web analytics

An Orwellian Minister for Open Government

Written By: - Date published: 1:46 pm, March 27th, 2018 - 257 comments
Categories: accountability, broadcasting, corruption, leadership - Tags: , ,

So, today we have news that veteran broadcaster and former senior manager at RNZ, Carol Hirschfeld, has resigned over lying for her Minister, covering up that she had a secret meeting in a fairly busy café in central Wellington, despite it later having been revealed that the meeting was pre-arranged. This looks like a case of extraordinary bungling from Clare Curran, who is our Minister for Open Government, and now potentially faces consequences for misleading the house, making her official title seem a bizarre parody. (no doubt, Curran will maintain her line that she simply regarded the meeting to be informal, which is clearly nonsense, but an arguable excuse in terms of procedure, but keeping to that line might convince the opposition to accuse her of misleading the House if they can drum up more evidence) The Minister for Open Government really does have one, and one job only: to be frank with the truth, and not only to never get caught lying, but to never actually lie in the first place. Having found someone backing up her story had lied makes it quite obvious Curran is concealing something here, and as is often said, the cover-up may in fact be worse than the crime here.

It’s also very sad that Carol Hirschfeld, who is a respected broadcaster with a long and productive career on both TVNZ and TV3, has been a victim of this fiasco, and losing her will be an absolute tragedy for Radio New Zealand, but it was absolutely a situation of her resigning or being fired after lying about the nature of her meeting, so the real tragedy here is that she bothered to cover it up at all.

For full disclosure, I was a critic of Curran from before her appointment, and have previously stated I don’t think there’s any reasonable way to say she is qualified to be a Minister, and that she must have somehow leveraged her way into the appointment politically. Given that Labour determines who gets into cabinet by a vote of their caucus, there is no easy way to tell if she did manage to do so, so I will admit to pure speculation there, but I honestly can’t see her impressing the rest of caucus with any actual skills, so it’s either a reward for some sort of favour, or she knows where some bodies are buried.

If Jacinda Ardern hasn’t already asked for a Please Explain note from Curran, I imagine she’s done so first thing today. Misleading Parliament is about as big a deal as you can get, and the House sits tomorrow, so the clock is ticking for Ardern to decide what she wants to do.

There is a very real argument that being overly defensive of infractions against the public trust is part of what helped John Key bring Helen Clark down, as much of his victory was in demotivating Labour supporters as well as in persuading swing voters and turning out his own base. With low polling for both her support partners either below or at the party vote threshold respectively, and neither holding electorate seats, Ardern can’t really afford any perception of public weakness, even though Bridges’ opposition is looking like a fish out of water right now, handing them ammunition seems like a terrible idea.

Firing Curran as a Minister over this, despite no evidence of actual wrongdoing in the meeting itself, is absolutely in the cards, especially given the high level of public trust she needs to maintain to be effective in her portfolios. There is absolutely an argument to do so immediately- it strengthens Ardern’s hand in saying she had accepted her Minister’s assurances and had no idea what was going on, it allows her to shed a minister who is clearly a drag on the Government- despite having portfolios which are incredibly minor, she has been the persistent target of questions from the opposition, who clearly perceive her appointment as a weak spot to harass the Government with.

Despite that, Ardern has been making moves suggesting she’s buying time today. This may just be her waiting to hear more about what went on, or it may suggest she doesn’t yet regard the story as serious enough to fire Curran. Likewise, Bridges is playing his attack a little cautious, suggesting he doesn’t know if there’s really evidence for a knockout blow here.

What’s really troubling, however, is that this takes the sheen of idealism off a government that rode it like a wave into power. We have Peters trying to force the Greens into passing an anti-defection law that legal experts are up in arms about, even if in the short term it may not be disastrous. We have our Minister for Open Government concealing meetings, and stonewalling on written questions to the opposition, and neither the Prime Minister or Speaker are calling her on it. (she can be forgiven for not single-handedly fixing the culture around the OIA in less than half a year, at least, so that’s not on the list) We have ministers defending a $114m subsidy for a private yachting competition as somehow not a drain on public money. (there is no good economic evidence spending on sports events like this is effective economically, so the argument surely has to be it’s worth it in terms of our participation in the event itself?) We have an entire third of Labour’s coalition partner’s caucus under attack for various small issues, and the expected attacks on the Greens for looking too liberal. We have the opposition attempting to separate Labour and the Greens from New Zealand First on permits for new oil drilling, a thoroughly moronic idea that nonetheless both New Zealand First and National somehow support in principle, despite us already having found at least four times as many fossil fuels as we can afford to burn within our estimated carbon-equivalent budget for 2° warming. (In fact, I’ve seen claims that it’s now five times as much as we can safely burn) This is dangerous ground for Labour, and they need to seriously consider if it isn’t time to change course so that they can maintain credible defense as an idealistic, hopeful new government. This story heating up is a perfect excuse to dump a minister who, regardless of whether she has actually done anything wrong, has absolutely passed the line in terms of the perception of corruption, and who is demonstrably doing the opposite of her job.

There is a reason that people say that in politics, the tripod is the most unstable of all structures- all three government parties are putting a lot of effort into hanging together, but it will require high standards from all of them for this government to succeed and last into subsequent terms.

Here is a selection of reactions on Twitter:

There are good people in Cabinet already, or on the backbenches, who could pick up at least one of Curran’s portfolios, if Ardern were to do the brave thing and let her go proactively for not meeting the high standards she requires of the Minister for Open Government. Kris Faafoi could easily take on Broadcasting, and ICT would be a great portfolio to promote a talented or dedicated backbencher into- I have been a persistent advocate for Louisa Wall, who in opposition made very clear she can wrangle support from other parties for important bills, has the technical skills to be a minister, and is one of the most veteran MPs to be left on the backbench without official responsibilities, and of course ICT too could be reshuffled to free up a portfolio well-suited for a particular minister in some other area.

The fact is that organizational politics is not a sufficient reason to make someone a Minister, and Curran was always a time-bomb waiting to go off for Labour. I take no pleasure in seeing her in trouble, because it’s bad for the country as a whole and RNZ in particular, but it does convince me that I was right that she needs to go. I hope Ardern has at least seriously considered where the line is that Curran has to cross, regardless of what she’s decided to do by tomorrow.


Update: Curran is about to speak to media about Hirschfeld’s resignation. You can watch live, and I’ll update the post again once she’s finished.

Update 2: Curran is defending the meeting as “not secret,” that she was mistaken to consider it informal even though it was scheduled, and is framing Hirschfeld’s description as “differing stories,” rather than a lie. So she is expecting to be able to tough this out and not need to resign, and therefore has likely been warned rather than fired. This is disappointing given how badly she has managed to stuff up such a minor issue, and her lack of progress in all her portfolios when compared to literally any other minister- even Shane Jones has made tangible announcements. She has admitted to “making a mistake” in describing the meeting as informal and attending it at all. Not knowing RNZ’s policies around ministerial meetings, as she claims, and not thinking to ask, however, is not a mistake, it is negligence, and Curran should absolutely be publicly apologizing to RNZ for putting a talented manager in this position.

Update 3: Articles released later have made it clear that Hirschfeld was not egged on by Curran, and in fact Curran appears to have tipped RNZ off to the inaccuracy of her statement which were repeated at Select Committee. Apologies for getting that wrong- initial reports were a little confusing.

257 comments on “An Orwellian Minister for Open Government”

  1. Matthew Whitehead 1

    More disclosure: I have a bit of a bet riding on whether Shane Jones or Clare Curran is the first Minister to resign or be fired in the government, but this hasn’t affected my opinion on this issue, and I wouldn’t call for a Minister’s resignation just to win a bet, lol.

    Thought you should all know, but didn’t think it was in keeping with the tone of the post to put it in the main text, lol.

  2. Carolyn_Nth 2

    Curran is saying she didn’t understand previously that there were clear rules about RNZ staff meeting with ministerd. How can a minister with that portfolio, and after having a long period as spokesperson for media and NOT understand this?

  3. Muttonbird 3

    Quoting Farrar, Matthew? That’s brave.

    • Matthew Whitehead 3.1

      I thought it was important to show different perspectives from varied areas of the political spectrum. Farrar and Compton are there to show us what the opposition thinks, and I get Lew’s take as a bonus by giving you that tweet from Farrar.

      • JohnSelway 3.1.1

        I enjoy that you show different perspectives. Shows a fairness as it were (and means I don’t need to visit Kiwiblog!)

  4. Sanctuary 4

    Curren is hopelessly incompetent.

    Everyone said so before the election and subsequent events have borne out those assessments. Curren owes her position to identity politics horse trading within Labour, not to any innate talent.

    Read NRT about her attempts to be secretive, even though she is the open government minister.

    She is reflexively secretive because all incompetent fools rely on secrecy. Now her idiocy has cost Carol Hirschfeld her job, and damaged the governments credibility.

    Jacinda needs to sack this liability immediately.

    • Matthew Whitehead 4.1

      I keep up with NRT all the time, I/S is an excellent blogger. I thoroughly agree with his takes on Curran.

      • tc 4.1.1

        You’re too kind matthew;
        “I don’t think there’s any reasonable way to say she is qualified to be a Minister…”

        A fantastic example of what’s wrong with identity, tick the box politics is you end up with the dull tools where sharp ones are needed.

        Labours thrown many useful tools overboard recently, she’s is way out of her depth and displayed as much in opposition.

        Shuffle the pack Jacinda, strong visible leadership’s a vote winner and getting winnie to give Jones a public kicking is also welcome.

        • Matthew Whitehead 4.1.1.1

          There is no way Curran was promoted due to “identity politics.” I’m usually an advocate for hiring or promoting more women when they’re under-represented, but if I can come out first thing and say “there is no way she’s qualified for Shadow Cabinet,” then you know that wasn’t a consideration.

          She was an absolute failure as an ICT spokesperson, but is probably a decent electorate MP. If there’s any legitimate reason for her having her portfolios, that’s it- Labour tends to over-value electorate performance in the new MMP environment, and like National, hasn’t yet realized that having unpopular ministers is worse than putting them on the backbench, or deselecting them altogether, as it drags on your party vote. But I find it much more plausible that she’s a great example of the Peter Principle, where people who are good at networking (or uncovering blackmail material…) but bad at their job can get promoted for no good reason.

          • Carolyn_Nth 4.1.1.1.1

            But I find it much more plausible that she’s a great example of the Peter Principle, where people who are good at networking but bad at their job can get promoted for no good reason.

            Yep.

          • Anne 4.1.1.1.2

            But I find it much more plausible that she’s a great example of the Peter Principle, where people who are good at networking (or uncovering blackmail material…) but bad at their job can get promoted for no good reason.

            I saw that in operation throughout my 30 plus years in the Public Service.
            Networking the bosses big time. Acting as spies for them on the rest of the staff. In my case, it went as far as changing my calculations in order to paint me as incompetent. They were promoted way beyond their actual level of competence but since it was normal practice in those days, nobody did anything about it.

            • Matthew Whitehead 4.1.1.1.2.1

              Yeah, it’s the most frustrating thing about the public service, and there really needs to be reforms so that staff can be performance managed fairly, and dismissed or demoted as appropriate if they fail to meet expectations. It creates a hostile workplace for other staff, and seeing it happen in Parliament too is the worst.

            • OncewasTim 4.1.1.1.2.2

              The Peter Principle probably best described what has motivated me to make comments on various threads over the past few days (especially in relation to the PS.
              I seem to rember ( from remarks you made a couple of years back ) you may have had some sort of employment dispute whilst a PS.
              Hopefully the employment court gave them as big a thrashing and admonishment as they did in my case.

              • Anne

                The prime culprit ended up losing his managerial position but not until after I left. There were no support services available for the kind of bullying and intimidation dished out to me in the 80s and early 90s. It was a serious miscarriage of justice, but there was nothing I could do about it because I didn’t have the financial means to take them to court.

    • Bearded Git 4.2

      Agreed Sanctuary, Curran has always seemed pretty useless to me.

      Time for Jacinda to be (and look) decisive and brave.

    • Unicus 4.3

      Absolutely this is an opportunity for Jacinda to rid us all of a complete dead head.

      Prior to the election she was the spokesperson for broadcasting who rarely if ever talked about her designated portfolio

      The government must have a keen and able Minister to deal with the vital changes neccessary in public media .

      Clare Curran is not that person she never been anything other than a time server – Ditch her JA -all of Labour would applaud .

    • Unicus 4.4

      Absolutely this is an opportunity for Jacinda to rid us all of a complete dead head.

      Prior to the election she was the spokesperson for broadcasting who rarely if ever talked about her designated portfolio

      The government must have a keen and able Minister to deal with the vital changes neccessary in public media .

      Clare Curran is not that person she never has been anything other than a time server – Ditch her JA -all of Labour would applaud .

    • Unicus 4.5

      Absolutely this is an opportunity for Jacinda to rid us all of a complete dead head.

      Prior to the election she was the spokesperson for broadcasting who rarely if ever talked about her designated portfolio

      The government must have a keen and able Minister to deal with the vital changes neccessary in public media .

      Clare Curran is not that person she never has
      been anything other than a time server – Ditch her JA -all of Labour would applaud .

    • SPC 4.6

      Hirschfield lost her job because she lied to her boss.

    • Chris 4.7

      I would say the same thing about Jacinda. Incompetent, and got there on good looks alone, and not having achieved anything.

  5. Ad 5

    A great opportunity for the PM to show she has the steel to discipline, by firing Curran’s ass today.

    Too many going off on tangents.

    SparklePony PM needs to rule caucus for real.

    • Matthew Whitehead 5.1

      If you think Ardern doesn’t have steel in private, you don’t know much about her. She can apparently be very hard on members of caucus when she feels she has the need.

      If Ardern’s decided she’s not firing Curran just yet, it’s because she thinks it would be worse for her Government than keeping her on. I certainly don’t agree, but then again, I don’t understand who in Caucus was actually voting for her to be a Minister in the first place. *shrugs*

      • Ad 5.1.1

        Private is irrelevant.

        • Matthew Whitehead 5.1.1.1

          It’s not irrelevant to actually being in control of caucus, it is in fact what matters most, but that does make it clearer you were talking about a perception of being in control, and I agree sacking Curran is probably now necessary for that.

