid lefties just want to pigeonhole everyone” into “I bet you’re a neo-Marxist” in a mere six comments.
”i have never read the book,(Marx),tho i was told to take a look,i lifted my pool hall cue for another game”,
(Thanks to the Clash for the lines which i have gleefully altered with the addition of the Social/economists moniker),
LOLZ, my pidgeon hole is somewhere in the vicinity of Pol Pot, a Communizing Fascist,
Thanks to the good old New Zealand education tho i have the ability to realize that getting KP’s relatives to bang a four inch nail into the back of His head at gun-point just isn’t acceptable human behaviour so good old Post-Modernist,(whatever the fuck that means), me has had to accept simply being a Socialist…
Trotter must have holidayed in one of those Batchs that have 50 year old lumpy couches!
He didn’t get a good rest and over stretched some of the points he was making.
Shearer should front foot the mercenary thing so that it is yesterday’s news by the time the Nats get their research ready for leaking through their usual channels
This is twilight zone stuff…are Right Wing commentators giving Key and English room to launch one or two definitively Left Wing policies? Can their strategy for 2014 be really this cunning? Mix in one or two headline Left Wing policies (top tax rate hike and youth employment/youth training programmes), and use it as cover for austerity and asset sell downs elsewhere?
I wonder if they have found in their polling that a lot of ordinary NZers – including the middle class – are worried that their kids can’t seem to get ahead and that there is a shortage of decent jobs and training opportunities.
Nah, it just won’t happen via a lift in the top tax rate, the Fed crowd would string English up by a very sensitive part of His anatomy in a rotary shed at the very thought of it,
The only invite Slippery would get from now until the little Shyster is given the kick would be from those wishing to have Him behave naturally,(dance like a clown),in their presence while they took pics to show off to the Grand-kids in their dotage,
The Bizness lobby would immediately stop calling, i think that if they are going to spend money on any sort of employment initiative,(or pretend to), the usual suspect will be trotted out, asset sales proceeds will have yet another attachment of ‘youth employment’ attached to it along with the continuously growing list of roading,health,schools,debt, blah blah blah,
Other than that if the Slippery little Shyster has half a brain He will be offering employers a years worth of dole payments as a ‘training allowance’ to actually employ a large number of the 24% of unemployed youth, possibly with a slight hint at a top tax rate rise…
Have people forgotten about the youth changes for 16-17 year olds?
Does one think it’s possible that that was setting the scene for harsher benefit conditions for all youth and more privatisation?
The right taketh more than they giveth so creating an enviornment where it seems that they are taking positive steps to address the issue may simply be a way of saying to people well now there’s no excuse to be on a benefit.
Bootcamps won’t work this time to get that 5% of swinging vote but the strategy surely won’t change – we’re offering this but if you don’t avail yourself of our wonderful opportunity then benefit damnation is yours.
Can their strategy really be this cunning? It sounds eerily like their 2008 me-to strategy. The must be getting a bit of polling feedback telling them to DO something.
This is what I reckon. Also, any PR headline increase in the top personal tax rate can be more than compensated for by drops in corporate and trust tax rates, see how it works
may I just pop in here?
I have made this letter longer than usual, only because I have not had time to make it shorter
(The last thing on knows when constructing a work is what to put first; continual eloquence is tedious) ;)-Blaise
WHAT WE CAN NEVER KNOW,or the collapsing hermeneutic (there’s your spiral)
-David Germez
“one could in the light of the fact that the divine life is itself a continued variation,,, apply to divinity in the most exalted sense the name of time. The old mythology of Chronos as primordial being and first divine principle seems thereby to be somehow in contact with the truth”
-Franz Bretano :Philosophical Investigations on Space Time and the Continuum.
“All created things are God’s speech. The being of a stone speaks and manifests the same as does my mouth about God: and people understand more by what is done than by what is said”
-Meister Eckhart : The Essential Sermons, Commentaries, Treatises and Defence.
Let just get this out there. A person in receipt of a benefit, if they earn more than $3,400 are pushed up into the second lowest band of taxation. Key did this because obviously he never read the convention on human rights, that if someone is so in need that they receive a benefit then they cannot be treated differently, that everyone should receive the same amount of welfare. Yet Key believes that progressive taxation should kick on those on welfare!
Looking at it another way. People who earn $100,000 pay 10.5% on the first $14,000 they earn.
People who earn $3,400 pay only at the 10.5% rate. Those in receipt of a welfare
check, and have no income, get the full entitlement, pay no tax on income. But Key in
his infinite stupidity believes that those individuals who do have some paltry $3,400+
of income should not get the full welfare entitlement (as effectively they pay more tax,
pay the 17.5% rate on their measly income after the first $3,400).
Just for a moment imagine the cost of filing tax returns as all those people on welfare
whose taxation just became a complicated mess. Whatever happened to keeping
government taxation simple. But worse, how can government argue that families
on welfare should not get family tax credit when there is clearly income tax
bands for those on welfare. I mean whatever happened to equal treatment in taxation.
You pay a higher rate of tax makes you eligible for the programs its funds to those who
also pay higher rates of tax.
“whatever happened to equal treatment in taxation”, only when the main beneficiaries of such treatment are those at the top of the food chain or those who vote to put them there,
The Working for Families fiasco where the Clark Government deemed the middle class,(and quite high up in that decile), to be more ‘in need’ of relief from taxation than beneficiaries with children was the final straw for me that broke my connection with Labour,
Incidently the ‘loud noise’ us lot at the Standard have been making over housing affordability has obviously attracted the attention of Labour so much so that Annette King has paid a visit and at least aquainted herself with the concerns many of us here have regarding State owned rentals being provided to the decile of lower waged workers so there is a small glimmer of hope of seeing some specific and substantial gains in that area when Labour release it’s completed election policy,(hopefully sooner rather than later),
My view is that the next ‘issue’ that we as the Standard need to address is just that of ‘working for Families’ and just how grossly unfair is it to tax the benefits of welfare dependent children and then refuse to offer them the ‘tax relief’ offered to the children of the upper echelons of the middle class…
The money spent on some of WFF would be better off being spent on a) a universal family benefit, and b) an increase in the state housing stock. The same outcome would be achieved.
Though I agree with the sentiments leveled at Labour, my point was this, that Key introduced a second progressive tax in the middle of the welfare. Imagine for a moment that we pay benefit to help people out of poverty only to tax them more if they do the right thing on welfare!
Save or get some part time work????
But worse, by taxing them on welfare we also don’t pay them WFF, which is blatantly unfair.
But its even worse, the 10.5% tax rate is a farce since its really just a tax relief for the rich, those who don’t get welfare don’t the relief since unlike everyone else the MSD take the first
10.5% tax band when they provide welfare. So the low tax band had no effect except for the
free who live off assets with little income (and can’t claim benefit), those geared to reduce their
taxes using trusts – the super rich.
Merging Madness and Reason (it’s the DSM V season)
“you have never been diagnosed as mad-this is the shifting sand upon which you erect your sanity. Yet, your illness has gone unrecognized…you have been deprived of treatment because the steady, sure advance of science has taken too long to reach you.”
“Beneath the (can’t read my handwriting, some adjective) labels of consensus there is just the homogenous zone-our common origins and physiology bind us together; we are a crowd of open-eyed children staring with wonder at the world. This vast assembly of “thrown” people is the homogenous zone-a coat of many (red) colours”.
“Reason too, recognized itself as being duplicated and dispossessed of itself; it thought itself wise and it was and it was mad; it thought it knew and it knew nothing; it thought itself righteous and it was insane; knowledge led one to the forbidden world when one thought one was being led by it to eternal light.” (thats “progress” for ya’s; Get Ya YaYa’s Out) (those art-school rockers aye)
-Foucault :Mental Illness and Psychology
According to Scheff, relative to the rate of treated “mental illness” the rate of unrecorded residual rule breaking of societal norms is extremely high.
-consider this continual self-absorbed flouting of cell -phone /driving legislation, and it’s on the increase; BodyCount’s in the house.Listen to how close people are to stress thresholds in their daily discourse with children, family, associates, witness the behavioural temperature on the roads, the anasthetization and subsequent harms carried out; that’s why I drank alone in the end; Dos Gusanos was fun though, all those years ago (an I’m not surprised productivity is tanking when I observe people ostensibly working yet using their work p.c for shopping and such-like)
“Once upon a time, in some out of the way corner of that universe which is dispersed into numberless twinkling solar systems, there was a star upon which clever beasts invented knowing. That was the most arrogant and mendacious minute of ‘world history’, but nevertheless, it was only a minute. After nature had drawn a few breaths, the star cooled and congealed and the clever beasts had to die-One might invent such a fable and yet still it would not have adequately illustrated how miserable, how shadowy and transient, how aimless and arbitrary the human intellect looks within nature.
-Friedrich Nietzsche :On Truth and Lies in a Non-Moral Sense
“Madness and sanity are variants of the same phenomena; everything that we see and fear in the madman can also be seen and feared in ourselves. We are all mad children, we are all autistic, we are all deluded, we are all abstract and solipsistic and we all madly cobble together systems of absurd beliefs on this lost planet of fools; perhaps a fundamental truth about our humanity can be found in the instability, ‘throwness’ and madness of the homogenous zone.”
(Baudrillard places his hopes in terrorism, viruses and catastrophe)
i read today of an analysts perspective on FIVE potential Asian Shocks
-Taiwanese Independence asserted by the democratic vote
-Islamic unrest reaching China
-US Defence (Naval) cuts
-Thailand destabilized
-Territorial disputes in E and S China seas (we do live in interesting times)
-Why, thou sayest well; I do now remember a saying, “The fool doth think he is wise, yet the wise man knows himself to be a fool.”
-As You Like It (if you are ruled by mind, you are a king, if by body, a slave-Cato)
WHAT WE CAN NEVER KNOW- David Gamez. I whole-heartedly recommend this little book; I read it this afternoon at the library (air-con and I cannot afford to pay my fees, yet;)
HBT-10 more hot dry days forecast, little rain since August, Irrigation Ban on the way, Farmers may ‘dry out’
-if you’re walking a dog, they cannot eat anything they find in or around rivers or ponds, (cyano-bacteria) meanwhile we are going to supply more dairy to another Infant Formula Manufacturer establishing in NI
Dom-The Children’s Commissioner, a HB paediatrician,Russell Wills,, is “incredulous” about child poverty and inequality in our country…
from your friendly neighbourhood “madman” (hyper-rationally and reflexively yours)
now what am I gonna do for a crust. hmmm
11.29 By faith the people passed through the RED Sea, as on dry land, but when the Egyptians tried to do so, they were drowned.
It’s a Mad Mad World, btw D, I’m gettin “bored” again, don’t wanna write a book, there’s enough been written already, might start an Anarchist Commune ala http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Kropotkin
I assumed your “watch from the High Plains” remark meant that you weren’t going to be actively commenting for the moment, forgive me if I misinterpreted.
Loved your stuff, trooper, a message from Nu-Earth?
“And I heard a voice in the midst of the four beasts
And I looked and behold, a pale horse
And his name that sat on him was Death
And Hell followed with him.”
“What is happening at the moment? Because the Falklands are back in the news. Belfast is back in the news. It’s like some sort of hideous 80s revival, isn’t it? All we need is a heartless Conservative prime minister attacking the unemployed and demonising the poor, bankers making obscene profits, David Bowie releasing a single…”–Sandi Toksvig, The News Quiz
mickysavage -> So tell me KP is unfettered capitalism in a healthy state and just what this world needs?
Obviously not. I was never a supporter of neo liberalism, except back in the 80s when I was in my middle teens. But everyone was entranced by it then, Muldoon was gone, the Cold War over, Lifestyles of the Rich and Famous was on TV.
This is an interesting piece by a contemporary philosopher I like, applying some Humanist qualities – imagination, intuition, memory, ethics – to the current morass:
“I can only ask: is there a single example in Western civilisation over the past 2500 years when a broad policy of austerity has pulled a civilisation out of crisis and set it on the road to wellbeing, prosperity or growth? No. There is no example. There is no evidence. Only ideological conviction – romanticism – coming out of a political-economic theory packed into an apparently inevitable force called globalisation…
…Crises usually strike when ideologies have been around too long and the elites that serve them have lost their ability for critical thought…
…Instead of retreating inside a received wisdom, which has already revealed that it doesn’t work, we could turn to some basic, helpful human qualities…
…Ethics, for example, are a simple, practical reminder that the primary obligation of a civilisation is to its citizens’ wellbeing, not to the protection of commercial contracts or the servicing of debts. The fact that most of these debts were incurred by the commercial sector and its financiers reinforces this point…
…Memory is an essential tool of education. You can’t deal with a crisis if you are in the hands of economists, managers and business elites who don’t know the history of debt. They don’t know the history of competition. Very few read anything of consequence. They are the briefing paper generation. Many are, in reality, functionally illiterate, except on very narrow topics. They don’t know what has worked and not worked in their own society. In fact, they don’t seem to understand the concept of either society or civilisation…
…As for Imagination, it is not the privileged domain of the arts. Good financial policy is an expression of imagination. Throughout history great financiers and great ministers of finance have usually also been great consumers of culture, intellectuals, men of imagination. I think of Solon in Athens 2600 years ago, of Sully at the side of Henry IV in 1600, of Siegmund Warburg after World War II, of Jean Monet rebuilding Europe. As they would explain: you must imagine your way out of an economic cul de sac, just as a good general imagines his way out of a military stalemate. Bad generals stick to trench warfare…
…History is clear. When faced by unsustainable debts, the fools, the weak, the degenerate civilisations become obsessed by what they owe. They convince themselves that money is real, not an agreed-upon convention. They become its slave. And they destroy themselves. Successful civilisations make these impossible debts disappear – clearly, intentionally, massively. In this way they protect what needs to be protected, such as the savings of real people and their pensions. They clear the decks and the result is raw, new human energy to deal with society’s needs. History is filled with examples of this being done on purpose. It is also filled with the carcasses of those who refused to face reality and so caused their societies to commit suicide.”
For some reason no reply buttons are showing for Pascal or karol, so here goes:
Pascal -> “Yep. I’d say it’s an odd sort of humanism that fails to recognise that humans interpret reality both subjectively, and through socially constructed lenses.”
Where did I deny any subjectivity? It’s the post structuralists/post modernists who go the hyper relativistic route.
You end up with crazy feminists calling Newton’s Laws of Physics a ‘rape manual’, and prattling on about “Rape Culture”. Science is dismissed or supposedly ‘improved’ via “Critical Theory” to “Feminist Science” or “Post Modernest Science”.
It’s all very poor philosophy and embodies atrociously low Academic standards.
You don’t necessarily “end up with crazy feminists calling Newton’s Laws of Physics a ‘rape manual’” if you accept a lot of what PM theorists say. And to equate that sort of thing with rape culture’ is just asinine.
Do you think that cultural norms are socially constructed, partially through the way we talk about things? And that cultural norms affect individuals thoughts about behavior and blameworthiness?
If so, then it’s no stretch to say that the way a society talks about rape, will affect the incidence of rape. ie, that some ways of talking about rape could increase the incidence of rape by creating cultural norms that support rapists interpretations of reality.
You end up with crazy feminists calling Newton’s Laws of Physics a ‘rape manual’, and prattling on about “Rape Culture”. Science is dismissed or supposedly ‘improved’ via “Critical Theory” to “Feminist Science” or “Post Modernest Science”.
Oops, k_p’s brain overloaded and it’s back to copy-pasting MRA propaganda which he’s already been informed multiple times is inaccurate. Balance has been restored to the Force.
karol -> “Ah, k-p, why so keen to put people in boxes? ”
Just want to know where you stand is all, nothing wrong with that.
“I do have difficulty following a party line or any one theory – the best still have their weaknesses.”
I don’t follow a part line and I get MOBBED on here for it – especially by your girl pals.
“It depends on the context and the issue as to which is most useful.”
It’s not good enough to go with what is “useful”. Marxism for example is a theory of everything, the guy was a genius obviously, nevertheless his philosophical system crashed and burned. Why should anyone believe you have the intellectual ability to uplift a fragment of it, remove it from context and claim it is “useful” for contemporary application.
“I am a little bit neo-Marxist and quite a bit post-structuralist. There are some things in postmodernism I agree with.”
The main tenet in postmodernism is that language is meaningless. Apparently Focault back tracked from that to the position that the meaning the reader gets from a text may differ from the author’s intention. In which case he hasn’t made any insight that authors and readers haven’t been aware of already.
As for Derrida, he’s been called an intellectual fraudster by some luminary academic types. Anyone who says they have read Derrida is lying, its incomprehensible – worse than Hegel.
The fact that Post-structuralist professors still hand out As Bs and Cs to their students submitted essays suggest the whole exercise is an insider’s joke.
“There is no theory of everything. But I am for democratic socialism, social and economic justice/fairness, and am against violence, prejudice, persecution and oppression.”
“And I am for evidence-based research, knowledge, understanding and argument.”
You are keeping the word “science” out of it. Are you referring to science, if not why not, and to what are you referring, Karol?
“I do think there is an objectively (scientifically) verifiable material reality.”
Ok you do bring up science now. Don’t know how you can claim to believe in science but claim to be “quite a bit post-structuralist”
“I see objectivity as a process, not an end point. And it doesn’t necessarily cancel out subjectivity, especially when it comes to human activities and communications. Objectivity is haunted by subjectivity, as you demonstrated with that sentence of yours I quoted above. But, that’s the thing about language and human communications.”
I never denied that there is subjectivity, it is postmodernist who deny the objective.
“You seem to miss your own contradictions. “believing” in something is a subjective statement.”
Is it? Does it matter? Like I said I don’t deny there is subjectivity eg “Chocolate tastes better than vanilla!” [ proviso – scientist discover genetic basis for varying tastes ]
[lprent: There is no “partY line” – it is every person’s argument for themselves. However there is a moderation line.
Personally I tend to view you as having a problem with dealing with women (what is it with that?) and indeed with anyone who thinks. You have that kind of “I’m just a poor victim” mentality (as you have amply demonstrated in this comment) that makes it difficult for you to deal with anyone disagreeing with you. And to top it off you seem to be a poor excuse for a psuedo-intellectual. Generally a waste of bandwidth and a bit of a luser in social media terms.
But these are just my opinions – they don’t enter into moderation.
Most of the time you pick up bans for either personally attacking authors or peristently going off topic in posts – usually the female authors. Right now you’re on most moderators “watch for stupidity” lists, and includes r0b’s list (about your only NOTABLE acheivement to date). ]
“I am a little bit neo-Marxist and quite a bit post-structuralist. There are some things in postmodernism I agree with.”
To be very blunt and clear, to me you are the typical KIWI IDIOT, I frown on, you have neither any understanding of complex history, socialism, social science, alternative social agendas and even scientifically evidenced social data.
I am totally flabber-ghasted about what brought you here.
Sorry, my impression is, you know too little of what goes down.
My comment was not really directed at the quote “kiwi_prometheus” used re what Karol may have commented on before, it was just totally incoherent, confusing, contradictory and much senseless, what “kiwi_prometheus” commented on in a wider context, also using that particular quote.
I tried to read his truly bizarre comments a few times, and I still cannot make that much sense at all out of what “k_p” tried to say or argue. Sorry for the frustration that lead to anger and some over the top comment I made in return.
You are not even just that “Kiwi idiot” I sometimes dismissably refer to, you are a totally ignorant, one sided coffin slicer of sorts, getting another angle on why some people may have died.
That is the lowest and cheapest crap I ever read and heard, man. Rot in fucking hell for that.
I don’t follow a part line and I get MOBBED on here for it – especially by your girl pals.
Have you ever considered that’s because you say really stupid things about girls?
It’s not good enough to go with what is “useful”. Marxism for example is a theory of everything, the guy was a genius obviously, nevertheless his philosophical system crashed and burned.
There’s only one thing to say here and it was said by Marx himself: I don’t know what I am but I know that I’m not a Marxist.
Marx considered that Marxists had twisted his teachings. This can most clearly be seen by his writings on the Paris Commune of 1871 which was anarchist. It was destroyed by military attack from the government.
Is it? Does it matter?
Yes it does. Opinion and belief cannot change objective fact. This is something that the RWNJs and economists can’t seem to grasp.
“The main tenet in postmodernism is that language is meaningless. Apparently Focault back tracked from that to the position that the meaning the reader gets from a text may differ from the author’s intention. In which case he hasn’t made any insight that authors and readers haven’t been aware of already.”
Hi xtasy. This paragraph pretty much sums things up. Every point made here is complete and utter bullshit and incorrect no matter how you look at it. So much so it’s impossible to engage with. I’d tell kp sayonara.
A great experience I had today, or rather yesterday (12.01.) to visit and view the NEW Rainbow Warrior vessel down at Princes Wharf. I am IMPRESSED, Greenpeace got their shit together, had I not been a member of sorts, I would have signed up right way.
I am worried for the ones who do not get it, how much NZ, Australian and Antarctic environmen is in danger! It is damned serious.
I left the vessel in doubt and worry, who is going to keep them alive to fight, I asked, being myself in dire straits.
I can only hope they get donations, manage and do more good, as that is what Greenpeace are here for. I would dread the day they die. I would want to die also.
A larger, enhanced Australian Defence Force reserve component is vital to Australia’s security. However, it has been largely overlooked in discussions around achieving greater self-reliance and meaningful capability in short order. Around one third of ...
Maybe I'll win the lottery, buy myself a lobotomyScoop out my brains, and maybe thenI'll blend right in with managementPretty, rich, or talented, you need two to make itI guess I'll just pledge allegiance to the paycheckSong: Durry. Read more ...
Here are a few tidbits that may be of interest this morning:1. National tops the list of donations to political parties with almost $5m in contributionsThe Electoral Commission's figures show National had by far the biggest donations to 30 April 2025.National: $4,889,538.20Labour: $1,627,713.92Greens: $1,588,680.02ACT: $1,463,445.22New Zealand First: $758,773.91 and ...
Hi,I am increasingly surrounded by friends talking to ChatGPT. Some of them are using it for work — getting vast amounts of information summarised and crunched down down to the bare essentials. Others are using it to write code. For many it seems to be replacing Google for recommendations — ...
Maiki Sherman revealed last night that Erica Stanford has been using her personal email for work, including for highly sensitive government documents.Despite Luxon claiming it was no big deal, and only done in limited circumstances (mainly tech related, he claimed), 1News revealed hundreds of pages of offending material over many ...
This is a re-post from the Climate Brink There are is a lot of dire news in the world these days – the dismantling of US climate policy, the apparent canceling of the 6th National Climate Assessment, etc. So sometimes its worth taking a break from doomscrolling and indulging in one’s hobbies. ...
An upcoming battle over defence acquisition will have repercussions for US military posture, particularly in the Pacific. The weapons that get bought in larger or smaller quantities, or are launched or cancelled, will indicate whether ...
WHAT IS WOKE MORALITY? How does it work? More to the point, can it be countered without making use of the same arguments and justifications deployed by the woke themselves?To begin with, “woke” is just the latest political shorthand for the ethical architecture supporting the tactics and strategies of anti-capitalism. ...