      • Enough is Enough 5.1.2

        She doesn’t get re-elected in private

    • Anne 5.2

      With Ad over what to do with Curran. Helen Clark did not hesitate and if I recall correctly her first ministerial sacking occurred around six months after they came to office – could be wrong though.

      As has been said a million times it is public perception that counts above everything.

      Stand her down please Jacinda. If she shows true remorse and ups her game she can always be reinstated some time in the future.

      • Baba Yaga 5.2.1

        Jacinda is no Helen Clark. Jacinda may well yet fire Curran, but only if Winnie let’s her.

        • Sacha 5.2.1.1

          Why would Winston have anything to do with Curran? He’s the only thing protecting Shane Jones from a proper bollocking, certainly.

          • Baba Yaga 5.2.1.1.1

            My opinion – Jacinda doesn’t blow her nose without consulting Winston. She’s weak, and the cracks are showing. But she’s great for a photo-op with Ed Sheeran.

            • Anne 5.2.1.1.1.1

              That’s crap Baba Yaga.

              She’s neither weak nor is she Peter’s puppet. The respect he has shown her from the start is testament to that.

                • Drowsy M. Kram

                  Prime Minister Ardern, weak and stupid? Heaven help us, and her.

                  Bring back the self-serving plunderers and blunderers (Key, English, Barclay, Joyce, Coleman) – they’ll stop the rot.

                  https://www.radionz.co.nz/news/national/353193/jonathan-coleman-hangs-up-on-hospital-rot-interview

                  • Baba Yaga

                    In just a matter of months this government is in huge trouble. Nothing the nats did comes near the incompetence and dishonesty we’re seeing from members of Ardern’s government on an almost daily basis. And then there’s Ardern herself, making NZ a ‘laughing stock’ internationally (https://www.msn.com/en-nz/news/national/pms-spy-comments-make-nz-a-laughing-stock/ar-BBKMSHp?ocid=spartanntp). Key was highly regarded on the international stage. Ardern is offering nothing beyond women’s magazine photo-ops.

                    • One Anonymous Bloke

                      🙄

                      Scientists are just like lawyers, dildos and Letterman, with a side-order of pedo-hair fetishism, Ad Nauseam.

                    • Drowsy M. Kram

                      Some of you comments are political hyperbole, and/or at best irrational misogyny.

                      Key’s long gone, but never forget – by a ponytail puller we were ‘led’.

                      Whereas repeated unsolicited hair pulling by a sober PM and National Party leader was (rightly) international news. Of course, the motivation for Key’s ‘playful’ assaults was not sexual in any way; honest John might just as well have been tugging on the ponytail of a male waiter. Nevertheless, by a ponytail puller we were led.

                    • Babayaga

                      “Key’s long gone, but never forget – by a ponytail puller we were ‘led’.“

                      A pony tail puller who would never have let his Government turn into the shambles this one has.

                      A pony tail puller who saw off four labour leaders, and enjoyed historically high levels of popularity.

                    • Jesters & Clowns point the finger

                      CleRly you were sound asleep during National’s time in government Babayaga. So we will forgive your ignorant trolling.

                      If Curren, and Jones are the worst culprits to surface during the present administration we are now better served than any time during the previous decade.
                      Jones can be forgiven as he is nothing less than a blunt speaking kiwi bloke, who speaks his mind in inopportune circumstances. He at least has a vision for the regions, however badly he paints it.
                      Curren likewise is forgivable, but because she is stupid, and obviously has risen above her level of natural incompetence. But forgiveness should mean driven out of cabinet, and reduced to the role of retiring back bencher, to permit more useful back benchers to come to the fore.
                      In the meantime, National’s ranks could do with a little more thinning to remove the remaining disengenuous, self serving Homerable arseholes. It’s a pity that a clean sweep of National’s incompetents would strip the opposition bare and would drive the country to dispair due to the extraordinary number of by-elections required.

                    • Baba Yaga

                      “If Curren, and Jones are the worst culprits to surface during the present administration we are now better served than any time during the previous decade.”

                      If you had left it there, I would have considered you delusional. As you then went on to try to mitigate Jones and Curran’s misdemeanors, without so much as a hat tip to Ardern’s utterly useless leadership, almost moves me to pity.

                    • Drowsy M. Kram

                      Ponytail pulling Key makes my breast swell with pride too. He’s the best ponytail pulling Prime Minister in history – what an amazing achievement, fantastic role model, extraordinary legacy, etc. etc.

                      Bring back honest John, National’s champion plunderer.

                      The great big list of John Key’s big fat lies (UPDATED)

                    • Baba Yaga

                      “Ponytail pulling Key makes my breast swell with pride.”

                      I tend to not let my breast swell with pride over any politician. They are all rat-bags in one way or another. But there are degrees of competence. Clark was very, very competent. Key was very, very competent. Ardern has only had 9 months and she looks like a possum in headlights.

                    • Drowsy M. Kram

                      Jacinda Ardern – eight months as leader of the Labour Party (numerical competency not your strong suit?), and five months as Prime Minister (sworn in on 26 October 2017).

                      Must be a bitter pill to swallow that such a weak and stupid (your words) leader managed to get NZ1st and the Greens onside, whereas National’s powerful, skilled and dynamic negotiators (and competent; let’s not forget competent) failed. Why, it’s almost inexplicable.

                      Many of National’s incompetent post-election negotiating ‘team’ (e.g. English, Joyce, Eagleson) have now left parliamentary politics.

                    • Baba Yaga

                      “Must be a bitter pill to swallow that such a weak and stupid (your words) leader managed to get NZ1st and the Greens onside…”

                      Not at all. Winnie was never going to negotiate with national in good faith…his hatred of national and the chance to be the effective PM over a weak labour leader were just too tempting. But more than that, this was an election national needed to not win…it brings rejuvenation (which you so kindly acknowledge)…something labour failed to do post Clark. Ardern is an accidental PM, a great smile but zero experience at running anything.

                    • McFlock

                      Ah, victory through defeat, the most cunning plan of all…

                    • Baba Yaga

                      “Ah, victory through defeat, the most cunning plan of all…”

                      A subtle correction. National were not ‘defeated’. They were the highest polling party. But Mr 7% chose Labour for the reasons I outlined above. How he must be regretting that decision, and giving up smoking at the same time!

                    • McFlock

                      Yup. They’re the most popular losers we’ve had for probably most of MMP. Not FPP, but never mind, that’s why MMP is better.

                    • Baba Yaga

                      “…that’s why MMP is better.”
                      Good grief…something on which we can agree!

  6. Venezia 6

    What a media beat up! And on a day where there are at least three significant issues of importance to our nation ( 22,000 cows to be culled after total failure to avert spread of infection, illegal withholding of information by ex attorney general, taxpayer now faced with $90,000 bill for this).

    • Matthew Whitehead 6.1

      you also forgot wasting $114m on a yachting competition.

    • Muttonbird 6.2

      What a media beat up!

      This.

      It’s the political struggle for RNZ on show. The right wing don’t want to let go, and the rest of the media want RNZ (and all public broadcasting) gone altogether and are horrified at the prospect of it expanding.

      The rest is people out for Curran’s head.

      • Carolyn_Nth 6.2.1

        Curran was seen by the right as a weak link. She does not have the competence for this role.

        • tc 6.2.1.1

          as demonstrated by her appalling performance as ICT spokesperson. This is a key area that requires a safe pair of hands not butter fingers.

          Great ideas are one thing…execution of them another.

      • Matthew Whitehead 6.2.2

        I’m sure there’s an element of that, but scalping Curran won’t scupper plans to expand and enrich RNZ’s content, which are well-earned and to be quite honest, it’s past time we did so.

  7. CHCOff 7

    No one cares, Curran ( who seems to give great leadership value with Dunedin ) had a coffee meeting that wasn’t on the books.

    Look at it this way, it was actually saving the org. money from being billed for the coffee and fudge cake or whatever that could have come down the pipe if was an official chin wag!!

    The actual deep issue is that there is no ‘neutral’ media, it is all coming from somewhere with a point of view, & as is the case in current structures often very lobby driven, and the mis-leading counter productive and wasteful nature of media, which is endemic in modern society, comes from pretending that is not so.

    Essentially the govt parties of the day should have their own produced content on across the telly channels one night of the week, and the opposition parties another night, with a lesser overall time since they are doing less than the govt.

    So the govt. gets say a 2 hour slot and the opposition an one hour slot, which they produce themselves, with all relevant parties having creative control over how and what they present.

    Without having thought about ratios, something like National 55 mins and Act 5 * say Tuesday.

    Labour gets 70 mins, NZ1st 30 mins and Greens 20 mins the following night.

  8. Ovid 8

    She’s a liability and an example of the Peter principle in action.

    • Matthew Whitehead 8.1

      Yes, I agree, but I thought the post was too long to go into that. I figured saying she leveraged her way into her position would imply it for everyone. 😉

  9. Carolyn_Nth 9

    I can understand Hirschfeld and Curran wanting to talk without RNZ Chairman Richard Griffin being present, because he was a National appointment, with a background working for National Party people. He was also tipped to be appointed to prepare RNZ for privatisation.

    http://www.stuff.co.nz/national/politics/5113211/How-the-Silver-Fox-turned-gamekeeper

    But, this was a pretty clumsy way to do it. And it was in a very public place where I understand many Wellington public servants hang out. Many are now pretty much Nat flunkies.

    Hirschfeld is a big loss to RNZ.

    Curran should go.

    As someone who has an interest in public service media, I have attended some meetings where party spokespeople talked about this in recent years.

    I rate Tracey Martin above Curran in her grasp of the significance of public service media, and would suggest, if she hasn’t already got enough responsibilities, that she step up to this role – perhaps with Kris Faafoi as associate minister.

    I do think the development of public service media is a very important part of improving democratic debate and engagement.

  10. McFlock 10

    I did see Curran speak well at a rally once.
    Other than that, I don’t think I’ve met anyone down here who has a good thing to say about her. Like, normal party people, not nutbars or zealots (known for their bile). She doesn’t seem to make political friends easily.

    As for why she’s a minister, I suspect the answer is “South Dunedin”. Apparently the Sth D Lab org owns a couple of properties that return good, regular income. Which gets sent to head office. Money talks.

    On a separate note, another classic Yes Minister line:
    Sir Humphrey: How are things at the Campaign for the Freedom of Information, by the way?
    Sir Arnold: Sorry, I can’t talk about that.

    • Matthew Whitehead 10.1

      If Labour has allowed itself to be set up so that its electorate candidates can blackmail it with donations from local orgs, that’s an absolute failure of leadership, and an excellent reason to leverage Curran out of Parliament altogether, so you can cut her influence out of South Dunedin.

      • McFlock 10.1.1

        She’s not the influence, the electorate committee is.

        The same ones who decided Benson-Pope was no longer their man.

        • Matthew Whitehead 10.1.1.1

          If an electorate committee has that much influence over the voting of caucus Labour has bigger problems than Curran.

          • McFlock 10.1.1.1.1

            Well, it’s not like she’s PM.

            But yeah, if that’s the case then labour HQ needs a more secure income stream than donors.

            • red-blooded 10.1.1.1.1.1

              It’s got nothing to do with the Dunedin South LEC or the fact that they own a building. The fact is that Dunedin is a Labour stronghold and Curran performed well in terms of increasing the Labour vote well above the average in the last election.

              I don’t know her well enough to rate her abilities as a Minister – I can’t claim to have really followed her. The decision to talk face to face with Hirshfield seems pretty innocent to me, and her office did contact RNZ to correct the “accidental meeting” story, but probably should have fronted to the select committee and corrected the record. Not doing so has allowed this story to become a lot bigger than it needed to be.

              Ironically, our Minister of Broadcasting seems to have poorly developed media skills. That doesn’t necessarily make her incapable of managing her portfolio, though. I’m really keen to see more detailed plans for change at RNZ and how these fit into our wider broadcasting landscape, no matter who holds the ministerial position.

              And yes, I’m sure Labour HQ would like a more secure income stream than donors. Income generated from commercial rents from buildings like the one owned by the South Dunedin LEC is one way of managing this.

              • Matthew Whitehead

                She ranks above Jonathon Coleman, but she’s about par for a National Party Minister in terms of competence at doing the advertised job. (which doesn’t mean that her performance is acceptable)

                Honestly, even if she’s innocent in all of this, her resignation will be necessary within a year for not managing to get anything done, so…

                • SPC

                  You’ve run the blame Curran line (to an anti-Curran audience from Red Alert era times), now said even if she is innocent in all this, its an excuse to get rid of her.

                  So much for “Greens” focusing on the issues …

        • Anne 10.1.1.2

          And probably the same ones who in 2013 tried to prevent Cunliffe’s then wife from being allowed into a leadership contest meeting where the candidates, including Cunliffe, were speaking.

    • weka 10.2

      She seems to me to be a good enough electorate MP, although I’d like to see what people in South Dunedin say about that. But she does seem quite active on their behalf.

      • Sanctuary 10.2.1

        May I direct you to her (Shrinking) majorities.

        • mac1 10.2.1.1

          Sanctuary, did you know that what you just wrote about Clare Curran’s majorities shrinking is aaaah very wrong? Or are you being sarcastic?

          Curran’s electorate performance is as follows.

          2017 21,404 votes 54.59% margin 8717
          2014 18,182 49.07% 3858
          2011 16,844 48.89% 4175

          4500 extra votes.
          5% increase to have an absolute majority!

          https://www.parliament.nz/en/mps-and-electorates/electorate-profiles/electorate-profiles-data/document/DBHOH_Lib_EP_Dunedin_South_Electoral_Profile/dunedin-south-electoral-profile#_32

          • Matthew Whitehead 10.2.1.1.1

            To be fair to Sanctuary, he may be referring to the shrinking share of the Party Vote Labour received in Dunedin South until the ’17 election. Labour regained some of that vote this time, but only some of it. It depends whether you think the job of a candidate is to win their electorate or to grow/hold the Party Vote.

            If it’s the latter, arguably Curran is under-performing- while her electorate is 3-4% ahead of the average national swing to Labour, it is a Labour stronghold and should be doing much better than that in an election that Labour won, but it’s also arguable the other way given that Dunedin South did still swing back 15 points towards Labour, so it’s very much a judgement call for the Party on whether they think she’s doing a good job.

            • mac1 10.2.1.1.1.1

              Maybe, but Sanctuary does say “her (shrinking) majorities”, not the Party’s.

              A candidate’s job is to do both. I was one.

              How did Labour do nationally in 2011 and 2014?

              Labour 2011 27% of the vote, down from 2008 by 6.5%
              Labour 2014 25% of the vote, down from 2011 by 2.35%

              Curran, in a Labour stronghold, got 48% in 2011, and 49% in 2014.

              Then, in 2017 the Dunedin South Labour Party vote went up 15% and her personal vote went up 5% to an absolute majority.

              Nothing like figures to disprove arguments based on other ‘rationales’.

              I’d say that Curran has performed very well in electorate and party votes in the last three elections.

              People may have a snitch against Curran. But the figures disprove Sanctuary, and also your apology for him, Matthew.

              • Matthew Whitehead

                I don’t really have a game in it one way or another. If Labour want to keep her on as an MP that’s their business. My disagreement is with her as a Minister, and her conduct being either unethical or incompetent or both in this matter.

                But, now you’re pretending to have won, let’s look a bit more closely at those years you gave.

                In 2011, Labour’s share of the party vote in Dunedin South was down by -11.76%. That’s a lot more than the national drop you gave of -6.5%, and it comes after a -10.4% drop in her electorate in her debut year in 2008, although that one I’ll give her for free, despite outpacing the -7.1% national drop, because she was a new candidate, and it can be hard to pick up a new electorate, even a party stronghold, if you’re not some kind of superstar candidate.

                To be fair to Curran, in 2014, the share of Dunedin South’s party vote won by Labour dropped by only -1.84%, compared to the 2.35% national average you gave, but with so many consecutive drops ahead of the national average, Curran may have simply been bottoming out on voters she could lose, so a drop roughly in line with the average is actually kinda bad. I’ve already looked at 2017, where you would expect Dunedin South to deliver well above the national swing given Curran was riding Ardern’s wave as a popular new Prime Ministerial candidate, but not so much. She got +15.0% vs a 11.76% national swing to Labour, which is acceptable but hardly stellar in a Labour stronghold.

                Like I said, if you judge Curran by her performance getting Party Votes, she didn’t do particlularly well, but wasn’t the worst. Certainly not some all-star that justifies her becoming a minister to retain her services regardless of her poor technical performance in her portfolios. If you’re going to quote figures, give them all. The only election year Curran has ever raised the Party Vote in her electorate was 2017.

      • Trewindle 10.2.2

        Hi Weka,

        Clare’s active enough that she fields requests and then acts on them from North Dunedinites as well as working for her own constituents. From what I’ve seen working with her (including on her campaign last year), she is the South D candidate because of her hard work in the electorate and her involvement in keeping our services and advocating on behalf of people that need help accessing them, as when she camped in the octagon until two young mothers were supplied with state houses here.

  11. Muttonbird 11

    Also not sure why we are promoting the right wing meme that it was a secret meeting, when clearly it wasn’t???

    • Matthew Whitehead 11.1

      I’m sorry, but if someone resigned due to lying about the meeting, there was absolutely a desire to keep it hush. Would you prefer the term “cover-up?” Because regardless of whether the meeting was wrong, the attempt to cover up its existence definitely was, especially for a Minister for Open Government.

      • Muttonbird 11.1.1

        As far as I can tell the meeting itself was not secret (why would they have met in the Astoria is it was?) The instigator of the meeting and presumably what was discussed has tried to be covered up since, but that’s not the same thing.

        The right wing are pushing the idea that the meeting itself was secret and you are helping them here, imo.

        • Matthew Whitehead 11.1.1.1

          No, I am opposing the idea that we can have someone who thinks covering her tracks is appropriate as a Minister for Open Government.

          Holding Labour accountable is not “helping the Right Wing.” If Labour wants to stay in Government, it has to act like a responsible Government.

          • JohnSelway 11.1.1.1.1

            “Holding Labour accountable is not “helping the Right Wing.” If Labour wants to stay in Government, it has to act like a responsible Government.”

            I wish others realised that too. I voted Labour/Green and as such I’ll harsher on my own ‘team’ than the opposition

          • dukeofurl 11.1.1.1.2

            Open Government isnt about ‘meetings’ its about increasing public participation amoung other things.
            http://ogp.org.nz/
            Commitment 1: Open Budget
            Commitment 2: Improving official information practices
            Commitment 3: Improving open data access and principles
            Commitment 4: Tracking progress and outcomes of open government data release
            Commitment 5: Ongoing engagement for OGP
            Commitment 6: Improving access to legislation
            Commitment 7: Improving policy practices
            Appendix A – Plan development and engagement

            Just playing to the right way who just play a gotcha is the antithesis of Open Government

            • Matthew Whitehead 11.1.1.1.2.1

              I know what open government is, good grief. (Coincidentally, Curran has done nothing to improve adherence with the OGP, which we are in serious danger of getting kicked out of)

              That you don’t get that the Minister for Open Government has moral responsibilities beyond their actual portfolio is very troubling to me. Just like we expect to see the Minister for Transport on buses and trains, we also expect to see the Minister for Open Government eating her own dogfood by being more open than other Ministers about her own schedule, information, and practices, otherwise she has demonstrated she doesn’t believe in what she’s supposed to be doing.

              • dukeofurl

                In your heading this is what you said
                ” The Minister for Open Government really does have one, and one job only: to be frank with the truth,”

                Tell me which one that is on the list ?

                That may be commendable , but lets NOT wrap it up in the Mantle of what Open Government really is.

                • Matthew Whitehead

                  It’s all of them, obviously. Forgive me for summing up the minister’s responsibilities in brief with metaphorical language.

      • McFlock 11.1.2

        Every politician needs a plaque on their wall that says something like:
        It’s not screwing up that will end your career, it’s the cover-up. The cover-up. That’ll be the end of you. The cover-up. Front up, don’t cover-up!

        • dukeofurl 11.1.2.1

          And the cover ups ended Keys career ?

          Dont make me laugh. he would just say anything he didnt want to reveal was ‘his work as an MP’ and thus none of your business.

          • McFlock 11.1.2.1.1

            Not many politicians lose their jobs because of a simple fuckup. It’s the coverup that usually takes them out when they go.

            That’s not to say they never get away with it.

          • Matthew Whitehead 11.1.2.1.2

            What exactly did Key cover up? He fronted on everything, would put on the charm for the media and say he didn’t think it was a particularly big deal, and oh look over there, haven’t we got some nice new money to announce for our corporate mates? And how about we cut taxes for well-paid journalists so you don’t have to question me?

            Sadly, the rules of the game seem to be: Minimization and misdirection are, to an extent, allowed, but actual cover-ups aren’t.

            • dukeofurl 11.1.2.1.2.1

              have you never seen the list of over 200 items where he covered up or lied.

              Ive given the reference to where he covered up his contact with bloggersjournalists
              There was Sky City or as Hootun put it
              ‘Close to corruption’
              Close to corruption
              The origins of this fiasco lie in the close private relationship established between John Key and SkyCity in the mid 2000s. When he became prime minister, Mr Key surprised many when he appointed himself minister of tourism but it was old news to SkyCity. Its executives had advised business partners well before election day that things were looking up because Mr Key had “agreed” to become tourism minister.

              https://www.nbr.co.nz/opinion/skycity-debacle-offers-morbid-fascination

              • tracey

                Surveillance of dotcom

                English covered up for Barclay

              • Matthew Whitehead

                I am intimitely familiar with his many lies. He never claimed to be responsible for opening up the government, and I agree they should have been scandals, but the fact is if you misdirect and minimize like key did, and have enough charisma, banked political capital, and consistent public support by your cronies, the media don’t care, but if you say things that simply aren’t plausible, they do. It sucks that there’s one standard for our lot and another, much lower standard for theirs, I agree. But the correct response is to go after their lot when they’re in power, not to excuse ministers because we like their party.

            • red-blooded 11.1.2.1.2.2

              Key covered up the whole Dirty Politics game, for starters. He just kept repeating that it was a left wing conspiracy theory.

            • Stuart Munro 11.1.2.1.2.3

              He wouldn’t front up on RNZ though – knew his smarm wouldn’t cut it except on talkback. A coward after all.

  12. Stunned Mullet 12

    CV will have burst his spleen from laughter

    • Muttonbird 12.1

      Would make a change from venting it.

    • McFlock 12.2

      He wasn’t always wrong, in the old days.

      • Muttonbird 12.2.1

        So I hear. He had a fight with Labour and has held a grudge ever since.

      • veutoviper 12.2.2

        100% McFlock.

        And Muttonbird it was Curran – not Labour – that the fight was with.

        • McFlock 12.2.2.1

          I wouldn’t go to 100% right either, though 🙂

          And his targets seemed to be wide-ranging.

          • veutoviper 12.2.2.1.1

            LOL – not well thought out on my part! But he was a very different person back then and still is from time to time. I was actually quite interested in some of his comments the other day when the axe fell yet again in OM 21 March down under 16.1.1.1.2. He answered John Selway’s questions in a quite reasonable manner which gave a little insight into where he was coming from. But getting onto ‘unsafe’ ground.

        • Muttonbird 12.2.2.2

          I see. Well the whole episode has turned him into a low-functioning anarchist.

    • RedLogix 12.3

      After a moment or two indulging in well-earned schadenfreude; I imagine he’s just disappointed like the rest of us.

      An utterly unnecessary and pointless embarrassment all for zero possible gain.

      • Stunned Mullet 12.3.1

        “I imagine he’s just disappointed like the rest of us.”

        Nope, he’s been vocal about Curran’s failings for a very long time.

  13. Carolyn_Nth 13

    Whoa! It’s all going down right now.

    Just breaking, Helen Clark says Ardern was “let down” by not being told about the Labour Summer camp sexual assault allegations.

    https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/politics/102623029/helen-clark-pm-ardern-was-let-down-when-she-wasnt-told-about-sexual-assault-allegations

    Ardern needs to step up and show she is in control. And I suspect Curran will be gone by lunch time tomorrow!

    • Matthew Whitehead 13.1

      Ardern has already said she currently doesn’t intend to fire Curran, so there would need to be an angle to this story that isn’t public for her to change course here, I think.

      • Carolyn_Nth 13.1.1

        But Ardern also was critical of Curran. Her support of Curran was pretty cautious. i suspect Ardern is playing for time, to see how things play out.

        It may require some more info to come to light for Curran to go. But, i do think Curran looked weak in press stand up this afternoon, and think she will go tomorrow. She’s a dead woman walking.

        • Matthew Whitehead 13.1.1.1

          That is my take too, although I don’t know if it will be as soon as tomorrow. 🙂 I would have thought it was when I first heard the story, but…

    • Bill 13.2

      “And in our second 100 days in office, we will attempt to eat ourselves for breakfast.”

      I’m right in saying there is pressure from within caucus to be done with Kirkton? And what does Helen Clark’s opinion have to do with anything – apart from the fact it carries heft and so plays into any pressure on Kirkton?

      • dukeofurl 13.2.1

        Kirton isnt appointed by Caucus, if he has the support of the President he will stay.

        [lprent: *sigh* The NZ Labour Party General Secretary is appointed as an employee by the NZ council into a paid position with some pretty specific tasks.

        Try reading the available documentation rather than simply lying when you don’t know. Take the next week to read it. Normally I’d give an educational ban. But I can’t be arsed doing the required work for someone who is probably just being a dimwit.

        However as you are probably aware, I really hate arseholes inventing false facts. Next time I see you do it, I will assist your attention to detail with a incredibly long ban. Your absence for an extended period will make the work worthwhile. ]

        • dukeofurl 13.2.1.1

          Quite so.
          “The General Secretary:
          (a) Holds office on terms and conditions agreed with the NZ Council; and
          (b) Must be confirmed in office at the first Annual Conference after his or her appointment.

          I merely ‘stated’ he wasnt appointed by caucus – the rules confirm this, my ‘opinion’ is if the President supports him he would stay.

    • weka 13.3

      I’m also curious about what the deal is with Clark. She’s been quite outspoken about a number of issues for NZ lately. Is she still between jobs?

      • Sacha 13.3.1

        Her close pal H2 will be keeping her updated from the inside more than in previous years.

      • Matthew Whitehead 13.3.2

        I think having been voted down by the UN and thus not needing to maintain a public profile that’s above national politics has freed her to talk.

        I wouldn’t classify her as “between jobs” so much as fulfilling the party elder role, and trying to be a conscience to the Labour Party now she doesn’t have to contend with political considerations herself.

      • veutoviper 13.3.3

        No, Helen Clark is not between jobs, but her new job is not as full time and consuming as her previous UN role.

        https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/politics/98718546/helen-clark-takes-job-at-global-commission-on-drug-policy

      • Anne 13.3.4

        Is she still between jobs?

        Not really. She’s highly sought after on the international speaking circuit. Don’t think she charges $500,000 though. 🙂

        She’s essentially back in NZ now. It’s her country and her base. She’s not holding down any official position so she is free to express opinions just like the rest of us.

  14. weka 14

    Can someone please catch me up on the sequence of events?

    CH and CC arranged to have a meeting, in a cafe.

    CC didn’t put that in her Ministerial diary?

    At some point CH told her bosses that the meeting was not prearranged but that they had run into each other.

    Eventually questions were asked in the House, and CC obfuscated but essentially said that the meeting was not prearranged.

    For some reason CH has now told her boss that it was prearranged. She resigned for lying to him?

    CC is now trying to fudge it some more.

    What I don’t get is what would be the problem with CH meeting with CC in a cafe? i.e why the need to lie about whether the meeting was planned or not?

    • Carolyn_Nth 14.1

      What I don’t get is what would be the problem with CH meeting with CC in a cafe? i.e why the need to lie about whether the meeting was planned or not?

      I suspect it’s because RNZ is a National Party appointment, and tipped to prepare RNZ for privatisation.