Indonesia is weighing a purchase of more US weapons—such as the new F-15EX—as a bargaining chip against US President Donald Trump’s 32 percent tariffs on Indonesian exports to the United States. But that approach carries ...
Australians went to the polls on Saturday in an election originally expected to be a tight contest between an uninspiring ALP government, and a full-on monstrous radical Coalition opposition. But then Trump happened, and Dutton doubled down on culture war bullshit, and so instead its been a Labour landslide. Which ...
Our PM and Foreign Minister appear to have a policy of staying low on Trump’s radar, but when might we finally stand up to support our two closest allies against his bullying? Photo: Getty ImagesBriefly, in Aotearoa-NZ’s political economy around housing, poverty and climate on Monday, May 5:When will our ...
The Australian Army needs a clearer sense of self. With no warning time for conflict, the army must cap its ongoing transformation with a new ‘theory of the army’ that enables civilian leaders to choose ...
The recent passing of "Sir" Bob Jones, the property tycoon and political meddler, has sparked an unsettling wave of accolades from across the political spectrum, including from some on the left. And although I don’t like to speak ill of the dead, ignoring what this evil man did to this ...
Australia has a unique opportunity to reinforce its national security by fostering a stronger domestic defence industry. For decades, foreign defence contractors have played a significant role in our military supply chains, but it’s essential ...
While Donald Trump is being widely cited as a reason/explanation for Anthony Albanese’s landslide victory on the weekend, that’s like blaming the icing for the state of a badly baked cake. In no particular order of incoherence…although allegedly being the party of low taxes, the Liberal opposition voted against Labor’s ...
Conflict Billionaires + Corrupted Government = Chaos Incorporated (and, frankly, possible species extinction at this rate). That’s the formula, and it keeps being rolled out. Today’s ultra-rich, trans-national entities and individual billionaire CEO’s have amassed wealth and power far, far in excess of those who were around in the ...
A listing of 23 news and opinion articles we found interesting and shared on social media during the past week: Sun, April 27, 2025 thru Sat, May 3, 2025. This week's roundup is again published by category and sorted by number of articles included in each. The formatting is a ...
Peter Dutton absorbs his loss in the Australian federal election. The fact that the ‘Trumpian’ candidates in both the Canadian and Australia elections lost not only the leadership vote but also their own seats must be giving pause to politicians here who may have thought Trump had a winning formula. ...
Rupert Murdoch’s Sky News was still trying to attack Anthony Albanese last night.Headlines on the channel replayed Albanese falling off a stage on the campaign trail. Apparently he “lied”, they said, and that was a negative for Rupert Murdoch’s commentators, who had spun out multiple videos and negative headlines based ...
The 2025 federal election wasn’t just a contest of political ideas; it was a bloody massacre, with Peter Dutton’s Liberal-National Coalition copping a hiding so severe it’s left them scrambling for the smelling salts. The opposition leader’s loss of his own seat of Dickson (held for 24 years) to Labor’s ...
When you came along boy, you were different from the restNever tried to hurt me like so many men beforeMade me feel important, something special in your eyeKnowing that you care for me has made me come aliveSongwriters: Garry Paige and Mark Punch.The headline in the Guardian this morning sums ...
On 14 May 1986, Paul Keating gave one of the most consequential political interviews in Australian history. He was interviewed by John Laws of 2UE, in the pre-internet era when talkback radio was dominant, and ...
Note: This blog post will be updated during EGU25 happening in Vienna from April 28 to May 2. Should recordings of the Great Debates and possibly Union Symposia mentioned below, be released sometime after the conference ends, I'll include links to the ones I participated in. This year's General Assembly of ...
Thanks to Michael Pezzullo’s Strategist article last month, we now know that Australia’s 2009 defence white paper foresaw our risky future and planned for it. The white paper’s outlook for Chinese force development and the ...
A major American study suggests they are not?This column is about the white working class. In the US 2024 elections they mainly voted for Donald Trump. Had they voted with the white middle class, Trump would have lost the election with only 42 percent of voters instead of the 50 ...
The Albanese government’s announcement of a $1.2 billion critical minerals strategic stockpile marks an important step towards securing Australia’s economic future. Yet history warns us that simply building supply is insufficient: market volatility, fragmented value ...
Australia’s two major parties are divided over nuclear energy and the future mix of the nation’s power sources. But they are missing Australia’s opportunity to power the next generation of AI models. During the election ...
Australia’s future prosperity will not be built on nostalgia for past booms. It’ll be forged in the critical supply chains of tomorrow. That’s why Prime Minister Anthony Albanese’s announcement of a $1.2 billion Critical Minerals Strategic ...
Sorry folks, I sent the wrong version out earlier. This video is the right one - and it took a long time to re-upload it. I’ve deleted the last post, if you’ve commented, please can you transfer it over. My apologies! - MTAs a relative newcomer to politics, I often ...
'Cause you know and I knowIt'll be fluctuating forеver yeah yeah yеahIt's the way it goHigh tide and then it's lowYou build it up and the wind blows and blows it down downdown down downSong: Casual Healing.Morena folks, this morning, we're taking a lighter look at some of the good ...
On 22 May, the coalition government will release its budget for 2025, which it says will focus on "boosting economic growth, improving social outcomes, controlling government spending, and investing in long-term infrastructure.” But who, really, is this budget designed to serve? What values and visions for Aotearoa New Zealand lie ...
Australia needs to develop a new veteran affairs strategy. Failure to do so will worsen the Australian Defence Force’s recruiting crisis, increase separations from service, and grow cynicism from families and taxpayers about how government ...
1. What did Nicola Willis say this week about her budget?a. There will be no lolly scrambleb.Do or do not. There is no tryc.Get in losers, we're going shoppingd. Is butter a carb?2. What was the full price of a 500g block of Anchor Butter at Woolworths on ...
Simeon Brown’s latest sleight of hand over Dunedin Hospital’s ICU beds isn’t fooling anyone who values the truth. The government’s plan to slash the number of ICU beds from 30 to 20 has been exposed, yet Brown insists there’s no real reduction. His reasoning? Both plans allow for a potential ...
Already fearful over austerity measures and the repeal of smokefree legislation, doctors now say patients are dying from ‘third world diseases’. Photo: Lynn Grieveson/Getty ImagesBriefly in our political economy of housing, poverty and climate on Friday, May 2:Waikato Hospital doctors say patients are dying from ‘third world diseases’ and the ...
After 100 days of action, US President Donald Trump’s national security strategy is coming into focus. His second presidency appears to embrace a ‘peace through strength’ approach, as first suggested by US Senator Roger Wicker ...
Hi,I usually try to keep Webworm laser focussed, for my own sanity — and yours. Not today. This is going to be an edition of stray thoughts and finds, and I hope you’ll bear with me.Thanks for sticking with me through that hard read about megachurch abuse on Monday. These ...
The podcast above of the weekly ‘Hoon’ webinar for paying subscribers on Thursday night features co-hosts & talking about the week’s news with regular and special guests, including: on news Tony Blair suggested giving up on net zero targets, on the debate about whether a full transition to ...
The only spectre haunting Anthony Albanese’s government going into Election Day tomorrow will be the way the polls got wrong the likely 2019 election outcome. Back then, the Scott Morrison government got re-elected in an upset result. Opposition leader Peter Dutton is clinging to that precedent, in hope of a ...
Open access notablesPublic opposition to coal-fired power in emerging economies, Alkon et al., Energy Policy:Constructing new coal fired power plants presents significant climate, ecological, health, and economic risks. This presents sometimes acute tradeoffs for leaders in emerging economies, where rapid economic and population growth are driving large increases ...
In early April, Victorian Supreme Court Justice James Elliot ruled that Abdul Nacer Benbrika—Australia’s most notorious terrorist and the architect of a planned mass-casualty attack on the Melbourne Cricket Ground in 2005—continued to pose an ...
The StrategistBy John Coyne, Henry Campbell and Justin Bassi
M-A-Y-D-A-YMayday, maydayM-A-Y-D-A-YMayday, maydayAnd so the days go on and onAnd I don't know if I can carry on much longerI just need a signAnything honey, just give me a signSongwriter: Ian Parton.The rain was heavy just after nine thirty this morning, and I thought, “Hmm, maybe this isn’t the best ...
Sea state An Australian contingent participated in Exercise Bersama Shield on 17-22 April, joining with forces from Britain, New Zealand, Malaysia and Singapore in a simulated defence operation around the Malay Peninsula. The exercise focused ...
The StrategistBy Linus Cohen, Astrid Young and Alice Wai
In the week of Australia’s 3 May election, ASPI released Agenda for Change 2025: preparedness and resilience in an uncertain world, a report developed for the next government and to promote public debate and understanding ...
Australian police officer Amy ScottMay Day Striking doctors outside Auckland hospital (1News)Today over 5000 senior doctors, surgeons, dentists and specialists around the country strike, not for themselves, but for the public health system. Vacancies are critical. Resourcing has never been as bad as the last year. Many doctors are stretched ...
It’s a staple of screenwriters and novelists, stock news footage and a spectre haunting ambassadors’ dreams: a spy unmasked; riots outside embassies, flags and effigies alight; newspaper headlines blaring outrage; and the chilling words persona ...
It’s not every day you see a so-called “human rights” figure spew racist rhetoric so toxic it could curdle milk, but Stephen Rainbow, New Zealand’s Chief Human Rights Commissioner, has outdone himself. This week, he’s earned the coveted Arsehole of the Week Award for his rancid claim that Muslim immigration ...
Briefly this morning in Aotearoa’s political economy: Nicola Willis may be about to means test the Government’s already-reduced $251 per person per year KiwiSaver contribution in Budget 2025.Air New Zealand lowers its emissions reduction target to barely 20% by 2030.The Commerce Commission says a market study of Air New Zealand’s ...
Sceptics of AUKUS Pillar 1, the nuclear-submarine element of the Australian-UK-US defence technology partnership, have called on the Australian government to go for a Plan B. Proposed alternatives have included buying nuclear submarines of French ...
Completed reads for April: The Gospel of Thomas, by Didymus Jude Thomas The Gospel of Mary (fragmentary) The Gospel of Judas The Infancy Gospel of James The Gospel of Peter The Stranger’s Book (fragmentary) Obviously a very quiet month in terms of reading. In fairness, real life and ...
This is a re-post from the Climate Brink by Andrew DesslerAs readers of this Substack will know, I've been increasingly concerned about the destruction of one of America’s greatest competitive advantages: our university research system. Recently, the Trump administration announced that they were going to cut university overhead rates to ...
Indonesia’s low-key rejection of reported Russian interest in military basing in Papua says more than it appears to. While Jakarta’s response was measured, it was deliberate—a calculated expression of Indonesia’s foreign policy doctrine of non-alignment, ...
In the week of Australia’s 3 May election, ASPI released Agenda for Change 2025: preparedness and resilience in an uncertain world, a report developed for the next government and to promote public debate and understanding ...
On 27 January 1973, the conflict in Vietnam was brought to an end with the formal signing in Paris of the Agreement on Ending the War and Restoring the Peace in Vietnam by four parties: ...
Back in 2018, Aotearoa was in the midst of the Operation Burnham inquiry. During this, it emerged that key evidence was subject to a US veto under an obscure and secret treaty. Part of the Five Eyes arrangement, this treaty was referred to by a number of different names in ...
I hate to sound the alarm, but New Zealand’s economy is teetering on the edge, and Finance Minister Nicola Willis is wielding her austerity axe with a reckless abandon that could plunge us into a prolonged recession. The 2025 Budget, with its brutal $1.1 billion reduction in baseline spending, is ...