    • McFlock 14.2

      I think it’s more the principle that if a minister is backchannelling two or three levels down the chain, it’s essentially making it impossible for the people in the intermediate positions to do their jobs by opening the organisation to conflicting objectives.

      Additionally, the minister is there for governance, not to manage specific aspects of operation.

      And the board is supposed to be in charge, as well. Ministerial meddling can make it difficult for them to fulfill their statutory obligations.

      And finally, if the minister is cutting a chief executive out of the loop, then basically it creates an untenable workplace for that executive and opens the govt to massive employment payouts, when you could have just replaced them normally without grievance some time later. Ctutting them out suggests any consideration was predetermined.

    • Sacha 14.3

      “CC didn’t put that in her Ministerial diary? ”

      And now we are told she did.

    • veutoviper 14.4

      I posted a detailed timeline at 13.3 on Open Mike as I have been watching this fiasco from its early days and had kept a record as I needed to get my head around the sequence etc.

    • veutoviper 14.5

      What I don’t get is what would be the problem with CH meeting with CC in a cafe? i.e why the need to lie about whether the meeting was planned or not?

      Nothing if they were personal friends, relatives etc and it was a strictly personal get-together.

      If however,it was a business meeting, then it would be unusual or possibly against RNZ’s own rules for someone at Herschfeld’s level to meet with a Minister without first getting the approval of the CEO – and possibly that of the Chairman of the RNZ Board.

      Its were a get-together is a bit of each that things can get really tricky – and perhaps this one was. In which case, you meet in private somewhere – your home etc; not in a very public cafe.

      Anyone at Curran’s level and at Herschfeld level should know the rules and conventions – as these are there to protect you as much as your position/organisation.

    • Ovid 14.6

      What I don’t get is what would be the problem with CH meeting with CC in a cafe? i.e why the need to lie about whether the meeting was planned or not?

      I delved into the Cabinet Manual. Radio New Zealand is a Crown Entity. The Manual says under the Crown Entities Act “an accountability relationship exists between Crown entities, their board members, and their responsible Ministers on behalf of the Crown and the House of Representatives”.

      Statutory Crown Entities: a guide for ministers (pdf) says on p.34 “As the responsible Minister, you should regularly engage with your board(s) to clarify performance and any other expectations you or the Government may have, reduce misunderstandings, and enhance the relationship you have with the board”.

      Engaging in an end-run around the board to a staff member while not explicitly ruled out by the Cabinet Manual or the Guide undermines this relationship.

    • Matthew Whitehead 14.7

      So, there’s a few problems:

      * RNZ has procedures about how to meet with ministers to avoid the perception of meddling in their operational independence. Curran made no attempt to check if such procedures existed before arranging a meeting, and either did not correctly direct her staff to find out any such information, or her staff failed to prevent her cock-up, too. If Curran wanted a meeting with Hirschfeld, she should have gone through top management at RNZ first for permission. At this stage, I will grant her that she didn’t intend to dodge those procedures.

      * Curran was incorrect that this meeting counted as informal, and corrected the record in her official dairy after the fact. This should be largely a non-issue now, as she has apologized and corrected the record, but it again goes to her lack of competence as a minister.

      * Both Curran and Hirschfeld have lied and said the meeting was coincidental, when it was in fact arranged.
      Hirschfeld has had to resign because she lied on the public record, and she had to admit so to her boss, (the reason for the admission is unknown at this stage) and she did the right thing by resigning. [Actually, looks like I was wrong here WRT Curran- I’m having difficulty finding Curran on record saying the meeting was coincidental, but she is in the “either lied or was incompetent” situation regardless in claiming that she thought it was informal, and had to correct the record. – MjW]
      Curran has spun this as “different versions of events,” but this does mean she has potentially misled the house if she ever claimed the meeting was coincidental in Parliament- from what I recall she may have said “informal” in oral answers, in which case she’s off the hook there, but would still be very vulnerable to attack from the opposition.
      A couple of senior RNZ managers will now need to correct their statements to the select committee, too.

      * Paul Thompson, RNZ’s CEO, has said the meeting was inappropriate and that it likely included discussion of RNZ+, and given Hirschfeld’s then-role as Head of News, she should probably not be meeting with the Minister alone, and there would be issues of commercial sensitivity here, too.

      * For LOLs, the meeting happened at Astoria, (for those who don’t know Wellington well enough, that’s a very busy café, and there’s no way Curran wouldn’t have been seen with Hirschfeld) so the secret part here is that the nature of the meeting has been covered up, not that it was actually happening in private in any way.

      * This is further complicated by Curran’s other role as Minister for Open Government, because she should have a higher standard about telling the truth and being perceived to tell the truth and properly disclose. For any other Minister, this would be a stupid mistake that couldn’t lead to calls for her head without evidence of the actual wrongdoing, (but would still make them look slimy) but in this case prevarication and attempts to dodge directly undermine her credibility in her other portfolio.

      So essentially, it’s a case of “don’t cover things up, it’s worse than the crime, especially if you’re the Minister for Open Government.

      • tracey 14.7.1

        Thanks for that summary

      • dukeofurl 14.7.2

        Are you sure of your facts ?
        Both Curran and Hirschfeld have lied and said the meeting was coincidental.”

        Curran has NEVER said the meeting was coincidental, that was Hirschfeld alone

        Theres rules about attacking authors here , but nothing says we cant point out gross misinformation

        • tracey 14.7.2.1

          Just that it was informal and didnt need to be reported

        • Matthew Whitehead 14.7.2.2

          She certainly never said so in Parliament, although she did have to correct a written answer on that meeting. I would have said she might have said “coincidental” outside of Parliament, but I wouldn’t bet on it, so you may be right.

          I encourage pointing out errors, this was an abnormally fast post for me, I usually take several hours of checking facts and ensuring I don’t imply anything I shouldn’t, but thought you all deserved some discussion of it, so things got a bit more muddled for me than they usually do.

      • veutoviper 14.7.3

        Matthew, all the videos and Hansard links to the Oral Questions in the House that Curran has answered on this meeting are in my comment at 13.3 in Open Mike if anyone wants them – rather than having to delve all over the Parliament website.

        The videos are worth a look to see Curran’s demeanour and attitude in answering questions. Mallard has no time for her as a result and gives her no leeway. They had quite a little ‘polite’ confrontation last Thursday when she was answering another question from Lee unrelated to this matter.

        https://www.parliament.nz/en/watch-parliament/ondemand?itemId=198962

      • weka 14.7.4

        Cheers Matt, that’s a good explanation (and that of others above).

        So essentially, from what everyone is saying, CH shouldn’t have met with CC without taking someone with her and telling her boss. CC should have known that was a requirement and is either doing her job badly or doing her job really badly.

        At some point CH or both of them lied about whether the meeting was planned.

        Still unexplained is why CH lied, and then why she came clean. Got to feel for her, because that might just be one of those stupid in the moment mistakes that one thinks isn’t going to be a big deal but seriously damages one’s life (in this case her career).

        • Matthew Whitehead 14.7.4.1

          Well, it’s more like CC should never have asked CH directly, he should have asked her boss, and CH should never have accepted directly, she should have uplined the request to her boss for approval through the correct processes.

          CH definitely lied, and CC is, at the least, spinning this rather unfairly as CH’s fault to minimize blowback on herself. There is speculation that she did so for internal RNZ politics reasons, and that CC may have been backing her, but we honestly don’t know why for sure- at first I couldn’t find that info so I had assumed the only reason to lie was to cover up the topic of the meeting, and that surely that would have to reflect badly on CC.

          And yeah, I definitely feel for her, although I would also say she should have been fired if she hadn’t resigned, even though I know she was excellent at her job if the final product is anything to judge her by.

  15. Ad 15

    My bet is Hirschfelt was being tapped to replace Griffin, so he knifed her.

    • Muttonbird 15.1

      Yeah, it’s nothing to do with ‘transparency’. The meeting at the Astoria was a (turns out clumsy) discussion about the future of RNZ under Hirschfeld.

      Griffin spat the dummy.

    • Tiger Mountain 15.2

      yep, traces of a classic Wellington “assassination”, and as another well known blogger asked–“who was the rat?”

      all of which does not excuse Curran’s behaviour, but the new govt. needs to realise “they” ARE out to get them; and need keep a closer eye on all the Yes Minister tories at the top of the public service!

      • Muttonbird 15.2.1

        Clearly a few in RNZ resented Hirschfeld’s rise.

        Hopefully Ardern has further information on how this played out and who the players are which is why she’s resisting calls for Curran’s sacking.

      • Carolyn_Nth 15.2.2

        Who was the rat? Seems to have been Curran – see my comment below.

    • weka 15.3

      He’ll be leaving anyway though, right? So he would knife her to keep a good person out of the job?

      • Ad 15.3.1

        Yes. He has his own names and succession plan. A core part of a Chair and Boards job.

        Fully a fireable offence.

        • Muttonbird 15.3.1.1

          A succession plan he had absolutely no power nor authority to implement. Unless I’m mistaken the government does the hiring there. Perhaps in the private sector or in party politics succession plans might be relevant but not in the public service I would have thought.

          His having a succession plan (if that’s the case) is as bad as Hirschfeld meeting with Curran to press her case for the job!

        • veutoviper 15.3.1.2

          ” He has his own names and succession plan.”

          Griffin always has – even when he was/is not actually in a position of authority to do so and whether it is a private business, public service organisation or a not for profit. I know from personal experience. But Griffin is well on in years now and from what I hear, not that interested in the hands-on way of operating that he used to be.

          But I am not sure that Chair of the Board, or on the Board ,of RNZ would actually be Herschfeld’s scene or interest.

      • McFlock 15.3.2

        Definitely.
        In defeat, malice; in victory, revenge!

        • Sanctuary 15.3.2.1

          You should open for Australia, I hear they have a vacancy. You’d fit right in!

          • McFlock 15.3.2.1.1

            ha – that was another Yes Minister line, talking about the motto of the new Prime Minister in series 1 as I recall. It really is an outstanding guide to dealing with workplace manipulators and bullies.

            I sometimes suspect that questions along the lines of “but why would X do Y?” are because the questioners are too nice to understand some of the seedier parts of life. But Aussie cricketers are a good start.

    • Sacha 15.4

      No way she would want to be the Chair. Would have led their push into TV and then likely become CEO when the timing was right. What a waste.

    • The whole incident stinks of Crosby/Dexter and the Nat’s dirty tricks brigade ,and how anyone who declares they are Labour supporters is beyond me.

  16. adam 16

    Curren is an awful failure as a politician, from her condescendance, to her inability to actually do the job she was elected for.

    I’m surprised how she holds her seat, let alone the utter shock when they made her a minister. I’m going with the dead bodies theory.

    This is a person who has truly risen way above their level of incompetence. Be nice to have a government unlike the last one, in that they actually deal with arrogant tools.

  17. Carolyn_Nth 17

    People are asking who was the rat that tipped off Richard Griffin that the meeting was not accidental.

    Well, it seems to have been Claire Curran on 1st and 22 March 2018.

    I am laughing as I type. But cynically. Seriously, Curran has REALLY let down Hirschfeld.

    https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/politics/102619960/rnz-senior-manager-carol-hirschfeld-resigns-over-meeting-with-minister

  18. Alfie 18

    Hold on a minute people. Stuff is reporting that it was actually Curran who informed RNZ on 1st March about the meeting with Hirschfeld. When CH denied this to her RNZ bosses, Curran’s office again contacted RNZ (22nd March) to point out the inconsistency in CH’s statement. Note also…

    “The meeting was pre-arranged, and was in Curran’s ministerial diary.”

    https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/politics/102619960/rnz-senior-manager-carol-hirschfeld-resigns-over-meeting-with-minister

    While I’ve never met the woman, Clare Curran has done a stirling job of representing the people of South Dunedin for many years. She’s one of those hard-working MPs who deserves a lot better than some of the treatment being handed out above.

    Just saying.

    • Ad 18.1

      Then she should be nothing but a local MP.

      Ain’t no one will ever speak to her or trust her in Wellington now.

      She’s radioactive.

      • dukeofurl 18.1.1

        Do you apply the same standard to Peter Dunne and his meeting with a journalist

        • Sacha 18.1.1.1

          This is the Minister of Broadcasting meeting with a person with editorial control over a public broadcaster. Bigger stakes.

          • DoublePlusGood 18.1.1.1.1

            You have to admire the huge euphemism of ‘meeting with’ though…

          • dukeofurl 18.1.1.1.2

            Would having a social meeting with Paul Holmes – a leading broadcaster at the time be regarded as ‘unacceptable’

            • Gosman 18.1.1.1.2.1

              Was Paul Holmes working for a public broadcaster at the time and the meeting was not made aware to the board of the broadcaster at the time?

    • Matthew Whitehead 18.2

      Cheers.

  19. dukeofurl 19

    Key used to wrangle out of revealing ‘official contacts’ all the time by claiming they were done as an MP

    Eg The Contacts with Slater

    “Back in early 2014 Newstalk ZB requested records of all such contacts that had occurred over a two year period.

    John Key’s office declined to release details, saying to do so would require substantial research and collation and also that some communications may have been made in Mr Key’s capacity as an MP and leader of the National Party.
    http://www.newstalkzb.co.nz/news/politics/ombudsman-to-investigate-john-key-over-blogger-contact/

    So Key was allowed to claim contacts with a ‘ self described journalist’ were done in his capacity as an MP and didnt have to be revealed !

    • Matthew Whitehead 19.1

      It’s about having arguable credibility. Curran attempting to claim the same thing here would be laughed out of the room- the Minister for Broadcasting does not meet with an RNZ employee as an MP, but any other Minister could.

  20. Sacha 20

    “after having been persuaded to lie for her minister”

    No evidence to support that claim yet, Matthew.

    • Matthew Whitehead 20.1

      That’s fair, but I’m not editing that because I do think there’s something that smells funny about Curran minimizing the meeting while Hirschfeld was lying about it. Upthread they seem to think it’s about a power play to take control of RNZ, which may be the case, but it’s still unacceptable.

      Curran is implicated either way as it would have been an inappropriate discussion for her to have.