I hate to sound the alarm, but New Zealand’s economy is teetering on the edge, and Finance Minister Nicola Willis is wielding her austerity axe with a reckless abandon that could plunge us into a prolonged recession. The 2025 Budget, with its brutal $1.1 billion reduction in baseline spending, is ...
Crime Pays for the PoliticiansThis morning, Paul Goldsmith, the Minister who wants Te Reo Maori scrubbed, announced that prisoners who are serving terms of less than 3 years be barred from voting. From left, Police Minister Mark Mitchell, Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith & Mental Health Minister Matt DooceyNZ’s Electoral Review ...
Well, I can't see and I can't hearThey've burnt out all the feelingsAnd I never been so crazy, and it's just my second yearFour walls, wash basinFour walls, wash basinFour walls, wash basin, prison bedSongwriter: Don Walker.The coalition parties are mulling the austerity budget they will soon put to the ...
First, hats off to Tory Whanau. Her decision to bow out and run for the Māori ward instead, putting the city’s future above her personal ambition, is commendable. Facing a torrent of personal abuse and a council mired in chaos, she still delivered on water investment, cycleways, and housing reforms. ...
Trump Kills A Sure-ThingIn Canada, the Conservatives fell from a 21 point lead a few months ago to a decisive loss yesterday. The Canadian Liberals are ~ 2 to 3 seats short of a majority, which means PM Mark Carney but will still need to work through opposition parties ...
Australia’s cost-of-living election has a khaki tinge and an uneasy international tone. You know defence is having an impact when a political party promises to raise taxes to buy more military kit, and makes defence ...
The Waitākere Ranges, a stunning natural taonga west of Auckland, are at the heart of a brewing controversy that’s exposing the ugly underbelly of New Zealand’s political discourse. A proposed deed of acknowledgement, grounded in the Waitākere Ranges Heritage Area Act 2008, aims to establish a joint decision-making committee with ...
I spoke last night with Simplicity Chief Economist and Head of Policy about the Government's latest budget policy tightening, the risks for infrastructure investment and a potential dampening of GDP growth.He points out that the Government has cut capital expenditure so far in the current financial year, rather than ...
The Ukrainian air force went to war against invading Russian forces in February 2022 with just 125 combat aircraft concentrated at around a dozen large bases. Given Russia’s overwhelming deep-strike advantage—hundreds of deployed warplanes and ...
Briefly this morning: Nicola Willis rules out charities tax or any tax hike to reduce budget deficit. She’s focused instead on spending cuts. There are 1,000 at-risk kids without a social worker, NZ Herald reports.Housing shortages are a factor in high-risk sex offenders being put out early into uncontrolled community ...
Truly, these are tough times for our nation’s leaders. In future, how on earth are they going to find the sort of money they’ve been happy to throw at landlords, tobacco companies, and wealthier New Zealanders ever since they got elected? On Defence, how are they going to find those ...
A couple of months ago now I wrote a post about the new set of discount rates government agencies are supposed to use in undertaking cost-benefit analysis, whether for new spending projects or for regulatory initiatives. The new, radically altered, framework had come into effect from 1 October last year, ...
Huawei dominates Indonesia’s telecommunication network infrastructure. It won over Indonesia mainly through cost competitiveness and by generating favour through capacity-building programs and strategic relationships with the government, and telecommunication operators. But Huawei’s dominance poses risks. ...
Democracy and the liberal tradition have long been seen as among the most basic tenets of the American way of life. They are also the main reason the West has for the past 80 years ...
Nicola Willis continues to compare the economy to a household needing to tighten its belt to survive. Photo: Getty Images The key long stories short in Aotearoa’s political economy around housing, climate and poverty on Tuesday, April 29 are: Nicola Willis today announced a cut in the Government’s new spending ...
The Herald had another announcement today about a new solar farm being officially opened - this time the 63MW Lauriston solar farm in Canterbury. It is of course briefly "NZ’s biggest solar farm", but it will soon be overtaken by Kōwhai park at Christchurch airport (168MW) and Tauhei (202MW), both ...
I woke this morning to the shock news that Tory Whanau was no longer contesting the Wellington mayoralty, having stepped aside to leave the field clear for Andrew Little. Its like a perverse reversal of Little's 2017 decision to step aside for Jacinda - the stale, pale past rudely shoving ...
In a pre-Budget speech this morning the Minister of Finance announced that this year’s operating allowance – the net amount available for new initiatives – was being reduced from $2.4 billion to $1.3 billion (speech here, RNZ story here). Operating allowance numbers in isolation don’t mean a great deal (what ...
Te Pāti Māori warns that the Government’s Treaty Clause Review represents the most severe erosion of iwi rights in modern legal history. “Luxon's Government is doing what the Treaty Principles Bill failed to do. They are removing every legal reference to Te Tiriti across health, housing, conservation, and child wellbeing ...
After failing to be upfront about cuts to intensive care beds, it’s now becoming clear that other downgrades to Dunedin Hospital are being concealed by the Minister of Health. ...
Te Pāti Māori stands firmly against any moves to downsize or close UCOL Whanganui. With over 30% of students identifying as Māori, the campus is a vital lifeline for education, upskilling, and community transformation in Te Tai Hauāuru. “Matapihi ki te Ao is more than a name, it’s a promise. ...
Te Pāti Māori spokesperson for Broadcasting, Tākuta Ferris, and MP for Tāmaki Makaurau, Takutai Tarsh Kemp, are demanding the Government significantly increase its investment in Whakaata Māori in Budget 2025. The call comes following the release of the network’s 2025 Social Value Report at an event today, attended by MP ...
The National Party’s announcement to reinstate a total ban on prisoner voting is a shameful step backwards. Denying the right to vote does not strengthen society — it weakens our democracy and breaches Te Tiriti o Waitangi. “Voting is not a privilege to be taken away — it is a ...
Nicola Willis announced that funding for almost every Government department will be frozen in this year’s budget, costing jobs, making access to public services harder, and fuelling an exodus of nurses, teachers, and other public servants. ...
Right‑wing ministers are waging a campaign to erase Māori health equity by tearing out its very foundations. ACT’s Todd Stephenson dismisses Treaty‑based nursing standards as “off‑track distractions” and insists nurses only need “skill and a kind heart,” despite clear evidence that cultural competence saves lives. Health Minister Simeon Brown’s funding cuts, hiring ...
The Government’s Budget looks set to usher in a new age of austerity. This morning, Minister of Finance Nicola Willis said new spending would be limited to $1.4 billion, cut back from the original intended $2.4 billion, which itself was already $100 million below what Treasury said was needed to ...
The Green Party has renewed its call for the Government to ban the use, supply, and manufacture of engineered stone products, as the CTU launches a petition for the implementation of a full ban. ...
Te Pāti Māori are appalled by Cabinet's decision to agree to 15 recommendations to the Early Childhood Education (ECE) sector following the regulatory review by the Ministry of Regulation. We emphasise the need to prioritise tamariki Māori in Early Childhood Education, conducted by education experts- not economists. “Our mokopuna deserve ...
The Government must support Northland hapū who have resorted to rakes and buckets to try to control a devastating invasive seaweed that threatens the local economy and environment. ...
New Zealand First has today introduced a Member’s Bill that would ensure the biological definition of a woman and man are defined in law. “This is not about being anti-anyone or anti-anything. This is about ensuring we as a country focus on the facts of biology and protect the ...
After stonewalling requests for information on boot camps, the Government has now offered up a blog post right before Easter weekend rather than provide clarity on the pilot. ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Ross Yates, Lecturer, Project Management, Edith Cowan University Shutterstock Ever tried to explain why a sausage would be referred to as a “snag” while overseas, or why the toilet is the “dunny”? If you found this challenging, spare a thought for ...
Comment: The fight to preserve the New Zealand Herald’s editorial independence from an agitating Canadian-NZ investor has leapt out of the fire and into the frying pan with the likely appointment of former National minister Steven Joyce to chair its owner NZME.Joyce, who had played no public role so far ...
Labour Leader Chris Hipkins says there's no justification for Education Minister Erica Stanford to use her personal email address for work business. ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Michelle Cull, Associate Professor of Accounting and Financial Planning, Western Sydney University With a convincing win for a second term of government, the pressure is now on the new Labor government to deliver the economic policies central to its win. Prime Minister ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Yee-Fui Ng, Associate Professor, Faculty of Law, Monash University Dan Breckwoldt/Shutterstock Labor’s historic election victory means the Albanese government has a rare opportunity to pursue a big, bold reform agenda. The scale of the victory all but guarantees a third term ...
Australia’s election result shows the limits of culture-war campaigning and the power of the political centre – with lessons for both National and Labour, writes Catherine McGregor in today’s extract from The Bulletin. To receive The Bulletin in full each weekday, sign up here.The Trump effect – and its limits ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Dougal Sutherland, Clinical Psychologist, Te Herenga Waka — Victoria University of Wellington Leon Neal/Getty Images A new report from New Zealand’s Classification Office has revealed how young people are being exposed to harmful content online and what it is doing to ...
Comment: Sometimes it takes a circuit-breaker; a trip to the other side of the world to clear your head, re-energise, and gear up for a big moment.The past couple of weeks, during a longer-than-usual, three-week parliamentary recess, Christopher Luxon has been overseas, pressing the flesh with world leaders. This is ...
The people paid by Meta to prevent predatory scammers from targeting its users aren’t doing a great job, so Facebook scam ad aficionado Dylan Reeves puts the company’s new AI chatbot to the test.Mark Zuckerberg has apparently become less interested in his weird legless avatars floating around the metaverse, ...
They’re both young, female, progressive leaders whose career trajectories are intertwined with Andrew Little. But their strengths, weaknesses, governing style and political legacies couldn’t be more different. Windbag is The Spinoff’s Wellington issues column, written by Wellington editor Joel MacManus. Subscribe to the Windbag newsletter to receive columns early. It was July ...
Analysis: The original ethical commitments of the World Health Organisation’s pandemic treaty have been dramatically eroded during the recently concluded negotiation process.The treaty was established in response to the Covid-19 pandemic and aims to strengthen global collaboration on prevention, preparedness and response to pandemic threats.Our research identifies a series of ...
NewsroomBy Dr Elizabeth Fenton, Professor John Crump and Emma Anderson
The Finance Minister says there will be no Budget Day piñata, so what could go, and what will survive Budget ’25? The post What could the Govt cut this Budget? appeared first on Newsroom. ...
Analysis: The use of technology in health is one of the fastest evolving areas in the digital revolution, and asthma is no exception. From cough monitors, smart inhalers to digital peak flow meters, digital tools are transforming the asthma journey for patients and health providers alike, potentially revolutionising the way ...
Alison Wong: I first met Catherine in the early 1990s when we both took a community education creative writing class run by Chris and Barbara Else. As part of the course Chris took us through the Myers-Briggs Personality Type Indicator test, explaining that our personality type influenced how we wrote. ...
More than $30 million has been bet on who will be the next pope, in what has been called the most unpredictable conclave yet.But one thing is certain, the winner won’t be a woman.With the conclave to begin on May 7 when 133 cardinals start to vote on Francis’ successor, ...
Report by Dr David Robie – Café Pacific. – COMMENTARY: By Caitlin Johnstone Benjamin Netanyahu said last Thursday that freeing the Israeli hostages in Gaza was not his top priority, suggesting instead that defeating Hamas should take precedence over a hostage deal. “We have many objectives, many goals in ...
RNZ Pacific The head of Fiji’s prison service has been caught on camera involved in a fist fight that appears to have taken place at the popular O’Reilley’s Bar in the capital of Suva. Sevuloni Naucukidi, the acting Commissioner of the Fiji Corrections Service (FCS), can be seen in the ...
By Kalafi Moala in Nuku’alofa On this World Press Freedom Day, we in the Pacific stand together to defend and promote the right to freedom of expression — now facing new and complex challenges in the age of Artificial Intelligence (AI). This year’s global theme is “Reporting a Brave New ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Adrian Beaumont, Election Analyst (Psephologist) at The Conversation; and Honorary Associate, School of Mathematics and Statistics, The University of Melbourne With 78% of enrolled voters counted, the ABC is calling 85 of the 150 House of Representatives seats for Labor, 39 for ...
By Michelle Curran of Pasifika TVWorld Press Freedom Day is a poignant reminder that journalists and media workers are essential for a healthy, functioning society — including the Pacific. Held annually on May 3, World Press Freedom Day prompts governments about the need to respect press freedom, while serving ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra It took an election win, but Anthony Albanese on Monday finally received that much-awaited phone call from US President Donald Trump. The conversation was “warm and positive,” the prime minister told a news conference, ...
ANALYSIS:By Matthew Ricketson, Deakin University and Andrew Dodd, The University of Melbourne Among the many lessons to be learnt by Australia’s defeated Liberal-National coalition parties from the election is that they should stop getting into bed with News Corporation. Why would a political party outsource its policy platform and ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Vincent Ho, Associate Professor and Clinical Academic Gastroenterologist, Western Sydney University Lordn/Shutterstock Coeliac disease is not a food allergy or intolerance. It’s an autoimmune disease that makes the body attack the small intestine if gluten (a protein found in wheat, rye ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Joanne Wallis, Professor of International Security, University of Adelaide The re-election of the Albanese Labor government by such a wide margin should not mean “business as usual” for Australia’s security policy. The global uncertainty instigated by US President Donald Trump means ...
Following the US president’s announcement of a 100% tariff on all films made ‘in foreign lands’, the local screen industry has been left concerned – if not slightly confused. Only 3.2% of The Spinoff’s readership supports us financially. We need to grow that to 4% ...
Annual donations to political parties published today show larger amounts than in the past, with new rules requiring smaller donations to be reported. ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Lisa M. Given, Professor of Information Sciences & Director, Social Change Enabling Impact Platform, RMIT University More than 18 million Australians voted on Saturday, after walking past countless corflutes, reading campaign flyers and reviewing how-to-vote cards. The 2025 federal election was ...
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Toby Slade, Associate Professor of Fashion, University of Technology Sydney Portrait of a Man, c. 1855National Gallery of Art Fashion is one of the most powerful tools we have for understanding ourselves and the world around us. Nowhere is this clearer ...
http://www.theaudience.co.nz/the-al1en/the-faeces-of-the-species-1/
Click the link, and vote to get NZonAir funding.
One more day, one more lie, one more smile, one more wave.
Some old joke wants my vote. Aspirational fail.
Did you see on TV? The third world disease on her face.
Unlike me, all you see, are scabs not your first world disgrace.
You’re the faeces of the species, you’re the disease, you’re the plague on the face of that girl.
You’re the hunger, you’re the plunder, all asunder, heaven wonder if there’s oil on the moon (in our bones).
You’re the statistic, optimistic, pessimist e-con-o-mystic, you’re the waste in the space.
Merchant banker, supertanker, deep drill wanker, pull your anchor, just get out of the way.
And we’ll rise. And when we rise up.
We will sing, and we will be glorious.
One more try, one more bribe, one more tea for your friend.
Some old bloke on a rope while they bury his dead.
Did you see on tv? The mould on kids in their bed.
Unlike me, all you see, is dirt and the profits from rent.
You’re the faeces of the species, you’re a disease, you’re a plague on the backs of us all.
You’re the sadistic, little twisted, first world gifted, Mi-pad whiz kid, the foul wind in the sales.
You’re the hunter, you’re the blunder, toxic numbers, six foot under, and you’re the slag of good grace.
Mother cluster, bunker buster, colonel mustard, general custard, just get out of our way.
And we’ll rise. And when we rise up.
We will sing, and we will be glorious.
19 on the daily chart, 304 on the wildcard chart, from two votes.
We’re all lefties here, right? we’re all anti poverty and pro children in need, right?
Two clicks, and you don’t even have to listen to the song to vote.
Pass the link around, and we’ll all have played a part in forcing the issue of child hunger and inept government in NZ in the faces of a head under the cover, not really listening public.
Surely you can see what the songs about, so please click to fight to win.
Click what Alien? I’ve followed the link twice and still can’t figure out how to vote.
Thanks for that, mate.
Underneath the title and band name, there’s an orange ‘vote’ button
Or click or mouse over the Al1en head picture and there’s an orange java vote button.
I’d do a screenshot if I knew how post it.
You can vote everyday until we win.
Viva revolution.
278 on the wildcard chart from 5 votes.
I’ve voted now. Thanks for telling us how. I couldn’t work it out either.
Funny isn’t it? You put a bright orange button with the word “vote” on it in the middle of a sparsely decorated page…
that’s not where that link takes me.
What do you see? js.
Your facebook page. I have to click on the picture to go further.
I have to to log in using my facebook details to access my profile, but if I log out, return to the site and dismiss the login screen, I always go straight to song page.
I don’t know why you can’t access the page, but I appreciate your efforts in trying.
Thanks.
That’s kind of you, thanks very much.
Sometimes I like a crooked day dream to keep me company at work.
My fave is the song does well using the government’s (ours) money, and the pm handing over an award at the tuis (or whatever they’re called), to a stunt double dressed in an alien suit, with the whole nation knowing it’s about his premiership and him doing sod all to help our children out of poverty, live on TV.
It makes international news reels, and as we know, there’s no such thing as bad, free publicity.
Then my boss comes and wakes me and tells me he’s made my coffee.
Daily chart is updated at midnight, wildcard chart by the hour.
So far, 242 with 6 votes.
A famous victory for the left slipping away.
Come on.
I voted. But it still asks for some silly flash player, I have never had any trouble playing anything from the net before It would be nice to know what I voted for
why wont it play??
I don’t know why it won’t play for you, but cheers for the solidarity.
If you want to hear the track it’s also up at https://soundcloud.com/theal1en/the-faeces-of-the-species
But don’t blame me if you can’t sleep tonight.
My respect to all those who have voted.
231 after 7 votes.
You see how easy this could be to win if the just the site stalwarts here gifted a daily vote over the next couple of weeks.
Tell your friends, use the pc at work and home and we could all be having a right old laugh at Teflon john expense.
I don’t want to spam more than I have, and certainly don’t want to wear out my welcome here, so for bearing with me, ta very much.
Actually I think you are ranked 220…
You must have just hit the hourly change over.
Cheers for looking out for me
Just in case anybody is still awake and or interested, I’ve made a Dr Evil pic to accompany the vote link if anyone wants it.
Right click, save as, and email away. http://www.al1en.org
And I’m serious, or one million dollars.
Always looking out for you mate. This Viper has your six.
Now lost amongst dead open mikes.
Got up to 7 in the daily chart and 168 on the chart that counts – The wildcard chart.
14 plays and 9 votes.
Not bad for a days revolutioneering. Thanks comrades.
Now please, do it again, and tell a friend.
Puff piece in the Herald today on Maggie Barry, written by Audrey Young, headlined ‘Maggie’s Way’.
A Q&A style article. She talks about the insults and bullying nature of parliament and it’s from her point of view all Labour’s fault. Gets politely and super lightly called on insulting and bullying Jacinda Adern, and it turns out it’s all because of Trevor Mallard twitter twatting or something.
Maggie doesn’t do insults or bullying, neither does National, its all Labour and the Greens fault. Of course Young leaves that and moves on to bigger more pressing issues.
Which MP outside your party impresses you?
That’s a hard one. Can I get back to you on that? That’s a really hard one.
Classy, there are good people on both sides of the house doing good work and you can’t even mention one, you f&^*ing work there on committees with these people . Says more about Barry than any of her other answers.
Maggie this may be the zenith of your political career, may your years of seat warming ahead be good for your garden.
This article was so light and fluffy from our hard hitting gallery journo I think the paper floated in from the letterbox this morning on its own.
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/politics/news/article.cfm?c_id=280&objectid=10858622
“Which MP outside your party impresses you?”
All the Maori party mps, for services to the National party.
John Banks, that he’s still clinging on to his salary, despite everything that says he shouldn’t.
Simon Bridges, for carrying on and making the best of it, despite taking a severe beating with the wanker stick.
And last and very much least, Paula Bennett, for her continued support for NZ tent makers in these troubled times, and popularising the moo moo all over again, even if she does need help to zip it.
Audrey young doing her bit for the party her daddy served and her herald masters.
Maggie Barry is a vacuous nasty piece of work, can’t even shut the f up and learn the ropes. Finally got selected for one of the safest seats as they couldn’t risk her in anything less.
“I personally think that men and men and women and women should be allowed to marry if that’s what they want. Frankly, I don’t quite understand why they want to do it. I’ve never got married in my life.”
She even manages to screw up her pro-marriage equality stance. It’s like a pre-women’s vote man telling a woman ‘I don’t know why you want the right to vote, I’ve never done it’.
Yes Maggie, we shouldn’t marry because you think it’s silly.
Im sure blokes all over the country will be breathing a sigh of relief, dont know why anyone would want to marry her…
Saw the headline, and figured I wanted to keep my breakfast.
No wonder our young are heading to Aussie, if this story is anything to go by.
Headline on the Herald : Student loan debtor: I’m better off in OZ.
In NZ a borrower has to pay back $10.000 a year,across the Tasman it’s only $3.000
Sorry i can’t link the story..
Here’s the link vivaciousviper:
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=10858618
Thanks for linking Olwyn (:
On the subject of student loan defaulters, I have no idea why the IRD cannot just make an agreement with the tax collection agencies of the UK, USA, Ireland, and Aus to have the student debt recovered through their respective tax systems?
Probably because those countries want nothing to change. At the moment, they get all our educated people improving their economy / society.
Not only would it cost their tax systems to chase kiwis, but it would stem the tide of highly educated people working within their country.
http://asianinvasion2006.blogspot.co.nz/2013/01/labour-struggles-with-its-direction.html
I wasn’t sure where to post the above. It is a blog by Cactus Kate, primarily abut Karol’s post, ‘State Housing versus Home Ownership’.
I haven’t left a teaser, it’s all pretty interesting.
Am half way through, yes it is interesting, but for the rest of the weekend can we please refer to Cactus Kate as “Cactus Kate”?
Sorry? You’ll have to explain.
“Cactus” decided to call Karol “Karol”.
Ahhh. Missed it. Ta.
And as for the delusion that anyone in their right mind would mistake “Cactus Kate” for QoT. And to say the least QoT makes way more sense.
I’m a bit stunned, I agree with almost everything “Cactus Kate” is saying.
It’s possibly an impostor writing. Maybe QoT.
She has paid homage to QoT I notice…..
(as is only fitting).
I don’t know how anyone could really confuse the two though, the writing styles are worlds apart. “Cactus Kate” is just a horrible bogan wrapped in a logical fallacy.
I actually quite like Cactus’s writing. Sure she is a right wing bogan but at least she is an up front bogan and she writes and thinks rationally. Her principles may be different to ours but at least she has some principles. And unlike Key she is exactly who she is. There is not pretension. She is not trying to make out she is something she is not.
I wish more right wingers were like that.
That’s very true micky, and I don’t doubt her sincerity one bit. She’s a straight up honest bastard.
However she does rely on some pretty flimsy logic. For example on RNZ she tried to argue that Matt McCarten shouldn’t criticise the operators of the Pike River mine because he wouldn’t want to run a mine himself.