      • Sacha 20.1.1

        Hey it’s your defamation risk, not mine. 🙂

        • Matthew Whitehead 20.1.1.1

          Eh, if anyone would like to contest that that’s what’s happened officially I’ll be happy to take it down or post a correction, but I don’t like to edit things that were overtaken by events that frequently.

        • Matthew Whitehead 20.1.1.2

          Have updated post now that commenting is finished to withdraw and apologize, btw. Later news definitely made it clear as to what was going on and that the fishiness was around Curran’s having dobbed Hirschfeld in, effectively.

      • dukeofurl 20.1.2

        Have you retracted your claim that Curran lied and claimed the meeting was coincidental ?

        • tracey 20.1.2.1

          Isnt that what she said in Parliament?

          ” because I didnt perceive it as an official meeting”

        • Sacha 20.1.2.2

          That one is supported by Curran’s own differing statements.

      • mac1 20.1.3

        Matthew, I do have to say that your failure to process properly figures on Clare Curran’s personal performance in Dunedin South both personally and for the Party vote does not sit well alongside your willingness to not amend an opinion based on such evidence as “I do think there’s something that smells funny”………

        I refer to our discussion at 10.2.1.1.1 and ff above.

        • Matthew Whitehead 20.1.3.1

          You left out every year she lost votes, Mac1. I didn’t fail anything there, and I feel you were very disingenuous in your argument that she did well given the other factors going on in the 2017 election. She has overall lost a lot more ground than she gained, even compared to Labour’s national-level figures.

          I’ve edited the comment in question- I had thought that the thing about talking about *both* of them was in the post when people raised it. It’s very easy to get confused when you go straight from writing to moderating with no gap in between about what you said in the comments vs what you said in your post, especially when you’ve got dyslexia and you can get mixed up when you’re tired.

  21. weka 21


    Tim Murphy
    ‏ @tmurphyNZ
    5h5 hours ago
    Replying to @jmjenningsnz

    It is odd. Surely editors can meet ministers, whether they bump into them or not, unless inopportune corporate or governance matters were discussed.

    WhakarauJK
    ‏ @ArrestJK
    4m4 minutes ago

    WhakarauJK Retweeted Sacha Dylan

    They are meant to put any such preplanned meetings in their diaries Clarie didn’t until 24 hrs later that’s it that’s all. Carol on the other hand lied and continued to (why is a good question)

  22. mary_a 22

    It’s a pity Carol Hirschfield resigned, considering she is one of the best broadcasters and broadcasting brains in NZ. Her resignation from RNZ is NZ’s loss.

    Clare Curran is proving a liability to the coalition government now. She has been caught covering up details of this issue, so on principle IMO she should resign.

  23. Delia 23

    Well tell it to Curran’s electorate because they have voted her in over and over again, so presumably are happy with her performance for them.

    • Sacha 23.1

      Electorate MPs do not need to be Ministers.

    • timeforacupoftea 23.2

      A turkey could win our Labour safe seat.

    • Matthew Whitehead 23.3

      Electorates don’t vote to determine ministers, Delia. Under Labour, their Caucus votes to determine who gets into cabinet, and then the Prime Minister distributes portfolios based on that team. So my real beef is with every MP who voted that Clare Curran should go into shadow cabinet.

      If she wants to stay on as MP for Dunedin South, that doesn’t bother me.

  24. Sacha 24

    http://www.newshub.co.nz/home/politics/2018/03/hirschfeld-resignation-clare-curran-to-stay-on-as-minister.html

    But Ms Curran defended her own conduct during what she called an “informal catch up over breakfast.”

    “At no time have I ever said the meeting was coincidental.

    “While I believe the meeting was not official and informal, as soon as I became aware that it should have been considered an official meeting in answer to a written question, I corrected the Parliamentary record. This was a mistake.

    “The meeting was not a secret, and I regret that the meeting took place.”

  25. tracey 25

    Cabinet Manual: in personal and professional behaviour will uphold the highest ethical standards.

  26. Sacha 26

    http://www.radionz.co.nz/news/national/353485/curran-on-hirschfeld-s-resignation-it-was-not-a-secret-meeting

    “now that I am aware RNZ has policies around meetings with ministers”

    FFS, you’re a Minister. How could it possibly be a surprise?

    • Matthew Whitehead 26.1

      Honestly, I actually believe her on that. She’s absolutely incompetent enough to have not known to check that sort of thing.

    • McFlock 26.2

      Also known as “I misinterpreted the rules” lol

      • tracey 26.2.1

        Nats have been wilfully misinterpreting the Privacy Act for years with no consequence.

        Are we suggesting this got leaked today to coved the Finlayson story cos outside Newsroom it appears Finlayson’s depriving a defendant of evidence was not deemed newsworthy.

      • Keepcalmcarryon 26.2.2

        Misunderestimated even.

  27. Grant 27

    Meet the new boss, same as the old boss

  28. mauī 28

    Thanks for encapsulating this Matt. It does seem a great opportunity to bring on a new talent now, someone who is a great communicator, onto it and knows politics. Having a look at the current Ministers in this Gov, there’s not really many to get excited about. Maybe I’m being too harsh though, expecting another Lange-esque figure to emerge.

    • Matthew Whitehead 28.1

      Eh, I don’t think it’s harsh to want people who are inspiring in government, but I’ll accept people who are convincing, or competent, or bold instead. I personally do not find Curran to be any of those things, but there are people in Dunedin who feel she’s an advocate, and I don’t think she’s done anything worthy of resigning as an MP over.

  29. timeforacupoftea 30

    It will be great to have somebody decent representing us labourites in the very very safe South Dunedin seat.
    A turkey could win this seat for Labour.
    It appears we have years of clowns representing us down here.
    Please find someone with good morals for a change.

    • Heather Grimwood 30.1

      to timeforacupoftea at 30 : Normally I dismiss such lazy vitriol, but this column is riddled with it today/tonight. I grieve.
      Please don’t let TS descend to level of talkback. It is an avenue for considered discussion, not for the vitriol being seeded.

      • Matthew Whitehead 30.1.1

        “Clowns” is rather tame by the standards here, but yes, I prefer considered discussion to name-calling, although I understand feelings will be high on this one.

  30. dukeofurl 31

    “Broadcasting Minister Clare Curran says she told RNZ in early March that her meeting with senior manager Carol Hirschfeld was not coincidental.”

    https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/politics/102619960/rnz-senior-manager-carol-hirschfeld-resigns-over-meeting-with-minister

    A lot of people need to retract their claims over Curran. We wait for the mea culpas

  31. veutoviper 32

    OMG – probably no connection, but Jacinda Ardern is looking for a new Chief Press Officer and the ad went up first thing on Monday morning.

    Herschfeld? I do like the occasional conspiracy theory ….

    https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/politics/102592564/prime-minister-jacinda-ardern-on-the-hunt-for-new-press-secretary

    • Anne 32.1

      Hope she goes for it and gets it.

      • veutoviper 32.1.1

        I was being a bit tongue in cheek – but I think there will be some interesting things coming up in the coming months in the field not just connected with RNZ directly – but also NZ on Air and various media advisory groups etc.

        Found this very interesting Australian Women’s Weekly (YES, believe it or not!) in June 2017, which leads me to think that because of her daughter’s age (17?) she might not be available for a heavy all hours job at present such as the Chief Press Officer job.

        https://www.pressreader.com/new-zealand/australian-womens-weekly-nz/20170622/281694024810236

  32. Muttonbird 34

    Here we go. Peter Thompson of The Better Public Media Trust argues that,

    Although the Opposition is attempting to highlight ministerial impropriety, informal meetings between ministers and people in public sector positions are commonplace.

    and,

    The timing of Hirschfeld’s departure may…hint at a deeper conflict with her RNZ bosses over RNZ+.

    and,

    Richard Griffin recently claimed that RNZ was not planning a stand-alone TV channel, and last year he rejected Better Public Media’s claims that RNZ needed significant additional funding, even advising the Commerce Committee that RNZ was a ‘competitive organisation, not public service per se’.

    Looks to me like Griffin has always been against RNZ+ and this is what led to the meeting between Hirschfeld and Curran, and the subsequent fall-out from that meeting.

    http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=12021221

    • Carolyn_Nth 34.1

      Thanks. Now that is interesting.

    • veutoviper 34.2

      And I would say that Thompson’s opinion that Hirschfeld’s departure hints at deeper conflicts within RNZ (ie with Griffin) over RNZ+ is absolutely spot on.

      IMO, having had some very close dealings with Griffin in relation to a not-for-profit we were both involved in outside of our paid work, he is a through and through blue and would have been mortified when the Coalition Government was set up – and will be totally opposed to what is proposed for RNZ. He is also someone who does not follow rules and conventions when it does not suit him and his goal to do so. Integrity is not his strong suite; expediency is.

      He sees himself as the saviour of RNZ over the last seven or so years since he was appointed Chairman of the RNZ Board; and will not accept anyone wanting to change it. So I don’t find it surprising he has come out of the woodwork after being very much MIA for some years.

      This article in Sept 2017 gives some insight into his thinking re RNZ
      https://www.stuff.co.nz/nelson-mail/news/96119720/enjoying-the-view-from-both-sides-of-the-fence

      But lets face it, this is a last ditch fight on his side, as he knows the new government is very unlikely to roll over his Chairmanship again.

    • Matthew Whitehead 34.3

      Ta.

  33. Delia 35

    Curran has been an MP since 2008, and I have never seen such a merciless attack on a Labour MP in here before. She is an electorate MP and is well regarded in her electorate. Why not just do National’s job for them, most of you are doing very well and from where I am sitting it all looks very personal.

    • Carolyn_Nth 35.1

      Curran may well be a very good electorate MP. But that doesn’t mean she’ll make a good minister. She has handled this issue very clumsily, and has put the whole Labour plan for RNZ+ under threat. This needs to be handled with someone with far better political savvy.

      We desperately need a better public service media. The right wing and the right wing commercial media do not want it. They perceive Curran to be weak and will go after her.

    • veutoviper 35.2

      Delia, some people are good are some things and bad at others. From everything I hear she is an excellent electorate MP. I personally would not like to see her resign from that role; it is just that to some of us outside her electorate, she did not seem to do to well in the IT and communications roles she held in opposition so it was a bit of surprise that she was made Minister in charge of these areas.

      Perhaps she would be better suited to some other areas like social welfare, poverty, housing etc ?

    • Louis 35.3

      +1 Delia

    • Matthew Whitehead 35.4

      I will concede she may be a good electorate MP, and I am certainly happy for the two women she helped into state houses. I have no objections to her remaining a good electorate MP. But if you know anything about either open government or ICT, you will know she is a terrible spokesperson or Minister in the areas she’s always been assigned.

      It may be she’s just got the wrong portfolios. But I ask you to seriously go and have a look and see if she has accomplished a single concrete thing since becoming a minister- Even Twyford has set up a housing development now, despite having a really hard job of getting the ball rolling on Kiwibuild, and he and David Clark have the two hardest jobs after nine years of National. I ask you to actually compare her speeches in the house with a speech on the same topic by an expert and look for a single informed or insightful comment in her policy areas.

      She was on Twitter arguing with Rachel Glucina after she defended herself today, which again goes to competence- when you are under attack and it looks bad for you, you should sit down and wait for feelings to cool, especially if you’re not Judith Collins.

      She has been a spokesperson for a long time, and needs to be moved on. This has crossed the line that is acceptable for someone in her portfolio in my view.

      As to loyalty to Labour- no thankyou. I will be friendly with Labour, and I will defend them when they deserve it, even though they’re not my party. But blindly withholding criticism is surely a step too far.

    • SHG 35.5

      Curran has been an MP since 2008, and I have never seen such a merciless attack on a Labour MP in here before.

      You must be new here. Curran’s a muppet, a vindictive poisonous incompetent pretender. She deserves everything she gets here.

  34. peterlepaysan 36

    Curran as Minister for open Government? Hah!
    Anyone remember Red Alert, the so called Labour Party blog?
    Curran censored any comments not approved of by a censor known as “Spud” (I suspect it was related to a duck).

    OBTW I too have had dealings with Richard Griffin (going back decades) and endorse comments from Veutoviper.

  35. SPC 37

    So someone who should not be meeting with the Minister, does so, at an arranged meet at a public location. So it’s in the Ministers personal diary but not the Ministerial diary, until added a day later as an informal meet.

    The Minister is asked about in Parliament (and calls it an informal meet, not an official meeting of the Minister), RNZ boss gets asked by a Select Committee (and repeats the line of a staff member that it was not an arranged meeting – thus the claim of being misled by the employee).

    What is the difference between an arranged unofficial meet between the Minister and a RNZ employee and an arranged official meeting with the Minister – well the one that occurs when the employee is not supposed to have (arranged) meetings with the Minister.

    Does no one arrange dinner parties … where the two can meet … just walk into the backyard and have a talk?

  36. repateet 38

    Curran as Minister for Open Government is as appropriate as having Judith Collins as Minister of Justice.

    Did Curran meet Hirschfeld on the way to the airport?

  37. Sacha 39

    Journos adding to the story: https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/politics/102649454/rnz-saga-could-hinge-on-curranhirschfeld-texts

    Stuff has been told by an RNZ source that Curran and Hirschfeld communicated by text over a period of several days ahead of their meeting …

    By Tuesday night Curran’s office could confirm that a [OIA] process was “in train” for the text messages to be released.

    RNZ is reeling over the controversy, with one source describing it as a “debacle” and a disaster for the broadcaster. Hirschfeld was a popular and respected member of the senior team and no one could understand why she did it.

    • Carolyn_Nth 39.1

      Thanks.

      And this from the article:

      parking suspicions within RNZ that Curran wanted to pump Hirschfeld for information about potential roadblocks to Labour’s plan for the state broadcaster to set up a free-to-air TV arm.

      Board chair Richard Griffin and chief executive Paul Thompson are known to be unenthusiastic about the TV plan, and would rather put the money into other platforms. Hirschfeld, who came to RNZ from a broadcasting background, backed the proposal.