Also there are times I think a responsible host should hide the keys to her computer…
That is a horrible accusation. I have never been on red radio.
And you’ve misrepresented the comments I did actually make on another station which were in relation to a defamatory comment made by another guest. One who consistently accuses directors of companies of all manner of bad behaviour, so I was merely making a point that it is not as easy and glamorously well remunerated that he may think it is and if it was he should be a mining company director.
Sorry, radio live perhaps?
But yes, that’s precisely the logical fallacy to which I refer. Thanks for restating it.
Should have stood on the ACT list IMO.
What is the world coming to, with Hooton cheer leading for team Shearer, and Cactus Kate arguing (albeit in a nuanced sense) in favour of team Cunliffe. As I read her, she wants to see actual political engagement and a proper battle of ideas, rather than both left and right racing to see who can do the best job of cosseting the middle class. And I have to say, it is a lovely piece of writing.
That’s the difference between Hooten and “Cactus”
“it is a lovely piece of writing.”
Maybe I’m just not used to her writing style, but I found myself repeatedly tripping over her use of grammar.
Yes, on re-reading I noticed a couple of grammatical mistakes as well, but her arguments were clearly thought out and hung together well.
Odgers can’t write to save herself. I find her at times close to illiterate. On top of this, no matter how much she tries to dress things up for her audience, her words are invariably littered with a belief that greed is good and spiked with a hatred for anyone she thinks may impede that pursuit. I would’ve loved to have seen her in parliament, getting roasted on a daily basis, away from the safety of her computer screen. Small fish in an even smaller pond.
Maybe concentrate on the subject matter, and add some value into a discussion that way.
Small picture types are one reason this country has become a joke!
Grammar – It’s not going to halt the county’s decline!
+1
Communication is a two way street. If you want to get your point across, grammar can help.
Of all the things to talk about you are all hung up on whinging about grammar and calling me a bogan.
Little wonder Cunliffe cannot gain momentum in a working class party.
His supporters are a bunch of snobby toffs.
Fair cop.
http://paintingthegreyarea.wordpress.com/2012/11/26/literacy-privilege/
This kind of grammar policing, of anyone, really makes me cringe. The style of my writing is often poor and ungrammatical. Yet somehow, I feel entitled to have my say. If I felt insecure about all this, as so many people do, reading these kinds of comments would make me even more reticent about participating in conversations at the Standard.
Looks like you’re hung up on issues with your bad writing, too. There was this, you know:
“On top of this, no matter how much she tries to dress things up for her audience, her words are invariably littered with a belief that greed is good and spiked with a hatred for anyone she thinks may impede that pursuit.”
Who are you replying to, Mary?
I hope you aren’t implying that those who are put off speaking out by comments deriding others for their writing deficits, are just being “oversensitive”.
No, just saying, it’s a response to Cactus Kate Viper who seems to think the focus of comments here is her bad grammar. It’s not.
Have another look at of what I said and see if you can see where the emphasis is.
I’m never too bothered about clumsy or wrong grammar, but “CK’s” summary of my post as:
The silly policy to build homes for middle class kiddies screaming poverty is an excellent example of this Cunliffe v Shearer tension. “Karol” has an excellent post on this and has thought of the conspiracy that capitalism in fact is to blame in forcing this idea that owning your own home is aspirational to all.
…. is just inaccurate, whether as result of clumsy use of words, or just a poor interpretation. I was critical of the political position and policy of the current Labour caucus leadership (Team Shearer really), but I’m pretty sure I never referred to Cunliffe directly or indirectly in my ‘state housing vs home ownership’ post. And “conspiracy” is not what I think of when I am writing about the way the loose networks of the wealthy and powerful operate to further their own interests.
So she doesn’t have much of an idea of what I was thinking, but then maybe the entity that is “karol” is just a quotation, a figment of someone’s (or some group’s) imagination?
You’re being far too charitable, Karol. Anyone who refers to the poor as the “pathetic heaving underclass”, believes beneficiaries should be paid not to “breed” and thinks Slater’s blog has anything to offer other than a window into how nasty the right can get can’t be taken seriously. Just as QoT saw the hook in Fran O’Sullivan’s piece, no matter how hard she tries Odgers cannot help but let her true colours show, even when she posts on The Standard as happened again throughout today. I do not see how some on the Left can place genuine value in anything she says.
There were some points of agreement between my views on home ownership & CK’s, but she went off on her own little tangent about the (allegedly continuing) Cunliffe-Shearer tension.
I’m more curious as to why TS suddenly got so much attention over the last 24 hours or so, from CK, MH, and a Labour MP and an LP policy person. Some things seem to be bubbling away out of my sight. Yes, FO’S was still being pretty right wing, but, also seemed to shift her position somewhat.
I’m wondering if it’s part of a growing sense of uncertainty about changes happening that some political people feel they are losing control of. While some may be just trying to manoeuvre so they’ll be in a relatively favourable position when the dust settles.
And February is approaching fast.
Hi weka, the game is far bigger than February, important as that is. Leaders come and go, MPs come and go, neither Shearer nor Cunliffe will be relevant 10-15 years from now. The real sea change has to happen at the Labour membership and constitutional level. And we’ve only just started.
As I read her, she sees the Shearer/Cunliffe tension as arising from the courting of the middle class by the Shearer people, and the desire for a genuinely left orientation by a lot of left wing people. And she sees the housing policy and your response to it as exemplifying this tension. But I agree that beyond those points, she does go off on her own tangent.
Paying homage to a greater being, self preservation being the aim. That’s the base level she operates on.
I think I’m meant to be hurt that “Cactus Kate” has noticed I get angry sometimes. How very unladylike of me.
(And interestingly *I* don’t get scarequotes on my name, which is nice and revealing about why “Kate” applies them to karol.)
It’s a white flag QoT. CK doesn’t want to get into any debate she is guaranteed to lose and that’s any debate with you.
Take it as a compliment.
Oh, I do. It would be quite a debate though, the epic battle of Chaotic Good vs Chaotic Neutral.
Maye because she knows that Karol wont tell her to Fark off!!
The same here. Now I too want to know who wrote that article because it dont look at all like the usual “Cactus Kate” stuff.
Queue some b/s about ck’s post being proof positive that ‘misguided’ types of the left are unwittingly in cahoots with portions of the right and in effect undermining the ‘nice’ Labour Party just as the ‘right’ wants, and how every one counted within the ‘misguided left’ ought now, and once and for all, STFU.
In fact. Haven’t I already read that line somewhere here at ts?
Indeed.
And if you replace “STFU” with “resign the leadership”, you’ll have it in both directions.
Does ‘indeed’ indicate you think that’s a reasonable line to spin, McFlock? The reason I ask is your follow-on, which I guess is attempting to posit the opposite of what I’d call a b/s line. And it’s another b/s line. No-one is calling on DS to resign the leadership. But lots of people are wanting to see democracy really exist within the Labour Party. And, I guess, pressure might be applied to mp’s who’d rather deny democracy in Feb.
Now, you might not agree with that sentiment or goal. Fine. But don’t mis-call it as a call for DS to resign.
Well, I have seen arguments that posit Hooten’s support for shearer is evidence that shearer is not fit to be leader.
If I were to make a similar quibble about your phrasing, I don’t recall seeing anyone here specifically demand that critics of the Labour party should “STFU”.
Fran is off the reservation, calling for the “the top personal tax break” to be cancelled amoungst other heresies: http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=10858589
Another impostor!
Must have banged Her head on something, Fran is just about demanding a Socialist solution to ‘youth unemployment’ from a Tory Government no less,
Wonder if Slippery lost control of His bowels when He read that lot this morning…
Ah, but if you read carefully, bad, you’ll see that Fran’s concerns are actually about “gaps in the NZ workforce”.
So solving youth unemployment is really just a side effect of her real goal, helping NZ businesses recruit.
Wonder if Slippery lost control of His bowels when He read that lot this morning…
That could lead to an awful mess, considering the lack of toilets on Planet Key.
Yep things are getting really strange. Chris Trotter thinks the nats have a mandate to sell our assets and the right are calling for tax increases for the wealthy.
What is going on?
Has it ever occurred to any of you lot that most people don’t have a blindly ideological approach to every issue unlike yourselves – that there are good points and bad points to both sides of most given arguments? That most peoples views may shift back and forth somewhat over time?
I guess it is because you lot are in constant battle mode fighting the good war against the forces of evil, you have developed an us vs them mentality – “you are either with us or against us!”.
You are left exasperated an confused when you can’t squeeze someone into one of a few pigeon holes.
Has it ever occurred to you that us lot don’t give one big fat f**k what you ‘think’ and we only tolerate you as an object of mirth to bestow the odd piece of spittle upon when we have run out of jokes about the Prime Minister Slippery’s bad habit of public displays of ‘spastic dancing’…
Yet another good illustration of why the Left is so broken it can’t even grab the ball of a team of drop kicks ie the Nats.
Goran Therborn
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G%C3%B6ran_Therborn
Neo marxism is dead in the water – who’s suppose to be the Agent of change since the proletariat failed to turn up to the party? Why should anyone believe that knowledge is only ever Historical never Universal?
So tell me KP is unfettered capitalism in a healthy state and just what this world needs?
Has it ever occurred to any of you lot that most people don’t have a blindly ideological approach to every issue unlike yourselves – that there are good points and bad points to both sides of most given arguments? That most peoples views may shift back and forth somewhat over time?
Sounds like poststructuralist mumbo-jumbo to me…isn’t that usually your target?
No its not poststructurlist, its Humanist. I believe there is an objective reality and objective universal values about ethics/justice.
Post structuralists/Deconstructionist/various Feminists splinter groups/Neo Marxists/Cultural Relativists/Multiculturalists – they all suffer from hyper relativism and symptoms of solipsism of varying severity.
Makes it hard to pin that lot down as they twist and squirm, grabbing a bit of this and a bit of that to create what can only be described as very bad philosophy.
well, that is where we part ways friend; existence precedes essence; consider the “existence” of people born with profound impairments (at Templeton there were “patients” that resembled sun-fish, to put it politely); consider the “essence” of so-called “schizophrenics”; I have followed your comments over the year, and like mine, there is nothing “objective” about them. (we need new lock-nuts)
You are putting forward an Existential argument, not a Post Modernist one.
Good example again of how the Left is in disarray.
Existentialism enjoyed brief popularity post WWII thanks to a French philosopher or 2. It descended into Nihilism fast and sank out of sight.
ciao
I believe there is an objective reality and objective universal values about ethics/justice.
Interesting statement.
It would be interesting to know where you stand – I’m picking neo-marxist, not that flakey Post Modernist stuff which I think QofT suffers from.
But like I said before you lot dart here and there depending on the direction of fire. Good tactic I guess as its harder to hit a moving target.
Ah, k-p, why so keen to put people in boxes? I do have difficulty following a party line or any one theory – the best still have their weaknesses. It depends on the context and the issue as to which is most useful. I am a little bit neo-Marxist and quite a bit post-structuralist. There are some things in postmodernism I agree with. There is no theory of everything. But I am for democratic socialism, social and economic justice/fairness, and am against violence, prejudice, persecution and oppression.
And I am for evidence-based research, knowledge, understanding and argument.
I do think there is an objectively (scientifically) verifiable material reality. I see objectivity as a process, not an end point. And it doesn’t necessarily cancel out subjectivity, especially when it comes to human activities and communications. Objectivity is haunted by subjectivity, as you demonstrated with that sentence of yours I quoted above. But, that’s the thing about language and human communications.
You seem to miss your own contradictions. “believing” in something is a subjective statement.
Yep. I’d say it’s an odd sort of humanism that fails to recognise that humans interpret reality both subjectively, and through socially constructed lenses.
not that flakey Post Modernist stuff which I think QofT suffers from.
No, please, do go on.
I’ll just be over here having a chuckle that you managed to get from “you stupid lefties just want to pigeonhole everyone” into “I bet you’re a neo-Marxist” in a mere six comments.
”i have never read the book,(Marx),tho i was told to take a look,i lifted my pool hall cue for another game”,
(Thanks to the Clash for the lines which i have gleefully altered with the addition of the Social/economists moniker),
LOLZ, my pidgeon hole is somewhere in the vicinity of Pol Pot, a Communizing Fascist,
Thanks to the good old New Zealand education tho i have the ability to realize that getting KP’s relatives to bang a four inch nail into the back of His head at gun-point just isn’t acceptable human behaviour so good old Post-Modernist,(whatever the fuck that means), me has had to accept simply being a Socialist…
PS, i think it all got lost in the translation for poor old Pol Pot, He thought it meant retribution when He was reading redistribution…
Trotter must have holidayed in one of those Batchs that have 50 year old lumpy couches!
He didn’t get a good rest and over stretched some of the points he was making.
Shearer should front foot the mercenary thing so that it is yesterday’s news by the time the Nats get their research ready for leaking through their usual channels
This is twilight zone stuff…are Right Wing commentators giving Key and English room to launch one or two definitively Left Wing policies? Can their strategy for 2014 be really this cunning? Mix in one or two headline Left Wing policies (top tax rate hike and youth employment/youth training programmes), and use it as cover for austerity and asset sell downs elsewhere?
I wonder if they have found in their polling that a lot of ordinary NZers – including the middle class – are worried that their kids can’t seem to get ahead and that there is a shortage of decent jobs and training opportunities.
Nah, it just won’t happen via a lift in the top tax rate, the Fed crowd would string English up by a very sensitive part of His anatomy in a rotary shed at the very thought of it,
The only invite Slippery would get from now until the little Shyster is given the kick would be from those wishing to have Him behave naturally,(dance like a clown),in their presence while they took pics to show off to the Grand-kids in their dotage,
The Bizness lobby would immediately stop calling, i think that if they are going to spend money on any sort of employment initiative,(or pretend to), the usual suspect will be trotted out, asset sales proceeds will have yet another attachment of ‘youth employment’ attached to it along with the continuously growing list of roading,health,schools,debt, blah blah blah,
Other than that if the Slippery little Shyster has half a brain He will be offering employers a years worth of dole payments as a ‘training allowance’ to actually employ a large number of the 24% of unemployed youth, possibly with a slight hint at a top tax rate rise…
Have people forgotten about the youth changes for 16-17 year olds?
Does one think it’s possible that that was setting the scene for harsher benefit conditions for all youth and more privatisation?
The right taketh more than they giveth so creating an enviornment where it seems that they are taking positive steps to address the issue may simply be a way of saying to people well now there’s no excuse to be on a benefit.
Bootcamps won’t work this time to get that 5% of swinging vote but the strategy surely won’t change – we’re offering this but if you don’t avail yourself of our wonderful opportunity then benefit damnation is yours.
Can their strategy really be this cunning? It sounds eerily like their 2008 me-to strategy. The must be getting a bit of polling feedback telling them to DO something.
This is what I reckon. Also, any PR headline increase in the top personal tax rate can be more than compensated for by drops in corporate and trust tax rates, see how it works
http://asianinvasion2006.blogspot.co.nz/2013/01/labour-struggles-with-its-direction.html?m=1
No, o revered one. I would not read Cactus Kate that way.
While she can be snappy, she never comes across as being anyone’s poodle.
Or they have all finally figured out that the Emperor really has no clothes
may I just pop in here?
I have made this letter longer than usual, only because I have not had time to make it shorter
(The last thing on knows when constructing a work is what to put first; continual eloquence is tedious) ;)-Blaise
WHAT WE CAN NEVER KNOW,or the collapsing hermeneutic (there’s your spiral)
-David Germez
“one could in the light of the fact that the divine life is itself a continued variation,,, apply to divinity in the most exalted sense the name of time. The old mythology of Chronos as primordial being and first divine principle seems thereby to be somehow in contact with the truth”
-Franz Bretano :Philosophical Investigations on Space Time and the Continuum.
“All created things are God’s speech. The being of a stone speaks and manifests the same as does my mouth about God: and people understand more by what is done than by what is said”
-Meister Eckhart : The Essential Sermons, Commentaries, Treatises and Defence.
Invasion of the body snatchers. A pod has got her – there’s a reason why they call Mars the “Red Planet”
scaloppine
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ernesto_Screpanti
Let just get this out there. A person in receipt of a benefit, if they earn more than $3,400 are pushed up into the second lowest band of taxation. Key did this because obviously he never read the convention on human rights, that if someone is so in need that they receive a benefit then they cannot be treated differently, that everyone should receive the same amount of welfare. Yet Key believes that progressive taxation should kick on those on welfare!
Looking at it another way. People who earn $100,000 pay 10.5% on the first $14,000 they earn.
People who earn $3,400 pay only at the 10.5% rate. Those in receipt of a welfare
check, and have no income, get the full entitlement, pay no tax on income. But Key in
his infinite stupidity believes that those individuals who do have some paltry $3,400+
of income should not get the full welfare entitlement (as effectively they pay more tax,
pay the 17.5% rate on their measly income after the first $3,400).
Just for a moment imagine the cost of filing tax returns as all those people on welfare
whose taxation just became a complicated mess. Whatever happened to keeping
government taxation simple. But worse, how can government argue that families
on welfare should not get family tax credit when there is clearly income tax
bands for those on welfare. I mean whatever happened to equal treatment in taxation.
You pay a higher rate of tax makes you eligible for the programs its funds to those who
also pay higher rates of tax.
“whatever happened to equal treatment in taxation”, only when the main beneficiaries of such treatment are those at the top of the food chain or those who vote to put them there,
The Working for Families fiasco where the Clark Government deemed the middle class,(and quite high up in that decile), to be more ‘in need’ of relief from taxation than beneficiaries with children was the final straw for me that broke my connection with Labour,
Incidently the ‘loud noise’ us lot at the Standard have been making over housing affordability has obviously attracted the attention of Labour so much so that Annette King has paid a visit and at least aquainted herself with the concerns many of us here have regarding State owned rentals being provided to the decile of lower waged workers so there is a small glimmer of hope of seeing some specific and substantial gains in that area when Labour release it’s completed election policy,(hopefully sooner rather than later),
My view is that the next ‘issue’ that we as the Standard need to address is just that of ‘working for Families’ and just how grossly unfair is it to tax the benefits of welfare dependent children and then refuse to offer them the ‘tax relief’ offered to the children of the upper echelons of the middle class…
The money spent on some of WFF would be better off being spent on a) a universal family benefit, and b) an increase in the state housing stock. The same outcome would be achieved.
Though I agree with the sentiments leveled at Labour, my point was this, that Key introduced a second progressive tax in the middle of the welfare. Imagine for a moment that we pay benefit to help people out of poverty only to tax them more if they do the right thing on welfare!
Save or get some part time work????
But worse, by taxing them on welfare we also don’t pay them WFF, which is blatantly unfair.
But its even worse, the 10.5% tax rate is a farce since its really just a tax relief for the rich, those who don’t get welfare don’t the relief since unlike everyone else the MSD take the first
10.5% tax band when they provide welfare. So the low tax band had no effect except for the
free who live off assets with little income (and can’t claim benefit), those geared to reduce their
taxes using trusts – the super rich.
Merging Madness and Reason (it’s the DSM V season)
“you have never been diagnosed as mad-this is the shifting sand upon which you erect your sanity. Yet, your illness has gone unrecognized…you have been deprived of treatment because the steady, sure advance of science has taken too long to reach you.”
“Beneath the (can’t read my handwriting, some adjective) labels of consensus there is just the homogenous zone-our common origins and physiology bind us together; we are a crowd of open-eyed children staring with wonder at the world. This vast assembly of “thrown” people is the homogenous zone-a coat of many (red) colours”.
“Reason too, recognized itself as being duplicated and dispossessed of itself; it thought itself wise and it was and it was mad; it thought it knew and it knew nothing; it thought itself righteous and it was insane; knowledge led one to the forbidden world when one thought one was being led by it to eternal light.” (thats “progress” for ya’s; Get Ya YaYa’s Out) (those art-school rockers aye)
-Foucault :Mental Illness and Psychology
According to Scheff, relative to the rate of treated “mental illness” the rate of unrecorded residual rule breaking of societal norms is extremely high.
(an I’m not surprised productivity is tanking when I observe people ostensibly working yet using their work p.c for shopping and such-like)
-consider this continual self-absorbed flouting of cell -phone /driving legislation, and it’s on the increase; BodyCount’s in the house.Listen to how close people are to stress thresholds in their daily discourse with children, family, associates, witness the behavioural temperature on the roads, the anasthetization and subsequent harms carried out; that’s why I drank alone in the end; Dos Gusanos was fun though, all those years ago
“Once upon a time, in some out of the way corner of that universe which is dispersed into numberless twinkling solar systems, there was a star upon which clever beasts invented knowing. That was the most arrogant and mendacious minute of ‘world history’, but nevertheless, it was only a minute. After nature had drawn a few breaths, the star cooled and congealed and the clever beasts had to die-One might invent such a fable and yet still it would not have adequately illustrated how miserable, how shadowy and transient, how aimless and arbitrary the human intellect looks within nature.
-Friedrich Nietzsche :On Truth and Lies in a Non-Moral Sense
“Madness and sanity are variants of the same phenomena; everything that we see and fear in the madman can also be seen and feared in ourselves. We are all mad children, we are all autistic, we are all deluded, we are all abstract and solipsistic and we all madly cobble together systems of absurd beliefs on this lost planet of fools; perhaps a fundamental truth about our humanity can be found in the instability, ‘throwness’ and madness of the homogenous zone.”
(Baudrillard places his hopes in terrorism, viruses and catastrophe)
i read today of an analysts perspective on FIVE potential Asian Shocks
-Taiwanese Independence asserted by the democratic vote
-Islamic unrest reaching China
-US Defence (Naval) cuts
-Thailand destabilized
-Territorial disputes in E and S China seas (we do live in interesting times)
Exit Strategy
http://www.amazon.com/dp/0847840247
-Why, thou sayest well; I do now remember a saying, “The fool doth think he is wise, yet the wise man knows himself to be a fool.”
-As You Like It (if you are ruled by mind, you are a king, if by body, a slave-Cato)
WHAT WE CAN NEVER KNOW- David Gamez. I whole-heartedly recommend this little book; I read it this afternoon at the library (air-con and I cannot afford to pay my fees, yet;)
HBT-10 more hot dry days forecast, little rain since August, Irrigation Ban on the way, Farmers may ‘dry out’
-if you’re walking a dog, they cannot eat anything they find in or around rivers or ponds, (cyano-bacteria) meanwhile we are going to supply more dairy to another Infant Formula Manufacturer establishing in NI
Dom-The Children’s Commissioner, a HB paediatrician,Russell Wills,, is “incredulous” about child poverty and inequality in our country…
from your friendly neighbourhood “madman” (hyper-rationally and reflexively yours)
now what am I gonna do for a crust. hmmm
11.29 By faith the people passed through the RED Sea, as on dry land, but when the Egyptians tried to do so, they were drowned.
This Isn’t the Petition Response You’re Looking For
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Kropotkin
It was Kropotkin’s Conquest of Bread that introduced me to anarchism.
Well, The Standard sure has evolved. That’s all from me, and that’s all from him. (a little birdy messaged me that a “challenge” is a moot point).
Adios Amigos, I’ll watch on from the High Plains from now on.