      Griffin is also seen as being on Curran’s hit-list, after the pair sparred for many years while she was opposition broadcasting spokesman. His term as chair expires in April and there is an expectation he will not be reappointed

    • veutoviper 39.2

      Right … I am now beginning to understand why the PM is backing up Curran for the moment at least. Basically to hold the line until Griffin is gone, replaced etc in April and other things that are in train (related budget decisions, announcements etc in May) have reached more conclusive stages.

      To step Curran down right now could be seen as weak, and giving in to the opposition from certain RNZ quarters to the RNZ+ plans, which were part of the Labour Party campaign promises.

      • Matthew Whitehead 39.2.1

        So why not just replace Curran but keep the plan and still replace Griffin?

        There’s nothing that says you need Curran to do any of that.

  38. Trewindle 40

    Hi Weka,

    Clare’s active enough that she fields requests and then acts on them from North Dunedinites as well as working for her own constituents. From what I’ve seen working with her (including on her campaign last year), she is the South D candidate because of her hard work in the electorate and her involvement in keeping our services and advocating on behalf of people that need help accessing them, as when she camped in the octagon until two young mothers were supplied with state houses here.

    • weka 40.1

      thanks Trewindle.

    • Heather Grimwood 40.2

      to Trewindle at 40: Absolutely so ….. regarding her camping protest in theOctagon…it was really freezing …she developed a chestiness through that but persisted. Another night would have seen her very ill indeed in my opinion. How many of the writers of vitriol above would have had the guts to do what she did? She actually had two-legged trolls sent to hassle her by day too….probably they had no idea how obvious that were.

    • dukeofurl 40.3

      Thanks Trewindle, good to hear from people who have experience with Clares work in Dunedin, as you reminded us
      Dunedin MP camps out in Octagon to highlight homelessness

      An MP who is camping in the centre of Dunedin until two single mothers get a state house says they have run out of options.

      Clare Curran started her protest in the Octagon on Sunday night, saying she will stay for as long as she has to.
      https://www.radionz.co.nz/national/programmes/checkpoint/audio/201851516/dunedin-mp-camps-out-in-octagon-to-highlight-homelessness

  39. Keepcalmcarryon 41

    Next time news hub or garner tries to crap on about labour how about reminding them of John Key and his non meetings before giving private media public money
    : https://thedailyblog.co.nz/2018/03/28/national-pissed-off-labour-is-nicking-john-keys-dodginess/

  40. Sacha 42

    Released text messages between Curran and Hirschfeld reveal nothing about meeting topic: http://www.radionz.co.nz/news/political/353548/text-messages-between-curran-and-hirschfeld-released

  41. Sparky 43

    It never gets any better…..not sure what more there is to say……

  42. Sacha 44

    Ex-TV3 head of news Mark Jennings tries to make sense of it: https://www.newsroom.co.nz/2018/03/27/100637/coffee-meeting-leaves-rnz-in-a-mess

  43. Peroxide Blonde 45

    I can hear Colonial Viper giggling madly in the distance.

    The hapless Curran screwed up publicly in handling lively activity in her electorate a few years ago. She even wanted the NZ Council to kick people out of the party who had the temerity to grow the Labour party in her patch.

    Her holding the national Govt to account during the “un-bundling of the loop” was atrocious. She failed to spot that Telecom/Spark retained the core network. She was way out of her depth. She help a positions because she is foot soldier for Grant Robertson.

    The story here is the dynamic between Robertson and Ardern.

  44. SHG 46

    Lest we forget.

    I, Vipertacus

    • veutoviper 46.1

      Lest we forget indeed! Gosh how time flies.

      just look at us all and see who is still here six years later.

      Really interesting to read your 42 there again SHG. Food for thought.

      Thanks for this.

      • SHG 46.1.1

        QoT’s comment at 46.1 of that old thread seems apropos:

        as far as Labour/Clare Curran is concerned, “Open Government” means “we demand transparency of the government while in opposition but deny basic freedom of expression to people who disagree with us”

  45. NewsFlash 47

    What a load of TRIVIA, I think I’ll go back to reading the Womens Weekly

    • R.P McMurphy 47.1

      right on the flash.
      this molehill is about to implode soon.
      what a crap shit storm invented by the nationals.
      time for RNZ to ditch the tory cabal and set off on a new direction of honesty and objectivity.

  46. Philg 48

    This, amongst other things, shows how the MSM are controlling the narrative in this country, and RNZ is part of the problem. Clare is not up to the huge task of setting up a quality, non commercial Public Broadcaster. This is the foundations of Demockary we are attempting to construct. Without a well resourced, impartial, non commercial, and informed media there is no Democracy. How much does the SIS and GCSB cost per annum? Get on with it.

    • SHG 48.1

      Quality noncommercial public broadcasting is what the country needs. Curran’s plan is to add… an Auckland TV station. If that isn’t reason to fire her I don’t know what is.

  47. Editor .My comment are not being recorded.

    [try altering your email address slightly (e.g. put a dot after the first three letters). At the moment all your comments are going into spam and sometimes that fixes that. – weka]