Don’t go too far away, mon ami
?
Oh, Clint, you’re back. It read like you were heading off along the ridge and leaving this little village behind.
High Plains Drifter
Great movie.
And The Two Ronnies
This is too much – I really going to miss you.
I assumed your “watch from the High Plains” remark meant that you weren’t going to be actively commenting for the moment, forgive me if I misinterpreted.
No I am going CV, it has been fun, and I have learned a lot (Thank You All and One and All A Good Night)
John James Elijah (Ha, comment 101 ers)
Farewell mate, take good care.
Nooooo, don’t go away!
Oh alright, if you must. I can’t force you to stay… but know that I’ve loved your contributions.
Take good care, as CV says. Fare thee well.
Loved your stuff, trooper, a message from Nu-Earth?
“And I heard a voice in the midst of the four beasts
And I looked and behold, a pale horse
And his name that sat on him was Death
And Hell followed with him.”
Great Clint Eastwood movie!!!
“What is happening at the moment? Because the Falklands are back in the news. Belfast is back in the news. It’s like some sort of hideous 80s revival, isn’t it? All we need is a heartless Conservative prime minister attacking the unemployed and demonising the poor, bankers making obscene profits, David Bowie releasing a single…”–Sandi Toksvig, The News Quiz
mickysavage -> So tell me KP is unfettered capitalism in a healthy state and just what this world needs?
Obviously not. I was never a supporter of neo liberalism, except back in the 80s when I was in my middle teens. But everyone was entranced by it then, Muldoon was gone, the Cold War over, Lifestyles of the Rich and Famous was on TV.
This is an interesting piece by a contemporary philosopher I like, applying some Humanist qualities – imagination, intuition, memory, ethics – to the current morass:
“I can only ask: is there a single example in Western civilisation over the past 2500 years when a broad policy of austerity has pulled a civilisation out of crisis and set it on the road to wellbeing, prosperity or growth? No. There is no example. There is no evidence. Only ideological conviction – romanticism – coming out of a political-economic theory packed into an apparently inevitable force called globalisation…
…Crises usually strike when ideologies have been around too long and the elites that serve them have lost their ability for critical thought…
…Instead of retreating inside a received wisdom, which has already revealed that it doesn’t work, we could turn to some basic, helpful human qualities…
…Ethics, for example, are a simple, practical reminder that the primary obligation of a civilisation is to its citizens’ wellbeing, not to the protection of commercial contracts or the servicing of debts. The fact that most of these debts were incurred by the commercial sector and its financiers reinforces this point…
…Memory is an essential tool of education. You can’t deal with a crisis if you are in the hands of economists, managers and business elites who don’t know the history of debt. They don’t know the history of competition. Very few read anything of consequence. They are the briefing paper generation. Many are, in reality, functionally illiterate, except on very narrow topics. They don’t know what has worked and not worked in their own society. In fact, they don’t seem to understand the concept of either society or civilisation…
…As for Imagination, it is not the privileged domain of the arts. Good financial policy is an expression of imagination. Throughout history great financiers and great ministers of finance have usually also been great consumers of culture, intellectuals, men of imagination. I think of Solon in Athens 2600 years ago, of Sully at the side of Henry IV in 1600, of Siegmund Warburg after World War II, of Jean Monet rebuilding Europe. As they would explain: you must imagine your way out of an economic cul de sac, just as a good general imagines his way out of a military stalemate. Bad generals stick to trench warfare…
…History is clear. When faced by unsustainable debts, the fools, the weak, the degenerate civilisations become obsessed by what they owe. They convince themselves that money is real, not an agreed-upon convention. They become its slave. And they destroy themselves. Successful civilisations make these impossible debts disappear – clearly, intentionally, massively. In this way they protect what needs to be protected, such as the savings of real people and their pensions. They clear the decks and the result is raw, new human energy to deal with society’s needs. History is filled with examples of this being done on purpose. It is also filled with the carcasses of those who refused to face reality and so caused their societies to commit suicide.”
http://www.johnralstonsaul.com/eng/articles_detail.php?id=98&lang=eng
Wow, just as I’m signing off, kiwi_prometheus posts a relevant comment
postscript
http://philosophynow.org/issues/74/What_We_Can_Never_Know_by_David_Gamez
subscription only
Sound familiar?
http://truth-out.org/news/item/13852-latvias-economic-disaster-as-a-neoliberal-success-story-a-model-for-europe-and-the-us
For some reason no reply buttons are showing for Pascal or karol, so here goes:
Pascal -> “Yep. I’d say it’s an odd sort of humanism that fails to recognise that humans interpret reality both subjectively, and through socially constructed lenses.”
Where did I deny any subjectivity? It’s the post structuralists/post modernists who go the hyper relativistic route.
You end up with crazy feminists calling Newton’s Laws of Physics a ‘rape manual’, and prattling on about “Rape Culture”. Science is dismissed or supposedly ‘improved’ via “Critical Theory” to “Feminist Science” or “Post Modernest Science”.
It’s all very poor philosophy and embodies atrociously low Academic standards.
There are silly things said in all schools.
You don’t necessarily “end up with crazy feminists calling Newton’s Laws of Physics a ‘rape manual’” if you accept a lot of what PM theorists say. And to equate that sort of thing with rape culture’ is just asinine.
Do you think that cultural norms are socially constructed, partially through the way we talk about things? And that cultural norms affect individuals thoughts about behavior and blameworthiness?
If so, then it’s no stretch to say that the way a society talks about rape, will affect the incidence of rape. ie, that some ways of talking about rape could increase the incidence of rape by creating cultural norms that support rapists interpretations of reality.
You end up with crazy feminists calling Newton’s Laws of Physics a ‘rape manual’, and prattling on about “Rape Culture”. Science is dismissed or supposedly ‘improved’ via “Critical Theory” to “Feminist Science” or “Post Modernest Science”.
Oops, k_p’s brain overloaded and it’s back to copy-pasting MRA propaganda which he’s already been informed multiple times is inaccurate. Balance has been restored to the Force.
karol -> “Ah, k-p, why so keen to put people in boxes? ”
Just want to know where you stand is all, nothing wrong with that.
“I do have difficulty following a party line or any one theory – the best still have their weaknesses.”
I don’t follow a part line and I get MOBBED on here for it – especially by your girl pals.
“It depends on the context and the issue as to which is most useful.”
It’s not good enough to go with what is “useful”. Marxism for example is a theory of everything, the guy was a genius obviously, nevertheless his philosophical system crashed and burned. Why should anyone believe you have the intellectual ability to uplift a fragment of it, remove it from context and claim it is “useful” for contemporary application.
“I am a little bit neo-Marxist and quite a bit post-structuralist. There are some things in postmodernism I agree with.”
The main tenet in postmodernism is that language is meaningless. Apparently Focault back tracked from that to the position that the meaning the reader gets from a text may differ from the author’s intention. In which case he hasn’t made any insight that authors and readers haven’t been aware of already.
As for Derrida, he’s been called an intellectual fraudster by some luminary academic types. Anyone who says they have read Derrida is lying, its incomprehensible – worse than Hegel.
The fact that Post-structuralist professors still hand out As Bs and Cs to their students submitted essays suggest the whole exercise is an insider’s joke.
“There is no theory of everything. But I am for democratic socialism, social and economic justice/fairness, and am against violence, prejudice, persecution and oppression.”
“And I am for evidence-based research, knowledge, understanding and argument.”
You are keeping the word “science” out of it. Are you referring to science, if not why not, and to what are you referring, Karol?
“I do think there is an objectively (scientifically) verifiable material reality.”
Ok you do bring up science now. Don’t know how you can claim to believe in science but claim to be “quite a bit post-structuralist”
“I see objectivity as a process, not an end point. And it doesn’t necessarily cancel out subjectivity, especially when it comes to human activities and communications. Objectivity is haunted by subjectivity, as you demonstrated with that sentence of yours I quoted above. But, that’s the thing about language and human communications.”
I never denied that there is subjectivity, it is postmodernist who deny the objective.
“You seem to miss your own contradictions. “believing” in something is a subjective statement.”
Is it? Does it matter? Like I said I don’t deny there is subjectivity eg “Chocolate tastes better than vanilla!” [ proviso – scientist discover genetic basis for varying tastes ]
[lprent: There is no “partY line” – it is every person’s argument for themselves. However there is a moderation line.
Personally I tend to view you as having a problem with dealing with women (what is it with that?) and indeed with anyone who thinks. You have that kind of “I’m just a poor victim” mentality (as you have amply demonstrated in this comment) that makes it difficult for you to deal with anyone disagreeing with you. And to top it off you seem to be a poor excuse for a psuedo-intellectual. Generally a waste of bandwidth and a bit of a luser in social media terms.
But these are just my opinions – they don’t enter into moderation.
Most of the time you pick up bans for either personally attacking authors or peristently going off topic in posts – usually the female authors. Right now you’re on most moderators “watch for stupidity” lists, and includes r0b’s list (about your only NOTABLE acheivement to date). ]
“I am a little bit neo-Marxist and quite a bit post-structuralist. There are some things in postmodernism I agree with.”
To be very blunt and clear, to me you are the typical KIWI IDIOT, I frown on, you have neither any understanding of complex history, socialism, social science, alternative social agendas and even scientifically evidenced social data.
I am totally flabber-ghasted about what brought you here.
Sorry, my impression is, you know too little of what goes down.
My comment was not really directed at the quote “kiwi_prometheus” used re what Karol may have commented on before, it was just totally incoherent, confusing, contradictory and much senseless, what “kiwi_prometheus” commented on in a wider context, also using that particular quote.
I tried to read his truly bizarre comments a few times, and I still cannot make that much sense at all out of what “k_p” tried to say or argue. Sorry for the frustration that lead to anger and some over the top comment I made in return.
You are not even just that “Kiwi idiot” I sometimes dismissably refer to, you are a totally ignorant, one sided coffin slicer of sorts, getting another angle on why some people may have died.
That is the lowest and cheapest crap I ever read and heard, man. Rot in fucking hell for that.
HC
I AM HAPPY TO BE BANNED AFTER SUCH IGNORANT POST AND ME GOING OVER THE TOP. SORRY, I COULD NOT HELP MYSELF. ALL THE BEST.
Have you ever considered that’s because you say really stupid things about girls?
There’s only one thing to say here and it was said by Marx himself:
I don’t know what I am but I know that I’m not a Marxist.
Marx considered that Marxists had twisted his teachings. This can most clearly be seen by his writings on the Paris Commune of 1871 which was anarchist. It was destroyed by military attack from the government.
Yes it does. Opinion and belief cannot change objective fact. This is something that the RWNJs and economists can’t seem to grasp.
“The main tenet in postmodernism is that language is meaningless. Apparently Focault back tracked from that to the position that the meaning the reader gets from a text may differ from the author’s intention. In which case he hasn’t made any insight that authors and readers haven’t been aware of already.”
Hi xtasy. This paragraph pretty much sums things up. Every point made here is complete and utter bullshit and incorrect no matter how you look at it. So much so it’s impossible to engage with. I’d tell kp sayonara.
A great experience I had today, or rather yesterday (12.01.) to visit and view the NEW Rainbow Warrior vessel down at Princes Wharf. I am IMPRESSED, Greenpeace got their shit together, had I not been a member of sorts, I would have signed up right way.
I am worried for the ones who do not get it, how much NZ, Australian and Antarctic environmen is in danger! It is damned serious.
I left the vessel in doubt and worry, who is going to keep them alive to fight, I asked, being myself in dire straits.
I can only hope they get donations, manage and do more good, as that is what Greenpeace are here for. I would dread the day they die. I would want to die also.