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

  • Shy Labour Voters?
    In previous elections pollsters have bemoaned the 'shy Tory' - the respondent who is so fearful of being judged as a cruel and heartless bastard by an anonymous pollster, or their spouses, workmates and friends, that they lie about their intention of voting Conservative, skewing the poll figures in Labour's ...
    2 hours ago
  • Seven reasons to be wary of waste-to-energy proposals
    Climate Explained is a collaboration between The Conversation, Stuff and the New Zealand Science Media Centre to answer your questions about climate change. If you have a question you’d like an expert to answer, please send it to climate.change@stuff.co.nz I was in Switzerland recently and discovered that they haven’t ...
    SciBlogsBy Guest Author
    6 hours ago
  • Reviewing the whitewash
    Back in 2015, then Ombudsman Beverley Wakem conducted a review of the OIA, Not a game of hide and seek. The "review" was a whitewash, which found no need for legislative change, and instead criticised the media and requesters - which destroyed Wakem's reputation, and undermined that of the Office ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    9 hours ago
  • You Gov MRP Poll Out
    So, You Gov's MRP poll - the weird one that tries to reflect what will happen at a constituency level and which pretty much nailed the hung parliament in 2017 - is not looking too good for Labour:
    UK #GE2019 MRP seat projection:CON: 339 (-20)LAB: 231 (+20)SNP: 41 (-2)LDEM: 15 ...
    10 hours ago
  • Climate Change: Accountability?
    We've known about climate change for over forty years now,and it has been a major political issue for twenty. And yet fossil fuel companies have kept polluting with impunity, while government have looked the other way and twiddled their thumbs and refused to do anything because "the economy", or just ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    10 hours ago
  • Delusional And Irrational: The Rise Of Paranoid Politics In New Zealand.
    Sheer Loopiness: Many of those expressing bemusement at the antics of these #turnardern effacers, were convinced that they were yet another expression of the National Party’s increasingly spiteful anti-government propaganda campaign. They marvelled at the oddness of the perpetrators’ mindset and questioned the common-sense of allowing the rest of New Zealand ...
    12 hours ago
  • Things to know about Whakaari/White Island
    Brad Scott, GNS Science VolcanologistThis post was originally published by GeoNet. Following the 9 December devastating eruption at Whakaari/White Island we have put together some information about the island. New Zealand’s most active volcano Whakaari/White Island is currently New Zealand’s most active volcano, it has been since an eruptive episode ...
    SciBlogsBy Guest Author
    1 day ago
  • Status quo supports status quo
    The Justice Committee has reported back on its Inquiry into the 2017 General Election and 2016 Local Elections, with a host of recommendations about how to improve our electoral systems. Some of their recommendations are already incorporate din the Electoral Amendment Bill currently before Parliament, but there's also a recommendation ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 day ago
  • The Greens abandon NeoLiberalism
    Back in 2017, in order to make themselves "electable" in the eyes of rich people who oppose everything they stand for, the Greens signed up for NeoLiberalism, adopting a restrictive set of "Budget Responsibility Rules" which basicly prevented them from using government to make things better. Now, they're finally abandoning ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 day ago
  • Lying about a failed war
    Since invading in 2001, the US has consistently claimed that their war in Afghanistan has been going well, even when it continued year after year after year. Of course, they were lying, and thanks to the Washington Post and the US Freedom of Information Act, we get to see just ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 day ago
  • Artificial Intelligence and You
    How should we think about artificial intelligence and the implications that it has for our work and leisure? There are many articles on artificial intelligence and its potential impacts on jobs, and the ethics of applications. These are important topics, but I want to focus on some less discussed aspects, ...
    SciBlogsBy Robert Hickson
    1 day ago
  • Statistical manipulation to get publishable results
    I love data. It’s amazing the sort of “discoveries” I can make given a data set and computer statistical package. It’s just so easy to search for relationships and test their statistical significance. Maybe relationships which ...
    1 day ago
  • More lies on the Twitter (Dan Hodges edition)
    The other big story concerning Leeds Hospital is Boris Johnson's bizzare behaviour at Leeds Hospital, where he was confronted by a journalist and challenged about a four year old boy with suspected pneumonia who was left sleeping on the floor, rather than getting  abed like a sick kid would in ...
    2 days ago
  • LabourActivistPunchedMattHancock’sSPADGate
    So, for a brief period of history, it was alleged that a protester had punched Matt Hancock's SPAD (not a euphemism; special adviser) when Hancock visited Leeds Hospital.This was reported by the likes of Robert Peston and Laura Keunssberg, as well as the less credible Guido Fawkes.  It also quickly ...
    2 days ago
  • France’s anti-Zionism is anti-liberté
    by Daphna Whitmore Last week France passed a law that equates anti-Zionism with anti-Semitism. It is based on a definition of anti-Semitism that includes criticism of Israel such as: “Denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, e.g., by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist ...
    RedlineBy Daphna
    2 days ago
  • Another bus lockout
    Over the past year we've seen major bus problems in Hamilton and Wellington, as drivers have sought better wages and an end to the bullshit of split shifts, which basicly see them "married to the job". And now its Auckland's turn. When NZBus's drivers planned low-level strike action of not ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    2 days ago
  • Climate Change: Showing us how its done
    The government has been congratulating itself over the passage of the Zero Carbon Act, which sets out long-term emissions targets. But those targets are insufficient. Meanwhile, Denmark is showing us how its done:Denmark’s parliament adopted a new climate law on Friday, committing to reach 70% below its 1990 emissions in ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    2 days ago
  • Public sector dysfunction should not be allowed to undermine freedom of information
    Another day, another piece of legislation with a secrecy clause. This time its the innocuous-seeming Mental Health and Wellbeing Commission Bill, which (after establishing a new body and making it subject to the OIA in three different ways) includes the rapidly-becoming-standard clauses enabling it to request information from other public ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    2 days ago
  • “This is England, this knife of Sheffield steel…”
    The state of the United Kingdom is fractured, torn up, shredded. The Empire is gone, it died a long time ago. And yet, the country is still tracking with a lead in favour of the ones who play to the ingrained, class-bound division for political gain. It is a disgrace ...
    exhALANtBy exhalantblog
    4 days ago
  • CORSIA, coming soon to an airport near you
    On 27 September, Greta Thunberg addressed a crowd of 500,000 at the School Strike for Climate in Montreal, saying: “You are a nation that is allegedly a climate leader. And Sweden is also a nation that is allegedly a climate leader. And in both cases, it means absolutely nothing. Because ...
    SciBlogsBy Robert McLachlan
    4 days ago
  • Cloaking hate speech and fake news in the right to free expression.
    It should be obvious by now but let’s be clear: The same folk who regularly traffic in disinformation, misinformation and “fake news” are also those who most strongly claim that their freedom of expression rights are being violated when moves are made to curb hate speech (as opposed to protected ...
    KiwipoliticoBy Pablo
    4 days ago
  • The Physics (and Economics, and Politics) of Wheelchairs on Planes
    Michael Schulson When Shane Burcaw flies on an airplane, he brings along a customized gel cushion, a car seat, and about 10 pieces of memory foam. The whole arsenal costs around $1,000, but for Burcaw it’s a necessity. The 27-year-old author and speaker — who, alongside his fiancée, Hannah ...
    SciBlogsBy Guest Author
    5 days ago
  • To Advance Civil Rights, Oppose Transgender Extremism
    We are very pleased to publish this submission is from Lucinda Stoan. She is a social justice activist, mother, and educator, based in Washington State in the  US.   This detailed and comprehensive source-linked overview of trans issues and what is at stake will be useful for many people, especially in ...
    RedlineBy Daphna
    5 days ago
  • Faafoi should be fired
    Newshub last night reported that Broadcasting Minister Kris Faafoi had apparently promised to help out a mate with an immigration issue. While its normal for people to approach MPs for assistance in this area, when you're a Minister, the rules are different: as the Cabinet Manual says, Ministers must "at ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    5 days ago
  • Adrian Orr – The Reserve Bank’s Revolutionary Governor?
    New Zealand's Underarm Banker: It bears recalling that the “independence” of the Reserve Bank Governor was for decades held up by neoliberal capitalists as the most compelling justification for passing the Reserve Bank Act. Interesting, is it not, how the ruling class’s support for the Bank’s independence lasted no longer than ...
    6 days ago
  • Driving Us Up The Poll.
    Rubbish In, Rubbish Out: Put all this together, and it’s difficult to avoid the conclusion that anyone who responds positively to a pollster’s request to “answer a few questions” is just ever-so-slightly weird. Desperately lonely? Some sort of psephological train-spotter? Political party member primed to skew the poll for or against ...
    6 days ago
  • Jordan Williams, Colin Craig podcast series announced
    “Free at last, Free at last, Thank God almighty we are free at last.” ― Martin Luther King Jr. A long and bitter court feud between former Conservative Party leader Colin Craig and Jordan Williams has been settled, with an apology and compensation from Williams. On Tuesday, Craig sent out ...
    The PaepaeBy Peter Aranyi
    6 days ago
  • Scientific integrity requires critical investigation – not blind acceptance
    Some people seem to want to close down any critical discussion of the current research into the relationship between water fluoride and child IQ. They appear to argue that claims made by researchers should not be open to critical review and that the claims be accepted without proper consideration ...
    6 days ago
  • Climate Change: The shameful reality
    The government has been congratulating itself over the passage of the Zero Carbon Act, which sets out long-term emissions targets. Meanwhile, Climate Action Tracker has the shameful reality: those targets are insufficient:While New Zealand is showing leadership by having passed the world’s second-ever Zero Carbon Act in November 2019, under ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    6 days ago
  • More secrecy
    The government introduced a Racing Industry Bill today. As an urban who horse racing as pointless-to-cruel, and gambling as a tax on stupidity and/or hope, this isn't normally a bill which would interest me in the slightest, beyond grumpiness at more government money for a dying industry. But there is ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    6 days ago
  • Unlikely online bully, Liam Hehir
    Check. Check. One, two, three, four. Is this thing ON? Hello readers, I logged in last night (yeah, it’s been a while) to mark THE END of the landmark legal case, Jordan Williams v Colin Craig, which (gulp) reached The Supreme Court, in which New Zealand’s most-defamed man was suing the politician he ...
    The PaepaeBy Peter Aranyi
    6 days ago
  • The Birth Of Israel: Wrong At The Right Time.
    Before The Birth: Israel’s most fervent supporters set their clocks ticking in Biblical times. They cite the kingdoms of David and Solomon as proof that, in the words of the Exodus movie’s theme-song: “This land is mine.” The majority of Israel’s backers, however, start their clocks in 1933 – the year Adolf ...
    6 days ago
  • Hard News: Public Address Word of the Year 2019: Korero phase
    In an unreliable, strange and confusing world, Public Address is proud to present a measure of comfort and stability by annually asking everyone what words or phrases sum up the year that's been – and then giving some of them consumer goods as prizes for being clever or simply lucky.Well, ...
    7 days ago
  • Generalist to specialist
    Both my parents are pretty handy – and they seem to have the right tools for most jobs in the garage and they know how to fix practically anything. A similar story could be told about their generation’s experience in the workforce – being a generalist was not unusual and ...
    SciBlogsBy Guest Author
    7 days ago
  • A “coincidence”
    When it was revealed that NZ First had tried to enrich itself from public office via the Provoncial Growth Fund, the Prime Minister assured us that everything was OK as Shane Jones, the Minister responsible for the fund, had recused himself. Except it seems that that recusal came very late ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • Member’s Day
    Today is a Member's Day, and probably the last one of the year. After the marathon of the End of Life Choice Act, most of the bills up for debate today are uncontentious. First up is the second reading of Chlöe Swarbrick's Election Access Fund Bill. This will be followed ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • Worse than I thought
    The Foreign Affairs, Defence and Trade Committee has reported back on the government's odious and tyrannical control orders bill. As expected, the fraudulent select committee process has made no significant changes (partly because they couldn't agree, but mostly because it was a stitch-up from the start, with no intention of ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • The cannabis bill and the referendum
    Yesterday, the government released its draft Cannabis Legalisation and Control Bill, which will be put to a non-binding referendum at the next election. I'm not a drug policy expert, but Russell Brown is, and he thinks its pretty good. And pretty obviously, it will be a massive improvement on the ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • Hard News: The Cannabis Legalisation and Control Bill: pretty good so far
    As you're probably aware, the draft bill outlining the proposed legal cannabis regime to be put to a referendum late next year was published yesterday, and has already attracted a flurry of comment. It's notable that a good deal of the comment is about proposals that aren't actually new.A minimum ...
    1 week ago
  • Climate Change: Alignment
    One of the big problems in New Zealand climate change policy is the government working at cross-purposes with itself. It wants to reduce fossil fuel use, but encourages oil and gas exploration. It wants to reduce transport emissions, but then builds enormous new roads. The problem could be avoided if ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • How climate change will affect food production and security
    Climate Explained is a collaboration between The Conversation, Stuff and the New Zealand Science Media Centre to answer your questions about climate change. If you have a question you’d like an expert to answer, please send it to climate.change@stuff.co.nz According to the United Nations, food shortages are a threat ...
    SciBlogsBy Guest Author
    1 week ago
  • More bad faith
    Last year, the government announced it was ending offshore oil exploration by no longer issuing new permits. The idea was that the industry would then die off as permits expired. Except almost immediately the government revealed its bad faith, by saying they would extend permits and alter conditions to keep ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • Banning foreign money from our elections
    The government has said it will ban foreign donations to political parties and candidates, and will be introducing legislation to be passed under all-stages urgency this afternoon. While I agree with the goal, I don't see a particular case for urgency, unless the government is concerned about a flood of ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • Reforming the Education Acts
    The government introduced the Education and Training Bill to Parliament yesterday. Its a massive bill, which replaces both existing Education Acts, as well as various other bits of legislation (including some which are still proceeding through the House). I'll leave the serious analysis to teachers and people who actually know ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • Bite-sized learning
    Amelia SharmanThere’s no one-size-fits-all when it comes to micro-credentials, those bits of bite-sized learning that can help workers stay on top of technological change.  What’s a micro-credential? While definitions vary, micro-credentials can be understood as short courses that allow people to learn new skills or have an existing competency recognised. ...
    SciBlogsBy Guest Author
    1 week ago
  • “Not The Labour Party We Once Knew.”
    All Smiles Now: Claire Szabo is taking up her presidential role after serving as the CEO of Habitat For Humanity. Which is absolutely perfect! After KiwiBuild was so comprehensively mismanaged by Phil Twyford, the party has not only elected a new president from a thoroughly respectable not-for-profit, but one who ...
    1 week ago
  • Marxist versus liberal methodology on transgender ideology/identity politics
    While much of the NZ left has transitioned to postmodern and identity politics in relation to transgender ideology, there are some very good articles about that deploy Marxist methodology in relation to this subject.  The one below is from the British marxist group Counterfire and appeared on their site here ...
    RedlineBy Admin
    1 week ago
  • Book review: The Farm by Joanne Ramos
    by Daphna Whitmore At Golden Oaks, a luxurious country retreat in the Hudson Valley, pregnant women have the best care money can buy. From the organic food, personalised exercise programmes, private yoga instruction and daily massages Golden Oaks looks like a country lodge for the upper class. Set some time ...
    RedlineBy Daphna
    1 week ago
  • Loosening the purse strings
    When Labour was running for election in 2017, it felt it needed to demonstrate "fiscal responsibility" and signed itself up to masochistic "budget responsibility rules". It was a fool's errand: the sorts of voters who demand fiscal responsibility are also the sorts of voters who believe that labour can never ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • Climate Change: How to get there
    Writing in Stuff, Joel MacManus looks at what we need to do to meet the Zero Carbon Act's targets. The core of it:1. Convert 85 per cent of vehicles on the road to electric. 2. Eliminate fossil fuels from all industrial heating up to 300 degrees Celsius. 3. Double our ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    1 week ago
  • anti-vaxxers in a measles epidemic: so many ways to be untruthful
    “Anti-vaxers are a pro-death movement,” those comments from Dr Helen Petousis-Harris speaking about six more Measles related deaths in Samoa over the past twenty-four hours. “Anti-vaxers are a pro-death movement,” those comments from Dr Helen Petousis-Harris speaking about six more Measles related deaths in Samoa ...
    SciBlogsBy Alison Campbell
    1 week ago
  • Is Youth Vaping a Problem in New Zealand?
    Professors Janet Hoek and Richard Edwards, Emeritus Professor Phil Gendall, Jude Ball, Dr Judith McCool, Anaru Waa, Dr Becky Freeman Recent media reports have presented conflicting evidence on youth vaping in NZ. While some NZ school principals report concerns about increasing vaping on school grounds and confiscating vapes, ASH Year ...
    SciBlogsBy Public Health Expert
    1 week ago
  • In pursuit of “Freedom and Democracy”: Forever Wars in “America’s backyard”.
    “America the Beautiful!”, staunch defender of democracy, freedom and… a whole lot of despotic tyrants that play nice with what is called “the Washington Consensus.” America is indeed capable of immense good, but like any Nation, and most assuredly any aspirant to the mantle of Empire, great, immense evil. All ...
    exhALANtBy exhalantblog
    1 week ago
  • November ’19 – NZ blogs sitemeter ranking
    Image credit: The beginner’s guide to blogging I notice a few regulars no longer allow public access to the site counters. This may happen accidentally when the blog format is altered. If your blog is ...
    1 week ago
  • Whodunnit? Finding the mystery 1080 testing lab
    1080 is used to control pests in NZ. Its use is contested by a noisy few. A new report claims high levels of 1080 in rats washed up on a beach. Flora and Fauna of Aotearoa (F&F) won’t name the laboratory that did their testing. It has sparked a hunt ...
    SciBlogsBy Grant Jacobs
    2 weeks ago
  • Authoritarian Friends, Democratic Enemies.
    What Kind Of Empire? The thing for Kiwis to decide is what kind of empire they want to belong to. The kind that, while offering its own citizens democratic rights, demands absolute obedience from its “friends”? Or, the kind that, while authoritarian at home, takes a relaxed attitude to the ...
    2 weeks ago
  • Boris Johnson Goes Down
    It hasn't been a good week for the Conservatives, pollwise.  All major recent polls are showing their lead shrinking.Comparing each pollster's current (between 29/11 and 22/11) and previous most recent poll.Com Res - Conservative lead down 3 points.You Gov - Conservative lead down 1 point.Kantar - Conservative lead down 4 ...
    2 weeks ago
  • Interesting
    Within quick succession, Countdown maths wizard and twitterer Rachel Riley, alleged comedian David Baddiel and prominent lawyer Andrew Julius have all expressed very similar opinions / ideas:
    These #3billboards are going round London today, organised by ex-Labour people, horrified by what their party has become. Their principles haven’t changed, they’re ...
    2 weeks ago
  • Damn the Polls
    So, there have been a bunch of bad polls out for Labour, and even the Leftie's friend, Survation, have recently given the Conservatives a rip-snorting 11% lead.  You Gov's much vaunted MRP poll - which pretty much nailed the result in 2015 - is currently predicting a comfortable majority for ...
    2 weeks ago
  • Climate Change: Europe declares an emergency
    The European Parliament has voted overwhelmingly to declare a climate emergency:The European parliament has declared a global “climate and environmental emergency” as it urged all EU countries to commit to net zero greenhouse gas emissions by 2050. The vote came as scientists warned that the world may have already crossed ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    2 weeks ago
  • A Bi-Partisan Commitment To X-ing “P”.
    Pure Fear: Worse than Heroin, this drug’s addictive power was terrifying. People under its influence didn’t drift off to Elysium. Nor did it persuade inadequate individuals that they could conquer the world. No, this drug – pure crystal methamphetamine, “P” for short – unlocked the gates of Hell itself. It ...
    2 weeks ago
  • Advice about measles: when ignorance is definitely not a virtue
    As the rate of measles infection, and of deaths, continues to climb in Samoa, antivaccination activists infectious disease proponents seem intent on doubling down on their claims about vaccination. (Check pretty much any news-media FB post about measles & you’ll see exactly what I mean.) Unfortunately, some of them have ...
    SciBlogsBy Alison Campbell
    2 weeks ago
  • Samoa’s devastating measles epidemic – why and how bad?
    Samoa are experiencing a devastating measles epidemic. It is possible that 2-3% of the population will ultimately be infected by the time it is over. Hopefully the mass immunisation campaign currently under way can mitigate some of this, for many it is too late. The first question many people ask ...
    SciBlogsBy Helen Petousis Harris
    2 weeks ago
  • “It’s basic rights we are defending”: the Meghan Murphy interview
    Meghan Murphy is a Canadian writer and journalist She runs the Feminist Current website which she founded in 2012.  She was a keynote speaker for the Feminism2020 conference in Wellington this month. When Massey University cancelled the original venue booking Feminism2020 was hosted in Parliament by MP David Seymour. Meghan ...
    RedlineBy Admin
    2 weeks ago
  • A week of protests in Colombia
    Text and photos by Gearóid Ó Loingsigh Colombia has lived through one week of protests against the economic measures taken by president Duque. What looked like a protest that would fizzle out after its first day on November 21st is still going strong. Part of the reason for the continuance ...
    RedlineBy Admin
    2 weeks ago
  • Anti-neutrinos–When you are your own opposite
    Around a million billion pass through you each second, almost all originating from our sun, but few of them are likely to interact with you enroute. I was reading in a physics magazine earlier in the week about the nature of neutrinos. These are extremely numerous elementary particles, but only ...
    SciBlogsBy Marcus Wilson
    2 weeks ago
  • Exoplanets, life, and the danger of a single study
    By Pallab Ghosh There’s value in covering new research advances, even when the underlying science is unsettled. But there are also risks. The recent announcement that scientists discovered water on the planet K2-18b, 110 light years away, prompted a media swoon. News stories, including a piece written by me, billed ...
    SciBlogsBy Guest Author
    2 weeks ago
  • The Intersex Continuum
    I wrote this review a couple of years ago when I was still in the process of getting my head around the politics of transgenderism, and specifically the claim that intersex conditions lend support to the notion that sex is ‘socially constructed’. Since writing this review I have come across ...
    RedlineBy Admin
    2 weeks ago
  • Leaving us with the bill
    Two weeks ago, Malaysian-owned oil company Tamarind declared it was insolvent and went into administration after a failed offshore drilling campaign. Tamarind apparently specialises in buying oil fields at the end of their life and trying to squeeze out the last few drops of pollution. But part of their scam ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    2 weeks ago
  • How much does flying contribute to climate change?
    Climate Explained is a collaboration between The Conversation, Stuff and the New Zealand Science Media Centre to answer your questions about climate change. If you have a question you’d like an expert to answer, please send it to climate.change@stuff.co.nz How much does our use of air travel contribute to the ...
    SciBlogsBy Shaun Hendy
    2 weeks ago
  • Climate Change: The task before us
    Two weeks ago, the Zero Carbon Act became law. Right this moment, the Climate Change Commisison will be working on its initial budgets for 2022-25 and 2026-2030, and the UN has just given them a very clear steer:Countries must make an unprecedented effort to cut their levels of greenhouse gases ...
    No Right TurnBy Idiot/Savant
    2 weeks ago
  • Among my favourite asteroids: (2309) Mr. Spock
    Minor planet/asteroid (2309) Mr. Spock is named not for the character in Star Trek, but for a cat that was itself imperturbable, logical, intelligent and had pointed ears In a preceding blog post I introduced one of my favourite asteroids, (2472) Bradman, and also mentioned (6581) Sobers amongst a few ...
    SciBlogsBy Duncan Steel
    2 weeks ago
  • Measles deaths and antivax misinformation
    Today the death toll from measles in Samoa rose to 32. All but four of the dead were less than 5 years old. Absolutely terrible, heartbreaking, news. That statistic alone should be enough to give the lie to the common claim by antivaccination activists plague enthusiasts that “measles is a ...
    SciBlogsBy Alison Campbell
    2 weeks ago
  • Colombia: the state murder of Dilan Cruz
    by Gearóid Ó Loingsigh It is late here in Bogotá, almost 11.30pm on Monday the 25th of November as I write this. The day began full of hope with yet more massive marches throughout the country, a mix of the International Day of Non-Violence Against Women and the National Strike. ...
    RedlineBy Admin
    2 weeks ago
  • Anti-fluoride propagandists appear not to read the articles they promote
    Anti-fluoride activists are rubbing their hands in glee over what they claim is “yet another study” showing fluoride harms the brains of children. But their promotion relies on IQ relationships which the paper’s authors acknowledge disappearing when outliers or other factors are considered. And they completely ignore other relationships ...
    2 weeks ago

  • New law sets up $300m Venture Capital Fund
    New Zealand firms expanding beyond the start-up phase are set for more support after today’s passage of the Venture Capital Fund Bill, Associate Finance Minister David Parker said. The Bill, which establishes a $300 million Venture Capital Fund, puts in place a key initiative of the Wellbeing Budget’s economic package. ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 hours ago
  • New Zealand’s National Statement to COP25
    E ngā mana, e ngā reo, e ngā iwi, e ngā rau rangatira mā. Tēnā koutou, tēnā koutou, tēnā koutou katoa. Señora Presidenta, Excellencies, Delegates. International action A common thread that runs through the Paris Agreement is the commitment we have made to each other to do what we can to ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 hours ago
  • Priorities for 2020 Wellbeing Budget outlined
    Budget 2020 will continue the Coalition Government’s focus on tackling the long-term challenges facing New Zealand while also investing to future-proof the economy. When the Government took office in 2017 it was left with crumbling infrastructure, severe underinvestment in public services, degraded rivers and lakes, a housing crisis and rising ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    9 hours ago
  • $12 billion in extra infrastructure investment
    The Government is lifting capital investment to the highest level in more than 20 years as it takes the next step to future-proof New Zealand. Finance Minister Grant Robertson has announced $12 billion of new investment, with $8 billion for specific capital projects and $4 billion to be added to ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    9 hours ago
  • Strong economy, careful spending gives $12bn of surpluses
    The Government is forecast to run $12 billion worth of surpluses across the four years to 2023/24 as the economy continues to grow. The surpluses will help fund day-to-day capital requirements each year. These include fixing leaky hospitals, building new classrooms to cover population growth and take pressure off class ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    9 hours ago
  • Minister welcomes data-rich coastline mapping tool
    The Minister responsible for the Marine and Coastal Area (Takutai Moana) Act 2011 (te Takutai Moana Act 2011), Andrew Little has welcomed the launch of an online geospatial tool that provides data-rich, dynamic coastline maps that will significantly boost research and evidence-gathering under the Act. Te Kete Kōrero a Te ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    11 hours ago
  • Chief Victims Advisor reappointed for a further two years
    The Chief Victims Advisor to Government Dr Kim McGregor, QSO, has been reappointed in her role for a further two years. Dr McGregor has held the role since it was established in November 2015. She provides independent advice to government on how to improve the criminal justice system for victims. ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    12 hours ago
  • New Zealand tsunami monitoring and detection system to be established
    Foreign Affairs Minister Winston Peters and Civil Defence Minister Peeni Henare have today announced the deployment of a network of DART (Deep-ocean Assessment and Reporting of Tsunami) buoys. “New Zealand and the Pacific region are particularly vulnerable to natural disasters. It is vital we have adequate warning systems in place,” ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    12 hours ago
  • DART Buoys Announcement
    DART Buoys Announcement Aotea Wharf, 9.30am 11 December 2019   Acknowledgements Acknowledgements to Minister for Civil Defence Hon Peeni Henare also here today. White Island It is with regret that this event shadows the tragic natural disaster two days ago. The volcanic eruptions on White Island have claimed 5 lives, ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    12 hours ago
  • Final steps for racing industry reform
    Racing Minister Winston Peters has welcomed the first reading of the Racing Industry Bill in parliament today. This is the second of two Bills that have been introduced this year to revitalise New Zealand’s racing industry. “Our domestic racing industry has been in serious decline.  The Government is committed to ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 day ago
  • Funding to promote New Zealand Sign Language initiatives
    Minister for Disability Issues, Carmel Sepuloni, is pleased to announce that $291,321 is to be awarded to national and local community initiatives to maintain and promote the use of New Zealand Sign Language (NZSL). “New Zealand is one of the few countries  in the world where Sign Language is an ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 day ago
  • How New Zealand defines and recognises veterans
    Minister for Veterans Ron Mark has announced today the Coalition Government’s initial response to work completed by the independent statutory body, the Veterans’ Advisory Board. “When Professor Ron Paterson completed his review of the Veterans’ Support Act in 2018, he made a number of recommendations, including one which I referred ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 day ago
  • Government to fund lion’s share of Ohakea water scheme
    The Government will fund the bulk of the cost of a rural water supply for the Ohakea community affected by PFAS contamination, Environment Minister David Parker announced today at a meeting of local residents. This new water scheme will provide a reliable and clean source of drinking water to the ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • Prime Minister statement on White Island eruption
    I have had the opportunity to be briefed on the details of the volcanic eruption of Whakaari/White Island, off the coast of Whakatane in the Bay of Plenty.  The eruption happened at 2.11pm today.  It continues to be an evolving situation.  We know that there were a number of tourists ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • Govt funds $100k for weather-hit communities
    Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern and Minister of Civil Defence Peeni Henare have today confirmed initial Government support of $100,000 for communities affected by the severe weather that swept across the South Island and lower North Island over the weekend. The contribution will be made to Mayoral relief funds across the ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • Death of NZ High Commissioner to Cook Islands
    New Zealand's High Commissioner to the Cook Islands, Tessa Temata, died in Palmerston North over the weekend, Foreign Minister Winston Peters said today. Ms Temata, 52, had recently returned to New Zealand for medical treatment. "On behalf of the Government and the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade, we extend ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    2 days ago
  • Wellington rail upgrade full steam ahead
    Transport Minister Phil Twyford today announced construction is underway on Wellington commuter rail upgrades which will mean more frequent services and fewer breakdowns. The upgrades include converting the Trentham to Upper Hutt single track section to a double track, with a new signalling system, upgraded stations and level crossings, and ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Defence Climate Change Implementation Plan released
    Minister of Defence Ron Mark and Minister for Climate Change James Shaw have announced the release of a Defence Climate Change Implementation Work Plan, titled Responding to the Climate Crisis: An Implementation Plan.  The plan sets out a series of recommendations based on the 2018 New Zealand Defence Assessment, The ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Govt releases funding to support South Canterbury
    A medium-scale adverse event has been declared for the South Canterbury district, which will see up to $50,000 in funding made available to support farming communities which have been significantly affected by recent heavy rain and flooding in the area, says Agriculture Minister Damien O’Connor. “Two weeks of solid rain ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Speech at launch of Rethinking Plastics Report
    Thank you Professor Juliet Gerrard and your team for the comprehensive and extremely helpful report and recommendations. Thank you too to all the stakeholders and interested parties who have contributed ideas and thinking to it. “Making best practice, standard practice” is a great framework for change and the action plan ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    3 days ago
  • Govt pledges next steps on plastic waste
    The Government will phase out more single-use plastics following the success of its single-use plastic bag ban earlier this year and the release today of a pivotal report for dealing with waste. Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern has welcomed the Rethinking Plastics in Aotearoa New Zealandreport, released by her Chief Science Advisor ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • International student enrolments grow in universities and the regions
    International education continues to thrive as the Government focuses on quality over quantity, Education Minister Chris Hipkins said. The tuition revenue from international education increased to $1.16 billion last year with the average tuition fee per student increasing by $960. The total number of international students enrolled in New Zealand ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • Speech to Government Economics Network 2019 Conference
    I want to talk about one of the most pressing issues in our national life: the housing crisis and the poor performance of our cities. The argument I want to make to you is that generations of urban land use policy have lacked a decent grounding in economics. The consequences ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    4 days ago
  • DHB leadership renewed and strengthened
    Health Minister Dr David Clark says new appointments to DHBs represent a significant changing of the guard, with 13 new chairs including four Māori chairs. Today 76 appointments have been announced to complement elected board members, as well as eight elected members appointed as either chair or deputy chair.  Four ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Tabuteau to advance New Zealand’s trade and political interests with European partners
    Parliamentary Under-Secretary for Foreign Affairs, Fletcher Tabuteau, is travelling to Germany, Poland, Austria, and Spain next week to bolster New Zealand’s political and trade relationships in Europe. While in Spain, Mr Tabuteau will represent New Zealand at the 14th Asia-Europe (ASEM) Foreign Ministers’ Meeting in Madrid. “New Zealand strongly supports ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Statement from the Prime Minister on Kris Faafoi
    “I’ve spoken to Minister Faafoi, who has apologised for his poor handling of this issue,” Jacinda Ardern said. “I have confidence in Kris as a hardworking and effective Minister, but this should have been dealt with in a much clearer manner, and I’ve made my views on that very clear ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Tonga-New Zealand Joint Ministerial Forum
    Deputy Prime Minister Winston Peters met with Tongan Prime Minister and Foreign Minister Pohiva Tu'i'onetoa in Wellington today. The pair signed a Statement of Partnership setting out joint priorities for cooperation out to 2023.  “We welcomed Prime Minister Tu'i'onetoa on his first visit to New Zealand as Prime Minister. Tonga ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Shooting in Kurow
    The Minister of Police Stuart Nash says his sympathies are with the family of a man who died after being shot by Police in Kurow. “Initial reports are that Police were called by a family member to help the man who was threatening to harm himself,” Mr Nash says. “However ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Government delivers funding boost for ethnic communities
    Ethnic communities will be able to plan and deliver more community initiatives thanks to an increase in Government funding, Minister for Ethnic Communities Hon Jenny Salesa said today. “Ensuring Aotearoa New Zealand is a place we can all be proud to call home has been a key priority of our ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Govt supports Southland farmers in sustainability
    Healthier waterways, better productivity and farmer wellbeing are front and centre in a new project involving more than 1000 Southland farmers and growers. Minister of Agriculture Damien O’Connor today announced that the Thriving Southland Change and Innovation Project is the first region-wide extension programme supported by the $229 million Sustainable ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Flood of support for Top of the South catchment
    Work to look after nature and restore freshwater quality in Te Hoiere/Pelorus River catchment is getting a significant boost, thanks to new Government funding support Minister for Conservation Eugenie Sage announced in Canvastown today. “Every New Zealander should be able to swim in their local river without getting sick, and ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    5 days ago
  • Eight Queen’s Counsel appointed under new criterion
    Eight Queen’s Counsel have been appointed under a process that includes the new criterion of a commitment to improving access to justice, Attorney-General David Parker announced today. “The new criterion was included this year. It emphasises that excellence and leadership in the profession can be seen through a wider, community ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Major expansion for Wellington’s Onslow College
    Onslow College in Wellington will get 20 new classrooms for more than 400 students, Education Minister Chris Hipkins announced today. The much-needed investment will relieve growth pressure the school has been experiencing for some time. Seven existing classrooms which have deteriorated over time will also be replaced, bringing the total ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Talented young Kiwis awarded PM’s Scholarships to Asia and Latin America
    More than 250 young New Zealanders will add international experience to their education, thanks to the latest Prime Minister’s Scholarships for Asia (PMSA) and Latin America (PMSLA), Education Minister Chris Hipkins announced today. This round of scholarships supports 252 recent graduates or current students to undertake study, research or internships ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • Government to improve competitiveness and transparency in the retail fuel market
    Consumers will benefit from a more competitive, transparent retail fuel market as a result of changes the Government will be making in response to the findings of the Commerce Commission’s study of the fuel sector. “We accept the Commission’s findings and, as the Prime Minister has said, we’re ready to ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    6 days ago
  • More cancer medicines for more people
    Five new cancer medicines have now been funded this year, meaning thousands of people have more treatment options PHARMAC has today announced that it has approved two new medicines for funding – fulvestrant for breast cancer and olaparib for ovarian cancer. This follows earlier decisions on advanced lung cancer treatment alectinib, ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • Government acts to sort out electoral ‘coin toss’ problem
    The Minister of Local Government, Hon Nanaia Mahuta says the Government will consider making changes to local electoral legislation before the 2022 elections to fix the problems that have arisen where elections are settled by a coin toss.  The Minister says the recount process in the Murupara- Galatea ward at ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    7 days ago
  • NZ to Join IMO Convention to Reduce Ship Emissions
    New Zealand will sign up to new international maritime regulations to reduce ship emissions and lift air quality around ports and harbours, Associate Transport Minister Julie Anne Genter announced today. Subject to completion of the Parliamentary treaty examination process, New Zealand will sign up to Annex VI of MARPOL, an ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Bill to empower urban development projects
    New legislation to transform our urban areas and create sustainable, inclusive and thriving communities will tomorrow be introduced to Parliament, Urban Development Minister Phil Twyford said. “The Urban Development Bill gives Kāinga Ora-Homes and Communities the tools it needs to partner with councils, communities, mana whenua and private developers to ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago
  • Early Learning Action Plan to kickstart long term change
    Today’s launch of He taonga te Tamaiti: Every child a taonga: The Early Learning Action Plan 2019-2029 provides the foundation for long-lasting changes to early learning, Education Minister Chris Hipkins says.   “Early learning will be one of the Government’s top education priorities going into 2020,” Chris Hipkins said.   ...
    BeehiveBy beehive.govt.nz
    1 week ago